HS – Hydrological Sciences

EGU22-1892 | Presentations | MAL1 | Alfred Wegener Medal Lecture

Understanding changing river flood hazards 

Günter Blöschl

There is serious concern that the hazard, or probability, of river floods is increasing over time. Anticipating any change in flood hazard is extremely important for adapting flood management strategies and thereby reducing potential damage and loss of life. However, floods are the result of complex interactions of runoff generation processes within the catchment area not easy to quantify. This presentation will review recent advances in understanding how and why river floods, and their probabilities, are changing over time.

Land use change, such as deforestation, urbanisation and soil compaction resulting from more intense agriculture, modify river floods by altering the infiltration capacity and soil moisture. Locally, these processes are well understood but less so at the catchment scale. The effect of land use on floods is particularly pronounced for flash floods in small catchments because of the role of soil permeability in infiltration at this scale. For regional floods, and for the most extreme events, land use is usually not the most important control, because areas of soil saturation are more relevant in runoff generation, which are less driven by soil permeability.

Instead, hydraulic engineering works, such as river training, reservoirs and levees, are more relevant. The effect of individual hydraulic structures can be captured well by hydraulic  modelling based on mass and momentum balance, and their role depends on the event magnitude. There is a tendency for all of these engineering works to exert the greatest effect on floods for events of intermediate magnitude, e.g. associated with return periods of the order of ten to one hundred years. Regional effects of engineering works are an active research topic.

Climate change can affect river floods at all catchment scales, from a few hectares to hundreds of thousands of square kilometres. Observed changes in river floods, e.g. in Europe, suggest that climate change is indeed modifying the river flood hazard, but the changes are not necessarily directly linked to precipitation, nor are they directly linked to rising air temperatures. The key to understanding climate change effects on floods is therefore the seasonal interaction between soil moisture (influenced by precipitation and evaporation), snow processes, extreme precipitation and runoff generation. In Europe, there have been a number of flood-rich periods in the past 500 yrs and we are currently in one of them. A trend of storm tracks to move further north in Europe has increased both average and extreme precipitation and thus river flood hazard in the Northwest of Europe, but floods are decreasing where snowmelt is relevant due to shallower snowpacks. There is a tendency for climate change to have the greatest effect on floods of large event magnitudes.

It is concluded that substantial progress has been made in recent years in understanding the role of land use, river works and climate in changing river flood hazards, both through data based and modelling approaches. Considering all three controls of change is essential in reliable flood risk assessment and management in order to maximise protection levels at an affordable cost.

Publications: https://hydro.tuwien.ac.at/forschung/publikationen/download-journal-publications/

How to cite: Blöschl, G.: Understanding changing river flood hazards, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1892, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1892, 2022.

EGU22-3458 | Presentations | MAL15 | HS Division Outstanding ECS Award Lecture

Floods and droughts: a multivariate perspective on hazard estimation 

Manuela Irene Brunner

Floods and droughts are often studied from a univariate perspective, which ignores their multivariate nature and can lead to risk under- or overestimation. The multivariate nature of hydrological extremes makes them particularly impactful, e.g. when they affect large areas or several components of the hydrological cycle, and should be considered when deriving frequency and magnitude estimates for hydraulic design and adaptation. However, studying multivariate extremes is challenging because different variables are related and because they are even less abundant in observational records than univariate extremes.
In this talk, I discuss different types of multivariate hydrological extremes and their dependencies including spatially co-occurring flood events, floods described by peak and volume, or droughts characterized by deficit and duration. I present different strategies to describe and model multivariate extremes, to assess their hazard potential, and to increase sample size – for example, the openly available R-package PRSim that stochastically simulates streamflow and hydrological extremes at multiple locations. I illustrate potential applications of some strategies using different large-sample datasets ranging from sets of alpine catchments in Switzerland to sets of hydro-climatologically diverse catchments in the United States and on the European continent. The strategies discussed enable a multivariate perspective in hydrological hazard assessments, which allows us to derive more comprehensive risk estimates than the classical univariate perspective commonly applied.

How to cite: Brunner, M. I.: Floods and droughts: a multivariate perspective on hazard estimation, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3458, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3458, 2022.

EGU22-10506 | Presentations | MAL15 | Henry Darcy Medal Lecture

Local solutions for global water security 

Wouter Buytaert

Globally, the terrestrial water cycle is changing rapidly, because of human interventions in catchment hydrological processes, and changing meteorological boundary conditions. Many of these changes have a negative impact on the water security of people living within and nearby those catchments. Plenty of scientific evidence points to increasing intensities and frequencies of floods and droughts and degrading water resources in many parts of the world. While increasing water security is globally high on the policy agenda, there are clearly no easy solutions to this problem. Catchments are complex, idiosyncratic systems from which society draws many different resources and services, and many of these activities affect the local hydrological processes and the human benefits and risks that emanate from those. 

Achieving global water security is therefore only possible with solutions that are tailored to these specific local characteristics and realities. Analysing cases from the Andes, the Himalayas, and Africa, in this lecture I set out to identify crucial ingredients for successful catchment interventions, as well as some of the main scientific challenges that remain. I start from the conceptualization of a catchment as a complex adaptive system, governed by a unique combination of natural, social, and cultural processes. 

A first step then involves characterizing and quantifying these processes, which requires data collection and measuring. Although high-quality data are severely lacking in most of the world, many new opportunities are emerging. These range from remote sensing and pervasive in-situ sensor networks to novel data collection arrangements such as participatory monitoring and citizen science. In a next step, potential catchment interventions must be identified and evaluated. Also here, the toolbox of the catchment managers is growing continuously, with new concepts such as green infrastructure and nature-based solutions gaining traction. However, evaluating different potential interventions requires careful scenario analysis. Computational models, as well as uncertainty and risk assessment, are crucial tools to do so, but it also involves a thorough analysis of the (potentially complex and interacting) benefits and disbenefits that each intervention exerts on various population groups. Lastly, long term monitoring and evaluation of catchment interventions remains a formidable challenge, even though it is a crucial element to ensure that interventions effectively generate the anticipated benefits, to mitigate unexpected side-effects, and to adjust and adapt to constantly changing boundary conditions and catchment dynamics.

How to cite: Buytaert, W.: Local solutions for global water security, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10506, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10506, 2022.

EGU22-3416 | Presentations | MAL18 | Arne Richter Award for Outstanding ECS Lecture

Dry drier drought – Understanding drought in a changing society and climate 

Niko Wanders

Droughts have major economic, social and environmental impacts around the world, and they are expected to increase in severity and magnitude because of changes in climate and its variability. In recent years we have seen incredible developments in the field of drought research and we have significantly improved our understanding of this complex phenomenon. While observations have become more abundant, we have also seen significant improvements in hydrological models that are better constrained by these observations. These model improvements also include the addition of new, relevant processes, needed to fully understand drought feedbacks.

In this talk I will discuss my experience with modeling drought at larger scales and including human-water interactions at these scales. These models are also used to study the impact of climate change on drought and show the impact of rising temperatures on society’s exposure to these impactful events. Spatial resolutions of hydrological models have improved significantly and the complexity of processes that we are able to simulate has increased, leading to exciting new insights. At the same time, we have to communicate these findings with not only the scientific community, but also the general public. This brings new challenges for scientists and affects our science.

I’ll highlight recent advances in the field of drought research and hydrological modelling, as well as frontiers and interesting developments in the field. I’ll mention some key challenges that we still have to face to better understand the impact and feedbacks of extreme hydroclimatic events.

How to cite: Wanders, N.: Dry drier drought – Understanding drought in a changing society and climate, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3416, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3416, 2022.

EGU22-6797 | Presentations | MAL18 | John Dalton Medal Lecture

On the value of thermal infrared remote sensing for water and land management 

Martha Anderson, Yun Yang, Jie Xue, Kyle Knipper, Yang Yang, Feng Gao, Christopher Hain, Thomas Holmes, William Kustas, Milan Fischer, and Mirek Trnk

Thermal infrared (TIR) and visible/near-infrared (VNIR) surface reflectance imagery from remote sensing can be effectively combined in surface energy balance models to map evapotranspiration (ET) and vegetation stress, with broad applications in agriculture, forestry, and water resource management. Particularly valuable are ET retrievals at medium resolution (100 m or finer), resolving scales at which water and land are actively managed over much of the Earth’s surface. At this scale, TIR and VNIR data in the Landsat archive provide a 40-year and growing global record of coupled land and water use change.  In this presentation we will discuss the unique information content conveyed by the land-surface temperature signal regarding the surface moisture status and vegetation health. We will explore applications for field-scale temperature and ET retrievals in promoting sustainable water use, forest health, and regenerative agricultural practices. Widespread and routine generation of ET data at this scale has been enabled by cloud computing technologies, with the OpenET ensemble modeling platform as an example of collaborative geospatial information development.  Looking forward, integration of Landsat with new sources of medium-resolution TIR imagery (e.g., ECOSTRESS, LSTM, TRISHNA, SBG, Landsat-Next, and Hydrosat), as well as all-sky microwave-based temperature retrievals, will improve our ability to detect rapid changes in water use and availability – a key factor in real-time decision making.

How to cite: Anderson, M., Yang, Y., Xue, J., Knipper, K., Yang, Y., Gao, F., Hain, C., Holmes, T., Kustas, W., Fischer, M., and Trnk, M.: On the value of thermal infrared remote sensing for water and land management, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6797, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6797, 2022.

HS1.1 – Hydrological Sciences for Policy and Society

EGU22-222 | Presentations | HS1.1.2

Modelling human-water systems experiencing drought-to-flood events: is there one model that fits all? 

Marlies H Barendrecht, Alessia Matanò, Heidi D Mendoza, Ruben V Weesie, and Anne F van Loon

According to future climate projections both droughts and floods are expected to increase in severity and frequency. A lot of research has been done on the adaptation of society and the feedbacks between hazard and society for these individual hazards, while the feedbacks between hazards and society in a system that experiences drought followed by flooding are less well known. In this study we aim to identify common variables and characteristics of different human-water systems that experience drought-to-flood events and use this to inform model development. Through a literature study of a variety of case studies across the world we investigate the hydrological and socio-economic settings and characteristics of each system as well as the underlying processes and adaptation measures that played a role in the events. Drought-to-flood events can have very different drivers and impacts. In some cases the main driver is human adaptation, such as in the case of the Millennium Drought in Australia where flood prevention reservoirs were already full because they were being used to store water to cope with the drought (Van Dijk et al. 2013). In other cases the combination of hydrological drivers plays a more important role, such as in the case of Peru where a drought followed by extreme rainfall resulted in mud-slides (Fraser 2017). The comparison across cases provides an overview of common variables as well as differences between case studies and is used to inform the construction of one socio-hydrological model that fits all or multiple models that capture the specifics of each case. In future work the model(s) will be used for a more in-depth investigation of the behaviour of a selection of human-water systems, using qualitative and quantitative data in combination with the models to investigate possible future pathways and policy interventions.

References

Fraser, B. (2017). Peru’s floods teach tough lessons. Nature, 544(7651), 405-406.

Van Dijk, A. I., Beck, H. E., Crosbie, R. S., de Jeu, R. A., Liu, Y. Y., Podger, G. M., ... & Viney, N. R. (2013). The Millennium Drought in southeast Australia (2001–2009): Natural and human causes and implications for water resources, ecosystems, economy, and society. Water Resources Research, 49(2), 1040-1057.

How to cite: Barendrecht, M. H., Matanò, A., Mendoza, H. D., Weesie, R. V., and van Loon, A. F.: Modelling human-water systems experiencing drought-to-flood events: is there one model that fits all?, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-222, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-222, 2022.

EGU22-2504 | Presentations | HS1.1.2

How to illuminate the twilight world of engineering hydrology 

Duncan Faulkner

In the words of David Sellars, engineering hydrologists ply their craft in the twilight, always looking for a shaft of illumination to enhance their understanding. Many decisions on flood risk management around the world are made using techniques that hydrological scientists would barely recognise. The Rational method, first formulated in 1850, is still widely used for design of structures, despite the availability of more scientifically justified alternatives. Software packages used by practitioners offer a variety of modelling techniques, sometimes without any guidance on their validity. It is common to see uncritical application of infiltration equations at a catchment scale with no acknowledgement that they ignore preferential pathway flow. There is a responsibility on both practitioners and software developers to improve scientific understanding.

Meanwhile, research projects and programmes, even with an operational focus, can produce reports, papers and even new techniques that never influence any engineering design, planning decision or operational forecast. In the UK, research into national flood frequency estimation by continuous simulation was completed in 2005 but has seen little implementation. One barrier was the decision to generalise rainfall-runoff model parameters using catchment properties which were not readily available to practitioners. Other UK initiatives have been more successfully adopted by practitioners, including recent development of guidance and tools for non-stationary flood frequency estimation. This produced a software tool that could be applied with a basic knowledge of the R language, along with practitioner-focused guidance, all freely available to download.

As an alternative to regulators trying to impose new approaches, a more promising avenue for implementation of research could be to create an environment in which the practitioner community is encouraged and incentivized to innovate, seeking out shafts of illumination from academia.

How to cite: Faulkner, D.: How to illuminate the twilight world of engineering hydrology, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2504, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2504, 2022.

A decline in spring flows has been observed in the Indian Himalayas due to changes in landuse and rainfall variability (Matheswaran et al., 2019). Consequently, the Himalayan communities face water scarcity issues, as springs remain a significant source of drinking and agriculture. To ensure water and livelihood security, management of these springs through landscape interventions and source protection is critical. But lack of fundamental understanding of factors influencing its flow regime limits the impact of management approaches (Vashisht and Bam, 2013) in hydrologically complex and ungauged Himalayan watersheds. To increase the flows, aquifer recharge is aided through interventions. Aquifers recharge is a function of hydrogeology, landuse and rainfall, and conventional hands-on management approaches (conceptual mapping, digging contour trenches, recharge area protection, vegetative measures) for improving spring flows are partially effective (Tarafdar et al., 2019). As the mitigating measures don’t incorporate aquifer recharge functions. Hence, understanding the flow behavior is a prerequisite for instituting a best-suited management practice.

In this study, four springs (A1, P1, P2, P3) were instrumented for high-resolution monitoring in two pilot watersheds in Almora and Pauri region, Uttarakhand, India. Hydrograph analysis, including Recession and Flow durations curves (FDC), facilitated the assessment of spring hydrodynamics. In addition, autocorrelation and cross-correlation functions (ACF and CCF) aided in understanding the memory of the system and the interdependence of rainfall and spring discharge. Results showed that spring A1 in Almora has intricate flow networks and slow flow velocities while P1, P2, P3 spring clusters in Pauri show characteristics of transmissive fractures. This is Indicative of better storage capacity and homogeneity of underlying geology for A1 compared to P1, P2, P3. Recession coefficient ‘α’ for A1, P1, P2, P3 was calculated as 0.038, 0.109, 0.088 and 0.081 respectively. The low value of α for A1 depicts diffused fracture system compared to P1, P2, P3, which indicate rapid emptying of the aquifer, the shallow spatial extent of the recharge area and a well-interconnected flow network. Steep FDC for P1, P2, P3 indicates high variability in springflows, while A1 has a gradually flattening curve attributed to the presence of storage. ACF for A1 shows a steady decline of rxx(k) value till 0.4, a high memory for more than 120 lag days, while P1, P2, P3 have rxx(k) value rapidly declining below 0.2 (significance threshold) in 50, 60 and 70 lag days exhibiting shorter system memory and poor drainage of the extensive flow network.

Such a multi-approach analysis of spring flow systems aids in spring flow characterization, assessment of response lags and flow regimes. The combined usage of such techniques permits detailed process understanding and limits erroneous interpretations (Torresan et al., 2020). Policymakers can extend the results across the Indian Himalayas to design site-specific management frameworks.

Keywords : Springshed management, memory effect, high-resolution dataset, spring aquifer, Himalayas

How to cite: Dass, B. and Sen, S.: Investigating spring flow dynamics towards solving water management issues in the Indian Himalayan region., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3559, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3559, 2022.

EGU22-5738 | Presentations | HS1.1.2

Addressing tradeoffs beyond disciplinary borders: HYDROpot_integral as a tool to simultaneously assess hydropower potential and ecological potential 

Dorothea Hug Peter, Tobias Wechsler, Rolf Weingartner, and Massimiliano Zappa

The steadily growing demand for energy and the simultaneous pursuit of decarbonization are increasing interest in the expansion of renewable energies worldwide. Hydropower produces around 60% of Switzerland's electricity and plays a key role in this energy transition strategy. However, habitat and ecosystem protection and climate friendly renewable energy production are sometimes at odds. While the environmental impact is usually addressed at some level, there is a lack of standardization and tools for a global assessment are still scarce. The GIS-based tool HYDROpot_integral allows the consideration of the total hydropower potential as well as the ecological potential of a region. Based on ecological and socio-economic geodata, both the current state of each river reach and the hydropower potential is assigned a rank. To record the suitability, every river reach is ranked according to their ecological, cultural and economic ecosystem services. A low rank means that a river reach is more suitable for hydropower production at low cost in terms of ecological and cultural ecosystem services; a high rank indicates high ecological and cultural ecosystem services and low economic services and is therefore more suitable for protection. As the limit between hydropower use and protection is adjustable, different scenarios can be explored. Results from five mesoscale test catchments in Switzerland show the feasibility of the present method, to provide a comprehensive and meaningful basis that can support the decision-making process. Overall, the assessment method is to be understood as a flexible tool to address tradeoffs between hydropower potential and ecological potential.

How to cite: Hug Peter, D., Wechsler, T., Weingartner, R., and Zappa, M.: Addressing tradeoffs beyond disciplinary borders: HYDROpot_integral as a tool to simultaneously assess hydropower potential and ecological potential, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5738, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5738, 2022.

EGU22-5977 | Presentations | HS1.1.2

BAR Talks: a YHS-Italy webinar series to bring hydrological researchers and practitioners close together 

Mara Meggiorin, Elena Cristiano, Martina Siena, Marco Peli, and Giulia Zuecco

Hydrological sciences can contribute to society in numerous impactful ways: thus, it is crucial that we make an effort to enhance the opportunities for collaboration between academia and society, such as industry and territorial authorities. With the support of the Italian Hydrological Society (‘Società Idrologica Italiana'), in 2021, the Italian Young Hydrologic Society (YHS-Italy) organized a series of webinars to reduce the gap between academic researchers and practitioners, belonging to both private and public sectors.

The webinar ‘Beyond Academic Research Talks’ (BAR Talks) hosted a total of 24 guests during five online public meetings discussing three overarching topics: i) the professional careers of Italian researchers, ii) the research in the private sector, particularly at consulting and manufacturing firms of any size, iii) the hydrological and hydrogeological research in the public sector.

The goal was to document heterogeneous experiences and promote a discussion on potential practical applications of academic research. The meetings also served as an opportunity to understand similarities and differences between the role of a hydrological researcher across different institutions. All webinars have been organized online with live sessions, where the audience could interact with the speakers and ask questions. Each meeting was also recorded and made available on YouTube for asynchronous attendances (https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCjDrMpQvRQrp3lxtZTr7Trg).

The initiative has been positively welcomed, particularly by young researchers, and many new interesting topics have been raised. The BAR Talks presented a comprehensive selection of professional paths available to researchers interested in working outside academia, and looking for a more immediate impact on society. The guests talked about the challenges of doing hydrological innovation and research outside academia, and highlighted some of the skills that become particularly handy in the private sector (e.g., open-source software, programming languages, digital water, project management, soft skills). 

Finally, one issue that came out strongly from the BAR Talks series was the need, especially for the private sector, to close the gap between academic research and its real-world applications in order to improve the positive impact that academic research can have on society. Indeed, real-world applications often encounter constraining challenges that are sometimes missing from academic research. Overall, we observed that there is a widespread desire for a closer collaboration between hydrological academic researchers and practitioners, which may take the form of joint research projects aimed at producing impactful knowledge. 

How to cite: Meggiorin, M., Cristiano, E., Siena, M., Peli, M., and Zuecco, G.: BAR Talks: a YHS-Italy webinar series to bring hydrological researchers and practitioners close together, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5977, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5977, 2022.

EGU22-7178 | Presentations | HS1.1.2

Study of end-user needs regarding behavior change to be more resilient to extreme weather events 

Montserrat Llasat-Botija, Maria Carmen Llasat, and Isabel Caballero-Leiva

Extreme weather events are increasing and will follow this trend due to climate change. In this scenario, adaptation, and mitigation in the face of them becomes essential both through technological innovations and through behavioural changes. In recent years, progress has been made in scientific knowledge on extreme hydrometeorological phenomena and climate change, and more funding is available for adaptation to climate change, both from European funds (e.g. Next Generation funds), country-level or regional funding. However, there are difficulties for to become this into a change in behaviors and actions to be more resilient to extreme phenomena both at the level of the general population and the public and private sector. This leads us to wonder if the knowledge and tools that are being generated are adjusted to the needs of these audiences in relation to adaptation and what are the facilities and barriers to carry out these changes towards more resilient patterns.

In order to analyze this aspect, a study has been carried out in which the viability and fitting of products and tools to improve the resilience of different type of end-users have been tested. For this, the first step was to conceptualize the tools and define hypotheses associated with them. The next step was to design the interviews to validate these hypotheses. Forty interviews were conducted with representatives of local administration, flood management companies, individuals, and so on. The interviews were customized to suit these different sectors and audiences. The answers served to validate or invalidate the starting hypotheses. In addition to the interviews, sources of expert information were consulted to identify similar strategies or tools and their level of success in their execution.

The interviews have made it possible to identify barriers to the implementation of changes both in individual habits (such as less interest than expected in attending participatory processes), and in organizations: budgetary limitations, political calendar or little knowledge/interest in knowing historical events. Motivations and interests were also identified, such as having a platform with centralized information on extreme phenomena or the prestige of collaborating with the academy to find optimal solutions to this problem.

This research has been done in the framework of the C3-Riskmed project (FEDER/MICINN-AEI/ PID2020-113638RB-C22) funded by the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation and EU Horizon 2020 project I-CHANGE (grant agreement 101037193).

How to cite: Llasat-Botija, M., Llasat, M. C., and Caballero-Leiva, I.: Study of end-user needs regarding behavior change to be more resilient to extreme weather events, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7178, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7178, 2022.

EGU22-7276 | Presentations | HS1.1.2

Getting to the crux(es) of the matter(s): Water quality and problem-setting in the Brantas River basin 

Schuyler Houser, Reza Pramana, and Maurits Ertsen

Effective policy problem structuring – especially for ‘wicked’ environmental problems such as river pollution – involves the abstraction of governable elements of often diffuse ‘problematic situations’ through analysis and deliberation in order to identify tractable policy space. This involves facilitating some convergence around problem conditions, matching said conditions with available solutions, and mediating the diverse priorities and perspectives of large groups of stakeholders.

For large river basins characterized by multi-level governance and high population, industrial, and agricultural density – as in the Brantas River in East Java, Indonesia – the process of structuring water quality problems and formulating management plans is inevitably complex. Three shifts in water resource management, all aimed to improve efficacy, policy legitimacy, and representativeness, also present new challenges for problem structuring and planning. First, the evidence-based policy movement has been tempered by recognition of the political nature of science, driving inclusion of additional kinds of knowledge beyond hydrological, chemical, and biological science. Second, the mainstreaming of IWRM has encouraged a shift towards horizontally-arranged, multilevel governance networks of diverse actors across sectors, who bring their own problem perspectives and strategic preferences. Third, renewed interest in implementation studies has refocused attention on institutional, cultural, and capacity-related design requirements.

This research posits that the effective implementation of river environmental solutions depends largely on their responsiveness to administrative, social, and institutional factors as well as on their sympathetic alignment with stakeholders’ established priorities. Nevertheless, these important design factors often fall to the wayside in the design and selection of interventions, simply because they are not specifically and intentionally included in the processes of problem analysis and policy deliberation.

As part of a multi-stakeholder water quality management project in the Brantas basin, this research gathers and analyzes administrative and political knowledge inputs to complement technical inputs in the design of an Integrated Water Quality Management Plan. It combines two policy enquiries with hydrological science to support problem-structuring, namely perceptions survey research of water managers and systematic review of government agencies’ medium-term strategic plans. The survey research gathers perceptions of water managers across agencies and levels of government in East Java regarding the legal environment of water quality governance (legal basis, allocation of responsibilities, regulatory settings, conflict mediation), policy conditions (planning, coordination, monitoring, finance), and administrative and management arrangements, revealing differing perspectives on institutional opportunities and challenges amongst agency representatives within the same basin. The second identifies areas of strategic commonality centered on hydrological data management, community engagement, integrated solid waste management, industrial wastewater enforcement, and communal wastewater treatment. These findings are set out for consideration in two subsequent processes: the appraisal of feasibility and sustainability of interventions proposed for inclusion in the management plan, and to inform the nomination of implementing bodies for component activities within the plan.

How to cite: Houser, S., Pramana, R., and Ertsen, M.: Getting to the crux(es) of the matter(s): Water quality and problem-setting in the Brantas River basin, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7276, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7276, 2022.

EGU22-7342 | Presentations | HS1.1.2

Identifying hydrological planning and water management and policy issues through an iterative participatory process: A coastal tourist experience in Benidorm, Spain 

Rubén Villar-Navascués, Sandra Ricart, Antonio M. Rico-Amorós, and María Hernández-Hernández

Water policy and hydrological planning are critical aspects regarding water supply systems adaptation to water scarcity risk, aggravated by the uncertainties that climate change may pose on water availability. The importance of the science-policy interface is especially relevant in coupled human-nature systems where different water uses and high competition for water resources (urban, agricultural, and tourist) coexist. This situation is particularly challenging in the coastal areas of the Mediterranean, subject to summer water shortages during the consumption peaks motivated by mass-tourism activity. Although national hydrological planning already includes the primary users’ participation in revising the five-year hydrological plans to reduce water conflicts and promote collaborative water management, on numerous occasions the need to improve these processes has been evidenced to propose feasible technical and political solutions in the water sector. Taking the coastal water system of the Marina Baja, located in the province of Alicante in Southeastern Spain, as example, we carried out an iterative participatory process involving the main representatives of the water sector management and both agricultural and tourism water demands to identify which topics should be collaboratively addressed to guarantee water supply in a future climate change scenario. Stakeholders’ perceptions about the main threats and needs to improve the functioning of the water system and their influence capacity, confronted interests, and power relations have been considered. Results determined that some hydrological policies applied at a regional scale, such as protocols for the monthly water discharge of reservoirs, the setting of ecological flows, or the sanitary policies for the management of swimming pool waters, collide with the individual experience and water management protocols applied by local stakeholders. Identifying these management issues through local experiences provides evidence about particular water management and policy challenges that must be addressed to increase the adaptation capacity of water supply systems conditioned by water stress or water confronted demands to the worst forecasts of climate change.

How to cite: Villar-Navascués, R., Ricart, S., Rico-Amorós, A. M., and Hernández-Hernández, M.: Identifying hydrological planning and water management and policy issues through an iterative participatory process: A coastal tourist experience in Benidorm, Spain, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7342, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7342, 2022.

EGU22-7785 | Presentations | HS1.1.2

Designing Nature-based Solutions in a Participatory Way: Usability of Tools for Water Professionals 

Borjana Bogatinoska, Angelique Lansu, Dave Huitema, Jean Hugé, and Stefan Dekker

Participatory processes provide opportunities for stakeholders such as: scientists, policy makers and citizens to meet, exchange information, deliberate and share values. The artefacts through which the water professionals (scientists and policy makers) and the other stakeholders can enable these participatory processes are defined as tools. There is a diversity of rapidly evolving tools for supporting the process of designing nature-based solutions (NbS) together with the stakeholders (participatory designing). This, however, requires a systematic and informed selection to facilitate the adequate choice of tool, aligned to the requirements and context of the water professionals but also the stakeholders. Despite this, there is still little progress and knowledge accumulation over preferred tools. Moreover, while tailored participatory tools could facilitate and accelerate the design process of NbS, a comprehensive mapping of their availability and capacity to respond to the values, requirements and needs of the stakeholders is still missing.

Consequently, in this research, we propose a stepwise framework for the use of tools as support in three interconnected processes: i) tools used for co-designing NbS with stakeholders - co-creation tools, ii) tools used for defining the hydro-meteorological hazards (HMH) and its effects with stakeholders – knowledge tools and iii) tools used for co-implementing the transition towards NbS – transition tools. We then test this stepwise framework in six brook catchments spread in four countries: the Netherlands, Belgium, France and the United Kingdom. The stepwise framework is designed in the following order: tool collection and selection; classification; grading and mapping. We are content that this stepwise framework could show how the water professionals, could make an informed selection and decision on the most suitable tool, based on the usability index of the tool for the specific stakeholder groups and the following criteria: tool category, objective of the tool, the required decision making process stage, the type of stakeholders, and the practical requirements (time, budget, number of participants).

Therefore we designed and tested a framework that allows the water professionals to make a decision on which tool/s could be best used based on their usability but also in terms of their characteristics analysed and described from the water professionals/practitioners themselves. What further discussion on this framework might entail is regarding the trends that we notice in the Co-Adapt project, the limitations and what happens after the tool or suite of tools is applied based on actual field experiences.

 

How to cite: Bogatinoska, B., Lansu, A., Huitema, D., Hugé, J., and Dekker, S.: Designing Nature-based Solutions in a Participatory Way: Usability of Tools for Water Professionals, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7785, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7785, 2022.

EGU22-8309 | Presentations | HS1.1.2

Ecological flow in southern Europe: implementation in temporary rivers 

Marianna Leone, Francesco Gentile, Antonio Lo Porto, and Anna Maria De Girolamo

The European Commission in 2015, as part of the Common Implementation Strategy (CIS), defined the Ecological Flow (EFlow) in natural surface water bodies as “a hydrological regime consistent with the achievement of the environmental objectives of the WFD in natural surface water bodies as mentioned in Article 4”. These environmental objectives refer to (i) non-deterioration of the existing status, (ii) achievement of good ecological status in natural surface water bodies, and (iii) compliance with standards and objectives for protected areas. The Report does not define a standard protocol for setting an EFlow but it provides some recommendations.

The approaches for determining the EFlow, which must be defined in the River Basin Management Plans, are grouped into four classes hydrological, hydraulic, habitat, and holistic method. However, few methods have been specifically defined for temporary rivers. Most of these waterways have been poorly monitored in the past. The lack of historical hydrological and biological data in natural conditions ("reference") further complicates the definition of the EF.

This work analyses the implementation EFlow in the European Member States in Southern Europe under Mediterranean climate with specific reference to temporary rivers, which are the most common waterways in Spain, Portugal, France, Greece, and Italy. Through an examination of the case studies reported in the literature, a critical review of the methodologies adopted in these EU Member States for setting an EFlow has been carried out.

Results of this study showed that although all States have integrated into their legislation the EFlow recommendations by the EC, in several cases its implementation is not enforced sufficiently and several difficulties still exist in setting an EFlow. Case studies where the EFlow implementation was specifically designed for temporary rivers are still very few and most of the applications are based on hydrological methods. The paucity of hydrological and water quality data is the most important limit in setting an EFlow.

How to cite: Leone, M., Gentile, F., Lo Porto, A., and De Girolamo, A. M.: Ecological flow in southern Europe: implementation in temporary rivers, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8309, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8309, 2022.

EGU22-8317 | Presentations | HS1.1.2

Modeling pesticides in surface runoff: a review of the current status, progress achieved and desirable improvements. 

Marco Centanni, Giovanni Francesco Ricci, Anna Maria De Girolamo, and Francesco Gentile

The excessive use of pesticides in agriculture poses a threat to water and environmental quality. Under Horizon Europe, considering the priorities of the European Green Deal (EGD), research activities, technological innovation, and investments are needed to contribute to reducing the use of pesticides, fertilizers, and antimicrobials. In this scenario, there is a need to carry out studies on the short and long-term effects of the use of pesticides in the agro-environment and on the effect of mitigation measures. For this purpose, hydrological models are useful tools for the simulation of the fate and transport of pesticides.

Through a critical review, this study aims to: (i) update the status of the use of the hydrological models to simulate pesticides coming from diffuse pollution, (ii) Analyze the spatial and temporal scale of the model applications, (iii) Investigate possible relationships between models and specific pesticides. The ISI papers were selected based on six keywords were used on Scopus: “pesticides, model, watershed, hydrology, water quality, diffuse pollutant”. After removing articles, not in English and articles not related to modeling applications, 37 papers were found and analyzed by constituting a database containing information about the study areas, the pesticides, the model, and the methodology adopted (I.e. warm-up, calibration, and/or validation). Pesticides were classified into three categories: herbicides, fungicides, and insecticides.

Results showed that most of the study areas were localized in Europe (55.5%) followed by North America (22.3%), Asia (13.9%), and South America (8.3%). Soil and Water Assessment Tool was the most commonly used model with a percentage of 45.95%. Regarding the substances investigated, herbicides were the most modeled (71.4%) followed by insecticides (18.2%) and fungicides (10.4%). In particular, among the most commonly modeled herbicides were atrazine, metolachlor, isoproturon, glyphosate, and acetochlor. Among the insecticides, chlorpyrifos and metaldehyde were the substances most frequently modeled. Finally, chlorothalonil and tebuconazole were the most investigated fungicides.

This work will be useful to create an updated guideline to facilitate the water and the landscape managers in selecting a specific hydrological model to assess the transport and fates of pesticides and to simulate the effect of potential mitigation practices.

How to cite: Centanni, M., Ricci, G. F., De Girolamo, A. M., and Gentile, F.: Modeling pesticides in surface runoff: a review of the current status, progress achieved and desirable improvements., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8317, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8317, 2022.

EGU22-8748 | Presentations | HS1.1.2 | Highlight

Review papers in hydrology for linking research to practice: a reflection on the why’s and how’s 

Nilay Dogulu, Giovanny M. Mosquera, and Maria-Helena Ramos

The constantly expanding research literature in hydrological sciences underlines the necessity of knowledge integration and synthesis. Review papers aim to provide a comprehensive overview of the published literature with focus on research gaps and priorities on a specific topic and/or region. While the hydrological science community has responded well to address the needs for knowledge integration and synthesis through publishing many review papers, it is not clear if and how these review papers can be helpful beyond academia. This is particularly important for tackling water-related issues in collaboration with water practitioners and stakeholders working towards providing operational hydrology services (e.g., data collection and management, modelling, prediction, hydroinformatics, decision support). Despite the societal relevance of applied hydrology research in the context of global development agenda, the potential of review papers for achieving the research-practice interface remains unexplored or largely ignored. Hereby, we discuss how review papers in hydrology could contribute to this dialogue and remove barriers around the translation of research into practice. With this objective in mind, we reflect on several principles of writing and communicating review papers, including: 1) effective writing (e.g., language and format), 2) purposeful content design and development (e.g., review context, research synthesis, main findings and implications), 3) high accessibility (e.g., open access publishing), and 4) efficient visibility and dissemination (e.g., meetings with stakeholders and/or users,  social media, artistic material). For each principle, we explore strategies, resources and tools to improve the benefit of review papers to  hydrology practitioners.

How to cite: Dogulu, N., M. Mosquera, G., and Ramos, M.-H.: Review papers in hydrology for linking research to practice: a reflection on the why’s and how’s, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8748, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8748, 2022.

EGU22-9160 | Presentations | HS1.1.2

The safety paradox in flood protection: the importance of communicating and contextualizing uncertainties 

Britta Höllermann, Mariele Evers, and Georg Johann

The flood events of 13-15 July 2021 in Germany brought the relevance of flood prevention acutely and once again to our attention. As the earth's atmosphere heats up, nature has more and more intense events in store for us, which push our flood protection and management measures to their limits and beyond. For planning purposes, but also in case of an event, it is therefore highly relevant to improve the communication of uncertainties and the assessment of their potential impact, e.g. in the climate or flood forecast, in a target group-oriented manner.

In Germany and in the European Union, the conditions for flood risk management have been improved since 2007 with the implementation of the European Flood Risk Management Directive (FRMD) and the amendments to the Federal Water Act. Many new instruments such as flood hazard and risk maps, building regulations or the category of flood emergence areas were introduced. For example, flood hazard and flood risk maps and corresponding management plans have been prepared on the basis of historical discharge data, water levels and hydrological and hydraulic modelling. However, recent examples have shown that the objective of the FRMD to reduce flood-related risks to human health, the environment, infrastructure and property has only been achieved to a limited extent.

In this paper we discuss why the developed maps and plans do not lead to a sufficient risk perception and why, in case of a flood event, it is often not clear what actions need to be taken when and by whom. For this, we want to highlight three aspects in particular:

1) Data: importance of using measured data and dealing with historical flood events, which are only comparable to a limited extent to today's and future conditions, which are shaped by the influences of climate change.

2) Actors: importance of involving different actors in the flood risk management planning process to strengthen risk perception and responsibility.

3) Communication: Importance of communicating uncertainties target group-specific and visualising uncertainties and their possible impacts context-specific.

For effective and sustainable flood risk management, we therefore believe that we are in need of a communication and dissemination strategy in order to contribute to a transparent description of the roles of the actors and their responsibilities. Consequently, the already developed tools (e.g. flood hazard /risk maps) should be supplemented by involving regional actors, uncertainty information and its effects should be classified and communicated to all decision-making levels in a way that is appropriate for the target group.

How to cite: Höllermann, B., Evers, M., and Johann, G.: The safety paradox in flood protection: the importance of communicating and contextualizing uncertainties, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9160, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9160, 2022.

While the added value of green roofs for mitigating rainfall extremes in urban drainage systems has been addressed in numerous studies, the microscale spatial redistribution of rainfall by solar panels (photovoltaic modules) mounted on green roofs and its impact on hydrology has hardly been studied so far. However, considering both green roofs and rooftop photovoltaic installations are emerging topics relevant for decision makers, since their combination supports both climate change adaptation (transforming grey to green infrastructure in order to cope with extreme rainfall in urban areas) and climate change mitigation (energy transformation). In the framework of an experimental study, we shed light on the hydrological and hydrodynamic effects of rooftop photovoltaic installations mounted on green roofs and how this contributes to the development of sustainable solutions in an interdisciplinary setting. Since solar panels redirect rainfall to the “green” fraction of the roof not covered by solar panels, the green roof part is in effect subject to higher rainfall and hence intensified surface runoff generation. Promising results were still obtained in a first investigation, where a photovoltaic green roof has been irrigated by a 100 years design storm with 27 mm over 15 minutes: the runoff coefficient (i.e., the percentage of rainfall that becomes runoff) at the end of the rainfall event amounts to only 23%, even though surface runoff occurred after 13 minutes. Based on this first investigation, a systematic measurement campaign has been launched to scrutinize the impact of the microscale spatial rainfall redistribution by solar panels on the runoff coefficient. In this presentation, we show the results of the first investigation along with results achieved in the systematic measurement campaign, which considers different vertical layer structures as well as various flow lengths and slopes of the photovoltaic green roof. In parallel, green roofs without photovoltaic rooftop installations are investigated alongside as a benchmark. In essence, our results suggest to consider both green roofs and photovoltaic rooftop installations to support both climate change mitigation and adaptation, which are important questions that decision makers are simultaneously confronted with. This way, this presentation highlights how experimental hydrology and interdisciplinary collaboration can contribute to address policy-related emerging research. Given that an obligation to install solar panels is expected in numerous countries, this kind of research might endorse new design approaches in future green roof design guidelines relevant for practitioners.

 

How to cite: Förster, K., Westerholt, D., and Lösken, G.: Photovoltaic green roofs – On the role of experimental hydrology to feature the acceptance of interdisciplinary and sustainable solutions for both climate change mitigation and adaptation, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9498, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9498, 2022.

EGU22-10129 | Presentations | HS1.1.2

Efficacy of source-control, use-related and end-of-pipe regulations on river water quality in a large German river catchment: a 50-year trajectory 

Sophia Hildebrandt, Elisabeth Helen Krüger, Katja Westphal, Aki Sebastian Ruhl, and Dietrich Borchardt

River water quality changes have been shown to follow typical trajectories, often characterized by sequential phases of accelerated degradation, environmental recovery, and responsive management. However, the relationships between anthropogenic mitigation measures such as regulatory interventions and their effects on water quality remain rarely studied and poorly understood.

In this study, we evaluate the effectiveness of three types of regulations: source-control, use-related and end-of-pipe regulations. Using phosphorus (P) as a model substance for water quality, we analyse a 50-year trajectory of measured total phosphorus (TP) concentrations in the river Ruhr, Germany, and link this with a comprehensive analysis of water quality related laws and regulations being enforced at the national and European level over the same time period. We categorized the regulations according to the aforementioned types and re-analysed the infrastructure developments and operation modes in a literature review and based on research in the archives of the responsible river basin management authority.

The strong decline of TP concentrations from a maximum of 0.59mg/l TP in 1977 to around 0.05mg/l TP in the early 21st century resulted dominantly from source control by banning of P in detergents, the parallel construction of wastewater treatment plants and their sequential upgrade to treatment stages incorporating P removal. Thus, while point source pollution decreased, the share of agricultural and other diffuse sources of riverine TP concentrations increased to around 50%, making them the focus of attention nowadays. As source control and end-of-pipe measures have reached a level at which a further reduction of TP concentration in the river through those means would be marginal, use-related measures gain importance, especially for agricultural practices.

Our results show that source-control was the most effective and fastest way of reducing TP pollution, whereas end-of-pipe measures were a necessary, complementary way to reduce P related water quality impairment. Given the current dominance of diffuse pollution sources resulting from agricultural inputs, where the effectiveness of regulation is likely to be limited, additional measures such as awareness, economic incentives and support for agricultural best management practices need to be addressed. These findings may provide important insights into understanding the effectiveness of different regulatory measures, in particular with regard to the increasing introduction of (new) pollutants and associated impacts on the environment and human health.

How to cite: Hildebrandt, S., Krüger, E. H., Westphal, K., Ruhl, A. S., and Borchardt, D.: Efficacy of source-control, use-related and end-of-pipe regulations on river water quality in a large German river catchment: a 50-year trajectory, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10129, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10129, 2022.

EGU22-10351 | Presentations | HS1.1.2

Public Drinking Water Access in Texas (United States) Communities During The Winter Storm 2021 

Brianna Tomko, Audrey H. Sawyer, Xavier Sánchez-Vila, and Christine Nittrouer

The Winter Storm of February 2021 left millions of Americans in Gulf Coast states without access to reliable, clean domestic water during the COVID19 pandemic. In the state of Texas, over 17 million people served by public drinking water systems were placed under boil water advisories for periods ranging from one day to more than one month. We combine public boil water advisory data with demographic information from the 2010 United States Census to understand the affected populations. Additionally, we are conducting a survey of over 350 households in Texas to portray the impact of demographics and family considerations on Texans personal experiences with water access during the Winter Storm of 2021. Statistical analysis shows that the duration of boil water advisories depended partly on the size of the public water system. Large, predominantly urban systems (serving more than 10,000 individuals) tended to issue shorter advisories (median of 6 days and a maximum of 12 days). Smaller systems (serving less than 10,000 individuals) experienced a wide range of advisory lengths with a median of 8 days and a maximum of 36 days. Principal component analysis shows two main dimensions of variability among public water systems based on weather and demographics. Some of the longest boil water advisories exhibit clustering consistent with smaller, more rural systems (which also tend to serve predominantly white communities). Though these communities' benefit from public water service, the systems that serve them may have fewer resources to address problems that arise in extreme weather events. Small, rural or ex-urban communities with a greater portion of non-white residents have historically been excluded from public water service in the US (a problem known as underbounding). Some of these communities lack access to clean drinking water year-round and are more likely to experience more significant barriers to access in extreme weather events such as the Winter Storm of 2021. More studies are needed to understand and address disparities in clean water access throughout the US.  

How to cite: Tomko, B., Sawyer, A. H., Sánchez-Vila, X., and Nittrouer, C.: Public Drinking Water Access in Texas (United States) Communities During The Winter Storm 2021, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10351, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10351, 2022.

EGU22-10886 | Presentations | HS1.1.2

Water and conflict on internal displacement: network analysis of Somalia case 

Woi Sok Oh, Rachata Muneepeerakul, Daniel Rubenstein, Mehran Homayounfar, and Simon Levin

Recent decades have witnessed an increasing trend of displacement—forced movements of people, e.g., refugee, internal displacement, asylum. The greatest portion of global displaced populations are internally displaced persons (IDP) who travel within a country's boundary. IDPs are relocated due to varying reasons such as conflict, drought, flood, etc. Somalia is particularly renowned for protracted internal displacement due to long-lasting conflicts, extreme droughts, and flooding events. Despite the severity and continuity of the problem, we still lack an understanding of how water (here, droughts and floods) and conflict build IDP networks respectively. This research answers the following questions to solve the gap: (1) What are the underlying push and pull mechanisms in water-induced and conflict-induced IDP networks?; (2) How are water-induced and conflict-induced IDP networks structured and characterized?; (3) How do geographical locations cluster differently in two IDP networks? The analysis was conducted on the yearly IDP flow data at the district level in Somalia. We compared water-induced and conflict-induced IDP networks in Somalia using multiple network metrics, motif analysis, and community detection algorithms. From the analysis, conflict-induced IDP networks followed a power law for both indegree and outdegree. Though the in-degree networks of water-induced IDPs were weakly scale-free, the out-degree case was a random network. Both water-induced and conflict-induced IDP networks shared a similar mesoscopic network structure through the motif analysis. Closed triads were more frequently observed, supporting the importance of social linkages such as social homophily or information/knowledge sharing. Through the community detection, we found that water drove IDPs to move to nearby locations and led neighboring locations to clustered. Conflict, however, facilitated IDP flows between remote locations, building geographically-dispersed clusters. These findings offer an in-depth insight into commonalities and differences between water-induced and conflict-induced IDP networks in Somalia.

How to cite: Oh, W. S., Muneepeerakul, R., Rubenstein, D., Homayounfar, M., and Levin, S.: Water and conflict on internal displacement: network analysis of Somalia case, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10886, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10886, 2022.

EGU22-11380 | Presentations | HS1.1.2

Leveraging the transformative potential of shocks: a conceptual framework to reach the adaptigation goal 

Thomas Thaler, Eva Posch, Sebastian Seebauer, and Claudia Winkler

Recent examples of climate-driven catastrophes both internationally (e.g. US and Australian wildfires in 2020) and nationally in Africa or Europe, as well as climate scenarios highlight that climate change impacts will likely reach dimensions which pose substantive shocks to social, economic and ecological systems in the near future. At some point, this increased number of shocks will overstretch current individual and collective coping capacities. However, on the other side catastrophic shocks may enable the transformation to decarbonisation and resilience of our society, if the rebuilding phase after an event is used for a broad societal transformation process and not only for quickly bouncing back to the pre-shock situation. A rushed return to normality may come at the cost of forgoing lengthy and challenging transformation processes, which may ultimately reorient a system to higher resilience. Fast recovery from shocks typically mobilizes extensive resources but often lacks an integrated perspective on climate change adaptation and mitigation policies (‘adaptigation’) that could leverage synergies and build up for long-term responses to climate impacts. Instead, many policies implemented after shocks act in isolated or even competitive silos, cater to immediate demands by affected citizens and businesses, and have different goals, instruments, financial resources, administrative practices, time perspectives, or lack of imagination how to implement. The aim of the paper is therefore to illustrate how the transformative potential of shocks can be leveraged to lower carbon emissions, higher climate resilience and encompassing adaptigation policy. This contribution presents a conceptual framework that focuses on the interaction between the individual actors affected by a shock, and the policy instruments in place in the aftermath of a shock. We strive to learn from past and current reactions to inform the future with the aim of directing post-shock learning to transformation outcomes and to avoiding maladaptation, backfire or inaction pitfalls. The paper derives guidance how to leverage the transformative potential of shocks by dedicated policy action, in order to promote outcomes congruent with the Sustainable Development Goals and the targets of European and Austrian climate change mitigation and adaptation strategies. The conceptual framework can be expected to apply to a wide range of emerging, novel or familiar shocks.

How to cite: Thaler, T., Posch, E., Seebauer, S., and Winkler, C.: Leveraging the transformative potential of shocks: a conceptual framework to reach the adaptigation goal, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11380, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11380, 2022.

EGU22-11789 | Presentations | HS1.1.2

An Interaction between flood and economy of Yangjae River in socio-hydrology perspective 

Subin Kang, Sumiya Uranchimeg, Hemie Cho, and Hyun-Han Kwon

Over several years, flood management was concentrated on a physical solution such as building flood control structures like levees or dikes. However, with the increasing term of  “socio-hydrology” within the scientific community, the importance of analyzing the feedback between socio and hydrological systems is drawing attention for effective flood management. Many studies(Di Baldassarre, G et al., 2013; Green, C et al., 2011) have warned about the levee effect, which means increasing vulnerability due to non-occurrence of frequent flooding as a result of flood control structure system. Research to understand such interactions from a sociohydrology perspective is mostly conceptual and limited to qualitative analysis. In this study, we quantitively evaluate the dynamic behavior of a system composed of flood-economy-infrastructure. Sociohydrology model based on the differential equation for dynamic analysis system was used to interpret the Yangjae river flood plain numerically. The results confirmed that excessively built flood control structure systems increased flood risk and hindered economic growth.

How to cite: Kang, S., Uranchimeg, S., Cho, H., and Kwon, H.-H.: An Interaction between flood and economy of Yangjae River in socio-hydrology perspective, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11789, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11789, 2022.

EGU22-11837 | Presentations | HS1.1.2

WMO Hydrological Research Strategy 2022‑2030: Operational Hydrology and Water Research Priorities 

Maria-Helena Ramos, Christophe Cudennec, Johannes Cullmann, Nilay Dogulu, Jürg Luterbacher, Ilias Pechlivanidis, and Aaron Salzberg

The World Meteorological Organization (WMO) supports the National Meteorological and Hydrological Services in their mission to deliver operational hydrology services for achieving water security and the water-dependent/water-related Sustainable Development Goals. Operational hydrology is defined as “the real time and regular measurement, collection, processing, archiving and distribution of hydrological, hydrometeorological and cryospheric data, and the generation of analyses, models, forecasts and warnings which inform water resources management and support water-related decisions, across a spectrum of temporal and spatial scales”. The WMO ‘Vision and Strategy for Hydrology and its associated Plan of Action*’, approved by the Extraordinary Congress in October 2021, identifies eight long-term ambitions for operational hydrology in support of the global water agenda: (1) No one is surprised by a flood, (2) Everyone is prepared for drought, (3) Hydro-climate and meteorological data support the food security agenda, (4) High-quality data supports science, (5) Science provides a sound basis for operational hydrology, (6) We have a thorough knowledge of the water resources of our world, (7) Sustainable development is supported by hydrological information, and (8) Water quality is known. The WMO initiatives aim at improving operational hydrology applications by communicating the needs and benefits of hydrological research in support of operational hydrology, and enabling new research partnerships and collaborations with academia and practice communities. In this presentation, we focus on science priorities and knowledge gaps necessary to improve the delivery and the use of hydrologic data, information, and services in operational hydrology. We discuss the WMO Hydrological Research Strategy and how we can strengthen Hydrology/Water topics under the umbrella of the WMO Research Board. We will also report on the main achievements of an expert team, brought together at the end of 2021 to identify complementary and new research areas to strengthen the linkages between water, weather, climate and environment within the existing WMO related programmes, including the Global Atmosphere Watch (GAW) Programme, the World Climate Research Programme (WCRP), and the World Weather Research Programme (WWRP).

* The process was led by the WMO Research Board (RB) with inputs from the WMO Hydrological Coordination Panel (HCP), the International Association of Hydrological Sciences (IAHS), and the Intergovernmental Hydrological Programme (UNESCO-IHP)

How to cite: Ramos, M.-H., Cudennec, C., Cullmann, J., Dogulu, N., Luterbacher, J., Pechlivanidis, I., and Salzberg, A.: WMO Hydrological Research Strategy 2022‑2030: Operational Hydrology and Water Research Priorities, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11837, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11837, 2022.

EGU22-13024 | Presentations | HS1.1.2 | Highlight

Hydrology Research Articles Are Becoming More Interdisciplinary 

Mashrekur Rahman, Jonathan Frame, Jimmy Lin, and Grey Nearing

We used Natural Language Processing (NLP) to assess topic diversity in the abstracts of all research articles (75,000) from eighteen water science and hydrology journals published between 1991 and 2019 -- these are all water science journals with an SCI h-index > 0.9. We found that individual water science and hydrology research articles are becoming increasingly interdisciplinary in the sense that, on average, the number of sub-topics that are represented in individual articles is increasing. This is true even though the body of water science and hydrology literature as a whole is not becoming more topically diverse. These findings suggest that the National Research Council's (1991) recommendation to increase multidisciplinarity of hydrological research has been followed in the sense that individual researchers are working to make their work more interdisciplinary. Topics with the largest increases in popularity were ‘Forecasting’ and ‘Climate Change Impacts’, and topics with the largest decreases in popularity were ‘Hydraulics’, ‘Solute Transport’, and ‘Aquifers and Abstraction’. Out of the eighteen journals that we tested, Hydrological Processes, Journal of Hydrology, and Water Resources Research are the three most topically diverse journals in the discipline. We also identified topics that are becoming increasingly isolated, and could potentially benefit from integrating more with the wider hydrology discipline.

How to cite: Rahman, M., Frame, J., Lin, J., and Nearing, G.: Hydrology Research Articles Are Becoming More Interdisciplinary, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13024, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13024, 2022.

EGU22-13135 | Presentations | HS1.1.2

Using a Water Budget Approach to Quantify Inflow and Infiltration Impacts on Urban Streamflow 

Jeremy Diem, Luke Pangle, Richard Milligan, and Ellis Adams

Human activities can have substantial impacts on watersheds, and a dominant, yet understudied, impact on urban watersheds is the inflow and infiltration (I&I) of water into sewage infrastructure. This study uses a water-budget approach to quantify the magnitude of I&I and its effects on streamflow. The analysis is performed over the 2013-2020 period on 90 watersheds in the Atlanta, Georgia USA metropolitan statistical area (MSA), which has a humid subtropical climate. The following annual totals are determined for each watershed: precipitation, water leakage from municipal sources, actual evapotranspiration (AET), water withdrawals, and observed stream discharge. AET is the most difficult component to estimate, therefore, multiple models are used to estimate AET totals, and reference watersheds are used to adjust the totals. Predicted discharge is estimated by subtracting known water outputs from the water inputs, and I&I was the difference between predicted discharge and observed discharge. The most I&I-impacted watersheds are those with the largest I&I to stream discharge ratios. Mean annual totals for precipitation and supply-pipe loss for those watersheds are 1,498 mm and 39 mm, respectively. Mean annual totals for AET, stream discharge, and I&I, are 737 mm, 534 mm, and 267 mm. Therefore, the mean I&I to streamflow ratio for the ten most I&I-impacted watersheds is 0.51 (i.e., I&I is 51% of streamflow). Mean population densities, percent developed, and percent imperviousness for the ten watersheds are as follows: 1,308 people per km2, 60%, and 37%, respectively. I&I is strongly positively correlated with the above three urbanization variables. Regression analyses show that population density explains approximately 50% of the variation in I&I and is the best predictor of I&I. The most urbanized watersheds in the Atlanta MSA have relatively low population densities compared to typical urban watersheds globally, so it remains to be seen if the regression model can be used in locales with much higher population densities. Nevertheless, these results are supported by previous findings in the eastern United States and the results should be transferrable to most urban watersheds there, while the general approach for quantifying I&I should be applicable globally.

How to cite: Diem, J., Pangle, L., Milligan, R., and Adams, E.: Using a Water Budget Approach to Quantify Inflow and Infiltration Impacts on Urban Streamflow, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13135, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13135, 2022.

EGU22-13166 | Presentations | HS1.1.2

High resolution coupled climate-hydrology-dynamical Malaria transmission modeling for regional Malaria transmission in sub-Saharan Africa 

Mame Diarra Bousso Dieng, Joël Arnault, Adrian Tompkins, Alie Sié, Stephan Munga, Jonas Franke, and Harald Kunstmann

Malaria remains a major health problem predominantly in tropical countries and is still being one of the biggest causes of mortality worldwide. It is an ancient vector borne infectious disease caused by parasitic protozoans of the genus Plasmodium and is transmitted by female mosquitos of the Anopheles species. The spatiotemporal distribution of this vector is sensitive to climate conditions and the distribution of hydrometeorological variables, particularly temperature, precipitation, and humidity. We present first results of a joint high resolution hydrometeorological- and subsequent dynamical vector transmission modelling. Our approach uses the couple atmospheric- and terrestrial model system WRF-Hydro, with a 1km grid spacing for the atmospheric part and a 100m grid spacing for the hydrological part. Besides traditional hydrometeorological variables, WRF-Hydro further resolves the surface water, which is potentially a crucial step forward for the grid cell distributed dynamical vector transmission model VECTRI. Our study addresses two Health and Demographic Surveillance Systems (HDSS) site regions at Nouna in Burkina Faso and Kisumu in Kenya. We present an analysis of the performance of the hydrometeorological model system and first results of the VECTRI modeling.

Preliminary results of the WRF-Hydro -VECTRI model system capture the Malaria seasonal variations correctly and show reasonable reproduction of the year-to-year variability of HDSS observed total Malaria cases.

How to cite: Bousso Dieng, M. D., Arnault, J., Tompkins, A., Sié, A., Munga, S., Franke, J., and Kunstmann, H.: High resolution coupled climate-hydrology-dynamical Malaria transmission modeling for regional Malaria transmission in sub-Saharan Africa, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13166, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13166, 2022.

EGU22-13392 | Presentations | HS1.1.2

Public perception of droughts and water shortages and metropolitan willingness to pay for water saving measures to improve water security 

Jullian Sone, Gabriela Gesualdo, Dimaghi Schwamback, Edson Wendland, and Roy Brouwer

The increase in water demand and droughts have exacerbated water inequalities and weakened the economy worldwide. Nonetheless, droughts alone do not justify the severity of water scarcity events, leading to public water rationing and restrictions. It is of paramount importance to obtain a better understanding of how public perceptions of and attitudes towards drought adaptation strategies influence the severity and extent of impacts on water consumption. Furthermore, studies on the general public’s willingness to pay for mitigation and adaptation measures are key for the design and implementation of efficient and effective water management policies. This study aims to inform policy and decision-making by investigating people’s experiences, perceptions, and assessments of past water scarcity events to understand how these past events may have changed their attitudes and behaviour towards water availability and saving. Data were collected by surveying a sample of 800 residents in the Metropolitan Area of São Paulo (MASP) in South-eastern Brazil, and in Campo Grande in Midwestern Brazil. The MASP faced a severe drought from 2014 until and including 2015 due to a decrease in rainfall and human factors, including water resource mismanagement. This vulnerability frame is also observed in Campo Grande, where residents faced serious water rationing in 2016 and 2019. Our results show that more than 80% of the respondents think the frequency of drought periods increased over the last 10 years and will continue to increase in the next 10 years, and 95% of the respondents believe climate change is real. These results also corroborate the fact that 80% of the sample have faced water restrictions or rationing in the past, of which most lasted more than one day. The study provides policy and decision-makers with important information about the future design of payments for watershed services (PWS) to improve water security. However, one in every fifth respondent does not believe that a possible payment for water saving measures in the surrounding watersheds supplying the cities with drinking water would be invested by the responsible authorities to reduce future water restrictions and rationing and, therefore, improve water security. This reveals a considerable mistrust in the local, regional, and state governments responsible for water supply. Our findings provide important insights into relevant feedbacks between hydrological events such as droughts and societal vulnerability and response inserted into the present-day Brazilian cultural, socioeconomic, and political context, and the effectiveness of economic policy instruments like PWS.

How to cite: Sone, J., Gesualdo, G., Schwamback, D., Wendland, E., and Brouwer, R.: Public perception of droughts and water shortages and metropolitan willingness to pay for water saving measures to improve water security, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13392, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13392, 2022.

EGU22-36 | Presentations | HS1.1.4

Coevolution and Prediction of Coupled Human-Water Systems: A Synthesis of Change in Hydrology and Society 

Fuqiang Tian, Melissa Haeffner, Heidi Kreibich, Aditi Mukherji, Jing Wei, Murugesu Sivapalan, and Günter Blöschl

There has been increasing recognition that the global water crisis is due to lack of understanding of wider economic and socio-cultural perspectives, resulted from the intended and/or unintended consequences of co-evolution of coupled human-water systems. In light of such recognition, Panta Rhei Initiative (2013-2022) was proposed to focus on changes in both hydrology and society. Approaching end of this decade, this study present the synthesis of knowledge gained in our understanding of coevolution and prediction of coupled human-water systems. Content include five parts: (I) Motivation and Overview, (II) Theoretical Foundations and Methodological Approaches, (III) Synthesis of Work Done and Understanding Gained in Specific Application Areas, (IV) Panta Rhei Case Studies, (V) Grand Synthesis and Recommendations.

How to cite: Tian, F., Haeffner, M., Kreibich, H., Mukherji, A., Wei, J., Sivapalan, M., and Blöschl, G.: Coevolution and Prediction of Coupled Human-Water Systems: A Synthesis of Change in Hydrology and Society, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-36, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-36, 2022.

EGU22-458 | Presentations | HS1.1.4

Assessing smallholder drought risk dynamics under climate change and government policies 

Marthe Wens, Anne Van Loon, Ted Veldkamp, Moses Mwangi, and Jeroen Aerts

The effectiveness of governmental disaster risk reduction policies in East Africa is influenced by how smallholder farmers react to droughts and adopt drought adaptation measures. In recent research on socio-hydrological feedbacks and the role of farmers’ adaptive behaviour in drought management, agent-based models (ABM) were found to be powerful tools. In this study, we developed an innovative agent-based drought risk model (ADOPT) that explicitly takes into account the two-way relationship between heterogenous individual agricultural adaptation decisions and the agro-hydrological system (modelled using AquacropOS). ADOPT is able to evaluate the effect of drought risk policies on the dynamics of poverty, food security and relief needs, and was applied to a case in Kenya.

First, we conducted a multi-method data survey among stakeholders and households in semiarid Kenya to better understand the drivers and barriers, such as knowledge of adaptation measures, fear of droughts, and perceived vulnerability, that determine the adoption of drought adaptation measures in this context. This information was used to calibrate the decision rules in ADOPT. We then applied ADOPT to simulate how drought policy interventions, such as improving extension services, improving early-warning systems, distributing ex-ante rather than ex-post cash transfers, and widening access to credit markets, influence the drought risk and adaptation of smallholders. We found that a holistic approach, including all these measures combined, can reduce the poverty rate with 66%, food insecurity with 70%, and aid needs with 75%, on average over six potential future climate scenarios.

How to cite: Wens, M., Van Loon, A., Veldkamp, T., Mwangi, M., and Aerts, J.: Assessing smallholder drought risk dynamics under climate change and government policies, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-458, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-458, 2022.

EGU22-857 | Presentations | HS1.1.4

COASTMOVE: A global agent-based model of adaptation and migration decisions in face of sea level rise 

Lars Tierolf, Toon Haer, Jens de Bruijn, Wouter Botzen, Lena Reimann, Marijn Ton, and Jeroen Aerts

Sea-level rise (SLR) and socioeconomic trends are increasing the population and assets exposed to extreme coastal flood events in the coming decades. People residing in communities experiencing this increase in coastal flood risk may choose to stay, to stay and adapt, or to migrate towards safer areas. However, these migration decisions are influenced by many socio- economic and environmental factors. For example, current assessments of SLR adaptation and migration do often not address risk perceptions of residents related to different environmental risks, such as flooding and erosion. These factors influence adaptation decisions, and thus exposure and vulnerability. In this study, we aim to improve the representation of the dynamics of adaptive behavior of coastal communities in flood risk assessment by including human behavior and its effect on adaptation decisions, in face of SLR. Therefore, we develop an agent-based model grounded in subjective expected utility theory and simulate adaptation- and migration decisions of households facing coastal flood risk in France between 19xx and 2020. The model is empirically calibrated using survey data on flood risk perception and people’s willingness to implement adaptation measures. Then, we use socio-demographic projections to estimate future changes (2020-2080) in demographic composition, and apply the model to simulate coastal adaptation. The agent-based model presented in this study functions as a platform for further development of 1) more realistic decision models and 2) global modelling approaches of both coastal adaptation and migration under projections of future development.

How to cite: Tierolf, L., Haer, T., de Bruijn, J., Botzen, W., Reimann, L., Ton, M., and Aerts, J.: COASTMOVE: A global agent-based model of adaptation and migration decisions in face of sea level rise, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-857, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-857, 2022.

EGU22-1323 | Presentations | HS1.1.4

Assessment of water resources conservation and sustainable management strategies in the Lower Mekong River Basin 

Ibrahim Mohammed, John Bolten, Nicholas Souter, Kashif Shaad, and Derek Vollmer

Uncertainties and indeterminate scope, divergent social values and stakeholder interests, and changing hydroclimatology in transboundary river basins are all factors that may complicate sustainable water resource management. To address such complex socio hydrological issues, we present an example of an integrated approach to assessing future sustainability challenges in their social, hydrological, and ecological dimensions using a case study from the Lower Mekong basin. Our study area here is the combined basin of the Se Kong, Se San, and Sre Pok (3S) rivers which deliver approximately 20% of flow to the Mekong River system. We used a mixed methods approach to analyze potential impacts of climate change on regional hydrology, the ability of dam operation rules to keep downstream flow within acceptable limits, and the present state of water governance in Laos, Vietnam, and Cambodia. Our results suggest that future river flows in the 3S river system could move closer to natural (i.e. pre-development) conditions during the dry season and experience increased floods during the wet season. This anticipated new flow regime in the 3S region would require a shift in the current dam operations, from maintaining minimum flows to reducing flood hazards. Moreover, our Governance and Stakeholders survey assessment results revealed that existing water governance systems in Laos, Vietnam, and Cambodia are ill-prepared to address such anticipated future water resource management problems. Our results indicate that the solution space for addressing these complex issues in the 3S river basins will be highly constrained unless major deficiencies in transboundary water governance, strategic planning, financial capacity, information sharing, and law enforcement are remedied in the next decade. This work is part of an ongoing research partnership between the National Aeronautical and Space Agency (NASA) and the Conservation International (CI) dedicated to improving natural resources assessment for conservation and sustainable management.

How to cite: Mohammed, I., Bolten, J., Souter, N., Shaad, K., and Vollmer, D.: Assessment of water resources conservation and sustainable management strategies in the Lower Mekong River Basin, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1323, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1323, 2022.

EGU22-1522 | Presentations | HS1.1.4

How much can we simplify irrigation in an integrated modelling purpose? A case study in southern France 

Myriam Soutif--Bellenger, Guillaume Thirel, Olivier Therond, and Jean Villerd

The estimation of irrigation amounts and timings is crucial for the design of water management strategies at the regional scale. However, simplified modelling approaches are often preferred even though very complex and high-accuracy crop models or agent-based models exist. In this study, we develop a sensitivity analysis to evaluate the impacts of simplifications and hypotheses in irrigation modelling. For this, different simple modelling approaches based on the CropWat model were compared to a multi-agent based approach (Maelia), which served as a benchmark. To make an in-depth comparison between simulations, several indicators characterizing daily simulated irrigation were calculated and a decomposition of variance was carried out to measure impacts of diverse factors on irrigation. Applied over a downstream portion of the Aveyron River (southern France), the sensitivity analysis shows a high variability between simulations in function of modelling assumptions. It also shows that several simplifying approaches were able to reproduce the high-accuracy model estimation of irrigation. Decisive variation factors we identified are rules of triggering and quantification of daily irrigation, irrigation period definition and evapotranspiration estimation. Recommendations to take into account highlighted variability linked to farmers’ irrigation practices are introduced in this work, consisting in a combining a set of irrigation models. In function of advancement, a complete integrated agro-hydrologic modelling chain might be presented.

How to cite: Soutif--Bellenger, M., Thirel, G., Therond, O., and Villerd, J.: How much can we simplify irrigation in an integrated modelling purpose? A case study in southern France, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1522, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1522, 2022.

EGU22-2333 | Presentations | HS1.1.4

Effects of historic changes in regional drainage characteristics on the drawdown of groundwater abstractions 

Marjolein van Huijgevoort, Gijsbert Cirkel, and Ruud Bartholomeus

Calculating the drawdown of groundwater abstractions for drinking water is usually done considering the current land use and regional drainage characteristics. However, many drinking water abstractions already exist for several decades and abstracted volumes have increased over time. In the Netherlands, especially in the more elevated parts of the country, the drainage characteristics were also significantly altered to prevent water logging and to optimize the water management for agricultural use, often after establishment of the groundwater abstraction site. These changes were intended to lower the phreatic groundwater levels to prevent waterlogging, but unintendedly also made the regions more vulnerable to drought. The question is whether groundwater abstractions for groundwater would have a similar impact in the former historic hydrological context and whether restoring the system to this state would ameliorate current drought problems.

In this study we investigated whether a drinking water abstraction would have the same drawdown if the regional drainage characteristics would not have been altered and whether restoring the historic situation would decrease drought impacts. First, a literature study was conducted to understand the changes to the drainage system over time. These changes were then implemented in a regional groundwater model (based on Modflow) for a conceptual region, representative for the eastern part of the Netherlands. Results from both the literature study and the groundwater model indicated that changes in the drainage system lowered the groundwater levels by tens of centimetres (differences ranged from 20 to 100 cm). Drawdown from the drinking water abstraction was larger in the historical situation than in the current situation, even though groundwater levels were higher. In the historical situation less reduction in transpiration occurred, leading to a lower recharge of the groundwater and thus a larger drawdown. However, when irrigation was applied, this effect was not found.  This implied that a correct estimate of groundwater recharge is crucial to calculate drawdown from abstractions. Recharge depends on actual evapotranspiration, of which the conceptualization in regional models could be improved. Returning the drainage system to the historical situation leads to higher groundwater levels, thereby reducing the drought impact, but also increasing the risk of oxygen stress in crops. More research with regard to the impact on crop yields is needed on local scale, before measures to mitigate drought impacts can be taken.

How to cite: van Huijgevoort, M., Cirkel, G., and Bartholomeus, R.: Effects of historic changes in regional drainage characteristics on the drawdown of groundwater abstractions, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2333, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2333, 2022.

There is a reason why Iceland is frequently called the land of fire and ice. Located on the mid-Atlantic ridge in the North Atlantic Ocean, Iceland is frequently exposed to explosive volcanic eruptions. Furthermore, due to its geographic location cold Arctic winds from the North and the warm humid winds coming from the Gulf of Mexico collide. The particular geographic location is the reason why over 10% of the Island area is covered by glaciers, precipitation can exceed 10´000 mm a-1, and glacial flood can reach several 100’000 m3 s-1. Regardless of the arctic winds, the extreme precipitation, and the frequent eruption, the original Icelandic vegetation has developed a resilience to with sand almost any natural hazard. However, with the arrival of the first settler over a millennium ago Iceland has been subject to dramatic deforestation due to intense sheep and horse farming. These anthropogenic impacts have severely mitigated the resilience of the Icelandic vegetation, altering the erosion patterns and finally also impacting the natural water flow. The Rangárvellir area in southern Iceland is an ideal location to study the interaction of human impacts, natural hazards, and consequences for the natural water cycle. Deforestation and intensive farming have decreased the resilience of the local ecosystems, leading to severe land degradation and extensive soil erosion. Since the beginning of the 20th century, diverse restoration measures have been implemented across Rangárvellir. Long-term monitoring programs demonstrate how restoration can help mitigate hydrometeorological and volcanic risks, providing a representative example of nature-based solutions. For this purpose, we present a metadatabase (http://rangarvellir.ru.is/) providing an overview of previous and ongoing research on land restoration, land management, reforestation, hydro-meteorological monitoring, and vegetation mapping. All relevant past and ongoing research and restoration projects are described in order to demonstrate the importance of an all-inclusive landscape restoration approach. The study concludes by outlining the importance of nature-based solutions and highlights the interaction between research projects in the frame of restoration and land reclamation efforts.

How to cite: Finger, D. C.: Hydrology at its extreme: climate change, societal impacts and natural hazards in the land of fire and ice, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4543, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4543, 2022.

EGU22-5096 | Presentations | HS1.1.4

Detecting natural and anthropic effects on displacements and water level changes: a combined observation from rain gauges, piezometers and CGNSS 

Massimo Nespoli, Nicola Cenni, Maria Elina Belardinelli, and Marco Marcaccio

The Po Plain (Northern Italy) has largely subsided due to natural processes and human activities. In particular, in order to reduce subsidence, in the Bologna metropolitan area a politic decision in 2010, imposed a significant reduction of civil water supply from groundwater withdrawal wells. The study area is characterized by an excellent monitoring activity which provides a good spatial and temporal distribution of data coming from continuous GNSS sites, piezometers and rain gauges.

In the present work we analyze both GNSS and piezometric data by means of the Principal Component Analysis (PCA). The results of the analysis are then compared with the rainfall time series measured by rain gauges. Thanks to the PCA analysis we can identify: i) a clear increase in the water level following the withdrawal decrease started in 2010 and ii) an anthropic induced surface displacement, which is smaller in magnitude than that induced by rainfall variations. Without the PCA analysis, such a small, but still significant, anthropic effect on vertical displacements would have remained hidden in the raw time series.

Our analysis reveals a decrease of about 4 mm/y of vertical velocity in some GNSS sites closest the withdrawal wells. We also found that on large time scales (> 1 month), the vertical displacement induced by rainfall strongly depends on the geological setting: in the mountains a water level increase causes subsidence (elastic response), whereas in the Po Plain it causes uplift (poro-elastic response). Thanks to the PCA analyses, the combined observations of different kind of instruments (GNSS, piezometers and rain gauges) and a basic knowledge of the geological context, we can correctly identify both the anthropic and natural signals on the data.

How to cite: Nespoli, M., Cenni, N., Belardinelli, M. E., and Marcaccio, M.: Detecting natural and anthropic effects on displacements and water level changes: a combined observation from rain gauges, piezometers and CGNSS, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5096, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5096, 2022.

EGU22-5520 | Presentations | HS1.1.4

Exploring local perceptions of water quality in the upper Santa River, Peru 

Sally Rangecroft, Rosa Maria Dextre, Isabel Richter, Claire Kelly, Cecilia Turin, Beatriz Fuentealba, Claudia V. Grados Bueno, Mirtha Camacho Hernández, Sergio Morera, John Martin, Adam Guy, and Caroline Clason

Water quality is an integral part of water security, but water quality itself is complex, due to its multifaceted nature. Measuring the physico-chemical indicators for water quality (e.g. pH, turbidity, heavy metal content) can provide an objective picture of water health, but it does not provide information on how it integrates and expresses the human perspective. Perceptual information and local ecological knowledge on water quality can help to understand the usability of water and support better conservation strategies. Therefore, the aims of the Nuestro Rio project were to investigate local perceptions of water quality in the upper Santa River basin, Peru. Walking interviews (n = 99) were conducted in the field between July-August 2021 to assess community members perceptions of their local rivers and streams. Through qualitative data analysis in two rural communities in the glaciated Santa River basin, we collected local perspectives on good and poor water quality, identified some of the key water concerns of the population, and explored the importance of emotions for determining water quality perceptions. Overall water quality perspectives differed within, and between, the two communities. Yet, it was possible to identify several characteristics and concerns that the population has been perceiving in recent years, as well as their causes, both natural and anthropogenic. Both communities felt the main cause of poor water quality was pollution due to the presence of minerals in the water, “invisible” aspects of water quality. We found that local perceptions on water quality also depend on water use as it has an important effect on local organisation. Emotions, on the other hand, reflect the population’s concern, fear, anger, and even frustration, when perceiving poor water quality, and happiness, trust, and even affection, when perceiving good water quality. More inclusive science that asks people what they observe, think and feel about the quality of their rivers and water can help provide a much deeper contextual understanding (e.g. useability of water, changes over time, traditional ecological knowledge) of local dynamic human-water systems, and improve science communication and policy implementation.

How to cite: Rangecroft, S., Dextre, R. M., Richter, I., Kelly, C., Turin, C., Fuentealba, B., Grados Bueno, C. V., Camacho Hernández, M., Morera, S., Martin, J., Guy, A., and Clason, C.: Exploring local perceptions of water quality in the upper Santa River, Peru, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5520, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5520, 2022.

EGU22-5577 | Presentations | HS1.1.4

Solving water management paradoxes requires a systems meta-model 

Ana Mijic, Leyang Liu, Jimmy O'Keeffe, Barnaby Dobson, and Kwok Pan Chun

Sustainable development is becoming increasingly urgent in the post-COVID recovery and climate crisis era. Despite this need, the water management scientific community is still deciding how to comprehensively represent and assess the role of humans within the hydrological cycle. An explanation may be found in numerous examples where water managers are often challenged when their decisions, policies, and interventions lead to a range of unintended consequences that cause increased pressures on the environment, which have been described by socio-hydrological paradoxes. If the paradoxes are seen as the main obstacles hindering sustainable development in the context of water management, then investigating their mechanisms and understanding logic may help us to reveal unintended system responses and define guiding principles critical for designing robust and sustainable water management plans. We analyse the socio-hydrological paradoxes from a systems perspective and assume that water management decisions and plans developed adopting a linear thinking and goals-focused approach are likely to neglect consequential effects which occur throughout the wider system. This definition enables us to rename the phenomena into water management paradoxes, which might be fundamentally related to systems’ complexity and unexpected behaviour arising from internal feedbacks along with external driving forces that generate nonlinear outcomes which are inconsistent with the expected results or responses from inputs and actions within the system.

To find solutions for the water management paradoxes, we hypothesise that they can be described in the context of three feedback mechanisms, which define the purpose of systems water management (SYWM) as coordination of development and water infrastructure with environmental management to improve the quality of life. We argue that the lack of consideration, integration and coordination of the SYWM meta-model loops will result in one of the water management paradoxes. As a solution, we propose three paradox archetypes that form the basis for guiding principles for systems water management. We suggest that environmental capacity indicators should be used in whole-system performance evaluation. The meta-model emphasises the need to better understand the baseline and development scenarios in the context of water neutrality, which is crucial for informing development decisions, including trade-offs in resource and infrastructure planning and operation. We encourage the use of a SYWM meta-model and proposed principles as a guide for analysing, modelling, and assessing human-water systems, thus creating an evidence base of case studies to demonstrate the meta-model’s applicability to solving water management paradoxes. In doing so, we hope to move towards the design of water systems that will support post-COVID recovery and enable long-term sustainable development.

 

How to cite: Mijic, A., Liu, L., O'Keeffe, J., Dobson, B., and Chun, K. P.: Solving water management paradoxes requires a systems meta-model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5577, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5577, 2022.

EGU22-6497 | Presentations | HS1.1.4

Polycentric governance and scale challenges in water management in the semi-arid river basin of Banabuiú, Ceará, Brazil 

Esmee van de Ridder, Louise Cavalcante, Pieter van Oel, Art Dewulf, Sarra Kchouk, Germano Ribeiro Neto, David Walker, and Eduardo Martins

Water scarcity and drought are sustainability issues that cut across borders and different scales and levels of organizations and cannot be designated to one governmental authority. Due to hydrological droughts in semi-arid Northeast Brazil, the region deals with water scarcity. In the case of Ceará state, water is stored in multiple reservoirs as part of a water supply system and is managed from different levels of organization. These are considered governance scales that include state level-, regional level- and municipal level institutions, local level communities, and individual households. Water management in Ceará is an example of how polycentric governance brings a multifold of governmental and non-governmental actors together for the management of public goods in the society, and therefore cross-scale and cross-level interactions are inevitable. However, a variety of multiple challenges of contradictory water policies, diverse and varying levels of water users and multiple overlapping governance systems and organizations in combination with resource depletion make equitable water allocation challenging in Ceará. For this reason, this research aims to examine the scale mismatches in the water management processes and level misalignments of different governance levels and understand the influences of multiple governance systems on collectively managing water for equal water allocation. The following research question is used: What are the scale mismatches in water management and the misalignments of levels in water governance in Ceará state, and how have these affected the equitable access to water by different groups?

A polycentric governance lens is used to understand the interplay and influences of multiple water governance systems with competitive and cooperative relationships over water resources. We analyzed the multiple scale challenges in water management in the Banabuiú basin in the state of Ceará, using minutes from official water committee meetings, and qualitative data from interviews conducted with smallholder farmers, field technicians, civil servants and researchers in November and December 2021.

Literature research and fieldwork interviews in Ceará provided insights into user conflicts and mismatches across varying scales and levels. Our results show that, at river basin levels, e.g., networks of reservoirs and the river basin of Banabuiú, conflicts of prioritization between small-scale farmers and urban water users occur when the metropolitan area of Fortaleza is prioritized. Prioritization of the metropolitan region has been shown to result in limited and non-participatory decision-making, lack of information sharing and restrictions for irrigated farmers at the local scale. At the local scale, state interference in water management is in some cases not appropriate to the local context or in accordance with local knowledge. These scale mismatches occur due to multiple types of local water management, lack of responsibility for the management of monitored and unmonitored reservoirs, and various overlapping assisting agencies at the community level. The cross-scale interactions and conflicts in water management systems highlight the interdependencies between stakeholders and scale challenges in socio-hydrological systems. 

 

How to cite: van de Ridder, E., Cavalcante, L., van Oel, P., Dewulf, A., Kchouk, S., Ribeiro Neto, G., Walker, D., and Martins, E.: Polycentric governance and scale challenges in water management in the semi-arid river basin of Banabuiú, Ceará, Brazil, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6497, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6497, 2022.

EGU22-6604 | Presentations | HS1.1.4

A comparative analysis between two pluvial flood events in Barcelona (Spain).  An example of a success story 

Maria Carmen Llasat, Blanca Aznar, Laura Esbrí, Tomeu Rigo, Oriol Grima, and Heidi Kreibich

The city of Barcelona is severely affected by pluvial floods, for which the risk management can be further improved. To provide essential information about pluvial flood risk we compare two events that occurred in 1995 and 2018 and put these into context of all convective precipitation events between 2013 and 2018 in Barcelona. The objective is to identify the main drivers of pluvial flood impact and the most flood prone areas. These results will help to further improve pluvial flood risk management in Barcelona, e.g. by developing targeted preparedness and empowerment campaigns.

The event comparison followed the paired event approach (Kreibich et al. 2017). In the 1995 event, the surface runoff of the streets caused a fatality in the Eixample quartier, a total of 2,500 calls were registered to the emergency services, 128,000 subscribers suffered cuts of light, 2 blocks of houses were evacuated, and numerous low floors were flooded.  33.6 Million €2018 were paid by the national insurance company, CCS, to compensate insured losses in Barcelona. The 1995 episode marked a turning point in the development of the sewerage in the city. Although the maximum 5-min intensity in the 1995 event was 235 mm/h in front of 211 mm/h in the 2018 event, the maximum rainfall recorded in 20 min (155,4 mm/h versus 169,8 mm/h, respectively) and 60 min (78,6 mm/h versus 88,1 mm/h), as well as the “average water volume precipitated over the city” (376,5 m3 versus 457,1 m3) was superior in the second event. However, in the 2018 event, only 294 emergency phone calls were received, mainly due to flooding of low plants and basements, water leaks or fallen trees; and 3.5 Million €2018 were paid by the CCS. This analysis shows the effectiveness of the mitigation measures taken in the city after the 1995 flood event that have diminished the vulnerability. The analysis of the 207 convective pluvial events registered by the city's drainage network between 2013 and 2018, with a focus on the 58 events for which radar images are available (Esbrí et al., 2021) provides information on the city quartiers which are most endangered by pluvial floods. Conclusion shows that the structural and non-structural improvements applied in Barcelona are a good example for other cities with similar characteristics, although the improvement in awareness, empowerment and communication with the population is still pending, mainly in the most affected quartiers of the city.

This work has been done in the framework of the I-CHANGE (H2020-2020 Prop.101037193) European project and the C3-RiskMed (PID2020-113638RB-C22) research project, funded by the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation.

References.

Kreibich, H., S. Vorogushyn, J.C.J.H. et al. 2017. Adaptation to flood risk – results of international paired flood event studies. Special collection “Avoiding Disasters: Strengthening Societal Resilience to Natural Hazards” in the journal Earth’s Future. Earth’s Future,5,953–965, doi:10.1002/2017EF000606.

Esbrí, L.; Rigo, T.; Llasat, M.C.; Aznar, B. Identifying Storm Hotspots and the Most Unsettled Areas in Barcelona by Analysing Significant Rainfall Episodes from 2013 to 2018. Water 2021, 13, 1730. https://doi.org/10.3390/w13131730.

How to cite: Llasat, M. C., Aznar, B., Esbrí, L., Rigo, T., Grima, O., and Kreibich, H.: A comparative analysis between two pluvial flood events in Barcelona (Spain).  An example of a success story, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6604, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6604, 2022.

EGU22-6759 | Presentations | HS1.1.4

The society interactions with floods in the modern Chinese history: a comparison between 1931 and 1954 floods 

Chang Liu, Akiyuki Kawasaki, and Tomoko Shiroyama

As the longest river in Asia, the Yangtze River has shown its impact on human societies with floods recorded since 12th century. In 1931, the Yangtze River has manifested its force again with one of the deadliest floods ever recorded in Chinese history, causing 422,499 deaths, damages to more than 25.2 million people and 58.7 billion m2 farmland. Similar flood occurred again in 1954, resulting in 31,762 deaths, damages to 18.9 million people and 31.7 billion m2 farmland. Researches have shown that 1954 flood being larger and higher compared to 1931 flood. However, it is still unclear for what reason that a more severe flood leading to less damage. Was it because of the change of residents’ interactions and for what extent had it affected the damage? To answer this question, first, we constructed a conceptual framework of 1930s and 1950s agricultural society. From which drastic changes has been detected (e.g., increase of absentee landlords, land reform) and the residents’ interactions with floods have been analyzed. Then, we reconstructed the flood inundation process of 1931 and 1954 floods with gauged rainfall dataset. After referring to the investigation report, the inundation information was applied to re-estimate the flood damage on farmland, houses, and residents. With the simulation and modification, we found that the inundated farmland of 1931 is about 83% more than former, indicating a much more severe influence on residents’ lives than we used to think. On the contrary, the total increase of influence farmland in 1954 is around 50% after modification, suggesting a relative success in reducing flood damage. To quantitatively explain it, the countermeasures during 1954 flood were estimated, showing that the reinforcement of levees in 1950s was more effective in reducing inundation area of 7%, while the construction of detention basins accounted for only 2%. Such results revealed that the countermeasures against 1954 flood being more successful than 1931. Moreover, the changes of agricultural interactions with floods have also been estimated using the potential crop production (PCP), indicating an improvement in disaster mitigation in 1954. Our results demonstrate how society changes are likely to affect the response towards natural hazards, the knowledge and method of which are expected to be applicable to many other regions and times.

How to cite: Liu, C., Kawasaki, A., and Shiroyama, T.: The society interactions with floods in the modern Chinese history: a comparison between 1931 and 1954 floods, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6759, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6759, 2022.

EGU22-7834 | Presentations | HS1.1.4

Improved SAFRAN forcing and ECOCLIMAP-SG datasets to simulate irrigation over the Ebro basin 

Anaïs Barella-Ortiz, Pere Quintana-Seguí, Jacopo Dari, Luca Brocca, Víctor Altés, Josep M. Villar, Giovanni Paolini, Maria José Escorihuela, Bertrand Bonan, Jean-Christophe Calvet, and Diane Tzanos

Irrigated agriculture plays an important role in the continental water and energy cycles of the basins where it is present. Land-Surface models (LSM) can be used to study and quantify the impact of anthropic processes on the continental water cycle. Therefore, it is necessary to have good quality forcing and physiographic data, including a correct representation of agricultural covers, irrigation methods and actual irrigated areas. 

This work presents four datasets, at a spatial resolution of 1 km, that have been prepared to simulate irrigation-related processes using a LSM over the Ebro basin, the largest Mediterranean Spanish basin, where irrigated agriculture has a large impact on the water cycle. These datasets are: (1) a land cover map, (2) an actual irrigated areas map, (3) a map of irrigation methods per area, (4) and a meteorological forcing dataset.

The most recent version of the ISBA LSM, in SURFEX v9, contains an improved irrigation scheme (Druel et al., 2021), which requires the also recent ECOCLIMAP-SG land cover map (Druel et al., 2021). We validated ECOCLIMAP-SG over the Ebro basin, using SIGPAC data (Agricultural Plot Geographic Information System) provided by the Spanish Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food. The results showed low F1-score values, indicating a poor representation of agricultural covers. The comparison also showed that ECOCLIMAP-SG overestimated the irrigated surface. Therefore, it was decided to improve the ECOCLIMAP-SG Land Cover Map and create a new map of actual irrigated areas over this basin.

For the improved cover map, SIGPAC information was used. Each agricultural plot was classified, assigning to the informed cultivated species its correspondent ECOCLIMAP-SG cover and replacing it in the original map. The actual irrigated areas map was elaborated combining SIGPAC information of plots prepared for irrigation with data from LAI increments computed for two Summer days (20/08/2017 and 10/08/2019) by LDAS-Monde (Albergel et al. 2017). LDAS-Monde is a tool based on SURFEX able to assimilate satellite-derived LAI from the Copernicus Global Land service in ISBA. The irrigation method map was generated using a simple approach. The irrigation districts were classified between traditional and modernized. In traditional areas, the irrigation method was set to surface irrigation. In modernized areas, plots with herbaceous crops and trees were assigned to sprinkler and drip irrigation respectively. 

In addition, a new version of the SAFRAN meteorological forcing (Vidal et al. 2010, Quintana-Seguí et al, 2017), was developed. For this project, observations from two different sources (Spanish Meteorological State Agency and Catalan Meteorological Survey) were obtained, together with ERA5 data, which is used as first guess (for all variables except Precipitation). SAFRAN has been used to generate forcing data for Precipitation, Temperature, Wind Speed and Relative Humidity.  

The forcing dataset sensitivity has been tested by comparing two SURFEX simulations performed using the new SAFRAN forcing dataset, one with the original ECOCLIMAP-SG maps and another one using the new land cover, actual irrigated areas, and irrigation methods maps.

This work is a contribution to the LIAISE campaign, through the IDEWA project (PCI2020-112043).

How to cite: Barella-Ortiz, A., Quintana-Seguí, P., Dari, J., Brocca, L., Altés, V., Villar, J. M., Paolini, G., Escorihuela, M. J., Bonan, B., Calvet, J.-C., and Tzanos, D.: Improved SAFRAN forcing and ECOCLIMAP-SG datasets to simulate irrigation over the Ebro basin, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7834, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7834, 2022.

EGU22-8170 | Presentations | HS1.1.4

Review on land subsidence and socio-hydrology of northern Java, Indonesia 

Yus Budiyono, Dian Nuraini Melati, Puspa Khaerani, Diyah Krisna Yuliana, Ritha Riyandari, Bondan Fiqi Riyalda, and Freek Colombijn

Northern Java coasts of Indonesia is dominated by unconsolidated Holocene alluvial deposits. Anthropogenic stresses on the area has lead to land subsidence at various rate relate to the deposition systems. This paper review reports on land subsidence in the area using the formal phrase as well as terms related to the phenomenons appeared in coastal communities. We found the formal phrase appeared decades after coastal communities has considered the impact without knowing the physical phenomenon. In addition to that, research agencies have been focusing on monitoring while national government bodies focused on mitigation infrastructures. To fill in the gap, we suggest flood risk study will help the efforts to bridge both activities. This will help local and national government to prioritize activities in to overcome negative impact of land subsidence.

How to cite: Budiyono, Y., Melati, D. N., Khaerani, P., Yuliana, D. K., Riyandari, R., Riyalda, B. F., and Colombijn, F.: Review on land subsidence and socio-hydrology of northern Java, Indonesia, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8170, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8170, 2022.

EGU22-8511 | Presentations | HS1.1.4

Spatial distribution of surface water losses from urban areas across the contiguous United States 

Irene Palazzoli, Alberto Montanari, and Serena Ceola

Human pressure on surface water is increasing globally, especially on river systems. Future scenarios of urban population growth anticipate an overexploitation of surface water resources in the proximity of cities, which in turn will produce environmental, social, and economic impacts whose effects are going to influence increasingly larger areas. Therefore, it is crucial to gain a better understanding of the dynamics of interaction between human settlements and surface water, to find a balance between urban planning and water management policies that ensure water conservation and ecosystem protection. In this study we assess the driving role of urban areas in the spatial distribution of surface water losses across the contiguous United States (CONUS). In particular, we analyze the frequency of occurrence of surface water loss as a function of distance from urban areas using remote sensing data and we define a distance decay model that reproduces the observed spatial behavior. We find that the frequency of surface water loss declines as the distance from urban areas increases and we successfully model this spatial trend with an exponential probability distribution function. Moreover, we observe distinct decay patterns of the frequency of occurrence of surface water loss associated to the main climatic conditions of the CONUS, as surface water losses are more concentrated around urban areas in regions with a temperate and continental climate, while they result to be more widespread over greater distances in regions with an arid climate.

How to cite: Palazzoli, I., Montanari, A., and Ceola, S.: Spatial distribution of surface water losses from urban areas across the contiguous United States, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8511, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8511, 2022.

EGU22-9025 | Presentations | HS1.1.4

Multi-scale Scenarios for Local Climate Change Policies 

Mohammadreza Alizadeh and Jan Adamowski

At the local and sub-regional levels, human-water systems are bound by regional constraints that are influenced by connected internal politics associated with particular socioeconomic conditions. This implies that any multi-scale scenario framework must account for the many scales at which socioeconomic change will manifest. In this study, we developed a series of localized shared socioeconomic pathways (SSPs) by downscaling global SSPs as boundary conditions integrated with climate change pathways (RCPs) to construct a narrative scenario development process that incorporates both a multi-scale (top-down) and a bottom-up (co-production) approach. To obtain insight into human-water systems in developing countries, the study focused on the extensive irrigated portions of Pakistan's central-northeastern Rechna Doab watershed, which served as a case study for a typical multi-stakeholder system. Our developed localized narrative SSPs served as the basis for evaluating the probable consequences of socioeconomic and climatic change at the local level across a variety of socioeconomic possibilities. These estimates provide information on the likely future consequences of socioeconomic and climatic change and the performance of various adaptation measures. Additionally, the localized narratives are designed as a starting point for downscaling projections of critical processes and variables such as population increase and economic development. By analyzing the localized SSPs narratives using a regional integrated assessment model, significant future changes in these critical socioeconomic and environmental variables are predicted, assisting decision-makers in exploring and developing appropriate policy interventions and adaptation strategies. These estimates are used to model and quantify the local consequences of the human-water system on social and environmental issues (e.g., farm income, crop yields, water demands, and groundwater resource depletion). Our findings show that even with modest socioeconomic advances (e.g., technology, policies, institutions, and environmental consciousness), water security is likely to decline, and environmental degradation (e.g., groundwater depletion) will exacerbate. The suggested framework makes it easier to establish future adaptation plans that take regional and local planning and socioeconomic factors into account.

How to cite: Alizadeh, M. and Adamowski, J.: Multi-scale Scenarios for Local Climate Change Policies, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9025, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9025, 2022.

EGU22-9413 | Presentations | HS1.1.4

Grasping water availability at regional scale: development of exploratory methods 

Esther Brakkee, Marjolein van Huijgevoort, and Sija Stofberg

Climate change and socio-economic development are putting water resources under increasing pressure, even in what are so far seen as ‘water-rich’ countries. At a regional scale, the water resources present in groundwater, soil water and surface water are often used for various functions, including nature, agriculture and drinking water production. Local changes in water management or land cover can potentially affect all these functions. Therefore, ensuring a sustainable water availability requires an integrated understanding of the interactions in the water system. However, regional water systems, that often include a wide range of water pathways and functions, can be complex to grasp and time-intensive to study in detail. There is therefore a need for exploratory methods that provide a fast and comprehensive overview of the interactions in regional water systems. This provides a valuable first step to direct research and management efforts.  

In this study, we have developed an exploratory water system analysis method using a case study in the south of the Netherlands. The case study area supports groundwater-dependent nature areas, agriculture, drinking water production and urban land use, which may face increasing pressure in the future. Several adaptation measures have been proposed, including restoration of natural brook systems, enhancing groundwater recharge and changing extraction regimes. As a first step, we developed quantitative visual overviews of the water system under both average and dry conditions, using a combination of a groundwater model and field data. Next, we used simplified analytical functions to assess the potential effects of several proposed measures on water stores and fluxes in the water system. Together, these analyses provide an overview of the main system drivers and potential threats to water availability. In addition, they help to identify which potential solutions are promising for further exploration. The results can be used to guide further research and cooperation in the area towards a sustainable water system. In addition, the methods can be easily applied to other regions and scales.

How to cite: Brakkee, E., van Huijgevoort, M., and Stofberg, S.: Grasping water availability at regional scale: development of exploratory methods, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9413, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9413, 2022.

EGU22-9459 | Presentations | HS1.1.4

Conceptualizing feedbacks between climate services and adaptation actions across various European contexts. 

Riccardo Biella, Giuliano Di Baldassarre, Luigia Brandimarte, and Maurizio Mazzoleni

The success of climate adaptation actions relies on the availability and quality of information, especially in climate-sensitive sectors such as tourism, agriculture, and river management. Over the years, researchers have highlighted how climate services providing such key information should focus on end-user needs to bridge the usefulness-usability gap. Thus, overcoming this dichotomy will enable the effective use of climate services in adaptation initiatives, especially at the local scale. In this study, we present the basis for a conceptual framework identifying the balancing and reinforcing feedbacks in a coupled human-climate system, with a focus on hydrological risks, i.e. floods and droughts. The analysis is based on system dynamics conceptualization and builds upon data from various living labs (i.e. case studies) across Europe. The framework is presented as a causal-loop diagram and emerging behaviors of the system are described using system archetypes. The proposed framework highlights the importance of understanding feedbacks between climate information and adaptation options when designing user-centered climate services. Moreover, it sheds a light on usefulness of system dynamics as a tool for informing the planning of effective adaptation actions while building resilience.

 

How to cite: Biella, R., Di Baldassarre, G., Brandimarte, L., and Mazzoleni, M.: Conceptualizing feedbacks between climate services and adaptation actions across various European contexts., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9459, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9459, 2022.

EGU22-11981 | Presentations | HS1.1.4

A survey-based evaluation of farmers’ drought risk reduction strategies in the Po Valley (Northern Italy) 

Brunella Bonaccorso, Iolanda Borzì, Beatrice Monteleone, and Mario Martina

Drought is the natural hazard producing the most significant impacts on the agricultural sector. In the Mediterranean area, drought-related losses were estimated at approximately 9€ billion/year and this value is going to increase in future climate change scenarios. In this context, implementing proper risk reduction strategies and effective water resources management is fundamental in coping with drought-related water crises.

In this study, a survey has been proposed to farmers of the Po Valley (Northern Italy), in order to identify past drought and heatwaves events that hit their cultivations and to know the strategies implemented to cope with those events.

Farmers were asked to answer questions about the use of irrigation during past droughts and heatwaves, the preferred irrigation strategies during water crises (i.e., irrigate at night, irrigate a reduced area to full irrigation, crop prioritization, etc), the decisional criteria they adopted to establish when to start irrigation during a drought and the availability of insurance coverage.

Past droughts have been identified using the Standardized Precipitation and Evaponstrspiration Index (SPEI) and compared with the ones identified through the survey, highlighting two main drought events: the first one occurred in June 2003 and the other one in August 2019. This last event has been analysed in detail. Survey’s results reveal that, even if the 2003 event was more severe than that one in 2019, since all the farmers decided to irrigate their cultures during the 2003 drought, yield reduction was less than in 2019, when half of the farmers decided to not irrigate their crops during the drought event. In particular, the mean yield reduction for farmers who irrigated their crops during drought events was 35% less than for those who decided to not irrigate.

It was also found that droughts occurring in different plant growth stages have caused very different economic damages in terms of yield reduction, the amount of water resources allocated, and thus the irrigation expenses.

Regarding insurance coverage and the corresponding farmers’ grade of satisfaction, the survey’s responses revealed that farmers who applied irrigation didn’t acquire insurance coverages, and farmers who haven’t used irrigation trusted more on insurance.

How to cite: Bonaccorso, B., Borzì, I., Monteleone, B., and Martina, M.: A survey-based evaluation of farmers’ drought risk reduction strategies in the Po Valley (Northern Italy), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11981, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11981, 2022.

EGU22-12216 | Presentations | HS1.1.4

Contribution of local examples of co-evolution of society and hydrology to address current and future challenges of sustainability in the context of the Panta Rhei Book 

María José Polo, Cyndi Vail, Gopal Penny, Thusdara Gunda, and Alberto Montanari

Impacts and trade-offs between society and hydrological processes cover a wide range of issues, for which climate, geography, environment, cultural context, economy, and society altogether result in largely different coevolution schemes and current scenarios. This work presents a selection of case studies addressing the Panta Rhei Decade’s goals and discussions, that cover representative examples to assess future challenges of sociohydrology to be included in the Panta Rhei Book results. As a follow-up of the work progress presented in previous conferences, we focus now on each storyline to highlight their contribution to the Panta Rhei decade’s work and impact on future reflections, and pathways.

Specifically, some similarities and major divergences are assessed between local cases across geography and topics in a preliminary attempt to identify the key conclusions of this paradigm and the most relevant sectors dealing with socio-hydrological processes now, and in the future. These results pave the line towards the final lessons learnt from this process, to be presented in the XXIst Scientific Assembly of the IAHS.

How to cite: Polo, M. J., Vail, C., Penny, G., Gunda, T., and Montanari, A.: Contribution of local examples of co-evolution of society and hydrology to address current and future challenges of sustainability in the context of the Panta Rhei Book, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12216, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12216, 2022.

EGU22-12234 | Presentations | HS1.1.4

Impact of linear infrastructure on floodplains on inundation characteristics 

Inna Krylenko, Vitaly Belikov, Pavel Golovlyov, Vitaly Surkov, Elena Zakharova, and Alexander Zavadskii

Linear infrastructure such as roads, bridge crossings, protective dams cause significant changes of the floodplains topography and flow characteristics. To estimate the anthropogenic impact on the changing of inundation characteristics we applied two-dimensional hydrodynamic modeling approach. The study is focused on wide populated floodplains areas of the Ob River near Surgut city (Western Siberia, Russia), Lena River near Yakutsk city (Eastern Siberia), Amur/Zeya Rivers near Blagoveshchensk (Far East). STREAM_2D software (authors V. Belikov et al.), which is based on the numerical solution of two-dimensional Saint-Venant equations on a hybrid curvilinear quadrangular and rectangular mesh, and includes sediment transport and ice modules, was used for the simulations. Detailed topography and bathymetry data, obtained as results of field surveys, were used for model setup. All linear infrastructure in river channels and floodplains, including dams, cities embankments, existing and under construction bridges, road embankments were taken into account in the model grid and relief. Second version of the model relief was constructed excluding infrastructure. Calibration and verification of the model were performed for modern conditions using data of field surveys and data of gauging stations. Additional verification of simulated flooded areas and the water level in ungauged reaches was done using high resolution satellite optical images and satellite altimetry measurements. For impact analysys two modeling scenarios were considered for each key area: modern conditions of flow with all infrastructure and natural conditions without any constructions. More pronounced effect of the infrastructure on the flooding zones was identified for the floodplains of Amur/Zeya Rivers near Blagoveshchensk and Heihe cities: the area of flooding in modern conditions decreased by 10%, which led to an increase in the average depth of flooding by 10%, and the average flow velocity in the modeling area by 2-5%. Significant backwater effects due to linear infrastructure on the floodplains were identified for the Ob River, water levels upstream the existing bridge transect can rise more than 0.5m and observed at a distance of more than 30 km.

The numerical experiments were designed within the framework of the Governmental Order to Water Problems Institute, Russian Academy of Sciences, subject no FMWZ-2022-0001. The Ob River floodplain model was adopted with the financial support of RSF № 22-27-00633.

How to cite: Krylenko, I., Belikov, V., Golovlyov, P., Surkov, V., Zakharova, E., and Zavadskii, A.: Impact of linear infrastructure on floodplains on inundation characteristics, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12234, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12234, 2022.

EGU22-12594 | Presentations | HS1.1.4 | Highlight

Global impacts of dams and reservoirs on hydrological droughts 

Elise Jonsson, Sara Lindersson, and Giuliano Di Baldassarre
Dams and reservoirs can have a wide range of impacts on local hydrology, for instance affecting soil moisture, water table, vegetation and modifying the frequency, severity and intensity of floods and droughts. In this work, we are quantifying trends in human-modified droughts (frequency, severity and intensity) in the wake of reservoir formation. Drought trends are compared before and after reservoir formation, using paired catchments for control.
 
We perform the analysis on a global level for large reservoirs, using satellite data of surface water changes and a dataset of georeferenced dams to determine the reservoir ages. We also include the impact of smaller reservoirs for a number of chosen case studies around the globe. The overarching goal of this research is to improve our understanding of the human impact on hydrological droughts across the world. Based on our results, we also discuss the potential impact of future dam constructions, particularly in developing countries where such developments are ramping up.

How to cite: Jonsson, E., Lindersson, S., and Di Baldassarre, G.: Global impacts of dams and reservoirs on hydrological droughts, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12594, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12594, 2022.

EGU22-12615 | Presentations | HS1.1.4

Modelling the impacts of climate and socio-economic changes on pesticide use and fate 

Poornima Nagesh, Rudrani Gajraj, Josef Eitzinger, and Stefan C. Dekker

Agricultural use of pesticides helps control a range of pests and diseases that threaten crops, thereby avoiding yield losses and improving the quality of the food produced. However, pesticides applied on agricultural fields dissipate with time. The export of pesticides and their transformation products after application from the agricultural fields threatens the water quality of aquatic systems in many world regions.

Climate change is further expected to intensify pest pressures and potential pesticide use by affecting agriculture in many ways. Changing climatic conditions can increase pesticide leaching due to increased and frequent rainfall, higher degradation rates, or higher temperatures or soil moisture contents. The indirect effects are changes in land use, the timing of crop cultivation, selection of other crop types, new pests and changed pest behaviour, etc. Additionally, several socio-economic factors influence pesticide use at the farm and national level, including regulation and legislation, economy, technology and crop characteristics. In order to better understand the pesticide risk to surface waters in the future, we aim to understand the influence of both climate and socio-economic change on pesticide use and fate.

Various catchment-scale models are available to assess pesticides and their impacts on water bodies. However, most modelling approaches solely concentrate on the total amount or concentration of pesticide exported from a catchment and do not necessarily analyse the future change of pesticide and transformation products. We propose an integrated modelling framework to answer the research questions: What are the current significant climate and socio-economic drivers influencing pesticide use and emissions? How can climate change influence pesticide and transformation products emission trends? How will socio-economic change influence pesticide emissions?

The integrated modelling framework helps to include adapting agricultural production to climatic (e.g., temperature, precipitation) and socio-economic drivers (e.g., land use, crop type, pesticide regulation) and quantifying pesticide emissions with the Zin-AgriTRA pesticide fate model. The ZIN-AgriTra is a catchment scale reactive transport model which can simulate agrochemical and transformation products exported from agricultural catchments. We use the Eur-Agri-SSP scenarios that extend and enrich the basic Shared Socio-economic Pathways with a regional and sectoral component on agriculture to explain the socio-economic change and climate projections for Representative concentration pathways to adopt climate change scenarios.

The integrated modelling framework links the future scenario results from independent, standalone models that present crop rotation, land use, pesticide regulation and climate to the pesticide fate model (Zin-AgriTRA). The framework is applied to an agricultural catchment in Burgenland, Austria, to quantify pesticide pollution under future climate and socio-economic change up to 2050.

 

How to cite: Nagesh, P., Gajraj, R., Eitzinger, J., and C. Dekker, S.: Modelling the impacts of climate and socio-economic changes on pesticide use and fate, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12615, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12615, 2022.

EGU22-2135 | Presentations | ITS3.2/HS1.1.8

Assessing the groundwater sustainability of Bengaluru megacity, India, through the lens of socio-hydrogeology 

Tejas Kulkarni, Matthias Gassmann, Chandrakanth Kulkarni, Vijayalaxmi Khed, and Andreas Buerkert

Water extraction in Bengaluru, India's fastest expanding metropolis, entirely depends on its ~500000 wells in a crystalline rock aquifer, of which an unknown number has been abandoned and the level of others has sunk to depths of 450 meters below surface. Recent research has highlighted the spatial heterogeneity and questioned the reliability of water level data in these settings. To fill existing knowledge gaps on the likely over-extraction of groundwater as a vital resource we used a socio-hydrogeological approach of front-lining local hydrogeologists to collect primary data on the spatio-temporal evolution of well depths across the city. Our data show that over the past 60 years borewell depth has increased significantly while water yields have remained unchanged, indicating that digging deeper wells is unsustainable. Using camera inspections of 56 wells in a 2.1km2 catchment of industrial land use in Electronic City of Bengaluru, we noted that water levels in the wells are largely determined by rock fractures, not by well depth. Our data show that increased borewell depths is a good signal of declining water levels in Bengaluru’s aquifers. Analysis of δ18O and δ2H signatures of groundwater samples across all depths followed the local meteoric water line indicating recent recharge, implying that drilling deeper only increased the borehole volume and did not tap into newer water sources.

How to cite: Kulkarni, T., Gassmann, M., Kulkarni, C., Khed, V., and Buerkert, A.: Assessing the groundwater sustainability of Bengaluru megacity, India, through the lens of socio-hydrogeology, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2135, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2135, 2022.

EGU22-3412 | Presentations | ITS3.2/HS1.1.8

Socio-hydrogeological approach to identify contaminant fluxes towards groundwater-dependent hydrosystems, case of the Biguglia lagoon (Corsica, France) 

Eléa Crayol, Frédéric Huneau, Emilie Garel, Viviana Re, Alexandra Mattei, Sébastien Santoni, and Vanina Pasqualini

Coastal Mediterranean lagoons are very often groundwater-dependent hydrosystems, however their hydrogeological functioning is poorly known, damaging their management. Socio-hydrogeology allows, in an inter-and transdisciplinary way to clarify the relationships linking human activities and groundwater status. Those interactions within the watershed, combined with consumption patterns of the population, and sanitation defects can generate processes leading to pollutant fluxes with impacts on surface water, groundwater and lagoon water quality. This approach integrates both social and economic components into hydrogeological investigations.

The Biguglia lagoon watershed (Northern Corsica, France) has been chosen as a pilot site. Indeed, significant nitrate content, emerging compounds, and pesticides have already been observed in the lagoon waters, but their origin still needs to be specified, both in terms of source and dispersion modalities.

The aim of this study is to (1) assess the link between groundwater quality and the anthropogenic pressures on the watershed, (2) understand water users’ and the stakeholders ‘perception and knowledge of the watershed and the local territory, (3) identify the origin of pollutions detected in the lagoon’s water.

In this purpose, a field sampling was led in spring 2021, combining several tools useful for the knowledge improvement of the hydrogeological functioning and the tracing of anthropic pollutant fluxes. Investigations with structured interviews was administered to 32 water users and 16 local stakeholders involved in the monitoring assessment, to determine the land use evolution since 1950’s to present and aiming at identifying past and present uses of the water resource over the watershed. At the same time, a multi-tracer water sampling, combining physico-chemical parameters, major ions and trace elements as well as, stable isotopes of the water molecule was carried out on 53 points (lagoon, rivers, canals waters, groundwater), of which 21 samples were also analysed for a set of pesticides (screening of 240 molecules).

Pesticide’s analysis show that the study site is affected by agricultural pollution. Indeed, neonicotinoid insecticides, extensively used worldwide, have been found on the sampling points with significant concentrations. Those pesticides are mainly used in fruit, vegetable and cereal crops. The field survey, the questionnaire and the sampling campaign have allowed to identify and confirm the presence of these cultures on the study site. In the same way, benzotriazoles, perfluorinated acids (PFAs) and DEET (insect repellent) have also been detected. They are related to the consumption habits of the population on the watershed.

Geochemical analysis correlated with the social analysis and the land use analysis permitted to better constraint pollution sources, evidencing two main sources: sanitation defect and agriculture activity.

The socio-hydrogeological approach is essential to improve the knowledge of the Biguglia lagoon hydrosystem. The purpose of this work is to offer a new functional diagram of the area, including the space-time continuum of anthropogenic impacts within the watershed. This new knowledge will help local stakeholders towards the recovery of a good geochemical and ecological status for the lagoon brackish water body of Biguglia.

How to cite: Crayol, E., Huneau, F., Garel, E., Re, V., Mattei, A., Santoni, S., and Pasqualini, V.: Socio-hydrogeological approach to identify contaminant fluxes towards groundwater-dependent hydrosystems, case of the Biguglia lagoon (Corsica, France), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3412, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3412, 2022.

Developing green infrastructures (GIs) for rainwater harvesting has prevailed in many arid regions, which requires a new water management framework. This paper focuses on a water policy - water trading scheme – design and analysis for integrated green infrastructures and water resource management in a watershed that consists of multiple urban areas. A multiagent model bringing together urban water management and GIs planning models for multiple water managers with hydrological models is proposed to show 1) what the optimized water trading scheme is, 2) how the scheme would affect watershed socio-hydrologic environments, and 3) what the role of GIs in the scheme is. In the model, the water trading scheme design depends not only on the hydrologic dynamics of watershed caused by GIs and but on the social interactions between watershed and multiple urban managers. The proposed model is applied to the Colorado River Lower Basin, which is one of the USA's aridest regions and is planning water trading. Results indicated that a water-trading scheme effectively allocates limited water resources with a minimized system cost in the study area. Results also show that developing GIs to use rainwater resources might further reduce the cost induced by the water trading scheme. However, it might also exacerbate water resource allocation inequity among water users. These findings can help decision-makers design the associated water policy to support sustainable watershed development in arid regions.

How to cite: Zhang, M. and Chui, T. F. M.: Modeling water trading to support integrated green infrastructure and water resources management in an arid watershed, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3487, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3487, 2022.

EGU22-4065 | Presentations | ITS3.2/HS1.1.8

Combining groundwater numerical modelling and social sciences to assess water access in developing countries rural environments 

Daniela Cid Escobar, Albert Folch, Nuria Ferrer, and Xavier Sanchez-Vila

Shallow groundwater is usually more accessible than surface water in remote and rural areas due to the infrastructure cost to collect and allocate surface water on dispersed communities. However, the absence of a proper hydrogeological characterization of the aquifer system added to the lack of groundwater infrastructure and maintenance, technical capacity, and governance has not allowed the development of sustainable use of local groundwater resources in different territories worldwide.

We propose an interdisciplinary approach to determine the risk of a household experiencing water shortage due to depletion of the aquifer, degradation of the water quality, not access to the water point, or sustainable functionality. Three main parameters were defined: Closeness (determined by geographical parameters and easily computed using GIS), Availability (determined by hydrogeological parameters that can be assessed from a groundwater model), and Sustainability (differentiating between software functionality and hardware functionality (Bonsor, MacDonald, Casey, Carter, & Wilson, 2018), the former analyzed through Multiple Factor Analysis. Each of these three factors range between 0 and 1, and their product provides an index that can be used to map the risk of individual households.

An application case in Kwale County, southeast coast of Kenya, is presented, where community handpumps are the main water supply system. The novelty of the index relies on the combination of groundwater model outputs with household data, which allows the generation of time-dependent risk indexes that can be calculated for several scenarios depending on the data available. In this case, we present three scenarios, one involving the potential malfunctioning of a percentage of the existing handpumps, and two other ones dealing with extreme climate scenarios, all of them designed to test the resilience and applicability of the proposed index and their applicability for decision making.

Acknowledgements: This work was funded by the Centre of Cooperation for Development of the Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya. We want to thank UPGRO and Gro For Good projects for their support and collaboration in acquiring available data.

References: Bonsor, H., MacDonald, A., Casey, V., Carter, R., & Wilson, P. (2018). The need for a standard approach to assessing the functionality of rural community water supplies. Hydrogeology Journal, 26(2), 367–370. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10040-017-1711-0

How to cite: Cid Escobar, D., Folch, A., Ferrer, N., and Sanchez-Vila, X.: Combining groundwater numerical modelling and social sciences to assess water access in developing countries rural environments, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4065, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4065, 2022.

EGU22-4383 | Presentations | ITS3.2/HS1.1.8

Insights from a transdisciplinary approach for water quality monitoring and multi-stakeholder management in the island of Santa Cruz, Galápagos (Ecuador) 

Chiara Tringali, Jonathan Rizzi, Viviana Re, Caterina Tuci, Marta Mancin, Edison Mendieta, and Antonio Marcomini

The Galápagos Archipelago (Ecuador) is traditionally considered a living museum and showcase of evolution. The rich biodiversity and distinctive environment attract thousands of visitors every year. However, this tourist flow exerts continuous pressures on the natural environment, and on water resources in particular, to the detriment of the local population who is faced with the challenges of accessing safe and sustainable drinking resources.

For this reason, over the years numerous projects, especially in the context of international cooperation activities, have tried to assess the impact of anthropogenic activities on the water quality and quantity in the islands. Unfortunately, the lack of coordination among all these projects did not allow to carry out continuous monitoring and, above all, to obtain homogenous and consistent time series of the measured hydrogeochemical parameters.

For this reason, in the framework of a joint technical cooperation project (“Health protection and prevention of anthropic pollution risks” in the Island of Santa Cruz” financed by Veneto Region, Italy; CS2012A19) a comprehensive assessment on water quality data (physico-chemical parameters, major elements, trace elements and coliforms) collected since 1985 in the Santa Cruz Island was performed. Results revealed the need of optimizing monitoring efforts to fill knowledge gaps and to better target decision making processes. All data were therefore standardized, homogenized and collected in an open database, accessible to all water stakeholders involved in water control, management and protection in the island. 

The information gathering activity also revealed the lack of coordination between the stakeholders themselves and the presence overlapping interests towards water resources, which represent an obstacle for coordinated actions targeted to sustainable water resources management in such a fragile environment. 

Therefore, under the guidance of the Santa Cruz Municipality, a Water Committee was established to foster the coordinated action among the water stakeholders in the island. The latter range from national to local authorities (e.g. National Water Secretariat, Ministry of Agriculture, Ecuador Naval Oceanographic Institute, National Park Galapagos, Municipality), research institutes (Charles Darwin Foundation), bottled water companies and Santa Cruz Households. Within the committee, shared procedures for data collection, sample analysis, evaluation and data assessment by an open access geodatabase were agreed collectively and tested in the field. Joint monitoring in the island can optimize the efforts for water quality assessment and protection, and improve accountability and outreach towards civil society and water users. Such a coordinated action can also ensure that international cooperation activities carried out in the island will respond to the real needs of the local population, and results will contribute to the long-term protection of the scarce water resources in the island.

Overall, results of the project revealed the high potential of adopting transdisciplinary approaches in complex, multi-stakeholder, framework typical of small island states.

How to cite: Tringali, C., Rizzi, J., Re, V., Tuci, C., Mancin, M., Mendieta, E., and Marcomini, A.: Insights from a transdisciplinary approach for water quality monitoring and multi-stakeholder management in the island of Santa Cruz, Galápagos (Ecuador), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4383, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4383, 2022.

EGU22-7114 | Presentations | ITS3.2/HS1.1.8

Integration of hydrogeology and social sciences in practice, two IWRM case studies with challenges and opportunities from semi-arid Africa 

Anne Van der Heijden, Maarten J. Waterloo, Anouk I. Gevaert, and Daniela Benedicto van Dalen

Groundwater resources in African drylands are important sources of freshwater but are under pressure due to population growth and climate change. It is therefore increasingly important that groundwater resources are managed in a sustainable way. Development of IWRM plans are ongoing in (semi-)arid African countries with support from national governments, NGOs and consultancies. This presentation aims to highlight two case studies in which bio-geophysical and socio-economic data were combined to assist in the Integrated Water Resources Management (IWRM) process: 1) catchment-scale Water Infrastructure Assessment (WIA) in Sudan and 2) assessment of pathways towards sustainable groundwater use in African drylands. Per case study lessons learned and recommended approaches are provided.

In IWRM intervention planning for semi-arid regions a local increase in available water resources is sought after, which can be found in the better use of excess runoff. A balance between water demand and water resources on community level is key and a prerequisite for implementing durable and inclusive interventions that last. The IWRM process starts with a strong knowledge base. In practice, however, the development of a good knowledge base is not simple. Challenges arise in collecting, processing, and mapping results. With hydrogeology, a 3D situation is translated to 2D maps. Socio-economic data are often stored based on administrative boundaries and need corrections for hydrological source-area delineation and seasonal and interannual variations. Population density and water demand change over seasons, following crop cycles and livestock migration patterns. Looking at local water availability, rainfall and surface water flows are becoming more variable and less reliable. Therefore, assessment of the rainfall regime and corresponding behaviour and movements of people and livestock is key. For WIAs, yields and usage are often averaged, thus disregarding seasonal changes, even though shallow wells and reservoirs regularly become depleted outside the rainy season. The Sudan case study presents an improved approach for a WIA, that is adaptable and can be applied in semi-arid environments in Africa and elsewhere, in which seasonality and socio-economic dynamics were taken into account.

Both hydrogeologic and socio-economic conditions tend to be quite location-specific. This makes developing a simple blueprint for integrated groundwater management impossible. However, by translating local conditions into regional advice, strategic pathways were developed for the drylands of Africa[1] to support IWRM. The zonal hydrogeological and socio-economic setting determined the main groundwater issues and the potential sustainability strategies. The sustainability pathways describe potential sets of strategies that can be effective in moving towards sustainable groundwater resources development and use. While these pathways provide insight into regional differences within the African drylands, these cannot be used at local scales. Tailor-made approaches are necessary. In these assessments, remote sensing provides opportunities. Gridded datasets of population density are of great value in water demand assessments on a larger scale. Participatory stakeholder processes also provide opportunities, including group interviews for development of community calendars providing useful information on the occurrence and frequency of natural hazards and water demand.

[1] Gevaert et al. 2020, Towards sustainable groundwater use in the African drylands

 

 

How to cite: Van der Heijden, A., Waterloo, M. J., Gevaert, A. I., and Benedicto van Dalen, D.: Integration of hydrogeology and social sciences in practice, two IWRM case studies with challenges and opportunities from semi-arid Africa, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7114, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7114, 2022.

EGU22-10542 | Presentations | ITS3.2/HS1.1.8

From Coarse Resolution to Realistic Resolution: GRACE as a Science Communication and Policymaking Tool for Sustainable Groundwater Management 

Li Xu, James S. Famiglietti, David Ferris, Xander Huggins, Chinchu Mohan, Sara Sadri, Palash Sanyal, and Jefferson S. Wong

Managing groundwater resources is challenging because they are difficult to monitor. The application of remote sensing methods has improved our capacity to monitor variability in groundwater storage, as is the case for the Gravity Recovery and Climate Experiment (GRACE) and the GRACE Follow-On (GRACE-FO) missions. While GRACE-based groundwater studies to date have covered many places across the globe, perspectives that link scientific studies to policymaking and practices are still limited. Challenges to applying GRACE data into practice result from their coarse resolution, which limits their utility at the smaller scales at which water management decisions are made. Another reason is that the data and related studies can be difficult to use and understand by policymakers and end-users. However, these challenges offer the GRACE scientific community opportunities to communicate with stakeholders, policymakers, and the public in raising awareness around groundwater sustainability issues. This paper addresses three questions: which GRACE data and GRACE-derived products can be useful for groundwater practices and management; how GRACE-derived groundwater messages can be better communicated with practitioners; and how to better operationalize GRACE-derived products for groundwater practice and management. This paper also aims to provide an agenda for the continued use of GRACE and GRACE-FO for the purpose of sustainable groundwater management. To gain insight into these questions, a policy Delphi survey was conducted to collect opinions of both the scientific and non-scientific communities. We made use of target search and snowballing techniques to identify suitable participants who are experienced groundwater researchers or practitioners, and who are familiar with GRACE. A total of 25 participants from around the world were surveyed (14 scientific and 11 non-scientific), and they provided thoughtful responses. We found that both communities acknowledged the potential of GRACE data and GRACE-derived products for groundwater management, and would be willing to collaborate to develop projects for practical applications. Better communication between researchers and practitioners was recommended as a key for the application of GRACE-derived products into practice. Practitioners noted their high demand for reliable data for their management responsibilities, but are more favorable towards locally observed data. The reliability of GRACE at small scales was an issue, even though some robust downscaling methods have been demonstrated down to local scales. The survey showed a desire for more comparison of GRACE-derived products to local measurements to determine whether GRACE products, e.g. downscaled data, can be useful for informing local decisions. Based on the survey, we proposed an agenda that helps to improve the usefulness of GRACE-derived products for practices. This agenda includes scientific recommendations that help to resolve the resolution and technical barriers for local applications, and professional perspectives that bridge the connection between science and policy, and facilitate communication for groundwater management.

How to cite: Xu, L., Famiglietti, J. S., Ferris, D., Huggins, X., Mohan, C., Sadri, S., Sanyal, P., and Wong, J. S.: From Coarse Resolution to Realistic Resolution: GRACE as a Science Communication and Policymaking Tool for Sustainable Groundwater Management, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10542, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10542, 2022.

EGU22-11819 | Presentations | ITS3.2/HS1.1.8

Adaptation to floods and droughts in (semi) arid transboundary basins: insights, barriers and opportunities drawn from socio-hydrogeological research in the Limpopo river basin, Southern Africa 

Jean-Christophe Comte, Luis Artur, Zareen Bharucha, Farisse Chirindja, Rosie Day, Joyce Dube, Fulvio Franchi, Josie Geris, Stephen Hussey, Eugene Makaya, Alessia Matano, Syed Mustafa, Edward Nesamvuni, Oluwaseun Olabode, Melanie Rohse, Simon Taylor, Sithabile Tirivarombo, and Anne Van Loon

The Limpopo river basin (LRB) is water-stressed and highly susceptible to floods and droughts. The impacts of floods and droughts on water availability and quality is increasing as a result of their increase in magnitude and frequency. The LRB encompasses a large diversity of physical and socio-economical characteristics spread across four Southern Africa countries (Botswana, Mozambique, South Africa and Zimbabwe). This dictates highly heterogeneous physical and human responses, coping mechanisms, and policy frameworks from local to transboundary scales.

Understanding the multidimensional connections that exist between and within flood and drought events and cycles, between various regions across the basin, between physical and social impacts, and between users and decision-makers, is critical to sustainable water resources management and long-term resilience to hydrological extremes.

The Connect4 Water Resilience project has brought together an international multidisciplinary team of hydrologists and social scientists from academia, policy, and practice to investigate the drivers and impacts of floods and droughts, and to promote solutions towards adaptation. In our research we deployed hydrological and geological investigations alongside community and governance interviews and workshops across the LRB to jointly feed in the application of a large-scale transboundary hydrological model of the LRB. Model assessment and future management scenario definition and analysis were implemented collaboratively with stakeholders across the basin, through iterative workshops at local, national, and transboundary scales.

Results so far revealed: (1) the high complementarity of physical (hydrological and sedimentological) and social (community narrative) data to reconstruct spatiotemporal dynamics and impacts of events, which has been crucial to model application in the basin affected by highly fragmented monitoring; (2) the observed increase in floods and droughts magnitude and frequency is not responsible for significant changes in groundwater recharge, suggesting that the general observed groundwater level decline is to be related to increasing abstraction, which in turn amplifies droughts; (3) flood severity and impacts are higher after droughts regardless of rainfall magnitude; (4) mitigation, through anticipatory action and preparation for floods and droughts at policy, user and community level is uneven and inadequately resourced, with generally some forms of preparation to droughts but little for floods; (5) the uptake of forecast and management recommendations from governments is patchy, while extension officers are playing a key role for communication and NGOs for training; (6) local stakeholder expertise and experience brought in during stakeholder workshops were critical to groundwater model conceptualisation, and management scenario definition and analysis; (7) preferred scenarios of management strategies, as collaboratively defined with stakeholders, were highly variable across the LRB countries and sub-regions, including preference for local water management (e.g. temporary flood water storage for subsequent droughts) in upstream upland regions vs large scale strategies (e.g. storage in dams) in downstream floodplain regions; however, hydrological model outputs showed that local/regional strategies have basin-scale (transboundary) impacts emphasizing the importance of transboundary cooperation and management of water resources and extreme events.

Research outcomes are being translated into tailored guidance for policy and practice including feeding in ongoing early warning system development and sustainable water resource management.

How to cite: Comte, J.-C., Artur, L., Bharucha, Z., Chirindja, F., Day, R., Dube, J., Franchi, F., Geris, J., Hussey, S., Makaya, E., Matano, A., Mustafa, S., Nesamvuni, E., Olabode, O., Rohse, M., Taylor, S., Tirivarombo, S., and Van Loon, A.: Adaptation to floods and droughts in (semi) arid transboundary basins: insights, barriers and opportunities drawn from socio-hydrogeological research in the Limpopo river basin, Southern Africa, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11819, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11819, 2022.

EGU22-12846 | Presentations | ITS3.2/HS1.1.8

Reflections on collaboration and capacity-building for sustainable groundwater quality monitoring in rural Malawi 

Fortune Gomo, Sarah Halliday, Wiktor Chichlowski, Susan Chichloska, Harlod Zaunda, and Alistair Geddes

Drinking water quality is a key component of water security to ensure clean and safe water supplies to achieve the Global SDG6. Yet frequently there are capacity constraints on the adequacy and sustained water quality monitoring programs in LDC contexts, especially in rural areas where resources are more limited and the resident population is more reliant on scattered independent groundwater supplies. In Malawi, knowledge of the importance of water quality has been developing over recent years, necessitating local capacity development for sufficient and sustained water quality monitoring.

International, transdisciplinary, and interdisciplinary research collaboration and capacity-building efforts in rural water quality monitoring can be a vehicle to improve technology development that supports operational monitoring and data reporting in resource-poor settings. However, in cognate fields, similar international partnership models have drawn some criticism of late, because of their alleged tendency to not translate collaboration agreements into demonstrable local capacity gains. We, therefore, link our consideration of these issues specific to our direct input to efforts to create a new water quality testing program in rural southern Malawi in southern Africa in a collaborative research project between the University of Dundee and Fisherman’s Rest, a local NGO in Malawi. Fisherman’s Rest works with rural communities in Malawi, specifically borehole monitoring under the Madzi Alipo program. However, their work lacked the water quality monitoring component, a key element to water security. Using our reflections, we find that the line of critique on international collaborations has some value in terms of thinking about how to advance ‘genuine’ collaboration and capacity-building in water quality monitoring programs as we look to expand our collaboration efforts with Fisherman’s Rest and other stakeholders in rural water quality monitoring in Malawi.

How to cite: Gomo, F., Halliday, S., Chichlowski, W., Chichloska, S., Zaunda, H., and Geddes, A.: Reflections on collaboration and capacity-building for sustainable groundwater quality monitoring in rural Malawi, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12846, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12846, 2022.

HS1.2 – Innovative sensors and monitoring in hydrology

EGU22-940 | Presentations | HS1.2.1

A simple low-cost Arduino based LoRaWAN automatic weather station 

Tom Müller, Bettina Schaefli, and Stuart N. Lane

With a rapid increase in the use of low-cost DIY Arduino solutions, many companies are providing low cost sensors for practically any environmental applications and new users can also benefit from a rich virtual community proposing diverse solutions and tutorials. Nowadays, these new hardware solutions, as well as more robust communication protocols, allow to design very simple almost plug-and-play automatic dataloggers.

In this talk we will discuss three simple datalogger solutions developed in the framework of a field campaign in a harsh proglacial environment in the Swiss Alps. The first solution consists of a simple autonomous datalogger (based on Seeeduino Stalker board) designed to record piezometric heads in wells, even during the winter cold season. The second station consists of two alternative main boards (SODAQ and CubeCell) that were used to develop a connected LoRaWAN automatic weather station to monitor air temperature and precipitation on the glacier. Connected to a base station LoRaWAN gateway (Dragino), this system successfully allowed for a remote monitoring of those parameters.

In a first step, we will quickly go through the main components of each system and detail the basic LoRaWAN architecture. We will then mostly focus on the practical deployment of these solutions in the field and discuss their potential and challenges. We will try to show a live demonstration of their functioning and will insist on the relative technical simplicity and low-cost of such solutions, which could be replicated for many other environmental applications. We will finally discuss the pros and cons of these solutions compared to professional senor companies.

How to cite: Müller, T., Schaefli, B., and Lane, S. N.: A simple low-cost Arduino based LoRaWAN automatic weather station, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-940, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-940, 2022.

The role of freshwater ecosystems in the global carbon budget has yet to be accurately quantified. Substantial uncertainties remain in estimation of greenhouse gas (GHG) fluxes to the atmosphere due to heterogeneity, temporal variability and small scale of many systems. Additionally, methods to measure dissolved gases involve expensive equipment and/or are time consuming, making fine scale resolution challenging. We here present a self-made low-cost (~ 250 €) sensor unit which can measure carbon dioxide (CO2) and methane (CH4) in the water phase, allowing inexpensive continuous in-situ logging of GHG concentrations with little manpower.

The electronic hardware of the sensor unit is integrated into a polypropylene tubing with two parts: The sensor body is completely waterproof and houses electrical hardware and battery. The sensor head houses the gas sensors and is separated from the water phase by a semipermeable PTFE membrane that is hydrophobic but permeable to gases, thereby allowing the gaseous phase in the sensor head to equilibrate with the water phase.

For CO2, we use a miniature non-dispersive infrared sensor; data from the factory-calibrated sensor can be read via I2C serial communication. For CH4, we use a semiconductor gas quality sensor from the Figaro sensor family. Originally developed for explosion warning systems, these sensors were shown to detect CH4 near ambient concentration. Incorporated into a voltage divider, sensor output voltage can be measured and translated into CH4 concentration. Electrical resistance of this sensor varies in presence of combustible gases but also with temperature and humidity. Additional sensors provide pressure, temperature and relative humidity; and mathematical models fitted to calibration data allow to adjust for reference output voltage at background concentration levels, thereby allowing measurement of CH4 concentration. As a microprocessor, we use an Arduino mini board in combination with a real-time clock, a voltage regulator and a micro SD-card module. The microprocessor is programmed using Arduino´s integrated development environment. Data is stored on the internal SD card and powered by two Li-Ion 18650 batteries connected in series. The sensor is able to measure continuously for 24 hours.

Our low-cost, yet accurate-enough sensor can help to address the major bottlenecks in better quantification of GHG fluxes: continuous measurements to capture natural temporal variability, as well as spatially replicated measurements to map carbon sources and sinks across heterogeneous ecosystems with little investment costs. 

How to cite: Dalvai Ragnoli, M.: RiverRunner: a low-cost sensor prototype for continuous dissolved GHG measurements, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1617, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1617, 2022.

EGU22-1657 | Presentations | HS1.2.1 | Highlight

Measuring the eigenfrequencies of candlestick stalagmites with a custom 3D-printed sensor modified from a Raspberry Shake 3D 

Aurélie Martin, Thomas Lecocq, Ari Lannoy, Yves Quinif, Thierry Camelbeeck, and Nathalie Fagel

The eigenfrequencies of speleothems are fundamental parameters in the study of their response to earthquakes. To study these, the seismic ambient noise is measured by three-component seismic sensors adapted to the geometry of the speleothems. This method is currently being studied in the Han-sur-Lesse cave (Ardenne, Belgium).

A previous study (Martin et al. 2020) was carried out with a SmartSolo IGU-16HR 3C sensor on an imposing 4.5 m tall stalagmite.  This approach demonstrated the feasibility and interest of studying the eigenfrequencies of stalagmites from ambient noise. However, this sensor was too heavy for use on thin and slender stalagmites. The challenge was to find and adapt a lighter sensor able to record very weak movements while being easily adjustable to the various shapes of the stalagmite and securely attachable on these to reduce the impact of the sensor on frequencies measurements and the risks for the fragile structure.

A solution was found by using a Raspberry Shake 3D Personal Seismograph (RS) that initially integrates three orthogonal velocity sensors (Sunfull PS-4.5B), the digitizer, and the Raspberry Pi computer into a single plexiglass box​. The RS has the advantage of being less heavy while being composed of three weak motion geophones. After a comparison study, this sensor gives similar results for eigenfrequency and polarization analyses. However, the use of this new sensor on thin and slender stalagmites requires the creation of suitable support. The RS was split and distributed around the stalagmite. The geophone wiring was modified and extended to separate the geophones from the acquisition system. A 3D-printed support was created to guarantee the orthogonality of the horizontal sensors while reducing the stresses by distributing the weight of the sensor around the stalagmite.

This new configuration allowed determining the eigenfrequencies of 16 thin and slender stalagmites in the Han-sur-Lesse cave (Ardenne, Belgium) and the polarization of the motions associated with these frequencies. Moreover, a two-week recording period allows to measure the daily and weekly variation of ambient noise and transient events like earthquakes, quarry blasts or flooding events in the cave.

Reference: Martin, A.; Lecocq, T.; Hinzen, K.-G.; Camelbeeck, T.; Quinif, Y.; Fagel, N. Characterizing Stalagmites’ Eigenfrequencies by Combining In Situ Vibration Measurements and Finite Element Modeling Based on 3D Scans. Geosciences 2020, 10, 418. https://doi.org/10.3390/geosciences10100418

How to cite: Martin, A., Lecocq, T., Lannoy, A., Quinif, Y., Camelbeeck, T., and Fagel, N.: Measuring the eigenfrequencies of candlestick stalagmites with a custom 3D-printed sensor modified from a Raspberry Shake 3D, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1657, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1657, 2022.

EGU22-2722 | Presentations | HS1.2.1

Using an open source approach to remotely collect reliable environmental data 

Mathis Björner, Michael Naumann, Frederik Furkert, Daniel Stepputtis, Andreas Hermann, Martin Gag, Sebastian Eilek, and Robert Wagner

Environmental monitoring programs carried out by expeditions or autonomous stations are expensive and only allow measurements for discrete times and locations. After data acquisition most of the data needs hand-operated validation and evaluation before being stored in databases.

For a higher local and temporal resolution on parameters of marine ecosystems, it is planned to extend monitoring programs by attaching a small-sized module, which combines a microcontroller with multiple sensors, to ships of opportunity or any other suitable platform. The modules design focuses on the usability, reliability and interoperability of the derived data by using metadata information and assessing in-situ which data is relevant to be measured and stored.

Using an ESP32, a popular microcontroller, to collect data from OEM sensors of different manufacturers enables a high flexibility in parameters and sensor types. The use of different OEM sensors also allows to experiment with unconventional hydrological sensors. The proposed open source module attempts to collect data as reliable as with conventional monitoring sensor systems.

This approach allows an event based data acquisition, e.g. by adjusting the sampling rate so that only as much data as necessary is measured. In order to provide precise spatio-temporal referencing, the system contains a real time clock and GPS positioning. Moreover, storing the raw data of the sensors alongside their calibration coefficients enables post-processing of the data. The ESP32 transmits the stored data to a server via WiFi or an external LTE module. From this point on, a machine-based validation, flagging of relevant data and basic visualization can assist the evaluation.

With such a module integrating multiple sensors and focusing on the interpretation and use of data starting at the measurement, reliable and pre-evaluated data from hard to access areas can be obtained and contribute to the assessment of dynamic and heterogeneous ecosystems.

How to cite: Björner, M., Naumann, M., Furkert, F., Stepputtis, D., Hermann, A., Gag, M., Eilek, S., and Wagner, R.: Using an open source approach to remotely collect reliable environmental data, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2722, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2722, 2022.

EGU22-3517 | Presentations | HS1.2.1

Portable low cost devices for in situ measurements of CO2 exchange and vegetation spectral indices: Design and first results. 

Reena Macagga, Danica Antonijevic, Rodrigo Monzon, Rinan Bayot, Matthias Lueck, Michael Asante, Leonce Geoffroy Sossa, Pearl Sanchez, Juergen Augustin, and Mathias Hoffmann

Measurements of greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions such as carbon dioxide (CO­­2) play an important role in finding solutions to mitigate the global climate crises. In case of direct treatment comparisons, dynamic manual closed chamber systems are often used to measure the CO2 exchange and determine the treatment corresponding net ecosystem C balance (NECB). These measurements are commonly accompanied by records of non-destructive spectral vegetation indices such as RVI and NDVI, which can be used to validate obtained CO2 flux dynamics, to improve the accuracy and precision of determined CO2 exchange during gap-filling, and for up-scaling purposes. However, commercially available systems for both measurements of CO2 exchange and spectral vegetation indices are usually cost-intensive, which resulted in a long-term focus in GHG research on the northern hemisphere and the fact that studies on agroecosystems in sub-Saharan Africa as well as Southeast Asia are still being underrepresented.

We present two portable, inexpensive, open source devices to measure in situ 1) CO2 fluxes using the manual closed chamber method; and 2) vegetation spectral indices, such as NDVI and RVI. The CO2 flux measurement device consists of a combination of multiple low-cost sensors, such as a NDIR-based CO­2 sensor (K30FR; 0-10,000 ppm, ± 30 ppm accuracy), a DHT-22 (humidity and temperature) and a BMP280 (air pressure). Sensors are connected to a bluetooth enabled, battery powered, compact microcontroller based logger unit for data visualization and storage.  The handheld, NDVI measurement device consist of a combination of two faced up and two faced down visible (AS7262) and IR (AS7263) sensors, as well as a CCS811 and BME280 for parallel measurements of relevant environmental parameters (e.g., ambient temperature and relative humidity). Sensor control, data visualization and storage is implemented using again a bluetooth enabled, battery powered, compact microcontroller based logger unit. Here, we present the design, and first results of both low-cost devices. Results were validated against results of customized CO2 and NDVI measurement systems using regular scientific sensors (LI-COR 850 and SKR 1840(ND) and data logger components (CR1000). 

Keywords: CO2 exchange measurements, closed chamber, NDVI, low-cost open source DIY device

How to cite: Macagga, R., Antonijevic, D., Monzon, R., Bayot, R., Lueck, M., Asante, M., Sossa, L. G., Sanchez, P., Augustin, J., and Hoffmann, M.: Portable low cost devices for in situ measurements of CO2 exchange and vegetation spectral indices: Design and first results., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3517, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3517, 2022.

EGU22-3719 | Presentations | HS1.2.1

Development of air quality boxes based on low-cost sensor technology 

Paul Gäbel, Christian Koller, and Elke Hertig

Analyses of the relationships between climate, air substances and health usually concentrate on urban environments due to increased urban temperatures, high levels of air pollution and the exposure of a large number of people compared to rural environments. Ongoing urbanization, demographic aging and climate change lead to an increased vulnerability with respect to climate-related extremes and air pollution. However, systematic analyses of the specific local-scale characteristics of health-relevant atmospheric conditions and compositions in urban environments are still scarce due to the lack of high-resolution monitoring networks. In recent years low-cost sensors became available, which potentially provide the opportunity to monitor atmospheric conditions with a high spatial resolution and which allow monitoring directly at exposed people.

We develop a measurement system for several air substances like ozone, nitrogen oxides, carbon monoxide and particulate matter as well as meteorological variables like temperature and relative humidity, based on low-cost sensors. This involves the assembly of compact, weatherproof boxes with 3D-printed parts. They contain a control unit based on Arduino hardware to gather the sensor data as well as self-designed printed circuit boards (PCBs). A Pycom microcontroller is used for low-power, high-temporal data transmissions by Long-Term Evolution Cat-M1 (LTE-M). These Atmospheric Exposure Low-cost Monitoring units (AELCM) include digital and analogue sensors for air substances and meteorological variables, LCD display, RTC module, uninterruptible power supply, active ventilation, a SD Module as a data black box in addition to an optional internally running FTP server and optional GPS module. A computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulation is used to evaluate the air flow inside the AELCM units. Sensors are selected based on own analyses as well as according to evaluation and performance in other projects. The measurement equipment is extensively tested using the high-quality measurement unit for meteorology and air substances (Atmospheric Exposure Monitoring System, AEMS) of our research group, located at the Augsburg University Hospital.

How to cite: Gäbel, P., Koller, C., and Hertig, E.: Development of air quality boxes based on low-cost sensor technology, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3719, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3719, 2022.

EGU22-3888 | Presentations | HS1.2.1 | Highlight

Using cotton pads to sample the stable water isotopes of throughfall inside tree canopies 

Michael Stockinger, Georg Ziesel, and Christine Stumpp

Stable water isotopes (δ18O, δ2H) are used as tracers in hydrology to study the components of the terrestrial water cycle. The stable water isotopes of precipitation are affected by the passage of rainfall through tree canopy, resulting in a change of the tracer signal. Several processes within the canopy are thought to be responsible for this, including evaporation, liquid-vapor equilibration, redistribution, and legacy effects. However, it is currently not clear which processes dominate under which conditions, and predictions of these changes are not yet possible. This is partly due to a lack of high resolution throughfall data, as previous studies usually sampled throughfall in evaporation-reducing bulk containers placed under canopy. Here we propose to hang commonly available cotton products in tree canopy, let them soak up rainfall water, and subsequently measure the stable water isotopes directly from the wet cotton products using the direct liquid-vapor equilibration method in the laboratory. First, four products (two types of tampons, two types of cotton pads) were evaluated in terms of the minimum amount of water drops necessary for a reliable measurement, their price, and ease of handling. Cotton pads had the overall best rating and were therefor hung in a coniferous tree placed in a rainfall simulator. With a fixed rainfall intensity, we tested how long the cotton pads can be left hanging before significant isotopic changes due to evaporation occurred. While cotton pads that were on the outer edge of the canopy showed significant deviations after only half an hour, cotton pads inside the canopy as well as close to the stem could be left hanging for one hour. As a comparison, throughfall was also collected using a bulk sampler under the canopy, and this sample showed no significant changes even after four hours. It can thus be assumed that due to the comparatively low amount of water in the cotton pads (even if soaking wet), evaporative changes of isotope values had a stronger impact on the remaining water compared to the bulk throughfall sampler. This study presents first laboratory results and further tests, in the laboratory or in the field, are called for.

How to cite: Stockinger, M., Ziesel, G., and Stumpp, C.: Using cotton pads to sample the stable water isotopes of throughfall inside tree canopies, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3888, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3888, 2022.

EGU22-5446 | Presentations | HS1.2.1 | Highlight

Global surface and groundwater levels - hand measurements with a mobile app. 

Dirk Diederen
Water levels are a key ingredient for water resources management.
Surface water levels are monitored to manage open channels and rivers.
Groundwater levels are crucial to bridge times of drought and keep everything and everyone alive.
Worldwide, signals of changes in (ground)water levels are picked up by the GRACE satellite.
The development of groundwater use has led to depleted levels in many regions around the world [https://www.mdpi.com/2072-4292/10/6/829].
Coarse global data sets, provided by satellite gravity measurements, should be complemented with a global data set of accurate hand measurements.

Recently, we have launched our new public mobile app for (ground)water level measurements.
This means that now everyone can measure (ground)water levels, using their mobile phone.
Take a photo of a staffgauge, the surface water level will be returned!
Play a sound into a well/pvc pipe, the groundwater level will be returned!
Public measurements on this platform could hopefully lead to a consistent, global data set of high quality (ground)water level time series.

The app is currently available in the google play store as Mobile Water Manager.
Also, the app can be found at https://portal.mobilewatermanagement.com/ (chrome/safari - add to home screen for PWA).

 

How to cite: Diederen, D.: Global surface and groundwater levels - hand measurements with a mobile app., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5446, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5446, 2022.

EGU22-5620 | Presentations | HS1.2.1

Low energy and cost soil moisture sensor technology 

Maria Marin, Faraj Elsakloul, John Sanchez, Juan M Arteaga Saenz, David Boyle, James H O’Keeffe, Ramesh Goel, Paul D Hallett, Paul D Mitcheson, Gareth J Norton, Eric Yeatman, Darrin J Young, Cody Zesiger, and Shad Roundy

Efficient water use is a must for sustainable agriculture, driving the need for affordable soil moisture sensors to guide irrigation timing. Sensors are limited by cost, maintenance and the need for wires for data capture and charging.  We are developing low-cost, long-life, wireless in-situ soil sensing networks, which can potentially enable a much higher sensor density for large farmland or intense research plot monitoring. This custom soil sensor is made from off-the-shelf electronics and consumes approximately 10x less energy per measurement, compared to commercially available sensors. Here we present our new sensor technology, while also investigating its repeatability and accuracy in controlled conditions and comparing it to that of commercially available soil moisture sensors. The final application of the custom soil moisture sensor is an underground in-situ sensing network, which will be enabled through wireless powering and telemetry systems implemented on autonomous vehicles, both ground and aerial.

How to cite: Marin, M., Elsakloul, F., Sanchez, J., Arteaga Saenz, J. M., Boyle, D., O’Keeffe, J. H., Goel, R., Hallett, P. D., Mitcheson, P. D., Norton, G. J., Yeatman, E., Young, D. J., Zesiger, C., and Roundy, S.: Low energy and cost soil moisture sensor technology, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5620, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5620, 2022.

EGU22-7886 | Presentations | HS1.2.1

Design of solar power systems for autonomous instruments deployed in the polar regions 

Michael R Prior-Jones, Elizabeth A Bagshaw, Thomas H Nylen, Joe Pettit, and Paul Carpenter

Solar panels and batteries are commonly used to power autonomous instrumentation in remote locations. The use of solar power in the polar regions needs a special approach to the system design because of the need to store sufficient energy to cover the period of total darkness in the winter. In this presentation we review the key principles of solar power system design for the polar regions and provide a spreadsheet model to aid the design process. We demonstrate the importance of assessing the power consumption of ancillary electronics (such as solar regulators and low-voltage disconnect units), as this can often be greater or equal to that of the instrument itself. Consequently, the choice of solar regulator (and other ancillary devices) can have a major impact on the size of the battery required for successful operation. Controlled laboratory measurements  of power consumption for fourteen commonly-used models of solar regulator demonstrated that there can be disparity between the manufacturer’s specifications and measured power consumption, so we assess the most suitable  systems for low temperature, long-term deployment at polar latitudes.

How to cite: Prior-Jones, M. R., Bagshaw, E. A., Nylen, T. H., Pettit, J., and Carpenter, P.: Design of solar power systems for autonomous instruments deployed in the polar regions, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7886, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7886, 2022.

EGU22-9749 | Presentations | HS1.2.1

DIY Neutron detection: Boron-based Large-scale Observation of Soil Moisture (BLOSM) 

Nick van de Giesen and Edward van Amelrooij

The ratio between slow or thermal (<2.2 km/s) and fast (>2.2 km/s) neutrons is known to be a good measure of the amount of water present in a radius of about 300m from the measurement. COSMOS detectors use this principle and measure neutrons by means of the helium isotope 3He. COSMOS has been in use for some time now and its large-scale observations are central to bridging the scaling gap between direct gravimetric observation of soil moisture (<<1m2) and the scale at which soil moisture is represented in hydrological models and satellite observations (>100m2). The main sources of 3He were nuclear warheads. The fortunate demise of nuclear weapons has had the less fortunate consequence that 3He has become expensive, leading to a search for more affordable alternatives.

Here, we present laboratory results of a boron-based neutron detector called BLOSM. About 20% of naturally occurring boron is 10B, which has a large cross-section for thermal neutrons. When 10B absorbs a neutron, it decays into lithium and alpha particles. Alpha particles can then be detected by ZnS(Ar), which sends out UV photons. Because real-estate is at a premium for most neutron detection applications, most boron detectors are based on relatively expensive enriched boron with >99% 10B. In hydrology, space is usually less of an issue, so one innovation here is that we use natural boron in a detector that is simply a bit larger than one based on enriched boron but much cheaper. A second innovation, put forward by Jeroen Plomp of the Delft Reactor Institute, are wavelength shifting fibers that capture UV photons by downshifting the wavelength to green. Green photons have a wider angle of total internal reflection and tend to stay in the fiber until they exit at the end. Here, a third innovation comes into play, inspired by Spencer Axani's $100 muon detector, namely the use of simple electronics and silicon photon multipliers (SiPMs).

Because we want to know the ratio between fast and slow neutrons, we need two detectors, one that just counts the thermal neutrons that continuously zap around and through us, and one covered by a moderator that slows down faster neutrons to thermal levels, so that they can be detected. Presently, we can build two detectors for about EU 1000. We expect that after the development of some custom electronics, this will come down to around EU 500. Ideally, we would like to build a network of these detectors in Africa in conjunction with the TAHMO network (www.tahmo.org).

How to cite: van de Giesen, N. and van Amelrooij, E.: DIY Neutron detection: Boron-based Large-scale Observation of Soil Moisture (BLOSM), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9749, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9749, 2022.

EGU22-9801 | Presentations | HS1.2.1

Leaf Structure and Function in Four Dimensions: Non-invasive MicroCT Imaging During Gas-exchange Measurements 

Danny Tholen, Susanne Scheffknecht, Klara Voggeneder, Elisabeth Weiss, and Guillaume Théroux-Rancourt

Plant physiologists have used microscopy to study how leaf anatomy is related to photosynthetic performance and how this relation is affected by environmental conditions. However, leaf anatomy is not invariant over time: small pores on the leaf surface (stomata) open and close within minutes in response to the availability of water, CO2 and light. Within tens of minutes following a water deficit, cells in many leaves also shrink significantly in volume and the leaf undergoes structural changes as a result of wilting. Gas-exchange setups can monitor changes in photosynthesis and transpiration under such conditions, but classical microscopy techniques are not well-suited to capture the concomitant changes in leaf anatomy for two main reasons. First, available non-destructive microscopy techniques are limited in resolution and imaging depth, making it difficult to analyze changes in anatomy to the required detail. Second, using sectioned fixated samples is known to be associated with tissue shrinkage, swelling or deformation, making estimates of cellular volumes and surfaces prone to artifacts. Moreover, the destructive nature of these techniques makes it impossible to monitor changes in leaf anatomy during ongoing gas-exchange measurements. These limitations hinder advancing our understanding of the relation between leaf anatomy and photosynthesis or transpiration.

Here, we present a novel gas-exchange setup that combines synchrotron-based high-resolution computed tomography (microCT) with concurrent measurements of gas-exchange using an commercially available infra-red gas analyzer. We designed and constructed a novel gas-exchange cuvette with CO2 and H2O control that allows for non-invasive monitoring of leaf anatomy in a microCT setup. Custom-built sensors were used to measure light intensity and leaf temperature. At given time points during gas-exchange measurements, 300-500 X-ray projections (100 ms) were taken while the chamber rotated 180°. From this data, a leaf volume corresponding to 0.5 mm2 leaf surface was reconstructed at high resolution (0.325 µm per voxel edge).

The setup provides 3D images that can be used to measure the aperture of multiple stomata and the volumes, shapes and surface areas of cells and airspaces within the leaf. We found that the same leaf section can be scanned several times without measurable radiation damage, allowing for the combination of three spatial dimensions with time to create a 4D analysis of the leaf structure. Using poplar, willow and Arabidopsis leaves we studied how leaf anatomy rapidly adjusts after limiting water availability and show that such effects are not limited to the stomatal pore alone. We discuss the issues and pitfalls with the methodology and suggest avenues for future improvement.

How to cite: Tholen, D., Scheffknecht, S., Voggeneder, K., Weiss, E., and Théroux-Rancourt, G.: Leaf Structure and Function in Four Dimensions: Non-invasive MicroCT Imaging During Gas-exchange Measurements, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9801, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9801, 2022.

EGU22-9972 | Presentations | HS1.2.1

The WaterWorm: a low-cost, low power sensor for the detection of dissolved CH4 in glacial meltwater 

Sarah Elise Sapper, Jesper Riis Christiansen, and Christian Juncher Jørgensen

An unknown source of methane (CH4) was recently discovered under the Kangerlussuaq sector of the Greenland Ice Sheet (GrIS). CH4 is transported dissolved in meltwater from the subglacial environment to the margin of the ice sheet, where it rapidly degasses to the atmosphere. Existing knowledge gaps concern the magnitude of emissions, seasonal patterns and spatial variations along the margin of the GrIS, which require long-term monitoring and large-scale measurement campaigns at multiple meltwater outlets. A limiting factor for such studies in remote areas is that CH4 analysers (laser spectroscopy) are power-hungry, maintenance-intensive, and expensive. To overcome these obstacles, we are developing a low-cost, low power sensor for measuring dissolved CH4 in subglacial meltwater systems in the MetICE project: the WaterWorm.

The WaterWorm is based on a metal oxide sensor (MOS) designed for CH4 detection (Figaro TGS2611-E00), which is highly sensitive to variations in relative humidity (RH) and temperature. In the WaterWorm, the MOS is encased in a hydrophobic but gas-permeable silicone tube, ensuring a stable and fully saturated headspace (100% RH) during submergence. We calibrated the analogue output (in mV) of the submerged WaterWorm against a reference CH4 analyser (μGGA, GLA-331, LGR Research) connected to a dissolved gas extraction system (DGES, LGR Research) in temperature-controlled laboratory experiments by stepwise enrichment of the water with CH4. These calibration tests showed that the sensor output (set at two readings per minute) is proportional to dissolved CH4 at constant humidity and temperature.

During fieldwork near Kangerlussuaq, Greenland, in summer 2021, a field baseline calibration was performed in a meltwater stream on the surface of the GrIS at ambient CH4 concentrations. WaterWorms were deployed for ten weeks in the meltwater of a small outlet of the Isunnguata Sermia glacier with known CH4 export and stable meltwater temperatures (0.0 - 0.1°C) to test the sensor under field conditions. Throughout this period, the WaterWorms measured elevated dissolved CH4 concentrations with diurnal variations that corresponded to similar diurnal variation in gaseous CH4 measurements performed with the reference CH4 analyser.

The WaterWorm is a promising and cost-efficient option for the seasonal monitoring of dissolved CH4 in glacial meltwater. With material costs of only 150€, the WaterWorm can be left unattended in the field and positioned directly at the ice edge. This makes the sensor suitable for a large-scale CH4 monitoring network along the margin of the GrIS. The next steps involve material tests to build WaterWorms for applications in other aquatic environments and at different water depths.

How to cite: Sapper, S. E., Christiansen, J. R., and Jørgensen, C. J.: The WaterWorm: a low-cost, low power sensor for the detection of dissolved CH4 in glacial meltwater, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9972, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9972, 2022.

EGU22-10102 | Presentations | HS1.2.1

A novel, low-cost floating chamber design for semi-automatic measurements of CO2 and CH4 emissions from ponds and ditches 

Barbara Vergara Niedermayr, Danica Antonijevic, Oscar Monzón, and Matthias Hoffmann
Barbara Vergara Niedermayr1,Danica Antonijevic,Oscar Monzón,and Matthias Hoffmann
Barbara Vergara Niedermayr et al. Barbara Vergara Niedermayr1, Danica Antonijevic, Oscar Monzón, and Matthias Hoffmann
  • 1Universität Potsdam, Potsdam, Germany (bvergaraniedermayr@gmail.com)
  • 2Leibniz-Zentrum für Agrarlandschaftsforschung (ZALF) e.V.
  • 1Universität Potsdam, Potsdam, Germany (bvergaraniedermayr@gmail.com)
  • 2Leibniz-Zentrum für Agrarlandschaftsforschung (ZALF) e.V.

Due to the large number of small and strongly anthropogenic influenced ponds (area <1 ha; IPCC 2019) and ditches there is a substantial emission of GHG, originating globally from open water (e.g., Peacock et al. 2017, Holgerson & Raymond 2016). Within those systems, high nutrient loadings from surrounding agriculture as well as low oxygen levels yield in N2O and especially CH4 emissions, sometimes exceeding those of small natural waterbodies many times over. The impact of land use and land use change on GHG emission regimes of these strongly anthropogenic influenced small systems is however still fairly unknown due to a lack of more broad data sets, exceeding single years and/or single case studies. The reason for this lies in the sheer variability of these systems (e.g., land use, underlying environmental conditions, hydrology, soil type, intensity of anthropogenic disturbances, etc.) as well as in the complexity to perform GHG emission measurements at a great number of locations with limited resources. The latter is even more of a problem, when considering the usually high cost-insensitivity of GHG emission measurements, as well as the persistence of an underrepresentation of data from developed or developing countries in e.g., Southeast Asia and or sub-Saharan Africa due to the long-term focus in GHG research on the northern hemisphere.

Here we present first results of an inexpensive, semi-automatic, do-it-yourself (DIY) floating chamber design, which can be used for in-situ measurements of CO2 and CH4 emissions from ponds and ditches. The floating chamber design consists of a star-shaped floating body (“rose dich”) with a cantered PVC chamber (A: 0,194 m²; V: 0,63m³. Low-cost NDIR-Sensors were attached to the chamber, for measuring CO2 (SCD30; 400-5,000 ppm, ± 50 ppm accuracy) and CH4 concentrations (Figaro Gas-Sensor TGS-2611; …). Environmental conditions during chamber deployment were recorded using a DHT-22 (humidity and temperature) and a BMP280 (air pressure) sensor device. All sensors were connected to a Bluetooth enabled, battery powered, compact microcontroller-based logger unit for data visualization and storage. Measured CO2 and CH4 emissions from ditches and ponds obtained on three locations spread over NE Germany were validated against in parallel performed GHG flux measurements using evacuated glass bottles for air sampling and subsequent GC-14A and GC-14B analyses (Shimadzu Scientifec Instruments, Japan).

 

First results indicate a generally good overall agreement of measured CO2 and CH4 emissions. Thus, the presented, semi-automatic floating chamber design might help to broaden the data basis/representativeness of GHG emission estimates of the globally relevant, small, strongly anthropogenic influenced ponds and ditches.

 

Keywords: Land use change, greenhouse gas emissions, low-cost floating chamber, semi-automatic measurements of CO2 and CH4, anthropogenic pond and ditches

How to cite: Vergara Niedermayr, B., Antonijevic, D., Monzón, O., and Hoffmann, M.: A novel, low-cost floating chamber design for semi-automatic measurements of CO2 and CH4 emissions from ponds and ditches, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10102, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10102, 2022.

Extended droughts are known to cause severe damage to crops. Short-term droughts of two to three weeks that occur in areas with high evapotranspiration demands and soils with low water-holding capacity can also significantly affect crop yields although their impact has not been well quantified. These short-term droughts are sometimes referred to as flash droughts. The timing of flash droughts likely has a major impact on whether or not they result in significant yield losses. An ongoing project funded by the U.S. National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) is quantifying the effect of flash drought on rainfed agronomic crops and pasture grasses in the southeastern U.S. The project is also developing tools to forecast when flash drought periods result in significant yield losses. This paper reports on the development of a tool for estimating daily crop water use and soil water content for three commonly used pasture grasses of the southeastern U.S. – Bermudagrasses (Cynodon dactylon and C. dactylon´ C. nlemfuensis), Bahiagrass (Paspalum notatum), and Tall Fescue (Lolium arundinaceum). Five rainfed farmer-managed fields in which these grasses are grown for hay were instrumented with capacitance-type soil moisture sensors to continuously measure volumetric water content in 12 cm increments to a depth of 60 cm. These data are used to estimate daily crop water use / daily crop evapotranspiration (ETc) which in turn is used to estimate daily crop coefficient (Kc) values using Penman-Montieth evapotranspiration (ETo). ETo is calculated from the University of Georgia Weather Station Network weather stations located near the fields. The final product is a decision support tool that helps farmers quantify the duration of periods of low soil moisture content. The effect on the yield of these flash droughts is quantified by using the DSSAT CSM-CROPGRO-Perennial-Forage crop simulation model.

Keywords: remote sensing, evapotranspiration, crop coefficient, smart irrigation.

How to cite: Maktabi, S., Gallios, I., Knox, P., Kukal, S., and Vellidis, G.: Developing a soil moisture Decision Support Tool to quantify the occurrence of flash droughts and saturated soil conditions for pasture grasses in the southeast of the United States, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10381, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10381, 2022.

Streamflow measurement is essential in hydraulic engineering to develop and manage water resources and ensure they are managed correctly and adequately. Two primary parameters for discharge measurements in natural rivers, namely, the mean flow velocity and cross-sectional flow area at the measurement site, are requisites. The cross-sectional area of the section could be measured using river bathymetric surveys or by using advanced and modern methods such as Acoustic Doppler Current Profiler (ADCP). For mean velocity, numerous ways and tools are available depending on the fact, whether the measurements are taken from a distance (non-contact) or using a contact method (traditional approach). Nowadays, non-contact velocity measurement approaches are becoming more popular as they are less time-consuming and user‑friendly to deal with high flows and rough weather. In contrast, the entropy-based concepts (such as Shannon entropy, Tsallis entropy and Renyi entropy) are utilized to obtain the discharge from the non-contact measurements, which gives better results than the traditional approaches such as the velocity area method. Entropy-based velocity distribution depends on the crucial parameter called entropy parameter (a function of the mean and maximum velocity), which is linked to the channel characteristics such as channel roughness and bed slope. Due to a lack of concrete evidence regarding its variation with the channel characteristics, the entropy parameter was surmised as constant. In this study, the experimental velocity data was collected from a rectangular flume fitted with a mechanical apparatus to change the bed slope. The obtained velocity data was employed to comment on the actual variation of the Shannon entropy parameter for the one such channel characteristic, i.e., channel bed slope. The velocity data analysis depict only a slight variation in entropy parameter. In addition, the discharge error analysis provided a substantial justification for using a unique constant value of the entropy parameter for the whole cross-section can be utilized instead of individual values for each channel bed slope condition.

How to cite: Singh, G. and Khosa, R.: Effect of Channel Bed Slope on Shannon Entropy-Based Velocity Distribution in Open Channel Flow, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-139, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-139, 2022.

EGU22-2218 | Presentations | HS1.2.2

Revealing unexpected sources and quantities of groundwater discharge into major river systems during drought conditions 

Julia Zill, Christian Siebert, Tino Rödiger, Markus Weitere, and Ulf Mallast

The understanding of groundwater interactions with riverine systems is of utmost importance for ecosystem assessment and management. Diffuse groundwater born nutrients, such as N, P and C contribute significantly to an increase of algae growth in rivers and eventually in estuaries, leading to eutrophication with severe consequences for water quality and ecosystem health. Thus, knowledge of both location dynamics and temporal dynamics of diffuse groundwater discharge areas, as well as the discharging groundwater quantity are required.

Here we provide a multi-methodological approach to gain this information for a large river in Germany, i.e. the Elbe River. We applied complementary methods to a 450 km long stretch including: i) analysis of daily time series of hydraulic gradients between river- and groundwater levels, ii) a flux balance for river segments spanning between neighboring gauging stations, iii) inverse geochemical modeling of the river water composition for each segment, and iv) a Darcy approach as an additional tool based on the hydraulic conductivity of the upper aquifer. The results are manifold, including a spatiotemporal answer to the dynamics and orientation of groundwater interaction with the Elbe.

Groundwater inflow is variable but occurs along the entire river. Areas of high groundwater contribution are located in the upstream mountainous parts, where groundwater makes up to 11% of the total river flow. Further downstream, groundwater inflow decreases, while inversion of hydraulic gradients indicate an immense infiltration of river water into the river banks. Unexpectedly high input of groundwater-like fluids could be detected in the lowland, where geochemical modeling indicated a massive inflow of water in a magnitude of 10% of the total river flow. Given a missing surface and groundwater contribution, an unidentified but apparently large system of subsurface drainage ditches co-exists, which transports water to the Elbe River efficiently during and due to drought-related low flow conditions.

Gaining insight into such a large-scale setting with interfering surface water contributions, effluents of wastewater treatment plants, and diffuse groundwater in- and outflows was possible only by applying the combination of independent geochemical, hydraulic and balancing approaches. With a similar availability of river and well levels and the physical access to the latter, the presented multi-method approach may provide a blueprint for the assessment of other large river systems.

How to cite: Zill, J., Siebert, C., Rödiger, T., Weitere, M., and Mallast, U.: Revealing unexpected sources and quantities of groundwater discharge into major river systems during drought conditions, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2218, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2218, 2022.

EGU22-2867 | Presentations | HS1.2.2

Non-contact, Low-cost Sensor Network for River Stage Monitoring and Dynamic Discharge Estimation 

Neeraj Sah, Wouter Buytaert, Jonathan D. Paul, Simon De Stercke, and Athanasios Paschalis

Long series of river discharge data are essential for developing improved river and water management strategies and for coping with water-related hazards such as floods. However, continuous direct measurement of river discharge is practically infeasible. Recently developed electromagnetic and ultrasonic methods can be used for automated (or direct) river discharge measurements; however, they are not widely used because they are expensive and are prone to damage during high flows.

At most gauging sites around the world, a rating curve is used to convert the measured stage into discharge. However, using rating curves is fraught with difficulties, including (a) hysteresis effect during unsteady flow, (b) extrapolation error during high flows, (c) need for regular updating due to change in hydraulic resistance and channel geometry. More recently, methods have been developed for dynamic river discharge estimation by solving governing equations of river flow i.e., shallow water equations (SWE). However, these methods (a) solve SWE in its conservative form, (b) are most suitable for prismatic channels with no lateral flow, (c) require one flow value, and (d) assume channel roughness or calibrate it by using observed stage data from two or three gauging locations. Although, stage data from two or three gauging locations are theoretically sufficient to calibrate channel roughness, in practice error margins are still high due to sub-optimal positioning of gauging stations, and coarse temporal resolution of existing measurement networks.

Therefore, motivated by a need to surmount the limitations in existing methods, we have developed a non-contact, robust, and cost-effective approach for dynamic river discharge estimation. We use an array of bespoke sensors to monitor the river stage at high resolutions and use these stage data to estimate river discharge. We present a methodology to calibrate a hydraulic model of a river reach by only using stage data from a network of such sensors. We use freely available HEC-RAS software as the solver for SWE. We have developed python scripts to control and automate HEC-RAS simulations and estimate river discharge dynamically.

How to cite: Sah, N., Buytaert, W., D. Paul, J., De Stercke, S., and Paschalis, A.: Non-contact, Low-cost Sensor Network for River Stage Monitoring and Dynamic Discharge Estimation, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2867, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2867, 2022.

EGU22-3049 | Presentations | HS1.2.2

Turbulence Metrics from Surface Image Velocimetry 

Leonardo Zandonadi Moura, Rui Ferreira, and Rui Aleixo

Image-based monitoring of rivers is a growing field of research and is being popularized as a technical alternative for discharge, erosion and flood risk estimation applications. Surface velocimetry can also be a way to characterize the turbulence structure of shallow flows, making possible the remote determination of quantities of interest such as dissipation and integral length scales. To evaluate velocimetry methods and data processing workflows, a laboratory facility emulating a river reach was assembled at IST, and monitored using commercial grade cameras, in field-like conditions. In this work the results of estimates of turbulent dissipation and integral length scales using multiple methods are provided, along with a discussion on the differences among methods and possible applications of the derived data in hydrodynamic model parameter calibration and data assimilation. LSPIV and PTV display similar results with regard to velocity estimation and vortex detection. In the estimation of integral lengths, the longitudinal scales are most affected by limitations in the measurement setup, whereas for the dissipation and turbulent viscosity estimates, spectrum methods seem to be less reliable than simpler methods based on dimensional analysis and integral length scales.

How to cite: Zandonadi Moura, L., Ferreira, R., and Aleixo, R.: Turbulence Metrics from Surface Image Velocimetry, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3049, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3049, 2022.

EGU22-3225 | Presentations | HS1.2.2

Towards automatic real-time water level estimation using surveillance cameras 

Xabier Blanch, Franz Wagner, Ralf Hedel, Jens Grundmann, and Anette Eltner

The handling of natural disasters, especially heavy rainfall and corresponding floods, requires special demands on emergency services. The need to obtain a quick, efficient and real-time estimation of the water level is critical for monitoring a flood event. This is a challenging task and usually requires specially prepared river sections. In addition, in heavy flood events, some classical observation methods may be compromised.

With the technological advances derived from image-based observation methods and segmentation algorithms based on neural networks (NN), it is possible to generate real-time, low-cost monitoring systems. This new approach makes it possible to densify the observation network, improving flood warning and management. In addition, images can be obtained by remotely positioned cameras, preventing data loss during a major event.

The workflow we have developed for real-time monitoring consists of the integration of 3 different techniques. The first step consists of a topographic survey using Structure from Motion (SfM) strategies. In this stage, images of the area of interest are obtained using both terrestrial cameras and UAV images. The survey is completed by obtaining ground control point coordinates with multi-band GNSS equipment. The result is a 3D SfM model georeferenced to centimetre accuracy that allows us to reconstruct not only the river environment but also the riverbed.

The second step consists of segmenting the images obtained with a surveillance camera installed ad hoc to monitor the river. This segmentation is achieved with the use of convolutional neural networks (CNN). The aim is to automatically segment the time-lapse images obtained every 15 minutes. We have carried out this research by testing different CNN to choose the most suitable structure for river segmentation, adapted to each study area and at each time of the day (day and night).

The third step is based on the integration between the automatically segmented images and the 3D model acquired. The CNN-segmented river boundary is projected into the 3D SfM model to obtain a metric result of the water level based on the point of the 3D model closest to the image ray.

The possibility of automating the segmentation and reprojection in the 3D model will allow the generation of a robust centimetre-accurate workflow, capable of estimating the water level in near real time both day and night. This strategy represents the basis for a better understanding of river flooding and for the development of early warning systems.

How to cite: Blanch, X., Wagner, F., Hedel, R., Grundmann, J., and Eltner, A.: Towards automatic real-time water level estimation using surveillance cameras, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3225, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3225, 2022.

EGU22-4435 | Presentations | HS1.2.2

Monitoring changes in temporary stream networks during rainfall events 

Jana von Freyberg, Izabela Bujak, Andrea Rinaldo, and Ilja van Meerveld

Stream networks are important flow pathways along which water transports solutes, sediments and affects living communities. Field observations in headwater catchments have shown that the networks of actively flowing channels are not static, but rather expand and contract over time, depending on the intensity and timing of hydro-climatic forcing. Until now, however, flowing stream networks (FSNs) have been mapped only sporadically and environmental tracer data to explore the varying stream-landscape connectivity are lacking. Thus, little is known about how and why these networks change and what the implications are for streamflow, water quality and biodiversity. 

To gain detailed insights into the mechanistic links between FSNs and catchment hydrological processes, we investigated two 4-ha head watersheds in the Alptal valley in central Switzerland. We deployed a wireless sensor network in the field to obtain spatially distributed continuous data of flow occurrence. In addition, we conducted multiple mapping surveys using a self-developed mobile phone application. Our data show that the total flowing stream length increased rapidly by more than a factor of 3 during individual rainfall events. This suggests that different water stores become dynamically connected to the stream network and disconnect again during subsequent dry periods. We test this hypothesis by linking short-term changes in FSN length to variations in subsurface water storage and water chemistry. The results help to broaden our understanding of flow intermittency in pre-Alpine headwater catchments, and thus aids in developing effective strategies to protect ecosystems dependent on temporary flow conditions.

How to cite: von Freyberg, J., Bujak, I., Rinaldo, A., and van Meerveld, I.: Monitoring changes in temporary stream networks during rainfall events, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4435, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4435, 2022.

EGU22-4457 | Presentations | HS1.2.2

Quantifying the operator effect in LSPIV image-based velocity and discharge measurements 

Guillaume Bodart, Jérôme Le Coz, Magali Jodeau, and Alexandre Hauet

The operator effect is a prominent error source in image-based velocimetry methods. Video sampling, ortho-rectification parameters, motion analysis parameters and filters can strongly impact velocity and discharge measurements. This has been reported in the literature (e.g. Detert, 2021) and highlighted by the Video Globe Challenge 2020, a video gauging intercomparison (Le Coz et al., 2021). The parameter choices made by the operator must be assisted to contain errors and to make image analysis methods accessible to non-specialists.

An investigation of the operator effect (or parameter effect) in various situations is proposed. The analysis focuses on the LSPIV measurements carried out during the Video Globe Challenge 2020. This contest involved around 15 participants with varying levels of experience, challenged over 8 videos. All the LSPIV measurements were replayed based on the data submitted by the participants. The objective was to identify the most sensitive parameter(s) for each video, based on an extensive analysis of the replayed velocity and discharge results.

The data retrieved were: video sampling rate, number of frames, ortho-rectification resolution, IA and SA sizes, correlation based and vector based filters, surface velocity coefficient (a.k.a. alpha) and transect interpolation parameters. To ensure valuable comparisons, grid points and video sequencing were fixed the same for all the participants. Replaying LSPIV measurements allowed to play with the parameters methodically and to quantify their impact on the measured discharge deviation from the reference.

Several lessons were learned from these analyses thanks to the variety of conditions offered by the 8 videos. A tendency to under-estimate the discharge in case of inappropriate parameters was observed. The influence of the video sampling rate has been noticed in many cases. It turns out to have more impact than the motion analysis parameters. The dataset was used to evaluate the benefit of automated parameters setting tools, e.g. ensemble correlation, automated time-interval, automated video sequencing.

 

Detert, M. (2021). How to avoid and correct biased riverine surface image velocimetry. Water Resources Research, 57, e2020WR027833. https://doi.org/10.1029/2020WR027833

 

Le Coz, J., Hauet, A., and Despax, A. (2021). The Video Globe Challenge 2020, a video streamgauging race during the Covid-19 lockdown, EGU General Assembly 2021, online, 19–30 Apr 2021, EGU21-2116, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu21-2116, 2021

How to cite: Bodart, G., Le Coz, J., Jodeau, M., and Hauet, A.: Quantifying the operator effect in LSPIV image-based velocity and discharge measurements, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4457, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4457, 2022.

Acoustic Doppler Current Profilers (ADCP) are used a lot all around the world to measure discharge in rivers. These instruments measure most of the vertical velocity profile in rivers, but due to technical and physical limitations they cannot measure all the way to the surface or all the way to the bottom. To calculate discharge, the instruments (or software) need to extrapolate data into the un-measured regions. Previously there was no good and available tools to aid the operators in selecting proper extrapolation. In 2010 USGS released the software Extrap, which plots relative velocity versus relative depth for ADCP measurements, and this tool made it way easier to determine the correct extrapolation of data. (Extrap is now a part of Qrev/QrevInt). Before the introduction of Extrap, 80-90% of the ADCP-measurements at NVE used the default power law extrapolation in the ADCP’s standard software (WinRiver at the time), and around 5% used constant at top and no-slip at the bottom. The first if these assumes a velocity profile that is very similar to the logarithmic velocity profile that comes from classical boundary layer theory. The latter one is much steeper (constant) close to the surface.

After starting to use Extrap regularly, 60% of the measurements use the constant/no-slip extrapolation, while 40 % uses the power law extrapolation. This impacts the reported discharge from the measurements by reducing the reported discharge by on average 4% for the measurements using constant/no-slip extrapolation, and data users must be aware, because these measurements eventually form the foundation for the long time, continuous data series for discharge in our archives.

How will a climate researcher react to a 4% decrease in annual run-off from Norway?

How to cite: Florvaag-Dybvik, K.: Climate change or just new software? The impact of Extrap software on ADCP discharge measurements in Norway, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5037, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5037, 2022.

EGU22-5967 | Presentations | HS1.2.2

Determination of continuous discharge time series based on the optical Particle Tracking Velocity (PTV) 

André Kutscher, Jens Grundmann, Anette Eltner, Xabier Blanch, and Ralf Hedel

The importance of optical measurement methods in hydrology is increasing in the last years. In contrast to conventional gauging techniques, they can be applied remotely, making the measurement safe for humans and equipment, even under difficult measurement conditions. One important hydrological parameter to measure is discharge. Deriving discharge with remote sensing can be done by applying particle tracking velocimetry (PTV) in combination with the velocity area method (VAM). VAM is a standardized and established method in hydrology. For reliable discharge results with the VAM, surface flow velocity measurements and thus trackable particles in the case of PTV usage are required across the entire width of the river cross section, which is not always the case in natural observation conditions. To fill these data gaps several statistical methods were investigated that incorporate information provided at different measurement times but with similar discharge conditions.

In this study, data were collected over longer time periods with different cameras at a gauging station of a medium scale river in Saxony, Germany. Stationary cameras recorded short videos, which are used to estimate the velocity distribution at the water surface using PTV incorporated in the FlowVelo tool (Eltner, 2020), and afterwards, to estimate the discharge using VAM. The obtained discharge time series from different cameras and camera positions were used to analyse the performance of different gap filling approaches. The results were compared to discharge and water level measurements of the official gauging station maintained by the federal measuring agency. They show, that the adjustment to the data of the reference measurements increases significantly by application of the gap filling methods. Next steps are to enhance the presented methods by using targeted data filtering and deep learning.

Keywords: velocity area method, particle tracking velocimetry, camera based discharge estimation

How to cite: Kutscher, A., Grundmann, J., Eltner, A., Blanch, X., and Hedel, R.: Determination of continuous discharge time series based on the optical Particle Tracking Velocity (PTV), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5967, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5967, 2022.

EGU22-6198 | Presentations | HS1.2.2

Non-contact volumetric flow monitoring in a semi-arid regions’ Wadi 

Salvador Peña-Haro, Beat Lüthi, Rudolf Düster, Issa Hansen, Kai Vogel, Mohammed Gad, and Mohammed Magdy

Monitoring volumetric flow in arid and semi-arid regions is a major challenge due to their harsh and continuously changing environment (e.g. extreme temperature, severe sand storms). In these regions, hydrological events such as rainfall storms and flash flood events occur intermittently, time between major events may take years. Drainage water courses in these areas are often referred as Wadis, which are ephemeral drainage courses. Wadis are normally dry except after a rain event, often resulting in flash floods events with flood peak values occurring in the first few minutes of the event.

Monitoring the volumetric flow under these environments requires robust devices which record continuously at relatively short recording intervals, e.g. minutes or less, to be able to capture the steep ramp of the flood peak.

On April 2021 a DischargeKeeper, an image-based system for flow monitoring, with a PTZ camera was installed at the Wadi Naqab located in northern United Arab Emirates. The Wadi is approximately 50m wide and has been dry for most of the time. One event occurred at the beginning of January 2022, reaching a peak discharge of 78 m3/s just 15min after water started flowing. In this session we will show the system, its challenges and the results of the event.

How to cite: Peña-Haro, S., Lüthi, B., Düster, R., Hansen, I., Vogel, K., Gad, M., and Magdy, M.: Non-contact volumetric flow monitoring in a semi-arid regions’ Wadi, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6198, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6198, 2022.

EGU22-7071 | Presentations | HS1.2.2

Heuristic measurement of river bathymetry in proglacial braided streams using SfM-MVS photogrammetry and statistical approaches 

Davide Mancini, Matteo Roncoroni, Gilles Antoniazza, Boris Ouvry, and Stuart Nicholas Lane

The quantification of river bathymetry and its change through time is a primary challenge in fluvial geomorphology. Whilst there has been a very rapid development of methods for measuring exposed river morphology, inundated zones remain a problem. The development of cheap UAV platforms and SfM-MVS photogrammetry have been particularly important as these allow low cost, high resolution, and repeat surveys. Researches have now shown that provided that there is a signal of water depth then it is also possible to map inundated areas by adopting, for example, two media refraction correction if there is sufficient bed texture in the imagery. The main problem arises, however, when the water is so turbid that the river bed is not visible in imagery. This is the case for braided rivers in proglacial margins where high rates of glacial erosion create high suspended sediment concentrations and also morphodynamically active braided rivers. In this paper we test a new and simple hypothesis to predict water depth distribution based upon heuristic reasoning: that our experience of braided river environments allows us to make a series of qualitative statements about where water will be deeper and where it will be shallower; and that if we can quantify them, we can model the water depths associated with inundated zones.

The simplest statement is that water depth increases with distance away from the nearest river bank; and it is likely to do so more rapidly when the total wetted width is lower. A more rapid increase is also likely on the outer bank of curved sections; and conversely, a slower increase is likely on the inner bank. In a braided river, streamline convergence is likely to lead to deeper water; streamline divergence is likely to lead to shallow water. On this basis, we ought to be able to model water depths in a shallow braided river on the basis of: (1) distance from the nearest bank; (2) local channel width; (3) total inundated width (given a braided river is multi-channel); (4) local curvature magnitude and direction; and (5) planform streamline convergence/divergence. We measure these parameters for a shallow braided proglacial stream (Glacier d’Otemma, south-western Swiss Alps) with high suspended sediment concentrations. Over the summers of 2020 and 2021 we acquired high resolution UAV-based imagery, as well as spatially distributed GPS data of water depths. We used resultant ortho-imagery to extract these parameters and to calibrate predictive models of water-depth based upon multivariate statistical modelling. The independent validation data suggest that between 50% and 75% of the variance in water depths can be reconstructed and confidence in estimated depths are of the order of +/- 0.10m. Finally, we integrate these water depths and their uncertainty into elevation data derived using SfM-MVS photogrammetry for the exposed areas to produce digital elevation models with spatially dependent uncertainty. Comparison of these DEMs shows that they can be used to visualize quantitative geomorphological changes and that the associated uncertainties in volume of change estimates are sufficiently low to be used in sediment budget studies.

How to cite: Mancini, D., Roncoroni, M., Antoniazza, G., Ouvry, B., and Lane, S. N.: Heuristic measurement of river bathymetry in proglacial braided streams using SfM-MVS photogrammetry and statistical approaches, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7071, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7071, 2022.

EGU22-7229 | Presentations | HS1.2.2

A new approach for flood risk estimation integrating remote sensing and in-situ data 

Rodolfo Roseto, Domenico Capolongo, and Pierfrancesco Dellino

A lot of different methods are used to estimate flood risk worldwide. The method that performs better depends on the catchment features and dimension, data time resolution and availability and uncertainty level required. Remote sensing approaches are more and more common, but because of the limited periods covered by time series derived by this new methodology, in-situ data integration is still required. A new methodology is proposed, based on a case-study of different reaches of Basento river, Basilicata (Southern Italy). Starting from hourly rainfall time series (covering not less than 20 years), for each pluviometric station taken into account into the catchment area, Intensity-Duration-Frequency (IDF) curves are computed (fitting a power law), in order to calculate the rainfall maximum at a certain percentile (typically 90° or 95° percentile are used) during the concentration time. Thiessen polygon method is used to divide the catchment area into smaller areas, each one corresponding to a pluviometric station, with the purpose of calculating weighted  rainfall values for each station area. A Digital Terrain Model is used to extract multiple cross sections of the river-bed, spanning different morphologies, from braided to meandering channels. For each cross section, starting from bankful level, it is possible to estimate diverse hydraulic parameters such as river stage, hydraulic radius, section’s surface area (using image analysis) and the mean velocity of the current, using the logarithmic law profile of the turbulent flow. Sediment size analysis is carried out as to estimate the river bed roughness for each cross section. The mean velocity value V can be used to estimate the concentration time t=L/V, where L is equal to the distance between the cross section and the hydraulically further point into the catchment area. The concentration time value t is used into the equation of the IDF curves, in order to link the corresponding rainfall height to the river stage reached at the cross section, eventually to estimate the rainfall value that, if exceeded, can cause flood. A FLO-2D model has been then used to run simulations with the aim to detect flood-prone areas, finding an overall good matching between the values of current mean velocity, discharge and river stage estimated in the cross sections.

How to cite: Roseto, R., Capolongo, D., and Dellino, P.: A new approach for flood risk estimation integrating remote sensing and in-situ data, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7229, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7229, 2022.

EGU22-7517 | Presentations | HS1.2.2

Flood flow in a proglacial outwash plain - quantifying spatial extent and frequency of inundation from time-lapse imagery 

Clemens Hiller, Lukas Walter, Kay Helfricht, Klemens Weisleitner, and Stefan Achleitner

High mountain environments have shown substantial geomorphological changes forced by rising temperatures in recent decades. As such, paraglacial transition zones in catchments with rapidly retreating glaciers and abundant sediments are key elements in high alpine river systems and promise to be revealing, yet challenging, areas of investigation for the quantification of current and future sediment transport. In this study, we explore the potential of semi-automatic image analysis to detect the extent of the inundation area and corresponding inundation frequency in a proglacial outwash plain (Jamtal valley, Austria) from terrestrial time-lapse imagery. We cumulated all available records of the inundated area from 2018-2020 and analysed the spatial and temporal patterns of flood flows. The approach presented here allows semi-automated monitoring of fundamental hydrological/hydraulic processes in an environment of scarce data. The pixel classification based on greyscale values from oblique hourly recordings returned plausible results of the spatial and temporal variability of surface runoff in the investigated glacier forefield. The image sets, processed in ImageJ, allowed geo-rectification to produce inundation frequency maps. Meteorological and discharge data from downstream measuring stations was consulted to interpret our findings. Runoff events and their intensity were quantified and attributed to either pronounced ablation, heavy precipitation, or a combination of both. We also detected an increasing degree of channel concentration within the observation period. The maximum inundation from one event alone took up 35% of the analysed area. About 10% of the observed area presented inundation in 60-70% of the analysed images. In contrast, 60-70% of the observed area was inundated in fewer than 10% of the analysed period. Despite some limitations in terms of image classification, prevailing weather conditions and illumination, the derived inundation frequency maps provide novel insights into the evolution of the proglacial channel network.

How to cite: Hiller, C., Walter, L., Helfricht, K., Weisleitner, K., and Achleitner, S.: Flood flow in a proglacial outwash plain - quantifying spatial extent and frequency of inundation from time-lapse imagery, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7517, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7517, 2022.

Since 2015, 13 agencies from all around the world (9 different countries in Europe, North and South America and Oceania) have been working together in an International Hydrometry Group, a loosely organized group of experts in instruments and methods for measuring discharge in rivers that meets virtually once a month to discuss scientific and technical issues relating to river flow measurements.

A main objective of the group is to lead the development and funding of an open-source software package, QRevInt, for postprocessing ADCP discharge measurements. The agencies participate in funding the software developer (Dave Mueller, Genesis HydroTech) or contribute scientific inputs. They define the annual development workplan and its funding, and monitor progress during monthly monitoring meetings.

In this presentation, the latest version of QRevInt is detailed and the main advantages of the software are explained, including processing of measurements from ADCP of different manufacturers (TRDI and SonTek) with the same calculation assumptions, objectification of the computation of unmeasured flow area (top, bottom, edges, invalid cells or ensembles), calculation of uncertainty and advanced graph options.

The workplan of the group for 2022 is presented, including the ongoing developments of QRevInt, and the new project for a software dedicated to mid- or mean-section ADCP measurement, QRevIntMS.

How to cite: Lennermark, M. and Hauet, A.: Developing a post-processing software for ADCP discharge measurement piloted by an international and inter-agency group: a unique, ambitious experience… and one that works!, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9379, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9379, 2022.

The annual monsoon inundations are vital in maintaining the fertility and productivity of the delta of the Mekong, Southeast Asia’s largest river. During the inundations, which traditionally last from July until November, nutrient-rich sediments are deposited on the floodplains, groundwater is recharged, and fish populations regenerate in the shallow waters. Consequently, local agriculture and fisheries are keyed to the timing of flood arrival and recession and reliant on overall flood duration. However, in recent years, the hydrological dynamics of the region have shifted. The Mekong’s hydrological regime has been impacted by shifts in land cover, the construction of hydropower infrastructure, and climate change. 

Yet the effects of these changes on the spatio-temporal patterns of inundations in the Mekong Delta remain largely unstudied, especially at local scales. Part of the reason for this is data sparsity: there is a lack of consistent long-term data on spatial inundation dynamics. No concerted in-situ monitoring efforts of flood extents existed until recently, while optical earth observation satellite missions such as Landsat often fail to provide data during the wet season due to cloud cover. Hydrological modelling approaches struggle with insufficiently precise elevation data - due to the flat topography of the Mekong Delta, even high-resolution Digital Elevation Models (DEMs) fail to capture small-scale dykes that determine whether large swaths of land become flooded. 

To cope with this data-scarce environment, we propose an innovative methodology harnessing recent satellite missions and long-term in-situ river water level measurements. This approach uses remote sensing data from the Sentinel-1 and 2 missions operated by the European Space Agency. Since 2017, these satellites provide optical and synthetic aperture radar (SAR) data at a spatial resolution of 10 m and a return frequency of 5-6 days. Furthermore, SAR provides data independent of cloud cover, which makes it particularly well-suited for operational flood monitoring purposes. After deriving inundation maps from available Sentinel images, we link these maps to water levels measured at a local hydrological station through a correlative approach to create a water-level flood link (WAFL). Using this link, we can describe the evolution of inundation patterns in the Mekong Delta since the 1990s. To quantify uncertainties, comparisons with historical inundation maps derived from available Landsat images,  and with a high- resolution DEM were carried out.  

The approach was tested in two study areas in the Cambodian Mekong Delta.  The results indicate that the accuracy of the WAFL for quantifying inundations on a per-pixel basis lies at 87%, reaching up to 93%. The spatio-temporal analysis shows that inundation incidence in the early wet season has declined by 21% since 1991 and that the average duration of inundations has decreased by 19 days. This illustrates that annual monsoon inundations have become an increasingly volatile resource, with significant impacts on agriculture, fisheries, and ecosystems. 

How to cite: Orieschnig, C., Belaud, G., Venot, J.-P., and Massuel, S.: Assessing long-term changes in annual monsoon inundations in the Mekong Delta (Cambodia): Testing an innovative approach linking remote sensing and in-situ measurements to overcome data scarcity, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9619, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9619, 2022.

The changing climate and corresponding increased variability in weather events globally have made clear the need for accurate measurements of streamflow, and the ability to respond quickly to conditions as they occur.

We present Infrared Quantitative Image Velocimetry (IR-QIV), a nearfield remote sensing method that uses infrared imagery of the surface of a river or other body of water to accurately calculate the surface flow field at high resolution in space (~10cm resolution) and time (>1Hz), accurately and continuously, over large areas (1,000s of m^2), for extended periods of time.

IR-QIV is similar to LSPIV (Large Scale Particle Image Velocimetry) and other image-based velocity measurement methods, however, it does not require any illumination or tracer particles since it uses thermal infrared images. IR-QIV has the advantages of being able to measure instantaneous velocity, in addition to mean velocity, and hence makes it possible to calculate metrics of turbulence, from which additional hydrodynamic properties of the flow can be found, including estimates of local bathymetry and bed stress, which allow estimation of discharge from a single, non-contact, measurement.

Since IR-QIV can be used to measure a wide range of flows, can operate day or night and in most weather conditions, and can continuously and robustly measure at high spatial resolution over large areas, it is particularly of use where high accuracy and resolution measurements are required, such as for fish management applications, near hydraulic structures or at other locations with complex hydrodynamics, or at locations where physical access to the water is restricted or dangerous. Because measurements can be set up relatively quickly and without requiring contact with the water, we expect IR-QIV to increasingly become an important tool in responding to changing environmental conditions.

IR-QIV was developed in a partnership between Cornell University, the California Department of Water Resources (DWR), and the US Geological Survey (USGS) for applications including monitoring flow and discharge, and high resolution hydrodynamic measurements near fish guidance structures and barriers. In this presentation we will present an overview of the method, and discuss its capabilities and applications, including considerations that are relevant for any image-based velocity measurement methods, regardless of the imaged wavelengths (thermal, or visible-light).

Figure 1. IR-QIV example: Velocity calculated by IR-QIV (black arrows), plotted over an infrared image of the water surface at Sutter Slough, Califiornia, USA, superimposed on an aerial image.  From: Schweitzer, S. A., & Cowen, E. A. (2021). Instantaneous river-wide water surface velocity field measurements at centimeter scales using infrared quantitative image velocimetryWater Resources Research57, e2020WR029279. https://doi.org/10.1029/2020WR029279

How to cite: Schweitzer, S. and Cowen, E.: Infrared Quantitative Image Velocimetry (IR-QIV): Instantaneous River-Wide Water Surface Velocity  Measurements at Centimeter Scales, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10350, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10350, 2022.

Non-contact and automated flow measurement in open channels is becoming more popular as techniques improve to measure surface velocity, reducing costs and risk to hydrographers.  However, these methods rely on estimates of bulk-to surface ratio estimates, as well as channel wetted area.  This study considers the accuracy and application of paired Up and Downstream Water Quality (WQ) measurements to estimate the Transit Time (TT) and average bulk velocity.  Combined with results from both the Automated Salt Dilution (AutoSalt) and Water Quality Mixing Model (WQMM) systems, we can calibrate the waterway for wetted area at a given water level, and hence estimate discharge from transit time velocity on a continuous basis using only temperature and conductivity insitu sensors.  This low-cost method can used to build or validate rating curves, measure peak and low flow events, and conduct cost-effective hydrological assessments over large regions for any size waterway,  to support climate change study and adaptation.  This method also has application to flood wave propagation and Initial Dilution Zone (IDZ) studies. Results from a large and a small waterway, along with uncertainty, is discussed.

How to cite: Sentlinger, G.: Water Quality Transit Time (WQTT) for Continuous Velocity/Discharge Measurement in Large and Small Waterways, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10795, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10795, 2022.

EGU22-10797 | Presentations | HS1.2.2

In-Situ, Near Real Time and Low Cost Image Velocimetry for Debris Flows and Flash Flood Monitoring in the Chilean Andes 

Alejandro Dussaillant, Nelson Sepúlveda, Felipe Aguilar, Johnny Valencia, Joel Ancan, Jaime Cotroneo, Rodrigo Herrera, Nikky Leiva, Carolina Peña, Alejandro Alfaro, Javier Fernández, and Antonio Muñoz

Debris flows and flash floods occur frequently in Chile due to geology, geomorphology and weather, costing human lives and impacting settlements, infrastructure and economic activities. One of the problems relates to the lack of adequate monitoring technology in remote areas with limited connectivity. We have developed a low cost system that processes acquired lidar and image data in-situ with a Raspberry Pi obtaining flow level and velocity and transmits near real time via satellite (or cellular network if available). The low implementation cost allows to replicate the system in the many hazardous sites, as well as advance towards early warning systems in locations with limited communication networks. The velocimetry method consists of two steps: first obtaining the images, and then a brightness filter and normalized cross correlation. To eliminate outliers a flow direction filter is used, and velocities are obtained by tracking of flow surface elements. Also the flow level is measured with a lidar also connected to the R-Pi. We will present both laboratory and field test results.

How to cite: Dussaillant, A., Sepúlveda, N., Aguilar, F., Valencia, J., Ancan, J., Cotroneo, J., Herrera, R., Leiva, N., Peña, C., Alfaro, A., Fernández, J., and Muñoz, A.: In-Situ, Near Real Time and Low Cost Image Velocimetry for Debris Flows and Flash Flood Monitoring in the Chilean Andes, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10797, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10797, 2022.

EGU22-11030 | Presentations | HS1.2.2

A stereo computer vision approach to automated stream gauging 

Nicholas Hutley, Daniel Wagenaar, Ryan Beecroft, Josh Soutar, Lee Pimble, Blake Edwards, Alistair Grinham, and Simon Albert

The gauging of open channel flows in waterways provides the foundation to monitor, understand and manage the water resources of our built and natural environment. Several methods are available for measuring the flow, with each of these methods having its own advantages and limitations. For a significant economic and environmental cost, hydraulic control structures can be built to measure the flow using analytical relationships with water height often by measuring the pressure head invasively in the water. Another common approach using the proxy measurement of water height without a hydraulic control structure is the expensive development and maintenance of a discharge rating table relating the measured water height to an estimated flow which has been manually measured at a previous time by acoustic instruments with technically proficient operators. Whilst these approaches are typically able to reasonably estimate flow within their measurement range, the safety risks in monitoring high flow events and the ongoing costs involved are prohibitive to increasing the spatial coverage of these approaches. As water resources become increasingly vulnerable to climate variability, modification of waterways, and increased extraction, there is a critical need to develop monitoring tools that can be flexible, cost-effective, and safe.

Much research has been undertaken into optical non-contact methods to estimate flow in waterways by measuring surface velocities without intrusive instruments or structures. However, to date, these surface velocimetry methods are limited to a narrow operational window of certain stream types and flow velocities due to inherent challenging optical variability in stream environments. A cost-effective stereographic camera-based stream gauging device has been developed for rapid stream gauging through the remote sensing of water height and stream velocities to estimate flows and employ the learning of an adaptive discharge rating envelope. The device includes embedded edge computing capabilities, local app connectivity for setup, and online cloud fleet management with a data dashboard for streamlined deployment and ongoing operational monitoring. Automated analysis is performed reconstructing the point cloud of the scene in front of the camera out to 40 m in order to estimate the water level without any instream equipment. An optical flow algorithm is passed over the short videos collected, generating an array of net motion in the scene which is projected out of the image plane onto the assumed water surface plane using the water level estimation combined with the accelerometer and the embedded intrinsic camera properties. The optically measured motions which are out of the plane of the waterway surface are then able to be automatically filtered and integrated into a water level indexed learning surface velocity distribution which generates an updating adaptive discharge rating envelope for the site. With over 100,000 videos recorded and analysed across 20 sites, the computer vision stream gauging approach has achieved discharge measurements within 15% RMSE of traditional acoustic gauging. This work evaluates this innovative approach across sites on the east coast of Australia and demonstrates the potential to improve the operational reliability and performance of surface velocimetry stream gauging.

How to cite: Hutley, N., Wagenaar, D., Beecroft, R., Soutar, J., Pimble, L., Edwards, B., Grinham, A., and Albert, S.: A stereo computer vision approach to automated stream gauging, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11030, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11030, 2022.

EGU22-11627 | Presentations | HS1.2.2 | Highlight

Capturing the Europe July 2021 flood event flows with an IP camera and OpenRiverCam 

Hessel Winsemius, Frank Annor, Rick Hagenaars, Willem Luxemburg, Gijs Van den Munckhof, Paul Heeskens, and Nick Van de Giesen

OpenRiverCam is a fully open-source, user-friendly, low cost and sustainable web-software stack with API to establish and maintain river rating curves (relationships between geometry and river discharge) in small to medium sized streams based on Large Scale Particle Image Velocimetry (LSPIV). The software is co-designed with practitioners from The Netherlands (Waterboard Limburg and KNMI) and Tanzania (Wami - Ruvu Basin Authority and TMA) with the principle that organizations should be able to establish and maintain operational flow monitoring sites and networks at low costs. A user only requires to establish a temporary or permanent camera site; a simple field survey to measure river cross sections and several control points; and feeding operational videos into the dashboard of the software.

In July 2021, a severe flood event hit several Western European countries including parts of Germany, France, The Netherlands and Belgium. Also the Geul river, a tributary to the Meuse river was severely affected. One of our camera setups was operational at the Geul, near the village Hommerich during the event. The camera recorded 10 second videos every 15 minutes. Through the recordings of this single event, we were able to reconstruct flows and prepare a large number of rating points over a wide diversity of flow domains within a period of less than 12 hours. In this presentation we will share the results of our analysis, and validation against formal flow observations of the Waterboard Limburg. We plan to extend the software with improved pre-processing and allow use of less precise smart phone videos.

How to cite: Winsemius, H., Annor, F., Hagenaars, R., Luxemburg, W., Van den Munckhof, G., Heeskens, P., and Van de Giesen, N.: Capturing the Europe July 2021 flood event flows with an IP camera and OpenRiverCam, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11627, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11627, 2022.

EGU22-13348 | Presentations | HS1.2.2

The RUHM framework for rapid rating curve uncertainty estimation: comparison to power-law methods and potential using drone-derived data 

Ida Westerberg, Valentin Mansanarez, Stephen Lyon, and Norris Lam

Climate change, together with other natural and anthropogenic drivers lead to changes in streamflow patterns that are now occurring with increasing frequency. At the same time traditional streamflow monitoring methods are time-consuming and costly so that it typically takes many years of significant field efforts to establish reliable streamflow data for a new location or for stations with major temporal changes to the stage—discharge relation. To provide timely and reliable streamflow data to tackle these changes to the hydrological regime and their impacts on society’s water management requires new cost-effective monitoring methods that can rapidly produce data with low uncertainty. Hydraulically modelled rating curves are a promising alternative to traditional power-law methods as they need much fewer calibration gaugings, but they are associated with additional uncertainty sources in the hydraulic knowledge and these need to be assessed.
We present the Rating curve Uncertainty estimation using Hydraulic Modelling (RUHM) framework which was developed to rapidly estimate rating curves and their uncertainty. The RUHM framework combines a one-dimensional hydraulic model with Bayesian inference to incorporate information from both hydraulic knowledge and the calibration gauging data. In this study we compare RUHM and the Bayesian power-law method BaRatin in application to a Swedish site using nine different gauging strategies associated with different costs. We compare results for the two methods in terms of accuracy, cost and time required for establishing rating curves. 
We found that rating curves with low uncertainty could be modelled with fewer gaugings for RUHM compared to BaRatin. As few as three gaugings were needed with RUHM if these gaugings covered low and medium flows, whereas high flow gaugings were not necessary. This makes the RUHM method both cost effective and time efficient as low and medium flows occur more frequently than high flows. When using all gaugings (i.e., a high-cost gauging strategy), the uncertainty for RUHM and BaRatin was similar. The results for this Swedish site show that hydraulic rating curve uncertainty estimation is a promising tool for quickly estimating rating curves and their uncertainties. Finally, we discuss the potential of using RUHM together with drone-derived data to make field efforts even more efficient.

How to cite: Westerberg, I., Mansanarez, V., Lyon, S., and Lam, N.: The RUHM framework for rapid rating curve uncertainty estimation: comparison to power-law methods and potential using drone-derived data, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13348, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13348, 2022.

A remote method of measuring surface and near-surface currents in wavy riverine environments
at high spatial and temporal resolution is presented. A two-dimensional power spectral density
technique (2D PSD), which is based on calculating the cross-spectrum between two images is
developed and compared with the established 3D PSD technique. In contrast to the 3D PSD
technique, the 2D PSD algorithm is capable of determining velocity time series and spectra,
thereby facilitating remote measurements of turbulence. Moreover, the 2D PSD algorithm can
accurately determine near-surface flows from fewer images. Results are presented from imagery
collected from an unmanned aerial vehicle and satellite imagery from a number of different
riverine locations.

How to cite: Johnson, E.: Measuring Instantaneous Velocity Fields Remotely using a Two-Dimensional Power Spectral Density Technique, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13487, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13487, 2022.

HS1.3 – Cross-cutting hydrological sessions

EGU22-1167 | Presentations | HS1.3.1

It takes a village to run a model 

Lieke Melsen

Computer models are frequently used tools in hydrological research. Many decisions related to the model set-up and configuration have to be made before a model can be run, which might influence the results of the model. This study is an empirical investigation of the motivations for certain modeling decisions. Fourteen modelers from three different institutes were interviewed about their modeling decisions. In total, 83 different motivations were identified. Most motivations were related to the team of the modeler and the modelers themselves, `Experience from colleagues' was the most frequently mentioned motivation. Institutionalization and Internalization were observed: a modeler can introduce a concept that subsequently becomes the teams' standard, or a modeler can internalize the default team approach. These processes depend on the experience of the modeler. For model selection, two types of motivations were identified: experience (from colleagues or the modelers themselves), and model vision (the model has assets that align with the modeling vision). Model studies are mainly driven by context, such as time constraints, colleagues, and facilities at the institute, rather than epistemic (such as aligning with the modeling vision). The role of local context in the construction of and the value assigned to models shows that models are social constructs, making model results time and place dependent. To account for this context in the estimation of the robustness of model results, we need diversity of opinions, perspectives, and approaches. This requires transparent modeling procedures and an explicit modeling vision for each model study. 

How to cite: Melsen, L.: It takes a village to run a model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1167, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1167, 2022.

EGU22-3905 | Presentations | HS1.3.1

Selection of flash flood models in data-scarce regions like Jordan 

Clara Hohmann, Christina Maus, Dörte Ziegler, Sameh Kantoush, and Qasem Abdelal

Severe flash floods have hit Jordan in recent years, e.g., in 2018 and 2020, leading to fatalities and infrastructure damages. Moreover, even though Jordan is one of the water scarcest countries of the world, extreme rainfall events might occur more frequently under climate change (IPCC Sixth Assessment Report 2021), causing flash floods in wadi systems. Also, the population growth combined with construction and sealing in cities increases the risk of damages, and authorities are under pressure to provide solutions for disaster risk reduction. Few flash flood models have been adopted and developed for wadi systems. Here the scientific community might help by providing tools to understand better, assess, and predict such events to introduce possible adaptation strategies.

The BMBF funded German-Jordanian project “CapTain Rain” studies flash flood risks with a transdisciplinary approach, interacting with local stakeholders. Jordan receives annual precipitation of around 110 mm overall, and hydrological data is not abundant, discontinuous, and of differing quality. Hence, flash flood modelling approaches and available software for humid regions from northern hemisphere industrialized countries cannot be easily transferred. Therefore, we want to review the variety of model options for flash flood modelling in arid and humid areas and give an overview of the selection process.

The model selection is often based on different aspects like application of interest, data requirements and availability, model complexity, code availability and open-source option, user knowledge, and modeling group experience. On the one hand, Beven and Young (2013) strengthen that model selection should not be more complex as necessary and fit-for-purpose. On the other hand, Addor and Melsen (2019) saw a strong social component. They mention the hydrological model selection is stronger influenced by legacy aspects instead of adequacy aspects. Horton et al. (2021) reviewed the hydrological model application for Switzerland. They discuss that not all aspects of model selection are mentioned in the published articles, mainly social elements. In addition, their author survey shows that modeling group experience plays a crucial factor in model selection, and most models used have a strong basis in the country.

By focusing on Jordan or other dry and data-scarce regions worldwide, other aspects need to be considered. For example, modelling knowledge of users might be limited, validation and calibration data are scarce, and financial resources for software are restricted. Therefore, we see an urgent need to analyze the aspects of model selection for flash floods in Wadi systems in a scientific context and to give the stakeholders a fact-based overview about possible model options.  

 

Literature:

Addor, N.; Melsen, L.A. (2019): Legacy, Rather Than Adequacy, Drives the Selection of Hydrological Models. WRR. 55, 378–390

Beven, K.; Young, P. (2013): A guide to good practice in modeling semantics for authors and referees. WRR. 49, 5092–5098

Horton, P; Schaefli, B.; Kauzlaric, M. (2021): Why do we have so many different hydrological models? A review based on the case of Switzerland. Wiley Interdiscip.Rev.-Water, e1574

How to cite: Hohmann, C., Maus, C., Ziegler, D., Kantoush, S., and Abdelal, Q.: Selection of flash flood models in data-scarce regions like Jordan, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3905, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3905, 2022.

EGU22-4802 | Presentations | HS1.3.1

Behind every robust result is a robust method: Perspectives from a hydrological case study 

Fabrizio Fenicia and Dmitri Kavetski

Stringent modelling methods and diagnostic techniques for improving the credibility of model predictions have received a lot of attention in the hydrological literature. However, previous discussions have revolved mainly around theoretical aspects, and arguably lacked persuasive examples. In this work, in order to illustrate the weaknesses of widespread modelling practices, we instead provide an applied perspective. In particular, we present the case of a distributed rainfall-runoff model that evolves in response to progressively more stringent application of model diagnostics. Through this example we demonstrate the usefulness of the following methodological instruments: (i) benchmarking model results against a null-hypothesis model, (ii) testing model predictions in space-time validation, and (iii) carrying out controlled model comparisons. These instruments, arguably still underutilized in the hydrological community, offer important diagnostic capabilities to increase the rigor of hydrological and environmental model applications.  Therefore their more widespread application is encouraged.

How to cite: Fenicia, F. and Kavetski, D.: Behind every robust result is a robust method: Perspectives from a hydrological case study, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4802, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4802, 2022.

Deep subsurface dynamic models allow simulating the interaction of multiple physical processes at regional and geological scale. In the past three decades, O&G industry developed so called Basin and Petroleum Systems Models to improve the prediction of hydrocarbons accumulation and reduce risks of exploration wells failure. By simulating the geological history of a sedimentary basin from its origin, these thermo-hydro-mechanical and chemical (THMC) models provide at present day a balanced distribution of static and dynamic properties of a huge volume of rocks.

 

For the last years, one of these THMC simulators has been extended to more generic application, such as geothermal potential assessment of sedimentary basins, large scale aquifers systems appraisal for massive CO2 sequestration or quantification of present-day methane seepage from shallow biogenic gas production.

 

At the basin scale, data to describe the subsurface are very diverse and scattered and the uncertainty of representativeness of basin geological models is large, especially if one expects to obtain results in quantitative terms on connected pore volumes, temperatures, pressures, stress or fluid composition.

This scarcity of data requires geoscientists to describe alternative scenarios that are compatible with the observational data.  The description of a 4D model (3D structure through geological time) of a sedimentary basin is a long and complex task and the creation and analysis of multiple digital scenarios is therefore almost impossible in reasonable timeframe.

 

We have developed and proofed the concept of interactive basin model that allows simulating while interpreting, hence comparing scenarios while interpreting. In the concept implementation, the processes of surface and subsurface data analysis, 3D scenario model building, simulation parameters setup, THMC simulation, results visualisation and analysis and scenario comparison is performed in a single “real-time” loop.

The concept also allows the incremental building of a geological basin model. Therefore, one can start by building a coarse model of the full sedimentary basin that is continuously watertight and consistent. Then by visualising the result of the simulation in terms of present-day temperature, pressure, stress, and fluid chemistry fields compared instantaneously with the available data, it can be improved to a more complete and consistent representation. This interactive loop avoids the need for costly and complex inversion and allows the geologist to quickly explore the consistency of his or her assumptions.

 

Ultimately, this interactive modelling protocol based on advanced multi-physics simulation tools should become an essential weapon for rapidly defining the basis for assessing the potential, risks and balances between human activity and the nature of an often poorly documented deep underground.

It is complementary to specific tools for data analysis or uncertainty and risk assessment, such as specialised simulators like reservoir or aquifer models.

How to cite: Gout, C. and Cacas-Stentz, M.-C.: An interactive geological basin model: supporting the fast-track assessment of large-scale subsurface potential in the context of the ecological transition, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5215, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5215, 2022.

EGU22-6363 | Presentations | HS1.3.1

Drivers of hydrological model diversity and model selection factors - The example of Switzerland. 

Pascal Horton, Bettina Schaefli, and Martina Kauzlaric

Hydrological models are fundamental tools that play a key role in many areas of hydrological science and climate change impact studies. However, it is well known that the number of models has increased beyond what is necessary. One of the key drivers for model diversity in hydrology is the wide range of model applications, motivated by specific needs and contexts that require suitable models. Yet, a significant part of this diversity is not driven by the context, as different models are applied under analogue circumstances.

To better understand the main drivers of model diversity, a review of hydrological modelling habits was conducted on studies carried out in Switzerland. Despite being a small country, Switzerland has a variety of hydro-climatological regimes, water resource management challenges, and hydrological research institutes, and can thus be representative of other regions. A first observation was that the motivations for selecting a model are rarely stated in scientific articles, and the adequacy of the model for the context or landscape is often not addressed. Thus, a survey was conducted to evaluate some subjective aspects that are otherwise difficult to retrieve from the scientific literature.

Not surprisingly, researchers are very keen on using a model developed at their own institute, which provides the benefit of expertise and efficiency, but at increased risk of context inadequacy and automatism in decisions. Other aspects were considered relevant in the model selection process, such as – indeed – adequacy, access to the code, reuse of existing model setups, collaborations, technical constraints or data availability.

Several hydrological models exist in Switzerland, while the vast majority of the studies were conducted using a single model. To some extent, model diversity is desirable to assess model variability, but multi-model applications to harness this diversity are largely missing. The survey could highlight that most researchers consider multi-model approaches important, but most do not apply them for various practical reasons, such as lack of resources (time and/or money) or lack of expertise in another model. We believe that some barriers can be lowered to facilitate multi-model approaches, requiring efforts from the modelling community and the funding agencies.

How to cite: Horton, P., Schaefli, B., and Kauzlaric, M.: Drivers of hydrological model diversity and model selection factors - The example of Switzerland., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6363, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6363, 2022.

EGU22-8211 | Presentations | HS1.3.1

Suggesting a new diagram and convention for characterising and reporting model performance 

Sina Khatami, Giuliano Di Baldassarre, Hoshin Gupta, Enayat A Moallemi, and Sandra Pool

A long-standing research issue, in the hydrological sciences and beyond, is that of developing methods to evaluate the predictive/forecasting skill, errors and uncertainties of a model (or model ensembles). Various methods have been proposed for characterising time series residuals, i.e. the differences between observed (or target) and modelled (or estimate) time series. Most notably, the Taylor Diagram summarises model performance via a single plot based on three related metrics: the (linear Pearson) correlation, standard deviation, and root mean squared differences of one or multiple pairs of target and estimate time series. Despite its theoretical elegance and widespread use, the Taylor diagram does not account for bias errors, which is an important summary statistic for evaluating model performance. Further, it is very common to evaluate, compare, and report on model “skill” by use of a single aggregate metric value, even when a vector of metrics is used to calibrate/train the model; most commonly this is a dimensionless efficiency metric such as Nash-Sutcliffe Efficiency (NSE) or Kling-Gupta Efficiency (KGE). Such “efficiency” metrics typically aggregate over multiple types of residual behaviours: for example the most commonly used version of KGE is based on correlation, bias, and variability errors, although the authors recommended that it should be applied in a context-dependent fashion based on which model behaviours are deemed to be important to a given situation. Nevertheless, the use of a single summary value fails to account for the interactions among the error component terms, which can be quite informative for the evaluation and benchmarking of models. In this study, we propose a new diagram that is as easy to use and interpret as the Taylor Diagram, while also accounting for bias. We further suggest a new convention for reporting model skill that is based on foundational error terms. Our vision is that this new diagram and convention will enable researchers and practitioners to better interpret and report model performance. We provide multiple numerical examples to illustrate how this approach can be used for evaluating performance in the context of multi-model and multi-catchment (large-sample) studies.

How to cite: Khatami, S., Di Baldassarre, G., Gupta, H., Moallemi, E. A., and Pool, S.: Suggesting a new diagram and convention for characterising and reporting model performance, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8211, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8211, 2022.

EGU22-8396 | Presentations | HS1.3.1

Rate my Hydrograph: Evaluating the Conformity of Expert Judgment and Quantitative Metrics 

Martin Gauch, Frederik Kratzert, Juliane Mai, Bryan Tolson, Grey Nearing, Hoshin Gupta, Sepp Hochreiter, and Daniel Klotz

As hydrologists, we pride ourselves on being able to identify deficiencies of a hydrologic model by looking at its runoff simulations. Generally, one of the first questions that a practicing hydrologist always asks when presented with a new model is: "show me some hydrographs!". Everyone has an intuition about how a "real" (i.e., observed) hydrograph should behave [1, 2]. Although there exists a large suite of summary metrics that measure differences between simulated and observed hydrographs, those metrics do not always fully account for our professional intuition about what constitutes an adequate hydrological prediction (perhaps because metrics typically aggregate over many aspects of model performance). To us, this suggests that either (a) there is potential to improve existing metrics to conform better with expert intuition, or (b) our expert intuition is overvalued and we should focus more on metrics, or (c) a bit of both.

In the social study proposed here, we aim to address this issue in a data-driven fashion: We will ask experts to access a website where they are tasked to compare two unlabeled hydrographs (at the same time) against an observed hydrograph, and to decide which of the unlabeled ones they think matches the observations better. Together with information about the experts’ background expertise, the collected responses should help paint a more nuanced picture of the aspects of hydrograph behavior that different members of the community consider important. This should provide valuable information that may enable us to derive new (and hopefully better) model performance metrics in a data-driven fashion directly from human ratings.

 

[1] Crochemore, Louise, et al. "Comparing expert judgement and numerical criteria for hydrograph evaluation." Hydrological sciences journal 60.3 (2015): 402-423.

[2] Wesemann, Johannes, et al. "Man vs. Machine: An interactive poll to evaluate hydrological model performance of a manual and an automatic calibration." EGU General Assembly Conference Abstracts. 2017.

How to cite: Gauch, M., Kratzert, F., Mai, J., Tolson, B., Nearing, G., Gupta, H., Hochreiter, S., and Klotz, D.: Rate my Hydrograph: Evaluating the Conformity of Expert Judgment and Quantitative Metrics, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8396, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8396, 2022.

EGU22-8603 | Presentations | HS1.3.1

How certain are we about the model-based estimations of global irrigation water withdrawal? 

Arnald Puy, Razi Sheikholeslami, Hoshin Gupta, Jim Hall, Bruce Lankford, Samuele Lo Piano, Jonas Meier, Florian Pappenberger, Amilcare Porporato, Giulia Vico, and Andrea Saltelli

Irrigation agriculture is the most important user of the global freshwater resources worldwide, which makes it one of the key actors conditioning sustainable development and water security. The anticipated future climate change, population growth, and rapidly rising global demand for food will likely lead to agricultural expansion by allowing the development of irrigated areas. This together with the fact that irrigated crops are approximately four times more profitable than rainfed crops will place much additional pressure on water resources in the next years. Therefore, it is of vital importance to devise solutions that minimize the negative impacts of agricultural expansion, particularly on biodiversity and water use, so as to help us achieve environmental and economic sustainability. To realize such an ambition, quantifying irrigation water withdrawal at different spatio-temporal scales is essential. Global Hydrological Models (GHM) are often used to produce irrigation water withdrawal estimates. Yet GHMs questionably rely on several uncertain estimates of irrigated areas, crop evapotranspiration processes, precipitation and irrigation efficiency, which are the four main inputs in the structure of GHMs. Here we show that, once basic uncertainties regarding these estimates are properly integrated into the calculations, the point-based irrigation water withdrawal estimates actually correspond to uncertainty intervals that span several orders of magnitude already at the grid cell level. Our approach is based on the concept of “sensitivity auditing”, a practice of process-oriented skepticism towards mathematical models. The numerical results suggest that current estimates of global irrigation water withdrawals are spuriously accurate due to their neglect of several ambiguities/uncertainties, and thus need to be re-assessed. Our analysis highlights that models of global irrigation water demands need to better integrate uncertainties, both technical and epistemological, so as to avoid misguiding the development of strategies intended to help ensure water and food security.

How to cite: Puy, A., Sheikholeslami, R., Gupta, H., Hall, J., Lankford, B., Lo Piano, S., Meier, J., Pappenberger, F., Porporato, A., Vico, G., and Saltelli, A.: How certain are we about the model-based estimations of global irrigation water withdrawal?, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8603, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8603, 2022.

EGU22-9464 | Presentations | HS1.3.1

Can digital twins incentivise good modelling practice? 

Joseph Guillaume

It has been said that culture eats strategy for breakfast. The effect of legacy over adequacy in modelling practice exemplifies the difficulty in changing behaviours to improve modelling outcomes. Ideally, good modelling practice would be incentivised by the systems in which modellers operate, and moreover, that modelling practice would have a learning orientation that gradually improves over time, seeking an ever closer alignment with organisational and societal needs.

Digital twins institutionalised within organisational operations provide a possible opportunity to incentivise these behaviours. A digital twin is a time-varying representation of a system that brings together observed information and predictive model capabilities. Juxtaposing model predictions with other sources of information forces models to demonstrate their value, in continually changing conditions. Operational use of a digital twin means that models need to be fit for purpose. The need to prioritise investment across a digital twin means that the model suite needs to address a broad range of purposes and model augmentation is more likely to be driven by consideration of value of information and prioritisation of efforts to reduce uncertainty over time.

These theoretical benefits are explored with example use cases in the context of cross-scale catchment water resource, landscape, and irrigation management, drawing on preliminary experiments in Australia.

How to cite: Guillaume, J.: Can digital twins incentivise good modelling practice?, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9464, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9464, 2022.

EGU22-10846 | Presentations | HS1.3.1

Time to Update the Split Sample Approach to Hydrological Model Calibration: A Massive Empirical Study 

Hongren Shen, Bryan Tolson, and Juliane Mai

Model calibration and validation are critical in hydrological model robustness assessment. Unfortunately, the commonly used split-sample test (SST) framework for data splitting requires modelers to make subjective decisions without clear guidelines.

A massive SST experiment for hydrological modeling is proposed and tested across a large sample of catchments to empirically reveal how data availability and calibration period features (i.e., length and recentness) simultaneously impact model performance in the post-validation period (e.g., forecasting or prediction), thus providing practical guidance on split-sample design. Unlike most SST studies that use two sub-periods (i.e., calibration and validation) to build models, this study incorporates an independent model testing period in addition to calibration and validation periods. Model performance of two lumped conceptual hydrological models (i.e., GR4J and HMETS) are calibrated and tested in 463 CAMELS catchments across the United States using 50 different data splitting schemes. These schemes are established regarding the data availability, length, and data recentness of the continuous calibration sub-periods (CSPs). A full-period CSP is also included in the experiment, which skips model validation entirely. The results are synthesized regarding the large sample of catchments and are comparatively assessed in multiple novel ways, including how model building decisions are framed as a decision tree problem and viewing the model validation process as a formal testing period classification problem, aiming to accurately predict model success/failure in the testing period.

Results span different climate and catchment conditions across a 35-year period with available data, making conclusions generalizable. Strong patterns show that calibrating to older data and then validating models on newer data produces inferior model testing period performance in every single analysis conducted and should hence be avoided. Calibrating to the full available data and skipping model validation entirely is the most robust split-sample decision. Findings have significant implications for SST practice in hydrological modeling. As the next phase of this study, results for discontinuous calibration sub-periods (DCSP) will be evaluated as an alternative SST design choice and contrasted then with the CSP results.

How to cite: Shen, H., Tolson, B., and Mai, J.: Time to Update the Split Sample Approach to Hydrological Model Calibration: A Massive Empirical Study, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10846, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10846, 2022.

EGU22-11463 | Presentations | HS1.3.1

Assessment of Suitability of Hydrological Models for Climate Change Impact Studies  

Andrijana Todorović, Thomas Grabs, and Claudia Teutschbein

Effective water resources management and mitigation of adverse effects of global warming requires accurate flow projections. These projections are generally focused on statistical changes in hydrologic signatures (e.g., 100-year floods, 30-year or 7-day minimum flows), which are obtained from statistical analyses of simulated flows under baseline and future conditions. However, hydrological models used for these simulations are traditionally calibrated to reproduce entire flow series, rather than statistical properties of the hydrologic signatures. Therefore, there is a dichotomy between criteria for hydrological model evaluation/selection and the actual requirements of climate change impact studies.

Here, we address this dichotomy by providing novel insights into the assessment of model suitability for climate change impact studies. Specifically, we analyse performance of numerous spatially-lumped, bucket-style hydrological models in reproducing observed distributions and trends in the annual series hydrologic signatures relevant for hydrologic impacts studies under climate change. Model performance in reproducing distributions of the signatures is evaluated by applying the Wilcoxon rank sum test. We consider that a model properly reproduces trends in the series of signatures if either series of observed and simulated signatures both exhibit lack of statistically significant trends, or both series exhibit statistically significant trends of the same sign. Statistical significance of the trends is estimated by applying the Man-Kendall test is used, while signs of the trends are obtained from the San slope. Model performance is also quantified in terms of commonly used numerical indicators, such as Nash-Sutcliffe or Kling-Gupta coefficients.

Our results, which are based on streamflow simulations in 50 high-latitude catchments in Sweden, show that high model performance quantified in terms of traditional performance indicators does not necessarily imply that distributions or trends in series of hydrologic signatures are well reproduced, and vice-versa. Therefore, these two aspects of model performance are distinct and complementary, and they require separate evaluation analyses. Accurate reproduction of statistical properties of hydrologic signatures relevant for climate change impact studies is essential for improving the credibility of future flow projections. We, therefore, recommend that the traditional process of selecting hydrological models for the impact studies should be enhanced with assessments of model ability to reproduce distributions and trends in the hydrologic signatures.

How to cite: Todorović, A., Grabs, T., and Teutschbein, C.: Assessment of Suitability of Hydrological Models for Climate Change Impact Studies , EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11463, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11463, 2022.

EGU22-12403 | Presentations | HS1.3.1

Deficiencies in Hydrological Modelling Practices 

Daniel Klotz, Martin Gauch, Grey Nearing, Sepp Hochreiter, and Frederik Kratzert

The goal of this contribution is to demonstrate deficiencies that we observe in hydrological modelling studies. Our hope is that awareness of potential mistakes, errors, and habits will support accurate communication and analysis — and consequently lead to better modelling practises in our community.

By deficiencies, we broadly mean wrong assumptions, false conclusions, and artificial limitations that impair our modelling efforts. To give some explicit examples:

  • Model calibration: Often, only two data splits are used: one for model calibration and one for model validation. To provide a robust estimate of model quality on unseen data, one should, however, involve a three-way split: a calibration set used for parameter adaptation, a validation set used for hyperparameter tuning and intermediate model evaluations, and a test set used only once to derive the final, independent model accuracy.
  • Artificial restrictions: Studies often restrict modelling setups to specific settings (e.g., model classes, input data, or objective functions) for comparative reasons. In general, one should use the best available data, inputs, and objective functions for each model, irrespective of the diagnostic metric used for evaluation and irrespective of what other models are (able to) use.
  • (Missing) Model rejection: Although benchmarking efforts are not an entirely new concept in our community, we do observe that the results of model comparisons are seemingly without consequences. Models that repeatedly underperform on a specific task continue to be used for the same task they were just proven not to be good for. At some point, these models should be rejected and we as a community should move forward to improve the other models or develop new models.
  • Interpretation of intermediate states: Many hydrologic models attempt to represent a variety of internal physical states that are not calibrated (e.g., soil moisture). Unfortunately, these states are often mistaken for true measurements and used as ground truth in downstream studies. We believe that (unless the quality of these states was evaluated successfully), using intermediate model outputs is of high risk, as it may distort subsequent analyses.
  • Noise: Albeit it is commonly accepted that hydrological input variables are subject to large uncertainties and imprecisions, the influence of input perturbations is often not explicitly accounted for in models. 
  • Model  complexity: We aim to model one of the most complex systems that exists, our nature. In practice, we will only be able to obtain a simplified representation of the system. However, we should not reduce complexity for the wrong reasons. While there is a tradeoff between simplicity and complexity, we should not tend towards the most simple models, such as two- or three-bucket models.

Our belief is that modelling should be a community-wide effort, involving benchmarking, probing, model building, and examination. Being aware of deficiencies will hopefully bring forth a culture that adheres to best practises, rigorous testing, and probing for errors — ultimately benefiting us all by leading to more performant and reliable models.

How to cite: Klotz, D., Gauch, M., Nearing, G., Hochreiter, S., and Kratzert, F.: Deficiencies in Hydrological Modelling Practices, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12403, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12403, 2022.

EGU22-13083 | Presentations | HS1.3.1

High-quality probabilistic predictions for existing hydrological models with common objective functions    

Mark Thyer, Jason Hunter, David McInerney, and Dmitri Kavetski

Probabilistic predictions describe the uncertainty in modelled streamflow, which is a critical input for many environmental modelling applications.  A residual error model typically produces the probabilistic predictions in tandem with a hydrological model that predicts the deterministic streamflow. However, many objective functions that are commonly used to calibrate the parameters of the hydrological model make (implicit) assumptions about the errors that do not match the properties (e.g. of heteroscedasticity and skewness) of those errors. The consequence of these assumptions is often low-quality probabilistic predictions of errors, which reduces the practical utility of probabilistic modelling. Our study has two aims:

1. Evaluate the impact of objective function inconsistency on the quality of probabilistic predictions;

2. To demonstrate how a simple enhancement to a residual error model can rectify the issues identified with inconsistent objective functions in Aim 1, and thereby improve probabilistic predictions in a wide range of scenarios.

Our findings show that the enhanced error model enables high-quality probabilistic predictions to be obtained for a range of catchments and objective functions, without requiring any changes to the hydrological modelling or calibration process. This advance has practical benefits that are aimed at increasing the uptake of probabilistic predictions in real-world applications, in that the methods are applicable to existing hydrological models that are already calibrated, simple to implement, easy to use and fast. Finally, these methods are available as an open-source R-shiny application and an R-package function.

How to cite: Thyer, M., Hunter, J., McInerney, D., and Kavetski, D.: High-quality probabilistic predictions for existing hydrological models with common objective functions   , EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13083, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13083, 2022.

EGU22-2993 | Presentations | HS1.3.2 | Highlight

Spatio-temporal synchronization of heavy rainfall events triggered by atmospheric rivers in North America 

Frederik Wolf, Sara M. Vallejo-Bernal, Niklas Boers, Norbert Marwan, Dominik Traxl, and Jürgen Kurths

Atmospheric rivers (ARs) are filaments of extensive water vapor transport in the lower troposphere. They are important triggers of heavy rainfall events, contributing to more than 50% of the rainfall sums in some regions along the western coast of North America. ARs play a crucial role in the distribution of water, but can also cause natural and economical damage by facilitating heavy rainfall. Here, we investigate the large-scale spatio-temporal synchronization patterns of heavy rainfall triggered by ARs over the western coast and the continental regions of North America.

For our work, we employ daily ERA5 rainfall estimates at a spatial resolution of 0.25°x0.25° latitude and longitude which we threshold at the 95th percentile to obtain binary time series indicating the absence or presence of heavy rainfall. Subsequently, we separate periods with ARs and periods without ARs and investigate the differing spatial synchronization pattern of heavy rainfall. To establish that our results are not dependent on the chosen AR catalog, this is conducted in two different ways: first based on a recently published catalog by Gershunov et al. (2017) , and second based on a catalog constructed using the IPART algorithm (Xu et al, 2020). For both approaches, we subsequently utilize event synchronization and a complex network framework to reveal distinct spatial patterns of heavy rainfall events for periods with and without active ARs. Using composites of upper-level meridional wind, we attribute the formation of the rainfall synchronization patterns to well-known atmospheric circulation configurations, whose intensity scales with the strength of the ARs. Furthermore, we demonstrate that enhanced AR activity is going in hand with a suppressed seasonal shift of the characteristic meridional wind pattern. To verify and illustrate how small changes of the high-level meridional wind affect the distribution of heavy rainfall, we, additionally, perform a case study focusing on the boreal winter.

Our results indicate the strong sensitivity of the intensity, location, frequency, and pattern of synchronized heavy rainfall events related to ARs to small changes in the large-scale circulation.

How to cite: Wolf, F., Vallejo-Bernal, S. M., Boers, N., Marwan, N., Traxl, D., and Kurths, J.: Spatio-temporal synchronization of heavy rainfall events triggered by atmospheric rivers in North America, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2993, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2993, 2022.

EGU22-3694 | Presentations | HS1.3.2

Prediction of drain flow fraction at high spatial resolution by combining physically based models and machine learning 

Raphael Schneider, Hafsa Mahmood, Rasmus Rumph Frederiksen, Anker Lajer Højberg, and Simon Stisen

In Denmark, about half of the agricultural land is artificially drained. These drainage systems have a significant effect on the hydrological system. Knowledge about the spatio-temporal distribution of drain flow is crucial to understand aspects such as groundwater recharge, streamflow partitioning and nutrient transport. Still, quantification of drain flow at regional and large scale remains a major challenge: Data on the distribution of the installed subsurface drainage system are scarce, as are measurements of drain flow. Large-scale simulations of drain with physically-based hydrological models are challenged by scale, as drain flow is controlled by small-scale variations in groundwater depth often beyond the model resolution. Purely data-driven models can struggle representing the complex controls behind drain flow.

Here, we suggest a metamodel approach to obtain a more accurate estimate of generated drain flow at high spatial resolution of 10 m, combining physically-based with data-driven models. Our variable of interest is drain fraction, defined as the ratio between drain flow and recharge per grid cell, which is an indicator for flow partitioning between drain and recharge to deeper groundwater.

First, we setup distributed, integrated groundwater models at 10 m grid resolution for 28 Danish field-scale drain catchments with observations of drain flow timeseries. A joint calibration of these field-scale models against observed drain flow resulted in an average KGE of above 0.5. Subsequently, the simulated drain fractions from the field-scale models were used to train a decision tree machine learning algorithm. This metamodel uses various mappable covariates (topography and geology-related) available at high resolution for all of Denmark. The metamodel then is used to predict drain fractions, within its limits of applicability, across relevant areas of Denmark with significant drain flow outside of the field-scale models.

Eventually, the predicted drain fractions are intended to inform national, large-scale physically based hydrological models: An improved representation of drain can, for example, make those models more fit to improve national targeted nitrate regulation.

How to cite: Schneider, R., Mahmood, H., Frederiksen, R. R., Højberg, A. L., and Stisen, S.: Prediction of drain flow fraction at high spatial resolution by combining physically based models and machine learning, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3694, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3694, 2022.

EGU22-4076 | Presentations | HS1.3.2

Information theory approach for enhancing time series analysis and predictability of soil environments 

Luiza Cristina Corpaci, Sebastian Raubitzek, and Kevin Mallinger

Soil environments are naturally governed by a multitude of interdependent chemical, biological, and physical processes that define their macro-state. In the context of farming these features are further complemented and affected by anthropogenic activities (ploughing, fertilizing, use of pesticides, etc.) that systematically aim to change soil and plant environments to enhance yield, but often with unforeseen detrimental effects (biodiversity loss, erosion, etc.). Assessing strategies for sustainable environmental management is therefore a highly challenging task that is often accompanied by incomplete knowledge of systemic feedback mechanisms and a lack of continuous and reliable data. 

To address this issue, we investigate the use of complexity metrics from information theory to gain insights about underlying patterns of multivariate soil systems and their potential implications for time series analysis. Here we apply existing methods for the processing and analysis of similar systems, we verify current theories about the dynamics and mechanisms of ecological processes in time and study innate interactions between separate components. Thereby, we will use available agricultural datasets that display a wide range of soil properties and explore several notions of complexity approaches, such as entropy measures (e.g., Permutation entropy, transfer entropy, Shannon entropy) and the Hurst exponent. Characteristic features will be highlighted that can be used to enhance time series prediction accuracy and systemic soil functions understanding.

How to cite: Corpaci, L. C., Raubitzek, S., and Mallinger, K.: Information theory approach for enhancing time series analysis and predictability of soil environments, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4076, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4076, 2022.

EGU22-4933 | Presentations | HS1.3.2

Integrating historical information, systematic data, and rainfall-runoff modelling to improve flood frequency estimates 

Miguel Angel Fernandez-Palomares and Luis Mediero

Abstract

Flood frequency curves are usually fitted to short time series of observations, leading to great uncertainties mainly for high return periods. However, reliable estimates are required for designing and assessing safety of hydraulic infrastructure, such as bridges and dams. Therefore, flood frequency analyses based on instrumental data collected at gauging stations can be improved by incorporating available information about historical floods before the beginning of the systematic period. This study presents how to identify and integrate all the information available, in order to improve flood frequency curve estimates. The Cuevas de Almanzora Dam located in southeast Spain is selected as case study.

The Cuevas de Almanzora Dam catchment has an area of 2122 km2 with a mean annual precipitation of 316 mm. However, daily precipitation can be higher, such as 600 mm for the 1973 flood event. Flood data are available at a gauging station located in the River Almanzora upstream of the dam, with a draining catchment of 1850 km2. The systematic period is 1963-2008 with information about 36 annual maximum floods. The largest flood in the 20th century was recorded at the gauging station in 1973. A two-dimensional (2D) hydrodynamic model of the River Almanzora was calibrated with such information.

Historical information about floods has been collated from local newspapers, books, chronicles, research papers, photographs, national archives of historical floods, and municipal archives. The three largest floods in the River Almanzora between 1830 and 1963 were identified, extending the systematic period to a total period of 191 years. Information about water depths and flood extensions at different cross sections of the River Almanzora were collected. The 2D hydrodynamic model was used to estimate the peak discharges in such historical flood events.

After the end of the systematic period, the hydrograph of the great 2012 flood event was estimated from the data recorded at the Cuevas de Almanzora reservoir. A rainfall-runoff model was calibrated in the catchment with 1-h precipitation data to estimate the flood hydrograph at the gauging station.

The five historical floods that exceed the perception threshold in the period 1830-2020 were integrated with the annual maximum floods extracted from the systematic data, using five techniques to incorporate historical information in the flood frequency curve. The Generalized Extreme Value (GEV) and the Two-Component Extreme Value (TCEV) distribution functions were considered. The best fit was selected considering the accuracy and the uncertainty of estimates by a stochastic procedure. Flood quantiles for the highest return periods triple the estimates obtained by using only the systematic data.

The methodology proposed can improve the reliability of flood quantile estimates, mainly in arid regions where the lack of information about the rare greatest flood, which can exceed several times the mean magnitude of floods in the systematic period, can lead to strong underestimates for the highest return periods that are needed to design and assess the safety of hydraulic infrastructure.

Acknowledgments: This research has been supported by the project SAFERDAMS (PID2019-107027RB-I00) funded by the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation.

How to cite: Fernandez-Palomares, M. A. and Mediero, L.: Integrating historical information, systematic data, and rainfall-runoff modelling to improve flood frequency estimates, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4933, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4933, 2022.

Beach cast is a material deposited on beaches after being washed up by storm (or tidal movement). The composition of beach cast usually includes seagrass or algae fragments, wracks of land plants and other materials of natural origin, (anthropogenic) marine litter, including plastic debris and microplastics. Beach casts monitoring is of current interest for beach management and maintenance of the sandy shores for recreational purposes, tracing marine litter transport and dispersion, evaluating environmental contamination by microplastiсs.

Large patches of marine debris appear on beaches after stormy weather. However, little is known about the sea state that precedes the formation of beach casts. From an observer's point of view, beach casts occur at random locations along the coast at unpredictable times. They may even be washed back to the sea at some time later. This work aims to disclose characteristic features of temporal variations of surface wave field parameters, which lead to beach cast formation.

Results of incidental surveys of the northern coast of the Sambia Peninsula, stretching from west to east in the southeastern part of the Baltic Sea, were analyzed. The presence of beach cast (at one or more locations) was observed during 234 days of 2011-2021. Some of the observations were performed during or shortly after the ending of the beaching process. Field information was collated with a freely available re-analysis database on surface waves (http://marine.copernicus.eu). Surface wave spectrum parameters were picked up from the database at the geographical point corresponding to the coastal zone's open-sea limit. Elements of Bayesian analysis were applied to overcome the lack of information on the very time of the beach casts formation and/or the unknown duration of the beaching process.

The analysis shows the values of significant wave height, peak period, and wave direction, which occurred before the beach cast appearance more often than follows from the overall time statistics ("climate"). A separate analysis of only recently formed beach casts made it possible to determine the evolution of wave spectrum parameters during the beaching process. Data suggests that most of the beach cast events on this coast are preceded by waves caused by cyclone passages from the northern direction.

Data analysis is carried out by I.I., with the support of the Russian Science Foundation, grant No 21-77-00027. Beach surveys are carried out by E.E. voluntarily and with partial support from IO RAS state assignment.

How to cite: Isachenko, I. and Esiukova, E.: Analysis of wind wave statistics preceding beach cast events on the southeastern shore of the Baltic Sea (Kaliningrad region): preliminary results, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5690, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5690, 2022.

EGU22-6761 | Presentations | HS1.3.2

Understanding the Information Content in the Hierarchy of Model Development Decisions: Learning From Data 

Shervan Gharari, Hoshin Gupta, Martyn Clark, Markus Hrachowitz, Fabrizio Fenicia, Patrick Matgen, and Hubert Savenije

Process-based hydrological models seek to represent the dominant hydrological processes in a catchment. However, due to unavoidable incompleteness of knowledge, the construction of “fidelius” process-based models depends largely on expert judgment. We present a systematic approach that treats models as hierarchical assemblages of hypotheses (conservation principles, system architecture, process parameterization equations, and parameter specification), which enables investigating how the hierarchy of model development decisions impacts model fidelity. Each model development step provides information that progressively changes our uncertainty (increases, decreases, or alters) regarding the input-state-output behavior of the system. Following the principle of maximum entropy, we introduce the concept of “minimally restrictive process parameterization equations—MR-PPEs,” which enables us to enhance the flexibility with which system processes can be represented, and to thereby investigate the important role that the system architectural hypothesis (discretization of the system into subsystem elements) plays in determining model behavior. We illustrate and explore these concepts with synthetic and real-data studies, using models constructed from simple generic buckets as building blocks, thereby paving the way for more-detailed investigations using sophisticated process-based hydrological models. We also discuss how proposed MR-PPEs can bridge the gap between current process-based modeling and machine learning. Finally, we suggest the need for model calibration to evolve from a search over “parameter spaces” to a search over “function spaces.”

How to cite: Gharari, S., Gupta, H., Clark, M., Hrachowitz, M., Fenicia, F., Matgen, P., and Savenije, H.: Understanding the Information Content in the Hierarchy of Model Development Decisions: Learning From Data, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6761, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6761, 2022.

EGU22-8321 | Presentations | HS1.3.2 | Highlight

Partitioning of green-blue water fluxes around the world: ML model explainability and predictability 

Daniel Althoff and Georgia Destouni

The consequences of ever-increasing human interference with freshwater systems, e.g., through land-use and climate changes, are already felt in many regions of the world, e.g., by shifts in freshwater availability and partitioning between green (evapotranspiration) and blue (runoff) water fluxes around the world. In this study, we have developed a machine learning (ML) model for the possible prediction of green-blue water flux partitioning (WFP) under different climate, land-use, and other landscape and hydrological catchment conditions around the world. ML models have shown relatively high predictive performance compared to more traditional modelling methods for several tasks in geosciences. However, ML is also rightly criticized for providing theory-free “black-box” models that may fail in predictions under forthcoming non-stationary conditions. We here address the ML model interpretability gap using Shapley values, an explainable artificial intelligence technique. We also assess ML model predictability using a dissimilarity index (DI). For ML model training and testing, we use different parts of a total database compiled for 3482 hydrological catchments with available data for daily runoff over at least 25 years. The target variable of the ML model is the blue-water partitioning ratio between average runoff and average precipitation (and the complementary, water-balance determined green water partitioning ratio) for each catchment. The predictor variables are hydro-climatic, land-cover/use, and other catchment indices derived from precipitation and temperature time series, land cover maps, and topography data. As a basis for the ML modelling, we also investigate and quantify (through data averaging over moving sub-periods of different time lengths) a minimum temporal aggregation scale for water flux averaging (referred to as the flux equilibration time, Teq) required to reach a stable temporal average runoff (and evapotranspiration) fraction of precipitation in each catchment; for 99% of catchments, Teq is found to be ≤2 years, with longer Teq emerging for catchments estimated to have higher ratio Rgw/Ravg, i.e., higher groundwater flow contribution (Rgw) to total average runoff (Ravg). The cubist model used for the ML modelling yields a Kling-Gupta efficiency of 0.86, while the Shapley values analysis indicates mean annual precipitation and temperature as the most important variables in determining the WFP, followed by average slope in each catchment. A DI threshold is further used to label new data points as inside or outside the ML model area of applicability (AoA). Comparison between test data points outside and inside the AoA reveals which catchment characteristics are mostly responsible for ML model loss of predictability. Predictability is lower for catchments with: larger Teq and Rgw/Ravg; higher phase lag between peak precipitation and peak temperature over the year; lower forest and agricultural land fractions; and aridity index much higher or much lower than 1 (implying major water or energy limitation, respectively). Identifying such predictability limits is crucial for understanding, and facilitating user awareness of the applicability and forecasting ability of such data-driven ML modelling under different prevailing and changing future hydro-climatic, land-use, and groundwater conditions.

How to cite: Althoff, D. and Destouni, G.: Partitioning of green-blue water fluxes around the world: ML model explainability and predictability, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8321, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8321, 2022.

EGU22-8372 | Presentations | HS1.3.2 | Highlight

Deciphering Hydroclimatic Complexity with Information Physics and Quantum Technologies 

Rui A. P. Perdigão and Julia Hall

Discerning the dynamics of complex systems in a mathematically rigorous and physically consistent manner is as fascinating as intimidating of a challenge, stirring deeply and intrinsically with the most fundamental Physics, while at the same time percolating through the deepest meanders of everyday life.

The socio-natural coevolution in hydroclimate dynamics is an example of that, exhibiting a striking articulation between governing principles and free will, in a stochastic-dynamic resonance that goes way beyond a reductionist dichotomy between deterministic and probabilistic approaches and between physical principles and information technologies.

Subjacent to the conceptual and operational interdisciplinarity of that challenge, lies the simple formal elegance of a “lingua franca” for communication with Nature. This emerges from the innermost mathematical core of Information Physics articulating the wealth of insights and flavours from frontier natural, social and technical sciences in a coherent, integrated manner.

Communicating thus with Nature, we equip ourselves by developing formal innovative methodologies and technologies to better appreciate and discern complexity in articulation with expert knowledge. Thereby opening new pathways to assess and predict elusive non-recurrent phenomena such as irreversible geophysical transformations and extreme hydro-meteorological events in a coevolutionary climate.

Our novel advances will be shared across the formal, structural and functional theory of the Information Physics of Coevolutionary Complex Systems, along with the analysis, modelling and decision support in crucial matters afflicting our environment and society, with special emphasis onto hydroclimatic problems.

In an optic of operational empowerment, some of our flagship initiatives will be addressed such as Earth System Dynamic Intelligence and Quantum Information Technologies in the Earth Sciences (QITES) on a synergy among our information physical and quantum technological developments.

The articulation between these flagships leverages our proprietary synergistic quantum gravitational and electrodynamic QITES constellation from deep undersea to outer space to take the pulse of our planet, ranging from high resolution 4D sensing and computation to unveiling early warning signs of critical transitions and extreme events.

How to cite: Perdigão, R. A. P. and Hall, J.: Deciphering Hydroclimatic Complexity with Information Physics and Quantum Technologies, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8372, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8372, 2022.

EGU22-10119 | Presentations | HS1.3.2

Life cycles of glacial lakes in Norway: Insights from machine learning algorithms on Landsat series and Sentinel-2 

Ghazal Moghaddam, Liss Marie Andreassen, and Irina Rogozhina

The observed retreat of mountain glaciers on a global scale promotes the formation and growth of glacial lakes across newly exposed ice-free areas. In mainland Norway, this process drives the rise in glacial lake outburst floods (GLOFs), posing a considerable threat to people and infrastructure  downstream. Moreover, many glacial lakes are used as reservoirs for hydropower production and thus represent an important energy source, emphasizing the need for continuous monitoring of glacial lake life cycles.

Remote sensing is currently the most efficient technique for tracking changes in glacial lakes, understanding their responses to climate change and observing lakes prone to GLOFs. Recent advances in machine learning techniques have presented new opportunities to automatize glacial lake mapping over large areas. For the first time, this study presents a Norway-wide reconstruction of glacial lake changes through the last three decades using  machine learning algorithms and long-term satellite observations. It contrasts the performance of two classification methods - maximum likelihood  classification (MLC) and support vector machine (SVM) - to outline glacial lakes and study their evolution using the Landsat series and Sentinel-2 images.

This study zooms into the pros and cons of each classification method and satellite product through the prism of glacial lake processes occurring over  disparate temporal and spatial scales - from lake formation, growth and dissociation from the proximal glaciers to the aftermath of rapid GLOF events. Based on this analysis, I conclude that the recognition skills of supervised classification methods largely depend on the quality of satellite images and careful selection of training samples. Some of the factors that adversely affect the classification results are unfavourable weather conditions such as  cloud, snow and ice cover, image disturbances through atmospheric corrections and shadows on slopes that lead to misclassifications. Regardless of higher spatial and temporal resolution, Sentinel imagery has not revealed significant advantages over Landsat but has shown a potential for their  complementary use to continue glacial lake observations in the future. The performance of SVM is clearly superior to MLC, but it is difficult to use over  large spatial scales, at least in the form it is currently implemented in ENVI.

How to cite: Moghaddam, G., Andreassen, L. M., and Rogozhina, I.: Life cycles of glacial lakes in Norway: Insights from machine learning algorithms on Landsat series and Sentinel-2, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10119, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10119, 2022.

EGU22-10890 | Presentations | HS1.3.2

One Saddle Point and Two Types of Sensitivities Within the Lorenz 1963 and 1969 Models 

Bo-Wen Shen, Roger Pielke, Sr., and Xubin Zeng

The fact that both the Lorenz 1963 and 1969 models suggest finite predictability is well-known. However, it is less known that mechanisms (i.e., sensitivities) within both models that lead to finite predictability are different. Additionally, the mathematical and physical relationship between these two models has not been fully documented. New analyses along with literature review are performed here to provide insights on the similarities and differences for these two models. The models represent different physical systems, one for convection and the other for barotropic vorticity. From theperspective of mathematical complexities, the Lorenz 1963 (L63) model is limited-scale and nonlinear; and the Lorenz 1969 (L69) model is closure-based, physically multiscale, mathematically linear, and numerically ill-conditioned. The former possesses a sensitive dependence of solutions on initial conditions, known as the butterfly effect, and the latter contains numerical sensitivities due to an ill-conditioned matrix with a large condition number (i.e., a large variance of growth rates).

Here, we illustrate that the existence of a saddle point at the origin is a common feature that produces instability in both systems. Within the chaotic regime of the L63 nonlinear model, unstable growth is constrained by nonlinearity, as well as dissipation, yielding time varying growth rates along an orbit, and, thus, a dependence of (finite) predictability on initial conditions. Within the L69 linear model, multiple unstable modes at various growth rates appear, and the growth of a specific unstable mode (i.e., the most unstable mode during a finite time interval) is constrained by imposing a saturation assumption, thereby yielding a time varying system growth rate. Both models have been interchangeably applied for qualitatively revealing the nature of finite predictability in weather and climate. However, only single type solutions were examined (i.e., chaotic and linearly unstable solutions for the L63 and L69 models, respectively), and the L69 system is ill-conditioned and easily captures numerical instability. Thus, an estimate of the predictability limit using either of the above models, with or without additional assumptions (e.g., saturation), should be interpreted with caution and should not be generalized as an upper limit for predictability of the atmosphere.

How to cite: Shen, B.-W., Pielke, Sr., R., and Zeng, X.: One Saddle Point and Two Types of Sensitivities Within the Lorenz 1963 and 1969 Models, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10890, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10890, 2022.

EGU22-11148 | Presentations | HS1.3.2 | Highlight

Disentangling direct and indirect soil moisture effects onecosystem carbon uptake with Causal Modeling 

Christian Reimers, Alexander Winkler, Vincent Humphrey, and Markus Reichstein

Soil moisture affects gross primary production through two pathways. First, directly through
drought stress and second, indirectly through temperature via evaporative cooling of the near-
surface atmospheric layer. Because it is not possible to disentangle these effects experimentally
at a biome level, Humphrey et al. (2021) has used Earth system model experiments in which soil
moisture is fixed to its seasonal cycle and evaluated the effects on gross primary production. In
contrast, we aim to use causal modeling to infer impacts directly from observation. To predict the
effects of soil moisture anomalies on gross primary production, we extend existing causal mod-
eling frameworks to cover situations where two variables influence one other. A major challenge
in applying causal modeling here lies in the bidirectional relationship between soil moisture and
temperature via evapotranspiration. On one hand, higher temperature leads to higher evapotran-
spiration and thus lower soil moisture. On the other hand, lower soil moisture leads to lower evap-
otranspiration and thus higher temperatures. Therefore, neither soil moisture nor temperature can
be adequately modeled as a function of the other. To address this challenge, we extend existing
causal modeling frameworks to account for these situations where the variables are not functions
of each other but are determined by equilibrium. We show that our method identifies the correct
links between variables in synthetic data. We further evaluate whether our new approach is con-
sistent with the results of Humphrey et al. (2021) based on idealized counterfactual experiments
using Earth system models. To this end, we use the control runs of the models to directly predict
the results of the idealized counterfactual experiment as proof-of-concept. Finally, we apply our
method to observations and determine the direct and indirect effect of soil moisture anomalies on
gross primary production.

References:
Vincent Humphrey, Alexis Berg, Philippe Ciais, Pierre Gentine, Martin Jung, Markus Reichstein,
Sonia I Seneviratne, and Christian Frankenberg. Soil moisture–atmosphere feedback dominates
land carbon uptake variability. Nature, 592(7852):65–69, 2021.

How to cite: Reimers, C., Winkler, A., Humphrey, V., and Reichstein, M.: Disentangling direct and indirect soil moisture effects onecosystem carbon uptake with Causal Modeling, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11148, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11148, 2022.

EGU22-12346 | Presentations | HS1.3.2

Configuration entropy analysis of river water quality dynamics under fine time resolution and network topology 

Tianrui Pang, Jiping Jiang, Peng Wang, Yi Zheng, and Tong Zheng

The water environment is an important carrier of material processes, in which a large number of biochemical reactions and energy transmission processes occur. High-frequency water quality observation can help us understand the dynamics of solute transport in the water environment. The information-theoretic approaches to system dynamics are receiving more and more attention that it reveals the new laws and support board applications. Configuration entropy (H*) is one of the derivative indexes that originated from information entropy, which was first introduced in 1994 to describe the disorder in random morphologies. It can reflect the complexity of the system under different space or time resolutions. Researchers have analyzed the characteristics of configuration entropy in some of the environment scenarios, such as spatial arrangement of rainfall. In this paper, we analyzed the space structure of river basin water quality dynamic system under the network topology of rivers, together with the time structure of water quality dynamic system. We calculated the configuration entropy of six water quality parameter data from four monitoring stations at Potomac River in two dimensions of time and space with topological treatment of river water system map. We arranged the high-frequency water quality time series according to different time slices to form a two-dimensional pixel image for calculating configuration entropy and the variation under different time resolutions. Results show that with the increasing length of time slice (from 1 day to 9 days), except pH and turbidity, the configuration entropy curve of other parameters has only one peak (1 day, 1.5 days, 2 days) to the valley (2.5 days and later), which confirms a hypothesis that the configuration entropy will not have a valley when the length of time grid is significantly greater than the width. When the length of the time slice is more than 2.5 days, even if the length of the time slice is increased, the overall shape of configuration entropy curve does not change significantly, suggesting that the configuration entropy of specific water quality parameters did not show temporal heterogeneity in a long-time period observation. We also assumed that temporal fractal phenomena exist in some water quality parameters consistent with previous studies. More analysis is in progress.

How to cite: Pang, T., Jiang, J., Wang, P., Zheng, Y., and Zheng, T.: Configuration entropy analysis of river water quality dynamics under fine time resolution and network topology, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12346, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12346, 2022.

EGU22-12588 | Presentations | HS1.3.2

A complex network perspective on catchment water quality dynamics: characteristics, pattern, and drivers 

Qingzhi Wen, Jiping Jiang, and Bellie Sivakumar

Understanding the connections in the dynamics of water quality at different locations in a catchment is important for catchment studies and watershed management. Complex network science provides effective ways to uncover connections and patterns in catchment water quality dynamics. This study  investigates the spatial connections in each of five water quality indexes (Chloride, Dissolved oxygen, pH, Total nitrogen, and Total organic carbon) and flow rate in the Chesapeake Bay basin, USA.High-resolution data (five minutes) from 120 water quality monitoring stations are analyzed. 1) The clustering coefficient (CC) and degree distribution methods are employed to examine the connections and identify the type of the water quality networks. The results indicate that the networks of water quality parameters are  scale-free. The power-law (γ) values of for the networks of Chl, DO, flow rate, pH, TN, TOC are 0.74, 0.67, 0.37, 2.0, 0.57 and 1.2, respectively. 2) Monte Carlo simulation of degree distributions and clustering coefficients (CC) shown that all water quality parameters present a decrease in the CC along with the turn down of the threshold of correlation coefficient (R), but the R threshold for DO and flow rate was 0.9. Other water quality parameters showed a sharp decline in the range of correlation coefficient (R) of 0.3-0.6, show a gentle decrease, and then decrease sharply, with an inverse s-curve. 3) All the WQ parameters show stable patterns of CC versus R, for different sizes of networks, arrived by randomly reducing the number of nodes (i.e. stations) of the networks. This seems to indicate that the pattern is an internal systemically feature of the networks, regardless of the node selected for analysis. The variations of CC values for the different stations in the networks  with different R values also help identify the “heat area” of the whole catchment, which  has some nodes with stable large CC. For the different water quality parameters, the heat area is basically the same, except for pH and TN for which the area is much smaller. The present findings on the characteristics, patterns, and drivers of water quality dynamics in catchments have important implications for water quality studies, especially in large networks of monitoring stations.

How to cite: Wen, Q., Jiang, J., and Sivakumar, B.: A complex network perspective on catchment water quality dynamics: characteristics, pattern, and drivers, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12588, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12588, 2022.

EGU22-13100 | Presentations | HS1.3.2 | Highlight

Machine Learning Methods with the Standardized VPD Drought Index to Identify and Assess Drought in the United States 

Brandi Gamelin, Vishwas Rao, Julie Bessac, and Mustafa Altinakar

Extreme drought has a strong socio-economic impact on the human environment, especially where surface and ground water supplies are significantly reduced due to reduced stream flow, reduced hydroelectric generation, and increased ground water pumping for agricultural and human consumption. This reduction will likely increase in the future as drought is expected to increase in the United States due to global warming and climate change. However, identifying drought is problematic due to the lack of standardized classification or reliable methods for drought prediction. Recently, machine learning techniques have been applied to drought indices to identify drought features and for risk assessment. For this work, we utilize unsupervised machine learning (ML) computational algorithms to identify drought characteristics with a new drought index based on vapor pressure deficit (VPD). The Standardized VPD Drought Index (SVDI) is used to cluster points with common features to characterize spatial and temporal drought characteristics. The SVDI is calculated with the NASA’s Land Surface Assimilation System (NLDAS) data from 1990-2010. Several ML cluster techniques (e.g. HMM, k_means, BIRCH, DBSCAN) are applied to the SVDI to identify known short and long term drought events. Optimized techniques will be applied to downscaled global climate models (e.g. CCSM4, GFDL-ESM2G, and HadGEM2-ES) based on the 8.5 Representative Concentration Pathway (RCP8.5). From the space-time clustering algorithm, we will extract the spatiotemporal information for each identified event as a means of determining the probability of each type of event under global warming in the future.

How to cite: Gamelin, B., Rao, V., Bessac, J., and Altinakar, M.: Machine Learning Methods with the Standardized VPD Drought Index to Identify and Assess Drought in the United States, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13100, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13100, 2022.

EGU22-416 | Presentations | HS1.3.3

Contributions of Eric Wood to hydrologic remote sensing 

Valentijn Pauwels

Remote sensing is one of the major sources of data for the hydrological sciences. This presentation provides an overview of the contributions of Eric Wood to this field, encompassing studies from the last three decades, across multiple continents and different spatial and temporal scales. The remotely sensed variables include, but are not limited to, surface soil moisture content (through active and passive remote sensing), precipitation, and evapotranspiration. A general overview of the field and satellite campaigns in which these methods and products were developed will be presented. A short overview of the application of these products for different purposes is also provided.

How to cite: Pauwels, V.: Contributions of Eric Wood to hydrologic remote sensing, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-416, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-416, 2022.

EGU22-1900 | Presentations | HS1.3.3

Eric Wood’s contributions to Scaling in Hydrology 

Günter Blöschl

This presentation will briefly review the scaling and similarity concepts developed by Eric Wood and evaluate their impact on the development of the hydrological science, in particular distributed hydrological modeling.

Eric Wood was a pioneer in fundamental research on scaling and similarity of catchment hydrologic response. He introduced the “representative elementary area” concept that showed that catchment response could be represented in terms of “building blocks” of some minimum size. This thinking launched him into the era of spatially distributed hydrologic modeling. Eric was the first to develop a distributed modeling framework that accounted for the effects of topography and land ­surface–​­atmosphere interactions involving coupled ­water–​­energy dynamics. Many of the distributed modeling concepts Eric pioneered found their way into the Variable Infiltration Capacity (VIC) macroscale hydrology model, which has become a common land surface parameterization scheme in global circulation models used in global change science.

How to cite: Blöschl, G.: Eric Wood’s contributions to Scaling in Hydrology, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1900, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1900, 2022.

EGU22-3054 | Presentations | HS1.3.3

Some reflections on Eric Wood’s career 

Dennis Lettenmaier

I will reflect on some of Eric’s major accomplishments, and my own experiences from having worked with him for over 40 years.  This will go back to our first professional meeting, at a meeting of the AGU Committee on Network Design in the late 1970s.  It will also include early consulting work, including Love Canal in particular, his leave at the (then) UK Institute of Hydrology in 1984, and work with the late James R Wallis.  I will focus especially on development of the Variable Infiltration Capacity (VIC) model starting in the early 1990s, and its many applications by his group over the last two plus decades.  I’ll finish with reflections on his approach to hydrologic research, and some messages our younger colleagues can take away from his life and contributions.

How to cite: Lettenmaier, D.: Some reflections on Eric Wood’s career, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3054, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3054, 2022.

EGU22-3084 | Presentations | HS1.3.3

Distributed Modeling: from REA to hillslope-resolving 

Christa Peters-Lidard

Eric Wood's contributions to distributed modeling were partially motivated by a desire to test the REA hypothesis as well as by a desire to demonstrate the impact of remotely sensed data on hydrologic prediction.  In this brief talk, I will review the advances in distributed modeling, such as high-resolution terrain, distributed hydrometeorological forcings and soil-vegetation parameters, high performance computing and communications, data assimilation, coupled land-atmosphere modeling, that laid the foundation for macroscale and ultimately "hyperresolution" modeling.  These foundational advances exemplify the 3rd paradigm in hydrology and are moving us towards embracing a 4th paradigm in hydrology, where we enable a rigorous confrontation of our hypotheses embodied within our models with a range of data types across many locations and spatial-temporal scales.  

How to cite: Peters-Lidard, C.: Distributed Modeling: from REA to hillslope-resolving, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3084, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3084, 2022.

Eric F. Wood was a pioneer in large-domain hydrologic modeling. Building on his work on hydrologic scaling in the 1980s, in the 1990s and 2000s Eric led the community in process-based approaches to hydrologic modeling across large geographical domains. Together with Dennis Lettenmaier, Eric developed the open-source Variable Infiltration Capacity (VIC), which became a leading large-domain hydrologic model used by dozens of research groups around the world. The capabilities of VIC advanced by Eric and Dennis' students and postdocs included improved representation of hydrologic scaling relationships, advanced representation of cold region hydrologic processes, new capabilities for large-domain streamflow forecasting, and understanding the sensitivity of large river basins to climate variability and change. Eric's work in leading community model inter-comparison projects (PILPS) and community large-domain modeling studies (GEWEX/GCIP and GEWEX/GAPP) advanced understanding of the limitations of large-domain hydrologic models and helped identify effective strategies for model improvement. It is clear that most large-domain hydrologic models that are in use today are heavily influenced by the legacy of VIC. As the community continues to advance in developing interdisciplinary approaches to Earth System modeling (integrating advances from terrestrial and aquatic ecology and the social sciences), explicitly representing a broader range of natural and human processes, it is increasingly clear that the community is indebted to the contributions of Eric F. Wood.

How to cite: Clark, M.: Celebrating Eric Wood's advances in large domain hydrologic modeling, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5238, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5238, 2022.

Eric F. Wood will be remembered as a visionary scientist and mentor to many hydrologists. As a master student, I had the good fortune to read one of his thought-provoking questions: What modelling experiments need to be performed to resolve the scale question? [1]. Further reading of his scientific contributions led me to appreciate the usefulness of the representative elementary area concept (REA) [2] for developing meso- or macro-scale hydrological models that benefit from the subgrid variability of model paramterizations to derive hydrological fluxes at multiple scales. Eric's scientific writings intrigued us so much that they lead to the development of the multiscale parameter regionalization (MPR) [3] technique originally implemented in the mesoscale hydrological model [4] and now applicable to any land surface model to derive seamless parameter fields at continental or global scales [5].

Eric was an early advocate of hyperresolution global land surface modeling and continental drought monitoring and forecasting initiatives [6,7]. His support and motivation were key to devising a project to demonstrate, for the first time, the feasibility of a high-resolution seasonal forecasting and projection system for Europe using a multi-model approach that use the same hyperresolution physiographic datasets and a common river routing model to reduce the predictive uncertainty of the target variables. We called this project the End to End Demonstrator for Improved Decision Making in Europe (EDgE) [8]. This proof-of-concept constitutes now a blueprint for several follow-up projects at national or global scales [e.g., 9].

Eric F. Wood's scientific legacy will shape future developments in land surface modeling and his contributions will keep guiding generations of hydrologists. I was one of the fortunate ones who had the opportunity to know him as a mentor, project partner and friend. In this presentation, I will attempt to synthesize some of his key contributions that are the cornerstone for developing a Digital Twin [11] of the Earth's water cycle.

References

[1] Wood, E. (Ed.): Land Surface, atmosphere interactions for climate modelling: observations, models, and analysis, Kluwer, 1990.
[2] Wood, E. F. et al. https://doi.org/10.1016/0022-1694(88)90090-X 1988.
[3] Samaniego, L. et al. https://doi.org/10.1029/2008WR007327, 2010b.
[4] mhm-ufz.org
[5] Schweppe, R et al. https://doi.org/10.5194/gmd-2021-103. 2021.
[6] Wood, E.F. et al. https://doi.org/10.1029/2010WR010090 2010.
[7] Sheffield, J., Wood, E. F. et al. https://doi.org/10.1175/BAMS-D-12-00124.1, 2014.
[8] Samaniego, L. et al. https://doi.org/10.1175/BAMS-D-17-0274.1 2019
[9] https://www.ufz.de/ulysses
[10] Bauer, P. et al. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41558-021-00986-y 2021

How to cite: Samaniego, L.: From the REA Concept to a High Resolution Digital Twin of the Earth's Water Cycle, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8072, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8072, 2022.

One of Eric Wood’s latest contributions was to set forth the needs and challenges for developing hyper-resolution LSMs in the order of ~100-m to 1-km spatial resolution. This expanded the applicability of land surface models (LSMs), to address critical challenges in monitoring terrestrial water.  Particularly, by representing the spatial variability of physical processes and their interactions with water, energy, and carbon fluxes at the fine-scale that are critical to advance monitoring and understanding of processes linked to freshwater dynamics, hydrologic extremes (floods and droughts), food security, water quality, among others. Over the past 10 years, Eric’s visions on hyper-resolution along with the ever-increasing availability of high-resolution environmental datasets, satellite and in-situ observations, computing resources, and the development of novel modeling frameworks provided a fertile environment for hyper-resolution land surface models to flourish. This presentation will review the community’s efforts towards the development of models, processes representation, and supporting datasets. In particular, it will highlight recent advances on leveraging big environmental datasets and machine learning for developing hyper-resolution LSMs’ sub-grid tiling schemes; the role of data assimilation in hyper-resolution LSMs to bridge spatial scale mismatch between satellite and in-situ observations; and applications of hyper-resolution LSM for understanding soil moisture spatial scaling.

How to cite: Vergopolan, N.: Eric Wood’s contributions and recent advances on hyper-resolution land surface modeling, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9726, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9726, 2022.

HS2.1 – Catchment hydrology in diverse climates and environments

EGU22-291 | Presentations | HS2.1.1

Potential of remote sensing data to analyze the effect of drought on wheat yields in the Mediterranean region: study area Kairouan Tunisia and Lleida Spain 

Manel Khlif, Aicha Chahbi Bellakanji, Maria José Escorihuela, Vivien-Georgiana Stefan, and Zohra Lili Chabaane

With climate change, mainly drought, the situation of water stress in most Mediterranean countries is worsening with the high demand for agricultural water and the scarcity of water resources. Forecasts have found that more than 33 countries, including Tunisia and Spain, will face extremely high water stress by 2040, threatening agriculture and food security. In this study, we analyze the potential of different drought indices to identify drought periods for two regions with different climates: Kairouan in Tunisia, and Lleida in Spain, and we identify the indices that give more accuracy for cereal yield prediction.

To achieve the objectives of this study, satellite data was used: MODIS (NDVI and LST) and SMOS. Spatial resolution enhancement algorithms have been applied, such as DISaggregation based on Physical And Theoretical scale Change (DISPATCh), to improve the spatial resolution of SMOS from 40 km to 1 km. In this study, we focus on two principal parameters to identify agricultural drought: Soil Moisture Anomaly Index (SMAI) calculated from soil moisture DISPATCh data, which gives an idea of the soil water status and Vegetation Anomaly Index (VAI) derived from MOD13Q1, which reflects the vegetative activity. 

Over the past 10 years, from the 2010/2011 agricultural year to 2019/2020, we have identified dry periods of agricultural drought based on VAI and SMAI. The results show that SMAI can detect more dry periods in space and time than VAI. For the study area in Tunisia, the strongest correlation obtained between wheat yield and SMAI is in November (R = 0.71). This result highlights the importance of water during this period. The correlation between wheat yield and SMAI decreased slightly in January (R=0.55), February (R=0.57), and March (R=0.63). However, the vegetation cover started to appear in January. A stronger, but later, correlation with VAI in March (R=0.63). For the second study area in Spain, Lleida, the correlation between drought index and yield anomaly of wheat and barley was studied separately. For barley, the increase in the correlation between grain yield and VAI started in February (R= 0.71), March (R=0.73), and then April where it reached its maximum (R=0.87). A more important correlation is noted in March with the SMAI which is about 0.8. Similarly, for wheat, the best correlation between yield and SMAI is recorded in March (R= 0.88) and with a slightly less important correlation with VAI of the order of 0.51 in March.

In conclusion, this study shows the interest in improving the spatial resolution of soil moisture to better study agricultural drought and its effect on cereal yield.

How to cite: Khlif, M., Chahbi Bellakanji, A., Escorihuela, M. J., Stefan, V.-G., and Lili Chabaane, Z.: Potential of remote sensing data to analyze the effect of drought on wheat yields in the Mediterranean region: study area Kairouan Tunisia and Lleida Spain, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-291, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-291, 2022.

EGU22-1390 | Presentations | HS2.1.1

Evaluation of the water response in a Mediterranean karstic catchment (SE Spain) with the SIMPA and SWAT models 

Antonio Jodar, Teresa Palacios - Cabrera, Ryan T. Bailey, Pablo Melgarejo - Moreno, Pilar Legua - Murcia, and Enas E. Hussein

Abstract:

Hydrological modelling in karst environments is a difficult task due to the inherent complexity of the karst system and the usual lack of information about its geometrical description. The hydrological processes of karst systems in Mediterranean semiarid environments are particularly difficult to simulate mathematically due to the pattern of long dry periods and short wet periods. In this study, we tested the ability of the open-source SWAT hydrologic modelling code to simulate the behaviour and hydrologic output of a karstic watershed in a Mediterranean semiarid environment (SE Spain). Calibration and first validation were accomplished using a 20-year and 10-year record of stream water discharge, respectively, at the catchment outlet. Additional testing of the model was accomplished using groundwater discharge data from four natural springs in the watershed and by comparing the results of the SWAT model with the SIMPA model (a hydrological model used by the Spanish national water authority to simulate the water balance among others). Likewise, an adapted form of the Nash-Sutcliffe Efficiency (NSE) index for arid environments, ANSE, is presented. Based on results, the simulated behaviour was good and very good (with ANSE values of 0.96 and 0.78 for the calibration and validation periods respectively). SWAT and SIMPA results provide spatial distributions of the main hydrological processes of the watershed, such as aquifer recharge, actual evapotranspiration, and surface runoff, being verified as useful tools for water policy managers in karstic environments.

Keywords:

Water balance; karst aquifer springs; SWAT; SIMPA; ANSE index; Mediterranean karstic catchment.

 

 

 

 

How to cite: Jodar, A., Palacios - Cabrera, T., Bailey, R. T., Melgarejo - Moreno, P., Legua - Murcia, P., and Hussein, E. E.: Evaluation of the water response in a Mediterranean karstic catchment (SE Spain) with the SIMPA and SWAT models, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1390, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1390, 2022.

EGU22-2768 | Presentations | HS2.1.1

In situ radar measurements for monitoring the physiological functioning of wheat crops in the semi-arid area 

Nadia Ouaadi, Ludovic Villard, Saïd Khabba, Pierre-Louis Frison, Jamal Ezzahar, Mohamed Kasbani, Pascal Fanise, Adnane Chakir, Valerie Le Dantec, Mehrez Zribi, Salah Er-Raki, and Lionel Jarlan

Irrigated agriculture is the largest consumer of freshwater in the world, particularly in the South Mediterranean region, that already suffers from water shortages. For a rational and sustainable management of water resources, monitoring the water stress status of plants can contribute to an optimal use of irrigation.

C-band radar data have shown great potential for monitoring soil and vegetation hydric conditions. Over forests, several studies have observed a diurnal cycle in the backscattering coefficient that can reach up to 1 dB between morning and evening measurements acquired by sun-synchronous satellites. This cycle is assumed to be related to the physiological functioning of trees, in particular to the diurnal cycle of the vegetation water content. A recent study also identified a diurnal cycle in the temporal coherence measured over tropical forests. The authors hypothesized that transpiration was the main factor in the decrease in coherence at dawn, especially since winds are almost zero at that time of day. While the diurnal cycle of radar data is well documented over trees, the behavior of annual crops is yet to be investigated. In this context, the objective of this work is to present a preliminary study of this behavior over wheat by assuming that water movement in the plant could lead to a daily cycle of the interferometric coherence and backscattering coefficient.

An experiment funded by LMI TREMA and TOSCA/CNES has been conducted over a winter wheat field in Morocco since January 2020. The experimental setup consists of six C-band antennas installed at the top of a 20 m high tower. It allows the full polarization acquisition of the backscattering coefficient and the interferometric coherence with a 15 minutes time step. The field is also equipped with an eddy covariance and weather stations that allow half-hourly measurements of evapotranspiration and wind speed. In addition to automatic measurements, field campaigns are also carried out to measure soil moisture, surface roughness, vegetation above-ground biomass and cover fraction.

The preliminary analysis of in situ radar acquisitions over the 2020 agricultural season reveals the existence of a diurnal cycle of the interferometric coherence whose amplitude increases with the development of vegetation. In particular, a drop in coherence was observed at dawn. This drop is concomitant with the increase in evapotranspiration, which may indicate that it could be due to the sapflow. On the other hand, low coherence values are recorded at the end of the afternoon, which may be related to wind peaks. For the backscattering coefficient, a good agreement is observed between the evolution of its daily average and the evolution of evapotranspiration. These results, which need to be consolidated, demonstrate the existence of important dependencies between the C-band response and the physiological functioning of wheat, which opens insights for the monitoring of crop water status using radar data acquired at sub-daily timescale. This rather highlights the interest of a future geostationary radar mission.

How to cite: Ouaadi, N., Villard, L., Khabba, S., Frison, P.-L., Ezzahar, J., Kasbani, M., Fanise, P., Chakir, A., Le Dantec, V., Zribi, M., Er-Raki, S., and Jarlan, L.: In situ radar measurements for monitoring the physiological functioning of wheat crops in the semi-arid area, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2768, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2768, 2022.

Due to the water shortage and poor management of limited water resources in semi-arid region, the improvement of irrigation efficiency became crucial. In this context, the objective of this work is to estimate water content and evapotranspiration using the HYDRUS-1D model. 

The study was carried out over wheat fields of the R3 perimeter (located in the Haouz plain of Marrakesh-Safi region, Morocco) for the growing season of 2003/2004. Four types of data have been used, namely: data related to the soil, data related to the plant, data related climatic parameters (recorded in a station close to the study site), and data related to the local agricultural practice.

We firstly used the inverse method, available in HYDRUS-1D, in order to estimate the hydrodynamic parameters of cultivated soil. The analysis of the convergence and consistency of this method showed that for correct calibration of the model, it is necessary to take into account the vertical heterogeneity of the soil. Therefore, we proceeded to the manual calibration of the model by testing different choices of initial parameters and taking into account the soil  vertical heterogeneity. The calibration carried out concerned mainly the water content of the soil and the evapotranspiration of the surface.

The simulations of the real evapotranspiration (ET) were carried out using the inputs obtained for the manual calibration. The results obtained by the HYDRUS-1D model gave an overestimation of the soil water content. This underestimation can be explained either by an underestimation of the LAI inputs or by the root extraction module that needs to be readjusted.

In the present work, the HYDRUS-1D model was tested, for the first time, over an area of Haouz plain in central Morocco.  The obtained results are not yet final. The model needs to be tested sufficiently over a wide spatio-temporal range. The HYDRUS-1D model is widely used in different regions of the world and the extensive literature reports a good score on the consistency and robustness of the model. Thus we are convinced that, overall, HYDRUS-1D seems to be an adequate model to estimate with acceptable accuracy the water content and the real ET under semi-arid conditions. It is also a promising tool for planning and decision support in the field of water and agro-environmental research.

How to cite: Moumni, A. and Lahrouni, A.: Towards a calibration of the HYDRUS-1D model on a wheat crop in the semi-arid conditions of Haouz region, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3121, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3121, 2022.

EGU22-3201 | Presentations | HS2.1.1

Simulation study of water balance and solute transport in agricultural soil in Haouz region, Morocco 

el houcine el moussaoui, Aicha Moumni, and Abderrahman Lahrouni

The hydraulic basin of Tensift is a concrete example of diversification and increase of pollutants discharged without treatment into the natural environment. This issue strongly threatens the water resources of this basin and makes it extremely sensitive to pollution, including groundwater that is a strategic resource in this area. The purpose of this study is to simulate two phenomena, which are hydrodynamic operation and leaching of solute in the conditions of the Haouz region.

The study was conducted on the R3 perimeter. It is an irrigated agricultural sector in the region of Sidi Rahal, about 40 km east of Marrakech city, Morocco. To carry out this work, the VS2DI model was chosen for the following reasons: accessibility, reliability, and free of charge. This model popularly uses Cartesian or radial coordinates and allows solving the Richards equation to model the water transfer and the convection-dispersion equation to model the transport of solutes and heat in a porous and variably saturated medium. Our research team collects the data needed for the VS2DI model during the agricultural season of 2002/2003. The collected data is related to climatic conditions, soil, plant, and cultivation practice. 

The results obtained showed that for the scenarios studied the moisture of the upper layers increases and tends towards saturation depending on the value of the flux imposed on the surface. However, the deep layers remain unsaturated for a long time because of drainage. Thus, after one day and for a flux of 12 cm/d, the first 40cm of the soil is saturated. For the 4 cm/d flow, the saturation, during 24h, did not exceed the 30 cm depth. Knowing that these upper layers are subject to strong thermal gradients and root extractions. On the other hand, in the simulations of solute transport, we try to describe the evolution of the degree of contamination of a layer after a period of one day as a function of the imposed water flow and the concentration of solute on the surface.

The results obtained by these simulations show that at 20cm depth the solute concentration starts to change only after a period of 4h and that the rate of change of the concentration is almost linear with time for each given water flux. Beyond 4h, the rate of change of the solute at this depth decreases in a non-linear way with the increase of the water flux imposed on the surface. From these first tests, we can say that this model performs water balances in an acceptable way. It has also been proved that the saturation rate of the soil increases with the increase of the imposed flux and of the moisture of this layer. Finally, it was found that the rate of change of the solute at a given depth decreases non-linearly with the imposed water flux at the surface.

How to cite: el moussaoui, E. H., Moumni, A., and Lahrouni, A.: Simulation study of water balance and solute transport in agricultural soil in Haouz region, Morocco, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3201, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3201, 2022.

Mediterranean mountainous regions are strongly affected by flash flood events causing many damages. The vulnerability to flooding in the Moroccan High Atlas, especially in the Tensift basin, has been increasing over the last decades. Rainfall-runoff models can be very useful for flash flood forecasting. However, event-based models require a reduction of their uncertainties related to the estimation of initial moisture conditions before a flood event. Soil moisture may strongly modulate the magnitude of floods and is thus a critical parameter to be considered in flood modeling.

Indeed, several studies have assimilated satellite soil moisture observations into rainfall-runoff models to improve their flood forecasting capabilities.

In order to have a better representation of the watershed states which leads to a better estimation of the streamflow. By exploiting the strong physical connection between soil moisture dynamics and precipitation, it has been shown that satellite soil moisture observations can also be used to improve the quality of precipitation observations.

The aim of this study is to compare daily soil moisture measurements obtained by time domain reflectometry (TDR) at Sidi Rahal station with satellite soil moisture products (European Space Agency Climate Change Initiative, ESA-CCI), in order to estimate the initial soil moisture conditions for each event. The systematic bias between soil moisture products and in situ measurements was corrected using a bias correction method. The correlations between soil moisture products and in situ observations are about 0.77 after the correction.  

However, a modeling approach based on rainfall-runoff observations of 30 sample flood events have been applied, from (2011 to 2018), in the Ghdat basin were extracted and modeled by an event-based rainfall-runoff model (HEC-HMS) which is based on the Soil Conservation Service (SCS-CN), loss model, and a Clark unit hydrograph was developed for simulation and calibration of the 10-minute rainfall runoff.

A similar approach could be implemented in other watersheds in this region for further operational purposes. This method is very satisfactory for reproducing rainfall-runoff events in this small Mediterranean mountainous watershed, the same approach could be implemented in other watersheds in this region. The results of this study indicate that the remote sensing data are theoretically useful for estimating soil moisture conditions in data-sparse watersheds in arid Mediterranean regions.

Keywords: Soil moisture; Floods; Remote sensing; Hydrological modelling, CN method, Mediterranean basin.

How to cite: Benkirane, M., Laftouhi, N.-E., and Khabba, S.: Impact of initial soil moisture on the hydrological response: Application for flood forecasting in the Mediterranean mountainous watershed., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3786, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3786, 2022.

EGU22-3894 | Presentations | HS2.1.1

A comparative study of snowmelt runoff modelling at Rheraya watershed in the Moroccan High Atlas Mountains 

Hafsa Bouamri, Abdelghani Boudhar, and Christophe Kinnard

In the Atlas Mountains range, streamflow is largely generated from meltwater supplied by the snowpack during spring and early summer. In this manner, snow is considered an important factor which determining water availability in semi-arid and arid mountains. This substantial part of freshwater stored in the form of snow contributes significantly to mountainous runoff. However, the contribution of snow and rain to the annual and multi-annual water balance remain largely unknown. Hydrological modeling is needed to support water resource assessment and management in the Atlas range. As meteorological data is often scarce, the models must be able to simulate the spatiotemporal heterogeneity of forcing variables while maintaining a low data input requirement.

In this study, the performance of the snowmelt runoff model (SRM) is assessed to simulate and forecast daily runoff essentially from snowmelt and rainfall at the Rheraya watershed in the Moroccan High Atlas range over the 2010 - 2016 period. The SRM runoff simulation is tested under two forcing inputs: (i) four snowmelt rates previously estimated by a classical temperature-index model (TI) and three enhanced temperature index models that respectively include the potential clear-sky direct radiation (HTI), the incoming solar radiation (ETI-A), and net solar radiation (ETI-B); (ii) calculated snowmelt from the snow cover area (SCA) products of Moderate-Resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer (MODIS).

All SRM simulated runoff were subjected to calibration and validation through the measured runoff in the Tahanaout weather station. The sensibility of recession coefficients was also evaluated. The SRM simulations results over the validation period show an acceptable performance.

Keywords: Runoff, SRM, snowmelt, SCA, temperature index model; enhanced degree-day models, MODIS, semi-arid climate, Rheraya, High Atlas, Morocco.

 

How to cite: Bouamri, H., Boudhar, A., and Kinnard, C.: A comparative study of snowmelt runoff modelling at Rheraya watershed in the Moroccan High Atlas Mountains, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3894, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3894, 2022.

EGU22-3937 | Presentations | HS2.1.1

Estimation of soil moisture within drip irrigation context in pepper fields using ALOS-2 and Sentinel-1 data. 

Emna Ayari, Zeineb Kassouk, Zohra Lili-Chabaane, Nicolas Baghdadi, and Mehrez Zribi

To ensure food security, the irrigation water demand is increasing with the growth of the population. Therefore, the optimization of irrigation scheduling is compulsory to improve water resources management where soil moisture estimation is an essential component. Over the last decades, remote sensing demonstrated its potential to retrieve soil water content. In this work, we investigate the potential of the Synthetic Aperture Radar (SAR) data in L-band acquired by Advanced Land Observing Satellite-2 (ALOS-2) and C-band data acquired by Sentinel-1 sensor, to estimate soil moisture in heterogenous row crop fields locally irrigated with drips in a semi-arid area in the center of Tunisia.

During SAR data acquisitions, ground data gathering campaigns were carried out over irrigated pepper fields. The in-situ measurements included soil surface parameters such as soil roughness and soil moisture, and pepper biophysical parameters such as vegetation height (H), Leaf Area Index (LAI), and cover fraction (Fc) measurements. Based on the pepper field’s organization and ground observations, we calculated an average soil moisture value per field as the sum of 15% of vegetation row soil moisture and 85% bare soil moisture.

In this context, we suggested the modification of the Water Cloud Model (WCM) to simulate the L-band signal in Horizontal-Horizontal polarization (L-HH) and C-band signal in Vertical-Vertical polarization (C-VV). The total backscattering is simulated as the sum of vegetation row cover contribution weighted by Fc and bare soil contribution weighted by (1-Fc). The vegetation row contribution is calculated as the sum of the scattered signal from pepper seedlings described by vegetation height and bare soil part contribution attenuated by vegetation. The bare soil part is considered as the contribution of two parts where the first is irrigated directly by drips and the second separates two successive pepper seedlings relatively far from water emitters namely the non-irrigated part. The bare soil signal simulations are performed using the Integral Equation model modified by Baghdadi (IEM-B).  

After calibration and validation of the modified WCM using three-folds cross-validation, we investigate the potential of the proposed model by various simulations under constant roughness parameters and different conditions of pepper biophysical parameters and bare soil moisture values. The examination of linear slopes between modeled backscattering and soil moisture measurements highlights that model sensitivity decreases as a function of the increase of pepper vegetation parameters (Fc and H). The sensitivity of the modified WCM is limited where Fc and pepper height are less than 0.4 and 0.5 m, respectively, using L-HH data and lower than 0.3 and 0.3 m using C-VV data. The aforementioned findings revealed the potential of the proposed WCM to simulate SAR signal in heterogeneous context of soil moisture.

How to cite: Ayari, E., Kassouk, Z., Lili-Chabaane, Z., Baghdadi, N., and Zribi, M.: Estimation of soil moisture within drip irrigation context in pepper fields using ALOS-2 and Sentinel-1 data., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3937, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3937, 2022.

EGU22-4049 | Presentations | HS2.1.1

Analysis and assessment of meteorological droughts in Morocco using CHIRPS data. 

Kaoutar Oukaddour, Younes Fakir, and Michel Le Page

Droughts can be defined as a climatic phenomenon in which periods of low precipitation may generate water shortages in various parts of the whole of the hydrological cycle. Droughts are natural hazards that usually have severe negative impacts on the economy, society, and environment. Meteorological drought is generally described by the magnitude and duration of the precipitation deficit. Therefore, precipitation is the primary variable often used in the calculation of drought indices, such as the Standardized Precipitation Index (SPI). The SPI is particularly useful for drought monitoring, allowing the identification of different drought types and their impacts on different systems.

Nevertheless, the sparse network of observation stations data-scarce regions, especially in developing countries, is often an obstacle to drought monitoring. To overcome this limitation, remote sensing observations of precipitation are increasingly used over large-scale regions. Climate Hazards Group Infrared Precipitation with Stations (CHIRPS) data are of particular interest. The CHIRPS monthly precipitation product at 0.05° spatial resolution, for the period 1981 to 2020, and the SPI have been used to study the intensity, duration, and spatial extent of meteorological droughts in Morocco at different time-scales (monthly, seasonal, and annual). The use of several time scales allowed us to highlight the spatial occurrence, temporal characteristics, and impacts of drought on different hydrological and agricultural landscapes of Morocco. Based on a threshold level of SPI, drought event statistics (number of events, duration, severity, and magnitude) over 39 years were derived at the watershed scale to highlight regional differences at multiple time scales. The results of this study allow existing water and agricultural strategies to be adapted to different types of drought. The results will also open perspectives for the development of drought monitoring and early warning systems in Morocco and over Africa.

How to cite: Oukaddour, K., Fakir, Y., and Le Page, M.: Analysis and assessment of meteorological droughts in Morocco using CHIRPS data., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4049, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4049, 2022.

EGU22-4125 | Presentations | HS2.1.1

Total phosphorus removal in multi-soil-layering nature-based technology: assessment of influencing factors and prediction by data driven methods 

Sofyan Sbahi, Naaila Ouazzani, Abdessamed Hejjaj, Abderrahman Lahrouni, and Laila Mandi

Excess phosphorus (P) in wastewater can produce eutrophication, posing a serious risk to the safety of water resources and ecosystems. Therefore, effective pollutant removal including P from wastewater is the key strategy to save the environment and public health. Multi-soil-layering (MSL) is a promising nature-based technology that mainly relies on a soil mixture containing iron to remove P-pollution from wastewater. Fifteen water quality parameters were monitored in the MSL influent to determine which ones have the strongest relationship with total phosphorus (TP) removal. The influence of hydraulic loading rate (HLR) and climatic variables on the removal of TP was investigated. Three data-driven methods including multiple linear regression (MLR), k-nearest neighbors (KNN), and random forest (RF) were conducted to predict TP removal at the MSL system outlet. In contrast to climatic variables, the results reveal that the HLR has a significant impact (p <0.05) on TP removal (47%-90%) in the MSL system. Furthermore, using a feature selection technique, the HLR, pH, orthophosphate, and TP were suggested as the relevant input variables affecting TP removal in the MSL system, while an examination of accuracy shows that the RF model achieves good prediction accuracy (R2 = 0.94).

How to cite: Sbahi, S., Ouazzani, N., Hejjaj, A., Lahrouni, A., and Mandi, L.: Total phosphorus removal in multi-soil-layering nature-based technology: assessment of influencing factors and prediction by data driven methods, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4125, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4125, 2022.

EGU22-4151 | Presentations | HS2.1.1

Diurnal and seasonal behavior observed by C-band radar measurements at high temporal frequencies over an olive orchard in a Mediterranean region 

Adnane Chakir, Pierre-Louis Frison, Said Khabba, Ludovic Villard, Nadia Ouaadi, Mehrez Zribi, Valerie Le-dantec, Jamal Ezzahar, Salah Erraki, and Lionel Jarlan

This work deals with crop monitoring in a semi-arid environment, the Mediterranean region, where up to 80-90% of already over-exploited water resources are used for irrigation. To help sustainable use of water resources in agriculture, more efforts have to be made to water use through a better assessment of crop water stress, evapotranspiration, and soil moisture at the plot scale on large areas.

This study is focused on the diurnal and seasonal variation of the backscatter coefficient and the interferometric coherence over an olive orchard, located in the Chichaoua region (central Morocco), that has an area of 2.4ha, irrigated by drip system, with olives trees of 20-years-old. The study site was equipped, since May-2019, with a radar device consisting of 7 C-band horn-antennas at the top of a 20m-high-tower, that collects measurements at 4-polarizations allowing radar acquisitions in high temporal frequency with a timestep of 15min.  An Eddy-covariance system has been also installed for measuring energy balance and the physiological functioning of olives trees with sapflow and dendrometer sensors on olives trunks. The study site is visible at the intersection of three different sentinel-1 orbit passes allowing to have six acquisitions every 10days to compare them with in-situ radar measurements at different incidence angles.

Both the backscattering coefficient s0  and the interferometric coherences are analyzed. At a seasonal scale, all s0  polarizations show a low temporal frequency profile with amplitude lower than 3dB. For VV-polarization, in 2021, it is quite constant, with a slight decrease of 1 dB during the summer, while for 2020, an increase of 2dB is observed at the end of the spring. At HV-polarization no particular seasonal behavior can be seen. On the contrary, a marked diurnal profile is observed at VV-polarization, which is closely correlated with plant activity, with daily amplitude varying between 3dB in winter to 5dB in summer. The diurnal s0  signature is low during night, increases from 6AM, reaches its maximum during 2 to 6PM, and then decreases to recover its low value around midnight.

Concerning the interferometric coherence r, similar behavior to the one observed over tropical forest is noted. The r daily evolution shows a clear diurnal cycle, with amplitude varying between 0.3 in winter to 0.7 in summer. During this latter, r is high (~0.9) at night when the wind and vegetation activity are low, and begins to decrease at 7AM, with vegetation activity start, before the wind picks up at 8AM, reaching minimum value at 7PM (~0,4). It then follows a rapid increase to reach its maximum value (0.9) at midnight. A high sensitivity to rainy events is also noted, corresponding to very low r values. It is worth noticing than r estimated between measurements separated by 6 days, show similar diurnal profiles, with r lower amplitude (0.2 to 0.4), suggesting it can be characterized by Sentinel-1 morning and evening observations. Additional work as to be carried on to relate this radar diurnal cycle to water cycle, that would be good omen to monitor water stress from spaceborne C-band radar sensors.

How to cite: Chakir, A., Frison, P.-L., Khabba, S., Villard, L., Ouaadi, N., Zribi, M., Le-dantec, V., Ezzahar, J., Erraki, S., and Jarlan, L.: Diurnal and seasonal behavior observed by C-band radar measurements at high temporal frequencies over an olive orchard in a Mediterranean region, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4151, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4151, 2022.

EGU22-4725 | Presentations | HS2.1.1

Sustainability issues of a Mediterranean semiarid irrigated piedmont inferred frommulti-decadal trends of water resources and land use 

Youness Ouassanouan, Younes Fakir, Vincent Simonneaux, Mohamed Hakim Kharrou, Houssne Bouimouass, and Abdelghani Chehbouni

Piedmonts around the Mediterranean are important hydro-agro-systems bridging between the mountains (upstream) where streamflow is generated, and the adjacent plains (downstream) where water is used. In Morocco, the piedmonts of the High-Atlas Mountains host secular irrigation channels (seguia) that divert the streamflow for irrigating a traditional agriculture since hundreds of years. These traditional hydro-agro-systems might be threatened by the effects of global change that requires in-depth study to identify the main causes and propose better sustainable management. The present study was carried out in the semi-arid piedmont of the High-Atlas mountains. A detailed analysis of hydro-climatological data was performed between 1965 and 2018 together with associated agricultural trends over the period 1984-2020. Statistical tests (Mann-Kendall and Pettitt) were used to assess whether there were significant trends or not in the long-term evolution of water resources. The findings revealed a significant decrease of the surface water and groundwater resource. The SPI meteorological drought index delineated three main droughts during 1982-1986, 1998-2008 and 2013-2017. Paradoxically, the scarcity and decrease trends in water resources are associated with an agricultural change from seasonal crops (cereals) to perennial crops (trees). The subsequent growing agricultural water demand exacerbates the water shortage and worsen the groundwater depletion.

How to cite: Ouassanouan, Y., Fakir, Y., Simonneaux, V., Kharrou, M. H., Bouimouass, H., and Chehbouni, A.: Sustainability issues of a Mediterranean semiarid irrigated piedmont inferred frommulti-decadal trends of water resources and land use, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4725, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4725, 2022.

EGU22-5330 | Presentations | HS2.1.1

Unraveling the Origin of Rainfall over Horn of Africa Drylands 

Akash Koppa, Jessica Keune, David A. MacLeod, Michael Singer, and Diego G. Miralles

The Horn of Africa drylands (HAD) are highly vulnerable to hydroclimatic extremes, with droughts and floods frequently leading to famines, crop losses, and significant humanitarian crises. However, development of robust mitigation measures has been hindered by the lack of understanding of the drivers of the two main rainfall seasons in the region: the long (March–May) and short (October–December) rains. In particular, the inter-annual variability of the long rains has been subject of much debate; a significant amount of research has attempted to diagnose the drivers of the observed decline in the long rains. Given the ecological and socio-economic importance of the two rain seasons for the HAD region, understanding the major moisture sources and their variability in both space and time is essential. Such an analysis can help disentangle the causes of temporal variability in rainfall, especially the long rains, improve forecasts, and build ecosystem and community resilience against hydroclimatic extremes.

To trace the origin of rainfall over the HAD region, we use global simulations of the FLEXPART version 9.01, forced with the ERA-Interim reanalysis for a period of 37 years (1980–2016). The FLEXPART outputs include the properties of the air parcels at 3-hourly time steps, which are then post-processed to identify the source regions of rainfall using the Heat and Moisture Tracking Framework (HAMSTER v1.2.0) described by Keune et al. (2021). Using this framework, we first trace the rainfall occurring over the HAD region during the long and short rain seasons to their terrestrial and oceanic sources spatially. Then, we track the changes in the contributions of ocean and land evaporation to HAD rainfall in time over the 37-year period. 

Preliminary results show that around 80% of HAD rainfall originates from Indian Ocean evaporation, for both seasons. For both seasons the contribution of evaporation from land is relatively low compared to the oceanic contribution. For the long rains, a similar amount of moisture originates from recycling (local) and remote sources (10.9% and 10.5% respectively). On the other hand the short rains show a larger proportion of local recycling (13.8%) relative to remote land evaporation (9.4%). The larger contribution of remote land sources for the long rains arises from the Indian subcontinent and Southeast Asia. Further, we shed light on the trends and anomalies in source regions for the two rain seasons, with particular focus on the anomalies in moisture sources that are characteristic of extreme dry and wet conditions.

References:

Keune, J., Schumacher, D. L., and Miralles, D. G.: A holistic framework to estimate the origins of atmospheric moisture and heat using a Lagrangian model, Geosci. Model Dev. Discuss. [preprint], in review, 2021.

How to cite: Koppa, A., Keune, J., MacLeod, D. A., Singer, M., and Miralles, D. G.: Unraveling the Origin of Rainfall over Horn of Africa Drylands, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5330, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5330, 2022.

EGU22-8060 | Presentations | HS2.1.1

Irrigation mapping using Sentinel-1 and Sentinel-2 data 

Mehrez Zribi, Michel Le page, Lionel Jarlan, Nicolas Baghdadi, Luca Brocca, Sara Modanesi, Jacopo Dari, Pere Quintana Segui, and Ehsan Elwan

Water resource management is a key issue in climate change conditions, considering the increasing number of drought events, as well as the increase in water use for irrigation in Mediterranean region. In this context, different decision tools have been developed to optimize water use for irrigation. One crucial question for managers is the precise identification of irrigated areas. Remote sensing has shown great potential for irrigation mapping. This study aims to propose an operational approach to map irrigated areas based on the synergy of Sentinel-1 and Sentinel-2 data. An application is proposed at two study sites in Mediterranean region, in Spain and in Italy, with two climatic contexts, semiarid and humid respectively. Several classifiers are proposed to separate irrigated and rainfed areas. They are based on statistical variables from Sentinel-1 and Sentinel-2 time series data at the agricultural field scale, as well as on the contrasted behavior between the field scale and the 5-km surroundings. Support Vector Machine (SVM) classification approach is tested with different options to evaluate the robustness of the proposed methodologies. The optimal number of metrics found is five. The highest accuracy of the classifications, approximately equal to 85%, is based on training dataset with mixed reference fields from the two study sites. In addition, the accuracy is consistent at the two study sites.

How to cite: Zribi, M., Le page, M., Jarlan, L., Baghdadi, N., Brocca, L., Modanesi, S., Dari, J., Quintana Segui, P., and Elwan, E.: Irrigation mapping using Sentinel-1 and Sentinel-2 data, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8060, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8060, 2022.

EGU22-8677 | Presentations | HS2.1.1

Recent changes in the probability of agrometeorological risks over the southern Mediterranean region, and potential impacts on crop growth 

Behnam Mirgol, Bastien Dieppois, Jessica Northey, Jonathan Eden, Lionel Jarlan, Yves Tramblay, and Gil Mahé

Climate change, as one of the most significant challenges that humans currently face, is defined as a shift in climate patterns in response to increasing greenhouse gas emissions in the atmosphere. Notably, climate change has been associated with global warming temperature, regional changes in rainfall patterns and extreme events. Such changes in climate are emerging at a time of rapid growth for many economies in the southern Mediterranean region, stressing the need to understand their impacts on sectors better. In addition, unlike other regions, very little research has been undertaken to understand how climate has changed (and will change) over the area and how such changes may affect the agricultural sector. Here, using trend analysis and the non-stationary generalized extreme value (GEV) model, we examine whether the probability of extreme agrometeorological risks has changed over the last 60 years in response to the globally warming temperature. We then quantify the magnitude of such changes over different phenological stages for wheat, maize and rice, highlighting the most vulnerable areas to extreme conditions in the southern Mediterranean region. Extreme agrometeorological risks are estimated using multiple state-of-the-art observational and reanalyzed daily datasets (REGEN, BERKELEY, CHIRPS, ERA5 and ERA5-land), and using multiple drought indices (standardized precipitation-evapotranspiration index [SPEI], standardized antecedent precipitation-evapotranspiration index [SAPEI], frequency and duration of dry spells) and heat stress indices (wet-bulb globe temperature [WBGT], effective temperature, discomfort index, heat index, frequency and duration of hot and cold spells). As such, this study, identifying areas in which crop growth and productivity are becoming particularly threatened by the increasing frequency and duration of extremes, provides vital evidence for climate change adaptation and mitigation plans in the southern Mediterranean region. 

How to cite: Mirgol, B., Dieppois, B., Northey, J., Eden, J., Jarlan, L., Tramblay, Y., and Mahé, G.: Recent changes in the probability of agrometeorological risks over the southern Mediterranean region, and potential impacts on crop growth, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8677, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8677, 2022.

EGU22-8680 | Presentations | HS2.1.1

Developing an operational impact-based flood forecasting system for the Greater Horn of Africa region 

Lorenzo Alfieri, Andrea Libertino, Lorenzo Campo, Tatiana Ghizzoni, Alessandro Masoero, Chiara Menchise, Maria Laura Poletti, Simone Gabellani, Lauro Rossi, Roberto Rudari, Luca Rossi, Katarina Mouakkid Soltesova, Kai Gatkuoth, Jully Ouma, Ahmed Amdihun, Godefroid Nshimirimana, Yves Tramblay, and Marco Massabò

Every year Africa is affected by extreme weather related hazards which, combined with high levels of vulnerability and increasing population exposure, result in considerable impacts to people and assets. Here we present recent activities in the development of an African Multi Hazard Early Warning System for disaster risk reduction, a multi-year project funded by the Italian Government through the United Nations Office for Disaster Risk Reduction. After a brief introduction on the main project goals, the presentation will give insights on one of its key activities, focused on strengthening impact-based flood monitoring and forecasting capabilities for the Greater Horn of Africa region. This ongoing activity foresees the implementation of a probabilistic impact-based flood forecasting system based on the Flood PRObabilistic Operative Forecasting System (Flood-PROOFS) developed by CIMA Foundation and run routinely in several world regions. Flood-PROOFS has as its core the Continuum distributed hydrological model, which takes as input meteorological variables and several other static and dynamic data to simulate the hydrological processes in the focus region. For this application, Continuum was set up at hourly time step on 17 hydrologically consistent domains, with grid resolutions ranging between 250m and 3.3km, ultimately covering a surface of 6.82 million km2. Given the relative scarcity of in situ data, model calibration is based on observed river discharges at 130+ river gauging stations, as well as on GLEAM satellite evaporation and soil moisture products. A 40-year continuous hydrological reanalysis is produced by forcing the model with ERA5 atmospheric reanalysis bias corrected for precipitation and temperature. Daily runs include model updates with satellite precipitation estimates and 5-day forecasts forced by the Global Forecast System. Ongoing activities are expanding the current deterministic setup to ensemble forecasts, as well as coupling hydrological forecasts in real time with state of the art global inundation maps, to estimate impact-based flood warnings by integrating information on exposure, vulnerability and coping capacity. Such information is used in the operational monitoring and early preparedness versus impending disasters, as well as to design prevention and mitigation measures, which is fundamental to prioritize and optimize the use of available resources for disaster response.

How to cite: Alfieri, L., Libertino, A., Campo, L., Ghizzoni, T., Masoero, A., Menchise, C., Poletti, M. L., Gabellani, S., Rossi, L., Rudari, R., Rossi, L., Mouakkid Soltesova, K., Gatkuoth, K., Ouma, J., Amdihun, A., Nshimirimana, G., Tramblay, Y., and Massabò, M.: Developing an operational impact-based flood forecasting system for the Greater Horn of Africa region, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8680, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8680, 2022.

Global food security is based on a limited number of species mainly cereals, maize and rice.                                    
In semi-arid region, the availability of cereals on the international market at competitive prices in relation to local production has led to a change in domestic demand in these countries and has affected the capacity of populations to cover their basic food needs. An operational early grain yield prediction system has been needed to assist policy makers in making initial assessments and planning for annual grain imports. In this context, the main objective of this study is to develop a method for the early estimation of grain and grain straw yields based on high spatial resolution optical satellite data and radar data. Thus, we used two lines of research: the first is based on analysing the relationship between vegetation index and the VH/VV ratio with cereals yields measured in situ. The second axis is based on the estimation of the cereal yields based on a combined index. This last is a combination of the radar index VH/VV and an optical index.

For the first axe, a 22 Sentinel-2 and 55 Sentinel-1 images acquired between 01/09/2017 and 31/08/2018 are used. From the optical data, three spectral indices (NDVI, EVI and EVI2) are calculated and from the Radar data, we calculated the VH/VV polarization ratio. At the same time, we realized experimental measurements made on 54 test plots of dry or irrigated cereals carried out in study area during the 2017-2018 agriculture year. The first approach based on a statistical analysis between the NDVI, EVI and EVI2 vegetation indices and the yields measured showed that NDVI is the best optical index allowing an estimate of grain yield from mid-March with a correlation coefficient R2 = 69.22% for the average weight of the grains and R2 = 72.38% for the average weight of the straw. Validation of estimates obtained by remote sensing shows that this approach is robust, with an error of 1.79qx/ha and 1.21 qx/ha, respectively, for seed and straw yields. The evolution of yields as a function of the VH/VV ratio was then studied for different dates. The analysis allows that an early estimate can be made the 10th of March based on this ratio with a correlation coefficient R2 = 53.79% for the average weight of the seeds and R2 = 56% for the average weight of the straw.

For the second axe, a combined index was developed based on the combination of the radar index VH/VV and the optical index. The results show that the most suitable combination is the one between the Radar Index and the NDVI where correlations R2 = 63.64% for the average seed weight and R2 = 64.03% for the average straw weight. The validation of the estimates obtained by this combined index is made with an error equal to 1.97 qx/ha and 1.31 qx/ha, respectively for the seed and straw yields.

How to cite: Chahbi, A., Zribi, M., Shil, E., and Lili-Chabaane, Z.: Characterization of cereals in a semi-arid context based on remote sensing indicators from high spatial resolution images from the Sentinel 1 and Sentinel 2 satellite in central Tunisia, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9150, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9150, 2022.

EGU22-10231 | Presentations | HS2.1.1

A comparison of different NDVI based methods for grapevines Kcb 

Benoit Huet, Michel Le Page, David Tous, Pascal Fanise, Sylvie Duthoit, and Joaquim Bellvert

The basal crop coefficient (Kcb) is the ratio of crop evapotranspiration that primarily corresponds to transpiration. A comparison of different approaches using remote sensing observations for the estimation of Kcb of grapevines is carried out. The study is done over a cv.Tempranillo vineyard located in Catalunya, Spain from March to July 2021.

The different approaches tested are the following: 1- a linear relation between NDVI and Kcb(Campos et al., 2010), 2 and 3 - the two different approaches proposed in (Allen and Pereira, 2009), where Kcb is estimated thanks to a density factor. The first version lies on an exponential of Leaf Area Index (LAI), the second version lies on the tree height and the fraction of effective exposed area. 4 and 5- an intercepted photosynthetic radiation (fiPAR) model (Oyarzun et al., 2007) using inferred crop height and width is related to Kcb through the (Lebon et al., 2003) and (Picón-Toro et al., 2012) proposals. 6- The generic tabulated approach proposed by (Allen et al., 1998) is also used to compare to a reference, however it must be remembered that those tabulations are only indicative.

The different approaches are compared to the actual Kcb retrieved from a flux tower and the reference evapotranspiration of a nearby weather station. The resulting Kcb are injected into a water budget and daily evapotranspirations are finally compared to actual measurements.

The simple linear method did not transfer well on this particular vineyard. The "Allen& Pereira LAI" and the "Oyarzun/Picon" had the best performance with a respective r2, RMSE of 0.57, 0.60 and 0.54 0.62 mm.day-1 on evapotranspiration estimates. However, the former approach through LAI does not seem really operational. The later method only needs to be parameterized with some easy to retrieve descriptions of the plot and plantation. In any case, a drawback of these NDVI based methods is the possible appearance of adventices, or the presence of a inter-row crop. Those must be withdrawn from the NDVI signal of the grapevine.

How to cite: Huet, B., Le Page, M., Tous, D., Fanise, P., Duthoit, S., and Bellvert, J.: A comparison of different NDVI based methods for grapevines Kcb, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10231, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10231, 2022.

EGU22-10349 | Presentations | HS2.1.1

Presentation of a high-resolution present-day joint atmosphere-land surface-hydrology simulation dataset for South Africa 

Zhenyu Zhang, Patrick Laux, Joel Arnault, Jussi Baade, Marcel Urban, Christiane Schmullius, and Harald Kunstmann

Due to the high variability of climate variables under climate change, the assessment of the climate impacts on water management, ecosystems restoration, as well as climate change adaptation requires very detailed climate information regionally and ideally at a local scale. State-of-the-art coupled land-atmosphere numerical models incorporate the water and energy exchange processes in the soil–vegetation–atmosphere continuum in a physically consistent way, thereby their simulations capture the complete evolution of state variables and provide the complex linkages across compartmental boundaries in the Earth system. As an effort to contribute to climate- and water-related research in South Africa, we present a high spatial and temporal resolution climatological atmosphere–land surface–hydrology analysis dataset covering the period 2000-2020. This analysis dataset is dynamically downscaled from ERA5 reanalysis using the Weather Research and Forecasting Model Hydrological modeling system (WRF-Hydro). This dataset covers the territory of South Africa with a grid resolution of 4 km and a time interval of 1 hour.

As a result, a comprehensive analysis dataset is provided, including the land surface and atmosphere state conditions, as well as the water flux components for the joint atmospheric-terrestrial water balance. The model performance is evaluated based on in-situ measurement records and remote sensing results. For instance, we evaluate the soil moisture and soil temperature using continuous in-situ measurement over six South Africa locations following a climate gradient, and the spatiotemporal trends of soil moisture are further evaluated using a newly developed radar-retrieved Surface Moisture Index (SurfMI). Biases of simulation results have been identified that should be taken into account in any application.

How to cite: Zhang, Z., Laux, P., Arnault, J., Baade, J., Urban, M., Schmullius, C., and Kunstmann, H.: Presentation of a high-resolution present-day joint atmosphere-land surface-hydrology simulation dataset for South Africa, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10349, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10349, 2022.

EGU22-10577 | Presentations | HS2.1.1

Links between land cover change and climate in the Horn of Africa 

Md Abdul Muktadir, Akash Koppa, Jeroen Claessen, David A MacLeod, Michael Singer, and Diego G. Miralles

Land use and land cover change significantly influence regional energy budgets, and hydrological and biogeochemical cycles which may occur from both anthropogenic and natural disturbances. Likewise, vegetation may also respond dynamically to climate. In the past decades, the Horn of Africa has been hit by several droughts and heatwaves causing severe economic, environmental, and social damage. To evaluate and mitigate such impacts, it is necessary to establish and quantify the linkage between land cover change and regional climate. This study presents an observational analysis of recent (2001–2019) historical changes in land cover and land use and their relation to climate in the Horn of Africa. 

Firstly, we evaluate changes in land cover using the Moderate Resolution Imaging Spectrometer (MODIS) dataset. Results indicate steady expansion of grasslands (net gain is 1.2% of total area) and an opposite pattern for open shrublands during the period 2001–2016. Importantly, deforestation of evergreen broadleaf forest (0.3% of the total area) is also noticeable in continuous fractional vegetation cover (FVC) analysis. Next, the Global Database of Historical Yields (GDHY) is explored to identify the yield trends for two main cereals: maize and wheat.  Wheat yield shows increasing trends in the northern and southern parts, while maize yields increase in Ethiopia and mildly decrease in Kenya. To quantify the adverse impact of drought on yields, three drought indices are used: (a) Standardized Precipitation Evapotranspiration Index (SPEI), (b) self-calibrating Palmer Drought Severity Index (scPDSI), and (c) Standard Evapotranspiration Deficit Index (SEDI). The analysis identifies SPEI12 as arguably the best performing drought index for monitoring and forecasting impacts on yields in this region. 

Finally, a Conditional Spectral Granger Causality (CSGC) algorithm is employed for understanding the influence of climate variability on vegetation dynamics. Although the influence of climatic factors (i.e., precipitation, temperature, and solar energy radiation) on vegetation dynamics is heterogeneous, given the wide spectrum of climate regimes in the region, an overall increased influence of temperature on vegetation dynamics is revealed. In conclusion, the observational evidence indicates that climate plays an important role as a driver of both crop and natural vegetation change in the Horn of Africa. 

How to cite: Muktadir, M. A., Koppa, A., Claessen, J., MacLeod, D. A., Singer, M., and Miralles, D. G.: Links between land cover change and climate in the Horn of Africa, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10577, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10577, 2022.

EGU22-11403 | Presentations | HS2.1.1

Quantifying the importance of vegetation in water fluxes partitioning over Mediterranean mountain areas: a study case in Cardeña-Montoro Natural Park (Spain) 

Ana Andreu, Rafael Pimentel, Pedro Torralbo, Javier Aparicio, María P. González-Dugo, and María José Polo

Mediterranean mountain areas are hotspots when evaluating vulnerability towards global warming. Future hydro-climatic scenarios present a probable situation of high alteration of these systems, mainly conditioned by an increase of extreme events frequency (e.g., heatwaves and droughts). Dehesas are one of these characteristic landscapes. They result from the co-evolution of autochthonous ecosystems and human settlement in a sustainable balance, with high relevance from the environmental (biodiversity) and socioeconomic (livestock farming, including the Iberian pork food industry) view. They have a complex vegetation cover structure formed by isolated trees, mainly holm oak, cork oak, and oak, Mediterranean shrubs, and pastures, with specific phenological cycles. This complexity conditions the partitioning of water fluxes, shifting their importance along the year. 

This work proposes to quantify the actual role of the vegetation in the water fluxes partitioning over mountain Mediterranean areas. Specifically, this study is conducted in the Martin Gonzalo watershed upstream of the Martin Gonzalo dam, located within the Cardeña-Montoro Natural Park (southern Spain). The vegetation role is assessed by comparing three different hydrological model simulations conducted using the distributed and physically-based hydrological model WiMMed (Watershed Integrated Model for Mediterranean Areas): i) non-vegetation, in which no vegetation is included in the modelling; ii) static vegetation, in which vegetation is defined in the model using the official land cover maps from the regional authorities; and iii) dynamical vegetation, in which vegetation information is provided by a dynamical spectral mixture analysis using Sentinel-2. All water fluxes in the water balance are quantified and compared between the three simulations. Results highlight, on the one hand, the key role of vegetation in controlling water partitioning and, on the other hand, the importance of considering the yearly phenological changes to model water partitioning accurately.  

 

 

This work has been funded by project SIERRA Seguimiento hIdrológico de la vEgetación en montaña mediteRránea mediante fusión de sensores Remotos en Andalucía, with the economic collaboration of the European Funding for Rural Development (FEDER) and the Office for Economy, Knowledge, Enterprises and University of the Andalusian Regional Government.

How to cite: Andreu, A., Pimentel, R., Torralbo, P., Aparicio, J., González-Dugo, M. P., and Polo, M. J.: Quantifying the importance of vegetation in water fluxes partitioning over Mediterranean mountain areas: a study case in Cardeña-Montoro Natural Park (Spain), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11403, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11403, 2022.

EGU22-11918 | Presentations | HS2.1.1

Climate change impact on water resources and forest sustainability of two Sardinian basins 

Serena Sirigu, Roberto Corona, and Nicola Montaldo

Over the past century, climate change has been affecting precipitation regimes across the world (Giorgi et al., 2008). In the Mediterranean regions, there is a persistent declining trend of precipitation and runoff decreases (Martinez-Fernandez et al.2013), contributing to a desertification process with dramatic consequences for agricultural and water resources sustainability.

The position of the island of Sardinia, in the center of the western Mediterranean basin, with its low level of both urbanization and human activity, its complex orography with many mountains and alluvial valleys, and its strong correlation with North Atlantic Oscillation index makes Sardinia a primary reference for the investigation of climate change effects on Mediterranean ecosystems.

Two contrasting basins are investigated, the Rio Fluminimaggiore basin and Rio Flumendosa basin, which are different for position in the island (west side vs. east side), size (83km2 vs. 934  km2) and land covers (Rio Fluminimaggiore is mainly covered by forest while Rio Flumendosa land cover is mixed). These are basin are crucial for the water resources system of Sardinia, because include dams. In particular, two large dams, the Flumendosa Dam at Nuraghe and the Mulargia Dam at Monte Su Rei, are in the Flumendosa basin with a total reservoir of 600 million of cubic meter. Long database of hydrologic data (runoff, precipitation, temperature) are available for both basins from 1925, and in both basins eddy covariance towers are installed in representative field sites.

A distributed hydrological model at basin scale has been developed, which predicts runoff, soil water storage, evapotranspiration and grass and tree leaf area index (LAI). The model has been successfully calibrated for runoff estimation. An alarming historical decreasing trend of runoff and winter precipitation has been detected in both basins. We used the future climate scenarios predicted by Global climate models (GCM) in the Fifth Assessment report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). Hydro-meteorological scenarios are generated using a weather stochastic generator that allows simulation of hydrometeorological variables from GCM future scenarios. The use of the model allowed to predict soil water balance and vegetation dynamics for the generated hydrometeorological scenarios. Results demonstrated that tree dynamics are strongly influenced by the inter-annual variability of atmospheric forcing, with tree density changing according to seasonal rainfall. At the same time the tree dynamics affected the soil water balance. We demonstrated that future warmer scenarios will impact forest, which could be not able to adapt to the increasing droughts. The decrease of tree cover will affect water resources of the Sardinian basins. In the Flumendosa basin future scenarios predict a reduction of the runoff, which is crucial for the dam reservoir recharge. The water resources system planning needs to carefully takes into account the effect of future climate change on water resources and vegetation dynamics.

How to cite: Sirigu, S., Corona, R., and Montaldo, N.: Climate change impact on water resources and forest sustainability of two Sardinian basins, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11918, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11918, 2022.

To feed the growing population, achieve the Sustainable Development Goals, and fulfil the commitments of the Paris Agreement, West African countries need to invest in agriculture and renewable energy, among other sectors. Irrigated agriculture, feeding millions of people, and hydropower, which generates clean electricity, both depend on the availability of water. We have investigated the extent to which synergies and trade-offs exist between simulated water demand and supply of three planned irrigation sites in the Volta basin and the hydropower potential at four dams using an eco-hydrological model. The impacts in terms of changes in the water balance and availability were attributed to single projects (irrigation site or dam).

We found that without upstream reservoirs, the naturally intermittent flow regime of the Black and White Volta Rivers either limits or makes dry-season irrigation impossible, depending on the location (climate) in the basin. The planned additional irrigated area of 104,000 ha could feed about half a million people but relies on upstream dams transforming the intermittent to a permanent flow regime. Irrigation withdrawals would be at the expense of hydropower potential, which decreased by 139 GWh/a. The 182 GWh/a of the planned Pwalugu dam thus contribute only 24% of its potential. Moreover, our process-based simulations revealed that solely the transformation from intermittent to permanent flow regime caused accumulating transmission losses downstream, which can be substantial.

Simulated future crop water requirements did not increase under climate change projections using an ensemble of 8 bias-adjusted global climate models, because the higher evaporative demand was outbalanced by increasing precipitation.

How to cite: Liersch, S. and Koch, H.: Recent and future developments in the Volta River basin from a Nexus perspective: Synergies and trade-offs between different water uses under climate change, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12416, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12416, 2022.

EGU22-12616 | Presentations | HS2.1.1

The AMMA-CATCH observatory : a platform to address scientific and societal issues in West-Africa 

Jean-Martial Cohard, Manuela Grippa, Emmanuel Lawin, Christophe Peugeot, Bil Assanou, Marie Boucher, Véronique Chaffard, Mamadou Diawara, Jordi Etchanchu, Gayane Faye, Sylvie Galle, Ibrahim Mainassara, Moussa Malam-Abdou, Ossenatou Mamadou, Armand Mariscal, Eric Mougin, Soumaïla Moumouni, Geremy Panthou, and Thierry Lebel

West Africa is undergoing a drastic transition in climate, demography and land use. This has a strong impact on the development capacities of every country in the region. While regional trends in each of these three key areas are relatively well known, decision makers scientists are often lacking a proper vision of how climate and land use are evolving at spatial and temporal scales that count most for the living of populations. Moreover, the hydrological implications of these climate and land use evolutions are hardly documented, while models have still difficulties in reproducing them. It is therefore of utmost importance to rely on combined observation-modeling strategies to better apprehend the ongoing transition and explore possible future trajectories in terms of water resources, hydrological risks and food security. To that end, the regional long-term observatory AMMA-CATCH aims at monitoring the impacts of global changes on the continental water cycle and the functioning of the critical zone in West Africa, through a combination of mesoscale observations, data analyses and local to regional modeling. Three main issues are currently guiding our observation strategy: (1) Multi-decadal trends of hydro-climatic hazards (past, current and projected); (2) Dynamics of vegetation, land use and their interactions with the water cycle; (3) Trajectories of water resources. This strategy is supported by metrology, technology watch and innovation. The AMMA-CATCH observatory has been collecting data since 1990 on four highly instrumented sites (each of the roughly covering 10000 to 20000 km²), staggered from North to South of West Africa, in order to measure the latitudinal gradient in different eco-climatic zones (Benin, Niger, Mali), and since 2016, from complementary sites in Senegal and Niger, to assess the longitudinal variability in the Sahelian area. It is part of the OZCAR French Critical Zone observatory network and supported by French research institutions with long term engagement.

This presentation aims at highlighting recent results obtained by analyzing the data of the AMMA-CATCH observatory covering a large range of hydrology/land use related issues, such as tipping points in hydrology, rainfall intensification, infrastructure design norms, soil restoration, local and regional hyper-resolution hydrological modeling, …. This presentation also aims at encouraging a African-European structuration of socio-hydro-climate observations in this region in order to provide a strong science-based foundation for the elaboration of adaptation policies.

How to cite: Cohard, J.-M., Grippa, M., Lawin, E., Peugeot, C., Assanou, B., Boucher, M., Chaffard, V., Diawara, M., Etchanchu, J., Faye, G., Galle, S., Mainassara, I., Malam-Abdou, M., Mamadou, O., Mariscal, A., Mougin, E., Moumouni, S., Panthou, G., and Lebel, T.: The AMMA-CATCH observatory : a platform to address scientific and societal issues in West-Africa, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12616, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12616, 2022.

EGU22-12963 | Presentations | HS2.1.1

Assessing annual and seasonal changes in the free-water reservoir surface state and turbidity conditions: implications for dam management in the Guadalquivir River Basin (Spain) 

Eva Contreras Arribas, Rafael Pimentel, Cristina Aguilar, Javier Aparicio, and María José Polo

In Mediterranean areas the high seasonal and annual variability in precipitation produces large changes in the reservoir water availability. However, the state of these water bodies is not only subjected to the weather and the natural hydrology of this kind of system, but is often modified on one hand by the water demands and on the other hand, by the land uses upstream which have serious effects on the water quality of the river contributions. Remote sensing and GIS methods are currently emerging as an alternative to traditional methods like field survey (usually laborious, time consuming and expensive) to analyse the evolution of the state of these water bodies in terms of the free-water reservoir surface.

In this paper, the Guadalquivir River Basin (southwest Spain), where the gradual and intense development of large irrigated areas (which has increased in the last 50 years by more than 50%) leads to an increase in the storage capacity in the basin (which doubles during the next 40 years), was taken as a research object. The Global Surface Water (GSWE) online machine, combined with historical, hydrological, meteorological and water quality data, were used to spatially quantify free-water reservoir surface during the period 1984-2020. This allowed us, through a water balance approach on a monthly basis, the estimation of water inputs and outputs to analyse the hydrological changes in terms of seasonality, but also considering the effects of the dam operations and the changes in water quality in terms of sediments loads in those reservoirs where turbidity data series are available. 

The results show the increase of the free-water reservoir surface along the study period, which is consistent with the dramatic decrease of the contribution of the water flowing into the last receiver of the network of reservoirs (Alcalá del Río dam). This also implies the storage of associated substances such as sediments (mainly from the extensive olive groves areas located upstream) that produce the filling of the reservoirs, and turbidity episodes in flood events, which was verified with field measurements in the main control points of the basin.

This work has been funded by the project Integrated Management for the control of water inputs and sediments in reservoir systems in the Guadalquivir basin, with the economic collaboration of the European Funding for Rural Development (FEDER) and the Office for Economy, Knowledge, Enterprises and University of the Andalusian Regional Government.

How to cite: Contreras Arribas, E., Pimentel, R., Aguilar, C., Aparicio, J., and Polo, M. J.: Assessing annual and seasonal changes in the free-water reservoir surface state and turbidity conditions: implications for dam management in the Guadalquivir River Basin (Spain), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12963, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12963, 2022.

EGU22-13351 | Presentations | HS2.1.1

Using SWAT model to evaluate the plausible changes in a karst snow-fed watershed in the Moroccan High Atlas 

Soufiane Taia, Lamia Erraioui, Jamal Chao, Andrea Scozzari, and Bouabid El Mansouri

High Atlas is considered as one of the major reservoirs of freshwater for crop yield and hydropower production in the plains of central Morocco. Nevertheless, snowmelt and discharge in this region have been reported very vulnerable to climate variability, which threaten the sustainability and development of socio-economic activities in this region. Thus, there’s a strong need to understand the spatio-temporal variability of water cycle in addition to the impact of the changing climate on the main hydrological components.  This work focuses on the application of SWAT model in the mountainous watershed of Oued Al Abid river, which is potentially threatened by climate and anthropogenic forcings. The study is based on two main axes: (i) the implementation of SWAT to model the snowmelt discharge processes over this watershed taking into consideration the karst structure of this area, (ii) the projection of climate change has been also analyzed by forcing SWAT model using three simulations of Regional Climate Model RCA4. Results showed that SWAT model performed satisfactory to very good in reproducing discharge and reservoir inflow. According to the results, the hydrological components showed a significant variability, particularly in snowmelt, infiltration and surface runoff. Furthermore, negative variation and peak shift in the projected inflows to the dam have been demonstrated by this study.

How to cite: Taia, S., Erraioui, L., Chao, J., Scozzari, A., and El Mansouri, B.: Using SWAT model to evaluate the plausible changes in a karst snow-fed watershed in the Moroccan High Atlas, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13351, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13351, 2022.

EGU22-13496 | Presentations | HS2.1.1

Evapotranspiration components of pine (Pinus brutia) trees in a Mediterranean ecosystem 

Mohsen Amini, Hakan Djuma, Ioannis Sofokleous, Marinos Eliades, and Adriana Bruggeman

One of the most deterministic aspects of water consumption in Mediterranean ecosystems is
evapotranspiration, which accounts for returning a large fraction of precipitation into the atmosphere.
Pine trees as an indigenous species play an important role in the soil water balance in these ecosystems.
The main objective of this study is to simulate the contribution of evapotranspiration components of pine
(Pinus brutia) in the water balance. The research includes a comprehensive sensitivity analysis and model
calibration. The field study is located in Athalassa Forest Park in Cyprus. The 10-ha field is covered by a
combination of seasonal vegetation and indigenous trees and shrubs, with a 5 to 6-m planting distance.
The site is relatively flat with a mean slope of 4% and an average annual rainfall of 315 mm.
Pine tree evapotranspiration components were modeled using a one-dimensional NOAH-MP land surface
model (one grid cell). Due to incomplete knowledge about the extent of the tree roots (root zone area),
we modeled the grid cell in three different scenarios according to tree density (the distance between
trunks, 5-6 m), tree canopy area (7.5 m2 on average), and leaf area index (LAI = 2.5 on average) to
represent our field study in the model. We analyzed the sensitivity of all modeled water balance
components, namely, evapotranspiration (evaporation from bare soil, transpiration, and evaporation
from the canopy), runoff (surface and subsurface runoff), soil moisture change of the soil column to all
related soil and vegetation input parameters, using a local sensitivity analysis. We also examined the
impact of the number of soil layers with roots, different soil layers thicknesses, and the slope of the area
on the model outputs (water balance components). The results showed that NOAH-MP is capable of 
representing a semi-arid Mediterranean ecosystem.


This research has received financial support from the PRIMA MED (2018 Call) SWATCH Project and the
Water JPI (Joint Call 2018) FLUXMED Project, both funded through the Cyprus Research and Innovation
Foundation.

How to cite: Amini, M., Djuma, H., Sofokleous, I., Eliades, M., and Bruggeman, A.: Evapotranspiration components of pine (Pinus brutia) trees in a Mediterranean ecosystem, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13496, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13496, 2022.

EGU22-1842 | Presentations | HS2.1.3

Understanding land cover influence on water resources in south-central Chile: A hydrological modelling with baseflow recession analysis approach 

Francisco Balocchi, José Luis Arumi, Diego Rivera, and Andrés Iroumé

Land cover change and its effect on water resources has been a continuous concern in south-central Chile. In this regard, we use two methodologies to study the effect of different land covers on the hydrological processes in several experimental catchments (<100km2) located between 36°S to 39°S. These experimental catchments include native forest and commercial plantations (Monterrey Pine and Eucalyptus) land covers. The first methodology is the use of hydrological modelling to analyze the land cover influence on the water yield of a catchment. [1] compared hydrological and evapotranspiration models and selected the best which represented daily stream flow. The best results were obtained through the more complex model (i.e GR6J and Oudin PET model) which can account for groundwater interaction. The second methodology is the use of the recession coefficient (a) as a metric for baseflow recession analysis, which is a good index of the risk of flow decreasing below a threshold. This coefficient represents the rate of decrease in streamflow after a rainfall event. [2] investigated through mathematical modelling how (a) differs between land cover within the same study sites as [1] study mentioned above. This coefficient did not differ in winter, indicating a similar soil saturation, but some differences were found in summer.  It was determined that (a) was similar between land cover types. Considering both methodological approaches we can conclude that at the experimental catchment scale geology and the fractured rock system play a crucial role in surface-groundwater interactions in these ecosystems. Therefore, future investigations should be focused on subsoil processes and surface-groundwater interaction. Due to its Mediterranean climate, rainfall in Chile is concentrated during winter months, when trees are dormant, meaning that they do not significantly transpire, and a larger proportion of rainfall can infiltrate into the soil. Therefore, metrics such as (a) can help develop landscape planning strategies to increase water availability in conjunction with hydrological modelling. 

References:

[1] Flores, N., Rodríguez, R., Yépez, S., Osores, V., Rau, P., Rivera, D., & Balocchi, F. (2021). Comparison of Three Daily Rainfall-Runoff Hydrological Models Using Four Evapotranspiration Models in Four Small Forested Watersheds with Different Land Cover in South-Central Chile. Water, 13(22), 3191.

[2] Balocchi, F., Flores, N., Arumí, J. L., Iroumé, A., White, D. A., Silberstein, R. P., & Ramírez de Arellano, P. (2021a). Comparison of streamflow recession between plantations and native forests in small catchments in Central‐Southern Chile. Hydrological Processes, 35(6), e14182.

How to cite: Balocchi, F., Arumi, J. L., Rivera, D., and Iroumé, A.: Understanding land cover influence on water resources in south-central Chile: A hydrological modelling with baseflow recession analysis approach, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1842, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1842, 2022.

EGU22-2794 | Presentations | HS2.1.3

How forests transpiration and interception evaporation can buffer variations in precipitation downwind 

Stefan C. Dekker, John C. O'connor, Arie Staal, Obbe A. Tuinenburg, Karin T. Rebel, and Maria J. Santos

Forests are important to regulate water-climate relationships, providing important ecosystem services locally and elsewhere. Therefore, understanding forest hydrology is crucial to understand the flows of these ecosystem services, and attribute the origins to either transpiration and interception as these can have very different underlying mechanisms. Atmospheric moisture recycling effectively increases the amount of usable water over land as the water can undergo multiple precipitation–evapotranspiration cycles. Forest contribution to atmospheric moisture recycling can come from water pressure deficit driven water transpiration through the stomata, or via evaporation of surface water intercepted in the canopy during precipitation. Disentangling these two pathways is fundamental as the former is dependent on the ability of the deep roots of trees to access groundwater facilitating a constant transpiration flux throughout the dry season, while the latter is fundamentally dependent on precipitation and canopy architecture and leaf morphology. We have demonstrated that forests can buffer precipitation variability elsewhere, for tropical and other types of forests. However, it is not known whether this buffering effect occurs directly through forest transpiration or whether indirect forest interception evaporation has a buffering effect as well. Here we apply a state-of-the-art Lagrangian moisture tracking model (UTrack) to study globally whether forests in the upwind precipitationshed can lead to a reduction in monthly precipitation variability downwind. Indeed, we found that forests are fundamental to reduce precipitation variability downwind in 10 out of 14 global terrestrial biomes, specifically for all forest biomes except Mediterranean forests. On average, if 50% of precipitation originates from forest, there is a strong buffering effect with an average reduction of 60% in the coefficient of variation of monthly precipitation. We also observed that a high fraction of precipitation from non-forest land sources has the opposite effect, that is, no buffering effect. The average variation of monthly precipitation was 69% higher in areas where 50% of precipitation originates from non-forest land sources in the precipitationshed. We also observed that the role of forest interception evaporation is less important than the role of forest transpiration for buffering precipitation variability. The largest buffering effect was found for the tropical forest biomes, mainly Amazon and Congo, while moisture recycling over Southeast Asia was mostly contributed by the surrounding ocean. For temperate biomes, the buffering capacity of forests is lower, related to shallower rooting depths and that large proportions of temperate forests are in areas dominated by precipitation from non-forested land or ocean, such as western Europe. Nevertheless, there is still a significant role in buffering precipitation and potentially this buffering capacity can be increased with large scale reforestation projects to mitigate climate change. Our findings clearly support an important role of forests in buffering precipitation downwind. Forests hereby regulate the climate system, which can become unbalanced if this regulating ecosystem service is removed. Furthermore, the importance of this mechanism is also relevant to maintain other processes, such as food production and highlights the tight connections between forests and other processes and ecosystem services

How to cite: Dekker, S. C., O'connor, J. C., Staal, A., Tuinenburg, O. A., Rebel, K. T., and Santos, M. J.: How forests transpiration and interception evaporation can buffer variations in precipitation downwind, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2794, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2794, 2022.

Afforestation is recognized as one of the commonly used nature-based solutions for flood risk mitigation as well as for reduction of anthropogenic impacts on sediment and nutrient flushing. Processes of nutrient cycles (e.g., nitrogen cycle) are directly dependent on the amount of precipitation and its temporal and spatial distribution as water is the main transport medium and the driving force for many ecosystem processes. To understand the natural background of biogeochemical processes and transport of their products, it is therefore necessary to improve understanding of the hydrological control mechanisms, especially the formation of rainfall-runoff. Forest ecosystems without any or with negligible anthropogenic influences represent such kind of a reference, i.e. natural state in the field of nutrient flushing research. For this reason, we established an experimental monitoring system in the small, almost completely afforested Kuzlovec river catchment, Slovenia. Most of the hydrometeorological variables were measured continuously at a 20-min time step accompanied with measurements of concentrations of nitrate-nitrogen in the stream and leaf area index, which was used as an indicator of seasonal growth periods. Based on a two-year data set of various variables, we identified rainfall events for which we investigated: i) the influences of rainfall characteristics on the nitrate-nitrogen flushing, ii) the rainfall-runoff formation processes taking into account nitrate-nitrogen concentration changes during rainfall events, and iii) the role of the forest on the dynamics of the nitrate-nitrogen flushing (i.e., are there differences between the seasons). The focus of this contribution will be on the latter. We will present the most important findings obtained by using statistical analyses, such as hierarchical clustering, k-means, and principal component analysis. We believe that information obtained from such research is extremely important for improving the understanding of the processes’ controlling factors in areas with anthropogenic activities that affect the circulation and amount of nutrients exported to water bodies. 

How to cite: Lebar, K. and Rusjan, S.: The role of forest vegetation seasonality on the dynamics of nitrate-nitrogen export during rainfall events, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3352, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3352, 2022.

A consequence of climate change, less investigated from the hydrological point of view, is the alteration of the frequency and intensity of forest disturbances that can reduce forest productivity, change the distribution of tree species, and shift their range and density. Based on this, this study evaluates the ability of remnants of native forests to resist or adapt to a changing climate. The case study is the island of Sardinia, located within the Mediterranean basin. Sardinia covers a latitudinal gradient of 300 km; and it is one of the least populated and the most forested regions in Italy. It is considered one of the most important biodiversity reservoirs inside the Mediterranean hotspot. From one hand Sardinia is experiencing a decreasing pressure on forests due to human factors, from the other, some studies demonstrate that winter precipitation and runoff are decreasing alarmingly, and this can have an impact on forests. Based on the above, this study aims, through the analysis of 20 years of satellite images (MOD44B), to evaluate forest cover changes and to detect any possible relationship with some of the most important climate variables such as precipitation, air temperature and vapor pressure deficit. Results indicate that in the last 40 years Sardinia has experienced a simultaneous increase in air temperatures (0.026 °C*y-1) and VPD (0.001 kPa*y-1) combined with reductions in both total precipitation (14.03 mm*y-1) and winter precipitation (12.09 mm*y-1), and that the areas with a mean annual precipitation lower than 700 mm went from the 26% in the period 1922-1979, to 63% during 1980-2018, and in effect 1980 was detect as changing point for annual precipitation. These climatic variations have led to an important reduction of the tree cover in some historical forests of Sardinia, and in the broad-leaved ones particularly. The reduction in TC shows a positive correlation with mean annual precipitation (ρ= 0.66) and altitude (0.72), while negative correlations were detected with temperature (ρ= -0.57) and VPD (ρ= -0.48). Results highlight that forests are adapting to climate change, and this may have an impact on local water resources.

How to cite: Cipolla, S. S. and Montaldo, N.: Spatiotemporal evolution of forest cover and of historical climate data: a case study in the Mediterranean basin, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5265, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5265, 2022.

EGU22-6224 | Presentations | HS2.1.3

Fertigation management of mixed-species plantation versus monoculture in plantation forestry: key aspects and future perspective. 

Andrea Rabbai, Stefan Krause, Nicholas Kettridge, Sami Ullah, Giulio Curioni, Rob Rob Mackenzie, and Kris Hart

According to the Forest European Process, the recent Climate Change Conference (COP26), and EU policies, conservation of forest ecosystems is a critical step in mitigating climate change and combating deforestation; accordingly plantation forests will be critical in achieving these goals. While limitations in monoculture plantation are well established in silvicultural practices and documented in research studies, in the face of intensifying climate change and resources scarcity, the need for knowledge on mixed-species plantations has grown. There has been also a recent develop in innovative and sustainable forest management practices, including irrigation and fertilization (fertigation) that aim to improve the productivity of forestry plantations, and therefore their carbon sequestration capacity, as well as the ecosystem services associated with healthy forests. However, the exact effects of fertigation on forests plantation have yet to be established. This study examines the growth patterns, productivity, and carbon storage capacity of four–year-old mixed-species and monoculture plantations in response to an intensive fertigation management. Particularly, our findings highlight differences in tree growth patterns and their performance in paired experimental plots based on different soil types. Such differences are associated varying soil moisture conditions due the interaction of fertigation and the soil water holding capacity. In general, trees growth is higher in sandy soil, due to the positive relation between high soil water diffusivity and fertigation. On the other hand, no such tree growth has been observed in clay soil, most likely due to the high susceptibility to waterlogging, which requires careful fertigation management to avoid limiting conditions for the healthy development of young forest plantation. Our research provides important insights into how young plantation trees respond to different soil moisture conditions, which can aid to in the design and fertigation management of mixed-species plantations resulting in more productive, biodiverse, economically viable, and healthier forests than monocultures.

 

 

How to cite: Rabbai, A., Krause, S., Kettridge, N., Ullah, S., Curioni, G., Rob Mackenzie, R., and Hart, K.: Fertigation management of mixed-species plantation versus monoculture in plantation forestry: key aspects and future perspective., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6224, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6224, 2022.

EGU22-6657 | Presentations | HS2.1.3

Development of Throughfall Simulation Models and Prediction Uncertainty Estimation by Different Forest Stand Characteristics 

Hyunje Yang, Honggeun Lim, Hyung Tae Choi, and Jiyoung Lee

Continuously increasing demand for freshwater makes many scientists study water yield prediction. In South Korea, of which two-third is covered by forests, understanding the water cycle especially in forests is even more important. Throughfall is penetrated rainfall through the tree canopy and it is the basic source for groundwater recharge which is directly related to the water yield on the catchment scale. Therefore, understanding the throughfall characteristics is essential for sustainable water management. This study is conducted to develop simple throughfall simulation models and estimate prediction uncertainty from developed models by different forest stand characteristics. National Institute of Forest Service (NIFoS) has collected throughfall data for 2 years from 7 different forest stand sites. Rutter model was used for the structure of the simple throughfall simulation model and it had several parameters for simulating. And over a million Monte Carlo experiments and generalized likelihood uncertainty estimation (GLUE) methodology were used for selecting parameters sets of behavioural models from comparing simulated throughfall and observed throughfall. From the range of behaviours in a period, we successfully estimated the prediction uncertainty. We also compared the features of behavioural parameter sets by different forest stand characteristics. We expect developed models can be applied for several forest stands in South Korea with various physical-based hydrological models.

How to cite: Yang, H., Lim, H., Choi, H. T., and Lee, J.: Development of Throughfall Simulation Models and Prediction Uncertainty Estimation by Different Forest Stand Characteristics, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6657, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6657, 2022.

EGU22-6703 | Presentations | HS2.1.3

Modelling Hydrological Ecosystem Services of native forest for Integrated Water Resources Management on a poorly monitored basin of Central Chile 

Pilar Barria, Anahí Ocampo-Melgar, Alejandro Venegas, and Claudia Cerda

Ecosystem goods and services (BSE) of native forest are fundamental for water supply in Central Chile. The ongoing Megadrought (MD)- a decade lenght below normal precipitation years (~30-40%)- that affects the region, has exacerbated the water scarcity, generating a favorable scenario for the systematization and structuring of Payment for Ecosystem Services (PES) schemes in Mediterranean-climate basins of Chile. Hydrological modeling tools can be useful to support collaborative decision processes needed to implement these PES, as well as water management adaptation plans. In this context, the Chilean Water Directorate is leading the implementation of Basin Scale Strategic Water Management Plans (BSWMP) using the Water Evaluation and Planning Model (WEAP). However, the lack of biophysical data in poorly monitored basins, challenge the model implementation to quantify these ecosystem services. In this research, we used satellite data, which combined with short term field data allow us to represent the climate-forest-hydrological feedbacks and to quantify the water related ecosystem services at the sub-basin scale in the Aculeo Lake catchment, an iconic agricultural basin located in the Metropolitan region of Chile. The results indicate that there is significant impact of the MD in the native forest of the Aculeo basin, revealed by decreases in the normalized difference vegetation index and the leaf area index (~50% since year 2019), which translate into reduced evapotranspiration values. Also, according to the hydrological model, the native forest ecosystem services exacerbated during the MD, leading to increased surface runoff, infiltration rates and lake water volume storage, revealing its key role on the hydrological system. Finally, a modelling framework has been designed to support the WEAP model implementation to simulate and quantify the native forest ecosystem services at the basin scale, for poorly gauged basins, in the context of the current BSWMP.

How to cite: Barria, P., Ocampo-Melgar, A., Venegas, A., and Cerda, C.: Modelling Hydrological Ecosystem Services of native forest for Integrated Water Resources Management on a poorly monitored basin of Central Chile, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6703, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6703, 2022.

EGU22-8574 | Presentations | HS2.1.3

Enrichment Processes in Throughfall and Stemflow in a Mixed Temperate Forest 

Maria Grundmann, Marius G. Floriancic, and Peter Molnar

Forest canopies redistribute precipitation by processes of interception and stemflow which also change the chemical signature of incoming precipitation. Understanding what controls these transformations and how they evolve across seasons is key to assess forest water cycling and nutrient transport. At the Waldlabor Zurich ecohydrological observatory (Switzerland) we measure the amount and chemical signature of precipitation since April 2020. Our measurement setup focusses on spruce (Picea abies) and beech (Fagus silvatica) trees, as they are the two most common species across Switzerland. In addition to the ion and isotope concentrations in precipitation, throughfall, stemflow as well as in the soil at different depths (10, 20, 40 and 80 cm), we also assess the canopy density in weekly resolution, groundwater depth and streamflow amount at the outlet of our forested catchment, as well as their chemical and isotopic composition

We assessed the seasonal variability of throughfall and stemflow and their relation to canopy density measurements for beech, spruce and young spruce trees. Canopy density had little to no effect on interception and stemflow fractions. We found almost half of the total annual precipitation is intercepted in the canopies of spruce and beech trees, this is because most precipitation events were quite small, resulting in almost no throughfall at all. However, in general, the fraction of interception decreased with increasing event size, on the other hand events below 4 mm did not produce significant amounts of throughfall and stemflow. Water chemistry is showing that major enrichment processes took place in the canopy, subsequently the ion signature was different in throughfall and stemflow compared to open field precipitation. Ion concentrations of sodium, chloride, nitrate, ammonium and potassium were 2 - 10 times higher in throughfall and up to 14 times higher in stemflow compared to concentrations measured in open field precipitation. We hypothesize this is the result of accumulation of wind deposits, especially of anthropogenic contaminants on the tree stem, branches and leaves, as we found concentrations where generally higher during events succeeding long periods without precipitation. In accordance with the much rougher surface of spruce needles and stems compared to beech leaves and stems, we found much higher concentrations in throughfall and stemflow below spruce trees and elevated ion concentrations in the soil waters up to 40 cm depth. Overall, our results highlight the importance of forests, not only in redistributing precipitation, but also in changing the chemical signal of precipitation and thus the forest water and nutrient cycle.

How to cite: Grundmann, M., Floriancic, M. G., and Molnar, P.: Enrichment Processes in Throughfall and Stemflow in a Mixed Temperate Forest, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8574, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8574, 2022.

Forests in hydric (wet) growing conditions are characterised by waterlogged soil conditions for a significant portion of the year with peat layer less than 30 cm. In these locations growth of most tree species is hampered due to lack of oxygen in waterlogged soil, but peat accumulation does not take place as the organic detritus is decomposed during the dry periods. These are marginal ecosystems in between wetlands and drylands and as such are sensitive to climate change. But due to their limited practical value have often been neglected by researchers.

We study the soil water regime of hydric forests constructing Hydrus-1D soil water model. The model was validated with field observations of soil water content, potential and groundwater level at three field sites in Latvia, northern Europe. The meteorological parameters for the model forcing were obtained from the E-obs data set (version v24.0e), including wind speed, relative humidity, incoming shortwave radiation, air temperature and precipitation. Model run period was from 1980 to middle of June 2021.

The model was used to explore the sensitivity of the forest water balance to the crucial parameters such as soil grain size distribution, seasonality and value of the leaf area index (LAI) and canopy surface albedo, and root system ability to compensate lack of water or waterlogged conditions in some part of the soil profile. Preliminary results indicated that there is feedback between soil aeration and transpiration. This can result in a memory effect where increased transpiration leads to soil pore water depletion, better soil aeration and further increase in transpiration and vice versa.

This work was supported by ERDF postdoctoral research project “Groundwater and soil water regime”, under climate change (No. 1.1.1.2/VIAA/3/19/524).

How to cite: Kalvans, A.: Memory effect of soil water regime in wet forests, Norther Europe, Latvia, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8604, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8604, 2022.

EGU22-9002 | Presentations | HS2.1.3 | Highlight

A thirst for snowmelt? Tree water use in spring 

Magali F. Nehemy, Jason Maillet, Nia Perron, Christoforos Pappas, Oliver Sonnentag, Jennifer L. Baltzer, Colin P. Laroque, and Jeffrey J. McDonnell

Describing the water sources for tree transpiration and how sources vary in time and space is fundamental to understand how vegetation impacts the hydrological cycle. While many tree water source partitioning studies have focused on the growing season, little is known about transpiration sources before, during, and after snowmelt when trees rehydrate and recommence to transpire in spring. Here we investigate spring snowmelt and the onset of tree rehydration and transpiration in two sites within the boreal forest of Saskatchewan, Canada. Specifically, we investigate the source of transpiration during the first days and weeks after transpiration onset relative to snowmelt timing. We document the source of transpiration of three boreal forest tree species— jack pine (Pinus banksiana), black spruce (Picea mariana), and larch (Larix laricina)by combining observations of weekly stable isotope values of xylem, soil water, rainfall, and snowmelt with physical measurements of soil moisture dynamics, snow depth and high-temporal resolution measurements of tree stem radius and sap flow. We show that the onset of rehydration and transpiration overlaps snowmelt and that trees use snowmelt water during stem rehydration and the onset of transpiration. Soil water showed a rapid shift to isotopically depleted-snowmelt water values during the end of the snowmelt period. But our data showed a delay in the shift in xylem isotope signatures from pre-melt to the clear snowmelt-depleted water signatures that dominate thereafter. This appears to be controlled by tree water transit time that was in the order of 9 to 18 days. Our study shows that snowmelt is an important source for stem rehydration and the onset of transpiration in the boreal forest during spring onset. Our data also highlights the importance of monitoring phenological and physiological responses during tree water source investigations. In a warmer world, the timing of snowmelt and vegetation phenology are likely to continue to change, as well as the decline in water availability via snowmelt in northern ecosystems. Therefore, understanding tree water use dynamics during spring onset is important to identify the impact of climate change on the evolution of forest composition and groundwater recharge.  

How to cite: Nehemy, M. F., Maillet, J., Perron, N., Pappas, C., Sonnentag, O., Baltzer, J. L., Laroque, C. P., and McDonnell, J. J.: A thirst for snowmelt? Tree water use in spring, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9002, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9002, 2022.

EGU22-10842 | Presentations | HS2.1.3

Snow drought reduces water transit times in headwater streams 

Catalina Segura

Knowledge of water transit times through watersheds is fundamental to understand hydrological and biogeochemical processes. However, its prediction is still elusive, particularly in mountainous terrain where physiography and precipitation change over short distances. In addition, much remains to be studied about the impact of climate change on transit time as it continues to change precipitation form in mountainous terrain. Water isotopic ratios were used to evaluate mean transit time (MTT) and young water fractions ( ) in seven small mountainous watersheds in western Oregon over the 2014–2018 period that included a major regional snow drought in 2015. The MTT was shorter in 2015 across all watersheds compared to any other year while the  was larger in 2015 than in any other year. The short transit times observed in 2015 could be related to low connectivity between surface water and older ground water which resulted in a homogenous hydrologic response across all the investigated watersheds despite their physiographical differences. The 2016–2018 MTT vary widely across all watersheds but especially within the smaller high elevation watersheds indicating that the impact of the 2015 snow drought was stronger for systems that depend heavily on snowmelt inputs. During relatively wet/cold years intrinsic watershed characteristics such as drainage area and terrain roughness explained some of the variability in transit time metrics across all watersheds. Shorter transit times during the drought have implications for water quality and solute concentrations as biogeochemical processes are controlled in part by the time water resides and interacts within the subsurface. Although the impact of the 2015 snow drought appears short lived these results are particularly critical considering the expected regional snowpack decline as the climate warms in the western USA.

How to cite: Segura, C.: Snow drought reduces water transit times in headwater streams, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10842, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10842, 2022.

EGU22-12591 | Presentations | HS2.1.3

New insights in the understanding of the water balance in a subalpine forest in the Alps 

Glenda Garcia-Santos, Nikolaus Obojes, and Leonardo Montagnani

Subalpine forests in the Alps are fragile ecosystems with high importance for human water resources and the local and mesoscale climate. While previous studies have measured different components of the water balance, little is known about the partition of all the water components during the same period and the role of forest age. We were able to measure the water balance components and will show how water distributed in the forest. Some highlights of our study are the evidences that canopies of old forests were able to intercept water in larger extend than the young forest canopies, representing the largest water reservoir, the frequency of fog during the study period, shown for the first-time in this ecosystem, the larger ratio of throughfall related to precipitation during days with mixed precipitation (fog and rainfall) and the role of epiphytes in the water balance.

How to cite: Garcia-Santos, G., Obojes, N., and Montagnani, L.: New insights in the understanding of the water balance in a subalpine forest in the Alps, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12591, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12591, 2022.

EGU22-274 | Presentations | HS2.1.4

Assimilation of EO based data into LSM to compute the contribution of snowmelt to discharge in the High Mountainous Region. 

Vikrant Maurya, Manika Gupta, Naresh Chandra Pant, and Atul Kumar Sahai

The cryosphere is an important component of the Earth’s climate system and is exceptionally sensitive to global warming. Studies have shown the decline in the ice and snow cover with increasing temperatures in the Himalayan Mountainous Region (HMR), the third-largest deposit of ice and snow. The melting of ice and snow contributes to the discharge and affects the availability of water in the downstream areas. The introduction of satellite-based observations in conjunction with land surface modelling is paramount as the scarcity of ground data in the mountainous region limits the study.

The study focuses on the snowmelt contribution of the HMR to the discharge of Ganga Basin. An integrative approach of NASA Land Information System Framework (LISF)-NOAH Land Surface Model and Runoff Routing Model is used to estimate the snowmelt contribution to discharge. The snowmelt contribution has been compared for the period 2008-2018 based on two model runs, i.e., control with experiment run wherein satellite-based snow cover observations (MODIS) has been assimilated in the model based on Direct Assimilation (DA). Assimilation of snow cover data helps to model the snowmelt efficiently as compared to control run which is then used to simulate discharge and snowmelt contribution to discharge.

The simulated DA mode results are more congruous with the station observed data and is helpful in producing a snowmelt baseline for the HMR. The snowmelt baseline can be used for comparing future snowmelt contributions to discharge in the context of environmental change.

How to cite: Maurya, V., Gupta, M., Pant, N. C., and Sahai, A. K.: Assimilation of EO based data into LSM to compute the contribution of snowmelt to discharge in the High Mountainous Region., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-274, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-274, 2022.

EGU22-503 | Presentations | HS2.1.4

Hydrologic response to climate change: A case from a high-mountain river basin 

Rupesh Baniya, Ram Krishna Regmi, Rocky Talchabhadel, Sanjib Sharma, Jeeban Panthi, Ganesh R Ghimire, Sunil Bista, and Bhesh Raj Thapa

Water resources in the Himalayan region are highly exposed and vulnerable to climate variability and climate change. We investigate the potential impact of climate change on hydroclimatic extremes and spatiotemporal distribution of water balance components of the Himalayan river basin, taking the Tila River Basin of Nepal as a test site. This study integrates CMIP6 climate model outputs with a semi-distributed hydrologic model to produce streamflow projections. We analyze climate change impact in three timeframes: near (2026-2050), mid (2051-2075), and far (2076-2100) future under SSP 245 and SSP 585 scenarios. Results showed that the projected change in precipitation, evapotranspiration, and water yield is as high as 50%, 45%, and 75%, respectively. Both low and high flows are projected to increase under future climate scenarios. High altitude regions, with dominant snow- and glacier-covered areas, are more vulnerable to climate change impact. Our results are of practical importance for planners and decision-makers to formulate adaptation strategies under a changing climate.

How to cite: Baniya, R., Regmi, R. K., Talchabhadel, R., Sharma, S., Panthi, J., Ghimire, G. R., Bista, S., and Thapa, B. R.: Hydrologic response to climate change: A case from a high-mountain river basin, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-503, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-503, 2022.

EGU22-630 | Presentations | HS2.1.4

SWAT+ application to a small catchment for NSWRM assessment 

Amro Negm, Paolo Gaini, Enrico Antonio Chiaradia, and Claudio Gandolfi

The assessment of soil-water balance is associated with several challenges, such as the mitigation effects of droughts and flooding, particularly under climate change. Such alerting threat has pushed forward the efforts that the governments are doing to mitigate this risk. Aiming at contributing to better characterize the soil-water balance in small agricultural catchments, the European Union has launched a project of OPtimal strategies to retAIN and re-use water and nutrients across different soil-climatic regions in Europe (OPTAIN). This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 862756. In the framework of this project, the Soil Water Assessment Tool Plus (SWAT+) model was applied to the Cherio river basin, located near the city of Milan, Northern Italy, to develop novel strategies for natural/small water retention measures (NSWRM). The topography of the basin is complex, in which the northern part of the basin is a mountainous area, while the middle and lower part is mainly covered by urban, forest, and agricultural areas. The digital elevation model, land uses, soils, river network, and a long dataset of observed meteorological variables from 2002 to 2020 were prepared and elaborated to satisfy the model requirements. The application of the SWAT+ model was done by delineating the watershed, mapping land use and soil and their associated parameters, and creating the Hydrologic Response Units (HRUs) that identify hydrological homogenous areas inside the basin. As a result, the SWAT+ was used to simulate the hydrological processes and a sensitivity analysis was performed to identify the sensitive parameters affecting the simulated discharge based on the Sobol method. Model calibration was then performed using the observed discharges recorded at a flow gauge close to the basin outlet. The results show that differences between the simulated and observed discharges are very significant and appear to be related to the insufficient quality of precipitation inputs, rather than to model limitations or poor parameter calibration. This returns to the role of the uncertainty associated with the temporal and spatial measurement of the precipitation even in small catchments when the hydromorphological characteristics are complex. The findings of this research can be used to have a better understanding of hydrological fluxes variability across the basin and to assess the proper NSWRM to improve the qualitative and quantitative management of water resources in the Cherio river basin.

How to cite: Negm, A., Gaini, P., Chiaradia, E. A., and Gandolfi, C.: SWAT+ application to a small catchment for NSWRM assessment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-630, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-630, 2022.

The study investigates the interactions between surface water and meteo-climate processes in an Alpine valley (Grosina, northern Italy) characterized by anthropogenic modifications affecting the hydrologic cycle. Grosina valley, an accessory valley of Valtellina on the border between Italy and Switzerland, features a central-alpine climatic type. The valley is composed of two main branches - Eita (62 km2) and Sacco (71 km2). Along the Eita stream, close to its confluence with the Sacco stream, a dam was built in 1960 for hydro-power exploitation and regulation purposes. After the confluence, the river takes the name of Roasco. Anthropogenic modifications of the natural water system include two diversion channels in the main branches that connect them to the dam and a third diversion tunnel that brings a high volume of water into the dam lake from a hydroelectric plant located outside the watershed.

The study general aim is two-fold: i) setting up a prototypal operational hydrologic model (forecast period of about one week) for water use management and ii) applying a hydrologic model for estimating impacts of climatic changes on water resources and the hydrologic cycle in the medium/long-term (decadal and multi-decadal analyses). The first step of this project is common to the two aims and involves the definition of the conceptual model and the implementation-calibration of a hydrologic model in such a challenging environment, representative of the multiple and concurrent uses of water resources in mountain areas.

The modeling of the Grosina valley catchment has been carried out exploiting the potentialities of the GEOframe system, an open-source, semi-distributed hydrologic model. It is a component-based model since it is developed starting from the creation of single modules (components) that describe the principal physical processes of the hydrologic cycle. After identifying Hydrological Response Units (HRUs) and their connections through a geomorphological analysis, contributions and losses to the system were considered by exploiting the components of meteorological data interpolation (from 22 stations), radiation calculation, partitioning between solid and liquid precipitation, and evapotranspiration. Then, the calibration of the model was performed by comparing the simulated flow to discharge data recorder at the diversion points, the dam, and a hydrometer placed at the end of the valley (hourly timestep). This phase proved to be very complex and demanding since only the measure of the derived flow, namely the flow captured for hydropower purposes, was available. Therefore, at the diversion points, it was chosen to estimate the natural flow as the sum of the derived flow and the minimum environmental flow (MEF), focusing the match between observation and simulation on the baseflow behavior rather than the discharge peaks. The calibration phase led to a good correspondence between simulated and observed flow with Nash-Sutcliffe Efficiency values greater than 0.6 at all points investigated.

How to cite: Citrini, A., Camera, C., Marini, L., and Beretta, G. P.: Preliminary results regarding the simulation of a streamflow strongly influenced by anthropogenic use in an alpine context: the case of the Grosina valley (northern Italy)., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1882, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1882, 2022.

EGU22-1908 | Presentations | HS2.1.4

Variable Runoff Generation Layer distributed hydrological model of hilly regions 

JianFei Zhao, ZhongMin Liang, JinTao Liu, BinQuan Li, and YaNan Duan

The variable runoff generation layer concept is proposed based on the new understanding of hillslope hydrological experiments to address the problem of flash flood forecasting in hilly regions. This concept has expanded the depiction of interflow from soil horizon to soil-weathering bedrock interface and provided a unified description of the infiltration excess and the saturation excess runoff and their conversion mechanism by meticulously depicting the formation and development process of interflow. Based on the concept of variable generation layer and the theory of kinematic wave model, the calculation formulas of infiltration excess (Horton), saturation excess (Dunne) surface runoff, and interflow of the unit grid are derived. The nonlinear reservoir method, 2-d diffusion wave equation, and 1-d diffusion wave equation are applied to calculate the groundwater flow, the surface runoff routing, and channel flow routing separately, based on which established the variable runoff generation layer distributed hydrological model (VRGL). The VRGL model is applied to the Tunxi watershed, a typical humid watershed of the hilly region. 24 flood events ranging from 2010 to 2019 were studied, and the results showed that the relative error of the flood peak and the flood volume were both within ±20%, and the Nash-Sutcliffe efficiency (NSE) was around 0.84. It is indicated that the accuracy of the VRGL model is high enough for flash flood forecasting in hilly regions.

How to cite: Zhao, J., Liang, Z., Liu, J., Li, B., and Duan, Y.: Variable Runoff Generation Layer distributed hydrological model of hilly regions, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1908, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1908, 2022.

Roads presence and landslides occurrence in steep slope mountain areas are often strictly connected. In recent decades, the use of Airborne Laser Scanning (ALS)-derived high-resolution topographic data amplified the possibilities to better represent landscapes and related physical processes at the basin scale. Additionally, the adoption of topographically-based hydrological models allows to simulating water overland flows dynamics and investigating the occurrence of specific degradative phenomena. In this regard, snowpack melting plays a key role in altering superficial water dynamics in mountain landscapes, but accurate investigation about the interaction between snowmelt runoff and human infrastructures (such as roads) in the occurrence of hillslope failures is still obscure. This research aims to assess the relationship between snowmelt runoff, road presence and terrain instabilities affecting a landslide-prone steep slope mountain meadow (northern Italy). An innovative multi-modeling approach was tested to detect the alteration of snowmelt overflows due to the road’s presence, as well as to investigate its relationship with the activation of a shallow landslide. The role of the road in altering snowmelt runoff was investigated both considering its presence and assuming its absence by a novel Digital Elevation Model (DEM) editing procedure. Different hydrological and slope stability models were interactively implemented, starting from pre-event ALS-derived DEM to propose predictive basin-scale simulations. Results attested the relevant role played by the road in altering snowmelt runoff overland flows, as well as their combined contribution in the foreseen activation of the observed shallow landslide. Starting from on-field observations conducted after the landslide triggering, the accuracy of instabilities predictions was tested through the computation of the Area Under the Receiver Operating Characteristic curve (AUC-ROC) and the Cohen’s kappa-index. This work could be a useful tool for planning mitigation interventions able to reduce the occurrence of similar risk scenarios, also providing specific suggestions for developing and promoting efficient sustainable actions for mountain landscapes.

How to cite: Mauri, L., Cucchiaro, S., Grigolato, S., Dalla Fontana, G., and Tarolli, P.: Investigating the interaction between snowmelt runoff and road in the activation of hillslope instabilities affecting a landslide-prone mountain basin through a multi-modeling approach, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4691, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4691, 2022.

EGU22-5028 | Presentations | HS2.1.4

Impact of recent ground thermal changes on the hydrology of a Tibetan catchment and implications for lake level changes 

Léo Martin, Sebastian Westermann, Michele Magni, Fanny Brun, Joel Fiddes, Yanbin Lei, Philip Kraaijenbrink, Tamara Mathys, and Walter Immerzeel

Ground thermal regime of high mountain catchments impacts the partition between infiltration and runoff, latent and sensible heat fluxes, frozen and liquid subsurface water and the presence (or absence) of permafrost. In the context of global warming, hydrological modifications associated to ground thermal changes are of critical importance for extensive headwater regions such as the Qinghai-Tibet Plateau (QTP) and the Himalayas, which are major water towers of the world. Improving our ability to quantify these changes is therefore a key scientific challenge both regarding basic science and continental-scale water resource management. Many watersheds of the QTP have seen their hydrologic budget modified over the last decades as evidenced by strong lake level variations observed in endorheic basins. Yet, the role of ground thermal changes in these variations has not been assessed.

Lake Paiku (central Himalayas, southern TP) has exhibited important level decreases since the 70s and thus offers the possibility to test the potential role of ground thermal changes and permafrost thaw on these hydrologic changes. We present distributed ground thermo-hydric simulations covering the watershed over the last four decades to discuss their implications on the lake level changes. We use the Cryogrid model to simulate the surface energy balance, snow pack dynamics and the ground thermo-hydric regime while accounting for the phase changes and the soil water budget. Because the surface radiative, sensible and latent heat fluxes in alpine environments are strongly dependent on the physiography, the model is forced with distributed downscaled forcing data produced with the TOPOSCALE model to account for this spatial variability. Simulated surface conditions are evaluated against meteorological data acquired within the basin, ground surface temperature loggers and remotely sensed surface temperatures. The simulations show that, contrary to large scale estimates of permafrost occurrence probability, an significant part of the basin is underlaid by permafrost (>20%). We also show that over the 1980-2020 period, ground temperature warmed up by 1.5 to 2°C per centuries. The permafrost limit rose from 5100 to 5300 m asl (in 40 years). Unfrozen surface conditions increased by around 25 days per century and evaporation increasing by +22% over the period. To represent the impact of these changes on the lake level, we included them in a simple hydrological budget calculation including the contribution of glacier melt and lake evaporation. This approach shows that ground thermo-hydric changes in the catchment have significantly contributed to the lake level changes. These first results highlight the potential of thermo-hydric simulation to better quantify hydrological changes to come in the QTP.

How to cite: Martin, L., Westermann, S., Magni, M., Brun, F., Fiddes, J., Lei, Y., Kraaijenbrink, P., Mathys, T., and Immerzeel, W.: Impact of recent ground thermal changes on the hydrology of a Tibetan catchment and implications for lake level changes, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5028, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5028, 2022.

EGU22-5821 | Presentations | HS2.1.4

Increased flood hazards within the Himalayan Karnali River catchment predicted for an ensemble of CMIP-6 climate change scenarios 

Ivo Pink, Sim Reaney, Isabella Bovolo, and Richard Hardy

The Himalayas are of exceptional importance for the water resources in Asia and provide fresh water for more than 1.4 billion people. However, they are also the source of frequent floods with the highest death-per-event rates in the world. The floods are caused by intense monsoon precipitation, but snow melt and glacier melt contribute to the flood peaks. Both, extreme precipitation and melt contributions are predicted to be impacted by climate change but it remains unclear how these changes will alter the flood risk in the region.

This study investigates the impact of climate change on peak runoffs in the transboundary Karnali River Basin (KRB) in Nepal / China using both hydrological and statistical modelling. The fully-distributed cryospheric-hydrological model SPHY is applied for the period 2002-2015 and calibrated and validated using the GLUE framework. The Nash-Sutcliffe efficiency, PBIAS of peak flows and extended GLUE are used as performance indicators for the selection of behavioural parameter sets. The model is run with the selected parameter sets and the outputs of 13 downscaled and bias-corrected CMIP-6 models of three different scenarios (historical, ssp245, ssp585) to quantify the climate-change-induced changes in peak flows until the end of the century. Extreme Value Analysis is then applied to estimate the exceedance probability from the simulated annual maximum flows for the climate models, scenarios and hydrological parameter sets.

The results indicate an increase in flood hazard frequency and magnitude until the end of the century. The mean magnitude of an event with 2% annual exceedance probability (AEP) increases by 23% (±19%) in the period 2020 - 2059, and 42% (±19%) in the period 2060 - 2099 for ssp245, and 28% (±23%) in the period 2020 - 2059 and 82% (±41%) in the period 2060 - 2099 for ssp585 compared to the baseline period (1975 - 2014). Flows with a 50 year return period (2% AEP) during the baseline period (10,900 m3/s) are projected to occur every 9 years in the period 2020 - 2059 and 7 years in the period 2060 - 2099 for ssp245 scenario, and every 9 and 3 years for ssp585 scenario, respectively. Glacier and snowmelt contributions are projected to change in terms of seasonality and quantity but the increase of peak flows is mainly driven by the increase in extreme precipitation.

How to cite: Pink, I., Reaney, S., Bovolo, I., and Hardy, R.: Increased flood hazards within the Himalayan Karnali River catchment predicted for an ensemble of CMIP-6 climate change scenarios, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5821, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5821, 2022.

EGU22-6024 | Presentations | HS2.1.4

Tackling the global change challenges to water security in Tajikistan, the water tower of Central Asia 

Shaktiman Singh, Anshuman Bhardwaj, Lydia Sam, and David Haro Monteagudo

Tajikistan occupies only 11% of the territory of Central Asia. However, more than 65% of the region’s water resources are formed in the mountainous areas of this country. Changing water availability in mountain regions has a strong impact on water-dependent economic sectors such as energy and agriculture. Anthropogenic climate change is projected to bring about considerable changes to both the timing and volume of water in the long term through rising temperatures, increased snow and glacier melt and a more variable rainfall regime. However, there is limited understanding of what the impact on Tajikistan’s water resources will be, associated with uncertainty around the climate projections and the rate of depletion of the region’s glaciers. In Tajikistan, two-thirds of agricultural production is irrigated, but many farmers still must make a living from rain-fed land, which is even more vulnerable to drought and climate change. In addition to climate change impacts, the potential for conflict in the region is exacerbated by the current high population growth rate of between 2.5% and 3.4% per year. As living standards improve and demand resources increase, pressures on scarce water resources heighten.

Water resources management in Tajikistan is in a state of transition from a centralized administrative approach that existed for more than 30 years to a more integrated river basin approach, as proposed under the current sector reforms. While the current reforms are an essential move towards Integrated Water Resources Management (IWRM), there is still much to be done in the development and implementation of such a strategy. Some of the main issues in this regard is the absence of reliable information on water resources and the need to update old monitoring systems to better understand the behaviour of the water resources systems in the country.

This research focuses on the Zarafshan River, where efforts to implement IWRM started a few years ago, and it is an example of an application for the development of IWRM in other basins in the country. We will present the work carried out to better understand the hydrological balance in the basin incorporating snow and ice melt dynamics by combining the SWAT model with satellite images of daily snow cover.

How to cite: Singh, S., Bhardwaj, A., Sam, L., and Haro Monteagudo, D.: Tackling the global change challenges to water security in Tajikistan, the water tower of Central Asia, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6024, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6024, 2022.

Anthropogenic activities such as dam regulation have altered the streamflow and sediment relationships in the Himalayan River basins. The effect of dams and barrage operations on streamflow and suspended sediment has been widely studied, but the impact of dam construction in this context is poorly understood. The goal of the study is to create a conceptual framework to explore the shifts in streamflow-sediment interdependence across the continuum of natural-to-post dam construction periods in the Eastern Himalayan Tista River basin. Previous studies have either used sediment rating curve (SRC) or hysteresis, but we have employed both to answer whether these two methods are independently diagnostic of changing streamflow and sediment relations in different stages of dam development in the basin? The Tista basin will have the highest density of dams globally if all the proposed 29 dams are commissioned in the future. Currently, a total of 13 major dams for hydropower (>25 MW) in the mountain basin and a diversion barrage in the alluvial plain for irrigation are functional. Cumulatively, the reservoir of these dams and barrage can store ~89 million m3 of water. The interannual and inter-seasonal streamflow and suspended sediment data from the gauge station located at the alluvial plain downstream of all the 14 regulation structures were analysed for the pre-dam, dam-construction, and post-dam periods. We observed that the annual streamflow is predominantly determined by the heavy monsoon rainfall-runoff in the basin that reduced to 28% during the post-dam condition. The same in the non-monsoon post-dam condition was reduced by 58% mainly due to regulation to satisfy the sectoral demand for water. The mean annual sediment was recorded ~11 Mt, ~46 Mt and ~14 Mt during the pre-dam, dam construction and post-dam period, respectively, while the reservoir trapping reduced 56% of sediment during the non-monsoon post-dam period. The SRC exhibited that erosive behaviour (b-value) of the river increased due to massive streamflow during the monsoon season but fairly increased during annual post-dam condition suggesting the role of dam released sediment starved streamflow to erode. High a-value and clockwise hysteresis demonstrated the sediment-surplus condition due to dam construction activities, which altered the mountain landscape through deforestation and excavation of mountain slope, resulting in further erosion and sedimentation. The post-dam high a-value indicates that reservoirs released sediment downstream by drawdown-flushing with reduced streamflow which develops a complex single-valued hysteresis, implying controlled discharge and carrying capacity. Consequently, due to regulation, the uneven sediment distribution across the river continuum has increased flood vulnerability and riverbank erosion, constraining the ecosystem services. The findings of the study will be beneficial for policies on future water-sharing and management of sediment and flood by the river managers and hydropower companies.

How to cite: Ghosh, K. and Munoz-Arriola, F.: Streamflow-sediment relations across the continuum of natural-to-post dam construction periods in the Himalayan river basin, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6129, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6129, 2022.

EGU22-6228 | Presentations | HS2.1.4

Modeling of glacial lake outburst in the Shakhdara river basin using the complex of mathematical models 

Viktoriia Yudina (Kurovskaia), Sergey Chernomorets, Inna Krylenko, Tatyana Vinogradova, Elena Savernyuk, Amiraidar Gulomaydarov, Inom Zikillobekov, Ubaidullo Pirmamadov, and Yusuf Raimbekov

Climate change leads to the degradation of mountain glaciers in Central Asia and subsequent formation of glacial lakes [Harrison et al., 2018]. Due to the fact that glacial lakes are located, as a rule, in hard-to-reach areas, where there are no systematic observations, it is rather difficult to predict outbursts. One of the ways to assess the risks associated with glacial lakes outburst (GLOF) is mathematical modeling. We used a complex of three models to estimate possible hazard in the downstream valleys. A lake outburst hydrograph was obtained with a model developed by Yu.B. Vinogradov [Vinodradov,1977], based on the emergence and expansion of the intraglacial channel. For the debris flow source, we applied an upgraded transport-shift model, the equations were obtained using the data of the Chemolgan experiment [Vinogradova, Vinogradov, 2017].  A two-dimensional model called FLO-2D was used to investigate quantitative characteristics of the debris flow in the river valley [O'Brien et al., 1993]. The prerequisites and modeling of possible glacier lake outburst were considered for the Bodomdara River valley (Tajikistan) using detailed field data. According to the route survey results, it was established that Lake Bodomdara Upper is a glacial one, which, in turn, may lead to a cascade outburst flood. The bowl of Lake Bodomdara Lower is relatively stable, its outburst is possible without cascade flooding at anomalously high temperatures, snowmelt combined with extreme rainfall. Two probable scenarios were considered: I - the outburst of the Lake Bodomdara Lower (the volume was 328 thousand m3 according to the bathymetric survey results) and II - the cascade outburst of the Lakes Bodomdara (with the volume of 700 thousand m3). A digital elevation model (DEM) ALOS PALSAR (12.5 m) was used as relief data, and for the Bodomdara river cone - DEM based on images from an unmanned aerial vehicle. The outburst flood hydrograph for the scenario I was obtained using the lake breakthrough model developed by Yu.B. Vinogradov, and for II - using an empirical formula. The material increment was estimated in the transport-shift model of debris flow formation. The resulting hydrograph was used for zoning the Bodomdara and Shahdara valleys with a total length of 75 km based on the FLO-2D model. According to the modelling results at the top of the estuary cone of the Bodomdara river discharge under scenario I, the maximum flow will be 111 m3/s, under scenario II - 525 m3/s.

1. Harrison S., Kargel J. S., Huggel C. et al. Climate change and the global pattern of moraine-dammed glacial lake outburst floods // The Cryosphere, 2018, vol. XII, 4, p. 1195–1209.

2. O'Brien J., Julien P., Fullerton W. Two-dimensional water flood, mudflow simulation // Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, ASCE, 1993, vol. CXIX, No 2, p. 244–259.

3. Vinogradova T.A., Vinogradov A.Yu. The experimental debris flows in the Chemolgan River basin // Natural Hazards, 2017, vol. LXXXVIII, 1, p. 189–198.

4. Vinogradov Yu.B. Glacial outburst floods and mudflows. Leningrad, Publishing House “Gidrometeoizdat”, 1977, 154 p.

How to cite: Yudina (Kurovskaia), V., Chernomorets, S., Krylenko, I., Vinogradova, T., Savernyuk, E., Gulomaydarov, A., Zikillobekov, I., Pirmamadov, U., and Raimbekov, Y.: Modeling of glacial lake outburst in the Shakhdara river basin using the complex of mathematical models, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6228, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6228, 2022.

EGU22-6695 | Presentations | HS2.1.4

Seasonal water storage dynamics of tropical high-Andean wetlands in Peru 

Fabian Drenkhan, Marc Martínez Mendoza, Anthony Ross, Nilton Montoya, Jan R. Baiker, and Wouter Buytaert

Tropical high-Andean wetlands, locally called bofedales, represent key ecosystems sustaining biodiversity, carbon sequestration, human water provision and fodder production for livestock farming. They are highly sensitive to climatic and anthropogenic disturbances, such as changes in precipitation patterns, glacier retreat and peat extraction, and are thus of major concern for watershed management. However, the eco-hydrological dynamics and responses of bofedales to impacts from global change are little explored.

In this study we map seasonal bofedales extent in the glaciated Vilcanota-Urubamba basin (Southern Peru) at unprecedented spatial resolution in the region. Therefore, we developed a supervised classification based on the Machine Learning algorithm Random Forest. As a baseline, Sentinel-2 MSI Surface Reflectance imagery between 2020 and 2021 and NASADEM elevation data were included. A total of 27 vegetation and topographic indices were computed and iteratively selected with cross-validated feature selection. As a result, the Wide Dynamic Range Vegetation Index, Normalised Difference Infrared Index and Compound Topographic Index adopt a major role for successful wetland extent classification. We identify a total wetland area of 282 km² (630 km²) at the end of the dry (wet) season in 2020 (2021). The observed high seasonal variability in bofedales extent within the study region suggests the presence of a pronounced intra-annual hydrological regime of drying, soaking and wetting.

For a more thorough assessment of the suggested pattern, we combined borehole water level and outlet river stage data from an arduino sensor network covering five bofedales sites in two micro-watersheds. These confirmed distinct wetting and drying regimes with all levels reducing and increasing during the dry and wet season, respectively, indicating a strong relationship between wetland area extent and water table levels. Based on these findings and a scoping review, a conceptual hydrological model has been proposed. As an initial attempt for model parameterisation, we undertook a statistical analysis, cross-correlating borehole levels, river stage and precipitation inputs to identify lag-times related to the intra-annual storage dynamics of the bofedales. A 4-hour lag-time was observed for outlet river stage to precipitation. However, results for water table response to precipitation were varied, with lag-times from 1 to 46 days, likely owing to the complex topography and hydrological processes within these ecosystems.

Our combined study of supervised wetland classification and eco-hydrological in-situ analysis provides first insights to understanding of high-Andean wetland dynamics. The proposed conceptual model offers a framework to further assess the capacity and residence times of bofedales that can support local decision-making. In view of severe impacts from climate and land use changes, locally tailored conservation and adaptation practices are urgently needed including innovative water storage enhancement interventions. These can be combined with traditional bofedales management by local, native livestock herders. In this regard, nature-based solutions, such as headwater and wetland protection and the implementation of additional water storage, can provide a cost-effective and flexible solution. These interventions leverage natural processes that sustain ecosystem services and increase the buffer function of bofedales to water loss from e.g. glacier shrinkage in headwaters and increasing water demand further downstream.

How to cite: Drenkhan, F., Martínez Mendoza, M., Ross, A., Montoya, N., Baiker, J. R., and Buytaert, W.: Seasonal water storage dynamics of tropical high-Andean wetlands in Peru, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6695, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6695, 2022.

EGU22-6905 | Presentations | HS2.1.4

Climate change impacts on water balancing components for a tropical river basin, Western Ghats India. 

Rakesh Kumar Sinha, Swatantra Kumar Sharma, and Eldho T.I.

Climate change is considered as the important factor for change in water balancing components (WBCs) at the river basin scale. In this study, the Soil and Water Assessment Tool (SWAT) hydrological model is used for the assessment of WBCs for the Kalada river basin (KRB) in the Western Ghats, India. To assess the climate change impacts of near (2021 – 2040), mid (2041 – 2060), and far (2081 – 2100) future for moderate scenarios under representative concentration pathways (RCP) 4.5 and worse scenarios (RCP 8.5) were considered by using the present (2018) fixed land use. The multi-optimization techniques have been used for model calibration and verification of climatic data of the five General Circulation Models in the study area. The results indicated that the actual evapotranspiration (ET), surface runoff, and water yield are decreased (16 to 27%) in all-time slices for both RCP 4.5 and 8.5 emission scenarios but the decreasing trend is non-uniform. This is because of the decline of rainfall by 50 to 230 mm and the increase of temperature by 2 to 5 ℃ in the study area. Furthermore, results indicated that the wet season showed less decrease in comparison to winter and summer, but impacts are high because more than 80% of rain occurred in the monsoon season.

Keywords: Water Balancing Components; Climate change; Surface runoff; GCMs; SWAT model.

How to cite: Sinha, R. K., Sharma, S. K., and T.I., E.: Climate change impacts on water balancing components for a tropical river basin, Western Ghats India., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6905, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6905, 2022.

EGU22-7051 | Presentations | HS2.1.4

Spring discharge, transit times and intermittency in an alpine catchment: how geomorphology shapes the spatio-temporal dynamics? 

Clément Roques, Eliot Chatton, Gaël Chrétien, Laurent Servière, Xavier Pasquier, Ronan Abhervé, Alexandre Gauvain, Luc Aquilina, and Jean-Raynald de Dreuzy

We investigate spatial and temporal behaviors of spring discharge, transit times and intermittency of a network of springs located in an alpine catchment (Natural conservation area of the Massif of Saint-Barthélemy, Pyrenees, France). Field observations have revealed unprecedented variability of behaviors across the catchment, with springs involving sustained high discharge rates during baseflow while others showing intermittency of wetting and drying periods. This dynamic is expected to be directly dependent on the volume and transmissivity of the connected aquifer set by specific geomorphological (topography scaling, rockslides, deep seated landslides, detritic sediments) and geological features (lithology, faults).  Here we aim at understanding the relative controls of those factors in controlling the observed hydrogeological behaviors across the catchment.

We performed two field missions during 2021 high and low flow regimes. More than 20 flowing springs and wetlands have been systematically mapped and sampled for environmental tracer analysis. We found that about 30% of the stream and wetland network contract between high and low flows. The springs responsible for this intermittence are connected to high transmissive shallow aquifers with low storage capacities organized within shallow soils and rockslides. However, perennial springs are influenced by deep groundwater flow paths within the bedrock. The analysis of anthropogenic dissolved gases like CFCs and SF6 revealed an average transit time of the order of 10 years for perennial springs with important variabilities across the catchment. The relatively high residence times is also confirmed by high Helium concentrations. We used the gathered dataset to calibrate a hydrogeological model designed to test the relative controls from specific geomorphological and geological characteristics. By comparing models with different structural settings, we found that topography and aquifer compartmentalization, through the decreasing trend in hydraulic conductivities, are key parameters in setting the spatio-temporal pattern of saturated areas and the distribution of transit times across the catchment. In perspective, we discuss the potential evolution of the extent, discharge magnitude and the transit time of seeping groundwater under changing recharge scenarios.  

How to cite: Roques, C., Chatton, E., Chrétien, G., Servière, L., Pasquier, X., Abhervé, R., Gauvain, A., Aquilina, L., and de Dreuzy, J.-R.: Spring discharge, transit times and intermittency in an alpine catchment: how geomorphology shapes the spatio-temporal dynamics?, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7051, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7051, 2022.

EGU22-7263 | Presentations | HS2.1.4

Hydrological Impact Assessment of Climate Change on a Tropical River Basin in Southern India 

Swatantra Kumar Sharma, Rakesh Kumar Sinha, and Eldho T. I.

The climate change has a significant contribution in the uncertainty in the river flow. In this study, the uncertainty in the river flow of Pamba River Basin (PRB) in South India is investigated due to climate change impacts. In order to assess the hydrological impact in the basin for future preparedness and planning for sustainable use of water resources, an ensemble of five general circulation models (GCMs) and hydrological model SWAT (soil and Water Assessment Tool) were used. The objective of the present study was to understand the surface runoff change over the PRB in the near future (2016-2030) under representative concentration pathways (RCP) 4.5 and 8.5 of the downscaled ensemble GCM data. Furthermore, spatial runoff change at sub-basin scale and percentage runoff change at monthly scale in the PRB were assessed. Hence, to study the impact due to climate change, SWAT model was simulated with base period historical data (1984 – 2015) and future climate data (2016 – 2030), and then changes at spatial and monthly scale were plotted. The results shows that at basin scale, there is an overall increase in the mean runoff by the 1.4 % and 3.0% under RCP4.5 and RCP 8.5 scenarios respectively. At seasonal scale, winter shows a tremendous increase in the runoff with around 38% increase in both RCP 4.5 and RCP 8.5, followed by summer with 17.9% and 18.6% for RCP 4.5 and RCP 8.5 scenarios respectively. Notably, Monsoon witnesses a negative trend in both the scenarios with -18.6% and -15.5% runoff change from the base period. This study will be useful in future water resources management in the basin at micro-level due the spatial and temporal variations.

Keywords: Climate change; SWAT model; GCMs; runoff change; spatial, and temporal change.

How to cite: Sharma, S. K., Sinha, R. K., and T. I., E.: Hydrological Impact Assessment of Climate Change on a Tropical River Basin in Southern India, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7263, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7263, 2022.

EGU22-7320 | Presentations | HS2.1.4

Actual evapotranspiration of abandoned grassland on a slope in the Western Italian Alps: Impact of shrub encroachment 

Davide Gisolo, Ivan Bevilacqua, Justus van Ramshorst, Alexander Knohl, Lukas Siebicke, Alessio Gentile, Maurizio Previati, Davide Canone, and Stefano Ferraris

Land cover changes affect the local hydrological cycle, including actual evapotranspiration (ETa).  Encroachment by shrubs on abandoned grasslands is an increasing phenomenon in the Alps, a region already suffering climate change effects. In addition, shrub encroachment is thought to occur faster on steep slopes. Unfortunately, steep mountain slopes are rarely studied because of complex morphologies, despite a need for data to better understand these changing ecosystems.

Four growing seasons (two wet – 2014 and 2015 and two dry – 2016 and 2017) of eddy covariance, meteorological, hydrological, and soil data were collected at an abandoned grassland on a slope encroached by shrubs in the Italian Western Alps. The objectives were to: 1) study the ETa differences between two land cover types, grassland and shrubland, based on Hydrus 1D model simulations. 2) Compare the simulated ETa from the two land covers (ETaSim grass and ETaSim shrub) with the observed eddy covariance-derived evapotranspiration (ETaObs).

The simulated ETa from shrubland showed a better agreement with the observed ETa (R2=0.4 to 0.5, slope=0.8 to 1.3). The simulated ETa from shrubland (ETaSim shrub) was higher compared to the simulated ETa from grassland (ETaSim grass) with the observations (ETaObs) in between, confirming that ETaObs represents a mixture of shrubland and grassland contributions. The relative contribution was different for each year due to meteorological conditions. On average across all years, a 51:49% contribution from respectively grassland and shrubland resulted in a good approximation of ETaObs, in particular in 2015 and 2016 growing seasons, characterised by long dry spells. In those growing seasons, the differences between cumulative ETa from simulations and observations were below 10 mm. In the other two growing seasons, more frequent rainfalls and the absence of long dry spell caused cumulative ETa underestimation (-25 mm) in 2014 and overestimation (66 mm) in 2017. Differences between shrubland and grassland were enhanced during dry spells, leading to a cumulative ETaSim shrub more than 100 mm higher than the cumulative ETaSim grass. In the longest dry spells of the growing seasons, ETaObs was closer to ETaSim shrub, confirming the role of deeper roots of shrubs.

The results indicate that the shrub-covered area, expected to increase, plays already a key role in the local hydrological cycle, particularly with changes in water availability.

How to cite: Gisolo, D., Bevilacqua, I., van Ramshorst, J., Knohl, A., Siebicke, L., Gentile, A., Previati, M., Canone, D., and Ferraris, S.: Actual evapotranspiration of abandoned grassland on a slope in the Western Italian Alps: Impact of shrub encroachment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7320, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7320, 2022.

EGU22-7604 | Presentations | HS2.1.4

Study of historical evolution (1979-2014) of key water cycle variables in the pyrenees using observations and modeled data 

Roger Clavera-Gispert, Pere Quintana-Seguí, Santiago Beguería, Leticia Palazón, Ane Zabaleta, Omar Cenobio, and Anaïs Barella-Ortiz

The natural border between Andorra, France and Spain are the Pyrenees, a South-Western European mountain range with a great environmental diversity: from Atlantic to Mediterranean climates, from high mountains to cliffs touching the sea, and from humid to semi-arid  conditions. Thus this region is particularly sensitive to climate and global change. On the other hand, this territory is the primary source of water in the region, feeding the runoffs and recharge zones of the region's main catchment basins. Rapid changes in the environment can have an influence on the availability of water resources downstream, increasing the uncertainty to an already tough water management situation.

Scientists use hydrological data to detect and quantify climate variability and change. Although data from gauging stations are basic to study the temporal evolution of water resources, more than these punctual data are needed for a regional study, as many relevant variables of the water cycle, such as evaporation, are seldom observed. Furthermore, models are necessary to study the future climate, but we need first to check if the models faithfully reproduce the intended processes. Therefore, hydrological modeling plays an important role in water resources studies, as they allow us to quantify the main components of the water balance (precipitation, evapotranspiration, drainage/recharge, runoff and streamflow) and the main stocks (soil moisture and snow) for the entire region. 

We have used observation values from non-influenced gauging stations and hydrological outputs of two different modeling tools (the fully distributed model SASER, and the semi-distributed model SWAT) to study the historical evolution (1979-2014) of the natural continental water cycle in the Pyrenees. The comparison of observational data with models, as well as models between them, will allow us to detect, evaluate and analyze the main sources of uncertainty.

We computed monthly, seasonal and annual statistics for three time periods (1979-2014, 1989-2014 and 1999-2014). Thus, we made and analyzed trends for the time series of the different variables applying a time series pre-whitening. These trends have been calculated with the Sen's slope estimator assuming that they are linear. The significance of the trends was estimated with the Mann-Kendall test on the pre-whitened time series with the statistical significance tested at the 95% level.

This work is a contribution to the EFA210/16 PIRAGUA project.

How to cite: Clavera-Gispert, R., Quintana-Seguí, P., Beguería, S., Palazón, L., Zabaleta, A., Cenobio, O., and Barella-Ortiz, A.: Study of historical evolution (1979-2014) of key water cycle variables in the pyrenees using observations and modeled data, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7604, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7604, 2022.

EGU22-7621 | Presentations | HS2.1.4 | Highlight

Estimation of the future water balance and water resources of the Pyrenees 

Pere Quintana-Seguí, Yvan Caballero, Roxelane Cakir, Roger Clavera, Benoît Dewandel, Youen Grousson, Guillaume Hevin, Jorge Jódar, Luis Javier Lambán, Sandra Lanini, Pierre Le Cointe, María del Carmen Llasat, Sabine Sauvage, José Miguel Sánchez-Pérez, Leticia Palazón, Jean-Phillippe Vidal, Ane Zabaleta, and Santiago Beguería

Mountainous areas are an important source of water resources, especially in the Mediterranean. The PIRAGUA project aims at assessing the water resources of the Pyrenees in the past and in the future. To this aim, different modelling approaches were used in order to assess the water resources of the Pyrenees and their future evolution. 

In this study, statistically downscaled climate scenarios, generated within the CLIMPY project were used in order to force four different modelling tools: SWAT, SURFEX, RECHARGEand GIS-Balan. SWAT is a semi-distributed hydrological model, SURFEX is a distributed physically based land-surface model, RECHARGE is a simple potential recharge estimation method base on water balance model for effective precipitation computation and GIS-Balan is a GIS-based groundwater model. 

With SWAT and GIS-Balan we used a delta-change approach to apply the scenarios, and with SURFEX and RECHARGE we used an analogue methodology, which used the SAFRAN-PIRAGUA gridded dataset of meteorological variables as the observational dataset. This way, we covered many sources of uncertainty, and provided an incomplete, but large, representation of the sources of uncertainty (GCMs, RCPs, downscaling methods and hydrological models) at play.

In this exercise, we found that the resulting uncertainties are rather large for almost all variables except temperature. Temperature will very likely increase more than 4 degrees at the end of the century for the RCP85 scenario. Precipitation changes, however, are quite uncertain, although we should expect decreases on the northern slope of the Pyrenees. On the southern slope, the different projections disagree on the sign of the change. They also agree on increases of precipitation on the eastern basins of the domain (Mediterranean), while it is very likely that there will be less solid precipitation (snowfall) in the future. From here, the uncertainties increase, due to the non-linearity of the hydrological models. In the SWAT approach, aridity does not change on average. However, SURFEX projects a likely increase in aridity all over the domain. In terms of water yield, SWAT presents a drier future on the northern and western slopes, but wetter on the southern and eastern slopes. SASER shows a similar picture but is generally much drier than SWAT in the future. In terms of seasonality, the water yield will decrease mainly in summer, but also in spring and autumn and, according to SASER, also in winter, especially for the RCP85 scenario. The RECHARGE model leads to a general decrease of the potential recharge over the whole domain that could be more severe in the northern and southern part of the Pyrenees than in the Central part. The GIS-Balan models report a clear decrease in total discharge flow of the basins, which is most pronounced in the RCP8.5 scenario.

We hope that these results, although uncertain, will serve to plan for the certainty that changes in the annual means and seasonality of the water cycle are coming, even if we do not know clearly what these changes will look like. 

This work has been funded by the EFA210/16 PIRAGUA project.

How to cite: Quintana-Seguí, P., Caballero, Y., Cakir, R., Clavera, R., Dewandel, B., Grousson, Y., Hevin, G., Jódar, J., Lambán, L. J., Lanini, S., Le Cointe, P., Llasat, M. C., Sauvage, S., Sánchez-Pérez, J. M., Palazón, L., Vidal, J.-P., Zabaleta, A., and Beguería, S.: Estimation of the future water balance and water resources of the Pyrenees, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7621, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7621, 2022.

EGU22-7825 | Presentations | HS2.1.4

Water cycle and water resources of the Pyrenees under climate change: the PIRAGUA datasets. 

Leticia Palazón and Santiago Beguería and the PIRAGUA Team

The Pyrenees range is a transboundary mountain region shared by Spain, France and Andorra. As many other mountain regions, the Pyrenees host the upper catchments and recharge zones of the region's main river basins and aquifers. Therefore, it is the main source of water resources that are used in a much larger area that includes important urban concentrations and highly productive rural areas. This territory and its water resources are particularly vulnerable to the consequences of climate change. The PIRAGUA project (2018-2021, https://www.opcc-ctp.org/piragua), funded by FEDER through the POCTEFA Program of the EU, addressed the characterization of the hydrological cycle of the Pyrenees in a climate change context, in order to improve the territories’ adaptation capacity. The goals of the project were to unify and homogenize the existing information, prospect future scenarios, develop indicators of change, and propose adaptation strategies with impact on the territory. The project results were compiled in a series of regional datasets, and are available through the geo-portal of the Pyrenees Climate Change Observatory (https://opcc-ctp.org/geoportal). These include the following resources: PIRAGUA_resources stores information related to water resources use, exploitation and management; PIRAGUA_indicators contains daily streamflow and aquifer level indicators from observed series during the historical period (1950-2019); PIRAGUA_flood includes the number and classification of flood events, at the municipal level; PIRAGUA_atmos_analysis contains observation-based meteorological data suited for hydrological simulation, for the historical period (1981-2010); PIRAGUA_atmos_climate is a  statistical downscaling of six global climatic models, for the historical and future periods (1981-2100); finally, two datasets include the hydrological water cycle components derived from simulations with different hydrological models (SWAT, SASER, GIS-BALAN and RECHARGE) and climate forcings: PIRAGUA_hydro_analysis (1981-2010) and PIRAGUA_hydro_climate (1981-2100). This contribution is devoted to describing these datasets and the tools to explore them and acquire the data, and to provide examples of the main results regarding the climate change effects on the Pyrenees’ water resources.

How to cite: Palazón, L. and Beguería, S. and the PIRAGUA Team: Water cycle and water resources of the Pyrenees under climate change: the PIRAGUA datasets., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7825, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7825, 2022.

Mountainous regions are viewed as “water towers”, where lower temperatures and higher precipitations affect the annual water balance with snow accumulation in winter and maximum runoff driven by snowmelt during spring or summer. Moreover, the need for effective water resources management has turned into a major challenge, especially in the face of climate change. The current development of computer models allows representing the response of catchments even under the impact of changing climate conditions. For this reason, the Devoll catchment in Albania, which is characterized by a Mediterranean climate and varying topography, is studied as part of a modelling chain up to the Banja reservoir, where sedimentation processes are of great importance.
Three different models are used to predict the response of the catchment within the modeling chain: i) a hydrological model (WaSiM), ii) a soil erosion and transport model (RUSLE and SEDD), and iii) a three-dimensional numerical model (SSIIM 2) to simulate flow and suspended sediment transport in the reservoir. Since numerous parameters are involved in the chain and those can introduce uncertainties in the subsequent models, an approximate method is applied to estimate the uncertainties arising from the model parameters, whereby each parameter is subject to a ±1% variation. In addition, climate change impacts are considered while running the modeling chain with different climate scenarios. In all cases, we focus not only on discharge as a target variable but also on the suspended sediment load and bed elevation along the reservoir transect. Finally, a comparison between the results obtained from the variation in parameters and climate change impacts is performed.

How to cite: Pesci, M. H., Mouris, K., Bosshard, T., and Förster, K.: How do changes in model parameters compare to climate change impacts signals? A case study of a modeling chain to predict reservoir inflow and sedimentation processes in the Devoll Catchment (Albania), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8002, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8002, 2022.

EGU22-8389 | Presentations | HS2.1.4

Isotopic and geochemical studies in the Upper Ganga Basin, Uttarakhand, India: Implications on Dissolved Inorganic Carbon systematics 

Nikitasha Chatterjee, Sameer K. Tiwari, Anil K. Gupta, and Kanishak Sharma

In the recent scenario of global warming, the release of organic and inorganic carbon from the melting glaciers has been a subject of scientific research since it can have a pronounced effect on the riverine carbon cycle and primary productivity. Apart from being one of the largest Himalayan glaciers, Gangotri glacier provides water to the Bhagirathi River (Ganga River) which is the most important perennial river in India in terms of economy and livelihood. In the last decade, the melting and recession of Gangotri glacier have increased significantly leading to the formation of glacial lakes and debris-covered areas. As a result, primary productivity and microbial activity have increased in the subglacial areas which release a great amount of soil CO2 that has not been documented previously in the literature. In the present study, the Bhagirathi River, which is the proglacial melt-stream of the Gangotri glacier has been sampled during the Post-monsoon period. A total of 27 samples including river, groundwater, geothermal spring, and reservoir were collected and have been analyzed for pH, surface temperature, Electrical conductivity (EC), major ions, and stable isotopes of carbon. From the study of major ion abundance patterns and mixing ratios, it has been inferred that carbonate weathering is predominant in the basin, though the major rock type of the area are silicates. The (HCO3- ≈ Dissolved Inorganic Carbon, DIC) values of river water show no correlation with altitude (mean = 42.8 mg/L), while δ13C values show a decreasing trend with a decrease in altitude, with an overall range between -10 and - 5‰. As altitude decreases, organic matter activity increases, and thus more CO2 is washed out from the Soil Organic Matter (SOM), which makes the δ13C values of the river depleted. The δ13C of groundwater (mean = -11.8‰) and reservoir water (mean = -9.4‰) are depleted than river water due to mixing of soil carbon in them, and δ13C of geothermal spring water (mean = -3.6‰), shows enriched values since these are places of active CO2 degassing. The source of DIC in the river water is mainly carbonate weathering in the upstream part and soil CO2 in the downstream part of the study area. Quantifying pCO2 values of the river water and calculating carbon flux from the river would provide important information on whether the Bhagirathi River is acting as a carbon source or sink to the atmosphere.

How to cite: Chatterjee, N., Tiwari, S. K., Gupta, A. K., and Sharma, K.: Isotopic and geochemical studies in the Upper Ganga Basin, Uttarakhand, India: Implications on Dissolved Inorganic Carbon systematics, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8389, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8389, 2022.

EGU22-8477 | Presentations | HS2.1.4

Spatially assessing the role of glacier and snowmelt for meeting environmental flow requirements in a high mountain Andean catchment 

Bryan Marinelli, Arthur Lutz, Lutz Breuer, Björn Weeser, and Alicia Correa

As climate change continues to alter the dynamics of hydrological flows, quantifying the associated environmental impacts become more and more vital.

Here we present a study focusing on analyzing the spatial and temporal distribution of flow components, particularly the contributions of glacier melt, snowmelt, rainfall-runoff, and groundwater flow to river discharge in the high mountain Santa River catchment. The catchment is located in the Cordillera Blanca of Peru, the region with the largest glacier cover in the tropics, and has an area of 12,279 km², an average discharge of 133 m3/s, and average annual precipitation of 750 mm.

We used the spatially distributed cryospheric-hydrological model SPHY, forced with W5E5 meteorological data (1979 - 2019) to simulate daily spatial discharge components. Additional static inputs such as a digital elevation model, land use maps, soil hydraulic properties, and glacier extent, thickness, and debris cover were collected from freely available remote sensing-based datasets.

The model runs at a spatial resolution of 500 x 500 meters with daily time steps. Data from 1995 to 1997 were used to spin up the model. Calibration (1998 - 2001) and validation (1998 - 2018) were performed through the comparisons of simulated and observed discharge. The model's performance was evaluated by the percent bias (1.5%; -7.2%), Nash-Sutcliffe efficiency (0.81; 0.65), and R2 (0.82; 0.68). With the best runs, the complete 41 years were simulated.

Further analysis evaluates how glacier melt and snowmelt compensate the discharge amount in dry periods to meet environmental flow requirements and the derived environmental services chain.

The overall outcome of this assessment will define spatially distributed compensated zones, ensuring an informed management of glacier covered watersheds, as well as open up new horizons to better understand, and mitigate, the impacts of climate change.

How to cite: Marinelli, B., Lutz, A., Breuer, L., Weeser, B., and Correa, A.: Spatially assessing the role of glacier and snowmelt for meeting environmental flow requirements in a high mountain Andean catchment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8477, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8477, 2022.

EGU22-9979 | Presentations | HS2.1.4

Automated discharge measurements with salt dilution in Alpine creeks and uncertainty quantification 

Florentin Hofmeister, Brenda Rubens Venegas, Gabe Sentlinger, Markus Disse, and Gabriele Chiogna

The extent to which climate change affects the frequency and magnitude of flood events in mountain catchments is still unclear due to strong regional differences and a limitation in streamflow observations in space and time. However, recent flood events in Western and Southern Alps from August 2021 highlight the need for new monitoring strategies of peak flood events to better compute return periods of flood events. In particular, measuring peak events in small Alpine catchments can be enhanced by using automated tracer measurement systems. We present results from a hydrometric program using an automated salt dilution system at three different sites in the Tyrolean and South Tyrolean Alps from 2020 and 2021. The AutoSalt system triggers salt slug injections in response to water level changes in the creek while two downstream electrical conductivity probes record the passage of the breakthrough curve with high temporal resolution (5 sec). We collected in total 288 discharge measurements ranging from 0.1 m³/s to 15 m³/s. Besides the requirement of complete mixing of the tracer, the main challenge in automated salt dilution is the monitoring and control of the system components to ensure a high reliability and quality of observation data. The internal quality check of the AutoSalt system allowed us to record mainly discharge measurements (81 %) with a very low measurement error < 7% while 19 % of the discharge measurements had an error range of 7 % to 15 %. Based on the collected discharge measurements and their uncertainties, we constructed robust rating curves with error bars for each site. In a next step, we will use the collected observation data to validate hydrological model results for these three different Alpine catchments to strengthen the robustness of the model for long-term climate change modeling.

How to cite: Hofmeister, F., Rubens Venegas, B., Sentlinger, G., Disse, M., and Chiogna, G.: Automated discharge measurements with salt dilution in Alpine creeks and uncertainty quantification, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9979, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9979, 2022.

EGU22-10333 | Presentations | HS2.1.4

Runoff modeling in the High-Mountain River Basin: A Case Study of the Terek River (Caucasus, Russia) 

Ekaterina Kornilova, Inna Krylenko, Ekaterina Rets, and Yuri Motovilov

Climate change and deglaciation in the 20th and 21st centuries cause runoff changes of a high-mountain regions. Modeling allows to predict runoff changes and possible extreme events in the future. In this research, we performed hydrometeorological data analysis, model calibration and validation in the key parts of the Terek River basin and simulated runoff and it’s components for a long-term historical period.

The Terek River flows from the highlands of the Central Caucasus and streams in an easterly direction, flowing into the Caspian Sea. Runoff modeling of the Terek River was carried out to the Mozdok outlet. The average height of the river basin is 1700 m, the basin area is 20600 km2, of which 34% is the high-altitude part of the basin (>2000 m). A rise in both amount of water availability and potential natural hazard is characteristic of the North Caucasus that is considered to be caused by recent climate change. Mean annual runoff during 1978-2010 increased compared to 1945-1977 by 5-30 % in the foothills and by 30-70% in the plain area.

The ECOMAG runoff formation model (author Y. Motovilov) was adopted for the high-mountain part of the Terek River basin. The input data for the model are meteorological data (temperature, precipitation, air humidity deficit), soil and landscape information, and a digital elevation model, output modeling results – water discharges in a river network. In addition, the runoff formation model allows to analyze all components of water balance in different parts of a river basin and to divide the hydrographs by types of nutrition.

As a result, a long-term historical period from 1977 to 2018 was modeled. Due to the regional features of the river basin, an additional block of the model was included to account the glaciation. In addition to the daily runoff data, the separation of the flow into components in a key part of the river basin (the Baksan River) was used to validate the model. Based on the results of the calibration and verification of the model, a good agreement was obtained between the model and actual discharges for hydrological stations in the mountainous part of the basin. The NSE criterion for the 2009-2018 verification period was 0.75, the simulated and actual volumes of runoff differ by less than 10%.

The Terek River runoff formation model was developed under the financial support of RFBR 21-55-10003. Validation of the model based on the separation of the flow into components were designed within the framework of the Governmental Order to Water Problems Institute, Russian Academy of Sciences, subject no FMWZ-2022-0001.

How to cite: Kornilova, E., Krylenko, I., Rets, E., and Motovilov, Y.: Runoff modeling in the High-Mountain River Basin: A Case Study of the Terek River (Caucasus, Russia), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10333, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10333, 2022.

EGU22-10454 | Presentations | HS2.1.4

Operational water forecast assessment of a spatially distributed process-based snow model; a case study in the East River Watershed, Colorado, USA 

Joachim Meyer, McKenzie Skiles, Patrick Kormos, Andrew Hedrick, Ernesto Trujillo, Scott Havens, and Danny Marks

Operational water-resource planning faces an increased challenge with a changing seasonal snowpack in mountain watersheds due to global and regional climatological factors. An example region is the Western United States, where there is a demonstrated decline in extent and amount of seasonal snow in mountain ranges such as the Sierra Nevada, California, or the Rocky Mountains, Colorado. Causes for the shift include precipitation phase changes or increased amounts of dust on snow. Like the Colorado Basin River Forecast Center (CBRFC), regional forecasters cannot currently account for these factors when their prediction method relies on an empirical snow model based on historic calibration records. To evaluate the options and supplement the current method of the CBRFC, we run a physical-based snow energy balance model for past water years in a subset region; the East River Watershed, Colorado. The results are compared with in-situ measurements, remote sensing observations, and the predictions by the current model. This assessment is an effort to include the process based model in day-to-day CBRFC operations and to create a foundation to expand to larger domains. This project also bridges the gap between scientific advancements and benefits for society with more accurate water resource forecasting.

How to cite: Meyer, J., Skiles, M., Kormos, P., Hedrick, A., Trujillo, E., Havens, S., and Marks, D.: Operational water forecast assessment of a spatially distributed process-based snow model; a case study in the East River Watershed, Colorado, USA, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10454, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10454, 2022.

Tropical regions have experienced rapid Land Use Land Cover Change (LULCC) in the last decades. Furthermore, climate change will likely intensify these changes due to global warming and increased frequency of extreme events. These changes have diverse effects on watershed and river hydro-morphological processes through alterations of the rainfall and runoff patterns, which translate into changes in the water balance components. The magnitude of these effects depends on the watershed characteristics, including the size, extent of change, topography, soil characteristics, and climate. Understanding the watershed hydro-morphological responses to changes in both climate and LULC –especially in tropical regions where rainy seasons are followed by dry seasons— is vital for effective land and water resources management in the face of future changes.

Sebeya catchment in the western part of Rwanda is prone to flooding, associated with erosive processes, and mass movements. Hence, destroying infrastructures and houses, damaging crops, and taking people’s lives yearly during long rainy season (February to May). This is partly attributed to the combination of steep topography and the loss of forest cover on fragile soils, coupled with the increased prevalence of extreme rainfall events. The hypothesis is that the hydro-morphological characteristics of Sebeya river have changed in the last few decades as a result of LULCC, including forest clearing from agriculture and built-up development. In light of it, this study intends to quantify changes in LULC of the Sebeya catchment over the last three decades, and predict future changes in the next three decades, using remote sensing data and LULC model. Furthermore, a hydrologic model will be used to simulate and forecast the associated changes in hydro-morphological and flood frequency.

How to cite: Kayitesi Manishimwe, N. and mariethoz, G.: Modeling River hydro-morphological responses to Land Use Land Cover Change in Tropical Regions, case of Sebeya catchment, Rwanda., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11899, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11899, 2022.

With their complex topography and orographic effects, the amount of solar radiation reaching a surface (insolation) can vary over short distances and time frames in mountainous areas, affecting the spatio-temporal variability of hydrological and ecological processes and contributing to the biodiversity of mountain ecosystems.  The combined effects of variable topography and meteorological conditions on insolation can complicate assessments of how land cover changes affect insolation in mountainous regions as measurement data is often limited to few locations. To incorporate the spatio-temporal variability of sky conditions as well as the spatial variability of terrain in estimates of solar radiation across a montane headwater basin over two summers, we extended an open-source geospatial model of surface solar radiation, r.sun.hourly, to permit the spatially and temporally explicit parameterization of atmospheric conditions at user-specified spatial and temporal resolutions with temporal raster datasets.  Sensitivity analyses indicated that of the three atmospheric parameters in the model, the coefficient of real-sky direct beam solar radiation (coeff_bh) (an index of cloudiness to clear sky conditions) had the greatest influence on insolation estimates for our study area, located in the southern Appalachian Mountains of the southeastern USA, and we developed a workflow for estimating coeff_bh from publicly available geostationary meteorological satellite images (GOES-13, 1 km spatial and 15-minute temporal resolutions).  The extended r.sun.hourly model was parameterized with a bare-earth digital elevation model (1/9 arc-second DEM obtained from the USGS National Map 3-D Elevation Program), the estimated coeff_bh temporal raster datasets (downscaled from 1 km to the DEM resolution), and monthly mean Linke Turbidity values to estimate global solar radiation across the basin at a 15-minute resolution over two summers.  Estimates of instantaneous (15-minute interval) and cumulative total (for 12-hour period bracketing solar noon) global solar radiation were evaluated with pyranometer (Eppley 8-48) measurements of global solar radiation collected by the U.S. Department of Agriculture Forest Service Coweeta Hydrological Laboratory for a total of 144 days (dates with recorded precipitation during daylight hours or incomplete imagery datasets were excluded from analyses).   Despite the low spatial resolution of the satellite images from which the real-sky direct beam radiation coefficient was estimated and the proximity of the ground measurement location to the edges of a GOES-13 cell (< 90 m north and < 230 m east), both instantaneous and daily total estimates of global solar radiation corresponded well with measurements (R2 = 0.81, p-value < 0.001, n = 7056 and R2 = 0.89, p-value < 0.001, n = 144). Estimate errors tended to be lower on cloudier days (MAPE = 6.8%, n = 61) than less cloudy days (MAPE = 13.6%, n = 83).  Offsets in the timing and magnitude of peaks and troughs in insolation over time (with passing clouds) between measurements and estimates were also greater during partly cloudy conditions.  Although these findings are for one location, they suggest the potential of the extended r.sun.hourly model to provide high-resolution estimates of solar radiation, over extensive areas and timeframes, in mountainous regions with remotely sensed elevation and meteorological data.

How to cite: Belica, L., Castro Garrido, M., Petrasova, A., and Nelson, S.: Exploring a method to estimate real-sky global solar radiation in mountainous areas at high resolutions with an open-source geospatial solar radiation model and GOES-13 geostationary meteorological satellite data., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12493, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12493, 2022.

EGU22-172 | Presentations | HS2.1.5 | Highlight

Aufeis impact on the hydrological cycle in the North-Eastern Russia 

Nataliia Nesterova, Olga Makarieva, Andrey Ostashov, Anastasiya Zemlianskova, Andrey Shikhov, and Vladimir Alexeev

Aufeis are produced annually in the rivers valleys in permafrost environment as the result of layer-by-layer freezing of groundwater flowing to the surface. Aufeis are widespread in the territory of the North-East of Eurasia (including the basins of large rivers in permafrost, such as the Yana, Indigirka, Kolyma, Anadyr, Penzhina Rivers and rivers of the Chukchi Peninsula (total area about 2 mln. km2).  They comprise an important water resource of the study region.

Based on the analysis of Landsat satellite images for the period 2013-2019 the number and total maximum area were estimated. As Landsat images do not always allow correctly assess the maximum area of aufeis, it was adjusted to get the maximum value before the beginning of ablation period for the assessment of aufeis resources. Total number of giant aufeis (>0.1 km2) formed by groundwater reaches 6217 with maximum area of about 4500 km2 (in average 0.22 % of studied area). For each aufeis field the assessment of maximum ice reserves was conducted.  

The aufeis resources of the North-East are at least 10.6 km3 or 5 mm of aufeis runoff. The aufeis resources vary from 0.4 to 4.25 km3 (or 3.7 – 11 mm) for individual basins of large rivers. The greatest aufeis resources in absolute values are found in the Indigirka River basin. The contribution of aufeis runoff to streamflow in different seasons was calculated for 58 hydrological gauges (area 523 – 526000 km2). Aufeis annual runoff varies from 0.3 to 29 mm (0.1 – 22%, average 3.8%) with the share in winter runoff amount about 6 – 712 % (average 112%) and the spring freshet 0.2 – 43% (average 7.1%).

The influence of aufeis and glaciers on the water balance is compared – in general, the aufeis runoff exceeds the glacial runoff. The response of aufeis to climate change depends on different factors of the natural system. The dynamics of aufeis formation is directly related to the winter runoff, which changes are observed in different parts of the cryolithozone. The presented results are relevant for studying the impact of climate change on the hydrological cycle and its components in the permafrost regions of the Northern Hemisphere.

The study was carried out with the support of RFBR (19-55-80028, 20-05-00666) and St. Petersburg State University (project 75295879).

How to cite: Nesterova, N., Makarieva, O., Ostashov, A., Zemlianskova, A., Shikhov, A., and Alexeev, V.: Aufeis impact on the hydrological cycle in the North-Eastern Russia, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-172, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-172, 2022.

EGU22-528 | Presentations | HS2.1.5

S3M Italy: a real-time, open-source cryospheric-forecasting chain for applications on a large scale 

Francesco Avanzi, Simone Gabellani, Fabio Delogu, Francesco Silvestro, Silvia Puca, Alexander Toniazzo, Pietro Giordano, Marco Falzacappa, Sara Ratto, Hervè Stevenin, Antonio Cardillo, Edoardo Cremonese, and Umberto Morra di Cella

Monitoring the state of the cryosphere in real time is a key to improved risk and water resources management, especially in a warming climate. All around the world, this goal is achieved through forecasting chains combining models with in-situ and remote-sensing measurements. Here, we discuss lessons learned while developing S3M Italy, one such chain delivering hourly estimates of snow water equivalent, density, snow and glacier melt, and bulk liquid water content across the Italian territory (300k+ km2, 200 m resolution1.5 hour turnaround). S3M Italy includes downloaders to ingest input data from automatic weather stations, spatialization tools to convert these data into weather-input maps, blending routines for deriving daily snow-covered-area maps from ESA Sentinel 2, NASA MODIS, and EUMETSAT H-SAF products, mapping algorithms based on multilinear regressions for assimilating on-the-ground snow-depth data, as well as algorithms to manage parallelized runs and then mosaic model outputs. S3M Italy has been developed to support decisions by the Italian Civil Protection Agency and is fully open source, not only in terms of underlying models (https://github.com/c-hydro/s3m-dev), but also in terms of all pre-processing routines (https://github.com/c-hydro/fp-hydehttps://github.com/c-hydro/fp-s3m). 

How to cite: Avanzi, F., Gabellani, S., Delogu, F., Silvestro, F., Puca, S., Toniazzo, A., Giordano, P., Falzacappa, M., Ratto, S., Stevenin, H., Cardillo, A., Cremonese, E., and Morra di Cella, U.: S3M Italy: a real-time, open-source cryospheric-forecasting chain for applications on a large scale, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-528, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-528, 2022.

EGU22-859 | Presentations | HS2.1.5

On the identification of hydrogeological reservoirs in a proglacial catchment and their future groundwater storage 

Tom Müller, Bettina Schaefli, and Stuart N. Lane

Rapid glacier retreat leads to the emergence of new rocky landscapes. The common assumption of the presence of bare bedrock underlying glaciers and the closely related assumption that glacier and snow melt manifest themselves essentially as surface runoff, is challenged by the rapid sediment accumulation and the formation of geomorphological landforms where water may be infiltrated and stored. Although some studies have provided rough estimates of groundwater storage and release in high elevation catchments, the actual reservoirs providing baseflow discharge are difficult to identify. While the combined effect of future glacier decline and earlier snowmelt are well recognized, it remains unclear how the rapid hydrogeomorphological transformations will modify the potential groundwater stores.

In this study we will provide results of a case study of a glaciated catchment in the Swiss Alps. Firstly, we will discuss, based on a simple modelling approach, the hydrological functioning of different landforms and show to which extend each hydrological unit is currently contributing to groundwater storage. We will then focus on a detailed assessment of the hydrological dynamics of an outwash plain using a 3D Modflow modelling approach. We will show how such a small fluvial aquifer is connected to other landforms and how it can maintain high storage during much longer time scales than other landforms due to strong river-groundwater interactions. Even though the current storage of the outwash plain is limited, we will discuss how glacier retreat may increase its relative contribution in the future. Finally, we will focus on the remaining unidentified storages in our field study and we will provide some geochemical analysis of their potential location and finally conclude with a summary of the hydrogeological functioning of a rapidly deglaciating proglacial catchment.

How to cite: Müller, T., Schaefli, B., and Lane, S. N.: On the identification of hydrogeological reservoirs in a proglacial catchment and their future groundwater storage, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-859, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-859, 2022.

EGU22-1106 | Presentations | HS2.1.5 | Highlight

Future hydrology of the cryospheric driven Lake Como catchment in Italy under climate change scenarios 

Fuso Flavia, Casale Francesca, Giudici Federico, and Bocchiola Daniele

In this paper we analyse the future hydrology of the Lake Como catchment under climate change scenarios. The management of the lake is extremely important because it is needed both to supply water for the irrigation demand of the Po Valley, and to prevent flood risk along the lake shores. The climate variations are affecting the lake operation with negative impacts both on agriculture and hydropower production. The lake dynamics are link to the cryospheric driven upstream basin, and so the use of a model able to assess the water input as related to snow cover processes is a key issue. Accordingly, we use the physically based hydrological model Poli-hydro able to represent the most important process in the cryospheric driven catchment. We set up and calibrated the model against lake inflows during 2002-2018, resulting in a mean error Bias = +2.15%, and a monthly/daily Nash-Sutcliff efficiency, NSE = 0.77/0.64. We then performed a stochastic disaggregation of 3 Global Circulation Models (GCMs) of the most recent Assessment report 6 (AR6) of the IPCC, under 4 different socio-economic pathways (SSPs), from which we derived daily series of rainfall and temperature to be used as inputs for the hydrological model Poli-Hydro. The climate projections show a potential increase of temperature at the end of the century between +0.61°C and +5.96°C, which would lead to a decrease of the total ice volume in the catchment of -50% and -77%, respectively. Future projections show generally an increase of discharge in autumn and winter (November-March) and a reduction in spring and summer (May-September). This is due to the increase of temperature with an increase of liquid precipitation instead of solid precipitation in winter and an anticipation of the snow melt peak at the beginning of spring. Possible consequences are the increase of flood hazard in the winter period and a scarcity of water availability in summer. A new regulation of Lake Como is essential to satisfy stakeholders requests.

How to cite: Flavia, F., Francesca, C., Federico, G., and Daniele, B.: Future hydrology of the cryospheric driven Lake Como catchment in Italy under climate change scenarios, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1106, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1106, 2022.

EGU22-1338 | Presentations | HS2.1.5

Evaluating the hydrological regime of the snow-fed and glaciated Hunza basin in the Hindukush Karakorum Himalaya (HKH) region 

Aftab Nazeer, Shreedhar Maskey, Thomas Skaugen, and Michael E. McClain

In the high altitude Hindukush Karakorum Himalaya (HKH) mountainous region, the complex weather and terrain and sparse measurements make the precipitation distribution and hydrological regime significant unknowns. Recent advances in remote-sensing and reanalysis-based global precipitation products and numerical models may provide more insights on the hydro-climatic regimes for such regions. This study examined the precipitation distribution and snow and glacier melt contributions to river flow in the highly glaciated and snow-fed Hunza basin of the Karakorum mountains. The Distance Distribution Dynamics (DDD), a rainfall-runoff model with its temperature index and an energy balance approach for glacial melt, was used. The model was forced with precipitation estimates based on a newly developed and fine resolution (0.1°×0.1°) gridded product of ERA5-Land. The model calibration and validation were performed from 1997–2005 and 2006–2010, respectively. The mean annual precipitation of the Hunza basin was estimated as 947 mm from 1997–2010. The precipitation distribution analysis showed more precipitation at lower elevations than at higher. The simulated snow cover area (SCA) was in good agreement with MODIS satellite-based SCA. The flow analysis indicated that the Hunza’s flow is strongly controlled by glacier melt (44–47 %) followed by snowmelt (31–32 %) and rainfall (22–23 %). The simulations showed that the DDD model has good potential to simulate hydrological processes satisfactorily for data-scarce basins.

How to cite: Nazeer, A., Maskey, S., Skaugen, T., and E. McClain, M.: Evaluating the hydrological regime of the snow-fed and glaciated Hunza basin in the Hindukush Karakorum Himalaya (HKH) region, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1338, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1338, 2022.

EGU22-2690 | Presentations | HS2.1.5

Changes in glacier and snow melt contributions to streamflow in James Ross Island, Antarctic Peninsula 

Michal Jenicek, Ondrej Nedelcev, and Jan Kavan

Antarctica has been significantly warming in the last decades. According to climate projections, the increase in air temperature is likely to continue in the future, which will affect runoff dynamics due to glacier retreat and changes in snow cover. Despite the large changes in glacier volume in some parts of Antarctica, little is known about streamflow dynamics and contribution of different water sources to total catchment runoff. Therefore, the objective of our research was to 1) describe runoff dynamics in six catchments located in the Ulu Peninsula, James Ross Island, which represents one of the largest deglaciated areas in Antarctica and 2) to assess the inter-annual variations in glacier melt, snowmelt and potentially rain contributions to runoff over the years 2015 – 2021. The study catchments have different glaciation, and thus considerable diurnal regime of streamflow. Streamflow measurements performed in 2018 austral summer were used to describe the streamflow dynamics of the six catchments. Additionally, a conceptual bucket-type catchment model has been set-up for two of the six catchments, first partly glacierized and second without glacier coverage. In-situ measurements of glacier ablations (2015–2019) and daily precipitation and air temperature partly measured directly at automatic weather stations located in the catchments and partly derived from ERA5-land reanalysis were used as model inputs. Since water level and streamflow data are limited for the study area, a genetic algorithm procedure was used to calibrate the model.

Direct streamflow measurements performed in 2018 austral summer showed the largest variations in Triangular and Shark Streams, which represent the most glaciated catchments among all study catchments. The less variable streamflow was found in Algal Stream, a completely deglaciated catchment. Highest streamflow was recorded in late afternoon, whereas minimum streamflow was recorded in late night or early morning which suggests the strong diurnal regime. In glacierized catchments, the streamflow responded fast on increased air temperature and solar radiation during day. In contrast, soil water stored in the active layer and snow patches mostly controlled streamflow dynamics in deglaciated catchments. Besides, the runoff response was somewhat delayed in these catchments compared to glaciated catchments due to temporal subsurface storage. The above findings were proved also by model simulations, which extended streamflow data for the period 2015-2021. Besides, the simulations showed different glacier and snow contributions to total runoff in study catchments and also different times of streamflow responses to changes in meteorological inputs in combination with different catchment storages which influence runoff delays.

How to cite: Jenicek, M., Nedelcev, O., and Kavan, J.: Changes in glacier and snow melt contributions to streamflow in James Ross Island, Antarctic Peninsula, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2690, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2690, 2022.

EGU22-2805 | Presentations | HS2.1.5

Assessment of streamflow trends in snow and glacier melt dominated catchments of SW Spitsbergen 

Marzena Osuch, Tomasz Wawrzyniak, and Elżbieta Łepkowska

The study focuses on the changes in the regime of the four High Arctic catchments in the last 40 years taking into account different percentages of glacial coverage. The selected catchments include Breelva, Ariebekken, Bratteggbekken and Fuglebekken with glacial coverage of 61%, 11.8%, 5.9% and 0% respectively.

The flow time series in the selected catchments were simulated using a glacio-hydrological model calibrated and validated based on the available archival hydro-meteorological data.

In the second step, the reconstructed flows from the period 1979-2020 were filtered and smoothed. This allowed for delineation of the seasonal pattern by filtering out small scale variability. The changes in flow regime were assessed with trend analysis for each calendar day.

Similar trends of change were detected in all studied catchments due to similar locations in the SW Spitsbergen and climatic conditions. These changes include the earlier onset of snowmelt driven floods, large increases in autumn flows, prolongation of the hydrologically active season (starts earlier and lasts longer), decrease in flows in the latter half of June and the early part of August (except for the Breelva catchment). These changes resulted in the changes of flood regime from snowmelt-dominated to the bi-modal with peaks in both July/August and September.

A comparison of the changes between the four catchments indicated differences in the magnitude of hydrological response depending on the percentage of glacial coverage in the catchments. The larger the glacierized area is, the larger the changes in the flow regime. The estimated changes are larger than observed in lower latitudes due to larger changes in climatic conditions.

How to cite: Osuch, M., Wawrzyniak, T., and Łepkowska, E.: Assessment of streamflow trends in snow and glacier melt dominated catchments of SW Spitsbergen, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2805, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2805, 2022.

EGU22-3798 | Presentations | HS2.1.5

Water Towers of the Pamirs: I. Precipitation and temperature trends 

Zulfiqor Khojazoda, Roy Sidle, and Arnaud Caiserman

Precipitation and temperature changes across the Vakhsh and Panj basins are of great importance for Tajikistan, Afghanistan, Turkmenistan, and Uzbekistan for consumption, agricultural, and energy purposes. While studies of precipitation and temperature trends have been conducted in these basins, attention to their heterogenous topography and nature have not been considered and analyzed together with glacial and permafrost melt. Here, we assessed the trends of precipitation and temperature over the last 20 years using remote sensing products. For precipitation, we used research grade daily GPM IMERG V06 Final Run from 2001 to 2020. Similarly, temperature MODIS Land Surface Temperature & Emissivity (LST&E) (MOD11A1) was used to assess temperature trends and separate liquid from solid precipitation. Annual precipitation and temperature trends were also assessed in three elevation bands: low (317-2225m), middle (2225-4500m) and high (4500-7543m).

Positive significant trends for solid precipitation mainly arise in the northern parts of the basins, while slightly positive with more negative trends occurred over the central and southern parts of the Panj basin. A significant solid precipitation trend of +1.30mm y-1 below 2225 m a.s.l. occurred in late spring. Many of the pixels (1 x 1 km) across the study region that exhibited significant trends were increases in temperature, especially in the high elevations in the eastern portion of the basins. There was a significant annual increase of liquid precipitation coupled with a decrease in solid precipitation and an increase in temperature trend in the central Pamirs, implying a shift from solid to liquid precipitation. An increase in rainfall below 4500 m a.s.l. was observed, where the largest increases occurred in the western portions of these basins with nearly no significant temperature trends; thus, potentially having a positive influence on agricultural and community water supplies. However, long-term water supplies in the dry regions of the central and eastern parts of the basins may create supply vulnerabilities.

How to cite: Khojazoda, Z., Sidle, R., and Caiserman, A.: Water Towers of the Pamirs: I. Precipitation and temperature trends, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3798, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3798, 2022.

EGU22-4005 | Presentations | HS2.1.5

The surprising weather conditions favoring artificial ice reservoirs (Icestupas) 

Suryanarayanan Balasubramanian, Martin Hoelzle, Michael Lehning, Jordi Bolibar, Sonam Wangchuk, Johannes Oerlemans, and Felix Keller

Since 2014, mountain communities in Ladakh, India have been constructing dozens of ArtificialIce Reservoirs (AIRs) by spraying water through fountain systems every winter. The meltwater from these structures is crucial to meet irrigation water demands during spring. However, there is a large variability associated with this water supply due to the local weather influences at the chosen location. This study compared the ice volume evolution of an AIR built in Ladakh, India with two others built in Guttannen, Switzerland using a surface energy balance model. Model input consisted of meteorological data in conjunction with fountain discharge rate (mass input of an AIR). Validation with drone’s ice volume observations shows the model performs well. Our results show that the conical shape of AIRs significantly reduce solar radiation-induced melt. The location in Ladakh had a maximum ice volume four times larger compared to the Guttannen site. However, the corresponding water losses for all the AIRs were more than three-quarters of the total fountain discharge due to high fountain wastewater. Drier and colder locations in relatively cloud-free regions are expected to produce long-lasting AIRs with higher maximum ice volumes. This is a promising result for dry mountain regions, where AIR technology could provide a relatively affordable and sustainable strategy to mitigate climate change induced water stress.

 

How to cite: Balasubramanian, S., Hoelzle, M., Lehning, M., Bolibar, J., Wangchuk, S., Oerlemans, J., and Keller, F.: The surprising weather conditions favoring artificial ice reservoirs (Icestupas), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4005, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4005, 2022.

EGU22-4317 | Presentations | HS2.1.5

Glacier runoff variation since 1981 in the upper Naryn river catchments, Central Tien Shan 

Tomas Saks, Eric Pohl, Horst Machguth, Amaury Dehecq, Martina Barandun, Ruslan Kenzhebaev, Olga Kalashnikova, and Martin Hoelzle

Water resources in Central Asia strongly depend on glaciers, which in turn adjust their size in response to climate variations. We investigate glacier runoff in the period 1981–2019 in the upper Naryn basin, Kyrgyzstan. The basins contain more than 1000 glaciers, which cover a total area of 776 km2. We model the mass balance and runoff contribution of all glaciers with a simplified energy balance melt model and distributed accumulation model driven by ERA5 LAND re-analysis data for the time period of 1981 - 2019. The results are evaluated against discharge records, satellite-derived snow cover, stake readings from individual glaciers, and geodetic mass balances. Modelled glacier volume decreased by approximately 6.7 km3 or 14%, and the majority of the mass loss took place from 1996 until 2019. The decreasing trend is the result of increasingly negative summer mass balances whereas winter mass balances show no substantial trend. Analysis of the discharge data suggests an increasing runoff for the past two decades, which is, however only partly reflected in an increase of glacier melt. Moreover, the strongest increase in discharge is observed in winter, suggesting either a prolonged melting period and/or increased groundwater discharge. The average runoff from the glacierized areas in summer months (June to August) constitutes approximately 23% of the total contributions to the basin's runoff. The results highlight the strong regional variability in glacier-climate interactions in Central Asia.

How to cite: Saks, T., Pohl, E., Machguth, H., Dehecq, A., Barandun, M., Kenzhebaev, R., Kalashnikova, O., and Hoelzle, M.: Glacier runoff variation since 1981 in the upper Naryn river catchments, Central Tien Shan, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4317, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4317, 2022.

EGU22-4705 | Presentations | HS2.1.5

Water Towers of the Pamirs: II. Cryosphere dynamics and implications for runoff and livelihoods 

Roy C Sidle, Arnaud Caiserman, Álvaro Salazar, and Zulfiqor T Khojazoda

Cryosphere components in the Pamirs play an important role in the release of water to the Vakhsh and Panj river systems where both mountain and downstream communities rely on sustainable water supplies for their agriculture, potable water, and hydropower. Of the three primary cryosphere sources of water (glacial, snow, and permafrost melt), glacial melt is the most predictable and constitutes and intermediate supply of runoff to streams, while almost no estimates of permafrost contributions are available. Snowmelt is highly variable from year to year and because it is the largest water supply to these rivers, understanding the potential amount and timing of snowmelt is critical for local communities.  

Based on our remote sensing investigations during the past 20 years, we water found wide interannual variations in snow water, snowline elevation, and snow persistence throughout the Vakhsh and Paji basins, but no clear evidence of basin-wide climate change trends. Specific locations of the central Pamirs appear to be shifting from snow to rain due to climate warming, approximately offsetting each other, but likely producing more runoff in late spring to early summer and less in mid to late summer. In the high, glaciated Vakhsh basin, temperature increases have been offset by higher snowfall, resulting in little glacial ice change. By overlaying maps of glaciers on a digital elevation model (Alos Palsar 12.5 m) containing stream networks, we estimated that about 75% of the glaciers were closely connected to first-order or larger channels; however, this may be a liberal estimate because some first-order streams are not connected to major river systems. Based on the TTOP model nearly 24,000 km2 of continuous permafrost terrain exists throughout the Panj and Vakhsh basins, the majority of which is located at elevations > 3577 m. Streamflow contributions from permafrost thaw during the summer were estimated as subsurface flux from streambanks; ≈ 638 x 106 m3 each summer, which represents about 1.5% of the average annual river discharge for both basins.

The climate variability and localized changes we observed pose challenges for predicting runoff from high elevation cold regions due to the altered patterns of the timing of snow, glacier, and permafrost accumulation and melt, including temporal changes, interannual variability, and hydrological connectivity of sources. The various water sources will respond differently in a changing climate, generating complex runoff scenarios and socioeconomic consequences downstream.

How to cite: Sidle, R. C., Caiserman, A., Salazar, Á., and Khojazoda, Z. T.: Water Towers of the Pamirs: II. Cryosphere dynamics and implications for runoff and livelihoods, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4705, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4705, 2022.

EGU22-6025 | Presentations | HS2.1.5

Integrating glacier flow in hydrological modelling for water resources management 

Andrea Momblanch, Tejal Shirsat, Anil Kulkarni, and Ian P Holman

The climate emergency will drive changes in the cryosphere and hydrology of high mountain catchments, with subsequent influences on water resources availability. Process-based hydrological and glaciological models require significant amounts of data which are often unavailable in high mountainous catchments, especially in developing countries, and are unable to explicitly integrate human-induced factors on river flows (Momblanch et al. 2019). This can be overcome by water resources systems models that take a more conceptual approach. However, they currently have limited capability to represent glacier evolution and thus river discharge dynamics, especially in long-term simulations required for climate change impact and adaptation analysis. There is, therefore, a clear need for improved representation of the spatio-temporal response of glaciers within water resources systems models to support the strategic water resources planning and management and ensure future water security.

The Water and Evaluation and Planning system (WEAP; Yates et al. 2005) is widely used in water resources management studies by both the scientific and decision-making communities around the world. WEAP includes a glacier module which accounts for ice accumulation and melt using the enhanced temperature-index method, but overlooks other processes such as glacier area change, snow redistribution, sublimation and ice flow. These omissions will severely impact the validity and utility of long-term simulations, especially in regions with very rough topography such as the Himalayas.

This research reports the development and application of an enhanced glacier modelling capability in the WEAP software that introduces ice flow dynamics. Through the integration of elevation bands and remote sensing-derived glacier velocities, a ‘plug-in’ extension into WEAP’s Application Programming Interface allows glacier routing to be represented. The Aleo catchment in the upper reaches of the Indus basin in the Western Himalayas is used as a case study to showcase the ‘plug-in’ and to compare outputs with other process-based models. The results show that the enhanced glacier model significantly improves the simulation of the main glacier variables, i.e. mass balance, depth and volume, with respect to the original glacier model in WEAP. The research outputs contribute to a better understanding of climate change impacts on high mountain hydrology, which is key for regional development.

 

References

Momblanch, A., Holman, I., Jain, S., 2019. Current Practice and Recommendations for Modelling Global Change Impacts on Water Resource in the Himalayas. Water 11, 1303. doi:10.3390/w11061303

Yates, D., Purkey, D., Sieber, J., Huber-Lee, A., Galbraith, H., 2005. WEAP21—A Demand-, Priority-, and Preference-Driven Water Planning Model. Water Int. 30, 501–512. doi:10.1080/02508060508691894

How to cite: Momblanch, A., Shirsat, T., Kulkarni, A., and Holman, I. P.: Integrating glacier flow in hydrological modelling for water resources management, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6025, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6025, 2022.

EGU22-6871 | Presentations | HS2.1.5

Dissecting the subseasonal and altitudinal water balance of a high-elevation Himalayan catchment using a land surface model 

Pascal Buri, Simone Fatichi, Thomas E. Shaw, Evan S. Miles, Michael McCarthy, Catriona Fyffe, Stefan Fugger, Shaoting Ren, Marin Kneib, Koji Fujita, and Francesca Pellicciotti

The snow and glacier reservoirs of High Mountain Asia play a key role in sustaining water supply to mountain communities and downstream ecosystems, populations and economic activities. However, little is known about how rain, snow- and ice melt vary sub-seasonally and along the altitudinal gradient in high-elevation watersheds.

We generate detailed simulations of catchment hydrology using a land surface model that constrains energy and mass fluxes using advanced physical representations of both cryospheric and biospheric processes in high detail at 100 m spatial resolution. We use the model to study how snow and glacier processes affect the hydrological cycle and how vegetation can mediate water yield from the high mountains of a glacierized Himalayan catchment downstream. This bridges the modelling gap between snow- and glacier dynamics, which generate the runoff, and vegetation processes, which interfere with runoff production and water uses at lower elevations.

We study the upper Langtang catchment (~4000-7000 m a.s.l.) in the Nepalese Himalayas, and simulate catchment runoff for two hydrological years (2017-2019), revealing the relative importance of precipitation, snow, ice, soil moisture and vegetation for different elevations and seasons. The land surface model is forced with hourly meteorological input data based on the main weather station in the basin and air temperature and precipitation were spatially distributed using observed elevational gradients. 

We calibrate a minimal set of parameters (physical properties of supraglacial debris) and use integrative variables such as catchment runoff or glacier mass balance only for validation. The availability of a rich dataset of field- and remote sensing observations allows validation of numerous physical processes simulated by the model and drastically reduces the probability of internal error compensation.

The model provides detailed insights into the importance of each of the energy and mass balance components in the catchment water budget and shows that evaporative fluxes are non-negligible contributors to mass loss at very high elevations (especially from snow) and in the lower part of the catchment (transpiration from vegetation). Often neglected or derived as a bulk quantity in simpler model approaches, evaporation accounts for about 15% of the water leaving the basin. We show precipitation to be the major source of uncertainty in the simulations and that vegetation is relevant in determining the amount of runoff transferred further downstream even for high elevation, extensively glacierized Himalayan catchments.

How to cite: Buri, P., Fatichi, S., Shaw, T. E., Miles, E. S., McCarthy, M., Fyffe, C., Fugger, S., Ren, S., Kneib, M., Fujita, K., and Pellicciotti, F.: Dissecting the subseasonal and altitudinal water balance of a high-elevation Himalayan catchment using a land surface model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6871, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6871, 2022.

EGU22-7605 | Presentations | HS2.1.5 | Highlight

Future effects of glacier retreat on downstream runoff and hydropower generation in the Alps 

Mario Wallner, Jakob Abermann, Gabriel Bachner, Elisabeth Frei, Wolfgang Schöner, and Karl Steininger

Due to climate change, glaciers are retreating worldwide. Among different consequences, the decline of meltwater in rivers will lead to a reduction in runoff. The aim of this work is to quantify the changes in runoff and the impact on selected hydropower plants in different drainage basins in the Alps until 2100.

Outputs from the Global Glacier Evolution Model (GloGEM), which uses 14 General Circulation Models to compute the future evolution of the glaciers worldwide, were used to determine past and future runoff from glaciers individual hydropower plants’ catchments. Measured runoff data at selected locations along rivers was used to compute the share of glacier runoff in total discharge. The computed river runoff was subsequently applied to determine the reduced electricity production of the hydropower plants.

The results reveal a decrease in summer runoff at all investigated power plants by 2100. However, large differences occur among the different catchments. In particular, geographical characteristics, such as glacier size and altitude, determine the intensity and timing of the decline. Areas located further away from glaciers, particularly in the North of the Eastern Alps, show the strongest reduction in glacier runoff (up to 86% compared to 1986-2015). In contrast, mountainous catchments and the South of the Alps are mostly affected by a decrease in river discharge (up to 33% compared to 1986-2015). Due to the dry summer climate, the summer runoff in these areas is reliant on the glacier discharge. This is also evident in the impact on hydropower production. For the run-of-river plants along the Rhone, one has to expect a decrease in summer production of up to 20%, which corresponds to an annual loss of € 5.3 Million. The losses are even higher for storage power plants located in catchments with a big glacier cover. For these, annual losses of up to € 35.0 Million were determined for the period 2071-2100.

How to cite: Wallner, M., Abermann, J., Bachner, G., Frei, E., Schöner, W., and Steininger, K.: Future effects of glacier retreat on downstream runoff and hydropower generation in the Alps, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7605, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7605, 2022.

EGU22-7894 | Presentations | HS2.1.5

Snow/rain source mixing and residence time modeling in a sub-alpine mountainous catchment under global warming 

Aniket Gupta, Didier Voisin, and Jean-Martial Cohard

Mountain catchments behavior is largely governed by snow accumulation and melting regime. These intricate water fluxes sustain the streamflow response for several months and maintain the surface moisture until late summer. The melting snow slowly percolates to the subsurface recharging underground reservoirs which later sustain the ecosystem during the dry periods. During the summer periods in mountainous catchment the rain contributes more to the surface runoff because of steep slopes. In this study, we hypothesise that middle elevation mountain catchments under a warming climate will shift from a snow hydrological recharging behavior to a flash flood behavior. We used ParFLOW-CLM, a fully distributed physical based surface-subsurface coupled integrated hydrological model to show how much water budget partitioning will change on a small subalpine mid-elevation (2000-2200 m) catchment at col du Lautaret (France). With a 10 m hyper-resolution setup, ParFLOW-CLM helps us to distinguish between the Hortonian and Dunian runoff along with the velocity of water movement in the x-y-z direction. Further, we applied a Lagrangian particle tracking model, EcoSLIM, to track the location, movement and residence time of the snow and rain sources. After running the model for the present climate we selected CMIP6 climate model projections that lead to temperature rise from 1 °C to 2.5 °C. The present climate results show that the snowmelt contributes to 90 % of subsurface source particles compared to rain and has a higher residence time in the catchment. These snow particles along with sustaining the streamflow also help in providing water to plants and evapotranspiration during the dry periods. Under warmer climates, the snow to rain ratio decrease leads to more surface runoff and less recharge to the subsurface. The decrease in subsurface recharge leads to reduced surface moisture in the dry season, which directly impacts the evaporation and transpiration through the vegetation. Hence, the rapid global warming leads to a decrease in the snow and subsurface storage which may impact downstream communities in terms of water availability, and at the same time, decrease water availability for the mountain vegetation through reduced surface moisture. In conjunction, the overall mountain ecosystem gets adversely impacted.

How to cite: Gupta, A., Voisin, D., and Cohard, J.-M.: Snow/rain source mixing and residence time modeling in a sub-alpine mountainous catchment under global warming, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7894, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7894, 2022.

Central Asia's river systems are largely fed by reliable snow and glacier melt which allows agricultural production in the dry lowlands and hydropower production. However, climate forcing is changing faster than ever and predictions of river discharge relying on past observations (as are currently applied by Central Asia’s Hydrometeorological Agencies) may no longer pass stringent quality criteria for good forecasts. There is a growing need for hydrological models for nexus studies and the feasibility study for small hydropower plants in the region. Central Asia is a large region with a sparse hydrometeorological monitoring network which makes it difficult to calibrate hydrological models with traditional methods. It is therefore good news that the amount of remotely sensed data or data from reanalysis products has been increasing in both quantity, and quality in the past few years. Such data offers a huge potential to improve hydrological modelling efforts but the required pre-processing of such data often exceeds the capacities of local stakeholders in Central Asia which does not allow them to valorize these data. As local workflows being digitized, tools need to be developed to facilitate the integration of improved model forcing and modelling techniques in applied hydrology. 

The present study uses the daily CHELSA-W5E5 v1.1 data set at daily 1km by 1km resolution, which is an ERA5 derivative with corrections for high mountain regions, to force degree-day melt models for glaciers and semi-distributed hydrological models using HBV. We combine the data from the Randolph Glacier Inventory in the region with recently available information on individual glacier elevation change (2000 - 2019), thickness and glacier discharge (2000 - 2016) to calibrate degree-day melt models for glaciers in Central Asia and to estimate daily glacier discharge until the end of the century for the 4 GCM models of the CIMIP6 climate projections with the highest priority for the region and for 4 socio-economic scenarios (i.e. 16 modeling scenarios). We also validate existing glacier volume, length and area scaling relationships for Central Asian glaciers from the literature. 

The glacier discharge time series is used as a source to a semi-distributed hydrological model to estimate the future water availability of the river Koksu,  a tributary to the Shakhimardan catchment in the south of the Fergana valley, and is a key input for the design of a small-hydropower plant. We further demonstrate a workflow to calibrate the snow components of the HBV modules in the hydrological model using the high mountain snow reanalysis product. 

We strive to streamline the use of such novel data products in the hydrological modelling process for Central Asian river basins by developing a suite of publicly available R packages & vignettes that facilitate data processing and modelling. The presented modelling effort is part of the ongoing EU Horizon 2020 project Hydro4U which aims at promoting sustainable small-hydropower solutions in Central Asia. The project's demonstration site of Shakhimardan is especially interesting because of its sensitive transboundary nature and the potential for socio-economic development in this remote enclave which is frequently cut off from power supply.

How to cite: Marti, B., Karger, D., and Siegfried, T.: Using recent public glacier data sets to calibrate glacier melt models and drive hydrological models in Central Asia: Facilitating hydrological modelling workflows, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7983, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7983, 2022.

EGU22-8568 | Presentations | HS2.1.5

Simulation of river flow in the Gunt River Basin in Tajikistan 

Ben Jarihani, Anastasia Zemlyanskova, and Olga Makarieva

Mountainous regions of the world are the source of water for large amount of population living downstream. This is also the case for Pamir Mountains in Tajikistan which produces majority of the water for the several countries in the region. Despite increasing impacts of climate change, last several decades, there have been critical decrease of number of monitoring networks in mountainous areas of Central Asia bringing high uncertainty to water resources management and planning. In this study we investigate the possibility to combine the remote sensing data, ground observations and a modelling approach to estimate discharge of Gunt River in the Eastern Pamir, Tajikistan. The Gunt River watershed is of great importance for the region, as about 60 settlements are concentrated along the entire length of the river, including the administrative city of Khorog. Two hydropower stations were built in the lower reaches of the river to provide electricity for the local communities. These headwater glacier-fed basins of Central Asia are particularly vulnerable; as climate change threatens water supply from glacier systems and increases evaporative losses, while demand to irrigation water and electricity is rising. This uncertainty in water supply can result, to a deterioration in the development of the economy and the quality of life in the region. Therefore, for sustainable electricity production and economic development in the region, a better understanding of water availability in the river, is required.

 

The aim of the study is to assess the characteristics of the flow regime of the Gunt River. We used "Hydrograph" hydrological model to simulate daily discharge of the Gunt River. The model algorithms combine physically based and conceptual approaches to describe snow and glacier melting and runoff generation processes. "Hydrograph" model has also successfully used to simulate river flow in Varzob River with similar climatic conditions in Tajikistan. Parametrization of the model including the assessment of precipitation distribution in the high mountainous areas is based on the data from the research watershed of the Varzob River with long term historical data availability. The verification and evaluation of the model was conducted based on the historical data (1970-1980) using data from the Dzhavshangoz and Khorog meteorological stations. The model performance and simulations for the recent period (2000-2020) were also evaluated by using the remote sensing data. The results have shown satisfactory quality with difference between the observed and simulated runoff does not exceed 2%. In general, the results of the paper confirm the possibility of using the deterministic model "Hydrograph" to simulate the daily water runoff in the river which is critical for hydropower and irrigation purposes. However, the lack of accurate information on distribution of precipitation in the catchment, significantly reduces the model results accuracy. The study was carried out with the support of St. Petersburg State University (project 75295879).

How to cite: Jarihani, B., Zemlyanskova, A., and Makarieva, O.: Simulation of river flow in the Gunt River Basin in Tajikistan, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8568, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8568, 2022.

EGU22-8570 | Presentations | HS2.1.5 | Highlight

Can fully satellite-products-driven simple models account for snow processes in data scarce regions? 

Dhiraj Raj Gyawali and András Bárdossy

This study investigates satellite-based information driven snow accounting routines to simulate snow processes in mountainous regimes that are inherently associated with data scarcity. Simple, independent and parsimonious snow accounting routines that are fully driven by remote sensing (RS) information such as the land surface temperatures and snow-cover information along with distributed temperature index-based snow-melt models, are presented. RS based snow-cover distribution does not only provide the crucial information on areal extent of snow, but can also be a highly imperative proxy for the precipitation accumulations in these data scarce regions, as the availability and resolution of the data doesn’t depend on the mountainous terrain. These models are calibrated independently on the snow-cover distribution, can be coupled with any rainfall-runoff models to simulate “snow-processes informed” discharge and are flexible enough to be extended to a wide geographical extent. These models, in addition to simulating the snow accumulation and melt processes, also use the timing of snow appearance and disappearance. This accounting of snow can be inverted to obtain seasonal precipitation estimates in data scarce snow dominated regions, which can be a very crucial information for water resources planning. Specific results pertaining to the validation of the models in Switzerland and southern Germany (ungauged scenario) are shown. 

How to cite: Gyawali, D. R. and Bárdossy, A.: Can fully satellite-products-driven simple models account for snow processes in data scarce regions?, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8570, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8570, 2022.

EGU22-8896 | Presentations | HS2.1.5

Combining high resolution atmospheric simulations and land-surface modelling to understand high elevation snow processes in an Himalayan catchment 

Achille Jouberton, Yota Sato, Akihiro Hashimoto, Masashi Niwano, Thomas E. Shaw, Evan S. Miles, Pascal Buri, Stefan Fugger, Michael McCarthy, Koji Fujita, and Francesca Pellicciotti

Glaciers are key components of the Asian water towers and provide water to large downstream communities for domestic, agricultural and industrial uses. In the Nepal Himalaya, the Indian Summer Monsoon dominates climate, and results in a complex meteorology and simultaneous accumulation and ablation that complicate the quantification of snow processes. Assessing solid precipitation input, especially in the upper accumulation area (> 6000 m a.s.l.), remains key to understanding recent mass losses. Catchment-scale glacio-hydrological modelling in the Himalaya has to date mostly relied on temperature-index or intermediate-complexity enhanced temperature-index methods, but recent studies have shown that such approaches can lead to inaccurate amounts of melt, especially at high elevations where refreezing, sublimation and avalanches influence the snow depth variability. The Trakarding–Trambau Glacier system experienced significant mass loss over the last decades, and recent field measurements of meteorology and glacier change present the opportunity to examine these problems with physically-based and spatially-resolved atmospheric and glacio-hydrological modelling.

We combine a novel non-hydrostatic atmospheric model (NHM; atmospheric core of the cryosphere-oriented regional climate model NHM-SMAP) and an advanced land surface model at cloud-permitting hyper-resolution (~ 100 m) to explore the role of snow processes in the water balance of this glacierized catchment. We force the land-surface model of the catchment with dynamically downscaled, hourly outputs from  NHM for the 2018-2019 hydrological year. We evaluate the NHM output using available in-situ meteorological observations  and evaluate the land surface model skills and process representation with in-situ mass balance observations, remotely sensed surface elevation change and snow cover. Coupling of the two types of models is unprecedented in the Himalaya, and holds promise to reveal processes that cannot be explicitly assessed by simpler models or forcing data. We investigate the contribution of sublimation and precipitation partition to the glacier mass balance and catchment runoff, and analyze the difference in mass balance and its drivers between the debris-covered and debris free-glaciers. To place this very novel type of simulations into the context of current research, we compare our NHM-forced simulations with simulations forced by station data and ERA5-Land reanalysis.  Finally, we evaluate the effect of spatial resolution (50 m, 100 m, 200 m) on model performance and process representation. 

Our results highlight the potential of sophisticated models based on the calculations of energy and mass fluxes to unravel the complex processes that shape the response of Himalayan catchments, and provide an assessment of their skills as a function of spatial resolution.

How to cite: Jouberton, A., Sato, Y., Hashimoto, A., Niwano, M., Shaw, T. E., Miles, E. S., Buri, P., Fugger, S., McCarthy, M., Fujita, K., and Pellicciotti, F.: Combining high resolution atmospheric simulations and land-surface modelling to understand high elevation snow processes in an Himalayan catchment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8896, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8896, 2022.

EGU22-9049 | Presentations | HS2.1.5

A novel method to understand the interaction between a patchy snow cover and the adjacent atmosphere 

Michael Haugeneder, Michael Lehning, Tobias Jonas, and Rebecca Mott

Late in the ablation season the snow cover gets patchy. The resulting surface temperature gradients and the lateral advection of heat over the partial snow cover engage different atmospheric processes such as the development of stable internal boundary layers (SIBL) or atmospheric decoupling close to the snow surface. Even though lateral advection of heat and the resulting atmospheric phenomena significantly influence the energy balance of the melting snow pack in spring, there is a lack of understanding and, thus, they are not explicitly taken into account in snow melt runoff models yet.
To gain further understanding of those complex near-surface atmospheric processes at the meter to sub-meter scale, we conducted a comprehensive field campaign at an alpine research site. The field campaign included the measurement of meteorological parameters, snow ablation pattern, and turbulence using eddy-covariance sensors. Furthermore, we applied a novel experimental method. Two thin synthetic screens were vertically, in parallel to the prevailing wind direction, deployed across the transition from bare ground to snow covering a horizontal distance of 6m. The screens quickly adapt to ambient temperature and, thus, serve as a proxy for the local air temperature. Using a high resolution thermal infrared camera, a 30Hz sequence of infrared frames was recorded. The recorded air temperature fields capture the dynamics of turbulent eddies adjacent to the surface depending on different parameters such as wind speed or the snow coverage. A thin SIBL develops above the leading edge of snow patches possibly protecting the snow surface from warmer air above. However, sometimes the warm air entrains into the SIBL and reaches down to the snow surface adding further energy to the snow pack.
In an attempt to quantify exchange processes from those dynamics, we developed a method to estimate high-resolution, near-surface 2D wind fields from tracking the air temperature pattern on the screens. A spatial correlation search yields the shift of an eddy or air parcel between two subsequent frames, using air temperature as a passive tracer. From this shift, the wind speed can be calculated at a very high spatial resolution. Vertical profiles of air temperature, horizontal, and vertical wind speeds across the transition from bare ground to snow can be evaluated with the advantage of a high spatial (0.01 m) and temporal (30 Hz) resolution.
The screen measurements and wind speed estimation are validated with 3D short-path ultrasonic anemometer measurements close to the surface, which provide further insights into the turbulence characteristics close to the snow surface.
With the high spatio-temporal resolution data we aim to better understand and quantify small scale energy transfer processes over patchy snow covers and their dependency on the atmospheric conditions. This will allow to improve parameterizations of these processes in coarser resolution snow melt models.

How to cite: Haugeneder, M., Lehning, M., Jonas, T., and Mott, R.: A novel method to understand the interaction between a patchy snow cover and the adjacent atmosphere, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9049, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9049, 2022.

The MODIS sensor on the NOAA Terra satellite has been providing daily information on global snow cover with a nominal spatial resolution of 500 m since February 2000. Since July 2022, this sensor is also located on NOAA's Aqua Satellite in orbit. The daily snow cover product of both platforms constitutes the basis for the DLR Global SnowPack (GSP) processor.

In the course of the GSP processing, the daily data of both MODIS sensors are merged and data gaps (e.g., clouds or polar night) are interpolated over 3 days. From a digital elevation model, the snow height (elevation above which only snow occurs), as well as the snow-free height (elevation below which no snow occurs) are determined. Heights above or below these thresholds are filled accordingly. Finally, remaining gaps are gradually filled by the values of preceding days. Since the year 2022, the daily cloud free GSP data has been made available in near real time (3 days delay due to the preprocessing of the NSIDC) via the GeoService Portal of the Earth Observation Center (EOC).

The rapid provision of the information on global snow coverage allows completely new applications of time-critical questions. These include hydrological estimates to what extent the snow conditions in the catchment area influence the drainage behavior. In addition to the satellite data, meteorological and hydrological data of the past 20 years are used to estimate the impact of a changing snow cover on the runoff. In the course of climate change, a delayed onset of snow cover and an earlier snowmelt is likely. Warmer winters also increase the risk of Rain-on-Snow events, which cause a strong increase in the outflow and have more dramatic ecological effects.

We will present results for selected river catchment areas with a special focus on hydrological extreme events (droughts and floods), and when their occurrence has been shown early in the development of seasonal snow coverage. Our goal is to provide an automatic early warning system based on near real time GSP for large river catchments with nival-influenced drainage regimes.

How to cite: Roessler, S. and Dietz, A.: Use of near real-time cloud-free MODIS snow cover data from DLR’s Global SnowPack for the early forecast of extreme hydrological events, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9205, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9205, 2022.

EGU22-9453 | Presentations | HS2.1.5

Investigating the impact of temporal resolution on a snow model used for hydrological modelling 

Anne-Lise Véron, François Tilmant, Guillaume Thirel, François Bourgin, Charles Perrin, and Félicien Zuber

Real-time flood forecasting and other hydrological applications in mountainous areas require a good understanding and accounting of snow accumulation and melt. The CemaNeige snow model is currently used with the GRP hydrological model by most regional operational services in France to produce floods forecasts with lead times varying from a few hours to a few days. The snow model is based on a degree-day approach and needs limited inputs (precipitation and air temperature) spatialized on altitude bands over the catchment. It was initially developed on snow-dominated catchments by Valéry et al. (2014) using only streamflow series as calibration information. The model was then adapted by Riboust et al. (2019) to better simulate snow-covered areas as estimated by MODIS satellite images. These data were used as a secondary source of information for parameter calibration. All these developments were made at the daily time step. However, for real-time purposes, the outputs from the snow model are often needed at a finer time step, typically hourly or sub-hourly.

Here the transposability and the consistency of the CemaNeige model were studied across a range of time steps, from hourly to daily, on a set of snow-influenced catchments. This follows previous works on the hydrological model to improve its consistency across time scales (see e.g. Viatgé et al., 2019). Several questions were addressed:

  • To which extent are the outputs of the snow model and its parameters consistent across various time steps?
  • Is the current snow model complexity (structure and parameters) sufficient to simulate the snow influence at the catchment scale at sub-daily time steps?
  • Can we expect better results by running the snow model at sub-daily time steps than by disaggregating the outputs of the snow model run at the daily time?

The answers to these questions will be presented based on a comprehensive testing scheme and a set of numerical criteria. Perspectives in terms of operational use will be discussed.

How to cite: Véron, A.-L., Tilmant, F., Thirel, G., Bourgin, F., Perrin, C., and Zuber, F.: Investigating the impact of temporal resolution on a snow model used for hydrological modelling, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9453, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9453, 2022.

EGU22-9540 | Presentations | HS2.1.5

What role do glaciers play in smoothing streamflow during summer rainfall events? A case study from the Swiss Alps. 

Bettina Schaefli, Ladina Binkert, Luca Benelli, Natalie Ceperley, Peter Leiser, Jan Baumgartner, Benjamin Berger, and Kevin Wyss

The retreat of glaciers, particularly in catchments where they were extensive, has important consequences for future water management and in particular for hydropower production. Glaciers store water in liquid or solid form on short- to long-term time scales and thereby affect the precipitation-runoff behavior of heavily glacier-covered catchments from interannual and seasonal to sub-daily time scales. While today reliable predictions can be made about the change in quantity and timing of glacier melt runoff, the consequences of glacier retreat for summer rainfall events remain unclear. By intensively monitoring streamflow during the summer months in an area with a high degree of glacier cover, we can fill this research gap. Our key research question is hereby how strongly the glacier smooths out the observed rainfall peaks and how the smoothing effect evolves over the course of the glacier melt season. The answer to this question is crucial to anticipate potential water and sediment management challenges under intense summer rainfall events in catchments with strongly reduced glacier-cover.

In this presentation, we share results from the Oberaargletscher catchment (10 km2, elevation 2310 - 3630 m a.s.l.) located in the Swiss Alps that was intensively monitored from July to October 2021. The monitored variables include precipitation, streamflow, electric conductivity, stable isotopes of water, water and air temperature. Based on the high resolution streamflow data, we analyze the influence of summer rainfall events on the runoff response, and in particular on the runoff lag time and the hydrograph shape. The obtained results are related to potential driving variables including the extent of snow cover and of the glacial drainage system, the precipitation intensity and air temperature.

We will furthermore discuss to what extent the rainfall fraction in the streamflow can be quantified based on streamflow observations alone, which will give valuable insights for future measurement campaigns at comparable sites.

How to cite: Schaefli, B., Binkert, L., Benelli, L., Ceperley, N., Leiser, P., Baumgartner, J., Berger, B., and Wyss, K.: What role do glaciers play in smoothing streamflow during summer rainfall events? A case study from the Swiss Alps., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9540, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9540, 2022.

EGU22-10540 | Presentations | HS2.1.5

Modelling the glacier-hydrology of two large catchments in the Peruvian Andes 

Catriona L. Fyffe, Emily Potter, Andrew Orr, Thomas E. Shaw, Edwin Loarte, Katy Medina, Evan Miles, Florian von Ah, Michel Baraer, Alejo Cochachin, Joshua Castro, Nilton Montoya, Matthew Westoby, Duncan J. Quincey, and Francesca Pellicciotti

Glacier meltwater is a vital component of river discharge in the Peruvian Andes, providing an important source of dry season runoff for communities, agriculture and fragile mountain ecosystems. Previous hydrochemical and modelling studies have identified the importance of glacier meltwater to downstream runoff and analysis of runoff records suggest ‘peak water’ has passed already. These studies, however, have been confined to the Rio Santa basin and the models applied have simplifications in their treatment of glacier melt and evolution. Our objectives are to i) determine the past glacier contribution to streamflow, determining when peak water passed and quantifying the recession of the glacier contribution to runoff; ii) predict future glacier evolution and its consequent impacts on water resources; and iii) to compare the hydrological response of catchments in central and southern Peru and establish their future response to glacier recession.

To meet these objectives we have applied the hourly physically-oriented, glacio-hydrological model TOPKAPI-ETH to two catchments in the Peruvian Andes: the Rio Santa in the Cordillera Blanca (4953 km2) and the Rio Urubamba draining the Cordilleras Vilcanota, Urubamba and Vilcabamba (11048 km2), the two most glacierised catchments in Peru. Past glacier recession has been substantial and future temperature rise is likely to lead to further glacier retreat, threatening water security in both regions. The model is forced with hourly atmospheric inputs from high-resolution (4 km), bias-corrected Weather Research and Forecasting (WRF) model outputs, which are downscaled to the TOPKAPI-ETH model resolution (100 m), using temperature and precipitation lapse rates defined from the WRF data for all sub-catchments of each domain. To reduce equifinality in model parameters we calibrate the model in a stepwise manner, using a combination of in-situ and remotely sensed data. Melt model parameters are calibrated based on full energy balance simulations at five sites across the two domains, with albedo parameters also derived from calibration with measured data. We calibrate the temperature decrease over glacier ice in an iterative manner using the WRF air temperatures, observed weather station data and the energy balance model outputs. Precipitation undercatch is a key unknown but it is constrained by careful comparison of modelled glacier surface mass balances with those inverted from remotely sensed data, while hydrological routing parameters are identified through calibration against hourly runoff records collected within the catchments. 

We use the model outputs to unravel the water balance characteristics of both catchments, their main drivers, including the relative importance of glacier and snow melt components within catchment runoff, and how they vary seasonally, inter-annually and through time due to glacier recession. By applying the model to two catchments with contrasting climatologies and glacier characteristics we are also able to disentangle the reasons for their distinct future trajectories. 

How to cite: Fyffe, C. L., Potter, E., Orr, A., Shaw, T. E., Loarte, E., Medina, K., Miles, E., von Ah, F., Baraer, M., Cochachin, A., Castro, J., Montoya, N., Westoby, M., Quincey, D. J., and Pellicciotti, F.: Modelling the glacier-hydrology of two large catchments in the Peruvian Andes, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10540, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10540, 2022.

EGU22-10582 | Presentations | HS2.1.5

A Novel Approach to Estimate Snowfall over an Alpine Terrain via the Assimilation of Sentinel-1 Snow Depth Observations 

Manuela Girotto, Giuseppe Formetta, Shima Azimi, Sara Modanesi, Gabrielle De Lannoy, Hans Lievens, Riccardo Rigon, and Christian Massari

Estimating snowfall over mountain regions is an extremely challenging task due to the high variability of spatial and temporal precipitation gradients. Traditional methods to estimate snowfall include in-situ gauges, doppler weather radars, satellite radars and radiometers, numerical modeling and reanalysis products. Each of these methods, alone, is unable to capture the complex orographic precipitation. For example, in-situ gauges are often too sparse and lead to significant interpolation errors; radar beams are shielded by the complex mountainous terrains; satellite estimates are sub-optimal over snowy mountains regions; while the physical parameterization of mountainous orography remains challenging for estimating precipitation in numerical models. A potential method to overcome model and observational shortcomings in precipitation estimation is land surface data assimilation, which leverages the information content in both land surface observations and models while minimizing their limitations due to uncertainty. Recently, the ESA and Copernicus Sentinel-1 constellation has been used to map snow-depth across the Northern Hemisphere mountains with 1 km spatial resolution by exploiting C-band cross-polarized backscatter radar measurements. This work aims at characterizing and estimating snowfall precipitation errors over an alpine watershed located in Trentino Alto Adige, Italy. We derive the snowfall errors via the data assimilation of 1 km Sentinel-1 snow-depth observations within a numerical model. The data assimilation applies a particle batch smoother to the coupled snow-17 and Sacramento hydrological models.

How to cite: Girotto, M., Formetta, G., Azimi, S., Modanesi, S., De Lannoy, G., Lievens, H., Rigon, R., and Massari, C.: A Novel Approach to Estimate Snowfall over an Alpine Terrain via the Assimilation of Sentinel-1 Snow Depth Observations, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10582, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10582, 2022.

EGU22-10735 | Presentations | HS2.1.5

Climate change impact on precipitation-phase partitioning and streamflow for glacierized catchments in Nepal 

Anju Vijayan Nair, Sungwook Wi, Colin Gleason, Rijan Bhakta Kayastha, and Efthymios I. Nikolopoulos

The change in climate, characterized by spatial and temporal variations in precipitation and temperature, significantly impacts the hydrological processes and water resources availability. Quantifying long-term changes in climatic variables and their effect on streamflow are crucial for understanding watershed hydrology and developing effective climate adaptation and water management strategies. In this study, we aim to quantify the changes in precipitation, temperature, and streamflow over the last 70 years (1950-2020) for two glacierized catchments in Nepal: Marsyangdi and Budigandaki River Basins. We utilize a distributed hydrological model (HYMOD_DS) forced by the most recent release of the ERA5 Land reanalysis product. Our investigation focuses on evaluating the impact of spatiotemporal changes in precipitation phases (either snow or rainfall) on streamflow characteristics. Specifically, we analyze the temporal trends and changes in the distribution of snow and rainfall and resulting streamflow separated into surface runoff and baseflow at daily and seasonal scales. The ERA5 Land reanalysis indicates a decrease in mean annual total precipitation for the period 1950-1980 and an increasing trend afterward. Annual mean temperature exhibits a rising trend for the entire period. Streamflow simulations for both basins revealed a significantly increased total flow over the last 20 years, primarily due to an increase in rainfall-induced streamflow. The results from this study will provide critical insight into the hydrology of glacierized basins and serve as a reference for water resources planning under climate change.

How to cite: Vijayan Nair, A., Wi, S., Gleason, C., Kayastha, R. B., and Nikolopoulos, E. I.: Climate change impact on precipitation-phase partitioning and streamflow for glacierized catchments in Nepal, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10735, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10735, 2022.

EGU22-11243 | Presentations | HS2.1.5

Modelling blue-green water fluxes in mountain headwaters at the climatic ends of High Mountain Asia 

Stefan Fugger, Pascal Buri, Thomas Edward Shaw, Simone Fatichi, Evan Stewart Miles, Michael McCarthy, Catriona Fyffe, Marin Kneib, Achille Jouberton, and Francesca Pellicciotti

Mountain catchments receive, retain, transport and release water that determines downstream ecology, landforms, hazards and human livelihoods. The hydrological regimes of such catchments are seasonally governed by the storage and release of water by snow and glaciers, and are modulated by the seasonality of liquid precipitation rates and energy fluxes. The wide range of climatic-topographical situations across High Mountain Asia creates a variety of hydrological regimes in this region.

In this study we apply a sophisticated modelling framework in two heavily glacierized catchments at opposite ends of the climatic spectrum in High Mountain Asia: an arid catchment with winter accumulation glaciers (Vaksh headwaters, Northern Pamir) and  a humid catchment with spring-summer accumulation (the Upper Parlung, South-Eastern Tibet). Both catchments span an elevation range of several thousand metres and a number of vegetation zones. To study the concomitant response of the cryosphere and biosphere, we use a land surface model with a mechanistic and energy-balance-based representation of both the cryosphere and biosphere, at 100m spatial and hourly temporal resolution. We force the model with statistically-downscaled and bias-corrected reanalysis data. For model setup and independent validation, we leverage extensive in-situ observations, collected at both sites. We complement those with spatial datasets, such as ice-dynamics-corrected glacier mass balance, snow cover, and vegetation indices.

We analyse the differences in the catchment water balance and flux partitioning between these two study sites in terms of energy fluxes, snow and glacier accumulation and ablation, vegetation distribution and phenology, and give special attention to patterns of evapotranspiration (ET). Using the model we determine the importance of supraglacial debris cover, widespread in the catchments, and its role in modifying the glacier mass balance under different moisture regimes. We also determine the links between snow melt seasonality, glacier mass balance, plant productivity and the responses in catchment runoff. This work presents one of the first applications of hyper-resolution land surface modelling to understand biosphere-cryosphere-hydrosphere interactions in High Mountain Asia, and will provide insights into the skills and drawbacks of such modelling approaches.

How to cite: Fugger, S., Buri, P., Shaw, T. E., Fatichi, S., Miles, E. S., McCarthy, M., Fyffe, C., Kneib, M., Jouberton, A., and Pellicciotti, F.: Modelling blue-green water fluxes in mountain headwaters at the climatic ends of High Mountain Asia, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11243, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11243, 2022.

EGU22-11271 | Presentations | HS2.1.5

Climate change impact on rain, snow and glacier melt components of streamflow for the river Rhine: synthesis of a model experiment and relevance for water use 

Kerstin Stahl, Markus Weiler, Marit Van Tiel, Irene Kohn, Andreas Haensler, Daphne Freudiger, Jan Seibert, Greta Moretti, and Kai Gerlinger

Streamflow of the river Rhine and its tributaries consists of rain, snowmelt and glacier ice melt components. The amounts of these components have already changed in the past years due to climate warming. Hydrological modelling until the year 2100 was carried out for the Rhine catchment using an ensemble of downscaled and bias-corrected climate projections and a chain of hydrological models considering cryosphere changes. The modelled daily streamflow components provide unique insight into the hydrological processes of a warmer future at different spatial and temporal scales down to individual events. In the Rhine basin, projected precipitation for the RCP8.5suggest wetter winters and drier summers, but annual net precipitation change differs in the up- and downstream regions with a net increase projected only in the lower basin. The model experiments suggest that the rain component of streamflow will dominate the seasonal variability in the future more than in the past. Snow will provide less seasonal water storage and melt earlier in winter and spring. Glaciers will continue their retreat with differences among individual glaciers and the ice melt component in the main river Rhine is projected to retreat fast with almost no ice melt component left at the end of the century. As a consequence, in particular low flows in downstream reaches will exacerbate due to the lack of buffering snow and ice melt; esp. during hot summer drought years. This change will affect environmental flows, water use for energy production, navigation and other water uses, changes of which can be estimated from the modelled scenarios. Overall, streamflow variability and extremes will increase. Despite propagated uncertainties from a range in the downscaled and bias-corrected climate model input, the projected changes are substantial and are a clear mandate to reconsider water uses and enhance river protection goals.

How to cite: Stahl, K., Weiler, M., Van Tiel, M., Kohn, I., Haensler, A., Freudiger, D., Seibert, J., Moretti, G., and Gerlinger, K.: Climate change impact on rain, snow and glacier melt components of streamflow for the river Rhine: synthesis of a model experiment and relevance for water use, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11271, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11271, 2022.

EGU22-11859 | Presentations | HS2.1.5

How are snowmelt rates changing across climates? Insights from a new Northern Hemisphere SWE dataset 

Adrià Fontrodona-Bach, Josh Larsen, Ross Woods, Bettina Schaefli, and Ryan Teuling

Although warming temperatures should intuitively lead to faster snowmelt, some studies suggest that melt rates might be slower in a warming world. This assumes that typically deep snowpacks are thinning and become isothermal earlier in the season when less solar radiation is available for melt. Investigating these changing snow dynamics is challenged by a lack of observations on water content of the snowpack, the Snow Water Equivalent (SWE). However, high quality observations of snow depth are generally more available in both space and time, even at higher elevations. Here we present a new dataset of historical SWE time series over the Northern Hemisphere, including a wide variety of climates. These time series are obtained converting historical ground-based snow depth time series to SWE by using the DeltaSNOW model. For the conversion to work over a range of climates, we apply a regional calibration of model parameters based on climatological data and provide model performance and uncertainty estimates. For >2.000 sites characterised by seasonal snow, we investigate changes in total snow accumulation, timing of snowmelt and melt rates for the period 1980-2020. Large decreases in total melt and earlier melt timing are widely observed. However, trends in snowmelt rates are generally weak and spatially inhomogeneous. Slower snowmelt in a warmer world occurs mostly on deep snowpacks that have been heavily depleted and where the number of days with melt has not significantly changed, making melt rates slower. However, both faster and slower melt are observed on sites where both the amount of melt and number of melt days have decreased. We provide an analysis of the causes for the spatial and temporal variability in trends. We find that trends can differ depending on the definition of melt rate and peak SWE, and that the drivers of the trends differ over different climates. Strong warming generates large melt events during the late accumulation season, challenging the commonly used definition of peak SWE and making it harder to compare the snowmelt dynamics of the past and the current climate. We note that focusing on melt rate change might mask important effects on melt timing and magnitude, because a proportional reduction in total melt and number of melt days can lead to no change in melt rate.

How to cite: Fontrodona-Bach, A., Larsen, J., Woods, R., Schaefli, B., and Teuling, R.: How are snowmelt rates changing across climates? Insights from a new Northern Hemisphere SWE dataset, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11859, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11859, 2022.

EGU22-11913 | Presentations | HS2.1.5

Unraveling energy balance partitioning in sub-alpine forests: interplay of canopy structure, topography, and meteorological conditions 

Giulia Mazzotti, Clare Webster, Louis Quéno, Bertrand Cluzet, Richard Essery, and Tobias Jonas

In Alpine regions, forests that overlap with seasonal snow mostly reside in complex terrain. Due to major observational challenges in these environments, the combined impact of forest structure and topography on seasonal snow cover dynamics is still poorly understood. However, recent advances in forest snow process representation and increasing availability of detailed canopy structure datasets now allow for hyper-resolution (<5 m) snow model simulations capable of resolving tree-scale processes. These simulations can shed light on the complex process interactions that govern forest snow cover dynamics.

We present multi-year simulations at 2 m resolution obtained with FSM2, a mass- and energy-balance based forest snow model specifically developed and validated for meter-scale applications. Our 3km2 model domain encompasses forested slopes of a sub-alpine valley in the Eastern Swiss Alps. Simulations thus span a wide range of canopy structures, terrain characteristics, and meteorological conditions typical for the region. We analyze spatial and temporal variations in forest snow energy balance partitioning, aiming to quantify and understand the contribution of individual energy exchange processes at different locations and times.

Our results suggest that snow cover evolution is equally affected by fine-scale canopy structure, terrain characteristics and meteorological conditions. We show that the interaction of these three factors can lead to snow distribution and melt patterns that vary between years. Generally, we find higher snow distribution variability and complexity in slopes that receive solar radiation early in winter. Our process-level insights corroborate and complement existing empirical findings that are largely based on snow distribution datasets only. Hyper-resolution simulations as presented here will thus help us to better understand how ecohydrological regimes sub-alpine regions may evolve as a result of forest disturbances and a warming climate.

How to cite: Mazzotti, G., Webster, C., Quéno, L., Cluzet, B., Essery, R., and Jonas, T.: Unraveling energy balance partitioning in sub-alpine forests: interplay of canopy structure, topography, and meteorological conditions, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11913, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11913, 2022.

EGU22-12146 | Presentations | HS2.1.5

Effects of Geologic Heterogeneity on Permafrost Distribution and Catchment Hydrology in Mountain Environments 

Cassandra Koenig, Christian Hauck, Lukas Arenson, and Christin Hilbich

Changes in surface runoff from permafrost thaw in mountain catchments can be estimated using numerical cryo-hydrogeology models. However, such models can be complex from a numerical standpoint due to the need to simulate transient thermo-hydrologic feedbacks in highly heterogenous geological settings. Models that also seek to quantify water movement and water-budget contributions from ground-ice thaw must further account for changes in water/ice saturation to continually estimate and update the physical properties that control heat and water transfer in the ground (i.e., thermal and hydraulic conductivity) during the model execution. This has important implications for permafrost hydrology modelling efforts in arid mountain watersheds like the High Andes, where water security is threatened by climate change and the role of permafrost in the hydrologic cycle is unclear.

In this contribution the coupled finite element codes TEMP/W and SEEP/W are used to illustrate ground thermal and hydrologic dynamics for different geological scenarios within a hypothetical mountain slope, characteristic of the High Andes at an altitude of up to 6000 m. The 3 km-long, two dimensional cross-sectional model was developed based on a simplified topography, and ground temperatures and climate data collected within the region. In the first scenario, a uniform hydraulic conductivity is applied to the full model domain. A second scenario simulates a case where the hydraulic conductivity of the ground in the upper 200 m is an order of magnitude higher than for the rest of the model (i.e., as in fractured bedrock or unconsolidated sediment). The scenarios were subjected to a 1,000-yr seasonally cyclic climate forcing, followed by 1,000 years of warming superimposed on inter-annual variability at an average warming rate of 4 deg/100 year.

Model experiments show that the applied variations in hydraulic conductivity support vastly different permafrost and ground ice-content distributions under identical climate forcing. Compared to the uniform hydraulic conductivity case, the scenario with high hydraulic conductivity upper layer produces an increase in the heterogeneity of ice-rich permafrost under the stable climate forcing, and a slightly accelerated rate of permafrost thaw under climate warming. Higher recharge and discharge fluxes across the model surface are also predicted for the high hydraulic conductivity scenario.

The divergence in the results is attributed to preferential flow paths that develop near the model surface in the higher hydraulic conductivity case, which in turn leads to increased spatial complexity in advective heat transfer. This can have profound effects on predictive models aiming to estimate rates of permafrost thaw and discharge behaviour under climate warming, and highlights the need for awareness of uncertainties associated with estimated or assumed thermal and hydrologic properties in modelling large mountain catchments.

How to cite: Koenig, C., Hauck, C., Arenson, L., and Hilbich, C.: Effects of Geologic Heterogeneity on Permafrost Distribution and Catchment Hydrology in Mountain Environments, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12146, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12146, 2022.

EGU22-12251 | Presentations | HS2.1.5

The value of complementary data for physically consistent hydrological models in mountain regions 

Paul Schattan, Benjamin Winter, Larissa van der Laan, Abror Gafurov, Gertraud Meißl, Giovanni Cuozzo, Felix Greifeneder, Valentina Premier, Matthias Huttenlau, Johann Stötter, and Kristian Förster

In the face of climate change and socio-economic developments, water scarcity is a tremendous challenge. In particular, a significant portion of the world’s population rely on water from cryospheric sources such as snow and/or glacier fed mountain rivers. However, the data coverage in mountain regions is often sparse, which substantially hampers the assessment of climate impacts on hydrological systems. Furthermore, the large impact of climate change on snow and glacier hydrology require physically sound hydrological models.

The gap between the growing need for sustainable water resources management, low data availability and uncertain hydrological projections calls for new approaches. To close this gap, a modular modelling framework was developed to foster the use of complementary data sets in hydrological models. The framework enables a flexible combination of remote sensing and in situ data for model calibration and validation providing a multi-model and multi-input ensemble. The additional consideration of data regarding snow covered area, snow water equivalent and soil moisture allows for physically meaningful representations of key hydrological processes, even in the absence of a dense network of meteorological stations and river discharge gauges.

Case studies in the European Alps (Inn and Adige/Etsch) and in Central Asia (Ala Archa and Karadarya) illustrate the high value of this approach for physically meaningful representations of the hydrological processes. Furthermore, a high impact of glacier retreat on future water availability was found for the highly glacierised basins of the Fagge river in the upper part of the Inn basin and the Ala Archa river.

How to cite: Schattan, P., Winter, B., van der Laan, L., Gafurov, A., Meißl, G., Cuozzo, G., Greifeneder, F., Premier, V., Huttenlau, M., Stötter, J., and Förster, K.: The value of complementary data for physically consistent hydrological models in mountain regions, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12251, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12251, 2022.

EGU22-2786 | Presentations | HS2.1.6

Global patterns of climate controlled root zone storage capacity based on a large sample of catchments 

Ruud van der Ent, Fransje van Oorschot, Markus Hrachowitz, and Andrea Alessandri

The root zone storage capacity (Sr) is the maximum volume of water in the subsurface that can potentially be accessed by vegetation for transpiration. It influences the seasonality of transpiration as well as fast and slow runoff processes. Sr is heterogeneous as controlled by local climate conditions, which affect vegetation strategies in sizing their root system able to support plant growth and to prevent water shortages. Climate controlled root zone storage capacities can be derived from the maximum water deficit in the root zone based on water balances in gauged catchments. However, root zone parameterization in most global hydrological models does not account for a climate control on root development, being based on look-up tables that prescribe worldwide the same root zone parameters for each vegetation class. These look-up tables are obtained from measurements of rooting structure that are scarce and hardly representative of the ecosystem scale. Several recent studies such as Van Oorschot (2021, https://doi.org/10.5194/esd-12-725-2021) have shown that replacing tabulated Sr values with climate controlled Sr estimates results in improvements in modelling catchment river discharge.

The objective of this research is to investigate global patterns of root zone storage capacity derived from catchment water deficits of a large sample of catchments worldwide. To this aim we explore relations of catchment Sr estimates and catchment climate descriptors such as climatological potential evaporation and precipitation, and catchment vegetation characteristics. These relations at a catchment scale will be used to develop a global coverage of climate controlled of Sr to replace tabulated root zone parameters in global hydrological and climate modelling.

How to cite: van der Ent, R., van Oorschot, F., Hrachowitz, M., and Alessandri, A.: Global patterns of climate controlled root zone storage capacity based on a large sample of catchments, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2786, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2786, 2022.

EGU22-3408 | Presentations | HS2.1.6

Low–flow parameters in relation to specific soil types and geology through long–term hydrological analysis 

Kazumasa Fujimura, Aki Yanagawa, and Yoshihiko Iseri

Low flow is related to the soil and geological conditions in a basin as well as rainfall, basin scale, and topography. Nonlinearity of runoff was originally described by Horton (1936) as a storage–discharge relationship, which is now used in many hydrological models for various purposes such as water resources planning and the assessment of projections of climate change impact on runoff. The storage–discharge relationship was represented in the form of Q=KNSN by Ding (2011). The constant K was already considered in the recession coefficient of groundwater runoff by Ando et al. (1983). The relationship between K and N was indicated as an inversely proportional equation by Fujimura et al. (2016) who carried out a sensitivity analysis. Although the understanding of the storage–discharge equation has been developed, the uncertainties of the parameters have not been resolved. To reduce the uncertainties of the parameters and improve the accuracy of hydrological models, it is important to clarify how natural factors in a basin, such as soil and geology, affect the parameters in the hydrological models. Therefore, we aim to investigate the statistical correlations between the recession constant K and the coverage rates of specific soil types and the geology in a basin.

The nine basins selected for this study are located in mountainous regions in Japan with different topographical, geological, and climatological conditions. The basin areas range from 103 to 332km2. Rainfall and runoff data were downloaded from databases of the Water Information System of the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport and the Automated Meteorological Data Acquisition System (AMeDAS) of the Meteorological Agency, respectively. The specific soil types and geological information (specific geological time and rock formations) of 1:200000 scale were obtained from databases of the Japan soil inventory of the National Agriculture and Food Research Organization (NARO) and of the Seamless Digital Geological Map of Japan of the National Institute of Advanced Industrial Science and Technology (AIST), respectively. The conceptual hydrological model for mountainous basins developed by Fujimura et al. (2011) was applied for a period of more than 15 years at hourly time steps to optimize the recession constant K for each study basin.

The results indicate that the recession coefficient K has correlations and significant differences (significance level alpha of 0.05) with the coverage rates of (a) Brown forest soils (p value of 0.00026), (b) Neogene rock formation (p value of 0.0049), and (c) Andosols / Volcanic rock formation ratio (p value of 0.012). The Andosols formation depends essentially on human activity as well as volcanic ash. The volcanic ash and volcanic rock might have been produced in the same geological time. To show the effect of human activity and other environmental factors, the area of Andosols is divided by the area of volcanic rock.

How to cite: Fujimura, K., Yanagawa, A., and Iseri, Y.: Low–flow parameters in relation to specific soil types and geology through long–term hydrological analysis, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3408, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3408, 2022.

EGU22-3804 | Presentations | HS2.1.6 | Highlight

Current practices in catchment characterization: data sources, aggregation approaches, derived descriptors and their value 

Larisa Tarasova, Sebastian Gnann, Soohyun Yang, Andreas Hartmann, and Thorsten Wagener

A common way to characterize catchments is to use catchment descriptors that summarize important physical aspects of a given catchment, often by aggregating large geospatial datasets into a single number. Such descriptors aim at extracting information that can inform us about different aspects of catchment functioning, help us to infer dominant hydrological processes, identify similarity among different sites, and transfer information across them. In this study we analyze a large sample of research articles indexed in Scopus, that were returned from the search words “catchment characteristic”, “catchment descriptor”, “catchment attribute”, “catchment indicator” or “catchment property”, to identify current practices of catchment characterization in hydrological science and related disciplines.

We particularly focus on analyzing the variety of data sources on which catchment descriptors are usually based (e.g., digital elevation, land use, lithographic and soil texture maps), on identifying how the datasets are aggregated into catchment descriptors, and on exploring how the value of those descriptors is assessed.

Based on this large sample of studies that cover diverse research areas (e.g., water quantity, water quality, lake research, aquatic ecosystems), different types of studies (e.g., data-based analysis, hydrological and statistical modeling, field studies) and various application purposes (e.g., descriptive site comparison, catchment clustering/classification, quantitative driver/control identification, regionalization), we provide a categorized overview of practices that are currently used for catchment characterization. This overview will provide guidance for future studies by summarizing the status quo and its strengths and limitations, and by providing suggestions for future research.

How to cite: Tarasova, L., Gnann, S., Yang, S., Hartmann, A., and Wagener, T.: Current practices in catchment characterization: data sources, aggregation approaches, derived descriptors and their value, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3804, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3804, 2022.

EGU22-4442 | Presentations | HS2.1.6

Identifying the impact of reservoirs on the flow regime across Great Britain 

Saskia Salwey, Gemma Coxon, Francesca Pianosi, Christopher Hutton, and Michael Singer

Reservoirs play a vital role in the supply and management of water resources around the world. In Great Britain, reservoir operations are largely determined by the local water company, and there is very little national-scale information available to quantify their impact on river flows. Consequently, large-scale hydrological modelling and data analyses often focus on ‘natural’ or ‘near-natural’ catchments. To support the long-term resilience of water supply and the environment under changing climate and demand, it is essential that we understand where, when and how reservoirs are leading to deviations from a natural flow regime. This will help inform and validate advancements in the large-scale simulation of reservoir-impacted catchments, as well as deepening our understanding of how reservoir operations influence streamflow behaviour.

Due to the age and location of reservoirs across Great Britain, there is a distinct lack of upstream or pre-construction flow timeseries. As a result, we cannot use standard approaches – such as indicators of hydrological alteration- which base analysis on the pre-and-post construction flow regimes. To fill this gap, we define a suite of hydrological signatures and compare observed streamflow timeseries from 1980- 2015 across 166 reservoir catchments and 112 near-natural catchments in Great Britain. We use signatures, characterizing the water balance, flow duration curve and low flow regime, to identify differences in streamflow between these two groups of catchments, and attribute alterations to upstream reservoir operation. We find that gauges with a reservoir upstream are more likely to induce runoff deficits exceeding total PET, and that routine reservoir releases lead to plateaus in the flow duration curve. By defining two new reservoir-based catchment descriptors, our results show that the degree of flow regulation at a gauge depends on the upstream storage capacity and the contributing area of upstream reservoirs. Such descriptors begin to identify thresholds below which the influence of reservoirs is indistinguishable, and help to characterise the extent of reservoir influence across Great Britain.

This analysis highlights groups of reservoir-impacted catchments which cannot be represented by a natural regime. It is in these locations that advancements in large-scale hydrological modelling are crucial for water resource simulation, and that the influence of reservoir operations on the flow regime must be accounted for.

How to cite: Salwey, S., Coxon, G., Pianosi, F., Hutton, C., and Singer, M.: Identifying the impact of reservoirs on the flow regime across Great Britain, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4442, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4442, 2022.

EGU22-5563 | Presentations | HS2.1.6

FaBI: A new collection of flood data and attributes of basins in Italy 

Pierluigi Claps, Martina Brunetto, Giulia Evangelista, Paola Mazzoglio, and Irene Monforte

The availability of large data samples can be useful in several research areas, including rainfall/flood frequency analysis, hydrological modelling and quantification of the hydrologic effects of catchment heterogeneities. In recent years, considerable efforts have been spent to build nation-wide databases of basin attributes, with catalogs or web repositories in USA, England, Switzerland, Austria, Canada, Australia, Brazil and Chile. We present here FaBI (Floods and attributes of Basins in Italy) i.e. the first collection of hydrologic data and gauged basin attributes encompassing the whole of Italy, that counts 631 basins and their flood records.

The collection puts together flood data and other hydrological indices on one side, and many basin geo-morpho-climatic and soil-related attributes. In terms of hydrologic data, the starting base is that of two recent databases, i.e. the Improved Italian - Rainfall Extreme Dataset (I2-RED) and the Catalogo delle Piene dei Corsi d’acqua Italiani. The latter was the main source for identification of the watersheds to consider, that are those for which extremes of daily or of peak discharges are available. On this set of 631 basins a consistent effort has produced the computation of spatially relevant attributes and indices with the condition that each variable derives from a uniform nation-wide coverage. Many attributes are related to the geomorphology of the river network, as Horton ratios, shape and amplitude factors. They were computed by processing a digital elevation model with a 30-meters spatial resolution, through the implementation of the r.basin R algorithm. On these values several quality-control procedures have been applied, starting with a check of consistency with previously published data. The raster river network extracted has been compared with a vector reference one provided by the Istituto Superiore per la Ricerca e Protezione Ambientale (ISPRA), allowing us to identify areas where it was necessary to manually force the digital elevation model. The relation between the length of the main channel and its longest path has been investigated and the Hack’s law was used to double-check the computed main channel length. Several spatial average values of climatological indices have been computed, privileging data gathered from ground stations, that are subsequently interpolated in the space. This attains average values of temperature and precipitation at different time scales, for the first time available in a unique repository. The FaBI collection provides a vast range of new opportunities to perform regional and national-scale hydrological analyses, taking advantage of the hydro-climatologic and morphologic variety of the Italian basins, that represent a vast range of transitions between Alpine and semi-arid geographic environments in a Mediterranean context.

How to cite: Claps, P., Brunetto, M., Evangelista, G., Mazzoglio, P., and Monforte, I.: FaBI: A new collection of flood data and attributes of basins in Italy, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5563, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5563, 2022.

EGU22-5918 | Presentations | HS2.1.6

QUADICA: A large-sample data set of water quality, discharge and catchment attributes for Germany 

Pia Ebeling, Rohini Kumar, Stefanie R. Lutz, Tam Nguyen, Fanny Sarrazin, Michael Weber, Olaf Büttner, Sabine Attinger, and Andreas Musolff

Environmental data are critical for understanding and managing ecosystems, including mitigation of degraded water quality. Therefore, we provide the first large-sample water quality data set of riverine water quality combined with water quantity, meteorological and nutrient forcing data, and catchment attributes for Germany in a preprocessed and structured form. The QUADICA data set (water QUAlity, DIscharge and Catchment Attributes for large-sample studies in Germany) covers 1386 German and transboundary catchments with a large range of hydroclimatic, topographic, geologic, land use and anthropogenic settings. The data set comprises time series of riverine macronutrient concentrations (species of nitrogen, phosphorus and organic carbon), discharge, meteorological and diffuse nitrogen forcing data (nitrogen surplus, atmospheric deposition and fixation). The time series are generally aggregated to an annual basis; however, for 140 stations with long-term water quality and quantity data (more than 20 years), we additionally provide monthly median discharge and nutrient concentrations, flow-normalized concentrations and corresponding mean fluxes as outputs from weighted regressions on time, discharge, and season (WRTDS). The catchment attributes include catchment nutrient inputs from point and diffuse sources and characteristics from topography, hydroclimate, land cover, lithology and soils. QUADICA is a comprehensive, freely available, ready-to-use data set that facilitates large-sample data-driven water quality assessments at catchment scale as well as mechanistic modeling studies. We hope to stimulate the hydrological and water quality communities to provide similar data sets to create novel research opportunities, increase our understanding of catchment functioning, and ultimately improve water quality management.

How to cite: Ebeling, P., Kumar, R., Lutz, S. R., Nguyen, T., Sarrazin, F., Weber, M., Büttner, O., Attinger, S., and Musolff, A.: QUADICA: A large-sample data set of water quality, discharge and catchment attributes for Germany, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5918, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5918, 2022.

EGU22-6234 | Presentations | HS2.1.6 | Highlight

Process-Based Estimates of Seasonal Catchment Hydrology: Dimensionless Models 

Zeqiang Wang and Ross Woods

Catchment functions (consisting of partition, storage and discharge) are difficult to measure or model, especially considering the wide variety of landscape forms (e.g. plant canopy and soil properties) and variable climate forcing (e.g. precipitation and radiation). After formulating an analytical model to predict the seasonal water balance of the canopy, the root zone, and the saturated zone by using functions of six dimensionless parameters (Woods, 2003, Advances in Water Resources), Woods (2009, Advances in Water Resources) developed a related model for seasonal snowpack dynamics. This presentation will use enhancements of these two simple models to estimate evaporation (E) and changes in water storage (dS/dt) and then the catchment runoff (Q), driven by summary statistics of precipitation (P), temperature and potential evaporation, based on the seasonal water balance (dS/dt= P-E-Q). In this study, we (i) firstly quantify the parameters (e.g. interception capacity relative to rainfall and melt factor) used in this improved model, using an a priori approach; (ii) assess this model in many catchments around the world by using existing global data products; (iv) identify the dominant parameters controlling the water balance; (v) discuss the limitations of this model. As a result, we will find in which situations it is possible to simply and reliably estimate seasonal variation in river flow without flow measurements, and other situations where model refinement is needed. This is important both for improving our understanding of catchment hydrology, and for predicting the seasonal hydrological differences between various hydro-climatic conditions or catchments, especially in locations with sparse measurements.

How to cite: Wang, Z. and Woods, R.: Process-Based Estimates of Seasonal Catchment Hydrology: Dimensionless Models, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6234, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6234, 2022.

The identification of the dominant controls for hydrological dynamics in a catchment is fundamental for the transfer of hydrological information. In particular, when the information to be transferred regards the rainfall-runoff transformation processes at fine temporal scale, as for the regionalisation of hydrological models, basin similarity should capture the sequential order and the stochastic nature of the runoff generation and propagation, considering the information content embedded in the entire streamflow hydrograph and also in its forcings.

While previous hydrological research has identified basins with similar meteorological forcings or with similar streamflow time series, a preliminary work (presented at the previous EGU General Assembly 2021, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu21-10152) proposed, for the first time, to quantify the interaction between the entire time-series of different forcing data and streamflow observations, to be considered as novel hydrological signature and used as catchment similarity metrics. The study highlighted the potential of transfer entropy which was applied for identifying the dominant hydrological processes occurring in a catchment, measuring the transfer of information from different meteorological forcings over the basin to the corresponding streamflow time series at its outlet. The resulting transfer entropy values were then used as signatures to characterise the catchment responses, and a classification of the basins was obtained assuming that similar values of transfer entropy identify similar basins.

In the present work, the results of an improved version of the approach, applied to a large and densely gauged set of Austrian basins, are thoroughly interpreted against a set of geo-morphological and climatic catchment features and a set of typical and consolidated streamflow signatures. Then, the proposed catchment classification is compared to a benchmark clusterisation approach based on the selected streamflow signatures and the two resulting partitions are analysed in terms of internal consistency and mutual affinity.

The outcomes of the approach are promising and demonstrate the potential of transfer entropy as an additional instrument for assessing hydrological similarity and for quantifying the connection between different governing processes: the method is able to distinguish the predominant or partial role of snow melt and evapotranspiration in the region, it helps to assess differences in catchment response time and to highlight the role of high orographic precipitation in snow-dominated catchments.

Finally both clusterisations (transfer entropy-based and benchmark signature-based) are coupled to the regionalisation of a rainfall-runoff model across the study region, investigating the potential benefits in terms of model efficiency allowed by the use of the novel similarity metric in comparison to the benchmark approach. 

How to cite: Neri, M., Coulibaly, P., and Toth, E.: Catchment classification based on a measure of the interaction between streamflow and forcing time series: insights on the use of a transfer entropy signature and comparison with benchmark attributes, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6313, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6313, 2022.

EGU22-6609 | Presentations | HS2.1.6

CAMELS-spat: catchment data for spatially distributed large-sample hydrology 

Wouter Knoben and Martyn Clark

The recent publication of large-sample datasets for hydrologic modeling and analysis has led to a revival of comparative hydrology. The “CAMELS” branch of these datasets currently provide catchment attributes and meteorological time series for basins located in the United States, Chile, Brazil, Australia and Great-Britain, with a dataset for France under development. A key characteristic of these datasets is that information is provided as catchment-averaged data; i.e. each catchment is treated as a lumped entity with no spatial variability. Some progress is being made to extend large-sample hydrology to include spatially distributed data, most notably by the recent LamaH dataset which covers part of Central Europe.

Here we present progress on developing a continental domain dataset for large-sample hydrology intended for spatially distributed modeling and analysis. Our domain covers the United States and Canada, expanding both geographically and climatically on the region covered by the LamaH dataset. We focus mostly on relatively undisturbed headwater catchments, because accurate data on water management policies and infrastructure can be difficult to obtain. Our aim is to provide the necessary data for process-based modeling and analysis at a sub-daily temporal resolution. 

How to cite: Knoben, W. and Clark, M.: CAMELS-spat: catchment data for spatially distributed large-sample hydrology, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6609, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6609, 2022.

EGU22-9859 | Presentations | HS2.1.6

CAMELS-CH - Building a Common Open Database for Catchments in Switzerland 

Rosi Siber, Marvin Höge, Martina Kauzlaric, Ursula Schönenberger, Pascal Horton, Jan Schwanbeck, Daniel Viviroli, Massimiliano Zappa, Anna E. Sikorska-Senoner, Sandra Pool, Marius Günter Floriancic, Peter Reichert, Jan Seibert, Nans Addor, Bettina Schaefli, and Fabrizio Fenicia

Over recent years, numerous open catchment datasets have been published. In 2017, the first CAMELS (catchment attributes and meteorology for large-sample studies) dataset was released for the continental US by Addor et al. (2017). It comprises data for several hundreds of catchments including dynamic time series of daily resolution over several decades for discharge, precipitation and temperature - originally compiled by Newman et al. (2015) - as well as static basin attributes such as indices on topography, soil, geology and climate. Subsequently, similar datasets for several other countries were made or will be made publicly available. Some of these also contain additional data such as attributes on glaciers or human influence like, e.g., the CAMELS datasets for Chile (Alvarez-Garreton et al., 2018) and Great Britain (Coxon et al., 2020). Such datasets build an accessible and unified basis for reproducible and complementary research.  They led to a high stimulation of hydrological research with methodologies that could not be applied before, like the joint evaluation of a large number of catchments.

We present CAMELS-CH, a new dataset for about 200 basins in Switzerland that will be released in 2022. In this collaborative project, several academic institutions and agencies work together to publish a hydro-meteorological dataset that covers both dynamic and static catchment data, and that accounts for the wide range of hydrological regimes in Switzerland, e.g., alpine environment, hydropower usage, densely populated and cultivated regions, etc. We summarize the current state of the project, remaining challenges, in particular regarding translating base data into the CAMELS format, and the final steps toward dataset publication.

 

References

Addor, N., Newman, A. J., Mizukami, N., and Clark, M. P.: The CAMELS data set: catchment attributes and meteorology for large-sample studies. Hydrology and Earth System Sciences, 21, 5293-5313, 2017

Alvarez-Garreton, C., Mendoza, P. A., Boisier, J. P., Addor, N., Galleguillos, M., Zambrano-Bigiarini, M., Lara, A., Cortes, G., Garreaud, R., McPhee, J., Ayala, A.: The CAMELS-CL dataset: catchment attributes and meteorology for large sample studies-Chile dataset, Hydrology and Earth System Sciences, 22, 5817–5846, 2018

Coxon, G., Addor, N., Bloomfield, J., Freer, J., Fry, M., Hannaford, J., Howden, N., Lane, R., Lewis, M., Robinson, E., Wagener, T.,and Woods, R.: CAMELS-GB: Hydrometeorological time series and landscape attributes for 671 catchments in Great Britain, Earth System Science Data 12, 2459–2483, 2020

Newman, A., Clark, M., Sampson, K., Wood, A., Hay, L., Bock, A., Viger, R., Blodgett, D., Brekke, L., Arnold, J.: Development of a large-sample watershed-scale hydrometeorological data set for the contiguous USA: data set characteristics and assessment of regional variability in hydrologic model performance. Hydrology and Earth System Sciences, 19, 209-223, 2015

 

How to cite: Siber, R., Höge, M., Kauzlaric, M., Schönenberger, U., Horton, P., Schwanbeck, J., Viviroli, D., Zappa, M., Sikorska-Senoner, A. E., Pool, S., Floriancic, M. G., Reichert, P., Seibert, J., Addor, N., Schaefli, B., and Fenicia, F.: CAMELS-CH - Building a Common Open Database for Catchments in Switzerland, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9859, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9859, 2022.

EGU22-10286 | Presentations | HS2.1.6

On the selection of precipitation products for the regionalisation of hydrological model parameters 

Oscar Manuel Baez-Villanueva, Mauricio Zambrano-Bigiarini, Pablo A. Mendoza, Ian McNamara, Hylke E. Beck, Joschka Thurner, Alexandra Nauditt, Lars Ribbe, and Nguyen Xuan Thinh

Daily streamflow data are crucial for various scientific and operational water resources applications, such as climate change impact assessment, flood forecasting, and catchment classification, among others. Streamflow is typically estimated through the implementation of hydrological models, which rely on parameters to represent hypotheses about the dominant processes in a catchment. In most cases, these parameters cannot be measured at the scales relevant for model applications and are therefore estimated through model calibration. Because most streams worldwide remain ungauged, novel parameter regionalisation techniques have been developed to predict daily streamflow over ungauged catchments. These regionalisation techniques transfer calibrated model parameters from gauged to ungauged catchments. To this end, an accurate spatio-temporal representation of crucial meteorological variables such as precipitation is essential, and therefore, most regionalisation studies have been conducted over regions with a dense network of meteorological stations. However, the characterisation of precipitation over data-scarce areas is challenging and might be subject to large uncertainties when only ground-based measurements are used. Despite that few daily regionalisation studies have used gridded precipitation products, there is no precise evaluation on how the selection of a particular precipitation product can affect the performance of the existing regionalisation techniques. Therefore, this work aims to analyse how the choice of gridded daily precipitation products affects the relative performance of three well-known parameter regionalisation techniques (spatial proximity, feature similarity, and parameter regression) over 100 near-natural catchments with diverse hydrological regimes across Chile. For this purpose, we calibrated a conceptual semi-distributed HBV-like hydrological model (TUWmodel) for each catchment, using four precipitation products (CR2MET, RF-MEP, ERA5, and MSWEPv2.8). We assessed the ability of these regionalisation techniques to transfer the parameters of a rainfall-runoff model, implementing a leave-one-out cross-validation procedure for each precipitation product. Despite differences in the spatio-temporal distribution of precipitation, all products provided good performance during calibration (median KGE's > 0.77), two independent verification periods (median KGE's > 0.70 and 0.61, for near normal and dry conditions, respectively), and regionalisation (median KGE's for the best method ranging from 0.56 to 0.63). We show how model calibration can compensate, to some extent, differences between precipitation forcings by adjusting model parameters and thus the water balance components. Feature similarity provided the best results, followed by spatial proximity, while parameter regression resulted in the worst performance, reinforcing the importance of transferring complete model parameter sets to ungauged catchments. Our results suggest that: i) merging precipitation products and ground-based measurements does not necessarily translate into an improved hydrological model performance; ii) a precipitation product that provides the best individual model performance during calibration and verification does not necessarily yield the best performance in terms of parameter regionalisation; iii) the spatial resolution of the precipitation products does not substantially affect the regionalisation performance; and iv) the model parameters and the performance of regionalisation methods are affected by the hydrological regime, with the best results for spatial proximity and feature similarity obtained for rain-dominated catchments with a minor snowmelt component.

How to cite: Baez-Villanueva, O. M., Zambrano-Bigiarini, M., Mendoza, P. A., McNamara, I., Beck, H. E., Thurner, J., Nauditt, A., Ribbe, L., and Thinh, N. X.: On the selection of precipitation products for the regionalisation of hydrological model parameters, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10286, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10286, 2022.

EGU22-10853 | Presentations | HS2.1.6

Regional Variability in the Performance of Annual Maxima vs. Peaks-Over-Threshold Methods for Predicting Frequent Floods 

Francesco Dell'Aira, Antonio Cancelliere, and Claudio I. Meier

Much geomorphic research on rivers focuses on the role of frequent floods (e.g., with return periods between one and two years), which have been shown in many regions to simultaneously perform sufficient geomorphic work as well as occur often enough, so that they tend to determine the shape of the channel. As compared to the Annual Maxima (AM) method, using the Peaks-Over-Threshold (POT) method for flood frequency analysis (also known as the Partial Duration method) allows for the inclusion of a larger number of peak values from the series of past flow observations, resulting in a better estimation of the probabilistic model. As it only considers events above a threshold, POT also decreases the likelihood of incorporating smaller events, when relatively dry years occurred within the period of observations. In the AM method, such smaller events could potentially come from a different population and have an inordinate influence on the predicted floods, introducing variability. Because of all these reasons, the POT approach should result in sounder statistical analyses when predicting frequent floods, with relatively short average recurrence intervals (ARIs). However, much geomorphic research into channel-forming floods has traditionally used AM instead of POT, presumably because it is much easier to obtain annual maxima data and perform frequency analyses when there are as many data as years in the record, while there is subjectivity in choosing an adequate threshold for POT analyses.

In this work, we study the variability in peak flow estimates for frequent (return period < 3 years) events, using both AM and POT, over multiple regions in the US. The objectives are: i) to search for homogeneous hydrological regions where the relation between the two methods is similar, and ii) to study the stability of predictions obtained with the two approaches, when considering different record lengths. The former objective aims at exploring how external factors related to the geographical location and the characteristics of the basin affect discrepancies in the results achieved by the two methods, such as the climate and the size of the basin. The former affects the magnitude and average number of other flooding events, neglected by AM, that occur every year besides the annual maximum. The latter influences the extent to which different types of rainfall events, with different spatial coverages, can involve the watershed. This insight might lay some groundwork for introducing “correction coefficients” for AM-based predictions of relatively frequent floods, depending on the characteristics of the study area. The latter objective is intended to test the stability of the statistical model and check whether POT leads to less variable predictions than AM.

Special care is adopted in two crucial aspects that may introduce bias in the analysis: i) the choice of the case-study gaging stations, in order to minimize any human impact on the studied flow time series, and ii) the methodology for selecting the flood threshold in the POT method, aimed at avoiding subjective decisions.

How to cite: Dell'Aira, F., Cancelliere, A., and Meier, C. I.: Regional Variability in the Performance of Annual Maxima vs. Peaks-Over-Threshold Methods for Predicting Frequent Floods, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10853, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10853, 2022.

EGU22-10908 | Presentations | HS2.1.6

Large Sample, High Dimension Hydrology Dataset Validation: Getting Bit By Bytes 

Daniel Kovacek, Sophia Eugeni, and Steven Weijs

Many large hydrometeorological datasets have been developed and published in recent years in support of wide applications from physical to machine learning models, and from operations forecasting to prediction in ungauged basins.  The HYSETS database (Arsenault et al. 2019) is one such large-sample dataset featuring numerous physiographic, geologic, and climate attributes associated with over fourteen thousand monitored watersheds in North America and Mexico.  The wide array of geospatial data sources used to extract the many basin attributes described by this dataset, combined with the continental scale of study regions, necessitates the assembly of geospatial data sources with non-uniform properties and the analysis of observations collected by different governing organizations.

In this study, the static basin attribute set derived for the HYSETS database was replicated.  Preliminary results suggest that incorporating updated geospatial data sources such as higher resolution DEM, and the interpretation of basin attribute derivations due to the use of different software packages, can yield distinct estimates of statistical properties of basin attributes with implications for their use as model input data.  At the very least, the preliminary results demonstrate that the greater the size and complexity of a dataset, the greater the likelihood of introducing bias and computational error.

How to cite: Kovacek, D., Eugeni, S., and Weijs, S.: Large Sample, High Dimension Hydrology Dataset Validation: Getting Bit By Bytes, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10908, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10908, 2022.

EGU22-11217 | Presentations | HS2.1.6

Inner-basin evaluation of the changes in the (lateral) fluxes of the distributed wflow_sbm hydrological model due to spatial scaling 

Jerom Aerts, Rolf Hut, Nick van de Giesen, Niels Drost, Peter Kalvera, Willem van Verseveld, and Albrecht Weerts

We conduct an inner-basin evaluation of the (lateral) fluxes of the wflow_sbm model at 3km, 1km and 200m spatial resolutions the CAMELS dataset. Previous work (Aerts 2021) has shown that while the quality of streamflow predictions at basin outlets might show small differences between basins for the different model resolutions, inner basin lateral flows can differ greatly over different resolutions.

In this work we study the impact of model resolution on rainfall partitioning and subsequent impact on lateral flows. To quantify terrain characteristics, we apply the method of Gharari et al. (2011) to classify parts of each basin as wetland, hillslope, or plateau. For the different model resolutions, we calculate how much rain falls on the different classifications and study lateral flow within the basin per terrain classification type.

The results of this work will shed light on how models run at different resolutions have different internal lateral flows while still generating similar and adequate streamflow predictions. This insight will help in making informed decisions on what resolution to run a model at for a given problem to optimize both output and internal realism of the model estimations.

This study is carried out within the eWaterCycle framework; allowing for a FAIR by design research setup that is scalable in terms of case study areas and hydrological models.

How to cite: Aerts, J., Hut, R., van de Giesen, N., Drost, N., Kalvera, P., van Verseveld, W., and Weerts, A.: Inner-basin evaluation of the changes in the (lateral) fluxes of the distributed wflow_sbm hydrological model due to spatial scaling, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11217, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11217, 2022.

HS2.2 – From observations to concepts to models (in catchment hydrology)

EGU22-489 | Presentations | HS2.2.1

A General Perspective of Discharge-Area Relationship during Recession 

Akshay Kadu and Basudev Biswal

One of the compelling problems in hydrology is to predict discharge at a point in a river network without any historical data. Any solution to such a problem requires knowledge of how a drainage basin functions, thus linking its response to precipitation inputs with its physiological characteristics. In this regard, considerable efforts have been made to understand the link between basin size and peak discharge. The present study extends the discharge-area analysis to the recession domain. We assumed two dominant flow processes to exist in natural basins viz; Pure Surface Flow (PSF) and Mixed Surface Sub-surface Flow (MSSF). As the recession progresses, MSSF is expected to become the dominant flow generation mechanism in the basin. The MSSF is directly proportional to the total length of the saturated channel network or active drainage network (ADN) in a basin, which is directly proportional to the basin area. Thus, during the late recession period, the discharge is supposed to be directly proportional to the basin area. Using a geomorphological hydrologic response model, we tried to prove this direct relationship between discharge and basin area during the recession period. The results obtained are in agreement with our assumed hypothesis.

How to cite: Kadu, A. and Biswal, B.: A General Perspective of Discharge-Area Relationship during Recession, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-489, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-489, 2022.

Flood forecasting agencies and hydropower companies require cost effective approaches for accurate estimation of snow water equivalent (SWE) to improve spring flow forecast and to make informed decision about reservoir operation.  The lack of accurate SWE estimation at the watershed scale is an issue in northern watersheds, as snow surveys are either absent, or sparsely distributed and infrequent (monthly to bi-weekly). Remotely sensed SWE data sets retrieved from passive microwave satellites, such as GlobSnow, offers the advantage of high frequent coverage of the Northern Hemisphere at the watershed scale.  The main issue is that SWE is typically underestimated because of vegetation. Also, the signal saturates for deep snowpacks.  An approach is therefore required to correct GlobSnow which does not resort to local SWE measurements.

A correction factor approach which focuses on improving the Maximum Snow Water Equivalent (MSWE) estimate for a watershed produced by publicly available regional databases, such as GlobSnow, has been developed. The method does not require point SWE measurements and assumes that the spring runoff volume calculated from historical streamflow observations equals the total snow melt volume retrieved from GlobSnow’s MSWE, less infiltration into frozen ground. The latter is calculated from freely available hydro-meteorological information. The method presented below introduces a cost-effective approach which can bridge the temporal and spatial sparsity that is often associated with the snow survey programs.

The results from applying this approach to the regional GlobSnow database to northern watersheds in Quebec show that the Corrected GlobSnow (C-Glob) more accurately correlates to the manual snow surveys, compared to the uncorrected GlobSnow data source. The corrected database may prove especially useful for watersheds where no SWE measurements are available, may serve as a supplementary source of information to better understand what takes place over the entire watershed by filling gaps of manual surveys.

How to cite: Whittaker, C. and Leconte, R.: A novel watershed scale Snow Water Equivalent (SWE) correction approach, using stream flow and remote sensing data, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1570, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1570, 2022.

EGU22-2828 | Presentations | HS2.2.1

Fully coupled subsurface-land surface hydrological models: A scaling approach to improve subsurface storage predictions 

Samira Sadat Soltani, Marwan Fahs, Ahmad Al Bitar, and Behzad Ataie-Ashtiani

The flow conditions (e.g., river network) for rivers and open channels are often forced into hydrogeological models that use a constant horizontal grid resolution without correction for grid mismatching. As a result, the flow velocity will be significantly underestimated if the width of rivers is substantially narrower than the grid size of these models. Furthermore, the exchange between the river and the subsurface is overestimated, resulting in an erroneously large vertical exchange.

In response to this challenge, in this work, the subscale channel flow is approximated in the kinematic wave equation by a scaled roughness coefficient. A relationship between grid cell size and river width is used for this purpose, which follows a simplified modification of the Manning-Strickler equation. In addition, the exchange between the subsurface and the river, as well as the rate of ex- and in-filtration, are scaled across river beds based on grid resolution. As a result, even though the grid size is relatively large, the exchange rates are corrected across river beds. The effectiveness of the scaling of river parametrization is validated against groundwater gauges and remote sensing-based surface soil moisture in a fully coupled subsurface-land surface ParFlow-CLM at a spatial resolution of 0.055° (~6 km) over the Upper Rhine Basin. The validity of the results is examined through an innovative application of the First Order Reliability Method (FORM) for the time period 2012-2014. Results indicate that the scaling approach improves the estimates of soil moisture, particularly in the summer and autumn seasons when cross-validated with independent CCI-SM observations. This improvement is achieved (SM RMSE reduction from 0.03 to 0.005) due to the effective impacts of the scaling river parametrization on SM estimation. FORM results show that the accuracy of ParFlow-CLM soil moisture simulations by using scaling approach is more than 95, 89, 85 and 92 percent for Autumn, Winter, April and Summer, respectively. The scaling river parametrization also shows overall improvements in groundwater level estimation, particularly over the central and northern regions where the groundwater level is shallow.

How to cite: Soltani, S. S., Fahs, M., Al Bitar, A., and Ataie-Ashtiani, B.: Fully coupled subsurface-land surface hydrological models: A scaling approach to improve subsurface storage predictions, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2828, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2828, 2022.

EGU22-3264 | Presentations | HS2.2.1

Sensitivity to spatial and temporal resolution in the performance of a parsimonious hydrological model for quantifying water balance partitioning in dryland regions. 

E. Andres Quichimbo, Michael Bliss Singer, Katerina Michaelides, Rafael Rosolem, and Mark Cuthbert

Dryland regions cover around one-third of the global land surface and are naturally prone to water scarcity. Drylands typically experience highly variable precipitation, both spatially and temporally, with potential evapotranspiration (PET) greatly exceeding annual rates of precipitation. However, our ability to accurately quantify the key components of the water partitioning in these regions is hampered by the scarcity of data and the highly dynamic nature of the hydrological processes. In this context, assessing the ability of models to represent the key hydrological processes at different spatial and temporal scales is of key importance to enhance our understanding and quantification of the water balance in dryland regions. Here, we have assessed the impact of the model grid size and the temporal scale of climatic forcing in combination with variations in model structure in the description and representation of key hydrological processes that influence the water partitioning in dryland regions. The analysis was performed in the Walnut Gulch Experimental Watershed where a dense network of hydrological measurements is readily available for model evaluation. We show that our parsimonious model, DRYP, can describe well the water partitioning across a range of different temporal and spatial scales. However, we find that sub-daily time steps of precipitation and PET, combined with a fine spatial resolution of less than or equal to 1km grid size, are needed for robust quantification of the water partitioning, which is also very sensitive to the choice of infiltration model. The results highlight the important role of channel losses through the streambed of ephemeral streams (~7% of the precipitation), and the impact of the underlying alluvial riparian area in the partitioning of water fluxes between riparian vegetation evapotranspiration (~60 % of transmission losses) and the production of focused groundwater recharge (~3 % of the precipitation). These results have important implications for the potential for improving the performance of large scale models in dryland regions by indicating the appropriate temporal and spatial scales required for the proper representation of dryland hydrological processes.

How to cite: Quichimbo, E. A., Singer, M. B., Michaelides, K., Rosolem, R., and Cuthbert, M.: Sensitivity to spatial and temporal resolution in the performance of a parsimonious hydrological model for quantifying water balance partitioning in dryland regions., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3264, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3264, 2022.

EGU22-4015 | Presentations | HS2.2.1

Does catchment nestedness enhance hydrological similarity? 

Andrea Betterle and Gianluca Botter

This contribution analyses how the topological relationship between two river basins affects the correlation of the flows at their outlets. A pair of river basins can have two distinct topological configurations. They can either be nested (if the smaller catchment is part of a larger one), or they can be disjointed (or non-nested), if their contributing areas are not overlapping.  Nested catchments tend to be considered as hydrologically more similar as they share a fraction of their contributing area and, consequently, a fraction of their streamflows (i.e. they are hydrologically connected).  Nonetheless, using a large dataset of catchments spanning a wide range of scales and geomorphoclimatic conditions, we show that – as inter-catchment distance increases – the correlation between daily flows at the outlet of nested sites experiences a faster decline as compared to non-nested sites. By using a recently developed analytical model we are able to highlight that the enhanced loss of streamflow correlation in nested sites is primarily due to a sharp decrease in the frequency of simultaneous runoff-generating rainfall in the two contributing areas, and to a larger loss of correlation between their magnitudes. This surprising effect can be explained by the fact that, as distance increase, nested catchments tend to become systematically more heterogeneous in hydrologically-critical features such as in their size, elevation and slope. Acknowledging and understanding the enhanced hydrological variability of nested catchments across scales can help to better capture the spatial variability of river flows, with benefits for streamflow regionalization, ecological modelling and processes interpretation.

How to cite: Betterle, A. and Botter, G.: Does catchment nestedness enhance hydrological similarity?, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4015, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4015, 2022.

EGU22-5206 | Presentations | HS2.2.1

Karst development in different tectonic settings (Middle East, Greece, South China), concept analysis and first findings towards hydrology modeling reconsideration 

Daniel Moraetis, Kosmas Palvopoulos, Charalambos Fassoulas, Andreas Scharf, Frank Mattern, Xuan Yu, Christos Pennos, Kostas Adamopoulos, Stylianos Zacharias, Hamdan Hamdan, and Nikolaos Nikolaidis

As part of the International Geoscience IGCP-715 project, we present the core objective and preliminary analyses on the karst development of the study areas. Our aim is to further characterize the geomorphologic features of the extended karst of Koiliaris Critical Zone Observatory (KCZO), Crete, Greece. Simultaneously to better understand the main drivers of karst development we compare the CKZO karst system with other areas in different tectonic contexts such as Oman (Salma Plateau), the northern UAE and southern China (Guilin karst area).

Hydrological studies and previous geomorphologic analysis of KCZO suggest that 27% of the total water budget is coming from the adjacent watershed in the east where an extensive karst system with two explored super-deep caves is situated (Liontari Cave - 1100 m, Gourgouthakas Cave - 1200 m). The area is build up by a continuous carbonate succession exceeding 5 km in depth, lying on top of the Hellenic subduction zone. Field work and Google Earth mapping show two dominantly striking directions of failures (fault, fracture surfaces), trending E-W to ESE-WNW (90-120°) and N-S to NNE-SSE (0-22.5°). The N-S surfaces are mainly fractures while the E-W ones are mainly thrusts and/or strike-slip faults with obvious large displacements of hundreds of meters. The karst development in a subduction zone with dramatic thrusting on the overriding plate has created super-deep caves which are controlled by the vertical bedding and a series of faults and fractures. The area exhibits two layers with different hydraulic properties, a fast water-transferring zone and a slower one which is consistent and supports the hypothesis of the hydrologic model.  

At the Salma Plateau, in Oman, the karstic system is related to rapid uplifted Eocene limestones that overlay the Semail Ophiolite. There is a large cave (Majilis Al Jinn) at an area of interconnected fractures (and/or faults?). It is the only karstic system presented inhere which has similarities with the karstic system in the KCZO.

At the UAE and northern Oman (Musandam) is an active collision zone between Arabia and Eurasia with 2000-m-thick allochthonous Mesozoic limestones. The area lacks a subsurface karst system, and the only karst has developed in steep wadis.

Finally, the Guilin area in China represents a former passive margin with a Devonian limestone. It features a spectacular karst of conical peaks (fengcong) and tower peaks (fenglin). Caves exhibit mainly a horizontal development and there is no similarities to the KCZO.

How to cite: Moraetis, D., Palvopoulos, K., Fassoulas, C., Scharf, A., Mattern, F., Yu, X., Pennos, C., Adamopoulos, K., Zacharias, S., Hamdan, H., and Nikolaidis, N.: Karst development in different tectonic settings (Middle East, Greece, South China), concept analysis and first findings towards hydrology modeling reconsideration, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5206, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5206, 2022.

EGU22-5695 | Presentations | HS2.2.1

Are temporary stream observations useful for the calibration of a lumped hydrological model? 

Mirjam Scheller, Ilja van Meerveld, Eric Sauquet, Jan Seibert, and Marc Vis

Since 2012 the Observatoire National des Étiages (ONDE) has collected observations about the state of headwater streams across France. Streams that occasionally dry up (also called temporary or intermittent streams) are visited at least five times a year by trained staff and the flow state is visually assessed (dry stream, standing water, flowing water). These data have been used to calculate regional probabilities of drying with statistical models. However, the usefulness of this kind of data for the calibration or validation of bucket-type hydrological models has so far not been assessed.

We, therefore, used the ONDE dataset for the calibration of the HBV model to evaluate the potential of temporary stream observations to improve model predictions in data-scarce regions. The model was calibrated for almost 90 catchments throughout France. We used the information on the flow state of temporary streams, either alone or in combination with limited observations of discharge or water level at the outlet of the catchment for model calibration and evaluated the simulations based on the measured discharge. Because the ONDE data set is large, we could do an extensive analysis of the value of temporary stream observations and the way to optimize their use in hydrological models. While the study focuses on catchments in France, visual observations of temporary streams can - with the help of citizen scientists - be collected at any place in the world. Thus, the method has the potential to be applied in truly data scarce regions.

How to cite: Scheller, M., van Meerveld, I., Sauquet, E., Seibert, J., and Vis, M.: Are temporary stream observations useful for the calibration of a lumped hydrological model?, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5695, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5695, 2022.

EGU22-6003 | Presentations | HS2.2.1

Sensitivity analysis of water balance components with the Noah-MP and WRF-Hydro models 

Ioannis Sofokleous, Adriana Bruggeman, Marinos Eliades, and Corrado Camera

The accurate simulation and partitioning of the water balance components is important for the simulation of hydrological processes and the interaction between the land and the atmosphere. The objective of this study is to identify the model parameters and parameterization options that impact the most the water balance components modelled with the Noah-MP land surface model coupled to the WRF-Hydro hydrological model. The water balance components are runoff and total evapotranspiration (ET), comprised of evaporation, transpiration and interception. Three types of different parameterization options and 12 model parameters were tested and the sensitivity of the model output was investigated for two consecutive hydrological years and for 31 watersheds in the Troodos mountains of Cyprus, in the Eastern Mediterranean. A baseline configuration, based on initial estimates of model parameters from previous literature and suggested default values, of the Noah-MP and WRF-Hydro model system was found to systematically overestimate the total streamflow of the 31 watersheds, with the median runoff coefficient equal to 0.4 compared to the observed value of 0.2. Consistent with the streamflow overestimation, the ratio of total ET to total precipitation was underestimated, with a value of 0.5 compared to the value of 0.8 from local observations. The sensitivity analysis revealed that specific parameters can substantially modify the amount of simulated streamflow and ET. The bedrock drainage parameter, hydraulic conductivity and soil porosity can each reduce or increase streamflow and ET up to 20% on average. Among the vegetation parameters and model parameterization options, the change of the dynamic vegetation option, the use of the Jarvis-based stomatal conductance model, instead of the Ball-Berry model, and the simulation of nocturnal transpiration can each increase ET by about 20%, and thus reduce the overestimation of total streamflow. The findings of this sensitivity analysis can be used to configure the Noah-MP and WRF-Hydro models in order to improve the simulation of the water balance of the studied area and other areas with similar hydroclimatic characteristics.

How to cite: Sofokleous, I., Bruggeman, A., Eliades, M., and Camera, C.: Sensitivity analysis of water balance components with the Noah-MP and WRF-Hydro models, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6003, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6003, 2022.

Runoff characteristics of wetland-dominated landscapes are highly influenced by the heterogeneity of wetland properties such as contributing areas, local storage deficits, and degree of connection to the wetland network. Field observations indicate the fill-and-spill process is a common and controlling process in wetland-dominated landscapes in which wetlands receive water until a threshold is satisfied and then release water to the next water bodies in a basin. The upscaled probabilistic fill-and-spill algorithm provided here aims to take the understanding from observation of the fill-and-spill process in individual wetlands at local scales to estimate the response of thousands of wetlands to precipitation or snowmelt events at a larger scale. For this purpose, a novel derived distribution approach is implemented using the probabilistic characteristics of wetlands, i.e., deficit and concentrating factor probability distribution functions. The method proposed here is a generalization of the Probability Distributed Model (PDM) and Xinanjiang probabilistic runoff models with the inclusion of the effects of wetland contributing area and cascading networks. The analytical solution of this upscaled fill-and-spill processes has been compared with a Monte Carlo solution and then implemented in RAVEN, a semi distributed hydrological modelling framework. The accuracy and ability of the model simulation has been tested on ten watersheds in the Qu'Appelle River Basin in Saskatchewan, Canada. The promising simulation results obtained from manual and automated calibration shows strength of the proposed upscaled fill-and-spill algorithm in simulation of low gradient landscapes.

How to cite: Taheri, M. and Craig, J.: Implementation of an upscaled probabilistic fill-and-spill method to simulate wetland-dominated landscapes, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6239, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6239, 2022.

EGU22-6315 | Presentations | HS2.2.1

Assessing the physical controls of simulated drain flow dynamics 

Hafsa Mahmood, Raphael Schneider, Rasmus Frederiksen, Anders Christiansen, and Simon Stisen

Almost 50% of the agricultural land in Denmark is tile drained, and it includes a wide range of hydrogeological and topographical settings. These drains in the shallow groundwater system influence the hydrology and nutrient transport in subsurface and surface waters significantly. Therefore, it is critical to understand the share of drainage with respect to the recharge in shallow groundwater systems to get a holistic picture of drain flow dynamics in varied topographical and hydrogeological settings. To address these issues, multiple tile-drain catchments (28 sites, with measured drain flow timeseries) across Denmark are used to test the response of tile drains in varied topographical and hydrogeological settings on field scale. Using the national hydrological model of Denmark (DK-model) in MIKE-SHE as a basis, 10m resolution groundwater flow models for all the drain catchments are established. Combined calibration for all drain catchments is conducted by evaluating percent bias (PBIAS) and Kling-Gupta Efficiency (KGE) of simulated and observed discharge data using the Pareto Archived Dynamically Dimensioned Search (PADDS) of the OSTRICH optimization tool. Principal component analysis (PCA) on independent physical explanatory variables (and indexes) representing topography and hydrogeology is used to reduce all collected variables to significant variables only. Linear polynomial ridge regression is used to study whether independent explanatory variables are sufficient to represent drain flow distribution or whether additional information derived from the groundwater flow models is needed. In this presentation, we will show if the independent topographical and geological variables can predict drain flow fraction and among all explanatory variables, which variables play the most significant role. Moreover, the resulting groundwater flow model of Denmark will serve to produce a training dataset of drain flow fraction that can be used further with machine learning approaches to predict drain flow dynamics for all of Denmark. The results of the study will contribute to improved drain flow predictions across all of Denmark by improving the understanding of controls on drain flow behaviour.

How to cite: Mahmood, H., Schneider, R., Frederiksen, R., Christiansen, A., and Stisen, S.: Assessing the physical controls of simulated drain flow dynamics, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6315, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6315, 2022.

EGU22-6534 | Presentations | HS2.2.1

Influences of temporal variability on the calibration of a hydrologic model  

Tibebe Tigabu, Paul Wagner, Balaji Narasimhan, and Nicola Fohrer

Abstract: Parametrization is an important step to construct a reasonable hydrologic model for a catchment. However, selecting appropriate model parameters can be challenging, particularly in data scarce regions. Conventionally, hydrologic model parameters are selected through calibration assuming that catchment processes and model parameters are stationary over time. However, the assumption of stationarity may not be valid all the time due to temporal changes in the behaviors of catchments. Therefore, the purpose of this study is to investigate the influence of temporal variability on the SWAT model parametrization using different calibration periods. To this end, we calibrated the SWAT model based on daily and monthly streamflow data in the Adyar catchment, Chennai. Results showed that the SWAT model performance and parameter values differed when the calibration periods were shifted by one year. This is reflected in the KGE (Kling Gupta Efficiency) values that varied between 0.38 to 0.68 for calibration periods of 2004-2007,2005-2008, 2006-2009, 2007-2010, 2008-2011, 2009-2012 and 2010-2013. Likewise, the selection of values for sensitive model parameters varied even though the parameter values were chosen in the same ranges. Moreover, independent model evaluation for wet and dry years showed significantly different performance indices and model parameter values. The model efficiency of wet years (NSE = 0.59 and KGE= 0.68) was by far better than the model efficiency of dry years (NSE = -0.59 and KGE = 0.1). In general, this study provides a good insight into hydrologic model calibration under non-stationarity conditions.

How to cite: Tigabu, T., Wagner, P., Narasimhan, B., and Fohrer, N.: Influences of temporal variability on the calibration of a hydrologic model , EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6534, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6534, 2022.

EGU22-7297 | Presentations | HS2.2.1

Exploring spatiotemporal dynamics of soil moisture: three model conceptualizations in a subarctic catchment 

Jari-Pekka Nousu, Kersti Leppä, Hannu Marttila, Pertti Ala-aho, Mika Aurela, Annalea Lohila, and Samuli Launiainen

Surface soil parameters, especially soil moisture has a key role in soil nutrient cycling, greenhouse gas emissions, vegetation water use as well as energy and water exchanges between land and the atmosphere. In this study, we model soil moisture with three different model conceptualizations developed in Spatial Forest Hydrology model (SpaFHy) in a subarctic Pallas catchment in Northern Finland, covered by coniferous forests and peatlands. The model versions differ in how the groundwater flow is treated, which is shown to have a clear impact on the spatiotemporal soil moisture dynamics within the catchment. The conceptualizations range from i) neglecting groundwater storage, to ii) TOPMODEL approach, and to iii) spatially distributed groundwater flow model. By comparing these scenarios, we are able to assess when and where solving the 2D ground water flow is prerequisite for accurate predictions of soil moisture, and in which conditions soil moisture variability is driven more by local processes. The model results are compared against continuous point-scale measurements, and spatially against distributed measurement campaigns conducted in the study area. In addition, we compare the spatiotemporal soil moisture simulations with novel SAR-based soil moisture maps. SAR signal is well suited to estimate topsoil moisture thanks to its high sensitivity to water. However, different topographic and vegetation settings create challenges for SAR signals to capture the properties of soil, and thus, SAR soil moisture estimates have not been as widely used in forested areas. Remote sensing products such as SAR-based soil moisture maps possess a major potential to further develop spatially distributed land surface and hydrological models.

How to cite: Nousu, J.-P., Leppä, K., Marttila, H., Ala-aho, P., Aurela, M., Lohila, A., and Launiainen, S.: Exploring spatiotemporal dynamics of soil moisture: three model conceptualizations in a subarctic catchment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7297, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7297, 2022.

EGU22-7298 | Presentations | HS2.2.1

100 years of river flow timing characteristics and extreme flow analysis 

Abolfazl Jalali Shahrood and Ali Torabi Haghighi

River ice has a significant impact on nearly 60% of rivers in the northern hemisphere where ice jams due to river ice are responsible for some severe and recurrent floods in the northern rivers. The ice formation (i.e., freeze-up event) occurs during the wintertime when the temperature drops to freezing point and when the flow gradually reaches the lowest value for a while, and it keeps the river frozen with low flow occurring close to the period of the maximum ice cover before the spring melt is initiated.  In this research, we focus on detecting the periods with low flow (i.e., freezing period). Daily discharge time series were used to derive the annual freezing periods as well as extreme discharge values over a century in Tana and Tornio Rivers in the Finnish borders of Sweden and Norway.  Therefore, the timing characteristics such as duration, probable shifts through time, and overall flow extremes including the average low and high flow in a period of 90 days in each water year were quantified. The study showed that both low and high flows in two rivers had a significant negative trend in their occurrence date by a confidence level of 95%. In addition, it was observed that the seasonal 90-day low and high flow periods happened earlier in recent years. On the other hand, Tana River showed a negative trend in its annual minimum flow over the century which is an opposite event in comparison with Tornio River. The duration of low flow in the Tana River has been significantly increased by the confidence level of 95% from a range of 50-70 days to a range of 100-140 days. In Tornio River, the duration has been significantly decreased by the confidence level of 95%. In the first ten years, the duration is about 120 days on average, while the duration in the last ten years is about 50 days.

How to cite: Jalali Shahrood, A. and Torabi Haghighi, A.: 100 years of river flow timing characteristics and extreme flow analysis, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7298, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7298, 2022.

EGU22-7786 | Presentations | HS2.2.1

Evidence-based requirements for perceptualising intercatchment groundwater flow in hydrological models 

Louisa Oldham, Jim Freer, Gemma Coxon, Christopher Jackson, John Bloomfield, and Nicholas Howden

Groundwater-dominated catchments are often critical for nationally-important water resources. Many conceptual rainfall-runoff models used for the simulation of river flows tend to degrade in their model performance in groundwater-dominated catchments as they are rarely designed to simulate spatial groundwater behaviours or interactions with surface waters. Intercatchment groundwater flow is one such neglected variable. Efforts have been made to incorporate this process into existing models, but there is a need for greater emphasis on improving our perceptual models of groundwater-surface water interactions prior to any model edits.

In this study, national meteorological, hydrological, hydrogeological, geological and artificial influence (characterising abstractions and return flows) datasets are used to develop a perceptual model of intercatchment groundwater flow and how it varies spatially and temporally across the River Thames. We characterise the water balance, presence of gaining/losing river reaches and intra-annual dynamics in 80 subcatchments of the River Thames in the UK, taking advantage of its wealth of data, densely gauged river network and geological variability.

We show the prevalence of non-conservative river reaches across the study area, with heterogeneity both between, and within, geological units giving rise to a complex distribution of recharge and discharge points along the river network. We identify where non-conservative reaches can be attributed to intercatchment groundwater flow, and where other processes (e.g. human abstractions and discharge uncertainty) are likely the cause. Escarpments of Chalk and Jurassic Limestone show evidence of intercatchment groundwater flow both from headwater to downstream reaches, and out-of-catchment via springlines. We found temporal as well as spatial variability across the study area, with more seasonality and variability in river catchments on Jurassic Limestone outcrops and less on Chalk and Lower Greensand outcrops. Our results show the need for a degree of local investigation and hydrogeological perceptualisation within regional analysis, which we show to be achievable given relatively simple geological interpretation and data requirements.  We then discuss the inclusion of external flow fluxes within existing models to enable calibration improvements in groundwater-dominated catchments, and, importantly, the characterisation of these fluxes given the temporal and spatial variability of intercatchment groundwater flow that our perceptual model has shown.

How to cite: Oldham, L., Freer, J., Coxon, G., Jackson, C., Bloomfield, J., and Howden, N.: Evidence-based requirements for perceptualising intercatchment groundwater flow in hydrological models, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7786, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7786, 2022.

EGU22-7813 | Presentations | HS2.2.1

On the accurate representation of hydropower systems in large-scale hydrological models 

Andrea Galletti, Diego Avesani, Alberto Bellin, and Bruno Majone

Natural streamflow of most mountain catchments worldwide is altered as a consequence of hydropower exploitation and other water uses. Hydrological modelling in these watersheds represents a challenging task, as the streamflow alteration caused by hydropower production is linked to operational schedules as well as to geometrical and technical constraints, which are system specific. Key parameters controlling hydropower functioning are difficult to acquire, because protected by producers, hence modelling hydropower systems in large domains often resorts to simplified (and less realistic) approaches, in order to cope with the lack of information. However, the accuracy of the simulations depends critically on the reliability of the simplified assumptions, which varies among the proposed approaches. In this work we analyzed the impact of the simplifications typically introduced in modelling hydropower at the catchment and larger scales by assuming as reference HYPERstreamHS, a coupled hydrological and hydraulic model exploiting the information publicly available on single hydropower systems. We present an application of the proposed framework to the Adige river basin, a large watershed located in the south-eastern portion of the Alps, in which the presence of 39 large hydropower systems characterized by complex infrastructures, 22 of which connected to storage reservoirs, causes significant alterations of streamflow timing and magnitude. We demonstrate the benefit of accurately representing hydropower-related water diversions by analyzing how the model represents the observed streamflows at impacted sites and hydropower production at the regional scale. We also provide insights on how a simplified representation of large hydropower systems can lead to a biased evaluation of streamflow alterations at impacted sections and of hydropower production at several sites. Our results show that the effects of different simplifications that may be adopted in the modelling framework combine in a non-linear manner, thus complicating the overall evaluation of the associated impacts.

How to cite: Galletti, A., Avesani, D., Bellin, A., and Majone, B.: On the accurate representation of hydropower systems in large-scale hydrological models, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7813, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7813, 2022.

Pedotransferfunctions (PTF) play a major role in physically based hydrological modeling, as they establish the relationship between soil properties and the water stress curve. The selection of the PTF thus has a great influence on the water balance of a catchment in general, as well as on the spatial distribution and intensity of runoff processes. In this study, these very influences of PTF's on the runoff processes will be investigated. The hydrological model "WaSiM-ETH", which was calibrated and validated, is used for the investigations. On the basis of this modeling, 11 further scenarios were created, which differ only in their PTFs. In all scenarios an artificial weather event is applied, which includes a constant heavy precipitation of 100 mm as well as input data, which excludes the generation of interfering processes e.g., evaporation or snowfall. In addition, these scenarios will be applied to different system conditions to determine the differences of dry, humid, and wet system preconditions. Ultimately, the precipitation intensity but not the amount of the artificial weather event will also be varied to be able to determine any change in the dominant runoff processes due to precipitation intensity. The results of the modeling will then be compared using the generated surface runoff, interflow, and deep infiltration. In addition, a check of the modeling with a runoff process map available for the catchment area as well as a pattern comparison using the spatial efficiency metric (SPEAF) will be performed. It is expected that the different PTF´s per se, as well as depending on the system precondition and precipitation intensity, will result in very different spatial distributions and dominance of the individual runoff processes. Thus, one goal is to find the PTF´s that provide comprehensible distributions and intensities of the considered runoff processes.

How to cite: Jackel, M., Casper, M., and Mohajerani, H.: The effect of different pedotransferfunctions on the spatial distribution and intensity of runoff processes using the hydrological model WaSiM-ETH., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8027, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8027, 2022.

EGU22-8451 | Presentations | HS2.2.1

Advancing the science and practice of community hydrologic modeling: Development of open-source models, methods, and datasets to enable process-based hydrologic prediction across North America (and beyond) 

Martyn Clark, Louise Arnal, Andrew Bennett, Dave Casson, Shervan Gharari, Janine Hay, Jim Freer, Wouter Knoben, Hongli Liu, Naoki Mizukami, Bart Nijssen, Simon Papalexiou, Raymond Spiteri, Guoqiang Tang, Ashley Van Beusekom, and Andy Wood

Many hydrologic modelling groups face similar challenges, with untapped opportunities to share code and concepts across different model development groups. An active community of practice is emerging, where the focus is not so much on developing a community hydrologic model, but more on advancing the science and practice of community hydrologic modeling. This presentation will summarize our recent efforts to develop open-source models, methods, and datasets to enable process-based hydrologic prediction across North America (and beyond). The contributions include (1) developing ensemble meteorological datasets for North America and the globe; (2) developing modular approaches to hydrologic modeling through a hierarchal approach that separates different model sub-domains (vegetation, snow, soil, groundwater) and separates the physical representations from the numerical solution; (3) implementing third-party numerical solvers (sundials) to improve the robustness and efficiency of the numerical solutions; (4) developing agile parallelization methods capable of handling heterogeneous computing loads and bottlenecks in the downstream reaches of large river networks; (5) implementing flexible model configuration toolbox to accelerate the implementation of large-domain hydrologic models; (6) advancing methods for river lake routing, including development of integrated river-lake hydrography datasets and development of large-domain reservoir management models; (7) advancing methods for large-domain parameter estimation; (8) advancing methods for ensemble data assimilation; and (9) advancing methods for probabilistic hydrologic prediction on time scales from seconds to seasons. We will discuss some of the major challenges encountered and the high-priority research that is necessary to advance capabilities in large-domain hydrologic prediction.

How to cite: Clark, M., Arnal, L., Bennett, A., Casson, D., Gharari, S., Hay, J., Freer, J., Knoben, W., Liu, H., Mizukami, N., Nijssen, B., Papalexiou, S., Spiteri, R., Tang, G., Van Beusekom, A., and Wood, A.: Advancing the science and practice of community hydrologic modeling: Development of open-source models, methods, and datasets to enable process-based hydrologic prediction across North America (and beyond), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8451, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8451, 2022.

Integrated hydrological models (IHM) are often used for a better understanding of the hydrological fluxes at the surface and in the subsurface. IHMs can also be coupled to land surface models to study the interactions between vegetation and hydrological processes. At our study site, the Weierbach catchment (43 ha), Luxembourg, sap flux observations showed high spatial variability in observed transpiration due to many factors such as DBH, landscape characteristics and position, and tree species. However, this spatial variability is often not captured by land surface models at small scale and transpiration fluxes are usually treated as an integrated flux. In our study, we employ the coupled integrated surface-subsurface hydrological model Parflow coupled with the land surface model (CLM) to simulate water and energy fluxes in the forested Weierbach catchment in Luxembourg. Our objectives are twofold. First, we evaluate the coupled physically-based model and land surface model with discharge, groundwater level and soil moisture, and spatiotemporal sap flow data. In addition to that, we are exploring whether simulated and observed transpiration for three different hillslope positions (plateau, midslope, hillfoot) are driven by atmospheric demand or water availability in the subsurface. Our main result was that model has captured discharge, groundwater fluxes and the average transpiration well. However, the modelled transpiration showed a much smaller spatial variability compared to the spatial variability derived from sapflow observation. For the three different hillslope positions, we found that the fluxes were mainly driven by atmospheric demand and the model captured this dominance well. Our results demonstrate that there is a limitation of the model in reproducing the spatial variability of transpiration in the heterogeneous forest and future modelling work at small scale needs to better parameterize the spatial characteristics of vegetation.

How to cite: Moussa, A., Sulis, M., and Klaus, J.: On the value of benchmarking a fully coupled surface-subsurface model with spatially distributed sap flow measurements, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8452, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8452, 2022.

EGU22-8487 | Presentations | HS2.2.1

Prediction of flow intermittence in Drying River Networks using a process-based hydrological model 

Annika Künne, Louise Mimeau, Flora Branger, and Sven Kralisch

Intermittent rivers and ephemeral streams (IRES) account for about half of the world’s river
networks and are considered to increase under climate change and growing anthropogenic water
use. However, the hydrological mechanisms that control the spatio-temporal flow patterns in IRES
and their effects on the expansion and contraction of stream segments are not fully understood.
Discharge measurements mainly exist for gauging stations, which are often located downstream and
in the rivers’ main stems. They are often less impacted by flow intermittence than headwaters and
smaller river channels. In consequence, impacts of climate change and anthropogenic alterations on
hydrological process dynamics in IRES cannot easily be analysed, neither the influences of climate
change and human water use on IRES be quantified.
Within the framework of the Horizon 2020 project DRYvER on Drying River Networks and
Climate Change, we try to tackle this challenge by developing methods and tools using the JAMS
modelling framework and J2K model family to assess hydrological process interactions at high
spatial and temporal resolutions, which include the scale of small reaches (about 50 ha catchment
size). For that purpose, we developed process-based hydrological models for six mesoscaled river
basins between 200 km² and 350 km² in different European countries (Croatia, Czech Republic,
Finland, France, Hungary, Spain). At the same time, we used data from field measurements
and a citizens science application to validate our models at the reach scale. In this study we
analyse the ability of our hydrological model to represent observed temporal and spatial dynamics
of flow intermittence at high resolution, and develop adaptations that allows using these models
in an upscaling step to estimate the impacts of future climatic changes and anthropogenic water
consumption on flow intermittence all over Europe.

How to cite: Künne, A., Mimeau, L., Branger, F., and Kralisch, S.: Prediction of flow intermittence in Drying River Networks using a process-based hydrological model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8487, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8487, 2022.

EGU22-9172 | Presentations | HS2.2.1

Potential of satellite surface soil moisture products for spatially calibrating distributed eco-hydrological models 

José Gomis-Cebolla, Alicia Garcia-Arias, Martí Perpinyà-Vallès, and Félix Francés

Calibration of distributed hydrological models needs to include spatial information of the hydrological processes in order to guarantee a robust spatial representation of the model state variables. Satellite remote sensing monitoring the Earth in a temporal and spatial comprehensive way stands out as a valuable resource of this kind of information. Surface soil moisture (SSM) plays a key role in the description of the hydrological cycle, especially in semi-arid areas. Nevertheless, the coarse resolution of available SSM products has restricted the use of SSM in the calibration of hydrological models to only the temporal approach. The current operational SSM estimates (1km) resulting from new sensor estimates or the application of downscaling methodologies pave the way for this spatial calibration approach. The present study explores the applicability of these spatially enhanced SSM estimates for distributed eco-hydrological modelling in Mediterranean forest basins. On one hand, it contributes to fill the existing research gap on the use of remote sensing SSM spatial patterns within the distributed hydrological modelling framework, in particular in medium/small basins. On the other hand, it serves as an indirect validation method for the spatial performance of satellite SSM products. TETIS eco-hydrological distributed model was implemented in three case studies, named Carraixet (eastern Spain), Hozgarganta (southern Spain), and Ceira (western Portugal), which were strategically selected to perform this research in the Mediterranean Region. The SSM estimates selected for evaluation were: Sentinel-1 SSM provided by the Copernicus Global Land Services (CGLS), SMAP SSM disaggregated using Sentinel-1 provided by the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA), SMOS SSM provided by the Barcelona Expert Center (BEC), and SMOS and SMAP SSM disaggregated using the Dispatch algorithm provided by Lobelia Earth. The methodology employed involved a multi-objective and multi-variable calibration using the considering remote sensing SSM spatial patterns and in-situ streamflow, using the Spatial Efficiency Metric (SPAEF) and the Nash-Sutcliffe efficiency index (NSE) respectively. In spite of the spatial and temporal differences amongst products, the multi-objective calibration approach proposed increased the robustness of the hydrological modelling. Spatial and temporal agreement depends on the selection of the SSM product. The disaggregating methodology determined the spatial agreement to a greater degree than the sensor itself.

How to cite: Gomis-Cebolla, J., Garcia-Arias, A., Perpinyà-Vallès, M., and Francés, F.: Potential of satellite surface soil moisture products for spatially calibrating distributed eco-hydrological models, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9172, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9172, 2022.

EGU22-9791 | Presentations | HS2.2.1

A biogeochemical approach to build a perceptual hydrological model for a small peri-urban catchment 

Olivier Grandjouan, Flora Branger, Matthieu Masson, Benoit Cournoyer, and Marina Coquery

The origin and transport of water in peri-urban catchments is complex to model as they are affected by multiple anthropogenic modifications of water pathways (surface imperviousness, sewer overflow releases…), especially in a context of fast growing urbanization. The hydrological dynamics are also  impacted by natural and agricultural land use patterns. Perceptual models aim at reproducing our understanding of a catchment behaviour and can be useful to illustrate the impact of such spatial contrast and human-induced modifications on a catchment hydrological dynamics. Conservative geochemical and microbiological tracers can be linked to the hydrological processes and water pathways to enhance this understanding and to build-up the hydrological perceptual model of a catchment.

From 2017 to 2019, a monthly monitoring of geochemical and microbiological tracers was conducted at the Ratier catchment (19 km²) near Lyon (France). Surface waters were collected and analysed for major chemical parameters (cations, anions, dissolved organic carbon and conductivity), dissolved metals, stable isotopes (2H et 18O), and microbial parameters (total bacterial counts, microbial source tracking DNA datasets, species – specific DNA trackings). Using these datasets, a step-by-step statistical approach was undertaken, and used to build-up the perceptual hydrological model. The main steps were: (1) group correlated biochemical parameters to reduce redundancy in the dataset, (2) compute the main indicators illustrating the hydro-climatologic dynamics during the sampling campaigns (e.g. antecedent index precipitation, average daily flow) based on the hypothesis of a two-component catchment (groundwater and subsurface flow), and (3) perform a principal component analysis to link the biogeochemical dataset to the computed hydro-climatologic indicators and the runoff processes.

Results revealed a differentiation of the datasets in two groups matching groundwaters and subsurface waters. Groundwaters showed two geochemical profiles linked to the two main geological formations of the catchment. Subsurface waters showed more variable biogeochemical patterns highly influenced by land use and soil properties. This step-by-step statistical approach led to a better understanding of the dynamics of the water pathways and these insights were then used to build-up the hydrological perceptual model of the catchment. As a next step, such a model should help in the evaluation and improvement of a distributed hydrological model.

How to cite: Grandjouan, O., Branger, F., Masson, M., Cournoyer, B., and Coquery, M.: A biogeochemical approach to build a perceptual hydrological model for a small peri-urban catchment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9791, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9791, 2022.

EGU22-9950 | Presentations | HS2.2.1

Alpine grassland hydrologic response to climate change from plot to catchment scale 

Matevz Vremec, Veronika Forstner, Markus Herndl, Luca Guillaumot, Peter Burek, and Steffen Birk

Warming and elevated CO2 concentrations are expected to alter catchment hydrology through changes in precipitation and evapotranspiration. In particular, warming is expected to enhance evapotranspiration, whereas elevated CO2 tends to decrease root-water uptake, thus reducing evapotranspiration. Plot-scale Lysimeter Temperature Free Air Carbon Enrichment (Lysi-T-FACE) systems provide in-depth information on the response of soil water fluxes to future climate conditions, particularly evapotranspiration and seepage. Hydrological models of different complexity can be used to extend the findings from the plot scale to the catchment level, allowing the assessment of the discharge response to climate change.

We run a climate change experiment by using lysimeters to study the effect of elevated CO2 and warming on alpine grassland soil water fluxes. The experiment includes six lysimeters, with a reference lysimeter operating under ambient conditions, two lysimeters are treated with elevated CO2 concentration of +300 ppm, two lysimeters are operating under constant warming of +3 K, and one operating under a combination of warming and elevated CO2. Soil water fluxes within each lysimeter were modelled with the process-based hydrological model Hydrus-1D. We observed differences in seepage between the six lysimeters at both the event-based and annual time scale. For some individual events, such as the heavy rainfall event following a dry period in summer 2018, more remarkable differences between the experiments were observed.

To upscale the effects of the lysimeter-based approach to catchment scale, a conceptual lumped-parameter model (GR4J-Cemaneige) was used to model the discharge of a nearby alpine grassland catchment. The GR4J model reproduced discharge well when using lysimeter ET at ambient conditions (NSE>0.75). Evapotranspiration (ET) as input was modified based on the lysimeter ET fluxes representing possible future climate conditions. The effects of different ET inputs on simulated catchment discharge were similar to those on seepage at the plot level on an annual basis. However, no significant effects of different ET input on discharge were observed at individual events, such as the one in 2018. A comparison between a process-based hydrological model and the conceptual lumped-parameter model is planned to further investigate the effect of the hydrological response to climate change at the catchment scale.

How to cite: Vremec, M., Forstner, V., Herndl, M., Guillaumot, L., Burek, P., and Birk, S.: Alpine grassland hydrologic response to climate change from plot to catchment scale, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9950, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9950, 2022.

EGU22-10770 | Presentations | HS2.2.1

How realistic are the spatial patterns simulated from field-scale resolving land surface models? 

Nathaniel Chaney, Laura Torres Rojas, Jiaxuan Cai, and Noemi Vergopolan

Emerging field-scale resolving land surface models (LSMs), such as HydroBlocks, aim to model the water, energy, and biogeochemical cycles (e.g., surface energy partitioning) at 10-100 meter spatial scales over continental extents. However, there has yet to be a concerted effort to evaluate the realism of the simulated field-scale spatial patterns. This presentation challenges the scientific community to evaluate the modeled multi-scale spatial patterns of contemporary land surface models more critically. Here, we present an approach to evaluate the modeled multi-scale spatial patterns of land surface temperature (a linchpin state variable in the land surface energy and water cycles) of the HydroBlocks LSM using GOES-16 land surface temperature over the contiguous United States (CONUS).

To perform this evaluation, HydroBlocks is run at an effective 30-meter spatial resolution over CONUS at an hourly time step between 2015 and 2020. The domain is then split into 0.5 arcdegree grid cells (~50 km) and a series of spatial statistics are computed (e.g., spatial variance and correlation length) at hourly, daily, monthly, and annual time steps. These spatial statistics are also calculated using the GOES-16 land surface temperature product at the available time steps (with 80%+ spatial coverage per 0.5 degree grid cell). GOES-16 provides hourly observations of land surface temperature over CONUS at a 2 km spatial resolution. The simulated and observed spatial statistics are then compared between 2017 and 2020 for each macroscale grid cell over CONUS. The results show a poor correlation between the two at hourly time scales but show marked improvement over larger time scales. In any case, the surprisingly weak correlation between the observed and simulated spatial statistics reinforce the need to think more critically about the spatial uncertainty chain in land surface models. More importantly, this work reemphasizes the need to make simulated spatial patterns an integral part of the evaluation and calibration of macroscale land surface and hydrologic models moving forward.

How to cite: Chaney, N., Torres Rojas, L., Cai, J., and Vergopolan, N.: How realistic are the spatial patterns simulated from field-scale resolving land surface models?, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10770, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10770, 2022.

EGU22-11728 | Presentations | HS2.2.1

Developing a global database of contemporary sediment yield observations 

Florence Tan, Pasquale Borrelli, Gert Verstraeten, Anatoly Tsyplenkov, Benjamin Campforts, Valentin Golosov, Bernhard Lehner, Jean Poesen, and Matthias Vanmaercke

For many decades, sediment yield (SY) observations have been collected around the world to analyze, monitor, and better understand the state and dynamics of various Earth system processes. These records are highly relevant for a wide variety of research applications, yet they remain poorly accessible, especially for large-scale studies. A main reason for this is the fact that many of these measurements are collected on an isolated basis, leading to inconsistencies across data sets. SY observations also suffer from large uncertainties in data quality: key factors such as location accuracy, sampling method and frequency, measuring period, and others vary greatly but are not systematically reported.

To address these shortcomings and provide a standardized global reference for SY data, we are developing an extensive, coherent and georeferenced global database of contemporary SY observations. Through an extensive review of (grey) literature and contacts with numerous research groups, we already compiled SY observations for >8,000 catchments worldwide (comprising a total of >80,000 catchment years of observations). These observations are either derived from gauging station measurements or reservoir sedimentation rates. We assess the reliability of SY records and provide data quality indices based on available information such as measuring location, reported catchment area, sampling method and frequency, and measuring period. We further link the SY observations to the HydroSHEDS global river network, making them readily accessible and consistent with a wide array of hydro-environmental catchment variables also connected to the HydroSHEDS network. 

This new global SY database creates untouched opportunities for large-scale model development and statistical analyses of sediment-related factors and processes, such as soil erosion, sediment budgets, land cover and land use change impacts, or hydrological and sediment connectivity. Here we present a first overview of the data collected so far, its spatial patterns and its research potential. 

How to cite: Tan, F., Borrelli, P., Verstraeten, G., Tsyplenkov, A., Campforts, B., Golosov, V., Lehner, B., Poesen, J., and Vanmaercke, M.: Developing a global database of contemporary sediment yield observations, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11728, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11728, 2022.

In recent years, major floods triggered by convective events during the summer months repeatedly occurred in central western Europe, where flood regimes had previously been characterised by slowly developing inundations in winter. This imposes a great challenge on conceptual hydrological models, as other runoff mechanisms seem to dominate during convective storms than the storage-driven runoff production, which dominates flood formation in the wet season. Hence, most hydrological models that are used for operational flood forecasting struggle when applied to convective events and show deficiencies in capturing peak flows and timing flood volumes. It is thereby unclear to which extent the uncertainty in precipitation input and discharge observations, the influence of the catchment state, the model structure itself, or a combination of several or all of these factors, compromise successful predictions. To shed light on this question, we will compare how different model structures perform during high flows across a range of catchment physiographic settings. We will analyse the performance of a conceptual hydrological water balance model and identify its deficiencies by comparing it to a data driven model. This comparison will reveal whether uncertainties in the input and output data or model structural deficiencies are the major source of error. This will allow us to identify systematic errors, compare them and improve the model structure.

How to cite: Meyer, J., Loritz, R., Pfister, L., and Zehe, E.: Learning from differing errors between machine learning and a conceptual hydrological model - the case of convective storms and flash floods, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12250, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12250, 2022.

EGU22-12561 | Presentations | HS2.2.1

Modeling the hydrological cycle of the Adige using the GEOframe system 

Martin Morlot, Riccardo Rigon, and Giuseppe Frometta

River Adige is the second longest in Italy and affects the population living in the Trentino Alto Adige and the Venetian plain for irrigation. Having an area relatively small (~11000 square kilometers), it is however affected by a complexity of issues including: high anthropization causing intensive and often conflicting water uses, displacement of water resources from one sub-catchment to another, presence of seasonal snow cover with runoff delayed from snow falling season to late Spring and Summer, glaciers depletion under the climate change impulse. All those issues make the modeling of the water cycle of the river area challenging and, at the same time urgent.

This contribution has the objective to illustrate an effort to model the basin at high resolution with the aim to search for the closure of the water and energy budgets for the years of 1980-2018. Within this budgets simulation, we want to address a quantitative assessment of the effects of recent climate changes on the availability of the resource and, for what concern, the basin area evaluate the regional variability of the resource up to the scale of sub-catchments of area of around 5km². This is done with the help of the GEOframe modeling system (Formetta et al, 2014), an open-source, semi-distributed, component-based hydrological modeling system. The different components of the system enable to model different processes of the hydrological cycle: geomorphology, radiation, evapotranspiration, rainfall-snowmelt separation, discharge calculation and the try of different hypothesis on the work of the elementary hydrological components. The results are also compared with those of the analysis conducted in Thedoros et al., 2020.

References:

Formetta, G., A. Antonello, S. Franceschi, O. David, and R. Rigon. 2014. “Hydrological Modelling with Components: A GIS-Based Open-Source Framework.” Environmental Modelling & Software 55 (May): 190–200.

Mastrotheodoros, Theodoros, Christoforos Pappas, Peter Molnar, Paolo Burlando, Gabriele Manoli, Juraj Parajka, Riccardo Rigon, et al. 2020. “More Green and Less Blue Water in the Alps during Warmer Summers.” Nature Climate Change 10 (2): 155–61.

How to cite: Morlot, M., Rigon, R., and Frometta, G.: Modeling the hydrological cycle of the Adige using the GEOframe system, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12561, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12561, 2022.

EGU22-13237 | Presentations | HS2.2.1

Testing a new hybrid runoff generation module in four typical watersheds across different hydrometeorological zones in China 

Qinuo Zhang, Ke Zhang, Linjun Chao, Xinyu Chen, Jiayi Wang, and Nan Wu

Runoff generation in semi-humid regions is always characterized by a complex nonlinear process influenced by both saturation excess mechanism and infiltration excess mechanism. A hybrid runoff generation module is proposed in this study to delineate the mixed rainfall-runoff process by integrating an infiltration module, based on a modified Horton equation, with the saturation excess runoff generation module of Xinanjiang model at grid scale. A new distributed hydrological model, termed grid-Xinanjiang-infiltration-excess (GXAJ-IE) model, is subsequently developed in the context of grid-Xinanjiang model. Not only in semi-humid regions, but GXAJ-IE model is also expected to achieve acceptable performance in other hydrometeorological zones due to its superimposed runoff generation structure. Thus GXAJ-IE model is tested in four watersheds across different hydrometeorological zones (humid, semi-humid, semi-arid and arid) of China, and two models with single runoff generation mode, grid-Xinanjiang (GXAJ) model and grid-infiltration-excess (GIE) model, are set as benchmarks for comparison purpose. The results indicate that compared with the two benchmark models, GXAJ-IE model has higher flexibility and robustness in reproducing the flood hydrographs, especially the flood peaks, driven by various rainfall patterns in the semi-humid Dongwan and Maduwang watersheds. Furthermore, GXAJ-IE model could well capture the spatiotemporal characteristic of the saturation and infiltration excess runoff components, and delineate the evolution of their contributing areas within a flood event. Yet rainfall input with low spatiotemporal resolution still remains a limitation to give full play to the advantage of GXAJ-IE model. None of the models performs well in the arid and semi-arid Suide watershed, even though, GXAJ-IE model shows comparable simulation accuracy with GIE model whereas GXAJ model absolutely loses its edge. In the humid Tunxi watershed, GXAJ-IE model produces comparably good performance with GXAJ model while GIE model is slightly inferior. Overall, GXAJ-IE model is fairly adaptable to different hydrometeorological regions in China and shows great potential for universal application, with an especially promising prospect in improving the flood forecasting accuracy for the semi-humid watersheds.

How to cite: Zhang, Q., Zhang, K., Chao, L., Chen, X., Wang, J., and Wu, N.: Testing a new hybrid runoff generation module in four typical watersheds across different hydrometeorological zones in China, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13237, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13237, 2022.

The hydrological responses of a catchment are predominantly governed by complex interactions among processes occurring at various spatial and temporal scales. Hydrological modelling serves as a powerful tool in assimilating this complex behaviour of hydrological systems. As hydrological processes exhibit non-linear behaviour at all scales, it becomes essential to understand how much spatial approximations are necessary for a model to adequately represent reality. This study aims at investigating the influence of spatial resolution of a physically-based hydrological model in capturing the hydrological processes of a catchment which is characterized by large scale variability in the regional distribution of water resources. In this study, the grid-based Variable Infiltration Capacity (VIC) model is employed at spatial resolutions of 0.125, 0.25, and 1-degree latitude by longitude over the Cauvery river basin in peninsular India. The model incorporates both surface and subsurface hydrological processes, features sub-grid land surface and vegetation heterogeneity, facilitates the inclusion of multiple soil layers with variable infiltration, and computes non-linear baseflow. The model is calibrated with respect to observed streamflow at various gauge stations located across the basin. The water balance components such as surface runoff, evapotranspiration, soil moisture at three distinct soil layers, and baseflow are estimated for the period 1951-2016. Performance evaluation of outputs obtained from model simulations adopting different spatial resolutions is carried out at seasonal and annual time scales. As the spatial scale increases, the catchment tends to organize and attenuate the complex behaviour of processes. This study provides significant insights towards adopting effective modelling strategies to ensure the adequate representation of hydrological processes in regionally complex catchments.

How to cite: Reghunath, G. and Mujumdar, P.: Role of spatial resolution in simulating hydrological processes using a physically-based hydrological model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-211, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-211, 2022.

Isotopic landscapes or “Isoscapes” are a valuable tool for studying hydro-climatic processes and their impact on water supplies at various spatial scales. These isoscapes are extremely useful because they enable the documentation and visualization of large-scale hydrological processes occurring on a regional, continental, or global scale. This study focuses on surface water isotope data (present study and published data) to interpolate, develop isoscapes of Himalayan basins (Indus, Ganga, and Brahmaputra), and analyze spatial variability from regional to local scale. We use physically based information of three basins from hydro-climatic variables such as actual evapotranspiration (AET), mean annual precipitation (MAP), mean annual runoff (MAR), and runoff coefficient, as well as basin variables such as elevation, slope, aspect, size, and land-use/land-cover (LULC), to develop geographically weighted regression (GWR) models. We identified a systematic spatial pattern in the stable isotopes (δ18O, δ2H, d-excess) of surface water that can be predicted using a GWR model. In the absence of long-term precipitation isotope records, an increased spatial and temporal sampling of surface water for isotopic isoscapes would significantly aid our understanding of hydrological processes, providing that catchment characteristics are taken into consideration. The GWR models used in this study demonstrated the ability to predict isotopic changes in the context of future climate and land-use change in these three major basins.

Keywords: Stable isotopes, Geographically Weighted Regression (GWR), Isoscapes, Himalayan basins.

How to cite: Dar, T., Jahan, A., Rai, N., Bhat, M. A., and Kumar, S.: Spatial analysis of hydrogen and oxygen stable isotopes (“isoscapes”) in Himalayan basins: improved prediction using Geographically Weighted Regression (GWR) models, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-290, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-290, 2022.

EGU22-569 | Presentations | HS2.2.2 | Highlight

hydroPASS: a newly developed R package to go through the regional calibration of distributed catchment models 

Matteo Pesce, Alberto Viglione, Jost von Hardenberg, Larisa Tarasova, Stefano Basso, and Ralf Merz

Large scale hydrological modelling requires the estimation of model parameters across a variety of different environments. To deal with this issue, robust parameter estimation procedures, able to exploit observed patterns of climate and geomorphological characteristics, must be considered. This contribution presents hydroPASS, a newly developed R package available in GitHub, which automatically implements the PArameter Set Shuffling (PASS) method in around 100 catchments over North-Western Italy. This was developed and tested for SALTO (SAme Like The Others) model, but in principle is valid for every distributed or semi-distributed catchment model. In particular, the package contains the function to run SALTO model (Fortran code), the function for PASS application (R code) and functions for data pre-processing and post-processing (R codes). To ease the repeatability and reproducibility of experiments, examples are provided with full documentation. An example of how to use PASS for the regional calibration of other models (e.g., TUW model), is also provided. From the source package, installation packages have been built for Windows, Linux and Mac operating systems and can be freely downloaded from GitHub.

How to cite: Pesce, M., Viglione, A., von Hardenberg, J., Tarasova, L., Basso, S., and Merz, R.: hydroPASS: a newly developed R package to go through the regional calibration of distributed catchment models, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-569, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-569, 2022.

EGU22-2990 | Presentations | HS2.2.2

Multi-objective Inverse Modelling Using Physically based Metrics 

Pouya Farokhzad, Masoud Asadzadeh, and Hartmut Holländer

The heterogeneity in the soil medium makes it economically impossible to measure the soil characteristics across the whole soil profile. Inverse modelling configures a computer model to simulate the groundwater system and calibrates it to identify the soil characteristics in all grid-cells defined in the model. In classic inverse modelling approaches, residuals between simulated and measured groundwater head time series are converted into a single likelihood function to be maximized; therefore, the information content in the measured data is not fully exploited in those approaches. Moreover, the large number of grid-cells makes inverse modelling an ill-posed optimization problem with more unknown parameters than known measured values, leading to different parameter sets having a similar model performance. Despite recent advances in groundwater calibration practices, such as the regularization approach, there is a considerable room to improve groundwater model calibration using information content in the measured data. Regularization aims to add various sets of information to the calibration to tackle the non-uniqueness problem. However, this approach could associate with a considerable degree of subjectivity and uncertainty. This study seeks a novel approach to extract information content from measured data in the form of physically-based metrics that are often called signatures for improving the identifiability in the groundwater model calibration. Moreover, this study proposes a novel automated powerful inverse modelling strategy using a multi-objective approach to incorporate most of the information content through physically meaningful metrics to obtain more consistent models. The benchmark Freyberg 1988 synthetic case study, in which the true model parameter values are known, is used to demonstrate the applicability and potentials of the proposed framework. The reconstructed Freyberg case study in MODFLOW 2005 showed the framework has the ability to find consistent estimates of the groundwater model parameters.

How to cite: Farokhzad, P., Asadzadeh, M., and Holländer, H.: Multi-objective Inverse Modelling Using Physically based Metrics, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2990, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2990, 2022.

EGU22-6212 | Presentations | HS2.2.2 | Highlight

An exploration of Bayesian identification of dominant hydrological mechanisms in ungauged catchments 

Cristina Prieto, Nataliya Le Vine, Dmitri Kavetski, Fabrizio Fenicia, Andreas Scheidegger, and Claudia Vitolo

Hydrological modelling of ungauged catchments, which lack observed streamflow data, is an important practical goal in hydrological sciences. A major challenge is to identify a model structure that reflects the hydrological processes relevant to the catchment of interest.

This study contributes a Bayesian framework for identifying individual model mechanisms (process representations) from flow indices regionalized to the catchment of interest. We extend a method previously introduced for mechanism identification in gauged basins, by formulating the inference equations in the space of (regionalized) flow indices and by accounting for posterior parameter uncertainty. A flexible hydrological model is used to generate candidate mechanisms and model structures, followed by statistical hypothesis testing to identify "dominant" (more a posterior probable) model mechanisms.

The proposed method is illustrated using real data and synthetic experiments based on 92 catchments from northern Spain, from which 16 catchments
are treated as ungauged. 624 hydrological model structures from the flexible framework FUSE are employed.

In real data experiments, the method identifies a dominant mechanism in 27% of 112 trials (processes and catchments). The most identifiable process is routing, whereas the least identifiable processes are percolation and unsaturated zone processes. In synthetic experiments, where "true" mechanisms are known, the reliability of method varies from 60% to 95% depending on the combined regionalization and hydrological error; the probability of making an identification remains stable at around 25%. More broadly, the study contributes perspectives on hydrological mechanism identification under data-scarce conditions; limitations and opportunities for improvement are outlined.

How to cite: Prieto, C., Le Vine, N., Kavetski, D., Fenicia, F., Scheidegger, A., and Vitolo, C.: An exploration of Bayesian identification of dominant hydrological mechanisms in ungauged catchments, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6212, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6212, 2022.

EGU22-6588 | Presentations | HS2.2.2

The impact of a multi-criteria calibration on the performances of the DREAM model 

Silvano Fortunato Dal Sasso, Alonso Pizarro, Ruodan Zhuang, Yijian Zeng, Paolo Nasta, Nunzio Romano, José Gomis Cebolla, Felix Frances, Brigitta Toth, Zhongbo Su, and Salvatore Manfreda

Water resources observation and modelling are essential to better understand hydrological processes and improve water resource management. However, the reliability of hydrological simulation is strongly controlled by the quality and type of field observations used for the calibration and validation processes. Therefore, it is critical to develop proper strategies for model calibration and validation in order to reduce prediction uncertainties. Standard hydrological calibration relies mainly on the time series of total streamflow at the catchment outlet; nevertheless, this leads to a limited insight into the spatial behaviour of a river basin. In this work, we use simulations from the physically-based distributed DREAM model to discuss the importance of multi-criteria calibration to obtain consistent parameter sets. The calibration methodology exploits a physical based filter to decompose the streamflow times series in two time series referring to the surface component and the baseflow. Therefore, we adopted a multi-criteria calibration procedures which optimizes: (a) the total streamflow measured at the basin outlet (used as a reference study case); b) both the surface runoff and baseflow measured at the basin outlet; and (c) the combination the time series of the two components along with the annual water balance components. In addition, we also explored the use of a lumped parametrization against a spatial parametrization derived from the soil type characteristics of the river basin. In all cases, parameter optimization was carried out using an automatic calibration performed by a genetic algorithm (GA) tool. The study was carried out for two experimental catchments located in Basilicata and Campania regions (Southern Italy). The performed experiments showed that the inclusion of physical information during the calibration process results in a general improvement of model reliability.

This research is a part of iAqueduct project funded under the Water JPI 2018 Joint Call, Closing the Water Cycle Gap – on Sustainable Management of Water Resources - Water Works 2017.

How to cite: Dal Sasso, S. F., Pizarro, A., Zhuang, R., Zeng, Y., Nasta, P., Romano, N., Cebolla, J. G., Frances, F., Toth, B., Su, Z., and Manfreda, S.: The impact of a multi-criteria calibration on the performances of the DREAM model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6588, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6588, 2022.

EGU22-7820 | Presentations | HS2.2.2

Improvement of high and low flow simulation in the hydrological model chain SASER. 

Omar Cenobio-Cruz, Pere Quintana-Seguí, Anaïs Barella-Ortiz, and Luis Garrote

SASER (SAfran-Surfex-Eaudysee-Rapid) is a distributed and physically-based modeling chain. Currently, SASER has been implemented for different spatial domains and resolutions. The Pyrenean application of the model at 2.5 km of spatial resolution has a good performance, but it can be improved. We have evaluated the simulated streamflows using the KGE score, which is above 0.5 over 57% of the near-natural catchments. We have seen that SASER simulates reasonably well high, but not extreme, and median daily streamflows, but low flows and peak flows are underestimated. Our hypothesis is that low flows are underestimated due to the lack of a groundwater model and that peak flows are underestimated due to low intensities hourly precipitation in SAFRAN, among other issues. 

The objective of this study is to improve the streamflow simulated by SASER by improving the intensity of the hourly precipitation produced by SAFRAN and by introducing a simple conceptual model to simulate groundwater effects.

SAFRAN ingests daily precipitation observations, which are distributed to an hourly scale using relative humidity, which generates low precipitation intensities. This is not realistic at all in a Mediterranean climate. Our hypothesis is that we can improve hourly intensities by using the outputs of an RCM simulation, forced by a reanalysis, to distribute the hourly precipitation. In this experiment we have used the CNRM-ALADIN model, forced by ERA-Interim, from the EURO-CORDEX database. We keep the daily amounts from SAFRAN (over windows that span from 1 to 14 days) and we redistribute hourly precipitation according to the RCM simulation. We evaluated the results by comparing the hourly precipitation distribution of a set of 13 precipitation stations from the Ebro Basin real-time observation system (SAIH), using the Perkin Skill Score (PSS), which improved from an average of 0.70 in the standard SAFRAN product to 0.88 in our best configuration. Consequently, we now have a new precipitation dataset with improved precipitation intensity patterns.

To improve SASER low flows, we followed the steps of Getirana et al. (2014) and Artinyan et al. (2008), we introduced a linear reservoir at grid point resolution between the LSM and the routing scheme. We calibrated the reservoir parameters catchment-by-catchment in near-natural sub-catchments. The KGE score of the square root of the streamflow shows on average an improvement of 21% with respect to default simulation (without reservoir)

The regionalization approach was chosen to set the reservoir parameters in human-influenced catchments, where calibration is unfeasible. This approach allows us to link physical characteristics with the reservoir parameters through a linear equation, as did Beck et al. (2020).  In this process, an evolutionary algorithm was implemented, which optimizes the equation coefficients, thereby we were able to produce maps (at 2.5 km resolution) of the model parameters based on physiographic data. Preliminary results show using this approach we obtain performances close to those obtained by a classical calibration procedure.

This work was funded by the HUMID project (CGL2017-85687-R, AEI/FEDER, UE), EFA210/16-PIRAGUA and IDEWA (PCI2020-112043) projects, and the predoctoral grant PRE2018-085027 (AEI/FSE).

How to cite: Cenobio-Cruz, O., Quintana-Seguí, P., Barella-Ortiz, A., and Garrote, L.: Improvement of high and low flow simulation in the hydrological model chain SASER., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7820, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7820, 2022.

EGU22-9129 | Presentations | HS2.2.2

Surrogate model for seepage analysis of a dike using generative adversarial networks 

Yusuke Homma, Seiichiro Kuroda, and Nobuo Makino

In recent years, the risk of sediment-related disasters has increased due to the increase in heavy rain disasters. Therefore, a technique for more easily diagnosing the internal structure of dikes such as fill dams is desired. We applied machine learning to this task.
In this study, we estimated the correspondence between the hydraulic conductivity distribution and the pressure head distribution of the zoned dike using machine learning. The machine learning method is pix2pix which is derived from generative adversarial networks (GAN). Pix2pix learns the relationship between input and output image. Training datasets were generated by using HYDRUS-2D In the HYDRUS-2D simulation, the dike was divided into three zones, and the seepage analysis was performed by changing the hydraulic conductivity of each zone to various values, and the pressure head distribution in the steady state was obtained.
In the forward problem, most of the results could be estimated accurately. On the hand, it was difficult to estimate the inverse problem because of the ill-posed problem. In the inverse problem, we were able to improve the results by giving the training data a priori information about the hydraulic conductivity.
This approach can be used as a surrogate model for the forward problem and the inverse problem in seepage analysis.

How to cite: Homma, Y., Kuroda, S., and Makino, N.: Surrogate model for seepage analysis of a dike using generative adversarial networks, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9129, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9129, 2022.

EGU22-10752 | Presentations | HS2.2.2

AnnAGNPS-MODFLOW integration for evaluation of agricultural practice impacts on surface and groundwater resources 

Henrique Momm, Ronald Bingner, Katy Moore, and Glenn Herring

The Lower Mississippi River Alluvial Plain, referred to as the Delta, is an important agricultural region in the southeastern United States. Recent trends in crop type conversion and higher crop yields resulted in increased irrigation demand for surface and groundwater, which can lead to aquifer levels dropping. Estimates of continued increased irrigation adoption are compounded by future climatic estimates suggesting hotter summers with higher unpredictability in precipitation amounts. In these conditions, the long-term sustainability of this system depends on understanding complex surface-groundwater flow interactions at different temporal and spatial scales, and the impacts of agricultural conservation practices on water use. In this study, a description of the development of the integrated AnnAGNPS-MODFLOW technology is provided. The proposed system was evaluated in the Upper Sunflower River watershed, located in the Delta region of Mississippi, to characterize existing conditions through comparison with observed streamflow and well water levels. Additionally, the system was used to evaluate the impact of alternative irrigation and management strategies on water levels in the aquifer at field and watershed scales. The proposed technology provides a management tool critical to understanding and evaluating the impact of agricultural practices, irrigation, and aquifer recharge strategies that are important to sustaining Delta water resources in a changing climate.

How to cite: Momm, H., Bingner, R., Moore, K., and Herring, G.: AnnAGNPS-MODFLOW integration for evaluation of agricultural practice impacts on surface and groundwater resources, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10752, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10752, 2022.

EGU22-11070 | Presentations | HS2.2.2

Multiple techniques for calibration and validation of SWAT model in an ungauged catchment in Inner Himalayan Ranges. 

Vicky Anand, Bakimchandra Oinam, and Silke Wieprecht

Reliability of hydrological model simulation plays an important role in better understanding of hydrological processes, eco-hydrologic and eco-hydraulic condition of a data scarce catchment with limited baseline data. Due to the lack of baseline hydrological dataset, precise simulation of hydrological output from a hydrological model becomes essential. There has been several studies carried out to calibrate a data scarce catchment using river discharge solely on remote sensing data but they have been limited to the rivers with large width. The current study was carried out in Manipur River basin where the widths of the streams are narrow due to which direct application of remotely sensed data possesses serious challenge. This study attempts to calibrate and validate a comprehensive physically semi-distributed Soil and Water Assessment Tool (SWAT) model in Manipur River basin. The SWAT hydrological model was set-up using elevation, soil, weather, and land use land cover (LULC) dataset. For the calibration and validation of model two different approaches has been applied. In the first approach, river streamflow was generated by using stage data based on stage-discharge curve through the technique of spatial proximity, whereas in the second approach, Moderate Resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer (MODIS) evapotranspiration dataset was used at sub-basin scale to calibrate and validate the SWAT model. In the calibration period, the model returned R2 and Kling-Gupta Efficiency (KGE) of 0.78 and 0.73, whereas in the validation period R2, KGE was found to be 0.75, 0.71 while using the stage-discharge curve approach. The model performance of R2, KGE equals 0.67, 0.41, respectively during calibration and R2, KGE equals 0.79, 0.53 respectively was obtained during validation when MODIS evapotranspiration dataset was used. From the modelling result it was observed that the model performance was found to be better when streamflow dataset derived from stage-discharge curve used as compared to the MODIS evapotranspiration dataset. The main reason behind the under performance of the model while using MODIS evapotranspiration dataset was due to the underestimation of evapotranspiration by the SWAT model in the cold-dry season from December to February.

 

How to cite: Anand, V., Oinam, B., and Wieprecht, S.: Multiple techniques for calibration and validation of SWAT model in an ungauged catchment in Inner Himalayan Ranges., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11070, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11070, 2022.

EGU22-11754 | Presentations | HS2.2.2 | Highlight

Towards improved simulation of water partitioning: which observations have most value in constraining a spatially-distributed ecohydrological model? 

Aaron Neill, Christian Birkel, Jan Boll, Marco Maneta, Olivier Roupsard, Laura Benegas, and Chris Soulsby

Improved quantification of water partitioning is needed to inform sustainable, integrated land and water management. Spatially-distributed, process-based ecohydrological models are promising tools for achieving this; however, such models typically have many parameters that require estimation from data. Utilising an extremely rich plot-scale dataset incorporating energy (net radiation, temperature, and latent and sensible heat), hydrological (soil moisture, sap flow and actual evapotranspiration) and vegetation (net primary productivity and structure) components, we investigated which types of observation best constrain the parameters of a complex ecohydrological model (EcH2O-iso) for simulation of water partitioning. Our experimental site was situated within one of the largest coffee agroforestry systems in Costa Rica and experiences high energy inputs and intense rainfall events, thus adding further complexity to the robust simulation of hydrological processes. A series of calibration exercises were undertaken based on combinations of the different observation types. In each case, 100 behavioural parameter sets were chosen following 100,000 Monte Carlo simulations. The “flux mapping” approach was then used to quantify the percentage contribution made by different simulated fluxes to total model outflows (e.g., contributions of transpiration, soil evaporation and interception evaporation to total evapotranspiration), in order to assess how consistently plot hydrology was simulated by the retained parameter sets. Additionally, PCA analysis of performance metrics (including those for observations not used in the given calibration) was undertaken to reveal how contrasting observation types “pull” the model in different directions and, thus, affect its ability to capture the dynamics of each type simultaneously. From this work, we are able to provide guidance on how different ecohydrological datasets may be optimally combined in model calibration. This has implications not only for reducing uncertainty in modelling studies underpinning land and water management, but also for designing future field campaigns such that collection of the most valuable data can be prioritised.

How to cite: Neill, A., Birkel, C., Boll, J., Maneta, M., Roupsard, O., Benegas, L., and Soulsby, C.: Towards improved simulation of water partitioning: which observations have most value in constraining a spatially-distributed ecohydrological model?, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11754, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11754, 2022.

Reservoir water balance models are often used in system models that translate state variables to measurable goals in water management studies. These models enable water managers to analyze the impact of various operational strategies on the performance of water resource systems. However, the water quality implications of reservoir operations are relatively less explored as it entails additional processes in the model, requiring data and parameterization. Water quality implications are particularly important in projects such as inter-basin water transfers (IBWTs), in which water is diverted from one basin to other in the presence of considerable regional differences in water supply and demands between two basins. When water from one basin is transferred to another, the difference in water quality can affect the local flora and fauna of the recipient basin. So, it is important to understand the relative proportion of water from either basins present in the recipient reservoir at any time. Here, we propose a source tracking framework to quantify the contribution of water from either basins to various reservoir-related fluxes in the recipient basin. These include water released from the recipient basin for: demand satisfaction, maintaining minimum environmental flows, preventing dam failure, and demands in basins. We quantify the proportion of water supplied from the donor basin and from the recipient's own inflows for each flux. We apply this framework to a proposed water transfer project in southern India that transfers water from the Godavari basin to the Krishna river basin. Our results show that under extreme droughts observed in the simulated inflows, up to 50% of the minimum environmental flows released downstream of the recipient reservoir are supplied from the water transferred from the donor basin. This generally occurs in the months from June to December in which the recipient experiences high demands. We also note that more than 50% of the water transferred out of the recipient reservoir to other basins arrives from the donor basin. Our framework can be used to evaluate the possible implications of water quality in the donor basin on the minimum environmental flows and other reservoir-related fluxes from the recipient reservoir. 

How to cite: Molakala, M. and Singh, R.: Unfolding the ecological and water quality Implications of Inter Basin Water Transfers Using a SourceTracking Modeling Framework, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11842, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11842, 2022.

EGU22-12666 | Presentations | HS2.2.2

Examining the effect of plant traits on moisture recycling in the Amazon Basin 

Kien Nguyen and Maria J. Santos

Moisture recycling is an important process in the hydrological system, as well as an important ecosystem service being responsible for more than 10% of precipitation in the majority of terrestrial areas. Changes in land use are known to affect this process, however, detailed understanding on how vegetation characteristics, i.e., plant traits, are seldom included in modeling this important process. To overcome this knowledge gap, we conduct a first order examination of the effect of plant traits on recycling, where we examine how variation in plant traits influences moisture recycling properties (average and standard deviation) in the Amazon Basin. More specifically, we used remotely-sensed estimates of trait values for: Specific Leaf Area (SLA), Leaf Dry Matter Content (LDMC), Leaf Phosphorus Content (LPC), Leaf Nitrogen Content (LNC), as well as information on Normalised Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI), and Leaf Area Index (LAI) for 10 years (2001-2010). We link this data on plant traits to six parameters that relevant for moisture recycling, namely Evapotranspiration (ET), Potential Evapotranspiration (PET), Land Surface Temperature (LST) Day and Night, Soil Moisture (SM) and Vapour Pressure Deficit (VPD). We used multivariate regression to analyse how plant traits explain the variance of moisture recycling parameters and find that NDVI (10- 40%), LAI (10-50%) and SLA (5-20%) exert the strongest effects on moisture recycling parameters suggesting that leaf gas exchange traits are most important in comparison to the other traits. We find, however, that the strength and the directionality of the effect while variable, it matches the expectations: NDVI positively correlates with ET, PET and negatively correlates with SM and LST Night; SLA positively correlates with VPD and LST Day. These results suggest that leaf gas exchange properties operate differently during the day and night-time, likely constrained by SM availability, and are linked with VPD and ET exchanges in the direction expected. We then examined whether these patterns were exacerbated or attenuated at the extremes of plant trait values using quantile regression (5th, 50th and 95th), to find that indeed some relationships became stronger (e.g. NDVI and LST Night, LAI and PET, ET and LST Day), while others became more attenuated (e.g. LPC and VPD, NDVI and ET). Finally, we examined whether the effect of traits would be related to the sub-basin processes due to the found control of SM on trait effects and founnd that nutrient and dry matter traits became more important, mostly for the extremes of trait distributions. These results show a promising first approach to include trait distributions in modeling hydrological processes. Indeed, we find some relationships in the direction expected, exacerbated in some cases at the extremes of trait distributions, and at local scale we show that different processes control hydrological parameters in comparison to the whole basin. While promising, more and better estimates of traits through remote sensing or in situ data acquisition are necessary to gain a better understanding of which traits might need to be managed to maintain this important ecosystem service and to understand its links with the overall hydrological cycle.

How to cite: Nguyen, K. and Santos, M. J.: Examining the effect of plant traits on moisture recycling in the Amazon Basin, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12666, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12666, 2022.

Soil moisture is a vital land surface variable that influences the terrestrial hydrothermal cycles, modulates the land-atmosphere interactions and provides important predictability for weather and climate forecasting. Numerous efforts have been made to investigate the contribution of meteorological forcings, land surface parameters and land models to the uncertainties or precision of soil moisture modeling through both complex statistical approaches and simple comparative land surface modeling experiments. However, previous research mainly focus on one or two factors and the influence of a specific factor is usually quantified by comparing two different datasets. It still unclear that how much added value the current high resolution forcings, surface parameters and land models have to the soil moisture modeling and whether the results depend on the choice of model, datasets and even study regions.

To address the above issue, we first performed a high resolution (6km) soil moisture modeling over China during 2012~2017 by using the newly developed Conjunctive Surface-Subsurface Process version 2 (CSSPv2) land model forced by high-resolution meteorological forcing and high-resolution soil hydraulic property data. The high-resolution simulation has good performance in representing the observed magnitudes and variations of the rootzone (0~1 m) soil moisture based on >1,500 soil moisture stations, and improves the Kling-Gupta efficiency by 33~118% from the current high-resolution global land reanalysis (e.g., ERA5-Land and GLDASv2.1) and remote sensing based products (e.g., ESA CCI and GLEAMv3.1). In order to quantify the contributions from forcings, parameters and CSSPv2 model, we repeated the simulation by using coarse resolution datasets and different models including three meteorological forcing datasets, two soil hydraulic property datasets and three land models. By comparing 48 sets of experiments, the model and soil parameter are found to contribute more than 50% of the improvements at national scale which indicates necessity of developing high resolution land models and model parameters. On the regional scale, however, the meteorological forcing is shown to has the largest added value over the northwestern and southwestern China while land model is most important for the improvement over southern and eastern China. Further works will analyze the specific physical process in CSSPv2 model that improve the soil moisture simulation which will shed light on the future land model development.

How to cite: Ji, P. and Yuan, X.: The added value of forcing, surface parameter and land model to the high resolution soil moisture modeling in China, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12945, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12945, 2022.

EGU22-2369 | Presentations | HS2.2.4

Water dynamics in karst soil: Modelling matrix and preferential flow using reservoir cascade scheme approach 

Mirna Švob, David Domínguez-Villar, and Kristina Krklec

When simulating soil water content (SWC) and dynamics, the reservoir cascade scheme (RCS) approach is considered appropriate in cases when number of parameters for model calibration and validation is limited. This is often the case in Mediterranean karst soils, where due to high rockiness and shallow soil depths it is often difficult to set dense measurement network. In this study, a 1-D model which simulates SWC using RCS approach was developed for a location in central Spain. The soil on the studied site has silt loam texture and is developed on dolomite marbles. The model simulates SWC at daily resolution for six layers in soil that range from 0-50 cm depth, and has three different configurations. Configuration 1 considers only basic RCS module, while configurations 2 and 3 simulate preferential flows in soil as well. Therefore Configuration 2 considers RCS module together with continuous preferential flow module, where between 1 and 5% of available SWC is drained from each soil layer every day. Configuration 3 considers discontinuous preferential flows in addition to two previous modules. Discontinuous preferential flows are active in cases of rainfall events that occur during prolonged dry periods. Simulated SWC values are compared with SWC values measured at five depths in soil, so model parameters are iteratively adjusted to optimize the model results. The simulation produced the best results when implementing Configuration 3: when matrix flow and two kinds of preferential flow are assumed. The model shows that preferential flows could significantly contribute to recharge and should be given more attention in soil hydrological models, especially in karst terrains. It is expected that the model can be implemented in a wide range of locations with karst soils, since it requires limited number of input parameters, but in the same time provides a detailed simulation of soil drainage processes and recharge.

How to cite: Švob, M., Domínguez-Villar, D., and Krklec, K.: Water dynamics in karst soil: Modelling matrix and preferential flow using reservoir cascade scheme approach, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2369, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2369, 2022.

EGU22-3151 | Presentations | HS2.2.4 | Highlight

Improving hydrological process understanding and model prediction using soil moisture data 

Flora Branger, Ryoko Araki, Inge Wiekenkamp, and Hilary McMillan

Soil moisture is a critical control of process-based hydrologic models. This variable has so far been little used, mainly due to the difficulty to extract information from in-situ soil moisture observations that can be directly compared to simulated model variables. The concept of hydrological signature is now being increasingly used for the evaluation of hydrological models. However, hydrological signatures based on soil moisture are still rarely used.

We propose nine soil moisture signatures, encompassing three levels of hydrological time response (storm event response : rising time, normalized amplitude, response type, rising limb density, seasonal response : dates and durations of seasonal transitions, average characteristic values : distribution type, field capacity and wilting point). These signatures were applied to datasets from six in-situ observatories around the world with contrasted climates and land uses. The obtained values were analysed to assess whether the signatures could discriminate between land uses and could be interpreted in terms of hydrological processes.

Results showed that differences could be found between land uses for most signatures, and that these differences could be attributed to flow pathways or soil wetness, hence indicating that the signatures are good indicators of key hydrological processes and potentially useful for model evaluation.

How to cite: Branger, F., Araki, R., Wiekenkamp, I., and McMillan, H.: Improving hydrological process understanding and model prediction using soil moisture data, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3151, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3151, 2022.

EGU22-3514 | Presentations | HS2.2.4

Assimilation of backscatter observations in a hydrological model: a case study in Belgium using ASCAT data 

Pierre Baguis, Alberto Carrassi, Emmanuel Roulin, Stéphane Vannitsem, Joris Van den Bergh, Sara Modanesi, and Hans Lievens

We investigate the possibilities to improve hydrological simulations by assimilating active radar backscatter observations from the Advanced Scatterometer (ASCAT) in the hydrological model SCHEME. This effort is motivated by the great need of accurate initial model states in hydrological forecasting and the potential to improve them by using remotely sensed data of land surface processes. ASCAT data assimilation is enabled by coupling the Water Cloud Model (WCM) with the SCHEME model. We calibrated the WCM over two catchments in Belgium exhibiting different hydrological regimes. We explore a data assimilation system based on the Ensemble Kalman Filter (EnKF) whereby the observation operator is given by the coupling of WCM and SCHEME models. This coupling underlines the advantage of using backscatter data for assimilation purposes instead of a soil moisture product carrying its own climatology. In the present study we focus on optimising the EnKF for the task, unveil the main challenges and investigate possible solutions including methods to address the biases affecting the data assimilation procedure.

How to cite: Baguis, P., Carrassi, A., Roulin, E., Vannitsem, S., Van den Bergh, J., Modanesi, S., and Lievens, H.: Assimilation of backscatter observations in a hydrological model: a case study in Belgium using ASCAT data, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3514, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3514, 2022.

EGU22-4465 | Presentations | HS2.2.4 | Highlight

Assessing modelled hydrological responses to afforestation using hectometre-scale cosmic-ray neutron soil moisture 

Mie Andreasen, Jesper R. Christiansen, Torben O. Sonnenborg, Simon Stisen, and Majken C. Looms

Since the 1990´s, and in particular during the last decade, afforestation has become a common water management practice. Afforestation improves the quality of the groundwater resource by reducing the leaching of nutrients and pesticides in the soil. Furthermore, planting of trees is also used to capture carbon from the atmosphere as an integral element of carbon emission mitigation, for biodiversity restoration and for biofuel. With the more extensive implementation of afforestation, it is important to understand the hydrological responses and to predict and quantify these adequately using hydrological modelling.

The hydrology of the forest system is characterized by high spatial variability. The forest vegetation intercepts and redistribute a considerable fraction of the precipitation resulting in an uneven input of water at the forest floor. The transpiration and soil evaporation vary in space according to the tree root distribution and soil texture. All these factors influence the soil moisture in the unsaturated zone, the percolation, and the groundwater recharge. Hydrological models are often used to estimate the groundwater recharge rate and to obtain information of the timing of the recharge to ensure sustainable groundwater exploitation and sufficient streamflow. The high spatial variability makes it difficult to predict forest hydrology and it is important that the observations are representative of the forest plot to assess the performance of the hydrological model.

In this study, we predict the water balance for bare ground conditions and for a coniferous forest to examine the hydrological responses to afforestation. We use a physically based and spatially distributed hydrological model with an energy-based description of evapotranspiration processes (MIKE SHE SVAT). The forest model was calibrated against timeseries of throughfall and point-scale soil moisture. Simulated soil moisture is evaluated against forest plot cosmic-ray neutron and point-scale estimates. Further assessment of the model is obtained through comparison to time-series of forest plot eddy-covariance evapotranspiration estimates and observation-based and predicted interception loss. We find that the forest plot and point-scale soil moisture estimates differ which in turn affects the assessment of the reliability of the model performance. The hydrological responses of afforestation are significant, influencing the total evapotranspiration, the soil moisture and the groundwater recharge.  

How to cite: Andreasen, M., Christiansen, J. R., Sonnenborg, T. O., Stisen, S., and Looms, M. C.: Assessing modelled hydrological responses to afforestation using hectometre-scale cosmic-ray neutron soil moisture, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4465, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4465, 2022.

EGU22-5078 | Presentations | HS2.2.4

Rainfall-runoff reaction controlled by soil moisture thresholds in a small Alpine catchment 

Gertraud Meißl, Thomas Zieher, and Clemens Geitner

Since 2009, we have continuously monitored soil moisture in the Eastern Alpine torrent catchment of the Brixenbach (Tyrol, Austria). The measurement network is one of the rare with a high spatial resolution and long temporal coverage and consists of eight sites with three frequency-domain (FD) sensors 10 cm below soil surface. The resulting data allowed us to analyse the precipitation-runoff reaction of the catchment depending on the antecedent soil moisture content. In Meißl et al. (2020) we found:

  • The site-specific soil moisture medians correlate with altitude, but don’t correlate with sites’ slope, the topographic index nor the specific upslope area.
  • In contrast to the results of other authors who analysed much shorter time series, the scatter plot of the spatial standard deviation of soil moisture against the spatial mean does not show a convex shape. We found that progressive drying during rainless periods leads to increasing spatial variability of soil moisture contents at mean soil moisture values<40 vol%. Above about 42 vol% the spatial variability of soil moisture contents decreases.
  • The most exceptional out of the 547 analysed rainfall-runoff events took place at rainfall event types with high precipitation sum and long duration, but low intensity or at events with medium precipitation sum, short duration, but high intensity.
  • 244 precipitation events triggered a significant increase in soil moisture (≥ 0.5 vol%) and a total runoff of at least three cubic metres. During these events, the Brixenbach catchment showed a clear threshold behaviour: Discharge coefficients above 0.23 were only observed when the spatial mean soil moisture exceeded 43.5 vol% at the eight sites. Looking at the individual sites, this threshold is also more or less clearly visible, but at different levels. The level of the spatial mean of all sites thus depends strongly on the number and local characterstics of the sites used.
  • If we define the relative soil moisture as proportion of the maximum soil moisture content of the site during the whole measurement period, the threshold ranges between 0.65 and 0.80 with the sites’ mean of 0.72, which can be interpreted as saturation deficit of 0.28.
  • At moist conditions, event streamflow peaked prior to soil moisture, which can be explained by increased surface flow volumes at higher soil moisture as well as already initialized subsurface flow paths.

The analyses of the long-term soil moisture time series provide a valuable insight into the hydrological system of the Brixenbach catchment and may help to identify critical conditions, which may lead to floods, also under changed conditions in future.

References: Meißl G., Zieher Th., Geitner C. (2020): Runoff response to rainfall events considering initial soil moisture – Analysis of 9-year records in a small Alpine catchment (Brixenbach valley, Tyrol, Austria). Journal of Hydrology: Regional Studies, August 2020, 100711. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ejrh.2020.100711

How to cite: Meißl, G., Zieher, T., and Geitner, C.: Rainfall-runoff reaction controlled by soil moisture thresholds in a small Alpine catchment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5078, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5078, 2022.

EGU22-5387 | Presentations | HS2.2.4

Multiscale analysis of soil moisture variability for a typical semi-arid Mediterranean ecosystem 

Roberto Corona, Nicola Montaldo, and Gabriel G. Katul

Soil moisture content influences the partitioning of net radiation into latent and sensible heat fluxes that, in turn, affect the dynamics of the atmospheric boundary layer depth and concomitant generation of precipitation. The interactive effect between soil moisture and precipitation has been found to be stronger in areas where soil moisture temporal variability is enhanced such as in arid and semiarid regions, and in transitional regions between dry and wet climate. For this reason, variability in soil moisture at multiple time scales continues to draw attention in climate science and hydrology. In this work, the soil moisture variability at multiple scales for a typical Mediterranean ecosystem, has been quantified using the spectrum of soil moisture.The case study is the Orroli site in Sardinia (Italy), a typical semi-arid Mediterranean ecosystem which is an experimental site for the ALTOS European project of the PRIMA MED program.The spectrum of root-zone soil moisture content for this Mediterranean ecosystem is analyzed using 14-years of half-hourly measurements. A distinguishing hydro-climatic feature in such ecosystems is that sources (mainly rainfall) and sinks (mainly evapotranspiration) of soil moisture are roughly out of phase with each other. For over 4 decades of time scales and 7 decades of energy, the canonical shape of the measured soil moisture spectrum is shown to be approximately Lorentzian determined by the soil moisture variance and its memory but with two exceptions: the occurrences of a peak at diurnal-to daily time scales and weaker peak at near annual time scales. Model calculations and spectral analysis demonstrate that diurnal and seasonal variations in hydroclimate forcing responsible for variability in evapotranspiration had minor impact on the normalized shape of the soil moisture spectrum. However, their impact was captured by adjustments in the temporal variance. These findings indicate that precipitation and not evapotranspiration variability dominates the multi-scaling properties of soil moisture variability consistent with prior climate model simulations. Furthermore, the soil moisture memory inferred by the annual peak of soil moisture (340 d) is consistent with climate model simulations, while the memory evaluated from the loss function of a linearized mass balance approach leads to a smaller value (50 d), highlighting the effect of weak non-stationarity on soil moisture variability. Spatial variability in infiltration rates introduce some whitening of rainfall temporal auto-correlation recovering a spectral decay in soil moisture spectra consistent with  f2 at sub-weekly time scales, where f is the frequency or inverse time scale.

How to cite: Corona, R., Montaldo, N., and Katul, G. G.: Multiscale analysis of soil moisture variability for a typical semi-arid Mediterranean ecosystem, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5387, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5387, 2022.

EGU22-6685 | Presentations | HS2.2.4

The Valencia Anchor Station: 20 Years of Uninterrupted Scientific Activity on Validation of Low and Middle Resolution Earth Observation Remote Sensing Data and Products 

Ernesto Lopez-Baeza, David Garcia Rodriguez, Erika Albero Peralta, Antonio Garcia-Celda, Victor Asensi Ortega, Domingo J. Catalan Alcober, and Juan J. Martinez Dura

The Valencia Anchor Station (VAS) was set up by the University of Valencia at the very end of the year 2001 starting its operations on 1st January 2002. Since then, uninterruptedly, the Climatology from Satellites Group (GCS) has developed a constant activity addressed to the difficult task of characterising an area sufficiently large as to also serve as a reference site for the scientific validation of current low and middle spatial resolution remote sensing instruments onboard the missions NASA CERES (Clouds and the Earth’s Radiant Energy System) and SMAP (Soil Moisture Active and Passive), EUMETSAT GERB (Geostationary Earth Radiation Budget), ESA SMOS (Soil Moisture and Ocean Salinity), ESA-EUMETSAT EPS (EUMETSAT Polar System) MetOp, EC-ESA Copernicus Sentinel-1, -2, -3 and is getting ready for the now close ESA-JAXA EarthCARE (Earth Clouds, Aerosols and Radiation Explorer) launch and for the current GNSS-R, -iR terrestrial applications from the Galileo, BeiDou, GPS and GLONASS constellations. All these instruments have in common their middle/large footprint sizes for which a sufficiently large validation area up to about 50 x 50 km2 needs to be robustly equipped and fully characterised from different viewpoints such as soils, vegetation, atmospheric parameters, etc. This presentation shows the fundamentals of the methodologies used for the validation of surface radiation, soil moisture and biophysical vegetation parameters, and a brief summary of the field campaigns developed for the characterisation of the site in the context of the models used and some of the achievements so far obtained. Detailed account of the validation exercises for the different parameters under consideration is also given in different sessions of this EGU 22 Assembly. The paper also emphasises the role of the distributed soil measurements carried out over a large vineyard field in relation to the rest of significant parameters from a dense FAPAR (Fraction of Absorbed Photosynthetically Active Radiation) network and from an eddy-covariance station, together with the complete surface radiation network and land surface and atmospheric temperatures, also provided by the VAS. It is worth noting the role of the collaborative interdisciplinary international teams associated to the Climatology from Satellites Group in the framework of the different Missions and Agencies above mentioned, the qualitative upgrading of the VAS as a GBOV (Ground-Based Observations for the Validation of Copernicus Land Products) supersite and its future prospects by incorporating artificial intelligence and data semantics techniques. The VAS is currently jointly run by LISITT (Integrated Laboratory of Intelligent Systems and Technologies of Traffic Information), a research and development group integrated into the IRTIC (Research Institute on Robotics and Information and Communication Technologies) and by UV-ERS (Environmental Remote Sensing Group) of the Faculty of Physics, both from the University of Valencia. This guarantees the envisaged new developments planned for the VAS to offer data and products in an optimum user-friendly format by using artificial intelligence and data semantics methods.

How to cite: Lopez-Baeza, E., Garcia Rodriguez, D., Albero Peralta, E., Garcia-Celda, A., Asensi Ortega, V., Catalan Alcober, D. J., and Martinez Dura, J. J.: The Valencia Anchor Station: 20 Years of Uninterrupted Scientific Activity on Validation of Low and Middle Resolution Earth Observation Remote Sensing Data and Products, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6685, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6685, 2022.

EGU22-8625 | Presentations | HS2.2.4

Modeling soil moisture at the Valencia Anchor Station (VAS), Eastern Spain. 

Ester Carbo, Pablo Juan, Carlos Añó, Somnath Chaudhuri, Carlos Diaz-Avalos, and Ernesto López-Baeza

The prediction of spatial and temporal variation of soil water content brings numerous benefits in the studies of soil. However, it requires a considerable number of covariates to be included in the study, complicating the analysis. Integrated nested Laplace approximations (INLA) with stochastic partial differential equation (SPDE) methodology is a possible approach that allows the inclusion of covariates in an easy way.

The current study has been conducted using INLA-SPDE to study soil moisture in the area of the Valencia Anchor Station (VAS), soil moisture validation site for the European Space Agency SMOS (Soil Moisture and Ocean Salinity). The data used were collected in a typical ecosystem of the semiarid Mediterranean conditions, subdivided into physio-hydrological units (SMOS units) which presents a certain degree of internal uniformity with respect to hydrological parameters and capture the spatial and temporal variation of soil moisture at the local fine scale. The use of the INLA-SPDE methodology presents the possibility to analyze the significance of different covariates having spatial and temporal effects and has allowed us to fit spatial and temporal hierarchical models that are too complicated to be fitted by maximum likelihood methods.

The models allow to analyze the influence of hydrodynamic properties on VAS soil moisture (texture, porosity/bulk density and soil organic matter and land use) filtering out the effect of spatial and temporal variation. With the goal of understanding the factors that affect the variability of soil moisture in the SMOS pixel (50 km x 50 km), five states of soil moisture are proposed (moisture values range from values near saturation to moisture values near wilting point). Regarding the different models for the different Soil Moisture states, a general pattern was detected where both porosity and organic matter are two significant elements in all the cases. The model with all covariates and spatial effect has the lowest DIC value. In addition, the correlation coefficient was close to 1 for the relationship between observed and predicted values.

The findings of this study demonstrate an advancement in that framework, demonstrating that it is faster than previous methodologies, provides significance of individual covariates, is reproducible, and is easy to compare with models. The use of this methodology permits to design more efficient sampling campaigns for future SMOS missions. In addition, it also allows to construct soil moisture maps in a more sensible and efficient way.

 

How to cite: Carbo, E., Juan, P., Añó, C., Chaudhuri, S., Diaz-Avalos, C., and López-Baeza, E.: Modeling soil moisture at the Valencia Anchor Station (VAS), Eastern Spain., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8625, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8625, 2022.

EGU22-9849 | Presentations | HS2.2.4

Quantifying the irrigation water use by assimilating SMAP-Sentinel1 1km soil moisture data using a particle batch smoother approach 

Ehsan Jalilvand, Ronnie Abolafia-Rosenweig, Narendra Das, and Massoud Tajrishy

Irrigation is the largest human intervention in the water cycle that can modulate climate extremes. Despite the importance of irrigation, global irrigation water use (IWU) remains largely unknown. Microwave remote sensing offers a low-cost solution to quantify IWU by monitoring the changes in the soil moisture caused by irrigation. However, high-resolution satellite soil moisture data has fewer observations and might miss irrigation events. This study tests a method to quantify the IWU by assimilating high resolution (~1km), but less frequent SMAP-Sentinel1 (SMAP-S1) remotely sensed soil moisture with a land surface model. We use a particle batch smoother (PBS) to assimilate the SMAP-S1 soil moisture data with the VIC (4.2d) land surface model. It is important to remove the biases between the model and the satellite observations prior to the data assimilation, so we also evaluate the impact of model calibration during the irrigation or rainy season on the quantified irrigation. Moreover, we conducted a synthetic experiment in which the uncertainty due to the noise in assimilated soil moisture data, the frequency of the satellite observations, and the knowledge of irrigation timing was investigated. We will present the results of these studies.

How to cite: Jalilvand, E., Abolafia-Rosenweig, R., Das, N., and Tajrishy, M.: Quantifying the irrigation water use by assimilating SMAP-Sentinel1 1km soil moisture data using a particle batch smoother approach, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9849, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9849, 2022.

EGU22-10703 | Presentations | HS2.2.4

Using Matlab´s Supervised Machine-Learning Tools to Retrieve Surface Soil Moisture from Sentinel-1 SAR Data Over the Valencia Anchor Station (Spain) 

Pierre Ferreira do Prado, Iolanda Cristina Silveira Duarte, and Ernesto Lopez-Baeza

The urgency on detailing surface soil moisture content worldwide, especially in agricultural soils, is well established. The efforts of the European Space Agency (ESA), regarding the Sentinel-1 mission, facilitated a synthetic aperture radar (SAR) sensor that, in conjunction with machine-learning-based methods, can be useful  and fruitful responding to this technological demand. This paper aims at  exploring the possibility of the Valencia Anchor Station, near the city of Valencia, Eastern Spain, to provide 1 km x 1 km soil moisture products using its ground-based reference meassurements. The results suggest that, among several options, an artificial neural network using the Levenberg-Maquardt learning algorithm, based on soil moisture recovery from Sentinel-1 SAR radar data should be preferred for this site. Among other options, the so called fine-tree regression also presented relevant results. All of this allows us to gain insights into the complexity of the relation SAR´s backscatter – surface soil moisture relation for this site, also aiming at the potential extension of this knowledge to other sites where Sentinel-1 data is available, for example, in framework of the Joint Research Center "Ground-Based Observations for Validation (GBOV) of Copernicus Global Land Products" Project.

How to cite: Ferreira do Prado, P., Silveira Duarte, I. C., and Lopez-Baeza, E.: Using Matlab´s Supervised Machine-Learning Tools to Retrieve Surface Soil Moisture from Sentinel-1 SAR Data Over the Valencia Anchor Station (Spain), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10703, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10703, 2022.

EGU22-10810 | Presentations | HS2.2.4

Machine learning-based multilayer soil moisture datasets: SoMo.ml 

Sungmin Oh, Rene Orth, and Seon Ki Park

Soil moisture information is valuable for a wide range of applications in various fields such as hydrology, agriculture, and climate. Although spatially continuous soil moisture data can be obtained from satellite observations or model simulations, each type of data has its own uncertainty and bias. In this study, we use machine learning as a hydrologic model and generate a gridded soil moisture dataset—SoMo.ml—that can complement existing soil moisture datasets (O and Orth, 2021). We train a Long Short-Term Memory neural network model using in-situ measurements to extrapolate daily soil moisture dynamics in space and in time. The first version of the data, SoMo.ml v1, provides multilayer soil moisture (0-10cm, 10-30cm, and 30-50 cm) at 0.25° and daily resolutions for the period 2000-2019; it has been actively used for drought analysis, data comparison, and other relevant research. The dataset is freely available from https://www.bgc-jena.mpg.de/geodb/. Given the growing needs for this unique soil moisture dataset, SoMo.ml v2 is currently under development, which aims to provide soil moisture data over Europe with a higher spatial resolution (0.1°). In this presentation, we will introduce the SoMo.ml datasets and show examples of data applications in other studies.

 

Reference: O and Orth, Global soil moisture data derived through machine learning trained with in-situ measurements. Sci Data, (2021). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41597-021-00964-1

How to cite: Oh, S., Orth, R., and Park, S. K.: Machine learning-based multilayer soil moisture datasets: SoMo.ml, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10810, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10810, 2022.

EGU22-10926 | Presentations | HS2.2.4

Root-zone “Periscope” and its applications for investigating plant-soil water relations and transpiration modelling 

Huade Guan, Zijuan Deng, Hailong Wang, Xiang Xu, Yuting Yang, Na Liu, Zidong Luo, Cicheng Zhang, John Hutson, Xinping Zhang, Xinguang He, and Craig Simmons

Since the first stoma appeared about 400 million years ago, moisture exchange between lands and the atmosphere extends into the root zone. However, due to its invisibility from the surface, root distribution and its temporal variation are difficult to estimate, which greatly hinders investigation of root zone moisture dynamics, soil-plant water relations, and transpiration modelling. Plant water potential reflects dynamic water condition in vegetation, which is determined by moisture supply in the root zone, atmospheric demand, and plant physiological control. Thus, dynamic water potential can provide a “periscope” to observe root zone hydraulic conditions. Based on this hydraulic connection in the soil-plant-atmosphere continuum (SPAC), plant individuals work very likely as “observation wells” to the whole root zone at predawn, and as “pumping test wells” in daytime. Meanwhile, stable isotopic composition of water in plant xylem approximately reflects the isotopic signature of bulk root accessible moisture. These hydraulic and isotopic root-zone periscopes provide information to estimate root-zone and plant hydraulic states and their dynamics, and hydraulic properties. In this presentation, we will show how this root-zone periscope concept, based on continuous monitoring of plant water potential, sapflow, and/or isotopic composition of xylem water, has been successfully applied in SPAC model development, root water uptake model improvement, transpiration model parameterisation, as well as investigation of ecohydrological separation.

How to cite: Guan, H., Deng, Z., Wang, H., Xu, X., Yang, Y., Liu, N., Luo, Z., Zhang, C., Hutson, J., Zhang, X., He, X., and Simmons, C.: Root-zone “Periscope” and its applications for investigating plant-soil water relations and transpiration modelling, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10926, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10926, 2022.

EGU22-11052 | Presentations | HS2.2.4 | Highlight

Assessing the suitability of remote sensing estimates of soil moisture and land evaporation in Switzerland for a better preparedness for projected drying trends 

Dominik Michel, Annkatrin Burgstall, Martin Hirschi, Anke Anke Duguay-Tetzlaff, and Sonia I. Seneviratne

Climate projections indicate an increasing risk of dry and hot episodes in Central Europe, including in Switzerland. However, models display a large spread in projections of changes in summer drying, highlighting the importance of related observations to evaluate climate models and constrain projections. Land hydrological variables play an essential role for these projections. This is particularly the case for soil moisture and land evaporation, which are directly affecting the development of droughts and heatwaves in both present and future.
The recent 2020 spring as well as 2015 and 2018 summer droughts in Switzerland have highlighted the importance of monitoring and assessing changes of soil moisture and land evaporation, which are strongly related to drought impacts on agriculture, forestry, and ecosystems.
The only Switzerland-wide soil moisture monitoring programme currently in place is the SwissSMEX (Swiss Soil Moisture Experiment) measurement network. It was initiated in 2008 and comprises 19 soil moisture measurement profiles at 17 different sites (grassland, forest and arable land). Since 2017, seven grassland SwissSMEX sites are complemented with land evaporation measurements from mini-lysimeters.
Here we analyze long-term satellite-based drought parameters, namely ASCAT Soil Water Index (SWI) derived from an H SAF test data set and LSA SAF Meteosat land evaporation products. We compare the satellite-based datasets with the SwissSMEX in-situ measurements of soil moisture and lysimeter land evaporation. The comparison of in-situ soil moisture and land evaporation data with the satellite parameters shows strong agreement in terms of anomalies. SWI indicates high correlations of 0.6 to 0.8 with in-situ measurements. The Meteosat land evaporation products strongly agree with measurements, with correlations of 0.7 and 0.9 for potential and actual land evaporation, respectively (Burgstall et al.).
These analyses provide useful insights in order to provide near-real time monitoring, enhance process understanding and for a better preparedness for future droughts.

References:
Burgstall, A. et al., Climatological drought monitoring in Switzerland using EUMETSAT SAF satellite products, Remote Sensing, in preparation.

How to cite: Michel, D., Burgstall, A., Hirschi, M., Anke Duguay-Tetzlaff, A., and Seneviratne, S. I.: Assessing the suitability of remote sensing estimates of soil moisture and land evaporation in Switzerland for a better preparedness for projected drying trends, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11052, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11052, 2022.

EGU22-11356 | Presentations | HS2.2.4

High resolution soil drought simulations evaluated at an unprecedented broad-range of soil moisture networks in Germany 

Friedrich Boeing, Oldrich Rakovec, Rohini Kumar, Luis Samaniego, Martin Schrön, Anke Hildebrandt, Corinna Rebmann, Stephan Thober, Sebastian Müller, Steffen Zacharias, Heye Bogena, Katrin Schneider, Ralf Kiese, and Andreas Marx

The 2018-2020 consecutive drought events in Germany resulted in impacts related with several sectors such as agriculture, forestry, water management, industry, energy production and transport. The key to increase preparedness for extreme drought events are high-resolution information systems. A major national operational drought information system is the German Drought Monitor (GDM), launched in 2014 [1]. It provides daily soil moisture (SM) simulated with the mesoscale hydrological model (mHM) and its related soil moisture index [2] at a spatial resolution of 4×4 km². The release of the new soil map BUEK200 allowed us to increase its model resolution to ≈1.2×1.2 km², which is used now for the second version of the GDM [3].

To explore the ability of the GMD-v2 to provide drought information at one-kilometer scale, we evaluated mHM soil moisture simulations against an unprecedented large sample of soil moisture observations from 40 locations across Germany. These SM observations are obtained from single profile measurements, spatially distributed sensor networks, cosmic-ray neutron stations, and lysimeters over a wide range of climatic conditions, vegetation types and soil depths. Specifically, the study aimed at answering two research questions: 1) how well do high-resolution German-wide soil moisture simulations capture the dynamics in observed soil moisture that constitute the basis for the near real-time soil moisture drought monitoring system? 2) Does the mHM simulations obtained with the high spatial resolution data set provide soil moisture estimates with greater model efficiency than those obtained in the coarser resolution?

The results showed that the agreement of simulated and observed SM dynamics is especially high during the vegetation period (0.84 median Spearman correlation(r)) and lower in winter (0.59 median r). Moderate but significant improvements between the low- and high-resolution GDM versions to observed SM were found in correlations for autumn (+0.07 median r) and winter (+0.12 median r). The spatially distributed sensor networks outperformed single profile measurements with higher than average correlation values especially for the 25–60 cm depth, which supports the closer scale match of spatially distributed measurements to the simulations. The results indicate areas for potential improvement and shows limitations from both: model parameterization (e.g., improvement of local scale hydrological processes) and observations methodology (e.g., reduction of measurement errors). Finally, the results of this study underline the fact that nationwide drought information systems depend both on appropriate simulations of the water cycle and a broad, high-quality observational soil moisture database.

References:

[1] Zink, M. et al. doi: 10.1088/1748-9326/11/7/074002 , 2016

[2] Samaniego et al. doi: 10.1175/jhm-d-12-075.1 2013

[3] Boeing, et al. doi: 10.5194/hess-2021-402 2021 (in revision)

How to cite: Boeing, F., Rakovec, O., Kumar, R., Samaniego, L., Schrön, M., Hildebrandt, A., Rebmann, C., Thober, S., Müller, S., Zacharias, S., Bogena, H., Schneider, K., Kiese, R., and Marx, A.: High resolution soil drought simulations evaluated at an unprecedented broad-range of soil moisture networks in Germany, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11356, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11356, 2022.

EGU22-11462 | Presentations | HS2.2.4

Multi-source soil moisture data fusion based on high-resolution land surface simulation and machine learning 

Junhan Zeng, Yuan Xing, Peng Ji, and Chunxiang Shi

Soil moisture (SM) plays an important role in hydrological processes and land-atmospheric interactions, and serves as an important boundary condition for the weather forecasting and climate modeling. Influenced by global environment change, SM changes significantly at local scales which rises the great need of high-resolution SM products to provide locally relevant information. However, the three SM estimation approaches, namely in-situ observation, remote sensing retrieval and land surface modeling, all have their disadvantages. Although recent works produce a combined SM products by merging the in-situ observations and several land surface simulation products, the long-term high-resolution SM product integrating multivariate data including remote sensing products is still lacking. In this study, high-resolution land surface modeling, high-resolution remote sensing products and SM observations from more than 2000 stations will be combined to generate spatially continuous and temporally complete soil moisture data in China by using the random forest algorithm. We first performed land surface simulations by using the Conjunctive Surface-Subsurface Process version 2 (CSSPv2) model forced by three meteorological forcings including the China Meteorological Administration Land Data Assimilation System version 2.0 (CLDASv2.0), ERA5 and GLDASv2.1. The validations over 2090 in situ stations during 2012–2017 showed that CLDASv2.0/CSSPv2 soil moisture simulation performed better than ERA5 and GLDASv2.1 reanalysis products, with an increased correlation of 26%–68% and reduced errors of 14%–24% at the daily time scale. The improvements mostly originate from the use of an advanced LSM because CLDASv2.0/CSSPv2 only increased the correlation by 5%–35% and decreased the errors by up to 9% when compared with ERA5/CSSPv2 and GLDASv2.1/CSSPv2. Due to the high accuracy of CLDASv2.0/CSSPv2 product, it will be used as a background to fuse the in-situ observations and satellite remote sensing soil moisture. The 70% of the observation site data, remote sensing products and CLDASv2.0/CSSPv2 product will be used to train the random forest model and generate a high resolution soil moisture product from 2008 to 2017, and another 30% of the site data will be used to evaluate the accuracy of the results. Such a SM product can describe the spatial and temporal distribution characteristics of soil moisture heterogeneity more accurately, and thus provide sufficient data support for scientific research and social development.

How to cite: Zeng, J., Xing, Y., Ji, P., and Shi, C.: Multi-source soil moisture data fusion based on high-resolution land surface simulation and machine learning, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11462, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11462, 2022.

EGU22-11810 | Presentations | HS2.2.4 | Highlight

Analysing the impact of calibrating a low-cost soil moisture sensor on FAO Aquacrop model performance. 

Soham Adla, Felix Bruckmaier, Leonardo Francisco Arias Rodriguez, Shivam Tripathi, Markus Disse, and Saket Pande

Poverty reduction programs across the world have invested in the agriculture sector, specifically in agricultural technology. Irrigation remains a crucial input to agriculture, and the lack of access to supplemental irrigation aggravates the distress of farmers, particularly, smallholders. Crop simulation models use parameters like crop characteristics, environmental conditions and management practices in combination with the local input data, to compute the 'yield response of crops to water', to better inform irrigation decision-making, for saving resources and/or increasing yield. Soil moisture data can be critical to develop more representative crop models by influencing soil hydraulic parameter estimation, and consequently improving the simulation of soil water movement. The dearth of cost-effective soil moisture sensors is a limitation to their effective incorporation in crop modelling, but calibrating them against primary or secondary standards can expand their scope of application. This study applies different calibration techniques on the low-cost capacitance based soil moisture sensor, Spectrum SM100. Calibration techniques include segmented linear regression, polynomial regression, spline regression, and machine learning algorithms such as support vector regression, random forest regression, multi-layer perceptron, extreme learning machine and support vector categorization. Independent soil moisture data are taken as both continuous and categorical variables, are calibrated both in the laboratory and field, and validated using field data. Field data is obtained from an experimental field in Kanpur (India) during a wheat cropping season in 2018. The experimental site is representative of an intensively managed rural landscape in the Ganga river basin, India. The calibrated soil moisture data are subsequently used in the  crop-water productivity model FAO Aquacrop to tune its soil hydraulic properties. Various models are developed with soil hydraulic parameter sets estimated using the calibrated soil moisture data. The respective performances of these models are compared with the default model performance (with parameters derived from the literature), based on outputs of interest such as above ground biomass, crop yield and water use efficiency. A representative crop model is then used to develop scenarios of irrigation scheduling, with varying degrees of water stress. Results indicate that calibrating the soil moisture sensors in laboratory conditions alone is not sufficient to parameterize soil hydraulic properties, and adequate parameterization requires sensor calibration in field conditions. Further, a cost-benefit analysis is conducted to assess and critically discuss the tradeoffs between the cost of soil moisture monitoring and the obtained crop yield.

How to cite: Adla, S., Bruckmaier, F., Arias Rodriguez, L. F., Tripathi, S., Disse, M., and Pande, S.: Analysing the impact of calibrating a low-cost soil moisture sensor on FAO Aquacrop model performance., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11810, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11810, 2022.

EGU22-12864 | Presentations | HS2.2.4

Ecohydrological responses to a series of dry years at the TERENO Observatory NorthEast Germany 

Theresa Blume, Andreas Güntner, Markus Weiler, and Ingo Heinrich

Ecohydrological consequences of dry years are difficult to predict. To understand the underlying drivers and responses, extensive monitoring over longer periods of time is a prerequisite. We are here providing an overview of multi-year monitoring of different forest stands in the TERENO Observatory NorthEast Germany. These forest stands include pure oak, beech and pine stands as well as mixed stands and the experimental design also allows the comparison of sites with and without accessibility to groundwater. Monitoring covers a large number of variables with high temporal resolution, such as soil moisture and groundwater dynamics but also sapflow and tree growth. Due to the deep groundwater levels and the high conductivity of the sandy soils, water storage dynamics in the large unsaturated zone and the deeper root zone are of special importance. Soil moisture monitoring therefore extends down to a depth of 2m. We provide an overview of the ecohydrological responses of this forest system to the extreme summer and fall of 2018 as well as the progression in the following years.

How to cite: Blume, T., Güntner, A., Weiler, M., and Heinrich, I.: Ecohydrological responses to a series of dry years at the TERENO Observatory NorthEast Germany, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12864, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12864, 2022.

HS2.3 – Water quality at the catchment scale

Modelling and predicting nitrate (NO3-N) concentrations at the catchment scale remain challenging as they are controlled by available sources, hydrological connectivity and biogeochemical transformations along the dominant flow paths, which are often spatially heterogenous and highly interacted. To unravel the controlling factors of catchment NO3-N cycling, a grid-based model, mHM-Nitrate, was applied to a 68 km2 mixed land use catchment (Demnitzer Millcreek) near Berlin. Results showed that landscape characteristics dictated the spatial distribution of NO3-N while hydroclimatic variability dominated its temporal dynamics. Restoration of riparian wetlands also mediated the NO3-N concentrations, leading to a modest reduction on NO3-N export (~10% reduction during 2001-2019). Further, the influence of three factors was validated in a spatially distributed sensitivity analysis (SSA) applied on key hydrological and nitrate parameters with a one-year moving window. The SSA results showed that the spatial pattern of parameter sensitivity was determined by NO3-N inputs and hydrological transport capacity, while its temporal dynamics were regulated by annual wetness conditions. Restoration management also contributed to the increase in sensitivity of denitrification parameters. Moreover, SSA identified the influential zones and time periods affecting simulation of NO3-N mobilisation and transport, which provides an evidence base for future model development and optimising of monitoring schemes.

How to cite: Wu, S., Tetzlaff, D., Yang, X., and Soulsby, C.: Landscape characteristics, hydroclimate and management control spatiotemporal NO3-N patterns in a lowland catchment: implication from 30-year modelling and sensitivity analyses, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-46, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-46, 2022.

EGU22-75 | Presentations | HS2.3.1 | Highlight

Projection of the risk of nutrient pollution and eutrophication for mid-21st century under changing climate and land use land cover 

Sneha Santy, Pradeep Mujumdar, and Govindasamy Bala

Large industrial pollution, agricultural runoff, and disposal of untreated sewage into the river have made Kanpur the most critical water pollution hotspot of Ganga River. This study assesses the risk of nutrient pollution and resulting eutrophication in this industrialized stretch passing through Kanpur for the mid-21st century under climate change and land use land cover projections. For this assessment, climate projections from an ensemble of 20 GCMs for the RCP 4.5 and RCP 8.5 scenarios, and future land use land cover (LULC) projections from a multi-layer perceptron neural network are used to drive a hydrological model HEC-HMS which is coupled to the water quality model QUAL2K. The nutrients assessed are ammonia, nitrate, total nitrogen, organic-, inorganic- and total phosphorous. An increase in nutrient pollution is simulated for future climate change due to a reduction in dilution volume caused by reduced low flows. An increase in nutrient pollution is also simulated for future land use land cover because of an increase in pollution from agricultural runoff. Both nitrogen and phosphorous components are highly sensitive to climate change, while only phosphorous components are highly susceptible to land use land cover. This is because, the major contribution of phosphorous pollution in this stretch is from agricultural runoff and only a negligible contribution is from point sources. The risk of nitrate pollution decreases and ammonia pollution increases with future climate change due to higher denitrification rate with warming, but the risk of total phosphorous pollution slightly decreases due to an overall reduction in phosphorous with warming following an overall increase in mean streamflow. A shift in the hotspot of eutrophication from Kanpur to Jajmau is also simulated due to limiting phosphorous eutrophication for future climate at Kanpur. The risk of eutrophication would increase with future climate change due to increased total nitrogen and total phosphorous with warming, and the risk is likely to become higher for the combined climate change and land use land cover projections. The results of this ongoing study will be presented in the meeting. Our study would be highly beneficial for the policymakers to save the Ganga River from further pollution in the future.

How to cite: Santy, S., Mujumdar, P., and Bala, G.: Projection of the risk of nutrient pollution and eutrophication for mid-21st century under changing climate and land use land cover, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-75, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-75, 2022.

EGU22-2591 | Presentations | HS2.3.1

Nitrogen transport and retention dynamics across central European catchments using large-sample data 

Tam Nguyen, Jan Fleckenstein, Fanny Sarrazin, Pia Ebeling, Stefanie Lutz, Andreas Musolff, and Rohini Kumar

Human activities, especially agricultural practices, have significantly altered the Earth’s landscape and the global cycle of nitrogen. In Europe, diffuse nitrogen (N) input from agriculture has been identified as a major driver of marine eutrophication. Despite a long history of measures, little improvement in groundwater and surface water quality has been observed. Recent studies have attempted to provide insights into nitrogen dynamics at the catchment scale, helping to explain the causes and effects of persistent water quality problems. However, there is a lack of large-scale, long-term studies that provide insights into both biogeochemical and hydrological N legacies under different landscape settings. Here using data of more than 100 German catchments of the last seven decades, we synthesis the nitrogen transport and retention dynamics, as well as their dominant (landscape and climate) controls in a large-sample setting. To this end, we adapted the mHM-SAS model (Nguyen et al., 2021) to reflect regional-scale biogeochemical and hydrological N legacies, taking into account the historical development of both diffuse and point sources. The underlying parameterizations were constrained using instream N concentrations. We found high heterogeneity in catchment responses to N inputs. The fractions of N surplus that were stored in the soil, removed by denitrification, stored in the subsurface, and finally exported to the stream vary over a wide range. Our analysis of the long-term (1950-2014) average N balances from all catchments suggests that a majority (mean = 57%) of N surplus was removed by denitrification, followed by stream N export (27%) and the rest was stored in the catchment (16%). Despite the reduction in N surplus after 1990s, biogeochemical legacy reflected in the soil N build-up showed an increasing trend over the analyzed period (1950-2014) across a majority of the study catchments. As for the hydrologic legacy, we found a varying range of mean transit times of discharge between 3.5 years and 13.1 years (95% confidence interval) among the analyzed catchments. Overall, our large-sample analysis provides a detailed overview of biogeochemical and hydrological N legacies across Germany; and thus provides useful insights for an improvement of agricultural practices and water quality management in Central European landscapes.

Nguyen, V.T., Kumar, R., Musolff, A., Lutz, S. R., Sarrazin, F., Attinger, S., & Fleckenstein, J. (2021 WRR - in revision). Disparate Seasonal Nitrate Export from Nested Heterogeneous Subcatchments Revealed with StorAge Selection Functions. https://doi.org/10.1002/essoar.10507516.1

How to cite: Nguyen, T., Fleckenstein, J., Sarrazin, F., Ebeling, P., Lutz, S., Musolff, A., and Kumar, R.: Nitrogen transport and retention dynamics across central European catchments using large-sample data, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2591, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2591, 2022.

Water quantity and quality of headwater catchments can react very sensitive to human impacts. While many studies focus on the influence of bigger cities on urban streams, the influence of rural villages and their associated infrastructure onto stream discharge and water quality dynamics is not often part of research.

We installed discharge measurements, UV-Vis probes Nitrate (NO3-) monitoring and conductivity probes on two neighboured headwater catchments, the Kelze (2.64 km²) and the Nesselbach (3.23 km²) catchment. All probes sample with a high temporal resolution of five minutes. We additionally equipped the sites with automatic samplers for also monitoring Nitrite (NO2-), Ammonium (NH4+), ortho-Phosphate (PO43- ) and total Phosphate (totP). All over the catchments are characterized by agriculture and forests, while the Kelze catchment is also influenced by a village. A part of the village is drained by a stormwater sewer while most of the area is drained by mixed sewer. A small wastewater treatment plant (WWTP), which is very common in rural areas, treats solely the wastewater of this village. The WWTP consists of four ponds in a series. Water flows solely driven by gravity and it is not possible to manually control the discharge of the WWTP.

First measurements show that during low flow conditions Nitrate concentrations are generally higher in the Nesselbach, which is more influenced by agricultural areas. While the outflow of the WWTP dilutes the NO3- concentration in the Kelze, it causes increased levels of NO2-, NH4+ and PO43- concentrations. Even though the village is comparatively small, the sealed area, which is connected to the sewer system, as well as private drainages lead to a fast runoff during rainfall events. The rainwater is directly transported to the WWTP. Due to the limited storage capacity of such WWTP high discharge peaks can be observed shortly after the event. Depending on the water storage in the WWTP, even small events can produce a discharge wave, leading to short time rise of water levels in the Kelze stream, while the Nesselbach catchment shows smaller peak flows and thus bigger storage effects for the same events.

Overall, the first measurements show, that understanding the interplay between agricultural and urban areas is crucial to understand the coupling of different hydrologic and biogeochemical processes and could lead to a better understanding of catchment processes.

How to cite: Spill, C., Ditzel, L., and Gassmann, M.: Influence of urban infrastructure on headwater streams – first insights into water quantity and quality measurements in two rural areas, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4087, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4087, 2022.

EGU22-4569 | Presentations | HS2.3.1

Trend analysis of nutrient losses in agricultural catchments using Generalised Additive Model and Pettitt test 

Golnaz Ezzati, Katarina Kyllmar, and Jennie Barron

The EU Water framework demands the Member States to set up water management plans with the aim that water bodies should reach good ecological status. However, the overall progress is slow and more efforts are needed to reach the goals. This study presents how long-term monitoring of water quality and agricultural management practices in four agriculturally dominated catchments in Sweden contribute to the knowledge to nutrient leaching and their behaviour in relation to catchment characteristics.

20 years of water quality data were analysed to understand nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P) trends and variations in surface waters leaving the catchments. The catchments represent a wide range of soil types and climate and hence different farming practices. Followed to time series analysis and in order to investigate how water quality data relate to management practices, two modelling approaches were used: non-parametric Pettitt test to determine significant changes in mean values of time series data; and generalized additive model (GAM) to identify the impact of climate/ anthropogenic variables on nutrient loads as a flexible model which avoids overfitting for long time series data.

Despite the general progress in preventing deterioration of water quality, the time series analysis indicated drastic changes over years in loads leaving some of the catchments. At the same time, there were large variations in N and P loads among catchments while runoff was the only significant indicator of losses in all. Clay dominated catchment showed more fluctuations in daily TN (0-40 mg/l) and TP (0-3.2 mg/l) concentrations, and also very high values of P (>0.07 mg PO4P/l) compared to other catchments. On the other hand, sandy loam catchment was more consistent in losses despite the high values of N (>7 mg NO3N/l). Although nutrients were washed into water bodies after the first heavy rain following a prolonged drought period, Pettitt model, which is insensitive against spikes, proved that permanent change points in P or N loads was not always following immediately after a change point in runoff or rainfall. Finally, GAM modelling did not generate a direct relationship between a single management practice and trend of nutrient concentration, and demonstrated the complexity in analysing the commutative impact of temporal/spatial factors that influence nutrients loads.

The study results proved that having long term water quality record is of great importance to show the pattern of nutrient trends, signal any undesirable changes, and to observe the impact of environment including cumulative impact of management practices on nutrient mobilization/retention. Therefore, continuing monitoring is critical to support the EU WFD 3rd cycle actions. However, better information on peak load events is needed as climate and especially precipitation–runoff evenest are changing. In addition, application of technologies such as sensors or remote sensing will increase accuracy of the measurement by providing high temporal data regardless of any logistic complications.

How to cite: Ezzati, G., Kyllmar, K., and Barron, J.: Trend analysis of nutrient losses in agricultural catchments using Generalised Additive Model and Pettitt test, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4569, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4569, 2022.

EGU22-4601 | Presentations | HS2.3.1

Study of environmental pressure of industrial effluent on rivers with a composed pressure index 

Paola Di Fluri, Valentina Di Talia, Antonio Leonardi, Giacomo Antonioni, Alessio Domeneghetti, and Valerio Cozzani

The deterioration of superficial water quality is a relevant issue as regards water management. Until today, most European rivers do not achieve qualitative standards defined by the Water Framework Directive (WFD). Given the goals of the WFD and taking into account current guidance for water quality management, this study has been carried out to evaluate pressures of anthropic activities - like industrial effluents, wastewater treatment plants, waste-to-energy plant, waste handling facilities, contaminates sites- on superficial waters.

In this study, we propose a simplified multidisciplinary methodology to perform a semi-quantitative analysis of water pressures on river segment starting from easily accessible data, thus attempting to overcome the endemic scarcity of monitoring data. In particular, the methodology proposes a procedure for: (1) identifying river segment exposed to pollution spills by the application of an expeditive raster-based numerical model; (2) determining a pressure index value for each identified river segment in relation to allocated spills. The developed pressure index offers the possibility of quantifying the significant pressures of several pollutant hotspots that impact simultaneously on a single river segment. The methodology has been tested over two rivers differently exposed to industrial and anthropogenic pressure and for which punctual environmental pollution hotspot were available at catchment scale.

The results allow to identify river segments most exposed to pollutant spills and, based on pressure index values, to do a comparative analysis between rivers segments with similar characteristics or to draw up a ranking magnitude of the river pressures. In this prospective, the developed methodology can represent a solid tool for decision-making processes and predictive studies in areas with no, or poor, monitoring data.

How to cite: Di Fluri, P., Di Talia, V., Leonardi, A., Antonioni, G., Domeneghetti, A., and Cozzani, V.: Study of environmental pressure of industrial effluent on rivers with a composed pressure index, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4601, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4601, 2022.

EGU22-5733 | Presentations | HS2.3.1

Potentialities of Sentinel-2 images for the study of the fresh water resource in a glacierized mountainous catchment 

Erica Matta, Claudia Giardino, Mariano Bresciani, Marta Chiarle, and Guido Nigrelli

Water quality and availability are nowadays essential requirements for all those activities that need an exploitation of the water resource: e.g. potable use, hydroelectricity production, agriculture, recreation. Inland water originates from atmospheric events and is stored in solid state as glaciers or snow (e.g. on the mountains) or in natural and artificial lakes at any altitude. The well documented climate warming has, among its multiple effects, the modification of the equilibrium between liquid and solid phase of water, its storage and availability, as well as changes in the precipitation regime, such as the reduction and intensification of rainfall events alternated to long dry periods. All these changes alter water quality and water availability at the catchment level.

We are experimenting the use of earth observation data (Sentinel-2) to track temporal variations of snow cover, water bodies (in terms of size and numbers) and water colour over the last five years in a small high-altitude, glacierized catchment in Italy (Lake Ceresole watershed, Orco Valley, Western Alps). In particular, water colour is chosen here as a proxy of water quality and is considered as mainly driven by the presence of suspended particles, because of the conditions that feature a mountainous environment (e.g.  minimized anthropic pressure and prevailing natural processes). Water colour is then supposed to change following the release of suspended particles from snow/glaciermelting during thaw periods at seasonal timescale, as well as be modified due to the transport of solid particles as river flow or runoff, which can be generated as a consequence of heavy rainfall events.

Satellite derived products on snow cover, lake size/number and water colour are then coupled with meteorological measurements (e.g. precipitation), and information on geo-hydrological events (e.g. floods) in order to find possible linkages between lake water dynamics and both snow/glaciermelting and significant meteorological and geo-hydrological events. Field measurements allow a validation of the satellite data on lake water colour to be performed.

 

With this study, we aim to understand if the high spatial resolution of Sentinel-2 acquisitions, except for the drawbacks of all optical satellite sensors (e.g. cloud cover), can provide useful information on water and sediment dynamics in an alpine glacierized basin, that can allow to follow the on-going modifications that the mountainous environment is facing due to the global warming. The use of Sentinel-2 data for this purpose would be a valuable tool in helping both monitoring and understanding of climate change consequences, and in managing the water resource in places not easily accessible for periodic in-situ measures. In fact, mountains respond promptly to climatic pressures, but are also the water sink of fresh water for downstream valleys.

How to cite: Matta, E., Giardino, C., Bresciani, M., Chiarle, M., and Nigrelli, G.: Potentialities of Sentinel-2 images for the study of the fresh water resource in a glacierized mountainous catchment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5733, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5733, 2022.

EGU22-5742 | Presentations | HS2.3.1 | Highlight

Long-term trajectories of Nitrogen and Phosphorous point sources to German river systems 

Fanny Sarrazin, Sabine Attinger, and Rohini Kumar

Concurrent excesses of nitrogen (N) and phosphorous (P) compounds in the environment are causing the eutrophication of water bodies worldwide, including the North Sea and Baltic Sea that border Germany. The N:P ratio is a crucial measure of the nature of nutrient limitation and of the state of aquatic ecosystems. While many studies focus on the diffuse sources of N and P, point sources from urban and industrial wastewater can substantially contribute to in-stream N and P levels. Yet, systematic studies of the co-development of N and P point sources that span different river basins and a long time period are greatly lacking at a national scale like Germany.

To this end, we provide a comprehensive investigation of the long-term trajectories of N and P point sources in German catchments over the last seven decades (1950-2019). We construct a novel gridded dataset of N and P point sources for Germany, adapting the methodology proposed by Morée et al. (2013) and using country-specific datasets on population counts, protein supply, food wastes, and population connection to sewer and wastewater treatment plants. In addition, we estimate the consumption of P detergents combining datasets of household detergent phosphate and phosphonate sales, household ownership of automatic dishwashers, and professional detergent use. Our reconstruction approach accounts for the uncertainty in coefficients (e.g. efficiency of wastewater treatment, N content in proteins). We create an ensemble of plausible combinations of coefficient values that are constrained by the contemporary observed N and P loading from urban wastewater treatment plants (2012-2016 values; Büttner 2020).

From the newly constructed dataset, we analyze the trajectories of N and P loading, the N:P ratio and the relative importance of diffuse and point sources across major German river basins. In particular, N and P loadings show large differences between West and East Germany. In addition, P loading exhibits a stronger decrease in the 1980s and early 1990s than N loading because of the introduction of phosphate-free laundry detergents. Overall, N and P trajectories have large temporal and spatial variations, in particular due to differences in treatment efficiency, in population density, and in regulations that limit the maximum phosphate content in detergents.

Büttner, O.: DE-WWTP - data collection of wastewater treatment plants of Germany (status 2015, metadata), https://doi.org/10.4211/hs.712c1df62aca4ef29688242eeab7940c, 2020.

Morée, A. L., Beusen, A. H. W., Bouwman, A. F., and Willems, W. J.: Exploring global nitrogen and phosphorus flows in urban wastes during the twentieth century, Global Biogeochemical Cycles, 27, 836–846, https://doi.org/10.1002/gbc.20072, 2013.

How to cite: Sarrazin, F., Attinger, S., and Kumar, R.: Long-term trajectories of Nitrogen and Phosphorous point sources to German river systems, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5742, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5742, 2022.

EGU22-6032 | Presentations | HS2.3.1

Evaluating the Impacts of Agricultural Transformation from Rainfed to Irrigation on Streamflow and Nitrates in a Mediterranean Agricultural Watershed in Spain 

Brian Omondi Oduor, Miguel Ángel Campo-Bescós, Noemí Solange Lana-Renault, and Javier Casalí Sarasibar

Agriculture intensification, such as irrigation, creates a lot of pressure on the available water resources and the environment. This paper explored the water quality dynamics, specifically nitrates, before and after transformation from rainfed to irrigation agriculture within the Cidacos River Watershed in Navarra, Spain. The watershed occupies 477 km2, of which approximately 260 km2 have been traditionally rainfed cultivated, whereas 77 km2 were transformed from rainfed to pressurized irrigation between 2009 and 2011. The newly irrigated area is located in the watershed's lower region, close to the river's mouth. Water quality data sampling has been taken at several points along the watershed from 2000 to date, up to the outlet of the Cidacos River in Traibuenas, where it joins with the Aragón River. Streamflow and nitrate concentration data have been measured at the watershed's outlet in Traibuenas since 2017. A previous baseline study by Merchán et al. (2020) showed an increase in the electrical conductivity and nitrate concentration in the river's lower reaches affected by irrigation. However, no information about the effect on streamflow, nitrate loads, and yields resulting from the irrigation was explored. The aim of this study was therefore to fill this research gap by using hydrological models such as the Soil Water Assessment Tool (SWAT) model, to recreate, simulate and understand the behaviour of the Cidacos River in the irrigated area from 2017 to the present, if the transformation from rainfed to irrigation had not occurred; and then compare those simulated variables with the measured ones since 2017. Simulation of streamflow and nitrate loads were done using the SWAT model until Olite from 2000 to 2020 under rainfed conditions. This was later extended for the entire watershed up to the mouth of the Cidacos River from 2017 to the present when the transformation to irrigation was fully completed and the Traibuenas outlet gauging station started operating. The results were then compared to the measured data for the irrigated region before and after the transformation to irrigation. For the simulations, the model was calibrated from 2000 to 2010 and validated from 2011 to 2020, and its sensitivity and uncertainties were analyzed for streamflow and nitrates at the Olite gauging station. The model evaluation results were satisfactory for both streamflow and nitrate loads, with streamflow having values of NSE = 0.82/0.83 and R2 = 0.83/0.84 during calibration and validation periods, respectively. Similarly, the statistical evaluation values for nitrate loads were NSE = 0.71/0.68 and R2 = 0.72/0.79 during calibration and validation periods, respectively. Subsequently, the calibrated parameters were used to simulate the entire watershed, considering all the territorial variables specific to each zone. Comparative analysis between the periods before and after the implementation of irrigation indicated a 6.6% and 43.2% increase in streamflow and nitrate loads, respectively, which subsequently increased the nitrate concentrations. The results from this study could provide useful information and guidance on nitrate pollution control, thus contributing to the management of the effects of agriculture on water quality and enhancing sustainable agricultural practices.

How to cite: Oduor, B. O., Campo-Bescós, M. Á., Lana-Renault, N. S., and Sarasibar, J. C.: Evaluating the Impacts of Agricultural Transformation from Rainfed to Irrigation on Streamflow and Nitrates in a Mediterranean Agricultural Watershed in Spain, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6032, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6032, 2022.

EGU22-6063 | Presentations | HS2.3.1

Leakage of water from public supply distribution networks is responsible for significant phosphorus fluxes within many urban catchments across the United States 

Elizabeth Flint, Matthew J. Ascott, Daren C. Gooddy, Ben W.J. Surridge, and Mason O. Stahl

The release of phosphorus into aquatic environments as a result of anthropogenic activity has led to eutrophication of many fresh and coastal waters around the globe and across the United States (US). Dosing of public water supplies (PWS) with phosphate (PO4) compounds is undertaken around the globe, including many parts of the US, in order to inhibit corrosion and release of lead and copper within water distribution network pipes. However, 17% of this treated water is released into the environment due to leakage, resulting in previously unquantified fluxes of phosphorus into the environment. We have calculated this PWS leakage PO4 flux (as phosphorus; PO4-P) for the US to be between 2.2-6.7 kt PO4-P yr-1. County PWS leakage fluxes range from 0-2,865 kg PO4-P km-2 yr-1, and the relative magnitude of the fluxes in many urban counties across the northeastern US highlights the need for these previously unquantified fluxes to be incorporated into catchment nutrient balances. Not only do PWS leakage fluxes of PO4-P make a potentially significant contribution to eutrophication in urban catchments, but they also represent a loss of phosphorus that subsequently cannot be easily recovered at wastewater treatment plants, driving increased extraction of non-renewable and dwindling global phosphorus rock reserves.

 

How to cite: Flint, E., Ascott, M. J., Gooddy, D. C., Surridge, B. W. J., and Stahl, M. O.: Leakage of water from public supply distribution networks is responsible for significant phosphorus fluxes within many urban catchments across the United States, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6063, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6063, 2022.

Managing river water quality at critical checkpoints that have significant impacts on water use is important for sustainable catchment development. This requires managing the whole multi-catchment systems upstream of a critical checkpoint. Concepts of systems headroom (deficit below permit) and excess (extra above permit) have been used to distinguish sub-catchments’ roles in pollution contribution. Based on the concepts, we propose a three-phase management approach. In the first phase, we frame the headroom and excess at temporal, spatial, and source domains and evaluate them to investigate the systems mechanisms. The evaluation is by simulating physical processes a semi-distributed integrated model (CatchWat-SD). We apply the model to 12 sub-catchments that make up the Upper Thames river basin and validate it using monitoring data. In the second phase, we incorporate the evaluated headroom and excess in loads allocation to develop a strategy that coordinates systems headroom for more efficient and realistic interventions. In the last phase, we validate the strategies by simulating the scenarios that coordinate headroom at different domains and evaluating them in water quality improvement, efficiency, temporal steadiness, spatial homogeneity, and practical feasibility. Results show that dry seasons, downstream catchments and urban sources generally have more excess. Thus, more target loads reduction is allocated to dry season, downstream catchments and urban sources in the fully coordinated scenario. The higher degree of headroom coordination a strategy achieves, the better performance this strategy generally obtains in all five metrics. This study emphasises the need to incorporate headroom in loads reduction allocation, which helps to more efficiently improve systems water quality performance with a more realistic degree of intervention. The whole procedure can be further expanded to water quality management at multiple checkpoints for sustainable management in large catchments.

How to cite: Liu, L., Dobson, B., and Mijic, A.: Coordinating systems headroom for more efficient multi-catchment water quality management at a critical checkpoint, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6221, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6221, 2022.

EGU22-7661 | Presentations | HS2.3.1

An integrated catchment modelling for assessment of water quality and its effect on aquatic ecology 

Katri Rankinen, José Cano-Bernal, and Juha-Pekka Vähä

The catchment is the appropriate scale to observe and quantify processes related to the water cycle and water quality. In the Karjaanjoki river basin (located in southern Finland) we aim to sustainable agricultural production that does not harm water ecosystems. Indicator species are trout and river pearl mussels. This is one of the few rivers that still has a natural pearl mussel population. Their living conditions have deteriorated, and the population is aging. We used mathematical models to assess the threats of human activity in the catchment area that can influence water quality and thus living conditions of these species. We estimated the change in living conditions from long water quality time series. We created an integrated, process-based model chain (Persist and INCA) to assess different loading scenarios from agricultural practices. Our results show that the agri-environmental measures are sufficient to maintain the current water quality, but more effective measures are needed to improve it. Climate change in particular is putting additional pressure on ecosystems.

How to cite: Rankinen, K., Cano-Bernal, J., and Vähä, J.-P.: An integrated catchment modelling for assessment of water quality and its effect on aquatic ecology, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7661, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7661, 2022.

EGU22-8467 | Presentations | HS2.3.1

Efficiency of BMPs for the reduction of sediment loads in the control of nutrients. 

Giovanni Francesco Ricci, Ersilia D'Ambrosio, Anna Maria De Girolamo, and Francesco Gentile

Inappropriate tillages and the intensive use of mineral fertilizers are fundamental driver of soil erosion and land diffuse pollution. The new European environmental policies, such as the European Green Deal (EUGD) and the Farm to fork strategy aims to restore the natural functions of ground and surface soil by 2030. Best Management Practices (BMPs) are mitigation measures which will be included in EU Member States management programs to achieve the policies goals. Most of BMPs have as their first function to reduce soil erosion, however these can have effect also on the nutrient loads. This work assessed the power of soil erosion oriented BMPs in achieving nutrient load reduction by means of the Soil and Water Assessment Tool (SWAT) in the Carapelle basin (Apulia, Italy). Moreover, their economic convenience was evaluated for both the public and the private sector. Five alternative scenarios were implemented: Contour farming (CF), no tillage (NT), reforestation (RF), and two additional scenarios, including the 20% reduction of fertilizers in CF and NT, (CFR) and (NTR), following the EUGD strategy. With the current management of the areas total nitrogen (TN) was ~49 kg ha-1y-1, while total phosphorous (TP) was ~0.044 kg ha-1y-1. N-NO3 load increased for NT and CT in terms of surface runoff and leaching. Contrariwise RF, as well as CFR and NTR scenarios showed a reduction of N-NO3 losses. In particular CFR and NTR abated of ~20% surface runoff and leached N-NO3 load. Economically, RF was profitable in sloped areas while CFR and NTR were the best alternative in those hilly and flat. This suggested that RF may be implemented in combination with other practices to have a greater impact at the basin scale. BMP implementation requires significant investments (public and private). The results of this study provide the scientific basis for decision-making for agriculture and watershed management.

How to cite: Ricci, G. F., D'Ambrosio, E., De Girolamo, A. M., and Gentile, F.: Efficiency of BMPs for the reduction of sediment loads in the control of nutrients., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8467, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8467, 2022.

Nitrate is one of the key parameters for the assessment of water quality, since an excess of NO3 in drinking water can lead to health risks, especially for young children. The purpose of our study was not only to detect occasionally exceedances of the water quality standards, but also to monitor the temporal highly resolved behavior of NO3 concentrations in the stream water over a one year period. To reach this goal we picked the small headwater catchment of the Nesselbach, located at Grebenstein in the North-Hessian low-mountain-ranges as our study area. We installed a UV-ViS-probe (s::can spectro::lyser), capable of detecting small quantities of nitrate with a 5 minutes resolution and added an automatic sampler to collect samples for lab calibration. Additionally, we installed discharge measurement in the stream and collected event-based samples of stable water isotopes with the installed automated samplers. The stable water isotopes are used to perform hydrograph separation for differentiation between event-water and baseflow, and therefore to gain deeper insights into the hydrology of the Nesselbach catchment.  

The sampling results show that the E.U. environmental quality standard of 50 mg/l NO3 is almost always exceeded during baseflow in the Nesselbach. Rain-event driven discharge dilutes the baseflow strong enough to reduce the concentrations below the threshold for a short time span, but snowmelt shows the opposite behavior, increasing the NO3 concentrations in the discharge over a longer period of time. While headwater catchments are often considered to be of good water quality in comparison to the much bigger catchments downstream, our findings suggest, that in catchments with agricultural landuse even the headwaters lag a good water quality and exceed the E.U. environmental quality standards for NO3. This first evaluation of the data of our study points to the relevance of monitoring NO3 concentrations in the baseflow. Because headwater catchments are often used for the extraction of drinking water and cattle watering, it could be necessary to expand the monitoring of NO3 to a higher number of headwater catchments.

How to cite: Ditzel, L., Spill, C., and Gaßmann, M.: Nitrate flux monitoring in small headwater catchments in the German low mountain range –  Threshold exceedance during baseflow and snowmelt., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9830, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9830, 2022.

EGU22-10051 | Presentations | HS2.3.1

Spatially distributed modeling of nitrate fluxes at the catchment scale using a transit time distribution approach 

Ingo Heidbüchel, Sabine Schütz, Jie Yang, Tam Van Nguyen, Pia Ebeling, and Jan Fleckenstein

Predicting dynamic nitrate fluxes at the catchment scale is relevant to understand solute transport processes, assess eutrophication risks and improve water quality management. In order to simplify the complex biogeochemical processes without disregarding the spatial heterogeneity and changing flow paths, we combine physical modeling and a conceptual transit time approach. First, we use the physically-based, 3D, spatially distributed hydrologic model HydroGeoSphere (HGS) to extract transit time distributions (TTDs) of a conservative tracer for different parts of a catchment (partitioned by land use). We systematically combine different initial and boundary conditions analyzing apparent changes in shape and scale of the TTDs. Then we modify the resulting land use-specific TTDs according to the typical decay and retardation processes that are associated with nitrate. This includes retention of organic nitrogen, as well as attenuation by plant uptake and denitrification of inorganic nitrate. Finally, we superimpose and convolve the time series of nitrate-specific TTDs to compute the total nitrate outflux from the catchment.

How to cite: Heidbüchel, I., Schütz, S., Yang, J., Van Nguyen, T., Ebeling, P., and Fleckenstein, J.: Spatially distributed modeling of nitrate fluxes at the catchment scale using a transit time distribution approach, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10051, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10051, 2022.

EGU22-10710 | Presentations | HS2.3.1

Assessing and predicting the impacts of wildfires on water quality in Portugal: Project FRISCO 

Joao Pedro Nunes, Bruno Aparício, Marta Carvalho, Carlos Brito, Dina Jahanianfard, Akli Benali, Joana Parente, Niels Nitzsche, Beatriz Faria, Jantiene Baartman, and Luis Filipe Dias

Wildfires change vegetation cover and soil properties, and create a layer of highly mobile ash. Enhanced runoff generation induced by the wildfire can transfer can transfer the ash to streams and water bodies, potentially causing contamination problems and imposing limitations on human uses. This is the focus of project FRISCO: Managing fire-induced risks of water quality contamination, an ongoing applied research project funded by the Portuguese government (PCIF/MPG/0044/2018). The project brings together scientists and water managers to develop tools to better assess post-fire water contamination risks, and identify the best risk mitigation options for water managers working in fire-prone watersheds.

This presentation will focus on the work to identify the main impacts of fires on surface water quality in Portugal based on an analysis of existing water quality data, and to examine the drivers for water quality deterioration. The Portuguese water quality database was examined for sampling stations in watersheds without significant upstream modifications, with data for at least 4 years before and after wildfires of at least 100 ha burned area. In the period 2000-2020, 28 sampling points in rivers and 15 points in 10 reservoirs were found with these characteristics, with monthly data for 6 parameters which are direct and indirect indicators of fire impacts in water quality. The datasets were assessed using Change-Point Analysis to determine the occurrence of breakpoints in water quality following the fire occurrence.

The results show that most fires led to changes in indirect indicators of fire impacts, including significant decrease in dissolved oxygen and pH levels in water, and significant increase of water conductivity. Moreover, changes to direct indicators of fire impacts occurred mostly in reservoir sampling stations, with significant increase in suspended solids, chemical oxygen demand and nitrates concentrations. An in-depth analysis of some stations indicates that the monthly sampling frequency might not be sufficient to capture fast changes associated with large post-fire rainfall events, which nevertheless have impacts on downstream reservoirs. This highlights the importance of finding proxies for water quality impacts which can either be monitored continuously or which can highlight fire impacts despite a monthly sampling frequency.

The work to identify drivers for these changes is ongoing. Special effort is being put in mapping the characteristics of the fires which occurred in the watersheds of the sampling points, including: (i) fire severity, assessed from satellite imagery using the difference Normalized Burn Ratio dNBR index; and (ii) hydrological connectivity between burned areas and the stream network, assessed using the Index of Connectivity by Borselli and Cavalli.

There is also ongoing communication with a group of water managers which operate in fire-prone watersheds, to (i) assess the resilience of the water intake and treatment operations, as well as the capacity to respond to different water qualities, (i) identify the levels of water quality impacts that can be classified as being of concern, and (iii) discuss potential risk mitigation options, including interventions before fire occurrence, emergency post-fire interventions, and changes to water quality treatment.

How to cite: Nunes, J. P., Aparício, B., Carvalho, M., Brito, C., Jahanianfard, D., Benali, A., Parente, J., Nitzsche, N., Faria, B., Baartman, J., and Dias, L. F.: Assessing and predicting the impacts of wildfires on water quality in Portugal: Project FRISCO, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10710, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10710, 2022.

EGU22-11307 | Presentations | HS2.3.1

Determination of the optimum sampling frequency for water quality monitoring schemes 

Elisa Coraggio, Dawei Han, Claire Gronow, and Theo Tryfonas

Water quality monitoring is essential to understanding the complex dynamics of water ecosystems, the impact of human infrastructure on them and to ensure the safe use of water resources for drinking, recreation and transport. High frequency in-situ monitoring systems are being increasingly employed in water quality monitoring schemes due to their much finer temporal measurement scales possible and reduced cost associated with manual sampling, manpower and time needed to process results compared to traditional grab-sampling.

Modelling water quality data at higher frequency reduces uncertainty and allows for the capture of transient events, although due to potential constraints of data storage, inducement of noise, and power conservation it is worthwhile not using an excessively high sampling frequency.

This study explores the issue of frequency optimisation of water quality monitoring schemes by applying three different statistical approaches for determining the optimum sampling frequency.

The proposed approaches are tested utilising a high frequency dataset built from recording continuous physical and chemical water quality parameters (temperature, dissolved oxygen (DO), fluorescent dissolved organic matter (fDOM), turbidity and conductivity) with multiparameter sondes at 3 sites in Bristol’s Floating Harbour.

As a result, this analysis provides practical tools to understand how different sampling frequencies are representative of the water quality changes. Furthermore, it helps determine the minimum frequency required to communicate periodic fluctuations in water quality and investigate the additional benefit of recording data at a frequency higher than the minimum required.

How to cite: Coraggio, E., Han, D., Gronow, C., and Tryfonas, T.: Determination of the optimum sampling frequency for water quality monitoring schemes, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11307, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11307, 2022.

EGU22-11352 | Presentations | HS2.3.1

Testing potential mitigation measures to reduce nutrient loads to a temporary river 

Anna Maria De Girolamo and Antonio Lo Porto

To achieve and maintain the good ecological status of surface waters, each EU Member State is expected to invest economic resources in a programme of measures. To do this, a preliminary analysis to quantify the anthropogenic pressures and their impacts on surface waters is necessary to prioritise the measures to be undertaken.

The objectives of this work were to: (i) quantify the nutrient loads from point and diffuse pollution to the Rio Mannu stream identifying the critical time in terms of water quality, and (ii) simulate some mitigation measures for reducing the nutrient loads being delivered to the wetland. Two “measures” were tested to mitigate nutrient pollution in high flow and low flow conditions: (1) the use of treated wastewater from urban wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) for the irrigation of cultivated olive trees and a (2) reduction in fertiliser usage rates (20%).

Results showed that under high flow conditions, NO3-N and TP loads accounted for 89% and 99% of the total load, respectively. The low flow contribution to the total load was very low, with NO3-N and TP accounting for 2.8% and 0.7%, respectively. However, the natural hydrological regime in the study area is intermittent, and low flow represents a critical condition for the water quality due to the high concentrations of TP and NO3-N from WWTP discharge. Results indicated that agriculture is the main source of NO3-N in the surface waters. The point sources made a minor contribution, in terms of nutrient load to the surface waters, but they constitute a relevant hydrological pressure for the Rio Mannu, producing a shift from an intermittent hydrological regime (natural conditions) towards a perennial regime. The measures are effective to reduce nutrient loads in surface waters at the outlet for all hydrological conditions. Under high flow conditions, the reduction was 9% and 12% for NO3-N and TP loads, respectively. The reduction increased under normal and low flow conditions (75% and 83% for NO3-N and TP loads, respectively).

Based on this study, it is evident that a “programme of measures” for improving the current status of surface waters must be oriented towards reducing nutrient loads, both under high and low flow conditions. The results show that a 20% reduction in fertiliser usage on the main crops in this area, and the reuse of wastewater from selected WWTPs, would result in a significant reduction in the nutrient loads delivered to the wetland, although this reduction is not large enough, and supplementary measures would be required.

How to cite: De Girolamo, A. M. and Lo Porto, A.: Testing potential mitigation measures to reduce nutrient loads to a temporary river, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11352, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11352, 2022.

EGU22-12369 | Presentations | HS2.3.1

High-resolution water quality simulation to disentangle multiple stressor effects on aquatic species 

Jens Kiesel, Kristin Peters, Paul Wagner, and Nicola Fohrer

Stream ecosystems are impacted by multiple stressors in complex spatio-temporal interactions. The lack of understanding of these interactions and impacts hampers the successful restoration of streams and rivers. The German Research Foundation-funded collaborative research centre RESIST (https://sfb-resist.de/index.html) aims to disentangle these complex dependencies applying a novel theoretical framework: the ‘Asymmetric Response Concept’. The concept hypothesizes that degradation and recovery processes depend on different, non-linear biotic and abiotic interactions between stressors, environmental variables, and organisms. Therefore, unprecedented data and information are required which are collected through lab and field experiments, species sampling, observations of environmental variables and modelling.

High-resolution ecohydrological modelling is a core component in this process to provide historic information on water quality in two mesoscale catchments (Boye with 124km² and Kinzig with 1065km²) in Germany. Due to history, storage- and hysteresis effects in the hydrologic system, the spatio-temporal dynamics of in-stream environmental variables follow an asymmetric function to degradation and recovery. The model SWAT+ (Soil and Water Assessment Tool) is therefore applied to simulate streamflow as well as the water quality components temperature, oxygen, nitrogen components and salinity (TONS) at more than 20 sites in each catchment.

We present the conceptual framework of the approach, including data sources and data collection, model parameterization, required code adaptations, calibration techniques and expected results. 

How to cite: Kiesel, J., Peters, K., Wagner, P., and Fohrer, N.: High-resolution water quality simulation to disentangle multiple stressor effects on aquatic species, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12369, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12369, 2022.

EGU22-12914 | Presentations | HS2.3.1

Predicting high-frequency nutrient dynamics in the Danube River from surrogates with sensors and machine-learning 

Jingshui Huang, Binh Yen Tran, and Leonardo F. Arias-Rodriguez

Nutrient dynamics play an essential role in aquatic ecosystems. Despite advances in sensor technology, nutrient concentrations are difficult and expensive to monitor in-situ and in real-time. Emerging data-driven methods may provide surrogate measures for nutrient concentrations. In this work, 4-year high-frequency (15-min interval) regularly monitored variables and 2 data-driven algorithms are used to build surrogate measures for nitrate, orthophosphate, and ammonium at 2 stations in the German part of the Danube River. The variables used as input futures are dissolved oxygen (DO), temperature (Temp), conductivity (EC), pH, discharge rate (Q), and chlorophyll-a (Chl-a). Multiple linear regression (MLR) and Random Forest Regression (RF) are trained and cross-validated for the concentration predictions of nutrient constituents. Prior to training, pre-processing procedures were implemented, including removing outliers and filling missing values by linear interpolation. This work presented a thorough description of the workflow, including intermediate steps for feature engineering, feature selection, hyper-parameter optimization. The results of the 12 surrogate models (2 algorithms * 3 constituents * 2 stations) are compared. The results show that the RF algorithm can reproduce the environmental phenomena and contribute to water quality management. The RF algorithm already outperformed MLR when adding at least three predictors in this work. The five-fold CV has identified the reliable and stable prediction of the targets NO3--N (R2 = 0.9967 and 0.9992), NH4+-N (R2 = 0.9861 and 0.9927), PO43--P (R2 = 0.9638 and 0.9643).

How to cite: Huang, J., Tran, B. Y., and Arias-Rodriguez, L. F.: Predicting high-frequency nutrient dynamics in the Danube River from surrogates with sensors and machine-learning, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12914, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12914, 2022.

EGU22-13198 | Presentations | HS2.3.1

Modelling stream temperature with multiple hydroclimatological temperature models 

Zheng Duan, Edward Duggan, Ye Tuo, Yuying Li, Jianzhi Dong, Junzhi Liu, and Hongkai Gao

Stream temperature is an important parameter to evaluate the water quality and biodiversity in aquatic ecosystems. Climate change and human activities (e.g. land use change) are affecting stream temperature, potentially leading to negative impacts on the habitats of native species and sustainability of aquatic ecosystems. Therefore, it is important to monitor and understand stream temperature under different conditions to better protect the aquatic ecosystems. The conventional in-situ measurements from gauge stations provide the most accurate stream temperature data, but they are often sparse and limited in terms of data length (temporal) and spatial coverages (many regions have no measurements). Stream temperature modelling is an effective way to extrapolate from limited measurements in both space and time, and it is the only way to predict the future to assess the climate change impacts. The stream temperature is influenced by meteorological and hydrological factors, and the relationship between the stream temperature and physical conditions is complex and can vary spatially and temporally. Different statistical and process/physically-based stream temperature models have been developed with the latter generally performing better. The Soil and Water Assessment Tool (SWAT) is a semi-distributed process-based hydrological model built with a simple statistical model to simulate stream temperature using only air temperature. Two hydroclimatological stream temperature models were recently developed to improve the capability of the SWAT model for simulation of stream temperature by considering influences of hydrological conditions and more detailed water-air heat transfer processes. The two recently developed models were tested mainly in a few river basins in U.S. and Canada. This study aims to compare and evaluate -for the first time- the performance of three models in simulating stream temperature in the Vils Basin located in Bavaria, Germany. The SWAT model is first calibrated and validated against the measured streamflow at the basin outlet on a daily timescale to ensure satisfactory streamflow simulation. Then the three different stream temperature models are run and evaluated with measured stream temperature at both daily and monthly time scales. The parameters and simulation results from the three different stream temperature models are analyzed. This study complements existing studies to improve our understanding of the performance of different stream temperature models in different river basins.

How to cite: Duan, Z., Duggan, E., Tuo, Y., Li, Y., Dong, J., Liu, J., and Gao, H.: Modelling stream temperature with multiple hydroclimatological temperature models, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13198, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13198, 2022.

EGU22-13347 | Presentations | HS2.3.1

Local determination of constituent's decay coefficients for river water quality modelling considering the catchment scale 

José Rodolfo Scarati Martins, Lais Amorim, Fabio Nogueira, Ariel Magalhães, and Barbara Duarte

Modelling water quality of polluted heavy loaded water courses as those crossing highly urbanized catchment areas are a complex task that involves several processes based on coefficients like unit loads, decay rates and self-depuration effects among others. The fate of pollutants as organic matter and nutrients are usually done through transport equations added by sourcing and sinking terms that implies the use of decay factors. The so-called k’s coefficients are present in the literature and were derived from typical water samples that don’t represent the local conditions founded in the urban rivers, usually affected by the catchment scale. This article presents an approach method used for local determination of the k’s coefficient for Biological Oxygen Demand (BOD-k1), Atmospheric Reaeration (AR-k2) and Sediment Oxygen Demand (SOD-k4) and compares results to typical adopted values bye modelists. The approach is based on local waters and sediment laboratory tests adjusted to consider specific driving forces as water temperature, constituent concentration and flow turbulence. Considering the catchment area (286 km²) and the river reach (25 km long) 4 sampling stations were defined to collect depth integrated water samples and the bed material. The k1 coefficient is the most sensible one due to the influence of the biological components and the relation between labile and refractory fractions, that varies along the reach with the contribution from the sub catchments’ land use and sanitary infrastructure. Considering Fujimoto’s and Thomas’ equations, different values of local dependent k1 were found. For k2, the concept of river shear stress velocity was applied to correlate the oxygen mass transferred to the water in the JAR test run for the observed range of velocity gradients in the natural flow. Results lead to a more realistic air entrainment rate due to hydraulic, superficial tension and presence of oils and greases. The SOD-k4 were determined after bottom sediment samples collected in the same defined stations for 3 different concentrations in clean water. The continuous oxygen demand for each sample was taken hourly in the first day and daily in the next 5, and then converted to the Toro’s active sediment layer demand considering local porosity and specific weight. Results showed considerably lower than the typical values referenced in the literature for all k’s, denoting the influence of the above-mentioned characteristics and the level of uncertainties that could affect modelling results when non-local parameters are employed.

How to cite: Scarati Martins, J. R., Amorim, L., Nogueira, F., Magalhães, A., and Duarte, B.: Local determination of constituent's decay coefficients for river water quality modelling considering the catchment scale, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13347, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13347, 2022.

EGU22-40 | Presentations | HS2.3.2

High-resolution DOC measurements indicate seasonal differences of the contribution of sub-catchments to DOC export 

Katharina Blaurock, Benjamin S. Gilfedder, Jan H. Fleckenstein, Stefan Peiffer, and Luisa Hopp

Dissolved organic carbon (DOC) is an important link between the terrestrial and aquatic carbon cycle. With regard to climate change, it is important to quantify DOC export from catchments as accurately as possible.  The goal of our study was to investigate the influence of topography on DOC export during different seasons.

We investigated DOC export in a small, forested headwater catchment in the Bavarian Forest National Park, Germany. From April 2020 until June 2021, we measured in-stream DOC concentrations at a 15 minutes interval at three nested sub-catchments using UV-Vis spectrometry. We compared DOC export between the different seasons (winter, snowmelt, wet early summer, wet autumn) and the different locations (two upper steep sub-catchments, one lower flat catchment).

Our results show that DOC export varied strongly between seasons. Whereas DOC export was only 2.3  – 2.7 kg/day/km2 on average in all sub-catchments during winter, it increased to 15.6 – 28.8 kg/day/km2 during the rainy early summer. Snowmelt also contributed to DOC export with 14.9 – 18.7 kg/day/km2 on average and was therefore almost as important as precipitation events in early summer and autumn. During winter and snowmelt, all sub-catchments contributed proportionally to total DOC export compared to their area. However, during the rainy seasons, the upper sub-catchments gained in relative importance leading to a disproportional contribution to total DOC export.

Our high-resolution data allowed us to obtain detailed quantities of DOC export over a long period covering different hydrological seasons. These numbers can help us to better understand the importance of DOC export during different seasons. Moreover, our results show that DOC export can vary strongly between small sub-catchments due to the importance of different hydrological processes. This finding is especially relevant as the number of drought periods and extreme rain events will increase and therefore not only influence the distribution of DOC export during the year but also have an impact on the contribution of different sub-catchments.

How to cite: Blaurock, K., Gilfedder, B. S., Fleckenstein, J. H., Peiffer, S., and Hopp, L.: High-resolution DOC measurements indicate seasonal differences of the contribution of sub-catchments to DOC export, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-40, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-40, 2022.

EGU22-341 | Presentations | HS2.3.2

Water quality and metabolism dynamics in a lowland urban Mediterranean stream 

zafrir adar, Noam Yogev, and Shai Arnon

The classification of metabolic regimes in aquatic ecosystems is based on gross primary production (GPP) and ecosystem respiration (ER). A recent advancement in sensor technology and modeling capabilities has enabled the metabolic regimes classification to be applied also to stream ecosystems. Current information about stream metabolism exists mostly for temperate climate while data in semi-arid and urban environments remain scarce. In this study, we used long-term high-frequency measurements of water quality parameters in the Yarkon Stream (Israel) to study the dynamics of water quality and metabolic regimes. The Yarkon is a lowland, urban, Mediterranean stream in which about 75% of the discharge consist of tertiary level treated wastewater. A multi-sensor monitoring station was installed in 2019 and includes sensors for measuring turbidity, carbon dioxide, electrical conductivity, nitrate, dissolved oxygen (DO), water level, temperature, and pH. In addition, photosynthetically active radiation (PAR) is measured near the stream. Real-time data can be accessed in the following link: https://tinyurl.com/Yarkon-public-view. Results show a very strong impact of seasonal floods on water quality, however, the stream returns back to pre-flood conditions relatively quickly due to the weak link between the stream and the subsurface. First floods of the winter also exhibit a strong hypoxic response due to the flush of contaminants that are accumulated during the long dry summer. Only weak seasonal patterns were observed in water quality as a result of the dominant fraction of treated wastewater relative to the freshwater in the stream, and the relatively low in-stream nutrient transformations. Preliminary results also show that a clear diurnal cycle in oxygen concentrations is not clearly visible throughout the year. GPP exhibits low values throughout the year, with slightly higher values during spring and summer. The average annual net ecosystem production (NEP) is negative because ER is much higher than GPP throughout the year. The long-term data from the Yarkon Stream provides an insight into the dynamics in water quality and stream metabolism of an urban Mediterranean stream ecosystem and allows to compare the dynamic behavior to streams from temperate climates.

 

How to cite: adar, Z., Yogev, N., and Arnon, S.: Water quality and metabolism dynamics in a lowland urban Mediterranean stream, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-341, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-341, 2022.

EGU22-605 | Presentations | HS2.3.2

Story continued: The Lagged Rejuvenation Phenomenon at the Krycklan catchment - 49 new samples reveal groundwater flow patterns and hydrological connectivity 

Tamara Kolbe, Jean Marçais, Virginie Vergnaud, Barbara Yvard, and Kevin Bishop

The distribution of groundwater ages in aquifers is a key indicator for flow processes, solute transport and biogeochemical reactions. A lagged rejuvenation of groundwater ages has been observed at a 0.47 km2 subcatchment of the Krycklan catchment in 20171. Chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs) were measured in 9 wells at different depths located close to the stream and revealed an overall representative age stratification for the subcatchment. Immediately below the water table at 1-2 meters depth, groundwater was already 30 years old. This lag in rejuvenation was successfully modeled on the assumption that it was caused by seepage flow of groundwater in the subsurface discharge zone that evolves along the interface between two soil types with different hydraulic permeability. The comparison of the observed groundwater age stratification with a simple analytical approximation shows that the lag in rejuvenation is an indicator for the extent of the subsurface discharge zone and the vertical gradient for the overall aquifer recharge.

To test this hypothesis a second sampling campaign in 2021 was performed. CFCs were measured in 49 sampling locations at different depths and distances to the stream within the subcatchment and neighboring subcatchment.  CFC-based groundwater ages show the extent of the subsurface discharge zone and reveal groundwater flow patterns. This study provides further information on the hydrological connectivity of groundwater in the hydrological cycle. 

 

References:

1Kolbe, T, Marçais, J, de Dreuzy, J-R, Labasque, T, Bishop, K. Lagged rejuvenation of groundwater indicates internal flow structures and hydrological connectivity. Hydrological Processes. 2020; 34: 2176– 2189. https://doi.org/10.1002/hyp.13753

 

How to cite: Kolbe, T., Marçais, J., Vergnaud, V., Yvard, B., and Bishop, K.: Story continued: The Lagged Rejuvenation Phenomenon at the Krycklan catchment - 49 new samples reveal groundwater flow patterns and hydrological connectivity, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-605, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-605, 2022.

EGU22-768 | Presentations | HS2.3.2

Combining residence time and isotopic tracers to better understand  groundwater reservoir and flows in a karst thermal aquifer 

Coralie Ranchoux, Bernard Ladouche, Véronique De Montety, Jean-Luc Seidel, and Christelle Batiot-Guilhe

Karst hydrosystems are complex systems but often undergo high anthropogenic pressure on their water resources in Mediterranean area since it is shared by many actors. The addition of thermal and/or marine components in these systems makes the interpretation of classical methods more difficult. The thermal karst aquifer of Thau Basin (South of France) illustrates well the complexity of such underpressured karst hydrosystems. In the Balaruc-les-Bains area, groundwater results from the convergence and mixing of (i) young and cold karst water, (ii) old, hot and mineralized thermal water and (ii) marine water (Thau Lagoon and/or seawater). In the framework of the Dem'Eaux Thau CPER/FEDER project (2017-2022), we propose to combine tracers of water-rock interaction processes (Sr, Li) and residence time tracers (4He, 14C, 36Cl) to better understand the origin and mean residence times of flow that takes place in the system, with a focus on the thermal water. In particular, the originality of this work was to constraint geological and hydrogeological informations using natural tracers and to calibrate He dating using 14C ages.

The combination of Si geothermometer and isotopic Sr signature (87Sr/86Sr) indicates that the thermal reservoir is located in the Jurrassic carbonate formation until 2000m depth. In addition Li concentrations show the existence of deep flows from granitic bed-rock. These new geochemical results allowed to better constraint the location of the thermal reservoir on the geological 3D map of the area and points out the major role of a local fault. However, there is significant uncertainty on the porosities of this reservoir impacting He age dating method. We used Carbon-14 dating in a deep karst well to constrain 4He ages and therefore determine the reservoir porosity. In parallel, the identification and quantification of the thermal flux by Li concentrations, allowed us to correct the 4He concentrations, and to propose a residence time of the thermal water of several thousands of years (10 000 to 50 000 years) which were consistent with the 36Cl results. Thermal water subsequently feed a shallow reservoir (100 – 300 m) through local fractures and mix with variable proportions of recent karst flows. 

How to cite: Ranchoux, C., Ladouche, B., De Montety, V., Seidel, J.-L., and Batiot-Guilhe, C.: Combining residence time and isotopic tracers to better understand  groundwater reservoir and flows in a karst thermal aquifer, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-768, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-768, 2022.

Anthropogenic nutrient inputs have led to nutrient enrichment in many waterbodies worldwide, including Chesapeake Bay (USA). River water quality integrates the spatial and temporal changes of watersheds and forms the foundation for disentangling the effects of anthropogenic inputs. We demonstrate with the Chesapeake Bay Non-Tidal Monitoring Network that machine learning approaches – i.e., hierarchical clustering and random forest – can be combined to better understand the regional patterns and drivers of total nitrogen (TN) trends in large monitoring networks. Cluster analysis revealed regional patterns of short-term TN trends (2007-2018) and categorized the stations into three distinct clusters, namely, V-shape (n = 23), monotonic decline (n = 35), and monotonic increase (n = 26). Random forest models were developed to predict the clusters using watershed characteristics and major N sources, providing information on regional drivers of TN trends. Results show encouraging evidence that improved agricultural nutrient management has contributed to water-quality improvement. Moreover, water-quality improvements are more likely in watersheds underlain by carbonate rocks, reflecting the relatively quick groundwater transport. By contrast, water-quality improvements are less likely in Coastal Plain watersheds, reflecting the effect of legacy N in groundwater. Notably, TN trends are degrading in forested watersheds, suggesting new and/or remobilized sources that may compromise management efforts. Finally, the developed random forest models were used to predict TN trend clusters for the entire Chesapeake watershed at the scale of river segments (n = 979), providing fine-level information that can facilitate targeted watershed management, especially in unmonitored areas. More broadly, this combined use of clustering and classification approaches can be applied to other monitoring networks to address similar questions.

 

How to cite: Zhang, Q., Bostic, J., and Sabo, R.: Regional patterns and drivers of total nitrogen trends in the Chesapeake Bay watershed: Insights from machine learning approaches and management implications, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-962, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-962, 2022.

EGU22-1712 | Presentations | HS2.3.2

Evaluation of a state-wide drainage monitoring in Mecklenburg-Vorpommern using artificial intelligence methods 

Jörg Steidl, Gunar Lischeid, Clemens Engelke, and Franka Koch

One challenge for modern agricultural management systems is to reduce their detrimental effects on water quality of water bodies. With this in mind, monitoring was carried out on behalf of the State Agency for Environment, Nature Conservation and Geology Mecklenburg-Vorpommern in the drainage outlets of 19 arable fields distributed throughout the state. In long-term measurement campaigns, runoff and substance concentration were determined at the drainage outlets. As expected with intensive arable land use, the nitrogen concentrations of most samples were far above the current quality standards and target values for surface waters according to the Surface Water Ordinance. Phosphorus concentrations were also generally very high. In parallel to the measurements, extensive data on agricultural management were collected and then correlated, together with pedological and meteorological data, with the temporal dynamics and spatial patterns of substance concentrations in drainage runoff. After selection and processing, 1037 data sets with 19 measured variables were available for the analyses.

These data were first subjected to a principal component analysis. The first seven principal components were each assigned to specific effects. The values of the principal components were interpreted as quantitative measures of the strength of the expression of these effects in the individual water samples. These were then placed in relation to extensive meteorological, hydrological, soil and management data. Classical correlation analyses revealed a bewildering variety of significant effects. Using random forest models, however, it was possible to map a large part of the observed spatial and temporal variance with just a few explanatory variables in each case.

The temporal dynamics of the nutrient concentrations in the outlet of the drains were mainly determined by hydrological conditions and weather. In contrast, direct short-term effects of individual arable farming measures on nutrient dynamics in the drainages could not be identified. Instead, clear indications of long-term effects of agriculture were found. In particular, the nitrogen and phosphorus balances of the areas played a decisive role. Soil recovery from long-term fertilisation thus does not seem to be achievable either through minor changes in agricultural management or in the short term.

Furthermore, it was shown that the many years of intensive use of the land had a massive impact not only on the nitrogen and phosphorus contents, but also on almost all other substances studied. Nitrogen and phosphorous data alone can only provide limited information on the source and development of soil eutrophication. This is still given too little attention in studies on the substance balance of agriculturally used land.

How to cite: Steidl, J., Lischeid, G., Engelke, C., and Koch, F.: Evaluation of a state-wide drainage monitoring in Mecklenburg-Vorpommern using artificial intelligence methods, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1712, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1712, 2022.

EGU22-1738 | Presentations | HS2.3.2

A multi-method and multi-model approach for predicting spatio-temporal patterns of sap flow, xylem isotopic composition, and water ages in the critical zone 

Julian Klaus, Kwok Pan Chun, Ginevra Fabiani, Maëlle Fresne, Markus Hrachowitz, Kevin McGuire, Adnan Moussa, Daniele Penna, Laurent Pfister, Nicolas Rodriguez, Remy Schoppach, Mauro Sulis, and Erwin Zehe

Vegetation exhibits critical feedback with runoff generation. Trees show distinct water uptake patterns relying on soil water from different depths and groundwater with a mixture of water sources that is commonly very different from runoff in terms of age distribution and isotopic composition. Here we present a multi-method and multi-model approach to study the spatio-temporal patterns of sap flow and age distribution of tree water uptake and streamflow in a headwater catchment (mixed forest, 43 ha). For this, we monitored sap flow spatially distributed at >30 trees over two years, sampled 2H and 18O bi-weekly and spatially distributed in xylem for two years and in streamflow sub-daily for four years. This was supplemented by tritium sampling in streamflow over two years for different flow stages. We used statistical modeling to determine spatio-temporal patterns of transpiration and isotopic composition of xylem water and their drivers. We used a multi-model approach to derive catchment travel times through (i) composite Storage Selection (SAS) functions, (ii) conceptual hydrological modeling, and (iii) coupled land surface-subsurface modeling (ParflowCLM) combined with particle tracking. Statistical data analysis revealed that tree species, tree diameter, and topographic wetness index at the tree location were the main driver of spatial variability of sap flow, while soil water was the main source of xylem water with little groundwater influence. The travel time modeling showed a strong seasonal and event-based variability of travel times and allowed to include information on vegetation behavior with different complexity. Last, our detailed sampling of vegetation offers a blueprint for a sampling strategy of isotopes in xylem water for travel time studies. Our data revealed that approximately 20 sampled trees are sufficient to capture the mean isotopic value of xylem water of a species at our study site, while we needed around 100 samples to detect landscape influence on the xylem isotopes needed for considering spatial patterns in the travel time analysis. Our results underline the feedbacks between vegetation and runoff generation and show their relevance for better simulating catchment travel times.

How to cite: Klaus, J., Chun, K. P., Fabiani, G., Fresne, M., Hrachowitz, M., McGuire, K., Moussa, A., Penna, D., Pfister, L., Rodriguez, N., Schoppach, R., Sulis, M., and Zehe, E.: A multi-method and multi-model approach for predicting spatio-temporal patterns of sap flow, xylem isotopic composition, and water ages in the critical zone, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1738, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1738, 2022.

EGU22-2119 | Presentations | HS2.3.2

An attempt to bridge the gap between physical and conceptual hydrological models used for transit time determination 

Baibaswata Bhaduri, Sekhar Muddu, and Laurent Ruiz

Bottom-up catchment scale distributed hydrological transport models based on physical process descriptions improve our understanding of the hillslope scale in a physically consistent way. They allow for characterization of the flow domain as a multi-continuum, and are amenable to account for biogeochemical processes. However, these models are computationally expensive, and the spatial heterogeneity of the forcings and the boundary conditions are hard to render, which leads to ill posed inverse problems that adversely affect their predictive skill and convenience in real world applications (Hrachowitz et al., 2016).

On the other hand, flexible lumped or semi-distributed modelling approaches based on interplay of conceptual stores have proven their worth in reproducing hydrological responses despite their simplicity. The physical basis of these models is however not well understood – they differentiate between the timescales of hydrological response (governed by wave celerity arising from pressure diffusion) and water quality response (governed by flow velocity and solute dispersion) using passive mixing volumes with zero hydraulic pressure. Being depth based, they’re not scalable either. Conceptual models are thus mostly suitable for inverse modelling to compare relatable conceptual parameters in similar catchments.

In this study, we attempted to bridge the gap between these 2 different ideologies for groundwater flow and transport by building a semi-distributed grid-based model which discretizes a catchment based on its hydrodynamic dispersivity. The flow part was based on the concept of Mean Action Times along hillslopes (Simpson et al., 2013) and the transport part was based on solving the pore-scale advection dispersion equation by discretizing the domain as a series of well-mixed reactors to mimic the optimal behavior between the extremes of complete segregation and maximum mixedness for a given catchment. We verified the model with FEFLOW for a synthetic homogenous unconfined aquifer for unsteady flow and in the process established mathematical relationships between physical and conceptual parameters for groundwater flow and solute transport. We then applied the same framework to Kerrien, an agricultural and groundwater dominated headwater catchment located in the French Critical Zone Observatory of Brittany and gained insights on the sensitivity of different parameters on solute breakthrough behavior and transit time.

 

 

 

Ref:

Hrachowitz, M., Benettin, P., Van Breukelen, B. M., Fovet, O., Howden, N. J., Ruiz, L., ... & Wade, A. J. (2016). Transit times—The link between hydrology and water quality at the catchment scale. Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Water3(5), 629-657.

Simpson, M. J., Jazaei, F., & Clement, T. P. (2013). How long does it take for aquifer recharge or aquifer discharge processes to reach steady state? Journal of Hydrology501, 241-248.

How to cite: Bhaduri, B., Muddu, S., and Ruiz, L.: An attempt to bridge the gap between physical and conceptual hydrological models used for transit time determination, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2119, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2119, 2022.

EGU22-2340 | Presentations | HS2.3.2 | Highlight

Drivers of multi-decadal in-stream nitrate regime shifts in a large European catchment 

Alexander Wachholz, James W Jawitz, Olaf Büttner, Seifeddine Jomaa, Ralf Merz, Soohyun Yang, and Dietrich Borchardt

Long-term monitoring shows evidence of persistent changes in the magnitude and timing of the seasonal pattern and C-Q relations of nitrate concentrations in rivers, with possibly grave effects on aquatic ecosystems. Seasonal patterns of riverine nutrient concentrations are driven by a complex interplay of inputs, transport, and in-stream processing. Over multi-decadal periods, each of these factors may change due to socio-economic factors such as consumption patterns, governance regimes, or technological control measures. Here we test the hypothesis that observed multi-decadal changes in stream nitrate seasonality could be explained by changes in the relative importance of catchment nutrient sources over time. We analyze 66 years of shifting nitrate seasonality in a large, central-European river (Elbe) during a period of significant socio-political changes (1954 to 2019), with correspondingly significant changes in the sources of anthropogenic nitrate emissions. We show that the in-stream nitrate seasonality of the River Elbe changed significantly from a weak seasonal pattern (chemostatic) with peak concentrations during summer in the 1950s to a strong seasonal pattern (chemodynamic) with peak concentrations during winter in the 1990s. We link these shifts to a succession of technical/ political developments which influence the contribution of point and diffuse sources over time. Such shifts in seasonal concentration patterns can significantly impact the macronutrient (carbon, nitrogen, phosphorus) ratios in rivers, which in turn highly affect the health of aquatic ecosystems.

How to cite: Wachholz, A., Jawitz, J. W., Büttner, O., Jomaa, S., Merz, R., Yang, S., and Borchardt, D.: Drivers of multi-decadal in-stream nitrate regime shifts in a large European catchment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2340, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2340, 2022.

EGU22-2392 | Presentations | HS2.3.2

The influence of landscape organized heterogeneity on riverine nitrate dynamics 

Rémi Dupas, Antoine Casquin, Patrick Durand, and Valérie Viaud

Landscape organized (or structured) heterogeneity is often assumed to influence hydrological and biogeochemical patterns across space and time. In this study, we quantified landscape organized heterogeneity with two indices describing the spatial configuration of nitrogen sources or sinks regarding 1) their hydrological distance to the nearest stream (i.e. upslope/downslope heterogeneity: in the lateral dimension) and 2) their hydrological distance to the outlet in the river network (i.e. upstream/downstream heterogeneity: in the longitudinal dimension). The nitrogen sources considered are agricultural fields, defined from interpretation of satellite images, and the sinks are riparian wetland, defined from a topoclimatic index. Using public nitrate concentration and discharge data from 180 catchments in western France (5-150km²), we tested whether landscape organized heterogeneity influenced riverine nitrate concentration and dynamics. The metrics computed to characterize nitrate concentration and dynamics were the flow-weighted concentration (FWNO3), the slope of the log(C)-log(Q) relationship (slope b) and the ratio of the coefficients of variation of concentration and discharge (CVratio). Results showed a high positive correlation between slope b and the CVratio, but no correlation between the later and FWNO3. 43% of the catchment exhibited a positive b slope, indicating maximum nitrate during the winter high flow period and 17% exhibited a negative b slope, indicating maximum nitrate during the summer/fall low flow period; the remaining 40% exhibited a near-zero slope. Landscape organized heterogeneity was larger in the lateral dimension for both nitrogen source and sinks than in the longitudinal dimension. In the lateral dimension, nitrogen sources were primarily located upslope and nitrate sinks downslope. In the longitudinal dimension, no general trend was observed for nitrogen sources and nitrate sinks were rather located upstream. Heterogeneity in the lateral dimension was highly variable among catchments for the smaller catchments and less variable for the larger ones. Heterogeneity in the longitudinal dimension did not exhibit a visible relationship with catchment size. No relationship was found between indices of landscape heterogeneity and FWNO3, arguably because other primary factors (such as the nitrogen surplus or runoff) control most of the regional variability in FWNO3. We found non-linear relationships between our indices of nitrogen sink organization and the b-slope or the CVratio, both in the lateral and longitudinal dimensions. The catchments with a negative b-slope (maximum nitrate during low-flow season) had their wetlands located more upstream and/or more upslope than the average. The relationship with nitrogen sources were opposite by construction (agricultural fields are often located outside wetland areas) but less clear. Further work is ongoing to explore the influence of landscape spatial organization on phosphorus concentration and dynamics.

How to cite: Dupas, R., Casquin, A., Durand, P., and Viaud, V.: The influence of landscape organized heterogeneity on riverine nitrate dynamics, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2392, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2392, 2022.

EGU22-2497 | Presentations | HS2.3.2

Water quality and trace metal concentrations of mine water in the Western Harz Mountains 

Mario Kolling, Elke Bozau, and Wilfried Ließmann

The tradition of mining in the Western Harz Mountains ranges from the Middle Ages to the 20th century. To evaluate the water-rock interactions as well as the environmental impact of trace metals, the mine water of three mining districts – Rammelsberg, St. Andreasberg and Clausthal-Zellerfeld – was investigated. The water samples were also analysed for the main ions. During the sampling campaigns pH-values and specific electrical conductivites (SEC) of the mine waters were measured. Compared to the most regions of Northern Germany, high precipitation rates (>850 mm/a) and a realatively low mineralisation of surface waters are found in the Upper Harz Mountains. The logging of temperature and SEC of spring and mine water over several months clearly showed that water mineralisation decreases with increasing precipitation rates (Bozau et al., 2017). The Devonian SEDEX deposit Rammelsberg is characterised by layer-bound ores and is famous for its non-ferrous metals. Acidification due to the oxidation of metal sulphides is rare. During the sampling campaigns only one sample of the Rammelsberg mine displayed a pH-value <3 (pH = 2.8). The majority of the measured pH-values ranges from 6.8 to 7.9. SEC values from 540 up to 2680 µS/cm were measured in the Rammelsberg mine. The adit "Ernst-August-Stollen" has a lenght of 40 km and is the biggest drainage tunnel of the mining district Clausthal-Zellerfeld. The portal of the adit is located in the triassic rocks of the Harz foreland, where SEC values from 980 to 1173 µS/cm and pH-values between 7.3 and 8.2 were measured. The SEC of the adit "Ernst-August-Stollen" ranges from 629 (inflow of the Kneseberg manhole) to 4710 µS/cm at the outflow of an oil separator into the main chanel (Bothe-Fiekert et al., 2021). The ICP-MS data of unfiltered and filtered (0.45 µm and 0.2 µm) water samples of this adit show that most of the iron (> 95 %) is transported as particulate fraction in the mine water. The mines of "St. Andreasberg" are situated on the highest elevations and receives the highest precipitation amount compared to the other two mining districts. The mine water of this area shows the lowest SEC values which range from 113 to 193 µS/cm and pH-values between 6.9 and 7.6. Due to the increased occurrence of Fe-Ni-Co arsenides in the St. Andreasberg gangue ore deposit and the association with antimony minerals, increased arsenic and antimony concentrations were observed in some water samples of this mining district. Although there are different and changing trace element concentrations in the single mines and adits, significant hydrochemical characteristics for the three mining districts are observed. Threshold limit values for drinking water were seldom exceeded during the investigations.

 

References:

Bothe-Fiekert, M., Bozau, E., Ließmann, W., 2021. Hydrogeochemical characteristics of an old mine adit in the Harz Mountains (Germany). Goldschmidt Virtual 2021.

Link: https://2021.goldschmidt.info/goldschmidt/2021/meetingapp.cgi/Paper/3614

Bozau, E., Licha, T., Ließmann, W., 2017. Hydrogeochemical characteristics of mine water in the Harz Mountains, Germany. Chemie der Erde 77 (2017), 614-624.

How to cite: Kolling, M., Bozau, E., and Ließmann, W.: Water quality and trace metal concentrations of mine water in the Western Harz Mountains, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2497, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2497, 2022.

EGU22-2540 | Presentations | HS2.3.2

Riparian zone control on catchment hydrology and biogeochemistry across European ecoregions 

José L. J. Ledesma, Andreas Musolff, Thomas Grabs, and Susana Bernal

The importance of riparian zones in shaping the hydrology and biogeochemistry of forest headwater catchments has been well-established in the last couple of decades. However, most studies rely on single catchment approaches or focus on a single ecoregion. Here, we present a multiple-site approach using data from four catchments located in four European ecoregions and encompassing a wide range of hydrological and biogeochemical conditions: the boreal Krycklan, the temperate Rappbode, the sub-humid Mediterranean Font del Regàs, and the semi-arid Mediterranean Fuirosos.

At long temporal scales, both climate and topography interrelate to determine the dominant source layer (DSL), i.e. the riparian zone depth stratum that contributes the most to water and solute fluxes to streams. Generally, shallower DSLs are found in wetter climates characterized by higher ratios of annual precipitation to potential evapotranspiration (e.g. boreal), but locally can occur in the flatter contributing areas defined by higher topographic wetness indexes. Riparian soils show large differences in carbon and nutrient content across ecoregions. Mediterranean riparian soils are characterized by lower organic matter content and small dissolved organic carbon (DOC) exports from deeper, mineral layers, resulting in overall lower stream DOC concentrations compared with the temperate and, especially, the boreal sites. On the other hand, the denitrification potential of the Mediterranean riparian zones, especially at the semi-arid site, is limited due to drier conditions that oxygenate the riparian soils and may even promote nitrification, resulting in higher stream nitrate (NO3-) concentrations compared to the boreal site. The denitrification potential of the temperate site is counterbalanced by a significantly higher nitrogen deposition compared to the other sites.

At the event scale, antecedent soil moisture conditions and associated hydrological connectivity within the catchments becomes an important factor defining solute export from riparian profiles and hysteresis patterns between riparian groundwater tables and stream discharge. Generally, the wetter conditions in the boreal site generate anticlockwise patterns between groundwater tables and discharge, indicating high catchment hydrological connectivity. Clockwise patterns are characteristic of the Mediterranean sites and imply low hydrological connectivity, except during very wet antecedent conditions. The temperate site is characterized by linear patterns and intermediate conditions. Solutes displaying relatively high concentrations in the riparian profile are generally transport limited, especially during events preceded by dry conditions, whereas source limitation occurs during events preceded by wet conditions, especially for solutes displaying relatively low concentrations.  

We highlight that multiple-site approaches can help identifying common patterns and differences in riparian hydrological and biogeochemical functions across ecoregions, as well as the factors driving these patterns and the resulting dynamics of stream water chemistry.

How to cite: Ledesma, J. L. J., Musolff, A., Grabs, T., and Bernal, S.: Riparian zone control on catchment hydrology and biogeochemistry across European ecoregions, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2540, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2540, 2022.

EGU22-3046 | Presentations | HS2.3.2

Integrating transpiration and xylem water stable isotopes in a process-based model to determine transpiration and discharge age distributions 

Maëlle Fresne, Kwok Pan Chun, Ginevra Fabiani, Markus Hrachowitz, Kevin McGuire, Adnan Moussa, Remy Schoppach, and Julian Klaus

Transpiration is an important component of the catchment water balance, and tree water uptake can significantly influence discharge dynamic and travel times. Tree usually use water of a different age than the water that generates discharge. Most hydrological models that track water age rely on discharge and stream water isotopes data for calibration. This calibrated age-tracking model enables to simulate time-variant discharge travel times. However, transpiration and related water isotopes data are rarely integrated. We currently lack understanding on the age distribution of transpiration and how discharge travel times relate to this age distribution. In this context, the objectives of this work are to 1) analyse spatio-temporal patterns of xylem water isotopes, 2) determine transpiration age distribution and investigate its temporal dynamic over two growing seasons and 3) evaluate how discharge travel times respond to changes in the transpiration age distribution. We determined the spatial controls on xylem water isotopes (δ18O and δ2H) and simulated travel times in discharge and transpiration in a forested catchment in Luxembourg. We used a lumped, process-based catchment model for water fluxes and tracer transport based on storage-age selection functions. Using discharge, transpiration, stream and xylem water δ2H measurements, the model was calibrated over a period of three years (October 2017-September 2020) by means of a Monte Carlo optimization and a multi-objectives approach. Preliminary results indicate that tree species and diameter are the main drivers of xylem water isotopes variation. Vegetation controls are especially dominant during a drier growing season while landscape variables (hillslope position, topographical position index, flow accumulation) appear to also control xylem water δ2H in wetter conditions. Investigations of transpiration and discharge age distributions will help to better understand how tree water uptake influences discharge travel times over the growing seasons. The spatial analysis of xylem water isotopes further provides a foundation for investigating the spatial variability of the transpiration age distribution. This study will also profit in assessing the value of transpiration and associated isotopes data for discharge travel times simulations and improving our current model representations of hydrological processes in forested catchments.

How to cite: Fresne, M., Chun, K. P., Fabiani, G., Hrachowitz, M., McGuire, K., Moussa, A., Schoppach, R., and Klaus, J.: Integrating transpiration and xylem water stable isotopes in a process-based model to determine transpiration and discharge age distributions, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3046, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3046, 2022.

EGU22-3390 | Presentations | HS2.3.2

Assessment of agricultural nitrogen pressures and legacies in Denmar 

Jørgen Windolf, Henrik Tornbjerg, Gitte Blicher-Mathiesen, and Brian Kronvang

The links between nitrate-nitrogen (N) leaching from agricultural fields and N measured in streams can in general terms be divided in two pathways: groundwater and a more surface-near transport (e.g. tile drains).  The former with a typical slower hydrological response than the latter.  Therefore, catchments with quick hydrologic pathways respond also quickly on programme of measures for N. On the other hand, catchments having bot high N-attenuation or longer N time lags makes it complicated for managers and policy makers as the response of the implemented programme of measures might both be dampened and delayed. As River Basin Management Plans (RBMPs) under the Water Framework Directive (WFD) runs in 6 years periods – such time lags might end up as an overdosing of measures. Therefore, attenuation and time lags needs to be mapped as they have major effects on the expected effects of RBMPs and its legacy for water quality. The aim of this study is to improve our understanding of N lags mapped based on 30 years of data from 160 Danish stream monitoring stations.

A national wide screening for trends in annual flow-weighted total nitrogen (TN) concentrations at 163 river monitoring stations shows in most cases a downward trend (average: 30% ± 17%) during the last 30 years 1990-2019). The N-surplus has been reduced (farm gate: -44%; field:  -45%) during the same period. Before 1990, the N-surplus in agriculture was increasing and started at first levelling off in the mid 1980ies. Diffuse N-sources and mostly agriculture contributed the most to TN in streams (93% ±8%) during the period 1990-2019). The reduction in the diffuse N loadings are paralleling the development of the N surplus for most Danish streams. However, in certain parts of Denmark several river monitoring stations shows a much different response, which in some cases is no response at all. Such a pattern can only be explained by N-flows in the catchments to be delayed in groundwater aquifers. Using long term data for national N-surplus a simple lag-time analysis shows that the time lags for N are long for 21 catchments (up to 20 years), medium long for N in 62 catchments and with nearly no delay for N in 80 catchments (Fig. 1). Moreover, all the stream stations experiencing long time lags are situated in the chalk and partly karstic landscapes of Denmark from the Danien period. The catchments having long delays for N shows in most cases also a very low attenuation of N in groundwater as measured N-concentrations are substantially higher than found in the streams having nearly no time lags. Therefore, we conclude that incorporation of biogeochemical and hydrologic time lag principles into water quality regulations will be necessary for providing managers and regulators with realistic expectations when implementing new policies for N.

Figure 1: Map of Denmark showing catchments with short (< 20% older than 10 years), medium (20-40 % older than 10 years) and long (> 40% older than 10 years) for nitrogen in groundwater.

How to cite: Windolf, J., Tornbjerg, H., Blicher-Mathiesen, G., and Kronvang, B.: Assessment of agricultural nitrogen pressures and legacies in Denmar, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3390, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3390, 2022.

EGU22-3439 | Presentations | HS2.3.2

Flow and residence time in a laboratory aquifer recharged by rainfall 

Eric Lajeunesse, Olivier Devauchelle, Valentin Jules, Adrien Guérin, Claude Jaupart, and Pierre-Yves Lagrée

During rainfall, water infiltrates the soil, and percolates through the unsaturated zone until it reaches the water table. Groundwater then flows through the aquifer, and eventually emerges into streams to feed surface runoff. We reproduce this process in a  two-dimensional laboratory aquifer recharged by artificial rainfall (Fig. 1). As rainwater infiltrates, it forms a body of groundwater which can exit the aquifer only through one of its sides. The outlet is located high above the base of the aquifer, and drives the flow upwards. The resulting vertical flow component violates the Dupuit-Boussinesq approximation. In this configuration, the velocity potential that drives the flow obeys the Laplace equation, the solution of which crucially depends on the boundary conditions. Noting that the water table barely deviates from the horizontal, we linearize the boundary condition at the free surface, and solve the flow equations in steady state. We derive an expression for the velocity potential, which accounts for the shape of the experimental streamlines and for the propagation rate of tracers through the aquifer  (Fig. 1). This theory allows us to calculate the travel times of tracers through the experimental aquifer, which are in agreement with the observations. The travel time distribution has an exponential tail, with a characteristic time that depends on the aspect ratio of the aquifer. This distribution depends essentially on the geometry of the groundwater flow, and is weakly sensitive to the hydrodynamic dispersion that occurs at the pore scale.

 

Figure 1 : Streamlines in a laboratory aquifer recharged by artificial rainfall. Flow is from left to right. The streamlines converge towards the aquifer outlet, in the upper right corner of the picture.

How to cite: Lajeunesse, E., Devauchelle, O., Jules, V., Guérin, A., Jaupart, C., and Lagrée, P.-Y.: Flow and residence time in a laboratory aquifer recharged by rainfall, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3439, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3439, 2022.

EGU22-4898 | Presentations | HS2.3.2

Evaluating the added value of young water fractions for determining water transit times in diverse catchments 

Arianna Borriero, Rohini Kumar, Tam Nguyen, Jan Fleckenstein, and Stefanie Lutz

Water transit time distributions (TTDs) are important descriptors of hydrological functioning and solute mobilization in catchments. The use of transport models based on StorAge Selection (SAS) functions is promising for characterizing non-stationary TTDs. Model parameters are typically calibrated using tracer concentration in inflow (e.g., precipitation) and outflow (e.g., streamflow) in order to obtain suitable values of SAS function parameters and, thereby, simulate TTDs at catchment-scale. However, due to uncertainties in tracer data and equifinality problems in SAS modelling, modeled TTDs can be subject to considerable uncertainty. Therefore, we need alternative and independent methods that can help constrain model parameters. An example is the young water fraction (Fyw), which quantifies the proportion of catchment outflow younger than approximately 2–3 months. Our work attempts to explore the robustness of Fyw in constraining SAS model parameter values and, in turn, reducing predictive uncertainty of TTDs in multiple contrasting sub-catchments in the Central European Bode River Basin. We simulated TTDs using sparse (i.e., monthly) stable water isotope data (δ¹⁸O) in streamflow for calibration in an experimental SAS modelling framework. In a subsequent step, we directly compared the model estimates of long-term average (marginal) TTDs with Fyw derived from the seasonal cycles of δ¹⁸O measured in precipitation and streamflow. Our results showcase if and to what extent Fyw is a valuable additional constraint to infer SAS parametrizations as well as improve TTD predictions and the characterization of water age selection dynamics, and identify potentials and gaps in isotope-based TTD models. Our results also show how the effectiveness of Fyw in reducing the predictive uncertainty of TTDs may depend on the water use by plants and land use change across physiographically different sub-catchments. Overall, as the relevance of Fyw in TTD modeling is not yet well established, our aim is to investigate whether additional indicators such as Fyw are useful for TTD modeling and thus allow improving the description of flow and transport in catchment areas, especially in situations where a high-resolution tracer data are lacking.

How to cite: Borriero, A., Kumar, R., Nguyen, T., Fleckenstein, J., and Lutz, S.: Evaluating the added value of young water fractions for determining water transit times in diverse catchments, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4898, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4898, 2022.

EGU22-4932 | Presentations | HS2.3.2

Combined Use Of 3H/3He Apparent Age And On‐Site Helium Analysis To Identify Groundwater Flow Dynamics And Transport Of PCE 

Christian Moeck, Andrea Popp, Matthias Brennwald, Rolf Kipfer, and Mario Schirmer

3H and tritiogenic 3He concentrations and their interpretation as  3H/3He apparent water ages have been proven to offer crucial insights on groundwater flow and transport processes. However, the analysis is expensive as well as labor‐ and time‐intensive. Recent developments of portable field‐operated gas equilibrium membrane inlet mass spectrometer (GE‐MIMS) systems provide however, a unique opportunity to measure relatively fast dissolved gas concentrations, such as 4He, in groundwater systems with a high resolution at relatively low costs but they are not capable of providing an apparent age. However, 4He accumulation rates are often obtained from 3H/3He ages and it has been shown that non-atmospheric 4He concentrations determined in the laboratory (e.g., by static (noble gas) mass spectrometry) and by field-based (GE-MIMS) methods closely agree. This agreement allowed to quantify the local (radiogenic) 4He accumulation, e.g., we were able to establishing an inter‐relationship between 3H/3He apparent groundwater ages and the non-atmospheric 4He excess (e.g., calibrating the 4He excess in terms of residence time).

We demonstrate that the 4He excess concentrations derived from the GE‐MIMS system serve as adequate proxy for the experimentally demanding laboratory based analyses. The combined use of 3H/3He lab‐ based ages and calibrated  4He ages opens new opportunities for site characterization due to the measurements facilitated by the GE‐MIMS.

For our urban and contaminated study site, we combine groundwater ages with hydrochemical data, water isotopes (δ18O and δ2H), and perchloroethylene (PCE) concentrations (1) to identify spatial inter‐aquifer mixing between artificially infiltrated surface water and groundwater originating from regional flow paths and (2) to explain the spatial differences in PCE contamination. Moreover, for some wells, we identify fault‐induced aquifer connectivity as a preferential flow path for the transport of older groundwater, leading to elevated PCE concentrations.

How to cite: Moeck, C., Popp, A., Brennwald, M., Kipfer, R., and Schirmer, M.: Combined Use Of 3H/3He Apparent Age And On‐Site Helium Analysis To Identify Groundwater Flow Dynamics And Transport Of PCE, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4932, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4932, 2022.

Quantifying the transfer of organic carbon from the terrestrial to the riverine ecosystems is  of crucial importance to fully appreciate the carbon cycle at the catchment, regional and global scales. Specifically, the entity of dissolved organic carbon (DOC) fluctuations in streamflow is of particular interest also for their impact on the nutrient cycles and on water quality, with implications also for drinking water treatment. In this study, we propose a framework for modelling the flux of DOC from hillslopes to stream and river networks which couples a transport model based on water travel time distributions with the reactivity continuum theory to model DOC degradation. We test the model by applying it to the Plynlimon catchments (UK) exploiting both weekly and high-frequency (7-hour interval) time-series. Besides DOC concentration data, we use information about chloride to get an independent estimate of water travel times using the framework of StorAge Selection functions. The composition and the degradation of DOC along the flowpaths is described assuming a continuous spectrum of quality which initially follows a gamma distribution. Results show that, chiefly for high-frequency measurements, the model is able to reproduce reasonably well both chloride and DOC streamflow concentrations and to capture the complex hysteretic relation between DOC concentration and discharge. The distribution of the age of the water comprised in the streamflow proves thus a key variable to predict the quantity but also the quality of the DOC exported from soils, and the effect of hydrologic variability on this process. Starting from the proposed framework and the results obtained, we discuss how future developments could help in shedding light on the complex relations among carbon, water cycle and the metabolic balance of riverine ecosystems.

How to cite: Grandi, G. and Bertuzzo, E.: Catchment dissolved organic carbon transport: a modeling approach combining water travel times and reactivity continuum, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5100, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5100, 2022.

EGU22-5852 | Presentations | HS2.3.2 | Highlight

Water ages at the soil root interface and beyond 

Stefan Seeger and Markus Weiler

At the catchment scale, incoming precipitation is typically partitioned into runoff and evapotranspiration. Most transit time modeling approaches focus on the runoff part of the water balance and are consequently evaluated with respect to water ages in streamflow. Nevertheless, most modeling approaches also include a more or less detailed representation of evapotranspiration. In order to evaluate whether a modeling approach appropriately captures evapotranspiration and its water ages, it is important to understand what processes are required to be considered in the models. While evaporation from the soil and canopy surfaces is relatively easy to observe, transpiration involves root water uptake from a range of depths below the soil surface and water transport within plants. In addition, experimental data to evaluate transit time models are sampled in different organs and locations of plants.

We will present the results of studies dealing with the transit times of root water uptake (between precipitation and water uptake) and with transit times internally in trees (between water uptake at the root tips and transpiration at the leaves) in temperate forests. A novel in-situ measurement technique enabled us to measure stable water isotopes in the soil and within tree stem xylem with unprecedented temporal resolution and thereby enabled us to refine our understanding of plant water uptake and tree internal water transport. Based on our experimental observations, we developed a new approach to model water transport and hence water transit time internally in trees.

How to cite: Seeger, S. and Weiler, M.: Water ages at the soil root interface and beyond, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5852, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5852, 2022.

EGU22-7307 | Presentations | HS2.3.2

Understanding climate control and hydrological regulation of dissolved organic carbon concentration in a Mediterranean headwater catchment through long-term, high-frequency monitoring 

Alfonso Senatore, Giuseppina Anna Corrente, Eugenio Licio Argento, Massimo Micieli, Giuseppe Mendicino, Amerigo Beneduci, and Gianluca Botter

Inland waters can be interpreted as “active pipelines” in which the complex dissolved organic carbon (DOC) dynamics occur, eventually contributing to negative net ecosystem production. Hydrological factors highly contribute to the DOC balance at the reach scale. Seasonal and event-based hydrological variability, particularly in headwater streams, affects both stream-hillslope organic matter exchanges and overall fluvial network connectivity, leading to significant space and time changes in sources and processes regulating DOC. Technological advances allow fine and continuous time scale measurements of several physicochemical parameters with optical aquatic sensors, providing great potential for a better understanding of aquatic ecosystems functioning.

This study investigates the spatial and temporal dynamics of DOC concentration in a Mediterranean headwater catchment (Turbolo River catchment, southern Italy) equipped with two multiparameter sondes providing approximately 2.5 years (May 2019 to January 2022) of continuous high-frequency measurements of several chemical-physical variables, among which DOC-related parameters (fluorescent dissolved organic matter - fDOM, streamwater temperature and turbidity) at two different outlets. One sonde was installed in a quasi-pristine sub-catchment, while the other at the catchment outlet, characterized by some anthropogenic disturbances.

The specific features of the upslope sub-catchments were considered to address the connection between seasonal and hydrologic dynamics and DOC changes. Continuous observations were supported by meteo-hydrological observations and discrete monitoring carried out in the period January-April 2021 when 59 samples were collected on-field and analysed in the laboratory to achieve reference DOC values, used for an original correction method of measured fDOM values.

Results concern both the seasonal variability of background values and hydrological regulation of DOC export. Specifically, applying a Principal Component Analysis multivariate approach to the background values, seasonal clusters emerged with a clear temporal trajectory, highlighting similarities and differences among DOC and other measured parameters. Furthermore, DOC concentrations were positively correlated with discharge and even more with antecedent precipitation, reflecting the flushing effect of intense and prolonged precipitation. In both sites, the accumulated export of DOC for discharge values below the flow equalled or exceeded for 10% of the time (Q10) was lower than 35% of the total. Also, some differences in DOC concentration emerged between the two sites, with increased values with high flows in the catchment more affected by disturbances.

High-frequency monitoring proved to be a valuable tool to explain DOC dynamics at multiple time scales with a quantitative approach, highlighting the climate control and the hydrological regulation on DOC production and export.

How to cite: Senatore, A., Corrente, G. A., Argento, E. L., Micieli, M., Mendicino, G., Beneduci, A., and Botter, G.: Understanding climate control and hydrological regulation of dissolved organic carbon concentration in a Mediterranean headwater catchment through long-term, high-frequency monitoring, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7307, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7307, 2022.

EGU22-7347 | Presentations | HS2.3.2

Temporal variability of transit time distributions in response to climatic variability: do stable water isotopes and tritium tell the same tale? 

Siyuan Wang, Markus Hrachowitz, Gerrit Schoups, and Christine Stumpp

Transit time distributions (TTDs) of water moving through a catchment can be estimated using water isotope data. However, different isotopes are characterized by different information contents, which may affect the estimation of TTDs. Stable isotopes, such as 2H and 18O can provide insights into the part of TTDs that describes water ages of up to a few years. However, they are “blind” to ages older than that. Radioactive isotopes, such as tritium (3H), on the other hand, have been shown to describe old water, and thus the tails of TTDs much better. Direct comparisons of the different information contents and the resulting differences in catchment TTDs estimated from stable and radioactive isotopes are rare, mostly due to very limited data availability. The objectives of this study are therefore to quantify the differences in TTDs together with their temporal variability and sensitivity to climatic variability in multiple components of the hydrological system estimated from both tritium and stable isotopes using a distributed wise-process based model in the Neckar river basin in Germany. More specifically, we test the hypotheses that (1) stable isotope- and tritium-based estimates of TTDs exhibit significant differences for both young and old water ages, (2) they are characterized by distinct sensitivities to climatic variability, and that (3) combined use of stable isotopes and tritium results in more robust estimates of TTDs. The analysis is carried out based on long term hydrological (1958-2016) and isotope data (1990-2016), using a distributed hydrological model coupled with StorAge Selection (SAS) functions, which is simultaneously calibrated (and evaluated) with respect to multiple variables and hydrological signatures including, amongst others, streamflow, tritium, and stable isotope data.

How to cite: Wang, S., Hrachowitz, M., Schoups, G., and Stumpp, C.: Temporal variability of transit time distributions in response to climatic variability: do stable water isotopes and tritium tell the same tale?, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7347, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7347, 2022.

EGU22-7839 | Presentations | HS2.3.2 | Highlight

Suitability of Environmental Tracers as groundwater dating tools in the next decade 

Jürgen Sültenfuß

In the last decade a large and various set of groundwater modelling tools were developed and provide wide range of applications. In contrast, the number of tools for field studies remains limited. One of the tools are Environmental Tracers: substances of natural or anthropogenic origin which enter the groundwater system and were traced on their way to the discharge zone. Methods to interpret the tracer concentrations and how groundwater dynamics could be derived were published also in textbooks by now. One parameter to describe groundwater dynamics is residence time, age or flow velocity. All these terms are interchangeable.

Here, I will present an overview on applied Environmental Tracers to determine groundwater ages and assess their current limitation. Specially, I will make some predictions on the applicability for the near future. This includes some estimates about the concentration changes for the input of the tracers for younger groundwater and the consequences for reliability of the derived ages.

Also, I give an overview on the state of the measurement capacities and the possible development. It will be estimated how the analytical errors affect the ages. These constraints must be recognized for planning of field studies for groundwater age determination.

How to cite: Sültenfuß, J.: Suitability of Environmental Tracers as groundwater dating tools in the next decade, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7839, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7839, 2022.

The residence time of groundwater is an essential parameter for water resource management. In the presented study, environmental tracers (Rn-222, S-35, H-3, δ18O) and hydrogeochemical groundwater components are used for assessing groundwater mean residence times in a near surface aquifer.

At a barrage station at the River Moselle, four groundwater monitoring wells and two surface water spots were sampled at a 4-week interval over an 18-month period. At each sampling event, isotopes as well as other hydrogeochemical parameters (e.g. water level, water temperature, oxygen, pH value and electrical conductivity) were measured and evaluated.

All tracers showed different concentrations and signatures in ground- and surface water samples. As expected, Radon showed high concentrations in groundwater (up to 25 Bq/L) and low concentrations (about 0.2 Bq/L) in surface water. The tritium content of groundwater (13 Bq/L; ~110 TU) was similar to the long-term average concentration measured in surface water (~14 Bq/L); these comparatively high concentrations are way above the natural background concentration of about 1 Bq/L and result from the release of tritium from the French nuclear power plant Cattenom (situated about 250 km upstream of the sampling site). S-35, produced in the atmosphere and entering the hydrological cycle via precipitation, could be determined only once (January 2021) due to technical obstacles. The S-35 concentration measured in surface water (0.035 Bq/L) was about 4 times higher than the concentration in groundwater (0.0093 Bq/L). Finally, the median δ18O signature in surface water (-8.13 ‰) was similar to the signature found in groundwater (-7.78 ‰).

The selected isotopes and water parameters indicate that (i) the aquifer is predominantly recharged by surface water and (ii) the groundwater mean residence times varies between 5 and 6 months based on S-35 and δ18O.

Hence, it can be concluded that the selected isotopes are suitable as tracers for estimating groundwater mean residence times. However, further studies are needed, especially to minimize the time gap between the established tracers Radon (useful for up to 40 days) and tritium (useful from about one year). The novel tracer S-35 seems promising, but long-term data series of S-35 in surface and precipitation water are still missing to establish the necessary input functions.

How to cite: Schmidt, A., Engel, M., Mischel, S., and Radny, D.: Estimation of groundwater mean residence times in a near-surface aquifer using different natural tracers (Radon-222, Sulfur-35, Tritium, and δ18O), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8196, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8196, 2022.

Livestock are known to be one of the leading sources of nitrogen and other organic pollutant contents in surface waters. In response to growing demand for animal-source foods, livestock production has shifted into more high-input systems, accompanied by increased fertilizer and animal manure application rates to produce feed, which has resulted in large losses of nitrogen. The effects of nitrogen contamination of water bodies on human and ecosystem health are not limited and localized but have large-scale implications and are rapidly becoming widespread. However, current approaches to estimate the changes in stream water quality often fail to explicitly account for livestock activities across large spatial scales. To overcome this challenge, we adopted a data-driven approach and developed a spatio-temporal water quality model. Our model is based on a popular supervised machine learning technique, known as random forests, that can efficiently handle large, heterogeneous geo-environmental datasets. The model was trained using several site-level measurements and a large set of gridded environmental covariates to predict monthly nitrogen concentrations across the world. We then performed variable importance analysis on the proposed model to identify influential drivers of nitrogen variability at global scale. Our results confirmed the prominent role of livestock population and nitrogen fertilizer use in pollution of the river systems. Finally, we quantified how much livestock has contributed to nitrogen pollution in 115 major river basins of the world. We found that during 1992-2010 the average increase in nitrogen concentrations due to livestock was about 15% globally. Importantly, model results also indicate that at some large basins livestock population is responsible for more than 50% of raise in the levels of nitrogen. These regions point to the global livestock ‘‘hot spots’’ where high nitrogen loading to waterways may be expected. The results and insights gained in this study can have important implications for better management of livestock faming systems and pollution control policies.

How to cite: Sheikholeslami, R. and Hall, J.: The role of livestock in nitrogen pollution of large river basins: A machine learning-based assessment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8223, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8223, 2022.

EGU22-8455 | Presentations | HS2.3.2

High-frequency, multi-elemental stream concentration timeseries as a tool for catchment flowpath identification 

Nicolai Brekenfeld, Ophélie Fovet, Arnaud Blanchouin, Laure Cordier, Solenn Cotel, Mikaël Faucheux, Paul Floury, Colin Fourtet, Yannick Hamon, Hocine Henine, Patrice Petitjean, Anne-Catherine Pierson-Wickman, Marie-Claire Pierret, and Jérôme Gaillardet

Stream water chemistry at catchment outlets is commonly used to infer the flowpaths of water through the catchment and to quantify the relative contributions of various flowpaths. High-frequency and multi-elemental timeseries could shed light on the dynamic activation/deactivation and the changing relative contributions of different flowpaths during storm events or diel cycles in summer. Here, we present multi-year, high-frequency (< 60 minutes) timeseries of the major cations and anions from the outlet of three small (0.8 – 40 km²) french catchments with contrasting land-use (forest, field crops and mixed farming-cropping productions). Instead of analysing the concentration dynamics of individual elements, we use elemental ratios in order to identify the contrasting temporal variations of different elements during storm events. We try to link the dynamics of the elemental ratios to specific flowpaths, constrained by the processes likely to modify the ratios. Then, we compare the inferred flowpath contributions with our perceptual understandings of the three catchments. These findings contribute to our understanding of dynamic flowpath activation in catchments and the value of high-frequency, multi-elemental stream concentration timeseries.

How to cite: Brekenfeld, N., Fovet, O., Blanchouin, A., Cordier, L., Cotel, S., Faucheux, M., Floury, P., Fourtet, C., Hamon, Y., Henine, H., Petitjean, P., Pierson-Wickman, A.-C., Pierret, M.-C., and Gaillardet, J.: High-frequency, multi-elemental stream concentration timeseries as a tool for catchment flowpath identification, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8455, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8455, 2022.

Catchment hydrologists have long puzzled over the question: How can catchments rapidly generate storm flows in response to storm events? That question is complex because changes in stream water chemistry during storms suggest that proportions of old (or pre-event) water and new (or event) water also change during the storm. Conceptual models viewing catchments as composed of discrete source areas generating flow at unique time scales and with unique chemical characteristics have been used to explain the observed changes in flow and water chemistry. Surprisingly, those conceptual models usually do not treat the stream channel as one of the potential source areas. Here, we propose the channel source hypothesis in which the stream itself should be considered as a potential source with the same rigor as other contributing areas. We pose this in the spirit of the scientific use of the word: a hypothesis[1] is not a proven idea but rather a provisional supposition serving as the basis for further study. We suggest that the channel should be considered as a potential source for dissolved organic carbon (DOC). Channels store substantial amounts of organic matter, and stream ecologists have long studied stream carbon cycling. From those studies we know that leaching and decomposition can generate DOC from particulate organic carbon (POC). Further, POC is stored in channel “dead-zones” - regions of low flow velocity - that can be activated as flow velocity increases, thus releasing accumulated DOC during storms. All catchments are different; there is no reason to assume that channel sources are always important, in every catchment, in every storm. Thus, the channel source hypothesis does not replace existing conceptual models. Instead, it adds another potential mechanism that may explain DOC dynamics observed in streams. The channel source hypothesis has substantial implications for catchment studies examining sources of DOC in stream water or using DOC as a tracer to determine the locations of, and proportional contributions of, different source areas for streamflow generation.


[1] Hypothesis: "a provisional supposition from which to draw conclusions that shall be in accordance with known facts and serves as a starting point for further investigation by which it may be proved or disproved and the true theory arrived at" quoted from the Oxford English Dictionary (OED), 1985.

.

How to cite: Ward, A. and Wondzell, S.: The Channel Source Hypothesis: Empirical Evidence for In-Channel Sourcing of Dissolved Organic Carbon to Explain Hysteresis in a Headwater Mountain Stream, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11739, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11739, 2022.

EGU22-11933 | Presentations | HS2.3.2

Can runoff event types explain some scatter in nitrate C-Q relationships? 

Felipe Saavedra, Andreas Musolff, Jana Von Freyberg, Ralf Merz, Stefano Basso, and Larisa Tarasova

Nitrate contamination of rivers from agricultural sources, is a challenging problem for water quality management. The relationship between solute concentrations and streamflow rates (C-Q) observed at catchment outlets provide useful information on hydrological functioning and biogeochemical transformations at catchment scale. Nevertheless, nitrate C-Q relationships (linear regression in log space) often exhibit a considerable scatter. 

 

During runoff events, different nitrate transport paths within the catchment might be activated, generating a variety of responses in nitrate concentration. We hypothesize that the differences in characteristics of runoff events, such as different portions of rainfall and snowmelt contributions or antecedent wetness states, can explain some observed scatter in long-term C-Q relationships of nitrate.

 

To investigate this hypothesis, we analyzed low frequency nitrate data from 184 German catchments during different types of runoff events and quantified the deviations of the C-Q relationship for different event types. First, we computed the long-term C-Q relationships for each study catchment. Then, we attributed each nitrate grab sample to the corresponding runoff event type or non-event conditions, based on the nature of the inducing event and the antecedent wetness states of the catchments. Finally, we quantified the deviations from the long-term C-Q relationship.

 

We found pronounced deviations of different event types from the long-term C-Q relationships in most of the study catchments. During snow-impacted events, deviations are normally positive, indicating higher nitrate concentrations than the long-term C-Q relationships. On the other hand, deviations of rainfall events during dry antecedent conditions are mostly negative. Moreover, for rainfall events during wet antecedent conditions, we do not find persistent deviations from long-term C-Q patterns. Pronounced differences in event runoff coefficients among different event types indicate that contrasting levels of hydrological connectivity are a key control of C-Q deviations among different event types.

How to cite: Saavedra, F., Musolff, A., Von Freyberg, J., Merz, R., Basso, S., and Tarasova, L.: Can runoff event types explain some scatter in nitrate C-Q relationships?, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11933, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11933, 2022.

EGU22-12903 | Presentations | HS2.3.2

Travel Time Uncertainty Reduction by Multiobjective Optimisation of Isotope Age Tracer Models 

Elena Petrova, Karsten Osenbrück, K. Ulrich Mayer, Michael Finkel, and Peter Grathwohl

Quantification of the travel time distribution and transport parameters in fractured aquifers is crucial for understanding contaminant transport in fractured systems. Although knowledge about the travel time distribution is a helpful tool to assess the solute transport, it can’t be measured directly. Travel time is typically back-computed from different tracers in groundwater by applying well established analytical methods. However, in fractured aquifers diffusive exchange with the rock matrix, intersection of streamtubes and associated mixing, as well as other processes can cause deviation of the estimated travel time from the mean advective travel time. Direct numerical modelling of the tracer’s reactive behavior with the travel time as one of the calibrated parameters can lead to non-uniqueness of the result. These non-unique solutions typically lead to a high level of parametric uncertainty especially on catchment scale. In this work, we address the reduction of uncertainty in mean travel time, shape parameter of travel time distribution, fracture aperture, and porosity by means of multiobjective optimization enhanced by surrogate modelling. For pre-selection of potentially plausible model runs Gaussian Processes Emulation (GPE) was applied within four-parametric space. We use the GPE with multitracer conditioning for pre-selection of plausible parameter combinations. Posterior distributions were employed to estimate the mean groundwater travel times at sampling locations, to distinguish between different rock facies of captured streamlines, and to get an estimate of fracture apertures. We confirm the hypothesis that using tritium and helium isotopes together with radiogenic helium measurements helps to achieve a unimodal posterior distribution and reduces uncertainty significantly.

How to cite: Petrova, E., Osenbrück, K., Mayer, K. U., Finkel, M., and Grathwohl, P.: Travel Time Uncertainty Reduction by Multiobjective Optimisation of Isotope Age Tracer Models, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12903, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12903, 2022.

EGU22-12985 | Presentations | HS2.3.2 | Highlight

High-frequency observations reveal acute chloride pulses and chloride legacy effects in an urbanizing watershed impacted by road salting 

Claire Oswald, Cody Ross, Luke Moslenko, and Christopher Wellen

In watersheds impacted by urban growth and road salt usage, increasing stream chloride (Cl-) concentrations are well-documented. Peaks in stream Cl- concentrations that exceed chronic and/or acute water quality guidelines are typical in the winter salting season when Cl- (from Cl--based de-icers) is flushed from the landscape but are not easily measured with grab samples. In some cases, chronic Cl- conditions persist into the summer growing season due to a build-up of Cl- in the subsurface. Estimating the proportion of Cl- loads transported in the salting and non-salting seasons is of interest for tracking the relative role of subsurface Cl- pools to the annual load, as well as the influence of runoff events on loads across the two periods. In this study, we made use of a 6-year record of high-frequency stream Cl- concentrations from an urbanizing watershed in southern Ontario, Canada. High-frequency measurements revealed that the acute and chronic water quality guidelines for Cl- were exceeded for 7 and 97 % of the study period, respectively. Salting season Cl- loads were 2 to 5 times higher than in the non-salting season, but surprisingly, inter-event periods contributed 21 to 56 % of the annual load across years. The results of this study illustrate the utility of high-frequency sensors for identifying water quality extremes that negatively impact aquatic ecosystems, identifying Cl- transport pathways, and tracking the build-up of legacy Cl- in the subsurface.

How to cite: Oswald, C., Ross, C., Moslenko, L., and Wellen, C.: High-frequency observations reveal acute chloride pulses and chloride legacy effects in an urbanizing watershed impacted by road salting, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12985, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12985, 2022.

EGU22-223 | Presentations | HS2.3.3

Stable water isotopes to understand sources, pathways and ages of water in complex urban settings 

Christian Marx, Dörthe Tetzlaff, Reinhard Hinkelmann, and Chris Soulsby

The hydrology of major cities is controlled by complex networks of both natural and engineered flow paths and characterised by spatio-temporal variations in connection and disconnection of water sources. Here, we traced the transformation of stable water isotopes through the urban critical zone, in Berlin, Germany. The Panke catchment is heavily influenced by a wastewater treatment plant (~700,000 inhabitants), and legacy effects of water management during the past century. Two and a half years of daily stream isotopes revealed the complicated interactions between the groundwater fed-stream and urban impacts, such as wastewater effluents and “imported” transboundary water sources, and urban stormwater overflows. To mitigate the effects of the latter, urban greenspaces are important to store and release water more naturally to imitate the “sponge-city” concept and retain water in the urban landscape. We therefore also investigated stable water isotopes at the plot scale in three parks in Berlin. We sampled grassland and urban forest sites during the dry year of 2020. Soil and xylem isotopes of different tree species and under grassland revealed shallower root water uptake from grasslands and greater recharge by younger waters. As evapotranspiration accounts for about 90% of rainfall, ecohydrological dynamics in urban green spaces were shown to be largely disconnected from urban runoff generation. Isotopes were shown to be invaluable tools in multi-scale understanding of urban hydrology and have great potential in contributing to the evidence base needed to develop policies for more sustainable urban water management in the face of increased urban growth and climate change.  

How to cite: Marx, C., Tetzlaff, D., Hinkelmann, R., and Soulsby, C.: Stable water isotopes to understand sources, pathways and ages of water in complex urban settings, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-223, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-223, 2022.

EGU22-353 | Presentations | HS2.3.3

Investigation of Stable isotope systematics and geochemical signatures of surface water from the Satluj River Basin (SRB), Himalayas, India. 

Akhtar Jahan, Tanveer Dar, Usman Khan, Nachiketa Rai, and Sudhir Kumar

The present study explores the signature of stable isotopes (δ18O and δD) and major inorganic solute ion concentrations of Satluj river water and its tributaries to gain insight into the dominant hydrogeochemical process that controls the water chemistry in the Satluj River Basin (SRB), Himalayas, India. In isotopic and geochemical terms, the surface water of SRB is poorly characterized for its whole length; their potential variability has yet to be widely used as an aid in hydrological research. The δ18O values in the SRB range from – 14.50‰ to – 7.35‰ and δD from – 100.30‰ to − 44.70‰, showing general enrichment from Khaab to downstream Harike barrage. The upper reaches of Satluj River and its major upstream tributaries like Spiti and other small streams contributing to the Satluj are relatively depleted in δ18O and δD, possibly indicative of precipitation originating at higher elevations and/ or recharge from snow/glacial meltwater. While lower reaches are relatively enriched in δ18O and δD. The local water line for the SRB was found to be δD = 8.12 × δ18O + 18.89. The higher slope and higher intercept as compared to GMWL indicate a system recharged by snow/glacier meltwater and recycled moisture derived from continental sources in addition to monsoonal climates. In addition, a higher intercept indicates that the moisture source of precipitation (snow/rainfall) in this region originates from the Western Disturbance (WD). The Deuterium excess (d-excess) in the SRB varies between 12.50‰ and 25.81‰ with an average of 17.40‰, which is mostly higher than the long-term average for the Indian summer monsoon (~ 8‰). The higher d-excess value is because of the contribution of moisture from Mid-latitude westerlies. A significant negative correlation of Satluj river water δ18O with elevation was observed with a vertical lapse rate of 0.15‰/100 m. Geochemical analysis showed that the solute concentrations show spatial heterogeneity with decreasing elevation in the SRB. This is related to the complex lithologic compositions and different water sources from different elevations that contribute to the Satluj river. This study also established a relationship between total cation abundance (∑Cat*, corrected for cyclic components) and δ18O in waters of the Satluj mainstream. The variation in δ18O and ∑Cat* along the course of the Satluj is brought about by independent processes, the intensity of chemical weathering in the catchments and associated sub-catchments (tributaries), and altitude effect. ∑Cat* is higher at higher altitudes because of intense weathering, and δ18O is more depleted because the source waters are from depleted snow/glacial melt and cloud that is depleted in 18O because of previous rainouts during its ascent. The relationship between total cation abundance (∑Cat*) and δ18O suggests that ∑Cat* would increase by a factor of 0.93 for every 1‰ increase in δ18O.

 

How to cite: Jahan, A., Dar, T., Khan, U., Rai, N., and Kumar, S.: Investigation of Stable isotope systematics and geochemical signatures of surface water from the Satluj River Basin (SRB), Himalayas, India., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-353, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-353, 2022.

EGU22-662 | Presentations | HS2.3.3

Nitrate and Water Isotopes as Tools to Resolve Nitrate Travel Times in a Mixed Land Use Catchment 

Christina Radtke, Stefanie Lutz, Christin Mueller, Jarno Rouhiainen, Ralf Merz, Xiaoqiang Yang, Rohini Kumar, Paolo Benettin, and Kay Knoeller

For the sake of food production, nutrients like nitrogen (N) are applied on agricultural land to supply crops. However, due to common agricultural practice, the amount of N provided very often significantly exceeds the uptake potential of the plants resulting in a N surplus that accumulates in the soil. Organic soil nitrogen is slowly transformed to nitrate, which is then mobilized by water and moves through the subsurface, with the risk of contaminating receiving water bodies. High nitrate loads cause poor chemical states for 27% of all groundwater bodies in Germany and foster eutrophication in lakes and rivers and by this a loss of biodiversity. The main problem are legacy issues of nitrate pollution, because there is a time lag between N input and nitrate mobilization and transport. Research on nitrate travel times is highly relevant for a reliable prediction of the capability of catchments to store, buffer and release nitrate. However, it is not clear how long nitrate is stored and transported in catchment’s storage. For this study, a 11 km2 headwater catchment with mixed land use within the Northern lowlands of the Harz mountains in Germany was investigated from spring 2017 until the end of 2020. A monitoring program was set up, starting with biweekly samples for the first two years and daily samples for the remainder, with sub-daily samples during precipitation events. Samples were taken from stream water and when available from precipitation water. Nitrate concentrations as well as isotopic signatures of water (δ18O and δ2H) and nitrate (δ18O and δ15N) were analysed. To investigate nitrate travel times, the numerical model tran-SAS (Benettin and Bertuzzo, 2018) was set up und modified for this catchment. Here, a time-variant power law function was used as rank StorAge Selection (SAS) function to select the composition of fluxes considering their age. Nitrate with a distinct δ18O from water, formed during microbial activities in the upper soil zone is transported with leaching water into the subsurface storage where denitrification with the corresponding isotope fractionation occurs. The combination of stable isotopes of water and biogeochemical equations to describe the forming of nitrate isotopes and the fractionation of nitrate isotopes during denitrification, which depends on transit times is a novel tool to investigate nitrate age and nitrate transport. Together with the usage of a SAS-based transit time model to simulate nitrate transport and denitrification in the subsurface, tran-SAS is transformed into a simplified reactive transport model (RTM).

A decoupling between nitrate age and water age as well as between nitrate travel times and water travel times is expected. Especially during precipitation events catchment’s processes and travel times are changing due to altering hydrological conditions. The model allows to investigate the age of water and nitrate during different hydrological conditions. This will become more and more important considering more frequent hydrological extremes (droughts and floods) and associated N mobilization in agricultural catchments.

How to cite: Radtke, C., Lutz, S., Mueller, C., Rouhiainen, J., Merz, R., Yang, X., Kumar, R., Benettin, P., and Knoeller, K.: Nitrate and Water Isotopes as Tools to Resolve Nitrate Travel Times in a Mixed Land Use Catchment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-662, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-662, 2022.

This study focuses on water quality assessment and hydrological aspects around northern Mara Sub-Goldfield (Tanzania). A total of 26 water samples were collected from different sampling sites for physicochemical characterization and H-O isotopes analysis. Parameters such as pH, electrical conductivity (EC), Total Dissolved Solids (TDS), Total Suspended Solids (TSS), and total hardness were analyzed for each water sample. The 18O/16O and 2H/1H ratios were measured in water samples and expressed as δ18O and δ2H relative to Vienna Standard Mean Ocean Water (V-SMOW). The study revealed that the majority of drinking water sources meet the recommended World Health Organization (WHO) and Tanzania Bureau of Standards (TBS) levels. Drinking water from Kegonga community borehole (pH=6.62, EC=1690 µs/cm, TDS=1080 mg/l), shallow well east of Ingwe Dam (pH=7.32, EC=1720 µs/cm, TDS= 1000mg/l), shallow well south of tailings dams (pH=7.6, EC=2670 µs/cm, TDS=1780 mg/l) and traditional well (pH=5.76) are not suitable for drinking purposes. Isotopic values of studied water samples have shown a wide variation from -28.5 to 21.4 ‰ for δ2H, -5.37 to 2.37 for δ18O ‰, and -3.7 to 16.08 ‰ for D-excess values. The slope of Local Meteoric Water Line (δ2H = 5. 9 δ18O + 5.51; R2=0.94) is slightly lower than the slope of Global Meteoric Water Line (δ2H = 8.2 δ18O + 11.27; R2=1), which indicates that the majority of studied water samples have been isotopically modified. The study demonstrated that the majority of groundwater has been recharged by more evaporated sources likely wastewater from tailings dams. This finding is supported by the consistency of isotopic signature and physicochemical parameters of several groundwater sources with those of surface water discharged from the mines.

Keywords: groundwater-surface water interaction; water quality; stable isotopes; d-excess; Tanzania

How to cite: Myovela, J. L., Godfray, G., and Salimu, M.: Physicochemical parameters and stable isotope composition of water in Northern Mara Sub-Goldfield, Tanzania: Implications for groundwater-surface water interaction, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1280, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1280, 2022.

Streams may be connected to a large store of water, such as regional groundwater, and/or sustained by smaller near-river stores (such as riparian groundwater). Documenting the sources of water in streams is important for understanding catchment water balances, protecting riverine environments from pollution, and predicting the efforts of near-river pumping. Additionally, streams connected to large water stores will be buffered against the impacts of short-term climate variability (such as droughts that last a few years). Many techniques that document groundwater-stream water interaction allow the location and fluxes of baseflow to be determined but do not constrain from where in the catchment the baseflow is derived. The mean transit time (MTT) represents the time taken for water to migrate from where it is recharged in the catchment to where it discharges into the stream. Estimating the MTTs of stream water allows the volume (V) of the water store that sustains streamflow (Q) to be estimated (V=Q×MTT). This study compares the water stores sustaining streamflow in contrasting rivers in southeast Australia based on tritium MTTs calculated using lumped parameter models. Perennial streams (Oven, Yarra, Latrobe, and Gellibrand Catchments) have long MTTs (4 to 179 years) that are higher at low streamflows. By contrast, the MTTs of similar size intermittent streams (Deep Creek, Wimmera, and Gatum Catchments) range from <1 to 35 years (and are mostly less than 20 years). The estimated volumes of the catchment contributing to streamflow are 3 to 5 orders of magnitude smaller than those in comparable perennial streams. These differences reflect the limited connection between the intermittent streams and the deeper regional groundwater system compared with the perennial streams, especially at low flows. Rather, intermittent streams may be sustained mainly by smaller younger reservoirs in the riparian zone. These intermittent streams will be more susceptible to short-term climate variabilities and changes to flow regimes may have significant impacts on water supplies and the health of the riverine system. Intermittent streams are globally distributed in a range of environments, especially in semi-arid areas. Climate change and water stress have resulted in many perennial streams gradually becoming intermittent and this trend is expected to increase. In southeast Australia, around 30% of catchments have not recovered following multiple drought years between 1996 and 2010 (the Millennium Drought), and streamflow has kept declining. The increased intermittence fundamentally changes the catchment water balance, specifically making regional groundwater less important, and increases the reliance of these streams on more vulnerable small young water stores.

How to cite: Zhou, Z., Cartwright, I., and Morgenstern, U.: Mean transit times help understand the volume of catchment water required to sustain streamflow in contrasting southeast Australian rivers, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3350, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3350, 2022.

Rising trends in the concentrations of dissolved organic carbon (DOC) exported from catchments can be observed in many places around the world, including in the catchment of the river Große Ohe (19 km²) in the Bavarian Forest National Park (Germany). During flood events, DOC is mainly exported via hydrological pathways due to the activation of loaded pre-event water, affecting for example aquatic ecosystems and the use of surface water for drinking water supply.

In previous work, the uppermost soil horizon, enriched with DOC through microbial decomposition of organic matter, was identified as the main source of DOC. However, more recent data show that soil properties play an important role in flood genesis, but are minor for DOC export. More important are the contributions of existing wet areas in the catchment, which provide good conditions for the solution of organic carbon. During rain events, these wet areas become connected to stream runoff and are the main source of DOC exports from the catchment.

We sampled and analysed three flood events with different hydrological conditions and used the results for multi-tracer flow separation and end ember mixing analyses. To do this, we collected water samples from the stream runoff, precipitation water, groundwater and soil water from various locations in the catchment and analysed them for DOC, SiO2, K+, Fe2+ and other cations and anions. Observations of the fingerprints of DOC and K+ show significant differences between water from the uppermost soil horizons (high DOC- and K+-concentrations) and the wet areas (high DOC-, low K+-concentrations). K+ results from the decomposition of organic matter and is mainly present in stemflow and water from the uppermost soil horizons.

During the flood event, we observe a significant correlation between instream DOC-concentration and runoff, but no correlation between instream K+-concentration and runoff. Nevertheless, instream DOC- and K+-concentrations increase at the beginning of the event, leading to the assumption that rapid surface runoff contributes to stream runoff in the first phase of the flood event. As the event progresses and the discharge continues to rise, K+ decreases rapidly, while DOC mainly follows the pattern of the hydrograph. In addition, we consistently observed a delay between the peaks of discharge and DOC concentration of approx. 1.5 - 2 hours. Both facts indicate that these are the fingerprints of the wet areas, which, depending on the hydrological conditions, take some time to “fill up and overflow”. The water of these wet areas then gets connected to the stream and leads to a delayed DOC release.

The findings are used to develop a predictive model for runoff generation and DOC mobilization. Since the identified processes are closely linked to the characteristics of the catchment (topography, hydrotopes, ...), the results have to be compared with other catchments in order to generalize them and ensure the transferability of the model to similar catchments. In the event of success, such forecast models are important tools, e.g. for drinking water suppliers who have to react quickly to changing DOC concentrations to ensure water quality standards.

How to cite: Kuhnert, L. and Wöhling, T.: Discriminating runoff source areas in a small forested catchment using a multi-tracer approach, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3772, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3772, 2022.

EGU22-3898 | Presentations | HS2.3.3

Spatial and temporal variability of near-surface flow pathways in a Swiss pre-alpine headwater catchment 

Anna Leuteritz, Victor Gauthier, and Ilja van Meerveld

In catchments with poorly drained soils, a significant part of the lateral flow on hillslopes takes place at or near the soil surface. However, there is still little knowledge about these shallow flow pathways and the factors that affect their temporal and spatial variability. Therefore, a better understanding of overland flow and shallow subsurface flow is required to enhance our understanding of runoff generation and solute transport at the catchment scale.

We installed 14 plots on vegetated hillslopes in the Studibach catchment in the Swiss pre-Alpine area that is underlain by poorly drained gleysols. We measured the overland flow and shallow subsurface flow rates at small (3 m wide) trenches, as well as the groundwater level near each plot. We, furthermore, sampled precipitation, overland flow and subsurface flow, soil water, groundwater, and stream water over a two-month period to obtain information about the stable water isotope and geochemical composition. Isotope hydrograph separation and end-member mixing analysis were used to determine the event water fractions and to quantify the fractions of precipitation, soil water, and groundwater in overland flow and lateral subsurface flow. In this presentation, we will present the first results on the temporal and spatial variability in the occurrence, amount and chemical composition of overland flow and shallow subsurface flow and describe how these are related to rainfall event characteristics and topographic position.

How to cite: Leuteritz, A., Gauthier, V., and van Meerveld, I.: Spatial and temporal variability of near-surface flow pathways in a Swiss pre-alpine headwater catchment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3898, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3898, 2022.

EGU22-4127 | Presentations | HS2.3.3

Assessment karstic water origin along South slope of Grate Caucasus Mountain range 

Sopio Vepkhvadze, Peter Malik, George Melikadze, Mariam Todadze, Ludmila Ghlonti, and Tornike Tchikadze

The impact of climate change had caused that precipitation has significantly decreased in Georgia which caused significant decrease of surface water flows and depletion of groundwater amounts in natural springs. In the same time, the waters recharged in karstic aquifers, occurring on the southern slopes of the Greater Caucasus Mountains, can be considered as alternative groundwater resources for the communities in lowlands and the adjacent foothills. Here, about half of the renewable groundwater resources in artesian basins and confined groundwater systems in Georgia can be considered as belonging to the above mentioned water-bearing horizon. In order to assess water resources, the pathways between the recharge zones along the Caucasus and aquifers need to be addressed and risks of groundwater contamination along these pathways need to be evaluated.

On the territory of West Georgia, hydrogeological and hydrogeochemical surveys were performed in order to define the main hydrogeological features of the region. In the frame of this research, more than one hundred water sources (springs, wells, boreholes, rivers) were sampled during 2019. Physical parameters (pH, O2, EC, temperature) were measured on site during sampling. Water samples were collected for chemical (major ions) and isotope analysis (18O and 2H). Karstic areas of West Georgia were covered by mapping. Isotopic composition of water in the study area evolves according to a line parallel with the global meteoric water line. Available isotopic data indicate several groups of groundwater types. Some of them very probably represent older waters, with substantially long mean residence time. Samples with pronounced isotope composition variability indicate the evolution of groundwater isotopic composition from the recharge area in the mountains through river valleys to the exfiltration areas. Deuterium excess shows higher values, typical for mountain precipitation and snow in mountain ranges. The conjunctive use of isotopic approaches demonstrates a high potential for future water resources studies in Georgia.

How to cite: Vepkhvadze, S., Malik, P., Melikadze, G., Todadze, M., Ghlonti, L., and Tchikadze, T.: Assessment karstic water origin along South slope of Grate Caucasus Mountain range, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4127, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4127, 2022.

Increased nutrient levels in aquatic systems can trigger issues such as eutrophication, water quality degradation, and algal blooms that have negative environmental and economic impacts. Nitrate contamination makes water unconsumable hence, reducing access to drinking water - a key factor of well-being as recognized in the UN Sustainable Development Goals. Nitrate source identification remains challenging using hydrochemical measurements, but the analysis of stable isotopes in nitrate (δ15N and δ18O) opened the possibility to track sources and processes. The efficiency of this isotopic approach lay in simple and precise field and analytical methods, with low cost and easy sample preparation. Despite the potential and usefulness, nitrate isotopes on their own cannot differentiate closely related sources of nitrate contamination with overlapping isotopic signatures, such as sewage (human sources) and manure (agricultural sources), as well as treated versus raw sewage inputs from the catchment. One solution is to combine isotopic techniques with analysis of compounds of emerging concern (CECs). Some CECs are ideal chemical markers of faecal contamination (sewage or manure) as they are usually linked to a specific source. They are ubiquitous in that source and are persistent and present at detectable concentrations in contaminated environmental samples. Their high solubility in water and low volatility facilitates their use as tracers for components originating in sewage and manure. Our study is focused on the innovative approach of combining stable isotopes with CECs in surface and groundwater to improve nitrogen source tracking and source delineation, and more precise quantification of groundwater/surface water interaction. As a proof of concept, we have combined stable isotopes of nitrate with CECs in surface water (large European river) and groundwater (shallow aquifer) case studies. Preliminary results provide a unique and versatile framework for expanding the use of isotopic techniques to tracing nitrate pollution sources and assessing water quality in the catchments worldwide.

How to cite: Vystavna, Y., Soto, D., and Miller, J.: Improving understanding of nitrate sources in connected river and groundwater systems through linking nitrate isotopes and contaminants of emerging concern, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4714, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4714, 2022.

EGU22-6080 | Presentations | HS2.3.3

Re-use of treated wastewater for irrigation and groundwater recharge: environmental impact assessment based on tracer method at the experimental site in Kinrooi, Belgium 

Lara Speijer, Delphine Vandeputte, Mateusz Zawadzki, Yiqi Su, Mingyue Luo, Yue Gao, Marc Elskens, Pascal Verhoest, Joke Bauwens, Tom Coussement, Frank Elsen, Birte Raes, Steven Eisenreich, and Marijke Huysmans

Re-use of treated wastewater is receiving increasing attention as method to reduce water stress resulting from population growth, socio-economic development and climate change. In 2018, the European Commission issued a policy strategy entailing minimum water quality requirements for water re-use for agriculture and aquifer recharge. However, the environmental impact of such solution is yet to be determined.

The VUB in collaboration with private and public sector partners set up a field experiment in Kinrooi (Belgium) in which the effects of re-using treated domestic wastewater for sub-irrigation of an agricultural field are monitored. This is an interdisciplinary project which includes analyses of the effects on water quality and quantity in the subsurface saturated and unsaturated zone and nearby surface water, the effects on crops as well as research on the public perception.

Within this project, one of the aims is to create an advection-dispersion groundwater transport model to investigate how the chemical composition of the shallow groundwater would change after the treated domestic wastewater is applied through sub-irrigation. Observation data of tracers of the re-used water in the groundwater are needed to calibrate the transport model. Therefore, it is critical to choose a suitable tracer, allowing to unambiguously tell apart the effluent and groundwater end members. Literature suggests the use of chemical properties such as stable isotopes and Cl/Br ratios to use as wastewater tracers. Stable isotopes of hydrogen and oxygen are investigated, but the focus is currently on the use of Cl/Br ratios, which shows promising results. The use of this ratio as tracer is based on the close to ideal conservative behaviour of bromide and chloride ions in water caused by their small size and hydrophilic characteristics. This implies that physical processes such as dilution and evaporation happening in the environment influence the absolute concentrations of the ions but leaves their ratio constant. At the moment, 21 monitoring wells are installed on the field of which 9 monitoring wells have been sampled for data on Cl/Br tracers.

In general, the results indicate that finding a suitable tracer is not straightforward because chemical and isotopic compositions of the groundwater and treated wastewater are often similar. Therefore, the research continues to focus on improving the analytical methods used to analyse the currently used tracers (e.g. Cl/Br ratio and stable isotopes) and on the selection of other tracers such as anthropogenic organic compounds (e.g. pharmaceuticals and artificial sweeteners) to quantify the influence of the effluent end member and to enhance modelling performance.

How to cite: Speijer, L., Vandeputte, D., Zawadzki, M., Su, Y., Luo, M., Gao, Y., Elskens, M., Verhoest, P., Bauwens, J., Coussement, T., Elsen, F., Raes, B., Eisenreich, S., and Huysmans, M.: Re-use of treated wastewater for irrigation and groundwater recharge: environmental impact assessment based on tracer method at the experimental site in Kinrooi, Belgium, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6080, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6080, 2022.

EGU22-6106 | Presentations | HS2.3.3

Mapping stable isotopes of oxygen and hydrogen in precipitation, surface waters and groundwaters of Georgia 

George Melikadze, Ladislav Holko, Mariam Todadze, Aleksandre Tchankvetadze, Aleksandre Gventsadze, Merab Gaphrindashvili, Ramaz Chitanava, and Tornike Chikadze

We present preliminary results of the monitoring of oxygen and hydrogen isotopes in the water cycle of Georgia. The objective of the monitoring is to create maps of isotopic composition of precipitation over Georgia, estimate seasonal amplitudes in the isotopic composition of precipitation, and relationships with the surface and ground waters. Monthly cumulative precipitation samples have been collected since 2013 at 17 sites over entire Georgia at elevations 14 m a. s. l to 2220 m a. s. l. Local meteoric water lines (LMWLs) indicated differences between western, central, and eastern Georgia. Although the LMWLs slopes were mostly not substantially different, only the highest stations (Bakuriani and Gudauri) exhibited slopes that were slightly greater than 8.  The lowest LMWL slope (7.4) was found for stations Chaladidi and Sabueti located in western and central Georgia. LMWL derived for Gudauri (the Greater Caucasus) had a significantly greater intercept (19.9) than at all other sites. Isotopic gradients in delta 18O and delta 2H calculated between stations Tbilisi (430 m a.s.l.) and Gudauri (2220 m a.s.l.) were -0.26 per mil and -1.8 per mil per 100 m, respectively. Monthly samples were collected in several major rivers (Rioni, Mtkvari, Alazani, Iori). Isotopic composition of the greatest Georgian river Mtkvari was best correlated with precipitation in the central Lesser Caucasus (Bakuriani and Sabueti) and southern slopes of the eastern Greater Caucasus (Lagodekhi). One-fourth of groundwater samples were collected in boreholes between mid-July and mid-August and almost all samples from the second half of September (i.e. in the periods without groundwater replenishment) contained evaporated water. Slopes of the evaporation lines were 5.4 and 4.8, respectively.

How to cite: Melikadze, G., Holko, L., Todadze, M., Tchankvetadze, A., Gventsadze, A., Gaphrindashvili, M., Chitanava, R., and Chikadze, T.: Mapping stable isotopes of oxygen and hydrogen in precipitation, surface waters and groundwaters of Georgia, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6106, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6106, 2022.

EGU22-6477 | Presentations | HS2.3.3

Using Stable Isotopes to Assess Surface-Groundwater Interactions and Contaminant Pathways in a Drinking Water Supply Watershed System 

Amanda Carneiro Marques, Emily Kumpel, John Tobiason, and Christian Guzman

The assessment of surface-groundwater fluxes is crucial for understanding pollutant pathways through the natural environment. Several techniques to characterize these surface-subsurface interactions have been applied as an attempt to quantify these fluxes in the humid temperate Northeastern USA. Most recently, stable isotopes are considered to be an important tool to describe the movement of waters through the hydrosphere. This study was conducted in the Quabbin-Wachusett Reservoir System, which supplies water for the Boston Metropolitan Area in Massachusetts and depends on water quality management based on environmental trends. Recent trends indicate that despite efforts to reduce road salt application during the winter, salt indicator trends are still increasing in the watershed. Salt transport characterized by monitoring trends of specific conductivity and chloride across the watershed demonstrate that subsurface water concentrations are significantly higher than the streams and reservoir (for chloride, median value is 204 mg/L for wells and 102 mg/L for streams). The present investigation hypothesizes that salt infiltrates through the subsurface during the cold months (October-March) and then releases back to surface water throughout the year. Since groundwater can act as salt storage, an important question for water management relates to the timeframe needed to observe a reduction of salt presence in the watershed after road salt reduction policies and other mitigation strategies take place. To investigate this, oxygen isotopes are being used to identify the dominant hydrological pathways influencing groundwater recharge patterns.  Stable water isotope compositions for warm precipitation (δ18O -2.14 to -8.98 per mille), cold precipitation (δ18O -4.57 to -13.57 per mille), and groundwater (δ18O -8.27 to -9.66 per mille) were used to assess proportional recharge dominance via local winter and summer precipitation isotope end-members. Preliminary analyses indicate that the groundwater recharge is winter dominant (92% obtained from the winter bias seasonal recharge ratio Rwinter/Rannual; values >= 80% represent winter dominance), thus the applied road salt during cold months can be contributing to sustained increases in conductivity in the groundwater. The results show potential dynamics that explain higher levels of specific conductivity and chloride in the subsurface water and the continued increases in stream and reservoir concentrations. Further investigation is being conducted with larger datasets in order to have a better understanding of sample frequency needed to be representative of the system’s predominant seasonal recharge and runoff generation patterns, as well as, how the water isotopic composition is variable spatially and temporally in the region.

How to cite: Carneiro Marques, A., Kumpel, E., Tobiason, J., and Guzman, C.: Using Stable Isotopes to Assess Surface-Groundwater Interactions and Contaminant Pathways in a Drinking Water Supply Watershed System, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6477, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6477, 2022.

EGU22-7211 | Presentations | HS2.3.3

Nitrate isotopes reveal the effectiveness of riparian denitrification for nitrate removal from riparian zones 

Stefanie Lutz, Andreas Musolff, Boris van Breukelen, Kay Knöller, and Jan Fleckenstein

The riparian zone is a hydrologically and biogeochemically active zone, characterized by mixing of stream water with groundwater and transformation of nutrients such as nitrogen. The riparian zone thus plays a key role in natural attenuation of nitrate pollution. Among the attenuation processes in riparian zones, denitrification is the only one that leads to permanent removal of nitrogen from the riparian system via the release of dinitrogen gas into the atmosphere. In contrast, other biogeochemical processes such as nitrate uptake by plants merely result in a temporary nitrogen retention within riparian zones. While hydrochemical data and endmember modelling can help assess nitrate transformation in riparian aquifers, this does not allow quantifying the extent of nitrate removal via denitrification. In this talk, I will demonstrate how nitrate isotope data can be used in combination with chloride and nitrate concentration data to quantify spatial and temporal variations in the extent of denitrification and mixing between groundwater and surface water. I will illustrate how the application of this approach to a riparian groundwater study site in Central Germany revealed that denitrification is largely exceeded by other processes that merely lead to temporary nitrate removal from the riparian groundwater. In comparable settings, a major fraction of nitrogen inputs is thus likely retained in riparian zones and may eventually be discharged into rivers. Such information is crucial to determine the effectiveness of riparian zones for removing nitrate from aquatic ecosystems, which is highly relevant for many river ecosystems at risk of eutrophication because of high nitrogen inputs from agriculture.

Reference

Lutz, S. R., Trauth, N., Musolff, A., Van Breukelen, B. M., Knöller, K., & Fleckenstein, J. H. (2020). How important is denitrification in riparian zones? Combining end-member mixing and isotope modeling to quantify nitrate removal from riparian groundwater. Water Resources Research, 56, e2019WR025528. https://doi.org/10.1029/2019WR025528

How to cite: Lutz, S., Musolff, A., van Breukelen, B., Knöller, K., and Fleckenstein, J.: Nitrate isotopes reveal the effectiveness of riparian denitrification for nitrate removal from riparian zones, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7211, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7211, 2022.

EGU22-7314 | Presentations | HS2.3.3

Stable isotopes of The River Sava as a tool for transit time investigations: a case study Ljubljansko polje, Slovenia 

Klara Nagode, Aljaž Pavšek, Urška Pavlič, and Polona Vreča

River water represents the spatial and temporal integrator of the isotopic composition of precipitation in a catchment area. Stable isotope measurements of oxygen and hydrogen (δ18O and δ2H) in stream waters and precipitation are widely applied to investigate hydrological pathways and transit times. In this study, we apply the stable isotope approach to improve knowledge on the hydrological characteristics of the River Sava, Slovenia, by performing monthly sampling of river water at two locations: Brod and Šentjakob and precipitation at one location (Ljubljana–Reactor), between 2020 and 2021. Gathered data was used for preliminary estimations of water transit times in streamflow. Moreover, different methods were used to determine the Local Meteoric Water Line and comparison with precipitation data for the period 1981–2021 to estimate temporal changes and transit times of the River Sava at selected locations.

The climatic characteristics of the investigated area are also reflected in δ18O and δ2H of precipitation that has been monitored since 1981. The δ18O and δ2H values of precipitation reveal strong seasonal variations, while the tracer output signal in the River Sava is dampened. Site-specific long-term (1981–2021) covariation of δ18O and δ2H is also in good agreement with Global Meteoric Water Line (GMWL), while short-period lines (2020–2021) differ in slope and intercept but lie close to the line GMWL. A longer time series is more suitable for the determination of the LMWL, as the error is much higher for shorter two-year periods. 

The exponential flow model produced mean stream water transit times of 4.2 and 3.1 years at Sava Brod and Sava Šentjakob, respectively, whereas estimated transit times were longer compared to the results of previous investigations. Although the identified results are hydrologically plausible, the limitation of this and previous studies are presented as uncertainties resulting from a short sampling period and low sampling frequencies.

How to cite: Nagode, K., Pavšek, A., Pavlič, U., and Vreča, P.: Stable isotopes of The River Sava as a tool for transit time investigations: a case study Ljubljansko polje, Slovenia, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7314, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7314, 2022.

EGU22-8287 | Presentations | HS2.3.3

An updated model for generating historic precipitation isotope time series from machine learning applied in Europe 

Daniel B. Nelson, David Basler, and Ansgar Kahmen

Hydrogen and oxygen isotope values of precipitation are critically important quantities for applications in Earth, environmental, and biological sciences. However, direct measurements are not available at every location and time, and existing precipitation isotope models are often not sufficiently accurate for examining features such as long-term trends or interannual variability. This can limit applications that seek to use these values to identify the source history of water or to understand the hydrological or meteorological processes that determine these values. We developed a framework using gradient boosted regression tree-based machine learning, which we used to implement a procedure for calculating isotope time series at monthly resolution using available climate and location data. Here we present two new updates to our model, Piso.AI, one of which applies the original approach to new climate predictor data to extend the time series to the 1950-2020 time interval, and the second of which uses a restricted set of predictors to allow time series to be generated that span the range from 1901-2020 with slightly reduced accuracy compared to the original model. Both new products can be applied over most of Europe, and were trained on the historic archive of precipitation isotope data available from the Global Network of Isotopes in Precipitation. These model products facilitate simple, user-friendly predictions of precipitation isotope time series that can be generated on demand and are accurate enough to be used for exploration of interannual and long-term variability in both hydrogen and oxygen isotopic systems. These predictions provide important isotope input variables for ecological and hydrological applications, as well as powerful targets for paleoclimate proxy calibration, and they can serve as resources for probing historic patterns in the isotopic composition of precipitation with a high level of meteorological accuracy. Predictions from our modelling framework are available at https://isotope.bot.unibas.ch/PisoAI/.

How to cite: Nelson, D. B., Basler, D., and Kahmen, A.: An updated model for generating historic precipitation isotope time series from machine learning applied in Europe, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8287, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8287, 2022.

EGU22-8681 | Presentations | HS2.3.3

Impact of data time resolution in long term baseflow index assessment from mass balance filtering 

Leisan Khasanova, Antonia Longobardi, Ilmir Khasanov, and Alexey Elizaryev

Key words: Mass balance filtering, baseflow, BFI, time-resolution, electrical conductivity, permeability

Baseflow plays an important role in sustaining freshwaters quality and quantity at the global scale. Quantitative estimates of baseflow are necessary but no direct observations are available to the purpose, thus hydrograph filtering appears as a valid solution to quantify the baseflow process. The mass balance filter (MBF), based on electrical conductivity (EC) observations, is one of the most objective filtering techniques.

The aim of the present study is to analyze the impact of data time resolution in the assessment of the long-term scale baseflow index (BFI, the ratio between baseflow and total flow) by hydrograph filtering. The MBF method was used to estimate the long-term BFI of 64 catchments across Continental United States ranging from about 5 to 50000 Kmq, from arid to continental climate conditions and accounting for 5 to 10 years of continuous observations. Streamflow and EC data were collected from the United States Geological Survey (USGS) National Water Information System website at the 15 minutes time resolution and aggregated at the daily scale. BFI15, the BFI computed at the 15 min time resolution, was compared with BFI24, that is with the BFI computed at the daily scale. The difference among the two indices was investigated in relation to catchment climate and physiographic characteristics.

The large dataset was divided into two groups, a poorly-drained group and a well-drained group on the base of the catchment permeability assessed by the GLobal HYdrogeology MaPS (GLHYMPS) project. The first group corresponds to BFI values < 0.5, the second to BFI values > 0.5. Overall the BFI15 was found to be larger than BFI24, with an average difference of about 7%, probably caused by the fact that at finer time scale a wider spectra of streamflow processes and components can be detected, more evidently during the peak flow conditions. The average difference drops to 1% in the case of the well-drained hydrological systems, which appear likely the less impacted by the monitoring time resolution and increase on average to 11% (with maximum values approaching 50%) in the case of the poorly drained systems.

 

How to cite: Khasanova, L., Longobardi, A., Khasanov, I., and Elizaryev, A.: Impact of data time resolution in long term baseflow index assessment from mass balance filtering, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8681, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8681, 2022.

EGU22-8917 | Presentations | HS2.3.3

Stream lithium isotope ratios record antecedent and transient hydrological conditions in catchment weathering exports 

Jon Golla, Julien Bouchez, Jean-François Didon-Lescot, Jean-Marc Domergue, Nadine Grard, Pierre-Alain Ayral, Didier Josselin, and Jennifer Druhan

Concentration-discharge relationships have been extensively utilized to infer the routing of water and pathways of (bio)geochemical reactions in the Critical Zone. To date, relatively little complementary development of stable isotope ratio - discharge relationships has been made, despite the fact that these tracers are commonly used to disentangle weathering reactions in the fluids draining from headwater systems. A process-based understanding of the extent to which fluid flow rates, antecedent hydrological conditions, and water age distributions impact these isotopic signatures in stream or river exports would present a pivotal advancement in the quantitative analysis of Critical Zone structure and function. Here, we explore how these factors regulate variations in stable lithium isotope ratios (expressed as δ7Li) of streamflow and the underlying water-rock interactions recorded by this signal during periods of hydrological transience. We present novel data sets collected during two distinct flooding events in Sapine Creek, a small, granitic catchment located on the southern flank of the Mont-Lozère, France and part of a Critical Zone Observatory within the French OZCAR Research Infrastructure. The data from this site are used to parametrize and validate an isotope-enabled, multicomponent reactive transport model capable of running transient simulations designed to mimic two sampling conditions at Sapine: (1) a storm preceded by a low-flow period and (2) a storm event during the wet season. The models are initiated from an unweathered granite subject to steady state uplift and infiltration. From this point, two synthetic storm events are simulated. Simulation of a storm event ending a period of dry conditions results in a net increase in streamflow lithium isotope ratios due to enhanced secondary mineral formation promoted by relatively long water residence times. In contrast, when the model is used to simulate a succession of relatively larger (~2 times greater in magnitude) storms during a wet season, a net decrease in δ7Li is observed. These lower isotope ratios are a consequence of attenuated secondary mineral formation. These preliminary results and trends demonstrate the influence of antecedent hydrological conditions and storm intensity on the magnitude and duration over which stream δ7Li is perturbed and, hence, the seasonal dependence of this signal as a record of transient behavior.

How to cite: Golla, J., Bouchez, J., Didon-Lescot, J.-F., Domergue, J.-M., Grard, N., Ayral, P.-A., Josselin, D., and Druhan, J.: Stream lithium isotope ratios record antecedent and transient hydrological conditions in catchment weathering exports, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8917, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8917, 2022.

EGU22-9097 | Presentations | HS2.3.3

Identification of the recharge zone using stable isotopes in the Salar de Atacama, Chile 

Sonia Valdivielso, Enric Vázquez-Suñe, Christian Herrera, and Emilio Custodio

In the peripheral aquifer of the Salar de Atacama, recharge is a key term of the water balance. This recharge is produced under arid conditions in the sub-basins surrounding the Salar and is dominated by medium salinity water due the intense evapo-concentration conditions. To solve the uncertainty in closing the water balance in the Salar de Atacama basin, this study aims to characterize the isotopic composition of precipitation, groundwater and surface water and to identify the recharge area. The results show that winter precipitation is more depleted in heavy isotopes, δ2H and δ18O, than summer precipitation. Surface water is evaporated and it has the same isotopic footprint as groundwater in each sub-basin, indicating that surface water runoff is a main recharge component. The meteoric source of surface and underground water in the basins of the Altiplano-Puna Plateau is isotopically lighter than the other waters found in the Salar de Atacama basin, although there is no significant transfer of isotopically lighter water to the peripheral aquifer of the Salar de Atacama from areas significantly outside the hydrographic basin.

How to cite: Valdivielso, S., Vázquez-Suñe, E., Herrera, C., and Custodio, E.: Identification of the recharge zone using stable isotopes in the Salar de Atacama, Chile, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9097, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9097, 2022.

EGU22-9190 | Presentations | HS2.3.3

Seasonal compartmentalisation of water in a grassland at 2600 m a.s.l. 

Alessio Gentile, Ivan Bevilacqua, Davide Canone, Natalie Ceperley, Davide Gisolo, Mesmer N'Sassila, Maurizio Previati, Giulia Zuecco, Bettina Schaefli, and Stefano Ferraris

High Alpine catchments are precious water-resources since they act as natural storage reservoirs, storing water in the snow cover and in the subsurface and thereby providing water during the dry seasons. Thus, a deeper knowledge of the hydrological functioning of these systems is necessary, in particular to make climate change projections. The role of seasonality is crucial in these catchments that generally exhibit a snow-dominated hydro-climatic regime.

Here we use high-frequency observations of stable isotopes of water to identify the seasonal origin of streamwater in a high-elevation Alpine catchment located in the Valle d’Aosta Region, Italy. We quantify the relative contribution of winter and summer precipitation reaching the stream through the Seasonal Origin Index (SOIQ), calculated using the δ18O values and the volumes of precipitation and streamflow. Highly negative SOIQ values are obtained suggesting that streamwater is mainly composed of winter precipitation. Conversely, the Seasonal Origin Index for evapotranspiration (SOIET), which can be directly inferred from SOIQ, returns a positive value reflecting that plants preferentially take up water deriving from summer precipitation.

These findings allow us to develop a conceptual model of this Alpine system. This conceptual model suggests:

  • a deep infiltration component, mainly composed by snowmelt water, reaching the stream through a preferential flow.
  • a shallow infiltration component, predominantly represented by summer rainfall, that dominates the shallow soils and that is used by plants.

Therefore, we presume a seasonal compartmentalisation of water in this high-elevation catchment.

Nevertheless, a previous study in Switzerland revealed SOIQ ≈ 0 for the Allenbach and Dischmabach snow-dominated catchments, indicating that similar fractions of summer and winter precipitation become streamflow. This different result achieved in systems with an apparently similar functioning highlights the need for a deep insight into the flow paths governing high-elevation catchments and it opens the way for new challenges to understand the hydrological processes hidden behind this difference.

How to cite: Gentile, A., Bevilacqua, I., Canone, D., Ceperley, N., Gisolo, D., N'Sassila, M., Previati, M., Zuecco, G., Schaefli, B., and Ferraris, S.: Seasonal compartmentalisation of water in a grassland at 2600 m a.s.l., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9190, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9190, 2022.

EGU22-9346 | Presentations | HS2.3.3

Factors that control the isotopic composition of precipitation in northern Chile 

Enric Vázque-Suñe, Sonia Valdivielso, Ashkan Hassanzadeh, Emilio Custodio, and Rotman Criollo

The determination of aquifer recharge zones is necessary for optimal and sustainable management of water resources. Stable isotopes (δ18O and δ2H) are an effective tool to better understand the relationship between precipitation and groundwater. However, there are areas in the world such as northern Chile, where there is a lot of available isotopic information on groundwater but very heterogeneous isotopic information on precipitation. This study contributes to a better understanding of the spatial and meteorological variables that control the isotopic composition in precipitation in Northern Chile and to estimate these meteorological and stable isotopes in precipitation. Results show that in summer, the significant features for temperature, relative humidity and precipitation are altitude-latitude, latitude and altitude-latitude respectively. The stable isotopes of precipitation are controlled by temperature, altitude, latitude, longitude, and precipitation. The monthly estimation models of temperature, relative humidity and precipitation and three isotopic models (summer, winter and annual) are created based on the controlling features.

How to cite: Vázque-Suñe, E., Valdivielso, S., Hassanzadeh, A., Custodio, E., and Criollo, R.: Factors that control the isotopic composition of precipitation in northern Chile, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9346, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9346, 2022.

EGU22-9590 | Presentations | HS2.3.3

Studying the dynamic of a high Alpine catchment through the scope of multiple natural tracers 

Natalie Ceperley, Anthony Michelon, Harsh Beria, Torsten Vennemann, and Bettina Schaefli

 

The characterization of surface-subsurface water exchange in snow-dominated catchments is key to predicting streamflow generation under a warming climate. Stable isotopes of water (SIW) as flow path tracers have become very popular in such environments despite sampling challenges related to access in harsh winter conditions and the fact that such analyses remain costly compared to other natural tracers such as electric conductivity and water temperature. However, SIW alone capitalize on the well-known difference of the SIW ratios from water originating as summer rainfall versus winter snowfall, which propagate into the water stored in the subsurface and into streamflow.

In this presentation, we report our conclusions on the potential of year-round SIW samples to characterize the hydrological processes in the high elevation Vallon de Nant catchment (13.4 km²), located in the Western Swiss Alps. SIW ratios are shown to be particularly useful to characterize the interplay of direct (surface) and subsurface snowmelt input to the stream network during winter and early snow melt periods. We furthermore show that subsurface flow plays a critical role during all melt periods and our tracer data points towards the presence of snowmelt even during winter base flow.

We furthermore demonstrate the added value of soil and water temperature measurements to interpret SIW ratios in snow-dominated environments, by giving additional information on snow-free periods, on flow path depths and on temporary fast connections between surface and subsurface flow.

How to cite: Ceperley, N., Michelon, A., Beria, H., Vennemann, T., and Schaefli, B.: Studying the dynamic of a high Alpine catchment through the scope of multiple natural tracers, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9590, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9590, 2022.

Export of carbon from terrestrial catchments remains a poorly understood flux within the global carbon budget. In order to better understand the release and in-stream transport of dissolved organic carbon (DOC) in a small forested headwater catchment within the Bavarian Forest National Park (Germany), we characterized the stream-groundwater exchange along the headwater stream. We divided a 3000 m long stretch of the headwater stream into three topographically delineated sections that consisted of a steep upstream section (length 620m, elevations 888-967 m a.s.l.), a transition section (length 770 m, elevations 805-855 m a.s.l.) and a flat and wide downstream section (length 1330 m, elevations 770-805 m a.s.l., outlet of headwater catchment). Using sequential tracer injections of known masses of sodium chloride, we determined stream discharge and lateral exchange fluxes between stream and the surrounding riparian zone in the three stream sections and evaluated the effects of the resulting hydrologic turnover on stream water composition. We also compared the calculated lateral exchange fluxes with previously measured longitudinal profiles of Radon activities that can be used to locate groundwater inflow points. Discharge increased over the investigated 3000 m stretch in downstream direction, as expected, although the transition section did not show any change in discharge. The analysis of recovered tracer masses revealed that in the steep upstream section, the exchange fluxes consisted mainly of inflow of water into the stream. The transition section was characterized by an absence of exchange fluxes. In the downstream section, however, large inflows were offset by slightly lower outflows, resulting in a very pronounced exchange between stream water and riparian zone groundwater in this flat valley bottom. The spatial pattern of exchange fluxes was supported by the longitudinal Radon profiles, which pointed to a marked groundwater inflow in the downstream section. Our results suggest that the dominant source area of in-stream DOC at the outlet of our headwater catchment is the flat and wide valley bottom in the downstream section as most of the DOC released into the stream along the steep upstream section will be removed from the stream during the passage through the downstream section.

How to cite: Hopp, L., Kehr, J., and Blaurock, K.: Elucidating source areas of in-stream DOC by characterizing stream-groundwater exchange in a low mountain forested headwater catchment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9628, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9628, 2022.

EGU22-10348 | Presentations | HS2.3.3

The impact of snow cover changes on source water contributions and associated biogeochemical cycling in high latitude catchments 

Andrea L. Popp, Nicolas Valiente, Kristoffer Aalstad, Sigrid Trier Kjær, Peter Dörsch, Alexander Eiler, and Dag O. Hessen

High latitude regions are experiencing global warming more rapidly and significantly than any other region of the Earth. A warmer climate has already severely altered the cryosphere. Cryospheric changes such as snowpack reduction are known to be strongly coupled with the entire hydrologic cycle. However, relatively little is known about the nexus between snow cover changes, source water contributions to groundwater and surface water bodies and associated biogeochemical cycling in aquatic systems. 

To better understand the rapid changes occurring in cold region environments, we obtained field- and satellite-derived data from two sub-arctic catchments (one glaciated, one unglaciated) in the north-western corner of the Hardangervidda mountain plateau (South Central  Norway). During 2020 and 2021, we analyzed various water sources including streams, lakes, groundwater, snow and ice for environmental tracers (major ions, stable water isotopes, radon-222) and greenhouse gases (GHG; CO2, CH4 and N2O). Combining the environmental tracer data with a Bayesian end-member mixing modelling approach (Popp et al., 2019) allowed us to partition water source contributions to streams and lakes. Moreover, we used the noble gas radon to assess hyporheic exchange flow and short water residence times (Popp et al., 2021). To estimate snow cover anomalies in 2020 and 2021 compared to a five-year mean, we retrieved fractional snow cover durations (fSCDs) from 2016 to 2021 by merging Sentinel-2 and Landsat 8 imagery over Finse and applying a spectral unmixing algorithm (Aalstad et al., 2020). 

According to the satellite-derived data, 2020 was exceptionally snow-rich, while 2021 was a snow-poor year. Initial results suggest that the snow-poor year (2021) resulted in comparatively longer groundwater and stream water residence times. As expected, in 2021, surface waters and groundwaters showed lower fractions of snow and ice meltwater. This signal is, however, less pronounced in the unglaciated catchment. With this approach, we aim to hone our understanding of the response of water source partitioning and associated biogeochemical cycling, particularly greenhouse gas concentrations, to climate change-induced alterations in the snowpack. 

References:

Aalstad, K., Westermann, S., & Bertino, L. (2020). Evaluating satellite retrieved fractional snow-covered area at a high-Arctic site using terrestrial photography. Remote Sensing of Environment, 239, 111618,  http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.rse.2019.111618

Popp, A. L., Scheidegger, A., Moeck, C., Brennwald, M. S., & Kipfer, R. (2019). Integrating Bayesian groundwater mixing modeling with on-site helium analysis to identify unknown water sources. Water Resources Research, 55(12), 10602– 10615. https://doi.org/10.1029/2019WR025677

Popp, A. L., Pardo-Alvarez, A., Schilling, O., Musy, S., Peel, M., Purtschert, R., et al. (2021). A framework for untangling transient groundwater mixing and travel times. Water Resources Research, 57. https://doi.org/10.1029/2020WR028362

How to cite: Popp, A. L., Valiente, N., Aalstad, K., Trier Kjær, S., Dörsch, P., Eiler, A., and Hessen, D. O.: The impact of snow cover changes on source water contributions and associated biogeochemical cycling in high latitude catchments, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10348, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10348, 2022.

EGU22-11177 | Presentations | HS2.3.3

Stable Isotope Techniques for the Evaluation of Water Sources for Domestic Supply in Stellenbosch, South Africa 

Jared van Rooyen, Celine Meyer, Lucia Ortega, and Jodie Miller

During 2017-2018, the City of Cape Town, South Africa faced an unprecedented drought crisis with the six main water storages supplying Cape Town falling to a combined capacity of just under 20%. Throughout the crisis, groundwater was considered the most important alternative urban water supply source but also the most vulnerable to contamination through accidental return flows from the municipal network, private residences and agricultural industries. This project aimed to constrain the stable isotope chemistry of the water supply network in the Stellenbosch municipality and monitor the augmentation of groundwater into the network using stable isotopes. Long-term monitoring points have been established at 35 tap water sites, 20 private wells as well as at the 3 supply reservoirs that feed the municipal network. Rainwater (4 locations) and local surface water (6 locations) were also monitored over the one-year sampling period in 2021. Preliminary data show distinct isotopic signals associated with each supply reservoir as well as in the local groundwater. Rainfall is predominantly received in the winter season (May-Aug) and typically has more negative isotope delta values. Typical residence times in storage dams and reservoirs appear to be between 2-3 weeks in the winter and 3-4 weeks in the summer, according to stable isotope hydrograph separations. Domestic water supply is consolidated at 2 water treatment facilities in Stellenbosch, where isotope values of all 3 supply reservoirs mix. The amounts of water received from each reservoir changes throughout the year according to dam levels, this change is evident in the stable isotope values at the tap water sample locations. The data also shows significant return flow into the alluvial aquifer system during warmer months when private stakeholders’ water consumption is at its highest. Groundwater is expected to supplement this urban supply network in Q1-2 of 2022 and will likely disrupt the current distribution of stable isotopes in the network, providing further insight into the potential return flow into the local groundwater system. For longer term monitoring, tap water locations that receive the same supply have been identified and single locations (8 in total) have been selected to monitor through 2022 to optimise the monitoring network. Similarly, only 4 rainfall collection sites will continue monitoring. Interested stakeholders and policy makers include municipal supply managers as well as local farmers and industry that can use this data to develop water management strategies and identify areas where leaks or overuse is likely. Hydrograph separations would be more accurate with longer term monitoring rainfall, reservoir and tap water by identifying trends in storage residence time, mixing and release schedules throughout the supply systems. Although the data indicates that there are return flows into local groundwater, these results could not distinguish the mechanisms by which water is entering the system. Further monitoring in targeted areas is needed to constrain if return flows originate from leaks, irrigation or other urban recharge processes.

How to cite: van Rooyen, J., Meyer, C., Ortega, L., and Miller, J.: Stable Isotope Techniques for the Evaluation of Water Sources for Domestic Supply in Stellenbosch, South Africa, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11177, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11177, 2022.

EGU22-11417 | Presentations | HS2.3.3

Alpine water cycle unraveled by hydrogeological measurements, isotopes (18O/2H, 3H, 3He, 14C) and tracer gas analyses (CFC-11,-12,-113, SF6) 

Ramon Holzschuster, Daniel Elster, Martin Kralik, and Christine Stumpp

Alpine regions are becoming more sensitive to climate change and to understand the hydrogeological processes that follow extreme climatic events (flooding, drought, heavy precipitation and fast snow melt), the hydrologic conditions and geologic realities need to be understood. Our research project “Understanding of Extreme Climatological Impacts from Hydrogeological 4D Modelling” (EXTRIG; funded by the Austrian Academy of Sciences) contributes to this challenge by applying an innovative interdisciplinary approach in an Austrian alpine research area (Sibratsgfäll, Vorarlberg) with a catchment of 5 km² situated at an altitude between 800 and 1.400 m based on a cooperation between hydrogeologists, meteorologists, social scientists and the local population.

This poster study emphasizes on preliminary results of applied hydrogeological methods conducted between 2019 and 2021 to understand the local water cycle.

  • To determine surface discharge, radar monitoring stations was installed at each of the four main streams, flowing into the main river beneath the village. Calibration of the results was conducted with several salt dilution measurements. Additional salt dilution measurements helped to estimate diffuse surface and groundwater discharge into the main river.
  • Precipitation was measured in Sibratsgfäll (906m) and compared with precipitation measurements of two nearby weather stations and with past precipitation measurements of the area since 1990.
  • Evapotranspiration was calculated as ET0 with the Hargreaves method in two different approaches, one using the air temperature reconstructed from surrounding weather stations, the other using temperature measurements from the monitoring station in Sibratsgfäll.

The resulting data was used to calculate the amount of water infiltrating into the ground via water balance calculation. The yearly precipitation from December 2019 including November 2020 sums up to 2.600 mm/a and approx. 50% discharges via the main streams. Evapotranspiration can be estimated to be 22 to 32% with a large uncertainty leaving 18 to 28% of precipitating water to diffuse discharge and infiltration into the groundwater. Estimating that surface-near discharge is at least 10%, between 8 and 18% of precipitating water may infiltrate into the ground. Diffuse surface near discharge has shown to be higher after snow melt and in summer, but almost absent during colder periods. Furthermore, a complex network of shallow agricultural drainages may only partially dewater to streams but also contribute to surface-near discharge.

The monitoring of the stable 2H/18O-isotopes in a meteorological station (906m) and of Flysch-springs close to the mountain ridge of the recharge area allow to differentiate the recharge altitude. The vertical unsaturated infiltration in silt/sand dominated glaciolacustrine sediments were estimated by seasonal variation of 2H/18O-isotopes in soil-water to be 1m/year approximately. Precipitation in the Flysch dominated area at higher altitudes is transported slope-parallel in the upper part of the glacial sediments. The Mean Residence Time (MRT) of the shallow groundwater (<40m) estimated by a combination of isotopes 2H/18O, 3H/3He, 13C/14C and tracer gases (CFC, SF6) indicate ages between some months and 4 years. Deeper (>40m) artesian wells in the western part are dominated by MRT older than 30 years.

How to cite: Holzschuster, R., Elster, D., Kralik, M., and Stumpp, C.: Alpine water cycle unraveled by hydrogeological measurements, isotopes (18O/2H, 3H, 3He, 14C) and tracer gas analyses (CFC-11,-12,-113, SF6), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11417, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11417, 2022.

EGU22-11790 | Presentations | HS2.3.3

Multi-analytical approach to investigate sources of dissolved organic matter in a peri-urban watershed 

Amine Boukra, Matthieu Masson, Corinne Brosse, Loïc Richard, Mahaut Sourzac, Edith Parlanti, and Cécile Miège

Dissolved organic matter DOM corresponds to a complex mixture of molecules and macromolecules playing a major role in terrestrial and aquatic biogeochemical process. DOM heterogeneous composition allows it to have innumerable interactions with organic and inorganic compounds, affecting both their bioavailability and mobility in the environment. At the watershed scale, there are many sources of DOM towards the river such as diffuse inputs by leaching of different types of soils (e.g. forest, meadows, crops, urban impermeable areas...) or urban point inputs (storm overflows, WWTP discharges, stormwater discharges....). However, the influence of of all these sources on the composition of the aquatic DOM remains poorly understood to this day.

In this context, the main objective of this study was to build a methodology to detect the different sources of DOM in the rivers. Using a detailed characterization of DOM, the aim was to identify physicochemical markers and construct source-specific fingerprints. For this purpose, approximately 150 samples were collected from natural and anthropogenic sources of DOM (forest, agricultural, wastewater and urban runoff). All samples were analyzed using an innovative approach based on the use of a wide range of analytical techniques: dissolved organic carbon measurement, optical properties (UV-Visible, 3D fluorescence, size exclusion chromatography coupled with UV-fluorescence detection) and molecular composition (high-resolution mass spectrometry coupled with liquid chromatography). A large amount of data has been generated, and processed by classical (Anova, TukeyHSD) and multivariate (PCA, MFA, DFA) statistical approaches.

The results obtained allowed highlighting optical and molecular markers relevant for the identification of the selected sources. These markers inform on specific characteristics of DOM, such as the size of the molecules, the aromaticity content, the degree of humification, polarity and reactivity. In addition, complementarities and redundancies between optical and molecular characterization techniques is investigated. This research also contributes to select relevant markers for geochemical tracing models.

How to cite: Boukra, A., Masson, M., Brosse, C., Richard, L., Sourzac, M., Parlanti, E., and Miège, C.: Multi-analytical approach to investigate sources of dissolved organic matter in a peri-urban watershed, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11790, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11790, 2022.

EGU22-11867 | Presentations | HS2.3.3

The Mobility and Interaction of Poly(ethylene glycol) in Column Experiments with Cambisol 

Nimo Kwarkye, Elisabeth Lehmann, Ivo Nischang, Jürgen Vitz, Ulrich Schubert, Thomas Ritschel, and Kai Totsche

The transport of colloidal organic matter (OM) in soil is governed by colloidal hydrodynamics and frequently features strong interactions at the biogeochemical interfaces provided in the soil pore space. Conventional reactive tracers used to study solute transport usually fail to cover the hydrodynamics of small-sized colloidal OM. This impedes a clear observation of transport phenomena that are characteristic for these OM fractions. Tailor-made poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG) is available in a molar mass range featuring similar hydrodynamic sizes as colloidal OM. Thus, characterizing the transport of PEG could help to decipher the transport behavior of colloidal OM in soil.
We studied the transport of PEG in soil columns filled with homogenized Cambisol material. PEG was labelled with fluorophores to enable a highly resolved and sensitive detection via fluorescence spectroscopy. Parallel factor analysis (PARAFAC) was applied to the measured excitation-emission matrices to estimate the concentration of PEG in the column effluent. Additionally, batch experiments were conducted to determine the adsorption isotherms of PEG with the column substrate and typical soil minerals.
The resulting breakthrough of PEG was retarded by about an order of magnitude and with a pronounced tailing when compared to the breakthrough of non-reactive NaCl. The retardation points towards organo-mineral associations. This was corroborated by the adsorption observed in batch experiments with high maximum adsorption capacity with homogenized soil and clay minerals. The observed tailing may be due to the varying molecular dimensions of PEG contributing to kinetic interactions with soil minerals.
With representative hydrodynamics, varying molecular dimensions as colloidal OM and the possibility of forming organo-mineral associations with soil minerals, tailor-made PEGs are promising candidates to also follow the transport of other colloidal OM.

How to cite: Kwarkye, N., Lehmann, E., Nischang, I., Vitz, J., Schubert, U., Ritschel, T., and Totsche, K.: The Mobility and Interaction of Poly(ethylene glycol) in Column Experiments with Cambisol, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11867, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11867, 2022.

EGU22-13405 | Presentations | HS2.3.3

Tracing nitrate pollution within the Agneby subcatchment, SE Côte d'Ivoire (West Africa) 

Isimemen Osemwegie, David Soto, Christine Stumpp, Julien Kalpy Coulibaly, and Barbara Reichert

Coastal environments around the globe provide services and support to the population. However, they are frequently impacted by human-based activities in addition to seawater intrusion problems. These lowland groundwater resources are exposed to a significant amount and types of pollutants, the most significant of which is nitrate. Tracking and quantifying the sources of nitrate that pollute surface and groundwater systems can be challenging without the use of environmental tracers such as nitrate isotopes. This study explored how changes in regional flow paths impact the nitrogen concentrations and origin of pollution in coastal waters during high tides. Water samples were collected from surface (rivers, lagoon and Atlantic shore) and groundwater (wells and boreholes) systems along the east coast of Côte d'Ivoire during the boreal summer (October). Water samples were analysed for major ions, dissolved nitrogen concentrations, coliforms presence/amount, as well as dual nitrate isotopes (δ15N-NO3- and δ18O-NO3-). Bayesian isotope mixing models were conducted to estimate the contributions of potential main sources (wastewater, seawater, atmospheric deposition, and agrochemicals). In some areas, nitrate inputs were found likely coming from wastewater sources. Nitrate concentration in groundwater was high at several sites. Some groundwater samples (n = 7) exceeded the WHO drinking water limit of nitrate concentrations of 50 mg/l, and most groundwater samples had high levels of total coliforms (>500 cfu/100ml). However, great isotope variation found in both surface and subsurface water samples suggested a spatial differential impact and origin of nitrate pollution, which is in agreement with the modelling. These water resources are the primary source of water for 53% of the local population and an alternative domestic water source for 97%, which highlights the importance of determining the main pollution sources for sustainable development. We expected that groundwater may have been better protected from nitrate pollution than lagoon surface water during wet periods, but this might have not been the case.

How to cite: Osemwegie, I., Soto, D., Stumpp, C., Coulibaly, J. K., and Reichert, B.: Tracing nitrate pollution within the Agneby subcatchment, SE Côte d'Ivoire (West Africa), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13405, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13405, 2022.

EGU22-1264 | Presentations | HS2.3.5

Transport and removal of spores of Bacillus subtilis in an alluvial gravel aquifer at varying flow rates and implications for setback distances 

Thomas James Oudega, Gerhard Lindner, Regina Sommer, Andreas Farnleitner, Georg Kerber, Julia Derx, Margaret E. Stevenson, and Alfred Paul Blaschke

To minimize the risk of waterborne disease outbreaks, drinking water wells should have a sufficiently large setback distance from potential sources of contamination, e.g. a nearby river. The aim of this study was to provide insight in regards to microbial contamination of groundwater under different hydraulic gradients, which can vary over time due to changes in river stage, season or pumping rate. The effects of these changes, and how they affect removal parameters, are not completely understood. In this study, field tracer tests were carried out in Vienna, Austria to evaluate the ability of subsurface media to attenuate Bacillus subtilis spores, used as a surrogate for Cryptosporidium and Campylobacter. The hydraulic gradient between injection and extraction was controlled by changing the pumping rate (1, 5 or 10 l/s) of a pumping well at the test site.  Attachment and detachment rates were determined using a HYDRUS-3D model and setback distances were calculated based on the 60-day travel time, as well as a quantitative microbial risk assessment (QMRA) approach. It was shown that scale must be taken into consideration when determining removal rate (λ), which is crucial for the calculation of setback distances, and that the effect of flow rate becomes more important at lower removal rates.

How to cite: Oudega, T. J., Lindner, G., Sommer, R., Farnleitner, A., Kerber, G., Derx, J., Stevenson, M. E., and Blaschke, A. P.: Transport and removal of spores of Bacillus subtilis in an alluvial gravel aquifer at varying flow rates and implications for setback distances, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1264, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1264, 2022.

EGU22-1833 | Presentations | HS2.3.5

Estimating E. coli concentrations in irrigation pond waters with machine learning algorithms 

Matthew Stocker, Yakov Pachepsky, and Robert Hill

The microbial quality of irrigation water is an important factor in the field of food safety. Concentrations of the microbial contamination indicator, Escherichia coli (E. coli), are used to make microbial water quality determinations. However, relationships between the concentrations of E. coli and water quality parameters are often non-linear. Machine learning (ML) algorithms have been shown to make accurate predictions in datasets with complex relationships. The purpose of this work was to estimate E. coli concentrations in agricultural pond waters with several popular ML algorithms and observe the differences in model performances. Two ponds in mid-Atlantic U. S. were monitored biweekly during the irrigation seasons of 2016, 2017, and 2018. Samples were collected across the two ponds and E. coli concentrations were measured concurrently with 12 other water quality parameters. The resulting datasets were used to estimate E. coli concentrations using stochastic gradient boosting machines, random forest, support vector machines, and k-nearest neighbor algorithms. The performance of the algorithms was compared by treating performance metrics as statistics obtained by Monte-Carlo modeling of the algorithms. The results of repeated 10-fold cross-validation showed that the random forest model provided the lowest RMSE value for predicted E. coli concentrations in both ponds for individual years and when multi-year datasets were evaluated. However, in most cases there was no significant difference (P > 0.05) between RMSE of random forest and other ML models. For individual years, the normalized RMSE of the predicted E. coli concentrations (log10 CFU 100 mL-1) ranged from 0.071 to 0.124 and from 0.102 to 0.155 for Ponds 1 and 2, respectively. For the 3-year datasets, these values were 0.119 and 0.132 for Ponds 1 and 2, respectively.  Turbidity, dissolved organic matter content, specific conductance, chlorophyll concentration, and temperature were the most important predictors as identified by a recursive feature elimination analysis. Model predictive performance did not significantly differ when the 5 least expensive and time-consuming predictors were used as compared with the complete set of predictors. Machine learning appeared to be efficient in discerning complex relationships between E. coli and water quality parameters which describe the aquatic habitat.  

How to cite: Stocker, M., Pachepsky, Y., and Hill, R.: Estimating E. coli concentrations in irrigation pond waters with machine learning algorithms, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1833, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1833, 2022.

EGU22-2062 | Presentations | HS2.3.5

Comparison of bacteriophage MS2, norovirus, rotavirus and adenovirus transport and attenuation in alluvial aquifer media 

Liping Pang, Kata Farkas, Susan Lin, Joanne Hewitt, Aruni Premaratne, and Murray Close

Contamination of potable groundwater by human enteric viruses pose serious health risks. Our knowledge about virus subsurface transport relies largely on using bacteriophages as surrogates. Relatively few studies have compared enteric viruses, especially norovirus, with phage surrogates regarding their transport behaviour.  Given that bacteriophages and enteric viruses have dissimilar physiochemical properties, differences in their behaviour and interactions in subsurface media and groundwater are possible.

Laboratory column studies were conducted to examine the attenuation and transport of norovirus and MS2 bacteriophage in alluvial sand (d10=0.25 mm), and rotavirus, adenovirus and MS2 in alluvial gravel (d10=2 mm) in 2 mM NaCl (pH 6.6–6.9) at pore velocities of 4.6–5.4 m/day. The experimental data were evaluated using colloid filtration theory and HYDRUS-1D two-site attachment-detachment modelling.

The log10 reduction values, mass recoveries, attachment efficiencies and irreversible deposition rate constants indicated that compared with MS2, norovirus removal was lower in the alluvial sand and the removal of rotavirus and adenovirus was markedly greater in the alluvial gravel. Modelling suggested virus attachment was reversible, and that the rates of virus detachment were faster than the rates of virus attachment, which favoured free virus transport. Hence, continual virus transport through subsurface media poses health risks if viruses are not inactivated, and virus remobilisation could cause contamination events. Thus, virus transport predictions in subsurface media should incorporate virus attachment reversibility.

Some of these observations align with other studies’ findings, but viruses behave very differently in different systems; hence, disparate relationships in other systems have been described, especially in the presence of multivalent cations and organic matter. Our understanding of enteric virus mobility and removal is limited, and data based on bacteriophages may not represent enteric virus behaviour accurately. Thus, further research is needed into enteric virus transport, especially that of norovirus, in different subsurface media under a variety of experimental conditions.

How to cite: Pang, L., Farkas, K., Lin, S., Hewitt, J., Premaratne, A., and Close, M.: Comparison of bacteriophage MS2, norovirus, rotavirus and adenovirus transport and attenuation in alluvial aquifer media, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2062, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2062, 2022.

EGU22-2157 | Presentations | HS2.3.5

Water quality modelling to assess sources and transport of pathogens within uMsunduzi catchment, South Africa 

Zesizwe Ngubane, Viktor Bergion, Bloodless Dzwairo, Karin Troell, Isaac Amoah, Thor Axel Stenström, and Ekaterina Sokolova

Water quality modelling is essential to integrated water resources management and decision-making, as it improves the understanding of the spatial and temporal dynamics of chemical and microbial pollution in a river system. Understanding of the spatio-temporal dynamics of pollution and accurate prediction of its pollution hotspots are vital to improving the microbial quality of surface water. South African rivers generally receive waste from inadequate wastewater infrastructure, mines, and farming activities, among others. The uMsunduzi River in KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa, is among rivers with recorded poor to very poor water quality. To identify parts of the uMsunduzi River that are polluted by Escherichia coli (E. coli) and Cryptosporidium, chosen to represent bacteria and protozoan parasites respectively, this study mapped out pollutants emanating from point and non-point sources using the Soil and Water Assessment Tool (SWAT) model. SWAT uses a combination of empirical and physically based equations that use readily available inputs and enables users to study long term impacts. Streamflow calibration in the upper and lower reaches of the catchment showed good performance with R2 of 0.64 and 0.58, respectively. The SWAT module for predicting microorganism loads and concentrations in the river was used. The main faecal sources in the uMsunduzi catchment can be summarised as: wastewater treatment plant (WWTP), broken sewers in the urban area, and faecal droppings from grazing livestock. The microorganism loads from these sources were described  in SWAT using data from different local water authorities and stakeholders. With respect to E. coli, the output from SWAT was compared to observed data from four points within the catchment representing upper rural, upper urban, lower urban, and lower rural parts. The output from the SWAT model showed slightly low variability, however, the trend in the SWAT model simulations followed the observed data patterns in most subbasins. The trend with Cryptosporidium was such that concentrations are higher downstream the WWTP than upstream, though insufficient data exists to compare the model Cryptosporidium output with observed data. Overall, the model microbial output showed that in rural areas, animals contribute more to pathogen loads than human sources. Human sources were more prominent in urban areas owing to the major contributions from wastewater infrastructure. The microbial output data from the SWAT model were used as input for quantitative microbial risk assessment (QMRA). Considering that not all E. coli are pathogenic, 8% of E. coli was assumed as pathogenic following various studies. The exposure routes investigated were direct ingestion of the uMsunduzi River water during recreational swimming, canoeing training, and drinking.  The exposed population was categorised as children (<18 years old) and adults (>18 years old). The probability of infection for most users exceeds the acceptable level for drinking and recreation as outlined in the South African water quality guidelines and by the World Health Organisation (WHO).

The results of this study can be used as a baseline to assess the economic and health implications of different management plans, resulting in better-informed, cost-effective, and impactful decision-making.

How to cite: Ngubane, Z., Bergion, V., Dzwairo, B., Troell, K., Amoah, I., Stenström, T. A., and Sokolova, E.: Water quality modelling to assess sources and transport of pathogens within uMsunduzi catchment, South Africa, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2157, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2157, 2022.

Chromium (VI) is a known toxin and carcinogen which is still abundantly used in various industries primarily as an anti-corrosive agent. Thus in case of accidental spillage of it, without proper treatment and disposal, it might leach into the ground and pollute the soil and the groundwater table. The reactivity and solubility of Cr(VI) is extremely high in water making it more dangerous if consumed. The transport and fate of a contaminant in sub-surface porous media is governed by the processes of advection, dispersion and sorption. The transport of Cr (VI) is highly influenced by the processes of adsorption and desorption. The soil sediments have different physical and chemical properties which affect their adsorption efficiencies to a large extent. Hence, the knowledge of adsorptive capacities of the soil sediments is necessary to determine the time of travel of the contaminant plume in the porous media. The present study is conducted to determine the adsorption efficiency of natural soil if Cr(VI) gets accidentally leaked from a stainless steel manufacturing plant located in Rupnagar district of Punjab, India. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDS) were performed to assess the surface morphology and chemical composition of the soil layers located above the local water table. The initial concentration of Cr(VI) was taken to be 2 mg/l to conduct the batch adsorption studies. The optimum values of parameters like: dose of soil, change of pH of the solution, the time of contact between the adsorbate and the adsorbent and concentration of metal ion adsorbed, are determined in the study. Langmuir, Freundlich and BET adsorption isotherms along with kinetic models were also examined to investigate the mechanisms of adsorption.

Keywords: Chromium (VI); Adsorption; Natural attenuation; Batch adsorption studies; Adsorption isotherms; Kinetic models.

How to cite: Ganguly, S. and Ganguly, S.: Adsorption of Chromium (VI) by soil sediments in heterogeneous porous media: a case study in Rupnagar district of Punjab, India., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2323, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2323, 2022.

The main objective of this study was to quantify the distribution of pathogens and antibiotic resistance genes in the vadose zone of the soil aquifer treatment (SAT) system. Soil samples were collected from a treated wastewater infiltration basin to a depth of 25 m in two sampling events: (i) at the end of flooding and infiltration and (ii) following three days of drying before the subsequent flooding event. Viable count parallelly of bacteria compared with microscopic live/dead count and enzymatic activity FDA hydrolysis. The abundance of the total bacteria, coliform, antibiotic resistance bacteria (ARB), were examined.  In addition, total genomic DNA was extracted from soil samples (n-28 for both flooding and drying cycle), and quantitative PCR (qPCR) was used to determine the relative abundance of antimicrobial resistance genes (ARGs), including 1 integron-integrase intI1, blaTEM, blaCTX-M-32, sul1, qnrS.

In both sampling events, the results demonstrate that the distribution of antibiotic resistance genes in the vadose zone exhibits a similar pattern to the one obtained for the examined pathogen. We observed a high concentration of pathogens in topsoil layers and a gradual decline with depth. In this presentation, the profile obtained will be described and discussed with pathogens and ARGs transport and retention in the SAT system. 

 

 

How to cite: Yadav, N., Ronen, Z., and Arye, G.: Distribution of pathogens and antibiotic resistance genes in the vadose zone of soil-aquifer treatment (SAT) system., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2616, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2616, 2022.

EGU22-3022 | Presentations | HS2.3.5

The fate of nanoparticles in soils and saturated systems 

Sondra Klitzke

Nanoparticles (NP) enter soils through various pathways. In soils, they undergo different interactions with the liquid and the solid phase. These interactions may govern the chemical and colloidal stability of the NP and hence affect their prospective fate.  Understanding NP fate in saturated systems is of relevance in order to assess any potential risks for the contamination of groundwater, which often serves as a drinking water resource.

In the literature, a fair body of knowledge has been established on the individual impacts of dissolved organic matter (DOM), multivalent ions, and intrinsic particle size on NP colloidal stability. However, little is known about the interactive effects of these parameters as well as the impact of the type of soilborne DOM. In batch studies, using different types of soil solutions, we investigated some of these interactions as well as the effect of DOM characteristics on NP stability.

Further, the potential risk for a breakthrough of both environmentally ‘aged’ NP and synthetically coated NP in an artificial riverbank filtration system was studied. In addition, factors leading to the remobilization of initially immobilized particles were identified.

The presented work provides an overview on how environmentally-induced changes in NP’ surface characteristic control their fate in soils and water resources.

How to cite: Klitzke, S.: The fate of nanoparticles in soils and saturated systems, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3022, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3022, 2022.

EGU22-3762 | Presentations | HS2.3.5

Climate change impact on precipitation extremes and associated infection risks from combined sewer overflows 

Hatice Seda Kilic, Hannes Müller-Thomy, Silvia Cervero-Arago, Rita Linke, Gerhard Lindner, Julia Walochnik, Regina Sommer, Komma Juergen, Andreas Farnleitner, A.Paul Blaschke, and Julia Derx

The climate-induced increase in precipitation extremes leads to more frequent combined sewer overflows (CSOs) from wastewater treatment plants into urban rivers, which are often used for recreation. This study simultaneously investigates the changes in precipitation extremes, CSO frequency and volume, the resulting fecal microbial loads to streams, and the human infection risks during recreational use.

Our model approach consists of four steps. First, a disaggregation model is used to increase the temporal resolution of the 22 climate scenarios used to cope with the dynamics of urban hydrological processes. Then, continuous simulations are performed using an urban hydrological model (SWMM) for the C20 period (1971-2000), the near-term future (2021-2050), and the long-term future (2071-2100). We simulated the microbial load of the combined sewer discharge with the fecal indicators E. coli, C. perfringens, a human-associated genetic fecal marker HF183/BacR287, and the pathogens Giardia and Cryptosporidium spp. To determine the dilution in the stream, rainfall-runoff modeling is performed using a conceptual semi-distributed hydrological model in the third step for the urban catchment towards the point of CSO discharge. In the final step, a quantitative microbial risk assessment (QMRA) is performed to quantify the potential human infection risks during recreational use.

A hypothetical urban drainage system serves as the study area, which was adapted to the local conditions of a subarea of the city of Vienna including a receiving river. For the precipitation extremes, average increases in precipitation of 13 % for the near future and 19 % for the long-term future are determined over the 22 climate scenarios and 5 rainfall stations considered (extreme event durations 5 min to 24 h, recurrence intervals 0.33 yrs to 10 yrs).

The increase in precipitation extremes results in a higher number of CSOs for both the near- and long-term future. The simulated discharge of the receiving river is often still unaffected by the rainfall event at the time of discharge due to the concentration-time of the catchment, resulting in no direct relationship between discharge and CSO. A realistic estimate of the microbial load discharges during extreme rainfall events is possible for the first time based on the simultaneous continuous hydrological and urban hydrological models in this study.

The resulting concentrations of E. coli, C. perfringens, HF183/BacR287, Giardia, and Cryptosporidium spp. in the receiving water as well as the potential infection risks are analyzed separately on a seasonal and annual basis. For both pathogens, infection risks in the distant future are found to increase in all seasons, with lower increases in the winter months (December-February) than in the rest of the year. The highest risk of infection is found in autumn (September-November).

How to cite: Kilic, H. S., Müller-Thomy, H., Cervero-Arago, S., Linke, R., Lindner, G., Walochnik, J., Sommer, R., Juergen, K., Farnleitner, A., Blaschke, A. P., and Derx, J.: Climate change impact on precipitation extremes and associated infection risks from combined sewer overflows, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3762, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3762, 2022.

EGU22-4739 | Presentations | HS2.3.5

Dynamics of pathogens and fecal indicators during riverbank filtration in times of high and low river levels 

He Wang, Dustin Knabe, Irina Engelhardt, Björn Droste, Hans-Peter Rohns, Christine Stumpp, Johannes Ho, and Christian Griebler

Riverbank filtration is an established and quantitatively important approach to mine high-quality raw water for 
drinking water production. Bacterial fecal indicators are routinely used to monitor hygienic raw water quality, 
however, their applicability in viral contamination has been questioned repeatedly. Additionally, there are 
concerns that the increasing frequency and intensity of meteorological and hydrological events, i.e., heavy 
precipitation and droughts leading to high and low river levels, may impair riverbank filtration performance. In 
this study, we explored the removal of adenovirus compared with several commonly used bacterial and viral 
water quality indicators during different river levels. In a seasonal study, water from the Rhine River, a series of 
groundwater monitoring wells, and a production well were regularly collected and analyzed for adenovirus, 
coliphages, E. coli, C. perfringens, coliform bacteria, the total number of prokaryotic cells (TCC), and the number 
of virus-like particles (TVPC) using molecular and cultivation-based assays. Additionally, basic physico-chemical 
parameters, including temperature, pH, dissolved organic carbon, and nutrients, were measured. The highest 
log10 reduction during the >72 m of riverbank filtration from the river channel to the production well was 
observed for coliforms (>3.7 log10), followed by E. coli (>3.4 log10), somatic coliphages (>3.1 log10), 
C. perfringens (>2.5 log10), and F+ coliphages (>2.1 log10) at high river levels. Adenovirus decreased by 1.6–3.1 
log units in the first monitoring well (>32 m) and was not detected in further distant wells. The highest removal 
efficiency of adenovirus and most other viral and bacterial fecal indicators was achieved during high river levels, 
which were characterized by increased numbers of pathogens and indicators. During low river levels, coliforms 
and C. perfringens were occasionally present in raw water at the production well. Adenovirus, quantified via 
droplet digital PCR, correlated with E. coli, somatic coliphages, TCC, TVPC, pH, and DOC at high river levels. At 
low river levels, adenoviruses correlated with coliforms, TVPC, pH, and water travel time. We conclude that 
although standard fecal indicators are insufficient for assessing hygienic raw water quality, a combination of 
E. coli, coliforms and somatic coliphages can assess riverbank filtration performance in adenovirus removal. 
Furthermore, effects of extreme hydrological events should be studied on an event-to-event basis at high spatial 
and temporal resolutions. Finally, there is an urgent need for a lower limit of detection for pathogenic viruses in 
natural waters. Preconcentration of viral particles from larger water volumes (>100 L) constitutes a promising 
strategy.

How to cite: Wang, H., Knabe, D., Engelhardt, I., Droste, B., Rohns, H.-P., Stumpp, C., Ho, J., and Griebler, C.: Dynamics of pathogens and fecal indicators during riverbank filtration in times of high and low river levels, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4739, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4739, 2022.

EGU22-5622 | Presentations | HS2.3.5

Impact of Reynolds number on tracer spreading in porous media 

Arvind Bairwa, Manish Shukla, Rakesh Khosa, and Rathinasamy Maheswaran

Interfacial transport across the free surface flow and obstructed region is critical for understanding the scalar transport and mixing in physical situations such as proximity of open water with vegetation in the aquatic system, sediment-water interface (SWI) in river and estuaries, tree canopies in the atmospheric boundary layer, mixing in coral reef and biofilm formation over biological systems. This interaction occurs over a wide range of Spatio-temporal scales due to fast and slow flow in the free layer and porous media which is determined by the key parameters such as degree of flow unsteadiness and porosity. In these situations, understanding and predicting the spreading of the scalar is crucial for water quality assessment and the health of aquatic ecosystems. In this study, we conduct a high-resolution numerical simulation of an array of circular cylinders packed with channels at moderate Reynolds number (Re). As the Reynolds number increases gradually, we observe that particle tends to form coherent structures at the interface as well as filamentation of tracer behind the cylinders. It is worthwhile to note that filaments are a good candidate for mixing as they enhance concentration gradient which is easily erased by molecular diffusion. Breakthrough curves (BTCs) are measured at the midpoint and outlet of the domain to investigate the spreading of tracers using a random walk-based particle tracking method. We found that as the Re decreases, BTCs become broader because the tracer spends a longer time near cylinder boundaries and within the coherent structure before exiting the domain. These BTCs are successfully predicted by the continuous-time random walk model.

How to cite: Bairwa, A., Shukla, M., Khosa, R., and Maheswaran, R.: Impact of Reynolds number on tracer spreading in porous media, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5622, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5622, 2022.

EGU22-6483 | Presentations | HS2.3.5

Improving microbial quality assessment for irrigation water in ponds using the Environmental Fluid Dynamic Code 

Seongyun Kim, Matthew Stocker, Manan Sharma, and Yakov Pachepsky

Microbial quality of irrigation water is a public health concern. Management decisions are routinely based on concentrations of fecal indicator bacteria like Escherichia coli (E. coli) in water sources. In the case of irrigation ponds, water samples are often collected near the banks and at shallow depths due to convenient access. However, we hypothesized that water is drawn from locations far from the shoreline and far below the water surface during irrigation events. We used the Environmental Fluid Dynamic Code (EFDC) water quality model to test this hypothesis by simulating water and tracer movement in a working irrigation pond. The initial condition datasets included (1) setting the tracer concentration to zero at the shoreline and to unity in the interior and (2) setting the tracer concentration to zero at the surface water layer and to unity in the deeper layers. Tracer transport to the intake location was simulated with and without wind effect. The simulated concentrations at the intake were close to unity, indicating an insignificant contribution of the near-surface and nearshore layers to the intake concentrations. Four years of biweekly sampling of nearshore and interior locations in two irrigation ponds revealed statistically different average E. coli concentrations between nearshore and interior locations under various environmental conditions. Additionally, when three-dimensional monitoring was conducted, significantly different E. coli concentrations between water depth layers (e.g., 0 m to 0.5 m, 0.5 m to 1 m, 1 m to 1.5 m, etc.) were frequently observed. Mixing water from different depths or locations in the same water body in response to the initiation of irrigation did not homogenize the tracer in the pond. Hydrodynamic modeling showed that the E. coli concentration at the intake changed over the course of the irrigation event in response to the 3D spatial heterogeneity of concentrations measured in the pond water. The results of this work show that 1) water samples should be collected from the pond interior at depths close to the irrigation water intake, and 2) water must be sampled several times during irrigation events if samples are taken at the irrigated fields rather than in ponds.

How to cite: Kim, S., Stocker, M., Sharma, M., and Pachepsky, Y.: Improving microbial quality assessment for irrigation water in ponds using the Environmental Fluid Dynamic Code, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6483, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6483, 2022.

EGU22-6608 | Presentations | HS2.3.5

Transport of dynamically fragmented polystyrene (PS) microplastics through saturated porous media 

Ahmad Ameen, Margaret E. Stevenson, Stefan Jakwerth, and A. Paul Blaschke

Insufficient information is available about the transport of fragmented microplastics in groundwater systems. To understand the transport processes, lab-scale column experiments were performed using fragmented microplastics. To mimic realistic microplastics present in the environment, polystyrene (PS) microspheres of diameter 3 and 10 µm were crushed dynamically into fragmented microplastics for injection. We examined the impacts of key physiochemical factors like concentration, soil grain size, flow velocity, ionic strength and straining. The detection and quantification of fragmented microplastics was carried out using solid-phase cytometry (SPC). We observed a high breakthrough of microplastics in coarse soils, and in fine soils, a lesser breakthrough of microplastics was observed because of straining phenomena and wedging of microplastics. Other influencing factors were: (i) greater flow velocity caused detachment and resulted in low attachment efficiency and (ii) ionic strength was found to have a smaller impact on microplastics transport due to their strong negative charge. Results and conclusions from the study provide a baseline of valuable information in order to better understand the mobility of small-sized fragmented microplastics through the soil-aquifer system.

How to cite: Ameen, A., Stevenson, M. E., Jakwerth, S., and Blaschke, A. P.: Transport of dynamically fragmented polystyrene (PS) microplastics through saturated porous media, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6608, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6608, 2022.

In this work, we investigate the interplay between dose-response models and permeability heterogeneity on the resilience of an aquifer contaminated with emerging contaminants under uncertainty. We focus our attention to Bisphenol A (BPA) in groundwater which is known to cause endocrine-related effects on humans. Health risks are computed through two distinct BPA dose-response models. The first one is a non-monotonic dose-response (NMDR) model while the second one is a monotonic dose-response (MDR) model. Through the use of a Monte Carlo numerical framework, we simulate transport of BPA from a source to an environmentally sensitive target in a three-dimensional aquifer. Results indicate the importance of considering both hydrological and toxicological information in water resources management. The magnitude and the uncertainty associated with the resilience loss are strongly impacted by the functional shape of the dose-response model and the level of heterogeneity. Further analysis indicates that the role of the ratio of the volumetric flow rate passing through the source zone to the ambient groundwater flow rate in controlling the aquifer resilience loss.

How to cite: Im, J., Rizzo, C., and de Barros, F.: Analysis of the joint impact of dose-response models and permeability heterogeneity on aquifer resilience loss due to Bisphenol A contamination, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6668, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6668, 2022.

EGU22-10808 | Presentations | HS2.3.5

Sorption of Per- and Polyfluoroalkyl Substances (PFAS) by Porous Media in Saturated Zone: A Review Study 

Ali A.A. Obeid, Ottavia Zoboli, Claudia Gundacker, Julia Derx, Alfred Paul Blaschke, and Matthias Zessner

PFAS are of emerging concern due to their high environmental persistence, human health effects, and bioaccumulation attributed to their chemical properties. These chemical properties make them preferable for many industrial and domestic purposes. In turn, PFAS are emitted from a vast amount of sources and eventually reach the surface water and groundwater environments. The most critical pathways for groundwater are infiltration via the unsaturated zone and riverbank filtration. Natural filtration of PFAS reduces the risk of PFAS contamination, and sorption is considered the most crucial removal mechanism of PFAS from saturated porous media. This study aims to better understand the sorption processes and factors affecting the affinity of soil to sorb different types of PFAS. A thorough understanding of these processes is needed to model PFAS fate and transport in groundwater and estimate human health's impact. To meet this aim, we conducted a literature survey involving PFAS sorption behavior to soil and external sorbents in batch and column experimental studies and monitoring studies in the field.

PFAS tail group are hydrophobic organic chemicals. Hydrophobic interactions are thus one of the main sorption mechanisms in groundwater, especially when the soil has a higher organic carbon content. Several studies have found that the retention of PFAS is increased with the increase in PFAS hydrophobicity and the amount of organic matter in the soil. Another important forces affecting the interaction of PFAS with soil are the electrostatic forces. Many PFAS are present in the environment in their anion form and bond to positively charged soil surfaces. Soils with a negative charge surface can repel PFAS and reduce retention. Other minor processes such as the hydrogen bond and PFAS functional group forming complexes can increase the sorption to soil. Soil properties and solution chemistry significantly affect these forces and bonds and can either reduce or increase the affinity of PFAS sorption to soil. The presence of co-contaminants and nonaqueous phase liquids in groundwater further affects these processes.

Difficulties in degrading PFAS compounds led to alternative ways of remediation, such as stabilizing PFAS in soil by employing sorption processes. With the gained knowledge, external sorption enhancers can be used to increase the PFAS sorption besides altering the solution chemistry to maximize the retention and stabilization of PFAS in soil.

The dynamics of the sorption process are affected by preferential flow and intra-sorbent diffusion, leading to rate-limited sorption effects. These dynamics are essential for the model selection and estimating the time needed for the clean-up during remediation.

How to cite: Obeid, A. A. A., Zoboli, O., Gundacker, C., Derx, J., Blaschke, A. P., and Zessner, M.: Sorption of Per- and Polyfluoroalkyl Substances (PFAS) by Porous Media in Saturated Zone: A Review Study, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10808, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10808, 2022.

Vembanad Estuary is located in the southern part of India and is also the country's longest lake. Its outlet to the Arabian sea is near Cochin. Particle trapping is one of the main issues found in this estuary. It causes the contaminants to stay in the region for extended durations, which can cause multiple problems. A large number of pollutants enter the Vembanad estuary due to the six rivers that discharge in the Vembanad lake. It is essential to comprehend the movement of these contaminants through the estuary to identify their effect on aquatic ecology and water quality. Flow in the lake is affected by numerous forcing parameters like inflowing rivers, tides, and other boundary conditions. The lack of standard methods to model particulate flow in such a complex environment poses a challenge in understanding flow dynamics and requires identifying new modeling methods.

In the present work, various sections of Vembanad are simulated to identify the trapping zones of the system. Lagrangian simulations of these individual parts of the lake are performed. The simulation results are further analyzed to obtain Lagrangian coherent structures (LCS) using Finite-Time Lyapunov Exponents (FTLE). LCS based on maximum FTLE values shows the dynamic boundaries present in the system, which help identify regions where potential trapping of non-inertial contaminants can occur. Lagrangian particle tracking also aids in recording the total movement of particulate matter from its initial position, which is used to find the resident time of these particles. The result of the study can also be used to find the potential risk posed by the non-inertial contaminants at a location based on their resident times.   

How to cite: Shukla, M., Bairwa, A., and Khosa, R.: A dynamic system theory approach to identify contaminant trapping zones in Vembanad Estuary using Lagrangian Coherent structures, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11456, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11456, 2022.

EGU22-106 | Presentations | HS2.3.6

Eichhornia crassipes macrophytes for treatment of heavy metal contaminated water 

Anuradha Anuradha and Brijesh Kumar Yadav

Heavy metal contaminated water is a major threat to human and aquatic life. Chromium is a toxic heavy metal discharged into surface water mainly due to industrial applications. Physico-chemical technologies to treat chromium-contaminated waters are expensive, especially for developing countries. Macrophytes-based phytoremediation is a competent method of water treatment that is simple, cost-effective, and provides satisfactory results. In the present study, we investigated the potential of macrophyte Eichhornia crassipes, commonly known as water hyacinth, to accumulate chromium concentrations from water. We conducted a hydroponics experiment for ten days under controlled laboratory conditions to examine the hyperaccumulation potential of the species. The experiment results showed that Eichhornia crassipes is an excellent accumulator of chromium. The maximum concentration was found in the plant's roots with small amounts in the shoots and leaves. These results demonstrate that E. crassipes can provide an efficient and environment-friendly option of remediating chromium-contaminated surface water bodies.

How to cite: Anuradha, A. and Yadav, B. K.: Eichhornia crassipes macrophytes for treatment of heavy metal contaminated water, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-106, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-106, 2022.

EGU22-122 | Presentations | HS2.3.6 | Highlight

Agrochemical transport in the field scale: the case study of a subsurface drainage system in the Kishon Basin, Israel 

Shulamit Nussboim, Orah Felicia Moshe, Jonathan B. Larrone, Lea Wittenberg, and Elazar Volk

Non-point pollutants, such as fertilizers and pesticides, are transported in water and travel via complex hydrologic flowpaths, with each field being a diffuse source of agrochemicals. Although pollutant transport in tile drains has been investigated widely, most studies occurred in temperate zones, with insufficient focus on leaching timing. We investigate the leachate timing and specific pathways from the field to the stream, to better understand the unique transport dynamics in Eastern Mediterranean climates, in areas with extensive subsurface drainage systems. To improve basin management strategies, this study targets the knowledge gap regarding specific pollutant transport and timing, which results in inefficient policies to reduce water pollution.  In our investigation of two crop fields in the Kishon basin, Israel, the systems drain both soil water and high groundwater, providing an opportunity to examine water quality dynamics in multiple pathways. We collected water samples from field runoff, subsurface pipes, and groundwater during summer irrigation and winter storm events. Results show a clear spatial distribution of agrochemicals due to their properties. Higher number of pesticides were found in ponded field water and their concentrations were higher in order of magnitude in compare to tile drainage pipes. We identified pesticides in all samples that had not been applied to the field within the last 1.5 years.  Leaching timing was demonstrated with higher pesticide concentration appearing in water collected from drainage pipes during irrigation and pesticides concentration decreasing after irrigation ended. The concentration changes were observed within 12-15 hours after opening or closing irrigation. Tracking the pools, the high concentration in the top soil creates a pesticides reservoir transported with the onset of irrigation and rain.  The leaching timing was demonstrated as well by lab results and measuring in-situ EC and pH.  After a four-day storm, EC declined drastically, demonstrating the input of relatively low nutrient content water to the high concentrations present in the high water table. Later in the winter, surface runoff in the main draining trench from the field to the stream contained high concentrations of phosphate and sediments and low concentrations of nitrate and chloride, compared to surface runoff in the field. Since nitrate and chloride are highly soluble, the reduced concentration in the draining trench to the stream demonstrates that water percolates downwards through the soil column with solutes rather than propagating with surface runoff, and particulate-bound species and sediments travel via surface runoff to the stream. Demonstrating pollutant transport pathways and timing, we provide a window into the propagation mechanisms of pollutants at a small scale, to support decision making and improve basin management.

 

How to cite: Nussboim, S., Moshe, O. F., Larrone, J. B., Wittenberg, L., and Volk, E.: Agrochemical transport in the field scale: the case study of a subsurface drainage system in the Kishon Basin, Israel, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-122, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-122, 2022.

EGU22-454 | Presentations | HS2.3.6

Microbial degradation of Atrazine in Groundwater 

Mohammad Arar and Anat Bernstein
Atrazine is one of the most frequently detected pesticides in groundwater. Its microbial degradation is often studied in soils, but less frequently studied in groundwater . In Israel, atrazine is the most frequently detected pesticide in groundwater. It was hypothesized that its degradation potential in groundwater is wide. Thus, this study aimed to gain indication for ongoing degradation in atrazine affected groundwater.

 Results of microcosm experiments with groundwater bacteria indicated on its degradation potential. PCR analysis of microcosms cultures has shown the presence of atzA and trzN genes. Furthermore, LC-MS analysis of groundwater extracts identified a large proportion of atrazine degradation products indicating on ongoing degradation in the field. Further isotope analysis of atrazine in  groundwater extracts will provide an additional line of evidence for ongoing degradation in groundwater.

How to cite: Arar, M. and Bernstein, A.: Microbial degradation of Atrazine in Groundwater, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-454, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-454, 2022.

EGU22-628 | Presentations | HS2.3.6

Impact of a new sediment parameterization method in VFSMOD on PECsw/sed in FOCUS step4 

Stefan Reichenberger, Robin Sur, Stephan Sittig, Sebastian Multsch, Álvaro Carmona-Cabrero, and Rafael Muñoz-Carpena

The most widely implemented mitigation measure to reduce transfer of pesticides and other pollutants to surface water bodies via surface runoff are vegetative filter strips (VFS). The most commonly used model for assessing the reduction of surface runoff, eroded sediment and pesticide inputs into surface water by VFS is VFSMOD, which simulates reduction of total inflow (∆Q) and reduction of incoming eroded sediment load (∆E) mechanistically. These variables are subsequently used to calculate the reduction of pesticide load by the VFS (∆P). Since errors in ∆Q and ∆E will propagate to ∆P, for strongly sorbing compounds, an accurate prediction of ∆E is crucial for a reliable prediction of ∆P. The most important parameter characterizing the incoming sediment in VFSMOD is the median particle diameter d50, which is currently fixed to 20 µm in the regulatory tool SWAN 5.01. The objective of this study was to derive an improved, generic d50 parameterization methodology that can be readily used for regulatory VFS scenarios.

A test dataset of d50 values and explanatory variables has been compiled from heterogeneous data sources. The established test dataset (n = 93) was analysed using Machine Learning techniques (Random Forest, Gradient Boosting) and multiple regression analysis (MLR). With the help of the knowledge gained with Machine Learning, a MLR equation with six predictor variables was established and thoroughly tested. Since three of the predictors are event-specific (eroded sediment yield, rainfall intensity and peak runoff rate), the predicted d50 values vary between runoff events according to their magnitude and intensity.

A modified version of SWAN-VFSMOD containing the improved d50 parameterization method was run for a number of contrasting compounds and application scenarios. The obtained ∆E and ∆P values as well as the resulting pesticide concentrations in surface water and sediment (PECsw/sed) were compared with the current FOCUS step4 approach.

How to cite: Reichenberger, S., Sur, R., Sittig, S., Multsch, S., Carmona-Cabrero, Á., and Muñoz-Carpena, R.: Impact of a new sediment parameterization method in VFSMOD on PECsw/sed in FOCUS step4, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-628, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-628, 2022.

EGU22-639 | Presentations | HS2.3.6 | Highlight

Evaluation of the effectiveness of mitigation measures to reduce pesticide inputs into surface water bodies via surface runoff and erosion 

Michael Klein, Stefan Reichenberger, Isabel O'Connor, Simon Spycher, Stephan Sittig, Sebastian Multsch, Kai Thomas, Jens Flade, and Dietlinde Großmann

Surface runoff from agricultural fields is a major input pathway of pesticides into surface waters. The aim of this project was to i) analyze the effectiveness of various mitigation measures to reduce pesticide runoff and erosion inputs into surface waters, ii) assess the suitability of the measures found effective for use in the quantitative environmental exposure assessment for authorization of plant protection products (PPP), and iii) make recommendations how the potentially suitable measures could be applied in risk assessment of PPP in Germany. Following a literature analysis, 16 risk mitigation measures were presented to five experts for evaluation of effectiveness, cost-effectiveness, controllability, current distribution and dissemination potential. Measures finally selected for quantitative analysis belong to 3 groups: vegetative filter strips (VFS), soil conservation measures and micro-dams in row crops. Subsequently, the effectiveness of the recommended measures was evaluated based on experimental data using different statistical methods (e.g. CART, MLR, graphical methods).

The quantitative analysis confirmed the effectiveness of VFS and micro-dams. For soil conservation measures (especially mulch-till), the evaluated data showed highly variable results. This was partly caused by the heterogeneity of the experimental data, which also made it difficult to aggregate the results of different studies.

The following conclusions were drawn: Both VFS and micro-dams can be recommended for application in quantitative environmental exposure assessment for pesticides.  However, infiltration and sedimentation in VFS should be simulated with a mechanistic model such as VFSMOD. The effect of micro-dams can be modelled as a reduction of the runoff Curve Number (CN). The runoff modelling should be carried out with a model such as PRZM which adjusts the CN daily based on soil water content.

How to cite: Klein, M., Reichenberger, S., O'Connor, I., Spycher, S., Sittig, S., Multsch, S., Thomas, K., Flade, J., and Großmann, D.: Evaluation of the effectiveness of mitigation measures to reduce pesticide inputs into surface water bodies via surface runoff and erosion, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-639, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-639, 2022.

EGU22-832 | Presentations | HS2.3.6

Global Sensitivity Analysis for a MACRO Meta-Model for Swedish Drinking Water Abstraction Zones 

Thorsten Pohlert, Stefan Reichenberger, Sebastian Multsch, Nicholas Jarvis, and Mikaela Gönczi

In Sweden farmers are legally obliged to apply for permits for pesticide use if their land lies within a drinking water abstraction zone. The standalone modelling tool MACRO-DB 4 developed by the Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences (SLU) is available for risk assessment and decision support. MACRO-DB 4 is used by local authorities, farmers/landowners and consultants, and is based on the well-established leaching model MACRO 5.2. However, the software is costly to maintain and slow for end users. Hence, a robust meta-model of MACRO-DB 4 was developed and integrated in a web-based tool (MACRO DB Steg2 v.5) that is fast, easy to maintain, and easy to understand for stakeholders. The meta-model (implemented as an R package) is based on i) a large number of MACRO simulations for the whole agriculturally relevant area of Sweden, and ii) a trilinear interpolation tool. The simulations comprised 18 climates, 72 soils, 1 typical crop (spring cereals), 3 application seasons (spring, summer and autumn), and 150 dummy compounds consisting of a grid of normalized Freundlich coefficient Koc, degradation half-life at reference conditions DT50 and Freundlich exponent. Target variables were i) the mean leaching flux concentration over 20 years at 2 m depth (PECgw), and ii) the 20-year mean concentration in large surface water bodies (PECsw; based on pesticide inputs via drainage and baseflow) . The meta-model performs a trilinear interpolation (in the three-dimensional space of Koc, DT50 and Freundlich exponent) for log10 of PECgw or PECsw, respectively. Different crops are taken into account in the web-based tool by adjusting the pesticide interception fraction according to the BBCH stage of the crop to be modelled at the time of application. In order to identify the most important input factors for PECgw and PECsw, a variance-based Global Sensitivity Analysis (GSA) was performed for the MACRO meta-model using the Sobol’ method. This method allows to i) identify first-order (direct) and higher-order (interaction) effects for each input factor (climate, soil, application season, Koc, DT50 and Freundlich exponent), and ii) rank the input factors according to their importance.

How to cite: Pohlert, T., Reichenberger, S., Multsch, S., Jarvis, N., and Gönczi, M.: Global Sensitivity Analysis for a MACRO Meta-Model for Swedish Drinking Water Abstraction Zones, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-832, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-832, 2022.

EGU22-1960 | Presentations | HS2.3.6

Spatiotemporal variations in the response mechanism between ARGs removal and the microbial community in estuary sediments under the bio-ecological restoration 

Ming Xu, Xing-hao Huang, Peng Gao, Hao-qiang Chen, Xiao-xiao Shen, Wu-hui Zhu, Yan-yan Zhang, and Guang-qiu Jin

Estuarine sediments are reservoirs of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs). However, spatiotemporal variations in the response mechanism between ARGs removal and the microbial community under the bio-ecological restoration of estuaries remain unclear. In this study, spatiotemporal hydrological and water quality data were collected from a 14,000 m2 estuary located in the downstream of the Yangtze River to construct a MIKE 21 hydrodynamic model. Based on this, a bio-ecological combined restoration technology of estuaries was constructed and has been running steadily for more than two years. Water and sediment samples in different sections of the bio-ecological restoration and in different seasons were collected to reveal the spatiotemporal variations and response mechanism of ARGs and the microbial community. In total, nine typical ARGs, intI1, and the microbial community were investigated by quantitative polymerase chain reaction and evaluation of the 16S rRNA. The results revealed that the ecological restoration improved the hydrodynamic conditions of the estuary, mitigated the accumulation of pollutants, and considerably removed macrolide (ermC: 63.17–99.06%, ermB: 30.32–96.29%), sulfonamide (sul2: 31.25–98.91%), and tetracycline (tetA: 26.93–98.68%, tetW: 64.86–94.99%) resistance genes. Meanwhile, the ARGs exhibited significant spatiotemporal variation, and that the dominant genes in the estuarine sediments were sulfonamide, macrolide, and tetracycline resistance genes. The absolute abundances of the ARGs followed the order winter > summer > autumn > spring. Proteobacteria (45.33%), Chloroflexi (11.24%), and Acidobacteria (9.99%) were the dominant phyla in the estuary sediment. Massilia and Pseudarthrobacter were the dominant genera in spring, whereas the genera belonging to Proteobacteria were dominant in the other three seasons. Proteobacteria, which was positively correlated with sul1, sul2, tetA, tetM, tetW, ermB, ermC, qnrS, and floR, was recognized as typical antibiotic resistant bacteria, while Thiobacillus, Massilia, and Dechloromonas were found to be potential host genera. Network analysis also revealed the possibility that sul1, tetA, and ermC can act as multi-antibiotic resistance genes. Furthermore, environmental factors including total phosphorus, total nitrogen, and heavy metal concentration also affected ARG dissemination by affecting microbes (p ≤ 0.05). Overall, our findings provided practical evidence for the role that bio-ecological restoration plays in controlling the propagation of ARGs by regulating the microbial community in the estuary sediment.

How to cite: Xu, M., Huang, X., Gao, P., Chen, H., Shen, X., Zhu, W., Zhang, Y., and Jin, G.: Spatiotemporal variations in the response mechanism between ARGs removal and the microbial community in estuary sediments under the bio-ecological restoration, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1960, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1960, 2022.

EGU22-3887 | Presentations | HS2.3.6

High resolution exposure modelling at landscape-level – on the development of a mechanistic drift module for SWAT+ 

Mike Fuchs, Sebastian Gebler, and Andreas Lorke

Modelling environmental concentrations of pesticides at landscape-level is of growing interest for pesticide registration and product stewardship, including higher-tier studies in risk assessment, mitigation measures, monitoring support and decision making. Typically, runoff, drainage, and leaching are taken into account, using different modelling concepts. However, the modelling of spray drift often is simplified or neglected in landscape-level models. For example, the Soil and Water Assessment Tool (SWAT) does not consider spray drift for pesticide transport simulation. Hence, external offline calculations of spray drift are necessary, with the pesticide masses added to the channel network via point sources. Although this is a pragmatic solution for including spray drift, future scientific questions in high spatial and temporal resolution require adequate integrated processes on landscape‑level. Hence, the goal of this project is to: (i) develop and validate a standalone spray drift model that can be used with other modelling approaches in a modular manner, and (ii) implement that model into SWAT+.

Our spray drift model consists of two parts. First, a mechanistic droplet model predicts the trajectories of individual droplets. Second, a 2D Gaussian diffusion model predicts longitudinal advection as well as vertical and lateral dispersion of droplets. This modelling approach allows for a reasonable tradeoff between accuracy and computational expenses. The following inputs are considered: (i) weather conditions, (ii) drop size distribution, (iii) physio‑chemical properties of the active ingredient, and (iv) operational characteristics (e.g., nozzle count, boom height and width, applied amounts and volumes, and forward driving speed).

It is planned to validate the model against an ensemble of computational fluid dynamics simulations. Additionally, the approach will be evaluated using high resolution SWAT+ models of medium sized agriculturally dominated catchments in Germany. We expect the implementation of spray drift to improve modelling performance for different research questions e.g., the sensitivity of aquatic pesticide concentrations on landscape-level regarding application timing.

How to cite: Fuchs, M., Gebler, S., and Lorke, A.: High resolution exposure modelling at landscape-level – on the development of a mechanistic drift module for SWAT+, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3887, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3887, 2022.

EGU22-4334 | Presentations | HS2.3.6 | Highlight

Measuring and modeling biocide entry from facades in urban swale sediment 

Felicia Linke, Lena Schnarr, Oliver Olsson, Klaus Kümmerer, Frank Preusser, Hannes Leistert, Marcus Bork, and Jens Lange

Urban swales collect stormwater runoff containing micropollutants such as biocides washed off from facades during wind driven rain. Although swales retain contaminants, they might eventually reach groundwater through soil. However, there is little data available of biocide occurrence in urban swale sediment. In this study, we measured the biocide entry to an urban swale and its distribution in sediment. The selected swale in south-west Germany collects runoff from a 3 ha residential area with 46 houses. Two pipes lead into the swale, one collecting runoff from a 1 ha area (“East”) and one from a 2 ha area (“West”). We took sediment samples after dry and wet periods close to both pipes and additional water grab samples during wet periods. In total, we collected 19 stormwater samples during 7 events and 116 sediment samples during 8 days over a period of two years. Water samples were analyzed for three biocides (diuron, terbutryn, octylisothiazoline= OIT) and four transformation products (= TPs, diuron-desmethyl, terbuthylazine-2-hydroxy, terbutryn-desethyl, terbumeton) using LC-MS/MS. Sediment samples were analyzed for terbutryn, OIT and 3 TPs of terbutryn. Finally, we linked a water balance model to a leaching model and simulated longterm biocide input into the swale. This we compared with biocide concentration in the swale sediments using a mass balance approach. We found all biocides and all TPs in water samples at both pipes confirming biocide input to the swale. In the sediment, terbutryn concentrations were generally below 1 ng/g. Of three measured TPs of terbutryn we detected only one, terbutryn-desethyl (<1 ng/g dry weight). There were no significant differences of terbutryn concentration in the sediment before and after storm events. This suggests continuous input and long presence of biocides. Concentrations at pipe West were higher than at pipe East. This pointed to differences in the connected areas such as differences in paints used at individual houses. At the outlet of pipe West, we found maximum concentrations of terbutryn (26 ng/g) in saturated sediments below standing water, which suggests more sorption and less degradation at this location. We thus assume that dry condition in swales during dry weather promote degradation. Overall, our findings emphasize that not only the quantity of urban runoff should guide the design of urban swale systems but also potential biocide entry.

How to cite: Linke, F., Schnarr, L., Olsson, O., Kümmerer, K., Preusser, F., Leistert, H., Bork, M., and Lange, J.: Measuring and modeling biocide entry from facades in urban swale sediment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4334, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4334, 2022.

Rare earth elements (REEs) are an emerging pollutant whose increasing use in various technological applications causes increasing risk of environmental contamination. Electronic waste (E-waste) could be one major source of REE pollution, as E-waste typically contains elevated REE concentrations and is often handled in unsafe and environmentally hazardous ways. Here, a series of leaching assays revealed that <1% of REEs available in a representative E-waste were released except at acidic conditions (pH 2) rarely observed in nature. If REEs are leached from E-waste, the extent of their spread in the environment will depend, in large part, on their mobility through porous media. Measurements of REE transport through saturated sand demonstrated extremely limited mobility except at acidic conditions (pH 2), though significant REE retention by the substrate still occurs at this low pH. Similar experiments in a natural soil found REE mobility to be even lower in that substrate, with complete REE retention even after the passage of up to 215 pore volumes of a 500 ppb REE solution. Aqueous REEs are therefore not expected to be highly mobile in the environment. The presence of natural or anthropogenic nanoparticles may affect REE behavior during leaching and/or transport. Measurements indicated that silica nanoparticles can increase the concentration of fluid-mobile REEs during E-waste leaching, but both plastic and silica nanoparticles have a negligible effect on REE transport. Ultimately, the experiments and analysis presented here suggest that the threat of REE pollution from E-waste is minimal except at specific sites with unusual environmental conditions.

How to cite: Brewer, A., Dror, I., and Berkowitz, B.: Electronic waste as a source of rare earth element pollution: Leaching, transport in porous media, and the effects of nanoparticles, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4540, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4540, 2022.

EGU22-4541 | Presentations | HS2.3.6

Assessment of the MHYDAS-Pesticide-1.0 model in simulating pesticide concentrations in surface waters at plot-scale continuously over decades 

Guillaume Metayer, Cecile Dages, Jean Stephane Bailly, David Crevoisier, and Marc Voltz

The use of pesticides in agriculture leads to widespread contamination of various environmental compartments. Surface water contamination represents a major environmental and health risk to manage. Models are a valuable tool for quantifying levels and temporal dynamics of contamination and for identifying and locating the physico-chemical processes involved in pesticide fate. The use of a model requires to know its performance for a given objective. Models simulating pesticide transfers to surface waters have generally been validated either in the laboratory or on a small scale (Gao et al., 2004, Joyce et al., 2010), or at field scale on mass export of discrete floods (Young and Fry, 2019), or at catchment scale on average concentrations or mass exports with minimum daily resolution (Wang et al., 2019). To our knowledge none have been evaluated on multi-year and field-scale databases. MHYDAS-Pesticide-1.0 is a continuous distributed mechanistic model used to simulate water and pesticide transfers from agricultural plots to the river system. The aim of this study is to evaluate at field scale the performance of this model to reproduce multi-year chronicles of runoff water contamination by a post-emergence herbicide intensively used in viticulture, glyphosate. The model was applied to a vineyard plot belonging to the Long-Term Observatory OMERE (Molénat et al., 2018), which outlet runoff discharge and glyphosate concentration have been monitored since 2001. The evaluation was conducted sequentially: the model was first evaluated on its performance in reproducing the runoff hydrographs observed at the plot outlet, then on its performance in simulating the temporal dynamics of glyphosate concentrations measured in runoff water. In both cases, the evaluation included a calibration and a validation step. The simulations were compared to data acquired between 2001 and 2017. The first three years were used for calibration and the following years for validation. To compare simulation results to observations, we considered variables of interest at flood event scale : the flood volume, the peak outflow and the mean glyphosate concentration. Goodness of fit was evaluated considering classical statistical performance indicators such as percent bias and Nash-Sutcliffe efficiency. These indicators were adapted to decrease the weight of the highest values relative to the lowest values. First calibration-validation results of saturated conductivity and height of surface detention enabled to identify a change of soil surface state during the assessment period that was corroborated by field observations. Taking this change into account by specific calibrations, the model reproduced very well runoff heights and peaks during the validation periods. The reproduction of concentration dynamics was also very satisfactory after calibration of glyphosate degradation kinetic and sorption coefficients and depth of the mixing layer between topsoil and surface runoff. This study demonstrates the ability of MHYDAS-Pesticide-1.0 to simulate multi-year time series of pesticide concentrations in surface water. It also provides a better understanding of the hierarchy of transfer processes occurring at the plot scale.

How to cite: Metayer, G., Dages, C., Bailly, J. S., Crevoisier, D., and Voltz, M.: Assessment of the MHYDAS-Pesticide-1.0 model in simulating pesticide concentrations in surface waters at plot-scale continuously over decades, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4541, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4541, 2022.

EGU22-5104 | Presentations | HS2.3.6

The Urban Biocide Terbutryn: Field investigations to explore release and reactive transport under environmental conditions 

Tobias Junginger, Sylvain Payraudeau, and Gwenaël Imfeld

Urban biocides like terbutryn are used in construction materials such as render and paints on façades to prevent the growth of algae and fungi. With wind-driven rain, those contaminants leach into the environment and pose a risk for groundwater contamination. In our study, we combined leaching experiments with artificial facades to quantify biocide release, lysimeter experiments to get insights into the reactive transport under environmental conditions, and field sampling in an urban catchment to follow-up biocide release from source (building facades) to sinks (stormwater retention systems/ groundwater). We use concentrations of terbutryn as well as its four major transformation products to establish mass balances. Furthermore, we use Compound-Specific Isotope Analysis (CSIA) as a concentration-independent tool to identify the dominant degradation processes in the environment by taking into account (i) isotopic enrichment of stable isotopes by dual-isotope plots and (ii) patterns of formed transformation products. Façade leaching experiments show that high quantities of terbutryn remain on the facades and leaching continues for a long period. Transformation products are already formed on the facades through photodegradation. Reactive transport on typical urban surfaces (gravel, paved stones with joints, soil) indicates high retention of terbutryn in the grass lysimeter and faster leaching in gravel and pavement lysimeters with low recoveries of terbutryn in the first 2 months (3 %, 1 % and <1 % in gravel, paved and grass lysimeter, respectively). In all lysimeters, transformation products were formed, exceeding the concentrations of leached terbutryn at some sampling points, indicating higher mobility through better solubility in water of the daughter compounds. The overall extend of (bio-)degradation in the lysimeters was low for terbutryn, as supported by CSIA data (changes in Δδ13C < 2‰). Grab samples in a stormwater retention pond and swale system in an urban catchment confirmed the leaching of terbutryn and transformation products in a catchment from 6-year-old buildings with concentrations of terbutryn between 3 and 70 ng/L, as well as TP terbutryn sulfoxide, exceeding 400 ng/L. Our study implies the importance of detailed monitoring of urban biocides to understand the reactive transport processes on their pathways into groundwater and underlines the importance of monitoring also transformation products in typical monitoring schemes.

How to cite: Junginger, T., Payraudeau, S., and Imfeld, G.: The Urban Biocide Terbutryn: Field investigations to explore release and reactive transport under environmental conditions, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5104, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5104, 2022.

EGU22-5666 | Presentations | HS2.3.6

Characterising trend changes of groundwater quality in Wallonia (Belgium) 

Elise Verstraeten, Alice Alonso, Marnik Vanclooster, and Louise Collier

Over the last decades, various regulations and good management practices have been implemented to reverse the increasing concentration of nitrates and pesticides in our groundwaters. The effects of these efforts on groundwater quality are complex to assess because of the non-linearity and the spatial heterogeneity of the hydrological fluxes, the numerous potential pollution sources, and the temporal delays due to the infiltration time in the vadose zone.

We use the information encoded in the monitoring data of 52 groundwater wells and galleries in Wallonia (Belgium) to assess the effectiveness of the regulations and management practices. We analyze the trends of the time series and subsequently seek to explain their spatial and temporal variability by looking into the characteristics likely to support or undermine the regulations and good practices such as water depth or urban development.

Our results should contribute to a better understanding and prediction of the groundwater quality trends at the catchment scale in Wallonia, providing guidance to catchment management. 

How to cite: Verstraeten, E., Alonso, A., Vanclooster, M., and Collier, L.: Characterising trend changes of groundwater quality in Wallonia (Belgium), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5666, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5666, 2022.

EGU22-5848 | Presentations | HS2.3.6

Evaluation of ageing effect on trace element mobility in sediment of sustainable drainage systems by chemical extractions 

Du Phuc Tho Dang, Liliane Jean-Soro, and Béatrice Béchet

The management of urban stormwater runoff has moved from approaches narrowly focused on reducing flooding to approaches more focused on improving water quality. From impervious surfaces, stormwater is often diverted into retention ponds where sedimentation is used to limit the impact on waterbodies by trapping particulate pollutants. Trace elements are of particular interest because of their potential toxicity. The composition of the sediment varies over time, particularly through the development of vegetation. Ageing has an effect on sediment removal ability of pollutants (Nuel et al., 2018). The aim of this study was to compare the mobility of trace elements in sediments of a retention-infiltration pond before and after its total dredging. The mobility of these pollutants is related to their geochemical fractionation between solid phases which is generally investigated by extraction methods. The single extraction method with ammonium acetate and calcium chloride was applied on sediment samples to quantify the highest labile fraction of these elements (Sakan et al., 2020). The ultrasound assisted sequential extraction based on the procedure proposed by Rauret et al., (2000) and certified by Pueyo et al., (2001) was applied to determine the pollutant distribution among the acid-extractable, reducible, oxidizable fractions of sediments. The ageing effect is examined to explain the global removal ability of sediments. Then, the distribution of trace elements in different solid phases is analyzed in function of the sediment ageing, the mineral composition and granulometry of sediments.

Nuel, M., Laurent, J., Bois, P., Heintz, D., Wanko, A., 2018. Seasonal and ageing effect on the behaviour of 86 drugs in a full-scale surface treatment wetland: Removal efficiencies and distribution in plants and sediments. Science of The Total Environment 615, 1099–1109. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2017.10.061

Pueyo, M., Rauret, G., Lück, D., Yli-Halla, M., Muntau, H., Quevauviller, Ph., López-Sánchez, J.F., 2001. Certification of the extractable contents of Cd, Cr, Cu, Ni, Pb and Zn in a freshwater sediment following a collaboratively tested and optimised three-step sequential extraction procedure. J. Environ. Monitor. 3, 243–250. https://doi.org/10.1039/b010235k

Rauret, G., López-Sánchez, J.-F., Sahuquillo, A., Barahona, E., Lachica, M., Ure, A.M., Davidson, C.M., Gomez, A., Lück, D., Bacon, J., Yli-Halla, M., Muntau, H., Quevauviller, Ph., 2000. Application of a modified BCR sequential extraction (three-step) procedure for the determination of extractable trace metal contents in a sewage sludge amended soil reference material (CRM 483), complemented by a three-year stability study of acetic acid and EDTA extractable metal content. J. Environ. Monitor. 2, 228–233. https://doi.org/10.1039/b001496f

Sakan, S., Frančišković-Bilinski, S., Đorđević, D., Popović, A., Škrivanj, S., Bilinski, H., 2020. Geochemical Fractionation and Risk Assessment of Potentially Toxic Elements in Sediments from Kupa River, Croatia. Water 12, 2024. https://doi.org/10.3390/w12072024

 

How to cite: Dang, D. P. T., Jean-Soro, L., and Béchet, B.: Evaluation of ageing effect on trace element mobility in sediment of sustainable drainage systems by chemical extractions, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5848, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5848, 2022.

The strength of the interaction between a pesticide and the soil organic matter is a key parameter to assess the risk of it reaching to groundwater with potentially harmful effects to human health. The humic substances (HS) play important role in the adsorption of pesticides. The mechanism of these reactions includes cation exchange, chelation, coordination, hydrogen bonding, charge transfer, hydrofobic bonding, π bonding, and van der Waals bonding. Many factors could affect the pesticide signals in LC-MS/MS analysis.  The chemical and physical properties of the analytes and the composition of the sample matrix are amongst them. Acidification of the solution can also affect the ionization of analytes (pesticides) in the ion source.

In this work, a approach that allows measuring such pesticide interactions  in acidic solutions (formic acid - FA, acetic acid - AA). These were representatives of pesticides phenoxycarboxylic, chloroacetanilide, urea, organophosphate, triazine, triazole and representatives of other pesticides. The measurements showed that different groups of pesticides exhibit different behaviors in the presence of humic acids. There were differences both between different groups of pesticides and between individual representatives within certain groups.

The resulting measured concentration values differed most from each other for organophosphate pesticides. At the same time, the structures of the molecules of these pesticides vary greatly. Dimethoat had a more pronounced signal drop than diazinon at lower pesticide concentrations (25 ng/l). The effect of the addition of FA and AA on the resulting concentration values also differed between the two pollutants studied. In diazinon, the addition of AA signal decreased in dimethoat, on the contrary, increased. The addition of FA in diazinon further dampened the signal, while dimethoat experienced a similar increase in analyte values as with the addition of AA. From the results of the measurements, it can be deduced that representatives of organophosphate pesticides show different behavior in the presence of HA.

How to cite: Kříženecká, S.: Influence of sample acidification in the presence of humic substances in determination of pesticide by LC-MS/MS, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7082, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7082, 2022.

EGU22-8261 | Presentations | HS2.3.6

Assessment of the variation of soil trace metals using artificial intelligence: A case study from Eastern Province, Saudi Arabia 

Mohamed Yassin, Mohammed Benaafi, Bassam Tawabini, and Sani Abba

Soils may preserve metals from different sources that might pollute the environment. Hence, it is very important to assess the concentration of the geochemical elements of areas where intensified agriculture and industrial activities. This study involved the spatial assessment of topsoil contamination with trace metals in selected areas in Eastern Province, Saudi Arabia. To achieve this objective, more than 130 samples of topsoil from residential, industrial, and agricultural areas were collected and analysed. Inductively coupled plasma - optical emission spectroscopy (ICP-OES) was used to analyse the samples for various trace metals. Moreover, different artificial intelligence (AI) models such as artificial neural network (ANN) were applied to estimation the zinc (Zn), copper (Cu), chromium (Cr), and lead (Pb) using feature-based input selection. The experimental results depicted that the average concentration levels of HMs were as follows: Chromium (Cr) (31.79±37.9 mg/kg), Copper (Cu) (6.76±12.54 mg/kg), Lead (Pb) (6.34±14.55 mg/kg), and Zinc (Zn) (23.44±84.43 mg/kg). The modelling accuracy showed that agricultural and industrial stations performance merit with goodness-of-fit ranges of 51-91% and 80-99%, respectively. This study concluded that AI models might be successfully applied for the quick estimation of soil trace metals and for decision support system.

How to cite: Yassin, M., Benaafi, M., Tawabini, B., and Abba, S.: Assessment of the variation of soil trace metals using artificial intelligence: A case study from Eastern Province, Saudi Arabia, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8261, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8261, 2022.

EGU22-11685 | Presentations | HS2.3.6

Soil management affects copper and zinc export in runoff from Northern vineyard plots (Rouffach, Alsace, France) 

Sylvain Payraudeau, Fatima Meite, and Gwenaël Imfeld

Zinc-based and Cu-based fungicides are widely used in European vineyards to prevent fungal diseases. The soil management and rainfall characteristics influence the runoff export of copper (Cu) and zinc (Zn) from vineyard plots, although quantitative field studies are mostly missing. The runoff exports of Zn and Cu from Northern vineyard plots (Rouffach, Alsace, calcareous-loamy soils with pH = 8.0) under conventional and alternative soil management were compared during two contrasting vine-growing seasons. The conventional management included standard soil maintenance with chemical weeding, whereas the alternative management involved the conversion to organic farming with a mechanical soil management. Cu in top-soil, i.e. the first 5 cm, reached 103.6 ± 19.1 and 70.8 ± 7.8 kg Cu ha-1 for conventional and alternative plots, respectively, mirroring accumulation since decades. Zn in top-soil reached 70.8 ± 16.4 and 63.9 ± 7.8 kg Cu ha-1 for conventional and alternative plots, respectively. No Zn applications on the conventional and alternative plots were recorded during the two growing seasons. Overall, our results emphasize that destructuring of the surface soil layer and tillage preceding a storm event largely influences water flows and exports of both dissolved and solid-bound Cu and Zn. Plowing work on the organic plot a few days before a most intense storm event resulted in significant mass export, accounting for 99% and 95% of the total mass exported during the vine-growing season for Cu and Zn, respectively. However, grass cover on one out of two inter-rows limited runoff volumes to a maximum runoff coefficient of up to 1.4% over the two vine-growing seasons. The seasonal export of Cu and Zn occurred mainly by surface runoff as the monthly water storage of the soil was lower than the water holding capacity, thereby limiting vertical flows in both management modes. The mass export of solid-bound Cu and Zn contributed to more than 95% of total export of both Cu and Zn from the vineyard plots. The seasonal Cu and Zn exports ranged from 0.001 to 0.05% of historical Cu and Zn in the top-soil, raising the issue of both Cu and Zn accumulation in vineyard soils. Altogether, this study underscores that soil mechanical management preceding a storm event largely affects Cu and Zn export, although Cu and Zn fluxes in runoff from the alternative management are globally lower. 

How to cite: Payraudeau, S., Meite, F., and Imfeld, G.: Soil management affects copper and zinc export in runoff from Northern vineyard plots (Rouffach, Alsace, France), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11685, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11685, 2022.

EGU22-12528 | Presentations | HS2.3.6

Occurrence, distribution and behaviour of contaminants of emerging concern and regulated organic pollutants. Case study: the endorheic catchment of Fuente de Piedra Lagoon (Southern Spain). 

Marta Llamas, Joaquín Jiménez-Martínez, Iñaki Vadillo, Pablo Jiménez-Gavilán, Pablo Lara-Martín, and Carmen Corada-Fernández

Contaminants of Emerging Concern (CECs) and regulated organic pollutants pose a serious threat to water quality and their spatial distribution is challenging to assess as it can be driven by several factors.

In the current work, we focus on the distribution of a wide range of regulated and non-regulated organic contaminants in groundwater of the Fuente de Piedra lagoon catchment, in Southern Spain. Groundwater samples were collected and they were analyzed for (I) 185 organic contaminants and (II) water ions and stable isotopes (δ2H, δ18O and δ13C). Target organic contaminants included pharmaceuticals, personal care products, polyaromatic hydrocarbons, pesticides, flame retardants and plastizicers.

The Fuente de Piedra lagoon is a hypersaline wetland located in an endorheic basin (150 km2) in which three main aquifer types, with an hydraulic connection, can be distinguished: (I) unconfined carbonate aquifers with low mineralized water corresponding to two mountain ranges; (II) an unconfined porous aquifer formed by Quaternary and Miocene deposits, more exposed to pollution from anthropogenic activities; and (III) a karstic-type confined aquifer developed in a massive accumulation of evaporites and gypsum (Upper Triassic). 

In total, 32 organic contaminants were detected, at least once. An attempt to evaluate the importance of the different factors affecting the spatial distribution of the organic contaminants have been conducted. Attention has been paid to the main physico-chemical properties of the pollutants (hydrophobicity and speciation), distribution of pollution sources and anthropogenic pressures in the area (including water management practices) and hydrogeological characteristics of the different aquifers. A geochemical model has been built to characterize water mixing processes in order to better understand transport and fate of these organic contaminants.

How to cite: Llamas, M., Jiménez-Martínez, J., Vadillo, I., Jiménez-Gavilán, P., Lara-Martín, P., and Corada-Fernández, C.: Occurrence, distribution and behaviour of contaminants of emerging concern and regulated organic pollutants. Case study: the endorheic catchment of Fuente de Piedra Lagoon (Southern Spain)., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12528, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12528, 2022.

EGU22-13012 | Presentations | HS2.3.6

PESTICIDE REMOBILIZATION in VEGETATIVE FILTER STRIPS USING MESOSCALE MULTI-EVENT EXPERIMENTATION 

John Howe and Rafael Munoz-Carpena

VFSMOD, a numerical storm-based vegetative filter strip (VFS) design model, calculates pesticide mitigation from runoff through VFS in regulatory long-term ecotoxicological exposure assessments. After each storm, the model calculates degradation in the hiatus period and currently adopts a risk-conservative approach of full remobilization of surface pesticide residues during following storms. For highly-sorbed chemicals, although risk-conservative, this assumption has been shown to be unrealistic and a revised mechanistic modeling approach that produces accurate estimates across a wide range of chemicals is sought.  To test the ability of the revised modeling approach to predict VFS efficacy accurately over time, a mesoscale experiment was designed using triplicated 1.2Lx0.35Wx0.5D m soil boxes with VFS planted on the surface.  The device was instrumented to quantify how different types of pesticides are remobilized from the VFS surface over consecutive rainfall events with a hiatus in between. A rainfall simulator provides uniformly distributed precipitation input at 5-year storm intensity and a lateral inflow spreader provides runoff entering the upper side of the VFS. A chemical tracer is added to the pesticide and sediment inflow suspension and tracked through the system using a longitudinal grid of 12 soil moisture and electrical conductivity sensors, and 4 automatic flow meters at 3 drainage and 1 surface runoff outlets per box. Infiltration and runoff are quantified to close the mass balance.  The use of advanced instrumentation is vital to achieve data with high spaciotemporal resolution for analysis. Due to the complex nature of the VFS environment, system subcomponents are sequentially tested for water traceability. Before the addition of pesticides, the system was tested with water and tracer. Preliminary mass balance results will ensure all water is traceable through the system, which will be essential during later experimentation with pesticides.

How to cite: Howe, J. and Munoz-Carpena, R.: PESTICIDE REMOBILIZATION in VEGETATIVE FILTER STRIPS USING MESOSCALE MULTI-EVENT EXPERIMENTATION, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13012, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13012, 2022.

Regulatory exposure assessments (EA) are a cornerstone in the registration of new or existing agrochemicals in the EU, USA and many other countries to preserve ecosystem health and water quality. VFSMOD (Muñoz-Carpena et al., 1999; 2004) is a numerical, storm-based design model that quantifies the performance of vegetative filter strips- VFS (grass buffers) to mitigate pesticide runoff into surface waters. The model has been coupled into current USA and EU long-term (20 to 30 yr), higher-tier regulatory pesticide EAs to estimate potential pesticide load reductions by the VFS before entering the aquatic environment. A new comprehensive modeling component has been added to VFSMOD to quantify the fate of pesticides residue on the VFS between events in the context of long-term simulations. The aim of this study is to present the verification of the assumptions and accuracy of the new pesticide residue component within VFSMOD in the context of continuous simulations by exploring a wide range of conditions (Koc, half-life, remobilization processes) of importance to improve current understanding of quantitative mitigation of pesticides in the regulatory environment.  The results show the complex interaction in the VFS amongst surface pesticide runoff, sedimentation, infiltration and leaching, degradation, evapotranspiration and soil moisture change, and mixing layer remobilization that produces emergent behavior in the amount of pesticide residue potentially remobilized in the next event in the series.

How to cite: Muñoz-Carpena, R., Reichenberger, S., and Sur, R.: Importance of surface pesticide residues in the quantitative mitigation of pesticides with vegetative filter strips: VFSMOD development and analysis, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13039, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13039, 2022.

Starting from plastic pollution in oceans as a widely recognized environmental problem, the research focus has also shifted towards rivers which were found to be a major inflow of plastics into the oceans. However, the source of plastic pollution itself is mostly upstream and for instance related to waste water treatment plants, littering of on-the-go consumer packages or agricultural films. For Switzerland a recent study modeled the release of the seven most used plastic polymers (LDPE, HDPE, PP, PS, EPS, PVC, PET) as micro- und macroplastic to the environment. Release maps of plastic emissions were obtained at high spatial resolution of 100 m by 100 m for soil grid cells and for each single river section in Switzerland. The aim of the current work was to couple this release model with its high spatial resolution to a model for the transport, accumulation and removal of the plastic polymers.

The model for the Swiss river and lake network allows to follow plastic pollution through every stream in Switzerland from the sources towards the outflows to the neighboring countries of Switzerland. We differentiate between the different plastic polymers and micro- and macroplastic. Furthermore, we consider physical properties (e. g. density, size) to establish parameters for accumulation and removal or cleaning rates of plastics in each river section and lakes based on parameters such as slope, urbanization or volume. In detail, we model the movement of plastic mass along the rivers based on average flow velocities while in lakes we consider sedimentation rates (accumulation) based on literature data. Input for the model is the yearly release of the seven polymers into about 2000 river sections. The transport model considers a network of over 600,000 river segments and 210 lakes. Our model provide contamination data on the scale of each river section which compared with so far available catchment scale model will provide an even closer look at rivers and local sources and sinks of plastics. However, many parameters regarding micro- or macroplastic transport in natural rivers at a large scale are still unknown or hydrological parameters on a country scale are not available. Therefore, a compromise between data availability and implementation of physical processes in the model had to be found. First results show the strength of our model to trace plastic particles regardless the size or polymer type. We are able to detect lakes as major sinks which substantially reduce plastic transport in rivers.

Our work can help to better understand the sources of the global plastic pollution but rises the need for experimental data on plastic transport in the environment. The large-scale understanding of plastic transport processes will provide policy makers with options were to tackle the spread of plastic pollution in the most efficient way.

How to cite: Mennekes, D. and Nowack, B.: Modeling polymer-specific exposure to micro- and macroplastics in freshwaters at high spatial resolution at the country-scale, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-76, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-76, 2022.

EGU22-205 | Presentations | HS2.3.7

Macroplastics monitoring in the Sea Scheldt estuary 

Milica Velimirovic, Bert Teunkens, Hossein Ghorbanfekr, Bart Buelens, Stefan Van Damme, Kristof Tirez, and Frank Vanhaecke

The presence of small plastic fragments in open ocean water was first noticed in the 1970’s. Throughout the last decade, the scientific interest has been renewed and has pointed out that rivers may act as sinks for land-based plastic pollution and a potential major source of marine plastic debris, thus presenting an environmental threat. As a long-term consequence, plastic fragmentation will lead to pollution release that can impose a negative impact on river, as well as marine ecosystems, especially once they enter the food webs. As a result, this is a topic of increasing concern, but research on this issue is still in its early stages with fundamental gaps in the understanding of the sources, transformation pathways, fragmentation processes, fate of the land-based plastic pollution and estimates of the riverine plastic flux in general.

In order to identify the most polluting rivers and to prioritize mitigation efforts, accurate estimates of global riverine plastic emissions are required. The present work is aimed to give an overview of the morphology, size and composition of plastic debris found in the Sea Scheldt estuary (Belgium). For that purpose, in 2018, 3 sampling campaigns were performed by using an anchor netting technique with the mesh size of the nets progressively becoming smaller, reaching 5 mm at the tip of the nets. The samples originating from the Scheldt were separated into two categories based on their appearance (morphology) and size. The morphology consisted of 5 classes: fragments, foam, foil, filaments and pellets, whilst the size was divided into 6 categories: 0-2.5 cm (where 0 represents smallest size of the mesh being 5 mm); 2.5-5 cm; 5-10 cm; 10-20 cm; 20-30 cm; and larger than 30 cm. As a result, a grand total of 12,801 plastic items were collected. On average 1.6x10-3 items per m3 were found as suspended fraction of plastic debris in the Scheldt river. Foils were the most abundant with more than 88% of the samples being characterized as such, followed by fragments for 11% of the samples and filaments constituting less than 1% of the plastic debris. By using FTIR, polypropylene and polyethylene were identified as the most common polymers found with an abundance of more than 70%. This can be expected, as polypropylene and polyethylene make up for more than 50% of the plastic production in general. Finally, analysis of plastic debris by using μ-XRF spectrometry presents a good method for the identification of the mineral elements present. Ca, P, S and Si are the most abundant elements in the plastic debris, followed by Al, Fe and Ti.

M.V. is a senior postdoctoral fellow of the Research Foundation – Flanders (FWO 12ZD120N).

How to cite: Velimirovic, M., Teunkens, B., Ghorbanfekr, H., Buelens, B., Van Damme, S., Tirez, K., and Vanhaecke, F.: Macroplastics monitoring in the Sea Scheldt estuary, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-205, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-205, 2022.

EGU22-251 | Presentations | HS2.3.7

Distribution and characteristics of microplastics and phthalate esters from a freshwater lake system in Lesser Himalayas 

Ajay Kumar, Diptimayee Behera, Sharmila Bhattacharya, Praveen Kumar Mishra, Ankit Yadav, and Anoop Ambili

The occurrence, distribution, characterization and quantification of microplastics (MPs) and phthalic acid esters (PAEs) from the freshwater aquatic environment are not thoroughly explored in the Indian Himalayas despite concern over their adverse effects on human health and ecosystem. In this study, we have investigated the presence of MPs and PAEs in an aquatic system from Indian subcontinent. The MPs were detected in all water and sediment samples with abundances ranging from 02–64 particles/L and 15–632 particles/kg dw, respectively. The abundance of MPs, dominated by polyethylene and polystyrene, with the majority being fibres and fragments indicated that they were derived from plastic paints, boats or synthetic products. The concentrations of PAEs in the surface sediment samples varied from 06-357 ng/g dw. The most abundant PAEs in the sediments were dibutyl phthalate (DBP) and di(2-ethylhexyl) phthalate (DEHP), since they were present in all the samples collected from the lake basin. The relatively higher abundances of MPs and higher concentrations of PAEs were generally found in the vicinity of areas impacted by anthropogenic activities. A clear correlation between the abundance of microplastics and PAEs concentration was observed suggesting that they are closely attributed to a single source. This study also provides an alternative approach to utilize the chemical additives in plastics as markers to trace the presence and distribution of MPs in the aquatic environment.

How to cite: Kumar, A., Behera, D., Bhattacharya, S., Mishra, P. K., Yadav, A., and Ambili, A.: Distribution and characteristics of microplastics and phthalate esters from a freshwater lake system in Lesser Himalayas, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-251, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-251, 2022.

EGU22-327 | Presentations | HS2.3.7

The effects of stream water velocity, streambed celerity, and particle properties on microplastic deposition in streams 

Verena Levy Sturm, Silvia Gobrecht, Roy Bernstein, and Shai Arnon

Microplastic (MP) is ubiquitously found in aquatic environments and poses a risk to organisms and potentially also to human health. While MP in oceans was studied extensively in recent years there is still a lack of knowledge especially on how MP is being transported and deposited in streams. We conducted flume experiments to study how plastic properties and bedform movement influence the deposition dynamics of MP. We used a recirculating stainless-steel laboratory flume (650 cm x 20 cm), that was packed with homogeneous sand (D50=0.65 mm). We compared the deposition dynamics of MP under stationary bed and under fast moving bedforms. We used aged MP fibers made from PET, PP, PA at various lengths (25, 100, 200 μm). The deposition rates were quantified by adding MP into the water and tracking their concentration in the stream water over time. In addition, streambed samples were taken to quantify and analyze the locations and concentrations of MPs within the sediment. It was found that the physical properties of MP including size, density, and type had a relatively minor influence on their deposition rate because the mechanism was dominated by the movement of the bedform and not due to their transport within the porous medium. Only a slight difference in deposition rate was observed for the different types of MP. The MP particles that we used are too large to be efficiently transported into the porous media and the resulting patterns were deposition close to the water-sediment interface in stationary bed, and below the moving fraction of the bed for moving bedforms. These experimental results represent unique observations of the transport mechanisms of MP in streams with moving bedforms. They are important for the understanding of the transfer of MP from its source toward the oceans, for understanding the life cycle of plastics in the environment, to develop sampling strategies in streams, and to find long-term solutions for reducing their concentrations and the associated risks.

How to cite: Levy Sturm, V., Gobrecht, S., Bernstein, R., and Arnon, S.: The effects of stream water velocity, streambed celerity, and particle properties on microplastic deposition in streams, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-327, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-327, 2022.

EGU22-440 | Presentations | HS2.3.7 | Highlight

Leveraging community data to characterize river macroplastic pollution 

Lisa Watkins and Jordan Yu

Intercepting mismanaged waste before it reaches the ocean is key to addressing global plastic pollution and its associated ecological effects. A successful strategy for disrupting the transport of macro debris is “trash traps”, cages and booms currently deployed in rivers worldwide to capture floating items. Existing traps are largely managed by NGOs and municipalities, many of whom collect comprehensive data on all captured trash. These community datasets provide a substantial, largely untapped opportunity to advance scientific understanding of riverine plastic pollution.

For this study, we partnered with Chattahoochee Riverkeeper, an NGO in Atlanta, U.S.A. that manages 11 trash traps across 6 rivers spanning a spectrum of urban to agricultural watersheds. After each rainstorm, NGO staff assess all captured debris according to U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Escaped Trash Assessment Protocol (ETAP), noting total volume and weight of the contents, as well as each item’s condition, material-type (e.g. glass, metal), and use (out of 41 item categories).

We analyzed data from each of their 281 trap collections occurring between 2019 and 2021, which captured 8904 items. We found that 80% of collected trash was plastic, with the most common item types being plastic bottles, Styrofoam and plastic bags. Their system of 11 trash traps intercepted 5.7 kg/day of trash from the Chattahoochee River watershed (median: 0.4 kg/day/trap). Though this amounts to 2 tonnes of trash in these tributaries annually, it’s the equivalent of each watershed resident contributing less than a water bottle each year (5.6 g/person/yr), supporting the need for centralized or system-scale pollution intervention strategies over distributed ones. To explore potential drivers of macroplastics, we utilize a general mixed effects model and find rainfall, watershed imperviousness, and local human engagement to be significant predictors of captured quantity. The model coefficients indicate, however, that these factors may be less important to macroplastics than they traditionally are for other river-transported pollutants. We suspect this is due to macroplastics being highly affected by harder-to-capture human activities.

In our presentation we explore these findings in the context of other macroplastic studies worldwide. Through this work, we hope to highlight how collaborative research principles can be used to leverage the local expertise and abundant, underutilized data of NGOs for the advancement of riverine plastic science, while also better engaging local communities around solutions.

How to cite: Watkins, L. and Yu, J.: Leveraging community data to characterize river macroplastic pollution, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-440, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-440, 2022.

EGU22-928 | Presentations | HS2.3.7 | Highlight

Roadmap for long-term macroplastic monitoring in rivers 

Paul Vriend, Tim van Emmerik, and Eric Copius Peereboom

Macroplastic pollution in and around rivers negatively impacts human livelihood, and aquatic ecosystems. Monitoring data are crucial for better understanding and quantifying this problem, and for the design of effective intervention strategies. However, current monitoring efforts are often short duration, or study single river compartments. We present a ‘Roadmap’ to overcome the challenges related to the design and implementation of long-term riverine macroplastic monitoring strategies. This ‘Roadmap’ can help accelerating the process of achieving structural monitoring through providing a stepwise approach, which links monitoring goals and research questions to the data and methods required to answer them. We identify four monitoring goals: (1) policy, (2) knowledge development, (3) operations, and (4) solutions. Linked to these, we provide a non-exhaustive list of 12 globally common research questions that are important to answer to reach these goals. The ‘Roadmap’ takes these questions and links them to development levels of monitoring methods for each river compartment: (1) method development, (2) baseline assessment, and (3) long-term monitoring. At each level, specific questions can only be answered if the level is achieved for specific river compartments. For questions at higher levels, the previous levels need to be achieved first. This creates a clear stepwise approach to solve open challenges. With the ‘Roadmap’, we provide a new tool to support decision-making and planning of specific projects by policy makers. The ‘Roadmap’ is a clear and stepwise, yet flexible framework that allows to add and remove elements based on new insights, available resources, and other relevant changes.

How to cite: Vriend, P., van Emmerik, T., and Copius Peereboom, E.: Roadmap for long-term macroplastic monitoring in rivers, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-928, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-928, 2022.

EGU22-1044 | Presentations | HS2.3.7

A new approach to extracting biofilm from environmental plastics using ultrasound-assisted syringe treatment for isotopic analyses 

Batdulam Battulga, Mariko Atarashi-Andoh, and Jun Koarashi

Plastic debris has been recognized as one of the carriers of hazardous substances in the aquatic ecosystem due to its ubiquitous distribution and potential interaction with pollutants through developed biofilms. Although an increasing number of studies have highlighted that diverse microbial species including biofilm-forming microorganisms are colonized on the plastic surfaces in aquatic environments, biofilm-mediated interactions between plastics and pollutants especially radionuclides remain unclear. In this study, we aimed to extract biofilms from the environmental plastics using a newly developed extraction method and to determine the concentration of radiocesium (137Cs) and stable isotope ratios (δ13C and δ15N) in the extracted biofilm samples. Visible plastics were collected from the mouths of coastal rivers in Ibaraki prefecture, Japan. Although the plastic concentration along the river mouth was not evaluated in this study, various abundances (96 – 1868 pieces), sizes (1 – 50 mm), colors, and morphotypes of plastics were applied to the extraction procedures. After plastic and biofilm separation with ultrasonication, biofilm samples were collected by the two ways: freeze-drying (15.5 – 44.4 mg); and freeze-drying after syringe treatment (14.5 – 65.4 mg). The XRD diffractograms of biofilm samples confirmed that biofilms obtained by freeze-drying only were still heterogeneous and the agglomerations of organic substances, mineral particles, and small microplastics (MPs, <1 mm). The results also demonstrated that biofilm extraction was achieved by syringe treatment separating the mineral and small MP particles, resulting in homogenous biofilms from the surface of plastics. Preliminarily results of 137Cs activity concentrations in heterogenous (ranging from 0.22 to 0.54 Bq g−1) and homogenous (0.82 ± 0.04 Bq g−1) biofilm samples revealed that plastics serve as a carrier for 137Cs in the coastal river environment mediated by developed biofilms. As a result of the presence of petroleum-derived small MPs, heterogeneous biofilm samples showed a relatively lower δ13C value (−26.03 ± 0.34‰; mean ± SE) compared with homogenous biofilm samples. A similar trend was observed in the δ15N values. Our results suggest that developed biofilms on the plastics might have specific signatures of δ13C and δ15N depending on the source and pathway of the organic matter. The study contributes to the knowledge of the developed biofilms on environmental plastics and their potential interactions with 137Cs in the coastal aquatic environment.

Keywords: environmental plastics, biofilm, coastal river, radiocesium, stable carbon and nitrogen isotopes

How to cite: Battulga, B., Atarashi-Andoh, M., and Koarashi, J.: A new approach to extracting biofilm from environmental plastics using ultrasound-assisted syringe treatment for isotopic analyses, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1044, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1044, 2022.

EGU22-1184 | Presentations | HS2.3.7

Controls on microplastic flux during sand bed evolution 

Annie Ockelford and Hazel Beaumont

Microplastic contamination of river sediments has been found to be pervasive at the global scale however, the physical controls governing the storage, remobilization and pathways of transfer in fluvial sediments remain largely unknown. This is particularly so in sand bed rivers where the migration of bedforms has the potential to both store and release any microplastics contained within the sediment bed.  Without detailed experiments to model the movement of microplastics through, and storage within, sand bedforms it is impossible to understand what the environmental legacy of our excessive plastic pollution will be.

We report a series of mobile-bed laboratory flume experiments designed to explicitly quantify the relationship between sand bed surface development and microplastic flux characteristics. Experiments were performed within a glass sided, flow recirculating flume of rectangular cross section (8m x 0.5m x 0.5m). A uniform sand bed (D50 of 450μm) was seeded with either PVC pellets (d=1.4g/cm3), Nylon pellets (d= 1.2 g/cm3), Polycarbonate fragments (d=1.2 g/cm3), Acetal beads (d = 1.4g/cm3) or Nylon fibres (d = 1.15g/cm3). Plastics were mixed into the sediment bed at either 0.1% or 0.5% concentration by mass and sediment beds were exposed to a flow rate of either 0.6 or 0.8 ms-1. Experiments were run until equilibrium conditions were attained as measured by bedform migration rate. During each experiment aerial photographs were taken every 2.5 minutes and videos shot through both the side walls and from top down to track bedform migration and plastic flux. Transported sediment and plastics were captured at the downstream end of the flume in a sediment trap to allow fluxes to be calculated. At the end of each run photographs were taken of the drained bed surface with photogrammetry then used to model the 3D bed surfaces.

Controls on microplastic flux as a result of bed evolution is discussed in terms of both flow rate flow rate and microplastic type.  

How to cite: Ockelford, A. and Beaumont, H.: Controls on microplastic flux during sand bed evolution, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1184, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1184, 2022.

EGU22-1211 | Presentations | HS2.3.7

Spatio-temporal variations in microplastic presence and composition in the sediments of the R. Thames (UK) and its tributaries 

Karolina Skalska, Annie Ockelford, James E. Ebdon, Andrew B. Cundy, and Alice A. Horton

Rivers form major conduits for land-derived plastic waste, with the annual emission of plastics to the world’s oceans currently being quantified at as much as 2.7 million metric tons. In particular, riverbed sediments have been found to retain high levels of microplastics (plastics <5 mm in size) and multiple studies reported microplastic concentrations in the sediments to exceed those in the water column by as much as 600,000 times. Emerging evidence suggests that high flows may remobilise some of the sedimentary microplastic pool, resulting in high microplastic loads entering the adjacent seas following flood events. However, the transport mechanisms that microplastics undergo in river settings remain poorly understood.

In this study, we investigated spatio-temporal variations in the microplastic contamination within river bed sediments in the R. Thames (UK) catchment. Sediment samples were taken on a seasonal basis over 3 years (2019-2021) from 12 sampling sites (classified as rural, urban and industrial) located on the main R. Thames and 8 of its tributaries. Microplastics were extracted from sediment using density flotation, then visually counted and investigated using a combination of ATR-FTIR and µATR-FTIR (Attenuated Total Reflectance - Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy). Additional SEM analysis was carried out to describe the morphology (degradational patterns/occurrence of biofouling) of extracted microplastics.

Microplastics were present in most sediment samples (85%), with fragments being the dominant shape (92% across all seasons), followed by beads/pellets (5%) and fibres (3%). Microplastic levels varied on a seasonal basis (0 - 4,200 MP·kg-1 range), increasing in the summer months and decreasing in the winter by up to 89%. This suggests the occurrence of microplastic accumulation in the summer low-flow conditions followed by subsequent flushing of microplastics as a result of higher winter flows. Inter-site variations in microplastic levels were evident in the summer months, with concentrations increasing in the order of industrial>urban>rural. Microplastics were also more abundant at inner river banks and near point sources (e.g. effluent outlets). In contrast, such inter- and intra-site variations were less clear in the winter. Urban and rural samples were dominated by fragments (96% on average) irrespective of season, with most items made out of polyethylene (PE), but also containing thermoplastic elastomers found in road marking paints (e.g. ethylene vinyl acetate (EVA), polyamide (PA)). Although samples taken from industrial locations were also dominated by fragments (84%), they contained higher numbers of microbeads and industrial pellets (12%) composed of polymers widely used for industrial applications (e.g. poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA) used as Perspex glass, poly(diallyl phthalate) used in the processing of thermosetting plastics and resins, or poly(1,4-butylene terephthalate) (PBT) used for insulation purposes in the electrical industry).

Our study reveals a multitude of microplastic sources contributing to the pollution of the R. Thames catchment and confirms the existence of a strong seasonal pattern in microplastic deposition within riverbeds, suggesting a need to account for this process in the global models of microplastic export from land to sea.

How to cite: Skalska, K., Ockelford, A., Ebdon, J. E., Cundy, A. B., and Horton, A. A.: Spatio-temporal variations in microplastic presence and composition in the sediments of the R. Thames (UK) and its tributaries, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1211, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1211, 2022.

EGU22-1275 | Presentations | HS2.3.7 | Highlight

First insight into the spatial pattern of macroplastic storage in a mountain river 

Maciej Liro, Paweł Mikuś, and Bartłomiej Wyżga

Amounts of macroplastic debris stored on different elements of mountain rivers are unknown, but such data are crucial to plan future mitigation activities in these fragile ecosystems. We determined the amounts of macroplastic stored on different surface types (geomorphic units and wood jams) in two reaches of the Dunajec River in the Polish Carpathians. A wide, multi-thread reach stored 36 times more macroplastic per 1 km of river length than the upstream-located narrow, channelized reach (1495.4 kg vs. 41.8 kg). In the multi-thread reach, 43.8% and 41.1% of macroplastic was stored on wooded islands and wood jams that covered, respectively, 16.7% and 1.5% of the area of active river zone. The median of macroplastic mass stored on wood jams equalled 113.2 g/m2 and was 180 times higher than on exposed river sediments, 129 times higher than in the areas overgrown with herbaceous vegetation and 19 times higher than on wooded islands. The results indicated that multi-thread reaches of mountain rivers supporting extensive wooded islands and numerous wood jams are hot-spots of macroplastic storage, whereas channelized reaches lacking these surface types act as transport reaches for macroplastic debris. Thus, multi-thread reaches of mountain rivers in populated areas can be used as target zones for river cleaning actions and downstream ends of channelized reaches as the location for installation of macroplastic trapping infrastructure.

How to cite: Liro, M., Mikuś, P., and Wyżga, B.: First insight into the spatial pattern of macroplastic storage in a mountain river, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1275, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1275, 2022.

EGU22-1285 | Presentations | HS2.3.7 | Highlight

Microplastic accumulation in streambed sediment downstream of a wastewater treatment plant in response to dynamic flow conditions 

Jen Drummond, Uwe Schneidewind, Nicolai Brekenfeld, Holly Nel, Lee Haverson, Anna Kukkola, Greg Sambrook-Smith, and Stefan Krause

Wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs), are known sources of microplastics (1-1000 µm) to receiving streams. We analyzed surface water and streambed sediments at ~1km downstream of a WWTP in a rural stream near Birmingham, UK. To assess the temporal variation in microplastic transport and accumulation, we conducted a total of five sampling campaigns to sample both during high and low flow conditions. Point sampling was supported by semi-continuous measurements of flow and electrical conductivity to characterize the stream hydrologic conditions, especially in response to the WWTP effluent. We used the high frequency flow data as input to a mobile-immobile model for microplastic transport in streams that can account for the exchange between the surface water and streambed sediments, deposition and resuspension during baseflow and stormflow conditions. By combining the model with the less frequent microplastic measurements, we estimated inputs from the wastewater treatment plant and timescales of microplastic deposition and retention in the stream. Our findings advance the understanding of the interplay between microplastics depositing during low flows and resuspending during high flows, to improve predictions of microplastic fate and transport in river systems.

How to cite: Drummond, J., Schneidewind, U., Brekenfeld, N., Nel, H., Haverson, L., Kukkola, A., Sambrook-Smith, G., and Krause, S.: Microplastic accumulation in streambed sediment downstream of a wastewater treatment plant in response to dynamic flow conditions, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1285, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1285, 2022.

EGU22-1528 | Presentations | HS2.3.7

Source activation or fluvial transport – dynamic controls on spatial patterns and temporal dynamics of plastic pollution in river corridors 

Stefan Krause, Holly Nel, Uwe Schneidewind, Anna Kukkola, Jennifer Drummond, Liam Kelleher, Iseult Lynch, Greg Sambrook Smith, Rob Runkel, Deonie Allen, Steve Allen, Mohammad Wazne, Andre-Marie Dendievel, Laurent Simon, Florian Mermillod-Blondin, Lee Haverson, Yasmin Yonan, Brice Mourier, Herve Piegay, and Jesus Gomez-Velez

Microplastic pollution has been found to be ubiquitous in freshwater ecosystems around the world, with global models predicting river network contributions to the oceans to present major and still increasing sources of marine plastic waste. While previous research has to a large degree focussed on identifying potential sources of plastic pollution to freshwater ecosystems (such as wastewater treatment plants, storm sewers, urban areas), and attributing these to observed microplastic pollution patterns in river corridors, little is known under what conditions potential pollution sources become activated and connected to surface waters, and how the fluvial transport of different micro- and nanoplastic size fractions determines spatial patterns of plastics along river networks, including long-term deposition, storage and potential resuspension.

This paper integrates field-based evidence of our global river microplastic survey and several comparative large river network studies (including the rivers Ganges, Boulder Creek, Rhone, and others) with river basin to global scale plastic fate and transport models to identify major drivers of hotspots and hot moments of riverine plastic pollution. Our results highlight under what conditions prior knowledge of the source distributions of plastic pollution carries significant predictive capacity for expected river corridor microplastic concentrations and when (and where) these patters can get transformed substantially by fluvial transport (and transformation) processes. Fusing this experimental evidence with our model predictions revealed significant differences in the downstream footprint, longevity and legacy of dominant sources and transport controls of plastics in the water column and in streambed sediments, driven by gravitational settling, hyporheic exchange flow and resuspension processes.  

How to cite: Krause, S., Nel, H., Schneidewind, U., Kukkola, A., Drummond, J., Kelleher, L., Lynch, I., Sambrook Smith, G., Runkel, R., Allen, D., Allen, S., Wazne, M., Dendievel, A.-M., Simon, L., Mermillod-Blondin, F., Haverson, L., Yonan, Y., Mourier, B., Piegay, H., and Gomez-Velez, J.: Source activation or fluvial transport – dynamic controls on spatial patterns and temporal dynamics of plastic pollution in river corridors, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1528, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1528, 2022.

Contamination of plastic materials in our environment has received more attention from the public, scientists, and policy makers during the last few decades. Though some of the models have succeeded to simulate the transport and fate of plastic debris in freshwater systems, a complete model is under development to elucidate the whole picture of plastic dynamics in the basin scale. One of the authors has so far developed a process-based eco-hydrology model, NICE (National Integrated Catchment-based Eco-hydrology) (Nakayama and Watanabe, 2004) and NICE-BGC (BioGeochemical Cycle) (Nakayama, 2017), and applied them to various basins from local/regional to continental/global scales. NICE-BGC can simulate iteratively nonlinear interactions between hydrologic, geomorphic, and ecological processes (water, heat, sediment, nutrient, and carbon cycles, etc.) (Nakayama, 2020). In this study, the authors extended NICE-BGC to couple with plastic debris model for freshwater systems, and applied it to all the first-class river basins in entire Japan (109 river basins). The new model included the advection, dispersion, diffusion, settling, dissolution and deterioration due to light and temperature, but assumed no interaction with suspended matter (heteroaggregation), resuspension, biofouling, and effect of wind, etc. The authors also assumed plastics as pure and totally inert polymers and spherical particles with constant size and density for model simplification. NICE-BGC simulated how mismanaged plastic waste (MPW) of about 36,000 ton/yr (Meijer et al., 2021) and point sources such as tyres, personal care products (PCPs), dust, and laundry in the entire country are transported from land to river, and finally to the ocean. The model showed the total flux of macro- and micro-plastics varies dependent on the removal efficiency of micro-plastic in wastewater treatment plants and the density of plastic. It was clear that only limited plastics discharged to land flows out into the ocean intensively during rainfall seasons, similar to plastic loading estimates in the previous study (Nihei et al., 2020). These results help to quantify the impacts of plastic waste on terrestrial and aquatic ecosystems, and find solutions and measures to reduce plastic input to the ocean.

How to cite: Nakayama, T. and Osako, M.: Evaluation of fate and transport of macro- and micro-plastics in terrestrial-aquatic continuum of entire Japan by developing a spatio-temporally explicit eco-hydrology model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1566, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1566, 2022.

EGU22-1768 | Presentations | HS2.3.7 | Highlight

The Estuary as a Natural Water Treatment Plant for Microplastics 

Nan Wu, Kate Spencer, Stuart Grieve, and Andrew Manning

Microplastics (MPs) are becoming an important component of suspended particulate matter (SPM), especially in estuaries which are hotspots of MPs pollution. Most SPM in estuarine water are removed via flocculation and further deposited. Therefore, we hypothesise that there is an efficient removal process for MPs by flocculation, which are expected to decrease the overall load of MPs in the marine environment. Here we systematically studied and quantified the influence of MPs properties (size, shape, density, polymer type and weathering condition) on flocculation behavior with suspended sediment in estuary conditions. 

We chose over 20 types of MPs with different properties for 8 size ranges from (10-300 µm for fragments and microbeads, and 10-1000 µm in length for microfibers, respectively). The MPs with different properties and suspended sediment were flocculated in artificial seawater, and the MPs in the system were observed using fluorescence microscopy to distinguish the incorporated MPs and suspended MPs. The incorporation rate (IR) is the ratio of incorporated MPs to total MPs, which is the parameter to evaluate the interaction between MPs and flocs.

The IR decreased with increasing size for fragments and microbeads, and also decreased as the diameter of microfibers rose. The IR for fragments smaller 20 µm is extremely high, from 94.8% to 100%, but gradually decreased with increasing size. For fragments larger than 200 µm, the IR of Polyethylene (PE), Polypropylene (PP) and Polystyrene (PS) are lower than 20%, while higher than 50% for Polyethylene terephthalate (PET) and Polyvinyl chloride (PVC). The IR of PE microbeads is significantly lower than those of fragments. When the diameter of microfibers are smaller than 20 µm, the IRs are always higher than 90%, and the length has no effect on IR. While the IR of microfibers decreased with the length increasing when the diameter of microfibers is larger than 30 µm. According to extensive comparisons between 20 types of MPs, we found that the IR is normally higher in the small size, elongated, angular, high density, weathered, chemically active MPs, while lower in the large size, spherical, low density, pristine and chemically inactive MPs. The size plays the most important role, followed by shape.

There is an evidence that MPs are likely to be removed from the water column and hence estuary sediments are important sinks for MPs. This process reduces overall load to marine environments, but this is selective and depends on the characteristics of MPs. This study offers a reference to predict the preferential removal behavior of MPs in the estuary.

How to cite: Wu, N., Spencer, K., Grieve, S., and Manning, A.: The Estuary as a Natural Water Treatment Plant for Microplastics, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1768, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1768, 2022.

EGU22-1804 | Presentations | HS2.3.7

Plastics Gone Missing: Resolving the Mass Balance at River Bifurcations 

Khoa Thi, Tim van Emmerik, Ton Hoitink, and Nhan Quy Pham

Recent studies suggest that more land-based plastics are accumulated and remobilized in riverine environments than exported to the ocean. Hydrodynamics and other factors like wind drag and navigation can drive plastics to riverbanks, where they can be retained in plants, on floodplains, or in stagnant water bodies. With this study, we provide additional observational evidence that a substantial share of floating plastics may not flow downstream. Every week from May to December 2021, we measured floating plastics at three bridges located in the Hong-Duong bifurcation of the Red River, Vietnam. These locations were chosen to monitor both the input plastics entering the bifurcation and the output plastics exiting the bifurcation in both branches. The upstream location is Nhat Tan, which is located on the Red River in northern Hanoi. The downstream location on the main stream is Long Bien, approximately 8 kilometers south of Nhat Tan on the Red River, while the third location is in Dong Tru, on the distributary Duong River, about 7 kilometers from Nhat Tan. We collected data on the plastic mass balance of various plastic categories in the bifurcation, including PET, PO-soft, PO-hard, multilayers, PS, and PS-E. The results indicated that the plastic mass balance does not close in general; there is more plastic upstream than in the two downstream locations combined. The dry season, from October to December, was more balanced, with a 4% difference. Meanwhile, between May and September, approximately 16% of floating plastics were discovered to be missing. Additionally, the majority of floating plastics remained in the main stream, with only 8% entering the distributary, and the division rate kept constant throughout the study period. However, the balance differed for specific categories. Five categories had missing downstream records compared to upstream, and PO-soft featured a more intricate balance mechanism with alternating changes between missing and abundant records from month to month. In the meantime, PS was seen upstream but was never detected downstream. For PS-E, most of the items found in the upstream were either detected in the distributary, or disappeared in the bifurcation; less than 1% was identified downstream. The variation in transport between PS and PS-E may be caused by deposition, extraction, accumulation, or sub-surface transport. Finally, except for PO-hard, the rate of plastic transport was found to be higher near the river banks than in the thalweg. These findings suggest that the transport mechanism of macroplastics in rivers may be more complex than previously assumed, and prompt further studies. Our data allow modelling plastic transport for different plastic categories, designing suitable monitoring or clean-up methods, and understanding the roles of hydrological components such as discharge and flow velocity in transporting plastics.

How to cite: Thi, K., van Emmerik, T., Hoitink, T., and Quy Pham, N.: Plastics Gone Missing: Resolving the Mass Balance at River Bifurcations, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1804, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1804, 2022.

EGU22-3582 | Presentations | HS2.3.7 | Highlight

Plastic accumulation on riverbanks after the July 2021 Meuse flood 

Rahel Hauk, Tim van Emmerik, Marijke Boonstra, Winnie de Winter, and Martine van der Ploeg

The majority of mismanaged plastic waste does not reach the oceans, and rather accumulates in terrestrial and freshwater environments. Since 2017, riverbanks along the Dutch part of the river Meuse have been monitored by volunteers in spring and fall. At each monitored riverbank macroplastic and other litter items were collected along a 100 m section and classified in over 100 specific item categories. In July 2021, the Meuse was hit by a severe flood event with an estimated return period between 100 - > 1000 years, similar to other rivers in Germany, France, Belgium, and the Netherlands. Flood conditions can highly increase plastic (re)mobilization and transport within river systems, and plastic discharge into the oceans. However, the impact of a severe flood event on plastic litter accumulation on riverbanks, to the authors knowledge, was never measured before. Within three weeks after the flood event we counted and classified macroplastic and other litter items on 25 riverbanks along the Meuse, from the Dutch-Belgian border to the river mouth. The additional sampling allows us to, for the first time, assess the impact of such a flood event on plastic accumulation on riverbanks. In this presentation we compare plastic accumulation on riverbanks after this flood event to plastic accumulation during normal conditions. We compare the amounts and types of litter, and possible litter sources. This study aims to contribute to better understand mobilization, transport, and accumulation dynamics of plastics in river systems, and the role and impact of extreme events on plastic accumulation on riverbanks.

How to cite: Hauk, R., van Emmerik, T., Boonstra, M., de Winter, W., and van der Ploeg, M.: Plastic accumulation on riverbanks after the July 2021 Meuse flood, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3582, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3582, 2022.

EGU22-3669 | Presentations | HS2.3.7

Microplastics in Indian freshwater systems – is an anthropogenic influence measurable? 

Simone Lechthaler, Kryss Waldschläger, Chavapati Gouse Sandhani, Sannasiraj Sannasi Annamalaisamy, Sundar Vallam, Jan Schwarzbauer, and Holger Schüttrumpf

Microplastics are detected in most environmental compartments and hence receive a great deal of attention, especially in aquatic environments where rivers act as pathways for microplastics. Currently, a particularly high input of microplastics through Asian rivers is assumed predominantly by modelling data, while field measurements are scanty.

Three rivers in South India were considered for this purpose to focus on their microplastic loads. The emphasis was on the comparison of microplastic concentrations in urban and rural rivers to identify if the anthropogenic influence control the loads. While two rivers in the megacity Chennai (Tamil Nadu) were found to have an average microplastic concentration of 0.4 microplastic particles/L, a rural river near Munnar (Kerala) had an average concentration of 0.2 microplastic particles/L. The results show higher loads in the urban area with a high anthropogenic influence by wastewater discharges and waste disposal through high number of residents dumping directly by the river. Fibres were the predominant shape (64.13%), black was the predominant particle colour (44.80%) and polyethylene and polyprolyene were the predominant polymers (each 46.67%) detected within the identified particles of all samples.

Rough estimates of annual microplastic discharge from the Adyar River (Chennai) into the Bay of Bengal are found to be as high as 11.6 trillion microplastic particles. This study, which is one of the first baseline studies for microplastic loads in South Indian streams, should be complemented with further environmental sampling during pre-monsoon, monsoon and post-monsoon seasons to get more detailed information on the storage and transportation of fluvial microplastics and to understand the seasonal effect on the river flow characteristics as well as the fate of microplastics.

How to cite: Lechthaler, S., Waldschläger, K., Sandhani, C. G., Sannasi Annamalaisamy, S., Vallam, S., Schwarzbauer, J., and Schüttrumpf, H.: Microplastics in Indian freshwater systems – is an anthropogenic influence measurable?, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3669, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3669, 2022.

EGU22-3775 | Presentations | HS2.3.7

Modeling microplastic deposition in sandy streams with moving bedforms 

Eshel Peleg, William P. Johnson, Yoni Teitelbaum, and Shai Arnon

Microplastic (MP) delivery from the terrestrial to aquatic environments is a global concern to many ecosystems and potentially also to humans. Currently, a limited number of models can accurately predict how MPs move through streams and rivers toward the oceans. The limited predictive power of classical colloid filtration theory and the lack of models that take into account the interactive effect between streambed characteristics, flow conditions and particle characteristics limit our ability to model the deposition of MP in streambeds. This study combines improved mechanistic prediction of colloid attachment with a model that predicts flow and transport of particles in a moving streambed to quantify MP deposition in streams. A set of numerical simulations were conducted using sand with D50 of 0.3 mm and hydraulic conductivity of 0.12 cm/s. Such sand is predicted to form ripples with a length of approximately 17 cm and a height of 1.9 cm. Coefficient of attachment (Katt) was predicted for simulated MP particles of four different densities (900, 1050, 1140, and 1350 (Kg/m3), which are typical densities of Polypropylene [PP], Polystyrene [PS], Polyamide [PA], Polyethylene terephthalate [PET], respectively. In addition, model scenarios included three colloidal sizes (0.5, 1, 10 μm) and various overlying stream velocities of 0.1-0.5 m/sec. Such stream velocities were predicted to yield bed celerities between 0-130 cm/hr. Hyporheic exchange flux between the stream and the bed increased non-linearly with celerity and was found to be ten times greater for the fast celerity (130 cm/hr at stream velocity of 0.5 m/sec) as compared to slow-moving bedform with the same geometry (10 cm/hr at stream velocity of 0.2 m/sec). Difference hyporheic exchange fluxes are also expected to influence the rate of MP delivery to the bed and their deposition. Initial simulations show that increased bedform celerity and Katt lead to a shallower depth of MP deposition and a more compact distribution in the bed. Increased celerity reduces deposition depth by flattening hyporheic exchange flow paths. Therefore, despite an increased flux of MP into the bed under high stream water velocity, deposition occurs at shallower depths, and the chance for resuspension due to erosion of the bed sediment increases. Quantifying the deposition rates and residence time in the bed is essential for understanding the transfer of MP through streams and rivers toward the oceans, developing sampling strategies, and finding long-term solutions for reducing their concentrations and the associated risks.

How to cite: Peleg, E., Johnson, W. P., Teitelbaum, Y., and Arnon, S.: Modeling microplastic deposition in sandy streams with moving bedforms, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3775, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3775, 2022.

EGU22-4239 | Presentations | HS2.3.7 | Highlight

Influence of chemical aging processes on releasing organic products from microplastics 

Jagoda Worek, Katarzyna Styszko, and Anna Białas

At the end of the 1940s, the production of plastics began on a large scale. Since then, a dynamic increase in their production has been observed. It is associated with a variety of applications and low costs. The negative consequences of the use of polymers and poor disposal are still growing. Microplastic is an important hazard. These are pieces of plastic, the size of which does not exceed 5 mm. Microplastic particles have already been detected all over the world. Increasingly, attention is being paid to their accumulation in the environment. During their stay in ecosystems, they undergo aging processes. Their structure and composition are changing. The washed substances are released into the environment. The aim of the research was to check the effect of artificial aging methods on the leaching of functional groups and changes in the structure of selected polymers. Polystyrene and polyethylene terephthalate were selected for the research. They belong to the most common kind of plastics. For aging, combined methods were used, with irradiation with UV lamp irradiation and hydrogen peroxide. Before and post-aging polymers were analyzed using spectroscopic methods and a microscope. ATR FTIR, Raman confocal microscope and FTIR microscope were used for this purpose. The tests showed leaching of organic products from the samples and the formation of additional  bands. The structure of plastics has changed. These changes show a possible degradation path for plastics with a significant environmental impact.

How to cite: Worek, J., Styszko, K., and Białas, A.: Influence of chemical aging processes on releasing organic products from microplastics, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4239, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4239, 2022.

EGU22-4402 | Presentations | HS2.3.7 | Highlight

Ensemble modeling of plastic flows in South Africa’s rivers with a large-scale hydrological model 

Alena Bartosova, Conrad Brendel, and Berit Arheimer

Plastic pollution is one of the major global water quality issues. Yet the lack of consistent data and standardized monitoring leads to a wide range of estimates of plastic load that is being delivered to marine environment. At the same time, continental and global dynamic hydrological models have emerged as tools for e.g. flood forecasting, large-scale climate impact analyses, and estimation of time-dynamic water fluxes into sea basins. One such tool is a dynamic process-based rainfall-runoff and water quality model Hydrological Predictions for Environment (HYPE) and its global application, World-Wide HYPE (WWH, Arheimer et al., 2020). We present the first results simulating riverine plastic pollution in South Africa using a WWH submodel.

WWH was amended to include the population living within different sanitation conditions. Sanitation service type and safely managed fraction were estimated for each catchment by combining country and regional sanitation data (WHO, 2017) with human development index data (5 arc-min resolution; Kummu et al., 2020) and high-resolution (1km grid) settlement type and population (Pesaresi et al., 2019) datasets. This information was then linked to plastic waste generation, both in terms of mismanaged waste production and microplastics associated with municipal point sources.

Data on plastic flows and concentrations in various South African freshwater bodies were collected from published literature. Traditional model calibration techniques may not be appropriate in this case due to insufficient number of data points, large variability in plastic characteristics and sampling techniques, as well as large uncertainty and a lack of current knowledge of transport and transformation processes in water bodies. Thus, an ensemble of the models was developed by varying model parameters that affect generation, transformation, and transport of plastic from the various sanitation categories and in rivers. Collected data together with other global estimates were then used to evaluate the ensemble with a weight of evidence approach, highlighting sources and processes of major significance and focusing the ensemble towards a realistic set. This set will be used to further develop modeling routines at a large scale and provide guidance in developing the full global model.

References:

Arheimer, B., Pimentel, R., Isberg, K., Crochemore, L., Andersson, J. C. M., Hasan, A., and Pineda, L., 2020. Global catchment modelling using World-Wide HYPE (WWH), open data and stepwise parameter estimation, Hydrol. Earth Syst. Sci. 24, 535–559, https://doi.org/10.5194/hess-24-535-2020

Kummu, Matti; Taka, Maija; Guillaume, Joseph H. A. (2020), Data from: Gridded global datasets for Gross Domestic Product and Human Development Index over 1990-2015, Dryad, Dataset, https://doi.org/10.5061/dryad.dk1j0

Pesaresi, Martino; Florczyk, Aneta; Schiavina, Marcello; Melchiorri, Michele; Maffenini, Luca (2019): GHS-SMOD R2019A - GHS settlement layers, updated and refined REGIO model 2014 in application to GHS-BUILT R2018A and GHS-POP R2019A, multitemporal (1975-1990-2000-2015). European Commission, Joint Research Centre (JRC) [Dataset] doi: 10.2905/42E8BE89-54FF-464E-BE7B-BF9E64DA5218 PID: http://data.europa.eu/89h/42e8be89-54ff-464e-be7b-bf9e64da5218

World Health Organization. "Progress on drinking water, sanitation and hygiene: 2017 update and SDG baselines." (2017).

How to cite: Bartosova, A., Brendel, C., and Arheimer, B.: Ensemble modeling of plastic flows in South Africa’s rivers with a large-scale hydrological model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4402, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4402, 2022.

EGU22-4450 | Presentations | HS2.3.7

Rising and settling velocities of macroplastic foils 

Boaz Kuizenga, Tim van Emmerik, Kryss Waldschläger, and Merel Kooi

Plastics accumulate in the environment due to inadequate waste management, and the durability of the material. A better understanding of fundamental plastic behaviour in the aquatic environment is essential to estimate transport and accumulation, which can be used for monitoring, prevention and reduction strategies. An important process for fate models is the vertical transport of particles, for which the rising and settling velocity are crucial variables. Several studies have described these for microplastics (<0.5 cm) using observations and models. For macroplastics (>0.5 cm) however, such data are scarce. In this study, the rising and settling behaviour of three polymer types (PET, PP, and PE) commonly found in the environment was investigated. The plastic particles were foils of different sizes and shapes. A new method for releasing rising plastics without interfering the flow and disturbing the column was used. Observational data were used to test the performance of four models, including one developed in this study, for estimating the settling and rising velocity based on the properties of the plastic particles. These models were validated using the data obtained in this study, as well as data from another study on plastic rising and settling rates. The newly introduced foil velocity model gave the best results (R² = 0.96 and 0.29 for both data sets, respectively). This model has the potential to estimate the rising and settling velocity of plastic foils, and should be further investigated using additional observational data. The results of our work can be used to further explore the vertical distribution of plastics in rivers, lakes and oceans, which is crucial for improving future efforts to monitor and reduce plastics.

How to cite: Kuizenga, B., van Emmerik, T., Waldschläger, K., and Kooi, M.: Rising and settling velocities of macroplastic foils, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4450, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4450, 2022.

The interaction of plastics with (trace) elements has recently attracted research interest. Plastic particles, in fact, are contaminating water environments and can possibly act as sinks or vector of (trace) elements affecting their environmental fate and bioavailability.

The details of the mechanisms driving the interaction of plastic particles and (trace) elements are unclear. It has been argued that the degradation processes of polymers and the colonization by micro-organisms can enhance adsorption of (trace) elements. Moreover, the chemistry of water solution is a determinant of the interaction equilibria.

The PLANET project (understanding PLAstic pollutioN effects on the biogeochemical cycle of ElemenTs) aims at elucidating the mechanisms behind plastic - (trace) element interactions and at investigating the implications for the biogeochemical cycle of (trace) elements in water bodies. This aim will be reached through 4 main pillars, consisting in: i) experiments with artificially aged plastics and biofouling experiments, including the characterization of surface physicochemical properties in aged plastics, ii) sorption and desorption tests with ions and metals in batch experiments under varying physicochemical conditions to measure the energy of the interaction; iii) construction of predictive mathematical frames describing this interaction and its impication for (trace) elements’ cycling; iv) assessment of model predictions through microcosms experiments.

The project was launched in November 2021 and currently the first pillar is under development. Tested materials included both polyolefins (PE and PP) and biodegradable materials (PLA and PBAT). Controlled artificial ageing is achieved through UV radiation in water at varying salinity and pH and through inoculation of bacteria and algae consortia into specially designed microcosms. Plastic materials are analyzed through Fourier transform-Infrared spectroscopy to measure changes in surface functional groups, and through scanning electron microscopy to analyze surface morphology. Preliminary results show that biofouling processes take place rapidly under these experimental conditions on different types of polymer (with attachment of first algae in few days). Biofouling has a strong influence on functional groups changes on the polymers: the presence of polysaccharides from bacteria is observable in most of the biofouled plastics. These evidences highlight that a main role in adsorption-desoprtion processes in plastic particles is mediated by the colonizing microorganisms, which can cover an abundant portion of the plastic surface in waters.

How to cite: Binda, G. and Nizzetto, L.: Understanding the effects of plastic pollution on the biogeochemical cycle of elements: introducing PLANET project, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5567, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5567, 2022.

EGU22-6516 | Presentations | HS2.3.7

“The net trapping effect”: is riparian vegetation affecting riverine macrolitter distribution? 

Luca Gallitelli, Maurizio Cutini, and Massimiliano Scalici

Plastics represent a new widely distributed global concern, affecting aquatic ecosystems. Macrolitter, with a focus on plastics, can cause detrimental effects on freshwater biota and also affect human health. Among freshwater systems, rivers are of particular interest as they carry the majority of macroplastic litter from the land to the seas. Recently, many studies quantified riverine macroplastic litter transport. Although plastic transport depends on river hydrometeorological factors (e.g. river discharge, wind speed) and geomorphological characteristics (e.g. meanders, river width), several studies highlighted macrolitter accumulation zones in riverbank vegetated areas. However, few studies observed the role of vegetation in entrapping macrolitter on riverbanks. Here, we aimed at quantifying for the first time the plant structure efficiency in macrolitter entrapment. To do so, we sampled riparian areas along 6 rivers in the three riverine zones (upper, middle, lower course) in Central Italy. For each river, riparian vegetation was sampled in relation to river width and riparian zone width. Overall, we found 1,548 macrolitter items on ~300 m2 of sampled riparian areas with plastics representing 96.3% of total litter. Specifically, riparian vegetation entrapped 93.9% of total litter, while 6.1% was found on unvegetated areas of the riverbank. The best efficient riparian plants in entrapping macrolitter were: (i) Populus spp. (51.6%), (ii) Salix spp. (19.0%), (iii) Rubus ulmifolius (6.7%), (iv) Phragmites australis (6.3%), and (v) Ficus carica (1.8%), accounting for 85.4% of the total macrolitter entrapped by plants. Precisely, plants entrapped macrolitter mainly in branches between 0.5 m and 2 m (69.5%) and below 0.5 m (28.3%). Plant structures (e.g. stolons, branches) form a sort of net that can trap litter but can also act as a wall retaining it. The top-5 items entrapped within plants (83.4% of total litter) were: (i) plastic pieces (74.7%), (ii) plastic bags (6.9%), (iii) plastic bendages (6.6%), (iv) sanitary and hygienic towels (4.8%), (v) plastic packaging (4.4%). Among river zones, plants in river lower course entrapped most macrolitter against the upper and middle zones. Some explaining factors for this could be changes in riparian vegetation characteristics and in hydrological regime, as well as higher leakage rate of macrolitter in the lower course of the river. In conclusion, the role of riparian vegetation in entrapping macrolitter is at an early stage, but with high potential to be developed and applied. For the first time, we characterized the role and the structure of riparian vegetation in entrapping macrolitter. We put our emphasis on plant species and structures that are important variables for understanding the entrapment efficiency of macrolitter, highlighting that the complexity of riparian vegetation structure is key for the trapping net effect. As riparian species can provide us the ecosystem service of trapping macrolitter, these findings are crucial for ecosystem restoration and sustainable requalification of the threatened freshwater habitats.

How to cite: Gallitelli, L., Cutini, M., and Scalici, M.: “The net trapping effect”: is riparian vegetation affecting riverine macrolitter distribution?, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6516, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6516, 2022.

EGU22-7423 | Presentations | HS2.3.7

A robust deep learning methodology to detect floating macro-plastic litter in rivers 

Tianlong Jia, Rinze de Vries, Zoran Kapelan, and Riccardo Taormina

Plastic pollution in rivers is a serious environmental concern. To improve the monitoring of floating macro-plastic litter in water, researchers increasingly resort to automatic detection tools based on Artificial Intelligence (AI) for Computer Vision (CV). The most advanced applications feature Deep Learning (DL) methods based on Convolutional Neural Networks (CNN) achieving state-of-the-art performances in standard CV datasets (e.g., ImageNet).

Despite promising initial results, only few studies validated the generalization ability of DL models across different locations, environmental conditions, and instrumental setups. Poor generalization results in the need for a new model for each different setting. This increases the data requirements and limits the applicability. These aspects are essential for practical implementations such as the development of a structural monitoring strategy backed by a reliable AI model.

In this work, we discuss how to develop a robust DL methodology by harnessing recent advancements in AI, such as data-centric AI and semi-supervised learning. We also show the effects of implementing these techniques on the generalization performances of a DL model by employing two different datasets of floating macro-plastic in rivers. The first is a new dataset recorded in a semi-controlled environment featuring a small drainage canal in the Netherlands; the second is a dataset available from the literature, with images from different waterways in Jakarta, Indonesia. The significant diversity among the two datasets grants a sound evaluation of model generalization performances and on the suitability of the proposed methodology for achieving increased robustness.

How to cite: Jia, T., de Vries, R., Kapelan, Z., and Taormina, R.: A robust deep learning methodology to detect floating macro-plastic litter in rivers, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7423, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7423, 2022.

EGU22-8010 | Presentations | HS2.3.7

Interplay of topography, flood frequency and soil properties determine the distribution of microplastics in a Rhine floodplain 

Markus Rolf, Hannes Laermanns, Lukas Kienzler, Christian Pohl, Julia Möller, Christian Laforsch, Martin G.J. Löder, and Christina Bogner

Rivers are important transport pathways of microplastics from terrestrial to marine environments. They also interact with terrestrial ecosystems, in particular during flood events, when microplastics can be deposited in or eroded from floodplains. The spatial distribution of these riverine microplastics in alluvial floodplains remains widely unclear. However, the knowledge on their abundance and distribution in floodplain soils is essentially important for ecological risk assessment.

We analysed the distribution of microplastics in three transects of a floodplain soil in a nature reserve in Cologne (Germany). We took soil samples in two different depths (0-5 cm and 5-20 cm), described the soil profiles and plant cover and determined the soil texture. Additionally, we used a hydrodynamic model (MIKE21 software by DHI) and time series of Rhine's water level to analyse the frequency of past flood events from 1950 to 2020. We analysed concentrations of microplastics via ATR-FTIR and µ-FPA-FTIR spectroscopy after density separation and enzymatic-oxidative purification of soil samples. We found elevated microplastic concentrations per kg of dry soil with increasing distance to the river ranging from 25,616 particles/kg to 84,824 particles/kg. Combining the analysis of flood events, the digital terrain model and quantification of microplastics, we show how the local topography (e.g., depressions), flood frequency and soil properties (e.g., grain size) interact and affect the spatial and vertical distribution of microplastics.

How to cite: Rolf, M., Laermanns, H., Kienzler, L., Pohl, C., Möller, J., Laforsch, C., Löder, M. G. J., and Bogner, C.: Interplay of topography, flood frequency and soil properties determine the distribution of microplastics in a Rhine floodplain, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8010, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8010, 2022.

EGU22-8453 | Presentations | HS2.3.7

Stuck in vegetation: the role of hyacinths in macroplastic debris accumulation in tropical rivers 

Louise Schreyers, Thanh-Khiet Bui, Tim van Emmerik, Lauren Biermann, and Martine van der Ploeg

Water hyacinths are considered one the world’s most invasive aquatic species and are found in most tropical rivers. Hyacinths can form dense patches of several meters of length and width at the water surface and drift due to the combined action of wind and flow velocity. In rivers, hyacinth patches can function as carriers for floating macroplastic debris from rivers into the ocean. In the Saigon river, Vietnam, water hyacinths were found to accumulate a majority of the total floating macroplastic items (Schreyers et al., 2021). Despite their crucial role in macroplastic accumulation and dispersion, precise quantification of both hyacinth coverage and macroplastic concentrations in rivers are currently lacking. We present insights on the accumulation of macroplastics within hyacinth patches based on the analysis of more than 3,000 Unmanned Aerial Vehicle images collected at the Saigon river in 2021. In particular, we explore the relation between hyacinth coverage, patch abundance and floating macroplastic concentrations, and how these vary through time and space. These findings clearly illustrate the complexity of plastic transport in rivers by highlighting its spatiotemporal variability. Our insights can be used for combined clean-up efforts and reduction strategies of both hyacinths and plastic debris in the Saigon river, and support the development of future plastic monitoring strategies in other tropical river systems.   

References

Schreyers, L., van Emmerik, T., Luan Nguyen, T., Castrop, E., Phung, N.-A., Kieu-Le, T.-C., Strady, E., Biermann, L., van der Ploeg, M. (2021). Plastic plants: Water hyacinths as driver of plastic transport in tropical rivers. Frontiers in Environmental Science 10.3389/fenvs.2021.686334  

 

How to cite: Schreyers, L., Bui, T.-K., van Emmerik, T., Biermann, L., and van der Ploeg, M.: Stuck in vegetation: the role of hyacinths in macroplastic debris accumulation in tropical rivers, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8453, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8453, 2022.

EGU22-8666 | Presentations | HS2.3.7

Microplastic dynamics within turbulence for improved modelling and monitoring strategies 

Hadeel Al-Zawaidah, Bart Vermeulen, and Kryss Waldschlager

Microplastics are an unavoidable part of riverine systems, altering the natural composition of rivers and the associated processes. Within a riverine system, microplastics can be present throughout the water column or within bedload, implying different transport, deposition, and erosion mechanisms. Some recent models have been developed to predict and understand the depth distribution concentration of microplastics and macroplastics, primarily relying on the Rouse model for sediments. However, the great variety in microplastics shape and size accompanied by the dynamic nature of riverine systems (e.g., variety of flow conditions, sediment composition and bedforms) question how realistic and reliable models for plastic distribution along the water column and within sediments are. Present models are often analogous to suspended sediment models and assume diffusivity to be equal to turbulent viscosity, they often exclude the bedload, neglect the effect of turbulence and bed morphology, and come short in explaining the behaviour of mixtures of microplastics and sediments. Understanding these aspects is crucial to improve present models and to aid mitigation efforts and to optimize collection systems and policy. This project targets employing both physical and numerical modelling techniques to further develop depth concentration models of microplastics. We aim to further examine and quantify the influence of turbulence on microplastics transport and concentration distribution by establishing preliminary estimates for the eddy viscosity and diffusivity of microplastics and further examine a wider range of mixtures of microplastics and sediments with different shapes and sizes.

How to cite: Al-Zawaidah, H., Vermeulen, B., and Waldschlager, K.: Microplastic dynamics within turbulence for improved modelling and monitoring strategies, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8666, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8666, 2022.

EGU22-8796 | Presentations | HS2.3.7

Using fluorometric techniques to quantify microplastic transport in an experimental flume 

Jan-Pascal Boos, Benjamin Gilfedder, and Sven Frei

Rivers and streams are a primary transport vector for microplastics (MPs), connecting terrestrial sources to marine environments. While previous studies indicated that pore-scale MPs can accumulate in streambed sediments, the specific MPs transport and retention mechanisms in fluvial systems remain poorly understood. We present a novel method for a quantitative analysis of the spatiotemporal transport and retention of pore-scale MPs in an experimental flume. A continuous mass balance for MPs in surface water was achieved using two online fluorometers, while a laser-induced Fluorescence-Imaging-System was developed to track and quantify the spatial migration of MPs through the streambed sediments. The detection limit was <1 μg/L for 1 μm polystyrene microbeads with the fluorometers and 3 μg/L for the Fluorescence-Imaging-System. The system was able to quantitatively track the advective transfer of MPs into the streambed sediments: a process that has yet not been observed experimentally. Results showed that MPs infiltrated into the streambed sediments up to a depth twice the bedform amplitude. This work provides a novel experimental method to quantitatively monitor MP transport through porous media and advective exchange of MP across the streambed interface.

How to cite: Boos, J.-P., Gilfedder, B., and Frei, S.: Using fluorometric techniques to quantify microplastic transport in an experimental flume, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8796, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8796, 2022.

EGU22-9060 | Presentations | HS2.3.7

16,000 riverbank litter items – A data driven approach to optimizing riverine plastic monitoring 

Finn Begemann, Sjoukje de Lange, Yvette Mellink, Paul Vriend, Paolo Tasseron, and Tim van Emmerik

Macrolitter in aquatic environments is an emerging environmental risk, as it negatively impacts ecosystems, endangers aquatic species, and causes economic damage. One of the major reservoirs of macrolitter in aquatic environments are riverbanks. To effectively clean riverbanks and prevent future litter from accumulating in these reservoirs, robust monitoring techniques are needed that allow for quick, but reliable, assessments of the type, size and mass of macrolitter in these reservoirs. Here, we present a unique dataset of more than 16,000 anthropogenic litter items in the Dutch Rhine, Meuse and IJssel rivers. With this dataset, we facilitate making considered decisions for developing future monitoring strategies. Items were collected on 8 different riverbanks once per month for one year. Items were collected at upstream and downstream locations along the Dutch part of the rivers, and were categorized (river-OSPAR), weighed and measured. The dataset shows that the majority of the found items is plastic, especially fragments of foam, soft plastics (foils), and hard plastics. The composition of litter type varies more in space than in time, indicating that the spatial resolution of a future monitoring campaign outweighs the importance of the temporal resolution. We performed a Monte Carlo analysis to determine sample size requirements to calculate a representative number of average item mass. Up until 8,900 items are needed for an accurate representation of average items mass, depending on item category uniformity. Finally, a method is proposed to determine on which item size should be focused. The presented dataset can be used in future research, modelling practices and development of management strategies. 

How to cite: Begemann, F., de Lange, S., Mellink, Y., Vriend, P., Tasseron, P., and van Emmerik, T.: 16,000 riverbank litter items – A data driven approach to optimizing riverine plastic monitoring, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9060, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9060, 2022.

EGU22-9118 | Presentations | HS2.3.7 | Highlight

Rivers as Plastic Reservoirs 

Tim van Emmerik, Yvette Mellink, Rahel Hauk, Kryss Waldschläger, and Louise Schreyers

Land-based plastic waste, carried to the sea through rivers, is considered a main source of marine plastic pollution. However, most plastics that leak into the environment never make it into the ocean. Only a small fraction of plastics that are found in the terrestrial and aquatic compartments of river systems are emitted, and the vast majority can be retained for years, decades, and potentially centuries. In this presentation we introduce the concept of river systems as plastic reservoirs. Under normal conditions, hydrometeorological variables (such as wind, runoff and river discharge) mobilize, transport and deposit plastics within different river compartments (e.g. riverbanks, floodplains, lakes, estuaries). The emptying of these plastic reservoirs primarily occurs under extreme hydrological conditions (e.g. storms, floods). We specifically focus on the retention mechanisms within different river compartments, and their effect on the fate of the plastics that are accumulated over various timescales. With this presentation, we aim to introduce the concept of rivers as (long-term) sinks for plastic pollution, and provide suggestions for future research directions.

How to cite: van Emmerik, T., Mellink, Y., Hauk, R., Waldschläger, K., and Schreyers, L.: Rivers as Plastic Reservoirs, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9118, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9118, 2022.

EGU22-9320 | Presentations | HS2.3.7

Macroplastic emissions from the Odaw river, Ghana, into the ocean. 

Rose Pinto, Tom Barendse, Tim van Emmerik, Frank Annor, Kwame Duah, Job Udo, Dorien Lugt, and Remko Uijlenhoet

Rivers have been highlighted to play a key role in the transport of plastics into the ocean and especially, urban water systems act as a major source of plastic leakage into the marine environment.  However, observed data on plastic pollution in these urban water systems are scarce.  Our study focuses on the Odaw river basin which is the main drainage systems in Accra, Ghana, and is heavily polluted with macroplastics.  This is due to the high anthropogenic activities which have increased the indiscriminate dumping of waste into the water system.  These macroplastics in the water system accumulates over long periods, and a part of it is emitted into the ocean during high discharges.  Due to limited data on the quantification of macroplastics in the Odaw river, the seasonality and hotspot accumulation zones of these macroplastics in the river are unknown.  Such information is crucial for policymakers to prioritize future plastic debris monitoring and mitigation strategies.  We aimed to quantify the macroplastic emissions from the Odaw river into the ocean.  Using visual plastic counting from four bridges together with a hydrodynamic model, estimations for total yearly plastic fluxes through the Odaw river were made.  This model used rainfall data from 2016-2021 at the input nodes to simulate the discharges in the water system.  We estimated a total plastic flux from the Odaw river into the ocean between 2.6 x 101 and 1.7 x 103 tons per year.  Low plastic fluxes were observed at the bridges during dry periods, but a 10 fold increase in plastic fluxes was observed during and after a rainfall event.  Except for two sampling days, negative plastic fluxes were observed at the two bridges closest to the ocean due to the effect of tides.  These observations made the estimation of the total plastic emissions into the ocean challenging because of the bidirectional flow dynamics of the macroplastics at these locations.  The findings of this study provide baseline data for macroplastic transport through the Odaw river into the ocean.  Future research could focus on investigating the accumulation zones of macroplastics at the bridges closest to the river mouths due to the role of tidal dynamics on the river plastic transport and export into the ocean.

How to cite: Pinto, R., Barendse, T., van Emmerik, T., Annor, F., Duah, K., Udo, J., Lugt, D., and Uijlenhoet, R.: Macroplastic emissions from the Odaw river, Ghana, into the ocean., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9320, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9320, 2022.

The pollution of the environment by plastics has become one of the most emerging environmental issues over the past years. Especially micro- and nanosized colloidal particles are of environmental concern since they can be easily taken up by organisms and accumulate in the food chain. Hitherto, only little attention has been paid to the transformation and elimination processes of colloidal microplastic (MP) in the environment. In aquatic environments, colloidal MP will interact with natural constituents, such as metal (oxyhydr)oxides or organic matter. The reaction of those particles is strongly controlled by the surface properties of both, MP particles and the environmental particles. In this study, we investigated the interactions of polystyrene (PS) particles (diameter 1 µm) and ferrihydrite, a common ferric (oxyhydr)oxide. PS particles were allowed to react with ferrihydrite for one week at different pH values (3-11) and constant ionic strength (10 mM). The surface properties of PS were examined before and after reaction with ferrihydrite using dynamic light scattering techniques. Furthermore, we determined the sedimentation rate of PS in presence and absence of ferrihydrite. The results demonstrate that the presence of ferrihydrite increases the sedimentation of PS at all pH values. At neutral pH, we observe not only the strongest sedimentation but also maximum heteroaggregation between PS and ferrihydrite. Overall, our research suggests that ferric (oxyhydr)oxides are highly important reactants to control the environmental behaviour of MP particles. Heteroaggregation with ferric (oxyhydr)oxides and subsequent sedimentation can remove microplastic particles from the water column.

How to cite: Schmidtmann, J. and Peiffer, S.: Heteroaggregation of PS microplastic with ferrihydrite leads to rapid removal of microplastic particles from the water column, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9603, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9603, 2022.

EGU22-9806 | Presentations | HS2.3.7

Evaluation of the Effects of Particle Characteristics on the Terminal Settling Velocities of Microplastics in Stagnant Waters using CFD 

Pouyan Ahmadi, Hassan Elagami, Franz Dichgans, Benjamin Gilfedder, and Jan H. Fleckenstein

Mismanaged waste leads to inputs of microplastics into the environment and the aquatic system affecting rivers and lakes. The physical properties of microplastic (MP) particles affect their terminal settling velocity (TSV) in the water column and in turn their distribution patterns in aquatic systems. To evaluate the settling behavior and the TSV of MP particles we simulated the settling of a large range of MP particles with regular and irregular shapes in the water column using a computational fluid dynamics (CFD) model. To validate the results returned by our model, we compared CFD findings to the corresponding results obtained by semi-empirical relationships as well as the results from experiments for 120 irregularly shaped MP particles with sizes and densities ranging from 500 to 2000 µm and 1.03 to 1.38 grcm-3, respectively. The CFD results are in good agreement with the results from the laboratory and semi-empirical relationships with a 0.05 difference in the slopes of their linear regressions. In a next step, we defined scenarios to systematically investigate the influence of different particle characteristics such as roundness, density, and volume as well as water temperature on the TSV of regular and irregular MP particles. Our simulations revealed a dominant effect of particle density on the TSV compared to the effects of the other parameters. For example, doubling particle densities increased the TSVs of the MP particles up to 500%, while, doubling their volumes only led to a maximum increase in their TSV of 200%. Increasing the roundness of the MP particles, letting them evolve towards a perfect sphere, increased their TSVs by up to 15%, while seasonal changes in lake water temperatures typical for lakes in temperate climate regions, caused changes in TSVs by up to 32%.

How to cite: Ahmadi, P., Elagami, H., Dichgans, F., Gilfedder, B., and Fleckenstein, J. H.: Evaluation of the Effects of Particle Characteristics on the Terminal Settling Velocities of Microplastics in Stagnant Waters using CFD, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9806, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9806, 2022.

EGU22-9938 | Presentations | HS2.3.7

Microplastics contamination in an artificially ventilated Lake (Lake Hallwil, Switzerland) 

Katrina Kremer, Stefano Fabbri, Deborah Rast, and Melina Zimmerli

Plastics are omnipresent in our daily lives, and this has a profound yet poorly understood impact on our health and environment. Since the 1950s, plastics consumption has strongly increased across the globe. Large amounts of this plastic is not recycled and is disposed into the environment. Through fluvial systems, plastics are transported and are deposited in reservoirs such as lakes and oceans where the plastics accumulate in the sedimentary systems. Thus, sediments which contain these plastic fragments can be used to assess their fate pathways, mass loads and accumulation rates in different environmental systems. This study aims to assess the plastics contamination in lake sediments, particularly for the microplastic size fraction (< 1mm) within an artificially ventilated lake, Lake Hallwil, Switzerland. We aim to understand plastics temporal deposition and understand accumulation areas. For this purpose, we retrieved short gravity sediment cores to study the temporal deposition history of plastics.  In addition, surface sediment samples have been taken from different locations within the lake basin for the geographical distribution of plastics. In order to quantify microplastics in sediments, the particles must be extracted from the lake sediments before further identification and characterization.

In this contribution, we present (1) the workflow to separate microplastic particles from the sediments and (2) the first data for the temporal evolution and the geographical distribution of the microplastic contamination recorded in lake sediments.

Using these first results, we plan to further expand the study to better understand the pathways of microplastics into lakes to assess specific release scenarios and mass concentrations of plastics from urban to natural areas surrounding Lake Hallwil, and compare these results to other lake systems.

How to cite: Kremer, K., Fabbri, S., Rast, D., and Zimmerli, M.: Microplastics contamination in an artificially ventilated Lake (Lake Hallwil, Switzerland), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9938, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9938, 2022.

EGU22-10288 | Presentations | HS2.3.7 | Highlight

Analysis of macro plastic transport processes in large rivers using GPS tracking and numerical simulations 

Marcel Liedermann, Sebastian Pessenlehner, Philipp Gmeiner, Michael Tritthart, and Helmut Habersack

Given the longevity of plastics and the yet incalculable effects on the biota in our environment, addressing plastic transport processes in fluvial systems is of emerging importance. Rivers are considered the main entry pathways for plastic into the world's oceans, yet there is still very little research in this area in particular. In Austria, the PlasticFreeDanube project focused on the problem of macroplastics in the Danube. Although Austria has very good waste management, a large amount of plastic still ends up in the national park downstream of Vienna. One of the most important questions in the project was therefore where the plastic comes from, how it is transported in the river and where it is deposited.

 

To improve the process understanding, numerical simulations were carried out on different scales. A particle tracking tool was implemented and adapted to the buoyancy of macroplastic items. The results of the numerical model were then blended with field data to quantify plastic deposition along the shoreline and in the floodplain. Furthermore, field data from GPS tagged plastic items were used for validation of numerical model results and to increase understanding of transport pathways within the system.

 

The modelling results clearly show that floating macroplastic particles interact with hydraulic structures, where the highest accumulation potential was observed in the middle groyne field within row of groynes. The comparison of macroplastic concentrations based on modelling and sampling results shows that floodplains act as filters during flood events. All the macroplastics that were tracked in the field experiment remained on the river’s side on which they were released, indicating that the main input appears to be on the right-hand side. The items mostly stranded on riprap of the bank protection and groyne fields, and the average distance to stranding was found to be 10.4 km. It was also shown that although the Freudenau hydropower plant can retain some of the plastic, a certain amount also passes downstream. The outcomes of this study may lead to a reduction of future collection efforts for macro plastics in riverine environments. The findings can also help to adapt hydraulic engineering structures in a way that facilitates removing more plastic from rivers.

How to cite: Liedermann, M., Pessenlehner, S., Gmeiner, P., Tritthart, M., and Habersack, H.: Analysis of macro plastic transport processes in large rivers using GPS tracking and numerical simulations, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10288, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10288, 2022.

EGU22-11219 | Presentations | HS2.3.7 | Highlight

The quest for the missing plastics:  Large uncertainties in global river plastic export into the sea 

Charlotte Laufkoetter, Caspar T.J. Roebroek, Daniel González-Fernández, and Tim van Emmerik

Plastic pollution in the natural environment is causing increasing concern at both the local and global scale. Understanding the dispersion of plastic through the environment is of key importance for the effective implementation of preventive measures and cleanup strategies. Over the past few years, various models have been developed to estimate global river plastic export into the oceans, using limited plastic observations in river systems. However, there is a large discrepancy between the amount of plastic being modelled to leave the river systems, and the amount of plastic estimated to be in the ocean.  Here we perform a careful uncertainty analysis of the riverine plastic export estimates, examining both observational uncertainty, model parameter uncertainty, and underlying assumptions in models. Among the quantifiable sources of uncertainty, the conversion of visual plastic observations to plastic mass estimates introduces the largest uncertainty, leading up to three orders of magnitude uncertainty in the final mass estimates in most observations. Model structure and parameter uncertainty add an additional order of magnitude of uncertainty. Additionally, most global models assume that variations in the plastic flux are primarily driven by river discharge. However, we show that within the largest currently available datasets, correlations between river discharge (and other environmental drivers) and the plastic flux are never above 0.5, and strongly vary between catchments. Overall, we conclude that the yearly plastic load in individual rivers as well as the global riverine plastic flow into the ocean may be substantially less well-constrained than indicated by previous studies.

How to cite: Laufkoetter, C., Roebroek, C. T. J., González-Fernández, D., and van Emmerik, T.: The quest for the missing plastics:  Large uncertainties in global river plastic export into the sea, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11219, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11219, 2022.

EGU22-11959 | Presentations | HS2.3.7

Method for AI-enhanced litter detection in aquatic environments using action cameras combined with net-based device for measuring submerged plastics 

Mattis Wolf, Marcel Liedermann, Ashraf El-Arini, Sebastian Pessenlehner, Klaus Sattler, and Oliver Zielinski

Plastic waste finds its way to the ocean often through rivers: it is estimated that between 1.15 and 2.41 million tons of plastic waste enters the ocean every year from rivers. Out of the 1500+ rivers that are estimated for being responsible for 80% of the riverine plastic emissions, around 70 of these rivers are located in Vietnam which highlights the importance of further investigating the plastic waste situation in its rivers.

The aim for this study was to develop a method for machine learning based measuring several types of plastic litter (in particular floating, trapped and submerged) in riverine systems. By considering the combined information of various litter categories this methodology is able to draw a holistic picture of plastic transport in riverine systems.

Two different methodological components were set up: (i) an AI (artificial intelligence) based litter detection algorithm which analyses imagery gathered by bridge-installed action cameras for floating and trapped plastic waste items in terms of abundances and waste types and (ii) a net-based sampling method which measures floating as well as submerged plastics at the bridge locations. The applied AI-based litter detection algorithm was originally developed for plastics detection in an aquatic environment in Cambodia for drone imagery. Within this framework, this approach was further developed and applied to detect floating and trapped plastic litter in polluted rivers captured with action cameras in Vietnam. The complementing net-based sampling for submerged plastics was applied in parallel to calibrate the continuous camera-based sampling with direct measurements.

Within this study it was shown that the combination of the two presented approaches provides a suitable methodology for the measurement of plastic transport along a river. Calibration of the continuous camera-based method showed that about 50% of the litter was transported at the surface and was thus directly detectable by AI. The methodology is relevant to the remote sensing community focusing on plastics detection and to researchers addressing plastic waste. The continuous assessment of plastic quantities transported by rivers will be key for policy makers to identify main polluters and to understand the impacts of any taken measures to reduce plastics pollution. Increasing the understanding of plastic types through these measurements is key for policy makers to develop the right measures which can target the items responsible for the majority of plastics pollution in rivers, as typically only few items are responsible for the majority of plastics leakage. The achievements of this study aim to fill these knowledge gaps by enhancing the litter detection method. As a next step, this method could be scaled up to be tested for a longer time period and at additional sites. The results of such longer-term measurements of surface and submerged plastics may allow for extrapolation of floating plastics to total transported plastics.

How to cite: Wolf, M., Liedermann, M., El-Arini, A., Pessenlehner, S., Sattler, K., and Zielinski, O.: Method for AI-enhanced litter detection in aquatic environments using action cameras combined with net-based device for measuring submerged plastics, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11959, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11959, 2022.

EGU22-12028 | Presentations | HS2.3.7 | Highlight

How gravity, wind, rain and surface runoff drive plastic transport on land 

Yvette Mellink, Tim van Emmerik, and Thomas Mani

To accurately predict the transport routes of mismanaged plastic waste from land-based sources to their sinks, terrestrial plastic transport models require a robust empirical basis. The main driving forces behind the transport of macroplastics on land are assumed to be gravity, wind, rain and surface runoff. However, the underlying transport principles remain undescribed and unresolved. To determine the minimum wind velocities, rainfall, and surface runoff that are required to mobilize and transport macroplastic items, physical laboratory experiments on an artificial hillslope were performed. Four types of macroplastic waste items were used (bottles, cups, food packaging, and bags) while surface roughness (concrete versus grass) and slope angles (0°, 10°, 20°) were systematically varied. Here we present the identified wind, rain and surface runoff thresholds, as well as the relations between the wind velocity and the plastic transport velocity. These thresholds and relations can be implemented in terrestrial plastic transport models to forecast the transport and (re)distribution of macroplastic waste on land due to wind, rain and surface runoff. The overland pathways simulated by these models, reveal where macroplastic retention occurs on land, and where terrestrial macroplastics enter waterbodies. The locations of the terrestrial accumulation zones, and the main entry points into waterbodies are crucial input for the design of mitigation and prevention measures.

How to cite: Mellink, Y., van Emmerik, T., and Mani, T.: How gravity, wind, rain and surface runoff drive plastic transport on land, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12028, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12028, 2022.

EGU22-12172 | Presentations | HS2.3.7

Tackling the challenge between lab- and field-based detection of floating plastics using hyperspectral remote sensing 

Paolo Tasseron, Louise Schreyers, Joseph Peller, Lauren Biermann, and Tim van Emmerik

Plastic pollution in aquatic ecosystems has increased dramatically in the last five decades, with strong impacts on human and aquatic life. Recent studies endorse the need for innovative approaches to monitor the presence, abundance, and types of plastic in these ecosystems. One such approach gaining rapid traction in the remote sensing community is the use of hyperspectral cameras to identify floating plastic litter. However, most experiments using this approach have been conducted in controlled laboratory environments, making findings exceptionally challenging to apply in natural environments. We present a method that links lab- and field-based identification of macroplastics using hyperspectral data (1150-1675 nm). Two experiments using riverbank-harvested macroplastics were set up in (1) a laboratory environment, and (2) at the Rhine River. The reflectance characteristics of the sample items were analysed to understand the influences of the two environmental settings. Eleven lab-based images (n = 786.264 pixels) and two field-based images (n = 40.289 pixels) were used for these analyses. Next, multiple classifier algorithms such as support vector machines (SVM), spectral angle mappers (SAM) and spectral information divergence (SID) techniques were applied, because of their robustness to varying light intensities and high accuracies in mapping spectral similarities. Our results showed that SAM classifiers are most robust in separating plastic debris from natural or human-made background elements, such as vegetation, quay walls, and sand. By applying lab-based spectral data for plastic detection in our field-based images, we were able to attain user accuracies up to 93.6% (n = 8.370 plastic pixels) using SAM. The same approach resulted in accuracies of 50.2% and 65.4% for SID and SIDSAM, respectively. The limitations of this study concern the low number of images used for training and classification, hardware issues related to the hyperspectral camera, and the unforeseen dynamic nature of environmental conditions outside a laboratory. Nevertheless, this study provides key fundamental insights in linking lab-based data to plastic detection in the field. In doing so, a contribution to the development of future spectral missions to monitor plastic pollution in aquatic ecosystems is made.

How to cite: Tasseron, P., Schreyers, L., Peller, J., Biermann, L., and van Emmerik, T.: Tackling the challenge between lab- and field-based detection of floating plastics using hyperspectral remote sensing, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12172, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12172, 2022.

EGU22-12272 | Presentations | HS2.3.7 | Highlight

The distribution and abundance of microplastics in the waters and organisms of the River Thames, UK. 

Stephanie Andrews, Ceri Lewis, and Tamara Galloway

A ubiquitous contaminant across the globe, microplastic contamination is a growing issue of which the effects and consequences in the environment are relatively unknown. Freshwater systems, specifically rivers, are important in the translocation of microplastics from terrestrial sources to the marine environment. This makes it vital to understand the abundance and distribution of plastics within them and any potential effects on freshwater organisms. The River Thames is the second largest river in the UK and has multiple anthropogenic stressors and pathways of potential microplastic contamination along its trajectory. This study aims to determine the distribution and abundance of microplastics in the waters and benthic organisms that inhabit the River Thames. It will explore how location and proximity to sites of potential contamination, and feeding type influence the ingestion of microplastics in organisms. Water samples were collected from the river in May 2019 along with benthic dwelling organisms from 3 sites of suspected microplastic contamination. Initial findings reveal a high abundance of microplastics in water samples from the River Thames (average 3.55 mp/m3) and abundance increases along the trajectory of the river (1.05 mp/m3 at the highest sampling site increasing to 5.72 mp/m3 at the lowest sampling site). In all sites sampled, fragments and fibres were the most dominant particle shapes. Filter feeders ingested the highest abundance of microplastic fibres whilst grazers had the highest abundance of ingested fragments. The abundance of particles ingested by invertebrates differed across study sites showing varying levels of contamination. The presence of microplastics in a range of benthic taxa aligned with differences in dominant particle shapes in species with distinct feeding modes indicates widespread contamination with potential ecological impacts of microplastics in freshwater species of the River Thames.

How to cite: Andrews, S., Lewis, C., and Galloway, T.: The distribution and abundance of microplastics in the waters and organisms of the River Thames, UK., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12272, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12272, 2022.

Plastic pollution has become a threat to both nature and humans. A substantial amount of plastic is transported in rivers towards the sea. Insight in the sources and transport in rivers, and how this is changing with conditions like discharge, is needed to plan effective mitigation strategies. Current measurement techniques mostly target floating items, recent studies however suggest that suspended plastics form a significant part of the total riverine plastic transport. Despite being successful, recently applied sampling techniques using several nets in the vertical are too invasive, expensive and labour intensive to apply on large spatial and temporal scale. A non-invasive and continuous measurement technique of suspended plastics, applicable on a large scale, is needed.

 

Sonar has shown potential for plastic detection. During measurements, a high-frequency acoustic signal is transmitted. This signal is scattered by water and suspended particles. Using an Acoustic Doppler Current Profiler (ADCP), the chosen sonar device, flow velocity can be obtained using the frequency shift of the signal. Aside from the frequency shift, also the strength of the returned acoustic signal can be measured. This backscatter strength depends on the size, form and material of the sampled object. It is nowadays used to estimate suspended sediment concentrations, but also relatively large objects like fish, organic matter and macro-plastics can be recognised by high backscatter intensity. As ADCPs have been broadly used for decades, current and historical data from a large network of measuring devices are available for analysis of plastic transport and its fluctuations. We propose steps for a method to quantify the macroplastic concentration from ADCP data.

 

During the study, a RDI StreamPro ADCP is horizontally mounted in a basin. Macroplastics differing in shape, size and polymer type are sampled 5 times within a period of 10 seconds, on three different distances (around 1, 3 and 5 meter) from the transducer. Almost all plastic items show a significantly higher backscatter intensity than the background signal, on all measurement distances. In contrast to net-based measurements, rotation is found to be an important aspect in the identification of items during ADCP measurements. To further develop the detection method, analysis of ADCP field data containing the usual background noise, combined with net measurements for validation, is needed. Expectation is that net measurements, used to make an estimate of the fraction organic material and plastic, are only needed periodically to make a good continuous estimate of macroplastic transport using ADCP data.

How to cite: Boon, A. and Buschman, F.: Revealing underwater plastics: Detection of suspended macroplastics using acoustic backscatter, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12712, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12712, 2022.

EGU22-12734 | Presentations | HS2.3.7

Plastic pollution impacts riverbed sand transport processes 

Catherine Russell, Roberto Fernández, Daniel Parsons, and Sarah Gabbott

Rivers are the primary link between terrestrial and ocean environments, crosscutting the landscape whilst providing fresh water, nutrients, and sediment to diverse ecosystems. However, over the past 50 years, rivers have become increasingly significant vectors for plastic pollution. On a riverbed, sediment migrates downstream as bedforms, such as dunes, via well-understood morphodynamic processes, yet the impact of plastic on sediment transport behaviours is unknown and so has been widely assumed as passive, whereby the sediment buries plastic between flood events and is otherwise unaffected. Here we find, through undertaking studies using an experimental recirculating flume tank, that when plastic particles are introduced to riverbed sand dunes, even at relatively low concentrations, novel morphologies and altered morphodynamic processes emerge, including irregular stoss-side erosion and dune wash out. We detail new mechanisms of plastic sequestration and transport to outline how plastic particles interacting with riverbed dunes fundamentally influence sediment transport processes, and the resulting deposits. We find that: i) plastic is not a passive component on riverbeds as it significantly speeds up morphological transformations, affecting bed topography and increasing dune erosion rates, which at present has unknown consequences for the wider landscape; ii) plastic inclusion locally changes the ratio of suspended load to bedload material as plastics create a local and temporal shift towards more sediment in suspension, thereby causing the river to develop more conduit-like than storage-like properties with unknown consequences for overall sediment transport fluxes and increased local turbidity; and iii) inclusion of plastic in the sediment layer creates heterogeneous deposits that propagates the disruption of sedimentary processes and forms irregular distribution of plastic on the riverbed that will affect the possibilities of representative sampling. Such insights shed light onto a new branch of environmental consequences of plastic in the environment that requires further research, as a new branch of sedimentology: plastic and sediment interactions. With plastic being continually added to our environments globally, this new field is set to be increasingly relevant amongst emerging challenges of the Anthropocene.

How to cite: Russell, C., Fernández, R., Parsons, D., and Gabbott, S.: Plastic pollution impacts riverbed sand transport processes, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12734, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12734, 2022.

EGU22-12841 | Presentations | HS2.3.7 | Highlight

Monitoring mesoplastic concentrations in estuarine waters: A case study in the River Guadalquivir (Southern Spain) 

Daniel González-Fernández, Sandra Manzano-Medina, Manuel M. González-Duarte, and Andrés Cózar

Rivers act as pathways transporting anthropogenic waste from inland sources to the sea, including large quantities of plastic. Estuaries are rich and diverse environments where the interaction between fluvial processes and the tidal regime results in complex dynamics that affects residence time and net transport plastics in the water column. The use of plankton nets (small mesh sizes, e.g. < 500 µm) to collect microplastic samples allows characterizing plastic particles of different sizes. At the same time, given the variability in plastic particles abundance, the limitation in number of samples and/or volume filtered per sample, may cause a large bias in such characterization. Generally, particle abundance decreases toward larger particle sizes, and therefore the collection of representative samples for a certain plastic size range depends on sampling effort. Here, we analyze abundance and weight of micro- (< 5mm) and mesoplastics (5-25 mm) collected in estuarine waters at the River Guadalquivir through bi-monthly monitoring over one year. Our results demonstrate that establishing ratios between micro- and meso-plastics concentrations can lead to large uncertainties when a limited number of samples is used in the analysis, causing strong bias in the extrapolation of mass budgets for mesoplastics. Collecting representative samples for mesoplastics implies a change in the current monitoring methods to specifically target such particle size range.

How to cite: González-Fernández, D., Manzano-Medina, S., González-Duarte, M. M., and Cózar, A.: Monitoring mesoplastic concentrations in estuarine waters: A case study in the River Guadalquivir (Southern Spain), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12841, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12841, 2022.

EGU22-12856 | Presentations | HS2.3.7 | Highlight

Finding Riverine Plastics in Floating Plant Patches using Worldview-3 Satellite Imagery 

Lauren Biermann, Louise Schreyers, Tim van Emmerik, Thanh-Khiet Bui, Yangrong Ling, and Davida Streett

Water hyacinths appear to play an important role in gathering and transporting macroplastic litter in riverine ecosystems. These fast-growing and free-floating invasive freshwater plants tend to form large patches at the water surface, which makes it possible to detect and map them in freely available imagery collected by the European Space Agency (ESA) satellites. In polluted rivers, hyacinth may thus serve as a viable proxy for macroplastics. However, at the ~10m spatial resolution offered by the Sentinel-1 and Sentinel-2 satellites, it’s not possible to discriminate smaller items of plastic caught up within large plant patches.

We present a case study from the Saigon River around Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam. Here, we were able to successfully discriminate plastic debris within hyacinth patches using MAXAR Worldview-3 multispectral optical data (1.24m) and panchromatic imagery (0.31m). For the optical data, we selected the ACOLITE atmospheric correction and applied a novel detection index that leveraged the panchromatic band and the red band (band 5) to highlight differences between vegetation and debris. This approach allowed for the detection of riverine plastics within hyacinth patches floating downstream from Ho Chi Minh City towards the coast. Initial results from the Han River and coastal waters of Da Nang in Vietnam suggest that our plastic litter discrimination method is transferable to other aquatic environments. This research is preparatory for further remote sensing monitoring of 'plastic plants' in riverine ecosystems, and will be supporting clean-up operations being trialled in 2022.

How to cite: Biermann, L., Schreyers, L., van Emmerik, T., Bui, T.-K., Ling, Y., and Streett, D.: Finding Riverine Plastics in Floating Plant Patches using Worldview-3 Satellite Imagery, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12856, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12856, 2022.

EGU22-13490 | Presentations | HS2.3.7

Measuring of microplastics settling velocities and implications for residence times in thermally stratified lakes 

Hassan Elagami, Pouyan Ahmadi, Jan H. Fleckenstein, Sven Frei, Martin Obst, Seema Agarwal, and Benjamin S. Gilfedder

Microplastic (MP) residence times are currently poorly constrained in lakes, especially at a quantitative level. In this work settling experiments with pristine and biofilm-colonized MPs were combined with model calculations to evaluate settling velocities, particle distributions and residence times in the epi- meta and hypolimnion of a hypothetical stratified lake broadly based on Upper Lake Constance. Settling velocities of various biodegradable and non-biodegradable polymers of various shapes, sizes and biofilm colonization were measured in a settling column. The settling velocities ranged between ~ 0.30 and ~50 mm s-1. Particle sizes and polymer densities were identified as primary controls on settling rates. MPs that had been exposed to a lake environment for up to 30 weeks were colonized by a range of biofilms and associated extracellular polymeric substances; surprisingly, however, the settling velocity did not vary significantly between pristine and colonized MP particles. Simulated MP residence times in the model lake varied over a wide range of time scales (10-1 - 105 days) and depended mainly on the size of the particles and depth of the lake layer. Long residence times on the order of 105 days (for 1 µm MPs) imply that for small MP particles there is a high probability that they will be taken up at some stage by lake organisms. It also suggests that insignificant amounts of small MPs will be found in the lake sediment unless some process increases their settling velocity as their residence time is considerably longer than the theoretical retention time of Lake Constance (~4.5 years).

How to cite: Elagami, H., Ahmadi, P., Fleckenstein, J. H., Frei, S., Obst, M., Agarwal, S., and Gilfedder, B. S.: Measuring of microplastics settling velocities and implications for residence times in thermally stratified lakes, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13490, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13490, 2022.

EGU22-941 | Presentations | HS2.3.8

Multivariate water environmental risk analysis in long-distance water supply project: A case study in China 

Xizhi Nong, Chi Zhang, Dongguo Shao, Hua Zhong, Yuming Shang, and Jiankui Liang

The variation of water quality in long-distance water supply projects is often different from that in natural water bodies, especially the environmental risks of artificial open canal water transfer projects are seldom studied. The spatial heterogeneity of algae growth and the absence of universal reference standards for algae control often lead to water quality problems in these projects. The Middle Route (MR) of the South-to-North Water Transfer Project of China (SNWTPC), the world’s largest inter-basin water transfer project, has operated stably for six years. Its water resources have benefited more than 60 million people and an ecosystem cover more than 160,000 km2. To understand the water environment risk of this mega hydro-project, this study focused on the relationships among three key parameters: water temperature (T), water discharge (Q), flow rate (V) and analyzed the spatial–temporal variation characteristics of the algal cell density (ACD) in the MR of the SNWTPC from January 2016 to December 2018, 36 months in total. The Copula functions were applied to identify and evaluate the multivariate risk variation of the water environment. Our result demonstrated that there was a significant positive correlation between T and ACD, and the ACD at the downstream has a 50% risk higher than 700 × 104 cell/L in summer. Overall, the water quality status of the MR of the SNWTPC is quite well, and the ACD kept at an average level of 106 cells/L during the monitoring period. Additionally, the ACD increased from upstream to downstream, showing the relatively higher ACD in summer and autumn than in spring and winter, with the ranges of 500 ~ 700 × 104 cells/L and 200 ~ 300 × 104 cells/L, respectively. The water temperature affected the ACD over the early-warning thresholds at different canal sections were as follows: 29, 26, and 21℃ from upstream to downstream, respectively. The influences of the hydrodynamic factors, water discharge and flow rate, impact on the ACD variation were analyzed to achieve the purpose of specific algae control for different canal reaches. Our study verified that the growth probabilities of the ACD under higher water temperature and water discharge in the MR of the SNWTPC than other natural water bodies.

    How to cite: Nong, X., Zhang, C., Shao, D., Zhong, H., Shang, Y., and Liang, J.: Multivariate water environmental risk analysis in long-distance water supply project: A case study in China, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-941, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-941, 2022.

    EGU22-1539 | Presentations | HS2.3.8 | Highlight

    Connecting actions to ecological and human health endpoints - evaluating the benefits of wastewater and stormwater projects 

    Timothy Clark, Carly Greyell, Norah Kates, Jennifer Lanksbury, and Daniel Nidzgorski

    Local wastewater and stormwater utilities invest millions to billions of dollars collected from ratepayers to meet regulatory requirements, protect human life and infrastructure, and protect water quality. In their project prioritization and planning efforts, utilities consider many factors, including the benefit to environmental outcomes. Utilities often compare the environmental benefits of potential projects by only evaluating changes in pollutant loads rather than looking at whether those projects will accomplish better environmental outcomes for people and wildlife. Many utilities lack a framework for considering these ultimate outcomes. In an effort for better-informed decision-making in King County, WA, we developed a framework (the Water Quality Benefits Evaluation toolkit) that connects actions to environmental outcomes.

    The toolkit is an adaptable framework containing a watershed pollutant loading model, a pollutant-reduction and cost optimization model, and causal models representing systems surrounding specified environmental outcomes. We developed causal models for six endpoints: toxics in edible fish, fecal contamination at shellfish beds, fecal contamination at swimming beaches, algal toxins at swimming beaches, natural-origin Chinook salmon population health, and Southern Resident Killer Whale population health. The causal models include Bayesian networks, narrative conceptual models, and fish bioaccumulation models. The holistic evaluation of environmental outcomes provides better information to decision-makers to consider alongside other factors such as costs to ratepayers and reversing environmental inequities.

    This presentation focuses on the development of the causal models and how they can be applied to support King County’s utility planning decisions. The presentation will also provide insight on how the framework can be employed for additional environmental endpoints and may be adapted to include other types of endpoints, such as equity and community health.

    How to cite: Clark, T., Greyell, C., Kates, N., Lanksbury, J., and Nidzgorski, D.: Connecting actions to ecological and human health endpoints - evaluating the benefits of wastewater and stormwater projects, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1539, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1539, 2022.

    Environmental decision support aims to aid decision makers in identifying management alternatives which reflect the societal preferences as close as possible. This requires a representation of societal preferences through describing the preference structure and elicitation of individual preferences. As scientific knowledge is always incomplete, societal preferences aggregate uncertain individual preferences, and both have to be quantified by simplified models, the consideration of uncertainty is of high importance in environmental decision support. Decision analysis, in particular multi-attribute value theory and multi-attribute utility theory, provide a good theoretical basis for such a decision support process. 

    Discrete choice experiments are a convenient tool for preference elicitation and their statistical evaluation leads to unbiased estimates of preference model parameters. We demonstrate that by extending discrete choice questions to the elicitation of preference indifference, we can achieve a reduction in the uncertainty of estimated value function parameters by about a factor of three or a reduction in sample size required to achieve the same accuracy by about a factor of ten. This is obtained at the cost of a higher elicitation effort for each question as it involves the provision of preference information through indifference statements. Using synthetically generated data to allow us to analyse potential bias and to perform a sensitivity analysis regarding sample size and uncertainty ranges, we quantitatively compare discrete choice experiments with indifference elicitation regarding the achieved accuracy of parameter estimates. We test these aspects by employing Bayesian inference for parameter estimation for different shapes of the value function using an error model for values as it is often used for the evaluation of discrete choice experiments, and an additional error model for the specification of the indifference point. Through the quantification of the gain in accuracy, our study provides a basis for assessing the trade-off between higher elicitation effort per choice situation and the required sample size. The elicitation of preference indifference opens new perspectives whenever the set of stakeholders from whom preferences have to be elicited is limited, for example in the case of preference elicitation from experts in environmental management. In such cases, the higher elicitation effort may be manageable and results in a similar accuracy of results with about one-tenths of the sample size compared to discrete choice replies or higher accuracy for smaller sample size reductions. 

    How to cite: Sriwastava, A. and Reichert, P.: Reducing Sample Size Requirements by Extending Discrete Choice Experiments to Indifference Elicitation, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3930, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3930, 2022.

    EGU22-4092 | Presentations | HS2.3.8 | Highlight

    Assisting stakeholders in their choice of riverine and estuarine plastic clean-up technologies with the aid of Bayesian Belief Networks 

    Giulia Leone, Ana I. Catarino, Ine Pauwels, Thomas Mani, Michelle Tishler, Matthias Egger, Marie Anne Eurie Forio, Peter L.M. Goethals, and Gert Everaert


    Plastic clean-up technologies deployed in rivers and estuaries can be fundamental to assist in plastic litter management and collection and to mitigate plastic pollution. However, it is vital to supply stakeholders with tools to monitor and minimize possible bycatch, as organic debris and biota provide essential functions to riverine and estuarine environments. Currently, even though some of the clean-up technologies companies perform environmental impact assessments, an independent and objective tool is still missing to assist stakeholders in deploying clean-up mechanisms with a minimal impact on biota. To support stakeholders in making informed decisions about which clean-up technology is best deployed under specific conditions, we suggest using Bayesian Belief Networks (BBNs) as a support tool that would ensure an effective plastic clean-up removal and minimum unintentional bycatch. We have identified four clusters of parameters that account for multiple conditions influencing the chances of bycatch and will form the basis of the BBN. To feed the model, we will acquire data from scientific and grey literature, expert knowledge, and experimental work. The data will include information on (i) the environmental conditions of the river (e.g., river flow), (ii) plastic debris characteristics such as size or buoyancy, (iii) biota traits (e.g., size, buoyancy, adhesiveness), and (iv) mechanism of clean-up technologies (e.g., river booms with conveyor belts, curtains of air bubbles). After the training and validating stages, the model can then be used in different river systems to suggest what type of plastic clean-up mechanism is best suited for the local parameters. This model will enable stakeholders, such as river managers and policymakers, to obtain information on the optimal trade-off between plastic removal and minimal collateral bycatch. 

    How to cite: Leone, G., Catarino, A. I., Pauwels, I., Mani, T., Tishler, M., Egger, M., Forio, M. A. E., Goethals, P. L. M., and Everaert, G.: Assisting stakeholders in their choice of riverine and estuarine plastic clean-up technologies with the aid of Bayesian Belief Networks, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4092, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4092, 2022.

    EGU22-5652 | Presentations | HS2.3.8 | Highlight

    Identifying and testing adaptive management options to increase catchment resilience using a Bayesian Network. 

    Kerr Adams, Christopher (Kit) A. J. Macleod, Marc J. Metzger, Nicola Melville, Rachel Helliwell, Jim Pritchard, Katie Edwards, and Miriam Glendell

    The cumulative impacts of future climatic and socio-economic change threaten the ability of freshwater catchments to provide valuable socio-ecological services. Stakeholders who manage freshwater resources require decision-support tools that increase their understanding of catchment system resilience and support the appraisal of adaptive management options. Our research aims to address the following question: Can a Bayesian Network (BN) model support stakeholders in the identification and testing of adaptive management options that help increase catchment system resilience to the impacts of cumulative future change? Using the predominantly arable Eden catchment (320km2), in eastern Scotland as a case study, we invited stakeholders from multiple sectors to participate in a series of workshops aimed at addressing water resource issues and achieving good ecological status in the catchment both now and in the future. Outputs of a BN model that simulates both current and future catchment resilience were presented to stakeholders. Outputs informed the identification of adaptive management options which were grouped into five management scenarios. The effectiveness of each management scenario in increasing catchment system resilience was tested using the BN model to support the appraisal of each management scenario by participating stakeholders. Two optimal adaptive management scenarios were identified; the first optimal management scenario focussed on predominantly nature-based management options such as wetland wastewater treatment methods and rural sustainable drainage systems. The second optimal scenario focussed on resource recovery, including phosphorus recovery from wastewater treatment works and constructed lagoons for crop irrigation. Outputs of the model describing the resilience of the catchment initiated conversations about feasible management options that could be applied across sectors to reduce risk and increase catchment resilience. The ability of the BN model to test and compare adaptive management scenarios in a time-effective manner was seen as an advantage in comparison to conventional methods.

    How to cite: Adams, K., Macleod, C. (. A. J., Metzger, M. J., Melville, N., Helliwell, R., Pritchard, J., Edwards, K., and Glendell, M.: Identifying and testing adaptive management options to increase catchment resilience using a Bayesian Network., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5652, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5652, 2022.

    EGU22-6062 | Presentations | HS2.3.8

    Machine learning-based water quality modeling at national level in data-scarce region 

    Holger Virro, Alexander Kmoch, Marko Vainu, and Evelyn Uuemaa

    Water quality modeling plays an important role in better understanding the magnitude and impact of water quality issues and in providing evidence for policy-making and implementing measures to mitigate water pollution. Process-based nutrient models are very complex, requiring a lot of input parameters and computationally expensive calibration. Often there is also a lack of high spatial and temporal resolution water quality data because water sampling is expensive and river water quality can’t be measured using remote sensing. Machine learning approaches have been shown to achieve similar accuracy to the physically-based models and even outperform them when describing nonlinear relationships. We used 242 observation sites located at 139 streams in Estonia, amounting to 469 yearly total nitrogen (TN) and 470 total phosphorus (TP) measurements covering the period 2016–2020 to train random forest models for predicting N and P concentrations. We used a total of 82 predictor variables, including land cover, soil, climate, and topography parameters, and applied a feature selection strategy to reduce the number of dependent features in the model. The models resulted in an accuracy of 82% in the case of TN and 54% for TP. The SHAP (SHapley Additive exPlanations) values used to explain the models showed that the most important features for predicting TN were arable land proportion, soil rock content, and hydraulic conductivity, while the main features affecting TP concentration were the urban and grassland proportion in the catchment. The results indicate that the TN model is a viable alternative to process-based models in Estonia. In the case of TP, the derived feature importances and feature interactions can potentially help improve the corresponding model in the future. 

    How to cite: Virro, H., Kmoch, A., Vainu, M., and Uuemaa, E.: Machine learning-based water quality modeling at national level in data-scarce region, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6062, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6062, 2022.

    EGU22-6847 | Presentations | HS2.3.8

    How does baseflow contribution affect catchment C-Q relationships? A continental synthesis using a Bayesian Hierarchical Model 

    Danlu Guo, Camille Minaudo, Anna Lintern, Ulrike Bende-Michl, Shuci Liu, Kefeng Zhang, and Clement Duvert

    Understanding concentration-discharge (C-Q) relationships is critical to inform catchment export processes for solute and particulates. The contribution of baseflow to streamflow has been found to affect C-Q relationships in some catchments in previous studies. Current understanding on the effects of baseflow contribution in shaping the C-Q patterns is largely limited to temperate catchments, but we still lack quantitative understanding of these effects across a wide range of climates (e.g., arid, tropical and subtropical). The study aims to assess how baseflow contributions within individual catchments influence C-Q slopes across Australia. The wide range of hydro-climatic regimes and land use/land cover conditions in Australian catchments make this continent the ideal experimental field to gain such an understanding. We analyzed 157 catchments in Australia spanning five climate zones, for six water quality variables: electrical conductivity (EC), total phosphorus (TP), soluble reactive phosphorus (SRP), total suspended solids (TSS), the sum of nitrate and nitrite (NOx) and total nitrogen (TN). The impact of baseflow contributions was defined by the median and the range of daily baseflow indices (BFI_m and BFI_range, respectively) for each catchment. A novel Bayesian hierarchical model was developed to synthesize these effects for individual catchments across the continent.  

    Sediments and nutrient species (TSS, NOx, TN and TP) generally show positive C-Q slopes for most catchments, suggesting a dominance of mobilization export patterns. Further, TSS, NOx and TP show stronger mobilization (i.e., steeper positive C-Q slopes) in catchments with higher values in both the BFI_m and BFI_range, while these two metrics are also positively correlated for most catchments. The enhanced mobilization in catchments with higher BFI_m or BFI_range might be explained by more variable flow pathways in catchments with higher baseflow contributions. In such catchments, the more variable flow pathways can lead to higher concentration gradients between low flows and high flows. These gradients are due to  different dominant flow pathways and contributions of groundwater/slow subsurface flow and surface water sources. Our results highlight the need for further studies focusing on identifying and quantifying: a) the influences of temporal variations of baseflow contributions on flow pathways, and b) the impacts of variable flow pathways on catchment C-Q relationships.

    How to cite: Guo, D., Minaudo, C., Lintern, A., Bende-Michl, U., Liu, S., Zhang, K., and Duvert, C.: How does baseflow contribution affect catchment C-Q relationships? A continental synthesis using a Bayesian Hierarchical Model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6847, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6847, 2022.

    EGU22-7796 | Presentations | HS2.3.8 | Highlight

    A Bayesian Belief Network model assessing the multi-scale effects of riparian vegetation on stream invertebrates 

    Marie Anne Eurie Forio, Francis J. Burdon, Felix Witing, Geta Risnoveanu, Benjamin Kupilas, Nikolai Friberg, Martin Volk, Brendan Mckie, and Peter Goethals

    Despite the benefits of riparian vegetation, they are limitedly implemented in water management – which is partly due to the lack of information on their effectiveness. In this context, social learning is valuable to inform stakeholders of the efficacy of riparian vegetation in mitigating stream degradation. Tools used in social learning activities are of paramount importance in the learning process. We developed a Bayesian belief network (BBN) model as a learning tool to simulate and assess the reach- and segment-scale effects of riparian vegetation properties and subcatchment-scale land use on instream invertebrates. We surveyed reach-scale riparian conditions, extracted segment-scale riparian and land use information from geographic information system (GIS) data and collected macroinvertebrate samples from four catchments in Europe (Belgium, Norway, Romania and Sweden). We modelled the ecological water quality, expressed as Average Score Per Taxon, as a function of different riparian variables using the BBN modelling approach. The collected data were used to populate the conditional probability table of the BBN model. The model simulations provided insights into the usefulness of both reach- and segment-scale riparian vegetation attributes in enhancing ecological water quality. We assessed the strengths and limitations of the BBN model for application as a learning tool. Despite some weaknesses, the BBN model has great potential in workshop activities to stimulate key learning processes that help inform the management of riparian zones.

    How to cite: Forio, M. A. E., Burdon, F. J., Witing, F., Risnoveanu, G., Kupilas, B., Friberg, N., Volk, M., Mckie, B., and Goethals, P.: A Bayesian Belief Network model assessing the multi-scale effects of riparian vegetation on stream invertebrates, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7796, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7796, 2022.

    Surface water bodies serve a critical role in preserving ecological systems and maintaining biodiversity. Anthropogenic eutrophication of fresh water ecosystems is one of the main causes of surface water quality degradation. Excessive nutrient loading to freshwater bodies is a driving cause of water quality impairments worldwide. Accurately estimating riverine nutrient loads remains an imperative step towards mitigating and managing impairments. Yet, load estimation is often hindered by the sporadic and infrequent monitoring of nutrient concentrations. Several modelling approaches have been proposed and implemented over the years to estimate pollutant loads; yet most suffer from biases and/or from their capabilities to transparently quantify uncertainties. In this work, we propose a spatio-temporal Bayesian hierarchical ratio-estimator model to predict the annual total phosphorus loads between 2005 and 2020 for six intensively monitored watersheds discharging in Lake Erie and the Ohio River-USA. The integration of higher-level Land-Use-Land-Cover predictors proved successful in capturing inter-station variabilities in phosphorus loading. Meanwhile, accounting for annual climatic variability partially helped explain temporal changes in the flow-weighted nutrient concentrations across the six watersheds. The performance of the model was tested against different levels of data censorship. Results showed that under a weekly sampling program, the load estimates from the proposed Bayesian Hierarchical spatio-temporal model were within -19 and 31 % (mean difference of 0.3% across stations and years) from the true loads calculated for years with uninterrupted concentration measurements. Predictions from traditional load estimation methods were found to vary between -56% and 73% from the true loads. Meanwhile, failing to account for the spatio-temporal hierarchical structure of the proposed model, either by adopting a completely pooled or an unpooled model, resulted in a significant drop in the accuracy of the predicted loads and inflated the associated uncertainties.

    How to cite: Alameddine, I., Sawma, J., and Khalife, H.: A Bayesian hierarchical spatio-temporal ratio-estimator approach to model phosphorus loading in six Ohio watersheds: the importance of accounting for inter-annual and inter-basin variabilities, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8907, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8907, 2022.

    EGU22-10539 | Presentations | HS2.3.8

    Metamodeling approaches to help designing vegetative filter strips and improve the water quality. 

    Claire Lauvernet, Céline Helbert, Zhu Xujia, and Bruno Sudret

    Significant amounts of pollutant are measured in surface water, their presence due in part to the use of pesticides in agriculture. One solution to limit pesticide transfer by surface runoff is to implement vegetative filter strips (VFS) along rivers. The sizing of these strips is a major issue, with influencing factors that include local conditions (climate, soil, etc.). The BUVARD modeling toolkit was developed to design VFSs throughout France according to these properties. This toolkit includes the numerical model VFSMOD, which quantifies dynamic effects of VFS site-specific pesticide mitigation efficiency. However, the toolkit is quite complex to use with many input uncertain parameters (quantitative - such as the slope, the Curve Number - or qualitative -such as the soil type or the rainfall event), making it not easy to use for risk management.

    In this study, a metamodeling (or model dimension reduction) approach is proposed to ease the use of BUVARD and to help users design VFSs that are adapted to specific contexts. Different reduced models, or surrogates, are compared, based on Bayesian learning approaches or not: Polynomial Chaos Expansions, Mixed-kriging, and Deep-GP. Mixed-kriging is a kriging method that was implemented with a covariance kernel for a mixture of qualitative and quantitative inputs. Kriging and Deep-GP are built by couple of modalities and PCE and Mixed-kriging are built considering mixed quantitative and qualitative variables. As a last step, Finally, we perform a global sensitivity analysis with the help of the two surrogate models with the best accuracy. The results show that they give the same ranking of the importance of the input parameters.

    The metamodel is a simple way to provide a relevant first guess to help design the pollution reduction device. In addition, the surrogate model is a relevant uncertainty tool, to visualize the impact that lack of knowledge of some parameters of filter efficiency can have when performing risk analysis and management.

    How to cite: Lauvernet, C., Helbert, C., Xujia, Z., and Sudret, B.: Metamodeling approaches to help designing vegetative filter strips and improve the water quality., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10539, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10539, 2022.

    EGU22-11003 | Presentations | HS2.3.8

    Key controls of catchment attribute on spatial differences and export regimes in riverine water quality: a study across the Australian continent using a Bayesian approach 

    Shuci Liu, Danlu Guo, Camille Minaudo, Anna Lintern, Rémi Dupas, Ulrike Bende-Michl, Kefeng Zhang, and Clément Duvert

    Investigations of concentration (C) and discharge (Q) relationships (C–Q relationships) at the catchment scale are commonly used to characterize export regimes of instream particulates and solutes. C–Q relationships also provide insights on spatial and temporal variability in pollutant export, allowing identification of the sources and transfer pathways of pollutants. Previous studies have shown that several key catchment attributes control the export of sediment and dissolved nutrients within catchments. These catchment attributes include land use, topography, geology and soils. However, only few studies have investigated the relative importance of multiple catchment attributes over large spatial scales (e.g., at the continental scale) and between different climate zones. This is mostly due to either a limited number of catchments that have been monitored or a strong focus on temperate catchments. Therefore, our current understanding of key controls on spatial variability and export regimes across different climates is still limited. In this study, we investigated spatial differences and the C–Q relationships of six commonly monitored constituents (i.e., total suspended solid – TSS, total nitrogen – TN, sum of nitrate and nitrite – NOx, total phosphorus – TP, soluble reactive phosphorus – SRP and electrical conductivity – EC) from 507 catchments across the Australian continent. These catchments represent five main climate zones in Australia (i.e., arid, Mediterranean, temperate, subtropical and tropical). We used a hierarchical Bayesian multi-model averaging approach to 1) identify key catchment attributes (e.g., land use, topography, geology and hydrology) driving the spatial variability of mean concentration and export regimes (CQ relationship) for individual constituents; 2) understand the role of climatic gradients in determining the magnitude and direction of the key controls, and 3) use the key controls identified to predict the mean concentration and CQ relationship in multiple catchments across Australia.

    The proposed Bayesian modelling framework provided a higher predictive capability for mean concentrations (Nash-Sutcliffe efficiency (NSE) ranging from 0.58 for SRP to 0.86 for EC), compared to log(C) – log(Q) slopes (NSE ranging from 0.25 for NOx to 0.39 for TP). For mean concentrations, land use (e.g., agriculture and urban) has a significantly positive effect on nutrients (i.e., TN, NOx, TP and SRP), particularly in the Mediterranean, subtropical and tropical regions, indicating that land use is a key driver for these constituents. For log(C) – log(Q) slopes, catchment topographical characteristics (e.g., slope and maximum flow pathway) have relatively high impacts on TSS, TP and EC, indicating export of sediments and solutes in catchments largely controlled by mobilization (sediment) and surface-subsurface flow interaction (solutes). Findings from our study provide a data-driven understanding of key controls on riverine water quality across multiple climate types and can inform future water quality management strategies.

    How to cite: Liu, S., Guo, D., Minaudo, C., Lintern, A., Dupas, R., Bende-Michl, U., Zhang, K., and Duvert, C.: Key controls of catchment attribute on spatial differences and export regimes in riverine water quality: a study across the Australian continent using a Bayesian approach, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11003, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11003, 2022.

    EGU22-11862 | Presentations | HS2.3.8

    Risk Analysis of Algal Blooms Using the Conditional Copula Model 

    Hemie Cho, Jae-Ung Yu, Jinyoung Kim, and Hyun-Han Kwon

    In Korea, algal blooms are repeated every year in the four major rivers. Especially, the frequency and duration of algal blooms have increased due to climate change (increase in the atmosphere and water temperature) and environmental changes (river development projects and weir construction), which has led to the development of related research. However, it is still difficult to elucidate the cause of algal blooms because of a complicated mechanism. In this study, the concentration of Chlorophyll-a was selected as an indicator of algae occurrence, and representative hydrometeorological factors affecting the algal phenomenon were selected. Then, the optimal marginal distribution for each variable was found. The risk of algal blooms was analyzed through bivariate copula analysis by identifying the relationship between the influencing factors and the concentration of Chlorophyll-a. As a result, it was possible to identify the factors that had the most significant influence on the occurrence of algal blooms. Further, this study will employ the Vine Copula function to improve the complex relationship between variables in the context of multivariate modeling.

    How to cite: Cho, H., Yu, J.-U., Kim, J., and Kwon, H.-H.: Risk Analysis of Algal Blooms Using the Conditional Copula Model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11862, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11862, 2022.

    EGU22-11975 | Presentations | HS2.3.8

    New insights on the practical significance of numerical methods for surface water pollution source identification 

    Ruiyi Yang, Jiping Jiang, Tianrui Pang, Yunlei Men, and Yi Zheng

    The source identification of surface water pollution is the key issue in environmental management and has important practical needs. Model-based numerical inversion methods have received widespread attention that there are many research reports. However, most of the existing research on the pollution source identification (PSI) problem focuses on the combination innovation and theoretical analysis of the inversion algorithm, and does not consider the urgent time constraints of the emergency response process, which has become an important technical bottleneck. To this end, this study focuses on the timeliness and operability of numerical inversion methods in the emergency response process, and makes full use of multi-source information of pollutants to explore robust and fast sampling and numerical inversion methods in practical operations. The study adopts the Adative Metroplis Monte Carlo (AM-MCMC) Bayesian method as the basic source identification inversion framework, and takes the USGS tracer test in Truckee River from 2006 to 2007 as the basic scenario to carry out numerical experiments. Through the data assimilation method, the pollution source information is dynamically updated. With the input of new monitoring data, the accuracy of the inversion results is gradually improved; By integrating multiple pollutants information, greatly improves the robustness and practical ability of the numerical source identification technology. The study establishes the best practice method of parallel sampling, which can achieve reliable numerical inversion accuracy in the early stage of sampling. The quantitative design criteria of the minimum sampling cost required for inversion to meet a certain error limit under different river hydrological conditions are discussed, and the relative critical time Λ of sampling and Peclet number (Pe) that characterizes river hydrodynamics are found as follow relation: Λ=-0.816×Pe-1/2-0.978×Pe-1/2lnPe-1/2+0.554, R2=0.938, and has been proved by information entropy theory. The precise design process of the emergency PSI monitoring scheme with the timeliness as the optimization goal is further proposed. This study provides important theoretical guidance for the innovative application of new monitoring methods in scenarios such as leakage detection and emergency monitoring under the background of environmental Internet of Things.

    How to cite: Yang, R., Jiang, J., Pang, T., Men, Y., and Zheng, Y.: New insights on the practical significance of numerical methods for surface water pollution source identification, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11975, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11975, 2022.

    EGU22-12525 | Presentations | HS2.3.8

    Bayesian updating despite model errors? A sliding time-window approach to rescue 

    Anneli Guthke, Han-Fang Hsueh, Thomas Wöhling, and Wolfgang Nowak

    Bayesian mechanistic modeling often suffers from overconfident and biased posterior distributions for parameters and predictions. This phenomenon arises because the fundamental assumption of Bayesian Model Analysis is violated: the underlying model is assumed to be true, but in fact, it is a simplification of reality with structural errors that show at least during some periods of the modeled time span. As a result, a compromise solution in parameter space is identified that can formally fit the full data set best, but this parameter set will not be representative of the true system state. Neither will it be representative of the “compensation mode” in which the model is whenever structural error kicks in. As a logical consequence, predictions will be biased and their intervals too narrow. The longer the data set used for calibration, the stronger the misleading effect. Typical sources of severe structural deficits that produce dynamically occurring errors are missing or misspecified processes in the model. 

    We propose a formal time-windowed Bayesian analysis to overcome this general problem. When performing Bayesian updating on shorter time windows, the assumption of a (quasi-) true model becomes more plausible, and by sliding this window through the calibration time series, we let the model adjust its posterior parameter distributions according to the current strength of error. These time-shifting parameter distributions allow us to (1) identify periods of statistically significant model error occurrence via measuring time-varying Bayesian model evidence, (2) diagnose potential sources of model error by understanding the time-varying parameter compensation mechanisms, and (3) predict with more realistic uncertainty intervals by distribution averaging. 

    We demonstrate the proposed method on a set of synthetic and real-world scenarios of soil moisture modeling. With this example, we also highlight its usefulness to analyze dynamic systems in a wide range of disciplines, such as water quality modeling, decision support, and risk assessment. Results show that the time sequence of posterior parameter distributions (and dependent model mechanisms such as water retention curves and unsaturated hydraulic conductivity functions) provides valuable insights into the model’s weaknesses, and it also provides guidance for model improvement.

    How to cite: Guthke, A., Hsueh, H.-F., Wöhling, T., and Nowak, W.: Bayesian updating despite model errors? A sliding time-window approach to rescue, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12525, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12525, 2022.

    EGU22-12783 | Presentations | HS2.3.8

    A Bayesian network approach to environmental risk assessment of pesticides: direct and indirect effects of climate change 

    Jannicke Moe, Sophie Mentzel, Merete Grung, Roger Holten, and Marianne Stenrød

    Weather patterns of Northern Europe are projected to change with increased temperature and precipitation by 2050. These climatic changes can potentially affect the transport and degradation of pesticides in the environment. Moreover, pesticide application patterns are expected to be altered as plant disease and insect pests potentially increase. Other agricultural practices are also expected to change such as crop types and application rate. We have used a Bayesian network model to better integrate these potential direct and indirect climate change effects on pesticide exposure, in a probabilistic approach to pesticide risk assessment. The Bayesian network serves as a meta-model to incorporate the predictions from a pesticide fate and transport model (i.e. WISPE). In this study, we ran the exposure prediction model for specific environmental factors linked to a representative Norwegian study area such as soil and site parameters together with chemical properties, under different scenarios of climate model projections and pesticide application patterns. The Bayesian network links the pesticide exposure predictions derived for this study area to effect distributions derived from toxicity tests to predict the probability distribution of the risk quotient to surrounding aquatic ecosystemsThus, this approach takes into account both direct climate change impacts (on pesticides fate and transport) and indirect effects (on pesticide application). Compared to traditional (deterministic) risk assessment methods, this probabilistic approach can better account for uncertainty associated with climate projections,

    How to cite: Moe, J., Mentzel, S., Grung, M., Holten, R., and Stenrød, M.: A Bayesian network approach to environmental risk assessment of pesticides: direct and indirect effects of climate change, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12783, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12783, 2022.

    HS2.4 – Hydrologic variability and change at multiple scales

    EGU22-444 | Presentations | HS2.4.1

    Identification of combined influence of climatic variables on indian summer monsoon rainfall extremes 

    Athira Krishnankutty Nair and Sarmistha Singh

    Spatio-temporal variability of Indian Summer Monsoon Rainfall (ISMR) is responsible for extreme events like floods and droughts across India. In recent decades, the incidence of extreme precipitation events during ISMR is increased significantly, which are primarily linked to climatic variables like El Niño Southern Oscillation (ENSO), Equatorial Indian Ocean Oscillation (EQUINOO), Pacific Decadal Oscillation (PDO), and Atlantic Multidecadal Oscillation (AMO). In this study, extreme precipitation indices (EPIs) like consecutive dry days (CDD), consecutive wet days (CWD), maximum consecutive 5-day precipitation (Rx5day), and 95th percentile (R95p) have been considered to explain the characteristics of ISMR extremes. Moreover, a regional analysis has been carried out using the multiple wavelet coherence method to determine the coupled association of climatic oscillations with EPIs. Here, two-, three-, and four- climatic variable combinations have been applied to identify the best combination which explains the fluctuations of ISMR extremes all over India. Results indicate that two or more climatic oscillations could be sufficient particularly, AMO-ENSO-EQUINOO and AMO-ENSO-PDO are the best combinations to explain the variability of ISMR extremes across India. Apart from this analysis, wavelet decomposition and reconstruction analysis have also been performed to understand the scale-specific variability of the spatial-extreme precipitation. More than half of India had a significant correlation between reconstructed modes of ISMR extremes and climatic oscillations at interdecadal and multidecadal scales (8-16 and 16-32 -years), despite their interannual periodicities. This indicates that the non-stationary behaviour of the ISMR extremes was strongly associated with climatic variables at higher scales. 

    How to cite: Krishnankutty Nair, A. and Singh, S.: Identification of combined influence of climatic variables on indian summer monsoon rainfall extremes, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-444, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-444, 2022.

    EGU22-551 | Presentations | HS2.4.1

    Multi-scalar association between large-scale climatic pattern and droughts in India 

    Sidhan Valiya Veetil and Sarmistha Singh

    Extreme meteorological events, such as droughts, are strongly influenced by large-scale climatic oscillations. Since India is one of the most drought-prone countries, comprehensive knowledge of the teleconnection of the climatic oscillations is very helpful towards developing precise drought prediction models. For evaluating the association between climatic indices and drought indices, the interdependency among the climatic oscillation time series has not been addressed well in previous studies. Hence in this study, an elaborate analysis is done in a time-frequency space using the variants of wavelet analysis such as Wavelet Coherence Analysis (WCA), Multiple Wavelet Coherence Analysis (MWCA), and wavelet reconstruction method. The study has used Five major climatic oscillations namely El Niño Southern Oscillation (ENSO), Pacific Decadal Oscillation (PDO), Atlantic Multidecadal Oscillation (AMO), Indian Ocean Dipole (IOD), and Equatorial Indian Ocean Oscillation (EQUINOO), and a PET-based drought index, called Standardized Precipitation Evapotranspiration Index (SPEI) at four time-scales. The results from the analysis show that the interannual variability (2-4 years) of Indian droughts are primarily influenced by ENSO while the drought variability at 4–8-year time scale is influenced by the combined effect of PDO and EQUINOO. Similarly, the interdecadal variability (16-32 years) of Indian drought is dominantly influenced by PDO and IOD. AMO has not shown any significant association at any scale. Moreover, the droughts in Northwest and North Central India are strongly influenced by climatic oscillations. Further, the teleconnection pattern doesn’t significantly vary with the different timescale of drought. The study will help the hydrologists to enhance the understanding of the connection between climatic oscillations and Indian droughts and thereby better prepare for the impending droughts.

    How to cite: Valiya Veetil, S. and Singh, S.: Multi-scalar association between large-scale climatic pattern and droughts in India, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-551, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-551, 2022.

    EGU22-589 | Presentations | HS2.4.1

    STUDY OF THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN THE TEMPERATURE OF THE ATLANTIC OCEAN AND HYDROLOGICAL VARIABILITY IN THE N'ZI WATERSHED (Central-North Côte d'Ivoire) 

    marc auriol amalaman, Gil Mahe, Armand Zamble Tra Bi, Beh Ibrahim Diomande, Nathalie Rouche, Zeineddine Nouaceur, and Benoit Laignel

    Summary: The decline in rainfall experienced by the West African band in the decades 70 and 80 strongly affected the flow in the various sub-catchments. In order to better identify the different modes of variability, this work is dedicated to studying the relationship between the temperature of the Atlantic Ocean and changes in flow in the N'zi watershed. Continuous wavelet analysis was used for signal search signal in the Fêtêkro (1960-1997) and N'zianouan (1960-2010) hydrometric series. As for the consistency in wavelet, it made it possible to verify the link between the flow and Atlantic Ocean temperature indices (North Atlantic Temperature: TNA and South Atlantic Temperature: TSA). Continuous wavelet analysis shows a fairly marked variability overall in high frequencies (6 months to 1 year) and interannual (> 1 year). Thus, at the Fêtêkro station north of the basin, the annual scale (1 year) records half of the variability ready with an estimated signal at 46.09%.  For the N'zianouan station, 37.18% explains the variability of the signal. At this stage, the Fêtêkro station has a rather pronounced variability to the detriment of that of N'zianouan. At the level of low frequency variability, the N'zianouan station has a fairly pronounced variability from 1 to 7 years.  Periodicity (1 – 2; 2 – 4 years) marks the highest signal (19.78%). The station of Fêtêkro shows a signal in the decade 60 estimated at 9.46% at 2-year frequency. As for wavelet consistency, it indicates a strong influence of the TSA.  index. In Fêtêkro, a consistency in phase is perceptible from 2 years in the decades 60 and 70.  At the frequency (4-8 years), this logic is observed over the entire time series. At the station of N'zianouan, we observe this reality in the decades 60 and 80 at periodicity (2-6 years), and (7-9 years) from 1990. Therefore, the results of the coherence show that the TSA index strongly impacts the flow in the N'zi watershed.

    Keywords: TSA, TNA, frequency, variability, N'zi watershed

     

    How to cite: amalaman, M. A., Mahe, G., Tra Bi, A. Z., Diomande, B. I., Rouche, N., Nouaceur, Z., and Laignel, B.: STUDY OF THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN THE TEMPERATURE OF THE ATLANTIC OCEAN AND HYDROLOGICAL VARIABILITY IN THE N'ZI WATERSHED (Central-North Côte d'Ivoire), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-589, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-589, 2022.

    EGU22-601 | Presentations | HS2.4.1

    Recent and future trends of river runoff in the North-West Russia 

    Elena Grek and Liubov Kurochkina

    The research is devoted to the identification of the patterns in spatio-temporal variability of river runoff characteristics in the North-West Russia. Based on long-term observation series, trends in the runoff characteristics were calculated as well as the patterns of their spatial variability were analyzed.

    Within the framework of the work, the river runoff characteristics for 3 long-term periods were analyzed: the previous (before 1966), modern (1966-2019) and future periods (2022-2099).

    The results of our study showed increase amount of cases with maximum runoff rainfall flood being higher than spring runoff from the end of 1980s.Estimates on expected changes in the hydrological regime under the implementation of RCP 2.6, 6.0 and 8.5 scenarios are presented. The most significant changes were detected in winter runoff and maximum spring and rainfall runoff. It is shown that an increase in winter runoff should be expected for the study area, as well as a decrease in the maximum water discharge of the spring flood. At the same time, according to scenarios 6.0 and 8.5, by the end of the century, the maximum annual discharge is likely to be observed during the period of rainfall floods.

    How to cite: Grek, E. and Kurochkina, L.: Recent and future trends of river runoff in the North-West Russia, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-601, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-601, 2022.

    In 2018 a mass death of fish occurred in the storage basin Lohsa I which is located in the Upper Lusatia, Germany. Lohsa I is a former lignite mining pit, which is now mainly used for industrial water supply, flood defence and fishing. It was assumed that an inflow of anaerobic groundwater could have been the cause for this event as groundwater inflow was observed before. Additionally, the input of fresh water from the river Kleine Spree was missing in summer 2018. In the project RoBiMo (robot assisted inland water monitoring) at the TU Bergakademie Freiberg there is a focus on collecting and analysing water quality data and climate data with the aim to quantify groundwater - surface water interactions and identify the influence of climate change in Saxony.

    With an annual mean temperature of 12.4°C the year 2018 was +1.3°C warmer than the former period from 2010 to 2017. Total precipitation in 2018 was 398 mm, only 61% of the average precipitation of the period between 2010 and 2017 (648 mm). These data were used to quantify the amount of groundwater inflow to the storage basin Lohsa I and the effect of climate change.

    For 2018 a positive value of groundwater flow was determined which implies an inflow of groundwater. A calculation from 1996 to 2019 shows an overall net inflow of groundwater. The calculation figures out a strong coherence between the groundwater flow, precipitation and sea water level. Until 2018 groundwater inflow and outflow were balanced but since then it became more deficient. The model BOWAHALD was used to determine evapotranspiration and storage change. The linear trend of precipitation is decreasing whereas the trend for evapotranspiration is increasing. As a result, the storage basin Lohsa I experiences a net loss of water.

    Based on the results from storage basin Lohsa I the water budget for Upper Lusatia is calculated. Less precipitation, heavy rainfall events and decreasing groundwater levels are predicted for this area. The Lusatian lakes with 23 post mining lakes and a water surface area of more than 14,000 hectares will be heavily affected by climate change. For 2018 a loss of water to the atmosphere through evapotranspiration of 1.18 x 108 m³ was calculated. It can be assumed that such warm and dry years as 2018 will occur more frequently in the future.

    How to cite: Jarosch, L. and Scheytt, T.: Influence of climate conditions and lake characteristics on the former lignite mining pit Lohsa I, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2724, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2724, 2022.

    EGU22-2859 | Presentations | HS2.4.1

    Sensitivity of groundwater level in the Seine River basin to changes in interannual to decadal climate variability 

    Lisa Baulon, Manuel Fossa, Nicolas Massei, Nicolas Flipo, Nicolas Gallois, Matthieu Fournier, Bastien Dieppois, Julien Boé, Luminita Danaila, Delphine Allier, and Hélène Bessiere

    Groundwater level (GWL) variations can be expressed over a wide range of timescales. As aquifers act as low-pass filters, low-frequency variability (interannual to decadal variability) originating from large-scale climate variability represents a significant part of GWL variance. Anthropogenically-driven climate change may affect, and have maybe already affected, the internal climate variability which explains the low-frequency variability of hydrological processes. Such changes in internal climate variability could therefore affect GWL variations. How GWL, including extremes, may respond to such changes and variations in climate variability however remains an open question.

     

    To tackle this issue, we implemented an empirical numerical approach allowing to assess the sensitivity of aquifers to changes in large-scale climate variability, using the whole Seine hydrosystem (76000 km2) as a case study. The approach consisted in: i) identifying and modifying the spectral content of precipitation, originating from large-scale climate variability, using signal processing; ii) injecting perturbed precipitation fields as input in a physically-based hydrological/hydrogeological model (the CaWaQS software) for the Seine river basin for simulating perturbed GWL; iii) comparing the spectral content, trend and extremes of perturbed GWL with the reference GWL. We used the Safran precipitation field over the period 1970-2018, which was initially used for model calibration and validation. GWL data for the Seine basin is a subset of a database of climate-sensitive time series (i.e. low anthropogenic influence) recently set up at the BRGM and University of Rouen Normandy. First, the Safran reanalysis and observed GWL time series were analyzed using continuous wavelet transform to identify the different timescales of variability: interannual (2-4yr and 5-8yr) and decadal (~15yr). Then, the different timescale of precipitation time series were extracted using maximum overlap discrete wavelet transform. For each time series of the precipitation field, the amplitude of each timescale was modified individually, by either increasing or decreasing it by 50%. This led to six scenarios of perturbed low-frequency variability of precipitation, which are subsequently used as input in the CaWaQS model to assess the response of GWL variability and extremes.

     

    Preliminary results indicate that perturbations of the amplitude of interannual to decadal precipitation variability result in substantial changes in the variability of GWL, affecting the same timescales, as well as timescales that were not modified in the precipitation field. Implications of these findings on potential trends and the frequency of extremes of GWL is currently being explored.

    How to cite: Baulon, L., Fossa, M., Massei, N., Flipo, N., Gallois, N., Fournier, M., Dieppois, B., Boé, J., Danaila, L., Allier, D., and Bessiere, H.: Sensitivity of groundwater level in the Seine River basin to changes in interannual to decadal climate variability, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2859, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2859, 2022.

    EGU22-4389 | Presentations | HS2.4.1

    Links between drought and atmospheric circulation types during 1950-2019 

    Zuzana Bešťáková, Jan Kyselý, and Ondřej Lhotka

    The study deals with links between drought and atmospheric circulation in different parts of Europe (Western Europe, Central Europe, Eastern Europe, Northern Europe, and Southern Europe) during 1950–2019. The links are evaluated using drought characteristics (based on a difference between potential evapotranspiration and precipitation) calculated from gridded EOBS data and atmospheric circulation types that were classified using daily sea level pressure patterns obtained from the NCEP-NCAR reanalysis. Circulation types supporting drought in warm half-year are identified, and we analyse changes in their occurrence in the period after 1950, seasonal changes, and the connection with drought trends in individual European regions.

    How to cite: Bešťáková, Z., Kyselý, J., and Lhotka, O.: Links between drought and atmospheric circulation types during 1950-2019, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4389, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4389, 2022.

    The ability to predict the frequency and magnitude of flooding at lead times of 1 to 10 years is of great interest to governments and institutions responsible for flood risk management. However, at these lead times there is significant uncertainty about dynamical changes in atmospheric circulation. The current generation of models underestimate the predictable signal of the North Atlantic Oscillation (NAO), the principal mode of variability in North Atlantic atmospheric circulation, leading to low confidence in predictions of regional precipitation and flooding. Recent work has shown that by post-processing a sufficiently large model ensemble, decadal variations in North Atlantic winter climate can become highly predictable (Smith et al., 2020). Here, we investigate whether this NAO-matching technique can be used to improve the skill of flood forecasts at decadal lead times in the United Kingdom. We use a large ensemble of decadal hindcasts consisting of 169 members drawn from CMIP phases 5 and 6, and observed flood records for the period 1960-2015. Following Smith et al. (2020), we adjust the variance of the raw ensemble mean NAO to match that of the observed predictable signal, then select the ensemble members showing the lowest absolute difference with the variance-adjusted ensemble mean. Working only with the selected members (n=20), we supply the ensemble mean precipitation and temperature to a distributional regression model to predict the occurrence and magnitude of winter floods at lead times of 1 to 10 years. We compare these predictions with those from an equivalent model which uses predictors drawn from the full ensemble (n=169) to assess the improvement in predictive skill. Our preliminary results suggest that NAO-matching shows promise at improving decadal flood predictions in northern Europe.

    Reference

    Smith, D.M., Scaife, A.A., Eade, R. et al. North Atlantic climate far more predictable than models imply. Nature 583, 796–800 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-020-2525-0.

    How to cite: Moulds, S., Slater, L., and Dunstone, N.: Improving decadal flood prediction in northern Europe by selecting ensemble members based on North Atlantic Oscillation skill, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6158, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6158, 2022.

    EGU22-7165 | Presentations | HS2.4.1

    Evaluating hydrologic change for a set of European catchments by performance-based weighting of an ensemble of hydrologic and climate models 

    Frederiek Sperna Weiland, Robrecht Visser, Peter Greve, Berny Bisselink, Lukas Brunner, and Albrecht Weerts

    Hydrologic variability is expected to change throughout Europe due to climate change. However, ensemble projections of future changes in discharge show large variation because of the uncertainty in climate projections. The robustness of the change signal can potentially be improved by performance-based weighting. Here we analyze future change projections from an ensemble of three hydrological models (CWatM, LISFLOOD and wflow_sbm) forced with climate datasets from the Coordinated Downscaling Experiment - European Domain (EURO-CORDEX). The experiment focusses on nine river basins spread over Europe. The basins have different climate and catchment characteristics that strongly influence the hydrological response. We evaluate the ensemble consistency, the geographical variation therein and apply two weighting approaches; (1) the Climate model Weighting by Independence and Performance (ClimWIP) that focuses on meteorological variables and (2) the Reliability Ensemble Averaging (REA) that is here applied to catchment specific discharge statistics.

    In Southern and Northern-Europe the ensemble consistency is high. There is a strong climate change signal. In Central Europe the differences between models are more pronounced. Analysis of the weighting method reveal that both weighting methods favor projections from similar GCMs and assign high weights to a single or few best performing GCMs.

    How to cite: Sperna Weiland, F., Visser, R., Greve, P., Bisselink, B., Brunner, L., and Weerts, A.: Evaluating hydrologic change for a set of European catchments by performance-based weighting of an ensemble of hydrologic and climate models, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7165, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7165, 2022.

    EGU22-7748 | Presentations | HS2.4.1

    Climate change impacts on river flow in England: a comparison of the UKCP18 and euro-CORDEX regional climate projections 

    Cordula I. Wittekind, Matthew B. Charlton, Michael Strauch, Felix Witing, and Megan J. Klaar

    In England, the priority catchment project focuses on developing innovative solutions to ensuring a clean and plentiful supply of water and environmental protection. Understanding the impacts of climate change on streamflow and water availability will ensure resilient management solutions into the future. The latest 12-member dynamically downscaled perturbed parameter ensemble of regional climate model projections (PPE-RCM) is part of the country specific UK Climate Projections UKCP18. In this study it was applied to estimate future changes in streamflow in an application of a new, revised version of the Soil and Water Assessment Tool (SWAT+) to two contrasting priority catchments in England. Both catchments are influenced by high rates of freshwater withdrawals but differ in their natural hydrological regimes and geographies. One is a wet coastal catchment with steep slopes while the other is a dry lowland catchment. Modelled impacts on natural monthly flows and flow duration statistics until the 2080s under the 12 member PPE were compared to those from 18 members of the euro-CORDEX initiative. Both ensembles are available for emissions pathway RCP8.5. To cover a broad range of scenarios, we also modelled the impact of the lower emissions (RCP4.5 & RCP2.6) euro-CORDEX projections.

    SWAT+ performs well in simulating natural flows during the validation period in both catchments. The PPE estimates are consistently drier than euro-CORDEX. It projects streamflow in the coastal catchment to increase in seasonality with higher winter and lower summer flows, while streamflow in the dry lowland catchment is projected to decrease across all months apart from February. In the dry lowland catchment, the euro-CORDEX under RCP8.5 predict the strongest decreases in streamflow for June at -13%, while the PPE projects beyond -20% decrease throughout June to September. The climate change signal in the coastal catchment is less clear. The PPE projects winter streamflow to increase by between 5% to 36% while the euro-CORDEX under RCP8.5 predict increases between 13% to 23%, summer streamflow is projected to decrease by -16% to -23% and -0.5% to -4% respectively. RCP2.6 and RCP4.5 represent a mixed result with rarely beyond 10% change and more months with increasing trends than under RCP8.5. The different emissions pathways largely agree on increasing high flows and decreasing low flows in the coastal catchment. For the lowland catchment both ensembles driven by RCP8.5 project decreases across the whole flow duration curve while RCP 2.6 and 4.5 project medium to high flows to increase and low flows at Q70 and Q95 to largely stay the same.

    This study suggests the need to adapt environmental protection and water withdrawals to decreasing water availability across the whole year in the lowland catchment and to pronounced changes in streamflow timing in the coastal catchment. To understand a broader range of climate impacts the UKCP18 PPE-RCMs should be used with other projections. However, they represent high-end warming scenarios translating into strong hydrological response, in particular streamflow decreases, that other ensembles might not capture, providing further insights into the challenges that water management may face.

    How to cite: Wittekind, C. I., Charlton, M. B., Strauch, M., Witing, F., and Klaar, M. J.: Climate change impacts on river flow in England: a comparison of the UKCP18 and euro-CORDEX regional climate projections, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7748, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7748, 2022.

    EGU22-7816 | Presentations | HS2.4.1

    How could uncertainty in future ENSO diversity influence assessments of seasonal precipitation anomalies over the 21st century? 

    Bastien Dieppois, Nicola Maher, Antonietta Capotondi, and John O'Brien

    The El Niño-Southern Oscillation (ENSO) is the leading mode of tropical climate variability, with impacts on ecosystems, agriculture, freshwater supplies, and hydropower production spanning much of the globe. Most impact studies use a canonical representation of ENSO, as characterised by sea-surface temperature anomalies (SSTa) in the central-eastern Pacific. However, ENSO shows large differences from one event to another in terms of its intensity, spatial pattern and temporal evolution. For instance, while the 1997/98 El Niño displayed extreme SSTa in the eastern equatorial Pacific, the largest SSTa during the 2002/03 event were weaker and primarily confined to the central equatorial Pacific. These differences in the longitudinal location and intensity of ENSO events, referred to as “ENSO diversity”, are associated with different regional climate impacts throughout the world. The representation of such differences in ENSO spatial patterns in climate models thus strongly influence the skill of impact prediction systems. Here, we exploit the power of single model initial-condition large ensembles (SMILEs) from 14 fully-coupled climate models from both CMIP5 and CMIP6 (totalling over 500 simulations in historical and SSP-RCP scenarios) to examine the system trajectories, and identify future variations in the location and intensity of El Niño and La Niña events. We then quantify how contrasting pathways for ENSO event location, and their associated intensity, could alter seasonal precipitation anomalies throughout the world over the 21st century.

    How to cite: Dieppois, B., Maher, N., Capotondi, A., and O'Brien, J.: How could uncertainty in future ENSO diversity influence assessments of seasonal precipitation anomalies over the 21st century?, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7816, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7816, 2022.

    EGU22-8209 | Presentations | HS2.4.1

    Decadal to multidecadal variability in long- and short-lived hydrological extremes in sub-Saharan Africa 

    Job Ekolu, Bastien Dieppois, Jonathan Eden, Yves Tramblay, Gabriele Villarini, Gil Mahe, Jean-Emmanuel Paturel, and Marco van de Wiel

    Sub-Saharan Africa is affected by a high-level of temporal and spatial climate variability, with large impacts on water resources, human lives and economies, notably through hydrological extremes, such as floods and droughts. Using a newly reconstructed 65-year daily streamflow dataset of over 600 stations distributed throughout sub-Saharan Africa, we first highlight that the frequency, intensity and duration of hydrological extremes are strongly impacted by decadal to multi-decadal variations. However, the key factors driving such decadal to multi-decadal variability remain poorly documented and understood. To address this research gap, we first compile information on local-scale (precipitation, temperature, soil moisture) and large-scale (e.g., El Niño–Southern Oscillation, Atlantic Multidecadal Variability) drivers. Then, by using relative importance analysis and multiple datasets, we investigate the contribution of large-scale versus regional-scale processes in driving decadal to multi-decadal variability in floods and droughts. Results show that the changes in flood and drought characteristics are significantly linked to modes of climate variability in the Pacific, Indian, and Atlantic Oceans. Although flood and drought characteristics are significantly correlated, the influences of large-scale climate variability on them are non-linear. Meanwhile, local-scale factors impacting floods and droughts are variable throughout the sub-continent. Our results highlight the role that changes in rainfall, soil moisture and temperature play across the major watersheds in sub-Saharan Africa.

    How to cite: Ekolu, J., Dieppois, B., Eden, J., Tramblay, Y., Villarini, G., Mahe, G., Paturel, J.-E., and van de Wiel, M.: Decadal to multidecadal variability in long- and short-lived hydrological extremes in sub-Saharan Africa, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8209, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8209, 2022.

    EGU22-9305 | Presentations | HS2.4.1

    Identifying and quantifying the impact of climatic and non-climatic effects on river discharge 

    Julie Collignan, Jan Polcher, Sophie Bastin, and Pere Quintana Seguí

    In a context of global change, the stakes surrounding water availability and use are getting higher. River discharge has significantly changed over the past century. Human activities, such as irrigation and land cover changes, and climate change have had impact on the water cycle. This raises the question of how to separate the impact of climate change from the impact of anthropogenic activities to better understand their role in the historical records.

    We propose a methodology to semi-empirically separate the effect of climate from the impact of the changing catchment characteristics on river discharge. It is based on the Budyko framework and long land surface simulation. The Budyko parameter is estimated for each basin and represents its hydrological characteristics. Precipitations and potential evapotranspiration are derived from the forcing dataset GSWP3 (Global Soil Wetness Project Phase 3) – from 1901 to 2010 –. The ORCHIDEE Land Surface Model is used to estimate the terrestrial water and energy balance for the past climate but assuming humans do not modify land surface processes. This is a first guess of evaporation and its evolution due to climatic factors. Not having reliable observations of the evolution of the actual evaporation, river discharge and atmospheric observations are used to reconstruct it. This provides estimates of the evolution of the catchment characteristic and the evaporation efficiency which can then be compared to the modelled natural system. The aim is to separate anthropogenic changes from the effect of climatic forcing. To better understand the sensitivity of our methodology we applyied modifications to the atmospheric forcing to see how specific climate variations impact the sensitivity of the Budyko detection.

    Our results show that for most basins tested over Spain, there is an increasing trend in the Budyko parameter representing increasing evaporation efficiency of the watershed over the past century which can not be explained by the climate forcing. This trend is consistent with changes in irrigation equipment and development of dams over the studied period. However when looking at decadal trends, climatic fluctuations take precedence over non-climatic trends. In a context of climate changes, the balance between these trends could change in the future. The methodology was extended to other areas in Europe. The clear non-climatic trends were especially significant in semi-arid climate.

    How to cite: Collignan, J., Polcher, J., Bastin, S., and Quintana Seguí, P.: Identifying and quantifying the impact of climatic and non-climatic effects on river discharge, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9305, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9305, 2022.

    EGU22-9659 | Presentations | HS2.4.1

    Spatiotemporal Patterns of Drought and Multi-scale Linkages of Seasonal Drought to Climate Indices: A Case Study in the Huaihe River Basin, China 

    Xin Li, Guohua Fang, Zhenyu Zhang, Joël Arnault, Xin Wen, and Harald Kunstmann

    In the context of the current ocean-atmosphere cycle anomaly, exploring the potential teleconnections between climate indices and regional drought can help us know the variability of natural hazards more comprehensively to cope with them. This study explores the spatiotemporal patterns of drought and its multi-scale relations with typical climate indices in the Huaihe River Basin, China. The spatiotemporal variabilities of meteorological drought are identified using Empirical Orthogonal Function (EOF) and Continuous Wavelet Transform (CWT). The Cross Wavelet Transform (XWT) and Wavelet Coherence (WTC) analysis are used for investigating the multi-scale linkages between seasonal drought and climate indices, including Arctic Oscillation (AO), Bivariate El Niño–Southern Oscillation (ENSO) Timeseries (BEST), North Atlantic Oscillation (NAO), Niño3, Southern Oscillation Index (SOI), and sunspot number. Seasonal Standardized Precipitation Index (SPI)-3 during 1956-2020 are investigated separately for winter and spring seasons. We found that NAO mainly affects the interdecadal variation in spring drought, while AO and Niño3 focus on the interannual variation. In addition, Niño3 and SOI are more related to the winter drought on interdecadal scales. Our results prove that the onset, process, and intensity of El Niño or La Niña events influence the dryness and wetness conditions in the Huaihe River Basin. The results are beneficial for improving the accuracy of drought prediction, considering taking NAO, AO, and Niño3 as predictors for spring drought and Niño3 and SOI for winter drought.

    How to cite: Li, X., Fang, G., Zhang, Z., Arnault, J., Wen, X., and Kunstmann, H.: Spatiotemporal Patterns of Drought and Multi-scale Linkages of Seasonal Drought to Climate Indices: A Case Study in the Huaihe River Basin, China, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9659, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9659, 2022.

    The water budget of a certain area for a certain time interval is one of the quantitative characteristics of the hydrological cycle, which reflects the objectively existing in nature relations between the inflow, losing, and change of humidity reserves.

    The paper presents the results of calculating the components of the water budget of the Udy River Basin (the Siverskyi Donets River Basin) based on the available observation materials, and also describes their long-term dynamics. Total evaporation was calculated from the temperature and absolute humidity by the Konstantinov method. For the study, four meteorological stations data, which zones of influence belong to the studied basin, and the hydrological gauge the Udy River - Bezlyudivka data were used. In order to identify changes that have already occurred with the water body, it was compared the hydrometeorological characteristics of the present period (1991-2020) with the period of climatological normal (1961-1990).

    Since meteorological stations observations characterize discrete values ​​of meteorological indicators at individual points, and hydrological gauges observations show integrated values ​​of water runoff related to the upper basin situated, meteorological data were reduced to their average values ​​in the river basin. For this purpose, the weighing method was used - the basin is graphically divided by the system of Thiessen triangles into zones of influence of a separate meteorological station within the studied basin. The amount of precipitation, temperature, and relative humidity were determined using the calculated weights coefficient.

    The study of the water budget of the Udy River Basin revealed an increase in air temperature within the basin and the associated increase in the value of total evaporation, a decrease in spring flood runoff, and an increase in total runoff of the low-water period. It is determined that the annual runoff in the present period has decreased by 17%. The total amount of precipitation for the two study periods is characterized by the same amount, but there was a change in their distribution during the year. The amount of precipitation decreased in the period of spring flood at the present period compared to the period of climatological normal and increased in the low-water period.

    How to cite: Bolbot, H. and Grebin, V.: The structure of the water budget of the Udy River (Ukraine) under the influence of present climate change, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11365, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11365, 2022.

    Solar activity and internal climate modes (e.g., ENSO and PDO) have significant effects on extreme climate events and streamflow variability. As the roof of the world and the water tower of Asia, the Qinghai-Tibet Plateau (QTP) is highly sensitive to climate change. Therefore, it is of great significance to study the relationship between extreme hydrometeorological events of the QTP and climate change for global hydroclimate research. In this study, we analyzed the spatiotemporal variation and significant oscillation period of several hydrometeorological variables such as extreme precipitation indices (EPIs), extreme temperature indices (ETIs) and annual runoff based on the observation data of hydrometeorological stations in the QTP during 1962–2019 using Sen’s slope estimator, Mann-Kendall test and continuous wavelet analysis (CWT). And the teleconnection patterns and the leading–lag relationship between solar activity, internal climate modes and these hydrometeorological variables were evaluated using wavelet coherence (WTC). The result showed that QTP has been wetter and warmer in the past 58 years. The EPIs mostly mutated around 2010, and the increase was more pronounced after that; while the ETIs mainly mutated in the late 20th century. In terms of spatial distribution, the EPIs (except consecutive dry days) decreased from southeast to northwest; while distribution of ETIs was much more complicated. The extreme warm and cold indices showed a significant increasing and decreasing trend, respectively. The annual runoff of natural rivers in the QTP showed an increasing trend, and suddenly changed around 2000. EPIs had significant periodicities at 2–4-year band and 4–7-year band, while the significant periodicity of ETIs was mainly concentrated in the 2–4-year band. In addition, the annual runoff of natural rivers had significant periodicities in the bands of 2-4 years, 4-7 years and 7-11 years. Hydrometeorological variables had higher correlations with EI Niño-Southern Oscillation (ENSO) and Pacific Decadal Oscillation (PDO) than with sunspot number (SSN). Solar activity first affects internal climate variability and then sequentially transfers this influence to meteorological and hydrological variables. This study has important implications for water resources management, flood control, climate feedback, ecosystem restoration, and the well-being of surrounding residents and sustainable development at the QTP.

    Keywords: climate change; extreme climate events; runoff; Qinghai-Tibet Plateau; spatiotemporal variability; wavelet analysis

    How to cite: Zhang, Z., Zhang, L., Liu, Y., and Jin, M.: Combined influence of solar activity and internal climate modes on long-term hydro-climatic variability in the Qinghai-Tibet Plateau, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12411, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12411, 2022.

    EGU22-12763 | Presentations | HS2.4.1

    Current changes in seasonal rainfall and the impact of the NAO in Serbia 

    Hristo Popov and Jelena Svetozarevich

    Climate fluctuations are highly dependent on changes in atmospheric circulation. The physical properties of air masses and their geographical distribution are of great importance because they determine the weather over large areas.

    The North Atlantic Oscillation (NAO) is the most significant mode of natural climate variability in the Northern Hemisphere. It has a major impact on weather and climate in the North Atlantic and mainland Europe. There are two phases of NAO, positive and negative. When it is positive in Europe, warmer and wetter weather prevails. When it is negative, the weather in Europe is colder with more rainfall.

    The Republic of Serbia is located in Southeastern Europe, in the western part of the Balkan Peninsula, the northern part of the country is located in the Middle Danube Lowland, the Sava Valley and the Tisza Valley. In the middle part are the river valleys of Drina, Kolubara and Morava. In the southern part of the country are occupied by mountains up to 2000 m high.

    The aim of the article is to study the current changes in seasonal precipitation in the Republic of Serbia. For this purpose, data from 15 climate stations were evenly distributed over the territory and the influence of the NAO during the winter months. Three of the stations are mountainous - located over 1000m. The rest are alpine with lower altitude. The data is for seasonal values 1990-2019 were obtained from NIMH Serbia.

    In structure of the research introduction presents the topic, tasks and bibliography. The Data and Methods section shows the geographical and climatic features of the study area and explains the methods. The next section provides results on seasonal changes and the impact of NAO. The conclusion shows the main results we have reached.

    Key words:  NAO, climate change, seasonal precipitation, Republic of Serbia

    How to cite: Popov, H. and Svetozarevich, J.: Current changes in seasonal rainfall and the impact of the NAO in Serbia, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12763, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12763, 2022.

    EGU22-12767 | Presentations | HS2.4.1

    Why is the atmosphere becoming drier? - An investigation of the role of dynamical drivers on recent trends in relative humidity 

    Kirsten Maria Florentine Weber, Julie Jones, Kate M Willett, Colin Osborne, and Robert Bryant

    Relative humidity (RH) over land has declined steeply since 2000. The drying signal is relatively consistent from the edge of the deep tropics to the mid-latitudes of both hemispheres, whereas regions equatorward and poleward show increasing RH trends. The drying trend observed in the gridded global humidity dataset, HadISDH, could not be captured by the CMIP5 climate models [1, 2].

    The drying trend finds partial explanation through thermodynamic drivers. Global warming causes an increase in both latent and sensible heat in the atmosphere. Over land, the increase in latent heat is much lower than that of sensible heat. Due to slower warming rates over the ocean compared to land, not sufficient humidity is evaporated and transported towards the coast to keep RH over land constant [3].

    Temperature and moisture in many regions are influenced by the atmospheric circulation, therefore can influence RH. In this study, we investigate the potential influence of atmospheric circulation on the observed regional RH changes. We have done this for selected regions with a strong RH trend (including the western US, eastern Brazil, Greenland's coastal areas, southern Africa, the Caspian Sea, Mongolia and Tibet). We firstly calculate correlation and regression coefficients between gridded and regional RH and a range of dynamical drivers (including the Northern and Southern Annular Modes, ENSO and the PDO). We also explored the relationship between regional RH and global fields of sea surface temperature (SST), sea level pressure (SLP), and wind from the ERA-Interim reanalysis. We find a significant relationship between RH and the dynamical drivers in many regions (for example with the ENSO in eastern Brazil), as well as the impact of small-scale atmospheric circulations on land cover change, which then impacts RH (for example evaporation over the Caspian Sea). We will present these results, and try to quantify the contribution of these drivers to recent trends.

    [1] Willet et al. (2014), HadISDH land surface multi-variable humidity and temperature record for climate monitoring

    [2] Dunn et al. (2017), Comparison of land surface humidity between observations and CMIP5 models

    [3] Sherwood and Fu (2014), A Drier Future?

    How to cite: Weber, K. M. F., Jones, J., Willett, K. M., Osborne, C., and Bryant, R.: Why is the atmosphere becoming drier? - An investigation of the role of dynamical drivers on recent trends in relative humidity, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12767, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12767, 2022.

    EGU22-13310 | Presentations | HS2.4.1

    What can hydrologic signatures teach us about a multiyear drought? 

    Margarita Saft, Murray Peel, Keirnan Fowler, and Tim Peterson

    The internal dynamics of a catchment can be shifted by multiyear dry periods. While there is consensus that annual streamflow decreases for a given annual rainfall in the case of multiyear dry period significantly more than during isolated dry years (thus representing a shift in hydrologic response), the mechanism of this shift remains debated. As the hydrological shifts were investigated on an annual and, to a lesser extent, seasonal scale, little is known regarding what parts of the flow regime (e.g. high flows, low flows, recessions) are affected and how. An event-scale analysis using process-linked hydrologic metrics (or signatures) can reveal hidden patterns in catchment response to multiyear drought and shed light on the otherwise hidden hydrological processes. Additionally, understanding whether some parts of flow variability experienced a more pronounced impact from the drought may be important for the water management decision-making. Here we investigate long-term changes in catchment response on daily to sub-monthly timescales to aid both hydrological processes understanding and water management practice.

    We calculate over 30 hydrologic signatures characterising different aspects of flow regime and hydrological processes before, during, and after a decade-long drought and compare the results.  The signatures are calculated with the Toolbox for Streamflow Signatures in Hydrology (TOSSH) which combines signature sets from several earlier studies. We use a well-known multiyear drought, the Millennium Drought (MD) in Australia as our case study. This drought spanned ~13 years (1997-2009) and affected over 1 million square kilometres of land including 156 semi-natural study catchments in Victoria.

    Our results suggest that on average both high and low flows were affected in similar proportion while the shape (i.e. slope) of the flow duration curve was largely preserved. The tendency to generate less runoff for a given rainfall has been demonstrated in a range of signatures from event to total flow volumes and thus is independent of the timescale. When analysing signatures related to catchment storage, we observe that the decline continues post-drought. Baseflow index and recession signatures show some evidence of multiyear catchment storage buffering. There is also evidence of lower hydrologic connectivity in the hillslopes affecting the event runoff. However, there are marked differences in signature behaviour between different catchments reflecting the differences in catchment internal structure and dominant hydrologic processes.

    How to cite: Saft, M., Peel, M., Fowler, K., and Peterson, T.: What can hydrologic signatures teach us about a multiyear drought?, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13310, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13310, 2022.

    EGU22-13363 | Presentations | HS2.4.1

    Exploring links between precipitation extremes and land use types through the UK Convection-Permitting Model 

    Kwok Pan Chun, Pingyu Fan, Qing He, Bastien Dieppois, Luminita Danaila, Nevil Quinn, Julian Klaus, Emir Toker, and Omer Yetemen

    Precipitation extremes are commonly linked with land use types. The UKCP18 Convection-Permitting Model (CPM) Projections at 5km high resolution simulation provide opportunities to investigate probable relationships between precipitation extremes and land use types. Changes in the duration and severity of extreme precipitation events can be linked to landscape characteristics, which affect the risk of rapid and local hydrological hazards.

    Based on publicly accessible data and a standard approach, Local Climate Zones (LCZs) provide coherent descriptions of the form and function of urban landscapes. From the World Urban Database and Access Portal, the LCZ is used to translate relevant land attributes to urban canopy parameters for climate and weather modelling applications at appropriate scales. Using the Severn River Basin as a case study, we use LCZ data to calculate urban fractions to investigate the roles of urban land types to the extreme distribution parameters.

    In conjunction with the LCZ data, the Corine Land Cover (CLC) and the Moderate Resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer (MODIS) datasets are used to benchmark how future changes in rainfall intensities and seasonal patterns might be related to land use. The results are used to generate possible hypotheses to run different CPM models based on the LCZ data.

    Based on these findings, we present a novel land-use-based approach for water hazard management addressing hydrological risk connected to regional climate resilience. For management authorities and infrastructure owners, precipitation extreme risk related to land use is critical for their long-term investment planning. The proposed methodology would be advantageous to many UK water regulators and stakeholders in generating more informative precipitation extreme estimations based on land use, for the high greenhouse gas emissions scenario RCP8.5.

    How to cite: Chun, K. P., Fan, P., He, Q., Dieppois, B., Danaila, L., Quinn, N., Klaus, J., Toker, E., and Yetemen, O.: Exploring links between precipitation extremes and land use types through the UK Convection-Permitting Model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13363, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13363, 2022.

    EGU22-756 | Presentations | HS2.4.2

    Climate change effects in a Mediterranean island and streamflow changes for a small area using EURO-CORDEX simulations combined with the SWAT model 

    Pier Andrea Marras, Daniela C.A. Lima, Pedro M.M. Soares, Rita M. Cardoso, Medas Daniela, Dore Elisabetta, and De Giudici Giovanni

    Climate change effects on the hydrologic cycle are a main concern for the evaluation of water management strategies. Climate models project important precipitation changes for the future, considering greenhouse emission scenarios. In this study, the EURO-CORDEX (European COordinated Regional Downscaling Experiment) climate models were first evaluated in a Mediterranean island (Sardinia), against observed precipitation for a historical reference period (1976-2005). A weighted Multi-Model Ensemble (ENS) was built, weighting the individual models based on their ability to reproduce observed rainfall. Future projections (2071-2100) were carried out, following the RCP-8.5 emissions scenario, to evaluate future changes in precipitations. ENS was then used as climate forcing for the SWAT model (Soil and Water Assessment Tool), with the aim to assess the consequences of such projected changes on streamflow and runoff of two small catchments located in the South-West Sardinia. Results showed that a decrease of mean rainfall values, up to -25 % at yearly scale, is expected for the future, along with an increase of extreme precipitation events. Particularly, in the eastern and southern areas, extreme events are projected to increase by 30%. Such changes reflect on the hydrologic cycle with a decrease of mean streamflow (-18% to -25%) and runoff (-12% to -18%), except in spring, when runoff is projected to increase by 20-30%. These results stress that Mediterranean is a hotspot for the climate change and the use of model tools can provide useful information to adopt water and land management strategies to deal with such changes.

    How to cite: Marras, P. A., Lima, D. C. A., Soares, P. M. M., Cardoso, R. M., Daniela, M., Elisabetta, D., and Giovanni, D. G.: Climate change effects in a Mediterranean island and streamflow changes for a small area using EURO-CORDEX simulations combined with the SWAT model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-756, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-756, 2022.

    With great changes, such as climate and land use/cover, occurring in hydrological processes over the last decades, runoff sensitivity, here defined as proportional changes in runoff caused by a given proportional change in its driving factors, has also been changing over time. However, few studies have focused on this sensitivity change, and runoff sensitivity is always considered to be constant in runoff attribution analysis with an elasticity-based method. In this study, we attempt to examine the temporal variation of runoff sensitivity in the middle reaches of the Yellow River basin, China, and quantify its effects on the changes in runoff so that the existing attribution method can be improved. We found that runoff sensitivity showed statistically significant trend, and runoff became more sensitive to changes in climate and catchment characteristics (CC). CC, largely affected by land use/cover change resulting from large scale ecological projects, was the major contributor to change in runoff sensitivity, followed by precipitation, and lastly potential evapotranspiration. Runoff sensitivity variation contributed approximately 20% to the proportional runoff change, and by allowing runoff sensitivity to change over time, relative contributions of climate and CC to runoff would range from − 5.05% to 9.94%. Our study supplements research focusing on hydrological changes and interactions, and we suggest that temporal variation in runoff sensitivity should be considered when quantifying the impacts of driving factors on changes in hydrological processes. 

    How to cite: Wang, Y.: Runoff sensitivity variation should be incorporated in hydrological analysis, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1295, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1295, 2022.

    Since the middle of the last century extreme rainfall events have intensified in many parts of the world (Martel et al., 2021), and increasing temperature is considered to let this development continue in the next decades. The Clausius-Clapeyron relationship, i.e. an about 7% increase per additional degree centigrade, yields an order of magnitude of what to expect, with convective rainfalls being likely to grow in a still more pronounced manner (Martel et al., op.cit.). Convective cells are, typically, associated with rainfalls of short duration and small spatial extent, which makes them particularly important for microcatchments.

    Combining Green-Ampt type infiltration with kinematic overland flow, the relationship between a square-topped hyetograph and runoff is modelled. Frequently, design rainfall duration is chosen equal to the time of concentration. In case of an infiltrating surface, however, maximum peak runoff may result from shorter rainfall. There may, thus, be partial area runoff only, in which case the Schmid (1997) design storm equation yields the critical rainfall duration needed to determine maximum peak flow.

    The study started from a chosen present-day IDF relationship of 20 years' return interval in Austria and a (rectangular) grass plot (hillslope) of 50 m length, 10% slope and an initial loss of 0.5 mm. Simulations were made using soil data from Columbia sandy loam, Guelph loam and Ida silt loam, in turn. Rainfall was assumed to be subject to Clausius-Clapeyron scaling and variable warming between 0.0 and 2.0 K.

    In the case of the most pervious soil of the three (Columbia sandy loam, vertical saturated permeability Ksv = 0.0139 mm/s) flow was laminar and described by the Dary-Weisbach friction law (K = 4000). Contributing area remained small throughout (length 0.9 m for 0 K and 8.3 m for 2 K temperature increase). Corresponding peak flow showed above-linear growth and increased strongly from 0.013 L/(s.m) for 0 K to 0.17 L/(s.m) for 2 K.

    The 'medium' soil, Guelph loam (Ksv = 0.00367 mm/s), was associated with contributing hillslope length growing from 35 m to the full 50 m as temperature increase varied from 0 to 2 K. Corresponding peak flows increased from 0.69 to 1.16 L/(s.m), i.e. by 68%. Flows over Guelph loam and Ida solt loam were turbulent (Manning's n = 0.4).

    In case of the finest soil, Ida silt loam (Ksv = 0.000292 mm/s), all of the microcatchment contributed to overland flow from the start (DT = 0 K). Peak flow increased almost linearly with temperature from 2.31 to 2.77 L/(s.m), i.e. by 20%.

    Consequently, it may be concluded that a future rise in temperature up to 2 K is likely to trigger strong increases in peak flows from infiltrating microcatchments. The present study indicates that Clausius-Clapeyron rainfall scaling may result in peak flows increasing much in excess of the 7% / K.

    References

    Martel, J.-L. et al.: Climate change and rainfall intensity-duration-frequency curves: overview of science and guidelines for adaption. J. Hydrol. Eng. 26(10), DOI: 10.1061/(ASCE)HE.1943-5584.0002122, 2021.

    Schmid, B.H.: Critical rainfall duration for overland flow from an infiltrating plane surface. J. Hydrol. 193, 45-60, 1997.

    How to cite: Schmid, B.: On climate change affecting the dynamics of overland flow from infiltrating microcatchments, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2033, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2033, 2022.

    EGU22-2300 | Presentations | HS2.4.2 | Highlight

    Was the 2020 Lake Victoria flooding linked to anthropogenic climate change? An event attribution study 

    Rosa Pietroiusti, Inne Vanderkelen, and Wim Thiery

    Heavy rainfall in East Africa between late 2019 and mid 2020 caused devastating floods and landslides throughout the region. These rains drove the level of Lake Victoria to a record-breaking maximum in the second half of May 2020, when the lake reached its highest level since measurements began in 1948. The high lake levels and consequent shoreline flooding triggered international attention, with media sources proposing a causal link with climate change. However, a formal attribution study identifying the possible role of anthropogenic climate change in increasing the likelihood of such record-breaking water levels has not been carried out so far.

    We present an attribution study that estimates how anthropogenic climate change influenced the likelihood of observing the rate of change in Lake Victoria’s level that was recorded in 2020. To this end, we reconstruct the record-high lake level using an observational water balance model for Lake Victoria. We first investigate the influence of the different water balance terms on the resulting lake level. Then, we apply the water balance model in a probabilistic event attribution framework by forcing it with historical and natural forcing only (hist-nat) bias-adjusted precipitation from six Earth system models from the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project phase 6 (CMIP6) ensemble, as made available through the Inter-Sectoral Impact Model Intercomparison Project phase 3b (ISIMIP3b). The study contributes to a better understanding of impacts caused by climate and weather extremes in the Greater Horn of Africa by disentangling the role of anthropogenic climate change and natural internal variability in a high-impact flood event.

    How to cite: Pietroiusti, R., Vanderkelen, I., and Thiery, W.: Was the 2020 Lake Victoria flooding linked to anthropogenic climate change? An event attribution study, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2300, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2300, 2022.

    EGU22-3319 | Presentations | HS2.4.2

    Can examining past variability help us understand catchment response to future climate change? 

    Clare Stephens, Lucy Marshall, Fiona Johnson, Laurence Lin, Larry Band, and Hoori Ajami

    It is common to test hydrologic models under contrasting historical periods as an indicator of likely performance under climate change. For example, a model calibrated under average conditions may be tested under increasingly dry subsets of the observational record. Any decline in performance as the testing conditions deviate further from the calibration conditions is then assumed to represent likely performance degradation under climate change scenarios with comparable rainfall decreases. Many studies have inherently applied the assumption that past rainfall variability can be used as a proxy for future climate change, but the analogy may be flawed for three main reasons:

    • Due to lagged hydrologic response to meteorological shifts, catchment behaviour under long-term wetting or drying may not be fully represented over shorter wet or dry periods.
    • Subsets of the past record selected based on rainfall are unlikely to reflect future temperature increases.
    • Past observations do not include expected increases in carbon dioxide levels.

    If any of these factors substantially impacts catchment response, subsets of the historical record with equivalent rainfall will not be accurate proxies for future climate scenarios. We tested the impact of each factor using the ecohydrologic model RHESSys. RHESSys dynamically simulates vegetation growth, subsurface flow and nutrient cycling and is thus able to capture the key processes that could drive nonstationary catchment response in the future. We found that all three future climate factors (rainfall change persistence, temperature, and carbon dioxide) altered catchment response substantially, especially for drier future scenarios. For our study catchment, persistence of dry conditions over many decades led to different subsurface water storage levels than the same rainfall experienced over shorter timeframes, leading to different streamflow. The impacts of increased temperature and carbon dioxide concentrations on vegetation further altered runoff behaviour. This means that long-term climate change effects will not necessarily emerge over short historical periods with equivalent rainfall. In our example, ignoring persistence in rainfall changes, rising temperatures, and higher carbon dioxide levels could lead us to underestimate model performance degradation in terms of Nash-Sutcliffe efficiency by as much as 0.41. Therefore, the uncertainty introduced in hydrologic models by future climate change has probably been underestimated in the current literature.

    How to cite: Stephens, C., Marshall, L., Johnson, F., Lin, L., Band, L., and Ajami, H.: Can examining past variability help us understand catchment response to future climate change?, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3319, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3319, 2022.

    EGU22-3707 | Presentations | HS2.4.2

    What does the future hold? Using Standardised Precipitation and Evapotranspiration Index (SPEI) to project drought in Scotland. 

    Sayali Pawar, Sarah Halliday, Miriam Glendell, and Paola Ovando Pol

    UN Sustainable Development Goal (SDG) 6.1 aims to achieve universal and equitable access to safe and affordable drinking water for all by 2030. However, even in a developed nation such as Scotland, climate change, and the water systems resilience to it, is putting achieving this goal at risk. Despite being abundantly blessed in terms of water resources, Scotland is facing an accelerated increase in the frequency of extreme weather events. The UK Climate Projections 2018 indicate that Scotland’s climate will become warmer, with drier summers, and increased occurrence of drought events. Recent water scarcity events prove the surge and are evidence for the projected weather patterns. Unlike drought indicators which are parameters describing meteorological, hydrological or agricultural drought conditions, like precipitation amounts, streamflow levels, soil moisture information, drought indices derive value based on statistical calculations. Once such meteorological drought index is the Standardised Precipitation and Evapotranspiration Index (SPEI) which is similar to the Standardised Precipitation Index (SPI). Unlike SPI, SPEI incorporates changes in evapotranspiration as it includes both precipitation and temperature as input data for calculation. Hence, SPEI makes a good choice for projecting future changes in a warming world and allows us to see the impact of climate change in inducing drought. Regional-scale analysis of SPEI across 36 sites using a 50 km grid generated drought scenarios for the longer term 2041-2080 using all 12 model members the UKCP18 dataset using 1981-2020 as the baseline period. These UKCP 18 projections were bias-corrected and downscaled to a 1km grid across Scotland before we acquired the data for analysis, thus enabling the calculation of SPEI at a finer scale. SPEI was then calculated at a 6-month timestep across the 36 sites in Scotland. The number of extreme drought months was computed for the baseline and the future periods. The drought month was defined as any month which has SPEI ≤ -2.  After calculating the extreme drought months for baseline and future periods, the metrics from 1981-2020 were subtracted from the future period for each model member to demonstrate the amount of change in the number of drought months from the baseline period. Results were calculated separately for the individual member and not averaged to avoid incorporating uncertainty associated with projections. The majority of the sites across the spatial extent showed projected increases in the number of drought months for the future period for each of the model members. Sites in the southwest and western Scottish islands showed a greater increase compared to other sites where extreme drought months were observed with little or no change. Results highlighted the need for better preparedness for water scarcity situations which are going to be exacerbated by climate change.

    How to cite: Pawar, S., Halliday, S., Glendell, M., and Ovando Pol, P.: What does the future hold? Using Standardised Precipitation and Evapotranspiration Index (SPEI) to project drought in Scotland., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3707, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3707, 2022.

    Climate drives the hydrological response in a more complex way that would result from a water balance analysis. I this study such a complex, spatiotemporal behaviour of flooding a wetland catchment is presented over 200 years. The study site is the Biebrza River catchment located in north-eastern Poland. This medium size catchment, especially its floodplain, was preserved in a relatively unchanged state in the last centuries. The yearly floods in the wetland floodplain are driven by complex contribution water from precipitation, snowmelt, groundwater, and upstream river. The hydrological simulations were conducted using a fully-integrated groundwater-surface water hydrological model (HydroGeoSphere). The historical simulations were driven by the NOAA Twentieth Century Reanalysis, whereas the future climate simulation was driven by an ensemble of EURO-CORDEX downscaling datasets for rcp26, rcp45, and rcp85 pathways. The contribution of different water sources to the floods was analysed using the hydraulic mixing-cell method. The results show spatiotemporal trends and year-to-year variation of the flooding water composition, depth and extent in the analysed period. This complex response stresses the importance of taking into account full hydrologic system interactions, such as climate, timing and hydraulic feedbacks for climate change analysis.

    How to cite: Berezowski, T.: Changes in groundwater, rainfall, snowmelt and river water contribution to floods in the 1900-2100 period for a wetland catchment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3810, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3810, 2022.

    Global bias-adjusted daily climate projections have been recently set up as part of the Inter-Sectoral Impact Model Intercomparison Project (ISIMIP) phase 3 based on CMIP6 projections (Lange et Büchner., 2021). This dataset is aimed at being used as input to global hydrological models, and their coarse resolution however prevents them to be used for catchment-scale and reach-scale applications.

    This work proposes to downscale these global climate projections through a pragmatic delta change approach and to derive catchment-scale streamflow time series through a fully-distributed hydrological model. The final objective is to produce future daily streamflow series over a high-resolution hydrographic network of 6 European catchment case studies for the DRYvER project (Datry et al., 2021). The advanced delta change approach (van Pelt et al., 2012) is selected here as it allows to create differential change factor according to distribution quantiles. The method is applied on precipitation, temperature, and potential evapotranspiration serving as input to the distributed JAMS-J2K model (Krause et al., 2006).

    This setup is first applied to the Ain catchment case study (France) that includes the intermittent Albarine river, considering a control period (1985-2014) and two future periods (2021-2050 and 2071-2100). These experiments are conducted using one run from 5 different global climate models and 2 emission/socio-economic scenarios (SSP1-RCP2.6 and SSP5-RCP8.5) from the CMIP6 experiments. This methodology allows to grasp the range of future changes in daily streamflow over the entire catchment. The comparison between the control period and the two future periods is used to describe possible changes over seasonal discharge and low flow characteristics.

    This approach is a preliminary step providing first and rapid insights into plausible futures for European intermittent rivers in terms of hydrology, biodiversity, ecosystem functioning and services, and adaptive management. Future steps will refine such futures using an innovative downscaling approach combining global and catchment-scale transient projections way to better grasp the joint influence of climate change and climate variability on reach-scale intermittence.

    This work has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement no. 869226

     

    Datry et al. (2021) Securing Biodiversity, Functional Integrity, and Ecosystem Services in Drying River Networks (DRYvER). Research Ideas and Outcomes. https://doi.org/10.3897/rio.7.e77750.

    Krause et al. (2006) Multiscale investigations in a mesoscale catchment: hydrological modelling in the Gera catchment. Advances in Geosciences. doi:10.5194/adgeo-9-53-2006.

    Lange et Büchner (2021) ISIMIP3b bias-adjusted atmospheric climate input data (v1.1), ISIMIP Repository. doi:10.48364/ISIMIP.842396.1.

    van Pelt et al., (2012) Future changes in extreme precipitation in the Rhine basin based on global and regional climate model simulations. Hydrology and Earth System Sciences. doi:10.5194/hess-16-4517-2012.

     

    How to cite: Devers, A., Lauvernet, C., and Vidal, J.-P.: Using the advanced delta change approach and a distributed model for a rapid assessment of reach-scale streamflow projections in intermittent rivers, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3950, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3950, 2022.

    EGU22-4613 | Presentations | HS2.4.2

    Sensitivity of hydrological predictions to ecosystem adaptation in response to climate change: the effect of time-dynamic model parameters 

    Laurène J.E. Bouaziz, Emma E. Aalbers, Albrecht H. Weerts, Mark Hegnauer, Hendrik Buiteveld, Rita Lammersen, Jasper Stam, Eric Sprokkereef, Hubert H.G. Savenije, and Markus Hrachowitz

    Typically, the future hydrological behavior of a river basin, for example as a result of climate change, is predicted using hydrological models calibrated with historical observations. In reality, hydrological systems, and hence model parameters, experience almost continuous change in time and space. More specifically, there is growing evidence that vegetation adapts to changing conditions by adjusting its root-zone storage capacity, i.e. the amount of water in the unsaturated subsurface which is available to the roots of vegetation for transpiration. Additionally, other species may become dominant under natural and anthropogenic influence. In this study, we test the sensitivity of hydrological model predictions to changes in vegetation parameters that reflect ecosystem adaptation to climate and potential land-use changes. In other words, if the climate changes, how should our models change and what is the effect on the hydrological response? Our methodology directly uses projected climate data to estimate how vegetation adapts its root-zone storage capacity at the catchment scale to changes in hydro-climatic variables and potential land-use change. We test the hypothesis that changes in the hydrological response under global warming are more pronounced when explicitly considering changes reflecting adaptation of the root-zone storage capacity of vegetation. We compare a stationary benchmark model with several non-stationary model scenarios reflecting climate and potential land-use changes in the Meuse basin. We found that the larger root-zone storage capacities (+34%) in response to warmer summers under projected +2K global warming result in up to -15% less streamflow in autumn due to up to +14% higher summer evaporation in the non-stationary scenarios compared to the stationary benchmark scenario. By integrating a time-dynamic representation of changing vegetation properties in hydrological models, we make a potential step towards more reliable hydrological predictions under change.

    How to cite: Bouaziz, L. J. E., Aalbers, E. E., Weerts, A. H., Hegnauer, M., Buiteveld, H., Lammersen, R., Stam, J., Sprokkereef, E., Savenije, H. H. G., and Hrachowitz, M.: Sensitivity of hydrological predictions to ecosystem adaptation in response to climate change: the effect of time-dynamic model parameters, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4613, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4613, 2022.

    EGU22-4777 | Presentations | HS2.4.2

    The effects of global warming on flood properties in small-medium Mediterranean catchments 

    Yair Rinat, Moshe Armon, and Efrat Morin

    Climate change impact on floods and water resources is crucial for planning adaptation strategies. This is especially true in Mediterranean regions where a decrease in precipitation and an increase in extreme rain rates are projected.  Global climate models and common hydrological models are often too coarse to represent rainfall properties and hydrological processes in these regions due to their scale. Therefore, the current understanding of climate change's impact on hydrological properties and processes in Mediterranean catchments is missing. To resolve this, we utilize the high-resolution (1 km2) weather research and forecasting (WRF) model (abstract #EGU22-1996). Rainfall simulations were input to a distributed hydrological model (<60 s, 100 m2 GB-HYDRA). Explicitly, we apply spatially-shifted ensemble results for 41 couples of heavy precipitation events in historic (end of 20th century) and future (end of 21st century; RCP 8.5 scenario) climate conditions to 4 small-medium-size basins (18–69 km2) in the eastern Mediterranean. Ensemble average total precipitation decreased by 24% between historic and future events. This resulted in an average decrease in outlet peak discharge (-20%, non-significant), and a significant drop in the total flood volume (-27%) in future events. This change can be attributed to a significant (-25%) decrease in runoff contributing area (RCA); hillslope sections from which water flows, reaches the stream network, and consequently, the basin outlet and significant decrease of the averaged rainfall rates over them (-22%). The results of this study suggest that ongoing climate change in Mediterranean regions is expected to have a considerable impact on the flow regime, and thus, practical actions should be taken.

    How to cite: Rinat, Y., Armon, M., and Morin, E.: The effects of global warming on flood properties in small-medium Mediterranean catchments, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4777, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4777, 2022.

    EGU22-5757 | Presentations | HS2.4.2

    Assessing Future Climate and Land Use Impacts to the Colorado River using a Bottom-up Modelling Approach Informed by Water Managers 

    Kristen Whitney, Enrique Vivoni, Zhaocheng Wang, and Giuseppe Mascaro

    Accelerated climate and land use land cover (LULC) changes are anticipated to have large impacts on water resources in the Colorado River Basin (CRB). Since land use is a result of complex socio-ecological factors, accurately predicting future patterns of LULC is challenging. In addition, substantial differences among a large number of climate models necessitate a screening process for impact and adaptation studies. As a result, limitations of conventional ‘top-down’ approaches are becoming increasingly apparent. More recently, ‘bottom-up’ assessments are gaining popularity for exploring climate and LULC conditions using a few selected cases that consider a range of possibilities. Here, we improved and employed the Variable Infiltration Capacity (VIC) model to generate streamflow projections across the CRB under multiple cases of climate and LULC changes. We integrated advances in the model using Landsat- and MODIS- based products to produce more realistic land surface conditions. Meteorological datasets were drawn from statistically downscaled projections (2006-2099) to represent ‘hot and dry’ and ‘warm and wet’ futures. Vegetation parameters were modified by using regional projections of a LULC model upon which more drastic disturbances were applied to forest cover types. Water managers in the CRB were consulted to ensure that a range of views were captured in the modeled storylines and to maximize the legitimacy and credibility of the research for decision-makers. Analyses were conducted to identify system vulnerabilities and unexpected outcomes that pose the greatest consequences to long-term water supplies in the CRB. Results indicated that forest disturbances partially offset warming effects to streamflow (basin-wide mean annual streamflow was up to 9% larger than the case without disturbance by end of century), allowing more neutral impacts under warming.

    How to cite: Whitney, K., Vivoni, E., Wang, Z., and Mascaro, G.: Assessing Future Climate and Land Use Impacts to the Colorado River using a Bottom-up Modelling Approach Informed by Water Managers, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5757, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5757, 2022.

    EGU22-6710 | Presentations | HS2.4.2 | Highlight

    Assessing patterns of future hydrological change for Australia: insights from the National Hydrological projections 

    Ulrike Bende-Michl, Louise Wilson, Wendy Sharples, Alison Oke, Pandora Hope, Vjekoslav Matic, Margot Turner, Zaved Khan, Greg Kociuba, and Elisabetta Carrara

    As one of the world’s driest continents, Australia’s water resources need to be carefully managed to ensure sustainable access to water for livelihoods, human well-being, and ecosystem health. Australia is also a land of extremes from floods to droughts and catastrophic wildfires which are all becoming more frequent and destructive. It is essential to understand future changes in water availability and hydrologic extremes to support the development of mitigation strategies and the planning for water infrastructure and policies. To build this understanding, the Bureau of Meteorology has released the Australian Water Outlook (AWO), a seamless national landscape water service. The AWO includes National Hydrological Projections, as well as seasonal forecast and historical products, all using the Bureau’s Australian Water Landscape Water Balance model (awo.bom.gov.au).

    Projection results feature many sources of uncertainty, including how future greenhouse gas emissions will develop, how a changing climate will lead to changes to hydrological features and feedback loops, and the climate and hydrological models used to simulate those changes. Acknowledging these uncertainties, the Bureau's National Hydrological Projections ensemble provides a unique opportunity to examine impacts of future changes on Australia’s hydroclimate and its water resources. It allows nationally consistent impact assessments across multiple spatial and temporal scales. To produce these projections, three bias-correction approaches were used as well as a regional downscaling model. These methods were in turn applied to four global climate models in an operational framework resulting in a nationally consistent future change dataset for climate (rainfall, solar radiation, temperature, and wind) and hydrological (soil moisture, evapotranspiration, and runoff) variables. 

    An overview of the National Hydrological Projections methods and results, including a series of 8 regional water resource assessment reports, will be presented. The reports were created to facilitate understanding and use of the data and describe future changes in regional hydrology using a novel storyline approach. The storyline approach is used to improve the communication of plausible impacts to Australia's future water availability. Plausible futures portend a drier climate for large parts of Australia which could pose challenges for future water resource management.

    How to cite: Bende-Michl, U., Wilson, L., Sharples, W., Oke, A., Hope, P., Matic, V., Turner, M., Khan, Z., Kociuba, G., and Carrara, E.: Assessing patterns of future hydrological change for Australia: insights from the National Hydrological projections, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6710, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6710, 2022.

    EGU22-6866 | Presentations | HS2.4.2

    How does the performance of rainfall-runoff models degrade due to multi-annual drought? A large-sample, multi-model study. 

    Luca Trotter, Margarita Saft, Murray Peel, and Keirnan Fowler

    We studied the effect of a 13-year long dry period on the performance of five conceptual rainfall-runoff models in 155 catchments in the Australian state of Victoria in order to identify (1) which aspects of the flow regime are harder for models to reproduce during and after the drought; and (2) how model performance during this persistent drought compares to that during similarly dry individual years in the historical record. Persistent dry conditions in recent decades have affected hydrological processes and water partitioning in several regions globally; given the increased risk of drought posed by climate change, studying these historical long-lasting droughts and their effects on model reliability can inform climate adaptation strategies in many drought-prone regions worldwide.

    The Millennium drought (MD), which affected more than 1×106 km2 of south-eastern Australia between 1997-2009, is one of such events and arguably the most reported on in literature. Research to date identifies significant shifts in catchment-level annual rainfall-runoff relationships in most catchments affected by the MD, many of which have failed to recover several years after the end of the meteorological anomaly. These shifts affect the reliability of models’ projections; however, by focusing on a handful of performance metrics only, currently published research falls short on identifying which specific aspects of model performance are affected and how.

    Here, we focused on a wider range of performance metrics to assess models’ ability to represent a variety of aspects of the hydrograph and the flow-duration curve during and after the MD. For objective (1), we used a statistical metric derived from Wilcoxon signed-rank test (known as matched-pairs rank-biserial correlation coefficient) to compare changes in model performance during and after the drought from a pre-drought benchmark across metrics and catchments. For objective (2), we analysed changes in the relationship between annual model performance and annual rainfall using a regression technique.

    We observed extensive degradation of model performance during the drought across most of the metrics studied. Overestimation of flow volumes drives the decline, while representation of shape and variability of the hydrograph and the flow-duration curve are more resilient to prolonged drought. This means that volumes’ overestimation is not associated to specific flow regimes, but results from flow declining proportionally throughout the hydrograph, suggesting that multiple catchment processes interact to cause the observed changes across high and low flows as well as through faster and slower routes. We obtained very similar results in the decade after the drought, indicating that model performance, similarly to rainfall-runoff relationships, often does not recover after the dry spell ends. Additionally, regression analysis of annual performance and rainfall showed disproportional decline of model reliability during the multi-year event compared to single dry years before the drought, suggesting that the persistency of the drought is likely responsible for exacerbated performance decline due to accumulation and aggravation of errors over subsequent dry years.

    How to cite: Trotter, L., Saft, M., Peel, M., and Fowler, K.: How does the performance of rainfall-runoff models degrade due to multi-annual drought? A large-sample, multi-model study., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6866, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6866, 2022.

    This study tends to attribute the spatial patterns of hydrologic alteration in mid-latitude montane basins to the key driving forces being the climate and land use change. Physically-based distributed modeling system MIKE SHE was used for the analysis of changing spatiotemporal patterns of extreme runoff processes in montane catchments by using time series of hydrometeorological  observations, and spatially distributed MODIS data for evapotranspiration (ET) and leaf area index (LAI) as key resources for the model setup.

    Czech Republic is surrounded by mountain ranges from all sides but the southeastern border, which is drained towards the Danube. Due to this concentric orientation of topography each mountain range has different aspect and exposition due to atmospheric processes. Does the basin hydrological reaction on changing the environment depend on the aspect or is there an overall trend present in all basins? In order to answer such a question, it is necessary to understand the main drivers of changes and to quantify the effect of each separately. 

    8 headwater basins were analyzed of average size of 73 km2 where significant trends of hydrologic processes were detected from long-termed time series (1952 to 2018). Some of the trends are common for all basins such as seasonal shift of snowmelt period but other trends are rather site specific such as frequency of peak flows. Previous studies show that the hydrologic reaction on climate signal is the most dominant driver of the hydrologic alterations however there are other drivers such as forest disturbances that can mislead the interpretation of trend behavior. 

    The aim of the study was to separate the effects of those main drivers by a detailed distributed physically-based modeling system MIKE SHE. Input data originated from official and publicly available sources in order to design a methodology that could be reproduced in other basins of comparable properties. Models are bent together thus results of similar spatial-temporal quality were obtained for further analysis. Stational data but also remote sensed data in the grid format were gathered in a comprehensive database. 

    Two groups of scenarios were applied. First group was focused on climate signals (namely trends in precipitation, mean daily temperature and potential evapotranspiration) and the second group included land use changes such as bark beetle outbreak. Effect of both groups was quantified and compared with baseline simulation across all basins.

    The model proved the long-term shifts in runoff seasonality, driven by the air temperature rise, and apparent across the mountain ranges. The seasonal runoff changes are marked by the shift of spring snowmelt toward an earlier season and a decline in spring flows. The second aspect of the changing seasonality is an earlier and prolonged period of summer low flows.

    The results proved the dominancy of climate change as a main factor of runoff alteration, acting in large scale patterns, despite the local variations in physiography and land use.

    How to cite: Bernsteinová, J. and Langhammer, J.: Attributing the spatial patterns of hydrological change to the effects of climate and land use change by distributed modelling, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7753, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7753, 2022.

    EGU22-8141 | Presentations | HS2.4.2

    Assessment of water provision under different future land use scenarios in the Cauquenes Catchment, Chile.  

    Aaron Grau-Neira, Daniela Manuschevich, Mauricio Galleguillos, Mauricio Zambrano-Bigiarini, and Rodrigo Marinao

    The landscape of south-central Chile, originally a mosaic of pristine native forests and crops, has been converted into tree plantations and agroindustry. Farmlands and native forests have undergone a rapid conversion to fast-growing non-native pine and eucalyptus plantations, as well as irrigated fruits production for international exports. These two drivers have severely transformed the socio-ecological system, resulting in less biodiversity, more erosion, emigration and work depence, less drinking water, and a fire-prone landscape. A participatory approach helps not only to visualise tensions in the territory, but it is also useful for stakeholders to explore the possible environmental futures. However, frequently the development of land-use scenarios is mostly based on the views of experts and policymakers, missing out a wealth of local knowledge about the environment which experts seek to comprehend. 

    This work aims at quantifying the impacts of the aforementioned land cover changes in water provision for the population and ecosystems, by incorporating the views of the people that still live in a drought-prone rural area in the construction of different narratives representing future land management scenarios. The study area is the Cauquenes River Basin, a mediterranean catchment located in central Chile, historically known for wine production and rainfed agriculture. To develop the narratives, we conducted semi-structured interviews to collect and analyse qualitative information using a coding system systematised in the Atlas.ti software. Using 2050 as the simulation target year, narratives gave us the guidelines to develop the spatial scenarios. Then, using an open-source land use change model- called CLUE-s we constructed scenarios of future land use change. The CLUE-s algorithm allocates land uses based on the suitability of each land use as well as spatial regulations. To assess the impact on water provision of each scenario, they were evaluated using a hydrological model (SWAT+).

    Our results identified two different narratives: i) rural development: where water availability could increase, if a protection strip is established near water courses, that is, scrublands and native forest are assigned in these areas and, rainfed agriculture is strengthened and reach the extension it had in 1990 and ii) agro-industrial development, in which the central government promotes irrigated agriculture for international export markets, at the same time, passive preservation plans for protect native forest are applied according to the current forestry regulation. We expect that this participatory approach will enrich and strengthen adaptive management capacity at the local level, to be able to face the challenges ahead presented by a drier future.

    How to cite: Grau-Neira, A., Manuschevich, D., Galleguillos, M., Zambrano-Bigiarini, M., and Marinao, R.: Assessment of water provision under different future land use scenarios in the Cauquenes Catchment, Chile. , EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8141, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8141, 2022.

    EGU22-8143 | Presentations | HS2.4.2 | Highlight

    Regional hydrological response to climate change across Sweden - impact modelling and communication 

    Rene Capell, Jude Musuuza, Peter Berg, Thomas Bosshard, and Göran Lindström

    Changes in climatic forcing will change regional hydrological responses, both long-term seasonal dynamics and extreme events. Impact assessments are urgently needed by decision makers for climate adaptation planning, despite the uncertainties in the impact model chain. Therefore, uncertainties in impact assessments need to be evaluated and communicated along with the actual results in a transparent and user-friendly way.

    Here, we show results from a hydrological climate impact study for Sweden, which is communicated to regional planners through a web-based assessment tool (smhi.se/en/climate/future-climate/advanced-climate-change-scenario-service/hyd). Climate change impacts are expected to alter seasonal hydrological dynamics as well as hydrological extremes in the region. We use a modelling framework based on a calibrated national hydrological model, S-HYPE, which divides the domain into  ~ 35000 computational sub-basins, for which hydrological states and fluxes are computed using a conceptual process model including lake and river management routines. S-HYPE is forced with an ensemble of Euro-CORDEX regional climate forcing for a 1971 to 2100 assessment period and representative concentration pathways 2.6, 4.5, and 8.5. All forcing is bias-corrected to a gridded reference forcing data set using quantile mapping. Results are communicated in a spatially aggregated form for ~ 250 river basins using climate impact indicators (CII), which highlight expected change patterns for specific parts of the hydrolgical cycle, e.g. change in maximum annual snow water equivalent or summer discharges. Uncertainties are communicated through ensemble spread and robustness measures, allowing users to directly assess at least parts of the uncertainty in the model results.

    We also use the modelled results for a comparative analysis of change impacts across river basins in Sweden, taking advantage of the north-south climate gradient across the domain. This allows for a direct comparison of modelled today and future behaviour of similar river basins across that gradient to evaluate the uncertainty in future impacts which orginate in the model representation of interactions and feedbacks between climate and hydrological system within the S-HYPE model framework.

    How to cite: Capell, R., Musuuza, J., Berg, P., Bosshard, T., and Lindström, G.: Regional hydrological response to climate change across Sweden - impact modelling and communication, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8143, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8143, 2022.

    EGU22-8434 | Presentations | HS2.4.2

    Are simpler models less robust? 

    Léonard Santos, Paul Royer-Gaspard, Alban de Lavenne, and Vazken Andréassian

    Among the properties that a wise modeler would desire for his or her own model is the capacity of extrapolation beyond known hydroclimatic conditions. Extrapolation capacity seems essential when a model is to be used to predict the impact of future conditions, which may not have occurred in the past (at least not during the calibration period). Hydrological good sense would let us imagine that the more complete the model, the better it should do in extrapolation. But because the wise should doubt even one’s good sense, we wish to test this hypothesis, starting with a series of extremely simple models, working at the annual time step:

    • the simplest of all annual models is a linear one, using only annual precipitation Pn as explanatory variable: Qn = a.Pn +b (Qn being streamflow for year n, a and b being calibrated parameters);
    • slightly more complex is a three-parameter linear model using both precipitation Pn and potential evaporation En as input: Qn = a.Pn +bEn + c;
    • slightly more complex is a non-linear model based on the Turc-Mezentsev formula (Andréassian & Sari, 2019);
    • again, more complex is a non-linear model based on the Catchment Forgetting Curves (CFC) accounting for the pluriannual catchment memory (de Lavenne et al., in review);
    • last, we use a much more complex daily time step hydrological model as reference.

    To answer our title question, we test the robustness of these models of increasing complexity using a dataset of 555 French catchments, a specific metric (PMR - Royer-Gaspard et al., 2021) and the robustness assessment test (RAT - Nicolle et al., 2021).

     

    References

    Andréassian, V. and Sari, T.: Technical Note: On the puzzling similarity of two water balance formulas – Turc-Mezentsev vs Tixeront-Fu. Hydrol. Earth Syst. Sci., 23, 2339-2350, 2019.

    de Lavenne, A., Andréassian, V., Crochemore, L., Lindström, G., and Arheimer, B.: Quantifying pluriannual hydrological memory with Catchment Forgetting Curves, Hydrol. Earth Syst. Sci. Discuss. [preprint], in review, 2021.

    Nicolle, P., Andréassian, V., Royer-Gaspard, P., Perrin, C., Thirel, G., Coron, L., and Santos, L.: Technical note: RAT – a robustness assessment test for calibrated and uncalibrated hydrological models, Hydrol. Earth Syst. Sci., 25, 5013–5027, 2021.

    Royer-Gaspard, P., Andréassian, V., and Thirel, G.: Technical note: PMR – a proxy metric to assess hydrological model robustness in a changing climate, Hydrol. Earth Syst. Sci., 25, 5703–5716, 2021.

    How to cite: Santos, L., Royer-Gaspard, P., de Lavenne, A., and Andréassian, V.: Are simpler models less robust?, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8434, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8434, 2022.

    EGU22-8676 | Presentations | HS2.4.2

    Climate change induced impacts on hydrological extremes at the catchment scale: case of Wadi Siliana (North western Tunisia) 

    Imen EL Ghoul, Fatma Tliha, Haykel Sellami, Kaoutar Mounir, Slaheddine Khlifi, and Marnik Vanclooster

    High and low flows are hydrological flow extremes threatening human being by causing floods and droughts. They are caused by meteorological extremes and human activities.  Changes in meteorological conditions will inevitably impact the frequency of hydrological extremes and exacerbate their associated hydrological impacts.

    This study focuses on modelling projected change in both frequency and magnitude of flow extremes as consequence to change in climate condition in the Siliana catchment in Tunisia. The SWAT and HBV hydrological models were calibrated using historical data and fed with an ensemble of high resolution CORDEX climate models. Results project a warmer and drier hydrometeorological conditions in the Siliana catchment. The precipitation is expected to decrease in the future by an average of 10% in dry season and 12% in wet season. In contrast, temperature is expected to increase by an average of +2°C in dry season and 1.8°C in wet period.

    The two models show that while magnitude and frequency of high flows are expected to decrease, low flows frequency is expected to increase which affirms that the Siliana catchment is likely to experience severe hydrological conditions with reduction in water availability and increase in drought frequency.

    How to cite: EL Ghoul, I., Tliha, F., Sellami, H., Mounir, K., Khlifi, S., and Vanclooster, M.: Climate change induced impacts on hydrological extremes at the catchment scale: case of Wadi Siliana (North western Tunisia), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8676, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8676, 2022.

    EGU22-9042 | Presentations | HS2.4.2

    Multi-year drought impacts on streamflow regimes 

    Ali Azarnivand, Ulrike Bende-Michl, Wendy Sharples, and Katayoon Bahramian

    Abstract:       With its highly variable climate, Australia is naturally susceptible to multi-year droughts. Previous studies have shown that Australia will, in future, experience longer and more severe droughts, especially across southern Australia. Extended periods of drought have been associated with hydrological changes, in particular streamflow  regimes including changes to the magnitude, frequency, duration, predictability or flashiness of streamflow (Kiem et al. 2016). Despite significantly impacting water availability across the world, links between multi-year drought effects on the hydrological responses of catchments and changing flow regimes are not well understood. This is an important issue since regime shifts from e.g., perennial to non-perennial, could be correlated to the variability in rainfall intensity and frequency, leading to changes in infiltration, excess overland flow and surface-subsurface connectivity.

    Our study aims to assess the effect of multi-year droughts on the streamflow regimes to inform future water resource management. We classify historical and current dominant streamflow regimes across Australia and explore whether the susceptibility of stream networks to perennialism under multi-year drought periods is likely to increase in the future. We first use Victoria as a case study region to improve collective knowledge on non-perennial rivers; their drivers, flow regime patterns and frequency of occurrence using the Australian Bureau of Meteorology (BoM)'s long-term hydrologic reference stations and a range of streamflow-based indicators. We analyse pre-drought states of streamflow regimes and explore whether they have shifted after the Millennium multi-year drought. We also investigate the major climatological and hydrological drivers that affect streamflow regime shifts, with a particular focus on those catchments which have shown to have shifted rainfall-runoff relationships resulting from the Millennium drought.

    References

    Kiem, A. S., and Coauthors, 2016: Natural hazards in Australia: droughts. Clim. Change, 139, 37–54.

    How to cite: Azarnivand, A., Bende-Michl, U., Sharples, W., and Bahramian, K.: Multi-year drought impacts on streamflow regimes, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9042, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9042, 2022.

    EGU22-9782 | Presentations | HS2.4.2

    Inter-comparison of climatological datasets for the hydrological modelling of six european catchments 

    Louise Mimeau, Annika Künne, Sven Kralisch, Flora Branger, and Jean-Philippe Vidal

    The H2020 project DRYvER (https://doi.org/10.3897/rio.7.e77750) on drying river networks and climate change aims at understanding the impact of climate change on intermittent rivers and ephemeral streams in six mesoscale river basins between 200~km² and 350~km² in different European countries (Croatia, Czech Republic, Finland, France, Hungary, Spain). 
    One of the objectives of the DRYvER project is to compare the evolution of streamflow intermittence under climate change in the six study areas.
    To do so we are developing a common modelling framework, using the distributed and physically based hydrological model J2000 (Krause et al., 2006), which is able to represent processes at the reach scale, and therefore, simulate flow intermittence at a high spatio-temporal resolution.

    A challenge here is to use a climate forcing dataset (precipitation and temperature) that has a sufficiently large coverage to cover all the catchment case studies, but that also accurately represents the spatial and temporal variability of the meteorological variables in order to accurately simulate the local hydrological response.

    In this study, we analyze the impact of using datasets with global or European coverage (ERA5-land, WFDE5, UERRA-MESCAN, E-obs) versus using local observed data or local gridded datasets (e.g. SAFRAN reanalysis for France, Nordic Gridded Climate Dataset for Finland).
    First, we compare the climate datasets at the catchment scale, and then analyze the impact of using them on the simulated runoff.
    Results show variable differences between the datasets for the six catchment case studies, with larger gaps in mountain basins with a larger range of elevations.

    This work has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement no. 869226.

    How to cite: Mimeau, L., Künne, A., Kralisch, S., Branger, F., and Vidal, J.-P.: Inter-comparison of climatological datasets for the hydrological modelling of six european catchments, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9782, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9782, 2022.

    The widely-used Budyko framework synthesizes the competition between water and energy availability simply using climatological mean precipitation (P) and potential evaporation (PE). While PE within the Budyko framework is often regarded as the atmospheric evaporative demand (AED), AED can substantially differ from PE assuming ample water availability due to its responsive behavior to soil moisture. This could violate the independence assumption between P and PE underpinning the Budyko framework, potentially leading to ill-posed parameterization of land-surface properties. Here, we showed that the use of AED as PE in a Budyko equation could significantly disturb a global runoff sensitivity assessment to climatic and land-property changes. By linking a two-parameter Budyko equation and the complementary evaporation principle (CEP), we found that climatic changes play a more important role in altering runoff than a prior assessment would suggest. This study also suggests that linking the Budyko equation with CEP can isolate the responsiveness of AED to soil moisture, allowing more proper consideration of surface energy balance.

    How to cite: Kim, D. and Chun, J. A.: Linking the Budyko framework with the complementary evaporation principle for proper consideration of surface energy availability, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10695, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10695, 2022.

    EGU22-11088 | Presentations | HS2.4.2

    Long-term differential water level responses of a group of tropical maar lakes in a semi-arid basin (Cuenca Serdán Oriental, México) 

    Raúl Alberto Silva Aguilera, Oscar Escolero, and Javier Alcocer

    Global change has different effects on inland water bodies. In the case of lakes, the water level is a variable frequently affected. Lakes in semi-arid zones are susceptible to climatic and anthropic forcing. Understanding how these factors modulate changes in lakes is essential to develop forecasts and generate management and conservation programs. However, lakes evolution under external forcing may differ despite belonging to the same system. The differences highlight the importance of developing particular management plans for each lake. Therefore, it is necessary to understand the factors that modulate these peculiarities. An example in central Mexico is the six maar lakes found in the easternmost basin of the Mexican Plateau, the Serdán Oriental Basin: Alchichica, Quechulac, La Preciosa, Atexcac, Tecuitlapa, and Aljojuca. Groundwater flow is essential in the water balances of these lakes. However, intensive groundwater exploitation for agriculture has occurred since the '80s in this semi-arid basin. Several studies have revealed that these lakes' trophic states, biota, and chemical compositions differ remarkably. Both locals and researchers have noted water-level declines in all lakes in recent decades. Water level evolution also seems to be particular in each lake. Data on the lakes water levels from 1960 to 1992 and subsequent changes are analyzed. We assessed physical (e.g., climatic, geological, hydrogeological, vegetation) and anthropic (land-use changes and groundwater exploitation) factors that could modulate the water level evolution differences. Time series analysis, remote sensing, and statistical methods were applied. This work represents a conceptual framework for further studies oriented to the numerical modeling of the lake system and the exploration of future change scenarios.

    How to cite: Silva Aguilera, R. A., Escolero, O., and Alcocer, J.: Long-term differential water level responses of a group of tropical maar lakes in a semi-arid basin (Cuenca Serdán Oriental, México), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11088, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11088, 2022.

    EGU22-11233 | Presentations | HS2.4.2

    Past and Future Climate Change Impacts on the Sustainability of a Wild Olive–based Heterogenous Ecosystem in Sardinia 

    Claudia Chessa, Roberto Corona, and Nicola Montaldo

    Mediterranean ecosystems are commonly heterogeneous savanna-like ecosystems, with contrasting plant functional types (PFTs, e.g., grass and woody vegetation) competing for the water use. At the same time the structure and function of the vegetation regulates the exchange of mass, energy and momentum across the biosphere-atmosphere interface, influencing strongly the soil water budget. Mediterranean regions suffer water scarcity due to (in part) natural influences, i.e., climate changes. Future climate scenarios are predicting further warmer conditions, increasing the uncertainty on the future of the water resources system of these regions.

    The objective is to investigate the role of the PFT vegetation dynamics on the soil water budget of a typical water-limited Mediterranean ecosystem in Sardinia, Italy, for both past and future climate conditions. The Sardinian site is characterized by strong heterogeneity, with wild olive trees coexisting dynamically with grass and bare soil, and a long database of land surface data is available from 2003, when an eddy covariance based tower was installed for estimating evapotranspiration, CO2 exchanges and energy fluxes. Sap flow of the wild olives (both in the trunk and in the roots), soil moisture, and leaf area index (LAI) are also measured. In water-limited conditions trees survive absorbing water from underlying fractured bedrocks through roots (hydraulic redistribution, HR). An ecohydrological model, based on the coupling of a land surface model (LSM) and a vegetation dynamic model (VDM) predicted the soil water balance, the tree and grass LAI, HR, and the dynamics of this sensitive ecosystem. The model was successfully tested for the case study, demonstrating model high performance for the wide range of eco-hydrologic conditions.

    Interestingly, from 2003 tree cover increased reaching an almost constant LAI (around 4) after six years, but the tree cover dramatically decreased in the last 4 years due to a dramatic drought in 2017, which significantly affected the tree sustainability. Indeed, the winter precipitation decreased in Sardinia, with a concomitant increase of air temperature during the spring and summer seasons.  Future climate scenarios predicted a further increase of air temperature and, therefore, of vapor pressure deficit (VPD), and a decrease of winter precipitation with a concurrent increase of rain extremes. We used the future climate scenarios predicted by Global climate models (GCM) in the Fifth Assessment report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). Hydro-meteorological scenarios are generated using a weather stochastic generator that allows simulation of hydrometeorological variables from GCM future scenarios. The use of the calibrated VDM-LSM allow to predict soil water balance and vegetation dynamics for the generated hydrometeorological scenarios. Results demonstrate that tree dynamics are strongly influenced by the inter-annual variability of atmospheric forcing, with tree density changing according to seasonal rainfall. At the same time the tree dynamics affected the soil water balance. We demonstrated that future warmer scenarios will impact wild olive trees, which could be not able to adapt to the increasing droughts. The decrease of tree cover will affect water resources and carbon balance of the heterogenous Mediterranean ecosystem.

    How to cite: Chessa, C., Corona, R., and Montaldo, N.: Past and Future Climate Change Impacts on the Sustainability of a Wild Olive–based Heterogenous Ecosystem in Sardinia, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11233, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11233, 2022.

    EGU22-11952 | Presentations | HS2.4.2

    Influence of land use and land cover change on natural flow variability: a case study of river Ramganga, India 

    Shivansh Shrivastava, Suresh Gurjar, Shakti Suryavanshi, and Vinod Tare

    The land use and land cover (LULC) change induces hydrologic variability in a catchment and studying this variability is central to efficient water management practice in a catchment. The assessment of the alteration in hydrological processes due to LULC change and its influence on overall river ecosystem functioning is even more pertinent to developing nations that face the issue of water scarcity and pollution. In this work, we investigate the influence of the LULC change over a period of ~40 years (1970-2013) on the variability of natural or virgin flow in the Ramganga river, a major tributary of the Ganga river, India. For LULC change data, object-based image classification was performed on high-resolution satellite imageries acquired for the Ramganga river basin – CORONA (1970) and LISS IV (2013) images. The natural or virgin flows (i.e., the flow in the river without regulation practices such as construction of dams or barrages) were estimated by performing hydrological modeling using the Soil and Water Assessment Tool (SWAT). Initially, the SWAT model was set up, calibrated, and validated for the present flow scenario (i.e. with all management practices present) using LULC data of the year 2013. Natural flows were derived by removing all interventions and keeping agricultural practices only rain-fed. Next, keeping all parameters unchanged, the LULC data of the year 2013 was replaced by the LULC data of the year 1970. This enabled us to study the effects of LULC change on river hydrology between the period 1970-2013. The model showed good agreement between the observed and simulated flows with R2 values of 0.82 for the calibration period (2002-2014) and 0.68 for the validation period (1990-1999). The Nash-Sutcliffe efficiency values were 0.81 and 0.66 for calibration and validation periods respectively. The comparison of LULC data between the study period (1970 and 2013) reveals that land cover classes of agriculture, built-up, mixed forest, barren land, shrubs and bushes, and water areas were altered by nearly 6%, 102%, -7%, -59%, -75%, and -2% respectively (‘-’ sign indicates decrement in the land cover area). The influence of this LULC change was evident in the results from the hydrological model. For the years 2002-2013 (calibration period), the natural flows estimated using the LULC map of 2013 at the basin outlet were observed to be higher by 3-12% compared to flows estimated using the LULC input of 1970. The estimates of mean monthly flows for the years 2002-2013 at the basin outlet reveal that while the natural flows estimated using the LULC map of 2013 were higher compared to flow estimates using the LULC map of 1970 for most of the months, the flows during the dry months (May-July) were observed to be lower for the former compared to the latter. Our work provides valuable insights into hydrological variability in a major sub-basin of the Ganga river induced due to LULC changes and we advocate that alterations associated with LULC must be incorporated into water management strategies.

    How to cite: Shrivastava, S., Gurjar, S., Suryavanshi, S., and Tare, V.: Influence of land use and land cover change on natural flow variability: a case study of river Ramganga, India, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11952, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11952, 2022.

    EGU22-12188 | Presentations | HS2.4.2

    Validation of Vegetation Biophysical Parameters at the Valencia Anchor Station in the Framework of Copernicus Sentinel-3 OLCI 

    Erika Albero-Peralta, Antonio Lidón, Inmaculada Bautista, Cristina Lull, Victor Asensi, and Ernesto López-Baeza

    The Valencia Anchor Station (VAS) is an Earth Observation super site run by the University of Valencia, where a fair number of satellite remote sensing missions are validated. Within the framework of the Joint ESA-EUMETSAT “OLCI Land Validation (OLCI-Land-Val)” project, and of the Joint Research Center Ground-Based Observations for Validation (GBOV) of Copernicus Global Land Products, the Climatology from Satellites Group (GCS) has installed a total of 16 FAPAR (Fraction of Absorbed Photosynthetic Active Radiation) stations over a large vineyard area, where the GCS has carried out an extended number of field campaigns following the vine phenological cycle to validate the relevant parameters related to chlorophyll and N2 content, LAI (Leaf Area Index), surface temperature and soil moisture together with the Sentinel-3-A and -B more OLCI-specific products OLCI FAPAR and OTCI (OLCI Terrestrial Chlorophyll Index).

    This presentation shows the work carried out from the design and assembly of the FAPAR fixed stations, and the data series processed for the entire study period (2016-2021), to the different observations and validations carried out during the intensive observation campaigns. carried out in the area. Specifically, the data collection carried out consists of measurements using the SPAD 502 Plus Chlorophyll Meter which instantly measures the chlorophyll content or “greenness” of the plants, and whose calibration is carried out by means of cold extraction in the laboratory. These measurements are also used for the validation of the OTCI product obtained from Sentinel-3, as well as for its correlation with the continuously measured FAPAR and with the corresponding Sentinel-3 OLCI FAPAR product. Additionally, LAI data are included to establish the vegetation cover as well as soil moisture content and radiative surface temperature as a reference for the hydric stress conditions suffered by the vegetation.

    At the same time, a study of the vegetation cover has been carried out on the study area using the products MCD15A3H, MCD12Q1-2 and MOD-MYD13, to establish a soil correction of the data collected at the plant level.

    This leads to results where FAPAR and chlorophyll can be observed at three different levels, namely, in-situ plant, in-situ 300m x 300m with correction for the influence of the soil and satellite data. This research is important as a starting point in the validation of new indices with greater physical foundation and as confirmation of the robustness of the sensors on board the Sentinel 3-A, -B satellites for the continuity of the programme.

    How to cite: Albero-Peralta, E., Lidón, A., Bautista, I., Lull, C., Asensi, V., and López-Baeza, E.: Validation of Vegetation Biophysical Parameters at the Valencia Anchor Station in the Framework of Copernicus Sentinel-3 OLCI, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12188, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12188, 2022.

    EGU22-12551 | Presentations | HS2.4.2

    Change in Climate Impact Assessment from CMIP5 to CMIP6 in a High-Mountaineous Catchment of Central Asia 

    Timo Schaffhauser, Stefan Lange, Ye Tuo, and Markus Disse

    In this study we investigated the impacts of climate change on a large nivo-glacial river basin (Naryn Basin) in Central Asia (Kyrgyzstan) using two different families of General Circulation Models (GCMs). Hence, we use the widely used ISIMIP2 (Inter-Sectoral Impact Model Intercomparison Project) data which is based on the GCMs of the 5th stage of the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project (CMIP5), as well as the newly derived ISIMIP3 data, which uses the latest GCM data from phase 6 of CMIP (CMIP6) to drive a hydrological model (Soil Water Assessment Tool - SWAT). As both sources of forcing (ISIMIP2 & ISIMIP3) show considerable differences in multiple aspects such as used GCM family, projections, bias-adjustment technique and reference dataset, we evaluate and compare the individual projected changes of both generations on different variables of the hydrological cycle, such as snowmelt, evapotranspiration and soil moisture. In order to quantify the uncertainty contribution of different components along the modelling chain we perform a sensitivity analysis using an ANOVA (Analysis of Variance) approach. Hereby, it is intended to reveal which source (CMIP phase, GCMs, scenario) can be attributed the largest contribution. Results show that significant differences in the impact assessment can occur depending on the
    CMIP generation. It is also shown that the CMIP phase has a high contribution to the total uncertainty estimates. However, in a next step special ephasize is put on the improvement of nivo-glacial processes, which will be performed by an improvement of the hydrological model SWAT, by integrating a glacier module which accounts for not only for glacier mass balance changes but also considers glacier recession and to a limited degree  potential advance.

    How to cite: Schaffhauser, T., Lange, S., Tuo, Y., and Disse, M.: Change in Climate Impact Assessment from CMIP5 to CMIP6 in a High-Mountaineous Catchment of Central Asia, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12551, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12551, 2022.

    EGU22-12742 | Presentations | HS2.4.2

    Explaining rainfall runoff changes associated with the Millennium Drought 

    Keirnan Fowler, Murray Peel, Tim Peterson, Margarita Saft, and Rory Nathan and the additional coauthors listed below

    Australia's Millennium Drought (1997-2010) was a multi-year event notable for causing persistent shifts in the relationship between rainfall and runoff in many catchments.  Here, we describe a multi-disciplinary eWorkshop held in late 2020 to discuss the hydrology of the Millennium Drought and explore the hydrological processes leading to the hydrological shifts.  Research to date has successfully characterised where and when shifts occurred, explored which catchment attributes are statistically related to the shifts, and noted changes in rainfall partitioning.  However, a physical explanation for the changes in catchment behaviour is still lacking, hence the need for this workshop.  

    Integrating perspectives from hydrogeology, ecohydrology, remote sensing, hydroclimatology, experimental hydrology and hydrological modelling, the workshop aimed to share and discuss “perceptual models” of flow response that could explain the Millennium Drought streamflow observations, considering both the spatial and temporal patterns of hydrological shifts. We considered a range of perceptual models of flow response, and then evaluated the models against available evidence. The models consider climatic forcing, vegetation, soil moisture dynamics, groundwater, and anthropogenic influence. Perceptual models were assessed both temporally (e.g. why was the Millennium Drought different to previous droughts?) and spatially (e.g. why did rainfall-runoff relationships shift in some catchments but not in others?). 

    The results point to the unprecedented length of the drought (10+ years) as the primary climatic driver, paired with interrelated groundwater processes: declines in groundwater storage, reduced recharge associated with vadose zone expansion/drying, and reduced connection between subsurface and surface water processes.  An additional contributor is increased evaporative demand, and minor contributors may include farm dams, salinity recovery, and drainage via regional groundwater systems.  The roles of deep-rooted vegetation, wildfire, rainfall patterns, and land use change, among others, were discounted on various grounds.  

    There is a need to confirm these landscape-scale evaluations with local long-term field monitoring, particularly of subsurface dynamics, faced with a lack of such monitoring during the drought itself.  A decline in monitoring meant that many variables went unmeasured that could have aided diagnosis.  Thus, the drought provides an example to other countries of the value of continued investment, particularly to build up and retain multi-decadal records in as many sites and variables as possible.  We strongly recommend investment in understanding of hydrological shifts through such monitoring, which is particularly important given the relevance of hydrological shifts to water planning under climate variability and change. 

    How to cite: Fowler, K., Peel, M., Peterson, T., Saft, M., and Nathan, R. and the additional coauthors listed below: Explaining rainfall runoff changes associated with the Millennium Drought, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12742, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12742, 2022.

    EGU22-12824 | Presentations | HS2.4.2

    Modelling effects of changing rainstorm size-frequency on annual interception and catchment water budgets in Sabah, Malaysian Borneo 

    Rory Walsh, Kawi Bidin, Arina Safjankova, and Anand Nainar

    Evaluating likely hydrological consequences of predicted and current actual climatic change is a complex challenge, not only because of uncertainties about societal, land-use and vegetational responses and feedbacks, but also because lack of information on some climatic variables that influence hydrological processes.  With a focus on the humid tropics, this paper addresses the influence of changes in rainstorm size-frequency on the interception component of evapotranspiration - and how this can in turn influences the nature and magnitude of impact of rainfall change on catchment water budgets.  This is critical for two reasons.  First, both climatic modelling predictions and current trends for annual rainfall in the humid tropics vary greatly between regions from significant increases to major declines.  Second, because of the ability of a warmer atmosphere to hold more water vapour, IPCC confidently predicts that extreme rainstorms worldwide will increase regardless of annual rainfall trends and it is also arguable that rainstorms in general will increase in intensity and storm total. Thus changes in rainstorm size-frequency distribution are to be expected.   

    This paper focuses on the primary and disturbed equatorial rainforest environment of Sabah, Malaysian Borneo.  The paper (1) uses long-term daily rainfall series at four stations in Sabah (from 1906 for Sandakan, Tawau and Kota Kinabalu; and from 1985 for Danum) to assess the magnitude of recent changes in rainstorm size-frequency distribution in Sabah and (2) presents and uses a simple Excel-based model to translate these data into estimated changes in interception (and also total evapotranspiration and river flow).  The underlying principle of the model is that Interception (as a percentage of storm rainfall) falls with increasing storm size, as interception storage capacity is filled.  Results of previous rainforest interception studies (including by one of the authors at Danum in Sabah) are used to calibrate the model, whereby percentage interception reduces in steps from 100 % for storms of < 1 mm and 80 % for storms of 1-2 mm, to 13.6 % for storms of 10-14.9 mm and the interception capacity of 2.2 mm (5.5 % or less) for storms of >40 mm.  It follows that annual interception, both in mm and as a percentage of annual rainfall, will be much greater if most rainstorms are small, but progressively lower as the percentage of rain falling in big storms increases.  Differences in rainstorm size-frequency distribution help to account for the big range (7-27 % of annual rainfall) in annual interception found between different rainforest locations.  The Pico presentation first presents the model and demonstrates the magnitude by which simulated annual interception values vary between individual years of contrasting annual rainfall and rainstorm size-frequency distribution at the four locations.  Then the temporal changes in daily rainfall size-frequency at the four stations are presented and compared and  (using model outputs) changes in seasonal and annual interception and other water budget variables are assessed.  Finally, problems with, possible improvements to, and the wider applicability of the approach adopted are discussed.       

    How to cite: Walsh, R., Bidin, K., Safjankova, A., and Nainar, A.: Modelling effects of changing rainstorm size-frequency on annual interception and catchment water budgets in Sabah, Malaysian Borneo, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12824, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12824, 2022.

    EGU22-13013 | Presentations | HS2.4.2

    Towards Understanding Evapotranspiration Shifts Under a Drying Climate 

    Hansini Gardiya Weligamage, Keirnan Fowler, Tim Peterson, Margarita Saft, Dongryeol Ryu, and Murray Peel

    Around 60 percent of terrestrial precipitation on the global average transforms into evapotranspiration. However, reliable estimation of actual evapotranspiration (AET) is challenging as it depends on multiple climatic and biophysical factors. Despite developments such as remotely sensed AET products, AET responses to prolonged drought is still poorly understood. Therefore, this study focuses on understanding long-term changes and variability of AET prior to and during the Millennium Drought in Victoria, Australia. We also investigate the capability of commonly used rainfall-runoff models to simulate AET under multiyear droughts. Therefore, we employ simple sensitivity analysis to examine four different water balance approaches between pre-drought and drought periods in six different study catchments in Victoria. The first water balance approach is the simplest long-term water balance approach, partitioning long-term precipitation into evapotranspiration and runoff. The second water balance approach adopts a long-term change in storage to the water balance during the Millennium Drought by employing regional-scale change in GRACE estimates derived from Fowler et al. (2020). The third and fourth water balances are based on simulations from SIMHYD and SACRAMENTO. Surprisingly, the adoption of long-term change in storage during the Millennium Drought indicates that the annual rates of pre-drought AET were largely maintained throughout the drought; i.e. the rate was relatively constant with time. This suggests that AET gets priority over streamflow following a drying shift in precipitation partitioning; resulting in a relatively constant AET under multiyear drought. In contrast, the rainfall-runoff models underestimated AET during the drought compared to both water balance approaches. These results broadly acknowledge the need for model improvements to provide more realistic AET estimates under future drying climates and provide a new perspective on recent hydrological phenomena such as changing rainfall-runoff relationships in these regions. Furthermore, this sensitivity analysis was augmented and confirmed by a regional-scale water balance approach.

    Keywords: Catchment water balance, Evapotranspiration, Change in storage, Rainfall-runoff models

    References: Fowler, K., Knoben, W., Peel, M., Peterson, T., Ryu, D., Saft, M., Seo, K.W., Western, A., 2020. Many Commonly Used Rainfall-Runoff Models Lack Long, Slow Dynamics: Implications for Runoff Projections. Water Resour. Res. 56. https://doi.org/10.1029/2019WR025286

     

    How to cite: Gardiya Weligamage, H., Fowler, K., Peterson, T., Saft, M., Ryu, D., and Peel, M.: Towards Understanding Evapotranspiration Shifts Under a Drying Climate, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13013, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13013, 2022.

    EGU22-2556 | Presentations | HS2.4.3

    The role of spatial rainfall variability for the emergence of heavy tails in streamflow distributions 

    Hsing-Jui Wang, Soohyun Yang, Ralf Merz, and Stefano Basso

    Heavy-tailed probability distributions of streamflow are frequently observed in river basins. In case of right skewed distributions, the larger probability assigned to relatively high flows translates into an unneglectable chance of occurrence of extreme floods in a long-term hydrological response. Although the spatial variability of rainfall has been identified as an impactful driver of flood events, delineating its effects for the emergence of heavy tails of streamflow distributions is still challenging.

    In this study we apply a simple stochastic approach to generate spatially various rainfall as the input of a well-established continuous hydrological model. The model embeds the soil water balance in hillslopes, the probability distributions of transit times in the hillslopes of subcatchments, and the response time distribution in channels derived from a geomorphological analysis of the river network. We investigate the role of spatially variable rainfall for the emergence of heavy tails in streamflow distributions by simulating a wide range of spatial rainfall variability in five catchments in Germany, and then put the modelling results into real world context by analyzing historical data in 175 catchments across the whole Germany.

    We find that increasing spatial variability of rainfall determines heavier streamflow tails only beyond a certain increase threshold which depends on physiographic features of catchments. Small and elongated catchments are less resilient to increasing spatial rainfall variability, i.e., their streamflow distributions begin to exhibit heavier tails for smaller increments of the spatial variability of rainfall. The distribution of runoff-routing pathway is suggested to be an effective attribute of catchments in this process.

    How to cite: Wang, H.-J., Yang, S., Merz, R., and Basso, S.: The role of spatial rainfall variability for the emergence of heavy tails in streamflow distributions, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2556, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2556, 2022.

    EGU22-3001 | Presentations | HS2.4.3

    Estimating Flood Peaks from Event Runoff Depth and Hydrograph Time Scales 

    Ross Woods, Yanchen Zheng, Roberto Quaglia, Giulia Giani, Dawei Han, Miguel Rico-Ramirez, and Gemma Coxon

    Flood estimation in ungauged basins is important for flood design, and for improving our understanding of the sensitivity of flood magnitude to changes in climate and land cover. Flood estimates by current methods (e.g. statistical regression, unit hydrograph) have high uncertainty, even in places with dense observing networks (e.g. +/- 50-100% in the UK). Reductions in this uncertainty are being sought by using alternative methods, such as continuous simulation using hydrological models (spatially-distributed or lumped), and event-scale derived distribution approaches. The very significant challenges for reliable application of continuous simulation models in ungauged catchments are well described in the literature.

    The research reported here is part of a larger project to estimate the probability distribution of flood peak magnitude in ungauged catchments, using an event-based derived distribution method. The derived distribution approach at the event scale typically combines the following elements: a stochastic rainfall model, an event-scale rainfall-runoff model (usually with “losses” and a “baseflow” component), and a runoff routing model. In principle, every element of this approach may be considered as a (seasonally varying) random variable, though previous research has typically considered only the rainfall as stochastic. The flood peak distribution is obtained by integrating over joint distributions of the model elements.

    One of the novel aspects of the proposed approach is that, in place of an explicit routing method, we estimate the flood peak magnitude as the ratio of the event runoff depth (mm) to a characteristic timescale of the hydrograph (hours). The event runoff depth is the product of rainfall depth and event runoff coefficient, which in turn depends on both antecedent conditions and event rainfall. The characteristic timescale of the hydrograph is a second temporal moment (temporal “width” of the hydrograph). Although a comprehensive theory exists for space-time influences on this hydrograph time scale, research to date suggests that it depends, to first order, on time scales associated with rainfall and catchment response.

    Here we report on extensive (many events, many catchments) testing in the UK of (i) whether the temporal standard deviation of the flow hydrograph is a good choice for the characteristic time scale of the hydrograph in the context of predicting the flood peak (Viglione et al 2010, Journal of Hydrology) (ii) whether the temporal standard deviation of the hydrograph can be predicted from time scales associated with rainfall and catchment response, as proposed by Woods and Sivapalan (1999, Water Resources Research) and Gaál et al (2012, Water Resources Research).

    How to cite: Woods, R., Zheng, Y., Quaglia, R., Giani, G., Han, D., Rico-Ramirez, M., and Coxon, G.: Estimating Flood Peaks from Event Runoff Depth and Hydrograph Time Scales, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3001, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3001, 2022.

    EGU22-3060 | Presentations | HS2.4.3

    The Physically-Based Extreme Value (PHEV) distribution of river discharges 

    Stefano Basso, Gianluca Botter, Ralf Merz, and Arianna Miniussi

    Reliable assessment of the flooding hazard of river basins is crucial for many social and economic activities. We present here the Physically-based Extreme Value (PHEV) distribution of river discharges. PHEV is a process-based alternative to empirical estimates and statistical methods hitherto used to characterize extremes of hydrometeorological variables. It arises from a description of key hydro-meteorological processes driving runoff production (e.g., precipitation inputs, evapotranspiration rates, soil moisture states and catchment responses) through solution of the master equation for the probability distribution of streamflow in a catchment. PHEV pairs physical understanding of the mechanisms producing extreme events and defining their chance of occurrence with an easily tractable mathematical descriptions of them, thus providing a theoretical underpinning to the study of manifold flood-related issues, such as the emergence of heavy tails in streamflow and flood distributions, flood rich and poor periods, and the reasons leading to the occurrence of extreme flood events.

    In this work we benchmark capabilities of PHEV for predicting odds and magnitudes of floods against a standard distribution and the latest statistical approach for extreme estimation. The methods are first applied to an extensive dataset to compare their skills for predicting observed flood quantiles in a wide range of case studies. Synthetic time series of streamflow, generated for select river basins from contrasting hydro-climatic regions, are later used to assess performances for rare events. The analyses outline the domain of applicability of PHEV and reveal less biased capabilities to estimate flood magnitudes with return periods much longer than the sample size used for calibration. Results also show reduced prediction uncertainty of PHEV for rare floods, notably if the flood magnitude-frequency curve displays an inflection point.

    Such discontinuities typically hinder estimation of high streamflow quantiles. PHEV reveals itself as a reliable tool to foresee their occurrence in a large set of case studies from the US and Germany, also when using shortened data series where the highest observations were removed. Case studies for which PHEV predicts the occurrence of an inflection point which is not visible in the empirical flood magnitude-frequency curve mostly belong to river flow regimes characterized by values weakly oscillating around their mean, which rarely exhibit extreme flow values by their nature. The limited length of the available data series might be thus constraining the possibility to observe extreme floods that shall be expected. These results indicate the possibility to reliably appraise the propensity of rivers to generate extreme floods by means of a process-based description of watershed dynamics, thus laying the foundation for a better comprehension of their physio-climatic controls.

    How to cite: Basso, S., Botter, G., Merz, R., and Miniussi, A.: The Physically-Based Extreme Value (PHEV) distribution of river discharges, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3060, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3060, 2022.

    EGU22-4086 | Presentations | HS2.4.3

    The importance of estuary shape in evaluating the flood risk in estuaries 

    Mirko Barada, Peter Robins, Matthew Lewis, and Martin Skov

    Floods are a constant threat to communities within and around estuaries worldwide. This is because several drivers may occur there at the same time which leads to the compound flooding (e.g. high river discharge + storm surge). In this study LISFLOOD-FP hydrodynamic model is applied to examine the efficiency of different management strategies on flooding in the Dyfi Estuary, in Mid Wales. Five different bathymetries, including the current one, were developed in ArcGIS and included in the analysis: a) “hold the line”, b) “remove the line”, c) “advance the line”, d) “retreat the line”, e) “breach in the line”. Modified November 2020 compound flood event boundary conditions were forced from the coast and from the Dyfi bridge. Model results shown, among other things, that nature-based solutions in the lower estuary, represented by salt marshes and floodplain restoration measures, have a great potential in reducing water elevations across the estuary, unlike the advance the line scenario or the current bathymetry.

    Additionally, results obtained from different management scenarios are analyzed and compared against results from the selected design storm events. These events were based on modifying parameters such as 1) relative timing of flood peaks, 2) storm duration and 3) climate change sensitivity (SLR and increase in discharge) which provided set of different compound flood events that were forced by LISFLOOD, in combination with the current estuary shape, unlike when modelling different management scenarios. This approach enabled us to perform an effective comparative analysis which addressed the key hypothesis of the research stating that changes in estuary shape will have bigger effect on flooding than changes in flood event itself. Indeed, it is shown that variability in water elevations caused by different management scenarios is bigger compared to variability caused by changing the boundary conditions only, although not always leading to higher water elevations along the estuary.

    How to cite: Barada, M., Robins, P., Lewis, M., and Skov, M.: The importance of estuary shape in evaluating the flood risk in estuaries, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4086, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4086, 2022.

    Dam design and safety assessment analyses require flood quantile estimates for high return periods up to 10000 years. However, systematic flood series are usually short with around 20-40 years, leading to high uncertainties. Historical information about floods is generally recognised as useful for estimating the magnitude of flood quantiles with return periods in excess of 100 years. Therefore, incorporating historical information in flood frequency analyses can reduce uncertainties and improve reliability of flood quantiles for high return periods. However, several techniques for incorporating historical information in flood frequency analyses have been proposed.

    This study presents a methodology to select the best technique to fit a flood frequency curve considering historical information. The methodology is based on a stochastic analysis that quantifies the accuracy and uncertainty for each technique. Monte Carlo simulations are used to generate synthetic flood series. Varying lengths of both historical and systematic periods are considered. The floods that exceed a given perception threshold are considered statistically as historical floods, regardless they occur in the systematic or historical period. A varying number of historical floods are also considered.

    Five streamflow gauging stations located in Spain are considered, where both systematic data and historical information are available. The analysis aims to find the best technique in each location in terms of flood quantile reliability and uncertainty reduction. It has been found that accuracy and uncertainty reduction in flood quantile estimates for each technique depend on the statistical properties of flood series.

    The results show that the maximum likelihood estimator (MLE) and weighted moments (WM) techniques are the best option in regions with a milder climate, where skewness in flood series is smaller. However, in regions with more extreme climates, where skewness of flood series increases, the biased partial probability weighted moments (BPPWM) and the unbiased partial probability weighted moments (UPPWM) techniques obtain the best results.

    Incorporating historical information about floods before the systematic period can improve the accuracy of flood quantile estimates, as well as reduce estimate uncertainties. The improvement is higher for shorter systematic periods and a greater number of historical floods available. In addition, historical information about floods can be crucial in arid regions where the greatest floods with low probability of occurrence are not usually recorded in the systematic period. The proposed methodology can be useful for reducing the uncertainty in design flood estimates for designing spillways and assessing hydrological dam safety.

    Acknowledgments: This research has been supported by the project SAFERDAMS (PID2019-107027RB-I00) funded by the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation.

    How to cite: Mediero, L., Jiménez, A., and Soriano, E.: Stochastic methodology to select the best technique to incorporate historical information in flood frequency analyses for dam safety assessment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4576, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4576, 2022.

    EGU22-5543 | Presentations | HS2.4.3

    A methodology to assess hydrological dam safety in dams with gated spillways under the effect of climate change. 

    Enrique Soriano Martín, Luis Mediero Orduña, Andrea Petroselli, Davide Luciano De Luca, and Salvatore Grimaldi

    Dam breaks can be driven by a flood that exceeds the design spillway capacity, causing important economic and human losses. Dam spillways are designed for a flood that is usually estimated through either hydrometeorological or statistical analyses with observed data. However, time series of observations are usually short, incomplete and recorded at a daily time step. Moreover, design floods have to be estimated for high return periods greater than 500 years, leading to high uncertainties. In addition, climate change is expected to increase the frequency and magnitude of floods in the future. Therefore, new methodologies are required to assess hydrological dam safety considering both short time series of observations and climate change.

    A stochastic methodology is presented here to assess hydrological dam safety considering the impact of climate change on floods, by integrating a stochastic rainfall generator and a rainfall-runoff model. The methodology is applied to the Eugui Dam on the Arga River in the north of Spain. The Eugui Dam has a draining catchment area of 69 km2, a reservoir volume of 22 hm3, and a gated spillway.

    First, the stochastic rainfall generator STORAGE (De Luca and Petroselli, 2021) based on the Neymann-Scott Rectangular Pulse Model has been used to simulate long time series of 500 years of precipitation with a time step of 15 minutes. The generator has been calibrated with rainfall observations. In addition, the STORAGE model has been used to generate synthetic time series of precipitation considering climate change. Delta changes extracted from precipitation projections of 12 climate models, three periods (2011-2040, 2041-2070, 2071-2100) and two emission scenarios (RCP 4.5 and RCP 8.5) are considered (Garijo and Mediero, 2019).

    Second, the stochastic precipitation time series are transformed into runoff time series by using the COSMO4SUB model (Grimaldi et al., 2021). COSMO4SUB is a continuous model that uses a high-resolution digital terrain model, land cover / soil type data, and precipitation supplied by the STORAGE model as input data, providing continuous runoff time series as output. The COSMO4SUB parameters have been calibrated with runoff observations by minimizing a set of objective functions.

    Third, annual maximum hydrographs, peak flows and hydrograph volumes are extracted from the runoff time series generated by COSMO4SUB. The Volume Evaluation Method (MEV) (Girón, 1988) is used to simulate the operation of spillway gates in flood events, obtaining maximum water levels in the reservoir and outflow hydrographs. The MEV method specifies when the spillway gates are opened and closed to reach the target reservoir water level at the end of the flood event. Hydrological dam safety at the Eugui Dam is assessed by analysing the frequency curve of maximum water levels in the reservoir for the 12 climate models, three return periods and two emission scenarios mentioned above. Therefore, the methodology proposed allows practitioners and dam owners to check the hydrological dam safety requirements detailed in the regulations, accounting for climate change.

    Acknowledgments: This research has been supported by the project SAFERDAMS (PID2019-107027RB-I00) funded by the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation.

    How to cite: Soriano Martín, E., Mediero Orduña, L., Petroselli, A., De Luca, D. L., and Grimaldi, S.: A methodology to assess hydrological dam safety in dams with gated spillways under the effect of climate change., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5543, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5543, 2022.

    EGU22-9872 | Presentations | HS2.4.3

    Detecting trends in flood series and shifts in flood timing across Kenya 

    Maureen Wanzala, Hannah Cloke, Elisabeth Stephens, Andrea Ficchi, and Shaun Harrigan

    The frequency and magnitude of flood events in Kenya have increased over the past decade. Observations show a shift in timing and variability in flood occurrences in most parts of the country. Trend analysis is useful in detecting and supporting the evidence of change in flow series, as well as variability in flood timing. In this study, the frequency and magnitude of floods observed in the annual maximum flood (AMAX) and peak over threshold (POT) flood series from 1981 to 2016 are compared in 19 Kenyan catchments. Flood peaks are identified using a threshold technique from Kenyan daily discharge data, and notable patterns in the AMAX series are compared to those in the POT series, which is created for three distinct exceedance criteria. The timing and variability of the annual floods is determined from the AMAX flow. Our findings show that, the AMAX series detects more trends in flood magnitude than the POT series, while the POT series detects more significant trends in flood frequency than flood magnitude. Sensitivity of trends to different exceedance thresholds selection reveal variable trend patterns across the stations. The timing of inter-annual floods occurs in peak rainfall months of April, May and November and shows a higher variability index in most of the coastal and western stations, and a low variability in stations whose annual floods occur in dry months of June, July, and August. This information is useful to hydrological applications such as flood protection facility design, risk assessment, and risk management for improved livelihoods in Kenya

    How to cite: Wanzala, M., Cloke, H., Stephens, E., Ficchi, A., and Harrigan, S.: Detecting trends in flood series and shifts in flood timing across Kenya, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9872, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9872, 2022.

    EGU22-11641 | Presentations | HS2.4.3

    More than just fast flowing water: the landscape impact of the July 2021 west Germany flood 

    Rainer Bell, Michael Dietze, Annegret Thieken, Kristen Cook, Christoff Andermann, Alexander Beer, Ana Lucia Vela, Johannes B. Ries, Maximilian Brell, Anette Eltner, Sigrid Roessner, Lothar Schrott, Thomas Iserloh, Manuel Seeger, and Ugur Öztürk

    Rain driven flash floods have severe impacts on society and landscape functions. The July 2021 flood in the Eifel region, west Germany, was one drastic example of such impact. While media and scientists rightfully highlighted the meteorological and hydrological aspects of this flood, it was the concurrent reorganisation of important landscape conditions and the debris carried by the fast flowing water that made this flood so devastating and unpredictable.

    Here, we take a process-based impact perspective and systematically ask, which were the specific roles of non-hydraulic but geomorphic dynamics that implemented the damage, caused flood non-linearities and amplified the landscape deterioration. We combine insights from field mapping campaigns during, right after and within the relaxation phase of the flood with high resolution geophysical and LiDAR surveys to discuss the role of hillslopes, vegetation, fluvial sediment mobilisation and the legacy of anthropogenic landscape reorganisation. We conclude that some of these elements emerged as the flood event evolved, causing either transient effects or persistent landscape features, thus modifying the response of the landscape to future events, also to less intense precipitation events.

    Our findings not only support more tailored recovery efforts for the flood affected Eifel catchments, but should also inform landscape development trajectories and potentially crucial factors in other Central European regions.

    How to cite: Bell, R., Dietze, M., Thieken, A., Cook, K., Andermann, C., Beer, A., Vela, A. L., Ries, J. B., Brell, M., Eltner, A., Roessner, S., Schrott, L., Iserloh, T., Seeger, M., and Öztürk, U.: More than just fast flowing water: the landscape impact of the July 2021 west Germany flood, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11641, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11641, 2022.

    EGU22-12637 | Presentations | HS2.4.3

    Multiple reservoirs impact on flood frequency curves: a new global and physically-based index 

    Stefano Cipollini, Aldo Fiori, and Elena Volpi

    The influence of the human activity (e.g. land use changes, alterations of the river system, hydraulic structures realization) on the flood frequency curves, represents a notable information to understand hydrologic changes identifying some of its drivers. In this work we provide a simple yet physically-based global index to assess the effect of multiple reservoirs, located in series along the main channel, on peak flood quantile at the catchment scale. The index formulation is based on an Instantaneous Unit Hydrograph (IUH) method, and it takes into account the main parameters of the system, such as the relative location and relative storage coefficient of the reservoirs, their number, and a climatic parameter. An analytical formulas of the index is provided, and it is independent of the return period. Numerical experiments and a comparison with the literature indices confirm the efficiency of the proposed index and allow to disentangle the role of the parameters on the flood peak reduction. Finally, we also present and discuss results of the index application for a real case study, that is the reservoirs system of the Tiber River (Central Italy).    

    How to cite: Cipollini, S., Fiori, A., and Volpi, E.: Multiple reservoirs impact on flood frequency curves: a new global and physically-based index, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12637, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12637, 2022.

    EGU22-13509 | Presentations | HS2.4.3

    Probabilistic regional envelope curves in Europe 

    Miriam Bertola, Attilio Castellarin, Elena Valtancoli, Alberto Viglione, and Günter Blöschl

    Regional envelope curves represent the current level of information about the most extreme flood events observed in a region. In this study, we derive and compare regional envelope curves across European regions, with a multi-scale approach. A large flood database, containing more than 7000 annual maximum discharge series from gauges located all over Europe, is used for the analysis. Multiple spatial scales are adopted to take into account the uneven gauge density in the study domain. In each region, we derive the slope of the regional envelope curve and the envelope flood for a representative catchment of size 1000km2. Based on the framework of probabilistic envelope curves, we also make a probabilistic statement about the regional envelope curves in terms of its return period. Results show that the slope of the regional envelope curves varies substantially across European regions and the correlation between envelope flood and the estimated return period is investigated.

    How to cite: Bertola, M., Castellarin, A., Valtancoli, E., Viglione, A., and Blöschl, G.: Probabilistic regional envelope curves in Europe, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13509, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13509, 2022.

    EGU22-93 | Presentations | HS2.4.4

    Event clustering approach for flood frequency analysis 

    Abinesh Ganapathy and Ankit Agarwal

    Design flood obtained under stationary conditions is obsolete in capturing the modulations induced by anthropogenic climate change. This leads researchers to employ the non-stationary approach to analyze the flood frequency. In that regard, hydroclimatic connections between extreme events and large scale climate drivers can be incorporated in flood frequency analysis by conditioning the distribution parameters with the climate covariates. However, more than one mechanism can drive floods, thus consideration of flood events as one category may neglect potential links or give rise to spurious connections. This necessitates the clustering of flood events based on its flood generating mechanisms to incorporate the climate drivers better. Therefore, this study focuses on grouping flood events based on the shape of hydrographs by using the time series clustering technique, based on the concept that the statistical shape of the flood hydrograph represents the hydrologic processes over the region. Germany, divided into three different streamflow regimes & driven by multiple flood mechanisms, is considered as the study area. Climate network is employed to identify the climate drivers of each cluster. The non-stationary flood frequency analysis is then carried out on the individual clusters using the identified climate covariates. Return flood values obtained from this study’s results are compared against the traditional stationary and climate conditioned non-stationary values. Thus, this study better represents the local/climate drivers' influence on the flood frequency at the changing climate conditions.

    How to cite: Ganapathy, A. and Agarwal, A.: Event clustering approach for flood frequency analysis, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-93, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-93, 2022.

    EGU22-128 | Presentations | HS2.4.4

    Historical increases in flood variability due to changing storm volumes and soil moisture 

    Conrad Wasko, Rory Nathan, Lina Stein, and Declan O'Shea

    Changes in flooding have substantial economic consequences. Increases in flooding increase economic losses while decreases in flooding increase water scarcity. Greater extreme rainfalls due to climate change are expected to cause greater flood magnitudes. This is particularly true for urban and developed catchments where there is a lack of impervious surfaces and surface water storage. However, in rural and undeveloped catchments historical trends are mixed, with many catchments experiencing decreases in flood magnitude.

    Here we argue the observed increase in flood variability is due to (1) changes in the extreme rainfall patterns and antecedent soil moisture conditions that drive flood response, and (2) the influence of event rarity on the interaction of these flood drivers. To investigate this hypothesis, we use 2776 stations from the Global Runoff Data Centre paired with rainfall and soil moisture from the Global Land Data Assimilation System. Flood events are chosen to isolate the flood driving rainfall volume, rainfall peak, and antecedent soil moisture, and trends are analysed in each of these variables alongside the subsequent flood peak. The analysis is limited to stations with 30 years or more of active record with the majority of stations in North America, Europe, Brazil, Oceania, and southern Africa.

    We find that, while peak rainfall magnitudes are increasing globally, storm volumes are not increasing as greatly, resulting in a decrease in storm durations. Antecedent soil moisture on the other hand is consistently drier across the world. The result is a mixed flood response that depends on the local climate and the event rarity. In temperate and cold regions of the world floods are generally increasing in magnitude – these increases are less for more frequent events (those expected to occur on average once per year) and greater for more rare events (those expected to occur once every 10 years). The increases in flood magnitude are consistently less than the increases in the peak rainfall and rainfall volume because of drying soils.

    In tropical and arid regions, there is a decline in flood magnitude for frequent flood events, with increases in flood magnitude only for the rarest events. This is because, in these regions, the antecedent moisture decreases outweigh the increase in rainfall. These results point to a worst of both world’s scenario where small floods, responsible for filling our water supplies, are decreasing, while the large flood events which pose a risk to life and infrastructure, are increasing.

    How to cite: Wasko, C., Nathan, R., Stein, L., and O'Shea, D.: Historical increases in flood variability due to changing storm volumes and soil moisture, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-128, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-128, 2022.

    EGU22-330 | Presentations | HS2.4.4

    Spatial analysis of major droughts in Seyhan River Basin, Turkey 

    Yonca Cavus, Kerstin Stahl, and Hafzullah Aksoy

    A particular location in a region may suffer from drought conditions while another may experience normal or even wet conditions. This study, therefore, performs spatial analysis using station-based monthly precipitation data for 19 meteorological stations over the Seyhan River basin in Turkey. Six major droughts each 2-year long at minimum were identified from the basin-average annual precipitation deficit. The Standardized Precipitation Index (SPI) was calculated for the meteorological stations at different time scales to characterize the severity and spatial extent of the major droughts. For the most severe month of each major drought, severities were interpolated over the river basin to form drought severity maps by using the Inverse Distance Weighted (IDW) technique. The study illustrates that the river basin experienced drought at least once every decade, which can be as severe as to impact the region and the whole country. Drought severity does not vary greatly over the river basin and it decreases with increasing accumulation time scales. The distribution of the most severe droughts changes depending on the characteristics of the major drought. We observed that the major drought in 1989-1990 was the most severe event in the time period. This is a significant statement for water resources planning with reference to the Seyhan River basin. Focusing only on the major droughts observed in the past when characterizing the severity of current drought events may improve our understanding of extreme meteorological drought events causing severe and long-lasting impacts.

    How to cite: Cavus, Y., Stahl, K., and Aksoy, H.: Spatial analysis of major droughts in Seyhan River Basin, Turkey, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-330, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-330, 2022.

    EGU22-368 | Presentations | HS2.4.4

    Drought recovery of southern Andes natural catchments 

    Jorge Vega-Briones, Mauricio Galleguillos, Steven de Jong, and Niko Wanders

    Drought causes hydroclimatic stress on terrestrial ecosystems and we see that these effects can have a long duration even when the drought is alleviated. The impacts of a drought are commonly dependent on the severity and duration of the hydrological drought event. At the same time, we see that the recovery from a severe drought is also impacted by catchment characteristics and regional climatology. In this study, we focus on Chile which has frequently experienced multi-drought periods with severe impacts.

    In this study, we quantify the recovery of discharge, vegetation productivity (kNDVI), and soil moisture after hydrological droughts to quantify the drought termination (DT) and drought termination duration (DTD). We used the CAMELS-CL data set from 1988-2020 to study drought recovery in natural catchments. Using a composite analysis we obtain the average response of discharge, vegetation, and soil moisture after severe drought events for catchments throughout Chile. We estimate the impact of different explanatory variables and catchment properties from the CAMELS-CL data on DT and DTD using lasso regression for discharge, vegetation productivity, and soil moisture without selecting strongly correlated variables.

    Our study demonstrates that the drought recovery of discharge can be explained by local characteristics while these relationships are less pronounced for vegetation and soil moisture droughts. Longer recovery times were found in environments with less precipitation and higher temperatures, with mainly shrub land cover. Shorter recovery times, at higher latitudes with increasing precipitation and lower temperatures under higher vegetation cover. The explanatory variables for discharge DT and DTD are associated with precipitation, potential evapotranspiration, and baseflow, or by a combination of them with catchment characteristics related to storage and release (e.g. land use). To that end, this work can help to identify drought vulnerability in regions where observations are lacking and help to predict drought recovery periods.

    How to cite: Vega-Briones, J., Galleguillos, M., de Jong, S., and Wanders, N.: Drought recovery of southern Andes natural catchments, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-368, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-368, 2022.

    EGU22-410 | Presentations | HS2.4.4

    Spatiotemporal distribution of hydrological extremes in Brazil 

    Gabriela Gesualdo, Marcos Benso, Manuela Brunner, and Eduardo Mendiondo

    To reduce the future negative impacts of hydrological extremes, it is crucial to understand the spatiotemporal variability of flood and drought hazard and social, economic, and environmental vulnerabilities. Such understanding is particularly important in developing countries which are strongly vulnerable to hydrological extremes because of greater economic dependence on climate-sensitive primary activities and infrastructure. Brazil is increasingly affected by hydrological extreme events and related losses. The sum of damages and losses caused by recurrent floods and droughts has a substantial impact, especially in small and medium-sized municipalities. Developing disaster resilience and adaptation strategies requires an understanding of the risks related to floods and droughts and how they are spatially distributed and related across the country. Therefore, we present a risk analysis of how floods and drought are distributed and spatially connected across Brazil. To assess flood hazard, we rely on frequency analysis and spatial dependence measures. Moreover, the vulnerabilities towards drought and flood hazard were derived using data from the Brazilian atlas of natural disaster: damages and losses($), people affected, deaths, and homelessness. Based on the results, we divide the country into regions suitable to risk pooling, i.e. groups of municipalities that can cooperatively share costs, liabilities and risks.These regions can implement adaptation measures at the regional level, i.e. flood-drought risk insurance framework, using conjugate return periods, extended losses, multi-risk coverage, and composite willingness to pay and adapt. Our risk analysis will support the development of adaptation plans to hydrological extremes at the catchment and regional scale.

    How to cite: Gesualdo, G., Benso, M., Brunner, M., and Mendiondo, E.: Spatiotemporal distribution of hydrological extremes in Brazil, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-410, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-410, 2022.

    EGU22-436 | Presentations | HS2.4.4

    Do Human Activities Influence Reservoir based Hydrological Droughts? 

    Deep Shah, Gang Zhao, Yao Li, and Huilin Gao

    Droughts pose enormous challenges to food security and freshwater availability across the globe. Reservoirs serve as a lifeline for drought mitigation, and as a prime source of irrigation water during extreme dry conditions. Despite the critical role reservoirs play during droughts, reservoir-based hydrological droughts have only been explored in a limited manner. Specifically, droughts based on reservoir storage levels and evaporative losses have not been accounted for at a global scale. Here, we use NASA’s new MODIS global water reservoir product, GRACE TWS, and GLDAS meteorological data to evaluate global reservoir-based hydrological droughts for 164 reservoirs located in different climatic zones and geographic settings. We introduce an Integrated Reservoir Drought Index (IRDI) that was developed using the concept of the copula, which incorporates the effects of reservoir storage and evaporation rates to effectively monitor reservoir-based hydrological droughts. From the observed climate data (2002-2020), we find that the frequency of reservoir based droughts is increasing in the western part of North America (NA), the eastern part of South America (SA), south-central Asia, and the majority of Africa, New Zealand, and Europe. Based on this information, we have reconstructed the drought characteristics (mean intensity, max intensity, max duration) using the IRDI for all of the 164 reservoirs during 2002-2020. We find that reservoirs in western Australia, southern Europe, southeast Asia, and the northern part of North America have gone through more prolonged droughts (of about 80-90 months, with a maximum intensity of about -2.6 to -3.2). We find contrasting trends of TWS anomalies and IRDI in south Asia, south Africa, eastern North America, and other places—which highlights the need for reservoir-based drought information (as TWS tends to be governed by groundwater changes, and does not necessarily give insights on reservoir droughts). Despite having high precipitation anomalies (wet conditions), reservoirs were mostly found to be under drought conditions, which points to the significant influence of human activities on reservoir-based droughts. Major factors contributing to this are inefficient water management policies and practices—especially during drought conditions—in different countries. Overall, our study highlights how human activities alter reservoir-based hydrological droughts, which has significant implications on sustainable and resilient water resources planning and management across the globe.

     

    How to cite: Shah, D., Zhao, G., Li, Y., and Gao, H.: Do Human Activities Influence Reservoir based Hydrological Droughts?, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-436, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-436, 2022.

    EGU22-485 | Presentations | HS2.4.4

    Amazon mega-flood naratives from large ensemble simulations – are they unseen or unrealistic? 

    Timo Kelder, Niko Wanders, Karin van der Wiel, Tim Marjoribanks, Louise Slater, Rob Wilby, and Christel Prudhomme

    Large ensemble simulations can be exploited to generate larger data samples than the observed record and consequently better assess the likelihood of rare events. Such simulations have the potential to inform storylines of ‘unseen’ flood episodes, i.e., that are more extreme than those seen in historical records. This method has, for example, been used to improve design levels of storm-surges in the river Rhine and to anticipate rainfall extremes over the UK. However, adequate evaluation of simulated ‘unseen’ events is a complex task.
    Here, we showcase simulated Amazonian mega-floods from the combination of global climate model EC-Earth and global hydrological model PCR-GLOBWB. We introduce a three-step procedure to assess the realism of these mega-floods based on the model properties (step 1), as well as the statistical features (step 2) and physical credibility of the simulation (step 3). For the Amazon example, we find that the unseen floods were the result of an unrealistic bias correction of precipitation. 
    We reflect on the different types of models that can be used to generate large sample sizes, and discuss the difference between storylines from large ensembles as compared to targeted model experiments to identify mega-floods. We conclude that understanding the driving mechanisms of unseen events may guide future research by uncovering key model deficiencies. They may also play a vital role in helping decision makers to anticipate unseen impacts by detecting plausible drivers. 

    How to cite: Kelder, T., Wanders, N., van der Wiel, K., Marjoribanks, T., Slater, L., Wilby, R., and Prudhomme, C.: Amazon mega-flood naratives from large ensemble simulations – are they unseen or unrealistic?, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-485, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-485, 2022.

    EGU22-641 | Presentations | HS2.4.4

    Multiannual Atmospheric Controls on Drought Stationarity: What the NAO can tell us about past behaviours and future climate change projections? 

    William Rust, John Bloomfield, Mark Cuthbert, Ron Corstanje, and Ian Holman

    Atmospheric variability in the North Atlantic region is known to modulate hydrometeorological variables across Europe. In this context, oscillatory systems, such as the NAO, may be used to indicate future water resource behaviours, such as hydrological droughts. Existing hydroclimate studies have identified a sensitivity of certain water resources to multiannual periodicities in systems such as the NAO and have highlighted that these long-term behaviours may be valuable to existing drought forecasting systems; for instance, by indicating multi-year periods of increased drought risk. However, the importance of multiannual NAO periodicities for driving water resource behaviour, and the feasibility of this relationship for indicating future droughts, has yet to be assessed in the context of known non-stationarities that are internal to the NAO and its influence on European meteorological processes. Here, we explore the role of NAO periodicities in defining water resource and drought behaviours over the past 90 years using a large dataset of 136 groundwater level records and 767 streamflow gauges in the UK. We identify significant relationships between the NAO and a calculated index of wide-spread water resource drought and find several abrupt shifts in drought frequency driven by non-stationarities in multiannual NAO behaviour. This includes a 7.5-year periodicity that has predominated water resource behaviour (and extremes) since the 1970s but has been weakening over recent years, suggesting a new shift in drought frequency may soon impact water resources. Furthermore, we show that the degree to which these periodicities have influenced recorded water resource anomalies is comparable to the projected effects of a worst-case climate change scenario. We discuss the potential origins for these modes of non-stationarity and their implications for existing water resource forecasting and projection systems, as well as the utility of these periodic behaviours as an indicator of future water resource drought in Europe.

    How to cite: Rust, W., Bloomfield, J., Cuthbert, M., Corstanje, R., and Holman, I.: Multiannual Atmospheric Controls on Drought Stationarity: What the NAO can tell us about past behaviours and future climate change projections?, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-641, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-641, 2022.

    EGU22-1239 | Presentations | HS2.4.4

    Regional Trends and Physical Controls of Streamflow Drought Characteristics in Tropical Catchments 

    Aparna Raut, Poulomi Ganguli, Nagarjuna N. Reddy, Thomas Wöhling, Rohini Kumar, and Bhabani Sankar Das

    Globally around half of the population resides in the tropics. Understanding the regional trends and physical controls of streamflow drought in the present day helps us to recognize the future changes in the hydrological cycle impacting the freshwater supplies. Few studies have examined the climatic and catchment controls on the propagation of streamflow droughts in tropical catchments. This study unveils the regional pattern of drought onset and deficit volume and identifies their evolution by analyzing the dominant climatic and physiographic controls. Two crucial streamflow drought signatures, the time of onset and deficit volume, are extracted from daily observed streamflow records of 82 rain-dominated catchments from peninsular India (8-24º N, 72-87º E). A daily variable threshold approach with an 80% exceedance probability of the flow record is used to identify drought events. Despite a decreasing trend in deficit volume, we show a delayed shift in drought onset of about a week for more than 50% of catchments. However, droughts with mean onset time clustered around the summer (Mar-May) season show a sharp rise in deficit volume trends. We show that while dynamic (precipitation and soil moisture) factors influence the onset of droughts, both static (catchment, topographic, and soil properties) and dynamic properties play a significant role in deciding the deficit volume. Based on a statistical approach (Taylor skill score and non-parametric dependence metrics), we identify static features, surface (30 cm) and sub-surface (up to 1m) soil organic stock and cation exchange capacity (CEC) to be dominant soil controls, also topographic ruggedness index, slope, topographic wetness index, and curvature are found to be the main controlling catchment attributes. The derived insights add new avenues in understanding the causal chain of physical processes linking climatic and physiographic controls on streamflow drought mechanisms, elucidating tropical climate response to water availability in a changing climate.       

    How to cite: Raut, A., Ganguli, P., Reddy, N. N., Wöhling, T., Kumar, R., and Das, B. S.: Regional Trends and Physical Controls of Streamflow Drought Characteristics in Tropical Catchments, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1239, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1239, 2022.

    EGU22-1430 | Presentations | HS2.4.4

    Classification of flood-generating processes in Africa 

    Yves Tramblay, Gabriele Villarini, Mohamed El Mehdi Saidi, Christian Massari, and Lina Stein

    Floods have large impacts on the populations and the economy of Africa, but little is known about the dominant flood generating mechanisms across this continent. This study is based on a large set of African basins, with the aim of identifying the main mechanisms causing floods. A total of 13815 flood events between 1981 and 2018 in 529 catchments are classified to identify the main flood drivers in different African regions. The classification is based on daily river discharge data together with precipitation and soil moisture from the ERA5-Land reanalysis, to identify flood events associated with short rains, long rains, or excess rain over saturated soils. Results indicated that processes related to soil saturation, either before floods or during long rainfall events, are strongly associated with the occurrence of floods in Africa. Excess rain in Western Africa, and long rain for catchments in Northern and Southern Africa, are the two dominant generating mechanisms, contributing to more than 75% of all flood events. Overall, no significant changes were detected in the relative importance of these drivers over the last decades. The major implication of these results is to underline the importance of soil moisture dynamics, in addition to precipitation intensity, to analyze the evolution of flood hazards or implement flood forecasting systems.

     

    How to cite: Tramblay, Y., Villarini, G., Saidi, M. E. M., Massari, C., and Stein, L.: Classification of flood-generating processes in Africa, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1430, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1430, 2022.

    EGU22-1693 | Presentations | HS2.4.4

    Future changes in flash flood frequency and magnitude over the European Alps 

    Marjanne Zander, Pety Viguurs, Frederiek Sperna Weiland, and Albrecht Weerts

    Flash Floods are damaging natural hazards which often occur in the European Alps. Precipitation patterns and intensity may change in a future climate affecting their occurrence and magnitude. For impact studies, flash floods can be difficult to simulate due the complex orography and limited extent & duration of the heavy rainfall events which trigger them.

    The new generation convection-permitting regional climate models (CP-RCMs) improve the representation of the intensity and frequency of heavy precipitation. Therefore, this study combines such simulations with high-resolution distributed hydrological modelling to assess changes in flash flood frequency over the Alpine domain.

     We use output from a state-of-the-art CP-RCM to drive a high-resolution distributed hydrological wflow_sbm model covering most of the Alpine mountain range on an hourly resolution.  First, the hydrological model was validated by comparing ERA5 driven simulation with streamflow observations from 130 stations (across Rhone, Rhine, Po, Adige and Danube basins). Second, a hourly wflow_sbm simulation driven by a CP-RCM downscaled ERAInterim simulation was compared to databases of past flood events to evaluate if the model can accurately simulate flash floods and to determine a suitable threshold definition for flash flooding. Finally, simulations of the future climate RCP 8.5 for the end-of-century (2096-2105) and current climate (1998-2007) are compared for which the CP-RCM is driven by a Global Climate Model. The simulations are compared to assess if there are changes in flash flood frequency and magnitude using a threshold approach. Results show a similar flash flood frequency for autumn in the future, but a decrease in summer. However, the future climate simulations indicate an increase in the flash flood severity in both summer and autumn leading to more severe flash flood impacts.

    How to cite: Zander, M., Viguurs, P., Sperna Weiland, F., and Weerts, A.: Future changes in flash flood frequency and magnitude over the European Alps, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1693, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1693, 2022.

    EGU22-1893 | Presentations | HS2.4.4

    Hybrid Forecasting of Recent Flood and Drought Events in Switzerland 

    Annie Y.-Y. Chang, Simone Jola, Konrad Bogner, Daniela I.V. Domeisen, and Massimiliano Zappa

    Flood and drought events can lead to severe socio-economic impact and damages. Thus, there is a need for early warnings of such extreme events, especially for decision-makers in sectors like hydropower production, navigation and transportation, agriculture, and hazard management. To improve the predictability of sub-seasonal streamflow, we propose the approach of a hybrid forecasting system, where a conceptual hydrological model PREVAH is combined with a machine learning (ML) model. The PREVAH model provides catchment level hydrological forecasts and the role of the ML model is to emulate a runoff routing scheme. Such a hybrid setup allows the forecasting system to benefit from the statistical power of ML while maintaining the understanding of physical processes from the hydrological model.

    The objective of this study is to investigate the predictability of a hybrid forecasting system to provide monthly streamflow predictions for three recent extreme events. These include the drought event in summer 2018, the drought event in spring 2020, and the flood event in summer 2021 in selected large Swiss rivers. We also investigate different predictability drivers by considering additional input features to the ML model, such as initial streamflow, European weather regime indices, and a hydropower proxy.

    We demonstrate that the proposed hybrid forecasting system has the potential to provide skillful monthly forecasts of the interested events. Informed ML models with additional input features achieve better performance than results obtained using hydrological model outputs only. This study sheds light on using hybrid forecasting for sub-seasonal hydrological predictions to provide useful information for medium-term planning at a monthly time horizon and reduce the impact of flood and drought events.

    How to cite: Chang, A. Y.-Y., Jola, S., Bogner, K., Domeisen, D. I. V., and Zappa, M.: Hybrid Forecasting of Recent Flood and Drought Events in Switzerland, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1893, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1893, 2022.

    Prediction of hydrological drought requires good process understanding of streamflow generation. It is known that during progressing drought the water availability in rivers is a composition of different delayed contributions from various stores in the catchments. However, the composition of delayed contributions often differs a lot across landscapes and hydrogeological settings. Solutes or isotope data sets are often limited to separate different contributions only during the campaign period in a specific catchment. Hydrological models incorporate delayed contribution typically with different soil and groundwater storages to simulate total streamflow. Here we analyzed the output from different storages of the water balance model LARSIM which is a well-established operational river forecasting model in Southern Germany. We hypothesized that the different storages' contributions can also be estimated by an advanced hydrograph separation method splitting total streamflow in four delayed contributions (i.e., storm flow, fast and slow interflow and baseflow). We used the Delayed Flow Index (DFI) for hydrograph separation as, compared to a BFI index, it estimates multiple storage-outflow components. Though not entirely similar in their results, the combined analysis of model simulations and DFI hydrograph has the potential to inform water management and forecasters about relevant time scales of different streamflow contributions and drought severity. The information of streamflow storage states and contributions may help hydrological drought prediction of time periods outside the model calibration period and also for periods when faster delayed contributions consecutively cease to sustain streamflow.

    How to cite: Stoelzle, M. and Stahl, K.: Deciphering streamflow composition during drought – model simulations as benchmark for advanced hydrograph separation, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1935, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1935, 2022.

    EGU22-2349 | Presentations | HS2.4.4

    Modelling the impact of land use change on floods and drought in a groundwater-dominated catchment 

    Sarah Collins, Anne Verhoef, Majdi Mansour, and David Macdonald

    In the UK, land use and land management change are being considered as part of a strategy to tackle flooding; the term natural flood management (NFM) is used in the UK to refer to this approach. Although evidence is limited, it is thought that practices considered as NFM, such as woodland planting or cover cropping, increase soil water storage and infiltration through improved soil structure, potentially reducing flooding within catchments where applied. Moreover, we know that trees and woodland have higher interception than shorter vegetation, increasing soil moisture deficit. We simulate what effect these land use and management changes have in the River Coln catchment (Upper Thames, UK), which is characterised by permeable geology and arable farming. The catchment has experienced both surface water and groundwater-driven flooding in recent history and is also important in maintaining summer low flows in the River Thames.  

    The land surface water balance was modelled with the detailed, field-scale hydrological model SWAP. Recharge from the SWAP model was passed to a semi-distributed groundwater model, which produces groundwater baseflow, and direct runoff from SWAP was passed to a linear reservoir model to produce surface runoff. Soil information (such as soil hydraulic parameters) was based on the NATMAP database; vegetation parameters (e.g. typical crop rotations or forest types) were derived from stakeholder workshops, surveys and interviews, and expert elicitation. Soil and farm management decisions were implemented by perturbing the SWAP soil and vegetation parameters. The parameters of the surface water routing and groundwater components were calibrated within a Monte Carlo framework.

    Overall, we found that land use and land management measures have very limited potential for reducing flooding in permeable catchments, where the primary driver of high flows is high winter groundwater levels. We found that only large-scale coniferous planting had the potential to reduce winter peak flows and flooding in the Coln (e.g. reduction of 21−27% with two-thirds of catchment as coniferous woodland), but that this would decrease summer mean flows (12% reduction in July mean flow, 8% in August). The levels of coniferous woodland required to achieve these reductions in winter high flows are unrealistic, given the large area of productive arable land that would need to be converted to woodland and the limited ecological benefits of coniferous woodland.

    How to cite: Collins, S., Verhoef, A., Mansour, M., and Macdonald, D.: Modelling the impact of land use change on floods and drought in a groundwater-dominated catchment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2349, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2349, 2022.

    EGU22-2389 | Presentations | HS2.4.4

    Uncertainty of uncertainty decomposition approaches for projections of hydrological extremes 

    Hossein Tabari and Patrick Willems

    The quantitative description of uncertainty in future projections of hydrometeorological variables provides valuable information for a better interpretation of climate change impact for informed policy decisions and actions to mitigate the associated risk. Several methods have been developed and used for decomposing the uncertainty in projections. The relative importance of the uncertainty associated with the choice of uncertainty decomposition methods compared to the other sources of uncertainty has however never been quantitatively investigated. We scrutinize where and to what extent the rate of fractional uncertainties could vary across the globe depending on the choice of uncertainty decomposition methods. We characterize drought by the standardized precipitation evapotranspiration index (SPEI) using a large ensemble of the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project Phase 5 (CMIP5) and Phase 6 (CMIP6) general circulation models (GCMs). Flood and extreme precipitation are quantified by fitting a generalized extreme value distribution (GEV) to the annual maxima time series of the ISIMIP2b global hydrological model and CMIP5/CMIP6 simulations. The uncertainty in future projections of extreme precipitation, flood, and drought is then split in the variance contributions using the traditional ANOVA, quasi-ergodic ANOVA (QE-ANOVA), HS09, and variance decomposition-same sample size (VD-SSS) methods. Finally, the uncertainty arising from the choice of uncertainty analysis methods is quantified and compared across different types of hydrological extremes and the IPCC reference regions.

    How to cite: Tabari, H. and Willems, P.: Uncertainty of uncertainty decomposition approaches for projections of hydrological extremes, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2389, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2389, 2022.

    EGU22-2902 | Presentations | HS2.4.4

    A new approach to transfer the discharge recession behavior from gauged to ungauged catchments 

    Michael Margreth, Massimiliano Zappa, Christoph Wanner, Dorothea Hug-Peter, Florian Lustenberger, and Fritz Schlunegger

    Many streams in the Swiss Plateau experienced in 2003, 2011, 2015 and 2018 extremely low streamflow conditions. In 2018, on several stream and groundwater gauging stations the lowest values since the start of observations were registered. Climate and hydrological impact models project that by the end of the century in the future summer half such dry periods with similar duration and intensity might occur more frequently. According to the models, extreme dry periods will last even longer as the drought in summer 2018.

    To be prepared on that, the public authorities want to know and to get an overview on how streams react in case of such scenarios predicting dryer conditions. A requirement for that is to understand the relevant factors controlling the available storages for low-flow generation and the drainage behavior of small to mesoscale catchments during low flow under recent climate conditions.

    Analysis of flow duration curves of over 200 gauged catchments in Swiss Plateau with information of mean annual precipitation and evapotranspiration, geological maps and some topographic properties allowed to identify factors reducing and increasing the low flow q95 percentile and controlling low flow behavior. With analysis of the resulting spatial pattern of specific discharges (l s-1 km-2) of more than 200 additional singular discharge measurements on selected sites during low flow periods, the effects of the relevant factors could be isolated more precisely. The relevant factors essentially consist of:

    • Lithological construction of bedrock
    • Infiltration and exfiltration of stream water in and from sediments of river bed
    • Extend and permeability of quaternary deposits like morains, rubbly deposits, talus or sagging.
    • Water withdrawal for water supply, irrigation and power plants.

    The spatial low flow pattern all over the Swiss Plateau will be presented with maps and the effects of the mentioned factors will be shown on expressive examples.

    A new automatic method is developped to calculate so-called master recession curves from the 200 available long-term discharge data series. With the intention to transfer the recession behavior from gauged to ungauged catchments, further analysis are planned in gauged catchments to identify the correlation between the recession curves and the effect of the above mentioned factors.

    How to cite: Margreth, M., Zappa, M., Wanner, C., Hug-Peter, D., Lustenberger, F., and Schlunegger, F.: A new approach to transfer the discharge recession behavior from gauged to ungauged catchments, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2902, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2902, 2022.

    EGU22-3469 | Presentations | HS2.4.4

    Rhine flood stories: Spatio-temporal analysis of historic and projected flood formation in the Rhine River basin 

    Erwin Rottler, Axel Bronstert, Gerd Bürger, and Oldrich Rakovec

    The genesis of riverine floods in large river basins often is complex. Streamflow originating from precipitation and snowmelt and different tributaries can superimpose and cause high water levels threatening cities and communities along the river banks. In this study, we develop an analytical framework that captures and shares the story behind major historic and projected streamflow peaks in the large and complex basin of the Rhine River. Our analysis is based on hydrological simulations with the mesoscale Hydrolgical Model (mHM) forced with an ensemble of climate projections. The spatio-temporal analysis of the flood formation includes the assessment and mapping of antecedent liquid precipitation, snow cover changes, generated and routed runoff, flood extent and the excess runoff from major sub-basins up to ten days before a streamflow peak. An interactive web-based viewer provides easy access to result figures of major historic and projected streamflow peaks at four locations along the Rhine River. Our results indicate that each streamflow peak is driven by a specific sequence of precipitation and snowmelt from different areas in the Rhine River basin. Furthermore, we map how rising temperatures increase liquid precipitation in the Alps, in turn, increasing streamflow peaks along the Rhine River. The highest streamflow peak simulated at Cologne using climate projections exceeds the historic record by almost 50 % and was driven by excessive rainfall over several days over large parts of the Rhine River basin. Such an event taking place today would have catastrophic consequences. Further research is required to assess the impacts of changes in the persistence of circulation patterns on flood extent and hazard.

    How to cite: Rottler, E., Bronstert, A., Bürger, G., and Rakovec, O.: Rhine flood stories: Spatio-temporal analysis of historic and projected flood formation in the Rhine River basin, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3469, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3469, 2022.

    EGU22-3618 | Presentations | HS2.4.4

    A multi-year drought can alter the nitrate retention capacity of a catchment 

    Carolin Winter, Tam V. Nguyen, Andreas Musolff, Stefanie R. Lutz, Michael Rode, Rohini Kumar, and Jan H. Fleckenstein

    From 2018 to 2020, large parts of Central Europe experienced an unprecedented multi-year summer drought with severe impacts on society and ecosystems. While strong reductions of water quantity were reported, our study is one of the first to analyze its impacts on water quality by looking at nitrate export dynamics in a nested mesoscale catchment in Germany with heterogeneous landscape settings. We used concentration-discharge (CQ) relationships to analyze catchment functioning in terms of nitrate retention and release, and the mechanistic process based mHM-SAS model (Nguyen et al., 2021) to simulate the underlying belowground nitrogen (N) fluxes and associated hydrologic transit times. For the three drought years, we found an amplification of the seasonality in nitrate export with lower concentrations in summer and higher concentration in winter, compared to normal conditions. Compared to the long-term average behavior, the catchment exhibited a disproportionally high annual load export relative to the discharge available for its transport. We argue that this loss in nitrate retention capacity was driven by a complex mixture of changes in N cycling and heterogeneous transit times among different contributing areas. During dry periods, long transit times and sufficient subsurface denitrification likely caused the low in-stream nitrate concentrations in the upper, more mountainous catchment, while reduced soil denitrification and plant uptake resulted in an accumulation of N in the soils. During the following wet periods, this accumulated N was rapidly exported to the stream (median transit times < 2 month) causing a steep increase in nitrate concentrations and load export. In the downstream (lower) sub-catchment, long median transit times (> 20 years) prevent such an immediate export of the accumulated soil-N to the stream. Our modeling analysis, however, suggests that the build-up of soil N-stores and the lack of fast, shallow flow path may exacerbate N legacies in the downstream part of the catchment, which might become visible as higher N export to the stream decades later. Hence, the more immediate concentration response to drought observed at the catchment outlet was dominated by the flushier upstream catchment. Overall, this increased temporal variability of nitrate export and intensified within-catchment differences caused by a multi-year drought call for a higher spatiotemporal resolution of monitoring and more site-specific management plans for site-specific problems.

    Nguyen, T. V., Kumar, R., Musolff, A., Lutz, S. R., Sarrazin, F., Attinger, S., & Fleckenstein, J. (2021, July 13). Disparate Seasonal Nitrate Export from Nested Heterogeneous Subcatchments Revealed with StorAge Selection Functions [preprint]. https://doi.org/10.1002/essoar.10507516.1

    How to cite: Winter, C., V. Nguyen, T., Musolff, A., Lutz, S. R., Rode, M., Kumar, R., and Fleckenstein, J. H.: A multi-year drought can alter the nitrate retention capacity of a catchment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3618, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3618, 2022.

    EGU22-3626 | Presentations | HS2.4.4

    The 2018-2020 multi-year drought sets a new benchmark in Europe 

    Oldrich Rakovec, Luis Samaniego, Vittal Hari, Yannis Markonis, Vojtech Moravec, Stephan Thober, Martin Hanel, and Rohini Kumar

    During the period 2018-2020, Europe experienced a series of hot and dry weather conditions with significant socioeconomic and environmental consequences. Yet, the extremity of these multi-year dry conditions is not recognized. Here, we provide a comprehensive spatio-temporal assessment of the drought hazard over Europe by benchmarking past exceptional events during the period from 1766-2020. We identified the 2018-20 drought event as a new benchmark having an unprecedented intensity that persisted for more than two years, exhibiting a mean areal coverage of 35.6% and an average duration of 12.2 months. What makes this event truly exceptional compared with past events is its near-surface air temperature anomaly reaching +2.8 K, which constitutes further evidence that the ongoing global warming is exacerbating present drought events. Our analysis shows that exceptional agricultural droughts enhanced by record-breaking near-surface air temperature anomalies have a significant impact (decline) on major crop yields (wheat, grain maize, and barley) across the European countries.  Furthermore, future events based on climate model simulations (CMIP5) suggest that Europe should be prepared for events of comparable intensity as the 2018-2020 event but with durations longer than any of those experienced in the last 250 years. Soil moisture drought projections synthesized in this study, even under a moderate emission scenario, indicate that decision-makers in Europe should be prepared for drought events of comparable intensity in future. Thus, the 2018--20 drought event could be considered as a wake-up call on agricultural policies. In this study, we compared and contrasted this event with earlier events of similar magnitudes and showed the role of increasing temperature rises. 

    DOI of dataset: https://zenodo.org/record/5801249

    Reference: 

    Rakovec, O., Samaniego, L., Hari, V., Markonis, Y., Moravec, V., Thober, S., Hanel, M., Kumar, R. (2022). The 2018-20 multi-year drought sets a new benchmark in Europe. Under Review, resubmitted version

     

    How to cite: Rakovec, O., Samaniego, L., Hari, V., Markonis, Y., Moravec, V., Thober, S., Hanel, M., and Kumar, R.: The 2018-2020 multi-year drought sets a new benchmark in Europe, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3626, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3626, 2022.

    EGU22-4397 | Presentations | HS2.4.4

    Drought-flood transitions across different hydro-climates 

    Jonas Götte and Manuela Irene Brunner

    Drought-flood transitions greatly challenge water management and the development of adaption measures to extreme events. These transitions can occur rapidly but may also take many months or years and are often studied using climate instead of streamflow data – neglecting the role of surface processes. The time between one extreme and the other may depend on climate and catchment characteristics including topography, soil types and water use. However, it is yet unclear how drought-flood transition times vary regionally in dependence of climate characteristics, flow processes, and water storage.
    In this study, we analyse how drought-flood transition times vary across different hydro-climatic zones. We show how transition times, i.e. the number of days between drought-termination and the following flood event, vary in space. We identify indicators and common patterns of rapid transitions by correlating drought and flood characteristics to transition times. To do so, we use large-sample datasets such as CAMELS and LamaH, which provide diverse catchment characteristics in addition to streamflow data. This information helps to identify catchments with a high likelihood of abrupt drought-flood transitions. Such identification is highly relevant because flood preparedness is often low during drought events, which potentially increases the severity of flood impacts.

    How to cite: Götte, J. and Brunner, M. I.: Drought-flood transitions across different hydro-climates, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4397, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4397, 2022.

    EGU22-4848 | Presentations | HS2.4.4

    Subsurface storage drives drought propagation and recovery across climates and catchment properties 

    Giulia Bruno, Francesco Avanzi, Simone Gabellani, Luca Ferraris, Edoardo Cremonese, Marta Galvagno, and Christian Massari

    Extensive knowledge of hydrological processes occurring during droughts is required for a sustainable water resources management, especially in a changing climate. Large-sample analyses are particularly informative in this sense, because they allow us to extend the understanding beyond specific catchments. Data from experimental catchments and observatories showed that water stored within the catchment can sustain evapotranspiration and discharge during dry periods and previous multi-catchments studies on droughts highlighted the storage control on hydrological drought characteristics, through the quantification of hydrological signatures and catchment properties. However, few studies have explicitly quantified across different climates and catchment types the contribution of subsurface storage changes (ΔS) in the annual water balance, in drought propagation (from the meteorological to the hydrological one), and in drought recovery. Here, we assembled a dataset blending ground-based precipitation and discharge data, and remote-sensed actual evapotranspiration data to study drought propagation and recovery in a water-balance and data-based perspective for 102 catchments across various climatic and morphological properties in Italy. This region experienced severe drought years over the study period (hydrological years 2010 - 2019), as detected by the Standardised Precipitation Index for an accumulation period of 12 months. This large-sample analysis revealed that (i) subsurface storage is a non-negligible term in the annual water balance, as ΔS mean annual value represents on average the 11% of precipitation across the catchments, (ii) its depletion sustains discharge during drought years (median annual ΔS anomaly equal to -97 mm for catchments attenuating the hydrological drought with respect to the meteorological one), and (iii) it recovers from precipitation deficits over shorter time scales than evapotranspiration, but similar as those of discharge. These findings emphasize the need of explicitly considering subsurface storage in drought analyses to properly inform policy makers and water managers, as it is a key driver in drought propagation and recovery across climates and catchment properties.

    How to cite: Bruno, G., Avanzi, F., Gabellani, S., Ferraris, L., Cremonese, E., Galvagno, M., and Massari, C.: Subsurface storage drives drought propagation and recovery across climates and catchment properties, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4848, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4848, 2022.

    EGU22-4951 | Presentations | HS2.4.4 | Highlight

    Hydrological Drought – 12 lessons learned in 12 minutes 

    Lena M. Tallaksen

    In this presentation, I highlight key lessons learned following a career within drought research. From its start with focus on low flows in the 1990'ties to the definition of hydrological drought and its spatial and temporal patterns in more recent work - it has been an interesting and learning journey. A period that coincides with an increasing awareness of drought as a natural hazard at the local, regional and continental scale. It is also a period when the influence of climate change on the hydrological cycle, water resources and extremes, became prominent. Accordingly, time series could no longer be assumed stationary, which had been the basis for our hydrological training at the time, and the research focus shifted from more traditional hydrological analysis to the detection, attribution and projection of the climate change signal on hydrology. When analyzing drought and its wide range of impacts, it is important to distinguish between the different types of droughts, and when analyzing changes and trends, it is important to distinguish between natural variability and changes due to climate change or human interventions. How drought is defined and perceived in different sectors and regions across the world influences the choice of methodology and how the results are interpreted and communicated. The importance of drought terminology and awareness of the diversity in drought behavior - within and among regions - are aspects that have been essential throughout my research and that I will reflect upon in my talk.

    How to cite: Tallaksen, L. M.: Hydrological Drought – 12 lessons learned in 12 minutes, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4951, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4951, 2022.

    EGU22-6146 | Presentations | HS2.4.4

    Lessons from the 2018-2019 European droughts: A collective need for unifying drought risk management 

    Veit Blauhut, Michael Stölzle, Lauri Ahopelto, Manuela Brunner, Claudia Teutschbein, and Doris Wendt and the Drought Risk Europe - a Panta Rhei working group

    In recent years, drought impacts have been perceived as more severe and frequent than those of past events throughout Europe. Due to the heterogeneity of Europe’s hydro- climatological situation as well as the multiple Nations on the continent, drought events and their impacts vary with respect to location, sector, extent, duration and scale. In order to understand recent effects of drought and their possible drivers, national representatives distributed a uniform questionnaire to water management related stakeholders at different scales of 28 contributing countries. The survey focused on collecting information on stakeholders’ perceptions of drought, impacts on water resources and beyond, water availability and current drought management strategies at national and regional scales. The survey results were compared with the actual drought hazard information registered by the European Drought Observatory (EDO) for 2018 and 2019. The final results of the study highlight the diversity among national drought event perception and the value of implemented drought management strategies. Only few countries practise drought management, an absence of drought management is mostly attributed to lacking of resources, but also lacking political will for implementation and lacking political advice. Supported by the national representatives’ perspectives, the study concludes with an urgent need to further reduce drought impacts by constructing and implementing a European macro-level drought governance approach, such as a directive, which would strengthen national drought management and lessen harm to human and natural potentials.

    How to cite: Blauhut, V., Stölzle, M., Ahopelto, L., Brunner, M., Teutschbein, C., and Wendt, D. and the Drought Risk Europe - a Panta Rhei working group: Lessons from the 2018-2019 European droughts: A collective need for unifying drought risk management, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6146, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6146, 2022.

    EGU22-6262 | Presentations | HS2.4.4

    Modelling of changes in hydrological balance in Gambia river basin using two lumped models 

    Doudou Ba, Petr Máca, Jakub Langhammer, and Ansoumana Bodian

    This study investigated the calibration performance of hydrological models applying a series of split-sample to crash-test potential combinations of calibration-validation periods under drought type (dry/wet) using lumped models: BILAN and GR2M. A sub-period focused on the drought was systematically selected for model calibration based on a particular climate characteristic (precipitation, temperature, runoff) and a 7-year moving window. This approach gives perception into calibrated parameters transferability overtime under similar or different climate conditions (drought). 

    Both lumped models yielded similar results over a set of 6 catchments in a main West African river basin located in Senegal: the Gambia river basin. The Kling-Glupta Efficiency (KGE) was the objective function to assess models’ efficiency. A dependency was found between the model performance and the extent of input data. 

    Results have shown that the calibration performance decreases within an extending simulation period width. A focus on the impact of drought type on calibration performance revealed models simulating better dry than wet years. The analysis on how model performance would be affected when calibrated in a climate condition different to the validation (e.g. calibrated in dry(wet) and validated into wet (dry) revealed that calibration over a wetter or dryer condition than the validation and vice-versa may lead to an over(under)estimation of the simulated runoff. 

    The results also indicate a general performance loss due to the transfer of calibrated parameters to independent validation periods of −5 to −25%, on average. The shift of model parameters in time (validation) may generate a significant level of errors. The outcome of this study may lead to a master of the uncertainty associated with one hydrological model and a better assessment of runoff in a real-world application.

    Keywords: Gambia river basin; calibration; crash test; rainfall-runoff model; BILAN; GR2M; lumped hydrological models;  

    How to cite: Ba, D., Máca, P., Langhammer, J., and Bodian, A.: Modelling of changes in hydrological balance in Gambia river basin using two lumped models, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6262, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6262, 2022.

    EGU22-6536 | Presentations | HS2.4.4

    Charting Australia’s changing hydrological extremes from the past to the present through to the future 

    Wendy Sharples, Ulrike Bende-Michl, Elisabeth Vogel, Chiara Holgate, Katayoon Bahramian, Zaved Khan, and Elisabetta Carrara

    In a changing climate, Australia’s ability to protect life and property against water related hazards such as floods, landslides, bushfires and droughts, will depend on high quality water resource information which is consistent across spatio-temporal scales. The Australian Bureau of Meteorology has recently released a new service: The Australian Water Outlook (awo.bom.gov.au) which provides nationally consistent water information including historical to near-real time hydrological monitoring, seasonal forecasts and long-term projections, offering a seamless perspective of Australian hydrology.

     

    We exploit the seamless nature of this dataset to track the change in frequency, duration, magnitude and spatial extent of hydrological extreme events such as hydrological, agricultural and meteorological droughts, floods, and heavy rainfall events, using a range of different indicators, across different hydro-climate regions in Australia. Taking a multiple lines of evidence approach by using a combination of indicators which leverage water balance components of rainfall, soil moisture, evapotranspiration and runoff, we can reduce uncertainty in extreme event identification, and estimated magnitude and duration. Charting hydrological extreme events across regions and timescales will bolster Australia’s emergency management efforts in planning, preparedness and response as well as facilitate recovery. 

    How to cite: Sharples, W., Bende-Michl, U., Vogel, E., Holgate, C., Bahramian, K., Khan, Z., and Carrara, E.: Charting Australia’s changing hydrological extremes from the past to the present through to the future, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6536, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6536, 2022.

    EGU22-7122 | Presentations | HS2.4.4

    A Global-Scale Analysis of Hydrologic Extremes using Hidden Climate Indices 

    Benjamin Renard, Seth Westra, Dmitri Kavetski, Mark Thyer, Michael Leonard, David McInerney, and Jean-Philippe Vidal

    Hydrologic extremes (floods and intense precipitations) are among Earth’s most common natural hazards and cause considerable loss of life and economic damage. Describing their space-time variability in relation to climate is hence important for scientific and operational purposes. This presentation describes the use of an innovative probabilistic framework to jointly analyze global datasets of floods and extreme precipitations. This framework is based on the idea that the temporal variability of the data is induced by hidden climate indices that are unknown and therefore have to be estimated directly from the data. This is to be contrasted with the usual approach using predefined standard climate indices such as ENSO or NAO for this purpose. In statistical terms, a two-level hierarchical model is used. The first level jointly describes floods and intense precipitations, with hidden climate indices treated as latent variables. The second level describes the temporal variability of the hidden climate indices (including trend and persistence components), and the spatial variability of their effects.

    This model is applied to station-based datasets describing seasonal maxima of streamflow and precipitation at the global scale, corresponding to more than 3,000 stations over a 100-year period (1916-2015). Several hidden climate indices governing the joint temporal variability of streamflow and precipitation data are identified. They affect floods and intense precipitations over large (continental) spatial scales and in a highly structured way. Overall these hidden climate indices do not present noticeable trend or persistence components, suggesting that they represent mostly interannual modes of variability. By contrast, when the same model is applied to precipitation data only, the estimated hidden climate indices are affected by stronger and mostly upward trends: this confirms that increasing intense precipitations do not identically translate into increasing floods, as highlighted by the latest IPCC report. Finally, we demonstrate that hidden climate indices can be predicted to some degree from atmospheric variables such as pressure, wind, temperature etc. This allows reconstructing the probability of occurrence of hydrologic extremes in the distant past using long reanalyses such as 20CR.

    How to cite: Renard, B., Westra, S., Kavetski, D., Thyer, M., Leonard, M., McInerney, D., and Vidal, J.-P.: A Global-Scale Analysis of Hydrologic Extremes using Hidden Climate Indices, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7122, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7122, 2022.

    EGU22-7345 | Presentations | HS2.4.4

    Stress-testing the buffering role of glaciers in the Rhine basin: How much worse could summer low flows get under future glacier retreat? 

    Marit Van Tiel, Markus Weiler, Daphné Freudiger, Greta Moretti, Irene Kohn, Kai Gerlinger, and Kerstin Stahl

    Past drought years, characterized by large scale precipitation deficits and high summer temperatures, such as 2018 in Europe, have resulted in extreme low flow situations with negative ecological, economic and social consequences. In large river basins that originate in high mountain ranges, such as the Rhine river originating in the Swiss Alps, glaciers and snowpack alleviate drought situations by continuously providing meltwater to downstream reaches during summer. However, this meltwater contribution is under threat due to ongoing climate warming and retreating glaciers. Here, we designed a stresstest model experiment to answer the question ‘what if a historical drought year reoccurs in future conditions with retreated glaciers?’ A model framework was used combining the HBV model for the glacierized headwater catchments of the Rhine and the LARSIM model for the rest of the basin. Three historical drought and low flow years, 1976, 2003 and 2018, were selected and their meteorological conditions were transferred and used as stresstest model input to three future conditions in time, namely now (2018), near future (2031) and far future (2070). These three model states were obtained by transient simulations up to the respective moment in time using meteorological observations or an ensemble of bias-corrected climate model output from the RCP 8.5 scenario, using coupled glacio-hydrological model runs. The results show an aggravation of downstream low flows, especially when drought years happen under conditions in the far future. From the three years, 2003 has the strongest effect in the future, because the ice melt contribution was highest in that year in the past. During August, flows reduce up to 80% upstream for highly glacierized catchments, compared to the streamflow of the original drought years. At downstream gauges, where flows were already critically low in the past, streamflow reduces by 5%-20%. This model experiment shows a glimpse in future low flow events and emphasizes the importance of upstream cryospheric changes for downstream streamflow dynamics during drought. 

    How to cite: Van Tiel, M., Weiler, M., Freudiger, D., Moretti, G., Kohn, I., Gerlinger, K., and Stahl, K.: Stress-testing the buffering role of glaciers in the Rhine basin: How much worse could summer low flows get under future glacier retreat?, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7345, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7345, 2022.

    The intensity and occurrence of groundwater flooding have been found to increase considerably in the past two decades. In general, groundwater flooding occurs over a larger area and for a longer duration, when compared to other types of flooding. The associated damage and disruption caused by groundwater flooding led researchers to focus on the development of groundwater flood forecasting models that can be used for flood risk assessment and development of flood mitigation planning and strategies. This study develops a nonlinear time series model to predict total flooded volume (TFV) in a lowland karst area of Ireland. A Nonlinear Autoregressive model with Exogenous variables (NARX) was developed in the karst region, where rainfall and tidal amplitude had been considered to influence the TFV. The developed NARX model was found to predict TFV with considerable accuracy up to 30 days ahead, with a Kling-Gupta Efficiency (KGE) value of 0.9 or above. The efficiency deteriorates beyond 30 days ahead prediction and becomes 0.81 KGE when the prediction window is 90 days. Comparison of the developed NARX model with a linear time series model in TFV forecast indicates the importance of considering the nonlinear terms while developing the forecasted model. The developed NARX model has the potential to create an early warning system for flooding. The model has further been used to predict freshwater discharge from the inter-tidal spring into the Atlantic Ocean in southern Ireland.

    How to cite: Basu, B. and Gill, L.: Nonlinear time series based forecast modelling of groundwater flooding at karst region in Ireland, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7539, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7539, 2022.

    EGU22-8930 | Presentations | HS2.4.4

    Drought Cycle Analysis to evaluate the influence of a dense network of small reservoirs on drought evolution 

    Germano Ribeiro Neto, Lieke Melsen, Eduardo S. P. R. Martins, David W. Walker, and Pieter van Oel

    Drought-affected regions often contain high densities of small reservoirs, usually informally built, as drought-coping mechanism. These structures influence socio-hydrological dynamics and have the potential to alter hydrological processes relevant to drought emergence and development. This study aimed to analyze the influence of a high concentration of small reservoirs on the intensification and evolution of drought events. We present an innovative method, which we call “Drought Cycle Analysis”, that tracks the concomitance of precipitation and water storage deficit and associates this with four drought stages: Wet Period, Meteorological drought, Hydro-meteorological drought and Hydrological drought period. The methodology was tested for the Riacho do Sangue River watershed located in the semi-arid region of northeast Brazil. We used a combination of satellite imagery (Landsat 5, 7 and 8) and an empirical equation to estimate the volume stored in the dense network of small reservoirs. Using the Drought Cycle Analysis, we show that the unmonitored small reservoirs induced and modified drought events, extending the duration of hydrological drought on average by 30%. Furthermore, this extension can double for specific drought events. The Drought Cycle Analysis method proved useful for monitoring and comparing the evolution of different drought events, in addition to being applicable as an auxiliary tool in the improvement of water resources management of large reservoirs. This study demonstrates the importance of considering small reservoirs in water resource management strategy development for drought-prone regions.

    How to cite: Ribeiro Neto, G., Melsen, L., S. P. R. Martins, E., W. Walker, D., and van Oel, P.: Drought Cycle Analysis to evaluate the influence of a dense network of small reservoirs on drought evolution, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8930, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8930, 2022.

    EGU22-9047 | Presentations | HS2.4.4

    Estimating the variation in runoff due to landcover changes using the SWAT model 

    Arunima Sarkar Basu and Francesco Pilla

    Land use and land cover changes are majorly associated with the anthropogenic causes as well as human growth and urban expansion. The rapid increase in urban development is interlinked to fragmentation of landcover changes leading to a rise in flood events. The growth rate of urbanization has been quite significant in Ireland over the past 30 years. Ireland’s annual growth rate of urbanization was found to be 3.1% between 1990 to 2012. Several studies have further documented that Ireland experienced an overall higher degree of land conversion relative to other European countries, concluding that the urban land expansion in Ireland has been among the highest in Europe. The majority of the physically-based hydrological models that are used to simulate the discharge dynamics from river basin outlets require land cover information. One of the major limitations of those models is that they, in general, assume that the land cover information remains the same over time. However, changes in land cover are evolving over time, which needs to be considered while simulating runoff at a river basin. In situations where the hydrological model is used to simulate runoff for a short period of time, ranging from a few months to a few years, a static land cover information might be sufficient, however, when runoff simulations are required for longer periods of time (more than a decade), it is important to consider the changes in land cover over such a period. This study investigates how changes in land cover impact hydrological runoff simulations using a rainfall-runoff model called soil water assessment tool (SWAT). The study area considered is the Dodder River basin located in southern Dublin, Ireland. Runoff at the basin outlet was simulated using SWAT for 1993–2019 using five landcover maps obtained for 1990, 2000, 2006, 2012 and 2018. The hypothesis specifically points to the consideration of dynamic and time-varying landcover data during the development of hydrological modelling for runoff simulation. Furthermore, two composite quantile functions were generated by using a kappa distribution for monthly mean runoff and GEV distribution for monthly maximum runoff, based on model simulations obtained using different landcover data corresponding to different time-period.

    How to cite: Sarkar Basu, A. and Pilla, F.: Estimating the variation in runoff due to landcover changes using the SWAT model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9047, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9047, 2022.

    EGU22-9070 | Presentations | HS2.4.4

    Projected Climate Change Impact Assessment on Drought Characteristics Over a Humid Tropical Region in India 

    Kashish Sadhwani, T. I. Eldho, and Subhankar Karmakar

    Droughts are the major natural disasters affecting water availability leading to social, economic, and environmental challenges. Due to climate variability, investigation of climate change impact on droughts is of vital importance for sustainable societal and ecosystem functioning.  Western Ghats, a humid tropical region of India is selected as a case study to investigate the change in drought characteristics subjected to future climate change. In the last few decades, due to monsoon failure, the intensity of droughts has been identified to increase in this region making this study important. For future climatic variables, the ensemble of five Global Climate Models (GCMs) in the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project (CMIP5) are considered for the Representative Concentration Pathways (RCPs) 4.5 and 8.5. Standardized Precipitation-Evapotranspiration Index (SPEI) for the 12-month accumulated period is considered to assess the change in the drought characteristics during near (2011–2040), mid (2041–2070), and far future (2071–2100). The results indicate an increase in drought events in the future with maximum change during the far future for both RCP 4.5 and 8.5 scenarios. The major areas affected are in the southern part of Kerala and Karnataka. The change in total severity and duration of these drought events are high during the near future, moderate during the mid-future, and very high during the far future in both scenarios with RCP 8.5 being more severe. The findings show the variability in drought characteristics both spatially and temporally across the study area. The results will be helpful in identifying the hotspots prone to drought risk. This will serve as important guidance in improving the identification of causes, minimizing impacts, and enhancing the resilience to droughts in the study area. Further, the important implication of the study will be for water resource planning and management to strategize policies that emphasize on providing water in water-scarce regions during extreme drought situations.

    How to cite: Sadhwani, K., Eldho, T. I., and Karmakar, S.: Projected Climate Change Impact Assessment on Drought Characteristics Over a Humid Tropical Region in India, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9070, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9070, 2022.

    EGU22-9475 | Presentations | HS2.4.4

    Investigating process drivers of Natural Flood Management and its flood risk reduction potential across scales 

    Salim Goudarzi, David Milledge, Joseph Holden, Tim Allott, Donald Edokpa, Martin Evans, Martin Kay, Emma Shuttleworth, and Tom Spencer

    Before-after monitoring of small-scale restoration activities in blanket peatlands, e.g., revegetation and gully blocking, suggests they can also deliver significant Natural Flood Management (NFM) benefits (reduce and delay floodpeaks). However, we still lack a clear understanding of the underlying processes driving NFM effects; and doubts remain about whether interventions will retain their impact when implemented at scales large enough to reduce flooding in downstream communities. We examine the impact of the two interventions at a range of scales from the 1 hectare micro-catchment scale at which a Before-After-Control-Intervention (BACI) study has been undertaken, to the 40 km2 scale (at which flooding begins to affect residential properties). We calibrate the Generalised Multistep Dynamic (GMD) TOPMODEL rainfall-runoff model to different BACI experimental catchments each representing an intervention scenario. Through numerical experimentation with the calibrated parameters, we estimate the impact-magnitude of different process drivers. Our findings confirm the NFM benefits of these restoration-focused interventions at the micro-catchment scale. In both interventions and in our largest storms, floodpeak attenuation is primarily due to roughness reducing the floodwave speed and thus thickening the overland flow (kinematic storage). More conventional, static storage (i.e. interception + ponding + evapotranspiration), becomes important only in smaller storms. Finally, we use the parameter-sets identified by calibrating to the BACI catchments to extend our findings to the 40 km2 Glossop catchment. Glossop has experienced several damaging floods in the last 50 years and has received appreciable recent restoration activity. Here we use GMD-TOPMODEL in a second set of modelling experiments to estimate downstream impact of existing interventions and to examine the impact of alternative scenarios of spatially distributed intervention configurations.

    How to cite: Goudarzi, S., Milledge, D., Holden, J., Allott, T., Edokpa, D., Evans, M., Kay, M., Shuttleworth, E., and Spencer, T.: Investigating process drivers of Natural Flood Management and its flood risk reduction potential across scales, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9475, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9475, 2022.

    EGU22-9712 | Presentations | HS2.4.4

    Participatory Development of Storymaps to Illustrate the Spatiotemporal Dynamics and Impacts of Extreme Flood Events 

    Lukas Munz, Olivia Martius, Martina Kauzlaric, Markus Mosimann, Anna Fehlmann, and Andreas Zischg

    Investments in flood protection are often made as a reaction to recent events. Flood risk communication and awareness creation might help to raise the motivation for preventive action in flood risk management, rather than implementing reactive measures after an event has occurred. In order to develop a way to convey scientific insight and data on flood risk, together with stakeholders, we are developing an interactive online tool to generate storymaps of local and national extreme flood events. To learn about the needs of every stakeholder, how flood risk information could be communicated and how practitioners can finally apply a resulting tool, we carried out an iterative co-development process. Stakeholders from local emergency intervention forces, insurance companies, cantonal and federal environment offices were interrogated in semi-structured interviews and workshops in an iterative process. The result is an online tool, which allows a user to construct storymaps of extreme flood events by varying several boundary conditions (e.g. duration of the precipitation event, initial conditions, etc.). These storymaps depict how a flood produced by physically plausible storylines of extreme precipitation events evolves and recedes.

    With the development of storymaps, we connect physically plausible storylines with dynamical mapping. Both methods address the episodic memory and allow the user to connect new information to personal experiences or the collective memory, and hence create an emotional element. Storylines furthermore allow focusing on single possible realisations of an extreme event rather than an ensemble mean.

    The storylines are constructed with the help of a comprehensive model chain: extreme precipitation events (return period >= 100 years) extracted from 8490 years of two merged hindcast archives of ECMWF – ENSext (1998-2017) and SEAS5 (1981-2017) – are used as scenarios to run a hydrological model for the main rivers and lakes in Switzerland. Subsequently, the results of the hydrologic simulations are fed into a hydrodynamic model coupled with an impact module to assess the flood impacts on buildings, roads, and critical facilities such as schools and retirement homes, including the number of affected people. The generated storymaps can be directly used in emergency intervention planning and training, because they provide dynamic information on possible flood impacts in contrast to static hazard maps, which are used for this purpose today. Furthermore, the tool might help to raise flood risk awareness among professionals as well as the interested public by visualizing and localizing physically consistent flood hazard information in an intuitive way.

    How to cite: Munz, L., Martius, O., Kauzlaric, M., Mosimann, M., Fehlmann, A., and Zischg, A.: Participatory Development of Storymaps to Illustrate the Spatiotemporal Dynamics and Impacts of Extreme Flood Events, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9712, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9712, 2022.

    The compound occurrence of two extremes of the hydrological spectrum (droughts and floods) either in space and/or time, could aggravate the associated socio-economic impacts with respect to those caused by the individual extreme event. Both extreme events share the potentially linked driving mechanisms and interconnected characteristics, therefore the better understanding of the dependence structures of the contributing variables is essential to avoid the underestimation of the possible risks of compound hazards. To this end, the present study focusses on spatio-temporally compound extreme events under a changing climate and identify/locate the most vulnerable hotspots in the Upper Jhelum Basin (South Asia), paving the way for adaptation and mitigation measures. Climate models are the main tools to assess climate projections and, particularly, to provide relevant information for sectoral applications. They often present systematic biases, thus some sort of bias adjustment is performed in impact assessments. The framework of the present study is two-fold: (i) evaluation of bias correction (BC) of climate model historical simulations and (ii) projection of extreme compound events in the near future (2040-2059) and far future (2080-2099) for three different Representative Concentration Pathways (RCP2.6, RCP4.5 and RCP8.5). Droughts and floods are characterized by using a multivariate drought index (namely the Standardized Precipitation Evapotranspiration Index, SPEI), which is derived from daily precipitation (P) and maximum (Tmax) and minimum temperatures (Tmin). In the first step, the intercomparison of different state-of-the-art BC methods (uni- and multi-variate) and BC approaches (direct and component-wise) for climate model simulations stemming from different experiments (CMIP6, CORDEX -WAS-44- and CORDEX CORE -WAS-22) is performed following a multivariate framework. The added value/performance of BC and climate model simulations is examined in terms of inter-variable physical coherence of involved key essential variables (P, Tmax and Tmin) and characteristics of extreme events (duration, severity, intensity, and frequency of floods and droughts) during the historical period. In the second step, projected changes in the extreme events characteristics and their compounding in space and time are analyzed for the near and far future under all available scenarios. Climate projections of this kind of extreme events, spanning different scenarios and other sources of uncertainty is essential to better implement adaptation and mitigation solutions that can help reduce the negative impacts of climate change.

    How to cite: Ansari, R., Casanueva, A., and Grossi, G.: Climate projections of spatio-temporally compound extreme events (floods and droughts) using a multivariate drought index, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10376, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10376, 2022.

    EGU22-10903 | Presentations | HS2.4.4

    Extreme droughts in Transilvania during Little Ice Age derived from documentary evidences 

    Gheorghe Badaluta, Carmen-Andreea Badaluta, Monica Ionita, and Marcel Mindrescu

    Drought represent one of the extreme aspects of the water cycle with impact on water resources, agriculture and socio-economic activities. Currently, droughts are used as an indicator of climate variability and change and are mainly driven by changes in the hydrological cycle and the large-scale atmospheric circulation. In order to have a long-term perspective on the drought variability and change, beyond the instrumental record, one needs to use different proxies and/or historical evidences. In this study we will present documentray evidences regarding the occurence of extreme droughts in Transilvania region (Romania) during the Little Ice Age (AD 1500-1800) and their socio-economic impacts. Between AD 1500-1800 we identify 126 drought events, frm which 33 are considered extreme droughts (e.g. with the character of a calamity). Of the 33 extreme droughts, 3 occurred between AD 1500-1600, 14 between AD 1600-1700 and 16 between AD1700-1800. These events have been driven by anomalous large-scale atmospheric and oceanic patterns in combination with strong variation in the solar and volcanic variability. In conclusion, our results will contribute to the knowledge of extreme events of Central Eastern Europe during the Little Ice Age and may be used as an indicator to predict their influences in the context of the climate changes.

    How to cite: Badaluta, G., Badaluta, C.-A., Ionita, M., and Mindrescu, M.: Extreme droughts in Transilvania during Little Ice Age derived from documentary evidences, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10903, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10903, 2022.

    Climate change is increasing frequency and magnitude of precipitation extremes and floods. Increasing design floods in the future could lead to underestimated design capacities of current spillways, increasing the probability of dam overtopping. Therefore, new methodologies are required for assessing hydrological dam safety considering climate change. Moreover, uncertainty should be accounted to properly assess future changes in overtopping probabilities. This study presents a methodology to assess hydrological dam safety considering the impact of climate change on inflow hydrographs and initial reservoir water levels in flood events, quantifying the uncertainty in estimations. The methodology is applied to the Eugui Dam in the River Arga catchment (Spain), upstream the city of Pamplona.

    The impact of climate change on inflow hydrographs in the Eugui reservoir is quantified by using the delta changes in precipitation quantiles extracted from climate projections in the Iberian Peninsula (Garijo & Mediero, Water 2019). The RIBS distributed hydrological model was used in Lompi et al. (Water, 2021) to quantify the expected changes in flood quantiles at the Eugui Dam for three-time windows (2011-2040, 2041-2070, and 2071-2100), two Representative Concentration Pathways (RCP 4.5 and RCP 8.5) and seven return periods (2, 5, 10, 50, 100, 500 and 1000 years).

    The impact of climate change on initial reservoir water levels in flood events is assessed integrating the HBV continuous hydrological model with a reservoir operation model. HBV simulates daily inflow discharges in the Eugui reservoir by using rainfall and temperature climate projections as input data. HBV is calibrated with 13 years of precipitation, temperature, and reservoir inflow discharge observations. The reservoir operation model is developed to obtain daily reservoir water levels. It uses HBV inflow discharges as input data and considers reservoir operation rules, such as water supplies and environmental releases. Rainfall and temperature climate projections for an ensemble of 12 climate models are used to assess the changes in the expected daily reservoir water levels at the Eugui dam for each time window and emission scenario, including the control period.

    A set of 10 000 peak inflow discharges are randomly generated from several GEV distribution functions fitted to the flood quantile outputs of the RIBS model. Given hydrograph shapes and initial reservoir water levels are assigned to each peak flow. The Volumetric Evaluation Method is used to simulate flow routing processes in the reservoir. The frequency curves of maximum reservoir water levels and maximum outflow discharges are obtained for each scenario, assessing the expected changes in the probability of exceedance of dam overtopping. In addition, a stochastic procedure quantifies the uncertainty chain of the methodology.

    The results show an increase of both the maximum water level frequency and the probability of dam overtopping, especially in the period 2071-2100 for the RCP 8.5. Moreover, the maximum outflow discharge frequency also increases in all the time windows for the RCP 8.5, exacerbating the hydraulic risk for the downstream population in the Pamplona city.

    Acknowledgments: This research is supported by the project SAFERDAMS (PID2019-107027RB-I00) funded by the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation.

    How to cite: Lompi, M., Mediero, L., Soriano, E., and Caporali, E.: A stochastic methodology to assess the impact of climate change on the Eugui hydrological dam safety (Spain) with an ensemble of climate projections, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11498, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11498, 2022.

    EGU22-11772 | Presentations | HS2.4.4

    Multivariate Analysis and Assessment of Regional Drought Risks under Climate Change using Copulas 

    Rajarshi Datta and Manne Janga Reddy

    This study intended to understand the effect of climate change on spatiotemporal characteristics of multivariate drought risk over the Vidarbha region of India. The Standardized Precipitation Evapotranspiration Index (SPEI) is employed to characterize droughts in the region. Gridded daily precipitation and temperature data produced by the Indian Meteorological Department (IMD) and Coupled Model Inter-comparison Project Phase 6 (CMIP6) were utilized for estimating the SPEI. The drought events were identified and subsequently characterized by duration, severity, and peak. Different goodness of fit tests was applied to select the best fitting marginal distributions of the individual drought characteristics. Several symmetric and asymmetric Archimedean trivariate copulas and seven bivariate copula families were evaluated for joint distribution modeling. Maximum pseudo-likelihood and genetic algorithms have been applied to estimate the copula parameters accurately. The asymmetric Frank copula was selected to construct the trivariate distribution of the drought characteristics. Frank, Student’s t and Clayton copulas were chosen to build the bivariate distribution of duration-severity, duration-peak, and severity-peak, respectively. The joint distributions were applied for computing the joint return periods of drought events. The drought risk over the region was illustrated using zoning maps for historical along with near and far future periods. The inferences derived from the study will help policymakers to prepare better mitigation strategies under the changing environment.

    How to cite: Datta, R. and Reddy, M. J.: Multivariate Analysis and Assessment of Regional Drought Risks under Climate Change using Copulas, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11772, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11772, 2022.

    EGU22-11887 | Presentations | HS2.4.4

    Uncertainty in estimating the observed relationship between hourly precipitation extremes and dewpoint temperature 

    Haider Ali, David Pritchard, Hayley Fowler, and Elizabeth Lewis

    Short-duration (hourly) precipitation extremes have intensified in the past and they are projected to increase more under the warming climate. The Clausius-Clapeyron (CC) relationship can be used to understand the sensitivity (scaling) of precipitation extremes with warming. According to the CC relationship, hourly precipitation extremes intensify at around a 7% (CC rate) per degree rise in temperature. However, the observed scaling rates deviate from the CC rate which can be due to multiple thermodynamic and dynamic factors which have been discussed in the recent scaling studies. Moreover, the choice of data and scaling methods may also lead to uncertainty in scaling rates. In this study, by using observed hourly precipitation and daily dewpoint temperature over the USA, we show that robust quality controlled precipitation data show differences in scaling. We also obtained higher scaling rates for the higher measurement precision data (0.25mm and 2.5mm). We further show the uncertainty in scaling rates using different four scaling methods. Our results highlight the need of using extensive quality controlled and finer precision observations for estimating accurate scaling rates.

     

    How to cite: Ali, H., Pritchard, D., Fowler, H., and Lewis, E.: Uncertainty in estimating the observed relationship between hourly precipitation extremes and dewpoint temperature, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11887, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11887, 2022.

    Water resource managers all over the world require timely and robust climate projections to support planning on a range of timescales. In the UK, water companies are obliged to produce long-term water resource management plans to ensure security of water supply, and these are required to take account of climate change. One of the challenges is having ready access to the latest climate projections, at an appropriate scale to support regional- and national-scale planning. In particular, a major gap has been the availability of a national, spatially-coherent dataset of river flows and groundwater projections.

    This presentation introduces the ‘enhanced Future Flows and Groundwater’ (eFLaG) project, that has delivered nationally consistent hydrological (river flow and groundwater) projections for the UK, based on the latest UK Climate Projections (UKCP18). The hydrological projections are derived from an ensemble of river flow models (Grid-to-Grid, PDM, GR4J and GR6J) and groundwater models (AquiMod and ZOODRM) to provide an indication of hydrological model uncertainty. A 12-member ensemble of transient projections of present and future (up to 2080) daily river flows, groundwater levels and groundwater recharge were produced using bias-corrected data from the UKCP18 Regional (12km) climate ensemble. Projections are provided for 200 river catchments, 54 groundwater level boreholes and 558 groundwater bodies sampling across the diverse hydrological and geological conditions of the UK. An evaluation, using multiple metrics, will be presented for the national scale.

    The eFLaG project also undertook a national-scale analysis of hydrological droughts. We present results showing the future evolution of hydrological drought severity compared to a current baseline – generally showing significant increases in drought severity in future. We also show the evolution of low flows through the 21st century, demonstrating the benefit of having long, transient ensemble runs of river flows and groundwater levels. While there are wide uncertainties, reflecting the diversity of RCM ensemble members and hydrological models alike, generally these results point towards decreasing low flows and minimum groundwater levels through the coming century. Finally, we also undertook an analysis of spatial coherence of drought, showing how inter-regional coherence of drought changes under anthropogenic warming – results which could have implications for water transfers that are integral to the latest round of Water Resources Management Plans (WRMPs).

    eFLaG is designed to provide a demonstration climate service to enhance the resilience of the water sector to drought events. In this regard, we will also describe three contrasting case studies (Thames, Wales and Scotland) where the team collaborated with the water industry to demonstrate the utility of eFLaG for water resources management applications. These demonstrators illustrate the potential benefit of coherent, multimodel, transient projections, while also the challenges in integrating them with current statutory WRMPs produced by water companies.

    While eFLaG was developed with drought applications as the primary focus, the evaluation metrics show that river flows and groundwater levels are generally well simulated across the regime. The eFLaG dataset can potentially be applied to a wider range of water resources research and management contexts, pending a full evaluation for the designated purpose.

    How to cite: Hannaford, J. and the the eFLaG Team: enhanced future FLows and Groundwater (eFLaG):  future hydrological projections to enhance drought resilience in the UK, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12040, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12040, 2022.

    EGU22-12338 | Presentations | HS2.4.4

    Risk Profiles of Impactful and Extreme Hydrological Events for Alpine Reservoirs 

    Tatjana Milojevic, Juliette Blanchet, and Michael Lehning

    Climate change impacts in the Swiss Alps have been seen through changes in the hydrologic regime. These include glacier mass loss, shifts in peak snowmelt and changes in seasonal precipitation type and timing (e.g., more rain-on-snow events in winter). In addition, it is expected that global warming will lead to more intense extreme rainfall events in the Alps in the future. Combined, all of these changes pose a challenge to planning, management and optimization for hydropower producers operating in the Alpine region. In particular, because the impacts are not expected to be felt homogeneously across the region, it is difficult to ascertain how the risks will differ between individual reservoirs without more localized assessment. This study focuses on the use of statistical tools that are specifically adapted for application to small datasets (such as the extended generalized pareto distribution), in order to calculate return periods of extreme precipitation and high reservoir inflow events for individual Alpine reservoirs. In addition, we show how the return periods of persistent low inflow periods (droughts), which have the potential for significant negative impacts on hydropower production, are determined using extreme value theory. The result is effectively a risk profile comprised of return periods for both extreme high precipitation/inflow and impactful low precipitation/inflow events that can be used by researchers and practitioners alike to further understanding of local climate change risks to individual reservoirs.

    How to cite: Milojevic, T., Blanchet, J., and Lehning, M.: Risk Profiles of Impactful and Extreme Hydrological Events for Alpine Reservoirs, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12338, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12338, 2022.

    EGU22-13137 | Presentations | HS2.4.4

    A rigorous attribution of the demand side of drought: a case study in the Midwest US. 

    Mike Hobbins, Darren Jackson, Mimi Hughes, and Molly Woloszyn

    Our goal here is to answer the question, “what drives the demand side of drought?” We achieve this by decomposing atmospheric evaporative demand (Eo) anomalies during periods of drought into contributions from all of its drivers, using the US Midwest as a study region. In drought, anomalies in Eo are driven by anomalies in moisture availability, but Eo reacts quickly and so is a robust drought indicator. Thus, asking to what extent each meteorological driver determines evaporative demand in drought conditions is of value both academically and operationally.

    We define drought as a sustained imbalance between the supply of moisture from the atmosphere to the surface (Precipitation) and the demand in the atmosphere for moisture from the surface, in favor of the demand. The demand arm is atmospheric evaporative demand (Eo; (sometimes referred to as “potential evaporation”); evapotranspiration (ET), the actual return flux to the atmosphere, is determined as the extent to which this demand can be met by the moisture available at the surface.

    In this context, Eo can be thought of as the “thirst of the atmosphere.” It is a function of meteorological and radiative drivers at the surface: specifically temperature, solar radiation, wind speed, and humidity (and to a lesser degree, surface pressure). For Eo we use daily reference ET (ETo) from the Penman-Monteith equation, which provides a fully physical estimate that incorporates the effects of both advective and radiative forcing. We drive ETo by inputs from the North American Land Data Assimilation System phase-2 (NLDAS-2), which are distributed across CONUS at a spatial resolution of 0.125 degrees, and available from 1979 to the present.

    Drought periods are determined using various spatially distributed drought-monitoring tools: specifically, the US Drought Monitor (USDM); the Evaporative Demand Drought Index (EDDI); the Standardized Precipitation Index (SPI); and soil moisture percentiles from the NLDAS-driven Noah land surface model.

    We conduct a first-order analysis of the anomalies in Eo that exist during drought conditions. This technique assumes that the contributions from anomalies in all drivers sum to the anomaly in Eo; each driver’s contribution is the product of the sensitivity of Eo to, and the anomaly in, the driver. As our expression for Eo (i.e., Penman-Monteith ETo) is differentiable, the sensitivity to each driver can be derived explicitly by partial differentiation. Drivers’ anomalies are observed by querying the reanalysis during drought periods and deriving deviations from the drivers’ long-term means for the same periods across the entire reanalysis period.

    Here we present the (i) general methodology for both the development of Eo and its decomposition and (ii) the results of the decomposition of drought-period Eo anomalies into the relative contributions from each driver across the Midwest Drought Early Warning System (DEWS) region.

    How to cite: Hobbins, M., Jackson, D., Hughes, M., and Woloszyn, M.: A rigorous attribution of the demand side of drought: a case study in the Midwest US., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13137, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13137, 2022.

    HS2.5 – Global and (sub)continental hydrology

    EGU22-310 | Presentations | HS2.5.1

    Assessment of the Water Cycle Acceleration in the Czech Republic 

    Mijael Rodrigo Vargas Godoy, Zuzana Bešťáková, Rajani K. Pradhan, Markéta Součková, Martin Hanel, Roman Juras, Jan Kyselý, and Yannis Markonis

    There is general agreement about the water cycle acceleration in the community, although its strength over land has been debated lately. While some common behavior is observed under similar climatic conditions across the globe, at the regional scale the water cycle's response to global warming is specific to its location's unique characteristics. Herein, we quantify the water cycle and characterize its climatology over the Czech Republic, which constitutes an essential headwaters area of the European continent, and in hydrological terms, it can be called the “roof of Europe”. The country's location involves three drainage catchments: the Elbe, Oder, and Danube rivers, which lead to the North Sea, the Baltic Sea, and the Black Sea respectively. Our analysis includes various data sets at  different spatiotemporal scales like: The Twentieth Century Reanalysis (20CR), CPC Merged Analysis of Precipitation (CMAP), CPC Global Unified Gauge-Based Analysis of Daily Precipitation (CPC), Climatic Research Unit gridded Time Series (CRU TS), Global Historical Climatology Network monthly (GHCN), Global Land Data Assimilation System (GLDAS), Global Land Evaporation Amsterdam Model (GLEAM), Global Precipitation Climatology Centre (GPCC), The Global Precipitation Measurement Integrated Multi-satellite Retrievals (GPM IMERG), Global Runoff Data Centre (GRDC), Global Runoff Reconstruction (GRUN), Moderate Resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer Terra Net Evapotranspiration (MOD16A2), National Centers for Environmental Prediction DOE Reanalysis 2 (NCEP DOE), National Centers for Environmental Prediction and the National Center for Atmospheric Research (NCEP NCAR), NOAA's Precipitation Reconstruction over Land (PRECL), Tropical Rainfall Measuring Mission Multi-Satellite Precipitation Analysis (TRMM 3B43), and University of Delaware Precipitation (UDEL). To exploit the availability of the various data sets for each component of the water cycle we merged them via simple weighted averages, a multi-source data integration method that has proven to be effective and with low computational requirements. Subsequently, we linked the computed components constraining them by the water budget equation. Thereafter, the time series were analyzed to quantify trends and their statistical significance, as well as their uncertainty derived by the multiple datasets. In addition to the time series analysis and the statistics involved so far, a spatial analysis explored the water cycle climatology and its variability over the whole Czech Republic and then its behavior in subdomains defined by the watersheds within the borders of the country.

    How to cite: Vargas Godoy, M. R., Bešťáková, Z., Pradhan, R. K., Součková, M., Hanel, M., Juras, R., Kyselý, J., and Markonis, Y.: Assessment of the Water Cycle Acceleration in the Czech Republic, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-310, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-310, 2022.

    EGU22-834 | Presentations | HS2.5.1

    Evaluating a reservoir parametrisation in a vector-based global routing model for Earth System Model coupling 

    Inne Vanderkelen, Shervan Gharari, Naoki Mizukami, David M. Lawrence, Sean Swenson, Martyn Clark, Ann van Griensven, Yadu Pokhrel, Naota Hanasaki, and Wim Thiery

    Humans have fundamentally altered global river flow by constructing reservoirs and building water-diversion schemes for irrigation. Reservoir operation and the regulation of river flow is important for estimating global water fluxes and water availability. Reservoirs and dam management are however generally not represented in Earth System Models. Recently, efforts are made to incorporate human water management in Land Surface Models by improving the irrigation representation and including high-resolution river networks.

    Here, we present the integration of a reservoir routine in the vector-based river routing model mizuRoute, to be coupled with the Community Terrestrial Systems Model (CTSM). We use the Hydrologic Derivatives for Modeling and Applications (HDMA) vector-based river network, which is intersected with lake and reservoir polygons from the HydroLAKES and GRanD databases to model both natural lakes and reservoirs. We implement reservoir management based on the parametrization of Hanasaki et al. (2006) and develop an irrigation topology to determine the irrigation water demand for every individual reservoir based on gridded water demands modeled by CTSM.

    We then evaluate our reservoir implementation both in a local setup, driven by observed inflow for 26 reservoirs, and in a global-scale setup, driven by gridded runoff from CTSM and using the Hydrologic Derivatives for Modeling and Applications (HDMA) river network. The local simulations show that accounting for reservoirs improves the skill compared to resolving reservoirs with a natural lake parametrization and not accounting for lakes/reservoirs. In the global-scale simulation, the reservoir management and natural lake parametrizations show however similar results, which could be attributed to biases in modeled reservoir inflow. These biases originate from biases in runoff simulated by CTSM and/or unresolved reservoirs on the river network.

    This study overall underlines the need to further develop and test water management parametrizations for improving the representation of anthropogenic interference with the terrestrial water cycle in Earth system models.

    References:
    Hanasaki, N., Kanae, S., & Oki, T. (2006). A reservoir operation scheme for global river routing models. Journal of Hydrology, 327(1–2), 22–41

    Mizukami, N., Clark, M. P., Gharari, S., Kluzek, E., Pan, M., Lin, P., Beck, H. E., & Yamazaki, D. (2021). A Vector-Based River Routing Model for Earth System Models: Parallelization and Global Applications. Journal of Advances in Modeling Earth Systems, 13(6).

    How to cite: Vanderkelen, I., Gharari, S., Mizukami, N., Lawrence, D. M., Swenson, S., Clark, M., van Griensven, A., Pokhrel, Y., Hanasaki, N., and Thiery, W.: Evaluating a reservoir parametrisation in a vector-based global routing model for Earth System Model coupling, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-834, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-834, 2022.

    EGU22-1417 | Presentations | HS2.5.1

    Hyper-resolution hydrological modelling over Europe: results and emerging challenges 

    Jannis Hoch, Edwin Sutanudjaja, Niko Wanders, Rens van Beek, and Marc Bierkens

    Modelling the terrestrial hydrological cycle at ‘hyper-resolution’, i.e., with a grid cell size of 1 km or below) was and still is a major quest in hydrological sciences. With an increase in computational power and the number of readily available and open datasets at useful spatial resolutions increasing as well, hyper-resolution modelling efforts have grown in number as well. We here present a first continental-scale application of the global hydrological model PCR-GLOBWB over Europe at 1 km spatial resolution, and offset it against runs with traditional resolutions of 10 km and 50 km, respectively. Model output was validated for more than 200 water provinces against observed discharge and the following remotely sensed data products: ESA-CCI soil moisture data and GRACE/GRACE-FO terrestrial water storage anomalies. Evaporation estimates were compared to GLEAM data. Evaluation metrics indicate good model performance over Europe and increased accuracy with finer spatial resolutions, particularly for discharge simulations. While the used validation products have the advantage of global coverage and long observational records, their spatial resolution is actually too coarse to fully assess the accuracy of models at hyper-resolution. At that scale, more recent satellite products can be of more use but at the cost of only short observation record. We thus additionally validated 1 km model output against Sentinel-1 surface soil moisture and compared it against results obtained for ESA-CCI soil moisture data. Besides challenges related to global-scale fine-resolution observational data, we also acknowledge that additional work needs to focus on model parameterization for hyper-resolution as well model improvements such as routing schemes better utilizing the available spatial detail. Another challenge we identified is required run time and computational power to analyze continental-scale 1 km data, even when using the state-of-the-art Dutch supercomputer. Here, efficient programming and use of latest parallelization techniques will become even more crucial. Despite these solvable challenges, our research shows that large-scale hyper-resolution modelling is now feasible and that further pursuing these efforts can eventually lead to more locally-relevant hydrological information and process understanding.

    How to cite: Hoch, J., Sutanudjaja, E., Wanders, N., van Beek, R., and Bierkens, M.: Hyper-resolution hydrological modelling over Europe: results and emerging challenges, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1417, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1417, 2022.

    Water used to irrigate accounts for 70% of total water withdrawal and 90% of water consumption worldwide. As a result, irrigation has a strong impact on water and energy budgets, on the associated biogeochemical cycles, and on local and regional climate. Furthermore, water volume for irrigation is projected to increase, due to population growth and climate change. This has encouraged the inclusion of irrigation in an increasing number of land surface models (LSM), which represent the continental branch of the water cycle in Earth System Models. To this end, three key aspects of irrigation must be described: when to irrigate (timing), how to irrigate (irrigation method), and how much to irrigate (water amount).

    We present a new irrigation scheme for the ORCHIDEE land surface model, developed to account for flood and drip irrigation techniques. In grid cells with irrigated areas, the water demand is deduced from the soil moisture deficit in the crop and grass soil column, i.e. is partially controlled by soil parameters. The soil column contains both irrigated and rainfed crops, but the fraction equipped for irrigation limits the water demand. The deficit is the difference between the actual soil moisture in the root zone and a soil moisture target. Both the root zone depth and the soil moisture target are user-defined. The volume of water utilized for irrigation is constrained by water availability from rivers and the unconfined groundwater reservoirs, while guaranteeing an environmental flow (i.e. irrigation cannot deplete completely the reservoirs). Additionally, priority in abstraction source (surface vs groundwater) is imposed based on the maps of Siebert et al., (2010). This means that a grid cell without infrastructure for groundwater irrigation, for example, will take all the water from the river, and vice versa. This adds an additional constraint to water availability. The water volume is put in the surface of the crop and grass soil column for infiltration, regardless of water source.

    Using offline simulations at global scale, we will evaluate the sensitivity of four key factors:  definition of the root zone, setting of the soil moisture target, water availability and the decay of soil hydraulic conductivity with depth. We will then tune the irrigation scheme to match the irrigation volumes reported at country level by the AQUASTAT dataset, and evaluate the effect of irrigation on soil surface hydrology and energy balance. The perspective of this work is to explore the effects of irrigation over present and future climates, using coupled land surface – atmosphere simulations with the IPSL-CM6 climate model. 

    S. Siebert et al., “Groundwater use for irrigation - A global inventory,” Hydrol. Earth Syst. Sci., vol. 14, no. 10, pp. 1863–1880, 2010.

    How to cite: Arboleda, P., Ducharne, A., Yin, Z., and Ciais, P.: Tuning an improved irrigation scheme inside ORCHIDEE land surface model and assessing its sensitivity over land surface hydrology and energy budget, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1984, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1984, 2022.

    EGU22-2151 | Presentations | HS2.5.1

    Classification reveals varying drivers of severe and moderate hydrological droughts in Europe 

    Manuela Irene Brunner, Anne Van Loon, and Kerstin Stahl

    Streamflow droughts are generated by a variety of processes including rainfall deficits and anomalous snow availability or evapotranspiration. The importance of different driver sequences may vary with event severity, however, it is yet unclear how. To study the variation of driver importance with event severity, we propose a formal classification scheme for streamflow droughts and apply it to a large sample of catchments in Europe. The scheme assigns events to one of eight drought types – each characterized by a set of compounding drivers - using information about seasonality, precipitation deficits, and snow availability. Our findings show that drought driver importance varies regionally, seasonally, and by event severity. More specifically, we show that rainfall deficit droughts are the dominant drought type in western Europe while northern Europe is most often affected by cold snow season droughts. Second, we show that rainfall deficit and cold snow season droughts are important from autumn to spring, while snowmelt and wet to dry season droughts are important in summer. Last, we demonstrate that moderate droughts are mainly driven by rainfall deficits while severe events are mainly driven by snowmelt deficits in colder climates and by streamflow deficits transitioning from the wet to the dry season in warmer climates. This high importance of snow-influenced and evapotranspiration-influenced droughts for severe events suggests that these potentially high-impact events might undergo the strongest changes in a warming climate because of their close relationship to temperature. The proposed classification scheme provides a template that can be expanded to include other climatic regions and human influences.

    How to cite: Brunner, M. I., Van Loon, A., and Stahl, K.: Classification reveals varying drivers of severe and moderate hydrological droughts in Europe, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2151, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2151, 2022.

    EGU22-2955 | Presentations | HS2.5.1

    The role of topography in the global hydrological cycle 

    Sebastian Gnann and Thorsten Wagener

    Topography influences how water is precipitated on, evaporated from, stored in, and routed through the landscape, often because of long-term evolutionary processes. How well do we know the links between topography and hydrology at large scales? Do we use this knowledge in, for example, large scale modelling efforts, or does topographic data contain information that is currently underused? To shed light on the role of topography in the global hydrological cycle, we explore three key themes.

    First, topography leads to gradients and contrasts in climatic/weather forcing. Well-known examples are orographic precipitation, rain shadowing, or the presence of snow and ice at high elevations.

    Second, topography is strongly related to different landforms, such as mountains and plains. These generic landforms provide a first broad classification, but there are further properties that vary along topographic gradients in a more nuanced way, such as sediment size or the depth of the critical zone.

    Third, topographically induced differences in potential energy drive water movement. This can result in surface and subsurface flow across large (horizontal) distances, providing water to distant areas, and thus decoupling local hydrology to some extent from local climate.

    The three themes (often in concert) describe partial controls on large scale hydrological processes and patterns. We derive several hypotheses based on these three themes, which would improve our understanding of large-scale hydrological processes, and help us in evaluating, constraining, and building hydrological models.

    How to cite: Gnann, S. and Wagener, T.: The role of topography in the global hydrological cycle, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2955, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2955, 2022.

    EGU22-4203 | Presentations | HS2.5.1

    Global sensitivity of inundation extent and population exposure to flood magnitude 

    Laura Devitt, Jeffrey Neal, Gemma Coxon, and Thorsten Wagener

    Understanding global river flood risk is fundamental for impact assessment of future climate and socio-economic change. There is a growing interest in understanding future flood risk using alternative methods that are independent of the uncertainties associated with the common approach based on a model cascade of global climate models coupled with hydrological and inundation models. Here, we propose a new sensitivity index that quantifies whether river reaches are more sensitive to flooding from low or high return periods using flood hazard data from a global flood model. We assess the sensitivity of flood extents and population exposure to increasing river flow magnitudes of 1.1 million river reaches globally. The dominant control on the sensitivity of reaches is the local topography and upstream drainage area. We find that steep bedrock and low slope alluvial streams are sensitive to high return periods, while intermediate and transitional streams are sensitive to low return periods. We find a clear spatial pattern in where the largest proportions of populations have settled on floodplains, which are found in North Africa, South America and South and East Asia. This analysis allows us to identify regions where river reaches and populations might be most affected by climate change and an increase in frequency and magnitude of flood events. 

    How to cite: Devitt, L., Neal, J., Coxon, G., and Wagener, T.: Global sensitivity of inundation extent and population exposure to flood magnitude, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4203, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4203, 2022.

    EGU22-4561 | Presentations | HS2.5.1

    Assessing the impact of climate change on Southeast Asia’s hydropower availability 

    Stefano Galelli and Thanh Duc Dang

    Southeast Asia’s electricity supply largely depends on the hydropower resources of the Mekong, Chao Phraya, Irrawaddy, and Salween River Basins. Uncertain precipitation patterns, rising temperature, and other climate-driven changes are exposing these resources to unprecedented risks, prompting decision makers to re-evaluate existing reservoir management strategies through climate change risk assessments. These assessments are important in shaping the operators’ response to hydro-climatic variability and are necessary to ensure energy security in the region. In this study, we developed high-resolution, semi-distributed hydrological models to examine the potential changes of hydropower availability under projected future climate scenarios in the four largest river basins in South East Asia. Specifically, we relied on a novel variant of the Variable Infiltration Capacity (VIC) model that integrates reservoir operations into the routing scheme, warranting a more accurate representation of cascade reservoir systems. Climate change impacts were derived from the outputs of five Global Circulation Models (GCMs) forced by two Shared Socioeconomic Pathways (SSPs 2.6 and 8.5) emission scenarios in the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project Phase 6 (CMIP6). We find that hydropower generation would be altered significantly in all scenarios in terms of temporal variability and magnitude due to the changes in duration and magnitude of the summer monsoon. Our findings further stress the importance of exploring how the impact of climate change on hydropower availability propagates through water-energy systems and call for adaptive reservoir operation strategies.

    How to cite: Galelli, S. and Dang, T. D.: Assessing the impact of climate change on Southeast Asia’s hydropower availability, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4561, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4561, 2022.

    EGU22-4658 | Presentations | HS2.5.1

    Implementation and sensitivity analysis of a dam-reservoir model over Spain 

    Malak Sadki, Simon Munier, and Aaron Boone

    Water resources are considered to be a major challenge for the coming century, particularly in the context of climate change and increasing demographic pressure. Water resources are directly linked to the continental water cycle and its processes are mainly described by hydrological models. ISBA-CTRIP, developed at the CNRM, is an example of a coupled land surface - river routing model used for this purpose. However, anthropogenic impacts on water resources, and in particular the effects of dams-reservoirs on river flows, are still poorly known and generally neglected in global hydrological models, including ISBA-CTRIP. This study focuses on the improvement of the CTRIP river routing model, recently upgraded to 1/12° resolution, by integrating the effects of man-made reservoirs. This work is in preparation for the upcoming SWOT mission, which will provide the data necessary to make improved global scale river and reservoir storage and flow estimates.

    A parameterized reservoir model was developed based on Hanasaki's scheme (Hanasaki et al., 2006). The model differentiates between irrigation and non-irrigation reservoirs, computes the mass balance in the reservoir and calculates monthly releases based on inflows and water demands. Using a first default parameterization, the model is run on the highly anthropized river basins in Spain. An operating rule is determined for each of the 215 largest reservoirs and simulated outflows and water storage variations are evaluated against in situ observations over the overall period 1979-2014. Results reveal the positive contribution of the model in representing the seasonal cycle of discharge and storage variation, specifically for irrigation large-storage capacity reservoirs as the model succeeds in reproducing the seasonal shift between inflows and outflows caused by irrigation management rules. The Nash-Sutcliff Efficiency (NSE) median index for discharge was 0.68, which corresponds to an outflow representation improvement of 28%, if compared to the naturalized representation of river flows. For irrigation reservoirs, the improvement rate reaches 67% in the median. 

    An exhaustive sensitivity analysis regarding the 7 parameters of the model was conducted on the performance of an NSE bounded version on outflows using the Sobol method. Following Saltelli's approach, sampling is performed using the probability density functions defined for each parameter input, and first-, second- and total-order Sobol indices are estimated. The study is carried out separately on irrigation and non-irrigation reservoirs. It is shown that the most influencing parameter is the threshold coefficient describing demand-controlled release level : in the median, ~54% and ~80% of the total variance, respectively in the two reservoir categories, is assigned to this parameter alone. On the other hand, parameters specifying the ideal reservoir filling level and the minimum release have less influence on monthly long-term mean outflows variance. The second-order Sobol indices revealed several interactions between parameters and explained the observed bias between first- and total-order indices.

    The results highlight the importance of incorporating reservoir operation in large scale hydrological models and represent a very useful step to further improve river flow modeling, through calibration schemes and SWOT data assimilation, by targeting the most influencing reservoir model parameters.

    How to cite: Sadki, M., Munier, S., and Boone, A.: Implementation and sensitivity analysis of a dam-reservoir model over Spain, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4658, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4658, 2022.

    EGU22-5118 | Presentations | HS2.5.1

    Error hotpots of the modelled global terrestrial water storage interannual variation 

    Hoontaek Lee, Martin Jung, Nuno Carvalhais, Tina Trautmann, Basil Kraft, Markus Reichstein, Matthias Forkel, and Sujan Koirala

    Terrestrial water storage (TWS) is a socially (e.g., floods and drought) and scientifically (e.g., water and carbon cycles) important variable. Hydrological models have been extensively used to study variations in TWS but the models are showing significant uncertainties, especially for the interannual variability (IAV). It is therefore essential for TWS IAV studies to further improve model accuracy, calling for a better understanding of the TWS IAV simulation error. We conducted a covariance matrix analysis to spatially attribute the contributions to global TWS IAV and its simulation error by two hydrological models: 1) a parsimonious process-based one, implemented in the Strategies to INtegrate Data and BiogeochemicAl moDels (SINDBAD) framework, and 2) a hybrid one, the hybrid hydrological model (H2M), which combines a dynamic neural network and a water balance concept. Both models were calibrated against observation-based data streams for evapotranspiration, snow water equivalent, and runoff, as well as against the Gravity Recovery and Climate Experiment (GRACE) satellite observations of TWS. Both models indicate that the global TWS IAV is largely driven by some regions such as Amazon, Zambezi, Mekong basins, and India. The analysis also identified hotspots of the global TWS IAV error from river basins (e.g., Amazon, Paraná, Congo, and Mekong basins) and inland water bodies (e.g., the Laurentian Great Lakes). Excluding those hotspots in the global integration, the 12-month running mean of the global TWS IAV showed a large improvement: R2 of the global TWS IAV time series was improved from 0.62 to 0.82 for SINDBAD and from 0.62 to 0.88 for H2M. Therefore, the model simulation of the global TWS can efficiently be improved by focusing on correcting the hotspot regions. Comparing GRACE and modelled TWS IAV time series revealed various potential sources of errors, including anthropogenic factors (e.g., reservoir management) and model structure (e.g., insufficient storage capacity and missing storage processes), while the latter was prevalent over many regions. A further comparison to surface water data could characterize the hotspots as areas of 1) more dynamic surface water, and 2) wetlands (i.e., near-inland water bodies). These characteristics of hotspots imply that surface water processes (e.g., seasonal inundation) are relevant for understanding global TWS IAV and are underestimated in the two tested models, calling for further improvement in that respect. Our approach presents a general avenue to identify model simulation errors for global data streams and can guide efficient model development.

    How to cite: Lee, H., Jung, M., Carvalhais, N., Trautmann, T., Kraft, B., Reichstein, M., Forkel, M., and Koirala, S.: Error hotpots of the modelled global terrestrial water storage interannual variation, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5118, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5118, 2022.

    EGU22-5321 | Presentations | HS2.5.1

    Joint assimilation of GRACE Total Water Storage Anomalies and In-Situ Streamflow Data into a Global Hydrological Model 

    Kerstin Schulze, Jürgen Kusche, Helena Gerdener, Olga Engels, Petra Döll, Hannes Müller Schmied, Sebastian Ackermann, and Somayeh Shadkam

    Global hydrological models simulate water storages and fluxes of the water cycle, motivated to assess water problems such as water scarcity, high flows and more generally the impact of anthropogenic change on the global water system. However, the models include many uncertainties due to the model inputs (e.g. climate forcing data), model parameters, and model structure which can lead to disagreements when simulation results are compared to observations. To reduce and quantify these uncertainties, some of the models are calibrated against in-situ streamflow observations or compared against total water storage anomalies (TWSA) derived from the Gravity Recovery And Climate Experiment (GRACE) satellite mission. In recent years, TWSA data are integrated into some models via data assimilation to directly improve the realism of the models.

    In this study, we present our framework for jointly assimilating satellite and in-situ observations into the WaterGAP Global Hydrological Model (WGHM). In addition to GRACE TWSA maps, for the first time here we experimentally jointly assimilate in-situ streamflow observations from gauge stations. This is in preparation for the Surface Water and Ocean Topography (SWOT) satellite, which will be launched this year and is expected to allow the derivation of streamflow observations globally for rivers wider than 50-100m.

    GRACE assimilation strongly improves the TWSA simulations in the Mississippi River Basin, e.g. the correlation increases to 91%, with which our results are consistent with previous studies. However, we find in this case that the streamflow simulation deteriorates, for example, correlation reduces from 92% to 61% at the most downstream gauge station. In contrast, jointly assimilating GRACE data and streamflow observations from GRDC gauge stations improves the streamflow observations by up to 33% in terms of e.g. RMSE and correlation while maintaining the good TWSA simulations. In view of the upcoming SWOT mission, our data suggest that the SWOT data will help to further improve the structure and simulations of global hydrological models.

    How to cite: Schulze, K., Kusche, J., Gerdener, H., Engels, O., Döll, P., Müller Schmied, H., Ackermann, S., and Shadkam, S.: Joint assimilation of GRACE Total Water Storage Anomalies and In-Situ Streamflow Data into a Global Hydrological Model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5321, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5321, 2022.

    EGU22-5368 | Presentations | HS2.5.1

    Improving impact model intercomparison by developing and applying quality control and quality assessment tools – the example of the ISIMIP global water sector 

    Hannes Müller Schmied, Matthias Büchner, Jochen Klar, Iliusi Vega del Valle, Aristeidis Koutroulis, Simon N. Gosling, Laura Dobor, Emmanuel Nyenah, and Christopher Reyer

    Process-based impact models are frequently used for a range of applications and are valuable for simulating fundamental processes in a changing world. Model Intercomparison Projects like the Inter-Sectoral Impact Model Intercomparison Project (ISIMIP, www.isimip.org) act as an umbrella for various sectors (e.g. water, agriculture, health) and numerous modelling teams that are following a common modeling protocol that enables model intercomparison and (cross-) sectoral multi-model impact assessments. However, such assessments require reliable model outputs which can be checked from two perspectives.

    First, a quality control (QC) check ensures that simulated files follow the standards defined in the modelling protocol and includes plausibility checks. For example, structural inconsistencies and correct metadata entries can be assessed, but also in cases where the range of a specific variable exceeds plausibility limits (e.g. negative precipitation values), such a tool can facilitate error checking which is very helpful especially in the case of high data volume simulation outputs (e.g., errors stemming from an erroneous unit conversion).

    Second, a quality assessment (QA) tool compares model output to observation data or benchmark models. This is particularly important for model development and improvement as it can highlight benefits and limitations of models for e.g., specific model configurations, but it also informs the identification of models that are best suited for specific regions and research questions.

    Within the EU COST-Action “Process-based models for climate impact attribution across sectors“ (PROCLIAS), the aim is to establish a QC/QA workflow for the ISIMIP models. A QC tool is already developed and in operation which checks the data format and, exemplarily for the global water sector, each variable for plausibility ranges. An operational QA tool does not yet exist within PROCLIAS and ISIMIP but some experiences have been gained with existing evaluation frameworks such as ILAMB and the ESMValTool.

    This presentation provides experiences gained with the QC tool and the application of ISIMIP data to existing QA frameworks and outlines the next milestones. It is planned to extend the plausibility ranges to all ISIMIP sectors by a survey within the modelling teams. For the QA tool, specific developments are required to integrate sector-specific evaluation methods (e.g., basin outlines into ILAMB). To use ESMValTool, the model output data needs to be restructured to a CF-compliant format. With the ISIMIP global water sector as a pilot sector, experiences are gained that will then be transferred to other sectors. This activity also calls for an exchange of ideas and experiences from other modeling communities.

    How to cite: Müller Schmied, H., Büchner, M., Klar, J., Vega del Valle, I., Koutroulis, A., Gosling, S. N., Dobor, L., Nyenah, E., and Reyer, C.: Improving impact model intercomparison by developing and applying quality control and quality assessment tools – the example of the ISIMIP global water sector, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5368, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5368, 2022.

    EGU22-5657 | Presentations | HS2.5.1

    Catchment memory explains hydrological drought forecast performance 

    Samuel J. Sutanto and Henny A. J. Van Lanen

    Skillful Drought Early Warning Systems (DEWSs) to predict drought a few months in advance are of utmost importance to reduce the impacts of the drought hazard. Previous studies on meteorological drought forecasts e.g. using the standardized precipitation index (SPI) show that drought can be sufficiently predicted up to 1-3 months ahead. The skill of hydrological drought forecasts e.g. using the standardized runoff index (SRI) and standardized ground index (SGI), on the other hand, is even 2-3 months higher than the meteorological ones. The high skill in hydrological drought forecasts is anticipated coming from the catchment storage/memory (e.g. lakes, soils, groundwater) that pools, attenuates, and lengthens the effect of the driving forces (i.e. precipitation). Yet, the importance of catchment memory in explaining hydrological drought forecast performance has not been studied. Here, we have conducted a pioneering study that investigates the importance of catchment memory on the forecast performance of streamflow drought across Europe. We identified streamflow drought using the Standardized Streamflow Index (SSI). The observed and forecasted streamflow droughts at major European rivers were derived from the streamflow data obtained from the European Flood Alert System (EFAS) driven by observed and forecasted weather data. Catchment memory was derived from the Baseflow Index (BFI) and the groundwater Recession Coefficient (gRC), which through the streamflow, give information on the catchment memory. Performance of streamflow drought forecasts was evaluated using the Brier Score (BS) for rivers across Europe. Results show that the use of higher accumulation periods in the SSI (e.g. SSI-3) forecasts improves forecast performance. The performance is even higher for catchment that has large memory. We found that BS is negatively correlated with BFI, meaning that rivers with high BFI (large memory) yield better drought prediction (low BS). A significant positive correlation between gRC and BS demonstrates that catchments slowly releasing groundwater to streams (low gRC), i.e. large memory, generates higher drought forecast performance. The higher performance of hydrological drought forecasts in catchments with relatively large memory (high BFI and low gRC) implies that Drought Early Warning Systems have more potential to be implemented there and will appear to be more useful.

    How to cite: Sutanto, S. J. and Van Lanen, H. A. J.: Catchment memory explains hydrological drought forecast performance, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5657, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5657, 2022.

    EGU22-6268 | Presentations | HS2.5.1

    Uncertainties in multi-model ensemble drought projections and implications on future drought risk 

    Yadu Pokhrel, Yusuke Satoh, and Ahmed Elkouk

    Future drought projection studies typically use multi-model ensemble climate and hydrological simulations. In particular, precipitation, soil moisture, and streamflow simulations are used to quantify the changes in meteorological, agricultural, and hydrological droughts under future climate. Many different drought indices have thus been developed and employed in these projections with different indices often leading to varying states of future droughts. Recently, terrestrial water storage (TWS) has also been used to examine future droughts considering integrated climatic and hydrologic impacts on water stores. This presentation will shed light on drought projections using precipitation, soil moisture, runoff, and TWS drought indices and highlight uncertainties in these projections, including those arising from differences in drought definition or the diversity in drought indices. The presentation will then discuss how the consideration of vulnerability alters drought risk projections, specifically by incorporating human development projections as a proxy of broad vulnerability. Results presented will be based on several dozen ensemble hydrological simulations that include multiple climate models, hydrological models, Representation Concentration Pathways (RCPs), and Shared Socioeconomic Pathways (SSPs). Emphasis will be placed on global scale analyses and regional projections over drought hotspots. The results have appeared in three recent publications.

    How to cite: Pokhrel, Y., Satoh, Y., and Elkouk, A.: Uncertainties in multi-model ensemble drought projections and implications on future drought risk, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6268, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6268, 2022.

    EGU22-6981 | Presentations | HS2.5.1

    Modeled water – vegetation dynamics under revision using GRACE-based data assimilation 

    Helena Gerdener, Jürgen Kusche, Kerstin Schulze, Gohar Ghazaryan, and Olena Dubovyk

    Water is a major source for growing crops and to ensure freshwater, thus it is essential to prevent the population from water shortages in agriculture and water supply. To globally observe changes in surface water and vegetation from space, remote-sensing satellites enabled a great opportunity in the last decades. But, especially in semi-arid and arid regions observing subsurface water gains a high importance as well. In-situ data and global hydrological models can provide subsurface information, however, the in-situ data are limited to an irregular temporal and spatial resolution that might not cover each climate regime and models do not yet perfectly represent the reality because of structural and forcing uncertainties. So far, the satellite mission GRACE (Gravity Recovery and Climate Experiment) and its successor GRACE-FO (FollowOn) are the only missions that observe the vertical sum of all water storages and thus observe surface and subsurface water, but they are limited to a coarser spatial resolution of about 300 km and can not distinguish between different water storages. To overcome these limitations, we combine GRACE observations with a global hydrological model (WaterGAP 2.2d) via data assimilation to make the model more realistic while spatially downscaling and vertically disaggregating the GRACE data into the different water compartments.

    In a case study for South Africa, we use observation-based surface water, soil moisture and groundwater (via assimilation) together with the remote sensed vegetation indices Leaf Area Index and Actual Evapotranspiration (via Moderate Resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer) to extract signatures and subsignals of the water propagation in the water cycle in the period from 2003 to 2016. The observed (via assimilation and remote-sensing) signatures are then compared to modeled signatures and subsignals. Two main processes are analyzed: First, the precipitation-storage dynamics and second, the storage-vegetation dynamics. Thus, we assess the propagation of water that is beginning as precipitation, recharges water storages and finally contributes to vegetation growth. Our study shows an overestimation of the amount of precipitation in the model that refills the water storages and also an overestimation of the amount of water stored that contributes to vegetation growth. Furthermore, we identify differences in the duration of the precipitation-storage-vegetation process. For example, we find that in general the annual peak of modeled groundwater lags the annual precipitation peak by 3 months, while the observations identify a 4-month lag. We believe that this study highlights the importance of assimilating GRACE into hydrological models and that modelers can use this information in future to improve model structures and relevant model processes.

    How to cite: Gerdener, H., Kusche, J., Schulze, K., Ghazaryan, G., and Dubovyk, O.: Modeled water – vegetation dynamics under revision using GRACE-based data assimilation, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6981, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6981, 2022.

    EGU22-7102 | Presentations | HS2.5.1

    Towards the establishment of a global COsmic-ray Soil Moisture Observing System 

    Rafael Rosolem, Daniel Power, Miguel Rico-Ramirez, John Patrick Stowell, David McJannet, Martin Schrön, and Heye Bogena

    Soil moisture is an important component of the water balance despite accounting for a small volume relative to other hydrological cycle components. With the continuing evolution of land surface and global hydrological models, characterizing soil moisture dynamics at sub-kilometer scales is becoming ever important. To help with that, the cosmic-ray neutron sensing is an established technology that provides estimates of root-zone soil moisture at 200-300m radius. In simple terms, cosmic-ray neutron sensors can estimate root zone soil moisture through an indirect relationship between measured neutrons scattered from the soil and the amount of hydrogen atoms observed in the soil water.

    Following its development in the late 2010s and the establishment of the first COsmic-ray Soil Moisture Observing System (COSMOS) network in the USA, a continuing adoption of this technology has been observed over the years, notably with the establishment of other national scale networks in Germany, Australia, and in the UK. As the cosmic-ray neutron sensing technology matures, so does our understanding on how to better isolate the soil moisture signal from other sources of hydrogen within the sensor footprint. However, despite recent improvements in our understanding, continental and global-scale datasets from cosmic-ray stations are still inexistent, partially due to a lack of proper data harmonization. This is simply because distinct networks operate under their own data processing protocols. This poses unwanted limitations to the use of these data by the wider scientific community.

    Here, we introduce the initial steps towards the harmonization of cosmic-ray neutron sensors worldwide. The harmonization is performed using the state-of-the-art and recent developed Cosmic-Ray Sensor PYthon data processing tool, applied to publicly available data from more than 200 stations. We highlight examples of applications using this global harmonized dataset in hydrology, agriculture, and environmental sciences; and present an open discussion about challenges and opportunities in potentially establishing a Global COSMOS network.

    How to cite: Rosolem, R., Power, D., Rico-Ramirez, M., Stowell, J. P., McJannet, D., Schrön, M., and Bogena, H.: Towards the establishment of a global COsmic-ray Soil Moisture Observing System, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7102, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7102, 2022.

    EGU22-7274 | Presentations | HS2.5.1

    The eWaterCycle platform for open and FAIR computational hydrological research 

    Rolf Hut, Niels Drost, Nick van de Giesen, Ben van Werkhoven, Jerom Aerts, Fakhereh Alidoost, Peter Kalverla, Stefan Verhoeven, Bouwe Andela, Jaro Camphuijsen, Yifat Dzigan, Gijs van den Oord, Inti Pelupessy, and Barbara Vreede

    The eWaterCycle platform (https://www.ewatercycle.org/) is a fully Open Source and ‘FAIR by Design’ Platform where hydrologists can do computational hydrological research using their own, or other’s, models and data. Using eWaterCycle, computational hydrologist can focus on the hydrological part of their work, without the headache that often comes with the computational part.

    In eWaterCycle experiments are separated from models: experiments are build and run in Jupyter notebooks and models can be accessed as objects in these notebooks. The models themselves are ‘hidden’ in (Docker) containers and accessed through an easy interface. This interface and the technology behind it that we’ve build allows computational hydrologists to work with (each others) models written in different programming languages without having to access that code. Currently PCRGlobWB 2.0, Hype, LISFlood, WFLOW and MARMoT are among the models supported by eWaterCycle.

    Furthermore, pre-processing of atmospheric forcing data is handled transparently by ESMValTool, which separates the process of selecting and standardising variables from the steps needed to make forcing compatible with a specific model. If a source of forcing data has been made ready for one model in eWaterCycle it is easy to use it for any other. If a model has been used with one forcing data source, it is easy to swap it with another. Currently ERA5 and ERA-Interim are supported in eWaterCycle.

    With eWaterCycle use cases such as (but not limited to!) these are now easier to implement:

    • Comparing two models for the same region against observation data (GRDC discharge observations are standard supported) to determine which model performs best for a given research question
    • Coupling two models (in different programming languages) to exchange information at every timestep, for example making a
    • Running a multi-model ensemble (including adding data assimilation of observations)

    Previously we have announced eWaterCycle as work in progress. At the 2022 General Assembly we will demonstrate the release of v1.0 of the eWaterCycle platform, giving the computational hydrological community access to a platform that supports fully reproducible, open, and FAIR Hydrological modelling.

    This work is currently under open review for publication in GMD: https://gmd.copernicus.org/preprints/gmd-2021-344/ and parts of this work have been presented at the AGU 2021 Fall Meeting.

    How to cite: Hut, R., Drost, N., van de Giesen, N., van Werkhoven, B., Aerts, J., Alidoost, F., Kalverla, P., Verhoeven, S., Andela, B., Camphuijsen, J., Dzigan, Y., van den Oord, G., Pelupessy, I., and Vreede, B.: The eWaterCycle platform for open and FAIR computational hydrological research, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7274, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7274, 2022.

    EGU22-7312 | Presentations | HS2.5.1

    Effect of merging large datasets on prediction accuracy of low flow estimation by random forest 

    Johannes Laimighofer and Gregor Laaha

    Low flow estimation is a crucial part in water management. Prediction of low flow in ungauged basins is often performed through statistical models. This can be either regionalization approaches, where homogeneous regions are used for modeling, or single model frameworks that range from simple linear models to more complex as random forest, support vector regression or deep learning approaches. Although there are large sample studies for the US (e.g. Tyralis et al. 2021) or Australia (e.g. Worland et al. 2018), we are not aware of a study that combines different large datasets and analyzing the effect on prediction accuracy. We are hypothesing that the heterogeneity of many datasets together can improve prediction accuracy for tree-based models relative to linear models. Hence, we propose to combine several similar datasets and analyze the effect on prediction accuracy for estimating Q95 by a simple random forest model.

    Our study uses four large hydrological datasets – CAMELS-GB (Coxon et al. 2020), CAMELS-US (Addor et al. 2017), CAMELS-AUS (Fowler et al. 2021) and LamaH-CE (Klinger et al., 2021). We are applying a random forest model to ensure that interactions and non-linearity can be captured. Prediction accuracy is evaluated by leave one out cross-validation (LOOCV) and several performance metrics, e.g. median absolute error (MDAE), or root mean squared error (RMSE). LOOCV is used for each individual dataset and in one run for the merged dataset. Results indicate that merging datasets can improve prediction accuracy, but models fail to correctly predict low flows around zero.

    References

    • Addor, N., Newman, A. J., Mizukami, N., and Clark, M. P.: The CAMELS data set: catchment attributes and meteorology for large-sample studies, Hydrol. Earth Syst. Sci., 21, 5293–5313, https://doi.org/10.5194/hess-21-5293-2017, 2017.
    • Fowler, K. J. A., Acharya, S. C., Addor, N., Chou, C., and Peel, M. C.: CAMELS-AUS: hydrometeorological time series and landscape attributes for 222 catchments in Australia, Earth Syst. Sci. Data, 13, 3847–3867, https://doi.org/10.5194/essd-13-3847-2021, 2021.
    • Coxon, G., Addor, N., Bloomfield, J. P., Freer, J., Fry, M., Hannaford, J., Howden, N. J. K., Lane, R., Lewis, M., Robinson, E. L., Wagener, T., and Woods, R.: CAMELS-GB: hydrometeorological time series and landscape attributes for 671 catchments in Great Britain, Earth Syst. Sci. Data, 12, 2459–2483, https://doi.org/10.5194/essd-12-2459-2020, 2020.
    • Klingler, C., Schulz, K., and Herrnegger, M.: LamaH-CE: LArge-SaMple DAta for Hydrology and Environmental Sciences for Central Europe, Earth Syst. Sci. Data, 13, 4529–4565, https://doi.org/10.5194/essd-13-4529-2021, 2021.
    • Tyralis, H.; Papacharalampous, G.; Langousis, A.; Papalexiou, S.M. Explanation and Probabilistic Prediction of Hydrological Signatures with Statistical Boosting Algorithms. Remote Sens. 2021, 13, 333. https://doi.org/10.3390/rs13030333
    • Worland, S. C., Farmer, W. H., and Kiang, J. E.: Improving predictions of hydrological low-flow indices in ungaged basins using machinelearning, Environmental modelling & software, 101, 169–182, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envsoft.2017.12.021, 2018.

    How to cite: Laimighofer, J. and Laaha, G.: Effect of merging large datasets on prediction accuracy of low flow estimation by random forest, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7312, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7312, 2022.

    EGU22-8161 | Presentations | HS2.5.1

    How do different drought types respond to climate change? 

    Parisa Hosseinzadehtalaei, Bert Van Schaeybroeck, and Hossein Tabari

    More frequent, longer, and more intense droughts are expected in many regions of the world because of climate change. Although drought can propagate from precipitation to runoff and soil moisture, the anticipated climate change impact, however, varies with different drought types. We investigate the response of meteorological, hydrological, and agricultural droughts to climate change for the end of this century using a multimodal ensemble of the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project Phase 6 (CMIP6) under the four Tier 1 ScenarioMIP scenarios (SSP1-2.6, SSP2-4.5, SSP3-7.0, and SSP5-8.5). The projected changes in five characteristics (median duration, longest duration, median intensity, peak intensity, and frequency) of the different drought types at the global level are compared on seasonal and annual time scales. Our results show that the spatial extent and magnitude of the increasing signals in all the characteristics rise from meteorological to hydrological and agricultural droughts. This gradient is highest for the median and longest duration of droughts with the largest increases among the five characteristics considered.

    How to cite: Hosseinzadehtalaei, P., Van Schaeybroeck, B., and Tabari, H.: How do different drought types respond to climate change?, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8161, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8161, 2022.

    EGU22-8551 | Presentations | HS2.5.1

    ROBIN - A Reference Observatory of Basins for INternational hydrological climate change detection  

    Stephen Turner, Lucy Barker, Harry Dixon, Jamie Hannaford, Adam Griffin, and Alannah Killeen and the ROBIN Network

    Floods and droughts may become more severe in a warming world, potentially furthering the significant adverse impacts they cause to lives and livelihoods, infrastructure, and economies. To adapt to future changes in water quantity and regimes, we need to detect and attribute emerging trends in hydrological variables such as river flow, and we require updated projections of future flood and drought occurrence.

    Numerical simulation models are used to provide such scenarios, but they are complex and highly uncertain. We can use long records of past hydrological observations to better understand and constrain these model-based projections; river flows are especially useful because they integrate climate processes over the areas covered by drainage basins.

    There have been many studies of long-term changes in river flows around the world although, at a global scale (as represented by successive IPCC (Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change) reports), confidence in observed trends remains very low. This is primarily due to the modification of river flows by human activities (e.g., presence of dams, land-cover change, channelisation and the abstraction of water for public water supplies, industry and agriculture). These human disturbances can obscure climate change signals and distort trends in river flows and in some cases lead to a complete reversal of the trends / changes caused by climate change. It is also challenging to integrate the results of various regional- and national-scale studies due to the many different methods used, hampering consistent continental- and global-scale assessments.

    Therefore, to detect climate-driven trends we need to analyse river basins that are relatively undisturbed by human impacts. Recognising this, many countries have ‘Reference Hydrometric Networks’ (RHNs) consisting of catchments where river flows are measured, and where human impacts are absent or minimal. Globally however, these are sparse and there is a need for an integrated approach to advance international assessments of hydrological change on a consistent basis, such that they can provide a robust foundation for global and regional assessments such as those undertaken by the IPCC.

    Here we introduce the 'Reference Observatory of Basins for INternational hydrological climate change detection' or ROBIN initiative, where we are advancing a worldwide effort to bring together a global RHN. With a growing network of partners from 20 countries spanning a broad range of climates and geographies, over the next two years ROBIN will develop a consistently defined network of near-natural catchments across the world, sharing knowledge from countries with established RHNs to enable other countries to define similar networks. ROBIN will use this network to undertake the first, truly global scale analysis of trends in river flows using minimally disturbed catchments.

    With the support of international organisations, including WMO, UNESCO and IPCC, ROBIN will lay the foundations for an enduring network of catchments, to support global assessments of climate-driven trends and variability in the future.

    How to cite: Turner, S., Barker, L., Dixon, H., Hannaford, J., Griffin, A., and Killeen, A. and the ROBIN Network: ROBIN - A Reference Observatory of Basins for INternational hydrological climate change detection , EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8551, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8551, 2022.

    EGU22-10789 | Presentations | HS2.5.1

    A Global Assessment of the Spatial-Temporal Origin of Soil Water Taken up by Vegetation 

    Gonzalo Miguez Macho and Ying Fan

    Vegetation modulates Earth’s water, energy and carbon cycles and provides a key link between water stores in the deep soil and the atmosphere. How its functions may change in the future largely depends on how it copes with droughts. There is evidence that in places-times of drought, vegetation shifts water uptake to deeper soil and rock moisture and groundwater. We differentiate and assess plant use of four types of water source: precipitation (P) in current month, past P stored in deeper unsaturated soils/rocks, past P stored in locally recharged groundwater, and groundwater from P fallen on uplands via river-groundwater convergence toward lowlands. We examine global and seasonal patterns and drivers in plant uptake of the four sources using inverse modeling and isotope-based estimates. We find that globally and annually, 70% (std 24%) of plant transpiration relies on current month P, 18% (std 15%) on deep soil moisture, only 1% (std 3%) on locally recharged groundwater, and 10% (std 22%) on groundwater or river water from upland more distant sources; (2) regionally and seasonally, recent P is only 19% in semi-arid, 32% in Mediterranean, and 17% in winter-dry tropics in the driest months; (3) at landscape scales, deep soil moisture, taken up by deep roots in the deep vadose zone, is critical in uplands in dry months, but groundwater and river water from uplands is up to 47% in valleys where riparian forests and desert oases are found. Because the four sources originate from different places-times, move at different spatial-temporal scales, and respond with different sensitivity to climate and anthropogenic forces, understanding space-time origin of plant water source can inform ecosystem management and Earth System Models on the critical hydrologic pathways linking precipitation to vegetation.

    How to cite: Miguez Macho, G. and Fan, Y.: A Global Assessment of the Spatial-Temporal Origin of Soil Water Taken up by Vegetation, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10789, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10789, 2022.

    EGU22-11224 | Presentations | HS2.5.1

    Most River Basins will Follow their Budyko Curves under Global Warming 

    Fernando Jaramillo, Luigi Piemontese, Wouter Berghuijs, Lan WAng-Erlandsson, and Peter Greve

    The Budyko framework consists of a curvilinear relationship between the evaporative ratio (i.e., actual evaporation over precipitation) and the aridity index (potential evaporation over precipitation) and defines evaporation’s water and energy limits. A basin’s movement within the Budyko space illustrates its hydroclimatic change and can help identify the main drivers of change. Basins are expected to move along their Budyko curves when only long-term changes in the aridity index drive changes in the evaporative ratio. We hypothesize that the increasing effects of global warming on the hydrological cycle will cause basins to move along their Budyko curves. To test our hypothesis, we quantify the movement in Budyko space of 353 river basins from 1901 to 2100 based on the outputs of nine models from the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project - Phase 5 (CMIP5). We find that significant increases in potential evaporation due to global warming will lead to basins moving primarily horizontally in Budyko space accompanied by minor changes in the evaporative ratio. However, 37% of the basins will still deviate from their Budyko curve trajectories, with less evaporation than expected by the framework. We elaborate on how land-use change, vegetation changes, or shifts in precipitation or snow to rain ratios can explain these deviations.

    How to cite: Jaramillo, F., Piemontese, L., Berghuijs, W., WAng-Erlandsson, L., and Greve, P.: Most River Basins will Follow their Budyko Curves under Global Warming, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11224, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11224, 2022.

    EGU22-2117 | Presentations | HS2.5.2

    Evaluation of the novel Drought Potential Index (DPI) over Japan 

    Abhishek Abhishek and Tsuyoshi Kinouchi

    Despite receiving an annual rainfall of about 1718 mm (twice as the global average of 810 mm), Japan has erratically faced water shortages at various levels. Since most of these events last less than six months, their detailed assessment remains largely unexplored. Here, firstly we correct the GRACE- and GRACE-FO-derived terrestrial water storage anomaly (TWSA) for co- and post-seismic corrections corresponding to the Tohoku-Oki earthquake (Mw=9.1) that occurred on March 11th, 2011. Secondly, we fill the 34 missing values (23 due to battery management and 11 between the two missions) in the TWSA time series using the ANN and LSTM models. Lastly, we employ the Drought Potential Index (DPI) recently devised by Abhishek et al. (Journal of Hydrology, Volume 603, Part A, 2021, 126868) to quantity the drought potential of the region. The seismic correction using the least square fitting of the TWSA in the spectral domain results in a 76% increase (raw: -3.50 mm yr-1 vs. corrected: -0.83 mm yr-1) in linear trends from May 2002 to April 2020. The seismic correction accounts for an increase of 54.45 mm of TWSA during March 2011, with continually decreasing post-seismic relaxations until 2017. Both ANN and LSTM performed reasonably well (r>0.85, NSE>0.70) during calibration and validation phases, and therefore, an average of the two modeled TWSA was used during the data gaps. The maximum water storage deficit (DPI = 1) was observed during July 2014, followed by September 2016 and October 2012 (DPI≈0.85 for both). Some other years of significant water-stressed conditions include 2005, 2007, 2008, and 2013. The crux of this effective water storage-based DPI is that, unlike traditional assessment of water deficit, it considers the monthly potential water deficit and is therefore capable of capturing the droughts that evolve during dry and wet seasons. DPI can also indicate the long-term tendency and transition of the study region to a drought-prone area.

    How to cite: Abhishek, A. and Kinouchi, T.: Evaluation of the novel Drought Potential Index (DPI) over Japan, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2117, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2117, 2022.

    EGU22-3078 | Presentations | HS2.5.2

    The contribution of glaciers to streamflow and surface water supply: a global-scale analysis 

    Denise Cáceres and Petra Döll

    Glaciers are important contributors to streamflow (Q), acting as water storage units during the accumulation season of a glaciological year and releasing water during its melting season. Glaciers often play an essential role in semiarid regions where the anthropogenic pressure on surface water resources is very high (e.g., Indus basin). The climate-driven glacier retreat observed worldwide is having major consequences on surface water supply. Here, we present a model-based approach to estimate the contribution of glaciers to streamflow and surface water supply over the global continental area (except Greenland and Antarctica). We refer to this contribution, i.e. the fraction of Q that can be explained by the presence of glaciers as opposed to their absence, as glacier-dependent streamflow (GDS). GDS is derived from the global hydrology model WaterGAP 2.2d at 0.5° resolution; it is equal to the difference between Q computed with the standard version of the model, which does not include glaciers, and Q computed with a non-standard version that includes glaciers (Cáceres et al., 2020). Global maps of mean yearly and mean monthly GDS are given in absolute values (m3/s), and in percentage of Q and of consumptive water use from surface water over two 30-year periods, 1951-1980 and 1981-2010. The model performance is evaluated by comparing Q simulated with WaterGAP 2.2d including glaciers to observations from the Global Streamflow Indices and Metadata archive (GSIM) downstream from glaciers. With this study, we aim (1) to identify the regions that rely the most on GDS for surface water supply and are therefore most vulnerable to water scarcity problems related to glacier retreat, (2) to identify spatial and temporal changes (e.g., shifts in seasonality, long-term trend) in GDS between 1951-1980 and 1981-2010, and (3) to evaluate the performance of WaterGAP 2.2d including glaciers in terms of Q.

    Cáceres, D., Marzeion, B., Malles, J. H., Gutknecht, B. D., Müller Schmied, H., and Döll, P.: Assessing global water mass transfers from continents to oceans over the period 1948–2016, 24, 4831–4851, https://doi.org/10.5194/hess-24-4831-2020, 2020.

    How to cite: Cáceres, D. and Döll, P.: The contribution of glaciers to streamflow and surface water supply: a global-scale analysis, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3078, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3078, 2022.

    EGU22-4269 | Presentations | HS2.5.2

    Estimating global scale evapotranspiration using soil-based evaporation characteristic length and root zone depth distribution 

    Peter Lehmann, Surya Gupta, Dani Or, and Andrea Carminati

    Evapotranspiration (ET) modeling is central to resolving water and energy balances and linking the terrestrial water and carbon cycles. An important challenge remains how to partition the ET flux into transpiration (T) and soil evaporation (E). We expand the surface evaporation capacitor model of Or and Lehmann (2019) by considering concurrent root water uptake. The original capacitor model simulates surface evaporation (focusing on stage-1) and internal redistribution following rainfall events. The thickness of the evaporation-active soil layer is defined by an intrinsic soil property termed the evaporation characteristic length (deduced from soil water characteristics and hydraulic conductivity functions). The modified model considers water extraction by plant roots  from the capacitor layer as well as water redistributed into deeper layers (sheltered from soil evaporation but accessible for root water uptake). Depending on the amount of water leaking below the capacitor depth, vegetation can take up this natural storage at rates limited by the hydraulic properties of the rhizosphere. To model evapotranspiration and its partitioning at the global scale, we use spatial information on (i) maximum root depth and (ii) soil hydraulic properties defining the depth of the capacitor layer. We assess the performance of the ET capacitor model in comparison with results from available land surface models and estimates based on remote sensing products.

    How to cite: Lehmann, P., Gupta, S., Or, D., and Carminati, A.: Estimating global scale evapotranspiration using soil-based evaporation characteristic length and root zone depth distribution, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4269, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4269, 2022.

    EGU22-4372 | Presentations | HS2.5.2

    Multivariate evaluation of four high-resolution hydrological models at  global scale 

    Luis Samaniego, Oldrich Rakovec, Alberto Martinez de la Torre, Edwin Sutanudjaja, Pallav K. Shrestha, Eleanor Blyth, Niko Wanders, Matthias Kelbling, and Stephan Thober

    Global hydrological models (GHMs) are a fundamental component of the Earth System Modeling  initiative that aims to realize a Digital Twin in the next five to ten years [1]. Recent model evaluations of the state-of-the-art global hydrological models [2,3], however, indicate that existing models have several deficiencies that lead to poor model efficiencies of key terrestrial environmental variables such as runoff, evapotranspiration, and soil moisture, among others. 

    In this study, we evaluate four hydrological models: JULES, HTESSEL, mHM, and PCR-GLOBWB. These models are part of the modelling chain of the Copernicus Climate Change Service project ULYSSES [4], which aims to deliver global operational hydrological forecasts at a spatial resolution of 0.1$^\circ$. The operational service started in July 2020 and the data will be provided every month through the Copernicus Data Store.

    The initial conditions of the GHMs for the hindcast skill assessment are obtained with the ERA5-land reanalysis [5]. This global dataset provides meteorological forcings (e.g., precipitation and temperature) since 1950 with daily time steps. For this reason, historical simulations of streamflow, obtained with these GHMs from 1981 until 2020 will be cross-evaluated against observed streamflow provided by 2850 GRDC gauging stations. Simulations of evapotranspiration and terrestrial water storage anomalies were evaluated against GRACE and FLUXNET datasets, respectively.

    During the model calibration phase, models were evaluated in a stratified sample of size 120 basins (i.e., considering hydroclimatic regions and locations around the world). The results of the evaluation indicate that the median value of the Nash-Sutcliffe efficiency obtained with daily streamflow for these models varies from 0.20 to 0.50. The mean Kling-Gupta efficiency (KGE) metric ranges from 0.45 to 0.63. The maximum KGE value corresponds to the mHM model, while the other models are clustered around 0.45.

    This result alone is quite promising considering the results presented in Beck et al. [2]. One reason for these good results is the relation between the standardization of the input data sets and the common routing model (mRM [6]) with a very detailed river network [7]. The considerable difference in performance between mHM and the other GHMs can be attributed to the parameterization of the models and model structure. mHM is the only GHM that employs the MPR technique [8] and includes fast and slow interflow components. Evaluation metrics obtained with the ILAMB [8] tool indicate that all models have exhibited satisfactory efficiencies (> 0.5 variable score) for monthly climatologies of latent heat, evapotranspiration and runoff. mHM, JULES, and PCR-GLOBWB, perform relatively well, representing the terrestrial water storage anomaly, although any of these models have explicit a detailed representation of the groundwater aquifers.

    In this presentation, specific results of the model cross-validation, per geographic region will be presented. Finally, recommendations for further GHM model improvement will be discussed.

    References:
    [1] Bauer, P. et al. https://doi.org/10.1038/s43588-021-00023-0  2021
    [2] Beck, H.E., et al.  https://doi.org/10.1002/2015WR018247, 2016.
    [3] Harrigan, S et al. https://doi.org/doi:10.5194/essd-12-2043-2020 2020. 
    [4] https://www.ufz.de/ulysses, ECMWF/COPERNICUS/2019/C3S\_432\_Lot3\_UFZ
    [5] https://www.ecmwf.int/en/era5-land
    [6] Thober et al. https://doi.org/10.5194/gmd-12-2501-2019, 2019
    [7] http://hydro.iis.u-tokyo.ac.jp/~yamadai/cama-flood/index.html
    [8] Samaniego et al. https://doi.org/10.1029/2008WR007327, 2010
    [9] https://www.ilamb.org. 

    How to cite: Samaniego, L., Rakovec, O., Martinez de la Torre, A., Sutanudjaja, E., Shrestha, P. K., Blyth, E., Wanders, N., Kelbling, M., and Thober, S.: Multivariate evaluation of four high-resolution hydrological models at  global scale, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4372, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4372, 2022.

    The countries of Southeast Asia are projected to experience severe flood damage and economic impacts from climate change, compared with the global average. Thailand is the second-largest economy in Southeast Asia and future flood damage is likely to hinder the economic growth of Thailand because Bangkok City (the commercial hub of the country) is located in the Chao Phraya River delta, where floods are frequent. Despite this fact, thus far, comparatively little research has been conducted to investigate the combined effects of climate change, human activities, and adaptation measures on flood risk reduction in the Chao Phraya River Basin (CPRB). Therefore, this study was conducted in the CPRB to examine the adaptation potential of (i) existing structural and non-structural measures that include reservoir and diversion dams, diversion canals, and water retention areas, and (ii) a combination of alterations made to the existing diversion canals and retention areas (combined adaptation) on reducing future floods using the H08 global hydrological model.

    Future flood risk was analyzed using various flood risk indicators including flood frequency, number of flooding days, and annual maximum daily discharge. The results revealed that the impact of existing measures on the future flood reduction was smaller than the increase caused by warming in the upper and lower CPRB. Although the combined adaptation measures had considerable potential to reduce the magnitude and duration of future floods in the CPRB, extreme floods may continue to occur in the basin and further strategies are needed to alleviate the flood risk. Our findings emphasize that the integration of various existing structural and non-structural measures along with adaptation measures will be insufficient to completely mitigate future flood risk in the CPRB although the considered measures can greatly reduce future flooding. This study highlights the areas of the CPRB that are vulnerable to extreme flooding in the future and thus require area-based prioritization for flood management. Moreover, this study clearly indicated that GHMs can be effectively implemented for the design of regional adaptation measures.

    How to cite: Padiyedath Gopalan, S. and Hanasaki, N.: Countermeasures against flood in the Chao Phraya River Basin, Thailand - Assessment and adaptation to combat climate change, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5336, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5336, 2022.

    EGU22-6085 | Presentations | HS2.5.2

    Estimating global terrestrial water storage components by a physically constrained recurrent neural network 

    Basil Kraft, Martin Jung, Marco Körner, Sujan Koirala, and Markus Reichstein

    While deep learning models are capable of representing complex temporal processes in a data-adaptive way, they lack physical consistency and interpretability. Thus, the combination of machine learning and physically-based approaches in so-called hybrid modeling has been proposed recently [1]. Gathering insights into complex Earth system processes in a data-driven way has, arguably, a large potential for hydrology. This is, on the one hand, due to the richness of Earth observations of hydrological quantities, such as terrestrial water storage, runoff, snow cover, or evapotranspiration. On the other hand, the large uncertainties in current global hydrological models across spatial and temporal scales motivate the exploration of alternative, complementary approaches.

    In this work [2], we evaluate an experimental approach for the global, data-driven decomposition of terrestrial water storage. Therefore, we developed a dynamic hybrid model which represents the main terrestrial water storage components of groundwater, soil moisture, and snowpack. The model consists of a recurrent neural network that estimates spatiotemporally varying and physically interpretable quantities, which are used as coefficients in a set of hydrological balance equations. The hybrid model is fed with meteorological variables and gridcell-level landscape properties and is optimized end-to-end using gridded evapotranspiration, runoff, terrestrial water storage, and snow water equivalent.

    By outsourcing the estimation of coefficients to a neural network, we achieve improved local data adaptivity. The simulated fluxes and storage components are realistic and plausible overall, and our approach yields a larger contribution of soil moisture to the terrestrial water storage variations compared to physically-based hydrological models, especially in tropical savanna regions. The presented approach is a proof of concept of the hybrid modeling approach for the global terrestrial water cycle and we acknowledge uncertainties due to data and physical constraints that can be further improved. The presented work is a first step toward the data-driven yet physically constrained estimation of global water storage components and could find broad application in the Earth sciences.

    [1] Reichstein et al. (2019, Nature) https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-019-0912-1

    [2] Kraft et al. (2021, HESSD) https://hess.copernicus.org/preprints/hess-2021-211/

    How to cite: Kraft, B., Jung, M., Körner, M., Koirala, S., and Reichstein, M.: Estimating global terrestrial water storage components by a physically constrained recurrent neural network, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6085, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6085, 2022.

    EGU22-6409 | Presentations | HS2.5.2

    Long-term impact of land use change on the simulation of distributed regional-scale groundwater recharge in cold and humid climates 

    Emmanuel Dubois, Marie Larocque, Philip Brunner, and Sylvain Gagné

    Although the long-term impacts of climate change on the different water budget components have been widely studied, numerous challenges in accounting for land use (LU) changes in regional scale hydrologic simulations remain. As it can be challenging to map the evolution of LU and incorporate the changes in models, models are often calibrated with the hypothesis that LU is constant through time. Therefore, little is known about the quantitative impact of LU change on the water budget components and more specifically on the regional-scale groundwater recharge (GWR), although it is widely accepted that GWR depends on LU. The objective of this work was to assess the impact of LU changes on the simulation of regional-scale GWR and identify the magnitude of changes to produce significant changes in GWR. GWR was simulated with a transient-state spatialized superficial water budget over three regional-scale watersheds (>2 000 km2) in the cold and humid climate of southern Quebec (Canada). The model computes snow accumulation and snowmelt, as well as soil freezing to provide spatially distributed runoff, actual evapotranspiration, and GWR fluxes with a monthly time step on a 500 m x 500 m grid. Four versions of the model are calibrated over the 1990-2017 period considering constant LU, constant LU and rainfall interception in forested areas, transient LU (annual time step, two data sources), and transient land use and rainfall interception in forested areas. The model versions with transient LU performed better and were calibrated with sets of statistically different parameters while the model versions with rainfall interception did not systematically enhanced the calibration results. Because the observed LU changes were relatively limited during the 1990-2017 period in the study areas, the simulated variables with the four versions were not significantly different. To assess the joint effects of LU change and climate change on GWR, two scenarios of future LU changes were developed and combined with climate change scenarios to simulate future GWR. Results were analyzed to identify the type and intensity of LU changes necessary to produce significant changes in GWR.

    How to cite: Dubois, E., Larocque, M., Brunner, P., and Gagné, S.: Long-term impact of land use change on the simulation of distributed regional-scale groundwater recharge in cold and humid climates, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6409, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6409, 2022.

    EGU22-6789 | Presentations | HS2.5.2

    Impact of rainfall intensity on GRACE total water storage across Australia 

    Amirhossein Shadmehri Toosi, Okke Batelaan, Margaret Shanafield, and Huade Guan

    Climate change has a significant impact on the environment by increasing the frequency of extreme precipitation events. Underestimating the potential risks of such events and lack of climate resilience will result in a substantial crisis in terms of water security. Understanding the hydrological consequences is difficult due to complexities and additional environmental feedbacks, depending on landuse/landcover, soil and climate.

    The Gravity Recovery and Climate Experiment (GRACE) has provided an unprecedented perspective on global fluctuations in terrestrial water storage (TWS) over the past decade. While numerous studies have correlated different hydrological variables against TWS, no study has tested different rainfall thresholds (intensity) impacting TWS. Existing studies mostly have explored the relationship between TWS anomalies and hydrological variables using individual responses, while few have looked at multi-variable interaction. Single indicators (e.g., standardized precipitation index) may limit ecohydrological understanding of soil-vegetation-atmosphere water transfer, as many factors play essential roles in land-atmosphere interactions. In particular, rainfall characteristics can significantly impact the interaction between hydrological factors by accelerating or slowing processes. Hence, including appropriate temporal resolution of precipitation in analyses is essential; e.g., monthly data are not a good indicator for understanding ecohydrological interactions. Therefore, this research aims to improve our understanding of the spatiotemporal response of TWS to climate change impacts on rainfall characteristics. Monthly GRACE TWS time series anomalies are analyzed against aggregated monthly rainfall with different daily thresholds (intensities). The obtained results are used to find explanatory variables such as land use/land cover, soil type, and climatic zones that determine the significance between TWS and various variables. The methodology provides a valuable insight into the mechanisms in which TWS is affected by rainfall characteristics at different spatiotemporal scales across various hydrological contexts across Australia.

    How to cite: Shadmehri Toosi, A., Batelaan, O., Shanafield, M., and Guan, H.: Impact of rainfall intensity on GRACE total water storage across Australia, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6789, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6789, 2022.

    EGU22-7708 | Presentations | HS2.5.2

    Implications of river storage for integrating GRACE TWS observations into a global hydrological model 

    Tina Trautmann, Sujan Koirala, Andreas Güntner, Hyungjun Kim, and Martin Jung

    Over the last decade Terrestrial Water Storage (TWS) variations from GRACE and GRACE-FO satellite gravimetry have provided valuable observations for validation and calibration of hydrological models, and for data assimilation. While GRACE estimates represent the vertically integrated variations of all water storages, previous studies have shown the regional relevance of surface water and flood plain storage for TWS variations, and the inability to reproduce observed TWS by global hydrological models is often attributed to neglecting processes of river routing and floodplain dynamics. However, it is unclear if these processes need to be considered by computationally expensive river routing schemes in hydrologic model calibration and validation at large to global scales.  

    In this exploratory analysis, we assess the effect of river water storage that is included in the vertically integrated GRACE TWS variations on the calibration of a global hydrological model, and its relevance for model validation. For this purpose, we first determine an observation-based estimate of river storage by applying a routing scheme on GRUN runoff data, considering different effective flow velocities. Obtained river storage is then removed from GRACE TWS, and the TWS variations either with or without river storage are used along with other observational based data of evapotranspiration, soil moisture and runoff to constrain parameters of a simple global hydrological model that does not encompass a river routing module in a multi-criteria calibration approach. 

    While the removal of river storage changes the TWS constraint itself, especially its amplitude, at regional and global scale, we do not find a significant influence on calibrated parameters and thus model simulations. Instead, issues related to data uncertainty and inconsistency, as well as hydrological processes neglected by the model impose greater limitations than the rather local to regional relevance of river water storage. Furthermore, additional constraints from other data streams seem to not allow for adjustment to the changed TWS constraint in the calibration approach. However, simulating and adding river storage to modelled TWS after model calibration improves model validation relative to GRACE TWS globally and regional. Largest improvement is obtained in tropics and Northern low- and wetlands, where a substantial volume of water accumulates in major rivers, highlighting the importance of considering river water in these regions. Difficulties to reproduce TWS variations are mainly apparent in semi-arid regions where a generally lower volume of water is stored on land surface and neglected processes (e.g. evaporation and percolation from the flow channel) play a role. 

    While it’s arguable that the presented results are quite specific to the used data and model structure, the key issues are shared among global hydrological modelling studies. Therefore, our findings suggest that omitting routing for large-scale model calibration against GRACE TWS is a valid option, considering limited computational and temporal resources. Nonetheless, the findings encourage the inclusion of river storage dynamics for validation of large-scale hydrological studies.

    How to cite: Trautmann, T., Koirala, S., Güntner, A., Kim, H., and Jung, M.: Implications of river storage for integrating GRACE TWS observations into a global hydrological model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7708, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7708, 2022.

    EGU22-8292 | Presentations | HS2.5.2

    Global Snow Water Equivalent for continuous groundwater monitoring from space: uncertainties, evaluation, and application 

    Miriam Kosmale, Kari Luojus, Jaakko Ikonen, and Pinja Venäläinen

    Sufficient groundwater resources are unarguably essential for human populations all over the world. With a contribution of over 30% to freshwater reserves in the global hydrological cycle, it is important to increase the capacity of the currently sparse groundwater monitoring network. Spatially and temporally continuous monitoring of groundwater as an Essential Climate Variable (ECV) can be realized with remote sensing techniques. Within the “Global Gravity-Based Groundwater Product” G3P-project (www.g3p.eu), gravimetric satellite missions GRACE and GRACE-FO are applied for global groundwater monitoring. Groundwater derived from gravimetric measurements require detailed knowledge of all continental water compartments, which are contributing to the total water storage variations.

    Within the G3P project the Finnish Meteorological Institute is producing a global gap-filled Snow Water Equivalent (SWE) product that describes the snow compartment for global groundwater estimation. The product complements remote sensing-based information with model-based data for regions where remote sensing can’t observe SWE on global scale.

    The production of SWE from long-term satellite observations covering the full GRACE and GRACE-FO mission period from 2002 to 2021 are investigated. The Finnish Meteorological Institute efforts within the Copernicus Land monitoring service and ESA frameworks ensure operational Near-Real-Time information on SWE for the Northern hemisphere. Microwave and optical remote sensing sensor techniques are the basis for the SWE monitoring services. Validation with in-situ reference data is important in understanding product accuracy. Pixel-level uncertainties provided with the snow product support efforts on groundwater estimation. Model- and remote sensing-based SWE are evaluated on various regional scales.  As part of the new Gravity-Based Groundwater Product G3P, global Snow Water Equivalent products will be presented and discussed.

    How to cite: Kosmale, M., Luojus, K., Ikonen, J., and Venäläinen, P.: Global Snow Water Equivalent for continuous groundwater monitoring from space: uncertainties, evaluation, and application, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8292, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8292, 2022.

    EGU22-8714 | Presentations | HS2.5.2

    Capturing future soil-moisture droughts from irregularly distributed ground observations 

    Verena Bessenbacher, Lukas Gudmundsson, and Sonia I. Seneviratne

    With a rapidly warming climate, future droughts are predicted to increase in frequency, duration, extent, and severity for many regions, whilst uncertainty of drought predictions in CMIP6 ensembles remains high. Monitoring the occurrence of agricultural and ecological droughts (i.e. soil moisture droughts), in present and future climate is therefore vital. However, available drought monitoring products do not use information from soil moisture ground observations, although those are the only observations available that extend into the vegetation-relevant root zone.

    A central challenge of these ground observations (included in the international soil moisture network ISMN) is that they are not evenly distributed across the globe, favoring Europe and the US. Upscaling these observations to global soil moisture estimates for drought monitoring can lead to underrepresented areas suffering from misrepresentation of drought occurrences. Installing new measurement stations is costly, therefore placing them should focus on alleviating the problem of these underrepresented regions and ecosystems. 

    We apply a statistical learning method to identify under-represented ecosystems and environmental conditions to inform future station placement. We overlay these maps with future drought occurrence maps and drought uncertainty maps to scan for regions that are especially vulnerable in the future given the current station net. The analysis is built around an up-scaling approach where the model is trained to predict station-level soil moisture as a function of gridded atmospheric precipitation and temperature. The resulting model can be used to estimate soil moisture at locations without observations. For doing so we rely on the CMIP6 ensemble as a laboratory, which enables us to create virtual soil moisture stations based on continuously available soil moisture simulations. 

    The first results show that strategically placing new soil moisture observation stations where the climate space is most under-sampled leads to an increase of drought estimation accuracy. We are planning to further investigate hypothetical station configurations and follow up with the question of where future “station measurement years” should optimally be distributed around the globe to increase drought monitoring from ground observation in areas with low station coverage but high drought risk and high uncertainty in future projections. 

    How to cite: Bessenbacher, V., Gudmundsson, L., and Seneviratne, S. I.: Capturing future soil-moisture droughts from irregularly distributed ground observations, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8714, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8714, 2022.

    EGU22-8759 | Presentations | HS2.5.2

    Nonstationarity in Global Hydrological Water Budget, Evidence-based on GRACE Satellite Mission 

    Emad Hasan, Himanshu Save, Mark Tamisiea, and Srinivas Bettadpur

    Anthropogenic climate change (ACC) has led to a significant shift in the hydrological water budget natural balance. The human-induced modifications in water systems, land cover, and land use have introduced the notion of “nonstationarity” in the hydrologic system. The concept implies significant changes in the hydrologic systems’ intra-annual and interannual variabilities with a time-variant mean, variance, and non-uniform density distribution. Under nonstationary conditions, extreme weather and climate events became frequent. Their magnitudes, durations, and frequencies are outside the historically observed ranges. A nonstationary system displays a volatile memory that hinders any reliable future projections. We revaluate the nonstationarity in global hydrological systems using gravity measurements from the GRACE (Gravity Recovery and Climate Experiment) mission. We utilized GRACE mascons (mass concentration blocks) solutions of RL06 from the Center for Space Research (CSR) between April 2002 to June 2017. We employed the KPSS and the ADF tests for stationarity in deterministic and periodic components, respectively. The KPSS test identified 25 hotspots globally that are nonstationary around the deterministic trend. These hotspot locations have undergone extensive anthropogenic activities on the available freshwater resources. The ADF test mapped the nonstationary systems around the mean and the variance components in 11 hotspot locations. These locations are noted by the KPSS test as nonstationary systems around the trend as well. Understanding the nonstationary state in hydrologic systems will enhance our awareness and preparedness to mitigate future extremes.

    How to cite: Hasan, E., Save, H., Tamisiea, M., and Bettadpur, S.: Nonstationarity in Global Hydrological Water Budget, Evidence-based on GRACE Satellite Mission, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8759, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8759, 2022.

    EGU22-9061 | Presentations | HS2.5.2

    Improving land surface hydrological simulations over France using a high resolution river network and a description of anthropocentric pressures 

    Lucia Rinchiuso, Agnès Ducharne, Jan Polcher, Philippe Peylin, Pedro Arboleda Obando, Anthony Schrapffer, and Eric Sauquet

    The evolution and possible limitation of water resources under climate change will become a crucial problem over the next decades and accurate hydrological projections are fundamental tools to assess the problem. The goal of this study is to improve the simulation of both river discharges and evaporation with the ORCHIDEE (Organising Carbon and Hydrology in Dynamic Ecosystems) land surface model by accounting for a high-resolution river network and water management influence.

    This work will allow us to produce long-term projections of river discharge in France under different regional-scale climate change scenarios for the national project Explore2 and the French climate services.

    To this end, we present here the evaluation and calibration of an improved version of ORCHIDEE, run off-line over France with atmospheric forcing from the SAFRAN reanalysis at an 8-km resolution and 1-hourly time step. First, we implement a high-resolution river routing scheme recently developed to better reproduce the water flow through the river network from the source to the outlet. It relies on topographical and hydrological information from the MERIT Hydro (Multi-Error-Removed Improved-Terrain) digital elevation model scaled at a 2km resolution, which allows us to define sub-basins at a higher resolution than the atmospheric forcing and to correctly position a majority of French gauging stations along the reconstructed rivers.

    By comparing the discharge simulations to observations from the French hydrometric database (http://hydro.eaufrance.fr/) on about 800 stations with variable upstream areas, selected for their long and good-quality record, and medium-to-low human pressures, we find a very general overestimation of river discharge by the model, except in mountainous areas where earlier studies showed that the SAFRAN reanalysis was underestimating precipitation. The comparison of the simulated evapotranspiration to the data-driven FLUXCOM gridded product, over the upstream area of each selected station, shows a systematic underestimation, which can be explained by the underestimation of precipitation over mountains, and is elsewhere consistent with the overestimation of river discharge.

    Further comparison to water withdrawals and consumption data from the national database BNPE (http://bnpe.eaufrance.fr/) suggests that both river discharge overestimate and evapotranspiration underestimate can be partly attributed to the neglect of water management in ORCHIDEE, although the studied stations have been selected for their weak human influence. We will thus incorporate water management information in ORCHIDEE in two ways: by activating an irrigation parametrization to consistently describe the impact of this human pressure on both river discharge and evapotranspiration, and by reducing river discharge from the other abstraction sources. The related parameters will finally be calibrated such as to best reproduce the observed discharge, evapotranspiration, and irrigation withdrawals.

    How to cite: Rinchiuso, L., Ducharne, A., Polcher, J., Peylin, P., Arboleda Obando, P., Schrapffer, A., and Sauquet, E.: Improving land surface hydrological simulations over France using a high resolution river network and a description of anthropocentric pressures, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9061, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9061, 2022.

    EGU22-9614 | Presentations | HS2.5.2

    Distinguishing Direct Human-driven Changes in the Global Terrestrial Water Cycle 

    Elisie Kåresdotter, Zahra Kalantari, and Georgia Destouni

    Growing populations contribute to increased pressures on water resource availability. Understanding the impacts of various human pressures on terrestrial water flows is important to meet the challenges of sustainable water resource management. For useful assessment of and planning for societal water-availability impacts, it is also imperative to disentangle the direct influences of human activities in the landscape from external climate-driven influences on water flows and their variation and change. One approach to such disentanglement is to use a distributed global hydrological model that can realistically represent climate and direct anthropogenic modifications of the water system. This study uses this approach to quantify and separate the climate-driven change components of key hydrological variables (evapotranspiration, runoff, soil moisture, and storage change) from the human-driven change components that are modified by interventions such as dams, water reservoirs, and water withdrawals for irrigation, industry, and households. Using a global hydrological model in two different modes, one with and one without the inclusion of human activities, the result differences indicate the direct anthropogenic influences. Human activities are found to drive changes to all hydrological variables with different magnitudes and directions depending on geographic location. The largest differences between the pristine and the human-activity model runs are seen in regions with the highest population density. In such regions, which also tend to have relatively large numbers of dams used for irrigation, water storage is largely decreasing and feeding into increased runoff and evapotranspiration. Our findings provide new knowledge of how humans affect different hydrological fluxes and storages globally, including a more complete set of hydrological variables than in previous studies. This enables closure of hydrological balances and informs further research on historic and future hydrological trends, which is of special interest for areas lacking historic data and being particularly vulnerable to water availability changes.

    Keywords: Hydrological variability and change; Global hydrological modeling; Anthropogenic change; Climate-driven change; Water fluxes and storages

    How to cite: Kåresdotter, E., Kalantari, Z., and Destouni, G.: Distinguishing Direct Human-driven Changes in the Global Terrestrial Water Cycle, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9614, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9614, 2022.

    EGU22-12034 | Presentations | HS2.5.2

    LATICE MIP evapotranspiration – A model intercomparison project for evapotranspiration estimates at high latitudes 

    Kolbjorn Engeland, Kjetil Schanke Aas, Helene Birkelund Erlandsen, Emiliano Gelati, Shaochun Huang, Devaraju Narayanappa, Norbert Pirk, Olga Silantyeva, Lena Merete Tallaksen, Astrid Vatne, and Yeliz Yilmaz

    We present a new initiative, LATICE MIP-ET, with the aim to compare model estimates of evapotranspiration (ET) in a high latitude environment. The study is part of the LATICE (Land-ATmosphere Interactions in Cold Environments) strategic research initiative at the University of Oslo.

    The main motivation for LATICE MIP-ET is the need to improve knowledge about the actual evapotranspiration in cold environments. Recent estimates of mean annual evapotranspiration for Norway summarized in Erlandsen et al (2021) range from 175 – 500 mm/year, i.e. between 13 and 31% of mean annual precipitation. These estimates are based on different gridded versions of the hydrological, water balance model HBV, where the estimated evapotranspiration depends on precipitation inputs and streamflow measurements included in the model calibration. No reference measurements of evapotranspiration are used to benchmark the model estimates.

    The aim of this MIP is to constrain the range of the estimated mean annual evapotranspiration by (i) introducing local observations of evapotranspiration and (ii) compare model estimates from two land surface models (CLM and SURFEX) and two hydrological models (SHYFT and HBV). Model estimates are compared at three scales, namely point, catchment, and regional. At the point scale, field observations of evapotranspiration are available at five eddy covariance flux sites covering a gradient in climate across Norway, from low altitude forested and grassland sites to high mountain and high latitude sites. At these sites we compare the models’ ability to capture diurnal and seasonal variations in evapotranspiration and compare to the observations. We will also compare how models simulate the relationship between potential and actual evapotranspiration and assess the models’ sensitivity to the choice of vegetation-and soil parameters. The second scale is the river catchment scale. For a selected set of catchments, we compare simulated water balance to observed discharge and evaluate the sensitivity to atmospheric forcing and land cover. The third scale is the regional scale. At this scale we compare mean annual estimates of evapotranspiration for the whole of Norway. The comparison will include mapping the spatial and temporal distribution of evapotranspiration fractions (transpiration, soil evaporation, and canopy evaporation).

    The presentation will focus on the design of the LATICE MIP-ET, including the choice of regional and local forcing and land cover data, and the first results of the model intercomparison at the local scale. In a follow-up study we aim to invite the scientific community to join the MIP.

    This work is a contribution to the Strategic Research Initiative ‘Land Atmosphere Interaction in Cold Environments’ (LATICE) of the University of Oslo and the EMERALD research project. 

    References:

    Erlandsen, H.B., Beldring, S., Eisner, S., Hisdal, H., Huang, S., Tallaksen, L.M. (2021) Constraining the HBV model for robust water balance assessments in a cold climate. Hydrology Research 2021; nh2021132. doi: https://doi.org/10.2166/nh.2021.132

    How to cite: Engeland, K., Aas, K. S., Erlandsen, H. B., Gelati, E., Huang, S., Narayanappa, D., Pirk, N., Silantyeva, O., Tallaksen, L. M., Vatne, A., and Yilmaz, Y.: LATICE MIP evapotranspiration – A model intercomparison project for evapotranspiration estimates at high latitudes, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12034, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12034, 2022.

    The increasing population numbers and demand for food has greatly increased the dependence of irrigated crops on groundwater resources. This has resulted in a steep rise of groundwater withdrawal for irrigation around the globe, with a decline of groundwater levels and the potential economic depletion of aquifers as a result. In this presentation we revisit the classic problem of determining economically optimal groundwater withdrawal rates for irrigation. The novelty compared to previous mathematical analyses is the inclusion of non-linear groundwater-surface water interaction that allows for including the impact of capture and the application of this framework at the global scale.

    We base our analysis on a recently published analytical framework of groundwater-surface water interaction subject to groundwater pumping (Bierkens et al., 2021). This framework distinguishes between two regimes: 1. a physically stable withdrawal regime, for which groundwater withdrawal q is smaller than a critical withdrawal rate qcrit. Here, groundwater level decline reaches an equilibrium and all groundwater withdrawal eventually comes out of capture; 2. a physically non-stable regime (q > qcrit) where groundwater withdrawal is larger than maximum capture and leads to persistent groundwater level decline. Using a simple hydroeconomic model based on competition of resources, we derive an equation for the optimal withdrawal rate under the stable regime. Similarly, we use the hydroeconomic model to derive economically optimal withdrawal and depletion trajectories for the non-stable regime assuming either full competition or optimal control (intertemporal efficiency). The expressions derived for optimal depletion trajectories under the non-stable regime are a generalization of the work of Gisser and Sánchez (1980), by including (non-linear) groundwater-surface water interaction.

    We apply the hydroeconomic framework at the global scale, limited to regions with significant groundwater use for irrigation. For the regions with stable groundwater withdrawal (q<qcrit) we determine the optimal withdrawal rate qopt and check whether it is attainable in the stable regime (qopt < qcrit). We also assess the economic gain that can be achieved when the current withdrawal is set equal to qopt. For regions with non-stable groundwater withdrawal (q>qcrit) we estimate the final groundwater level decline and associated net present value (NPV) of accumulated profits over time, and compare these between competition and optimal control. This allows us to assess, at first order, globally where the so-called Gisser-Sánchez effect olds, in that competition and optimal control lead to similar depletion rates and economic value. Finally, we use the hydroeconomic framework to assess for regions with non-stable groundwater withdrawal (q>qcrit) whether it is more profitable (in the long run) to pursue controlled depletion or reduce withdrawal rates to the stable regime.

    How to cite: Bierkens, M., van Beek, R. L. P. H., and Wanders, N.: Revisiting optimal groundwater withdrawal under irrigation: including groundwater-surface water interaction and global analyses, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-989, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-989, 2022.

    EGU22-1009 | Presentations | HS2.5.3

    A more active role for groundwater in the land water cycle 

    Wouter Berghuijs, Scott Allen, Scott Jasechko, Christian Moeck, Elco Luijendijk, and Ype van der Velde

    How much precipitation recharges groundwaters varies enormously across Earth's surface, but recharge rates are uncertain because field observations are sparse and modeled global estimates remain largely unvalidated. Here we show that annual recharge is predictable as a simple function of climatic aridity — the ratio of long-term potential evapotranspiration to precipitation — using a global synthesis of measured recharge of 5237 sites across six continents. We use this relationship to estimate long-term recharge globally outside of permafrost regions. Our estimates double previous global hydrological model estimates and are more consistent with empirical field observations. These revised higher estimates of global groundwater recharge imply that groundwater contributes more actively to evapotranspiration and streamflow than previously represented in global water cycle depictions or global hydrological and Earth system models. In addition, we quantify the sensitivity of groundwater recharge to changes in aridity using the empirical relationship between groundwater recharge rates and climatic aridity. This analysis indicates that recharge is most sensitive to climate aridity in mesic regions, where changes in the replenishment of aquifers will be amplified relative to projected changes in precipitation. Global hydrological models seem to underestimate changes in recharge with climate aridity. Thus, the impacts of climatic changes on the replenishment of Earth's largest liquid freshwater stores may be larger than previously anticipated.

    How to cite: Berghuijs, W., Allen, S., Jasechko, S., Moeck, C., Luijendijk, E., and van der Velde, Y.: A more active role for groundwater in the land water cycle, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1009, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1009, 2022.

    EGU22-1659 | Presentations | HS2.5.3

    The Global Gravity-based Groundwater Product (G3P): first results 

    Ehsan Sharifi and Andreas Güntner and the G3P team

    The Global Gravity-based Groundwater Product (G3P) aims at developing a satellite-based groundwater storage (GW) data set as a new product for the EU Copernicus Climate Change Service. As the world’s largest distributed freshwater storage, GW is a key resource for mankind, industrial, and agricultural demands. In Copernicus, there is no service available yet to deliver data on this fundamental resource, nor is there any other data source worldwide that operationally provides information on changing groundwater resources in a consistent way, observation-based, and with global coverage. Therefore, G3P develops an operational global groundwater service as a cross-cutting extension of the existing Copernicus portfolio. G3P capitalizes from the unique capability of GRACE and GRACE-FO satellite gravimetry as the only remote sensing technology to monitor subsurface mass variations, and from other satellite-based water storage products to provide a data set of groundwater storage change for large areas with global coverage. G3P is obtained by using a mass balance approach, i.e., by subtracting satellite-based water storage compartments (WSCs) such as snow water equivalent, root-zone soil moisture, glacier mass, and surface water storage from GRACE/GRACE-FO monthly terrestrial water storage anomalies (TWSA). For a consistent subtraction of all individual WSCs from GRACE-TWSA, the individual WSCs are filtered in a similar way as GRACE-TWSA, where optimal filter types were derived by analyses of spatial correlation patterns. G3P groundwater variations are provided for almost two decades (from 2002 to the present), with the monthly resolution, and at a 0.5-degree spatial resolution globally. In this contribution, we also illustrate preliminary results of the G3P data set and of its uncertainties, as well as its evaluation by independent groundwater data.

    This study has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme for G3P (Global Gravity-based Groundwater Product) under grant agreement nº 870353.

    How to cite: Sharifi, E. and Güntner, A. and the G3P team: The Global Gravity-based Groundwater Product (G3P): first results, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1659, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1659, 2022.

    EGU22-2374 | Presentations | HS2.5.3

    How does thawing permafrost change groundwater discharge? A case study from southern Siberia 

    Li Han, Hotaek Park, and Lucas Menzel

    In permafrost environments, groundwater recharge and groundwater flow are strongly affected by seasonal thawing and freezing cycles, the depth of the active layer, and the spatial coverage of permafrost. In such areas, groundwater is an important supply to the regional water resources, especially during the cold season when the frozen ground strongly restricts the water flows close to the ground and the runoff in rivers. However, due to absent or very limited groundwater observations in the permafrost domain, in combination with remoteness and harsh environments such as in Siberia, key processes and factors that control the subsurface dynamics on the large scale are not well understood yet. In a warming climate, the storage and movement of water in the subsurface system are expected to be altered through degrading permafrost and changing underground connections. However, due to the lack of corresponding studies, assumptions in this regard are very speculative.

    Based on long-term daily river flow records (1950-2010) of large southern Siberian catchments (about 1,600,000 km² in total) with different permafrost conditions, we investigate the historical variations in magnitude, timing, and duration of low flow (as an indicator of groundwater dynamics) during the winter period. Our results show that the magnitude of low flow in the catchments has increased during 1950-2010, with the most considerable rise being noticed in the late 30-years period since 1980. Furthermore, we also found that the occurrence of the minflow (i.e., the minimum value of low flow) fluctuates between early and late winter in the catchments with sparse permafrost coverage. In contrast, in the catchments where continuous permafrost prevails, the minflow always occurs in late winter. Finally, for the catchments underlain by discontinuous permafrost, the timing of minflow shows relatively stable conditions in the earlier 30-year period. However, it starts fluctuating between early and late winter during the latter 30 years when a significant rise in low flow is observed. Given the unprecedented warming over the last decades in southern Siberia, these significant changes in both the magnitude and timing of low flow could be induced by the altered surface water-groundwater interactions that are triggered by the degrading permafrost. Overall, our results provide insights into the potential evolutions in the large-scale groundwater dynamics over varied temporal and spatial distributions of permafrost under a warming climate.

    How to cite: Han, L., Park, H., and Menzel, L.: How does thawing permafrost change groundwater discharge? A case study from southern Siberia, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2374, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2374, 2022.

    EGU22-2495 | Presentations | HS2.5.3

    GRACE-derived groundwater storage estimation: Lake/Reservoir storage controls across Canada 

    Mohamed Akl, Brian Thomas, and Jon Mills

    Abstract:
    Accurate estimation of groundwater storage is hindered by the lack of direct observations of groundwater over space and time. Gravity Recovery and Climate Experiment (GRACE) satellite observes total water storage, thus presenting issues in applying water budget approaches to extract GRACE-derived groundwater storage. This is especially true in regions with complicated hydrology, ranging from numerous small lakes/reservoirs, elevation variation, and changes in active layer thickness in regions with frozen ground. While the objective of many GRACE studies is to disaggregate total water storage budget, to separately estimate groundwater storage changes, the influence of reservoir storage change within a basin is generally ignored. Extraction of groundwater time series from GRACE, using hydrologic and land surface model output, fails to capture storage changes caused by changes in lake and reservoir storage. In significant surface water areas, reservoir storage may alter water storage changes by increasing leakage errors, and offsetting seasonal variability, leading to accumulation of errors in groundwater estimates. Here, we conducted data-driven experiments to understand the spatial influence of lake and reservoirs on GRACE-derived groundwater storage estimation, using independent information of recorded lake/reservoir water level. The study included comparisons with in-situ groundwater observations throughout Canada to validate our GRACE-derived groundwater storage signal. Accounting for reservoir storage combined with GRACE, improved out estimate of GRACE-derived groundwater storage changes for most basins. Identifying what factors did or did not influence goodness of fit will be addressed.

    Acknowledgement: The researcher, Mohamed Akl, is funded by a full scholarship from the Ministry of Higher Education of the Arab Republic of Egypt.

    How to cite: Akl, M., Thomas, B., and Mills, J.: GRACE-derived groundwater storage estimation: Lake/Reservoir storage controls across Canada, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2495, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2495, 2022.

    The application of machine learning in geosciences began several decades ago and is, especially in the advent of increasing and affordable computational power, continuously gaining popularity. However, in some specific areas such as hydrogeology, where processes are partly or fully subsurface, the application of machine learning is still limited due to either missing or noisy data, such as in mapping hydrogeochemical parameters of aquifer properties. The presented dataset EU-MOHP v013.1.0 partly closes this gap. It provides cross-scale information on the multiorder hydrologic position (MOHP) of a geographic point within its respective river network and catchment as gridded maps. More precisely, it comprises the three measures “lateral position” (LP) as a relative measure of the position between the stream and the catchment divide, “divide stream distance” (DSD) as sum of the distances to the nearest stream and divide and “stream distance” (SD) as an absolute measure of the distance to the nearest stream. These three measures are calculated for several hydrologic orders to reflect different spatial scales. Its spatial extent covers major parts of the European Economic Area (EEA39), which also largely coincides with physiographical Europe. Although there might be many potential use cases, this dataset serves predominantly as valuable static environmental predictor variable for hydrogeological and hydrological modelling such as mapping or regionalization tasks using machine learning. The concept is strongly inspired by Belitz et al. (2019), who generated this dataset for conterminous USA.

    How to cite: Nölscher, M., Mutz, M., and Broda, S.: Multiorder Hydrologic Position for Europe (EU-MOHP) as a Set of Environmental Predictor Variables for Hydrologic Modelling and Groundwater Mapping with Focus on the Application of Machine Learning, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2543, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2543, 2022.

    EGU22-4158 | Presentations | HS2.5.3

    Pan-European high-resolution groundwater recharge mapping – combining satellite data and national survey data using machine learning 

    Simon Stisen, Grith Martinsen, Helene Bessiere, Yvan Caballero, Julian Koch, Antonio Juan Collados-Lara, Majdi Mansour, Olli Sallasmaa, David Pulido Velázquez, Natalya Hunter Williams, and Willem Jan Zaadnoordijk

    Groundwater recharge quantification is essential for sustainable groundwater resources management, but typically limited to local and regional scale estimates. A high-resolution (1 km x 1 km) dataset consisting of long-term average actual evapotranspiration, effective precipitation, a groundwater recharge coefficient, and the resulting groundwater recharge map has been created for all of Europe using a variety of pan-European datasets and seven national gridded recharge estimates. As an initial step, the approach developed for continental scale mapping consists of a merged estimate of actual evapotranspiration originating from satellite data and the vegetation controlled Budyko approach to subsequently estimate effective precipitation.  Secondly, a machine learning model based on the Random Forest regressor was developed for mapping groundwater recharge coefficients, using a range of covariates related to geology, soil, topography and climate. A common feature of the approach is the validation and training against effective precipitation, recharge coefficients and groundwater recharge from seven national gridded datasets covering the UK, Ireland, Finland, Denmark, the Netherlands, France and Spain, representing a wide range of climatic and hydrogeological conditions across Europe.  The groundwater recharge map provides harmonised high-resolution estimates across Europe and locally relevant estimates for areas where this information is otherwise not available, while being consistent with the existing national gridded estimates. The Pan-European groundwater recharge pattern compares well with results from the global hydrological model PCR-GLOBWB 2. At country scale, the results were compared to a German recharge map showing great similarity. The full dataset of long-term average actual evapotranspiration, effective precipitation, recharge coefficients and groundwater recharge is available through the EuroGeoSurveys’ open access European Geological Data Infrastructure (EGDI).

    How to cite: Stisen, S., Martinsen, G., Bessiere, H., Caballero, Y., Koch, J., Juan Collados-Lara, A., Mansour, M., Sallasmaa, O., Pulido Velázquez, D., Hunter Williams, N., and Jan Zaadnoordijk, W.: Pan-European high-resolution groundwater recharge mapping – combining satellite data and national survey data using machine learning, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4158, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4158, 2022.

    EGU22-7057 | Presentations | HS2.5.3

    Understanding coastal groundwater processes in a changing climate: A perceptual model of global-scale coastal groundwater dynamics 

    Daniel Kretschmer, Robert Reinecke, Nils Moosdorf, Holly Michael, and Thorsten Wagener

    Groundwater is the primary drinking water supply of billions of people worldwide. While groundwater is under pressure globally due to extensive water abstractions, proximity to coasts amplifies these pressures due to potential sea water intrusion that can endanger groundwater quality. It is unclear how climate change (changing potential groundwater recharge), as well as rising sea levels, will alter coastal groundwater dynamics, i.e., submarine groundwater discharge and seawater intrusion.

    Various factors impact coastal groundwater dynamics, including groundwater recharge & extraction, hydraulic gradients, permeabilities, water densities, and oceanic activity (e.g., tidal pumping and wave setup). It is currently unclear how much these different factors control submarine fluxes along global coastlines. We developed perceptual models of coastal groundwater fluxes based on a literature review of regional and global models. Here we present our perceptual model and discuss it in the context of currently available global data, uncertainties, climate change, and whether it can be implemented with an existing Open Source global groundwater modeling framework (G³M-f).

    How to cite: Kretschmer, D., Reinecke, R., Moosdorf, N., Michael, H., and Wagener, T.: Understanding coastal groundwater processes in a changing climate: A perceptual model of global-scale coastal groundwater dynamics, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7057, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7057, 2022.

    EGU22-7127 | Presentations | HS2.5.3

    Estimating groundwater storage changes for major river basins in France using a regional groundwater data set 

    Kuei-Hua Hsu, Annette Eicker, Mehedi Hasan, Andreas Güntner, and Laurent Longuevergne

    The German Research Unit GlobalCDA has the goal to improve the predictive skills of hydrological models by combining remote sensing information using a calibration/data assimilation (C/DA) approach. In order to validate model results and to assess the success of the C/DA efforts, independent data sets are crucially needed, such as in-situ groundwater observations to assess the ability of the model to describe groundwater storage changes. The main challenge arising from such comparisons is to capture basin-scale groundwater storage from a set of in-situ GW observations settled in highly heterogeneous lithologies with irregular & non-homogeneous sampling. Furthermore, the conversion from groundwater (GW) level measurements to storage variations requires information on specific yield, ideally given site-specific for each monitoring well. However, this information is largely not available and difficult to estimate in areas with highly heterogeneous geology.

    In our study we use a data set of groundwater level observations at about 3000 groundwater monitoring wells in France. Based on a high-resolution hydro-geological information system provided by the French geological survey (BRGM) and water authorities (BDLISA), we assign the borehole data to individual hydro-geological units. For the upscaling to river basin averages, we (i) aggregate the measurements that originate from the same unit and (ii) account for the areal fractions of the hydro-geological units within the river basin. For the interpretation of GW level variations to GW storage changes, we tested several approaches to estimate specific yield values for the individual hydro-geological units. Wherever possible, we use the specific yield values explicitly provided in the BDLISA data base, mostly estimated from pumping test analysis. When not available, we assign literature-based specific yield values based on the detailed lithological information provided for each unit. This method is compared to global porosity information provided by low resolution geological data from GHYLMPS (Gleeson et al., 2014)

    Besides presenting the methodological approach, this presentation shows the resulting groundwater storage time series, averaged for individual river basins in France and for individual 0.5° grid cells. Additionally, comparisons to simulated groundwater storage variations of the WaterGAP Global Hydrology Model (WGHM) will be presented. We discuss the sensitivity of basin averaged GW storage time series to different choices of specific yield for individual boreholes.

    How to cite: Hsu, K.-H., Eicker, A., Hasan, M., Güntner, A., and Longuevergne, L.: Estimating groundwater storage changes for major river basins in France using a regional groundwater data set, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7127, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7127, 2022.

    EGU22-7966 | Presentations | HS2.5.3

    Identification of large-scale aquifer behavior across three decades of groundwater storage change in the western Mediterranean region 

    Rafael Chavez Garcia Silva, Robert Reinecke, Emmanouil Varouchakis, Jaime Gómez-Hernández, Michael Rode, and Seifeddine Jomaa

    The Mediterranean region is undergoing increasing climatic and anthropogenic pressures that challenge water security. Groundwater is a strategic resource for agriculture and water supply in the region, buffering climate change impacts. While previous studies have focused on specific aquifers' water budgets and trends at plot scales, regional dynamics remain unclear. One of the challenges for assessment is the uneven distribution of access to groundwater level monitoring data, as it's not centralized and publicly accessible in most Mediterranean countries. Here we present results that focused on analyzing the groundwater level trends in the countries with the most available groundwater level information: France, Portugal, and Spain. This study contributes to our understanding of groundwater dynamics under varying drivers and groundwater-depletion mitigation options.

    As a system with 'memory,' analyzing decades of time series is essential to understand the changes, vulnerability, and resilience. For 1985-1994, 1995-2004, and 2005-2014, a trend analysis was performed on the groundwater levels for piezometers (n=844) covering these periods with considerable completeness. We identified clusters of similar groundwater level developments and categorized them into nine aquifer archetypes, for example: stable water table depth, continued depletion, groundwater level recovery, and local gaining or depleting water levels occurring in each of the three decades. Furthermore, the influence of climate and geological variables on these temporal evolutions were analyzed. Overall, about a third of the studied piezometers showed trends in at least one of the periods. Increasing depths were observed more abundantly in the first period (1985-1994), while decreasing depths were more abundant in the last period.

    This work was developed in the scope of the InTheMED project. InTheMED is part of the PRIMA programme supported by the European Union's Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 1923.

    How to cite: Chavez Garcia Silva, R., Reinecke, R., Varouchakis, E., Gómez-Hernández, J., Rode, M., and Jomaa, S.: Identification of large-scale aquifer behavior across three decades of groundwater storage change in the western Mediterranean region, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7966, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7966, 2022.

    EGU22-8739 | Presentations | HS2.5.3

    Accelerating large scale groundwater simulation with machine learning: modeling approaches and science implications for changing systems 

    Laura Condon, Andrew Bennett, Hoang Tran, Ben Horowitz, Elena Leonarduzzi, Peter Melchior, and Reed Maxwell

    It is well established that groundwater is an important buffer to hydrologic systems; stabilizing water supplies across spatial scales and long time frames. However, groundwater surface water interactions are non-linear and can vary greatly based on climate and hydrogeologic setting.  This challenge is exacerbated in changing systems where shifting land cover, extreme droughts and floods can significantly change groundwater storage, discharge and recharge dynamics. Observations of groundwater levels and the hydrogeologic properties that govern flow are sparse both in space and time.  As a result, we rely heavily on physically based numerical models to help us understand this critical component of the hydrologic cycle. There are an increasing number of national to global scale groundwater models that take a variety of numerical approaches and simplify the system to varying degrees.  One of the challenges we face is that the integrated models best suited to capture changing dynamics, are also by far the most computationally expensive. This creates a trade-off between the physical complexity we can represent and the size of the ensembles we can explore (another critical dimension in highly uncertain systems). 

                Here we will explore the potential for machine learning emulators to help accelerate solutions while maintaining physically rigorous solutions in changing systems. First, we present progress in the development of the next generation high resolution (1km2) ParFlow model of the contiguous US (ParFlow-CONUS).  Next, we explore a range of machine learning architectures that have been developed to emulate the national model. Here we focus on solutions that can emulate the full 3D subsurface system as this allows for the most flexibility in hydrologic applications.  Specifically, we explore 3D convolutional neural networks, recursive neural networks and LSTM approaches.  For every approach we evaluate the fidelity with which the machine learning model can emulate the physics-based model. We focus specifically on performance for extreme hydrologic conditions both when the ML emulator is provided training data on these cases and when the ML model is applied to out of sample scenarios.  One of the key strengths of physically based hydrologic models is their ability to represent scenarios that we haven’t seen in the past. This can be a large challenge for purely data driven ML approaches which can provide erroneous results on conditions that fall outside historical behavior.  

    How to cite: Condon, L., Bennett, A., Tran, H., Horowitz, B., Leonarduzzi, E., Melchior, P., and Maxwell, R.: Accelerating large scale groundwater simulation with machine learning: modeling approaches and science implications for changing systems, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8739, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8739, 2022.

    EGU22-9196 | Presentations | HS2.5.3

    Combining a global groundwater model ensemble with in-situ data for groundwater assessment in the Mediterranean region 

    Nahed Ben-Salem, Robert Reinecke, George P. Karatzas, Michael Rode, and Seifeddine Jomaa

    Growing water demands in the Mediterranean region have increased groundwater exploitation, imposing urgent and efficient groundwater management. Sustainable management requires a proper understanding of groundwater status and accurate estimates of groundwater levels with less uncertainty. In this context, large-scale modelling has been shown to assess groundwater resources under changing conditions, especially in regions known for data scarcity. This study aims to quantify the steady-state groundwater levels at continental scales using a model ensemble and in-situ groundwater observations. To test the models' applicability and validity, we utilize one of the most monitored groundwater systems in the Mediterranean region, the Iberian Peninsula. Outputs of three global gradient-based groundwater models (Reinecke et al. (2019), de Graaf et al. (2017), and Fan et al. (2013)) were compared to observations from long-term groundwater monitoring network. The model ensemble showed reasonable performance in replicating the groundwater levels for shallow groundwater, but performance deteriorated with increased elevation.

    In this study, we argue that we can develop continental scale groundwater maps for groundwater assessment by combining model results with in-situ data. Historical groundwater levels were used to test, train and validate the different combination methods. Here we present the outcomes and discuss the accuracy of the final product. We see this study as a benchmark approach of using multi-model ensemble and observations to deliver better groundwater steady-state conditions as a baseline for groundwater users and managers in the Mediterranean region.

    This work was supported by the German Federal Ministry of Education and Research (BMBF, Germany, Grant 01DH19015) under the Project Sustain-COAST, co-funded by EU PRIMA 2018 programmes.

    How to cite: Ben-Salem, N., Reinecke, R., P. Karatzas, G., Rode, M., and Jomaa, S.: Combining a global groundwater model ensemble with in-situ data for groundwater assessment in the Mediterranean region, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9196, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9196, 2022.

    HS3 – Hydroinformatics

    EGU22-523 | Presentations | HS3.1

    A visual approach for water quality monitoring within the CrowdWater project 

    Sara Blanco Ramírez, Ilja van Meerveld, Jan Seibert, Mirjam Scheller, and Franziska Schwarzenbach

    CrowdWater is a citizen science project that uses a mobile phone application (app) to collect hydrological data. The project aims to develop and test methods for hydrological measurements that do not require sensors. So far, the app is used to collect data about stream water levels, the state of intermittent streams, soil moisture, and plastic pollution. The app can also be used to record general characteristics of streams, such as the color, the presence of fish and other living beings, or water pollution.

    Perhaps without realizing it, many people make visual water quality assessments for their daily decisions. Based on visual aspects of the water, people decide whether the water is suitable for swimming or drinking. This presents an opportunity to explore the potential of a visual approach through citizen science-based water quality observations. Water color and clarity are one of the most frequently used indicators for the visual assessment of water quality. Remote sensing studies have shown that water color is changing in many areas, which suggests that it is useful to characterize visual water quality aspects throughout time and to relate these to perceptions of water quality and how this affects water use. However, most of the time this perception is not just based only on the current characteristics of the water but also on local environmental knowledge, such as the presence of outlets that discharge waste water or sewage overflows, the water quality in the past, etc.

    This presentation will describe the visual approach for water quality that fits within the CrowdWater philosophy of not using any sensors so that observations can be made by anyone at any place. We will also present a first evaluation of the method. This includes discussing how consistent people are in their assessment of water color and whether they can assess differences in water color over time or between sites.

    How to cite: Blanco Ramírez, S., van Meerveld, I., Seibert, J., Scheller, M., and Schwarzenbach, F.: A visual approach for water quality monitoring within the CrowdWater project, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-523, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-523, 2022.

    In recent decades, the uncertainty associated with characteristics (i.e., frequency, intensity, severity, and duration) of extreme events (e.g., droughts, floods) has increased considerably due to the changing global climatic condition and intensification of anthropogenic activities. Effective in-situ monitoring of the hydrometeorological drivers (e.g., precipitation, temperature) is crucial for precise prediction/forecasting and early warnings to initiate measures for mitigating the adverse effects of these extreme events.  However, due to the increased availability of satellite-based data products and economic constraints, the density of in-situ gauges has reduced drastically over the past few decades. Against this backdrop, this study proposes a multivariate hydrometeorological gauge network design methodology to facilitate integrated monitoring of dry and wet conditions. It harnesses the advantages of multi-objective optimization and fuzzy concepts and involves multi-level clustering and the use of multiple ground- and satellite-based hydrometeorological products.  The multi-level clustering is based on (i) a newly proposed multi-objective Non-dominated Sorting Genetic Algorithm III (NSGA-III) based fuzzy optimization clustering and (ii) fuzzy ensemble clustering. The key stations in the designed network were selected based on the Drought/Wetness Gauge Demand Index (DWGDI), which accounts for the region's drought/wetness characteristics and crop yield.  It also offers scope to consider additional attributes based on the specific purpose of the network design. The potential of the proposed methodology is illustrated through Monte Carlo simulations on a hypothetical region and a case study on Karnataka state (~191,791 km2) in India to arrive at gauge network monitoring three hydrometeorological variables (precipitation, maximum and minimum temperature, and soil moisture). A random forest-based merging procedure is considered to obtain hydrometeorological time-series at ungauged locations using ground-based measurements and multiple gridded/satellite-based products (CRU, CPC, IMD, CHIRPS and IMERG). Overall, the proposed network design methodology appears promising for application to small as well as large data-sparse areas. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first study of its kind, which proposes a multivariate gauge network design procedure for integrated monitoring of dry and wet conditions. The proposed methodology yielded wet/dry condition-specific monitoring networks for the Karnataka state. Additionally, the key stations crucial for monitoring both wet and dry conditions are identified. The counts of precipitation, temperature and soil moisture stations in the network designed for monitoring (i) dry conditions are 1059, 1059, and 552, respectively, (ii) wet conditions are 1144, 1144, and 664, respectively. Stations in the two networks were prioritized by assigning ranks based on DWGDI. The information could be helpful to decision-makers in identifying potential locations for the installation of new gauges accounting for budgetary constraints. The real-time observations from the designed gauge network could be helpful for various purposes, such as better water management to meet irrigation demands, monitoring droughts and floods, and forecasting natural hazards like wildfires, soil erosion, and landslides. 

    How to cite: Vijay, S. and Venkata Vemavarapu, S.: An Approach to Integrate Ground- and Satellite-based Products for Multivariate Hydrometeorological Network Design to Monitor Dry and Wet conditions, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-610, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-610, 2022.

    EGU22-716 | Presentations | HS3.1

    Remote Sensing and Clustering Applications in Landscape Hydrology: Characterizing a Subarctic Watershed in Nunavik (Canada) 

    Eliot Sicaud, Jan Franssen, Jean-Pierre Dedieu, and Daniel Fortier

    Hydrological data are often sparse and incomplete for large northern watershed with difficult access. Landscape hydrology approaches are useful for the indirect assessment of their hydrological characteristics by analysing the landscape properties of the watersheds. In this study, we use unsupervised Geographic Object-Based Image Analysis (GeOBIA) paired with the Fuzzy C-Means (FCM) clustering algorithm to produce a total of seven high-resolution territorial classifications for the 1985-2019 time-period. Each classification spans 5-year period and is based on key hydro-geomorphic metrics. Our application site is the George River watershed (GRW), draining a 42 000 km2 area and is located in Nunavik, northern Québec (Canada). The retrieved subwatersheds within the GRW are used as the objects of the GeOBIA and are classified in function of their hydrological similarities.

    First, classification results for the time-period 2015-2019 show that the GRW is composed of two main types of subwatersheds distributed along a latitudinal gradient. This indicates differences in water balance, and hydrological regime and response. Second, six other classifications are then computed for the period 1985-2014 to investigate past changes in hydrological behavior. The seven-classification time series present an expansion of the southern-type subwatersheds northwards, principally along the George River’s main channel. This expansion is due to increases of (i) vegetation production and (ii) moisture content in soil and canopy. These are the major changes occurring in the land cover metrics of the GRW. We speculate that a rise in vegetation production contributes to evapotranspiration increase and therefore induces changes in water balance, which could explain the measured decrease of about 1% in the George River’s discharge since the mid-1970s.

     

    How to cite: Sicaud, E., Franssen, J., Dedieu, J.-P., and Fortier, D.: Remote Sensing and Clustering Applications in Landscape Hydrology: Characterizing a Subarctic Watershed in Nunavik (Canada), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-716, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-716, 2022.

    EGU22-936 | Presentations | HS3.1

    Hydroclimatic time series analysis and clustering at multiple time scales 

    Georgia Papacharalampous, Hristos Tyralis, Yannis Markonis, and Martin Hanel

    Detailed investigations across time scales and variable types can progress our understanding of hydroclimate. In this work, we analyse temperature, precipitation and streamflow time series at nine time scales (i.e., the 1-day, 2-day, 3-day, 7-day, 0.5-month, 1-month, 2-month, 3-month and 6-month ones). The analyses are performed over the continental United States, and in terms of temporal dependence, temporal variation, “forecastability”, lumpiness, stability, nonlinearity (and linearity), trends, spikiness, curvature and seasonality, among others. Thus, they facilitate extensive characterizations of the cross-scale properties of the temperature, precipitation and streamflow variables. Based on these characterizations, various similarities and differences are identified between the examined variables regarding the evolution patterns of their features with increasing (or decreasing) time scale. Moreover, the computed features are used as inputs to unsupervised random forests to detect any meaningful clusters between the time series. The clustering is performed separately for each set {time scale, variable type}, and allows the investigation of the spatial variability of the temperature, precipitation and streamflow features across the examined continental-scale region and across time scales, with the spatial patterns emerging from it being largely analogous across time scales. Lastly, explainable machine learning is applied to compare the features with respect to their importance-usefulness in the clustering. For most of the features, this usefulness can vary to a notable degree across time scales and variable types, thereby implying the need for conducting multifaceted time series characterizations for the study of hydroclimatic similarity.

    How to cite: Papacharalampous, G., Tyralis, H., Markonis, Y., and Hanel, M.: Hydroclimatic time series analysis and clustering at multiple time scales, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-936, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-936, 2022.

    EGU22-937 | Presentations | HS3.1

    Feature-based clustering of hydroclimatic time series 

    Georgia Papacharalampous and Hristos Tyralis

    Both the grouping of hydroclimatic time series (often required, e.g., for technical and operational purposes) and the identification of spatial hydroclimatic patterns can be formalized and automated through algorithmic clustering methodologies. In this presentation, we focus on a new family of such methodologies that can be applied to various types of hydroclimatic variables (e.g., temperature, precipitation and streamflow) and at various temporal scales (e.g., the daily, monthly, seasonal, annual and climatic ones) with minimal adaptations. Aiming to exploit the largest part possible of the total information encompassed in the hydroclimatic time series, this family of clustering methodologies primarily relies on massive feature extraction, a concept sourced from the data science field. Once a compilation of numerous and diverse time series features (comprising autocorrelation, long-range dependence, entropy, temporal variation, seasonality, trend, lumpiness, stability, nonlinearity, linearity, spikiness, curvature and more features) has been computed, the clustering upon them is performed using a selected machine and statistical learning algorithm, with unsupervised random forests being an appealing choice for the task. Explainable machine learning can also be applied, as part of wider methodological frameworks, for ranking the features from the most to the least informative ones in obtaining the clusters, thereby facilitating the interpretability of the clustering outcomes in a comprehensive manner. We extensively discuss the above-outlined approach to hydroclimatic time series clustering emphasizing its main similarities and differences with the current well-established approaches in hydrology (e.g., from the catchment hydrology field), as well as its strengths and current limitations. Our discussions are well-supported by global-scale and other large-scale investigations, which have been conducted for temperature, precipitation and streamflow variables at several temporal scales.

    How to cite: Papacharalampous, G. and Tyralis, H.: Feature-based clustering of hydroclimatic time series, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-937, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-937, 2022.

    EGU22-1827 | Presentations | HS3.1

    The Sensitivity of Simulated Streamflow to Individual Hydrologic Processes Across North America 

    Juliane Mai, James R. Craig, Bryan A. Tolson, and Richard Arsenault

    Streamflow sensitivity to different hydrologic processes varies in both space and time. In numerical modeling of streamflow, this sensitivity manifests as parameter sensitivity, which is typically model-specific.

    In this study, we apply a novel analysis over more than 3000 basins across North America enabling the estimation of the process sensitivities on streamflow based on basin characteristics that can be derived from physiographic and climatologic data without needing to perform the expensive sensitivity analysis itself. This continental-scale analysis allows for high-level conclusions as to the importance of water cycle components on streamflow predictions, as the analysis considers a flexible model structure rather than an individual model. This work derives the sensitivity of streamflow simulation to entire hydrologic processes rather than only specific parameters. Process sensitivities are computed and provided for each day of the year over a wide range of physiographic and climatologic regimes, enabling future hydrologic model improvement at the continental scale.

    A few highlight results are: 1) Baseflow and other sub-surface processes are of low importance across North America- especially when time points of high flows are of interest. 2) Percolation, evaporation, and infiltration show very similar patterns with increased importance in South-eastern US and west of the Rocky Mountains. 3) Up to 30% of the overall model variability can be attributed to snow melt in regions that are snow dominated (Northern Canada and Rocky mountains). Potential melt shows a similar gradient as snow melt with sensitivities of above 60% in the Province of Quebec and the Rocky Mountains. 4) Direct runoff (quickflow) is the most sensitive of all hydrologic processes- especially in South-Eastern US it is responsible for more than 80% of the model variability. 5) The derived functional relationship to estimate the process sensitivities based on basin characteristics has predictive power of at least 0.8 in Pearson correlation coefficients based on more than 1000 basins used for validation.

    How to cite: Mai, J., Craig, J. R., Tolson, B. A., and Arsenault, R.: The Sensitivity of Simulated Streamflow to Individual Hydrologic Processes Across North America, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1827, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1827, 2022.

    In recent years, artificial intelligence (AI) tools have gained popularity as forecasting and predictive tools able to approximate with high accuracy trends and outcomes in many fields such as robotics, climatology, and hydrology, including water resources. AI models have shown remarkable performances handling big data and dealing with their nonlinearity and nonstationary features in monitoring and forecasting water quality, complementing the traditional numerical water quality models that provide precise parametrizations of near-shore and off-shore processes and their complex interactions.

    In this research, we examine the accuracy of different machine learning techniques in estimating and predicting dissolved oxygen concentration (DO) in water bodies. DO is a crucial water quality variable that influences the living conditions of all aquatic organisms requiring oxygen. Low DO concentration, when persistent, can cause eutrophic conditions, thus altering the normal nutrient cycle, favoring the formation of algal blooms and furtherly reducing water quality and affecting the entire ecosystems, also causing fish mortality.

    The Random Forest (RF) and the generalized regression neural network (GRNN) are explored and compared. The two models are developed using high frequency in situ data collected from Andromeda Group, a leading company in the aquaculture sector in Greece, at four different stations in the Greek Mediterranean Sea. The input variables used for the two models are temperature and currents. The performances of the models are evaluated using root mean square errors (RMSE) and mean absolute error (MAE). The RF and GRNN showed similar performances, with the best fit obtained using the GRNN model. Results are also compared with a traditional numerical model developed with the DELFT3D-WAQ modeling suite. The AI models show better performances in estimating daily changes of the DO concentration and by being less computationally expensive than the numerical model, enhance the water quality monitoring and provide aquaculture and farmers managers with a forecasting tool.

    Acknowledgments:

    The work has been conducted within the framework of the HiSea project, which has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 821934 and of the Water Harmony project, an ERA-NET WATERJPI Co-fund Action. Funding received via the Dutch Research Council - NWO Project number ENWWW.2018.1

    How to cite: Spinosa, A. and El Serafy, G.: Enhancing the modeling of dissolved oxygen concentration using machine learning, a case study in the Greek Mediterranean Sea., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1912, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1912, 2022.

    EGU22-2398 | Presentations | HS3.1

    Towards capturing bedform transition: harnessing capabilities of CFD bedform models and machine learning 

    Amin Shakya, Sanjay Giri, Toshiki Iwasaki, Mohamed Nabi, Biswa Bhattacharya, and Dimitri Solomatine

    Our understanding of bedform processes and their associated effect on bedform roughness is limited, and accounts for large uncertainties in hydraulic roughness computation. It is a standard practice in hydraulic modelling to consider hydraulic roughness as a roughness coefficient and to calibrate the model to this coefficient. Such an approach is empirical and does not well capture the physical processes involved in hydraulic roughness dynamics. When bedforms are present, they can account for a significant portion of hydraulic roughness. Consequently, when bedform transitions occur, an abrupt and significant disruption in the hydraulic roughness regime occurs; affecting our water management applications, such as navigability, flood risk management, sediment transport, etc. Bedform transitions are rarely captured, either in laboratory or in real-scale river channels. As such, our understanding of such transition behaviour is further constrained.

    In this research, we modelled a CFD physics-based bedform model for the Chiyoda channel, Japan based on previous study of Yamaguchi et al. (2019). The model configuration and results of that study had been validated. The CFD model was initialized at flat-bed condition and run till a dynamic equilibrium in dune regime was obtained. In our research, we captured the bedform in this simulation in each time step, effectively obtaining a timeseries of bed evolution from flatbed regime to dune regime.

    It is hoped, the use of physics-based CFD models can simulate the physical processes that invoke bedform transitions. As these have not been easily observed in the field or in lab, the simulations can provide an important insight into these complex processes. This is particularly important in the context of changing hydraulic regimes under the changing climate scenario – possibly making past calibrations of river systems incompatible in the future. An alternative to physics-based (CFD) model is the use of a data-driven model (using machine learning techniques). The use of surrogate machine learning models that capture the behaviour of these physics-based (CFD) models, provides an advantage in terms of computational cost and computational time.

    We also developed a proof-of-concept artificial neural network ML models to predict dune height and mean flow depth respectively based on the CFD model results as input. Several models were built using various combinations of input variables: the lagged values of dune height and mean flow depth, mean flow depth or dune height (alternatively), as well as the present and lagged values of spectral power from Fast Fourier Transform spectral analysis. The lagged values of the predicted variable were the most important input parameters compared to other variables. The use of spectral power as predictive variable did not much improve the results, owing to a strong cross-correlation of the parameter with dune height and mean flow depth.

    Alternative predictive variables such as stream discharge, Froude number, etc may be considered in future studies to ensure better prediction ability. Validation of these ML and physics-based CFD model results remain a challenge as bedform transition timeseries dataset is not much available. Future outlook of the research in this direction is discussed.

    How to cite: Shakya, A., Giri, S., Iwasaki, T., Nabi, M., Bhattacharya, B., and Solomatine, D.: Towards capturing bedform transition: harnessing capabilities of CFD bedform models and machine learning, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2398, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2398, 2022.

    EGU22-3334 | Presentations | HS3.1

    Application of Simulation-Optimization modeling to suggest optimal hybrid in-situ flushing for nitrate attenuation 

    Suh-Ho Lee, In-Woo Park, Seong-Sun Lee, and Kang-Kun Lee

    Uncertainties in efficiently managing contaminated groundwater still pertains. Several in-situ remediation technologies can be applied to treat nitrate contamination; however, those cannot be applied at aquifer which has high hydraulic conductivity. In this study, we apply Simulation-Optimization modeling (S-O modeling) to suggest optimal in-situ flushing integrated to pump-and-treat design that can reduce and manage nitrate contamination of groundwater. MODFLOW-2005 and MT3D-USGS are used to simulate groundwater flow and nitrate transport. Genetic Algorithm(GA) is used to suggest proper well location and pumping rate for reducing nitrate contamination. Our optimization modeling based on the field tests conducted on a multi-layered aquifer. There is an uncontaminated lower aquifer and an upper aquifer contaminated with nitrate. At the first stage, we generated hydraulic gradient for collecting pre-existed contamination with installing pumping well at the lower aquifer and injection well at the upper aquifer contaminated with nitrate. In the second stage, 1 moving well of variable location and pumping rate was used for pump-and treat well. Cost function satisfies minimizing the total expenses of drilling, pumping, injection, water treatment, and penalty for violating nitrate concentration. The early stage result of S-O modeling shows nitrate moves along the groundwater flow and is captured at the moving well that is located in the center of nitrate plume.

     

    Keyword: Simulation-Optimization modeling (S-O modeling) ∙ Remediation ∙ On-site flushing ∙ Groundwater modeling

    Acknowledgement: This work was supported by Korea Environment Industry & Technology Institute(KEITI) through "Activation of remediation technologies by application of multiple tracing techniques for remediation of groundwater in fractured rocks" funded by Korea Ministry of Environment (MOE) (Grant number:20210024800002/1485017890), Korea Environment Industry & Technology Institute(KEITI) through the Demand Responsive Water Supply Service Program (RE20191097) funded by the Korea Ministry of Environment (MOE) and Korea Ministry of Environment as "The SEM projects; RE2020002470001/1485017133".

    How to cite: Lee, S.-H., Park, I.-W., Lee, S.-S., and Lee, K.-K.: Application of Simulation-Optimization modeling to suggest optimal hybrid in-situ flushing for nitrate attenuation, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3334, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3334, 2022.

    EGU22-3809 | Presentations | HS3.1

    Estimation of the reference hydrological conditions in Slovenia with application of clustering analysis 

    Sašo Šantl, Luka Javornik, and Katarina Zabret

    The reference hydrological conditions describe the natural discharge as it would be without the exploitation of the water resources. The measured values of the discharge are obtained in the scope of national hydrological monitoring and are in most cases reduced for the amount of abstracted water. Therefore, the values measured in this way provide information on the amount of residual water in the river and not the total amount of water that would be available without abstraction. However, knowing the natural hydrological state is important when calculating the ecological flow and planning the future water use. For this purpose, our goal was to established the methodology for estimating the reference discharge on any water body in Slovenia with catchment size larger than 10 km2. The development of the methodology was based on detailed simulations of reference hydrological conditions for 56 selected cases. As those simulations require extensive data preparation and are very time consuming, we intended to generalize the results obtained for selected cases to the whole country using clustering analysis. The hierarchical clustering and K-means approach were applied taking into account different model arguments (e.g. number of clusters, distance metrics, number of iterations). First we have grouped the simulation points to check which of the attribute data influence the classification the most. Than clustering was repeated on the data set representing points distributed over the whole country as well as simulation points. However, the further analysis of the clustering results and application of other methods for generalization showed, that clustering analysis is in this case suitable for analysis of patterns in data and identification of influential variables, while generalization turned out to be better performed applying multiple regression analysis.

    How to cite: Šantl, S., Javornik, L., and Zabret, K.: Estimation of the reference hydrological conditions in Slovenia with application of clustering analysis, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3809, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3809, 2022.

    EGU22-3863 | Presentations | HS3.1

    Mapping Ireland’s Surface Water from Space: Comparison of three remote sensing platforms  

    MinYan Zhao and Fiachra O'Loughlin

    Water plays a vital role in Earth’s ecosystems, hence, the management and monitoring of water resources are significantly important. Ireland has more than 12200 lakes, 3,192 river water bodies including rivers, streams, and tributaries that exceed in total 70,000 km. However, few of them are currently monitored (2% of lake and 1.8% of river). Earth observation (EO) has shown promise in understanding and monitoring water resources. However, the sizes of Ireland’s water bodies have remained a challenge for EO monitoring.

    In this research, three different platforms (Landsat 8-OLI, Sentinel-2A and PlanetScope Ortho Scene 3B product) are used to calculate their individual spatial coverage of water bodies across Ireland and quantity their usefulness for water quality monitoring. To explore if water extraction methods impact the results, four different water extract methods (NDWI, NDVI, MNDWI, and AWE have been used to create water masks for Ireland. These water masks created for each platform were then compared with existing map of river network, lakes, and water monitoring stations. The results indicated that AWE’s water mask is the best performing extraction method compared to the existing maps, while the high-resolution platforms (Planetscope and Sentinel-2) clearly outperforms Landsat, Landsat is still able to detect at least 51.90% and 1.63% of rivers. This shows that even the coarser resolution Landsat imagery is useful in monitoring water quality across Ireland.

    How to cite: Zhao, M. and O'Loughlin, F.: Mapping Ireland’s Surface Water from Space: Comparison of three remote sensing platforms , EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3863, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3863, 2022.

    Partitioning a dataset in multivariate analysis is one of the key points to better understanding the hydrological process. Different regions of a catchment may bring floods variously due to distinct types of floods or their simultaneous occurrence. Therefore, it is needed to determine the spatial extent floods brought together. In a multidimensional space, it is demanding to investigate floods. It is not clear which kind of clustering methods or dimension reduction techniques are appropriate for visualizing initial similarities among measured peaks. Two methods are applied to reduce dimensions and compare their differences in this research. Multidimensional scaling (MDS) and t-distributed Stochastic Neighbor Embedding (tSNE) are the employed models for 55 years of extreme floods in the Neckar catchment. MDS is based on Principal Component Analysis (PCA), which is a linear technique. While tSNE is a non-linear dimensionality reduction method. In theory, tSNE can handle outliers and perplexity and preserve the local structure of data. As a result, compared to the MDS, both methods react similarly in soliciting an additional algorithm to cluster data in 2D space. It is another challenge that has to be investigated in future research. Due to the fatter and heavier tails, the t-student distributions have a greater chance for extreme values than normal distributions. Therefore, tSNE can better visualize data in a high-dimensional space for assessing extreme events. However, these algorithms must be run in different climates and deal with distinct hydrometeorological variables.

    How to cite: Modiri, E. and Bárdossy, A.: Multidimensional flood analysis challenges and similarities utilizing linear and non-linear approaches, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3921, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3921, 2022.

    Urbanization substantially changes many aspects including the regional hydrological cycle, energy balance, and microclimate. However, the degree to which urbanization alters urban evapotranspiration (ET) and its components (soil evaporation (E), vegetation transpiration (T), impervious surface evaporation (I) and water body evaporation (W)) remains unclear. A significant obstacle is the absence of a multi-source energy balance model for an urban area. To solve this issue, a customized four-source energy balance model for urban areas (FSU model) is proposed that differentiates between urban E, T, W, and I. The performance of the FSU model was verified using the eddy correlation (EC), stable hydrogen and oxygen isotope observations in a mega city: Tianjin, China. Long-term urban ET and its composition changes were reconstructed using the Landsat image during the period of 1986-2021 in Tianjin. Trend analyses demonstrate that urban ET, E, and T exhibit significant decreases of trend, while urban W, sensible heat flux (H), and Bowen ratio (BR) exhibit significant increases in trends with urbanization. Urban ET decreased at a rate of 1.41 mm/yr, corresponding to a ~ 13% decrease below the long-term mean value of total urban ET during the period 1986-2021. Correlation analyses revealed a declining trend of urban ET, E, and T primarily caused by urban land use changes, while the increasing trends of urban W, H, and BR were mainly due to the urban microclimate changes. The proposed FSU model aids in assessment of the urban heat island (UHI) effect and facilitates scientific water resources management in urban areas. This research improves the in-depth understanding of the impact of urbanization on urban ET and its components.

    How to cite: Chan, H., Huang, J., Li, H., and Wei, Y.: Assessing the impact of urbanization on urban evapotranspiration and its components using a novel four-source energy balance model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4382, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4382, 2022.

    Preventive Drought Management Measures (PDMM) aim to reduce the chance of droughts and minimise their negative consequences in the short and long term. A wide range of interventions can be considered PDMM, including Nature-Based Solutions, grey infrastructure, land use management, and soil conservation practices, among others. This study intends to apply an optimisation procedure to find optimal combinations and allocations of PDMM that contribute to minimising the agricultural and hydrological drought's severity at a basin scale. To achieve this goal, we coupled the multi-objective genetic algorithm (NSGA-II) with the semi-distributed hydrologic model, Soil and Water Assessment Tool (SWAT). The PDMM evaluated in this study are rainwater harvesting ponds, parallel terraces, forest conservation, grade stabilisation structures and floodplains restoration. Preliminary results indicate that optimal combinations and allocations of PDMM reduce the drought's severity in downstream subbasins. The analysis was developed in the La Vieja basin (West-central Colombia).

    How to cite: Paez, A., Corzo, G., and Solomatine, D.: Optimization of preventive drought management measures to alleviate the severity of agricultural and hydrological droughts, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4790, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4790, 2022.

    EGU22-4885 | Presentations | HS3.1

    An enhanced deep learning approach to assessing inland water quality and the affecting factors using Landsat 8 and Sentinel-2 

    Hongwei Guo, Xiaotong Zhu, Jinhui Huang, Zijie Zhang, Shang Tian, and Yiheng Chen

    The estimation of water quality parameters (WQPs) using remote sensing is difficult due to the complex correlation between WQPs and water optical properties, the interactions of WQPs, and the impacts of climate. We proposed enhanced multimodal deep learning (EMDL) models for Chlorophyll-a (Chla), total phosphorous (TP), total nitrogen (TN), Secchi disk depth (SDD), dissolved organic carbon (DOC), and dissolved oxygen (DO) estimation in Lake Simcoe, Canada. The EMDL models were developed and validated using the remote sensing reflectance derived from the harmonized Landsat and Sentinel-2 images, synchronized in-situ water quality measurements, water surface temperature, and climate data (N = 950). Using the EMDL models, the spatiotemporal water quality patterns of Lake Simcoe from 2013 to 2019 were reconstructed. Besides, we quantitatively analyzed the impacts of 12 potential natural and anthropogenic factors on the water quality of Lake Simcoe. The results showed that the EMDL models had the potential to detect the spatiotemporal dynamics of water quality with the Slope being close to 1 (0.84−0.95), normalized mean absolute error ≤ 20.17%, and Bias ≤ 14.68%. Human activities such as urban development and agricultural activities mainly affected the water quality of Lake Simcoe. This study provides a practical approach to supporting the environmental management of regional inland watersheds.

    How to cite: Guo, H., Zhu, X., Huang, J., Zhang, Z., Tian, S., and Chen, Y.: An enhanced deep learning approach to assessing inland water quality and the affecting factors using Landsat 8 and Sentinel-2, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4885, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4885, 2022.

    EGU22-4930 | Presentations | HS3.1

    Prediction of hourly runoff in the Savitri River basin in India: Use of a local approximation approach 

    Namitha Saji, Vinayakam Jothiprakash, and Bellie Sivakumar

    In this study, the concept of nonlinear dynamics is used to predict runoff in the Savitri River basin, Maharashtra, India. Hourly runoff from four stations in the basin, namely Kangule, Bhave, Birwadi, and Kokkare, are studied. The nonlinear prediction method with a local approximation approach is employed, and one-hour-ahead runoff predictions are made. The method uses (1) reconstruction of the single-dimensional runoff series in a multi-dimensional phase space; (2) determination of the Euclidean distances between the reconstructed vectors; and (3) prediction using a nearest-neighbor local approximation approach, with consideration of different number of neighbours. For each of the four streamflow stations, data observed during the period 2000–2009 are used for phase space reconstruction, and predictions are made for the year 2010. Three statistical evaluation measures, correlation coefficient (CC), Nash-Sutcliffe efficiency (NSE), and normalized root mean square error (NRMSE), are used to determine the performance of the method. The prediction results for the four stations indicate very good accuracy, with the CC values ranging between 0.980 and 998, the NSE values between 0.961 and 0.995, and the NRMSE values between 0.010 to 0.014. The optimal embedding dimensions (i.e. the dimensions yielding the best predictions) for the Kangule, Bhave, Birwadi, and Kokkare are 9, 13, 6, and 9, respectively. These dimensions suggest that the complexity of the dynamics of hourly runoff in the Savitri River basin is medium-to-high dimensional. The outcomes from the present study are certainly encouraging to further enhance the application of nonlinear dynamic concepts for studying the runoff dynamics in the Savitri River basin.

    Keywords: Runoff prediction, Nonlinear dynamics, Chaos, Phase space reconstruction, Local approximation prediction, Savitri River basin

    How to cite: Saji, N., Jothiprakash, V., and Sivakumar, B.: Prediction of hourly runoff in the Savitri River basin in India: Use of a local approximation approach, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4930, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4930, 2022.

    EGU22-4931 | Presentations | HS3.1

    Data assimilation of soil moisture measurements in land surface simulations to study the impact on evapotranspiration estimates in European forests 

    Lukas Strebel, Heye Bogena, Harry Vereecken, and Harrie-Jan Hendricks Franssen

    Land surface models are important tools to improve our understanding of interacting ecosystem processes and for the prediction of future risks of droughts and fires. However, such predictions are associated with uncertainties related to model forcings, parameters and process simplifications. Therefore, the increasing availability of high-quality observations should be used to improve the accuracy of land surface model predictions. In this study, we use the Ensemble Kalman Filter for the fusion of in-situ soil moisture observations from different observation networks across Europe (e.g. eLTER, FLUXNET, TERENO, ICOS) into the Community Land Model 5.0 (CLM5). The sites selected for this study cover different regional climate zones and forest types and feature in-situ soil moisture as well as evapotranspiration observations from eddy covariance towers for the period from 2009 to 2019. In this study, we specifically focus on European forested study sites where both in-situ soil moisture and evapotranspiration observations are available for the period from 2009 to 2019. CLM5 simulates a broad variety of important land surface processes including water and energy partitioning, surface runoff, subsurface runoff, photosynthesis and carbon and nitrogen storage in vegetation and soil. Here, we focus on improving the accuracy of model predictions by updating soil moisture dynamics and related soil hydraulic parameters by coupling CLM5 to the Parallel Data Assimilation Framework (PDAF) to assimilate soil moisture data into CLM5 during simulation runtime. Additionally, we implemented a new and more direct approach to update the hydraulic parameters compared to previous versions of the CLM5-PDAF coupling and show the effects of this implementation.We demonstrate the value and limitation of assimilating soil moisture data for simulating evapotranspiration focusing on recent drought events in 2018 and 2019. We found that soil moisture dynamics were better characterized by data assimilation, but this did not result in improved estimation of evapotranspiration for the different sites during both wet and dry periods.

    How to cite: Strebel, L., Bogena, H., Vereecken, H., and Hendricks Franssen, H.-J.: Data assimilation of soil moisture measurements in land surface simulations to study the impact on evapotranspiration estimates in European forests, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4931, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4931, 2022.

    Reservoir operation causes spatiotemporal variations in outflow, which influence the dynamics of downstream aquatic communities. However, empirical evidence of community responses to flow regime (FR) and water quality (WQ) remains limited for dam-regulated rivers. This study focused on identifying the influences of both FR and WQ on metacommunity dynamics downstream of the reservoir. First, the metacommunity dynamics model (MDM) was used to simulate aquatic community dynamics under changing FR and WQ. Then, the flow-ecology relationship was established to identify community response to reservoir outflow. Third, the novel ecological indicators were proposed to evaluate the resilience and resistance of multi-population systems. Finally, the reservoir operating rule curves were optimized by considering tradeoffs between socioeconomic and ecological objectives. The coevolution processes of multi-population systems (fish, phytoplankton, zooplankton, zoobenthos, and macrophytes) were simulated by MDM for each local community. The population densities of stable states showed continuous downward trends with increasing alteration degree of FR and WQ for multi-population systems, and aquatic community systems could be destroyed when alteration reached its acceptable maximum. The greater the alteration degree of FR and WQ, the longer the recovery time from an unstable to a stable state, and the weaker resistance for each population system. The resilience and resistance of downstream multi-population systems can be enhanced by optimizing reservoir outflow. The optimization results illustrated that all the performances of the multiple objectives of water supply, hydropower generation, and ecological benefits were improved by no less than 2.5% compared with the conventional operation. This study provided an approach to identify dual effects of FR and WQ on aquatic community systems, which is helpful in guiding ecological restoration for river ecosystems.

    How to cite: Wang, Y., Liu, P., and Solomatine, D.: Optimizing reservoir operation rules for ecological sustainability by identifying dual effects of flow regime and water quality on metacommunity dynamics, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4964, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4964, 2022.

    EGU22-5509 | Presentations | HS3.1

    Hydrological model adaptivity to inputs of varied quality 

    Jiao Wang, Lu Zhuo, and Dawei Han

    Hydrological models serve as useful tools to describe current conditions and to predict future conditions in a catchment. However, the errors from input data including precipitation and potential evapotranspiration (PET) and model parameterization can lead to huge uncertainties on the model outputs. Although it is challenging to quantify the effect from individual sections due to the high non-linearity of hydrological processes, the potential compensations among different inputs and model parameters may provide valuable insights into the input data correction and the model calibration.

     

    In this study, we aim to improve the understanding of the adaptation mechanisms between model parameters and the quality of inputs during the hydrological simulation. The objectives are to investigate: (1) the most effective metrics needed to characterize the hydrological applicability of input sources; (2) the hydrological model adaptivity to input sources of varied quality; (3) the compensating interaction of different inputs on the hydrological modelling. We demonstrate our approach to the widely used conceptual Xin’anjiang (XAJ) hydrological model. Rainfall estimations from multiple sources are collected for a headwater catchment in the Southern United States and the Brue catchment in Southwest England, from rain gauges, weather radars, satellites, reanalysis products, and Weather Research and Forecasting (WRF) model dynamic downscaling.

     

    Results suggest that: (1) The total water balance is a poor indicator of rainfall data quality for hydrological simulations. Instead, the event-based water balance shows a stronger influence on representing the differences in hydrological applicability, especially for heavy storm events; (2) A high compensation relation exists among the quality of rainfall data, the model’s initial soil moisture state, and water balance-related parameters in the XAJ model, allowing the poor WRF rainfall datasets to generate good streamflow simulations; (3) A new hydrological proxy (term), called Compensating Interaction Angle  (CIA) between different inputs is diagnosed to quantitatively measure the trade-off between their quality in producing satisfactory hydrological performance. The proposed CIA is recommended to apply in other regions and hydrological models to validate if a general pattern exists and how it varies regionally.

    How to cite: Wang, J., Zhuo, L., and Han, D.: Hydrological model adaptivity to inputs of varied quality, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5509, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5509, 2022.

    EGU22-5580 | Presentations | HS3.1

    Assessing the generalization power of three machine learning models and three evapotranspiration formulas using 143 FLUXNET towers data 

    Alireza Amani, Marie-Amélie Boucher, Alexandre R. Cabral, and Daniel F. Nadeau

    Direct measurement of evapotranspiration (ET) is costly and difficult to implement on a large scale. It is therefore a necessity to count on reliable approaches to estimate it. Among such approaches, Machine learning models (MLMs) are easily applicable and computationally inexpensive, especially for broadscale analyses. In this study, three different types of MLMs, namely Random Forest, Light Gradient Boosting Machine and Neural Networks are assessed for their estimation accuracy on unseen locations (i.e. generalization power). Estimates of ET from these MLMs are compared against direct observation from 143 eddy-covariance flux towers spanning across a broad range of climate and vegetation types. We initially hypothesized that the MLMs, provided that they are trained using data from a wide variety of climate and vegetation types, are able to accurately estimate ET on unseen locations (default experiment).  The MLMs are benchmarked against Penman, Priestley-Taylor, and Oudin ET formulas/models. The results show that the MLMs indeed perform satisfactorily on the majority of the test locations, but not in all of them, yielding on average a 15% lower normalized mean-absolute-error (NMAE) than the Priestley-Taylor formula. Moreover, we compared the performance of the MLMs trained and tested using different data splitting strategies. When training and testing data are not spatially separated, the results show that the Random Forest model has a 7% lower NMAE compared to when the spatial separation is done (the default experiment). This suggests that the MLMs are prone to overfit to site-specific patterns that might not be relevant for other locations. In conclusion, the results of this large scale study points toward reliability of the MLMs as far as their generalization power is concerned. At the same time, they also show that different data splitting strategies can lead to significantly different results. 

    How to cite: Amani, A., Boucher, M.-A., Cabral, A. R., and Nadeau, D. F.: Assessing the generalization power of three machine learning models and three evapotranspiration formulas using 143 FLUXNET towers data, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5580, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5580, 2022.

    EGU22-5674 | Presentations | HS3.1

    Clustering networks: reducing the complexity of urban hydrology models with graph partitioning for fast and flexible simulations 

    Barnaby Dobson, Samer Muhandes, Morten Borup, and Ana Mijic

    Graph partitioning algorithms separate nodes of a graph into clusters, resulting in a smaller graph that maintains the connectivity of the original. In this study we use graph partitioning to produce reduced complexity sewer networks that can be simulated by a novel urban hydrology model. We compare a variety of algorithms, including spatial clustering, spectral clustering, heuristic methods and we propose two novel methods. We show that the reduced network that is produced can provide accurate simulations in a fraction of the time (100-1000x speed up) of typical urban hydrology models. We address some likely use cases for this approach. The first is enabling a user to pre-specify the desired size of the resultant network, and thus the fidelity and speed of simulation. The second is enabling a user to preserve desired locations that must remain in their own cluster, for example, locations with complex hydraulic structures or where monitoring data exists. The third is a case where detailed sewer network data is not available and instead the network must be simulated hundreds of times in a random sampling of network parameters, something that is only possible with the speed gains that our method allows. We envisage that this reduced complexity approach to urban hydrology will transform how we operate and manage sewer systems, enabling a far wider range of model applications than are currently possible, including optimisation and scenario analysis.

    How to cite: Dobson, B., Muhandes, S., Borup, M., and Mijic, A.: Clustering networks: reducing the complexity of urban hydrology models with graph partitioning for fast and flexible simulations, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5674, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5674, 2022.

    EGU22-6255 | Presentations | HS3.1

    Sensitive parameters for hydrodynamic modelling of a multi-use case study 

    Rieke Santjer, Erik Sieburgh, Vindhya Basnayake, Ni Ye, and Ghada El Serafy

    The sector of aquaculture cultivation is rapidly growing, since aquaculture is a promising food and protein supply for the increasing human world population. However, aquaculture is adding to the competition of marine space, especially in European Seas. One possible solution for relaxation of spatial competition is an approach of marine multi-use such as the combination of food and renewable energy production. Implementation of offshore aquaculture cultivation systems creates challenges for offshore engineers with respect to risks and huge costs. Large-scale hydrodynamic models, which are able to represent large and small-scale impacts, can serve as a tool to ease such challenges during the planning and assessment phase. One of these models is the calibrated and validated Dutch Continental Shelf Model (DCSM), developed by Deltares. This hydrodynamic large-scale and three-dimensional model covers the North-Western European Shelf and is based on the D-FLOW FM software. However, due to the complexity and thus computational costs of the DCSM, the application of the DCSM for various inputs and scenarios to understand multi-use in practice is limited. In this work, the DCSM is used for a case study in the North Sea. To minimise the computational amount, the considered area is cut-out from the DCSM. This nested model is based on initial conditions and inputs of the DCSM and the FINO3 platform. This platform was chosen as it is part of the UNITED project. The UNITED project is 4-year Horizon2020 EU project led by Deltares with 26 partners. The present study uses this nested model to investigate the sensitivities of input parameters. The variables water temperature, salinity and current velocities are selected, since these are the most important variables for mussel and seaweed cultivation, which are covered by this model. It is important to have information on the impact by changing the model input. Therefore, the parameters will be ranked according to their sensitivity. Since the used model still is a large and complex model, several sensitivity analysis techniques will be used. The Morris method will give a pre-liminary ranking of parameters. However, this method only changes one input at a time (one-at-a-time) and does not consider correlations between parameters. Therefore, it is planned that the method will be extended by copulas for the model input. Furthermore, it is planned to also give information about the variances of outputs. The Sobol’ variance-based method will be applied on the most influential parameters as previously detected, because the number of model runs is dependent on the number of parameters. The final results can later be used for model optimisation to allow efficient spatial planning of marine multi-use configurations. 

    How to cite: Santjer, R., Sieburgh, E., Basnayake, V., Ye, N., and El Serafy, G.: Sensitive parameters for hydrodynamic modelling of a multi-use case study, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6255, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6255, 2022.

    EGU22-6277 | Presentations | HS3.1

    Estuarine morphodynamics forecast using a numerical model emulator based on deep learning methods. A first approach. 

    Willian Weber de Melo, José Luís Pinho, Isabel Iglesias, Ana Gomes, José Vieira, Ana Bio, Luisa Bastos, Fernando Veloso-Gomes, and Paulo Avilez-Valente

    Estuaries are transition zones between rivers and oceans that provide essential ecosystem services with high economic, environmental and social importance. These areas are exploited by fishing, maritime transportation and tourism industries, having banks usually highly urbanized and, thus, their waters are exposed to anthropogenic activities. They also serve as nursery areas for many fish and marine birds species, providing shelter and food in their early stages of life. Therefore, the preservation of the quality of estuarine natural resources is essential for all stakeholders, being of utmost importance to promote its sustainable use. However, the anthropogenic pressure threatens the availability of these natural resources, demanding a continuous monitoring effort.

    Morphological conditions are determinants for most of the services provided by estuaries. Though its forecasting is a very challenging task due to the involved physical-process complexity. At the same time, its characteristic timescales demand long-term simulations with high computational costs to achieve relevant and accurate results. Anticipating the morphology evolution, allows, for example, to optimize dredge operations to maintain navigation channels, being necessary for efficient flood management.

    Available state-of-the-art physical-based numerical models can be applied to predict estuarine morphology. However, the sediment transport component usually requires additional computational resources, increasing the CPU time and limiting their application for short to medium-term forecasts. An artificial intelligence (AI) emulator based solely on the hydrodynamic component results could be a solution to minimize the total morphodynamic forecast CPU time.

    This work implemented a convolutional neural network (CNN) to emulate the morphodynamic evolution of the Minho river estuary, located at the northern Portuguese coast. AI-based methods demand considerable time to be implemented, mainly during dataset preprocessing and training tasks, but their simulation performance could be superior when compared to numerical models if sufficient data are available for training the algorithm. In this proof of concept work, the CNN used the estuarine currents average velocity and direction and the bottom stress extracted from the Delft3D numerical model runs as input to forecast the accumulated sedimentation/erosion. The hydrodynamic numerical model was automatically calibrated using the OpenDA tool, determining the best value combination for the numerical parameters. Simulations were performed considering a 20-year return period flood event, with hourly generated outputs. The network was implemented using the TensorFlow open-source platform and was composed of an input layer, for reading the results of the hydrodynamic model, a filter layer, for simplifying the inputs, a hidden layer, for learning and processing the input information and, lastly, an output layer, for generating the accumulated erosion/accretion patterns within the estuary.

    The results demonstrated the emulator’s capacity to reproduce the sandbar patterns inside the estuary, revealing to be a promising approach to forecast estuarine morphodynamics in a shorter computational time. The mean absolute percentage error of the CNN model was 0.80 during training and 0.77 during testing. While the numerical model requires 38 minutes to simulate a one-month simulation period, the emulator needed only a couple of seconds. Future works will analyze the networks hyperparameters, aiming to increase the emulator performance and accuracy.

    How to cite: Weber de Melo, W., Pinho, J. L., Iglesias, I., Gomes, A., Vieira, J., Bio, A., Bastos, L., Veloso-Gomes, F., and Avilez-Valente, P.: Estuarine morphodynamics forecast using a numerical model emulator based on deep learning methods. A first approach., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6277, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6277, 2022.

    EGU22-6319 | Presentations | HS3.1

    Engaging the public for water data collection – experiences from the CrowdWater project 

    Jan Seibert, Sara Blanco, Mirjam Scheller, Franziska Schwarzenbach, Wang Ze, and Ilja van Meerveld

    CrowdWater is a citizen science project in which we investigate how the public can be involved in the collection of hydrological data, such as stream water levels, soil moisture conditions and the presence of water in temporary streams. Another important part is to study the value of the collected data for hydrological forecasts. Therefore, we have evaluated the potential value of citizen science observations, which might be uncertain and spotty in time, in several studies. The project's long-term goal is to collect a large number of observations and thus improve the prediction of hydrological events, such as drought or flooding, by using data collected by the public in hydrological model calibration. In this presentation, we discuss our experiences from the CrowdWater project with regard to app-based data collection and evaluation of these data. We also highlight methods to ensure data quality, including a gamified approach and machine learning for the analyses of the photos that are submitted through the app. Additionally, we will give an update on new activities in the CrowdWater project.

    How to cite: Seibert, J., Blanco, S., Scheller, M., Schwarzenbach, F., Ze, W., and van Meerveld, I.: Engaging the public for water data collection – experiences from the CrowdWater project, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6319, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6319, 2022.

    EGU22-6656 | Presentations | HS3.1

    A framework for smart assessment of river health using machine learning 

    Enya Roseli Enriquez Brambila, Gerald Corzo Perez, Michael McClain, and Dimitri Solomatine

    There is a current concern for the health of river ecosystems due to their vulnerability and increasing deterioration from human pressures, as well as the interest in achieving freshwater environmental sustainability in the well-known climate change challenges.

    Analysis of international monitoring frameworks of river health have highlighted the need to increase data availability and frequency as well as reduce data uncertainty. With this, new aggregation, standardization, and classification methods are required as the development of technologies have grown and reached citizens at different social and cultural levels, their participation have increased in the recent years, showing important time-cost advantages. However, still there are no clear protocols to implement as assessment using mobile phone tools and platforms. 

    This study aims to develop a dynamic framework for smart river health ecosystem monitoring, employing citizen science and remote sensing. This concept uses hydro-morphological and biological river indicators, combined with machine learning algorithms to analyze spatiotemporal data. 

    The smart framework for assessment presented here aims to be provide to 1) Characterized  natural and non-natural changes of river ecosystem health; 2) Improve river monitoring methods linking local observation and remote sensing data; 3) Develop databases and data visualization of river condition components; 4) Enable citizens to become a large sensor network to contribute to river health monitoring; and 5) Determine and georeferenced the causes of  river health changes to support nature-based solutions for river ecosystem management.

    How to cite: Enriquez Brambila, E. R., Corzo Perez, G., McClain, M., and Solomatine, D.: A framework for smart assessment of river health using machine learning, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6656, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6656, 2022.

    EGU22-6706 | Presentations | HS3.1

    Comprehensive comparison performances of Landsat-8 OLI atmospheric correction methods for inland and coastal waters 

    Shang Tian, Hongwei Guo, Jinhui Jeanne Huang, Xiaotong Zhu, and zijie Zhang

    Remote sensing is important for aquatic environment monitoring. The Operational Land Imager (OLI) sensor onboard Landsat-8 has been proved to be able to monitor water quality of inland and coastal waters. Atmospheric correction (AC) is a crucial step in the quantitative research of remote sensing, and its accuracy is the key to the quantitative analysis of inland and coastal waters. However, the optical complexity of inland and coastal waters remains a major challenge for AC of Landsat-8 imagery, which in turn affects the retrieval accuracy of optically active constituents (OACs). A variety of AC algorithms had developed specifically for water application. However, comprehensive comparative studies of AC methods for both inland and coastal waters with a gradient of turbidity levels are lacking. Meanwhile the comparation of different AC algorithms coupled with Landsat-8 Chlorophyll-a (Chl-a) retrieval algorithm are also limited. In this study, the performances of six water-based AC methods were evaluated by using multiple global datasets (N = 139). The AC methods include the default and Management Unit Mathematics Models (MUMM) algorithms integrated into Sea-Viewing Wide Field-of-View Sensor (SeaWiFS) Data Analysis System (SeaDAS), the Dark Spectrum Fitting (DSF) and Exponential Extrapolation (EXP) algorithms integrated into the Atmospheric Correction for OLI ‘lite’ (ACOLITE), image correction for atmospheric effects (iCOR), and the Case 2 Regional CoastColour processor (C2RCC). Four evaluation strategies were applied in this study including spectral similarity and Chl-a retrieval. The results showed that SeaDAS and DSF performed the best in term of analytical match, band ratio, Chl-a retrieval and spectral similarity for all matchups. SeaDAS had the lowest root-mean-square-error (RMSE) in the blue-green bands of 0.0036 sr-1 and 0.0043 sr-1 respectively. SeaDAS also showed good consistency across the spectra with the lowest median spectral angle of 7°. It should note that DSF performed best in high turbid waters, but was not as accurate as SeaDAS for remote sensing reflectance (Rrs) retrievals in most low-to-moderately turbid waters. For the retrieval of Chl-a using OC3 and Clark algorithm, all AC methods except iCOR and EXP gave similar performance compared to in-situ measurements. SeaDAS coupled with OC3 and Clark algorithms had the lowest RMSE of 1.3359 and 1.4250 mg m-3 respectively, which showed the advantage of SeaDAS in Chl-a retrieval. This study provides scientific basis for choosing AC methods of Landsat-8 OLI data for aquatic environment monitoring.

    How to cite: Tian, S., Guo, H., Huang, J. J., Zhu, X., and Zhang, Z.: Comprehensive comparison performances of Landsat-8 OLI atmospheric correction methods for inland and coastal waters, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6706, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6706, 2022.

    EGU22-7060 | Presentations | HS3.1

    Optimization of water work operations during critical flood events using neural networks and data visualization 

    Laura Lotteraner, Miguel Angel Marazuela, and Thilo Hofmann

    In this work we aim to understand how current questions in hydrogeology can be answered using new methods of data analysis developed in recent years. Water works supplying drinking water to large cities represent a hydrogeological challenge of great global interest. Ensuring optimal water quality not only under normal conditions but also during flood events is a public health issue. The pollution processes associated with flood events are the result of a combination of numerous factors at the basin scale, which complicates their prediction. Numerical models are powerful tools to simulate and manage groundwater flow around water works, but due to their high computational costs, simplifications and assumptions must be made, which reduces modelling precision. 

    We selected a water work located in a subalpine fluvio-glacial aquifer, providing water to a large city. The water work is compound of several drains that extract the water from the aquifer by gravity. Hydrochemistry is stable under normal conditions but changes drastically during flood events, with a decrease in water quality. Due to the vast amount of data, on hydraulic heads, river levels and hydrochemistry, that is available from over 40 locations across the relevant area, modern data analysis tools perfectly complement the numerical model.  

    The goal of our work is to review how to predict critical flood events and optimize water work operations accordingly by complementing numerical models with new methods of data analysis. To reach the ultimate goal of building a decision support system for water work operations state-of-the art data visualization tools must be combined with machine learning methods such as deep neural networks. These methods have a lower computational cost than numerical models, which makes them suitable for real-time predictions. They can also answer questions that are too complex for the numerical model.  

    We provide an overview on the current literature on data visualization tools and neural networks for ground water modelling and suggest approaches relevant for the selected site. Customized data visualization tools are used to allow both researchers and water work operators gain information directly from the data, without further computations. A neural network trained with parameters describing rainfall in the area as well as groundwater and river levels is able to predict the correlation between rain events and water levels. A second neural network links river and groundwater levels to water quality at the water work. In a next step, water quality at the water work under different conditions is correlated with different modes of operation.   

    How to cite: Lotteraner, L., Marazuela, M. A., and Hofmann, T.: Optimization of water work operations during critical flood events using neural networks and data visualization, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7060, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7060, 2022.

    EGU22-8107 | Presentations | HS3.1

    Robust multi-objective optimization and probabilistic analysis methods under multiple uncertainties: the CROPAR algorithm. 

    Jitao Zhang, Dimitri Solomatine, and Zengchuan Dong

    Appropriate water resource allocation schemes are essential for the coordinated and stable development of the basin. Identifying the risks existing in a basin and proposing a robust water resource allocation scheme are of great significance for water resource management in a basin. In this study, the Coupled Robust Optimization and Robust Probabilistic Analysis (CROPAR) algorithm is proposed based on the Robust Optimization and Robust Probabilistic Analysis (ROPAR) algorithm, taking into account the multiple uncertainties of water resources allocation in a basin. First, this study calculates the multi-objective optimal allocation of water resources under certainty. In this study, a single Pareto front is obtained by minimizing the water shortage rate and minimizing the typical pollutant emissions as two objective functions. Then, this study analyzes the frequency and uncertainty of inflow based on historical record data. This study assumes that the basin inflows vary within a certain interval, while the basin has multiple inflows. In this study, the joint probability distribution function of the inflows was constructed with the Copula function, and nine scenarios were generated. Then, the ROPAR algorithm was applied to these nine cases. A total of 9,000 Pareto fronts were calculated through 1,000 Monte Carlo samples for each scenario. Finally, a probabilistic analysis is performed for each scenario to reach a robust optimal solution for a specific scenario according to the robustness criterion. The results show that the CROPAR algorithm can adequately tackle the uncertainty of water allocation in the basin. It helps to make a wide range of risk-based decisions.

    How to cite: Zhang, J., Solomatine, D., and Dong, Z.: Robust multi-objective optimization and probabilistic analysis methods under multiple uncertainties: the CROPAR algorithm., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8107, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8107, 2022.

    EGU22-8548 | Presentations | HS3.1

    HydroCAL: An Integrated Surface-Subsurface Cellular Automata Hydrological Model 

    Luca Furnari, Alfonso Senatore, Alessio De Rango, and Giuseppe Mendicino

    The Integrated Surface and Subsurface Hydrologic Modeling (ISSHM) approach, based on the coupling of physical-based surface and subsurface routing processes, evolved significantly in the last decades, also thanks to the continuously increasing capabilities offered by high-performance computing (HPC). The Extended Cellular Automata (XCA) paradigm perfectly fits the needs of HPC infrastructures, due to its inherent aptitude for parallel computing and other specific features like asynchronism that allow not only parallelization but also the reduction of the computational cost.

    We present HydroCAL, a new ISSHM based on the Extended Cellular Automata paradigm linking a two-dimensional weighted XCA surface routing model with a three-dimensional XCA subsurface model. The model was implemented in the parallel software library Open Computing Abstraction Layer (OpenCAL), which allows users to exploit several parallelization strategies, hardware architectures and XCA features.

    Preliminarily, the subsurface model was tested in several thousand synthetical test cases to assess the effects produced by an asynchronous functionality based on a fixed threshold rule on the hydraulic head difference. The results show the high efficiency of the asynchronous XCA model in terms of elapsed time, preserving the accuracy of the results.

    Then, the coupled surface and subsurface HydroCAL modules were tested with high-resolution (101 m) simulations in a small headwater Mediterranean catchment characterized by high hydrogeological heterogeneity. The model parameters were calibrated and validated using different events, characterized by several discharge peaks, during two years.

    The results show that the model can accurately catch the hydrological response, reproducing multi-peak events with correct peak times and discharge values, simulating adequately also the recession phases. At the same time, the XCA model implementation permits highly detailed coupled simulations with computational times adequate to operational (even real-time) purposes.

    Further study will regard the application of different asynchronism rules on both the surface and subsurface modules and the addition of other modules concerning subsurface-groundwater and land surface-atmosphere interaction.

    How to cite: Furnari, L., Senatore, A., De Rango, A., and Mendicino, G.: HydroCAL: An Integrated Surface-Subsurface Cellular Automata Hydrological Model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8548, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8548, 2022.

    EGU22-10140 | Presentations | HS3.1

    Design of wireless soil moisture sensor powered by bacteria charged paper battery. 

    Sumit Meshram, Dr. Saket Pande, and Dr. Ludovic Jourdin

    Lack of information and dependence on unscientific techniques for measuring soil moisture has resulted in water loss and reduced crop yield for smallholder farmers in developing countries. Existing sensors are expensive, eco-unfriendly, and require an external power source hence cannot be used in off-grid and rural areas. The objective of this work is to design a wireless low-cost, biodegradable, and environment-friendly paper-based soil moisture sensor powered by microbes present in the soil which will transmit this moisture data to smartphones. The expected outcome of this work is the real-time soil moisture monitoring system accessible in off-grid areas based on microbial fuel cells (MFC). The fundamental assumption here is that the current generated by MFC and signal sent by the flexible near field communication (NFC) tag will be a function of soil moisture. This document describes the empirical procedure followed to execute this study. A lab-scale proof of concept is presented where the current is generated by a paper battery fabricated using cellulose paper and conductive ink along with microbes present in the soil and nitrates. Future plans of embedding the paper battery with NFC tags for designing soil moisture sensor using MFC technology is also presented.

    How to cite: Meshram, S., Pande, Dr. S., and Jourdin, Dr. L.: Design of wireless soil moisture sensor powered by bacteria charged paper battery., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10140, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10140, 2022.

    EGU22-10239 | Presentations | HS3.1

    Regionalization of a Distributed Hydrology Model Using Random Forest 

    Siavash Pouryousefi-Markhali, Annie Poulin, and Marie-Amélie Boucher

    Distributed hydrology models are suitable tools for understanding the hydrological processes, which take place on heterogeneous media under ever-changing internal (e.g. land use change) and boundary conditions (e.g. climate change). The generally accepted practice for applying such models is to calibrate their parameters using observed data. Still in many locations, even in developed countries, observed data is lacking or unreliable. Regionalization is a way around this problem. In this research, we built a Random Forest (RF) model to regionalize the parameters of a distributed hydrology models (Hydrotel), which is the operational model at Quebec government. Using the RF model, the following three hypotheses were tested regarding the efficiency and spatio-temporal variability of the proposed regionalization technique: (1) A finer time-step adds more information to the calibrated parameters and therefore improves the efficiency of the regionalization method; (2) The parameters approximated by RF are spatially consistent and therefore transferrable across spatial scales (i.e. from lumped to sub-catchment to hydrological response units); (3) Using more spatially representative predictors (i.e. by refining the spatial resolution of CDs) to reflect heterogeneity of the catchment will improve the performance of regionalization at internal ungauged locations. All these hypotheses were tested on three groups of nested catchments at 3- and 24-hour time-steps. The results show that for simulations at sub-daily time-steps, the calculated loss of regionalization efficiency (with respect to calibration) is less than that of the 24-hour time-step (12% improvement). Approximating the parameters at different levels of spatial discretization demonstrates that the parameters are spatially consistent as the distribution of parameters and catchment descriptors are spatially correlated. Finally, we found a consistent improvement of simulations when we replace lumped with fully distributed parameters, for simulations with a 24-hour time step. This improvement in the efficiency is higher for catchments with a higher degree of spatial heterogeneity (up to 12%). However, no significant improvement in the efficiency of simulation from lumped to distributed parameters has been observed when the time-step of the simulation was reduced to 3-hour.

    How to cite: Pouryousefi-Markhali, S., Poulin, A., and Boucher, M.-A.: Regionalization of a Distributed Hydrology Model Using Random Forest, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10239, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10239, 2022.

    EGU22-10394 | Presentations | HS3.1

    Using public cloud computing infrastructure for rapid simulations of large-scale global reservoirs 

    Pieter Hazenberg, Albrecht Weerts, Bart van Osnabrugge, Ivo Miltenburg, and Willem van Verseveld

    Water reservoirs play an important role in relation to water security, flood risk, agriculture production, hydropower, hydropower potential, and environmental flows. However, long-term daily information on reservoir volume, inflow and outflow dynamics are not publicly available. To enable deriving long-term reservoir dynamics for many reservoirs across the globe using a distributed hydrological model, large amounts of computer power are needed. Therefore, these types of simulations are generally performed on super computers. Nowadays, public cloud computing infrastructure offers interesting alternative and allows one to quickly access hundreds to thousands of computer nodes.

    The current work presents an example of making use of the public cloud offers by simulating the dynamics of 3236 headwater reservoirs on a Kubernetes Cluster on Microsoft Azure. Within the cloud, distributed model forcing and hydrological parameters at a 1-km grid resolution were derived using HydroMT, which subsequently were used by wflow_sbm to perform long-term hydrological simulation over the period 1970-2020. To enable operation in the cloud, usage is made of the Argo workflow engine, that is effective able to schedule the sequential execution of the HydroMT and wflow_sbm containers. Using this setup, all model simulation results were obtained in less than a week. We will present the executed modeling setup within the public cloud as well as present some of the results derived in this manner by comparing observations with in situ and satellite observations.

    How to cite: Hazenberg, P., Weerts, A., van Osnabrugge, B., Miltenburg, I., and van Verseveld, W.: Using public cloud computing infrastructure for rapid simulations of large-scale global reservoirs, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10394, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10394, 2022.

    EGU22-10782 | Presentations | HS3.1

    Clustering fine-scale river network topologies for use in Earth system models 

    Laura Torres-Rojas, Noemi Vergopolan, Daniel Guyumus, and Nathaniel W. Chaney

    Representing the physical heterogeneity of the land surface in Earth System Models (ESM) remains a persistent challenge due to its relevance to represent weather and climate dynamics and the hydrological cycle accurately. To address this challenge, the HydroBlocks Land Surface Model (LSM) [1] uses a hierarchical tiling scheme that defines its Hydrologic Response Units (HRUs) by clustering high-resolution global environmental data (e.g., 30-m land cover, topography, soil properties). The recently implemented reach-based routing scheme in HydroBlocks enables a two-way coupling between the high-resolution river network and the land HRUs. However, preliminary results show that the implementation is only computationally manageable for a limited number of river reaches (~5,000) per macroscale grid cell (1x1 arc degree). This hinders the scheme generalization and scalability over continental scales. As such, further simplification of the river network structure in routing schemes is required to ensure the feasibility of the approach in ESMs.

    This presentation will explore simplification alternatives for river network topologies using clustering analysis. Initially, given that a significant fraction of the total river reaches on any domain are first-order, we propose an approach that clusters these streams based on average basins’ physical and environmental features (e.g., slope, upslope contributing area, aspect, average precipitation, and land cover), and channels’ geometry. The river network topology is simplified by depicting all the clusters’ members as single equivalent channels. The clustering is performed using K-means, and the number of clusters depends on a maximum target number of reaches required to provide computational tractability. Although useful, this approach will not be enough to sufficiently reduce the computational burden, for which solving the second- and even third-order reaches remain a substantial load. Therefore, the second approach relies on clustering the river channel structure over sets of interconnected reaches (i.e., topologies including first-, second-, and third-order streams). The performance of the proposed approach will be compared to the original HydroBlocks implementation for the temporal evolution of the streamflow, inundation height and the resulting computation times.

     

    [1]      N. W. Chaney, L. Torres-Rojas, N. Vergopolan, and C. K. Fisher, “HydroBlocks v0.2: enabling a field-scale two-way coupling between the land surface and river networks in Earth system models,” Geosci. Model Dev., vol. 14, no. 11, pp. 6813–6832, Nov. 2021, doi: 10.5194/gmd-14-6813-2021.

    How to cite: Torres-Rojas, L., Vergopolan, N., Guyumus, D., and Chaney, N. W.: Clustering fine-scale river network topologies for use in Earth system models, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10782, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10782, 2022.

    EGU22-11408 | Presentations | HS3.1

    AI-enhanced drought forecasting: a case study in the Netherlands 

    Claudia Bertini, Schalk Jan van Andel, Gerald Corzo Perez, and Micha Werner

    Drought is a natural phenomenon linked to a temporary but significant reduction in the availability of water resources. Drought usually originates as a deficit in precipitation, with prolonged drought having substantial repercussions on the hydrological, agricultural and socio-economic sectors; making drought one of the most impactful natural hazards modern society faces. The ability to forecast the occurrence of drought events with sufficient lead time, however, allows for the implementation of strategies to reduce drought impacts. Although drought forecasting using both statistical and dynamic techniques has been widely studied, challenges still remain in predicting drought events, especially for sub-seasonal to seasonal forecasts. Because of the increased availability of Earth Observation data, advances in Artificial Intelligence, and progress in computing capabilities in the last decades, drought prediction has received a new impulse. Machine Learning, especially Deep Learning, techniques are now increasingly being used both to improve current weather forecasts and as an alternative to conventional predictions of extreme events.

    In this contribution we explore the use of Machine Learning techniques to improve meteorological drought prediction through post-processing of weather forecast analogues. To this aim, we use both ECMWF extended and long-range forecasts, together with reanalysis data, to build a ML-based model that helps correcting forecasts. We then test the model to explore how much current forecasts can be actually improved with the use of AI-based techniques. We apply the method proposed, in the area of the Rhine Delta in the Netherlands, focussing on 1-month lead time predictions. This work is part of the CLImate INTelligence (CLINT) project, which aims at developing AI-enhanced Climate Services for extreme events detection, causation, and attribution.

    How to cite: Bertini, C., van Andel, S. J., Corzo Perez, G., and Werner, M.: AI-enhanced drought forecasting: a case study in the Netherlands, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11408, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11408, 2022.

    EGU22-11467 | Presentations | HS3.1

    Prediction of evapotranspiration using a nonlinear local approximation approach 

    Gunturu Vamsi Krishna, Vinayakam Jothiprakash, and Bellie Sivakumar

    Evapotranspiration is a key process in the water cycle. Evapotranspiration is influenced by several hydro-meteorological variables in complex and nonlinear ways and, therefore, its estimation is often very challenging. This study employs a chaotic time series approach to predict evapotranspiration. Measured monthly evapotranspiration data over a period of 40 years (1976–2015) from the Rietholzbach monitoring station in Switzerland are analysed. The nonlinear local approximation prediction method, which uses nearest neighbours, is employed. The method involves the following steps: (1) Phase-space reconstruction of a single-variable time series in a multi-dimensional phase space using delay embedding; (2) Identification of the nearest reconstructed vectors using Euclidean distance; and (3) Prediction of the future value based on the evolution of the nearest neighbours in the phase-space. The phase-space reconstruction is done with embedding dimension (m) from 1 to 10, and nearest neighbours (k) varying from 1 to 300 are used for prediction. Out of the 480 monthly evapotranspiration values available, the first 320 values are used for phase-space reconstruction and prediction, and the remaining 160 values are used for checking the prediction accuracy. The performance of the prediction method is evaluated using correlation coefficient and root mean square error. The results generally indicate very good predictions. The prediction accuracy generally increases with an increase in the embedding dimension up to a certain point and then somewhat saturates beyond that point. The best predictions are achieved when the embedding dimension is five and the number of neighbours is 10, with a correlation coefficient value of 0.86 and root mean square error value of 14.64 mm. The low embedding dimension and small number of neighbours yielding the best predictions suggest that the dynamics of monthly evapotranspiration in the Rietholzbach station exhibit chaotic behaviour dominated by five governing variables. The optimal embedding dimension value obtained from the prediction method also matches with the optimal embedding dimension estimated using the False Nearest Neighbour (FNN) algorithm, which is a dimensionality-based approach. The results from this study have important implications for modelling and prediction of evapotranspiration.

    Keywords:

    Evapotranspiration, Chaos, Local approximation prediction, Phase space reconstruction, False nearest neighbour algorithm

    How to cite: Vamsi Krishna, G., Jothiprakash, V., and Sivakumar, B.: Prediction of evapotranspiration using a nonlinear local approximation approach, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11467, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11467, 2022.

    EGU22-11940 | Presentations | HS3.1

    Optimization Processes for Decision Aiding 

    Ioanna V. Anyfanti, Paraskevas Diakoparaskevas, Antonis Lyronis, Emmanouil Varouchakis, George P. Karatzas, Maria Giovana Tanda, Andrea Zanini, and Seifeddine Jomaa

    During the last decades, the Mediterranean region faces increase of mean temperature and decrease of precipitation. In combination with augmented needs in water for irrigation and human consumption, overexploitation of groundwater aquifers has been observed in many Mediterranean basins. The aim of this work is to attempt a fuzzy optimization procedure for groundwater management and specifically for the determination of the optimal pumping rates in the Tympaki coastal aquifer, in Crete, Greece. The intense agricultural production in the area and the consequent overpumping have resulted in saltwater intrusion. The optimization problem has been set as the maximization of the pumping rates, subjected to a set of hydraulic head constraints, in order to push back the saltwater front and simultaneously fulfill water demands. In the first place, the piece-wise linear technique is used and after iterative runs of the simulation – optimization (S – O) procedure, the problem is linearized after the convergence of two consecutive S – O runs. This is the baseline for the assessment of the fuzzy optimization method that is deployed in the next stage. Then, the problem is also expressed as a fuzzy one and the bound and decomposition method for the fully fuzzy linear problems is used in the piece-wise steps. The groundwater system simulation was calibrated according to 2004 – 2008 period of observation data from 6 wells and the runs were based on precipitation data for the ten-year period 2010 – 2020. The pumping wells in the study area are up to 371, which were grouped to 20 to enhance the computational speed of the simulation. The modeling of the groundwater flow is performed with the use of Finite Element subsurface FLOW and transport modelling system (FEFLOW), while the optimization process is executed in Matlab R2017b. It is expected that enhancing results, along with the use of surrogate models, will enable the integration of this technique in a Decision Support System for groundwater management of coastal aquifers. After validation, the same methodology is going to be applied in a second coastal aquifer, Malia, in Crete, Greece.

    This work was developed under the scope of the InTheMED and Sustain-COAST projects.

    InTheMED is part of the PRIMA programme supported by the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 1923. Sustain-COAST is funded by the General Secretariat for Research and Innovation of the Ministry of Development and Investments under the PRIMA Programme. PRIMA is an Art.185 initiative supported and co-funded under Horizon 2020, the European Union’s Programme for Research and Innovation.

    How to cite: Anyfanti, I. V., Diakoparaskevas, P., Lyronis, A., Varouchakis, E., Karatzas, G. P., Tanda, M. G., Zanini, A., and Jomaa, S.: Optimization Processes for Decision Aiding, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11940, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11940, 2022.

    EGU22-12880 | Presentations | HS3.1

    Point clouds and Hydroinformatics 

    Vitali Diaz, Haicheng Liu, Peter van Oosterom, Martijn Meijers, Edward Verbree, Fedor Baart, Maarten Pronk, and Thijs van Lankveld

    Point cloud is made up of a multitude of three-dimensional (3D) points with one or more attributes attached. Point cloud is the third data paradigm in addition to the well-established object (vector) and gridded (raster) representations, since point cloud data can be directly collected, computed, stored, and analyzed without converting to other types. Modern ways of data acquisition, including laser scanning from airborne, mobile, or static platforms, multi-beam echo-sounding, and dense image matching from photos, generate millions to trillions of 3D points with attached attributes. If the collection is carried out in different periods, one of the essential attributes is precisely time, allowing spatiotemporal analysis to be performed. Its use is widespread in some fields such as metrology and quality inspection, virtual reality, indoor/outdoor navigation, object detection, vegetation monitoring, building modeling, cultural heritage, and diverse visualization applications. There are some examples in fields related to hydroinformatics, mainly related to terrain modeling. Due to its nature of big data, over the past decades, a series of developments have been carried out in the different processing chains for the optimal use of point cloud. This research seeks to introduce the various point cloud developments from which the hydroinformatics community and research could benefit. A review of recent advances is made, mainly including the analysis and visualization of point cloud for dealing with water-related problems. Potential areas of application and development in hydroinformatics are identified. These include, for example, the topics of coastal monitoring, coastal erosion, shallow water assessment, ice sheet change analysis, sea-level rise assessment, monitoring of levels in water bodies, crop and vegetation monitoring, analysis of the effects of groundwater depletion, detail tracing of basins and channels, analysis of floods with detailed terrain models, and drought monitoring in crops and forests. The challenges to overcome and ongoing developments regarding point cloud application in hydroinformatics are also discussed.

    How to cite: Diaz, V., Liu, H., van Oosterom, P., Meijers, M., Verbree, E., Baart, F., Pronk, M., and van Lankveld, T.: Point clouds and Hydroinformatics, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12880, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12880, 2022.

    EGU22-13414 | Presentations | HS3.1

    The potential of crowdsourced personal weather stations for hydrological forecasting in a Dutch lowland catchment 

    Claudia Brauer, Romy Lammerts, Lotte de Vos, and Aart Overeem

    Accurate and real-time available rainfall data are indispensable for flood forecasting and warning. Crowdsourced personal weather stations have a high spatiotemporal resolution (in our case 9 km2 and 5 min) and are available in near-real-time, but are prone to errors. In this study, we (1) assessed the accuracy of rainfall observations from personal weather stations in a Dutch lowland catchment (Oude IJssel, 1210 km2) and (2) used these PWS data as input to a rainfall-runoff model (WALRUS) to assess their potential for discharge forecasting.

     

    The catchment-averaged rainfall depths measured by personal weather stations slightly overestimated the reference with a bias of only 0.03 mm, which is much lower than the underestimation of the real-time available (unadjusted) radar product (-0.16 mm). Quality control of PWS did not reduce the bias, but time series varied less and correlated better with the reference. For individual stations, quality control reduced the bias with 11% while retaining 85% of the data.

     

    Discharge simulations using quality-controlled personal weather stations (NSE=0.98, using simulations with gauge-adjusted radar rainfall data as reference) were better than before quality control (NSE = 0.95) and much better than the real-time available (unadjusted) radar product (NSE=0.70).

     

    To conclude, rainfall data from personal weather stations are suitable for real-time hydrological applications, especially after quality control.

     

    How to cite: Brauer, C., Lammerts, R., de Vos, L., and Overeem, A.: The potential of crowdsourced personal weather stations for hydrological forecasting in a Dutch lowland catchment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13414, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13414, 2022.

    EGU22-14 | Presentations | HS3.3

    Improved decision-making in geochemical sampling based on both frequency and Bayesian frameworks 

    Behnam Sadeghi, David Cohen, and Dietmar Müller

    A common problem in geochemical exploration projects is the limited number of collected samples due to budgetary, time, and other constraints. Therefore, to study spatial mineralisation patterns using available samples in both sampled and unsampled areas, the interpolation of the available data is essential to assign estimates to unsampled areas. Because interpolation estimates are based on the data available only within the search window, in continuous field geochemical modelling such interpolations using any single method are often the main source of uncertainty. Error propagation analysis needs to be considered to evaluate interpolation errors’ effects in geochemical anomaly detection. One method for analysing the propagation of errors in models and evaluating their stability is Monte Carlo Simulation (MCSIM). In this method, the P50 (median) value (called ‘return’) and the uncertainty value (called ‘risk’) are calculated. Here the uncertainty is calculated as 1/(P90-P10) for which P10 (lower decile) and P90 (upper decile) are the average 10th and 90th percentiles of the multiple simulated values, correspond to each element. We have applied this method to Swedish till data, collected throughout the country by the Geological Survey of Sweden. The main concern is whether to evaluate if the samples are sufficient and representative of the target elements concentrations for geochemical studies. To address this concern, the sampling uncertainty in a statistical sense (not geochemical) per element was studied using the return-risk matrix. This matrix was applied to volcanogenic massive sulfide (VMS) target elements, then subsequently to the samples per bedrock. Therefore, a large number of simulated values (e.g., 5,000, which is higher than the number of the samples, i.e., 2,578) was generated using MCSIM. Where the quantified return is low or negative, and the quantified uncertainty is high, particularly higher than its relevant return, additional sampling is required to achieve the minimum required spatial continuity in the data or the stability of the later applied classification models. This affects the certainty of the models generated in the study area. In the Sweden data, all the elements assessed have relatively high returns and low uncertainty, demonstrating the stability of the parameters. The process was subsequently applied to samples separated into the main lithological categories or geological domains to determine if the stability in the patterns is affected by rock type (and associate natural variability in the background). In Swedish till samples, the statistical sampling quality is acceptable in the bedrocks of Exotic Terranes, Archean, Baltoscandian, and Idefjorden. However, it is not acceptable in the Palaeoproterozoic units and the Eastern Segment, due to the risks being higher than the returns, which may increase the error propagation effect on the interpolated map and efficiency of the classes obtained by different classification models.

    How to cite: Sadeghi, B., Cohen, D., and Müller, D.: Improved decision-making in geochemical sampling based on both frequency and Bayesian frameworks, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-14, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-14, 2022.

    EGU22-4032 | Presentations | HS3.3

    Building saturated hydraulic conductivity maps with machine learning and geostatistics 

    Héctor Aguilera, Carolina Guardiola-Albert, Luis Moreno Merino, Carlos Baquedano, Elisabeth Díaz-Losada, Pedro Agustín Robledo Ardila, Almudena de la Losa, and Juan José Durán Valsero

    Hydraulic conductivity (Ks) is one of the most challenging, time-consuming, and expensive soil hydraulic properties to estimate. Pedotransfer functions (PTFs) of general use for Ks estimation are often site and sample-scale specific and perform poorly when extrapolated to different regions and extents. The present work develops a stepwise methodology for topsoil Ks mapping at a catchment scale based on easy, fast, and inexpensive measurements and auxiliary data (Aguilera et al., 2022). It includes a double-scale sampling of the Ks to account for small-scale variability in the spatial geostatistical interpolation. A supervised selection of variables through correlation analysis and hierarchical clustering of variables precedes the development of site-specific PTFs with machine learning (ML) techniques. The ML model is then used to generate new Ks point data predictions to extend the spatial coverage for mapping. Finally, the consistency of the final Ks map is assessed in terms of a geomorphological base map.

    The variable selection process filtered out four predictor variables from the initial pool of fourteen predictors. An artificial neural network (ANN) provided the best Ks prediction model with one hidden layer and six input variables (latitude, longitude, silt, clay, medium sand, and land use). Latitude and longitude coordinates and land use are surrogates for other physical and environmental (e.g., anthropic) factors. The relative importance of input variables in the ANN was determined as the sum of the product of raw input-hidden, hidden-output connection weights across all hidden neurons using Olden's algorithm. Longitude, percentage of clay, and percentage of medium sand presented a stronger positive relationship with Ks, while irrigated and dry land uses together with the percent of silt were the variables with a more significant negative influence on Ks. The fact that Ks was positively related to clay content is surprising, and it appears to be related to soil plowing before sampling.

    The ANN was used to estimate new Ks values from a subsequent sampling of model covariates, which doubled the input information for spatial interpolation using ordinary kriging. Overall, the spatial distribution of Ks was consistent with the lithological variability and other superimposed anthropic factors, as the method adequately considers the spatial variability of Ks added by anthropization to the already high natural heterogeneity. The produced maps will help in the hydraulic planning and flood risk management in the study area where high and low Ks, respectively, are clearly outlined.

    Reference:

    • Aguilera, C. Guardiola-Albert, L. Moreno Merino, C. Baquedano, E. Díaz-Losada, P. Agustín Robledo Ardila, J.J. Durán Valsero, Building inexpensive topsoil saturated hydraulic conductivity maps for land planning based on machine learning and geostatistics, CATENA, Volume 208, 2022, 105788, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.catena.2021.105788.

    This work is performed within the framework of the RESERVOIR project, part of the PRIMA Programme supported by the European Union. The PRIMA programme is supported under Horizon 2020 the European Union's Framework Programme for Research and Innovation. PRIMA RESERVOIR Grant Agreement number is 1924.

    How to cite: Aguilera, H., Guardiola-Albert, C., Moreno Merino, L., Baquedano, C., Díaz-Losada, E., Robledo Ardila, P. A., de la Losa, A., and Durán Valsero, J. J.: Building saturated hydraulic conductivity maps with machine learning and geostatistics, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4032, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4032, 2022.

    EGU22-4640 | Presentations | HS3.3

    Joint spatial modelling of sediment nutrients and their ratio in Lake Balaton (Hungary) using multivariate geostatistics 

    Gábor Szatmári, Mihály Kocsis, András Makó, László Pásztor, and Zsófia Bakacsi

    Eutrophication, water quality and environmental status of lakes is a global issue that depends not only on the quality and quantity of nutrients stored in lake sediments but also on their relative content. On the example of Lake Balaton (Hungary), we jointly modelled the spatial distribution of the nutrients nitrogen and phosphorus, and their ratio (i.e. nitrogen to phosphorus ratio) in the sediments of the lake and then provided spatial predictions at different supports (i.e. point, basin and entire lake) with the associated prediction uncertainty. The objective of our study was to illustrate the merits of applying multivariate geostatistics when spatial modelling of more than one variable is targeted at various scales in water ecosystems. Exploratory variography confirmed that there is a spatial interdependency between the nutrients and therefore it is better to jointly model their spatial distribution. The results revealed that by the application of multivariate geostatistics the spatial interdependency existing between the nutrients under study can be explicitly taken into account and exploited in the course of spatial modelling to provide coherent and more accurate spatial predictions that could support the complex assessment of the water quality and environmental status of Lake Balaton. Besides, stochastic realizations reproducing the joint spatial variability of the two nutrients can be generated that allow to compute stochastic realizations of their ratio, furthermore, to provide spatially aggregated predictions for larger supports (e.g. basins or entire lake) with the associated prediction uncertainty, which may be better fit to the end-users' demands on spatially explicit information about sediment nutrients. Our study highlighted that it is worthy of applying multivariate geostatistics in case spatial modelling of two or more variables, which jointly vary in space, is targeted in water ecosystems.

     

    Acknowledgements: Our research was funded by the National Research Development and Innovation Office (NKFIH), grant number K-131820. The work of Gábor Szatmári was supported by the Premium Postdoctoral Scholarship of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences (PREMIUM-2019-390).

    How to cite: Szatmári, G., Kocsis, M., Makó, A., Pásztor, L., and Bakacsi, Z.: Joint spatial modelling of sediment nutrients and their ratio in Lake Balaton (Hungary) using multivariate geostatistics, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4640, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4640, 2022.

    EGU22-5381 | Presentations | HS3.3 | Highlight

    Quantifying the impact of bathymetry changes on flood  events for the Trois-Lacs Basin 

    Sergio Redondo, Marie-Amélie Boucher, Jay Lacey, and Jérémy Parent

    Floods are a major threat to the security of populations worldwide. Their impact is dependent on the flood extension and water levels,  topographic factors, and many other variables. Meteorological factors such as precipitation, snow melt and base flow also influence the magnitude of flood events. Factors like river morphology, slopes, presence of flood plains, vegetation and soil types determine the response of the river or lake to meteorological conditions and hydrological events. Meteorological factors tend to be cyclical while topography is generally considered to remain constant over extended periods of time. However, river bathymetry is subject to changes over time due to sediment transport. For example, sediment re-positioning and accumulation can modify the bathymetry of water bodies.  Furthermore, lakes or reservoirs receive and accumulate sediments transported from upstream which could influence flood levels. In this study we use a two-dimensional hydraulic model (Telemac2D) to simulate different flood scenarios coupled with several different bathymetries of Trois-Lacs Lake in the province of Quebec, Canada. Four bathymetries were obtained between November 2020 and August 2021 and 3 historical bathymetries were also provided (yrs, 1974, 2004, and 2019).  To compare the bathymetries, total ‘available water volume’ is calculated, taking a common and constant reference water surface elevation. Streamflows entering the lake system were estimated using Hydrotel, a physics-based semi distributed hydrological model. These streamflows are used to calibrate the two-dimensional hydraulic model with measured water levels.  The project may help to establish a direct relation between sediment shifting and deposition and water distribution for extreme flood events, while also allowing the local community to improve measures for civil security and land-use planning at a regional scale.

    How to cite: Redondo, S., Boucher, M.-A., Lacey, J., and Parent, J.: Quantifying the impact of bathymetry changes on flood  events for the Trois-Lacs Basin, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5381, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5381, 2022.

    The prediction skill of the S2S period (usually referred to as two weeks but less than a season) always suffers from the integrated influence between weather and climate. Although S2S prediction has attracted more attention than before and multiple efforts have prompted related studies, the accuracy of surface soil moisture prediction in the dry condition is generally inferior to that of other variables in the S2S period. This study proposes a framework combing an ensemble empirical mode decomposition (EEMD) and Multilayer perceptron (MLP) to predict the surface soil moisture (0-7 cm) in two drought-prone regions. The proposed method has been verified and optimized in the Netherlands and Spain by using hindcasts driven by ERA5 reanalysis which can be regarded as a proxy for the real weather. The concrete practice consists of 1) calculating intrinsic mode functions (IMFs) collection and their residual components of selected ERA5-Land variables that are sensitive to surface soil moisture after data pre-processing, 2) similar IMFs curves classifications, 3) further feature selection according to classified sets, and 4) performing IMFs-driven MLP daily predictors and integrating the predicted IMFs and residual components to obtain the predicted surface soil moisture. The positive results show that this framework can be served as a regional S2S forecasting approach based on ERA5-Land reanalysis data, and with an expected daily ERA5-Land update of 5 days behind real time in 2022 instead of the current 3-month latency, the employed hybrid model is anticipated to explore realistic hydrological and agricultural applications.

    How to cite: Wang, X.: Surface soil moisture in sub-seasonal to seasonal (S2S) prediction driven by a hybrid model over drought-prone regions, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6244, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6244, 2022.

    EGU22-6288 | Presentations | HS3.3

    Data-driven Warping of Gaussian Processes for Spatial Interpolation of Skewed Data 

    Dionissios Hristopulos, Vasiliki Agou, and Andrew Pavlides

    Gaussian processes are a flexible machine learning framework that can be used for spatial interpolation and space-time prediction as well. Gaussian process regression (GPR) is quite similar to the geostatistical kriging method.  It encompasses various types of kriging (e.g., simple, ordinary, universal and regression kriging).  In addition, it is formulated in an inherently Bayesian framework which allows taking into account a priori beliefs regarding the distribution of the model’s hyper-parameters. Thus, it also incorporates Bayesian versions of kriging [1].  GPR is based on the assumption that the stochastic component of the observations follows a Gaussian distribution.  However, this is not the case for various environmental variables (e.g., amount of precipitation, hydraulic conductivity, wind speed), which follow skewed probability distributions.  The skewness is handled within the geostatistical framework using nonlinear transforms such that the marginal distribution of the data in the latent space becomes normal.  This procedure is known as Gaussian anamorphosis in geostatistics.  In the context of GPR, the term warped Gaussian process is used to denote the nonlinear transformation of the observations [2].   Gaussian anamorphosis (warping) is usually implemented using explicit, monotonically increasing nonlinear functions.  A different approach involves generating the warping function with the help of the empirically estimated cumulative probability distribution of the data.  This approach provides flexibility because the transformation is data-driven (non-parametric) and is thus not constrained by specific functional forms.  Furthermore, the cumulative distribution function of the data can be accurately estimated using smoothing kernels [3].  We investigate warped Gaussian process regression using synthetic datasets and precipitation reanalysis data from the Mediterranean island of Crete. Cross validation analysis is used to establish the advantages of non-parametric warping for the interpolation of incomplete data. We demonstrate that warped GPR equipped with data-driven warping provides enhanced flexibility compared to "bare" GPR and can lead to improved predictive accuracy for non-Gaussian data.  

    Keywords: Gaussian processes, Mediterranean island, non-Gaussian, warping, precipitation

    Funding: This research is co-financed by Greece and the European Union (European Social Fund- ESF) through the Operational Programme «Human Resources Development, Education and Lifelong Learning 2014-2020»in the context of the project “Gaussian Anamorphosis with Kernel Estimators for Spatially Distributed Data and Time Series and Applications in the Analysis of Precipitation” (MIS 5052133).

    References

    [1] T. Hristopulos, 2020. Random Fields for Spatial Data Modeling. Springer Netherlands, http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/978-94-024-1918-4.

    [2] Snelson, E., Rasmussen, C.E. and Ghahramani, Z., 2004. Warped Gaussian processes. Advances in neural information processing systems, 16, pp.337-344.

    [3] Pavlides, A., Agou, V., and Hristopulos, D. T., 2021. Non-parametric Kernel-Based Estimation of Probability Distributions for Precipitation Modeling. arXiv preprint arXiv:2109.09961.

    How to cite: Hristopulos, D., Agou, V., and Pavlides, A.: Data-driven Warping of Gaussian Processes for Spatial Interpolation of Skewed Data, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6288, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6288, 2022.

    EGU22-6992 | Presentations | HS3.3

    Statistical properties of extreme wave groups based on field data 

    Ruili Fu, Jinhai Zheng, Aifeng Tao, and Gang Wang

    An extreme wave always evolves from a wave group in random wave trains. Therefore, better insights into extreme wave groups are crucial for the safety design of marine structures. In the present work, the marginal and bivariate distributions of extreme wave group energy and duration are investigated based on the field datasets from Norway's North Sea. The most probable extreme wave group energy and duration can be obtained based on the distributions, then evolutions of wave shapes of extreme wave groups are investigated and compared with the present extreme wave group theories. It is found that the wave shapes are asymmetry with time-spatial evolution.

    How to cite: Fu, R., Zheng, J., Tao, A., and Wang, G.: Statistical properties of extreme wave groups based on field data, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6992, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6992, 2022.

    EGU22-8167 | Presentations | HS3.3

    The GeoStat-Framework: Create your geostatistical model in Python! 

    Sebastian Müller, Lennart Schüler, Alraune Zech, and Falk Heße

    The GeoStat Framework is a coherent ecosystem of Python packages for geostatistical applications and subsurface simulations. 
    It provides an easily usable open source collection of software packages. They are well documented, including exhaustive hands-on guides and examples for helping non-programmers and non-domain-experts getting started. The main applications of the packages are:

    • GSTools & PyKrige - spatial random field generation, kriging, data normalization & transformation, and geostatistical analyses based on variogram methods
    • AnaFlow - (semi-)analytical solutions for specific groundwater-flow scenarios and the extended Generalized Radial Flow model
    • welltestpy - store, manipulate, and analyze well-based field testing campaigns with a focus on estimating parameters of subsurface heterogeneity from pumping test data.
    • ogs5py - pre-processing, operating, and post-processing of subsurface flow and transport simulations by providing a Python API for the FEM solver OpenGeoSys 5

    With this collection of flexible toolboxes we aim to close the gap of missing software for real-world applications in the field of geostatistics. 
    Especially GSTools is the first comprehensive Python-toolbox for covariance models, field generation, kriging, variogram estimation, data normalization and transformation. The formerly independed project PyKrige, developed by Benjamin Murphy, has been migrated to the GeoStat-Framework und we started to build a common Rust backend for the numerical heavy lifting called GSTools-Core.

    We will show a set of complex workflow examples, like temperature trend analysis and pumping test ensemble simulations, and we will give an overview of the provided functionality and an outlook for the future. All workflows are made accessible as GeoStat-Examples repositories.

    References

    • GSTools: Müller, S., et. al. https://doi.org/10.5194/gmd-2021-301, 2021 (in review)
    • AnaFlow: Müller, S., et. al. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.advwatres.2021.104027, 2021
    • welltestpy: Müller, S., et. al. https://doi.org/10.1111/gwat.13121, 2021
    • ogs5py: Müller, S., et. al. https://doi.org/10.1111/gwat.13017, 2020

    Links

    • Website: https://geostat-framework.org/
    • GitHub: https://github.com/GeoStat-Framework
    • GeoStat-Examples: https://github.com/GeoStat-Examples

    How to cite: Müller, S., Schüler, L., Zech, A., and Heße, F.: The GeoStat-Framework: Create your geostatistical model in Python!, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8167, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8167, 2022.

    EGU22-11000 | Presentations | HS3.3

    Estimates of total phosphorus for Amazonia based on an expanded harmonized soil database 

    Monique Rodrigues da Silva Andrade Maia, Liana Oighenstein Anderson, and Carlos Alberto Nobre Quesada

    The element phosphorus total (Pt) is considered a basic element for life on earth. It controls key processes of CO2 absorption from tropical forests to food production. For the Amazon region, estimates of Pt in the soil are scarce. In this study, we developed models through equations of pedotransfer function (PTF's) using data collected in the field (RAINFOR data). Were generated 16 regression models based on the Akaike information criteria (AIC) with R² above 65% was validated with independent RAINFOR data. The results Pt distribution were spatialized using interpolations by geostatistical method of inverse distance weights (IDW) and shown through maps.

    How to cite: Maia, M. R. D. S. A., Anderson, L. O., and Quesada, C. A. N.: Estimates of total phosphorus for Amazonia based on an expanded harmonized soil database, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11000, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11000, 2022.

    EGU22-11644 | Presentations | HS3.3

    Space-time groundwater level distribution estimation in a complex system of aquifers 

    Emmanouil Varouchakis, Ioannis Trichakis, and George Karatzas

    A geostatistical analysis based on a machine learning method was conducted to generate reliable spatial maps of groundwater level variability and to identify groundwater level patterns over the island of Crete, Greece. Geostatistics plays an important role in model-related data analysis and preparation, but has specific limitations when the aquifer system is inhomogeneous. Self-Organizing Maps can be applied to identify locally similar input data and then by means of Ordinary Kriging to estimate the spatial distribution of groundwater level. The proposed methodology was tested on a large dataset of groundwater level data in a complex hydrogeological district, and the results were significantly improved if compared to the use of classical geostatistical approaches.

    This work was developed under the scope of the InTheMED project. InTheMED is part of the PRIMA programme supported by the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 1923.

    How to cite: Varouchakis, E., Trichakis, I., and Karatzas, G.: Space-time groundwater level distribution estimation in a complex system of aquifers, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11644, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11644, 2022.

    EGU22-11777 | Presentations | HS3.3 | Highlight

    Machine Learning Model to Reproduce Nature-Based Solutions for Flood and Drought Mitigation 

    Kabita Gautam, Gerald Corzo, Shreedhar Maskey, and Dimitri Solomatine

    Reducing the threat of severe spatiotemporal events like floods and droughts is raising concerns for water resource development and management. The severity of drought and floods increases more due to human interventions. Recent studies have focused on finding long-term solutions that mimic nature's process, while posing no environmental risks and targeting sustainability in traditional approaches. The terminology given in Europe for this natural solution is Nature-Based Solutions (NBS). Some examples of NBS are afforestation or reforestation, storage areas, vegetation buffers, and riparian forest. The main principle of NBS is that they slow down the rate of runoff by boosting interception, infiltration, or storage for flood water, hence mitigating the risk downstream. However, there is still not enough experimental nor theoretical experience on how they could be implemented to optimize their use. The way to represent NBS and the scale of implementation in models and real life is for now a process based on approximated propositions of the empirical knowledge of experts in the field. Although some experience have shown important contributions, this is not enough for an optimal implementation and a complete understanding of all possible outcomes. This is the problem expected to be addressed in this research. The main goal is to construct machine learning models to explore their use as an alternative (surrogate) that will aid in performing multiple scenario analyses of NBS, and quantifying their impacts. This approach will consider spatial and temporal data and create a link between several environmental variables and human actions without explicitly knowing the physical behavior of the system, yet clustering(grouping) behaviors or processes responses to structural properties of the hydrological model representation. The case study area for this research is the Bagmati River Basin of Nepal, covering a catchment area of 2822 sq. km, and the flow is dominated by spring and monsoon rainfall. Soil and Water Assessment Tool (SWAT) is used and the baseline scenario (without the implementation of NBS) is modeled. Different scenarios of afforestation, ponds, and conservation tillage will be intervened in the SWAT model and the changes made by those interventions will be replicated in Artificial Neural Network-Multi Layer Perceptron (ANN-MLP). Several unforeseen scenarios will also be tested in machine learning. Thus, the Spatio-temporal analysis will be done regarding the impact of NBS on the flows, and the machine learning model’s ability to replicate such complex systems will be evaluated.

     

    The outcome presented here shows the construction of a SWAT model and the preliminary results of machine learning models capable of promptly predicting changes in flow induced by the adoption of various Nature-Based Solutions. It is anticipated to be a simple, effective, and time-saving way for studying the effectiveness of various Nature-Based Solutions for flood and drought mitigation. Thus, this study contributes to the experiences in interpreting and linking complex hydrological problems in machine learning systems.

     

    Keywords: SWAT, Machine learning, Nature-Based Solutions, Hydrological extremes, Spatio-temporal analysis

    How to cite: Gautam, K., Corzo, G., Maskey, S., and Solomatine, D.: Machine Learning Model to Reproduce Nature-Based Solutions for Flood and Drought Mitigation, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11777, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11777, 2022.

    EGU22-12784 | Presentations | HS3.3

    Analysis of spatiotemporal rainfall objects in hydrological ensemble forecast predictions 

    Andres Julian Ruiz Gomez, Gerald Corzo Perez, Schalk Jan Van Andel, and Germán Ricardo Santos Granados

    Initial works on forecasting focused their efforts on one-dimensional precipitation time-series analysis. However, rainfall phenomena are sometimes quite heterogeneous and spatially variable in space and time, especially in extreme events. To address this issue, an integrated approach might be needed, where not only the spatio-temporal variability of rainfall is considered, but also the uncertainty that is present in forecasting. The objective of this research is to analyse the relationship between spatio-temporal rainfall objects estimated from numerical weather prediction models and their hydrological response in a river basin. It is assumed that a better understanding of this relation could help to characterize and forecast extreme phenomena. For this study, the Dapoling-Wangjiba catchment is evaluated, where observed precipitation and discharge data from 2006 to 2009 were available. The analysis is based on four main components:  first, the rainfall perturbed members data are obtained through the TIGGE dataset from ECMWF. Second, the object-based methodology ST-CORA is used in order to characterize the possible rainfall events via its spatio-temporal characteristics such as centroid, spatial coverage and duration. Third, a fully distributed and calibrated HAPI model is used for obtaining a simulated discharge in the catchment outlet and finally, an analysis between the statistics of the object’s characteristics and the hydrological response is carried out. The results of this research are expected to be used in future improvements on how forecasting and early warning and nowadays emitted and understood.

    How to cite: Ruiz Gomez, A. J., Corzo Perez, G., Van Andel, S. J., and Santos Granados, G. R.: Analysis of spatiotemporal rainfall objects in hydrological ensemble forecast predictions, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12784, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12784, 2022.

    EGU22-12817 | Presentations | HS3.3

    Exploratory analysis of Sub-seasonal to Seasonal precipitation forecasting using Machine Learning Techniques 

    Mohamed Elbasheer and Gerald Corzo Perez

    Sub-seasonal to seasonal (S2S) forecasting ranges from two weeks to two months. This range of time is significant and has a substantial socio-economic impact for many societal applications such as agriculture, food security and risk mitigation because it gives a reasonable margin of time for any management measure (for example, disaster or risk mitigation measures) that need one or two weeks to be implemented. However, the reliability of the S2S forecasting is still underdeveloped, and many studies and even competitions have been promoted to aim at the study of how can Machine learning and other techniques help. So, in this study we evaluate the accuracy and reliability of the ECMWF S2S precipitation forecasts focusing on the extreme events (above and below normal precipitation events) using three verification methods; Receiver operating characteristic curve (ROC), Reliability diagram and Ranked probability skill score (RPSS). For this evaluation, three regions are selected globally. In addition to the accuracy evaluation, we investigated the use of machine learning techniques such as k-nearest neighbors (k-NN), Logistic Regression (LR) and Multilayer Perceptron (MLP) to improve the accuracy and reliability of the ECMWF S2S forecast. To select the appropriate input variables for the machine learning models; An analysis of temporal and spatial continuity of the variables is done using the Pearson correlation coefficient for temporal correlation and the experimental variogram for spatial continuity.

    How to cite: Elbasheer, M. and Perez, G. C.: Exploratory analysis of Sub-seasonal to Seasonal precipitation forecasting using Machine Learning Techniques, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12817, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12817, 2022.

    EGU22-12857 | Presentations | HS3.3

    Bidimensional Spatiotemporal analysis of local atmospherically fluxes and regional moisture budgets in river basins 

    Karel Aldrin Sanchez Hernandez and Gerald Augusto Corzo Perez

    Many regions in the world are threaten by Climate change, and there is a large global concern on the dependency of water contributions from neighbouring countries. In order to understand more how the water contributions from other region affect a river basin, global spatiotemporal information could be used to obtain budgets balance. This study proposes a methodology to analyse the atmospheric moisture balance around hydrological units (watersheds) using ERA 5 reanalysis data sets, allowing the evaluation of the role of spatiotemporal patterns associated with the transport of regional moisture fluxes and understanding how these components modulate regional water heterogeneity, sources and sinks. This study consists of 3 phases: 1) collection and validation of the required hydrometeorological sets and variables and two-dimensional discretization of the hydrographic domain or unit establishing the boundaries for computational analysis; then, estimation and evaluation of the contribution patterns of transported moisture fluxes based on the Eulerian model developed by Brubaker,1993. Finally, for each region, we proceed to estimate the spatiotemporal variations of the atmospheric water balance by establishing the calculation of the precipitation recycling rate as well as the fractions of horizontal moisture flux contributions from each direction or boundary, as well as their seasonality and interannual variability, magnitudes and concentration rates associated with flux divergence. As a case study, the Pamplonita river basin in Colombia was selected. Here we present these results, that have provided valuable information related to the identification of biases in the estimation of atmospheric water supplies, monitoring strategies and hydrological balance.

    How to cite: Sanchez Hernandez, K. A. and Corzo Perez, G. A.: Bidimensional Spatiotemporal analysis of local atmospherically fluxes and regional moisture budgets in river basins, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12857, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12857, 2022.

    EGU22-12878 | Presentations | HS3.3

    Climate change analysis of hydrological droughts in Jiet catchment, Romania. 

    Cindy Beltran Mora, Ioana Popescu, Andreja Jonoski, Gerald Corzo, Marcel de Ruijter, and Daniela Dudau

    Drought events are more common nowadays than it used to be in the past in different areas around the world. Some of its consequences are the reduction of cropping areas, lower rates of percolation for recharge of aquifers and scarcity of drinkable water. To analyse and identify droughts location, dates of occurrence and severity, it is necessary to collect meteorological data. However, based on the location of the study region, some places do not have measurement stations, hence, spatiotemporal databases are the best alternative. Present paper shows the analysis of the past and future scenarios of hydrological droughts due to climate change in the Jiet river basin in Romania. Spatiotemporal data from remote sensing with different resolutions is analysed and processed. Data from year.1990. to year 2020. At a resolution of 0.1̊ is compared to projection scenario RCp 8.5 during 2030 to 2060.

    An assessment of hydrological droughts for past scenarios is made by defining a statistical threshold (85 percentile) from historical data. Further, an analysis of characteristics of hydrological drought events is performed for present and future scenarios. Drought is measured through soil moisture analysis, using results from HEC – HMS v4.9 BETA, hydrological modelling tool. This study presents the results of the first stage of the process were a spatiotemporal analysis of the calibration performance of the of the hydrological model and the droughts found are characterized. 

    How to cite: Beltran Mora, C., Popescu, I., Jonoski, A., Corzo, G., de Ruijter, M., and Dudau, D.: Climate change analysis of hydrological droughts in Jiet catchment, Romania., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12878, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12878, 2022.

    EGU22-12896 | Presentations | HS3.3 | Highlight

    Machine Learning Techniques for Spatiotemporal drought patterns forecasting 

    Laura Viviana Garzon Useche, Karel Aldrin Sánchez Hernández, Gerald Augusto Corzo Perez, and German Ricardo Santos Granados

    The erratic drought nature and its great spatiotemporal variability make conventional forecasting systems or stochastic forecasting systems very limited in terms of the monitoring of its dynamic characteristics. Therefore, this study proposes a dynamic forecasting methodology based on machine learning models by tracking the spatial and temporal characteristics of drought events.

    This methodology consists of four main phases. 1) the drought spatiotemporal characteristics calculation and extraction such as spatial aggregations or extensions, geospatial properties (area, perimeter), centroid location and trajectory from their connectivity, which are generated following the contiguous drought area analysis (CDA) proposed by Corzo--- 2) feature engineering and dataset preparation, which is consolidated according to the hierarchy and relative importance of the associated predictor and predictor variables 3) implementation of an intelligent analysis method based on deep neural network architecture (CNN, LSTM) techniques, which combines spatial observation mediated by convolution integrated with temporal analysis for prediction. Thus generating primary results against the future propagation pattern or trajectory of a spatial unit. 4) Analyzing the various model performances based on statistical metrics, validation of the generated trajectories using the area under the curve (AUC) and receiver operating characteristic (ROC) and error approach as Root Mean Square Error (RMSE).

    This methodology is presented using indexes derived from the ERA 5 reanalysis dataset as SPEI and SPI on the Central America dry corridor (1979-2020), where the performance of the intelligent system will be evaluated not only taking into account the statistical performance, but also in the identification and forecasting of those regions with major drought generation tendencies.

    How to cite: Garzon Useche, L. V., Sánchez Hernández, K. A., Corzo Perez, G. A., and Santos Granados, G. R.: Machine Learning Techniques for Spatiotemporal drought patterns forecasting, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12896, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12896, 2022.

    EGU22-13051 | Presentations | HS3.3

    Spatial and temporal long-range dependence in the scale domain 

    Panayiotis Dimitriadis, Theano Iliopoulou, G.-Foivos Sargentis, and Demetris Koutsoyiannis

    Long-range dependence (LRD) estimators are traditionally applied in the lag domain (e.g., through the autocovariance or variogram) or in the frequency domain (e.g., through the power-spectrum), but not as often in the scale domain (e.g., through variance vs. scale). It has been contended that the latter case introduces large estimation bias and thus, corresponds to "bad estimators" of the LRD. However, this reflects a misrepresentation or misuse of the concept of variance vs. scale. Specifically, it is shown that if the LRD estimator of variance vs. scale is properly defined and assessed (see literature studies for the so-called climacogram estimator), then the stochastic analysis of variance in the scale domain can be proven to be a robust means to identify and model any LRD process ranging from small scales (fractal behavior) to large scales (LRD, else known as the Hurst-Kolmogorov dynamics) for any marginal distribution. Here, we show how the above definitions can be applied both in spatial and temporal scales, with various applications in geophysical processes, key hydrological-cycle processes, and related natural hazards.

    How to cite: Dimitriadis, P., Iliopoulou, T., Sargentis, G.-F., and Koutsoyiannis, D.: Spatial and temporal long-range dependence in the scale domain, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13051, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13051, 2022.

    Improving streamflow forecasts helps in reducing socio-economical impacts of hydrological-related damages. Among them, improving hydropower production is a challenge, even more so in a context of climate change. Deep learning models drew the attention of scientists working on forecasting models based on physical laws, since they got recognition in other domains. Artificial Neural Network (ANN) offer promising performance for streamflow forecasts, including good accuracy and lesser time to run compared to traditional physically-based models. 

     

    The objective of this study is to compare different spatial discretization schemes of inputs in an ANN model for streamflow forecast. The study focuses on the “Au Saumon” watershed in Southern Quebec (Canada) during summer periods, with a forecast window of 7 days at a daily timestep. Parameterization of the ANN was a key preliminary step: the number of neurons in the hidden layer was first optimized, leading to 6 neurons. The model was trained on a 11-year dataset (2000-2005 and 2007-2011) followed by model validation on one dry (2012) and one wet (2006) year to take into account extreme hydrologic regimes. 

     

    To lead this study, the physically-based hydrological ‘Hydrotel’ model is the reference to compare our results. The model defines watershed heterogeneity using hydrological units based on land uses, soil types, and topography, called Relative Homogeneous Hydrological Units (RHHU). The Nash-Sutcliffe Efficiency score (NSE) is the main evaluation criteria calculated. In a preliminary step, we have to ensure the ANN model can satisfactorily mimic Hydrotel. With the same model inputs, that is same variables and same spatial discretizations of variables (total precipitation, daily maximum and minimum temperatures, and soil surface humidity), the ANN forecasts were found to be better than those of Hydrotel for one to 7-day forecasts. 

     

    Three different watershed spatial discretizations were tested: global, fully distributed, and semi-distributed. For the global model, hydrometeorological data used as inputs to the ANN model were averaged across all RHHUs. The complexity is reduced with loss of spatial details and heterogeneity. For the fully distributed model, a regular grid was defined with six cells of 28x28km2 covering all the watershed. For the semi-distributed model, spatial distribution of the input data was that of the RHHUs. For this discretization, the state variables (soil moisture and outflow) were updated at each forecast timestep, whether on all RHHUs, or only on the RHHU of the outlet.

     

    Depending on the spatial discretization of inputs used, the accuracy differed. The fully distributed model offered the least performance, with NSE values of 0.85 ,while the global model surprisingly performed better with a 0.93 NSE. Moreover, updating soil moisture on all the RHHUs of the semi-distributed model improved the NSE across the entire window of forecast.

    This research will assess the ANN model performance developed using ERA5-land precipitation and temperature reanalysis and ground observations of soil moisture. Given the promising results obtained with the fully and semi distributed models, our ANN model will be tested with state variables retrieved from satellite data, such as surface soil moisture from SMAP and SMOS missions.



    How to cite: Buire, M., Ahlouche, M., Jougla, R., and Leconte, R.: Forecasting streamflow using Artificial Neural Network (ANN) with different spatial discretizations of the watershed : use case on the Au Saumon watershed in Quebec (Canada)., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1767, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1767, 2022.

    EGU22-2254 | Presentations | HS3.4

    Flood forecasting using sensor network and Support Vector Machine model 

    Jakub Langhammer

    Machine learning has shown great promise for hydrological modeling because, unlike conventional approaches, it allows efficient processing of big data provided by the recent automatic monitoring networks. This research presents the Support Vector Machine (SVM) model designed for modeling floods in a montane environment based on data from a distributed automated sensor network. The study aimed to test the reliability of the SVM model to predict the different types of flood events occurring in the environment of a mid-latitude headwater basin, experiencing the effects of climate and land use change. 

    The sensor network uses four hydrological and two meteorological stations, located in headwaters of the montane basin of Vydra, experiencing intense forest disturbance, a rise in air temperatures, and frequent occurrence of flood events. Automated hydrological stations are operating in the study area for ten years, recording the water levels in a 10-minute interval with online access to data. Meteorological stations monitor air temperatures, precipitation, and snow cover depth at the same time step. 

    The model network was built using the Support Vector Machines (SVM), particularly the nu-SVR algorithm, employing the LibSVM library. The network was trained and validated on a complex sample of hydrological observations and tested on the scenarios covering different types of extreme events. The simulation scenarios included the floods from a single summer storm, recurrent storms, prolonged regional rain, snowmelt, and a rain-on-snow event. 

    The model proved the robustness and good performance of the data-driven SVM model to simulate hydrological time series. The RMSE model performance ranged from 0,91-0,97 for individual scenarios, without substantial errors in the fit of the trend, timing of the events, peak values, and flood volumes. The model reliably reconstructed even the complex flood events, such as rain on snow episodes and flooding from recurrent precipitation. 

    The research proved that the data-driven SVM model provides a reliable and robust tool for simulating flood events from sensor network data. The model proved reliability in a montane environment featuring rapid runoff generation, transient environmental conditions, and variability of flood event types. The SVM model proved to efficiently handle big data volumes from sensor networks and, under such conditions, is a promising approach for operational flood forecasting and hydrological research. 

    How to cite: Langhammer, J.: Flood forecasting using sensor network and Support Vector Machine model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2254, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2254, 2022.

    EGU22-3281 | Presentations | HS3.4

    Assessment of Transfer Learning Techniques to Improve Streamflow Predictions in Data-Sparse Regions 

    Yegane Khoshkalam, Farshid Rahmani, Alain N. Rousseau, Kian Abbasnezhadi, Chaopeng Shen, and Etienne Foulon

    Reliable streamflow predictions are critical for managing water resources for flood warning, agricultural irrigation apportionment, hydroelectric production, to name a few. However, there are geographical heterogeneities in available observed streamflow data, river basin geophysical attributes, and meteorological data to support such predictions. Moreover, in data-sparse regions, both process-based and data-driven models have difficulties in being sufficiently calibrated or trained; increasing the difficulty to achieve satisfactory predictions. That being mentioned, it is possible to transfer knowledge from regions with dense and available measured data to data-sparse regions. In earlier work, we have shown that transfer learning based on a long short-term memory (LSTM) network, pre-trained over the conterminous United States, could improve daily streamflow prediction in Quebec (Canada) when compared to a semi-distributed hydrological model (HYDROTEL). The dataset used for pre-training (source dataset) was the Catchment Attributes and Meteorology for Large-sample Studies (CAMELS), while the data for the basins located at the target locations (local dataset) were extracted from the Hydrometeorological Sandbox-École de Technologie Supérieure (HYSETS). Both datasets provide access to various types of information with different spatial resolutions. While HYSETS is generally spanning from 1950 to 2018, the temporal interval for most of the basins reported in CAMELS goes back to 1980. The types of data included in both CAMELS and HYSETS include daily meteorological data (precipitation, temperature, etc.), streamflow observations, and basins physiographic attributes (i.e., considered time-invariant or static). In this work, the techniques applied to further improve streamflow simulations included the use of: (i) streamflow observations and simulated flows from HYDROTEL as input to the LSTM model, (ii) different forcing (meteorological data) and static attribute data from the source and the local datasets, and (iii) additional basins from HYSETS with similar climatological features for model training. The ultimate goal was to improve the accuracy of the predicted hydrographs with an emphasis on enhancing the prediction of peak flows by transfer learning while using the Kling-Gupta efficiency (KGE) and Nash-Sutcliffe efficiency (NSE) metrics. This investigation has revealed the benefits of using transfer learning techniques based on deep learning models to improve streamflow predictions when compared to the application of a distributed hydrological models in data-sparse regions.

    How to cite: Khoshkalam, Y., Rahmani, F., Rousseau, A. N., Abbasnezhadi, K., Shen, C., and Foulon, E.: Assessment of Transfer Learning Techniques to Improve Streamflow Predictions in Data-Sparse Regions, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3281, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3281, 2022.

    EGU22-3661 | Presentations | HS3.4

    Neural ODEs in Hydrology: Fusing Conceptual Models with Deep Learning for Improved Predictions and Process Understanding 

    Marvin Höge, Andreas Scheidegger, Marco Baity-Jesi, Carlo Albert, and Fabrizio Fenicia

    Deep learning methods have repeatedly proven to outperform conceptual hydrologic models in rainfall-runoff modelling. Although attempts of investigating the internals of such deep learning models are being made, traceability of model states and processes and their interrelations to model input and output is not fully given, yet. Direct interpretability of mechanistic processes has always been considered as asset of conceptual models that helps to gain system understanding aside of predictability. We introduce hydrologic Neural ODE models that perform as well as state-of-the-art deep learning methods in rainfall-runoff prediction while maintaining the ease of interpretability of conceptual hydrologic models. In Neural ODEs, model internal processes that are typically implemented in differential equations by hard-coding are substituted by neural networks. Therefore, Neural ODE models offer a way to fuse deep learning with mechanistic modelling yielding time-continuous solutions. We demonstrate the basin-specific predictive capability for several hundred catchments of the continental US, and exemplarily give insight to what the neural networks within the ODE models have learned about the model internal processes. Further, we discuss the role of Neural ODE models on the middle ground between pure deep learning and pure conceptual hydrologic models.

    How to cite: Höge, M., Scheidegger, A., Baity-Jesi, M., Albert, C., and Fenicia, F.: Neural ODEs in Hydrology: Fusing Conceptual Models with Deep Learning for Improved Predictions and Process Understanding, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3661, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3661, 2022.

    EGU22-3825 | Presentations | HS3.4

    Karst spring discharge modeling based on deep learning using spatially distributed input data 

    Andreas Wunsch, Tanja Liesch, Guillaume Cinkus, Nataša Ravbar, Zhao Chen, Naomi Mazzillli, Hervé Jourde, and Nico Goldscheider

    Despite many existing approaches, modeling karst water resources remains challenging and often requires solid system knowledge. Artificial Neural Network approaches offer a convenient solution by establishing a simple input-output relationship on their own. However, in this context, temporal and especially spatial data availability is often an important constraint, as usually no or few climate stations within a karst spring catchment are available. Hence spatial coverage is often unsatisfying and can introduce severe uncertainties. To overcome these problems, we use 2D-Convolutional Neural Networks (CNN) to directly process gridded meteorological data followed by a 1D-CNN to perform karst spring discharge simulation. We investigate three karst spring catchments in the Alpine and Mediterranean region with different meteorologic-hydrological characteristics and hydrodynamic system properties. We compare our 2D-models both to existing modeling studies in these regions and to own 1D-models that are conventionally based on climate station input data. Our results show that our models are excellently suited to model karst spring discharge and rival the simulation results of existing approaches in the respective areas. The 2D-models show a better fit than the 1D-models in two of three cases, learn relevant parts of the input data themselves and by performing a spatial input sensitivity analysis we can further show their usefulness to localize the position of karst catchments.

    How to cite: Wunsch, A., Liesch, T., Cinkus, G., Ravbar, N., Chen, Z., Mazzillli, N., Jourde, H., and Goldscheider, N.: Karst spring discharge modeling based on deep learning using spatially distributed input data, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3825, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3825, 2022.

    EGU22-3946 | Presentations | HS3.4

    Graph Neural Networks for Reservoir Level Forecasting and Draught Identification 

    Aiden Durrant, David Haro, and Georgios Leontidis

    The management of water resource systems is a longstanding and inherently complex problem, balancing an increasing number of interests to meet short- and long-term objectives sustainably. The difficulty of analyzing large-scale, multi-reservoir water systems is compounded by the scale and interpretation of the historic data. Therefore, to assist in the decision-making processes for water allocation we propose the use of machine learning, specifically deep learning to uncover and interpret relationships in high-dimensional data that can enable more accurate forecasting.   

    We explore the problem of reservoir level prediction as a pilot study, comparing traditional machine learning approaches to our proposal of spatial-temporal graph neural networks that embed the topological nature of the water system. The graph convolutional neural network explicitly captures spatial interaction among segments of river within the system. The construction of the graph is as follows: nodes represent the reservoir and river monitoring stations; edges define the characteristics of the river sections connecting these stations (i.e. distance, flow, etc.); multiple states of the aforementioned graph, each at different measurement intervals. We then train the network to predict the water level of a node (reservoir measurement station) from previous time intervals. The proposed network is trained on historic data of the EBRO basin, Spain, from 1981 to 2018, specifically utilizing river and reservoir gauging station flow rate and fill level respectively, with the addition of characteristics defining each component of the water system. 

    We validate our approaches over a 4-year period, making predictions across various time frames, showing the robustness to various circumstances, and meeting necessary objective requirements ranging from daily to monthly forecasting. As an extension, we also investigate the use of our predictions to allow for drought identification, demonstrating just one of many use-cases where machine learning can uncover vital information that can lead to better management and planning decisions. 

    How to cite: Durrant, A., Haro, D., and Leontidis, G.: Graph Neural Networks for Reservoir Level Forecasting and Draught Identification, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3946, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3946, 2022.

    EGU22-4303 | Presentations | HS3.4

    Fast and detailed emulation of urban drainage flows using physics-guided machine learning 

    Roland Löwe, Rocco Palmitessa, Allan Peter Engsig-Karup, and Morten Grum

    Hydrodynamic models (numerical solutions of the Saint Venant equations) are at the core of simulating water movements in natural streams and drainage systems. They enable realistic simulations of water movement and are directly linked to physical system characteristics such as channel slope and diameter. This feature is important for man-made drainage structures as it enables straightforward testing of the effects of varying channel designs. In cities, models with hundreds up to tens of thousands of pipes are commonly used for drainage infrastructure. Their computational expense remains high and they are not suited for a systematic screening of design options, discussing water management options in workshops, as well as many real-time applications such as data assimilation.

    Hydrologists have developed many approaches to enable faster simulations. All of these do, however, compromise on the physical detail of the simulated processes (for example, by simulating only flows using linear reservoirs), and usually also on the spatial and temporal resolution of the models (for example, by simulating only flows between key points in the system). The link to physical system characteristics is thus lost. Therefore, it is challenging to incorporate such approaches into planning workflows where changing city plans require a constant revision of water management options.

    Recent advances in scientific machine learning enable the creation of fast machine learning surrogates for complex systems that preserve a high spatio-temporal detail and a physically accurate simulation. We present such an approach that employs generalized residue networks for the simulation of hydraulics in drainage systems. The key concept is to train neural networks that learn how hydraulic states (level, flow and surcharge volume) at all nodes and pipes in the drainage network evolve from one time step to another, given a set of boundary conditions (surface runoff). Training is performed against the output of a hydrodynamic model for a short time series.

    Once trained, the surrogates generate the same results as a hydrodynamic model in the same level of detail, and they can be used to quickly simulate the effect of many different rain events and climate scenarios. Considering pipe networks with 50 to 100 pipes, our approach achieves NSE values in the order of 0.95 for the testing dataset. Simulations are performed 10 to 50 times faster than the hydrodynamic model. Training times are in the order of 25 minutes on a single CPU. The surrogates are system specific and need to be retrained when the physical system changes. To minimize this overhead, we train surrogates for small subsystems which can subsequently be linked into a model for a large drainage network.

    Our approach is an initial application of scientific machine learning for the simulation of hydraulics that is readily combined with other recent developments. Future research should, in particular, explore the application of physics-informed loss functions for bypassing the generation of training data from hydrodynamic simulations, and of graph neural networks to exploit spatial correlation structures in the pipe network.

    How to cite: Löwe, R., Palmitessa, R., Engsig-Karup, A. P., and Grum, M.: Fast and detailed emulation of urban drainage flows using physics-guided machine learning, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4303, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4303, 2022.

    EGU22-4639 | Presentations | HS3.4

    Mapping Sweden’s drainage ditches using deep learning and airborne laser scanning 

    William Lidberg, Siddhartho Paul, Florian Westphal, and Anneli Ågren

    Drainage ditches are common forestry practice across northern European boreal forests and in some parts of North America. Ditching helps with lowering the groundwater level in the wet parts of the forest to improve soil aeration and to support tree growth. However, the intensive ditching practice pose multidimensional environmental risks, particularly for degradation of wetland and soil, greenhouse gas, increased nutrient and sediment loadings to water bodies, as well as biodiversity loss. At the same time there is a discrepancy between the potential significance of artificial water bodies, such as drainage ditches and their low representation in scientific research and water management policy. A comparison with a national inventory of Sweden showed that only 9 % of drainage ditches are present on the best avalible map of Sweden. The increasing understanding of the environmental risks associated with forest ditches together with the poor representation of ditch networks in existing maps of many forest landscapes makes detailed mapping of these ditches a priority for sustainable land and water management. Here, we combine two state-of-the-art technologies – airborne laser scanning and deep learning - for detecting drainage ditches on a national scale.

     

    A deep neural network was trained on airborne laser scanning data and 1607 km of manually digitized ditch channels from 10 regions spread across Sweden. 20 % of the data was set aside for testing the model.  The model correctly mapped 82 % of all small drainage channels in the test data with a Matthew's correlation coefficient of 0.72. This approach only requires one topographical index, a high pass median filter calculated from a digital elevation model with a 1 m spatial resolution. This made it possible to scale up over large areas with limited computational resources and the trained model was implemented using Microsoft Azure to map ditch channels across all of Sweden. The total mapped channel length was 970 00 km (equivalent to 24 times around the world). Visual inspection indicated that this method also classifies natural stream channels as drainage channels, which suggests that a deep neural network can be trained to detect natural stream channels in addition to drainage ditches. The model only required one topographical index which makes it possible to implement this approach in other areas with access to high resolution digital elevation data.

    How to cite: Lidberg, W., Paul, S., Westphal, F., and Ågren, A.: Mapping Sweden’s drainage ditches using deep learning and airborne laser scanning, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4639, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4639, 2022.

    EGU22-5130 | Presentations | HS3.4

    Advancing drought monitoring via feature extraction and multi-task learning algorithms 

    Matteo Giuliani, Paolo Bonetti, Alberto Maria Metelli, Marcello Restelli, and Andrea Castelletti

    A drought is a slowly developing natural phenomenon that can occur in all climatic zones and can be defined as a temporary but significant decrease in water availability. Over the past three decades, the cost of droughts in Europe amounted to over 100 billion euros, with the recent summer droughts being unprecedented in the last 2,000 years. Although drought monitoring and management are extensively studied in the literature, capturing the evolution of drought dynamics, and associated impacts across different temporal and spatial scales remains a critical, unsolved challenge.

    In this work, we contribute with a Machine Learning procedure named FRIDA (FRamework for Index-based Drought Analysis) for the identification of impact-based drought indexes. FRIDA is a fully automated data-driven approach that relies on advanced feature extraction algorithms to identify relevant drought drivers from a pool of candidate hydro-meteorological predictors. The selected predictors are then combined into an index representing a surrogate of the drought conditions in the considered area, including either observed or simulated water deficits or remotely sensed information on crop status. Notably, FRIDA leverages multi-task learning algorithms to upscale the analysis over a large region where drought impacts might depend on diverse but potentially correlated drivers. FRIDA captures the heterogeneous features of the different sub-regions while efficiently using all available data and exploiting the commonalities across sub-regions. In this way, the accuracy of the resulting prediction benefits from a reduced uncertainty compared to training separate models for each sub-region. Several real-world examples will be used to provide a synthesis of recent applications of FRIDA in case studies featuring diverse hydroclimatic conditions and variable levels of data availability.

    How to cite: Giuliani, M., Bonetti, P., Metelli, A. M., Restelli, M., and Castelletti, A.: Advancing drought monitoring via feature extraction and multi-task learning algorithms, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5130, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5130, 2022.

    EGU22-6191 | Presentations | HS3.4

    An operational framework for data driven low flow forecasts in Flanders 

    Tim Franken, Cedric Gullentops, Vincent Wolfs, Willem Defloor, Pieter Cabus, and Inge De Jongh

    Belgium is ranked 23rd out of 164 countries in water scarcity and the third highest in Europe according to the Water Resource Institute. The warm and dry summers of the past few years have made it clear that Flanders has little if any buffer to cope with a sharp increase in water demand or a prolonged period of dry weather. To increase the resilience and preparedness against droughts, we developed the framework named hAIdro: an operational early warning system for low flows that allows to take timely, local and effective measures against water shortages. Data driven rainfall-runoff models are at the core of the forecasting system that allows to forecast droughts up to 30 days ahead.

    The architecture of the data driven hydrological models are inspired by the Multi-Timescale Long Short Term Memory (MTS-LSTM, [1]) that allow to integrate past and future data in one prediction pipeline. The model architecture consists of 3 LTSM’s that are organized in a branched structure. The historical branch processes the historical meteorological data, remote sensing data and static catchment features into encoded state vectors. These are passed through fully connected layers to both a daily and an hourly forecasting branch which are used to make runoff predictions on short (72 hours) and long (30 days) time horizons. The forecasting branches are fed with forecasts of rainfall and temperature, static catchment features and discharge observations. The novelty of the proposed model structure lies in the way discharge observations are incorporated. Only the most recent discharge observations are used in the forecasting branches to minimize the consequences of missing discharge observations in an operational context. The models are trained using a weighted Nash-Sutcliffe Efficiency (NSE) as objective function that puts additional emphasis on low flows. Results show that the newly created data driven models perform well compared to calibrated lumped hydrological PDM models [2] for various performance metrics including Log-NSE and NSE.

    We developed a custom cloud-based operational forecasting system, called hAIdro to bring the data driven hydrological models in production. hAIdro processes large quantities of local meteorological measurements, radar rainfall data and ECMWF extended range forecasts to make probabilistic forecasts up to 30 days ahead. hAIdro has been forecasting the runoff twice a day for 262 locations spread over Flanders since April 2021. A continuous monitoring and evaluation framework provides valuable insights in the online model performance and the informative value of hAIdro.

    [1] M. Gauch, F. Kratzert, D. Klotz, G. Nearing, J. Lin, and S. Hochreiter. “Rainfall–Runoff Prediction at Multiple Timescales with a Single Long Short-Term Memory Network.” Hydrol. Earth Syst. Sci., 25, 2045–2062, 2021 

    [2] Moore, R. J. “The PDM rainfall-runoff model.” Hydrol. Earth Syst. Sci., 11, 483–499,  2007

    How to cite: Franken, T., Gullentops, C., Wolfs, V., Defloor, W., Cabus, P., and De Jongh, I.: An operational framework for data driven low flow forecasts in Flanders, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6191, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6191, 2022.

    EGU22-6231 | Presentations | HS3.4

    Potential of natural language processing for metadata extraction from environmental scientific publications 

    Guillaume Blanchy, Lukas Albrecht, Johannes Koestel, and Sarah Garré

    Adapting agricultural management practices to changing climate is not straightforward. Effects of agricultural management practices (tillage, cover crops, amendment, …) on soil variables (hydraulic conductivity, aggregate stability, …) often vary according to pedo-climatic conditions. Hence, it is important to take these conditions into account in quantitative evidence synthesis. Extracting structured information from scientific publications to build large databases with experimental data from various conditions is an effective way to do this. This database can then serve to explain, and possibly also to predict, the effect of management practices in different pedo-climatic contexts.

    However, manually building such a database by going through all publications is tedious. And given the increasing amount of literature, this task is likely to require more and more effort in the future. Natural language processing facilitates this task.  In this work, we built a database of near-saturated hydraulic conductivity from tension-disk infiltrometer measurements from scientific publications. We used tailored regular expressions and dictionaries to extract coordinates, soil texture, soil type, rainfall, disk diameter and tensions applied. The overal results have an F1-score ranging from 0.72 to 0.91.

    In addition, we extracted relationships between a set of driver keywords (e.g. ‘biochar’, ‘zero tillage’, …) and variables (e.g. ‘soil aggregate’, ‘hydraulic conductivity’, …) from publication abstracts based on the shortest dependency path between them. The relationships were further classified according to positive, negative or absent correlations between the driver and variable. This technique quickly provides an overview of the different driver-variable relationships and their abundance for an entire body of literature. For instance, we were able to recover the positive correlation between biochar and yield, as well as its negative correlation with bulk density.

    How to cite: Blanchy, G., Albrecht, L., Koestel, J., and Garré, S.: Potential of natural language processing for metadata extraction from environmental scientific publications, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6231, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6231, 2022.

    EGU22-6362 | Presentations | HS3.4

    Flood Forecasting With LSTM Networks: Enhancing the Input Data With Statistical Precipitation Information 

    Tanja Morgenstern, Jens Grundmann, and Niels Schütze

    Reliable forecasts of water level and discharge are necessary for efficient disaster management in case of a flood event. The methods of flood forecasting are rapidly developing, part of this being artificial neural networks (ANN). These belong to the data-driven models and therefore are sensitive to the quality, quantity and relevance of their input and training data.

    Previous studies at the Institute of Hydrology and Meteorology at the TU Dresden used both hourly discharge and precipitation time series to model the precipitation-runoff process with ANN, e.g. Deep Learning LSTM networks (Long Short-Term Memory – a subcategory of ANN). The precipitation data were derived of area averages of radar data, in which the spatial structure of the precipitation and thus important information for rainfall-runoff modelling is lost. This is a problem especially for small-scale convective rainfall events.

    As part of the KIWA project, we carry out a study with the aim of improving the reliability of flood forecasts of our LSTM networks by supplementing the input data with statistical precipitation information. For this purpose, we are adding statistical information such as area maximum and minimum of precipitation intensity, as well as its standard deviation over the area, to the area mean values of precipitation from the hourly radar data.

    As this information contains details on the precipitation intensity distribution over the area, we expect an improvement of the discharge prediction quality, as well as an improvement of the timing. In addition, we expect the LSTM network to learn from the statistical information to better assess the relevance and quality of the given precipitation values and to recognize the spatial uncertainties inherent to the area means. The resulting knowledge of the network should now enable it to forecast the discharge while communicating information on the uncertainty of the current discharge forecast.

    We present the preliminary results of this investigation based on small pilot catchments in Saxony (Germany) with differing hydrological and geographical characteristics.

    How to cite: Morgenstern, T., Grundmann, J., and Schütze, N.: Flood Forecasting With LSTM Networks: Enhancing the Input Data With Statistical Precipitation Information, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6362, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6362, 2022.

    EGU22-8471 | Presentations | HS3.4

    Machine learning-derived predictions of river flow across Switzerland 

    Etienne Fluet-Chouinard, William Aeberhard, Eniko Szekely, Massimilano Zappa, Konrad Bogner, Sonia I. Seneviratne, and Lukas Gudmundsson

    The prediction of streamflow in gauged and ungauged basins is a central challenge of hydrology and is increasingly being met by machine learning and deep learning models. With increase in data volume and advances in modeling techniques, the capacity for deep learning tools to compete and complement physics-based hydrological models over a variety of settings and scales is still being explored. Here, we present initial results of the MAchine learning for Swiss (CH) river FLOW estimation (MACH-Flow) project. We train machine learning models on daily discharge data from 260 gauging stations across Switzerland covering the 1980-2020 time window. The river gauging stations we included have catchment areas ranging between 0.1-3000 km2, and average streamflow between 0.1-100 m3/second. We also test a range of predictor features including: air temperature, precipitation, incoming radiation, relative humidity, as well as a number of static catchment variables. We evaluated multiple model architectures of ranging complexity, from models focusing on runoff predictions over individual headwater catchments, such as Neural Network, Long short-term memory (LSTM) cells. We also investigate Graph Neural Networks capable of leveraging information from neighbouring stations in making point location predictions. Predictions are generated at gauging locations as well as over 307 land units used for drought monitoring. We benchmark and compare deep learning methods against two process-based hydrological models: 1) the PREecipitation Runoff EVApotranspiration HRU Model (PREVAH) used operationally by Swiss federal agencies and 2) the comparatively streamlined Simple Water Balance Model (SWBM). We compared the deep learning and physics-based models with regards to predicting daily river discharge as well as of low-flows during drought conditions that are essential for water managers and planners in Switzerland. We find that most deep learning methods with sufficient tuning and lookback periods can compete with the streamflow predictions from process-based models, particularly at gauging stations on larger non-regulated rivers where hydro-dynamic time lags are significant. Finally, we discuss the prospects for generating discharge predictions across all river segments of Switzerland using deep learning methods, along with challenges and opportunities to achieve this goal.

    How to cite: Fluet-Chouinard, E., Aeberhard, W., Szekely, E., Zappa, M., Bogner, K., I. Seneviratne, S., and Gudmundsson, L.: Machine learning-derived predictions of river flow across Switzerland, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8471, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8471, 2022.

    EGU22-9771 | Presentations | HS3.4

    Simulating and multi-step reforecasting real-time reservoir operation using combined neural network and distributed hydrological model 

    Chanoknun Wannasin, Claudia Brauer, Remko Uijlenhoet, Paul Torfs, and Albrecht Weerts

    Reservoirs and dams are essential infrastructures for human utilization and management of water resources; yet modelling real-time reservoir operation and controlled reservoir outflow remains a challenge. Artificial intelligence techniques, especially machine learning and deep learning, have become increasingly popular in hydrological forecasting, including reservoir operation. In this study, we applied a recurrent neural network (RNN) and a long short-term memory (LSTM) to model the reservoir operation and outflow of a large-scale multi-purpose reservoir at the real-time (daily) timescale. This study aims to investigate the capabilities of RNN and LSTM models in simulating and reforecasting the real-time reservoir outflow, considering the uncertainties in model inputs, model training-testing periods, and different model algorithms. The Sirikit reservoir in Thailand was selected as a case study. The main inputs for the RNN and LSTM models were daily reservoir inflow, daily storage, and the month of the year. We applied the distributed wflow_sbm model for reservoir inflow simulation (using MSWEP precipitation data) and ensemble inflow reforecasting (using ECMWF precipitation data). Daily reservoir storage was obtained from observations and real-time recalculation based on the reservoir water balance. The models were trained and tested with 10-fold cross-validation. Results show that both RNN and LSTM models have high accuracies for real-time simulations and reasonable accuracies for multi-step reforecasts, and that LSTM exhibits better model performance in forecasting mode. The performance varied between each cross-validation, being highly related to the extreme events included in either training or test period. With further understanding of the reservoir inflow uncertainty influences on reservoir operation, we conclude that the models can be potentially applicable in real-time reservoir operation and decision-making for operational water management.

    How to cite: Wannasin, C., Brauer, C., Uijlenhoet, R., Torfs, P., and Weerts, A.: Simulating and multi-step reforecasting real-time reservoir operation using combined neural network and distributed hydrological model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9771, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9771, 2022.

    Modelling accurate rainfall-runoff (RR) simulations is a longstanding contest in hydrological research. These models often treat the RR relationship as stationary; in other words, model parameters are assumed to be fixed, time-invariant values. In reality, the RR relationship is continuously changing due to factors such as climate change, rapid urban growth, and construction of hydraulic infrastructure. Therefore, there is a need for hydrological models to be able to adapt to these changes.

    The suitability of machine learning (ML) models for flow forecasting has been well established over the past 3 decades. One advantage of such models is their ability to rapidly and continuously adapt to the non-stationary relationship between rainfall and runoff generation. However, changes in model performance and model adaptation in an operational context have not received much attention from the research community.

    We present a large-scale framework for daily flow forecasting models in Canada (>100 catchments). In our framework, local artificial neural network (ANN) ensembles models are automatically trained to forecast flow on an individual catchment basis using openly available daily hydrometeorological timeseries data. The collection of catchments taken from across Canada have highly heterogenous soil groups, land use, and climate. We propose several experiments that are designed to evaluate the robustness of ANN-based flow forecasting across time. Using the most recent year of observations for validation, we evaluate the effects of incrementally providing increasing amounts of historic observations. Similarly, we quantify changes to ANN model parameters (weights and biases) across increasing historic training data. Finally, we analyse feature importance across time using multiple feature importance algorithms. Our research aims to provide guidance on initial model training and adaptive learning, as ML-based approaches become increasingly adapted for operational use.

    How to cite: Snieder, E. and Khan, U.: Large-scale evaluation of temporal trends in ANN behaviour for daily flow forecasts in Canadian catchments., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10744, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10744, 2022.

    EGU22-11110 | Presentations | HS3.4

    Physics-informed LSTM structure for recession flow prediction    

    Prashant Istalkar, Akshay Kadu, and Basudev Biswal

    Modeling the rainfall-runoff process has been a key challenge for hydrologists. Multiple modeling frameworks have been introduced with time to understand and predict the runoff generation process, including physics-based models, conceptual models, and data-driven models. In recent years the use of deep learning models like Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM) has increased in hydrology because of its ability to learn information in the sequence of input. Studies report LSTM outperforms the well-established hydrological models (e.g. SAC-SMA), which led authors to question the need for process understanding in the machine learning era. In the current study, we claim that process understanding helps to reduce LSTM model complexity and ultimately improves recession flow prediction. Here, we used past streamflow information as input to LSTM and predicted ten days of recession flow. To reduce LSTM complexity, we used insights from a conceptual hydrological model that accounts for storage-discharge dynamics. Overall, our study re-emphasizes the need to understand hydrological processes.

    How to cite: Istalkar, P., Kadu, A., and Biswal, B.: Physics-informed LSTM structure for recession flow prediction   , EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11110, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11110, 2022.

    EGU22-986 | Presentations | HS3.6

    Quantifying solute transport numerical dispersion in integrated surface-subsurface hydrological modeling 

    Beatrice Gatto, Claudio Paniconi, Paolo Salandin, and Matteo Camporese

    Numerical dispersion is a well-known problem that affects solute transport in groundwater simulations and can lead to wrong results, in terms of plume path overestimation and overprediction of contaminant dispersion. Numerical dispersion is generally introduced through stabilization techniques aimed at preventing oscillations, with the side effect of increasing mass spreading. Even though this issue has long been investigated in subsurface hydrology, little is known about its possible impacts on integrated surface–subsurface hydrological models (ISSHMs). In this study, we analyze numerical dispersion in the CATchment HYdrology (CATHY) model. In CATHY, a robust and computationally efficient time-splitting technique is implemented for the solution of the subsurface transport equation, whereby the advective part is solved on elements with an explicit finite volume scheme and the dispersive part is solved on nodes with an implicit finite element scheme. Taken alone, the advection and dispersion solvers provide accurate results. However, when coupled, the continuous transfer of concentration from elements to nodes, and vice versa, gives rise to a particular form of numerical dispersion. We assess the nature and impact of this artificial spreading through two sets of synthetic experiments. In the first set, the subsurface transport of a nonreactive tracer in two soil column test cases is simulated and compared with known analytical solutions. Different input dispersion coefficients and mesh discretizations are tested, in order to quantify the numerical error and define a criterion for its containment. In the second set of experiments, fully coupled surface–subsurface processes are simulated using two idealized hillslopes, one concave and one convex, and we examine how the additional subsurface dispersion affects the representation of pre-event water contribution to the streamflow hydrograph. Overall, we show that the numerical dispersion in CATHY that is caused by the transfer of information between elements and nodes can be kept under control if the grid Péclet number is less than 1. It is also suggested that the test cases used in this study can be useful benchmarks for integrated surface–subsurface hydrological models, for which thus far only flow benchmarks have been proposed.

    How to cite: Gatto, B., Paniconi, C., Salandin, P., and Camporese, M.: Quantifying solute transport numerical dispersion in integrated surface-subsurface hydrological modeling, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-986, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-986, 2022.

    EGU22-1210 | Presentations | HS3.6

    An alternative strategy for combining likelihood values in Bayesian calibration to improve model predictions 

    Michelle Viswanathan, Tobias K. D. Weber, and Anneli Guthke

    Conveying uncertainty in model predictions is essential, especially when these predictions are used for decision-making. Models are not only expected to achieve the best possible fit to available calibration data but to also capture future observations within realistic uncertainty intervals. Model calibration using Bayesian inference facilitates the tuning of model parameters based on existing observations, while accounting for uncertainties. The model is tested against observed data through the likelihood function which defines the probability of the data being generated by the given model and its parameters. Inference of most plausible parameter values is influenced by the method used to combine likelihood values from different observation data sets. In the classical method of combining likelihood values, referred to here as the AND calibration strategy, it is inherently assumed that the given model is true (error-free), and that observations in different data sets are similarly informative for the inference problem. However, practically every model applied to real-world case studies suffers from model-structural errors that are typically dynamic, i.e., they vary over time. A requirement for the imperfect model to fit all data sets simultaneously will inevitably lead to an underestimation of uncertainty due to a collapse of the resulting posterior parameter distributions. Additionally, biased 'compromise solutions' to the parameter estimation problem result in large prediction errors that impair subsequent conclusions. 
        
    We present an alternative AND/OR calibration strategy which provides a formal framework to relax posterior predictive intervals and minimize posterior collapse by incorporating knowledge about similarities and differences between data sets. As a case study, we applied this approach to calibrate a plant phenology model (SPASS) to observations of the silage maize crop grown at five sites in southwestern Germany between 2010 and 2016. We compared model predictions of phenology on using the classical AND calibration strategy with those from two scenarios (OR and ANDOR) in the AND/OR strategy of combining likelihoods from the different data sets. The OR scenario represents an extreme contrast to the AND strategy as all data sets are assumed to be distinct, and the model is allowed to find individual good fits to each period adjusting to the individual type and strength of model error. The ANDOR scenario acts as an intermediate solution between the two extremes by accounting for known similarities and differences between data sets, and hence grouping them according to anticipated type and strength of model error. 
        
    We found that the OR scenario led to lower precision but higher accuracy of prediction results as compared to the classical AND calibration. The ANDOR scenario led to higher accuracy as compared to the AND strategy and higher precision as compared to the OR scenario. Our proposed approach has the potential to improve the prediction capability of dynamic models in general, by considering the effect of model error when calibrating to different data sets.

    How to cite: Viswanathan, M., Weber, T. K. D., and Guthke, A.: An alternative strategy for combining likelihood values in Bayesian calibration to improve model predictions, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1210, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1210, 2022.

    EGU22-1459 | Presentations | HS3.6

    Modelling decisions: a quantification of their influence on model results 

    Janneke Remmers, Ryan Teuling, and Lieke Melsen

    Scientific hydrological modellers make multiple decisions during the modelling process, e.g. related to the calibration period and temporal resolution. These decisions affect the model results. Modelling decisions can refer to several steps in the modelling process. In this study, modelling decisions refer to the decisions made during the whole modelling process, beyond the definition of the model structure. This study is based on an analysis of interviews with scientific hydrological modellers, thus taking actual practices into account. Six modelling decisions were identified from the interviews, which are mainly motivated by personal and team experience (calibration method, calibration period, parameters to calibrate, pre-processing of input data, spin-up period, and temporal resolution). Different options for these six decisions, as encountered in the interviews, were implemented and evaluated in a controlled modelling environment, in our case the modular modelling framework Raven, to quantify their impact on model output. The variation in the results is analysed using three hydrological signatures to determine which decisions affect the results and how they affect the results. Each model output is a hypothesis of the reality; it is an interpretation of the real system underpinned by scientific reasoning and/or expert knowledge. Currently, there is a lack of knowledge and understanding about which modelling decisions are taken and why they are taken. Consequently, the influence of modelling decisions is unknown. Quantifying this influence, which was done in this study, can raise awareness among scientists. This study pinpoints what aspects are important to consider in studying modelling decisions, and can be an incentive to clarify and improve modelling procedures.

    How to cite: Remmers, J., Teuling, R., and Melsen, L.: Modelling decisions: a quantification of their influence on model results, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1459, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1459, 2022.

    EGU22-1639 | Presentations | HS3.6

    Rigorous Exploration of Complex Environmental Models to Advance Scientific Understanding 

    Robert Reinecke, Francesca Pianosi, and Thorsten Wagener

    Environmental models are central for advancing science by increasingly serving as a digital twin of the earth and its components. They allow us to conduct experiments to test hypotheses and understand dominant processes that are infeasible to do in the real world. To foster our knowledge, we build increasingly complex models hoping that they become more complete and realistic images of the real world. However, we believe that our scientific progress is slowed down as methods for the rigorous exploration of these models, in the face of unavoidable data- and epistemic-uncertainties, do not evolve in a similar manner.

    Based on an extensive literature review, we show that even though methods for such rigorous exploration of model responses, e.g., global sensitivity analysis methods, are well established, there is an upper boundary to which level of model complexity they are applied today. Still, we claim that the potential for their utilization in a wider context is significant.

    We argue here that a key issue to consider in this context is the framing of the sensitivity analysis problem. We show, using published examples, how problem framing defines the outcome of a sensitivity analysis in the context of scientific advancement. Without appropriate framing, sensitivity analysis of complex models reduces to a diagnostic analysis of the model, with only limited transferability of the conclusions to the real-world system.

    How to cite: Reinecke, R., Pianosi, F., and Wagener, T.: Rigorous Exploration of Complex Environmental Models to Advance Scientific Understanding, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1639, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1639, 2022.

    We propose a method to analyse, classify and compare dynamical systems of arbitrary dimension by the two key features uncertainty and complexity. It starts by subdividing the system’s time-trajectory into a number of time slices. For all values in a time slice, the Shannon information entropy is calculated, measuring within-slice variability. System uncertainty is then expressed by the mean entropy of all time slices. We define system complexity as “uncertainty about uncertainty”, and express it by the entropy of the entropies of all time slices. Calculating and plotting uncertainty u and complexity c for many different numbers of time slices yields the c-u-curve. Systems can be analysed, compared and classified by the c-u-curve in terms of i) its overall shape, ii) mean and maximum uncertainty, iii) mean and maximum complexity, and iv) its characteristic time scale expressed by the width of the time slice for which maximum complexity occurs. We demonstrate the method at the example of both synthetic and real-world time series (constant, random noise, Lorenz attractor, precipitation and streamflow) and show that conclusions drawn from the c-u-curve are in accordance with expectations. The method is based on unit-free probabilities and therefore permits application to and comparison of arbitrary data. It naturally expands from single- to multivariate systems, and from deterministic to probabilistic value representations, allowing e.g. application to ensemble model predictions. 

    How to cite: Ehret, U. and Dey, P.: c-u-curve: A method to analyze, classify and compare dynamical systems by uncertainty and complexity, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1742, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1742, 2022.

    EGU22-1870 | Presentations | HS3.6

    Inference of (geostatistical) hyperparameters with the correlated pseudo-marginal method 

    Lea Friedli, Niklas Linde, David Ginsbourger, Alejandro Fernandez Visentini, and Arnaud Doucet

    We consider non-linear Bayesian inversion problems to infer the (geostatistical) hyperparameters of a random field describing (hydro)geological or geophysical properties by inversion of hydrogeological or geophysical data. This problem is of particular importance in the non-ergodic setting as no analytical upscaling relationships exist linking the data (resulting from a specific field realization) to the hyperparameters specifying the spatial distribution of the underlying random field (e.g., mean, standard deviation, and integral scales). Jointly inferring the hyperparameters and the "true" realization of the field (typically involving many thousands of unknowns) brings important computational challenges, such that in practice, simplifying model assumptions (such as homogeneity or ergodicity) are made. To prevent the errors resulting from such simplified assumptions while circumventing the burden of high-dimensional full inversions, we use a pseudo-marginal Metropolis-Hastings algorithm that treats the random field as a latent variable. In this random effect model, the intractable likelihood of observing the hyperparameters given the data is estimated by Monte Carlo averaging over realizations of the random field. To increase the efficiency of the method, low-variance approximations of the likelihood ratio are ensured by correlating the samples used in the proposed and current steps of the Markov chain and by using importance sampling. We assess the performance of this correlated pseudo-marginal method to the problem of inferring the hyperparameters of fracture aperture fields using borehole ground-penetrating radar (GPR) reflection data. We demonstrate that the correlated pseudo-marginal method bypasses the computational challenges of a very high-dimensional target space while avoiding the strong bias and too low uncertainty ranges obtained when employing simplified model assumptions. These advantages also apply when using the posterior of the hyperparameters describing the aperture field to predict its effective hydraulic transmissivity.

    How to cite: Friedli, L., Linde, N., Ginsbourger, D., Fernandez Visentini, A., and Doucet, A.: Inference of (geostatistical) hyperparameters with the correlated pseudo-marginal method, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1870, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1870, 2022.

    This study proposes a new approach for quantitively assessing the importance of precipitation features in space and time to predict streamflow discharge (and, hence, sensitivity). For this, we combine well-performing deep-learning (DL) models with interpretability tools.

    The DL models are composed of convolutional neural networks (CNNs) and long-short term memory (LSTM) networks. Their input is precipitation data distributed over the watershed and taken back in time (other inputs, meteorological and watershed properties, can also be included). Its output is streamflow discharge at a present or future time. Interpretability tools allow learning about the modeled system. We used the Integrated Gradients method that provides a level of importance (IG value) for each space-time precipitation feature for a given streamflow prediction. We applied the models and interpretability tools to several watersheds in the US and India.

    To understand the importance of precipitation features for flood generation, we compared spatial and temporal patterns of IG for high flows vs. low and medium flows. Our results so far indicate some similar patterns for the two categories of flows, but others are distinctly different. For example, common IG mods exist at short times before the discharge, but mods are substantially different when considered further back in time. Similarly, some spatial cores of high IG appear in both flow categories, but other watershed cores are featured only for high flows. These IG time and space pattern differences are presumably associated with slow and fast flow paths and threshold-runoff mechanisms.

    There are several advantages to the proposed approach: 1) recent studies have shown DL models to outperform standard process-based hydrological models, 2) given data availability and quality, DL models are much easier to train and validate, compared to process-based hydrological models, and therefore many watersheds can be included in the analysis, 3) DL models do not explicitly represent hydrological processes, and thus sensitivities derived in this approach are assured to represent patterns arise from the data. The main disadvantage of the proposed approach is its limitation to gauged watersheds only; however, large data sets are publicly available to exploit sensitivities of gauged streamflow.

    It should be stressed out that learning about hydrological sensitivities with DL models is proposed here as a complementary approach to analyzing process-based hydrological models. Even though DL is considered black-box models, together with interpretability tools, they can highlight hard or impossible sensitivities to resolve with standard models.

    How to cite: Morin, E., Rojas, R., and Wiesel, A.: Quantifying space-time patterns of precipitation importance for flood generation via interpretability of deep-learning models, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1907, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1907, 2022.

    EGU22-2220 | Presentations | HS3.6

    Inversion of Hydraulic Tomography Data from the Grimsel Test Site with a Discrete Fracture Network Model 

    Lisa Maria Ringel, Mohammadreza Jalali, and Peter Bayer

    This study aims at the stochastic characterization of fractured rocks with a low-permeability matrix based on transient data from hydraulic tomography experiments. In such rocks, fractures function as main flowpaths. Therefore, adequate insight about distribution and properties of fractures is essential for many applications such as groundwater remediation, constructing nuclear waste repositories or developing enhanced geothermal systems. At the Grimsel test site in Switzerland, multiple hydraulic tests have been conducted to investigate the hydraulic properties and structure of the fracture network between two shear zones. We present results from combined stochastic inversion of these tests to infer the fracture network of the studied crystalline rock formation.

    Data from geological mapping at Grimsel and the hydraulic tomography experiments that were undertaken as part of in-situ stimulation and circulation experiments provide the prior knowledge for the model inversion. This information is used for the setting-up of a site-specific conceptual model, to define the boundary and initial conditions of the groundwater flow model, and for the configuration of the inversion problem. The pressure signals we apply for the inversion stem from cross-borehole constant rate injection tests recorded at different depths, whereby the different intervals are isolated by packer systems.

    In the forward model, the fractures are represented explicitly as three-dimensional (3D) discrete fracture network (DFN). The geometric and hydraulic properties of the DFN are described by the Bayesian equation. The properties are inferred by sampling iteratively from the posterior density function according to the reversible jump Markov chain Monte Carlo sampling strategy. The goal of this inversion is providing DFN realizations that minimize the error between the simulated and observed pressure signals and that meet the prior information. During the course of the inversion, the number of fractures is iteratively adjusted by adding or deleting a fracture. Furthermore, the parameters of the DFN are adapted by moving a fracture and by changing the fracture length or hydraulic properties. Thereby, the algorithm switches between updates that change the number of parameters and updates that keep the number of parameters but adjust their value. The inversion results reveal the main structural and hydraulic characteristics of the DFN, the preferential flowpaths, and the uncertainty of the estimated model parameters.

    How to cite: Ringel, L. M., Jalali, M., and Bayer, P.: Inversion of Hydraulic Tomography Data from the Grimsel Test Site with a Discrete Fracture Network Model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2220, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2220, 2022.

    EGU22-2388 | Presentations | HS3.6

    Estimation of simulation parameters for steady and transient 3D flow modeling at watershed scale 

    Gillien Latour, Pierre Horgue, François Renard, Romain Guibert, and Gérald Debenest
    Unsaturated water flows at watershed scale or Darcy-scale are generally described by the Richardson-Richards equation. This equation is highly non-linear and simulation domains are limited by computational costs. The porousMultiphaseFoam toolbox is a Finite Volume tool capable of modeling multiphase flows in porous media, including the solving of the Richardson-Richards equation. As it has been developed using the OpenFOAM environment, the software is natively fully parallelized and can be used on super computers. By using experimental data from real site with geographical informations and piezometrics values, an iterative algorithm is set up to solve an inverse problem in order to evaluate an adequate permeability field. This procedure is initially implemented using simplified aquifer model with a 2D saturated modeling approach. A similar procedure using a full 3D model of the actual site is performed (handling both saturated and unsaturated area). The results are compared between the two approaches (2D and 3D) for steady simulations and new post-processing tools are also introduced to spatialize the error between the two models and define the areas for which the behaviour of the models is different. In a second part, an optimization of the Van Genuchten parameters is performed to reproduce transient experimental data. The 3D numerical results at the watershed scale are also compared to the reference simulations using a 1D unsaturated + 2D satured modeling approach.

    How to cite: Latour, G., Horgue, P., Renard, F., Guibert, R., and Debenest, G.: Estimation of simulation parameters for steady and transient 3D flow modeling at watershed scale, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2388, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2388, 2022.

    EGU22-2782 | Presentations | HS3.6

    Global Sensitivity Analysis of an integrated parallel hydrologic model: ParFlow-CLM 

    Wei Qu, Heye Bogena, Christoph Schüth, Harry Vereecken, and Stephan Schulz

    An integrated parallel hydrologic model (ParFlow-CLM) was constructed to predict water and energy transport between subsurface, land surface, and atmosphere for a synthetic study using basic physical properties of the Stettbach headwater catchment, Germany. Based on this model, a global sensitivity analysis was performed using the Latin-Hypercube (LH) sampling strategy followed by the One-factor-At-a-Time (OAT) method to identify the most influential and interactive parameters affecting the main hydrologic processes. In addition, the sensitivity analysis was also carried out for assumptions of different slopes and meteorological conditions to show the transferability of the results to regions with other topographies and climates. Our results show that the simulated energy fluxes, i.e. latent heat flux, sensible heat flux and soil heat flux, are more sensitive to the parameters of wilting point, leaf area index, and stem area index, especially for steep slope and subarctic climate conditions. The simulated water fluxes, i.e. evaporation, transpiration, infiltration, and runoff, are most sensitive to soil porosity, van-Genuchen parameter n, wilting point, and leaf area index. The subsurface water storage and groundwater storage were most sensitive to soil porosity, while the surface water storage is most sensitive to the Manning’s n parameter. For the different slope and climate conditions, the rank order of in input parameter sensitivity was consistent, but the magnitude of parameter sensitivity was very different. The strongest deviation in parameter sensitivity occurred for sensible heat flux under different slope conditions and for transpiration under different climate conditions. This study provides an efficient method of the identification of the most important input parameters of the model and how the variation in the output of a numerical model can be attributed to variations of its input factors. The results help to better understand process representation of the model and reduce the computational cost of running high numbers of simulations. 

    How to cite: Qu, W., Bogena, H., Schüth, C., Vereecken, H., and Schulz, S.: Global Sensitivity Analysis of an integrated parallel hydrologic model: ParFlow-CLM, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2782, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2782, 2022.

    EGU22-3691 | Presentations | HS3.6

    Hydrogeological inference by adaptive sequential Monte Carlo with geostatistical resampling model proposals 

    Macarena Amaya, Niklas Linde, and Eric Laloy

    For strongly non-linear inverse problems, Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) methods may fail to properly explore the posterior probability density function (PDF). Particle methods are very well suited for parallelization and offer an alternative approach whereby the posterior PDF is approximated using the states and weights of a population of evolving particles. In addition, it provides reliable estimates of the evidence (marginal likelihood) that is needed for Bayesian model selection at essentially no cost. We consider adaptive sequential Monte Carlo (ASMC), which is an extension of annealed importance sampling (AIS). In these methods, importance sampling is performed over a sequence of intermediate distributions, known as power posteriors, linking the prior to the posterior PDF. The main advantages of ASMC with respect to AIS are that it adaptively tunes the tempering between neighboring distributions and it performs resampling of particles when the variance of the particle weights becomes too large. We consider a challenging synthetic groundwater transport inverse problem with a categorical channelized 2D hydraulic conductivity field designed such that the posterior facies distribution includes two distinct modes with equal probability. The model proposals are obtained by iteratively re-simulating a fraction of the current model using conditional multi-point statistics (MPS) simulations. We focus here on the ability of ASMC to explore the posterior PDF and compare it with previously published results obtained with parallel tempering (PT), a state-of-the-art MCMC inversion approach that runs multiple interacting chains targeting different power posteriors. For a similar computational budget involving 24 particles for ASMC and 24 chains for PT, the ASMC implementation outperforms the results obtained by PT: the models fit the data better and the reference likelihood value is contained in the ASMC sampled likelihood range, while this is not the case for PT range. Moreover, we show that ASMC recovers both reference modes, while none of them is recovered by PT. However, with 24 particles there is one of the modes that has a higher weight than the other while the approximation is improved when moving to a larger number of particles. As a future development, we suggest that including fast surrogate modeling (e.g., polynomial chaos expansion) within ASMC for the MCMC steps used to evolve the particles in-between importance sampling steps would strongly reduce the computational cost while still ensuring results of similar quality as the importance sampling steps could still be performed using the regular more costly forward solver.

    How to cite: Amaya, M., Linde, N., and Laloy, E.: Hydrogeological inference by adaptive sequential Monte Carlo with geostatistical resampling model proposals, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3691, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3691, 2022.

    EGU22-3782 | Presentations | HS3.6

    Uncertainty assessment and data-worth evaluation for estimating soil hydraulic parameters and recharge fluxes from lysimeter data 

    Marleen Schübl, Christine Stumpp, and Giuseppe Brunetti

    Transient measurements from lysimeters are frequently coupled with Richards-based solvers to inversely estimate soil hydraulic parameters (SHPs) and numerically describe vadose zone water fluxes, such as recharge. To reduce model predictive uncertainty, the lysimeter experiment should be designed to maximize the information content of observations. However, in practice, this is generally done by relying on the a priori expertise of the scientist/user, without exploiting the advantages of model-based experimental design. Thus, the main aim of this study is to demonstrate how model-based experimental design can be used to maximize the information content of observations in multiple scenarios encompassing different soil textural compositions and climatic conditions. The hydrological model HYDRUS is coupled with a Nested Sampling estimator to calculate the parameters’ posterior distributions and the Kullback-Leibler divergences. Results indicate that the combination of seepage flow, soil water content, and soil matric potential measurements generally leads to highly informative designs, especially for fine textured soils, while results from coarse soils are generally affected by higher uncertainty. Furthermore, soil matric potential proves to be more informative than soil water content measurements. Additionally, the propagation of parameter uncertainties in a contrasting (dry) climate scenario strongly increased prediction uncertainties for sandy soil, not only in terms of the cumulative amount and magnitude of the peak, but also in the temporal variability of the seepage flow. 

    How to cite: Schübl, M., Stumpp, C., and Brunetti, G.: Uncertainty assessment and data-worth evaluation for estimating soil hydraulic parameters and recharge fluxes from lysimeter data, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3782, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3782, 2022.

    EGU22-6882 | Presentations | HS3.6 | Highlight

    A review of conceptual model uncertainty in groundwater research 

    Okke Batelaan, Trine Enemark, Luk Peeters, and Dirk Mallants

    For more than a century, the strong advice in geology has been to rely on multiple working hypotheses. However, in groundwater research, as supported by modelling, often a stepwise approach with respect to complexity is promoted and preferred by many. Defining a hypothesis, let alone multiple hypotheses, and testing these via groundwater models is rarely applied. The so-called ‘conceptual model’ is generally considered the starting point of our beloved modelling method. A conceptual model summarises our current knowledge about a groundwater system, describing the hydrogeology and the dominating processes. Conceptual model development should involve formulating hypotheses and leading to choices in the modelling that steer the model predictions. As many conceptual models can explain the available data, multiple hypotheses allow assessing the conceptual or structural uncertainty.

    This presentation aims to review some of the key ideas of 125 years of research on (not) handling conceptual hydrogeological uncertainty, identify current approaches, unify scattered insights, and develop a systematic methodology of hydrogeological conceptual model development and testing. We advocate for a systematic model development approach based on mutually exclusive, collectively exhaustive range of hypotheses, although this is not fully achievable. We provide examples of this approach and the consequential model testing. It is argued that following this scientific recipe of refuting alternative models; we will increase the learnings of our research, reduce the risk of conceptual surprises and improve the robustness of the groundwater assessments. We conclude that acknowledging and explicitly accounting for conceptual uncertainty goes a long way in producing more reproducible groundwater research. Hypothesis testing is essential to increase system understanding by analyzing and refuting alternative conceptual models. It also provides more confidence in groundwater model predictions leading to improved groundwater management, which is more important than ever.

    How to cite: Batelaan, O., Enemark, T., Peeters, L., and Mallants, D.: A review of conceptual model uncertainty in groundwater research, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6882, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6882, 2022.

    EGU22-7774 | Presentations | HS3.6

    Efficient inversion with complex geostatistical priors using normalizing flows and variational inference 

    Shiran Levy, Eric Laloy, and Niklas Linde

    We propose an approach for solving geophysical inverse problems which significantly reduces computational costs as compared to Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) methods while providing enhanced uncertainty quantification as compared to efficient gradient-based deterministic methods. The proposed approach relies on variational inference (VI), which seeks to approximate the unnormalized posterior distribution parametrically for a given family of distributions by solving an optimization problem. Although prone to bias if the family of distributions is too limited, VI provides a computationally-efficient approach that scales well to high-dimensional problems. To enhance the expressiveness of the parameterized posterior in the context of geophysical inverse problems, we use a combination of VI and inverse autoregressive flows (IAF), a type of normalizing flows that has been shown to be efficient for machine learning tasks. The IAF consists of invertible neural transport maps transforming an initial density of random variables into a target density, in which the mapping of each instance is conditioned on previous ones. In the combined VI-IAF routine, the approximate distribution is parameterized by the IAF, therefore, the potential expressiveness of the unnormalized posterior is determined by the architecture of the network. The parameters of the IAF are learned by minimizing the Kullback-Leibler divergence between the approximated posterior, which is obtained from samples drawn from a standard normal distribution that are pushed forward through the IAF, and the target posterior distribution. We test this approach on problems in which complex geostatistical priors are described by latent variables within a deep generative model (DGM) of the adversarial type. Previous results have concluded that inversion based on gradient-based optimization techniques perform poorly in this setting because of the high nonlinearity of the generator. Preliminary results involving linear physics suggest that the VI-IAF routine can recover the true model and provides high-quality uncertainty quantification at a low computational cost. As a next step, we will consider cases where the forward model is nonlinear and include comparison against standard MCMC sampling. As most of the inverse problem nonlinearity arises from the DGM generator, we do not expect significant differences in the quality of the approximations with respect to the linear physics case.

    How to cite: Levy, S., Laloy, E., and Linde, N.: Efficient inversion with complex geostatistical priors using normalizing flows and variational inference, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7774, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7774, 2022.

    EGU22-8583 | Presentations | HS3.6

    Quantifying transport ability of hindcast and forecast ocean models 

    Makrina Agaoglou, Guillermo García-Sánchez, Amaia Marcano Larrinaga, Gabriel Mouttapa, and Ana M. Mancho

    In the last years, there has been much interest in uncertainty quantification involving trajectories in ocean data sets. As more and more oceanic data become available the assessing quality of ocean models to address transport problems like oil spills, chemical or plastic transportation becomes of vital importance. In our work we are using two types of ocean models: the hindcast and the forecast in a specific domain in the North Atlantic, where drifter trajectory data were available. The hindcast approach requires running ocean (or atmospheric) models for a past period the duration of which is usually for several decades. On the other hand forecast approach is to predict future stages. Both ocean products are provided by CMEMS. Hindcast data includes extra observational data that was time-delayed and therefore to the original forecast run. This means that in principle, hindcast data are more accurate than archived forecast data. In this work, we focus on the comparison of the transport capacity between hindcast and forecast products in the Gulf stream and the Atlantic Ocean, based on the dynamical structures of the dynamical systems describing the underlying transport problem, in the spirit of [1]. In this work, we go a step forwards, by quantifying the transport performance of each model against observed drifters using tools developed in [2].

    Acknowledgments

    MA acknowledges support from the grant CEX2019-000904-S and IJC2019-040168-I funded by: MCIN/AEI/ 10.13039/501100011033, AMM and GGS acknowledge support from CSIC PIE grant Ref. 202250E001.

    References

    [1] C. Mendoza, A. M. Mancho, and S. Wiggins, Lagrangian descriptors and the assessment of the predictive capacity of oceanic data sets, Nonlin. Processes Geophys., 21, 677–689, 2014, doi:10.5194/npg-21-677-2014

    [2] G.García-Sánchez, A.M.Mancho, and S.Wiggins, A bridge between invariant dynamical structures and uncertainty quantification, Commun Nonlinear Sci Numer Simulat 104, 106016, 2022, doi:10.1016/j.cnsns.2021.106016 

    How to cite: Agaoglou, M., García-Sánchez, G., Marcano Larrinaga, A., Mouttapa, G., and Mancho, A. M.: Quantifying transport ability of hindcast and forecast ocean models, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8583, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8583, 2022.

    Conceptual models are indispensable tools for hydrology. In order to use them for making probabilistic predictions, they need to be equipped with an adequate error model, which, for ease of inference, is traditionally formulated as an additive error on the output (discharge). However, the main sources of uncertainty in hydrological modelling are typically not to be found on the output, but on the input (rain) and in the model structure. Therefore, more reliable error models and probabilistic predictions can be obtained by incorporating those uncertainties directly where they arise, that is, into the model. This, however, leads us to stochastic models, which render traditional inference algorithms such as the Metropolis algorithm infeasible due to their expensive likelihood functions. However, thanks to recent advancements in algorithms and computing power, full-fledged Bayesian inference with stochastic models is no longer off-limit for hydrological applications. We demonstrate this with a case study from urban hydrology, for which we employ a highly efficient Hamiltonian Monte Carlo inference algorithm with a time-scale separation.

    How to cite: Ulzega, S. and Albert, C.: Bayesian parameter inference in hydrological modelling using a Hamiltonian Monte Carlo approach with a stochastic rain model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8729, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8729, 2022.

    In this work we introduce hydroMOPSO, a novel multi-objective R package that combines two search mechanisms to maintain diversity of the population and accelerate its convergence towards the Pareto-optimal set: Particle Swarm Optimisation (PSO) and genetic operations. hydroMOPSO is model-independent, which allows to interface any model code with the calibration engine, including models available in R (e.g., TUWmodel, airGR, topmodel), but also any other complex models that can be run from the system console (e.g. SWAT+, Raven, WEAP). In addition, hydroMOPSO is platform-independent, which allows it to run on GNU/Linux, Mac OSX and Windows systems, among others.

    Considering the long execution time of some real-world models, we used three benchmark functions to search for a configuration that allows to reach the Pareto-optimal front with a low number of model evaluations, analysing different combinations of: i) the swarm size in PSO, ii) the maximum number of particles in the external archive, and iii) the maximum number of genetic operations in the external archive. In addition, the previous configuration was then evaluated against other state-of-the-art multi-objective optimisation algorithms (MMOPSO, NSGA-II, NSGA-III). Finally, hydroMOPSO was used to calibrate a GR4J-CemaNeige hydrological model implemented in the Raven modelling framework (http://raven.uwaterloo.ca), using two goodness-of-fit functions: i) the modified Kling-Gupta efficiency (KGE') and ii) the Nash-Sutcliffe efficiency with inverted flows (iNSE).

    Our results showed that the configuration selected for hydroMOPSO makes it very competitive or even superior against MMOPSO, NSGA-II and NSGA- III in terms of the number of function evaluations required to achieve stabilisation in the Pareto front, and also showed some advantages of using a compromise solution instead of a single-objective one for the estimation of hydrological model parameters.

    How to cite: Marinao-Rivas, R. and Zambrano-Bigiarini, M.: hydroMOPSO: A versatile Particle Swarm Optimization R package for multi-objective calibration of environmental and hydrological models, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9902, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9902, 2022.

    EGU22-10431 | Presentations | HS3.6

    Consistency and variability of spatial and temporal patterns of parameter dominance on four simulated hydrological variables in mHM in a large basin study 

    Björn Guse, Stefan Lüdtke, Oldrich Rakovec, Stephan Thober, Thorsten Wagener, and Luis Samaniego

    Model parameters are implemented in hydrological models to represent hydrological processes as accurate as possible under different catchment conditions. In the case of the mesoscale Hydrological Model (mHM), its parameters are estimated via transfer functions and scaling rules using the Multiscale Parameter Regionalization (MPR) approach [1]. Hereby, one consistent parameter set is selected for the entire model domain. To understand the impact of model parameters on simulated variables under different hydrological conditions, the spatio-temporal variability of parameter dominance and its relationship to the corresponding processes needs to be investigated.

    In this study, mHM is applied to more than hundred German basins including the headwater areas in neighboring countries. To analyze the relevance of model parameters, a temporally resolved parameter sensitivity analysis using the FAST algorithm [2] is applied to derive dominant model parameters for each day. The temporal scale was further aggregated to monthly and seasonal averaged sensitivities. In analyzing a large number of basins, not only the temporal but also the spatial variability in the parameter relevance could be assessed. Four hydrological variables were used as target variable for the sensitivity analysis, i.e. runoff, actual evapotranspiration, soil moisture and groundwater recharge.

    The analysis of the temporal parameter sensitivity shows that the dominant parameters vary in space and time and in using different target variables. Soil material parameters are most dominant on runoff and recharge. A switch in parameter dominance between different seasons was detected for an infiltration and an evapotranspiration parameter that are dominant on soil moisture in winter and summer, respectively. The opposite seasonal dominance pattern of these two parameters was identified on actual evapotranspiration. Further, each parameter shows high sensitivities to either high or low values of one or more hydrological variable(s). The parameter estimation approach leads to spatial consistent patterns of parameter dominances. Spatial differences and similarities in parameter sensitivities could be explained by catchment variability.

    The results improve the understanding of how model parameter controls the simulated processes in mHM. This information could be useful for more efficient parameter identification, model calibration and improved MPR transfer functions.

     

    References

    [1] Samaniego et al. (2010, WRR), https://doi.org/10.1029/2008WR007327

    [2] Reusser et al. (2011, WRR), https://doi.org/10.1029/2010WR009947

    How to cite: Guse, B., Lüdtke, S., Rakovec, O., Thober, S., Wagener, T., and Samaniego, L.: Consistency and variability of spatial and temporal patterns of parameter dominance on four simulated hydrological variables in mHM in a large basin study, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10431, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10431, 2022.

    EGU22-10654 | Presentations | HS3.6 | Highlight

    Uncertainty assessment with Bluecat: Recognising randomness as a fundamental component of physics 

    Alberto Montanari and Demetris Koutsoyiannis

    We present a new method for simulating and predicting hydrologic variables and in particular river flows, which is rooted in the probability theory and conceived in order to provide a reliable quantification of its uncertainty for operational applications. In fact, recent practical experience during extreme events has shown that simulation and prediction uncertainty is essential information for decision makers and the public. A reliable and transparent uncertainty assessment has also been shown to be essential to gain public and institutional trust in real science. Our approach, that we term with the acronym "Bluecat", assumes that randomness is a fundamental component of physics and results from a theoretical and numerical development. Bluecat is conceived to make a transparent and intuitive use of uncertain observations which in turn mirror the observed reality. Therefore, Bluecat makes use of a rigorous theory while at the same time proofing the concept that environmental resources should be managed by making the best use of empirical evidence and experience and recognising randomness as an intrinsic property of hydrological systems. We provide an open and user friendly software to apply the method to the simulation and prediction of river flows and test Bluecat's reliability for operational applications.

    How to cite: Montanari, A. and Koutsoyiannis, D.: Uncertainty assessment with Bluecat: Recognising randomness as a fundamental component of physics, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10654, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10654, 2022.

    EGU22-11794 | Presentations | HS3.6

    Effect of regional heterogeneities on inversion stability and estimated hydraulic properties field 

    Hervé Jourde, Mohammed Aliouache, Pierre Fischer, Xiaoguang Wang, and Gerard Massonnat

    Hydraulic tomography showed great potential on estimating the spatial distribution of heterogeneous aquifer properties in the last decade.  Though this method is highly performant on synthetic studies, the transition from an application to synthetic models to real field applications is often associated to numerical instabilities. Inversion techniques can also suffer from ill-posedness and non-uniqueness of the estimates since several solutions might correctly mimic the observed hydraulic data. In this work, we investigate the origin of the instabilities observed when trying to perform HT using real field drawdown data. We firstly identify the cause of these instabilities. We then use different approaches, where one is proposed, in order to regain inverse model stability, which also allows to estimate different hydraulic property fields at local and regional scales. Results show that ill-posed models can lead into inversion instability while different approaches that limit these instabilities may lead into different estimates. The study also shows that the late time hydraulic responses are strongly linked to the boundary conditions and thus to the regional heterogeneity. Accordingly, the use on these late-time data in inversion might require a larger dimension of the inverted domain, so that it is recommended to position the boundary conditions of the forward model far away from the wells. Also, the use of the proposed technique might provide a performant tool to obtain a satisfying fitting of observation, but also to assess both the site scale heterogeneity and the surrounding variabilities.

    How to cite: Jourde, H., Aliouache, M., Fischer, P., Wang, X., and Massonnat, G.: Effect of regional heterogeneities on inversion stability and estimated hydraulic properties field, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11794, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11794, 2022.

    EGU22-11844 | Presentations | HS3.6

    Benchmarking Automatically Identified Model Structures with a Large Model Ensemble 

    Diana Spieler, Kan Lei, and Niels Schütze

    Recent studies have introduced methods to simultaneously calibrate model structure choices and parameter values to identify an appropriate (conceptual) model structure for a given catchment. This can be done through mixed-integer optimization to identify the graph structure that links dominant flow processes (Spieler et al., 2020) or, likewise, by continuous optimization of weights when blending multiple flux equations to describe flow processes within a model (Chlumsky et al., 2021). Here, we use the combination of the mixed-integer optimization algorithm DDS and the modular modelling framework RAVEN and refer to it as Automatic Model Structure Identification (AMSI) framework.

    This study validates the AMSI framework by comparing the performance of the identified AMSI model structures to two different benchmark ensembles. The first ensemble consists of the best model structures from the brute force calibration of all possible structures included in the AMSI model space (7488+). The second ensemble consists of 35+ MARRMoT structures representing a structurally more divers set of models than currently implemented in the AMSI framework. These structures stem from the MARRMoT Toolbox introduced by Knoben et al. (2019) providing established conceptual model structures based on hydrologic literature.

    We analyze if the model structure(s) AMSI identifies are identical to the best performing structures of the brute force calibration and comparable in their performance to the MARRMoT ensemble. We can conclude that model structures identified with the AMSI framework can compete with the structurally more divers MARRMoT ensemble. In fact, we were surprised to see how well we do with a simple two storage structure over the 12 tested MOPEX catchments (Duan et al.,2006). We aim to discuss several emerging questions, such as the selection of a robust model structure, Equifinality in model structures, and the role of structural complexity.

     

    Spieler et al. (2020). https://doi.org/10.1029/2019WR027009

    Chlumsky et al. (2021). https://doi.org/10.1029/2020WR029229

    Knoben et al. (2019). https://doi.org/10.5194/gmd-12-2463-2019

    Duan et al. (2006). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhydrol.2005.07.031

    How to cite: Spieler, D., Lei, K., and Schütze, N.: Benchmarking Automatically Identified Model Structures with a Large Model Ensemble, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11844, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11844, 2022.

    Pearson’s correlation is usually used as a criterion for the presence or absence of a relationship between time series, but it is not always indicative for nonlinear systems like climate. Therefore, we implement one of the methods of nonlinear dynamics to detect connections in the Sun-climate system. Here we estimate the causal relationship between Total Solar Irradiance (TSI) and Ocean climate indices over the past few decades using the method of conditional dispersions (Cenys et al., 1991). We use a conceptual ocean-atmosphere model (Jin, 1997) with TSI added as a forcing to calibrate the method. We show that the method provides expected results for connection between TSI and the model temperature. Premixing of Gaussian noise to model data leads to decrease of detectable causality with increase of noise amplitude, and the similar effect occurs in empirical data. Moreover, in the case of the empirical data, we show that the method can be used to independently estimate uncertainties of Ocean climate indices.

    How to cite: Skakun, A. and Volobuev, D.: Ocean climate indices and Total Solar Irradiance: causality over the past few decades and revision of indices uncertainties, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12691, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12691, 2022.

    EGU22-2978 | Presentations | HS3.8

    ArchPy, automated hierarchical modelling of Quaternary aquifers: an example from the Upper Aare Valley, Switzerland 

    Ludovic Schorpp, Julien Straubhaar, and Philippe Renard

    When modelling groundwater systems in Quaternary formation, one of the first steps is to construct a geological and petrophysical model. This  is often  repetitive because it relies on multiple manual steps which include geophysical interpretation, construction of a structural model, identification of geostatistical model parameters, facies and property simulations. Those steps are often carried out in different softwares, which makes the automation intractable or very difficult. A non automated approach requires a lot of time and is critical to update the model for integrating new available data or when some geological interpretations are modified, and to conduct a cross-validation procedure to assess the overall quality of the models. Moreover, it renders the quantification of the joint structural and parametric uncertainty tedious. 

     

    To address these issues, we propose a new approach and a Python module to automatically generate realistics geological and parameter models. One of its main features is that the modelling operates in a hierarchical manner. The input data consists of a set of borehole data, surface geology, and a stratigraphic pile. The stratigraphic pile describes formally and in a compact manner how the model should be constructed. It contains the list of the different stratigraphic units and their order in the pile, their conformability (eroded or onlap), the surface interpolation method (e.g. kriging, SGS, MPS, etc.) or also the filling method (e.g. MPS, SIS, etc.). Then, the procedure is automatic. In a first step the stratigraphic unit boundaries are simulated. Secondly, they are filled with lithologies and finally the petrophysical property models are simulated inside the lithologies. All these steps are straightforward and automated once the stratigraphical pile and its related parameters have been defined. Hence, this approach is extremely flexible. It is illustrated using data from an alpine quaternary aquifer in the Upper Aare plain (south-east of Bern, Switzerland).

    How to cite: Schorpp, L., Straubhaar, J., and Renard, P.: ArchPy, automated hierarchical modelling of Quaternary aquifers: an example from the Upper Aare Valley, Switzerland, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2978, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2978, 2022.

    EGU22-3529 | Presentations | HS3.8

    Hyperresolution Global Operational Hydrological Modelling and Forecasting: enhancing reproducability, skill and workflows setup 

    Stephan Thober, Luis Samaniego, Sebastian Müller, Pallav Shrestha, Matthias Kelbling, Oldrich Rakovec, Friedrich Boeing, Andreas Marx, Rohini Kumar, and Sabine Attinger

    Operational hydrological modelling and forecasts are based on complex simulation workflows that include, a.o. input data acquisition, pre-processing, hydrologic simulations, post-processing, publication and dissemination of the results. Stakeholders expect regular updates of the information at specified times and in high quality. Therefore, it must be ensured that in the event of an interruption in the workflow, the error can be quickly identified and rectified. Simultaneously, practitioners have high expectations of the model results, that should profit from continuous development of the hydrologic model and other components.

    The open-source mesoscale Hydrologic Model mHM (mhm-ufz.org) is a spatially distributed hydrologic model that conceptualizes dominant hydrological processes on the land surface. The unique feature of mHM is the Multiscale Parameter Regionalization (MPR) [1] that relates geophysical properties of the land (e.g., soil and land cover properties) to model parameters via transfer functions at a high spatial resolution (typically less than 250 m cell size). Subsequently, model parameters are aggregated to the spatial resolution at which the model runs are conducted (over 1 km). MPR allows seamless model application at different spatial resolutions and model parameters to be transferred in space [2]. mHM has been applied at different scales ranging from catchments to continents ([3], [4], [5]). mHM is written in Fortran programming language and is available under the GNU Lesser General Public License v3.

    mHM has been in continuous development for more than a decade now. In the past year, the following technical and methodological features have been added to the model:

    • Installation via conda: mHM installation can be cumbersome because a Fortran compiler and netCDF4 library is required. We have now created a conda package (ananconda.org) for mHM that allows installing release versions of mHM.
    • Reading of hourly meteorological input files: Traditionally, mHM was designed to read daily meteorological files. However, its internal time step is hourly. As higher resolved observational datasets become available, mHM can now read hourly data. This feature is critical for flood forecasting.

    Recently, mHM was applied globally at 0.1 deg grid resolution within the EU Copernicus-funded ULYSSES project. It took 36 hours to simulate 1.4 million  grid cells for 30 years of daily values at 18 compute cores (using OpenMP parallelization). Although the run time provides an acceptable CO2 footprint of  the simulations, it was challenging to organize a 51 member global hydrological forecast ensemble of six terrestrial environmental variables (Q, ET, SM, SWE, PET, GWR). We used the ecFlow workflow manager (https://confluence.ecmwf.int/display/ECFLOW) to submit the simulations to an HPC cluster. ecFlow allows to monitor the status of jobs and build complex workflows that include various tasks. Using a workflow manager like ecFlow allows creating reproducible simulation results more easily. We developed a general-purpose python package (ecPy) to interact with ecFlow functionalities for a wide range of software applications. We will present these new features and design of ecPy in this presentation.

    References:

    [1] https://doi.org/10.1029/2008WR007327

    [2] https://doi.org/10.5194/gmd-2021-103

    [3] https://doi.org/10.1002/wrcr.20431

    [4] https://doi.org/10.1175/bams-d-17-0274.1

    [5] https://doi.org/10.1061/(asce)he.1943-5584.0002097

    How to cite: Thober, S., Samaniego, L., Müller, S., Shrestha, P., Kelbling, M., Rakovec, O., Boeing, F., Marx, A., Kumar, R., and Attinger, S.: Hyperresolution Global Operational Hydrological Modelling and Forecasting: enhancing reproducability, skill and workflows setup, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3529, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3529, 2022.

    EGU22-4195 | Presentations | HS3.8

    Recharge model performance in the context of setting groundwater allocation limits 

    Wolfgang Schmid, Catherine Moore, Joel Hall, Warrick Dawes, Richard Silberstein, Susana Guzman, Adam Siade, and Rob Nelson

    Setting groundwater allocation limits requires an understanding of recharge fluxes to the aquifer system. Very often rainfall percolation through the subsurface represents the critical recharge flux. In this groundwater limit setting context, recharge estimates are often established as a component of the groundwater flow model history matching process. Typically, there are many recharge models available, and the basis for selecting any particular model is often confusing.

    Some of these recharge models are numerical solutions of variably saturated pressure head and flow and represent the full complexity of the soil-vegetation-atmosphere transfer of water. Such models require many parameters that may not be measured or verified, and/or are computationally expensive. This can make the history matching process and predictive uncertainty analyses difficult.

    Simpler model representations of the recharge processes are also available, either through upscaling (e.g., by lumping together different soil profiles, with different vegetation) and/or by simplification of the recharge estimation method. Such simplifications may involve empirical equations to derive gross recharge, single bucket-type root zone water balance calculations, or solving net recharge with the help of analytical solutions of flow or pressure heads and linear approximations of gross recharge or evapotranspiration from groundwater as function of the groundwater head. These simpler models often have a greater utility (i.e., they are quicker to run and are more numerically stable) but may be accompanied by additional ‘simplification’ induced uncertainty.

    Regardless of the method used, the uncertainty and bias of these recharge predictions can be high.  The uncertainty of groundwater model predictions underpinning the setting of allocation limits can also be high. However, the performance of a recharge model in terms of how it impacts the reliability of the predicted impacts relevant to the groundwater allocation limit, is currently not considered. This study addresses this issue, exploring the costs and benefits of recharge models of varying complexity, in the context of setting groundwater abstraction limits. This is demonstrated using a synthetic, but realistic case study in Western Australia.

    We adopt a paired complex-simple model analysis workflow, and implement it using the Flopy-PyEMU Python-based scripting framework. This workflow is then used to explore the performance of more complex and simpler models within the groundwater allocation management context by measuring each model’s bias and uncertainty. We compare a cell-by-cell Richards’ equation-based recharge model, with a series of simpler recharge contender models. This scripted workflow supports the efficient deployment of the paired complex-simple model stochastic analysis and interpretation of its outputs.

    How to cite: Schmid, W., Moore, C., Hall, J., Dawes, W., Silberstein, R., Guzman, S., Siade, A., and Nelson, R.: Recharge model performance in the context of setting groundwater allocation limits, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4195, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4195, 2022.

    EGU22-4496 | Presentations | HS3.8

    HydroMT: A Python package to build and analyze hydro models like a data wizard 

    Hélène Boisgontier, Mark Hegnauer, and Dirk Eilander

    Setting up spatially-distributed geoscientific models typically requires many (manual) steps to process input data and might therefore be time consuming and hard to reproduce. Furthermore, it can be hard to improve models based on new or updated (large) datasets, such as (global) digital elevation models and land use maps, potentially slowing down the uptake of such datasets for geoscientific modelling.

    HydroMT (Hydro Model Tools; https://deltares.github.io/hydromt/latest/) is an open-source Python package that aims to facilitate the process of building models and analyzing model results based on the state-of-the-art scientific python ecosystem, including xarray, geopandas, rioxarray, pyflwdir, numpy, scipy and dask. The package provides a common interface to data and models as well as workflows to transform data to models and analyze model results based on (hydrological) GIS and statistical methods. The common data interface is implemented through a data catalog, which is setup with a simple text yaml file, and supports many different (GIS) data formats and some simple pre-processing steps such as unit conversion. The common model interface is implemented per model software package and provides a standardized representation of the model configuration, maps, geometries, forcing, states and results. The user can describe a full model setup including its forcing in a single ini text file based on a sequence of workflows, making the process reproducible, fast and modular. Besides the Python interface, HydroMT has a command line interface (CLI) to build, update or analyze models. 

    The package has been designed with an iterative, data-centered modelling process in mind. First-order models can be setup for any location in the world by leveraging open global datasets. These models can later be improved by updating the input datasets with detailed local datasets. This iterative process enables the user to quickly get an initial model and analyze its result to then make informed decisions about the most relevant model improvements and/or required data collection and to kick-start discussions with stakeholders. Furthermore, model parameter maps or forcing data can easily be modified for model sensitivity analysis or model calibration to support robust modelling practices.

    Currently, HydroMT has been implemented for several models through a plugin infrastructure. Supported models include the distributed rainfall-runoff model wflow, the sediment model wflow_sediment, the hydrodynamic flood model SFINCS, the water quality models D-Water Quality and D-Emissions and the flood impact model Delft-FIAT.

    In this contribution we will present different modelling applications, including a loosely coupled flood risk model chain, with a focus on how HydroMT was used to build and analyze these models.

    How to cite: Boisgontier, H., Hegnauer, M., and Eilander, D.: HydroMT: A Python package to build and analyze hydro models like a data wizard, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4496, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4496, 2022.

    EGU22-5095 | Presentations | HS3.8

    Flash flood spatial analysis using hydraulic modelling and Geographic Information Systems 

    Miguel Leal, Eusébio Reis, and Pedro Pinto Santos

    The relationships between flow components and stream channel features during flash floods are theoretically well known and proven under controlled environments but are rarely explored and quantified for case studies in different geographic contexts. This research is focused on the spatial relationships between water depths and flow velocities for several return periods (RT), and how these are influenced by stream channel features. Spatial analyses were performed in Geographic Information Systems (GIS) using the hydraulic modelling results (HEC-RAS/HEC-GeoRAS) in a section of a small watershed in Portugal, which is frequently affected by flash floods. This section comprises about 1000 meters of the main watercourse (Barcarena stream) and the last 350 meters of one of its main tributaries (Massamá stream).

    The relationships between water depths and flow velocities are not particularly evident in the floodable areas, although correlation coefficients increase with increasing return periods (0.39 for 5-year RT; 0.50 for 100-year RT). Water depths tend to grow with increasing flow velocities and vice versa. Nevertheless, this trend changes when high values of water depth or velocity are reached, preventing higher correlations. This inversion is explained by modifications in channel geometry, morphology or slope, the presence of confluences and obstacles, and flood width/overbank flooding. Unlike what happens with the entire floodable area, strong negative correlations between water depths and flow velocities were found along the stream centrelines. Correlation coefficients of -0.78 and -0.83 (2-year RT), and -0.66 and -0.87 (100-year RT) were determined for the Barcarena and Massamá streams, respectively. The more direct relationship in the tributary can be explained by the narrower channel when compared to the main watercourse and by the limited overbank flooding. Bed slope, channel and flood width, and roughness are highly relevant on the longitudinal variations of water depths and velocities and on the location of their maximum values. The relationships between water depths and velocities can also change in result of increasing peak discharges and return periods.

    The 1D hydraulic model provided good results in the definition of floodable areas, water depths and longitudinal flow velocities. Lateral velocities are correctly represented in straight sections or in mildly curved bends, which are present in most of the study area, but there are errors in the sharp bends and at the confluence of the Barcarena and Massamá streams. The lack of hydrometric data compromises the calibration and validation of the velocity results. The non-existence of LiDAR elevation data in the floodplains and the lack of elevation data along the stream channels compromise the quality of the DSM. However, it was possible to overcome the lack of elevation data along the stream channels by including the position of the thalwegs in the DSM through the Topo to Raster tool of ArcMap. This guarantees the transversal and longitudinal variations of elevation, improving the hydrologic modelling results in areas with scarce or no elevation data along the channels. The obtained results demonstrate the usefulness of GIS to represent hydraulic modelling results and perform spatial analysis for flood events and other natural hazards.

    How to cite: Leal, M., Reis, E., and Pinto Santos, P.: Flash flood spatial analysis using hydraulic modelling and Geographic Information Systems, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5095, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5095, 2022.

    EGU22-5826 | Presentations | HS3.8

    Optimization of pumping rates in an island freshwater lens considering parameter, observation, and climate uncertainty 

    Cécile Coulon, Jean-Michel Lemieux, Alexandre Pryet, and Laura Gatel

    Numerical models and optimization algorithms can be valuable tools for decision-making in coastal and island aquifers, where pumping wells are threatened by salinization. Yet, the implementation of pumping optimization under uncertainty remains limited in practice, because of long simulation times and challenges associated with uncertainty propagation through series of models. A method was developed to optimize pumping rates in an island freshwater lens considering parameter, observation, and climate uncertainty. It was implemented in an island aquifer in the Magdalen Islands (Québec, Canada). A seawater intrusion model with rapid simulation times was developed using MODFLOW-SWI2. The iterative ensemble smoother algorithm implemented by PESTPP-IES allowed for history matching and nonlinear uncertainty quantification. The model predictive uncertainties were coupled with climate uncertainties, including recharge uncertainty (derived from various global circulation models and emission scenarios) and sea-level rise uncertainty. Using PESTPP-OPT, the pumping rates in the freshwater lens were then maximized while avoiding the risk of well salinization and considering parameter, observation, and climate uncertainty. Results of the pumping optimization were compared with estimates of water demand uncertainty. This study used widely available, model-independent software and could be used to support groundwater management decision-making in other insular or coastal areas.

    How to cite: Coulon, C., Lemieux, J.-M., Pryet, A., and Gatel, L.: Optimization of pumping rates in an island freshwater lens considering parameter, observation, and climate uncertainty, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5826, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5826, 2022.

    EGU22-5966 | Presentations | HS3.8

    Particle tracking as a vulnerability assessment tool for drinking water production 

    Alexandre Pryet, Pierre Matran, Yohann Cousquer, and Delphine Roubinet

    The assimilation and prediction of concentration data is often impeded by the computation time of groundwater transport models based on the resolution of the advective-dispersive equation. This is unfortunate because such data is often rich in information and the prediction of concentration values is of great interest for decision making.  Particle tracking may be used as an efficient alternative under a series of simplifying assumptions, which are often reasonable at groundwater sinks. A rapid transport model allows the use of assimilation and optimization methods requiring many model calls.  We developed a Python package to facilitate the use of the USGS MODFLOW6 and MODPATH7 models to simulate the transfer of tracer or contaminant concentrations to a groundwater sink (typically a pumping well or a drain). The approach requires the identification of one or a series of sources of tracer/contaminant such as a contaminated stream or area in the model domain. The package handles particle seeding around the sink and estimation of the concentration of water withdrawn from the sinks. Both “strong” and “weak” sources can be considered. Concentrations are computed with a mixing law from the particle endpoints and velocities. We investigated the best practice to obtain robust derivatives with this approach, which is essential for all methods based on the linearized version of the model. We provide a step-by-step workflow from model construction to parameter estimation, linear uncertainty analysis, and chance-constraints optimization with the PEST suite. The interest and practical details of the approach are illustrated on a well field vulnerable to a stream, and a parametric analysis is provided in order to evaluate the impact of key numerical parameters on the presented results.

    How to cite: Pryet, A., Matran, P., Cousquer, Y., and Roubinet, D.: Particle tracking as a vulnerability assessment tool for drinking water production, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5966, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5966, 2022.

    In recent years, meteorological droughts over Northwestern Europe caused severe declines in groundwater levels with significant damage to groundwater-dependent ecosystems and agriculture. One possible solution to reduce the declines in groundwater levels is to temporarily lower the extraction rates of nearby well fields used for drinking water production. The effectiveness of such measures depends on the magnitude and time of the response of the groundwater system to changes in groundwater extraction, which is salient information for decision makers. The response of the groundwater system is commonly quantified using numerical groundwater models that are time-consuming to develop and can be difficult to calibrate. In this research, a quick data-driven approach is proposed, based on time series analysis, that serves as a complement to more traditional groundwater modeling approaches. 

    A scripted workflow was developed using Pastas, an open-source Python module for Transfer Function Noise modeling. The approach was applied to 243 monitoring wells in an area of the Netherlands, a country where summer droughts can cause serious problems, even though the country is better known for problems with too much water. For each monitoring well, the best model structure and relevant hydrological forcings (rainfall, evaporation, river stages, and extraction rates of well fields) were selected iteratively. Model selection was performed through split-sample testing and diagnostic checking. The accepted model for each monitoring well represents an independent estimate of the contribution of different hydrological forcings and processes to the groundwater response and is based exclusively on observed data. The modeled responses to the pumping rates of the well fields were used to determine the feasibility of reducing extraction rates to control heads during droughts.

    How to cite: Brakenhoff, D., Vonk, M., Collenteur, R., and Bakker, M.: Application of time series analysis to explore the feasibility of reducing extraction rates to mitigate groundwater declines during summer droughts: a case study in the Netherlands, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8764, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8764, 2022.

    EGU22-8976 | Presentations | HS3.8

    Groundwater balance estimators using Machine Learning 

    Sreekanth Janardhanan, Dan Pagendam, Dan MacKinlay, Jorge Pena-Arancibia, and Mohammed Mainuddin

    Groundwater use for irrigation, stock and domestic purposes from shallow unconfined aquifers is rarely metered in most parts of the world despite significant increase in the rate of use in the recent decades. Most aquifers systems are poorly characterized and monitored rendering assessment of groundwater balance and informed management decision making difficult.

    Advances in automated data collection through remote sensing and other technologies in the recent years, makes available pertinent data sets that can indirectly inform groundwater balance from which groundwater recharge and discharge can be estimated. Assimilating such data sets using traditional means would require simulating the physics across multiple domains including climate, surface water, unsaturated and saturated zones and may be untenable in most decision-making contexts.

    Recent advances in Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning techniques (AI/ML) have created the opportunity to estimate groundwater balance components probabilistically by considering the correlation and causal relationships with other climatic, hydrological and geospatial variables for which data sets are readily available, for example estimates of actual evapotranspiration from remote sensing data. Such machine learning-based models need not necessarily be underpinned by the explicit solutions of governing equations pertaining to the physical processes involved across multiple domains. These ML-based models can be used either independently or in combination with physically based models for retrospective or predictive assessments of groundwater balance components and quantification of recharge and discharge components including historical pumping rates from an aquifer.

    This study develops ML-based groundwater balance estimators using machine learning based on suitable supervised learning algorithm for a selected unconfined aquifer system that spans across 16 districts in northwest Bangladesh region. The study uses daily precipitation data, evapotranspiration estimates using Moderate Resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer (MODIS) data, interpolated river stages, and weekly observed water levels from monitoring bores to train, test and validate a Deep Neural Network model implemented using PYTORCH.

    Simulated groundwater levels obtained using the trained and tested ML models are used to estimate long-term groundwater storage changes in region and are compared to estimates from a numerical groundwater MODFLOW model developed and history-matched using Flopy and PEST++ frameworks. Both the ML and MODFLOW models are implemented for a rectangular grid with 1500 m × 1500 m cells.  The workflow scripted using PYTORCH and Flopy libraries enabled the ready comparison of ML and numerical models’ outputs and evaluate the applicability of ML models for groundwater balance simulation.

     

    How to cite: Janardhanan, S., Pagendam, D., MacKinlay, D., Pena-Arancibia, J., and Mainuddin, M.: Groundwater balance estimators using Machine Learning, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8976, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8976, 2022.

    EGU22-10013 | Presentations | HS3.8

    Region-specific multiple-approach separation of river hydrograph using the GrWat R package 

    Timofey Samsonov, Ekaterina Rets, and Maria Kireeva

    River hydrograph separation is one of the most important operations applied to the streamflow data. Numerous separation techniques and and their software implementations have been developed so far. In operational practice of Russian hydrological organizations and research institutes an event-based approach is commonly used for the hydrograph separation. Different meteorological events such as temperature transition through zero and rains are recognized in meteorological data, and then the corresponding changes in river hydrograph are identified, which eventually helps to attribute each peak in hydrograph with corresponding genetic component. The base flow component is traditionally defined according to Kudelin’s approach, taking into consideration different schemes of surface-ground water runoff interaction. In contrast, the most widespread separation approach in Western school is filtering-based. Lyne-Hollick, Maxwell, Boughton, Jakeman, Chapman and some more sophisiticated filters can be applied to separate the flow into quick and base. Results of two approaches are quite different, especially in terms of the baseflow component. In current study we present the updated open-source grwat R package, which puts both worlds together. It contains both the genetic event based and filtering-based hydrograph separation approaches with the ability to mix them together. In particular, applying the filtering-based separation inside the detected genetic events provides curve of the baseflow well corresponding to tracer-based studies. The second novelty of the package is the intellectual procedure for determination of the second-order events that complicate the freshet (seasonal) flood, such as rain floods. Finally, the updated package contains the internal spatial database of hydrograph separation parameters which is obtained over the European territory of Russia through experimental work. This database allows automated selection of the optimal separation parameters based on the location of the river gauge supplied by package user. The database can be extended to other regions of the world through collaborative work of package users.

    The study was supported by the Russian Science Foundation grant No. 19-77-10032

    How to cite: Samsonov, T., Rets, E., and Kireeva, M.: Region-specific multiple-approach separation of river hydrograph using the GrWat R package, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10013, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10013, 2022.

    Model structural error, arising from the inevitable simplification and abstraction modelers must make of complex real-world system and processes, has been shown to produce biased predictions as a direct result of parameter compensation during data assimilation. The specter of structural error especially plagues groundwater decision support modeling, since the inverse methods underpinning calibration and uncertainty analysis favor a computationally efficient and numerically stable model, or in other words, a simpler model. This work explores sequential data assimilation (DA) as a potential coping mechanism for the structural error encountered by simpler models. Unlike traditional batch methods, sequential methods assimilate data in discrete time intervals or ‘cycles’, and simultaneously estimate model state along with model parameters in order to advance the model forward in time. We hypothesize that the estimable model states in sequential DA afford more flexible and appropriate receptacles for the noise introduced into observations from model structural error. Using a paired complex-simple model approach, we empirically evaluate the predictive outcomes of batch and sequential DA in two model error scenarios: first where error arises from coarser resolution in the simple model, and second where error arises from both coarser resolution and fixed pumping rates in the simple model. Overall, we find that both formulations perform well in both history matching and forecasting when employing a high-dimensional parameterization stance, that is, treating all properties and stresses as uncertain and adjustable during the inversion process. When uncertain parameters are removed from the inversion process, however, the data assimilation process is degraded in different ways for batch and sequential formulations. These results have implications for groundwater decision support modeling as they underscore the pitfalls of fixing parameters a priori, such as with pumping, and present a proof of concept for using adjustable model states to cope with model error in decision support modeling contexts.

    How to cite: Markovich, K., White, J., and Knowling, M.: Rapid, reproducible, and wrong? Exploring sequential data assimilation as a coping mechanism for model structural error in groundwater decision support modeling, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10074, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10074, 2022.

    A scripted development and deployment approach was used for developing the next-generation groundwater flow and land-surface subsidence model of the region surrounding Houston, Texas, USA.  The area has historically experienced substantial land subsidence resulting from groundwater use. Python scripts leveraging the FloPy and PyEMU packages were written to build and run the MODFLOW 6 model, perform very-high-dimensional parameter estimation and uncertainty analysis using PEST++, and process results. Automating these processes allowed for fast and repeated iterations through all or part of the modeling workflow for purposes including: troubleshooting input errors, testing hypotheses about the hydrologic system characteristics, evaluating the influences of structural model assumptions, and experimenting with different and increasingly complex formulations of the prior parameter distribution and likelihood functions in Bayesian sense. Automated generation and storage of processed output allowed easy comparison between iterations of the modeling workflow, and Git version control software provided a self-documented model repository with full-featured “undo” for returning to previous states of the workflow and investigating outcomes. The modeling team convened regularly (monthly to twice-weekly) to review results of the latest iteration and decide the next course of action. Model performance was improved steadily and incrementally by focusing on one new feature or problem per workflow iteration until modeling goals were met. This workflow style fostered a sense of predictability and confidence in the project outcome, a welcome departure from the “typical” numerical modeling process of panic and despair.

    How to cite: Knight, J.: A worked example of an iterative, scripted approach to stochastic model development and deployment in a highly contentious decision-support setting., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10181, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10181, 2022.

    Groundwater models are simplified and simulated depictions of aquifer systems that represent flow and/or transport of groundwater. For decades, practitioners would construct a model with the help of a graphical user interface (GUI) for a simulator such as MODFLOW, a finite-difference groundwater flow modeling program written by the United States Geological Survey (USGS). Due to the nature of GUIs, most of the time (and therefore cost) went in to the creation of model input datasets, and the “calibration” of the model would be hastily rushed at the end of the project time window. Unfortunately, the calibration process will almost certainly reveal issues derived from early stages of the project, and in the GUI framework it can take significant time and effort to manually address issues with the upstream workflow elements.

    More recently, script-driven modeling workflow tools have been made available for practitioners to use to mitigate the time and cost associated with undertaking complex groundwater modeling analyses. Tools like FloPy and pyEMU python packages for interfacing with MODFLOW and the parameter estimation software PEST and PEST++.  When used together, these tools allow for all workflow steps to be automated, including the creation of the model input datasets as well as deployment analyses like data assimilation and uncertainty analysis.  More importantly, a script-driven approach allows issues (which statistically will always occur) to be addressed cleanly and efficiently, with minimal effort and little to no loss of practitioner time.

    In this presentation, we present the development and implementation of a decision-support workflow for the history matching of 1,000 geostatistical realizations of transmissivity, storage, anisotropy, and recharge using multiple simulations. This work is part of a larger risk-analysis for the Waste Isolation Pilot Plant (WIPP) project in southeastern New Mexico. The predictive focus is on estimating particle travel times of long-lived radionuclides. 

    Using script-driven approaches and recent iterative ensemble smoother techniques, our team was able undertake an advanced data assimilation analysis in a few hours one afternoon using a single workstation.  Previously, a similar analysis for the WIPP project took months of practitioner time on a massively parallel super-computer.

    How to cite: Kushnereit, R.: Calibrating an ensemble of 1,000 realizations for estimating the uncertainty of aquifer properties in the vicinity of a long‐lived radioactive waste repository using a script-driven approach (on a Friday afternoon), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10403, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10403, 2022.

    EGU22-10686 | Presentations | HS3.8

    From datasets to decisions – a repeatable workflow for groundwater decision support 

    Michael Fienen, Nicholas Corson-Dosch, Jeremy White, Andrew Leaf, and Randall Hunt

    Environmental water management often benefits from a risk-based approach where information on the area of interest is characterized, assembled, and incorporated into a decision model considering uncertainty. This includes prior information from literature, field measurements, professional interpretation, and data assimilation resulting in a decision tool with a posterior uncertainty assessment accounting for prior understanding and what is learned through model development and data assimilation. Model construction and data assimilation are time consuming and prone to errors, which motivates a repeatable workflow where revisions resulting from new interpretations or discovery of errors can be addressed and the analyses repeated efficiently and rigorously. In this work, motivated by the real-world application of delineating risk-based (probabilistic) sources of water to abstraction wells in a humid temperate climate, a scripted workflow was generated for groundwater model construction, data assimilation, particle-tracking, and post-processing. The workflow leverages existing datasets describing hydrogeology, hydrography, water use, recharge, and lateral boundaries to build the model. The workflow performs ensemble-based history matching and uses a posterior Monte Carlo approach to provide probabilistic capture zones describing areas that contribute recharge to wells in a risk-based framework. The water managers can then select areas of varying levels of protection based on their tolerance for risk of potential wrongness of the underlying models. All the tools in this workflow are open-source and free, which facilitates testing of this repeatable and transparent approach to other environmental problems. The specific data are available in the United States but the tools can be applied to similar datasets worldwide.

    How to cite: Fienen, M., Corson-Dosch, N., White, J., Leaf, A., and Hunt, R.: From datasets to decisions – a repeatable workflow for groundwater decision support, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10686, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10686, 2022.

    EGU22-10694 | Presentations | HS3.8

    Modified AquaCrop-OpenSource tool for data-scarce regions 

    Felix Bruckmaier, Soham Adla, Markus Disse, and Shivam Tripathi

    The Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) AquaCrop model has demonstrated its ability to accurately simulate the growth of various crops. However, the quality of simulation results depends on the calibration of the model, which in turn requires field observations of model inputs and parameters. This limits the utility of AquaCrop in data-scarce regions, such as the Global South. A user-friendly method to analyze parameter sensitivities and model output uncertainties could facilitate the assessment of the model output reliability. The AquaCrop version provided by FAO, however, is run through a standalone graphical user interface (GUI) and therefore does not allow for systematic calibration. Besides, the user cannot customize parameter-specific features like irrigation scheduling.

    This work presents a tool that enhances the MATLAB-based open-source application of AquaCrop, AquaCrop-OS (AOS), with the following functionalities: A Bayesian modeling feature is designed to calibrate the AOS model considering input data uncertainty, while the MATLAB toolbox Sensitivity Analysis For Everybody (SAFE) is integrated to automate sensitivity and uncertainty analysis. Irrigation schedules may now also be created dynamically and depending on different simulated parameters like the rooting depth. The user can distinguish between different environmental stresses, either by cause or affected variable. Every functionality is supplemented with intuitive graphics. The tool will be released under an open-source license on GitHub. A standalone executable version with a GUI will cater for non-MATLAB users.

    The AOS model is calibrated on field data from an experimental agricultural plot in the Ganga River basin in Kanpur, India, for two wheat cropping seasons between 2018 and 2019. The proposed tool is used to quantify the uncertainty in the model input data and parameters and their effects on model outputs.

    How to cite: Bruckmaier, F., Adla, S., Disse, M., and Tripathi, S.: Modified AquaCrop-OpenSource tool for data-scarce regions, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10694, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10694, 2022.

    EGU22-10747 | Presentations | HS3.8

    Decision-support modelling for an uncertain future: developing forecasts of sea level rise impacts on groundwater 

    Lee Chambers, Brioch Hemmings, Catherine Moore, Simon Cox, Richard Levy, and Matthew Knowling

    The low-lying coastal urban area of South Dunedin, New Zealand, is particularly susceptible to the impacts of sea-level rise, which is projected to rise by as much as 1.2 m by 2100 under high emissions scenarios.  Currently, more than 2,500 homes are < 50 cm above mean sea level and groundwater levels are typically < 1 m below the surface.  As sea levels rise, groundwater levels are also predicted to rise, increasing the probability of inland groundwater inundation (groundwater flooding) throughout South Dunedin.  It is therefore imperative to develop an improved understanding of the physical controls, and the uncertainty associated with these controls, on the occurrence and severity of the groundwater inundation hazard caused by rising sea levels.  We deploy a simple and fast-running model within a highly-parametrised Uncertainty Quantification (UQ) workflow to investigate the adequacy of steady-state-only versus transient calibration when assessing the risks of groundwater inundation.  The decision to proceed beyond a steady-state-only calibration is time-consuming and costly (often vastly so) and requires careful attention and further research in practical application.  The reduction in uncertainty of decision-relevant forecasts accrued through implementing a transient calibration procedure (or lack thereof), given existing and yet to be acquired data, is the metric by which the modelling is judged.  Firstly, the workflow involves history matching and uncertainty analysis implemented through PESTPP-IES to explore and reduce the uncertainty of decision-relevant forecasts (spatial groundwater elevation and drain fluxes).  Secondly, a paired complex-simple model analysis is used to: explore 1) the potential uncertainty reductions in decision-relevant forecasts achieved through transient calibration and 2) the potential introduction of unquantifiable bias of decision-relevant forecasts introduced by the competing calibration procedures.

    How to cite: Chambers, L., Hemmings, B., Moore, C., Cox, S., Levy, R., and Knowling, M.: Decision-support modelling for an uncertain future: developing forecasts of sea level rise impacts on groundwater, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10747, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10747, 2022.

    EGU22-11823 | Presentations | HS3.8

    Integrated hydrological modelling for decision support to improve field and catchment scale water management in agriculture 

    Syed Md Touhidul Mustafa, Anna Autio, Ali Torabi Haghighi, Hannu Marttila, Tamara Avellan, Oliver S. Schilling, Philip Brunner, Miklas Scholz, and Björn Klöve

    Particularly in the Nordic region, water excess and shortage (drought) are becoming more frequent phenomena that challenge the development of agriculture and crop production. Identification of appropriate water management strategies is essential (i) to ensure sustainable water resources management for crop production and the functioning of healthy ecosystems; and (ii) to improve resilience to hydrological extremes. Integrated hydrological models offer that potential through understanding and forecasting of hydrological systems under anthropogenic and climatic influences, and providing information for improved decision-making. This study aims to develop a decision support instrument based on integrated hydrological modelling to identify appropriate management solutions and improve field- and catchment-scale water management in Nordic agriculture. The study area is Tyrnävä catchment, located in the northern part of Finland near Oulu city. Initially, the available hydro-climatological and hydrogeological data of the Tyrnävä catchment are characterized in detail. Then the hydrogeological parameters of the model are identified based on existing hydrogeological, climatic and remotely sensed data and their spatial, temporal and vertical variability. Next, a regional integrated surface-subsurface hydrological model is set up using HydroGeosphere. After successful calibration and validation using observed groundwater level, river discharge and soil moisture data, the model will be used in implementing and evaluating different management strategies (e.g., different irrigation options during droughts and controlled drainage management) for the future and their influence on the surface and groundwater systems. Uncertainty arising from different sources will be quantified using the Integrated Bayesian Multi-model Uncertainty Estimation Framework with the support of a supercomputer to improve the reliability and accuracy of the decision support instrument. Additionally, stakeholders’ involvement through local workshops is ensured throughout the modelling study, from the beginning to obtain reliable and useful decision support. Finally, based on these results, informed decisions regarding the appropriate water management can be made, which is important for sustainable water resources management for crop production and the functioning of healthy ecosystems particularly in Nordic agriculture.

    How to cite: Mustafa, S. M. T., Autio, A., Haghighi, A. T., Marttila, H., Avellan, T., Schilling, O. S., Brunner, P., Scholz, M., and Klöve, B.: Integrated hydrological modelling for decision support to improve field and catchment scale water management in agriculture, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11823, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11823, 2022.

    Water distribution network (WDN) is an essential infrastructure for conveying potable water to communities. Constituting different components, it has a complex structure involving significant financial investments for its design. During its life span, the failure of WDN partially or entirely is an inevitable consequence of the network's hydraulic or mechanical uncertainties. Therefore, the WDN design problem naturally involves a tradeoff between the reliability and cost aspects. The present study formulates a reliability-based hybrid metaheuristic optimization model for its robust design. Primarily, the proposed framework is composed of three components, an optimization algorithm, a simulation model, and a reliability assessment model. 
    A novel hybrid technique in a combination of differential evolution (DE) and krill herd algorithm (KHA), DE-KHA, is used as the optimization algorithm. The DE-KHA is the computationally efficient algorithm for effortlessly tackling the WDN design problems by balancing the exploration and exploitation features. EPANET 2.0 hydraulic simulator that performs the hydraulic analysis of WDN is used as a simulation model. The hydraulic characteristics of the network, such as flow-through pipes, unit headloss, the actual and total pressure head at the demand nodes, and the demands delivered to the demand nodes, are assessed using EPANET 2.0. The reliability model evaluates the network's performance under mechanical uncertainties. The mechanical failures are the scenarios of networks component failure, which in the present study are considered network pipe outages. The reliability model is based on the minimum cut set method, where the pipe failure combinations that cause the failure of the network are found explicitly considering the minimum pressure head requirement at the demand nodes.
    Search for the optimal solution is progressed by the optimization technique, where the constraints of continuity and energy balance equations are explicitly taken care of by the EPANET 2.0 simulation model. Then considering the hydraulic head at the demand node, the minimum cut sets are finalized, and the network’s performance under mechanical failure scenarios is assessed using the reliability model. The DE-KHA and reliability model code is written in MATLAB and linked to EPANEt 2.0 using MATLAB-EPANET toolkit.
    The application of the developed framework is validated considering Two loop Network (TLN). It is a hypothetical network studied by many researchers for validating their optimization models. TLN is made up of eight pipes, connected by seven nodes with a single reservoir of 210 m total head that feeds the entire network. Thus, it is a gravity-fed network with no pumps operated. Considering this simple case study, yet a challenging problem with 148 possible solutions in the search space, the reliability-based model is validated. The results present the computational efficiency of the model in yielding the optimal design cost of $ 419,000 with minimal computational effort. Furthermore, the algorithm proposed is efficient in exploring various alternate optimal solutions with considerable reliability, thus, presenting robust design options for TLN. Considering the efficiency of the proposed model, the study suggests it for the robust design of real-life WDNs.

    Keywords: Water distribution network design; Reliability; Mechanical uncertainty; Metaheuristic algorithms 

     

    How to cite: Naga Poojitha, S. and Jothiprakash, V.: Reliability-Based Hybrid Metaheuristic Optimization Model for the Design of Two Loop Network Under Mechanical Uncertain Scenarios, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12971, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12971, 2022.

    HS4 – Hydrological forecasting

    EGU22-1952 | Presentations | HS4.1

    Estimation of Floods Related to Extreme Precipitations through a Machine Learning Approach 

    Leonardo Sandoval, Monica Riva, and Alberto Guadagnini

    The study is geared towards the implementation of a workflow based on a Support Vector Regression Machine Learning (SVR-ML) approach which is conducive to estimates of flowrates across a given cross-section of a target stream in the presence of extreme precipitation events. The work is motivated by the observation that damages ensuing flash floods are a matter of global concern. A broad set of evidences suggests the ecosystem is experiencing changes of precipitation extremes, a causality relationship between increasing extreme floods and global climate dynamics being evidenced. In this context, practical tools associated with analyses of floods caused by extreme precipitation events can assist the design of early alert strategies across vulnerable regions. Physically and conceptually-based models have been extensively employed to link stream flowrates to precipitation events. These kinds of models are formulated and validated upon relying on continuous monitoring of flowrates as well as hydrometeorological variables associated with the area of the watershed related to a target stream. The typically high uncertainties underlying (a) the description of the physical processes governing the rainfall-runoff relationship as well as (b) monitoring and quantification of quantities and attributes characterizing the system behavior tend to propagate to outputs of interest of a given model. When considering well instrumented watersheds, data-driven modeling approaches grounded on machine learning (ML) algorithms can be an attractive alternative/complement to physically-based modeling approaches to analyze extreme flood events. Here, we rely on a Support Vector Regression ML (SVR-ML) algorithm that makes use of a linear kernel to provide estimates of hourly flowrate at a stream upon relying on observations of hydrometeorological variables across the watershed associated with the stream. The analysis encompasses three watersheds differing in size (ranging from about 25 to 250 km2) and located in the North of Italy and is structured across three steps: (i) identification of variables that are most informative to the target quantity (i.e., the flowrate in the stream), a step relying on cross-correlation and partial auto-correlation analyses; (ii) training of the SVR-ML algorithm, comprising the estimation of the optimal hyperparameters and parameters of trained models and the ensuing validation; and (iii) analysis of the anticipation time at which an early alert is effective, model performance being then quantified through the typical Mean Average Percentual Error (MAPE) metric. Our results suggest that, as expected, precipitation is the main driving force in a rainfall-runoff process, quantities such as temperature and relative humidity being least informative to the construction of the ML model considered. The predictive capability of the model (quantified through MAPE) is influenced by the desired anticipation time (i.e., the distance in time between the inputs and the output of the ML model). In general, one can note that (i) predictions of enhanced quality (MAPE smaller than 10%) are obtained for shorter anticipation times and (ii) models associated with low values of MAPE are obtained if the anticipation time is equal to or smaller than the time of concentration of the watershed.

    How to cite: Sandoval, L., Riva, M., and Guadagnini, A.: Estimation of Floods Related to Extreme Precipitations through a Machine Learning Approach, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1952, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1952, 2022.

    EGU22-3142 | Presentations | HS4.1

    FastFlood: a fast and simple 2D hydrodynamic or hydrostatic numerical solution to river flow in landscape evolution models 

    Philippe Steer, Philippe Davy, Dimitri Lague, Thomas Bernard, and Hélène Feliciano

    Modelling river hydrodynamics in an efficient approach remains a technical challenge which limits our ability to assess river flood hazard or to use process-based erosion laws at a high-resolution in landscape evolution models. Here we present a fast iterative method, entitled FastFlood, to compute river depth and velocity in 2D on a digital elevation model (DEM). This new method solves for the 2D shallow water equation, without the inertia terms, by iteratively building the river water depth using classical flow routing algorithms based on directed acyclic graphs, including the classical single or multi-flow, applied to the water surface. At each iteration, the water depth of each cell of the DEM increases by an increment that is a function of water discharge, computed using a flow accumulation operation, and decreases based on a flow resistance equation, in a manner similar to the Floodos model (Davy et al., 2017). In the hydrostatic mode, this operation is repeated until reaching a near constant water depth over the entire DEM, which occurs after a few tens or hundreds of iterations. FastFlood can also solve for the dynamic propagation of a flood in the hydrodynamic mode. In this case, the water depth increment is only a function of the water discharge exiting the direct upstream neighbors and the iterations are replaced by a time evolution of the water depth. Water depths obtained with the hydrostatic solution were validated against an analytical solution in the case of a rectangular channel and with the Floodos model for natural DEMs. Compared to previous hydrodynamic models, the main benefits of FastFlood are its simplicity of implementation, which mainly requires a classical flow routing algorithm, and its efficiency. Indeed, for a DEM of 106 cells, the algorithm takes about 2 minutes on a laptop to find the hydrostatic solution, about 10 times faster than using the Floodos model (Davy et al., 2017) that was already significantly faster than other hydrodynamic models. Moreover, the computational time scales a little more than linearly with the number of cells, which makes FastFlood a suitable solution even for DEMs larger than 106 – 107 cells. In the future, we expect to make progress on the numerical method by adapting graph-based solutions to the issue of flow water routing. Following Davy et al. (2017), we will also include FastFlood in a landscape evolution model to couple it to process-based laws for erosion, transport and deposition of sediments.

    How to cite: Steer, P., Davy, P., Lague, D., Bernard, T., and Feliciano, H.: FastFlood: a fast and simple 2D hydrodynamic or hydrostatic numerical solution to river flow in landscape evolution models, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3142, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3142, 2022.

    EGU22-3213 | Presentations | HS4.1

    Quantifying the impact of soil moisture dynamics on UK flood hazard under climate change 

    Youtong Rong, Paul Bates, and Jeffrey Neal

    Extreme precipitation events are expected to intensify with global warming, and naturally a widespread assumption is that the intensity and frequency of flooding will grow with the heavier downpours under climate change. However, flood magnitude is not only dependent on the spatial distribution, time evolution and rarity of precipitation, antecedent soil moisture and snowmelt are also the potential controls on flood hazard. Few studies have jointly quantified the influence of soil moisture dynamics and spatiotemporal distribution of precipitation on flood amplitude, though many research attempted to explain the elusive relationship between rainfall and flood conceptually. Here, the connections of changes in extreme precipitation and direct surface water flooding intensities in the periods of 1981-2000, 2021-2040 and 2061-2080 are quantified in 6 study areas in the UK, with high-resolution spatial and temporal characteristics of hourly rainfall data from UKCP Local 2.2 km. Dynamic soil moisture is modeled empirically and continuously to capture the moisture variation and infiltration loss, and distributed rainfall-runoff is calculated on the uneven terrain with the sub-grid river channel model in LISFLOOD-FP. Results indicate a strong correlation of the extreme rainfall and flood magnitude changes with the capacity of the soil moisture. Extreme precipitation can be magnified in rainy seasons due to amplified moisture convergence, while in dry periods limited moisture availability may offset extreme precipitation increases.

    How to cite: Rong, Y., Bates, P., and Neal, J.: Quantifying the impact of soil moisture dynamics on UK flood hazard under climate change, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3213, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3213, 2022.

    EGU22-4952 | Presentations | HS4.1 | Highlight

    New insights for real-time flood forecasting in Germany: Lessons learned from 2021 summer flood in Ahr river 

    Husain Najafi, Stephan Thober, Oldrich Rakovec, Pallav Kumar shrestha, and Luis Samaniego

    We investigate the 2021 summer flood in Ahr catchment in West Germany, with the return period estimated preliminarily as 1 in more than 500 years [1]. A recent study has indicated that science did not fail to predict the flood event [2]. Yet, several scientific and administrative challenges are still to be addressed to improve existing flood forecasting systems for supporting local authorities to manage such extreme events. We bring some examples of what science and technology gaps need to be filled to address these issues. To do this, uncertainties associated with near-real time precipitation products with hourly and daily resolutions provided by the German weather service (DWD) have been investigated. The hydrological response of the catchment is tested to several high-resolution gridded precipitation observations and reanalysis data for post-assessment of the event. A new feature to read hourly meteorological input data was added to the mesoscale Hydrologic Model (mHM- www.ufz.de/mhm) to forced it with Radar-Online-Adjustment of hourly values measured at the precipitation stations (RADOLAN-mHM). Comparing the flood peak from RADOLAN-mHM with REGNIE-mHM at daily time steps provided valuable insights on development-orientation of near-real time and high-resolution flash flood analysis and forecast applications for Germany. Last but not least, the variability of maximum streamflow in the Ahr catchment was evaluated for future periods under climate change to check if such megafloods can be considered as new norms.

    Fig 1. Boxplots of the annual maximum streamflow in Ahr river simulated by the mesoscale Hydrologic Model (mHM)
      for three periods between 1971-2000, 2000-2050 and 2051-2100. Simulation is conducted based on 21 ensembles under RCP 2.6 and 49 ensembles under RCP 8.5

    References

    [1] L. Samaniego, H. Najafi, O. Rakovec, P. Shrestha, S. Thober. (2021) High-resolution hydrologic forecasts were able to predict the 2021 German Floods: what failed?. AGU 2021 Fall Meeting, New Orleans.
    [2] World weather attribution report, (2021) Rapid attribution of heavy rainfall events leading to the severe flooding in Western Europe during July 2021. https://www.worldweatherattribution.org/wp-content/uploads/Scientific-report-Western-Europe-floods-2021-attribution.pdf

    How to cite: Najafi, H., Thober, S., Rakovec, O., shrestha, P. K., and Samaniego, L.: New insights for real-time flood forecasting in Germany: Lessons learned from 2021 summer flood in Ahr river, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4952, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4952, 2022.

    EGU22-6170 | Presentations | HS4.1

    Quantifying rainfall forecast uncertainty and error propagation in flash flood and landslide prediction models 

    Bastian Winkels, Julian Hofmann, Anil Yildiz, Ann-Kathrin Edrich, Holger Schüttrumpf, and Julia Kowalski

    Extreme weather situations are becoming increasingly frequent with devastating consequences worldwide. Heavy rainfall events in July 2021 caused severe flash floods in western Germany, Belgium and the Netherlands, resulting in a high number of casualties and material damage. The high hazard potential combined with the low reaction times, associated with these events, make it necessary to develop efficient and reliable early warning systems (EWSs) to facilitate the preparation of response strategies. As nowcast precipitation forecasts are continuously improving in both quality and spatial resolution, they become an essential input for flash flood and landslide prediction models and therefore an important component in EWSs. However, the inherent uncertainty of radar-based nowcasting systems are carried over to the output of those prediction models. Therefore, this study aims to analyze the uncertainty sources of nowcasting products of the German weather service (DWD) using the July flood Event 2021 as a case study. More specifically, the objective is to determine whether the quality of precipitation nowcast products is sufficient for usage in physics-based flood or landslide prediction models. Due to the complex nature of weather and rainfall structures as well as their spatio-temporal variability, traditional cell-by-cell comparison of predictions and ground truth is insufficient to quantify forecast quality. To overcome this issue, uncertainties in magnitude, time and space and their respective sources are identified, using techniques from various fields of science. Subsequently, error propagation in flash flood prediction models is analyzed by applying the previously determined uncertainty ranges to a hydrological model.

    How to cite: Winkels, B., Hofmann, J., Yildiz, A., Edrich, A.-K., Schüttrumpf, H., and Kowalski, J.: Quantifying rainfall forecast uncertainty and error propagation in flash flood and landslide prediction models, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6170, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6170, 2022.

    EGU22-6953 | Presentations | HS4.1

    Super-fast flash flood simulation using steady-state flow solvers 

    Bastian van den Bout

    Flash floods are a rapid burst of flood water that can cause extreme damage to populated areas. The European floods in France, Belgium, Germany and the Netherlands in the summer of 2021 featured a wide range of flash floods with a large number of casualties and vast financial damage. Reflection on the risk reduction strategies have reemphasized the need for early warning systems in the upstream catchments of North-Western Europe. For applications such as this, the speed of flow simulations is critical, as the quality of real-time forecasting often depends on the frequency and amount of simulations that can be carried out as new weather forecasts come in. We present a new type of flood hazard model that, in many typical cases, solves flash flood hazard a 100 times faster with similar accuracy. The developed method employs steady-state solvers for diffusive wave water flow equations to skip the dynamical process and directly estimate relevant parameters such as maximum flow height, maximum flow velocity and relative arrival time of the flood water. These paramters are often the most important for warning systems and descision making in risk reduction. Our adapted algorithm improves upon traditional steady-state flow solvers by employing inversed flow accumulation results and compensation for partial steady-state flow. We show the accuracy of the method is similar to full dynamic water flow simulation in many types of events, such as the extreme 2003 floods in the Fella Basin (Italy), Hurricane-induced flooding on Dominica and the flood impact in Limburg in 2021 (The Netherlands). On average, with highly similar accuracy, calculation time was reduced from approximately 6 hours to 2.5 minutes. We further investigate the limits of the developed methods, in particular to practical applications in different type of flood events. While the sensitivity of the model to initial conditions is similar to that of regular flood models, the sensitivity of the hydraulic aspects is lower. Finally, we discuss potential usage for early-warning, spatial descision support systems and serious gaming approaches. While further investigation is required to fully validate the method, a break-through in flood hazard assessment could be on hand.

    How to cite: van den Bout, B.: Super-fast flash flood simulation using steady-state flow solvers, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6953, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6953, 2022.

    EGU22-7212 | Presentations | HS4.1

    Automatic 2D mapping of flash floods: which possibilities and limits? An illustration based on the Cartino2D method 

    Frédéric Pons, Mathieu Alquier, and Elodie Paya

    Efficient pluvial flood mapping methods are needed to produce realistic flood scenarios in very small upstream catchments. The Cartino2D method was developed to launch automatically 2D models based on the Telemac2D hydraulic software. The principle is quite simple, (1) create automatically the mesh with a topography based on Lidar, (2) manage automatically the boundary conditions, (3) run the model based on rainfall input data, and (4) postprocess the results. The extent of each 2D model generally varies between 2 to 10 km² with a maximum of 20km². The only manual work consists in checking or modifying the limits of hydrological catchments.

    We began to use this method on the Toulon metropole (South of France) with 66 complementary computation domains covering about 180km² and using eight statistical rainfalls. We also tested and evaluated this method on twenty other case studies in different regions of France. In this presentation, we focus on two evaluations (flood of June 2010 in Draguignan and flood in 2014/2015 around Montpellier) conducted within the ANR PICS project.

    In this project, we improved the method to automatically integrate radar rainfall and to compare the results with local knowledge, observed historical floods and local hydraulic studies.

    Cartino2D offers interesting results in areas with natural, rural land-use or few urban developments. The density of the mesh (less than 3m in the thalwegs) and the Telemac2D model quality are sufficient to obtain a good accuracy in these areas.  

    In urban areas, the method provides a first knowledge, but more complex input data are needed to improve the accuracy of results.

    We try in this presentation to describe which databases should be created to improve the accuracy of such automatic computations. At the scale of urban areas with results around buildings, the databases need to be spatially well defined. We propose some standard of databases to be integrated in computations: for example, the main underground channels or culverts, the main aerial channels (particularly very small channels not recognized by Lidar), a spatial distribution of the Curve Number and of the Manning’s coefficient.

    This kind of databases, which cannot be deduced automatically from Lidar data, appears as essential to improve the results of Cartino2D automatic process. This kind of knowledge exists locally, but up to now it is not integrated in homogeneous national or regional databases.

    In the same way, we need also to have well-defined databases to compare automatic results with historical floods as flood marks, gauge stations.

    Automatic 2D mapping of flash floods seems to be a realizable goal at a scale of a region or country with standard 2D hydraulic models. But the current main limits appear to be a lack of good input database management, which limits the current accuracy of mapping results.

    How to cite: Pons, F., Alquier, M., and Paya, E.: Automatic 2D mapping of flash floods: which possibilities and limits? An illustration based on the Cartino2D method, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7212, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7212, 2022.

    EGU22-7768 | Presentations | HS4.1

    Debris floods and channel widening in mountain rivers: Examples from the Vaia Storm (October 2018) in the Cordevole River catchment (Dolomites, Italy) 

    Andrea Brenna, Lorenzo Marchi, Marco Borga, Mattia Zaramella, and Nicola Surian

    Mountain rivers experience channel widening as a response to high-magnitude hydrological events. Several studies indicate that the unit stream power (ωpk) and the lateral confinement (CI) are among the most important constraints to explain channel modifications induced by a flood. That said, with the same controlling factors, a relatively broad spectrum of width ratios (WR = channel width after/before the flood) is commonly observed in real case studies. Sediment transport in mountain streams occurs via processes classified as debris flows (DFW), debris floods (DFD) and water flows (WF). This study aims to test if different flow-types are one of the drivers of channel response to floods, specifically investigating if there is a relationship between DFD (i.e. a transport condition characterized by extremely high bedload) and intense channel widening.

    The case study is the Cordevole catchment (Dolomites, Italy; drainage area of 857 km2), which in October 2018 was affected by a severe hydrological event (Vaia storm). Besides the main stem of the Cordevole River, we considered four of its tributaries (Tegnas, Pettorina, Liera and Corpassa torrents). WR was determined at the sub-reach scale through aerial photographs analysis and ωpkwas calculated considering the discharge at the flood peak provided by hydrological modelling. A post-flood survey allowed us to determine the flow-types that occurred at each sub-reach of the Tegnas Torrent during the event. The possible upheaval from WF to DFD along the other streams was determined considering the presence of conditions required for local occurrence of DFD (i.e. ωpk exceeding 5000 Wm-2 and/or DFW tributaries delivering large amount of sediment into a receiving stream).

    DFD sub-reaches of the Tegnas Torrent experienced widenings that, at the same ωpk, were 2-3 times larger than WR of WF sites. These processes-specific relationships were used to recognize sub-reaches of the other streams were an “anomalous widening” occurred during the Vaia event, i.e. sites where WR was significantly larger-than-expected for a specific ωpkunder conditions of WF. Among 117 sub-reaches, anomalous widening was recognized at 13 and 6 sub-reaches of the Liera (WR up to 16) and Pettorina (WR up to 10) torrents, respectively. All these sub-reaches were characterized by the presence of conditions required for DFD occurrence during a high-magnitude flood, allowing us to infer that the process responsible for sediment transport during the Vaia event was likely DFD. Contrariwise, no sub-reaches of the Cordevole and Corpassa streams experienced anomalous widening, likely because WF occurred along their whole courses due to their morphological characteristics (e.g. wide channel before the flood) and/or lower magnitude of the flooding locally induced by the storm.  

    These results suggest that an extraordinary-widening characterizes DFD channel sites, which, during a severe flood, can be affected by channel changes remarkably more intense than those occurring in response to WF. For this reason, in addition to hydraulic and morphological constraints, the different sediment–water flows possibly occurring at a sub-reach should be considered as a further controlling factor for channel modifications and, consequently, for prediction of geomorphic hazard at local scale.

    How to cite: Brenna, A., Marchi, L., Borga, M., Zaramella, M., and Surian, N.: Debris floods and channel widening in mountain rivers: Examples from the Vaia Storm (October 2018) in the Cordevole River catchment (Dolomites, Italy), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7768, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7768, 2022.

    EGU22-7913 | Presentations | HS4.1 | Highlight

    Towards a hydrological consensus about the 2nd – 3rd October 2020 ALEX storm event in the French “Alpes Maritimes” region 

    Frédéric Pons, Laurent Bonnifait, David Criado, Olivier Payrastre, Felix Billaud, Pierre Brigode, Catherine Fouchier, Philippe Gourbesville, Damien Kuss, Nathalie Le Nouveau, Olivier Martin, Stan Nomis, Emmanuel Paquet, and Bernard Cardelli

    After having swept over western France, the ALEX storm led to an exceptional Mediterranean rainfall event which hit the “Alpes Maritimes” region during the night of the 2nd to 3rd October 2020. The rainfall accumulations observed on 12 to 24 hours durations were unique in this region, with a record of 663mm in 24h (EDF raingauge at Les Mesces).

    Form West to East, several valleys, mainly those of Tinée, Vésubie, and Roya were affected by major floods, landslides, sediment transport and geomorphological changes. The hydrometric network was almost destroyed. The human and material damages were considerable, with many fatalities and missing people, several villages largely destroyed, and important destructions of communication and transport networks.

    A lot of technical post-flood surveys were launched by national authorities to gather a detailed knowledge of the event characteristics, with regard to rainfall accumulations, water discharges, description the torrential phenomena, and inventory of damages. This communication is focused on the question of water discharges.

    National and local authorities and organisms, universities and companies, were involved in different post-flood surveys aiming at gathering information on the peak discharges and the hydrographs of the floods, for their own needs and/or within structured programs (Administrative survey, HYMEX research project www.hymex.org).

    Several kind of discharge field estimations were provided using field survey measurements, satellites images, post-event Lidar data, combined with hydraulic estimations based on hydraulic formulas, and 1D/2D hydraulic models. Several teams also applied hydrological models based on radar quantitative precipitation estimates, to calculate hydrographs at different basins outlets.

    To combine and draw a uniform synthesis of all these results, a consensus exchange was launched to share the knowledge gathered by the different data providers. The objective was to compare, assess, and propose common intervals of peak discharges in the different impacted valleys. We also evaluated for each valley the return period of the final interval of discharge established by the consensus.

    The final product is an official administrative document, established at the end of October 2021 by the French state authorities, providing the peak discharge values to be used for post flood studies, reconstruction, and prevention measures.

    How to cite: Pons, F., Bonnifait, L., Criado, D., Payrastre, O., Billaud, F., Brigode, P., Fouchier, C., Gourbesville, P., Kuss, D., Le Nouveau, N., Martin, O., Nomis, S., Paquet, E., and Cardelli, B.: Towards a hydrological consensus about the 2nd – 3rd October 2020 ALEX storm event in the French “Alpes Maritimes” region, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7913, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7913, 2022.

    Best allocation of ressources from stakeholders that face fast-flooding implies a dynamic representation of the risk, exposure, and danger, in a situation where parameters (roughness, infiltration, drainage network etc.), and input (bathymetry and rainfall) can be both uncertain and volatile. Ensemble strategy simulation appears as a good approach to deal with these issues.
    Fast-flood event are also typically events where meteorological predictions can underestimate the actual rainfalls until very late. Urban microcharacteristics can also make models sensitive to spatial resolution, and « events » such as log jam can even modify DEM. 
    At Strane Innovation, we develop a decision-support tool called BlueMapping. To be operational, that is, fast to deploy and reliable, we use this ensemble strategy together with the fastests simulation models deployed on powerful computers. It also requires quick and robust routines for the setup of the model, with proxies when data is not available at the moment, and inputs that are easy to modify if necessary.
    We will ilustrate this discussion through the test case of the Alex storm that hit la Vésubie and la Roya valleys. After a quick benchmark with a standard model, we will compare the outcome between the flooding predicted by different models and the actual outcome. 
    Since BlueMapping can be integrated in an alarm system, it is important to assess the values of the confusion matrix, in particular the false alarm ratio, to make sure our tool keeps its value over time.

    How to cite: Wacheux, C.: Ensemble strategy for decision-support tool : a case study of the Alex storm in 2020 in la Roya and la Vésubie valleys, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9023, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9023, 2022.

    EGU22-12136 | Presentations | HS4.1

    Assessing parsimonious hydrological model structures with distributed adjoint-based calibration in SMASH Python-Fortran platform on large sample of French catchments and flash floods 

    François Colleoni, Pierre-André Garambois, Maxime Jay-Allemand, Pierre Javelle, Patrick Arnaud, Catherine Fouchier, and Igor Gejadze

    This contribution presents improvements of conceptual models in SMASH (Spatially distributed Modelling and ASsimilation for Hydrology) platform, underlying the French national flash flood forecasting system Vigicrues Flash [1], based on: (i) the 3-parameters model formulation and variational data assimilation algorithm of [2] that showed promising results (i) hypothesis testing on a large sample of catchments and flash floods; (ii) comparison of the SMASH model performances in uniform and distributed calibration to GR models; (iii) a new wrapped Python interface automatically generated by the f90wrap library [3]. Multiple tests have allowed us to converge on two parsimonious distributed model structures that have comparable performances to the GR models in spatially uniform calibration. These two structures, mainly based on GR operators at the pixel scale, differ in the production operator, with the 6-parameters structure being GR production and the 7-parameters structure being VIC production. Furthermore, the use of distributed calibration applied to these formulations via adjoint model resolution shows significantly better calibration performances without being less robust in spatio-temporal validation. Immediate work deals with improving the regional calibration scheme by tayloring the global search of semi-distributed prior parameter sets, with multi-gauge constrains, improving physiographic regularizations in the forward-inverse SMASH assimilation chain, using Python librairies.

    References
    [1] P. Javelle, et al. Flash flood warnings: Recent achievements in france with the national vigicrues flash system UNDRR GAR, 2019.
    [2] M. Jay-Allemand, et al.. On the potential of variational calibration for a fully distributed hydrological model: application on a mediterranean catchment. HESS, 2020, https://doi.org/10.5194/hess-24-5519-2020
    [3] J. R. Kermode. f90wrap: an automated tool for constructing deep python interfaces to modern fortran codes. 2020. https://doi.org/10.1088/1361-648X/ab82d2

    How to cite: Colleoni, F., Garambois, P.-A., Jay-Allemand, M., Javelle, P., Arnaud, P., Fouchier, C., and Gejadze, I.: Assessing parsimonious hydrological model structures with distributed adjoint-based calibration in SMASH Python-Fortran platform on large sample of French catchments and flash floods, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12136, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12136, 2022.

    EGU22-13445 | Presentations | HS4.1 | Highlight

    Nowcasting Flood Impacts of Convective storms in the Sahel 

    Steven J Cole, Seonaid Anderson, Abdoulahat Diop, Christopher Taylor, Cornelia Klein, Steven Wells, Gemma Nash, and Malick Diagne

    Flash flooding from intense rainfall frequently results in major damage and loss of life across Africa. Over the Sahel, intense rainfall from Mesoscale Convective Systems (MCSs) is the main driver of flash floods, with recent research showing that these have tripled in frequency over the last 35 years. This climate-change signal, combined with rapid urban expansion in the region, suggests that the socio-economic impacts of flash flooding will become more frequent and severe. Appropriate disaster preparedness, response, and resilience measures are required to manage this increasing risk.

    The NFLICS (Nowcasting FLood Impacts of Convective storms in the Sahel) project has co-developed a prototype early warning system for Senegal, incorporating nowcasting of heavy rainfall likelihood and flood risk from MCSs at city and sub-national scales. This system uses remote sensed satellite data and has been developed in partnership with the national meteorological agency (ANACIM) to operate quickly in real-time. To identify convective activity, wavelet analysis is applied to Meteosat data on cloud-top temperature for historical periods (2004 to 2019) and for the start-time of a nowcast. Data on historical convective activity, conditioned on the present location and timing of observed convection, are used to produce probabilistic forecasts of convective activity out to six hours ahead. Verification against the convective activity analysis and the 24-hour raingauge accumulations over Dakar suggests that these probabilistic nowcasts provide useful information on the occurrence of convective activity. The highest skill (compared to nowcasts based solely on climatology) is obtained when the probability of convection is estimated over spatial scales between 100 and 200km, depending on the forecast lead-time considered. Furthermore, recent advances have included incorporation of land surface temperature anomalies to modify nowcast probabilities – this recognises that MCS evolution favour drier land.

    A flood knowledge database, compiled with local partners, allows estimation of the flood risk over Dakar given the identified probability of convective activity. The flood hazard is estimated from the probabilistic convective-activity nowcast when combined with information on the historical relationship between convective activity and precipitation totals. Information on the antecedent conditions can also be included, with a higher level of hazard associated with recent rainfall and already-wet conditions. Flood vulnerability is estimated at the local scale from post-event analysis of the 2009 flood events along with information from recent modelling studies and flood-alleviation measures. The combined information from nowcasts of convective-activity and flood-risk is visualised through an interactive desktop GUI and an online portal. Operational trials over the 2020 and 2021 rainy seasons, and during intensive nowcasting testbeds with researchers and forecasters, has shown the utility of these new nowcast products to support Impact-based Forecasting.

    How to cite: Cole, S. J., Anderson, S., Diop, A., Taylor, C., Klein, C., Wells, S., Nash, G., and Diagne, M.: Nowcasting Flood Impacts of Convective storms in the Sahel, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13445, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13445, 2022.

    In the Indian subcontinent, the uncertainty associated with potential evapotranspiration (PET) over drought characterization is inadequately studied. This study was conducted to understand the sensitivity of PET estimation methods towards drought characterization using multiple PET-based drought indices under future climate change. We used eleven PET estimation methods (Blaney-Criddle (BC), Hamon (HM), Hargreaves (HG), Kharrufa (KF), Thornwaithe (TW), Dalton (DN), Meyer (MR), Irmak-Rn (IRN), Irmak-Rs (IRS), Priestley-Taylor (PT), and Penman-Monteith (PM)) for the future period (from the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project 5). Further, for drought characterization six PET-based drought indices are utilized in this study: the Standardized Precipitation Evaporation Index (SPEI), the Supply-Demand Drought Index (SDDI), the Reconnaissance Drought Index (RDI), the self-calibrated Palmer Drought Severity Index (sc-PDSI), the Standardized Moisture Anomaly Index (SZI), and the Standardized Palmer Drought Index (SPDI). We also employed a variance-based global sensitivity analysis to determine the relative sensitivity of projected drought indices to the GCM and PET estimation methodologies under climate change scenarios. Results indicate that different PET-based drought indices show vastly different drought projections for the future, which is highly influenced by the PET methods. Overall, SPEI and SDDI produce comparable results, indicating an increase in future drought estimates compared to the rest (RDI, SPDI, SZI, and sc-PDSI). The TW method reported higher drought projections compared to other PET methods irrespective of the drought indices.  This is due to the fact that the TW method also showed the highest increase in PET compared to the rest of the methods. Results from the sensitivity analysis indicate that all the drought indices are more sensitive to the choice of PET methods compared to the GCM. However, analysis was done after excluding the TW approach significantly altered the sensitivity, and GCMs were found to be more sensitive compared to PET methods. The results from this study reveal that drought projections derived from multiple PET estimation methodologies indicate drier conditions in the future, albeit at variable levels. Thus, the selection of the PET estimation method and drought index will be crucial in the Indian subcontinent for future drought investigations.

    How to cite: Varghese, F. C. and Mitra, S.: Sensitivity of PET estimation methods towards drought characterization under climate change in the Indian subcontinent, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-235, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-235, 2022.

    EGU22-240 | Presentations | HS4.2

    Explaining reported drought impacts in the European Alpine region with selected drought indices 

    Ruth Stephan, Carsten F. Dormann, and Kerstin Stahl

    Even across Europe’s generally water-rich Alpine region the number of reports on negative drought impacts increased recently. The Alpine Drought Impact report Inventory EDIIALPS archives information of more than 3,200 specifically reported impacts with a majority in the last decade underlining the need for region-specific drought monitoring and adaptation strategies. The relation between drought conditions and drought impact occurrence has not been analyzed systematically in this heterogeneous mountain terrain. This study aims to improve such systematic understanding through the analysis of selected drought characteristics and reported impacts. Therefore, we assigned EDIIALPS’ reported impacts as soil-moisture drought impacts (SMD) and hydrological drought impacts (HD) and explored statistically the relation of these two impact groups to the following drought indices: Soil Moisture Anomalies, Standardized Precipitation Index, Standardized Precipitation Evapotranspiration Index, Vegetation Condition Index and Vegetation Health Index. The density of the reported SMD impacts and HD impacts increased clearly, the stronger the index’ value indicates drought conditions - apart from the vegetation indices. However, the correlation tests between reported impacts and indices did not identify explicit linear relations. To capture non-linear effects and differences between reported SMD impacts and HD impacts we applied decision trees using recursive partitioning. This way, we identified the Standardized Precipitation and Evapotranspiration Index to be most important for reported HD impacts and the Soil Moisture Anomalies to be most important for reported SMD impacts. To predict impact occurrence we recommend to model and evaluate a combination of drought indices allowing non-linearities in order to improve drought impact monitoring and early warning.

    How to cite: Stephan, R., Dormann, C. F., and Stahl, K.: Explaining reported drought impacts in the European Alpine region with selected drought indices, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-240, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-240, 2022.

    EGU22-947 | Presentations | HS4.2

    Evaluating probability distribution functions for the Standardized Precipitation Evapotranspiration Index over Ethiopia 

    Estifanos Addisu Yimer, Bert Van Schaeybroeck, Hans Van De Vyver, and Ann Van Griensven

    Drought indices are used to identify and monitor drought events. Standardized precipitation evapotranspiration index (SPEI) is a widely used index based on accumulated water balance. There is, however, no broad consensus on which probability distribution is most appropriate for water balances. We investigate this issue for Ethiopia using 125 meteorological stations spread over the country. Based on long-term series, a selection was made among the generalized extreme value, Pearson type 3, and generalized logistics (Genlog) distributions. Additionally, the effect of using actual instead of potential evapotranspiration and a limited amount of data (10, 15, 20, and 25 years) is explored.

    Genlog is found to be the best distribution for all accumulation periods. Furthermore, there is a considerable difference amongst the SPEI values estimated from the three distributions on the identification of extreme wet or extreme dry periods. Next, there are significant differences between standardized precipitation actual evapotranspiration index (SPAEI) and SPEI, signifying the importance of drought index selection and input data for proper drought monitoring. Finally, time series of 20 or 25 years of data lead to almost similar SPEI values as those estimated using more than 30 years of data so could potentially be used to assess drought in Ethiopia.

    Key words: Drought; SPEI; Candidate distribution; Global datasets; SPAEI; short time series

    How to cite: Yimer, E. A., Van Schaeybroeck, B., Van De Vyver, H., and Van Griensven, A.: Evaluating probability distribution functions for the Standardized Precipitation Evapotranspiration Index over Ethiopia, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-947, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-947, 2022.

    EGU22-1315 | Presentations | HS4.2

    How do we identify flash droughts? Analysis tool and Central European Croplands analysis 

    Pedro Henrique Lima Alencar and Eva Nora Paton

    Flash droughts are often characterized as events of rapid and unusually large depletion of root-zone soil moisture, in comparison to average conditions, caused by climatic compound conditions over short periods (weeks). We compared six flash drought identification methods and analysed their functioning using measured data from FLUXNET2015 stations across Central Europe. All methods were implemented in an R package and are available as a Shiny app for the public, where the user can visualise the different results of flash drought identification for each method. An in-depth analysis and cross-comparison of methods for co- and misidentification for cropland sites showed a large degree of synchronicity among them, although some divergence was detected, related to four intrinsic differences in the underlying flash drought definitions associated to each identification method: (1) type of critical variable, (2) velocity of drought intensification, (3) pre-set threshold values for final depletion, and/or (4) minimum length of the duration of flash droughts. To balance strengths and weaknesses of the individual methods, we suggest the use of an ensemble approach for each event identification. To balance such strengths and weaknesses of the individual methods we propose an ensemble approach for event identification, allowing the detection of the current unclearly defined sub-types of flash droughts, related to the different combinations of compound drivers and differences in intensification dynamics.

    How to cite: Lima Alencar, P. H. and Paton, E. N.: How do we identify flash droughts? Analysis tool and Central European Croplands analysis, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1315, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1315, 2022.

    Solar-induced chlorophyll fluorescence (SIF) from the ground, airborne to satellite-based observations has been increasingly used in drought monitoring recently, due to its close relationship with photosynthesis. SIF emissions do respond rapidly to drought, relative to the wide used vegetation indices (VIs, e.g., Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI)), thus indicating its potential for early drought monitoring. The response of SIF to drought can be attributed to the confounding effects of both physiology and canopy structure. In order to reduce the re-absorption and scattering effects, total emitted SIF (SIFtot) was proposed and served as a better tool to estimate GPP compared with top-of-canopy SIF (SIFtoc) in some studies. However, the response time and response magnitude of SIFtot to drought and its relationships with environmental parameters and soil moisture, that is, the knowledge of drought monitoring using SIFtot remains unclear. Here the continuous ground data of F760toc (SIFtoc at 760 nm) in nadir view that was downscaled to F760tot (SIFtot at 760 nm), surface soil moisture at 20cm soil layer (SM), meteorological and crop growth parameters, were measured from four winter wheat plots with different intensities of drought (well-watered treatment, moderate drought, severe drought and extreme drought) over two months. By analyzing these data, we found that F760tot was indeed more closely related to physiological and was less subjected to canopy structure than that of F760toc, but this relationship was reversed under extreme drought. It was more closely correlated with SM than VIs at short time lags, but weaker at longer time lags. The daily mean values of F760tot were able to distinguish the differences in drought gradients and respond quickly to the onset of drought, especially for the moderate drought, which appears to have the most decrease. These results demonstrate that F760tot has potential for early drought monitoring.

    How to cite: Lin, J., Shen, Q., Wu, J., Liu, L., and Zhao, W.: Assessing the potential of the downscaled far-red solar-induced chlorophyll fluorescence from canopy to leaf level for drought monitoring in winter wheat, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1474, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1474, 2022.

    Drought is a complex and multidimensional phenomenon affecting the global population. The widespread impacts of drought propagate through the climatic and hydrological cycle and affect the socio-economic security of the related stakeholders, especially farmers. Countries like India use several indices to determine the severity of the drought for governmental relief and mitigation measures, which is crucial for farmers facing agricultural stress and failures. However, the use of single or several separate drought indices cannot capture the combined effect of principal drivers responsible for the drought, where the effect of groundwater availability for agriculture is often neglected despite its heavy use in irrigation through groundwater extraction. In this study, we focus on the multidimensional response of drought in a single joint index to better capture the spatiotemporal variability in drought severity. The semi-arid region of Marathwada from central India, which frequently faces drought and is infamous for farmer suicides due to agriculture failures is taken as the study area. The response of hydroclimatic variables viz. precipitation, evapotranspiration, soil moisture, surface runoff, and groundwater storage were captured in their respective standardized indices (SPEI, SSI, SRI, and SGI respectively) which were then used to construct the Joint Drought Index (JDI) using two principal methods: 1) Principal Component Analysis (PCA) and 2) Gaussian copula. Both the methods were found to be capable of identifying the severity of the drought along with its onset, duration, and termination. Although individual indices such as SPI can sometimes acknowledge the meteorological response better, the JDI has the potential of capturing the response of multiple hydrological variables together at once for drought monitoring and assessment. During the period between 2003 to 2020, the drought of 2015 was identified as exceptionally severe in both the methods, where copula could better accommodate the severity of every integrated index whereas PCA averages the response of the variables to drought by allocating the weights to each index for each month.

    How to cite: Katneshwarkar, B. and Kinouchi, T.: Integration of Multiple Drought Indices for Agriculture Drought Categorization and Impact Assessment in Central India, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3286, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3286, 2022.

    EGU22-3365 | Presentations | HS4.2

    Land-atmospheric coupling amplify the flash drought intensity in India 

    Shanti Shwarup Mahto and Vimal Mishra

    Concurrent high temperature and low soil moisture during flash drought (FD) can become significantly hazardous, posing a devastating impact on human health, agriculture, and the ecosystem. Strong land-atmospheric coupling influences the intensity of flash drought events. Despite flash drought having detrimental impacts, the soil moisture (SM)-temperature (T) relationship and their characteristics are poorly understood in a coupled land-atmospheric scenario. Using variables from ERA5 reanalysis, we identify the major flash drought events and evaluate the SM-T coupling in India for the 1980-2019 period. We find that the summer monsoon season experiences most flash drought events during the monsoon breaks. Temperature anomalies and FD intensities remained strongly correlated (r= 0.78 and r= 0.67, respectively) with the SM-T coupling. Central India and Indo-Gangetic Plain experienced higher FD intensity and SM-T coupling compared to other parts of the country. Moreover, the SM-T coupling during flash drought increased by three-fold against the normal condition with an increasing trend over India. The strengthening of SM-T coupling is attributed to the increasing temperature and potential of declining soil moisture to influence the partitioning of the heat budget in the warming climate. Overall, we find that SM-T coupling is a key factor in deciding the intensity of flash drought, which may further increase under the future warming climate. Exacerbated flash drought intensity can severely affect crop production, irrigation demand, and ecological health.

    How to cite: Mahto, S. S. and Mishra, V.: Land-atmospheric coupling amplify the flash drought intensity in India, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3365, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3365, 2022.

    EGU22-4547 | Presentations | HS4.2

    Long-term climatological SM2RAIN dataset for drought monitoring 

    Hamidreza Mosaffa, Paolo Filippucci, Christian Massari, Luca Ciabatta, and Luca Brocca

    Drought is a natural disaster that has serious economic, social and environmental impacts. Drought monitoring is one of the components of drought risk management. The main requirement of drought monitoring is to have a reliable and accurate long-term rainfall dataset. SM2RAIN datasets are among the available rainfall products that estimate rainfall from satellite soil moisture observations. The high performance of SM2RAIN products has been shown in several studies over different regions of the globe. The aims here are as follow: 1) to develop the long-term climatological SM2RAIN datasets that cover the period of 1998-2020 at 0.25° spatial and monthly temporal resolution on the global scale. This dataset is designed by merging two rainfall SM2RAIN products including SM2RAIN-CCI (1998-2015) and SM2RAIN-ASCAT (2007-2020). For this purpose, the quantile mapping method is applied to remove the bias between these two products and match the monthly values. In the QM method, a correction factor is calculated during the overlap period (2007-2015) as a reference period and then applied to for the entire study period, 2) to analyses of drought based on standardized precipitation index on the global scale. In addition, the analysis is compared with drought analysis of other ground observations and reanalysis rainfall products such as the Global Precipitation Climatology Project (GPCP) and ERA5. The results show that the developed SM2RAIN-based rainfall product has the potential to improve global drought monitoring by capturing the drought events accurately.

    How to cite: Mosaffa, H., Filippucci, P., Massari, C., Ciabatta, L., and Brocca, L.: Long-term climatological SM2RAIN dataset for drought monitoring, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4547, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4547, 2022.

    EGU22-4944 | Presentations | HS4.2 | Highlight

    Increasing footprint of climate warming on flash droughts occurrence in Europe 

    Jignesh Shah, Vittal Hari, Oldrich Rakovec, Yannis Markonis, Luis Samaniego, Vimal Mishra, Martin Hanel, Christoph Hinz, and Rohini Kumar

    Flash droughts cause a rapid depletion of soil moisture, which severely affect vegetation growth and agricultural production. Notwithstanding the growing importance of flash droughts under the warming climate, drivers of flash droughts across the Europe are not well understood. Here we estimate the changes in flash droughts characteristics across Europe using the latest release of ERA5 reanalysis for 1950-2019 period. We find a substantial increase in the frequency and spatial extent of flash droughts across Europe (with 76\% of the total area) during the growing season in the recent decades. Increased occurrence of flash drought is largely attributed to frequent occurrence of warmer and drier compound extremes, with a sharp gradient of changes being noticed in Mediterranean and Central European regions. Compound extremes causing the flash drought events across Europe are pre-dominantly driven by the recent climate warming. With unabated greenhouse gas emissions and current pace of climate warming, Europe is likely to face an increased occurrence of flash droughts, requiring prompt response for effective drought adaptation and management strategies.

    How to cite: Shah, J., Hari, V., Rakovec, O., Markonis, Y., Samaniego, L., Mishra, V., Hanel, M., Hinz, C., and Kumar, R.: Increasing footprint of climate warming on flash droughts occurrence in Europe, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4944, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4944, 2022.

    The world is confronted with the increasing threat of food insecurity which is driven by several shocks including droughts, floods, and conflict. The United Nations World Food Programme (WFP) is currently feeding over 95million people around the globe in urgent need of food including those in high emergency countries like Southern Madagascar, Haiti, Afghanistan, Northern Nigeria, South Sudan, Syria, and Yemen. The situation has been worsened by the impacts of COVID - 19 interrelated factors of movement restrictions and reduced economic activity, which together have caused income losses at the household level. Discussions with institutions like the Southern Africa Development Community (SADC), United Nations (UN) partners and respective governments in Southern Africa have clearly shown that the impacts of these shocks are more devastating in countries where early warning systems are weak. Over the years, USAID's Famine Early Warning Systems Network (FEWS NET) has invested in building the capacity of partners and governments to timely identify key shocks that are likely to cause food insecurity in different countries. Using a methodology called scenario development, FEWS NET has been able to develop understanding of the current situation, create informed assumptions about the future, compare their possible effects to food security and the likely responses of various actors. The ability to develop early warning systems helps to estimate future food security outcomes many months in advance, so that decision makers have adequate time to plan for and respond to potential humanitarian crises. This presentation seeks to (i) explore the different methods used to project the likely impacts of shocks on food security in different environments, (ii) highlight the strengths of collaborative partnerships in enhancing early warning systems to promote early action in food security response, and (iii) discuss the use of science products to improve forecasting of future food insecurity outcomes. The use of agrometeorological and remote sensing products including Water Requirement Satisfaction Index (WRSI), Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) and CHIRPS Rainfall Estimates has proved useful in identifying hotspots of drought and have helped to facilitate projections in areas where physical access is impossible due to factors like conflict. Practical examples including those from southern Africa will be used to enrich discussions under this topic.

    How to cite: Kafera, G.: Understanding and mitigating challenges to food security through observations, projections, and early warning and action capabilities, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6356, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6356, 2022.

    EGU22-6492 | Presentations | HS4.2

    Machine learning for discharge prediction in the Alps 

    Marco Mazzolini, Felix Greifeneder, Giacomo Bertoldi, Daniela Quintero, Mattia Callegari, Klaus Haslinger, and Georg Seyerl

    In the context of the Alpine Drought Observatory (ADO) project, a database of discharge measurements with more than 1400 gauging stations on alpine rivers with, on average, 35 years of records was assembled. This wealth of information constitutes an ideal source for data-driven discharge modelling with Machine Learning (ML). Discharge forecasting is relevant for many sectors related to the water cycle, such as agriculture and energy production. Moreover, appropriate river low streamflow prediction can improve preparedness for drought-related risks.

    This paper proposes comparing two ML algorithms for discharge prediction using meteorological reanalysis and modelled snow variables over the gauging stations' catchment area as predictors. The selected meteorological variables are total precipitation, temperature, and potential evapotranspiration. ERA5 reanalysis [1] bias-corrected with quantile mapping and down-scaled to a 5.5 km grid is the source. The last predictor is the snow water equivalent (SWE), obtained with an adaptation of the SNOWGRID model [2]. All the predictors have a daily temporal resolution.

    First, we build on existing work [3] with Support Vector Regression (SVR). The experiments aim at predicting the monthly discharge mean in the present and up to several months of advance. We evaluate the performances of the different approaches, investigate each input variable's importance for several test catchments with different hydrological regimes, and carry out trials with different temporal and spatial aggregations to find the best configuration.

    We evaluate the prediction with the r2 metric. Depending on the size and water management in the studied basin, results range from 0,7 to 0,85 for the present. We also perform the analysis based on discharge anomalies (computed as the deviation from the average discharge for the specific day) to erase the climatology effect. In this case, the r2 metric ranges from 0,5 up to 0,7. For predictions of the future discharge, the model's performance decreases in about one month to the level of climatology. The SWE is a relevant predictor since the performance decrease is slower for larger basins with a nivo-glacial regime.

    The results show the suitability of ML for discharge prediction on different kinds of alpine basins with up to one month of advance. The subsequent development will be to conduct a similar analysis with convolutional neural networks (CNN). This class of deep networks should allow the model to learn the spatial pattern in the input data.

     

    [1] Copernicus Climate Change Service (C3S) (2017): ERA5: Fifth generation of ECMWF atmospheric reanalyses of the global climate. Copernicus Climate Change Service Climate Data Store (CDS), date of access. https://cds.climate.copernicus.eu/cdsapp#!/home

    [2]: Olefs, M.; Koch, R.; Schöner, W.; Marke, T. Changes in Snow Depth, Snow Cover Duration, and Potential Snowmaking Conditions in Austria, 1961–2020—A Model Based Approach. Atmosphere 2020, 11, 1330. https://doi.org/10.3390/atmos11121330

    [3]: De Gregorio, L., Callegari, M., Mazzoli, P. et al. Operational River Discharge Forecasting with Support Vector Regression Technique Applied to Alpine Catchments: Results, Advantages, Limits and Lesson Learned. Water Resour Manage 32, 229–242 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11269-017-1806-3

    How to cite: Mazzolini, M., Greifeneder, F., Bertoldi, G., Quintero, D., Callegari, M., Haslinger, K., and Seyerl, G.: Machine learning for discharge prediction in the Alps, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6492, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6492, 2022.

    Flash drought is a new type of drought with rapid onset, which occurred frequently in recent years over the world. Compared with the traditional drought, the rapid onset makes it difficult to predict in time, and it poses a serious threat to agriculture and ecosystem. However, causes of the rapid onset and underlying mechanisms are still unclear. Considering that the land-atmosphere coupling can regulate the evolution of extreme drought, here we investigate the coupling characteristics during flash droughts over South China, and carry out the attribution by using the latest Coupled Model Intercomparison Project Phase 6 (CMIP6) model simulations. Through the synthetic analysis of flash drought onset, it is found that extreme precipitation deficit and strong evapotranspiration provide favorable conditions for flash drought onset, and the dry coupling between land and atmosphere further aggravates the decline in soil moisture, and increases the onset speed. In addition, with the increase of onset speed, the contribution of evapotranspiration increases accordingly, and the dry coupling between land and atmosphere further dominates the evolution. This suggests that the land-atmosphere coupling plays a key role in increasing the onset speed of flash drought. Furthermore, the impact of climate change on the onset speed of flash drought also can’t be ignored. The results of detect and attribution show that anthropogenic climate change (caused by the emissions of greenhouse gases and aerosols, etc) has increased the likelihood of flash drought onset speed over South China in 2019 by 24±16%, which is closely related to anthropogenically increased evapotranspiration.

    How to cite: Wang, Y. and Yuan, X.: Land-atmosphere coupling speeds up flash drought over South China in a changing climate, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6639, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6639, 2022.

    EGU22-6687 | Presentations | HS4.2

    The timing of unprecedented hydrological drought under climate change 

    Yusuke Satoh, Kei Yoshimura, Yadu Pokhrel, Hyungjun Kim, Hideo Shiogama, Tokuta Yokohata, Naota Hanasaki, Yoshihide Wada, Peter Burek, Edward Byers, Hannes Müller Schmied, Dieter Garten, Sebastian Ostberg, Simon Gosling, Julien Boulange, and Taikan Oki

    Droughts that exceed the magnitudes of historical variation ranges could occur increasingly frequently under future climate conditions. However, the time of the emergence of unprecedented drought conditions under climate change has rarely been examined. Here, using multimodel hydrological simulations, we investigate the changes in the frequency of hydrological drought (defined as abnormally low river discharge) under high and low greenhouse gas concentration scenarios and existing water resource management measures and estimate the timing of the first emergence of unprecedented regional drought conditions. When investigating 59 subcontinental-scale regions, the times are detected for 11 and 18 regions under low and high greenhouse gas concentration scenarios, respectively. Three regions (Southwestern South America, Mediterranean Europe, and Northern Africa) exhibit particularly robust and early timings under the high-emission scenario. These three regions are likely to confront unprecedented conditions within the next 30 years with a high likelihood regardless of the emission scenarios. Additionally, the results obtained herein demonstrate the benefits of the lower-emission pathway in reducing the likelihood of emergence. The Paris Agreement goals are shown to be effective in reducing the likelihood to the unlikely level in most regions. However, appropriate and prior adaptation measures are considered indispensable when facing unprecedented drought conditions. The results of this study underscore the importance of improving drought preparedness within the considered time horizons.

    How to cite: Satoh, Y., Yoshimura, K., Pokhrel, Y., Kim, H., Shiogama, H., Yokohata, T., Hanasaki, N., Wada, Y., Burek, P., Byers, E., Müller Schmied, H., Garten, D., Ostberg, S., Gosling, S., Boulange, J., and Oki, T.: The timing of unprecedented hydrological drought under climate change, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6687, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6687, 2022.

    EGU22-7613 | Presentations | HS4.2

    Global intensification of flash droughts in the past and future 

    Xing Yuan and Yumiao Wang

    Flash droughts have raised a wide concern in recent years. Besides many regional analyses, global distributions of flash droughts have been discussed in a few studies. With certain differences due to different drought indices or datasets, a few hotspots consistently show increasing flash droughts among studies. However, to date, there is no global picture on whether flash droughts have been intensified, or whether the intensification will continue into the future. Here we propose a method to quantify the intensification of global flash droughts, and investigate the historical trends (trends in the past 60 years) by using global reanalysis data and CMIP6 climate models with or without human-induced climate change. The human fingerprint can be identified for the global trends, which suggests the important role of anthropogenic intensification of global flash droughts in the past. Moreover, future projection of flash drought is also carried out over IPCC SREX regions by using CMIP6 future scenarios. The results show that intensification of flash droughts is projected to continue across most regions, with larger increase under higher emission scenarios. This raises an urgent need to adapt to the intensifying flash droughts in the future.

    How to cite: Yuan, X. and Wang, Y.: Global intensification of flash droughts in the past and future, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7613, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7613, 2022.

    EGU22-8811 | Presentations | HS4.2

    Avoiding Day Zero water crisis management La Paz 

    Harm Nomden, Michel Riemersma, Adrian Zamora, Hidde Kats, Ric Huting, Wouter Engel, and Tomas Quisbert

    Bolivia, November 2016: the reservoirs high in the mountains around the city of La Paz completely dried out after an dry year, limiting the supply of (drinking) water to the city. Heavy rationing had to take place over a period of 6 weeks, resulting in social unrest. 

    The drinking water company EPSAS is responsible for the water supply to the city and region. Over the period 2016-2030, the number of inhabitants will grow from 1.6 to 2.1 million and the water demand increases with 58% while raw water resources are limited and further constrained (climate change and loss of glaciers). To cope with these conditions, the supply infrastructure will double in size: from 3 to 6 treatment plants and from 14 to 26 reservoirs spread over 9 catchments. Total water storage capacity doubles from 54 hm3 to 110 hm3. Additional stream intakes are constructed to extract water, water can even be pumped over the mountains in dry periods. Water is transported from the reservoirs to plants via pipe lines, channels and free flowing streams.

    A continuously changing and expanding reservoir network, signifies an increase in complexity, more choices to be made on a daily and weekly basis by the operational staff, influencing (forecasted) water availability. Since 2016 Royal HaskoningDHV and EPSAS have been working together to develop a Monitoring & Decision Support System which is able to monitor the water availability and the status of the catchments, generate hydrological forecasts and optimize (future) use of available raw water resources.

    This is done by:

    • installing a system of 40-60 monitoring stations at all dams and upstream in all catchments - monitoring water levels, discharges, extraction volumes and meteorological variables. New to be constructed telemetry stations will send all data to the control room;
    • developing an operational software system to translate measured variables into water volumes and other indicators; to generate hydrological run-off forecasts using advanced hydrological models; to optimize the distribution of water over the reservoirs and the use of water; and forecast resulting water availability and shortages over the coming 18 months. The system generates forecasts and advices on a daily or weekly basis, as defined by the user.

    How to cite: Nomden, H., Riemersma, M., Zamora, A., Kats, H., Huting, R., Engel, W., and Quisbert, T.: Avoiding Day Zero water crisis management La Paz, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8811, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8811, 2022.

    EGU22-8967 | Presentations | HS4.2

    Aquifer Response Lag to Meteorological Droughts from GRACE Satellites 

    Brielle Paladino, Racha El Kadiri, and Henrique Momm

    Climate change increases the probability of drought occurrence in many parts of the United States and worldwide. Aquifer response to these drought events vary in space and time. This project seeks to understand the response of aquifers to drought events by quantifying the lag time between meteorological droughts and groundwater droughts using the Standardized Precipitation and Evapotranspiration Index (SPEI) and Gravity Recovery and Climate Experiment (GRACE) derived groundwater storage anomalies. Ten major aquifer systems in the continental United States were selected for analysis: Columbia Plateau, Arizona Alluvial, Snake River Basin, Upper Colorado, Pennsylvanian, Mississippi Embayment, Texas Gulf Coast, Edwards-Trinity Plateau, Floridian, Central California, and the High Plains Aquifer Systems. Groundwater storage anomaly data was derived from GRACE total water storage anomaly data by removing all other hydrologic components using the Global Land Data Assimilation System’s (GLDAS) Community Land Surface Model (CLM) of 1.0-degree spatial resolution monthly datasets. Timeseries on monthly intervals for both the derived groundwater storage and SPEI were created for the period of April 2002 to June 2021. Each selected aquifer system had a meteorological drought occur at least three times during the study period, with a maximum occurrence of fifteen in central California. There is a temporal gap in between the original GRACE mission and the launch of GRACE-Follow on (GRACE-FO) from June 2017 to June 2018, five of the ten selected aquifers had meteorological droughts occur in this gap, which have been excluded. Preliminary results indicate that the lag time between the start of the two types of droughts for these aquifer systems is between zero and one month, while the lag time between the end of these types of droughts is more widely varied, between zero and eight months. As these results are varied, contextualizing them with more in-depth looks at the aquifer system characteristics is important and is the next step in furthering our understanding of aquifer responses to the increasing number of probable drought events.

    How to cite: Paladino, B., El Kadiri, R., and Momm, H.: Aquifer Response Lag to Meteorological Droughts from GRACE Satellites, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8967, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8967, 2022.

    EGU22-9418 | Presentations | HS4.2

    Underestimated increase in duration of annual meteorological drought in future climate projections 

    Irina Yu. Petrova, Diego G. Miralles, Florent Brient, Markus Donat, Yeon-Hee Kim, and Seung-Ki Min

    The increasing risk of dry extremes and droughts and their further projected exacerbation due to climate change urges the development of reliable risk assessments and mitigation pathways on a regional and global scale. This foremost requires accurate and unambiguous model predictions of dry extremes, as this underpins the effectiveness of the proposed strategies. At present, however, the confidence in regional drought projections is defined as ‘medium to low' by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) sixth assessment report (AR6), and reducing this uncertainty remains one of the main goals in coming years.
    In this study, the bias in future projected changes in annual meteorological drought duration (hereafter, longest annual drought, LAD) is assessed in the ensemble of CMIP5 and CMIP6 models. The analyses show that it is the present-day inter-model spread in LAD climatology that largely determines the inter-model uncertainty in future predicted LAD changes. Hereby, both CMIP5 and CMIP6 model ensembles indicate a robust “dry-model-gets-drier” relationship in future LAD projections on a global and regional scale. Correcting for this bias using emerging constraint principles and past observational LAD information, we find that nearly half of the world's land area with projected increases in drought duration is underestimating the predicted model ensemble mean change, imposing higher-than-expected risks to the societies and ecosystems. Analysis of physical mechanisms that could underlie this emergent “present-future relationship” points to differences in the responses of “dry models” and “wet models” to CO2 forcing. Dry and wet models show differences in climate states, which support the role of land–atmosphere feedbacks and convective scheme sensitivity to atmospheric moisture in the spread of future LAD change projections.
    In conclusion, the study reveals world regions where climate change may cause stronger drought duration aggravation than expected, and emphasizes the importance of reducing systematic model errors, which are presently largely owed to rainfall biases. Correcting these biases will increase the confidence of future dry extremes predictions, a prerequisite for the effective drought risk reduction in the near future with direct benefits for human and natural systems.

    How to cite: Yu. Petrova, I., G. Miralles, D., Brient, F., Donat, M., Kim, Y.-H., and Min, S.-K.: Underestimated increase in duration of annual meteorological drought in future climate projections, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9418, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9418, 2022.

    EGU22-9827 | Presentations | HS4.2

    Assessing drought vulnerability of maize production in the Po Valley 

    Beatrice Monteleone, Iolanda Borzì, Brunella Bonaccorso, and Mario Martina

    Drought affects a wide range of economic activities, with agriculture as the worst affected sector by the consequences of such an extreme in many regions of the world. Past studies showed that droughts and heat waves are the weather extremes that significantly reduce cereal production at global level, while there is no evidence on the influence of floods and extreme cold on cereal yields. The projected increase in the severity and frequency of droughts can lead to water scarcity situations in regions that are already water-stressed and to overexploitation of available water resources in other areas.

    The way regulators and farmers manage water resources during droughts has effects on agricultural resilience and the increased frequency of drought and water scarcity will require more collaborative partnership-based approaches to water resources and drought management in the next future. The development of quantitative models to establish relationships between water scarcity and crop yield losses can help in understanding in which situations farmers need access to water to avoid high losses.

    This study develops crop specific vulnerability curves that establish a relationship between water deficit and yield losses during various crop growth stages (vegetative, flowering and yield formation) and can thus provide useful indication on how to allocate water resources to avoid irreparable yield losses. The case study region is the Po river basin (Northern Italy).

    The Po river basin is the largest Italian agricultural area and accounts for 35% of the country’s agricultural production. The basin is characterized by the presence of big cities and wide rural zones. Over the past years the it has been hit by multiple droughts. Ten cities were considered in the analysis, based on maize yield data provided by the Italian National Institute for Statistics (ISTAT).

    At first the Agricultural Production System sIMulator (APSIM) crop model was used to simulate maize growth. The model was calibrated and validated over the ten provinces based on ISTAT data. An R² of 0.75 was found for both the steps.

    The yield in the absence of any water stress during the entire growing season was computed as the reference yield. Then, the reduced yield for the same season was derived introducing a water stress in a single growth stage by progressively reducing the precipitation amount during that growth stage. The yield reduction was expressed as one minus the ratio between the reduced yield and the reference yield.

    The water deficit for each season and each growth stage was derived from APSIM. The relationship between yield reduction and water deficit was plotted to derive the vulnerability curves and data points were fitted to appropriate functions.

    In the case of maize, flowering was found to be the most sensitive stage to water deficit, followed by yield formation and vegetative. During the establishment phase the crop never went under water stress in the considered area. Soil texture has also proven to play a role on the response of the crop to the water deficit, particularly in the flowering and yield formation stages.

    How to cite: Monteleone, B., Borzì, I., Bonaccorso, B., and Martina, M.: Assessing drought vulnerability of maize production in the Po Valley, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9827, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9827, 2022.

    EGU22-9914 | Presentations | HS4.2

    Analysis of high-resolution decadal prediction of drought events in the Department of Chocó-Colombia 

    Yenny Marcela Toro Ortiz, Sonia Raquel Gámiz Fortis, Yolanda Castro Díez, Reiner Palomino Lemus, María Jesús Esteban Parra, and Samir Córdoba Machado

    Agriculture and livestock represent 21% of the economic sector of the Department of Chocó (Colombia), being drought and flood events one of the main difficulties. Although this Department has the largest records of annual precipitation, in some seasons with scarce precipitation, it shows great drought problems and crop deterioration.

    Consequently, several institutes use short-term decadal climate simulations using general circulation models (GCM), which consider climate warming as well as the predictable climate signal associated with the initial climate conditions to inform water resource managers.

    This work analyzes the potential use of the decadal predictions of precipitation from the Japanese model BCC-CSM2-MR to predict of drought events in the Department of Chocó through the analysis of the hindcasts in the period 1960-2018. The choice of this model is based on its suitability to reproduce the main patterns of climate variability that affect the study area. Drought events will be characterized by the Standardized Index of Precipitation (SPI) on different time scales.

    Since the resolution of this GCM is very vast and does not allow to solve regionalized characteristics, such as topographic factors, land-sea distribution, or vegetation types, etc., a statistical downscaling of the decadal hindcasts for precipitation will be carried out from which the SPI will be calculated. These results will be compared with those obtained from the observational database "Global Precipitation Climatology Centre (GPCC)”.

    Keywords: drought, Colombia, SPI, decadal predictions, GCM, statistical downscaling.

    Acknowledgments: Y.M. Toro-Ortiz acknowledges the Colombian Ministry of Science, Technology, and Innovation for the predoctoral fellowship (grant code: 860). This research was funded by the Spanish Ministry of Economy and Competitiveness project CGL2017-89836-390R, with additional support from FEDER Funds, by FEDER/Junta de Andalucía-Consejería de Economía y Conocimiento, project B-RNM-336-UGR18, and by FEDER/Junta de Andalucía-Consejería de Transformación Económica, Industria, Conocimiento y Universidades (project P20_00035).

    How to cite: Toro Ortiz, Y. M., Gámiz Fortis, S. R., Castro Díez, Y., Palomino Lemus, R., Esteban Parra, M. J., and Córdoba Machado, S.: Analysis of high-resolution decadal prediction of drought events in the Department of Chocó-Colombia, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9914, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9914, 2022.

    EGU22-10481 | Presentations | HS4.2 | Highlight

    Improving early warning of droughts near onset and middle of a growing season 

    Shraddhanand Shukla, William Turner, Greg Husak, Daniel McEvoy, Seydou Tinni, Adoum Alkhalil, Abdou Ali, Bako Mamne, Ibrah Sanda, Kathryn Grace, Emil Cherrington, and Rebekke Muench

    Early warning of drought is crucial for mitigation of the most adverse impacts of water and food insecurity to lives and livelihoods. Recent advances in routine production (i.e., weekly) and open access to NMME SubX—subseasonal climate forecasts—provide an unprecedented opportunity to improve drought early warning near the onset and middle of the crop-growing season. Near the onset of a season, subseasonal precipitation forecasts have the potential to provide early indication of delay in rain onset, which, as shown in a recent study (Shukla et al., 2021, PLOS ONE), can be a reliable indicator of agricultural drought development. This is particularly relevant for some of the most food-insecure regions in East Africa. Additionally, subseasonal forecasts have the potential to improve drought forecasting during the middle of the season—several months before the harvests—when they are used in combination with to-date observations. Integration of near-real-time observations with subseasonal climate forecasts can enhance drought detection capabilities by leveraging the skill that is derived from initial conditions (as of middle of the season) and complementing it with the skill of subseasonal climate forecasts. Here, we first describe how onset of the rainy season is a reliable indicator of agricultural droughts. The results indicate that in the administrative units in sub-Saharan Africa, which  have the highest risk of acute food insecurity, a delay of about 20 days in the rainy season onset can double the probability of agricultural droughts. We then describe the results of an analysis examining the performance of subseasonal climate forecasts in identifying the timing of the onset of the rainy season in those administrative units. Next, we describe a SERVIR-AST-supported project, which uses subseasonal climate forecasts to develop a West Africa-focused water-deficit forecasting system in collaboration with AGRHYMET, primarily  for agropastoral usage. Here, we make  use of a widely used crop water balance model, the Water Requirement Satisfaction Index (WRSI), to generate improved forecasts of crop water stress, and hence, crop production outcomes, during the middle of the rainy season in West Africa (June through September). We compare the performance of these forecasts with the forecasts generated using climatology only. Finally, we briefly describe how these subseasonal climate forecasting products are being disseminated, communicated, and used in the focus regions.

    How to cite: Shukla, S., Turner, W., Husak, G., McEvoy, D., Tinni, S., Alkhalil, A., Ali, A., Mamne, B., Sanda, I., Grace, K., Cherrington, E., and Muench, R.: Improving early warning of droughts near onset and middle of a growing season, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10481, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10481, 2022.

    EGU22-10806 | Presentations | HS4.2

    Operational Framework for Near-real Time Daily Drought Monitoring Using Global Remotely Sensed Precipitation Products and In-situ Datasets 

    Olivier Prat, David Coates, Ronald Leeper, Brian Nelson, Rocky Bilotta, Steve Ansari, and George Huffman

    We present an operational near-real time drought monitoring framework on a global scale that uses quantitative precipitation estimates (QPEs) from gridded Satellite Precipitation Products (CMORPH-CDR, IMERG) and in-situ datasets (NClimGrid). The Standardized Precipitation Index (SPI) is computed daily for various time scales from the reprocessed, bias-corrected CMORPH-CDR. The near-real time availability of CMORPH-CDR permits for a daily update of global drought conditions starting in 1998. It provides a global daily SPI at a 0.25x0.25 degree spatial resolution. The global SPI is publicly available via the Global Drought Information System (GDIS) dashboard. The GDIS website includes an interactive map hosted within the NOAA GeoPlatform (ArcGIS Online). It provides 45 layers of drought indices and indicators in addition to the global daily CMORPH SPI (https://gdis-noaa.hub.arcgis.com/pages/drought-monitoring).

    The pipeline assembled to produce CMORPH-SPI is extended to IMERG (Integrated Multi-satellitE Retrievals for GPM) to generate a daily global IMERG-SPI at a higher spatial resolution (0.1x0.1deg) from 2000 to the present. The 6-fold increase in spatial resolution comes at a higher computational cost which is alleviated by accessing cloud-scale computing resources such as Microsoft Planetary Computer and Azure that allows to optimize the process and reduce considerably the computation time. Similarly, we use the high resolution gridded in-situ precipitation dataset NClimGrid to generate a daily high resolution NClimGrid-SPI over CONUS (5x5-km). Because of NClimGrid longer period of record, it allows accessing daily drought conditions from 1950 up to the present day.

    Comparisons between the generated SPIs (CMORPH-SPI, IMERG-SPI, NClimGrid-SPI) are conducted with a focus on the influence of the different resolutions, sensors characteristics, and SPI formulations (two parameter Gamma distribution: McKee et al. 1993; three parameter Pearson III distribution: Guttman 1999). When possible, an evaluation of the remotely sensed and in-situ SPIs is performed against existing droughts monitoring tools such as the US Drought Monitor (USDM). Finally, we present the results of the implementation of a drought relief module that quantifies the precipitation amount that would be needed (i.e. rainfall deficit) for drought relief as a function of the accumulation period considered.

    How to cite: Prat, O., Coates, D., Leeper, R., Nelson, B., Bilotta, R., Ansari, S., and Huffman, G.: Operational Framework for Near-real Time Daily Drought Monitoring Using Global Remotely Sensed Precipitation Products and In-situ Datasets, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10806, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10806, 2022.

    EGU22-10927 | Presentations | HS4.2

    Hydrological response to meteorological drought in Chirchik river basin of Western Tian-Shan 

    Gulomjon Umirzakov, Renji Remesan, Komiljon Rakhmonov, Sanskriti Mujumdar, and Nurmukhammad Omonov

    This study investigated the link between meteorological and hydrological droughts in two rivers with and without glaciers in Сhirchik river basin of Western Tian Shan. Observed monthly hydrometeorological data was used to estimate Standardized Precipitation Indexes (SPI) and Standardized Streamflow Indexes (SSI) to analyze the hydrological response of snow-glacier fed Pskem and snow-rain fed Ugam rivers in the region. The Pearson correlation coefficient has been used to estimate statistical relations between SPI and SSI indices for the selected rivers. The SPI-SSI correlation coefficient has shown a positive trend with an increase in timescales, and it was more evident in indexes between the 6-month to 12-month  timescales in both rivers. The statistical relationships between the meteorological and hydrological drought indexes showed that the SPI-SSI relationship varies with river flow generation and its dynamics, and it was more in the Ugam River than the Pskem River. That indicates snow-dominated Ugam River is more prone to meteorological droughts, whereas the glaciers in the Pskem River basin were buffering hydrological drought and its frequency and severity. Obtained results allow better-informed forecasting of hydrological droughts in the river basin and, consequently, enable efficient water management in agricultural and hydropower sectors.

    How to cite: Umirzakov, G., Remesan, R., Rakhmonov, K., Mujumdar, S., and Omonov, N.: Hydrological response to meteorological drought in Chirchik river basin of Western Tian-Shan, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10927, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10927, 2022.

    EGU22-11147 | Presentations | HS4.2

    Sub-seasonal to climatic hydrologic predictions for sustainable reservoir management in water-stressed Mediterranean basins 

    Aristeidis Koutroulis, Manolis Grillakis, Nicola Crippa, Guang Yang, and Matteo Giuliani

    Given the specific nature of the Mediterranean region, water scarcity and documented progressive degradation of groundwater quality poses hazardous environmental, economic and social threats to several Mediterranean countries, with a significantly increased risk of conflicts around the limited availability of water resources. These risks are expected to be further exaggerated with the projected climate drying. Due to continued changes in drivers and pressures, traditional management practices alone are no longer sufficient.

    Recent advances in weather and climate modeling research are putting into practice hydroclimatic projections of timescales ranging from sub-seasonal to climatic. Seasonal forecasts can be used for triggering a variety of water management strategies, as for example activating early responses and decisions in order to make water systems more adaptive and resilient to the increasing variability and uncertainty of hydrologic regimes, ultimately facilitating the reduction of drought related risks.

    In the premises of the STREAM project, we use projections at the climate timescale to estimate the long-term trends and the changes in the temporal and quantitative variability of the hydrologic conditions in the basin of the Faneromeni reservoir under two concentration scenarios, the RCP 4.5 and RCP 8.5. The reservoir is located in Messara valley in Crete Island, Greece, an area highly water overexploited during the recent decades. We further use several seasonal forecast products provided under the umbrella of the Copernicus C3S programme, for a range of lead time horizons. Scenarios of water inflow and evaporation losses are used to inform the multi-objective operation design for the investigation of the impacts of alternative management policies. Our results are expected to improve the current practices used by the local practitioners for the management of water resources for sustainable water exploitation.

     

    This work is supported by the STREAM project funded by the Prince Albert II of Monaco Foundation, grant number 2981 (www.streamflows.eu).

    How to cite: Koutroulis, A., Grillakis, M., Crippa, N., Yang, G., and Giuliani, M.: Sub-seasonal to climatic hydrologic predictions for sustainable reservoir management in water-stressed Mediterranean basins, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11147, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11147, 2022.

    EGU22-11509 | Presentations | HS4.2

    A spatiotemporal deep learning forecasting model for long-term drought prediction 

    Athanasios Loukas and Lampros Vasiliades

    Droughts are slow-moving natural hazards that comes with high hazardous impacts on the society. Early and timelines forecasting of a drought event can help to take proactive measures and set out drought mitigation strategies to alleviate the impacts of drought. Traditionally, forecasting techniques have used various time-series and/or machine learning methods. However, the use of deep learning methods has not been tested extensively despite its potential to improve our understanding of drought characteristics. This study develops a hybrid spatiotemporal scheme for integrated spatial and temporal forecasting. Temporal forecasting is achieved using a deep feed-forward neural network (DFFN and the temporal forecasts are extended to the spatial dimension using a deep learning approach the Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM) to forecast an operational meteorological drought index the Standardized Precipitation Index (SPI) calculated at multiple timescales. The temporal input variable determination is achieved with the use of the Gamma test that estimates the minimum mean square error (MSE) that can be achieved when modelling the unseen data using any continuous non-linear models. 48 precipitation stations and 18 independent precipitation stations, located at Pinios river basin in Thessaly region, Greece, are used for the development and spatiotemporal validation of the hybrid deep learning forecasting model. Several drought characteristics (drought severity and duration, drought category and spatial extent) are analysed to better understand how drought forecasting was improved. Several quantitative temporal and spatial statistical indices are considered for the performance evaluation of the models. Furthermore, qualitative statistical criteria based on contingency tables between observed and forecasted drought episodes are calculated. The results show that the lead time of forecasting for operational use depends on the SPI timescale. The hybrid spatiotemporal deep learning forecasting model could be operationally used for predicting up to three months ahead for SPI short timescales (e.g. 3-6 months) up to six months ahead for large SPI timescales (e.g. 12-24 months). The above findings could be useful in developing a drought preparedness plan in the region and for drought mitigation purposes.

     

    Key words: deep learning, drought, Standardized Precipitation Index, drought forecasting, spatiotemporal droughts, DFNN, LSTM.

    How to cite: Loukas, A. and Vasiliades, L.: A spatiotemporal deep learning forecasting model for long-term drought prediction, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11509, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11509, 2022.

    EGU22-11590 | Presentations | HS4.2 | Highlight

    Forecasting a proxy of humanitarian drought impact with machine learning using meteorological predictors; a case study for Zimbabwe 

    Marijke Panis, Phuoc Phùng, Bouke Pieter Ottow, and Aklilu Teklesadik

    The impacts of drought are complex due to the multidimensionality (intensity, duration, and extent) and slow-onset nature of droughts. To be able to forecast the impact of droughts, one needs to prioritize and disentangle the diversity of impacts. In Zimbabwe, our country of interest, the Zimbabwe Red Cross Society prioritized crop loss, livestock loss, child malnutrition, and stunting. However, no high-quality data with national spatial coverage on these impacts is available. Therefore, it is necessary to use a proxy indicator for these impacts (or one of these impacts). As Zimbabwe is strongly dependent on rainfed- agriculture for its livelihood, our assumption is that a crop yield anomaly can be used as a proxy for crop loss impact. A negative crop yield anomaly derived from global historical yield series was used to determine the drought status (yes or no impact) in April and forms the target or predictand. The meteorological indicators to predict the crop yield are the observed 3-month-averaged El Niño–Southern Oscillation (ENSO) and the observed monthly rainfall from CHIRPS for each lead time. Also, a combination of monthly rainfall and ENSO was used as predictor. Our forecasting ML classification model, XGBoost, is run at lead times of one to seven months and at the livelihood zone/agro-climatic zone level. The entire dataset for 1983-2015 is divided into train (80%), test, and validation sets. Statistical performance is measured with the Probability of Detection and False Alarm Ratio of both the test and validation set. Our findings show the potential of ENSO-based data in forecasting our proxy for drought impact over various lead times. The addition of rainfall does not improve forecast skill. Future research will investigate if additional meteorological- and biophysical predictors such as soil moisture and Vegetation Condition Index improve the forecast skill. Our IBF Trigger Model for drought is currently a sequence of automated tasks that feed into an IBF-Portal with comprehensive visualizations for decision-makers. Both the development of the trigger model and the portal result from close collaborations and co-designs with the Zimbabwe Red Cross Society and its in-country partners.

    How to cite: Panis, M., Phùng, P., Ottow, B. P., and Teklesadik, A.: Forecasting a proxy of humanitarian drought impact with machine learning using meteorological predictors; a case study for Zimbabwe, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11590, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11590, 2022.

    EGU22-12413 | Presentations | HS4.2

    Integrated irrigation and drainage approach to overcome summer droughts in Nordic conditions 

    Kedar Ghag, Amirhossein Ahrari, Syed Mustafa, Anandharuban Panchanathan, Toni Liedes, Björn Klöve, and Ali Torabi Haghighi

    Globally, the hydro-climatological parameters such as precipitation, temperature, and soil moisture are getting more uncertain and varying regionally as well as seasonally with the changing climate. The Nordic region and the regional agriculture are no exception to this. Recent global studies have projected the increasing trend of precipitation during winter and autumn in Northern Europe. Whereas, the declining trend during spring and summer. The studies further lead to the resulting decline in mean soil moisture that consequently will increase the potential for agricultural drought. Additionally, the summer droughts are already getting highlighted locally as the agriculture in the region experiencing substantial yield losses besides excessive rainfall as a common issue. Therefore, supplemental irrigation, and controlled drainage during water-sensitive growth stages of crops, or crop selection could be potential alternatives and need further investigation. In this study, we present an integrated irrigation and drainage approach (IIDA) based on Water Balance Simulation (WBS) to reduce the negative impact of summer droughts in Nordic agriculture. A WBS is developed in the present study for potato crop fields in Tyrnävä municipal area of Finland to examine the required irrigation or drainage during the cropping season. The model considers precipitation, temperature, and soil water-holding properties as inputs to simulate daily water availability in the crop root zone and provide output as the required amount of either irrigation or drainage or a combination of both for the cropping season from 2000 to 2020. The results showed that around 20% of the mentioned period (2003, 2006, 2018, and 2019), the potato fields required supplemental irrigation between 12-120 mm during the entire season. Furthermore, except for 2009 and 2018, an annual average of 44 mm of drainage was required due to extreme rainfall events. The findings of the study will benefit to increasing the sustainability of agricultural yield in the Nordic region by reducing the negative impact of summer droughts.

    How to cite: Ghag, K., Ahrari, A., Mustafa, S., Panchanathan, A., Liedes, T., Klöve, B., and Torabi Haghighi, A.: Integrated irrigation and drainage approach to overcome summer droughts in Nordic conditions, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12413, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12413, 2022.

    EGU22-12562 | Presentations | HS4.2

    Hydrological modeling and water budget quantification of the Po river basin through the GEOframe system 

    Gaia Roati, Giuseppe Formetta, Silvano Pecora, Marco Brian, Riccardo Rigon, and Hervè Stevenin

    Hydrological extremes, such as floods or droughts, cause significant social and economic damages, posing risks to lives worldwide. Quantifying the spatially variability of water availability across the entire river basin is, thus, deemed important for preparedness to the intensification of such hydro-extremes.

    In 2021, the Po River District Authority (AdbPo) undertook the implementation of this modelling system on the whole territory of the district in accordance with the GCU-M (Gruppo di Coordinamento Unificato-Magre) to update the existing numerical modelling for water resource management. This development is part of the research project “Data and models integrated system for the water resources management and the Po River basin district planning” which supports the use of innovative modelling tools and strengthen studies, research, monitoring and simulations of the main hydrological variables characterizing the territory of the Po River District. To reach this goal the GEOframe system has been adopted. This is an open source, hydrological modelling system developed by a technical and scientific international community, leaded by the University of Trento and already used at operational level, including the Civil Protection Agency of the Basilicata Region.

    In particular, in this framework the action plan of the Po River District Authority aims to:

    • deploy the GEOframe system over all the catchments in its territory (covering Valle d’Aosta, Piemonte, Lombardia, Emilia-Romagna, Veneto and Marche regions), capable to account for the major lakes and reservoirs;
    • calibrate and verify the results obtained by the hydrological and hydraulic models against measured discharges and water levels across the whole area;
    • interface the GEOframe system with the Deltares-DEWS system;
    • analyse the water resources management impacts resulting from climate change or land use changes scenarios.

    The implementation has begun on the Valle d’Aosta Region since it is in the most upstream part of the district, which makes this region a good starting point for the initial calibration of the model and the assessment of all the single components (e.g. energy balance, evapotranspiration, snow melting and river discharge components).

    The activity is being carried out according to different phases:

    • data collection, validation, and preliminary elaboration;
    • geomorphological analysis;
    • spatial interpolation of the meteorological data (mainly temperature and precipitation) through the krigings components;
    • multi-site calibration of the snow melting and rainfall-runoff model parameters;
    • validation of the model results against measured data.

    Additionally, the calibration phase is essential to test the effectiveness of the model in simulating the components of the hydrological cycle, such us river discharge, evapotranspiration and snow water equivalent and, therefore, to determine the possible identification of drought periods in real-time forecast and long-term prediction, including climate change impacts.

    In this work, the initial results achieved in the Valle d’Aosta region will be presented and a detailed analysis on the GEOframe elaboration of information is provided, with a focus on the high flexibility and modularity of the system. The results from a first comparison against river discharge and snow evolution measured in multiple points of the Valle D’Aosta are promising and encouraging.

    How to cite: Roati, G., Formetta, G., Pecora, S., Brian, M., Rigon, R., and Stevenin, H.: Hydrological modeling and water budget quantification of the Po river basin through the GEOframe system, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12562, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12562, 2022.

    EGU22-12797 | Presentations | HS4.2

    Flash droughts early warning based on evaporative stress forecasts 

    Qiqi Gou, Akash koppa, Hylke E. Beck, Petra Hulsman, and Diego G. Miralles

    Flash droughts are regional phenomena that can manifest in region areas with a rapid intensification, and that often last for short periods of time. Flash droughts have received considerable scientific attention in recent years. However, their prediction is still a challenge, largely due to their abrupt onset and often unknown regional drivers. Here, we establish a forecast system to predict flash droughts at a medium-range weather scale. The system uses forcing data from the Multi-Source Weather (MSWX), an operational, high-resolution (3‑hourly, 0.1°), bias-corrected meteorological product with global coverage from 1979 to several months into the future (Beck et al. 2021). MSWX data are used as input to the Global Land Evaporation Amsterdam Model (GLEAM), more specifically its recent hybrid version (Koppa et al., 2021). This allows us to compute forecasts of actual and potential evaporation;  the ratio of both (also know as 'evaporative stress') is used here as flash drought diagnostic. This forecast system is evaluated on its ability to predict flash droughts globally and 2, 4, 7 and 10 days advance. The new tool shows potential to improve our understanding of flash droughts, and it serves as an early prediction system to enable more efficient agricultural and water management.

     

    References:

    Beck, H. E., Wood, E. F., Pan, M., Fisher, C. K., Miralles, D. M., van Dijk, A. I. J. M., McVicar, T. R., and Adler, R. F., MSWEP V2 global 3‑hourly 0.1° precipitation: methodology and quantitative assessment. Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society. 100(3), 473–500, 2019

    Koppa, A., Rains, D., Hulsman, P., and Miralles, D. M., A Deep Learning-Based Hybrid Model of Global Terrestrial Evaporation. Preprint. 2021. 10.21203/rs.3.rs-827869

    How to cite: Gou, Q., koppa, A., E. Beck, H., Hulsman, P., and G. Miralles, D.: Flash droughts early warning based on evaporative stress forecasts, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12797, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12797, 2022.

    EGU22-12814 | Presentations | HS4.2

    Understanding the Drought Situation in a Water-Stressed Region of India 

    Ashutosh Pati, Smaranika Mahapatra, and Pawan Wable

    The onset of drought is very crucial from an agricultural as well as water management point of view in a catchment. A meteorological drought results from a lack of rainfall beyond a certain threshold and is translated to a hydrological drought when the water bodies get affected due to lack of flow to them resulting in storage depletion. This further transforms into agricultural drought when it affects agriculture. Being difficult to observe on-ground, the drought is generally represented in terms of different hydro-meteorological proxies such as precipitation, temperature, soil moisture, streamflow. This study explored the translation of meteorological drought to vegetation in a drought-prone state of India. For this, the vegetation condition index (VCI) and the widely used Standardized Precipitation Index (SPI) were estimated at the district scale. The VCI was calculated from the MODIS-derived NDVI in Google Earth Engine platform. The in-situ rainfall data was used for SPI estimation at different time scales (3-month, 6-month, and 12-month).  Further, different weightage functions such as rectangular, gaussian, triangular, and circular weightage functions were applied for their performance in estimating SPI and their correlation to VCI. Analysis of the results reveals strong dependence of VCI on SPI at larger time scales such as 6-month and 12-month time scales for the whole year as well as in monsoon season. Further, the SPI estimated using the rectangular weightage function shows a better correlation to VCI followed by the circular weightage functions. 

    Key Words: Drought, Standardized Precipitation Index (SPI), Vegetation Condition Index (VCI), Weightage Function

    How to cite: Pati, A., Mahapatra, S., and Wable, P.: Understanding the Drought Situation in a Water-Stressed Region of India, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12814, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12814, 2022.

    EGU22-220 | Presentations | HS4.3

    Intermodel comparison of Short to Medium Range Precipitation Forecasts over the Indian Sub-Continent 

    Sakila Saminathan and Subhasis Mitra

    Reliable and accurate precipitation forecast information is needed for various disaster management and mitigation purposes. Spatio-temporal variability of forecast and uncertainty in the NWP models reduces the skill and reliability of the forecasts, hampering greater uptake for various purposes. This study aims to quantify the performance of short to medium range (1 to 7 days) precipitation forecast information from four different NWP models over the Indian sub-continent. The precipitation forecasts from these four models, namely Climate Forecast System version 2 (CFSv2), European Centre for Medium Range Weather Forecasts (ECMWF), Global Ensemble Forecast System (GEFS), and Indian Institute of Tropical Meteorology (IITM), has been assessed using different precipitation indices namely number of rainy days, accumulated precipitation, consecutive wet days, and consecutive dry days. The indices are evaluated for all the models using the evaluation metrics Heidke Skill Scores (HSS) for different seasons and basins. HSS for different indices shows that monthly HSS value was around 0.2 for the consecutive wet days while being 0.4 for the consecutive dry days showing that model's performance was good for the consecutive dry days than consecutive wet days. Results also show that the models are able to capture the number of rainy days and accumulated precipitation satisfactorily. The assessment of models and indices for monsoon and non-monsoon season showed better performance in the non-monsoon season. The evaluation of models and indices spatially over different basins in India showed that the performance was good in the central region (i.e., Narmada and Tapti basin). Overall, the forecasts from the ECMWF performed better compared to GEFS, CFSv2, and IITM. 

    How to cite: Saminathan, S. and Mitra, S.: Intermodel comparison of Short to Medium Range Precipitation Forecasts over the Indian Sub-Continent, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-220, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-220, 2022.

    EGU22-302 | Presentations | HS4.3

    The potential of a hybrid framework including data driven approaches for hydrological forecasting 

    Sandra Margrit Hauswirth, Marc F.P. Bierkens, Vincent Beijk, and Niko Wanders

    Ensemble hydrological forecasts are important for operational water management and near future planning, even more so in times of increased extreme events such as floods and droughts. Especially the latter requires a planning horizon of several weeks to months to optimize water availability. Having a flexible forecasting framework that can deliver this information in a fast and computational efficient manner is critical. In this study we are exploring a new hybrid framework, combining machine learning models with seasonal (re)forecasting information, in a hindcasting experiment to evaluate the potential of data driven approaches for seasonal forecasting purposes.

    We focussed on 5 different ML methods, which are used to predict discharge and surface water levels of various stations at a national scale (the Netherlands). Input from the European Flood Awareness System and SEAS5 serve as boundary conditions. The ensemble hydrological hindcasts were then evaluated against climatological baseline hindcast with commonly used scores such as anomaly correlation coefficient (ACC), brier skill score (BSS) and continuously ranked probability score (CRPS).

    We observed consistently skilful predictions for the first lead months throughout the year for all station and model combinations. Early spring and summer months show increased skill up to several months as a result of snow dynamics that were captured. Furthermore, we show that the choice of ML model only has a limited impact on the overall forecast performance.

    With our study we show that a hybrid framework is able to bring location specific skilful seasonal forecast information with global seasonal forecast inputs. At the same time our hybrid approach is flexible and fast, and as such a hybrid framework could easily be adapted to make it even more interesting to water managers and their needs.

    How to cite: Hauswirth, S. M., Bierkens, M. F. P., Beijk, V., and Wanders, N.: The potential of a hybrid framework including data driven approaches for hydrological forecasting, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-302, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-302, 2022.

    EGU22-367 | Presentations | HS4.3

    Dynamic vs. Hybrid Seasonal Rainfall Forecasts over Central America: A Comparative Evaluation of C3S and NMME 

    Katherine Kowal, Louise J. Slater, Alan García-López, and Anne F. Van Loon

    Seasonal forecasts present an opportunity to enhance preparedness for hydrometeorological extremes in Central America. Many seasonal forecasts are publicly available, but their comparative value is not well understood, especially over the Central American region. Knowing how best to combine the different seasonal forecast models on offer, or when and where to trust them, requires further study. This evaluation compares seasonal rainfall forecasts over Central America with a focus on hydrometeorological extremes using two of the globally leading ensembles: the Copernicus Climate Change Service seasonal forecasting system (C3S), and the North American Multimodel Ensemble (NMME). We compare the two multimodel ensemble means, eleven individual model means, and model member predictions of monthly and seasonal rainfall over different months, locations, and lead times to better understand their relative forecast quality and identify potential regional predictability limits at the seasonal scale. Direct rainfall forecasts from the models are compared with indirect dynamical-statistical forecasts using large-scale climate precursors within a statistical rainfall prediction system. Results show that C3S and NMME exhibit similar regional variability in their direct rainfall forecasts, revealing the influence of important climate mechanisms on rainfall predictability in the region, which originate in both the Pacific and Atlantic Oceans. The models with the best skill also vary depending on the season, subregion, and lead time assessed. The relative accuracy of indirect versus direct forecasts is still under consideration but we expect their accuracy to vary geographically and seasonally, depending on the associations between the regional climate precursors (e.g. El Niño Southern Oscillation and Tropical North Atlantic variability) and local rainfall. Overall, the models compared can provide useful information on upcoming rainfall, but their regional and seasonal variability affect their usefulness for different types of forecasting applications.

    How to cite: Kowal, K., Slater, L. J., García-López, A., and Van Loon, A. F.: Dynamic vs. Hybrid Seasonal Rainfall Forecasts over Central America: A Comparative Evaluation of C3S and NMME, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-367, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-367, 2022.

    EGU22-2596 | Presentations | HS4.3

    High-Resolution Ensemble Precipitation for Pluvial Flood Forecasting in the Urban Data Scarce city of Alexandria, Egypt 

    Adele Young, Biswa Bhattacharya, Faisal Mahood, Emma Daniels, and Chris Zevenbergen

    High-resolution Quantitative Precipitation Forecasts (QPF)  are essential to accurately forecast the magnitude, timing and location of precipitation and as input for pluvial flood forecasting using urban drainage models. However, there are challenges of producing high-resolution forecast capable of capturing the spatial and temporal variability of rainfall needed for urban flood modelling and the uncertainty associated with meteorological forecast and urban flood models. Therefore there is a challenge to balance data availability, model uncertainty, resolution, forecast lead-time and computational demands, especially in data-scarce regions.

    Ensemble precipitation forecasts are used to capture uncertainties of meteorological forecasting in flood models. This research aims to evaluate the skill of a downscaled ensemble precipitation forecast over the coastal city of Alexandria, Egypt which experiences extreme rainfall and flooding from winter storms. A Weather Research Forecast (WRF) convection-permitting model was initialised using the Global Ensemble Forecast System (GEFS) which provides 21 ensemble members (1 degree archived). The model was run using three domains with horizontal grid resolutions of 30km, 10 km and 3.3 km at a 24h leadtime). For the 3.3 km horizontal grid, ensemble members were coupled with a 1D Mike urban model to evaluate the meteorological uncertainty representation and propagation.

    In the absence of sufficient rainfall and flow gauge data, results were verified against Multi-Source Weighted-Ensemble Precipitation (MSWEP) satellite-derived product and further compared with the ECMWF ensemble prediction system precipitation forecast. 1D flood simulations were evaluated against 1D- 2D hydrodynamic simulations run with MSWEP data.

    Ensembles showed varying probability of detection for different severity events. In general, the majority of ensemble rainfall values resulted in flooding greater than the flooding simulated from the satellite observed rainfall. Although deterministic forecast also indicated flooding and threshold exceedance, the number of ensemble members exceeding critical thresholds has the benefit of providing decision-makers with the probability of threshold exceedance and likelihood of flooding to trigger protective actions. A study such as this provides knowledge for understanding, future applications and limitations of using high-resolution ensemble Quantitative Precipitation Forecasts (QPFs) and the importance of capturing the spatial and temporal variability of rainfall in urban drainage models. Additionally, the potential use of MSWEP for the verification of ensemble forecasts in ungauged and data-scarce regions is investigated.

    How to cite: Young, A., Bhattacharya, B., Mahood, F., Daniels, E., and Zevenbergen, C.: High-Resolution Ensemble Precipitation for Pluvial Flood Forecasting in the Urban Data Scarce city of Alexandria, Egypt, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2596, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2596, 2022.

    EGU22-3228 | Presentations | HS4.3

    Bayesian merging of large scale and local scale hydrological forecasts 

    Marie-Amélie Boucher, Jean Odry, Vincent Fortin, Simon Lachance-Cloutier, Richard Turcotte, and Dominic Roussel

    Global or large-scale hydrological forecasting systems covering entire countries, continents and even the entire planet are growing in popularity. As more large-scale hydrological forecasting systems emerge, it is likely that they will co-exist with pre-existing local forecasting systems. It is the case for instance in Canada, where most provinces have their own streamflow forecasting system, while the new NSRPS will eventually cover the whole country using a 1km by 1km grid. Those province, for instance Quebec, built their own forecasting systems on hydrological models configured for river catchments rather than a regular grid. Using this situation as a starting point and a case study, we propose a Bayesian framework for merging the forecasts from two systems. Within this Bayesian framework, the large-scale prior information comes from the NSRPS. This prior information is then updated using forecasts from the government of Quebec and the associated likelihood. In order to account for forecast uncertainty, this work is carried out using a probabilistic approach for both the NSRPS and Quebec’s Système de Prévision Hydrologique (SPH). While SPH produces probabilistic forecasts by default, the preliminary version of the NSRPS that we had access to is deterministic. Consequently, forecasts from the NSRPS had to be dressed into an ensemble in order to use them as prior distribution within the Bayesian merging framework. Alternative prior distributions (climatology, Markov chain) are also considered instead of those obtained from the NSRPS. Since both forecasting systems include ungauged sites, a version of this Bayesian merging framework based on regional statistics was also developed and tested using cross-validation. Our results show that the merged forecasts perform at least as well as the best individual system, for both gauged and ungauged basins. For longer lead times, merged forecasts can even outperform individual systems. Considering that the NSRPS relies on a non-calibrated model with no data assimilation, those results show that there could be important practical gains in merging large scale hydrological forecasts with local scale forecasts.

    How to cite: Boucher, M.-A., Odry, J., Fortin, V., Lachance-Cloutier, S., Turcotte, R., and Roussel, D.: Bayesian merging of large scale and local scale hydrological forecasts, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3228, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3228, 2022.

    EGU22-4458 | Presentations | HS4.3

    Addressing effective real-time flood forecasting for upstream artificial reservoirs through predictive uncertainty  

    Silvia Barbetta, Bhabagrahi Sahoo, Bianca Bonaccorsi, Tommaso Moramarco, Trushnamayee Nanda, Chandranath Chatterjee, and Ezio Todini

    The impact of flood events is usually approached through structural measures, such as riverbanks and dams able to mitigating, although not fully eliminating flooding risk. Therefore, complementary non-structural measures, mainly real-time Flood Forecasting and Warning Systems (FFWSs), usually combined with operational decision support systems, must be developed to improve the population safety and resilience. Flood forecasting models, essential components of FFWSs, provide deterministic forecasts of discharge or water levels at critical sections on forecast horizons to support the decision-makers activities. Unfortunately, under the uncertainty of future events, predictions must be probabilistic, to be effective and to guarantee the required robustness to the decision makers (Todini, 2017).

    Many studies are available in the literature on generating probabilistic forecasting starting from a deterministic forecast and considering the error distribution. Alternatively, the introduction of the Hydrological Uncertainty Processor (Krzysztofowicz, 1999) has posed the basis for the estimation of the predictive uncertainty, PU, that is the probability of occurrence of a future value conditional on all the available information, usually provided by forecasting models.

    In this context, for estimating the PU, Todini (2008) proposed the Model Conditional Processor (MCP) which allows for the analytical treatment of the multivariate probability densities after converting both observations and model predictions into the Normal space. Afterwards, MCP was extended to the multi-model approach (Barbetta et al., 2017) enabling a decision based on “multiple forecasts” of different deterministic models at the same time.

    With the aim to shed light on the benefits of using PU, the multi-model MCP is applied to discharge forecasts at sites along Indian rivers. Specifically, a data-driven model, i.e. a novel Wavelet-based Non-linear AutoRegressive with eXogenous inputs (WNARX) model and the grid-based semi-distributed VIC hydrological model are used to this end. The future estimates of the river discharge coming into artificial reservoirs, provided by VIC and WNARX models (Nanda et al., 2019) at the same time, are used to feed simultaneously the MCP; thus, showing the benefits in terms of improved effectiveness of the future prediction. The analysis is performed for the Hirahud dam along the Manhanadi River: the results indicate that the methodology could be able to provide effective probabilistic real-time inflow forecasting to be used during significant floods as an appropriate support for the artificial reservoir management.

     

    Barbetta S., Coccia G., Moramarco T., Brocca L., and Todini E. (2017). Improving the effectiveness of real-time flood forecasting through Predictive Uncertainty estimation: the multi-temporal approach, J. of Hydrol., 51, 555-576. 

    Krzysztofowicz, R. 1999. Bayesian theory of probabilistic forecasting via deterministic hydrologic model, Water Resour. Res., 35, 2739–2750.

    Nanda, T., Sahoo, B., Chatterjee, C. (2019). Enhancing real-time streamflow forecasts with wavelet-neural network-based error-updating schemes and ECMWF meteorological predictions in Variable Infiltration Capacity model. J. Hydrol., 575, pp. 890–910.

    Todini, E. A model conditional processor to assess predictive uncertainty in flood forecasting. Int. J. River Basin Manag. 2008, 6, 123–137.

    Todini E. Flood Forecasting and Decision Making in the new Millennium. Where are We?, Water Resour Manage. 2017, doi:10.1007/s11269-017-1693-7, pp.1-19.

     

    How to cite: Barbetta, S., Sahoo, B., Bonaccorsi, B., Moramarco, T., Nanda, T., Chatterjee, C., and Todini, E.: Addressing effective real-time flood forecasting for upstream artificial reservoirs through predictive uncertainty , EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4458, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4458, 2022.

    EGU22-6280 | Presentations | HS4.3

    A benchmark for probabilistic seasonal streamflow forecasting over North America 

    Louise Arnal, Martyn Clark, Vincent Fortin, Alain Pietroniro, Vincent Vionnet, Paul Whitfield, and Andy Wood

    Seasonal streamflow forecasts represent critical operational inputs for water sectors and society, for instance for spring flood early warning, water supply, hydropower generation, and irrigation scheduling. Initial hydrological conditions (e.g., snow cover and soil moisture) are an important driver of hydrological predictions on these timescales. In high-latitude and/or high-altitude basins across North America, and the basins downstream of these headwaters, snow is one of the main sources of runoff generation. As a result, data-driven forecasting from snow observations is a well-established approach for operational seasonal streamflow forecasting in the USA (Fleming et al., 2021) and Canada (Zahmatkesh et al., 2019).

    As part of the Global Water Futures programme (GWF), we are advancing capabilities for probabilistic streamflow forecasting over North America. The first aim of this work is to benchmark probabilistic seasonal streamflow predictability across the continent. To this end, a data-driven probabilistic seasonal streamflow hindcasting system is being developed and implemented for basins with a nival regime across North America. It uses snow water equivalent measurements from the recent update of the Canadian historical Snow Water Equivalent dataset (CanSWE, 1928–2020; Vionnet et al., 2021) and the Natural Resources Conservation Service (NRCS) manual snow surveys and the SNOTEL automatic snow pillow in the USA. These datasets are gap filled using quantile mapping based on neighbouring snow and precipitation stations (SCDNA dataset; Tang et al., 2020), and subsequently transformed into principal components. These principal components are then used as predictors into a regression model, to generate ensemble hindcasts of streamflow volumes for basins across North America. Preliminary results indicate that this approach is skilful (i.e., better than streamflow climatology) for basins across the Canadian Rockies during the snowmelt season.

    References

    Fleming, S. W., Garen, D. C., Goodbody, A. G., McCarthy, C. S., and Landers, L. C.: Assessing the new Natural Resources Conservation Service water supply forecast model for the American West: A challenging test of explainable, automated, ensemble artificial intelligence. Journal of Hydrology, 602, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhydrol.2021.126782, 2021.

    Tang, G., Clark, M. P., Newman, A. J., Wood, A. W., Papalexiou, S. M., Vionnet, V., and Whitfield, P. H.: SCDNA: a serially complete precipitation and temperature dataset for North America from 1979 to 2018, Earth Syst. Sci. Data, 12, 2381–2409, https://doi.org/10.5194/essd-12-2381-2020, 2020.

    Vionnet, V., Mortimer, C., Brady, M., Arnal, L., and Brown, R.: Canadian historical Snow Water Equivalent dataset (CanSWE, 1928–2020), Earth Syst. Sci. Data, 13, 4603–4619, https://doi.org/10.5194/essd-13-4603-2021, 2021.

    Zahmatkesh, Z., Sanjeev Kumar, J., Coulibaly, P., and Stadnyk, T.: An overview of river flood forecasting procedures in Canadian watersheds, Canadian Water Resources Journal / Revue canadienne des ressources hydriques, 44, 3, https://doi.org/10.1080/07011784.2019.1601598, 2019.

    How to cite: Arnal, L., Clark, M., Fortin, V., Pietroniro, A., Vionnet, V., Whitfield, P., and Wood, A.: A benchmark for probabilistic seasonal streamflow forecasting over North America, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6280, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6280, 2022.

    Reliable warnings and forecasts of extreme precipitation and resulting floods are an important prerequisite for disaster mangers to initiate flood defence measures. Thus, disaster managers are interested in extended lead times, which can be obtained by employing forecast of numerical weather models as driving data for hydrological models. To portray the inherent uncertainty of weather model output, ensemble hydro-meteorological forecasts can be used, which offers the opportunity of probability based decision making for disaster managers. However, especially for changing weather systems under unstable atmospheric conditions and for small, fast-responding catchments, the signals of extreme precipitation in the forecasting models may change quickly in magnitude and ensemble spread for successive forecast in expectation of an approaching event.

    With this contribution, we analyse the behaviour and reliability of ensemble hydro-meteorological forecasts depending on their lead time in order to derive appropriate indicators for decision making. We use results of our operational web-based demonstration platform for ensemble hydrological forecasting in small catchments, which is established for three pilot regions with different hydrological settings in Saxony, Germany. The demonstration platform processes ensemble forecasts of the ICON/COSMO-D2-EPS product of the German Weather Service, which provides an ensemble of 20 members each three hours, for lead times up to 27 hours.  Each member is evaluated regarding specific extreme precipitation thresholds. If these thresholds are exceeded in a specific region, rainfall-runoff models for the associated catchments are used to propagate the meteorological uncertainty into the resulting runoff, followed by statistical post processing and visualization. In addition, different options for the visualization of the uncertainty information were developed to monitor the behaviour and reliability of the forecast ensemble over successive forecast lead times. These options contain exceedance probabilities for thresholds in rainfall and resulting runoff and were discussed with decision makers regarding their applicability for decision making. First results are presented for observed extreme events in the small pilot regions.

    How to cite: Grundmann, J. and Philipp, A.: Analysis of ensemble forecasts over successive forecast lead times for decision support in flood management, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6373, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6373, 2022.

    EGU22-7191 | Presentations | HS4.3

    Postprocessing of precipitation forecasts over India with Quantile Mapping  and Ensemble Model Output Statistics 

    Martin Widmann, Michael Angus, Andrew Orr, and Gregor Leckebusch

    Accurate predictions of heavy precipitation in India are vital for impact-orientated forecasting, and an essential requirement for mitigating the impact of damaging flood events. Operational forecasts from non-convection-permitting models can have large biases in the intensities of heavy precipitation, and while convection-permitting models can perform better, their operational use over large areas is not yet feasible. Statistical postprocessing can reduce these biases for relatively little computational cost, but few studies have focused on postprocessing forecasts of monsoonal rainfall.

    As part of the UK Weather and Climate Science for Service Partnership India (WCSSP India), the HEavy Precipitation Forecast Postprocessing over India (HEPPI) project has evaluated and compared two popular postprocessing methods: Univariate Quantile Mapping (UQM) and Ensemble Model Output Statistics (EMOS). The project focuses on the suitability of the methods for postprocessing heavy rainfall in India. Both methods are applied to daily precipitation in the National Centre for Medium Range Weather Forecasting (NCMWF) 12km forecast for the 2018 and 2019 monsoon seasons. The evaluation is based on day 1 forecasts and fitting the methods individually for each location.

    UQM leads by construction to precipitation distributions close to the observed ones, while EMOS optimises the spread of the postprocessed ensemble without guaranteeing realistic rainfall distributions, and it is not a priori clear which method is better suited for practical applications. The methods are therefore compared with respect to several aspects: local distributions, representation of temporal variability using the Continuous Ranked Probability Score, ensemble spread using Rank Histograms, and exceedance of heavy precipitation thresholds using Brier Scores, Reliability Diagrams, and Receiver Operating Characteristics curves.

    EMOS performs not only best, as expected, with respect to correcting under- or overdispersive ensembles, but also with respect to scores for temporal variability, both for the whole range of rainfall values and specifically for heavy rainfall. UQM performs best, as expected, with respect to the local precipitation distributions. The ROC results are inconclusive and location dependent, although both postprocessing methods consistently outperform the raw forecast. These findings are independent of the choice of gridded precipitation data sets used for model fitting and validation.

    We recommend EMOS for operational application, as from a user perspective a good performance in forecasting values at a given time, in particular heavy precipitation events, can be expected to be more important than achieving a close match between the forecasted and observed local precipitation distributions.

     

    How to cite: Widmann, M., Angus, M., Orr, A., and Leckebusch, G.: Postprocessing of precipitation forecasts over India with Quantile Mapping  and Ensemble Model Output Statistics, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7191, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7191, 2022.

    EGU22-10728 | Presentations | HS4.3

    Comparing different versions of the continuous ranked probability score to account for forecast or observation uncertainty 

    Alireza Askarinejad, Mélanie Trudel, and Marie-Amélie Boucher

    Recent studies have shown that probabilistic forecasts are superior to
    deterministic forecasts in terms of quality, reliability, and representing the
    uncertainty of future states. One of the most well-known and widely used
    tools for assessing the performance of (probabilistic) forecast systems is the
    continuous ranked probability score (CRPS). This metric is employed to
    evaluate the forecasting system when only forecast uncertainty is
    considered. In addition to multiple sources of uncertainty in a forecasting
    system (such as initial conditions, model structure and parameters, and
    boundary conditions), the uncertainty can also originate from observations
    (e.g., streamflow). However, this uncertainty, which has rarely been
    explored in previous research, should also be regarded in evaluating the
    forecasting system. A version of the CPRS is redefined and analyzed to
    overcome this important flaw, considering the observation's uncertainty. To
    estimate the uncertainty associated with streamflow observations, the
    Bayesian Rating curve method (BaRatin) is utilized. This study focuses on
    comparing the different versions of the CRPS in considering the
    uncertainties of forecasts and observations. Three types of streamflow
    forecasting systems are used in this study: deterministic forecasts, raw
    ensemble forecasts (applying meteorological ensemble forecasts as inputs to
    the hydrological model), and post-processed ensemble forecasts (postprocessing
    of hydrological model outputs using weighted ensemble dressing
    method). The assessment is performed for short-term forecasts (lead times of
    1 to 5 days) for the Au Saumon watershed in southern central Quebec,
    Canada. It is found that considering observation uncertainty has a significant
    effect on the values of CRPS compared to when only forecast uncertainty is
    considered. In addition, CRPS changes in probabilistic forecasts are more
    than deterministic ones. Our results also point out that using the modified
    version of the CRPS can help end-users better understand and evaluate their
    forecasting system.

    How to cite: Askarinejad, A., Trudel, M., and Boucher, M.-A.: Comparing different versions of the continuous ranked probability score to account for forecast or observation uncertainty, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10728, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10728, 2022.

    EGU22-10805 | Presentations | HS4.3

    IDF curves in nonstationary regions using regional frequency analysis and RCP scenarios in south korea 

    Heechul Kim, Miru Seo, Taewon Lee, and Junhaeng Heo

    Recently, extreme hydrological phenomena are increasing rapidly due to abnormal climate caused by global warming, and many damages are occurring as the change of precipitation characteristics. The intensity-duration-frequency(IDF) curve is widely applied in practice for designing the hydro-infrastructures. In addition, it is important to predict future changes in rainfall intensity due to climate change.

    For this purpose, this study intends to derive the IDF curve, for future periods. In this study, the RCP scenario, a climate change scenario, was used based on historical data (1975-2020) and future rainfall data (2021-2100). Using these data, the stationary and nonstationary regions in the Korean are classified using regional frequency analysis, and the rainfall quantiles for non-stationary regions was calculated using the GEV(1,0,0) model with time varying location parameter. Finally, IDF curves for the historical and future data were derived and analyzed.

     

    How to cite: Kim, H., Seo, M., Lee, T., and Heo, J.: IDF curves in nonstationary regions using regional frequency analysis and RCP scenarios in south korea, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10805, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10805, 2022.

    EGU22-10937 | Presentations | HS4.3

    Statisrical Probable Maximum Precipitation using RCP 4.5 and RCP 8.5 scenarios 

    Miru Seo, Sunghun Kim, jihye Kwon, and Junhaeng Heo

    Probable maximum precipitation (PMP) means the maximum precipitation that can occur under the most severe weather conditions at specific area and rainfall duration in watershed. Greenhouse gas emissions in the atmosphere have increased due to industrialization caused by economic development and population growth. As a result, natural disaster damage from climate change is rapidly increasing because of many abnormal climates and phenomena. Futhemore, PMP has been increased due to such climate change. There are several methods for estimating PMP; statistical method, hydrometeorlogical method, and encelope method. In this study, statistical PMP was calculated using observed data up to 2020, and future PMP was estimated using the RCP 4.5 and RCP 8.5 scenarios up to 2100. The Hershfield’s method was used to calculate the statistical PMP, World meteorological organization (WMO) introduced the statistical method suggested by Hershfield (1961) in which frequency factor was 15. However, the frequency factor of 15 was reported to be too large in the area with heavy rainfall and too small in a dry area. Therefore, Hershfield (1965) suggested the range of 5 ~ 20 as a frequency factor.  In this study, PMPs for observed(historical) data and simulated data from RCP 4.5 and RCP 8.5 scenarios were calculated. Then the frequency factors were compared with those suggested by Hershfield. Finally, the derived statistical PMPs were compared with those from hydrometeorlogical method.

    How to cite: Seo, M., Kim, S., Kwon, J., and Heo, J.: Statisrical Probable Maximum Precipitation using RCP 4.5 and RCP 8.5 scenarios, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10937, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10937, 2022.

    EGU22-12149 | Presentations | HS4.3 | Highlight

    Assessment of a short-term machine learning streamflow forecasting in small Alpine catchments leveraging Deutscher Wetterdienst ICON climate forecasting model 

    Daniele Dalla Torre, Andrea Menapace, Ariele Zanfei, and Maurizio Righetti

    Data-driven methods are widely adopted to forecast short-term streamflow with lead time up to a few days. Flood risk mitigation, multi-use water management and hydropower plants schedule are the most common fields to use forecasting results. Increasing the accuracy and limiting the uncertainty of the predictions are common needs and also this work would evaluates these aspects combining regional climate models and machine learning techniques. Thus, the research question addressed regards the suitability of the machine learning algorithm fed by the ICON forecasting regional climate model for short lead time streamflow prediction in a small and complex Alpine environment.

    A data-driven forecasting procedure is used for streamflow forecasting on a lead time of two days in small Alpine catchments of the Alto Adige Province (Italy). Bias correction of the ICON prediction data inputs against the historical data and the machine learning module compose the two steps data-driven methodology that we propose. Historical time series of precipitation and temperature provided by weather stations have been used for training the machine learning algorithms, while the ICON prediction data of precipitation and temperature have been adopted for testing them. The use of historical data has been essential for collecting a reasonable amount of data required for algorithm learning. The methodology performance evaluation is on the meteorological correction and on the hydrological forecasting.

    This first assessment shows promising results for two-day head streamflow prediction even in the context of small catchments with complex orography. This finding suggests that the merging of robust data-driven methodologies with high-resolution detailed weather prevision inputs can be a consistent breakthrough for reliable hydrological short-term forecasting. In conclusion, the flexibility of machine learning and ensemble climate prediction allows for adequate management of uncertainty along the prediction procedure, which is crucial in hydrological applications.

    How to cite: Dalla Torre, D., Menapace, A., Zanfei, A., and Righetti, M.: Assessment of a short-term machine learning streamflow forecasting in small Alpine catchments leveraging Deutscher Wetterdienst ICON climate forecasting model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12149, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12149, 2022.

    This study evaluates the deterministic and ensemble quantitative precipitation forecasts (QPFs) obtained from four Numerical Weather Prediction (NWPs) models over the Indian region during the monsoon period (June to September) for the years 2011 to 2020. We considered 18 river basins and 14 Agro climatic zones to compare the skill of the forecasts with the observation data. From The Observing System Research and Predictability Experiment Interactive Grand Global Ensemble (TIGGE) archives, we obtained QPFs from Environment and Climate Change Canada (ECCC), European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasts (ECMWF), Korea Meteorological Agency (KMA), and National Centres for Environmental Prediction (NCEP) with 1 to 5 day lead time at a spatial resolution of 0.50. The Integrated Multi-satellite Retrievals for Global Precipitation Measurement (IMERG) data for the same time period is used as observation data. Deterministic (RMSE, NSE, and CC) and dichotomous (POD and FAR) assessment have been performed to evaluate the skill of the QPF(s). Our result shows that overall the performance of ECMWF ensembles mean is better than the other NWPs model, as the NSE and CC value is more close to 1. The river basins in the southern part of the country (Godavari, Krishna and Cauveri River Basins) have the higher error (RMSE more than 100 and NSE close to 0) compared to Brahmputra, Ganga, and Barak River basins. The errors are less in those agro-climatic zones which has high elevation where the rainfall is less. The detailed result of the ongoing research will be presented at the conference. 

    How to cite: Singh, A. and jha, S.: Evaluation of ensemble precipitation forecasts from NWP models in Indian River basins and agro-climatic zones, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12242, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12242, 2022.

    EGU22-12775 | Presentations | HS4.3

    Do more complex hydrological models produce more skilful streamflow forecasts? 

    Seán Donegan, Conor Murphy, Ciaran Broderick, Dáire Foran Quinn, Saeed Golian, and Shaun Harrigan

    Ensemble streamflow prediction (ESP) is a well-established and widely used approach to hydrological forecasting, the application of which requires a hydrological model that can contribute to forecast skill by providing: (i) accurate initial hydrological conditions; and (ii) accurate transformation of climate to river flow signals. It is widely known that there exists a relationship between ESP skill and the hydrological regime of a catchment, and several studies have correlated forecast quality with sets of catchment descriptors. The choice of hydrological model is therefore significant. Whilst a parsimonious structure may be preferable for efficiency, potential skill could be lost if the model’s simplicity means it cannot adequately reproduce key hydrological processes in the catchment. This work seeks to examine the contribution of hydrological model complexity to forecast skill. Using a parsimonious model as a reference, we investigate if additional model complexity adds forecast skill at different lead times and initialisation months through the use of models with different structures and parametric complexity. Forecast skill is evaluated within a hindcast experiment for a selection of Irish river catchments using the continuous ranked probability skill score. Results are presented for our reference model, GR4J (Génie Rural à 4 paramètres Journalier), and our complex model, SMART (Soil Moisture Accounting and Routing for Transport). The performance of each model is viewed in the context of its ability to reproduce key hydrological signatures known to control forecast quality in Ireland (e.g., baseflow index).

    How to cite: Donegan, S., Murphy, C., Broderick, C., Foran Quinn, D., Golian, S., and Harrigan, S.: Do more complex hydrological models produce more skilful streamflow forecasts?, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12775, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12775, 2022.

    EGU22-13078 | Presentations | HS4.3

    Improving sub-seasonal forecasts of high and low flows using a flow-dependent nonparametric model 

    Dmitri Kavetski, David McInerney, Mark Thyer, Richard Laugesen, Fitsum Woldemeskel, Narendra Tuteja, and George Kuczera

    Sub-seasonal streamflow forecasts are used in a wide range of water resource management and planning applications. Practical interest includes forecasts of high flows (e.g., for managing flood events) and low flows (e.g., for managing environmental flows). However, this work reveals that while probabilistic forecasts evaluated over the full flow range can appear statistically reliable, performance specifically for high/low flows can suffer from notable under/over-estimation of forecast uncertainty, respectively. To address this challenge we consider a flow-dependent (FD) nonparametric representation of hydrological forecasting errors, and employ this representation to enhance the existing Multi-Temporal Hydrological Residual Error (MuTHRE) forecasting model. In a case study with 11 Australian catchments, the new MuTHRE-FD model achieves practically significant improvements over the original MuTHRE model in the reliability of forecasted cumulative volumes for high flows out to 7 days, low flows out to 2 days, and mid flows for majority of lead times in the range of 1-30 days. The improved performance of the MuTHRE-FD model provides forecast users with increased confidence in using sub-seasonal streamflow forecasts for applications across a range of flow magnitudes and lead times.

    How to cite: Kavetski, D., McInerney, D., Thyer, M., Laugesen, R., Woldemeskel, F., Tuteja, N., and Kuczera, G.: Improving sub-seasonal forecasts of high and low flows using a flow-dependent nonparametric model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13078, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13078, 2022.

    EGU22-520 | Presentations | HS4.4 | Highlight

    A4alerts: Design and implementation of a mobile device app for a community-based Site-Specific Early Warning System (SS-EWS) in Catalonia, Spain 

    Erika Meléndez-Landaverde, Daniel Sempere-Torres, and Marc Berenguer

    Significant progress has been made in the capability and accuracy of forecasting extreme rainfall events and their associated impacts. However, damages remain high and will continue to rise unless immediate actions are taken to support communities in decreasing the impacts of upcoming extreme weather-induced events. In this context, innovative technological tools can help to quickly disseminate relevant impact-based warning information and trigger appropriate self-protection actions based on the local vulnerability and exposure for effective disaster risk reduction.  For this purpose, a mobile app named “A4alerts” has been designed in this research.  

    The tailor-based A4alerts app communicates impact-based warnings for vulnerable locations within high-risk areas (SSWs) generated by a community-based site-specific early warning system (SS-EWS). Based on a participatory approach with community stakeholders, the SS-EWS blends meteorological information coming from radar-based nowcasting, numerical weather prediction models and local risk information to trigger the SSWs disseminated via the A4alerts app. In addition to communicating the active warnings in the area, the app lists the available actions recommended to mitigate and reduce the potential local impacts for each warning level based on pre-approved self-protection plans. Furthermore, users can send geotagged photos and information through the A4alerts app to validate the events and their impacts.

    The A4alerts app has been implemented and tested for selected vulnerable points in cities across Catalonia, Spain. Its capabilities and design have been improved following an iterative approach with end-users to incorporate their feedback and suggestions. Finally, the configuration of the A4alerts app allows it to be easily implemented and exported to new cities to help communities be prepared in times of climate emergency.

    How to cite: Meléndez-Landaverde, E., Sempere-Torres, D., and Berenguer, M.: A4alerts: Design and implementation of a mobile device app for a community-based Site-Specific Early Warning System (SS-EWS) in Catalonia, Spain, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-520, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-520, 2022.

    EGU22-2476 | Presentations | HS4.4

    7th February 2021 Chamoli (Uttarakhand, India) Rock-ice Avalanche: Numerical Model Simulated Prevailing Meteorological Conditions 

    Piyush Srivastava, Prabhakar Namdev, and Praveen Kumar Singh

    The present study aims to analyze the high-resolution model-simulated meteorological conditions during the Chamoli disaster, Uttarakhand, India (30.37°N, 79.73°E), which occurred on 7th February 2021. The Weather Research and Forecasting (WRF) model is used to simulate the spatiotemporal distribution of meteorological variables pre and post-event. The numerical simulations are carried out over two fine resolution nested model domains covering the Uttarakhand region over a period of 2 weeks (2nd February to 14th February 2021). The model simulated meteorological variables, e.g., air temperature, surface skin temperature, turbulent heat flux, radiative fluxes, heat and momentum transfer coefficients, specific humidity, and upper wind patterns are found to show significant departure from their usual pattern starting from 72 h until a few hours prior to the Chamoli rock-ice avalanche event. The average 2-m air and skin temperatures near the rock-ice avalanche site 48 h prior to the event are found to be much lower than the average temperatures post-event. The total turbulent heat flux mostly remained downward (negative) throughout 72 h prior to the event and was found to have an exceptionally large negative value just a few hours before the rock-ice avalanche event. Model simulated rainfall and Global Precipitation Measurement Mission (GPM, IMERG) derived rainfall suggest that the part of the Himalayan region falling in the simulation domain received a significant amount of rainfall on 4th February, ~ 48 h prior to the event, while the rest of days prior and post-event mostly remained dry. 

    How to cite: Srivastava, P., Namdev, P., and Singh, P. K.: 7th February 2021 Chamoli (Uttarakhand, India) Rock-ice Avalanche: Numerical Model Simulated Prevailing Meteorological Conditions, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2476, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2476, 2022.

    EGU22-3185 | Presentations | HS4.4

    Developing an operational forecast system as byproduct of scientific research - an example for inland floods at the German North Sea coast 

    Jonas Lenz, Conrad Jackisch, Kremena Burkhard, Anett Schibalski, and Boris Schröder-Esselbach

    Within the research project RUINS we assess the risk of inland floods of the Krummhörn region at the German North Sea coast. One third of this area lies below mean sea level, which demands to drain inland water during low tides by sluicing or otherwise by pumping. If, at any point in time, the drainage demand exceeds the drainage capacity, the available storage in polders and canals will be filled. Once this storage capacity is exceeded inland floods will occur.

    Previous risk assessment for such inland floods assumed a constant daily drainage capacity, which results from the installed pump capacity. We analysed process data provided by the operator of the drainage system (1. Entwässerungsverband Emden) at sub hourly resolution. The recorded water levels within the canal system showed that under current conditions the maximum areal drainage capacity is usually limited by the flow capacity within the canal network. The capacity of the pumps is dependend on the gradient from canal to North Sea water level.

    Under increased tidal water levels in the North Sea (e.g. storm flood situations) the pumping capacity can drop below the canal flow capacity. In consequence the areal drainage capacity is variable and can become much smaller than the constant daily drainage capacity assumed in previous studies. Due to the predicted increase in mean sea level with climate change the area might face an increased risk of inland floods despite a situation of insignificant changes in predicted rainfall patterns.

    Instead of costly infrastructural improvements, we propose a forecast system i) to optimise the drainage capacity in foresight of short term extreme situations and ii) to enable preparation for inland floodings. The proposed system includes the inherent uncertainty of the analysed processes and predicts the magnitude of upcoming inland floods. Currently, we use synthetic data as drivers, but these shall be exchanged by available weather and tide level predictions. The forecast system is realized as online accessible app, providing an easy usable and understandable access point for the operator and the interested public.

    How to cite: Lenz, J., Jackisch, C., Burkhard, K., Schibalski, A., and Schröder-Esselbach, B.: Developing an operational forecast system as byproduct of scientific research - an example for inland floods at the German North Sea coast, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3185, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3185, 2022.

    EGU22-4028 | Presentations | HS4.4

    Operational short-term hydro-ecological forecasting for algal-related threats in seawater desalination 

    Maria Sklia, Kyriakos Kandris, Evangelos Romas, and Apostolos Tzimas

    Coastal resources are productive drivers of the so-called blue economy, impacting rapidly growing industries, as the Seawater desalination. Yet, the efficiency of desalination operations is at stake as a result of an imminent operational threat at a global scale, i.e., the proliferation of microscopic algae in seawater. Algal blooms are associated with operational difficulties in the desalination industry, i.e., clogging and bio-fouling, which increase the costs of chemicals, energy and maintenance.

    To alleviate the impact of algal blooms, desalination could be supported by innovative tools that foretell the onset and evolution of bloom events. However, the desalination sector lacks near-real time decision-support tools. This work aims to address this gap. To this end, an operational forecasting service was developed, deployed and tested in a seawater desalination plant,  located at the Saronic Gulf (Greece).

    The operational forecasting service comprises three components: (a) a hydrodynamic component, (b) a water quality component, and (c) an early warning system for algal bloom events.

    The hydrodynamic model predicts the hydrodynamic regime in the Gulf, including vertical mixing, circulation patterns, temperature and salinity profiles. The hydrodynamic model accounts for the heat exchange between the water body and the atmosphere, the salinity, wind and wave action. Both the hydrodynamic and the wave component have been calibrated and validated using satellite-derived and reanalysis data for the first and in situ data for the latter. Specifically, on the validation of the hydrodynamic component, comparisons with satellite-derived water temperatures proved the model’s ability to accurately predict water temperature profiles in the domain, with MAE=1.11oC and MAPE=4% at the validation period from 01/07/2018 to 30-11-2018. To further improve the predictive capacity of the forecast model, the service assimilates satellite-derived sea surface temperature (obtained by Landsat-8 imagery) using the Ensemble Kalman Filtering method.

    The prediction of algal-related water quality attributes (i.e., chlorophyll-a) is based on a data-driven approach. An ensemble learning method (i.e., a random forest) was trained to map hydrodynamic data (temperature, mixed layer thickness), biogeochemical data (inorganic nutrients) and meteorological data (air temperature, wind speed, solar radiation) to chlorophyll-a concentrations at the area of interest. The random-forest-based model produced accurate predictions in hindcast (the mean absolute percentage error was 14% for the held-out data), allowing for its further deployment in an operational setting.

    Ultimately, forecasted hydrodynamic and water quality attributes of the coastal zone are integrated into an early warning system that generates and disseminates readily interpretable warning information to enable operators threatened by a probable shift in the regime of the coastal environment to act promptly and appropriately to reduce the vulnerability of those due to be impacted.

    In conclusion, this work delivers an operational platform that predicts accurately algal-related parameters in coastal waters. Following its deployment and testing in hindcast, the service line will be tested and validated in operational conditions, aiming to assess the limitations in its forecasting abilities.

    Acknowledgements: This work is supported by a grant from Iceland, Liechtenstein and Norway through the EEA Financial Mechanism 2014-2021, within the framework of the Programme “Business Innovation Greece”. 

    How to cite: Sklia, M., Kandris, K., Romas, E., and Tzimas, A.: Operational short-term hydro-ecological forecasting for algal-related threats in seawater desalination, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4028, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4028, 2022.

    The Science for Humanitarian Emergencies and Resilience (SHEAR) programme is an interdisciplinary, international research programme jointly funded for five years by the UK's Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office (FCDO) and the Natural Environmental Research Council (NERC). It aims to support improved disaster resilience and humanitarian response by advancing monitoring, assessment and prediction of natural hazards and risks across sub-Saharan Africa and South Asia. SHEAR projects have been working with stakeholders to co-produce demand-led, people-centred science and solutions to improve risk assessment, preparedness, early action and resilience to natural hazards.

    This session will share recently published challenges, learning and research outcomes from the SHEAR programme related to operational forecasting and early warning on: i) improvements in forecasting science, data, tools and decision making; ii) putting stakeholder needs at the centre; iii) interdisciplinary collaboration; iv) and lessons for future funding.

    SHEAR projects have worked to advance the quality of the forecast information to support preparedness, by increasing the confidence, credibility and usability of forecasting science. The session will share advances made in developing new or improved forecast products for various natural hazards and their impacts in Asia and Africa.

    SHEAR has also been working towards improvements in data; data plays a key role in preparing for and responding to disaster risks. With improved quality, availability, and accessibility of hazard-related data, disaster impacts can be better defined and anticipated.

    The SHEAR projects have generated new knowledge through the development and use of new co-designed tools to support forecasting, early warning, and early action. The strong focus on participatory methods improved the effectiveness, the sustainability and the (policy) commitments to address risks and strengthen resilience in some of the most hazard-prone parts of the world. The co-designed, practical tools applied in SHEAR has enabled effective, appropriate and accessible transformation of knowledge into action.

    The action people take based on forecasts is not always sufficient. SHEAR has worked with stakeholders at all levels and across sectors to improve anticipatory capacities and decision-making processes to enhance action in the face of future hazards. The session will show learning and examples from SHEAR demonstrating the requirement for a dedicated processes to support stakeholders in vulnerable areas to access, understand and subsequently plan for action that can strengthen their resilience in the face of potential upcoming disasters.

    How to cite: Brown, S., Budimir, M., and Sneddon, A.: Learning from the Science for Humanitarian Emergencies and Resilience (SHEAR) programme: challenges, innovations and research outcomes on forecasting and early warning, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5405, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5405, 2022.

    EGU22-6731 | Presentations | HS4.4

    Progress of developing flood forecasting system by Today’s Earth (TE) 

    Wenchao Ma, Yuta Ishitsuka, Akira Takeshima, Kenshi Hibino, Dai Yamazaki, Taikan Oki, Ying-Wen Chen, Masaki Satoh, Kotsuki Shunji, Takemasa Miyoshi, Kosuke Yamamoto, Misako Kachi, Takuji Kubota, Riko Oki, and Kei Yoshimura

    A flood forecasting system (FFS) is widely recognized as essential to protect people’s lives and prosperities. Developing an FFS with high accuracy, longer lead time, and high resolution is the ideal goal, but there are lots of obstacles to achieving this challenge. Here, we would like to introduce our progress in the development of 5-km resolution FFS system in Japan by Today’s Earth (TE) system (Ma et al., 2021). TE was developed by the collaboration between JAXA and The University of Tokyo and is routinely run at https://www.eorc.jaxa.jp/water/index.html. Among various events, we focus on a case study for forecasting Typhoon Hagibis by assessing its forecasting performance. The results showed that this method was accurate in predicting floods at 130 locations, approximately 91.6% of the total of 142 flooded locations, with a lead time of approximately 32.75 h. In terms of precision, these successfully predicted locations accounted for 24.0% of the total of 542 locations under a flood warning. On average, the predicted flood time was approximately 8.53 h earlier than a given dike-break time. Further, we would like to present our current work for developing an FFS with much higher resolution (1 km), with a probabilistic approach by the ensemble method using NEXRA (NICAM-LETKF JAXA Research Analysis, Kotsuki et al. 2017, https://www.eorc.jaxa.jp/theme/NEXRA/) data, and other developing versions of Today’s Earth system of Global scale (https://www.eorc.jaxa.jp/water/).

     

    Ma, W., Ishitsuka, Y., Takeshima, A. et al. (2021). Applicability of a nationwide flood forecasting system for Typhoon Hagibis 2019. Sci Rep 11, 10213. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-021-89522-8.

    Kotsuki S, Miyoshi T, Terasaki K. Lien GY, Kalnay E (2017) Assimilating the global satellite mapping of precipitation data with the Nonhydrostatic Icosahedral Atmospheric Model (NICAM), J. Geophys. Res. Atmos., 122, 631–650. doi: 10.1002/2016JD025355.

    How to cite: Ma, W., Ishitsuka, Y., Takeshima, A., Hibino, K., Yamazaki, D., Oki, T., Chen, Y.-W., Satoh, M., Shunji, K., Miyoshi, T., Yamamoto, K., Kachi, M., Kubota, T., Oki, R., and Yoshimura, K.: Progress of developing flood forecasting system by Today’s Earth (TE), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6731, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6731, 2022.

    EGU22-6832 | Presentations | HS4.4

    EcoConnect - a specialist environmental multi-hazard forecasting and information service 

    Stuart Moore, Christo Rautenbach, Céline Cattoën-Gilbert, Trevor Carey-Smith, Richard Turner, Bernard Miville, David Sutherland, Phil Andrews, Emily Lane, Richard Gorman, Glen Reeve, Hilary Oliver, and Michael Uddstrom

    The National Institute of Water and Atmospheric Research (NIWA) is mandated to research and develop tools to increase New Zealand’s resilience to environmental hazards, including floods. NIWA generates and delivers its bespoke past, present and future environmental information services via a platform called EcoConnect. Comprising forecast output from numerical models of meteorological, hydrological and hydrodynamical hazards and data from related observation platforms, EcoConnect specialises in the creation and delivery of information that increases awareness of a broad range of environmental conditions, and provides input for a variety of specialist decision-support tools, chief of which is a customisable user-interface called NIWA Forecast, that uses this information to mitigate environmental hazards and commercial risk.  EcoConnect operates 24 hours a day, 7 days a week and is fully supported by scientific and technical staff.

    The EcoConnect workflow, which operates autonomously via the Cylc workflow meta-scheduler, begins with the data-assimilating New Zealand Limited Area Model (NZLAM) and New Zealand Convective-Scale Model (NZCSM) numerical weather prediction models.  These are based on the Met Office Unified Model, running with horizontal resolutions of 4.5km and 1.5km respectively over the full New Zealand, Tasman Sea and eastern Australia region (NZLAM) and just New Zealand and its coastal waters (NZCSM). These models provide input data for a hydrological river flow model, TopNet, based on the TopModel framework, that forecasts streamflow for just under 50,000 river reaches around New Zealand and a hierarchy of sea state and wave forecast models, based on the Wavewatch III model and locally called NZWAVE and NZTIDE. A coastal inundation model called RiCOM is also driven using data from the weather forecast models. Observation datasets provided within EcoConnect include satellite imagery, surface weather station data, river gauges and wave buoys. All of these data are created, collected, processed and archived by bespoke tasks in the EcoConnect workflow, all managed by Cylc. 

    Almost all users of forecast products have bespoke needs, such as operational decision-making, and hence it is important to be able to cater to specific client requirements. Through EcoConnect, fit-for-purpose warnings can be configured, based on a user’s operational requirements, for any of the data sources in EcoConnect. For example, if the forecasted wave, or streamflow discharge, at a specified location were to exceed a specific threshold, a client can be warned via customisable alerts within EcoConnect and thus react appropriately. A collection of standard products is generated within EcoConnect and tools within the primary user-interface are provided to interrogate the data and define custom “workspaces” that provide at-a-glance monitoring capabilities. 

    In this presentation, we will describe capabilities of the EcoConnect platform as they relate to hazard forecasting and warning. By means of a case study, we will show how EcoConnect was used to provide heads-up forecasting and decision-making support for an event that comprised weather, hydrological and wave hazards at the same time.  We will also highlight lessons learned and future development plans.

    How to cite: Moore, S., Rautenbach, C., Cattoën-Gilbert, C., Carey-Smith, T., Turner, R., Miville, B., Sutherland, D., Andrews, P., Lane, E., Gorman, R., Reeve, G., Oliver, H., and Uddstrom, M.: EcoConnect - a specialist environmental multi-hazard forecasting and information service, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6832, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6832, 2022.

    EGU22-7162 | Presentations | HS4.4

    Making the best of little information: operational forecasting and early warning systems in a data-scarce environment, the Beni River watershed in Bolivia. 

    Alessandro Masoero, Andrea Libertino, Matteo Darienzo, Simone Gabellani, and Lauro Rossi

    Implementing hydrological models in data-scarce watersheds involves several critical issues, especially in relation to the availability and reliability of input data. This becomes particularly challenging when dealing with real-time hydrological applications for EW purposes (e.g., flood forecasting chains) where input data should be up-to-date and reliable, to provide timely warnings and drive trustworthy early actions.

    When local data are available, those are often collected with inadequate frequency and continuity and cannot be used for proper calibration, configuration and subsequent operational use of the hydrological model underpinning a flood forecast chain. Furthermore, the lack of information reduces knowledge and awareness of risk and increases the vulnerability of these data-scarce areas to water-related disasters. It is therefore of utmost importance to build reliable EWS for these watersheds, making the best of what (little) is available.

    The combined use of satellite observations and innovative hydrometeorological data processing can be a practical solution to integrate and enhance local observations, improving the hydrological model performance in poorly gauged watersheds.

    This approach has been applied to the upstream portion of the Beni River in Bolivia (Alto Beni, closing at Rurrenabaque, 70’000 km2), an Amazon River tributary originating from the Andes. The Flood-PROOFS forecasting chain, based on the CONTINUUM hydrological model (Silvestro, 2013) has been implemented on the Alto Beni together with SENAMHI (Hydrometeorological Service) and VIDECI (Civil Defence).

    Despite the large size of the watershed and its socio-economic importance (hosting several riverine communities and representing a main connection route between Bolivian Altiplano and Amazon plain) few water-level and weather stations are available and in operation in Alto Beni. This scarcity of information, particularly to feed the Flood-PROOFS chain, can be mitigated by using satellite data and by complementing available local data with additional analyses.

    To test the approach and select the best available data source, the hydrological model reconstruction of the 2014 event, the highest on records, has been performed comparing different remote-sensed rainfall inputs: GSMaP, IMERG, MSWEP, PERSIANN, GHE. Performance of each input in reproducing the 2013-2014 rainy season hydrograph at Rurrenabaque has been evaluated. GSMaP and MSWEP performed the best, yet with a non-negligible underestimation of discharge values. Moreover, none of the rainfall inputs was able to reconstruct the double peak shape of the 2014 event. The uncertainty in the rating curve, lacking regular updates and high flow records, should be also considered.

    To address these issues two innovative data processing approaches have been undertaken: firstly, the level-discharge relation at Rurrenabaque has been revised, using an innovative approach (BayDERS, Darienzo 2021) to review the rating curve and update the discharge timeseries. Then, the satellite rainfall inputs have been integrated with the available ground weather station records, using an innovative conditional merging technique (GRISO, Bruno 2021).

    After having performed these two local data enhancement techniques, the combination of GSMaP and ground stations demonstrated to perform the best in reproducing the 2014 event. Moreover, GSMaP, given its near-real-time availability, is a solid data source to feed the operational flood forecasting and EWS for the Alto Beni.

    How to cite: Masoero, A., Libertino, A., Darienzo, M., Gabellani, S., and Rossi, L.: Making the best of little information: operational forecasting and early warning systems in a data-scarce environment, the Beni River watershed in Bolivia., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7162, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7162, 2022.

    EGU22-8016 | Presentations | HS4.4

    InfoSequia: Towards an operational satellite-based Drought Early Warning and Forecasting System for quantifying risks of crop and water supply by using machine learning and remote sensing 

    Sergio Contreras, Gabriela G. Nobre, Amelia Fernández-Rodríguez, Sonu Khanal, Corjan Nolet, and Gijs Simons

    Droughts have directly affected at least 1.5 billion people in the last century, generating economic losses up to $124 billion. They are a recurrent, creeping meteorological hazard that may endanger the water and food security of large regions. The frequency and severity of droughts are expected to increase with climate change, especially in Africa, Central America, and also in Europe where annual losses may multiply by 7 and represent up to 2 times the size of the European economy in the medium-long term.

    Drought Early Warning Systems (DEWS) are key pillars of a risk-based, proactive management strategy. The increasing number of sources of EO data has remarkedly improved the monitoring capabilities of DEWS. Despite there are good examples of global and regional drought monitoring systems, these tools still lack of seasonal forecasting capabilities able to provide enough accurate and specific predictions of drought impacts at the subregion level (e.g. basin, district). These deficiencies constitute a challenge for the scientific community and provide an opportunity to improve the current services.

    To address this gap in the DEWS landscape, the InfoSequia DEWS is developed to integrate the strengths of spatial, satellite-derived data with machine learning techniques for seasonal forecasting. InfoSequia consists of two modules:

    • InfoSequia-MONITOR provides more than 50 drought predictors including meteorological (SPI, SPEI), vegetative (VCI / TCI / VHI), and hydrological (water level in reservoirs, groundwater storage status) drought indices, as well as atmospheric oscillation indices, all of them retrieved from satellite (e.g. MODIS, Sentinel-2, Sentinel-3, GRACE), hybrid (eg CHIRPS), or reanalysis and modeling (ERA5-Land) products. All indices are obtained from dekad values ​​ which are timescale aggregated at 1, 3, 6 and 12 months. The spatial resolution of the indices ranges from 5km (SPI, SPIE) to 250m (VH indices).
    • Acknowledging the limitations of physically-based modelling on the seasonal time scale, the InfoSequia-4CAST module rests on the Fast and Frugal Tree (FFT) algorithm, a machine learning technique in which binary decision trees are trained and generated at the subregional level with the historical and spatially-aggregated predictors of drought. Final outputs are delivered in the form of monthly warnings of risk of failure up to 6 month lead times.

    All InfoSequia algorithms run on a cloud platform, with cloud geoprocessing functionalities.

    With support of the European Space Agency (ESA), InfoSequia is being developed and piloted to provide operational seasonal forecasts of: a) crop yield failures at the district level in Mozambique, and b) water supply failures in the Segura river basin in SE Spain.

    Seasonal outlooks of drought impact support improvement of the water and food security of a region by allowing the early exploitation of groundwater reserves or unconventional water resources (desalination, reuse), the optimal water allocation of limited resources among users, or the implementation of ex-ante cash transfers or food vouchers. This research introduces the general workflow which underpins InfoSequia, how limitations due to technical barriers and data gaps are addressed, and the key performance indicators generated for both pilot cases.

    How to cite: Contreras, S., G. Nobre, G., Fernández-Rodríguez, A., Khanal, S., Nolet, C., and Simons, G.: InfoSequia: Towards an operational satellite-based Drought Early Warning and Forecasting System for quantifying risks of crop and water supply by using machine learning and remote sensing, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8016, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8016, 2022.

    EGU22-8144 | Presentations | HS4.4

    A probabilistic hydrometeorological forecasting chain for operational warning procedures in Marche Region 

    Simone Gabellani, Andrea Libertino, Fabio Delogu, Giulia Ercolani, Matteo Darienzo, Francesca Sini, and Valentino Giordano

    An operational hydrometeorological forecasting chain has been developed and implemented to support the civil protection activities of the Multi-risk Functional Centre of Marche Region. The chain includes a distribute hydrological model (Continuum) feed by observed meteorological variables from different sources: ground stations, weather radars and satellites (snow cover from Sentinel 2, MODIS and HSAF, and soil moisture from ASCAT). The precipitation field is obtained using a merging algorithm that fuse rain gauge data and weather radars (Modified Conditional Merging). In the forecasting configuration the chain ingests weather forecast (QPF and other meteorological variables) from different sources producing an ensemble of streamflow forecast (COSMO-LAMI 5 km, WRF 1.5 km, HRES 9 km). An interesting feature of the hydrometeorological forecasting systems on small and medium catchments is the possibility to feed the model with quantitative prediction issued by expert forecasters. They consider the meteorological uncertainty by using the output of various meteorological models combined with their knowledge of the territory, of its climatic peculiarities and on the meteorological situation to give their best quantitative estimate of expected precipitation amount and maxima. Part of the forecasting chain is an interactive tool that allows to create different scenarios to mitigate floods by acting in advance on some of the dams present in the area and used for hydropower production and water supply. Modelling upgrade, an activity of the STREAM project, was financed by the European Regional Development Fund  inside the  Interreg IT-HR programme.  In this work the performances of the forecasting chain will be presented on a set of several past events. 

     

    How to cite: Gabellani, S., Libertino, A., Delogu, F., Ercolani, G., Darienzo, M., Sini, F., and Giordano, V.: A probabilistic hydrometeorological forecasting chain for operational warning procedures in Marche Region, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8144, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8144, 2022.

    EGU22-8184 | Presentations | HS4.4

    Operational impact-based flood forecasting in data-scarce environments: the Early Warning System of the Buzi watershed in Mozambique 

    Andrea Libertino, Alessandro Masoero, Maria Laura Poletti, Isac Filimone, Matteo Darienzo, Flavio Pignone, Giacomo Fagugli, Lia Romano, Agostinho Vilanculos, Lauro Rossi, and Simone Gabellani

    Mozambique is one of the countries in Africa most frequently and most seriously affected by natural disasters such as floods, cyclones and droughts. In March 2019 the Cyclone Idai, one of the Southern Hemisphere’s deadliest storms, made landfall in the central part of the country, affecting about 1.7 million citizens, with devastating flooding in the central part of the country, especially in the Buzi and Pungwe river basins. Despite the existence of several studies aimed at the hydrological characterization of the area, the unexpected severity of the event undermined the local EW/EA system.

    In the framework of the ECHO funded project “Building inclusive resilient communities and schools to face rapid-onset hazards in risk-prone areas in Mozambique affected by cyclone Idai, linking early warning to early action”, an operational flood forecasting system, up to real-time inundation mapping, have been implemented for the Buzi watershed (30’000 km2, in Manica and Sofala Provinces), with the aim of increasing the preparedness and response capacity to rapid onset disasters of the local and national levels of the EW/EA systems. For granting the sustainability and the maintenance of the tool, the operational chain has been implemented in co-operation with the local authorities (DNGRH) and is based on the use of open-source free software and models.

    A preliminary collection of the available data has been carried out for the setup and the calibration of the CONTINUUM hydrological fully distributed model (Silvestro, 2013). Several existing studies have been considered for the development of the land data and the collection of hydrological measurements for calibration. Furthermore, the outdated level-discharge rating curves available have been reviewed and updated using an innovative approach (BayDERS, Darienzo 2021).

    Stemming from the output of a long-term hydrological simulation fed with meteorological reanalysis conditioned with local rainfall data, dynamic flood scenarios have been developed for the Dombe flood prone community by setting up a hydraulic model with the Telemac-2D open system using the Copernicus DSM at 30 m resolution as topographical input. Outcomes obtained by simulating the Idai 2019 flood has been compared with satellite images, demonstrating good agreement and reliability of the implemented model. Modelled flood maps have been shared and commented with the local community in Dombe, with the dual objective of receiving feedback on map reliability and increasing flood risk awareness.

    The full flood forecasting chain for the Buzi watershed has been then operationally implemented by means of the FloodPROOFS open-source modelling system (https://github.com/c-hydro), fed twice per day by deterministic and probabilistic forecasts freely provided by NOAA (GFS and GEFS). Operational forecasts are made available to DNGRH officers through the myDEWETRA.world EW platform, informing on potential flood events expected for the following 5 days, including their probability of occurrence, thus facilitating decision making in issuing early warnings and taking early action measures.

    Finally, for the Dombe pilot-case the flood depth and water velocity maps are combined with the spatial distribution of the exposed assets, identified in collaboration with the community itself, resulting in real-time forecasts of the expected impacts. 

    How to cite: Libertino, A., Masoero, A., Poletti, M. L., Filimone, I., Darienzo, M., Pignone, F., Fagugli, G., Romano, L., Vilanculos, A., Rossi, L., and Gabellani, S.: Operational impact-based flood forecasting in data-scarce environments: the Early Warning System of the Buzi watershed in Mozambique, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8184, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8184, 2022.

    EGU22-8549 | Presentations | HS4.4

    Forecasting agricultural drought using VCI and VHI across Africa 

    Pedram Rowhani, Edward Salakpi, Andrew Bowell, Minh Tran, and Seb Oliver

    Droughts are complex and a major threat globally as they can cause substantial damage to society, especially in regions that depend on rain-fed agriculture. It is understood that acting early based on alerts provided by early warning systems (EWS) can potentially provide substantial mitigation, reducing the financial and human cost of such hazards. Several satellite-based indicators such as the Vegetation Condition Index (VCI) or the Vegetation Health Index (VHI) are included in these EWS to monitor the agricultural and ecological droughts. In this presentation, we first present a suite a machine-learning techniques that we developed to forecast up to 12 weeks ahead these indicators at the second administrative boundaries across Kenya. Our approaches (Gaussian Process, auto-regressive distributed lag model, Hierarchical Bayesian Model) all provided skilful forecasts at various lead times. Finally, we show our Africa-wide forecasts of VCI and VHI using Gaussian Processes where we analyse whether the performance of the forecasts is influenced by season, land cover, or agro-ecological zone. Providing highly skilful forecast on vegetation condition will allow disaster risk managers act early to support vulnerable communities and limit the impact of a drought hazard.

    How to cite: Rowhani, P., Salakpi, E., Bowell, A., Tran, M., and Oliver, S.: Forecasting agricultural drought using VCI and VHI across Africa, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8549, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8549, 2022.

    EGU22-9056 | Presentations | HS4.4

    Impact-based Forecast and Warning Services Capacity Development 

    Paul Kucera and Elizabeth Page

    The COMET program has been supporting impact-based forecast and warning services (IBFWS) capacity development.  An IBFWS system has been implemented at the Barbados Meteorological Service (BMS) as part of the US National Weather Service (NWS) Weather Ready Nations (WRNs) initiative.  COMET collaborated with local partners and stakeholders including BMS, Barbados Department of Emergency Management, (DEM), and the Caribbean Institute of Meteorology and Hydrology (CIMH) in the implementation of the IBFWS framework.  The IBFWS system was implemented in six phases that included 1) identifying the hazards, impacts, risks through stakeholder workshops; 2) developing new standard operating procedures; 3) adapting software tools that integrates the IBFWS framework; 4) training of stakeholders; 5) testing and evaluation of system; and 6) the development of documentation for public outreach.  Recently, IBFWS training resources have been developed following the guidance of WMO-No. 1150: WMO Guidelines on Multi-hazard Impact-based Forecast and Warning services.  The IBFWS course includes topics on the Process for Implementing Impact-based Forecast and Warning Services, Identifying Hazards and Constructing Impacts Tables, Using Multi-hazard, Impacts-based Forecast and Warning Services, and Communicating Risk.  These online training modules include engagement simulations related to the types of decisions that need to be made in developing impact-based forecasting programs. Future work is planned to develop a full curriculum related to impact-based forecasting. The presentation will provide an overview of the IBFWS system implementation in Barbados and the associated training resources that have been developed.

    How to cite: Kucera, P. and Page, E.: Impact-based Forecast and Warning Services Capacity Development, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9056, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9056, 2022.

    EGU22-9832 | Presentations | HS4.4

    A flood map catalogue for integration into aEuropean flood awareness system (ECFAS) 

    Marine Le Gal, Tomás Fernández-Montblanc, Juan Montes Perez, Paola Emilia Souto Ceccon, Enrico Duo, Véra Gastal, Sébastien Delbour, and Paolo Ciavola

    The European Coastal Flood Awareness System - ECFAS (EU H2020 GA 101004211) - project aims to deliver a proof of concept for a coastal flood awareness system as an improvement of the Copernicus Emergency Management Service. One of the project’s keystones is the generation of a flood map catalogue for European flood-prone coastlines. To obtain this product, the work started with the identification of 28 historical test cases representing the wide variety of oceanographic and morphological conditions observed along European coastlines. The inundations generated by these events were numerically reproduced to calibrate and validate the LISFLOOD-FP model that will be used to generate the catalogue. For this step, observed flood maps derived from Very High Resolution satellite images and in situ observations were used as references. In parallel, validated hindcasts of oceanographic conditions in shallow water were produced using the ANYEU-SSL model. An Extreme Value Analysis was performed on the hindcast along the European coastlines to provide: (i) local storm conditions for a set of return periods (1, 2, 5, 10 and 20 years), (ii) local total water level thresholds for triggering the awareness system. Finally, 100 km long coastal sectors were identified along the European coastline for which a 100 m resolution LISFLOOD-FP numerical model will be generated. The catalogue will collect the maps generated with the storm conditions identified from the hindcast for each flood-prone coastal sector. These flood maps will represent a set of reference flooding scenarios in case of forecasted over-threshold coastal oceanographic events triggering the awareness system. 

    How to cite: Le Gal, M., Fernández-Montblanc, T., Montes Perez, J., Souto Ceccon, P. E., Duo, E., Gastal, V., Delbour, S., and Ciavola, P.: A flood map catalogue for integration into aEuropean flood awareness system (ECFAS), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9832, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9832, 2022.

    EGU22-12097 | Presentations | HS4.4

    InfoWas – Developing an Information System for Water Quality in the North and Baltic Seas – Forecasting Oxygen Deficiency Zones 

    Alexandra Marki, Fabian Große, Simon Jandt-Scheelke, Xin Li, Fabian Schwichtenberg, Eefke van der Lee, Anju Sathyanarayanan, Lars Nerger, and Ina Lorkowski

    Seasonally occurring oxygen deficiency zones (ODZs) are a regular feature in the coastal zones of the Baltic and North Seas, and their frequency has increased over the last years. The development of ODZs is favoured in areas of high primary production supported by excess nutrient loads from land, sluggish ventilation and strong salinity and/or temperature gradients. For forecasting the risk of oxygen deficiency, we redefine the oxygen deficiency index (ODI) originally developed for the North Sea by Große et al. (2016) to account for the fundamental differences between Baltic and North Seas (e.g., haline vs. thermal stratification) and to obtain a common ODI, applicable to both seas and in an operational context. The InfoWas system is based on the results from the operational physical-biogeochemical model (HBM-ERGOM) at the BSH. The model system is further coupled with the Parallel Data Assimilation Framework (PDAF) developed at the Alfred Wegener Institute (AWI). Since ODZs in coastal zones can become hazardous to organisms and can cause ecological and economic consequences for the environment, the fisheries and the tourism-industries, combining the operational InfoWas system with the revised ODI offers intuitive, short-term forecasts of the risk of oxygen deficiency on a high spatio-temporal resolution for the entire coastal zone of the North and Baltic Seas. These easily interpretable forecasts will help to quickly inform environmental agencies of potentially upcoming harmful events and to act in advance in order to diminish environmental and economic consequences.

    How to cite: Marki, A., Große, F., Jandt-Scheelke, S., Li, X., Schwichtenberg, F., van der Lee, E., Sathyanarayanan, A., Nerger, L., and Lorkowski, I.: InfoWas – Developing an Information System for Water Quality in the North and Baltic Seas – Forecasting Oxygen Deficiency Zones, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12097, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12097, 2022.

    EGU22-12160 | Presentations | HS4.4

    Insights into stakeholder perceptions of Impact -based Forecasting (IbF) and implications for operational implementation in hydrometerology 

    Joanne Robbins, Emma Bee, Alison Sneddon, Irene Amuron, Elisabeth Stephens, and Sarah Brown

    Impact based Forecasting (IbF) represents a shift away from traditional hazard focussed hydrometeorological forecasts and warnings (e.g. wind gusts exceeding 80mph at a location and time), towards those that communicate the risk, as a function of probability of the hazard occurring and its consequence(s) or impact on society. To achieve this shift, there is recognition that the exposure and vulnerability of society to the hazard, need to be considered in addition to hazard forecasts. The methods by which these additional variables are integrated to provide IbF outputs varies, but there has been limited research to understand why this is the case and what implications this has for operational IbF services.

    To understand the variation in perceptions around IbF and the possible consequences these perceptions may have for operational implementation, this work invited practitioners, forecasters and researchers, working within the NERC and FCDO Science for Humanitarian Emergencies and Resilience (SHEAR) Programme, to provide their perspectives on a range of IbF related topics. Semi structured interviews were conducted with individuals that were selected by the project team based on their experience and expertise regarding IbF. A total of 11 interviews were held with stakeholders from the UK, South Africa, Uganda, Kenya, India, and Nepal, with representation from international institutions and NGOs, research institutes and hydrometeorological agencies.  

    Our research aimed to answer the following questions: (1) Is there a shared understanding of what IbF is and means across individuals involved in its development? (2) Is there a shared perception of the challenges, barriers and opportunities associated with implementing IbF operationally? In this session, we illustrate areas of consensus and clarity, as well as areas of divergence, and knowledge gaps that could impede effective collaboration and implementation. We review the relevance of our findings for researchers and practitioners and explore how this might inform IbF activities in the future. 

    How to cite: Robbins, J., Bee, E., Sneddon, A., Amuron, I., Stephens, E., and Brown, S.: Insights into stakeholder perceptions of Impact -based Forecasting (IbF) and implications for operational implementation in hydrometerology, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12160, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12160, 2022.

    EGU22-12455 | Presentations | HS4.4

    A regional flood impact prediction tool using machine learning to manage flood risk in real-time. A case study in New Zealand. 

    Phil Mourot, Nick Lim, Bernhard Pfahringer, and Albert Bifet

    Regional resilience has been identified as a key strategic priority for the Waikato Regional Council in New Zealand. Weather extremes are going to impact more our communities and what is important is how the regions can anticipate and respond to the impact of climate change. Flooding is the Waikato region’s most frequent and widespread natural hazard. The council’s priority is to prevent risks to people and property by providing flood protection and flood warnings. The local government works close to emergency services and civil defence to help people at risk. In addition to flood defences, flood impact prediction can help our communities be more resilient. This research is part of the TAIAO project (taiao.ai) that aims to develop new machine learning (ML) methods to provide a robust and fit-for-purpose tool to help New Zealand solve critical environmental problems. Over the past decade, increased research has aimed to develop new hydrological models for flood forecasting using machine learning. A data-driven approach provides the ability to deliver reliable results, especially for short-term forecasts, without the complete and complex knowledge of the physical processes usually required by a physically-based approach. Our research focuses on developing a regional real-time flood forecasting tool for emergency management that can run with low computational effort and a small number of parameters. Our target is to provide a better flood prediction with available information from the observation network. For our pilot study, we focus on the Coromandel Peninsula, a popular destination for the holidays, and where the weather is often challenging to forecast, like in New Zealand in general. We have used and compared the capability of various ML models to provide accurate results with low timing errors. To solve the problem of lagged prediction, we have developed a more holistic approach that combines hydrological state parameters and Long Short-Term Memory networks (LSTM). From these preliminary results, we demonstrate the real challenge to embed our LSTM-based model into operational procedures to predict with a lead time from 1 hour to 6 hours the severity of the impacts of heavy rainfall. The predictions are presented in a helpful way that facilitates decision-making and improves the regional flood response management.

    How to cite: Mourot, P., Lim, N., Pfahringer, B., and Bifet, A.: A regional flood impact prediction tool using machine learning to manage flood risk in real-time. A case study in New Zealand., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12455, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12455, 2022.

    EGU22-12766 | Presentations | HS4.4

    Lessons learned from developing a multi-model hydrometeorological forecasting system 

    Fredrik Wetterhall, Umberto Modigliani, Milan Dacic, and Sari Lappi

    The project “South-East European Multi-Hazard Early Warning Advisory System” (SEE-MHEWS-A) is a collaborative effort to strengthen the existing early warning capacity in south-eastern Europe. The project was initiated in 2016 by the World Meteorological Organization (WMO), and has been supported by the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID), World Bank and the European Commission and has now developed from a concept into implementation of a pilot for a multi-hazard forecasting system. The pilot consists of four limited area numerical weather prediction models which are used as forcing to three hydrological models. In the implementation phase the hydrological models are setup over small catchments, but the plan is to increase the coverage when the project moves to the operationalization phase. The pilot also consists of a nowcasting system and the output are visualized on a web-based common information platform. The project has led the countries in the region to increase sharing of observational data, knowledge and resources to create a common information platform that can potentially deliver a tailored decision support system for hydrometeorological hazards to agencies and authorities.

    How to cite: Wetterhall, F., Modigliani, U., Dacic, M., and Lappi, S.: Lessons learned from developing a multi-model hydrometeorological forecasting system, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12766, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12766, 2022.

    EGU22-760 | Presentations | HS4.5

    Using Value Chain Approaches to Evaluate End-to-End Warning Systems 

    David Hoffmann, Beth Ebert, Carla Mooney, and Brian Golding

    The weather information value chain provides a framework for characterising the production, communication, and use of information by all stakeholders in an end-to-end warning system. Since the generation of weather warning and climate services has become more complex, both technically and organizationally, the value chain concept has become a popular tool for describing and assessing the production, use and benefits of such services.

    The end-to-end warning system for high impact weather brings together hazard monitoring, modelling and forecasting, risk assessment, communication and preparedness activities and systems and processes which support people to take timely action to reduce risks. Weather and associated warning services are typically developed and provided through a multitude of complex and malleable value chains (networks), often established through co-design, co-creation and co-provision.  

    A 4-year international project under the WMO World Weather Research Programme that started in November 2020 is using value chain approaches to describe and evaluate the end-to-end warning system for high impact weather. Its aims are

    • To review value chain approaches used to describe weather, warning and climate services to assess and provide guidance on how they can be best applied in a high impact weather warning context that involves multiple users and partnerships;
    • To generate an easily accessible means (an End-to-End Warning Chain Database) for scientists and practitioners involved in researching, designing and evaluating weather-related warning systems to review previous experience of high impact weather events and assess their efficacy using value chain approaches.

    We encourage the research and operational community to participate in this project by contributing case studies of high impact events and collaborating in their analysis. Integration of the physical and social sciences in this project will lead to new insights that we hope will ultimately improve the effectiveness of warnings for high impact weather.

    How to cite: Hoffmann, D., Ebert, B., Mooney, C., and Golding, B.: Using Value Chain Approaches to Evaluate End-to-End Warning Systems, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-760, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-760, 2022.

    EGU22-2129 | Presentations | HS4.5

    Climate Predictions in a Forecast based Action (FbA) pilot within the Greater Horn of Africa; Experiences from ForPAc and Down2Earth Projects 

    Dr. George Otieno, Dave MacLeod, Martin C Todd, Emma Visman, Richard Graham, Shamton Waruru, Abebe Tadege, and Khalid Hassaballah

    Skillful weather and climate forecasts, if utilized effectively, have the potential to improve preparedness and disaster risk reduction. Forecast-based Action (FbA) is a framework for aiding decisions on preparedness in advance of weather/climate hazards, through use of forecasts. Here, we present a summary of research results and pilot project work within the Arid and Semi-Arid Land (ASAL) areas of Kenya conducted under the Towards Forecast-based Preparedness and Action (ForPAc) project. We also present opportunities for scaling up FbA  across the Greater Horn of Africa region through leveraging on connected projects and initiatives like Down2Earth.  Skill assessment of a pool of weather/climate models has established the most skilful multi-model combinations for monthly-seasonal timescale.  Co-production initiatives between forecast users and producers established the forecast variables best aligned with Kenya’s existing Drought Early Warning Systems (DEWS); Standardized Precipitation Index (SPI), Vegetation Condition Index (VCI) and soil moisture, as well as optimum forecast delivery time required by the DEWS processes. Our analysis shows that rainfall forecasts have skill across ‘seamless’ sub-seasonal to seasonal lead times, offering the potential to improve the anticipatory actions within the DEWS of Kitui county of Kenya. Working with multiple stake-holders from across local and national government, humanitarian agencies, forecasting services and climate researchers, we have explored the potential for a more anticipatory, proactive DEWS using forecast information. The Down2Earth project, which aims at translating climate information for adaptation and climate-resilience across decision-making levels is leveraging on gains of ForPAc by advancing FbA approaches within the rural communities of Kenya, Somalia and Ethiopia. To facilitate the institutionalization of FbA, we have developed a regional roadmap to guide implementation within National, regional and international humanitarian actors.   

    How to cite: Otieno, Dr. G., MacLeod, D., Todd, M. C., Visman, E., Graham, R., Waruru, S., Tadege, A., and Hassaballah, K.: Climate Predictions in a Forecast based Action (FbA) pilot within the Greater Horn of Africa; Experiences from ForPAc and Down2Earth Projects, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2129, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2129, 2022.

    EGU22-2648 | Presentations | HS4.5

    Assessing and Forecasting Dengue Risk with Hydrological Data 

    Jacopo Margutti, Marc van den Homberg, Fleur Hierink, and Nicolas Ray

    We introduce a methodology to assess and forecast the risk of mosquito-borne diseases using open hydrological and socio-economic data, with a specific focus on scalability, i.e. applicability to countries where limited data is available. We apply this methodology to assess and forecast the risk of dengue in the Philippines. We embedded this model into a full Early-Warning Early-Action system, which includes a web portal to convey the information to disaster managers and a set of pre-defined preventive actions, to mitigate the impact of potential outbreaks. This system has been developed in collaboration with the Philippines Red Cross, which is now adopting it.

    How to cite: Margutti, J., van den Homberg, M., Hierink, F., and Ray, N.: Assessing and Forecasting Dengue Risk with Hydrological Data, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2648, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2648, 2022.

    EGU22-3341 | Presentations | HS4.5

    Comparative Suitability of the Global Flood Awareness System and a Catchment-based Model to Simulate Floods in Uganda 

    Douglas Mulangwa, Andrea Ficchì, Philip Nyenje, Jotham Sempewo, Linda Speight, Hannah Cloke, Shaun Harrigan, Benon Zaake, and Liz Stephens

    This study aims to evaluate the comparative suitability of a global hydrological forecasting and monitoring system, the Copernicus-Emergency Management Service - Global Flood Awareness System (GloFAS), and a local catchment-based model (GR4J) as possible alternative or complementary flood forecasting tools in Uganda. Local stakeholders and end-users in Uganda need to understand whether flood forecasts from ready-to-use global systems can be relied on as one of the available tools to inform flood preparedness actions or whether other easy-to-set-up local hydrological models can provide more reliable information at the catchment scale or some advantages in particular regions. While GloFAS provides probabilistic extended-range forecasts, it has only been calibrated at a few locations in Africa and remains uncalibrated at most locations in Uganda and eastern Africa. A simpler catchment-based model can be calibrated more easily by local national authorities using observed hydrological data. This research investigates whether the reanalysis data from GloFAS can perform satisfactorily in Uganda with respect to the simulation of a lumped catchment-based model (GR4J) using the same meteorological inputs across Uganda.

    Results are presented for four Ugandan catchments with different morphological and hydrological characteristics. An evaluation of both GloFAS reanalysis (GloFAS-ERA5) and extended-range (re-)forecasts has been carried out against observed streamflow data, analysing performance statistics including the Kling-Gupta Efficiency (KGE) for the reanalysis, and the False Alarm Ratio and Probability of Detection for forecasts at short lead times (< 15 days). The GR4J model simulations were run using the ERA5 meteorological reanalysis as input. In both calibration and validation mode, on average, the calibrated GR4J model provides better KGE scores than GloFAS, especially for the smaller catchments (< 2000 km2). However, GloFAS performance is relatively good for the two largest basins (>2200 km2) and is acceptable with respect to a mean flow benchmark for all catchments, except the smallest (500 km2). Our results suggest that in small- to medium-size basins in Uganda, a simple lumped catchment-based model may outperform GloFAS, but even without calibration GloFAS performs satisfactorily in larger basins. Thus, GloFAS can be relied on as interim solution for flood forecasting in Uganda, especially for larger river catchments. An evaluation of the accuracy of the rainfall reanalysis (ERA5) with respect to local rainfall observations showed significant differences in biases and correlation of rainfall input data across catchments and this can explain the different performance of the hydrological models across Uganda. Finally, the importance of assessing and calibrating flood forecasting models with action-relevant scores to support humanitarian actions is highlighted by analysing the discrepancies between traditional general scores (as the KGE) with other more specific flood event-based scores.

    How to cite: Mulangwa, D., Ficchì, A., Nyenje, P., Sempewo, J., Speight, L., Cloke, H., Harrigan, S., Zaake, B., and Stephens, L.: Comparative Suitability of the Global Flood Awareness System and a Catchment-based Model to Simulate Floods in Uganda, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3341, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3341, 2022.

    EGU22-4480 | Presentations | HS4.5

    Localised Drought Early Warning using In-situ Groundwater Sensors 

    Will Veness, Wouter Buytaert, and Adrian Butler

    Drought Early Warning Systems (DEWSs) require data on spatial drought intensity and exposure to highlight the most-affected areas for early interventions. This data also provides evidence of drought severity to trigger early financing mechanisms. However, existing DEWSs are dependent on satellite-based parameters, which have a course spatial resolution and high measurement uncertainty. As a result, these indicators do not provide a reliable proxy for local groundwater availability during hydrological drought. This research explores groundwater monitoring for providing an alternative, direct index of groundwater availability for DEWSs, considering the increasing affordability and feasibility of monitoring due to advancements in modern sensors. Using in-situ observations collected from abstraction wells in Maroodi Jeex, Somaliland, a lumped parameter groundwater model has been calibrated that can forecast local groundwater levels during drought, by inputting seasonal and mid-range weather forecasts. The model can also simulate well water levels if the sensor is removed after 1 year, enabling an ongoing, locally calibrated groundwater index without the need for sensor maintenance. This suggests that national-scale groundwater monitoring in Somaliland is technically feasible, and it raises further research questions regarding how such a system can be funded, governed and maintained, as well as how this groundwater information would be practically used in the drought early warning early action process to inform management and financing decisions.

    How to cite: Veness, W., Buytaert, W., and Butler, A.: Localised Drought Early Warning using In-situ Groundwater Sensors, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4480, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4480, 2022.

    EGU22-5901 | Presentations | HS4.5 | Highlight

    How do we ensure that the humanitarian use of forecasts is robust? 

    Liz Stephens, Faith Mitheu, Linda Speight, Sazzad Hossain, Hannah Cloke, and Stefania Giodini

    Forecast-based action within the humanitarian community supports at-risk communities when a forecast indicates a potentially imminent disaster. Within the Red Cross Red Crescent Movement the development of an Early Action Protocol enables access to pre-agreed funds and avoids indecision when faced with an uncertain forecast. To ensure value for money, this protocol must demonstrate that the forecast is good enough for the decisions being made. But how can we be confident that forecasts are good enough if we don’t have any observations? How do we evaluate an impact-based forecast? And how do we communicate these limitations to all stakeholders? In this talk I will discuss some of the challenges we have faced, and some solutions.

    How to cite: Stephens, L., Mitheu, F., Speight, L., Hossain, S., Cloke, H., and Giodini, S.: How do we ensure that the humanitarian use of forecasts is robust?, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5901, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5901, 2022.

    EGU22-6618 | Presentations | HS4.5

    Machine learning tools for predicting multi-hazards caused by convective storms - the TAMIR project 

    Seppo Pulkkinen, Tero Niemi, Annakaisa von Lerber, Miikka Leinonen, and Tiia Renlund

    Convective storms and long-lasting mesoscale convective systems have the potential to cause heavy rainfall, flooding, hail, wind gusts and lightning that can result in significant damage to property and loss of lives. Accurate prediction of the location or severity of such storms (e.g. in the sub-kilometer resolution for the next hour) to assist the decision-making of civil protection authorities is beyond the capabilities of the current numerical weather prediction models. Thus, weather radar and machine learning-based methods provide an important tool to predict such events and their impacts in advance. Identifying a storm cell or system as an “object” from a radar image provides a natural way for associating different meteorological attributes of a storm with its impacts. In the TAMIR project funded by the EU Civil Protection Mechanism, we have implemented this by combining a cell tracking system with a machine learning model. The hazard levels of storms are estimated from their distance and time delay to the associated emergency reports obtained from the PRONTO database provided by the Finnish civil protection authorities. Using several meteorological attributes related to severe weather (e.g. lightning flash, hail and wind observations and indicators of convective potential), a random forest model was trained for predicting the storm hazard level. This was done by using a large sample of data during summer months between 2013-2020. The model for predicting the hazard level was verified by cross-validation. A Kalman filter-based methodology was applied for probabilistic nowcasting of future storm locations, which was combined with the model for hazard level prediction. Finally, the hazard nowcasts were combined with different exposure layers to translate them into prediction of impacts caused by convective storms. In the presentation, we demonstrate the added value of the implemented hazard and impact nowcast products with case studies. The products have also been evaluated by the Finnish civil protection authorities during the test period June-September 2021 with largely positive feedback. While the feasibility of the proposed methodology is demonstrated in Finland, discussion about its transferability to other parts of the world is also given.

    How to cite: Pulkkinen, S., Niemi, T., von Lerber, A., Leinonen, M., and Renlund, T.: Machine learning tools for predicting multi-hazards caused by convective storms - the TAMIR project, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6618, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6618, 2022.

    EGU22-8204 | Presentations | HS4.5

    Disaster Risk Financing systems for fluvial flood risk in Democratic Republic of Congo and Pakistan 

    John Bevington, Heather Forbes, Kay Shelton, Richard Smith, Elizabeth Wood, Paul Maisey, and Sophie Ludlam

    Flood Foresight is JBA’s strategic flood forecasting system, providing flood inundation and depth estimates at 30m resolution up to 10-days ahead of fluvial flood events.  The system is globally scalable and recent projects have seen the Forecasting module provide forecast flood footprints in Democratic Republic of Congo, Myanmar and the Indus River basin in Pakistan.  Data produced by these systems are being used for a variety of purposes including informing humanitarian anticipatory actions, parametric insurance and disaster risk financing.  This presentation will explore the use of Flood Foresight in Democratic Republic of Congo and Pakistan for the purposes of humanitarian disaster risk financing and demonstrate the benefits to this user community in otherwise data sparse regions. 

    Disaster Risk Financing (DRF) programmes are being developed for the Democratic Republic of Congo and Pakistan and are designed to allow civil society actors in country to proactively manage disaster risks. By quantifying risks in advance of disasters, pre-positioning funds, and releasing them according to pre-agreed plans, the user community are better placed to enable early disaster relief actions to help reduce the human and economic costs of disasters.  In both Democratic Republic of Congo and Pakistan, JBA were tasked with developing an operational fluvial flood forecasting model which can, at lead times of 0 – 10 days ahead, predict the number of people who will be inundated by fluvial flooding.

    For forecasting population impacts, JBA’s Flood Foresight system couples the Copernicus Global Flood Awareness System (GloFAS) with the Flood Foresight technology to generate daily probabilistic forecasts of flood inundation extents and depths.  From the maps generated, the system then generates estimates of the population at risk.  This fully automated early warning system is providing humanitarian organisations with daily forecasts of flood conditions to inform rapid financing for anticipatory actions designed to reduce overall humanitarian impact.  To help inform the definition of risk and subsequently set appropriate financing triggers, a probabilistic flood risk assessment was also developed using JBA’s Global Flood Model, providing national, province and territory level risk profiles of population affected by fluvial flooding.

    How to cite: Bevington, J., Forbes, H., Shelton, K., Smith, R., Wood, E., Maisey, P., and Ludlam, S.: Disaster Risk Financing systems for fluvial flood risk in Democratic Republic of Congo and Pakistan, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8204, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8204, 2022.

    EGU22-9001 | Presentations | HS4.5

    Windows of opportunity for Anticipatory Action along the crisis timeline for slow-onset hazards: a phased approach 

    Joshua Ngaina, Niccolo Lombardi, Dunja Dujanovic, Nora Guerten, Catherine Jones, Luca Parodi, Sergio Innocente, Brenda Lazarus, Quraishia Merzouk, and Siphokazi Moloinyane

    Slow-onset disasters build up gradually over time, often at the confluence of different hazards, and progressively erode livelihoods, especially among most vulnerable people. The aim of the paper is to summarize FAO’s conceptual and programmatic approach for anticipating and mitigating the impact of slow-onset hazards on the most vulnerable people depending on agriculture for their livelihoods and food security. In order to protect diverse livelihood groups at the right time before such sequenced impacts materialize, the phased approach to Anticipatory Action (AA) seeks to facilitate the identification of multiple windows of opportunity for anticipatory action along the crisis timeline of the slow-onset hazards. The five steps process include (1) determining who is at risk and when, (ii) which actions can be taken to mitigate hazard impacts, and when, (iii) how much time is needed to implement the actions selected, (iv) what kind of early warning information is available at the critical points in time identified and (v) bringing all the information together to define the action phases and the cut-off points beyond which an intervention cannot be considered ‘anticipatory’ anymore.  Since 2016, FAO has supported extensive country-level work on AA against several slow-onset hazards such as drought (e.g. in Kenya, Madagascar, Afghanistan, Philippines, Pakistan, and Sudan, among others), cold waves dzud (Mongolia), pests and diseases (e.g. desert locusts in the Greater Horn of Africa Region and Yemen), Rift valley fever in Kenya and the secondary consequences of COVID-19 (e.g. in Afghanistan, Bangladesh, the Democratic Republic of the Congo, Haiti, Kenya, Senegal, Sierra Leone, the Syrian Arab Republic, and Zimbabwe). Drawing on FAO’s experiences gathered in implementing AA and the technical expertise built over decades of supporting agriculture-based livelihoods, this paper recommends a phased approach to AA for slow-onset hazards as it reduces uncertainties associated with early warning information, improves the targeting of AA interventions, and helps adapt the selection of AA options to the evolving hazard context.

    How to cite: Ngaina, J., Lombardi, N., Dujanovic, D., Guerten, N., Jones, C., Parodi, L., Innocente, S., Lazarus, B., Merzouk, Q., and Moloinyane, S.: Windows of opportunity for Anticipatory Action along the crisis timeline for slow-onset hazards: a phased approach, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9001, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9001, 2022.

    EGU22-9300 | Presentations | HS4.5

    Towards a community-led approach to improve the design of early warning systems and anticipatory action for flood risk preparedness 

    Faith Mitheu, Elisabeth Stephens, Elena Tarnavsky, Andrea Ficchi, Rosalind Cornforth, and Celia Petty

    As the world faces an uncertain future due to climate variability, environmental and climate change, and an increase in extreme hydrometeorological events, investing in early warning early action mechanisms can be an effective way to prepare and adapt to changes and extremes and reduce any impending impacts. Such an investment will require an understanding of the information needs of the users/user-groups, and in particular, the communities at risk, to ensure the design of tailored anticipatory actions, as well as an evaluation of how forecasts perform in detecting these extreme events and their impacts. This helps to ensure that flood-risk preparedness actions are better contextualised and not taken in vain. Community-led approaches for anticipatory action planning are based on the engagement with the communities at risk and can be an effective way of ensuring that: 1) the information needs of the specific user-groups are identified and integrated with the development of preparedness actions and plans; 2) data on loss and damages to lives and livelihoods can be used to demonstrate how reliable the forecasts are in informing early actions at the community level; and 3) gaps and challenges that hinder effective use of early warning information are identified across user-groups to help improve on the design and dissemination of early warning information. In this talk, we bring together information collected at the community and disaster management levels together with a recent evaluation of flood forecasts using impact (loss and damage) reports at a district level, to show how community-led approaches can help towards improving early warning mechanisms. By integrating global hydro-meteorological forecasts with information on crop calendars and impact reports collected from farmers and local communities, an enhanced impact-based flood early warning system focusing on crop impacts, as well as the natural hazard, is developed for a flood-prone district in Uganda (Katakwi).

    How to cite: Mitheu, F., Stephens, E., Tarnavsky, E., Ficchi, A., Cornforth, R., and Petty, C.: Towards a community-led approach to improve the design of early warning systems and anticipatory action for flood risk preparedness, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9300, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9300, 2022.

    EGU22-10916 | Presentations | HS4.5

    Towards use of extreme rainfall forecast and socio-economic data to generate Impact-based forecasts 

    Akshay Singhal, Ashwin Raman, and Sanjeev Jha

    Each year India witnesses numerous casualties, economic losses and vast displacement of people due to extreme rainfall events (EREs). One of the reasons for such losses is that the weather warnings associated with the EREs are not properly communicated to the general public. It is essential that the expected impacts are communicated well in advance so that appropriate remedial actions can be taken and losses can be minimized. Several national and regional rainfall forecasting agencies have started issuing risk-based warnings which includes the potential impacts arising due to the EREs. This framework of providing forecast information based on the potential impacts of a hazard is called Impact-Based Forecasting (IBF). In this study, we develop a framework for generating the impact-based forecasts and associated warning matrices for the districts of eastern Uttar Pradesh, India, by integrating the rainfall forecasts and the socio-economic characteristics of the region. The region is densely populated, has relatively poor socio-economic conditions and is prone to frequent EREs. We take into account various sectors such as population, economy and agriculture where maximum impacts are expected to take place. Moreover, we identify the vulnerable districts based on the frequency of the number of extreme rainfall forecasts in the past four years (2017-2020) and the nature of socio-economic conditions. The vulnerable districts are categorized in three categories (low, medium and high) based on the expected impacts. For each of the vulnerable districts, sample IBFs and warning matrices are generated. IBFs inform about the possible impacts different sectors in each district may face on a given day due to the forecasted ERE. On the other hand, warning matrices provide updated information regarding the category of risk for the district a few days in advance. The study is significant since it follows a methodological framework to generate impact-based forecasts and warnings which includes analysis of rainfall forecasts, identification of possible impacts and suggestion of appropriate mitigation actions.

    How to cite: Singhal, A., Raman, A., and Jha, S.: Towards use of extreme rainfall forecast and socio-economic data to generate Impact-based forecasts, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10916, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10916, 2022.

    EGU22-12660 | Presentations | HS4.5

    Co-designing Global Water Watch for Anticipatory Action 

    Emie Klein Holkenborg, Hessel Winsemius, and Marc van den Homberg

    Climate change, political instability, and the non-sustainable use of water threaten the per capita water resources of dependent societies and severely impact communities during a period of below-average rainfall. To combat the increasing impact of drought disasters, the International Red Cross Red Crescent Movement focuses on Anticipatory Action. The indication of the status quo of droughts is vital in the anticipation of natural disasters. This indication is potentially benefitted by data on the freshwater reserves. Global Water Watch, being developed by Deltares, WRI, and WWF, is the first online platform providing open access, transparent, and near real-time information on the (historic) water dynamics of fresh surface water resources across the globe, ranging from small to large water bodies. The dataset ranges from 1985 to the present and is derived from earth observation data using artificial intelligence on a global scale. In the scope of Human Centred Design, co-design sessions were held with representatives of Red Cross Red Crescent National Societies in Mozambique, Eswatini, and Zimbabwe. The results were analyzed in a persona journey, gap analysis, and product definition. This resulted in the identification of five potential products of Global Water Watch, related to Anticipatory Action as well as responsive action, the traditional disaster management method used by National Societies. The priority in the recommendation was based on the products their effort in development, relative to their impact. Products that are considered low-hanging fruits in development (high impact, low effort) are monitoring surface waters in near-real-time, and the service of providing data in an API. This ensures that the data can be used in the Impact Based Forecasting platform, developed by 510. Over the long run, a reservoir volume monitor in near-real-time is recommended (high impact, high effort). Also, a long-term recommendation is a product that ensures the export of data in a specific format that can be easily read and shared via email and WhatsApp (low impact, low effort). Last, a product that estimates the future volume of reservoirs (high impact, high effort) could be considered. However, it is not sure if the impact is worth the effort, especially in a situation where a reservoir volume monitor in near-real-time might already be in place.  

    How to cite: Klein Holkenborg, E., Winsemius, H., and van den Homberg, M.: Co-designing Global Water Watch for Anticipatory Action, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12660, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12660, 2022.

    EGU22-12673 | Presentations | HS4.5

    Assessing the riverine flood forecast skill of GloFAS with streamflow observations and impact data: a case study for Mali 

    Marc van den Homberg, Andrea Ficchi, Phuoc Phung, Sidiky Sangare, Abdouramane Gado Djibo, and Cheikh Kane

    Riverine floods are one of Mali's most devastating and frequently occurring disasters. However, so far, actions linked to it are mainly post-disaster ones. For this reason, the Mali Red Cross has recently established with partners a Forecast-based Financing mechanism that triggers early actions to reduce the impacts of floods once a predefined trigger is reached. Given the lack of forecasts at the national scale, the current trigger model is based only on real-time observations from the hydrological monitoring network of the National Directorate of Hydraulics (DNH): if the observed upstream water level exceeds the 5-year return period, an action is triggered to prepare for floods downstream, four days ahead, taking into account the delays in the propagation of the flood. Global flood forecasting systems can possibly complement this local flood monitoring model, especially in large transboundary river basins. This research aims to investigate the riverine flood forecast skill of the Global Flood Awareness System (GloFAS version 3.1, part of the Copernicus Emergency Management Service) in the Niger river basin by evaluating reforecast data against two reference datasets: river flow observations and impact data. The False Alarm Ratio (FAR) and the Probability of Detection (POD) have been calculated for all available extended-range reforecasts (lead times up to 46 days) over a 20-year period and for 15 river gauge station locations. For the skill assessment of GloFAS against river flow observations, most river gauge stations with enough observed data (8 out of 15) show good and robust skill scores for all lead times up to 10 days. For the skill assessment based on impact data, even though at some stations the POD is good, the FAR is too high. A preliminary conclusion is that setting trigger levels for longer lead times (up to 10 days) - to complement the existing monitoring system with a four-day lead time - can be done only for those locations where enough historical observed data is available. Using impact data to set triggers is currently hampered by limitations of the impact dataset, such as no precise event dates and locations.

    How to cite: van den Homberg, M., Ficchi, A., Phung, P., Sangare, S., Gado Djibo, A., and Kane, C.: Assessing the riverine flood forecast skill of GloFAS with streamflow observations and impact data: a case study for Mali, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12673, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12673, 2022.

    EGU22-12707 | Presentations | HS4.5 | Highlight

    Beyond hazard: Combining pan-European exposure data with flash flood hazard forecasts to create impact forecasts for civil protection agencies 

    Eleanor Hansford, Calum Baugh, Christel Prudhomme, Marc Berenguer, Shinju Park, Annakaisa von Lerber, Anna Berruezo, Victor González, Juan Colonese, Corentin Carton de Wiart, Seppo Pulkkinen, and Tero Niemi

    As part of TAMIR, a European Commission Civil Protection Preparedness project (ID. 874435), probabilistic operational pan-European flash flood impact forecasts with lead times from 0 to 120 hours have been developed by combining flash flood hazard forecasts with exposure data. Working with civil protection agencies, the aim is to develop forecasts which clearly identify the areas most at risk of serious impacts and therefore may require their intervention. Firstly, the project engaged with these agencies to identify their requirements of flash flood impact forecasts and which elements of exposure and important to them when assessing impacts. Accordingly, pan-European exposure data for population and critical infrastructure (health, education, transport, and energy generation facilities) were sourced from several open source datasets (HARCI-EU, OSM, GHS). These exposure data were (if necessary) regridded and cropped to the spatial domain, transformed to reduce skewness, and rescaled between 1 and 2 to give the datasets common units. The five exposure types were then added together and re-scaled, to produce a combined exposure layer with values ranging from 1 (low exposure) to 2 (high exposure). Flash flood hazard forecasts were created in a previous project by blending hourly ensemble precipitation nowcasts with ensemble numerical weather predictions (NWP) from the ECMWF IFS (Integrated Forecast System). These forecasts are created once per hour and have a lead time of up to 5 days. The flash flood impact forecasts were created by combining the hazard forecasts and exposure data on a two-dimensional impact matrix. Both axes of matrix are split into 3 categories (low, medium, high). For exposure, the ranges for each category were chosen based on the distribution of the data. For hazard, the low, medium, and high categories indicate where the forecast probability shows a 5%-50%, 50%-80%, and 80%+ likelihood of exceeding the 5-year return period threshold.

    Once developed, the impact forecasts were applied to 6 case studies of single flash flooding events across Europe chosen by the civil protection agencies, and the results presented to them. This helped evaluate the impact forecasts and enabled end users to provide feedback for further improvement. Results indicated the impact forecasts provided considerable added value compared to the hazard forecasts, by identifying targeted areas where serious impacts were observed. In the final stages of the project, the methods and products described here will be implemented in the European Flood Awareness System (EFAS) platform as a quasi-operational experimental product, and made available to the wider scientific community in the form of a Web Map Service Time (WMS-T) layer. Overall, this presentation focuses on the creation and communication of the exposure data and subsequent impact forecasts. Additionally, it outlines the evaluation of the impact forecasts, and the benefits obtained from engaging end users throughout the process. Finally, it highlights some of the challenges of using pan-European data and a continental scale forecast system to provide impact forecasts useful at the smaller scales required by decision makers.

    How to cite: Hansford, E., Baugh, C., Prudhomme, C., Berenguer, M., Park, S., von Lerber, A., Berruezo, A., González, V., Colonese, J., Carton de Wiart, C., Pulkkinen, S., and Niemi, T.: Beyond hazard: Combining pan-European exposure data with flash flood hazard forecasts to create impact forecasts for civil protection agencies, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12707, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12707, 2022.

    EGU22-12917 | Presentations | HS4.5

    Forecasting impacts of tropical cyclones with machine learning : A case study in the Philippines 

    Aklilu Teklesadik and Marc van den Homberg

    Due to its geographical location, the Philippines is highly exposed to Tropical Cyclones (TC). Every year at least one TC will make landfall and cause significant humanitarian impact and economic loss. To reduce the humanitarian impact of TC, the Philippine Red Cross with the German Red Cross and 510, an initiative of The Netherlands Red Cross, designed and implemented a Forecast Based Financing (FbF) system. The early actions in the FbF system are pre-identified and will be triggered when an impact-based forecasting model indicates a pre-defined danger level will be exceeded. This research develops and evaluates multiple ML algorithms for classification and regression with a lead time of 120 to 72hrs before TC landfall. The algorithms are trained on around 40 historical typhoon events and xx predictors on the hazard, vulnerability, coping capacity, and exposure are used. The classification model predicts if 10% of buildings in a municipality are completely damaged or not. The regression model gives the percentage of buildings that are completely damaged in a municipality. The RandomForest algorithm outperformed other algorithms for both classification and regression for both training and validation datasets. The ML models performed better than a baseline model (a wind-damage curve per building type) for the historical typhoon events. The Philippine Red Cross has been using the ML model since 2019, whereby actual forecast information from ECWMF replaces the historical hazard information at landfall. However, the ML impact-based forecasting model cannot be better than the hazard information that goes into it. Those typhoons that rapidly intensify cannot be captured at the cutoff of 72 hrs lead time (the minimum time required to start up early actions). But for the other typhoons, ML is very beneficial as a trigger tool for activating early actions and can support the reduction of the impact of typhoons on vulnerable communities.

    How to cite: Teklesadik, A. and van den Homberg, M.: Forecasting impacts of tropical cyclones with machine learning : A case study in the Philippines, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12917, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12917, 2022.

    To support Mozambique and Zimbabwe in the mitigation and management of droughts, the World Food Programme (WFP) is seeking to implement innovative approaches to protect people’s livelihood who face drought risk. The approach that has potential of closing the humanitarian funding gap is Forecast-based Financing (FbF). FbF enables anticipatory actions against droughts using seasonal forecasts, which are implemented to reduce impacts in the critical window between a forecast and an event. An important step for leveraging seasonal forecasting information to implement FbF is the development of an operational trigger system for drought anticipatory action.

    During the past year, WFP has been developing, and is currently testing, a FbF system for droughts in eight pilot districts across Mozambique and Zimbabwe using the ECMWF 7-month rainfall ensemble forecast. This system aims to reduce the impact of droughts by releasing anticipatory action based on the forecast of a drought of mild, moderate, and severe categories. In its current set up, droughts are defined in the system through the Standardized Precipitation Index (SPI), and therefore focuses on detecting rainfall anomalies within key months of the growing season in the pilot areas. Based on an extensive skill assessment, we find that there are several opportunities for implementing FbF against droughts in the four pilot districts using the ECMWF long-range forecasting information, which opens opportunities for scaling up.

    In addition to reliable seasonal forecast information, a drought FbF system requires substantial articulation between national actors on the selection of which forecast trigger to be used for the identified anticipatory action. For this, WFP has been working with several governmental agencies and stakeholders for a joint development of a nationally agreed drought contingency plan and system. However, given the inherent complexity of this climate phenomenon, reaching a common agreement on the definition of drought and a trigger menu is a difficult, and yet, a prime task. In addition, forecasting information should be coupled with a systematic decision of when to act to effectively enable the reduction of impacts as well as with a clear and standardized procedures of how to mobilize resources, to target beneficiaries and to act.

    With this abstract we seek to share lessons learnt and technical challenges experienced with the process of developing an operational drought forecast-based financing system embedded into national systems. Besides its complex and interlinked configuration, we believe that implementing FbF against droughts based on forecast information can help humanitarian organizations to prepare more articulated response plans that can better leverage and preserve the gain of development programming, reduce losses to livelihoods and cost of humanitarian operations while supporting communities in a more dignified manner.

     

    How to cite: Guimarães Nobre, G. and Bonifácio, R.: Drought Forecast-based Financing: lessons learned in building a trigger menu for anticipatory action in Mozambique and Zimbabwe, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-621, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-621, 2022.

    EGU22-754 | Presentations | HS4.6

    Assessing the seasonal forecast performance of hydrological extremes over Europe 

    Yiheng Du, Ilias Pechlivanidis, and Ilaria Clemenzi

    The attention given to hydro-climate services is continuously increasing due to the scientific improvements of hydrological models and numerical weather forecasts. However, there is still an urgent need to highlight the predictability of hydrological droughts and floods in order to meet the growing demand on hydrological forecast information from socio-economic sectors, such as energy production and agricultural irrigation. In this study, we evaluated the seasonal hydrological reforecasts generated by the E-HYPE hydrological model forced with predictions from the fifth-generation seasonal forecasting system of the European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasts (ECMWF SEAS5), covering the period 1993-2015. The forecast skill was benchmarked to the simulated streamflow climatology by calculating the Brier Skill Scores for both high and low streamflow for each initialization month and lead time. Results show that both hydrological droughts and flooding over Europe are generally well predicted, with spatial and temporal variability depending on the initialization month and lead time. The results are of high importance since geographical areas and times are identified where the seasonal hydrological forecasts provide an added-value for flooding and droughts, and consequently contribute to decision-making in water resources management.

    How to cite: Du, Y., Pechlivanidis, I., and Clemenzi, I.: Assessing the seasonal forecast performance of hydrological extremes over Europe, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-754, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-754, 2022.

    EGU22-2804 | Presentations | HS4.6

    Translating seasonal climate forecasts into decision-relevant water security forecasts 

    David MacLeod, Dagmawi Asfaw, Katerina Michaelides, Erick Otenyo, Abebe Tadege, Zewdu Segele, George Otieno, Khalid Hassaballah, Andrés Quichimbo, Mark Cuthbert, and Michael Singer

    Early warning of drought conditions can help protect lives and livelihoods, especially in dry regions of subsistence agriculture and pastoralism. Regions such as the Horn of Africa Drylands (HAD) may benefit from advance warning of changes to available water supplies, as rural communities make critical decisions about planting and moving livestock at particular points in time. However whilst the regionally-mandated seasonal forecast for HAD provides information on rainfall totals, it does not quantify expected impacts on water balance components such as soil moisture and groundwater storage. This latter information may be more useful to rural communities who rely on groundwater for water resources for humans and livestock, and soil moisture for crop growth. These hydrological quantities can typically be estimated with hydrological models, but in drylands the processes governing water partitioning are complex and largely unrepresented in most existing regional and global hydrological models. 

     

    Here we leverage the capability of a dryland-specific hydrological model (DRYP) to produce rainfall-driven water security forecasts for HAD. DRYP incorporates spatially varying rainfall and evaporative demand, dynamic surface-groundwater interactions, ephemeral flow through channels and focused groundwater recharge. We employ DRYP in a pilot application to produce seasonal forecasts of soil moisture and groundwater recharge for a large catchment within the HAD. We use the objective seasonal forecasts provided by the IGAD Climate Prediction and Application Centre (ICPAC) and disseminated within the Greater Horn of Africa Climate Outlook Forum (GHACOF). Methodological approaches to integrate DRYP with the regional climate outlook disseminated by ICPAC are described, along with evaluation of potential skill of these new water security forecasts for the regional pilot catchment. Finally, we describe and update on an active forecast pilot activity, where water security forecasts for the current rainfall season (March-May 2022) have been co-produced with ICPAC and disseminated to stakeholders in February 2022 as part of the GHACOF event, now publicly available via the ICPAC East Africa Hazards Watch platform, under the EU H2020-funded DOWN2EARTH project. Co-design activity arising from recent stakeholder workshops will be described.

    How to cite: MacLeod, D., Asfaw, D., Michaelides, K., Otenyo, E., Tadege, A., Segele, Z., Otieno, G., Hassaballah, K., Quichimbo, A., Cuthbert, M., and Singer, M.: Translating seasonal climate forecasts into decision-relevant water security forecasts, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2804, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2804, 2022.

    EGU22-5720 | Presentations | HS4.6 | Highlight

    The Water and Climate Coalition: Establishing a Globally Connected Water Resources Assessment System   

    Michael Peter Schwab, Gregory Davies-Jones, Sulagna Mishra, and Johannes Cullmann

    Water is key to sustainable development and improving resilience to climate change yet, sixty percent of countries worldwide report declining water monitoring capabilities. This decline, combined with a growing information gap, hinders optimal use and planning of water resources.  

    Water information is needed for effective and efficient water management and climate change adaptation. Currently, this information is fragmented, has large gaps and is partially inaccessible. We want to empower national water management by catalyzing international cooperation through trustful bilateral and multilateral water assessments and outlooks. We want to create a global system that is consistent, interconnected, and helps current and future generations to better understand how global hydrological cycles respond to a changing climate and anthropogenic factors. 

    A fundamental arm of the Paris Agreement is the Global Stocktake: a component employed to monitor implementation and evaluate the collective progress made in achieving the agreed carbon goals. In conjunction with the climate stocktake, there is a need for a water resources assessment system that can feed local, regional and global hydrological data into modelling systems. This data can then support evaluations and inform decision processes – in other words, a water stocktake. 

    An example of a water resources assessment system under the framework of the Water and Climate Coalition (water-climate-coalition.org) and its partners is the World Meteorological Organization (WMO) Hydrological Status and Outlook System (HydroSOS). HydroSOS aims to cement itself as a chief constituent of this water stocktake – capable of providing actionable information of current and future water availability. HydroSOS intends to strengthen the capacity of National Meteorological and Hydrological Services (NMHSs) to develop a system capable of assessing the status of surface and subsurface hydrological systems and predicting how they will change in the future. HydroSOS is the first global operational mechanism for integrating reliable and timely hydrological status assessments and outlooks that is consistent and comparable on a global scale in collaboration with producers and users of hydrological information.  

    How to cite: Schwab, M. P., Davies-Jones, G., Mishra, S., and Cullmann, J.: The Water and Climate Coalition: Establishing a Globally Connected Water Resources Assessment System  , EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5720, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5720, 2022.

    EGU22-6155 | Presentations | HS4.6

    How long do initial conditions prevail over boundary conditions in streamflow forecasting in South America? 

    Ingrid Petry, Fernando Fan, and Louise Crochemore

    In the model-based streamflow forecasting context, initial conditions (ICs) and meteorological forcings (boundary conditions) are two important drivers of predictability. While the meteorological forcings increasingly influence forecasts at long time horizons, ICs’ influence tends to decrease, being nonetheless the predominant source of predictability at short time horizons. Quantifying the period of time when the ICs contribute to streamflow predictability can help researchers and water managers to choose the best forecasting method for each study area and horizon, balancing computational effort and streamflow forecast accuracy. In this work we quantify IC's prevalence time over boundary conditions in natural river flow forecasts in large basins (>1000km²) in South America (SA) from the MGB-SA model, a continental and hydrodynamic version of the MGB conceptual semi-distributed hydrological model. The methodology consisted of forcing MGB-SA with null precipitation as meteorological forcing, so that all the predictability obtained from the experiments was due to ICs. Streamflow experiments had a 215-day horizon, monthly initialization, daily timestep and comprehended the period of 1990 to 2010. The results were compared to the MGB-SA streamflow simulations with MSWEP as observed rainfall. Errors from the hydrological model were thus not considered in this analysis. The prevalence (T50) was estimated by the horizon (from 1 to 215 days) when streamflow predictability was degraded by 50%, i.e. when meteorological forcings start prevailing over ICs. Predictability was estimated by the performance indicator KGE, and the T50 for each of the river reaches of MGB-SA was presented in a map. The T50 map shows that the shortest IC’s prevalence on streamflow predictability is observed on riverheads, ranging from 1 to 3 days. IC's influence increases near the main reaches of the great rivers of SA, reaching up to 10 days on the Iguaçu River and up to 20 days on the Oricono River and Araguaia River. T50 is up to 40 and 90 days on reaches of the Amazon River, Atlantic coast of North Argentina and Pantanal plains. In general, IC’s influence is higher in the main river reaches of basins with flat relief, due to their greater drainage area and the slow response time of the basin.

    How to cite: Petry, I., Fan, F., and Crochemore, L.: How long do initial conditions prevail over boundary conditions in streamflow forecasting in South America?, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6155, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6155, 2022.

    EGU22-6456 | Presentations | HS4.6

    Assessing skills of the ULYSSES global multi-model hydrological seasonal prediction system 

    Pallav Kumar Shrestha, Luis Samaniego, Stephan Thober, Alberto Martínez-de La Torre, Edwin Sutanudjaja, Oldrich Rakovec, Matthias Kelbling, Eleanor Blyth, and Niko Wanders

    It is a well-known fact that multi-model forecast systems provide greater reliability over single-model systems, as hydrological models have a solid contribution to forecast uncertainty [1]. Yet many prevalent skill scores for verification of forecasting systems are calculated relative to a benchmark skill. Benchmark skills across hydrological models could vary largely because the benchmark simulation is biased. This bias is not accounted for in the benchmark skill. For example, hydrological models with a high auto-correlation in their state variables tend to have increased skill but do not necessarily have the lowest error when compared against observations [2]. Thus, the correct interpretation of skill can only be conducted if the models are compared against the ground truth, i.e. observations.

    With this outlook, we assess the performance of ULYSSES [3] - the first seamless global multi-model hydrological seasonal prediction system. Using four state-of-the-art hydrological models (Jules, HTESSEL, mHM, and PCR-GLOBWB), the production chain utilizes identical land surface datasets (e.g. DEM, soil properties) and forecast inputs for all HMs, and the same river routing scheme (i.e., the multi-scale Routing Model; mRM). The system initializes based on the ERA5-Land dataset, and the seasonal forecasts are driven by a 51-member ensemble generated by the ECMWF seasonal forecasting system 5.

    The skill assessment includes the verification of seasonal streamflow forecast at 2400+ GRDC gauges distributed globally during the period from 1993 to 2019, at a monthly time scale. The set of skill scores considered includes metrics concerning monthly observations (Kling-Gupta efficiency skill score, i.e., KGESS, KGE components, Equitable Threat Score for droughts, relative bias), skills with reference to benchmark run (CRPSS) and skills on forecast characteristic (forecast extremity, spread). On average, the system was found to have the skill (monthly KGESS) at most for two months. At the lead of 1 month, mHM exhibits KGESS of 0.56, HTESSEL has KGESS of 0.5, Jules 0.48, and PCR-GLOBWB 0.46. A KGESS value of one corresponds to a perfect forecast. Evaluating the median KGE r component (or Pearson's correlation), mHM (0.68), PCR-GLOBWB (0.59), HTESSEL (0.59) and Jules (0.57). The percentage of gauges with positive KGESS is distributed evenly with PCR-GLOBWB (84.9 %), HTESSEL (84.2 %), Jules (82.4 %) and mHM (80.5 %). Model performances over median skill and gauges with positive skill indicates models to have contrasting performance at high and low skill gauges. Besides, the spatial distribution of KGESS shows marked seasonal changes in the skill of the hydrological models. All of this provides insights on the strengths and weaknesses of the models for further improvement of the system.

    In the future, the skill assessment would be expanded to additionally compare forecasted fluxes and state variables (e.g., terrestrial water storage anomalies, soil moisture) against other observations such as GRACE, SMOS, etc. All ULYSSES outputs will be made available in the Copernicus Climate Data Store [4] and will be open access. We aim to engage institutions and researchers around the world that are willing to evaluate the forecasts model performance to improve the system in the future.

    [1] https://doi.org/10.1175/BAMS-D-17-0274.1

    [2] https://doi.org/10.1175/JHM-D-18-0040.1

    [3] https://www.ufz.de/ulysses

    [4] https://cds.climate.copernicus.eu

    How to cite: Shrestha, P. K., Samaniego, L., Thober, S., Martínez-de La Torre, A., Sutanudjaja, E., Rakovec, O., Kelbling, M., Blyth, E., and Wanders, N.: Assessing skills of the ULYSSES global multi-model hydrological seasonal prediction system, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6456, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6456, 2022.

    EGU22-7149 | Presentations | HS4.6

    Seasonal forecasting of Alpine snow depth: evaluation of a climate service prototype 

    Silvia Terzago, Giulio Bongiovanni, and Jost von Hardenberg

    Mountain glacier shrinking, seasonal snow cover reduction and changes in the amount and seasonality of meltwater runoff are already affecting water availability for both local and downstream uses. Water is needed by different competing sectors including drinking water supply, energy production, agriculture, tourism, and extremely dry seasons can lead to economic losses. Reducing potential impacts of changes in water availability involves multiple time scales, from the decadal time scale for the realization of water management infrastructures to the seasonal scale, to plan the use of water resources and allocate them with some lead time.

    In the framework of the MEDSCOPE ERA4CS project we focused on the seasonal time scale and we developed a climate service prototype to estimate the temporal evolution of snow depth and snow water equivalent with up to 7 months lead time. Forecasts are initialized on November 1st and run up to May 31st of the following year. The prototype has been co-designed with and tailored to the needs of water and hydropower plant managers and of mountain ski resorts managers. 

    We present the modelling chain, based on the seasonal forecasts of ECMWF and Météo-France seasonal prediction systems, made available through the Copernicus Climate Change Service (C3S). Seasonal forecasts of precipitation, near-surface air temperature, radiative fluxes, wind and humidity are bias-corrected and downscaled to three high elevation sites in the North-Western Italian Alps, and finally used as input for a physically-based multi-layer snow model (SNOWPACK). The RainFARM stochastic downscaling procedure adapted for mountain regions is used for downscaling precipitation data, and stochastic realizations are employed to estimate the uncertainty due to the downscaling method.

    The skill of the prototype in predicting the monthly snow depth evolution from November to May in each season of the hindcast period 1995-2015 is demonstrated using station observations as a reference. We show the correlation between forecasted and observed snow depth and we quantify the forecast quality in terms of reliability, resolution, discrimination and sharpness using a set of probabilistic measures (Brier Skill Score, Area Under the ROC Curve Skill Score and Continuous Ranked Probability Skill Score). We finally discuss implications of the forecast quality at different lead times as well as the added value of bias-correction and downscaling of precipitation data on snow depth forecasts. Real-time snow forecasts for the current season (2021-2022) and for earlier ones are available at this link: http://wilma.to.isac.cnr.it/diss/snowpack/snowseas-eng.html

    How to cite: Terzago, S., Bongiovanni, G., and von Hardenberg, J.: Seasonal forecasting of Alpine snow depth: evaluation of a climate service prototype, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7149, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7149, 2022.

    EGU22-7663 | Presentations | HS4.6

    Introduction to the CO-MICC pilot climate service: Supporting risk assessment and adaptation by providing multi-model based information on freshwater-related hazards of climate change for all land areas of the globe 

    Stephan Dietrich, Denise Cáceres, Fabian Kneier, Petra Doell, Harald Koethe, and Dirk Schwanenberg and the CO-MICC consortium

    While decision makers in climate-dependent sectors are increasingly considering climate change (CC) in their risk portfolios, there is a structural lack of information on how to assess specific CC-related risks and what to do in practice. The ERA4CS (European Research Area for Climate Services) supported the CO-MICC research project (2017-2021) that aimed to co-develop in a participatory manner with potential end-users how the output of global hydrological models can be optimally used to support climate change risk assessment of freshwater-related hazards at different scales.

    In particular, it was investigated how the output of multiple global hydrological models (e.g., groundwater recharge or streamflow), each driven by the output of multiple global climate models, can be best provided in an interactive map-based web service to show the range of plausible future impacts of climate change on freshwater. Data sources are state-of-the-art global future projections following the ISIMIP (Inter-Sectoral Impact Model Intercomparison Project) protocol simulated by the modelling groups of the CO-MICC consortium from PIK, IIASA and Goethe University Frankfurt. In addition, methods for using the relatively coarse information (0.5° by 0.5° grid cells) in regional and local climate change risk assessments were investigated. Through an iterative dialogue process in three rounds of workshops, scientists and end-users learned from each other which particular hydrologic information is valuable for end-user risk assessments - and how to best communicate that information so that it can be practically used by end-users around the world in local, transboundary, and global climate change adaptation and mitigation planning.

    The climate service was developed by the CO-MICC consortium and is freely available as a pilot application to all users worldwide at www.co-micc.eu. The web portal of the climate service consists of two components, the knowledge portal and the data portal, respectively. The interactive data portal provides free and easy access to multi-model-based data on future freshwater availability on a global scale. It is a web-based information system that provides access to freshwater-related indicators of climate change hazards for all land areas of the globe except Greenland and Antarctica. The data are visualized and provided for individual 0.5° grid cells or aggregated at the basin or country level. The data viewer contains map display, showing spatio-temporal developments, and a data analysis tool can be used to create statistical and graphical representations of the data. In the knowledge portal, in addition to the introduction to the methodology, online trainings as well as the PUNI (Providing and Utilizing eNsemble Information) handbook are included.

    In December 2021, the CO-MICC knowledge and data portal was launched supported by WMO and UNESCO. The pilot climate service is hosted by the UNESCO Center ICWRGC in conjunction with the German Federal Institute of Hydrology. We will demonstrate the capabilities of the interactive web platform and will provide details on the development process.

    How to cite: Dietrich, S., Cáceres, D., Kneier, F., Doell, P., Koethe, H., and Schwanenberg, D. and the CO-MICC consortium: Introduction to the CO-MICC pilot climate service: Supporting risk assessment and adaptation by providing multi-model based information on freshwater-related hazards of climate change for all land areas of the globe, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7663, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7663, 2022.

    EGU22-8741 | Presentations | HS4.6

    Evaluation of different forecasting approaches in predicting the spring flood in Northern Sweden 

    Wei Yang, Kean Foster, and Ilias G Pechlivanidis

    About 70% of the annual streamflow volume in Northern Sweden is generated during the spring flood (i.e., May-July), and consequently this relatively short period is of great significance to the hydropower industry. Moreover, the mismatch in the timing between the energy demand and the natural streamflow generation, as well as the condition to regulate the reservoirs for flooding control, make the storage management challenging.

    Over the past years, different methodologies have been developed to enhance the skilfulness of seasonal hydrological forecasts. Ensemble streamflow prediction (ESP) is a well-established approach in which a hydrological model is forced with historical meteorological observations, hence representing a climatological evolution constrained by the initial hydrological conditions. In addition, dynamic forecasting employs bias-adjusted (at least in most cases) seasonal forecasts of daily precipitation and temperature from Global Circulation Models (GCM) to force a hydrological model to estimate the hydrological evolution. Moreover, statistical forecasting is based on deriving links between predictors and predictands, for instance large-scale atmospheric variables and observed spring flooding volume can be used to make forecasts of the seasonal inflow volumes. Another approach is based on analogue conditioned ESP (A-ESP) and uses hydrological weather regimes (HWRs) as a condition to select analogues from the historical ensemble of meteorological observations and combining these together with the ESP to create a weighted ESP. The HWRs are based on large-scale circulation patterns and optimized using local precipitation observations.

    Here, we compare the A-ESP approach against statistical and dynamic forecasting approaches in predicting the spring flood in 84 sub-catchments in Northern Sweden. The forecast skills are assessed by using the traditional ESP approach as a benchmark. The results show that: (1) the A-ESP can improve forecast skill at all lead-times, (2) statistical forecasting is of most benefit for forecasts with long lead-times, and (3) dynamic forecasting has limited skill at short lead-times. 

    How to cite: Yang, W., Foster, K., and Pechlivanidis, I. G.: Evaluation of different forecasting approaches in predicting the spring flood in Northern Sweden, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8741, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8741, 2022.

    EGU22-9612 | Presentations | HS4.6

    Evaluation of the accuracy of drought-related seasonal forecasts using large-scale hydrological modelling and drought indices 

    Hector Macian-Sorribes, Tatiana Vargas-Mora, Ilias Pechlivanidis, and Manuel Pulido-Velazquez

    Drought is one of the most severe weather-induced natural hazards, causing significant economic and environmental impacts to water and water-related systems. Drought indices can be used to monitor, manage and anticipate drought events and their undesired consequences. In this regard, large-scale hydrological models can provide drought indices to assess drought risks under a harmonized and integrated view, including meteorological, soil and hydrological processes. Moreover, seasonal forecasting of droughts can provide longer anticipation times than the application of drought indices to current and near past records.

    In this study we take advantage of seasonal forecasts from large-scale hydrological models and generate drought indices for the anticipation of meteorological, agricultural (soil moisture) and hydrological droughts. Seasonal forecasts from the pan-European E-HYPE hydrological model, forced by bias‐adjusted ECMWF SEAS5 forecasts, are employed. The analysis period is 1993-2015. A sample of 617 sub-basins from E-HYPE was chosen taking into account the different hydroclimatic regimes found in Europe. The variables considered are: precipitation and precipitation less than potential evapotranspiration (meteorological drought); soil moisture (agricultural drought); and streamflow (hydrological drought). For each variable, different probability distributions are tested and the most suitable one is selected using a two-step automatic procedure programmed in Python. Firstly, the theoretical function for each variable with the best fit to the empirical distribution is selected using the sum of squares method, the Kolmogorov-Smirnov test and the QQ-plot. Afterwards, the fitting of the tails of the distribution is evaluated by the D’Agostino’s K-squared, Shapiro and Wilcoxon tests. In case of a failure in fitting the tails, the fitting of the distribution is re-calculated. The selected probability distribution is further used to compute the standardized drought indices (SPI and SPEI for meteorological, SSMI for agricultural, and SSI for hydrological droughts) at the monthly scale, with temporal aggregations of 1, 3, 6 and 12 months for the historical period. Afterwards, seasonal drought index forecasts are calculated for each initialization month, lead month, and temporal aggregation.

    The skill of these forecasts is evaluated with respect to the modelled variables using the Absolute Mean Error (MAE) and the Continuous Ranked Probability Score (CRPS). The results show how the predictability of droughts changes across drought type, hydroclimatic regime, temporal aggregation and lead month.

    Acknowledgements: This study has been supported by the ADAPTAMED project (RTI2018-101483-B-I00), funded by the Ministerio de Economia y Competitividad (MINECO) of Spain including EU FEDER funds; and the subvencions del Programa per a la promoció de la investigación científica, el desenvolupament tecnològic i la innovació a la Comunitat Valenciana (PROMETEO) under the WATER4CAST project.

    How to cite: Macian-Sorribes, H., Vargas-Mora, T., Pechlivanidis, I., and Pulido-Velazquez, M.: Evaluation of the accuracy of drought-related seasonal forecasts using large-scale hydrological modelling and drought indices, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9612, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9612, 2022.

    EGU22-10164 | Presentations | HS4.6

    Seasonal forecast of land indicators for decision-making in the field of agriculture, forestry and hydrology 

    André Chanzy, Patrick bertuzzi, Elisa Kamir, Hendrik Davi, Jean-Luc Dupuy, Nicolas Martin, Guillaume Pouget, Marc Lagier, Olivier Maury, Inaki Garcia de Cortazar, Christian Viel, and Jean-Michel Soubeyroux

    Many decisions in the field of agriculture, forestry and/or hydrology can get profit from seasonal forecast. However, the skill of such forecast is a critical issue to promote their use in operational context and get profitable decisions. If many methods to assess meteorological forecast performances are available, they are mostly implemented on raw climate variables, while their implementation in sectorial application remains limited to some case studies. In this study a wide range of indicators covering most of the decision-making needs in agriculture, forestry and in some extent to hydrology were considered. These indicators are either direct climate variables, a combination of climate variables, or variables calculated by dynamic models (e.g. a crop model). The study was implemented in southern France using the Méteo-France system 6 1993-2016 hindcast, downscaled using the UERRA reanalysis and the ADAMONT methods available in CS-Tools R package developed in the frame of the MEDSCOPE project. These computed indicators need various climate variables as wind speed, radiation and air humidity while most of the downscaling methods were designed for air temperature and precipitation. The main results are the following.

    • We showed that all variables led to comparable level of accuracy. Seasonal forecasts provide added value compared to climatological forecasts with Brier Skill Scores between 0.05 and 0.20.
    • The predictability of the number of rainy days or the number of days with temperature above a threshold is comparable to those of the corresponding scalar quantities such as cumulative precipitation or mean air temperature. However seasonal forecast of extreme events such as heat waves or drought episodes was not possible.
    • Indicators combining several climatic information such as potential evapotranspiration or fire weather index have comparable predictability than the individual climate variables used in the calculation.
    • With indicators based on dynamic models, the memory effect, i.e. the effect of the system state at the beginning of the forecast period, has a strong impact on the skill scores. We propose a methodology based on an ANOVA to qualify this memory effect by using the F-value. It is shown that when the memory effect is strong (F-value >10) the seasonal forecast does not bring any added value compared to the climatological forecast.
    • An evaluation of the interest of a seasonal forecast in a decision-making framework was carried out by an economic approach. We have based our analysis on the decision making based on the forecast of an event. We show that there is a generic relationship between the AUC score and the gain from the forecast. We show that this relationship depends on the frequency of the decision event, the rarer the event the higher the AUC value must be to have a profitable decision. In our case, a decision based on the detection of a tercile leads to a profitable decision in more than half of the indicators while no indicator leads to a profitable decision when it is based on the detection of a quintile.

    How to cite: Chanzy, A., bertuzzi, P., Kamir, E., Davi, H., Dupuy, J.-L., Martin, N., Pouget, G., Lagier, M., Maury, O., Garcia de Cortazar, I., Viel, C., and Soubeyroux, J.-M.: Seasonal forecast of land indicators for decision-making in the field of agriculture, forestry and hydrology, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10164, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10164, 2022.

    EGU22-10661 | Presentations | HS4.6 | Highlight

    I-CISK: Towards a social and behaviourally informed approach to co-producing climate services 

    Micha Werner, Ilyas Masih, Rebecca Emerton, Ilias Pechlivanidis, Marije Schaafsma, Lluís Pesquer, Giuliano di Baldassare, Marc van den Homberg, Stefano Bagli, Megi Gamtkitsulashvili, Lucia De Stefano, Benedikt Gräler, Györgyi Bela, and Apostolis Tzimas

    Climate Services (CS) are crucial in empowering citizens, stakeholders and decision-makers in defining resilient pathways to adapt to climate change and extreme events. Whilst recent decades have seen significant advances in the science that underpins CS; from sub-seasonal, seasonal through to climate scale predictions; there are several barriers to the uptake of CS and realising of the full opportunity of their value-proposition. Challenges include incorporating the social and behavioural factors, and the local knowledge and customs of climate services users; the poorly developed understanding of the multi-temporal and multi-scalar dimension of climate-related impacts and actions; the translation of CS-provided data into actionable information; and, the consideration of reinforcing or balancing feedback loops associated to users’ decisions.

    The ambition of the recently initiated EU-H2020 I-CISK research & innovation project in addressing these challenges, is to instigate a step-change to co-producing CS through a social and behaviourally informed approach. The trans-disciplinary framework the research sets out to develop recognises that climate relevant decisions consider multiple knowledges; innovating CS through integrating local knowledge, perceptions and preferences of users with scientific climate data and predictions.

    In this contribution we reflect on initial steps in setting up seven living labs in climate hotspots in Europe and Africa. Instrumental to the research, we will work from these living labs with multi-actor platforms that span multiple sectors to co-design, co-create, co-implement, and co-evaluate pre-operational CS to address climate change and extremes (droughts, floods and heatwaves). We present the vision and plans of the I-CISK project, and explore links, contributions and collaborations with existing projects and networks within the community of CS research and practice. 

    How to cite: Werner, M., Masih, I., Emerton, R., Pechlivanidis, I., Schaafsma, M., Pesquer, L., di Baldassare, G., van den Homberg, M., Bagli, S., Gamtkitsulashvili, M., De Stefano, L., Gräler, B., Bela, G., and Tzimas, A.: I-CISK: Towards a social and behaviourally informed approach to co-producing climate services, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10661, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10661, 2022.

    EGU22-11124 | Presentations | HS4.6

    Evaluating dynamical downscaling and bias correction methods for hydrological impact assessments 

    Vogel Elisabeth, Justin Peter, Ulrike Bende-Michl, Conrad Wasko, Wendy Sharples, Louise Wilson, Pandora Hope, Andrew Dowdy, Jake Roussis, Vi Co Duong, Chantal Donnelly, Zaved Khan, and Sri Srikanthan

    Climate change is predicted to affect the availability of water resources, including changes in the frequency and severity of hydrological extremes, such as droughts or extreme precipitation. Hydrological impact studies are critical, for example, for ensuring sustainable water resource management, food production, and economic prosperity into the future. Such impact studies are commonly based on hydrological models forced with outputs of global climate models (GCMs) that simulate future climate conditions under a range of greenhouse gas emission scenarios. Generally, global climate models are run at relatively coarse resolution – coarser than what would be required to force hydrological models. In addition, small-scale processes that are below the climate model resolution are approximated using parameterisations, leading to potential biases in some variables or processes. A range of bias-correction and downscaling methods have been developed to remove systemic biases in GCM outputs and to increase the resolution of the model output to match the spatial resolution required by the impact models.

    The Bureau of Meteorology (BoM) has recently released a National Hydrological Projections service as part of the new Australian Water Outlook (https://awo.bom.gov.au). This new projections service provides estimates of future climate change impacts on Australian water resources based on an ensemble of two greenhouse gas concentration pathways, four global climate models and a total of four statistical and dynamical bias-correction and downscaling methods (one dynamical downscaling and three bias-correction methods). This presentation provides an overview of the four bias correction and downscaling methods employed as part of the service and the evaluation of these methods for hydrological impact assessments in Australia.

    The following methods have been applied to raw GCM outputs: 1) a trend-preserving quantile matching approach developed for the Intersectoral Impacts Model Intercomparison Project (ISIMIP2b) (Hempel et al., 2013), 2) a multi-variate recursive nested bias-correction method (MRNBC) (Johnson & Sharma, 2012; Mehrotra & Sharma, 2016; Nahar et al., 2017), and 3) a quantile matching method optimised for preserving extreme events (Dowdy, 2019). Additionally, dynamically downscaled projections based on the CCAM regional climate model (Watterson & Rafter, 2017) were bias corrected using the ISIMIP2b method. The Australian Water Availability Project data (AWAP; Jones et al., 2009), a gridded dataset that contains climate observations (including precipitation, temperature) at 0.5 km grid resolution, was used as target dataset for the bias-correction methods. Subsequently, we forced the gridded land surface water balance model AWRA-L (Frost et al., 2018) with the bias-corrected and downscaled outputs to produce hydrological simulations for the historical period (1950-2005). We evaluated the outputs against a historical reference run using AWAP data as climate inputs. Here, we present the evaluation of bias-corrected and downscaled climate inputs (particularly precipitation and temperature) as well as impact-model simulated soil moisture, evapotranspiration and runoff over a 30-year period (1976-2005). The evaluation includes assessments of mean biases, cross-correlations, and temporal autocorrelations, as well as biases in variability and extremes at multiple time scales (monthly to multi-annual). We discuss implications of our findings for impact assessments for water resource management and outline potential uses of these methods.

    How to cite: Elisabeth, V., Peter, J., Bende-Michl, U., Wasko, C., Sharples, W., Wilson, L., Hope, P., Dowdy, A., Roussis, J., Duong, V. C., Donnelly, C., Khan, Z., and Srikanthan, S.: Evaluating dynamical downscaling and bias correction methods for hydrological impact assessments, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11124, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11124, 2022.

    EGU22-11173 | Presentations | HS4.6

    Unravelling user requirements for climate services to support water allocation decisions in a drought prone region in Spain 

    Celia Ramos Sánchez, Lucia De Stefano, Micha Werner, and Schalk Jan van Andel

    The development of climate services to address water-related challenges is rapidly progressing. Users’ engagement and adequate interaction between climate service providers and climate service consumers are recognized factors favouring climate services uptake among and the tracking and evaluation of their socio-economic benefits. Under the framework of the H2020 CLINT project, this research presents a preliminary analysis of user requirements in the Douro River Basin (Spain) to develop a climate service prototype, enhanced with artificial intelligence (AI), and intended to assist in the water allocation process; thereby improving drought adaptation. Participatory modelling is applied to explore the full decision-making process among competing needs, namely the allocation of water resources to environmental flows and irrigation. The research focuses on how different actors use historical and forecast hydrometeorological information to inform drought early warning and water use planning (e.g. user-inspired drought indicators), understanding how uncertainty influences decisions, the role of other types of information in the decision-making process, and the differing perceptions of droughts and drought impacts. These assessments of local user knowledge and the need for enhancements are key inputs to further develop and evaluate AI-enhanced climate service in the following stages of the CLINT project.

    How to cite: Ramos Sánchez, C., De Stefano, L., Werner, M., and van Andel, S. J.: Unravelling user requirements for climate services to support water allocation decisions in a drought prone region in Spain, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11173, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11173, 2022.

    EGU22-11449 | Presentations | HS4.6

    Assessment of hydrological extremes and water resources availability under climate change in the Main river basin, Germany 

    Teresa Pérez Ciria, Raul Wood, Braun Gunnar, and Ralf Ludwig

    Human-induced climate change is already impacting hydrometeorological extremes in every region across the globe (IPCC, 2021). In fact, changes in the climate system are projected to become larger with increasing global warming. This includes regional increase of frequency and intensity of heavy precipitation, hydrological extremes, agricultural and ecological droughts. Recent studies indicate that this problematic seems to be particularly relevant also in Central Europe, a region usually perceived as an area of comparatively low vulnerability to climate change due to its high adaptive capacity. The presented study focuses on the Main river basin, a tributary to the Rhine river in Germany: the watershed, covering an area of 21.519 km² (at Kleinheubach gauging station) with over four million inhabitants, is characterized by intense gradients of topography and climate, and diversified land use. The region already suffers from water scarcity and consequently water use conflicts are becoming more relevant recently, especially during summer months. This study presents results from a single hydrological model initial condition large ensemble (i.e. the spatially explicit process-based hydrological model WaSiM (Willkofer et al., 2020)) being driven by 50 members of the Canadian Regional Climate Model Vers.5 (CRCM5) over Europe (Leduc et al., 2019) for the time interval 1950-2099. A remarkable decline of mean annual runoff in the Main river basin is projected, while both frequency and intensity of extreme floods show strong increasing trends. This work is meant to tackle this challenge as a first step to achieve co-designing systemic solutions and science-driven technical and cross-sectoral innovations to build new climate-resilient development pathways for efficient water resources management.

    The presented study is supported by results from the project ClimEx (www.climex-project.org), funded by the Bavarian State Ministry for the Environment and Consumer Protection, and the project ARSINOE (GA: 101037424), funded under EU’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme. 

    How to cite: Pérez Ciria, T., Wood, R., Gunnar, B., and Ludwig, R.: Assessment of hydrological extremes and water resources availability under climate change in the Main river basin, Germany, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11449, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11449, 2022.

    Due to unavailability of observation data in the north-western Himalayas, reanalysis data is used as an alternative. The reanalysis dataset generally have bias compared to observation data. Hence, different bias correction approaches are used to post-process the data before using it for any hydro-climatic study. Although distribution parameters in the bias correction approaches are adjusted according to observation data, it can modify or misrepresent dependence structure between variables and sites. Ignoring the observed inter-site dependencies in the correction procedure can result in obtaining corrected outputs with mismatched spatial dependence. Hence a multi-site bias correction approach is used with Schaake shuffle approach to reconstruct the inter-site correlation with rank reordering.

     In this study, we apply multivariate bias correction with schaake shuffle approach on 12 observatory stations of north-western Himalayas. The approach is applied on the variables mean temperature, precipitation, downward longwave radiation, downward shortwave radiation, and wind speed obtained from High Asia Reanalysis dataset at 0.25° horizontal resolution. The bias correction is applied using the observation data availed from the Princeton University global meteorological forcings for a time period of 2001 to 2011. The Leave-One-Out-Cross-Validation approach is used to apply the bias correction by leaving one year data for validation on each loop.

    The multi-site bias correction applied to all the variables in different seasons shows that it is reducing the inter-station bias considerably for monsoon, winter, and summer seasons. For Post-monsoon season the improvement is not significant. For monsoon season the RMSE, MAE, and Bias percentage is decreasing for all the variables except precipitation. The inter-site correlation is improved after application of multi-site bias correction.

    How to cite: Samal, N. and Jha, S.: Applying multi-site bias correction approach preserving inter-site correlation in the north-western Himalayan region, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12101, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12101, 2022.

    EGU22-12608 | Presentations | HS4.6

    Future Projections of Potential Evapotranspiration and Fresh Water Availability in India using CMIP6 GCMs 

    Swapan Kumar Masanta and V. Vemavarapu Srinivas

    Detection and quantification of climate change impact on hydrological processes (e.g., precipitation, evapotranspiration and streamflow) in different climatic regions is necessity for water resources planning and management in order to ensure water security for various purposes. Globally evapotranspiration is the major cause of water loss, which is about 62% of global land-surface precipitation. Reference or potential evapotranspiration (ET0) represents the atmospheric water demand, which would be the upper limit of actual evapotranspiration in humid climate. Climate change induced variation in meteorological variables will affect ET0 or crop water requirements. Increase of ET0 can intensify dry conditions in the arid and semi-arid regions of the world. In our previous study on historical records, we noted regional increase in ET0 in south and central India due to increase in net solar radiation and temperature; and decrease in regional ET0 in north-east and north-west India) due to either global stilling (i.e., decrease in wind speed) or global dimming (i.e., decrease in net solar radiation) during 1958-2013. The decreasing trend in ET0 despite significant increase evident in air temperature is widely referred to as “evaporation paradox”. The objective of the present study is to determine the regional-scale spatialtemporal variations of ET0 in future climate conditions using recently released GCMs of CMIP6 (Coupled Model Intercomparison Project Phase 6), as this can provide valuable information for future ET0 regional trend and fresh water availability in India. For this purpose, the homogeneous ET0 regions formed over India in our recent study are considered.   We considered three GCMs namely CanESM5, INM-CM4-8 and INM-CM5-0 because of the availability of all required climate variables for all four CMIP6  shared socioeconomic pathways (SSPs; SSP126, SSP245, SSP370, and SSP585). The projected changes were estimated for each GCM for the late 21st century (2015–2100). The results were discerned based on ensemble mean of the projections of climate variables obtained from the three GCMs. The trend analysis of ET0 as well as climate variables reveal that ET0 will increase significantly in all the homogeneous ET0 regions in India. Similarly, maximum and minimum temperatures, and net solar radiation are also projected to increase significantly. The evaporation paradox was not found in any parts of India in the future simulations. Among other climate variables, significantly increasing trend for relative humidity and decreasing trend for wind speed was found in majority of regions for higher SSPs. The ET0 and precipitation data are used in budyko relationship to obtain the futute fresh water availability in the regions. It is found that, despite increase in ET0 there is significant increase in futute fresh water availability across all the regions for higher SSPs due to increase in precipitation. 

    How to cite: Masanta, S. K. and Srinivas, V. V.: Future Projections of Potential Evapotranspiration and Fresh Water Availability in India using CMIP6 GCMs, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12608, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12608, 2022.

    EGU22-1457 | Presentations | HS4.7 | Highlight

    Calibration framework for derived flood frequency analysis driving a rainfall-runoff model with stochastically generated rainfall data 

    Luisa-Bianca Thiele, Ross Pidoto, and Uwe Haberlandt

    For derived flood frequency analyses, stochastic rainfall models can be linked with rainfall-runoff models to improve the accuracy of design flood estimations when the length of observed rainfall and runoff data is not sufficient. Previous studies have shown here that for an optimal calibration of rainfall-runoff models, flood statistics should be considered and the same input data should be used for the calibration as for the application of the model. In general, however, the observed runoff data as annual maximum values are too short to follow the classical split-sampling approach and divide the sample into a calibration and validation period. To ensure an independent validation of the calibrated rainfall-runoff models with an increased sample size to enable split-sampling, this work will investigate a calibration framework using monthly maximum values of the observed runoff. The objective function takes into account flood statistics of monthly maximum flows, e.g. l-moments of the independent peaks and the ratios between peak and volume. The conceptual rainfall-runoff model HBV-IWW is driven by stochastically generated rainfall data on an hourly time step for 140 meso- and macroscale (30km² - 1500km²) catchments in Germany. The results of this calibration framework could be used as benchmarks for future studies.

    How to cite: Thiele, L.-B., Pidoto, R., and Haberlandt, U.: Calibration framework for derived flood frequency analysis driving a rainfall-runoff model with stochastically generated rainfall data, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1457, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1457, 2022.

    EGU22-3389 | Presentations | HS4.7

    Integrated Multiscale Urban Flood Modeling with Drainage pipe system 

    Lea Dasallas, Hyunuk An, and Seungsoo Lee

    The integrated multiscale urban flood model (IMUFlood Model) is developed to incorporate the hydrologic influence of rainfall-runoff, and surface and sewer pipe interaction in a grid-size varying scheme for urban flooding. The aim of the research is to solve the calculation of the multiscale integrated relationship between the watershed-scale flood routing to urban domain-scale inundation, and the flow interaction between the surface and drainage pipe system.  The integration was performed by applying kinematic equation on the coarser-resolution watershed grid and 2D shallow water equation on the higher-resolution urban inundation domain. Likewise, the surface and subsurface interaction are calculated in the storm drain inlets using weir and orifice equations and the flow within the pipe system was estimated using Priessmann slot model discretized in finite volume and Euler Method. The flood extent and depth are validated for an extreme rainfall event in Marikina basin, Philippines.

    Results show the possibility to simulate urban inundation without the need to require observed boundary conditions which opens the possibility of the use of rainfall forecast data for real-time flood prediction. The developed model can provide flood information such as the concentration of flood, estimated peak time, flood source point and flow velocity. The computation of spatial variations of pipe flow, wetted area and water depth inside the pipe can be used to identify the flood susceptible regions. This information can be used as supplementary tools to aid for early warning and flood prevention, as well as to be used for the improvement of sewer construction in decreasing urban flood risk.

    How to cite: Dasallas, L., An, H., and Lee, S.: Integrated Multiscale Urban Flood Modeling with Drainage pipe system, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3389, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3389, 2022.

    EGU22-5409 | Presentations | HS4.7

    Combined assimilation of reanalyzed SWE and observed streamflow to enhance spring flow forecasts in southern Quebec, Canada 

    Sepehr Farhoodi, Robert Leconte, and Mélanie Trudel

    Incorporation of observed streamflow into different hydrological models has resulted in improved streamflow forecasting in many studies. This approach is currently used by different hydropower companies to maximize hydroelectric production and also to predict and mitigate flood damages. In addition, snow-related model states, such as SWE, snow depth, and snow wetness, also carry important information regarding both timing and volume of spring flow in snow-dominated regions. Consequently, the main objective of this study is to combine assimilation of observed streamflow and reanalyzed SWE to enhance spring flow forecasting. The reanalyzed SWE product investigated is SNODAS.

    SNODAS is a snow data assimilation system that improves outputs of a snow model by assimilating observed snow data provided by airborne platforms, satellites, and ground stations and generates snow-related data, such as SWE and snow depth at 1 km resolution.  SNODAS is run each day so that the data product is available in near real-time.

    In this study, SNODAS SWE data has been assimilated into HYDROTEL, a physically-based distributed hydrological model equipped with a snow module based on a mixed energy budget – degree-day approach, along with observed streamflow during the spring flow season in order to enhance spring flow forecasts. The study site is Au Saumon watershed, located in southern Quebec, Canada.  The Au Saumon watershed has an area of 1022  and is predominantly forested. The simulation period is the 2014-2015 water year. Preliminary results show that combined assimilation of SNODAS SWE and observed streamflow improve spring flow predictions, while SWE assimilation has a more delayed impact than streamflow assimilation.

    Keywords: Data Assimilation, SNODAS, SWE, Spring Flow Prediction

    How to cite: Farhoodi, S., Leconte, R., and Trudel, M.: Combined assimilation of reanalyzed SWE and observed streamflow to enhance spring flow forecasts in southern Quebec, Canada, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5409, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5409, 2022.

    EGU22-7790 | Presentations | HS4.7 | Highlight

    Evaluating quantitative precipitation estimates and hydrological models for simulating the 2021 extreme events in Germany 

    Mohamed Saadi, Carina Furusho-Percot, Alexandre Belleflamme, Ju-Yu Chen, Ricardo Reinoso-Rondinel, Silke Troemel, and Stefan Kollet

    Implementing an effective nationwide, extreme-flood forecasting system requires improving both the estimation of quantitative precipitation and the hydrological modelling tools. We investigated the ability of state-of-the-art radar-based precipitation products and two contrasting hydrological models in providing reliable flood hindcasts and nowcasts for the July 2021 catastrophic floods. Among others, rainfall retrievals based on specific attenuation, a polarimetric radar variable, were used to improve the accuracy of the rain rates, and different radar-based nowcasting methods (deterministic and stochastic) were tested to quantify their added value in improving the forecast lead time. Hydrological models consisted of a lumped, conceptual model (GR4H) and a distributed physically-based model (ParFlow-CLM) that couples 3D surface and sub-surface flows. The parameters of the lumped model were calibrated on historical data, whereas the parameters of the distributed model were estimated based on landscape and soil properties. Preliminary results indicate that differences in simulated peakflows were predominantly due to differences in the rainfall retrievals rather than hydrological models. Warm rain processes near the surface led to underestimated precipitation sums compared to ground-based estimations. The precipitation estimates largely impacted the ability of models in detecting the exceedance of the 100-year flood, which highlights the need for reliable precipitation estimates to forecast such extreme events.

    How to cite: Saadi, M., Furusho-Percot, C., Belleflamme, A., Chen, J.-Y., Reinoso-Rondinel, R., Troemel, S., and Kollet, S.: Evaluating quantitative precipitation estimates and hydrological models for simulating the 2021 extreme events in Germany, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7790, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7790, 2022.

    EGU22-7851 | Presentations | HS4.7

    Establishing the potential impacts of climate change on extreme flood events across the UK. 

    Laura Ramsamy, James Brennan, Hamish Mitchell, Markela Zeneli, Claire Burke, and Kamil Kluza

    The severity and frequency of extreme flood events has intensified both globally, and across the UK. Climate change will influence weather patterns across the UK, making it increasingly important to understand the impacts this may have on future flood events.

    We developed 90m hydraulic models to simulate extreme pluvial and fluvial flood events across the UK based on observed events. The models have been climate conditioned, allowing the potential impacts of climate change on extreme pluvial and fluvial flood events to be understood. Using different climate scenarios, we examine the variation in outcome depending on what efforts are taken to reduce emissions. Modelling the impacts climate change could have on flooding at a national scale, enables us to understand the spatial-temporal distribution of flood risk. This information can be used in the real world for decision making and providing a way to mitigate against the impacts of climate change.

    How to cite: Ramsamy, L., Brennan, J., Mitchell, H., Zeneli, M., Burke, C., and Kluza, K.: Establishing the potential impacts of climate change on extreme flood events across the UK., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7851, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7851, 2022.

    EGU22-8051 | Presentations | HS4.7 | Highlight

    A Review on Need of Application of Ensemble Techniques for Streamflow Forecasting in India 

    Ayushi Panchal, Dr. S. M. Yadav, Rashmi Yadav, and Anant Patel

    Water is the most essential resource, which is naturally available. Poor management of water can cause drought in some areas and also floods in some areas. Flood is one of the most disastrous events which can cause tremendous losses. In India, the techniques which are developed for real time flood forecasting are based on deterministic as well as statistical approach. The quantification of uncertainties is having the primary importance in flood modelling systems. The forecasts are simulated multiple times with slight changes in initial conditions as well as model parameters. This is known as ‘Ensemble forecasting’. The Ensemble Techniques approach minimizes the uncertainties in the forecasting. This approach is used in Numerical Weather Prediction (NWP). The advance techniques like remote sensing, data acquisition and monitoring system, hydrologic modelling have led to progress in the flood forecasting techniques and skills. The ensemble approach has potential for creating and disseminating the probabilistic predictions, extending lead-time as well as quantification of predictability. Due to ensemble techniques, the capability to issue the flood warnings and alerts can be increased. In addition to forecast the flood, the ensemble techniques can be used for the reservoir operation, drought estimation, hydropower as well as water management. Hence, moving towards probabilistic approach from deterministic approach would be much helpful to develop reliable flood forecasting systems.  Ensemble forecasting is the probabilistic approach and has the ability for giving information of probability of occurrence for the extreme events. The ensemble forecasting approach is used successfully in various countries of the world. India also needs the reliable approach for producing the operational forecasts.

    How to cite: Panchal, A., Yadav, Dr. S. M., Yadav, R., and Patel, A.: A Review on Need of Application of Ensemble Techniques for Streamflow Forecasting in India, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8051, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8051, 2022.

    EGU22-10864 | Presentations | HS4.7

    Flood prediction in ungauged basins with machine learning and satellite precipitation data 

    Zimeena Rasheed, Akshay Aravamudan, Georgios Anagnostopoulos, and Efthymios Nikolopoulos

    Global hydrologic climate assessments posit increasing flood risk. Hydrologic forecasting is critical in both gauged and ungauged basins having implications not only for hazard assessments and the development of mitigation strategies but also for informing the design and operation of critical infrastructure. The hydrology community grapples with the need to predict floods particularly in ungauged basins where the absence of continuous and spatially representative precipitation and streamflow data are enunciated. 

    Global precipitation observations from satellite constellations combined with recent advancements of hydrologic forecasting with machine-learning (ML) models, offer an attractive solution for addressing flood prediction in ungauged regions. Towards that end, in this work, we investigate a) the performance of ML flood prediction models integrated with satellite precipitation estimates and b) the transferability/applicability of ML models trained in data rich regions for flood prediction in ungauged regions. We use NASA IMERG precipitation dataset for ML-based predictions and we train the ML models for ~600 catchments from different hydroclimatic zones in Contiguous US. The performance of the ML-IMERG predictions are then evaluated for a large number of catchments (~1000) in the UK, Brazil, Chile and Australia. Predictive performance is evaluated with respect to climate and catchment characteristics in each region. Results suggest that despite the variability in the performance across regions, there is great promise on the integration of global satellite precipitation estimates with ML models for flood prediction in ungauged basins.  

    How to cite: Rasheed, Z., Aravamudan, A., Anagnostopoulos, G., and Nikolopoulos, E.: Flood prediction in ungauged basins with machine learning and satellite precipitation data, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10864, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10864, 2022.

    In this presentation, some insights into the various contributing factors of the floods in southwestern British Columbia, Canada, will be shared. These floods followed a large atmospheric river event, combined with high antecedent soil moisture and rain on snow mechanisms. In some locations, including some that were affected by extensive wildfires in the preceding summer, estimated return periods of river flows during this event exceeded 2000 years. Various alternative estimations of this return period will be presented, conditional on various assumptions and side information  Due to the large scale disruption of infrastructure, this event is expected to be (one of) the costliest natural disaster in history for Canada. This presentation is informed both by probabilistic analysis of the various factors and anecdotal evidence based on an aerial reconnaissance of the flood affected area. 

    How to cite: Weijs, S. and Kovacek, D.: The November 2021 floods in British Columbia, Canada: observations, mechanisms and probabilities, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10998, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10998, 2022.

    HS5 – Water policy, management and control

    EGU22-929 | Presentations | HS5.1

    Increasing water system robustness: potential of cross-sectoral water reuse 

    Ruud Bartholomeus, Geertje Pronk, Sija Stofberg, Henk Krajenbrink, and Klaasjan Raat

    We are increasingly confronted with drought damage in agriculture and nature as well as an increasing pressure on the availability of water for high-grade applications such as the production of drinking water. Strategies are being developed to control these risks and to secure long-term supplies of freshwater. These include increasing regional self-sufficiency in meeting the demand for freshwater and improving the utilization of the available water sources. We provide examples of adaptation measures to reduce the gap between water demand and availability under climate and water use changes, including reuse of water resources across sectors. Water reuse has the potential to substantially reduce the demand on groundwater and surface water. We present an integrative framework to evaluate the potential of water reuse schemes in a regional context and demonstrate how water reuse propagates through the water system and potentially reduces pressure on groundwater resources. The use of Sankey diagram visualisation provides a valuable tool to explore and evaluate regional application of water reuse, its potential to reduce groundwater and surface water demand, and the possible synergies and trade-offs between sectors. The approach is demonstrated for the Dutch anthropogenic water system in the current situation and for a future scenario with increased water demand and reduced water availability due to climate change. Four types of water reuse are evaluated by theoretically upscaling local or regional water reuse schemes based on local reuse examples: municipal and industrial wastewater effluent reuse for irrigation, effluent reuse for industrial applications, and reuse for groundwater replenishment. Doing so, we share a general framework for developing strategies to integrate water reuse in a robust regional water system. Responsible water reuse requires a multidisciplinary approach with knowledge on water demand and availability, water quality and health, technology and governance. Systematic evaluation of these aspects can help determine when water reuse is, or is not (!), a viable part of a regional strategy. This integrative context, including water systems thinking and modelling to identify risks and benefits, is essential for a successful implementation of water reuse in practice.

    How to cite: Bartholomeus, R., Pronk, G., Stofberg, S., Krajenbrink, H., and Raat, K.: Increasing water system robustness: potential of cross-sectoral water reuse, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-929, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-929, 2022.

    EGU22-1621 | Presentations | HS5.1

    Quantifying the economic feasibility of solar irrigation in sub-Saharan Africa 

    Giacomo Falchetta, Francesco Semeria, and Marta Tuninetti

    An erratic water supply is a limiting factor for crop production. In several world regions, switching from rainfed to irrigated agriculture has allowed farmers to increase production robustly and stabilise agricultural yields. Yet, in sub-Saharan Africa - the world region with the fastest demographic growth - extensive rain-fed still agriculture accounts for more than 90% of agricultural land, more than one-in-six people are undernourished, and electricity access mostly lacks in rural areas. Previous assessment revealed significant solar irrigation technical potential in the region thanks to the large availability of water supply sources and high solar irradiance. To assess the economic feasibility of this large-scale transformation, here we conduct a high-resolution assessment of solar irrigation solutions, comparing system costs with potential revenues. We estimate and locate the share of rainfed cropland in SSA could be equipped with solar irrigation while ensuring groundwater sustainability and calculate the relative payback time. In addition, we estimate how and to what extent the transition could positively impact food security, in term of kilocalories, and protein and fat grams per capita per year. Our analysis supports public and private actors working along the water-energy-food-economy nexus wishing to identify economic feasibility areas, quantifying the potential net economic benefit of developing solar irrigation, and fostering investment for a synergetic achievement of the Sustainable Development Goals. 

    How to cite: Falchetta, G., Semeria, F., and Tuninetti, M.: Quantifying the economic feasibility of solar irrigation in sub-Saharan Africa, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1621, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1621, 2022.

    EGU22-3040 | Presentations | HS5.1

    Dynamic Water-Energy-Food nexus management in transboundary river basins incorporating water infrastructure operation and demand control 

    Guang Yang, Matteo Giuliani, Elena Matta, Veronica Piuri, and Andrea Castelletti

    Water resources infrastructure plays an important role in energy and food security by providing water storage for hydropower generation and food production. Yet, Water, Energy, and Food (WEF) often interplay and evolve dynamically over time with social-economic development and water system expansions. Understanding the WEF Nexus is particularly challenging in transboundary contexts, where interdependencies also develop across multiple riparian countries. In this work, we investigate how to address the WEF Nexus in transboundary river basins to discover innovative solutions mitigating existing tradeoffs and facilitating international agreements. Our approach is demonstrated on the Nile River basin, where we explore tradeoffs between power generation and irrigation water supply across Ethiopia, Sudan, and Egypt. In particular, we analyze innovative portfolios of interventions that combine the coordinated operation of large water reservoirs (i.e., the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam, Merowe Dam, and High Aswan Dam) and the main irrigation diversions, with water demand management options (e.g., aquaponics systems, new desalination plants) for reducing the water demand in the Nile Delta. Our results show that the Nile River basin features both strong tradeoffs and notable synergies across the WEF Nexus and across countries. For example, our analysis shows a clear tradeoff between hydropower generation in Egypt and irrigation water supply in Sudan. In contrast, the hydropower generation in Sudan and Egypt are positively correlated. Additional challenges will be generated by the projected decrease in water availability as suggested by most climate change scenarios. Finally, the potential reduction of the irrigation demands in the Nile Delta can contribute in mitigating existing tradeoffs and represents an additional option in the current international negotiations between Ethiopia, Sudan, and Egypt.

    How to cite: Yang, G., Giuliani, M., Matta, E., Piuri, V., and Castelletti, A.: Dynamic Water-Energy-Food nexus management in transboundary river basins incorporating water infrastructure operation and demand control, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3040, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3040, 2022.

    EGU22-3217 | Presentations | HS5.1

    Research on integrated modeling of a coupled regional water-food systems based on system dynamics 

    Xinkui Wang, Janez Susnik, and Zengchuan Dong

    Water resources supply is closely related to food production and economy development. The importance of such a complex system is increasingly recognized in academia and policy. An integrated System Dynamics Model for the water-stressed Loudi city in Hunan Province, China, assessing water balance, and agricultural yield and revenue to 2050, is presented. Considering the uncertainty of future inflows, the formulation of water supply policies, and changes in cropping regimes, this study simulated multiple scenarios to better understand the impacts on water, food, and economic security and their interactions to highlight Loudi's realization of potential pathways to a more sustainable future. Current water resource over-exploitation can be mitigated while still allowing for agricultural development. While most simulations hinted at continued over-exploitation, some suggested that improvements can be achieved by altering parameters such as per-capita domestic water demand, per-capita industrial water demand and the cropping regime. Relevant policies should be considered in parallel to introduce redundancy into the policy framework. From initial results, it is hypothesized that by producing excess crops, a virtual water trading market can be developed, thereby further improving water balance, yield and revenue. This study used system dynamics as a powerful tool to explore complex, feedback-driven water-food systems, providing a viable framework for water resource management approaches and policies at the regional scale.

    How to cite: Wang, X., Susnik, J., and Dong, Z.: Research on integrated modeling of a coupled regional water-food systems based on system dynamics, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3217, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3217, 2022.

    Water shortage and soil salinization are main limiting factors in agricultural production in arid and semi-arid regions worldwide. Located in western Inner Mongolia of China, the Hetao Irrigation District (HID) is the largest gravity-fed irrigation district in Asia and one of the top three largest irrigation districts in China. Irrigation water overuse and high level of soil salinity are the main challenges that curb agricultural productivity, adversely affect farmers’ revenues, and threaten long-term sustainability of irrigated farming in the HID. Nevertheless, irrigation water allocation, salt leaching and accumulation, crop productivity and farming decisions are intrinsically connected and thus necessitate taking a holistic approach to investigate into the interactions among all those factors and devising appropriate technological, management and policy interventions. Towards this goal, an integrated hydro-agro--economic optimization model was developed to optimize water allocation among sub-irrigation districts, across stable and cash crops, and in the four irrigation events of a year that are unique for the HID. The model optimizes net revenue of the HID considering water and salt balance, the response of crops to salinity and water stress, land availability, and existing irrigation management practices that have been proved effective. The Positive Mathematical Programming (PMP) approach is used to calibrate the model such that it can reproduce base year observations of crop acreage, water uses and production costs and benefits, making the model suitable for evaluating alternative management and policy scenarios. Sensitivity analysis were conducted for initial groundwater table, initial soil salinity level and leaching coefficient, and the results were moderately sensitive to initial soil salinity and marginally sensitive to groundwater table and leaching coefficient values. Scenario analyses were conducted to analyze the effects of irrigation water supply, winter irrigation (non-growing period) water application, irrigation efficiency and crop commodity market prices. We found that water supply reduction increases land fallow and reduces net revenue. Winter irrigation can store soil moisture to increase summer crop planting areas and increase salt-leaching to lower crop salinity stress. However, irrigation water use efficiency improvement can cause unintended negative consequences, such as exacerbated soil salinization. Higher crop commodity market price increases planting areas and water allocation of the crop but reduce areas and water uses of other crops, leading to a “crowding-out” effects. These results and modeling exercises provide a holistic perspective and useful insights for future water, land and salinity management, irrigation infrastructure investment, and market risk management in the HID.

    How to cite: Cao, Z. and Zhu, T.: Hydro-agro-economic Optimization of Water and Land Management in the Hetao Irrigation District, China, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4054, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4054, 2022.

    EGU22-4423 | Presentations | HS5.1

    Hydroeconomic Analysis for Climate Adaptation Guidance under Future Climate Water Stress 

    Safa Baccour, Frank Ward, and Jose Albiac

    Climate water stress internationally challenges the goal of achieving food, energy, and water security.  This challenge is elevated by population and income growth and by considerable uncertainty about future water supplies. Increased climate water stress levels reduce water supplies in many river basins and intensify competition for water among sectors and over time periods.  Organized information is needed to guide river basin managers and stakeholders who must plan for a changing climate through innovative water allocation policies, trade-off analysis, vulnerability assessment, capacity adaptation, and infrastructure planning. Several hydroeconomic models have been developed and applied assessing water use in different sectors, counties, cultures, and time periods.  However, none to date has presented an optimization framework by which historical water use and economic benefit patterns can be replicated while showing measures to adapt to future climate water stresses to inform the design of policies not yet implemented. This paper’s unique contribution is to address this gap by designing and presenting results of a hydroeconomic model for which optimized base conditions match observed data water use and economic welfare for several urban and agricultural uses at several locations in a large European river basin for which water use supports a population of more than 3.2 million.  We develop a state-of-the arts empirical dynamic hydroeconomic optimization model that integrates hydrology, economics, climate stress, and institutional water sharing measures. The model is used to discover land and water use patterns that optimize sustained farm and city income under various levels of climate-water stress. Findings using innovative model calibration methods allow for the discovery of efficient water allocation plans as well as providing insight into marginal behavioral responses to climate water stress and water policies. Results show that a water trading policy for handling climate water stress provides more economically efficient water use patterns, reallocating water from lower valued uses to higher valued uses such as urban water.  The Ebro River Basin in Spain is used as an example to investigate water use adaptation patterns under various levels of climate water stress. That basin’s issues and challenges light a path to relevance for other river basins internationally.

    How to cite: Baccour, S., Ward, F., and Albiac, J.: Hydroeconomic Analysis for Climate Adaptation Guidance under Future Climate Water Stress, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4423, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4423, 2022.

    EGU22-5169 | Presentations | HS5.1

    Assessing Water-Energy-Food nexus synergies and trade-offs:  an ecosystems services-based perspective 

    Anna Sperotto, Ferdinando Villa, Stefano Balbi, and Stefano Bagli

     

    Managing water, energy and food adopting a nexus approach is crucial to guarantee the sustainable and efficient use of resources, particularly in light of global changes. Ecosystem Services (ESs), namely the multiple benefits that ecosystems provide to human well-being, constitute a useful perspective to look at the critical interactions occurring between Water-Energy-Food (WEF). ESs have been rarely explicitly addressed in nexus assessment, however representing the bio-physical foundation of the WEF interactions, they can be used as common assessment endpoints permitting to better disentangle and manage cross-sectoral synergies and trade-offs. The UNTWIST project (MSCA-IF) proposes an innovative approach to look at the WEF nexus through the lens of ecosystem services theory gaining insights about potential interdependencies between sectorial policies and thus unlocking opportunities for delivering integrated solutions towards the achievement of multiple Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). Starting from the nexus framing, a participative approach is adopted for engaging local stakeholders’ representative of different nexus sectors in identifying existing conflicts in water use and prioritizing ESs they value the most. Later, ARIES (Artificial Intelligence for Environment and Sustainability), an Artificial Intelligence modeler based on the semantic web, is used to develop an integrated model to spatially-temporally represent most relevant ESs and flows exchanged through the WEF nexus building on available sectoral data and models. The proposed approach permits to map critical areas for multiple ESs provision to WEF and thus to identify where synergies and trade-offs between sectors are likely to arise. Based on this results, different scenarios describing multiple combinations of social, economic and climatic pathways are tested serving as the basis for the definition of a shared management strategy for long-term nexus sustainability. Preliminary insights derived from the application to two different case studies in Europe (i.e. Po river basin (Italy), Pas Miera Ason river basins (Spain)) will be presented to discuss the novelty and implications of the proposed approach.

     

    How to cite: Sperotto, A., Villa, F., Balbi, S., and Bagli, S.: Assessing Water-Energy-Food nexus synergies and trade-offs:  an ecosystems services-based perspective, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5169, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5169, 2022.

    EGU22-6982 | Presentations | HS5.1

    Assessing Environmental Benefits in the Hydro-economic Model of the Ebro Basin 

    Daniel Crespo, José Albiac, Ariel Dinar, Encarna Esteban, and Taher Kahil

    The increasing concern about the degradation of water-dependent ecosystems calls for consideration of ecosystem benefits in water management decision-making. Sustainable water management requires adequate economic and biophysical information on water systems that support both human activities and natural ecosystems. This information is essential for assessing the impact of water allocation options on social welfare. This paper evaluates various alternative water management policies by including the spatial and sectoral interrelationships between the economic and environmental uses of water. A hydro-economic model is developed to analyze water management policies in response to reduced water availability in the Ebro Basin of Spain. The originality in our contribution is the integration of environmental benefits across the basin, by using endemic biophysical information that relates stream flows and ecosystem status in the Ebro Basin. The results show the enhancement of social welfare that can be achieved by protecting environmental flows, and the tradeoffs between economic and environmental benefits under alternative adaptation strategies. The introduction of water markets is a policy that maximizes the private benefits of economic activities, but disregards environmental benefits. The results show that the practiced institutional policy where stakeholders cooperate inside the basin water authority, provides lower private benefits but higher environmental benefits compared to those obtained under water markets, especially under situations of severe droughts. However, the water authority is not allocating enough environmental flows to optimize social welfare. This study informs strategies for protection of environmental flows in the Ebro Basin, which is a compelling decision under the imminent climate change impacts on water availability in coming decades

    How to cite: Crespo, D., Albiac, J., Dinar, A., Esteban, E., and Kahil, T.: Assessing Environmental Benefits in the Hydro-economic Model of the Ebro Basin, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6982, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6982, 2022.

    EGU22-7012 | Presentations | HS5.1

    Accountability and Transparency through Water-Energy-Food Nexus Accounting in Central Asia 

    Tobias Siegfried, Oyture Anarbekov, Silvan Ragettli, and Beatrice Marti

    In Central Asia, more than 90 % of annually renewable water resources are consumptively utilized in irrigation, and allocation conflicts between large-scale hydropower in the upstream and irrigation in the downstream occur regularly and mostly across complex international borders, especially during water scarce years and low storage conditions. With increasing attention on climate-neutral hydropower solutions, including on small-scale hydropower
    (< 10MW), the water-energy-food-environment nexus is now under renewed focus in the region. In line with these developments, new nexus tradeoffs emerge that need to be yet acknowledged and quantified, also under the considering of a changing climate.

    As part of the ongoing EU Horizon 2020 Project Hydro4U that demonstrates innovative and sustainable hydropower solutions targeting the unexplored small-scale hydropower potential in Central Asia, a new online nexus toolbox with an innovative monitoring and accounting methodology is developed. It assimilates data from different sources, including from remote sensing and through local monitoring, to monitor and predict water availability and energy production in the mountainous zones of runoff formation and irrigation water use in the downstream. Target user groups are Basin Irrigation System Administrations, private and public energy stakeholders, and Ministry of Water representatives in the two demonstration sites where small-scale hydropower plants are built as part of the project.

    Irrigation water use is monitored using an innovative unsupervised machine learning technique for mapping crop-disaggregated irrigated areas at the catchment scale. State-of-the-art datasets on evapotranspiration and biomass production are used for the detailed analysis of crop water demands and irrigation efficiencies in conjunction with local scheme-level water use where available. All processing steps were implemented in Google Earth Engine (GEE), enabling to process large amounts of irrigated crop statistics at a high spatial resolution for the entire semi-arid Central Asia region, including Afghanistan.

    In relation to water availability and renewable energy, hydropower production at the demonstration sites is modeled using hydrological modeling using the HBV model. Discharge is forecast at decadal (10-days) to monthly time scales using data from the NOAA NCEI Global Forecasting System product and information on the development of the catchment scale snow cover from the MODIS Snow Cover Daily Global 500m product in the zones of runoff formation.

    The nexus toolbox is a web-based tool that can deliver unique and objective data and intelligence to local stakeholders and decision-makers, off-farm and on-farm alike. The advantage of such technology is that no local infrastructure, beyond a computer connected to the internet, is required to access these types of data and intelligence relevant for irrigation improvements is required. The software can be specifically tailored (through an iterative co-design approach) to the needs and wants of stakeholders at all levels, from farmers to Water User Associations on the consumer side and from service providers at district, Province, and National levels. It will also contribute to designing climate-proofed benefits sharing regimes considering uncertainties explicitly to ensure optimal and fair resource use and distribution across the different domains and countries and, therefore, contributing to regional cooperation and peace.

    How to cite: Siegfried, T., Anarbekov, O., Ragettli, S., and Marti, B.: Accountability and Transparency through Water-Energy-Food Nexus Accounting in Central Asia, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7012, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7012, 2022.

    EGU22-7842 | Presentations | HS5.1

    Multi-objective trade-off analysis in operating dams for the environment: The case of the Lower Volta River 

    Afua Owusu, Jazmin Zatarain Salazar, Marloes Mul, Pieter van der Zaag, and Jill Slinger

    Historically, overcoming energy deficits or increasing water security has translated into a demand for more dams. However, the construction and conventional operation of dams have had contradictory outcomes, negatively impacting natural riverine ecosystems and riparian communities. In the Lower Volta River Basin in Ghana, the construction of the Akosombo dam, with a residence time of 3.9 years, led to the formation of the largest artificial lake by surface area and the resettlement of 80,000 people. Furthermore, the riverine ecosystem changed, as did the lives of the downstream communities who lost their traditional livelihoods. In contrast, the Akosombo dam is credited for powering Ghana’s industrialization and making it one of the more developed countries in West Africa. Thein lies the issue: there exists a trade-off between anthropogenic water demands such hydropower, irrigation or recreation on the one hand, and water for river ecosystems and services on the other. A transparent approach to managing these trade-offs between multiple water users is therefore needed to operate dams equitably. In this study, an Evolutionary Multi-Objective Direct Policy Search (EMODPS) is applied to case of the Lower Volta River Basin to identify the multi-sectorial trade-offs that exists between water users.  A designer environmental flow is incorporated as an objective rather than as a constraint and additionally, different policy framings and scenarios encompassing climate change and varying energy futures are investigated. This study highlights the challenges faced by dam operators in balancing water demands, and also identifies synergies and opportunities for compromise in the Lower Volta River.

    How to cite: Owusu, A., Zatarain Salazar, J., Mul, M., van der Zaag, P., and Slinger, J.: Multi-objective trade-off analysis in operating dams for the environment: The case of the Lower Volta River, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7842, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7842, 2022.

    Agriculture is essential for economic growth in the Lower Mekong River basin (LMB), which plays a key role in ensuing water and food security of the riparian regions and provides livelihoods for tens of millions of people. Agricultural irrigation, hydropower development, increasing water demand from other sectors, and ecosystem protection necessitate taking a holistic approach when analyzing irrigation in the LMB. This paper examines the existing problems and opportunities of irrigation in the LMB from the angle of water-food-energy (WFE) nexus. We selected journal articles from the Web of Science database and imported them into CiteSpace, a bibliometric analysis software for visual exploration of scientific literature. The visualized results summarize the significance of authors and their affiliations in the selected body of literature, and the country-wise distribution. Four key research themes of LMB irrigation were identified based on the bibliometric analysis, for conducting an in-depth review. First, we investigated the factors that influence agricultural water management which directly affects irrigation water demand and supply as well as crop productivity. This part of the literature focused on water and land management and applications of various models to assess impacts on crop yields of irrigation management. Second, from the literature we analyzed the identified impacts of human flow alternations on downstream water uses, ecosystem health, and land subsidence due to groundwater overdraft. Nevertheless, upstream water management can mitigate downstream flood damages and augment dry-season water supply. Third, the spatiotemporal mismatch between water demand and supply pose a serious challenge for transboundary river basin management. Moreover, inappropriate water utilization, mismanagement and poor governance appear to be the more fundamental causes of the LMB water problems, thus calling for sound agricultural water policies within a riparian country and effective water management cooperation strategies across the riparian countries.  Fourth, despite of the relatively few publications on the Mekong’s WFE nexus so far, this particular topic is gaining growing attention in the Mekong basin research community. Moreover, it offers a valuable holistic perspective for analyzing irrigation in the LMB, by considering its connections with the food and energy sectors in one way or another, compared against many existing studies that view irrigation as solely an agricultural water management problem.

    How to cite: Wang, G. and Zhu, T.: A Review of Irrigation in the Lower Mekong Basin: Opportunities and Challenges from a Water-Food-Energy Nexus Perspective, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8202, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8202, 2022.

    EGU22-8545 | Presentations | HS5.1

    The balancing act of robust decision-making in complex water resource systems 

    Doris E Wendt and Francesca Pianosi

    Balancing drinking water supply and environmental water needs requires careful use of water resources. Some water sources are more resilient to climate extremes than others. For example, groundwater resources can buffer climate extremes, as groundwater storage in aquifers is slowly released, complementing water supply from surface sources during periods of water scarcity, heatwaves and (extreme) drought events. However, this resilience declines when groundwater storage is compromised due to periodic or sustained overuse with severe consequences for groundwater-dependant ecosystems. Sustainable groundwater management needs a robust decision-making approach, that looks beyond historical drought events and prepare for a possible combination of extreme conditions in a future climate, including not only climate uncertainty but also a changing water anthropogenic demand and environmental water needs.  

    In this study we present a bottom-up approach to support robust decision-making to improve climate resilience of drinking water supply systems, considering both surface water and groundwater use. We consider uncertainties related to model parameters, changing water demand and future climate conditions, as we apply this method to a system-level representation of a water management region in South England.  

    Results show under which climate conditions current water management strategies are confidently meeting drinking water supply with a margin for (seasonally) increased water demand. Future extreme conditions reveal increasing competing interests with environmental water needs and possible shortages in drinking water supply. Mapping the associated (un)certainty of short-term and long-term management strategies shows the value of robust decision-making to sustainable water use in complex water resource systems.

    How to cite: Wendt, D. E. and Pianosi, F.: The balancing act of robust decision-making in complex water resource systems, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8545, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8545, 2022.

    EGU22-8778 | Presentations | HS5.1

    Balancing sediment connectivity and energy production via optimized reservoir sediment management strategies 

    Marco Tangi, Simone Bizzi, Rafael Schmitt, and Andrea Castelletti

    Dam development projects cumulatively alter natural river connectivity, e.g., for fish and sediment, resulting in cumulative negative externalities across different spatio-temporal scales. Strategic siting of dams combined with dam-scale management, e.g., drawdown flushing for sediment passage, can help mitigate these impacts.

    Designing optimal reservoir management strategies for multiple dams (i.e., dam portfolios), which account for economic objectives as well as sediment connectivity, is rarely done due to the lack of specifically designed modelling tools to properly quantify the hydro-morphological response of river systems to water and sediment management schemes. Models designed for this purpose must retain both a basin-scale perspective (to capture cumulative impacts of multiple dams) and a dynamic time representation (to capture dynamic reservoir operations).

    This work presents a novel approach to reduce trade-offs between hydropower and sediment through integrating both optimal site selection and optimized joint operation of selected dam sites for sediment flushing. To estimate basin-wide sediment delivery and transport and quantify the effect of reservoirs on it, the study uses a new version of the D-CASCADE model, a process-based basin-scale dynamic sediment transport model.

    The study focuses on the 3S river system, a data-scarce tributary of the Mekong river, where major dam development is ongoing. First, (1) the D-CASCADE model is set up and compared to available evidence of grain sizes and transport rates in the network. Then, (2) the effect of reservoir management is explored for different, pre-defined dam development portfolios focusing on downstream reservoirs, assessing daily sediment transport and delivery. Reservoirs features (i.e., volume, energy generation, and sediment storage) are dynamically simulated via integrated modelling add-ons. Finally, (3) sediment management (through drawdown flushing) is optimized by including parameters specific to the timing, frequency, and design of drawdown flushing into the operation rules.

    Modelled network sediment yields matching field data measurements are identified and used as a baseline scenario to which to compare dam impacts on sediment delivery. Without sediment management, the model estimates a reduction in network sediment yield to the Mekong river of 32%-57%, depending on the dam portfolio. Sediment management portfolios showcase how reservoir sedimentation and downstream sediment starvation can be mitigated via well-designed flushing operations, albeit at a non-indifferent loss in energy production.

    How to cite: Tangi, M., Bizzi, S., Schmitt, R., and Castelletti, A.: Balancing sediment connectivity and energy production via optimized reservoir sediment management strategies, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8778, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8778, 2022.

    Setting upper limits to water consumption per river basin is crucial for ensuring sustainable water use. A blue water footprint cap is an upper limit to the consumptive use of surface and groundwater. A method to determine monthly blue water footprint caps in a river basin as a whole has been proposed (monthly natural runoff minus environmental flow requirements). However, the question remains how to translate caps for a river basin as a whole to caps for each sub-catchment within the basin. A relevant question, because human interventions in rivers have reduced water scarcity in upstream parts of river basins, but aggravated it in downstream parts. We apply two alternative water allocation scenarios to translate blue water footprint caps for the Yellow River basin to caps per sub-catchment and evaluate their effects on upstream-downstream differences in water scarcity: (i) the population-based scenario takes the relative population size per sub-catchment as the basis for water allocation, which makes sense from the perspective of equity and fair sharing of natural resources; (ii) the demand-based scenario takes the historical water demand as the basis for water allocation, which is an option to consider for river basin managers aiming to reduce environmental flow violations. Both scenarios make use of the fact that blue water can be reserved (not consumed) in an upstream sub-catchment for consumption further downstream. We measure the effects of the scenarios against a base case in which sub-catchments are allowed to consume all available water after considering environmental flow requirements without the consideration of downstream uses: the use-what-is-there principle. We find that blue water scarcity increases from upstream to downstream under the use-what-is-there principle. Both the population- and demand-based scenarios reduce upstream-downstream differences in the degree of blue water scarcity. The demand-based scenario is most effective in this respect. On the other hand, the population-based scenario leads to the smallest upstream-downstream differences in water availability per capita. The results feed into a discussion on how to translate upper-limits to water consumption from the river basin to the sub-catchment level which needs to take place for cap-setting to become a practical instrument in river basin management.

    How to cite: Schyns, J., Albers, L., and Booij, M.: Translating blue water footprint caps for a river basin to caps per sub-catchment: trade-offs between upstream-downstream uses and the environment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9224, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9224, 2022.

    EGU22-10611 | Presentations | HS5.1

    Vulnerable basins for global prioritisation: Hotspots for social and ecological impacts from freshwater stress and freshwater storage loss 

    Xander Huggins, Tom Gleeson, Matti Kummu, Samuel C. Zipper, Yoshihide Wada, Tara J. Troy, and James S. Famiglietti

    Society and ecosystems are deeply connected to, and through, hydrological processes. Significant research efforts have revealed the breadth of ways humans have become dominant drivers of the global water cycle, however less attention has been placed on how hydrological change will affect social and ecological systems at the global scale. Understanding both directions of this coupled social-ecological system are critical to achieving sustainable freshwater futures in complex, multi-objective decision making environments. Here, we identify the global hotspots for social and ecological impacts from freshwater stress and freshwater storage loss.

    We applied the concept of hotspot mapping, from the field of conservation biogeography, to integrated socio- and eco-hydrological considerations for the first time at the global scale. We identified 168 basins for global prioritisation that are most vulnerable to suffer social and ecological impacts from freshwater stress and storage loss. These basins encompass over 1.5 billion people, 17% of global food crop production, 13% of global gross domestic product, and hundreds of internationally significant wetlands (Ramsar sites). The impacts that can be realised in these basins include transgressed environmental flows, increased drought frequency, decreased ecological resilience, threatened water, economic, and food security through reduced freshwater availability, and increased risk of wells running dry which may exacerbate existing economic inequalities. Regions and nations home to hotspot basins include: Argentina, northeastern Brazil, southwestern USA, Northern, Eastern, and Southern Africa, the Middle East and Arabian Peninsula, the Caucasus, West Asia, northern India, Nepal, Pakistan, Southeast Asia, and northern China.  

    The 168 hotspot basins present an initial set of regions to prioritise in global sustainability initiatives that link water, ecosystems, and society, such as the Sustainable Development Goals. Furthermore, the hotspots represent the multiple epicentres where management of trade-offs between social, economic, and ecological water uses is most crucial, and thus represent the regions where implementation of integrated water resources management (IWRM) practises becomes most critical.  To this end, we compared IWRM implementation levels to our global vulnerability results. While no direct relationship was found between IWRM implementation and social-ecological vulnerability to freshwater stress and storage loss, we observed, among hotspot basins, that IWRM implementation is lower in transboundary basins than in non-transboundary basins, suggesting that greater multilateralism and cooperation are needed. 

    We identified hotspot basins by integrating global socio-hydrological and eco-hydrological datasets, remote sensing observations of freshwater storage trends, freshwater use, and streamflow datasets into a basin-scale social-ecological vulnerability analysis. This presentation reports the findings from Huggins et al. (in press, Nature Communications), and the hotspot basin results are available online for use by policy and research communities.

    Freshwater stress and storage loss are only two of many important aspects of freshwater with broad social-ecological resilience implications. Developing a network of similar analyses based on other processes and attributes, such as intra- and inter-annual storage variability, and water quality considerations, will support a more comprehensive understanding of the social-ecological impacts of global hydrological change.

    How to cite: Huggins, X., Gleeson, T., Kummu, M., Zipper, S. C., Wada, Y., Troy, T. J., and Famiglietti, J. S.: Vulnerable basins for global prioritisation: Hotspots for social and ecological impacts from freshwater stress and freshwater storage loss, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10611, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10611, 2022.

    EGU22-11027 | Presentations | HS5.1

    Enhancing global hydrological models with local knowledge to support Nexus analyses 

    David Haro Monteagudo, Andrea Momblanch, Peter Burek, Taher Kahil, Joaquín Andreu, Javier Paredes-Arquiola, Abel Solera, and Santiago Beguería

    Over recent decades major advances have been made in global hydrological modelling underpinned by progress in high-resolution data availability, as well as in computational and data storage capabilities. These advances have provided hydrologists with opportunities to develop high-resolution large-scale hydrological models (LHMs) designed to represent and study the global hydrological cycle. However, with the aim of answering relevant questions for water resources policy and management, LHMs have recently been used in a number of regional applications. This has been enabled by their increasing spatial resolution which makes it possible to zoom-in on specific regions, essentially removing the barriers between global and regional models.

    Notwithstanding their growing sophistication, the current generation of LHMs still fall short in their ability to represent dynamic trade-offs in the water-food-energy-environment nexus, and water competition between upstream and downstream users. These limitations hinder the ability of LHMs to provide reliable insights at any scale other than the global, leaving the task of incorporating human water management activities within these models as one of the grand challenges for the hydrologic research community.

    Catchment-scale water management models (CWMMs) adopt a holistic systems approach to comprehensively address water availability, use, infrastructure, and policy aspects within multi-sectoral water allocation. The coupling of these models with LHMs can enhance their representation of human interventions in the natural water cycle (e.g., management of reservoirs, intra- and inter-basin water transfers) and improve the accuracy of water demand estimations such as irrigation requirements by including irrigation schemes. The inclusion of this local knowledge into LHMs’ modelling process can, therefore, increase their capacity to support rigorous nexus analyses to inform water policy and management decisions.

    This work represents the preliminary outcome of a project with the overall research objective of developing and providing a “proof-of-concept” to explore and design an approach for integrating CWMMs with LHMs, and to assess its potential and limitations to enhance the quality of information LHMs provide at regional scale. This work will present the initial efforts to compare the outcomes of LHMs from the Inter-Sectoral Impact Model Intercomparison Project and the CWMM AQUATOOL in the Ebro River basin, a heavily managed catchment in Spain with multiple competing water uses. This comparison will provide an estimate of the capacity of LHMs to provide useful information for decision making, as well as to identify knowledge gaps to be filled with management models.

    How to cite: Haro Monteagudo, D., Momblanch, A., Burek, P., Kahil, T., Andreu, J., Paredes-Arquiola, J., Solera, A., and Beguería, S.: Enhancing global hydrological models with local knowledge to support Nexus analyses, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11027, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11027, 2022.

    EGU22-11170 | Presentations | HS5.1

    Reducing future water stress in the Seewinkel region in Austria: exploring water management opportunities for the sustainable use of the shared groundwater resource. 

    Reetik Kumar Sahu, Taher Kahil, Luca Guillaumot, Peter Burek, Susanne Hangar-Kopp, Veronica Karabaczek, Martina Offenzeller, and Helga Lindinger

    Austria is well endowed with water resources where the total water demand consumes only 3% of the total water supply. However, with increased water demand from agriculture, domestic and industrial sectors and increased frequency of high heat and drought occurrences from future climate change, several regions can potentially face high water stress for short periods in a year which is detrimental to the economy and the environment. The Seewinkel region located in eastern Austria is one such case where both agriculture and environment are dependent on a reliable quantity of water to be available throughout the year. Apart from precipitation, additional crop water requirement is satisfied using an irrigation infrastructure. Groundwater which is the sole source of irrigation water in the region is pumped based on the water allocations prescribed to each irrigation cooperative in the region. These allocations currently limit groundwater withdrawals for potentially higher agricultural output and maintain the natural Seewinkel wetland supported by groundwater body. With climate change induced water stress in the future, sufficient water table levels cannot be maintained throughout the year whil​e simultaneously trying to satisfy agricultural and environmental water demand. Our study identifies different cost optimal management strategies to optimally manage the groundwater resources shared between multiple irrigation cooperatives in the region. Some of the strategies include optimal crop-land mix, irrigation technology transitions, building new water supply infrastructure and using financial instruments. Additionally, the study aims to identify the nature of the shared common pool of groundwater to identify the potential of trading water allocation rights between irrigation cooperatives which can lead to efficient water use. The strategies have been identified based on the stakeholder interviews conducted in the region under the WaterStressAT project KR19AC0K17504 funded by the Austrian Climate Research Program twelfth call.

    How to cite: Sahu, R. K., Kahil, T., Guillaumot, L., Burek, P., Hangar-Kopp, S., Karabaczek, V., Offenzeller, M., and Lindinger, H.: Reducing future water stress in the Seewinkel region in Austria: exploring water management opportunities for the sustainable use of the shared groundwater resource., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11170, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11170, 2022.

    EGU22-11450 | Presentations | HS5.1

    The role of multi-sector climate impacts in achieving water, energy, and land SDGs 

    Adriano Vinca, Muhammad Awais, Edward Byers, Oliver Fricko, Stefan Frank, Yusuke Satoh, Volker Krey, and Keywan Riahi

    Several studies have explored the interaction across the water, energy, and land (WEL) systems under the scope of policy analysis, highlighting the importance and usefulness of integrated approaches in exploring pathways for achieving the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) in the WEL sectors. However, most of these studies neglect the possible impact of climate change on the natural system (e.g. water cycle and crop yields changes) or on technologies (e.g. power plant potentials, desalination, etc.) because of the high complexity, interconnection and uncertainty of these impacts.
    Using the latest version of the MESSAGEix-GLOBIOM Integrated Assessment Model (IAM), we study the long-term resources, supply and demand of the energy, water and land sectors to determine the regional and sectoral investments required for achieving the SDGs. Here we show the implications of climate feedbacks for different regions and sectors under different climate mitigation scenarios. The largest component of climate impacts, and the highest source of uncertainty, are changes in water availability, which affect irrigation, provision of basic water and sanitation access, hydropower potential and the available technology options for cooling power plants.

    How to cite: Vinca, A., Awais, M., Byers, E., Fricko, O., Frank, S., Satoh, Y., Krey, V., and Riahi, K.: The role of multi-sector climate impacts in achieving water, energy, and land SDGs, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11450, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11450, 2022.

    EGU22-12231 | Presentations | HS5.1

    A framework to assess cooperation benefits of new infrastructure in transboundary river basins without formal water sharing arrangements and operating rules 

    Jose M. Gonzalez, Evgenii S Matrosov, Emmanuel Obuobie, and Julien Harou

    New dams can alter river flow regimes impacting downstream benefits and multi-sector services from water infrastructure and ecosystems. Impacts can be unpredictable in complex transboundary river basins that do not follow standardised operating rules nor have extensive historical data. In this case it is more difficult to assess the consequences of new infrastructure and provide a structured approach to achieve cooperative operating strategies to avoid transboundary water conflicts. This study presents a framework to evaluate the benefits of cooperation on managing new dams in transboundary multi-sector river basins that do not have formal cooperating strategies. A case study of the new Pwalugu Multipurpose Dam (PMD) located in Ghana’s Volta river basin is provided. The PMD could impact downstream riverine livelihood, ecosystem services, and water infrastructure like the downstream Aksomobo hydropower plant, the country's largest installed generation plant (1,020 MW). Also, the PDM could be impacted by future irritation developments of the Bagre Dam, an existing upstream dam managed in Burkina Faso. We show that a non-cooperative operation between the PMD and the Bagre dam in Burkina Faso could reduce inflows into the Akosombo dam, negatively impacting national hydropower generation. Also, a non-cooperative operation could decrease floods in Northern Ghana, impacting environmental services and local communities that depend on flood recession activities. We show that cooperative infrastructure management achieved by the proposed approach could offset possible negative impacts produced by the new PMD.

    How to cite: Gonzalez, J. M., Matrosov, E. S., Obuobie, E., and Harou, J.: A framework to assess cooperation benefits of new infrastructure in transboundary river basins without formal water sharing arrangements and operating rules, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12231, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12231, 2022.

    EGU22-12235 | Presentations | HS5.1

    Present and future water scarcity hotspots for rainfed and irrigated agriculture under climate change: a global study. 

    Juliana Arbelaez Gaviria, Amanda Palazzo, Esther Boere, Petr Havlik, Peter Burek, Juraj Balkovič, and Miroslav Trnka

    Climate change disrupts weather patterns in various ways across the world, leading to an increased variability in rainfall and therefore water availability, which in turn exacerbates water scarcity. At the same time, a growing population and rising GDP increases the demand for food and the demand for water in agriculture and other sectors. While 40% of agricultural production comes from irrigated systems, and represents 20% the total cultivated land, large-scale assessments of climate change impacts on agricultural production and food security typically focus on direct crop yield effects only. The increased water scarcity through an increased demand and a decreased supply for irrigation water is likely to impact agricultural production, leading to cascading effects on consumption, markets, and food security.

    Using an integrated impact chain including climate, hydrology, crop, and economic models, we present the results of a fully integrated assessment of the climate change impacts on both crop yields and water availability relying on the most recent CMIP6 climate change projections to analyze the impacts of irrigation as an adaptation measure for climate-induced yield losses and socio-economic increased demands. Using the Community Water Model (CWatM) we simulate changes to water availability for irrigation under various climate and socio-economic scenarios. Using the Environmental Policy Integrated Climate model (EPIC) model, we assess the impact of climate on yield under irrigated and rainfed systems. The availability of water and requirements for irrigated and rainfed crop production are subsequently integrated in the Global Biosphere Management Model (GLOBIOM) model to assess the uptake of irrigation as an adaptation mechanism and the probability, location, and extent of agricultural water scarcity hotspots, where available water resources fail to meet the agricultural demand, considering also demands from non-agricultural sectors. The model further assesses the consequences of subsequent changes in production, consumption, market, and highly productive areas that coincide with water scarcity hotspots under climate change. Areas with a surplus of water are also identified as potential irrigation investment locations.  

    Results show that, by the mid-century, water use for irrigation is projected to increase worldwide. Brazil, China, Canada, Europe, and South-East Asia are expected to use over 40% more water for irrigation compared to 2000 in the high-emissions RCP 8.5 scenario. In contrast, water available for irrigation is diminished in Brazil and other regions in South and Central America as non-agricultural water demand increased. Non-agricultural water demand constrained the water available for irrigation in India and Sub-Sharan Africa as well. The irrigation water use in Europe and Canada are expected to occur at expenses of environmental flow requirements. 

    How to cite: Arbelaez Gaviria, J., Palazzo, A., Boere, E., Havlik, P., Burek, P., Balkovič, J., and Trnka, M.: Present and future water scarcity hotspots for rainfed and irrigated agriculture under climate change: a global study., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12235, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12235, 2022.

    EGU22-12703 | Presentations | HS5.1

    Hydropower capacity expansion in the African continent under different socio-economic and climate policy scenarios 

    Angelo Carlino, Matthias Wildemeersch, Matteo Giuliani, and Andrea Castelletti

    Hydropower and other renewable energy sources are experiencing new investments for capacity expansion to provide clean and accessible energy to a growing population in many world areas. As most of the untapped hydropower potential lies in developing countries, here, strategic dam planning is critical in supporting the design of capacity expansion with reduced impact on interconnected water, food, and climate systems.

    This is true especially for Africa, where more than 300 new hydropower projects are under consideration, and future population growth projections and associated energy, water, and food demands are highly uncertain.

    In this work, we investigate how to strategically plan hydropower capacity expansion at the African continental scale, providing an estimate of future hydropower capacity needs. Specifically, we model the energy system using The Electricity Base Model for Africa (TEMBA), based on the OSeMOSYS energy modelling framework, and we consider capacity factors for each hydropower project reported in the African Hydropower Atlas as derived from the hydrologic simulation of the SWAT model that accounts for irrigation demand. To explore different socio-economic and climate policy projections, we also downscale final energy demands projections at the country level from the SSP database. We then investigate two different planning approaches: first, using scenario analysis, we examine how the different individual projections influence hydropower and power system development; second, we adopt a two-stage robust optimization methodology to develop a robust capacity expansion plan common for all the socio-economic and climate policy scenarios until 2035. Finally, we hypothesize that uncertainty about the socio-economic scenario is resolved, and we model the adaptation of the capacity expansion strategy to each of the narratives considered in the period 2035-2050 by solving a new optimization problem.

    Our results show that not all the 100 GW of hydropower projects considered in the African Hydropower Atlas are needed to satisfy the final energy demands. Furthermore, as we observe large variability in hydropower capacity expansion under different socio-economic projections, we produce a short-term robust plan extracting the most relevant hydroelectric projects via robust optimization. Finally, we show that adapting capacity planning decisions based on new information can strongly reduce the price of robustness.

    Our work proposes a methodology for taking planning decisions in an integrated assessment context where scenarios are used to link different societal sectors and resources. When the uncertainty spanned by plausible future states of the world is large and diverging, a combination of robust optimization and adaptive planning can reduce the potential for bad societal outcomes.

    How to cite: Carlino, A., Wildemeersch, M., Giuliani, M., and Castelletti, A.: Hydropower capacity expansion in the African continent under different socio-economic and climate policy scenarios, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12703, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12703, 2022.

    EGU22-13160 | Presentations | HS5.1

    Factors Influencing the Awareness and Adoption of Borehole-Garden Permaculture in Malawi: Lessons for the Promotion of Sustainable Practices 

    Rebekah Hinton, Christopher Macleod, Mads Troldborg, Gift Wanangwa, Modesta Kanjaye, Emma Mbalame, Patrice Mleta, Kettie Harawa, Steve Kumwenda, and Robert M. Kalin

    Using wastewater accumulating around rural waterpoints to irrigate community gardens, borehole-garden permaculture presents a method of local sustainable water management. Alongside this, borehole-garden permaculture also presents public health benefits through the removal of stagnant water around boreholes, key Malaria breeding grounds, and through providing year-round food to supplement diets. By analysing a dataset of over 100,000 cases, this research examines the awareness and adoption of borehole-garden permaculture across Malawi. Generalised linear models identified significant variables influencing borehole-garden permaculture awareness and uptake revealing that socioeconomic, biophysical, and waterpoint-specific variables influenced both the awareness and adoption of borehole-garden permaculture. While 43.0% of communities were aware of borehole-garden permaculture uptake in Malawi was low; only 2.4% of communities surveyed were practising borehole-garden permaculture. Communities in areas with unreliable rainfall and high malaria susceptibility had low borehole-garden permaculture awareness despite borehole-garden permaculture being particularly beneficial to these communities. This work suggests that future work in the promotion of borehole-garden permaculture should focus their efforts within these areas. Furthermore, this work highlights the value of community networks in knowledge sharing and suggests that such social capital could be further used by NGOs and the Government of Malawi in the promotion of borehole-garden permaculture and other sustainable practices in water management. 

    How to cite: Hinton, R., Macleod, C., Troldborg, M., Wanangwa, G., Kanjaye, M., Mbalame, E., Mleta, P., Harawa, K., Kumwenda, S., and Kalin, R. M.: Factors Influencing the Awareness and Adoption of Borehole-Garden Permaculture in Malawi: Lessons for the Promotion of Sustainable Practices, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13160, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13160, 2022.

    EGU22-699 | Presentations | HS5.2

    Exploration of the theoretical, financial, technical and sustainable hydropower generation potential in the Upper Indus basin 

    Sanita Dhaubanjar, Arthur Lutz, David Gernaat, Santosh Nepal, Saurav Pradhananga, Sonu Khanal, Arun Bhakta Shrestha, and Walter Immerzeel

    Hydropower investment decisions in the Upper Indus take a short-sighted approach based on energy generation potential at individual hydropower sites considering historical hydro-climatology. But hydropower will increasingly be affected in the future by changing climate and demands for water, energy and food – all heavily dependent on water resources availability. The seasonality and variability in runoff are changing. Anthropogenic water consumption may see a two to three fold increase by the end of the century with socio-economic development. Climate change and interlinkages with the water-energy-food nexus are emerging as primary stressors to land and water resources availability for hydropower in the Indus. Hence, we assess the extent of the challenges posed by climate change versus the nexus linkages on hydropower potential in the Upper Indus. Our sustainable hydropower exploration framework takes a systems approach to quantify theoretical, technical, economic and sustainable hydropower potential by successively considering the impact of natural, technical, financial, anthropogenic, environmental, and geo-hazard constrains on hydropower potential at both the individual site and the basin scales. The framework explicitly considers the water available for hydropower versus other nexus usages. We combine the framework with downscaled CMIP6 general circulation models and water consumption projections to compare current and future hydropower potential. Thus, we present hydropower development portfolios that are more robust under climate change and changes across the water-energy-food nexus. Future changes in climate and water demands will increase the need for a multi-sectoral approach in the identification of potential sites to achieve sustainable hydropower development. We present a basin-scale analysis of hydropower potential in the Upper Indus, now and in the future, considering growing demands for water, food and energy to fulfill the Sustainable Development Goals.

    How to cite: Dhaubanjar, S., Lutz, A., Gernaat, D., Nepal, S., Pradhananga, S., Khanal, S., Bhakta Shrestha, A., and Immerzeel, W.: Exploration of the theoretical, financial, technical and sustainable hydropower generation potential in the Upper Indus basin, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-699, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-699, 2022.

    In the United Kingdom (UK), the amount of electricity generated from small-scale hydropower has nearly tripled since 2010. One of the key areas of growth within the sector has been run-of-river hydropower schemes, with several hundred now operating across the UK and the Republic of Ireland (RoI), the majority situated in mountainous areas of Scotland and Wales. Although the overall grid contribution of these schemes is small (~2%), they still play an important role, not only in decarbonising the grid and contributing to national emission reduction goals, but also at local scales, where schemes often provide financial benefit to local communities and individuals. However, future climate change threatens to alter precipitation patterns and therefore streamflows, potentially impacting both the timing of hydropower generation and the total power output potential.

    In this study, we quantify the impact of a worst-case future climate change scenario (Representative Concentration Pathway 8.5) on the generation potential of run-of-river hydropower schemes in the UK and RoI. EXP-HYDRO hydrological model is used to simulate future daily streamflow for the 2021-2080 hydrological years in 178 catchments containing 531 hydropower abstractions. We estimate daily abstraction potential at each site based on the local environmental regulators’ (for Scotland, England, Wales, Northern Ireland, and Ireland) general abstraction conditions. We then perform seasonal and annual Mann-Kendall trend analysis at each site to analyse changes in: 1) the number of days when abstraction is possible, 2) the number of days when maximum abstraction is reached, 3) mean abstraction volume on days when abstraction is possible, and 4) the total abstractable volume. The scale of study undertaken allows for characterisation of both the impact of regional variation in future climate forcing, as well as analysis of the impact of local environmental regulation, on the future generation potential of run-of-river hydropower in the UK and RoI.

    Results show increasing annual total abstraction potential in northern England and Scotland, while a decline is seen in Wales; little change is seen in Ireland and Northern Ireland. The number of days per year that abstraction is possible declines in all areas except the northwest of Scotland, while the number of days that maximum allowable abstraction is reached increases; mean daily abstraction therefore increases. A disparity can be seen in different nations between the magnitude, and in some cases direction, of change in annual mean streamflows compared to annual abstraction potential. This is likely caused by differences in water abstraction regulations between UK nations. This poses an interesting question in terms of the impact of environmental regulations for the different nations of the UK, and how best to maximise renewable energy output by hydropower, while protecting the natural environment.

    How to cite: Dallison, R. and Patil, S.: Water availability assessment for run-of-river hydropower under future climate change in the UK and Ireland, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-806, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-806, 2022.

    EGU22-2132 | Presentations | HS5.2

    Application on the Micro-hydropower generation Benefits of Agricultural Channels and the Water- Energy-Food nexus 

    Jen-Chieh Shih, Fu-Yuan Lin, Ming-Der Hong, Hong-Ru Lin, and Jet-Chau Wen

    Micro-hydropower is necessary renewable energy to provide baseload, and it has the advantages of sustainable development and reduction of greenhouse gas emissions. There is an interrelationship between irrigation water and energy from micro-hydropower with micro-hydropower development in agricultural irrigation systems. Li et al. (2019) mentioned that the agricultural system estimated the water supply-demand, energy supply-demand, land demand, and food production and was quantitatively analyzed under different scenarios. However, the study of water for electricity generation was neglected in the agricultural system. Zhou et al. (2019) apply small-hydropower into water supply systems to lift renewable power output and uplift the synergistic benefits of the Water-Food-Energy (WFE) Nexus steered by the optimal water allocation and small-hydropower installation. Still, the adjustment of the water source by the reservoir makes the flow of the water supply system unstable, which leads to inconsistent electricity generation of small hydropower. Gaudard et al. (2018) research that hydropower plants' relationship between water and energy is set-upstream. The results show that seasonality slightly affects hydroelectric power generation.

    Therefore, the study set up a micro-hydropower generation system in the Linnei channel of the Zhuoshuixi river watershed in the middle of Taiwan. Collected channel background information and used Doppel (Teledyne StreamPro ADCP) to measure the water level, velocity, and discharge of the study site, analyze potential power generation, and evaluate the profit and payback period micro-hydropower generation and the impact of micro- hydropower systems in agriculture. Furthermore, to investigate the relationship nexus of WFE and assess micro-hydropower's effectiveness in reducing carbon dioxide emissions. According to the results of this study, it can be used as a reference basis for setting up other micro-hydropower systems in the future.

    How to cite: Shih, J.-C., Lin, F.-Y., Hong, M.-D., Lin, H.-R., and Wen, J.-C.: Application on the Micro-hydropower generation Benefits of Agricultural Channels and the Water- Energy-Food nexus, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2132, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2132, 2022.

    The European Union’s endeavors to find the right path to a climate-neutral future in 2050, the so-called green shift, is the subject of heated debate. One of the currently most discussed question is: What are the electricity sources of the future? While EU’s member states arguing about the advantages and disadvantages of nuclear and gas-fired power plants during this green shift, other countries have already succeeded in achieving extensive climate-neutrality in the electricity sector. Norway is currently one of the largest producers of sustainable electricity in Europe with an annual hydropower production capacity of 136.6 TWh from around 33,000 MW installed capacity (2021)[1]. Moreover, one of Norway’s possible strategies is to become the green battery of Europe – enabling neighboring countries to store energy peaks from renewable electricity generation in the Norwegian energy system.

    Its geological and climate prerequisites enabled Norway to become a forerunner for renewable energies in the global electricity market. The advantages of hydropower technology found unbroken success in Norway in the first decades after World War II, heralding the beginning of the “most intense period for hydropower development in Norway”[2]. This period ended in 1990 when most of today’s hydropower capacities were fully developed and new legislation was introduced. Today we take Norway’s hydropower legacy for granted and therefore know little about the country’s own electricity debates during this expansion period.

    As part of the PhD research project “Norway’s hydropower development boom in the perception of society”, this contribution to the EGU General Assembly 2022 is intended to shed light on these electricity debates by elaborating the sociotechnical imaginaries of electricity futures in Norway from 1945 to 1990[3]. Different public debates facing electricity capacity building of this period will be presented by analyzing 62 articles of Norway’s most important newspaper of public record Aftenposten. Who participated in these debates? What is the respective imagination about Norway’s electricity future about and for what reason?

    It turns out that the renewables pioneer in the north of Europe was not a hermetically sealed land of hydropower enthusiasts. Quite the opposite: In the public debates of scientists, engineers, politicians and residents in Norway, developments on the global electricity market were taken seriously, such as the introduction of nuclear power technology, the onset of transnational electricity trading, and the emerging social skepticism about ecological damages caused by hydropower. As a final remark, this contribution will face the question why hydropower remained the ‘royal road’ for Norway’s electricity development.


    [1] Norges vassdrags- og energidirektorat (ed.). 2021. Vannkraft. https://www.nve.no/energi/energisystem/vannkraft/

    [2] Lia, L. et al. 2015. “The current status of hydropower development and dam construction in Norway”. International journal of hydropower and dams. Vol. 22(3): 42.

    [3] The wording refers to the concept of “sociotechnical imaginaries” as described in Jasanoff, S. 2015. “Future Imperfect: Science, Technology, and the Imaginations of Modernity’” in Jasanoff, S. and Kim, S. H. (eds.) Dreamscapes of Modernity: Sociotechnical Imaginaries and the Fabrication of Power. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, pp. 1–33.

    How to cite: Fischer, M. and Lia, L.: The reasons why hydropower remained. Sociotechnical imaginaries of electricity futures in Norway from 1945 to 1990. A media analysis based on articles from the Norwegian daily newspaper Aftenposten, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4651, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4651, 2022.

    EGU22-4726 | Presentations | HS5.2

    Climate change impacts on Alpine hydropower in the context of environmental impacts and technical constraints 

    Tobias Wechsler, Dorothea Hug Peter, Massimiliano Zappa, and Bettina Schaefli

    Hydropower production affects different stakeholders, levels of administration and ecosystems, which makes the question of its sustainability complex. Hydropower delivers energy, storage capacity, jobs, economic value, but also involves altered streamflow, water temperature and sediment transport conditions, fractioning of aquatic habitats and modification of the landscape. Thus, an increasing demand for renewable and climate friendly energy from hydropower also results in more pressure on aquatic habitats, thereby potentially calling into question its sustainability.

    In this work, we compare climate change impacts on the future energy production of 21 hydropower plants in Switzerland, to impacts related to environmental flow requirements and to site-specific technical optimisation potential. The simulation-based study corresponds to three future periods (2020–2049, 2045–2074 and 2070–2099) under three emission scenarios (RCP2.6, RCP4.5, RCP8.5), assuming unchanged environmental flow requirements and installed machinery. The results show an increase of winter production and a decrease of summer production, which in conjunction leads to an annual decrease. The simulated impacts strongly depend on the elevation and the plant-specific characteristics. The climate induced changes in production are of a similar order of magnitude as the production loss due to environmental flow requirements and the increase potential due to technical optimisations. A key result is that the climate induced reduction is not linearly related to the underlying streamflow reduction, but is modulated by environmental flow requirements, the design discharge and streamflow projections. Taken a step further, a change in production does not necessarily mean a linear change in financial revenue. The Water-Energy Nexus in terms of hydropower concerns more than just a m3s-1–kWh relationship: it is part of a complex framework that is namely sensitive to legal adjustments and to long lasting technical decisions taken in the past.

    How to cite: Wechsler, T., Hug Peter, D., Zappa, M., and Schaefli, B.: Climate change impacts on Alpine hydropower in the context of environmental impacts and technical constraints, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4726, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4726, 2022.

    EGU22-4882 | Presentations | HS5.2

    A quantitative technology for supporting multi-objective decision making in hydropower operation 

    Xiaokuan Ni, Zengchuan Dong, Yong Jiang, Hongyi Yao, Wenhao Jia, and Guang Yang

    There is a conflict between the hydropower benefit of hydraulic engineering and other functions such as ecological protection, water supply, flood control, etc. Deciding on an appropriate scheme to balance the interests among multiple objectives is a crucial issue in hydropower operation management. The Pareto set is the carrier and embodiment of a multi-objective mutual feedback relationship. It has a constant increasing or decreasing tendency, and most distribute unevenly, meaning different change rates and sensitivities are embedded. Based on this understanding, a new idea of "profit/loss ratio" is obtained, which constructed the average change rate of each neighbouring non-inferior solution on the Pareto frontier. Processed dimensionless, a new non-dominated subset of Pareto non-inferior solutions is filtered out according to the dominance relationship to limit scheme selection scope. On this basis, a method for calculating the "bias degree" of each Pareto non-inferior solution relative to different objective functions is proposed, which leads to the quantitative evaluation of Pareto solutions and provides quantitative support for decision-makers select operation schemes according to their preferences. Taking the cascade reservoirs in the lower reaches of the Jinsha River Basin in China as a case, the trade-off between the two objectives of hydropower generation and ecological protection is investigated, and the feasibility and effectiveness of the methodology are verified.

    How to cite: Ni, X., Dong, Z., Jiang, Y., Yao, H., Jia, W., and Yang, G.: A quantitative technology for supporting multi-objective decision making in hydropower operation, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4882, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4882, 2022.

    EGU22-5384 | Presentations | HS5.2

    Hard-coupling of water and power system models increases the complementarity of renewable energy sources 

    Rachel Koh, Jordan Kern, and Stefano Galelli

    Multi-sector modelling frameworks are fundamental platforms for exploring the complex interactions between the water and energy sectors. While acknowledging the pivotal role of hydropower within the energy system, it is essential to understand the feedback mechanisms between power and water systems to guide the design of hydropower operations and enhance water-energy management strategies. Here, we developed a novel modelling approach that hard-couples a reservoir system model and a power system model. The two-way dynamic feedback mechanism between the models allows for operational decisions to be made contingent upon the states of both water and energy systems. Operating the system as a whole offers flexibility in managing the physical storage of hydropower reservoirs to buffer the variability in other renewables, such as wind or solar. We evaluate the framework on a real-world case study based on the Cambodian grid, which relies on hydropower, coal, oil and imports from neighboring countries. In light of the country’s plan to further decarbonize its grid, we tested the framework on three grid configurations, the as-is grid, and the grid with two different levels of installed solar. To evaluate the effects of hard coupling, the experiments were simulated with and without feedback, and external inputs were varied with 1,000 stochastic generations of streamflow, solar and load. As demonstrated in our results, hard-coupling the water and energy systems brings benefits such as reduced operating costs, and boosts decarbonization efforts by supporting the integration of renewables in the grid. The two main external factors that determine the effectiveness of the feedback mechanism are streamflow and load. Under favorable conditions (large reservoir inflow and low electricity demand), the system experienced a 44% saving in annual operating costs and 53% reduction of CO2 emissions. A spatio-temporal analysis on the reservoir operations and transmission line usage reveals that the timing of the monsoon and interconnections between the grid components also play significant roles in influencing the system’s responses to the hard coupling. Overall, our modeling framework paves way for optimized operations within the water-energy nexus. By accounting for the interdependencies between the reservoir and power system, a more efficient operating scheme for hydropower reservoirs can be derived, leading to greater complementarity of renewable energy sources.

    How to cite: Koh, R., Kern, J., and Galelli, S.: Hard-coupling of water and power system models increases the complementarity of renewable energy sources, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5384, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5384, 2022.

    EGU22-5468 | Presentations | HS5.2

    Towards energy autonomy of small Mediterranean islands: Challenges, perspectives and solutions 

    Athanasios Zisos, Maria-Eleni Pantazi, Marianna Diamanta, Ifigeneia Koutsouradi, Anna Kontaxopoulou, Ioannis Tsoukalas, Georgia-Konstantina Sakki, and Andreas Efstratiadis

    The energy autonomy of small non-interconnected islands in the Mediterranean, taking advantage of their high renewable energy potential, has been a long-standing objective of local communities and stakeholders. This is also in line with the recently implemented European Green Deal, which has set the goal of increasing the renewable energy penetration in European countries’ power systems. However, the islands have further challenges than the large-scale inland areas. On the one hand, their population fluctuates significantly across seasons, as result of tourism, which is their key economic activity. The footprint of tourism is a substantial stress to all associated resources and infrastructures during the summer period. On the other hand, most of these areas suffer from both water and land scarcity. These features raise several challenges regarding the development of really autonomous energy systems, based on renewables and essential storage works to regulate the energy surpluses and deficits in the long run. Taking as example the Cycladic island of Sifnos, Greece, we investigate the design of a hybrid power system, combining wind, solar and hydroelectric energy. A major component of the proposed layout is the pumped-storage system. Due to the limited surface water resources of the island, we configure an upper tank at an elevation of 320 m, recycling seawater. This peculiarity introduces a significant level of uncertainty in hydraulic calculations, as well as various technical challenges, such as the erosion of pipes and the electromechanical equipment, and the waterproofing of the tank. An additional challenge is raised by the peculiar wind regime of the island, that makes essential to choose a hub height of turbines to minimize the frequency of power cut-offs. The basis of a rational design procedure for the main system components is the financial optimization that ensures a desirable level of reliability. This is achieved through a stochastic simulation approach that takes into account the stochastic nature of the underlying hydrometeorological drivers (wind velocity and solar radiation) and the energy demand.

    How to cite: Zisos, A., Pantazi, M.-E., Diamanta, M., Koutsouradi, I., Kontaxopoulou, A., Tsoukalas, I., Sakki, G.-K., and Efstratiadis, A.: Towards energy autonomy of small Mediterranean islands: Challenges, perspectives and solutions, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5468, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5468, 2022.

    EGU22-7787 | Presentations | HS5.2

    The role of innovative econometric models in short-term hydropower optimization 

    Diego Avesani, Ariele Zanfei, Di Marco Nicola, Andrea Galletti, Ravazzolo Francesco, Righetti Maurizio, and Bruno Majone

    The recent transformation of the electricity market has modified the hydropower production paradigm, especially for storage reservoir systems. In particular, the process of market liberation has led to a shift in hydropower management approaches. These have moved from strategies oriented to maximizing energy production to strategies aimed at revenue maximization. Indeed, hydropower producers bid their energy production scheduling in advance, attempting to align the operational plan for the ensuing day (i.e., allocating 1-day ahead the hourly time series of turbined water discharges) with hours where the expected electricity prices are higher. As a result, the accuracy of 1-day ahead electricity prices forecasts, as given by econometric models, has started to play a key role in the short-term optimization of storage reservoir systems. Though recognized, this aspect has so far received limited attention in the literature.

    This work aims to contribute to the topic by presenting a comparative assessment of revenues provided by the solution of short-term hydropower optimization problems driven by two econometric models during an entire year of simulation. Both models are autoregressive time-adapting hourly forecasting models which exploit the information provided by past values of electricity prices. One model, referred as Autoarimax, can be considered as the state-of-the-art in electricity prices forecasting, the peculiarities of which are rooted in the use of time-varying exogenous variables related to electricity demand and production, while the other, referred to as the Benchmark, can be considered a standard autoregressive model.

    The added value of using an innovative econometric model is exemplified in two selected hydropower systems with different storage capacities located in the south- eastern Alpine region. The enhanced accuracy of electricity prices forecasting is not constant across the year due to the large uncertainties characterizing the electricity market, the fluctuations of which are controlled by short-term and seasonal imbalances in factors affecting electricity demand and production. Our results also show that the adoption of this more accurate econometric model leads to larger revenues with respect to the use of a standard model. The increased revenues depend strongly on the hydropower system characteristics, such as reservoir capacity and the ratio between inflows and maximum turbined water discharge that can be conveyed to the plant. Specifically, we showed that, for the reservoir characterized by a larger storage capacity, the use of Autoarimax forecasts led to a revenue increase of up to 2.31% at monthly scale with respect to the case in which Benchmark forecasts are used in the optimizations. This revenue gain can reach up to a 31.06% increase if we consider the maximum daily deviations.

    How to cite: Avesani, D., Zanfei, A., Nicola, D. M., Galletti, A., Francesco, R., Maurizio, R., and Majone, B.: The role of innovative econometric models in short-term hydropower optimization, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7787, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7787, 2022.

    EGU22-8044 | Presentations | HS5.2

    Hydropower Portfolio Site and Design using a Simulation - Optimisation Model incorporating High Resolution Hydraulic Modelling in Data Scarce Regions 

    Simbi Hatchard, Rafael J. P. Schmitt, Francesca Pianosi, James Savage, and Paul Bates

    Development of hydropower in developing countries carries economic development rewards, particularly for storage hydropower which can be used to balance fluctuating supply of other renewables. Yet, dams and reservoirs carry significant environmental impacts, e.g., network fragmentation and flow alteration. While flood control has often been a motivator for reservoir construction, one environmental impact of storage hydropower on tropical rivers is the reduction of peak flows resulting in less hydraulic connectivity between floodplains and channels. In many tropical rivers, where most future dams are planned, this reduced lateral connectivity will create negative impacts on biodiversity, the biophysical functioning of floodplains, and human uses such as recession agriculture. Determining the optimal siting, design, and operation (SDO) of dam portfolios which maximises power generation and minimises this environmental impact, e.g., in terms of maintaining lateral connectivity, is a complex problem.

    Simulation - Optimisation models of hydropower portfolios have often included impact on annual flood peak as a proxy objective for floodplain impacts, but have rarely explicitly included inundated area as an objective. Furthermore, when this type of analysis is done, it is usually performed at a monthly timescale, which underestimates flood peaks and neglects in-channel and floodplain hydraulics.

    This work presents a multi-dam simulation - optimisation framework which uses a high-resolution hydrodynamic modelling framework (LISFLOOD-FP) to explicitly model the impact of SDO of many different dam portfolios on inundated floodplain extent, and to include this modelled extent as an optimisation objective. This incorporates channel and floodplain hydraulics at a fine time resolution, allowing a more realistic representation of the impact of hydropower development on biodiversity.

    The optimisation framework is applied to the data scarce Pungwe Basin in Mozambique / Zimbabwe, and identifies significant trade-offs from mainstem damming between power production and downstream hydraulic connectivity between rivers and floodplains. It identifies Pareto Optimal combinations of site and design (large dam, small dam, and run-of-the-river installations) for these two objectives. The inclusion of hydraulically modelled inundated area represents a step forward for increasing the ability of simulation - optimisation frameworks to model complex downstream impacts of hydropower development and operation related to changing discharge and channel hydraulics.

    How to cite: Hatchard, S., Schmitt, R. J. P., Pianosi, F., Savage, J., and Bates, P.: Hydropower Portfolio Site and Design using a Simulation - Optimisation Model incorporating High Resolution Hydraulic Modelling in Data Scarce Regions, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8044, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8044, 2022.

    EGU22-8110 | Presentations | HS5.2

    New environmental restrictions - aggregate effects on the Norwegian power system 

    Lennart Schönfelder, Atle Harby, Anders Arvesen, and Ingeborg Graabak

    Over 93% of Norway's power production stems from hydropower. The Nordic power market is constantly transforming, current main drivers include climate change effects on hydrology, an increase of variable renewable energy production, increasing interconnector capacity, and revision of concession terms for hydropower plants. A common plant layout is comprised of a reservoir and an underground penstock leading to a downstream located hydropower plant (HPP); in many cases several reservoirs and power plants are interconnected in complex systems. Consequently, the natural hydrology of many lakes and rivers are heavily impacted by hydropower operation.

    Hydropower operation is legally regulated by concessions that include regulations to limit negative environmental and societal impacts. More than 400 HPPs currently undergo a revision of terms of their concessions, which will likely impact hydropower operations and subsequently the Nordic power market. Updated or new environmental restrictions of three main types may have significant impact: 1) r 2) requirements for minimum discharge and restricted flow variation downstream of power plants and 3) filling requirements for hydropower reservoirs for the summer season. The joint effect likely has impacts on the power-balance and the hydropower system’s flexibility at multiple timescales from seconds to seasons.

    The objective of this cross-disciplinary study was to investigate the impacts of an ensemble of updated or new environmental restrictions on hydropower operations and on the Norwegian power market in the future. We developed a nationwide framework to quantify probable future environmental restrictions. . Additionally, a market model dataset for a 2030 scenario was created and input data adjusted, e.g. energy mix development in grid-coupled regions such as central Europe. Implemented in a state-of-the-art market optimization model, we modelled a range of restriction scenarios for the year 2030,

    We analyzed resulting future price scenarios. Preliminary results show an increase in average yearly production loss in the range of 5 TWh (or 3% of total hydropower production) due to new environmental restrictions. Modelled market response is an increase of average spot-price by about 0.8 €/MWh for all regions of Norway. Norwegian export of electricity to other countries is reduced. Another effect is that reservoir filling levels are typically higher than in the current situation, likely due to filling restrictions and model tendencies to avoid risk of violating reservoir filling restrictions, as well as increased inflow during winter.

    How to cite: Schönfelder, L., Harby, A., Arvesen, A., and Graabak, I.: New environmental restrictions - aggregate effects on the Norwegian power system, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8110, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8110, 2022.

    EGU22-8993 | Presentations | HS5.2

    An Approach to Representing Wind Uncertainties in the Long-Term Operation Planning of Systems with Hydropower Predominance 

    Maria Elvira Maceira, Albert Melo, José Francisco Pessanha, Cristiane Cruz, Victor Almeida, and Thatiana Justino

    Intermittent sources, especially wind, have experienced accelerated growth - in the last decade, wind power grew 13 times in Brazil, reaching 19 GW of installed capacity in 726 wind farms and became the second largest source in the electricity mix (10%). According to the Ten Year Expansion Plan, in 2029 the wind power installed capacity will increase more than 2.5 times, reaching 39,500 MW (17.3% of the country's electricity mix).

     In Brazil, expansion and long term operation planning studies have been carried out since 1998 with the support of the NEWAVE model, which has been used in the routine and official activities of sector entities: generation dispatch by the National System Operator; calculation of the spot prices by the Whole Sale Energy Market Entity; expansion planning by the Ministry of Mines and Energy and the Energy Research Company; parameters of public auctions for the purchase of electricity by the Electricity Regulatory Agency; as well as by utilities of the power industry to develop corporate strategies.

     Currently, in accordance with the guidelines of the Electricity Regulatory Agency, the representation of wind generation in the NEWAVE model is currently carried out in a simplified manner, based on the monthly average of the last five years of net generation of each wind farm, aggregated by sub-system and load level, for the entire planning horizon.

     The objective of this work is to describe an approach to be used by the Brazilian power industry to represent the uncertainties of monthly wind power production in the SDDP algorithm applied in the long-term operation planning model, keeping the large-scale stochastic problem still computationally viable, when applied to large interconnected systems, especially with hydroelectric predominance, as is the case of the Brazilian system.

     The approach consists of four main stages: (i) statistical clustering of wind regimes and definition of equivalent wind farms; (ii) evaluation of monthly transfer functions (MTFs) between wind speed and power production; (iii) an integrated model for the generation of monthly multivariate synthetic series of inflows and winds, considering the correlations between wind speeds, between inflows and between wind speeds and inflows; and (iv) representation of the monthly wind power obtained through MTFs in the SDDP algorithm.

     Initial results obtained from the application of the proposed approach to actual configurations of the Brazilian interconnected power system are presented and discussed.

    How to cite: Maceira, M. E., Melo, A., Pessanha, J. F., Cruz, C., Almeida, V., and Justino, T.: An Approach to Representing Wind Uncertainties in the Long-Term Operation Planning of Systems with Hydropower Predominance, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8993, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8993, 2022.

    EGU22-9249 | Presentations | HS5.2

    Run of River hydropower: in an uncertain world, is smaller financially smarter? 

    Veysel Yildiz, Solomon Brown, and Charles Rougé

    Run of River (RoR) hydropower plants are one of the most cost-effective energy technologies available for rural electrification and sustainable industrial expansion. These plants are characterised by a negligible storage capacity and by generation almost completely dependent on the timing and size of river flows. Their environmental footprint is minimal compared to that of reservoir-powered plants, and they are much easier to build.

    RoR plants are deployed in a world with a changing hydro-climate, and in an uncertain economic context (electricity prices, interest rates, cost overruns). Through seven plants proposed in a range of hydro-climatic regions of Turkey, this work investigates whether maximising NPV (net present value), the usual design criterion, leads to financial viability for a range of possible climatic and economic futures. To assess this financial robustness, it uses and extends HYPER, a state-of-the-art toolbox that computes technical performance, energy production, maintenance and operational costs of a design at a given site (hydraulic head, flow record).

    It combines HYPER with many-objective robust decision making (MORDM) to find alternatives to NPV design and assess their robustness to changing climatic and financial conditions. Our application of MORDM uses the following steps: (1) an explicit three-objective formulation is introduced to find design parameters that balance cost, revenue, and dry year (first percentile) power generation objectives, (2) coupling of a multi-objective evolutionary algorithm with HYPER to solve the problem using 1,000 years of synthetic streamflow data obtained with the Hirsch-Nowak synthetic streamflow generator, (3) sampling of deeply uncertain factors to analyse robustness to uncertain climatic and financial futures, (4) quantification of robustness based on the probability to make the plant financially viable within 10 and 20 years in each future.

    Preliminary results suggest that applying MORDM approach to RoR hydropower plant design provides insights into the trade-offs between installation cost and hydropower production, while supporting design with a range of viable alternatives to help them determine which design is most robust and reliable for given site conditions and river stream characteristics. When contrasting robustness of a design with its NPV, designs with the highest NPVs do not necessarily perform well in terms of dry period revenue unless a small turbine is installed in triple turbine configuration. They also show less robustness to both climate change (and associated drying) and to evolving financial conditions than smaller design alternatives with less installed capacity. These better balance average annual revenue with dry period revenue. Preliminary results also suggest that maximising the benefit cost ratio (BCR) yields more robust and financially viable solutions than maximising NPV, as it leads to less costly designs that generate slightly less revenue on average but tend to better exploit low flows.

    How to cite: Yildiz, V., Brown, S., and Rougé, C.: Run of River hydropower: in an uncertain world, is smaller financially smarter?, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9249, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9249, 2022.

    EGU22-10162 | Presentations | HS5.2

    Potential for virtual energy storage in a wind-PV-hydropower system in Yalong River Basin, China. 

    Jing Hu, Anders Wörman, Yu Li, Bingyao Zhang, Wei Ding, and Huicheng Zhou

    Wind and hydropower are generally more prevalent in stormy weather conditions when solar radiation is relatively lower, which is why these renewables show complimentary characteristics over time. Similarly, weather patterns show spatial covariance. This means that spatio-temporal coordination of renewable energy production can reduce significantly the variance in the system power, hence, contribute to a virtual energy storage similar as has previously been done by matching the demand response to power availability. The 130,000 km2 Yalong River Basin in southwest China is used as an example in this study and for this basin we found typical climate-controlled periods in the renewable energy variations on periods of half a year, one year and 11-years. Based on historical hydro-climatic records, results for a planned combined wind-PV-hydropower system show that the maximum virtual energy storage has similar trends under different periods, i.e. it decreases with coordination distance and stabilizes on a coordination range of between 200 – 400 km. The maximum virtual energy storage gain was found to be 737 MWh . The project developed an existing spectral method for the analysis of the variance of the potential power and virtual energy storage in combined wind-PV-hydropower systems under different climate periods. Two different scenarios were analyzed, one in which all power stations were matched regardless of transmission constraints and one in which coordination of PV and wind power is fully centralized around single hydropower stations. The virtual energy storage gain obtained at decadal long periods, such as the 11-year cycle, can also be seen as an alternative to reserve power capacity that is activated only to avoid energy droughts. This study focused on the theoretical maximum potential for virtual energy storage, but the feasibility of this potential is limited by the uncertainty associated with production optimization and the meteorologic forecasts of future energy availability.

     
     
     
     
     

    How to cite: Hu, J., Wörman, A., Li, Y., Zhang, B., Ding, W., and Zhou, H.: Potential for virtual energy storage in a wind-PV-hydropower system in Yalong River Basin, China., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10162, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10162, 2022.

    EGU22-10328 | Presentations | HS5.2

    Territorial analysis for energy supply of western Turin area from alternative renewable sources: impact and potential 

    Arianna Paschetto, Chiara Caselle, Claudia Leso, Fabrizio Manfroni, and Sabrina Maria Rita Bonetto

    It is now generally assumed that a radical reversal in economy is needed in order to cope with the effects of climate changes and to improve the resilience of populations in relation to these effects.

    In fact, European policies for climate change and economic recovery due to Covid-19 (Guidance to Member States, Recovery and Resilience Plans, 8th Environmental Action Program) are supposed to work in synergy to promote green and efficient energies, shifting the cost/benefit ratio in favor of renewable natural resources. As part of these policies, Italy is increasing the number of mini hydroelectric plants (max. power of 1000 kW), which are considered advantageous both in economic and environmental terms without being in contrast with the surrounding environment.

    The aim of this study is the evaluation of potential production of hydroelectric energy, by means of mini hydroelectric, in the western area of ​​Turin, considering lowland areas (such as the Municipalities of Collegno, Druento and Alpignano) and high valley areas such as the Municipality of Coazze and upper Sangone Valley. In these investigated area, the development of mini hydroelectric could possibly result in partial or entire energy self-sufficiency.

    In order to comply with environmental policies, a feasibility study will be conducted, based on geological, hydrogeological, morphological, ecological and climatic components.

    The study will also be congruent with European and national guidelines regarding the Environmental Impact Assessment, so as to evaluate any possible plant locations in terms of environmental impact.

    The geological and geomorphological data collected will also be employed to evaluate the possibility of reuse of the materials which could possibly accumulate in the reservoirs, in accordance with the policies of the Green Communities.

    How to cite: Paschetto, A., Caselle, C., Leso, C., Manfroni, F., and Bonetto, S. M. R.: Territorial analysis for energy supply of western Turin area from alternative renewable sources: impact and potential, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10328, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10328, 2022.

    As an important renewable energy source, hydropower can meet China's needs for sustainable decarbonization. But it is very sensitive to climate change, and the occurrence of hydrological droughts will have a severe impact on hydropower. The significant decline in hydropower supply in dry years or seasons increases the demand for other power resources, especially fossil fuel, which will further increase greenhouse gas emissions. In the future, seasonal droughts are expected to change in the context of global warming, and their impact on hydropower generation needs to be studied, especially over the Yangtze River basin that has the largest hydropower resources and potential in China. In this study, the characteristics of seasonal hydrological drought events under historical and future climate conditions are analyzed in the Yangtze River Basin, and the PCR-GLOBWB hydrological model is further used to simulate the changes of water resources and hydropower generation under drought conditions. This study is beneficial to bring extreme events into the consideration of hydropower development and operation planning in China, and provides scientific basis for ensuring the safety of hydropower system.

    How to cite: Liu, X. and Yuan, X.: Impacts of future changes in seasonal hydrological drought on hydropower potential in the Yangtze River Basin, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10963, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10963, 2022.

    EGU22-12440 | Presentations | HS5.2

    The value of incorporating technological uncertainty in adaptive infrastructure planning – a conceptual example in hydropower investment 

    Kevis Pachos, Jose M. Gonzalez, Tohid Erfani, Mohammed Basheer, Eduardo Martínez-Ceseña, Mathaios Panteli, and Julien J. Harou

    In response to the increasing environmental concerns, there has been significant research and development of power generation technologies based on renewable energy sources (RES) such as solar, and hydrogen. On the one hand, the technologies are becoming more attractive by offering higher efficiencies and lifetimes, and lower costs. On the other hand, it has become challenging to cost-effectively plan and deploy RES technologies as their characteristics have become significantly more uncertain. This can have strong impacts on other established renewable generation technologies, such as hydropower, which might become less or more attractive depending on technological change. Furthermore, in the context of interlinked water-energy systems, RES impacts on hydropower can have cascading effects on water use. Accordingly, decision makers require improved planning strategies to “adapt” to technological change when making long-term planning and investment decisions. 

    This work explores how considering RES, namely solar and hydrogen, alongside their technological uncertainties related to installation costs and lifetimes, would impact hydropower investments in an adaptive plan. Based on a conceptual case study of a water-energy system, we demonstrate that hydropower investments could be delayed and/or reduced because of the possibility of efficiency improvements related to renewable energy technologies. Furthermore, we quantify the forgone financial value from not using adaptive approaches to design and plan infrastructure projects under technological uncertainty.

    How to cite: Pachos, K., Gonzalez, J. M., Erfani, T., Basheer, M., Martínez-Ceseña, E., Panteli, M., and Harou, J. J.: The value of incorporating technological uncertainty in adaptive infrastructure planning – a conceptual example in hydropower investment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12440, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12440, 2022.

    EGU22-13005 | Presentations | HS5.2

    On the needs to evaluate power grid models’ hydropower scheduling with a river operations model 

    Nathalie Voisin, Tim Magee, Sean Turner, Mitch Clement, Konstantinos Oikonomou, and Edith Zagona

    Production Cost Models (PCMs) simulate the economic dispatch of generators across a large power grid and are used widely by planners to study the reliability of electricity supply. As energy systems transition away from the thermoelectric technologies that have traditionally balanced electricity supply and demand, hydropower and its representation in PCMs is of increasing importance for storage and ramping capabilities. A limitation of PCMs applied to continental power grids with diverse generation portfolios is that hydropower generation is simulated without full consideration of complex river dynamics, leading to possible misrepresentation of grid flexibility and performance.

    Using a detailed hydropower model, we evaluate whether the hourly hydropower schedule from a PCM with simplified monthly parameterization can be attained when accounting for realistic river dynamics, such as spill requirements and general water movement through a cascading reservoir system. We perform this hydropower generation test for the “Big 10” hydropower system on the Columbia River (part of the Western Interconnect of the United States), revealing 9% overestimation of available hydropower generation in a PCM solution in an average hydrologic year.

    We reflect on the sources of differences with implications onto long term planning practices expected to address uncertainties associated with energy transitions, climate change, environmental regulation and competing water uses.

    How to cite: Voisin, N., Magee, T., Turner, S., Clement, M., Oikonomou, K., and Zagona, E.: On the needs to evaluate power grid models’ hydropower scheduling with a river operations model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13005, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13005, 2022.

    EGU22-18 | Presentations | HS5.3

    Tools to develop environmental flow guidelines in an uncertain future hydrological context 

    André St-Hilaire, Laureline Berthot, Habiba Ferchichi, and Daniel Caissie

    Environmental flows (eflows) refer to the amount of water required to sustain aquatic ecosystems. In its formal definition, three flow characteristics are listed that need to be minimally maintained: quantity, timing and quality. Ssome of the current tools used for eflow determination in the context of an evolving climate are based on hydrological metrics. Some of the potential caveats associated with their usage are caused by the fact that flow time series are increasingly non-stationarity. Timing of low flow events will also likely change within a season, but will also likely shift in seasonality in some regions. Flow quality is a multi-faceted concept. It is proposed that a first simple step to partly incorporate flow quality in future analyses is to include water temperature as a covariate.  An example of this combination of flow and temperature is provided for Eastern Canada.

    How to cite: St-Hilaire, A., Berthot, L., Ferchichi, H., and Caissie, D.: Tools to develop environmental flow guidelines in an uncertain future hydrological context, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-18, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-18, 2022.

    EGU22-965 | Presentations | HS5.3

    Unconventional Water Resources: A golden opportunity to mitigate the mismatch between water supply and water demand 

    Zahra Karimidastenaei, Tamara Avellán, Mojtaba Sadegh, Bjørn Kløve, and Ali Torabi Haghighi

    Water scarcity is a serious socio-environmental challenge for sustainable development which is recognized as a potential cause of social conflict within and between countries. It is expected to intensify due to increasing water demands from increasing populations, rapid urbanization, industrialization, and climate changes. With predictions of dire global water scarcity, attention is turning to Unconventional Water Resources (UWRs) which are considered as supplementary water resources that need specialized processes to be used as water supply. The literature encompasses a vast number of studies on various UWRs and their usefulness in certain environmental and/or socio-economic contexts. Considering the increasing importance of UWRs in the global push for water security, the current study intends to offer a nuanced understanding of the existing research on UWRs by summarizing the key concepts in the literature. The number of articles published on UWRs have increased significantly over time and most publications were authored from researchers based in the USA or China, India, Iran, and Spain. Here, twelve general types of UWRs including fog, dew, rainwater harvesting, and cloud seeding as Atmospheric Unconventional Water (AUW); artificial recharge, fossil water as Unconventional Ground Water (UGW); iceberg water and virtual water as Transferred Unconventional Water (TUW), and wastewater, desalinated water, and agricultural drainage water as Processed Unconventional Water (PUW), were used to assess their global distribution, showing that climatic conditions are the main driver for the application of certain UWRs. Overall, the literature review demonstrated that, even though UWRs provide promising possibilities for overcoming water scarcity, current knowledge is patchy and points towards UWRs being, for the most part, limited in scope and applicability due to geographic, climatic, economic, and political constraints. Future studies focusing on improved quantitative documentation and demonstration of the physical and socio-economic potential of various UWRs could help in strengthening the case for some, if not all, UWRs as avenues for the sustainable provision of water.

    Keywords: Water scarcity; UWRs; distribution maps; literature review

    How to cite: Karimidastenaei, Z., Avellán, T., Sadegh, M., Kløve, B., and Torabi Haghighi, A.: Unconventional Water Resources: A golden opportunity to mitigate the mismatch between water supply and water demand, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-965, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-965, 2022.

    EGU22-1735 | Presentations | HS5.3

    Enhancing anticipatory actions for disaster preparedness considering physical and social factors 

    Paul Block, Jonathan Lala, and Juan Bazo

    Climate and weather-related disasters are increasingly expensive and deadly. Hydrologic catastrophes are especially devastating, accounting for over half of all disasters and global disaster victims. Novel approaches are desperately needed for vulnerable communities subject to hydrologic and water-related crises. Post-disaster assistance is a crucial component of disaster relief, however the potential for reducing humanitarian impacts through anticipatory, pre-disaster planning and actions cannot be overstated.  Short-term early warning systems are common, yet hydrologic forecasts at monthly or seasonal scales are relatively underused to guide preparatory actions, despite their potential value. Empirical evidence suggests that pre-disaster actions can reduce loss of life and property and result in cost savings for relief and governmental organizations. Such interventions often flow through water management systems, highlighting the central role of water resources decision-making in hazard resilience.

    Various humanitarian relief agencies have recently developed operational early action protocols, conditioned on forecasts and risk analysis, outlining trigger criteria and identifying early actions. Concurrently, an extensive number of subseasonal-to-seasonal climate forecast products are now available to derive hydrologic forecasts. Thus there exists significant potential to tailor subseasonal-to-seasonal hydrologic forecast products to appropriately trigger a suite of preparedness actions and decisions across multiple lead times.  Various frameworks exist to understand pareto trade-offs in actions and financing, including community-based constraints and preferences.  These approaches respond to the strong demand for large-scale, multi-sectoral hydrologic forecast and management tools to enable early preparedness for anticipated drought and flood extremes.

    How to cite: Block, P., Lala, J., and Bazo, J.: Enhancing anticipatory actions for disaster preparedness considering physical and social factors, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1735, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1735, 2022.

    EGU22-3405 | Presentations | HS5.3

    Identifying the geographic distribution of seawater desalination plants globally using species distribution models 

    Zhipin Ai, Fumiko Ishihama, and Naota Hanasaki

    Desalination water is a vital source of freshwater for regions with coastal water scarcity. Identifying the geographic distribution of global seawater desalination plants enables a spatially detailed water sources assessment. In this study, which is the first of its kind, we investigated the potential application of species distribution models (SDMs), which are widely used in ecology, to predict the global spatial distribution of seawater desalination plants. Two regression SDMs, a generalized linear model (GLM) and a generalized additive model (GAM), along with two machine learning SDMs, a random forest (RF) model and a generalized boosted regression model (GBM), were trained and tested using the cross-validation method at 0.5 degrees. For each SDM, we considered four explanatory variables: aridity, distance to seashore, gross domestic product (GDP) per capita, and the sum of annual domestic and industrial water withdrawal. Our results showed that the four SDMs have good accuracy according to three different evaluation metrics. An ensemble presence map was then created from the four individual SDM predictions. Finally, we mapped the future distribution of seawater desalination plants. Due to the increases in aridity, GDP per capita, and domestic and industrial water withdrawal, the total number of presence grid cells is predicted to increase from 2014 figures by 37%, 47%, 35%, and 30% in 2030, 2050, 2070, and 2090, respectively. Using future predictions such as these, our study can contribute to integrated global water resources assessments. Our findings also provide insight into how SDMs can be used for predicting the geographic locations of water management facilities.

    How to cite: Ai, Z., Ishihama, F., and Hanasaki, N.: Identifying the geographic distribution of seawater desalination plants globally using species distribution models, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3405, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3405, 2022.

    EGU22-4242 | Presentations | HS5.3

    Water Governing Systems: addressing conflicts between hydrological and institutional scales 

    Peyman Arjomandi A., Seyedalireza Seyedi, and Nadejda Komendantova

    The human-generated systems typically meet biophysical ones within different geographical terrains. The space where those systems face each other is framed at the human-crafted and natural scales. Conventionally such sphere is a contestation field where various levels of contributing scales confront to embed a functional system. The water governing systems are as of the frequently debated of such systems. They resemble controversial evidence in the course of conflicts between hydrological and administrative/institutional scales. Indeed, due to the dominancy of human-determined objectives to the environmental requirements, the water governing systems have not considered reasonably the requisite of natural cycles in many areas. This issue produces externalities and mismatches between human-formulated and hydrological systems. To enhance the governance, there is a need to detect problems which arise from unfit of those systems in associated levels. Therefore, an inferential methodology which is able to capture and project the water (demand/supply) governing system state is being developed. The methodology encompasses incorporation of a system cost formulation approach. Besides, the system status in relation to microscopic configurations of its components is appraised through the method. This inscribed that a unique macroscopic state driven by a certain configuration is reflectable as a cost system bears in respect to its structure. Such cost is a theoretical estimate to measure the impact of a confiscated structure on the effectiveness of governing system. Correspondingly, the induced inefficiencies by the misfit between human-designed and biophysical systems are diagnosable through the comparison of system costs associated to pertinent structures/configurations.

    How to cite: Arjomandi A., P., Seyedi, S., and Komendantova, N.: Water Governing Systems: addressing conflicts between hydrological and institutional scales, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4242, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4242, 2022.

    Water scarcity is one of the major challenges of the century. Climate change and population growth are exacerbating this problem, especially in river basins with arid climates such as the Middle East or North Africa, calling for the design of integrated water management strategies to meet competing water demands in interconnected Water-Energy-Food systems. In this work, we explore the potential for integrating innovative technological solutions, namely desalination and aquaponics, into conventional water management measures to mitigate existing tradeoffs. Our approach is demonstrated on the Nile River basin, a paradigmatic example of transboundary river basins where the overexploited traditional water sources cannot fully satisfy the increasing water demands, thus requiring innovative solutions to address this challenge. Here, we first investigate the optimal operation of the major water infrastructures in the basin to explore the tradeoffs between hydropower generation and irrigation supply across Ethiopia, Sudan, and Egypt. Then, we analyse the role of desalination and aquaponics in reducing the Egyptian water demand in the Nile delta and mitigating the existing tradeoffs. Desalination is widely used in many of the Middle East’s countries and offers the possibility to unlock the potential contribution of sea water in meeting the water demand of the coastal region. Aquaponics is a soilless agricultural technique characterized by lower levels of water consumption than traditional techniques. For both desalination and aquaponics, we run an exploratory analysis to understand the key technological parameters influencing the successful uptake of these solutions. Our results aim to demonstrate the effectiveness of integrated management solutions in arid river basins and explore the potential uptake of new technologies for reducing agricultural water demands. These measures contribute in increasing the flexibility of water management strategies in arid areas when coping with water scarcity while improving water quality conditions.

    How to cite: Piuri, V., Yang, G., and Giuliani, M.: Exploring the potential of desalination and aquaponics in the integrated management of arid river basins: the case of the Nile River basin, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4624, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4624, 2022.

    Dams contribute to water security, energy supply, and flood protection but also fragment habitats of freshwater fishes, limiting their dispersal ability and impairing fish movements to feeding and spawning grounds. This endangers freshwater biodiversity and the livelihoods and food security of people depending on freshwater fish.  Globally, only 37% of rivers longer than 1,000 km remain free-flowing. Habitat fragmentation levels for fish are highest in North America, Europe, India, and China. However, the expansion in hydropower capacity driven by national plans and energy transition scenarios will increase habitat fragmentation by 20-40 percentage points in fish diversity hotspots like the Amazon, Congo, and Mekong basins, with potentially detrimental consequences for fishes. Therefore, it is paramount to understand opportunities to reconcile needs for expanding renewable hydropower while preserving habitat for fish and associated benefits for humans. Using the Mekong as a case study, we prototype a tool to optimize tradeoffs between habitat fragmentation and energy benefits for basin-level dams’ portfolios based on global data sets. Such an approach can close an important gap in policy and trade-off analyses for hydropower which, because of lacking data, do not commonly include biotic impacts of dams as a metric. Based on a genetic algorithm, the approach allows identifying which dams to develop, remove, or upgrade with fish passages in order to reach the greatest benefits for future renewable energy systems with the least impact on fish populations.

    How to cite: Barbarossa, V. and Schmitt, R.: Accounting for fish habitat fragmentation in global strategic assessments of future hydropower dam portfolios, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5817, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5817, 2022.

    EGU22-6023 | Presentations | HS5.3

    Irrigation storage is a blind spot for analyzing and mitigating externalities of future water infrastructure 

    Rafael J. P. Schmitt, Lorenzo Rosa, and Gretchen Daily

    Dams and reservoirs are crucial components for the water-energy-food (WEF) nexus but have major impacts on rivers and people. Future dams would compound impacts of existing dams and threaten so far undammed river systems. Recent research has highlighted threats from future hydropower dams and opportunities to reduce impacts through better infrastructure planning and proliferation of other renewable energy. Yet, while irrigation storage was a major driver for dam development in the past, the role of water storage in future food systems and the associated benefits and impacts has not been part of debates around future dams.

    Here, we provide a global analysis that fuses global hydrologic modeling and infrastructure assessments to (1) quantify future demands for irrigation storage, (2) its role for food security, and (3) the contribution of existing and identified potential reservoirs to future irrigation. For that, we firstly analyze potentials for future sustainable (i.e., on existing croplands and without depleting environmental flows) irrigation and determine how much storage is needed to match water availability and crop water demand on a river basin level. Secondly, we quantify how much food could be grown with that water. Lastly, we perform a Monte-Carlo Analysis for all current and potential dams to robustly estimate possible water allocations from current and future dams to irrigation, and thus the role of this water infrastructure for global food security.

    We find that future irrigated agriculture will require 460 km3/yr of water storage, 265 km3/yr on land that is already irrigated and 195 km3/yr on land that is currently rainfed. Much of that additional storage will be required in South Asia and West Africa. This storage-fed irrigation could grow enough food for 1.15 billion people. Yet even all current and future dams could only meet around 60 % of that potential.

    Our results provide spatially explicit global information on (1) irrigation storage as important externality and cost factor for future food systems, (2) challenges for the WEF nexus in meeting concurrent demands for irrigation and hydropower, (3) the need to include irrigation in strategic impact/benefit assessments for future dams, and (4) urge to evaluate alternatives to large dams for future agricultural water storage.

    How to cite: Schmitt, R. J. P., Rosa, L., and Daily, G.: Irrigation storage is a blind spot for analyzing and mitigating externalities of future water infrastructure, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6023, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6023, 2022.

    EGU22-6680 | Presentations | HS5.3

    Studying spatial agreement of catchment response to climate and landuse change under uncertainty for prioritizing investment into hydropower catchments 

    Zhaowei Ding, Hector Angarita, Christian Montesino Cárceres, Waldo Lavado-Casimiro, Cesar David Barreto Escobedo, Leo Guerrero, Hua Zheng, and Rafael Schmitt

    Joint climate and land cover change can significantly alter catchment hydrologic response, e.g., in terms of runoff and sediment delivery, and thus key determinants for downstream hydropower outcomes. While many studies highlight climate risk for hydropower operation, it is less clear how climate and landuse change together will impact hydropower outcomes, if managing landuse can reduce those impacts, and how to prioritize effective investments in the face of uncertainty about the future climatic drivers.

    In this study, we use Chaglla Dam, Peru’s third largest electricity generator, to develop an ensemble approach to identify parts of Chaglla’s contributing area with consistent changes in runoff and sediment under climate change. Those areas could then be targeted for maintaining or restoring natural land cover to increase baseflow and decrease sediment. We use SWAT to model catchment response for a large ensemble of climate trajectories based on latest CMIP 6 data, downscaled using multiple state-of-the-art algorithms and high-resolution regional weather observations (Figure 1 A and B). Based on the results, we identify parts of the catchment with greatest changes in water yield.  We find that 35 % of the watershed area shows consistent trends in water yield and sediment across all climate scenarios.

    Climate risks will increase in the near and midterm future with increases the length of low-flow periods (up to 40 %) and increases in sediment (up to 17 %). Compared to that, additional changes in water and sediment because of projected land use change are relatively minor (+ 0.3 % in low-flow length and + 0.7 % in sediment).

    Yet, our study introduces a spatially-explicit framework for analyzing large ensembles of climate and landuse projections to identify where future change will translate in most change in hydrologic parameters related to hydropower. Results enable to study if investing in catchment conservation in those areas will significantly improve hydropower outcomes and will thus help to develop management plans for hydropower catchment that are robust under future change.

    How to cite: Ding, Z., Angarita, H., Montesino Cárceres, C., Lavado-Casimiro, W., David Barreto Escobedo, C., Guerrero, L., Zheng, H., and Schmitt, R.: Studying spatial agreement of catchment response to climate and landuse change under uncertainty for prioritizing investment into hydropower catchments, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6680, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6680, 2022.

    EGU22-8944 | Presentations | HS5.3

    Historical analysis of large reservoir storage resilience and vulnerabilities in CONUS 

    Jen Steyaert and Laura Condon

    There are over 2,000 large reservoirs with a storage capacity greater than 1 million cubic meters (MCM) in the contiguous United States (CONUS). While many of these structures are documented in static datasets that include spatial locations and general characteristics (such as maximum storage capacity), there has previously been no comprehensive dataset of historical reservoir operations. To remedy this gap, we have assembled ResOpsUS, the first national dataset of historical reservoir operations. ResOpsUS contains historical time-series of storage, inflow, outflow, elevation, and evaporation data for 679 large reservoirs in CONUS. Here we use the unique ResOpsUS dataset to analyze storage trends over the last 40 years, identify potential causes of regional differences in reservoir variance and evaluate the relationship between meteorological drought and reservoir storage. Our preliminary analysis demonstrates that reservoir storage capacity in CONUS hit a limit in the early 1980s and no longer increased. Additionally, reservoir storage has decreased over the past 20 years with the magnitude of decrease greater in more arid regions.  Finally, correlations between precipitation and reservoir storage depict more direct relationships in wetter climates compared to drier climates where reservoirs are a necessary water supply during dry periods and thus storage in drier years may be higher than in wetter years.

    How to cite: Steyaert, J. and Condon, L.: Historical analysis of large reservoir storage resilience and vulnerabilities in CONUS, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8944, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8944, 2022.

    EGU22-9862 | Presentations | HS5.3

    Assessing the impact of climate and water demand change on hydrology and water resources in the Turia river basin, Spain 

    Ivan Lagos-Castro, Manuel Pulido-Velazquez, Hector Macian-Sorribes, and Maria Pedro-Monzonis

    Adapting water systems to climate is one of the most significant challenges. Nowadays, the research focus has been shifted from understanding climate change phenomena to studying its impacts on water resource systems in detail. Facing this challenge requires rigorous methodologies that increase the confidence in the climate models outputs, consider the physical complexity of our systems, and consider other factors such as population growth or the use of technologies enabling water saving.

    This study presents a robust methodology to estimate climate change impacts on a complex water resources system, including changes in water consumption. It relies on a modelling chain involving climate, hydrological, and water resource system models. Future hydrological scenarios are generated by forcing a conceptual lumped hydrological model by bias-adjusted climate change CMIP5 scenarios. A joint meteorological-hydrological innovative process is used to assess and rank each scenario according to its performance in reproducing the climate and streamflow historical patterns and the streamflow change signal between two periods in a basin. Hydrological projections are used to feed a water resource system model, which includes the main physical and management complexities. By using this model, two complementary impact characterizations were defined: 1) assessing the impacts on the system only as a result of climate change; and 2) incorporating complexities inherent to the basin on top of climate change scenarios, such as the increase in water demand associated with population growth and the improvement in water use efficiencies after adopting better technologies.

    This methodology is applied to the Turia River Basin (eastern Spain), a highly regulated system characterized by a strong variation in seasonal streamflows, intensive water use in urban and agriculture, and recurrent droughts. The system demands are supplied by surface and groundwater resources, water transfers from the neighboring Jucar river basin, and reclaimed wastewater reuse. The 18 available climate change trajectories from EURO-CORDEX for RCPs 4.5 and 8.5 were evaluated, and 12 were selected due to their satisfactory meteorological and hydrological performance. A water resources system model was built in the AQUATOOL Decision Support System (DSS) shell. We found that the entire water resources system could suffer significant adverse impacts even in the short term. Moreover, the projections show decreases in the water storage in reservoirs, increases in pumped water from aquifers, and increments in deficits to urban and agricultural demands. However, the methodology results also concluded that improvements in irrigation efficiencies in the Turia basin are an efficient measure to face the impacts of climate change.

     

    Acknowledgements:

    This study has been supported by the ADAPTAMED project (RTI2018-101483-B-I00), funded by the Ministerio de Economía y Competitividad (MINECO) of Spain including EU FEDER funds; the SÀPIDES project (INNEST/2021/276) funded by the Agència Valenciana de la Innovación (AVI), from the Generalitat Valenciana; and the Subvencions del Programa per a la promoció de la investigación científica, el desenvolupament tecnològic i la innovació a la Comunitat Valenciana (PROMETEO) under the WATER4CAST project.

    How to cite: Lagos-Castro, I., Pulido-Velazquez, M., Macian-Sorribes, H., and Pedro-Monzonis, M.: Assessing the impact of climate and water demand change on hydrology and water resources in the Turia river basin, Spain, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9862, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9862, 2022.

    Severe droughts are challenging the development of society and economy worldwide. Whilst hedging rules for reservoir operations contribute to reduce the risk of unacceptably severe water shortage during droughts, they could be of trivial value for some reservoir water supply systems considering water supply reliability, vulnerability and resilience. There is still no consensus on the quantitative characteristics of water system hedging rules should be applied to. In this work, reservoir water level named as drought limited water level(DLWL) is employed to trigger practical zone-based water supply rule firstly. Then the impact of DLWL on the water supply performance is analyzed with a range of hypothetical reservoir water supply systems. Based on it, characteristics of reservoirs which DLWL should not be applied to is identified using scenario discovery. For these reservoirs, main influencing factors are revealed and effective drought management measures to ensure reliable water supply are proposed accordingly. For the rest reservoirs that DLWL should be applied to, a multi-objective DLWL optimization method is proposed and applied to Qing Reservoir, a typical water supply reservoir in Northern China. The influence of changing environment on DLWL is studied with a comprehensive sample of deeply uncertain factors. Results show that hedging policy triggered by DLWL has a remarkable advantage over the standard operation rules to mitigate effect of drought. To adapt to increasing water supply pressure featured with increasing demand, decreasing streamflow volume and more variable streamflow, DLWLs during high water demand period ought to be raised and DLWLs during dry season ought to be reduced. Insights from this work have general merit for taking the most effective measures to relieve water shortage and regulate existing hedging rules to adapt to changing environment.

    How to cite: Luo, C., Ding, W., Xu, B., and Zhang, C.: Characteristics of reservoirs to mitigate drought effects with a hedging rule triggered by drought limited water level, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10009, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10009, 2022.

    EGU22-10085 | Presentations | HS5.3

    Robust River Basin planning under extreme climate events and socio-economic changes: the Red River Basin in China-Vietnam 

    Anna Costa, Matteo Giuliani, Scott Sinclair, Nadav Peleg, Roderick van der Linden, Van Anh Truong, Andreas H. Fink, Andrea Castelletti, and Paolo Burlando

    Climate and socio-economic changes bring multiple challenges to river basin development worldwide. The large uncertainty characterizing future conditions requires robust and adaptive planning and management solutions capable of handling uncertain future changes. This is particularly true in monsoonal Southeast Asian catchments, where large multipurpose reservoir systems play a crucial role in flood protection and providing water, energy, and food to a rapidly changing society. In such river basins, high intra-annual and inter-annual hydroclimatic variability, as well as increasing frequency of extreme events, further challenge the management of multi-sector water demands across multiple time scales.

    In this context, we develop a robust decision-analytic framework for supporting the strategic planning of river basins in monsoonal areas with respect to future changes in water availability and demands. The framework integrates future climate scenarios, including a catalogue of extreme climate events, future water demand scenarios, a high-resolution infrastructure-accounting hydrological model, Topkapi-ETH, and a strategic, operational model to design multiobjective optimal water management policies. We first build climate change driven projections of water availability; second, we apply the optimization engine to select a subset of operation policies optimized based on key selected indicators; and third, we use the spatially distributed hydrological model to evaluate the impact of the chosen policies on a broader set of indicators capturing the spatially distributed impact of dam operations.

    We focus here on the Red River Basin, a large transboundary river basin in China and Vietnam. In the basin, conflicts among different water uses, such as flood control, hydropower production, agriculture and aquaculture, are expected to increase under the combined pressure of increasing water and energy demands and climate change. A specific focus is given to extreme rainfall events, expected to increase their frequency and magnitude. The framework proposed will allow us to assess the vulnerability of the basin under future scenarios as well as the sustainability and robustness of future river basin development plans in the context of the water-energy-food-environment nexus.

    How to cite: Costa, A., Giuliani, M., Sinclair, S., Peleg, N., van der Linden, R., Truong, V. A., Fink, A. H., Castelletti, A., and Burlando, P.: Robust River Basin planning under extreme climate events and socio-economic changes: the Red River Basin in China-Vietnam, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10085, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10085, 2022.

    EGU22-10126 | Presentations | HS5.3

    Perturbing the flow duration curve to explore future flow conditions without a hydrological model 

    Charles Rougé, Veysel Yildiz, and Solomon Brown

    Assessing the robustness of a water resource system to climate change involves exploring a range of streamflow conditions. For this, rainfall-runoff models are routinely to produce future streamflow, using as inputs either climate model projections or modified historical hydro-climatic conditions. However, these models have generally been calibrated and validated under historical conditions, and there is no guarantee that calibrated parameters would still be valid in a different climate. Indeed, recent literature suggests that rainfall-runoff models’ predictive skill decreases with changed climatic conditions especially when predicting drier climates. What is more, rainfall-runoff models require time, expertise and input data to calibrate and validate against the historical streamflow record.

    With this abstract, we propose an alternative approach based on a near-universal parameterisation of flow duration curves (FDCs), and perturbation of these parameters to simulate a range of futures. Our method represents FDCs with a three-parameter function called the Kosugi model, which has been shown to provide an excellent approximation to FDCs under a wide range of climates. We directly relate these three parameters with three streamflow statistics that are of interest to water resource management: median, coefficient of variation, and first percentile. These values represent central tendency, variability, and low flow characteristics respectively. As a result, a broad range of changes in streamflow can be related to modified parameters, and our method goes through the following steps: (1) Kosugi model parameters are calibrated with a historical FDC, (2) a set of scenarios with modified flow statistics are determined, (3) a new set of coefficients of the Kosugi model are derived for each future scenario, (4) future scenarios are created by using these coefficients.

    We apply this method to represent possible climate change impacts on the hydrology of seven headwater basins from different geographical and climatic conditions in Turkey. Preliminary results show that this method provides a dramatically large range of inflows, with increased frequency of high flows and low flows to better represent hydrological variability and extremes. This then supports robustness analyses for rivers for which no detailed hydrological model is available: here, on the financial viability of run-of-river hydropower design in a changing climate. The method supports time series with a large number of no-flow days.

    How to cite: Rougé, C., Yildiz, V., and Brown, S.: Perturbing the flow duration curve to explore future flow conditions without a hydrological model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10126, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10126, 2022.

    EGU22-11159 | Presentations | HS5.3

    Operationalizing Justice in Integrated Water Resources Modeling and Management 

    Seleshi Yalew, Jan Kwakkel, Jazmin Zatarain Salazar, and Neelke Doorn

    Justice in the allocation and distribution of water is one of the most recent topics in the water resources management literature. This topic, i.e., justice/equity/fairness, is especially noteworthy in integrated water resources management where competing needs, sectors, and societal segments are involved in the utilization of water. Although the concept of justice, such as procedural justice, in general and in water management in particular is not as new, the concept of distributive justice and tools and technics for the allocation and distribution of water resources is very recent. As a result, particularly tools and techniques for the operationalization of such concepts are still lacking.

    In this study, we operationalized theoretical justice theories in terms of moral principles into functions and parameters for use with traditional water resources optimization models and frameworks. These moral principles include Utilitarianism (which evaluates measures according to their effect on welfare), Sufficientarianism (which makes sure that each individual gets a sufficient threshold),  Prioritarianism (which guarantees extra weight to worse-off individuals), and envy-freeness (which requires that each individual prefers his share to the share of others).

    The result of the study as applied in the case study of the Susquehanna basin, USA, displays undertanding and outlooks of various perspectives of fairness on integrated water resources management among competing stakeholders and needs. Such perspectives are presented together with traditional resource efficiency and/or conservation oriented optimization techniques and methods to highlight synergy and trade-offs in integrated water resources management. We think that the methods and approaches presented here will advance the scientific discussion on the operationalization of justice/equity/fairness in real-world modeling and management of integrated water resources.

    How to cite: Yalew, S., Kwakkel, J., Zatarain Salazar, J., and Doorn, N.: Operationalizing Justice in Integrated Water Resources Modeling and Management, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11159, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11159, 2022.

    EGU22-11884 | Presentations | HS5.3

    Multiobjective and real-options based planning for adaptive and robust water resources 

    Tohid Erfani, Kevis Pachos, Ivana Huskova, Evgenii Matrosov, and Julien Harou

    Planning for sustainable future water resources needs to consider multiple goals like cost and resilience. The ability to adapt given uncertainties about climate change, population growth and other unknowns should be embedded into planning approaches. Adaptive planning can help meet future needs and reduce the risk of over-investment, capitalizing on the upside situation of future supply-demand balances being less stressed than anticipated. In this study, we propose a multi-objective real-options based multi-stage formulation well- suited to regulated water utilities with a regular planning cycle. The formulation can be used to explore the trade-offs between long term water management plan’s resilience and financial costs while considering the effects of different types of demand growth and supply side uncertainties. Using London's water resource and supply system as a case study, we demonstrate how the generalized approach can be applied to reveal the cost-resilience trade-off delineated by different efficient planning alternatives.

    How to cite: Erfani, T., Pachos, K., Huskova, I., Matrosov, E., and Harou, J.: Multiobjective and real-options based planning for adaptive and robust water resources, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11884, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11884, 2022.

    EGU22-12450 | Presentations | HS5.3

    On temporal resolution of performance indicators of water resources systems 

    Sai Veena and Riddhi Singh

    The spatiotemporal variation of water resources and growing global requirements for freshwater necessitates planning and construction of water resource infrastructure to enable the management of a variable and potentially scarce resource. Large-scale water infrastructure serves multiple purposes including provisioning of freshwater, protection from floods, navigation, hydroelectricity, etc. At present, more than 16.7 million reservoirs with an area greater than 100 m2 exist, a majority of which serve multiple water sectors. Decision analysis for reservoir systems relies heavily on optimization techniques that identify optimal operational strategies for a dynamic systems model. All optimization frameworks require the analyst to define performance indicators, more formally, objective functions, that aggregate performance across multiple time periods in a planning horizon. A question thus arises: does the manner in which objective functions are aggregated have a substantial impact on resultant optimal operational strategy? For complex reservoir systems such as inter-basin water transfers, which require coordinating operations across multiple reservoirs, the temporal scale of operations likely impacts the system's performance. Here, we assess the impact of temporal aggregation of the objective function on resultant operational strategies for a proposed inter-basin water transfer in Southern India. We optimize monthly water transfer decisions using a multi-objective evolutionary algorithm that optimizes for the reliability of demand satisfaction at multiple temporal resolutions (annual, seasonal, fortnightly). We then re-evaluate the performance of all resultant strategies at fortnightly resolution. We find strategies obtained by optimizing reliability at an annual resolution that release water based on annual demands outperform the other two resolutions. This improvement in performance requires the presence of additional storage structures like lakes, ponds, check dams, etc. in the reservoir system, which is true in our study region. We further quantify the dependency between decision variables across these formulations to better understand the convergence dynamics of the optimization algorithm.

    How to cite: Veena, S. and Singh, R.: On temporal resolution of performance indicators of water resources systems, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12450, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12450, 2022.

    EGU22-12831 | Presentations | HS5.3

    Vulnerability assessment for climate adaptation planning in a mediterranean basin 

    Alba Solans, Hector Macian-Sorribes, Francisco Martinez-Capel, and Manuel Pulido-Velazquez

    In the context of climate uncertainty, planning for resilient, robust and adaptive water measures to achieve social, economic and environmental objectives, is a challenge.

    The aim of this study is to identify critical climatic conditions that cause system failure in a Mediterranean basin in order to evaluate vulnerabilities and design robust and adaptive measures of water supply. The methodology employed adopts a stress test under non-stationary climatic conditions consisting of: 1) generation of meteorological scenarios, by using a weather generator, 2) generation of hydrological scenarios by using a hydrological model, and 3) evaluation of system performance by using a water resource system model whose outcomes are used to identify climatic vulnerabilities .

    Meteorological scenarios are built using, first, a weather generator at the sub-basin scale that generates synthetic precipitation (P) and temperature (T) time series at annual scale by using autorregressive models to extract low-frequency signals. Afterwards, these series are disaggregated to the monthly scale by the method of fragments. Finally, climate change modifications are introduced to alter weather variables outside of the range of historical variability. Changes in the precipitation monthly mean ranged from -30% to +30%, using increments of 15% (5 increments). The coefficient of variation of monthly precipitation changed from -30% to +30%, using increments of 30% (3 increments). A quantile mapping method altered the distribution of monthly precipitation. For temperature, shifts in the monthly mean ranged from 0ºC to 3ºC by increments of 1ºC (4 increments). An standard additive method was used for altering temperature distribution. The combination among modifications led to a total of 60 (5 x 3 x 4) climate change scenarios to consider.

    This methodology is applied to the Serpis River basin, which has an area of 752.8 km2 and it is regulated by one reservoir whose main function is water supply to agriculture. A total of 434 generation runs per scenario were developed in MATLAB® in order to explore model uncertainty.

    Potential evapotranspiration (ETP) time series were estimated from T by using a periodic factor previously obtained from historical data and using Fourier series method. A hydrological semi-distributed model (Temez model) was employed to transform meteorological data into hydrological discharges.

    A water resource system model built using the GAMS software (General Algebraic Modeling System) was applied to evaluate the performance of the river network system and to identify critical conditions for allocation reliability. Identification of adaptation actions was based on future risk and the likelihood of future conditions that was defined by a high convergence in the GCM predictions from CMIP6.

    How to cite: Solans, A., Macian-Sorribes, H., Martinez-Capel, F., and Pulido-Velazquez, M.: Vulnerability assessment for climate adaptation planning in a mediterranean basin, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12831, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12831, 2022.

    EGU22-13134 | Presentations | HS5.3

    Seepage loss from unlined, lined, and cracked-lined canals: a case study of Ismailia canal reach from 28.00–49.00 Km, Egypt 

    Elsayed Elkamhawy, Martina Zelenakova, Salvatore Straface, Zuzana Vranayová, Abdelazim M. Negm, Andrea Scozzari, and Ismail Abd-Elaty

    Water resources face global and local challenges. In Egypt, for example,  the negative impacts of climatic changes and the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam (GERD), cause a shortage of water resources. Shortage of water resources is considered an urgent issue particularly in semiarid regions (like many MENA countries) and arid ones (like Egypt). Therefore, the Egyptian Ministry of Water Resources and Irrigation has launched the national project of canals rehabilitation and lining for effective water resource management and decreasing seepage losses. This study dealt with three different lining techniques, as well cracked-liner for the Ismailia canal, which is considered the largest end of the Nile in Egypt. A steady-state 2-D seep/w model was established for the Ismailia canal section, at the stretch from 28  to 49 km. The results showed that the amount of seepage was considerably depending on the hydraulic characteristics of the lining material. Pumping from aquifers through wells also has a significant influence on the seepage rate from the unlined canal. Nevertheless, a negligible effect was present in the lined canal case. The highest efficiency was obtained with the concrete liner, after that the geomembrane liner, and then the bentonite liner; with nearly 99%, 96%, and 54%, respectively, in the case of no pumping from aquifer via wells. The efficiency decreased by 4% for the bentonite and geomembrane liners during pumping from the aquifer, but the concrete liner efficiency did not change significantly. However, in the case of deterioration of the lining material through cracks, the efficiency strictly decreased to 25%, irrespective of the utilized lining technique. The dual effect of both cracked-liner material and extraction from the aquifer via pumping wells revealed an efficiency of 16%, regardless of the utilized liner type.

    How to cite: Elkamhawy, E., Zelenakova, M., Straface, S., Vranayová, Z., Negm, A. M., Scozzari, A., and Abd-Elaty, I.: Seepage loss from unlined, lined, and cracked-lined canals: a case study of Ismailia canal reach from 28.00–49.00 Km, Egypt, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13134, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13134, 2022.

    Floodwater conservation in reservoir flood control capacity will lead to additional flood control risk for reservoir operation during flood seasons. Coupling the meteorological and hydrological uncertainties, the probability density function of reservoir initial flood regulation water level is derived to quantify the uncertainty in floodwater conservation through an analytical method. In reservoir flood control operation, the uncertainty of initial water level being above the designed flood limited water level and the uncertainty of inflow caused by flood forecast error are two main risk factors. This study developed a dynamic and intelligent risk prediction and diagnosis model for reservoir flood regulation under two-dimensional uncertainties based on Bayesian network. Three modules are included: Bayesian network structure learning, parameter learning, and probability inference. The nodes of Bayesian network are determined and the network structure is established with expert knowledge; the parameter learning is conducted with the training samples obtained from Monte Carlo simulation. Thereafter, through the prior probability inference without posterior information and the posterior probability inference with given posterior information, the variation of flood risk is analyzed under single-factor uncertainty and two-factors uncertainties. The model is applied to Xianghongdian Reservoir in China using a flood of 100 years return period. Results indicate: the risk resulted from inflow uncertainty is greater than that of the uncertainty of initial water level; there is a certain complementarity between the uncertainties of inflow and initial water level, and the combined risk is between the results of two single-factor risk levels. Moreover, Bayesian Network is able to conduct bi-directional inferences and infer the probability distribution of any other node, which has practical value for risk assessment and control of reservoir flood control operation.

    How to cite: Lu, Q.: Risk analysis for reservoir flood control operation considering two-dimensional uncertainties based on Bayesian network, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-710, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-710, 2022.

    EGU22-1072 | Presentations | HS5.4

    Optimizing the operating rule of a controversial interbasin water transfer: the Tagus-Segura aqueduct (Spain) 

    Carlotta Valerio, Matteo Giuliani, Andrea Castelletti, Alberto Garrido, and Lucia De Stefano

    Interbasin water transfers (IBWT) are often conceived as solutions to balance freshwater's uneven spatial and temporal distribution. Climate change, increasing water demand and water quality deterioration are expected to further increase the importance of water transfer schemes in future. At the same time, IBWT are often controversial and raise concerns about their social, environmental and economic impacts.

    The Tagus-Segura aqueduct (TSA) in Spain is among the major IBWT projects existing in the world. It is designed to transfer a maximum of 650 hm3/year from the Entrepeñas and Buendía dams in the Tagus headwaters river basin to the Segura river basin for irrigation and urban water supply purposes. The reduction of the natural runoff registered since the 80ies, the implementation of a non-optimal operating rule and, finally, the degradation of the Tagus river ecosystems have generated strong, still unsolved tensions between donor and receiving regions.

    In this study, we employ the Evolutionary Multiobjective Direct Policy Search (EMODPS) to optimize the operation of the TSA with respect to four potentially conflicting objectives: the Tagus (i) and the Segura water demands (ii); hydropower production downstream of the Entrepeñas and Buendía dams (iii) and the social-economic benefit of the population living on the shores of the reservoirs (iv). The release decision parameters and the operating rule parameters are jointly optimized, thus allowing the exploration of trade-offs between objectives and the definition of an operating rule that could benefit all the stakeholders involved. We tested the optimization under several scenarios, with the aim to assess the effect of the implementation of different environmental flows in the Tagus river on the TSA operations.

    By applying a state-of-art method such as the EMODPS to the TSA case, this work contributes to the intense ongoing debate on the present and future of this controversial water transfer in Spain. We also explore the potential of the EMODPS approach to guide the design of efficient and sustainable operating rules of water transfers, with the ultimate goal of mitigating tensions between recipient and donor regions and seeking to fulfil the environmental needs in the donor basin.

    How to cite: Valerio, C., Giuliani, M., Castelletti, A., Garrido, A., and De Stefano, L.: Optimizing the operating rule of a controversial interbasin water transfer: the Tagus-Segura aqueduct (Spain), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1072, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1072, 2022.

    EGU22-3103 | Presentations | HS5.4

    Connecting spatial climate information to infrastructure operations using deep reinforcement learning 

    Liam Ekblad, Jonathan Herman, Scott Steinschneider, Matteo Giuliani, and Andrea Castelletti

    Water infrastructure operations can adapt to both short-term variability and long-term change. Studies that have leveraged climate information to reoperate infrastructure have yet to explore the direct use of spatially distributed information in operating policy training, which could enable learning from weather patterns associated with emerging risks—for example, flood and drought events associated with atmospheric rivers or high-pressure ridges, respectively, which result from co-occurring weather and climate patterns on multiple timescales. This study investigates the potential for spatial projections from large-ensemble climate models to directly inform reservoir operating policies using a deep reinforcement learning strategy, aiming to discover flexible, climate-informed policies without prior dimension reduction, which could cause loss of information. The approach is demonstrated for Folsom Reservoir in California. We investigate how learned policies interpret spatial climate information by connecting flood control and water supply shortage operations to the sensitivity and salience patterns associated with the input images. To assess the extent to which trained policies generalize to possible future climates, policies trained on historical data are tested on held-out scenarios drawn from the same period, and their performance is compared to flood and shortage scenarios drawn from a future period. Trained policies are robust to the variability present across climate model ensembles, demonstrate value in identifying spatial climate patterns for operations, and maintain the flexibility to dynamically adapt to climate change as it occurs, illustrating a broad benefit to global infrastructure systems facing climate risks.

    How to cite: Ekblad, L., Herman, J., Steinschneider, S., Giuliani, M., and Castelletti, A.: Connecting spatial climate information to infrastructure operations using deep reinforcement learning, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3103, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3103, 2022.

    EGU22-5783 | Presentations | HS5.4

    Extracting the most valuable information from multi-timescale hydrological forecasts for informing the operation of multipurpose water systems 

    Andrea Castelletti, Dennis Zanutto, Andrea Ficchì, and Matteo Giuliani

    Given the ever-growing accuracy of forecast products over different lead times, it’s increasingly important to understand how to efficiently select and use the most valuable information to support adaptive and robust management of water resources under changing hydroclimatic conditions. In this study, we investigate how the most valuable information from multi-scale forecasts can be selected and used to inform the optimal operation of multipurpose water reservoirs. Our framework combines Input Variable Selection algorithms supporting the selection of the most informative policy inputs, including different forecast variables over diverse lead times, with the Evolutionary Multi-Objective Direct Policy Search method for designing Pareto optimal control policies conditioned on forecast information.

    We test this approach on the Lake Como system, a regulated lake in Northern Italy which is operated for preventing floods along the lake shores, providing irrigation supply to downstream users and avoiding low lake levels. Our approach allows the identification of the best subset or combination of variables and metrics extracted from a suite of forecast products. In particular, the performance of the system is evaluated using short-term local deterministic forecasts as well as sub-seasonal and seasonal large-scale ensemble forecasts provided by the European Flood Awareness System (EFAS), part of the Copernicus Emergency Management Service. The candidate variables proposed as inputs for the IVS include different statistics extracted from these forecasts, including the accumulated inflow up to different lead times, the maximum daily flow over different temporal scales and spatial domains, the ensemble forecast variance and some skill scores. The performance of the designed forecast-informed operating policies is contrasted against various benchmarks, including perfect forecasts and the climatology. Beside improving the operating policy performance, results are expected to provide insights about the intrinsic bias of forecast products and to highlight the role of forecast uncertainty in policy design.

    How to cite: Castelletti, A., Zanutto, D., Ficchì, A., and Giuliani, M.: Extracting the most valuable information from multi-timescale hydrological forecasts for informing the operation of multipurpose water systems, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5783, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5783, 2022.

    EGU22-5846 | Presentations | HS5.4

    Integrated real-time control of water reservoirs with deterministic and probabilistic multi-timescale forecasts: Application to the Lake Como 

    Andrea Ficchì, Federico Staffa, Raffaele Giuseppe Cestari, Simone Formentin, and Andrea Castelletti

    Hydro-meteorological forecasts are more and more easily available with improving skill over longer timescales and with higher spatiotemporal resolutions. Their uncertainties are commonly represented by ensemble prediction systems which are now dominant at the global and continental scale, while short-term deterministic forecasts are still used, especially in some local contexts. For effective water resources management, it is critical to understand how to use the wealth of information provided by different forecast systems over multiple timescales to help meet the water demand of key competing socio-economic sectors, while reducing short-term impacts and bringing the controlled systems to desirable states in the long term. Real-time control schemes of water reservoirs like Model Predictive Control (MPC) can help meet these goals, by providing a flexible framework to use forecasts proactively and satisfy multiple competing objectives while respecting operational constraints.

    In this study, we propose a new nested multi-stage stochastic MPC framework integrating the use of both deterministic and ensemble hydrological forecasts over multiple timescales from short-term (60 hours) to seasonal (7 months ahead). We demonstrate the performance of this real-time controller for the Lake Como system, located in the Italian Alps, where a large lake is regulated mainly for irrigation supply and flood control. First, seasonal ensemble forecasts are used to solve a Tree-Based MPC (TB-MPC) problem optimising the reservoir management over several months, by adopting a tree structure to summarise the ensemble information including the resolution of uncertainty in time. Second, the decisions identified so far are used to condition daily operations over a month using sub-seasonal probabilistic forecasts (up to 46 days) under the same TB-MPC approach. Third, the decisions for the first few days are then further adapted to optimize operations three days ahead using deterministic short-term forecasts with MPC. The sub-seasonal and seasonal ensemble (re-)forecasts used are those produced by the European Flood Awareness System (EFAS) from the Copernicus Emergency Management Service which uses ensemble meteorological forecasts from the European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasts (ECMWF). While EFAS is uncalibrated for the study area, we apply bias-correction techniques to improve the agreement of forecasts with local observations and allow their use for resolving the water-balance within MPC. The short-term 60-h forecasts come from a locally calibrated hydrological model (TOPKAPI) using deterministic weather forecasts from the COSMO (Consortium for Small Scale Modelling) model. The skill of all these forecasts is assessed, as well as the ensemble spread–error relationship for EFAS at different lead times. To evaluate the value of the forecasts we compare the performance of the real-time MPC controller with different benchmarks including perfect forecasts, climatology, and persistence. Finally, we investigate the link between forecast skill and value for reservoir operation, and we compare the performance of the nested MPC framework integrating multi-timescale forecasts with the MPC using single forecasts.

    How to cite: Ficchì, A., Staffa, F., Cestari, R. G., Formentin, S., and Castelletti, A.: Integrated real-time control of water reservoirs with deterministic and probabilistic multi-timescale forecasts: Application to the Lake Como, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5846, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5846, 2022.

    EGU22-5956 | Presentations | HS5.4

    Assessing the value of seasonal forecasts in informing reservoir operations in water-stressed Mediterranean basins 

    Nicola Crippa, Guang Yang, Manolis Grillakis, Aristeidis Koutroulis, and Matteo Giuliani

    Population expansion and socio-economic development have been increasing the pressure on water resources, which are often exploited in a non-renewable way. Besides, climate change can modify hydroclimatic patterns and exaggerate freshwater water stress. Flexible operation of existing water reservoirs is one of the most cost-effective ways to mitigate water-related stress, by storing water when it is abundant and releasing it when droughts persist. In this context, medium - to long-term hydroclimatic forecasts are set to cover a central role for properly informing reservoir decision-making and operation policy design. State-of-the-art hydroclimatic forecast products are indeed becoming more and more skillful at seasonal or longer lead-times, especially in regions characterized by climate teleconnections or by predictable hydrological behavior, such as baseflow- or snow-dominance. Nevertheless, the link between forecast skill and forecast value, i.e. the performance improvement obtained thanks to the use of the forecasts, is neither easily predictable nor necessarily positive. Each system indeed requires specific forecasts according to its characteristics, such as climate and hydrological regime, size of the reservoir, management objectives, and the skill of existing forecast systems do not necessarily translate into a significant gain in system performance.

    In this work, we quantify the value of seasonal forecast information in informing the operations of the Faneromeni reservoir on the Crete island. The reservoir is primarily used to provide water to an important agricultural district during the dry summer season. Current operation of this reservoir is based on the available storage at the beginning of the irrigation season, which, in normal conditions, allows the supply of the irrigation demand if the reservoir is completely full; otherwise, the reservoir releases are modulated according to the storage shortage. We instead investigate alternative policies for the operations of the Faneromeni reservoir by using the Evolutionary Multi Objectives Direct Policy Search (EMODPS) method, which allows the design of flexible rules to cope with the variability of the hydrologic conditions as well as to include forecast information for conditioning operational decisions.

    Preliminary results show that EMODPS policies can improve the existing operation of the Faneromeni reservoir. Moreover, these solutions also allow to mitigate the negative impacts of climate change and flexibly adapt the reservoir operations to the projected hydroclimatic conditions.

     

    This work is supported by the STREAM project funded by the Prince Albert II of Monaco Foundation, grant number 2981.

    How to cite: Crippa, N., Yang, G., Grillakis, M., Koutroulis, A., and Giuliani, M.: Assessing the value of seasonal forecasts in informing reservoir operations in water-stressed Mediterranean basins, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5956, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5956, 2022.

    In many studies arises the need to generate synthetic data sets. Such data can answer different needs as data imputation, non-stationary systems analysis, Monte Carlo simulations, training of data-driven models, uncertainty analysis and more. Previous efforts to generate synthetic data focused mostly on statistical methods which did not maintain the statistical moments of the original dataset, while producing a large number of random different time series. Here, a novel method is developed, based on signal processing and discrete Fourier transform (DFT) theory. The method allows to generate synthetic time series signals with similar statistical moments of any given signal. Moreover, the method allows control on the correlation level between the original and the synthesized signals. We also provide mathematical proofs that our method maintains the first two statistical moments. The method is illustrated on two different datasets showing that also the third and fourth moments are kept. Figure 1 shows, in blue, a true water demand time-series taken from a real-life system. For this signal, 50 synthesized signals are generated with increasing correlation levels - from top, with the lowest correlation, to bottom, presenting the highest correlations between the original and synthesized signals.

                                                                                                                        

                                                                    Figure 1 – Domestic water demand signal with different correlation level

    How to cite: Perelman, G. and Fishbain, B.: Synthesizing water-related time series for simulation studies while maintaining the original signal’s statistical moments, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8805, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8805, 2022.

    EGU22-9553 | Presentations | HS5.4

    Post-processing of seasonal forecasts in a semi-arid river basin through artificial intelligence 

    Manuel Pulido-Velazquez and Hector Macian-Sorribes

    The use of artificial intelligence is growing in many science areas boosted by an unprecedent increase in data availability and the improvements in computer hardware. Its application in Earth system sciences is particularly relevant due to the existence of complex behavioural patterns whose reproduction with traditional methods is challenging. Its use in seasonal forecasting is favoured by the existence of large amounts of open meteorological data.

    This study showcases the potential of artificial intelligence to downscale and post-process seasonal meteorological forecasts in semiarid river basin. The artificial intelligence methodology used is fuzzy logic. Daily raw seasonal forecasts correspond to the ECMWF SEAS5 seasonal forecasts from the Copernicus Climate Change Service (CS3), available at a 1º grid, while daily ERA5 reanalysis, available at a 0.25º grid through the C3S, is employed as observational data. The meteorological variables used are precipitation; 2-meter mean, minimum and maximum temperatures; incident shortwave solar radiation and wind speed.

    The artificial intelligence algorithm is coded in a Python script. The script requires the coordinates of a target grid (that may coincide or not with the grid of observational data). For each point it performs the post-processing with the following process: 1) extracts the observational and forecast data for the closest point available; 2) computes the cdf’s of both datasets per month; 3) builds and trains fuzzy logic systems to match the forecasts cdfs to the observational cdfs; and 4) obtains the post-processed forecasts for the target grid provided. The script admits any meteorological variable, seasonal forecasting system from the C3S and observational dataset (it has been successfully tested with ERA5Land and the Spain02 gridded dataset).

    The script has been applied to the semi-arid upper Tagus and Segura river basins. The Segura river basin suffers a severe overexploitation alleviated by a water transfer from the upper Tagus. The fuzzy logic systems chosen were Sugeno of order 1, with two inputs: the raw meteorological forecasts and the month of the year. The same grid as ERA5 was considered, and for each point the fuzzy logic systems were trained so that the forecasts monthly cdfs match the ones from ERA5. The training process took on average 20 minutes per point and variable with a standard computer, and results show that the post-processed cdfs closely match the ERA5 cdfs. Furthermore, the skill of the post-processed forecasts was evaluated using the Mean Absolute Error (MAE) and compared to the skill of raw forecasts to assess the adequacy of the post-processing.

    Acknowledgements:  This study has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under the GoNEXUS project (grant agreement No 101003722); the eGROUNDWATER project (GA n. 1921), part of the PRIMA programme supported by the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme; and the subvencions del Programa per a la promoció de la investigación científica, el desenvolupament tecnològic i la innovació a la Comunitat Valenciana (PROMETEO) under the WATER4CAST project.

    How to cite: Pulido-Velazquez, M. and Macian-Sorribes, H.: Post-processing of seasonal forecasts in a semi-arid river basin through artificial intelligence, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9553, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9553, 2022.

    EGU22-9611 | Presentations | HS5.4

    Assessment of seasonal forecasts for reservoir operation in South Korea 

    Yongshin Lee, Francesca Pianosi, Miguel Rico-Ramirez, and Andres Peñuela

    Increased intensity and frequency of extreme weather events predicted in a warmer climate can cause damages to human life, properties and the natural environment. Also, these changes pose significant challenges to water resources management. For example, in South-Korea, there were prolonged droughts lasting more than 3 years from 2013 to 2015 whereas, record-breaking monsoon caused severe flood damages in 2020.  Nowadays the construction of new water infrastructure such as large reservoirs is almost impossible in many developed countries due to social and environmental objections and therefore the operation of existing reservoirs is extremely important. In order to improve the performance of reservoir operations, we need to make better use of reliable weather forecasting information.

    There have been noteworthy advances in seasonal climate forecasts over the last decade. Seasonal forecasts are long-term meteorological forecasts (1 to 7 months) that could be a game changer in reservoir operation and adaptation to climate change once it is demonstrated that they provide reliable information in the water sector. However, so far seasonal forecasts have never been used in practice and simulation experiments similar to those reported in the scientific literature for other regions, such as Europe or the US, have not been conducted for South Korea.

    Therefore, assessing the value of seasonal forecasts in reservoir operation is highly significant matter. In this study, we will try to demonstrate their value by comparing, via model simulation, the use of forecasts with the use of diverse scenarios, including deterministic low inflow scenarios (or worst cases), Ensemble Streamflow Prediction (ESP) and perfect forecast conditions (where observations are used in place of forecasts). The analysis will be carried out for 6 different reservoirs having different catchment sizes  from 95.4km2 to 1,584km2 to determine any link between forecasts value and catchment characteristics and draw general guidelines for future forecasts use. The results from each scenario will be compared in terms of ‘skill’, representing the forecast accuracy, and ‘value’, representing the final effect on reservoir operation such as water resources availability and flood prediction. This study aims at understanding how valuable the seasonal forecasts can be and how to apply them to have better performance in practice.

    How to cite: Lee, Y., Pianosi, F., Rico-Ramirez, M., and Peñuela, A.: Assessment of seasonal forecasts for reservoir operation in South Korea, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9611, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9611, 2022.

    EGU22-9677 | Presentations | HS5.4

    On the relationship between forecast skill and value for water management 

    Francesca Pianosi, Andres Peñuela-Fernandez, and Charles Rougé

    Over the last decade, weather and hence hydrological forecasts with lead time up to six-seven months (so called “seasonal” forecasts) have become increasingly available. One of the key intended purposes of these forecast products is to support water resources management, particularly for water supply or other operational objectives that require a lead time longer than decadal. However, examples of water agencies that have formally embedded these products in their operational practice are hardly reported to date. This is often traced back to the uncertainty and inaccuracy that affect these forecast products, particularly outside the tropics, and many have concluded that skill must increase before seasonal forecasts can be used in operational management (Jackson-Blake et al. 2021). However, a handful of simulation studies have recently suggested that forecasts value (that is, the enhancement of management performance when forecasts are integrated into decision-making procedures) may exceed their skill (that is, the ability to predict inflows correctly). This is an interesting perspective and calls for more studies to investigate the relationship between skill and value for water management, so to understand when and how value could be extracted from forecasts despite their limited skill.

    With this motivation, in a previous simulation study (Penuela et al. 2020) we evaluated the potential of seasonal forecasts for improving the operations of a pumped-storage supply system in the UK. We found that the forecast value was only loosely related to skill, and that operational priorities (that is, the relative weight given to the two objectives of saving energy and reaching full capacity at the end of the filling season) and hydrological conditions (the initial reservoir storage and the overall inflow volume over the filling season) determined the forecast value more than its skill.

    In this work, we use the same case study to further explore the skill-value relationship by comprehensively assessing and comparing ensemble of forecasts with different skill. First, we use a novel technique to generate synthetic ensembles of weather forecasts with similar characteristics to the original one (provided by the ECMWF seasonal forecasting systems SEAS5, in our case) and artificially increased skill – up to the ‘perfect’ forecast where all ensemble members coincide with observations. Second, for each synthetic ensemble, we generate the corresponding hydrological forecasts through a conceptual rainfall-runoff model. Last, through a nested optimisation-simulation procedure, we reconstruct the reservoir operations that would have resulted from (optimally) using those hydrological forecasts over a 11-years simulation period. We then compare resulting performances in terms of storage conservation and energy costs (the forecast ‘value’) as forecast skill increases. This helps us shed some more light on the skill-value relationship, and identify thresholds (if they exist) below which forecasts are not useful, or conversely, above which further improving skill does not significantly increase value.

    Peñuela et al. (2020) Assessing the value of seasonal hydrological forecasts for improving water resource management: insights from a pilot application in the UK, HESS, 24. https://doi.org/10.5194/hess-24-6059-2020

    Jackson-Blake et al. (2021) Opportunities for seasonal forecasting to support water management outside the tropics, HESSD, In review. https://doi.org/10.5194/hess-2021-443

    How to cite: Pianosi, F., Peñuela-Fernandez, A., and Rougé, C.: On the relationship between forecast skill and value for water management, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9677, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9677, 2022.

    EGU22-9742 | Presentations | HS5.4

    What family of Radial Basis Functions to use in Direct Policy Search? A comparative analysis 

    Jan Kwakkel and Jazmin Zatarian-Salazar

    Direct policy search (DPS) is increasingly being used to flexibly design policies for multi-objective reservoir control. DPS is a promising approach that can easily find policies for many heterogenous objective functions, particularly when coupling global approximators with evolutionary algorithms. Nonetheless, specifying the topology and the family of global approximators, i.e., radial basis functions, is usually done by trial and error for practical applications and is often not reported in the literature. How does the selected family of radial basis functions affect the quality of the resulting control policies? Does the chosen family influence the search behavior of the evolutionary algorithms? Can we formulate recommendations for which families are more or less suitable in general, or given the characteristics of the control problem? We test a suite of radial basis functions to address these questions for finding Pareto optimal reservoir control policies using an established reference case. This reference case is the Conowingo reservoir, a transboundary water body in the Susquehanna River Basin in North-East US. The reservoir needs to meet multiple competing water needs for hydropower production, environmental flows, recreation, cooling water for Peach Bottom atomic power plant, and urban water supply for Baltimore, MD, and Chester, PA. To optimize the Pareto optimal reservoir control policies, we use the e-NSGA2 algorithm. Our study shows the effect of using different families of radial basis functions, particularly their impact on the recommended reservoir operations, the resulting tradeoffs across the different sectors, and the search behavior of the evolutionary algorithm.

    How to cite: Kwakkel, J. and Zatarian-Salazar, J.: What family of Radial Basis Functions to use in Direct Policy Search? A comparative analysis, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9742, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9742, 2022.

    EGU22-10682 | Presentations | HS5.4

    Rumble on the River: Analyzing Model Performance in a Year-Long, Live Streamflow Forecasting Competition 

    Alden Keefe Sampson, David Lambl, Lauren Gulland, Mostafa Elkurdy, Phillip Butcher, and Laura Read

    Accurate streamflow forecasts equip water managers to adapt to changing flow regimes and constraints, increase water supply reliability, reduce flood risk, and maximize revenue. Over the 2021 water year, the Upstream Tech team took part in a live, 1-10 day ahead streamflow forecasting competition using our flow forecast system, HydroForecast. The competition was a chance to objectively compare operational forecasts using a range of modeling approaches from national agencies, hydropower utilities’ in-house teams, private forecasters and individual modelers at 19 sites in North America. HydroForecast outperformed both statistical and conceptual models and won the competition. We evaluate HydroForecast’s performance relative to other models to identify its strengths and areas for further research by region, season, and forecast horizon. We also share what our theory-guided machine learning approach to hydrologic modeling means in practice for HydroForecast, focusing on the key facets of our approach which contribute most to our accuracy. Finally, we describe the largest opportunities for further forecast accuracy gains we identified in this competition and some of the research efforts we are working on to meet those opportunities.

    How to cite: Sampson, A. K., Lambl, D., Gulland, L., Elkurdy, M., Butcher, P., and Read, L.: Rumble on the River: Analyzing Model Performance in a Year-Long, Live Streamflow Forecasting Competition, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10682, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10682, 2022.

    EGU22-12889 | Presentations | HS5.4

    Flash flood early-warning system in a Mediterranean reservoir at operational scales for hydropower production 

    Cristina Aguilar, Rafael Pimentel, Sergio Vela, Eva Contreras, Fátima Moreno, and María José Polo

    The operation of hydropower systems relies on the hydraulic conditions of the water system and their management is carried out based on certain operation rules (e.g., turbine minimum and maximum discharge) and environmental flows requirements. The effects of global change in hydropower systems are varied as expected changes in the meteorological forcing agents determine considerable modifications in the water flows that affect the amount of available water and thus, the production and profitability from hydropower plants. In this context, flash-flood events are especially relevant as quick management decisions need to be applied to minimize not only the potential damages downstream, but also the energy production losses connected to a conservative approach. The optimization of the decision-making process under flash flood events has two main challenges in these areas. On the one hand, there are several meteorological forecasting systems at different spatiotemporal scales currently available. However, the greater uncertainty linked to the rapid response time of these headwater catchments limits their use. On the other hand, the insufficient number of control points with available real time measurements (i.e., precipitation gauges and water level controls) makes it difficult to create early warning systems with an appropriate uncertainty quantification.

    This study presents the definition of an early warning system that forecasts the inflow into a headwater Mediterranean catchment with a fast hydrological response. The Cala dam (59 hm3) was selected as the pilot reservoir with hydroelectric production as its main use, but also with irrigation and leisure demands. The contributing catchment (535 km2) is a good example of Mediterranean conditions in southern Spain, with agroforestry uses and a quick response to intense precipitation events due to steep slopes, shallow soils and groundwater redistribution, which does not favor the modulation of the hydrological response. The warning system was built based on the current operational rules of the reservoir. Once the flood event starts, the use of real time information about the water volume stored in the reservoir and the inflow in the next hour estimated using a Bayesian approach based on antecedent precipitation and other water flows states in the catchment, constitute the hydrological indicators to base the decision on, together with the generation of thresholds and requirements of the hydropower system. This methodological scheme could be easily transferable into other Mediterranean catchments with similar characteristics. Moreover, the development of these tools as decision support systems in the decision-making process is essential and allows the incorporation of advanced plans to adapt to global warming.

     

    This work has been funded by the project FEDER UCO-1381239 Herramienta de pronóstico estocástico de caudal para gestión de centrales hidroeléctricas en cuencas mediterráneas a distintas escalas temporales, with the economic collaboration of the European Funding for Rural Development (FEDER) and the Office for Economy, Knowledge, Enterprises and University of the Andalusian Regional Government.

    How to cite: Aguilar, C., Pimentel, R., Vela, S., Contreras, E., Moreno, F., and Polo, M. J.: Flash flood early-warning system in a Mediterranean reservoir at operational scales for hydropower production, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12889, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12889, 2022.

    EGU22-13011 | Presentations | HS5.4

    Sustainable Reservoir Operation and Control Using a Deep Reinforcement Learning Policy Gradient Method 

    Sadegh Sadeghi Tabas and Vidya Samadi

    The increasing stress on water resource systems has prompted researchers to look for ways to improve the performance of reservoir operations. Changes in demand, various hydrological inputs, and new environmental stresses are among issues that water managers face. These concerns have sparked interest in applying different techniques to determine reservoir operation policy to improve reservoir system performance. As the resolution of analysis rises, it becomes more difficult to effectively represent a real-world system using currently available approaches for determining the best reservoir operation policy. One of the challenges is the "curse of dimensionality," which occurs when the discretization of the state and action spaces becomes finer or when more state or action variables are taken into account. Because of the dimensionality curse, the number of state-action variables is limited, rendering dynamic programming (DP) and stochastic DP (SDP) ineffective in handling complex reservoir optimization issues. Reinforcement learning (RL) is one way to overcome the aforementioned curses of stochastic optimization of water resources systems. RL is a well-known and influential technique in machine learning research that can solve a wide range of optimization and simulation challenges. In this study, a novel continuous-action deep RL algorithm called Deep Deterministic Policy Gradients (DDPG) is applied to solve the DP problem for the Folsom Reservoir system located in California, US. Without requiring any model simplifications or surrendering any of the critical characteristics of DP, the employed continuous action-space RL method effectively overcomes dimensionality concerns. The system model employs an iterative learning method that takes into account delayed rewards without requiring an explicit probabilistic model of hydrologic processes, and it can learn the best actions that maximize total expected reward by interacting with a simulated environment. This research is funded by the US Geological Survey.

    How to cite: Sadeghi Tabas, S. and Samadi, V.: Sustainable Reservoir Operation and Control Using a Deep Reinforcement Learning Policy Gradient Method, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13011, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13011, 2022.

    EGU22-13084 | Presentations | HS5.4

    A flexible approach for evaluating the value of probabilistic forecasts for different decision types and risk averse decision-makers 

    Richard Laugesen, Mark Thyer, David McInerney, and Dmitri Kavetski

    Forecasts have the potential to improve decision-making but have not been widely evaluated because current forecast value methods have critical limitations. The ubiquitous Relative Economic Value (REV) is limited to binary decisions, cost-loss economic model, and risk neutral decision-makers. Expected Utility Theory can flexibly model more real-world decisions, but its application in forecasting has been limited and the findings are difficult to compare. To enable a systematic comparison of these methods a new metric, Relative Utility Value (RUV), is developed based on Expected Utility Theory. It has the same interpretation as REV but is more flexible and able to handle a wider range of real-world decisions because all aspects of the decision-context are user-defined. Also, when specific assumptions are imposed it is shown that REV and RUV are equivalent. We demonstrate the key differences and similarities between the methods with a case study using probabilistic subseasonal streamflow forecasts in a catchment in the Southern Murray-Darling Basin of Australia. This showed that for most decision-makers the ensemble forecasts were more valuable than a reference climatology for all lead-times (max 30 days), decision types (binary, multi-categorical, and continuous-flow), and levels of risk aversion. Risk aversion had a mixed impact across the different decision-types and the key driver was found to be the specific decision thresholds relative to the damage function. The generality of RUV makes it applicable to any domain where forecast information is used for making decisions, and the flexibility enables forecast assessment tailored to specific decisions and decision-makers. It complements forecast verification and enables assessment of forecast systems through the lens of customer impact.

    How to cite: Laugesen, R., Thyer, M., McInerney, D., and Kavetski, D.: A flexible approach for evaluating the value of probabilistic forecasts for different decision types and risk averse decision-makers, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13084, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13084, 2022.

    EGU22-1826 | Presentations | HS5.5

    Quantifying economic-social-environmental trade-offs and synergies of water-supply constraints: An application to the capital region of China 

    Dandan Zhao, Junguo Liu, Laixiang Sun, Bin Ye, Klaus Hubacek, Kuishuang Feng, and Olli Varis

    Quantifying economic-social-environmental trade-offs and synergies of water-supply constraints: An application to the capital region of China

     

    Dandan Zhao a,b, Junguo Liub,, Laixiang Sunc,d,e,, Bin Ye b, Klaus Hubacekf, Kuishuang Fengc, Olli Varisa

     

    a Water & Development Research Group, Aalto University, PO Box 15200, 00076 Espoo, Finland

    b School of Environmental Science and Engineering, Southern University of Science and Technology, China

    c Department of Geographical Sciences, University of Maryland, College Park, USA

    d School of Finance and Management, SOAS, University of London, London, UK

    e Institute of Blue and Green Development, Weihai Institute of Interdisciplinary Research, Shandong University, Weihai,

    f Integrated Research of Energy, Environment and Society (IREES) , University of Groningen, the Netherlands

     

    Sustainable water management is one of the sustainable development goals (SDGs) and is characterized by a high level of interdependencies with other SDGs from regional to global scales. Many water as[1]sessment studies are restricted to silo thinking, mostly focusing on water-related consequences, while lacking a quantification of trade-offs and synergies of economic, social, and environmental dimensions. To fill this knowledge gap, we propose a “nexus” approach that integrates a water supply constrained multi-regional input-output (mixed MRIO) model, scenario analysis, and multi-criteria decision analysis (MCDA) to quantify the trade-offs and synergies at the sectoral level for the capital region of China, i.e. the Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei urban agglomeration. A total of 120 industrial transition scenarios includ[1]ing nine major industries with high water-intensities and water consumption under current development pathways were developed to facilitate the trade-off and synergy analysis between economic loss, social goals (here, the number of jobs) and environmental protection (with grey water footprint representing water pollution) triggered by water conservation measures. Our simulation results show that an imposi[1]tion of a tolerable water constraint (a necessary water consumption reduction for regional water stress level to move from severe to moderate) in the region would result in an average economic loss of 68.4 (± 16.0) billion Yuan (1 yuan ≈ 0.158 USD$ in 2012), or 1.3 % of regional GDP, a loss of 1.94 (± 0.18) million jobs (i.e. 3.5 % of the work force) and a reduction of 1.27 (± 0.40) billion m3 or about 2.2% of the regional grey water footprint. A tolerable water rationing in water-intensive sectors such as Agriculture, Food and tobacco processing, Electricity and heating power production and Chemicals would result in the lowest economic and job losses and the largest environmental benefits. Based on MCDA, we selected the 10 best scenarios with regard to their economic, social and environmental performances as references for guiding future water management and suggested industrial transition policies. This integrated approach could be a powerful policy support tool for 1) assessing trade-offs and synergies among multiple criteria and across multiple region-sectors under resource constraints; 2) quantifying the short-term supply-chain effects of different containment measures, and 3) facilitating more insightful evaluation of SDGs at the regional level so as to determine priorities for local governments and practitioners to achieve SDGs.

    How to cite: Zhao, D., Liu, J., Sun, L., Ye, B., Hubacek, K., Feng, K., and Varis, O.: Quantifying economic-social-environmental trade-offs and synergies of water-supply constraints: An application to the capital region of China, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1826, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1826, 2022.

    EGU22-3637 | Presentations | HS5.5

    Integrated assessment of renewable urban heating systems considering water use, committed emissions and energy justice 

    Chelsea Kaandorp, Nick van de Giesen, and Edo Abraham

    Transitioning towards renewable heating is important to minimise the use of fossil fuels and abate carbon emissions, because heating accounts for 50% of the final energy consumption and 40% of carbon dioxide emissions globally. In the city of Amsterdam, the Netherlands, the aim is to transition towards renewable heating by 2040 and achieve carbon-neutral heating by 2050 through a neighbourhood-based approach. Such an approach entails that per neighbourhood a renewable heat solution is chosen  based on criteria such as carbon emissions, reliability, affordability and feasibility. The impacts of urban heating systems however goes beyond a neighbourhood, and take place on multiple spatial and temporal scales. In this presentation we discuss how a transition towards renewable heating systems can influence the water-energy-land nexus on multiple scales in three ways.

    First, heating systems use water locally, but also indirectly through the water footprint embedded in energy carriers. We therefore present an analysis of the direct and indirect water use of heating pathways towards 2050. Second, heating systems which currently have the lowest carbon emissions, may not be the heat option with the lowest carbon emissions in the future. Current decisions for heat options can therefore create non-optimal solutions for minimising carbon emissions in the future. An optimization model to find a mix of heating systems to reduce committed emissions on a neighbourhood scale within a given time period for different scenarios for the insulation of buildings and the decarbonisation of electricity generation is therefore presented. At last, new norms and forms of organising neighbourhood-based heating systems may emerge, potentially creating or exacerbating social inequalities within and beyond the spatial boundaries of a neighbourhood. We therefore present the preliminary results of an analysis on energy justice based on in-depth interviews with urban professionals, dwellers and decision makers in Amsterdam. 

    By presenting these three studies we aim to address the challenge of multi-scale impacts of transitioning towards renewable urban energy systems and show how energy-water-land nexus research can contribute to decision making for urban infrastructures.

    How to cite: Kaandorp, C., van de Giesen, N., and Abraham, E.: Integrated assessment of renewable urban heating systems considering water use, committed emissions and energy justice, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3637, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3637, 2022.

    Nature-based solutions (NbS) in brook catchments are considered as climate measures to adapt to hydro-meteorological extremes (storms, floods, droughts) and human-induced water demand. These NbS, often wetlands at multiple scales, cause land-use change (LUC), e.g., from cropland into wetland. Furthermore, LUC is also caused by other anthropogenic reasons (e.g., urbanization, channeling).

    To improve this modelling by incorporating multi-scale spatial and temporal aspects, earlier studies modelled LUC and carbon pools, but did this without a regional focus on the impact of NbS. A system analysis of a brook catchment (Dutch Aa/Weerijs; 147 km2; S of Breda)  determines the spatio-temporal dynamics of LUC and its connection to carbon pools including the climate mitigation impact of NbS. The question arises if ready-to-use tools can help to connect the associated spatio-temporal datasets, to support professionals in regional development on rapid appraisal of carbon pool dynamics and impacts of NbS.

    Firstly, in a pilot study, a system analysis of LUC and temporal carbon pool data has been developed on open access datasets (e.g., open topo and land registry). To get an outlook for 2050, 1960 was taken as a starting point because the brook catchment, including the brook itself, transformed just after 1960. To determine historic spatio-temporal dynamics of LUC and carbon pools, 2010 was chosen. Then, the landscape is predicted for 2050 in two scenarios: A Technical/physical scenario (in which a business-as-usual situation is considered) and a NbS/Wetlands scenario which focusses on NbS and in particular on wetlands. Four terrestrial carbon pools within seven land-use categories have been used. Land-use classification for 1960 and 2010 has been done with topographic maps and ArcGIS. Land-use prediction for 2050 has been done with a Land Change Modeler (TerrSet2020, ClarkLabs) with land-use from 1960 and 2010 as input data.

    Secondly, the results of the pilot study have been validated by a field visit and regional professionals with expertise on LUC and carbon pools. As a third step, the updated, validated method has been applied to the whole Dutch catchment.

    Findings indicate that 40 km2 (≈ 27%) transformed between 1960 and 2010 with an impact on terrestrial carbon of + 0.5 Mton (≈ +50% change: 1 Mton in 1960 and 1.5 Mton in 2010). Findings for 2050 are:

    • For the Technical-physical scenario a minor increase of terrestrial carbon. This will probably be explained by settlement expansion and by the increase areal of tree nursery. Tree nursery is especially a land-use category that emerges in the study area.
    • For the NbS/Wetlands scenario, which emphasizes wetlands as nature-based solutions, a major increase of terrestrial carbon. This is explained by the increase of the areal of wetlands.

    In this study we presented an approach where a combination of tools - a land change modeler and ArcGIS - can be used for a rapid assessment of mitigating effects on climate adaptation measures. This offers water professionals the opportunity to meet the many challenges on NbS in brook/river basins.

    How to cite: Timmer, L., Van Wijnen, J., and Lansu, A.: Nature-based solutions in brook catchments: Modelling land-use change and its impact on terrestrial carbon pools (1960 – 2010 – 2050)., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4006, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4006, 2022.

    EGU22-6964 | Presentations | HS5.5 | Highlight

    Global emission trade market design and local outcomes on the water-energy-land nexus 

    Mel George, Sha Yu, Leon Clarke, and Jae Edmonds

    The COP26 in Glasgow produced a Paris Agreement rulebook for international cooperation through carbon markets under Article 6. The intent of Article 6 is to enhance mitigation ambition by utilizing efficiency gains from trading and to cooperatively implement nationally determined contributions (NDCs) while avoiding double-counting. Such international emissions trading forms the bedrock to mobilize public and private sector investment flows to meet ambitious climate goals. At the same time, a growing body of research concludes that there are important links between mitigation and other societal objectives, such as those embodied in the UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). Such local and national decisions which consider co-benefits and tradeoffs on some of the SDGs, in turn, are critical in deciding the aggregate success and consequences of global policies. This raises the question of how emissions trading may enable or hinder SDG attainment and how different countries might value their participation in such markets.

     

    Countries view their own climate mitigation efforts through a more comprehensive lens than mere emissions reduction, and the links with societal outcomes would influence their consideration of comparability and participation in emissions trading markets. The success of these markets in enhancing ambition would depend on perceptions of the relationships of mitigation with local and regional societal goals around water, energy & land use. The degree of congruence between these relationships could influence future climate negotiations and market design.

     

    In this paper, using a global integrated assessment model (GCAM: Global Change Analysis Model, ver. 5.4), we demonstrate that spatial and temporal distributions of the influence of Article 6 emissions markets on a subset of the broader SDGs may differ. We use a subset of sustainability metrics related to the energy-water-land nexus issues. Our analysis of these metrics tracks the interconnected nature of human and earth systems under different emission market designs for 10 key geographical regions (USA, EU, China, India, Japan, Brazil, Russia, Australia, Sub-Saharan Africa & Latin America) from 2030 to 2050, under a consistent integrated framework. This allows us to assess the local implications of emissions market design on energy access, prices & security, water consumption for different applications, food prices and forest area changes. We include the effects of redistribution and international financial transfers. We demonstrate these effects on the energy-water-land nexus for different national and global mitigation scenarios: the recently updated NDCs, a net zero emissions target in 2050 and a scenario which allows countries to reach net zero goals based on equity principles.    

     

    Our results imply that global cooperation in markets can be altered if interactions between mitigation and local effects on the energy-water-land triad were accounted for. Furthermore, we demonstrate that the extent to which these distributions differ depends on market design and pricing of nature-based mitigation options.

     

    Our analysis provides a foundation for assessing how global emission market schemes under Article 6 could be better understood in the local developmental contexts of energy, water & land use changes.

    How to cite: George, M., Yu, S., Clarke, L., and Edmonds, J.: Global emission trade market design and local outcomes on the water-energy-land nexus, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6964, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6964, 2022.

    EGU22-9311 | Presentations | HS5.5 | Highlight

    Trade-offs between water needs for food, utilities, and the environment—a nexus quantification at different scales 

    Lotte de Vos, Hester Biemans, Jonathan C Doelman, Elke Stehfest, and Detlef P van Vuuren

    With a growing population and a changing climate, competition for water resources in the water-energy-food (WEF) nexus is expected to increase. In this study, competing water demands between food production, freshwater ecosystems and utilities (energy, industries and households) are quantified. The potential trade-offs and related impacts are elaborated for different SSP scenarios with the integrated assessment model IMAGE, which includes the global vegetation and hydrology model Lund-Potsdam-Jena managed Land (LPJmL). Results for the 2045–2054 period are evaluated at the global scale and for a selection of 14 hotspot basins and coastal zones. On the global scale, we estimate that an additional 1.7 billion people could potentially face severe water shortage for electricity, industries and households if food production and environmental flows would be prioritized. Zooming in on the hotspots, this translates to up to 70% of the local population. Results furthermore show that up to 33% of river length in the hotspots risks not meeting environmental targets when prioritizing other water demands in the nexus. For local food production, up to 41% might be lost due to competing water demands. The potential trade-offs quantified in this study highlight the competition for resources in the WEF nexus, for which impacts are most notably felt at local scales. This emphasizes the need to simultaneously consider different dimensions of the nexus when developing scenarios that aim to achieve multiple sustainability targets.

    How to cite: de Vos, L., Biemans, H., Doelman, J. C., Stehfest, E., and van Vuuren, D. P.: Trade-offs between water needs for food, utilities, and the environment—a nexus quantification at different scales, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9311, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9311, 2022.

    EGU22-10568 | Presentations | HS5.5

    High-resolution water temperature impact assessment on thermal power plants operations in Europe and riverine ecosystems 

    Marko Adamovic, Ad de Roo, Berny Bisselink, and Bruna Grizzetti

    Thermal power plants consume large amounts of water for electricity generation, mainly for cooling purposes that is later discharged back to riverine eco-systems. Increase in water temperature of the river systems and oceans is becoming the real environmental challenge to tackle, posed by the accelerated changes in climate change.  

    In this study, new high-resolution data set of the water temperature projections of the main rivers in Europe due to climate change has been created using the new LISTEMP water resources model. We developed the new model called LISTEMP as a result of online coupling between the LISFLOOD open source hydrological model and newly developed water temperature module that runs on a 5 km grid and solved using a semi-Lagrangian numerical scheme. The results are based on 11 climate models which project current and future climate under two Representative Concentration Pathways (RCPs): RCP4.5 and RCP 8.5 emission scenario. We assess thermal plant's vulnerability to water temperature changes as climate change continues.  

    We conclude that operations and maintenance of many thermal power plants could be at risk due to the water temperature change since their efficiency and performance depend mostly on a possibility to intake huge quantities of cooling water. Furthermore, we identified the hot spots in Europe where current power plants urge for technological change in order to be more resilient to climate. We also detect spots where plants are returning water at a temperature above the ecologically desirable ranges due to climate change. Knowledge acquired in this study and dataset contribute to multi-scale water-energy-food nexus and Common Fisheries Policy for conserving fish stocks with future climate.

     

    How to cite: Adamovic, M., de Roo, A., Bisselink, B., and Grizzetti, B.: High-resolution water temperature impact assessment on thermal power plants operations in Europe and riverine ecosystems, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10568, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10568, 2022.

    EGU22-10882 | Presentations | HS5.5

    Integrating climate impacts across energy, water, land systems within a global framework 

    Muhammad Awais, Adriano Vinca, Edward Byers, Oliver Fricko, Stefan Frank, Yusuke Satoh, Volker Krey, and Keywan Riahi

    IIASA’s Integrated Assessment Model (IAM), MESSAGEix-GLOBIOM is used in various assessments to understand scenarios of socio-economic development within the energy and land systems across scales (global, country, basin). However, the representation of climate impacts and water systems within IAMs until now has been limited. The study goes a step forward on improving the representation of climate impacts and the capability to analyze interactions between population, economic growth, energy, land, and water resources in a dynamic system simultaneously. It uses spatially resolved representation of water systems to retain hydrological information without compromising computational complexity, and simplified water availability and key infrastructure assumptions mapped with the energy and land systemsThe results from this study inform the required regional and sectoral investments pathways across mitigation and non-mitigation pathways. The results also highlight the importance of water as a constraint in energy and land-use decisions and implications of global responses to the limited water availability from water resources – renewable water, non-renewable groundwater, desalinated water 

    How to cite: Awais, M., Vinca, A., Byers, E., Fricko, O., Frank, S., Satoh, Y., Krey, V., and Riahi, K.: Integrating climate impacts across energy, water, land systems within a global framework, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10882, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10882, 2022.

    EGU22-10955 | Presentations | HS5.5

    Causality Analysis in the Water-Energy-Food Nexus in the Canadian Prairies 

    Behdad Saed, Amin Elshorbagy, and Saman Razavi

    As global water, energy, and food (WEF) demands are continuously increasing because of population growth, climate change, and the modernization of the human lifestyle, sustainable resource management is of prime importance. Societies have been struggling with the planning and management of WEF resources under changing population, climate, and ecosystem. Integrated resource management is essential to achieve optimal and sustainable WEF management as sector-centric (e.g. water-centric) management can lead to poor outcome. To that end, WEF nexus as a multi-centric approach has been introduced to emphasize interlinkages among WEF sectors. Such interlinkages need to be identified, quantified, and analyzed to facilitate sustainable WEF resources management.

    This study aims to conduct a quantitative data analysis within the WEF nexus context to identify the interrelationships among WEF sectors and to understand how each sector interacts with other sectors in the Canadian Prairie provinces (Alberta, Saskatchewan, and Manitoba) individually, and as a whole over the period 1990-2020. Historical data used in this study are at annual temporal and provincial spatial resolution. A correlation-and-causality analysis has been conducted for different pairs of WEF sectors to measure the degree of relationships and to explore the cause-and-effects between each pair of sectors. The Multispatial Convergent Cross Mapping method, as a causal inference tool, has been used for identifying and assessing the causal relations. Determining the causal relationships among WEF sectors helps researchers identify critical components, of a large and complex system, for further investigation and modelling. It can also guide policy-makers for better allocation of resources.

    Results showed that water has a stronger influence on food and energy than the other way around in the upstream province of Alberta. It was also found that food had more influence on energy than the other way around in the three prairie provinces. This study is a step forward toward a better understanding of the WEF nexus by using causal inference methods for tracking the strength of interactions to identify dominant sectors at both the provincial and regional scales. This can help build more parsimonious and efficient WEF nexus models for further simulation and scenario analysis.

    How to cite: Saed, B., Elshorbagy, A., and Razavi, S.: Causality Analysis in the Water-Energy-Food Nexus in the Canadian Prairies, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10955, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10955, 2022.

    EGU22-11545 | Presentations | HS5.5

    Integrated surface and groundwater resources management in a coastal aquifer (Cap BonPeninsula-NE of Tunisia) 

    Ichrak Khammessi, Serge Brouyère, Jalel Aouissi, adel zghibi, Ali Mirchi, Anis Chkirbene, Amira Merzougui, Mohamed Haythem Msaddek, and Hamadi Habaieb

    Coastal aquifers are usually the main source of water supply for irrigation, drinking
    and industrial purposes in coastal regions. They are often subject to overexploitation and
    consequent quantitative and qualitative degradation. The groundwater flow system of the Chiba
    watershed in the CapBon peninsula (NE of Tunisia) is a typical case of an overexploited aquifer,
    where a piezometric depression exceeding -10 m (a.m.s.l) appeared has developed over the two
    last decades. Among the numerous remediation tentatives, the SMART-WATER project aimed
    to propose a remediation plan based on a smart monitoring and water-energy nexus solution
    through the installation of smart energy and water meters (SEWM). This technology aims to
    optimize groundwater pumping at a set of selected representative farming systems in the
    watershed. In this context, a first coupled surface water-groundwater flow model has been
    developed and applied, coupled with energy nexus for the irrigated Chiba plain. The model is
    implemented using a dynamic coupling between MODFLOW WEAP and LEAP in order to
    assess the SEWM system efficiency in reducing aquifer exploitation and electrical energy
    consumption at farm level. Multi-objective calibration of the model using river discharge and
    GW level data has yielded accurate simulation of historical conditions, and resulted in better-
    constrained parameters compared to using either data source alone. Model simulations show that
    crop water demand cannot be met during droughts due to limited GW pumping capacity, and that
    increased GW pumping has a relatively strong impact on GW levels due to the small specific
    yield of the aquifer. Groundwater and energy models have also revealed that, under different
    management and climatic scenarios, electric energy consumption and groundwater table decline
    are intricately connected. Despite the short monitoring period and the intermittence of the
    received data, SEWMs have shown a promising role in monitoring groundwater pumping and
    engaging farmers in energy saving and aquifer sustainability.

    How to cite: Khammessi, I., Brouyère, S., Aouissi, J., zghibi, A., Mirchi, A., Chkirbene, A., Merzougui, A., Msaddek, M. H., and Habaieb, H.: Integrated surface and groundwater resources management in a coastal aquifer (Cap BonPeninsula-NE of Tunisia), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11545, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11545, 2022.

    EGU22-12998 | Presentations | HS5.5 | Highlight

    Exploring Uncertainty Surrounding Deep Decarbonization Pathways: Application to Colombia 

    Mengqi Zhao, Thomas Wild, Brinda Yarlagadda, Leon Clarke, and Gokul Iyer

    Limiting end-of-century temperature rise to 1.5-2 degrees C will require achieving net-zero CO2 emissions globally by 2050. Toward this goal, the Government of Colombia (GoC) is crafting a portfolio of actions (i.e., a mid-century strategy) that will not only substantially reduce emissions but also perform well across a range of societal objectives, despite the many uncertainties to which those actions will be exposed. In collaboration with a diverse array of stakeholders, here we seek to discover which actions hold promise for Colombia to achieve its climate and other societal objectives under a range of future uncertainties. The most effective mix of actions from Colombia’s perspective maybe those that create a solid near-term foundation for future ambitious action, and also those that avoid poor performance (across multiple societal objectives) under future uncertainty. This presentation will identify key elements of a robust decarbonization strategy for Colombia, and understand which sources of uncertainty may be critical to acknowledge and better understand.

    It is not possible to assign meaningful probabilities to scenarios that consist of complex combinations of policy actions (i.e., levers) and uncertainties. However, it is possible to discover which scenarios, or combinations of levers and uncertainties, drive consequential outcomes across societal objectives. We use the “XLRM” conceptual organizing framework for defining this immense challenge and its possible solutions in Colombia, including: policy levers ("L"), such as renewable portfolio standards and electric vehicles deployment; future uncertainties ("X") such as socioeconomic change, technological change, and climatic change; and metrics ("M") for evaluating the relevant societal outcomes that result from the implementation of levers in uncertain future worlds, such as air quality, food security, water security, energy access, land use change, and economic development. To map policy levers to key outcomes (metrics) under uncertainty, we use the Global Change Analysis Model (GCAM) v5.3 to explore the order of 10,000 GCAM scenarios reflecting diverse futures. The study focuses on a set of questions, and a methodological approach, that have immediate relevance to Colombia but also broader applications both within Latin America and beyond to the rest of the world.

    How to cite: Zhao, M., Wild, T., Yarlagadda, B., Clarke, L., and Iyer, G.: Exploring Uncertainty Surrounding Deep Decarbonization Pathways: Application to Colombia, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12998, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12998, 2022.

    EGU22-1584 | Presentations | HS5.6

    Impact of land-use/cover changes due to urbanization on groundwater recharge by precipitation in South Korea 

    Junyong Heo, Seongwoo Jeong, Seoggan Jang, Linn Kim, Daewoong Kwon, and Minjune Yang

    Due to urbanization, land use and cover change (LUCC) are considered one of the concerns in groundwater recharge by precipitation because urban development increases impermeable surfaces. The main objective of this study is to investigate the effects of LUCC on groundwater recharge by precipitation in South Korea. Ten monitoring wells were selected based on a significant difference in LUCC using Arc-GIS software. Then lag-time between precipitation and groundwater level response was estimated based on correlation coefficients computed from cross-correlation function (CCF) and moving average (MA) for 3 years before and after LUCC. As a result of the estimated lag-time, monitoring wells were classified into two groups: group Ⅰ (n = 3) with more than 30% increase in the impermeable surface and group Ⅱ (n = 7) with less than 30% increase in the impermeable surface. Group I showed a significant increase in lag-time computed from MA (28 to 127 days) and CCF (6 to 19 days), while group II showed no significant difference in lag-time. The results of this study indicate that groundwater recharge is regulated by the occurrence of the impermeable surface, interrupting direct groundwater recharge from rainwater infiltration.

    How to cite: Heo, J., Jeong, S., Jang, S., Kim, L., Kwon, D., and Yang, M.: Impact of land-use/cover changes due to urbanization on groundwater recharge by precipitation in South Korea, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1584, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1584, 2022.

    In eastern Germany, the Czech Republic, and Slovakia, historic policies have led to large, monocropped agricultural landscapes resulting in degradation of traditional landscapes with impacts on the local water and climate cycles. In the last 20 years, the expansion of urban and industrial areas has added to this landscape degradation. The growing interest in nature-based solutions, including landscape-based water-retention measures, is a response to reversing landscape degradation, rejuvenating ecosystem services, and mitigating the impacts of large-scale commercial agriculture and climate change. In this study, the costs and benefits of water-retention measures in east Germany, the Czech Republic, and Slovakia are assessed. Results indicate that water-retention measures, should they be implemented throughout the study area, offer potentially increased water availability over all land use classes assessed, help to increase local crop productivity, and aid in local landscape cooling. Croplands are suggested as being the best value for money, offering the greatest volume potentials (mean = 88 million m3), cooling effects (mean = -1.6°C), and productivity gains (mean = €66 million yr-1), while also being the cheapest to implement per unit area. Differing policies in the three states will likely result in non-uniform selection or implementation of measures. Future research should focus on local-level studies offering greater practical messages beyond the regional-level analysis conducted in this work, as well as ways towards harmonising policy across the states. This work contributes to the growing body of literature assessing the costs and benefits of water-retention measures, including the potential for landscape cooling, lowering temperature gradients, and ecosystem restoration. As the world urbanises, and as more land is converted to homogeneous cropland, such measures may prove critical in mitigating climate change, landscape drying, flood runoff, and soil and nutrient loss.

    How to cite: Susnik, J., Masia, S., Kravčík, M., Pokorný, J., and Hesslerová, P.: Estimating the costs and benefits of landscape-based water retention measures as nature-based solutions to mitigating climate impacts in eastern Germany, the Czech Republic, and Slovakia, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1636, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1636, 2022.

    EGU22-3945 | Presentations | HS5.6

    Sustainable runoff management using spatial modeling and multi-objective optimization 

    Merav Tal-maon, Dani Broitman, Michelle Portman, and Mashor Housh

    The rise in urbanization and the potential effects of climate change have increased the risk of flooding. Water Sensitive Planning (WSP) is a novel development approach combining regional and urban planning with water resources management. WSP aims to reduce stormwater's adverse effects, enhance potential hydrological ecosystem services, and treat stormwater as a resource rather than a hazard. This method considers various structural solutions (e.g., wetlands, permeable pavement, swales) to increase infiltration and water detention/retention.

    These solutions need to be part of a regional-based strategy for maximum effectiveness. A spatial modeling tool can be used to simulate and quantify the effects of different solutions according to the characteristics of each place. The results of the simulation can then feed an optimization problem. This research aims to develop a holistic, simple-to-use methodology for surface runoff management by combining spatial modeling and multi-objective optimization. This methodology will be capable of considering various and sometimes conflicting hydrological, ecological, social, and economic goals.

    We consider a realistic case study of the Tavor subbasin of the Jordan South watershed in Israel, using two different hydrological modeling tools: OpenNSPECT and SWAT. In the OpenNSPECT model, we divided the watershed into land parcels; then introduced a water detention-based solution to each parcel. We used the results to construct a Pareto optimum frontier to indicate the optimal placement for reducing runoff and sediment in key flood-sensitive areas. The SWAT model was used to compute annual average runoff and sediment. We then used this data as input for the systematic conservation software MARXAN to identify areas of an effective trade-off between hydrologic ecosystem services (runoff and sediment retention) and alternative land-use costs. We provide insight into the different solutions yielded by these two approaches and discuss the advantages, disadvantages, and possible future use.

    How to cite: Tal-maon, M., Broitman, D., Portman, M., and Housh, M.: Sustainable runoff management using spatial modeling and multi-objective optimization, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3945, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3945, 2022.

    EGU22-4846 | Presentations | HS5.6 | Highlight

    Advancing the modeling of land use and land cover change impacts on water resources 

    Paul Wagner and Nicola Fohrer

    Land use and land cover (LULC) change is one of the most important drivers of global change and has strong impacts on water resources. Analyzing these impacts in space and time requires appropriate monitoring and modeling approaches. In particular, interactions between land and water resources need to be better represented in modeling approaches to allow for a consistent assessment of impacts. Therefore, it is necessary to move from static to dynamic representations of LULC in hydrologic models. Moreover, modeling of LULC impacts on water resources can be further advanced by coupling LULC and hydrologic models. A coupled modeling approach enables us to consider feedback effects as well as to take management decisions into account. The benefits of a coupled modeling approach are demonstrated by coupling the hydrologic model SWAT with the LULC model CLUE-s for a meso-scale catchment in India. The coupling of the two models allows for a better representation of spatial dynamics and management decisions during a model run. Moreover, by using the example of cropland abandonment, we show the potential of the coupled modeling approach to address topics like the water-energy-food nexus and climate resilience.

    How to cite: Wagner, P. and Fohrer, N.: Advancing the modeling of land use and land cover change impacts on water resources, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4846, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4846, 2022.

    EGU22-6476 | Presentations | HS5.6

    A global gridded monthly water withdrawal dataset for multiple sectors from 2015 to 2100 at 0.5° resolution under a range of socioeconomic and climate scenarios 

    Zarrar Khan, Isaac Thompson, Chris Vernon, Neal Graham, Tom Wild, and Min Chen

    Future sectoral-specific water withdrawals at a temporal resolution capable of representing patterns in seasonality and a commonly used spatial resolution are an important factor to consider for energy, water, land and environmental research.  Projected water withdrawals that are harmonized with assumptions for alternate futures that capture socioeconomic and climatic variation are critical for many modeling studies on future global and regional dynamics. Here we generate a novel global gridded water withdrawals dataset by coupling Global Change Analysis Model (GCAM) with a land use spatial downscaling model (Demeter), a global hydrologic framework (Xanthos) and a water withdrawal downscaling model (Tethys) for the five Shared Socioeconomic Pathways (SSPs) and four Representative Concentration Pathways (RCPs) scenarios. The dataset provides sectoral monthly data at 0.5° resolution for years 2015 to 2100. The presented dataset will be useful for both global and regional analysis looking at the impacts of socioeconomic, climate and technological futures as well as in characterizing the uncertainties associated with these impacts.

    How to cite: Khan, Z., Thompson, I., Vernon, C., Graham, N., Wild, T., and Chen, M.: A global gridded monthly water withdrawal dataset for multiple sectors from 2015 to 2100 at 0.5° resolution under a range of socioeconomic and climate scenarios, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6476, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6476, 2022.

    EGU22-7398 | Presentations | HS5.6 | Highlight

    Sea-land transitions in food supply across global deltas 

    Maria J. Santos, Martin O. Reader, and Maartje Oostdijk

    River deltas represent globally important population centres and areas for food production, embedded on a nexus of land-water production. Yet pressures at the sea-land interface in these coastal areas are increasing from population growth, economic expansion and climate change. Over time, delta human populations have shifted from sea to land-based food production, the former more associated with local communities’ subsistence and the latter with exports of food products elsewhere leading to potentially irreversible land use-land cover changes (LULCC). While livelihood diversification by switching between or including both sea and land food production systems, could promote resilience and increase food security, food production based on sea and land-based resources has seldom been addressed in tandem, and potential unintended spill-over effects and LULCC may emerge which may jeopardise both. Here we examine the extent to which deltas have food production systems based on sea and land-based food sources (biomass, calories and protein) and which factors could drive these relationships, as transitions between sea and land food production in deltas may have local and global food security implications.

    We use global datasets across 235 large deltas, which include information on food biomass, calories and proteins from sea (fishing and aquaculture) and land (crops and livestock) production systems. Based on these indicators of food production, we calculated a sea:land ratio to examine to what extent food production of each delta is weighted towards the sea or land. We find clear geographical patterns in the sea:land food production ratio in global deltas: the majority of the deltas exhibit a dominance of sea-based food production (particularly those at higher latitudes) while the deltas in most of Europe, Central and Southern America, show a dominance of land-based food production. We found similar geographical patterns for biomass, calories and protein, with the relationship being stronger for protein than biomass or calories. We then examined how the sea:land ratio changes along gradients of human population density, and condition of the local ecosystems. Surprisingly, we found no relationship between population density and the sea:land ratio, indicating other factors may be at play (e.g., local context). Indeed, we found that as food production is mostly due to land contributions (i.e., the lower the sea:land ratio) the stronger the negative relationships with ecosystem conditions such as biodiversity intactness, soil and water quality. These results suggest that transitions between sea and land food production and subsequent LULCC can therefore be both complex and problematic in deltas globally, as these may represent switches in not just biomass but also nutritional quality, and may have severe implications for local ecosystem health and functioning. Increasing our understanding of what drives these transitions and associated LULCC at the nexus between land-water, and their effects, will allow more sustainable management of coupled food production systems and associated earth system processes.

    How to cite: Santos, M. J., Reader, M. O., and Oostdijk, M.: Sea-land transitions in food supply across global deltas, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7398, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7398, 2022.

    EGU22-9675 | Presentations | HS5.6

    Modelling the impacts of water harvesting and climate change on rainfed maize yields in Senegal 

    Giulio Castelli, Andrea Setti, Lorenzo Villani, Roberto Ferrise, and Elena Bresci

    The agricultural sector of Senegal is prone to drought and climate change impacts. Despite this, the country counts less than 5% of irrigated lands, suggesting that its national agriculture is still strictly dependent on the rainy season. Moreover, rainfall is characterized by the presence of great variability, both on interannual and interdecadal timescales. In this framework, a research gap is represented by the lack of analyses on how much the current agricultural practices can be resilient, and on what water management strategies can be effective against climate change.

    Using FAO’s AquaCrop crop-growth model, made up of a set of four sub-model components (climate, crop, soil, and management) to simulate a crop cycle, we simulated plausible climate change scenarios at different fertility levels, testing the efficiency of tied ridges water harvesting for the maize crop in the Fatick region, Senegal. Non-conservative parameters were adjusted with crop data collected within the project "Rain, Forest and People" of the International Rainwater Harvesting Alliance (IRHA, https://www.irha-h2o.org/en/projects/la-pluie-la-foret-et-les-hommes) while calibration and validation were performed with regional yield data.

    Considering the current climatic scenario and soil fertility, tied ridges did not significantly impact the maize yields. Rainfall amount was enough for maize production and to avoid high water stresses along the cropping season. Under climate change scenarios, high reductions in yield were registered up to 70% in optimally fertilized soil and 50% in conditions of fertility stress.  Tied ridges only slightly increased yields up to 3.8% when a high reduction of rainfall occurred. When also considering the occurrence of dry spells in addition to climate change, maximum yield reductions do not exceed the values found without dry spells. However, in such context, tied ridges water harvesting performed better against climate change, especially under full fertilization management.

    Our results highlighted how the current maize production in the Fatick region of Senegal is sustainable in the current climate scenario, while it could be potentially impacted by climate change in the near future. In a pessimistic climate change scenario with dry spells occurring in the rainy season, in-situ water harvesting has the potentiality to avoid excessive crop losses.

    How to cite: Castelli, G., Setti, A., Villani, L., Ferrise, R., and Bresci, E.: Modelling the impacts of water harvesting and climate change on rainfed maize yields in Senegal, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9675, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9675, 2022.

    The anthropogenic influences, allied with land-use dynamics, induce the spatial variability of the constituents by overall altering the groundwater qualitative status. It is one of the pertinent linkages, that is seldomly discussed, and in turn, would highlight an insight into the potent pollution sources, pathways, and emergent plumes for accretion or dilution effects in groundwater hydrochemistry. A case study was attempted for assessing the spatial variability of groundwater quality (within shallow aquifers) in the populous Ghaziabad district of western Uttar Pradesh of India. A total number of 26 sampling sites were analyzed for quality parameters such as major cations, anions, and heavy metals for pre-and post-monsoon seasons for two consecutive years (2017&2018). The magnitude of accretion and dilution effects in groundwater were estimated by using a numerical method of Normalized Difference Dispersal Index (NDDI), which targets the site-specific variability of the quality constituents in terms of degree and space. The index value for each constituent parameter was profiled by using geostatistical mapping (ordinary kriging) and further, validated for the spatial pattern through Global Moran’s I. For a plausible comparison, NDDI spatial maps were analyzed with land use indices, namely, Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI), Normalized Differential Salinity Index (NDSI), Normalized Difference Built-Up Index (NDBI), and Modified Normalized Difference Water Index (MNDWI), to predict the influence sources of accretion or dilution effects of the constituents in the groundwater quality. The obtained results have shown that the NDDI method coupled with land use indices, in the spatial extent, has profoundly estimated the plumes of abundant accretion/dilution of the quality parameters and hotspots were preferably found within the urbanized & highly populated as well as irrigating fields (peri-urban regions) of Ghaziabad district. The study concludes that spatial variations of groundwater quality are easy to comprehend and would pertinently assess the quality control while delivering groundwater monitoring & management strategies for predicting the impacts arising from land-use influences within the regional/localized studies.

    How to cite: Tyagi, S. and Sarma, K.: Spatial variability assessment of groundwater quality dispersion with reference to land-use indices, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10317, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10317, 2022.

    EGU22-10578 | Presentations | HS5.6

    Assessing land use impacts on catchment hydrology with participatory monitoring: lessons for experimental design, network building, and policy support 

    Wouter Buytaert, Luis Acosta, Fabian Drenkhan, Katya Perez, Javier Antiporta, and Boris Ochoa Tocachi

    Many regions in the world face declining water availability and increasing water-related risks, as a result of pressures such as environmental degradation, global warming, and population growth. Sustainable and integrated land management is an important tools to improve and safeguard catchment water resources, and to minimize flood and drought risk. However, land management to optimise water security is still severely hindered by a lack of hydrological information about the impact of different management practices on the catchment hydrological response. Statutory hydrological monitoring networks tend to be sparse in most of the world, and focused on operational purposes such as water supply and flood risk. Here we present the case of iMHEA, a participatory hydrological monitoring network in the tropical Andes that aims at characterising the hydrological impact of different land management practices in the upper Andes, especially conservation, livestock grazing, and forestry. The network monitors currently 59 catchments in 22 Andean sites from Venezuela to Chile. It operates as a community of practice, exchanging experimental designs, technical expertise on monitoring equipment, protocols, and experience. It largely follows a pairwise catchment comparison approach, which has been able to show statistically significant trends in land-use impacts on flow characteristics such as runoff ratio, baseflow index, and slope of the flow duration curve. Thanks to rigorous technical support, the generated data are generally of high scientific quality and reliability. The involvement of stakeholders with a policy background, such as NGOs and government agencies, is key to dissemination and operational uptake of the scientific results. As such, iMHEA can be considered a success story, which has created a step change in scientific evidence for land use planning in the Andes. However, several challenges remain. One is the experimental design, which is not yet able to accommodate all the specific interests and challenges that iMHEA members are faced with. Longevity and long-term financial sustainability also remains a major challenge. Lastly, improvements are needed to process and dissimenate the results to specific stakeholders, and especially local communities and governments.

    How to cite: Buytaert, W., Acosta, L., Drenkhan, F., Perez, K., Antiporta, J., and Ochoa Tocachi, B.: Assessing land use impacts on catchment hydrology with participatory monitoring: lessons for experimental design, network building, and policy support, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10578, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10578, 2022.

    EGU22-11203 | Presentations | HS5.6

    Re-designing the urban water cycle: Towards Water-Age-Neutral Habitats 

    Paolo Benettin, Martina Barcelloni Corte, Cédric Wehrle, and Chris Soulsby

    Knowledge of how to articulate the “urban transition” is today urgently needed. Urbanization is on a steadily growing trend that impacts the water cycle as a whole. However, while the effects of urbanised/urbanising areas on water quantity (how much water) have been well studied for flood prevention, other effects –as those related to water quality (which water)– are less known. Taking hold from the most recent developments on the “water age” concept, i.e. the time that water resides in the landscape before exiting as runoff or evaporation, we propose a proof-of-concept study on the notion of “water-age-neutral” design. This concept envisions the possibility of lowering –through design– net impacts on the City-Territory’s “natural” water age balance. To do this, we selected 4 representative areas of 250x250 meters within the Panke watershed, in the metropolitan area of Berlin (DE), which are characterized by specific land-use/urban form patterns (industry, single family housing, residential slabs and residential open block housing). For these 4 areas, we used an ecohydrological model to analyse a set of water/land use interaction patterns and their outputs in terms of water flow partitioning and water age. We use such outputs to evaluate the broader impacts of land-use/urban form on the urban water cycle. These results are considered as a first step towards a larger evaluation of the multiple relationships between land-use/urban form and the water cycle as a whole.

    How to cite: Benettin, P., Barcelloni Corte, M., Wehrle, C., and Soulsby, C.: Re-designing the urban water cycle: Towards Water-Age-Neutral Habitats, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11203, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11203, 2022.

    EGU22-12434 | Presentations | HS5.6

    Evaluating the Water Ecosystem Services Footprint to support agricultural water management in Central Italy: a watershed scale approach 

    Tommaso Pacetti, Giulio Castelli, Boris Schroeder, Elena Bresci, and Enrica Caporali

    The application of Water-related Ecosystem Services (WES) concept in water resources planning can support the development of productive activities and, at the same time, sustain local ecosystems. Gaining insights into the ecohydrological behavior of a basin and the anthropogenic pressures on the available water resources requires the spatial explicit evaluation of WES for the identification of the strategies to explore the sustainable coupling of biosphere and anthroposphere. By integrating hydrological modelling and Water Footprint (WF) analysis, this study aims at evaluating a Water Ecosystem Services Footprint (WESF) associated with the agricultural sector analyzing both the supply and demand of WES.

    Combining the evaluation of WES demand, determined by the agricultural sector using the WF assessment methodology and the quantification of WES supply by applying the Soil Water Assessment Tool (SWAT), the proposed methodology introduces green, blue, and gray WESF indicators to identify the main hotspots connected to the agricultural production. The methodology is applied to a specific case study in the upstream part of the Arno River basin (Central Italy).

    WESF represents an operative tool to look at agricultural water management from an ecosystem-based perspective, introducing a useful approach that potentially can be extended to different sectors. The results allow the evaluation of WESF spatial pattern, identifying the most critical areas in the catchment and supporting a stronger integration of water management with ecosystems conservation.

    How to cite: Pacetti, T., Castelli, G., Schroeder, B., Bresci, E., and Caporali, E.: Evaluating the Water Ecosystem Services Footprint to support agricultural water management in Central Italy: a watershed scale approach, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12434, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12434, 2022.

    Science-informed models provided undoubtable indications of the crucial interlinkages that govern the Water, Energy, Food and Ecosystem (WEFE) dynamics. Managing natural and urban ecosystems without considering WEFE interlinkages may determine undesirable consequences in terms of safety and sustainability from multiple perspectives (e.g. environmental, social, economic). From short term operations to long term projections, science evidences depict the pivotal importance and multiple benefits of embracing WEFE Nexus approaches. Nevertheless, while science and technological advancements are pushing ahead such understanding, several technical and non-technical barriers still avoid the WEFE Nexus transition. WEFE-related Multi-Sector, Multi-Disciplinary and Multi-Actor cross-cooperation and mutual trust are still lacking in actual water and land management strategies. Moreover, stakeholders and citizens are not adequately informed and involved. WEFE Nexus policies are also generally missing.

    The NEXUS Nature Ecosystem Society Solution or NEXUS-NESS project - funded by the PRIMA Programme under the 2020 Nexus Innovation Action - seeks to address this issue of paramount importance for the Mediterranean regions. NEXUS-NESS aims to co-produce and co-test with stakeholders WEFE Nexus management plans for fair and sustainable allocation of resources. At the same time a technological solution and tailored procedures are co-tested to provide actionable information and easy-to-follow guidelines for WEFE Nexus operators and stakeholders in selected case studies.

    This contribution aims to specifically focus on the transdisciplinarity concept that was a guiding principle of the NEXUS-NESS project design and mission. The NEXUS-NESS solution transdisciplinary datasets and tools seek to interlink the WEF Nexus components with a three-fold conceptualization of the Ecosystem component (Environment, Economy, Engagement/Society). NEXUS-NESS will operationalize the adoption of a WEFE Nexus bottom-up approach in four different case studies employing Living Lab and Responsible Research And Innovation (RRI) principles. Results from the first year of project development are here illustrated with specific focus on the the Val di Cornia (Italy), Duero basin (Spain), Wadi Naghamish (Egypt) and Wadi Jir basin (Tunisia) Nexus Ecosystem Lab (NELs) initiation activities and feedbacks co-processed with local and regional stakeholders.

    How to cite: Nardi, F. and the NEXUS-NESS Project team: Advancing transdisciplinary knowledge and procedures for mainstreaming WEFE Nexus: insights from the PRIMA NEXUS-NESS projects, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13291, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13291, 2022.

    EGU22-13353 | Presentations | HS5.6

    Land Use Changes and Ecosystem Services Supply in Transboundary River Basins. The Case of the Maroni River (French Guiana/Suriname) 

    Ina Maren Sieber, Sylvie Campagne, and Benjamin Burkhard

    The Maroni River in the Guiana Shield marks the border between  French Guiana and Suriname. In the Maroni River Basin, as in many transboundary river basins of the world, socio-political borders criss-cross through natural ecosystems and hence intersect through ecological boundaries. As neighbouring countries share ecosystems, they also share inherent ecosystem processes, functions and, hence, the ecosystem services (ES) that these areas provide. However, life and land uses are changing in the river basin. A growing need for land, urbanization, a decrease of shifting cultivation patterns towards smallholder agriculture and a run for gold put pressure on natural ecosystems.

    Our work on ES in this area was twofold: under the umbrella of the ECOSEO Project, we conducted a first ecosystem services assessment for the river basin, extracted from two national ES assessments on the base of Land Use Land Cover data. In participatory expert workshops in Paramaribo, Suriname and Cayenne, French Guiana, stakeholders from the territory assessed the capacity of abundant ecosystem types to supply 21 different ecosystem services using a matrix-based approach. A comparative assessment of workshop results showed that experts in both territories shared a similar understanding on ES supply capacities despite the different cultural and socio-political contexts of both territories. Whilst Suriname’s economy still depends on the primary sector and exploitation of natural resources, French Guiana as Outermost Region of the European Union has to adhere to the much stricter EU/French environmental legislation. Between 2015 to 2020, , land uses in Suriname changed much stronger then in French Guiana. Gold mining is the major driver for deforestation, especially on the Surinamese side of the river basin, followed by agricultural expansion. An overview of the ecosystem service bundles presents a snapshot of ecosystem service supply, and allows to quantify changes in ES supply.

    The expert-based matrix assessment showed direct changes in ES based on LULC changes, a qualitative assessment was added. We conducted 14 in depth interviews with local and indigenous population in the Upper Basin in 2019. Hereby, land use changes and their effects on ES supply were thematized. Illegal gold mining activities and intensification of agriculture were mentioned to contribute strongly to the degradation of ecosystems. Especially regulating ES in the Upper Maroni River were affected, with consequences on freshwater quality, supply of wild foods and fish and transportation for the entire lower River Basin.

    As LULC changes, especially gold mining-related activities, on both sides of the river have a severe degrading effect on ecosystem condition and related ES supply, cross- or transboundary conservation efforts are needed to safeguard ecosystems and their services for the population on both sides of the Maroni River.

    How to cite: Sieber, I. M., Campagne, S., and Burkhard, B.: Land Use Changes and Ecosystem Services Supply in Transboundary River Basins. The Case of the Maroni River (French Guiana/Suriname), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13353, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13353, 2022.

    EGU22-620 | Presentations | HS5.7

    Restoring the liver of the river: Instream wood as a nature-based solution to nutrient pollution in agricultural watercourses 

    Ben Howard, Ian Baker, Nick Kettridge, Sami Ullah, and Stefan Krause

    The hyporheic zone, the regions in the river sediment where surface water and groundwater interact, acts as the liver of the river that often can attenuate nutrients and other pollutants from mixing groundwater and river water. Nutrients can be retained and transformed by sediments to environmentally benign products (e.g. N2) by microbially mediated reactions. However, in most watercourses the capacity for this filtering function has been reduced by centuries of mismanagement such as channel straightening and the removal of instream wood and riparian buffers. The addition of instream wood, directly in restoration or indirectly by rewooding riparian zones, could restore the functioning of hyporheic zones and provide nature-based solutions to persistent water quality challenges.

    Nutrient transformation in the river corridor is limited by two primary mechanisms which could be abated by wood introductions. Firstly, reaction kinetics, including the availability and quality of organic matter. Here, the decomposition of wood could provide a local and sustained source of labile organic matter. Secondly, transport, namely the total flux of water into the hyporheic zone and its residence time therein. Instream wood causes an obstacle for river flow which can induce hyporheic exchange of suitable properties to allow favourable nutrient transformations.

    Here we present the results of two linked experiments which have been designed to investigate the effect of wood introductions at different scales: the microbial, restoration feature and reach scales. An incubation experiment focuses on the microbial scale, which allowed us to demonstrate that additions of wood to river sediments increases concentrations of dissolved organic carbon, leading to increased rates of nutrient transformation and increased microbial metabolic activity and production of greenhouse gases. The restoration feature and reach scale impacts are investigated using a before-after-control-intervention field experiment – including a series of smart tracer injections to estimate (metabolically active) transient storage. Preliminary results from this study suggest that wood introductions in river restoration increased reach-scale residence time and ecosystem metabolism, which are good indicators for reach scale nutrient turnover. 

    Our results could provide evidence that supports the use of wood in river restoration and of nature-based solutions to water quality challenges.

    How to cite: Howard, B., Baker, I., Kettridge, N., Ullah, S., and Krause, S.: Restoring the liver of the river: Instream wood as a nature-based solution to nutrient pollution in agricultural watercourses, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-620, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-620, 2022.

    EGU22-2204 | Presentations | HS5.7

    Terrestrial nutrient exports and environmental changes explain eutrophication trends in fifty large lakes of Yangtze Plain, China 

    Qi Guan, Jing Tang, Lian Feng, Stefan Olin, and Guy Schurgers

    Over the past two decades, lakes in Yangtze Plain have suffered from serious eutrophication, in some regions with increased frequency of cyanobacteria blooms over years. In this study, we investigated the underlying causes of eutrophication using a combination of process-based ecosystem modelling and statistical data analysis. We found that terrestrial nutrient exports with runoff have significantly increased from 1979 to 2018 in Yangtze Plain, directly linked to the enhanced usage of chemical fertilizer for crops. Based on statistical analyses of environmental variables, terrestrial nutrient exports and satellite-observed probability of eutrophication occurrence (PEO), we separated the studied fifty lakes into five classes with similarities in environmental and nutrient variations, and attributed key factors in controlling the temporal changes of PEO. The results showed that the satellite-observed PEO trends in five classes could be largely linked to the terrestrial nutrient exports and environmental changes. Specifically, we found agricultural activities can explain the observed eutrophication trends in western lakes where lake catchments are dominated with arable and natural land, and the reduced discharge of industrial wastewater was found to be linked to the declining trends in eutrophication for eastern lakes where the green growth of industrialization were promoted from 2003 to 2011. These findings highlight the importance of sustainable management of agriculture and industrialization to overcome eutrophication issues in this region.

    How to cite: Guan, Q., Tang, J., Feng, L., Olin, S., and Schurgers, G.: Terrestrial nutrient exports and environmental changes explain eutrophication trends in fifty large lakes of Yangtze Plain, China, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2204, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2204, 2022.

    EGU22-3761 | Presentations | HS5.7 | Highlight

    The role of floodplains for denitrification along large rivers in central Europe – measurements and modeling for a comprehensive overview 

    Stephanie Natho, Thomas Hein, Ute Susanne Kaden, Ann-Christin Kra, and Martin Tschikof

    Floodplains, especially along large rivers in central Europe, have been modified heavily during the last centuries. Not only floodplain losses by embankment and dikes, but also a decoupling of river hydrology by river bed incision and embankments occurred. Nevertheless, floodplains are known to act as nutrient sinks when inundated by river water during floods. Nutrients, such as nitrate, are nowadays known to be of higher concentrations than under natural conditions and can cause water quality issues. How much of this retention function is left in several highly modified European rivers?  

     

    With this study, we provide an overview of our activities to quantify denitrification along large rivers in Germany and the Danube in Austria as well as in its river basin by applying models as well as field and laboratory measurements. We explore this key ecosystem function of endangered floodplain ecosystems and their potential to act as nature-based solutions to mitigate the effects of nitrate pollution.

    Therefore, we modeled denitrification by a semi-empiric model for the rivers Rhine, Elbe, Main, and Weser as well as the Danube. For the latter, a comparison with a statistical model based on in-site measurement on nutrient concentrations was carried out. Furthermore, we are currently estimating the denitrification potential of the Danube River by applying the semi-empirical model for in-stream retention and for floodplains, considering controlling soil physical and chemical parameters as well as flooding probabilities.

    On the measurement side, we applied the acetylene inhibition method for 6 locations (113 plots) along the rivers Elbe, Rhine, Main, and Weser together with calculated average inundation time to determine upper-bound soil denitrification potential estimates. Through this combined model- and measurement-based approach, proxy-based statements were further developed on a large scale.

    From all our studies we conclude that floodplains still contribute to nitrate retention in large modified rivers. Depending on the level of connectivity between rivers and their adjacent floodplains, the occurrence of frequent inundation during the year, and the way floodplains are inundated (large spatial extent vs preferential pathways carrying the water quickly through the floodplain), averaged modeled N-retention is about 400 kg N/ha/yr which is mid to upper range of reported removal rates in other systems. However, compared to the large nutrient loads and the small regular inundation extent, current floodplains alone limited in their current connectivity level are not capable to improve water quality significantly. Based on the laboratory measurements resulting in lower retention rates of 25-100 kg N/h/yr we conclude that the pH value is a key parameter that influences denitrification: thus, even in well-connected floodplains denitrification potential is comparably low due to low pH values as proved for the Elbe River. Further field studies and laboratory experiments under closer in-situ conditions are necessary to better understand which processes limit and foster denitrification. Therefore, we adapt our methods to assess actual/quasi-in-situ soil denitrification on a study site along the Havel River in spring 2022.

    How to cite: Natho, S., Hein, T., Kaden, U. S., Kra, A.-C., and Tschikof, M.: The role of floodplains for denitrification along large rivers in central Europe – measurements and modeling for a comprehensive overview, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3761, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3761, 2022.

    EGU22-4101 | Presentations | HS5.7 | Highlight

    Mitigation measures for improvement of agricultural drainage water and surface water quality in Denmark 

    Carl Hoffmann, Dominik Zak, Brian Kronvang, Mette Carstensen, and Joachim Audet

    Nutrient losses from agricultural areas constitute a major cause for the degradation of aquatic ecosystems worldwide. Sixty percent of the area in Denmark is arable land and thus there is a huge need for mitigation measures to decrease the transport of nutrients from agricultural areas to downstream recipients. We discuss results, experiences and challenges for an optimised implementation of nutrient transport mitigation measures targeting agricultural nutrient losses to fresh and marine water. In 2016 the Agricultural Package was adopted by the Danish Parliament and Danish farmers were again allowed to fertilise their crops to economic optimum. To compensate for the consequent increase in fertilisation rates and the potential negative consequences on water quality, a new nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P) management plan was introduced. This plan consists of measures to mitigate N losses in smaller catchments (≈ 15 km2) and knowledge of the N-retention capacity of the individual catchments is used for optimisation of the implementation of mitigation measures. A series of nutrient transport mitigation measures has been scientifically approved for use in this new regulation, and more measures are currently undergoing scientific testing. This study focuses on documenting the nutrient retention effects of already approved nutrient transport mitigation measures, such as restoration of riparian wetlands, lowland fens and swamps, re-establishment of shallow lakes, constructed wetlands (surface flow and subsurface flow), as well as measures not yet approved and still under development such as integrated buffer zones, saturated buffer zones and controlled drainage.

    How to cite: Hoffmann, C., Zak, D., Kronvang, B., Carstensen, M., and Audet, J.: Mitigation measures for improvement of agricultural drainage water and surface water quality in Denmark, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4101, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4101, 2022.

    EGU22-5708 | Presentations | HS5.7

    Natural Flood Management features mitigate sediment and nutrient loading in a lowland agricultural catchment in England 

    John Robotham, Gareth Old, Ponnambalam Rameshwaran, David Sear, Emily Trill, James Bishop, David Gasca-Tucker, Joanne Old, and David McKnight

    Natural Flood Management (NFM) is a nature-based solution for reducing flood risk whilst delivering multiple benefits such as water quality improvements through the mitigation of diffuse pollution (e.g. from soil erosion). This study aimed to assess the ability of NFM storage features to trap potential pollutants in run-off from two small (3.4 km2) agricultural catchments. The masses of sediment, total phosphorus and organic carbon trapped by 14 NFM features (since construction 2 to 3 years previously) were quantified through sediment surveying and sampling. Streamflow and suspended sediment monitoring downstream of the features enabled catchment fluxes to be calculated. The features trapped a total of 83 tonnes sediment, 122 kg phosphorus, and 4.3 tonnes organic carbon over 2 to 3 years of functioning. Although the footprint of the features was <1% of the catchment area, they drained 44% of the total land area and were able to capture the equivalent of 25% of the total suspended sediment flux (22% of the fine (silt and clay) sediment flux), 14% of the total phosphorus flux, and 13% of the particulate organic carbon flux during the monitored period. Results show how accumulation rates were influenced by hydrological connectivity, with greater accumulation in features constructed directly on streams (online features), and offline features which filled from streamflow diverted by instream woody dams. Compared with the topsoil in each contributing area, trapped sediment was enriched in phosphorus and carbon in the majority of features, having on average 50% higher phosphorus and 17% higher organic carbon concentrations than surrounding arable soils, highlighting its potential value for redistribution on farmland. The results of this monitoring demonstrate the potential of NFM interventions to provide additional value by mitigating diffuse pollution in lowland catchments.

    How to cite: Robotham, J., Old, G., Rameshwaran, P., Sear, D., Trill, E., Bishop, J., Gasca-Tucker, D., Old, J., and McKnight, D.: Natural Flood Management features mitigate sediment and nutrient loading in a lowland agricultural catchment in England, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5708, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5708, 2022.

    EGU22-7487 | Presentations | HS5.7

    Artificial wetland for mitigation of non-point source agricultural pollution in a French drained context: lessons from a 10-years monitoring. 

    Julien Tournebize, Cédric Chaumont, Aliénor Jeliazkov, Jérémie Lebrun, Aya Bahi, Alexandre Michel, Bruno Lemaire, and Hocine Henine

    Managing water flow at the outlet of subsurface drainage networks is an important issue for water authorities aiming to preserve freshwater quality. As buried drains are directly connected to arterial ditches, dynamic and specific hydrological functioning of drained plots contribute to export part of chemical compounds derived from the farm inputs application, such as the exceed pesticides or fertilizers. Provided the necessary changes of agricultural practice at the farm scale, intercepting water at the outlet of subsurface drainage network in artificial wetland is considered as an efficient mitigation measure and constitutes a nature-based solution that addresses multiple ecological objectives.

    From the pilot experimental subcatchment of Rampillon in France (355ha of intensive farming in the agricultural region of Brie, rural Parisian basin), we propose a synthesis of the results obtained from the 10 years of performance assessment of this artificial wetland in buffering nitrates and pesticides from drained fields. We also provide a feedback from the 15-years collaboration with the local and national stakeholders strongly involved from the early beginning of this long-term project. After an initial stage of dialog and co-construction with the stakeholders (5 years), the experimental artificial wetland (0.5ha or 0.15% of upscale watershed) was constructed in 2010. The full monitoring of the wetland for water quality and quantity started in 2012 and was complemented by biodiversity surveys in 2017 and 2021.

    We will present yearly and seasonal variations of removal efficiency of nitrate and pesticides and discuss the limits and interests of artificial wetland in this context, including the high potential for removal with high seasonal variability due to thermal sensitivity and hydrological effects. Concerning heavy metals, a former study showed that agricultural fields do not significantly contribute to their transfer and that the artificial wetland retained the major part of them. In a hydraulic study using conservative tracers, we highlight the role of vegetation patches on the hydraulic performance of the wetland and on the pollutant mitigation. All those results allowed us to develop a modeling approach based on Tank In Serie (for nitrate and pesticides) to define a standard design aiming 50% annual removal efficiency.

    After ten years, involved farmers are now the best ambassadors to disseminate the role of nature-based solutions in helping mitigate the unintentional pollutions from agricultural activities, not considering artificial wetland as a right to pollute but a complementary tool to Best Management Practices.

    Finally, part of our works focuses on the role of artificial wetland in biodiversity maintenance in agricultural landscape by monitoring the ecosystem dynamics and the seasonal exposure of different vertebrate and invertebrate communities using ecotoxicological approach. In fine, this will allow us to better understand the intricacy of the ecological functions ensured by these artificial ecosystems and to assess their potential in supporting multiple ecosystem services such as water quality preservation, biodiversity protection, landscape connectivity and recreational activities to local populations.

    How to cite: Tournebize, J., Chaumont, C., Jeliazkov, A., Lebrun, J., Bahi, A., Michel, A., Lemaire, B., and Henine, H.: Artificial wetland for mitigation of non-point source agricultural pollution in a French drained context: lessons from a 10-years monitoring., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7487, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7487, 2022.

    EGU22-7572 | Presentations | HS5.7

    PESTIPOND: A fate model of pesticides in ponds 

    Aya Bahi, Sabine Sauvage, Sylvain Payraudeau, Gwenaël Imfeld, and Julien Tournebize

    Non-point pollution by pesticides affects the quality of drinking water supplies and aquatic environments. Ponds collecting runoff and erosion fluxes offer a complementary tool to mitigate pesticide transfer to aquatic ecosystems. Pesticides mitigation results from various physicochemical processes operating in the water column, the sediment layer, the vegetation, and the suspended particles of ponds. Many studies on ponds dissipation potential focus on nitrates and suspended sediments, but very little is known about the behavior of pesticides. In order to predict and enhance the dissipation of pesticides in ponds, a new 0D time-dependent model was designed, “PESTIPOND.” The dissipation function of ponds is due to a combination of transport, transfer, and transformation processes of pesticides in an interplay between pond compartments. A previous review helped us identify the main processes of pesticides dissipation in ponds and their controlling factors. A time-dependent environmental fate model is currently developed to describe the behavior of dissolved and particulate pesticides at the pond scale. We tested the performance of this process-based model by simulating the behavior of four molecules with contrasted physicochemical properties (i.e., Aclonifen, chlorotoluron, s-metolachlor, and tebuconazole) in a synthetic scenario representing an experimental pond study. PESTIPOND enabled to compute the outlet concentration of pesticides in ponds based on their inlet concentration. The model simulated the behavior of pesticides in water, sediments, vegetation, and suspended particles of a pond due to sorption, settling/resuspension, volatilization, and degradation processes. The conceptual model is based on pesticide mass-budget equations in pond compartments depending of climate and hydraulic conditions. Sensitivity analysis provides a framework to recognize important variables in the computational model. We adopted the Morris and Sobol methods for the sensitivity analysis of PESTIPOND to identify dominant parameters influencing the model outputs. A preliminary result showed that the prevailing processes determining pesticide fate were sorption and biodegradation for dissolved pesticides and settling for particulate pesticides. The identification of effective mechanisms can be helpful to hierarchize processes based on their contribution to the dissipation function of ponds. This hierarchization may improve the estimation of ponds efficiency with respect to pesticide dissipation. In the future, implementing the PESTIPOND model in SWAT is expected to extend the prediction of ponds dissipation to the catchment scale. PESTIPOND will be particularly helpful to set up dimensioning criteria to design performant and efficient ponds to mitigate pesticides transfer into the environment.

    How to cite: Bahi, A., Sauvage, S., Payraudeau, S., Imfeld, G., and Tournebize, J.: PESTIPOND: A fate model of pesticides in ponds, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7572, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7572, 2022.

    EGU22-10377 | Presentations | HS5.7

    Challenges in model based estimation of mitigation measures to improve water quality on catchment scale 

    Tomasz Okruszko, Mateusz Grygoruk, Pawel Marcinkowski, and Mikołaj Piniewski

    Restoration of wetlands as well as other measures aimed on increasing water and nutrients buffering capacity along the streams are becoming increasingly proposed as solutions addressing problems of water pollution. We observed, however limited integration of this type of measures in  river basin management plans. We assume, that it is caused mainly by lack of knowledge (and tools) about   effectiveness assessment in case of numerous measures applied in a particular catchment. In other words, upscaling of restoration measures should be possible, when we can provide water managers with more accurate estimates of cumulative effects of different measures. It can be achieved by  hydrological model application in appropriate scale.

    We have tested different approaches in modelling of several river basins where restoration activity or buffering  measures where applied or planned. This includes Kamienna River in upland landscape, Słupia River in costal settings and Pilica River in lowlands. There were also modelling experiments conducted on rivers in Finland, Sweden and Lithuania.   Based on the modelling  experience from these catchments using Soil and Water Assessment Tool (SWAT), where different types of river buffer zones and wetlands  implementation has been tested, a number of challenges can be emphasized. At a general level, three major sources of challenges dominate: (1) spatial extent and location of measures, (2) their accurate parametrization and (3) simplification of processes in modelling scheme. Most commonly, in semi-distributed models, principal calculation units for which water and nutrient balance is calculated, are lumped and non-contiguous geographic units within each sub-catchment. Particular model setup may consist of thousands of such units, and each of them may represent one field, a portion of a field, or, more likely, portions of many fields. It becomes problematic when we aim to simulate measures for particular river reach or wetland, but can only define it at coarser sub-catchment level. The second issue is related to proper parametrization of empirical/physical sub-models, simulating processes of nutrients adsorption and settling. In most cases, uncertainty related to parametrization of buffer zones and wetlands  is significant. No simple calibration procedure for setting the optimal parameters’ values can be applied, and the process itself is more expert-dependent. Another issue is related to simplifications of processes. For instance, in SWAT, nutrient transformations simulated in wetlands are limited to the removal of nutrients by settlings however transformations between nutrient pools are ignored. For the buffer zones, model only affects contaminants that are present in surface runoff and neglects the potential effects of buffer zones on shallow groundwater.

    There is a big room for improvement by providing the best monitoring results of particular measures and applying them in a modeling scheme. This can be done based on wetland restoration projects which were monitored by our group in Kampinos National Park, Biebrza NP,  Słowiński NP as well as in Lithuania and Norway. Showing the results of our models we would like to rise discussion on inter-calibration of the particular measures in the modelling settings.

    How to cite: Okruszko, T., Grygoruk, M., Marcinkowski, P., and Piniewski, M.: Challenges in model based estimation of mitigation measures to improve water quality on catchment scale, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10377, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10377, 2022.

    EGU22-13064 | Presentations | HS5.7

    Compact filter system for mitigating phosphorus losses from agricultural drainage discharge 

    Goswin Heckrath and Lorenzo Pugliese

    Phosphorus (P) losses from artificially drained agricultural land can locally contribute to surface water eutrophication. These losses are a function of hydrological processes and long-term P accumulation in soils due fertilization practices, which is why agronomic mitigation options tend to be ineffective. However, as subsurface drainage systems concentrate water flow spatially, drainage filter technologies represent a potentially cost-effective end-of-pipe mitigation practice for P losses. The aim of this study was to test such a compact, full-scale P filter system under field conditions.

    The system is located in the Fensholt catchment, Denmark, and has two main compartments: a sediment filter for retaining particulate P and a porous reactive filter consisting of iron-coated sand (ICS) for dissolved P. A pump feeds drainage water from an adjacent ditch into the filter system at flow rates of typically 1-1.5 l s-1. Hydraulic loading of the system and drainage water composition were monitored continuously on a daily basis to evaluate system performance. Measurements of total P (TP), total dissolved P (TDP) and turbidity (NTU) were done. Suspended sediment was estimated in all water samples from turbidity measurements.

    During the runoff season October 2020 to June 2021 the hydraulic load to the filter system was 18000 m3 corresponding to an average hydraulic retention time (HRT) for the sediment filter of 92 minutes. Total P concentrations in drainage water at the system inlet varied substantially between 0.03 and 2.47 mg P l-1, while TDP varied between 0.04 and 0.84 mg P l-1. On average TDP represented 60% of TP. The sediment filter retained 71% and 64% of the estimated sediment and PP load, respectively. However, occasionally TDP was remobilized from the sediment filter in late spring due to chemical and biological processes. The TDP retention in the ICS filter averaged 51% for the drainage season. On a monthly basis TP retention in the filter system varied between -33% and 88% averaging 61% in 2020/21. This compares positively with other end-of-pipe solutions such as constructed wetlands which tend to have lower TP retention efficiencies under Danish conditions. However, the effective storage capacity of the compact P filter system has to be better understood including the mechanisms of potential P release processes and the required frequency of filter cleaning.

    How to cite: Heckrath, G. and Pugliese, L.: Compact filter system for mitigating phosphorus losses from agricultural drainage discharge, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13064, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13064, 2022.

    EGU22-13435 | Presentations | HS5.7

    A field study of nitrogen removal and N2O and CH4 fluxes from integrated buffer zones 

    Mette Vodder Carstensen, Dominik Zak, Sofie van't Veen, Kamila Wisniewska, Niels Ovesen, Brian Kronvang, and Joachim Audet

    We present a detailed field study on the dynamics between processes retaining nitrogen (denitrification, plant uptake) and processes producing greenhouse gasses (incomplete denitrification, methanogenesis) in integrated buffer zones (IBZ). Integrated buffer zones are novel systems designed to be integrated within the riparian zone to retain nitrogen and other pollutants that otherwise bypass the riparian buffer zone via drainpipes. However, the anaerobic conditions established within the IBZ to enhance denitrification, can lead to production of the greenhouse gasses N2O and CH4. We investigated both the atmospheric emission of N2O and CH4, and waterborne losses of dissolved nitrogen, N2O and CH4 from two IBZ sites in Denmark for one year. The study showed that the emission of N2O was relatively low, and that IBZ can even work as a sink of N2O. On the contrary, the IBZ were sources of CH4, although the emissions were comparable to those of natural wetlands and other drainage transport mitigation measures. The hydrology was identified as the key driver of emission pathways and their relative importance, as well as the nitrogen retention efficiency.

    How to cite: Vodder Carstensen, M., Zak, D., van't Veen, S., Wisniewska, K., Ovesen, N., Kronvang, B., and Audet, J.: A field study of nitrogen removal and N2O and CH4 fluxes from integrated buffer zones, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13435, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13435, 2022.

    EGU22-13454 | Presentations | HS5.7

    Wetland observatories for rewetting of drained peatlands (ReWeT-DK) 

    Rasmus Jes Petersen, Dominik Zak, Astrid Maagaard, Carl Hoffmann, Andersen Hans, Christiansen Jesper, Elsgaard Lars, Pullens Johannes, and Lærke Paul

    ReWet is currently establishing four observatories on drained peatlands in Denmark. These observatories will serve as platforms for ecosystem monitoring, experimental research, technological development and demonstration. The objective of ReWet is to facilitate climate smart management and land use change related to agriculture and forestry on peat soils  The ReWet observatories will focus on measurements of fluxes of greenhouse gases (GHG), energy, water and matter (including major nutrients and dissolved carbon) in the interface of the upper groundwater, soil, vegetation and the atmosphere under different rewetting strategies and land use combinations. The ecosystem monitoring will include biodiversity namely vegetation composition and soil microbial communities. The vertical movement of the peat surface will be monitored using dynamic radar reflectors. The monitoring and research carried out at the observatories will, in combination with nationwide  soil databases, enable development of science based national strategies for rewetting of temperate wetlands like in Denmark to achieve substantially lower GHG emissions at national scale, less nutrient pollution of aquatic ecosystems and increased landscape biodiversity.

    How to cite: Petersen, R. J., Zak, D., Maagaard, A., Hoffmann, C., Hans, A., Jesper, C., Lars, E., Johannes, P., and Paul, L.: Wetland observatories for rewetting of drained peatlands (ReWeT-DK), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13454, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13454, 2022.

    EGU22-13507 | Presentations | HS5.7 | Highlight

    Climate impact of constructed wetlands treating nitrate-rich agricultural runoff: The methane problem 

    Ülo Mander, Kaido Soosaar, Julien Tournebize, Keit Kill, Cedric Chaumont, Martin Maddison, and Kuno Kasak

    Constructed wetlands (CW) treating runoff from agricultural catchments can efficiently reduce nitrate contamination, however, most wetlands are inherently net sources of methane (CH4), which is of environmental concern due to its potent global warming capacity. For the mitigation of this negative aspect of CWs we need investigations on the CH4 emission dynamics and environmental conditions governing CH4 production and consumption in CWs.

    This study integrates results from 4-years (2014-2017) investigations in an off-stream CW in Rampillon, France (0.53 ha, depth 0.3-0.8 m, est. 2010) and from 4-years (2018-2021) studies in an in-stream CW in Vända, Estonia (0.45 ha, depth 0.1-0.6 m, est. 2015). In Rampillon, during four 2-weeks measurement campaigns throughout all seasons CH4 fluxes were measured using floating automated chambers connected to the QCLAS laser system. In addition, gas was sampled twice day from manual floating chambers for further analysis in lab. In Vända in-stream CW, CH4 fluxes were measured twice a month using manual chambers and gas-chromatographs.

    The average annual CH4 emission in Rampillon for 2014-2015 was 7.7 g CH4-C m-2 yr-1, showing highest values from deeper (0.5-1.0 m) parts in summer and autumn. The highest values reached up to 180 mg CH4-C m-2 h-1, mainly due to ebullition. The emissions in winter and spring were up to 10 times lower, however no negative values were observed. There was an increasing trend in CH4 fluxes: in 2017 the average emission reached to 12.0 g CH4-C m-2 y-1. Differences between the emission values gathered from authomated chambers were about 10% higher than those measured from manual chambers.

    In Vända in-stream CW, a clear increase in average annual emissions was found: from 0.4 in2018 to 10.5 g CH4-C m-2 yr-1 in 2021. It was correlated with increasing Typha latifolia-dominated vegetation cover. Emissions showed strong correlation with air and water temperature while no clear relationship was found with the depth of various parts.

    Large CH4 emission from CWs is a major concern and therefore a smart management is needed. Our previous studies in surface flow CWs treating nitrate-contaminated runoff demonstrate that above-ground biomass harvesting of plants can decrease the CH4. The end of growing season is likely the best time for biomass harvesting while avoiding the excessively high CH4 emissions that the summer harvest may produce.

    How to cite: Mander, Ü., Soosaar, K., Tournebize, J., Kill, K., Chaumont, C., Maddison, M., and Kasak, K.: Climate impact of constructed wetlands treating nitrate-rich agricultural runoff: The methane problem, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13507, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13507, 2022.

    EGU22-13510 | Presentations | HS5.7

    Saturated buffer zones as novel drainage mitigation measure in Denmark 

    Dominik Zak, Astrid Maagaard, Brian Kronvang, Carl Hoffmann, Joachim Audet, and Rasmus Petersen

    Vegetated buffer strips have been introduced in some European countries since the 1980s to mitigate the deterioration of watercourses by surface runoff from intensively managed agricultural land. However, the effectiveness was proven to be less for the retention of dissolved nutrients than expected, as agricultural drainage water was directly charging streams via tile drainage pipes. Therefore, a new drainage mitigation measures was introduced in Denmark to lower the nutrient load of freshwater and eventually marine systems, called saturated buffer zone (SBZ). Drainage pipes are disconnected at the sloping field margin and to the riparian zone by diverting drainage water to a buried, lateral distribution pipe running parallel to the stream. Results of a 2-year monitoring study unravel a high performance of the investigated SBZ as nitrate and phosphate removal efficiency was as high as 87% and 76 %, respectively. However, these high efficiencies must still be interpreted with caution since subsurface water flows was rather heterogenous varying by two orders of magnitude within the investigated transects. None the less, SBZs are a promising mitigation measure for removing nutrients from farmland.

    How to cite: Zak, D., Maagaard, A., Kronvang, B., Hoffmann, C., Audet, J., and Petersen, R.: Saturated buffer zones as novel drainage mitigation measure in Denmark, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13510, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13510, 2022.

    EGU22-333 | Presentations | HS5.10

    Assessing the use of earth bunds as Natural Flood Management features 

    Jeremy Teale and Julia L.A. Knapp

    Nature based solutions to urban flooding have drawn growing attention in recent years as climate change models predict a catastrophic increase to flood-risk in the UK and around the world. The lack of systematic empirical evidence to support Natural Flood Management (NFM) initiatives still presents a key barrier to the widespread implementation of NFM techniques. The disconnect between practitioners and academics in the field also remains a central issue to be addressed to improve uptake and acceptance of NFM by landowners.

    Urban centres in the Wear Catchment in Northeast England are substantially affected by flooding. In this study, we assess the effectiveness of several earth bunds in creating temporary storage of flood water in the upper catchment of the Wear. For this purpose, we assess flood storage frequency and record the impacts of flood storage on bund structure. Arduino-based water sensors in each of the five bunds record the frequency of flood storage, which is related to precipitation intensity and volume. Changes in soil hydraulic conductivity and soil chemistry are also measured throughout the year to assess changes in infiltration capacity as a measure of bund stability. Finally, vegetation surveys are carried out to gain insights on soil recovery after the installation of the bunds, providing a measure of suitability for the land to be used for grazing.

    Working closely with the Environment Agency and the landowner, this work aims to develop an improved understanding on the importance of the design requirements and location setting for the installations. We hypothesise that the varying build quality and placing of the bunds in relation to the stream will directly impact the regularity with which the bunds become active storage. This project adds to the evidence base of NFM in the UK and is of direct consequence to practitioners around the world seeking to improve NFM methods.

    How to cite: Teale, J. and Knapp, J. L. A.: Assessing the use of earth bunds as Natural Flood Management features, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-333, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-333, 2022.

    EGU22-369 | Presentations | HS5.10 | Highlight

    Nature-based Solutions, mangrove restoration and global coastal flood risk reductions 

    Timothy Tiggeloven, Eric Mortensen, Thomas Worthington, Hans de Moel, Mark Spalding, and Philip Ward

    In order to mitigate the expected increase in coastal flood risk it is critical to better understand how adaptation measures can reduce that risk, including Nature-based Solutions. We present the first global scale assessment of the (future) flood risk reduction and the benefits mangrove restoration. Unlike previous studies on Nature-based Solutions, we provide a quantitative assessment of mangrove restoration and nature contributions to people in terms of monetary flood risk reduction, people exposed to flooding, and poverty indicators. We find that mangrove restoration is an effective measure to contribute to future flood risk reduction and estimate that a large share of future flood risk may be reduced by implementing mangrove restoration. Our estimates indicate that nature-based solutions like mangrove restoration constitute promising complementary measures to other adaptation measures (e.g. structural measures). We further indicate that the benefits of mangrove restoration are unevenly distributed across the population in terms of poverty, and show that only looking into property damages and people exposed is not enough to understand the range of impacts of adaptation on population distributions. Even though this study can only be used as a first proxy analysis or indicative, it provides valuable insight into the feasibility of mangrove restoration at the global scale, and supports the need for sustainable adaptation and global assessmenst of Nature-based Solutions. Furthermore, implementing adaptation measures, such as mangrove restoration, in developing countries will contribute to the resilience of people in poverty, poverty alleviation and help tackle poverty traps.

    How to cite: Tiggeloven, T., Mortensen, E., Worthington, T., de Moel, H., Spalding, M., and Ward, P.: Nature-based Solutions, mangrove restoration and global coastal flood risk reductions, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-369, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-369, 2022.

    EGU22-1444 | Presentations | HS5.10

    Large scale installation of multilayer blue-green roofs as solution for a sustainable urban water management 

    Elena Cristiano, Antonio Annis, Francesco Viola, Roberto Deidda, and Fernando Nardi

    The modern society is facing multiple challenges, that are reshaping urban areas: the fast population growth, with a consequent high urbanization, combined with an increase of the average temperature and an intensification of extreme rainfall events, facilitates the pluvial flood risk in cities. Several solutions have been proposed in the literature to mitigate the runoff generation from rooftops and to contribute to a sustainable water management. In this context, multilayer blue-green roofs incorporate the high retention capacity of traditional green roofs with the storage capacity that characterizes rainwater harvesting systems. Moreover, these innovative nature-based solutions present countless benefits for the creation of smart, resilient and sustainable cities, e.g., they contrast the urban heat island, reducing the surrounding air temperature, they contribute to the building thermal insulation, limiting the energy consumption, they attract multiple species of insects and small animals, increasing the biodiversity, etc. 

    The potential impacts of multilayer and traditional blue-green roofs and rainwater harvesting systems on the runoff generation reduction have been investigated mostly at local scale, analysing the impact of the installation of these tools on single buildings. However, in order to estimate and to evaluate the potential benefits and limitations for a sustainable urban development, it is fundamental to simulate the potential implications of a large-scale installation of these tools on large neighbourhoods or entire cities. For these reasons, in this work we simulate the installation of multilayer blue-green roofs on all the suitable roofs of the cities of Cagliari and Perugia (Italy). Thanks to the two multilayer blue-green roofs, installed in Cagliari and Perugia as part of the EU Climate-KIC Polderroof field lab project, it was possible to calibrate an ecohydrological model to simulate the potential retention and storage capacities of these nature based solutions. The potential discharge reduction and water storage capacity at large urban scale are discussed using as input for the model long historical time series of local rainfall and temperature.

    How to cite: Cristiano, E., Annis, A., Viola, F., Deidda, R., and Nardi, F.: Large scale installation of multilayer blue-green roofs as solution for a sustainable urban water management, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1444, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1444, 2022.

    Abstract

    Green roofs received increased scientific attention with respect to climate adaptation in urban environments for their hydrological, biodiversity and insulative capacities. Yet, the thermal properties of roofs with an additional water layer underneath the vegetation substrate (blue-green roofs) are not well represented in scientific research. In this field study, we examined the impact of surface temperatures, indoor temperature and insulative properties of blue-green, green, and conventional gravel/bitumen roofs in the city of Amsterdam for early 20th century buildings. Temperature sensor (IButtons) results indicate that outside surface temperatures of blue-green roofs were more stable than for conventional roofs. For instance, for three warm periods during summer (2021) surface substrate temperatures peaked much higher for gravel roofs (+8 oC) or bitumen roofs (+18 oC) than for blue-green roofs. On top of that, during a cold period in winter average water crate layer temperatures remained 3.0 oC higher and much more stable than substrate temperatures of blue-green roofs and conventional roofs, implicating that the blue layer functions as an extra temperature buffer. The effect of lower daily variation of surface temperatures in winter and summer is also reflected by inside air temperatures. Inside temperatures showed that locations with blue-green roofs are less sensitive to outside air temperatures, as daily temperature fluctuations (standard deviations) were 0.19 and 0.23 oC lower for warm and cold periods, respectively, compared to conventional roofs. This effect seems rather small but comprises a relatively large proportion of the total daily variation of 24% and 64% of warm and cold periods respectively.

    How to cite: Föllmi, D., Corpel, L., Solcerova, A., and Kluck, J.: What is the thermal effect of ‘blue’ in blue-green roofs? A quantitative case study on the insulative effects of blue-green roofs in Amsterdam, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2949, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2949, 2022.

    Multi-stage constructed wetlands (CWs) are widely used for water quality improvement, especially in the treatment of wastewater. Many studies focus on their treatment efficiency under steady loading, but fewer studies consider their stability and sustainability under variable conditions. This study monitors the hydrology and water quality at the multi-stage CWs in the Hong Kong Wetland Park. Five wetland units along the flow path are examined for their long-term performance and sustainability in terms of water quality under seasonal changes, storm events, and shock loadings of pollutants. Time-series statistical analysis indicates that the multistage design well achieves stable performance. Each wetland unit has certain roles and they work together to achieve good performance. The reliability analysis shows that the CW system can largely buffer the fluctuations from most disturbances. While the resiliency analysis also shows that most water quality indicators could recover in a few days after the fluctuations. The water levels recover quickly but it was difficult to return to original water levels in multi-stage CWs. Besides, a numerical model is developed, calibrated, and utilized to predict future water quality changes. This will help evaluate measures to improve the sustainability of multi-stage CWs by simulating water quality changes under different influent concentrations and rainfall conditions. This study could provide appropriate recommendations and early warnings for wetland management and improvement.

    How to cite: Jiang, L. and Chui, T. F. M.: Sustainability of a multi-stage free water surface constructed wetland in terms of water quality under changing conditions, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3745, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3745, 2022.

    EGU22-3941 | Presentations | HS5.10

    Plasma water quality treatment for SuDS development 

    Rasool Erfani, Lena Ciric, and Tohid Erfani

    Sustainable drainage systems (SuDS) design and management can contribute to a healthier and greener urban development. We show how the inclusion of innovative approaches to SuDS namely the plasma engineering can lead to a more effective and less detrimental water quality treatment. The treatment method using Dielectric Barrier Discharge Plasma actuator, can be retrofitted to the current urban setting, it is cheap and provides efficient alternative for water purification and pollution treatment. We present its environmental benefits causing minimal impact to the surroundings while controlling and managing the pollution. We investigate this in both the city and catchment scale contexts.

    How to cite: Erfani, R., Ciric, L., and Erfani, T.: Plasma water quality treatment for SuDS development, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3941, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3941, 2022.

    Urbanisation and climate change jeopardize the health of peri-urban streams, by yielding decreased baseflow and increased peakflows. Green infrastructure can help protecting and even restoring urban streams by storing, infiltrating and losing urban runoff to evapotranspiration. However, whether green infrastructure implementation at the catchment-scale (and how much) can counter future urbanisation and climate change remains a question of interest for urban managers. We modelled the hydrology of a 20 km2 peri-urban catchment in the western suburbs of Lyon, France with the physically-based, spatially distributed hydrological model J2000P, at the hourly time step. We created 12 future urbanisation scenarios with stepwise increases of impervious cover as well as 36 climate change scenarios based on one climate projection (CNRM-CM5-ARPEGE- ALADIN63-RCP 8.5) and the observed temperature and precipitation records from the city of Orange, which is located 200 km south of Lyon in France. We applied a delta method to transform current hourly rainfall and evapotranspiration timeseries into potential future climate timeseries. We coupled these scenarios to stormwater management strategies, through the integration of a site-scale model of green infrastructure into J2000P. Five stormwater management strategies with increasing implementation of green infrastructure were tested: from ‘no green infrastructure’ to ‘all impervious areas drained into green infrastructure’. 640 scenarios coupling urbanisation, climate and stormwater management scenarios were simulated. For each simulation a range of hydrological indicators were calculated. We found that catchment-scale implementation of green infrastructure could mitigate the hydrological impacts of urbanisation. Sewer overflow were particularly sensitive to green infrastructure and urbanisation. Green infrastructure was however unable to mitigate the impact of climate change on the stream flow regime, because green infrastructure only impacted the urban parts of the catchment that accounted for less than 15% of the whole catchment. Non-urban areas (forests, pastures), which contributed very strongly to the flow regime, were impacted by climate change but not significantly by urban stormwater management strategies. These results can inform urban planners and water managers of the great potential of green infrastructure (reduction of sewer overflows, compensation for urbanisation) but also its limitations (little impacts on catchment scale induced flow peaks and droughts).

    How to cite: Bonneau, J., Branger, F., and Castebrunet, H.: Can catchment scale implementation of green infrastructure protect the flow regime of an urban stream facing urbanisation and climate change ? A modelling study in Lyon, France., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3983, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3983, 2022.

    EGU22-6104 | Presentations | HS5.10

    Resilience to flow rate variability in a green wall for greywater treatment 

    Elisa Costamagna, Bianca Raffaelli, Silvia Fiore, and Fulvio Boano

    Green and blue infrastructures are an innovative solution to contrast climate changes (SDG 13 of UN 2030 Agenda) and increase cities resilience (SDG 11), using a smarter water management that transform wastewater into a new resource for non-potable reuses. Due to the lack of horizontal surfaces in urban areas, green walls are one of the most suitable nature-based solution to treat greywater (i.e. the portion of household wastewater that exclude toilet flush and kitchen sink). Green walls allow for a multidisciplinary approach, providing multiple benefits such as thermal and acoustic regulation, biodiversity preservation, decreasing heat islands effects and removing CO2, improving life quality and buildings value.

    Green walls have also been proposed for treating the large amount of greywater that is daily produced (e.g. around 100 L/PE/die in Italy), an approach that also provides urban green while reducing the need of irrigation water. Following previous work on a pilot system, this study aims to improve the green walls design and test its resilience to variations in the flow rate of greywater fed to the green wall. Two panels have been built in which synthetic greywater flows by gravity along three levels of pots with different plant species. The 18 pots (arranged in a 3x3 matrix in each panel) have been filled with a mix of coconut fibre and perlite (1:1 in volume) and fed with greywater, and output water samples have been collected almost weekly from June to December 2021. The control panel has been regularly fed with 24 L/die/col (standard flow rate), the other has been fed with different flow rates (standard, underflow, overflow and maintenance) that usually changed after three weeks. Different parameters (e.g. TSS, BOD5, COD, DO, TN, TP, MBAS), have been monitored in the outflow of each pot and average performances of each level has been evaluated. Results indicate a good efficiency of the green wall in removing contaminants even when the provided flow rate is not constant.

    The treatment performances increase along the columns in both panels and the first two levels guarantee a good compounds removal during standard flow and underflow rates. On the other hand, the overflow rate caused a performances decrease in the variable flow panel for many parameters, followed by a visible plant stress. However, one week of standard flow rate was sufficient to reduce the negative effects of the three- weeks-overflow. This demonstrated the resilience of the green wall facing flow variability, that can be caused by seasonal variation or system failure.

    How to cite: Costamagna, E., Raffaelli, B., Fiore, S., and Boano, F.: Resilience to flow rate variability in a green wall for greywater treatment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6104, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6104, 2022.

    EGU22-7432 | Presentations | HS5.10

    Studies on the active use of urban forest areas as pluvial flood prevention 

    Sebastian Gürke and Jürgen Jensen

    In recent years, heavy rainfall events have caused significant damage in urban areas across Germany. Experiences in coping with pluvial floods show that single measures alone cannot reduce the risk, but the combination of different measures is required. Economic aspects and limited land availability in cities emphasize the demand for multifunctional and sustainable retention areas. In the ongoing research project WaldAktiv*, we investigate the integration of existing urban forest areas into municipal flood prevention. The idea is to direct parts of the surface stormwater run-off into urban forest areas for storage and infiltration to reduce flooding in built-up areas. As study area, we use the district of Siegen-Wittgenstein, which has a high vulnerability to pluvial flooding due to its low mountain range topography. At the same time, with an area share of 71%, it is the most densely forested district in Germany and thus particularly well suited to determine corresponding potentials. However, this aim and other positive synergy effects are countered by (ecological) risks, such as the possible entry of pollutants into the forest areas, which must be taken into account during the studies.

    First, potential flow paths and terrain depressions are identified based on a digital elevation model using a topographic analysis. While flow paths are used to delineate the individual catchments, terrain depressions in the urban forest areas represent potential retention basins for stormwater run-off. Although many terrain depressions are found, the analyses show that they are rarely located in suitable areas, so that artificial retention basins may have to be created in certain forest areas. Using hydrological modelling, the capability of the forest soil in terms of infiltration is estimated based on various soil geodata sets. In order to model the measures and assess their effectiveness, hydrodynamic numerical modelling is performed for different rainfall scenarios. In this contribution, we will present methods and current findings of the research project.

    * WaldAktiv is a research project, funded by the German Federal Ministry for the Environment, Nature Conservation, Nuclear Safety and Consumer Protection (BMUV) and the district of Siegen-Wittgenstein through the project management of Zukunft – Umwelt – Gesellschaft (ZUG) gGmbH under the grant number 67DAS179.

    How to cite: Gürke, S. and Jensen, J.: Studies on the active use of urban forest areas as pluvial flood prevention, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7432, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7432, 2022.

    EGU22-8387 | Presentations | HS5.10 | Highlight

    Hydrologic performance of Natural Water Retention Measures: outcomes from the LIFE BEWARE project test site 

    Francesco Bettella, Lucia Bortolini, Tommaso Baggio, and Vincenzo D'Agostino

    The consequences of climate change are exacerbated by land-use changes, which affect the control of rainfall-runoff relations and the impact on flooding hazards. Effectively, urbanization is constantly contributing to the increase of impervious areas and reducing the time-to-peak. The effect of Natural Water Retention Measures (NWRMs) in the mitigation of these phenomena is known. Nevertheless, this kind of sustainable infrastructures are still poorly known by citizens and administrators, and consequently barely adopted in many parts of the European Countries. The LIFE BEWARE project aims to enhance hydraulic safety and spread good practices on rainwater management by promoting and facilitating the adoption of NWRMs in the Altovicentino, a highly rainy foothills area in Northern Vicenza Province (Veneto Region, Italy). In order to support the dissemination activities, some full-scale NWRMs have been realized in the area of intervention of the project. The hydrological functioning of these nature-based green infrastructures is continuously monitored thanks to the installation of devices measuring inlet and outlet runoff. The aim of this research is to present the realized NWRMs and the adopted monitoring system, and to analyze the data collected during the firsts two years. Results show that at this field-scale experiment all the monitored interventions were able to manage almost all the rainfall events occurred during these two years and the fraction of the rainfall runoff that reached the outflow was always less than 2%. Finally, the research provides insights in better understanding the behavior of NWRMs exposed to different weather and environmental conditions. This also adds some useful information at the design phase of such green infrastructure.

    How to cite: Bettella, F., Bortolini, L., Baggio, T., and D'Agostino, V.: Hydrologic performance of Natural Water Retention Measures: outcomes from the LIFE BEWARE project test site, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8387, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8387, 2022.

    EGU22-8783 | Presentations | HS5.10

    Systemic Design Approach: A Framework for a resilient urban transition 

    Stanislava Boskovic, Pepe Puchol-Salort, Vladimir Krivtsov, and Ana Mijic

    Cities are open living systems, which rely on the confluence of multiple layers of infrastructure and corresponding services. The interaction among these components is made even more complex by the demands of businesses and governments, together with constraints arising from ecological and environmental considerations. Climate change-related phenomena are putting an enormous strain on cities’ infrastructure, basic services, human livelihoods, public health and well-being. In many parts of the world concerns mount in regard to the scarcity of resources and growing risk of natural disasters (heat waves, urban flooding, droughts).  The converse also holds true, cities are major contributors to climate change through greenhouse gas emissions, notwithstanding other sources of pollution. This, together with the increase in urban growth and urbanization, results in an expansion of urban hazards - including water pollution, disease spread and issues with food security. Despite these pressing issues, we are witnessing an almost paradoxical mismatch between the needs of future cities and the practices currently used in numerous urban projects. A wholesale re-thinking of existing urban design methods at systems level (Systemic Design), is therefore not only necessary, but also provides significant opportunities to explore critical aspects of Blue-Green Infrastructure (BGI) and systematic assessment of possible future scenarios of different scales (local, urban, regional…). Nature-based solutions (NBS) are at the very core of the conception and development of BGI and provide a range of ecosystem services including alleviation of flood risk, mitigation of climatic effects, increase in biodiversity and amenity values, improvements in water quality, and further, rather more intangible benefits related to the residents’ health and wellbeing.

    In this work we provide a systemic design as an innovative and integrated approach, based on ecology and ecological design, which introduces the systematic context analysis (environmental, climatic, historic…).  A GIS-based mapping of the context, produced in relation to the functional purpose, can give us synthetic prospects to better understand the potential effectiveness of BGI solutions (design options) in relation to their wider ecosystem. The systemic design approach allows an examination of possible steps to reduce actual cities vulnerability and to explore the main drivers of urban development, climate change mitigation and urban resilience. In this way, the systemic design approach also supports decisions for further planning and anticipates actions for the management of the multifaceted hazards of the entire urban system.

    How to cite: Boskovic, S., Puchol-Salort, P., Krivtsov, V., and Mijic, A.: Systemic Design Approach: A Framework for a resilient urban transition, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8783, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8783, 2022.

    EGU22-9353 | Presentations | HS5.10 | Highlight

    Assessing Physical Processes of Permeable Pavements with a Large-Scale Laboratory Model 

    Giulia Mazzarotto, Matteo Camporese, and Paolo Salandin

    In recent decades, due to on-going urbanization and changes in rainfall patterns, urban drainage systems are facing increasing challenges. The expansion of impermeable surfaces and the increase of both frequency and intensity of rainfall events, are responsible for the augmented peak-flows and heavily polluted stormwater volumes conveyed by combined sewer overflows to water bodies. The need of assessing these challenges to mitigate the impact on water bodies’ quality has prompted International Authorities to develop standards and scientific communities to find solutions for an effective stormwater management.

    Sustainable Drainage Systems are effective at-source stormwater management solutions designed for collecting, retaining, and infiltrating direct rainfall and runoff from impervious surfaces. When properly applied in the urban drainage system, they mitigate pollution coming from wash-off of impervious surfaces and reduce both volumes and flood peaks conveyed to the drainage system.

    Among others, Permeable pavements (PPs) and infiltration trenches (ITs) are two solutions that can be easily retrofitted into the urban environment. PPs reduce surface runoff allowing direct infiltration of rainfall, whereas ITs collect runoff from nearby impervious surfaces. Both can temporally store relevant amount of water which is then slowly released to deeper native soil layers. Moreover, these systems act as filters trapping solids and pollutants onto or into the filter layers. However, physical clogging related to particle accumulation on the surface or inside the porous media reduce permeability of the system decreasing infiltration rates along time. This is a crucial aspect affecting both PPs and ITs effectiveness that must be accounted in the urban environment maintenance plans.

    A large-scale laboratory model is currently under development to analyze the main physical processes and to assess the efficiency starting first from the PPs. To this aim, a laboratory facility (Lora et al., 2016), built in the Laboratory of Hydraulics and Hydraulic Works of the Department of Civil, Environmental and Architectural Engineering (University of Padova), is being rearranged. The facility consists of a reinforced concrete box 6 m long x 2 m wide, and the height varies from 3.5 to 0.5 m. It is equipped with 50 openings on each lateral side for the insertion of probes (e.g. water content reflectometers - WCR) to continuously collect long term monitoring data in different positions. The end side of the facility is made of porous bricks allowing subsurface runoff to drain into a V-notch stream gauge. Another stream gauge is installed to measure exceeding surface runoff. During experiments, steady rainfall intensities ranging from 50 to 150 mm/h will be produced with a specifically designed rainfall simulator.

    Suitable materials for the filter layers package will be laid for 1 m total depth assessing filtration processes through the probes in three positions along the vertical. The rainfall simulator will be rearranged to guarantee uniform rainfall distribution on the PP surface characterized by a mild slope (about 2-3%).

    In the first set of experiments, the characteristics of the investigated PP will be tested in clear water condition, thus without adding suspended solids, to define the maximum infiltration capacity.

    How to cite: Mazzarotto, G., Camporese, M., and Salandin, P.: Assessing Physical Processes of Permeable Pavements with a Large-Scale Laboratory Model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9353, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9353, 2022.

    EGU22-9356 | Presentations | HS5.10

    Modelled and observed stage-discharge relationships for cobble leaky barriers with and without pipes 

    David Milledge, Adam Johnson, Tim Allott, David Brown, Donald Edokpa, Martin Evans, Salim Goudarzi, Martin Kay, Joe Rees, Emma Shuttleworth, and Tom Spencer

    Flooding is costly and disruptive in the UK and worldwide. Leaky barriers (LBs), small-scale blockages to streamflow, provide multiple environmental benefits. Depending on design, and if installed in sufficient numbers, they could also play an important role in reducing downstream flooding. Leaky barrier installation is proceeding at pace, thousands of cobble dams have been installed in peat gullies across the South Pennines (UK). However, the hydraulics of LBs in general and these cobble barriers in particular is poorly understood. Here we develop a simple model coupling two classical engineering flux estimates: Darcy/Casagrande equations for matrix flow and Colebrook equation for pipe flow (where drains are installed). We test this model against observed stage and discharge measurements for four study features with and without drains to: identify stage-discharge relationships; evaluate model performance for individual features; and apply it to model chains of features of varying design (i.e., LB density, matrix permeability, and pipe diameter). We find that: 1) stage-discharge relationships for cobble dams are concave up and are generally well captured by our simple model; 2) current designs offer relatively little attenuation because they are too permeable; 3) instead, optimal designs have low matrix permeability with pass-forward pipes at their base of a diameter tuned to design flow. Based on these results we hypothesise that LBs will perform best where they are designed to have negative permeability-depth relationships (and thus convex up stage-discharge relationships) and where the form and magnitude of the relationship is optimised to accommodate peak flood discharges.  

    How to cite: Milledge, D., Johnson, A., Allott, T., Brown, D., Edokpa, D., Evans, M., Goudarzi, S., Kay, M., Rees, J., Shuttleworth, E., and Spencer, T.: Modelled and observed stage-discharge relationships for cobble leaky barriers with and without pipes, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9356, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9356, 2022.

    EGU22-9465 | Presentations | HS5.10 | Highlight

    How to choose the most relevant Nature-Based Solutions and to assess their performances? Insight from two projects implemented on the French territory. 

    Pierre-Antoine Versini, Mario Al Sayah, Chloé Duffaut, and Daniel Schertzer

    Nature-based Solutions are presented as relevant features to make the cities more resilient in a context of global change. By providing ecosystem services, they are considered as particularly efficient solutions to mitigate urban heat islands and floods, while preserving biodiversity. Nevertheless, despite this consensus, it is still very difficult to quantitatively assess these services. Some methodologies and tools have therefore to be developed to better understand the thermo-hydric behavior of such infrastructure in relation with biodiversity, and to assess their performances across scales.

    This presentation aims to present the work carried out to solve these issues through two current projects dedicated to NBS. On the one hand, the French ANR EVNATURB project aims to develop an operational platform to assess some of the eco-system services (ie stormwater management, cooling effect, or biodiversity conservation) provided by NBS at the district scale. On the other hand, the LIFE ARTISAN project deals with the creation of a framework to promote NBS for the implementation of the national plan for adaptation to climate change (PNACC) in France by improving scientific and technical knowledge. Both aim to develop and disseminate relevant tools for project leaders (for the design, sizing, implementation and evaluation of ecosystem performance).

    The presentation of the results is particularly focused on monitored pilot sites and modelling platforms developed during these projects. In addition to these scientific investigations devoted to the thermo-hydric balance, some specific literature reviews and interviews were conducted to facilitate the choice of the more efficient species to implement, and the way to arrange NBS to optimize their performances. One of the results of this work is a dedicated database related to the a priori main ecosystem functions provided by plant species, and a list of quantitative indicators relevant for an urban project (certification, labelling, compliance with local regulations, ...) and that NBS can comply. Then this presentation concludes on remaining research gaps that have be to filled on this topic.

    How to cite: Versini, P.-A., Al Sayah, M., Duffaut, C., and Schertzer, D.: How to choose the most relevant Nature-Based Solutions and to assess their performances? Insight from two projects implemented on the French territory., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9465, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9465, 2022.

    EGU22-9468 | Presentations | HS5.10

    Development of a 3D urban canopy model for evaluating cooling effect of urban green space. 

    Seokhwan Yun, Eunsub Kim, and Dongkun Lee

    Urbanization is progressing around the world and the phenomenon of urban heat islands, where the temperature of cities increases compared to the surrounding areas due to climate change, is intensifying. Many strategies are being applied to alleviate urban heat islands, and one of them is urban greening. Urban green areas form shadows to block solar radiation, or change the rate of reflection and emission of heat caused by changes in surface environment. It also has the effect of reducing the surface temperature by increasing latent heat through the evapotranspiration occurring in the leaves. Representative urban greening strategies are street trees, green roof, and green wall. Since the cooling effect varies greatly depending on the weather environment, size of green space, and location, it is challenging to estimate the cooling effect that changes according to various environments. In this study, a three-dimensional urban canopy model was developed to evaluate the effects of various green space. This model, which simulates the copy transfer process between urban elements, first builds a domain consisting of squares of a certain size and calculates the view factor and the sky view factor. Next, the short-wave radiantion and the long-wave radiantion are simulated to calculate the net radiation. Finally, the net radiantion is partitioned into sensible heat, latent heat, and storage heat. This model can be used for efficient green space planning to reduce urban heat.

    How to cite: Yun, S., Kim, E., and Lee, D.: Development of a 3D urban canopy model for evaluating cooling effect of urban green space., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9468, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9468, 2022.

    EGU22-9488 | Presentations | HS5.10 | Highlight

    In-situ evaluation of sponge-city-type sites for urban trees to tackle flooding and heat islands 

    Anna Zeiser, Erwin Murer, Peter Strauss, Daniel Zimmermann, and Thomas Weninger

    Trees in urban environment face plenty of problems that hamper vital and long-standing growth, which would be essential to counteract urban heat island effect. The major issue is a tremendously reduced volume of appropriate rooting space due to impervious surface and highly condensed underground in the immediate surrounding. Sponge city substrate based on the model of Stockholm promises to provide conditions suitable for root growth even underneath sealed surfaces. This innovative type of substructure construction method consists of unconsolidated fine substrate flushed into the voids of edged stones that serve as load-bearing structure. If well-designed in a function-oriented manner, the volume of sponge city substrate is able to serve as an underground retention basin saving soil water for transpiration and enabling excess water to infiltrate further into the groundwater. To support the creation of such highly functional substrate-pore systems, knowledge about the effects of different materials and methods on the hydrological functions is needed.

    In Austria several projects using sponge city for urban tree planting have been implemented in recent years in various cities and municipalities. In order to increase the understanding of the system in hydrological, soil physical and implementational terms and to enable improvements and identification of reasons for malfunction, research is performed at laboratory, lysimeter and field scale. The latest monitoring project has been built in a small street in Graz, where both sides next to the street have been excavated and rebuilt with sponge city substrate. Two different substrate types have been used and 9 trees have been newly planted. The closest monitored part consists of about 100 m³ sponge city substrate, 4 trees and various types of surface design and usage including parking space, perennial plantings and a seepage basin with topsoil passage for purification of street water. Sensors measuring matric potential, volumetric water content, electrical conductivity, soil temperature, sap flow and water inflow from roof and street deliver the basic data to calculate the full water balance within this area and set up a water balance model offering the opportunity to assess the impact and potentialities of sponge city substrate in various temporal and spatial scenarios.

    Coupling data from sponge city lysimeters, laboratory experiments and other field monitoring sites an estimation of ecosystem services accomplished by this innovative construction type will be attempted. Focus will be put on retention behaviour for heavy rainfall, plant water availability as well as tree vitality, growth and transpiration.

    How to cite: Zeiser, A., Murer, E., Strauss, P., Zimmermann, D., and Weninger, T.: In-situ evaluation of sponge-city-type sites for urban trees to tackle flooding and heat islands, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9488, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9488, 2022.

    EGU22-9977 | Presentations | HS5.10

    Evaluation of Snow Management using Green Infrastructure in Subarctic Climate 

    Emelie Hedlund Nilsson, Ico Broekhuizen, Tone Merete Muthanna, and Maria Viklander

    In subarctic regions, a significant part of annual precipitation occurs as snow. This creates challenges since (a) the occurrence of rain on snow during melting season might increase runoff peak flow and cause flooding in urban areas and (b) snow needs to be removed from roofs and streets. Current snow management practice includes removal of snow to large deposits outside of cities. Downsides of this approach are the carbon footprint and air pollution caused by transport and the release of untreated polluted melt water to nearby water bodies. One strategy to reduce transport and increase treatment of meltwater could be to integrate snow deposits with existing green infrastructure that manages stormwater within the urban environment, i.e. multifunctional areas.

    When studying the potential performance of multifunctional areas with respect to snow management it is important to consider the flood risk that comes with increased snowmelt and rain on snow. Prior studies have evaluated the combined effect of frozen soils, snowmelt and rainfall during the melting season on runoff from urban catchments, but there are no similar studies on facility scale. Hydrological models can be used to investigate these factors and the snow deposit potential, without risking flooding. It is, however, unclear to what extent current urban hydrological models are suited to this purpose. This study aims to explore how hydrological models can be used to predict snow deposition volumes in multifunctional areas and the effect on runoff.

    This study used EPA SWMM because it is a commonly used urban hydrological model with a relatively advanced snow management module. The modelled facility was a grassed swale in Luleå, Northern Sweden, receiving runoff from a 60 ha catchment with commercial and light industrial land use.  The swale was separated into 6 identical parts to test different scenarios for the amount and distribution of snow deposited in the swale. The long-term performance of the swale with regard to stormwater quantity was investigated with historical rain and temperature data. Runoff from the catchment to the swales was calibrated based on observed data from late spring 2021.

    Hydrological models as a support tool for snow management using green infrastructure shows promising results. Using the model, it was possible to evaluate the effect of snow volume and placement within the swale. Such information can be of great use when designing green infrastructure and snow management strategies. However, SWMM has some limitations in this regard. For example, pollutants such as sediments (gravel, sand and micro plastics) affect the properties and melting behavior of urban snow and the release of pollutants, yet these factors are not represented in SWMM. Differences in the actual melt rate will affect the total volume of snow that can be deposited in the swale, hence this topic requires further research.

    How to cite: Hedlund Nilsson, E., Broekhuizen, I., Muthanna, T. M., and Viklander, M.: Evaluation of Snow Management using Green Infrastructure in Subarctic Climate, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9977, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9977, 2022.

    EGU22-10925 | Presentations | HS5.10

    Pedestrian Level Greenery Perception quantification 

    Marie Meulen and Maider Llaguno-Munitxa

    The implementation of Nature-based Solutions (NbS) has become a priority in many cities. The benefits of urban demineralization or ‘greening’ initiatives are manifold and range from the mitigation of the urban heat island effect, reduction of flooding risk, to improvements in the outdoor environmental quality. The positive impact on pedestrian level well-being and comfort is also to be taken into account from not only an environmental, but also a visual perspective, given the psychological benefits induced by the attractiveness to nature, and enhanced walkability of streets and squares.

    Today, the green infrastructure (GI) evaluation methods utilized in urban planning processes focus on the quantification of the total greenery ratio making use of remote sensing technologies, or often incomplete geospatial databases. The Normalized difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) deduced from aerial imagery, however, does not match the green infrastructure perception at the pedestrian level. From the geospatial databases, on the other hand, tree location and park areas can be retrieved, however these datasets only provide a partial and oversimplified description of the GI. Strategies for the implementation of range in scale and type. Aside from the diverse tree species, cities are populated by diverse grass fields, bushes, and green walls amongst others. Based on the type and distribution of each GI, the impact on the pedestrian level well-being is different. Thus, the quantification of green infrastructure requires the identification of the distinct GI and their distribution evaluated from a pedestrian perspective.  

    Our research investigates a novel methodology to quantify the perception of GI from the pedestrian perspective.  We propose to combine NDVI index metrics computed from high-resolution satellite images, with green view index metrics. Making use of a 360° six-lens camera, videos have been collected for 12 different squares selected based on their varied GI ratios and located in the neighborhoods of Saint Gilles and Molenbeek in the city of Brussels. Through Light Detection and Ranging (LiDAR) scanning technologies, point clouds have also been collected for these sites. Once the remote sensing datasets, video recordings, and scans were completed, through geospatial processing and semantic classification, the distinct GI types and ratios were quantified. Our research methodology enables a comparison between remote sensing, geospatial analysis, and first-person quantification of GI computation, and addresses the need of high-res urban environmental analysis for the development of an accurate GI infrastructural evaluation.

    How to cite: Meulen, M. and Llaguno-Munitxa, M.: Pedestrian Level Greenery Perception quantification, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10925, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10925, 2022.

    EGU22-13180 | Presentations | HS5.10

    Enhancing Kathmandu’s Urban Design Through Implementation of Green Infrastructures 

    Rupesh Shrestha, Robert Jüpner, and Thomas Thaler

    Urban areas provide a range of benefits to sustain human livelihood and contribute to human well-being through urban ecosystem services. Open spaces in core urban areas of Kathmandu valley in Nepal carries multiple advantages of stimulating social cohesion, offers safe area immediately after a crisis induced by natural hazards, contributes in environmental improvement and mitigates urban flooding. In most urban areas of Nepal, unplanned urbanization has resulted in alteration of landscapes from permeable vegetated surfaces to a series of impervious interconnected surfaces resulting in large quantities of stormwater runoff, requiring wider implementation of water sensitive urban design. After 2015 Gorkha earthquake, several blue-green infrastructure projects are implemented by local governments inside Kathmandu valley in open spaces. This paper presents application examples of green infrastructure projects and through case studies provides a framework for optimization of green infrastructure systems in Nepal. The paper also provides a practitioners perspective on the current state of knowledge, highlights technical challenges in green infrastructure implementation in Kathmandu and points out recommendations to overcome them.

    How to cite: Shrestha, R., Jüpner, R., and Thaler, T.: Enhancing Kathmandu’s Urban Design Through Implementation of Green Infrastructures, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13180, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13180, 2022.

    EGU22-13418 | Presentations | HS5.10 | Highlight

    Stratified hydraulic conductivity testing of green infrastructure: A lysimeter bioretention cell study 

    Daniel Green, Alethea Goddard, and Ross Stirling

    Bioretention cells, also referred to as ‘rain gardens’, are Green Infrastructure features with a functional role of managing urban flood risk and relieving pressure on traditional grey infrastructure systems. These Sustainable Drainage Systems (SuDS) rely on the use of soil and vegetation to attenuate and discharge stormwater via infiltration into the ground or via underground outlets into sewer networks whilst filtering pollutants in urban runoff and providing value to public space. Soil makes up a large proportion of these systems and plays a key role in providing the storage capacity for retaining stormwater and determining outflow discharges. This role is typically characterised using laboratory or in-field surface assessments of saturated hydraulic conductivity (Ksat), which provide an empirical assessment of SuDS performance. Guidance suggests that SuDS substrates should have a Ksat that ensures that systems are able to collect and store runoff to provide water retention without becoming waterlogged before the next rainfall event. However, in-field evaluations are rarely conducted due to cost and testing rarely identifies variation with depth through the soil profile.

    This paper presents in-field Ksat testing from four-purpose built, vegetated bioretention cell lysimeters at the UKCRIC National Green Infrastructure Facility, Newcastle-upon-Tyne, UK, commissioned as part of the Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) project ‘Urban Green Design and Modelling of SuDS’ (EP/S005536/1). Ksat was measured using a Soil Moisture Equipment Corporation Guelph Constant Head Field Permeameter to obtain stratified Ksat values throughout the 750 mm deep soil profile of the lysimeters. Ksat was assessed in the context of four different vegetation treatments, including an unvegetated control lysimeter, an amenity grass covered lysimeter and two mono-cropped lysimeters planted with Iris sibirica and Deschampsia cespitosa.

    Results show that Ksat values are systematically variable through the soil column and are a function of confining pressure with soil depth and wash through processes. Trends in porosity with soil depth are shown to be comparable across all lysimeter planting styles with some subtle differences associated with vegetation planting. All lysimeters feature higher Ksat values at the near-surface (ranging from 160.2 – 648.0 mm/hr at 0 – 100 mm depth), thought to be due to weathering and wash-through processes associated with near-surface soil strata being exposed to prevalent weather conditions. Where larger vegetation is present, higher Ksat values are recorded, reflecting the presence of root-derived preferential flow pathways. The depth of elevated near-surface Ksat values reflects the rooting depth and structure of the plant species studied.

    The use of a single Ksat value does not adequately capture the spatially variable hydraulic properties of bioretention systems. The results presented herein also have implications for SuDS design and maintenance, suggesting that the hydraulic properties of these systems may change through time. Consequently, SuDS scheme planners and developers should conduct multiple assessments of Ksat through the soil profile to provide robust empirically-based model parameter values to ensure that systems are fit for purpose.

    How to cite: Green, D., Goddard, A., and Stirling, R.: Stratified hydraulic conductivity testing of green infrastructure: A lysimeter bioretention cell study, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13418, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13418, 2022.

    EGU22-1911 | Presentations | HS5.11

    A tale of two methods: Uncertainties in data-driven versus model-based leakage detection and localization methods in water distribution systems. 

    Prasanna Mohan Doss, David Bernhard Steffelbauer, Marius Møller Rokstad, and Franz Tscheikner-Gratl

    Water utilities worldwide are under constant stress to reduce water loss due to urbanization, population growth, and climate change. Globally, Water Distribution Networks (WDNs) lose about 30% of the treated water on an average during supply. In addition to the amount of water lost, leaky WDNs consume additional energy and increase the risk of contamination. Deteriorating pipes and pipe network elements such as valves and joints, as well as improper pressure management are the main contributing factors for water loss in WDNs. Due to the increasing concern about water loss, leakage detection and localization have been widely researched in recent decades, both in continuously pumped and intermittently pumped systems.

    The techniques used for leakage detection and repair range from conventional methods with direct inspection on-site to model-based optimization methods. In the present era of low-cost sensors and the availability of high computing power, the transformation of WDNs into smart water systems is higher than ever. This has led to the research and development of data-driven and hybrid methods for solving leakage detection and localization methods. Irrespective of the class of methods used, their ultimate goal can be distilled primarily into two questions – a) How quickly and reliably can the presence of leak(s) be detected, and b) How accurate and precise can the location and size of the leak(s) be estimated?

    Answers to these questions include uncertainties inherent to the methods and models used, their underlying assumptions and necessary abstractions. Although much research has been done for many years to reduce uncertainties in leakage detection and localization, a comprehensive study using a consistent terminology of their types, sources, and effects on the outcome are missing. The main contribution of this work is to discuss (i) why there are uncertainties in the formulation of leakage detection and localization problem, (ii) identify the sources and types of uncertainties for different classes of modeling approaches (i.e., data-driven vs. model-based), and (iii) provide a brief review of their influence concerning error bounds from existing literature.

    How to cite: Mohan Doss, P., Steffelbauer, D. B., Rokstad, M. M., and Tscheikner-Gratl, F.: A tale of two methods: Uncertainties in data-driven versus model-based leakage detection and localization methods in water distribution systems., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1911, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1911, 2022.

    Non-stationary hydroclimatic, social, and economic stressors can potentially have temporary or permanent effects on water consumption behaviors at the individual, community, and global scale. The on-going COVID19 pandemic with prolonged Shelter in Place orders, for instance, has already transformed and is expected to further transform lifestyles and work patterns globally. Understanding how individuals change their water demand in response to evolving external conditions would provide us with better information on water demand flexibility, along with the possibility to evaluate the effects of demand management strategies (e.g., water use restrictions) and inform future operations and management of water infrastructure. Yet, existing behavioral studies on water consumption change are often limited in size (only a few households are considered), spatial scale (water demand is often aggregated at the district/city scale), or temporal scale (length of water demand time series). These limitations so far prevented a consistent comparison of the potentially heterogeneous responses of households with different socio-demographic background to different external stressors, along with a quantification of the duration of such changes.

    In this work, we investigate how individual and community-scale water consumption behaviors changed for 8871 customers in the city of Costa Mesa, California (USA) from 2002 to 2020. Three types of stressors impacted the Costa Mesa area in the considered time span: the 2008-10 and 2012-16 California droughts, the 2009 economic recession, and the first COVID-19 lockdown in 2020. Our analysis is based on bi-monthly water billing data collected at the individual account level. We developed a data-driven behavioral analysis for customer segmentation that integrates the following sequential modules: (i) quantitative water consumption change assessment for individual accounts under each of the three stressors (i.e., droughts, economic recession, and COVID-19). We identify similar behaviors by means of state-of-the-art unsupervised clustering techniques (agglomerative hierarchical clustering); (ii) pattern analysis of water consumption changes. We analyze deviations from baseline water consumption patterns using regression models; and (iii) identification of relevant socio-economic determinants as potential determinants of water consumption behavior change. We explore different subsets of explanatory determinants by means of scenario discovery algorithms. This research contributes behavioral insights on urban water consumption under non-stationary hydroclimate and socio-economic scenarios. Such insights on human-water interactions in urban areas can be ultimately exploited by utilities and decision makers alike to design and implement optimized and tailored water demand management strategies targeting short-term resilience of urban water systems under rapidly changing water demand patterns, or longer-term behavioral changes.

    How to cite: Becker, M.-P., Ajami, N., and Cominola, A.: Discovering heterogeneous water demand responses under non-stationary hydroclimatic, social, and economic stressors. A 20-year analysis in Costa Mesa (California), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4256, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4256, 2022.

    EGU22-5700 | Presentations | HS5.11

    Evaluating residential water consumption at high spatio-temporal level of detail: a Dutch case study 

    Filippo Mazzoni, Mirjam Blokker, Stefano Alvisi, and Marco Franchini

    Due to population growth, urbanization, and climate change, it is nowadays necessary to go for an ever-more adequate management of water resource in order to satisfy current and future demand. In this regard, an accurate estimation of water consumption is helpful for the implementation of strategies aimed at developing efficient water systems [1]–[2]. Strategic assessments are often carried out with the support of predictive or descriptive demand models (e.g. [3]). However, when no observed data are available, these models have to be parameterized according to predefined parameters distributions (e.g. probability distribution of duration, volume, flow rate of each end use), but the availability of this kind of information derived by field observation is rather limited.

    The current study aimed at exploring the characteristics of water consumption at nine households – different in terms of occupancy rate and end-uses – located north of Amsterdam (The Netherlands), in which smart monitoring of water consumption at 1-s temporal resolution with 0.1 L/pulse accuracy started in 2019. The aggregate water consumption observed at each household was automatically disaggregated into individual end-use events, which were then manually classified by expert analysts based on the responses of water use questionnaires subjected to household occupants. Specifically, more than 64,000 events registered over about 445 days of monitoring were labelled in five categories of indoor water use: dishwasher, washing machine, faucets, shower/bathtub, and toilet.

    Statistical analyses were then conducted for each household in order to evaluate: i) the daily per capita end-use water consumption; ii) the end-use parameter values (i.e., duration, volume, flow rate, per capita daily frequency) and their main statistical properties such as mean, variance, and probability distributions. On the one hand, the results confirmed that, on average, the largest components of the daily residential water consumption were related to the use of showers/bathtubs and toilets (43 and 30 L/person/day, respectively), followed by washing machines, faucets, and dishwashers (16, 14, and 3 L/person/day). On the other hand, the largest average volumes per event were tied to showers/bathtubs and washing machines (64 and 63 L/use), while the highest average frequency of use was observed for faucets and toilets (14 and 4 uses/person/day). Moreover, different parameter distributions were estimated, depending on the end-use and the parameter considered.

     

    References

    [1]    K. Aksela and M. Aksela. “Demand estimation with automated meter reading in a distribution network”, Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management, vol. 137, no. 5, September 2011, pp. 456–467.

    [2]    S. H. A. Koop, S. H. P. Clevers, E. J. M. Blokker, and S. Brouwer, S. "Public attitudes towards Digital Water Meters for households" Sustainability, vol. 13, no. 11, June 2021, 6440.

    [3]    E. J. M. Blokker, J. H. G. Vreeburg, and J. C. van Dijk, “Simulating residential water demand with a stochastic end-use model”, Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management, vol. 136, no. 1, January 2010, pp. 19–26.

    How to cite: Mazzoni, F., Blokker, M., Alvisi, S., and Franchini, M.: Evaluating residential water consumption at high spatio-temporal level of detail: a Dutch case study, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5700, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5700, 2022.

    EGU22-6293 | Presentations | HS5.11

    Probabilistic forecasting and scenario generation of pumped discharge in polder systems 

    Ties van der Heijden, Nick van de Giesen, Peter Palensky, and Edo Abraham

    The Netherlands is a low-lying country in the Rhine-Meuse delta. Because a large part of the Netherlands is situated below sea level, proper management of local and national waterways is a necessity. Polders are used to manage groundwater levels, drain excess rainwater and store water for droughts. Typically, pumping stations in local Dutch polders pump water up to a drainage canal (in Dutch: ‘boezem’).

    The Noordzeekanaal—Amsterdam-Rijnkanaal (NZK-ARK) is one such drainage canal, receiving discharge from the Rhine and four local water authorities. The canal connects with the North Sea in IJmuiden, through a pumping station and a set of undershot gates. The combination of pump and gate discharge allow the canal to discharge excess water to the North Sea when the sea water level is both higher and lower than the water level in the canal.

    Pump and gate discharge is scheduled through Model Predictive Control (MPC), where reliable forecasts are necessary to reliably schedule discharge. The objectives for the control system of the gates and pumps are likely to become more complex in the future. For example, the availability of renewable energy, or electricity prices are to be taken into account when scheduling pump discharge. Research has shown that regular MPC can lead to suboptimal schedules when uncertainty is introduced, for example leading to high energy costs. Stochastic MPC allows for the consideration of uncertainty in decision making, optimising control actions over a set of possible scenario’s.

    One way of generating these scenarios is by using a probabilistic forecasts. A Quantile Regression Deep Neural Network (QR-DNN) can be used to forecast quantiles of a forecast variable. When enough quantiles are considered, a Cumulative Distribution Function (CDF) can be constructed. A Bayesian Network (BN) is a graph-structured network that can estimate multi-dimensional Probability Density Functions by conditionalizing random variables according to a user defined structure and observed data. The BN can be applied to sample from the marginal CDF’s generated by the QR-DNN, while respecting autocorrelation or considering exogenous variables that are not yet considered by the QR-DNN.

    In this research, we apply probabilistic forecasting methods to generate pump discharge scenarios that can be used in a stochastic MPC for the NZK-ARK. We use actual data from the four local water authorities discharging into the NZK-ARK, and apply a QR-DNN to generate marginal CDF’s of the expected pump discharge into the NZK-ARK. A BN is then applied to generate scenarios by conditionalizing the marginal CDF’s and take multidimensional samples with autocorrelation.

    How to cite: van der Heijden, T., van de Giesen, N., Palensky, P., and Abraham, E.: Probabilistic forecasting and scenario generation of pumped discharge in polder systems, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6293, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6293, 2022.

    EGU22-6635 | Presentations | HS5.11

    Reliability metrics for permanent water network partitioning 

    Giovanni Francesco Santonastaso, Armando Di Nardo, and Roberto Greco

    The reliability of water distribution networks (WDN) can be defined as the ability of the system to meet water demands under both normal and abnormal conditions (Bao and Mays, 1990). The measure of reliability is influenced by many factors: possible failure of one or more components, unusual high demand, connectivity of the network, poor water quality, etc. Although reliability of WDN was originally defined by Goulter (1987) and Walters (1988), measuring reliability is an open challenge for researchers. Consequently, there is no established measure of WDN reliability.

    In recent years, many studies have attempted to mathematically define the reliability of water distribution networks and several synthetic indices are provided as proxy of reliability measures. The objective of this paper is to investigate the suitability of two of these metrics: one based on surplus of power head and other   on Shannon’s informational entropy for the assessment of reliability of partitioned water distribution networks (WDNs). The creation of permanent DMAs involves permanently an alteration of the WDN by closing multiple lines at the same time, and, therefore, it is a more severe test than those commonly used in the scientific literature where a little or no disruption occurs to the operation of the WDN (e.g., segment isolation or demand amplification). In addition, the two metrics were compared with other known indicators of hydraulic performance to determine which of them is better suited to evaluate the reliability of water network partitioning. For this purpose, a medium-sized water distribution network in South of Italy was used as case study and the hydraulic simulations were performed with a pressure-driven approach using EPANET2.2 software.

     

    References

    Bao, Y., Mays, L.W. (1990). "Model for water distribution system reliability",  J. Hydrual. Eng., 116, 1119-1137

    Greco, R., Di Nardo, A., Santonastaso, G.F (2012). "Resilience and entropy as indices of robustness of water distribution networks", J. Hydroinformatics, 14 (3), 761–771.

    Gouher, I.C. (1987). "Current and future use of system analysis in water distribution network design", Civ. Engrg. Sys., 4(4), 175-184.

    Walters, G. (1988). "Optimal design of pipe networks: a review." Proc.,1st Int. Conf. on Compo and Water Resour., Vol. 2, Computational Mechanics Publications, Southampton, U.K., 21-31.

    How to cite: Santonastaso, G. F., Di Nardo, A., and Greco, R.: Reliability metrics for permanent water network partitioning, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6635, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6635, 2022.

    Urban water demands vary across multiple spatio-temporal scales, driven by population growth, climate change, and urbanization. Demand-side management emerged as an important complementary measure to supply-side interventions to address urban water scarcity, foster water conservation, and inform water governance. Moreover, rapid development and deployment of Advanced Metering Infrastructure (AMI) and so-called digitalization in the water sector unfold new opportunities to uncover water demand patterns and model water demands at increasingly high spatial and temporal scales. However, challenges to modelling water demands arise from the uncertainties of water demands under abrupt environmental and societal change. The current Covid-19 Pandemic with the Stay-at-Home order is an example of such sources of uncertainty because it rapidly and unexpectedly changed people’s working patterns and lifestyles. Understanding and modelling water demands across spatial and temporal scales considering an uncertain world is, thus, key to designing robust demand management strategies.

    In this work, we investigate urban water demand changes at multiple spatio-temporal scales in Milan (Italy). We combine different state-of-art data-driven models (i.e., Ruptures breakpoint detection framework, LightGBM, Hierarchical clustering, and Recurrent Neural Networks) to extract water demand characteristics from heterogeneous data sources, including historical time series of water consumption recorded with AMI, drinking water volumes pumped in the water distribution network, and socio-demographic characteristics of different urban districts. At the city scale, we found that a significant declining trend in water consumption occurred in 2017-2020, especially during the Pandemic and the first lockdown measures. At the sub-city scale, we explored the relationships between water demand and different socio-demographic, economic, and urban form features with data from 2004 to 2020. Finally, we analyzed AMI data collected at the water account level in 2019-2021 to assess the effect of Pandemic on demand pattern change and cross-correlate it with spatial heterogeneity of neighborhood features. While the investigation of historical demand pattern change gives insights to design long-term demand management strategies, accurate prediction of future demand can help improve short-term operational efficiency for water utilities. In this regard, in the last phase of this work, we compare state-of-art predictive models to explore how accurately machine learning/deep learning models can predict water demand at city and sub-city scales. Preliminary prediction results show that advanced models like Long Short Term Memory networks (LSTM) with wavelet transform technique can attain model accuracies (R2) of 0.80 to 0.95 for 1-day ahead prediction. 

    How to cite: Hao, W., Cominola, A., and Castelletti, A.: Multi-scale Modelling of Urban Water Demand under Urban Development and Societal Uncertainties: The Case Study of Milan, Italy., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7292, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7292, 2022.

    EGU22-7315 | Presentations | HS5.11 | Highlight

    Urban water neutrality at different scales: CityPlan design and evaluation framework 

    Pepe Puchol-Salort, Jiaying Lu, Stanislava Boskovic, Ana Mijic, Barnaby Dobson, and Maarten van Reeuwijk

    London aims to build more than half a million households over the next 10 years to cope with the growing demand for housing in the UK. In this future scenario, urban water security levels will be threatened due to new development pressures combined with the climate emergency and exponential population growth in the city. In addition to this, there is a lack of agreement between the policy and decision-making sectors to decide what can be accepted as a sustainable urban development project and which are the physical and decision boundaries inside the city (i.e., while boroughs and wastewater zones present decision boundaries, new urban developments have physical boundaries only). In our previous work, we developed a new concept for urban Water Neutrality (WN) inside an operational framework called CityPlan to frame the concerns about rising water stresses in cities. This framework integrates spatial data with an integrated urban water management model, enabling urban design at systems level and delivering a new index that assesses possible future scenarios. Despite several studies related to WN, little evidence is yet available in the literature of how urban water neutrality can be achieved at different urban scales and if results might vary depending on the scale studied.

    In this work, we expand the CityPlan framework and present an innovative evaluation approach that sets several urban indicators to be tested at different urban scales. As part of the evaluation toolkit of CityPlan, we also develop the Water Efficiency Certificate (WEC) by boroughs using two novel criteria: the Housing Age Indicator (HAI) and the Device Efficiency Score (DES). The WEC evaluates the current situation of household water consumption and can be used to support predictions of water consumption under different scenarios, to study the potential for retrofitting existing residential buildings, and to develop water-efficient households. In the end, the full development of the CityPlan framework will provide a clear vision to contextualise water neutrality in urban water systems and its key role in urban water security at different urban scales.

    How to cite: Puchol-Salort, P., Lu, J., Boskovic, S., Mijic, A., Dobson, B., and van Reeuwijk, M.: Urban water neutrality at different scales: CityPlan design and evaluation framework, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7315, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7315, 2022.

    EGU22-7399 | Presentations | HS5.11 | Highlight

    Analysing the influence of different temporal resolutions of water consumption data for leakage detection and localisation 

    Martin Oberascher, Andreas Halm, Torsten Ullrich, and Robert Sitzenfrei

    Digital water meters are increasingly installed in water distribution networks providing detailed information about the water consumption in households at a high temporal resolution (e.g., ranging from seconds to daily readings). While the benefit on household scale is well described in literature (e.g., scarcity billing, awareness raising, leakage detection in domestic installations), recent research is also investigating the potential of digital water meters for an accurate fault management on network scale. In this context, water losses represent a major challenges for the operation of water distribution networks (WDNs), and a timely detection and localisation of water leakages is of greatest interest to reduce these losses. Especially model-based techniques require accurate nodal demands for the numerical simulation of the hydraulic states, which can be obtained for example by using high resolution consumption data.

    Therefore, the aim of this work is to first investigate the influence of different temporal resolution of household water consumption data and to define an optimal temporal resolution for the detection and localisation of water leakages. However, power supply (e.g., transmission interval), communication technology (e.g., packet losses), and urban population (e.g., consumer agreement to digital water meters) influence the temporal and spatial quality of data received in a real-word implementation and may differ from the optimal performance. Therefore, different methods are tested to overcome the data gaps caused by data transmission and availability uncertainties. As case study, a real WDN from a pilot project in the city of Klagenfurt is used which is extended by artificial water demand series (temporal resolution varies between 1 min and 24 h) and water leakages. Following, performance of leakage detection (data-based approach) and localisation (model-based approach) in combination with machine learning techniques is evaluated by using detection time and distance between leakage and identified location as selected indicators.

    The first results showed that the temporal resolution of consumption data influences the applicable methods for an efficient leakage detection and localisation. For example, water consumption data with a temporal resolution of 15 min allow an accurate mapping of consumption fluctuations, therefore the difference between inflow and measured values is very well suited to identify leakages. In contrast, using the same technique for 24 h consumption data (e.g., difference from inflow and daily mean value), the morning and evening peak would also be indicated as a possible leakage and thus requiring different approaches.

    How to cite: Oberascher, M., Halm, A., Ullrich, T., and Sitzenfrei, R.: Analysing the influence of different temporal resolutions of water consumption data for leakage detection and localisation, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7399, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7399, 2022.

    EGU22-7921 | Presentations | HS5.11

    Transferable surrogate models based on inductive biases of graph neural networks for water distribution systems 

    Bulat Kerimov, Franz Tscheikner-Gratl, and David Steffelbauer

    Water utilities tackle various problems in planning and operating their systems with complex and computationally expensive hydraulic models, i.e., maximizing system resilience, fault isolation, risk assessment, optimal pump scheduling, or water loss reduction via pressure management. To meet limited computational budgets, engineers employ less resource-intensive surrogate models. Current surrogate models based on artificial neural networks deliver similar accuracies as hydraulic models with lower computational costs. However, they require retraining when applied to an unknown water distribution system, which increases their computational load and limits their general applicability. Recent advancements in graph-based machine learning address these limitations. Graph neural networks (GNNs) naturally connect with the network elements (e.g., pipes and valves with edges, junctions, and tanks with vertices)  of water distribution systems, proving themselves to be a promising candidate for surrogate modeling. Once trained on a specific network to be a surrogate model, GNNs possess inductive biases that allow transferability to an unseen topology. In this work, we adopted a demand-driven simulation of a water distribution system in a graph machine learning setting. We built a synthetic dataset of demand-driven simulation with EPANET, founded on the example of real-world water distribution systems, and trained an attention-based GNN to emulate the hydraulic simulator. The accuracy was evaluated inductively on an unseen larger-sized water distribution network. We observed that the model showed promising transferability results to a larger network without the need for additional re-training on the unseen topology.

    How to cite: Kerimov, B., Tscheikner-Gratl, F., and Steffelbauer, D.: Transferable surrogate models based on inductive biases of graph neural networks for water distribution systems, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7921, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7921, 2022.

    EGU22-8046 | Presentations | HS5.11

    One model fits all – on the generalizability of pipe deterioration models between utilities 

    Shamsuddin Daulat, Marius Møller Rokstad, Stian Bruaset, and Franz Tscheikner-Gratl1

    For proactive management of water distribution pipe networks, one pre-requisite is to predict either pipe failure probability for risk assessment on a tactical level or life expectancies for budget allocation on a strategic level or preferably both. Machine learning methods are documented to provide promising results for predicting water distribution pipe failures. Still, they rely on a considerable amount of data, which is seldom available with sufficient quality. Especially, small municipalities lack the required amount and quality of data to utilize the benefits of machine learning models. This study aims to train a deterioration model based on random survival forests (RSFs) by using datasets from several utilities in Norway and testing the model’s usability for the individual networks to assess its generalizability. The benefit of using RSFs is twofold: 1) it can model complex relationships between the variables and output, 2) it accounts for right-censored data. The method is tested on pipe failure data from nine different, small to medium-sized water utilities. Furthermore, this work highlights the possibilities and limitations of such a machine learning approach.

    How to cite: Daulat, S., Rokstad, M. M., Bruaset, S., and Tscheikner-Gratl1, F.: One model fits all – on the generalizability of pipe deterioration models between utilities, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8046, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8046, 2022.

    EGU22-8049 | Presentations | HS5.11

    Water Supply Networks with Dynamically Adaptive Connectivity and Hydraulic Conditions: Design and Control 

    Ivan Stoianov, Filippo Pecci, and Aly-Joy Ulusoy

    Water utilities around the globe are facing an extraordinary demand for the secure supply of potable water as a result of population growth, urbanisation and climate change. New knowledge, technologies and systems-based approaches are urgently needed to adaptively optimise resource capacity, operations and assets utilisation during a time of escalating environmental, regulatory and financial pressures.
    This presentation summarises fundamental mathematical and engineering challenges for the design, optimisation and control of next generation water supply networks. These networks dynamically change connectivity (topology), hydraulic conditions and operational objectives. The design and control of dynamically adaptive water supply networks aims to improve pressure management, resilience, efficiency, incident management and sustainability.
    The current ability of complex water networks to dynamically adapt their connectivity, operational conditions and application objectives is extremely limited. Water supply networks are operated as disjointed (or loosely coupled) sub-systems that have evolved over many years. The operational practice of sub-dividing water supply networks into small discrete areas, District Metered Areas (DMAs), has been successfully implemented by the UK water industry to reduce leakage in excess of 30% in the last 25 years. A DMA has a fixed network topology with permanent boundaries, typically a single inlet and it includes between 1,000 and 3,000 customer connections. By closing boundary valves to form small metered areas, the natural redundancy of connectivity and supply within large looped networks is severely reduced; thus affecting operational resilience, water quality and energy losses. Consequently, the implementation of DMAs has introduced operational constraints that affect both consumers and utilities. Furthermore, these constraints are beginning to inflict financial penalties upon water utilities through recently introduced performance indicators.
    The dynamically adaptive sectorisation and configurability of water supply networks that we have pioneered combines the benefits of the traditional DMA approach for leakage management with the advantages of substantially improved resilience and considerably enhanced management of pressure, energy, failure incidents and water quality. This operational method includes the replacement of a subset of kept-shut boundary and control valves with self-powered network controllers with varying modulation functions. The controllers modify the network connectivity and continuously monitor and control the hydrodynamic conditions. To enable this new approach, we have been developing novel monitoring, modelling and control methods and technologies. We have been extensively evaluating these in operational networks. 
    In this presentation, we summarise design-for-control strategies to improve the pressure management and resilience of sectorized water distribution networks (WDN). We formulate the mathematical optimization problems and describe solution methods for the resulting large-scale non-linear (NLP) and multi-objective mixed-integer non-linear programs. We also discuss analytical and engineering challenges for the scalable implementation of these methods. 

    How to cite: Stoianov, I., Pecci, F., and Ulusoy, A.-J.: Water Supply Networks with Dynamically Adaptive Connectivity and Hydraulic Conditions: Design and Control, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8049, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8049, 2022.

    EGU22-10025 | Presentations | HS5.11 | Highlight

    Probabilistic water demand forecasting focussing on the impact of climate change and the quantification of uncertainties in the short- and mid-term 

    Gregor Johnen, Jens Kley-Holsteg, Andre Niemann, and Florian Ziel

    As could be seen in recent years, the impact of climate change is already detectable in water demand patterns and results in new challenges for the water supply sector. Demand peaks caused by changing climate conditions such as longer dry periods force water suppliers to a more efficient control and management of their assets and water resources to avert supply shortages. Especially demand peaks of multiple hours during the day or persisting demand peaks of several days and weeks threaten the supply demand-balance. By utilizing accurate forecasts of the expected water demand, suppliers are enabled to better prepare their assets for such extreme conditions.

    To adapt to the consequences of changing hydro-climatic and demand conditions, this research proposes a water demand forecasting model to predict such extreme demand conditions caused by climate change for the short- to mid-term range. Here, a special emphasis is put on modelling the impact of weather variables on the water consumption caused by climate change. Those effects are complex, non-linear and multidimensional in nature and therefore challenging to model. Focusing on the practical usage, the forecasting model is appropriate for real-time application providing accurate forecasts coupled with a high interpretability. This allows the quantification of the ongoing effects of climate change and enables a better consideration of the underlying uncertainty.

    Our case study uses real data on district level from two regions in West and Central Germany. To appropriately account for the practical need of varying forecast schemes, historical demand and weather data are used at quarter-hourly, hourly as well as daily resolution.

    Multiple linear, non-linear and stacked models tailored to the forecasting purpose and the varying horizons are implemented with a clear focus on interpretability and forecasting accuracy. To model the underlying uncertainty, complete probablistic forecasts are proposed. Model assessment takes place by utilizing appropriate metrics as the MAE, CRPS or energy score.

    How to cite: Johnen, G., Kley-Holsteg, J., Niemann, A., and Ziel, F.: Probabilistic water demand forecasting focussing on the impact of climate change and the quantification of uncertainties in the short- and mid-term, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10025, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10025, 2022.

    EGU22-11444 | Presentations | HS5.11

    Optimal real-time control of water distribution systems undergoing cyber-physical attacks 

    Andres Murillo, Davide Salaorni, Riccardo Taormina, and Stefano Galelli

    In recent years, researchers have developed intrusion detection tools to improve the security of Water Systems in the presence of novel and sophisticated cyber-attacks. Nevertheless, such tools lack prescriptive analytics conceived to determine the best course—that is, how to control a system undergoing an attack. Here, we fill in this gap by presenting a numerical modelling framework based on the coupling of DHALSIM with a Deep Q-Learning agent.  The former is a simulation environment providing a high-fidelity representation of both hydraulic processes and ICT devices, while the latter is an optimal control algorithm tasked with the problem of curbing the impact of cyber-physical attacks by re-operating key hydraulic devices, such as pumps and valves. Their integration is made feasible thanks to a new feature implemented in DHALSIM—the stepwise simulation—allowed by the addition of a new simulator wrapper, namely Epynet. The evaluation phase is run considering the system in normal operating conditions and undergoing cyber-attacks. Our results show a good behaviour in terms of Demand Satisfaction Ratio. In particular, the control agent manages to satisfy the customers demand, without overflowing the tanks in the system.  To our knowledge, these results are the first in the unexplored area of attack recovery in water distribution systems.

    How to cite: Murillo, A., Salaorni, D., Taormina, R., and Galelli, S.: Optimal real-time control of water distribution systems undergoing cyber-physical attacks, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11444, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11444, 2022.

    EGU22-11531 | Presentations | HS5.11

    Cellular Automata-based high-resolution hydrological modeling for urban digital water information 

    Seong Jin Noh, Eunhyung Lee, Hyeonjin Choi, Garim Lee, and Sanghyun Kim

    In this study, we propose and evaluate a Cellular Automata (CA)-based high-resolution hydrological model for an urban digital water information framework. Pluvial flooding in the extreme events and water balance in the non-rainy seasons are usually simulated by different modeling frameworks hampering holistic understandings of the complex water cycle in the urbanized areas. However, for smart water systems such as digital twins or multiverse, street-resolving, high-fidelity water information is required regardless of types of hydrologic events. To provide seamless urban water information on the digital world such as digital twins, Cellular Automata, a rule-based machine learning technique, is adopted and extended to simulate continuous hydrological variables such as inundation depth, infiltration, soil water content, and evapotranspiration in the complex urbanized domain. A proto-type CA model is implemented in the Oncheon-Cheon catchment in Busan, South Korea, which is highly urbanized and vulnerable to pluvial flooding. In the presentation, we discuss advances and challenges in machine learning-based integrated urban water modeling.

    How to cite: Noh, S. J., Lee, E., Choi, H., Lee, G., and Kim, S.: Cellular Automata-based high-resolution hydrological modeling for urban digital water information, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11531, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11531, 2022.

    EGU22-13089 | Presentations | HS5.11

    Youth-led Participatory Sensing (YPS) Model to enhance drinking water security: a case study of Pokhara Metropolitan City, Nepal 

    Amrita Gautam, Lars Ribbe, Karl Schneider, Sudan Panthi, and Mahesh Bhattarai

    Water supply for drinking purpose with adequate quality is a global challenge. Majority of the developing countries face serious problems in proper technology and management strategy to regulate drinking water quality, though there are numerous cases of adverse health impacts. Population growth, unsystematic urbanization and improper management of the resources are some of the pressing factors. In Nepal, about 80% of prevalent communicable diseases are due to poor sanitation and lack of access to quality water. The coverage and functionality of the water supply system is still crucial owing to the degraded quality of water. In fact, there is no data available on water quality. Despite huge investment in implementing Water Safety Plan (WSP) approach in developing regions, many countries still lack the baseline water quality data (information flow) in the water supply system. Nepal is one of the countries where WSP is implemented for a long time (more than a decade) but the regular drinking water monitoring mechanism is still a matter of question. Studies have mentioned Water, Sanitation and Hygiene (WASH) practices in schools and possibilities of involving schools in WSP programs as well but the systematic method and model to integrate Youth/ Students and Information and Communication Technologies (ICTs) in Drinking Water Quality Monitoring is yet unexplored. In addition, the data accuracy of Citizen Based Monitoring needs to be checked. Therefore, the first phase of this research has developed a suitable design of Youth-led Participatory Sensing (YPS) to improve water supply management facility, including the strategy to support Climate Resilient Water Safety Plan (CR-WSP) framework of the local water utilities and, this paper highlights on performance evaluation and accuracy of data acquired from YPS Model with paired experimental approach, and gamified techniques in designing the participation from training to field implementation, including the community awareness targets for the selected water supply schemes of Pokhara Metropolitan City (PMC), Nepal, which can be validated and replicated in similar urban or peri-urban settings of national, regional and the global context.

    Keywords:

    Youth-led Participatory Sensing (YPS), Drinking Water Security, Water Quality, ICTs, Water Supply Schemes, CR-WSPs

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kS71uqFnjF0&t=66s

    • A video link about a part of the on-going doctoral research work in Nepal

    How to cite: Gautam, A., Ribbe, L., Schneider, K., Panthi, S., and Bhattarai, M.: Youth-led Participatory Sensing (YPS) Model to enhance drinking water security: a case study of Pokhara Metropolitan City, Nepal, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13089, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13089, 2022.

    EGU22-57 | Presentations | HS5.12

    Process modification and low-cost intervention of an old sewage treatment plant to improve biological nutrient removal 

    Reshma Mohan Thattaramppilly, Lakshminarayana Rao, Mohan Kumar Mandalagiri S, and Chanakya Hoysall Narayana

    Typically, municipal wastewater is collected from cities and is treated at centralized sewage treatment plants (STPs), which are then discharged to nearby surface water bodies.  A city placed downstream picks up this water from the water body for its usage.  As the distance between the cities gets closer with increasing population and urbanization, treating the wastewater in STPs to a much higher treatment standard becomes necessary.  A 2–5-day interval is assumed between the point of discharge and the offtake point into the next town /city downstream.  This interval has now shortened to a few hours, especially in the developing world. Another issue is about the life of the STP and the reigning norms for treatment quality.  Many of these centralized STPs have a typical life of about 25-30 years and are designed to achieve specific effluent discharge standards formulated when designing them. However, these effluent discharge standards have been made more stringent over the years, requiring municipalities to improve the treated wastewater quality every decade. Therefore, to meet new discharge standards, there is a need to modify or remodel these old STPs.  This can be achieved either by process modifications or retrofitting existing STPs with modern machinery.  However, retrofitting an existing STP can be an expensive proposition; also, it is time-consuming in terms of design, approval, construction, and commissioning.  Thus, it is better to modify the treatment process while retaining the plant capacity to its original design.  Mathematical models are useful tools for optimization and process modifications of STPs.

    In this work, a plant-wide BioWin - activated sludge mathematical model was developed for the 55 MLD treatment unit in the KC valley sewage treatment plant in Karnataka, India. The model was calibrated using STOWA protocol and validated with experimental field results. Eight process equations, including fifty state variables, were solved for the modeling. In order to improve plant performance, a modification in the treatment process was proposed. The proposal was to introduce anoxic/anaerobic zones in between the existing aeration zones in the plant to improve simultaneous nitrification-denitrification and total dissolved phosphorous (TDP) removal.  Several sensitivity analyses were carried out to identify the optimized operating conditions for this process modification. The dissolved oxygen and mixed liquor suspended solid concentrations in the aeration zones were varied from 2.5 to 4 mg/L and 2500 to 4500 mg/L, respectively, until the optimized conditions were achieved. The modifications were then implemented in the 55 MLD unit with minimal intervention and without shutting down the plant. The plant performance, as predicted by the model, improved after the modification.  The effluent's total nitrogen and TDP values were reduced from 20 mg/L to 8 mg/L and 3.5 mg/L to 0.9 mg/L before and after the modification. All other parameters effluent parameters were also within the standard discharge limits. Also, a total saving of 2,60,2490 USD in capital costs and 1,48,910 USD in operational costs was achieved by this modification.

    How to cite: Mohan Thattaramppilly, R., Rao, L., Mandalagiri S, M. K., and Hoysall Narayana, C.: Process modification and low-cost intervention of an old sewage treatment plant to improve biological nutrient removal, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-57, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-57, 2022.

    EGU22-2819 | Presentations | HS5.12 | Highlight

    Designing a Satellite-Based Smart Health Water Related Platform for Lake’s Water Quality Monitoring in Nordic Cities 

    Amirhossein Ahrari, Ali Torabi Haghighi, Pekka Rossi, and Mourad Oussalah

    Water Quality Management (WQM) in the 21st century is a growing challenge because of the large number of chemicals used in our everyday lives and industry, which often make their way into our waters  outbreaks of waterborne infectious diseases are still a public health concern in developed countries. More than 50% of European surface water bodies are either in less than good ecological status or potentially in worse condition. These trends reflect the need to shift from basic responsiveness to a comprehensive, multidisciplinary approach that involves communities to improve access to safe water and improve the quality of water bodies. In this research project, we will design a mobile app platform for a Smart Water Quality Monitoring/Warning System based on Remote Sensing (RS) images and available in situ data for City of Oulu as one of the leading smart cities in Europe. This platform will forecast Water Quality (WQ) parameters for open lakes that people often use for swimming and leisure activities. It works as an early warning system to notify people about WQ in advance. The following parts will constitute the proposed Smart Water Quality Monitoring/Warning System (SWQMS): 1) Data collection from Landsat and Sentinel-2, 2) Data processing and information extraction about WQ criteria, 3) Designing a user interface to notify WQ condition to the community before planning for activities  4) real-time updating based on the inhabitant feedback on appearence water condition (Color, Turbidity etc.).  Along with the processing steps, this project faces some challenges on 1) Finding the best algorithm for WQ measurement in Nordic regions, 2) Improving temporal frequency in mid-resolution satellites in the cloudy sky, 3) Identifying the best machine learning approach to monitor and predict WQ in remote sensing, 4) combining remote sensing and GIS technology to designing a web-based early warning platform.

    Two open lakes in north of Oulu City have been considered: 1) Kuivasjärvi and 2) Pyykosjärvi. These lakes are located in a populated area and are widely used for swimming and fishing in summertime. Eutrophication problems significantly face lakes due to the low oxygen content of the water and the prolonged water circulation because of specific layouts and geometry. Besides, due to their specific locations at the heart of densely populated areas, their quality are important for inhabitants’ health and the City of Oulu. Two lakes are connected through a narrow stream, and the lower lake (kuivasjärvi) is mainly fed by upper lakes and drain water of the watershed. The outlet of kuivasjärvi discharges into the Bay of Bothnia.

    Finally, this platform is going to help to have a safe leisure activities in open lakes and even coastal regions so it can be extended to all around the world. By this application, it is expected to significantly reduce the number of water related disease outbreakes which are caused by swimming in open lakes and coastal regions.

    How to cite: Ahrari, A., Torabi Haghighi, A., Rossi, P., and Oussalah, M.: Designing a Satellite-Based Smart Health Water Related Platform for Lake’s Water Quality Monitoring in Nordic Cities, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2819, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2819, 2022.

    EGU22-3154 | Presentations | HS5.12

    An integrated multi-criteria approach for urban drainage system design considering spatial equity 

    Omid Seyedashraf, Andrea Bottacin-Busolin, and Julien J. Harou

     The application of optimisation approaches to the spatial design of urban water systems can result in unequal distributions of infrastructure services among different communities unless spatial equity objectives are explicitly considered. Differences between urban communities can be exacerbated if the co-benefits of water infrastructure are not properly distributed over the urban catchment. This is especially important when designing sustainable urban drainage systems, which carry several co-benefits in addition to the attenuation of stormwater runoff,  such as the improvement of urban landscape and mental health of the residents. In this work, we propose a new multi-objective optimisation framework that takes into account both cost-effectiveness and socio-economic aspects of urban drainage infrastructure design. The proposed framework considers the minimisation of capital costs, average flood damages, and total suspended solids as design objectives, as well as the minimisation of inequalities in the spatial distribution of flood damages and green infrastructure benefits quantified via appropriate equity metrics. A population-based multi-objective optimisation method is linked to a hydrologic-hydraulic model to determine a set of Pareto-optimal design portfolios associated with different trade-offs between traditional drainage design objectives and social goals. The proposed multi-criteria design approach was applied to a synthetic case study where sustainable urban drainage systems are used to expand the drainage capacity of an existing pipe network. The results demonstrate the applicability of the proposed methodology to the design of urban drainage systems and provide insights into the trade-offs between overall cost-effectiveness and social equity in urban infrastructure design decisions.

    How to cite: Seyedashraf, O., Bottacin-Busolin, A., and Harou, J. J.: An integrated multi-criteria approach for urban drainage system design considering spatial equity, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3154, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3154, 2022.

    EGU22-5887 | Presentations | HS5.12

    Assessing the environmental impact of combined sewer overflows through a parametric study 

    Alessandro Farina, Armando Di Nardo, Rudy Gargano, and Roberto Greco

    Design and management of combined sewer overflows (CSO) have been, so far, mainly based only on complying a fixed dilution rate of wastewater in stormwater during rain events. This poses serious environmental issues since the definition of the acceptable dilution (i.e. overflows are usually designed for activation when Q > ~5Qmw, the latter being the mean dry weather wastewater discharge) does not consider the characteristics of the upstream urban catchment nor those of the receiving water body. Accordingly, more recent regulations started enforcing limits also on the yearly number of overflows or increasing dilution coefficient.

    Overflows activation frequency and discharged volumes of pollutants may depend on the upstream catchment features as well as on the precipitation regime. The great variability of these factors could make the impact on the receiving water body of similarly designed overflows to be quite different.

    In this study, the behaviour of a CSO with fixed dilution rate placed at the outlet of urban catchments with same size, but different hydrological and urbanistic characteristics, has been simulated through SWMM multi-scenario simulations. The considered hydrological parameters were catchment imperviousness, width, slope, routing Manning coefficient and depression storage for both pervious and impervious surfaces. Urbanistic characteristics of the catchment affecting the combined sewer hydraulic regime were studied by changing the density of population, the imperviousness, and the mean per capita wastewater discharge.

    After defining realistic ranges for each parameter, the time series of discharged overflows have been calculated for all the combinations of the variable catchment parameters, corresponding to 20 years long precipitation time series of a single rain gauge.

    The obtained results indicate that CSOs impact on the receiving water body, strongly depends on the characteristics of the upstream urban catchment. Therefore, such characteristics should be considered in CSO design and management.

    How to cite: Farina, A., Di Nardo, A., Gargano, R., and Greco, R.: Assessing the environmental impact of combined sewer overflows through a parametric study, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5887, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5887, 2022.

    RainWater Harvesting (RWH) and the use of the collected rainwater for the irrigation of urban green areas allow saving potable water resources with respect to a traditional supply from the urban water distribution system. The potential for RWH and reuse depends on the urban surfaces made available for rainwater collection, the associated runoff coefficient and the statistics about the frequency and intensity of rainfall events in the region (the rainfall climatology), compared to the irrigation demand.

    In this work we present a case study of a RWH system in course of realization within a reconversion project of a former military area, located in Genova (Italy). The project provides for the rainwater, suitably treated if necessary, to be collected and used for irrigation in the park. Three rainwater collection scenarios (from ground surfaces, sheet metal roof and brick roof) are investigated also by varying the size of the storage tank from 30 to 480 cubic meters. The daily rainfall data as observed in the period 1833-2008 in Genova are used.

    We implement a behavioural model to simulate the operation of the RWH system in different conditions. The model is updated with a suitable algorithm for the optimization of the irrigation system in case of significant precipitation events and in the following days. The algorithm accounts for the actual soil water availability for the vegetation and its decay with time, considering the soil type and vegetation.

    As the performance indicators for the RWH system, two temporal reliability indexes (fraction of time when storage is not empty and when the demand is fully met) and two volumetric reliability indexes (efficiency and overflow ratios) are calculated per each scenario, upon varying the size of the tank. Finally, the detention time is calculated to assess the water quality deterioration while stored in the tank. The optimal sizing of the storage tank and the mean annual potable water saved are calculated for the three examined rainwater collection scenarios and compared.

    The results of the present case study can be applied to a larger scenario by contributing to the cost reduction for irrigation of green urban areas, the street washing and the toilet flushing that do not require using precious potable water.

    How to cite: Cauteruccio, A. and Lanza, L. G.: A case study of a rainwater harvesting system for the irrigation of green areas within an urban reconversion project, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6047, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6047, 2022.

    Anaerobic ammonium oxidation (anammox) has been recognized as a promising microbial denitrification technique in recent years,duing to  the treatment of high-strength ammonium wastewater. Compared to typical nitrification and denitrification methods, the anammox process transforms ammonium  and nitrite to nitrogen gas , and saves up to 60% of energy on aeration, sludge disposal and organic carbon addition. Furthermore, the process reduces greenhouse gas emissions by more than 25%, particularly in the production of nitrous oxide (N2O). However, the anaerobic ammonia oxidation bacteria (AnAOB) are very sensitive and vulnerable to many inhibitors, especially antibiotics in wastewater. In this study, the feasibility of applying electric fields to mitigate inhibition of tetracycline (TC) on anammox process and improve system stability was evaluated. Three electric field intensities of 1, 3 and a variable intensity of 1-6 V (VEF) were used to optimize electric field intensity under gradually increasing addition of TC (0.5, 2 and 10 mg·L-1). Results showed that the application of electric fields (3 V and VEF) could improve TC tolerance and keep relatively high-efficiency nitrogen removal performance, especially at TC ≥ 2 mg·L-1. Furthermore, applying electric fields contributed to mitigate irreversible inhibition and improve the stability of community structure. Underlying mechanism analysis indicated that the main mechanism of applying electric fields to mitigate inhibition relies on sludge structure strengthening. This study explored a novel strategy to reduce the inhibition of antibiotics on microbial denitrification and broaden the application of anammox in industrial water treatment.

    How to cite: Cheng, B.: Application of electric fields to mitigate inhibition on anammox consortia under long-term tetracycline stress, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6291, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6291, 2022.

    EGU22-6860 | Presentations | HS5.12 | Highlight

    Optimal detention ponds in urban drainage systems 

    Azadeh Hosseinzadeh, Ali Torabi Haghighi, Pekka M. Rossi, Kourosh Behzadian, and Mozhgan Karami

    Urban development and the increase of impervious surfaces have a broad impact on the hydrological cycle leading to increased peak flow and flooding, especially in downstream areas. Surface water detention ponds are among the most common measures to attenuate the peak flow and return it from development to pre-development conditions. The effect of these ponds on reducing a flood depends on the location and the dimensions. This paper presents a new framework for identifying the best strategies for using the detention ponds to flood control in urban drainage systems. The stormwater management model (SWMM) was applied for hydraulic and hydrological simulations of urban drainage systems. In addition, a multi-objective optimisation model was used to find the optimal location and size of detention ponds. The effect of physiographic and social factors on selecting ponds was analysed by simulating and examining the GIS environment. Based on the criteria reviewed in the previous steps, the best management solutions were prioritised by a multi-criteria decision-making method (MCDM) named Compromise Programming (CP). The methodology was then demonstrated on the real-world case study of the Karaj city basin in Iran. The results show that these detention ponds can improve current drainage performance and decrease flooding damage.

    How to cite: Hosseinzadeh, A., Torabi Haghighi, A., Rossi, P. M., Behzadian, K., and Karami, M.: Optimal detention ponds in urban drainage systems, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6860, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6860, 2022.

    EGU22-9484 | Presentations | HS5.12

    Integrating urban development and stormwater management; Car parking allocation in north of Finland 

    Pekka M. Rossi, Azadeh Hosseinzadeh, Ali Torabi Haghighi, Abolfazl Jalali Shahrood, Tarja Outila, and Johannes Jutila

    Intensified urbanization and climate change alter natural water systems, resulting in urban flooding. To overcome this issue, urban development decisions should align with resiliency needs including stormwater management. Integrating stormwater management within urban planning helps us to design more sustainable alternative systems. Developing vacant or underused areas which leads to changes of imperviousness percentage, hence influences runoff volume, is a key action in urban development. We investigated the effect of car parking allocation on stormwater management in urban areas. In this analysis, several car parking allocation scenarios are considered for this analysis in three independent urban areas in Oulu, northern Finland. These areas are encountering some changes in land use and new construction based on their approved detailed plan. We used a calibrated Stormwater Management Model (SWMM) to simulate different redevelopment scenarios. In this study, impact of climate change is addressed by comparing a range of precipitation values. Based on the results a promising structure is provided that decreases flooded areas in the future. Results indicate, that we can conduct stormwater flood management more efficiently by changing regulations in urban planning in the context of car parking, which helps us construct more green infrastructure instead of grey ones; in addition, changes in people's mobility habits and behavior which is affected on urban structure indirectly contributes to stormwater control.

    How to cite: Rossi, P. M., Hosseinzadeh, A., Torabi Haghighi, A., Jalali Shahrood, A., Outila, T., and Jutila, J.: Integrating urban development and stormwater management; Car parking allocation in north of Finland, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9484, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9484, 2022.

    EGU22-10001 | Presentations | HS5.12

    Integrated redundancy measure for the analysis of water distribution network 

    Jyotsna Pandey and Venkata Srinivas Vemavarapu

    The directional nature and complex interconnections of a water distribution network (WDN) layout make it challenging to analyze its performance. The interplay of nodes and links in a WDN creates inherent redundancy in the network layout, which should be accounted for in performance assessment. Previous studies mainly focussed on the hydraulic nature of WDN redundancy. In this respect, to understand the importance of topological configuration on the performance of WDN, it is imperative to have proper measures to provide a comprehensive picture of the WDN redundancy. This study presents a new redundancy measure that integrates topological and hydraulic redundancies. Complex network theory (CNT) offers an option to gain insight into the topological behavior of a WDN. Nodal indegree, a directional CNT metric based on connections incident on a node, can provide information about the redundancy of various configurations of WDNs. Hydraulic nodal redundancy index is based on entropy value of demand fraction determined based on incident pipes/links. Our investigations indicate a high correlation between hydraulic redundancy and indegree ranging from 0.80 to 0.99, implying that nodal indegree is an effective CNT metric. The effectiveness of the proposed integrated redundancy measure is demonstrated by application to WDNs having different configurations (tree, looped, and mixed). The study gives new insight into the overall redundant nature of WDNs. The integrated redundancy measure is found to be better for evaluating existing WDNs and analyzing new network layouts at the planning and design stage.

    How to cite: Pandey, J. and Vemavarapu, V. S.: Integrated redundancy measure for the analysis of water distribution network, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10001, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10001, 2022.

    EGU22-10872 | Presentations | HS5.12

    ­Water Affordability Challenges in Urban Water Systems 

    Yeldar Mussatayev and Siamac Fazli

    A vital prerequisite for the quality of living in settlements is uninterrupted access to water supply and sanitation. However, the affordability of users to be provided with drinking and wastewater services is challenging in developed and developing countries. Moreover, there is no broad understanding of the water affordability concept and how the tariffs of urban water systems are associated with different economic wealth indicators.

    This study investigates water tariffs and affordability in global urban water and wastewater systems. Our data is compiled from the International Water Association (IWA) and the World Bank. This data covers over 60 countries and 190 cities in a time range from 2010 to 2019, divided by geography (Africa, Asia, Australia and Oceania, Europe, North America and South America) and income level (High, Upper Middle, Lower Middle and Low income).  In addition, information on water sources, delivery, consumption and tariffs for drinking water (including sewage), and financial indicators of the countries (minimum wage, average income, GDP, exchange rate to US dollar and others) are considered in this work.

    Our analysis aims to answer the following research questions: Is it possible to find computational models to identify patterns that can understand the current situation and predict future outcomes of water affordability? If yes, to what degree is it possible and what are the limitations of this approach? Are there actual thresholds for sustainable water use in urban water systems? How can these be inferred from the data?

    Our preliminary results and visualizations demonstrate a significant difference between developed and developing countries in the water supply and a lack of a single approach to tariff setting. Some countries could not collect reliable data for each year, complicating the study’s objectivity. As a result, the use of recognized and reliable algorithms to predict and fill in missing data could help complete the data and thus obtain a clear picture of the worldwide differences in water availability. Therefore, our study might be helpful to the scientific community in developing approaches to inequitable water allocation and economical water consumption.

    How to cite: Mussatayev, Y. and Fazli, S.: ­Water Affordability Challenges in Urban Water Systems, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10872, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10872, 2022.

    EGU22-12115 | Presentations | HS5.12

    Climate-justified strategies for sustainable urban water supply system: sources diversification in Almaty city, Kazakhstan 

    Ali Torabi Haghighi, Aziza Baubekova, and Stefanos Xenarios

    Kazakhstan is a country in transition experiencing a rapid urbanization process with the highest rate in Almaty, the former capital of the country and the largest metropolis in the whole region. Over the past ten years, the city area has doubled its size. Being a concentration of economic and political power, Almaty attracts people from rural areas and neighboring states. Uncontrolled migration of the population leads to disproportional development of the city with inequality between the center and the periphery of the city. Rapid economic development and city growth led to increased per-capita water use and overall water demand and put pressure on water infrastructure. Such the foothill areas of Almaty, the southern part of the Nauryzbay, Bostandyk, and Medeu districts are experiencing a shortage of water supply due to low productivity, deterioration, or absence of networks and facilities. The city is located at the foothills of the northern Tien Shan Mountains in the valley of 4 rivers: Big and Small Almatinka, Esentay, and Kargaly. Climate change led to severe changes in Central Asia at high altitudes, including two times higher than the global average temperature rise and rapid glacier retreat. Shrinking glaciers supply ample quantities of water in the form of increased glacial runoff, and reduced glacier volume will ultimately result in a decrease in both glacier-fed and total runoff. There is no reduction in streamflow in any catchment or season in the northern Tien Shan. Instead, there is a positive trend in surface water availability.  At the same time, climate change poses the risk of more prolonged recharge of reservoirs and aquifers and may cause exhaustion of this water source that currently provides 70% of water for the city. Therefore, envisioning a long-term sustainable development perspective for a city, water resource efficiency, and climate change adaptation should be addressed together. Thus, our study suggests for the short term to limit the use of strategic groundwater reserves and diversify the water supply sources with a bigger share of surface water to benefit from the melting glacials. If the water allocation from groundwater reservoirs will be reduced and the aquifers will be recharged the water deficit for the city may be postponed.

    How to cite: Torabi Haghighi, A., Baubekova, A., and Xenarios, S.: Climate-justified strategies for sustainable urban water supply system: sources diversification in Almaty city, Kazakhstan, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12115, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12115, 2022.

    EGU22-12268 | Presentations | HS5.12

    Sustainability of Water Supply and Sanitation systems in Kazakhstan 

    Kamshat Tussupova, Ainagul Kaliyeva, and Kenneth M Persson

    Sustainable development goals (6.1 and 6.2) call for full coverage with safely managed drinking water and safely managed sanitation by 2030. Thus, the UN Sustainable development goals declare to provide water, sanitation and hygiene for all and to involve local water users and find most suitable local practices for water provision.

    While the MDGs highly promoted access to piped water and flushed toilets as the safest distribution of water and sanitation services, the SDGs promote access to all water sources and sanitation facilities if a safe management can be assured.

    The SDGs "Safely managed drinking water" indicator includes the three following conditions: accessible on-premises, available when needed and free from contamination, and “Safely managed sanitation” indicator includes an improved sanitation facility which is: not shared, excreta is safely disposed in situ or excreta is transported and treated off-site. Thus, both centralized and decentralized water supply and sanitation systems are considered safe if met the sustainability criterias.

    Since the Soviet Union time most of the centralized water systems in towns and rural areas in Kazakhstan were built in a linear way with piped water in and no sewer pipes out or limited wastewater collection pipes with no treatment and direct discharge. This research attempts to assess centralized water supply and sanitation systems on a household and the system levels in rural/urban areas in Kazakhstan using six sustainability components: environmental, socio-cultural, institutional, economic, health and technological sustainability. The survey included the questionannire of the households, discussions with the responsible for water supply systems and observation of water and sanitation points. The survey was conducted in three settlements with the access to centralised and decentralized water supply systems in Nothern part of Kazakhstan and covered 82% of the households. More than 85% of households used water from private sources; water from centralized sources if used mainly for watering the garden and not for drinking purposes. No sewer system was provided in the settlements and the waste/grey water is the responsibility of the household itself. Every household had pit laterine outside, meeting basic technical requirements and partially lacking the environmental safety requirements.  

    For this study, several sustainability limitations were recognised where the most prevalent component, which consequently affected other components, was the institutional sustainability in the region, namely lack of community-based water supply systems,  the local municipality organization and regulation and education on maintaining the WSS systems.

    How to cite: Tussupova, K., Kaliyeva, A., and Persson, K. M.: Sustainability of Water Supply and Sanitation systems in Kazakhstan, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12268, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12268, 2022.

    EGU22-12670 | Presentations | HS5.12

    Urban water metabolism of Brisbane city: a multi-scale interdisciplinary evaluation framework 

    Mojtaba Moravej, Kamshat Tussupova, and Kenneth M Persson

    Continually providing water services for increasing urban population while minimising the impacts of urbanisation on the environment is becoming challenging. The technological/engineering solutions alone are not sufficient. Interventions from other disciplines such as urban design, planning, and social science are needed in addition to engineering solutions to overcome the challenges. However, suboptimal integration of interdisciplinary interventions might lead to unintended and undesirable outcomes. There is a need to holistically evaluate the benefits (and potential drawbacks) of integrated interventions, which is missing from the literature. Urban water metabolism at multiple scales as an evaluation framework for testing and comparing interdisciplinary interventions has been introduced. Urban water metabolism is a conceptual model for describing water flows in and out of urban areas, which can be used to study the interactions between natural landscape, built-environment, and socio-technological systems. It is based on urban water mass balance principles accounting for all water flows including natural and anthropogenic flows. The quantitative capacity of the evaluation framework at the development scale (i.e. site-scale) and city-scale is shown in the Australian city of Brisbane using a set of water performance indicators (e.g. naturalness ratios). Six scenarios were developed representing a variety of demand management strategies (e.g. efficient appliances), on-site water servicing technologies (e.g. rainwater tanks), and architectural design interventions. The results show, depending on the interventions implemented, stormwater runoff spikes between 332 to 392%, evapotranspiration is reduced in the range of 41 to 83%, and infiltration shrinks to 34 to 71% of the flows in the natural landscape (i.e. natural hydrology). More than 36% of water demand can be met internally at the site (i.e. self-sufficiency) if smart irrigation systems are installed, the efficiency of appliances and water fixtures is increased, on-site storage for local harvest is introduced, and architectural design is optimised. The framework developed in our study is useful for evaluating interdisciplinary options quantitatively and systematically. Additionally, it has applications as a design tool to identify and test alternatives to achieve greener and more sustainable urban spaces.

    How to cite: Moravej, M., Tussupova, K., and Persson, K. M.: Urban water metabolism of Brisbane city: a multi-scale interdisciplinary evaluation framework, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12670, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12670, 2022.

    EGU22-13339 | Presentations | HS5.12

    Assessing centralized water supply systems in rural settlements of Kazakhstan 

    Rauan Kurbanaliyev Mukanovich, Beisenova Raikhan Rymbaevna, and Tazetdinova Rumiya Maratovna

    The Sustainable Development Goals established worldwide targets for access to drinking water and sanitation by all. The progress toward these goals, aided by international monitoring, has helped to reduce global disease burden and improve quality of life. Safe drinking water and sanitation are critical determinants of human health and well-being, and the international community has lately deemed their human rights. This research aims at assessing the access to drinking water and sanitation services at the individual home level in the rural villages of Nothern Kazakhstan that either used to have access to piped water systems or currently can enjoy the water from the centralized water systems. The questionnaire was conducted in 10 villages of Pavlodar region to identify the access to drinking water and sanitation services as well as perceived satisfaction with the water source, additionally water samples from existing water sources were analysed. The results show that every fourth household used water from the centralised system. At the same time, every household had a complaint about the water from the system, namely, every fourth has complained about the turbidity of the water, 30% of households were unhappy with the smell and the same amount of households found water very hard. As the raw water source for the centralised systems is underground water, the water quality analysis has shown that the pH fluctuates between 3.90 and 8.96 with an average value of 7.79, which indicates the different nature of the groundwater in the study area.

    Half of the respondent households used water from private boreholes where more than half connected water to the house and enjoyed the tap water. Still, 8% of the households used water from an open-source - the Irtysh river. All the above-mentioned households have access to piped water while using the other alternative water sources. All the investigated rural settlements had only private houses and about 82% of the households had toilets outside. 2,3 % of the households had only toilets at home connected to the centralized sewer system and 15% of the households had toilets inside the house connected to septic tanks. This means that more than half of households are still inaccessible for full sanitation and hygiene. In Kazakhstan's rural communities with the access to centralized water systems the disparity in access to better drinking water and sanitation does exist. Monitoring within-country disparity in these metrics can help Kazakhstan achieve progress toward the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development by identifying neglected regions and implementing strategies to reduce access disparities.

    How to cite: Kurbanaliyev Mukanovich, R., Raikhan Rymbaevna, B., and Rumiya Maratovna, T.: Assessing centralized water supply systems in rural settlements of Kazakhstan, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13339, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13339, 2022.

    EGU22-13383 | Presentations | HS5.12

    Water reuse and examples from the case of California 

    Cecilia Tortajada

    Water resources are essential for every development activity, not only in terms of available quantity but also in terms of quality. Water scarcity, due to physical lack or pollution, has become one of the most pressing issues globally, a matter of human, economic and environmental insecurity. Wastewater, whose value had not been appreciated until recently, is increasingly recognised as a potential ‘new’ source of clean water for potable and non-potable uses, resulting in social, environmental and economic benefits. This presentation will discuss the potential of reclaimed water (also known as reused water) to become a significant source of safe water for drinking purposes and improved sanitation in support of the Sustainable Development Goals, with the example of California.

    How to cite: Tortajada, C.: Water reuse and examples from the case of California, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13383, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13383, 2022.

    EGU22-13391 | Presentations | HS5.12

    Water Tariffs and Affordability in Urban Water Supply and Wastewater Systems 

    Stefanos Xenarios, Joost Buurman, and Eduardo Araral

    The current study attempts to identify the role of the most widely used physical, economic and institutional parameters that may affect water tariffs and affordability across several cities in high and upper-middle income countries. Differential inferential statistical methods were employed to explore potential associations of the water consumption, variable and fixed costs, utility management, and minimum wage, with the economic affordability on household level. The findings indicate a loose association of the tariffs with the above indicators which may not lead to certain assumptions. Although the results may be uncertain and inconclusive, however, there have only few studies till now exploring and comparing water affordability of urban water systems in high and upper-middle income countries. The findings could trigger further research on the better comprehension of affordability and water tariffs by improving social inclusion of low-income households on urban water accessibility and usage.

    How to cite: Xenarios, S., Buurman, J., and Araral, E.: Water Tariffs and Affordability in Urban Water Supply and Wastewater Systems, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13391, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13391, 2022.

    Since a few years, the effects of global warming are becoming more visible, also in Belgium: long heat periods in springtime or in summer (2018-2019-2020), irregular rainfall, leading to peak water demand. At the same time, the aquifers are not restored in wintertime; the surface waters are less reliable as a raw water resource. Belgium will be one of the more water-stressed countries in 2040. The mission of the water company “De Watergroep” reflects the willingness to solve the water stress issue in the future. The problem is complex, but the solutions are multiple: instead of making tap water from surface water of groundwater, alternative sources for making tap water are used as well, such as rainwater or low-quality water like brackish river water or effluent from a wastewater plant. This kind of solution can be realised even in the short term, and the beneficial environmental effect is part of the global aim to reduce the CO2 footprint. Today, industrial customers are not just looking for tap water for processing purposes; they expect public water companies to deliver a full-blown water service starting from an optimisation plan and a business case. Together with the client, the water company looks for other water sources to reduce costs, lower the CO2 footprint to avoid wastewater taxes and meet today’s socio-economic expectations in general.  To cover the industry’s water needs sustainably, De Watergroep offers several formats, but in most cases, the DBFO. The industry wants to eliminate the complex water processing themselves, leaving water specialists to focus on their own production processes. The next step is the field tests on a pilot scale to try out several treatment techniques and optimise them, for example, upgrading the effluent from a wastewater plant up to tap water or up to demineralised water for steam production and other uses. After that, the “water plant” is upscaled to “the real thing”. De Watergroep knows perfectly how to meet the needs of several sectors like the chemical industry, the potato industry, the milk industry, and even the micro-chips industry that uses massive volumes of 100% purified water. State of the art techniques are used, some of them being “not yet so common”: The plus value offered to the client is the specific water knowledge: everybody knows several techniques to clean or upgrade water to a certain quality, but dimensioning, tuning, running and managing these techniques, putting them together in the most efficient way, requests specialists’ work. Partnership from both industry and the public water company De Watergroep leads to innovative, holistic water solutions in Flanders today, saving water for future generations.

    How to cite: Hammenecker, J.: Water circles: the secrets revealed drivers for the circular mindset in Belgium,  with examples in the industry, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13485, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13485, 2022.

    HS6 – Remote sensing and data assimilation

    We use Sentinel-1 and Sentinel-2 images to study drainage congestion due to road networks on a large alluvial fan of the Kosi River. We have estimated the soil moisture from Sentinel-1 images by applying an empirical modified Dubois model (MDM), and a data-driven machine learning model based on the fully connected feed-forward artificial neural network (FC-FF-ANN). We observed that the MDM underestimates the soil moisture (R = 0.43, RMSE = 0.08 m3/m3, and bias = -0.10). The FC-FF-ANN accurately predicts the soil moisture (R = 0.85, RMSE = 0.05 m3/m3, and bias = 0) in our study area. 

    We now used the soil moisture obtained from the FC-FF-ANN model to study the spatial pattern of the surface soil moisture in the proximity of road networks that act as drainage barriers. For this, we generated a buffer of 1 km along the road network. Within this, we extract the soil moisture value at the locations where the road network traverses in the vertical, inclined, and horizontal directions. We observed a clear accumulation of soil moisture near the road network that decreases gradually as we move farther from the road. We found that the impact of drainage congestion ranges between 320 to 760 m on either side of the road. This study is a step towards assessing the effect of structural interventions on drainage congestion and flood inundation.

    How to cite: Singh, A., Naik, M. N., and Gaurav, K.: Assessing the spatial variability of soil moisture in the proximity of road networks on a large alluvial fan in the Himalayan Foreland, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-96, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-96, 2022.

    EGU22-352 | Presentations | HS6.1

    Mapping field-scale soil moisture and its spatial variability across the United States using SMAP-HydroBlocks 

    Noemi Vergopolan, Justin Sheffield, Nathaniel W. Chaney, Ming Pan, Hylke E. Beck, Craig R. Ferguson, Laura Torres-Rojas, Felix Eigenbrod, Wade Crow, and Eric F. Wood

    Soil moisture (SM) varies widely in space and time. This variability influences agriculture, land-atmosphere interactions and triggers hazards, such as flooding, landslides, droughts, and wildfires. Yet, current observations are limited to a few regional in situ measurement networks or coarse-scale satellite retrievals (9–36-km resolution). As a result, besides site-specific studies, little is known on how SM varies locally (1–100-m resolution). Consequently, quantifying the impact of this variability remains a critical and long-standing challenge in hydrology. This presentation introduces SMAP-HydroBlocks – a novel 30-m resolution SM dataset (2015–2019) that combines hyper-resolution land surface modeling, satellite, and in-situ observations over the United States. Using this data, we reveal the striking variability of local-scale SM across the United States. By mapping the SM spatial variability and its persistence across spatial scales, we show the complex interplay between the landscape and hydroclimate and how this variability is highly scale-dependent. Results show that up to 80% of SM spatial variability information is lost at the 1-km scale, with further losses expected at the scale of current monitoring systems (5–25-km). This high degree of SM variability has a critical influence on freshwater and land ecosystem dynamics. By mapping its spatial variability locally, we provide a stepping-stone towards understanding SM-dependent hydrological, biogeochemical, and ecological processes at local (and so far unresolved) scales.

    How to cite: Vergopolan, N., Sheffield, J., Chaney, N. W., Pan, M., Beck, H. E., Ferguson, C. R., Torres-Rojas, L., Eigenbrod, F., Crow, W., and Wood, E. F.: Mapping field-scale soil moisture and its spatial variability across the United States using SMAP-HydroBlocks, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-352, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-352, 2022.

    EGU22-1663 | Presentations | HS6.1

    Recent trends in root-zone soil moisture over India using the GLEAM data for the period 1980-2020 

    Kanike Raghavendra Prasad Babu and Kantha Rao Bhimala

    Root Zone Soil Moisture (RZSM) plays a critical role in land-atmospheric interactions, water & energy budget, terrestrial evaporation and vegetation health. Unfortunately, the in-situ observations of RZSM are very sparse all over the globe. The present study utilized the RZSM product (based on microwave satellite data) from the GLEAM (Global Land Evaporation Amsterdam Model) to study the trends and spatial variability over India during the period 1980-2020. The annual RZSM climatology map shows that the highest values (>0.35 m3/m3) are found over dense vegetation regions (Western-Ghats, North-East India, and foothills of Himalayas) and low values (<0.2 m3/m3) are found in arid and semi-arid regions of North-West India. The all India annual mean RZSM (area averaged) is 0.285 m3/m3 with the standard deviation of 0.0076 m3/m3 and showing a significant increasing trend (p<0.05) during the period 1980-2020. The analysis found a distinct seasonal variability in RZSM and found the highest RZSM during the southwest monsoon (June-September) season and low values in the pre-monsoon season (March-May) for most of the sub-divisions classified by the India Meteorological Department. The seasonal all India mean RZSM values are 0.23 m3/m3, 0.33 m3/m3, 0.31 m3/m3 during pre-monsoon, monsoon, and post-monsoon seasons respectively, and found a significant increasing trend in all seasons during the study period. The sub-division wise trend (Mann-Kendall test) analysis shows that the pre-monsoon RZSM showed a tremendous increasing trend in most (23 out of 34) of the sub-divisions (except north and northeast India) whereas in monsoon and post-monsoon season only 9 and 12 sub-divisions showed an increasing trend in India respectively. The present study improves our understanding of the regional scale hydrological cycle and the importance of realistic representation of irrigation and land use land cover changes in climate models for better prediction of monsoon and other natural disasters in India.

    How to cite: Babu, K. R. P. and Bhimala, K. R.: Recent trends in root-zone soil moisture over India using the GLEAM data for the period 1980-2020, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1663, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1663, 2022.

    EGU22-1883 | Presentations | HS6.1

    High resolution (1 km) soil moisture and precipitation for developing a Digital Twin Earth for hydrology 

    Luca Brocca, Luca Ciabatta, Christian Massari, Stefania Camici, Silvia Barbetta, Angelica Tarpanelli, Paolo Filippucci, Jacopo Dari, and Hamidreza Mosaffa

    In recent years, the availability of high-resolution observations (<1km, sub-daily) from remote sensing, in situ monitoring networks and new sensors/techniques (drones, citizen science), in addition to the increased computational and storage capacity, have fostered the development of modelling systems at high resolution for hydrological applications. The European Commission (EC) is promoting these developments through the EU’s digital strategy, the Green Deal, and specifically the Destination Earth initiative. The development of digital twins of the Earth System is currently in the EC agenda as one of the most pressing activities to be accomplished to build a resilient society able to cope with adverse extreme events (flood, drought, heatwaves, landslides), exacerbated by global and climate changing.

    Despite the high-resolution hydrology is an important opportunity for future research and operation applications, the challenges to be addresses are quite a lot and non-trivial. First, the increased computational capabilities are far from being sufficient to develop high resolution hydrological systems because observations (e.g., precipitation, evapotranspiration, soil moisture, river discharge) have to be available not only at high resolution, but also with sufficient accuracy. A second problem is related to the representation of physical processes that, at high resolution, are significantly different from processes at coarse resolution (20km), currently modelled at large scale. Last but not least, the human impact on the water cycle (e.g., irrigation, reservoir management, river water diversion) acting at very high resolution, challenges the current attempts of reproducing a digital replica of the Earth.

    The launch of Sentinel-1 satellites has opened a number of opportunities for developing high resolution satellite soil moisture and precipitation products. These products are an important element for building a Digital Twin Earth (DTE) for Hydrology, i.e., for the reconstruction of the water cycle at high resolution. In this contribution we will present the recent advances over this topic carried out under European Space Agency projects DTE Hydrology and Irrigation+. Specifically, we will present the application of high-resolution products for hydrological applications: flood simulation, landslide risk prediction and irrigation water management. Finally, the main challenges to be addressed will be discussed.

    How to cite: Brocca, L., Ciabatta, L., Massari, C., Camici, S., Barbetta, S., Tarpanelli, A., Filippucci, P., Dari, J., and Mosaffa, H.: High resolution (1 km) soil moisture and precipitation for developing a Digital Twin Earth for hydrology, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1883, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1883, 2022.

    EGU22-2084 | Presentations | HS6.1

    Assessment of the impacts on data assimilation performance caused by spatio-temporal gaps in satellite soil moisture data 

    Khaled Mohammed, Robert Leconte, and Mélanie Trudel

    Previous studies have shown that assimilating satellite soil moisture data in land surface models can improve the estimations of soil moisture. One of the limitations of these satellite soil moisture products is that there are often spatial gaps (in the horizontal direction) in data availability over certain areas due to issues such as dense vegetation or hilly terrain. These products are also limited in the vertical direction because, for the microwave-based products for example, the microwave radiation captured by the satellite sensors to estimate soil moisture is usually representative of a very thin top layer of soil (up to about 5 cm). Lastly, data over a specific watershed may not be available every day (i.e. temporal gaps) because of the orbital configuration of the satellite in question. From the existing literature, it is not clear what the benefits will be for soil moisture modeling, if these spatio-temporal gaps in satellite soil moisture datasets could somehow be minimized or eliminated. To answer this question, a synthetic assimilation study was carried out on the Noah-MP land surface model within the WRF-Hydro modeling system. The study was conducted with ERA5 forcing data on the Susquehanna River Basin and the Ensemble Kalman Filter was the chosen assimilation algorithm. Multiple scenarios were explored in which spatio-temporal gaps were introduced in the synthetic observations by mimicking the actual spatio-temporal gaps that are present in the SMAP soil moisture product. Results indicate that the model’s ability to accurately simulate soil moisture is much lower when assimilated observations have spatio-temporal gaps, compared to model simulations where there are no gaps in the assimilated observations. However, it was found that this lower model accuracy can be improved if the model grids with missing observations are updated based on the covariance between the soil moisture of those grids and their surrounding grids.

    How to cite: Mohammed, K., Leconte, R., and Trudel, M.: Assessment of the impacts on data assimilation performance caused by spatio-temporal gaps in satellite soil moisture data, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2084, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2084, 2022.

    EGU22-2147 | Presentations | HS6.1

    Evaluating high resolution soil moisture maps in the framework of the ESA CCI 

    Remi Madelon, Hassan Bazzi, Ghaith Amin, Clement Albergel, Nicolas Baghdadi, Wouter Dorigo, Nemesio Rodriguez-Fernandez, and Mehrez Zribi

    Surface Soil Moisture (SM) plays a key role in the Earth water cycle and many hydrological processes (Koster 2004), it is essential for accurate weather forecasting (Rodriguez-Fernandez 2019) and agriculture management (Guerif 2000). SM was also identified as one of the 50 “Essential Climate Variables” (ECVs) by the Global Climate Observing System (GCOS). Long time series of ECVs are crucial to monitor the Earth’s climate evolution, and developing them is the goal of initiatives such as the European Space Agency’s Climate Change Initiative (ESA CCI).

    The ESA SM CCI product (Gruber 2019) provides global time series for the 1979-2021 period at 25-km resolution using scatterometers and passive microwave sensors. Based on extensive feedbacks from the user communities of SM products, a strong need for higher spatial resolutions SM data was identified (Dorigo 2018, Peng 2020). This also includes climate applications such as assessment of climate change impacts at regional level.

    SM can be estimated at high spatial resolution using Synthetic Aperture Radars such as Sentinel-1 (S1). Several high resolution (HR) S1 SM data sets exist such as the products from the Copernicus Global Land Service and the one using the S²MP (Sentinel-1/2 Soil Moisture Product) algorithm (El Hajj 2017). Despite the actual short temporal coverage of such data, it is worth to evaluate them in the context of the ESA CCI as potential future HR SM long time series, and also as benchmarking references for HR SM data sets that could be obtained by the downscaling of coarser resolution sensors.

    In this context, the S²MP algorithm, which was originally designed to retrieve SM at a plot level, was adapted to compute SM maps at 1-km resolution over six 100-km² regions in the Southwest and Southeast of France, Tunisia, North America, Spain and Australia. The S²MP algorithm is based on a neural network approach using backscattering coefficients and incidence angles from S1, and either NDVI from Sentinel-2 (S2) or that of Sentinel-3 (S3), as input data.

    Both S1+S2 and S1+S3 1-km SM maps are compared to HR SM data from the SMAP+S1 product and the Copernicus SM and Soil Water Index (SWI) data sets. The S1+S2 and S1+S3 SM maps are in very good agreement in terms of correlation (R > 0.9), bias (< 0.05 m3.m-3) and standard deviation of the difference (STDD < 0.025 m3.m-3) over the 6 regions of study. They also are well correlated (R ~ 0.6-0.7) with the Copernicus products over homogeneous pixels containing croplands and herbaceous vegetation. However, the results are more mitigated over Tunisia and mixed land cover pixels as well as when the maps are compared to those of SMAP+S1.

    The high resolution products are also evaluated against in-situ measurements along with coarse scale SM data sets (SMAP, SMOS, ESA CCI). In general, the coarse resolution SM products show better correlation than the HR ones. However, the HR products, in particular S²MP, show lower STDD and bias.

    How to cite: Madelon, R., Bazzi, H., Amin, G., Albergel, C., Baghdadi, N., Dorigo, W., Rodriguez-Fernandez, N., and Zribi, M.: Evaluating high resolution soil moisture maps in the framework of the ESA CCI, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2147, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2147, 2022.

    EGU22-2479 | Presentations | HS6.1

    A global analysis of water storage variations from remotely sensed soil moisture and daily satellite gravimetry 

    Daniel Blank, Annette Eicker, Laura Jensen, and Andreas Güntner

    Information on water storage changes in the soil can be obtained on a global scale from different types of satellite observations. While active or passive microwave remote sensing is limited to investigating the upper few centimeters of the soil, satellite gravimetry can detect changes in the full column of terrestrial water storage (TWS), but cannot distinguish between storage variations occurring in different soil depths. Jointly analyzing both data types promises interesting insights into the underlying hydrological dynamics and may enable a better process understanding of water storage change in the subsurface.

    In this study, we investigate the global relationship of (1) several satellite soil moisture (SM) products and (2) non-standard daily TWS data from the GRACE and GRACE-FO satellite gravimetry missions on different time scales. The six SM products analyzed in this study differ in their data source, processing level, and soil depth for which the SM information is provided. Original level-3 surface SM data sets of SMAP and SMOS are compared to post-processed level-4 data products (both surface and root zone SM) and a multi-satellite product provided by the ESA CCI. A tailored temporal and spatial masking has been applied to focus on time spans with favorable signal-to-noise ratio and to exclude periods with snow cover or frozen soil.

    We sample all TWS and SM data sets to a common 1 degree spatial resolution, decompose each signal into seasonal to sub-monthly frequencies and carry out the comparison with respect to spatial patterns and temporal variability. We find increasingly large correlations between the TWS and SM for deeper integration depths (root zone vs. surface layer) and for post-processed level-4 data products. Even for highpass-filtered (sub-monthly) variations, significant correlations can be found of up to 0.6 in regions with large high-frequency variability. A time-shift analysis shows differences in the temporal dynamics of soil moisture versus TWS storage variations, indicating different water storage dynamics in the different depth layers. Precipitation data have been added to the analysis to enhance the interpretation of the comparison of soil moisture and total water storage variations.

    How to cite: Blank, D., Eicker, A., Jensen, L., and Güntner, A.: A global analysis of water storage variations from remotely sensed soil moisture and daily satellite gravimetry, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2479, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2479, 2022.

    EGU22-3206 | Presentations | HS6.1

    Evaluation of reanalysis soil moisture products using Cosmic Ray Neutron Sensor observations across the globe 

    Yanchen Zheng, Gemma Coxon, Ross Woods, Daniel Power, and Rafael Rosolem

    Soil moisture influences many physical processes in hydrology, meteorology, and agriculture, such as evapotranspiration, infiltration, runoff generation, drought development, crop growth, among others. Robust and accurate soil moisture estimates are needed for drought monitoring, climatology research and hydrological model initialization. Compared to in-situ soil moisture measurements and satellite products, reanalysis soil moisture products are becoming good alternatives for analysis at the global scale due to their long temporal coverage. However, there are a great variety of reanalysis products available and choosing a suitable product that is consistent with the observed soil moisture condition is of significant interest.

    In this study, we evaluate the performance of seven reanalysis products including ERA5-Land, CFSRv2, MERRA2-Land, JRA-55, GLDAS-Noah v2.1, CRA40, and GLEAM against field measurements from 109 sites with Cosmic Ray Neutron Sensors (CRNS). CRNS provide estimates of root-zone soil moisture at the field scale (~250m radius from sensor). The sites used in this study are located in the United Kingdom (51 sites), United States (40 sites), and Australia (18 sites). Metrics describing the temporal correlation (Pearson correlation coefficient, R) for the daily time series, seasonal cycle and anomaly time series, bias (mean square error, MSE) as well as root mean square difference (unbiased root mean square error, ubRMSE) are employed to quantify agreement between reanalysis products and measurements.

    As an example, for the UK sites, CFSRv2 and GLEAM soil moisture products have lower errors in terms of temporal correlation and bias, while MERRA2-Land and GLDAS datasets exhibit higher errors. Reanalysis soil moisture products tend to have poorer behaviour at wet sites, with low temporal correlation and high bias. Relatively low correlation coefficient values are also found at sites with organic soils and low bulk density. This study provides guidelines for researchers about choosing the reanalysis soil moisture products.

    How to cite: Zheng, Y., Coxon, G., Woods, R., Power, D., and Rosolem, R.: Evaluation of reanalysis soil moisture products using Cosmic Ray Neutron Sensor observations across the globe, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3206, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3206, 2022.

    EGU22-3332 | Presentations | HS6.1

    Land Surface Temperature/ Vegetation Index Space for Soil Moisture Assessment over Ganga Basin 

    Sooraj Krishnan and Indu Jayaluxmi

    Soil Moisture (SM) remains one of the inevitable geophysical land surface variables, influencing climatological and hydrological fluxes that can control the interaction between Earth's surface and atmosphere. It is also a crucial land surface parameter indicating drought conditions in agricultural areas, significantly impacting agricultural production. The temperature vegetation dryness index (TVDI), a simplified surface dryness index based on vegetation index (VI) - land surface temperature (LST) triangle/trapezoidal spectral space, can monitor SM conditions in vegetation-covered areas.

    The present study estimated a high-resolution temperature vegetation dryness index (TVDI) for assessing SM over the largest river basin in India, Ganga Basin. Triangular feature space between LST and VI is generated to obtain the dry and wet edges to calculate TVDI over the Ganga basin for three years (2017, 2018, and 2019). Two different TVDI were developed using two vegetation indices, normalized difference vegetation index (NDVI) and enhanced vegetation index (EVI). Estimated TVDI is evaluated using ESA CCI SM product. The relation of subsurface SM with TVDI is investigated using GLDAS Noah LSM SM available at four different layer depths (0–10, 10–40, 40–100, and 100–200 cm).

    The result shows that TVDI generated using EVI correlates better with SM than NDVI generated TVDI. The relationship between TVDI and SM was found to be closer in Summer (-0.49–0.62) than in post monsoon season. The applicability of TVDI in investigating SM at soil layer depth at 10-40 cm (r close to -0.6) was found to be better than that at depth 0-10 cm, especially during the summer season. The results reveal relevance of generated TVDI with satellite-derived information only, in SM monitoring and assessment, especially in the summer season, over the area of sparse in-situ SM network.

    How to cite: Krishnan, S. and Jayaluxmi, I.: Land Surface Temperature/ Vegetation Index Space for Soil Moisture Assessment over Ganga Basin, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3332, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3332, 2022.

    EGU22-3698 | Presentations | HS6.1

    A hybrid methodology based on Neural Network and Change detection approaches and using Sentinel-1/Sentinel-2 for soil moisture estimation 

    Mehrez Zribi, Simon Nativel, Nemesio Rodriguez Fernandez, Nicolas Baghdadi, Remi Madelon, and Clement Albergel

    Soil moisture is an essential parameter for a better understanding of water processes in the soil-vegetation-atmosphere interface. In this context, passive and active microwave remote sensing have enabled the development of various increasingly operational approaches, in particular for low spatial resolution products. Synthetic aperture radar (SAR) is particularly suitable for monitoring water content at fine spatial resolutions of the order of 1 km spatial resolution. Since the launch of Sentinel-1 in 2014, numerous methodologies have been proposed for estimating fine spatial resolutions soil moisture, especially in agricultural areas. Two approaches are often considered in the inversion of SAR signals: approaches based on machine learning methodologies, such as neural networks trained on scattering models, or approaches based on change detection, essentially validated on low spatial resolution products using scatterometers. In this study, we propose a hybrid approach combining both the neural networks and change detection approaches. The methodology was applied to Sentinel-1 and Sentinel-2 using numerous predictors; Vertical-Vertical (VV) polarization radar signal, incidence angle, Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) optical index, VH/VV ratio, etc.

    This hybrid approach is tested on the database of the international soil moisture network (ISMN) with moisture networks covering different climatic contexts. Results are very encouraging with 10% improvement in the accuracy of soil moisture estimates compared to the use one of each approach individually (Neural Network or change detection).

    How to cite: Zribi, M., Nativel, S., Rodriguez Fernandez, N., Baghdadi, N., Madelon, R., and Albergel, C.: A hybrid methodology based on Neural Network and Change detection approaches and using Sentinel-1/Sentinel-2 for soil moisture estimation, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3698, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3698, 2022.

    EGU22-4023 | Presentations | HS6.1

    Characterizing natural variability in complex hydrological systems using Passive Microwave based Climate Data Records: a case study for the Okavango Delta 

    Robin van der Schalie, Mendy van der Vliet, Clement Albergel, Wouter Dorigo, Piotr Wolski, and Richard de Jeu

    The Okavango river system in southern Africa is known for its strong interannual variability of hydrological conditions. Here we present how this is exposed in surface soil moisture, land surface temperature, and vegetation optical depth as derived from the Land Parameter Retrieval Model using an inter-calibrated, long term, multi-sensor passive microwave satellite data record (1998-2020). We also investigate how these interannual variations relate to state-of-the-art climate reanalysis data from ERA5-Land. We analyzed both the upstream river catchment and the Okavango Delta, supported by independent data records of discharge measurements, inundated area, precipitation and vegetation dynamics observed by optical satellites. 

    The results from this study show that the seasonal vegetation optical depth anomalies have a strong correspondence with MODIS Leaf Area Index over both the Delta and the Catchment. Land surface temperature anomalies derived from passive microwave observations best match those of ERA5-Land, as compared to MODIS nighttime LST. Although surface soil moisture anomalies from passive microwave observations and ERA5-Land also correlate well, an in-depth evaluation over the Delta uncovered situations where passive microwave satellites record strong fluctuations, while ERA5-Land does not.

    This difference is further analyzed using information on inundated area, river discharge and precipitation. The passive microwave soil moisture signal demonstrates a response to both the inundated area and precipitation. ERA5-Land however, which by default does not account for any lateral influx from rivers, only shows a response to the precipitation information that is used as forcing. This also causes the reanalysis model to miss record low land surface temperature values as it underestimates the latent heat flux in certain years, which can have a large impact on detecting and assessing extremes.

    These findings demonstrate the complexity of this hydrological system and suggest that future land surface model generations should also include lateral land surface exchange. Our study highlights the importance of maintaining and improving climate data records of soil moisture, vegetation and land surface temperature from passive microwave observations and other observation systems.

    How to cite: van der Schalie, R., van der Vliet, M., Albergel, C., Dorigo, W., Wolski, P., and de Jeu, R.: Characterizing natural variability in complex hydrological systems using Passive Microwave based Climate Data Records: a case study for the Okavango Delta, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4023, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4023, 2022.

    EGU22-4169 | Presentations | HS6.1

    Inter-comparison of Soil Moisture Satellite products on  European Ecoregions 

    Arianna Mazzariello, Raffaele Albano, Aurelia Sole, Teodosio Lacava, and Salvatore Manfreda

    Soil moisture (SM) content is a crucial parameter for an extensive range of fields (e.g., hydrology cycle, smart agriculture, environmental risk management, climate system) as it regulates the water balance, land surface energy, and the carbon cycle. However, the non-homogeneous horizontal and vertical distribution of water content in the soil complicates SM evaluation. The integration of in-situ measurements with those remotely acquired or produced by models may help in overcoming such a problem.

    Focusing on satellite data, it is worth noting that the growing availability of sensors (active or passive) working in the microwave spectral region has increased the capability to have SM information on a regional scale with a level of accuracy depending on the selected data, the characteristics of the study area as well as the metric considered for their evaluation.  

    This study aims to compare the accuracy of several freely available microwave-based SM satellite products with in-situ measurements distributed, after quality control and harmonization, by the International Soil Moisture Network (ISMN) for several stations located in the European (EU) Ecoregions for rivers and lakes (WFD 2000/60/CE) in the time frame 2015-2020.

    The satellite products investigated are based on the acquisition by: i) the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) Soil Moisture Active Passive (SMAP) mission, ii) the European Space Agency (ESA) Soil Moisture and Ocean Salinity (SMOS) mission, iii) the Advanced Scatterometer (ASCAT) aboard of MetOp satellites and iv) the radar onboard ESA’s SENTINEL-1 platforms. In particular we have used processed the following SM products: the SMAPL4 V5 (3-hourly and 9 km of spatial resolution) is based on the assimilation of SMAP (operated in L-band ) observations into a customized version of the NASA Goddard Earth Observing System Version 5 (GEOS-5) land data assimilation system (LDAS); the SMOS-IC V2.0 is the second version of a physically-based algorithm applied to SMOS retrievals operating in L-Band; the H115 and H116 SM products from the ASCAT backscatter observations provided on a fixed Earth grid (12.5 km sampling) in time series format. Finally, the SSM1km -CGLS V retrieved by Sentinel-1 radar images have been also considered (available only for the European continent every 1.5-4 days at spatial resolution of 1km).

    Satellite SM retrievals performances are evaluated against ground-based measurements in terms of Bias, Root Mean Square Error (RMSE), unbiased RMSE, and Pearson correlation (considering both original observations and anomalies). On average, SMAP and SMOS-IC highlight the best performance.

    The proposed inter-comparison offers both guidelines for choosing among available satellite products and insights on SM retrieval products and versions. As the EU Ecoregions outline is based on a large scale, they enclose areas affected by several climate change impacts (such as drought, changes in relative sea level, salinity, etc.). Thus, the outcomes can be used to develop novel satellite-based integrated methods for modelling the hydrologic response to climate change.

    How to cite: Mazzariello, A., Albano, R., Sole, A., Lacava, T., and Manfreda, S.: Inter-comparison of Soil Moisture Satellite products on  European Ecoregions, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4169, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4169, 2022.

    EGU22-5383 | Presentations | HS6.1

    Scientific evolution of the International Soil Moisture Network: Past, present, and future developments in support of soil moisture validation and applications 

    Ivana Petrakovic, Irene Himmelbauer, Daniel Aberer, Lukas Schremmer, Philippe Goryl, Raffaele Crapolicchio, Roberto Sabia, Klaus Scipal, Stephan Dietrich, Tunde Olarinoye, Fay Böhmer, and Wouter Dorigo

    With its steadily growing provider and user community (4000 active users), the International Soil Moisture Network (ISMN, https://ismn.earth)  is a unique centralized global data hosting facility, making in-situ soil moisture data easily and freely accessible. 

    The main goal of the ISMN in the past decade was to build up the harmonized and quality-controlled in-situ soil moisture source it is today.

    The ISMN provides benchmark data for several operational services such as ESA CCI Soil Moisture, the Copernicus Climate Change (C3S) and Global Land Service (CGLS), and the online validation tool QA4SM (https://qa4sm.eu). ISMN data is widely used for support of algorithm development and validation of different satellites, evaluation of soil moisture products, as a training set for various data-driven approaches, model developments, drought monitoring and diverse meteorological applications (Dorigo et. al 2021).

    In this presentation, we will provide an overview of the ISMN scientific achievements accomplished in the last decade, show recent scientific and service developments, and present foreseen future developments.

    We provide a review of hundreds of papers making use of ISMN data to identify major scientific breakthroughs facilitated through the ISMN. We also identify current limitations in data availability, functionality and challenges in data usage (e.g., in-situ data inclusion in data sparse regions, in-situ data inclusion from official governmental observation networks, data and measurement traceability, etc.).

    One of the major successes has been the achievement of long-term financial support for the ISMN through the German Ministry of Digital Infrastructure and Transport. Therefore, the ISMN operations is currently transferred from Vienna Austria (TU Wien) to the new host in Koblenz, Germany (International Center for Water Resources and Climate Change - ICWRGC, Federal Institute for Hydrology – BfG).

    This evolution not only opens up a stable future for the ISMN but also gives TU Wien once more the opportunity to focus on the scientific development of the ISMN as currently proceeded within the ESA project “Fiducial Reference Measurement for Soil Moisture (FRM4SM)”.  Within this two-year project (May 2021 – May 2023) the goal is also to identify and create standards for independent, fully characterized, accurate and traceable in-situ soil moisture measurements (from the ISMN) with corresponding uncertainty estimations and independent validation methods (inserted in the QA4SM service: https://qa4sm.eu).

     

    How to cite: Petrakovic, I., Himmelbauer, I., Aberer, D., Schremmer, L., Goryl, P., Crapolicchio, R., Sabia, R., Scipal, K., Dietrich, S., Olarinoye, T., Böhmer, F., and Dorigo, W.: Scientific evolution of the International Soil Moisture Network: Past, present, and future developments in support of soil moisture validation and applications, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5383, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5383, 2022.

    EGU22-8349 | Presentations | HS6.1

    Statistical approaches to assimilate soil moisture information: Methodology, first assessment and future plans 

    Filipe Aires, Peter Weston, Patricia De Rosnay, and David Fairbairn

    Land surfaces are characterized by strong heterogeneities of soil texture, orography, land cover, soil moisture, snow and other variables. These are very challenging to represent accurately in radiative transfer models which have currently a still limited reliability over land. In this study, we compare two statistical modeling approaches: the traditional CDF-matching used routinely in NWP centers (used here as a normalization and as an inversion technique), and the Neural Network (NN) methods. NNs and CDF-matching are compared and combined. Two cases are considered: (1) the more traditional inversion scheme, and (2) the forward modelling that could be attractive for assimilation purposes. It is shown that in the context of ASCAT, the inversion approach seems better suited than the forward modelling but this could be different for another type of observations. It is also shown that it is possible to combine the global model obtained using the NN and the localized information of the LSM offered by the CDF-matching. A first assessment is performed over the USA using in situ soil measurements. Localization strategies for the NN models are introduced. Another necessity for the use of NN in an assimilation framework are estimations of NN uncertainties: this is unfortunately not available so far and we propose several schemes in order to obtain them. Finally, we will present future plans to develop a forward operator for low-frequency microwave channels (SMOS, AMSR-E, SMAP, CIMR) based on a statistical modeling of surface emissivities over continental, snow-ice and sea ice surfaces.

    How to cite: Aires, F., Weston, P., De Rosnay, P., and Fairbairn, D.: Statistical approaches to assimilate soil moisture information: Methodology, first assessment and future plans, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8349, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8349, 2022.

    EGU22-8370 | Presentations | HS6.1

    Assessment of an ESA CCI Soil Moisture data assimilation framework 

    Zdenko Heyvaert, Michel Bechtold, Alexander Gruber, Samuel Scherrer, Wouter Dorigo, Emanuel Büechi, and Gabriëlle De Lannoy

    We present a comprehensive assessment of a land surface data assimilation system, in which microwave-based satellite retrievals of surface soil moisture from the combined active-passive ESA CCI Soil Moisture product are assimilated into the Noah-MP model, using a one-dimensional Ensemble Kalman Filter (EnKF) within the NASA Land Information System (LIS). This data assimilation system produces consistent estimates of surface and root-zone soil moisture, as well as all other geophysical variables, over the European continent from January 2002 to December 2019.

    The aim of this study is twofold. Firstly, we explore the impact of design choices and forcing inputs on the skill of the data assimilation system, specifically: (1) the magnitude of observation errors, (2) the bias correction method, i.e., climatological or seasonal CDF matching, and (3) the choice of the meteorological reanalysis dataset used to drive the land surface model. For the latter, we compare the results obtained by forcing the Noah-MP model with the NASA Modern-Era Retrospective analysis for Research and Applications version 2 (MERRA-2) with those obtained by forcing the model with the European Center for Medium-Range Weather Forecasts (ECMWF) Reanalysis version 5 (ERA5). Secondly, we explore how the data assimilation skill is related to the quality of the satellite retrievals and environmental factors such as land cover, soil texture, and climate.

    For both objectives listed above, the skill of the data assimilation system is evaluated by comparing the surface and root-zone soil moisture estimates with in situ observations. Furthermore, we evaluate the behavior of internal diagnostics derived from the data assimilation innovations and increments.

    The results display the inevitable trade-off in choosing the observation error magnitude: a smaller observation error will cause the data assimilation to perform worse than an open loop run at some sites, whereas a larger observation error will reduce the skill at well-performing sites. We also show that the bias correction method and the choice of meteorological forcing both have a clear effect on the data assimilation diagnostics, but a negligible impact on the skill of the system that is observed over in situ reference sites. Finally, we show that the skill improvement by the data assimilation framework is strongly related to the quality of the satellite soil moisture retrievals.        

    Acknowledgments: this work is part of the ESA CCI+ Soil Moisture CCN1 Scientific Evolution project and the FWO-FWF CONSOLIDATION project.

    How to cite: Heyvaert, Z., Bechtold, M., Gruber, A., Scherrer, S., Dorigo, W., Büechi, E., and De Lannoy, G.: Assessment of an ESA CCI Soil Moisture data assimilation framework, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8370, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8370, 2022.

    EGU22-9798 | Presentations | HS6.1

    Monitoring Relative Surface Soil Moisture Using Sentinel-1 Across the River Thames Catchment 

    William Maslanka, Keith Morrison, Kevin White, Anne Verhoef, and Joanna Clark

    Soil moisture is a critical component in many hydrological, agricultural, and meteorological applications and processes, and understanding the spatiotemporal dynamics and changes is critical to further their understanding. They are also an important parameter for use within soil- and land-based Natural Flood Management (NFM) schemes, to determine a relationship between surface wetness and soil water storage. Satellite-based remote sensing offers the ability to capture this spatiotemporal information on soil moisture on the synoptic scale; compared to more site-based in-situ field measurements, made up of numerous national and international soil moisture networks. In this study, we use Sentinel-1 SAR imagery over the course of six water years (from 2016 to 2021), utilizing the TU-Wein change-detection algorithm to calculate the relative Surface Soil Moisture (rSSM) across the River Thames Catchment in Southern England, equating to approximately 11,000 km2. As part of this, two pairs of backscatter normalisation factors were considered, in order to negate the impact from varying local incidence angles: a simple direct-slope and a complex multiple regression slope, both calculated annually and monthly. Whilst the monthly normalisation factor does exhibit a seasonal cycle (attributed to the growth and harvest of arable crops within the study area) in both the simple and multiple regression methodology, the impact upon the rSSM, when compared to the traditional annual method is small. In order to assess the spatiotemporal patterns of soil moisture across the River Thames Catchment, the rSSM timeseries was calculated using multiple spatial scales (1km, 500m, 250m, and 100m), to effectively estimate the rSSM across the catchment, sub-catchment, inter-field, and intra-field spatial scales. Comparisons with the Cosmic-ray Soil Moisture Observing System, United Kingdom (COSMOS-UK), show that, although there is an overestimation in rSSM over the summer months during the growing season of Arable farmland, we were able to effectively capture the general temporal dynamics of the relative Surface Soil Moisture across the region, with an average uncertainty of 30%, across both pairs of backscatter normalisation factors, and across all four spatial scales. Having catchment-wide datasets of rSSM such as this would be advantageous for evaluating land- and soil-based NFM measures across catchment and sub-catchment scales and have the potential for further application to improve hydrological model outputs.

    How to cite: Maslanka, W., Morrison, K., White, K., Verhoef, A., and Clark, J.: Monitoring Relative Surface Soil Moisture Using Sentinel-1 Across the River Thames Catchment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9798, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9798, 2022.

    EGU22-9883 | Presentations | HS6.1

    Assessing the impact of land cover type on Sentinel-1 soil moisture retrievals 

    Samuel Massart, Mariette Vreugdenhil, Bernhard Bauer-Marschallinger, Claudio Navacchi, Felix David Reuẞ, Raphael Quast, and Wolfgang Wagner

    Active microwave remote sensing satellites allow to retrieve surface soil moisture (SSM) consistently and independently from sun illumination or cloud cover. The current generation of Synthetic Aperture Radars (SAR) on-board of the Sentinel-1A and 1B satellites, launched in 2014 and 2016 respectively, provide backscatter observations in their interferometric wide swath mode at 20 x 22 m resolution. These data are being used by the Copernicus Global Land Service (CGLS) for generating SSM data at kilometre-scale resolution using a change detection approach. The data are operationally and freely available from https://land.copernicus.eu/global/. The goal of this study was to assess the quality of the CGLS SSM retrieval algorithm over different land cover types and crop species. For this purpose, we compared the satellite retrievals against in-situ SSM from the International Soil Moisture Network (ISMN). The stations analyzed are located in France and Austria (SMOSMANIA and HOAL) and cover a wide range of land cover types, from cropland and grassland to forested areas. For each station, backscatter at 20m resolution was averaged over fields containing the ISMN station using Land Parcel Identification System (LPIS) data. The resampled field backscatter, which covers one specific land cover or crop type, was then used as input for the change detection model and compared to the in-situ SSM from ISMN. The study shows that the temporal correspondence of the resulting SSM with in-situ data is strongly varying between crop species and land cover type. The results suggest that crops with seasonal variations in vegetation structure (e.g. winter wheat stem elongation and heading), have a negative impact on the performance of the model. In comparison, the retrieved SSM is better correlated to in-situ data over land cover such as grasslands or maize fields with more homogeneous vegetation development. This study explores the potential and challenges posed by the high resolution of Sentinel-1 backscatter data for SSM retrieval. It demonstrates the effect changes in vegetation structure can have on S1 backscatter, which is important information to all retrieval algorithms for S1 SSM retrieval.  It also provides a first path forward to improve SSM using the TUWien change detection from Sentinel-1. 

    How to cite: Massart, S., Vreugdenhil, M., Bauer-Marschallinger, B., Navacchi, C., Reuẞ, F. D., Quast, R., and Wagner, W.: Assessing the impact of land cover type on Sentinel-1 soil moisture retrievals, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9883, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9883, 2022.

    EGU22-9918 | Presentations | HS6.1 | Highlight

    Satellite soil moisture for drought assessment and early-warning in water limited regions 

    Mariette Vreugdenhil, Isabella Greimeister-Pfeil, Wolfgang Preimesberger, Luca Brocca, Stefania Camici, Samuel Massart, Markus Enenkel, and Wolfgang Wagner

    Many parametric or index-based drought risk financing instruments are based on in situ or satellite-derived rainfall, temperature and/or vegetation health data. However, an underlying issue is that indices often do not perfectly correlate to the actual losses experienced by the policy holders. Remotely sensed soil moisture (SM) can help decrease basis risk in parametric drought insurance through complementary and/or improved parameters and variables in existing models, or as a stand-alone model. Here, we demonstrate the added value of satellite-based soil moisture for drought assessment and early-warning yield prediction for Senegal and Morocco.  

    SM from both ESA CCI and EUMETSAT HSAF were used in combination with rainfall from CHIRPS and SM2Rain, and Copernicus Global Land Service NDVI to assess droughts through a convergence of evidence approach. Satellite-based soil moisture, and the retrieved rainfall through SM2Rain, provided early indicators of drought onset compared to NDVI. They also corresponded to major droughts and impacts as obtained from public reports of the African Risk Capacity (ARC) and existing models used for parametric drought insurance, such as the Water Requirement Satisfactory index (WRSI).   

    Furthermore, rainfall, SM and NDVI were used to predict yield obtained from the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO). SM showed a high predictive skill early in the growing season, where negative early season soil moisture anomalies often lead to lower yields. NDVI showed more predictive power later in the growing season. Combining satellite-based SM with precipitation and NDVI in multiple linear regression improved yield prediction. Especially at the start of the season SM improved predictions, with the ability to explain 60% (groundnut), 63% (millet), 76% (sorghum) and 67% (maize) of yield variability. These findings are particularly relevant for parametric drought insurance, because an earlier detection of drought conditions enables earlier payouts, which then help to mitigate the development of shocks into serious crises with often long-lasting socioeconomic effects. 

    Based on the analysis a yield deficiency indicator was developed. Strong spatial correspondence was found between the yield deficiency indicator and the WRSI as reported by the African Risk Capacity reports. For example, for millet in Senegal for the drought 2019 strong yield deficiencies in the provinces of Ziguinchor, Fattick, Kaolack and Kaffrine and moderate deficiencies in Thies, Louga and Tambacounda were found. Which corresponded to low WRSI as reported by the African Risk Capacity in its end of season report of 2019. This analysis demonstrates the high added-value of satellite-based soil moisture for anticipatory drought risk financing and early warning systems. 

    How to cite: Vreugdenhil, M., Greimeister-Pfeil, I., Preimesberger, W., Brocca, L., Camici, S., Massart, S., Enenkel, M., and Wagner, W.: Satellite soil moisture for drought assessment and early-warning in water limited regions, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9918, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9918, 2022.

    EGU22-10123 | Presentations | HS6.1 | Highlight

    The International Soil Moisture Network: supporting and advancing EO research through open source in-situ soil moisture observations 

    Tunde Olarinoye, Stephan Dietrich, Matthias Zink, Fay Boehmer, Irene Himmelbauer, Lukas Schremmer, Ivana Petrakovic, Daniel Aberer, and Wouter Dorigo

    For over a decade, the International Soil Moisture Network (ISMN) has been providing free in-situ soil moisture data for validating and improving global satellite soil moisture products, weather prediction, agricultural activities, research and training as well as for the development of hydrological models. The ISMN is a community-wide effort and aggregates soil moisture observations from several organizations, harmonizes them and provides a centralized platform where end users can access them. Presently, the ISMN consists of over 72 soil moisture networks and more than 2800 stations spread across the globe. For more than a decade, the ISMN has been funded by European Space Agency and established, developed and maintained by Vienna University of Technology (TU Wien), Austria.

    For continuing development, outreach and maintenance of the ISMN, a sustainable and long-term support is required. In order to achieve such long-term support, the ISMN will be transferring to the German Federal Institute of Hydrology (BfG) and connected International Center for Water Resources and Global Change (ICWRGC) in Germany within 2022. While BfG and ICWRGC (operating under the auspice of UNESCO and WMO) will host and maintain the ISMN data facility, long-term financial support will be provided by the German Federal Institute of Hydrology through the Federal Ministry of Digital Infrastructure and Transport.

    The ICWRGC has being coordinating the Global Terrestrial Network – Hydrology (GTN-H) as well as Global Environment Monitoring System for Freshwater (GEMS/Water Data Center) for several years. Hence, the center has an extensive experience, resources as well as scientific advisory support for a long-term sustainable operation and maintenance of the ISMN. As we look forward to a new future of ISMN, we also want to maintain, even improve on the great community support the project has received.

    Therefore, our presentation aims to give an overview of the contribution of ISMN to research and training development, provides recent updates regarding the data service and ongoing technical developments. Furthermore, we want to introduce the new host as well as presenting the future outlook of the ISMN, which include setting up scientific advisory board with members from relevant UN organizations, key data providers and data users that would help promote and develop the ISMN further. Through the connection to UN organizations, member states could be encouraged to share their operational soil moisture data with the ISMN for continuing support of global climate and water resources observations. We also look forward to gaining new collaborations that will help in extending the ISMN database, initiate discussion between stakeholders to improve visibility and scientific advancement of the ISMN as well as promoting the importance of soil moisture within global earth observations data products.

    How to cite: Olarinoye, T., Dietrich, S., Zink, M., Boehmer, F., Himmelbauer, I., Schremmer, L., Petrakovic, I., Aberer, D., and Dorigo, W.: The International Soil Moisture Network: supporting and advancing EO research through open source in-situ soil moisture observations, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10123, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10123, 2022.

    EGU22-10336 | Presentations | HS6.1

    Intercomparison of current soil moisture products from remote sensing and modeling over COSMOS field sites in Germany 

    Toni Schmidt, Martin Schrön, Zhan Li, and Jian Peng

    Soil moisture (SM) is a critical part of the terrestrial water cycle, drives land–atmosphere interactions, and can represent hydro-climatic extremes such as floods and droughts. Numerous SM products from remote sensing and modeling were developed within the last decades to investigate SM dynamics on a large scale. However, a manifold of their retrieval algorithms, resolutions and coverages of horizontal, vertical, and temporal domains make a fair intercomparison challenging. The focus of this study is the intercomparison of the temporal SM dynamics of 15 selected SM products over 25 field sites in Germany using SM estimations from ground-based sensors of the Cosmic-Ray Soil Moisture Observation System (COSMOS) as a reference. A temporal coverage of 2015–2020 was selected, covering the European drought of 2018/19. SM estimations from COSMOS intrinsically average out the spatial heterogeneity of the surrounding environmental properties and cover the dynamics of both, surface SM (SSM) and root-zone SM (RZSM). This makes them a valuable ground reference for the validation of coarse-resolution SM products from remote sensing and modeling on the horizontal domain. On the vertical domain, the deeper vertical representation of COSMOS estimations is a challenge for the validation of SM estimations from remote sensing which capture SSM dynamics only. The newly released extensive COSMOS Europe data set contains hourly time series of in-situ SM at many locations. It allowed a comprehensive intercomparison and validation of the selected SM products over locations of different land cover types in Germany. We have selected SSM products from single remote sensors (AMSR2 L3, ASCAT L3 (H115/H116), Sentinel-1 L2, SMAP L3E, and SMOS L3), from dual sensors (Sentinel-1/ASCAT L3 and SMAP/Sentinel-1 L2), and from multiple sensors (ESA CCI and NOAA SMOPS). These SSM products have furthermore been vertically extrapolated using an exponential filter to additionally investigate their potential of resolving RZSM dynamics. In addition, we have selected products that already comprise both SSM and RZSM. These were obtained either through the assimilation of remote sensing SSM estimations into models (ASCAT L3 (H141/H142), SMAP L4, GLDAS-2 L4, and GLEAM), through exponential filtering of remote sensing SSM estimations (SMOS L4), or through reanalysis (ERA5-Land). We found that all selected products show a similar seasonal variability, but represent the sub-seasonal variability differently. For this we have analyzed bias and uncertainty estimations as static and dynamic measures, respectively. The match of SM dynamics of the selected SSM products with the SM dynamics obtained from COSMOS increases after applying an exponential filter. The same is true for the comparison of SM dynamics from COSMOS with those within lower layers of RZSM products. Nevertheless, the RZSM dynamics cannot be completely resolved by the selected products, neither by exponential filtering of given SSM data nor by published RZSM data. Our findings contribute to providing a systematic evaluation of state-of-the-art large-scale SM products and insights on how to improve SM estimation. Future work is needed to extend our study to a European scale to increase the complexity of environmental properties of the ground reference field sites.

    How to cite: Schmidt, T., Schrön, M., Li, Z., and Peng, J.: Intercomparison of current soil moisture products from remote sensing and modeling over COSMOS field sites in Germany, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10336, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10336, 2022.

    EGU22-10452 | Presentations | HS6.1

    Soil Moisture Mapping Using Uncrewed Arial Systems (UAS) 

    Ruodan Zhuang, Salvatore Manfreda, Yijian Zeng, Brigitta Szabó, Silvano F. Dal Sasso, Nunzio Romano, Eyal Ben Dor, Paolo Nasta, Nicolas Francos, Antonino Maltese, Giuseppe Ciraolo, Fulvio Capodici, Antonio Paruta, János Mészáros, George P. Petropoulos, Lijie Zhang, Teresa Pizzolla, and Zhongbo Su

    Soil moisture (SM) is an essential element in the hydrological cycle influencing land-atmosphere interactions and rainfall-runoff processes. Quantification of the spatial and temporal behaviour of SM at field scale is vital for understanding water availability in agriculture, ecosystems research, river basin hydrology and water resources management. Uncrewed Arial Systems (UAS) offer an extraordinary opportunity to bridge the existing gap between point-scale field observations and satellite remote sensing providing high spatial details at relatively low costs. Moreover, UAS data can help the construction of downscaling models which can link the land surface features and SM to identify the importance level of each predictor. To optimize the usage of data from UAS surveys for generating high-resolution SM at field scale, a comparative study of various SM retrieval or downscaling methods can be beneficial.

    In this study, four methods, which include the apparent thermal inertia method, Kubelka–Munk method (KM), simplified temperature-vegetation triangle method, and random forest model (RF), were compared by theory background, data requirements, operation procedures and SM estimation results. The above-mentioned models have been tested using UAS data and point measurements collected on the Monteforte Cilento site (MFC2) in the Alento river basin (Campania, Italy) which is an 8 hectares cropland area (covered by walnuts, cherry, and olive trees). A number of long-term studies on the vadose zone have been conducted across a range of spatial scales. The thermal inertia model is built upon the dependence of the thermal diffusion on SM, which were inferred from diachronic thermal infrared data. The Kubelka–Munk Model is a spectral model to retrieve surface SM using optical data. The simplified temperature–vegetation triangle model, was used to map surface SM based on simultaneous information of the vegetation coverage and surface temperature. In addition, we also introduce an SM downscaling method using the RF model and SENTINEL-1 CSAR 1km SM product.

    The study is concluded with the inter-comparison of methods. The results from KM have the highest resolution which is the same as the input multispectral data. The results of RF and KM provides information only for bare soil pixels according to the principle of the model. Results show good performances for all methods, but the simplified triangle and thermal inertia model provides better performances in terms of correlation coefficient and RMSE measured with respect to in-situ measurements. In addition, it is worthy to say that the RF downscaling method reveals the features controlling the spatial distributions of SM at a different scale.

    This research is a part of EU COST-Action “HARMONIOUS” and waterJPI project “iAqueduct”.

    How to cite: Zhuang, R., Manfreda, S., Zeng, Y., Szabó, B., Dal Sasso, S. F., Romano, N., Ben Dor, E., Nasta, P., Francos, N., Maltese, A., Ciraolo, G., Capodici, F., Paruta, A., Mészáros, J., Petropoulos, G. P., Zhang, L., Pizzolla, T., and Su, Z.: Soil Moisture Mapping Using Uncrewed Arial Systems (UAS), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10452, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10452, 2022.

    A multifractal technique has been used to downscale 1 km optical remote sensing MODIS derived soil moisture index (SMI) to the scale of interpolated soil moisture map produced by ground measurements at the Valencia Anchor Station (VAS) during the SMOS Validation Rehearsal Campaign (2008) with the spatial resolution of 32 meters. Scale invariance assessment shows a constant behavior of soil moisture variability at all scales of aggregation. This result proves the homogeneity of the VAS region from a mathematical point of view and exempts or allows us from using ancillary data such as topography, soil texture and vegetation characteristics in our downscaling model. Our predicted soil moisture values compared to the observed ground data show RMSE ranges from 0.026 to 0.039 for 2008/05/02, indicating accurate predictions for this date. However, there are high RMSE values in the range of 0.761 to 0.784 for 2008/04/24, due to rainfall events (30 mm accumulated) occurring in the region a few days prior to the measurements, which influenced the result of the downscaling model. At the same time, the strong correlation (77%) between the predicted and the observed data is promising and warrants further application of the model to other homogeneous areas with or without rainfall events.

    How to cite: Ansari Amoli, A., Mahmoodi, A., and Lopez-Baeza, E.: A Statistical Downscaling Approach of Soil Moisture Estimations by Synergistically using Optical Remote Sensing and Ground Soil Moisture Measurements at the Valencia Anchor Station, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10457, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10457, 2022.

    EGU22-11252 | Presentations | HS6.1

    Characterising recent drought events using current reanalysis and remote-sensing soil moisture products with a standardised anomalies-based framework 

    Martin Hirschi, Bas Crezee, Wouter Dorigo, and Sonia I. Seneviratne

    Drought events have multiple adverse impacts on environment, society, and economy. Monitoring and characterising such events is thus crucial. Here we test the ability of selected current reanalysis and merged remote-sensing products to represent major seasonal and multi-year drought events of the last two decades globally. We consider the ERA5, and the related ERA5-Land, as well as the MERRA-2 reanalysis products, and the ESA CCI, and the corresponding near-real time C3S remote-sensing soil moisture products (both encompassing an ACTIVE, a PASSIVE and a COMBINED product). The considered products offer opportunities for drought monitoring since they are available in near-real time.

    We focus on soil moisture (or agricultural) drought and analyse events within pre-defined spatial and temporal bounds derived from scientific literature. Based on standardised daily anomalies of surface and root-zone soil moisture, the drought events are characterised by their magnitude, duration, spatial extent, and severity (i.e., the combination of duration and standardised anomalies below -1.5).

    All investigated products are able to indicate the investigated drought events. Overall, responses of surface soil moisture are often strongest for the reanalysis products ERA5 and ERA5-Land and weakest for the remote-sensing products (in particular for the ACTIVE satellite products). The weaker drought severities in the remote-sensing products are related to shorter event durations as well as partially less pronounced negative standardised soil moisture anomalies. The magnitudes (i.e., the minimum of the standardised anomalies over time) are reduced in MERRA-2 and in the ACTIVE satellite products. Diverse global distributions of long-term trends in dry-season soil moisture may explain some differences in the drought responses of the products. Also, the lower penetration depth of microwave remote sensing compared to the top layer of the involved land surface models, as well as sensing issues of active microwave remote sensing under very dry conditions could explain the partly weaker drought responses of the remote-sensing products during the investigated events. In the root zone (based on the reanalysis products), the drought events often show prolonged durations, but weaker magnitudes and smaller spatial extents.

    How to cite: Hirschi, M., Crezee, B., Dorigo, W., and Seneviratne, S. I.: Characterising recent drought events using current reanalysis and remote-sensing soil moisture products with a standardised anomalies-based framework, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11252, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11252, 2022.

    EGU22-294 | Presentations | HS6.2

    Performance of satellite rainfall estimates for flood and drought monitoring 

    Mohamed Hamouda, Gilbert Hinge, and Mohamed Mohamed

    In recent years, many researchers indicated that earth-observing satellites perform well in measuring or estimating precipitation rates. However, it has been highlighted that the performance of satellite rainfall estimates (SREs) is affected by many factors. In this study, a meta-data analysis was conducted to assess the performance of different SREs for flood and drought monitoring under diverse settings to test the influence of factors related to climate, topography, watershed size, and length of SREs data record. Koppen climate classification was used to classify the different studies into different climatic zone. Mean elevation was used as an indicator of varying topography. Studies were grouped into three different categories depending upon their available data record length. The impact of various factors on the performance of SREs was assessed with three statistical indices: Pearson correlation coefficient, Root Mean Square Error, and Nash-Sutcliffe Efficiency. Results showed that the performance of SREs for drought and flood monitoring is influenced by the climate, length of the data record, interactions between the applied hydrological model and type of SRE, and topography. Microwave-based SREs performed were found to perform better than infrared-based SREs. Low lying landscapes exhibited higher accuracy of SREs in flood and drought monitoring compared to complex mountainous terrain. In most cases, IMERG and CMORPH outperformed other SREs.  IMERG showed the best drought monitoring performance with Pearson correlation values ranging between 0.96-0.99. It was found that the best SREs that can represent the observed streamflow vary depending on the type of hydrological models. Also, the hydrological model performance for flood prediction significantly increases (p<0.05) when using the SREs for model calibration compared to when the model is manually calibrated with historical gauge data. Bias-adjusted SREs performed better than their counterpart. Overall, SREs offer great potential for flood and drought monitoring, but their performance needs to be enhanced for hydrological applications.

    How to cite: Hamouda, M., Hinge, G., and Mohamed, M.: Performance of satellite rainfall estimates for flood and drought monitoring, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-294, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-294, 2022.

    EGU22-721 | Presentations | HS6.2

    Spatial scale evaluation of forecast flood inundation maps using Synthetic Aperture Radar (SAR) images. 

    Helen Hooker, Sarah L. Dance, David C. Mason, John Bevington, and Kay Shelton

    Flood inundation forecast maps provide an essential tool for disaster management teams to aid planning and preparation ahead of a flood event in order to mitigate the impacts of flooding on the community. Evaluating the accuracy of forecast flood maps is essential for model development and improving future flood predictions and can be achieved by comparison with flood maps derived from remote-sensing observations. Conventional, quantitative binary verification measures typically provide a domain averaged score, at grid level, of forecast skill. This score is dependent on the magnitude of the flood and the spatial scale of the flood map. Binary scores have limited physical meaning and do not indicate location specific variations in forecast skill that enable targeted model improvements to be made. A new, scale-selective approach is presented to evaluate forecast flood inundation maps against Synthetic Aperture Radar (SAR)-derived observed flood extents. We evaluate forecast flood maps out to 10-days lead time for the Rivers Wye and Lugg (UK) during Storm Dennis, February 2020. A neighbourhood approach based on the Fraction Skill Score is applied to assess the spatial scale at which the forecast becomes skilful at capturing the observed flood. This skilful scale varies with location and when combined with a contingency map creates a novel categorical scale map, a valuable visual tool for model evaluation and development. The impact of model improvements on forecast flood map accuracy skill scores are often masked by large areas of correctly predicted flooded/unflooded cells. To address this, the accuracy of the flood-edge location is evaluated: this provides a physically meaningful verification measure of the forecast flood-edge discrepancy. Representation errors are introduced where remote sensing observations capture the flood extent at different spatial resolutions in comparison with the model. We evaluate the sensitivity of the verification measures to the resolution of the SAR-derived flood map.

    An ensemble of forecast flood inundation maps has the potential to represent the uncertainty in the flood forecast and provides a location specific, probabilistic, likelihood of flooding. This gives valuable information to flood forecasters, flood risk managers and insurers and will ultimately benefit people living in flood prone areas. We apply a scale selective approach to evaluate the spatial predictability of forecast ensemble flood maps. An ensemble forecast of flooding of the Brahmaputra in the Assam region, August 2017, is evaluated using flood extents derived from Sentinel-1 SAR images. The results are presented on a Spatial Spread-Skill (SSS) map, indicating where the flood map ensemble is over-, under- or well-spread. Overall, emphasis on scale, rather than domain-average score, means that comparisons can be made across different flooding scenarios and forecast systems and between forecasts at different spatial scales.

    How to cite: Hooker, H., Dance, S. L., Mason, D. C., Bevington, J., and Shelton, K.: Spatial scale evaluation of forecast flood inundation maps using Synthetic Aperture Radar (SAR) images., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-721, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-721, 2022.

    EGU22-1819 | Presentations | HS6.2

    Improved urban flood mapping: dependence of SAR double scattering on building orientation. 

    David Mason, Sarah Dance, Hannah Cloke, and Helen Hooker

    Urban flood mapping using SAR is an important tool for emergency flood incident management and improved flood forecasting. We have recently developed a method for detecting urban flooding using Sentinel-1 and WorldDEM data1. This is a change detection technique that estimates flood levels using pre- and post-flood images. It searches for increased backscatter in the post-flood image due to double scattering between water and adjacent buildings, compared to that in the pre-flood image where double scattering is between unflooded ground and buildings. If φ is the angle between building and satellite direction of travel, double scattering is strongest for low φ, and falls off as φ increases. It also depends on the building height and length, the depth of flooding, the roughness of the ground surface, and the complex dielectric constants of the building wall and ground surface.

    Ref. 2, modelling X-band data, concluded that the increase of double scattering was only high if buildings were roughly parallel to the flight direction. The modelling assumed isolated buildings, and in a complex urban environment any increase would be further masked due to adjacent buildings. This implies a limitation in our method, since if the falloff with φ is very rapid, this could reduce the number of flooded double scatterers detected.

    We used the model of ref. [3] to estimate the post- to pre-flood radar cross section (RCS) ratio for double scatterers in Sentinel-1 C-band images. In agreement with ref. [2], this predicted that high ratios would only be obtained from building walls with φ < 10°.

    However, there are limitations in the models, and as a result it was decided to carry out an empirical study to examine the relationship between the RCS ratio and φ. This was based on S-1 data from the UK floods of winter 2019/2020, using flooding in Fishlake as an example of flooding in moderate housing density, and flooding in Pontypridd as an example of flooding in dense housing. A LiDAR DSM was used to allow accurate measurement of φ.

    Our results showed that, as well as flooded double scatterers (DSs) with φ < 10°, a significant number of flooded DSs with 10° < φ < 30° also produced a high RCS ratio. Our method also benefited from the predilection for building houses facing south in the northern hemisphere. As the S-1 sensor is in polar orbit, descending/ascending passes image the east/west walls of a house at low φ values. Similar arguments hold in the southern hemisphere and tropics. These effects combined to provide a sufficient density of high ratio DSs from flooded buildings to estimate an accurate average flood height for a local region. In areas of high housing density, the density of high ratio DSs from flooded buildings did fall, probably due to adjacent buildings, but was still sufficient to estimate an accurate local flood height.

    1 Mason et al., JARS 15(3), 032003, (2021).

    2 Pulvirenti et al., IEEE TGRS, 54(30), 1532-1544. (2016).

    3 Franceshetti et al., IEEE TGRS, 40(8), 1787, 1801. (2002).

     

     

    How to cite: Mason, D., Dance, S., Cloke, H., and Hooker, H.: Improved urban flood mapping: dependence of SAR double scattering on building orientation., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1819, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1819, 2022.

                    Rapid and accurate mapping of floods offers an excellent advantage for local, regional decision-makers to mitigate the exposure of human and material losses. The current study assessed the performance of several machine learning (ML) and deep learning (DL) models for detecting and mapping floods using Sentinel-1 SAR imagery. Three distinct approaches were used with machine learning and deep learning models: pixel classification, object-based image analysis and object instance segmentation. The ML models are Random Forest (RF) and Support Vector Machine applied for pixel classification and object-based image analysis. The DL models are U-NET, DeepLabV3 and Mask RCNN used for pixel classification and object instance segmentation. The models were implemented using SNAP (Sentinel Application Platform), ESRI ArcGIS Pro, Esri ArcGIS API for Python and Python programming language. To test the model's scalability, five different cases studies were selected. These areas are located in Romania (Prut River sector, Timiș River sector and Râul Negru sector), the United States of America (Missouri River sector) and Australia (Broughton Creek sector). Five Sentinel-1 images were used for each flood, having four collected previous to the flood event and one collected after the flood event. Each Sentinel-1 image was calibrated and ortho-corrected, and filtered using SNAP. The intensity images were stacked and scaled in the range of the intensity thresholds associated with water and non-water so that all the case studies have the same margins for intensity. Further, samples were collected in ArcGIS Pro from the Prut River region using the stack of images created from the previous step. Besides water, other classes, such as forest, agricultural fields and bare soil, were collected and used in the training process. The training for the ML models took place directly on the standardized radar images within ArcGIS Pro. The training of the DL models was done through the use of Jupyter Notebooks and ArcGIS API for Python. The models were trained on samples collected from the Prut River area and then tested on all selected regions to assess their ability to perform in different study areas. The highest accuracy, calculated as Intersect over Union, was obtained by the U-Net model (IoU score of 0.74). Comparable accuracies were obtained by the RF and SVM models implemented with OBIA, with an IoU score of 0.72. Mask R-CNN and DeepLabV3 got IoU scores of 0.70, and the lowest accuracies for floods mapping were obtained by the RF and SVM models implemented as pixel classification (both having IoU scores of 0.53).

    How to cite: Toma, A. and Sandric, I.: Mapping flooded areas using Sentinel-1 radar satellite imagery series through Machine learning and Deep learning methods, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2947, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2947, 2022.

    EGU22-3724 | Presentations | HS6.2

    Bare-earth DEM generation from ArcticDEM, and its use in flood simulation 

    Yinxue Liu, Paul Bates, and Jeffery Neal

    Terrain representation is important in many fields including flood mapping. In urban areas, topography data without ground objects are preferred in flood simulation for multiple concerns. However, the topography data collected by remote sensing techniques all contain the artefacts height to some extent. High-resolution photogrammetry DEMs, like ArcticDEM, are emerging with the widely available possibility while approaches to generate bare-earth DEM from them has yet been fully investigated. In this paper, we used the city of Helsinki as a case study. The optimal filter was selected among two morphological filters (PMF, SMRF) and then was used to generate bare-earth ArcticDEM with its various parameter combinations, generating a filtered ArcticDEM ensemble. Then, the elevation error and the flooding performance for a pluvial flooding scenario of this ensemble were evaluated at 2 m and 10 m resolution, respectively, using the LIDAR DTM as the benchmark. The SMRF was found to be advantageous over PMF and be effective at removing artefacts with broad parameter range. In the optimal ArcticDEM-SMRF the RMSE was reduced by up to 70%, achieving 1.02 m, and the simulated water depth error was reduced to a comparable magnitude expected from the LIDAR DTM simulation of 0.3 m. This paper indicates that the SMRF can be directly applied to generate bare-earth ArcticDEM in urban environment although caution should be taken when using in areas with densely packed buildings or vegetation. The results imply that the high-resolution photogrammetry DEMs have the potential to be an alternative of LIDAR in the future.

    How to cite: Liu, Y., Bates, P., and Neal, J.: Bare-earth DEM generation from ArcticDEM, and its use in flood simulation, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3724, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3724, 2022.

    EGU22-3787 | Presentations | HS6.2

    Flood inundation mapping using 2-d streamflow hydraulic modeling and land subsidence data from InSAR observations in the Alto Guadalentin valley, Spain. 

    María Navarro-Hernández, Javier Valdés-Abellán, Roberto Tomás, Serena Tessitore, Pablo Ezquerro, and Gerardo Herrera

    Floods are natural extreme events that occur after heavy rains, having a great impact on human settlements developed along flood risk areas (such as floodplains, valleys, etc.). Alto Guadalentin Valley is an orogenic tectonic depression affected by extreme flash floods. Additionaly, this area is affected by the fastest subsidence in Europe with a rate up to -10 cm/year due to groundwater withdrawal. In this study we present two flood event 2-D models comparison between different time land subsidence scenarios (1992 and 2016). The flood inundation modelling was performed in the Alto Guadalentin River and their tributaries using the Hydrologic Engineering Center River Analysis System 2D (HEC-RAS 2D) model, for the purpose of determining the flooded area extent and the depth water variations produced by the effect of land subsidence over time. To recreate both scenarios, different sets of synthetic aperture radar (SAR) images acquired by ERS (1992-2000), ENVISAT (2003-2010) and Cosmo-Skymed (2011-2016) satellites were used to calculate the magnitude and  spatial distribution of land subsidence using SAR Interferometry (InSAR) technique. The subsidence accumulated between 1992 and 2009 and between 2009 and 2016 derived from InSAR was substracted and added, respectively, to a Digital Surface Model (DSM) with 2.5 m spatial resolution from 2009 obtained using Light Detection and Ranging (LiDAR) to obtain the actual topography of the valley before (i.e. 1992) and after (i.e. 2016) the subsidence period covered by InSAR. These DEMs were used to generate the two 2D hydraulic models that ran in an unsteady mode. The results revealed significant changes in the water surface elevation with an increase of 3,073,200 m2 in the areas with depth water greater than 0.8 m over 24 years. From these simulation a flood risk map was performed. The resulting flood hazard data provides useful information to understand the inundation risk taking into account land subsidence contribution in the Alto Guadalentin Valley. This information can be of paramount importance for emergency management and civil protection against future potential floodings.

    How to cite: Navarro-Hernández, M., Valdés-Abellán, J., Tomás, R., Tessitore, S., Ezquerro, P., and Herrera, G.: Flood inundation mapping using 2-d streamflow hydraulic modeling and land subsidence data from InSAR observations in the Alto Guadalentin valley, Spain., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3787, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3787, 2022.

    EGU22-4067 | Presentations | HS6.2

    Analysis of pan-tropical GNSS-R observations from CYGNSS satellites for floods detection and mapping 

    Pierre Zeiger, Frédéric Frappart, and José Darrozes

    Global Navigation Satellite System Reflectometry (GNSS-R) is an emerging remote sensing technique for studying land geophysical parameters. The launch of NASA’s Cyclone GNSS (CYGNSS) mission in 2016 provides GNSS-R data in the pan-tropical area with high spatiotemporal resolution. In this study, we analyze the bistatic observations from CYGNSS for a dynamic floods detection. We compute the coherent reflectivity from CYGNSS L1 data and we grid it at a 0.1°, 7 days spatiotemporal resolution. We use a K-means clustering technique to label the CYGNSS pixels based on their time series of reflectivity. Several reflectivity patterns are extracted from the characteristics of each labelled class: low, medium or high values of reflectivity, and constant or variable amplitude throughout the year. Results are compared to static and dynamic inundation maps, elevation from digital elevation models (DEM), and to land cover information to evaluate the potential of CYGNSS observations for mapping flood dynamics at a global scale. Results highlight the influence of the presence of water on the reflected signals recorded by the CYGNSS satellites. First, high reflectivity values are found over permanent water bodies (lakes, large rivers). Then, seasonal floods are identified by a highly variable value of reflectivity throughout the year, with a peak consistent with the maximum extent of inundations. This is clearly identified over some great floodplains in the Orinoco, Amazon and Parana basins, and over irrigated croplands in the Ganges-Brahmaputra, Mekong and Yangtze basins.

    While the global link between CYGNSS observations and floods is assessed, we have identified some limitations at the regional scale. First, very dense canopy layers in tropical forests reduce drastically the penetration of GNSS L-band signals, as for other microwave remote sensing data. Thus, floodplains in densely vegetated areas are underestimated using CYGNSS dataset only. Secondly, the reflectivity over bare soils as in the Sahara or in Australia is high, creating sometimes a confusion with water bodies. Soil Moisture is also well captured by CYGNSS observations with a similar seasonality and a lower amplitude of reflectivity when compared to flooded regions. Finally, CYGNSS observations are affected by the elevation. Water bodies at high elevation suffer from a reduced amplitude of the signal, but are still detectable. To overcome these limitations, a CYGNSS-based mapping of floods dynamics should integrate additional information from the biomass, the land cover and the elevation. We are currently working on this aspect to supply a 0.1°, 7 days CYGNSS flood product to the hydrological community.

    How to cite: Zeiger, P., Frappart, F., and Darrozes, J.: Analysis of pan-tropical GNSS-R observations from CYGNSS satellites for floods detection and mapping, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4067, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4067, 2022.

    EGU22-4078 | Presentations | HS6.2

    How many inundations are detectable in Europe using Sentinel-1 and Sentinel-2? 

    Angelica Tarpanelli, Stefania Camici, and Alessandro Mondini

    Inundation is one of the major natural hazards in Europe. After a number of dramatic floods, the Member States agreed to draw up guidelines to develop a flood risk assessment, flood hazard and risk maps and flood risk management plans (Directive 2007/60/EC) with the aim to reduce the adverse consequences on the human health and the environment. Flood hazard and risk evaluation is not straightforward and it is traditionally based on hydro-monitoring systems  not adequately distributed in the territory or on hydrodynamic models as a tool for delineating flooded areas. In the last decades, the satellite sensors launched for Earth Observation represent a valid support for early warning systems and for mitigating the impact of future flooding. The ESA Earth Observation Program includes a series of satellites, Sentinels, for the operative observation of the natural phenomena and, in particular, Sentinel-1 (SAR) and Sentinel-2 (optical) are more suitable for mapping flooded areas. The two instruments assurance an almost global coverage for free. However, the spatial resolution (10 – 20 m) and the revisit time (5 – 6 days) of the sensors do not always guarantee a full mapping of inundated territories.

    Here, we proposed a study to evaluate the effectiveness of the Sentinel-1 and Sentinel-2 in the mapping of floods in Europe, where the flood events have duration ranging from some hours to a few days. To reach the target, we analyzed ten years of river discharge data over almost 2000 sites in Europe and we simulated flood riverine inundations selecting flood events over three established thresholds (97th, 99th and 99.5th percentile). Based on the revisit time of both the satellites constellations and the cloud coverage for the optical sensors, we derived the percentage of potential inundation events detectable from Sentinel-1 and Sentinel-2. Assuming the configuration of a constellation of two satellites for each mission and considering the ascending and descending orbit, we find that on average the 58 % of flood events were potentially observable by Sentinel-1 and only the 28 % by Sentinel-2.

     

     

    How to cite: Tarpanelli, A., Camici, S., and Mondini, A.: How many inundations are detectable in Europe using Sentinel-1 and Sentinel-2?, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4078, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4078, 2022.

    EGU22-4403 | Presentations | HS6.2

    High spatial and temporal resolution flood monitoring through integration of multisensor remotely sensed data and Google Earth Engine processing 

    Rosa Colacicco, Alberto Refice, Raffaele Nutricato, Annarita D'Addabbo, Davide Oscar Nitti, and Domenico Capolongo

    Climate change and anthropogenic impact are intensifying the frequency and intensity of extreme flood events. This is particularly worrying in the Mediterranean area, which is highly vulnerable and therefore subject to increased flood risk. The monitoring of flooded areas at high-resolution plays an important role in all phases of disaster management, from alert to the emergency and civil protection phase, up to damage assessment, for compensation and risk reduction purposes.

    This study aims at the multi-temporal analysis of remote sensing data, mainly radar data, through the implementation of a semi-automated system for the high-resolution mapping of river flooding effects. The objective is also to develop a system based on the fusion of different data sources and for different land cover types. The system includes an algorithm for the computation of multi-temporal, probabilistic flood maps, based on the analysis of amplitude series (in dB) of a stack of SAR images, acquired both in areas with permanent water and in areas with potential flooding. Exploiting a Bayesian inference framework, conditioned probabilities are estimated for the presence of water. The procedure relies on the temporal modelling of the SAR amplitudes time series, in order to account for seasonal and other slow temporal trends, and thus highlighting floods as events causing abrupt variations of the backscatter, lasting for a single or a few acquisitions. The methodology is particularly suited to data from sensors characterized by a high temporal frequency, such as the European Sentinel-1 constellation, whose two sensors acquire with the same geometrical configuration every 6 days over Europe. In parallel, a land use classification, at high resolution, is produced for each year within the period of acquisition of the satellite image stack (late 2014 to present) using Google Earth Engine [1]. This cloud-based platform makes it easy to access high-performance computing resources for processing geospatial data, allowing for the independent development of algorithms and subsequently specific applications. This supervised classification, achieved with the 'random forest' machine learning technique, is obtained through the combined use of SAR Sentinel 1 and optical Sentinel 2 images, over each entire year of interest. We show how the combination of these techniques can help gaining insight on the land cover, and on the expected changes of their appearance in the remotely sensed data in flooded conditions. This information can be used to improve the performance of the monitoring algorithm over various land cover scenarios and climatic settings.

    The procedure is tested over the Metaponto plain, in the Basilicata region (southern Italy). The proposed methodologies can however be used for other contexts affected by similar events, in the Mediterranean area and worldwide.

    References

    • Gorelick, N., Hancher, M., Dixon, M., Ilyushchenko, S., Thau, D., Moore, R. (2017) - Google Earth Engine: Planetary-scale geospatial analysis for everyone. Remote Sensing of Environment, Volume 202, 2017, Pages 18-27, ISSN 0034-4257, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rse.2017.06.031.

    How to cite: Colacicco, R., Refice, A., Nutricato, R., D'Addabbo, A., Nitti, D. O., and Capolongo, D.: High spatial and temporal resolution flood monitoring through integration of multisensor remotely sensed data and Google Earth Engine processing, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4403, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4403, 2022.

    EGU22-4556 | Presentations | HS6.2

    Observation-based bankfull discharge estimates to improve global flood models 

    Michel Wortmann, Louise Slater, Richard Boothroyd, Greg Sambrook Smith, and Jeffrey Neal

    The conveyance capacity of rivers is a key uncertainty in regional and global flood models. Most models resort to assumptions of uniform discharge recurrence of 1-2 years, using modelled discharge. While this assumption may hold on average, reach-scale bankfull discharge has been shown to vary significantly at the global scale. To improve this key boundary condition in large-scale hydrodynamic models, we have coupled emerging understanding of the hydrological and geomorphological drivers of bankfull discharge with recent advances in remote sensing products and machine learning. Using measured bankfull discharge values derived from stage-discharge and width-discharge relationships as reference, we construct a data-driven model to estimate bankfull discharge globally at the reach scale (30m centreline pixels and sub-kilometre vector reaches). Various remote sensing products are used as predictor variables that pertain to either catchment-wide or reach-specific attributes. This includes river geometry and floodplain metrics derived from Landsat water masks that have also been used to construct the underlying river network. This novel river network was designed to be as DEM-independent as possible, allowing for multi-thread channels, bifurcations and canals. Early results indicate good agreement between predicted and independent reference values.

    The new dataset will be used to improve the parametrisation of a state-of-the-art global flood model as part of the EvoFlood research project (NERC, UK), but is also expected to be useful for other hydrological and hydrodynamic models as well as investigations at regional to global scales.

    How to cite: Wortmann, M., Slater, L., Boothroyd, R., Sambrook Smith, G., and Neal, J.: Observation-based bankfull discharge estimates to improve global flood models, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4556, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4556, 2022.

    EGU22-4657 | Presentations | HS6.2

    The optimal processing chain for flood mapping using polarimetric SAR in a temperate zone wetland 

    Monika Gierszewska and Tomasz Berezowski

    In this study, we investigated the influence of speckle filters and decomposition methods with different combinations of filter and decomposition windows sizes on classification accuracy. The study area was a part of Biebrza National Park, located in Northeast Poland. The C-Band SAR image from Radarsat 2 sensor was processed using various speckle filters (boxcar, IDAN, improved Lee sigma, refined Lee) in 5x5, 7x7, 9x9, and 11x11 pixel window sizes. We processed the filtered data using nine polarimetric decompositions also in 5x5, 7x7, 9x9, and 11x11 pixel window sizes. We used the calculated polarimetric features to conduct a supervised classification with random forest machine learning algorithms for each combination of processing parameters in three different scenarios: (1) each decomposition product was used separately as a model input; (2) all decomposition products with the same speckle filtering method were used as a model input; (3) all decomposition products with all speckle filtering methods were used together as the model input. Overall, the most accurate classification model (87%) was produced in scenario 3 with an 11x11 filter and decomposition windows. In scenario 1, the highest overall accuracy achieved the Cloude-Pottier decomposition (72%) and the lowest produced the Touzi decomposition (38%). In scenario 2, the IDAN filter provided the highest accuracy (84%) with an 11x11 filter window and a 9x9 decomposition window. The obtained results show that the selection of appropriate processing parameters is an important step in the SAR data classification workflow. Our study also indicates the most suitable combination of radar image processing parameters for wetland classification.

    How to cite: Gierszewska, M. and Berezowski, T.: The optimal processing chain for flood mapping using polarimetric SAR in a temperate zone wetland, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4657, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4657, 2022.

    EGU22-4887 | Presentations | HS6.2

    Surface water detection and flood mapping using optical remote sensing and water-related spectral indices 

    Cinzia Albertini, Andrea Gioia, Vito Iacobellis, and Salvatore Manfreda

    The use of multispectral satellite imagery for flood mapping and river monitoring is a fast and cost-effective method that can benefit from the growing availability of medium-high-resolution and free remote sensing data. Since the 1970s, several satellites are observing the Earth surface supporting water detection studies and flood management. In addition, many techniques exploiting different spectral indices have been proposed in the literature. Considering the high number of available sensors and their differences in spectral and spatial characteristics, this work aims to examine the applications of satellite remote sensing for water extent delineation and flood monitoring. Focusing on freely available optical imagery, this study presents a discussion of the most used satellites for flood and wetland mapping to highlight trends of current research studies. Furthermore, performances of the most common spectral indices for water segmentation are analysed first qualitatively, based on evidence obtained from a significant literature review, and then quantitatively by comparing different water-related index algorithms applied to a real case study. Performance assessment is carried out to provide an overview of the best sensor-specific spectral index in detecting surface water and expressed in terms of overall accuracy (OA) and Kappa coefficient.

    How to cite: Albertini, C., Gioia, A., Iacobellis, V., and Manfreda, S.: Surface water detection and flood mapping using optical remote sensing and water-related spectral indices, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4887, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4887, 2022.

    EGU22-4942 | Presentations | HS6.2

    A Comparison of three deep learning-based methods for large-scale urban flood mapping using SAR data 

    Jie Zhao, Yu Li, Patrick Matgen, Ramona Pelich, Renaud Hostache, Wolfgang Wagner, and Marco Chini

    Synthetic Aperture Radar (SAR)-based floodwater detection in urban areas remains challenging because of the complex urban environment. Generally, open water appears as dark in SAR intensity images due to low values of backscattering caused by specular reflections, while standing water in built-up areas may lead to an increase of the backscattering value depending on the strength of the double bounce effect between the floodwater and the building’s facades. According to previous studies, it is known that the multitemporal interferometric SAR coherence is valuable for improving flood detection in urbanized areas while SAR intensity is more suited to map floods over bare soil. Deep convolutional neural networks approaches have also shown promising results in remote sensing applications, such as land cover classification, object detection and floodwater mapping. For the latter case and with particular attention to urban areas, there is not yet a well-established and unique method neither a privileged dataset to perform the detection of floodwater. In order to have a better understanding of the ability of different deep learning models for urban flood mapping, we compared the performance of three different deep learning-based methods, i.e. U-Net, U-Net with convolutional block attention module (CBAM) and U-Net with an Urban-aware module developed by us, for large-scale urban flood mapping. Here, we used as input multi-temporal intensity and interferometric SAR coherence data and the classification differentiates between flooded bare soils/sparely vegetated areas and flooded urban areas. To learn how to focus on different inputs, the urban-aware U-Net considers prior information provided by a SAR-derived probabilistic urban mask while CBAM U-Net only uses annotated data.
    The annotated training dataset is composed of a small subset of Sentinel-1 data acquired during the Houston (US) flood, caused by Hurricane Harvey in 2017, and the Iwaki (Japan) flood, caused by Typhoon Hagibis in 2016, where ground truth data are available. Three independent datasets (i.e. Houston (US) flood in 2017, Koriyama (Japan) flood in 2016 and Beira (Mozambique) flood in 2019) were considered as test cases in order to evaluate the generalizability capabilities of the proposed approach with respect to different scenarios. To evaluate the accuracy of flood mapping in urban areas, we adopted the F1 score. The urban-aware U-Net improves the F1 score to 0.63 in the Houston case and 0.66 in the Beira case while the other two models’ results have quite low F1 values (0.04 ~ 0.38) in Houston case and Beira case. Moreover, a visual inspection of the resulting floodwater maps over the entire Sentinel-1 frame suggests that urban-aware U-Net has less over-detection compared with U-Net and CBAM U-Net. These results indicate that the prior information helps in the proper use of multi-temporal SAR data in large-scale flood mapping. Moreover, considering that the models were trained using a very small and independent dataset and given the agreement of the results with the available ground truth, we consider urban-aware U-Net as a promising approach, having the potential to be used for near real-time urban flood mapping in case of future flood events.

    How to cite: Zhao, J., Li, Y., Matgen, P., Pelich, R., Hostache, R., Wagner, W., and Chini, M.: A Comparison of three deep learning-based methods for large-scale urban flood mapping using SAR data, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4942, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4942, 2022.

    EGU22-5877 | Presentations | HS6.2

    Flood inundation mapping using Sentinel-1 SAR images with Google Earth Engine cloud platform 

    Qin Wang, Lu Zhuo, Miguel Rico-Ramirez, Dawei Han, Jiao Wang, Ying Liu, and Sichan Du

    Flood events are expected to become increasingly common with the global increases in weather extremes. The present state of the technologies for flood risk mapping is typically tested on small geographical regions due to limitation of flood inundation observations, which hinders the implementation of flood risk management activities. Synthetic aperture radar (SAR) sensors represent an indispensable data source for flood disaster planners and responders, given their ability to image the Earth's surface nearly independently of weather conditions and the time of day or night. The decision by the European Space Agency (ESA) Copernicus program to open data from its Sentinel-1 SAR satellites to the public marks the first time of global, operational SAR data freely available. Combined with the emergence of cloud computing platforms like the Google Earth Engine (GEE), this development presents a tremendous opportunity to the disaster response community, for whom rapid access to analysis-ready data is needed to inform effective flood disaster response interventions and management plans. Here, we present an algorithm that exploits all available Sentinel-1 SAR images in combination with historical Landsat and other auxiliary data sources hosted on the GEE to rapidly map surface inundation during flood events. Our algorithm relies on multi-temporal SAR statistics to identify unexpected floods in near real-time. Additionally, historical Landsat-based surface water class probabilities are used to distinguish unexpected floods from permanent or seasonally occurring surface water. The flexibility of our algorithm will allow for the rapid processing of future open-access SAR data, including data from future Sentinel-1 missions.

    How to cite: Wang, Q., Zhuo, L., Rico-Ramirez, M., Han, D., Wang, J., Liu, Y., and Du, S.: Flood inundation mapping using Sentinel-1 SAR images with Google Earth Engine cloud platform, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5877, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5877, 2022.

    EGU22-6019 | Presentations | HS6.2

    Flood analysis using satellite imagery and machine learning within Google Earth Engine: A catchment-based study in Northern Iran 

    Mostafa Rashidpour, Mahdi Motagh, Karim Solaimani, Mohammadali Hadian Amri, Sigrid Roessner, and Kaka Shahedi

    Knowledge about the location and extent of flooded areas in large catchments with different rainfall- runoff response in each sub-catchment is of key importance for planning flood management strategies. Haraz catchment with an area of more than 4000 square kilometers is located in the north of Iran and is frequently affected by floods. The lack of reliable spatiotemporal information on flood occurrence has been the main limiting factor for assessment of flood hazard and risk in this catchment.

    The current availability of satellite remote sensing sensors with high spatial and temporal resolution is highly valuable for detailed analysis of individual flood occurrence across various scales. In this study, we develop a machine learning approach using data from various remote sensing sensors including Landsat, Planet and Sentinel-2 to detect flood events in different tributary areas within the Haraz catchment which have occurred between 2015 and 2021. The random forest algorithm implemented in Google Earth Engine was used for image classification before and after flood events. The areas of each landcover type inundated by flood waters were calculated for the single flood events and the binary flood masks were overlaid on the study area. The results have revealed that seven flood events could be detected, whereas the two events in April 2015 and April 2019 had led to the largest areas of inundation because of the nature of these floods as riverine flood. Moreover, we have found that two parts of the river network – one in middle part of Norroud subcatchment adjacent to Baladeh City and another one in the area of the catchment outlet - have the largest potential for flood risk because of the frequency of inundation and the high vulnerability of built-up areas that occupy the floodplain. Thus, the findings of this study form the basis for a better understanding of the characteristics for recent flood hazard and risk in Haraz catchment.

    How to cite: Rashidpour, M., Motagh, M., Solaimani, K., Hadian Amri, M., Roessner, S., and Shahedi, K.: Flood analysis using satellite imagery and machine learning within Google Earth Engine: A catchment-based study in Northern Iran, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6019, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6019, 2022.

    EGU22-8645 | Presentations | HS6.2 | Highlight

    Novel usage of remotely-sensed flood footprints in the re/insurance sector 

    Federica Remondi, David Schenkel, and Rogier de Jong

    Flooding has been consistently one of the most recurrent and costly natural catastrophes globally. Only in 2021 large flood events claimed more than 2 000 victims and caused over USD 75 billion of economic losses, of which a quarter was covered by the insurance sector.
    Modelling floods and simulating their impact have proven to be particularly challenging in locations with fine-scale changes in elevation, complex terrains and man-made structures as is typical for dense urban centres.  By partnering with ICEYE, the largest commercial synthetic-aperture radar satellite operator, Swiss Re aims to advance flood risk modelling, assist disaster response and provide enhanced insights and new products to its clients. 

    We present few applications for the re/insurance sector of the remotely acquired flood maps at high resolution and water depth estimations. Firstly, the flood footprints are provided to clients for assessing the event magnitude and enabling faster loss assessment and payouts. Secondly, they are used as input to flood catastrophe models to obtain a first loss estimation for reinsurance portfolios. Thirdly, new insurance products that rely on the remotely-sensed flood footprints to trigger a payout have been explored. These parametric flood insurances, even with their limitations, present relevant potential applications for cities, large regions and the agriculture sector.

    How to cite: Remondi, F., Schenkel, D., and de Jong, R.: Novel usage of remotely-sensed flood footprints in the re/insurance sector, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8645, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8645, 2022.

    EGU22-9031 | Presentations | HS6.2

    Advances in online computing platforms and satellite sensor technologies enable unprecedented uptake of EO products 

    Guy J.-P. Schumann, Laura Giustarini, and Paolo Campanella

    Since the early seventies, it has been known that satellite images can add value to mapping and monitoring floods. With the early launches of the Landsat series, followed in the early eighties and nineties by synthetic aperture radar (SAR) missions on SIR-B, ERS-1 and RADARSAT-1 with their all-weather and day and night capabilities considerably expanded the potential of flood mapping from space. Since then, the world of open-access Earth Observation (EO) has grown considerably and available data to inform about floods and assist flood disasters from local to global scales have proliferated.

    This EO data proliferation coupled, in recent years, with complementing data from drones, IOT sensors and significant progress in online cloud computing platforms and interoperability has led to a massive amount of progress in both geospatial technology development and better actionable products and services based on EO. In the context of floods, machine learning has started to enable onboard satellite mapping, and reconstructing flooded area under cloud cover in optical images. In addition, recent scientific progress in SAR signal coherence processing is enabling the mapping of flooded buildings in urban areas. Online cloud computing platforms can now be used to upscale such flood mapping applications over entire regions, countries or even continents with the click of a button.

    Using several use case illustrations, this paper will present some major historical breakthroughs in EO-based flood mapping before presenting recent technological advances in rapidly mapping rural and urban flooding across various spatial scales. 

    How to cite: Schumann, G. J.-P., Giustarini, L., and Campanella, P.: Advances in online computing platforms and satellite sensor technologies enable unprecedented uptake of EO products, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9031, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9031, 2022.

    EGU22-9345 | Presentations | HS6.2

    Space-Enabled Modeling of the Niger River to Enhance RegionalWater Resources Management 

    Margherita Bruscolini, Taiwo Ogunwumi, and Guy Schumann

    The Niger River and floodplain landscape is experiencing a constant change as a result of natural and human processes thereby contributing to the yearly occurrence of flooding. The increasing flood frequency and intensity causes loss of life, destruction of assets and disrupts the livelihood of a large proportion of the population. Due to the current data challenges and lack of hydrological information we are developing a 2-D flood inundation model showing the spatially distributed dynamics of water surface elevation and future flood extent of Niger river and its surroundings. We considered the following parameters such as floodplain topography, river channel widths, banks heights, model parameters, and hydrology information to develop our final output which is an interactive web visualization map showing the inundated extent. Our developed 2D flood prediction model can be extended to other parts of the Niger River Basin which will contribute to a positive regional economic and environmental impact. It will also help the relevant ministries, emergency institutions, local partners and national government of Niger to build safe and resilient communities through effective risk communication and contribute to the achievement of the Sustainable Development Goal (SDG) 11 and 13.

    How to cite: Bruscolini, M., Ogunwumi, T., and Schumann, G.: Space-Enabled Modeling of the Niger River to Enhance RegionalWater Resources Management, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9345, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9345, 2022.

    It is expected that climate change – combined with a growing global population in ill-planned flood-prone coastal and riverine areas – will increase the destructive potential of river floods. Central to inundation risk mitigation are the acquisition and processing of high resolution and high frequency information on river discharge response to precipitation. To address this pressing societal need, we introduce a global scale satellite Earth Observation-based flood mapping and forecasting service – capitalizing on the quasi-continuous data stream generated by the radar onboard the Sentinel-1 satellite. Radar signals emitted from satellites are a very powerful tool for assessing flood extents – capable of ‘seeing’ through cloud covers and covering almost instantaneously thousands of square kilometers. In order to rapidly translate the large volume of SAR data into floodwater maps and value adding services, the European Commission’s Joint Research Centre (JRC) recently added Global Flood Monitoring (GFM) products based on Sentinel-1 as a new component to its Copernicus Emergency Management Service (CEMS). The GFM products are obtained by processing all incoming Sentinel-1 SAR images within 8 hours after data acquisition.  To reach a high degree of automation, the system takes advantage of the constantly updated 20 m Sentinel-1 data cube made available by the Earth Observation Data Centre (EODC) facilities. It is requisite that the Sentinel-1 based retrieval algorithm, as one of the core components of GFM, is both efficient and robust. Moreover, it is designed to balance two objectives:  to detect water at high accuracy (i.e. permanent and seasonal water bodies, and floodwater), while minimizing the identification of false alarms due to water-look-alikes surfaces that can be confused with floodwater. To enhance the robustness of the system, an ensemble-based mapping algorithm is implemented, which combines three independent floodwater mapping algorithms driven by different approaches. 1) LIST’s algorithm that requires three main inputs: the most recent SAR scene to be processed, a previously recorded overlapping SAR scene acquired from the same orbit and the corresponding previously computed flood extent map. The change detection algorithm maps all increases and decreases of floodwater extent and makes use of this information to regularly update the flood extent maps. 2) DLR’s algorithm requires one scene as the main input and further exploits three ancillary raster datasets: i.e. a digital elevation model (DEM), areas not prone to flooding and a reference water map. 3) TU Wien’s algorithm requires three input data sets: i.e. the SAR scene to be processed, a projected local incidence layer, and the corresponding parameters of a previously calibrated multitemporal harmonic model. The final floodwater map is obtained by integrating the results of the three independently developed algorithms. Pixelwise flood classifications are based on majority voting, such that at least two algorithms are in agreement. The algorithm is currently being extensively tested for different regions all over the world. A first quantitative evaluation shows encouraging results in relation to the accuracy for delineating the evolution of water bodies and further improvements to increase the accuracy of the GFM product is ongoing. 

    How to cite: Chini, M. and the Global Flood Monitoring team: An ensemble-based approach to map floods globally using Sentinel-1 data: The Global Flood Monitoring system of the Copernicus Emergency Management Service, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11555, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11555, 2022.

    EGU22-11696 | Presentations | HS6.2

    Application-Oriented Methods for Obtaining Geometrically Robust Digital Surface Models for Flood Hazard Assessment 

    Jose Maria Bodoque del Pozo, Estefanía Aroca Jiménez, Miguel Ángel Eguibar Galán, and Juan Antonio García Martín

    Digital surface models (DSMs) play a critical role in obtaining reliable flood hazard maps for urban areas. Widespread availability of LiDAR data (where available) greatly facilitates obtaining geometrically sound DSMs. However, to date, insufficient attention has been paid to generating methodological approaches to obtain geometrically consistent DSMs. Here, we propose an application-oriented protocol to obtain a geometrically robust DSM (DSM1 hereafter). Additionally, two further DSMs were produced considering, firstly, depiction of streets using breaklines as ancillary information (DSM2) and, secondly, direct interpolation of LiDAR data (DSM3). Geometric robustness of these DSMs was evaluated qualitatively, by plotting longitudinal profiles and cross sections to dominant runoff pathways, as well as quantitatively, through assessing DSMs vertical accuracy. We also assessed impact on hazard maps depending on geometric consistency of DSMs employed. To do so, hydraulic outputs resulting from DSM1 were used as a benchmark to compare hydraulic outputs obtained from DSM2 and DSM3. This comparison was made at two spatial resolution levels: i) considering total area flooded in each case through determining the F statistic; and ii) at the level of each pixel by calculating the kappa statistic from a confusion matrix. Our results revealed that: 1) DSM1 defined geometrically consistent configurations for main runoff pathways; 2) in urban areas with higher street and building density DSM1 provided better vertical accuracies than DSM2 and DSM3; and 3) reliability of flood hazard maps strongly depend on geometric quality of the DSMs produced. Findings deployed here, might be very valuable in achieving further reduction and better flood risk management.

    How to cite: Bodoque del Pozo, J. M., Aroca Jiménez, E., Eguibar Galán, M. Á., and García Martín, J. A.: Application-Oriented Methods for Obtaining Geometrically Robust Digital Surface Models for Flood Hazard Assessment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11696, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11696, 2022.

    During the last three decades, six major floods have stricken Al Ain city, UAE, caused serious property loss. Therefore, morphometric and hydrologic characteristics of Hafit mountain basin / Al Ain city have been investigated using GIS and remote sensing. This investigation helped to determine the main factors controlling flood hazard in Al Ain city and the most affected area by flood hazard.

    Watershed analysis of the study area helped to identify five main sub-basins. All of them are drained to the west as they are influenced by the surface topography and dipping slopes. This analysis explains the abundance of surface and groundwater west of Hafit Mountain.

    Five pour points have been placed on the lowest point of each basin where the highest accumulation flow ratio occurs. Another pour point was identified where a big change in stream direction occurred. These pour points are considered the most threatened areas by flood hazard and consequently potential sites for building dams and stream gauges. The dams and gauges could be also used to recharge exploited groundwater aquifer that contribute significantly to sustainable water resource management in such a hyper-arid area.

    The highest flow accumulation occurs in the northwestern part of Wadi Al Ain up to 140 km2, which explains the re-occurrence of flood in Al Ain City for several years.

    How to cite: Abu Ghazleh, S., Al Bizreh, A., and Sass, I.: Hydrological Analysis and Flood Hazard Mitigation in Al Ain City, United Arab Emirates (UAE), SE Arabia: GIS and Remote Sensing Implication, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12538, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12538, 2022.

    High resolution flood forecasting models integrated in Early Warning Systems (EWSs) can be supported by traditional (e.g., stage gauges) or innovative (e.g., Earth Observation – EO - data) sensors as inputs or observations for model calibration/validation or data assimilation. Stage gauges provide information only in specific points along the river network and could fail during extreme events. On the other hand, EO data could have strong limitations due by their spatial and temporal resolution, especially at medium-small scales. Therefore, multiple sources of distributed flood observations could represent a solution for managing uncertainties of flood models and lack of information left by each sensor.

    In this work, a flood modelling approach is proposed for the joint assimilation of both water level observations and EO-derived flood extents. The assimilation approach implements a Ensemble Kalman Filter, whose forecasting model includes a parsimonious geomorphic rainfall-runoff algorithm (WFIUH) and a Quasi-2D hydraulic algorithm. To overcome stability issues related to the updating of the Quasi-2D hydraulic model, novel approaches are proposed to both assimilate multiple stage gauge observations and retrieve distributed observed water depths from satellite images. The flood modelling chain is tested both separately and jointly assimilating stage gauges and satellite derived flood extents on a flood event for the Tiber river basin in central Italy. Results reveal that the assimilation of observations from static sensors and satellite images led to an overall improvement of the simulation performances in terms of Nash-Sutcliffe efficiency Pearson correlation and Bias to the Open Loop simulation. Moreover, the joint assimilation of the abovementioned observations allowed to reduce the flood extent uncertainty as respect to the disjoint assimilation simulations for several hours after the satellite image acquisition.

    How to cite: Annis, A., Nardi, F., and Castelli, F.: Testing the performance of a near-real time flood mapping framework jointly assimilating water levels from river gauges and satellite flood maps, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12867, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12867, 2022.

    Flooding is the most common and costliest global natural disaster, accounting for 43% of all recorded events in the last 20 years and expected to increase the global cost of flooding tenfold by 2030. Satellite imagery has proven beneficial for numerous flood use cases from historical modeling, situational awareness and extent, to risk forecasting. The addition of high resolution, high cadence satellite imagery from Planet Labs PBC has been widely adopted by the flood community, from researchers in academia to private companies in the insurance and financial services. 

    Planet Labs PBC currently operates over 200 satellites, comprising the largest constellation of Earth observation satellites. The PlanetScope dataset consists of broad coverage, always-on imaging of the entire landmass by 140+ Dove satellites at 3.7 meter resolution. Complementary to PlanetScope, the SkySat dataset includes 21 high resolution satellites imaging at .50 meter resolution with the ability to image and video any location on Earth via automated tasking commands. This presentation will highlight Planet’s capabilities serving the hydrological science community and cutting-edge flood research and technology.

    How to cite: Zajic, B. and Roy, S.: Flooding applications enabled by high resolution, high cadence imagery from the Planet Labs PBC constellation of satellites, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13512, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13512, 2022.

    EGU22-736 | Presentations | HS6.3

    Combining satellite altimetry, in-situ observations, and models to improve hydrological forecasting in West Africa 

    Claudia Canedo Rosso, Jafet C.M. Andersson, David Gustafsson, Mohammed Hamatan, and Mélissande Machefer

    Water level information is highly sought-after by operational hydrologists and emergency managers to improve flood management in, for example, West Africa (Lienert et al 2020). A main constraint of large-scale flood forecasting systems is an inability to convert streamflow volumes to water level at specific locations. Accurately representing water levels – and hence potential impacts of peak flows on local scale – is possible through detailed field work and hydraulic simulations (e.g. Massazza et al 2020). However, large-scale implementation of such approaches is typically constrained by lack of detailed topographic data. In this study we therefore develop a pragmatic method to estimate water levels using rating curves created through a combination of ground-based (in-situ) hydrometric gauge observations, hydrological simulations, and satellite altimetry data. Specifically, rating curves are created based on simulated discharge from HYPE models and 305 in-situ discharge observations from 1980 to 2020, in addition to 42 in-situ and 558 virtual water level stations (i.e. locations where Sentinel-3 missions intersect large rivers) from 2018 to 2020. The rating curves were estimated by fitting a conventional power-law equation. For the in-situ data this could be done directly from the two variables. These were, however, very scarce. We therefore exploited the EO-based virtual stations to be able to predict water levels at many more locations. To this end, rating curves were estimated using simulated discharge together with EO-based water level data at the virtual station locations. The inverted rating curve equation was subsequently used to transform simulated discharge to water level. The water levels estimated from simulated discharge were finally compared with the in-situ and virtual altimetry stations using accuracy performance metrics such as Nash-Sutcliffe efficiency (NSE) and Kling-Gupta efficiency (KGE). Furthermore, we examine and compare the rating curve uncertainty obtained from different data sources (in-situ, modelled and satellite data). This pragmatic methodology can be used in operational hydrology, specifically flood forecasting, to render forecasts more relevant at local scale and hence enable better flood risk management.

    How to cite: Canedo Rosso, C., Andersson, J. C. M., Gustafsson, D., Hamatan, M., and Machefer, M.: Combining satellite altimetry, in-situ observations, and models to improve hydrological forecasting in West Africa, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-736, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-736, 2022.

    EGU22-1131 | Presentations | HS6.3

    ToolBoxSWOT - A Python library dedicated to synthetical SWOT-like data for pre-launch river hydrodynamics studies. 

    Sophie Ricci, Charlotte Emery, and Andrea Piacentini

    The upcoming Surface Water and Ocean Topography (SWOT) satellite mission will provide a global and high resolution measurement of river water surface elevation. This product issued from large swath interferometry altimetry will be combined with high fidelity hydrodynamics solvers thanks to data assimilation algorithms to allow for river discharge estimation and prediction. Before launch, the SWOT-HR hydrology simulator is used to produce synthetic SWOT observation at each overpass time, adding the radar measurement error, such as layover and thermal noise, to the water elevation issued from a golden run simulation. 

    The ToolBoxSWOT is a chain of python scripts that formats the time varying hydrodynamic model outputs into a temporal sequence of water elevation raster data files used as inputs for SWOT-HR. A Digital Elevation Model, a geolocalized series of bathymetric profiles and river centerline are used to map the outputs of the hydrodynamic models onto the expected regular and high resolution 2D grid requested by SWOT-HR. The toolbox gathers strategies adapted to various levels of knowledge from well-known to unknown catchments. The ToolBoxSWOT is available on git and is provided with a container featuring the proper environment that embeds Python3, QGIS3, QGDAL and GRASS78. The ToolBoxSWOT was applied over a well-known reach of the Garonne river for which a DEM and gauge data are available as well as on the Brahmaputra river, using SWOT only-derived data. The toolbox allows the generation of various observation data sets available for the SWOT-hydrology community.

    How to cite: Ricci, S., Emery, C., and Piacentini, A.: ToolBoxSWOT - A Python library dedicated to synthetical SWOT-like data for pre-launch river hydrodynamics studies., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1131, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1131, 2022.

    EGU22-2927 | Presentations | HS6.3

    Shallow Lakes Water Level Estimation using Satellite Optical Imagery and Digital Elevation Models Over the Persian Plateau, Iran 

    Amirhossein Ahrari, Epari Ritesh Patro, Mahdi Akbari, Björn Klöve, and Ali Torabi Haghaighi

    Lakes' water levels have a dynamic behavior, and their variations are an essential subject for water resources research and management. These variations have a wide range of time scales, from short-term (daily) to long-term (yearly) scales. However, access to hydrological data is limited due to scarce observation stations, fragmented data holdings, and low data quality in developing countries. Satellite altimeters are considered the main source of water level estimation among remote sensing data. Although many seas and oceans are covered by altimetry satellites, currently, they have a huge gap in covering inland lakes. Accordingly, we proposed an alternative approach to estimate shallow lakes' water levels using typical optical imageries and digital elevation models. The water level is estimated based on the Area Elevation Model (AEM) approach, using MODIS surface reflectance product, ALOS DSM and Landsat JRC product as inputs to the model. The AEM helps extract the water level time series based on the information about water area obtained from satellite products using various spectral indices (NDWI_GNIR, NDVI, NDWI_RSWIR and MNDWI). The methodology was applied to eight shallow lakes in Iran using Google Earth Engine (GEE) platform. These lakes are located across the arid and semi-arid regions of the Persian Plateau, Iran. The lakes' water level in these regions is declining, and there is a great need for taking important measures by regional authorities for sustainable water management. Spectral indices and the effect of satellite resolutions were evaluated. Overall, this methodology can be the alternative approach for water level estimation for lakes with minimum or no ground observation and altimetry coverage.

    How to cite: Ahrari, A., Patro, E. R., Akbari, M., Klöve, B., and Torabi Haghaighi, A.: Shallow Lakes Water Level Estimation using Satellite Optical Imagery and Digital Elevation Models Over the Persian Plateau, Iran, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2927, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2927, 2022.

    EGU22-3513 | Presentations | HS6.3

    River Discharge estimation from optical satellite data: latest advances using NIR sensors 

    Paolo Filippucci, Luca Brocca, Stefania Bonafoni, and Angelica Tarpanelli

    River discharge is worldwide recognized as one of the variables whose knowledge is most needed in order to understand the evolution of climate, to assess the related risks and to develop mitigation and adaptation strategies. Notwithstanding this, river monitoring is still an open issue. The ground monitoring network is declining, with many rivers that are ungauged due to the difficulties of installing instruments on remote areas and the high costs of installation and maintenance of instruments. Furthermore, the absence of strategies for data sharing and the long latency in data dissemination worsen the situation, preventing the use of methods for natural hazard forecasting in many regions.

     In this framework, over the last few decades, satellite data have been used to support the ground network information thanks to the strong growth in technologies, data processing and applications that fostered their use for the water cycle monitoring. In particular, considering the daily river discharge measurement, the recent advances in near-infrared (NIR) satellite sensors encouraged their use for the river discharge estimation, due to their frequent revisit time and wide spatial coverage. Therefore, passive remote sensing data from multiple sensors such as MODIS, MERIS and OLCI (spatial resolution of about 250 - 300 m) have been used to develop a non-linear regression model to estimate the river flow in medium-sized catchments (around 100’000 km2). The model is based on the different behavior in the NIR band between a calibration pixel C, selected over land, and a measurement pixel M, selected over the river boundaries. The ratio of the two pixels is indeed well correlated with in situ river discharge, but the methodology still needs to calibrate the pixel locations by using observed data, limiting the usefulness of the methodology to the gauged areas.

    More recently, Sentinel-2 satellites of the European Union’s Earth observation COPERNICUS programme, foster the monitoring of narrow rivers (< 150 m wide) thanks to the high spatial resolution (10 m). The high resolution enables to better identify the main geographical features (e.g., water, vegetation, urban area, river boundaries) and to better monitor the effect of several factors (vegetation and sediments) in the river discharge estimation. An important contribution has been found in the sediment component, affecting the reliable reproduction of high flow due to the high reflectance of turbid water sensed by the satellite. For this reason, the original formulation for the estimation of river discharge has been modified and tested over several rivers worldwide to assess its influence in different environments.

    Here, we show the results of the analysis applying the new approach for the estimation of the river discharge to both Sentinel-2 and MODIS data, in order to evaluate the advantages of the use of high spatial resolution information. Furthermore, results and limitations of the uncalibrated version of the algorithm are also shown underling the possibility to use the methodology over ungauged rivers, where the absence of observed data prevents the applicability of the classical satellite methods for river discharge estimation. 

    How to cite: Filippucci, P., Brocca, L., Bonafoni, S., and Tarpanelli, A.: River Discharge estimation from optical satellite data: latest advances using NIR sensors, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3513, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3513, 2022.

    EGU22-3716 | Presentations | HS6.3

    Hydroclimate Elasticity of Accessible Water 

    Brian Thomas

    Terrestrial water response to climate-induced acceleration of the hydrologic cycle underpins water management challenges, whereby water management in an increasingly uncertain climate must adapt to ensure sufficient resource availability to sustain global ecosystems while meeting societal water needs. Although hydrologic cycle intensification is expected through increased evaporation and precipitation, the unequal redistribution of water fluxes over terrestrial land remains unclear. Studies investigating hydroclimatic sensitivity of runoff assumed long-term steady-state basin storage conditions where P=ET+Q.  Steady-state assumptions neglect the role of groundwater, lakes and reservoirs as vital management resources.  Although hydrologic models have been used to measure sensitivity of basin responses attributed to climate, an assessment of observation-based data which captures temporal changes in basin storage can provide valuable insights to understand fundamental changes in water storage due to hydroclimatic factors.  Here, a sensitivity analysis using the Gravity Recovery and Climate Experiment (GRACE) satellite observations combined with auxiliary hydroclimate variables is investigated.  GRACE captures changes in water stores that result due to water management schemes to offset short-term (i.e., monthly) and long-term (i.e., annual) water deficits in addition to water budget changes driven by P and ET.  Accessible water (AW) represents the combination of groundwater and surface water storage anomalies derived from GRACE, water stores deemed accessible to fulfill water demands.  Results document the role of seasonality and storage potential with respect to hydroclimate elasticity.  Findings reveal that >1 billion people live in basins with elasticity magnitudes >10, meaning that small shifts in P-ET will be magnified 10-fold with respect to AW.

    How to cite: Thomas, B.: Hydroclimate Elasticity of Accessible Water, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3716, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3716, 2022.

    EGU22-3900 | Presentations | HS6.3

    A first continuous and distributed satellite-based mapping of river discharge over the Amazon 

    Victor Pellet, Filipe Aires, Dai Yamazaki, Adrien Paris, and Xudong Zhou

    River discharge integrates many water-related processes over land, it is crucial for understanding inland water. Unfortunately, in situ measurements are very sparse at the global scale. This study presents a totally new approach for the mapping (i.e. spatially continuous estimate) of the river discharge based on satellite observation of hydrological variables and the water budget balance. First continuous satellite estimate of three water components (precipitation, evapotranspiration, and total water storage change) are corrected at basin scale using river discharge from a few gauge measurements. Secondly, the water budget is balanced at the grid level using flow direction for horizontal water exchange. This new approach is therefore based solely on satellite products and in situ measurements without the use of any dynamical model (except river map). The methodology is evaluated with the river dynamic model  CaMa-flood, altimetric water surface level (WSL) and surface water extent satellite estimate. While the spatial pattern of extreme events cannot be well represented only by in situ gauges information, our study shows the added value of the mapping to better describe these events. As hydrological application, our method can be used in synergy with all the altimetric stations to create discharge-WSL pair data, which will benefit to advanced applications.

    How to cite: Pellet, V., Aires, F., Yamazaki, D., Paris, A., and Zhou, X.: A first continuous and distributed satellite-based mapping of river discharge over the Amazon, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3900, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3900, 2022.

    EGU22-4110 | Presentations | HS6.3

    Estimating Water Surface Slope of Rivers Using ICESat-2 Observations 

    Daniel Scherer, Christian Schwatke, and Denise Dettmering

    The water surface slope of rivers is an essential variable for estimating river discharge. It is also helpful as a correction applied to range measurements of satellite altimetry missions to derive water level time series at a virtual station. Still, only rough and mean estimates of water surface slope are obtainable using classical satellite altimetry because of its coarse time and space resolution.

    Using the unique measurement geometry of ICESat-2 with six parallel laser beams, we derive instantaneous reach-scale water surface slope along and across the satellite's ground track. The method can be applied globally and provides extending insights into the time- and space-variability of the water surface slope of any river with increasing mission duration.

    We compare the ICESat-2 water surface slope estimates with time-variable slopes derived from in-situ data from multiple gauging stations and with static datasets (e.g., from SWORD). We also show the possible performance gain at multiple virtual stations in the "Database for Hydrological Time Series of Inland Waters" (DAHITI, https://dahiti.dgfi.tum.de) applying the water surface slope estimates as a correction of the orbit-drift which can be a few kilometers for repeat missions such as Jason-2/3. However, the largest impacts are expected for non-repeat orbit missions such as CryoSat-2 or Saral (after July 2016).

    How to cite: Scherer, D., Schwatke, C., and Dettmering, D.: Estimating Water Surface Slope of Rivers Using ICESat-2 Observations, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4110, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4110, 2022.

    EGU22-4817 | Presentations | HS6.3

    Improving the reliability of large-scale hydrological models with satellite observations 

    Dung Trung Vu, Thanh Duc Dang, and Stefano Galelli

    Over the past three decades, large-scale hydrological models have gained popularity due to the need to support water resources management at the regional and continental scales. One of the most challenging tasks for developing such models is the availability of data. The presence of human-water interactions, especially reservoir operations, can influence the model parameterization, while measured discharge and/or water levels along the rivers are necessary to the calibration purpose. However, such information is often unavailable. In particular, data on reservoir storage or river discharge are often not measured or shared between the riparian countries of transboundary rivers. A potential solution for this challenging task lies in satellite observations. Specifically, reservoir storage/release and river discharge/water level can be inferred from satellite images (Landsat/Sentinel-1/2) and/or altimetry data (Jason/Sentinel-3). In this study, we take advantage of remote-sensed data to improve the accuracy of a hydrological-water management model (VIC-Res) setup for the northern portion of the Mekong River Basin. Our modeling framework combines VIC-Res with an automated calibration procedure (based on a multi-objective evolutionary algorithm) that explicitly accounts for key water management decisions—inferred from satellite data—occurring within the basin. Results show that the use of such data largely improves the performance and reliability of the model.

    How to cite: Vu, D. T., Dang, T. D., and Galelli, S.: Improving the reliability of large-scale hydrological models with satellite observations, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4817, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4817, 2022.

    EGU22-5716 | Presentations | HS6.3

    Unraveling the hydrology of water bodies in the African Sahel Region using continental scale remote sensing 

    Tabea Donauer, Silvan Ragettli, Peter Molnar, Ron Delnoije, and Tobias Siegfried

    Water resources in the African Sahel Region are under increasing pressure due to climatic changes, population growth and land degradation. Often, societies rely on surface water from lakes and rivers to sustain their lives and livelihoods. It is therefore essential to monitor and understand the dynamics of these water bodies to assess past, present, and future water resource changes.

    Here we use satellite imagery and altimetry to determine water level and storage changes in small water bodies across the African Sahel. The method consists of detecting the ever-shifting edge of lakes and rivers in Landsat and Sentinel-2 optical imagery and assigning heights to shoreline points using altimetric data from ICESat-2satellite. This so-called “waterline method” assumes that the water-land boundary can be regarded as a contour line that connects points of equal elevation. We present novel extension of the waterline method which also allows to identify bathymetry changes over time from shoreline position observations. By tracking the temporal changes of surface water contour shapes, we can quantitatively analyse erosion and deposition processes. Past reservoir capacity changes and water storage variations are thus retrieved from optical remote sensing data, which are available over much longer periods of time and at higher revisiting frequenciesthan altimetry data.

    The operational implementation of the method offers access to the water levels and storage variations of more than 300 water bodies in 10 Sahelian countries over the period 2000-2021. The identified spatio-temporal trends reveal fascinatingly heterogeneous patterns of drying and wetting across the Sahelian zone. Wet-season water level data reveal increasing trends over the last 20 years from West to East. Dry-season water availability then depends to a large degree on storage capacity.

    Finally, we use the method for a detailed attribution analysis to identify drivers of change at Lac Wégnia, a designated RAMSAR site in Mali. The lake is characterized by an alarming decrease of dry-season surface water extent over the last 20 years. We recognize silting at the tributaries to the lake, but overall, erosion processes are dominant and threaten the persistence of the lake because of continuous backward erosion at the outlet of the lake. This explains the decreasing trend in water levels even for the wet-season, in spite of positive rainfall patterns.

    How to cite: Donauer, T., Ragettli, S., Molnar, P., Delnoije, R., and Siegfried, T.: Unraveling the hydrology of water bodies in the African Sahel Region using continental scale remote sensing, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5716, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5716, 2022.

    EGU22-7160 | Presentations | HS6.3

    Improving SAR Altimeter Processing over Inland Water - the ESA HYDROCOASTAL Project 

    Jérôme Benveniste and David Cotton and the HYDROCOASTAL Project Team

    Introduction

    HYDROCOASTAL is a two-year project funded by ESA, with the objective to maximise exploitation of SAR and SARin altimeter measurements in the coastal zone and inland waters, by evaluating and implementing new approaches to process SAR and SARin data from CryoSat-2, and SAR altimeter data from Sentinel-3A and Sentinel-3B. Optical data from Sentinel-2 MSI and Sentinel-3 OLCI instruments will also be used in generating River Discharge products.

    New SAR and SARin processing algorithms for the coastal zone and inland waters will be developed and implemented and evaluated through an initial Test Data Set for selected regions. From the results of this evaluation a processing scheme will be implemented to generate global coastal zone and river discharge data sets.

    A series of case studies will assess these products in terms of their scientific impacts.

    All the produced data sets will be available on request to external researchers, and full descriptions of the processing algorithms will be provided.

    Objectives

    The scientific objectives of HYDROCOASTAL are to enhance our understanding of interactions between the inland water and coastal zone, between the coastal zone and the open ocean, and the small scale processes that govern these interactions. Also, the project aims to improve our capability to characterize the variation at different time scales of inland water storage, exchanges with the ocean and the impact on regional sea-level changes.

    The technical objectives are to develop and evaluate new SAR and SARin altimetry processing techniques in support of the scientific objectives, including stack processing, and filtering, and retracking. Also, an improved Wet Troposphere Correction will be developed and evaluated.

    Presentation

    The presentation will describe the different SAR altimeter processing algorithms that are being evaluated in the first phase of the project, and present results from the evaluation of the initial test data set. It will focus particularly on the performance of the new algorithms over inland water.

    How to cite: Benveniste, J. and Cotton, D. and the HYDROCOASTAL Project Team: Improving SAR Altimeter Processing over Inland Water - the ESA HYDROCOASTAL Project, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7160, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7160, 2022.

    EGU22-7475 | Presentations | HS6.3

    Constraining river streamflow determination using bathymetry and slope from ICESat-2 satellite altimetry 

    Nico Sneeuw, Bo Wang, Jingyi Bao, Siqi Ke, and Mohammad Tourian

    In order to determine river streamflow over poorly gauged basins, spaceborne techniques are widely used to obtain hydraulic parameters like river height variation (H), slope (S), river width (W), velocity (V) and river cross section (or bathymetry). Conventional radar altimetry can only provide water height. It is also difficult to measure the slope of a reach even from multi-mission altimetry, due to the problems of the simultaneity and intersatellite biases.

    Laser altimetry with ICESat-2 enhances the opportunity to constrain river streamflow. The Advanced Topographic Laser Altimeter System (ATLAS) on the mission carries 3 pairs of laser transmitters (one strong and one weak beam in each pair) with photon-counting detectors. ATLAS emits 532-nm laser pulses (green light) at a 10 kHz repetition rate. It detects individual photons at 70 cm along-track separation for each shot on the earth’s surface with ~17 m diameter footprint. The very dense measurements can provide the height profile of the cross section. Since the laser penetrates water, it can potentially measure the river bathymetry, at least the nearshore part, depending on the turbidity of the water. With its off-nadir beams, the system is able to provide the slope of a reach.

    In our study, we process the point cloud of the river cross section and extract the nearshore river bathymetry. The slope is determined by three strong beams of one track. We also analyze the maximum depth of bathymetry in different seasons and different turbidity conditions. The water height of each beam is obtained from measurement of the center of the river (centerline from SWOT River Database), and validated with measurements of the weak beams.

    How to cite: Sneeuw, N., Wang, B., Bao, J., Ke, S., and Tourian, M.: Constraining river streamflow determination using bathymetry and slope from ICESat-2 satellite altimetry, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7475, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7475, 2022.

    EGU22-7925 | Presentations | HS6.3

    A generic hydrological forecasting system using existing and future altimetry assimilation: an OSSE study over the Niger basin 

    Vanessa Pedinotti, Rémi Jugier, Adrien Paris, Laura Sourp, Laetitia Gal, Marielle Gosset, Nicolas Picot, Gilles Larnicol, Sylvain Biancamaria, Denis Blumstein, Bachir Tanimoun, and Kone Soungalo

    The main motivation for this study is to evaluate the use of real time observations from different sources for hydrological forecasting. The advent of new satellite missions providing high-resolution observations of continental waters has raised the question of how to use them, especially in conjunction with models. At the same time, the multiplication of extreme events such as flash floods points to the need for tools that can help anticipate such disasters. To do so, it is necessary to set up a forecasting system that is generic enough to be used with different types of data and to be applied to different basins. It is in this perspective that a platform named HYdrological Forecasting system with Altimetry Assimilation (HYFAA) was implemented, which encompasses the MGB large scale hydrological model and an EnKF module that corrects model states and parameters whenever observations are available. As a preliminary study towards operationnability, the platform was tested in offline mode, in the framework of Observing Systems Simulation Experiments (OSSEs). Discharge estimates from three different observing systems were generated, namely in-situ streamflow measurement stations, Hydroweb radar altimetry, and the future SWOT interferometry mission. In this study, we chose to assimilate these data separately in order to analyze the capacity of the system to adapt itself to different orbital characteristics, especially coverage and repetitivity. This also allows us to quantify the contribution of SWOT. The MGB model, developed within the large-scale hydrology research group of the University of Rio Grande do Sul (Brazil), is a physically based and distributed hydrological model, which was coupled to an externalized Ensemble Kalman Filter (EnKF) to give corrected estimates of the model state variables and parameters.

    HYFAA is run on the Niger river basin over a reanalysis period and its performance against a control ensemble simulation (without data assimilation) is assessed to quantify the impact of assimilating observations from the different observing systems. The results show that data assimilation leads to significant improvements of NRMSE and KGE of the simulated discharge, everywhere on the basin and regardless of the observation system considered. Moreover, it is shown that the correction of the hydrodynamic parameters helps to improve the performance of the assimilation, in particular when observations are dense in space, probably due to the concomitant correction of forcing biases. The assimilation of SWOT data combined with a selection method provides the best correction of the discharge on the river itself as well as on its tributaries, giving promising perspectives for the prediction of flash floods. We therefore discuss limits and prospects for application in the framework of Observing System Experiments (using real observations).

    How to cite: Pedinotti, V., Jugier, R., Paris, A., Sourp, L., Gal, L., Gosset, M., Picot, N., Larnicol, G., Biancamaria, S., Blumstein, D., Tanimoun, B., and Soungalo, K.: A generic hydrological forecasting system using existing and future altimetry assimilation: an OSSE study over the Niger basin, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7925, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7925, 2022.

    EGU22-8505 | Presentations | HS6.3

    Large-scale spatio-temporal variability of the Congo Basin surface hydrologic components from space 

    Benjamin Kitambo, Fabrice Papa, Adrien Paris, Raphael Tshimanga, Stéphane Calmant, and Frédéric Frappart

    Despite being the second-largest watershed and tropical forest worldwide, with significant impacts on the global water cycle and in regulating Earth’s climate, the Congo River Basin’s (CRB) hydroclimatology remains among the least studied worldwide due to the lack of situ observations. To better characterize CRB surface hydrology and the variability of its different components at large scale, we jointly used a trove of large records of in situ and satellite-derived observations, specifically, Surface Water Level (SWL) from radar altimetry (a total of ~2,300 virtual stations) and Surface Water Extent (SWE) from the Global Inundation Extent from Multi-Satellite (GIEMS) dataset. A good performance is found between SWL from multi- satellite missions and in situ water height of historical and contemporary observations at different locations. The root mean square error varies from 10 cm for Sentinel-3A to 75 cm for European Remote Sensing-2.  SWL annual amplitude exhibits large spatial variability across the basin, with Northern sub-basins varying more than 5 m while the central and the southern sub-basins vary in smaller proportions (1.5 to 4.5 m). The assessment of SWE also agreed relatively well over a ~25-year period with in situ discharge from sub-basin to basin scale. At the basin scale, SWE shows that cuvette centrale is flooded at its maximum in October/November. The northern part of the basin reaches its maximum in September/October, and the southern eastern one in January/February. Furthermore, SWL and SWE help capture the water travel time across the basin that varies from 0 to 3 months and the regional relative contribution to the flow at Brazzaville station characterized by a bimodal hydrological regime. Northern sub-basins and the cuvette centrale contribute much to the large peak in December-January while the southern sub-basins contribute to both peaks. We further combine these two datasets to estimate the variability of Surface Water Storage (SWS) in rivers, lakes, floodplains, and wetlands across the entire basin over the period 1992–2015. The CRB SWS shows an annual amplitude varying between ~74 km3 and ~112 km3. Moreover, the combination of SWS and the annual variations of GRACE/GRACE-FO-derived terrestrial water storage permits us to estimate the long-term variation of sub-surface water storage. The use of these new long-term satellite-derived observations are an invaluable source of information for hydrological modeling and will allow to properly characterize and reproduce the hydro-climate variability of the CRB, and a better representation of local and regional hydrological processes. These results ensure therefore an improved monitoring of CRB hydrological variables from space, and open new perspectives towards a better evaluation of the impact of climate variability on water availability in the region.

    How to cite: Kitambo, B., Papa, F., Paris, A., Tshimanga, R., Calmant, S., and Frappart, F.: Large-scale spatio-temporal variability of the Congo Basin surface hydrologic components from space, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8505, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8505, 2022.

    EGU22-9234 | Presentations | HS6.3

    Satellite observations for runoff and river discharge estimation: STREAMRIDE approach 

    Stefania Camici, Angelica Tarpanelli, Luca Brocca, Christian Massari, Karina Nielsen, Nico Sneeuw, Mohammad J. Tourian, Shuang Yi, Marco Restano, and Jérôme Benveniste

    River discharge monitoring is crucial for many activities ranging from the management of water resources to flood risk mitigation. Due to the limitations of the in situ stations (e.g., low station density, incomplete temporal coverage as well as delays in data access), the river discharge is not always continuously monitored in time and in space. This prompted researchers and space agencies, among others, in developing new methods based on satellite observations for the river discharge estimation.

    In the last decade, ESA has funded the SaTellite based Runoff Evaluation And Mapping and River Discharge Estimation (STREAMRIDE) project, which proposes the combination of two innovative and complementary approaches, STREAM and RIDESAT, for estimating river discharge. The innovative aspect of the two approaches is an almost exclusive use of satellite data. In particular, precipitation, soil moisture and terrestrial water storage observations are used within a simple and conceptual parsimonious approach (STREAM) to estimate runoff, whereas altimeter and Near InfraRed (NIR) sensors are jointly exploited to derive river discharge within RIDESAT. By modelling different processes that act at the basin or at local scale, the combination of STREAM and RIDESAT is able to provide less than 3-day temporal resolution river discharge estimates in many large rivers of the world (e.g., Mississippi, Amazon, Danube, Po), where the single approaches fail. Indeed, even if both the approaches demonstrated high capability to estimate accurate river discharge at multiple cross sections, they are not optimal under certain conditions such as in presence of densely vegetated and mountainous areas or in non-natural basins with high anthropogenic impact (i.e., in basin where the flow is regulated by the presence of dams, reservoirs or floodplains along the river; or in highly irrigated areas).

    Here, we present some new advancements of both STREAM and RIDESAT approaches which help to overcome the limitations encountered. In particular, specific modules (e.g., reservoir or irrigation modules for STREAM approach) as well as algorithm retrieval improvements (e.g., to take into account the sediment and the vegetation for RIDESAT algorithm) were implemented. Furthermore, in order to exploit the complementarity of the two approaches, the two river discharge estimates were also integrated within a simple data integration framework and evaluated over sites located on the Amazon and Mississippi river basins. Results demonstrated the added-value of a complementary river discharge estimate with respect to a stand-alone estimate.

    How to cite: Camici, S., Tarpanelli, A., Brocca, L., Massari, C., Nielsen, K., Sneeuw, N., Tourian, M. J., Yi, S., Restano, M., and Benveniste, J.: Satellite observations for runoff and river discharge estimation: STREAMRIDE approach, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9234, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9234, 2022.

    Climate change affects the Earth system at all levels (IPCC et al., 2007). The Monitoring and prediction of droughts and flood events, agricultural production, and analysis of energy and water will continue to gain importance, accordingly. Especially agricultural systems are of the main affected by rising temperatures, extreme precipitation events, and droughts, all of which can lead to crop failures (Lobell et al., 2011). Approximately 40% of the world's crop production comes from irrigated agriculture (Vereecken et al., 2009), the future expansion of which will continue to provide adequate food for the population. However, efficient irrigation must be ensured to prevent unnecessary groundwater depletion (Richey et al., 2015). To increase efficiency and safeguard yields, novel technologies need to be developed for innovative, real-time water management strategies that will allow farmers to make management decisions at the right time (OECD, 2010). Predicting the overall water supply and its components (e.g., soil water content and groundwater) for plants growth and at each growing stage would assure a sustainable irrigation. Therefore, the aim of this study is to predict the root zone soil water content which is one of the main components of the total water supply for plant growth. For this purpose, spaceborne remote sensing data from C- and L-band Synthetic Aperture Radar will be used. These data provide valuable information about the surface soil moisture only. But by integration into a hydrologic model in a data assimilation framework the soil moisture of the root zone as well as the groundwater recharge can be estimated to identify the actual irrigation requirements and resources. 

    How to cite: Moradi, S., Mengen, D., Vereecken, H., and Montzka, C.: Integrating satellite remote sensing data and hydrological models by data assimilation for a near real time estimation of the soil water content at local scale., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9755, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9755, 2022.

    EGU22-10411 | Presentations | HS6.3

    Long-term dynamics of reservoirs across the globe 

    Albrecht Weerts, Pieter Hazenberg, Bart van Osnabrugge, and Willem van Verseveld

    In many places of the world, reservoirs play an important role in relation to water security, flood risk, agriculture production, hydropower, hydropower potential, and environmental flows. By limiting the amount of water flowing out of the reservoir, reservoirs control flooding downstream, but they can also increase downstream runoff during drought.  

    Detailed information about reservoir management (e.g. inflow, volume and outflow operations) is generally unknown or only available to the local control authority. As a result, large-scale information on reservoir dynamics is currently unknown. Recently, reservoir volume dynamics have been estimated from satellite observations based on reservoir surface area estimates. While Earth observation (EO) has the potential to monitor water from space and fill this gap, temporal resolution of these datasets generally varies between 3-7 days without direct information on reservoir inflow and outflow. Hydrological model reanalysis provides a complementary data source. Using cloud computing infrastructure and a high resolution distributed hydrological model wflow_sbm, we present a novel dataset of historical daily reservoir variations for 3236 headwater reservoirs across the globe for the period 1970-2020. Results derived with wflow_sbm model forced with various forcing sources based on observations and reanalysis (ERA5, EOBS, CHIRPS, NLDAS, BOM, MSWEP) are compared with: 1) measured discharge observations, 2) in situ reservoir elevation and volume measurement, and 3) volume estimates derived using satellite observations. Overall good comparisons between the hydrological model and the different measurement sources are observed, although considerable variations are observed. During the presentations we will zoom in on some of the large-scale changes in reservoir dynamics as observed in South America and Africa and how these potentially impact society.

     

    How to cite: Weerts, A., Hazenberg, P., van Osnabrugge, B., and van Verseveld, W.: Long-term dynamics of reservoirs across the globe, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10411, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10411, 2022.

    EGU22-12647 | Presentations | HS6.3

    Deriving storage of small and medium-sized reservoirs with elevation datasets and medium-resolution satellite imagery 

    Gennadii Donchyts, Hessel Winsemius, Tjalling de Jong, Antonio Moreno-Rodenas, and Maarten Pronk

    Small and medium-sized reservoirs play an important role in water systems that help cope with climate variability. Although reservoirs and dams are criticized for their negative social and environmental impacts by reducing natural flow variability and obstructing river connections, they are also recognized as important for social and economic development and climate change adaptation. These reservoirs are crucial to the well-being of many societies worldwide, but regular monitoring records of their water dynamics are mostly missing. Multiple studies exist which look into the quantification of water stored in the reservoirs behind these dams. Still, very few studies focus on small and medium-sized reservoirs globally. In this research, we present the current status of the research focusing on the derivation of storage for small and medium-sized reservoirs. We use multi-annual multi-sensor satellite data with up to daily observation frequency, combined with cloud analytics, derive dynamics and storage of small (10-100ha) to medium-sized (>100ha) artificial water reservoirs globally. We derive storage by combining multiple datasets such as water occurrence, surface water area dynamics observed from space, and several elevation datasets available globally such as ALOS, NASADEM, EU-DEM. We evaluate the applicability of ICESat-2 and GEDI LiDAR sensors to estimate water storage in these reservoirs, perform validation for more than 700 reservoirs globally, and assess the applicability of these datasets to monitor water storage for more than 70 000 reservoirs globally.

    How to cite: Donchyts, G., Winsemius, H., de Jong, T., Moreno-Rodenas, A., and Pronk, M.: Deriving storage of small and medium-sized reservoirs with elevation datasets and medium-resolution satellite imagery, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12647, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12647, 2022.

    EGU22-993 | Presentations | HS6.4 | Highlight

    Modeling future Snow Line Elevation dynamics in the Alps based on long remote sensing time-series 

    Jonas Köhler, Andreas Dietz, and Claudia Kuenzer

    The inter and intra-annual dynamics of seasonal snow are of key interest in the tourism-based economies of many Alpine regions as well as for millions of people in the adjacent European lowlands when it comes to freshwater supply and electricity generation. However, accurate snow observations over long periods of time and at large spatial scales are especially challenging in inaccessible mountainous areas. This can be overcome by using data from Earth Observation satellites, which have been constantly monitoring the Earth’s surface for almost 40 years. On a catchment basis, we derive the Snow Line Elevation (SLE) from Landsat data for the entire Alpine region and model the spatio-temporal dynamics in monthly time-series ranging from 1984 to today. Based on the historical observations we model future SLE dynamics comparing different uni-variate and multi-variate approaches and assess them for their ability to generate multi-year forecasts from EO-derived time series data. These forecasts can enable local and regional stakeholders to adapt to a potentially changing snow regime under climate change.

    How to cite: Köhler, J., Dietz, A., and Kuenzer, C.: Modeling future Snow Line Elevation dynamics in the Alps based on long remote sensing time-series, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-993, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-993, 2022.

    Rationale: After the Tropical Rainfall Measuring Mission (TRMM) was successfully launched by NASA and JAXA in 1997, NASA released the first GPM-era global precipitation product (IMERG) in April 2014, aiming to obtain precipitation data with ultra-fine temporal and spatial resolution around the world. Examining the key precipitation data in different climatic areas influenced by the monsoon can effectively help users and algorithm developers maximise the accuracy and characteristics of new satellite remote sensing products. Objective: To this end, this study used the upper and middle Lancang River basin (UMLRB), a transnational river with complex climatic conditions, as the research area to explore the applicability and precipitation distribution of IMERG and TRMM, and evaluate their accuracy. Methods: In this study, various performance indexes were used to comprehensively evaluate the retrieval accuracy of IMERG and TRMM remote sensing precipitation data in UMLRB; these indexes can be divided into two categories according to the evaluation objectives. One type of indexes mainly evaluates the amplitude consistency of precipitation, and the other type of indexes is mainly used to evaluate the occurrence consistency of precipitation. Results: The results indicated that: (1) The temporal distribution of precipitation in different climatic regions was correctly detected by IMERG and TRMM in the UMLRB, and the dry and wet seasons in the climate transition zone were distinct. (2) IMERG and TRMM tended to overestimate moderate rain (1.0-20 mm/d) while underestimating heavy rain (20-50mm/d) and extreme precipitation (> 50mm/d). (3) In terms of the amplitude consistency of precipitation, the detection results of IMERG in the alpine climate zone were not completely consistent with those of TRMM, while those in the climate transition zone were consistent with TRMM. (4) The stronger the precipitation intensity, the worse the accuracy of IMERG and TRMM, especially between heavy rain (20-50 mm/d) and extreme precipitation (> 50mm/d). (5) The IMERG, which had greater application potential in complex climatic conditions, had higher accuracy than TRMM.” Conclusions/Recommendations: Therefore, before using remote sensing precipitation data to study watershed hydrometeorology in monsoon-affected areas, their seasonal distribution, precipitation intensity, and the type of remote sensing data should be carefully considered to verify their accuracy.

    How to cite: Lu, C., Fang, G., Ye, J., and Yang, Z.: Accuracy assessment of IMERG and TRMM remote sensing precipitation data under the influence of monsoon over the upper and middle Lancang River basin, China, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2078, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2078, 2022.

    Remotely sensed MODIS (Moderate Resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer) data and the NDSI (Normalized Difference Snow Index) based approach have been applied globally for snow cover mapping. However, this method displays severe omission errors in forested areas, due to the forest canopy shading of snow. In this study, we developed a new forest snow mapping algorithm based on MODIS reflectance data, time-lapse observations of forest snow, and a random forest model. We built a time-lapse camera network in the eastern Qilian Mountains in northwestern China to monitor the forest snow processes and obtain the ground truth data. The random forest (RF) model seems to be powerful in capturing the relationships between the MODIS surface reflectance bands and the forest snow presence. The presented approach significantly improved the accuracy of binary snow cover (BSC) mapping in forests. We evaluated the performance of the proposed algorithm with the traditional NDSI-based method. The results show that the new algorithm has a superior performance in forest BSC mapping, compared to the NDSI-based BSC. The proposed RF-BSC can retrieve ~70% of all real forest snow pixels, while the NDSI-BSC can only detect 8-14%. We further investigated the geographical influence (e.g. topography, forest coverage, and solar illumination) of the algorithm performance. This study suggests that the fusion of optical remote sensing data and ground-based observations using machine learning techniques has a great potential in improving the accuracy of land cover mapping.

    How to cite: Dong, C. and Luo, J.: Development of a new forest snow mapping algorithm using MODIS data, machine learning and time-lapse photography, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3473, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3473, 2022.

    EGU22-4520 | Presentations | HS6.4

    Snow extend and snow change mapping with Sentinel-1 imaging using SVM 

    Flora Weissgerber, Céline Monteil, and Alexandre Girard

    Snow dynamics is a key parameter for the hydrological model predicting the river flow rate used in dam management. In the MORDOR model used by EDF, the information of the daily snow extent is an input to improve the flow prediction. This information is extracted from MODIS NDSI daily product. Due to cloud cover, this information can be lacking or imprecise for multiple consecutive days over one catchment, reducing the precision of the prediction.

    The goal of this study is to detect the snow extent using SAR data, since it can acquire images through clouds. We focus over the Guil catchment in the French Alps. Sentinel-1 interferometric stacks from June 2018 to August 2019 are used for three different orbits.

    Previous studies showed the capacity of the ratio between the current image and a reference image acquired in summer to detect wet snow [Nagler2016], or that the ratio between VH and VV could be linked to the height of snow [Lievens2019]. Interferometry has be shown capable to detect snow since the snow covered area can exhibit a lower coherence [Singh2008].

    To compare these parameters using a ground truth, we projected the MODIS NDSI data on our S1-stack using a 1m DEM and considered pixels as snowy if the NDSI is above 0.4.

    As pointed in other studies [Löw2002, Wang2015], it is very hard to set a threshold for these parameters, mostly because the vegetation exhibits volume scattering and changes the same way as snow. Using SVM, we investigated the capability of these parameters to detect snow in two setups:
    - snow detection: the goal is to classify the pixels as snow or snow-free for all the image, using Nagler parameter in VV and VH, the ratio between VH and VV at each date and the polarimetric coherence at each date. For Nagler parameter, the reference image is the temporal average of the images over July and August 2018.
    - change detection: the goal is to classify the pixels into 4 classes, snow-free to snow-free, snow to snow, snow-free to snow and snow to snow-free. Considering two consecutive images, this was done using the variation of the VV and VH ratio, the interferometric coherence between these images, and the ratio between the polarimetric coherences of the images.
    For each setup, the learning and the testing were done on two samples of 20000 randomly selected pixels, equally distributed between the classes.

    For the snow detection method, between 54% and 59% of the pixels are correctly classified, for the three orbits. This result is stable with the choice of the learning sample. For the change detection setup only 30% of the pixels are correctly classified. Moreover, the per-class metrics vary widely from one experience to the other. This variability as well as the low classification results underline the difficulty of the task but can also be linked to the resolution difference between MODIS used as ground truth and S1. To robustify the detection, spatial and temporal regularization seems necessary.

    How to cite: Weissgerber, F., Monteil, C., and Girard, A.: Snow extend and snow change mapping with Sentinel-1 imaging using SVM, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4520, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4520, 2022.

    EGU22-5117 | Presentations | HS6.4

    Development of a snow reanalysis pipeline using downscaled ERA5 data: application to Mediterranean mountains 

    Laura Sourp, Simon Gascoin, Mohamed Wassim Baba, and César Deschamps-Berger

    The Snow Water Equivalent (SWE) is a key variable to characterize water resource availability in mountain catchments. Despite its hydrological significance, the snow cover is poorly monitored in many regions due to a lack of in situ measurements. 

    Global climate reanalysis products provide increasingly accurate data but are too coarse to be used directly in mountain regions to reconstruct snow related variables. However these reanalyses have been successfully used to generate high resolution meteorological forcing and run a snowpack model in the central Andes and the High Atlas mountain ranges (Mernild et al. 2017; Baba et al. 2018). 

    The method is based on the MicroMet/SnowModel package (Liston and Elder 2006a; 2006b). MicroMet performs spatial interpolation of meteorological variables using the digital elevation model (downscaling) and the other routines of SnowModel computes the snowpack energy and mass balance. We have implemented a tool to improve the automation and scalability of this method to simulate the snow cover distribution in other regions using ERA5 or ERA5-Land. Our snow simulation tool only requires a digital elevation model as input. The land cover is extracted from the Copernicus global land cover map and the meteorological data are retrieved from either ERA5 or ERA5-Land over the period of interest.  

    We used three catchments under the influence of Mediterranean climate to evaluate the performance of this tool: Tuolumne (USA), Bassies (France) and Yeso (Chile). For each catchment either the modeled SWE depth or snow depth are compared with the validation data, over periods going from 3 to 8 years.  In the Tuolumne basin, where the dataset is the most accurate with several SWE maps per year, we find a very good agreement at the basin scale (RMSE 40 mm w.e.). However, the mean RMSE in the highest elevation band (3500-4000 m asl) can exceed 500 mm w.e., which we attribute to the  lack of gravitational transport in SnowModel and errors in the spatial distribution of precipitation. To reduce these errors in particular, we are implementing a non-deterministic representation of the precipitation input data to eventually allow the assimilation of globally available remote sensing data. 

    This tool will allow us to compute snow reanalyses in key mountain ranges around the Mediterranean sea over the past two decades (Pyrenees, Atlas and Mount Lebanon) and study the influence of topography and climate on the snow cover variability.

    How to cite: Sourp, L., Gascoin, S., Baba, M. W., and Deschamps-Berger, C.: Development of a snow reanalysis pipeline using downscaled ERA5 data: application to Mediterranean mountains, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5117, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5117, 2022.

    EGU22-7319 | Presentations | HS6.4

    SnowPEx+: The International Snow Products Intercomparison and Evaluation Excercise 2015-2020 

    Thomas Nagler and the SnowPEx Team

    Satellite observations are the only means for timely and complete observations of the global snow cover. A range of different satellite snow products is available, the performance of which is of vital interest for the global user community. We provide an overview on goals and activities of the SnowPEx+ initiative, dedicated to the intercomparison of northern hemispheric and global satellite snow products, derived from data of long-term operational as well as recently launched satellites. SnowPEx+ is the continuation of SnowPEx (2014-2017), carried out as an international collaborative effort under the umbrella of Global Cryosphere Watch / WMO and funded by ESA.

    SnowPEx+ focuses on two parameters of the seasonal snowpack, the snow extent (SE) from medium resolution optical satellite data (Sentinel-3, VIIRS, MODIS, AVHRR, etc.) and the snow water equivalent (SWE) from passive microwave satellite data. Overall, 15 hemispheric and global SE products (binary and fractional SE) and two SWE products are participating in the experiment. For intercomparison, daily SE products are transformed to a common map projection and standardized SnowPEx protocols are applied, elaborated by the international snow product community. The SE product evaluation applies statistical measures for quantifying the agreement between the various products, including the analysis of spatial patterns. Validation of SE products uses as benchmark high resolution snow maps from about 150 globally distributed Landsat scenes acquired in different climate zones, under different solar illumination conditions and over various land cover types. This snow reference data set, based on various retrieval algorithms, is generated and evaluated by the SnowPEx+ High Resolution Snow Products Focus Group. In-situ snow data from several organisations in Europe, North America and Asia are also used for validating the satellite SE and SWE products. SWE products are also inter-compared with gridded snow products from land surface models driven by atmospheric reanalysis data. In addition, the multi-year trends of the various SE and SWE products are evaluated. We provide an overview on the snow products, discuss the validation and intercomparison protocols, and report on preliminary results from the intercomparison and validation of various snow products.

    How to cite: Nagler, T. and the SnowPEx Team: SnowPEx+: The International Snow Products Intercomparison and Evaluation Excercise 2015-2020, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7319, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7319, 2022.

    EGU22-9744 | Presentations | HS6.4

    Snow depth mapping over large, high-alpine regions by airplane photogrammetry 

    Leon Bührle, Mauro Marty, Lucie Eberhard, Andreas Stoffel, and Yves Bühler

    Abstract.

    Snow depths are traditionally determined by point measurements at automatic weather stations or field observations, which cannot capture the complexity of snow depth distribution in alpine terrain. Therefore, remote sensing techniques have become key tools for spatially continuous snow depth mapping. Only satellites, airborne laser scanners (ALS) or photogrammetry from piloted aircrafts are capable of covering large regions of more than 100 km². However, the accuracy of satellite data does not match/achieve the requirements for exact snow depth mapping yet. In comparison to ALS, photogrammetric methods are considerably more economic, but have the disadvantages of light and weather dependence as well as the lacking ability to penetrate high vegetation. Nevertheless, previous studies of photogrammetric snow depth mapping on a large scale have already proven the accurate implementation, but those studies were either limited to only one recording or characterized by a spatial resolution of around 2 m. These properties limit the comparison of snow depth distribution and the analysis of small-scale features.

    In our study we apply airborne imagery from the current state-of-the-art survey camera Vexcel Ultracam acquired during the annual peak of winter for the five years from 2017 to 2021 in an area of approximately 300 km2 around Davos, Switzerland. This enables the calculation of outstandingly improved annual snow depth maps. The high spatial resolution of the snow depth maps (0.5 m) in combination with the high-resolution orthophoto (0.25 m) enables the identification of small-scale snow depth features. Additionally, the development of masks for high-vegetated and settled areas in combination with the high accuracy of the unmasked snow depth values (root mean square error of around 0.15 m) represents a significant step forward for reliable snow depth mapping of large alpine regions with photogrammetric methods. Our study focuses on the consistent workflow used for processing the snow depth maps, demonstrates the special characteristics of the snow depth distribution and presents the potential for investigations and applications based on this unique snow depth time-series.

    How to cite: Bührle, L., Marty, M., Eberhard, L., Stoffel, A., and Bühler, Y.: Snow depth mapping over large, high-alpine regions by airplane photogrammetry, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9744, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9744, 2022.

    EGU22-9932 | Presentations | HS6.4

    Fractional snow cover estimation through linear spectral unmixing of Sentinel-2 and Sentinel-3 optical satellite data using local endmembers 

    Lars Keuris, Thomas Nagler, Nico Mölg, and Stefan Scheiblauer

    Precise snow cover estimations are relevant for many fields of research applications, such as for hydrological and meteorological modelling. Furthermore, snow plays an important role in hydropower management and flood prediction. Snow cover monitoring from satellite imagery has received increasing attention over the past decades. Nowadays, improvements in estimation methodologies and better availability of augmented satellite imagery provide an excellent basis for reliable estimations of fractional snow cover.

    In this work we exploit the available spectral information of the Sentinel-2 MSI and Sentinel-3 OLCI for automatic estimation of fractional snow coverage. This is achieved through linear spectral unmixing with local endmembers. Similar implementation of methods that employ spectral unmixing use a reflectance model or a spectral library with pre-selected endmembers. Our approach selects the spectral endmembers from the data itself and applies them depending on the distance from the query point assuming spectral similarities of ground reflectance nearby. Endmembers are found through a pre-classification step based on conservative thresholds in combination with a similarity measure. The linear unmixing problem is solved several times for each query point using different combinations of endmembers detected in the vicinity of the query point; accounting for different illumination conditions and shaded areas. Finally, a careful selection of accurate fractional snow cover estimations is performed. This approach is globally applicable, adjusts to the local environment and illumination conditions and avoids costly endmember modelling or the provision of an external spectral library. The method was tested in different regions in the world using different satellite data including Sentinel-2, Landsat and Sentinel-3 OLCI and were inter-compared with snow information from other sources. In the presentation we will present the method, and examples of fractional snow cover maps. The performance of the method will be shown in comparison with other data and the limitations and capabilities will be discussed.

    How to cite: Keuris, L., Nagler, T., Mölg, N., and Scheiblauer, S.: Fractional snow cover estimation through linear spectral unmixing of Sentinel-2 and Sentinel-3 optical satellite data using local endmembers, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9932, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9932, 2022.

    EGU22-10725 | Presentations | HS6.4 | Highlight

    Global Snow Water Equivalent Observations from Space 

    Ana Barros, Carrie Vuoyvich, Michael Durand, Leung Tsang, Paul Houser, and Hans-Peter Marshall

    Global snow water equivalent (SWE) data are required for understanding the role of snow in the Earth’s water, energy and carbon cycles, and are critical for informing water resource and snow-related hazards. While exciting progress has been made in recent decades, there are currently no global SWE data at the required frequency, resolution and accuracy to address scientific and operational requirements. These data are needed to inform science and application areas and, taken as a whole, are critical to global water and food security. New higher-resolution microwave instruments can provide this information, especially when combined with modeling.  We now have the capability to put these instruments in space to monitor SWE and volume at the required resolution for improved and useful water prediction globally.  This presentation will describe the requirements of a spaceborne SWE mission, review progress in snow remote sensing technology and algorithms, and describe a potential path forward to meet identified snow data needs.

    How to cite: Barros, A., Vuoyvich, C., Durand, M., Tsang, L., Houser, P., and Marshall, H.-P.: Global Snow Water Equivalent Observations from Space, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10725, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10725, 2022.

    EGU22-11519 | Presentations | HS6.4

    Synthesizing Daily Snow Cover Maps Using Satellite Images and Climate Information 

    Fatemeh Zakeri and Gregoire Mariethoz

    Daily snow cover is an essential parameter in hydrology, climate, and environmental studies. Although remote sensing images provide valuable information on snow, they are restricted by clouds, clouds’ shadows, and temporal and spatial coverage. This study synthesizes daily snow cover maps based on climate and near clear sky Sentinel-2 and Landsat images. The motivation of this study is that snow patterns are repeatable between years with similar meteorological characteristics. Accordingly, a distance metric based on climate information is computed, including temperature and precipitation (1km resolution) as well as auxiliary data such as daily MODIS snow cover. This distance quantifies the mismatch between the days when clear sky Landsat or Sentinel-2 data is available, learning days, and days when there is no clear sky satellite data or test days. The proposed methodology is applied on a subset of the Alpine belt called the Western Swiss Alps and on the Jonschwil sub-basin, both located in Switzerland. We have synthesized daily snow cover maps for each of our regions of interest for 20 years since 2000.

    To evaluate synthesized snow cover maps, we use leave-one-out cross-validation, comparison with a random selection process, and a degree-day snow model. The leave-one-out assessment shows a good agreement between the actual Landsat and the synthesized one. The synthesized snow cover maps also show that the proposed method output agrees with physical concepts as the physical features have been used along with satellite data in the proposed model. Considering physical features in synthesizing Landsat images is an innovation that allows us to use the methodology to synthesize images for the pre-satellite period. Moreover, random selection assessment shows that considering a metric based on climate and auxiliary data can synthesize snow cover as repeatable patterns depending on meteorological data.

    How to cite: Zakeri, F. and Mariethoz, G.: Synthesizing Daily Snow Cover Maps Using Satellite Images and Climate Information, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11519, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11519, 2022.

    EGU22-12576 | Presentations | HS6.4 | Highlight

    Climate change-driven seasonal snow cover variations in Central Asia 

    Abror Gafurov, Olga Kalashnikova, Djafar Niyazov, Adkham Mamaraimov, Akmal Gafurov, and Uktam Adkhamov

    Snow is an important hydrological component in Central Asia. The snowmelt contributes to about 50 % of total water formation in the region, depending on geographic conditions. Many hydro-meteorological phenomena such as floods or drought conditions can be triggered by snowmelt amounts in Central Asia. The amount of snow accumulation in the mountains of Tian-Shan and Pamir also defines the availability of water for summer months to be used for agricultural production or re-filling of reservoirs for energy production in the winter period. Thus, it is of high importance to better understand the seasonal variation of snow and if the over the global average climate warming in the region is affecting the processes related to snow accumulation and melt.

    In this study, we analyze 22 years of daily Moderate Resolution Imaging Radiometer (MODIS) snow cover data that was processed using the MODSNOW-Tool, including cloud elimination. Additionally, observed snow depth data from meteorological stations were used to estimate trends related to snow cover change. We used several parameters such as snow cover duration, snow depth, snow cover extent, and snowline elevation to analyze changes.  We conducted this analysis in 18 river basins across the Central Asian domain with each river basin having different geographic conditions and the results show varying tendencies. In many river basins, a clear decrease of snow cover was found to be significant, whereas in some river basins also increase in the snow cover extent in particular months could be identified. We attributed the changes related to snow cover to available historical temperature and precipitation records from meteorological stations to better understand the driving forces. The results of this study indicate seasonal snow cover variations but also potential water shortages in particular months as well as water abundance in months where water demand is not high in Central Asia. 

    How to cite: Gafurov, A., Kalashnikova, O., Niyazov, D., Mamaraimov, A., Gafurov, A., and Adkhamov, U.: Climate change-driven seasonal snow cover variations in Central Asia, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12576, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12576, 2022.

    EGU22-12801 | Presentations | HS6.4

    Quantifying the role of mixed pixels in snow cover distribution in semiarid regions: A study case in Sierra Mountain (Spain) 

    Rafael Pimentel, Javier Aparicio, Pedro Torralbo, Eva Contreras, Fátima Moreno-Pérez, Cristina Aguilar, and María José Polo

    Observations worldwide identify snow cover persistence together with snowfall occurrence as the most affected variables by global warming. In particular, Mediterranean mountain areas are pointed as climate warming hotspots. The characteristic snow-patched distribution shown over these areas, which result in different accumulation-ablation cycles during the cold season, usually makes spatial resolution the limiting factor for its correct representation. Remote sensing is the only feasible data source for distributed quantification of snow in mountain regions on medium to large scales, due among other to the limited access to these areas together with the lack of dense ground monitoring stations for snow variables. Among the numerous remote sensing sources, the Landsat constellation is those that better fit both basic requirements for studying snow over these areas, to cover a long period with observation and to have an high spatial resolution. However, the traditional classification algorithms for snow detection are usually based on normalized indexes that  provide a binary classification as snow and no-snow pixels throughout the study area; this simple classification may result in large error in heterogeneous and transitional areas within the snow-dominated domain. Alternatively, the spectral mixture analysis (SMA) approach provides a fraction of snow cover within each pixel and thus, constitutes a step forward to characterize heterogeneous and patchy snow areas in semiarid regions. 

    This work analysed the role of mixed pixels, defined as pixels made up of different types of surfaces, in snow cover distribution over Mediterranean mountains. Sierra Nevada Mountain Range in southern Spain has been chosen as representative of a Mediterranean mountain area, which is characterized by strong altitudinal gradients with marked differences between the south (directly affected to the sea) and the north faces are found in the area. The fractional snow cover maps, at 30×30 m and 16 days spatial and temporal resolution respectively, derived from SMA of Landsat TM and ETM+ validated using as high resolution terrestrial photography (Pimentel et al., 2017) has been used for mixed pixel analysis. On the one hand, the results show the importance of mixed pixels, which can constitute more than 50% of the total pixels in some areas of the mountainous range and season of the year. On the other hand, the analysis carried out has allowed the identification of areas more prone to allocate this type of pixels, linking that fact to climatic drivers. 

    This work has been funded by project MONADA - "Hydrometeorological trends in mountainous protected areas in Andalusia: examples of co-development of climatic services for strategies of adaptation to climatic change", with the economic collaboration of the European Funding for Rural Development (FEDER) and the Andalusian Ministry of Economic Transformation, Industry, Knowledge and Universities. R+D+i project 2020.

    How to cite: Pimentel, R., Aparicio, J., Torralbo, P., Contreras, E., Moreno-Pérez, F., Aguilar, C., and Polo, M. J.: Quantifying the role of mixed pixels in snow cover distribution in semiarid regions: A study case in Sierra Mountain (Spain), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12801, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12801, 2022.

    EGU22-3564 | Presentations | HS6.5

    Benefits of Sentinel-1 backscatter assimilation to improve land surface model irrigation estimates in Europe 

    Sara Modanesi, Christian Massari, Michel Bechtold, Angelica Tarpanelli, Luca Brocca, Hans Lievens, Wouter Dorigo, Luca Zappa, and Gabriëlle De Lannoy

    Irrigation has been applied by humans for as long as they have been cultivating plants. Nowadays, the amount of water used for agricultural purposes is rising because of an increasing food demand. However, this human influence on the water distribution on land is typically not, or poorly, parameterized in regional and larger-scale Land Surface Models (LSM). Satellite-based microwave observations indirectly observe irrigation, when they sense the entire integrated soil-vegetation system. The optimal integration of fine-scale modeling and satellite observations using data assimilation (DA) is promising to detect irrigation and possibly improve the estimation of irrigation amounts.

    This work was realized in the framework of the European Space Agency (ESA) Irrigation+ project. The main aim of this study was to test potential improvements in irrigation simulation due to the assimilation of 1-km Sentinel-1 backscatter data into a system composed by the Noah-MP LSM, equipped with a sprinkler irrigation scheme, and a backscatter operator represented by a Water Cloud Model (WCM), as part of the NASA Land Information System (LIS).  The calibrated WCM was used as an observation operator in the DA system to map model surface soil moisture and Leaf Area Index (LAI) into backscatter predictions and, conversely, map observation-minus-forecast residuals in backscatter back to updates in soil moisture and LAI through an Ensemble Kalman Filter (EnKF). Two separate DA experiments were realized using backscatter data at VV and VH polarizations. The system was tested  at two irrigated sites, located in the Po Valley (Italy) and in northern Germany.

    Results confirm a stronger link between the backscatter VV with soil moisture and larger updates in the vegetation state variables when using the VH polarization. The backscatter DA introduced both improvements and degradations in soil moisture, evapotranspiration and irrigation estimates. The spatial and temporal scale had a large impact on the outcomes, with more contradicting results for a detailed analysis at the plot scale. Above all, this study sheds light on the limitations resulting from a poorly-parameterized sprinkler irrigation scheme which prevents large improvements in the irrigation simulation due to the ingestion of Sentinel-1 data and points out to future developments needed to improve the system.

    How to cite: Modanesi, S., Massari, C., Bechtold, M., Tarpanelli, A., Brocca, L., Lievens, H., Dorigo, W., Zappa, L., and De Lannoy, G.: Benefits of Sentinel-1 backscatter assimilation to improve land surface model irrigation estimates in Europe, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3564, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3564, 2022.

    Irrigated rice agriculture, if traditionally conducted applying continuous flooding, requires much more irrigation water than non-ponded crops. This is usually a constraint in areas facing water scarcity issues that might directly affect rice production and the competition for water. Climate change might furthermore amplify current difficulties, depending on the hydrological regime, the availability of irrigation infrastructures, rice variety and rice agronomic management practices, among other factors.

    Whereas different water availability conditions determine differences in rice growth and yields, the response of this crop is not well established for the rice producing area of the Lower Mondego region (Portugal), which is identified as an area vulnerable to climate change, in particular with respect to increasing precipitation and temperature variability. In coastal areas’ lowlands, the groundwater table (e.g., depth and quality) can also play an important role, namely under the influence of sea level rise. For this region, in the proximity of the Atlantic Ocean, we report on using remote sensing tools to assess irrigated rice growth, in areas i) served by a full gravity irrigation system, and ii) fed directly from a small, non-regulated, river. The data used in our study include land surface images of rice cultivated areas obtained from satellite Sentinel-2A during several years (including a particularly dry year). Although the remote sensing data available from satellite multispectral imagery present some practical constraints (e.g. cloud cover, resolution), results from this study show that remote sensing tools, including the Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI), are able to differentiate between established rice growth phases, which highlights their usefulness as rice monitoring tools and potential role in assessing the impact of applying different irrigation and agriculture management practices on rice cultivation.

    This work was conducted under the umbrella of the international project MEDWATERICE (www.medwaterice.org) that focuses on improving the sustainable use of water in the Mediterranean rice agro-ecosystem and aims at exploring the opportunity to apply water-saving, alternative, rice irrigation methods.

    How to cite: Gerardo, R. and de Lima, I.: Rice monitoring in Lower Mondego (Portugal) using multi-temporal Sentinel-2 satellite images: comparison between different irrigation conditions, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7942, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7942, 2022.

    EGU22-10127 | Presentations | HS6.5

    Irrigation management though the assimilation of multiple remote sensing data into an energy-water-crop model 

    Chiara Corbari, Ahmad Al Bitar, Drazen Skokovic, josè sobrino, and marco mancini

    The agricultural sector is the biggest and least efficient water user, accounting for around 80% of total water use in South Europe, which will be further impacted by climate change in the incoming years. Precision agriculture tools are then needed to increase water use efficiency.

    Here, the proposed system couples together remotely sensed land surface temperature (LST), leaf area index (LAI) and ground soil moisture data (SM) with a pixel wise crop-water-energy balances model, for improving irrigation management. The SAFY (Simple Algorithm for Yield) crop model has been fully coupled with the energy water balance FEST-EWB model, exchanging in a double direction the LAI evolution in time from SAFY, which is used by FEST-EWB for evapotranspiration computation, while FEST-EWB provides soil moisture (SM) and LST to SAFY model for constraining crop growth.

    A data assimilation framework, based on the Ensemble Kalman filter approach, is implemented to reduce the requirements for parameters calibration, either for soil assimilating satellite LST and for crop growth using LAI. This framework allows overcoming the issues related to crop exposure to shocks due extreme events non-reproducible by the model alone, as well as nutrient lack, crops hybrids or precise amount of irrigation water.

    The FEST-EWB-SAFY model has been applied in two Irrigation Consortia in the North and South of Italy which differ for climate and agricultural practices, using data from Sentinel2, Landsat 7 and 8 satellites. The model has then been validated in specific fields where ground measurements of evapotranspiration, soil moisture and crop yields are available.

    Overall, the results suggested that the under-calibrated model estimates of LST, LAI, SM and yield are enhanced through the assimilation of satellite data, suggesting the potential for improving irrigation management at both field and Irrigation Consortium scales.

    How to cite: Corbari, C., Al Bitar, A., Skokovic, D., sobrino, J., and mancini, M.: Irrigation management though the assimilation of multiple remote sensing data into an energy-water-crop model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10127, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10127, 2022.

    EGU22-11841 | Presentations | HS6.5

    Trends of crop daily water requirements driven by 50-years global hydro-climatic data 

    Stefania Tamea, Matteo Rolle, and Pierluigi Claps

    The impact of climate forcings on the agricultural water demand is a key issue for a globalized food secure world. Most of the withdrawn freshwater is globally consumed by agriculture and assessing how climate variability affect the crop irrigation requirements is essential for effective irrigation policies and large-scale water management. Moreover, given that rainfed agriculture provides 60% of total food production and it is highly dependent on meteorological factors, the assessment of climate-driven changes of crop water requirements and water stress periods is very important to highlight potential impacts on the global food security.

    This study deals with the spatio-temporal changes of crop water requirements over 50 years, considering 26 main agricultural products. A comprehensive model for the assessment of daily crop water requirement has been used, based on a soil water balance and considering both rainfed and irrigated scenarios. The analysis exploits the potential of the ERA5 reanalysis dataset from the Climate Change Service of the Copernicus Programme, providing hydro-climatic variables over a multi-decade period. The study analyses the variability of water requirement induced by climate variability and the consequent periods of water stress and irrigation volumes per unit harvested areas.

    Results show the evolution of water requirement from 1970 to 2019, enabling the analysis of trends in stressed periods over rainfed areas and of changes in irrigation requirements over lands equipped for irrigation. Significant increases of water stress have been found in almost 40% of global rainfed areas, and 62% of irrigated lands require more irrigation comparing the 1970s and 2010s decades. The irrigation requirement has been estimated per crop, pointing out significant increases through the years and comparing the length of dry periods with the precipitation availability during the growing seasons. A global assessment of crop requirement changes can support policies of water management in different areas of the world, considering also the effects of climate change in the densely harvested areas of the world.

    How to cite: Tamea, S., Rolle, M., and Claps, P.: Trends of crop daily water requirements driven by 50-years global hydro-climatic data, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11841, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11841, 2022.

    EGU22-11902 | Presentations | HS6.5

    Monitoring and integrating the expansion of vegetated areas with the rate of groundwater use in arid regions 

    Mona Morsy, Silas Michaelides, Thomas Scholten, and Peter Dietrich

    Frequent water table measurements are crucial for sustainable groundwater management in arid regions. These locations have developed a problem with excessive withdrawal throughout time. However, continuous readings are not available for the majority of these locations. Therefore, an approximate estimate of the rate of increase/decrease in water consumption over time may serve as a temporary substitute for the missing database. The goal is achieved by tracking the increase/decrease in vegetated areas that will generally correlate with changes in the rate of water use. The technique is based on two remote sensing data sets: Landsat7&8 from 2001 to 2021 and Sentinel2A from 2015 to 2021, as well as five vegetation indices: Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI), Renormalized Difference Vegetation Index (RDVI), Soil Adjusted Vegetation Index (SAVI), Enhanced Vegetation Index (EVI), and Transformed Vegetation Index (TVI). The datasets chosen provided the best performance for small-scale land farms at the research location. (Landsat7) data with a resolution of 30m revealed a substantial increase in land farms from 2.9km2 in 2001 to 23.3km2 in 2021. The use of the five indices with (Sentinel2A) allowed the classification of vegetated regions as heavy, moderate, or light, as well as the tracking of each class's increase from 2015 through 2021. Additionally, preliminary scenarios were built to measure the pace of growth in water use at the research site by evaluating the rise in vegetated areas and obtaining general information about crop types from farmers. Finally, the NDVI index was modified to better suit the arid areas. The new index is named Arid Vegetation Index or (AVI).

    How to cite: Morsy, M., Michaelides, S., Scholten, T., and Dietrich, P.: Monitoring and integrating the expansion of vegetated areas with the rate of groundwater use in arid regions, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11902, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11902, 2022.

    EGU22-12078 | Presentations | HS6.5

    Importance of land-cover data-set spatio-temporal resolution on water budget modeling in highly irrigated areas, Telangana, India 

    Abhilash Kumar Paswan, Sylvain Ferrant, Adrien Selles, Virendra Mani Tiwari, and Shakeel Ahmed

    Falling water tables in several parts of India, especially in the southern part, experiencing semi-arid climatic conditions with hard rock aquifer systems, possess a threat to food, water and economic security to millions of citizens. Understanding of the water budget in such an area is paramount to take necessary steps towards planning of water usage and its management. Land use information at 1km is recognized as sufficient in hydrological modeling. But what is the best resolution of land use forcing variables for agro-hydrological modeling to simulate the water budget by taking agricultural water withdrawal into account. This study focuses on the use of medium (500m) and high resolution (10m) land cover maps derived from satellite products to map the seasonal rice inundated area extent in the Telangana state to estimate the Irrigation Water Demand (IWD) and withdrawal. We employed Soil and Water Assessment Tool (SWAT), a process based ecohydrological river basin or watershed model, to assess how resolution of land use maps may affect the water budget representation of Telangana. The model is calibrated and validated for a period from 2015 to 2020 (6 years) using monthly river runoff data, groundwater and terrestrial water fluctuation derived from respectively governmental piezometric observations (TSGWD) and GRACE. An uncertainty analysis was performed using the Sequential Uncertainty Fitting (SUFI-2) algorithm. Preliminary results suggest that though trends in runoff are influenced by climate drivers, as southwest monsoon contributes appx. 80% of annual rainfall. However, the farmers seasonal land cover adaptation to surface and groundwater availability have a strong impact on water balance over the study area. Precise land cover information of such temporal variations based on appropriate spatial resolution satellite observations contributes to accurate estimate of IWD especially in groundwater fed areas where rice areas are spread in small aggregates. This study also highlights the adaptation and importance of temporal and spatial resolution of datasets in strategic planning and water management practices in water stressed regions. 

    How to cite: Paswan, A. K., Ferrant, S., Selles, A., Tiwari, V. M., and Ahmed, S.: Importance of land-cover data-set spatio-temporal resolution on water budget modeling in highly irrigated areas, Telangana, India, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12078, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12078, 2022.

    EGU22-12307 | Presentations | HS6.5

    A novel methodology for mapping irrigation types from very high resolution remotely sensed data 

    Giovanni Paolini, Maria jose Escorihuela, Joaquim Bellvert, Olivier Merlin, josep Maria Villar, and Ivan Cester

    This research aims at introducing a new methodology to create maps of irrigation types at very high resolution, with yearly updates. While different studies were already performed on simply mapping irrigated areas, there is still no research on classifying irrigation types based on remotely sensed data. This information has a critical scientific value since detailed information on irrigation greatly improves the understanding of human activities on the water cycle. In particular, precise knowledge of different irrigation types is needed in order to correctly model the anthropogenic impact in various land surface models (Ozdogan et al., 2010; Evans and Zaitchik, 2008). Additionally, these maps are also useful for administrative purposes, to estimate the percentage of different irrigation types, monitor changes in irrigation practices and consequently encourage more sustainable use of the freshwater resources. In this research, we produce maps of irrigation types combining state-of-the-art supervised AI classification algorithms for time series classification together with a selection of hydrological variables. In order to train and test the AI models, a field campaign to collect ground truth data was performed in November 2020 around the intensely cultivated region of Catalunya, Spain. From this campaign, important information about crop types and irrigation types (sprinkler, flood, drip/subsurface and non-irrigated) were retrieved for a large number of fields, ensuring to collect a representative sample of the different cultivation and irrigation types employed in the area. Three different models were tested using as inputs a large variety of hydrological variables both alone and combined in multivariate models. Two machine learning models, Time-Series Forest and Rocket, and one Deep Neural Network model, ResNET, were selected for this classification task. The classification was performed using time-series from three different years in order to train the models with a more general and robust dataset, independent from specific meteorological conditions of a single year. The main finding of the research was that Soil Moisture (SM) and Actual Evapotranspiration (ETa) at very high spatial resolution (20 m) consistently showed the highest accuracy, when combined together, with respect to the other variables considered, regardless of the AI model used. Additionally, ResNET showed consistently better performance than the other two AI models over all the metrics used for the comparison (accuracy, precision, recall and kappa). The final classification accuracy retrieved from ResNET using SM and ETa as inputs was 86.59 +/- 2.79, obtained from 10 different runs of the model trained each time with different ground truth data subsamples. As a result of these findings, yearly maps of irrigation types can be created for large areas at field level, delivering detailed information on the status and evolution of irrigation practices.  

    REFERENCE:

    Ozdogan, M.; Rodell, M.; Beaudoing, H.K.; Toll, D.L. Simulating the effects of irrigation over the United States in a land surface model based on satellite-derived agricultural data. J. Hydrometeorol 2010, 11, 171–184.

    Evans, J.P.; Zaitchik, B.F. Modeling the large-scale water balance impact of different irrigation systems. Water Res. 2008, 44, W08448.

    How to cite: Paolini, G., Escorihuela, M. J., Bellvert, J., Merlin, O., Villar, J. M., and Cester, I.: A novel methodology for mapping irrigation types from very high resolution remotely sensed data, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12307, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12307, 2022.

    EGU22-13316 | Presentations | HS6.5

    The economic value of ensemble numerical weather forecasts combined with remote sensing data and hydrological modeling for irrigation scheduling: an application to Southern Italy 

    Anna Pelosi, Giovanni Battista Chirico, Salvatore Falanga Bolognesi, Carlo De Michele, and Guido D'Urso

    The use of numerical weather prediction (NWP) outputs in hydrological modeling combined with remote sensing data for forecasting irrigation water demand in the short-medium term, has becoming one of the key actions adopted in precision farming for decreasing water and energy consumptions in the long-term perspective of sustainability.

    In the last decades, ensemble prediction systems (EPS) have been developed to support operational decision-making processes in many environmental fields. Unlike traditional deterministic forecasts where the numerical weather prediction model is run only once, in EPS the NWP model is run several times from very slightly different initial conditions and perturbed model parameters, to produce an ensemble of forecasts that are used to account for uncertainty in initial atmospheric conditions and NWP model errors. Moreover, in recent years, limited area ensemble prediction systems (LEPS) have been developed as dynamic regional downscaling of global ensemble prediction systems, opening new opportunities for the application of weather forecasts in agriculture and water resource management. Indeed, high resolution probabilistic forecasting may allow water irrigation managers to set-up agrometeorological advisory services based on a more reliable risk analysis.

    This study exploits the potential economic benefit (i.e., economic value) related to the use of an ensemble numerical weather prediction model, such as COSMO-LEPS (20 members, 7 km of spatial horizontal resolution) for irrigation scheduling at farm scale in Southern Italy, by combining its outputs with high resolution satellite images in the visible and near infrared wavelengths for crop parameter estimations. An adaptive ensemble Kalman filter is employed for bias correcting weather forecasts by assimilating ground based meteorological variables. Then, a bucket model for soil-vegetation-atmosphere modeling is implemented for providing spatial and temporal estimates of crop water requirements and irrigation schedules along with their predictive uncertainty.

    How to cite: Pelosi, A., Battista Chirico, G., Falanga Bolognesi, S., De Michele, C., and D'Urso, G.: The economic value of ensemble numerical weather forecasts combined with remote sensing data and hydrological modeling for irrigation scheduling: an application to Southern Italy, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13316, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13316, 2022.

    Evapotranspiration (ET) is a major component of the hydrologic cycle and plays a fundamental role in water and land management. However, previous studies have shown that estimating ET is quite challenging, particularly at fine temporal and spatial scales. Dense time series of harmonized Landsat 8 and Sentinel-2 imagery (HLS) combined with ECOsystem Spaceborne Thermal Radiometer Experiment on Space Station (ECOSTRESS) data provide a unique opportunity to enhance monitoring, mapping, and characterizing ET at unprecedented spatial and temporal resolutions. In this study, we develop and evaluate an improved ET estimation method based on Priestley-Taylor Jet Propulsion Laboratory algorithm (PT-JPL) with HLS optical reflectance imagery and ECOSTRESS land surface temperature (LST) and surface emissivity, in addition to MODIS surface albedo and ERA5-Land climate reanalysis data. The new approach creates denser times series of ET from HLS imagery, which can also be used to map ET at 30 m spatial resolution. The new ET estimates are evaluated against ground-based observations from the AmeriFlux network and compared with the performance of the original ECOSTRESS PT-JPL ET estimates across different ecosystems and landcover settings over the continental United States. We present results for evaluating ET estimates, the remote sensing and climate reanalysis inputs, and illustrating the sensitivity and uncertainty of the improved ET method and its performance related to land cover and terrestrial ecosystem properties.

    How to cite: Rashid, T. and Tian, D.: Improving ECOSTRESS-based Evapotranspiration Estimates Using Harmonized Landsat Sentinel-2 Imagery, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-685, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-685, 2022.

    EGU22-1380 | Presentations | HS6.6

    Consumptive Water Use for the Riparian Areas of the Little Colorado River within Navajo Nation 

    Pamela Nagler, Armando Barreto-Muñoz, Ibrahima Sall, and Kamel Didan

    Accurate estimates of natural plant area water use or evapotranspiration (ET, mm/day) are important to quantify so that in-stream use can be partitioned for human and natural environments. The natural grasses, shrubs and trees that grow alongside rivers and streams are collectively called riparian vegetation and their leaves transpire water that is considered a loss to the ecosystem. Bare soil also loses water through evaporation. In the landscape, we quantify both losses as one variable, actual evapotranspiration (ETa). ETa is the most difficult component of the water cycle to measure. Furthermore, estimates of ETa in uncultivated lands are a fraction of the estimates studied compared with cropped, agricultural lands. Riparian areas of the Little Colorado River are of critical importance to the Navajo Nation. Select riparian reaches were delineated using digitized shrubs and trees so that we could track plant health and its evapotranspiration (ET) with Landsat for the recent seven years (2014-2020). We acquired six Landsat scenes, processed and filtered the data and computed the two-band Enhanced Vegetation Index (EVI2) as a proxy for vegetation at a 16-day interval. We then computed daily potential ET (ETo, mmd-1) using Blaney-Criddle with input temperature data from two sources, Daymet (1 km) and PRISM (4 km) data. ETo from Blaney-Criddle was then averaged over 16-days using the 8-days before- and after- the Landsat overpass date. The riparian corridor’s high-definition digitized shrubs and trees were aggregated using a 10 m buffer in ArcGIS and then rasterized to match the Landsat 30 m grid pixels. Two raster masks were created; the first used a 50% threshold majority option to include/exclude the grid pixels resulting in a ‘conservative’ estimate of the riparian area, and the second considered all pixels that intersected the vegetation buffered outline, resulting in the ‘best-approximation’ estimate of the riparian acreage. The best-approximation raster-area for the riparian corridor was 25,615 ha (63,296 acres) and the conservative raster-area estimate was 19,362 ha (47,846 acres), whereas the digitized area included only a fraction of the total vegetative area, was only 4,974 ha (12,291 acres). We utilized ETo to estimate actual ET (ETa) using EVI2 (mmd-1). Including seven years, 2014 through 2020, the average annual ETa (mmyr-1) increased from 423.9 to 489.2 mmyr-1 or 65.3 mmyr-1 (15%) over the recent seven years, 2014-2020. Precipitation decreased by 73.1 mmyr-1 (38%) from 190.8 mmyr-1 (2014) to 117.7 mmyr-1 (2020). The water deficit (WD), like ETa, shows an increasing trend from 235.6 mmyr-1 (2014) to 373.5 mmyr-1 (2020); this is an increase in WD of 137.9 mmyr-1 (59%). We produced three estimates of consumptive water use (CU) based on riparian area using a best-approximation and conservative-estimate from the rasterized area, and vector area. Our CU estimates for the riparian corridor range from 31,648 (conservative) to 36,983 (best; Daymet) to 41,585 (PRISM) acre-feet. These findings refine predictions in the range between 25,387 and 46,397 acre-feet using only literature for similar areas. Better estimates of water use are valuable to the Navajo Nation in the adjudication of water rights.

    How to cite: Nagler, P., Barreto-Muñoz, A., Sall, I., and Didan, K.: Consumptive Water Use for the Riparian Areas of the Little Colorado River within Navajo Nation, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1380, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1380, 2022.

    EGU22-3223 | Presentations | HS6.6 | Highlight

    Emerging technology for daily, field-scale, global evapotranspiration from space 

    Joshua Fisher and the Hydrosat Team

    Science and applications communities have made clear the needs and requirements for daily, field-scale ET. However, we do not have the high spatiotemporal TIR data to meet these requirements. Exciting new technology is now emerging to finally achieve this long-standing goal. With an upcoming launch en route to 16+ smallsat satellites, the Hydrosat constellation will provide field-scale, global TIR and VNIR measurements for ET every day, multiple times per day. An Early Adopters product is available now with 20 m daily TIR data globally from the fusion of Landsat, ECOSTRESS, MODIS, VIIRS, and Sentinel-2. Hydrosat data will be a game-changer and will significantly advance our monitoring and management capabilities for ecosystems, agriculture, and other applications.

    How to cite: Fisher, J. and the Hydrosat Team: Emerging technology for daily, field-scale, global evapotranspiration from space, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3223, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3223, 2022.

    EGU22-3224 | Presentations | HS6.6

    How Changes in Harvested Area Impacts the Actual Evapotranspiration of Croplands Using Optical Remote Sensing 

    Neda Abbasi, Hamideh Nouri, Pamela Nagler, Sattar Chavoshi Borujeni, Armando Barreto-Muñoz, Christian Opp, Kamel Didan, and Stefan Siebert

    Associated with drought, the increased agricultural water consumption in arid and semi-arid regions has caused water competition among water users and worsened water scarcity and food security. Hence, there is an imminent need for accurate and reliable estimation of actual evapotranspiration (ETa) for large scales, as a key component of the water cycle due to its critical role in determining crop water requirement. This work aims to investigate the impact of changes in harvested area (HA) over time on ETa estimates using remote sensing (RS) in the Zayandehrud River Basin, Iran, where croplands are highly dependent on irrigation and strongly influenced by aridity and recurring drought events. RS provides a dependable basis for ETa quantification across large areas, particularly regions where lack of ground data hampers ETa estimation. The efficient RS data handling is of importance. In this regard, Google Earth Engine (GEE), a cloud-based open-access platform for accessing and analysing the RS data, was used to derive ETa and HA. The Vegetation Index-based ETa (ET-VI) approach is one of the RS-based methods which combines a vegetation index as a proxy of crop factor and reference ET (ET0) to estimate ETa. We calculated ET-VI as a tool to monitor agricultural water consumption and drought over croplands (2000-2019). Since reducing crop area is a common strategy employed by farmers against drought, HA tends to show considerable inter-annual variability, particularly in semi-arid regions, where drought is a major factor affecting rainfed and irrigated agriculture. Shrinkage of HA during water-stressed periods often leads to an ETa underestimation when HA changes are ignored in ETa estimation (i.e., HA is assumed static for ETa calculation). To assess the effect of cropping patterns’ inter-annual change on the annual ETa, annual maximum Normalized Difference Vegetation Index layers were derived. Analyses of HA and ET-VI showed that inter-annual variability in cropland extent affects ETa considerably, therefore using static cropland extent is not recommended in drought studies. ETa remained less variable while cropped areas changed in response to dry years. This means that drought has forced farmers to use the limited available water on a smaller area to cope with drought and safeguard reliable crop production. The average difference between ET-VI estimated based on static and dynamic HA was 221.7 mm per annum in our study area. Our findings highlight the necessity of incorporating both cropped areas and ETa rates in water management and drought monitoring of croplands. Our analysis offers insights into the capability and suitability of RS-based ETa as an efficient and quick tool for understanding spatio-temporal variability of ETa across croplands and monitoring water resources. Future research should evaluate the potential of high-resolution sensors with frequent return in the ETa derivation to monitor drought, vegetation health, and water consumption at different time scales, and whether they can improve the accuracy of drought mapping and monitoring.

    How to cite: Abbasi, N., Nouri, H., Nagler, P., Chavoshi Borujeni, S., Barreto-Muñoz, A., Opp, C., Didan, K., and Siebert, S.: How Changes in Harvested Area Impacts the Actual Evapotranspiration of Croplands Using Optical Remote Sensing, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3224, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3224, 2022.

    EGU22-4761 | Presentations | HS6.6

    A low-cost, open-path water vapor analyzer for eddy covariance measurement of evapotranspiration 

    Yin Wang, Zhimei Liu, Ting-Jung Lin, Xiaojie Zhen, Xiaohua Zhang, Kai Wang, and Xunhua Zheng

    Among various measurement techniques, eddy covariance (EC) is the most direct one for measuring evapotranspiration (ET) fluxes at field to ecosystem scales (Aubinet et al., 2000). In the past two decades, EC flux towers around the world, particularly those within the FLUXNET, have served as a worldwide network of calibration and validation for surface-atmosphere energy and ET flux data obtained from remote sensing-based models or hydrological process-based models (Wang and Dickinson, 2012). 

    One of the major challenges in model-data benchmarking is the spatial mismatch issue. For example, the grid cell size of around 106 – 108 m2 in typical Earth system regional modeling cases is often several orders of magnitude larger than the EC flux footprints of around 103–107 m2. Since most flux tower sites are located in more-or-less heterogeneous landscapes, multiple measurement units for spatially adequate sampling and representative fluxes are of interest for capturing the fine-scale spatial variation. However, the deployment of higher density sampling points was mainly limited by the costs of conventional analyzers. Therefore, there is increasing demand in the development of low-cost water vapor analyzers specifically for more spatial representative terrestrial ET flux footprints measurements based on EC methods.

    In recent years, laser-based gas spectrometers have shown good reliability and effectiveness in the high-frequency and high-sensitivity measurement of various atmospheric trace gases. In this work, we have developed an open-path analyzer (HT1800, HealthyPhoton Co., Ltd.) for fast and sensitive measurements of atmospheric water vapor density. The analyzer employs a low-power vertical cavity surface emitting laser (VCSEL) and a near-infrared Indium Galinide Arsenide (InGaAs) photodetector. An open-path configuration with 0.5 m effective optical path length is used for selective and sensitive detection of the single spectral transition of H2O at 1392 nm, which has been extensively studied in the field of spectroscopic analysis. Using this spectral line to realize the single-component measurement of water vapor density can avoid the complex cross-calibration process due to the H2O-CO2 spectral interference as happened in traditional nondispersive infrared (NDIR) analyzers. On the other hand, the semiconductor nature of lasers and detectors can borrow the mature optical communication industry fabrication process, so that the cost of the core optoelectronic devices is expected to be reduced in mass production.

    The analyzer has a precision (1σ noise level) of 15 μmol mol−1 (ppmv) at a sampling frequency of 10 Hz. Due to its open-path configuration, there is no delay or high-frequency damping due to surface adsorption. The analyzer head has a weight of ~2.8 kg and dimensions of 46 cm (length) and 9.5 cm (diameter). It can be powered by solar cells, with a total power consumption of as low as 10 W under normal operations. With good performance in terms of response time and precision, this instrument is an ideal tool for ET flux measurements based on the EC technique. An EC flux tower was built based on the open-path analyzer, which also included an integrated CO2 and H2O open-path gas analyzer and 3-D sonic anemometer (IRGASON, Campbell Scientific) for comparison of ET flux measurement.

    How to cite: Wang, Y., Liu, Z., Lin, T.-J., Zhen, X., Zhang, X., Wang, K., and Zheng, X.: A low-cost, open-path water vapor analyzer for eddy covariance measurement of evapotranspiration, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4761, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4761, 2022.

    EGU22-6517 | Presentations | HS6.6

    Crop water productivity studies of leading world crops in California utilizing advanced multispectral remote sensing and modeling on the Google Earth Engine (GEE) cloud 

    Daniel Foley, Prasad Thenkabail, Adam Oliphant, Itiya Aneece, and Pardhasaradhi Teluguntla

    As the global population expands in the 21st century, demand for food and water are increasing whereas supply of arable land and accessible fresh water are decreasing. A way to mitigate this looming problem is to increase agricultural Crop Water Productivity (CWP) by improving how much yield (e.g., grain, biomass) is produced per unit of water. To produce more crop with less water (more crop per drop) over large scales, a better understanding of measuring, modeling, and mapping CWP of major world crops utilizing multi-sensor remote sensing, meteorological data, crop yield statistics, and cloud based machine learning is needed.  This study aims to establish a novel methodology to measure evapotranspiration and CWP of select crops at 30m resolution. To accomplish this, a benchmark study area within the San Joaquin section of the Central Valley of California, USA was chosen to represent a diverse agricultural growing region. Within this area, leading and high-water consuming world crops were selected and mapped with respective growing seasons determined by NDVI analysis. Actual evapotranspiration (Eta) as a proxy for water use was determined with new methods to map Evaporative Fraction (Etf) and Reference Evapotranspiration (Eto) per crop type. Using the equation Eta = Eto x Etf, a novel approach for hot and cold pixel selection in image analysis was developed to determine Etf utilizing Landsat thermal bands in conjunction with Google Earth Engine (GEE).

    This analysis determined CWP for nine major world crops (almonds, cotton, wheat, pistachios, grapes, barley, rice, corn, and walnuts) specific to individual crop growing seasons. This study also provides the quantum of water that can be saved if CWP is raised by 10, 20, and 30% relative to existing water use, thus establishing a pathway to create potential water banks from the saved water. Although this study focused on California, the application of methods used has potential to expand globally. This methodology provides insight to help ensure water security and potentially implement better water management strategies in the 21st century.

    How to cite: Foley, D., Thenkabail, P., Oliphant, A., Aneece, I., and Teluguntla, P.: Crop water productivity studies of leading world crops in California utilizing advanced multispectral remote sensing and modeling on the Google Earth Engine (GEE) cloud, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6517, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6517, 2022.

    EGU22-8129 | Presentations | HS6.6

    Using multispectral and thermal UAV data to infer the influence of contrasting urban green space on evapotranspiration and heat fluxes 

    Philipp Jordan, Birgit Kleinschmit, Alby Duarte Rocha, Tobias Graenzig, and Stenka Vulova

    As global urbanization has become more dominant in recent years so have the negative consequences of dense, artificial, urban environments on their inhabitants. The urban heat island is one such phenomena, describing an increase of air temperature in the inner city in comparison to the periphery, with negative effects for human health. Urban green spaces are crucial to mitigating this heat stress due to their higher levels of evapotranspiration (ET) and shading. To maximize cooling potential, the individual contribution of typically heterogenous urban green space to ET and heat fluxes needs to be better understood. Higher ET rates of urban vegetation need to be balanced against on-site water availability to plan the most efficient green spaces. Moreover, trees and shrubs possess the additional benefit of shading the surface below.
    Traditional remote sensing methods have focused on the use of satellite data with multi-meter spatial resolution as a cost-effective way to observe and analyze the large spatial extent of cities. However, the individual vegetation compositions of urban green spaces cannot be resolved through these systems, making it hard to evaluate their superimposed spectral signal. Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs) record data with very high spatial resolution and also allow multiple flights per day to cover the temporal and spatial urban green space heterogeneity.
    Estimation of vegetation indices, land surface temperature (LST) or ET can reveal the high spatial heterogeneity of urban vegetation patches and help to better understand the spatial and temporal patterns of ET and urban cooling at a plot scale.
    In our study, we assessed multiple remote sensing-based ET modelling techniques for thermal and multispectral UAV remote sensing data and validated them against in-situ measurements. Data has been recorded at a monthly interval from April to October at an urban research garden in Berlin, Germany consisting of representative urban vegetation types. An inference method was tested with different vegetation indices to estimate ET for three different green space classes (trees, shrubs, grass). In situ measurements for sap flow, soil moisture, leaf area index and meteorological conditions were used to compare and validate the UAV-based ET, LST, and greenness estimates.
    Results showed a significant difference for ET and surface cooling between green space classes throughout the year, with trees and shrubs showing consistently lower temperatures then grassland. The influence of shadow on cooling potential (ET and LST) also became apparent.
    The findings of our study provide further insights into the influence of different urban green spaces on ET and cooling potential and are valuable for upscaling approaches to the city scale. This knowledge can further support valuable decision-making for planning and managing urban green spaces to mitigate heat risks and optimize urban water supply.

    How to cite: Jordan, P., Kleinschmit, B., Duarte Rocha, A., Graenzig, T., and Vulova, S.: Using multispectral and thermal UAV data to infer the influence of contrasting urban green space on evapotranspiration and heat fluxes, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8129, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8129, 2022.

    EGU22-9019 | Presentations | HS6.6

    An application of evapotranspiration partitioning for monitoring drought from Sentinel-2 data 

    My Nguyen, Hyunho Jeon, Wanyub Kim, and Minha Choi

    Drought is one of the globally extreme events and is physically defined as an extended imbalance between moisture supply and demand, which might severely affect crop growth and water preservation. More specifically, agricultural and meteorological droughts are manifest as the deficits in actual evapotranspiration (ET) and a surplus in atmospheric evaporative demand ET0 (sometimes referred to as potential ET). Therefore, the accurate estimations and reliable information regarding to ET might enhance the drought monitoring and provide better agricultural management policies. However, ET estimations and its components remain many challenges. For example, as three ET contributors are soil evaporation (ETsoil), plant transpiration (ETveg), and vegetation interception evaporation (ETic), current ET models tend to ignore the ETic and consider it as residual of two others. This leads to the uncertainties and incomprehensive reflection of ET. Additionally, ET models-based flux measurement might produce good accurate results, but they have limitations of spatial coverage. With the rapid development of remote sensing platforms, the models-based remote sensing are able to cover a large and regional scale, but they remain higher uncertainties due to the low spatial resolution, complexities in processing, requirements of many input data. Currently, the optical Sentinel-2 is a newly launched product with the Multi Spectral Instruments that might provide 10, 20, and 60-m spatial resolution, which potentially supports to design and improve ET models with superior performance. To overcome these mentioned disadvantages of ET models, the main objective of this study are to propose a simple and objective method using only optical Sentinel-2 dataset to improve the accuracy of ET estimation; and to project the enhanced ET partitioning as feasible method for further monitoring the agricultural drought. This study might bridge the gap in knowledge and applicability of ET in monitoring the hydrological disasters under severe climate change context.

    How to cite: Nguyen, M., Jeon, H., Kim, W., and Choi, M.: An application of evapotranspiration partitioning for monitoring drought from Sentinel-2 data, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9019, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9019, 2022.

    EGU22-10572 | Presentations | HS6.6

    Hyper-resolution modeling of crop evaporation in a semi-arid region using GLEAM and METRIC 

    Mojtaba Naghdyzadegan Jahromi, Shahrokh Zand-Parsa, Hamideh Nouri, Akash Koppa, Dominik Rains, and Diego G. Miralles

    Water scarcity is a major challenge for effective agricultural water management in semi-arid regions. The lack of water resources often requires irrigation (e.g., surface and sprinkler irrigation), providing crops with sufficient soil moisture to maintain photosynthesis and transpiration. To improve crop yields and simultaneously minimise water usage, accurate monitoring of crop evaporation, the primary indicator of plant water consumption, is essential. Given the heterogeneity inherent to semi-arid croplands, hyper-resolution images can enhance the quality and accuracy of monitoring(<30m). Such monitoring systems necessitate the development of remote sensing-based models capable of resolving processes at hyper-resolution and providing spatio-temporally consistent estimates of evaporation.
    In this study, we estimate daily crop evaporation of wheat in the experimental site of the Agriculture College of Shiraz University (Shiraz, Iran) over four years (2016–2020). As a first step, we drive the Global Land Evaporation Amsterdam Model (GLEAM) with Landsat 8 data to generate evaporation at hyper-resolution (30 m). The GLEAM model, originally designed to estimate evaporation at ecosystem-to-global scales, is adapted to consider both surface and sprinkler irrigation in water balance calculation, a common feature in irrigated agriculture. The additional water through surface irrigation is introduced into the system via the soil water balance module, whereas the sprinkler irrigation is introduced as additional precipitation into the interception module. In a second step, we execute an energy balance model, the Mapping EvapoTranspiration at high Resolution with Internalized Calibration (METRIC), using Landsat 8 data. When appropriate extreme pixels (hot and cold pixels) are specified, METRIC can calculate advection, and also METRIC performance is accurate under heterogeneous land use. The results of these two distinct approaches are intercompared and validated against in situ data.

    How to cite: Naghdyzadegan Jahromi, M., Zand-Parsa, S., Nouri, H., Koppa, A., Rains, D., and G. Miralles, D.: Hyper-resolution modeling of crop evaporation in a semi-arid region using GLEAM and METRIC, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10572, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10572, 2022.

    EGU22-10751 | Presentations | HS6.6

    Diurnal and seasonal variation in ET at canopy scales using a novel UAV-based approach 

    Bryn Morgan and Kelly Caylor

    Unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) constitute a new frontier in remote sensing of ET that bridges the gap between in situmeasurements and remotely sensed observations of plant water use. While a single satellite pixel often comprises a mixture of plant types and bare soil, UAV imagery can resolve fine- (m- to cm-) scale differences in surface temperature without thermal unmixing. Furthermore, they can be used to observe diurnal patterns of plant water use and photosynthesis, providing critical insights into the timing and severity of plant water stress. We highlight a novel approach for estimating ET at leaf- to canopy-scales using thermal infrared (TIR) imagery, structural data, and a suite of environmental sensors mounted on a UAV platform. ET is calculated solely from these UAV-acquired data using a combined atmospheric profile and surface energy balance algorithm. Centimeter-scale leaf position and orientation information derived from Structure-from-Motion (SfM) are integrated with the functional data to constrain available energy, allowing for multi-scale estimation of plant water use within and across canopies.

    We present UAV-derived ET across diurnal and seasonal time scales for two landscapes, a native California grassland and a riparian oak woodland. Grassland flights were conducted at 90-minute intervals spanning early morning to late afternoon during the 2021 and 2022 growing seasons. Results show good agreement (<20%) with measured ET fluxes from a collocated eddy covariance tower throughout the growing season. Riparian oak canopies were observed monthly and diurnally over the summer of 2021. Ground measurements of surface temperature, stomatal conductance, and soil moisture were collected during each flight. Water-stressed tress at the driest site showed peak ET at midday, decreasing into afternoon, reflecting down-regulation of photosynthesis to preserve hydraulic function. Relative canopy water use and stress across a range of tree sizes will also be discussed using measurements of stem and canopy area and ET for individual tree crowns extracted from the UAV imagery. By collecting comprehensive meteorological data from sensors on the UAV itself, our approach eliminates the need for extensive field data collection and enables characterization of highly spatially and temporally resolved fluxes within and across complex landscapes. This work opens up new avenues to investigate how ecologically important species—and even individual trees—respond to drought and the impacts of these responses on water use, water stress, and the ecological health of critical habitats like riparian forests.

    How to cite: Morgan, B. and Caylor, K.: Diurnal and seasonal variation in ET at canopy scales using a novel UAV-based approach, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10751, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10751, 2022.

    EGU22-12163 | Presentations | HS6.6

    A new methodology for Standard Evapotranspiration classification over mesoscale regions: Application and evaluation of SOM over remotely sensed data 

    Maria Solis-Aulestia, Israel Pineda, Elisa Piispa, and Scott Williams

    Standard Evapotranspiration (ETo) is an indicator of water losses given by evaporation and plant transpiration. Its quantification is particularly important for irrigation purposes, however in-situ data is not always accessible. This research aims to develop a methodology for Eto ‘weather’ classification through clustering Eto zones over Ecuador using remotely sensed data and an unsupervised learning algorithm. Thus, we obtained climatological variables from the Weather Research and Forecasting model  corresponding to years 2017, 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021. Following, we pre-processed the raw variables into eight parameters for Eto estimation, as in the Penman-Monteith equation, providing the model input variables for each year of study. Hence, we implemented a Self-Organizing Map (SOM) Artificial Neural Network over each dataset to obtain maps representing Eto clustered classes. Moreover, we tested the methodology's repeatability by applying SOM ten different times over each dataset and by applying the modified Cramers’ V-index to quantify the differences between map comparisons. Accordingly, we selected the SOM parameters that produced a Cramer’s V-index > 0.9  and differences between clustered maps < 0.0001. The outcomes of this research contribute to the classification of Eto ‘weather’ in mesoscale regions with future prospects to Eto ‘climate’ classification over larger temporal and spatial resolutions.

    How to cite: Solis-Aulestia, M., Pineda, I., Piispa, E., and Williams, S.: A new methodology for Standard Evapotranspiration classification over mesoscale regions: Application and evaluation of SOM over remotely sensed data, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12163, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12163, 2022.

    EGU22-13187 | Presentations | HS6.6 | Highlight

    The impact of drought on urban green space 

    Sattar Chavoshi Borujeni, Hamideh Nouri, Pamela Nagler, Neda Abassi, Biswajeet Pradhan, and Alfredo Huete

    The role of water in shaping and developing cities has been known and referred to in numerous studies in the last two decades. Urban water management encounters compelling features, including rapid urban expansion and consequent demographic change, climate change, and environmental limitations. Urban green spaces bridge the relationship between humans and nature. As the major feature of green infrastructure, urban green space (UGS) has a crucial role in cities' human health and quality of life. UGS makes cities more habitable and promotes psychological and physical health by filtering air, enhancing water quality, reducing traffic noise, and adjusting wind speed, among other benefits. One of the most important features of urban greenery is its contribution to reducing urban heat islands and cooling the city. In order to attain a water-resilient city, we need to overcome challenges associated with water scarcity, such as drought events. While the impact of drought on forestry, agriculture, and riparian corridors has already been studied, this study is one of the first to assess the effect of drought on the UGS. The main objective of this study is to find a sustainable approach toward a green, livable city under climate change by optimizing the water footprint of UGS. As the third most liveable city in the world in 2021, Adelaide city was selected as the case study. The changes in greenness and water requirement of UGS in Greater Adelaide were studied to detect the impact of drought from 2000 to 2020. The optical remote sensing techniques were employed using Landsat, MODIS, and Sentinel images. The study area's greenness and ETa time series were simulated on the Google Earth Engine platform. Preliminary results show that the water footprint of Adelaide's urban green space is the highest in December with the highest rate of heat-wave and the lowest in June.

    How to cite: Chavoshi Borujeni, S., Nouri, H., Nagler, P., Abassi, N., Pradhan, B., and Huete, A.: The impact of drought on urban green space, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13187, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13187, 2022.

    EGU22-13191 | Presentations | HS6.6

    Improving satellite-based evaporation estimates by incorporating plant access to groundwater 

    Petra Hulsman, Akash Koppa, Jaap Schellekens, and Diego G. Miralles

    Evaporation is one of the major fluxes in the hydrological cycle, yet there are still unresolved issues in its estimation. As a result, many different land surface models and satellite-based algorithms currently exist, each with their own strengths and weaknesses. One major assumption typically applied in these models/algorithms is that groundwater levels are deep enough so that there is free vertical drainage across the root zone. As a result, it is assumed that groundwater dynamics do not influence evaporation. However, in many regions, the groundwater table is shallow, such that vegetation does have access to the groundwater system. This interaction with the groundwater system may increase evaporation, particularly during dry seasons and in some regions more significantly than in others. Therefore, the common assumption of a deep groundwater system may result in underestimated evaporation estimates. This applies to land surface models and satellite-based algorithms relying on plant available water for the computation of evaporative stress. In this study, the inclusion of a groundwater module is explored in a commonly used satellite-based algorithm, namely the Global Land Evaporation Amsterdam Model (GLEAM), by assuming that the groundwater system can be represented with a linear reservoir. This simple approach was selected for its limited data requirements, global applicability and for being compatible with the structure of GLEAM. To assess the reliability of this new groundwater model, analyses were carried out for The Netherlands due to groundwater data availability. For this purpose, groundwater level predictions were compared to in situ data and a national groundwater model based on MODFLOW (Modular Three-Dimensional Finite-Difference Groundwater Flow Model). In addition, the new evaporation estimates were compared to those by the original GLEAM and to in situ eddy covariance data. This study sets a new step towards understanding the impact of groundwater on evaporation using satellite data at a global scale.

    How to cite: Hulsman, P., Koppa, A., Schellekens, J., and Miralles, D. G.: Improving satellite-based evaporation estimates by incorporating plant access to groundwater, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13191, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13191, 2022.

    EGU22-482 | Presentations | HS6.7

    Hour-to-hour vegetation water dynamics captured in radar backscatter: lessons learned from experimental studies 

    Paul Vermunt, Susan Steele-Dunne, Saeed Khabbazan, Jasmeet Judge, Nick van de Giesen, Vineet Kumar, Leila Guerriero, Alejandro Monsivais-Huertero, and Pang-Wei Liu

    In recent years, radar remote sensing has been increasingly used for studies on interactions between vegetation and hydrology. New opportunities arise for more advanced studies, as unprecedented spatiotemporal monitoring capability will be offered by the next generation of spaceborne radar instruments. To avail of these opportunities, we need a better understanding of the water dynamics in a canopy which is captured in a radar signal.

    Here, we present our latest findings from two experimental campaigns. In these campaigns, we used a ground-based prototype L-band radar instrument to obtain sub-daily observations, and extensive hydrometeorological measurements to monitor the water flow and storage in the soil-plant-atmosphere continuum of a corn field. Estimating 15-minute fluctuations of vegetation water content (VWC), surface canopy water (dew, interception), and surface soil moisture allowed us to quantify backscatter sensitivity to each of these moisture stores.

    It will be shown that the nocturnal cycle of dew, and the diurnal cycle of VWC have a considerably higher effect on L-band backscatter than previously assumed. Both particularly affected the vertically polarized signals. Furthermore, we will demonstrate that the non-uniform vertical distribution of moisture in the canopy is dynamic, both on seasonal and diurnal timescales. A modelling study quantified the impact this has on backscatter. Our findings demonstrate the opportunities for spaceborne sub-daily radar observations to monitor rapid vegetation water dynamics. Moreover, they offer insights for future validation field campaigns.

     

    References

    Vermunt, P. C., Khabbazan, S., Steele-Dunne, S. C., Judge, J., Monsivais-Huertero, A., Guerriero, L., & Liu, P. W. (2020). Response of Subdaily L-Band Backscatter to Internal and Surface Canopy Water Dynamics. IEEE Transactions on Geoscience and Remote Sensing, 59, 7322-7337.

    Vermunt, P. C., Steele-Dunne, S. C., Khabbazan, S., Judge, J., & van de Giesen, N. C. (2021). Reconstructing Continuous Vegetation Water Content To Understand Sub-daily Backscatter Variations. Hydrology and Earth System Sciences Discussions, 1-26.

    How to cite: Vermunt, P., Steele-Dunne, S., Khabbazan, S., Judge, J., van de Giesen, N., Kumar, V., Guerriero, L., Monsivais-Huertero, A., and Liu, P.-W.: Hour-to-hour vegetation water dynamics captured in radar backscatter: lessons learned from experimental studies, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-482, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-482, 2022.

    EGU22-510 | Presentations | HS6.7

    Effect of Drought Stress on Forest Evapotranspiration- A case study on Indian forests 

    Triparna Sett, Bhaskar R Nikam, Hukum Singh, and Saurabh Purohit

    Forest evapotranspiration (ET) is one of the most important processes regulating the terrestrial hydrological cycle, and it is increasingly affected by drought episodes. This emphasizes the need of comprehending the relationship between forest ET and forest drought stress, we chose two forested regions for our investigation, a Deciduous Broadleaf Forest (DBF) and an Evergreen Needle leaf forest (ENF) from India. ET was reduced in most forests around the world during severe and extreme droughts that lasted for lengthy periods, yet their susceptibility to forest drought stress is the crucial component in ensuring their long-term viability. Rainfall data from CHIRPS was used to estimate the monthly Standardized Precipitation Index (SPI) and identify wet and dry spells during the period 1981 to 2020. Vegetation drought indexes viz. Vegetation Condition Index (VCI), Temperature Condition Index (TCI) and Vegetation Health Index (VHI) were estimated using MODIS EVI and LST data from 2002 to 2020.

    According to our findings, the ENF experienced a lengthier dry spell from 1998 to 2007. In 2002, the lowest (-2.28) SPI was recorded. There is a substantial increase in the frequency of dry spells for DBF. In 2002, the most negative SPI of -2.03 was recorded in DBF. As a result, 2002 is considered a drought year for the type of forests. 2015 was selected as a wet year due based on SPI values 3.94 and 3.46 for ENF and DBF, respectively. The ET of these two regions was estimated using an auto-calibrated METRIC model. During the drought period (2002) the ET of the DBF region decreased to 0.17-2.19 mm/day from 0.66-4.89 mm/day during the normal/wet period (2015). Similarly, ET of the ENF region was also decreased to 2.81-4.51 mm/day during the dry period in comparison to 2.92-6.65 mm/day in the year 2015. The ET rate is not changed as much by ENF as it is by DBF.

    There are three possible explanations for why these distinct plant species react to drought stress. The first is the pattern of precipitation. Because ENF's overall precipitation is always higher than DBF's, the ET rate is naturally higher, and there is very little change in ENF's ET between drought and non-drought years. The next factor to consider is temperature variation; during droughts, the temperature in DBF is higher than in ENF, hence the ET is higher. The final cause is due to physiological and anatomical differences between DBF and ENF. The governing variables of evapotranspiration are leaf water content, stomatal conductance, the relative water content in leaves, absolute and relative transpiration rates, variation in species-wise water usage efficiency, and deep plant root systems. Drought conditions impair plant development and productivity by reducing stomatal conductance, reducing leaf area, stem extension, and root growth, and disrupting plant osmotic relations and water-use efficiency, among other things. As a result, DBF has a higher intensity of drought stress than ENF. In this sense, ENF outperforms DBF in terms of plant resistance and strategic adaptation to drought stress.

    Key Words: Forest drought stress, forest evapotranspiration, SPI, VHI, METRIC

    How to cite: Sett, T., Nikam, B. R., Singh, H., and Purohit, S.: Effect of Drought Stress on Forest Evapotranspiration- A case study on Indian forests, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-510, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-510, 2022.

    EGU22-1737 | Presentations | HS6.7

    Hydrological drivers of the spatial distribution of herbaceous wetland communities at Poyang Lake 

    Wenqin Huang, Tengfei Hu, Jingqiao Mao, Carsten Montzka, Roland Bol, Songxian Wan, and Jin Yue

    Hydrological processes are known as driving forces in structuring wetland plant communities, but still specific relationships are not always well understood. The dynamic, seasonally inundated wetland at Poyang Lake (less than 1000  km2 in the dry season and more than 3000 km2 in the wet season), the largest freshwater lake in China, underpinnes critical regional ecosystem services (e.g. flood water retention, water supply and biodiversity conservation). However, recent drier conditions of Poyang Lake are having a profound impact on its wetland vegetation leading to degradation of the entire wetland ecosystem, thereby also threatening the winter habitat of migratory birds. We aim to develop an integrated framework to quantitatively investigate the spatial distribution of major herbaceous communities that provide habitat for the migratory birds in response to Poyang Lake flood inundation. First, ground references are obtained from a combination of drone imagery and field surveys as an input for the wetland herbaceous community classification model. Our classification model is based on a machine learning technique applied to Sentinel-2 satellite data. This new search strategy provides an accurate classification based on the more optimal input variables and model parameters gained simultaneously. Secondly, based on the dynamic changes in water levels since 2000, we statistically evaluate the key environmental drivers of the hydrological regime on the spatial distribution of the wetland vegetation communities. This showed that: 1) different plant communities exhibited varying tolerance to flood inundation and 2) two key factors, i.e., average water depth and average duration of the inundation events, were found to be able to characterize the communities’ tolerance independently. For example, Carex cinerascens Ass. which had the widest inundation stress tolerance, being adapted to an inundation duration of 120~230 d and depth of 1.5~1.7 m, accounted for the largest herbaceous community (>27% cover) within the entire study area. Different survival strategies to inundation stress, such as dormancy and morphological restructuring, can explain the varying tolerance of plant species/communities. Our work elucidated the linkages between hydrological processes and herbaceous plants’ distribution in wetlands, and the approach can be readily applied at small to large catchment scales and provides a straightforward practical tool to predict the possible responses of the lake wetland vegetations to potential hydrological changes.

    How to cite: Huang, W., Hu, T., Mao, J., Montzka, C., Bol, R., Wan, S., and Yue, J.: Hydrological drivers of the spatial distribution of herbaceous wetland communities at Poyang Lake, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1737, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1737, 2022.

    EGU22-1775 | Presentations | HS6.7

    Rapid and temporary increases in low flows in the Amazon explained by changes in root-zone water storage 

    Rodolfo Nóbrega and Iain Colin Prentice

    Increases in streamflow are often attributed to land-cover clearing (LCC) on the basis that it reduces soil infiltration capacity and increases surface runoff. Nonetheless, these changes can result from different hydrological mechanisms depending on the vegetation, and temporal and spatial scales. LCC triggers a series of changes in hydrological fluxes that have non-linear responses to precipitation and that were established upon the long-term balance with regional climatological, edaphic, and geological characteristics. We analysed streamflow and root zone water capacity (RZSC) to identify underlying relationships between stream dynamics and water consumption by plants. We used a time-series segmentation and residual trend analysis on streamflow and precipitation of high-order tributaries of the Tapajós River whose catchments underwent intense land-use changes over the past decades. We estimated the RZSC using the "Earth observation-based" mass-curve balance method by considering the annual land-cover changes over a >30-year period. We show that the reduction in the RZWC caused by changes in the water consumption by plants over the dry season is tightly associated with the increased baseflow contribution to rivers. Finally, we analysed gross primary productivity (GPP) and ET estimates generated by a model based on eco-evolutionary optimality that integrates the water and carbon cycles at the canopy level. We found that trends in ET from croplands are not as pronounced as trends in GPP. Although RZWC is quantified using the water deficit driven by ET, changes in RZWC are more correlated to changes in GPP. We show that the potential effects of vegetation responses to increasing atmospheric CO2 concentrations on streamflow are still outweighed by impacts of land-use change on low flows in Amazon rivers. However, this might not be the case for all water cycle components, and, therefore, we highlight the importance of considering the carbon cycle in hydrological assessment studies.

    How to cite: Nóbrega, R. and Prentice, I. C.: Rapid and temporary increases in low flows in the Amazon explained by changes in root-zone water storage, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1775, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1775, 2022.

    EGU22-5128 | Presentations | HS6.7

    Disentangling soil moisture and vegetation effects on the ASCAT backscatter-incidence angle relationship 

    Isabella Greimeister-Pfeil, Wolfgang Wagner, Raphael Quast, Sebastian Hahn, Susan Steele-Dunne, and Mariette Vreugdenhil

    Microwave scatterometers provide global and frequent observations of the Earth’s surface. In particular, C-Band scatterometers are sensitive to the moisture content of the soil and vegetation in the sensor footprint, and can therefore be used for the retrieval of soil moisture (SM) and vegetation optical depth (VOD).

    To model the vegetation component in the signal, and subsequently retrieve VOD, the slope (σ’) of the backscatter dependence on the incidence angle of the observation is exploited. This is possible because σ’ is related to the water content and structure of the canopy. Early studies moreover showed that SM effects on σ’ are weak and can, in a first approximation, be neglected. However, short-term dynamics in σ’ have raised questions about the validity of this assumption.

    In this study, we investigate a potential SM effect on σ’ time series derived from the Advanced Scatterometer (ASCAT) by exploring relationships between σ’, SM, and leaf area index. We carry out the analysis over six study regions in Portugal, Austria, and Russia with different climate, land cover and vegetation cycles.

    Spearman correlations between short-term anomalies of σ’ and SM are stronger than between σ’ and LAI, indicating that SM does have an effect on σ’. The analysis of daily σ’ values, as opposed to the smoothed σ’ that is used in retrieval algorithms, shows SM effects even more clearly: SM increases correspond to decreases of σ’, even during periods of vegetation growth, which are typically characterized by increasing σ’ values. Thus, we conclude that there is a SM signal in σ’ time series on top of the vegetation signal. Over sparse vegetation, the SM effect may be as large as 20% of the seasonal, vegetation-induced variation of σ’, whereas it is smaller over dense vegetation. Moreover, the short-term dynamics in σ’ time series might be caused by water on the canopy, i.e., interception or dew, to some extent. Further work is needed to confirm this hypothesis. For the retrieval of SM from ASCAT observations, these results confirm the use of a long-term average σ’ climatology instead of dynamic σ’ time series to correct for vegetation effects.

    How to cite: Greimeister-Pfeil, I., Wagner, W., Quast, R., Hahn, S., Steele-Dunne, S., and Vreugdenhil, M.: Disentangling soil moisture and vegetation effects on the ASCAT backscatter-incidence angle relationship, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5128, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5128, 2022.

    EGU22-5814 | Presentations | HS6.7

    Satellite-observed vegetation responses to intraseasonal rainfall variability 

    Bethan L. Harris, Christopher Taylor, Graham P. Weedon, Joshua Talib, Wouter Dorigo, and Robin van der Schalie

    The response of vegetation to changes in rainfall is a key factor in understanding terrestrial water availability, as well as land-atmosphere feedbacks that can occur as a result of the changes in evapotranspiration, albedo and surface roughness.

    Studies of vegetation responses to rainfall have typically focused on variations at the seasonal timescale or longer. However, there is considerable rainfall predictability associated with atmospheric modes of intraseasonal (25 to 60 day) variability, for example the Madden-Julian Oscillation. An improved understanding of land surface predictability at the intraseasonal timescale could aid decision-making in areas such as water management or agriculture, as well as feeding back onto atmospheric predictability. Quantifying intraseasonal vegetation responses could also highlight required improvements in dynamic vegetation modelling for land surface models.

    Here, we use satellite-based measurements of rainfall and Vegetation Optical Depth (VOD) to assess the relationships between the intraseasonal variability of rainfall and vegetation across the tropics and mid-latitudes. VOD is a proxy for vegetation water content and is also linked to biomass dynamics. Since it is derived from microwave observations, it can be retrieved under cloudy conditions, giving sufficient daily observations to permit the investigation of variations on the 25-60 day timescale in regions with frequent cloud cover such as the tropics. We use cross-spectral analysis to characterise the intraseasonal vegetation responses at a 0.25° pixel scale in each season.

    Coherent intraseasonal relationships between rainfall and vegetation are typically found in arid or semi-arid regions, where vegetation is water-limited and hence sensitive to wet and dry spells. We also analyse the phase difference between rainfall and vegetation, i.e. by how many days one lags the other. Changes in vegetation are generally found to lag changes in rainfall, with increased rainfall followed by increased VOD. The results show that the observations capture distinct distributions of phase difference according to land cover type, with very fast (0-5 day) vegetation responses most likely in sparsely vegetated areas. Following strong intraseasonal wet events, the increase in VOD can persist for at least two months after the peak in rainfall.

    How to cite: Harris, B. L., Taylor, C., Weedon, G. P., Talib, J., Dorigo, W., and van der Schalie, R.: Satellite-observed vegetation responses to intraseasonal rainfall variability, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5814, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5814, 2022.

    EGU22-8239 | Presentations | HS6.7

    Revealing the drought response of large-scale vegetation physiology from multiple satellite-based observations 

    Wantong Li, Mirco Migliavacca, Markus Reichstein, Matthias Forkel, Christian Frankenberg, and René Orth

    The frequency and the intensity of drought events have increased during the past decades in some regions, yet the implications of drought for the terrestrial vegetation functioning are not fully understood. In particular, drought in related studies has often been characterized by meteorological conditions rather than the actual soil moisture deficit. Further, previous research focused predominantly on the structural vegetation response, such that the large-scale physiological response remains poorly understood.

    Here, we analyze and compare the vegetation’s physiological and structural responses to drought across the globe using high-resolution daily TROPOMI sun-induced fluorescence (SIF) as a proxy for productivity, short-wavelength vegetation optical depth (VOD) as a proxy for canopy water conditions and biomass, and near-infrared reflectance of terrestrial vegetation (NIRv) during the period March 2018 - August 2021. Taking advantage of an extended soil moisture record (1979-2021, ERA5-Land reanalysis) we identify and focus on regions where severe soil moisture droughts occurred during our relatively short analysis period. Therein, we quantify and compare the amounts of SIF, VOD and NIRv changes during the early and late drought stages as well as for the recovery period. We also compute the vegetation response to short-term soil moisture changes, i.e. the vegetation sensitivity to short-term soil moisture and the respective changes during the course of droughts. The absolute changes of vegetation indices allow to disentangle physiological and structural responses, while the sensitivity analysis can quantify vegetation responses straightforward to water limitation by accounting for meteorological forcings. To infer vegetation sensitivity, we train random forest regression models at each grid cell, and apply the SHapley Additive exPlanations (SHAP) method to isolate the influence of soil moisture on vegetation from that of other meteorological variables such as temperature, solar radiation, precipitation and vapor pressure deficit. 

    Analyzing the absolute value changes of NIRv, SIF and VOD during the 2018 European drought and the 2020 Russian drought events, we find asynchronous responses of vegetation productivity and vegetation water content. This indicates different hydraulic regulation strategies in response to drought. Moving beyond these case studies, we quantified and averaged the vegetation sensitivity to soil moisture across many severe droughts across the globe, which reveals systematic sensitivity increases during the course of the drought. From an ecological perspective, this indicates increases in ecosystem vulnerability to drought, and can induce feedback in climate and ecosystem services. Vegetation responses to drought differ depending on different vegetation types, climate and soil conditions. In addition, we conduct carbon fluxes from eddy covariance measurements to confirm the vegetation responses to drought derived from Earth observation satellites. In summary, this study provides insights into vegetation responses to droughts at large spatial scales which can help to accurately quantify respective anomalies in terms of land carbon uptake to consequently improve climate projections.

    How to cite: Li, W., Migliavacca, M., Reichstein, M., Forkel, M., Frankenberg, C., and Orth, R.: Revealing the drought response of large-scale vegetation physiology from multiple satellite-based observations, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8239, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8239, 2022.

    In the presence of uncertain initial conditions and model parameters coupled land surface model (LSM)- vegetation dynamic model (VDM) performance can be significantly improved by the assimilation of periodic observations of certain state variables, such as the soil moisture and normalized difference vegetation index (NDVI) as observed from satellite remote platforms.

    The possibility to merge grass and tree NDVI observations and radar data with the model optimally for providing robust predictions of soil moisture and grass and tree leaf area index (LAI) in heterogenous ecosystems is demonstrated. We propose an assimilation approach that assimilates backscatter data from radar and NDVI from optical sensors through the Ensemble Kalman filter (EnKF) and provides a physics-based update of soil moisture and grass and tree LAI predicted by VDM. We used Sentinel 1 radar data for soil moisture, and Landsat 8 and Sentinel 2 optical data for NDVI. Soil moisture is predicted by the LSM, while the VDM predicts the LAI, which is strictly related to NDVI, through a field-estimated empirical relationship.

    This approach, as with other common assimilation approaches, may fail when key model parameters, e.g. the saturated hydraulic conductivity of LSM and the maintenance respiration coefficient (ma) of VDM, are estimated poorly. This leads to biased model errors producing a violation of a main assumption (model errors with zero mean) of the EnKF. For overcoming this model bias an innovative assimilation approach was developed, which accepts this violation in the early model run-times and dynamically calibrates all the components of the model parameter ensembles as a function of the persistent bias in soil moisture and LAI predictions, allowing to remove the model bias, restore the fidelity to the EnKF requirements and reduce the model uncertainty.

    The proposed multiscale assimilation approach was tested in a Sardinian field site, a typical Mediterranean ecosystem characterized by strong heterogeneity of the vegetation and water limited conditions. The site is also a case study of the SWATCH European Research Project, and in this field a micrometeorological eddy-covariance based tower is operating from 2003.

    The positive impact of the proposed assimilation approach on the soil water budget, evapotranspiration and CO2 uptake predictions in the heterogenous ecosystem is demonstrated finally. 

    How to cite: Gaspa, A., Corona, R., and Montaldo, N.: Multi Scale Assimilation of NDVI and radar data for soil moisture and Leaf Area Index Predictions in an Heterogeneous Mediterranean Ecosystem, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10048, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10048, 2022.

    As future changes in climate announce an increase in the frequency of drier periods, it is important to understand how climatic variables can influence vegetation productivity. An analysis in the growing season is especially relevant, as it is the period when vegetation is most sensitive to climate change.  In this study, the NDVI and SPEI were used to represent vegetation productivity and climate variables, respectively, at a global scale, in different temporal scales. The growing season variable was defined as a function of vegetation productivity. Pearson correlation between both variables at different timescales was carried in Google Earth Engine, with a total of 72 scenarios: 3 different NDVI scales vs 24 different SPEI scales. An optimal scenario was defined for each pixel, representing the NDVI vs SPEI timescale where the correlation was higher. Aiming to understand the importance of different climatic variables on vegetation productivity a CART model was run. Temperature (T), precipitation (P) and solar radiation (Swd) were used as independent variables while optimal Pearson’s R was the dependent variable of the model.  Additionally, to further detail how the climatic variables were spatially distributed, a multiple linear regression between optimal values of vegetation health (NDVI) and optimal climatic variables (T, P, Swd) was run in each pixel of the map.

    The optimal NDVI timescale found for most of the globe was of 5 months, with exceptions in northern latitudes (optimal NDVI: 1 month) and in some arid regions of the globe (optimal NDVI: 3 months). The optimal SPEI timescale exhibits little variation, with optimal timescales between 9 and 12 months for most pixels. CART results showed that locations of low precipitation (<800mm/years) and high solar radiation (net radiation>97 W/m2) were the locations with the best correlations between climate and vegetation productivity during the growth season, with branches of the model averaging a Pearson correlation above 0.5. The pixel-by-pixel multiple linear regression indicated that precipitation is the controlling factor of vegetation in arid regions, such as Australia, southern Africa and the Mojave and Sonoran deserts. Vegetation in northern latitudes and regions of temperate climate, i.e., Patagonia and temperate prairies in the US, tended to have radiation as its limiting climate factor. Whilst temperature was the driving factor in wetlands, such as the Pantanal in South America and parts of Southern China and Vietnam. Finally, vegetation in tropical forests and temperate forests showed none of the three climatic factors analysed controlling more than 20% of vegetation response, potentially indicating the dominance of secondary factors.

    How to cite: Fileni, F., Feng, S., Erikson, J., Pettersson, R., and Winterdahl, M.: The influence of climatic variables on vegetation response during the growing season – Using Decision Trees (CART) and Multiple Linear Regression (MLR) to define how precipitation, temperature, and solar radiation shape vegetation response globally., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10700, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10700, 2022.

    EGU22-10934 | Presentations | HS6.7

    The contribution of soil, topographic, and vegetation traits to plant-water sensitivity 

    Alexandra Konings, Krishna Rao, Meng Zhao, A. Park Williams, Noah Diffenbaugh, and Marta Yebra

    Spatio-temporal patterns of plant water uptake, loss, and storage are a first-order control on photosynthesis, evapotranspiration dynamics, and thus, land-atmosphere interactions. These patterns depend on temporally variable hydrometeorological conditions but also on geographically varying characteristics. These include, but are not limited to, topographic and soil properties that influence rainfall infiltration and water distribution in the unsaturated zone and vegetation properties, such as rooting depth, stomatal and xylem properties, leaf area, and more. Understanding how these different factors interact to control the overall dynamics of plant water uptake is fundamental to understanding the response of vegetation to hydrologic variations, but has traditionally been hindered by data limitations. In situ measurements are too sparse to sufficiently span the range of possible variations across different geographic factors. Remote sensing estimates of plant water uptake either are not available or (in the case of ET estimates) are sufficiently indirect that they are unlikely to correctly account for all of the factors above. Here, we study the effects of different geographic factors on plant-water interactions by analyzing the dynamics of live fuel moisture content (LFMC, defined as the vegetation water content divided by dry biomass) determined from Sentinel-1 synthetic aperture radar and Landsat multispectral observations. LFMC directly reflects vegetation water content and therefore patterns of plant water uptake and evapotranspiration. We quantify the "plant-water sensitivity" by using an auto-regressive model comparing LFMC to climate and analyze the spatial patterns of plant water sensitivity at 4 km resolution across the Western United States. No individual factor explains a majority of the spatial patterns in plant-water sensitivity. With the exception of the maximum soil conductance, no soil, topographic, or vegetation traits exerts a dominant control on plant water sensitivity. However, when aggregated, soil characteristics explain about twice as much variability in plant water sensitivity as topographic or plant characteristics do, despite little previous recognition of the influence of soil hydraulic properties on plant-water interactions. 

    How to cite: Konings, A., Rao, K., Zhao, M., Williams, A. P., Diffenbaugh, N., and Yebra, M.: The contribution of soil, topographic, and vegetation traits to plant-water sensitivity, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10934, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10934, 2022.

    EGU22-11165 | Presentations | HS6.7

    Partitioning of rainfall and snowmelt between trees and streams in the Swiss Alps 

    Harsh Beria and James W. Kirchner

    The hydrologic cycle in Switzerland relies heavily on snowmelt sustaining streamflows during spring and summer. Climate warming will shrink the regional coverage of seasonal snowpacks thereby leading to an earlier onset of snowmelt, which in turn will alter streamflow regimes. However, the effects of changes in snow regimes on Alpine vegetation are largely unknown. In this context, it is imperative to understand how much streamflow and vegetation water uptake depend on different precipitation phases (rainfall versus snowfall), and what factors control the relative proportion of rainfall and snowfall that are ultimately used by vegetation (versus that flow to streams).

    In this presentation, we use stable water isotopes to assess seasonal origin of waters used by Alpine trees vs water flowing into the nearby stream across different sites in Switzerland. We then correlate remote sensing based plant water abundance indicators (NDVI, NDWI, VOD) against long term streamflow records to assess how strongly waters flowing into streams are decoupled from waters taken up by vegetation, and how this decoupling varies across space and time. Using these results, we propose a theoretical framework that explains the phenomenon of “drought paradox”, where precipitation deficits during periods of drought disproportionally impact streamflow generation over vegetation in the Swiss Alps.

    How to cite: Beria, H. and Kirchner, J. W.: Partitioning of rainfall and snowmelt between trees and streams in the Swiss Alps, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11165, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11165, 2022.

    Many studies have demonstrated the value of microwave remote sensing for soil and vegetation applications in agricultural and natural systems. The sensitivity of microwave observables to internal water content makes them suitable for monitoring changes in above ground biomass associated with growth, seasonality and land cover change. In recent years, microwave observations have increasingly been used to monitor changes in vegetation water content associated with water status. Here, novel experimental data from field campaigns and analyses of satellite data records will be synthesized to provide a perspective on the current and future use of radar for monitoring vegetation water dynamics.

    Ground-based radar and in-situ data will be used to illustrate the sensitivity of sub-daily radar data to detect the subtle response of the vegetation to variations in moisture supply and demand. These data will also be used to highlight the sensitivity of radar observables to surface canopy water (dew and/or interception). On the one hand, it will be shown that surface canopy water can have a confounding effect on vegetation parameter retrieval. On the other hand, microwaves can provide valuable information on this quantity of considerable interest in hydrology and land-atmosphere interactions.

     Analyses of existing satellite data records (ASCAT, Sentinel-1) will be used to show that the opportunities and challenges identifiable at field scale translate to the footprint scale. Furthermore, they will be used to outline a way forward. Future microwave missions offer unprecedented diversity in terms of sensors (in terms of frequency, polarization, viewing geometry, observation technique), as well as finer spatial and temporal resolution. To make optimal use of these new capabilities, we need to be willing to revisit our fundamental understanding of the factors affecting microwave interactions with vegetation. Finally, it will be argued that the use of machine learning can facilitate extracting the full information content of microwave observations by providing a means to reconcile microwave observables with land surface model states and parameters.

    How to cite: Steele-Dunne, S.: A perspective on the current and future use of satellite radar observations for monitoring vegetation water dynamics, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11542, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11542, 2022.

    EGU22-12339 | Presentations | HS6.7

    UAV based thermal imaging at the leaf scale – A case study in a tropical dry forest 

    Malkin Gerchow, Kathrin Kühnhammer, Alberto Iraheta, and Matthias Beyer

    Leaf and canopy temperature have long been recognized as an important indicators of plant water status. Recently, unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) became arguably the superior platform to acquire leaf temperatures due to their low cost and high spatiotemporal resolution and flexibility compared to satellite platforms. However, when interested in absolute leaf temperatures of individual leaves, the resolution of thermal cameras is often not sufficient and UAV overflight height needs to be adjusted. This causes heterogeneous forests to become inherently complex structures with great challenges for generating thermal orthomosaics. In addition, currently applied uncooled thermal sensors are affected by their ambient conditions causing temperature readings to drift during flight operation.
    To address these issues, we employed a dual camera setup consisting of a visible and thermal sensor to aid the geometric calibration of the thermal sensor. To account for the temperature drift, we developed an alternative flight planning approach: During the UAV mapping mission ground temperature references are repeatedly captured from above forest clearings to estimate temperature drift and continuously adjust temperature calibration. We compare our temperature calibration approach to the default camera calibration and to a simple pre- and post-flight calibration method under different atmospheric conditions (temperature, wind and cloud coverage). The geometric accuracy of the forests thermal orthomosaics is validated against ground control points.
    Accurate calibrated canopy temperatures will allow to compare canopy temperature differences while also providing uncertainty estimates of the temperature data. High resolution thermal maps at the forest leaf scale will open up the possibility to analyze plant water status during seasonal dry forest changes.

    How to cite: Gerchow, M., Kühnhammer, K., Iraheta, A., and Beyer, M.: UAV based thermal imaging at the leaf scale – A case study in a tropical dry forest, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12339, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12339, 2022.

    EGU22-12559 | Presentations | HS6.7 | Highlight

    Monitoring drought impact on vegetation with Sentinel-1 

    Mariette Vreugdenhil, Isabella PFeil, Susan Steele-Dunne, and Wouter Dorigo

    With the Copernicus Sentinel-1 series, for the first time high temporal and spatial resolution backscatter time series have become available. Sentinel-1 backscatter observations are sensitive to changes in water content and structural changes in vegetation and soils and provide complementary information next to optical remote sensing datasets such as Leaf Area Index. However, most studies have looked at the sensitivity of Sentinel-1 backscatter to vegetation water dynamics at very local scale. Furthermore, no specific focus has yet been on monitoring drought impact on vegetation with Sentinel-1. Here we will present results of a study over Europe which assesses the potential of Sentinel-1 to monitor drought impact on vegetation.

    In this study we use the record summer drought of 2018 as a case study. This drought led to decreased yields in northwestern Europe, and to decreased GPP in for example grasslands and forests (Fu et al., 2020). We have calculated anomalies of co-, and cross-polarized backscatter, and the ratio thereof, the so-called cross-ratio (CR) of 2018 with the reference year of 2016 which had normal conditions. These anomalies were compared to anomalies calculated with Copernicus Global Land Service LAI anomalies and ESA CCI soil moisture anomalies and analyzed per land cover type. The results show very strong negative anomalies in VV, VH backscatter and CR from June to November over central and northwestern Europe, similar to those observed in LAI. However, differences in patterns can be seen between LAI and CR, especially over forest areas. Although LAI showed stronger anomalies in the Netherlands and western Germany in July, CR shows stronger anomalies in eastern Germany and Czech Republic, and especially over forests. These differences in patterns may be related to the penetration depth of microwaves, and the sensitivity to vegetation water content of the above ground biomass.

    How to cite: Vreugdenhil, M., PFeil, I., Steele-Dunne, S., and Dorigo, W.: Monitoring drought impact on vegetation with Sentinel-1, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12559, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12559, 2022.

    EGU22-13063 | Presentations | HS6.7

    The long-term floodplain forest modifications of a regulated tropical river 

    Luca Salerno, Alvaro Moreno-Martínez, Emma Izquierdo-Verdiguier, Nicholas Clinton, Annunziato Siviglia, and Carlo Camporeale

    The regular flood pulse of large tropical rivers is the main driver of ecological and biogeochemical process in large Amazonian floodplains. Endemic vegetation species developed adaptation to survive in seasonal flood environments and tune their vital process with periodic flood events, water levels, and sedimentary processes. The construction of hydroelectric dam causes alterations of natural hydrological regime and sediment supply, threatening downstream floodplain forest.

    An assessment of impact of river regulation on floodplain vegetation is crucial to develop a modern approach to the regulated rivers management in the Neotropics and to mitigate the impact of damming on floodplain environment. Nevertheless, floodplain forest monitoring requires high resolution mapping as vegetation dynamics are in the narrow area at the interface terrestrial and aquatic systems. Most of the existing satellite images that afford land observations have severe limitations due to their coarse resolution or missing  data caused by the extreme cloudiness conditions in of tropical regions.

    In the present work, we propose an innovative approach based on high-resolution mapping for the monitoring long-term evolution of vegetation in a highly impacted environment (Uatama river) due to Balbina dam regulation.  We combine Landsat (30m spatial resolution and 16 days revisit cycle) and the MODIS missions (500m spatial resolution and daily revisit cycle), using HISTARFM algorithm, to reduce noise and produce monthly gap-free high-resolution (30 m) observations over land. Areas characterized by vegetation changes are identified through the analysis of of vegetation index products derived from the high-resolution reflectance data.  Furthermore, hydrological modification within these areas are assessed by using a global water surface dataset.

    We found a deep redistribution of floodplain forest concentrated in areas that experienced a hydrologic regime transition after dam construction. The vegetation changes comprise not only vegetation degradation of areas with greater hydrological stress but also with large floodplain areas not flooded afterwards, which were invaded by upland forest. Although the dam was built more than 30 years ago, its effects on the vegetation continue and the situation seems far from reaching a new environmental equilibrium.

    The framework proposed offers a practical and novel tool to accurately monitor riparian vegetation dynamics over time even for very remote and poorly accessible areas such as tropical floodplains. Furthermore, the assessment of the impact that the human footprint has on tropical floodplain allows a more careful management of the watersheds.

    How to cite: Salerno, L., Moreno-Martínez, A., Izquierdo-Verdiguier, E., Clinton, N., Siviglia, A., and Camporeale, C.: The long-term floodplain forest modifications of a regulated tropical river, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13063, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13063, 2022.

    EGU22-1010 | Presentations | HS6.8

    The impact of assimilating Earth Observation and in situ data on seasonal hydrological predictions in a snow-dominated river system 

    Jude Lubega Musuuza, Louise Crochemore, and Ilias G. Pechlivanidis

    Earth Observations (EO) have become popular in hydrology because they provide valuable information in locations where direct measurements are either unavailable or prohibitively expensive to make. Recent scientific advances have enabled the assimilation of EO’s into hydrological models to improve the estimation of initial states and fluxes which further leads to improved forecasting of different hydrometeorological variables. When assimilated, the data exert additional controls on the quality of the forecasts; it is hence important to apportion the effects according to model forcing and the assimilated data. Here, we investigate the impact of assimilating different EO and in itu data-sets individually and as combinations on the discharge and reservoir inflow estimations in the snow dominated Umeälven catchment in northern Sweden. We further assess the impact of the assimilations on seasonal predictions over the catchment. Six datasets are assimilated comprising of four EO products (fractional snow cover, snow water equivalent, and the actual and potential evapotranspiration) and two in situ datasets (discharge and reservoir inflow). For the latter investigation,  we drive the E-HYPE hydrological model with two meteorological forcings: (i) a down-scaled GCM product based on the bias-adjusted ECMWF SEAS5 seasonal forecasts, and (ii) historical meteorological data based on the Ensemble Streamflow Prediction (ESP) method. We finally assess the impacts of the meteorological forcing and the assimilated data on the streamflow and reservoir inflow seasonal forecasting skill for the period 2001-2015. We assessed the value of assimilating different data-sets and identified the datasets that can be meaningfully combined. We further show that all assimilations generally improve the forecasting skill but the improvement varies depending on the season and assimilated variable. The lead times until when the data assimilations influence the forecast quality are also different for different datasets and seasons; as an example, the impact from assimilating snow water equivalent persists for more than 20 weeks during the winter. We finally show that the assimilated datasets exert more control on the forecasting skill than the meteorological forcing, highlighting the importance of initial hydrological conditions for this snow-dominated river system.

    How to cite: Musuuza, J. L., Crochemore, L., and Pechlivanidis, I. G.: The impact of assimilating Earth Observation and in situ data on seasonal hydrological predictions in a snow-dominated river system, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1010, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1010, 2022.

    EGU22-2209 | Presentations | HS6.8

    Assessing the suitability of multi-spectral satellite data for the development of data-driven models of phytoplankton dynamics in lakes and reservoirs 

    Kyriakos Kandris, Evangelos Romas, Apostolos Tzimas, Ilias Pechlivanidis, Philipp Bauer, Klaus Joehnk, Mariano Bresciani, Claudia Giardino, Janet Anstee, Blake A. Schaeffer, and Maria-Antonietta Dessena

    Phytoplankton blooms threaten aquatic ecosystems worldwide, with implications going beyond their apparent ecological aspects. Management solutions are needed to control the appearance of phytoplankton blooms and alleviate their impacts. Such solutions are supported by scientific results, many of which derive from modeling approaches.

    Data-driven models are now routinely deployed for the short-term (day to weeks) forecasting of phytoplankton dynamics. Nonetheless, such data-oriented efforts are often plagued by two issues, i.e., the lack of sufficient data and interpretability. On one hand, insufficient data result in overfitting, which produces poorly generalizable models that are unreliable under extrapolating conditions. On the other hand, the lack of interpretability hinders the contribution of such models in decision-making, since acting upon model predictions relies heavily on understanding of the model hypothesis.

    These two challenges motivated the present work, which aspired to investigate the suitability of multi-spectral satellite imagery as a source of phytoplankton-related data for the development of credible and accountable data-driven models. To this end, first, satellite-derived chlorophyll-a times series were created using Sentinel-2 and Landsat 8 imagery and a physics-based modular inversion and processing system. Then, two machine learning algorithms, i.e. a Random Forest (RF) and a Gaussian Process (GP) regression algorithm, were trained to map hydrometeorological drivers to the satellite-derived chlorophyll-a time series.

    The two algorithms were benchmarked against each other and against a naïve alternative, i.e., the persistence method, in terms of accuracy, uncertainty, and interpretability in three cases: (a) the mesotrophic Mulargia reservoir in Italy, (b) the hypereutrophic Harsha Lake in the USA, and (c) Lake Hume in Australia, a reservoir facing an increasing number of algal bloom events over the last 10 years.

    Results indicate that both machine learning models forecasted surface phytoplankton dynamics more accurately compared to their naïve alternative up to ten days ahead in the future. It should be noted though that forecasting accuracy deteriorated with increasing forecasting windows, mostly due to the uncertainty of meteorological forecasts.

    When the machine learning methods were compared to each other, the RF-based models were marginally better compared to their GP counterparts; they produced slightly more accurate and more certain chlorophyll-a predictions. RF-based models are also preferable in terms of interpretability. Their predictions unveiled specific patterns in hydrometeorological data that could explain phytoplankton dynamics in each case. On the contrary, it remained obscure how chlorophyll-a predictions were made by the GP regression models.

    More importantly this work offers evidence supporting that multi-spectral satellite data allow for the development of theory-guided, data-driven models for the forecasting of phytoplankton dynamics in lakes and reservoirs.

    How to cite: Kandris, K., Romas, E., Tzimas, A., Pechlivanidis, I., Bauer, P., Joehnk, K., Bresciani, M., Giardino, C., Anstee, J., Schaeffer, B. A., and Dessena, M.-A.: Assessing the suitability of multi-spectral satellite data for the development of data-driven models of phytoplankton dynamics in lakes and reservoirs, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2209, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2209, 2022.

    Agricultural production has been exposed to increased pressure in the latest years due to the combination of different factors. On one hand, indeed, there is an increasing demand for food due to the growth of the world population, on the other, some effects of climate changes, such as temperature increase and land degradation represent an evident threat for freshwater resources. In this context, implementing adequate and sustainably irrigation systems is fundamental, especially for semi-arid areas. The IDEWA (Irrigation and Drainage monitoring by remote sensing for Ecosystems and Water resources management) project, funded by the EU PRIMA program, aims at evaluating the whole performance of the irrigation process by developing innovative irrigation management tools based on readily available multi-sensor remote sensing data. Used input water and drained ones will be monitored together with other parameters (e.g. soil moisture, evapotranspiration, …) to evaluate their impact on downstream ecosystems in two study areas, namely the Ebro (Spain) and Tensift (Morocco) basins.

    Among the different parameters considered, water quality variability between input and drained waters has been evaluated by using high-resolution satellite data,  acquired by the Multispectral Instrument (MSI) onboard SENTINEL-2 satellites and by the Operational Land Imager (OLI aboard Landsat-8). Two main in-water constituents, such as the chlorophyll-a (chl-a) and suspended particulate matter (spm) have been investigated. Different algorithms have been tested and assessed also for comparison with in-situ measurements collected during specific measurement campaigns. In this work, we analyzed water quality variability at the outlet of the Algerri-Balaguer irrigation district (within Ebro basin), an intensively irrigated area characterized by a dense network of drainage channels. The achieved results show that the chl-a and spm seasonal variability could be affected by agricultural and hydrological forcing, such as the use of fertilizers and water level variations/fluctuations.

    How to cite: Lacava, T. and Ciancia, E.: Analysing water quality variability at the Algerri-Balaguer irrigation district (Ebro River basin, Spain), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3878, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3878, 2022.

    EGU22-3982 | Presentations | HS6.8

    Increasing cropping options in seasonal floodplain wetlands of sub-Saharan Africa: A remote-sensing approach for assessing available green water for cultivation 

    Saher Ayyad, Poolad Karimi, Matthias Langensiepen, Lars Ribbe, Lisa-Maria Rebelo, and Mathias Becker

    Producing more food for a growing population requires sustainable crop intensification and diversification, particularly in high-potential areas such as the seasonal floodplain wetlands of sub-Saharan Africa (SSA). With emerging water shortages and concerns for conserving these multi-functional wetlands, a further expansion of the cropland area must be avoided as it would entail increased use of blue water (surface and groundwater) for irrigation and infringe on valuable protected areas. We thus advocate an efficient use of the prevailing green water (plant-available water stored in the soil) on the existing cropland areas in seasonal floodplain wetlands, where small-scale farmers grow a single crop of rainfed lowland rice during the wet season. However, soil moisture at the onset of the rains (pre-rice niche) and residual soil moisture after rice harvest (post-rice niche) may suffice to cultivate short-cycled crops. We developed a methodological approach to analyze the potential for green water cultivation in the pre- and post-rice niches in the Kilombero Floodplain in Tanzania, as a representative case for seasonal floodplain wetlands in SSA. The three-step approach used open-access remote sensing datasets to: (i) extract cropland areas following a cross-comparison of multiple land cover products; (ii) analyze soil moisture conditions using evaporative stress indices to identify the pre- and post-rice niches (using MOD16A2GF potential (PET) and actual (AET) evapotranspiration products), and (iii) quantify the green water availability in the identified niches (using an ensemble mean of SSEBop and WaPOR to calculate AET).

    Results showed that the WaPOR land cover product reliably identified cropland areas in Kilombero, followed by CGLS-LC, while ESA-CCI largely miss-captured the cropland extent and MCD12Q1 did not capture almost any cropland areas. Estimates of the AET ensemble mean product of 2.6 mm/day were comparable with previously reported values in Kilombero cropland (2.05–2.74 mm/day) and were correlated with NDVI (MOD13Q1) on the monthly basis (R2 = 0.58; p <0.05), demonstrating the good performance of the AET ensemble mean product. We further identified distinct patterns of green water being available both before and after the rice-growing period. Based on the analyses of evaporative stress indices, the pre-rice niche tended to be longer (~70 days with AET of 20–40 mm/10-day) but also more variable (inter-annual variability >30%) than the post-rice niche (~65 days with AET of 10–30 mm/10-day, inter-annual variability <15%). These findings confirm the large potential for cultivating short-cycled crops beyond the rice-growing period on at least 53% of the total cropland area. A wider application of the developed approach in this study can help identifying opportunities and guiding interventions towards establishing cropping intensification and diversification practices in floodplain wetlands in SSA. The uncertainties, limitations, and implications of the proposed approach are discussed.

    How to cite: Ayyad, S., Karimi, P., Langensiepen, M., Ribbe, L., Rebelo, L.-M., and Becker, M.: Increasing cropping options in seasonal floodplain wetlands of sub-Saharan Africa: A remote-sensing approach for assessing available green water for cultivation, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3982, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3982, 2022.

    One of the important issues faced by human in 21st century is to meet the need of food particularly in the background of increasing population. Steep-slope agricultural landscapes are making a relevant contribution for food protection. To protect and mitigate the impact of more frequent rainfall events as well as improve the food production in, more researches about how to increase water resource efficiency and management is necessary. In addition, understanding the interactions between water management infrastructure and runoff process is a great concern on the sustainable development of steep-slope agricultural landscapes. Several researches focused on water and soil conservation measures aims at soil erosion control, while less studies were conducted to study on runoff trapping under different rainfall intensities and water managements measures through the remote sensing data. In this study, we simulated surface water flow under different rainfall events before and after the application of designed water storages network to search the best solution for water runoff mitigation and water conservation in steep-slope agricultural areas. In detail, our works focus on (1) to design the sustainable and cost-effective water management infrastructures to the study area; (2) to quantify the amount of water resource maintained by appropriate management measures; (3) to simulated the overflow in steep slope agricultural areas under different rainfall conditions using hydrologic model based on high-resolution topography derived by remote sense data, with the aims to test the impacts of designed water storages in saving water and mitigating runoff. The research results not only have theoretical significance, but also provide a more accurate example of the how to design the reliable water resource managements in steep slope agricultural areas under the background of climate change.

    How to cite: Wang, W., Straffelini, E., and Tarolli, P.: Influence of water resource management on runoff trapping under different rainfall events based on remote sense technology in steep-slope agricultural landscapes, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5092, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5092, 2022.

    The worldwide spread of invasive aquatic plants in freshwater environments often leads to serious environmental (including ecological and socio-economic) problems, which requires a deeper knowledge of the extent of infestations (in time and space), and the abundance and propagation rates of aquatic weeds in invaded water systems. In particular, water hyacinth (Eichhornia crassipes) has become a threat to many aquatic environments: by presenting a rapid reproductive capacity; water hyacinth outcompetes other aquatic plant species, forming dense free-floating mats, which in many instances completely cover fresh-water surfaces. The infestation leads to several impacts that are hazardous to aquatic systems, disables human uses of surface waters, and affects hydraulic infrastructures (e.g., waterways, pumping stations). In general, the water hyacinth’s fast growth rate is explained, to a large extent, by eutrophication in water bodies.

    This study explores the use of remote sensing tools to characterize the presence of water hyacinth in a river environment, aiming at new insights into the detection, observation, and mapping of this invasive plant using multispectral based vegetation indices and water indices, such as NDVI and NDWI. The study focuses on a small watercourse located in the downstream part of the Mondego River Valley, in Portugal. Multi-temporal data were acquired by multispectral satellite Sentinel-2; the data spatial resolution is 10 m. Results from this study show that the new generation sensors’ data have the potential to better detect the spatial distribution of invasive plant species and temporal dynamic changes in their incursion level, compared to data collected during (traditional) time costly ground-based surveys. The remote sensing approach provides a baseline to inform planners and decision-makers and a framework for developing water hyacinth management and important eradication strategies.

    How to cite: P. de Lima, I. and Gerardo, R.: Analysis of water hyacinth (Eichhornia crassipes) infestation in a river branch using Sentinel-2 satellite data, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6664, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6664, 2022.

    EGU22-6990 | Presentations | HS6.8

    Application of satellite and reanalysis precipitation for hydrological modeling in data-scarce Porijõgi catchment, Estonia 

    Desalew Meseret Moges, Alexander Kmoch, and Evelyn Uuemaa

    The lack of adequate and reliable gauge observations has long been a major obstacle for hydrological modeling. This study focuses on a comprehensive evaluation of hydrological applicability of satellite and reanalysis-based precipitation products (IMERG, ERA5, PERSIANN-CDR, SM2RASC, and CMORPH-CRT) in Porijõgi catchment, Estonia. The evaluations were carried out in two parts: 1) evaluating the quality of satellite and reanalysis-based precipitation products relative to gauge observations, 2) comparing gauge-simulated streamflow with satellite and reanalysis-based simulations using the SWAT model.  Results show reasonable variation in the detection capability of satellite and reanalysis-based precipitation products with further influence on the streamflow simulations. IMERG, ERA5, and PERSIANN-CDR show better detection capability for the monthly precipitation and demonstrated reliable performance in simulating the monthly streamflow. However, SM2RASC and CMORPH-CRT products have a common tendency to underestimate the gauged precipitation and fail to show satisfactory performance in streamflow simulation. Overall, our findings suggest that satellite and reanalysis-based precipitation products can be a priori alternative sources of precipitation data for hydrological applications in poorly gauged areas. However, along with the efforts to improve satellite and reanalysis-based precipitation products, it is important to develop more effective bias adjustment techniques at a daily scale.    

    How to cite: Moges, D. M., Kmoch, A., and Uuemaa, E.: Application of satellite and reanalysis precipitation for hydrological modeling in data-scarce Porijõgi catchment, Estonia, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6990, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6990, 2022.

    As the built-up areas extend and become denser with time, high-resolution land use and especially imperviousness data is of increasing importance, e.g., for detailed studies on settlement and landscape water retention to provide for extremes such as (flash) floods, heatwaves, and droughts.

    The open-source COPERNICUS imperviousness density dataset covers 2006 until 2018 with a three-year timestep with incremental raster resolution (2018: ten meters). On the other hand, there is an accurate object-oriented cadastre dataset of German authorities called ATKIS. It describes the geometries of buildings and all types of traffic routes from airports to dirt roads with an increasing amount of attributes like shape, area, width, or material. While both datasets are very detailed, they have specific (dis-)advantages due to their very different data and surveying type.

    We used the information stored in the ATKIS database of 2020 to create an alternative object-based imperviousness map of the German state Bavaria with roughly 70,000 km² to contrast and compare it with the COPERNICUS imperviousness density dataset of 2018 in several different (urban and rural) areas. We found that COPERNICUS indicates much higher imperviousness for densely settled areas as city centres and commercial and industrial zones and can describe even complex types of significant extent (such as golf courses, transhipment stations, and allot settlements) better. Vice versa, ATKIS could resolve even linear traffic elements in rural areas and detached house settlements to an outstanding level of detail, which COPERNICUS cannot afford due to its limited resolution. Both products cannot distinguish clearly between sealed concrete and loose stony material (e.g., from construction or mining sites), nor give indications on sub-surface water retention or sewage infrastructure.

    Overall, we can name both methods' (dis-)advantages, relate them to surprisingly distinct land use classes, and give guidance, where additional object-oriented information can significantly improve COPERNICUS imperviousness data. Finally, the resulting maps highlight the hotspots of extreme building-independent imperviousness. They can serve as a tool to prioritize areal and building-centred measures to prevent large amounts of fast runoff.

    How to cite: Mitterer, J. and Disse, M.: Remote sensing versus surveyed object-based cadastre data: Comparing the advantages of COPERNICUS imperviousness density and ATKIS data in Bavaria/Germany using GIS analysis, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7477, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7477, 2022.

    EGU22-7990 | Presentations | HS6.8

    A user friendly web-based solution for crop mapping for different contexts of in-situ data availability 

    Silvan Ragettli, Lorenzo De Simone, William Ouellette, and Tobias Siegfried

    The unprecedented availability of free and open Earth Observations (EO) data and accessibility to free and low-cost cloud computing provide the ideal conditions for implementing scalable solutions for improved agriculture monitoring and agricultural water management that can be used in operational contexts. However, the uptake of EO data in National Statistics Offices is still limited, especially in developing countries. The main reason for this is the common lack in countries of sufficient and high quality of in-situ data which is required to provide ground truth information for the training of the classification algorithms and for validation of crop maps.

    In this context, FAO in partnership with hydrosolutions ltd have developed a user-friendly platform (named EOSTAT CropMapper) for high resolution mapping of crop types at country-scale using earth observations. All processing steps are implemented in Google Earth Engine. The system provides smooth access to crop maps, crop statistics and irrigation water requirements and works in three different contexts of in-situ data availability:

    • Scenario 1: a large and accurate in-situ data is available. The system relies on a traditional Random Forest (RF) classifier.
    • Scenario 2: a limited amount of in-situ data is available. The system relies on the use of a Dynamic Time Warping (DTW) algorithm to classify pixels into crop types based on only a few reference samples per crop type that represent the characteristic phenologies.
    • Scenario 3: no in-situ data is available. The system relies on K-means clustering to map clusters of crop pixels. Subsequently the user is requested to associate each cluster to a crop label based on his expert knowledge.

    In this contribution we present an overview of the methodology, of the functionalities of the tool and the architecture, and we provide results of the mapping workflow and the accuracy measures. The system has been first deployed in Afghanistan, but can be easily transferred to any place where samples of geotagged crop type information are available. Here we present an implementation of the EOSTAT CropMapper for Kashkadarya Region in Uzbekistan and an accuracy assessment of the crop type classification based on a dataset of ground-truth data (Remelgado et al., 2020). The reference ground-truth dataset consists of 2’172 crop type samples collected in the year 2018.

    We demonstrate that the crop classification with DTW based on few carefully checked training samples can outperform conventional RF classification with at least two times more samples. With five times more training samples, RF outperforms DTW in terms of overall accuracy. The main condition for obtaining good results with DTW is a comprehensive quality assurance and quality control of the training data points. While the full ground-truth dataset consists of 2’172 samples, we used only 40-80 samples to train the DTW algorithm. It is understood that the quality assurance and control of such small samples sizes requires less time and is a more cost effective solution. RF is less sensitive to noise in the training data, and a large training data set can compensate the mistakes in the labeling of the ground-truth data.

    How to cite: Ragettli, S., De Simone, L., Ouellette, W., and Siegfried, T.: A user friendly web-based solution for crop mapping for different contexts of in-situ data availability, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7990, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7990, 2022.

    EGU22-10200 | Presentations | HS6.8

    Review of scientific literature on the use of globally available remote sensed data products for distributed hydrological modelling. 

    M. Haris Ali, Ioana Popescu, Andreja Jonoski, and Dimitri Solomatine

    To assess the capability of globally available satellite or remote sensed data products (GASRSDP) for distributed hydrological modelling and expedite their widespread uptake require a comprehensive knowledge-base related to their efficiency, temporal and spatial specifications and extents. Moreover, it is important to assess their performance in setting up hydrological models, their use as forcing data of models or for calibration, validation or evaluation of the model itself, along with an assessment of their limitation.

    Hydrological models are the key tools for sustainable water management decision-making process. In order to capture the spatio-temporal variation in hydrological fluxes, the input data and representation of physical parameters in hydrological models plays an important role in their credibility. Models require rich amounts of data, which is mostly not readily available in data scare regions. The remotely sensed or satellite derived globally available data products are a vast and rich source of data with continuous addition to daily inventory. This data is widely in use for setting up hydrological models, their calibration, validation, evaluation and improvement.

    Each day new data products are being released by different agencies. The scientific community is continuously mentioning the use of these data products in scientific articles. Present article does a systematic literature review of the articles over the last 5 years (2016 to 2021) in order to analyse the use of remote sensed / satellite globally available data products for detailed distributed hydrological modelling so that the progress in this context can be ascertain and future directions can be established. The review process was started by sourcing 179 articles from Scopus and 206 articles from Web of Science. After excluding the common and out of scope articles, the full analysis has been performed on about 100 articles. We conclude that the use of GASRSDP for the hydrological modelling of macro-scaled catchments has extensively explored and their performance is being evaluated by many authors while their worth for setting up physically based distributed hydrological model for catchment at meso-scale still need exploration, evaluation and assessments.

    How to cite: Ali, M. H., Popescu, I., Jonoski, A., and Solomatine, D.: Review of scientific literature on the use of globally available remote sensed data products for distributed hydrological modelling., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10200, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10200, 2022.

    EGU22-10297 | Presentations | HS6.8

    Field level crop performance, farmer pressures and challenges in a large irrigation scheme 

    Brian Carthy, Jeroen Degerickx, Ben Somers, Guido Wyseure, and Eleazar Rufasto

    Irrigation is the largest consumer of freshwater and irrigated lands contribute a significant proportion of total food production. These statements are often accompanied by figures illustrating inefficient water use in agriculture. Policy decisions concerning water in agriculture tend to reference efficiency as the principal metric assessing performance. We see this reflected in documents such as the United Nations Social Development Goal 6 target 4 which aims to “substantially increase water-use efficiency across all sectors”. Optimising the output from a limited resource is necessary, however, the true measure of irrigation efficiency has been widely debated, creating different approaches and interpretations. The typical avenue is techno-centric and can lead to an offhand dismissal of so-called ‘old’ lower-technology irrigation systems as wasteful and inefficient. Irrigation efficiency has become a powerful tool both in political discourse as well as marketing campaigns for irrigation equipment.

    A majority of farms are family-run enterprises and do not have at their disposal the capital and expertise of large agro-industrial companies. Challenges they face at field level may not be overcome by upgrading traditional irrigation methods with higher technology systems. The complexity of large irrigation schemes as hydrosocial systems cannot be overstated and compound the challenges individual farmers may be experiencing, such as problems related to their position in a scheme or along the supply network. The head-end/tail-end effect is one situation where farmers further from the head-end of water supply find a disadvantage compared to their head-end neighbours.

    This work aims to follow recent research in irrigation efficiency which encourages employing a wider ranging and more comprehensive framework of indicators of irrigation performance, looking beyond the purely technical irrigation efficiency perspective and across scales. Working toward this, field level crop performance knowledge gaps were addressed. Using a set of phenology, crop stress and biomass productivity indicators derived from high-resolution optical and thermal satellite imagery, we were able to reveal important spatial patterns among farmers’ fields which may be linked to the performance of the irrigation scheme.

    The study looks at the arid Northern Peruvian coast where the 110,000 ha Chancay-Lambayeque Irrigation System is supplied by water from the Andes. A substantial reservoir buffers discharge in the Chancay river on which an offtake supplies a 65 km main canal with an initial construction over 1000 years ago. The scheme is owned and operated by several Water Users’ Associations and small farmers share the supply with agro-industrial enterprises upstream. In this climate of almost negligible precipitation, crop stress and seasonal biomass production may be good performance indicators for irrigation. The resolutions are 30 m for crop stress using Landsat-8 surface temperature data and 20 m for biomass productivity using Sentinel-2 derived fAPAR. A spatial pattern analysis alongside the irrigation canal network was based on these indicators aiming to elucidate how a farmer may be affected by their location relative to the supply network, the crop type grown on their own or a (upstream/downstream) neighbour’s field and the condition of supply (abundance/scarcity).  

    How to cite: Carthy, B., Degerickx, J., Somers, B., Wyseure, G., and Rufasto, E.: Field level crop performance, farmer pressures and challenges in a large irrigation scheme, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10297, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10297, 2022.

    EGU22-12908 | Presentations | HS6.8

    Estimating the productivity of boreholes in fractured crystalline basement using lineaments extracted from remote sensing data 

    Tagne Dzukam Brice, Thomas Hermans, Gouet Daniel Hervé, Ndougsa Mbarga Theophile, and Njueya kopa Adoua

    Crystalline basement formations are originally without any hydrogeological potential  due to the poor primary porosity of rocks that they content. Therefore, finding productive zones of groundwater in those area becomes possible by a better knowledge of fracturing. The mapping of linear features on remotely sensed data is one of the keys to understand groundwater occurrence, in those area. For that purpose, The extraction of lineaments is a preliminary step in the selection of favorable sites for exploration of basement aquifers. The purpose of this work is to study the hydraulic role of the major lineaments of the Mayo-Banyo department (Adamawa Region, Cameroon) in the productivity of the boreholes through the analysis of the correlation between the productivity parameters of the high flow boreholes and the proximity to the major lineaments associated with other productivity index parameters such as topography, drilling depth, proximity to the nearest fracture node, lineament density and alteration thickness, and to suggest favorable areas for future hydraulic surveys. The application of the Canny filter and the shaded relief respectively on the Landsat 8 and SRTM image of the study area shows after statistical analysis a good correlation between the two methods in view of the obtained directional rosettes for lineaments. The main directions of the extracted lineaments are N-S, NNE-SSW and NNW-SSE. The NNE-SSW direction as indicated by several structural studies carried out in the region corresponds to the orientation of the D1 phase of tangential tectonics that the region underwent. The correlation analysis between the productivity of high flow boreholes (Q> 5 m3/h) and the proximity to major lineaments (L> 5km) of the NNE-SSW directional class shows a positive and relatively significant correlation (0.41). This result shows that the productivity of the boreholes in the department is influenced by the proximity to the main fracture directions. In addition, the analyses also show a combined effect of lineament density, topography (slope), borehole depth and alteration thickness on the productivity of high flow boreholes. The northeast and west of the study area have a greater density of lineaments. These areas would have been affected by greater structural deformation and therefore may have a higher potential for groundwater infiltration due to a greater density of lineaments that serve as weaving. Therefore, more local analysis with geophysical data in those areas should help to better locate future wells. 
    Keywords: lineaments, basement aquifers, Mayo-Banyo.

    How to cite: Brice, T. D., Hermans, T., Daniel Hervé, G., Theophile, N. M., and Adoua, N. K.: Estimating the productivity of boreholes in fractured crystalline basement using lineaments extracted from remote sensing data, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12908, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12908, 2022.

    EGU22-13425 | Presentations | HS6.8

    Co-designing climate services for drought management in the Guadalquivir River Basin 

    Lluís Pesquer, Cristina Domingo-Marimon, Annelies Broekman, Lucia De Stefano, and Miquel Ninyerola

    Water availability is a limiting factor for many human activities and for the maintenance of ecosystems. Monitoring of water resources, as well as the impacts of water scarcity on human activities and natural ecosystems, is key for building adequate water management strategies. With this aim, different European and Worldwide organisations provide several datasets and services. However, do these services fit to the user needs and requirements?

    This work focusses on the refinement of existing drought indexes for fitting users’ needs. We review the specifications and characteristics of drought related databases obtained from Copernicus, such as the European Drought Observatory (EDO) and the Global Drought Observatory (GDO) at Copernicus Emergency Management Service, tools produced by the United Nations - UNCCD Drought Toolbox- and other datasets provided by research centres such as CSIC or the Global SPEI database.

    Climate services are obtained by tailoring the datasets to the needs and recommendations expressed by selected stakeholders representing different relevant sectors: agriculture, livestock, forestry, biodiversity, etc. and different professional profiles: decisions makers on water management strategies, managers of protected areas, farmers, etc. Thanks to innovative settings, such as living lab frameworks, stakeholders are enabled to co-design the new drought services proposed, as well as helping to improve the indexes through sharing the evaluation of their usability and impact when implemented in real-life decision taking processes.

    The new drought related information products and services obtained through co-production, contribute to improve

    • the spatial resolution requirements of the involved climate variables (mainly temperature and precipitation) by remote sensing products (i.e. land surface temperature, vegetation indexes, etc.)  through downscaling techniques of the existing drought databases
    • the coherence between these derived remote sensing products and the existing in-situ observations
    • the usability of climate services for decision making

    The living lab framework underpinning this study is located in the Guadalquivir River Basin, in the northern part of the region of Andalusia, Spain, particularly vulnerable to drought impacts. Results will help improving mitigation and adaptation measures to reduce the vulnerability to different drought scenarios forecasted for the upper and middle parts of the Basin.

    How to cite: Pesquer, L., Domingo-Marimon, C., Broekman, A., De Stefano, L., and Ninyerola, M.: Co-designing climate services for drought management in the Guadalquivir River Basin, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13425, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13425, 2022.

    EGU22-13462 | Presentations | HS6.8

    Use of Remote Sensed Products for Large-scale SWAT+ Model Calibration 

    Wim Thiery, Celray James Chawanda, Jeffrey Arnold, and Ann van Griensven

    Calibration of large-scale models comes with several challenges. Among these challenges are the availability of observation data and the computational cost of running the calibration. As such, some large-scale models are not calibrated. Yet calibration of impact models is crucial, as Krysanova et al. (2018) concluded. A calibration strategy focusing on hydrological mass balance can reduce calibration computational costs and improve the model application while global remote sensed products provide data for large-scale applications. This study presents the Hydrological Mass Balance Calibration (HMBC) methodology for SWAT+. We test the method using a remotely sensed ET product (WaPOR). We also use flow data from the Global Runoff Data Centre (GRDC) and compare projections made by the HMBC model and those without. We then apply the HMBC to a SWAT+ model for Africa. Results show that HMBC leads to improved simulation of discharge and evapotranspiration with fewer iterations than a full parameter calibration. Substantial spatial differences are also observed in projections made by the HMBC model compared to the uncalibrated model. Thus, it makes a difference if we apply HMBC. In addition, HMBC used with remotely sensed data can remedy some barriers to the calibration of hydrological models applied at large scales, as demonstrated by application to the Africa SWAT+ model.

    How to cite: Thiery, W., Chawanda, C. J., Arnold, J., and van Griensven, A.: Use of Remote Sensed Products for Large-scale SWAT+ Model Calibration, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13462, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13462, 2022.

    EGU22-1622 | Presentations | HS6.9

    Representing South Indian water tanks in a hydrologic model using remote sensing data 

    Nariman Mahmoodi, Paul Wagner, Chaogui Lei, Balaji Narasimhan, Daniel Rosado, and Nicola Fohrer

    Water tanks in South India have undeniable impacts on the natural hydrological regime of rivers by storing water during the monsoon season and releasing it for irrigation purposes during the dry season. As data on water tanks is limited, they are often not considered in hydrological modeling, which could reduce model performance. Therefore, this study aims at representing water tanks in the hydrologic model SWAT+ and evaluating their impacts on the model performance for a catchment model of the upper Adyar River catchment in South India. To obtain data on the spatio-temporal variations in water storage of the tanks for the years 2015-2018 a random forest classification of water areas is carried out using Sentinel-2 satellite data. Two model setups are evaluated, one with and another one without water tanks. A multi-metric approach including the Kling–Gupta efficiency (KGE), the Nash-Sutcliffe efficiency (NSE), and the ratio of the root mean square error to the standard deviation (RSR) was applied to calibrate and validate the hydrologic model for the time periods 2012-2018 and 2004-2011 respectively. The water tanks are considered as reservoirs in the hydrologic model and the required data such as the location, the surface area, and the volume of reservoirs are extracted from the satellite data. Our results show that implementing water tanks in the SWAT+ model leads to a better representation of the monthly streamflow by having an effect on the peak flows of the wet season. A higher goodness of fit is achieved for the validation period with KGE = 0.67, NSE = 0.76, and RSR = 0.62 in comparison to the calibration period where KGE and NSE are 0.56 and 0.61, respectively. The agreement between simulated and observed streamflow is the highest for the period 2015-2018 (KGE = 0.76, NSE = 0.81 and RSR = 0.43). Therefore, it can be concluded that implementing water tanks in a hydrologic model enhances the performance of the model.

    How to cite: Mahmoodi, N., Wagner, P., Lei, C., Narasimhan, B., Rosado, D., and Fohrer, N.: Representing South Indian water tanks in a hydrologic model using remote sensing data, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1622, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1622, 2022.

    Soil moisture (SM) measurements over large areas are vital for many operational applications such as flood forecasting, irrigation scheduling, and drought monitoring. Although obtaining SM over extensive areas was difficult until recently, the advent of satellite remote sensing technologies such as passive microwave satellites (e.g., SMOS and SMAP) opened a new way. Nevertheless, the utilization of SM products of these satellites is often impeded because of their coarse spatial resolution (i.e., about 40 km). A number of studies have been attempted to improve the coarse resolution satellite SM products via downscaling. However, despite of many downscaling efforts, subsequent use of downscaled satellite SM products for operational applications has not yet been fully explored. Thus, the objective of this study is to evaluate the value of SMAP SM in enhancing short-term streamflow forecast skills. The random forest machine learning technique was used to downscaled SMAP SM from 36 km to a range of resolutions from 1 to 9 km (i.e., 9, 3, and 1 km). Thereafter, a host of experiments were carried out to update a physically-based distributed hydrological model through direct ingestion of the original SMAP SM (e.g., 36 km), SMAP enhanced SM (i.e., 9 km), and downscaled SMAP SM at different spatial resolutions (e.g., 9, 3 and 1 km). A non-updated model was used as a benchmark for comparison. The result shows that the downscaled SMAP SM has presented better spatial detail than its corresponding native resolution and updating the model state with SMAP SM products (i.e., with the native and downscaled products) shows promising potential for improving short term flood forecasting. Finally, this will in turn helps in better water resources management.

    How to cite: Wakigari, S. A. and Leconte, R.: Evaluation of the value of spatially improved SMAP soil moisture products in enhancing streamflow forecast skills, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3318, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3318, 2022.

    Precipitation is a key component of the water cycle and an important forcing data for hydrological simulations and forecasts  and other applications. Having high quality data of precipitation at the watershed scale is challenging. Many methods are used to estimate precipitation such as rain gauges, remote sensing, and reanalysis. Among these, rain gauge provides the most accurate estimate of precipitation, but its scarcely available in remote areas. This in turn badly affects hydrological studies and operational applications. However, the advent of remote sensing offers an opportunity to estimate precipitation in remote areas. The main objective of this study is to evaluate the reliability and the usefulness  satellite precipitation products for hydrological modelling and forecasting. The study was carried out on 7 contrasting catchments located in Eastern Canada. Five gridded daily satellite precipitation products (SPP) including CMORPH, PERSIANN-CDR, CHIRPS, TMPA and GPM were first compared against ERA-5 daily precipitation product used as reference over the 2001-2015 period. Each precipitation product was then used to calibrate a lumped and a semi-distributed version of the GR4J model. Temperature data required by the hydrological models was from ERA-5. Calibration covered a 10-year period (2001-2010), while validation was on a 5-year period (2011-2015). Four scenarios were considered. First, both GR4J models were calibrated using ERA5 and satellites products separately as inputs. Second, SPP were used during the summer period and ERA5 precipitation was used for the remaining seasons separately as input to calibrate the lumped model. Third, the lumped GR4J model was calibrated only during summer seasons using precipitation of each SPP as forcing data. Lastly, the mean of SPP products was used as forcing data to calibrate lumped GR4J model for the first scenario. Evaluation of the reliability of the SPP demonstrate that the GPM product shows highest correlation for daily precipitation compared to reference data (ERA5) with a correlation coefficient of 0.73 for Androscoggin watershed for duration of 2001 to 2015.Moreover, the results depict that all SPP tend to underestimate daily precipitation compared to reference data. Preliminary results also show that the lumped and the semi-distributed two versions of GR4J give comparable results for the first scenario, with NSE values ranging between 0.480 and 0.86 for calibration and 0.357 and 0.86 for validation, respectively. This is followed by the last (0.586 < NSE < 0.809), second (0.0.470 < NSE < 0.85) and the third scenario(0.249<NSE< 0.809) during calibration for the lumped model. Similarly, the NSE values ranging from 0.50 to 0.77 ,0.59 to 0.81 and 0.293 to 0.68 for the last, second and the third scenario for validation respectively. In addition, the third scenario illustrates that CMORPH product performs well in the summer period whereas all the other SPP outperform CMORPH during the spring and winter seasons. In conclusion, merging the 3 SPP contribute to the improvement of the performance of GR4J lumped model. The next step will be to implement short-term forecasting experiments for a subset of the catchments that were already calibrated and validated with the five SPP.

    How to cite: Kouki, S. and Leconte, R.: Evaluation of reliability and the added value of satellite precipitation products in hydrological modelling calibration and forecasting in remote areas of northern Canada, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6091, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6091, 2022.

    EGU22-6116 | Presentations | HS6.9

    Improving the realism of distributed hydrological models in mountainous catchments using remotely sensed observations 

    Nicolás Vásquez, Pablo A. Mendoza, and Nicolas Cortés

    Over the past decades, remote sensing products have contributed with additional information on various components of the water cycle, especially in sparsely monitored areas. Although the inclusion of spatial patterns derived from satellite products can improve the performance of distributed hydrological models, simulating streamflow at interior points remains a challenge. In this study, we characterize the added value of incorporating remotely sensed soil moisture, fractional snow covered area, evapotranspiration and land surface temperature in the calibration of a distributed hydrological model. To this end, we configure the variable infiltration capacity (VIC) model at a 5-km horizontal resolution in two catchments located in Central and Southern Chile, and conduct calibration experiments with only streamflow data, and combining streamflow with remotely sensed spatial patterns. Specifically, we examine: (i) the effects at interior “ungauged” points, (ii) the benefits of adding gauging points in the calibration process, and (iii) the benefits of including additional variables. Previous results show that including spatial patterns in the calibrations allows a better representation of interior ungauged points, similar to including more streamflow gauges at interior locations.

    How to cite: Vásquez, N., Mendoza, P. A., and Cortés, N.: Improving the realism of distributed hydrological models in mountainous catchments using remotely sensed observations, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6116, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6116, 2022.

    EGU22-9642 | Presentations | HS6.9

    Assimilation of Sentinel-1 backscatter into a land surface model for soil moisture and leaf area index updating: Impact on streamflow simulations 

    Michel Bechtold, Sara Modanesi, Hans Lievens, Isis Brangers, Augusto Getirana, Alexander Gruber, Christian Massari, and Gabrielle De Lannoy

    Streamflow forecasts suffer from errors in the initial conditions of the catchment-scale soil moisture distribution. In this research, we evaluate the potential of improving streamflow simulations through the assimilation of Sentinel-1 backscatter data into a land surface model. Our modeling setup consists of the Noah-MP land surface model coupled to the HYMAP river routing model and the 'Water Cloud Model' (WCM), which acts as backscatter observation operator, integrated into the NASA Land Information System. The system was set up at 1 km resolution for two contrasting catchments in Belgium: i) the Demer catchment dominated by agriculture and low topographic gradients, and ii) the Ourthe catchment dominated by mixed forests and high topographic gradients. Surface soil moisture and leaf area index (LAI) dynamically simulated by Noah-MP in an open-loop run were used to calibrate the parameters of the WCM using a Bayesian objective function and Sentinel-1 backscatter data processed to 1 km spatial resolution for the period 2015-2021. We present results of a suite of data assimilation experiments obtained from an ensemble Kalman filter that updates both soil moisture and LAI. We tested the use of (i) WCM parameters that were calibrated using backscatter data from all Sentinel-1 orbits simultaneously or using data from each Sentinel-1 orbit separately, (ii) backscatter observations with or without seasonal bias correction, (iii) backscatter observations in VV and VH polarization separately or combined. The different data assimilation experiments are evaluated with leaf area index from optical remote sensing, microwave-based soil moisture retrievals and streamflow measurements.

    Preliminary results indicate substantial differences between the different data assimilation experiments. For the Ourthe catchment, streamflow skill improvement was highest when simultaneously assimilating VV and VH observations without bias correction but using orbit-specific WCM parameters. For soil moisture and LAI, however, the highest skill was obtained by assimilating only VV observations. For the Demer catchment, assimilating observations without seasonal bias correction led to a skill degradation for streamflow while the impact of data assimilation was neutral when applying rescaled observations. Over this agriculturally dominated area, evaluation with soil moisture and LAI generally indicated the highest degradation. Difficulties in the Demer catchment might be related to crop rotation practices typical for the region that causes an interannual variability in backscatter dynamics not well accounted for by a static set of WCM parameters.

    How to cite: Bechtold, M., Modanesi, S., Lievens, H., Brangers, I., Getirana, A., Gruber, A., Massari, C., and De Lannoy, G.: Assimilation of Sentinel-1 backscatter into a land surface model for soil moisture and leaf area index updating: Impact on streamflow simulations, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9642, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9642, 2022.

    Precipitation with high spatio-temporal resolution is one of the critical components of meteorological forcing for hydrological modeling. Its accurate measurement required a large number of rain gauges that are limited for many regions, especially highly elevated domains with a complex and mountainous topography, such as the eastern part of Turkey. On the other hand, open access Gridded Precipitation Datasets (GPDs) varying in spatial and temporal resolutions deliver alternative sources in data-scarce regions. However, their hydrological utilities are to be assessed in different basins to make adequate knowledge for both the developers and end-users. Hence, this study was carried out to investigate the spatio-temporal stability and hydrological utility of four GPDs (MSWEPv2.8, CHIRPSv2.0, ERA5, and IMERGHHFv06) over the upper Euphrates (Karasu) River Basin in the eastern part of Turkey. The accuracy of selected GPDs compared to observed precipitation is expressed in the form of Kling–Gupta Efficiency (KGE), while Hanssen–Kuiper (HK) skill score was utilized to address the detectability strength of GPDs for five different precipitation intensities. Moreover, the hydrological utility of GPDs is evaluated by employing a conceptual hydrologic model under KGE and Nash–Sutcliffe Efficiency (NSE) statistical metrics. Overall, MSWEPv2.8 shows the highest performance (median KGE of 0.34) for the direct comparison with observed precipitation followed by CHIRPSv2.0 (median KGE of 0.34) and ERA5 (median KGE of 0.08) where IMERGHHFv06 shows low performance (median KGE of 0.02) comparatively. Furthermore, CHIRPSv2.0 shows a stable performance for streamflow prediction compared to other Gridded precipitation datasets for the entire period (2015 – 2019), considering two different scenarios. These findings provide guidance for selecting appropriate GPD for the particular region of interest.

    How to cite: Hafizi, H. and Sorman, A. A.: Evaluating the hydrological utility of four gridded precipitation datasets for streamflow prediction in a mountainous basin, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12151, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12151, 2022.

    EGU22-672 | Presentations | HS6.10

    Impacts of atmospheric transport and biomass burning on the inter-annual variation in black carbon aerosols over the Tibetan Plateau 

    Han Han, Yue Wu, Jane Liu, Tianliang Zhao, Bingliang Zhuang, Honglei Wang, Yichen Li, Huimin Chen, Ye Zhu, Hongnian Liu, Qin'geng Wang, Shu Li, Tijian Wang, Min Xie, and Mengmeng Li

    Atmospheric black carbon (BC) in the Tibetan Plateau (TP) can largely impact regional and global climate. Applying a backward-trajectory method that combines BC concentrations from a global chemical transport model, GEOS-Chem, and trajectories from the Hybrid Single-Particle Lagrangian Integrated Trajectory (HYSPLIT) model, we assess the contributions of worldwide source regions to surface BC in the TP. We estimate that on a 20-year average (1995-2014), 77% of surface BC in the TP comes from South Asia (43%) and East Asia (35%). In terms of the amount of BC imported, South Asia and East Asia are dominant source regions in winter and summer, respectively. However, in terms of affected areas in the TP, South Asia is the dominant contributor throughout the year. Inter-annually, surface BC over the TP is largely modulated by atmospheric transport of BC from non-local regions year-round and by biomass burning in South Asia, mostly in spring. We find that the extremely strong biomass burning in South Asia in the spring of 1999 greatly enhanced surface BC concentrations in the TP (31% relative to the climatology). The strength of the Asian monsoon correlates significantly with the inter-annual variation in the amount of BC transported to the TP from non-local regions. In summer, a stronger East Asian summer monsoon and a South Asian summer monsoon tend to, respectively, lead to more BC transport from central China and north-eastern South Asia to the TP. In winter, BC transport from central China is enhanced in years with a strong East Asian winter monsoon or a Siberian High.

    How to cite: Han, H., Wu, Y., Liu, J., Zhao, T., Zhuang, B., Wang, H., Li, Y., Chen, H., Zhu, Y., Liu, H., Wang, Q., Li, S., Wang, T., Xie, M., and Li, M.: Impacts of atmospheric transport and biomass burning on the inter-annual variation in black carbon aerosols over the Tibetan Plateau, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-672, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-672, 2022.

    EGU22-1028 | Presentations | HS6.10

    Study on the Land-Atmosphere Interaction in the Coordination Effect of Westerly Wind and Monsoon 

    Maoshan Li, Wei Fu, Ming Gong, Na Chang, Yaoming Ma, Zeyong Hu, Fanglin Sun, and Yaoxian Yang

    By using sounding data from Mount. Everest, Nyingchi, Nam Co, Nagqu and Shiquan River sites and ERA5 reanalysis data in 2104 and 2019. The characteristics of the temporal and spatial changes of the atmospheric boundary layer structure and its relationship with sensible heat, latent heat flux, and vertical velocity field, in order to deeply understand the different characteristics of the plateau atmospheric boundary layer structure under the coordinated action of westerly and monsoon and its change mechanism. The main findings of this study are as follows:

    (1)     The height of the convective boundary layer at each station under the westerly south branch wind field is higher than that under the summer monsoon wind field. The hight of convective boundary layers of Mount Everest, Nyingchi, Nam Co, Nagqu and Shiquan River under the westerly south branch wind field are 4500m, 3000m, 2400m, 2760m and 3500m. In the plateau monsoon field, the hight convective boundary layers are 3000 m, 2100 m, 2200 m, 1650 m and 2000 m.

    (2)     The specific humidity of the lower atmospheric boundary layer at each station under the westerly south branch wind field is smaller than that of the lower atmospheric boundary layer under the plateau monsoon wind field. The specific humidity of the near-surface layer in Linzhi area is obviously larger than that of the other four areas, and its maximum specific humidity is 12.88 g.kg-1. The lower layers of Mount Everest are often affected by the northerly valley wind at 14 o'clock and the glacier wind with southerly wind at 20 o'clock.

    (3)     The boundary layer has strong atmospheric turbulence and strong convection, which makes the boundary layer high. However, the latent heat flux at each station under the plateau summer monsoon wind field is large, and the moisture content in the air is large, which inhibits the development of the boundary layer.

    (4)     Convection in the boundary layer at each site is active during the day, with ascending and sinking movements alternately occurring. There was a strong sinking motion at Nyingchi Station at 14:00 on May 16th and October 25th, 2019, and at the same time, there was inverse humidity at the lower level. The vertical velocity in the atmospheric boundary layer of Nyingchi area is basically sinking. This may be one of the reasons that the height of the convective boundary layer in the Nyingchi area is lower than that of other stations, and it is also one of the reasons why inverse humidity often occurs in Nyingchi.

    Key words: the Tibetan plateau, South branch of westerly, Plateau monsoon, Atmospheric boundary layer

    How to cite: Li, M., Fu, W., Gong, M., Chang, N., Ma, Y., Hu, Z., Sun, F., and Yang, Y.: Study on the Land-Atmosphere Interaction in the Coordination Effect of Westerly Wind and Monsoon, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1028, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1028, 2022.

    The exchange of heat and water vapor between land surface and atmosphere over the Third Pole region (Tibetan Plateau and nearby surrounding region) plays an important role in Asian monsoon, westerlies and the northern hemisphere weather and climate systems. Supported by various agencies in the People’s Republic of China, a Third Pole Environment (TPE) Integrated Three-dimensional Observation and research Platform (TPEITORP) is now implementing over the Third Pole region. The background of the establishment of the TPEITORP, the establishing and monitoring plan of long-term scale (5-10 years) of it will be shown firstly. Then the preliminary observational analysis results, such as the characteristics of land surface energy fluxes partitioning and the turbulent characteristics will also been shown in this study. Then, the parameterization methodology based on satellite data and the atmospheric boundary layer (ABL) observations has been proposed and tested for deriving regional distribution of net radiation flux, soil heat flux, sensible heat flux, latent heat flux and evapotranspiration (ET)and their variation trends over the heterogeneous landscape of the Tibetan Plateau (TP) area. To validate the proposed methodology, the ground measured net radiation flux, soil heat flux, sensible heat flux, latent heat flux and ET of the TPEORP are compared to the derived values. The results showed that the derived land surface heat fluxes over the study areas are in good accordance with the land surface status. These parameters show a wide range due to the strong contrast of surface feature. And the estimated land surface heat fluxes are in good agreement with ground measurements, and all the absolute percent difference in less than 10% in the validation sites. It is therefore conclude that the proposed methodology is successful for the retrieval of land surface heat fluxes and ET over heterogeneous landscape of the TP area. Further improvement of the methodology and its applying field over the whole Third Pole region and Pan-Third Pole region were also discussed.

    How to cite: Ma, Y.: Land-atmospheric interactions over heterogeneous landscapes of the Third Pole Region, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1059, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1059, 2022.

    EGU22-1135 | Presentations | HS6.10

    Spatial variation of runoff depth and sediment yield in relation to dominant Factors on the Tibetan Plateau 

    Fan Zhang, Chen Zeng, Guanxing Wang, Li Wang, and Xiaonan Shi

    The riverine runoff and sediment are essential carriers for nutrients and pollutants delivery and are considered as important indicators of land degradation and environmental changes. With growing interest in environmental changes over the Tibetan Plateau, this study investigated mean annual runoff depth and sediment yield from eight headwater catchments in relation to dominant factors such as annual precipitation, air temperature, and glacier area ratio, etc. Results show that runoff depth (Q) is positively correlated with both precipitation (P) and temperature (T), indicating combined water supply from rainfall and meltwater, increase of which may exceed the evapotranspiration water loss caused by temperature raise. Sediment yield (S) shows an inverted parabolic relationship with precipitation and at the same time positive correlation with glacier area ratio (Ag). The variation in sediment yield with precipitation can be explained by the operation of two factors, i.e., rainfall erosive action that increases continuously with increase in precipitation, and vegetation protective action that is unity for zero precipitation and decreases with increases in precipitation. 

    How to cite: Zhang, F., Zeng, C., Wang, G., Wang, L., and Shi, X.: Spatial variation of runoff depth and sediment yield in relation to dominant Factors on the Tibetan Plateau, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1135, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1135, 2022.

    Using data from cloud radar, ground observations and ERA5 reanalysis data, factors influencing nighttime precipitation during summer in the Yushu area of the Tibetan Plateau (TP) are investigated. The cloud top height (CTH), cloud base height (CBH) and liquid water content (LWC) are compared between the non-precipitating days and precipitating days. The results show that the average CTH during precipitating days over Yushu is below 10 km above ground level (hereafter AGL) in the daytime, while it is more than 10 km AGL at night with the maximum at 23 Beijing Standard Time (BST, = Coordinated Universal Time + 8 hour). The CBH is in phase with the dew-point spread. The precipitation intensity and CTH is in phase with the LWC. The hourly averaged precipitation intensity and convective available potential energy (CAPE) in ERA5 reach the maximum at 21 BST, which is 3 hours ahead of the observations. There is downward motion flow at noon during non-precipitating days, while there is upward motion flow at night during the precipitating days. In addition, the horizontal wind direction in the lower level (below 5000 m) shows clockwise rotation from morning to night. Wind shear occurs in the middle level of the atmosphere, is accompanied by subtropical westerly jet in the upper level. The difference of horizontal wind speed between the level of 200 hPa and 500 hPa is positively related to the LWC, making contribution to the formation of upper-level clouds

    How to cite: Cao, B.: Factors Influencing Diurnal Variation Of Cloud And Precipitation In the Yushu Area, Tibetan Plateau, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1272, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1272, 2022.

    In this paper, three parameterization schemes, one considering gravel influence (test1), one considering organic carbon influence (test2) and one comprehensively considering gravel and organic carbon influence (test3), were set up to modify different typical underlying surfaces of the Tibetan Plateau (TP). In addition, their soil thermal properties and hydraulic property variations were discussed. Additionally, discussing the key thermal and hydraulic parameters affected the performance of different schemes from the perspective of observation data in the TP to improve the simulation ability of soil temperature and soil moisture in the plateau areas. Compared the original Community Land Model (CLM) scheme, test1 resulted in higher soil temperature and lower soil moisture, while test2 had lower soil temperature and higher soil moisture. The key thermal and hydraulic parameters are the changes in the saturated thermal conductivity and the thermal conductivity of dry soil and the variations of the porosity and exponent B, respectively. The test3 scheme was the same as test2 for the modified changes of thermal properties, except that the proportion of change was slightly different. In terms of soil thermal properties, test2 and test3 were better at 0-20 cm depth, while test1 and test3 were better for the deeper (40 cm) simulation. Regarding hydraulic properties, the test1 and test3 schemes performed better on the Gobi and alpine meadows at 20-40 cm depth, while the original CLM scheme and test2 performed better on the underlying grassland surface. Test3 was better at balancing the relationship between the thermal and hydraulic parameters and could be used for the further research on the entire plateau area.

    How to cite: Yuan, Y.: Modification and comparison of thermal and hydrological parameterization schemes for different underlying surfaces on the Tibetan Plateau in the warm season, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1291, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1291, 2022.

    EGU22-1421 | Presentations | HS6.10

    Significantly increased evapotranspiration reveals accelerated water cycle on the Tibetan Plateau during 1982–2018 

    Ling Yuan, Xuelong Chen, Yaoming Ma, Deliang Chen, Zhongbo Su, Dianbin Cao, Binbin Wang, Cunbo Han, Weiqiang Ma, and Massimo Menenti

    Precipitation studies suggest an accelerated water cycle over the Tibetan Plateau (TP) in recent decades. However, the exact changes to evapotranspiration (ETa) over this period remain largely unknown. Multiple ETa products for the TP region report that ETa experienced a significant increasing trend of around 8.4 ± 2.2 mm/10 a during 1982–2018. Here, we quantified and explained the ETa trend using a comprehensive process-based ETa model refined on ground-based observations over the TP. Attribution analysis revealed that a large part of the increasing ETa trend was caused by higher temperature (53.8%) and more soil moisture (23.1%) caused by the melting cryosphere and increased precipitation. The increasing rate of ETa on the TP was approximately twice that of the global ETa, providing strong and independent evidence for an accelerated hydrological cycle. The dominant role of increased temperature in ETa implies a continued acceleration of the water cycle in the future.

    How to cite: Yuan, L., Chen, X., Ma, Y., Chen, D., Su, Z., Cao, D., Wang, B., Han, C., Ma, W., and Menenti, M.: Significantly increased evapotranspiration reveals accelerated water cycle on the Tibetan Plateau during 1982–2018, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1421, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1421, 2022.

    By integrating data from 25 flux observation sites in the alpine grasslands of the Tibetan Plateau with corresponding remote sensing and reanalysis data, a data-driven Extremely Randomized Trees regression (ETR) was used to estimate the NEE of alpine grasslands on the Tibetan Plateau from 1982-2018. The spatial and temporal variation patterns of the NEE were also analyzed. The results show that the annual mean NEE of alpine meadows on the Tibetan Plateau from 1982 to 2018 was -35.59 g C m-2 yr-1, and showed a significant decreasing trend at -0.78 g C m-2 yr-1; on the spatial scale, the alpine meadows in the relatively wet eastern and northeastern parts of the Tibetan Plateau were strong carbon sinks with the intensity around -150 ~ -100 g C m-2 yr-1. From the alpine meadows in the east to the semi-arid or arid alpine grasslands in the west and north, the carbon sink intensity gradually decreased along the longitudinal gradient and becomes a weak carbon sink or a weak carbon source (0 ~ ± 20 g C m-2 yr-1). The sensitivity analysis showed that precipitation and mean temperature contributed significantly to the interannual trend variation of NEE in grasslands on the Tibetan Plateau during the 1982-2018. The contribution of precipitation was large in the alpine steppe region in the western and northwestern part of the plateau, while the contribution of mean temperature was highest in the alpine meadow region in the east and south, where precipitation dominated 84% of the interannual NEE variation of the entire alpine steppe region, while mean temperature accounts for 55% of that of the alpine meadow region. In general, the interannual variability of NEE in the alpine steppe region tended to be dominated by precipitation, while the alpine meadow region tended to be regulated by temperature. In addition, the NEE of alpine meadow region showed a significant decreasing trend with -0.91 and -0.67 g C m-2 yr-1 during 1982-1999 and 2000-2018, respectively, while the alpine steppe region showed a non-significant decreasing trend change with -0.37 and -0.19 g C m-2 yr-1, respectively. The different changes of NEE in different vegetation type regions at different time periods were mainly caused by the changes of temperature and precipitation.

    How to cite: Wang, Y. and Ma, Y.: Spatio-temporal patterns of NEE based on upscaling eddy covariance measurements in the alpine grassland of the Tibetan Plateau, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1440, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1440, 2022.

    EGU22-1462 | Presentations | HS6.10

    Dynamic effects of the Tibetan Plateau on the sustained drought in southwest China 

    Yiwei Ye and Rongxiang Tian

    A continuous drought event happened in Southwest China from the winter of 2009 to the spring of 2014, which has a wide range of impacts and a long duration, causing great economic losses to southwest China.  This research focuses on the dynamic field anomalies of the Tibetan Plateau during this event using statistical analysis methods. Moreover, a further conclusion is drawn about the mechanism of the dynamic effect of the Tibetan Plateau on drought in Southwest China. And a regression model is given. Here we show that, the absolute values of relative divergence, relative vorticity and vertical velocity of the lower layer over the Tibetan Plateau were abnormally low during the winter half year from 2009 to 2014, that is, the downdraft and anticyclone over the Tibetan Plateau were weaker than usual. It would weaken the southward cold airflow from the north of the Tibetan Plateau, while the westerly wind from dry central Asia would intensify on the south of the plateau. As a result, the intersection position of the cold and warm air shifted to north and to east, so that a larger area of the southwest China was controlled by the warm and dry air mass, which was against the precipitation. The conclusion and regression model will be referential to the forecast of drought in Southwest China and help reduce damages.

    How to cite: Ye, Y. and Tian, R.: Dynamic effects of the Tibetan Plateau on the sustained drought in southwest China, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1462, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1462, 2022.

    EGU22-1471 | Presentations | HS6.10

    In-situ observation, modeling and analysis for water and energy parameters over the Tibetan Plateau 

    Weiqiang Ma, Yaoming Ma, Yizhe Han, Wei Hu, Lei Zhong, Zhipeng Xie, Zeyong Hu, Rongmingzhu Su, Jianan He, Weiyao Ma, Ling Bai, and Fanglin Sun

    Tibetan Plateau Observation Platform (TORP), Third Pole Environment (TPE) observation and research Platform (TPEORP) and new stations were set up in recently years.
    Firstly, based on the difference of model and in-situ observations, a serious of sensitive experiments were done by using numerical model, Such as Noah-MP and WRF. Better schemes in ground temperature and soil water content at shallow layer simulation were selected by comparing with Moderate Resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer (MODIS) land surface temperature and Soil Moisture Active Passive (SMAP) soil moisture data. In order to use remote sensing products, a land-atmosphere model was initialized by ingesting land surface parameters, such as AMSR-E RS products, and the results were compared with the default model configuration and with in-situ long-term CAMP/Tibet observations. 
    Secondly, we analyzed the spatiotemporal variation characteristics of the heating field in the Tibetan Plateau through the observation data and reanalysis data and then revealed the influencing factors and potential effects of the changes of atmospheric heat sources on the Tibetan Plateau in summer and winter. Finally, the relationship between the change of spring AHS in the Tibetan Plateau and the change of summer precipitation in Northeast China was also analyzed from the level of mathematical statistics.
    Thirdly, based on historical observations daily data for 1981-2016 from 130 meteorological stations over and around the Tibetan Plateau , the trends of sensible heat flux (SH) and their elevation-dependence were investigated. Results indicate that the SH over and around the Tibetan Plateau experienced apparent trends’ shift in approximate 2000, demonstrating noticeable reductions during 1981-2000 and pronounced recovery during 2001-2016 for the four seasons.
    All of the different methods will clarify the water and energy parameters in complex plateau, it also can affect atmospheric cycle over the Tibetan Plateau even all of the global atmospheric cycle pattern.

    How to cite: Ma, W., Ma, Y., Han, Y., Hu, W., Zhong, L., Xie, Z., Hu, Z., Su, R., He, J., Ma, W., Bai, L., and Sun, F.: In-situ observation, modeling and analysis for water and energy parameters over the Tibetan Plateau, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1471, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1471, 2022.

    The source region of the Yellow River (SRYR) is located in the northeastern of the Tibetan Plateau and is known as the “water tower” of China because it contains 48 lakes. Daytime lake breezes are proved by ERA-Interim reanalysis data in the SRYR. We use the Large Eddy Model to depict the effect of the circulations induced by surface anomaly heating (patches) on the boundary-layer turbulence. A set of 1D tests of strip-like surface heat flux distribution are carried out, which based on observations in the Ngoring Lake basin in the summer of 2012. The simulations show that for the cases without background wind, patch-induced circulations (SCs) promote the growth of convective boundary layer (CBL), enhance the turbulent kinetic energy (TKE), and then modify the spatial distribution of TKE. Based on phase-averaged analysis, which separates the attribution from the SCs and the background turbulence, the SCs contribute no more than 10% to the vertical turbulent intensity, but their contributions to the heat flux can be up to 80%. The thermal internal boundary layer reduces the wind speed and forms the stable stratification, which produces the obvious change of turbulent momentum flux and heat flux over the heterogeneous surfaces. The increased downdrafts, which mainly occur over the lake patches, carry more warm, dry air down from the free atmosphere. The background wind inhibits the SCs and the development of the CBL; it also weakens the patch-induced turbulent intensity, heat flux, and convective intensity.

    How to cite: Zhang, Y., Huang, Q., and Ma, Y.: Large eddy simulation of boundary-layer turbulence over heterogeneous underlying surfaces in the northeastern Tibetan Plateau, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1580, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1580, 2022.

    EGU22-1605 | Presentations | HS6.10

    Estimation of hourly actual evapotranspiration over the Tibetan Plateau by random forest model 

    Xian Wang, Lei Zhong, Yaoming Ma, Weiqiang Ma, and Cunbo Han

    Actual evapotranspiration (ETa) is a key variable in the energy and water cycle of the earth climate system. Evapotranspiration product with high temporal resolution and accuracy is of great significance to the effective use of water resources and regulation of local climate. Here, one–year hourly ETa over the entire Tibetan Plateau (TP) was estimated by a combination use of satellite data from Fengyun-4A and Random Forest (RF) model. The validation against in situ measurements from six stations equipped with eddy-covariance instruments shows a root mean square error (RMSE) of 32.24 mm month-1 and a correlation coefficient of 0.85. Compared with results from surface energy balance system (SEBS) with a RMSE value of 59.13 mm month-1, Maximum Entropy Production (MEP) with a RMSE value of 62.28 mm month-1 and the European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasts Reanalysis-5 (ERA5) with a RMSE value of 53.64 mm month-1, the ETa results from RF model have the highest accuracy. The annual spatial average RF ETa over the whole TP was about 387.34 mm. Thus, the total ETa of the TP was about 1039.85 km3 yr−1. The annual average ETa in the eastern (long. > 95°E), central (95°E ≥ long. > 85°E) and western (long. ≤ 85°E) parts of the TP are 478.63 mm, 356.94 mm and 279.67 mm, respectively. In addition, diurnal averaged and monthly averaged ETa over different land cover types and different climate zones over the TP were also clearly identified. The ETa over cropland and the humid area is the highest with the largest variation range.

    How to cite: Wang, X., Zhong, L., Ma, Y., Ma, W., and Han, C.: Estimation of hourly actual evapotranspiration over the Tibetan Plateau by random forest model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1605, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1605, 2022.

    EGU22-1859 | Presentations | HS6.10

    Substantial increases in riverine sediment loads in a warmer and wetter Third Pole 

    Dongfeng Li, Xixi Lu, Irina Overeem, Desmond Walling, Jaia Syvitski, Albert Kettner, Bodo Bookhagen, Yinjun Zhou, and Ting Zhang

    Rivers originating in the Third Pole (Tibetan Plateau and surrounding high-Asian mountains) are crucial lifelines for one-third of the world’s population. These fragile headwaters are now experiencing amplified climate change, glacier melt, and permafrost thaw. Observational data from 28 headwater basins demonstrate substantial increases in both annual runoff and annual sediment fluxes across the past six decades. The increases have accelerated since the mid-1990s, in response to a warmer and wetter climate. The total riverine sediment load from HMA is projected to more than double by the mid-21st century under an extreme climate change scenario. The substantially increasing riverine sediment loads could negatively impact the hydropower-food-environmental security in the Third Pole region. Such findings also have implications for other cold environments such as the Arctic, Antarctic, and other high mountain areas.

    How to cite: Li, D., Lu, X., Overeem, I., Walling, D., Syvitski, J., Kettner, A., Bookhagen, B., Zhou, Y., and Zhang, T.: Substantial increases in riverine sediment loads in a warmer and wetter Third Pole, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1859, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1859, 2022.

    EGU22-1957 | Presentations | HS6.10

    Influence of topography on Tibetan Plateau snow cover simulations in land surface modeling 

    Xin Miao, Weidong Guo, Yongkang Xue, and Shufen Sun

    The Tibetan Plateau (TP) is the highest plateau in the world and has complex topography. On the TP, seasonal snow cover is widespread in different topographic areas, but the influence of topography on snow cover simulations is often ignored in most land surface models. In this study, the relationships among the snow cover fraction (SCF) and complex topography are investigated over the TP based on satellite observations. The standard deviation of topography is used as an index to describe the topographic complexity. We conduct 12 numerical experiments using the Simplified Simple Biosphere Model version 3 (SSiB3) to investigate the influence of topography on the snow cover simulations. Our results show that ignoring topography leads to significant SCF simulation biases. By adding a topographic factor to the original scheme, the SCF simulations are greatly improved. Compared with the simulation results of the default SCF scheme, the annual mean SCF bias at location at CMA stations is reduced from 3.833% to -0.097% by adding a topographic factor. The improved SCF simulations further lead to reduced biases in winter surface albedo and land surface temperature simulations. Compared with in situ observations, the winter surface albedo bias over the TP is reduced from 0.02 to 0.007 compared with GLASS albedo data, and the winter land surface temperature bias is reduced from -3.43 K to -3.04 K. This study highlights the importance of the topographic effect in simulating snow and energy exchanges between the land and atmosphere over the TP, and it can contribute to reducing the “cold bias” in winter climate simulations over the TP.

    How to cite: Miao, X., Guo, W., Xue, Y., and Sun, S.: Influence of topography on Tibetan Plateau snow cover simulations in land surface modeling, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1957, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1957, 2022.

    EGU22-2088 | Presentations | HS6.10

    INVC-Investigation of the water vapor channel within the Yarlung Zangbo Grand Canyon, China 

    Xuelong Chen, Xiangde Xu, Gaili Wang, Deliang Chen, Yaoming Ma, Liping Liu, Xie Hu, Yajing Liu, Luhan Li, Maoshan Li, Gong Ming, Siqiong Luo, and Xin Wang

    The Yarlung Zangbo Grand Canyon (YGC) is an important pathway for water vapor transport from south Asia to the Tibetan Plateau (TP). This area exhibits one of the highest frequencies of convective activity in China, and precipitation often brings natural disasters to local communities that can dramatically affect their livelihoods. In addition, the produced precipitation has produced vast glaciers and large rivers around the YGC. In 2018, the Second Tibetan Plateau Scientific Expedition and Research Programme tasked a research team to conduct an "Investigation of the water vapor channel of the Yarlung Zangbo Grand Canyon" in the southeastern Tibetan Plateau. This team subsequently established a three-dimensional comprehensive observation system of land-air interaction, water vapor transport, cloud cover, and rainfall activity in the YGC. This paper introduces the developed observation system and summarizes preliminary results obtained during the first two years of the project. Using this observation network, we focus herein on the development of heavy rainfall events in southeast Tibet that are associated with water vapor transported from the south. This project also helps to monitor geohazards in the key area of the Sichuan-Tibet railway that traverses the northern YGC.

    How to cite: Chen, X., Xu, X., Wang, G., Chen, D., Ma, Y., Liu, L., Hu, X., Liu, Y., Li, L., Li, M., Ming, G., Luo, S., and Wang, X.: INVC-Investigation of the water vapor channel within the Yarlung Zangbo Grand Canyon, China, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2088, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2088, 2022.

    Land-atmosphere interactions are an essential component of the climate system. However, no detailed description of the underlying effects of the surface forcing of the atmosphere has been established. In this study, GLEAM, MODIS, and ERA5 were the input set of multiple analysis algorithms, "segmentation" was the core idea of the analysis method. The study area is segmented into six surface response functional groups, and the multidimensional evaporation regime function was segmented into piecewise functions controlled by segment authoritative variables. Inspired by the surface heat balance equation and moisture-limited, energy-limited evaporation regimes, we chose soil moisture content and the net radiation flux to represent the moisture and energy status, respectively, and chose the leaf area index (LAI) to characterize the vegetation cover to investigate the primary effects of surface parameters on the energy partitioning of the land surface and evaporative regime. The results show that though a coupling strength 1.8 times greater was obtained when the LAI was used as the explanatory variable instead of soil moisture, soil moisture was still the highest explanatory variable in the regression tree analysis. This is consistent with the essence of the evaporative fraction and indicates that water should be the most fundamental explanatory variable. The evaporative regime was subdivided from two phases into five phases according to the effects such as water extraction by vegetation, photosynthesis, soil shading, and roughness changes, each with an authoritative explanatory variable.

    How to cite: Yang, C.: Terrestrial and Atmospheric Controls on Surface Energy Partitioning and Evaporative Fraction Regimes Over the Tibetan Plateau in the Growing Season, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2633, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2633, 2022.

    The Tibetan Plateau (TP) is also called the “Third pole” because its aquifers constitute the origin for several major rivers, which are the water supply for millions of people all over Asia. Groundwater is the most important fresh water resource, however population is continuously growing, resulting in an increasing need of water supply. Due to the remote character of the TP, hydrogeological aquifer information is scarce, which leads to uncertain water resource management. To ensure future sustainable water supply, aquifer characterisation is therefore an important issue on the TP. This study is motivated by the need of increasing hydrogeological knowledge on the TP and provides the physical and numerical hydrogeological characterisation of the Zhagu subcatchment, which is a subcatchment of the third largest lake on the TP: the Nam Co Lake. This project is part of the International Research Training Group “Geoecosystems in transition on the Tibetan Plateau” (TransTiP), funded by the DFG.

    Multiple interdisciplinary geophysical (electrical resistivity tomography, ERT), lithological (grain size analysis) and hydrogeological methods (observed hydraulic heads, hydraulic conductivity and recharge estimation) followed by numerical groundwater flow modeling (OpenGeoSys6, OGS6) were applied in order to hydrogeologically characterize the Zhagu subcatchment. The interdisciplinary results reveal the existence of a Quaternary hydrostratigraphic unit (Zhanongtang-Ganmanong aquifer). Furthermore, the results show three hydraulic conductivity zones in the Zhagu subcatchment. Monsoonal recharge in 2018 ranged between 108 and 242 mm and covered 30% to 67% of monsoonal precipitation. The physical results were interpreted into a conceptual model, which was prerequisite for the numerical groundwater flow model. For model calibration, the parameter estimation code PEST was coupled to OGS6. The model was successfully calibrated against hydraulic heads. The simulation results reveal that hydraulic head distribution ranged between 4691 and 5043 m and groundwater fluxes flow from the Zhagu subcatchment into the Nam Co lake by 0.03 m3m-2s-1.

    This study provides an overall insight into the hydrogeological conditions of the remote Nam Co catchment on the TP.  The new insights of the hydrostratigraphic unit and numerical groundwater flow modeling results are helpful in order to improve current hydrological water balances, which neglect and/or assume groundwater inflow fluxes. In future, the calibrated model can be used for different water extraction and/or climate change scenarios in order to evaluate anthropogenic and climate change influences on the regional aquifer. This study and further future physical and numerical hydrogeological analyses can help to develop a sustainable water management on the TP.

    How to cite: Tran, T. V. and Graf, T.: Hydrogeological Aquifer Characterisation by Multi-Physical Methods and Numerical Modeling: A case study of the Zhagu subcatchment (Tibetan Plateau), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5925, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5925, 2022.

    EGU22-6770 | Presentations | HS6.10

    Extreme lake expansion on the Tibetan Plateau: Observations and consequences 

    Yanbin Lei, Tandong Yao, Yongwei Sheng, Kun Yang, and Jing Zhou

    After the considerable lake level decrease in 2015 in response to the super 2015/2016 El Niño and lake level recovery in 2016, an extreme lake expansion occurred on the central and northern TP in the following two years (2017 and 2018), in contrast with the slight lake level changes on the southern TP. In-situ observations at Zhari Namco near Cuoqing County show that lake level increased abruptly by 1.4 m and 1.7 m in summer 2017 and 2018, respectively, which was even close to the accumulated lake level increase between 2000 and 2015. At Dazeg Co near Nima Country, lake level increased by 0.9 m and 1.4 m in summer 2017 and 2018, respectively, which is about 3 times as large as the increasing rate between 2000 and 2015. At Eya Co and Cedo Caka near Shuanghu County, lake level accumulatively increased by 1.5 m and 2.0 m, respectively, in the two years. The extreme lake expansion had significant impact on geomorphology and even posed great threat on the infrastructures such as road and bridges around the lakes. Causes of the extreme lake expansion are investigated by examining precipitation data and changes in large scale circulations. 

    How to cite: Lei, Y., Yao, T., Sheng, Y., Yang, K., and Zhou, J.: Extreme lake expansion on the Tibetan Plateau: Observations and consequences, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6770, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6770, 2022.

    EGU22-8171 | Presentations | HS6.10

    The role of surface coupling, turbulent mixing, and radiation in modeling a stable boundary layer over Tibetan Plateau 

    zhangwei Ding, Gert-Jan Steeneveld, Yaoming Ma, and Xuelong Chen

    To enhance the understanding of the impact of small-scale processes in the polar climate, this study focuses on the relative role of snow-surface coupling, radiation and turbulent mixing in stable boundary layer over Tibetan Plateau. This is the first attempt to reveal physical processes under stable stratification with WRF-3D model. All cases are characterized by three different stable boundary layer archetypes, namely, a radiative night, an intermittently turbulent night, and a fully turbulent night (all at clear-sky conditions). First a set of WRF configurations that vary in parametrization schemes for the planetary boundary layer, and land surface are evaluated. we find a wide variety in the state of the atmosphere and the surface variables for the selected parameterization schemes after intercomparisons. To understand this variety, we implement the sensitivity runs to examine which physical process is most crucial, using a unique analysis method so-called ‘process diagrams’. The variation between the sensitivity runs display a relative orientation of model sensitivities to variations in each of the governing processes and these can explain the variety of model results obtained in the intercomparison of different parameterization schemes.

    How to cite: Ding, Z., Steeneveld, G.-J., Ma, Y., and Chen, X.: The role of surface coupling, turbulent mixing, and radiation in modeling a stable boundary layer over Tibetan Plateau, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8171, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8171, 2022.

    Meteorological variables (e.g. air temperature (T2), radiation flux and precipitation) determine the evolution of glacier mass and characteristics. Observations of these variables are not available at adequate spatial coverage and temporal / spatial resolution over the Tibetan Plateau. This study focuses on evaluating the performance of albedo parameterization scheme in WRF coupled with Noah-MP in terms of glacio-meteorological variables, by conducting sensitivity experiments on Parlung No. 4 Glacier in ablation season in 2016. The control experiment (CTL) uses the model’s default albedo scheme and unrealistic surface type, while sensitivity experiments apply the default albedo scheme (Sens1) and the modified scheme (Sens2) in ice surface. The key results are as follows. First, all experiments yield similar T2 diurnal patterns to the observations and realistic land-use type considerably reduces model warm bias on the glacier. The RMSE of T2 decreases by 1 °C with an improvement of 37 % by sensitivity experiment estimates. Second, Sens1 keeps rather high albedo value of 0.68 causing net shortwave radiation and net radiation apparent underestimation, while Sens2 holds mean albedo value of 0.35 close to observations contributing to relieve net shortwave radiation and net radiation underestimation. Thirdly, compared with Sens1 estimates, more energy from Sens2 is used to heat ice surface resulting in high ground heat flux (182 W m-2), ice melt and liquid water content increase more quickly and preferentially. Our study confirms the ability of WRF model in reproducing glacio-meteorological variables as long as a reasonable albedo parameterization scheme is applied, and provides a theoretical reference for researchers committed to further improving the surface albedo scheme.

    How to cite: Liu, L. and Ma, Y.: Evaluation of albedo schemes in WRF coupled with Noah-MP on the Parlung No. 4 Glacier against in-situ observations, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8345, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8345, 2022.

    EGU22-9534 | Presentations | HS6.10

    Increasing lake levels on the central Tibetan Plateau since 1920 CE inferred by a sub-fossil chironomid record from Shen Co 

    Sonja Rigterink, Paula Echeverría-Galindo, Rodrigo Martínez-Abarca, Julieta Massaferro, Philipp Hoelzmann, Bernd Wünnemann, Andreas Laug, Liseth Pérez, Wengang Kang, Nicole Börner, Anja Schwarz, Ping Peng, Junbo Wang, Liping Zhu, and Antje Schwalb

    Lakes on the Tibetan Plateau are especially vulnerable to global warming and increasing temperatures but are also sensitive to changes in the atmospheric circulation such as the Westerlies and the Asian Summer Monsoon, which are main drivers of precipitation on the Plateau. Shallow lake environments in such high-altitudinal areas, which are not directly influenced by meltwater supply, are excellent study sites to determine changes in precipitation and evaporation. Here, we present a 300-year high-resolution chironomid record from the high-altitude (> 4,733 m a.s.l.), saline (9 g L-1) and shallow (~ 5 m water depth) lake Shen Co (N 31° 00’, E 90°29’), situated on the southern part of the central Tibetan Plateau. We combined chironomid assemblages with sedimentological, mineralogical and geochemical data from a short sediment core (37.5 cm) to detect hydrological changes since 1830 CE. Our study revealed three different periods in Shen Co: (1) from 1830 until 1920 CE sediments were void of chironomids, suggesting dry conditions leading to low lake levels, high salinity resulting from low runoff and high evaporation rates, supported by increasing Mg/Ca and Sr/Rb ratios of the sediments; (2) a humid phase characterized by the appearance of Acricotopus indet. morphotype incurvatus from 1920 until 1950 CE, indicating rising lake levels caused by higher runoff and decreased evaporation, also supported by sediment analysis with increasing TOC and Ti as well as a decreasing Ca/Ti ratio; and (3) a continuous water level rise from the 1950s onwards with a lake level maximum as well as high macrophyte growth since the beginning of the 21th century, supported by the dominance of Procladius and the phytophilic taxon Psectrocladius sordidellus-type. We compared our results with paleoclimate records from the Tibetan Plateau, based on e.g. ice core δ18O, pollen, tree rings, indicating warmer and wetter climate conditions on the central Tibetan Plateau during the last ~ 100 years. Our findings highlight that chironomid records from shallow lake environments are excellent indicators of lake level variations as well as changes in macrophyte vegetation.

    How to cite: Rigterink, S., Echeverría-Galindo, P., Martínez-Abarca, R., Massaferro, J., Hoelzmann, P., Wünnemann, B., Laug, A., Pérez, L., Kang, W., Börner, N., Schwarz, A., Peng, P., Wang, J., Zhu, L., and Schwalb, A.: Increasing lake levels on the central Tibetan Plateau since 1920 CE inferred by a sub-fossil chironomid record from Shen Co, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9534, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9534, 2022.

    EGU22-9708 | Presentations | HS6.10

    Detecting occurrence of blowing snow events with decision tree model 

    Zhipeng Xie, Yaoming Ma, Weiqiang Ma, and Zeyong Hu

    Blowing snow processes are crucial in shaping the strongly heterogeneous spatiotemporal distribution of snow and in regulating subsequent snowpack evolution in mountainous terrain. Although empirical formulae and constant threshold wind speeds have been widely used to estimate the occurrence of blowing snow in regions with sparse observations, these methods struggle to accurately capture the high local variability of blowing snow. This study investigated the potential capability of the decision tree model to detect blowing snow occurrence based on routine meteorological observations (mean wind speed, maximum wind speed, air temperature and relative humidity) and snow measurements. Results show that the maximum wind speed contributes the most to the classification accuracy, and the inclusion of more predictor variables improves the overall accuracy. Besides, the overall accuracy of blowing snow occurrence detected by the decision tree model is comparable or even better than traditional methods, indicating it is a promising approach requiring limited meteorological variables and having the potential to scale to multiple stations across different regions, such as the Tibetan Plateau.

    How to cite: Xie, Z., Ma, Y., Ma, W., and Hu, Z.: Detecting occurrence of blowing snow events with decision tree model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9708, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9708, 2022.

    The Upper Blue Nile Basin (UBNB) in Ethiopia has a huge hydropower development potential and it covers a considerable amount of the present hydropower consumptions in the country. However, as hydropower is basically rainfall-dependent, its future sustainable utilization under climate change is highly uncertain. As a result, it is critical to identify the amount of wind energy that can be harnessed in the area since wind is a good substitute for hydropower. Nonetheless, wind energy suitability studies and potential estimations are rarely researched in the UBNB. The objective of this study is, therefore, to investigate wind farm suitability based on multi-criteria decision method using Geographic Information System (GIS) and to determine the energy potentials of those suitable areas in UBNB. Wind speed, slope, land use/land cover, distance from grids, roads, urban areas, and protected areas were considered to identify suitable wind farm sites. The relative weights of these factors were calculated and overlaid by the principle of pairwise comparison in the context of the Analytic Hierarchy Process. From the total area it was found that 1498.69 km2 was highly suitable. The suggested highly suitable areas for wind farm sites fall in the northeastern part of the study area. For wind power potential investigation, wind speed data of ten sites with 15 min intervals of four years (2017-2020) were accessed from National Meteorology Agency (NMA). And it was statistically analyzed using statistical methods and software like MS-Excel and MATLAB programs. The best Weibull parameters estimator was identified based on the statistical test results for each station. From the wind power density analysis using 15-minute interval wind speed, the highest wind power density was recorded in Wogeltena followed by Gatira. Finally, the power density was higher during dry and short rainy season and can be said that wind is a good complementary to hydropower. In conclusion, most of the wind speed data in this study were not enough for wind energy potential estimations at large scales. This may be because the meteorological stations in the study area may not be located at ideal places for wind energy potential estimations. Thus, different wind speed measuring tools (i.e. taller wind mast) are suggested for additional wind energy potential investigations. Relatively, the northeastern parts of the study area are the most promising sites discovered in this study. Hence, these areas might be regarded as feasible for various wind energy applications (i.e. grid-connected and stand-alone).

    How to cite: Tegegne, E. B., Berhanu, Y., and Wang, B.: Suitability Analysis for Wind Farm Establishment and Wind Energy Potential Investigation: The Case of Upper Blue Nile River Basin, Ethiopia, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10679, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10679, 2022.

    EGU22-13329 | Presentations | HS6.10

    It's a match: increasing understanding of dissolved organic matter processing of Tibetan catchments by combining optical spectroscopy and ultrahigh-resolution mass spectrometry 

    Philipp Maurischat, Michael Seidel, Åsmund Rinnan, Tsechoe Dorji, and Georg Guggenberger

    Dissolved organic matter (DOM) is an important carbon and nutrient source for biota in streams and lakes. The composition and bioavailability of DOM depends on the formation in the catchments as well as on the biogeochemical and photochemical processing during its fluvial transport. Our study aimed to understand how the chemical composition of DOM is shaped by its sources and how natural organic matter is modified by biogeochemical processes during the fluvial transport to the endorheic Lake Nam Co, Tibet. Three subcatchments of the Lake Nam Co watershed were selected, based on different biomes and various degrees of land degradation. Samples characterizing endmembers along the stream network were analysed for optical properties (UV/VIS, fluorescence matrices decomposed by parallel factor analysis). Solid phase extracted (SPE) DOM was further analysed on the molecular level using ultrahigh-resolution mass spectroscopy (FT ICR-MS).

    FT ICR-MS analysis revealed that meltwater from glaciers was on the one hand relatively rich in polyphenols, potentially derived from atmospheric deposition. Optical properties on the other hand suggest a high biological lability together with mainly microbial DOM sources, probably from microbial primary production in the glaciers. DOM originating from peatlands and Kobresia pygmaea pastures showed a “terrestrial-like” optical DOM signature derived from plant litter and organic soil material and had a strong seasonal variability. Furthermore, grassland sites degraded by overgrazing released more organic compounds with higher molecular weight into the stream, likely due to hampered retention of water and organic matter in the disturbed topsoils. Molecular level data from FT ICR-MS analysis further revealed greater DOM processing in the terminal lake compared to the streams, which can be attributed to bio- and photooxidation in the lake water column. The analysis shows, that the use of complementary analytical techniques reveals matching indicators to unravel relevant biogeochemical processes in the catchment. This methodological approach allows novel, in-depth insights into the dynamics of DOM characteristics for the sensitive and threated environments of the Tibetan highlands.

    How to cite: Maurischat, P., Seidel, M., Rinnan, Å., Dorji, T., and Guggenberger, G.: It's a match: increasing understanding of dissolved organic matter processing of Tibetan catchments by combining optical spectroscopy and ultrahigh-resolution mass spectrometry, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13329, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13329, 2022.

    HS7 – Precipitation and climate

    EGU22-323 | Presentations | HS7.1

    Study of Downscaling Techniques and Standings of Bias Corrected Global Climate Models for Brahmani Basin at Odisha, India 

    Minduri Uma Maheswar Rao, Kanhu Charan Patra, and Akhtar Jahan

    Climate change is emerging as one of the most pressing issues facing our environment since it will have severe consequences for both natural and human systems. The ability to estimate future climate is required to investigate the influence of climate change on a river basin. The most reliable instruments for simulating climate change are Global Climate Models (GCMs), also known as General Circulation Models. The performance of a precipitation simulation for the Brahmani river basin spanning 94 locations (with a grid resolution of 0.25° X 0.25°) is evaluated in the present study. The observed and model historical temperature datasets cover the period from 2000-2019. Twelve Coupled Model Intercomparison Project – Phase 6 (CMIP6) GCMs (ACCESS- CM2, CESM2, CIESM, FGOALS- g3, HadGEM3, GFDL- ESM4, INM- CM5-0, MIROC- ES2L, NESM3, UKESM1, MPI- ESM1, NorESM2) are used for the climate variable (Pr) using five indicators of performance. Indicators used are Average Absolute Relative Deviation (AARD), Skill Score (SS), Absolute Normalized Mean Bias Deviation (ANMBD), Correlation Coefficient (CC), Normalized Root Mean Square Deviation (NRMSD). GCMs are downscaled to finer spatial resolution before ranking them. The statistical downscaling technique is applied to eliminate the systematic biases in GCM simulations. Weights are determined using the Entropy technique for each performance metric. Cooperative Game Theory (CGT), Compromise programming (CP), Weighted Average Technique, Technique for Order Preference by Similarity to an Ideal Solution (TOPSIS), and Preference Ranking Organization Method of Enrichment Evaluation (PROMETHEE-2) methods are utilized to rank the GCMs for the study area. GDM is an approach utilized to integrate the ranking techniques of GCMs to get a collective single rank. The results obtained for precipitation suggest that MIROC-ES2L, HadGEM3, GFDL-ESM4, UKESM1, FGOALS-g3 are the top five models that are preferred for the prediction of precipitation in the Brahmani River Basin.

    How to cite: Rao, M. U. M., Patra, K. C., and Jahan, A.: Study of Downscaling Techniques and Standings of Bias Corrected Global Climate Models for Brahmani Basin at Odisha, India, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-323, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-323, 2022.

    EGU22-1996 | Presentations | HS7.1

    Reduced rainfall in future heavy precipitation events tied to decreased rain area and takes place despite increased rain rate 

    Moshe Armon, Francesco Marra, Chaim Garfinkel, Dorita Rostkier-Edelstein, Ori Adam, Uri Dayan, Yehouda Enzel, and Efrat Morin

    Heavy precipitation events (HPEs) can lead to deadly and costly natural disasters and, especially in regions where rainfall variability is high, such as the eastern Mediterranean, they are critical to the hydrological budget. Reliable projections of future HPEs are needed, but global climate models are too coarse to explicitly represent rainfall processes during HPEs. In this study we used pseudo global warming high-resolution (1 km2) weather research and forecasting (WRF) model simulations to provide rainfall patterns projections based on simulations of 41 pairs of historic and “future” (end of 21st century) HPEs under global warming conditions (RCP8.5 scenario). Changes in rainfall patterns were analyzed through different properties: storm mean conditional rain rate, storm duration, and rain area. A major decrease in rainfall accumulation occurs in future HPEs (−30% averaged across events). This decrease results from a substantial reduction of the storms rain area (−40%) and duration (−9%), and occurs despite an increase in the mean conditional rain intensity (+15%). The consistency of results across events, driven by varying synoptic conditions, suggests that these changes have low sensitivity to the specific synoptic evolution during the events. Future HPEs in the eastern Mediterranean will therefore likely be drier and more spatiotemporally concentrated, with substantial implications on hydrological outcomes of storms. (For hydrological results see: abstract #EGU22-4777)

    • Armon, M., Marra, F., Enzel, Y., Rostkier‐Edelstein, D., Garfinkel, C. I., Adam, O., et al. (2022). Reduced Rainfall in Future Heavy Precipitation Events Related to Contracted Rain Area Despite Increased Rain Rate. Earth’s Future, 10(1), 1–19. https://doi.org/10.1029/2021ef002397

    How to cite: Armon, M., Marra, F., Garfinkel, C., Rostkier-Edelstein, D., Adam, O., Dayan, U., Enzel, Y., and Morin, E.: Reduced rainfall in future heavy precipitation events tied to decreased rain area and takes place despite increased rain rate, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1996, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1996, 2022.

    Limited-area convection-permitting climate models (CPMs) with horizontal grid-spacing less than 4km and not relying on deep convection parameterisations (CPs) are being used more and more frequently. CPMs represent small-scale features such as deep convection more realistically than coarser regional climate models (RCMs) with deep CPs. Because of computational costs CPMs tend to use smaller horizontal domains than RCMs. As all limited-area models (LAMs), CPMs suffer issues with lateral boundary conditions (LBCs) and nesting. We investigated these issues using idealised Big-Brother (BB) experiments with the LAM COSMO-CLM. Grid-spacing of the reference BB simulation was 2.4 km. Deep convection was triggered by idealised hills with driving data from simulations with different spatial resolutions, with/without deep CP, and with different nesting frequencies and LBC formulations. All our nested idealised 2.4-km Little-Brother (LB) experiments performed worse than a coarser CPM simulation (4.9km) which used a four times larger computational domain and yet spent only half the computational cost. A boundary zone of >100 grid-points of the LBs could not be interpreted meteorologically because of spin-up of convection and boundary inconsistencies. Hosts with grid-spacing in the so-called grey zone of convection (ca. 4 - 20km) were not advantageous to the LB performance. The LB's performance was insensitive to the applied LBC formulation and updating (if smaller or equal 3-hourly). Therefore, our idealised experiments suggested to opt for a larger domain instead of a higher resolution even if coarser than usual (~5km) as a compromise between the harmful boundary problems, computational cost and improved representation of processes by CPMs.

    How to cite: Ahrens, B. and Leps, N.: On the Challenge of Convection Permitting Precipitation Simulations: Results from Idealised Experiments, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2531, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2531, 2022.

    EGU22-3074 | Presentations | HS7.1 | Highlight

    A global scale assessment of the intensification of rainfall extremes 

    Athanasios Paschalis, Yiannis Moustakis, and Yuting Chen

    Intensification of precipitation extremes under a changing climate is expected to severely impact societies due to increased flooding, and its impacts on infrastructure, agriculture, and ecosystems. Extensive research in the last decades has identified multiple facets of precipitation changes, from super Clausius – Clapeyron scaling of precipitation extremes with temperature increase, to the change of the intensity and spatial extent of mesoscale convective systems.

    In this study we attempt to compile state of the art data and simulations to understand the multiple facets of the changes in precipitation extremes across the world. To do that we combined data from thousands of weather stations globally, reanalysis datasets, and general circulation and convection permitting model simulations. Our results show that:

    • Hourly precipitation extremes scale with temperature at a rate of ~7%/K globally, albeit very large spatial heterogeneities were found, linked to topography, large-scale weather dynamics and local features of atmospheric convection
    • Precipitation extremes change beyond this thermodynamic basis, with increases in the heaviness of the tails of precipitation distribution at fine scales
    • The spatial extent of convective systems is expected to increase
    • Precipitation extremes with shorter spell duration that are distributed more uniformly throughout the year are expected

    How to cite: Paschalis, A., Moustakis, Y., and Chen, Y.: A global scale assessment of the intensification of rainfall extremes, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3074, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3074, 2022.

    EGU22-3117 | Presentations | HS7.1 | Highlight

    Identifying a regional model for extreme rainfall in current climates – quo vadis? 

    Ida Bülow Gregersen, Karsten Arnbjerg-Nielsen, Hjalte Jomo Danielsen Sørup, and Henrik Madsen

    Establishing a regional model for intensity-duration-frequency (IDF) curves remain a vital task for design of urban infrastructures such as sewer systems and storm water detention ponds. However, identifying a suitable model remains tricky as subjective decisions and assumptions, that easily can be challenged, is needed. The talk will focus on recognizing and overcoming these shortcomings to develop a framework that is trusted by the users, i.e., the engineering professionals.

    Since 1999 a regional model for IDF-curves has been developed and employed in Denmark. The model consists of a Partial Duration Series (PDS) framework using covariates to explain the regional variation supplemented with a regression across different durations. The first model was based on 41 series with a total of 650 station-years. Currently a fourth model based on a total of 132 series with almost 3000 station-years is being developed. The underlying data for all models come from a network of tipping bucket gauges initiated in 1979.

    While the PDS modelling framework to describe extreme rainfall data has been applied and validated every time, the model setup has changed during each of the three updates. The second model, released in 2006, focussed on describing a significant increase in the design intensities and identifying a new regionalization, reducing the number of regions in the country from three to two. The third model, released in 2014, further increased the design intensities substantially, but more importantly, a cycle of precipitation extremes in Denmark with a frequency of around 35 years was acknowledged, and new co-variates were identified, enabling a description of Denmark as one region with variations that could be explained by two spatially continuous covariates.

    Presently a new model is being developed. Most parts of the model are unchanged. However, inclusion of many recent relatively short series (10-20 years) both increase the sampling uncertainty and bias the model towards the very peak of the cyclic variation of the precipitation extremes, whereby the mean intensities will increase, as well as the overall uncertainty of the model. Hence the short series have been excluded.  As a result hereof, the engineering community expresses a concern that such an update will not, in general, increase design intensities in a current climate that is regarded as non-stationary with increasing extreme rainfall. For the scientists it could be an indication that the model may have reached a mature state, where the changes are small and random over a 5-year horizon. For the practitioners there is a concern that this may lead to infrastructure design that over time proves inadequate and fails to meet the service levels set to protect the citizens and important assets.  

    As indicated above having much data at hand for a regional model does not hinder large structural uncertainties. What are reasonable assumptions and how can they be communicated to the users? When looking across Europe the structural differences in the model setups are even larger, not only reflecting variations in climate, but also choices made by different groups of scientists.

    How to cite: Gregersen, I. B., Arnbjerg-Nielsen, K., Danielsen Sørup, H. J., and Madsen, H.: Identifying a regional model for extreme rainfall in current climates – quo vadis?, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3117, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3117, 2022.

    EGU22-4004 | Presentations | HS7.1

    Regridding and interpolation of climate data for impacts modelling – some cautionary notes 

    Richard Chandler, Clair Barnes, Chris Brierley, and Raquel Alegre

    Users of climate data must often confront the problem that information is not available at the precise spatial locations of interest; or the related problem that multiple sources of information provide data at different collections of locations. An example of the first situation is the use of weather station data to calibrate a hydrological or land surface model requiring inputs on a regular grid; an example of the second is the use of information from an ensemble of climate models to sample structural uncertainty, but where each model produces output on its own grid. Dealing with this spatial misalignment is a common first step in any analysis, and is usually done by some form of interpolation. In this poster, we use standard approaches to convert regional climate model (RCM) outputs from the EuroCORDEX ensemble to the common grid used in the UK national Climate Projections (UKCP). We find that although these standard approaches perform acceptably in some situations, in others they can induce surprisingly large biases and inconsistencies in the statistical properties of the resulting fields – particularly those relating to variability and extremes. For example, although the resolutions of the UKCP grid and the EuroCORDEX RCMs are all similar, it is not hard to find locations where the maximum daily precipitation within a month is systematically underestimated by 5-10% in the regridded data; and where the maximum daily precipitation over a 20-year period is systematically underestimated by 25%. These effects could have major implications for impacts studies carried out using interpolated or regridded data, if they are not recognised and dealt with appropriately. We offer some suggestions, varying in ease of implementation, for dealing with the problem.

    How to cite: Chandler, R., Barnes, C., Brierley, C., and Alegre, R.: Regridding and interpolation of climate data for impacts modelling – some cautionary notes, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4004, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4004, 2022.

    EGU22-4405 | Presentations | HS7.1

    Evaluation of precipitation reanalysis products in space and time for ungauged sites in Slovenia 

    Hannes Müller-Thomy, Patrick Nistahl, Nejc Bezak, and Marcos Alexopoulos

    Precipitation reanalysis products (PRP) are a promising data source for ungauged regions. Since observed time series are often i) too short, ii) their temporal resolution is not sufficient or iii) the network density is too low, they cannot be used as e.g. input for rainfall-runoff (r-r) modelling and derived flood frequency analysis. Reanalysis products as global simulation of the atmosphere over the last decades solve the aforementioned issues.

    From the latest PRP three are most promising due to their spatial and temporal resolution for r-r modelling of small to mesoscale catchments: ERA5-Land (raster with approx. 9 km width), REA6 (6 km) and CFSv2 (22 km). These three PRP are able to cope with the dynamics of the r-r process due to their hourly resolution. The PRP are evaluated for Slovenia (Europe) with both, precipitation characteristics in space and time, and runoff characteristics. For areal precipitation, continuous and event-based characteristics are evaluated as well as precipitation extreme values. Simple correction methods for identified biases are suggested and applied. It can be seen that although the PRP clearly differ from each other, there is no clear ‘favourite’ to use as input for the r-r modelling.

    To conclude about the suitability of the PRP for r-r modelling, continuous simulations are carried out with GR4H for 20 catchments in Slovenia (55 km²-480 km²). Models are re-calibrated for each PRP input based on KGE. Simulation results of calibration and validation period are evaluated by runoff extreme values, KGE, flow duration curve and intra-annual cycle. Interestingly, first results show that the deviations of some rainfall characteristics do not necessarily transfer to deviations in runoff characteristics, which can be explained by the high nonlinearity of the r-r process. PRP lead to better, at least similar results for runoff characteristics for catchments without rain gauges in their centre.

    How to cite: Müller-Thomy, H., Nistahl, P., Bezak, N., and Alexopoulos, M.: Evaluation of precipitation reanalysis products in space and time for ungauged sites in Slovenia, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4405, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4405, 2022.

    EGU22-4453 | Presentations | HS7.1

    Complexity of rainfall dynamics in India in the context of climate change 

    Bhadran Deepthi and Bellie Sivakumar

    Global climate change has become one of the major environmental issues today. Climate change impacts rainfall (and other hydroclimatic processes) in many ways, including its temporal and spatial variability. Hence, understanding the impact of climate change on rainfall is important to devise and undertake more effective and efficient adaptation and management strategies. The present study attempts to determine the temporal dynamic complexity of monthly historical and future rainfall in India at a spatial resolution of 1º × 1º. The historical and future rainfall data are simulated from 27 General Circulation Models (GCMs) from the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project Phase 6 (CMIP6). The historical rainfall consists of the rainfall data simulated by GCMs for the period 1961–2014, and the rainfall simulated by the GCMs under shared socio-economic pathway scenarios (SSPs) constitutes the future rainfall. Four scenarios (SSP126, SSP245, SSP370, and SSP585) and two different timeframes (near future (2015–2060) and far future (2061–2099)) are considered to determine how the rainfall and its dynamic complexity vary across the scenarios and timescales. The false nearest neighbor (FNN) algorithm is employed to determine the dimensionality and, hence, the complexity of the rainfall dynamics. The algorithm involves two major steps: (i) reconstruction of the single-variable rainfall time series in a multi-dimensional phase space; and (ii) identification of “false” neighbors in the reconstructed phase space and estimation of the dimension of the rainfall time series. The results suggest that the FNN dimensions of both the historical rainfall and future rainfall simulated by the 27 GCMs across India under all scenarios range from 3 to 20, indicating low to high-level complexity of the rainfall dynamics. However, only less than 1% of the study area shows high-level complexity in historical and future rainfall dynamics. Moreover, around 20 GCMs exhibit low to medium-level complexity of rainfall dynamics in 80% of the study area, with the dimensionality in the range from 3 to 10. Therefore, considering both the historical rainfall and future rainfall under all the four scenarios and the two timeframes considered in this study, the number of GCMs simulating rainfall that exhibits dimensionality in the range 11 to 20 are few. This may be an indication that the complexity of rainfall dynamics in India in the future will be low-to-medium dimensional.

    How to cite: Deepthi, B. and Sivakumar, B.: Complexity of rainfall dynamics in India in the context of climate change, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4453, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4453, 2022.

    EGU22-5071 | Presentations | HS7.1

    Impact of GPM Precipitation Error Characteristics on Hydrological Applications 

    Ankita Pradhan and Indu Jayaluxmi

    Precipitation-measuring satellites constitute a constellation of microwave and infrared sensors in geosynchronous earth orbit. The limited sampling of passive microwave constellations continues to be a problem, affecting applications such as hydrological modeling. Recent constellations have contributed in the construction of the next generation of earth and space science missions by allowing measurement settings to be customized to meet changing scientific understanding. Our study focuses on examining the Global Precipitation Measurement (GPM) constellation mission. The aim of the study is to examine the impact of different uncertainties carried by the GPM constellation on hydrological applications. Firstly we investigated the evaluation and comparison of spatial sampling error for the Global Precipitation Measurement (GPM) mission orbital data products. The region over India with high seasonal rainfall appears to have lower sampling uncertainty, and vice versa, with some exceptions due to differences in precipitation variability and space-time correlation length.  Second, we investigated how intermittency produced by low temporal sampling propagates through a hydrological model and contributes to stream flow uncertainty. We also examined the effect of grid resolution and how it relates to Clausius-Clapeyron scaling. This paper proposes and discusses techniques for quantifying the influence of grid resolution as a function of spatial–temporal characteristics of heavy precipitation based on these findings. Thirdly, we have quantified the influence of two different algorithms i.e top down and bottom up approach utilizing precipitation products that includes the Global Precipitation Measurement mission's (GPM) integrated Multi-satellite Retrievals (IMERG) late run, the SM2RAIN-Climate Change Initiative (SM2RAIN-CCI), and the SM2RAIN-Advanced SCATerometer (SM2RAIN-ASCAT) on hydrological simulations. The results from our study indicate that precipitation forcing at 6-hourly integration outperforms the stream flow simulations as compared to 3-hourly and 12-hourly forcing integration times. IMERG based precipitation also contains significant bias which is propagated into hydrological models when used as precipitation forcing.

    How to cite: Pradhan, A. and Jayaluxmi, I.: Impact of GPM Precipitation Error Characteristics on Hydrological Applications, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5071, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5071, 2022.

    We present an analysis of uncertainty in model-based Probable Maximum Precipitation (PMP) estimates. The focus of the study is on “model-based” PMP derived from WRF (Weather Research and Forecasting) model reconstructions of severe historical storms and amplified by the addition of moisture in the boundary conditions (so-called Relative Humidity Maximization technique). Model-based PMP offers numerous advantages over the currently-used approach that is described in NOAA Hydrometeorological Reports. By scaling moisture and producing the resulting precipitation according to model formulation, the model-based approach circumvents the need for linearly scaling precipitation. Despite the significant improvement this represents, model-based PMP retains some degree of uncertainty that precludes its use in operational settings until the uncertainty is rigorously evaluated. This paper presents an ensemble of PMP simulations that samples recognized sources of uncertainty: (1) initial/boundary condition error, (2) choice of physics parametrizations and (3) model error due to unresolved subgrid processes. To our knowledge, this is the first uncertainty analysis conducted for model-based PMP. We applied this ensemble approach to the Feather River watershed (Oroville dam) in California. We first carried out in-depth evaluation of model reconstructions and found that the performance of some storm reconstructions that underlie the PMP estimate is not ideal, though the lack of uncertainty information about observations currently prevents us from identifying “well-reconstructed” storms or performing bias correction. That being said, our ensemble indicates that the 72-hour maximized precipitation totals used for PMP estimation do not differ greatly (110% at most) from the single-value estimate when model uncertainty is considered. We emphasize that model-based PMP estimates should always be presented as a range of values that reflects the uncertainties that exist, but concerns about model uncertainty should not hinder the development of model-based PMP.

    How to cite: Tarouilly, E., Cannon, F., and Lettenmaier, D.: Improving confidence in model-based Probable Maximum Precipitation : Assessing sources of model uncertainty in storm reconstruction and maximization, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6217, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6217, 2022.

    EGU22-6342 | Presentations | HS7.1 | Highlight

    Influence of morphology on the spatial variability of rainstorms over Italy 

    Paola Mazzoglio, Ilaria Butera, Massimiliano Alvioli, and Pierluigi Claps

    The investigation of the influence of terrain morphology on rainfall extremes has never been conducted over the entire Italy, where some studies have been carried out over limited areas. We then present the first systematic investigation of the role of elevation and other morphological attributes on rainfall extremes over Italy, that is made possible by using the Improved Italian – Rainfall Extreme Dataset (I2-RED). I2-RED is a database of short duration (1 to 24 hours) annual maximum rainfall depths collected from 1916 until 2019 by more than 5200 rain gauges.

    The analyses involved the relations between morphology and the mean annual rainfall extremes (index rainfall) using univariate and multivariate regressions. These relations, built countrywide, demonstrated that the elevation alone can explain only a part of the spatial variance. The inclusion of regression covariates as longitude, latitude, distance from the coastline, indexes of obstructions and the mean annual rainfall depth demonstrated to be significant in relations built at the national scale.

    However, high local bias with notable spatial correlation derives from the national-scale analysis. This led us to focus on smaller areas. We started dividing Italy into 4 main regions: the Alps, the Apennines, and the two main islands (i.e. Sicily and Sardinia). A dedicated multiple linear regression analysis was conducted over each of these areas. Evident improvements were obtained through this approach; nevertheless, clusters of high residuals persisted, especially in orographically-complex areas. A different approach was then undertaken, based on a preemptive subdivision of Italy in morphologically similar regions, to both reduce the clustering of errors and better define the role of elevation. Using four morphological classifications of Italy from the literature, we applied simple regression models to the rain gauges available inside each region. Among all, the classification that embeds hydrological information turned out to produce the best results in terms of local bias, MAE and RMSE, outperforming the multivariate relations obtained at the national scale. This approach proved to better reproduce the effects of geography and morphology on the spatial variability of rainfall extremes.

    Our analysis confirmed a general increase of 24-hour rainfall depths with elevation, as already pointed out by studies conducted over smaller areas. For 1-hour rainfall depths, in flat or in pre-hill zones a modest increase with elevation is visible, while over the Alps and in most of the Apennines a reverse orographic effect (i.e., a reduction of rainfall depth with increasing elevation) is clearly detected, confirming previous outcomes in those areas.

    How to cite: Mazzoglio, P., Butera, I., Alvioli, M., and Claps, P.: Influence of morphology on the spatial variability of rainstorms over Italy, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6342, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6342, 2022.

    EGU22-6677 | Presentations | HS7.1

    Can Radar Quantitative Precipitation Estimates Reproduce Extreme Precipitation Statistics in Central Arizona? 

    Nehal Ansh Srivastava and Giuseppe Mascaro

    In this study, we assess the ability of 4-km, 1-h Quantitative Precipitation Estimates (QPEs) from the Stage IV analysis of the NEXRAD radar network to reproduce the statistics of extreme precipitation (P) in central Arizona, USA. As reference, we use 19 years of records from a dense network of 257 rain gages. For each radar pixel and gage record, we fit the generalized extreme value (GEV) distribution to the series of annual maximum P at durations, τ, from 1 to 24 hours. We found that the GEV scale and shape parameters estimated from the radar QPEs are slightly negatively biased when compared to estimates from gage records at τ = 1 h; this bias tends to 0 for τ ≥ 6 h. As a result, the radar GEV quantiles for return period, TR, from 2 to 50 years exhibit negative bias at τ = 1 h (median between -23% and -12% for different TR’s), but the bias is gradually reduced as τ increases (average of +4% for τ = 24 h). The relative root-mean-square-error (RRMSE) ranges from 17% to 44% across all τ’s and TR’s and these values are similar to those computed between gages and operational design storms from NOAA Atlas 14. Lastly, we found that radar QPEs reproduce fairly well observed scaling relationships between the GEV location and scale parameters and P duration, τ. Results of our work provide confidence in the utility of Stage IV QPEs to characterize the spatiotemporal statistical properties of extreme P and, in turn, to improve the generation of design storm values.

    How to cite: Srivastava, N. A. and Mascaro, G.: Can Radar Quantitative Precipitation Estimates Reproduce Extreme Precipitation Statistics in Central Arizona?, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6677, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6677, 2022.

    EGU22-8792 | Presentations | HS7.1

    Space-time simulation of storms and beyond! 

    Simon Michael Papalexiou, Francesco Serinaldi, and Emilio Porcu

    Simulating storms, or hydro-environmental fluxes in general, in space and time is challenging and crucial to inform environmental risk analysis and decision making under variability and uncertainty. Here, we advance space-time modelling by enabling simulation of random fields (RF) described by general velocity fields and anisotropy. This advances the skills of the Complete Stochastic Modeling Solution (CoSMoS) framework in space and time and enables RF's simulations that reproduce desired: (a) non-Gaussian marginal distribution, (b) spatiotemporal correlation structure (STCS), (c) velocity fields with locally varying speed and direction that describe advection, and (d) locally varying anisotropy. We demonstrate applications of CoSMoS by simulating storms at fine spatiotemporal scales that move across an area, spiraling fields such weather cyclones, air masses converging to (or diverging from) a point and more. The methods are implemented in the CoSMoS R package freely available in CRAN.

    Reference: Papalexiou, S. M., Serinaldi, F., & Porcu, E. (2021). Advancing Space-Time Simulation of Random Fields: From Storms to Cyclones and Beyond. Water Resources Research, 57(8), e2020WR029466. https://doi.org/10.1029/2020WR029466

    How to cite: Papalexiou, S. M., Serinaldi, F., and Porcu, E.: Space-time simulation of storms and beyond!, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8792, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8792, 2022.

    EGU22-10253 | Presentations | HS7.1

    Spatial and temporal variability of rainfall on different time scales 

    András Bárdossy

    Rainfall is highly variable in space and time. The knowledge of precipitation variability is very important for design or for uncertainty assessment of models. In this contribution two different aspects of variability are investigated – the treatment of zero observations for spatial interpolation and the problem of high order dependence. The finer the temporal resolution of precipitation observations the more zeros have to be considered. Should one include all zeros for the description of the spatial variability (for example variograms)? Examples corresponding to different time aggregations are show that zeros need a specific treatment. High order dependence is investigated using time series observed at multiple sites. Results are compared to a meta-Gaussian approach. A large high-resolution dataset from South-West Germany is used to demonstrate the problems and the different approaches.

    How to cite: Bárdossy, A.: Spatial and temporal variability of rainfall on different time scales, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10253, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10253, 2022.

    EGU22-10355 | Presentations | HS7.1

    Combining commercial microwave link and rain gauge observations to estimate countrywide precipitation: a stochastic reconstruction and pattern analysis approach 

    Nico Blettner, Christian Chwala, Barbara Haese, Sebastian Hörning, and Harald Kunstmann

    Precipitation is characterized by large spatial variability. For hydrological applications it is crucial to estimate precipitation such that spatial correlation lengths and precipitation patterns are represented accurately.

    We derive countrywide precipitation estimates using approx. 4000 commercial microwave links (CMLs) obtained from Ericsson and approx. 1000 rain gauges operated by the German Weather Service. CML and gauge observations are regarded as non-linear and linear constraints on the spatial estimate, respectively.

    We apply the Random-Mixing-Whittaker-Shannon method in a Python based environment (RMWSPy) to reconstruct ensembles of precipitation fields. With RMWSPy, linear combinations of unconditional random spatial fields are conditioned to the observational data. This involves the exact local representation of rain gauge observations as well as the consideration of the path-averaged precipitation along the CMLs. Additionally, the method ensures that resulting estimates are similar to the data with respect to spatial correlations and marginal distributions. The stochastic process allows for variability at unobserved locations and thereby the calculation of ensembles.

    We evaluate the spatial pattern of our results by performance characteristics such as ensemble Structure-, Amplitude-, and Location-error (eSAL). This approach considers precipitation objects as connected areas that exceed a certain precipitation value, and involves the analysis of the objects’ shapes and locations. Thereby, it is possible to quantify aspects of precipitation patterns in a way that is not possible with standard performance metrics which are based on pixel-by-pixel comparisons.

    We find that our precipitation estimates are in good agreement with the gauge-adjusted weather radar product RADOLAN-RW of the German Weather Service which we use as a reference. In particular, we see advantages in reproducing the pattern of precipitation objects, in terms of smaller structure- and location-errors, when comparing our ensemble-based Random-Mixing approach to an Ordinary Kriging interpolation.

    How to cite: Blettner, N., Chwala, C., Haese, B., Hörning, S., and Kunstmann, H.: Combining commercial microwave link and rain gauge observations to estimate countrywide precipitation: a stochastic reconstruction and pattern analysis approach, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10355, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10355, 2022.

    EGU22-10437 | Presentations | HS7.1

    Uncertainty Quantification of Precipitation Measurement with Weather Radar 

    Angelica Caseri and Carlos Frederico Angelis

    Extreme rainfall events can cause flash floods and are responsible for socioeconomic damage worldwide. In Campinas, southeastern Brazil, countless events take place throughout the year. In order to monitor and predict these events, with the support of Fapesp's SOS-Chuva project, a mobile rainfall radar was installed in the region. With the purpose to identify the accuracy of this data, the radar data were compared with rain gauge data. Through this study, it is noted that, at some points, the difference between the rain gauges measurements and the radar data is significant, which may hinder the calibration and performance of a rainfall-runoff hydrological model. To improve the rainfall measurement considering both data source, this study proposes to combine both information and generate rainfall probabilistic maps, derived from geostatistical methods, thus making possible to quantify the uncertainty of these data.

    How to cite: Caseri, A. and Angelis, C. F.: Uncertainty Quantification of Precipitation Measurement with Weather Radar, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10437, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10437, 2022.

    EGU22-10931 | Presentations | HS7.1

    Assessing future extreme rainfall trends through multifractal scaling arguments: A CONUS-wide analysis based on NA-CORDEX model outputs 

    Stergios Emmanouil, Andreas Langousis, Efthymios I. Nikolopoulos, and Emmanouil N. Anagnostou

    The quantification of future flood risk, as well as the assessment of impacts attributed to the evolution of extreme rainfall events under rapidly changing climatic conditions, require multi-year information at adequately high spatiotemporal scales. The spatial and temporal evolution of regional extreme rainfall patterns, however, is quite challenging to describe due to natural climate variability and local topography. Hence, the use of conventional climate model outputs to evaluate the frequency of extreme events may not be conclusive due to significant epistemic uncertainties.  To date, there is limited knowledge on how extreme precipitation patterns will evolve under the influence of climate change, at spatiotemporal resolutions suitable for hydrological modeling, and considering the non-stationarity of rainfall as a process. In this study, we evaluate future trends related to extreme rainfall using hourly estimates acquired through the North American (NA) CORDEX Program (see Mearns et al., 2017), spanning from 1979 to 2100, over a 25-km CONUS-wide grid. In view of the practical importance of high spatial and temporal resolutions in hydrological modeling, we first simultaneously bias-correct and statistically downscale the NA-CORDEX model outputs, by using the two-component theoretical distribution framework described in Emmanouil et al. (2021), as well as the Stage IV weather radar-based gridded precipitation data (4-km spatial resolution) as a high-resolution reference. To investigate the validity of the yielded rainfall intensity quantiles, we use as benchmark the hourly rainfall measurements offered by NOAA’s rain gauge network (National Centers for Environmental Information, 2017). Finally, to evaluate the effects of climate change on the spatial and temporal evolution of rare precipitation events while taking into consideration the nonstationary nature of rainfall, we apply a robust (Emmanouil et al., 2020) parametric approach founded on multifractal scaling arguments (Langousis et al., 2009) to sequential 10-year segments of the data, where conditions can be fairly assumed stationary. In view of revealing future infrastructure vulnerabilities over a wide range of characteristic temporal scales and exceedance probability levels, our analysis is founded on Intensity-Duration-Frequency (IDF) curves, which are derived using the previously acquired CORDEX-based, gridded (4-km), hourly precipitation estimates, and cover the entire CONUS for a period of 120 years.

    References

    Emmanouil, S., Langousis, A., Nikolopoulos, E. I., & Anagnostou, E. N. (2020). Quantitative assessment of annual maxima, peaks-over-threshold and multifractal parametric approaches in estimating intensity-duration-frequency curves from short rainfall records. Journal of Hydrology, 589, 125151. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhydrol.2020.125151

    Emmanouil, S., Langousis, A., Nikolopoulos, E. I., & Anagnostou, E. N. (2021). An ERA-5 Derived CONUS-Wide High-Resolution Precipitation Dataset Based on a Refined Parametric Statistical Downscaling Framework. Water Resources Research, 57(6), 1–17. https://doi.org/10.1029/2020WR029548

    Langousis, A., Veneziano, D., Furcolo, P., & Lepore, C. (2009). Multifractal rainfall extremes: Theoretical analysis and practical estimation. Chaos, Solitons and Fractals, 39(3), 1182–1194. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chaos.2007.06.004

    Mearns, L. O., McGinnis, S., Korytina, D., Arritt, R., Biner, S., Bukovsky, M., et al. (2017). The NA-CORDEX dataset, version 1.0. NCAR Climate Data Gateway. Boulder (CO): The North American CORDEX Program, 10.

    National Centers for Environmental Information. (2017). Cooperative Observers Program Hourly Precipitation Dataset (C-HPD), Version 2.0 Beta. NOAA National Centers for Environmental Information, [accessed July 17, 2020].

    How to cite: Emmanouil, S., Langousis, A., Nikolopoulos, E. I., and Anagnostou, E. N.: Assessing future extreme rainfall trends through multifractal scaling arguments: A CONUS-wide analysis based on NA-CORDEX model outputs, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10931, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10931, 2022.

    EGU22-11055 | Presentations | HS7.1

    Intensity-dependence of interarrival times and run lengths in multifractal rainfall 

    Alin-Andrei Carsteanu, Andreas Langousis, and Roberto Deidda

    Mass scaling of atmospheric precipitation has been successfully characterized by multifractal frameworks in the literature dedicated to this subject. However, the dependence of the statistics of interarrival times and run lengths on the employed detection threshold, as theoretically predicted by multiplicative cascade models with different degrees of multifractality, is yet another aspect of interest when such models are being used for the purpose of rainfall modelling. It must be noted that interarrival times and run lengths are complementary variables, by representing uninterrupted time intervals above and below the detection threshold, respectively. The present communication deals with the intricacies of parametrizing and validating those aspects of multifractal rainfall models.

    How to cite: Carsteanu, A.-A., Langousis, A., and Deidda, R.: Intensity-dependence of interarrival times and run lengths in multifractal rainfall, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11055, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11055, 2022.

    EGU22-11126 | Presentations | HS7.1

    Accounting for anisotropy in the simulation of rainfall fields with blunt extension of discrete Universal Multifractal cascades 

    Auguste Gires, Ioulia Tchiguirinskaia, and Daniel Schertzer

    Universal Multifractals have been widely used to characterize and simulate geophysical fields extremely variable over a wide range of scales such as rainfall. Despite strong limitations, notably its non-stationnarity, discrete cascades are often used to simulate such fields. Recently, blunt cascades have been introduced in 1D, 2D, and space-time to cope with this issue while remaining in the simple framework of discrete cascades. It basically consists in geometrically interpolating over moving windows the multiplicative increments at each cascade steps.

     

    While being a well-known feature of rainfall fields, anisotropy is not yet addressed with blunt extensions of discrete Universal Multifractal cascades. In this paper, we suggest to extend this framework to account for anisotropy. It basically consists in using different sizes according to the direction for the moving window over which the interpolation is carried out. In a first step Multifractal expected behaviour is theoretically established. Then it is numerically confirmed with the help of ensembles of stochastic simulations. Finally, the features of simulated fields are compared with actual rainfall data ones. Data collected with help of a dual polarisation X-band radar operated by HM&Co-ENPC is used (radx.enpc.fr/).

     

    Authors acknowledge the RW-Turb project (supported by the French National Research Agency - ANR-19-CE05-0022), for partial financial support.

    How to cite: Gires, A., Tchiguirinskaia, I., and Schertzer, D.: Accounting for anisotropy in the simulation of rainfall fields with blunt extension of discrete Universal Multifractal cascades, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11126, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11126, 2022.

    EGU22-11273 | Presentations | HS7.1

    A new perspective on projected precipitation changes in Tanzania 

    Stephanie Gleixner, Jascha Lehmann, and Christoph Gornott

    Informed decision-making on adaptation strategies for future climate change need reliable climate information. In particular, vulnerable economies like Tanzania, which is strongly reliant on rain-fed agriculture, struggle with the lack of agreement on precipitation changes between the climate models. In order to find robustness in these projections, we compare precipitation simulations from the CORDEX Africa Ensemble under three emission scenarios (RCP 2.6, RCP 4.5, RCP 8.5) within different precipitation categories defined by the Standardized Precipitation Index (SPI). We find that despite the disagreement on the sign of the total precipitation trend, there is strong agreement among on a decrease in normal conditions and an increase in both extreme wet and extreme dry conditions throughout the 21st century. The differences between the projections in terms of total precipitation are related to shifts of (near) normal conditions to wetter conditions in the case of ‘wetter’ projections and to drier conditions for ’drier’ projections. These results indicate an overall broadening of the rainfall distribution especially toward extremely wet conditions.

    How to cite: Gleixner, S., Lehmann, J., and Gornott, C.: A new perspective on projected precipitation changes in Tanzania, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11273, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11273, 2022.

    EGU22-11629 | Presentations | HS7.1

    Clarifying the importance of serial correlation and field significance in detection of trends in extreme rainfall 

    Stefano Farris, Roberto Deidda, Francesco Viola, and Giuseppe Mascaro

    Rainfall extremes are expected to intensify in a warmer environment according to theoretical arguments and climate model projections. Inferential analysis involving statistical trend testing procedures are frequently used to validate this scenario by investigating whether significant changes in precipitation measurements can be detected. Recent studies have shown that statistical trend tests applied to hydrological data might be misinterpreted if (1) the analyzed time series exhibit autocorrelation, and (2) field significance is not considered when tests are applied multiple times. In this study, these aspects have been investigated using time series of frequencies (or counts) of rainfall extremes derived from long-term (100 years) daily rainfall records of 1087 gauges of the Global Historical Climate Network (GHCN) database. Monte Carlo experiments are carried out by generating random synthetic count time series with the Poisson first-order Integer-valued AutoRegressive model (Poisson-INAR(1)) characterized by different sample size, level of autocorrelation, and trend magnitude. The main results are as follows. (1) Empirical autocorrelations are highly consistent with those exhibited by uncorrelated and non-stationary count time series, while empirical trends cannot be explained as the exclusive effect of autocorrelation; moreover, accounting for the impact of serial correlation has a limited impact on tests’ performance. (2) Accounting for field significance prevents wrong interpretations of results of multiple tests by limiting type-I errors, but it may reduce test power; a careful use of local test outcomes could help identify regions with potentially significant changes where clusters of multiple trends with coherent signs are detected. (3) Statistical trend tests based on linear and Poisson regressions are more powerful than nonparametric tests (e.g., Mann-Kendall) when applied to count time series. Finally, using these methodological insights, spatial patterns of statistically significant increasing (decreasing) trends emerge in central and eastern North America, northern Europe, part of northern Asia, and central regions of Australia (southwestern North America, part of southern Europe, and southwestern and southeastern regions of Australia).

    How to cite: Farris, S., Deidda, R., Viola, F., and Mascaro, G.: Clarifying the importance of serial correlation and field significance in detection of trends in extreme rainfall, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11629, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11629, 2022.

    Evaluation of winter mean precipitation over North India in CMIP6 models

    Nischal Sharma1, Raju Attada1*, A. R. Dandi2, R. K. Kunchala3, Anant Parekh2, J. S. Chowdary2

    1Department of Earth and Environmental Sciences - Indian Institute of Science Education and Research Mohali, Punjab – 140306

    2 Indian Institute of Tropical Meteorology, Pune, India

    3Centre for Atmospheric Sciences, Indian Institute of Technology Delhi, India

    *E-mail of corresponding author: rajuattada@iisermohali.ac.in

     

    Abstract

    North India receives a significant proportion of annual precipitation during winter (December to February) through mid-latitudinal cyclonic perturbations (Western Disturbances) embedded in subtropical westerly jet stream. This region accounts for a paucity of available in-situ observations owing to complex topography which underpins the necessity of other non-conventional tools for precipitation estimation. Global Climate Models are an effective tool to investigate global monsoon systems and are being extensively used to better understand spatio-temporal characteristics of precipitation. In the present study, north Indian winter precipitation (NIWP) and its variability has been characterized in 30 CMIP6 historical simulations (1979-2014) and compared with IMD gridded data observations. Normalized biases in different models relative to observations have been used to categorize models as wet (11), dry (8) and normal (11) models and further composite analysis has been conducted for these model categories. Our findings suggest that all the models show highest precipitation orientation along the western Himalayan belt, with the normal model category showcasing quite similar results to observations. Wet models show highest variability, errors and positive bias over the region while dry models exhibit least variability and negative bias. Majority of the models show an overall good correlation with observations. The representation of winter mean dynamical and circulation patterns has been carried out using composite analysis of three model categories relative to observations. The composite analysis reveals an intensified jet in both wet and dry model categories, with a southward shift of the jet position in wet models.  Detailed results will be discussed.

    Keywords: Global climate models, CMIP6, winter precipitation

    How to cite: Sharma, N.: Evaluation of winter mean precipitation over North India in CMIP6 models, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12030, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12030, 2022.

    EGU22-526 | Presentations | HS7.2

    Throughfall variability at the hillslope scale: the role of topography and tree characteristics 

    Matteo Verdone, Marco Borga, Andrea Dani, Federico Preti, Paolo Trucchi, Giulia Zuecco, Ilja van Meerveld, Christian Massari, and Daniele Penna

    Understanding the role of forest on rainfall interception is fundamental for a correct analysis and modelling of runoff generation and catchment hydrological response. Despite many studies were carried out at the stand and hillslope scale, very little is known about the role of hillslope topography and the associated tree population characteristics on throughfall spatio-temporal variability. Therefore, this work aimed at better understanding the dominant factors on throughfall variability and on the temporal persistence of throughfall spatial patterns along a transect on a steep hillslope characterized by trees with different size and density.

    The experimental activities were carried out in the upper part of the densely-forested Re della Pietra catchment, Tuscany Apennines, Central Italy. The hillslope is roughly 110 m long and 60 m wide, has a mean slope of 30°, and is dominantly covered by beech trees and by sparce individuals of oak trees. A grid of 126 throughfall collectors was installed in July 2020 and divided in three sub-plots: two plots of 144 m2 with 2-m spaced 49 collectors at the bottom and the top of the hillslope, and a transect of 28 1-m spaced collectors from the bottom to the top of the hillslope. A survey was conducted to measure the diameter and basal area of the stand. Throughfall was manually measured from the collectors approximately monthly from June 2020 to November 2021, and compared with gross precipitation measured by a rain gauge placed outside the vegetation cover. Moreover, five automatic gauges connected to 1.5 m-long gutter to increase the collection area were installed in November 2021 along the hillslope to measure throughfall at high temporal resolution.

    Preliminary results from 25 manual measurements over the experimental grid highlighted a large temporal variability of interception (mean: 17%, standard deviation: ±31%), reflecting the variable seasonal precipitation pattern of Mediterranean areas and the phenological stage of trees (leaves/no leaves). Overall, the spatial variability in throughfall increased with increasing gross precipitation. Particularly, the bottom plot, characterized by lower tree density and larger tree size compared to the top plot, showed a lower spatial variability with respect to the top plot, while the longitudinal transect exhibited an intermediate variability. Analogously, the temporal stability analysis revealed that the most temporally-stable and representative measurement points laid on the transect that, overall, captured the different tree characteristics along the hillslope.

    Future work will make use of the high-resolution measurements of the five gauges to assess their representativeness compared to the manual grid and to test and validate an interception model at the hillslope scale to be possibly upscaled to the entire catchment.

    How to cite: Verdone, M., Borga, M., Dani, A., Preti, F., Trucchi, P., Zuecco, G., van Meerveld, I., Massari, C., and Penna, D.: Throughfall variability at the hillslope scale: the role of topography and tree characteristics, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-526, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-526, 2022.

    EGU22-961 | Presentations | HS7.2

    Evaluation of the Performance of Multi-Source Satellite Products in Simulating Precipitation over the Tensift Basin in Morocco 

    wiam salih, Abdelghani chehbouni, and Terence Epule Epule

    The Tensift basin in Morocco is prominent for its ecological and hydrological diversity. This diversity is marked by rivers flowing into areas such as Ourika. In addition to agriculture, the basin is a hub of variable land use systems. It is important to have a better understanding of the relationship between simulated and observed precipitation measurements in this region to be able to better understand the role of precipitation in the variability of the climate and water resources in the basin. This study aims at evaluating the performance of multi-source satellite products against weather stations precipitation in the basin. In this work, the satellite product based data were first culled for seven satellite products namely PERSIANN, PERSIANN CDR, TRMM3B42, ARC2, RFE2, CHIRPS, and ERA5 (simulated precipitation) from, CHRS iRain, RainSphere, NASA, EUMETSAT, NOAA, FEWS NET, ECMWF respectively. Precipitation observations data from six weather stations, located at Tachedert (2343 m), Imskerbour (1404 m), Asni (1170 m), Grawa (550 m), Agdal (489 m), and Agafay (487 m) at different altitudes, latitudes and temporal scales (1D, 1M, 1Y), over the period 13/05/2007 and 31/09/2019, at Tensift basin were used. The data were compared and analyzed through inferential statistics such as Nash-Sutcliffe Efficiency Coefficient, Bias, Root Mean Square Error (RMSE), Root Mean Square Deviation (RMSD), the standard deviation, the Correlation Coefficient (R) and the Coefficient of Determination (R²) and visualized through taylor diagrams and scatter plots to have a visual idea of the closeness between the seven satellite products and the observed precipitation data. A second analysis was carried out on the monthly precipitation resulting from the six weather stations based on standardized precipitation index (SPI) in order to  determine the onset, duration, and magnitude of the meteorological drought. The results show that PERSIANN CDR performs best and is more reliable with regrad to its ability to estimate precipitation rates over a wide spatial and temporal scale over the basin. The precipitation of Persiann CDR  has significant rates for the different statistics (Bias: -0.05 (Daily asni), RMSE: 2.86 (Daily Agdal), R: 0.83, R²:0.687 (Monthly Agdal)). However, most of the time, this product records low or negative Nash values (-6.06 (Annual Grawa)), due to the insufficient weather station data in the study area (Tensift). It  was observed that TRMM overestimates precipitation during heavy precipitation and underestimates during low precipitation. This makes it important for the latter observations to be viewed with caution due to the quality of annual comparison results and underscores the need to develop more efficient precipitation comparison approaches. Also, the performance of the satellite products is better at low altitudes and during wet years. Finally, it was concluded from the SPI that Tensift Region has experienced 13 drought periods over the study period, with the longest event of 12 months was from Marsh 2015 to February 2016 and  the most intense event with the highest drought severity (19.6) and the lowest SPI value (-2.66) was in 2019.

    How to cite: salih, W., chehbouni, A., and Epule, T. E.: Evaluation of the Performance of Multi-Source Satellite Products in Simulating Precipitation over the Tensift Basin in Morocco, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-961, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-961, 2022.

    Data availability and accuracy is predominantly an issue for building hydrological applications, particularly in data-scare regions, like Africa. This is further one of the challenges that hinders understanding the climate variability and its subsequent extreme flood and drought events. Forcing data from different sources, e.g., satellite sensors, in-situ observations, or reanalysis products, are required to derive hydrological models. Reanalysis products have recently become an alternative tool of meteorological data given their long record at various temporal and spatial scales. The overarching goal of this study is to evaluate the primary forcing data for hydrological models; precipitation, as produced by six different reanalysis data (JRA55, 20CRv3, ERA5, ERA-20C, MERRA, NCEP/NCAR). We here focused our evaluation on the major river basins in Africa during a 15-year period spanning from 2001 to 2015. The five major river basins include the Nile River, Congo River, Zambezi River, Orange River, and Niger River basins. Our evaluation method is summarized as follows: Firstly, precipitation data is compared with the gridded gauged data, e.g., CHIRPS for precipitation. Secondly, statistical indices, including categorical and continuous statistical metrics, will be used to assess the accuracy of reanalysis products over each of the major basins. Finally, we present the intercomparison of reanalysis products for extreme events including floods and droughts. The results from our evaluation will pinpoint the skill of reanalysis products and thus benefit the future development of hydrological modeling over the river basins in Africa.

    How to cite: Abdelmoneim, H. and Eldardiry, H.: Intercomparison of reanalysis products during extreme flood and drought events: evaluation over the major river basins of Africa, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-970, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-970, 2022.

    EGU22-2494 | Presentations | HS7.2

    Storm movement effects on the flash flood response of the Kan catchment 

    Shahin Khosh Bin Ghomash, Daniel Bachmann, Daniel Caviedes-Voullième, and Christoph Hinz

    Rainfall is a complex, spatial and temporally variated process and one of the core inputs for hydrological and hydrodynamic modelling. Most rainfalls are known to be moving storms with varying directions and velocities. Storm movement is known to be an important influence on runoff generation, both affecting peak discharge and the shape of hydrographs. Therefore, exploring the extent rainfall dynamics affect runoff generation and consequently flooded areas, can be an asset in effective flood risk management.

    In this work, we study how storm movement (e.g. characterized by velocity and direction) can affect surface flow generation, water levels and flooded areas within a catchment. Moreover, the influence of rainfall temporal variability in correlation with storm movement is taken into account. This is achieved by means of numerical-based, spatially explicit surface flow simulations using the tool ProMaIDes (2021), a free software for risk-based evaluation of flood risk mitigation measures. The storm events are generated using a microcanonical random cascade model and further on trajected across the catchment area.

    The study area is the Kan river catchment located in the province of Tehran (Iran) with a total area of 836 km², which has experienced multiple flooding events in recent years. Due to its semi-arid climate, steep topography with narrow valleys, this area has high potential for flash flood occurrence as a result of high intensity precipitation.

    The results of this study show a range of possible magnitudes of influence of rainfall movement on the catchment´s runoff response. The resulting flood maps highlight the importance of rainfall velocity and most importantly the direction of the movement in the estimation of flood events as well as their likelihood in catchment area. Moreover, its shown that the magnitude of influence of storm velocity and direction on discharge  strongly depends on the location within the river network which it is measured.

    ProMaIDes (2021): Protection Measures against Inundation Decision support. https://promaides.h2.de

    How to cite: Khosh Bin Ghomash, S., Bachmann, D., Caviedes-Voullième, D., and Hinz, C.: Storm movement effects on the flash flood response of the Kan catchment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2494, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2494, 2022.

    EGU22-2840 | Presentations | HS7.2

    Dual-polarisation X-band radar estimates of precipitation assessed using a distributed hydrological model for mountainous catchments in Scotland 

    John R. Wallbank, Steven J. Cole, Robert J. Moore, David Dufton, Ryan R. Neely III, and Lindsay Bennett

    Observing, in a quantitative and robust way, the dynamic space-time pattern of precipitation in mountainous terrain presents a major challenge of great practical importance. The difficulties of this task are further exacerbated in mid to high latitudes where the typical melting layer for precipitation (i.e. the 0°C isotherm) is often close to the surface during winter months. One way to address this challenge is by improving observations made using networks of weather radars. Quantitative Precipitation Estimates (QPEs) derived from these instruments have many applications, for example as input to a hydrological model to simulate river flow for flood forecasting purposes. 


    Here, a set of QPEs - obtained from an observation campaign using the National Centre for Atmospheric Science’s mobile X-band dual-polarisation Doppler weather radar (NXPol) in a mountainous area of Northern Scotland - are assessed with reference to observed river flows. Each form of QPE is used as an input to Grid-to-Grid (G2G), a distributed hydrological model used for flood forecasting across Great Britain, and the simulated river flows compared to observations. The location of the radar was specially chosen to infill an area of reduced coverage in the existing C-band radar network for the British Isles.

    Assessments of radar QPE often only examine a final precipitation “best estimate” product and typically with reference to raingauges at specific locations. Here, we exploit the processing capabilities of NXPol and the hydrological modelling framework to investigate the benefits of ten separate processing methods that increase with complexity and make differing use of dual-polarisation variables. The role of the radar beam elevation and distance from the radar is investigated, and NXPol QPEs are compared to that provided by the radar network. Additionally, a preliminary investigation is carried out into the role of the drop-size distribution on the relationship between radar-reflectivity and rain-rate using disdrometer data.

    The hydrological assessment reported on here has the benefit of integrating the precipitation over space and time which serves to complement and extend a previous meteorological assessment using raingauge data alone. The assessment proves to be insensitive to issues affecting both raingauges (e.g. representativity, wind-induced under-catch) and local artefacts in the space-time radar-rainfall field. It facilitates a direct assessment of whether potential benefits in the new QPEs are carried forward to an end-use such as flood forecasting, providing fresh insights for the development of new dual-polarisation radar QPE methods.

    How to cite: Wallbank, J. R., Cole, S. J., Moore, R. J., Dufton, D., Neely III, R. R., and Bennett, L.: Dual-polarisation X-band radar estimates of precipitation assessed using a distributed hydrological model for mountainous catchments in Scotland, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2840, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2840, 2022.

    EGU22-2887 | Presentations | HS7.2

    Intercomparison between 2DVD and MRR Datasets 

    Christopher K. Blouin, Carson A. Barber, and Michael L. Larson

    Simultaneous measurements of the rain drop size distribution were made by a 2-dimensional video disdrometer (2DVD, Joanneum Research, Graz, Austria) and a MicroRain Radar-Pro (MRR-Pro, Metek, Elmshorn, Germany) deployed near Charleston, South Carolina, USA and horizontally separated by approximately 20 meters. The 2DVD data was post-processed to correct for spurious drop detection and incorrect assignment of effective sensor area, and the MRR-Pro spectral data was corrected to incorporate a height-dependent estimate of the ambient vertical wind. Surface 2DVD drop measurements were utilized to reconstruct an approximation of the drop size distribution aloft at different heights and times to compare to the inferred MRR-Pro drop spectrum and bulk rain parameters. Despite fundamentally different measurement principles and different sets of assumptions associated with the reconstruction of drop size distributions aloft, the agreement between the 2DVD and MRR-Pro data showed promise. The two data sets are further investigated in order to reveal possible features of boundary layer rain vertical variability, estimates of drop-drop collision rates, and near-surface rain microphysical phenomena.

    How to cite: Blouin, C. K., Barber, C. A., and Larson, M. L.: Intercomparison between 2DVD and MRR Datasets, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2887, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2887, 2022.

    EGU22-3256 | Presentations | HS7.2

    Dual-frequency radar retrievals of snowfall using Random Forest 

    Tiantian Yu, Chandra V.Chandrasekar, Hui Xiao, Ling Yang, and Li Luo

    The microphysical parameters of snowfall directly impact the hydrological and atmospheric models. Dual-frequency radar retrievals of particle size distribution (PSD) parameters are developed and evaluated over complex terrain during the International Collaborative Experiment held during the Pyeongchang 2018 Olympics and Paralympic winter games (ICE-POP 2018). The observations used to develop retrievals were included the NASA Dual-frequency Dualpolarized Doppler Radar (D3R) and a collection of second-generation Particle Size and Velocity (PARSIVEL2) disdrometer. Conventional look-up table method (LUT) and random forest method are applied to the disdrometer data to develop retrievals for volume-weighted mean diameter Dm, the shape factor mu, snowfall rate S, and ice water content IWC. Evaluations are performed between D3R radar and disdrometer observations using these two methods. The results show that the random forest method performs better in retrieving microphysical parameters because the mean errors of the retrievals relative to disdrometer observations are small compared with the LUT method.

    How to cite: Yu, T., V.Chandrasekar, C., Xiao, H., Yang, L., and Luo, L.: Dual-frequency radar retrievals of snowfall using Random Forest, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3256, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3256, 2022.

    EGU22-4319 | Presentations | HS7.2

    Testing nonlinearity and nonstationarity of the connection between Palmer drought indices and Danube discharge in the lower basin 

    Ileana Mares, Constantin Mares, Venera Dobrica, and Crisan Demetrescu

    The aim of the study is to reduce the uncertainty of the influence of Palmer-type drought indices in estimating seasonal discharge in the lower Danube basin. For this, four indices were considered: Palmer Drought Severity Index (PDSI), Palmer Hydrological Drought Index (PHDI), Weighted PDSI (WPLM) and Palmer Z-index (ZIND). These indices were quantified by PC1 of EOF decomposition, obtained from 15 stations located along the Danube basin.

    The influences of these indices on the Danube discharge were tested, both simultaneously and with certain lags, by linear and nonlinear methods applying the elements of information theory. Nonstationarity was tested by wavelet analysis. The results differ depending on the season and the Palmer index.

    The linear connections are generally obtained for synchronous links, and the nonlinear and nonstationary ones for the predictors considered with certain lags (in advance) compared to the discharge predictand. This result is useful for estimating the discharge, as Palmer indices can be estimated from the simulated data by the General Circulation Models or Regional Climate Models.

     

    How to cite: Mares, I., Mares, C., Dobrica, V., and Demetrescu, C.: Testing nonlinearity and nonstationarity of the connection between Palmer drought indices and Danube discharge in the lower basin, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4319, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4319, 2022.

    EGU22-4756 | Presentations | HS7.2

    Impact of Additional Assimilation of Dual-Polarimetric Parameters: Analysis and Forecasts in a Real Case 

    Bing-Xue Zhuang, Kao-Shen Chung, and Chih-Chien Tsai

    The purpose of this study is to investigate the impact of assimilating dual-polarimetric parameters, i.e. differential reflectivity (ZDR) and specific differential phase (KDP), in addition to reflectivity (ZH) and radial wind (Vr) in a severe weather system. A squall line case forced by the synoptic southwesterly wind is selected to conduct the assimilation experiments. Besides, different microphysics parameterization schemes, including GCE, MOR, WSM6 and WDM6, are examined in the experiments. The results of the analysis field show that assimilating additional ZDR with single moment schemes (GCE and WSM6) can capture better mean raindrop size, yet it deteriorates the intensity of simulated ZH and KDP. Differ from GCE and WSM6, assimilating additional ZDR with double moment schemes (MOR and WDM6) would not lead to significant deterioration in the simulated ZH and KDP since the prognostic hydrometeor variables in double moment schemes include both mixing ratio and total number concentration. There will be more flexibility in adjusting microphysical states with two independent prognostic hydrometeor variables. The results of the short-term quantitative precipitation forecast (QPF) show that assimilating additional dual-polarimetric parameters with either single or double moment schemes increases the maximum of accumulated rainfall and the probability of heavy rainfall. In conclusion, double moment schemes can make better use of the extra information from dual-polarimetric parameters; furthermore, assimilating additional dual-polarimetric parameters, even with single moment schemes, can improve the performance of QPF, especially heavy rainfall events.

    How to cite: Zhuang, B.-X., Chung, K.-S., and Tsai, C.-C.: Impact of Additional Assimilation of Dual-Polarimetric Parameters: Analysis and Forecasts in a Real Case, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4756, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4756, 2022.

    EGU22-5361 | Presentations | HS7.2

    Mesoscale precipitation nowcasting from weather radar data using space-time-separable graph convolutional networks 

    Daniele Trappolini, Luca Scofano, Alessio Sampieri, Francesco Messina, Fabio Galasso, Saverio Di Fabio, and Frank Silvio Marzano

    Forecasting weather systems are capable to model atmospheric phenomena at various space-time scales. At very short space-time nowcasting techniques are still relying on measured data processing from ground-based microwave radars and satellite-based geostationary spectrometers. In this respect, precipitation field nowcasting from a few minutes up to a few hours is one of the most challenging goals to provide rapid and accurate updated features for civil prevention and protection decision-makers (e.g., from emergency services, marine services, sport, and cultural events, air traffic control, emergency management, agricultural sector and moreover flood early-warning system). Deep learning precipitation nowcasting models, based on weather radar network reflectivity measurements, have recently exceeded the overall performance of traditional extrapolation models, becoming one of the hottest topics in this field. This work proposes a novel network architecture to increase the performance of deep learning mesoscale precipitation prediction. Since precipitation nowcasting can be viewed as a video prediction problem, we present an architecture based on Graph Convolutional Neural Network (GCNN) for video frame prediction. Our solution exploits, as a cornerstone, the topology of Space-Time-Separable Graph-Convolutional- Network (STS-GCN), originally used for posing forecasting. We have applied our model on the TAASRAD19 radar data set with the aim of comparing our performance with other models, namely the Stacked Generalization (SG) Trajectory Gated Recurrent Unit (TrajGRU) and S-PROG Spectral Lagrangian extrapolation program (S-PROG).

    The proposed model, named STSU-GCN (Space-Time-Separable Unet3d Graph Convolutional Network), has a structure composed of an encoder, decoder, and forecaster. The role of the encoder and decoder are accomplished by a Unet3d a structure borrowed with the specific purpose of modifying the spatial component, but not the temporal component. In the bottleneck of this Unet3D network, we use a graph-based forecaster. The performance of the STSU-GCN has been quantified using conventional metrics, such as the Critical Success Index (CSI), widely used in the meteorological community for the nowcasting task. Using TAASRAD19 radar data set and literature data, these CSI metrics have been applied to 4 different classes of rain rate, that is 5, 10, 20, 30 mm/h. Our STSU-GCN model has overperformed both TrajGRU and S-PROG in the classes 10 mm/h and 20 mm/h obtaining a CSI respectively of 0.148 and 0.097. On the other hand, STSU-GCN is underperforming in class 5mm per hour getting a CSI respectively of 0.099. Our STSU-GCN model is aligned with the results of the S-PROG benchmark, for the class 30 mm/h confirming a model skillful for classes with a high rain rate. In this work, we will also illustrate the results of the proposed STSU-GCN algorithm using case studies in the area of interest of the Italian Central Apennines during the summer of 2021. Statistical performances, potential developments, and critical issues of the STSU-GCN algorithm will be also discussed.

    How to cite: Trappolini, D., Scofano, L., Sampieri, A., Messina, F., Galasso, F., Di Fabio, S., and Marzano, F. S.: Mesoscale precipitation nowcasting from weather radar data using space-time-separable graph convolutional networks, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5361, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5361, 2022.

    Vertically pointing radars (VPRs) provide detailed observations of precipitating cloud systems as they pass directly over the radar site. Two VPRs operating side-by-side and at different millimeter wavelengths (mm-wave) will observe the same raindrops but will have different return signals due to wavelength dependent raindrop backscattering and attenuation characteristics. These differences enable the retrieval of raindrop size distributions and vertical air motions. Yet, as the rain rate increases, the attenuation increases. Eventually, at some combination of path length [km] and rain specific attenuation [dB/km], the attenuation [dB] will extinguish high frequency VPR return signals; limiting high frequency VPRs to studying rain processes close to the ground. 

    In order to estimate how far VPRs can measure into rain shafts, this study simulated constant rain rate precipitation columns and then estimated the path length needed to produced enough attenuation to drop the VPR signal-to-noise ratio below the VPR’s detection limit. This study used surface disdrometer observations and publically available T-Matrix scattering code to produce realistic VPR measurements at frequencies from 3 to 200 GHz.

    These simulations found that in order to observe raindrops above a 3.5 km rain shaft, the constant rain rate needed to be less than 138, 67, 26, 14, and 4 mm/h for VPRs operating in the X-, Ku-, K-, Ka-, and W-bands, respectively (i.e., 9, 13.6, 24, 35.6, and 94 GHz). Additionally, due solely to atmospheric gas attenuation, the G-band (200 GHz) VPR return signal will be completely extinguished by 3.5 km. Preventing a G-band VPR from detecting raindrops above 3.5 km.

    How to cite: Williams, C.: How far into a rain shaft can mm-wave vertically pointing radars detect raindrops?, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6386, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6386, 2022.

    EGU22-6420 | Presentations | HS7.2

    An Examination of Alternate Partitioning Methods for Disdrometer Data 

    Brianna G. Brunson and Michael L. Larsen

    Historically, disdrometer data records have been divided into disjoint, equal-time intervals (often of 1- or 5-minute durations). Previous research of drop-resolving disdrometer data taken by the two-dimensional video disdrometer (Joanneum Research, Graz, Austria) has noted evidence of statistical structures on sub-minute timescales, which could lead to underestimations of rainfall variability when 1- or 5-minute partitionings are used. Here, we introduce and explore alternatives to the standard fixed-duration partitioning of disdrometer data. We compare the distributions of standard bulk rain measurements (rainfall rate and mass weighted mean diameter) under each partitioning method to demonstrate the utility of these alternative partitioning methods.

    How to cite: Brunson, B. G. and Larsen, M. L.: An Examination of Alternate Partitioning Methods for Disdrometer Data, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6420, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6420, 2022.

    EGU22-6968 | Presentations | HS7.2

    Improvement of rainfall estimates using opportunistic sensors - the example of the flood in Rhineland-Palatinate in July 2021 

    Micha Eisele, András Bárdossy, Christian Chwala, Norbert Demuth, Abbas El Hachem, Maximilian Graf, Harald Kunstmann, and Jochen Seidel

    Abstract

    Precipitation is highly variable in space and time. Ground-based precipitation gauging networks such as those from national weather services are often not able to capture this variability. Weather radars have the potential to capture the spatio-temporal characteristics of rainfall fields but they also suffer from specific errors such as attenuation. The increasing number and availability of opportunistic sensors (OS), such as commercial microwave links (CML) and personal weather stations (PWS), provides new opportunities to improve rainfall estimates based on ground observations.

    We have developed a geostatistical interpolation method that allows a combination of different opportunistic sensors and their specific features and geometric properties, e.g., point and line information. In addition, the uncertainty of the different data sets can be considered [1].

    The flood event in the western provinces of Germany in July 2021 showed that both, the precipitation interpolations based on rain gauge data from the German National Weather Service and radar-based precipitation products, underestimated precipitation. We show that the additional information of OS data can improve precipitation estimates in terms of areal precipitation amounts and spatial distribution.  

     

    References
    [1] Graf, M., El Hachem, A., Eisele, M., Seidel, J., Chwala, C., Kunstmann, H. and Bárdossy, A.: Rainfall estimates from opportunistic sensors in Germany across spatio-temporal scales, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ejrh.2021.100883

    How to cite: Eisele, M., Bárdossy, A., Chwala, C., Demuth, N., El Hachem, A., Graf, M., Kunstmann, H., and Seidel, J.: Improvement of rainfall estimates using opportunistic sensors - the example of the flood in Rhineland-Palatinate in July 2021, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6968, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6968, 2022.

    EGU22-7339 | Presentations | HS7.2

    A precision raindrop generator to calibrate non-catching rain gauges 

    Enrico Chinchella, Mattia Stagnaro, Arianna Cauteruccio, and Luca G. Lanza

    The need for high-resolution and low maintenance weather stations is the major factor behind the increasing adoption of Non-Catching Gauges (NCGs) by national weather services and research institutions. Data from such instruments are used for several applications and in numerous research fields, where instrumental biases can have a strong impact. For NCGs, rigorous testing and calibration are more challenging than for catching gauges. Hydrometeor characteristics like particle size, shape, fall velocity and density must be carefully reproduced to provide the reference precipitation, instead of the equivalent water flow used for the calibration of catching gauges. Instrument calibration is usually declared by the manufacturers, using internal procedures developed for the specific technology employed. No standard calibration methodology exists, that encompass all or at least most of the available NCGs (Lanza et al. 2021). The EURAMET project 18NRM03 ‘INCIPIT’ on the ‘Calibration and accuracy of non-catching instruments to measure liquid/solid atmospheric precipitation’, was initiated in 2019 to address such issues.

    A calibration device was developed to achieve individual drop generation on demand and in-flight measurement of the released drops. Water drops in the range from 0.5 to 6 mm in diameter are generated to mimic natural raindrops. A high-precision syringe pump is used to form the drop of the desired volume at the tip of a calibrated nozzle. A high-voltage power supply is used to apply a large potential difference between the nozzle and a metallic ring, and the resulting electric field triggers the release of the drop. A precision motorized gantry moves the generator across the horizontal plane, to cover different releasing positions within the instrument sensing area. By either varying the release height or accelerating the drop using compressed air, different fractions of the terminal velocity can be achieved, depending on the drop size. A second gantry, just above the gauge under test, aligns the plane of focus of a high-resolution camera with the fall trajectory of the drop. Three images of the same drop are captured in a single picture, using speedlights triggered at fixed time intervals. Photogrammetric techniques and a photodiode to measure the time between flashes provide the shape, size, speed, and acceleration of the drop. This characterizes each released drop before it reaches the instrument sensing area and, by comparison with the gauge measurement, the instrumental bias is obtained. Laboratory tests are presented to assess the performance of the calibration device.

    This work is funded as part of the activities of the EURAMET project 18NRM03 “INCIPIT Calibration and Accuracy of Non-Catching Instruments to measure liquid/solid atmospheric precipitation”. The project INCIPIT has received funding from the EMPIR programme co-financed by the Participating States and from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme.

    References:

    Lanza L.G. and co-authors, 2021: Calibration of non-catching precipitation measurement instruments: a review. J. Meteorological Applications, 28.3(2021):e2002.

    How to cite: Chinchella, E., Stagnaro, M., Cauteruccio, A., and Lanza, L. G.: A precision raindrop generator to calibrate non-catching rain gauges, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7339, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7339, 2022.

    EGU22-7482 | Presentations | HS7.2

    Comparison of rainfall retrieval from collocated commercial microwave links with adjusted radar reference 

    Anna Špačková, Martin Fencl, and Vojtěch Bareš

    One of the pivotal variables in the hydrological system processes is precipitation. In this context, many hydrological applications require a reliably captured structure and temporal development of rainfalls. Therefore, the crucial challenge is to monitor rainfall in high spatial and temporal resolution. The opportunistic sensors for rainfall measurements have a great potential since they can complete standard observation networks with high number of alternative measuring sensors. Nowadays, one of the most prominent opportunistic source of rainfall information are telecommunication networks composed of commercial microwave links (CMLs). CMLs can supply dense path-averaged rainfall information derived from power-law relationship of the microwave signal attenuation and the rainfall intensity.

    However, the actual implementation and employment requires a careful consideration of the errors and uncertainties of the measurements. In this study, the influence of different state of the rainfall is excluded using the set of pairs of collocated independent CMLs with paths in the immediate vicinity. Therefore, each pair of collocated CMLs can be assumed as identically influenced by the same rainfall conditions, while their characteristics (e.g., lengths, frequencies, polarizations) vary. The dataset consists of 33 rainfall periods within the years 2014 – 2016 monitored by 13 groups of collocated CMLs.

    High correlation (around 0.95) was found for collocated CMLs. Compared to conventional rainfall sensors, for example, Peleg et al. (2013) demonstrated a correlation of 0.92 for collocated tipping bucket rain gauges. The CMLs are also compared with the adjusted weather radar rainfall information which is used as a reference. The dispersion of the data within five intensity ranges was used to set the boundaries (5 % and 95 % quantile). Subsequently, the fit of the CML measurements into the boundaries was examined. CMLs with 0.2 dB/mm/h sensitivity had the highest fit ratio, almost 80 %. Contrastingly, sensors with sensitivity 1.5 dB/mm/h just exceeded the fit ratio of 60 %. Observed differences describe the uncertainties which are not directly driven by the propagation of the signal. The uncertainties of CML need to be further studied to maximize the knowledge-based use of the favourable spatial and temporal resolution of this opportunistic sensing network.

    References
    Peleg, N., Ben-Asher, M., and Morin, E. (2013) Radar subpixel-scale rainfall variability and uncertainty: lessons learned from observations of a dense rain-gauge network, Hydrol. Earth Syst. Sci., 17, 2195–2208, https://doi.org/10.5194/hess-17-2195-2013.


    This study is supported by the project SpraiLINK (20-14151J) of the Czech Science Foundation and by the grant of Czech Technical University in Prague no. SGS21/052/OHK1/1T/11.

    How to cite: Špačková, A., Fencl, M., and Bareš, V.: Comparison of rainfall retrieval from collocated commercial microwave links with adjusted radar reference, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7482, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7482, 2022.

    Adjustments of the wind-induced bias of conventional catching type rain gauges derive from collection efficiency (CE) curves that can be obtained either from field experiments or from numerical simulation (Lanza and Cauteruccio, 2021). The use of numerical simulation allows to overcome the limitations of the experimental installations and monitoring campaigns (e.g., the many influencing variables involved and the variability of the rainfall process) to cover a wide range of wind speed and rainfall intensity (RI) conditions. Also, the accuracy of the measurements taken as a reference is still an issue in field experiments.

    A Lagrangian particle tracking (LPT) model, suitably validated in the wind tunnel (see Cauteruccio et al., 2021), is applied to the results of computational fluid dynamic (CFD) simulations of the airflow field surrounding a rain gauge to derive a simple formulation of the collection efficiency curves as a function of wind speed (Cauteruccio and Lanza, 2020). A new parameterization is proposed to highlight the influence of rainfall intensity, based on the typical form of the drop size distribution (DSD) of rainfall events (data from the Italian territory). The methodology is applied to a cylindrical gauge, which has the typical outer shape of most tipping-bucket rain gauges, as a representative specimen of operational measurement instruments.

    Using rainfall intensity as a controlling factor for the collection efficiency has solid physical bases in the relationship between RI and the DSD (Colli et al., 2020), and the role of RI can only be quantified using numerical simulations of both the airflow field (using CFD) and the particle motion (via the LPT).

    A simple formulation of the adjustment curves is obtained, which can be easily applied in an operational context, since wind velocity is the only ancillary variable required to perform the adjustment. Wind is often measured by operational weather stations together with the precipitation intensity, so the correction adds no relevant burden to the cost of meteo-hydrological networks.

    References

    Cauteruccio, A. and L.G. Lanza (2020). Parameterization of the collection efficiency of a cylindrical catching-type rain gauge based on rainfall intensity. Water, 12(12), 3431. https://doi.org/10.3390/w12123431.

    Cauteruccio, A., Brambilla, E., Stagnaro, M., Lanza, L.G. and D. Rocchi (2021). Wind tunnel validation of a particle tracking model to evaluate the wind-induced bias of precipitation measurements. Water Resour. Res., 57(7), e2020WR028766. https://doi.org/10.1029/2020WR028766.

    Colli, M., Stagnaro, M., Lanza, L.G., R. Rasmussen and J.M. Thériault (2020). Adjustments for Wind-Induced Undercatch in Snowfall Measurements Based on Precipitation Intensity, J. Hydrometerol., 21, 1039-1050, https://doi.org/10.1175/JHM-D-19-0222.1.

    Lanza, L.G and A. Cauteruccio (2021). Accuracy assessment and intercomparison of precipitation measurement instruments. Chapter 1, p. 3 – 35. In: Michaelides, S. (ed.), Precipitation Science. Elsevier, Amsterdam, Netherlands. ISBN: 978-0-12-822973-6, pp. 833. https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-12-822973-6.00007-X.

    How to cite: Lanza, L. G. and Cauteruccio, A.: Influence of the drop size distribution on the collection efficiency of catching gauges as a function of rainfall intensity, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7871, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7871, 2022.

    This research addresses a strong need to precisely improve the statewide seasonal precipitation intensity duration frequency (IDF) estimates at ungauged locations. In order to obtain IDFs at unvisited sites, IDFs observation locations are interpolated. Therefore, different deterministic and geostatistical approaches include Inverse Distance Weighted (IDW), Ordinary kriging (OK), Regression Kriging (RK), Co-Kriging (CoK), Kriging with External Drift (KED), and Functional Kriging (FK) have been taken into account for comparison. Apart from visual assessment, a cross-validation approach is used to compare these methods to judge their prediction accuracy.

    Annual or intra-annual IDF calculations across the state is not well correlated with other variables except elevation, thus directionally smoothed altitude is only considered as a covariate that offered a significant reduction in bias.  All results indicate that IDW interpolation is incapable of improving the regional point IDF approximations provided by kriging algorithms except in the case of annual IDF predictions at shorter scales where its performance is more or less similar to OK.  Whereas summer IDF observations are well predicted by KED that also exhibits good behavior for longer duration extremes of all seasons. Moreover, the shorter duration winter IDF guesstimates are best achieved with CoK. From now, it can be noticed that the accuracy of the interpolator changes according to the hydrological seasons and storm durations.

    Overall, this study ensures to design of a well-planned map in advance for the entire state of Baden Wurttemberg on the basis of accurate forecasting of seasonal IDF estimates of precipitation extremes at unsampled sites. Hence, this crucial step will surely help us to tackle the natural disasters due to climate change before time.

    How to cite: Amin, B. and Bárdossy, A.: Evaluation of various regionalization techniques for the seasonal precipitation IDF estimates of Baden Württemberg, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8106, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8106, 2022.

    EGU22-8119 | Presentations | HS7.2

    Using radar-derived precipitation data for hydrological modelling in selected study sides in Norway 

    Jessica Sienel, Lennart Schönfelder, and Jochen Seidel

    Gathering accurate precipitation data is an important task for setting up hydrological models. In Norway, the gauge network density is higher in the southern parts and decreases in the north. Furthermore, the amount of high evaluated precipitation gauges is rather scarce. Radar data is available but lacks an accurate reflectivity-precipitation relation and errors in precipitation estimation are caused for example by beam blockage.

    For modelling purposes, this study aims to evaluate whether the application of radar derived data gives any benefit, especially when modelling in a higher temporal resolution. The results of this study can give decision support for modellers having difficulties choosing the precipitation product. For that cause, spatial interpolated precipitation products were evaluated and compared in terms of performance in hydrological models. The Meteorological Institute Norway publishes gridded hourly datasets covering the Norwegian mainland: seNorge2, where gauge data is interpolated using an optimal interpolation, and the numerical weather prediction product (NWP), a combination of gauge data, radar data and a numerical weather model. Five different catchments were simulated in the numerical precipitation-runoff model HYPE with both datasets for comparison. The catchments vary in area, hydrological regime and availability of nearby gauges. The simulation was done in an hourly time step in order to compare precipitation variability on a small time scale.

    In this study, a calibration method was developed that generates comparable and stable performance results in terms of the Kling–Gupta efficiency (KGE) for each catchment and dataset. The resulting discharges and water balances of the catchments were analysed and compared. Additionally, selected precipitation events, where the precipitation products were not able to describe atmospheric processes appropriately, were analysed. The datasets were further compared by spatially accumulating annual precipitation sums over the catchments, by using a private weather station to evaluate the fit of the data and by comparing the runoff and precipitation volume of the basins.

    Preliminary results show the significant differences in water volume and spatial distribution of precipitation between these products. Furthermore, when comparing a private gauge with the precipitation products at an ungauged area, daily precipitation data tends to be more accurate than hourly data.

    How to cite: Sienel, J., Schönfelder, L., and Seidel, J.: Using radar-derived precipitation data for hydrological modelling in selected study sides in Norway, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8119, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8119, 2022.

    EGU22-9096 | Presentations | HS7.2

    The Fresnel Platform for increasing the Greater Paris resilience to spatio-temporal variability of local rainfall 

    Guillaume Drouen, Daniel Schertzer, Auguste Gires, and Ioulia Tchiguirinskaia
    Urban areas are at stake under the threat of climate change. To overcome this challenge it is necessary to deepen our understanding of heavier and particularly local rainfall to avoid flooding and build resilient cites that can become sustainable. The main difficulty is that geophysics and urban dynamics are strongly nonlinear with associated extreme variability over a wide range of space-time scales.

    To better connect theoretical and experimental research on these topics, an advanced urban hydro-meteorological observatory with associated SaaS (Software as a Service) developments, the Fresnel platform of the Co-Innovation Lab of the École des Ponts ParisTech, has been purposely set-up. The mission of the Fresnel platform is to facilitate synergies between research and innovation in the pursuit of upstream research and the development of innovative downstream applications. With profiled access for specialized services, it provides the concerned communities with the necessary high resolution measurements in real time and in replay form, that easily yield Big Data.

    The Fresnel platform unites several components. One of them, the RadX SaaS platform, provides online tools to study rainfall data over the greater Paris area (i.e., about 50 km radius and more). It provides an easy access to various products based on precipitation measurements performed by the ENPC polarimetric X-band radar at the pixel scale of 125 m. It broadcasts these measurements in free access and in real-time (https://radx.enpc.fr) together with a point measured environmental parameters provided by another component of Fresnel, namely the exTreme and multi-scAle RAiNdrop parIS observatory (Taranis) observatory, containing several, a 3D sonic anemometer and a meteorological station.

    The RadX platform was developed in participatory co-creation, and in scientific collaboration with the world industrial leader in water management. As the need for data accessibility, fast and reliable infrastructure were major challenges, the platform was constructed as a cloud-based solution. The components that make up this platform are designed to be configurable for specific case studies using an adjustable visual interface. Depending on a case study, specific components can be integrated to meet particular needs using maps, other visual tools and forecasting systems, eventually from third parties.

    Developments are still in progress, with a constant loop of requests and feedback from the scientific and professional world.

    How to cite: Drouen, G., Schertzer, D., Gires, A., and Tchiguirinskaia, I.: The Fresnel Platform for increasing the Greater Paris resilience to spatio-temporal variability of local rainfall, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9096, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9096, 2022.

    EGU22-9515 | Presentations | HS7.2

    Effect of diverse microwave link characteristics on rainfall retrieval errors 

    Martin Fencl, Anna Spackova, and Vojtech Bares

    Commercial microwave links (CMLs), point-to-point radio connections forming the backbone of cellular networks, can be used as opportunistic rainfall sensors and provide rain rate at high temporal resolution. The CML rainfall retrieval methods have been mostly developed for devices operating between 13 – 40 GHz where attenuation-rainfall relation is relatively insensitive to drop size distribution. New deployments have, however, an extensive share of E-band CMLs operating at 71 – 81 GHz frequency where drop size distribution (DSD) represents a major source of errors (Fencl et al., 2020). This study investigates for the first time the joint use of 13-40 GHz and 71-86 GHz CMLs with focus on evaluating different sources of errors.

    Rainfall retrieved from 250 CMLs located in the city of Prague and its vicinity are compared to the quantitative precipitation estimates from C-band weather radar adjusted to the local network of 23 municipal rain gauges. Diverse path-lengths and frequencies of CMLs enable us to distinguish between different sources of errors. Shorter CMLs operated at lower frequencies are dominantly disturbed by errors related to antenna wetting whereas E-band CMLs are significantly more affected by DSD variability and non-uniform distribution of rain rates along the CML path. Moreover, longer E-band CMLs suffer from outages during heavy rainfalls. In general, E-band CMLs are more sensitive to low rain rates and thus suitable for retrieving light rainfalls whereas CMLs operating at lower frequencies are more accurate during heavy rainfalls.

    Diverse characteristics of CMLs typically occurring in real-world cellular networks pose a challenge as each CML is affected by the instrumental errors in a different manner. On the other hand, the diversity in CML characteristics can be also exploited to quantify and possibly reduce these errors, especially in cities, where CML networks are usually dense and thus often provide collocated (redundant) rain rate measurements.

    References:

    Fencl, M., Dohnal, M., Valtr, P., Grabner, M., and Bareš, V.: Atmospheric observations with E-band microwave links – challenges and opportunities, 13, 6559–6578, https://doi.org/10.5194/amt-13-6559-2020, 2020.

    Acknowledgements: This study was conducted within SpraiLINK project (20-14151J) and supported by Czech Science Foundation.

    How to cite: Fencl, M., Spackova, A., and Bares, V.: Effect of diverse microwave link characteristics on rainfall retrieval errors, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9515, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9515, 2022.

    EGU22-9843 | Presentations | HS7.2

    Measuring rainfall with microwave links: the influence of temporal sampling strategies 

    Luuk van der Valk, Miriam Coenders-Gerrits, Rolf Hut, Hidde Leijnse, Aart Overeem, Bas Walraven, and Remko Uijlenhoet

    Single-frequency microwave links can be used to monitor path-averaged precipitation by determining the rain-induced attenuation along the link path, as for example is done with commercial microwave links (CMLs) from cellular telecommunication networks. However, using these networks to estimate precipitation, the temporal resolution of these estimates is bound to the temporal sampling strategy employed by the network operator, which solely uses the information on the link signal to assure the functioning of the network. Moreover, not all operators store the same variables describing the link signal. Most commonly, a temporal resolution of 15 minutes with a recording of the minimum and maximum values during this interval is applied. For research purposes, often higher temporal resolutions in combination with averaged values are preferred. Yet, it is uncertain how these sampling strategies affect the computed amount and intensity of rainfall. To address this uncertainty, we investigate the influence of various temporal sampling strategies regarding the link signal on the estimated amounts and intensities of rainfall events from a single microwave link. For the analysis, we resample microwave link data to multiple intervals and variables characterizing the measured signal. The original data consist of three collocated microwave links sampled at 20 Hz, all operational for more than a year, and covering a 2.2 km path over the city Wageningen in the Netherlands. Additionally, the resulting rainfall estimates for the intervals and variables are compared to measurements of five disdrometers deployed along the link path. Overall, the results of this study can help to quantify the uncertainties associated with rainfall estimates from microwave links.

    How to cite: van der Valk, L., Coenders-Gerrits, M., Hut, R., Leijnse, H., Overeem, A., Walraven, B., and Uijlenhoet, R.: Measuring rainfall with microwave links: the influence of temporal sampling strategies, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9843, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9843, 2022.

    EGU22-9945 | Presentations | HS7.2

    Toward a low-cost disdrometer: Measuring drop size with a cantilever piezo film 

    Chi-Ling Wei and Li-Pen Wang

    Raindrop size distribution (DSD) is the key factor to derive reliable rainfall estimates. It is highly related to a number of integral rainfall parameters, including rain intensity (R), rain water content (W) and radar echo (Z). Disdrometers are the sensors commonly used to measure DSD based upon microwave or laser technologies; for example, JWD (Joss-Waldvogel Disdrometer), Parsivel and 2DVD (Two-Dimensional Video Disdrometer). These sensors may have their own strengths and weakness, but they are all relatively expensive. This hinders the possibility to have a high-density network for observing DSD at large scales. In this work, the ultimate goal is to develop a lightweight and low-cost disdrometer with descent accuracy.

    We started with establishing a model that can well simulate the signal response of a single drop falling on a cantilever piezo film. A series of experiments were conducted to test the reaction of drops at different sizes (i.e. diameters ranging from 2 - 4 mm) and as drops fall onto various locations of the film. We then modelled the collision by assuming the piezo film to be a damped cantilever beam and drop force to be a step force. The drop force can be derived based upon the measurement of the deflection of beam end, which can be further used to calibrate the damp ratio. Preliminary results suggest that the signal response of a single drop hits can be well simulated based upon the proposed model under current experimental setting. We then developed an algorithm to optimize the simulation of signal responses with four four variables; these include drop’s weight, film thickness, film damping ratio and drop force. The result shows that the simulated drop force constitutes a strong linear relationship with the real drop’s weight.

    We are now experimenting on the capacity of the developed model to work with a more complex yet realistic setting. For this purpose, we have created a more realistic rainfall condition by employing a micro pump. This pump can help control the size and timing of drops, so we can generate continuous single drops of consistent quality. In addition, we utilise a simple 1-D laser device to simultaneously measure the size of drops by analyzing the fluctuation in the laser signal. This would enable better understanding the actual size distribution of drops.  We expect that the outcome of the experiments  will provide useful insights on developing low-cost disdrometers with a cantilever piezo film.

    How to cite: Wei, C.-L. and Wang, L.-P.: Toward a low-cost disdrometer: Measuring drop size with a cantilever piezo film, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9945, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9945, 2022.

    EGU22-11125 | Presentations | HS7.2

    Missing extremes in CML rainfall estimates due to total loss of signal 

    Christian Chwala, Julius Polz, Maximilian Graf, and Harald Kunstmann

    Attenuation data from commercial microwave links (CMLs) has proven to provide useful rainfall information. With their high density in urban areas, CMLs offer a great potential to estimate and study rainfall variability on small scales. Since the transmission power of CML hardware is limited, heavy rainfall can, however, lead to a complete loss of signal at the receiving end. As a consequence, very high rain rates can be missing in CML-derived rainfall information. The rain rate for which a specific CML experiences complete loss of signal depends on its length and frequency as well as on its dynamic range which is defined by transmit power, receiver noise level and antenna gain.

    We analyze the occurrence and effect of such complete losses of signal, which we term “blackouts”, using two different datasets. First, a CML dataset with one minute temporal resolution consisting of 4000 CMLs in Germany is used to investigate the blackouts in real CML attenuation data over a period of three years. Second, the gauge-adjusted radar climatology RADKLIM-YW from the German Meteorological Service is used to derive synthetic rain induced attenuation data for each CMLs path with 5-minute temporal resolution for a period of 20 years.

    For the real CML observations we introduce and apply a new algorithm to detect rain induced blackout gaps. This allows us to quantify the number and length of the blackout gaps stemming from heavy rainfall. Using the path-averaged RADKLIM-YW data as reference, we then quantify the rain rates and rainfall amount that is missed due to the CML blackout gaps. We find that longer CMLs are more likely to be affected by blackout gaps. This effect occurs even though the CMLs in our dataset are configured so that longer CMLs have a larger dynamic range to account for the increasing attenuation with increasing length. Using the dynamic range of each CML, we derive the long-term statistics of potential blackout occurrence from the synthetic attenuation data based on RADKLIM-YW. We find a pattern similar to the one in the real CML attenuation data, albeit with a smaller fraction of time steps affected by blackouts for all CMLs.

    Our results provide a reliable basis for researchers to judge the capability of their CML dataset to capture rainfall extremes. Furthermore, it can serve as an improved basis for planning the layout and configuration and thus the dynamic range of individual CMLs.

    How to cite: Chwala, C., Polz, J., Graf, M., and Kunstmann, H.: Missing extremes in CML rainfall estimates due to total loss of signal, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11125, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11125, 2022.

    EGU22-12993 | Presentations | HS7.2

    Using weather radar to classify wet and dry periods for Commercial Microwave Links 

    Erlend Øydvin, Vegard Nilsen, Nils-Otto Kitterød, Mareile Astrid Wolff, and Christoffer Artturi Elo

    Using Commercial Microwave Links (CMLs) for measuring precipitation have gained more and more attention the past 10 years as it seems like a promising supplement to weather radar and rain gauge observations. It works by relating rainfall to signal attenuation along the CMLs path. As the signal level also can change due to other meteorological conditions such as air temperature and water vapor content, this opportunistic sensing method requires sophisticated data processing in order to relate signal attenuation to rain rate. One of the processing steps involves detecting wet and dry periods. 

    For this presentation, we classified wet and dry periods using a weather radar and a rain gauge in Ås, Norway. We use data like equivalent reflectivity and phase shift between horizontal and vertical polarization and compare it to ground truth measurements. The resulting wet dry classifications are then compared with a single CML link in the same area.

    How to cite: Øydvin, E., Nilsen, V., Kitterød, N.-O., Wolff, M. A., and Artturi Elo, C.: Using weather radar to classify wet and dry periods for Commercial Microwave Links, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12993, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12993, 2022.

    Due to the combined effect of human-driven depletion and anthropogenic climate change, groundwater storage is decreasing across the globe. This trend will potentially have an adverse impact on future human socio-economic development, by increasing the frequency and duration of both hydrological and socio-economic droughts as well as generating inter-sectoral competition for limited water resources.

    Large-scale modelling studies on changes in groundwater availability can be separated into two big families. First, hydrological impact models actively consider water usage across sectors but ignore land-atmosphere interactions by design. Second, Earth System Models consider two-way interactions between climate and groundwater resources, but almost never consider the anthropogenic water resource depletion, except in some cases for irrigation.

    The goal of this study is to connect the expertise of these two families by implementing domestic and industrial water usage in the Community Earth System Model version 2. Using land-atmosphere coupled simulations, we will revisit previously computed trends in future groundwater availability by simultaneously accounting for climate change and anthropogenic water resource usage.

    How to cite: Taranu, I. S. and Thiery, W.: Implementing sectoral water usage in the Community Earth System Model for projecting future water resource availability, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-596, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-596, 2022.

    EGU22-898 | Presentations | HS7.3

    Salinity-inclusive water scarcity: examples from food bowl regions of the US and Australia 

    Josefin Thorslund, Marc F.P. Bierkens, Anna Scaini, Edwin H. Sutanudjaja, and Michelle T.H. van Vliet

    Irrigated agriculture sustains more than 40% of global food production and uses up to 90 % of the world’s water resources. Water scarcity for the irrigation water use sector is a common problem, which may be driven by both water shortages and increased salinity levels. Limited studies however considered salinity issues in water scarcity assessment. We here developed a salinity-inclusive water scarcity framework for the irrigation sector, accounting for crop-specific irrigation water demands and salinity tolerance and its relation to water availability and salinity levels of both surface and groundwater resources. We assess temporal and spatial variation of water scarcity in agricultural river basins of the Central Valley (California) and the Murray Darling Basin (Australia), which are important food bowl regions. Our results show that including salinity and crop-specific salinity tolerances leads to very different water scarcity levels, compared to water scarcity approaches based on water quantity only, particularly at local scales. Further, our results from the Central Valley region highlights that severe water scarcity can be strongly alleviated by conjunctive groundwater use, to dilute and lower salinity levels below crop specific tolerance values in many sub-basins. However, groundwater resources needed for dilution frequently exceed renewable groundwater rates in this region, posing additional risks for groundwater depletion. Taken together, through capturing these dynamics, our water scarcity framework can support local-regional water management and provide a useful tool for sustainable water use and assessing the impact of agricultural practices, such as crop choices, on water scarcity levels.

    How to cite: Thorslund, J., Bierkens, M. F. P., Scaini, A., Sutanudjaja, E. H., and van Vliet, M. T. H.: Salinity-inclusive water scarcity: examples from food bowl regions of the US and Australia, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-898, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-898, 2022.

    Quantification of the Water Losses (WL) components in Water Distribution Networks (WDNs) is a vital task towards their reduction. However, current WL estimation methods rely on semi-empirical approaches with high uncertainty levels, which usually lead to inaccurate estimates of the lost volume. Here, we compare the probabilistic Minimum Night Flow (MNF) estimation method introduced by Serafeim et al. (2021) to the Water Balance components analysis, introduced by the International Water Association (IWA). The strong point of the Serafeim et al. (2021) approach is that it uses statistical metrics to filter out noise effects in the flow timeseries used for MNF estimation, leading to more accurate estimation of the low flows during night hours. The effectiveness of the applied methods is tested via a large-scale, real world application to the 4 largest Pressure Management Areas (PMAs) of the WDN of the city of Patras, the third largest city in Greece (see Serafeim at al., 2022). Although methodologically different, the two approaches lead to very similar results, substantiating the robustness of the Serafeim at al. (2021) approach which allows for reliable confidence interval estimation of the observed Minimum Night Flows, making it particularly suited for engineering applications.

    Acknowledgements

    The research work was supported by the Hellenic Foundation for Research and Innovation (H.F.R.I.) under the “First Call for H.F.R.I. Research Projects to support Faculty members and Researchers and the procurement of high-cost research equipment grant” (Project Number: 1162).

    References

    Serafeim, A.V., Kokosalakis, G., Deidda, R., Karathanasi I. and Langousis A (2021) Probabilistic estimation of minimum night flow in water distribution networks: large-scale application to the city of Patras in western Greece, Stoch. Environ. Res. Risk. Assess., https://doi.org/10.1007/s00477-021-02042-9

    Serafeim, A.V.; Kokosalakis, G.; Deidda, R.; Karathanasi, I.; Langousis, A. (2022) Probabilistic Minimum Night Flow Estimation in Water Distribution Networks and Comparison with the Water Balance Approach: Large-Scale Application to the City Center of Patras in Western Greece, Water, 14, 98, https://doi.org/10.3390/w14010098

    How to cite: Langousis, A., Serafeim, A., Kokosalakis, G., Deidda, R., and Karathanasi, I.: Probabilistic water losses estimation in water distribution networks and comparison with the top down - water balance approach: A large-scale application to the city center of Patras in western Greece, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1974, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1974, 2022.

    EGU22-2855 | Presentations | HS7.3

    Parametric model for probabilistic estimation of water losses in water distribution networks: A large scale real world application to the city of Patras in western Greece 

    Athanasios V. Serafeim, George Kokosalakis, Roberto Deidda, Irene Karathanasi, and Andreas Langousis

    Abstract

    Quantification of the leakage volume in pressure management areas (PMAs) is a vital task for water agencies’ financial viability. However, currently, there is no rigorous approach for their parametric modeling on the basis of networks’ specific characteristics and inlet/operating pressures. To bridge this gap, the current work focuses on the development of a probabilistic framework for minimum night flow (MNF) estimation in water distribution networks that: 1) parametrizes the MNF as a function of the network’s specific characteristics, and 2) parametrically describes water losses in individual PMAs as a function of the inlet/operating pressures. MNF estimates are obtained using the robust, non-parametric, probabilistic minimum night flow (MNF) estimation methodology developed and validated by Serafeim et al. (2021 and 2022), which allows for confidence interval estimation of the observed MNFs. The effectiveness of the developed model is tested in a large-scale real world application to the water distribution network of the city of Patras in western Greece, which serves approximately 200,000 consumers with more than 700 km of pipeline. The developed framework is validated through flow-pressure tests conducted by the Municipal Enterprise of Water Supply and Sewerage of the City of Patras to 78 PMAs of the network, indicating that the developed framework can be effectively used to improve water loss estimation and flow-pressure management in a morphologically and operationally diverse set of PMAs.

    Acknowledgements

    The research work was supported by the Hellenic Foundation for Research and Innovation (H.F.R.I.) under the “First Call for H.F.R.I. Research Projects to support Faculty members and Researchers and the procurement of high-cost research equipment grant” (Project Number: 1162).

     

    References

    Serafeim, A.V., Kokosalakis, G., Deidda, R., Karathanasi I. and Langousis A (2021) Probabilistic estimation of minimum night flow in water distribution networks: large-scale application to the city of Patras in western Greece, Stoch. Environ. Res. Risk. Assess., https://doi.org/10.1007/s00477-021-02042-9

    Serafeim, A.V.; Kokosalakis, G.; Deidda, R.; Karathanasi, I.; Langousis, A. (2022) Probabilistic Minimum Night Flow Estimation in Water Distribution Networks and Comparison with the Water Balance Approach: Large-Scale Application to the City Center of Patras in Western Greece, Water, 14, 98, https://doi.org/10.3390/w14010098

    How to cite: Serafeim, A. V., Kokosalakis, G., Deidda, R., Karathanasi, I., and Langousis, A.: Parametric model for probabilistic estimation of water losses in water distribution networks: A large scale real world application to the city of Patras in western Greece, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2855, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2855, 2022.

    EGU22-3301 | Presentations | HS7.3

    Monitoring of agricultural drought from remote sensing products and in-situ meteorological data 

    Mathis Neuhauser, Thomas Tilak, Christophe Point-Dumont, and Alexandre Peltier

    The extreme events increasingly present in the Pacific (El Nino / La Nina phenomena) have significant consequences on island territories. The effect of climate change and drought episodes is therefore a central concern in many Pacific islands like Vanuatu, Wallis-and-Futuna, French Polynesia, etc. The intense drought events have undeniable impacts on biodiversity, agricultural crops and water resource, as was the case in 2019 for New Caledonia. In particular, projections in New Caledonia count on a possible increase in temperatures of 3°C and a water deficit of 20% in 2100 with longer and more intense drought episodes and an even greater west coast/east coast disparity (Dutheil, 2018). To date, the monitoring and anticipation of these drought episodes is done via meteorological measurements providing information on the rainfall deficit and not on the water stress of plants. In addition, the data are only available on a few measurement points and are not continuous over the territories.

    In order to meet this need, a tool for monitoring environmental and agricultural drought using satellite images and meteorological data is being developed and validated in New Caledonia: Earth Observations for Drought Monitoring (EO4DM) project. This project is carried out in collaboration with Météo-France NC as a technical partner and the local Rural Agency as end user, and aims to provide a tool to help decision-making to institutions and management assistance for farmers. This solution will provide data constituting a singularly important source of information whose valuations and contributions can be multiple: agriculture, resource management (water), security (monitoring of risks linked to floods, fires), environment, etc.

    To do so, various surface indices reflecting the state of the vegetation and certain soil properties such as humidity and temperature were estimated from different satellite sensors (MODIS, Sentinel-2, Landsat-8, ASCAT) in order to address different space scales from the field to regional scale. These indices were normalized over a relatively long period, allowing access to drought indicators: VHI (Vegetation Health Index; Kogan et al., 1997), VAI (Vegetation Anomaly Index; Amri et al., 2011), MAI (Moisture Anomaly Index; Amri et al., 2012) or TAI (Temperature Anomaly Index; Le Page and Zribi, 2019). Combined with in-situ meteorological products like SPI (Standardized Precipitation Index; McKee et al., 1993) and SPEI (Standardized Precipitation Evapotranspiration Index; Vicente-Serrano et al., 2010), these indicators assess the intensity of drought episodes and estimate their severity over the entire territory.

    How to cite: Neuhauser, M., Tilak, T., Point-Dumont, C., and Peltier, A.: Monitoring of agricultural drought from remote sensing products and in-situ meteorological data, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3301, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3301, 2022.

    EGU22-5834 | Presentations | HS7.3

    Performance of regional climate models in simulating rainy seasons in West Africa 

    Torsten Weber, Vincent O. Ajayi, Imoleayo E. Gbode, Daniel Abel, Katrin Ziegler, Heiko Paeth, and Seydou B. Traore

    Agriculture in West Africa is highly dependent on rainfall during the rainy seasons. Therefore, modifications in rainy season characteristics due to recent and future climate change have a direct impact on crop yields and production in the region. Consequently, stakeholders and decision-makers need reliable regional climate change information on rainy seasons in order to develop appropriate adaptation measures.

    Regional Climate Models (RCMs) can provide information on climate change at high temporal and spatial resolution through dynamic downscaling of climate projections generated by Earth System Models (ESMs). In order to assess the performance of RCMs in simulating rainy seasons and their characteristics such as onset and cessation, length and total sum of rainfall, a thorough evaluation of RCMs is required.

    The current study evaluates the performance of three different RCMs (REMO2015, RegCM4-7 and CCLM5-0-15) in simulating rainy seasons in West Africa using gridded observational data sets. For the assessment, we will use the ERA-INTERIM driven simulations of the RCMs from the Coordinated Output for Regional Evaluations (CORE) embedded in the WCRP Coordinated Regional Climate Downscaling Experiment (CORDEX) for Africa with a spatial resolution of about 25 km.

    How to cite: Weber, T., Ajayi, V. O., Gbode, I. E., Abel, D., Ziegler, K., Paeth, H., and Traore, S. B.: Performance of regional climate models in simulating rainy seasons in West Africa, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5834, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5834, 2022.

    EGU22-7460 | Presentations | HS7.3

    Environmental, economic and social sustainability of Alternate Wetting and Drying rice irrigation in Northern Italy 

    Olfa Gharsallah, Alice Mayer, Marco Romani, Andrea Ricciardelli, Sara Caleca, Michele Rienzner, Stefano Corsi, Giovanni Ottaiano, Giulio Gilardi, and Arianna Facchi

    Italy is the Europe’s leading rice producer, with over half of total European production. The main rice area is in the north-western part of the country (Lombardy and Piedmont regions). In this area, irrigation of rice has been traditionally carried out by flooding; the introduction of alternative water-saving irrigation strategies could reduce water consumption, but their overall environmental and economic sustainability, as well as their social acceptability, should be investigated.

    An experimental platform was set up in the core of the Italian rice district (Lomellina, PV) to compare different rice irrigation management options: wet seeding and traditional flooding (WFL), dry seeding and delayed flooding (DFL), wet seeding and alternated wetting and drying (AWD). Six plots of about 20 m x 80 m each were set-up, with two replicates for each irrigation option. One out of two replicates for each option was instrumented with: water inflow and outflow meters, set of piezometers, set of tensiometers and water tubes for the irrigation management in the AWD plots. Proper agronomic practices were adopted for the three management options. Periodic measurements of crop biometric parameters (LAI, crop height, crop rooting depth) were performed and rice grain yields and quality (As and Cd in the grain) were determined. Data measured in the field, together with those provided by the farmer, concerning the agronomic inputs and the economic costs incurred for the three irrigation options, were used to assess their economic and environmental sustainability through a set of quantitative indicators. Finally, through interviews with rice growers of the area, barriers to the adoption of the AWD technique were assessed and ways of overcoming them identified. In order to support water management decisions and policies, data collected at the farm level are extrapolated to the irrigation district level through a semi-distributed agro-hydrological model, used to compare the overall irrigation efficiency achieved implementing AWD when compared to WFL.

    How to cite: Gharsallah, O., Mayer, A., Romani, M., Ricciardelli, A., Caleca, S., Rienzner, M., Corsi, S., Ottaiano, G., Gilardi, G., and Facchi, A.: Environmental, economic and social sustainability of Alternate Wetting and Drying rice irrigation in Northern Italy, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7460, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7460, 2022.

    EGU22-8093 | Presentations | HS7.3

    Can an agro-hydrological model improve the irrigation management of maize under a center pivot? 

    Arianna Facchi, Alice Mayer, Bianca Ortuani, and Alberto Crema

    Plain areas of Northern Italy are characterized by a strong agricultural and zootechnical vocation. In the Lombardy region, the total utilized agricultural area (UAA) is about 700,000 ha, 72% of which is irrigated. Globally, about one half of the UAA is cropped with maize, but in some provinces this crop reaches almost the totality of the UAA. Maize is typically irrigated by border irrigation; however, in the context of the climate change and of the increased competition for the use of water in the plain, it is crucial to optimize the use of this resource.

    This study is aimed at demonstrating the applicability of Precision Irrigation approaches in a large farm located in the core of the maize basin of the Lombardy plain (La Canova farm, BS, Italy; http://lacanovasrl.it/). In the farm, irrigation is provided by center pivots and linear irrigation systems. Although sprinkler irrigation can reduce the applied irrigation volumes compared to border irrigation, at present, a uniform irrigation rate is provided at fixed time intervals without accounting for spatial heterogeneity of soil or crop development.

    During the agricultural season 2021, in a 15 hectares surface cropped with maize under a center pivot the irrigation was applied following a variable-rate approach. The soil variability was investigated using an Electromagnetic induction (EMI) sensor; through the application of cluster analysis techniques to the EMI survey, four types of soils were detected and characterized through a traditional soil sampling. According to soil variability and pivot geometry, four management zones (MZ) were identified: two MZs were characterized prevalently by coarse soils while the other two by medium-fine soils. In one ‘coarse’ MZ and one ‘fine’ MZ the irrigation was managed with the support of soil probes installed at two depth, and by a physically based agro-hydrological model (SWAP, https://www.swap.alterra.nl/) fed with weather forecasts at 7 days (https://www.abacofarmer.com/). A MATLAB code was developed to run the whole modelling system. Irrigation in the other two MZs was applied by the farmer according to the farm’s typical management (about 25-30 mm every four days). In the MZs managed with Variable Rate irrigation, the model was used to identify the optimal water depth to be applied at each irrigation event, depending on the soil water balance computed for the following 5 days; in doing this, a 4-day turn and a minimum irrigation depth of 18-25 mm (as a function of the time of the season) were respected, since they were constraints imposed by the farmer. Despite the constraints, compared to the reference MZs, the approach adopted led to a water saving of about 20 and 25% for the ‘coarse’ and ‘fine’ MZs, respectively, without a loss of yield. In the next step, the approach adopted will be used to estimate the water and energy saving achievable at the farm scale.

    How to cite: Facchi, A., Mayer, A., Ortuani, B., and Crema, A.: Can an agro-hydrological model improve the irrigation management of maize under a center pivot?, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8093, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8093, 2022.

    EGU22-8392 | Presentations | HS7.3

    Limnological responses to active management of the invasive aquatic fern Salvinia molesta in Las Curias Reservoir, San Juan, Puerto Rico. 

    Xavier García López, Jorge Ortiz Zayas, Rodrigo Díaz, Aurelio Castro Jiménez, and Moisés Abdelrahman López

    In the Anthropocene, human action and globalization are closely linked to the deterioration of natural habitats and water resources. Invasive aquatic weeds have been recognized as a major problem in watersheds worldwide due to their environmental impacts. This study focuses on the management of the Las Curias Reservoir in Cupey Puerto Rico in the Río Piedras watershed since the arrival of Salvinia molesta after Hurricane María in 2017.
    Aquatic weed control consists of three methods: biological, mechanical, and chemical. Since December 2019, with the help of federal and local agencies, the University of Puerto Rico in Rio Piedras and a community-driven initiative led to the introduction of the Cyrtobagous salviniae in Las Curias Reservoir.  This insect is considered an effective biological control agent for S.  molesta.  Simultaneously, community members initiated a mechanical removal campaign using an aquatic harvester. Monthly sampling was conducted to measure physicochemical, biochemical, and biophysical variables in the reservoir in response to the reduction of S. molesta cover. In addition, monthly drone flights were conducted to create orthomosaic maps of the plant coverage over the water surface, as part of the monitoring of the ecosystem health and characterization. Probably the propagation of S. molesta occurred due to eutrophication after an increase in nutrient-rich sewage discharges from septic tanks and faulty sewage pump stations affected by power outages after Hurricane Maria. By 2019, the reservoir was completely covered with S. molesta. It is not until August 2020 that we noticed considerable changes in the reduction of plant density. Upon the reduction of S. molesta coverage, we found increases in the mean of water temperature (+3 Cِ°), dissolved oxygen (+1.4 mg/L), pH (+0.5) specific conductance (+118.3 µS/cm) and in light penetration (+255.6 
    μmo/m^2/s).  The water stored in Las Curias could become an invaluable source of raw water for public supply during future droughts, especially in the densely populated San Juan Metropolitan Area, where Las Curias is located. Therefore, its restoration is socially relevant and justifiable. 

    How to cite: García López, X., Ortiz Zayas, J., Díaz, R., Castro Jiménez, A., and Abdelrahman López, M.: Limnological responses to active management of the invasive aquatic fern Salvinia molesta in Las Curias Reservoir, San Juan, Puerto Rico., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8392, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8392, 2022.

    EGU22-8409 | Presentations | HS7.3

    Statistical methodology for PRV malfunction detection and alerting in Water Distribution Networks 

    Anastasios Perdios, George Kokosalakis, Irene Karathanasi, and Andreas Langousis

    As the outflow velocity from a pipe crack increases with increasing hydraulic pressure, pressure management concepts have been widely applied to reduce water losses in the delivering and distribution parts of water networks. In this context, pressure reducing valves (PRVs) have been commonly used to regulate pressures and therefore reduce water losses, in both water supply and water distribution networks, by reducing the upstream pressure to a set outlet pressure (i.e. downstream of the PRV), usually referred to as set point.

    As all types of mechanical equipment, PRVs exhibit malfunctions affecting pressure regulation, which can be defined as events when the outlet pressure does not match the set point. These events can be classified in two categories: a) high frequency fluctuations around the set point, and b) prolonged systematic deviations from the set point. Since PRV malfunctions result in systematic or random deviations of the outlet pressure from the set point, their detection can be approached in a statistical context.

    In this study, we develop a novel framework for detection of PRV malfunctions in water supply and water distribution networks, which uses: a) the root mean squared error (RMSE) as a proper statistical metric for monitoring the performance of a PRV by detecting individual malfunctions (i.e. malfunction occurrences) in the high-resolution pressure time series, and b) the hazard function concept to identify a proper duration of sequential events from (a) to issue alerts.

    The suggested methodology is implemented using pressure data at 1-min temporal resolution from pressure management area “Diagora” of the water distribution network of the city of Patras (the third largest city in Greece), for a 3 year period from 01 January 2017 to 31 December 2019. The obtained results show that the developed statistical approach effectively detects major PRV malfunctions (as reported by the Municipal Water Supply Company and Sewerage of Patras, DEYAP), allowing it to be used for operational purposes.

    Acknowledgments:

    This research is co‐financed by the European Regional Development Fund of the European Union and Greek national funds through the Operational Program Competitiveness, Entrepreneurship and Innovation, under the call RESEARCH – CREATE – INNOVATE (project code: T2EDK-4177).

    How to cite: Perdios, A., Kokosalakis, G., Karathanasi, I., and Langousis, A.: Statistical methodology for PRV malfunction detection and alerting in Water Distribution Networks, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8409, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8409, 2022.

    EGU22-8898 | Presentations | HS7.3

    Small Islands – Precipitation in the Future 

    Maria Meirelles, Fernanda Carvalho, Diamantino Henriques, and Patrícia Navarro

    For most islands, there is very little published literature documenting the probability, frequency, severity,or consequences of climate change impacts, such as an decrease in precipitation. Some times, projections of future climate change impacts are limited by the lack of model skill in projecting the climatic variables that matter to small islands. The Azores are an archipelago formed by nine high volcanic islands, presenting a relatively small land area where precipitation is of orographic origin. Relatively projections up to the end of the 21st century, they were used for the same geographic region - the Azores region between 37 °N - 40°N and 32°W - 25°W - the results of the CMIP5 project for the RCPs (Representative Concentration Pathways) scenarios; trajectories describe four possible future climate scenarios, which depend on the amount of greenhouse gases emissions that may be emitted in the coming years. The four RCP scenarios (RCP 2.6, RCP 4.5, RCP 6.0 and RCP 8.5), correspond to four radiative forcing intervals for the year 2100, to pre-industrial values ​​(+2.6, +4.5, +6.0 and +8.5 W/m2, respectively). Most of the CMIP5 climate data and projections used in this work they are freely available on the Climate Ex plorer portal (https://climexp.knmi.nl/) of the KNMI (Koninklijk Nederlands Meteorologisch Instituut). Anomaly of the average annual precipitation for the Azores was calculated in the 1979-2019 period and its projections are estimated up to 2100, according to the RCP scenarios (Figure 1). In this case, the average variation calculated for the three scenarios for annual precipitation is -7.8 mm; in the case of the scenario more pessimistic (RCP 8.5), the models show for the Azores a decrease in average annual precipitation of about 9.8 mm/day until the end of the century, compared to the average of the last 30 years. According to the RCP4.5 scenario, a decrease is observed which is accentuated from the northwest to the southeast in the region under consideration, especially affecting the islands of the central and eastern groups. Of the calculations results for the average of the models an increase of the maximum number consecutive days with low rainfall (<1mm) from + 0.2 to 4.8 days / year until the year 2100. The demand for water affects basically four activities: the agriculture, energy production, industrial uses and consumption human. The projections found for the Azores of a decrease in precipitation are in line with other small island regions, such as the Caribbean and Mediterranean region. Thus, these regions become more vulnerable to social, economic and environmental impacts.

    How to cite: Meirelles, M., Carvalho, F., Henriques, D., and Navarro, P.: Small Islands – Precipitation in the Future, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8898, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8898, 2022.

    EGU22-10221 | Presentations | HS7.3 | Highlight

    Pandemic Medical Supply Needs with a Coincident Natural Disaster and an Analysis of COVID-19 Data Availability 

    Paul Churchyard, Ajay Gupta, and Joshua Lieberman

    The Open Geospatial Consortium’s Disaster Pilot 2021 focused on turning earth observation and reporting data into decision ready indicators (DRI) for disaster response and management.  HSR.health as a Pilot participant  developed the recipe for, and produced a Medical Supply Needs Index that indicates what medical supplies, such as Personal Protective Equipment, are needed to respond to COVID-19 cases throughout a population. Medical Supply Needs Indices were calculated for areas within the Pilot focus regions and shared via a dashboard-style application. HSR.health and collaborators then set up an integrated demonstration showing the Medical Supply Needs Index updating in real-time as a result of data on the occurrence and impacts of multiple coincident natural disasters such as flooding, landslides, and pandemic spread. HSR.health also carried out work within the Pilot to apply and evaluate the draft Health Spatial Data Infrastructure (HSDI) model developed in the pre-Pilot OGC Health Spatial Data Infrastructure Concept Development Study. This included research into the availability of pandemic-related health related data in the US and in Peru, as well as investigation of the spatiotemporal granularity or resolution of observation data best suited to support indicators for community-level public health interventions.

    How to cite: Churchyard, P., Gupta, A., and Lieberman, J.: Pandemic Medical Supply Needs with a Coincident Natural Disaster and an Analysis of COVID-19 Data Availability, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10221, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10221, 2022.

    Coastal cities in India houses nearly 100 million people and are evenly distributed across India’s 7516-kilometer coastline. These cities are important centers of socio-economic activities in the country and are some of the densely populated regions in the world. A number of studies recently have predicted that there is a risk of substantial portions of these cities’ areas being lost to the sea due to sea-level rise in the next few decades, since a major portion of these cities are at a near zero elevation from the mean sea level (M.S.L). Further, in the past few decades, major coastal cities in India have been repeatedly affected by recurrent extreme rainfall events and subsequent floodings. Several studies document that rapid change in the Indian monsoon, increased frequency in the formation of cyclones and the swift changes in the hydro-climatic regime in the Indian Ocean are the major contributors to the occurrence of these extreme precipitations events. While we can safely conclude that these events are likely to occur more frequently in the future, it is important to understand the factors that control and influence these events, comprehend how the cities are and will be affected, and develop feasible policy changes and mitigation action for effective governance. In this paper, we have taken the case of Chennai – an important coastal city located in the southern part of India that has been severely affected by extreme precipitation and subsequent flooding (notably the infamous 2015 Chennai floods) in the past few years, to study the influencing factors contributing to these events and the ground challenges faced by the government machinery in planning and managing these disasters effectively. Our findings indicate that there is a notable variation in the monsoon rainfall pattern in Chennai and the net annual rainfall in the city has increased significantly in the past decade (by ~15%). Further, we found that significant urban centers in the city, especially the regions that are at near zero elevation (± 5 meters above M.S.L) are more vulnerable to flooding, and the important contributing factors to the increased severity of the recent floodings include the lack of adequate stormwater drainage infrastructure and poor policy choice of converting natural surface water bodies (lakes and ponds) into towns during the past three to four decades. We also discuss the planning and execution of Chennai city’s mitigation action during the 2021 floods, analyze its success and shortcomings, and suggest sustainable and feasible policy changes and measures that can be adopted for better management of similar events in the future in other coastal cities as well.

    How to cite: Mohanavelu, A. and Soundharajan, B.-S.: Increased frequency of urban floodings in coastal Indian cities caused by variation in monsoon rainfall: Influencing factors, challenges, and solutions, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10483, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10483, 2022.

    EGU22-11068 | Presentations | HS7.3

    Optimal sowing dates for major crops in India under climate change 

    Aditya Narayan Sharma, Sai Jagadeesh Gaddam, and Prasanna Venkatesh Sampath

    Agriculture plays a pivotal role in supporting the socioeconomic situation of millions of farmers in India, which is increasingly coming under threat due to climate change. In particular, the future changes in rainfall patterns has the potential to directly affect the irrigation water demands, thereby impacting water consumption, agricultural productivity, and influencing food security. For instance, the optimal sowing dates for crops may change according to the altered rainfall patterns. With this motivation, we studied the impacts of shifts in sowing periods in order to identify the optimal sowing dates for a particular crop. First, we collected daily temperature and rainfall data for India at a resolution of 0.25o from different GCM models (EC-Earth 3 and EC-Earth 3 veg) under different SSP scenarios (SSP 126, SSP 245, SSP370, SSP585). Also, region-wise agricultural data such as crop acreage and sowing dates were collected for seven major crops - paddy, wheat, maize, groundnut, sugarcane, red gram, black gram, and soybean. Subsequently, we estimated the reference evapotranspiration using the modified Penman-Monteith method. The estimated reference evapotranspiration and rainfall data were incorporated into FAO’s CROPWAT model to calculate the irrigation water requirements (IWR) of the selected crops. The optimal IWR for each crop was selected by varying the sowing dates at fifteen-day intervals across the year (twenty-four dates for the year). Preliminary results indicate that there is considerable scope for water savings by shifting the sowing dates of staple crops to account for climate change impacts. These strategies may become vital for policymakers in the coming decades to reduce the stresses on water without endangering food security. Indeed, such strategies require the cooperation of various stakeholders for better implementation at multiple scales.

    How to cite: Sharma, A. N., Gaddam, S. J., and Sampath, P. V.: Optimal sowing dates for major crops in India under climate change, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11068, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11068, 2022.

    EGU22-11145 | Presentations | HS7.3

    Optimizing cropping patterns under the influence of climate change 

    Sindhuja Reddy Pasula, Swethu Sree Gudem, Sai Jagadeesh Gaddam, and Prasanna Venkatesh Sampath

    The world needs 70% more food by 2050, increasing the pressure on the available water resources. With the climate change threat approaching, the water stress will further be exacerbated that would adversely affect food security. In countries like India, with extensive cultivation of staple crops like paddy, there has been a rapid increase in the total water consumption. At the same time, cultivation of crops such as pulses and millets has not been sufficient to satisfy the nutritional requirements of India’s population. With the increased likelihood of droughts and floods due to the advent of climate change, it becomes imperative to achieve water, food, and nutritional security into the future. This study attempts to optimise cropping patterns to minimise future water requirement, while satisfying the nutritional and caloric requirements of future generations. We perform the analysis for the southern Indian state of Andhra Pradesh, where agriculture depends predominantly on irrigation. To achieve this objective of optimization, we collected bias-corrected climate datasets from three General Circulation Models (BCC-CSM2-MR, INM-CM5-0, MPI-ESM1-2 HR) that include future rainfall and temperature information from 2021 to 2050. Further, we collected crop-wise farm-level data of five major crops in the state - paddy, sugarcane, groundnut, sorghum, and red gram. The irrigation water requirement (IWR) of the selected crops was estimated using FAO’s CROPWAT model under two different scenarios - SSP 245, SSP 585. Further, we developed an optimization model to obtain the optimal cropping pattern that minimises water consumption. Future food requirements in terms of protein and calorie demands and arable land available for cultivation were used as constraints to perform this optimization. Preliminary results indicate that shifting from water-intensive crops like sugarcane to relatively more nutritious crops like red gram and sorghum has the potential to significantly reduce water consumption, while also enhancing the nutritional security of the region. Interestingly, the optimization results indicated that the southern part of the study region required more interventions in terms of crop diversification as compared to the northern part. Such insights could help decision makers to devise holistic policies, enhancing the water-food security under different climate change scenarios. Further, this research could be extended to domains such as economics, ecology, and energy to achieve overall sustainability in the agricultural sector.

    How to cite: Pasula, S. R., Gudem, S. S., Gaddam, S. J., and Sampath, P. V.: Optimizing cropping patterns under the influence of climate change, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11145, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11145, 2022.

    EGU22-11578 | Presentations | HS7.3

    The role of urban streams in the microplastics contamination scenario: the case study of the Mugnone Creek (Florence, Italy) 

    Alessio Monnanni, Gabriele Bicocchi, Eleonora De Beni, Valentina Rimondi, Tania Martellini, David Chelazzi, Alessandra Cincinelli, Stefania Venturi, Guia Morelli, Pierfranco Lattanzi, and Pilario Costagliola

    Due to their spread, abundance and potential impact on food security and human health, microplastics (MPs) are emerging global pollutants. Metropolitan areas are among the main sources of MPs (1 μm - 5 mm); indeed, about 80% of the MPs found in the oceans come from freshwaters. In particular, impervious surfaces runoff in urban areas results in the transport of large quantities of solid wastes, comprising MPs, to the superficial water bodies. Thus, the ecological state of urban streams represents a reliable indicator to evaluate the environmental impact of a city. In this study, we report data about MPs in stream sediments and waters of a minor urban stream, the Mugnone Creek (MC), which flows across the highly urbanized city of Florence (Italy) and discharges to the Arno River.

    Several sites along the 17 km-long MC were chosen, including “greenfield” sites upstream of the Florence urban area, urban-impacted sites located along congested roads, and the MC outlet. The stream sediments were collected in June 2019, while stream waters were recovered via glass bottles twice a year (June and December) in 2019 and 2020, to account for seasonal variability. Stream discharge was simultaneously determined during water sampling to allow mass flow calculations of contaminants.

    Water samples were filtered onto glass microfiber filters (ø 47 mm) and observed by HD digital stereomicroscope; a similar method was followed for sediments after a density separation step (NaCl saturated solution) and H2O2 digestion. Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy (FT-IR) was used for identification and characterization of MPs. Microparticles classification was based on polymer type, shape and colour.

    MPs concentration in sediments showed an increasing trend from the pre-urban site to the outlet. A maximum value (1.540 MPs/kg) was reached immediately after the Terzolle Creek confluence, which drains the large University Hospital District of Careggi. Fibers were the dominant shape class of polymers observed and blue/black items stand out among the colour classes. The highest concentrations of MPs in water samples were recorded during winter seasons (up to 16.000 items/m3), with a predominance of fibers and blue/black colours. Polymer classification by FTIR indicated the presence of (in order of abundance): PA (polyamide), PET (Polyethylene Terephthalate), SBR (butadiene-styrene rubber), PP (Polypropylene), blend PP+PE (PP+Polyethylene), PTFE (Polytetrafluoroethylene) and PU (Polyurethane). The black-SBR polymers likely related to tyre abrasion occurring during vehicles driving, since they were especially found on a site close to traffic-congested roads. In addition to synthetic particles, high concentrations of natural fibers (mainly cellulose) were found in waters at all sites. Up to 109 synthetic particles are estimated to be discharged daily by MC to the Arno River during the winter season, a load much higher than creeks with similar urbanization context worldwide. Mass loads of natural fibers were of the same order of magnitude of MPs in every season.

    Studies are in progress to elucidate the impact on local biota and to characterize the anthropic pressure on the Arno River, aiming to improve the knowledge about the environmental status of one of the main Italian river basins.

    How to cite: Monnanni, A., Bicocchi, G., De Beni, E., Rimondi, V., Martellini, T., Chelazzi, D., Cincinelli, A., Venturi, S., Morelli, G., Lattanzi, P., and Costagliola, P.: The role of urban streams in the microplastics contamination scenario: the case study of the Mugnone Creek (Florence, Italy), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11578, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11578, 2022.

    Due to climate change, extreme weather conditions such as droughts may have an increasing impact on the water demand and the productivity of irrigated agriculture. For the adaptation to changing climate conditions, knowledge about adequate irrigation control strategies and information, e.g., about future climate development and soil properties, is of great importance for the optimal operation of irrigation systems. We consider climate and soil variability within one probabilistic simulation-optimization framework for irrigation scheduling based on Monte Carlo simulations to support informed decisions. The framework implements optimizers for full, deficit, and supplemental irrigation strategies. We provide the  Matlab code as the open source Deficit Irrigation Toolbox (DIT). For this analysis, we apply DIT for preliminary test simulations for a global numerical deficit irrigation experiment (GDIE) which allows for the analysis of both the impact of the selected irrigation strategy on water productivity and the value of information about (i) different scheduling methods, (ii) climate development, and (iii) soil hydraulic properties. The first results show a strong dependency on the value of information about climate and soil for sites required for increasing water productivity in different climate regions. Moreover, DIT can enable and support the site-specific transformation of low efficient rainfed and irrigated systems achieving higher water productivity and food insecurity on a local scale.

    How to cite: Schütze, N. and Dietz, A.: Comparison of the value of information for the management of deficit irrigation systems in different climate regions, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11631, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11631, 2022.

    EGU22-12798 | Presentations | HS7.3

    FORESHELL Project: development of sanitary/weather-environmental predictive technological tools to enhance the efficiency and sustainability of shellfish farming. 

    Barbara Tomassetti, Annalina Lombardi, Valentina Colaiuda, Federica Conti, Giuseppina Mascilongo, Fabrizio Capoccioni, Domitilla Pulcini, Gabriella Di Francesco, Ludovica Di Renzo, Chiara Profico, Carla Ippoliti, Carla Giansante, Nicola Ferri, and Federica Di Giacinto

    Many of the estuaries and coastal areas in Europe are used for the cultivation and harvesting of bivalve mollusks. Mussel farming is strongly influenced by weather and environmental conditions. Several studies have shown that the sanitary conditions of shellfish are related to hydrological factors of rivers adjacent to the farming area, as rivers are the main routes of bacteriological contamination from the surface or sub-surface.

    The "FORESHELL" project, funded by Costa Blu FLAG as part of the EMFF 2014-20 program of the Abruzzo Region, is carrying out a pilot initiative for the development of sanitary/weather-environmental predictive technological tools in order to improve efficiency and sustainability of the mussel farm located at the Giuliano Maritime District.

    A specific sampling schedule is established before and after severe weather events to determine the E. coli
    concentration in freshwater at the river mouths and in mussels/seawater in the farming site. At the same time, the hydrographic basins of the rivers close to the farm, Vibrata and Salinello, are constantly monitored trough the hydrological model (CHyM), to predict the occurrence of flow discharge peaks at mouth of the river. In addition, the satellites and the in-situ probe acquire environmental parameters such as sea water temperature, salinity, chlorophyll-a, sea currents and wave motion.

    The web application for data visualization is under construction, as well as the early warning reports to the farmer. Furthermore, the growth of mussels is constantly monitored with biometric controls. The implementation of all phases of the FORESHELL project are proceeding according to the timeline in order to develop innovative tools useful for the management of mussel farming area.

    How to cite: Tomassetti, B., Lombardi, A., Colaiuda, V., Conti, F., Mascilongo, G., Capoccioni, F., Pulcini, D., Di Francesco, G., Di Renzo, L., Profico, C., Ippoliti, C., Giansante, C., Ferri, N., and Di Giacinto, F.: FORESHELL Project: development of sanitary/weather-environmental predictive technological tools to enhance the efficiency and sustainability of shellfish farming., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12798, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12798, 2022.

    EGU22-541 | Presentations | HS7.4

    How well do convection-permitting climate models represent sub-daily precipitation upper tail in complex orography? 

    Eleonora Dallan, Francesco Marra, Formetta Giuseppe, Giorgia Fosser, Marco Marani, Christoph Schaer, and Marco Borga

    Convection‐permitting climate models (CMPs) give a much more realistic representation of sub-daily precipitation statistics compared to coarser resolution climate models, thanks to the explicit representation of convection. Their higher spatial and temporal resolution allows to used them directly to study future changes in the frequency, intensity, and spatiotemporal patterns of heavy rainfall over complex terrain. However, the high computational requirements of CPM runs restricts the existing simulations to relatively short time periods (10–20 years), too short for deriving precipitation frequency analyses with conventional approaches. Alternative methods, based on the so called Metastatistical Extreme Value Distribution, were recently proposed (e.g. Marani and Ignaccolo, 2015) for deriving frequency analyses from shorter data records, promising improved applications based on CPMs. These approaches rely on the concept of ordinary events, which are all the independent events that share the statistical properties of extremes: once the upper tail of the distribution of ordinary events is known, it is possible to derive an extreme value distribution by explicitly considering their yearly occurrence frequency.

    Here, we investigate the CPM ability to represent the upper tail of sub-daily precipitation in a complex-orography region in the Eastern Italian Alps. In this area, different orographic impacts on sub-daily precipitation upper tail were reported at different durations (Formetta et al., 2021), and significant temporal trends in their intensity were reported during the last few decades (Libertino et al., 2019), making it a challenging and interesting test case for CPM simulations. As CPM we used the COSMO model run at 2.2 km resolution over Europe, driven with ERA Interim for the period 2000-2009. We use 180 rain gauges to benchmark the CPM simulation. CPM time series are extracted for the grid points corresponding to the rain gauges, and hourly time series are created from both stations and CPMs. In each time series, independent storms are separated by 24-hour dry hiatuses, and ordinary events for 9 durations between 1 and 24 hours are defined as the corresponding peak intensity of each storm. Ordinary events upper tails are modeled using a Weibull distribution (two-parameter stretched exponential), which was previously reported to well reproduce the statistics of extremes in the area. The ability of CPMs to reproduce the model parameters and extreme quantiles up to 100-year return period, and their dependence on elevation are evaluated, together with the dependence of the biases with elevation. A general overestimation is found for annual maxima (10-40%), and the estimated quantiles (10-60%), especially for short durations. The bias significantly depends on elevation, with increasing overestimation of the 1-hour quantiles with elevation. It seems that CPMs cannot represented well the “reversed orographic effect” reported by previous studies.

     

    How to cite: Dallan, E., Marra, F., Giuseppe, F., Fosser, G., Marani, M., Schaer, C., and Borga, M.: How well do convection-permitting climate models represent sub-daily precipitation upper tail in complex orography?, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-541, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-541, 2022.

    EGU22-1393 | Presentations | HS7.4

    Should we correct biases in the diurnal cycle of climate model for hydrological studies? 

    Mina Faghih and François Brissette

    With the growing importance of climate change risk assessment, the use of climate models as a tool to model the impact of a warmer climate on water resources has now become quite common. When working with climate model outputs, bias correction is considered an important and necessary step to ensure that impact models provide realistic simulations in the current and future climates. The past decades have seen continuous improvements in the spatial and temporal resolution of global and regional climate models. Climate model outputs are now available at the sub-daily temporal resolution and very few studies have looked at the need for correcting biases present in the representation of the diurnal cycles of model variables. This study has looked at the impact of correcting such biases on simulated streamflow over 133 North American catchments. The temperature and precipitation hourly outputs from a 50-member large-ensemble regional climate model (ClimEx) were used to model the impact of sub-daily bias correction on simulated streamflow using a hydrological model. To better understand the importance of diurnal bias correction as a function of the spatial scale, the impact of bias-correcting the diurnal cycle was evaluated on three classes of catchment area:  small (<500 km2), medium (500< area <1000 km2) and large (>1000 km2). Bias correcting the diurnal cycle resulted in small but systematic improvements in the representation of simulated streamflow, with an average bias reduction of 5%, likely due to a better representation of the daily evapotranspiration cycle.  The improvements were especially noticeable on the small catchments.

    How to cite: Faghih, M. and Brissette, F.: Should we correct biases in the diurnal cycle of climate model for hydrological studies?, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1393, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1393, 2022.

    EGU22-3039 | Presentations | HS7.4

    Determining optimal scale of water infrastructure considering economical aspects with stochastic evaluation – Case study at the Municipality of Western Mani 

    David Markantonis, Aimilia Siganou, Konstantina Moraiti, Maria Nikolinakou, G.-Fivos Sargentis, Panayiotis Dimitriadis, Michalis Chiotinis, Theano Iliopoulou, Nikolaos Mamassis, and Demetris Koutsoyiannis

    Infrastructures for the supply of water are one of the most necessary facilities in modern life. The optimal design of such infrastructures (for example, dams or even small-size tanks) is often a great challenge in civil engineering, given the large number of factors required for their design (e.g., feasibility, reliability, cost effectiveness, resilience). One of the most critical decisions that may have a great impact on the optimization procedure is the determination of the scale of the proposed system.

    During a study of such a design of a water supply infrastructure in the Municipality of Western Mani, it became clear that several solutions of different scales coexisted. Ultimately, the cost-benefit factors were the most heavily considered ones, provided that the required reliability was met. Stochastic methods have been proven to be appropriate tools for studying such highly complex and uncertain puzzles. The current study intends to approach this problem by considering solutions of different scales, and to establish the long-term cost effectiveness as the main criterion to evaluate the different solutions.

    How to cite: Markantonis, D., Siganou, A., Moraiti, K., Nikolinakou, M., Sargentis, G.-F., Dimitriadis, P., Chiotinis, M., Iliopoulou, T., Mamassis, N., and Koutsoyiannis, D.: Determining optimal scale of water infrastructure considering economical aspects with stochastic evaluation – Case study at the Municipality of Western Mani, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3039, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3039, 2022.

    EGU22-3055 | Presentations | HS7.4

    Optimizing water infrastructure solutions for small-scale distributed settlements – Case study at the Municipality of Western Mani. 

    Konstantina Moraiti, David Markantonis, Maria Nikolinakou, Aimilia Siganou, G.-Fivos Sargentis, Theano Iliopoulou, Panayiotis Dimitriadis, Ilias Taygetos Meletopoulos, Nikos Mamassis, and Demetris Koutsoyiannis

    Water infrastructure is an indicator of human civilization and its evolution. The sustainable water management and distribution to local communities remains a critical engineering priority so that the most efficient usage is achieved. In this analysis the design of water-infrastructure establishments is studied for the community of the Municipality of Western Mani (western Peloponnese, Greece).

    One of the main issues that arise is the presence of karstic-limestone geological structure at the study area with no permanent watercourses. Furthermore, the lack of data about the current quantity of surface water makes it difficult to formulate trustworthy conclusions on the availability of water resources. Additionally, the notable growth of the tourist sector during the summer months in the past few years exacerbates this issue. Due to the above reasons, the available water is not enough to cover the needs of the Municipality, especially during the summer.

    After examining all the possible options that have been proposed to increase the water availability (e.g., through dams, wells, desalination, water ponds etc.), we investigate an optimal solution that aims to achieve a more efficient water management and distribution to the communities of Western Mani. To this aim, we apply a multi-criteria decision-making approach by also considering local traditional water harvesting systems to increase water resilience.

    How to cite: Moraiti, K., Markantonis, D., Nikolinakou, M., Siganou, A., Sargentis, G.-F., Iliopoulou, T., Dimitriadis, P., Meletopoulos, I. T., Mamassis, N., and Koutsoyiannis, D.: Optimizing water infrastructure solutions for small-scale distributed settlements – Case study at the Municipality of Western Mani., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3055, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3055, 2022.

    EGU22-3063 | Presentations | HS7.4

    Investigating the water supply potential of traditional rainwater harvesting techniques used – A case study for the Municipality of Western Mani 

    Maria Nikolinakou, Konstantina Moraiti, Aimilia Siganou, David Markantonis, G.-Fivos Sargentis, Theano Iliopoulou, Panayiotis Dimitriadis, Ilias Taygetos Meletopoulos, Nikos Mamassis, and Demetris Koutsoyiannis

    Water availability is a critical issue for growing local communities. For example, in the Municipality of Western Mani (western Peloponnese, Greece) tourist development has caused scarcity of water intensifying during the summer period. In this context, multiple solutions are being studied in order to assist the local communities of Western Mani to deal with this situation.

    This study focuses on traditional water harvesting structures and more specifically cisterns. In the past, a cistern was present nearby or almost at every house, collecting rain water so as to cover the various needs of the inhabitants, including human consumption and irrigation. However, although cisterns today have fallen into disuse due to the developments of modern water supply systems, they remain an important part of cultural heritage and an architectural element of great interest.

    In this work, we evaluate the potential of traditional water infrastructures to cover domestic needs employing the method of stochastic simulation based on hydrological data and by also taking into account traditional architecture.

    How to cite: Nikolinakou, M., Moraiti, K., Siganou, A., Markantonis, D., Sargentis, G.-F., Iliopoulou, T., Dimitriadis, P., Meletopoulos, I. T., Mamassis, N., and Koutsoyiannis, D.: Investigating the water supply potential of traditional rainwater harvesting techniques used – A case study for the Municipality of Western Mani, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3063, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3063, 2022.

    EGU22-3082 | Presentations | HS7.4

    Investigation of stochastic similarities between wind and waves and their impact on offshore structures 

    Sofia Efraimia Vrettou, Alexandra Trompouki, Theano Iliopoulou, G.-Fivos Sargentis, Panayiotis Dimitriadis, and Demetris Koutsoyiannis

    Offshore wind farms are increasingly gaining acceptance in the field of energy production. From an engineering point of view, such offshore structures are affected by various sources of uncertainty. The most severe one, is the impact that wave (height and period) and wind processes have, either at the fatigue, and in some cases failure of such structures, or at the efficiency of their energy production. In this work, we are focusing on the stochastic properties of the above processes and on their impacts on offshore structures. By extracting data from gauging stations at the Aegean Sea, we specifically examine the stochastic similarities among the marginal moments and the correlation function with focus on the extremes of the wind velocity and the wave height and period, and we discuss their impacts on open sea structures.

    How to cite: Vrettou, S. E., Trompouki, A., Iliopoulou, T., Sargentis, G.-F., Dimitriadis, P., and Koutsoyiannis, D.: Investigation of stochastic similarities between wind and waves and their impact on offshore structures, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3082, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3082, 2022.

    EGU22-3083 | Presentations | HS7.4

    Investigation of the spatial correlation structure of 2-D wave fields at the Aegean Sea 

    Alexandra Trompouki, Sofia Efraimia Vrettou, G.-Foivos Sargentis, Panayiotis Dimitriadis, Theano Iliopoulou, and Demetris Koutsoyiannis

    The great potential of oceanic energy resources adds a new challenge in the field of off-shore engineering, that of the efficient energy extraction from sophisticated structures in the open sea. An additional challenge that the engineers have to face is the intrinsic uncertainty of the oceanic processes. In this work, we investigate the uncertainty of the wave process through the estimation of the variability in two-dimensional wave height and direction data. These are retrieved from satellite images over the Aegean Sea for a 5-year period with a 3-hour resolution. Particularly, we estimate first-order moments, considering the double seasonality of the wave events, and also the correlation structure in terms of the climacogram (i.e., variance of the averaged process vs. spatial scale). Finally, we discuss on how the spatial dependence of the wave field is affected by various weather events.

    How to cite: Trompouki, A., Vrettou, S. E., Sargentis, G.-F., Dimitriadis, P., Iliopoulou, T., and Koutsoyiannis, D.: Investigation of the spatial correlation structure of 2-D wave fields at the Aegean Sea, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3083, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3083, 2022.

    EGU22-3086 | Presentations | HS7.4

    Stochastic simulation of hydrological timeseries for data scarce regions - Case study at the Municipality of Western Mani 

    Aimilia Siganou, Maria Nikolinakou, David Markantonis, Konstantina Moraiti, G.-Fivos Sargentis, Theano Iliopoulou, Panayiotis Dimitriadis, Michalis Chiotinis, Nikos Mamassis, and Demetris Koutsoyiannis

    West Mani, an attractive place in western Peloponnese, Greece, faces water shortage. The problem lies not only in the quantity but also in the quality of the available water. Investigating the options for the sustainable management of water resources, utilizing surface water seems to be the optimal solution. However, the complex geomorphology and geology of the study area, and its particular its karstic structure, when combined with the scarcity of hydrological data, makes the estimation of surface water availability challenging. As a result, it is considered necessary to take hydrological uncertainty into account using stochastic analysis. To this aim, we generate synthetic rainfall and streamflow timeseries based on available meteorological data from basins near the area of interest. We then appropriately adjust them so that they represent the magnitude and the variability of the rainfall and streamflow of the study area. For the timeseries generation algorithm, we employ a stochastic model following the Hurst-Kolmogorov dynamics by reproducing marginal distribution, seasonality and persistence.

    How to cite: Siganou, A., Nikolinakou, M., Markantonis, D., Moraiti, K., Sargentis, G.-F., Iliopoulou, T., Dimitriadis, P., Chiotinis, M., Mamassis, N., and Koutsoyiannis, D.: Stochastic simulation of hydrological timeseries for data scarce regions - Case study at the Municipality of Western Mani, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3086, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3086, 2022.

    EGU22-4704 | Presentations | HS7.4

    Future changes of average and extreme rainfall for the Bologna region 

    Rui Guo and Alberto Montanari

    Simulation of daily rainfall for the region of Bologna produced by 13 climate models for the period 1850 - 2100 are considered. Data are compared with the historical series of daily rainfall observed in Bologna for the period 1850 - 2014. In particular, we focus on annual rainfall data, seasonality and extremes to derive information on the future development of water resources availability and flood risk. The results prove that rainfall seasonality is fairly well simulated by models, while the historical sequence of annual rainfall is not satisfactorily reproduced. Future projections for different emission scenarios allow to assess the impact of climate change on cumulative rainfall and extremes, therefore outlining important technical indications.

    How to cite: Guo, R. and Montanari, A.: Future changes of average and extreme rainfall for the Bologna region, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4704, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4704, 2022.

    EGU22-5944 | Presentations | HS7.4

    Identifying links between hydroclimatic variability and economical components using stochastic methods 

    Ilias Arvanitidis, Marianna Diamanta, G.-Fivos Sargentis, Theano Iliopoulou, Panayiotis Dimitriadis, and Demetris Koutsoyiannis

    Since ancient times water has been a substantial factor for driving economic growth, as abundance in water resources can be linked to the development of prosperous communities. This study examines the effect of water resources availability on different sectors of the economy, by identifying components of Gross Domestic Product which are most affected by key water cycle processes and water infrastructures. In this analysis, we investigate the correlation among the above processes, on both temporal and spatial scale with the implementation of stochastic methods, in order to assess the sensitivity of the economy to hydroclimatic variability. We also take into consideration the effect of hydroclimatic extremes such as droughts and the limitations they may impose on growth. Differences between climate zones are taken into consideration by the Köppen climate index.

    How to cite: Arvanitidis, I., Diamanta, M., Sargentis, G.-F., Iliopoulou, T., Dimitriadis, P., and Koutsoyiannis, D.: Identifying links between hydroclimatic variability and economical components using stochastic methods, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5944, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5944, 2022.

    EGU22-10144 | Presentations | HS7.4

    Climate change and hydrological extremes: predicting and preparing for the impact on water resources 

    Andrew Watson, Jodie Miller, Sven Kralisch, Yuliya Vystavna, David Soto, Astrid Harjung, and Jörg Helmschrot

    Understanding hydrological flow variability and quantification of groundwater recharge rates have been two of the cornerstones of sustainable water management for decades. The cause-and-effect relationship between flow variability and groundwater recharge is mainly dependent on climate type, for example Mediterranean climates vs tropical climates. Each climate type, has historically been predictable, for example mean annual temperature, temperature amplitude, mean annual precipitation and precipitation seasonality, implying that the system could be modelled so long as there were sufficient data records. However, two of the most commonly cited consequences of climate change are extreme weather events and hydroclimatic instability. Both processes break down the “predictable” component of hydro-climatic modelling and require a re-evaluation of both how models are set up for simulation of the hydrological system in any given location as well as the data needed to support these simulations. In short, are our current models ready for a dynamic climate and the associated hydrological system change? Adapting to this changed climate reality requires a multifaceted approach that integrates environmental parameters (temperature, evaporation, precipitation), hydrological tracers (e.g., water isotopes), hydro-climatic indices but also incorporates anthropogenic impacts (e.g., water impoundments). Often these parameters/tracers are governed by data constraints at the spatial (e.g., point data) and temporal scale (data continuity). In this contribution we examine the results of rainfall-runoff modelling in southern Africa where soil-moisture-deficit-index was used to show that headwater drought is a key indicator of severe oncoming dry conditions. In particular, changes in precipitation seasonality required the recalibration of model parameters for ‘wet’ and ‘dry’ periods in order to make the model adaptable to unpredictable climate variability. In spite of multiple calibration efforts, the temporal uncertainty remained significant due to anthropogenic changes in the system being modelled, for example water diversions into dams and abstractions for irrigation, changes that are likely to increase in the future. Stable water isotopes are sensitive tracers of the impact of climate change on hydrological flow because they are natural constitutes of water and their partitioning is strongly dependent on temperature. The integration of temperature sensitive hydrological tracers like water isotopes and along with other hydro-climatic indices within hydrological modelling systems can advance the development of flexible modelling tools that better accommodate climate variability. Doing so however, requires an assessment of what data records will be needed in the future, and taking steps to ensure that the collections of these datasets are prioritized.

    How to cite: Watson, A., Miller, J., Kralisch, S., Vystavna, Y., Soto, D., Harjung, A., and Helmschrot, J.: Climate change and hydrological extremes: predicting and preparing for the impact on water resources, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10144, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10144, 2022.

    EGU22-10418 | Presentations | HS7.4

    Copulas for hydroclimatic analysis: A practice-oriented overview 

    Faranak Tootoonchi, Mojtaba Sadegh, Jan Olaf Haerter, Olle Räty, Thomas Grabs, and Claudia Teutschbein

    A warming climate is associated with increasing hydroclimatic extremes, which are often interconnected through complex processes, prompting their concurrence and/or succession, and causing compound extreme events. It is critical to analyze the risks of compound events, given their disproportionately high adverse impacts. To account for the variability in two or more hydroclimatic variables (e.g., temperature and precipitation) and their dependence, a rising number of publications focuses on multivariate analysis, among which the notion of copula-based probability distribution has attracted tremendous interest. Copula is a mathematical function that expresses the joint cumulative probability distribution of multiple variables. Our focus is to re-emphasize the fundamental requirements and limitations of applying copulas. Confusion about these requirements may lead to misconceptions and pitfalls, which can potentially compromise the robustness of risk analyses for environmental processes and natural hazards. We conducted a systematic literature review of copulas, as a prominent tool in the arsenal of multivariate methods used for compound event analysis, and underpinned them with a hydroclimatic case study in Sweden to illustrate a practical approach to copula-based modeling. Here, we (1) provide end-users with a didactic overview of necessary requirements, statistical assumptions and consequential limitations of copulas, (2) synthesize common perceptions and practices, and (3) offer a user-friendly decision support framework to employ copulas, thereby support researchers and practitioners in addressing hydroclimatic hazards, hence demystify what can be an area of confusion. 

    How to cite: Tootoonchi, F., Sadegh, M., Haerter, J. O., Räty, O., Grabs, T., and Teutschbein, C.: Copulas for hydroclimatic analysis: A practice-oriented overview, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10418, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10418, 2022.

    EGU22-10822 | Presentations | HS7.4

    Extreme rainfall quantile estimation based on SSP scenarios: Focusing on the Hangang river basin 

    Sunghun Kim, Heechul Kim, Gyobeom Kim, and Jun-Haeng Heo

    This study attempts to estimate the extreme rainfall quantile using the climate model data of the Shared Socioeconomic Pathways (SSP) scenarios presented in the sixth Assessment Report (AR6), published by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). Generally, the applied research related to climate change is conducted using numerical simulation data from various climate models. Generally, an ensemble scenario based on various regional climate models is used as a way to reduce the uncertainty from one climate model. In this study, the ensemble rainfall data (based on HadGEM3-RA, WRF, CCLM, GRIMs, and RegCM4) were obtained from the climate information portal (CIP, http://www.climate.go.kr/). The observed rainfall data was extracted and the regional quantile delta mapping (RQDM) method was applied for bias correction. Regional frequency analysis (RFA) was performed to estimate the rainfall quantile. In addition, the generalized extreme value (GEV) distribution was applied as an appropriate probability distribution and the L-moments method was used for parameter estimation. As a result, the rainfall quantiles were estimated, and the effects of climate change were analyzed quantitatively in the study area.

    How to cite: Kim, S., Kim, H., Kim, G., and Heo, J.-H.: Extreme rainfall quantile estimation based on SSP scenarios: Focusing on the Hangang river basin, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10822, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10822, 2022.

    EGU22-11845 | Presentations | HS7.4

    Changes in Intensity-Duration-Frequency Curves with an Ensemble of EA-CORDEX over South Korea 

    Jae-Ung Yu, Jangwon Moon, Yunsung Kim, and Hyun-Han Kwon

    An ensemble of ten regional climate model (RCM) simulations, forced by two global climate models (GCM) such as HadGEM2-AO, MPI-ESM-LR, and GFDL2M, at 25km spatial resolution from the CORDEX-EA Phase-2 is explored to assess the changes in rainfall intensity-duration-frequency (IDF), commonly employed in the hydrologic study, in a changing climate. This study first constructs a probability density function (PDF) for the observed precipitation. The log-likelihood for the modeled precipitation is then estimated from the PDF to rank the RCMs. Ensemble construction is further performed based on these rankings. The temporal downscaling approach employed in this study is based on a conditional copula function method developed by So et al. (2018), which incorporates a quantile mapping approach for bias correction. The proposed ensemble modeling framework for constructing future IDF relationships could provide a better representation of the uncertainty associated with climate models. A detailed discussion of the potential application of the ensemble approach in extreme analysis is further provided.

    How to cite: Yu, J.-U., Moon, J., Kim, Y., and Kwon, H.-H.: Changes in Intensity-Duration-Frequency Curves with an Ensemble of EA-CORDEX over South Korea, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11845, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11845, 2022.

    EGU22-12320 | Presentations | HS7.4

    Hydrological Model Calibration Strategy for Climate Change Impacts Study  

    Ye-Rin Lee, Yoon-Jeong Kwon, Hojun Kim, and Hyun-Han Kwon

    Hydrological models require calibration to provide accurate simulation, and the calibration usually often requires long-term historical hydrometeorological data. The calibrated parameters obtained from historical data are assumed to be stationary. However, the stationary assumption for the para terms in the hydrological modeling may not be appropriate for the future climate, especially in a changing climate. This study aims to explore different approaches to minimize this issue by comparing calibration frameworks and offer alternative strategies to improve model robustness for climate change impact studies. The optimization strategies consider nonstationarity in the model parameters associated with different climate regimes and provide a functional form with dynamic climate predictors to better represent abnormal climates informed by a set of climate change scenarios over South Korea.

    How to cite: Lee, Y.-R., Kwon, Y.-J., Kim, H., and Kwon, H.-H.: Hydrological Model Calibration Strategy for Climate Change Impacts Study , EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12320, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12320, 2022.

    The Intensity and frequency of extreme storms have been increasing due to possible climate change, making it challenging to manage stormwaters in highly urbanized areas. Without an adequate and appropriate stormwater system, these storms may cause significant damage and losses to live and properties. Low Impact Development (LID) is a recent but widely accepted alternative for managing the increased stormwater. However, limited research is available to understand their effectiveness and optimize the mix of LIDs and conventional stormwater systems. This study evaluates the performance of several LIDs under current and future storm conditions, identify the best performing mixes of LIDs and convention stormwater system and provide a decision-making tool for urban stormwater management. The methodologies will be tested for Renton City, which is part of the Seattle Metropolitan Area.

    In order to achieve our objective, first, a statistical rainfall-runoff model will be developed to assess the current stormwater system and estimate runoff for the current and future periods. The final results indicate a significant increase in runoff due to the increased rainfall in the future (2020-2040) compared to the past (1995-2014). The Stormwater Management Model (SWMM) will then be used to simulate the rainfall-runoff under conventional and LIDs (e.g., bio-retention, rain barrels, rain gardens, infiltration trenches, and permeable pavement) stormwater system. The final results show that the performance of LIDs in reducing total runoff volume varies with the types and combinations of LIDs. A 30% to 75% reduction in runoff was achieved for the past and future 50-year and 100-year storms. A Genetic Algorithm (GA) is used to optimize the LID and conventional stormwater system considering the reduction in runoff, installation and maintenance costs. The type, size, location, and number of different LIDs will be considered as decision variables for the GA. Finally, the study aims at developing a comprehensive framework to evaluate the performance of LIDs under present and future storms and identify cost and performance effective LIDs in a given urban area. The framework introduced in this study will help local authorities and practitioners to implement appropriate climate change adaptation strategies by maximizing the benefit from LIDs and ensure sustainable stormwater management for the current and future climates.

    How to cite: Abduljaleel, Y. and Demissie, Y.: Evaluation and Optimization of Low Impact Development Designs for Sustainable Stormwater Management in a Changing Climate, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13, 2022.

    EGU22-1830 | Presentations | HS7.5

    Prestorm root zone soil moisture conditions critical for flood forecasting in Europe 

    Christian Massari, Francesco Marra, Yves Tramblay, Wade Crow, Stefania Camici, Sara Modanesi, Luca Brocca, and Gaby Gruendemann

    Recent evidences suggest that in Europe, flood frequency and precipitation frequencies are often not aligned. Beside other factors pre-storm conditions exert a significant impact on flood generation thus their knowledge is paramount for a proper flood forecasting. A number of predictors have been used in the past to understand how much precipitation is transformed into runoff (i.e., runoff coefficient, RC). Notable examples are the antecedent precipitation index (API), the prestorm river discharge and soil moisture. On top of these new products potentially available from satellite observations like surface soil moisture and total water storage anomalies (TWSA), root zone soil moisture from reanalysis and hydrological models can be used along with precipitation to predict in advance the severity of the storm runoff.Our goal here is to provide an objective description of the role played by different predictors for hydrologic forecasting in Europe. In particular, we aim at answering the following research questions:

    • How variable is runoff coefficient across the European catchments?
    • How much are surface and root zone soil moisture, river discharge, antecedent precipitation and total water storage anomalies able to explain the RC variability across European floods?
    • Under which conditions (climate period, location and flood magnitude) are the different pre-storm indices able to predict this runoff coefficient variability?

    We answered these questions using long term (1980-2016) precipitation and river discharge observations from more than 100 basins covering different European regions. Results demonstrated that root zone soil moisture and TWSA are the best predictors of prestorm conditions under a variety of climatic and geographic features and thus their correct representation in land surface and hydrological models is strategic for an effective flood forecasting.

    How to cite: Massari, C., Marra, F., Tramblay, Y., Crow, W., Camici, S., Modanesi, S., Brocca, L., and Gruendemann, G.: Prestorm root zone soil moisture conditions critical for flood forecasting in Europe, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1830, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1830, 2022.

    EGU22-1981 | Presentations | HS7.5 | Highlight

    Globally consistent tropical cyclones impact forecast system for population displacement 

    Pui Man Kam, Christopher Fairless, and David N. Bresch

    Tropical cyclones (TCs) displace millions of people every year. Displaced people are subject to heightened risks to their physical and mental well-being. We present the first results of a TC impact forecast system for population displacement, aiding the decision-making process for planning early prevention and mitigation actions. For example, planning precautionary evacuations and the allocation of humanitarian aid. We work closely with the Internal Displacement Monitoring Centre (IDMC) to develop a global TC impact forecast system that predicts the number of people potentially affected or displaced.

    We build the impact forecast system using a python-based, open-source, globally consistent platform called CLIMADA (CLIMate ADAptation). The platform integrates probabilistic hazard, exposure, and vulnerability information to compute the potential impacts from TC events. The first prototype of the forecast system extracts information from ECMWF ensemble TC forecast tracks, a global population layer at ~1km resolution, and vulnerability functions that relate the exposed people to the intensity of TC wind speed. We show case studies of recent TC events to reveal the potential of the displacement forecast system, the uncertainties of the forecast results

    The displacement forecast system will provide richer information for decision-makers and help improve warnings. The open-source data and codes of this implementation are also transferable to other users, hazards, and impact types. 

    How to cite: Kam, P. M., Fairless, C., and Bresch, D. N.: Globally consistent tropical cyclones impact forecast system for population displacement, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1981, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1981, 2022.

    EGU22-1985 | Presentations | HS7.5

    Extremes in South African Rainfall: Mean Characteristics and Seamless Variability Across Multiple Timescales 

    Asmat Ullah, Benjamin Pohl, Julien Pergaud, Bastien Dieppois, and Mathieu Rouault

    Rainfall extremes are of major and increasing importance in semi-arid countries and their variability has strong implications for water resource and climate impacts on the local societies and environment. Here, we examine extremes intraseasonal descriptors (ISDs) in austral summer rainfall (November–February) over South Africa (SA). Using daily observations from 225 rain gauges, ERA5 reanalysis and satellite estimates (TRMM-3B42), we propose a novel typology of wet extreme events based on their spatial fraction, thus differentiating large- and small-scale extremes. Long-term variability of both types of extreme rainfall events is then extensively discussed. The relationship between these two types of rainfall extremes and different modes of climate variability is further explored at multiple timescales. At low-frequency modes, rainfall extremes are assessed at interannual (IV: 2−8 years) and quasi-decadal (QDV: 8−13 years) timescales which are primarily associated with El Niño Southern Oscillation (ENSO) and Interdecadal Pacific Oscillation (IPO) respectively. At high-frequency modes, rainfall extremes are evaluated with synoptic-scale variability related to seven convective regimes of Tropical Temperate Troughs (TTTs: 3–7 days) and intraseasonal variability associated with eight phases of the Madden-Julien Oscillation (MJO: 30–60 days).

    The results demonstrate that using 7% of spatial fraction simultaneously exceeding the local threshold of the 90th percentile produces remarkable results in characterizing rainfall extremes into large- and small-scale extremes. Austral summer total rainfall is found to be primarily shaped by large-scale extremes which constitute more than half of the rainfall amount under observation, and nearly half in ERA5. Observation (ERA5) shows an average of 8 ± 5 (20 ± 7) days per season associated with large-scale extremes, which are comprised in 5 ± 3 (10 ± 3) spells with an average persistence of at least 2 days. Overall, we find a strong dependence of total rainfall on the number of wet days and wet spells that are associated with large-scale extremes. We also find that large- and small-scale extremes are well-organized and spatially coherent yet extreme conditions during small-scale events are found sporadic over the region, contrasting with large-scale events for which extreme conditions are found over a larger and coherent region.

    Teleconnections with global SSTs confirm that La Niña conditions favor overall wet conditions and wet extremes in SA. The frequency of large-scale extremes is consistently related to warmer SSTs in the North Atlantic while their link with warmer Indian and tropical South Atlantic Ocean found stronger without ENSO influence. At low-frequency timescale, risk ratio assessment shows that the frequency (total rainfall) of large-scale extremes is significantly modified by IV (QDV) timescale. We note strong variations in the frequency (total rainfall) of large-scale (small-scale) extremes when IV timescale lies in strong positive phase (i.e., +0.5 standard deviation). At high-frequency timescale, the synoptic-scale variability associated with TTT events, are mostly responsible for changes in large-scale extremes as nearly 75% of such events occur during early to mature TTT regimes (3−5) whereas small-scale extremes were found equiprobable during all synoptic regimes. A risk ratio assessment suggests that the probability of large-scale extremes in TTT regime 5 significantly enhance (suppress) during MJO phases 6−8 (1−2).

    How to cite: Ullah, A., Pohl, B., Pergaud, J., Dieppois, B., and Rouault, M.: Extremes in South African Rainfall: Mean Characteristics and Seamless Variability Across Multiple Timescales, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1985, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1985, 2022.

    EGU22-2474 | Presentations | HS7.5

    Modelling flood events in Venice Lagoon with a cumulant CO lattice Boltzmann shallow water model 

    Jessica Padrone, Silvia Di Francesco, and Sara Venturi

    In this work a multi-relaxation time (MRT) Lattice Boltzmann model based on the use of non-conventional collision operator is used to simulate the flood event in Venice Lagoon.

    Numerical methods (finite difference, finite volume and finite element methods) that solve the macroscopic equations of fluid mechanics (Navier Stokes equations), are usually employed for these aims. Most of these methods put in evidence that the application of bed slope and friction forces can lead to inaccurate solutions due to numerical errors.

    In addition, the extension of these schemes to complex geometries is not straightforward and some of these approaches are very computational expensive if applied to real flows. Since the problems are posed at a large scale, it should be the aim to develop a simple and accurate representation of the source term to simulate realistic shallow water flows.

    The LBM approach is a versatile method and it has been extensively applied in different fields.

    Non-conventional Lattice Boltzmann models based on central moments and cumulants collision operators allows to simulate large-scale hydraulic problems such as flooding events and the use of a GIS environment allows to set the information related to topography, initial conditions (water depth and velocity values distribution), boundary conditions (position and type of solid and inlet/outlet boundaries), external force (value and distribution of roughness coefficients, obstacles position) and to make this data available for the execution of the numerical model.

    In order to validate the correctness of the proposed mathematical model for Venice Lagoon, the real flood event that took place on November 12, 2019 is simulated: several field data are available for this test case; the results, in terms of water level and velocity field are compared with recorded data, verifying the accordance. Moreover, technical solutions for hydraulic risk evaluation and mitigation, taking account of the expected sea level rise, due to climate change, are proposed.

    How to cite: Padrone, J., Di Francesco, S., and Venturi, S.: Modelling flood events in Venice Lagoon with a cumulant CO lattice Boltzmann shallow water model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2474, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2474, 2022.

    EGU22-2578 | Presentations | HS7.5

    Identification of regional landslide triggering thresholds in the Lombardy region using multivariate statistical analysis 

    Nunziarita Palazzolo, David Johnny Peres, Enrico Creaco, and Antonino Cancelliere

    Landslides represent a critical natural hazard in many mountain and hilly regions worldwide, provoking causalities and property damages. Landslide triggering thresholds are at the basis of early warning systems to protect livelihoods. Traditionally, landslide triggering thresholds are expressed in terms of not more than two or three precipitation variables, mostly rainfall event depth, and duration. Indeed, the availability of soil moisture information and its proxies (such as antecedent precipitation), can improve the performance of landslide triggering thresholds, thus calling for a multivariate approach.  

    Given the above context, this study aims to develop regional landslide triggering thresholds by using multivariate statistical analysis to investigate the performance of multiple combinations of rainfall variables and event soil moisture data, in the identification of regional rainfall thresholds for landslide initiation. Lombardy region (northern Italy) was selected as a study area since it is one of the most susceptible Italian regions to landslide risk. The data on landslides were retrieved from the FraneIalia project that is a comprehensive spatio-temporal database of recent landslides affecting the Italian territory from 2010 onwards. For the Lombardy region, from 2010 to 2019, 592 landslides events triggered by rainfall were detected, all distributed within the mountain and hilly areas of the region.

    Precipitation and soil moisture time series, instead, were derived from the ERA5-Land reanalysis dataset and the rainfall events were reconstructed using the CTRL-T code developed by IRPI-CNR, which characterizes each rainfall event by duration, mean intensity, total depth, and peak intensity. The most probable rainfall conditions associated with each landslide are, then, computed based on the distance between the rain gauge and the landslide location. Different combinations of precipitation and soil moisture variables are tested using dimensionality reduction multivariate statistical techniques. An optimization procedure is set up with the aim to maximize the True Skill Statistic (TSS) ROC index associated with parametric thresholds. Several multivariate combinations show better performances than the traditional depth-duration power-law thresholds.  

    How to cite: Palazzolo, N., Peres, D. J., Creaco, E., and Cancelliere, A.: Identification of regional landslide triggering thresholds in the Lombardy region using multivariate statistical analysis, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2578, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2578, 2022.

    EGU22-3026 | Presentations | HS7.5 | Highlight

    The RiskChanges tool for multi-hazard risk-informed planning at local government level 

    Cees van Westen, Manzul Hazarika, Ashok Dahal, Tek Kshetri, Anish Shakya, and Syams Nashrrullah

    Local governments are faced with increasing levels of risk from extreme hydro-meteorological events such as (tropical) storms,  flooding, landslides, drought, heatwaves, wildfires, etc. The frequency and interaction of these events, also in combination with other events that do not have a direct climate driver, makes that it is likely that many areas are faced with higher impacts from compounding events. Global trends such as population growth, urbanization, increased dependency on technology also contributed to larger exposure and vulnerability. In order to plan for future developments, and for reducing the increasing levels of risk, local governments require to plan ahead and evaluate the options available for reducing the risk under future scenarios. For this task Spatial Decision Support Systems are required that allow local governments to make informed decisions, considering the current and future levels of risk. RiskChanges is a Spatial Decision Support System for the analysis of current and future multi-hazard risk at a local level, in order to analyze optimal risk reduction alternatives. The system is developed by the University of Twente in collaboration with the Asian Institute of Technology, GeoInformatics Centre. RiskChanges ( http://www.riskchanges.org/ ) is an Open-Source, web-based tool, based on a series of python scripts, which are integrated into a Graphical User Interface. The tool includes several major features: multi-hazard, multiple assets, a vulnerability curve database, multi-user approach, comparison of risk, and spatial analysis. Users can upload their own datasets (in the form of hazard maps, elements-at-risk maps, administrative unit maps, and vulnerability curves). The tool contains an open-source vulnerability curve database, allowing to sharing of physical vulnerability curves among users. Multiple users can collaborate on the same project, and provide different input data. The multi-hazard feature allows performing the risk assessment for multiple natural and manmade hazard interactions. Exposure and vulnerability are combined in a loss calculation for each combination of element-at-risk and hazard. Loss maps are integrated into a risk map, where the user indicates the interaction between the hazard types. The system allows to analyze the risk of multiple asset types with different spatial characteristics.  Users can compare the risk for the current situation and future scenarios and/or planning alternatives.  

    How to cite: van Westen, C., Hazarika, M., Dahal, A., Kshetri, T., Shakya, A., and Nashrrullah, S.: The RiskChanges tool for multi-hazard risk-informed planning at local government level, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3026, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3026, 2022.

    EGU22-3200 | Presentations | HS7.5

    Dynamic flood hazard maps based on traffic flow forecasts using mobile phone data 

    Babak Razdar, Rodolfo Metulini, Maurizio Carpita, and Roberto Ranzi

    Maps of flooding risk and exposure generally assume people and vehicles density constant over time, although this is not the case in the real world, as crowding is a highly dynamic process in urban areas. Monitoring and forecasting people mobility is a relevant aspect for metropolitan areas subjected to high risk of flooding. Information and communication technologies (ICT) along with big data are massively used, e.g., to support the optimization of traffic flows and the study of urban systems. In particular, mobile phone network data suits with the aim of producing dynamic information on people's movements that can be used to develop dynamic exposure to flood risk maps for areas with hydrogeological criticality, as done by Balistrocchi et al. (2020).

    In this work we aim at proposing a time series modelling strategy to obtain “real time” traffic flows prediction. To do so we use mobile phone origin-destination signals on the flow of Telecom Italia Mobile (TIM) users among different census areas (ACE of ISTAT, the Italian National Statistical Institute), and for the MoSoRe Project 2020-2022 and recorded at hourly basis from September 2020 to August 2021.

    An Harmonic Dynamic Regression (HDR) model (Hyndman, Athanasopoulos, 2021) as it follows:

    Flow= α+Fourier.day (K_d )+Fourier.week (K_w )+ Month+ε_(ARIMA(p,d,q))                        (1)

    is proposed, where multiple seasonal periods are modelled with a properly selected number of Fourier basis, month is a dummy variable to account for different levels of flows by months and the error component is structured as an ARIMA.

    HDR model suits for our purposes due to the strong daily and weekly patterns in traffic flows, as also confirmed by preliminar results on the accuracy of prediction based on a cross-validation strategy.

    In future developments, the model in equation 1 may be improved by adding proper features as explanatory variables to increase the prediction accuracy, such as, e.g., the presence of people in the census area of origin and in the census area of destination of the flow, or precipitation data.

    People’s and vehicles’ exposure obtained from mobile phone data and processed with the above stochastic model are then combined to flooding hazard maps estimated for different storm return period in a urbanized area close to Brescia to estimate dynamic flood risk maps.      

    References

    Balistrocchi, M., Metulini, R, Carpita, M., Ranzi, R.: Dynamic maps of human exposure to floods based on mobile phone data. Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences, 20: 3485{3500 (2020).

    Hyndman, R. J., Athanasopoulos, G.: Forecasting: principles and practice. 3rd edition, OTexts: Melbourne, Australia. OTexts.com/fpp3 (2021)

    How to cite: Razdar, B., Metulini, R., Carpita, M., and Ranzi, R.: Dynamic flood hazard maps based on traffic flow forecasts using mobile phone data, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3200, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3200, 2022.

    EGU22-4011 | Presentations | HS7.5

    Long waves in the Port of Klaipėda 

    Laura Nesteckytė, Loreta Klepšaitė-Rimkienė, and Kai Antero Myrberg

    The entire strait is the base of the port aquatorium and a vital shipping artery from the Baltic Sea to the Curonian Lagoon as well as a complex water system connecting two water basins of different sizes and depths and nature: differing considerably in salinity and density. Although the quays are well protected from the waves of the open sea, dangerous water level fluctuations still occur in the port area, the origin of which is not yet well understood. This study aims to identify the occurrence and main characteristics of the long waves, with the period from minutes to several hours, to identify their origin and impact.

    Analysis of the spectral composition of these oscillations is based on continuous pressure recordings at a frequency of 4 Hz in Klaipėda harbour during the stormy season 2016-2017 and repeated during calm and stormy seasons in 2021. Most of the oscillation energy is concentrated in two frequency bands. Significant water level changes occurred due to infragravity motions with periods of 30 s (0.03 Hz) and disturbances with the typical periods of wind waves on the Lithuanian coast with periods of 3-10 s (0.1-0.3 Hz). The highest peak in the wind wave frequency band corresponds to typical storm conditions in the Baltic Sea with periods of 5-9 s. While the typical amplitudes of the oscillations in this range were modest, hazardous changes in water level occurred at lower frequencies with amplitudes of 0.5 m. The record shows the presence of harbour oscillations with periods of 30-200 s (0.005-0.03 Hz) and seiches of the Curonian Lagoon with periods of 1200 s (0.0008 Hz).

    The largest oscillations are created by a combination of wind waves and infragravity waves with periods that roughly match the natural seiche periods of Klaipėda Strait and harbour oscillations and seiches can be observed not only during the stormy season.

    How to cite: Nesteckytė, L., Klepšaitė-Rimkienė, L., and Myrberg, K. A.: Long waves in the Port of Klaipėda, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4011, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4011, 2022.

    EGU22-4523 | Presentations | HS7.5

    High-impact weather events in Greece: Analysis of the period 2000-2020 

    Katerina Papagiannaki, Vassiliki Kotroni, Konstantinos Lagouvardos, and Antonis Bezes

    The subject of this presentation is the assessment of the occurrence, intensity, and impact severity of weather-related events with socio-economic implications during the period 2000-2020 in Greece. The aim is to draw critical conclusions through the distribution of events at the temporal and spatial level and in relation to their societal impact as measured by a qualitative impact-severity index. The data derived from the High Impact Weather Events (HIWE) database that has been developed by the METEO Unit at the National Observatory of Athens (NOA), is systematically updated and publicly available. The analysis includes events related to floods, lightning activity, hail, snow/frost, windstorms, and tornados having caused impacts on life (injury or death) and/or infrastructure. The presentation provides an overview of the data used and methodology applied for assessing weather-related hazards, and the results of their analysis that include the evolution of events, the most damaging phenomena, and the areas most exposed to each phenomenon. This work was conducted in the frame of CLIMPACT – National Νetwork on Climate Change and its Impacts, a flagship initiative on climate change to coordinate a Pan-Hellenic network of institutions.

    How to cite: Papagiannaki, K., Kotroni, V., Lagouvardos, K., and Bezes, A.: High-impact weather events in Greece: Analysis of the period 2000-2020, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4523, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4523, 2022.

    EGU22-4716 | Presentations | HS7.5

    Vulnerability scenarios for flash floods occurred in Campanian Apennines (South Italy) 

    Giovanni Forte, Melania De Falco, Nicoletta Santangelo, and Antonio Santo

    Flash floods are related to short duration and high intensity rainfalls, they are common phenomena in many parts of Europe as well as Italy. These events can result in debris flow, debris flood or water flood. The main differences are in the triggering, propagation, and depositional phases and more importantly in terms of velocity, impact forces and associated damage.
    In Campania Region (Southern Italy) these phenomena historically involved the catchments several times, with an increase in frequency in the last decade. They are associated to small watershed – fan systems that fall in the southern Apennines characterized by intermittent flow. The alluvial fans in the outlet zones are highly urbanized, hence the population living in the deposition areas is exposed to high risk. 
    In this study, the geomorphic response to flash floods is assessed through magnitude evaluation of some flash floods recently occurred in heterogeneous geological and geomorphological settings in both coastal and inland areas. Each scenario is reconstructed through the mapping of areal extent, water heights, particle sizes and estimate of volumes and built damage aiming at vulnerability definition, a relevant topic considering the global climate changes.
    In this study, an approach aimed at developing vulnerability curves is proposed. It is based on a application of a typical method widely adopted in the earthquake engineering that in this case assume as intensity parameter the water height measured in post-event surveys. 
    The results are expressed as vulnerability curves at different damage scenarios that can be valuable tools for local authorities, emergency, and disaster planners since they can assist decision making analysis of protection measures for future events.

    How to cite: Forte, G., De Falco, M., Santangelo, N., and Santo, A.: Vulnerability scenarios for flash floods occurred in Campanian Apennines (South Italy), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4716, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4716, 2022.

    EGU22-5214 | Presentations | HS7.5

    Global analysis of emergency service provision to vulnerable populations during floods of various magnitude under climate change 

    Sarah Johnson, Robert Wilby, Dapeng Yu, and Tom Matthews

    In a world of increasing global flood hazards, vulnerable populations (very young and elderly) are disproportionately affected by flooding due to their low self-reliance, weak political voice and insufficient inclusion into climate adaptation and emergency response plans. These individuals account for most flood casualties and often rely on emergency services due to flood induced injuries, exacerbated medical conditions, and requiring evacuative assistance. However, emergency service demand often exceeds the potential capacity whilst flooded roads and short emergency response timeframes decrease accessibility, service area, and population coverage; but how does this compare across the globe and what will the future hold?

    To answer this question, a global analytical framework has been created to determine the spatial, temporal, and demographic variability of emergency service provision during floods. This is based on global fluvial and coastal flooding (at 10-year and 100-year return periods), and present and future flood conditions (present-day and 2050, under RCP 4.5 and RCP 8.5 climate scenarios). The framework includes a hotspot analysis to identify the extent and distribution of flood hazards and at-risk vulnerable populations, an accessibility analysis to identify emergency service accessibility to vulnerable populations based on restrictions of flood barriers and response-time frameworks, and a vulnerability analysis to compare the environmental injustice of emergency service provision between key demographic groups.

    The highlighted geographical and temporal differences in emergency service provision globally and between regions, in addition to the framework itself, can be used by national and international organisations to inform strategic planning of emergency response operations and major investments of infrastructure, services, and facilities to maximise the benefit to the disproportionately affected vulnerable populations. This includes the production of more detailed flood hazard and evacuation maps that highlight vulnerability hotspots, the prioritisation of vulnerable population groups in emergency response plans to minimise geographic and population disparities of flood injuries and fatalities, and the allocation of emergency service hubs in regions of high vulnerability but low emergency response provision.

    How to cite: Johnson, S., Wilby, R., Yu, D., and Matthews, T.: Global analysis of emergency service provision to vulnerable populations during floods of various magnitude under climate change, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5214, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5214, 2022.

    EGU22-6434 | Presentations | HS7.5

    Preliminary analysis of high-resolution precipitation in Friuli Venezia Giulia region, Italy 

    Elisa Arnone, Dario Treppiedi, and Leonardo Noto

    The northeastern area of Italy, and specifically of Friuli Venezia Giulia region (FVG), is characterized by the heaviest precipitation annual totals in the country. Effects of both prolonged and extreme precipitation can be particularly damaging in this area, causing debris flow, flash floods, avalanches. Due to the very short times of concentration and hydrological response of the mountain watersheds of the analyzed area, extreme and short events are of particular interest. The region has a dense ground-station network which is managed by the regional Civil Protection Agency, constituted by 2 main rain-gauges networks, based on CAE and Micros-SIAP technology, respectively; this last is co-managed by the OSMER-ARPA (OSservatorio MEteorologico Regionale-Agenzia Regionale per la Protezione dell’Ambiente) FVG. The networks count a total of about 200 rain-gauges; for some stations, data at 5-minute resolution are available since the 1996 (CAE network), whereas Micros-SIAP works continuously and at high resolution since the early 2000s. Over the last two decades, the temporal resolution of stations has been progressively increased up to 1-minute step.

    This work presents a comprehensive analysis of the available dataset at high temporal resolution (i.e. 30 min, 5 min and 1 min) to verify whether trends in very short rainfall duration are underway. The continuous time series of data recorded by a sample of rain-gauges by the two networks are first analyzed. A preliminary analysis aims at verifying the consistency of the dataset at the higher resolutions. Statistical trends are then assessed by comparing two methods, i.e., the classical Mann-Kendall and the quantile regression at different thresholds and durations. Differently than the traditional methods that require a subset of data (e.g., the rainfall annual maxima), the quantile regression method allows to detect changes in the tails of the rainfall distributions and to screen the whole rainfall time series.

    How to cite: Arnone, E., Treppiedi, D., and Noto, L.: Preliminary analysis of high-resolution precipitation in Friuli Venezia Giulia region, Italy, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6434, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6434, 2022.

    EGU22-6884 | Presentations | HS7.5

    Spatial relationship between extreme rainfall anomalies and density of the triggered landslides 

    Slim Mtibaa and Haruka Tsunetaka

    Precipitation extremes affect the landscape differently and often drive numerous landslides widespread with disparate densities and features. Revealing the factors that govern this spatial variability is critical for understanding landslide susceptibility and developing prediction models. To this end, examining the peculiarities of the triggering rainfall event at spatial and temporal scales emerges as a promising method. Here, we relied on radar gauge-analyzed (R/A) rainfall estimates (period > 30 years, spatial resolution ≈ 5 km) and a landslide inventory for studying the spatial relationship between rainfall anomalies and triggered landslide density. The landslide inventory counts more than 7,600 shallow landslides distributed in about 550 km2 and triggered by an extreme rainfall event that hit the Kyushu area in southern Japan in July 2017. A total of 23 R/A cells with different landslide densities were identified from the landslide inventory. A standard period of 72 h (Pstd), where the cumulative rainfall during the triggering event is maximum, was used to evaluate the spatial rainfall peculiarities at short (1 – 24 h) and long (48 – 72) timescales. Subsequently, rainfall anomalies were discussed by plotting the mean intensities computed at multiple timescales within the Pstd in the intensity duration frequency (IDF) curves developed for each R/A cell. The spatial density of triggered landslides was strongly influenced by the rainfall intensities that exceeded the 100-years return levels at disparate timescales and demonstrated anomalies. More than 65 % of the triggered landslides were located in only three R/A cells. In these cells, rainfall intensities of the triggering event exceeded the 100-years return level at the various timescales (from short to long) within the Pstd, favoring numerous landslides of different geometric features. Rainfall intensities in cells with low landslide density reached the 100-years return levels at short timescales (3 – 24 h). However, this was not necessarily achieved in all low landslide density R/A cells. These preliminary results highlighted the spatial impacts of rainfall anomalies computed at multiple timescales on landslide densities and features and motivated further analysis.

    How to cite: Mtibaa, S. and Tsunetaka, H.: Spatial relationship between extreme rainfall anomalies and density of the triggered landslides, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6884, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6884, 2022.

    EGU22-8096 | Presentations | HS7.5

    Relationship between atmospheric rivers and landslides in western North America 

    Sara M. Vallejo-Bernal, Frederik Wolf, Lisa Luna, Niklas Boers, Norbert Marwan, and Jürgen Kurths

    In this study, we investigate the relationship between land-falling atmospheric rivers (ARs) and landslides in western North America. ARs are channels of enhanced water vapor flux in the atmosphere and play an essential role in the water supply for precipitation in the midlatitudes. However, they can also trigger natural hazards such as floods and landslides. Our objective is to determine if the occurrence of landslides in western North America can be attributed to ARs hitting the western coastline and causing rainfall at the locations of the landslides and to characterize the strength and persistence of the ARs that lead to landslides. To that aim, we use landslide records with daily temporal resolution along with daily rainfall estimates from the ERA5 reanalysis, for the period between 1996 and 2018. We propose and run two attribution models to relate landslides to rainfall and rainfall to ARs and subsequently verify statistically if there is a unique and significant association between the landslides and the ARs. Our results show that the majority of the landslides reported along the western coast of North America are preceded by an AR. In the coastal regions, ARs and landslides are significantly correlated. Further inland, landslides are less likely, but those that do occur are significantly correlated with very intense ARs. Understanding and revealing the impacts of ARs on landslides in western North America will lead to better forecasts and risk assessments of these natural hazards.

    How to cite: Vallejo-Bernal, S. M., Wolf, F., Luna, L., Boers, N., Marwan, N., and Kurths, J.: Relationship between atmospheric rivers and landslides in western North America, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8096, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8096, 2022.

    EGU22-8229 | Presentations | HS7.5 | Highlight

    User-driven platform to facilitate community data access, collaboration, and knowledge sharing on Nature-Based Solutions as mitigation measures for hydro-meteorological hazards 

    Laura S. Leo, Milan Kalas, Joy Ommer, Sasa Vranić, Irina Pavlova, Zahra Amirzada, and Silvana Di Sabatino

    In the context of disaster risk management and climate change adaptation, Nature-based Solutions (NBS) are being increasingly recognized and promoted as viable measures against hydro-meteorological hazards, while also being able to provide a range of environmental, social, and economic benefits. Yet, the employment of NBS to mitigate the impact of hydro-meteorological phenomena remains still sporadic and uncoordinated at the global and European level.

    In order to assist competent authorities, practitioners and other stakeholders in developing successful NBS interventions for hydro-meteorological risk mitigation and climate change adaptation, while also raising general public awareness and community stewardship of NBS, the EU-H2020 project OPERANDUM has recently launched a multi-dimensional, open and user-friendly web-platform called GeoIKP (Geospatial Information Knowledge Platform).

    GeoIKP follows a multi-stakeholder approach demonstrated through the integration of multiple modules related to science, policy and practice. This contribution offers an overview of GeoIKP and discusses in detail some of the innovative aspects and tools of the platform. It represents the first example of NBS web-platform with advanced interface customization. Functionalities and graphical interfaces are tailored to match specific user needs and interests for six different user profiles: 1) policy bodies (from international to local level), 2) knowledge-based organizations (research institutions, labs and data providers), 3) companies or private businesses, 4) associations, interest groups and grass-roots movements, 5) citizens and 6) other affected or interested parties (e.g. media outlets).

    The platform combines the latest scientific and technological knowledge on the topic gathered within OPERANDUM with advanced webGIS functionalities, analytical algorithms, and a comprehensive repository for NBS data (and metadata) management and cataloging. The highly structured and comprehensive data model adopted here enables to query the database and/or filter the results based on a multitude of individual parameters which encompass all different dimensions of NBS (e.g. geophysical, societal, environmental, etc.). This not only allows for a straightforward and automatic association to one or more thematic aspects of NBS, but also enhances standardization, discoverability and interoperability of NBS data in the context of disaster risk management and climate change adaptation.

    Among its functionalities, GeoIKP offers an interactive map which enables users to visualize and combine in real time geo-referenced datasets on a variety of thematic areas (hydro-meteorological hazards and associated socio-ecological risks, land cover/use characteristics, climate, Earth and ground observations, etc.), thus providing evidence-base support for the planning and management of NBS in a given geographic area. Through the map, the user can also access a geo-catalogue of existing NBS, and thus discover how NBS have been employed worldwide for hydro-meteorological risk reduction and climate change adaptation. At the same time, the platform serves as a hub for the growing NBS community to share information, tools, data, and experiences to reduce hydro-meteorological hazards. For example, scientists and practitioners can freely contribute to GeoIKP data repository as well as to the NBS catalogue, while the “Citizen Stories” functionality gives a voice to vulnerable, affected or concerned citizens to share personal experiences of how and why they started applying NBS to their areas, and to inspire others to take action.

    How to cite: Leo, L. S., Kalas, M., Ommer, J., Vranić, S., Pavlova, I., Amirzada, Z., and Di Sabatino, S.: User-driven platform to facilitate community data access, collaboration, and knowledge sharing on Nature-Based Solutions as mitigation measures for hydro-meteorological hazards, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8229, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8229, 2022.

    EGU22-10067 | Presentations | HS7.5

    Correlation of Meteorological and Hydrological Droughts using Observational and Modelled Data in the Guadalquivir River Basin 

    Emilio Romero-Jiménez, Matilde García-Valdecasas Ojeda, Patricio Yeste, Juan José Rosa-Cánovas, María Jesús Esteban-Parra, Yolanda Castro-Díez, and Sonia R. Gámiz-Fortis

    Future scenarios of climate change foresee an increase in frequency, duration, and severity of droughts, especially in arid and semiarid regions. This predictions require an intensive study of drought mechanics, starting with how past and present droughts behave, and continuing with the study of future droughts.
    In this research, it has been studied how a precipitation decrease that causes a meteorological drought is related to hydrological drought, caused by a decrease in river streamflow. The area of study is located in the Guadalquivir River basin, south of the Iberian Peninsula, which serves as an example of semiarid region. Two different sources of streamflow data are used: observational data obtained from the Spanish Centre for Public Work Experimentation and Study (CEDEX), which takes into consideration regulation from reservoirs, and modelled data obtained with the Variable Infiltration Capacity (VIC) model. The use of two data sources allows for a comparison of results, serving as a validation for future projects that will rely on the use of modelled data to study the behaviour of droughts in the near future.
    The numerical description and correlation of droughts is performed by means of drought indices, such as the Standardized Precipitation Evapotranspiration Index (SPEI) or the Standardized Streamflow Index (SSI), each describing one drought type, respectively meteorological and hydrological.


    Keywords: Drought indices, Hydrological model, Observational data, Guadalquivir basin.


    Acknowledgements
    This work was funded by FEDER/Junta de Andalucía-Consejería de Economía y Conocimiento, project B-RNM-336-UGR18, by the Spanish Ministry of Economy and Competitiveness project CGL2017-89836-390 R with additional support from FEDER Funds, and by FEDER/Junta de Andalucía-Consejería de Transformación Económica, Industria, Conocimiento y Universidades (project P20_00035).

    How to cite: Romero-Jiménez, E., García-Valdecasas Ojeda, M., Yeste, P., Rosa-Cánovas, J. J., Esteban-Parra, M. J., Castro-Díez, Y., and Gámiz-Fortis, S. R.: Correlation of Meteorological and Hydrological Droughts using Observational and Modelled Data in the Guadalquivir River Basin, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10067, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10067, 2022.

    EGU22-10468 | Presentations | HS7.5 | Highlight

    Reconstruction of the July 2021 European floods footprint – from field measurements to hydraulic model calibration 

    Jose Luis Salinas Illarena, Ludovico Nicotina, Stephan Tillmanns, Daniel Bernet, Panagiotis Rentzos, Stefano Zanardo, Yang Yang, Shuangcai Li, and Arno Hilberts

    Between 13th and 16th July 2021, low-pressure system Bernd caused heavy flooding in parts of eastern Belgium, western Germany, and north-eastern France. In many of these areas, the 24 hours rainfall amounts exceeded the mean monthly precipitation (T. Junghänel et al. 2021). With at least 220 reported fatalities and insured loss estimates ranging between 10 and 13 EUR billion, it is one of the most devastating natural catastrophes in the central-European region of the last decades (GDV 2021).
    Given the relevance of this event, a detailed reconstruction of the flood footprint would be of interest for both earth scientists and the insurance industry. For this purpose, a reconnaissance field trip was organised between 1st and 3rd November 2021 to affected municipalities in the German states of North Rhine-Westphalia, Rhineland-Palatinate, and the Belgian province of Liège. Remaining flood marks in buildings and other infrastructure were measured for over 200 locations, and water depths were inferred from them. In addition, information was collected on the degree of damage to buildings, as well as on the stage of reconstruction and clean-up. The focus was on areas that did not get much media attention back in July 2021, smaller ungauged streams, and, in general, any location where the flood depths and damages could not be easily inferred from other sources. The information collected during this field trip, combined with updated E-OBS precipitation data, river discharge gauge data, satellite imagery, as well as media and authorities’ reports was used to input, calibrate, and validate the different components of the RMS in-house flood model chain. In particular, the depth measurements from the reconnaissance trip were useful to calibrate the inundation model in municipalities affected by flash flooding from small to medium-sized ungauged streams, or by pluvial flooding. These point measurements allowed for a more detailed and comprehensive reconstruction of the flood depths over the entire affected area, beyond the better monitored larger river systems.

    T. Junghänel, et al. (2021) Hydro-klimatologische Einordnung der Stark- und Dauerniederschläge in Teilen Deutschlands im Zusammenhang mit dem Tiefdruckgebiet „Bernd“ vom 12. bis 19. Juli 2021, DWD Geschäftsbereich Klima und Umwelt, https://www.dwd.de/DE/leistungen/besondereereignisse/niederschlag/20210721_bericht_starkniederschlaege_tief_bernd.pdf

    GDV (2021) Hochwasserkatastrophe: Versicherer zahlen bereits über drei Milliarden Euro, https://www.gdv.de/de/medien/aktuell/hochwasserkatastrophe-versicherer-zahlen-bereits-ueber-drei-milliarden-euro--73798

    How to cite: Salinas Illarena, J. L., Nicotina, L., Tillmanns, S., Bernet, D., Rentzos, P., Zanardo, S., Yang, Y., Li, S., and Hilberts, A.: Reconstruction of the July 2021 European floods footprint – from field measurements to hydraulic model calibration, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10468, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10468, 2022.

    EGU22-10722 | Presentations | HS7.5

    Storm characteristics and extreme sub-daily precipitation statistics over CONUS 

    Diogo Araujo, Francesco Marra, Haider Ali, Hayley Fowler, and Efthymios Nikolopoulos

    The analysis of short-duration precipitation extremes is of foremost importance as heavy precipitation is directly related to many hazards, e.g. flash floods, landslides and crop damage. Here, we adopt an extreme value framework based on the concept of ordinary events, defined as independent realizations of the process of interest. In particular, we aim at investigating the link between the characteristics of ordinary storms (e.g. seasonality, average duration, autocorrelation) and the statistics of the emerging extremes at sub-daily durations (1-24 h). We used the Global Sub-Daily Rainfall (GSDR) dataset, which provides quality controlled hourly precipitation data from rain gauges over the Contiguous United States (CONUS). 

    First, we tested the hypothesis that a Weibull distribution can describe the tail of ordinary events and independently reproduce the annual maxima. Then, we quantified the portion of ordinary events, termed tail hereinafter, which share the statistical properties with annual maxima. Analysis of the storm characteristics show shorter average duration storms (< 12h) in the central portion of CONUS, between latitudes 90ºW and 105ºW. Seasonality analysis showed predominance of summer events in all central and eastern areas, with exception to a region encompassing the northwestern areas of the southern US states, which are dominated by spring events. On the western coast, winter events dominate the tail of the distribution of the ordinary events. The majority of these events happened in the afternoon (12PM to 6PM) or night (6PM to 12AM). The parameters describing our extreme value distribution revealed insightful features. The scale parameter of the Weibull distribution describing the tail followed the local climatology, with higher values over the southeast of CONUS (region characterized for high intensity precipitation), and small values over the northwest. The shape parameter indicates heavier-tailed distributions on the north and central regions of the US, as opposed to the majority of stations CONUS-wide. On average, the number of events per year is larger in the east (50 to 100 events per year) when compared to the west (0 to 50 events per year) . 

    Further analyses include investigating the influence of storm properties in the parameters of our extreme value distribution. This link, if proven significant, can be used to establish predictors for extreme precipitation statistics that stem from characteristics of ordinary storm events.

    How to cite: Araujo, D., Marra, F., Ali, H., Fowler, H., and Nikolopoulos, E.: Storm characteristics and extreme sub-daily precipitation statistics over CONUS, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10722, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10722, 2022.

    EGU22-11082 | Presentations | HS7.5

    Towards a quantitative spatiotemporal assessment of probabilistic landslide risk for large-area applications: challenges and perspectives.   

    Massimiliano Pittore, Stefan Steger, Mateo Moreno, Piero Campalani, Kathrin Renner, Carlos Villacis, Jesica Piñón, Eduardo Pérez, Lydia Rincón de la Rosa, Idriss Achour, and Emmanuel Noel

     The probabilistic assessment of risk due to landslides for Disaster Risk Reduction (DRR) purposes in terms of absolute and quantitative metrics (e.g., number of expected fatalities, economic damage) is still quite challenging. If, on the one side, landslide susceptibility models based on the combined statistical analysis of observed events and geomorphological predisposing factors can be efficiently implemented, they must be integrated by further hypothesis and information to capture the complexity of landslides hazard and be efficiently used for the assessment of risk. For instance, most susceptibility models are static and do not formally account for main triggering conditions (e.g., rainfall or seismic activity). Furthermore, they do not include any probabilistic information on the frequency/magnitude relationships of the related events, hence conveying relative and partial information. In this contribution, a simplified framework for probabilistic landslides risk assessment is presented and its application for multi-hazard risk assessment in Burundi is discussed. The proposed approach is based on the integration of multi-temporal susceptibility models accounting for monthly average precipitation patterns into a heterogeneous Poisson point process model. The occurrence process model is used to generate a large portfolio of events, each associated with a feature representing its magnitude whose distribution is modelled by a simple power law. These events can be combined with exposure and fragility/vulnerability information to obtain a probabilistic assessment of risk of different adverse consequences on people, assets and infrastructure.

    The proposed approach has been exemplified in the context of a multi-hazard risk assessment at national scale for Burundi and has proved successful in providing spatialised absolute and relative risk estimates that could be compared and combined with risk assessments related to other hazards (e.g., earthquakes and floods) with different characteristics and return periods.

     The practical implementation was based on the available data for the targeted region, which is limited, and relies on several assumptions and hypothesis that are accompanied by a significant level of uncertainty. The results have been preliminarily assessed using the data provided by the IOM Emergency Tracking Tool (ETT) from the period 2018-2021. The results indicate that the framework is flexible and can be used to obtain actionable information on risk due to landslides at different temporal and spatial scales. Our findings further highlight the importance of addressing landslide risk from a larger, interdisciplinary perspective, fostering the systematic collection of risk-oriented data (e.g., event inventories including information on damage and loss) and the synergies among different actors involved in DRR and Climate Change Adaptation. The potential and limitations of the proposed approach for regional landslide risk and for multi-hazard risk assessment will be discussed. The described research activities have been carried out within the framework of an international project funded by the European Union, implemented by the International Organization of Migration (IOM) and coordinated by IDOM (Spain).

    How to cite: Pittore, M., Steger, S., Moreno, M., Campalani, P., Renner, K., Villacis, C., Piñón, J., Pérez, E., Rincón de la Rosa, L., Achour, I., and Noel, E.: Towards a quantitative spatiotemporal assessment of probabilistic landslide risk for large-area applications: challenges and perspectives.  , EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11082, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11082, 2022.

    EGU22-11559 | Presentations | HS7.5 | Highlight

    Evaluation of the extreme rainfall event of July 2021 in Western Germany and its impact based on the Catalogue of Radar-based Heavy Rainfall Events (CatRaRE) 

    Ewelina Walawender, Katharina Lengfeld, Tanja Winterrath, and Elmar Weigl

    Within a few days of July 2021, extreme heavy rainfall associated with the low-pressure weather system “Bernd” caused severe flooding in Western Germany (North Rhine-Westphalia and Rhineland-Palatinate), as well as in Luxembourg, and parts of Belgium and the Netherlands. In Germany, this devastating event resulted in at least 184 fatalities.

    In our presentation, we take a closer look at this event as classified in the Catalogue of Radar-based Heavy Rainfall Events (CatRaRE), derived from 21 years of climatological radar data (RADKLIM 1km,1h) for the area of Germany.

    The CatRaRE Catalogue covers both the attributes of all classified heavy rainfall events as well as their spatial extent. The dataset is published annually by the German Meteorological Service and is freely available for all interested users at: dwd.de/catrare.

    We present the extent and parameters of this extreme rainfall as an event classified in the CatRaRE together with a comprehensive analysis and comparison against all heavy precipitation events lasting between 1 to 72 hours which occurred in Germany in the period from 2001 to 2020. Apart from various extremity statistics such as return period, heavy precipitation index, and weather extremity indices, additional variables are examined as predictors for a potential impact: e.g. antecedent precipitation index, population density, land cover, imperviousness degree and topography indices.

    How to cite: Walawender, E., Lengfeld, K., Winterrath, T., and Weigl, E.: Evaluation of the extreme rainfall event of July 2021 in Western Germany and its impact based on the Catalogue of Radar-based Heavy Rainfall Events (CatRaRE), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11559, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11559, 2022.

    EGU22-11993 | Presentations | HS7.5

    Accounting for long-term climatic trends in Probable Maximum Precipitation estimation 

    Jaya Bhatt and Venkata Vemavarapu Srinivas

    The compounding evidence on the aberrant behavior of extreme precipitation has drawn attention of hydrometeorologists towards re-evaluating the existing hydraulic design criteria for protection of large structures (e.g., spillways of dams, nuclear power plants) in changing climate. Traditionally, design flood estimates for those structures were based on Probable Maximum Precipitation (PMP) to minimize or avert the risk of failure and consequent catastrophic damage to mankind and the environment. PMP, as defined by the World Meteorological Organization (WMO), does not account for long-term climatic trends. However, in recent decades, there has been an increase in frequency and magnitude of extreme precipitation events in different parts of the globe. This necessitates devising potential strategies to arrive at effective PMP estimates to re-assess the existing design criteria.  Against this backdrop, researchers have been actively developing new methods or modifying the existing ones to adapt to changing climate. The majority of these methods are physics-based whose application demands voluminous data on various hydrometeorological variables and computationally intensive systems to run simulations on weather models. In comparison, statistical approaches are simple and not data intensive. Among available statistical approaches, Hershfield method is widely used due to its ease of application. There is a dearth of attempts to extend it for use in climate change scenarios.

    In the present study, a new variant of Hershfield method is proposed which yields reliable PMP estimates by accounting for long-term trends in precipitation data for better estimation of at-site frequency factor in the climate change scenario. The applicability of the proposed method is illustrated over India considering 119 years (1901-2019) long 0.25-degree gridded precipitation records from IMD (India Meteorological Department). The country has more than 5000 dams, and currently PMP estimates are being considered for risk analyses of several ageing dams through the aid of the World Bank, under DRIP (Dam Rehabilitation and Improvement Project). The proposed methodology is applied to arrive at PMP estimates for sites/grids in homogeneous precipitation regions delineated in the country using cluster analysis. The overall impact of increasing/decreasing trend of precipitation on the regional estimate of frequency factor and one-day PMP estimates is clearly demonstrated using the proposed and conventional Hershfield methods.

    How to cite: Bhatt, J. and Srinivas, V. V.: Accounting for long-term climatic trends in Probable Maximum Precipitation estimation, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11993, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11993, 2022.

    EGU22-12046 | Presentations | HS7.5 | Highlight

    Impact-based Forecasting: Bridging the gap between forecast and post flood impact with remote sensing 

    Margherita Sarcinella, Brianna R. Pagán, Jeremy S. Pal, Arthur H. Essenfelder, Lisa Landuyt, and Jaroslav Mysiak

    The economic loss associated with natural hazards has drastically increased over the past decades, reaching over $210 billion dollars worldwide in 2020. The explication of regional-scale climate change effects with the tendency to exacerbate local climate criticalities has long jeopardized disaster resilience and the coping capacity of many communities. There is a lack of a robust operational linkage between the pre-disaster and post-disaster segments when a disaster occurs. This hampers an effective emergency response often leading to delayed humanitarian intervention and unplanned evacuations. Moreover, the great amount of openly available impact information on past events is commonly discarded and the forecast potential which the data yields has yet to be fully explored. In this context, the Impact-based Forecasting (IbF) approach aims to interconnect pre-emptive planning for early action with post-disaster impacts while taking advantage of historical data. The underlying principle of IbF is that the magnitude of an event is translated to site-specific impact information. Therefore, a paradigm shift from the conventional magnitude-likelihood relationship to impact-likelihood is proposed. This research develops a method to fully exploit the potential of IbF while overcoming the typical site-specificity of emergency response through remote sensing and automation. While the IbF framework allows for a multi-hazard approach, here we present a method targeting the ex-ante impact assessment of riverine floods. The analysis consists of two main components: i) the delineation of the flood extent from Sentinel-1 SAR imagery and ii) the definition of the event impact on the population, land and built environment. The IbF impact-likelihood relationship is ultimately derived by matching the two components for a historical event series. A fully automated Google Earth Engine algorithm for flood extent mapping with a 10 m spatial resolution has been developed to detect floodwater with a single-scene classification based on an automated thresholding method. The flood magnitude is then matched with open-access geodata such as human settlements, population density, land cover and infrastructure from the OpenStreetMap catalogue to generate the impact assessment. Once trained on several site or region specific past events, it can automatically forecast the impact associated with a given event magnitude. Here we apply the technique to three case studies including the flooding associated with the Tropical Cyclone Idai, which made landfall in Mozambique in March 2019 causing over 1200 fatalities and $2 billion worth of damage. The performance of the flood mapping algorithm has been evaluated as satisfactory for the impact application and further validation at two additional sites is ongoing. Therefore, local triggers can be set to ensure a valuable temporal window to promptly plan and estimate the cost of intervention on the field. This work is a first step to providing a consistent and regionally transferable disaster preparedness tool that allows for multi-hazard impact forecasts.

    How to cite: Sarcinella, M., Pagán, B. R., Pal, J. S., Essenfelder, A. H., Landuyt, L., and Mysiak, J.: Impact-based Forecasting: Bridging the gap between forecast and post flood impact with remote sensing, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12046, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12046, 2022.

    EGU22-12696 | Presentations | HS7.5

    Comprehensive risk assessment of July 2021 European flooding including associated uncertainties 

    Punit Bhola, Margot Doucet, Stefanie Alarcon, and Bernhard Reinhardt

    In July 2021, low-pressure system “Bernd” parked itself over central Europe in July 2021 and caused significant flooding in western Germany and neighbouring countries. The devastating flooding led to more than 180 causalities in Germany and caused catastrophic losses by disrupting infrastructure.

    As the flood event unfolded, we at Verisk Extreme Event Solutions, re-modelled the event using state-of-the-art flood models by simulating river flows in our hydrological and flood inundation patterns in hydraulic model from observed precipitation fields derived from NASA’s Global Precipitation Measurement (GPM). Using the remodelled hazard and our Industry Exposure Database (IED), we provided a range of insured loss estimates for the insurance and reinsurance market. We will discuss the event with respect to hazard and uncertainties associated with risks, such as demand surge, cost inflation and infrastructure damage.

    How to cite: Bhola, P., Doucet, M., Alarcon, S., and Reinhardt, B.: Comprehensive risk assessment of July 2021 European flooding including associated uncertainties, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12696, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12696, 2022.

    EGU22-12786 | Presentations | HS7.5

    New Dam Break Risk Assessment Method in Fuzzy Framework 

    Anubhav Goel and Venkata Vemavarapu Srinivas

    Dams are useful for mitigation of floods, and at the same time there is a risk of dam breach or failure from floods, apart from seismic hazards and factors such as ageing of dam material. In recent decades, there is an alarming increase in dam breach events. This has drawn the attention of hydrologists to have a relook at methodologies being considered for dam risk analysis. Effective risk analysis requires accounting for both failure probability of dam and dam break consequences. There are numerous factors which effect the consequences, and there is considerable amount of uncertainty, vagueness and ambiguity among them due to lack of data and knowledge. To address this, we propose a new dam break risk assessment method in fuzzy framework. It considers fuzzy hierarchical model for risk assessment based on combination of static and variable fuzzy set theory. A hierarchical structure is devised for various factors influencing dam break consequences. Furthermore, weights are assigned to the factors using Fuzzy Analytical Hierarchy Process (FAHP). Thereafter, weighted information of different factors is comprehended to arrive at estimate of a risk index. The effectiveness of proposed method is demonstrated through case study on Hemavathi dam located in upper reaches of Cauvery River basin, India. It is a composite dam with masonary spillway and earthen flanges. The catchment area of river up to the dam site is 2904 sq. Km. Furthermore, height of dam above riverbed level is 44.5 m, and its gross storage capacity is 1047 Mm3. As per Bureau of Indian Standards (BIS) the dam is classified as large dam and therefore qualifies for Probable Maximum Flood (PMF) as design flood. Breach analysis of Hemavathi dam was performed using 1D-2D coupled HEC- RAS model to map the extent of flooding downstream of the dam using PMF (corresponding to 2-day PMP) as inflow and maintaining initial pool level in reservoir at maximum water level (MWL). For comprehensive risk assessment, life loss, economic loss, and social and environmental influence caused by dam break are considered in the model.

    How to cite: Goel, A. and Srinivas, V. V.: New Dam Break Risk Assessment Method in Fuzzy Framework, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12786, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12786, 2022.

    EGU22-1587 | Presentations | HS7.6

    Chemical characteristics of summer rainwater at an urban site in South Korea 

    Hyemin Park, Taeyong Kim, and Minjune Yang

    In this study, we investigated the chemical characteristics of rainwater and evaluated the correlation among rainwater quality factors for seven precipitation events from June 2020 to August 2020. Rainwater samples (n = 84) were collected every 50 mL at Pukyong National University, Busan, South Korea. Values of pH and electrical conductivity (EC) were measured in the field, and concentrations of water-soluble cations (Na+, Mg2+, K+, Ca2+, and NH4+) and anions (Cl-, NO3-, and SO42-) were determined using ion chromatography. For all rainwater samples, the pH ranged from 3.63 to 5.59, with mean pH = 4.78, and the measured mean EC was 30.54 µS/cm, indicating that the precipitation was acidified in Busan, South Korea. A strong negative correlation (r = -0.83) was found between the pH and EC values. The major ionic components of rainwater were SO42- > NH4+ > NO3-, which are predominantly attributed to anthropogenic forces in the study area, such as emissions from vessels and fossil fuels. Anion concentrations of rainwater samples were SO42- (average concentration: 2.15 mg/L) > NO3- (1.43 mg/L) > Cl- (1.04 mg/L) and showed a strong positive correlation with EC values (r = 0.81) and a negative correlation with pH values (r = -0.72) of rainwater samples. The average concentrations of cations (NH4+ (1.56 mg/L) > Ca2+ (1.31 mg/L) > Na+ (0.63 mg/L) > K+ (0.57 mg/L) > Mg2+(0.29 mg/L)) were relatively lower than those of anions. Cation concentrations showed no significant correlation with the values of EC (r = 0.29) and pH (r = -0.21). The result of this study indicates that acidic precipitation occurs even in summer with relatively low concentrations of air pollution and strong rainfall intensity.

    How to cite: Park, H., Kim, T., and Yang, M.: Chemical characteristics of summer rainwater at an urban site in South Korea, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1587, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1587, 2022.

    EGU22-1730 | Presentations | HS7.6

    Return periods in current and future climate 

    Dan Rosbjerg

    The distribution functions for large rain events Xc in current climate is denoted F(x) = P{Xcx} and for large rain events Xf in a future climate G(x) = P{Xfx}. A climate factor k is introduced, and it is assumed that P{Xcx} = P{Xfk x} corresponding to G(k x) = F(x). If we further assume that the distribution functions F and G have exponential tails, the following simple transformation of the return period in current climate Tc to the corresponding return period in future climate Tf can be deduced

    Tf = Tc1/k

    Applying a first order analysis on this equation with k as independent variable leads to a relation between the uncertainties of k and Tf. In terms of the coefficient of variations we get

    CV{Tf} ≈ 1/ lnTc CV{k}

    This equation reveals that even with moderate uncertainty in k, the uncertainty in Tf is notably increased.

    How to cite: Rosbjerg, D.: Return periods in current and future climate, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1730, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1730, 2022.

    EGU22-2595 | Presentations | HS7.6

    A Stochastic Rainfall Generator Suitable for Modeling Future Compound Disasters Associated with Heavy Rainfall 

    Dongkyun Kim, Christain Onof, Jeongha Park, and Lipen Wang

    Disasters associated with heavy rainfall such as urban floods, riverine floods, and landslides often simultaneously occur while each of them sensitively reacts to rainfall variabilities at distinct ranges of time scales. Therefore, a stochastic rainfall model suitable for modeling compounding of disasters must be good at reproducing the rainfall variability across all timescales relevant to all types of disasters. This study proposes a point stochastic rainfall generator that can reproduce various rainfall characteristics at timescales between 5 minutes and one decade. The model generates the fine-scale rainfall time series using a randomized Bartlett-Lewis Rectangular Pulse (RBLRP) model. Then the rainstorms are shuffled such that the correlation structure between the consecutive storms is preserved. Finally, the time series is rearranged again at the monthly timescale based on the result of the separate coarse-scale monthly rainfall model. The method was tested using the 69 years of 5-minute rainfall data recorded at Bochum, Germany. The mean, variance, covariance, skewness, and rainfall intermittency were well reproduced at the timescales from 5 minutes to a decade without any systematic bias. The extreme values were also well reproduced at timescales from 5 minutes to 3 days. The past-7-day rainfall before an extreme rainfall event, which is highly associated with the extreme riverine flow and landslide was reproduced well too. Then, the model was extended to integrate the influence of climate change. For this, the model was re-parameterised in terms of parameters representing average magnitude and temporal structure of the rainfall time series. Then, the relationship between these new parameters and the covariates (e.g. monthly, weekly, daily temperature) were investigated. Lastly, the derived regression relationships were applied to adjust the duration and the magnitude of rain storms and cells that were generated by the stationary RBLRP model.

    This work was supported by the National Research Foundation of Korea(NRF) grant funded by the Korea government(MSIT) (No. NRF-2021R1A2C2003471).

     

    How to cite: Kim, D., Onof, C., Park, J., and Wang, L.: A Stochastic Rainfall Generator Suitable for Modeling Future Compound Disasters Associated with Heavy Rainfall, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2595, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2595, 2022.

    EGU22-2624 | Presentations | HS7.6

    Comparing extreme precipitation between data from rain gauges, weather radar and high-resolution climate models 

    Karsten Arnbjerg-Nielsen, Emma Dybro Thomassen, Søren Liedtke Thorndahl, Christoffer Bang Andersen, Ida Bülow Gregersen, and Hjalte Jomo Danielsen Sørup

    The representation of extreme precipitation at small spatio-temporal scales is of major importance in urban hydrology. The present study compares observations from tipping bucket gauges and a C-band radar to two sets of re-analysis climate model output data for a historic period of 14 years where there is full spatial and temporal overlap between datasets. The reanalysis data are based on models with different parametrizations and spatio-temporal resolutions, one being a “convective-permitting” model while the other uses a convective parametrization scheme to account for convective rainfall. The study focuses on an area of approximately 100 by 150 km.

    The datasets are compared with respect to seasonality of occurrence, intensity levels and spatial structure of the extreme events. All datasets have similar seasonal distributions, and comparable intensity levels. There are, however, clear differences in the spatial correlation structure of the extremes. Seemingly, the radar data is best representation of a “real” spatial structure for extreme precipitation, even though challenges appear in data when moving far from the physical radar. The spatial correlation in point observations is a valid representation of the spatial structure of extreme precipitation. The convective-permitting climate model seem to represent the spatial structure of extreme precipitation much more realistically, compared to the coarser convective parameterized model. However, improvement could be made for the shortest durations and smallest spatial scales.

    How to cite: Arnbjerg-Nielsen, K., Thomassen, E. D., Thorndahl, S. L., Andersen, C. B., Gregersen, I. B., and Sørup, H. J. D.: Comparing extreme precipitation between data from rain gauges, weather radar and high-resolution climate models, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2624, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2624, 2022.

    EGU22-2799 | Presentations | HS7.6

    Surveillance audio-based rainfall observation: a crowdsourcing approach 

    Xing Wang, Xuejun Liu, Thomas Glade, and Meizhen Wang

    Rainfall data with high spatiotemporal resolutions are of great value in many research fields, such as meteorology, hydrology, global warming, and urban disaster monitoring. Current rainfall observation systems include ground-based rain gauges, remote sensing-based radar and satellites. However, there is an increasing demand of the spatiotemporal rainfall data with high resolution. Thanks to the advocacy from many research institutions and international organizations, several innovative crowdsourcing ideas including opportunistic sensing and citizen science initiatives have been followed in recent years. Commercial cellular communication networks, windshield wipers or optical sensors in moving vehicles, smart phones, social medias, and surveillance cameras/videos have been identified as alternative rain gauges. In particular environmental audio recordings are a rich and underexploited source to identified and even characterize rainfall events.
    Widespread surveillance cameras can continuously record rainfall information, which even provides a basis for the possibility of rainfall monitoring. Comparing the aforementioned methods, surveillance audio-based rainfall estimation has been discussed in existing studies with advantages of high-spatiotemporal-resolution, low cost and all-weather. Therefore, this study focuses on mining the rainfall information from urban surveillance audio for quantitative inversion on precipitation. Rain sound is generated by the collision of rain particles with other underlying objects in the process of falling. In real applications, the complex subsurface structure and random background noises from human activity in urban areas make surveillance rainfall sound vulnerable and surveillance audio-based rainfall estimation more challenging. In our study, the rainfall acoustic indicators were selected for rainfall sound representation. Deep learning-based rainfall observation systems were built based on urban surveillance audio data. Experimental results show the efficiency of our system in rainfall estimation. Our research is a new attempt to develop crowdsourcing-based rainfall observations, which can also provide a beneficent supplement to the current rainfall observation networks.

    How to cite: Wang, X., Liu, X., Glade, T., and Wang, M.: Surveillance audio-based rainfall observation: a crowdsourcing approach, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2799, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2799, 2022.

    EGU22-5356 | Presentations | HS7.6

    A method for adjusting design stormpeakedness to reduce biasin hydraulic simulations 

    Samer Muhandes, Barnaby Dobson, and Ana Mijic

    In the UK, decision-makers use hydraulic model outputs to inform funding, connection consent, adoption of new
    drainage networks and planning application decisions. Current practice requires the application of design storms to
    calculate sewer catchment performance metrics such as flood volume, discharge rate and flood count. With flooding
    incidents occurring more frequently than their designs specify, hydraulic modelling outputs required by practice are
    questionable. The main focus of this paper is the peakedness factor (ratio of maximum to average rainfall intensity)
    of design storms, adjudging that this is a key contributor to model bias. Hydraulic models of two UK sewer
    catchments were simulated under historical storms, design storms and design storms with modified peakedness to
    test bias in modelling outputs and the effectiveness of peakedness modification in reducing bias. Sustainable
    drainage systems (SuDS) were implemented at catchment scale and the betterment achieved in the modelling outputs
    was tested. The proposed design storm modification reduced the bias that occurs when driving hydraulic models
    using design storms in comparison with historical storms. It is concluded that SuDS benefits are underestimated when
    using design rainfall because the synthetic rainfall shape prevents infiltration. Thus, SuDS interventions cannot
    accurately be evaluated by design storms, modified or otherwise.

    How to cite: Muhandes, S., Dobson, B., and Mijic, A.: A method for adjusting design stormpeakedness to reduce biasin hydraulic simulations, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5356, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5356, 2022.

    EGU22-6652 | Presentations | HS7.6

    Impact of malfunctions on urban drainage for different design rainfall events 

    Fabian Funke, Stefan Reinstaller, and Manfred Kleidorfer

    Urban drainage is subject to a variety of external influencing factors that can have a negative impact on hydraulic system performance. These include changing precipitation characteristics due to climate change [1], an increase in sealed surfaces due to advancing urbanisation [2], but also further failures and malfunctions [3] in the technical grey and green infrastructure. With an increasing share of decentralised urban stormwater measures and uncertainties regarding responsibility, care and maintenance of these facilities, an increase in malfunctions can be assumed [4]. In this work, we are investigating common malfunctions in urban drainage systems with 1D/2D urban flood model in a virtual urban study site. The goal is to highlight differences between the failures and malfunctions in both grey and blue-green infrastructures for different design rainfall events (Type Euler II) and compare them to other possible scenarios like climate change and urbanization.

    For the research, a model of a small virtual urban study site (1.5ha) is developed with the commercial software PCSWMM2D [5], which represents a small part of an urban catchment. It includes the following sub-structures and assets: i) combined sewer system, ii) urban stream, iii) urban structures including buildings, marketplaces, streets, bridges, pathways, and underbridges and iv) four sustainable urban drainage system (SUDS) structures (green roofs, permeable pavements, swales and bioretention cell). Connected to the combined sewer system are three border areas (30ha, 10ha, 10ha), representing inflows from outside. The urban drainage infrastructures and SUDS were designed based on a design rainfall (Euler Typ II) event with a 5-year return period and 1-hour event duration.

    In total 12 different scenarios were designed for the virtual urban study site i) the SUDS-base-scenario which includes four different green infrastructure assets, ii) three reference scenarios with climate change, urbanisation and wet preconditions and iii) the malfunction-scenarios with seven single malfunction scenarios and one worst case which is all of the single scenarios combined. Each scenario was run with design rainfall events with an Euler II distribution and interval lengths between 15 minutes and 24 hours as well as return periods between 1 and 100 years.

    To compare the different scenarios and assess their severity for the urban area we used 3 different objective values. i) The maximum water depth in the vulnerable infrastructure (underbridge), ii) the flooded area with water depths > 10cm and iii) the total combined sewer overflow emissions released into the urban stream.

    Results show a clear difference between the different malfunction scenarios, with a higher influence of malfunctions in grey than in green infrastructures. In most cases, the reference scenarios climate change, urbanisation and wet preconditions show higher values than the malfunctions scenario. All scenarios are highly dependent on the rainfall event characteristics, with no differences in the objective values compared to the base case for low return periods and rising differences for medium to high return periods.

    How to cite: Funke, F., Reinstaller, S., and Kleidorfer, M.: Impact of malfunctions on urban drainage for different design rainfall events, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6652, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6652, 2022.

    EGU22-7879 | Presentations | HS7.6

    Selecting Good Quality Official and Citizen Science Rain Gauge Data and Blending with Radar for More Accurate Rainfall Representation 

    Tess O'Hara, Elizabeth Lewis, Fergus McClean, Hayley Fowler, and Geoff Parkin

    Rainfall data collected by citizen scientists is typically regarded as low quality and therefore remains underused in hydrological applications. Conversely, official data collected by professional organisations is often treated as more reliable than it really is. Here we demonstrate that value can be extracted from citizen science rainfall data by applying automated statistical quality control combined with manual checks. We also consider the pros and cons of citizen science rain observations.

    Carefully selected rain data from official and citizen science gauges have been blended with radar.  Examples of how rainfall depths vary depending on the data inputs are presented, highlighting the benefit of incorporating all available data sources. This approach is particularly important when determining rainfall during spatially and temporally variable convective storms. The research is concerned with convective storms that resulted in pluvial flooding in urban areas of the UK between 2014 – 2018, however, the methodology could be implemented in any location where hourly (or shorter interval) rain gauge data and radar are available.  

    How to cite: O'Hara, T., Lewis, E., McClean, F., Fowler, H., and Parkin, G.: Selecting Good Quality Official and Citizen Science Rain Gauge Data and Blending with Radar for More Accurate Rainfall Representation, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7879, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7879, 2022.

    In response to recent major flood events in Ireland, the authorities have prioritised the development of a national flood forecasting model for use as a tool in flood risk management. Accurate flood predictions by this model require high resolution spatiotemporal rainfall data. One source for this type of data is the remote sensing estimated precipitation provided by the Global Precipitation Measurement (GPM) satellite. The GPM has ability to detect and estimate all forms of precipitation using a range of advanced instruments, including Microwave and Radar technologies. This study evaluates the accuracy of detecting the large rainfall events which occurred in Ireland during the period 2014-2021 by three Integrated Multi-satellitE Retrievals for GPM (IMERG) precipitation products (i) early run ; (ii) late run; and (iii) final run. The satellite estimates of these events have been assessed using five statistical indices applied to various temporal scales; hourly, daily, and monthly. The results showed that, for satellite detection, all of the three IMERG products had an acceptable detection accuracy of the large rainfall events. In particular, the calibrated product – final run product – outperformed the other near-real-time products in terms of estimation error and bias. Overall, the results indicate that IMERG satellite precipitation products can be used with confidence to detect large events over high latitude areas such as Ireland. Besides, they have a high potential for coupling with in-situ data to improve the accuracy of the integrated flood forecasting model.

    How to cite: Mohammed, S., Nasr, A., and Mahmoud, M.: Evaluation of the spatiotemporal representation of the GPM satellite precipitation products over diverse climatic regions in Ireland, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8942, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8942, 2022.

    Since Hinton et al. introduced Deep Learning (DL) in 2006 [1], DL methods have led to breakthroughs in various scientific fields, such as speech recognition, medical, materials, and many more. Various early attempts to apply DL to short-term rainfall forecasting (nowcasting) were also reported. However, these early models did not lead to significant improvements as compared to non-AI nowcasting models such as STEPS [2]. It was TrajGRU model [3] which first demonstrated the potential gains that may be achieved with DL-based nowcasting models. Since then, a variety of DL models have been proposed or applied to tackle rainfall nowcasting, with the most iconic ones including U-Net, MetNet and DGMR [4-6]. Similarly to the Trajectory GRU (TrajGRU) model, the U-Net and MetNet models show clear improvements in predicting the occurrence of rainfall at high spatial and temporal resolutions and with a longer lead time, as compared to non-AI models. However, the predicted rainfall images from these three models (and their variants) become overly smooth rather quickly (at lead times of 15-20 minutes); this is a common ‘feature’ of many other DL models [7]. This means that significant amount of spatial rainfall details is lost, which is undesirable for certain hydrological applications, such urban flow and flood forecasting where small-scale rainfall variability -in particular localised peaks- may have tangible impacts [8]. In 2016, DeepMind [6] proposed a new type of DL-based nowcasting model called the Deep Generative Model of Radar (DGMR), which is based upon a Generative Adversarial Network (GAN) framework. The DGMR successfully improves the aforementioned smoothing drawback of other DL-models by incorporating noise into the rainfall forecast generator such that small-scale rainfall details can be preserved and, consequently, localised peak intensities can be better predicted. DGMR thus shows great potential for hydrological applications.

    In spite of the success, the model structure of DGMR is complex and hard to digest by someone without proper training in DL. Therefore, even though the model structure has been published, it remains a mystery for most hydrologists, thus hindering its application.

    In this work, we explore the success of DGMR with an in-depth analysis of its model structure. More specifically, through the process of re-constructing the DGMR model, we have developed a short tutorial on the different model components, in plain language and with example images and intermediate analyses. This will enable better understanding of the features and behaviour of the DGMR model and of the implications for hydrological applications. Additionally, a better understanding of the DGMR model components may instigate further improvements.

    References:

    [1] Hinton, G.E., et al., Neural Comput., 18 (7), 1527-1554, 2006.

    [2] Bowler, N.E., et al., Q. J. Roy. Meteor. Soc., 132(620), 2127-2155, 2006.

    [3] Shi, X., arXiv preprint arXiv:1706.03458, 2017.

    [4] Agrawal, S., et al., arXiv preprint arXiv:1912.12132, 2019.

    [5] Sønderby, C.K., et al., arXiv preprint arXiv:2003.12140, 2020.

    [6] Ravuri, S., et al., Nature, 597, 672-677, 2021.

    [7] Ayzel, G., Geosci. Model Dev., 13(6), 2631-2644, 2020.

    [8] Ochoa-Rodriguez, S., et al., J. Hydrol., 531, 389-407, 2015.

    How to cite: Heh, Y.-T. and Wang, L.-P.: Unraveling the mystery of DeepMind’s rainfall nowcasting: a step-by-step tutorial for hydrologists, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9054, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9054, 2022.

    EGU22-10291 | Presentations | HS7.6

    Effect of spatially distributed radar-gauge rainfall products on simulated urban flows 

    Edwin Echeverri-Salazar, Bora Shehu, Alexander Verworn, and Markus Wallner

    Weather radars have become a valuable tool for urban hydrological studies because they capture the rainfall intensities at a high spatial and temporal resolution. However, radar products are affected by objects or phenomena not of meteorological interest, making it necessary to apply various algorithms to correct and improve their rainfall estimation. In addition, multiple methods for merging rain-gauge and radar data are presented in the literature, which combines the advantages of high spatial resolution of radar products with the measurement accuracy of rain gauge stations. While merging methods are commonly validated on rain-gauge measurements, little has been discussed in the literature about the influence of such techniques on urban hydrological models. Therefore, this study investigates the use and selection of gauge-radar merging methods as input for urban hydrological modeling.

    This work studies the influence of different precipitation products (rain-gauge stations, radar, and radar-gauge merged products) on flow rates simulated with a hydrodynamic model in two cities: Hildesheim and Osnabrück, Germany. Sewer pipe measurements at least every 2 minutes for several discharge events within 2020-2021 are available and used to evaluate different rainfall products. The techniques to be assessed are temporal and spatial smoothing and radar merging methods such as external drift kriging, quantile mapping, and conditional merging. This study will allow identifying if, in general, there is a single product that presents the best results for urban flow simulations or if, on the contrary, it depends on the type of rainfall event. Additionally, since the study areas are located at different distances from the Hannover radar station, it will be possible to analyze the influence of the attenuation correction on the improvement of the radar product.

    How to cite: Echeverri-Salazar, E., Shehu, B., Verworn, A., and Wallner, M.: Effect of spatially distributed radar-gauge rainfall products on simulated urban flows, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10291, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10291, 2022.

    EGU22-11015 | Presentations | HS7.6

    Observing Extreme Rainfall Events at Fine Timescales 

    Ching-Chun Chou and Li-Pen Wang

    The Computational Hydrometeorology Lab in National Taiwan University (NTU CompHydroMet Lab) recently launched a rainfall monitoring network, with a special focus on observing extreme storm events, such as typhoons and thunderstorms, over the south area of Taipei. Due to the topographic effect and the constant humidity brought by the sea breeze, together with the high temperature, south Taipei is a hotspot for the occurrence of thunderstorms in summer. The monitoring network constitutes a collocated pair of an OTT Pluvio S and an OTT Pluvio L weighing rain gauges, as well as two ‘unconventional’ rain sensors – an OTT Parsivel2 disdrometer and a Lufft WS100 radar precipitation sensor. These rain sensors are co-located within a 10 x 10 m2 area, providing rainfall estimates at high temporal resolutions, ranging from 10 seconds to 1 minute.

    Since the launch of the monitoring network in March 2021, the monitoring network has collected rainfall data for two typhoons and a number of thunderstorms, with the highest peak intensity at 245.6 mm/h. The measurements are generally consistent between four sensors; in particular, those from two weighing gauges are of the highest consistency. In addition, a  preliminary comparison shows that the high-intensity rainfall measured by weighing gauges and disdrometer are in high agreement. This suggests that weighing gauges –which were widely used as a verification gauge for the tipping bucket gauges in the operational context–  can provide reliable rainfall measurements with high accuracy, including capturing extreme rainfall. 
     
    As compared to other sensors, WS100 tends to underestimate rainfall at high intensities. However, it is more sensitive to low-intensity rainfall than others; and, similarly to the disdrometer, it provides reflectivity data and requires less maintenance. The cause of underestimation is currently under investigation, which could potentially be improved through the calibration of the current algorithm with weighing gauges’ measurements. 

    At the next stage of the work, these ground measurements will be compared with the coincidental three-dimensional radar data product from the Central Weather Bureau (CWB), Taiwan. The radar data product from CWB is available at approximately 1.2 km spatial resolution and 10-min intervals. The comparison result will be presented, and the potential of using the monitoring network to support the correction of radar data will be discussed.

    How to cite: Chou, C.-C. and Wang, L.-P.: Observing Extreme Rainfall Events at Fine Timescales, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11015, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11015, 2022.

    EGU22-11572 | Presentations | HS7.6

    Gauging the ungauged: Estimating rainfall in urbanized river basins using ground-based and spaceborne sensors 

    Linda Bogerd, Rose Boahemaa Pinto, Tim van Emmerik, and Remko Uijlenhoet

    Accurate rainfall estimates in urban areas are vital for water management, pollution transport, and flood forecasts. To cover the high spatial (and temporal) variability of rainfall, uniformly distributed observation networks are required.

    In many urban areas dedicated rainfall observations are limited because of low available budgets or unsuitable technology. Therefore, this study compared and assessed the accuracy of three “non-traditional” rainfall datasets in the Odaw (Accra, Ghana) river basin to help future modellers to decide which dataset is the best fit, for instance to predict floods. The Odaw river basin is one of the main drainage systems in Accra with a total catchment area of about 270 km2. Over the past three decades, the Odaw basin has been challenged with floods, but due to the lack of a good representation of rainfall measurements, the ability to accurately simulate or forecast floods in the basin is limited.

    Two rainfall datasets are derived from satellite observations and one from crowdsourced rain gauges. The three estimates were all available for the study period (2020) and were analysed and compared at a thirty-minute time-interval. The first space-based product is the most recent version (V06B) of IMERG, the gridded multisatellite precipitation product of the Global Precipitation Measurement (GPM) mission; the second space-based product is the MSG-SEVIRI infrared satellite imagery, an innovative rainfall dataset based on geostationary data available day and night. The ground-based data was retrieved from ten TAHMO rain gauges. Because the satellite products consists of pixels while the TAHMO observations are point measurements, the stations were assigned to the pixels of the satellite products.

    Results show that all three rainfall datasets revealed a systematic spatial variation, with on average more rainfall observed upstream than downstream. Although all datasets reproduced a similar annual accumulation, the rainfall intensity observed by the TAHMO stations (point measurements) were much higher, sometimes even more than twice as high. Days with high rainfall amounts (when the daily average TAHMO rain rate exceeded 15 mm/hr) were used as case studies, as these days were hypothesised to be related to flooding. During these days space-borne radar overpasses were used to get some impression about the spatial characteristics of the rainfall events. With this presentation we aim to demonstrate the applicability of freely available data to estimate rainfall at various temporal and spatial scales in (formerly) ungauged urbanized river basins.

    How to cite: Bogerd, L., Pinto, R. B., van Emmerik, T., and Uijlenhoet, R.: Gauging the ungauged: Estimating rainfall in urbanized river basins using ground-based and spaceborne sensors, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11572, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11572, 2022.

    EGU22-12694 | Presentations | HS7.6

    Mitigation of stormwater flooding by identifying areas suitable for Sustainable Drainage Systems and Aquifer Storage and Recovery (case study: Rome, Italy) 

    Elisa Meddi, Azzurra Lentini, Jorge P. Galve, Claudio Papiccio, and Francesco La Vigna

    This study proposes a survey methodology to identify areas for combined Sustainable Drainage Systems (SUDS) and Aquifer Storage and Recovery (ASR), (Dearden et al. 2013, Sharp Jr., 1997); these techniques exploit the hydrogeological and geomorphological characteristics of an area, to increase the natural capacity of water to infiltrate the ground.

    The target area of this case study is the city of Rome and the aim of such techniques is to reduce the problems related to rainwater which, in case of extreme events, struggles to infiltrate the ground, overloads the undersized hydraulic systems and floods the urban space.

    The proposed method involves GIS geospatial analysis of various data: the permeability of outcropping lithology, the piezometric level of the aquifer, hydrogeological units, geomorphology and land use.

    In this aim zones characterised by high permeability and a piezometric level that would confer a volumetric capacity to possibly store even large quantities of water without triggering possible problems associated with fluctuations in the water table, have been identified.

    The data have been divided into classes and indexed for comparison and overlap them. Finally, hydrogeological units were also taken into account (by analysing their depth trend) in order to identify areas with similar characteristics of permeability with respect to depth. The latter will also be compared with the previous data to identify the areas suitable for SUDS and ASR.

    The final product of the suitable areas from a hydrogeological point of view will be compared with the land use map in order to exclude those areas that, for administrative and other legislative reasons, cannot be used for such activities.

     

    How to cite: Meddi, E., Lentini, A., Galve, J. P., Papiccio, C., and La Vigna, F.: Mitigation of stormwater flooding by identifying areas suitable for Sustainable Drainage Systems and Aquifer Storage and Recovery (case study: Rome, Italy), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12694, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12694, 2022.

    In recent years, scientists have shown that the increasing trend in precipitation and flash floods during the monsoon season, combined with rapid land-use change, is leading to an increase in river discharge and flood inundation in the Kathmandu valley. The Kathmandu valley is a mid to low elevation mountain region (mean ~ 1250 m), surrounded by hills, particularly to the north, south and west, and has a population of over 3 million.  In this study, statistical analysis of 30 to 50 years of historical rainfall and river discharge data indicate a strong spatial variability in daily rainfall over the catchment during the monsoon season. Hilly regions which surround the Kathmandu basin receive significantly more rainfall than the valley, and rainfall intensity can vary greatly between the northern and southern hills, in particular. Combining our statistical analysis with physical-based numerical modelling of a range of historical flood events we demonstrate that the spatial variability in rainfall can lead to large differences in flood inundation patterns across the valley. Traditional flood early warning systems in the Kathmandu valley do not consider the effect of spatial variability of rainfall on flooding in the basin, which can lead to over or under predictions of flood extent in certain regions for a given event. We demonstrate that flood extent is the centre of Kathmandu and to the west of the city will be significantly higher if heavy rainfall occurs in the northern region of the valley.

    How to cite: Creed, M. and Muthusamy, M.: Modelling the impact of spatial variability of precipitation on flood hazards in the Kathmandu Valley, Nepal, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12829, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12829, 2022.

    The compound dry and hot event (CDHE) has been paying attention in recent decades due to its disastrous impacts on diverse sectors. The teleconnections between dry conditions and large-scale circulation patterns have been widely studied at different spatial and temporal scales. However, studies investigating the links between large-scale circulation patterns and CDHE using a multiscale approach is missing. Quantifying the external forcing of compound dry and hot extremes (CDHE) is tedious and demands in-depth understanding.  We introduce a novel method by integrating wavelets, entropy and complex networks to quantify the potential drivers linked with CDHE. Firstly, a standardized dry and hot Index (SDHI) is developed to model the combined effect of precipitation and temperature using a copula approach. Second, the SDHI and Sea Surface Temperature (SST) is decomposed using wavelets to comprehend multiscale dynamical processes across time scales. Next, entropy is employed to quantify the similarity between SDHI and SST across multiple timescales. The proposed method uses the wavelet energy distribution of CDHI at different time scales and compares it with the wavelet energy distribution of SST to quantify the similarity. From similarity, complex networks is constructed to bridge the links between CDHE and circulation patterns. To investigate the efficiency and reliability, the proposed method is explored to improve the understanding and quantify the potential drivers of CDHE at a regional scale during the summer monsoon in India.  The results show that an integrated approach combining wavelets, entropy and complex networks offers a fresh perspective in analyzing the teleconnections between the compound extremes and large scale circulation patterns.

    How to cite: Guntu, R. K., Merz, B., and Agarwal, A.: Understanding and quantifying potential drivers of compound extremes: A complex networks based on multiscale entropy approach, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-215, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-215, 2022.

    EGU22-471 | Presentations | HS7.7

    Dimensional analysis and intercomparison of the basin time of concentration formulas 

    Giulia Evangelista and Pierluigi Claps

    A wide literature dealing with the assessment of the critical time scale for basin hydrologic response exist worldwide. The time of concentration (tC) is recognized as the most frequently used time parameter, followed by the lag time (tL). However, despite the high sensitivity of design flood peaks to the estimated time parameter values, there is still no agreement on the conceptual and operational definitions of these two parameters, resulting in several different approaches and formulations available.

    In our work, we suggest a conceptual approach to validate formulas of the basin time of concentration, with the aim of drawing some guidance in the choice of a robust formulation to be used in hydrological modelling and hydrograph design. To this end, 47 empirical and semi-empirical formulations to quantify tC have been selected and their structure compared in dimensional terms, using the hydraulic Chezy formula as a litmus paper. Using the river network morphology of 197 watersheds in north-western Italy we have then examined and compared the variability of the estimated average flow velocity within the most hydraulically compatible formulas.

    Mindful of recent outcomes on tracer studies (see Azizian, 2019), our results lead to justify some of the coefficients of just a few of the empirical expressions of the critical basin travel time and to further clarify the distinction between tC and tL, according to some theoretical justifications discussed in Beven (2020).

    How to cite: Evangelista, G. and Claps, P.: Dimensional analysis and intercomparison of the basin time of concentration formulas, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-471, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-471, 2022.

    EGU22-2179 | Presentations | HS7.7

    Partially interpretable neural networks for high-dimensional extreme quantile regression: With application to wildfires within the Mediterranean Basin 

    Jordan Richards, Raphaël Huser, Emanuele Bevacqua, and Jakob Zscheischler
    Quantile regression is a particularly powerful tool for modelling environmental data which exhibits spatio-temporal non-stationarity in its marginal behaviour. If our interest lies in quantifying risk associated with particularly extreme or rare weather events, we may want to estimate conditional quantiles that are outside the range of observable data; in these cases, it is practical to describe the data using some parametric extreme value model with its parameters represented as functions of predictor variables. Classical approaches for parametric extreme quantile regression use linear or additive relationships, and such approaches suffer in either their predictive capabilities or computational efficiency in high-dimensions. 
     
    Neural networks can capture complex non-linear relationships between variables and scale well to high-dimensional predictor sets. Whilst they have been successfully applied in the context of fitting extreme value models, statisticians may choose to forego the use of neural networks as a result of their “black box" nature; although they facilitate highly accurate prediction, it is difficult to do statistical inference with neural networks as their outputs cannot readily be interpreted. Inspired by the recent focus in machine learning literature on “explainable AI”,  we propose a framework for performing extreme quantile regression using partially interpretable neural networks. Distribution parameters are represented as functions of predictors with three main components; a linear function, an additive function and a neural network that are applied separately to complementary subsets of predictors. The output from the linear and additive components is interpreted, whilst the neural network component contributes to the high prediction accuracy of our method.
    We use our approach to estimate extreme quantiles and occurrence probabilities for wildfires occurring within a large spatial domain that encompasses the entirety of the Mediterranean Basin.
     

    How to cite: Richards, J., Huser, R., Bevacqua, E., and Zscheischler, J.: Partially interpretable neural networks for high-dimensional extreme quantile regression: With application to wildfires within the Mediterranean Basin, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2179, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2179, 2022.

    EGU22-2384 | Presentations | HS7.7

    Methodologies for the characterisation of spatially distributed hydrological events: the Italian case study. 

    Alessandro Borre, Alberto Viglione, Simone Gabellani, and Tatiana Ghizzoni

    Evaluating historical extreme flood events is fundamental due to their socioeconomic impacts. In this context, the spatial distribution of the event has a key role and the univariate approach, based on the analysis of local flood frequency on a single site, is not the proper one.

    For this reason, in the recent past, an increasing amount of research has focused on the regional characterization of flood events, trying to describe their temporal and spatial distribution. The main objective of this work is the comparison of two different methods widely used for the selection and characterization of spatially distributed flood events for risk assessment purposes. Both methods were applied to the Italian territory and compared in terms of parameters used, results obtained, and technical analogies and differences. 

    The two methodologies reveal similar results, comparable with a list of extreme events produced as a collection of historical flood reports. The results show that floods co-occurring in several basins are unevenly distributed, with a higher number of selected events occurred in Northern and Central Italy, where the largest Italian basins are located.

    How to cite: Borre, A., Viglione, A., Gabellani, S., and Ghizzoni, T.: Methodologies for the characterisation of spatially distributed hydrological events: the Italian case study., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2384, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2384, 2022.

    Recent developments in Extreme Value Theory have led to the adoption of multivariate methods for modeling extreme rainfall in a way that the spatial dependence between the different measuring stations is used to "borrow“ information. A commonly used method, Brown-Resnick Max-Stable processes, extends the geostatistical concept of the variogram to suit block maxima, allowing to explicitly model the spatial extremal dependence shown by the data. This extremal dependence usually stems from physical processes that generate rainfall in such a way that several stations are affected simultaneously by the same extreme event, such as convective storms or frontal events. Depending on the region, this dependence can change in time, as different meteorological processes dominate the rainfall generation process for different seasons.

    In this study, we analyze in the Berlin-Brandenburg region the change in extremal dependence for annual block maxima. We consider two different seasons – winter and summer – to investigate the effects of two different rainfall generating processes: frontal rainfall is more likely to occur in winter, while convection is dominating in summer. Furthermore, we investigate how this extremal dependence affects the accuracy of the estimation of return levels by using a Brown-Resnick Max-Stable process and comparing the estimated return levels to the results of a covariates model assuming spatial independence. We obtain the uncertainty of our estimates within a Bayesian modeling framework. The bivariate extremal coefficient shows a notable difference in the extremal dependence for summer and winter. Moreover, we observe a difference in the skill of the model when comparing the two seasons, suggesting that the difference in the extremal dependence has an impact on the marginal estimates from the model.

    How to cite: Jurado, O. E. and Rust, H. W.: Estimating the impact of seasonal extremal dependence with a Max-Stable process for modeling extreme precipitation events over Berlin-Brandenburg, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3660, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3660, 2022.

    EGU22-4136 | Presentations | HS7.7

    Modeling Spatial Extremes Using Normal Mean-Variance Mixtures 

    Zhongwei Zhang, Raphaël Huser, Thomas Opitz, and Jennifer Wadsworth

    Classical models for multivariate or spatial extremes are mainly based upon the asymptotically justified max-stable or generalized Pareto processes. These models are suitable when asymptotic dependence is present, i.e., the joint tail decays at the same rate as the marginal tail. However, recent environmental data applications suggest that asymptotic independence is equally important and, unfortunately, existing spatial models in this setting that are both flexible and can be fitted efficiently are scarce. Here, we propose a new spatial copula model based on the generalized hyperbolic distribution, which is a specific normal mean-variance mixture and is very popular in financial modeling. The tail properties of this distribution have been studied in the literature, but with contradictory results. It turns out that the proofs from the literature contain mistakes. We here give a corrected theoretical description of its tail dependence structure and then exploit the model to analyze a simulated dataset from the inverted Brown--Resnick process, hindcast significant wave height data in the North Sea, and wind gust data in the state of Oklahoma, USA. We demonstrate that our proposed model is flexible enough to capture the dependence structure not only in the tail but also in the bulk.

    How to cite: Zhang, Z., Huser, R., Opitz, T., and Wadsworth, J.: Modeling Spatial Extremes Using Normal Mean-Variance Mixtures, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4136, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4136, 2022.

    EGU22-5528 | Presentations | HS7.7

    A globally-applicable framework for compound flood risk modeling 

    Dirk Eilander, Anaïs Couasnon, Hessel C. Winsemius, Sanne Muis, Job Dullaart, Tim Leijnse, and Philip J. Ward

    Low-lying coastal deltas are prone to floods as these areas are often densely populated and face flooding from fluvial (discharge), coastal (surge and waves) and pluvial (rainfall) drivers. If these drivers co-occur, they can cause or exacerbate flooding, and are referred to as compound flood events. Most compound flood studies have either investigated the statistical dependence between drivers or used hydrodynamic models to assess the physical interactions between drivers, but few have combined both aspects to examine extreme flood levels for e.g. risk assessments. Furthermore, hydrodynamic compound flood models are often setup at a local scale, require many person hours to set up and are based on local data, making these hard to scale up. Hence, the need for globally-applicable compound flood risk modelling remains. 

    We developed a globally-applicable framework for compound flood risk modelling. It consists of a local hydrodynamic SFINCS model which is automatically set up based on global datasets after several processing steps and loosely coupled to global models using HydroMT (https://deltares.github.io/hydromt_sfincs/latest/). We applied to the Sofala province of Mozambique where we validated it for two historical tropical cyclone events and used it for a compound flood risk analysis. For the validation, we compared flood extents from the global and local flood models with observed flood extents from remote sensing. Our analysis shows that the local model, while based on the same data, has a higher accuracy compared to the global model. This is due to a more complete representation of flood processes and an increased spatial resolution. We also analyzed the compound flood dynamics and show that the areas where water levels are amplified by interactions between flood drivers vary significantly between events. Finally, we also calculated the compound flood risk from fluvial, pluvial and coastal drivers based on a large stochastic event set of plausible (compound) flood conditions derived from ~40 years of reanalysis data. We find that coastal flood drivers cause the largest risk in the region despite a more widespread fluvial and pluvial flood hazard as most exposure is affected by elevated sea levels. Flood risk increases when accounting for the observed dependence between flood drivers compared to independence and this difference is mainly attributed to events with large return periods. Since the model setup and coupling is automated, reproducible, and globally-applicable, the presented framework offers a way forward towards large scale compound flood risk modelling. 

    How to cite: Eilander, D., Couasnon, A., Winsemius, H. C., Muis, S., Dullaart, J., Leijnse, T., and Ward, P. J.: A globally-applicable framework for compound flood risk modeling, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5528, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5528, 2022.

    EGU22-5970 | Presentations | HS7.7

    Precipitation regridding – Impacts at global scale 

    Chandra Rupa Rajulapati, Simon Michael Papalexiou, Martyn P. Clark, and John W. Pomeroy

    Re-gridding considerably alters precipitation statistics. Despite this fact, regridding precipitation datasets is commonly performed for coupling or comparing different models/datasets. In general, several studies have highlighted the effects of regridding at regional scale. In this study, the effects of re-gridding precipitation are emphasized at a global scale using different regridding methods, size of the shifts and resolutions of the dataset. Substantial differences are noted at high quantiles and precipitation dry (or wet-dry frequency) is altered to a great extent. Specifically, a difference of 46 mm in high (0.95) quantiles and a reduction of 30% wet-dry frequency is noted. The differences increase with the size of the grid shift at higher quantiles and vice versa for low quantiles. As the grid resolution increases, the difference between original and regridded data declines, yet the shift size dominates for high quantiles for which the differences are higher. Spatially, large differences at high quantiles in tropical land regions, and at low quantiles in polar regions are noted. These impacts are approximately same for the three different (first order conservative, bilinear, and distance weighted averaging) regridding methods considered in this study. Overall, re-gridding should be performed with caution as it can alter the statistical properties of precipitation to a great extent and adds uncertainty to further analysis of using in any models or in combined precipitation products.

    How to cite: Rajulapati, C. R., Papalexiou, S. M., Clark, M. P., and Pomeroy, J. W.: Precipitation regridding – Impacts at global scale, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5970, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5970, 2022.

    EGU22-6595 | Presentations | HS7.7

    Realistic and Fast Modeling of Spatial Extremes over Large Geographical Domains 

    Raphael Huser, Arnab Hazra, and David Bolin

    Various natural phenomena, such as precipitation, generally exhibit spatial extremal dependence at short distances only, while the dependence usually fades away as the distance between sites increases arbitrarily. However, the available models proposed in the literature for spatial extremes, which are based on max-stable or Pareto processes or comparatively less computationally demanding "sub-asymptotic" models based on Gaussian location and/or scale mixtures, generally assume that spatial extremal dependence persists across the entire spatial domain. This is a clear limitation when modeling extremes over large geographical domains, but surprisingly, it has been mostly overlooked in the literature. In this paper, we develop a more realistic Bayesian framework based on a novel Gaussian scale mixture model, where the Gaussian process component is defined by a stochastic partial differential equation that yields a sparse precision matrix, and the random scale component is modeled as a low-rank Pareto-tailed or Weibull-tailed spatial process determined by compactly supported basis functions. We show that our proposed model is approximately tail-stationary despite its non-stationary construction in terms of basis functions, and we demonstrate that it can capture a wide range of extremal dependence structures as a function of distance. Furthermore, the inherently sparse structure of our spatial model allows fast Bayesian computations, even in high spatial dimensions, based on a customized Markov chain Monte Carlo algorithm, which prioritize calibration in the tail. In our application, we fit our model to analyze heavy monsoon rainfall data in Bangladesh. Our study indicates that the proposed model outperforms some natural alternatives, and that the model fits precipitation extremes satisfactorily well. Finally, we use the fitted model to draw inferences on long-term return levels for marginal precipitation at each site, and for spatial aggregates.

    How to cite: Huser, R., Hazra, A., and Bolin, D.: Realistic and Fast Modeling of Spatial Extremes over Large Geographical Domains, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6595, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6595, 2022.

    EGU22-8617 | Presentations | HS7.7

    Spatial classification of typical European heatwaves using clustering 

    Elizaveta Felsche, Andrea Böhnisch, and Ralf Ludwig

    Prolonged heat periods have become a recurring feature of the European climate. Recent events like the 2003 heatwave in France, the 2010 Russian heatwave, and the 2019 European heatwave have caused considerable economic losses due to crop failure, imposed substantial stress on the health system, and caused thousands of heat-related deaths. Due to climate change, an increase in length and frequency of heatwaves has been observed since 1950 in most regions worldwide. However, until now, little knowledge is available on the generalized patterns of heatwaves since most studies focus on the analysis of single historical heatwave events.

    This study aims to increase the general understanding of heatwaves by identifying and analyzing stable classes, i.e., recurring patterns, of heatwaves present in Europe. In this study, we use data from a regional climate model large ensemble (Canadian Regional Climate Model version 5, CRCM5-LE) consisting of 50 possible realizations of climate in the years 1981-2010 in the EUR-11 domain. We use the 95th percentile of three days' mean temperature as a threshold of heatwave occurrence. Those events are additionally filtered to at least one percent of the land area to ensure that the events have a considerable spatial extent. We repeatedly apply hierarchical agglomerative clustering to find a dozen stable heatwave patterns in Europe. Those results are in good correspondence with clustering on an observational dataset (E-OBS) and when comparing those to historical events. Therefore it is shown that the catastrophic historical events can be explained as an extreme manifestation of the same recurring pattern.

    Moreover, we analyze the obtained typical patterns regarding a precipitation deficit present before or after the event. We find that, e.g., after a summer heatwave in South-East Europe, there is a high chance of having increased precipitation in autumn, while no such trend can be observed in Scandinavia. Moreover, the study serves as a blueprint for the analysis of other spatial extreme events (e.g., droughts). 

    How to cite: Felsche, E., Böhnisch, A., and Ludwig, R.: Spatial classification of typical European heatwaves using clustering, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8617, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8617, 2022.

    EGU22-9139 | Presentations | HS7.7

    Drought self-propagation in drylands through moisture recycling 

    Jessica Keune, Dominik L. Schumacher, Paul Dirmeyer, and Diego G. Miralles

    Soil dryness modulates the surface energy balance through a reduction in evaporation, and can in turn affect both local and downwind precipitation. But when evaporation is heavily constrained by soil moisture, there is also a reduced local water vapor supply to the atmosphere, manifesting as downwind moisture deficits. Soil moisture–precipitation feedbacks as a whole — including surface heating-induced boundary layer processes and interactions, as well as changes in tropospheric moistening — have already been extensively investigated, particularly at the local scale. However, little is known about the non-local impact of soil moisture on precipitation. Here, we focus on the impact of water vapor reductions instigated by already existing soil drought, estimate the downwind effect on precipitation and thus gauge the potential for drought self-propagation. A Lagrangian approach constrained by observational and reanalysis data is employed to reveal the origins of water vapor, establishing a causal link between upwind evaporation and downwind rainfall. We assess the self-propagation of the 40 largest soil drought events from 1980 to 2016, obtained with a novel mathematical morphology method. Specifically, we estimate the reduction in precipitation caused by drought-stricken areas in the direction of drought propagation, and isolate the effect of upwind soil moisture drought from the influence of potential evaporation and circulation variability. Our results show that droughts self-propagate in subtropical drylands, owing to the strong decline in evaporation in response to soil water stress. For entire events, the reduction in precipitation along the propagation front can be more than 15%, and up to 30% for individual months. Our findings highlight that terrestrial ecosystems reliant on their own evaporation supplying  rainfall are most affected, and underline the susceptibility of arid environments to self-inflicted drought expansion.

    How to cite: Keune, J., Schumacher, D. L., Dirmeyer, P., and Miralles, D. G.: Drought self-propagation in drylands through moisture recycling, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9139, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9139, 2022.

    EGU22-9725 | Presentations | HS7.7

    Investigating the Spatial Extent of Extreme Precipitation 

    Abbas El Hachem, András Bárdossy, Jochen Seidel, Golbarg Goshtasbpour, and Uwe Haberlandt

    Investigation of precipitation extremes is traditionally based on point observations. Such rain gauges networks  often have an insufficient network density to  correctly capture the spatial extent of extreme events. An alternative is to use weather radar data which provide a spatially distributed rainfall field but these observations are prone to errors. To reduce the errors in the radar observations, a copula-based merging procedure is applied to combine radar and station observations with high temporal resolution. From this product, the spatial extent of extremes in investigated. This is done by extracting the connected rainfall areas from every rainfall field for several precipitation thresholds and temporal aggregations. The location, size, station data whithin these areas, areal mean precipitation value, and the areal maximum precipitation value are gathered and investigated.

    This procedure was applied to the area covered by the German Weather Service (DWD) radar in Hannover with a 5 minutes temporal resolution and for the period 2000-2019. The first results of this investigation shows that station observations underestimate the true areal maxima in most of the cases. Moreover, the connected areas are categorized based on their size and the areal mean precipitation values are compared. It was found that with increasing area size the corresponding areal mean increased. This was observed until a certain area size is reached after which the areal mean almost stabilizes. A clustering of the continuous areas revealed that the occurrence of the areas is independent of the location and that extreme observation can occur anywhere within the study region.

    How to cite: El Hachem, A., Bárdossy, A., Seidel, J., Goshtasbpour, G., and Haberlandt, U.: Investigating the Spatial Extent of Extreme Precipitation, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9725, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9725, 2022.

    EGU22-10335 | Presentations | HS7.7

    Global analysis of extreme precipitation changes in the Köppen-Geiger climate classification 

    Salma Hobbi, Sofia Nerantzaki, Simon Michael Papalexiou, and Chandra Rupa Rajulapati

    Changes in the frequency and intensity of extreme precipitation resulting from climate change are responsible for natural disasters such as severe floods and have been a major study focus during the last decades. Previous studies have mainly focused on the trends of annual maxima precipitation at global and regional scales. However, little is known about how extreme precipitation trends change among different climate types. This study offers a global analysis of extreme precipitation changes in terms of climate type by using over 8500 gauge-based records. We focus on the period 1964 to 2013 when global warming was accelerating. A climate type is assigned to each station based on the Köppen Geiger (KG) climate classification, resulting in 30 KG climate subtypes. Mann-Kendall test and Sen’s slope estimator are applied to each time series, measuring the magnitude and significance of trends. The heaviness of the tail for each station is assessed based on the shape parameter of the Generalized Extreme Value distribution. Our results indicate a decreasing trend for the majority of stations associated with some of the arid, temperate, and continental subtypes (i.e., hot semi-arid (BSh); hot-summer temperate (Csa); warm-summer temperate (Csb); and warm, dry-summer continental (Dsb)). An increasing trend is observed for the stations associated with the remaining KG subtypes, especially stations associated with dry-summer subarctic (Dsc) and monsoon-influenced extremely cold subarctic (Dwd). A significant increasing trend is estimated for 9.7% of stations located in the eastern USA, Asia, and northern Europe. However, only 2% of stations, mainly in eastern Australia and the central USA have a significant decreasing trend. The heaviness of the tail is the largest in the Polar major climate type (E), followed by Tropical (A), Dry (B), Continental (D), and Temperate (C). For the climate subtypes, large heavy-tailed extremes are observed in extremely cold subarctic (Dfd), polar tundra (ET), and tropical monsoon (Am), while only light-tailed extremes were observed in subpolar oceanic (Cfc). This study reveals the relationship of extreme precipitation characteristics (e.g., tail heaviness and trend) with the climate types at the global scale.

     

    How to cite: Hobbi, S., Nerantzaki, S., Papalexiou, S. M., and Rajulapati, C. R.: Global analysis of extreme precipitation changes in the Köppen-Geiger climate classification, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10335, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10335, 2022.

    EGU22-10954 | Presentations | HS7.7

    Classification of Boreal Summer East Asian Marine Heatwaves and Their Possible Mechanisms 

    Hyoeun Oh, Go-Un Kim, Chan Joo Jang, and Jin-Yong Jeong

    Marine heatwave (MHW) is one of the severe extreme events under global warming, which affects the marine ecosystem and its relevant socio-economic losses. In particular, East Asian sea surface temperature is projected to increase more under the future climate change scenarios than any other ocean worldwide. According to concern for the increasing SST over East Asia, studies on the MHW are needed to minimize the damage. Thus, this study will classify the different spatiotemporal characteristics of East Asian MHWs and find their possible mechanisms using a self-organizing map. There are four dominant modes of MHWs over East Asia: (1) Global warming-like mode, (2) East China Sea mode, (3) East Sea/Japan Sea mode, and (4) Yellow Sea mode. We found the enhanced net downward shortwave radiation plays a crucial role in modulating the onset of the MHW everywhere over East Asia. When looking at the process of MHW occurrence, the spatial patterns related to the Yellow Sea mode and the East Sea/Japan Sea mode appear very similar, but the significant difference between the two modes is the presence or absence of preceding Indian monsoon heating. This means the Indian monsoon heating can precursor the MHWs over the East Sea/Japan Sea. As a result, this study has a significant implication for the predictability of the MHW over East Asia by finding precursors of the MHWs.

    How to cite: Oh, H., Kim, G.-U., Jang, C. J., and Jeong, J.-Y.: Classification of Boreal Summer East Asian Marine Heatwaves and Their Possible Mechanisms, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10954, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10954, 2022.

    EGU22-549 | Presentations | HS7.8

    Differential orographic impact on sub-hourly, hourly, and daily extreme precipitation 

    Giuseppe Formetta, Francesco Marra, Eleonora Dallan, Mattia Zaramella, and Marco Borga

    Extreme precipitation in mountainous regions is the main trigger of hydrological hazards such as flash floods and debris flows, among the most dangerous natural-hazards worldwide, both for social and for economic losses. Mountains significantly influence weather and climate, including altered distribution of precipitation and of its extremes, with different impacts at different durations. Understanding the orographic impact on the statistics of precipitation extremes is therefore crucial for improving hydrological design and risk management strategies. Here, we use a novel statistical approach for the analysis of extremes based on ordinary events, which are defined as the finite independent samples of the analyzed stochastic process (e.g. Marani and Ignaccolo, 2015), to improve our understanding of the orographic impact on extreme precipitation of durations ranging between 5 minutes and 24 hours. We focus on Trentino, a rough orographic region in the eastern Italia Alps, and use data from 78 quality-controlled rain gauges with 5-minute resolution. We validated our statistical framework against statistical properties of the observed annual maxima (Nash-Sutcliffe and Bias) as well as their relation with orography. We then exploit the reduced uncertainty of this approach to quantify the orographic impact on precipitation right-tail statistics and on extreme return levels using a regression analysis. We identify two main modes of orographic relationship: a reverse orographic effect for hourly and sub-hourly durations and an orographic enhancement for durations of ~8 hours or longer. We observe that these two modes result from three main precipitation regimes, which show different proportion between extreme and very-extreme events and which emerge at very short durations mid durations and long durations. These findings are of interest for risk management applications and climate change impact studies.

    References

    Marani, M., & Ignaccolo, M. (2015). A metastatistical approach to rainfall extremes. Advances in Water Resources, 79, 121-126.

     

    How to cite: Formetta, G., Marra, F., Dallan, E., Zaramella, M., and Borga, M.: Differential orographic impact on sub-hourly, hourly, and daily extreme precipitation, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-549, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-549, 2022.

    EGU22-570 | Presentations | HS7.8

    Regional predictions of sub-daily rainfall extremes through data-driven blends of morphoclimatic descriptors 

    Andrea Magnini, Michele Lombardi, Elena Valtancoli, and Attilio Castellarin

    Due to the limited length of locally available sequences of precipitation extremes, estimates of design rainstorms at a given location (i.e. point rainfall depth associated with given durations and non-exceedance probabilities) are traditionally obtained from regional frequency analysis. Several statistical regionalization methods proposed in the literature enable one to exploit sequences of precipitation extremes observed at a number of sites that supposedly share the same frequency regime of rainfall extremes with the site of interest (herein also referred to as a homogeneous pooling group of sites). Homogeneous pooling groups of sites can be identified by looking at specific climatic descriptors; for instance, some reliable authors successfully utilize Mean Annual Precipitation (MAP) as the sole proxy for locally characterizing the frequency regime of sub-daily rainfall extremes and for grouping sequences of rainfall extremes records. We aim at advancing this traditional approach (1) by relaxing the hypothesis of the existence of a homogeneous pooling group of sites characterized by a unique regional parent distribution and (2) by incorporating additional morphological and climatic information in the regional model. Our research focuses on a large study area in Northern Italy, counting more than 2350 Annual Maximum Series of rainfall depth for different time-aggregation intervals between 1 and 24 hours, that have been collected between 1928 and 2011 in the Italian Rainfall Extreme Dataset (I2-RED).  We refer to local MAP value as well as to several other morphologic descriptors (e.g. minimum distance to the coast, elevation of orographic barriers, aspect, terrain slope, etc.) for characterizing the frequency regime of sub-daily rainfall extremes. We train a probabilistic neural network that uses the descriptors cited above as input layers for modeling the local frequency regime of observed rainfall annual maxima. We resort to a Generalized Extreme Value (GEV) distribution whose parameters are data-driven functions of the local morphoclimatic descriptors as well as the time-aggregation interval. We then perform a series of cross-validation experiments targeted at assessing the accuracy of the developed data-driven regional frequency model relative to a simpler regional model in which GEV parameters are functions of MAP and time aggregation intervals.

    Our results address the following research problems: (a) identification of the most descriptive morphological proxies for representing the frequency regime of sub-daily rainfall extremes, (b) assessment of potential, limitations, and robustness of data-driven multivariate regional frequency models of sub-daily rainfall extremes relative to simpler and more traditional regionalization schemes.

    How to cite: Magnini, A., Lombardi, M., Valtancoli, E., and Castellarin, A.: Regional predictions of sub-daily rainfall extremes through data-driven blends of morphoclimatic descriptors, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-570, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-570, 2022.

    EGU22-987 | Presentations | HS7.8

    Uncertainty analysis of regionalized intensity-duration-frequency curves in Germany 

    Bora Shehu and Uwe Haberlandt

    Rainfall intensity-duration-frequency (IDF) curves are required for the design of several water systems and protection works. Typically, long (more than 40 years) station data are employed first to generate annual extremes (AMS) for different durations and then to fit a GEV probability distribution. Since station data are only point measurements, regionalization techniques are applied to estimate IDF curves at ungauged locations.  Prior results revealed that the best way to obtain IDF maps for Germany was kriging interpolation of parameters from very long stations with the parameters of the short stations acting as an external drift. However, how certain the obtained IDFs values are, and how to derive the uncertainty range at each location, remain still unanswered. Therefore, it is the objective of this study, to investigate the propagation of uncertainty in the regionalization of the IDF curves for Germany.

    For this purpose, the available station data from the German Weather Service (DWD) for whole Germany are employed, which includes; 1100 sub-hourly (5min) recordings with observations period shorter than 20 years, and 89 sub-hourly (5min) recordings with 60-70 years of observations. Annual extremes are extracted at each location for different durations (from 5mins up to 7days), and local IDF curves are estimated according to Koutsoyiannis et al. (1998). The parameters of the obtained IDF functions are then interpolated using external drift kriging. Finally, quantiles are derived for each location, duration and given return period (Ta=2, 10, 20, 50 and 100 years). Through a non-parametric bootstrap, the uncertainty is estimated for three different components of the regionalization: i) local estimation of parameters, ii) variogram estimation and iii) spatial sampling distribution.  Simulated annealing is employed to ensure that the spatial resampling of locations represents the obtained variograms. The final uncertainty range is then considered as the 95% confidence interval of the obtained IDF curve for each location, duration and return period.      

    The results of this study reveal how the uncertainty of annual rainfall extremes propagates from local estimation to the regionalization of IDF curves based on kriging theory. The comparison of the three components will shed light to the following questions: Which is the contribution of each component to the final uncertainty range of IDFs curve? How is the uncertainty range changing based on different durations and return periods? Are there any spatial trends in Germany regarding the uncertainty range of IDFs curves? 

    How to cite: Shehu, B. and Haberlandt, U.: Uncertainty analysis of regionalized intensity-duration-frequency curves in Germany, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-987, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-987, 2022.

    EGU22-2423 | Presentations | HS7.8

    Efficient usage of information for modeling precipitation extremes and large scale influence 

    Felix Fauer, Jana Ulrich, and Henning Rust

    Extreme precipitation is currently the biggest climate-change-related thread in middle Europe with flooding events leading to high death tolls and huge existential and financial losses. Evaluating the probabilities of these extremes can help preventing casualties and reducing impact consequences. Our analysis is based on Intensity-Duration-Frequency (IDF) curves which describe the major statistical characteristics of extreme precipitation events. They provide information on the probability of exceedance of certain precipitation intensities for a range of durations and can help to visualize how extreme the event for different durations is.  A popular way of evaluating return periods of extremes is to model the underlying distribution of block maxima with the Generalized Extreme Value (GEV) distribution. A core problem when modeling extremes is the scarce availability of data. This can be addressed by using the available data more efficiently. Therefore, including maxima from different measurement durations is useful for (1) gathering more information from the data and (2) estimating return periods for different time scales with a consistent modeling approach. Duration-dependence is implemented directly into the parameter estimation (Koutsoyiannis et al., 1998) and enables a consistent model, i.e. without quantile-crossing. We present a new parameterization of the duration-dependent GEV (d-GEV) that is more flexible with respect to long ranges of durations and is considering the different time scales on which extremes occur in winter and summer (Fauer et al., 2021). Applying the new model to the extreme rain event on 14 July 2021 in Ahrtal, Germany reveals that the event was most extreme on a time scale of 20-30 hours.

    Investigating the impact of large-scale atmospheric flow on extremes will help to learn how extremes changed in the past and make projections about their change in the future. Large scale variables are incorporated into the model as covariates in generalized linear models for the d-GEV parameters. An ongoing study tests for the inclusion of NAO, a blocking index, monthly mean temperature, etc., as predictor variables. First results show a significant correlation (5%-level) between monthly precipitation maxima and NAO/blocking for some durations and some seasons. It will be analyzed whether this connection can be useful for modelling d-GEV parameters with large-scale variables.

    How to cite: Fauer, F., Ulrich, J., and Rust, H.: Efficient usage of information for modeling precipitation extremes and large scale influence, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2423, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2423, 2022.

    EGU22-2738 | Presentations | HS7.8

    Statistical Analysis of Space-times Dynamics of Extreme Precipitation 

    Golbarg Goshtsasbpour, Uwe Haberlandt, Abbas El Hachem, Jochen Seidel, and András Bárdossy

    Precipitation extremes are space-time phenomena and traditionally the statistical analyses on such occurrences have treated them merely as point events. Many of the consequences of such events like floods are related to the water volume, hence the spatial aspect of them cannot be neglected. This work aims to bring the areal aspect of the extreme rainfall into play by introducing the area into the Extreme Value Analysis (EVA) and providing Area-Depth-Duration-Frequency (ADDF) curves. For this purpose, different spatial rainfall products have been used and compared with each other. Processed raw radar data, a product of conditional merging of the radar and station data as well as the RADKLIM data (a product of the German Weather Service designed for climate research) have been used for the EVA. Unexpected patterns have been observed in the ADDF curves based on the processed radar data which were not in agreement with the assumptions of the classical approach of areal reduction factor.  Usually, it is assumed that areal precipitation extremes increase with decreasing area, so in practice reduction factors are used to estimate areal precipitation extreme values from point observations. This behavior was observed as expected mostly for durations shorter than 2 hours in all the study locations whereas the opposite was present for longer durations, where the precipitation is increasing with increasing area, so that the ADDF curves, representing different areas, show crossings at these durations. Different hypotheses about the reason for the crossings like seasonality and spatial non-stationarity have been tested and did not explain the crossings. On the other hand, the ADDF curves of the merged rainfall product hardly showed such patterns and followed the classical assumptions. Therefore, the appearance of such crossings in the ADDF curves of a spatial rain product might be an indicator of artifacts in the radar rainfall product. It has to be investigated in further tests if these results hold and if these crossings could be used as an indicator for unplausible radar data.  

    How to cite: Goshtsasbpour, G., Haberlandt, U., El Hachem, A., Seidel, J., and Bárdossy, A.: Statistical Analysis of Space-times Dynamics of Extreme Precipitation, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2738, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2738, 2022.

    The parent distribution of daily precipitation is usually not known, and the exceedance probability of extremes is described using a Generalized Extreme Value distribution (GEV) fitting the annual maxima. However, knowing the parent distribution would allow us to use ordinary statistics to describe extremes, with two advantages: (i) a decreased parameter estimation uncertainty; (ii) the possibility to establish direct relations between ordinary and extreme events. Recent studies suggest that daily precipitation could have Weibull tails, meaning that the probability of exceeding large values decrease as a stretched exponential. Here, we exploit a global dataset of long and quality-controlled continuous rain gauge records (~8,000 stations, ≥50 complete years) to investigate this question.

    We find that the observed annual maxima are likely samples from Weibull tails in ~88% of the stations worldwide. On average, ~36% of the wet days belong to these tails. We find a strong climatic dependence in their definition, with smaller portions of data in the Weibull tails in central Europe, US east coast and southern Australia. We then generate synthetic records with the same characteristics (yearly number of wet days, Weibull tails with the same shape parameter) and increasing lengths (10-110 years); we estimate the corresponding GEV shape parameters and contrast them with the ones obtained from very long annual maxima records (~15,000 stations, 40-163 years; Papalexiou and Koutsoyiannis, 2013, https://doi.org/10.1029/2012WR012557). We show that parent distributions with Weibull tails well explain the properties of the observed GEV shape parameters. These GEV tails (type-III, Frechet) are heavier than the limiting GEV for Weibull parent distributions (type-I, Gumbel); this implies a pre-asymptotic behavior: the average yearly number of wet days (globally, n=100±50) is not large enough to fulfill the asymptotic assumption (n~∞) of extreme value theory. Contrasting our results with generalized Pareto tails, as predicted by extreme value theory for high threshold exceedances, we find that the two models are equivalent within the observational uncertainties; the Weibull model, however, describes a portion of data which is, on average, 7 times larger.

    How to cite: Marra, F. and Papalexiou, S. M.: Daily precipitation with stretched-exponential tails could explain the statistics of observed annual maxima, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3805, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3805, 2022.

    EGU22-6720 | Presentations | HS7.8

    A multi-scale space-time hybrid weather generator 

    Ross Pidoto and Uwe Haberlandt

    Long term time series of meteorologic variables are generally lacking and is especially the case at sub-daily temporal resolutions. These time series are needed for applications such as hydrological modelling of catchments and derived flood frequency analyses. Stochastic weather generators are one such solution and are able to generate long synthetic time series of arbitrary length.

    This study explores the coupling of an hourly space-time rainfall model with a non-parametric K-NN resampling approach for non-rainfall climate variables such as temperature, humidity and global radiation. A daily gridded observational climate dataset is used for the resampling. As a last step, a simple disaggregation technique is applied to the resampled non-rainfall climate variables to achieve an hourly timestep.

    To study the effectiveness and performance of the hybrid weather generator, synthetic time series for 400 mesoscale catchments within Germany consisting of 700 rainfall stations were generated and compared to observations. Results show that the hybrid weather generator adequately reproduces observed statistics for rainfall and the non-rainfall climate variables in addition to maintaining cross correlations between the climate variables.

    How to cite: Pidoto, R. and Haberlandt, U.: A multi-scale space-time hybrid weather generator, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6720, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6720, 2022.

    EGU22-7181 | Presentations | HS7.8

    A Bayesian framework to derive consistent intensity-duration-frequency curves from multiple data sources 

    Thordis Thorarinsdottir, Thea Roksvåg, Julia Lutz, Lars Grinde, and Anita Dyrrdal

    As a warming climate leads to more frequent heavy rainfall, the importance of accurate rainfall statistics is increasing. Rainfall statistics are often presented as intensity-duration-frequency (IDF) curves showing the rainfall intensity (return level) that can be expected at a location for a duration, and the frequency of this intensity (return period). IDF curves are commonly constructed by fitting generalized extreme value (GEV) distributions to observed annual maximum rainfall for several target durations, where the available observation data sources may vary for the different durations. As the estimation is performed independently across durations, the resulting IDF curves may be inconsistent across durations and return periods. We discuss how consistent estimates across the different durations may be derived by post-processing independently obtained Bayesian posterior distributions for each duration. The proposed methods are evaluated for simulated data and for Norwegian rainfall data from 83 locations, for 16 durations between 1 minute and 24 hours, where the post-processing yields consistent and accurate estimates.

    How to cite: Thorarinsdottir, T., Roksvåg, T., Lutz, J., Grinde, L., and Dyrrdal, A.: A Bayesian framework to derive consistent intensity-duration-frequency curves from multiple data sources, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7181, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7181, 2022.

    EGU22-412 | Presentations | HS7.9 | Highlight

    Sensitivity of global surface moisture dynamics under changed land cover and land management 

    Steven De Hertog, Carmen Elena Lopez Fabara, Felix Havermann, Suqi Guo, Julia Pongratz, Iris Manola, Fei Luo, Dim Coumou, Edouard L. Davin, Sonia I. Seneviratne, Quentin Lejeune, Carl-Friedrich Schleussner, and Wim Thiery

    Land cover and land management changes (LCLMC) have often been highlighted as crucial regarding climate change mitigation (e.g., enhanced carbon uptake on land through afforestation), but their potential for adaptation has also been suggested (e.g., local cooling through irrigation). Regarding the latter, the effects of LCLMC on the climate remain uncertain. LCLMC can have strong implications on surface moisture fluxes and have even been linked to changes in large scale atmospheric circulation. Here, we study the effects of three LCLMC (i) global afforestation, (ii) global cropland expansion and (iii) large-scale irrigation extension on climate by employing three fully coupled Earth System Models (CESM, MPI-ESM, and EC-EARTH). Sensitivity simulations were performed under present-day conditions and extreme LCLMC, of which the effects on moisture fluxes and atmospheric circulation are investigated. We do this by first analyzing the surface moisture fluxes using monthly precipitation and evaporation data to perform a moisture convergence analysis, before performing a moisture tracking analysis with the Water Accounting Model (WAM-2 layers) , this model solves the atmospheric moisture balance and requires sub-daily data from the sensitivity experiments as an input.

    Here we focus on the results from CESM, cropland expansion has shown to cause an average shift southward of the Intertropical convergence zone as well as a weakening in westerlies strength and consequent decrease in moisture transport. This causes an increase in continental moisture sources over most of the Northern Hemisphere. Afforestation, in contrast, shows an average shift northward of the Intertropical convergence zone and enhanced westerlies and moisture transport. Lastly, irrigation expansion enhances the moisture convergence over areas where irrigation is applied, causing an increase in both precipitation and evapotranspiration.

    How to cite: De Hertog, S., Lopez Fabara, C. E., Havermann, F., Guo, S., Pongratz, J., Manola, I., Luo, F., Coumou, D., Davin, E. L., Seneviratne, S. I., Lejeune, Q., Schleussner, C.-F., and Thiery, W.: Sensitivity of global surface moisture dynamics under changed land cover and land management, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-412, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-412, 2022.

    EGU22-634 | Presentations | HS7.9

    Mechanistic differences of leaf and ecosystem-scale water use efficiencies on the Qinghai-Tibet Plateau 

    Xiang Wang, Guo Chen, Mingquan Wu, Xiaozhen Li, Qi Wu, Peng Wang, Hui Zeng, Rui Yang, and Xiaolu Tang

    Water use efficiency (WUE) is an important indicator of carbon and water cycles in terrestrial ecosystems. However, little is known about differences in water use efficiency at the leaf scale (WUELeaf) and ecosystem-scale (WUEECO) and response to environmental variables, particularly in plateau ecosystems with gradient effects. We obtained leaf carbon isotope data and calculated leaf-scale water use efficiency on the Qinghai-Tibet Plateau through field surveys and literature collection and calculated ecosystem-scale water use efficiency based on remote sensing data (MODIS). The study analyzed the differences between leaf-scale WUE and ecosystem-scale WUE in terms of vegetation type and spatial distribution and explored the response of water use efficiency to changes in environmental factors at both scales. The results found that the two water use efficiency scales showed different vegetation type trends and spatial distribution. At the leaf scale, WUELeaf showed grasses (10.91 mmol/mol) > trees (9.55 mmol/mol) > shrubs (8.34 mmol/mol), and spatially as a whole showed higher in the western high altitudes (Grasses) than in the low eastern altitudes (Trees). In contrast, at the ecosystem scale, WUEEco shows trees (1.17 g C/kg H2O) > shrubs (1.05 g C/kg H2O) > grasses (0.53 g C/kg H2O), while at the spatial scale, the eastern low elevation region (Forests) is greater than the western high elevation region (Grasslands). Climate (MAT) and vegetation (EVI) factors are the most important environmental variables affecting the variation of WUE at leaf and ecosystem scales, respectively, on the Tibetan plateau. The effect of altitude on water use efficiency is not caused by the vegetation type, although the WUE varies among vegetation types. Conversely, the effect of elevation is influenced by the interaction between environmental conditions and vegetation. These results suggest that the appropriate water use efficiency scale should be selected for specific purposes in carbon and water cycle studies. When the focus is on the influence of climate on the carbon-water cycle, leaf-scale water use efficiency is more appropriate, while if the effect of vegetation, ecosystem-scale water use efficiency would be more appropriate.

    How to cite: Wang, X., Chen, G., Wu, M., Li, X., Wu, Q., Wang, P., Zeng, H., Yang, R., and Tang, X.: Mechanistic differences of leaf and ecosystem-scale water use efficiencies on the Qinghai-Tibet Plateau, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-634, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-634, 2022.

    EGU22-2709 | Presentations | HS7.9

    OCELAND: A Conceptual Model to Explain the Partitioning of Precipitation between Land and Ocean 

    Luca Schmidt and Cathy Hohenegger

    The spatial distribution of precipitation is often misrepresented by General Circulation Models. In particular, precipitation tends to be underestimated over land and overestimated over ocean.

    In this study, we investigate whether large-scale constraints on the partitioning of precipitation between land and ocean exist by using a conceptual box model based on water balance equations. With a small number of empirical but physically motivated parametrizations of the water balance components, we construct a set of coupled ordinary differential equations which describe the dynamical behavior of the water vapor content of land and ocean atmospheres as well as the soil moisture content of land. We compute the equilibrium solution of this system and analyze the sensitivity of the equilibrium state to model parameter choices.

    Our results show that the precipitation ratio between land and ocean is primarily controlled by the land fraction, a scale-dependent atmospheric moisture transport parameter and the permanent wilting point of the soil. We demonstrate how the proposed model can be adapted for applications on both global and local scales, e.g. to model island precipitation enhancement. For a global scale model configuration with one ocean and one land domain, we show that the precipitation ratio is constrained to a range between zero and one and are able to explain this behavior based on the underlying equations and the fundamental property of land to lose water through runoff.

    How to cite: Schmidt, L. and Hohenegger, C.: OCELAND: A Conceptual Model to Explain the Partitioning of Precipitation between Land and Ocean, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2709, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2709, 2022.

    EGU22-3411 | Presentations | HS7.9 | Highlight

    Mapping ecological and human systems responses to land-atmosphere interactions altered by climate change 

    Yannick Back, Peter Bach, Alrun Jasper-Tönnies, Wolfgang Rauch, and Manfred Kleidorfer

    Land cover alteration due to anthropogenic activities modify land surface properties in absorbing, reflecting and emitting radiation as well as infiltrating, evaporating and storing water. This consequently modifies surface energy and water fluxes and, thus, climatic conditions. Progressive surface sealing results in higher runoff rates, less groundwater recharge, inhibited diurnal evaporative cooling and increased substrate heat storage, leading to augmented heat exchange by convection and, consequently, to an intensification of urban heat. We have identified a profound and robust relationship between the individual fluxes of the surface energy balance. From this, we derived an index including decisive aspects of land-atmosphere interactions and its feedbacks for assessment of the implication of surfaces to the climate system. The Surface Thermal Contribution Index (STCI) is intuitive to understand and can be calculated directly from Normalised Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI), from climate models or using data from on-site measurements. We provide a comprehensive framework to measure ecological and human systems responses to changes in land-atmosphere interactions and resulting feedbacks under global warming as well as critical malfunctions related to environmental and human well-being. Here, we use the index to map the partitioning of surface energy and water fluxes and assess surface thermal contribution at global to intra-urban microscale. Our results show that increasing global land evapotranspiration from 1999 to 2020, visible through a higher proportion of latent heat fluxes, is primarily observable in forested and irrigated regions and dominant on the northern hemisphere. Regional aridity, visible through a higher proportion of sensible and substrate heat fluxes, in combination with the 2019 European heatwave inhibited diurnal intra-urban evaporative cooling indicating that current urban adaptation measures cannot cope with decreasing water availability. Results confirm the hypotheses that land evapotranspiration should increase in a warming climate accompanied by increasing land aridity, amplified by land-atmosphere feedbacks, and thus reaffirm an intensification of the global water cycle. Although increasing latent heat fluxes favour surface cooling, land-atmosphere feedbacks lead to a decrease in surface water availability with increasing evapotranspiration, due to an acceleration in the transfer of water into the atmosphere. Global warming intensifies the global water cycle and increases the water holding capacity of the atmosphere as defined by the Clausius-Clapeyron relation. This further decreases surface water availability. The combination of increasing temperatures, land aridity and frequency of extreme heat events deteriorates urban vegetation health, diminishes the evaporative cooling effect and eventually leads to degradation of urban ecosystems. We conclude that green infrastructure interventions to reduce urban heat will not cope with future consequences, by means of regional water scarcity, if not irrigated extensively, which in turn will increase the pressure on local water resources and global water challenges. We stress the importance of restoring natural surface energy and water balances for climate-sensitive development. With global cities projected to shift to warmer and drier conditions, increasing resilience requires more comprehensive urban water management that sustainably provides sufficient water availability to avoid fatalities of ecological and human systems and maintain the evapotranspiration-driven cooling effect for successful urban heat mitigation.

    How to cite: Back, Y., Bach, P., Jasper-Tönnies, A., Rauch, W., and Kleidorfer, M.: Mapping ecological and human systems responses to land-atmosphere interactions altered by climate change, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3411, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3411, 2022.

    Storm-resolving simulations where deep convection can be explicitly resolved are performed in the idealized radiative-convective equilibrium framework to explore multiple equilibria in the vegetation-atmosphere system and the role of interactive leaf phenology. Firstly, by initializing the system with different initial soil moisture and leaf area index (LAI) conditions, we find three equilibrium states: a hot desert state without vegetation, an intermediate sparsely vegetated state, and a wet vegetated state. The existence of the three equilibrium states is subdued only to initial soil moisture conditions, not to initial LAI. The wet vegetated state is the most probable state among the multiple equilibria starting at different initial soil moisture and LAI. This indicates that a quite harsh environment, with soil moisture values very close to the permanent wilting point, is needed to kill leaves. It also implies that the vegetation-atmosphere system is more stable with interactive leaf phenology and can be interpreted as Amazon may be more resilient to the disturbances than we have thought. Secondly, interactive leaves allow an earlier transition between the intermediate to the wet vegetated state. These results imply that the vegetation-atmosphere system is more stable with interactive leaf phenology and can be interpreted as Amazon may be more resilient to the disturbances than we have thought. In our set-up, interactive leaves are only important for soil moisture larger than 54%, and their effect could be well approximated by prescribing the LAI to its maximum value. Finally, our sensitivity experiments reveal that leaves influence the climate equally through their controls on canopy conductance and vegetation cover, whereas albedo plays a negligible role.

    How to cite: Lee, J., Hohenegger, C., Chlond, A., and Schnur, R.: Multiple equilibria of the vegetation-atmosphere system in radiative-convective equilibrium storm-resolving simulations with interactive leaf phenology, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5263, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5263, 2022.

    EGU22-5410 | Presentations | HS7.9 | Highlight

    Effects of land-use change in the Amazon on precipitation are likely underestimated 

    Mara Baudena, Obbe A Tuinenburg, Pendula A Ferdinand, and Arie Staal

    Land-use changes in the Amazon affect precipitation patterns, as the forest enhances precipitation levels regionally due to tree transpiration. However, it remains unclear to what extent such changes can influence precipitation. Recent studies used hydrological and atmospheric models to estimate the contribution of tree transpiration to precipitation but assumed that precipitation decreases proportionally to the transpired portion of atmospheric moisture. Here, we relaxed this assumption by, first, relating observed hourly precipitation levels to atmospheric column water vapor in a relatively flat study area encompassing a large part of the Amazon. We found that the effect of column water vapor on hourly precipitation was strongly nonlinear, showing a steep increase in precipitation above a column water vapor content of around 60 mm. Next, we used published atmospheric trajectories of moisture from tree transpiration across the whole Amazon to estimate the transpiration component in column water vapor in our study area. Finally, we estimated precipitation reductions for column water vapor levels without this transpired moisture, given the nonlinear relationship we found. Although loss of tree transpiration from the Amazon causes a 13% drop in column water vapor, we found that it could result in a 55%–70% decrease in precipitation annually. Consequences of this nonlinearity might be twofold: although the effects of deforestation may be underestimated, it also implies that forest restoration may be more effective for precipitation enhancement than previously assumed.

    How to cite: Baudena, M., Tuinenburg, O. A., Ferdinand, P. A., and Staal, A.: Effects of land-use change in the Amazon on precipitation are likely underestimated, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5410, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5410, 2022.

    EGU22-6246 | Presentations | HS7.9

    Use of Isotopes in Examining Precipitation Patterns in North-Central Ukraine 

    Elizabeth Avery, Olena Samonina, Lidiia Kryshtop, Iryna Vyshenska, Alan E. Fryar, and Andrea M. Erhardt

    North-central Ukraine is vulnerable to temperature increases and precipitation pattern changes associated with climate change. With water management becoming increasingly important, information on current water sources and moisture recycling is critically needed. Isotope ratios of oxygen (δ18O) and hydrogen (δ2H) in precipitation are sensitive to these variables and allow comparisons across the region. For this study, precipitation was collected over a period of one year from Kyiv and Cherkasy and local meteoric water lines were created for both cities. The δ2H and δ18O values from collected precipitation and published 3H data for Kyiv from the year 2000 show an influence of the North Atlantic Oscillation (NAO) and provide information about processes affecting precipitation along the storm trajectory. The δ18O values also show correlation with temperature, indicating that precipitation patterns may be affected by the rising temperatures in the region, as predicted by recent regional studies using Representative Concentration Pathway scenarios and the global climate model GFDL-ESM2M. When compared to backtracked storm trajectory data, clear relationships emerged between water isotope ratios, storm paths, and likely moisture recycling. These results show that when isotopic data are used with backtracked storm trajectories and NAO cycles, a more complete idea of regional processes can be formed, including addition of water vapor from more localized sources. Overall, δ2H, δ18O, 3H, and backtracked storm trajectory data provide more regional and local information on water vapor processes, improving climate-change-driven precipitation forecasts in Ukraine.

    How to cite: Avery, E., Samonina, O., Kryshtop, L., Vyshenska, I., Fryar, A. E., and Erhardt, A. M.: Use of Isotopes in Examining Precipitation Patterns in North-Central Ukraine, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6246, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6246, 2022.

    Central Asia is a semiarid to arid region that is sensitive to hydrological changes. We use the Community Atmosphere Model, version 5 (CAM5), equipped with a water-tagging capability, to investigate the major moisture sources for climatological precipitation and its long-term trends over central Asia. Europe, the North Atlantic Ocean, and local evaporation, which explain 33.2% ± 1.5%, 23.0% ± 2.5%, and 19.4% ± 2.2% of the precipitation, respectively, are identified as the most dominant moisture sources for northern central Asia (NCA). For precipitation over southern central Asia (SCA), Europe, the North Atlantic, and local evaporation contribute 25.4% ± 2.7%, 18.0% ± 1.7%, and 14.7% ± 1.9%, respectively. In addition, the contributions of South Asia (8.6% ± 1.7%) and the Indian Ocean (9.5% ± 2.0%) are also substantial for SCA. Modulated by the seasonal meridional shift in the subtropical westerly jet, moisture originating from the low and midlatitudes is important in winter, spring, and autumn, whereas northern Europe contributes more to summer precipitation. We also explain the observed drying trends over southeastern central Asia in spring and over NCA in summer during 1956–2005. The drying trend over southeastern central Asia in spring is mainly due to the decrease in local evaporation and weakened moisture fluxes from the Arabian Peninsula and Arabian Sea associated with the warming of the western Pacific Ocean. The drying trend over NCA in summer can be attributed to a decrease in local evaporation and reduced moisture from northern Europe that is due to the southward shift of the subtropical westerly jet.

    How to cite: Jiang, J.: Tracking moisture sources of precipitation over Central Asia: A study based on the water-source-tagging method, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6735, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6735, 2022.

    EGU22-6751 | Presentations | HS7.9

    Observational constraints on the uncertainties of the future precipitation change projections 

    Hideo Shiogama, Masahiro Watanabe, Hyungjun Kim, and Nagio Hirota

    Future projections of global mean precipitation change (ΔP) based on Earth system models have larger uncertainties than those of global mean temperature changes (ΔT). While many observational constraints on ΔT have been proposed, constraints on ΔP have not been well studied and are often complicated by the large influence of aerosols on precipitation. By analyzing the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project Phase 5 and 6 ensembles, we show that the upper bound (95th percentile) of ΔP (2051-2100 minus 1851-1900, % of the 1980-2014 mean) can be lowered from 6.2% to 5.2-5.7% (min-max range of sensitivity analyses) under a medium greenhouse gas concentration scenario. ΔP for 2051-2100 is well correlated with the global mean temperature trends during recent decades after 1980 when global anthropogenic aerosol emissions were nearly constant. ΔP is also significantly correlated with the recent past trends of precipitation when we exclude some tropical land areas with few rain gauge observations. Based on these significant correlations and observed trends, the variance of ΔP can be reduced by 8-30%. The observationally constrained ranges of ΔP should provide further reliable information for impact assessments.

    How to cite: Shiogama, H., Watanabe, M., Kim, H., and Hirota, N.: Observational constraints on the uncertainties of the future precipitation change projections, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6751, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6751, 2022.

    EGU22-7400 | Presentations | HS7.9

    Land use options for Viticulture in Portugal in light of bioclimatic shifts 

    Cristina Andrade, André Fonseca, and João A. Santos

    Climate and land are closely intertwined through multiple interface processes. On one hand, land endows means for agriculture practices and agroforestry systems thus contributing to the food and materials supply; on the other, climate change may lead to significant impacts in land use and efficient water availability and management. Therefore, the study of these interactions and the impact of the bioclimatic shifts, since land use, plays a relevant role in the climatic system is highly relevant.

    Towards this aim, in this study, 1‒km observational gridded datasets are used to assess changes in the Köppen–Geiger and Worldwide Bioclimatic (WBCS) Classification Systems in mainland Portugal. As such, two past periods were analyzed: 1950–1979 and 1990–2019. A compound bioclimatic-shift exposure index (BSEI) is defined to identify the most exposed regions to recent climatic changes. The temporal evolution of land cover with vineyards between 1990 and 2018, as well as correlations with areas with bioclimatic shifts, are then analyzed.

    Results show significant climatic changes between the two periods with an increase of 18.1% in the Warm Mediterranean with hot summer (CSa) climate in Portugal. This increase was followed by a 17.8% decrease in the Warm Mediterranean with warm summer (CSb) climate. Furthermore, the WBCS Temperate areas also reveal a decrease of 5.11%. Arid and semi-arid ombrotypes areas increased, whilst humid to sub-humid ombrotypes decreased. Thermotypic horizons depict a shift towards warmer classes. BSEI highlights the most significant shifts in northwestern Portugal.

    Overall results show that vineyards have been displaced towards regions that are either the coolest/humid, in the northwest, or the warmest/driest, in the south. Since vineyards in southern Portugal are commonly irrigated, options for the intensification of these crops in this region may threaten the already scarce water resources and challenge the future sustainability of this sector. As similar problems can be found in other regions with Mediterranean-type climates, the main findings of this study can be easily extrapolated to other wine producer countries worldwide.

    Acknowledgement: This work was supported by National Funds by FCT - Portuguese Foundation for Science and Technology, under the project UIDB/04033/2020.

    Keywords: Köppen-Geiger Climate Classification, Worldwide Bioclimatic Classification System (WBCS), Vineyards, Portugal.

    How to cite: Andrade, C., Fonseca, A., and A. Santos, J.: Land use options for Viticulture in Portugal in light of bioclimatic shifts, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7400, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7400, 2022.

    Mediterranean climates experience important climatic variability often causing droughts, whose consequences are especially worrisome in highly human-altered basins such as the Ebro Basin. An accurate understanding of the governing interactions of the water cycle is crucial in this area, which is a basin representative of water-related issues of the Mediterranean area. The HUMID project (CGL2017-85687-R) studies how remote sensing data and models (Quintana-Seguí et al., 2019; Barella-Ortiz and Quintana-Seguí, 2019) can improve our understanding of the alterations of rainfall-evapotranspiration-soil moisture interactions, which is essential to characterize the water cycle in drought-prone regions. Climates in these areas are driven by radiative factors while controlled by water-related ones, but the dominance of certain feedbacks such as the one of evapotranspiration-rainfall can locally modify the water balance and interactions.

    Within the complex climatic mosaic of the Ebro basin, there are areas with interesting high levels of local water recycling due to storm tracks of relevance at Iberian and even European scale. However, other areas of the basin barely show any moisture recycling. Since recycling suggests enhanced interaction between evapotranspiration and rainfall, this study explores the differences in the magnitude of rainfall anomalies with evapotranspiration and soil moisture anomalies between areas with low and high recycling. The comparison of the dominance of evapotranspiration-rainfall interaction over the other interactions of the water cycle is evaluated over areas of storm tracks compared to those barely affected by recycling. The comparison is conducted over three climatic types of the Köppen-Geiger classification: BSk, Cfa and Cfb in order to distinguish the relevance of recycling, mostly of local scale, in comparison to the climatic type, influential at the synoptic scale.

    High-resolution remote sensing products such as SMOS 1km and MODIS16 A2 ET enable evaluating rainfall, evapotranspiration and soil moisture anomalies with a level of detail suitable for local-scale analysis. Standardized drought indices such as soil moisture deficit index (SMDI) or the evapotranspiration deficit index (ETDI) can be calculated based on SMOS 1km data (2010-2019) and MODIS16 A2 ET 500m. The SPI index is used for rainfall anomalies. To assess the impact of recycling on the rainfall-evapotranspiration and soil moisture interactions we compare the distribution and magnitude of lags between these three variable-specific drought indices at the contrasting regions. The method allows identifying differences in the distribution of lags between the SPI, ETDI and SMDI that differ depending on the vicinity to the storm track. The type of climate shows certain interaction with the effects of local recycling.

    The study illustrates the worth of high-resolution remote sensing data to evaluate recycling mechanisms and the anomalies of the land-atmosphere system propagating drought across feedbacks, even at the local scale. This advantage facilitates a better understanding of the climatic variability in semi-arid Mediterranean climates while encouraging developing monitoring tools integrating the particularities of water-limited types of climate.

    How to cite: Gaona, J. and Quintana-Seguí, P.: Local recycling alters the balance of interactions between rainfall, evapotranspiration and soil moisture in the semi-arid Ebro basin., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7782, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7782, 2022.

    EGU22-9371 | Presentations | HS7.9 | Highlight

    Investigating impacts of large-scale vegetation restoration on water recycling processes in the agro-pastoral ecotone of Northern China 

    Xuejin Wang, Baoqing Zhang, Zhenyu Zhang, Harald Kunstmann, and Chansheng He

    From 1998 until now, the Chinese government has implemented numerous policies and programs, such as the Grain for Green Program, the Three-North Shelter Forest Program, and the Beijing-Tianjin Sand Control Program, to restore ecosystems and to improve environmental protection in the agro-pastoral ecotone of Northern China (APENC). However, it remains unclear how the large-scale vegetation restoration modulates the regional moisture cycle in the APENC. To fill this gap, we investigated the variations of observed precipitation and estimated evapotranspiration from 1995 to 2015. The evapotranspiration is estimated by the Priestley-Taylor Jet Propulsion Laboratory model with dynamic vegetation (DV). The precipitation recycling ratio calculated by the Dynamic Recycling Model is used to analyze the impacts of vegetation restoration on regional moisture recycling. Our results show that the precipitation and ET under the DV were significantly increased during the period of 1995-2015, with the increasing rate of 4.42 mm yr-1 and 2.13 mm yr-1, respectively. The precipitation recycling ratio was also significantly increased during the study period, showing positive feedback of vegetation restoration on precipitation. The atmospheric water budget analysis shows that vegetation restoration noticeably modifies the annual mean values of water transport terms in the regional water cycle, indicating an indirect effect on local precipitation. Our findings help better understand the impacts of land cover change on local water resources, which in turn supports local water resource management and decision making.

    How to cite: Wang, X., Zhang, B., Zhang, Z., Kunstmann, H., and He, C.: Investigating impacts of large-scale vegetation restoration on water recycling processes in the agro-pastoral ecotone of Northern China, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9371, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9371, 2022.

    EGU22-10113 | Presentations | HS7.9

    Ground Water Effects on Soil Moisture and Regional Climate using WRF-NoahMP Model Over Ganga Basin, India 

    Vinayak Huggannavar and Indu Jayaluxmi

    Soil moisture plays a crucial role in partitioning surface fluxes. Several studies in past have highlighted the role of soil moisture in Land-Atmosphere (L-A) interactions. Understanding such interactions through regional climate models helps improve the simulation of global and regional hydrological processes. On the contrary, shallow subsurface groundwater also affects soil moisture variations. This calls for an accurate representation of physical processes involved in soil moisture interactions with groundwater. In addition, Shallow groundwater is known to act as a source and sink to the overlying soil layer during dry and wet seasons respectively. In this study, we analyze the impact of two different groundwater models in the Weather Research and Forecast (WRF) model coupled with the Noah-MP land surface model over the Ganga basin, India. Two experiments were carried out, one with the default-free drainage approach (CTL) and another with Miguez-Macho groundwater model (GW). The period of study was between 2008-2014. Preliminary analysis revealed that GW simulations improved soil moisture for the top and bottom-most soil layers. Reduction in temporal dry bias by around 91mm was observed for precipitation during the monsoon season. Dry bias in latent heat flux over the region also improved by 28 W/m2. GW run improved soil moisture and precipitation representation compared to CTL run. In summary, our results advocate the need for a better representation of groundwater within coupled regional climate models for improved simulation of hydrological processes

    How to cite: Huggannavar, V. and Jayaluxmi, I.: Ground Water Effects on Soil Moisture and Regional Climate using WRF-NoahMP Model Over Ganga Basin, India, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10113, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10113, 2022.

    EGU22-12711 | Presentations | HS7.9 | Highlight

    Vegetation fueled summer 2021 floods in Germany and Belgium 

    Damián Insua Costa, Martín Senande Rivera, Gonzalo Miguez Macho, and María del Carmen Llasat Botija

    Plants play a key role in the hydrological cycle, yet their contribution to extreme rainfall remains uncertain. Here we show that more than half of the vast amounts of water accumulated in the recent Germany and Belgium floods were supplied by vegetation (41% from transpiration, 11% from interception loss). We found that intercontinental transport of moisture from North American forests (which contributed more than 463 billion liters of water to the event) was a more important source than evaporation over nearby seas, such as the Mediterranean or the North Sea. Our results demonstrate that summer rainfall extremes in Europe may be strongly dependent on plant behavior and suggest that significant alterations in vegetation cover, even of remote regions, could have a direct effect on these potentially catastrophic events.

    How to cite: Insua Costa, D., Senande Rivera, M., Miguez Macho, G., and Llasat Botija, M. C.: Vegetation fueled summer 2021 floods in Germany and Belgium, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12711, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12711, 2022.

    EGU22-12789 | Presentations | HS7.9

    The impact of different land use change scenarios on precipitation in a semiarid Mediterranean area in Southeastern Spain 

    Hassane Moutahir, Pau Beneto, Joel Arnault, Zhenyu Zhang, Patrick Laux, Samira Khodayar, and Harald Kunstmann

    Land use changes are the major anthropogenic alterations which are considered to have an important impact on the climate system. In semiarid regions such as the the Southeastern Spain where water is the major limiting factor for ecosystems functioning and human development, knowledge about future water availability is of high importance above all in the context of climate change. To better understand the potential impact of land use change on the regional climate, we used the Weather Research and Forecasting (WRF) model to simulate the impact of different land use scenarios on precipitation in the Jucar Basin in Southeastern Spain. We conducted three different scenarios: (1) increasing the tree cover areas, (2) removing the tree cover and increasing the shrubland areas, and (3) increasing the urban areas in the coastal areas. Preliminary results show that increasing the tree cover areas will likely increase the annual precipitation (approximately +3%) in the region, and mostly affecting the autumn period (+8%) with respect to the actual land use scenario. Removing the tree cover and increasing the urban areas resulted in reduced precipitation above all during the spring season (-3%).

    How to cite: Moutahir, H., Beneto, P., Arnault, J., Zhang, Z., Laux, P., Khodayar, S., and Kunstmann, H.: The impact of different land use change scenarios on precipitation in a semiarid Mediterranean area in Southeastern Spain, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12789, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12789, 2022.

    HS8.1 – Subsurface hydrology – General sessions

    EGU22-1129 | Presentations | HS8.1.1

    Stochastic modeling of the multimodal behavior of spatially heterogeneous calcite dissolution rate at the nanoscale 

    Chiara Recalcati, Martina Siena, Monica Riva, and Alberto Guadagnini

    Mineral dissolution/precipitation reactions are critical in several contexts (e.g., geologic sequestration of CO2 or reservoir hydraulic fracturing). High-resolution imaging techniques such as Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM) allow direct observation of the (nanometer-scale) evolution of the crystal topography during the reaction, thus enhancing our knowledge on the various dissolution mechanisms occurring at the liquid-solid interface. These mechanisms are imprinted onto the highly heterogeneous patterns observed and are originated from the presence of inhomogeneities and defects in the mineral lattice, resulting in a broad range of local reaction rate values. We rely on a multimodal Gaussian model to capture the spatial heterogeneity of dissolution rates from AFM (in-situ and in real time) topography measurements collected on calcite samples subject to dissolution at far from equilibrium conditions. We resort to an imaging segmentation technique to cluster reaction rate data into regions associated with diverse dissolution mechanisms and relate each region to a component of the Gaussian mixture. We analyze the temporal trend of model parameters to provide quantitative insights on the dynamic evolution of the spatial heterogeneity of dissolution rate.

    How to cite: Recalcati, C., Siena, M., Riva, M., and Guadagnini, A.: Stochastic modeling of the multimodal behavior of spatially heterogeneous calcite dissolution rate at the nanoscale, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1129, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1129, 2022.

    EGU22-2140 | Presentations | HS8.1.1

    Quantification of Predictive Uncertainty for Reversible Degradation of Diclofenac under Biotic, Denitrifying Redox Conditions 

    Laura Ceresa, Alberto Guadagnini, Giovanni Porta, Monica Riva, Xavier Sánchez-Vila, and Paula Rodriguez-Escales

    Drinking water resources and the associated delicate aquatic ecosystem are threatened by several contaminants. Diclofenac poses major concerns due to its persistent nature and frequent detection in groundwater. Despite some evidences of its biodegradability under reducing conditions, Diclofenac attenuation is often interpreted through geochemical models which are too simplified, thus potentially biasing the extent of its degradation. In this context, we suggest a modeling framework based on the conceptualization of the molecular mechanisms of Diclofenac biodegradation which we then embed in a stochastic context. The latter enables one to quantify predictive uncertainty. Biotic and denitrifying reference conditions are taken from a set of available batch experiments that evidence the occurrence of a reversible degradation pathway. Our model is subject to stochastic calibration through Acceptance-Rejection Sampling. The associated results fully embed uncertainty quantification and support the recalcitrance of Diclofenac in groundwater. Our results show that data scarcity and/or redundant model parametrization seem to deteriorate the quality of some parameter estimates, a feature that appears to be associated with the degree of information contained in the available dataset, which is addressed towards specific model processes. We then address the issue by reducing the complexity of the model and embed the resulting formulations within a multi-model context. The resulting models are calibrated through a Maximum Likelihood approach assisted by modern sensitivity analyses techniques, the performance of each candidate model being then assessed (in a relative sense) through classic model identification criteria. Our results suggest that an optimal trade-off in terms of model complexity (i.e., level of parametrization) given data availability can be assessed to satisfactorily interpret the system dynamics.

    How to cite: Ceresa, L., Guadagnini, A., Porta, G., Riva, M., Sánchez-Vila, X., and Rodriguez-Escales, P.: Quantification of Predictive Uncertainty for Reversible Degradation of Diclofenac under Biotic, Denitrifying Redox Conditions, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2140, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2140, 2022.

    EGU22-2288 | Presentations | HS8.1.1 | Highlight

    3D geological modelling of fluvio-glacial aquifers to improve water work operations 

    Johannes Ehrendorfer, Miguel Anchel Marazuela, Klaus Erlmeier, Giovanni Formentin, Georg Seidl, and Thilo Hofmann

    Fluvio-glacial aquifers in subalpine quaternary basins are global sources of drinking water.
    Water works need to consider the geological framework of such aquifers to optimize 
    groundwater management. This can be achieved by developing 3D geological models, which 
    act as powerful tools for aquifer visualization and estimation of hydraulic properties. In recent 
    years 3D geological modeling has emerged as an asset to sustainable groundwater management. 
    However, the implementation of such models is no trivial task and requires expert geological 
    knowledge. In this study a 3D geological model is developed for a subalpine quaternary basin,
    that provides drinking water to a major city. The relationship between aquifer geometry and 
    heterogeneity, preferential flow paths, and observed hydraulic and hydrochemical trends is
    investigated. A database consisting of around 300 bore logs as well as geophysical, hydraulic
    and hydrochemical data provides the foundation for the 3D geological model. The software 
    package Leapfrog Works is employed to create the model. The resulting model depicts the 
    complexity of the fluvio-glacial stratigraphy and the hydrogeological units of the study area 
    and demonstrates the retarding effect that glacial terraces can have on flood wave propagation 
    in aquifers. It allows the assessment of total groundwater volume and areas of low hydraulic 
    conductivity. Our understanding of aquifer interconnectivity and constraints imposed on 
    groundwater flow in fluvio-glacial quaternary sediment basins is improved. As such, 
    recommendations for future groundwater explorations in subalpine basins are provided.

    How to cite: Ehrendorfer, J., Marazuela, M. A., Erlmeier, K., Formentin, G., Seidl, G., and Hofmann, T.: 3D geological modelling of fluvio-glacial aquifers to improve water work operations, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2288, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2288, 2022.

    Multiphase fluid flow and multicomponent transport in porous media are often controlled by thermodynamic phase change dynamics. In a nanometer-scale pore space, the phase behavior of a multicomponent fluid deviates from that in a larger pore space (i.e., micrometer or greater)—the pressure and temperature at which the fluid begins to evaporate or condensate in nanopores can significantly differ from those in large pores. This pore size-dependent phase change behavior is further complicated in natural nanoporous media (e.g., clay soil or shale rock) that often contain a significant fraction of interconnected pores spanning from nanometers to micrometers. While the nanoconfined phase behavior in a single nanopore has been extensively studied by molecular-level theories, the new molecular-level understanding has not yet been incorporated in Darcy-scale continuum models.

    We address this challenge of scale translation by developing a new pore-network-scale modeling framework for flow, transport, and thermodynamics in nanoporous media. The new modeling framework is comprised of 1) a phase-equilibrium model that accounts for the pore-size and -geometry dependent nanoconfinement effects and 2) a fully implicit dynamic pore-network model framework coupling the individual-pore nanoconfined phase-equilibrium model with the two-phase compositional flow. This framework for the first time allows us to investigate the interactions between compositional flow dynamics and nanoconfined phase behaviors at an REV-scale, which we will illustrate by a series of numerical experiments on complex networks with pores varying in size, geometry, and wettability.

    How to cite: Chen, S., Jiang, J., and Guo, B.: Compositional two-phase flow and phase behavior in nanoporous media: pore-level physics, pore-network modeling, and upscaling, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7058, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7058, 2022.

    EGU22-7266 | Presentations | HS8.1.1 | Highlight

    A comparison study of process complexity in permafrost dominated regions 

    Radhakrishna Bangalore Lakshmiprasad, Thomas Graf, Fan Zhang, Xiong Xiao, and Ethan T Coon

    The Qinghai-Tibet Plateau (QTP), also known as the “Water tower of Asia”, is threatened by climate warming. Climate warming leads to permafrost degradation, which in turn affects the natural and man-made environment. Permafrost is defined as ground where temperatures remain at or below 0°C for a minimum period of two consecutive years. Near-surface atmospheric processes give rise to seasonal thawing and freezing of permafrost. The thawing promotes groundwater movement because of the increase in liquid water content and hydraulic conductivity. The pore water phase change from ice to liquid also causes variation in the thermal parameters of the soil leading to non-linear coupled processes. Therefore, complex interactions exist between hydraulic and thermal surface and subsurface processes.

    Numerical models are useful tools to study coupled processes. Model complexity arises as several physical processes need to be considered, especially due to the presence of permafrost. The amount of input data, parameters, boundary conditions and hence the difficulty increases as the number of physical processes increases. The main aim of this research work is to therefore conduct a comparison study of three modelling scenarios: (i) Coupled subsurface flow and energy transport with ice content, (ii) including coupled surface flow and surface energy balance to scenario (i), (iii) including snow component to scenario (ii). The Advanced Terrestrial Simulator (ATS) and Parameter ESTimation (PEST) codes were applied for simulation and calibration, respectively. The near-surface temperature and moisture measurements from a meteorological station at QTP were used for calibration. Results show that all three models have good agreement with the measurement dataset, however scenario (i) exhibited the best performance in terms of both matching the measured data and representative literature parameter values. Future work will focus on predicting permafrost behavior under various climate change scenarios.

    How to cite: Bangalore Lakshmiprasad, R., Graf, T., Zhang, F., Xiao, X., and Coon, E. T.: A comparison study of process complexity in permafrost dominated regions, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7266, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7266, 2022.

    EGU22-7279 | Presentations | HS8.1.1 | Highlight

    Determination of the vertical distribution of hydraulic parameters using gadolinium as an anthropogenic tracer and inverse modelling 

    Klaus Erlmeier, Miguel Angel Marazuela, Giovanni Formentin, Robert Bruenjes, and Thilo Hofmann

    Bank filtration is widely used for drinking water production around the world. Due to the general composition of river water and the possibility of direct anthropogenic inputs, it is of great importance to understand the interaction between river and groundwater as well as the subsurface flow conditions. These can alter with increased runoff during flood events. Higher gradients between the surface water and groundwater, enlarged infiltration zones or the removal of colmation layers can lead to elevated infiltration rates and thus to changes in the river aquifer system. Due to often high hydraulic permeabilities and the potential spatial proximity between the river and the extraction system, short dwell times may therefore occur. Additionally, associated with stormwater runoff of wastewater treatment plants, higher contamination risks can therefore be expected in the extraction system during flood events.

    In our investigations, we use a regional three-dimensional numerical groundwater model to help prevent changes in the quality of the extracted water through optimized operational management. However, the need to predict the flow paths between the river and the water work with maximum precision makes it necessary to complement the regional model with high resolution local models. To better capture vertical heterogeneities constraining local flow paths, a two-dimensional vertical model following the direction of maximum contribution of bank filtration to the water work was additionally created using FEFLOW 7.5 (DHI). Along this transect, the X-ray contrast agent gadolinium was sampled for use as a conservative anthropogenic tracer at different depths.

    The sampling of gadolinium every 12 hours during a minor flood event showed a weekly, wastewater-influenced signal in the surface water, which could also be followed in the transect. This signal, together with 222Rn tracer ages, complements the time-resolved observations of groundwater levels to calibrate the vertical distribution of hydraulic parameters of the two-dimensional mass transport model. These are supposed to improve the conceptual regional model to ultimately optimize the operation of the waterworks and allow the extraction of the groundwater with the best possible quality.

    How to cite: Erlmeier, K., Marazuela, M. A., Formentin, G., Bruenjes, R., and Hofmann, T.: Determination of the vertical distribution of hydraulic parameters using gadolinium as an anthropogenic tracer and inverse modelling, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7279, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7279, 2022.

    EGU22-8053 | Presentations | HS8.1.1

    Sub-rock typing and its influence on pore-scale, image-based simulations of multiphase flow in complex geological rocks 

    Shan Wang, Leonardo C. Ruspini, Pål-Eric Øren, Stefanie Van Offenwert, and Tom Bultreys

    Image-based pore-scale modeling is an important method to study multiphase flow in permeable rocks. However, many rocks have pore size distribution that are so wide that they cannot be resolved in a single pore-space image. The accurate identification and characterization of this sub-resolution porosity have received extensive attention, due to its crucial impact on porosity and permeability estimation. To date, several modeling methods incorporate this information to improve the simulation of multiphase flow in complex rocks. The challenge is that the microporosity’s flow properties are difficult to characterize in images, and to include in models, of representative volumes. In this study, a novel sub-rock typing method was proposed to better characterize and classify microporous regions in rock samples, and to reduce the uncertainty of image-based pore-scale modeling of such samples. To this end, we performed capillary drainage experiments with brine and decane on two water-wet rock samples (Estaillades limestone and Luxembourg sandstone). Laboratory-based Micro-CT was used to image intricate pore structures and fluid occupancy changes at controlled capillary pressure steps during drainage. We proposed a novel workflow to generate 3D, micrometer-scale capillary pressure maps, which we combined with porosity maps to classify zones of microporosity types (sub-rock types). This was used to extract multi-scale pore network models and perform multiphase flow simulations. We found that the new approach yielded a good match with macroscopic experimental measurements, and significantly improved the prediction accuracy of the fluid distributions on a pore-by-pore basis. The results illustrate the importance of characterizing microporosity for simulations in heterogeneous rocks. The workflow can be applied to other complex geological porous rocks to improve modeling and simulation of subsurface multiphase flow.

    How to cite: Wang, S., Ruspini, L. C., Øren, P.-E., Van Offenwert, S., and Bultreys, T.: Sub-rock typing and its influence on pore-scale, image-based simulations of multiphase flow in complex geological rocks, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8053, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8053, 2022.

    EGU22-8059 | Presentations | HS8.1.1

    Modeling of Reactive Transport in Porous Rock: Influence of Peclet Number 

    Evgeny Shavelzon and Yaniv Edery

    Dissolution and precipitation processes in reactive transport in porous rocks play an important role in many contexts, such as geological CO2 storage, reactive contaminant transport, and acid injection in petroleum reservoirs. They are responsible for wormholing and alteration of the rock and transport characteristics due to feedback between the geochemical and the transport processes. A critical aspect of studying reactive transport is the influence of Peclet number on a coupled reactive process, which aims to understand the contributions of advection and diffusion as the two main transport mechanisms.

    Our study investigates the influence of Peclet number on dissolution and precipitation processes in a porous calcite matrix due to reaction with the incoming low-pH flow using a particle tracking (Lagrangian) approach. The coupled reactive process is simulated in a series of computational analyses that capture the subtleties of the multiple scale heterogeneity phenomena, such as anomalous (non-Fickian) transport.

    Our results show that reaction is manifested most significantly for small Peclet numbers, thus signifying the importance of diffusion in mixing processes that facilitate the reaction and increase the heterogeneity of the porous media. The evolution of the field heterogeneity due to reaction follows a similar trait, which is indirectly supported by fractal dimension estimation. Related to the field heterogeneity is the Shannon entropy, which is considered as a measure of the self-organization of the flow.

    How to cite: Shavelzon, E. and Edery, Y.: Modeling of Reactive Transport in Porous Rock: Influence of Peclet Number, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8059, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8059, 2022.

    EGU22-8082 | Presentations | HS8.1.1

    An improved Local Grid-Refined Numerical Groundwater Model Based on the Vertex-centred Finite-Volume Method 

    Yingzhi Qian, Yan Zhu, and Alberto Guadagnini

    A variety of algorithms have been proposed to cope with issues associated with local refinements of numerical grids typically employed to cope with subsurface flow driven by sources acting on diverse scales (e.g., pumping wells, channels or ditches or abrupt changes in hydraulic conductivity distributions). In this context, here we focus on grid refinement associated with nonmatching grids, which still pose significant challenges in terms of accuracy. We propose a numerical modeling scheme based on a new algorithm that has an improved accuracy when compared against approaches that are typically used in conjunction with nonmatching grids. Our approach is based on the vertex-centred finite-volume method (VCFVM), the key feature of the algorithm resting on setting all unknowns on vertices of the mesh elements while the flux crossing a lateral surface of the control volume centred around a mesh vertex is expressed as a function of the hydraulic heads at the vertices of the element containing the lateral surface. A given row of the stiffness matrix of the system includes the entries associated with mass conservation formulated for the control volume associated with a corresponding grid node. Since the algorithm sets all unknowns on element vertices and a control volume can be defined for each vertex, our scheme readily embeds treatment of nonmatching grids in the presence of local grid refinement. Hydraulic heads evaluated through our algorithm are benchmarked against (a) results obtained from the widely used and tested MODFLOW and MODFLOW6 groundwater modeling suites in the presence of a variety of boundary conditions and considering high resolution matching (for MODFLOW) and nonmatching (for MODFLOW6) grids, and (b) a test analytical solution. Our results show that the average value of relative root mean square error (RRMSE) resulting from comparing our approach against the analytical solution and the MODFLOW simulations performed on the highly resolved grid (which we consider as reference) was always lower than 0.50%, thus imbuing us with confidence with respect to the accuracy of our proposed scheme. Additionally, while the requirement of CPU time associated with our algorithm is of the same order (on average) as the one associated with MODFLOW6 (benefits being noted mainly for settings involving flow in confined groundwater scenarios), our scheme is highly flexible in terms of spatial discretization and is characterized by higher accuracy for a given discretization.

    How to cite: Qian, Y., Zhu, Y., and Guadagnini, A.: An improved Local Grid-Refined Numerical Groundwater Model Based on the Vertex-centred Finite-Volume Method, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8082, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8082, 2022.

    Particle tracking is the most direct and a computationally efficient method to determine travel times and trajectories in subsurface flow modeling. Accurate and consistent particle tracking requires element-wise mass conservation and conforming velocity fields, which ensure continuity of the normal-flow component on element boundaries. These conditions are not met by standard finite-element-type methods. Despite this shortcoming, finite-element-type methods are often used in subsurface flow modeling because they continuously approximate the potential-head field and can easily handle unstructured grids and full material tensors. Acknowledging these advantages and the wide-spread use of finite-element-type models in subsurface flow simulations, we present a novel postprocessing technique that reconstructs a cell-centered finite-volume approximation from a finite-element-type primal solution of the variably-saturated subsurface flow equation to obtain conforming, mass-conservative fluxes. Using the resulting velocity fields, we derive a semi-analytical, parallelized particle tracking scheme applicable to triangular prisms, which leads to consistent and mass-conservative trajectories and associated travel times. Compared to other postprocessing schemes, our flux reconstruction is stable, robust, and fast as it only solves a linear elliptic problem on the order of the number of elements, whereas the original flow problem was transient and non-linear. The methods are implemented as postprocessing codes and linked to the finite-element-type code HydroGeoSphere, but could also be linked to any other software yielding a solution of variably saturated flow in porous media on triangular prisms. The postprocessing codes can handle catchment-scale models including heterogeneous materials, geometries, and boundary conditions, and facilitate to track a million particles through a catchment in just a few minutes on a Standard-PC in Matlab. The approach is described by Selzer et al. (2021).

    How to cite: Selzer, P., Allgeier, J., Therrien, R., and Cirpka, O. A.: Finite-Volume Flux Reconstruction and Semi-Analytical Particle Tracking for Finite-Element-Type Models of Variably Saturated Flow in Porous Media, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8636, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8636, 2022.

    The characterization of the inherent heterogeneity of aquifer systems on a regional scale represents one of the main challenges in the study of groundwater, especially when there are uncertainties associated with the scarcity of hydrogeological information (Maliva, 2016).

    Based on the implementation of a numerical hydrogeological model in a regional scale, the objective of this study was to characterize the most recent geological formations which have the greatest hydrogeological potential in the Middle Magdalena Valley (VMM) in Colombia. The VMM is bounded by the Eastern Cordillera of the Colombian Andes and the Bucaramanga-Santa Marta fault to the east and the San Lucas Mountain range and the Central Cordillera to the west. This is considered one of the main hydrogeological basins in the country, in which a high potential of hydrocarbon production from the exploitation of unconventional deposits has also been identified (Sarmiento et al., 2015; Londoño, 2019).  For these reasons, the groundwater management, based on the characterization of this hydro system, has a national interest.

    In this study the characterization of the heterogeneity was approached from the estimation of hydraulic parameters by solving the inverse problem by means of a hydrogeological model on a regional scale (Carrera et al., 2005; Zhou et al., 2014). For this, 153 pumping tests were carried out and interpreted, allowing to parameterize the model in seven iso-conductivity zones. Also 12,383 discrete static level data were measured and collected in 19 years -time window and they were used in the calibration process. Furthermore, three field campaigns for measuring in-situ parameters (electrical conductivity, pH, dissolved oxygen, and temperature) were performed they served to enhance the conceptual model.

    Based on this, variations in hydraulic conductivities were identified on a regional scale for each iso-conductivity zone, fluctuating by four (4) orders of magnitude. The main flow direction was in the south-north, parallel to the Andes cordillera and therefore to the Magdalena River, and with some minor local flows perpendicular to them, producing important outflows from the system in permanent lentic water bodies in the north. The results of the research are encouraging, but at a regional scale they still do not allow to have a high resolution of the heterogeneity of the hydro system models for decision making, so it is suggested to implement stochastic models at a regional scale and to construct multi-purpose groundwater monitoring networks in this basin.

    Acknowledgments
    The researcher thanks the MEGIA Research Project, Contingent Recovery Contract FP44842-157-2018 funded by Minciencias and the National Hydrocarbons Agency.

    How to cite: Lora, B., Silva, L., Castro, E., and Donado, L.: Characterization of spatial heterogeneity in sedimentary aquifer systems at regional scale by using hydrogeological modeling: A case study of the Middle Magdalena Valley basin - Colombia., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10680, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10680, 2022.

    EGU22-11193 | Presentations | HS8.1.1

    Visualization and quantification of single and multiphase flow in a rough fracture 

    Ping Wang, Yong Huang, Alberto Guadagnini, and Xiang Zhao

    Immiscible displacement of fluids across fractures with spatially variable aperture is key in several subsurface processes, including enhanced oil recovery and geological CO2 sequestration. We illustrate the results of an experimental investigation campaign focused on qualitative and quantitative assessment of main features associated with single and multiphase flow in a single fracture, including, e.g., an appraisal of the geometrical parameters of the fracture and the distribution and dynamic characteristics of fluids.
    Experiments are performed on fracture replicas reproduced from natural rock blocks, that are artificially split by steer wedges under normal load. Two fracture replicas are then considered, corresponding to (a) a sample molded with synthetic material after the rock sample and (b) the actual rock sample, respectively. This enables one to provide a first appraisal of the impact of the material constituting the wall of the fracture on the multiphase flow system behavior. A transparent upper wall is set in place to enable visualization.
    Surface profiles of the fracture are collected, comprising a set of more than 400,000 data of aperture distribution to create a digital twin of the system. These data are first subject to detailed statistical characterization, including standard geostatistical and fractal-based approaches. Experimental data of flow are quantitatively correlated to the key statistical features characterizing fracture geometry under various flow rates and normal loading conditions. Temporal monitoring of fluid saturation distribution enable us to provide a preliminary assessment of the impact of the material constituting the fracture wall (e.g., in terms of its wettability) on fluid saturation distribution.

    How to cite: Wang, P., Huang, Y., Guadagnini, A., and Zhao, X.: Visualization and quantification of single and multiphase flow in a rough fracture, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11193, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11193, 2022.

    Darcy scale transport in porous media ranges between Fickian and non-Fickian according to the medium conductivity layout, which ranges between homogenous and heterogeneous. Yet, evidence shows that preferential flows that funnel and bypass even areas with high conductivity occur in heterogeneous and homogenous cases. We model the Darcy scale transport using a 2D conductivity field ranging from homogenous to heterogeneous and find that these preferential flow bifurcate, leaving voids where particles do not invade while forming a tortuous path. The fraction of bifurcations decreases downflow and reaches an asymptotical value, which scales as a power-law with the heterogeneity level. We show that the same power-law scaling holds for the void fraction, tortuosity, and fractal dimension analysis. We conclude that the scaling with the heterogeneity is the dominant feature in the preferential flow geometry, which will lead to variations in weighting times for the transport and eventually to anomalous transport.

    How to cite: Edery, Y. and Dagan, A.: Bifurcating-Paths: the relation between preferential flow bifurcations, void, and tortuosity on the Darcy scale., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11340, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11340, 2022.

    EGU22-11821 | Presentations | HS8.1.1

    Modeling biodegradation and growth of microorganisms via particle tracking 

    Malik Dawi and Xavier Sanchez-Vila

    Biologically mediated degradation of organic compounds is heavily non-linear. When an organic compound is degraded part of the carbon is present in the form of metabolite while a fraction of it is used to increase the biomass, capable then to enhance the degradation process. The rate of biomass growth is usually modeled with the experimentally derived Monod equation, so that it is proportional to the actual existing biomass multiplied by a non-linear factor in terms of available organic matter. The non-linearity in the degradation equation implies a strong difficulty in directly implementing a numerical solution within a Lagrangian framework. Thus, numerical solutions have traditionally been sought in an Eulerian framework.

    Here we pursue a fully Lagrangian solution to the problem. First, the Monod empirical equation is derived from a two-step reaction ( B+C → k1 BC → k2 B +  ΔB + P); while the approach is less general to other derivations existing in the literature, it allows two things: (1) providing some physical meaning to the actual parameters in Monod equation, and more interestingly (2) formulate a methodology for the solution of the degradation equation incorporating Monod kinetics by means of a particle tracking formulation. For the latter purpose, reactants and biomass are represented by particles, and their location at any given time is represented by a kernel that includes the uncertainty in the actual physical location. By solving the reaction equation in a kernel framework, we can reproduce the Monod kinetics and, as a particular result in the case of no biomass growth is allowed, the Michaelis–Menten kinetics. We show how the method is successfully applied to reproduce two studies of microbially induced degradation. First, the observed kinetics of Pseudomonas putida F1 in batch reactors while growing on benzene, toluene and phenol, and second, the column study of carbon tetrachloride biodegradation by the denitrifying bacterium Pseudomonas Stutzeri KC.

     

    How to cite: Dawi, M. and Sanchez-Vila, X.: Modeling biodegradation and growth of microorganisms via particle tracking, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11821, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11821, 2022.

    EGU22-13055 | Presentations | HS8.1.1

    Chaotic mixing in laminar flows through rocks 

    Alexandre Puyguiraud, Tanguy Le Borgne, and Joris Heyman

    Recent studies have shown that chaotic advection is spontaneously produced by laminar flows through granular media such as bead packs, strongly impacting solute mixing rates. This has strong implications for many reactive and biological processes in the subsurface. Chaotic dynamics could also be key in a wide range of environmental and industrial applications driven by mixing. Beside granular media, there is still no evidence that chaos broadly arises in the large variety of porous architectures that exist. In particular, it is unknown how the pore structure and topology can control chaotic dynamics.
    In this study, we numerically investigate the mixing behavior of solute for a wide range of natural and engineered porous material that goes from carbonates and sandstones to beadpacks. We quantify chaotic advection by measuring Lagrangian stretching statistics (Lyapunov exponent) and its impact on mixing by estimating the decay of solute concentration variance. We find that stretching and mixing rates vary significantly between the different classes of porous architectures. A simple topological model is proposed to explain this behavior.

    How to cite: Puyguiraud, A., Le Borgne, T., and Heyman, J.: Chaotic mixing in laminar flows through rocks, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13055, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13055, 2022.

    EGU22-2112 | Presentations | HS8.1.2

    Effect of surfactant concentration on the decomposition rate of alkaline activated persulfate 

    Pejman Abolhosseini, Thomas Robert, Richard Martel, and Satinder Kaur Brar

    Hydrocarbon contamination is among the most frequent sources of soil and water environmental impacts. Many remediation methods have been implemented to clean up the contaminated environment so far. In-Situ Chemical Oxidation has attracted attention as it has shown efficiency in contaminants removal and cost-effectivity. In addition, soil washing by surfactant foam has been recently proven as a promising method. The combination of these two methods can take the advantage of oxidation while eliminating the challenges regarding the poor distribution of treatment fluid in a heterogeneous porous media. The ultimate goal of this study is to use surfactant foam for delivering oxidant (persulfate) through diesel-contaminated soil in permafrost. However, the interaction between the surfactant and the oxidant needs to be studied first. A better understanding of the impact of surfactants and oxidants on each other can lead to an optimized process. At the first stage of this study, different concentrations of surfactant solutions (sodium dodecyl sulfate: cocamidopropyl betaine in a mass ratio of 1:1) were mixed with a constant persulfate concentration activated with alkali, in absence of hydrocarbon. The preliminary results showed that the initial concentration of the oxidant has no significant effect on its decomposition rate. Also, as the concentration of surfactant was increased above the Critical Micellar Concentration (CMC), the persulfate decomposition rate decreased, likely due to the formation of micelles. However, as the micelles started to be destroyed, the decomposition rate of the oxidant increased gradually and the highest rate was observed when the concentration of surfactant was close to the CMC. When no micelle was left in the solution, the decomposition rate of the oxidant waned to a low value. Thus, coupling the surfactant and the oxidant can be effective for the degradation of hydrocarbon contaminants. Micelles bring part of the hydrocarbon into the aqueous phase and then the micelles are destroyed by the oxidant that can also degrade the hydrocarbon effectively over time.

    How to cite: Abolhosseini, P., Robert, T., Martel, R., and Kaur Brar, S.: Effect of surfactant concentration on the decomposition rate of alkaline activated persulfate, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2112, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2112, 2022.

    EGU22-2970 | Presentations | HS8.1.2

    Effect of CO2-rich water injection on the hydromechanical properties of Pont Du Gard limestone 

    Atefeh Vafaie, Jordi Cama, and Josep M Soler

    CO2 storage in deep geological formations (e.g., saline aquifers) is essential for global warming mitigation. Storage of large amounts of CO2 in the saline aquifers results in acidification of the resident brine, inducing chemical reactions that change the pore structure of the host rock. Hence, the hydromechanical properties of the host rock are likely to alter, which affects the long-term injectivity and mechanical integrity of the reservoir.

    To improve our understanding of the alteration of carbonate rocks after the injection of CO2, we have conducted percolation experiments under supercritical CO2 conditions. CO2-saturated water was injected at a constant rate of 0.15 mL/min through cylindrical core samples of Pont Du Gard limestone (diameter of 2.5 cm and length of ~5 cm) at 100 bar PCO2 and 60°C for 14 and 28 days. Fluid chemistry analyses were combined with X-ray microtomography imaging (XCMT) and porosity, permeability, and ultrasonic waves velocity (i.e., compressional and shear) measurements to assess the induced changes in rock properties.

    Measured chemical parameters of the effluent solutions revealed rapid calcite dissolution correlating with 4% and 9.6% porosity enhancements for the 14-day and 28-day injections, respectively. Porosity enhancement affected mostly the inlet of the cores. Permeability increased by three orders of magnitude in both cases (from 10-14 to 10-11 m2). XCMT images disclosed that the substantial increase in permeability coincides with the formation of large wormholes along the cores, likely controlled by their intrinsic heterogeneity. Ultrasonic waves velocity measurements under ambient conditions demonstrated that the observed alterations in the pore structures degrade the mechanical stiffness of the rock by up to 40%. Our findings provide insight into the key role of natural heterogeneity in the reactivity of the rock and in the resulting evolution of its hydromechanical properties during CO2 storage.

    How to cite: Vafaie, A., Cama, J., and M Soler, J.: Effect of CO2-rich water injection on the hydromechanical properties of Pont Du Gard limestone, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2970, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2970, 2022.

    EGU22-3303 | Presentations | HS8.1.2

    Evolution characteristics and model of nanosclae pores in organic-rich shale during thermal maturation 

    Liangwei Xu, Lei Chen, Keji Yang, and Hao Wei

             Shale is an unconventional and complex oil-bearing system with the trinity of source, reservoir and cap. The coupling evolution of thermal maturation hydrocarbon generation, diagenesis and nanoscale porosity is the key scientific problem affecting the accumulation and accumulation of shale gas. In this research, the low matured marine shale of Mesoproterozoic Xiamaling shale in Zhangjiakou, Hebei were selected to conduct the thermal simulation experiments, then the pyrolysis products at each temperature point were recovered and were subject to an ongoing multidisciplinary analytical program. The simulation experiment results show that, in the process of simulated temperature increasing, the maturity of the shale sample is risen generally. the role of hydrocarbon expulsion of the shale at the same time, also to form the inner groove and the shrinkage hole edge groove organic matter more, side by side out of a large number of organic acid, the acid fluid for inorganic pore formation and evolution of simulated sample plays an important role in promoting, It also affects the diagenetic evolution of mud shale. Along with the hydrocarbon generation and expulsion, shale also forms a large number of internal multi-pore and contractive margin pores, and expel a large number of organic acids. These acidic fluids play an important role in promoting the generation and evolution of inorganic pores in the simulated samples, and also affect the diagenetic evolution process of shale.

            The increased temperature accelerates the dissolution of unstable brittle minerals and produces dissolution pores, promotes the transformation of clay minerals, and accelerates the formation and development of clay mineral pores. The nanoscale pore diameter did not change significantly during the simulation process, while the pore volume decreased first and then increased, reaching the minimum and maximum values at 350°C and 650°C, respectively. The surface area of micropores and mesoporous pores firstly decreased and then increased, reaching the minimum value at 350°C, while the surface area of macropores firstly increased and then decreased, reaching the minimum value and maximum value at 350°C and 650°C, respectively(Figure 1).

    Figure 1. The pore volume and surface area variation characteristics of micropore (a,a'), mesopore(b, b'), macropore(c, c') during the increase of the thermal temperature.

             The diagenetic evolution during simulated temperature rise can be divided into four stages, and the main diagenetic types are dissolution, clay mineral transformation, thermal maturation hydrocarbon generation, compaction and recrystallization. In our research, the diagenetic evolution process and pore evolution model of shale were roughly divided, and the coupling evolution model of thermal mature hydrocarbon generation, diagenesis and pore structure of shale was established based on thermal simulation experiment (Figure 2).

    Figure 2. Comprehensive diagram of the diagenetic evolution sequence and pore evolution model based on the hydrous pyrolysis experiment

     

             The coupling evolution model  provides qualitative and quantitative characterization and evaluation methods for hydrocarbon generation, diagenesis and nanoscale pore structure evolution of organic-rich shale. 

     

    How to cite: Xu, L., Chen, L., Yang, K., and Wei, H.: Evolution characteristics and model of nanosclae pores in organic-rich shale during thermal maturation, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3303, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3303, 2022.

    EGU22-3823 | Presentations | HS8.1.2

    Mobility of Fluopyram in soils under saturated flow conditions 

    Mariana Vasconcelos Barroca and Gilboa Arye

    A new generation of non-fumigant nematicides has recently been introduced and is essential to enable efficient and sustainable agricultural production. Fluopyram (FL) is a new compound with a novel mode of action and an improved safety profile. The aim of this study was to quantify the adsorption and transport of FL in 3 soils with different texture under increasing water flows. Initially, equilibrium adsorption isotherms were measured by batch method. Then, FL transport characteristics were analyzed by flowthrough experiments under saturated flow conditions in soil columns. A pulse input of FL was given together with Bromide (Br), used as a conservative tracer. The flowthrough experiments were performed with 3 different soil types, loamy sand, loam and clay under 3 water flow rates, 0.3, 1 and 4 ml min-1, then analyzed and simulated with the convection–dispersion equation (CDE). Equilibrium and kinetic reaction terms were employed to consider sorption of FL. The adsorption isotherms of FL exhibited linear behavior for all soils, with distribution coefficient (Kd) varying from 0.72 to 1.87 L Kg-1 for loam and clay respectively. The established breakthrough curves (BTCs) obtained for bromide exhibited a symmetrical pattern, regardless of soil texture and flow rates, with an average of 100% of Br recovered, suggesting that physical equilibrium is prevailing in all columns. The FL BTCs exhibited sharp increase in concentration after pulse input and long tailing during leaching phase, not fully completed after leaching for 17 pore volumes (PV). The experimental mass balance demonstrated a maximum of 90% recovery on sandy soil and a minimum of 79% in clayey texture. This might indicate that FL has fast adsorption on soil and slow desorption kinetics or even some irreversible adsorption. To understand better the processes affecting FL transport in soils, two models of solute transport were used, a Two-sites sorption model (TSM) and Two-kinetic sites model. When irreversibility was assumed, both models underestimated the tailing of BTCs, trending the curve to zero; showing that instead of irreversible desorption, the long-term leaching behavior is due to a very slow desorption rate. All the models could describe well the adsorption process and confirmed that part of FL has quick adsorption in soil which is in agreement with the low mobility observed. Further evaluation on FL transport characteristics and the adequacy of the different numerical model will be discussed. 

    How to cite: Vasconcelos Barroca, M. and Arye, G.: Mobility of Fluopyram in soils under saturated flow conditions, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3823, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3823, 2022.

    EGU22-3964 | Presentations | HS8.1.2

    A pore-scale study of bacterial chemotaxis with segregated and controlled nutrient sources 

    Maximilian F. Stoll, Roman Stocker, and Joaquin Jimenez-Martinez

    Natural porous systems, like soils and aquifers, are physically and chemically highly heterogeneous. Microorganisms inhabiting these environments are therefore exposed to heterogeneous fluid flow velocities and nutrient landscapes. Bacteria capable of biasing their motion to swim along chemical gradients – known as chemotaxis – profit from their ability to localize and navigate towards nutrient hot spots, such as soil aggregates or plant roots.
    We propose a novel experimental microfluidic platform to study chemotaxis at the pore-scale, allowing full optical access to the pore space and simultaneously enabling control over the spatio-temporal availability of nutrients. The microfluidic device contains hydrogel features, acting as nutrient hotspots, embedded in a porous medium, made out of transparent polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) pillars. Nutrients are transported by diffusion from the access channels through the hydrogel into the porous medium, where they are released. The generated nutrient gradients downstream of the hotspots under flow conditions drive the swimming of chemotactic bacteria.
    This approach enables the study of subsurface processes at the pore-scale under more realistic conditions, and shed new light onto the influence of physical and chemical heterogeneity on bacterial dispersion and residence time in the subsurface.

    Keywords: porous media, soil, chemotaxis, microfluidics, heterogeneity

    How to cite: Stoll, M. F., Stocker, R., and Jimenez-Martinez, J.: A pore-scale study of bacterial chemotaxis with segregated and controlled nutrient sources, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3964, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3964, 2022.

    EGU22-5191 | Presentations | HS8.1.2

    Effect of chaotic advection generated by oscillatory flow on mixing-induced precipitation 

    Guido Gonzalez-Subiabre, Daniel Fernàndez-Garcia, Michela Trabucchi, and Jesús Carrera

    Chaotic advection can be created by engineered sequence of extraction and injection of groundwater in aquifers and by creating an engineered oscillatory flow. It has been used in a wide range of applications, including enhancement of degradation during aquifer remediation, in-situ leaching of metals to enhance mining recovery, and dissipation of energy in geothermal systems. Most of these works are based on numerical simulations and little experimental evidence are reported in the literature. In this work, we analyze how an engineered oscillatory flow can favor mixing-induced precipitation, increasing the total amount and the extension of precipitation zone, with the objective to provide new corrective measures based on permeability reduction. For instance, one can isolate a target aquifer region hydraulically by creating an impervious barrier in the mixing zone. Laboratory experiments were used to study the effect of chaotic advection on mixing-induced precipitation. The experiments were performed in a transparent horizontal two-dimensional tank made of plexiglass filled with glass beads. In the experimental investigation, two different chemical solutions containing CaCl and NaCO3 were injected in separate inlet ports with different concentration. oscillatory flow was created by tuning the inflow rate, we analyze the effect of different injection rates on precipitation. As a result, a calcite precipitate layer with different width was formed between the individual solutions. Color tracer tests were injected before and after the experiment to visualize the impact of precipitation.

    How to cite: Gonzalez-Subiabre, G., Fernàndez-Garcia, D., Trabucchi, M., and Carrera, J.: Effect of chaotic advection generated by oscillatory flow on mixing-induced precipitation, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5191, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5191, 2022.

    EGU22-5286 | Presentations | HS8.1.2

    Effect of radial geometry on autocatalytic reaction-diffusion-advection fronts 

    Alessandro Comolli, Fabian Brau, and Anne De Wit

    The understanding of the dynamics of reaction diffusion (RD) fronts is crucial for a wide variety of applications in chemistry, biology, physics and ecology, and it is especially important for hydrogeological problems involving chemical reactions. Reactive transport in geological media is generally controlled by the interplay of physical and chemical processes, which can give rise to complex dynamics of the reaction front. An important subset of RD fronts is represented by autocatalytic fronts, for which it is well known that the coupling of diffusion and chemical processes gives rise to self-organization phenomena and pattern forming instabilities [1]. When the initial interface between the reactant and the catalyst is a straight line, the autocatalytic front behaves as a solitary wave, which means that the shape of the front remains unchanged as it travels towards the nonreacted species [2]. The coupling with uniform advection does not change the picture, provided that the system is described in the proper comoving reference frame.

    However, in this work we show that the geometrical properties of the injection source have a significant impact on the reaction front dynamics. Indeed, if the injection of one reactant into the other is performed radially at a constant flow rate, the pre-asymptotic dynamics of the front is strongly affected by the nonuniform velocity field. Moreover, although at long times the front still behaves as a solitary wave, the efficiency of the reaction is strongly increased in virtue of the increasing volume occupied by the radial front. We show how injecting a finite amount of reactant into the catalyst gives rise to collapsing fronts and we characterize their dynamics in terms of their position, width and the production rate. In contrast, when the reactant is injected into the catalyst at a constant flow rate, a stationary regime is reached where, unlike the case of solitary waves, the autocatalytic front does not move.      

     

    References:

    [1] I. R. Epstein and J. A. Pojman, An Introduction to Nonlinear Dynamics: Oscillations, Waves, Patterns, and Chaos (Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1998)

    [2] P. Gray, K. Showalter, and S. K. Scott, J. Chim. Phys. 84, 1329 (1987)

    How to cite: Comolli, A., Brau, F., and De Wit, A.: Effect of radial geometry on autocatalytic reaction-diffusion-advection fronts, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5286, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5286, 2022.

    EGU22-6000 | Presentations | HS8.1.2

    Forced air and water flow in porous media – Dynamics, Saturation degree, and phase distribution 

    Ilan Ben-Noah, Shmulik P. Friedman, Brian Berkowitz, Juan J. Hidalgo, and Marco Dentz

    Air saturation degree and flow pattern significantly affect physical, biological, and chemical processes in natural and industrial multiphase systems. However, despite long-standing and current research of multiphase flow, the predictive capabilities in conditions where unstable flow patterns prevail and their consequence on the phase distribution remain extremely limited.

    We demonstrate the strong coupling between flow dynamics and phase saturation by analyzing experimental data of steady air injection into background (initially) saturated granular media. Next, we evaluate, using image analysis of recent multiphase experiments in microfluidic devices, the decoupled effect of the saturation degree on the micro-scale distribution of the phases.

    We present a simple evaluation of the effects of the steady air flow velocity and of the media’s grain diameter on the macroscale air saturation degree. Using only two variables, one for the matrix (grain diameter) and one for the flow (air velocity), for estimating the air (and water) saturation degree seems to be an oversimplification, especially if one considers the complexity of the two-phase flow problem and the differences between flow patterns and geometries. Nevertheless, the suggested power-law model explains about 90% of the value of the phase saturation across a wide range of saturation degrees and different flow patterns and geometries. Moreover, analysis of this data set reveals a positive effect of both flow velocity and grain diameter on the air saturation degree. Using dimensional analysis, we conclude that viscous and buoyancy forces increase air saturation while capillary forces decrease the saturation degree. Our findings also suggest a significant effect of inertial forces on air saturation in coarse granular media (glass beads). The effect of phase saturation on the flow pattern is significant as deduced from the two extremum conditions of continuum air flow in dry media and predominant unstable flow in initially water-saturated media. However, the effects of the air saturation and flow dynamics cannot be easily evaluated as these are strongly correlated. Recent experimental studies of nearly simultaneous steady air and water injection into microfluidic devices allow a morphological analysis of the phase distribution (e.g., water-filled pore size distribution, coordination number distribution), decoupled from the flow dynamics, i.e., for different saturation degrees of the same capillary number and vice-versa.

    Quantifying the impact of macroscale phase saturation and flow dynamics on microscale phase distribution will enable a better prediction of the flow patterns (at the different scales), the local flow velocity distribution, and the effective hydraulic characteristics of the media. In this context, this work, for example, can refine Buckingham’s “law” for different capillary equilibrium conditions.

    How to cite: Ben-Noah, I., P. Friedman, S., Berkowitz, B., J. Hidalgo, J., and Dentz, M.: Forced air and water flow in porous media – Dynamics, Saturation degree, and phase distribution, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6000, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6000, 2022.

    The kinetic interface-sensitive (KIS) tracer, relying on a zero-order reaction on the fluid-fluid interface, is a newly developed method to measure the fluid-fluid interfacial area (FIFA) in drainage processes. The concentration of the reaction product, obtained by measuring the water samples after the breakthrough, is interpolated with numerical model to determine the FIFA. However, a major limitation of the previous method is that the volume of available water sample is highly dependent on the sand type and the system parameters, and the measurement is not applicable when the water sample is not sufficient. An alternative is to apply the KIS tracer in the “push-pull” test, meaning the drainage process is followed by an imbibition process with the flow direction reversed. This study applies the pore-scale numerical simulation and the column experiment to study the KIS tracer reactive transport during a push-pull test. The breakthrough curve of the product concentration is interpolated with both macro-scale numerical model and a modified analytical solution for the push-pull process. It is found the shapes of the concentration breakthrough curves from the pore-scale simulations and the column experiments are fit, showing a non-linear descending trend with respect to time. The KIS tracer reactive transport process in the push-pull test and the validation of the measured FIFA from the concentration breakthrough curve, are demonstrated based on the pore-scale simulation results. Finally, for the (n-octane/water) displacement process in the column packed with the glass beads with diameter of 240 μm (at the capillary number of 5×10-7), the FIFA is measured 210 m-1 at the water saturation of 0.33, which is consistent with some literature data.

     

    How to cite: Gao, H., Tatomir, A., Abdullah, H., and Sauter, M.: A push-pull kinetic interface-sensitive tracer method to quantify the fluid-fluid interfacial area in dynamic two-phase flow in porous media, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6606, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6606, 2022.

    EGU22-8398 | Presentations | HS8.1.2

    On the effect of probabilistic nucleation on the distribution of mineral precipitates in porous media 

    Mohammad Masoudi, Mohammad Nooraiepour, and Helge Hellevang

    The process of mineral precipitation and crystal growth begins with nucleation, which is usually overlooked in reactive transport simulators. Nucleation controls the location and timing of solid mineral formation in porous media. For an accurate prediction of the hydrodynamics of the porous medium after mineral precipitation, it is crucial to know the spatial distribution of stable secondary nuclei. We developed a novel probabilistic nucleation approach wherein induction time is treated as a random variable in order to better understand the nucleation process. The probabilistic induction time statistically spreads around the measured or reported induction time, either obtained from experiments or approximated by the exponential nucleation rate equation suggested by the classical nucleation theory (CNT). In this study, we used the classical nucleation theory. The location and time of nucleation are both probabilistic in our model, affecting transport properties at different time and length scales.

    We developed a pore-scale Lattice Boltzmann reactive transport model incorporated with the new probabilistic nucleation model to investigate the effect of nucleation rate and reaction rate on the extent, distribution, and precipitation pattern of the solid phases. The simulation domain is a 2D substrate with an infinite source of the supersaturated solution. We use Shannon entropy to measure the disorder of the spatial mineral distributions. The results of the simulations show that all the reactions follow similar random behavior with different Gauss-Laplace distributions. The simulation scenarios start from a fully ordered system with no solid precipitation on the substrate (entropy of 0). Entropy starts to increase as the secondary phase precipitates and grows on the surface until it reaches its maximum value (entropy of 1). Afterward, the overall disorder declines as more surface areas are being covered, and eventually, entropy approaches a constant value. The results indicate that the slower reactions have longer windows of the probabilistic regime before entering the deterministic regime. The outcomes provide the basis for implementing mineral nucleation and growth for reactive transport modeling across time-scales and length-scales.

    How to cite: Masoudi, M., Nooraiepour, M., and Hellevang, H.: On the effect of probabilistic nucleation on the distribution of mineral precipitates in porous media, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8398, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8398, 2022.

    EGU22-9633 | Presentations | HS8.1.2

    Dynamic instabilities caused by reaction-cross-diffusion waves in compacting porous media 

    Manman Hu, Qingpei Sun, Christoph Schrank, and Klaus Regenauer-Lieb

    Patterns in nature are often interpreted as a product of reaction-diffusion processes which result in dissipative structures. Thermodynamic constraints allow prediction of the final state with the dynamic evolution of the micro-processes refrained. Here we introduce a new micro-physics based approach that allows us to discover a family of soliton-like excitation waves - coupling the micro-scale cross-constituent interactions to the large scale dynamic behaviour of the open system. These waves can appear in hydromechanically coupled porous media under external loads. They arise when mechanical forcing of the porous skeleton releases internal energy through a phase change, leading to tight coupling of the pressure in the solid matrix with the dissipation of the pore fluid pressure. In order to describe these complex multiscale interactions in a thermodynamic consistent framework, we consider a dual-continuum system, where the large-scale continuum properties of the matrix-fluid interaction are described by a reaction-self diffusion formulation, and the small-scale release of internal energy by a reaction-cross diffusion formulation that spells out the macroscale reaction and relaxes the adiabatic constraint on the local reaction term in the conventional reaction-diffusion formalism. Using this approach, we recover the familiar Turing bifurcations (e.g., rhythmic metamorphic banding), Hopf bifurcations (e.g., Episodic Tremor and Slip), and present the new excitation wave phenomenon. The parametric space is investigated numerically and compared to  serpentinite deformation in subduction zones.

    How to cite: Hu, M., Sun, Q., Schrank, C., and Regenauer-Lieb, K.: Dynamic instabilities caused by reaction-cross-diffusion waves in compacting porous media, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9633, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9633, 2022.

    EGU22-10079 | Presentations | HS8.1.2

    Complex Pattern Formation and Viscous Fingering Stabilization in Radial Flow 

    Darío Martín Escala and Alberto Pérez Muñuzuri

    Interfacial fluid instabilities are ubiquitous in Nature and are responsible for many important phenomena. In some cases, they play a constructive role like in the redistribution of energy in a system but, in some other cases, the role is destructive and may pose a serious threat to technical or industrial applications. In most cases, these fluids involve reactants that are known to modify the instability itself.

    Fingering instabilities are special cases of fluid instabilities that occur when a high mobility fluid displaces a low mobility one [1]. Processes like enhanced oil recovery or other fluid displacements in porous media, such as chromatography, are examples in which the existence of fingering instability is crucial for the overall extraction performance. At a laboratory scale, these instabilities are studied in experimental arrangements known as Hele-Shaw cells. A particularity of these cells is that the flow inside them is representative of the flow in porous media.

    In this work, we propose a chemical system likely to produce instabilities. We endow it with the appropriate chemical reactions at the interface that make it possible to control the activation or deactivation of the fingering instability at will. In particular, we consider two different fluids with different viscosities and analyze the displacement of one fluid by the other injected into a radial Hele-Shaw cell. We studied two different scenarios depending on which fluid is used as displacing/displaced solution [2].

    In the first case, where the most viscous fluid displaces the less viscous one (initially stable configuration), pattern formation is observed when the characteristic flow and reactive timescales are similar. The patterns show complex dynamics in which fingers not only grow but move forward/backward. In the second case (initially unstable configuration), the unfavorable mobility ratio produces complex wormhole structures similar to those observed in dissolving rock fractures [3,4]. The displacement stabilizes when flow, diffusive, and reactive timescales are comparable.

    We extensively characterized and numerically modeled both scenarios. Our results establish the basis to control fluid instabilities that may arise in a broad variety of contexts.  

    REFERENCES:

    [1] Homsy, G. M. (1987). Viscous fingering in porous media. Annual review of fluid mechanics, 19(1), 271-311.

    [2] Escala, D. M., & Muñuzuri, A. P. (2021). A bottom-up approach to construct or deconstruct a fluid instability. Scientific reports, 11(1), 1-16.

    [3] Szymczak, P., & Ladd, A. J. C. (2009). Wormhole formation in dissolving fractures. Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth, 114(B6).

    [4] Kalia, N., & Balakotaiah, V. (2007). Modeling and analysis of wormhole formation in reactive dissolution of carbonate rocks. Chemical Engineering Science, 62(4), 919-928.

    How to cite: Escala, D. M. and Pérez Muñuzuri, A.: Complex Pattern Formation and Viscous Fingering Stabilization in Radial Flow, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10079, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10079, 2022.

    The kinetic interface sensitive (KIS) tracers have been the focus of research in the past decade, as a new, reactive tracer method to estimate the interfacial area between immiscible fluids in porous media. We present here a novel experimental approach to measure the capillary associated fluid-fluid interfacial area using the KIS tracers in simultaneous two-phase flow conditions. The new approach is applied in a sand column filled with glass-beads (d50 = 170µm). Four laboratory experiments are performed in a simultaneous two-phase injection scheme using different fractional flow ratios (Flow rate of wetting phase: total flow rate). The different fractional ratios create different saturations inside the column, which correlate to different fluid-fluid interfacial areas. The new method, introduces also a new analytical method to handle reacted by-product concentration data acquired, different from the KIS tracer method in dynamic conditions. By comparing the results to other established techniques reported in the literature (i.e., interfacial partitioning tracer test and computed micro-tomography) used to measure fluid-fluid interfacial area we observe a good agreement.  The capillary associated interfacial area increases with decreasing wetting saturation until a maximum value, which then drops near the residual saturation. The maximum capillary associated interfacial area occurs at wetting saturation ranges between 0.45 < Sw < 0.6, which is slightly shifted towards the higher wetting saturation when compared to the other techniques. Furthermore, the results are simulated using a Darcy-scale reactive transport multiphase flow in porous media numerical model.

    How to cite: Abdullah, H., Tatomir, A., and Sauter, M.: Experimental approach to measure capillary associated interfacial area using kinetic interface sensitive tracers in a simultaneous two-phase flow, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11132, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11132, 2022.

    EGU22-11813 | Presentations | HS8.1.2

    Experimental study of miscible Rayleigh-Taylor convection in a granular porous medium 

    Shabina Ashraf, Jayabrata Dhar, François Nadal, Patrice Meunier, and Yves Méheust

    More than 60% of greenhouse gas emissions are due to CO2 released from fossil fuels and industrial processes [1]. It is expected that by 2035, the expected increase in CO2 emissions will be 37.2 Gt/yr [2]. To reduce the resulting further adverse effects in climate changes, geological sequestration of CO2 provides an effective solution for carbon capture and storage (CCS) [2-4]. Dissolution trapping of CO2 in deep saline aquifers is a trapping mechanism that allows for long term storage. When CO2 is injected into the subsurface geological layers, the supercritical CO2 (sCO2) dissolves into the aquifer’s aqueous solution positioned below. The formation of a layer of CO2-enriched brine at the upper interface of the liquid domain results in unstable stratification which evolves into gravitational convection [2-5].

    To evaluate the storage capacity and the efficiency of the trapping, it is necessary to understand the dynamics of the instabilities and convection, and the affect of granular media properties on them. To do so, we perform a 2D experimental study in a 3D granular medium and use Darcy scale simulations to complement our experimental findings [6]. Analog experiments are performed by using two miscible fluids with a density contrast between them. In doing so we decouple the gravitational instability process from the dissolution process; the latter is not modeled in our experiment. We match the refractive index of the fluids to that of the granular medium to allow for optical measurement of the concentration field. We observe that there is substantial difference in convection development time scales between the experimental results and the Darcy scale simulations performed with the experimental macroscopic parameters (porosity, permeability, dispersivity lengths, density contrast). We attribute this to the role played by pore scale heterogeneity of the velocity field, which cannot be predicted by Darcy scale models. This would suggest that Darcy scale simulations [2, 4,6] significantly overestimate the typical time scale of the convection.

    [1] Contribution of Working Group III to the Fifth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, IPCC 2014.

    [2] Emami-Meybodi, H., Hassanzadeh, H., Green, C. P., & Ennis-King, J. (2015). Convective dissolution of CO2 in saline aquifers: Progress in modeling and experiments. International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control, 40, 238-266.

    [3] Bachu, S. (2008). CO2 storage in geological media: Role, means, status and barriers to deployment. Progress in energy and combustion science, 34(2), 254-273.

    [4] Pau, G. S., Bell, J. B., Pruess, K., Almgren, A. S., Lijewski, M. J., & Zhang, K. (2010). High-resolution simulation and characterization of density-driven flow in CO2 storage in saline aquifers. Advances in Water Resources, 33(4), 443-455.

    [5] Nadal, F., Meunier, P., Pouligny, B., & Laurichesse, E. (2013). Stationary plume inducedby carbon dioxide dissolution. Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 719, 203-229.

    [6] Dhar, J., Meunier, P., Nadal, F. & Méheust, Y. (2021). Convection dissolution of CO2 in  2D and 3D porous media: the impact of hydrodynamic dispersion. Submitted to Physics of Fluids.

    How to cite: Ashraf, S., Dhar, J., Nadal, F., Meunier, P., and Méheust, Y.: Experimental study of miscible Rayleigh-Taylor convection in a granular porous medium, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11813, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11813, 2022.

    EGU22-12516 | Presentations | HS8.1.2

    Identification of the leading role of pore structure in determining recovery during low salinity water flooding 

    Edward Andrews, Alistair Jones, Ann Muggeridge, and Samuel Krevor

    Low salinity water flooding is a promising enhanced oil recovery technique that has been observed, in experiments over a range of scales, to increase oil production by up to 14% in some systems. However, there is still no way of reliably predicting which systems will respond favourably to the technique. This shortcoming is partly because of a relative lack of pore scale observations of low salinity water flooding. This has led to a poor understanding of how mechanisms on the scale of micrometres lead to changes in fluid distribution on the scale of centimetres to reservoir scales. In this work, we present the first systematic comparison of the pore scale response to low salinity flooding across multiple sandstone samples. We use X-ray micro-CT scanning to image unsteady state experiments of tertiary low salinity water flooding in Berea, Castlegate, and Bunter sandstone micro-cores. We observe fluid saturations and characterise the wetting state of samples using imagery of fluid-solid fractional wetting and pore occupancy analysis. In the Berea sample, we observed an additional oil recovery of 3 percentage points during low salinity water flooding, with large volumes of oil displaced from small pores but also re-trapping of mobilised oil in large pores. In the Bunter sandstone, we observed 4 percentage point additional recovery with significant displacement of oil from small pores and no significant retrapping of oil in large pores. However, in the Castlegate sample, we observed just 1 percentage point of additional recovery and relatively small volumes of oil mobilisation. We observe a significant wettability alteration towards more water-wet conditions in the Berea and Bunter sandstones, but no significant alteration in the Castlegate sample. We hypothesise that the pore structure, specifically the connectivity of the largest pores in each sample, significantly affected production. This work gives the first pore scale insights into the role of pore geometry and topology on the mobilisation and retrapping of oil during low salinity water flooding.   

    How to cite: Andrews, E., Jones, A., Muggeridge, A., and Krevor, S.: Identification of the leading role of pore structure in determining recovery during low salinity water flooding, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12516, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12516, 2022.

    EGU22-13563 | Presentations | HS8.1.2

    Convective dissolution of Carbon Dioxide in two- and three-dimensional porous media: the impact of hydrodynamic dispersion 

    Yves Méheust, Jayabrata Dhar, Patrice Meunier, and François Nadal

    Convective dissolution is the process by which CO2 injected in geological formations dissolves into the aqueous phase and thus remains stored perennially by gravity. It can be modeled by buoyancy-coupled Darcy flow and solute transport. The transport equation should include a diffusive term accounting for hydrodynamic dispersion, wherein the effective diffusion coefficient is proportional to the local interstitial velocity. We investigate the impact of the hydrodynamic dispersion tensor on convective dissolution in two-dimensional (2D) and three-dimensional (3D) homogeneous porous media. Using a novel numerical model we systematically analyze, among other observables, the time evolution of the fingers’ structure, dissolution flux in the quasi-constant flux regime, and mean concentration of the dissolved CO2; we also determine the onset time of convection, ton. For a given Rayleigh number Ra, the efficiency of convective dissolution over long times is controlled by ton. For porous media with a dispersion anisotropy commonly found in the subsurface, ton increases as a function of the longitudinal dispersion’s strength (S), in agreement with previous experimental findings and in contrast to previous numerical findings, a discrepancy which we explain. More generally, for a given strength of transverse dispersion, longitudinal dispersion always slows down convective dissolution, while for a given strength of longitudinal dispersion, transverse dispersion always accelerates it. Furthermore, systematic comparison between 2D and 3D results shows that they are consistent on all accounts, except for a slight difference in ton and a significant impact of Ra on the dependence of the finger number density on S in 3D.

    How to cite: Méheust, Y., Dhar, J., Meunier, P., and Nadal, F.: Convective dissolution of Carbon Dioxide in two- and three-dimensional porous media: the impact of hydrodynamic dispersion, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13563, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13563, 2022.

    The reduction of carbon dioxide concentration in the atmosphere has become an important objective to diminish the predicted exponential increase in global temperatures. A promising long-term solution is carbon capture, and sequestration (CCS), whereby CO2 is injected into saline aquifers containing high concentrations of divalent cations leading to the mineralization of carbonate salts. These precipitation reactions provide a potential long-term solution for storing and preventing reentry of this greenhouse gas into the atmosphere. Our study aims to understand the influence of the initial host solution composition on CCS. Using two glass plates separated by a thin gap (~1 mm), we steadily inject CO2 gas above an alkaline aqueous solution of either calcium chloride and/or magnesium chloride and monitor the convective uptake of CO2 and subsequent mineralization into calcium carbonate (e.g., calcite, aragonite, and vaterite), magnesium carbonate (e.g., hydromagnesite), or calcium magnesium carbonate (e.g., dolomite). The buoyancy-driven convective dynamics from the dissolution of CO2 is monitored using schlieren imaging techniques. In addition, a pH indicator in the initial metal salt solution shows its acidification from the continuous uptake of CO2. The mineral products are analyzed using X-ray diffraction, Raman spectroscopy and scanning electron microscopy to determine the composition, crystal structure, and crystal habit.

    How to cite: Knoll, P. and De Wit, A.: The Effect of Calcium and Magnesium Ions on CO2 Convective Dissolution and Carbonate Precipitation, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13570, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13570, 2022.

    The fate and transport of heavy metals in the soil have been intensively studied over the last decades due to its implications on public health and the environment. The mobility of heavy metals in the soil depends on the surface characteristics of the soil minerals and other solid components such as organic matter, the pore water pH and its composition, among others. Specifically, in calcareous soils, the introduction of heavy metals has been shown to induce dissolution of the calcite and formation of metal-based carbonate minerals. The study of such processes traditionally involves intensive sample collection and chemical analysis of multiple species. In this study, we use spectral induced polarization (SIP) to in-situ monitor the transport three heavy metals (Pb, Zn and Cu) through soil that contain calcite to different extents. In SIP, an alternating current in wide range of frequencies is injected, and the phase and amplitude difference between the injected and induced potential are measured and translated into a complex conductivity spectrum. These measurements are sensitive to both pore water characteristics and to surface processes. Our experimental setup involves flow-through columns packed with different types of soil, through which the inflow solution is passed. Electrical potentials are recorded at three locations along the column. The analyzed SIP measurements allow not only non-invasive, non-destructive monitoring of the metal progression through the soil but also deduction of its fate through combination with elemental analysis.  The results show that both the real and the imaginary components of the complex conductivity are sensitive to the minerals’ dissolution/precipitation. The conductivity values at the peak polarization frequency over time depict the progression of the dissolution/precipitation ‘front’ along the soil profile.

    How to cite: Furman, A. and Ben Moshe, S.: On the transport and fate of heavy metals in calcareous soils – a spectral induced polarization study, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-889, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-889, 2022.

    EGU22-4562 | Presentations | HS8.1.3

    Structure induced vortices control anomalous dispersion in porous media 

    Pietro de Anna, Ankur Bordoloi, David Scheidweiler, Marco Dentz, Mohammed Bouabdellaoui, and Marco Abbarchi

    Natural porous systems, such as soil, membranes, and biological tissues comprise disordered structures characterized by dead-end pores connected to a network of percolating channels. The release and dispersion of particles, solutes, and microorganisms from such features is key for a broad range of environmental and medical applications including soil remediation, drug delivery and filtration. Yet, the role of microscopic structure and flow for the dispersion of particles and solutes in such disordered systems has been only poorly understood, in part due to the stagnant and opaque nature of these microscopic systems. Here, we use a microfluidic model system that features a pore structure characterized by dead-ends to determine how particles are transported, retained and dispersed.  We observe strong tailing of arrival time distributions at the outlet of the medium characterized by power-law decay with an exponent of 2/3. Using numerical simulations and an analytical model, we link this behavior to particles initially located within dead-end pores, and explain the tailing exponent with a hopping and rolling mechanism along the streamlines inside vortices within dead-end pores. These dynamics are quantified by a stochastic model that predicts the full evolution of arrival times. Our results demonstrate how microscopic flow structures can impact macroscopic particle transport.

    How to cite: de Anna, P., Bordoloi, A., Scheidweiler, D., Dentz, M., Bouabdellaoui, M., and Abbarchi, M.: Structure induced vortices control anomalous dispersion in porous media, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4562, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4562, 2022.

    EGU22-4649 | Presentations | HS8.1.3

    Coupling between biomass growth and hydraulic properties of porous systems 

    Wenqiao Jiao, David Scheidweiler, and Pietro De Anna

    Permeable systems can accommodate the flow of fluids through their porous structure that is characterized by solid impermeable grains and empty volumes (the pores). Biofilms are complex and heterogeneous aggregates of communities of microorganisms adhered together, and biofilm growth will affect the evolution of the pore system, such as changing the morphology and structure of grains and reduce the porosity in the host media, and then result in significant alteration in hydrodynamic and transport properties of the porous media. So far, this has been overlooked. Thus, we develope an experimental method to measure the flow through a microfluidics replica of a homogeneous porous medium while imposing a macroscopic pressure gradient. With this novel set-up, we explore the influence of the pore structure that is altered by the growth of biofilms on the hydraulic permeability of porous media.

    How to cite: Jiao, W., Scheidweiler, D., and De Anna, P.: Coupling between biomass growth and hydraulic properties of porous systems, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4649, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4649, 2022.

    EGU22-5735 | Presentations | HS8.1.3

    Diffusiophoretic transport of colloids in a porous medium 

    Mamta Jotkar, Pietro de Ana, and Luis Cueto-Felgueroso

    The ability of a colloidal particle to migrate along a local salt concentration gradient, referred to as diffusiophoresis [1, 2], has recently been explored for a variety of technological applications [3-5]. Flows containing dissolved salts and suspended particles in a porous medium can occur in a variety of natural and engineered scenarios including groundwater contamination and remediation, water infiltration in soil, geological carbon sequestration, enhanced oil recovery, to name a few. In all these scenarios, local salt gradients can induce diffusiophoretic motion of transported particles and contribute to the complexity of the overall transport problem. Aiming to unravel the coupling of the underlying physical mechanisms, we conduct pore-scale simulations to investigate the fluid, solute and particle transport in a micromodel. On one hand, we measure the time-lapsed effluent concentration of the colloidal particles close to the outlet and compute the so-called breakthrough curves to understand the influence of diffusiophoresis on the particle macroscopic transport through the whole host medium. On the other hand, we compute Lagrangian statistics from particle tracking at the microscale. Our results hint towards the fact that the microscopic interplay between salt transport, diffusiophoretic particle motion and host medium disorder can impact the macroscale particle dynamics. Lastly, while both, the flow and transport through a porous medium and the diffusiophoretic motion of colloids in a variety of microfluidic devices, are active areas of research, the novelty of our work lies in the intersection of the two.  

     

    References:

    [1] Derjaguin et al. (1947), “Kinetic phenomenon in boundary films of liquids”, Colloid J. USSR, 9, 335-347.

    [2] Anderson (1989), “Colloid transport by interfacial forces”, Annu. Rev. Fluid Mech., 21 (1), 61-99.

    [3] Kar et al. (2015), “Enhanced Transport into and out of dead-end pores”, ACS Nano, 9(1), 746-753.

    [4] Shin et al. (2017), “Membraneless water filtration using CO2”, Nat. Commun., 8(1), 15181.

    [5] Rasmussen et al. (2020), “Size and surface charge characterization of nanoparticles with a salt gradient”, Nat. Commun., 11(1), 2337.

    How to cite: Jotkar, M., de Ana, P., and Cueto-Felgueroso, L.: Diffusiophoretic transport of colloids in a porous medium, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5735, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5735, 2022.

    EGU22-6283 | Presentations | HS8.1.3

    Transport and retention of motile cells in a complex microsystem comprising dead-end pores 

    Ankur Bordoloi, David Scheidweiler, and Pietro de Anna

    Disordered microstructures comprising dead-end pores are prevalent in soil, membranes and biological tissues. Predicting transport and dispersal patterns of microorganisms in such media is important for various natural and bio-engineered systems. Herein, we study the transport of motile and non-motile E. Coli bacteria cells through a complex micromodel described in [1]. The prediction of bacteria transport in such systems is challenging due to their complex swimming behavior within confined structures. Based on microfluidic experiments, we observe that motile cells tend to migrate into the dead-end pores unlike their non-motile counterparts, leading to higher retention of motile cells and consequent accumulation of biomass inside dead-end pores. To predict the observed behavior numerically, we simultaneously solve a set of Langevin equations for active elongated microswimmers. Simulation results agree well with our experimental retention curves. Further, based on the simulated trajectories we uncover how a motile cell migrates from a transmitting channel into a dead-end pore.

     

    [1] Bordoloi, A.D, Scheidweiler, D., Dentz, M., Bouabdellaoui, M., Abbarchi, M. and P. de Anna, Structure induced vortices control anomalous dispersion in porous media,  2021 arXiv preprint arXiv:2112.12492

    How to cite: Bordoloi, A., Scheidweiler, D., and de Anna, P.: Transport and retention of motile cells in a complex microsystem comprising dead-end pores, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6283, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6283, 2022.

    EGU22-7580 | Presentations | HS8.1.3

    Dispersion of motile bacteria in a porous medium: Experimental data and theory 

    Marco Dentz, Adama Creppy, Carine Douarche, Eric Clément, and Harold Auradou

    The sound understanding and quantification of the transport and dispersion
    mechanisms of bacteria in porous media is of central concern in applications
    such as bioremediation and biomineralization. Recent experimental and numerical
    studies indicate that motility plays a key role for the fate of bacteria.
    Data from microfluidic experiments in model porous media consisting of randomly
    placed pillars show that non-motile bacteria have compact displacement
    distributions, while the distribution of motile bacteria are characterized by
    strong peak retention and forward tailing. Detailed analysis of bacteria
    trajectories reveals two key attributes: 1. The emergence of a motility-induced
    trapping and retention process due to active motion from the stream toward the
    solid grain. 2. Increase or decrease of dispersion due to the transfer between
    pore channels and grains, depending on the flow rate. We develop a physical model
    based ona continuous time random walk (CTRW) approach. Bacteria dispersion due to
    hydrodynamic flow fluctuations is quantified by a Markov model for the equidistantly
    sampled particle speeds. The impact of motility is modeled by a two-rate trapping
    process that accounts for the motion toward and active trapping at the grains.
    The theoretical model captures the displacement distributions of both non-motile
    and motile bacteria. It provides explicit analytical expressions for the motility-induced
    hydrodynamic dispersion coefficients in terms of the trapping and release rates,
    which characterize the bacteria motility. The experimental data shows that these
    motility parameters are flow-rate dependent, which manifest in a reduction of
    dispersion compared to the non-motile bacteria at low flow rates, and an increase
    at high flow rates. The model reproduces the experimental observations and allows to
    predict bacteria dispersion at the continuum scale.  

    How to cite: Dentz, M., Creppy, A., Douarche, C., Clément, E., and Auradou, H.: Dispersion of motile bacteria in a porous medium: Experimental data and theory, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7580, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7580, 2022.

    EGU22-7629 | Presentations | HS8.1.3

    BES-based biosensors for methane emissions assessment in freshwater ecosystems 

    Marta Fernandez-Gatell, Xavier Sanchez-Vila, and Jaume Puigagut

    Climate change is one of the most important and probable aspects influencing the stability of human societies. Anaerobic carbon oxidation by methane producing bacteria (MPB) in natural and human-made freshwater ecosystems influence the global greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions and its dynamics.  Moreover, these ecosystems are highly sensitive to climate change. However, GHG emissions assessment methodologies are complex and cannot be applied continuously. Thus, better tools to characterize methane emissions and its dynamics in these ecosystems are of capital importance to deal with climate change. Bioelectrochemical systems (BES) are devices that transform the chemical energy of organic and inorganic substrates into electric current thanks to the metabolic activity of the electroactive bacteria (EAB’s). EAB and MPB oxidate the same carbon source (acetate) and, therefore, current produced by EAB can be used as a proxy for methane formation. BES-based biosensors are an interesting type of biosensors since they do not need a transducer, can be manufactured using cost-effective materials and can be applied for real-time and remote location monitoring. The work presented aim to assess the potential use of the electric signal produced by a low-cost, membrane-less BES-based biosensor as an indicator of methane emissions. To this purpose, 3.8L PVC vessels representing a core of a shallow flooded ecosystem were constructed and a BES cell was placed in the centre for the biosensing assessment. Methane emissions were assessed through the close chamber method and analysed by gas chromatography coupled to a flame ionisation detector while the bio-electric signal was continuously recorded. Results show that the methane and the electric production follow a similar pattern, but are displaced in time, being the electric production faster than the methane one. Results indicate that the electric current of a BES-based biosensor has the potential to be used as an indirect measure of methane emissions.

    How to cite: Fernandez-Gatell, M., Sanchez-Vila, X., and Puigagut, J.: BES-based biosensors for methane emissions assessment in freshwater ecosystems, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7629, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7629, 2022.

    EGU22-9229 | Presentations | HS8.1.3

    Investigating the pore scale mechanism of miscible phases mixing in porous medium 2D 

    Yahel Eliyahu-Yakir, Tal Ballas, Ludmila Abezgauz, and Yaniv Edery

    Abstract

    The process of a fluid replacing a separate miscible fluid in a porous medium is present in many industrial and natural systems, such as enhanced oil recovery, CO2 sequestration and salt-fresh water interfaces in the ground. While the replacement can be approximated with the Darcy law, the mechanisms of the miscible phases mixing to the displacement remain unclear, specifically as the heterogeneity of the domain increases. As this mixing influences the reaction pattern between the fluids, it is important to estimate it using indirect measurements that are available, such as pressure and flux measurements. We propose a set of experiments that allow us to observe and measure the displacement and mixing process in high resolution and with the use of image analysis we can distinguish between the mechanisms. We can clearly see how the heterogeneous rate of the pore structure influences the mixing pattern, rate, and duration. Surprisingly, we found a clear and typical “mark” of the mechanisms on the flow rate, under constant pressure, which allows us to relate the heterogeneity level of the structure to the ratio of displacement to mixing.

    How to cite: Eliyahu-Yakir, Y., Ballas, T., Abezgauz, L., and Edery, Y.: Investigating the pore scale mechanism of miscible phases mixing in porous medium 2D, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9229, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9229, 2022.

    The heterogeneous spatial organization and composition of bacterial communities in soils are expected to deeply impact geochemical quantities at the pore-scale, shaping steep solutes gradients in spite of mixing processes. Oxygen distribution is of major interest since localized anoxic niches might host facultatively anaerobic bacteria. This means that metabolisms alternative to aerobic respiration might be triggered even in well-oxygenated systems, thus largely impacting soil ecological functions.

    Our ability to non-invasively monitor O2 time-space distributions at the scale of interest for bacterial clusters is still limited. Moreover, the identification of the critical O2 level at which facultative bacteria switch their metabolism is little explored and largely debated. 

    This work presents an innovative experimental setup allowing to simultaneously quantify oxygen concentrations and biomass arrangement as a function of time and space in microfluidic devices, which mimic natural porous media. Our methodology makes use of i) a newly developed and customized planar transparent fluorescent sensor whose fluorescence intensity is sensitive to oxygen concentration, and ii) a fully automated microscope to collect high-resolution large images.

    Our results reveal that microbial aggregates and oxygen distribution are closely correlated both spatially and temporally demonstrating that microbial activity can generate and sustain anoxic micro-niches. This anoxic space occupies up to 2-3 % of the porous volume and is controlled by the competition between advective/diffusive processes (supplying oxygen) and microbial O2 consumption. Interestingly, bacterial cluster shapes and their spatial organization are key elements determining the development of anoxic micro-niches and their impact on macroscale processes. Based on the new insights provided by our experiment, we develop an original definition of Damköhler number to describe the conditions for anoxic micro-niches onset under the laminar diffusion-dominated flow that typically characterized groundwater systems.

    This novel methodology combined with opportunely tagged laboratory strains opens new frontiers to investigate the O2 critical concentration associated with facultative metabolism trigger for bacteria with interesting function in soil ecology and wastewater water and drinking water remediation engineering.

    How to cite: Ceriotti, G., Borisov, S., Berg, J., and de Anna, P.: Real-time spatial O2-sensing in 2D porous media to investigate conditions for anoxic micro-niches onset and microbial facultative metabolism trigger., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9665, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9665, 2022.

    EGU22-12807 | Presentations | HS8.1.3

    An analysis of the future of quantum gravimeters in hydrology using computer modelling. 

    Eleanor Pike, David Hannah, Stefan Krause, and Kai Bongs

    There are still many unexplored hypotheses regarding subsurface water movement, and gravimetry could be a tool to elucidating them. The field of gravimetry has been used in hydrology as an auxiliary methodology for many years, but recent developments in quantum technology has improved the sensitivity and accuracy of gravimeters significantly. Computer modelling can provide a helpful way of assessing the benefits of new technologies. A number of soil types were modelled to determine their wetting and drying curves, as well as a number of weather event scenarios. From these hydrological models, the changes in density produced in accordance with the wetting and drying curves were determined. The resulting change in local gravity could then be calculated and modelled with the parameters for each instrument, to determine the detection thresholds and relevancy of classical and quantum gravimeters, as well as gravity gradiometry. The data shows not only the sensitivity and accuracy of each, but can also be scaled to show their utility in varying degrees of environmental noise, ensuring that these results can be relevant to field conditions. This project should clearly demonstrate the increased visibility of subsurface water storage and flux with the use of quantum technology, sparking a conversation around the future of data gathering in hydrology.

    How to cite: Pike, E., Hannah, D., Krause, S., and Bongs, K.: An analysis of the future of quantum gravimeters in hydrology using computer modelling., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12807, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12807, 2022.

    EGU22-13554 | Presentations | HS8.1.3

    Characterization of an Aquifer Thermal Energy Storage system with an Active Distributive Temperature Sensing Experiment 

    Jérémy Godinaud, Maria Klepikova, François Larroque, Nicolas Guilhéneuf, Alain Dupuy, Alexandre Pryet, and Olivier Bour

    Aquifer Thermal Energy Storage systems (ATES) are reversible open loop geothermal systems involving a minimum of two reversible boreholes. It gains more and more popularity with a great potential to reduce greenhouse gas emission of the building sector.

    During operation, ATES storage efficiency and energy recovery rate depend on the cold and warm thermal plumes extension. The thermal plumes shaped are particularly impacted by the aquifer vertical and horizontal heterogeneity especially regarding the flux and thermal properties distribution. In addition, ATES performance also depends of the sustainability of the wells and the major issues of their aging. Among the major causes, biofouling, chemical and physical clogging are well documented for open loop system.

    However, field methods existing to quantify aquifer properties are not well suited to estimate both thermal and hydrodynamic aquifer heterogeneity with a high spatial resolution. Recent developments in Fiber-Optic Distributed Temperature Sensing (FO-DTS) have solved this issue. In particularly, active -DTS experiments (ADTS) were shown to be a promising avenue for imaging the spatial distribution of subsurface heterogeneities. It consists on monitoring the thermal response along the FO cable induced by a heat source placed in the borehole which allow to estimate thermal and hydrodynamic properties distributed along boreholes.

    In that context, we performed a series of ADTS experiments on a ATES site. The field experiments were run under cross-borehole configuration and replicate in two different piezometers to check the reciprocity of the results. Our work demonstrates the potential of ADTS to estimate both thermal conductivity and groundwater flux along the two boreholes. At the same time, it was shown to be a good tool to detect clogging locations along the boreholes. The proposed experimental design is simple and the tests can be run without opening boreholes and stop the pump. First, this method enables the characterization of thermal and hydrodynamic heterogeneities to develop more advanced numerical models. Secondly, it can be used as strategy surveillance to monitor clogging evolution into geothermal boreholes and to plan maintenance works before major deterioration.

    How to cite: Godinaud, J., Klepikova, M., Larroque, F., Guilhéneuf, N., Dupuy, A., Pryet, A., and Bour, O.: Characterization of an Aquifer Thermal Energy Storage system with an Active Distributive Temperature Sensing Experiment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13554, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13554, 2022.

    EGU22-13555 | Presentations | HS8.1.3

    Assessment of hydraulic conductivity from the hydrographic network in shallow crystalline aquifers 

    Ronan Abhervé, Alexandre Gauvain, Clément Roques, Laurent Longuevergne, Luc Aquilina, and Jean-Raynald de Dreuzy

    Hydrological predictions for ungauged basins at catchment and regional scales still faces the challenge of lack of available data. To meet this challenge, we propose a new method relying on the structure of the stream network. Under the assumption that the perennial stream network is mostly fed by groundwaters, its structure derives from the underlying aquifer properties. It is especially the case for shallow crystalline aquifers under temperate climates where the surface and subsurface hydrological systems are directly connected. The groundwater table remains close to the topography and the spatial extent of the stream network is then controlled by the magnitude of the subsurface hydraulic conductivity (K) with respect to the actual recharge rates (R).

     

    Using a parsimonious 3D groundwater flow model, we propose a novel performance criterion to assess the similarity between the modelled seepage areas and the observed stream network. We investigate the sensitivity of our methodology to different digital elevation models (DEM) and stream network products from different databases that may impact the estimates through their different spatial resolutions. We use this method to determine the equivalent hydraulic conductivity for 25 crystalline catchments in western France.

     

    The results show that our methodology allows predicting the spatial patterns of the stream network with a high sensitivity to the hydraulic conductivity. We found that estimated hydraulic conductivities vary over two orders of magnitude [10-5 to 10-4 m/s] across the 25 investigated catchments and are well correlated to the lithology. While the DEM resolution has no major effect on the results, we found that the proportion of described low-order streams significantly controls the estimations.

     

    The proposed approach constitutes a paradigm shift in current methodologies designed to assess catchment-scale hydraulic properties with great perspectives regarding the emergence of remote sensing techniques for the mapping of wetlands and soil moisture. Our method might bring up new opportunities to provide predictions for ungauged basins such as the hydrographic network dynamics in a changing climate.

    How to cite: Abhervé, R., Gauvain, A., Roques, C., Longuevergne, L., Aquilina, L., and de Dreuzy, J.-R.: Assessment of hydraulic conductivity from the hydrographic network in shallow crystalline aquifers, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13555, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13555, 2022.

    EGU22-13559 | Presentations | HS8.1.3

    TERRA FORMA: Developing the observation platform of the Anthropocene 

    Laurent Longuevergne, Arnaud Elger, and Virginie Girard

    The Anthropocene, a new geological period when human actions are altering the habitability of the Earth for all forms of life, raises new challenges in terms of knowledge integration that fragmented approaches cannot overtake. Due to complex interactions within geo-eco-socio-systems (GESS), a “whole system” approach is required to answer societal concerns around soil capital, water resources, chemical pressure and biodiversity.

    To address these challenges, the TERRA FORMA project will design and test in-situ observation plateform coupling sensor viewpoints on human, biotic and abiotic dynamics. This project builds on pioneering and mature technological advances (optical sensors, 3D printing, IoT, AI) to design and probe a scalable network of smart sensors. We will develop a new generation of smart, connected, low-cost, low-impact and socially appropriated environmental sensors, adapted to field conditions, dedicated to capture the behavior, metabolism and trajectory of GESS emerging from states and fluxes of liquid, gas and solid matter and biota. These new technologies will contribute to shed light on “essential variables” for GESS and evaluate the descriptive and predictive potential of models over a wide range of contexts. TERRA FORMA gathers scientists, in an interdisciplinary effort at the crossroad of Earth, environmental, technological, computer and social sciences.

    In this presentation, we will show how instrumental developments (spectroscopy, lab on a chip, …) and methodological developments (biogeophysics, …) contributes to the construction of the observation plateform.

    How to cite: Longuevergne, L., Elger, A., and Girard, V.: TERRA FORMA: Developing the observation platform of the Anthropocene, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13559, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13559, 2022.

    EGU22-207 | Presentations | HS8.1.4

    Improving analytical methods for the extraction and analysis of biodegradable and non-biodegradable microplastics in the soil environment. 

    Grace Davies, Iseult Lynch, Stefan Krause, Samantha Marshall, and Massimiliano Mascelloni

    Global plastic production reached 368 million tonnes in 2019 (Plastics Europe, 2020), with the greatest demand being for packaging. Plastic waste management in many countries is mismanaged, with ~25% of post-consumer waste globally sent to landfill in 2018, this increases the likelihood of plastic ending up in the environment, raising concerns about the impact of plastic pollution on the environment. Microplastics (particles <5mm) are emerging contaminants with high risk due to their ubiquity in the environment and the as yet unknown scale of their impact on organisms and ecosystems.

    Microplastics are present in all environmental compartments, but research to date has focused on marine systems, leaving a substantial knowledge gap in understanding how microplastics behave in and impact other environments, especially terrestrial ones. Terrestrial soils provide key ecosystem services (e.g. food provision and climate regulation), however these services are threatened by soil pollution including from microplastics. Soils act as a sink for microplastics, which typically enter the soil through their widespread use in agriculture. Common entry pathways include the application of microplastic containing sewage sludge as fertiliser, and the direct application of microplastics via the polymer encapsulation of pesticides and seeds. Whilst the impacts of microplastics are not fully known, it is possible that they will compromise soil health and functions.

    We urgently need to understand how microplastics of different compositions and sources affect soil ecosystems, but research progress is hindered due to the lack of standardised protocols for the identification, extraction, and analysis of microplastics in the complex soil environment. Soil is high in organic matter, meaning protocols devised for aquatic samples are not feasible because more aggressive digestion steps are required to remove soil organics.

    This poster looks at the extraction and analysis of microplastics from soil samples, following a generalised framework of sieving, density separation, organic digestion, and analysis. It outlines the effectiveness of each step in the soil matrix and its applicability for both biodegradable and non-biodegradable microplastics. It compares the effect of commonly used digestion solutions (e.g. Fenton’s reagent, hydrogen peroxide) on the polymers, by using Raman spectroscopy to characterise the plastics before and after treatment, and thus to assess chemical changes arising from the sample processing. Based on these results an optimal workflow is defined as the basis for evaluating the biodegradation of microplastics in soil.

    How to cite: Davies, G., Lynch, I., Krause, S., Marshall, S., and Mascelloni, M.: Improving analytical methods for the extraction and analysis of biodegradable and non-biodegradable microplastics in the soil environment., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-207, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-207, 2022.

    EGU22-819 | Presentations | HS8.1.4

    Effects of Microplastics on Soil Hydraulic Properties 

    Yingxue Yu and Markus Flury

    Agricultural soils have been recognized as a major reservoir of microplastics, and concerns have arisen about the impacts of microplastics on soil properties and functioning. Here, we investigated the effects of microplastics on hydraulic properties of soils and determine the underlining mechanisms contributing to the effects. We measured the responses of a silt loam soil, a typical agricultural soil, to the incorporation of pristine as well as UV-weathered polypropylene granules and polyester fibers, two common types and shapes of microplastics, in terms of bulk density, saturated hydraulic conductivity, field capacity, permanent wilting point, water holding capacity, wet aggregate size distribution, and contact angle. We mixed polypropylene granules and polyester fibers into soil at different volume-based concentrations to elucidate the effect of microplastic shape. We also studied how weathering (UV and soil burial exposure) will affect the impact of microplastics on soil hydraulic properties. Due to the generally hydrophobic nature of plastic particles, the soil was found to lose some of its water holding capacity when contaminated with plastics. Fibrous microplastics rearrange soil structure and thus trigger more pronounced responses of soil hydraulic properties than granular microplastics. The results of this study provide fundamental knowledge about how microplastics interact with soil matrices and affect soil hydraulic properties, and advance current understanding about the impacts of microplastics on soil health.

    How to cite: Yu, Y. and Flury, M.: Effects of Microplastics on Soil Hydraulic Properties, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-819, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-819, 2022.

    EGU22-826 | Presentations | HS8.1.4

    Fly ash releases from surface impoundments can be identified through spICP-TOF-MS fingerprinting 

    Jan Schüürman, Vesna Micić, Frank von der Kammer, and Thilo Hofmann

    Coal fly ash is used in the construction industry and holds potential as a resource for the extraction of rare earth elements and high-value metals such as scandium. It is commonly stored in uncovered landfills or ash ponds close to the coal-fired power stations. Major releases from these surface impoundments into adjacent rivers pose an environmental concern due to the harmful effects of associated heavy metals. Future releases may occur more frequently as the globally impounded ash volume continues to grow and climate change threatens to further increase extreme rainfall events, which can cause overflows of surface impoundments and failure of their retention dams. Minor releases of fly ash from the storage sites could be early warning signs of their declining retention. When reaching a river, fly ash particles deposit in its sediments. Thereby, fly ash particles may leave a sedimentary record of minor releases over many years, but these particles are difficult to detect due to their small size and low concentration.

    We used single particle inductively-coupled plasma time-of-flight mass spectrometry (spICP-TOF-MS) to identify element fractionation patterns in micrometer- and nanometer-sized fly ash particles. Some intermediately-volatile elements such as nickel, cobalt, and vanadium fractionate towards smaller particle sizes during coal combustion. These elements were enriched in fly ash up to three orders of magnitude above the natural sedimentary background levels. We found particles with this characteristic fly ash elemental fingerprint in four depths of a sediment core downstream of a fly ash landfill, indicating fly ash release into the river. Upstream river sediment reference samples, on the contrary, did not contain these particles. The detected releases of fly ash deposited only trace amounts of fly ash in the sediment, which were neither detected applying major and trace element analysis (ICP-OES, ICP-MS, and XRF), nor found through mineralogical (XRD) or morphological (SEM) investigations.

    We demonstrated that spICP-TOF-MS can be used to identify fly ash particles in river sediment at previously undetectable concentrations. This technique can thus help assess surface impoundment integrity to prevent catastrophic future spills.

    How to cite: Schüürman, J., Micić, V., von der Kammer, F., and Hofmann, T.: Fly ash releases from surface impoundments can be identified through spICP-TOF-MS fingerprinting, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-826, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-826, 2022.

    EGU22-1561 | Presentations | HS8.1.4

    Bacterial motility dynamics in open and confined porous media 

    Lazaro J. Perez, Andrew Plymale, and Rishi Parashar

    Diverse processes such as bioremediation, biofertilization, and microbial drug delivery rely on bacterial migration in porous media. However, how pore-scale confinement alters bacterial motility is unknown due to the inherent physical heterogeneities on porous media. As a result, models of migration are limited and often employ ad hoc assumptions.

    We aim to determine the impact of pore confinement in the spreading dynamics of two populations of motile metal-reducing bacteria by directly visualizing individual Acidovorax and Pelosinus in an unconfined liquid medium and a microfluidic chip containing arrays of pillars placed at regular intervals. We observe that the length of runs of the two species differs between the unconfined and confined medium. Results show that bacteria in the confined medium display systematic shorter jumps due to grain obstacles when compared to the open porous medium. Close inspection of the trajectories reveals that cells are intermittently and transiently trapped, producing superdiffusive motion at early and subdiffusion behavior at late times as they navigate through the confined pore spaces. While in the open medium, we observe a linearly increasing variance with respect to time for Acidovorax, and for Pelosinus the variance increases at a much faster rate showing superdiffusive behavior at early times. At late times, the rate of growth in spreading increases for Acidovorax while it reduces for Pelosinus. We finally discuss that the paradigm of run-and-tumble motility is dramatically altered in confined porous medium, which can have strong implications for large-scale transport.

    How to cite: Perez, L. J., Plymale, A., and Parashar, R.: Bacterial motility dynamics in open and confined porous media, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1561, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1561, 2022.

    EGU22-1744 | Presentations | HS8.1.4

    Impact of metal nanoparticles on tomato growth, physiology and symbiosis with the Fusarium solani FsK strain 

    Constantinos V. Chrysikopoulos, Anastasios A. Malandrakis, Nektarios Kavroulakis, Marianna Avramidou, Kalliope K. Papadopoulou, and Georgios Tsaniklidis

    Metal nanoparticles constitute promising, eco-compatible alternatives to be used as nano-fertilizers or nano-fungicides although their potential impact on the agroecosystem is poorly studied. In the present study, the impact of copper (Cu-NPs, CuO-NPs), silver (Ag-NPs) and zinc oxide (ZnO-NPs) nanoparticles (NPs) on tomato plant development, physiological properties and the symbiotic relationship with the endophytic Fusarium solani FsK strain was assessed in comparison with their respective bulk/ionic counterparts. Both NPs and their counterparts did not affect the number of germinated tomato seeds even at higher concentrations except for AgNO3, which significantly decreased seed germination rates. On the contrary, a dose dependent decrease of root length was observed in most NP/bulk treatment cases. This was also the case for dry weight of tomato plants which was also significantly reduced upon treatment with NPs and counterparts especially in the cases of AgNO3, Cu-NPs, ZnO-NPs, and ZnSO4. Although differences between NPs and bulk counterparts varied, root and shoot length of grown tomato plants was also negatively affected by treatments. NPs/bulk counterpart treatments resulted in a marked oxidative stress response as indicated by increased MDA and H2O2 levels of treated plants. Photosynthetic pigments were also significantly affected by NP/bulk treatments, a fact evident from the reduced chlorophyl-a and carotenoid levels recorded. The FsK tomato-symbiotic strain was significantly more sensitive to Cu-NPs and ZnO-NPs than CuO-NPs and Ag-NPs as revealed in both mycelial growth and spore germination fungitoxicity tests. With the exception of AgNO3,which was 8 to 9-fold more toxic than Ag-NPs, all NPs were more fungitoxic to FsK than their bulk/ionic counterparts. FsK colonization of roots was not significantly affected by treatments with NPs and counterparts indicating that, once established inside the roots, the endophyte is shielded against the toxic effect of metals. At the same time, an alleviation of CuO-NPs, ZnO-NPs,and ZnSO4 phytoxicity was observed when FsK was present inside tomato roots in terms of plant dry weight. Concluding, results suggest that phytotoxicity of NPs in tomato treated plants should be considered before nano-fertilizer/fungicide treatments while the benefits of FsK inoculation of tomato plants may extent to resistance towards these toxic agents for both organisms.

    How to cite: Chrysikopoulos, C. V., Malandrakis, A. A., Kavroulakis, N., Avramidou, M., Papadopoulou, K. K., and Tsaniklidis, G.: Impact of metal nanoparticles on tomato growth, physiology and symbiosis with the Fusarium solani FsK strain, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1744, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1744, 2022.

    EGU22-2723 | Presentations | HS8.1.4

    Disentangling microplastics effects on soil structure, microbial activity and greenhouse gas emissions 

    Jonathan Nunez, Joaquin Jimenez-Martinez, and Denise Mitrano

    There is an expected increase of microplastics (MPs) concentrations in terrestrial ecosystems in the next decades from a variety of sources. Understanding the responses of soil ecosystems to the presence of MPs becomes increasingly important as multiple stressors can act together to negatively impact this environmental compartment, especially in the context of global warming. It has already been shown that MPs (particularly fibers) can influence several parameters of soil structure and function, including aggregate formation, water holding capacity and microbial activity. Furthermore, recent studies suggest that the presence of MPs in soils affects the emissions of the greenhouse gases (GHG) carbon dioxide (CO2) and nitrous oxide (N2O). The mechanisms underpinning the direction and magnitude of MPs effects on GHG emissions from soils are uncertain, mainly due to the lack of knowledge of how the presence of MPs drives changes in soil structure and the subsequent link between soil structure and microbial activity. Here, we hypothesized that the presence of MPs affects soil structure by increasing porosity, leading to higher O2 availability and consequently higher decomposition of soil organic matter (SOM) and lower denitrification activity. In this study, we spiked MPs of different polymers (PET, PLA), morphologies (fragments, fibers) and sizes to a custom built rhizotron (7 x 4 x 1 cm) filled will a clay soil with a MP treatment of 5 w/w%. The soil was initially sterilized, but we added microbial inoculum collected from the same soil and glucose (as a substrate source) in known concentrations to assess soil respiration over time. We determined the spatial distribution of microbial respiration by mapping O2 concentrations using optode imaging, with a resolution of 1 image every 10 minutes over the course of 48 hours. Soil pore size, pore distribution and the pore connectivity network were determined by using X-ray micro-tomography (µCT). GHG emissions were measured by placing replicate set-ups in a Tedlar bag and collecting CO2 and N2O from the headspace in exetainers to be analyzed by gas chromatography. This approach allowed us to collect real-time O2 distribution and compare this to X-ray micro-tomography (µCT) data from the same soil matrix to assess MPs impacts to the soil structure and link it to GHG emissions compared to the control (i.e. no MPs addition). Collectively, in this presentation we will discuss the impacts of MPs addition to soil and on the linkages between soil structure, microbial activity and GHG emissions. This study can serve as a baseline for understanding the important impacts of MPs to soil functioning, which is particularly relevant as plastics are increasingly used directly in agriculture and can have direct releases to the terrestrial ecosystem.

    How to cite: Nunez, J., Jimenez-Martinez, J., and Mitrano, D.: Disentangling microplastics effects on soil structure, microbial activity and greenhouse gas emissions, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2723, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2723, 2022.

    Visible flow chamber systems packed with porous media (at both macroscale and pore scale) and packed column systems for the first time were used to systematically investigated the impacts of seawater intrusion and groundwater-seawater displacement on the transport behaviors of marine plastic particles with different sizes in porous media. We found that seawater intrusion could transfer all three sized plastics into coastal porous media and their transport would be affected by seawater flow velocity. For example, 8.5%, 24.8%, 39.8% of 1 mm plastic particles could pass through the columns during the 10, 50 and 250 m/d seawater intrusion processes, respectively. The groundwater-seawater displacement process could re-mobilize plastic particles pre-attached onto sand. The percentages of released plastic particles were negatively correlated with the sizes of plastic particles and the ionic strength of displacement groundwater. Groundwater velocity did not obviously affect the release of plastic particles from sand. The percentage of released plastic particles were affected by seawater intrusion cycles. XDLVO was employed to theoretically explain the transport behaviors of plastic particles under different conditions. Our study showed that seawater intrusion would transfer marine plastic particles into coastal aquifer and groundwater-seawater displacement could affect the release of plastic particles from porous media.

    How to cite: li, M. and tong, M.: Transport and deposition of plastic particles in porous media during seawater intrusion and groundwater-seawater displacement processes, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3489, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3489, 2022.

    EGU22-3497 | Presentations | HS8.1.4 | Highlight

    Microplastic mass balances in remote alpine lakes 

    David Gateuille, Julia Dusaucy, Emmanuel Naffrechoux, Philippe Fanget, Grégory Tourreau, Peter Gallinelli, and Frédéric Gillet

    Microplastics pose a threat to all the environmental compartments and specifically to aquatic ecosystems. Lakes are particularly exposed to it as they act as accumulator of pollution from their watersheds. Unfortunately, the fate of microplastics in lake ecosystems remains poorly understood because of the multiplicity of sources and transfer pathways. For the first time, the Plastilac project focuses on the contamination of high altitude lakes (from 1300 m to 2800 m above the sea level) by microplastics. Remote lakes constitute easier-to-investigate ecosystems because there are fewer potential sources of microplastics in their watershed, namely the atmospheric deposit, the supply from the watershed through the tributaries and the tourist attendance. Thus, both water column and sediment from 10 lakes located across the French Alps were sampled. The results showed that no lake was free from microplastics, proving the ubiquity of this pollution at a regional scale. The abundance of microplastics varied significantly from one lake to another and the concentrations measured in high altitude lakes (around 10 MP.m-3) were approximately 100 times lower than those reported in the literature for lowland lakes. The water column contamination was not correlated to the vicinity of potential sources (urban areas). On the contrary, higher sediment contaminations were observed in lakes located nearby urban areas. Our analyses also showed that the residence times of microplastics in the water column of these lakes were relatively short, of the order of a few days. In contrast, the residence times of microplastics in the sediments were much longer and lake bottoms retain traces of past contamination. This work constitutes a first for understanding the fate of microplastics in mountainous environments. It provides important information on their dynamics and, in particular, on the temporal dimension of this pollution.

    How to cite: Gateuille, D., Dusaucy, J., Naffrechoux, E., Fanget, P., Tourreau, G., Gallinelli, P., and Gillet, F.: Microplastic mass balances in remote alpine lakes, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3497, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3497, 2022.

    Bacterial removal by sand filtration system is commonly inefficient due to the low bacterial adsorption capacity of sand. To improve the bacterial removal performance, biochar fabricated at different temperatures (400 °C, 550 °C and 700 °C) and arginine modified biochar were added into sand filtration columns as filter layers (0.5 and 1 wt%). Addition of biochar into sand columns could improve the removal efficiency for both Escherichia coli and Bacillus subtilis under both slow (4 m/day) and fast (240 m/day) filtration conditions. Bacterial removal efficiency in sand columns with the addition of biochar fabricated at 700 °C were higher than those fabricated at 400 °C and 550 °C due to its best bacterial adsorption capacity. Modification of biochar with arginine could further improve the bacterial removal performance. Specifically, complete bacterial removal (1.35×107 ± 10% cells/mL) could be achieved under both slow and fast filtration conditions in sand columns with 1 wt% arginine functionalized biochar amendment. The enhanced bacterial adsorption capacity mainly contributed to the increased bacterial capture performance in columns with addition of arginine-modified biochar. Bacteria more tightly bounded with arginine-modified biochar than bulk biochar. Moreover, complete bacterial removal with the copresence of 5 mg/L humic acid in suspensions was acquired in columns with addition of 1 wt% arginine-modified biochar. Efficient bacterial removal in actual river water, multiple filtration cycles as well as longtime injection duration (100 pore volumes injection) was also obtained. The results of this study demonstrated that arginine-modified biochar had great potential to treat water contaminated by pathogenic bacteria.

    How to cite: Mengya, Z. and Tong, M.: Improved removal performance of Gram-negative and Gram-positive bacteria in sand filtration system with arginine modified biochar amendment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3505, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3505, 2022.

    Due to the interaction of fertilizers with microplastics (MPs) and porous media, fertilization process would influence MPs transport and distributions in soil. The co-impacts of N fertilizers (both inorganic and organic N fertilizers) and humic substance on MPs transport/retention behaviors in porous media were examined in 10mM KCl solutions at pH 6. NH4Cl and CO(NH2)2 were employed as inorganic and organic N fertilizers, respectively, while humic acid (HA) was used as model humic substance. We found that for all three sized MPs (0.2, 1 and 2 μm) without HA, both types of N fertilizers decreased their transport/increased their retention in porous media (both quartz sand and soil). N fertilizers adsorbed onto surfaces of MPs and sand/soil, lowering the electrostatic repulsion between MPs and porous media, thus contributed to the enhanced MPs deposition. MPs with N fertilizers in solutions more tightly attached onto porous media and thus were more difficult to be re-mobilized by low ionic strength solution elution. Via steric repulsion and increasing electrostatic repulsion between MPs and porous media due to adsorption onto their surfaces, HA could increase MPs transport with N fertilizers in solutions.

    How to cite: Rong, H. and Tong, M.: Transport and deposition behaviors of microplastics in porous media: Co-impacts of N fertilizers and humic acid., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3664, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3664, 2022.

     Amoebas are protists that are widespread in water and soil environments. Some species are pathogenic, inducing potentially lethal effects on humans, making them a major threat to public health. Nonpathogenic amoebas are also of concern because they have the potential to carry a mini-microbiome of bacteria, either transiently or via more long-term stable transport. Due to their resistance to disinfection processes, the physical removal of amoeba by filtration is necessary to prevent their propagation throughout drinking water distribution networks and occurrence in tap water. In this study, a model amoeba species Dictyostelium discoideum was used to study the transport and retention behavior of amoeba spores in porous media. The key factors affecting the transport behavior of amoeba spores in fully saturated media were comprehensively evaluated, with experiments performed using a quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation monitoring (QCM-D) and parallel plate chamber system. The effects of ionic strength (IS) on the deposition of spores were found to be in contrast to the predicted Derjaguin-Landau-Verwey-Overbeek (DLVO) theory that more deposition is observed under lower-IS conditions. The presence of extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) was found to be the main contributor to deposition behavior. Overall, these results provide plausible evidence for the presence of amoeba in tap water. Furthermore, this is one of the first studies to examine the mechanisms affecting the fate of amoeba spores in porous media, providing a significant baseline for future research to minimize the safety risk presented by amoeba in porous media.

    How to cite: Jin, C.: Transport and Retention of Free-Living Amoeba Spores in PorousMedia, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3893, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3893, 2022.

    EGU22-4924 | Presentations | HS8.1.4 | Highlight

    Colloid-facilitated Transport of Heavy Metals in Lake Sediments 

    Sema Sevinç Şengör and Kahraman Ünlü

    This work focuses on the development of a mechanistic Fe(hydr)oxide based (HFO) colloid-facilitated reactive transport model which identifies the impact of HFO colloids on the stability and mobility of heavy metals (Zn and Pb) in example subsurface benthic sediments of Lake Coeur d’Alene (LCdA), USA. Ferrihydrite colloids are considered as the major sorbing phases for heavy metals, where the metal adsorption is implemented by surface complexation using double layer modeling and with electrostatic double layer (EDL) implementation using the dual-domain diffusive mass transfer characteristics of the PHREEQC code. The transport of colloidal phases is implemented by using 4 different advective velocities of the solution and colloidal particles (3 x 10-8 cm/s, 3 x 10-7 cm/s, 9 x 10-7 cm/s, and 3 x 10-6 cm/s), which are within the range reported in the literature for similar porous systems with relevant ranges of Peclet numbers. The advective transport simulation results are also compared with pure diffusive transport of solutes (and HFO) in the system, where the effective diffusion coefficient of colloidal particles is determined by the surface characteristics of ferrihydrite mineral discussed in previous studies. The simulations compare the biogeochemical cycling of metals considering colloidal vs. immobile phases of Fe(hydr)oxide minerals in the lake sediments. The impact of colloidal HFO particles on reactive transport and sorption of heavy metals in a natural environment, integrating coupled biotic reaction network with multiple terminal electron acceptors is presented.

    The simulation results show that the colloidal HFO runs indicate a significant difference in results when advective transport of solutes (and HFO) is considered, as opposed to pure diffusive transport of ions and colloidal particles in this system. The increase in flow velocity observed to result in an increase in the transport of heavy metals with depth with increases in heavy metal profiles, indicating the importance of colloidal transport in the presence of especially advective transport. Hence, the results of the study reveal that when the potential transport of sorbed contaminants with colloidal particles are ignored, the contaminant concentrations in aqueous environments might be underestimated.

    How to cite: Şengör, S. S. and Ünlü, K.: Colloid-facilitated Transport of Heavy Metals in Lake Sediments, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4924, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4924, 2022.

    EGU22-5082 | Presentations | HS8.1.4 | Highlight

    Nanoplastics measurements in Northern and Southern Polar Ice 

    Dušan Materić, Helle Astrid Kjær, Paul Vallelonga, Jean-Louis Tison, Thomas Röckmann, and Rupert Holzinger

    It has been established that various anthropogenic contaminants have already reached all the world’s pristine locations, including the polar regions. While some of those contaminants, such as lead and soot, are decreasing in the environment, thanks to international regulations, other novel contaminants emerge. Plastic pollution has been shown as a durable novel pollutant, and, since recently, smaller and smaller plastics particles have been identified in various environments (air, water and soil). Considerable research already exists measuring the plastics in the 5 mm to micrometre size range (microplastics). However, far less is known about the plastics debris that fragmented to the sub-micrometre size (nanoplastics). As these small particles are light, it is expected that they have already reached the most remote places on Earth, e.g. transported across the globe by air movement. In this work, we used a novel method based on Thermal Desorption – Proton Transfer Reaction – Mass Spectrometry (TD-PTR-MS) to detect and measure nanoplastics of different types in the water sampled from a Greenland firn core (T2015-A5) and a sea ice core from Antarctica. We identify polyethylene (PE), polypropylene (PP), polyethylene terephthalate (PET), polystyrene (PS), polyvinyl chloride (PVC), and Tire wear nanoparticles in the 14 m deep Greenland firn core and PE, PP and PET in sea ice from Antarctica. Nanoplastics mass concentrations were on average 13.2 ng/mL for Greenland firn samples and 52.3 ng/mL for Antarctic sea ice. We further discuss the possible sources of nanoplastics that we found at these remote locations, which likely involve complex processes of plastic circulation (emission from both land and sea surface, atmospheric and marine circulation).

    How to cite: Materić, D., Kjær, H. A., Vallelonga, P., Tison, J.-L., Röckmann, T., and Holzinger, R.: Nanoplastics measurements in Northern and Southern Polar Ice, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5082, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5082, 2022.

    Climate-induced hydro-meteorological extreme events such as the occurrence of heavy precipitations or lack thereof, intense continuous rainfall, flooding, and drought are increasing worldwide and will likely be escalating in the future. Understanding of climate-induced hydro-meteorological extremes is essential to characterize the fate, transport, and survival of pathogens in the environment and strengthen global health security. This study discusses the role of climate-induced hydrological and meteorological extreme events and tipping points on the environmental transmission of pathogenic microorganisms in terrestrial and aquatic systems, waterborne disease outbreaks, and biological threats to human health. Research on the effects of climate-induced hydro-meteorological extremes on the incidence of infectious diseases will allow the development of climate-driven early warning systems and risk forecasting to reduce infectious diseases threats to human populations.

    How to cite: Darnault, C.: Incorporating climate-induced hydro-meteorological extremes in global health security: A waterborne disease perspective, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6565, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6565, 2022.

    EGU22-6821 | Presentations | HS8.1.4

    Coupled impact of proteins with different molecular weight and surface charge on nanoparticle mobility 

    Jianying Shang, Chaorui Yan, and Prabhakar Sharma

    The widely present proteins in the natural environment interact with the released nanoparticles, which change the stability, transport, and fate of nanoparticles. Since proteins with different molecular weights contain various amino acids, the surface properties of the protein are different, and the mechanisms that affect the stability and mobility of nanoparticles are also distinct. Until now, the effects of proteins with different molecular weights and surface charges on nanoparticles have received little attention. In this study, the effects of concentrations and three different molecular weights of protein on the stability and mobility of TiO2 nanoparticles are investigated. Our study found that with the increase in bovine serum albumin (BSA) concentration from 2 to 16 mg L-1, the capacity of the BSA adsorption on the TiO2 surface increased from 37 to 85 mg g-1, and the thickness of the BSA adsorption layer increased from 4.7 to 5.8 nm, causing stronger steric repulsive interaction. When the proteins had similar negative surface charge, the molecular weight decreased from 68 to 14 kDa, the capacity of the protein adsorption on the TiO2 surface increased from dozens to more than 100 mg g-1, and the thickness of the protein adsorption layer increased from 5.4 to 7.5 nm, resulting in stronger steric repulsion. For the proteins with different molecular weights and negative surface charges, the thickness of the protein adsorption layer is the dominant factor for TiO2 stability, and both the steric and electrostatic repulsion played the critical role in TiO2 mobility. This study emphasized that the steric repulsion induced by the thickness of the protein adsorption layer increased nanoparticle stability in aqueous environment, and the coupled impact of steric and electrostatic repulsion due to different molecular weights and negative surface charges of proteins strongly affects nanoparticle mobility in saturated porous media.

    How to cite: Shang, J., Yan, C., and Sharma, P.: Coupled impact of proteins with different molecular weight and surface charge on nanoparticle mobility, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6821, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6821, 2022.

    EGU22-7055 | Presentations | HS8.1.4

    Comparing the transport of pristine and biofouled microplastic particles on rough surfaces 

    Hannes Laermanns, David Haas, Markus Rolf, Florian Steininger, Martin Löder, and Christina Bogner

    Although the occurrence of microplastic particles (MPs) and their impact on different environments have become a widely recognized research topics, their transport mechanisms in terrestrial environments are still understudied. While first research in this field have focused on the abundance of MPs in soils and its vertical distribution, only little is known about the mechanisms of MP transport on sediment and soils surfaces. This might be explained by the challenges of detecting MPs in terrestrial settings.

    Therefore, we investigate the surface transport mechanisms and patterns by using fluorescent MP particles that can be tracked by an advanced complementary metal–oxide–semiconductor (CMOS) high-resolution camera. Within this study we used an experimental set-up including a flume box with surfaces of different roughness and several rates of surface discharge. We traced the pathways of environmentally pristine and biofouled fluorescent amorphously shaped Polystyrene (PS) and Polymethyl methacrylate (PMMA) to analyze how polymer type, biofilm, surface roughness and film thickness influence their transport. Subsequently, time series analysis of the images were performed and evaluated using R software. This included the calculation of particle size, estimation of pathways and path lengths. First results suggest a large influence of the water film thickness of the runoff and the surface roughness. 

    How to cite: Laermanns, H., Haas, D., Rolf, M., Steininger, F., Löder, M., and Bogner, C.: Comparing the transport of pristine and biofouled microplastic particles on rough surfaces, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7055, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7055, 2022.

    EGU22-7987 | Presentations | HS8.1.4

    Bioturbation-driven transport of microplastic fibres in soil 

    Wiebke Mareile Heinze, Denise M. Mitrano, and Geert Cornelis

    Microplastic pollution of the terrestrial environment and its potential impact on ecosystem services are gaining increasing public and scientific attention. Although the number of investigations on microplastic presence in soil under different management systems is growing, knowledge on the potential mobility of microplastics and their spatial distribution within soil is still lacking. In particular, microplastic fibres are often considered less mobile in soil due to their elongated shape and the resulting potential entanglement in pore structures or aggregated soil particles. While these processes may affect their water-driven transport, biologically-driven transport may still occur unimpeded because particles may be ingested by macrofauna such as earthworms. Micro- and nanoplastic transport by earthworms has been previously observed, however, the effect of particle shape on the transport dynamics is still elusive.

    For understanding microplastic fibre transport in soil from a mechanistic perspective, we performed a series of process-studies with deep-burrowing earthworms, i.e. Lumbricus terrestris, in microcosms. We utilized metal-doped fibrous polyethylene terephthalate (PET) microplastics (1.27±0.66 mm) for a facilitated detection through acid extraction and subsequent analysis via inductively-coupled plasma mass-spectrometry. Fibres were spiked into the top of the soil columns of the microcosms, which were sampled according to specific depth segments every 7 days for four weeks. As a result, we were able to quantify fibre transport in soil profiles with a temporal resolution. Earthworms were important drivers of vertical transport of microplastic fibres in the soil, with fibres visibly incorporated into burrow walls. Thus, despite their elongated shape and relative larger size, microplastic fibres are not necessarily immobilized by interactions with soil particles, but continuously affected by burrowing soil organisms. Understanding these transport dynamics and the potential spatial distribution of microplastics of different shapes and sizes in the field is crucial in order to support appropriate sampling schemes for monitoring and for obtaining accurate mass estimates of microplastic pollution of terrestrial ecosystems.

    How to cite: Heinze, W. M., Mitrano, D. M., and Cornelis, G.: Bioturbation-driven transport of microplastic fibres in soil, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7987, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7987, 2022.

    EGU22-9035 | Presentations | HS8.1.4

    Fate and transport of titanium dioxide nanoparticles in porous media 

    Rima Manik and Seetha Narayanan

    Fate and transport of titanium dioxide nanoparticles in porous media

    Rima Manik, N. Seetha

    Department of Civil Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology Hyderabad, Kandi, Sangareddy-502284, India

     

    Abstract

    Increasing use of engineered nanoparticles in various fields has led to its inevitable release into the natural environment thereby causing soil and groundwater contamination. Soil is inhabited by various types of bacteria, which forms biofilm on the grain surface. Biofilms have been found to influence the fate & transport of nanoparticles. In this study, the transport behavior of titanium dioxide (nTiO2) nanoparticles through soil is studied through laboratory column experiments in the presence and absence of soil biofilm. Escherichia coli BL21 strain is used for the biofilm formation. It is observed that the retention of nTiO2 is larger in the presence of biofilm than in its absence. This indicates that biofilm acts as a more favourable attachment site for TiO2 than the bare soil. The column experiment results are further modelled using a 1D advection-dispersion-deposition equation. The mechanisms predominantly observed in the experiment are straining and ripening.

    How to cite: Manik, R. and Narayanan, S.: Fate and transport of titanium dioxide nanoparticles in porous media, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9035, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9035, 2022.

    EGU22-9811 | Presentations | HS8.1.4

    Visualization of fluorescent microplastics in soil column experiments in different depths 

    Christina Bogner, Markus Rolf, and Hannes Laermanns

    Microplastics are ubiquitous in the terrestrial environment and have also been detected in soils. However, how microplastics are transported vertically in the soil is still a matter of research. Especially, the influence of precipitation, preferential pathways and bioturbation on the vertical translocation of microplastics is still unclear. One cause is the time-consuming microplastic analysis in soils that requires substantial sample pretreatment. Additionally, we are still lacking a standard protocol to quantify and qualify microplastic particles in environmental samples.

    Therefore, in this study, we present a method for irrigation experiments with soil column to study the vertical transport of microplastics. In the upper 2 cm of the column, fluorescent microplastics are added. We spike the irrigation water with deuterium oxide to trace the breakthrough of the water during the irrigation experiment. After the irrigation experiment, the soil column is frozen and subsequently cut in 2 cm slices and photographed under UV illumination. Then, we process the images by the software MP-VAT to analyse the distribution of the MP particles within the slices and within the soil column.

    How to cite: Bogner, C., Rolf, M., and Laermanns, H.: Visualization of fluorescent microplastics in soil column experiments in different depths, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9811, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9811, 2022.

    EGU22-11802 | Presentations | HS8.1.4

    On modeling the fate of microplastics along river networks 

    Nerea Portillo De Arbeloa, Alessandra Marzadri, and Alberto Bellin

    The increasing amount of microplastics (hereafter MPs) in freshwater ecosystems appears as a highly relevant environmental issue as MPs represent a group of contaminants of emerging concern responsible for water pollution worldwide. Within MPs are included particles with the potential to enter the environment, persist in it and be easily ingested by aquatic organisms with important adverse effects on both the ecosystems and human health. Research has revealed that the presence of MPs in organisms can cause negative effects and the risk associated with their long-term exposure is still under debate. Within freshwater ecosystems, streams and rivers represent one of the most important delivery vectors responsible for the transfer of MPs from terrestrial to marine environments. Therefore, understanding their transport dynamics became crucial to propose mitigation strategies and to manage and possibly reduce adverse health effects. Here, we present a simple model able to predict the fate of MPs along the different reaches that compose a river network. The model solves the general advection-dispersion-reaction equation (ADRE) along each reach of the river network considering the release of MPs from the Waste Water Treatment Plants (WWTPs). Using a combination of free access databases (MERIT, ReachHydro) and computational algorithms we estimate MPs concentrations at different locations in the river network. The model capability to capture MPs transport was tested by using available literature data where MPs samples were collected upstream and downstream of WWTPs. Our proposed method was able to satisfactorily reproduce the measured values proving a useful tool to understand the role of river networks in controlling the fate of MPs and to provide the basis for introducing suitable mitigation strategies.

    How to cite: Portillo De Arbeloa, N., Marzadri, A., and Bellin, A.: On modeling the fate of microplastics along river networks, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11802, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11802, 2022.

    EGU22-12098 | Presentations | HS8.1.4

    TD-PTR-MS for nanoplastics research – high sensitivity and big challenges 

    Dušan Materić, Hanne Ødegaard Notø, Sophie Mosselmans, and Rupert Holzinger

    Thermal Desorption – Proton Transfer Reaction – Mass Spectrometry (TD-PTR-MS) is a sensitive method capable of measuring nanoplastics in environmental samples. The method works on the principle that different types of plastic have different melting points (also different from many organics in the matrix), and they release rich (semi)volatile organic compounds signal (smells) when heated up. A gradual increase of the sample temperature combined with real-time, quantitative mass spectrometry (PTR-MS) allowed us to selectively measure the type and concentration of the nanoplastics. Data processing involves multiple ions associated with thermal degradation products of plastics, which ensures selectivity in identifying different plastic types.

    However, the method is procedural and challenging. The sampling practice, sample treatment, instrument's operational settings, and data processing can result in large uncertainties, which need to be addressed in each experiment. Here we discuss these analytical challenges in the context of complex environmental nanoplastic measurement and provide recommendations for good experimental practice and robust quality control.

    How to cite: Materić, D., Notø, H. Ø., Mosselmans, S., and Holzinger, R.: TD-PTR-MS for nanoplastics research – high sensitivity and big challenges, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12098, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12098, 2022.

    EGU22-12462 | Presentations | HS8.1.4

    Microplastic water repellency reduced by ferrihydrite coating 

    Andreas Cramer, Johanna Schmidtmann, Anders Kaestner, and Andrea Carminati

    Pathways of Microplastic (MP) into ecosystems are manifold and range from agricultural mulching practices to atmospheric deposition with soil being considered the largest sink of MP in terrestrial ecosystems. Once deposited there, MP is posing a hydrophobic surface addition. Former experiments showed that pristine MP can cause lower water saturation of pore spaces and so change the liquid configuration within a porous network. If water cannot reach MP, biotic degradation might be hindered. However, in natural soil systems MP can be coated over time by soil abundant substances e.g., iron compounds with the potential effect of decreasing their hydrophobicity. We hypothesize that: 1) ferrihydrite pre-coated MP shows reduced hydrophobicity; 2) in-situ wetting and drying cycles with ferrihydrite leads to partial coating of MP.

    We tested these hypotheses by applying hotspots of MP, pre-coated and pristine, to sand in rectangular columns and performed neutron imaging during capillary rise. Neutron imaging allowed for visualizing and quantifying liquid dynamics and configuration. Water was used for the pre-coated MP (n=6) variants and ferrihydrite suspension (100 mg L-1) in three wetting and drying cycles for the pristine MP (n=6) variants. The utilized MP are polystyrene (PS, 20-75 µm) and polyethylene terephthalate (PET, 20-75 µm). The grain size of sand was 0.7-1.2 mm. Pre-coating was achieved by shaking the raw material for 3 h in a 100 mg L-1 ferrihydrite suspension and subsequent drying in a sieve supported by a vacuum pump.

    Capillary rise of water into pristine MP variants exhibited zero water saturation at the hotspot and water movement around the MP aggregation was observed. Capillary rise of water into pre-coated MP variants differ in result by polymer type. While pre-coated PS is still hydrophobic, the pore space of pre-coated PET was completely water saturated. The rising water accelerated towards the hotspot due to its lower matric potential compared to sand.

    Capillary rise of ferrihydrite suspension in wetting and drying cycles also showed varying results according to polymer type. While there is no effect on water saturation on PS in the hotspot after three wetting cycles, PET exhibits a slightly higher water saturation during the second wetting but stagnating in the third.

    Our results suggest that ferrihydrite coating, being only one of numerous potential coating agents, can bond to MP and change its surface polarity. Differences in completeness of coating can be explained by inherent chemical and physical properties of different polymer types. But once hydrophilic, completely, or only part of the surface, water flow induced colonization and migration of microorganisms and their enzymes can proceed and biotic degradation can take place. The open question lies within the time frame necessary to overcome MP’s inherent hydrophobicity.

    How to cite: Cramer, A., Schmidtmann, J., Kaestner, A., and Carminati, A.: Microplastic water repellency reduced by ferrihydrite coating, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12462, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12462, 2022.

    EGU22-12906 | Presentations | HS8.1.4

    In the exploration of novel Surface Enhanced Raman (SERS) approaches towards the challenging detection of Per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) 

    Zoi Lada, Georgios Mathioudakis, Amaia Soto Beobide, Konstantinos Andrikopoulos, and George Voyiatzis

    Per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) are a group of man-made chemicals used in a variety of industries around the globe since the 1940s due to their water- and oil-repellent properties. Perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA) and perfluorooctane sulfonic acid (PFOS) have been the most extensively produced and studied of these chemicals and their toxicity has been well characterized in humans and animal models. Both chemicals are very persistent in the environment and in the human body – meaning they don’t break down and they can accumulate over time. Currently, environmental and epidemiological PFAS analysis is predominantly based on high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) coupled with tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS). As the conventional analytical methods for the detection of PFASs utilize techniques based on ion-pair extraction of the analytes and quantification by MS, they can detect concentrations as low as ppt. However, they typically require, off-site analyses, are very time consuming, relatively expensive and matrix-matched calibration standards should be routinely employed. Furthermore, although these methods have demonstrated reliable results, substantial challenges still exist in increasing the number of PFASs detected and quantified in a single analytical run, working with varied sample matrices, and developing more efficient sample preparation strategies. The development of sensors to detect contaminants in environmental samples is a growing topic in environmental monitoring and management. Many limitations within existing methods of PFAS determination can be addressed through the development of PFAS-detecting sensors. One promising and sophisticated spectroscopic technique is Surface-Enhanced Raman Spectroscopy (SERS), which combines the detection limits of chromatographic techniques and the versatility and speed of the spectroscopic ones. SERS has great potential as an analytical technique based on the unique molecular signatures presented even by structurally similar analyte species and the minimal interference of scattering from water when sampling in aqueous environments. Since the SERS method can provide information which ascertains chemical and molecular composition of a sample, it is usually regarded as a promising tool suitable for the selective detection of pollutants. In this study, Surface Enhanced Raman Scattering (SERS) is explored towards the fast, accurate and versatile identification and quantification of several PFAS along with their possible degradation and transformation products. To that end, different approaches is followed, based mainly on the designed modification/functionalization of Au and Ag nanoparticles (NPs) in colloidal suspensions and the exploitation of the adsorption selectivity of Metal Organic Frameworks for PFAS in order to develop MOF-based SERS substrates. This novel and challenging task bearing both scientific and technological aspects will potentially lead to the development of a sensitive and robust SERS application for PFAS detection suitable for environmental and/or biomonitoring.

    Acknowledgments: This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No101037509.

     

    How to cite: Lada, Z., Mathioudakis, G., Soto Beobide, A., Andrikopoulos, K., and Voyiatzis, G.: In the exploration of novel Surface Enhanced Raman (SERS) approaches towards the challenging detection of Per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12906, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12906, 2022.

    The hyporheic zone is a thin porous sedimentary interface that connects the river to the water table. It is a place where a large part of the groundwater transits and mixes with surface water. Recent studies point to the key role of this zone, a natural biological reactor at the groundwater-river interface, in altering the nitrogen and carbon cycles, capturing and releasing contaminants and buffering river temperatures. Past studies have suggested that, locally hyporheic fluxes can overtake groundwater-river exchanges, although the physical conditions (permeability, roughness, head, ...) under which such scenario occurs remains unclear. In this study, geophysical monitoring of electromagnetic conductivity along a river reach (Sélune, France) was used to identify longitudinal variations in bed permeability, and identify potential hotspot of hyporheic exchanges.
    In practice, we will measure electrical conductivity at different depths into the river sediment using the electromagnetic instrument “CMD explorer”. The instrument is displaced over the river surface using a floating board. A two-layer model is then considered to separate the contribution of sediment bed and water column conductivities. Based on the law (Archie, 1942) in a saturated environment, we link measured variations in electrical conductivity to variations in sediment properties such as pore volume change. In parallel, manual permeability measurements of the riverbed were performed to compare and validate the permeability deduced by the electromagnetic method.
    The recent removal of two dams over the Sélune river which was associated with an abrupt change of transported sediment load motivates us to perform time-lapse measurements of electromagnetic conductivity in several sectors upstream and downstream of the dams, before and after removal. Such repeated measure provides interesting data on the time scales of bed clogging processes and its impact on hyporheic exchanges.

    How to cite: Mouhamadoul, M. B.: Use of electromagnetic tools to evaluate the risk of silting of the ‘Sélune’ river bed following the dismantling of the 'Vezins' and 'Roche Qui Boit' dams., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1234, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1234, 2022.

    EGU22-2636 | Presentations | HS8.1.6

    The zeta potential of quartz. Surface complexation modelling to elucidate high salinity measurements 

    Philippe Leroy, Shuai Li, Alexis Maineult, and Jan Vinogradov

    The zeta potential is a measureable electrical potential of paramount importance to understand the electrochemical properties of colloids and grains in contact with brines. However, the zeta potential remains poorly understood because it takes place at the nanoscale of the electrical double layer on the mineral surface. Streaming potential measurements on quartz-rich Fontainebleau and Lochaline sandstones carried out at high salinity (above 0.1 M NaCl) yield surprisingly high zeta potential values. We found that placing the shear plane, where the zeta potential is defined, slightly closer to the mineral surface than the outer Helmholtz plane significantly improves the predictions of the zeta potential and surface charge density of quartz at high salinity as well as the values of the equilibrium constant describing sodium adsorption in the Stern layer. Our results have strong implications for the modelling of the electrochemical properties of minerals in contact with highly saline solutions.

    How to cite: Leroy, P., Li, S., Maineult, A., and Vinogradov, J.: The zeta potential of quartz. Surface complexation modelling to elucidate high salinity measurements, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2636, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2636, 2022.

    EGU22-4469 | Presentations | HS8.1.6

    Application of Electrical Resistivity Tomography (ERT) to study to soil water and salt movement under drip irrigation in a saline soil cultivated with melon 

    Agnese Innocenti, Veronica Pazzi, Marco Napoli, Riccardo Fanti, and Simone Orlandini

    The issue of salinity in agricultural soils is a growing problem. Soil with a high sodium content in the root growth zone compromises plant health and growth. Irrigation is one of the main techniques used to reclaim high-salt soils, as water dilutes the sodium concentration. In this study, electrical resistivity tomography (ERT) is proposed as a reliable non-invasive technique to quantify sault movement during the irrigation process. The first step was to identify the best set up of electrodes for this type of investigation. 3D-ERT measurements were carried out in two different campaigns to identify the most suitable electrode distribution. The study area is a segment of land, located in Barbaruta (GR, Italy) and used for the cultivation of melons. The investigation site is characterised by irrigated soils in which an accumulation of sodium has occurred over time. To detect the movement of salt during the irrigation phases, ERT surveys were carried out before, during, and after the irrigation phases.

    Considering the objective of the experiment, the measurement carried out during the first campaign (July 2021) was performed by creating a 3D grid in which the 72 electrodes were spaced 0.2 m apart and arranged in 5 parallel lines, spaced 0.2 m apart, two of which (lines 1 and 5) were 2.8 m long, for a total of 15 electrodes, and three of which (lines 2, 3 and 4) were 2.6 m long, for a total of 14 electrodes. This configuration made it possible to include two melon plants.

    The survey carried out in the second campaign (August 2021) was carried out with a 3D grid in which the 72 electrodes were spaced 0.3 m apart and arranged in three parallel lines, 0.3 m apart and 6.9 m long, for a total of 24 electrodes in each line. This configuration allowed five melon plants to be incorporated. A Dipole-Dipole configuration was adopted for all the acquisition of electrical resistivity data. The commercial software ViewLab 3D was used to process the geoelectric data.

    Data analysis showed that the range of conductivity values increases from dry to wet soil conditions, and conductivity increases with depth. The ERTs sections, carried out after the irrigation phase, showed areas where conductivity decreases over time during irrigation, this can be explained by the leaching of salts because of water input. While other areas show higher conductivity after irrigation, and this may mean not only an increase in water content but also a displacement of salts with water input. For this reason, further analysis is required, including the use of Induced Polarisation (IP).

    The test showed that the best configuration is the one with the electrodes arranged in three lines, as it allows more plants to be incorporated.

    The test also led to the need to avoid stressing the plants during the measurement phase. This made it necessary to create a special set of electrodes to be installed during the transplanting phase, so as not to disturb the plants during the growth phas.

    How to cite: Innocenti, A., Pazzi, V., Napoli, M., Fanti, R., and Orlandini, S.: Application of Electrical Resistivity Tomography (ERT) to study to soil water and salt movement under drip irrigation in a saline soil cultivated with melon, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4469, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4469, 2022.

    EGU22-5419 | Presentations | HS8.1.6

    Application of Electromagnetic Induction Method and Distributed Process-Based Modeling for Optimized Soil Water Variability Assessment 

    Mohammad Farzamian, Tiago B. Ramos, Ana R. Oliveira, Hanaa Darouich, Nadia Castanheira, Ana Marta Paz, and Maria Gonçalves

    Irrigated agriculture plays a crucial role in the food supply in many countries where ecological conditions are characterized by warm and dry summers with high solar radiation and evapotranspiration rates. Evaluating spatio-temporal variability of soil water is critical for the delignating of management zones and optimal irrigation scheduling. However, the soil water content variability is normally obtained using simple water balance models and for representative areas, not taking into consideration the variability of soil properties. This is because for large-scale studies, the traditional sampling method is extremely difficult to implement and it remains critical to finding alternative methods of characterization of soil texture, which is required for soil hydraulic parameters assessment.

    Geophysical techniques such as electromagnetic induction (EMI) provide enormous advantages compared to soil sampling because they allow for in-depth and non-invasive analysis, covering large areas in less time and at a lower cost. we carried out EMI surveys in a 23ha almond field, located in Alentejo, Portugal to evaluate the potential use of this methodology in mapping spatial distribution of soil texture in this water-scarce region. We firstly inverted field apparent conductivity data (σa) using a Quasi-3D inversion algorithm in order to obtain 3D electromagnetic conductivity images (EMCI) of the real soil electrical conductivity (σ) with depth. Afterward, we evaluated the possibility of establishing a linear regression (LR) relationship between σ and soil texture collected from 13 soil sample locations to a depth of 0.60 m. We concluded that it is possible to establish a relatively good LR between σ and clay and sand, allowing us to convert EMCI to clay and sand content maps and generate these maps for different depts. With this information at hand, pedotransfer functions were applied to define the soil hydraulic parameters necessary to run the distributed model and map the within soil variability at the field scale.

    we used the MOHID-Land distributed process-based model to compute the variability of the soil water balance components in this field, at a resolution of 5m. Irrigation data was monitored on-site, at two locations, while weather data was extracted from a local meteorological station. The distributed modeling approach included the definition of potential evapotranspiration fluxes computed from the product of the reference evapotranspiration obtained according to the FAO56 Penman-Monteith equation and a crop coefficient for each stage of almond’s growing season, the variable-saturated flow using the Richards equation, and root zone water stress following a macroscopic approach. Modeling results are then used to present the maps of the variability of the seasonal actual crop transpiration and soil evaporation, the mean soil moisture, seasonal runoff, and seasonal percolation, which are then used to propose management zones for improving irrigation water use in the studied almond field.

    Acknowledgments

    This work was developed in the scope of SOIL4EVER “Sustainable use of soil and water for improving crops productivity in irrigated areas” project supported by FCT, grant no. PTDC/ASP-SOL/28796/2017.

     

     

     

     

    How to cite: Farzamian, M., Ramos, T. B., Oliveira, A. R., Darouich, H., Castanheira, N., Paz, A. M., and Gonçalves, M.: Application of Electromagnetic Induction Method and Distributed Process-Based Modeling for Optimized Soil Water Variability Assessment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5419, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5419, 2022.

    EGU22-5638 | Presentations | HS8.1.6

    Spectral Induced Polarization: Laboratory measurements on artificial soils with varying water saturation, salinity and clay content 

    Veronika Iván, Benjamin Mary, Nimrod Schwartz, Massimiliano Ghinassi, and Giorgio Cassiani

    Geoelectrical methods provide diverse toolsets to image the subsurface and monitor its water dynamics. These observations might be crucial in arid areas, where the structure and function of agricultural and natural ecosystems are dramatically determined by water availability. Dryland ecosystems can be characterized by heterogeneous soil cover, high salt content in upper soil layers and low levels of soil moisture. However, understanding the combined effect of soil water content, salinity and soil composition on the electrical signal remains a challenging issue. Recent studies demonstrated the sensitivity of the IP method to water content [1; 2], clay content [3] and salinity [4; 5]. [4] noted that the quadrature conductivity is weakly dependent on the pore fluid salinity, thus, it might be used to separate between pore water salinity and water content.

    Here, in a laboratory experiment series, we conducted spectral measurements on artificial soils in small sample holders to observe under controlled conditions how the IP response is affected by water saturation and salinity. This laboratory setup with manipulated gradients of water content and salinity levels allowed to perform measurements with high accuracy, and establish relationships between the electrical and hydrological properties of unconsolidated deposits or soils. Sand-clay mixtures were used, consisting of very fine-coarse sand and clay powder (Ca-montmorillonite) which were mixed during multiple dry-wet mixing cycles with gradually growing clay content (0-8 %). The samples were packed under dry conditions and afterward saturated with tap water. The decreasing water content was obtained by air injection with growing pressure (0,05-2,5 bar). At the second phase of the experiment, the salinity was increased through the pore water (NaCl solution up to the electrical conductivity of 7000 μS/cm). Regression analysis is carried out on the obtained dataset to calibrate the sensitivity of the complex resistivity to the changing parameters at different frequencies. Based on the preliminary results, the method may have the potential for the construction of a pedophysical model, allowing the field application for water content monitoring in arid areas.

    [1] Breede, K. et al. (2012) ‘Spectral induced polarization measurements on variably saturated sand-clay mixtures’, Near Surface Geophysics, 10(6), pp. 479–489.

    [2] Kremer, T. et al. (2016) ‘Modelling the spectral induced polarization response of water-saturated sands in the intermediate frequency range (10 2 –10 5 Hz) using mechanistic and empirical approaches’, Geophysical Journal International, 207(2), pp. 1303–1312.

    [3] Osterman, G. et al. (2019) ‘Effect of clay content and distribution on hydraulic and geophysical properties of synthetic sand-clay mixtures’, GEOPHYSICS, 84(4), pp. E239–E253.

    [4] Grunat, D.A. (2013) Effects of soil saturation and pore fluid salinity on complex conductivity. PhD Thesis. Rutgers University-Graduate School-Newark.

    [5] Mendieta, A. et al. (2021) ‘Spectral Induced Polarization Characterization of Non‐Consolidated Clays for Varying Salinities—An Experimental Study’, Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth, 126(4).

    How to cite: Iván, V., Mary, B., Schwartz, N., Ghinassi, M., and Cassiani, G.: Spectral Induced Polarization: Laboratory measurements on artificial soils with varying water saturation, salinity and clay content, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5638, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5638, 2022.

    EGU22-5861 | Presentations | HS8.1.6

    Combined use of structurally-coupled and petrophysically-coupled joint inversion for the characterization of rock glaciers 

    Mirko Pavoni, Jacopo Boaga, Florian Wagner, Alexander Bast, and Marcia Phillips

    The monitoring of alpine rock glaciers has both scientific and economic relevance. The degradation of mountain permafrost is a relevant proxy of climate change and global warming, but also a possible source of hazards for mountain communities since it can trigger natural processes such as rockfalls, debris flows, and floods. Geophysical techniques have been used to study these periglacial forms, particularly electrical and seismic refraction methods. Nevertheless, the independent data processing applied to these measurements does not lead to quantitative estimation of the physical components (air, water, ice, and rock) in the frozen subsoil. Moreover, the structural interpretation of the ground with independent resistivity and seismic sections can introduce ambiguities. To quantify the composition of the mountain permafrost, Wagner et al. (2019) developed a petrophysical joint inversion approach of electrical resistivity and seismic refraction datasets. We applied this method to several datasets collected in the rock glaciers of Schafberg (Engadin, Switzerland) and Ritigraben (Canton of Valais, Switzerland). To estimate the parameters in Archie’s and Timur’s laws, we performed the petrophysical joint inversion with a range of plausible values, selecting the ones that guaranteed the lowest final root-mean-square (RMS) error between the model response and the observed data. Our approach can be applied wherever information from boreholes is unavailable. This is a common situation in rock glacier studies since drilling in high mountain environments is very complicated and expensive. Finally, to improve the quality of individual resistivity and seismic velocity sections, we applied the structurally-coupled cooperative joint inversion method to our datasets, developed by Günther and Rücker (2008). This approach is based on the exchange of structural information between the independent geophysical inversions of electrical and seismic datasets. The process is driven by 3 different coupling parameters and the choice of their values has been done again by running the inversion with a range of values, choosing those that guaranteed the lowest final RMS. This method can be useful to better define the active layer thickness and the lower boundary of frozen ground. From the obtained results, it is clear that combined use of petrophysically-coupled and structurally-coupled joint inversion can represent a significant improvement for the characterization of mountain permafrost, in comparison to the traditional independent geophysical inversions, even in the absence of prior information from boreholes. In future studies, both structural and petrophysical coupling could be incorporated into a single inversion framework to adaptively allow structural agreement if quantitative petrophysical agreement cannot be satisfied.


    References
    -    Wagner, F.M., Mollaret, C., Günther, T., Kemna, A., & Hauck, C. (2019). Quantitative imaging of water, ice, and air in permafrost systems through petrophysical joint inversion of seismic refraction and electrical resistivity data. Geophysical Journal International, 219(3), 1866–1875. doi:10.1093/gji/ggz402.
    -    Günther, T., & Rücker, C. (2008). A new joint inversion approach applied to the combined tomography of DC resistivity and seismic refraction data. Symposium on the application of geophysics to engineering and environmental problems 2006 (pp. 1196–1202). doi:10.4133/1.2923578.

    How to cite: Pavoni, M., Boaga, J., Wagner, F., Bast, A., and Phillips, M.: Combined use of structurally-coupled and petrophysically-coupled joint inversion for the characterization of rock glaciers, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5861, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5861, 2022.

    EGU22-6956 | Presentations | HS8.1.6

    Time-lapse multi-frequency EMI mapping and ERT profiling for the characterization of soil water behavior in mountain catchments. 

    Giorgio Cassiani, Matteo Censini, Paolo Nasta, Carolina Allocca, Benedetto Sica, Ugo Lazzaro, Caterina Mazzitelli, Matteo Verdone, Andrea Dani, Francesca Manca di Villahermosa, Daniele Penna, and Nunzio Romano

    Hydrological processes along mountain hillslopes involve complex interaction between soil storage and surface and subsurface flow, drainage and evapotranspiration. To capture this complexity, time-lapse extensive and intensive measurements are needed, potentially capable of providing spatially dense information in 3D and time frequent data. To this end, hydro-geophysical methods (ground penetration radar, GPR, electromagnetic induction, EMI and electrical resistivity tomography, ERT) based on electrical and electromagnetic laws are widely used as they naturally link to the electrical properties of soil moisture. ERT produces, especially in time lapse mode and using permanent installations, very detailed images of the water dynamics along hillslopes. While ERT requires galvanic contact with the ground, and thus relatively slow operations, EMI can be applied over large areas in a very short time. This method has been used for decades, mainly to produce apparent electrical conductivity (ECa) maps. Only recently, inversion of EMI data as a function of depth has become a viable practice.

    In this work, we present two cases of hillslope monitoring using non-invasive methods, both performed as part of the WATZON project, funded by the Italian Ministry of University and Research (MIUR). The first case is the Mediterranean catchment of the Alento River, in southern Italy. The monitoring was carried out using 7 different EMI surveys, acquired in multifrequency mode (FDEM) between August 2020 and December 2021. The purpose of this survey was to characterize the structure of the basin’s subsoil within the first few meters, as well as to record the variation of electrical conductivity (EC) associated with seasonal variations. The second case is related to the Apennines catchment of the Re Della Pietra, located at the border between Tuscany and Emilia-Romagna in central Italy. The monitoring was carried out through 6 different EMI surveys, acquired in multifrequency mode (FDEM) between August 2020 and May 2021. The purpose of this survey was to characterize the structure of the basin’s subsoil within the first few meters, as well as to record the variation of electrical conductivity (EC) associated with seasonal variations. Furthermore, ERT measurements were carried out along a fixed line on the ground, according to the direction of the maximum slope. The combination of EMI and ERT proved particularly effective in delineating the hydrologic dynamics of the hillslope.

    How to cite: Cassiani, G., Censini, M., Nasta, P., Allocca, C., Sica, B., Lazzaro, U., Mazzitelli, C., Verdone, M., Dani, A., Manca di Villahermosa, F., Penna, D., and Romano, N.: Time-lapse multi-frequency EMI mapping and ERT profiling for the characterization of soil water behavior in mountain catchments., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6956, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6956, 2022.

    EGU22-7568 | Presentations | HS8.1.6

    Soil compaction imaging through Pedophysical Joint Inversion: a Northeastern Italy case study 

    Alberto Carrera, Mirko Pavoni, Ilaria Piccoli, Jacopo Boaga, Giorgio Cassiani, and Francesco Morari

     

    One of the major threats to global arable lands is represented by soil compaction, mainly due to agricultural traffic. Modern heavy agricultural machinery and unsuitable soil moisture conditions might irreversibly induce soil compaction that, in turn, adversely affects soil quality and ecosystem. Restriction to root penetration alongside impaired water and air fluxes are a few principal drawbacks of compacted soils, resulting in significant ecological and economic damage to society.
    However, traditional methods to study soil compaction are limited by punctual nature and not-in-situ conditions.
    In this context, the purpose of this work was to combine different non-invasive geophysical techniques, with a joint inversion approach of the acquired datasets, to study the complexity of the soil structure. In detail, we tried to adapt the petrophysical joint inversion developed in permafrost systems, combining geoelectrical and seismic soundings to characterize the subsoil structure in compacted and non-compacted soils. This methodology rests on the conjunction of seismic refraction tomography (RST) and electrical resistivity tomography (ERT), acquired on the very line, through a representative pedophysical model, able to quantitatively estimate the fractions of investigated soil phases (e.g., air, water, and matrix fractions).
    The survey was conducted on an arable field of “L. Toniolo” Padova University experimental farm. The reliability of the obtained models was compared with direct measurements of volumetric water content, bulk density, and penetration resistance along the survey line. Preliminary results showed that the methodology might be a promising tool for spatio-temporal evaluation of soil structure evolution as related to soil compaction.

    How to cite: Carrera, A., Pavoni, M., Piccoli, I., Boaga, J., Cassiani, G., and Morari, F.: Soil compaction imaging through Pedophysical Joint Inversion: a Northeastern Italy case study, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7568, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7568, 2022.

    EGU22-10364 | Presentations | HS8.1.6

    Monitoring of an aquifer thermal storage system in the field scale using crosshole ERT 

    Susann Birnstengel, Thomas Günther, Marco Pohle, Götz Hornbruch, Johannes Nordbeck, Uta Ködel, Ulrike Werban, and Peter Dietrich

    Heat storage in aquifer structures takes on greater significance and is therefore an important subject for risk assessment and impact analysis on groundwater resources. Geophysical methods contribute substantially to the observation of hydrogeological processes by providing information
    about physical subsurface properties. In order to allow for correct process interpretation, it is essential to find and evaluate their relationship
    to the corresponding rock-physical parameters. Therefore a heat injection experiment and a corresponding monitoring system have been developed
    and established in a shallow aquifer environment characterized by quaternary glaciofluvial sediments. The focus is on the investigation of coherence between geophysical proxies and the temperature distribution in the near-surface. A geological subsurface model derived from geophysical and hydrological pre-investigations has been used to simulate heat distribution and resulting electrical conductivity variations in the affected area.
    Tests for thermal energy storage and extraction have been conducted via Aquifer thermal energy storage (ATES) system. With time-lapse inversion
    we want to detect the direct impact of changing temperature distribution in the subsurface on the related electrical resistivity when heating the
    aquifer up to 80 °C. Rein et al. (2004) state that electrical conductivity of the subsurface depends to a great extent on water saturation. Heating
    up the governed pore water by 1 °C results in a linear relative electrical conductivity increase of 2.5% (Dachnov, 1962). Different inhole and cross-
    hole arrays at the test site assure good coverage of the heated area and pass through the monitoring routine once a day. The ongoing injection
    cycles consist of a heating period of 2 weeks, a down time of 3 weeks, an extraction period of 2 weeks and another down-time of 1 week followed by
    the next cycle. We prove the applicability of heat injection and extraction monitoring by combined crosshole ERT (and seismic) and correlated
    the resistivity with the directly measured temperature data of the temperature sensors additionally installed in the boreholes. At the highest
    observed temperature level of 75 °C the electrical conductivity increases by a factor of three. 3D inversion allows for a direct reference to the temperature distribution in the subsurface. This study provides information about the resolution capacity of crosshole ERT for heat storage systems
    in shallow aquifers.
    These activities have been done within the follow-on TestUM-Aquifer Project - TestUM-II ”Cyclic high temperature - Aquifer thermal energy storage (ATES) experiment” funded by the BMBF (grant 03G0898A/B).

    How to cite: Birnstengel, S., Günther, T., Pohle, M., Hornbruch, G., Nordbeck, J., Ködel, U., Werban, U., and Dietrich, P.: Monitoring of an aquifer thermal storage system in the field scale using crosshole ERT, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10364, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10364, 2022.

    EGU22-10924 | Presentations | HS8.1.6

    Understanding hydrocarbon fate and transport in peat soils using column experiments 

    Pankaj Kumar Gupta, Behrad Gharedaghloo, and Jonathan S. Price

    Increasing hydrocarbon resource developments in and around peatlands impose risks of petroleum hydrocarbon spills on these important wetland landscapes. Despite the potential severity of consequences, there is a big gap of knowledge on parameter values controlling liquid hydrocarbons’ redistributions in peat soil after a spill. Complete excavation of contaminated peat soil is a common practice in contaminated sites, but destroys wetland function, and contributes nothing to the understanding of the problem. To partially fill this knowledge gap and to examine potential remediation strategies that are less destructive, we examined the fate, transport, and degradation of petroleum hydrocarbon non-aqueous phase liquids (NAPLs) in peat soils using a series of column tests on intact peat monoliths. Three-phase flow experiments with numerical simulations provided values of multiphase flow parameters that control NAPL redistribution in a variety of peat soils. We observed that water table fluctuations reduced residual NAPL saturation from 8.1-11.3% to 7.7-9.5%; increased headspace concentrations of n-C8 and n-C12 an average 163.7% and 13.4%, due to volatilization. Results also illustrated that water table dynamics promoted growth (from 104 CFU/gram to 106 CFU/gram peat) of specialized microbial communities in NAPL polluted peat columns. These results suggest that water table fluctuation can be a suitable tool for physical and microbial NAPL removal in peat soils, and for the first time provide evidence for it. We also observed a high ratio of Proteobacteria to Acidobacteria in the NAPL contaminated zone, which can be linked to the restoration success for a NAPL polluted peatland. The results could help environmental scientists in forecasting the behavior of spilled non-aqueous phase liquids (NAPLs) in peatland.

    How to cite: Gupta, P. K., Gharedaghloo, B., and Price, J. S.: Understanding hydrocarbon fate and transport in peat soils using column experiments, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10924, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10924, 2022.

    EGU22-11720 | Presentations | HS8.1.6

    In situ monitoring of rain infiltration and evapotranspiration in the critical zone using self-potentials 

    Damien Jougnot, Bertille Loiseau, Simon Carrière, Cédric Champollion, Emily Voytek, and Nolwenn Lesparre

    Characterizing and monitoring water flow in the critical zone is of uttermost importance to understand the water cycle. Water link several process within critical zone from aquifer recharge and solute transfer to eco-hydrology, many eco-systemic services and biogeochemical reactions. However, the in situ quantification of water flow is technically challenging using traditional hydrological methods and numerous gaps of knowledge remain. The self-potential (SP) method is a passive geophysical method that relies on the measurement of naturally occurring electrical field. One of the contributions to the SP signal is the streaming potential, which is of particular interest in hydrogeophysics as it is directly related to both the water flow and porous medium properties. Unlike tensiometers and other point sensors, which use the measurement of state (e.g., matric pressure) at different locations to infer the intervening processes, the SP method measures signals generated by dynamic processes (e.g. water movement). However, the amplitude of the SP signal depends on multiple soil properties which are dependent to soil type, moisture content, and water chemistry (composition and pH). During the last decades, many models have been proposed to relate the SP signal to the water flow. In this contribution, we will present a soil-specific petrophysical model to describe the electrokinetic coupling generated from different water fluxes in the critical zone: rain water infiltration and water uptake from tree-roots. We tested a fully coupled hydrogeophysical approach on a large SP dataset collected in a two-dimensional array at the base of a Douglas-fir tree (Psuedotsuga menziesii) in the H.J. Andrews Experimental Forest in central Oregon, USA. We collected SP measurements over five months to provide insight on the propagation of transpiration signals into the subsurface with depth and under variable soil moisture. The coupled model, which included a root-water uptake term linked to measured sap flux, reproduced both the long-term and diel variations in SP measurements, thus confirming that SP has potential to provide spatially and temporally dense measurements of transpiration-induced changes in water flow. Similar set-ups are being installed on several test-sites of the French Critical Zone observatory network, OZCAR: Larzac, LSBB, Strengbach. This will allow us to test the approach under different climatic conditions, different soil types and in different ecohydrological systems.

    How to cite: Jougnot, D., Loiseau, B., Carrière, S., Champollion, C., Voytek, E., and Lesparre, N.: In situ monitoring of rain infiltration and evapotranspiration in the critical zone using self-potentials, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11720, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11720, 2022.

    EGU22-12621 | Presentations | HS8.1.6

    Improved hydrogeophysical imaging with ERT using direct push data as priors and geostatistical regularization 

    Thomas Günther, Janek Greskowiak, Nele Grünenbaum, Nico Skibbe, and Thomas Vienken

    Imaging saltwater/freshwater interfaces is of importance to understand flow and transport in coastal aquifers. For hydrogeophysical imaging the method of electrical resistivity tomography (ERT) yields high-resolution images and is suited for monitoring. However, there is an intrinsic ambiguity in the inversion of the data that limits accurate quantification. In contrast, direct push (DP) data provide accurate point information. Moreover, DP fluid sampling helps to transfer the measured electrical conductivity into salinity by computing a spatially variable formation factor. Both data show typically the same structures but contradict in detail.
    We present a methodology to combine both methods using joint inversion. To this end, DP data are treated like geophysical data with standard deviations derived from statistics so that the resistivity distribution strives to match the DP data at the given point. Additionally, the spatial distribution of DP data can be used to derive geostatistical correlation lengths in the horizontal and vertical directions that are incorporated into the ERT inversion using an anisotripic geostatistical regularization operator. Synthetic modellings with geostatistical media show that the ERT image is improved, not only in the vicinity of the sampling points.
    We present data from the northern beach of the North Sea island of  Spiekeroog where we want to image the circulation cell that formes under the influence of the tides (upper saline plume). There is a significant improvement of the classical smoothness-constrained inversion compared to the DP-guided inversion. As a result, we observe a split into several circulation cells with local groundwater discharge zones. Our hypothesis is that these are mainly driven by the changing beach morphology.

    How to cite: Günther, T., Greskowiak, J., Grünenbaum, N., Skibbe, N., and Vienken, T.: Improved hydrogeophysical imaging with ERT using direct push data as priors and geostatistical regularization, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12621, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12621, 2022.

    Previous field self-potential (SP) surveys have suggested this passive, non-intrusive geophysical method to be a powerful tool for characterizing subsurface flow of water in shallow fractured systems. However, to accurately interpret the measured signal requires knowledge of electrochemical properties of these settings. Despite the interest, the controls on the electric surface charge and the zeta potential of gneiss at conditions relevant to naturally fractured systems remain unreported. There are no published zeta potential measurements conducted in such systems at equilibrium, hence, the effects of composition, concentration and pressure remain unknown. This study reports zeta potential values measured in a fractured gneiss sample, obtained from the Lewisian complex in NW Scotland, and saturated with NaCl solutions of various concentrations, artificial seawater and artificial groundwater solutions under equilibrium conditions at confining pressures of 4 MPa and 7 MPa. The constituent minerals of the sample were identified using X-ray diffraction and linked to the concentration and composition dependence of the zeta potential. The results reported in this study demonstrate that the zeta potential of gneiss was unique and dissimilar to pure minerals such as quartz, calcite, mica or feldspar. Moreover, the measured zeta potentials suggest that divalent ions (Ca2+, Mg2+ and SO42−) acted as potential determining ions. The zeta potential was also found to be independent of salinity in the NaCl experiments, which is unusual for most reported data. Moreover, the impact of fracture aperture on the electrokinetic response was investigated and likely implications for characterization of fractured systems using SP analyzed. Our novel results are an essential first step for interpreting field SP signals and facilitate a way forward for characterization of water flow through fractured basement aquifers.

    How to cite: Vinogradov, J., Hidayat, M., Kumar, Y., Healy, D., and Comte, J.-C.: Zeta Potential of Fractured Gneiss Saturated with NaCl and Natural Aqueous Solutions – Impact of Composition, Concentration and Fracture Aperture on SP Signal in Response to Water Flow in Fractured Crystalline Bedrock, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13059, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13059, 2022.

    EGU22-4 | Presentations | HS8.1.7

    Groundwater sensitivity to climate across Australia 

    Xinyang Fan, Tim Peterson, Benjamin Henley, and Meenakshi Arora

    Climate change is projected to significantly influence groundwater resources in many regions around the world. However, the Fifth Assessment Report of the IPCC states that it is still poorly understood how groundwater level and recharge has and will be impacted by climate change due to the limited groundwater observation records and the confounding influence from multiple drivers, such as climate, pumping, and land cover change. This study aims to understand the risks to groundwater by estimating the sensitivity of groundwater level and recharge across Australia to climate variability.

    To achieve this we firstly used HydroSight, a time-series groundwater hydrograph modeling toolbox, to identify those sites having experienced minimal influence from anthropogenic impacts such as groundwater pumping or land cover changes. A total of 5077 sites were modeled, from which 336 sites were identified as having groundwater levels primarily driven by climate variations alone, with 245 sites located in Victoria. HydroSight groundwater simulations were then undertaken and used within multivariate regression to estimate the groundwater sensitivity to precipitation and potential evapotranspiration.

    Results show that around one-fifth (n=72) sites are highly sensitive to changes in precipitation, with a sensitivity of more than 0.5m change in groundwater level per 1 percent shift in precipitation. The highly sensitive sites are mostly located in southwest Western Australia and southeastern Australia. The groundwater recharge sensitivity in Victoria shows a high spatial consistency which gradually increases from North to South. By quantifying the sensitivity of groundwater to historic climate variations, this study allows the identification of regions most vulnerable to climate change throughout Australia and hence a more targeted future climate adaptation strategy.

    How to cite: Fan, X., Peterson, T., Henley, B., and Arora, M.: Groundwater sensitivity to climate across Australia, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4, 2022.

    EGU22-1476 | Presentations | HS8.1.7 | Highlight

    Deep groundwater – the most vulnerable part of the water cycle to climate change 

    Gunnar Lischeid

    Deep groundwater is the backbone of the regional water cycle, ensuring stream baseflow even after extended drought periods. The thicker the overlying vadose zone the more groundwater head dynamics is buffered against short-term fluctuations of groundwater recharge.  Thus deep groundwater is usually considered to be the least susceptible to climate change effects. However, the opposite is true. Long-term trends (20-41 years) of groundwater head in more than 200 wells in a 50,000 km2 region in Northeast Germany have been analysed. Both increasing and decreasing trends were found, irrespective of land use, geology, etc. Factoring out local, mostly anthropogenic effects from the time series did hardly affect the results. In contrast, sign and size of long-term trends was very closely related to the degree of damping of the groundwater recharge signal. Damping was clearly related to mean depth to groundwater. The stronger the damping the more clearly groundwater head exhibited a 40-year decrease, whereas positive trends were found only for shallow groundwater sites.

    A thorough analysis revealed a fundamental but widely ignored physical cause for these counter-intuitive results. From a thermodynamic perspective, seepage flux in the vadose zone can be described as dissipation of a hydrological input signal. This dissipation is subject to dispersion: The vadose zone acts as a low-pass filter due to preferential damping of the high frequency part of the input signal, recognizable by strong smoothing of soil hydrological time series at greater depth. Consequently, the smoother the time series the more probably a trend analysis would indicate a long-term monotonic increase or decrease even when no trend can be detected in the corresponding input signal. Note that in terms of spectrum analysis climate can be defined as a low-pass filtering of weather dynamics. Then it is only logical that deep groundwater as the part of the water cycle with the strongest low-pass filtering would be the first to clearly exhibit climate change signals.

    This interpretation is consistent with an alternative perspective in terms of hydrological processes: The more shallow the groundwater, the more likely seepage flux will reach down to the groundwater table even after minor rain storms due to a smaller soil volume that needs to be refilled and to preferential flow. Consequently, groundwater recovers more rapidly from drought here. This holds especially true for groundwater in the riparian zone where most of the short-term response of stream discharge to rain storms is generated. In fact, none of these streams exhibited any clear trend. However, discharge in minor streams and water level in lakes at mid-slope positions already started to decline during the last decade. We would do well taking deep-groundwater dynamics as an early warning tool against climate change effects.

    How to cite: Lischeid, G.: Deep groundwater – the most vulnerable part of the water cycle to climate change, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1476, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1476, 2022.

    EGU22-6670 | Presentations | HS8.1.7

    Geochemical models help to understand the influence of climate change and intensive groundwater extraction in the chemical composition of a tropical, maar lake in Central Mexico 

    Selene Olea-Olea, Javier Alcocer, Raúl Silva-Aguilera, Oscar Escolero, and Luis A. Oseguera

    The tropical maar Lake Alchichica lays in the high altitude (> 2,000 m a.s.l). The orographic shadow of the Sierra Madre Oriental generates a semiarid climate with a negative water budget (1 to 3) so the lake's water balance depends on groundwater. Nonetheless, the decreasing trend of the water level from 1959 on suggests a combined effect of climate change and increasing groundwater extraction (agriculture, urban). Applying geochemical models to explore the interaction between groundwater and surface water allow to identify the geochemical source of the reported increase in sulfate, magnesium, and chloride concentration in the lake water and its relation to climate change and intensive extraction of groundwater. Thirty-five groundwater samples were obtained from wells surrounding Lake Alchichica. Samples were analyzed for major ionic composition and trace elements. We generated a conceptual model of groundwater-surface water interaction and conducted inverse and evaporation geochemical models using the PHREEQC code. Geochemical models explore the water-rock processes between groundwater and geologic materials, understanding the chemical evolution of the groundwater flow system, and understanding the influence of groundwater chemical characteristics in the chemical composition of the lake. This investigation unravels how climate change and intensive groundwater extraction define the way in which: 1) groundwater influences the chemistry of the lake, and 2) to understand the chemical changes that have been reported in the lake.

    How to cite: Olea-Olea, S., Alcocer, J., Silva-Aguilera, R., Escolero, O., and Oseguera, L. A.: Geochemical models help to understand the influence of climate change and intensive groundwater extraction in the chemical composition of a tropical, maar lake in Central Mexico, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6670, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6670, 2022.

    The Chia-nan Plain is one of the major grain-growing areas in Taiwan where groundwater over-exploitation for irrigation has long been an unsolvable problem because of uneven temporal /spatial rainfall distribution. Based on past studies, it reveals that paddy field plays an important role in groundwater conservation; however, paddy field also requires a large amount of water for irrigation simultaneously. Furthermore, due to the impacts of climate change, the issue of uneven temporal/spatial rainfall distribution in Southern Taiwan has aggravated, which also affects plenty of hydro-meteorological variables, including the water level of Zheng-wun River, precipitation, temperature, and relative humidity (RH).

    This study aims to unravel the nexus between specific agriculture acts, hydro-meteorological variables, and groundwater levels. As a result, the Multi-dimensional Ensemble Empirical Mode Decomposition (MEEMD) method and Time Dependence Intrinsic Correlation (TDIC) method are implemented to analyze the NDVI time series and hydro-meteorological variables. With the analysis of MEEMD, we can establish the most influential time scales of hydro-meteorological variables and fallow duration associated with the groundwater level. Besides, the time lag effect of fallow to water-table depth can be determined by applying time-dependent intrinsic correlation (TDIC) approaches.

    Groundwater is one of the valuable water resources worldwide; therefore, this study provides insights into the response of water-table depth to the non-linear, non-stationary hydro-meteorological variables. Additionally, we also formulate a new strategy for groundwater conservation by regulating the fallow duration.

    Keywords: Fallow duration; Water-table depth; Hydro-meteorology; Time-frequency analysis (TFA); MEEMD; TDIC

    How to cite: Hsieh, K.: Response of Water-Table Depth to Fallow Duration and Hydro-Meteorological Factors: A Case Study in the Sigang District of Tainan, Taiwan., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7546, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7546, 2022.

    EGU22-7739 | Presentations | HS8.1.7

    Dynamic 3D modelling of the unconfined aquifer of the River Marecchia alluvial fan (Rimini) 

    Ilaria Delfini, Alberto Montanari, and Andrea Chahoud

    Aquifers play a relevant role in the mitigation of the risk due to the occurrence of drought events in the Emilia-Romagna region. In fact, their capability to store relevant volumes of water and the long time span between meteorological and groundwater droughts make aquifers an essential resource during dry periods. To mitigate the risk induced by water scarcity, in 2014 a managed recharge experiment was carried out on the River Marecchia alluvial fan. In detail, an additional volume taken from the river was diverted into a quarry lake. The lake is an outcrop of the aquifer, therefore an increase in the lake water volume produces a corresponding increase of the piezometric level in the aquifer, and therefore larger groundwater availability.

    Several international experiences on the management of aquifers for civil and agricultural water supply have shown the value of the information that can be derived by running groundwater simulation models. In particular, MODFLOW, an open access groundwater simulation model developed by the United States Geological Survey, is widely applied.

    The purpose of this work is to apply MODFLOW to study solutions for managing artificial recharge in the River Marecchia alluvial fan. In particular, a previous application of MODFLOW by the Regional Agency for Prevention, Environment and Energy of Emilia-Romagna (ARPAE) has been repeated by using a different model interface, ModelMuse, and additional climatic scenarios.

    The work confirms the potential benefits that can be provided by a groundwater simulation model for optimizing aquifer recharge. The application confirmed that recharge may be very successful in this specific case for mitigating the impact of water withdrawals.

    How to cite: Delfini, I., Montanari, A., and Chahoud, A.: Dynamic 3D modelling of the unconfined aquifer of the River Marecchia alluvial fan (Rimini), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7739, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7739, 2022.

    EGU22-8483 | Presentations | HS8.1.7

    Groundwater temperature study - Subsurface Urban Heat Island in the city of Wrocław (Poland) 

    Jan Blachowski and Monika Hajnrych

    The average air temperature in the world has increased recently. Over the past 20 years, the global average has increased by 0.6 C and continues to increase [1]. In south-western Poland, in Wrocław, for the same period, the recorded increase in the average air temperature is approx. 0.5 °C [2]. The reason for this phenomenon is human activity. The process of urbanisation has created another phenomenon called the Urban Heat Island (UHI), which can be studied analysing for example the Land Surface Temperature (LST). The combined effect of the UHI and climate change can influence groundwater temperature by penetrating underground. The phenomenon of elevated groundwater temperatures is called the Subsurface Urban Heat Island (SUHI) [3,4]. While the Urban Heat Island effects is generally negative and widely investigated, the higher groundwater temperature may have positive aspect, such as e.g. use in heat pumps. The SUHI phenomenon is less understood than the UHI one.
    This presentation focuses on the spatial distribution of temperature in shallow aquifers in the city of Wroclaw (SW Poland) developed with various interpolation techniques and based on measurements made in a network of piezometers in the 2004-2005 period. In total 67 locations have been measured and the temperatures recorded varied between 1.1 °C and 24.5 °C with the average of 13.2 °C. The data has been processed with the IDW, spline and kriging interpolation methods. The groundwater temperature distribution was analysed spatially, taking into account the then land use and location of technical infrastructure. In addition, an attempt has been made to compare the distribution of groundwater temperature with the Land Surface Temperature. The latter was determined based on Landsat 5 satellite imagery.
    The interpolated groundwater temperature maps have made it possible to analyse and present graphically the spatial distribution of temperature and link it to the LST UHI for the analysed period.

    Bibliography:

    [1] Global Climate Change https://climate.nasa.gov/ (accessed on 11 January 2022)

    [2] Polish climate 2020. Institute of Meteorology and Water Management, National Research Institute. Available online: https://www.imgw.pl/sites/default/files/2021-04/imgw-pib-klimat-polski-2020-opracowanie-final-pojedyncze-min.pdf. (accessed on 11 January 2022)

    [3] Luo Z., Asproudi C., Subsurface urban heat island and its effects on horizontal ground-source heat pump potential under climate change, Applied Thermal Engineering, Volume 90, 2015, doi: 10.1016/j.applthermaleng.2015.07.025.

    [4] Zhu, K., Bayer, P., Grathwohl, P., and Blum, P. (2015), Groundwater temperature evolution in the subsurface urban heat island of Cologne, Germany, Hydrol. Process., 29, 965– 978, doi: 10.1002/hyp.10209

    How to cite: Blachowski, J. and Hajnrych, M.: Groundwater temperature study - Subsurface Urban Heat Island in the city of Wrocław (Poland), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8483, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8483, 2022.

    EGU22-8552 | Presentations | HS8.1.7

    Assessing the resilience of the Carboniferous limestone transboundary aquifer (Belgium/France) to recharge deficit events and groundwater abstraction 

    Guillaume Vandelois, Géraldine Picot, Marc Parmentier, and Pascal Goderniaux

    The carboniferous aquifer of the international hydrographic district of the Scheldt river extends across three countries and administrative regions: France, Wallonia (South Belgium), Flanders (North Belgium) covering 1420 km². More than 75 million cubic meters of water are pumped every year in the considered hydrogeological system for drinking water distribution, agriculture, industry, and quarry dewatering. Stresses on groundwater resources in the aquifer are therefore important and pumping operations need to be managed adequately. Groundwater levels have been decreasing significantly due to the overexploitation of the aquifer caused by the industrial and demographic development of the region during the 20th century. In some area the piezometric level has dropped by 90 meters between 1910 and 2010.

    The transboundary aquifer is mainly composed of fractured carboniferous limestone. The aquifer is considered as unconfined in eastern part and confined below marls and chalk in the northwest area. Recharge is thus mainly observed within the unconfined area, with important lateral groundwater flows to the confined area.

    Groundwater flow in the aquifer has been modelled in 3D using the finite volume calculation code MARTHE, in collaboration between the different involved entities, and using data officially exchanged between administrations. The model has been calibrated for the 1900-2017 period considering abstracted groundwater volumes, recharge calculated from precipitation and evapotranspiration data, observed piezometric levels and river flow rates, collected or reconstructed since 1900.

    The model is used for predictive purpose. Simulations are performed for the next decades following several scenarios including the possible evolution of groundwater abstraction as a function of the demographic and economic development of the region, the expected climate evolution and related groundwater recharge change, the evolution of dewatering operations in stone quarries. Recently, recharge scenarios based on historical meteorological data were applied to the model to determine the impact of rainfall deficit on groundwater resources and the resilience of the aquifer. The impact has been quantified and time recovery map of the aquifer were built. Results show a recovery time difference up to twenty years between the confined and unconfined area of the aquifer.

    All these simulations constitute a scientific support for the decision-makers involved in the management of this transboundary aquifer.

    How to cite: Vandelois, G., Picot, G., Parmentier, M., and Goderniaux, P.: Assessing the resilience of the Carboniferous limestone transboundary aquifer (Belgium/France) to recharge deficit events and groundwater abstraction, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8552, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8552, 2022.

    EGU22-8939 | Presentations | HS8.1.7

    Using GRACE Satellites to Estimate Impacts of Climate and Irrigation on Water Storage Changes in Major U.S. Aquifers 

    Bridget Scanlon, Ashraf Rateb, and Alexander Sun

    Managing water resources sustainably requires a comprehensive understanding of the effects of climate extremes (floods and droughts) and human water use (particularly irrigation) on water storage. In this study we examined the relative importance of climate and human drivers on variability in total water storage (TWS) from GRACE satellites compared with drought indices and irrigation water use in 14 major aquifers within the U.S. Results show marked depletion of TWS, tracked by GRACE satellites, was restricted to the semi-arid southwestern Central Valley and south-central High Plains, totaling ~90 km3, ~3× greater than the capacity of Lake Mead, the largest U.S. reservoir. Water storage depletion in the Central Valley was linked to long-term droughts (≤5 years) that were amplified by changing water sources from predominantly surface water irrigation during wet periods to groundwater irrigation during droughts. Interannual variability in TWS dominates long-term variability in major aquifers throughout the rest of the U.S. In the eastern U.S., aquifers in humid regions show low TWS trends related to low drought intensity. Although groundwater pumpage for irrigation in the humid Mississippi Embayment aquifer exceeded that in the semi-arid California Central Valley, no TWS depletion was recorded in the GRACE satellites in the Mississippi Embayment aquifer. The lack of TWS depletion is attributed to groundwater pumpage capturing streamflow in this humid region. Low or slightly rising trends in TWS in the northwest U.S., Columbia and Snake River Basins are attributed to surface water irrigation dampening drought impacts and disconnecting storage from climate forcing. The analysis of GRACE data shows synergies between climate and irrigation, with amplified water storage depletion in the semi-arid southwest and southcentral U.S., little impact on water storage in the humid east, and dampened water storage depletion in the northwest and north central U.S. To enhance the sustainability of water resources, groundwater and surface water should be used conjunctively, with inefficient surface water irrigation increasing groundwater recharge and efficient groundwater irrigation minimizing storage depletion. The use of managed aquifer recharge has been expanding within the past decade in different aquifers. Results of this study have important implications for managing water resources more sustainability within the context of climate extremes and intense irrigation globally.

    How to cite: Scanlon, B., Rateb, A., and Sun, A.: Using GRACE Satellites to Estimate Impacts of Climate and Irrigation on Water Storage Changes in Major U.S. Aquifers, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8939, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8939, 2022.

    EGU22-9374 | Presentations | HS8.1.7

    Re-use of treated wastewater for irrigation and groundwater recharge: feasibility and effects on groundwater quantity at the experimental site in Kinrooi, Belgium. 

    Mateusz Zawadzki, Lara Speijer, Delphine Vandeputte, Yiqi Su, Mingyue Luo, Yue Gao, Marc Elskens, Pascal Verhoest, Joke Bauwens, Tom Coussement, Frank Elsen, Birte Raes, Steven Eisenreich, and Marijke Huysmans

    It took several consecutive years of devastating droughts sweeping through Europe, causing substantial economic losses, for many to realise how urging it is to improve the water directives, making critical sectors like agriculture more resilient to a changing climate. Shrinking water supplies and growing demand further forced stakeholders to seek alternative sources, drawing their attention to projects previously considered economically unjustified. Therefore, water re-use and reclamation became one of the EU’s priorities fulfilling the ambitions of the European Green Deal to implement circular water management strategies. To facilitate the transition and support new legislation, in-depth research in the feasibility and environmental impacts of aquifer recharge with reclaimed wastewater is essential. The GROW project investigates this issue on multiple levels, among which the effect of reclamation of wastewater through aquifer recharge on local and regional scale groundwater levels.

    At the experimental site in Kinrooi, Belgium, the groundwater levels are closely monitored with automatic submersible data loggers installed in 21 monitoring wells distributed on the investigated agricultural field and its vicinity. Data on water levels in the underlying Quaternary, porous aquifer are collected hourly and are verified through monthly manual measurements taken to ensure an unhindered operation of the infrastructure.

    A distributed, transient-state flow model is used to simulate the groundwater table’s response to the effluent sub-irrigation at the desired rate. The model’s flexibility also allows making predictions of the aquifer behaviour under changing climatic conditions by augmenting the soil-water balance model with revised weather data. The model’s performance is tested against the high temporal resolution dataset obtained from the monitoring network. Attention is also paid to the experiment’s effect on the water levels in the adjacent hydrological network, while the effluent is partly rerouted from the hitherto used surface water discharge to the sub-irrigation system.

    The data collected in our experiment is used to determine the capability of the aquifer to store and recover the reclaimed wastewater during drought periods. That would reduce the demand for traditional, inefficient surface irrigation and increase the climate resilience of the agricultural sector in Flanders. Together with data from similar projects carried out throughout Europe, our results can be used to facilitate long-expected EU legislation enabling circular water use. To support this process, we also investigate the impact of the re-use of treated wastewater for agriculture on groundwater quality and the public perception of this sensitive issue.

    How to cite: Zawadzki, M., Speijer, L., Vandeputte, D., Su, Y., Luo, M., Gao, Y., Elskens, M., Verhoest, P., Bauwens, J., Coussement, T., Elsen, F., Raes, B., Eisenreich, S., and Huysmans, M.: Re-use of treated wastewater for irrigation and groundwater recharge: feasibility and effects on groundwater quantity at the experimental site in Kinrooi, Belgium., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9374, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9374, 2022.

    Changes in groundwater storage are dominantly influenced by anthropogenic and climatic factors. In global and/or regional scale groundwater storage change studies, storage changes are often estimated using gravimetric satellite data (GRACE). However, the applicability of such analysis at basin-scale is still limited due to its relatively coarse spatial resolution of 1° x 1°. Combination of GRACE data with groundwater level monitoring observations, where available, and numerical modeling might yield more accurate results for catchment-scale studies.

    In this study, we estimate the basin-scale groundwater storage change component in the data-scarce area of the Bandung groundwater basin in West Java, Indonesia, using MODFLOW. We parameterize the model using hydraulic conductivity data obtained from slug-tests, pumping-tests, and laboratory analysis. There is some historical groundwater level observation available to compare the model outputs against. The model is forced by recharge calculated with a distributed hydrological model (wflow_sbm). Groundwater abstraction is estimated based upon population density and other known water demands as reported in earlier studies. We simulate the period of 2005 to 2018, starting from an initial steady-state assumed to exist prior to 2005.

    We compare the groundwater storage change observed in the model to that derived from GRACE data, which was calculated by subtracting the soil moisture change derived from the wflow_sbm simulation from the total terrestrial water storage change. The results show how the groundwater storage change estimated from the groundwater flow model can mimic both the dynamic and magnitude of that derived from GRACE in combination with wflow_sbm. The capability of groundwater modeling to estimate basin-scale groundwater storage change, validated by GRACE, unravel the opportunity of using such methods to predict the behavior of groundwater storage dynamics to the future impact of anthropogenic and climatic factor and to assist in deriving basin-scale groundwater policies and management strategies in data-scarce areas.

    How to cite: Rusli, S. R., Bense, V., and Weerts, A.: Estimating basin-scale groundwater storage change component in data-scarce area of Bandung Basin, West Java, Indonesia, using groundwater modeling and GRACE data, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11227, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11227, 2022.

    Potential impacts of climate change on groundwater recharge in South Africa using stable isotopes of water

    KE Ramudzuli, JA Miller, T. Vennmann, A Watson and JD van Rooyen

    Department of Earth Sciences, Stellenbosch University.

    Unimodal wet season precipitation plays a significant role in ensuring sustainable and continuous replenishment of groundwater resources, especially in arid to semi-arid climates that only recharge during heavy rainfall events. For this reason, changes in precipitation patterns (i.e., the frequency, intensity, duration and seasonality of precipitation events) may impact the reliability and sustainability of groundwater resources. This study investigates the relationship between the stable water isotope precipitation vs groundwater composition from across different climatic zones in South Africa. The analysis was done to examine the record of evaporation recorded in the stable water isotopes of precipitation before groundwater recharge, in order to extrapolate how variable changes in climatic conditions would translate to groundwater recharge (e.g., induced evaporative loss of rainfall). Both precipitation and groundwater samples showed a strong alignment with the Global Meteoric Water Line (GMWL) and respective LMWLs with a dispersion that increased from the O- and H- isotope depleted sections towards the enriched areas. Groundwater samples generally recorded the same characteristics as wet season precipitation irrespective of whether this was winter or summer rainfall regions, and plotting with the same regionality for Local Meteoric Water Lines (LWMLs). Secondary evaporation of precipitation, noted by the deviation of groundwater samples from the GMWL and respective LMWLs, increased from the south-eastern and east coasts, which receive relatively higher precipitation amounts, towards the interior along with south and west coast of the country, which are somewhat dryer. This analysis will assist in the forecasting of future groundwater recharge patterns in response to climate change and represents an important step in assessing the impact of climate variability on groundwater sustainability.

    How to cite: Ramudzuli, K. E.: Potential impacts of climate change on groundwater recharge in South Africa using stable isotopes of water, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11279, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11279, 2022.

    EGU22-11392 | Presentations | HS8.1.7

    Assessment of groundwater determinative recharge seasons and their spatial distribution in the Baltic States based on response to historical drought 1989–2018 

    Alise Babre, Andis Kalvāns, Konrāds Popovs, Inga Retiķe, Marta Jemeļjanova, Zanita Avotniece, and Jānis Bikše

    To assess groundwater response to climate change scenarios in the context of groundwater drought it is fundamental to understand controlling periods of groundwater recharge as well response time to meteorological forcing (Hughes et al 2021, Jasechko et al 2014). 

    The study aims at assessing the spatial and temporal distribution of groundwater drought events in the Baltic States over the period 1989 – 2018 as well as the meteorological and hydrological indicators associated with periods of below-normal groundwater level. A set of meteorological, hydrological and groundwater drought indices were used for the identification of significant drought events in the region. Used groundwater level time series were treated and checked for errors according to the Retike et al. (2021).

    Four major drought events affecting all monitoring sites under study are identified (1992–1994, 1996–1997, 2002–2004 and 2005–2007), although, the fluctuations in groundwater level display distinct patterns which might be associated with the impact of local meteorological conditions and geological setting of particular monitoring sites such as seasonally derived recharge. It was found that meteorological drought indices (SPI, SPEI, DRI) showed the highest correlation with groundwater drought conditions rather than hydrological indices (SRI and SSRI) calculated from ERA-5 reanalysis data. FHowever, for most indices and most monitoring sites there is a one month time lag between the signal of the hydrometeorological index and the response of groundwater drought. Time series analysis of drought indices at groundwater monitoring sites demonstrated varying characteristics of the onset, duration, and propagation of drought events through different scales thus highlighting the complex nature of groundwater drought events in the Baltic State area.

    This research is funded by the Latvian Council of Science, project “Spatial and temporal prediction of groundwater drought with mixed models for multilayer sedimentary basin under climate change”, project No. lzp-2019/1-0165.

     



    References

    Jasechko, Scott & Birks, Sandra & Gleeson, Tom & Wada, Yoshihide & Fawcett, Peter & Sharp, Zachary & McDonnell, Jeffrey & Welker, Jeff. (2014). The pronounced seasonality of global groundwater recharge. Water Resources Research. 50. 10.1002/2014WR015809.

    Hughes, A. & Mansour, Majdi & Ward, Rob & Kieboom, Natalie & Allen, S. & Seccombe, David & Charlton, Matthew & Prudhomme, C. (2021). The impact of climate change on groundwater recharge: National-scale assessment for the British mainland. Journal of Hydrology. 598. 126336. 10.1016/j.jhydrol.2021.126336.

    Retike, I., Bikše, J., Kalvāns, A., Dēliņa, A, Avotniece, Z., Zaadnoordijk, W.J., Jemeljanova, M., Popovs,K., Babre, A., Zelenkevičs, A., Baikovs, A. (2022) Rescue of groundwater level time series: How tovisually   identify   and   treat   errors.   Journal   of   Hydrology,   605,   127294.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhydrol.2021.127294

    How to cite: Babre, A., Kalvāns, A., Popovs, K., Retiķe, I., Jemeļjanova, M., Avotniece, Z., and Bikše, J.: Assessment of groundwater determinative recharge seasons and their spatial distribution in the Baltic States based on response to historical drought 1989–2018, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11392, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11392, 2022.

    EGU22-11520 | Presentations | HS8.1.7

    Monitoring short-term transient groundwater hydrochemical and hydrodynamics changes following the onset of an early dry season and hydrological drought period 

    Esteban Rafael Caligaris, Rudy Rossetto, Stefanie Schmidt, and Christoph Schueth

    While there have been significant advances in the understanding of drought in the surface water domain, little knowledge is available for groundwater and the interactions with surface water. In particular, few studies have been run to understand the short-term transient changes in groundwater quality since the early onset of a hydrological drought period. This contribution presents data and information on the groundwater hydrochemical and hydrodynamics changes occurring in an aquifer following the onset of an early dry season in Spring 2021 and developed in a hydrological drought period lasted until December 2021 in the alluvial plain of the Cornia River in coastal Tuscany (Italy).

    The Cornia plain hosts a Holocene coastal aquifer constituted, in the investigated area, mainly by gravel in silty matrix. We monitored groundwater chemical quality and hydrodynamics in a series of multi-depth piezometers in a recharge area covering three different depths from the soil surface (i.e., 8m, 12m, and 18m) in the near of a Managed Aquifer Recharge (MAR) scheme (Caligaris et al. 2022). We monitored these piezometers alongside with the existing network of piezometers and the relations with Cornia River surface water for nine months from April 2021 (when the max groundwater head was recorded) until December 2021 (when the minimum was recorded).

    Ten sampling campaigns were performed in this period, covering the early end of the annual MAR operation period in May 2021, and monitoring every fifteen days in the initial phase of the dry season. The last effective rainfall occurred on 11 May 2021. A total of about 130 water samples were collected. The concentrations of the main ions in the water samples were determined using an Ion Chromatography (IC) instrument. The concentrations of trace elements were determined using an Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometer (ICP). The concentration of Boron in water was determined using a Microwave Plasma Atomic Emission Spectrometer (MP-AES). Physico-chemical parameters were measured in the field with a multiparametric probe. This resulted on the measurement of the spatiotemporal variation of 49 different parameters at each of the study point.

    An important groundwater table decline, ranging from 6 to 10 m, was observed in this period, which brought to relevant water stress even in trees at the end of October 2021. The statistical behavior of the different parameters as well as their relationships are studied and presented to define a robust conceptual model unifying hydrochemistry and hydrodynamics in order to describe the evolution of the aquifer.

    Acknowledgement

    This paper is presented within the framework of the project MARSoluT (www.marsolut-itn.eu), a four-year Marie Skłodowska-Curie Actions (MSCA) Innovative Training Network (ITN) funded by the European Commission (Grant Agreement 814066).

    References

    Caligaris, E.; Agostini, M.; Rossetto, R. Using Heat as a Tracer to Detect the Development of the Recharge Bulb in Managed Aquifer Recharge Schemes. Hydrology 2022, 9, 14. https://doi.org/10.3390/hydrology9010014

    How to cite: Caligaris, E. R., Rossetto, R., Schmidt, S., and Schueth, C.: Monitoring short-term transient groundwater hydrochemical and hydrodynamics changes following the onset of an early dry season and hydrological drought period, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11520, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11520, 2022.

    This work compares two different surrogate data-driven models in order to evaluate the effects of climate change on groundwater resources by means of an ensemble of 13 Regional Climate Models (RCM), provided within the Euro-Cordex project, under two different scenarios (RCP 4.5 and RCP 8.5). The impact was evaluated for three future periods: 2006-2035 (short term), 2036-2065 (medium term) and 2066-2095 (long term). Both approaches are based on historical data collected in northern Tuscany, covering the period 2005-2020. Historical precipitation and temperature records, observed in 18 gauging stations, and piezometric levels for 14 wells were used to build the surrogate models. The first methodology is based on a linear regression model and adopted standardized indices: the Standardized Precipitation Evapotranspiration Index (SPEI) and the Standardized Groundwater Index (SGI). First, for each well, the correlations between SPEIs and SGIs were investigated for the period 2005-2020. In case of meaningful correlation, linear regression equations are used to estimate SGIs as function of SPEIs. The linear regression models were then applied to predict future SGIs ​​using SPEIs computed from the data ​​provided by the RCMs projections. The second surrogate technique involves the use of a Long-Short Term Memory (LSTM) neural network. LSTM allows to work directly with climate variables and normalized groundwater levels. The LSTM network was trained using the historical precipitation and temperature time series for the period 2005-2018 as input and the normalized groundwater levels as output. Rain, temperature and piezometric level data from 2019 to 2020 were used to test the network. Subsequently, the rainfall and temperature time series ​​provided by the RCMs have been used by the LSTM to predict the future groundwater levels. The analysis highlights, for both approaches, a negative impact of climate change on the groundwater system. In particular, according to the RCP 4.5 in the medium-term period a larger reduction of groundwater availability is expected, while with the RCP 8.5 the long-term period is the most affected by a groundwater level decline.

    How to cite: Tanda, M. G., Secci, D., D'Oria, M., and Todaro, V.: Assessment of the impact of climate change on groundwater resources using regional climate model projections: comparison of surrogate modeling techniques, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12836, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12836, 2022.

    Aquifer Storage and Recovery (ASR) is one of the most effective ways of artificial groundwater recharge to assure freshwater availability during droughts in arid and semi-arid areas. However, this method of managed aquifer recharge is less prevalent in saline groundwater regions due to low recovery efficiency (RE). The injected freshwater of an ASR scheme in saline regions is decreased due to mixing between fresh-saline water and the upward movement of stored freshwater due to gravity effects. The losses due to mixing, however, can be reduced by managing the operational parameters. This study proposes a solution for reducing losses of injected freshwater due to gravitational within the saline aquifer by introducing multiple partially penetrating well-system (MPPW) in place of a single fully penetrating well-system (SFPW). A variable-density flow (SEAWAT) model is used to simulate and compare the ASR system performance for specific hydrogeological conditions and variable operational parameters for SFPW and MPPW well systems. The results indicate that by using MPPW in place of the SFPW ASR well system, 8 to 15% extra injected freshwater can be recovered. The difference in recovery efficiency due to the use of MPPW in place of SFPW tends to increase with the increasing values of injected freshwater storage duration and the number of successive ASR cycles and decreases with increasing the injection/recovery rates and injection volumes. This research provides the basis for understanding the suitable ASR well type for any specific site for different operational factors.

    How to cite: Tiwari, S. and Yadav, B. K.: Improving the performance of Aquifer Storage and Recovery schemes using Multiple Partially Penetrating Wells, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-92, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-92, 2022.

    Human modernizations and achievements are at peak but in contrary we ignore facts about the tremendous amount of anthropogenic waste that are exposed directly to atmosphere which later reach groundwater aquifer and contaminate through natural water cycle. So, to limelight man-made sources, Wanaparthy watershed is chosen as it is densely agriculture urban area covering about 1600 km2 were peoples solely get their daily wages from farming. Samples were collected systematically for pre (march-may) and post monsoon (september-december) through gird preparation (5*6 sq.km) to determine the hydrogeochemical characteristics of physicochemical parameters and major analytes concentration to preside the types, quality, permissibility, facies and nitrate health risk of different age groups in groundwater. In short findings are as follows: Major analytes concentration for pre-monsoon, Cl- (8.02%) >HCO3- (3.27%) >SO42-(2.75%) >NO3-(1.09%) >F-(0.02%); Na+(4.08%) >Ca+2(1.71%) >Mg+2 (0.45%) >K+ (0.26%)while post-monsoon, HCO3-(8.94%) >Cl- (6.9%) >SO42- (2.46%) >NO3- (2.42%) >F-(0.02%); Na+(3.28%) >Mg+2(2.14%) >Ca+2(0.75%) >K+(0.28%) respectively. Piper diagram explains the major water types for pre- and post-monsoon as Na-Cl type and Ca-Mg-Cl type. Gibb’s plot shows that in both seasons the dominant environmental facies are influence by rock and evaporation conditions. Water quality index shows deterioration increase at most twice from “poor to unfit class” (36.21% - 60.34%) during pre to post season. Health Quotient evaluation for nitrate indicates “children group” as most effected where HQ value range from 5.40E-03 to 1.23E+01 (72.4 pc) followed by infant group, 5.80E-03 to 1.31E+01 (68.97 pc) and adult 2.10E-03 to 4.68E+00 (32.7pc). And, from spatial distribution maps it is observed that slope and structure have direct response to recharge/discharge as well as aquifer properties.

    How to cite: Vaiphei, S. P. and Mohan, K. R.: Characteristics of groundwater quality and its non-carcinogenic health risk assessment through monsoon inputs in Wanaparthy watershed, Telangana, India, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-173, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-173, 2022.

     

     

    ABSTRACT: Harvesting rain and flood water is a common practice in desert and arid areas. The storage of water is always influenced by hot weather periods where most of the stored water is lost either by evaporation or infiltration of water into very deep aquifers.  Utilizing sand clay liners as barriers for near-surface material can work as an efficient tool for better use of water resources.  In desert areas where groundwater is located at a deep level the cost of retrieving water is high and requires expensive infrastructure and systems. The concept of this study is to create an artificial aquifer enhanced with pumping systems to supply water to shallow-rooted plants in an adjacent zone.  A simplified model consisting of major collection tanks with automatic pumps was used in a project to save irrigation water in the Eastern province of Saudi Arabia. This concept can be expanded to create large deep-seated storage overlain by granular soil to minimize evaporation. Water supply from this aquifer can be transported to nearby fields by gravity if the water level in the aquifer is higher than the planted area or by pumping if water is needed at a higher level. The sand-clay liner can be made up of bentonite of 10% to 15% clay content by dry weight. The work presented in this study includes the characteristics of the material used and the mechanism followed to retain and re-use water multiple times.  5TE Decagon sensors capable of recording moisture content, temperature, and electrical conductivity connected to Em50 data loggers were employed.  Chemical tests and the salinity of water were monitored during the process. Suggested storage geometries are presented for efficient use of the system.

     

     

    KEYWORDS: subsurface storage, barriers, sand-clay mixtures, hydraulic conductivity, evaporation.  

    How to cite: Dafalla, M.: Intercepting rain and stormwater using clay-sand liners to maximize irrigation to shallow-rooted plants in desert and arid areas, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2492, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2492, 2022.

    EGU22-3104 | Presentations | HS8.1.8

    Controlled drainage with subirrigation: a water management measure to discharge, retain and recharge freshwater 

    Janine de Wit, Marjolein van Huijgevoort, Gé van den Eertwegh, Dion van Deijl, and Ruud Bartholomeus

    Sufficient freshwater is needed for water dependent sectors as agriculture, nature, drinking water, and industry. However, even in low-lying, flood prone countries like the Netherlands, climate change, weather extremes, economic growth, urbanization, land subsidence and increased food production will make it more complex to guarantee sufficient freshwater for all sectors. Specifically, the range of weather extremes from extremely dry to extremely wet is expected to increase and extremes are expected to occur more frequently.

    Over the last decades, drainage, land consolidation and urbanization resulted in declining groundwater tables. Additionally, the freshwater demand of different sectors caused an increased pressure on the regional groundwater system. As a consequence, the annual groundwater table in the Dutch sandy soil areas dropped over time with the effect that, nowadays, freshwater is becoming scarce in dry periods. Agriculture needs to anticipate on these conditions in order to prevent both drought and waterlogging. However, the current Dutch agricultural water management system is historically focused on water discharge and not designed to anticipate on both weather extremes.

    One of the solutions could be to modify the current pipe drainage systems (already existing in 34 % of the agricultural land) to drainage systems with three purposes, called: controlled drainage with subirrigation. First, the drainage systems could discharge water if the risk of waterlogging increases. Second, the drainage system could store water during rainfall in the soil (retain water). Third, (external) water can be actively pumped into the drainage network to raise groundwater tables (recharge water).

    We focus on the data and model output of four experimental sites in the Pleistocene uplands of the Netherlands, where controlled drainage with subirrigation is applied. Field data is collected over ± the years 2017-2021, like water supply, groundwater table, soil moisture content. Water balance components as actual transpiration, drainage and downward seepage are modelled with SWAP (Soil-Water-Atmosphere-Plant model). The effects on crop yield and configuration of the management are also quantified with the model.

    The construction of controlled drainage with subirrigation, topographical location, and a proper management of these systems are important. First, results show that through subirrigation, water can be stored in the soil instead of discharged. The water storage leads to an increase in groundwater tables of ± 0.70 m during the growing season, leading to higher crop yields. By storing external water at the field scale, fast drainage was prevented, which decreased drought vulnerability. Second, results of the four experimental sites show that effects of subirrigation on the water balance components are strongly site dependent. For example, an impermeable layer at a shallow depth is needed for enough resistance to increase the phreatic groundwater level. Furthermore, ditch levels surrounded by the field are important as a shallow groundwater table with low ditch levels results in lateral drainage, an unfavorable effect. Third, results of the experimental sites show that proper management of these systems is important to prevent clogging of the system.

    How to cite: de Wit, J., van Huijgevoort, M., van den Eertwegh, G., van Deijl, D., and Bartholomeus, R.: Controlled drainage with subirrigation: a water management measure to discharge, retain and recharge freshwater, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3104, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3104, 2022.

    EGU22-4147 | Presentations | HS8.1.8

    Use of satellite remote sensing and independent component analysis to assess land subsidence and aquifer system properties over the Willcox Basin, USA 

    Mimi Peng, Zhong Lu, Chaoying Zhao, Mahdi Motagh, Lin Bai, and Brian D. Conway

    The Willcox Basin, located in southeast of Arizona, USA, covers an area of approximately 4,950 km2 and is essentially a closed broad alluvial valley basin. The basin measures approximately 15 km to 45 km in width and is 160 km long. Long-term excessive groundwater exploitation for agricultural, domestic and stock applications has resulted in substantial ground subsidence in the Willcox Groundwater Basin. The land subsidence rate of the Willcox Basin has not declined but has rather increased in recent years, posing a threat to infrastructure, aquifer systems, and ecological environments.

    In this study, an integrated analysis of remote sensing and in-situ groundwater observations is made to assess characteristics of land subsidence and response of the aquifer skeletal system to the change in hydraulic head in Willcox Basin. L-band ALOS and C-band Sentinel-1 SAR data acquired from 2006 to 2020 are analyzed using multi-temporal interferometric approach to derive subsidence deformation. We show that the overall deformation patterns are characterized by two major zones of subsidence, with the mean subsidence rate increasing with time from 2006 to 2020. This study also suggests that subsidence here is a result of human-induced compaction of sediments due to massive pumping in the deep aquifer system and groundwater depletion. 

    Independent component analysis (ICA) a leading method for blind source separation to isolate signals without knowing a priori information about the signal sources, which was adopted to separate the mixed InSAR time series signal into a set of independent signals. On the one hand, the application of ICA filtered the residual errors in InSAR observations to enhance the deformation time series, and the deformation accuracy is improved by more than 13%. On the other hand, it also revealed that two different spatiotemporal deformation features exist in this area, indicating hydrogeological properties of aquifer systems are spatially variable in this basin.

    In addition, the relationship between the observed land subsidence variations and the hydraulic head changes in a confined aquifer is analyzed. Using InSAR measurements and groundwater level data, the response of the aquifer skeletal system to the change in hydraulic head was quantified, and the hydromechanical properties of the aquifer system is characterized. The estimated storage coefficients, ranging from 6.0×10-4 to 0.02 during 2006-2011 and from 2.3×10-5 to 0.087 during 2015-2020, signify an irreversible and unrecoverable deformation of the aquifer system in the Willcox Basin. The reduced average storage coefficient (from 0.008 to 0.005) indicates that long-term overdraft has already degraded the storage ability of the aquifer system and that groundwater pumping activities are unsustainable in the Willcox Basin. Historical spatiotemporal storage loss from 1990 to 2020 was also estimated using InSAR measurements, hydraulic head and estimated skeletal storativity. The estimated cumulative groundwater storage depletion was 3.7×108 m3 from 1990 to 2006. 

    Understanding the characteristics of land surface deformation and quantifying the response of aquifer systems in the Willcox Basin and other groundwater basins elsewhere are important in managing groundwater exploitation to sustain the mechanical health and integrity of aquifer systems.

    How to cite: Peng, M., Lu, Z., Zhao, C., Motagh, M., Bai, L., and Conway, B. D.: Use of satellite remote sensing and independent component analysis to assess land subsidence and aquifer system properties over the Willcox Basin, USA, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4147, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4147, 2022.

    EGU22-4617 | Presentations | HS8.1.8

    Vulnerability of aquifers on volcanic islands: the case of La Palma and El Hierro (Canary Islands, Spain) 

    Juan C. Santamarta, Noelia Cruz-Pérez, Jesica Rodríguez-Martín, Miguel Ángel Marazuela, Rosana Álvarez-Vázquez, and Alejandro García-Gil

    The outermost regions of Europe are nine: Guadeloupe, French Guiana, Martinique, Mayotte, Reunion and Saint Martin (France), the Canary Islands (Spain), the Azores and Madeira (Portugal). These regions enrich the EU economically, culturally and geographically, hosting 80% of its biodiversity. However, due to their remoteness and other unique features, they pose challenges for their development. The particular case of the Canary Islands will be developed in the framework of the European H2020 project Arsinoe, where the hydrological cycle and agriculture in the Canary archipelago will be studied in El Hierro and La Palma. These two islands have been selected for the following reasons: i) El Hierro is a pioneer in presenting a self-sufficient energy model (La Gorona del Viento project) and is rich in groundwater, this being the most used water resource on the island; ii) La Palma has been selected because it is an island rich in groundwater (in fact, it is the only island in the Canary archipelago that does not have desalination plants) and where agriculture is very important (especially tropical crops such as banana, mango, avocado, etc.) and, due to the volcanic eruption that began in September 2021, the situation of the aquifer is uncertain, something that is worrying since La Palma depends on groundwater resources to guarantee the water demand of agriculture, local population and tourism. The effect of the eruption on the vulnerability of the aquifer of La Palma is still unknown, so it is desired to study in depth the effects on the aquifer in quantitative and qualitative terms therefore, ARSINOE will focus on the ecological transition and vulnerability of aquifers in volcanic islands and will put further efforts to the primary production including agriculture, forestry, fisheries and aquaculture, water management and clean energy infrastructure. ARSINOE will take into account the interdependence between water and agriculture. The agricultural sector is the largest water user in the Canary Islands, where wine, potatoes and tomatoes are the main exports. Therefore, greater sustainability within the water sector (through the water footprint and the carbon footprint) will positively affect the agricultural sector and, therefore, the water and energy situation of the archipelago. But aquifers of both islands are also at risk due to other circumstances, specifically those derived from climate change: greater saline intrusion (due to rising sea levels), losses in freshwater inputs (due to decreased rainfall), changes in physic-chemical conditions of all water bodies… All these effects will be studied on both islands, through the ARSINOE Project, and from a local point of view. 

    How to cite: Santamarta, J. C., Cruz-Pérez, N., Rodríguez-Martín, J., Marazuela, M. Á., Álvarez-Vázquez, R., and García-Gil, A.: Vulnerability of aquifers on volcanic islands: the case of La Palma and El Hierro (Canary Islands, Spain), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4617, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4617, 2022.

    EGU22-5856 | Presentations | HS8.1.8

    Downscaling WGHM-Based Groundwater Storage Data Using Regression Method: A Regional Study over Qazvin Plain, Iran 

    Soroush Zarghami Dastjerdi, Ehsan Sharifi, Bahram Saghafian, and Andreas Güntner

    Climate change, urbanization, and growing population have led to the rapid increase in the use of groundwater. Therefore, monitoring the groundwater (GW) changes is essential for water management and decision-makers. Due to frequent lack of reliable and sufficient in-situ information, remote sensing and hydrological models can be counted as the alternative sources for assessing GW storage changes on a regional and global scale. Here, we test such an approach for Qazvin Plain in Iran, one of the regions that recently have been facing severe drought conditions. The main purpose of this study is to downscale GW storage anomaly (GWSA) of the WaterGAP Global Hydrology Model (WGHM) from a coarse (0.5-degree) to a finer spatial resolution (0.1-degree) using fine spatial resolution auxiliary datasets (0.1-degree) such as the evaporation, surface and subsurface runoff, snow depth, volumetric soil water, and soil temperature from the ERA5-Land model and precipitation from integrated multi-satellite retrievals for global precipitation measurement (IMERG). Different regression models were tested for the GWSA downscaling. Moreover, since different water budget components such as precipitation or storage are known to have temporal lead or lag relative to each other, the approach also includes a time shift factor among the components. The most suitable regression model with the highest skill score during the validation test was selected and applied to predict the 0.1-degree GWSA. The downscaled results showed a high agreement with the in-situ groundwater levels for Qazvin Plain in both interannual and monthly scales, with a correlation coefficient of 0.99 and 0.65, respectively. Moreover, the downscaled product clearly proves that the developed downscaling technique is able to learn from high-resolution auxiliary data to capture GWSA features at higher spatial resolution. The major benefit of this method is in utilizing only the auxiliary data that are available with global coverage and free of cost, and that this method does not need in-situ GW records for training. Therefore, the proposed downscaling technique can potentially be applied to a global scale, other geographical regions, or aquifers.

    This study has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme for G3P (Global Gravity-based Groundwater Product) under grant agreement nº 870353.

    How to cite: Zarghami Dastjerdi, S., Sharifi, E., Saghafian, B., and Güntner, A.: Downscaling WGHM-Based Groundwater Storage Data Using Regression Method: A Regional Study over Qazvin Plain, Iran, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5856, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5856, 2022.

    Arid and semi-arid areas characterised by low precipitation and high evaporation rates are highly vulnerable to alterations in precipitation regimes, leading to water deficiency and an increase in dependence on groundwater resources. Flash floods have become more frequent in several semi-arid regions due to changing climatic conditions. Thus, an efficient water management system is needed for these regions to manage flash floods and support groundwater recharge. A coupled surface water-groundwater model is an advanced tool for simulating large-scale hydrologic processes and quantifying factors influencing floods and drought. To accommodate the high variability and heterogeneous spatial distribution of surface and groundwater resources, distributed modelling tools are essential. However, scarce monitoring networks may lead to the unavailability of spatio-temporal input data and limit the applicability of these models. Advances in remote sensing (RS) techniques for monitoring hydrological parameters like precipitation, soil moisture, evapotranspiration, and groundwater depth can mitigate this problem.

    This study analyses the remote sensing product MOD11A1.006 of Moderate Resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer (MODIS), which provides daily day and night land surface temperature (LST) at a spatial resolution of 1000 m, facilitating the analysis of surface water-groundwater interactions through distributed hydrological modelling in the semi-arid Banas River basin (~6800 km2). Remotely sensed LST data allowed air surface temperature (Ta), which is crucial for estimating reference evapotranspiration, to be retrieved. While Ta at weather stations 2 m above the ground are more accurate, those data have limited spatial coverage. The Banas River basin contains five weather stations located primarily in the central region. To improve the spatial distribution of reference evapotranspiration, which is a significant input of the hydrological models, a linear regression model using Ta observed at the weather stations of Banas basin, along with LST, elevation, Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI), latitude, and longitude of the pixels coinciding with the location of weather stations was developed to estimate the air surface temperature for the whole basin.

    A multiple linear regression model was built by stepwise linear regression (SLR) method using the OLSRR package of R. Calibration using day LST, latitude and longitude provided the best estimate of maximum Ta, with an adjusted R2 value of 0.60, Pearson correlation coefficient (r) of 0.72, and Root Mean Square Error (RMSE) of 3.2o C. While calibration using night LST and elevation data provided the best estimate of minimum Ta with an adjusted R2 value of 0.81, r of 0.84 and RMSE of 3.02o C. The daily LST data and daily Ta data have shown a good agreement. This research improves the understanding of the spatial distribution of daily day and night air temperature in the Banas River basin. It opens a new methodological perspective for groundwater and surface water management through hydrological modelling with a spatial resolution greater than that of the existing monitoring networks.

    How to cite: Singh, N., Cartwright, I., and Chinnasamy, P.: Estimation of air surface temperature using MODIS land surface temperature over data-scarce Banas River basin, Western India, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6881, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6881, 2022.

    Benfratello's conceptual method, to estimate the irrigation deficit for agricultural districts in semiarid or arid climate, firstly came to light in 1961. The method generalizes previous Thornthwaite (1948) and Thornthwaite and Mather (1955) water balances to assess the irrigation deficit as the difference between the maximum evapotranspiration, exerted by the plant in full irrigation conditions and traditionally estimated with the Thornthwaite formula, and the actual evapotranspiration provided by the available soil water. Since its first appearance, it has been applied to the study of many areas in Southern Italy. Due to its simplicity and to the small number of required parameters, Benfratello's method might be regarded to as an effective tool to assess the effects of climatic, landuse and anthropogenic changes on the soil water balance and on the irrigation deficit.

    In the previous General Assembly we presented a GIS based application of Benfratello's method to the case study of the semiarid Capitanata plane (4550 km2, Southern Italy), which is one of the most important agricultural districts in Italy. With this contribution we present a further theoretical development of the method that allows to simply estimate in closed form the uncertainity of the calculated irrigation deficit, once known the uncertainty of the required climatic variables (temperature and precipitation). Our procedure is based on a local linearization of the core—function of Benfratello’s method, which presents the decrease of the available soil water, during the dry season, as a function of the potential soil water loss, given by the difference between the maximum evapotranspiration demand and the precipitation. The maximum evapotranspiration was in this case determined by means of the Hargraves formula, according to FAO procedure in case of limited availability of meteorological data. The estimate of the uncertainty can be easily performed in both the cases in which the field capacity is completely or only partially restored during the wet season. As a test case, the method was then applied to some sites in the Capitanata plane and extended to the whole plane through a GIS application, with fair results if compared with the required water volumes declared by the local irrigation consortium.

    How to cite: Barontini, S., Peli, M., Rapuzzi, C., Colosio, P., and Ranzi, R.: A method to assess the uncertainty of Benfratello’s estimate of the irrigation deficit in a semiarid area and its GIS based application for anthropogenic and climate change scenarios, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8159, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8159, 2022.

    EGU22-8221 | Presentations | HS8.1.8

    Impact of climate change and groundwater consumption scenarios on a major transboundary karst water resource - The Western Mountain Aquifer in Israel and the West Bank 

    Lysander Bresinsky, Jannes Kordilla, Irina Engelhardt, Yakov Livshitz, and Martin Sauter

    Climate simulations indicate that the Mediterranean region will be severely affected by climate change and is often referred to as the most prominent climate change hotspot (Gao and Giorgi, 2008). This study addresses the combined effects of climate change and three groundwater consumption scenarios on the water availability of the Western Mountain Aquifer (WMA) in Israel and the West Bank. Generally applied methods to quantify recharge and water resources rely on linear regressions or simplified models, such as data-driven approaches (i.e., lumped-parameter and black-box approaches). However, they are unfit to assess climate change impacts because the predictive power of data-driven approaches is low, should the variability of, e.g., precipitation expand beyond historically observed fluctuations, such as expected from climate change effects. Furthermore,  they do not honor the physics of flow. Therefore, assessing the impact of climate change requires the application of distributed process-based numerical models that incorporate as many relevant physical flow processes as feasible. For example, when karstified vadose zones measure several hundreds of meters, such as in the case of the WMA, variably saturated flow is a highly relevant flow process controlling vadose storage at large timescales and altering recharge flux at the “control plane” groundwater table.
    We simulate the complex dynamics of the dual-domain infiltration and partitioning of the precipitation input signal by employing HydroGeoSphere (HGS) for transient variably saturated water flow. Flow in the limestone rock matrix and secondary high porosity system (i.e., conduits and fractures) is modeled by overlapping individual continua based on the bulk effective Richards’ equation with van Genuchten (VG) parameterization. The model input of this study stems from two coherent dynamically downscaled high-resolution regional climate projections (daily, 3km, and 8km resolution) until the year 2070, assuming the IPCC RCP4.5 climate change scenario. The results indicate that long-term average recharge quantities will decrease by circa 10 % compared to the reduction in average precipitation by 30 %. The mitigated impact on recharge is an effect of the pronounced heterogeneity of karstic flow (i.e., preferential recharge along with karst dissolution features) and increased intensity of individual rainfall events, emphasizing the need to apply spatiotemporally resolved climate models with daily precipitation values as input to the recharge assessment. However, despite the comparatively moderate decrease in recharge, the length and severity of consecutive drought years with low recharge values are likely to increase while freshwater demand is believed to increase during these periods, emphasizing the need to adjust the current management practices to climate change. Finally, the model is used to simulate managed aquifer recharge applications to mitigate the effects of more extended drought periods by strategic freshwater reserves. 

    How to cite: Bresinsky, L., Kordilla, J., Engelhardt, I., Livshitz, Y., and Sauter, M.: Impact of climate change and groundwater consumption scenarios on a major transboundary karst water resource - The Western Mountain Aquifer in Israel and the West Bank, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8221, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8221, 2022.

    EGU22-8732 | Presentations | HS8.1.8

    Prospecting Potential Groundwater Zones through Geotechnology and Statistics Techniques in the Grande River Basin, Bahia,Brazil 

    Thyago Anthony Soares Lima and Paulo de Tarso Amorim Castro

    The source of the Grande river and its tributaries on the left bank are located in a tropical region adjacent to the humid valley of the Tocantins river, with rainfall that favors the continuity of the rivers. In the middle and east part of the basin, the predominance is of the semi-arid climate, as well as typical of the middle São Francisco basin, with irregular rainfall that does not contribute to the supply of the rivers. It is noteworthy that most of the tributaries of the hydrographic basin are intermittent. The Grande river basin is part of two important hydrogeological systems, the Group Bambuí system and the Urucuia system (SAU), which is the most important system in the western region of Bahia, as well as one of the most important in the São Francisco river basin, as well as the entire brazilian Northeast region, in addition to being one of the most relevant in the country, since it is a strategic source of water. Such hydrogeological systems are directly responsible for supplying the hydrographic basin in its dry periods. The Brazilian semi-arid region, with its limited water resources, is currently classified as a critical dry and water-poor area. This study aims to identify potential areas of groundwater in the aforementioned hydrographic basin, located in the middle eastern portion of the São Francisco river basin, in the State of Bahia. Integrating geological and hydrogeological analyses, remote sensing, geographic information systems (GIS) and multicriteria statistical evaluation (AHP) techniques. It is intended to create thematic layers in a GIS where values will be assigned using appropriate weights and classifications in relation to their relative contribution to the occurrence of groundwater through multicriteria assessment techniques. These layers include lithology, geomorphology, lineament density, drainage density, soil texture, precipitation, and slope. The final groundwater potential map is composed of five classes of groundwater potential: very high, high, moderate, low and very low. The validity of the results of this GIS-based model was performed by superimposing existing wells, analyzing the statistical probability of the existence of groundwater. The single parameter sensitivity test was performed to evaluate the influence of the signaled weights on the groundwater potential model, and new effective weights will be derived after the analysis, as a way to calibrate the model, and the ROC analysis was applied to validate the model

    Keywords :Groundwater, Grande River Basin, AHP, Prospecting, Statistical probability, GIS

     

    How to cite: Soares Lima, T. A. and Amorim Castro, P. D. T.: Prospecting Potential Groundwater Zones through Geotechnology and Statistics Techniques in the Grande River Basin, Bahia,Brazil, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8732, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8732, 2022.

    EGU22-9631 | Presentations | HS8.1.8

    Predicting evaporative loss at an Argentinian vineyard using a coupled water, vapor and heat flow model 

    Johanna Blöcher, Arij Chmeis, and Michal Kuraz

    Water resources in arid regions around the world are under a lot of strain due to extremely low precipitation rates and very high evaporation. In addition to water scarcity, irrigation methods can be inefficient. For example, over-irrigation beyond soil saturation can cause many problems, such as an increase in soil salinity and a decrease in productive soil capacity. This research aims to design a water content and soil temperature prediction system for an automated sensor monitoring system installed at the vineyard Ecohumus in San Juan province, Argentina. Short-term predictions of the water balance have the potential in delivering a useful tool to farmers for optimizing their irrigation water consumption.

    For modeling soil water dynamics with evaporation and root water uptake losses, we use a coupled water, vapor, and heat flow model implemented in DRUtES software, Kuraz and Blöcher (2020). The model's top boundary condition solves the surface energy balance. For that we use weather forecast data and solar radiation as an input. The weather forecast is obtained from Norwegian meteorological institute (yr.no) using their API for developers which is provided as a free service. The solar radiation is computed based on equations suggested in the FAO Irrigation and Drainage guideline No. 56 and by Saito et al. (2006). Due to the lack of measurement data on the study site, soil hydraulic and thermal properties are estimated. We neglect the effect of soil organic matter in the water retention model and assume a homogeneous type of soil for the thermodynamic model. We establish communication with sensors installed in the soil for estimating initial conditions as well as with weather forecast service for estimating boundary conditions using our R script.

    The result is output records that simulate pressure heads and water content distribution across the flow field over the simulated period. We present a system that describes the flow field allowing us to calculate evaporation rate changes with time, thereby optimizing the irrigation process according to soil and plant needs. This can be a helpful decision-making tool for farmers.

    How to cite: Blöcher, J., Chmeis, A., and Kuraz, M.: Predicting evaporative loss at an Argentinian vineyard using a coupled water, vapor and heat flow model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9631, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9631, 2022.

    EGU22-12385 | Presentations | HS8.1.8

    Impact of irrigation scheduling on yield and water productivity of soybeans in a sub-humid environment: A modelling approach. 

    Angela Gabriela Morales Santos, Reinhard Nolz, and Margarita García-Vila

    In sub-humid areas, supplementary irrigation is often needed to meet crop water requirements and avoid yield reduction. The effect of water scarcity on agriculture is worsened in locations where summer rainfall is decreasing as a consequence of climate change. In order to stabilize crop production through sustainable water management, improvements of irrigation scheduling methods are required. For instance, traditional irrigation scheduling criteria that provided adequate yields in the past, may no longer be appropriate under drier conditions. Models that combine crop physiological and soil hydrological processes can help improving irrigation scheduling to optimize water productivity. The purpose of this study was to evaluate irrigation management approaches traditionally used by farmers in Austria, specifically at a study site located in the largest crop production area of the country (ca. 35 km east from Vienna), by means of a modelling approach. This study also aimed at proposing an irrigation schedule that increases water productivity, thereby aiding water conservation.

    AquaCrop is a crop growth model developed by the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO) that uses an empirical and mechanistic approach to simulate yield response to water for a variety of crops. In this study, AquaCrop was used to simulate crop water requirements of soybeans in a sub-humid environment under different water management practices. The model was validated after adjustments on the non-conservative crop parameters based on field measurements. The experimental field was divided into four plots. One plot was rainfed and the others were irrigated – each of them by means of a different irrigation system. The systems used were sprinklers on a pipe network, drip lines and a hose reel boom. Irrigation was managed by the farmers based on their experience. The collected data included leaf area index to obtain green canopy cover development and soil samples at different depths to characterize the soil. After the validation process, an irrigation schedule that covered the full crop water requirements was automatically generated by the model. Additionally, irrigation schedules for each irrigated plot were generated based on percentage of readily available soil water (RAW) thresholds.

    The simulated yields were in good agreement with the observed data, with a model efficiency coefficient (EF) > 0.80 for the four plots. The irrigated plots revealed a certain level of stress during the critical crop growth stage of flowering, even though they were expected to represent well-watered conditions. After simulating net crop water requirements, the resulting potential yield was larger than the observed yields. Furthermore, the irrigation events generated using RAW thresholds also produced larger yields than the observed ones. The results showed that to schedule the irrigation events earlier in the season and distribute the same total irrigation water amount in four events rather than three – as scheduled by the farmers – increased the yield and thus, water productivity. Therefore, AquaCrop model predictions can help improving farmers’ irrigation scheduling strategies for soybeans under this study conditions. This might be helpful for local farmers in situations of increasing pressure on water resources.

    How to cite: Morales Santos, A. G., Nolz, R., and García-Vila, M.: Impact of irrigation scheduling on yield and water productivity of soybeans in a sub-humid environment: A modelling approach., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12385, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12385, 2022.

    EGU22-12997 | Presentations | HS8.1.8

    Monitoring Solanum lycopersicum var. Elpida salinity stress using multispectral imaging 

    Dimitris Papadimitriou, Ioannis Daliakopoulos, Constantinos Constantinopoulos, Thrassyvoulos Manios, and Dimitrios Kosmopoulos

    Under salinity stress, plant physiology and yield characteristics deteriorate, showing, among others, symptoms similar to those of water stress. Tomato (Solanum lycopersicum) is moderately sensitive to salinity stress and suffers yield losses of over 15% at irrigation water electrical conductivity (ECw) of  3 dSm-1 (Malash et al., 2008) and over 25% at ECw of 3.5 dSm-1 (Daliakopoulos et al., 2019). As salinity can often buildup in soils and substrates, it can have a creeping effect not readily measurable in irrigation water ECw, therefore it is essential that plant physiology symptoms are spotted early to take corrective action. Here we investigate the potential of multispectral imaging, to detect early symptoms of salinity stress on S.lycopersicum plants (var. Elpida) due to NaCl accumulation in the nutrient solution of a soilless cultivation system. In this context, we established a control (0.5 mM) and five salinity treatments of 5.0, 10.0, 15.0, 20.0 mM NaCl, with three tomato plants (replications) per treatment, resulting in a total number of 18 S.lycopersicum plants. During the experiment, multispectral images (bands 460, 540, 630, 850, and 980 nm) were obtained at three stages of plant development (30, 60, and 90 days after transplant) using a MUSES9-MS sensor. For each multispectral image, four spectral indices (NDVI, OSAVI, LWSI and GOSAVI) were calculated. Although, the statistical analysis of the results reveal low sensitivity to the increasing salinity at early sampling stage (60 DAT), during the third sampling stage (120 DAT) all spectral indicators demonstrate significant sensitivity for treatments over 10.0 mM NaCl.

    References

    Daliakopoulos, I.N., Apostolakis, A., Wagner, K., Deligianni, A., Koutskoudis, D., Stamatakis, A., Tsanis, I.K., 2019. Effectiveness of Trichoderma harzianum in soil and yield conservation of tomato crops under saline irrigation. Catena 175. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.catena.2018.12.009

    Malash, N.M., Ali, F.A., Fatahalla, M.A., A. khatab, E., Hatem, M.K., Tawfic, S., 2008. Response of tomato to irrigation with saline water applied by different irrigation methods and water management stratigies. Int. J. Plant Prod. 2, 101–116.

    Acknowledgements
    This research has been co-financed by the European Union and Greek national funds through the Operational Program Competitiveness, Entrepreneurship, and Innovation, under the call RESEARCH-CREATE-INNOVATE (project codes: T1EDK-04171)

    How to cite: Papadimitriou, D., Daliakopoulos, I., Constantinopoulos, C., Manios, T., and Kosmopoulos, D.: Monitoring Solanum lycopersicum var. Elpida salinity stress using multispectral imaging, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12997, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12997, 2022.

    EGU22-13446 | Presentations | HS8.1.8

    Water harvesting in the Jordanian Badia: Trade-offs between micro and macro structures 

    Mira Haddad, Geert Sterk, Jasper Goos, Stefan Strohmeier, and Job de Vries

    The Jordanian Badia is a desert region that covers roughly 90% of Jordan. Average annual rainfall in the Badia is below 200 mm and is only occurring during the winter months (Nov – Feb). Despite the dry conditions the Badia it is a vital region to the country, especially for ago-pastoralist communities. Over the past decades unsustainable land management and especially overgrazing have resulted in reduced vegetation cover, soil degradation, and loss of biodiversity. Rainwater harvesting structures are used to regenerate soils, improve vegetation cover and allow barley production in local depressions. Two types of water harvesting structures are currently tested in experimental catchments.

    The first type is the Vallerani micro water harvesting structure. A Vallerani is constructed along a hillslope contour and consist of a ridge and furrow. The interspace area between two Vallerani’s is the surface runoff collection area. Inside the furrow native shrubs (Atriplex halimus) are planted and provide fodder for livestock. Vallerani structures are simple and cheap to construct, reduce soil erosion, conserve moisture and stimulate vegetation cover. The second type of rainwater harvesting is the Marab, which is a macro-scale water harvesting technique. A Marab consists of a series of earthen dams that are constructed parallel in a local depression. Surface water from a wadi enters at the upstream end in the Marab and is forced to flow in a zig-zag pattern around the constructed dams. The flow speed of the surface water is slowed down which results in enhanced infiltration. The stored water in the soil is used to grow a barley crop in the interspaces between the constructed dams. Apart from conserving moisture, Marabs retain sediments and help to reduce flash floods in the Badia.

    When Vallarani’s and a Marab are both constructed in one catchment there is a trade-off between the two structures. The more Vallerani’s are implemented on hillslopes the less water will flow towards the downstream Marab. In this study modelling was used to optimize the location and number of Vallerani structures and quantify the available water running to the Marab in an experimental catchment. The Soil and Water Assessment Tool (SWAT) was used for this purpose. Rainfall, discharge and soil data were collected from the field during the 2018/2019 rainy season. The calibrated model showed good performance for large events but underestimated smaller events. A 30 year run was made, with and without Vallerani structures. Increasing the number and area of Vallerani structures from zero to the maximum decreased the number of significant runoff events by 45.3%, and the total discharge reaching the Marab by 36.2%. Using SWAT, the number and locations of the Vallerani’s were optimized to ensure that the Marab would receive enough water, while maximizing the number of hillslope water harvesting structures. It is concluded that implementation of Vallerani’s in sub-watersheds that produce low amounts of surface runoff results in most vegetation cover on hillslopes, while allowing sufficient barley production in the Marab.

    How to cite: Haddad, M., Sterk, G., Goos, J., Strohmeier, S., and de Vries, J.: Water harvesting in the Jordanian Badia: Trade-offs between micro and macro structures, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13446, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13446, 2022.

    HS8.2 – Subsurface hydrology – Groundwater

    Choushui River alluvial fan is an important agricultural area with complicated agricultural cropping patterns in central-western Taiwan. Groundwater has long been regarded as an alternative water source because of the lack of sufficient surface water. Nitrogen loading from intense application of chemical fertilizer has been identified as a major source of non-point source pollution of shallow groundwater in this area. To evaluate the effectiveness of rational fertilization policy promoted by governmental agency on nitrogen pollution control since the beginning of the 21st century, the currently status (averaged from 2018 to 2020) and variation trend of ammonium-N and nitrate-N concentrations recorded from 38 monitoring wells were determined. High level of ammonium-N concentrations appeared not only in double-rice cropping area, but also in rotational cropping area, which dominate the nitrogen pollution in shallow groundwater currently. Mann-Kendall’s trend test revealed that upward trends only exhibited in 4 and 6 wells for ammonium-N and nitrate-N, respectively. In contrast, downward trends occurred in 15 and 25 wells for ammonium-N and nitrate-N. However, the further analysis combined with the Theil-Sen slope estimation and magnitude classification indicating that most of the downward trends should be classified into stable conditions due to the relatively small variation magnitudes. Nevertheless, the promotion of rational fertilization has achieved a preliminary goal for mitigating the nitrogen pollution in shallow aquifer. As the current situation of ammonium-N contamination in shallow groundwater of the study area is still severe, relevant agricultural non-point source pollution control measures should continue to be vigorously promoted for a long time.

    Keywords: Groundwater, Ammonium-N, Nitrate-N, Mann-Kendall’s trend test

    How to cite: Chen, S.-K., Lee, Y.-Y., and Liao, T.-L.: Assessment of ammonium-N/nitrate-N contamination in the shallow aquifer of a complex agricultural region, central-western Taiwan, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1138, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1138, 2022.

    EGU22-1828 | Presentations | HS8.2.1 | Highlight

    Groundwater vulnerability of megacity under changing climate and land use scenarios 

    Balaji Lakshminarayanan, Saravanan Ramasamy, and Saravanan Karuppanan

    Rapid urbanization and climate change pose a serious threat to the groundwater resource of urban regions in terms of contamination and excessive groundwater abstraction. To understand and protect groundwater resources from anthropogenic activities, an index-based vulnerability assessment model which integrates future climatic variables and land use (LU) is needed. This study attempts to identify the impact of climate and land use change on future groundwater vulnerability of rapidly urbanizing South Asian city, Chennai Metropolitan Area (CMA), India using DRASTIC-LU model under RCP4.5 and RCP8.5 scenarios for near (2020-2035) and far future period (2035 - 2050). The dynamic variables of the DRASTIC-LU model such as depth to groundwater - D, net recharge - R, and land use - LU were projected using regional climatic models and land change modeler. Three regional climatic models (RCMs) namely ICHEC-EC-EARTH, MIROC-MIROC5, and CNRM-CERFACS-CNRM-CM5 were compared and selected using Taylor’s diagram. The ICHEC-EC-EARTH model was found to perform better than the other two RCMs for this region and was used to project future climatic variables under RCP4.5 and RCP8.5 scenarios for two future periods (4 scenarios). Terrset land change modeler (LCM) was used to project future land use for the years 2030 and 2050. Vulnerability condition of the base period (2018) was assessed using nitrate concentration and vulnerability indices, the developed DRASTIC-LU model produces an accuracy of (AUC = 0.796). The projected groundwater vulnerability depicts an increase in vulnerability area from the base period as 21.41%, 30.09%, 20.98%, and 22.01% for scenario-1,2,3 and 4 respectively. Variation in precipitation pattern contributes to change in future net recharge and groundwater level and increased built-up region, i.e, change in land use attributes to increase in future groundwater vulnerability. Based on future vulnerability analysis, it is identified that the CMA groundwater system is in critical condition of high vulnerability for near and far future periods. 

    How to cite: Lakshminarayanan, B., Ramasamy, S., and Karuppanan, S.: Groundwater vulnerability of megacity under changing climate and land use scenarios, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1828, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1828, 2022.

    EGU22-2232 | Presentations | HS8.2.1

    Exploring climate change impact on groundwater supporting a medium and long term water management planning, a case study in Northern Italy. 

    Agnese Redaelli, Marco Rotiroti, Tullia Bonomi, Letizia Fumagalli, Mariachiara Caschetto, Francesco Esposto, Gianfranco Sinatra, Mauro Olivieri, Sonia Bozza, and Chiara Zanotti

    Groundwater systems are going to play an increasingly important role in facing climate change, representing one of the most significant worldwide water sources. At the same time, climate change may inevitabily lead to considerable direct and indirect impacts on groundwater systems.

    The aim of this work is the development of a knowledge framework for groundwater bodies in relation to water availability and its vulnerability to possible climate change scenarios, identifying the mitigation action that can be adopted to resiliently respond to changes. The study area is the province of Brescia, in northern Italy, including 100 municipalities served by 183 wells and 98 springs. This area includes a higher plain, hosting a unconfined acquifer, a lower plain with several layered confined acquifers and two morainic amphitheaters.

    To define the evolutionary scenarios of groundwater resources at basin and sub-basin scale, hydrodynamic conditions and temporal trends, over a time span from 2009 to 2021, have been evaluated.

    Groundwater availability data have been analysed in relation to hydro-nivo-meteorological data collected from the meteorological stations distributed in the area. Mann-Kendall and Sen Slope estimator have been applied for trend identification and changing point analysis to explore groundwater time series.

    Regarding precipitation, a first analysis aimed at the identification of extreme phenomena through the yearly distributions of dry and rainy days and through the calculation of specific indices such as SPI (Standard Precipitation Index) and PCI (Precipitation Concentration Index).

    The piezometric and precipitation series have been subjected to time series decomposition, a mathematical procedure that splits the original series into three sub-components: seasonal, trend, and random. Successively, a comparative analysis has been performed between the three components of groundwater levels and the three components of the neighboring rain stations data.

    This methodology allowed to investigate the actual effect of precipitation on groundwater level variability with respect to the other components that contribute to the total water budget: it emerged that in the higher plain the effects of irrigation return flow contributes to the summer groundwater table rise more than precipitation, and that in the lower plain groundwater table depth is more related to human abstraction than local precipitation. These results provide the basis for implementing future sustainable water management plans.

    How to cite: Redaelli, A., Rotiroti, M., Bonomi, T., Fumagalli, L., Caschetto, M., Esposto, F., Sinatra, G., Olivieri, M., Bozza, S., and Zanotti, C.: Exploring climate change impact on groundwater supporting a medium and long term water management planning, a case study in Northern Italy., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2232, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2232, 2022.

    EGU22-2236 | Presentations | HS8.2.1

    Mapping areas suitable for artificial recharge structures in the Ropar District of Punjab, India 

    Thallam Prashanth, Dolon Banerjee, and Sayantan Ganguly

    Groundwater is an important resource in India as it is used extensively for industrial, agricultural and drinking purposes. With the increase in demand due to growth in population, industrialization and improvement of living standards, the groundwater resources in India are depleting. For instance, the long-term trend of groundwater level observed in the Ropar district of Punjab, India for a span of ten years shows a gradual decline. The maximum fall of groundwater level is observed to be 1.05 m/year. In Ropar, the natural recharge process is diminishing because of rapid urbanization, variation in rainfall, and temperature patterns. Therefore the available water is found to be insufficient to fulfil the rise in water demand.To replenish the declining groundwater table and thus maintain the balance between the water supply and demand, artificial recharge techniques are proven to be beneficial in various studies. In this study, areas suitable for artificial recharge have been proposed.Remote Sensing(RS) techniques and the Geographic Information System(GIS) has been used to prepare various thematic maps constituting slope, land use & land cover, soil, geomorphology, the thickness of granular zone (permeable zones), the distance between recharge structure and the Sutlej river, rainfall map, drainage density, and population density. Lithological mapping in and around the Ropar district has been analyzed using borehole logs and reports from Central Ground Water Board, Govt. of India. Analytical Hierarchical Process (AHP) and Artificial Neural Networks (ANN) model have been used to determine the weightage of different parameters to map the suitable areas required for artificial recharge in the Ropar District. Finally, the best type of artificial recharge structure has been chosen based on higher stream order, drainage density and lithology for the present scenario.

    How to cite: Prashanth, T., Banerjee, D., and Ganguly, S.: Mapping areas suitable for artificial recharge structures in the Ropar District of Punjab, India, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2236, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2236, 2022.

    EGU22-3643 | Presentations | HS8.2.1

    Groundwater Quality Assessment Using CCME WQI and GIS Technique for Ujjain City, India 

    Usman Mohseni, Nilesh Patidar, Azazkhan Pathan, Saran Raaj, Nitin Kachhawa, Dr. P.G Agnihotri, Dr. Dhruvesh Patel, Dr. Cristina Prieto, Dr. Pankaj Gandhi, and Dr. Bojan Durin

    Groundwater is a significant source of freshwater for people all around the world. About 97.2 % of the water on Earth is saline, with only 2.8 % available for usage as fresh water, of which approximately 20 % is groundwater. In India, a large portion of the populace relies on groundwater for drinking. The determination of water quality in residential, commercial, and industrialised areas is of great importance, and for this, the water quality index (WQI) is an effective tool which determines the suitability for drinking water of groundwater. The WQI is described as an index that reflects the combined impact of several water quality parameters that are analysed and accounted for while calculating the water quality index. In the present study, 54 groundwater samples were collected from the 54 wards of Ujjain city, Madhya Pradesh, India, during the summer period of 2019. The Bureau of Indian Standards (BIS, 2012) was used to assess the appropriateness of groundwater for drinking and calculate WQI. The water quality index was calculated using eight water quality parameters, including pH, turbidity, electrical conductivity (EC), total dissolved solids (TDS), alkalinity, chlorides (Cl–), hardness, and fluorides (F–). The objective of the study is to determine the class of all 54 samples using the Canadian Council of Ministers of Environment Water Quality Index (CCMEWQI) into five classes: excellent, good, fair, marginal, and poor. Also, the Geographic Information System (GIS) mapping technique was used to outline the spatial distribution trend of physiochemical properties and predominant ion concentration in groundwater. The obtained results suggest that wards 34 and 39 had the lowest CCMEWQI values of 32.873 and 32.120, respectively, which is unsatisfactory when compared to other wards. As a result, the general water quality of both wards (34 and 39) is poor and completely unfit for direct drinking. The CCMEWQI was found to be marginal in Wards 2, 3, 4, 6, 8, 9, 10, 12, 15, 19, 24, 25, 26, 35, 38, 40, 41, 42, 45, 46, 48, 49, and 53. Wards 5, 8, 11, 13, 14, 21, 22, 23, 28, 29, 30, 31,32, 33, 36, 50, 51, and 54 had fair water quality. CCMEWQI > 79 indicates that the water quality is good, as in Wards 20, 44, and 47. It is concluded from CCMEWQI that 6% of samples were found in the good category. 33% of the ground water samples were found to be in the range of fair quality. Similarly, 41% of samples were marginal, while 20% of samples were found to be poor. In the study area, groundwater is the main source of drinking water, so it must be managed effectively before its quality degrades.

    How to cite: Mohseni, U., Patidar, N., Pathan, A., Raaj, S., Kachhawa, N., Agnihotri, Dr. P. G., Patel, Dr. D., Prieto, Dr. C., Gandhi, Dr. P., and Durin, Dr. B.: Groundwater Quality Assessment Using CCME WQI and GIS Technique for Ujjain City, India, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3643, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3643, 2022.

    EGU22-3814 | Presentations | HS8.2.1

    GIS-Based Mapping of Groundwater Potential Zones Using AHP for Ujjain District, Madhya Pradesh, India 

    Nilesh Patidar, Usman Mohseni, Azazkhan Pathan, Saran Raaj, Dr. P.G Agnihotri, Khushboo Jariwala, Nidhi Chandarana, Dr. Dhruvesh Patel, Dr. Cristina Prieto, and Dr. Bojan Đurin

    Groundwater is one of the most important natural resources, with quality and quantity fluctuating across space. One of the key sources that contributes to the overall yearly supply is groundwater. Groundwater resources are under significant threat as a result of various factors, including rising population, urbanization, and industrialization. In rural regions, groundwater supplies 80–90% of household water. The fall in groundwater levels is caused by unreliable monsoons and poor-quality surface water supplies. As a result, identifying and delineating the GWPZ that can be used to supplement the groundwater supply is important. The goal of this research is to combine geospatial techniques such as geographic information systems (GIS) and remote sensing (RS) to analyse the groundwater potential in the Ujjain district of Madhya Pradesh, India. To create the GWPZ map, the thematic layers of the primary elements that govern the occurrence and movement of groundwater in hard rock regions were prioritized, weighted, and aggregated in a linear combination equation in the ArcGIS Raster Calculator. In this study area for evaluating groundwater potential zones, a total of nine thematic maps were prepared, such as geology, drainage density, geomorphology, lithology, soil, land use/land cover, elevation, and slope. The weights for the different thematic layers were calculated using a multi-criteria decision-making (MCDM) technique, i.e., the analytical hierarchy process (AHP), that permits pairwise evaluation of criteria influencing the prospective zone. The groundwater potential (GWP) map has also been reclassified into five distinct classes, i.e., excellent, very good, good, moderate, and poor. According to the findings, the excellent potential zone accounts for 1.15% of the total area, with the remaining areas classified as very good (23.21%), good (45.76%), moderate (21.54%), and low (8.35%). A total of 53 well sites are available for the validation of the GWPZ map in the research region. According to our findings, 38 existing wells are in the good and very good potential zones. This suggests that the study's groundwater potential zone map is quite consistent and dependable when it comes to estimating groundwater potential. On the basis of the groundwater potential zone map, a spatial rearrangement of cropping patterns might be recommended. This study is even more essential in an era of drinking water shortages, as the GWPZ map would have been beneficial in water resource planning and management. Future management plans, including natural and artificial recharge practices, may be established successfully in these locations since the approach used yielded reliable analysis.

    How to cite: Patidar, N., Mohseni, U., Pathan, A., Raaj, S., Agnihotri, Dr. P. G., Jariwala, K., Chandarana, N., Patel, Dr. D., Prieto, Dr. C., and Đurin, Dr. B.: GIS-Based Mapping of Groundwater Potential Zones Using AHP for Ujjain District, Madhya Pradesh, India, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3814, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3814, 2022.

    EGU22-4516 | Presentations | HS8.2.1

    Assessment of the influence of surface water on groundwater quality related to the Wadi El-Bey watershed (Tunisia) using field sampling and quantitative groundwater modelling 

    Hatem Baccouche, Manon Lincker, Hanene Akrout, Thouraya Mellah, Makram Anane, Ahmed Ghrabi, George P. Karatzas, and Gerhard Schäfer

    The PRIMA Sustain-COAST European project aims at exploring innovative governance for sustainable coastal groundwater management and pollution reduction in the context of a changing climate by involving researchers, local citizens, water stakeholders, and policy makers in interactive dialogue. Four study sites have been selected, among them the Wadi El-Bey watershed in Tunisia, located about 40 km south of Tunis. The study area is the Grombalia aquifer whose size is approximately 391 km². It is boarded to the north by the Gulf of Tunis and the Tekelsa Hills, to the east by the Abderrahman Mountain and the oriental coastal highlands, to the south by the Hammamet Hills, and to the west by the Bou Choucha and the Halloufa mountains. The Grombalia aquifer is bounded northward by the Mediterranean Sea and westward by the Gulf of Tunis. It constitutes a complex aquifer system formed by shallow unconfined, semi deep, and deep aquifers with different exploitation levels. The interest of the study relies on the upper aquifer. Surface flow occurs mainly in 5 wadis toward the north, reflecting regional topographic gradients.

    During the last few decades, the Grombalia shallow unconfined aquifer had been under stress by groundwater pumping due to the increasing population and development of agricultural and industrial activities. Recently, it has been noticed in some wells a rise in the level of the water table due to the abandonment of the exploitation of surface wells and to the irrigation by the water transferred from the north of the country, and considerable deterioration of groundwater quality due to saltwater intrusion and increased nitrate contamination as well as the organic matter in terms of COD.

    A groundwater numerical model for the Grombalia aquifer has been developed using Feflow 7.4 to simulate groundwater level changes under steady state and transient conditions. The steady state flow calibration was carried out using the water levels measured 1972 in 35 observation wells and then used as initial state of the Grombalia aquifer system. To show the influence of groundwater management, especially for agricultural activities, and interaction with surface water, measurements of water level, water temperature, pH, electric conductivity and water quality data (e.g., nitrate concentration) have been conducted during the 2020 field campaign, at selected monitoring wells and in neighbouring transects of surface water.

    The groundwater model constitutes a solid basis for further studies under transient flow and transport conditions to compare different water management, climate change and contamination scenarios, and is part of the calibrated multi-criteria decision supporting system developed in the PRIMA Sustain-COAST project context.

    References

    The project is funded by the General Secretariat for Research and Technology of the Ministry of Development and Investments under the PRIMA Programme. PRIMA is an Art.185 initiative supported and co-funded under Horizon 2020, the European Union’s Programme for Research and Innovation.

     

    How to cite: Baccouche, H., Lincker, M., Akrout, H., Mellah, T., Anane, M., Ghrabi, A., Karatzas, G. P., and Schäfer, G.: Assessment of the influence of surface water on groundwater quality related to the Wadi El-Bey watershed (Tunisia) using field sampling and quantitative groundwater modelling, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4516, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4516, 2022.

    Uneven water resources distribution and saline groundwater have become urgent concerns in inland arid areas because they pose difficulties for managing water resources. Policies and decisions depend on understanding the recharge sources, flow patterns, and hydrogeochemical evolution of groundwater systems. A comprehensive approach of hydrogeochemistry and environmental isotopes (δD, δ18O, 3H, 14C) was used to assess the groundwater recharge sources and hydrogeochemical evolution, and the Aksu River Basin was taken as the study area, which is located in the northwestern Tarim Basin, NW China. Results indicate that groundwater was originated from precipitation and meltwater in mountainous areas of Tianshan Mountain. Modern groundwater was found in the mountain front area and shallow groundwater locality near the surface area, while the deep confined groundwater was recharged by the paleo precipitation during the last glacial period. In the lowest discharge area, groundwater was recharged by the lateral flow from both the south desert and north Mountain areas. Along the flow path, groundwater evolves from freshwater to brine water and saline water, with a shift in hydrochemistry type from Na·Ca·Mg-HCO3·SO4 and Na·Ca·Mg-HCO3·SO4·Cl to Na-Cl. Mineral dissolution dominates the groundwater chemistry in the alluvial fan. The groundwater in the flow-through area is dominated by mineral (halite, gypsum) dissolution and cation exchange due to the longer residence times, leading to an increase in solute inputs along the flow paths and thus the evolving trend from freshwater to brackish water and finally saline water. On the contrary, infiltration of surface water decreases the salinity of groundwater partly. In the discharge area, the mineral dissolution and reverse cation exchange are the primary geochemical process controlling groundwater chemistry. This study could provide essential information for groundwater resource management.

    How to cite: Lei, Y., Sun, Z., and Zou, C.: Recharge sources, flow regime, and hydrogeochemical evolution of saline groundwater in an arid inland basin, northwestern China, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4728, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4728, 2022.

    EGU22-4772 | Presentations | HS8.2.1

    Evaluation of possible asbestos fibres movement in porous aquifers through laboratory column tests 

    Manuela Lasagna, Chiara Avataneo, Leonardo Magherini, Elena Belluso, Silvana Capella, Rajandrea Sethi, and Domenico Antonio De Luca

    Weathering and erosion of rocks and sediments containing Naturally Occurring Asbestos (NOA), together with run off from mine tailings deposits containing non-exploitable fibrous minerals, may result in asbestos (and other asbestiform minerals non-asbestos classified) fibres dispersion in surface waters and groundwater.

    Asbestos is considered highly carcinogenic to humans when is respired (Group 1 by IARC). Therefore, in the past, asbestos occurrence has been mainly monitored in air and not considered in other matrices, such as water. Nowadays, waterborne asbestos is gaining new attention since it can constitute a non-conventional exposure way. Indeed, as groundwater and surface waters resources are exploited for both agricultural and industrial activities and as a source for tap water, water contamination by asbestos could pose a risk related to possible water-to-air migration of fibres, thus being a secondary source of airborne asbestos, and to possible ingestion (particularly when present in the tap water). Therefore, asbestos could be considered as an Emerging Pollutant in water because, historically, it has not been systematically monitored in this matrix and it could actually represent a problem for human health and environment.

    NOA-containing rocks are widespread in Italy, such as in northwest (NW) and Central Alps and also in the Apennines. In NW area, possible diffusion of asbestos in water has been recently considered as a consequence of interactions between water and ophiolitic rocks or related sediments. Migration through water (particularly groundwater) far away from the pollution source, which has been considered negligible until recently, has gained new attention since column-based laboratory study has highlighted asbestos mobility through porous media under particular conditions, suggesting that the same could happen in the environment.

    Knowing this background, it is particularly important to investigate possible fibres diffusion in porous aquifers and their transport linked to aquifer characteristics, dimension and morphology of fibres, their chemical composition and surface charge.

    To better understand groundwater flow and fibres transport, a laboratory test has been set in collaboration with Politecnico di Torino using a packed column in which polluted water movement was forced. Several tests have been done using different material to pack the column with various granulometry and changing water characteristics, such as asbestos fibres concentration and ionic strength.

    Details regarding the experimental setup and first data on the tests will be presented to better define possible groundwater contamination by asbestos fibres and their movement through porous aquifers. These data will help to understand how reservoir peculiarities (geology, hydrogeology) and anthropogenic activities could influence mineral fibres presence and movement in the water system and, more generally, would help to monitor asbestos (and asbestiform) fibres transport due to water flowing in NOA rich settings or in areas where uncontrolled mine tailings deposits are present.

    How to cite: Lasagna, M., Avataneo, C., Magherini, L., Belluso, E., Capella, S., Sethi, R., and De Luca, D. A.: Evaluation of possible asbestos fibres movement in porous aquifers through laboratory column tests, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4772, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4772, 2022.

    EGU22-5008 | Presentations | HS8.2.1

    What we can learn about transboundary aquifers from geochemical signatures of springs 

    Oliver Koit, Inga Retike, Jaanus Terasmaa, Jānis Bikše, Elve Lode, Marko Vainu, Konrāds Popovs, Alise Babre, Pamela Abreldaal, Karin Sisask, Siim Tarros, Andres Marandi, Marlen Hunt, Magdaleena Männik, and Maile Polikarpus

    As groundwater does not follow human-drawn boundaries such as country borders, groundwater pollution in one country can adversely affect groundwater quality and availability in a neighboring country. It is vital to develop a conceptual understanding of shared groundwater resources not only to ensure their protection, but also to avoid future conflicts, especially in a changing climate. Both the Water Convention and EU Water Framework Directive emphasize the need for joint assessment and management of transboundary groundwater resources (commonly referred to as “transboundary aquifers” or “groundwater bodies''), and it is crucial to establish a representative transboundary groundwater monitoring network to gather the necessary data. Often, the coverage of monitoring points in the existing groundwater monitoring networks is scarce in the peripheral areas and the installation of new wells would be economically unreasonable. Springs are natural groundwater outflows that can fill gaps in monitoring networks. Monitoring springs can be cost-effective, make water sampling easier, moreover, their water can provide information on a significantly larger catchment area than monitoring wells. The spring site cannot be selected like monitoring wells, so selecting the best springs requires a thorough preliminary assessment. A good conceptual understanding of the recharge area is a prerequisite for the selection of suitable monitoring springs. In this study, 46 springs in the transboundary area of Estonia and Latvia (NE Europe) were screened in 2021-2022 for a variety of geochemical parameters (field parameters, major ions, biogenic and trace elements, water stable isotopes). Some springs were sampled more than once to assess seasonal variability. Then springs were clustered based on their geochemical characteristics using multivariate statistics. This study is the first step in the procedure established on how to select representative springs for transboundary aquifer monitoring.

    This study is financed by the Interreg Estonia-Latvia cooperation program project “WaterAct”, the EEA and Norway Grants Fund for Regional Cooperation project “EU-WATERRES”, and by performance-based funding of University of Latvia Nr.AAP2016/B041 within the “Climate change and sustainable use of natural resources” program.

    How to cite: Koit, O., Retike, I., Terasmaa, J., Bikše, J., Lode, E., Vainu, M., Popovs, K., Babre, A., Abreldaal, P., Sisask, K., Tarros, S., Marandi, A., Hunt, M., Männik, M., and Polikarpus, M.: What we can learn about transboundary aquifers from geochemical signatures of springs, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5008, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5008, 2022.

    EGU22-5703 | Presentations | HS8.2.1

    Hydrogeological, hydrochemical and isotopic study of the Chibunga river basin (Ecuador) 

    Luis Miguel Santillan Quiroga, Chiara Marchina, Manuela Lasagna, Domenico Deluca, and Enrico Destefanis

    This study provides a description of the hydrogeologic, hydrogeochemical and isotopic setting of the Chibunga river basin in the Province of Chimborazo (Ecuador). The basin has an area of approximately 514 km2 and 44 km in length. Its main river, the Chibunga River, originates on the slopes of the Chimborazo Volcano. The study area is located at an altitude comprised between 6268 aslm of Chimborazo volcano and 2598 aslm. This area has suffered for years of social conflicts for the access to water, due to an inadequate water resources management system.  Moreover, there is a deficiency of information about the water quality and groundwater recharge. The aims of this study was to investigate hydrogeochemical features of the Chibunga water resources and to improve information about hydrogeological structure, groundwater recharge processes and water quality.

    From a hydrogeological point of view, a multilayer aquifer system is present, consisting in volcanoclastic deposits, and alternating pyroclastic and lava layers. An unconfined shallow aquifer is located in the most superficial part, feeding the plain springs. More in depth, confined and semiconfined aquifers are hosted in the more permeable layers, and are used for drinking water purposes. The plain is bordered by volcanic formations, mainly of andesitic rocks, characterized by a low permeability by fracturing. According to the literature, the aquifer system is mainly recharged by melting glaciers from the Chimborazo volcano. However, glaciers have been affected by a generalize retreat in the last decades that influences the water availability.

    In this view, sampling campaigns were carried out to improve the hydrogeochemical characterization of precipitation, surface water and groundwater of the area.

    The analyses of major elements highlight that, although Ca-HCO3 hydrochemical facies is the most common, a wide variability can be found in the groundwater of the area. On the whole, excluding the wells nearby urban settlements, chemical analyses show good quality of the water for drinking, irrigation, and agricultural use. Isotopic results, represented in δ18O – δ2H plot, are close to the Global Meteoric Water Line with a d-excess on average 16.3. Water stable isotopes reveal the contribution of precipitation to springs (δ18O ranging between -15.9 and -14.5; and; δ2H ranging between -110.5 and -99.2) at different altitude, while, near-stream groundwater has a similar isotopic signature to that of the river water (δ18O ranging between -14.4 and -13.7; and; δ2H ranging between -96.5 and -92.7) and reveal the interaction between surface and groundwater system.

    How to cite: Santillan Quiroga, L. M., Marchina, C., Lasagna, M., Deluca, D., and Destefanis, E.: Hydrogeological, hydrochemical and isotopic study of the Chibunga river basin (Ecuador), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5703, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5703, 2022.

    One of the major concerns for agriculturally driven countries like India is said to be the depletion of groundwater. Therefore, understanding the dynamics of groundwater system is prerequisite for assuring its sustainability. According to the GRACE (Gravity Recovery and Climate Experiment) satellite data, the declining TWS (terrestrial water storage) trends are apparent in north and south of India during 2003-2016, while the Narmada river basin, which is situated in the central west of the country, shows apparent increase of TWS. To unravel the possible reasons for this increasing trend, the part of the Narmada river basin was studied. Between 2003 and 2016, two dams (Indira Sagar dam (2005) and Omkareshwar dam (2008)) were constructed in the basin, and the canal systems to supply water for agricultural activities were developed. The canal system was considered to influence water resources availability in the area, and hence, groundwater fluctuations and groundwater storage. To understand the impact of the canal system on groundwater behavior, the well water levels were analyzed based on two timelines, i.e., before (1996-2010) and after the canal operation (2011-2017) in the Omkareshwar canal command area. The wells were classified into three groups, i.e., those located nearby the canal network, nearby the river network, and outside the canal command area. Pre-monsoon (dry) and monsoon (wet) seasons were chosen for the analysis. The results indicated that, after the canal operation, only the wells located nearby the canal showed the average well water level increase with about 2.56 m in pre-monsoon and 1.97 m in monsoon season, respectively. Whereas, the wells located nearby the river network showed very small changes, i.e., about 0.53 m drop in pre-monsoon and 0.84 m drop in monsoon season, respectively. Similarly, the wells outside the canal command area showed only 0.18 m drop in pre-monsoon and about 0.42 m increase in monsoon season. In summary, the groundwater well levels were observed to increase in wells located near canal system, after the canal operation, in both pre-monsoon and monsoon seasons with a considerable water depth of approximately 2 m. These distinct differences observed in the well water level changes indicated that the Omkareshwar canal system has been influential to the groundwater storage in the study area, and this may at least partly explain the reason why the terrestrial water storage has increased in this area.

    How to cite: Shiradhonkar, S. and Tokunaga, T.: Changes in groundwater levels by introducing the canal system in the basaltic aquifer of Narmada basin, Central India, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6112, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6112, 2022.

    EGU22-6511 | Presentations | HS8.2.1

    Assessment of spatiotemporal variations of groundwater recharge in the Upper Lerma River basin using a process-based hydrological model 

    Febe Ortiz, Zhechen Zhang, Shreedhar Maskey, Yangxiao Zhou, and Michael McClain

    Water resources are under high stress worldwide due to multiple factors. There is a general need to develop better and more efficient management practices. Understanding groundwater and surface water as one source is crucial for this determination. A clear comprehension of groundwater and surface water interactions as an integrated system requires a good knowledge of topography, geology, and climate. This research analyzes the spatiotemporal variation and availability of surface water resources and groundwater recharge in a highland basin using a comprehensive hydrological model. The hydrological model is based on the Soil and Water Assessment Tool (SWAT), allowing spatially distributed assessment using sub-basin and hydrological response units. The case study is the Upper Lerma River basin located in the central part of Mexico. Its location and topography (highland) have made its aquifer the second most source to satisfy the water demand of Mexico City since 1940. As a result, groundwater levels have declined, and springs in the surrounding mountainous regions have progressively disappeared over time. Although few studies attempted to estimate recharge and variability, a lot is unknown to analyze the declining water resources in the basin. This research contributes to understanding the basin water resources using the modeling approach, which integrates topography, land use, soil, and climate data to calculate different water cycle components in space and time. The analysis period is 1985-2017. Statistics of model calibration show a good correlation between the computed and measured discharges from 1995 to 2003 with a Nash-Sutcliffe Efficiency (NSE) value of 0.77, an R2 value of 0.79, and a PBIAS of -1%. The preliminary results show that the foothills and alluvial fans are the most extensive recharge areas, which agree with the piezometric data. Detailed analysis on recharge and surface runoff is ongoing.

    How to cite: Ortiz, F., Zhang, Z., Maskey, S., Zhou, Y., and McClain, M.: Assessment of spatiotemporal variations of groundwater recharge in the Upper Lerma River basin using a process-based hydrological model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6511, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6511, 2022.

    EGU22-7242 | Presentations | HS8.2.1

    The impact of climate change on groundwater temperature of the Piedmont Po plain (NW Italy) 

    Elena Egidio, Manuela Lasagna, Susanna Mancini, and Domenico Antonio De Luca

    It’s now recognized that a global climate change is taking place, leading to an increase in temperatures and a variation in precipitation regime, also affecting groundwater (GW) (Taylor et al., 2013).

    In this study we want to evaluate how climate variability affects GW temperature (GWT) in the Piedmont Po plain (NW Italy).

    The Piedmont Po plain covers the 27% of the whole region and it’s the most important GW reservoir of Piedmont. It consists, from top to bottom, by Alluvial deposit complex (lower Pleistocene-Holocene), that hosts a shallow unconfined aquifer, the “Villafranchiano” transitional complex (late Pliocene-early Pleistocene), that hosts a multilayered aquifer, and a Marine complex (Pliocene) hosting a confined aquifer.

    For this research, 41 wells in the shallow aquifer and 20 weather stations were selected throughout the Piedmont Po plain area, and GW and air temperature parameters were analysed for the period 2010-2019.

    Both GW and air temperature data (respectively, GWT and AT) were firstly studied with basic statistical analysis (mean, maxima, minima) and then with the Mann-Kendall and Theil-Sen methods to evaluate the trend.
    The AT monthly mean data have a mean increase of 1,69 °C/10years; the monthly mean GWT also show a general increase in all the plain, with a mean of 0.85 °C/10years.

    Then to compare water and air temperature, the Voronoi polygons method was used on QGis by centring the polygons on the weather stations. From this comparison, it was possible to highlight that in most cases (37 on 41, thus 90% of the analysed couples of temperature data) there is a greater increase in the monthly mean AT than in the monthly mean GWT.

    The same behaviour was observed for the monthly minima and maxima GW and AT.

    These results testify a greater resilience of GWT to climate variability. Future insights will be a detailed analysis of the factors influencing the more or less evident increase in GWT in relation to AT (e.g. depth of the water table, position of the monitoring well, position of the probe inside the well).

     

    References

    Taylor R.G., Scanlon B., Döll P., Rodell M., van Beek R., Wada Y., Longuevergne L.,

    Leblanc M., Famiglietti J.S., Edmunds M., Konikow L., Green T.R., Chen J.,

    Taniguchi M., Bierkens M.F.P., MacDonald A., Fan Y., Maxwell R.M., Yechieli

    Y., Gurdak J.J., Allen D., Shamsudduha M., Hiscock K., Yeh P.J.F., Holman I.,

    Treidel H. 2013. Ground water and climate change. Nat. Clim. Change 3, 322-329.

     

    How to cite: Egidio, E., Lasagna, M., Mancini, S., and De Luca, D. A.: The impact of climate change on groundwater temperature of the Piedmont Po plain (NW Italy), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7242, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7242, 2022.

    EGU22-7841 | Presentations | HS8.2.1

    Clustering of groundwater hydrographs to reveal common patterns for the Baltic region 

    Inga Retike, Jānis Bikše, Andis Kalvāns, Konrāds Popovs, and Ezra Haaf

    The aim of this study is to identify salient patterns of groundwater level dynamics in the Baltic region. The study investigates correspondence between (grouped) groundwater level dynamics and catchment, well and physiographic site characteristics. The analysis was carried out in five consecutive steps. Firstly, 1691 groundwater hydrographs were collected from Baltic surveys responsible for national groundwater level monitoring (Latvain Environment, Geology and Meteorology Centre; Estonian Environment Agency; Geological Survey of Lithuania). Observation wells represent both unconfined and confined aquifers. Groundwater level time series were checked for errors and treated according to an approach proposed by Retike et al., 2021. Secondly, the dataset was limited to the time period when daily groundwater level measurements were available in all three countries. The resulting time period covers 8.5 years at 689 wells. Then, the acceptable amount of missing values was defined as the balance between most complete hydrographs, the number of retrained hydrographs and spatial coverage of the wells. Gaps (if present) in the remaining 283 wells were filled with missForest (Stekhoven and Bühlmann, 2012). The results were visually inspected to identify groundwater hydrographs with suspicious modeling patterns and five wells were removed from further analysis based on expert judgment. Finally, 278 groundwater hydrographs (136 from Latvia, 58 from Lithuania and 86 from Estonia) were retained and clustered using Hierarchical Cluster Analysis. The identified clusters of groundwater level times series were then explained using descriptive geological (like aquifer lithology, thickness), hydrological (distance to the nearest stream), climatic (precipitation, seasonality) and anthropogenic (land use) characteristics. This research is funded by the Latvian Council of Science, project “Spatial and temporal prediction of groundwater drought with mixed models for multilayer sedimentary basin under climate change”, project No. lzp-2019/1-0165.

    References:

    Retike, I., Bikše, J., Kalvāns, A., Dēliņa, A, Avotniece, Z., Zaadnoordijk, W.J., Jemeljanova, M., Popovs, K., Babre, A., Zelenkevičs, A., Baikovs, A. (2022) Rescue of groundwater level time series: How to visually identify and treat errors. Journal of Hydrology, 605, 127294. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhydrol.2021.127294

    Stekhoven, D.J., Bühlmann, P. (2012) Missforest-Non-parametric missing value imputation for mixed-type data. Bioinformatics, 28, 112–118. https://doi.org/10.1093/bioinformatics/btr597

    How to cite: Retike, I., Bikše, J., Kalvāns, A., Popovs, K., and Haaf, E.: Clustering of groundwater hydrographs to reveal common patterns for the Baltic region, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7841, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7841, 2022.

    EGU22-9091 | Presentations | HS8.2.1

    Assessing uncertainty in groundwater flow directions by an iterative Ensemble Smoother technique 

    Giovanni Formentin, Miguel Angel Marazuela, Klaus Erlmeier, Nathalie Tepe, and Thilo Hofmann

    A sub-alpine catchment hosts a drinking water plant that collects groundwater through a series of drains. The catchment is crossed by a river that recharges the aquifer with potentially polluted water. The waterworks managers need a management strategy to maximize groundwater collection and minimize the probability to extract river water. This request was addressed by means of a groundwater model that simulates the mixing of river water and groundwater under a stochastic framework.

    Samples of river water show the presence of Gadolinium, a rare earth element used as a contrast agent (GBCA) for magnetic resonance imaging. This element is also recurrently found in samples taken from some monitoring wells, and previous studies have determined its suitability as a tracer of solute dispersion. We used it as an indicator of partitioning between river water and original groundwater.

    We built a simple, fast-running numerical groundwater model with the FEM code Feflow (DHI). We coupled it with PESTPP-IES, an optimization tool that implements the ensemble-smoother form of the Gauss-Levenberg-Marquardt algorithm. Through it, an ensemble of "realistic" parameter fields was generated, all of which support a good fit between model outputs and the calibration dataset. The latter included mixing ratios (calculated by measured Gadolinium concentrations) and groundwater levels. To simulate Gadolinium spread in groundwater, we used particle tracking instead of building an advective-dispersive transport model, because the latter is costlier to build and slower to run, therefore it does not allow the high number of runs required by PESTPP-IES. Although dispersion is not explicitly represented, its role is surrogated by uncertainty in hydraulic conductivity.

    With this study, we built the engine of a decision support system that will optimize waterworks management. We also demonstrated that a lean, purpose-driven model is adequate in simulating solute transport in complex hydrogeological systems. Gadolinium concentrations were instrumental in identifying the partitioning between river water and groundwater.

    How to cite: Formentin, G., Marazuela, M. A., Erlmeier, K., Tepe, N., and Hofmann, T.: Assessing uncertainty in groundwater flow directions by an iterative Ensemble Smoother technique, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9091, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9091, 2022.

    EGU22-9217 | Presentations | HS8.2.1

    Hydrochemical and isotopic study of Maggiore Valley deep aquifers (NW Italy): evaluation of the interactions with the Po River 

    Daniele Cocca, Marta Moriondo, Manuela Lasagna, and Domenico Antonio De Luca

    The Maggiore Valley well field plays a fundamental role in supplying drinking water to a large territory of the Piedmont Region (north-western Italy) and has been intensively exploited since the early XX century. Due to the lack of other relevant sources of drinking water in this part of Piedmont region, this well field represents a drinking water reserve of regional importance.

    This water resource  is host in a deep multi-layered aquifer system. The recharge area of the deep exploited aquifer is located towards the Po Plain, west (Turin Plain) and south (Cuneo Plain) of the study area. Most likely, the deep aquifer is recharged from west by Po river, that in this area is a losing river, due to the highly permeable Quaternary gravelly sand deposits in correspondence with the river.

    The main purpose of this study was to confirm the interaction between deep aquifer and the Po River through a hydrochemical and isotopic assessment, and to characterize the different water resource quality in this areas (Po Plain, Poirino plateau, Maggiore Valley area).  

    Two sampling campaigns were carried out both in the shallow and deep aquifers (March and June 2021) for a total of 128 samples. Physical-chemical analyzes of the main ions on all samples and isotopic analyzes (δ18O, δ2H) on 50 samples were conducted.

    The processing of chemical data has confirmed the bicarbonate-calcium facies for the majority of the shallow and deep aquifers samples. Moreover, clear hydrochemical differences were observed between the investigated sectors; e.g. the shallow aquifer of the Poirino Plateau shows nitrate concentrations superior than the limits, unlike the deep aquifer of Maggiore Valley is characterized by low concentration of nitrate and other ions.  

    The processing of isotopic data, combined with previous data, made it possible to identify a gradual increase in values of the isotopic composition along the flow direction into the Cuneo deep aquifer due to the progressive interaction with the shallow aquifer; moreover, isotopic data confirmed the interaction between the Po River (more negative values) and the shallow aquifer (more positive values) along the watercourse in the Turin Po Plain, resulting with a more negative isotopic composition in the shallow aquifer compared to nearby areas.

    In the Maggiore Valley, the isotopic signals of the deep aquifer, flowing from the Turin plain and interpreted as potentially influenced by the Po River showed an isotopic composition highly similar to the watercourse, with to the least enriched waters of the area.

    The isotopic signals of the deep aquifers in the Maggiore Valley flowing from the Cuneo plain (more positive) and Turin plain (more negative) were distinguished and the mixing between these converging aquifers in the well field area was verified.

    In conclusion, the stable isotopes suggest an interaction between the Po River and the deep aquifer of the Maggiore Valley wells.

    The study provides an additional tool for a better groundwater management and protection of a regional importance drinking water reserve.

    How to cite: Cocca, D., Moriondo, M., Lasagna, M., and De Luca, D. A.: Hydrochemical and isotopic study of Maggiore Valley deep aquifers (NW Italy): evaluation of the interactions with the Po River, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9217, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9217, 2022.

    EGU22-9607 | Presentations | HS8.2.1

    Groundwater quality determination using stable isotopes 

    Vesna Zupanc, Anja Koroša, Sonja Cerar, Janko Urbanc, Joseph Adu-Gyamfi, Janine Halder, and Marina Pintar

    Alluvial plains are an important agricultural area because of favourable soil properties, topography, and proximity to surface and groundwater resources. The predominant land use in the alluvial plains is agriculture, but there are also many urban and industrial areas. Groundwater bodies beneath the alluvial plains are threatened by nitrate pollution from agricultural activities and urban sources such as faulty sewage systems. For the Krško-Brežiško polje case study, an assessment of nitrate sources in groundwater was conducted using stable isotopes (δ15N) to produce maps of groundwater vulnerability. In addition, stable isotope composition of groundwater (δ18O and δ2H) was used to obtain information on the characteristics of the recharge area. Nuclear techniques (i.e., stable isotopes) are excellent for determining pathways and travel times of contaminants through the vadose zone in soil-groundwater systems, especially in areas with shallow aquifers. Results show contamination from manure application and the potential to reduce pressures on groundwater for specific sampling points.

    This research was financed by the ARRS L4-8221 URAVIVO and IAEA TCP SLO5004 Improving Water Quality in Vulnerable and Shallow Aquifers under Two Intensive Fruit and Vegetable Production Zones.  

    How to cite: Zupanc, V., Koroša, A., Cerar, S., Urbanc, J., Adu-Gyamfi, J., Halder, J., and Pintar, M.: Groundwater quality determination using stable isotopes, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9607, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9607, 2022.

    EGU22-9835 | Presentations | HS8.2.1

    Cutting-edge tools for spring monitoring and groundwater system characterization in mountain environments 

    Michele Mondani, Martina Gizzi, Glenda Taddia, and Stefano Lo Russo

    Mountain aquifers represent one of the largest and most valuable water sources, necessary to meet the population's water needs. Over time, they have been threatened by huge anthropogenic exploitation activities, which are currently leading to the depletion of aquifers in many regions worldwide. Furthermore, the vulnerability of groundwater resources is rapidly increasing due to climate change, urbanization, massive industry production, intensive agriculture, and breeding.

    Knowledge and forecasting about groundwater flow systems are required to guarantee proper management and territorial planning strategies, according to the mountain environmental evolution taking place. Besides, examining how groundwater storage mechanisms in different regions have changed in response to both climate-driven and anthropogenic effects is becoming increasingly crucial.

    In remote alpine areas, continuous monitoring and data collection of springs’ hydrogeological parameters is still often hampered by technical and logistical problems. In these contexts, new automated techniques and tools need to be applied to monitor springs’ hydrogeological parameters, punctually understanding the dynamics of exhausting of the available groundwater resources.

    The instrumentation and sensors complex, installed in correspondence with the Mascognaz spring basin (Aosta Valley, Italy) allows detailed analyses of the surface and underground groundwater system, recording continuously hydrogeological variables entering and leaving the spring recharge system. A cutting-edge weather station was here combined with a spring monitoring system through snowpack-hydrometeorological sensors installation. This setup, composed of a snow scale, ultrasonic and laser sensors for snow weight and snow depth reading, provides the possibility of a detailed study of the snow layer evolution during each season. Besides, a multiparametric probe allows water discharge, temperature and electric conductivity values detection.

    The high quality of the data provided and the small-size basin features have permitted highlighting the variables affecting the system and standing out those are evolving in time. Besides, the relationship between changes in weather conditions and water availability can be defined by performing correlations between different hydrogeological and meteorological available data series.

    The Mascognaz spring’s pilot site could be helpful as an example for other researchers and authorities who need to identify suitable instruments, sensors and methods to reconstruct the groundwater flow system and hydrogeological structure of a mountain basin.

    How to cite: Mondani, M., Gizzi, M., Taddia, G., and Lo Russo, S.: Cutting-edge tools for spring monitoring and groundwater system characterization in mountain environments, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9835, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9835, 2022.

    EGU22-10323 | Presentations | HS8.2.1

    Investigation of the contribution of groundwater to the water budget of a shallow soda lake in Hungary by using stable and radioactive isotopes as natural tracers 

    Petra Baják, Katalin Hegedűs-Csondor, Mia Tiljander, Kirsti Korkka-Niemi, Bálint Izsák, Márta Vargha, Tamás Pándics, Ákos Horváth, and Anita Erőss

    Lake Velence is a shallow soda lake in Hungary that is located in a tectonic subsidence in the southern foreland of the Velence Hills. Since the lake is semi-astatic (the volume and level of water in the lake fluctuates frequently), climate has a serious effect on its water budget. Until recently, the groundwater inflow into the lake has been neglected and only the recharge from surface water and rainwater have been taken into account. Because increasing climate change threatens the existence of the lake and its unique ecosystem, it is important to properly assess the components of the lake's water budget.

    To understand the role of groundwater for the lake-water quantity and quality, the groundwater flow patterns were mapped constructing pressure-elevation profiles and tomographic potential maps. During our research, 15 water samples were collected from groundwater wells, springs and from the  Lake Velence. Physico-chemical properties of the water (e.g. temperature, pH, redox potential, specific electrical conductivity) were recorded during sampling on the field. The samples were analyzed for major ions (Ca, Mg, Na, K, HCO3, SO4, Cl). To verify the results of the groundwater flow mapping, stable isotopes (O, H) and radioactive isotopes (Ra, Rn, U) were applied as natural tracers. δD and δ18O were measured by using PICARRO L2130-i δD/δ18O Ultra High-Precision Isotopic Water Analyzer. 222Rn activity concentration was determined by using TRICARB 1000 TR liquid scintillation detector. The 234U+238U and 226Ra activities were measured by a unique method, alpha spectrometry using Nucfilm discs.

    The p(z) profiles indicated that recharge areas are dominant south from the lake, while groundwater discharges along the lake’s shoreline.  According to the tomographic potential maps, the regional groundwater flow travels from the Velence Hills toward the regional base level (River Danube). The water chemistry analysis indicated that the majority of the water samples can be classified as Ca-Na-HCO3 and Ca-Na-HCO3-Cl-SO4 type waters. δD measures were between -98.4 and -13.4‰; while δ18O values were between -13.4 and 0.15‰. Most of the samples are characterized by relatively high 234U+238U activity concentration (up to 497 mBq L–1). Based on δD and δ18O values, groups of groundwater having different recharge environment, can be distinguished. This is in line with the results of the groundwater mapping: a deep regional flow system with longer residence time and more shallow local flow systems with shorter residence time can be identified. The dominance of recharge areas and the presence of local flow systems can be further supported by the 234U+238U measurements, because uranium can be mobilized by the groundwater primarily under oxiziding conditions. It was revealed that groundwater contribute to the lake's water budget and the lake is fed by local groundwater flow systems known to be more sensible for the climate changes.

    This topic is part of a project that has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 810980.

    How to cite: Baják, P., Hegedűs-Csondor, K., Tiljander, M., Korkka-Niemi, K., Izsák, B., Vargha, M., Pándics, T., Horváth, Á., and Erőss, A.: Investigation of the contribution of groundwater to the water budget of a shallow soda lake in Hungary by using stable and radioactive isotopes as natural tracers, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10323, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10323, 2022.

    EGU22-10479 | Presentations | HS8.2.1

    Artificial recharge effects in water balance of a peri-urban semi-arid catchment: a case study in an Andean aquifer using WEAP-MODFLOW 

    Pedro Sanzana, Melissa Vargas, Mauricio Muñoz, Cristobal Soto, Jorge Gironas, and Isabelle Braud

    Artificial recharge in urban and peri-urbans areas is not a typical practice, but the prolonged severe drought in central Chile has encouraged the study of this practice as an option for optimal and sustainable water management. The Andean piedmont of Santiago (Chile) has been urbanized that implies high water consumptions and increasing irrigation, which in turn acts as a new groundwater recharge. We simulated the period 1989-2015 using an integrated surface and subsurface model (WEAP-MODFLOW) to evaluate the impact of urbanization in groundwater recharge in a representative catchment in the area. An artificial recharge injection of 100 l/s (60,480 m3/day) was introduced in the model for a period of 26 weeks in a specific year (2009, between week 27 to 52, included). The recharge wells were implemented in key zones of the upper aquifer and monitoring wells were also implemented in different zones. The artificial recharge reproduced the hydraulic dome created by the infiltration flow, locally reaching a height of 6 m and beginning to dissipate approximately at 2.5 km (≤ 0.5 m) from the injection point. Moreover, we created a zone budget control section (2 km downstream) and we observed impacts on the water level in this sector, with a 1-year lag  year after starting artificial recharge. The maximum impact was observed after approximately 1.5 years. Not only the study watershed has a high natural storage capacity, which benefits natural water retention, but its average residence time (4 years) is quite. Thus, our results could encourage different public or private stakeholders in the watershed to implement low impact development practices that could infiltrate water to cope with water shortage periods.

    How to cite: Sanzana, P., Vargas, M., Muñoz, M., Soto, C., Gironas, J., and Braud, I.: Artificial recharge effects in water balance of a peri-urban semi-arid catchment: a case study in an Andean aquifer using WEAP-MODFLOW, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10479, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10479, 2022.

    EGU22-12719 | Presentations | HS8.2.1 | Highlight

    Permafrost and groundwater interaction 

    Magdalena Diak, Marta Borecka, Michael E. Böttcher, Wei-Li Hong, Jochen Knies, Lech Kotwicki, Karol Kuliński, Aivo Lepland, Katarzyna Koziorowska-Makuch, Arunima Sen, Catia M.E. von Ahn, Aleksandra Winogradow, and Beata Szymczycha

    Permafrost is defined as perennially frozen ground (soil or rock and included ice and organic material) with a temperature near or below 0°C that remains for at least two consecutive years. Permafrost occurs mainly in high latitudes of the Southern and Northern Hemispheres, but significant area can also be found in the middle- and low-latitude regions. In these areas, the groundwater cycle is mainly controlled by the permafrost layer that may act as an aquiclude and hence block or retard the groundwater flow. However, rapid climate changes which are observed during the last decades, markedly contribute to permafrost degradation. New connections between permafrost and groundwater are expected to form during the permafrost thawing process. This will contribute to enhance permafrost and groundwater interaction and reinforce groundwater discharge. In general, groundwater discharge is a groundwater movement from the saturated ground to the surface water bodies or submarine groundwater inflow into the sea. Increased groundwater discharge may transport a significant amount of nutrients, metals, and gases to land and ocean waters and hence may change their physicochemical parameters. Unfortunately, due to the limited number of studies, understanding the significance of groundwater discharge in the Arctic regions is limited.

    The study aims to provide a comprehensive review of the present literature data that contribute to better understanding interaction between permafrost and groundwater in the Arctic regions, which are particularly vulnerable to climate changes. This review is focused on permafrost thawing, groundwater discharge, and recharge processes and their implication on the environment. We attempt to answer the following questions: How does permafrost affect groundwater discharge and recharge? Does permafrost act as a hindrance for groundwater? How does progressive global warming and thereby permafrost thawing impact the groundwater discharge? How significant is groundwater discharge? How important is the transport of different solutes to the environment by groundwater discharge?

    Based on the literature, we can conclude that the degradation of permafrost greatly influences hydrological systems in cold zones. Permafrost has a strong impact on fluid dynamics caused by negligible hydraulic conductivity. This relationship, beyond all physical, chemical, and biogeochemical responses, contributes to the formation of complex permafrost–groundwater interactions. Permafrost degradation strongly affects the ecosystem through direct and indirect impacts on the transport and cycles of different compounds, elements, and ions. Moreover, all processes are dependent on topography, geomorphology, tectonics, and surface hydrology. Research conducted in other than Arctic permafrost areas also indicated that permafrost thawing is the cause of enhanced groundwater recharge and discharge rates, which resulted in deeper water tables and groundwater flow paths. However, comprehensible and systematic studies are still needed for global assessment also in terms of searching for interdependencies between different regions.

    This belongs to Project No. 2019/34/H/ST10/00645 "Submarine Groundwater Discharge in a Changing Arctic Region: Scale and Biogeochemical impact", which is supported by the Norwegian Financial Mechanism and Polish national Basic Research Program.

    How to cite: Diak, M., Borecka, M., Böttcher, M. E., Hong, W.-L., Knies, J., Kotwicki, L., Kuliński, K., Lepland, A., Koziorowska-Makuch, K., Sen, A., von Ahn, C. M. E., Winogradow, A., and Szymczycha, B.: Permafrost and groundwater interaction, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12719, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12719, 2022.

    EGU22-12780 | Presentations | HS8.2.1

    A multi-disciplinary approach to characterize groundwater systems in coastal areas: the case studies of the Muravera Plain (Sardinia, Italy) 

    Claudio Arras, Riccardo Biddau, Paolo Botti, Cristina Buttau, Rosa Cidu, Antonio Funedda, Francesca Lobina, Alfredo Loi, Mario Lorrai, Maria Chiara Porru, Maurizio Testa, and Stefania Da Pelo

    A multi-disciplinary approach for the hydrogeological assessment and characterization of groundwaters in a coastal area with high anthropogenic pressure and ongoing seawater intrusion phenomena is presented. Such phenomena are increasingly widespread in coastal areas all over the world and could seriously threaten groundwater resources and socio-economic development of territories.

    The coastal plain of Muravera, in south-eastern Sardinia (Italy), has been studied since the sixties because of important seawater intrusion phenomena. Over the years, many research and studies, including geological, geophysical and geochemical, have been carried out, but dynamics and processes controlling the groundwater flow system were not fully understood. To define a three-dimensional (3D) hydrogeological conceptual model, all the available existing data were integrated within a 3D GIS environment along with those collected during new field surveys, including piezometric, hydrochemical and multi-isotope data, namely deuterium and oxygen isotopic composition of water (δ2H and δ18O), tritium(3H), strontium (86Sr/87Sr), and boron (δ11B). Stratigraphic logs and geophysical, interpreted according to a geological–depositional model based on sequential stratigraphy, allowed to constrain the geometry of the groundwater system, resulting in a complex multilayer aquifer, mostly phreatic and locally confined. Results from bulk chemistry and isotopes provided information regarding recharge sources, flow paths and residence times of groundwaters.  Four main flow paths, including lateral recharge from bedrock, surface water infiltration from the Flumendosa river and Rio Flumini Uri, and the occurrence of young mixing processes between fresh and sea waters were recognized. Moreover, a major contribution of meteoric water to groundwater recharge has been documented.

    The proposed approach improves the understanding of the aquifer system under investigation and reduces uncertainties about main groundwater dynamics. Moreover, results of the conceptualization become new input information and data required in the development of a groundwater flow numerical model. The latter represents a useful tool for an efficient management of groundwater resources aimed at improving the quality and availability of water resources by local government.

    How to cite: Arras, C., Biddau, R., Botti, P., Buttau, C., Cidu, R., Funedda, A., Lobina, F., Loi, A., Lorrai, M., Porru, M. C., Testa, M., and Da Pelo, S.: A multi-disciplinary approach to characterize groundwater systems in coastal areas: the case studies of the Muravera Plain (Sardinia, Italy), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12780, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12780, 2022.

    EGU22-725 | Presentations | HS8.2.4

    The contribution of Satellite-data driven snow routine to karst hydrological models 

    Suleyman Selim Calli, Kübra Özdemir Calli, M. Tuğrul Yılmaz, and Mehmet Çelik

    Snow recharge is an important dominant hydrological process in the high altitude mountainous karstic aquifer systems. In general, widely used karst hydrological models (e.g., KarstMod, Varkarst) do not include a snow routine in the model structure to avoid increasing the number of model parameters while representing the complex hydrological process. As a result, recharge process is not represented well, which questions the optimality of the results that can be obtained under available datasets. This study presents a novel pre-processing method –called SCA routine– to compensate for the missing snow routine in karst models. The proposed pre-processing method is driven by the temperature, precipitation, and satellite-based snow observation datasets while classifying the precipitation input into three physical phases (rain, snow, and mixed) based on the temperature datasets to distribute each phase over the catchment using satellite-driven Snow-Covered Area (SCA) products. By the proposed method, the spring discharge simulation result is regulated well in time and magnitude. To examine the added utility of the SCA routine, the SCA-included simulation results are compared to the model performances with no routine and the classical Degree-Day method as a benchmark. To test the efficiency of our proposed method we use a karst hydrological model (KarstMod) to simulate the karst spring discharge in a well-observed semi-arid snow-dominated karstic aquifer (Central Taurus, Turkey). Our results confirm that the KarstMod model coupled by SCA routine ensures better model performance with a value of NSE = 0.784 than those of the classical Degree-day method (NSE = 0.760) and the model with no routine (NSE = 0.306) while providing a physically more realistic parameter set.

    Key Words: MODIS, Degree-Day, Hydrological model, Snowmelt, Mountainous karst

     

    How to cite: Calli, S. S., Özdemir Calli, K., Yılmaz, M. T., and Çelik, M.: The contribution of Satellite-data driven snow routine to karst hydrological models, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-725, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-725, 2022.

    EGU22-1619 | Presentations | HS8.2.4

    Challenges in characterisation and mapping of solution pipes 

    Matej Lipar, Piotr Szymczak, Rok Ciglič, Rishabh Prakash Sharma, Matija Zorn, Uroš Stepišnik, and Mateja Ferk

    Solution pipes are vertical or near-vertical cylindrical tubes occurring within the vadose zone of limestones during the eogenetic stage of their diagenesis, characterised by high permeability and matrix porosity (e.g., Quaternary calcarenites). The pipes vary in size and can be wider than 2 m and deeper than 100 m; depths between 1 m and 4 m and diameters between 20 cm and 80 cm are most common. The radius of a single pipe within a homogeneous rock is usually either constant or tapers slightly downwards. Some of the pipes, particularly the ones in coastal areas in the Mediterranean climate, have well cemented calcrete rims. These rims are usually less porous and more resistant to weathering than the host rock, and may consequently stand out after erosion of the surrounding material.

    The unifying process responsible for their formation is a focused vertical flow of water, which depends primarily on sufficient water supply – e.g., rainfall. A detailed understanding of the formation of solution pipes can therefore provide us with a tool to estimate the climatic conditions prevailing at the time of their formation based on the density and shape of the pipes. The first important component here is the distribution of pipes. In addition to manual mapping and measuring, a combined photogrammetry and 3D laser scanning can be used to record their distribution on a larger scale. However, the machine learning algorithm needs to be developed to automatically detect their appearance and radius. This is challenging because pipes can appear in various shapes: as flat circles filled with sediment (with no relief on the surface), as holes, or as elevated cylindrical pinnacles due to erosion of the surrounding bedrock. In addition, their visibility is often limited due to sediment and vegetation cover. Cliff faces offer a glimpse of their interior, but their true spatial distribution is unknown. In contrast the eroded coastal platform shores provide a horizontal cross-section and distribution, but their vertical morphology and their depths are unknown. Similar situation appears in anthropogenic outcrops such as road cuttings and quarries. Promising methods for non-invasive mapping of the pipes are ground penetrating radar (GPR), magnetic gradiometer and electrical resistivity tomography (ERT), but with certain limitations, mainly related to unclear detection of the depths of the pipes, and the reliability of the mineralogy, geochemistry and texture of the fill of the pipes.

    The second important component is the morphology of the pipes. In order to properly estimate their shapes, especially their depths, a denudation factor must be considered. This can be partially assessed with numerical modelling of reactive-infiltration instability, which incorporates the lowering of the landscape during the formation of the pipes. However, this remains limited to the accuracy of dating of solution pipe formation, and estimations of post-formation landscape denudation.

    ACKNOWLEDGEMENT: We acknowledge the financial support of Slovenian Research Agency (P6-0101; I0-0031; N1-0162; J6-3142).

    How to cite: Lipar, M., Szymczak, P., Ciglič, R., Prakash Sharma, R., Zorn, M., Stepišnik, U., and Ferk, M.: Challenges in characterisation and mapping of solution pipes, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1619, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1619, 2022.

    EGU22-1906 | Presentations | HS8.2.4

    Experimental studies at a coastal cave in the Apulian karst, southern Italy 

    Mario Parise, Tommaso Chiarusi, Massimo Esposito, Michele Onorato, Raffaele Onorato, Sergio Orsini, Giuseppe Palmisano, and Marco Poto

    Grotta delle Corvine is a submarine cave which opens along the Ionian coast of Apulia (southern Italy), in the spectacular landscape of the Natural Reserve of Porto Selvaggio. The cave takes its name from a species of fish (corvine = Sciaena umbra), which accompanied the cave divers during the first phases of exploration. As concerns its origin, Grotta delle Corvine represents the remaining part of an original karst conduit which development was controlled by the fault systems that shaped the Ionian coastline in the time span from Miocene to Pliocene, and that was later invaded by the sea due to the Mediterranean eustatic movements during the Quaternary. It is definitely the largest among the many submarine caves in the area: with a 8mt-wide and 4mt-high access, opening at -12 m below the sea level, it is widely decorated by speleothems, reaches a total development of some 50 meters, and is characterized by two aerated rooms in its final sector. These latter are two large air sacks, with the widest being over 8mt-large and about 12mt-high, without communication with the outside. The cave hosts a remarkable biodiversity, as testified by a variety of biological studies which documented the presence of 195 species, including 2 new ones. In addition to biology, several other issues are of scientific interest in the cave: these include the “fog effect” related to the wave action and to condensation of the water vapor due to pressure changes, and the presence of cold and hot springs in different sectors of the karst system, among the others.

    Recently, research activities have been started by a group of multi-disciplinary scientists and cavers, aimed at exploring some aspects of scientific interest at Grotta delle Corvine, and at documenting them. In detail, an experiment for measuring the amount of radon in the innermost room of the system has been performed by leaving for 15 days in the cave a measure station with plastic nuclear track detectors (CR39 and Makrofol) in a diffusion chamber. The sensors were dislocated at different heights (from the sea level to 6 mt). Analysis of the CR39 detectors showed uniform radon values over 4000 bequerel/m3 for all sensors, regardless of the height position. Analysis of the Makrofol sheets, on the other hand, is still ongoing.

    The activities performed so far highlighted the importance of Grotta delle Corvine for many aspects of science: beside the marine biology, already extensively studied but still with a high potential to explore, further geological, hydrogeological and physical investigations are worth to be undertaken at the site. For these reasons, in the next future we plan to continue these experiments aimed at collecting data about the physics of the underground climate, and to add observations and water samplings to define the main hydrogeological characters of the karst system, and to check the main variations in temperature and salinity of the waters, in particular at the two identified springs.

    How to cite: Parise, M., Chiarusi, T., Esposito, M., Onorato, M., Onorato, R., Orsini, S., Palmisano, G., and Poto, M.: Experimental studies at a coastal cave in the Apulian karst, southern Italy, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1906, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1906, 2022.

    EGU22-1913 | Presentations | HS8.2.4

    Improvement of structural data by means of FracPaQ software to implement groundwater flow model in karst settings 

    Isabella Serena Liso, Claudia Cherubini, Mario Parise, and Roberto Emanuele Rizzo

    Carbonate rock formations are inherently extremely anisotropic rock masses, due to the simultaneous presence of well-defined stratabounds discontinuities and wide-spread fracturing. When karst processes occur, they can obliterate or widen the aperture of the original discontinuity networks, adding further complexity to the system. In karst territories the carbonate rock masses host important freshwater resources, which are often the only available water supply for local communities. In order to protect karst groundwater, it is imperative to properly evaluate the underground flow dynamics. To do so, we need to build detailed datasets of the three-dimensional (3D) spatial distribution of discontinuity networks, which serve as primary input for numerical simulation of fluid movement in the underground water reservoirs. Field structural-geological surveys are common means for obtaining the necessary information regarding the spatial distribution of the discontinuity networks. However, this approach is highly time-consuming and struggles to provide sufficient data to build robust statistics.

    In recent years, the combination of new technologies for data acquisition (e.g. drones and high precision cameras) and new freely-available softwares, such as DigiFract (Hardebol and Bertotti, 2013), FracPaQ (Helay et al., 2017), and NetworkGT (Nyberg et al., 2018) are bridging the gap between fast and reliable fracture data acquisition and analyses. Through the use of these techniques, we are now able to directly work on digital images taken from the outcrops as input, and to produce outputs which provide robust statistics about the discontinuities within the analysed medium.

    In this contribution, we present research aiming at full characterization of the rock mass discontinuities within a study area in Apulia Region (Southern Italy). Specifically, we studied the Canale di Pirro polje where the deepest Apulian cave, named Inghiottitoio di Masseria Rotolo, is located. The cave opens at 300 m a.s.l. and reaches the water table at about -260m depth below the topographic surface. By means of combining detailed photogrammetric survey and the use of the FracPaQ software toolbox, we were able to analyse in details the discontinuity network exposed at the outcrops, and consequently to use this information for evaluating how the network influences the underground flow direction and its velocity.  The statistical and spatial analysis of the discontinuity network, together with data derived from both the surface and underground, with specific surveys performed within the cave, allowed to present the first considerations about the groundwater flow in the surroundings of the karst system, useful to implement a numerical model heavily based upon direct observations from surface and underground karst areas.

     

     

    REFERENCES

    Hardebol, N. J., & Bertotti, G. (2013). DigiFract: A software and data model implementation for flexible acquisition and processing of fracture data from outcrops. Computers & Geosciences, 54, 326-336.

    Healy D., Rizzo R.E., Cornwell D.G., Farrell N.J.C., Watkins H., Timms N.E, Gomez- Rivas E. and Smith M. (2017). FracPaQ: A MATLABTM toolbox for the quantification of fracture patterns. J. Structural Geology, 95, 1-16. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jsg.2016.12.003.

    Nyberg, B., Nixon, C. W., & Sanderson, D. J. (2018). NetworkGT: A GIS tool for geometric and topological analysis of two-dimensional fracture networks. Geosphere, 14(4), 1618-1634.

    How to cite: Liso, I. S., Cherubini, C., Parise, M., and Rizzo, R. E.: Improvement of structural data by means of FracPaQ software to implement groundwater flow model in karst settings, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1913, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1913, 2022.

    EGU22-2041 | Presentations | HS8.2.4

    Variability of long-term denudation rates measured by 36Cl analyses on a karst levelled surface 

    Kristina Krklec, Regis Braucher, Dražen Perica, and David Domínguez-Villar

    Studies of karst denudation rates are great approach to provide an insight to karst landscape development. Traditionally, dissolution of carbonate rocks is considered to be the main process governing carbonate weathering, other processes should not be overlooked. Here we present research done in the North Dalmatian Plain, a carbonate erosive surface located in the Dinaric karst region. Although study site is composed of two different carbonate lithologies having different weathering style, there is no evident lithological impact on the topography of erosive surface. Analyses of 36Cl were performed in ten proximal samples from both lithologies resulted in denudation rates from 14.7 to 22.7 m/Ma. Since no statistical significance was found between samples from different lithologies (all samples belong to a single normal population) having same geomorphological context and climate features, variable denudation rates are attributed to local differences in denudation.  

    In the study site there are no large outstanding rock residuals, or deep soil patches, thus in order to maintain the levelled erosive surface local differential denudation rates have to vary with time. We hypothesize that lichens and pedogenic carbonates have a significant role in modulating local differences in denudation rates. Our study shows that even at outcrop scale, differences in local denudation rate can be significant and study of large set of samples is preferred to properly characterize the overall denudation rates of carbonate surfaces. Thus, the long-term denudation rate of the North Dalmatian Plain, including local variability, is 18.55 ±0.79 m/Ma. Despite classical studies on karst terrains assume that dissolution is the main process responsible for denudation of these landscapes, our research highlights the importance of physical weathering in combination with dissolution of carbonates as main controls on the denudation of karst landscapes.

     

    Acknowledgements: This research is a part of the research project “Inter-comparison of karst denudation measurement methods” (KADEME) (IP-2018-01-7080) financed by Croatian Science Foundation.

    How to cite: Krklec, K., Braucher, R., Perica, D., and Domínguez-Villar, D.: Variability of long-term denudation rates measured by 36Cl analyses on a karst levelled surface, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2041, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2041, 2022.

    EGU22-2297 | Presentations | HS8.2.4

    Hydrogeological, geochemical and structural features of the aquifer feeding the Nadìa spring: an "oasis in the desert" of the Northern Apennines (Italy). 

    Maria Filippini, Stefano Segadelli, Michele Failoni, Francesca Stendardi, Gianluca Vignaroli, Giulio Viola, Christine Stumpp, Enrico Dinelli, and Alessandro Gargini

    The Nadìa spring is the second largest tapped spring in the Emilia Romagna Region (northern Italy), representing a strategic local source of drinking water, also in the perspective of future global changes. The spring flowrate ranges between 65 l/s in the recharge season and 45 l/s at the end of the low-flow season, when most of the other tapped springs in the region have flowrates lower than 5 l/s. Geological, geomorphological, hydrological and geochemical investigations were carried out in the spring watershed to unravel the factors causing this peculiarly high discharge. The spring arises at the base of a calcarenitic fractured aquifer (Pantano Formation, upper Burdigalian-lower Langhian) underlain by lower permeability units. Karst dissolution along structural discontinuities in the Pantano Formation has been suggested in the past as a possibility to account for the aquifer high permeability resulting in the high spring discharge. A continuous monitoring of the spring flowrate, temperature, electric conductivity and pH was conducted during the 2020-2021 hydrologic year. Hydrographs and chemographs indicated atypical karst flow dynamics. The time to halve the peak-discharge of the spring is between 20 and 50 days, lower than that of most springs of the Northern Apennines (> 50 days). This implies a higher average aquifer flow rate (around 10 m/day) compared to that typical of arenitic or turbiditic aquifers (around 1 m/day). Spring water samples collected once to twice a year since 2011 for the analysis of major ions revealed an obvious calcium-bicarbonate hydrochemistry that is consistent with the hypothesis of karst dissolution. However, the chemical variability over time expected in a karst system due to the drainage of different groundwater fractions (newly infiltrated vs. older groundwater) was not observed. Instead, the water chemical composition was exceptionally constant over time, suggesting that drainage occurs from a large, homogeneous reservoir. Water stable isotopes have been analyzed in 2021 revealing a composition close to that of the local winter precipitations and suggesting exceptional stability of the spring water composition over different seasons. An 80 m deep borehole has been drilled in the Pantano Formation 7 km away from the spring, documenting the occurrence of fractures with decimetric apertures as deep as 60-70 m below ground surface, which may be interpreted as the result of karst dissolution. In addition to the debatable karst aquifer hypothesis, geomorphological observations indicate the occurrence of depressed areas, of likely tectonic origin, in the aquifer overlying the spring, which may provide a favorable setting for concentrated infiltration and groundwater recharge. However, the hypothesis of concentrated recharge is in apparent contrast to the abovementioned stability of spring water chemical composition over time. A volume of the aquifer representing a reasonable reservoir for the spring has been identified based on spring flow recession analysis and a geo-structural model of the Pantano outcrop up-gradient to the spring. The structural-stratigraphic setting of the hypothesized reservoir includes the occurrence of fault-related fractures that cross-cut the low-dipping bedding of the calcarenites, possibly enhancing the local permeability and the drainage towards the Nadìa spring.

    How to cite: Filippini, M., Segadelli, S., Failoni, M., Stendardi, F., Vignaroli, G., Viola, G., Stumpp, C., Dinelli, E., and Gargini, A.: Hydrogeological, geochemical and structural features of the aquifer feeding the Nadìa spring: an "oasis in the desert" of the Northern Apennines (Italy)., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2297, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2297, 2022.

    EGU22-2329 | Presentations | HS8.2.4

    3D structural analysis of the cave of Saint Michael at Minervino Murge, Bari (Italy) – a typical case of karst environment in Puglia 

    Stefano Cardia, Francesco Langella, Marco Pagano, Biagio Palma, and Mario Parise

    The presence of surface and subterranean landforms (caves, sinkholes, etc.) produced by karst processes in the Apulian territory is among the most typical features of the local landscape. Numerous examples can be counted throughout the region, especially in the Murge plateau, one of the three karst sub-regions of Apulia. Here the rock, being composed mainly of carbonates, has been affected in multiple stages by karst, which more visible results nowadays consist of numerous cavities, some of which show evidence of instability problems. At the present day, especially for those caves which are open to the public, it is necessary to perform stability analysis aimed at evaluating the stability conditions at the sites. In the Murge area, the cave of Saint Michael at Minervino Murge is among the most famous, belonging to the set of caves dedicated to the figure of Saint Michael the Archangel, which also includes the UNESCO protected site at Monte Sant’Angelo, in the Gargano Promontory of northern Apulia, a major Catholic pilgrimage site. At Minervino Murge, the cave consists of a wide room hosting a deep and wide stairway leading to the altar dedicated to Saint Michael, and an innermost, smaller, environment which entirely keeps its naturality. Besides the religious and historical interests, the whole cave needs a detailed analysis of the stability of the rock mass, both for the protection of its architectural and archaeological values and for the safeguard of the pilgrims. At this aim, we performed various digital surveys by means of laser scanners and drones equipped with high-resolution cameras. The results of these scans are going to be processed in order to understand the geometry of the entire cave and to properly determine the main volumes of unstable blocks, as well as the likely kinematics of movement. Given the height of the cave, remote sensing techniques are particularly suitable for such an analysis, allowing to obtain from a distance the relevant data, rather than investigating the site with traditional geomechanical survey methods. Furthermore, the facility of acquisition of the remote sensing data will allow repetitiveness of the surveys, thus permitting monitoring over different time windows, in order to check periodically the most dangerous situations and to properly exploit this site of historical importance and religious worship.

    How to cite: Cardia, S., Langella, F., Pagano, M., Palma, B., and Parise, M.: 3D structural analysis of the cave of Saint Michael at Minervino Murge, Bari (Italy) – a typical case of karst environment in Puglia, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2329, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2329, 2022.

    EGU22-2372 | Presentations | HS8.2.4

    Geomorphological analysis of dolines in a low-topography karst, and considerations about their hydraulic functioning 

    Luca Pisano, Lagna Francesca, Isabella Serena Liso, and Mario Parise

    Starting from previous experiences in karst settings of southern Italy, and following the same procedure for the identification of dolines and endorheic basins (Zumpano et al., 2019; Pisano et al., 2020), we focus here our attention on several dolines characterizing the landscape of the Salento peninsula, in the southernmost part of Apulia. This region shows a typical low-topography karst, with elevations reaching maximum values of about 120 m a.s.l.. Thus, very often the main karst landforms, such as dolines and endorheic basins, are not clear to identify and present subdue connections with the adjoining land. Only at those sites where the doline was produced by collapse of the carbonate bedrock, or of the overburden above it, and where an active swallow hole is present, recognition appear more direct and straightforward.

    Nevertheless, it is exactly this difficulty in identification of the karst landforms which makes particularly intriguing the research in the central sector of Salento. Further, in this area one of the two Apulian caves where speleologists are able to directly reach the water table, at depth of -60 m below the ground surface, is located: Vora Bosco opens within a narrow, W-E oriented, fissure in the topographic surface, and develops through the overall stratigraphic succession of Salento, from Quaternary deposits, to Plio-Pleistocene and Miocene calcarenites, down to the Cretaceous limestones, with these latter hosting the water table.

    In a 240km2-wide area around Vora Bosco, a systematic survey was carried out aimed at identifying all dolines. The work started from analysis of historical sources, integrated by periodic field surveys, and by detailed analysis of multi-temporal sets of aerial photographs. Several tens of dolines and endorheic basins of variable size were mapped, and distinguished on the basis of the mechanism at the origin of their formation, according to the most widespread international classification (Gutierrez et al., 2014).

    In addition to the genetic and morphometric characterization of the identified dolines and endorheic basins, these were also discriminated as concerns the role they play for hydraulic functioning: based upon the local situation, with particular regard to presence and thickness of residual deposits, and to the discontinuity networks in the rock mass, these sites may act as absorption point to recharge the karst aquifer, or as impervious areas which retard the downward infiltration of water.

     

    References

    Gutierrez F., Parise M., De Waele J. & Jourde H., 2014, A review on natural and human-induced geohazards and impacts in karst. Earth Science Reviews, vol. 138, p. 61-88.

    Parise M., 2019, Sinkholes. In: White W.B., Culver D.C. & Pipan T. (Eds.), Encyclopedia of Caves. Academic Press, Elsevier, 3rd edition, ISBN 978-0-12-814124-3, p. 934-942.

    Pisano L., Zumpano V., Liso I.S. & Parise M., 2020, Geomorphological and structural characterization of the “Canale di Pirro” polje, Apulia (Southern Italy). Journal of Maps, vol. 16 (2), p. 479-487.

    Zumpano V., Pisano L. & Parise M., 2019, An integrated framework to identify and analyze karst sinkholes. Geomorphology, vol. 332, p. 213-225.

    How to cite: Pisano, L., Francesca, L., Liso, I. S., and Parise, M.: Geomorphological analysis of dolines in a low-topography karst, and considerations about their hydraulic functioning, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2372, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2372, 2022.

    Six tracer experiments were undertaken under different flow periods to delineate the catchment area and identify transport parameters in two snow-governed springs Laban and Assal in Mount Lebanon used for water supply. The two springs yield different responses to snow melt, ambient temperature in high flow and in recession despite their common origin from the same Albian-Cenomanian rock sequence. These discrepencies were attributed partly to different facies within the aquifer (limestone and dolostones). Yet faults and secondary fractures also play an important role in defining preferential flows in such a complex system. Secondary faults and fractures are difficult to depict in the field and were assessed via fracture analysis. In this work, primary faults with their characteristics (displacement and trends) are input in a Havana software (developed by Norsk Regnesentral; SAND 2021) based on field data used to simulate new faults. The model generates a secondary set of faults from a truncated fractal distribution, yielding thus different realizations of the set of secondary faults depending on the parametrization of the fractal model. The realizations will be validated with field data, doline distribution, and fracture analysis as well as tracer experiments results. This work allows to combine physical data with geostatistical techniques to optimize the delineation of the catchment and preferential flow in complex vulnerable karst systems.

    How to cite: Doummar, J. and Almendral Vazquez, A.: Identification of fast preferential flow distribution in a complex snow-governed karst system based on an inference of secondary faults, doline distribution, and tracer tests experiments: An application to Mount Lebanon , EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2572, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2572, 2022.

    EGU22-2628 | Presentations | HS8.2.4

    Large-scale spatial reconstitution of pressure and tracer tests responses in a karst aquifer (Lez aquifer, France) 

    Pierre Fischer, Hervé Jourde, and Véronique Leonardi

    Spatial characterization of the hydraulic properties in the subsurface is an extensively studied problematic. Inverse problems allow to image those properties by interpreting the information from a dataset of field measurements with a chosen physical formulation of fluxes in a numerical distributed model. However, karst media characterization remains a complex task, due to the fact that the matrix and conduits entities generate a highly contrasted distribution of property values. Furthermore the matrix and conduits compartments respond to different flow physics that can be approached by considering Darcy flow and pipe flow, respectively. Thus, one needs to employ a multi-physics model, an inversion method able to capture the properties contrast, and also to use data providing information on the localization of the conduits network and its connectivity.

    We propose a large-scale 2-D application of characterization of the Lez aquifer in southern France, covering a surface of about 250 km². We take advantages of long-terms measurements within the framework of the MEDYCYSS observation site, part of the Karst observatory network (www.snokarst.org) initiated by the French institute INSU/CNRS. Drawdown signals measured in 11 wells and incorporating a periodic response due to a daily pumping at the aquifers spring were thus considered to identify the location of the conduit network. The periodic responses can provide connectivity information between wells in the inversion process, while non-periodic responses permit to better assess the large-scale property values of the whole aquifer. A Cellular Automata-based Deterministic Inversion (CADI) is used to generate a contrasted property field able to reproduce the measured signals in the 2-D distributed numerical model solving Darcy flows. However, pressure data alone remain limited to characterize the fast flows that can occur in the conduits network. Thus, the flow velocities in the preferential flow paths located with the pressure data are then reconstituted by inverting a set of different tracer tests responses at the Lez spring, considering this time a pipe flow physics in the model.

    How to cite: Fischer, P., Jourde, H., and Leonardi, V.: Large-scale spatial reconstitution of pressure and tracer tests responses in a karst aquifer (Lez aquifer, France), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2628, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2628, 2022.

    EGU22-2637 | Presentations | HS8.2.4

    A lumped parameter modeling approach considering land-cover and land-use for the simulation of karst spring hydrological functioning. 

    Vianney Sivelle, Hervé Jourde, Daniel Bittner, Beatrice Richieri, David Labat, Andreas Hartmann, and Gabriele Chiogna

    The lumped parameter modeling approach has been widely applied in karst hydrology for, among other applications, the understanding of their functioning of the assessment or groundwater availability in a context of global change. Nonetheless, such an approach generally does not account for land-cover land-use (LCLU) changes and their potential impacts on recharge processes. The study focuses on three forests dominated karst catchments: Kerschbaum (Lower Austria), Baget (French Pyrenees) and Oeillal (southern France), and investigates how LCLU changes in a lumped parameter modeling approach can affect both the internal fluxes and the model performance. The active subspace method is used to perform sensitivity analysis of model parameters, and to quantify parameter uncertainty. We show that the consideration of a semi-distributed recharge constitutes a relevant approach to capture the impact of LCLU changes on flow dynamics, but also introduces more uncertainty in the modeling approach. This approach may thus allow identifying the trade-off between modeling approach complexity and its performance. Finally, it gives new insight for the assessment of LCLU changes impacts on karst groundwater resource.

    How to cite: Sivelle, V., Jourde, H., Bittner, D., Richieri, B., Labat, D., Hartmann, A., and Chiogna, G.: A lumped parameter modeling approach considering land-cover and land-use for the simulation of karst spring hydrological functioning., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2637, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2637, 2022.

    EGU22-2785 | Presentations | HS8.2.4

    Relationship between the hydrodynamic response and the geometrical and topological properties of the karst conduit network 

    Mohammed Aliouache, Chuanyin Jiang, and Hervé Jourde

    In karst catchments, groundwater is generally drained from recharge zones towards main outlets (springs). Karst systems develop mainly in limestone and have three different porosities which are the result of sedimentation, diagenesis, tectonics but also dissolution that generate the conduits.  Continuous monitoring at high temporal resolutions is largely used to characterize the hydrodynamic behavior and variability of karst systems hydrological functioning Hydrologic models are used in order to better asses the functioning of karst systems but can also help identifying the impact of global change on water resources. Though these models require an adequate representation of main heterogeneities and processes, the heterogeneity of karst systems is often poorly characterized by available data. For these reasons, most of hydrological models considered for the understanding of karst systems hydrodynamic are lumped parameters models. In this study, we simulate precipitation-discharge relationship as a function of different karst geometries and topologies using two dimensional distributed models. We then investigate the relationship between the hydrodynamic response (e.g. flow rate at discharge point) and topology of the karst conduit network. Lumped approaches are later on compared to distributed models in term of predicting hydrodynamic response to precipitation.

    How to cite: Aliouache, M., Jiang, C., and Jourde, H.: Relationship between the hydrodynamic response and the geometrical and topological properties of the karst conduit network, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2785, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2785, 2022.

    EGU22-2789 | Presentations | HS8.2.4

    Incipient karst generation in three-dimensional jointed layered rocks: influence of aperture configurations and flow boundary conditions 

    Chuanyin Jiang, Xiaoguang Wang, Herve Jourde, and Mohammed Aliouache

    Karst aquifers provide considerable groundwater resources and supplies in many countries of the world. Karst systems exhibit complex spatial distributions of conduits, caves and vugs, but speleogenesis modeling remains very limited at aquifer scale. Early stage of wormholes development generally controls the final pattern of karst due to the positive feedback loop. In this study, we analyze the incipient karst generation in 3D jointed carbonate rocks with multiple horizontal layers, on the basis of numerical simulations. First, the fracture networks are generated while considering pseudo-mechanical rules for the nucleation and propagation of joints. Then, we analyze the impact of aperture configurations and flow boundary conditions on the dissolution patterns in such a 3D joint layered rock based on a developed hydro-chemical model. Preliminary results show that, for uniform apertures and horizontal flow, similar dissolution patterns are obtained whatever the flow orientations; bedding planes control and favor the tree-shape conduit networks while the joints promote the vertical spread. Results also show that karstification processes are dominated by the joint network structure and are significantly confined in individual layers when the aperture of bedding plane is lower than that of the joints. Changing flow boundary conditions (i.e. recharge and discharge from localized points instead of domain borders) tends also to induce different dissolution patterns. Compared to dissolution in a 2D fracture networks, these 3D reactive transport simulations further reveal the interaction of joint networks among different layers. This study has an important implication on understanding the initiation of different types of incipient karst patterns observed in nature.

    How to cite: Jiang, C., Wang, X., Jourde, H., and Aliouache, M.: Incipient karst generation in three-dimensional jointed layered rocks: influence of aperture configurations and flow boundary conditions, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2789, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2789, 2022.

    EGU22-2878 | Presentations | HS8.2.4

    Assessing the ability GEOframe modeling system for water budget analysis of a challenging karst basin in the Apennines chains, Central Italy. 

    Shima Azimi, Christian Massari, Giuseppe Formetta, Silvia Barbetta, Alberto Tazioli, Davide Fronzi, Sara Modanesi, Angelica Tarpanelli, and Riccardo Rigon

    The analysis of the water budget in the Upper Nera River basin, typical karst and fissured rocks catchment located in the Apennines chains in central Italy, has been performed to simulate snow, Evapotranspiration (ET), and runoff through different components of the GEOframe system. During this study, we showed that using an unsupervised approach for extracting the basin boundary could provide significant issues in the correct estimation of water budget components. To overcome this problem, both hydrogeological and hydrological information -obtained through a new type of time-series analyses and recent geological surveys- have been considered to estimate the contribution area and time response of the karst discharge. According to the mentioned information and benefiting the flexibility of the GEOframe-NewAge modeling system, a conceptual reservoir with a 30-day time response, derived from the time series analysis, has been added to estimate the karst river discharge contributed to Nera. The model, evaluated by different signatures (including mean daily discharge, high flow, low flow, low flow duration frequency, and flow duration curve slope and a new empirical probability function) has been shown to reproduce the water fluxes of the hydrological cycle in the basin relatively well (KGE values equal to 0.61, 0.80, and 0.71 in different sections, respectively). The karst discharge flux has a significant effect on the water budget of the basin especially in the upstream part (Castelsantangelo section) and this effect decreased through the river downstream to the outlet of Visso. We showed that 85% of the total discharge at Castelsantangelo station comes from outside of the geomorphological boundary of the basin. According to the water balance analysis, the maximum karst flux that happened in 2014 could be mainly caused by the maximum precipitation that happened in 2013 over the basin.  

    To further cross-validation of the model performance, MODIS ET and Sentinel-1 snow depth products were used. The comparison of remote-sensed MODIS ET and GEOframe ET shows a systematic difference, with higher values of MODIS ET than our model estimations. As well, the spatial correlation of snow cover retrieved from Sentinel-1 snow depth and GEOframe Snow Water Equivalent has been examined and a good correlation has been reported especially for Castelsantangelo. The values of Sentinel-1 were also verified through some in-situ snow depth data.  

    How to cite: Azimi, S., Massari, C., Formetta, G., Barbetta, S., Tazioli, A., Fronzi, D., Modanesi, S., Tarpanelli, A., and Rigon, R.: Assessing the ability GEOframe modeling system for water budget analysis of a challenging karst basin in the Apennines chains, Central Italy., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2878, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2878, 2022.

    EGU22-3484 | Presentations | HS8.2.4

    The neglected role of karst features in rock mass characterization and stability assessment 

    Lidia Loiotine, Gioacchino Francesco Andriani, Marc-Henri Derron, Michel Jaboyedoff, Piernicola Lollino, and Mario Parise

    Stability analyses in karst settings, whether to assess the equilibrium conditions of natural slopes or to design engineering interventions, coexist with a significant uncertainty related to difficulties in modelling karst features. As a matter of fact, most of the rock mass classification systems do not directly take into account the presence of karst structures such as voids, conduits or caves, which can strongly influence the mechanical behaviour and the water flow in rock masses.

    In the last decades, the identification and characterization of discontinuity systems for rock mass characterization, aimed at stability analyses, have been intensively investigated by means of remote sensing techniques. However, semi-automatic or automatic methods for the extraction of discontinuities from point clouds are not easily applicable in karst because surface and subsurface features produce irregular surfaces, which are difficult to classify even using the most-advanced algorithms. This occurs even more heavily in the case of soft rocks, such as calcarenites.

    In this study, a demonstration of the influence of karst features in rock mass characterization and slope stability assessment is presented. First, the results of the Discontinuity Set Extractor (DSE) software used on an appropriate case study show that the irregular surfaces produced by carbonate dissolution, further enhanced by weathering, caused an incorrect classification of the discontinuity sets. Second, a high-resolution Digital Outcrop Model (DOM) was used to generate a very fine mesh (average element size = 35 cm, to take into account the large-scale karst structures) and to carry out 3-D numerical stability analyses by means of Finite Element Method, using a continuum-based approach. Although in the current conditions the examined slope is stable, the results illustrate that the maximum shear strain is localized in correspondence of the karst features (e.g. caves and voids) and at the sea level. By applying the Shear Strength Reduction method, it was found out that weathering processes can cause the same structures to be under yield and lead to localized failures.

    In addition, the key role that the discontinuities (extracted using an ad-hoc procedure) play on the rock mass mechanical behaviour was investigated using a 2-D FEM, based on a discontinuum approach. The results, which are in agreement with field observations, point out that karst processes, which features are characterized by the highest values in pervasiveness and aperture of the discontinuity systems and tend to reduce the rock bridges over time, need to be implemented in the rock mass classification systems and in numerical modelling techniques to avoid incorrect results. 

    How to cite: Loiotine, L., Andriani, G. F., Derron, M.-H., Jaboyedoff, M., Lollino, P., and Parise, M.: The neglected role of karst features in rock mass characterization and stability assessment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3484, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3484, 2022.

    Karst groundwater dependent ecosystems (KGDEs) represent an important asset worldwide due to their ecological and socioeconomic values. Although they are increasingly recognized as such, they have not been adequately documented and studied. The present contribution aims at characterizing the main KGDEs of the Dinaric karst in Slovenia. Their classification is based on their position within the hydrological system, geomorphology and ecological settings The main hydrological processes (i.e., extent, duration and frequency of groundwater inflow), the main biota and indicator communities, and the factors limiting the evolution of species (e.g., darkness) were identified. An overview of rare, endemic and charismatic species was also shown including Proteus anguinus, Marifugia cavatica, Monolistra racovitzae racovitzae and others. Due to its location in an area of very high geographical diversity and between different climate types, the Slovenian Dinaric karst is one of the hotspots of subterranean biodiversity on a global scale. The interaction between orographic, climatic, hydrological and edaphic conditions, as well as the fact that the area served as a hub for different species and as a refuge during the ice ages, are crucial for the very high biodiversity in this area. Due to deforestation in prehistoric times, man has even contributed to the diversification of the flora by creating space for the appearance or spread of habitats that are now considered natural (e.g., dry grasslands). An important factor in maintaining a particularly rich diversity of karst flora and fauna is also the low human impact and the very well preserved landscape in its natural state. KGDE sites in Slovenia with the greatest known species diversity are the Postojna-Planina and Škocjanske Jame cave systems, Cerkniško and Planinsko Polje, and the intermittent lakes of Pivka. Characterization of KGDEs is a prerequisite for a better understanding of the processes that control them, their biological function, and their vulnerability. Based on knowledge of how they will change and adapt under current pressures and global challenges from climate, land use, and societal changes, appropriate protection can be built. The ecohydrological characterization of KGDEs of Slovenian Dinaric karst presented here can serve as a pilot study for other karst regions with high biodiversity.

    How to cite: Ravbar, N. and Pipan, T.: Ecohydrological characterization of the karst groundwater dependent ecosystems of the Dinaric karst in Slovenia, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3675, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3675, 2022.

    EGU22-3817 | Presentations | HS8.2.4 | Highlight

    Citizen science and 3D modeling to study and protect Mediterranean marine caves: a real application in the caves of the Gulf of Orosei (Sardinia, Italy). 

    Laura Marroni, Peter Brandt, Peter Gaertner, and Andrea Marassich

    The Mediterranean coastline presents a high number of marine caves of different types. Marine caves are protected by the EU Habitats Directive (92/43/EEC - code 8330). Semi-dark and dark cave communities have been included in two Action Plans by UNEP-MAP-RAC/SPA (2008 and 2015 respectively) and are considered as sensitive reservoirs of biodiversity requiring protection. However, the scientific community still has scarce information about these important habitats, that are listed as Data Deficient.

    The main reason for the lack of knowledge about marine caves is that they are very difficult to access and study. Lack of a breathable source, lack of light and a physical ceiling are the hazards characterising any underwater cave; specific locations can force cave divers to deal with limited visibility, restricted passages or high water flow. The number of individuals with the skills required to safely navigate such caves while carrying out research or scientific work is extremely limited.  

    Our project aims at closing this information gap, by providing a methodology for surveying underwater caves. Our main study area is the Gulf of Orosei, Sardinia Italy. We count essentially on two important elements: 

    • citizen science - over the years, we gained a lot of experience in coordinating groups of volunteers, working with professional scientists to achieve common goals. All our projects and missions are carried out with the precious involvement of skilled individuals that perform specific tasks.
    • advanced technology - technology is essential to gather information about underwater environments in general, and caves in particular. Photogrammetry is the most detailed methodology to create a multidimensional cave model. Thanks to the precision and the very realistic representation of the environment, these models are ideal for both scientific and dissemination purposes. Photogrammetry relies on the connection between polygon line survey and photographic data. We can split the procedure in three parts: data collection (survey and media), software processing and model refinement. Once the model is finished, there are many useful applications that can be considered. For scientific purpose, the model can be geo-referenced and can be scaled and calibrated by a variety of methods to allow measurements and further analysis of the cave environment and surrounding landscape. For publication purposes to the wider public, the model can be exported to graphical design or ‘animated’ with VR and gaming softwares. Annotating the model and any artifact inside it with information can entertain and educate the visitors in virtual reality.

    Possibilities are endless and to fully master the flow from data capture inside the cave down to an interactive virtual representation or a scientific survey, a lot of expertise and knowledge is required and a strong cooperation between cave divers and researchers.

    References:
    Directive 2000/60/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 23 October 2000;
    Directive 2006/118/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 12 December 2006;
    Global Wetland Outlook: State of the World’s Wetlands and their Services to People. Gland, Switzerland: Ramsar Convention Secretariat (2018);
    European Red List of Habitats (ISBN 978-92-79-61586-3; ISBN 978-92-79-61588-7).

    How to cite: Marroni, L., Brandt, P., Gaertner, P., and Marassich, A.: Citizen science and 3D modeling to study and protect Mediterranean marine caves: a real application in the caves of the Gulf of Orosei (Sardinia, Italy)., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3817, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3817, 2022.

    EGU22-3926 | Presentations | HS8.2.4

    Isotopic and geochemical evolution of rainwater percolating through the rocky outcrops: Judaea mountain case study.   

    Or Letz, Hagar Siebner, Naama Avrahamov, Roey Egozi, and Ofer Dahan

    Groundwater recharge of mountain aquifer requires detailed knowledge of the hydrologic system and adequate monitoring and modeling methods to determine water amount and water quality evolution. Mountain aquifers are well known of their highly complex lithologic structure and surface morphology. These become more significant in dry climate regions (<300 mm rainfall/year) which are characterized by erratic rain pattern and extreme deep thickness unsaturated zone.

    In this study we monitor the isotopic and geo-chemical evolution affecting the composition of the unsaturated porewater during deep infiltration, from surface to depth that is not affected from evaporation. The geo-chemical processes were characterized related to land surface morphology and climate conditions.

    The research setup includes instrumentation of first-order stream which is characterized by two main typical geomorphologic setting: rocky terrain and deep soil along the stream channel. Each plot was instrumented with a monitoring setup that include a meteorological station and Vadose Zone Monitoring System (VMS) that enables continuous water content measurement and collection of unsaturated porewater from the vadose zone.

    Fast increases in water content and arrival of depleted δ18O (VSMOW) reveal quick and deep infiltration of rainwater during storm events, while enriched δ18O arrival indicates slower infiltration of water that is exposed to evaporation. In addition, the geo-chemical processes exhibited depletion in δ13C (PDB) of rainwater during the infiltration (-19 to -11 ‰) which indicates on dominant of biogenic activities and relatively low rock-water interactions. Major elements correlation network expresses the contribution of dust and rain to the rock evolution across the water flow path.

    The study results clearly exhibited different infiltration rates in each site. Fast infiltration at the rocky terrain due to rock outcrops on the surface create funnels for collecting the local runoff and delivering it into high permeability fractured zones where the water penetrates directly to the deep sections. In contrast, the bare soil areas such as hilltops or man-made terraces in streams with highly developed soil cross-section, reveal limited infiltration. Also, the annual rainfall pattern impacts the geochemical process and finally impacts the groundwater quantity and quality.

    How to cite: Letz, O., Siebner, H., Avrahamov, N., Egozi, R., and Dahan, O.: Isotopic and geochemical evolution of rainwater percolating through the rocky outcrops: Judaea mountain case study.  , EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3926, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3926, 2022.

    EGU22-4232 | Presentations | HS8.2.4

    Submarine springs in the Gulf of Taranto (Italy): geology, hydrogeology and cave diving explorations 

    Andrea Marassich, Sven Bertelmann, Francesco Marco D'Onghia, Isabella Serena Liso, and Mario Parise

    In coastal karst lands, due to difference in permeability among contiguous strata, emergence of springs may occur inland or as submarine springs, as in the Gulf of Taranto (Italy), marking the S limit of Murge, the largest karst sub-region in Apulia. Groundwater from N-NW feed some inland springs, sometimes originating small rivers, with Tara as the main significant. In addition to surface waters, submarine springs are present within the gulf, namely in Mar Piccolo of Taranto, an over 20 km2 wide basin (10-14m depth) consisting of two bays with elliptical shape, connected through a channel. In the N sectors of the bays 34 submarine springs have been identified. Locally called citri, a word of Greek origin, deriving from history of Taranto (founded as a Greek colony), they work as thermal regulators for the water temperature, allowing extensive development of mussel farming. The groundwater emission sites are characterized by funnel-shaped morphology with a circular profile at the sea surface. In the past, attempts were done to tap these waters (Cotecchia et al., 1990), but technical and engineering problems, brought to abandon such activities.

    In the Murge district the Cretaceous limestone aquifer is covered by Plio-Pleistocene calcarenites, clays and terraced marine deposits, with secondary porous aquifers flowing within these latter. Origin of the citri is related to surface dismantling and erosion of the cover, and to emergence of the confined water hosted in the limestones. In most of the cases, it comes out in wide areas, without a clear karst conduit. Among the few caves explorable by man, there is Citro Galeso, at the W bay: with a diameter of 20 m, and 18m depth, it has discharge of 0,750 m3/s.

    Inventoried since the first half of the XX century (Cerruti, 1938), only recently the distribution of citri was studied in detail (Valenzano et al., 2018). The largest spring (Saint Cataldo’s eyes) is located just outside the two bays, in Mar Grande: 200x300 m-wide, it consists of two cavities, reaching depth of 48 and 52 m, respectively, below sea level, and deepening for 20 additional meters.

    To improve the hydrogeological knowledge of the area, we are carrying out a variety of scientific activities, starting from exploration and surveying of accessible springs. A significant role is being attributed to the study of the cave systems, as regard their distribution and pattern network. As outflow yield and flow velocity data are not yet available for all citri, some measurements will be done at this aim. In addition, water samplings will be taken for characterizing the chemical constituents, and for assessing the presence and nature of pollutants.

     

    References

    Cerruti A., 1938, Le sorgenti sottomarine (Citri) del Mar Grande e Mar Piccolo di Taranto. Ann. Ist. Sup. Navale, Napoli, 7.

    Cotecchia et al., 1990, Hydrogeological conditions and field monitoring of Galeso submarine spring in the Mar Piccolo of Taranto (southern Italy). Proc. 11th SWIM, 171-208.

    Valenzano et al., 2018, Holocene Morpho-sedimentary evolution of Mar Piccolo basin (Taranto, Southern Italy). Geogr. Fis. Dinam. Quat., 41, 119-135.

    How to cite: Marassich, A., Bertelmann, S., D'Onghia, F. M., Liso, I. S., and Parise, M.: Submarine springs in the Gulf of Taranto (Italy): geology, hydrogeology and cave diving explorations, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4232, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4232, 2022.

    EGU22-4715 | Presentations | HS8.2.4

    Morphology and hydrogeology of a complex sinkhole system in a remarkable archaeological site along the Adriatic coastline (Apulia, S Italy) 

    Sven Bertelmann, Andrea Marassich, Isabella Serena Liso, and Mario Parise

    The Grotte della Poesia karst system is a complex of caves, sinkholes and submerged galleries, located along the Adriatic side of southern Apulia (Italy). In detail, the system consists of two main collapse sinkholes (Grotta della Poesia Grande and Piccola), connected through sumps with an intervening cave, and linked to the sea on two sides. Sinkhole development was strongly favoured by hyperkarst processes due to intermixing between fresh and salt water, and by the resulting increased aggressivity on carbonate rocks. The overall system is within the remarkable archaeological site of Roca, which incorporates remains from late Bronze to Medieval age (Scarano 2010). In particular, Grotta della Poesia Piccola hosts along its walls thousands of Messapian inscriptions dating back to IV-II centuries B.C., which are still the object of study by archaeologists.

    Local stratigraphy in the area consists of weak, laminated calcilutites and fine calcarenites alternated to coarser macro-fossiliferous and bioturbated calcarenites (Middle-Upp. Pliocene). Differences in permeability among the layers originate a multi-layered water table. To this, name of the caves has probably to be related, since the word poesiacomes from the local dialect (in turn, from ancient Greek), to indicate a spring or water emergence (Parise et al. 2003). A spring would therefore have been present within Grotta della Poesia Piccola, but at present is not visible anymore, probably due to lowering of the water table.

    Tectonically, wide folds with N 150 E axes (about parallel to the coast) characterize the area. They determine the presence inland of a wide marshland (Tamari), that has been interpreted as the inner and protected harbour for the ancient town of Roca.

    The Adriatic coastal landscape is characterized by a number of marine terraces resulting from the combined action of regional uplift and glacio-eustatic sea level changes. The coastline is very articulated, with 10-15m high cliffs, intensely affected by slope instabilities (Delle Rose and Parise 2004; Lollino et al. 2021). Within this geological setting, we are carrying out detailed speleological and diving explorations aimed at fully surveying the intricate system of caves (in both aerated and flooded conditions), as a mandatory step in order to identify the sites most susceptible to rock instabilities. Since the site is highly touristic, it is crucial to recognize the likely hazards, and to properly delimit the most dangerous areas. The surveys are also going to be used to better understand the hydrogeological situation, and to verify the possibility of presence of submarine springs in the coastal area and its surroundings.

     

    References

    Delle Rose M. & Parise M., 2004, Slope instability along the Adriatic coast of Salento, southern Italy. Proc. IX Int. Symp. Landslides, 1, 399-404.

    Lollino et al., 2021, Multi-scale approach to analyse the evolution of soft rock coastal cliffs and role of controlling factors: a case study in South-Eastern Italy. Geomatics 12 (1), 1058-1081,

    Parise et al., 2003, Karst terminology in Apulia (southern Italy). Acta Carsologica 32, 65-82.

    Scarano T., 2010, Roca. Le fortificazioni della media età del Bronzo. Ann. Scuola Normale Sup. Pisa, s. 5, 2 (2), 151-204.

    How to cite: Bertelmann, S., Marassich, A., Liso, I. S., and Parise, M.: Morphology and hydrogeology of a complex sinkhole system in a remarkable archaeological site along the Adriatic coastline (Apulia, S Italy), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4715, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4715, 2022.

    EGU22-4866 | Presentations | HS8.2.4

    Assessment of the water balance of a Dinaric karst polje (Planinsko Polje, Slovenia) 

    Cyril Mayaud, Blaž Kogovšek, Franci Gabrovšek, Matej Blatnik, Metka Petrič, and Nataša Ravbar

    Poljes are flat closed depressions in karst terrains that are prone to regular flooding. The strongest floods can be several meters high and persist for months, making significant damages in infrastructures. To predict how climate change might affect the occurrence, amplitude and duration of the flood, a better understanding of the flooding dynamics is necessary. Among others, the computation of the water balance is a prerequisite. This method allows assessing when the polje will begin to flood, and gives information on the maximum water level potentially reached. However, this technique encounters the difficulty that a notable part of the inflow entering in poljes is generally ungauged, while it is challenging to quantify the outflow. This is because numerous springs and ponors activate only temporary with the rise of the water level. Moreover, many poljes are generally poorly monitored due to financial reasons. This work aims to see whether these drawbacks can be overcome. To this end, a typical Dinaric polje recharged by a combination of allogenic inflow and a rise of the regional groundwater level is equipped with a network of several measuring stations installed over its surface and in the nearby water-active caves. Combining an accurate Lidar of the surface with recorded water levels and inflow of the main two springs made possible to evaluate the polje flooding dynamics and to characterize its water balance. The method is able to quantify the polje total inflow, while an estimation of the outflow is presented. Then, the main ungauged signals affecting flooding are identified and separated. These values are used as input and calibration data in a numerical model aiming to reproduce the flood dynamics of the polje and its surrounding aquifer. Modelling results validate both water balance and conceptual hydrogeological model, and justify the significance of installing a network of several hydrological stations to monitor the poljes. The method can be applied to other poljes flooding in a complex way of superimposed input and output signals.

    How to cite: Mayaud, C., Kogovšek, B., Gabrovšek, F., Blatnik, M., Petrič, M., and Ravbar, N.: Assessment of the water balance of a Dinaric karst polje (Planinsko Polje, Slovenia), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4866, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4866, 2022.

    EGU22-5149 | Presentations | HS8.2.4

    Possible bias in the assessment of karst hydrological model performance. Example of alpha and beta parameters compensation when using the KGE as performance criterion. 

    Guillaume Cinkus, Naomi Mazzilli, Hervé Jourde, Andreas Wunsch, Tanja Liesch, Nico Goldscheider, Nataša Ravbar, Jaime Fernández-Ortega, Juan Antonio Barberá, Bartolomé Andreo, and Zhao Chen

    Performance criteria such as the mean squared error (MSE), the Nash-Sutcliffe efficiency (NSE) and the Kling-Glupta efficiency (KGE) are extensively used to calibrate hydrological models. In recent years, numerous authors have stressed the inherent limitations of squared-error based criteria such as MSE and NSE. As a result, KGE criterion is gaining in popularity and is being widely used for calibration and for assessment. KGE has been initially proposed to address the poor consideration of discharge variability by NSE, but it also helps to lower the impact of squared errors in highly variable time series. KGE is a combination of (i) the Pearson correlation coefficient (r), (ii) the ratio between simulated and observed means (β), and (iii) the ratio between simulated and observed variances (α). In this study, we used KGE to compare the performance of two karst hydrological models (ANN and LP) over different flow regimes (dry, intermediate, wet) of two karst springs. The considered karst systems exhibit high contrasts in geometrical and hydrodynamic properties, inducing a high variability of the discharge at the springs. The discharge time series were divided into three sub-time series (dry, intermediate, and wet flows) according to fixed thresholds of discharge values. KGE values were higher for LP model for each sub-time series of both karst systems, thus indicating a better performance of LP over ANN at dry, intermediate and wet flows. However, KGE of the whole discharge time series were higher for ANN model, thus indicating a better overall performance of ANN over LP. The analysis of the decomposition of KGE (r, β, α) alongside a visual assessment of the simulated discharges of both models revealed that a compensation bias may be induced by β and α parameters. Simultaneous and equal overestimations and underestimations of multiple parts of the discharge time series seem to favour β and α values, leading to an overall better KGE coefficient without being associated to an increased model relevance.

    How to cite: Cinkus, G., Mazzilli, N., Jourde, H., Wunsch, A., Liesch, T., Goldscheider, N., Ravbar, N., Fernández-Ortega, J., Barberá, J. A., Andreo, B., and Chen, Z.: Possible bias in the assessment of karst hydrological model performance. Example of alpha and beta parameters compensation when using the KGE as performance criterion., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5149, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5149, 2022.

    EGU22-5213 | Presentations | HS8.2.4

    Solute transport in dual conduit structure: effects of aperture and flow rate 

    Chaoqi Wang, Samer Majdalani, Vincent Guinot, and Hervé Jourde

    We built 11 lab-scale dual-conduit structures by varying the apertures of the two conduits and we conduct solute transport experiments consisting of step tracing. We investigated how the transport process can be influenced by the following two factors: flow rate and aperture width of both conduits. We found that, as the flow rate increases, the dual-conduit structures more likely presents a breakthrough curve (BTC) with double-peak effect. When the shorter conduit has smaller aperture than the longer conduit, the dual-conduit structure may lead to either single-peaked BTCs or to dual-peaked BTCs with a much lower early peak. When the shorter conduit has larger aperture than the longer conduit, the dual-conduit structure may lead to double-peaked BTCs or to single-peaked BTCs with a bump on the falling limb.

    We then compared the ability of three different numerical models in fitting the experimental BTCs: Weighted Sum Advection–Dispersion Equation (WSADE), Mobile Immobile Model (MIM), and Dual Region Mobile Immobile Model (DRMIM). MIM does not reproduce the double-peaked or bump-tailed BTCs, but it captures the overall shape of the experimental curves. The WSADE reproduces some of the double-peaked BTCs except the experiment of 4-6, 200 rpm. The DRMIM exhibits better performance than the other two models, and it captures the observed behaviors of all the experimental BTCs: the second peak, the bump, and the tailing. We finally showed that parameter estimation of the DRMIM model can be improved by restricting the contrast between the parameter pairs: um1 and um2, Dm1 and Dm2, k1 and k2, wm1 and wm2.

    How to cite: Wang, C., Majdalani, S., Guinot, V., and Jourde, H.: Solute transport in dual conduit structure: effects of aperture and flow rate, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5213, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5213, 2022.

    EGU22-5229 | Presentations | HS8.2.4

    Comparative study of undissolved and karstified limestone based on microtomography 

    Mariusz Białecki, Rishabh Prakash Sharma, Max P Cooper, and Piotr Szymczak

    We develop methods for qualitative and quantitative assessment of the transformation of pore geometry of a rock as a result of karstification. We then apply these tools to characterize dissolution-induced changes in Miocene limestone samples collected from a quarry located near Smerdyna (Poland), where intense epikarst development is observed, with the formation of hundreds of solution pipes. Partially dissolved samples collected in the immediate vicinity of the pipes are compared with undissolved samples collected several meters away.

    For both types of samples 26 micron resolution grayscale X-ray scans has been performed, and cubical regions of interest of size 506^3 voxels, which corresponds to (13,156 mm)^3, have been studied. Images have been segmented by tuning the grayscale threshold to match the experimentally measured porosity values of respective samples. Additionally, based on the segmented tomograph of undissolved sample another geometry was numerically created in order to mimic a uniform dissolution of the rock up to a porosity value equal to that of the dissolved sample.

    The irregular geometry of the pore space, vast majority of which forms a single connected component, can be conveniently characterized by a local thickness function,  which corresponds to a diameter of the largest sphere that fits within the pore space and contains a given point. A similar measure can be introduced for the solid component (grains). We have compared thickness distributions  of undissolved and dissolved sample as well as numerically generated uniformly dissolved sample. Such a comparison allowed us to quantify the extent of homogeneity of the natural karstification process.

    To further characterize pore geometry, we have calculated the ellipsoid factor, which – based on the axis lengths of the fitted ellipsoids – can be used to characterize how prolate or oblate the pore space locally is. Next, we have used (modified) Flinn diagram to quantify differences between undissolved, numerically eroded and naturally dissolved samples, especially those indicating pore merging and inhomogeneous dissolution.

    The above analysis is complemented by calculation of connectivity density – a topological measure of the degree to which a structure is multiply connected. Values obtained for undissolved, numerically dissolved and naturally dissolved samples indicate on ‘excessive’ reduction of interconnections during natural dissolution, which may be understood on the basis of high degree of pore merging due to inhomogeneous dissolution.

    Both methods: (generalized) thickness analysis and connectivity calculation emphasise the role of merging of pores and inhomogeneous dissolution in the process of natural dissolution for the analyzed  samples.

    How to cite: Białecki, M., Sharma, R. P., Cooper, M. P., and Szymczak, P.: Comparative study of undissolved and karstified limestone based on microtomography, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5229, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5229, 2022.

    EGU22-5444 | Presentations | HS8.2.4

    Dual-domain modeling of discharge dynamics in a laboratory-scale fractured porous matrix system 

    Florian Rüdiger, Marco Dentz, John R. Nimmo, and Jannes Kordilla

    Fracture networks often provide rapid pathways for water infiltration and play an important role for the time-dependent recharge in the vadose zone of consolidated fractured rock and karst formations. Such systems are often conceptualized using a dual-domain approach, since they can be divided into a fracture and a matrix domain. The fracture domain, especially when well connected, provides fast preferential flow paths, whereas the matrix domain usually acts as a storage due to the high contrast in hydraulic conductivities. Under partially saturated conditions, fracture-matrix interactions, i.e., imbibition of water from the fracture system into the matrix, strongly control the fracture flow progression. We conducted infiltration experiments in simple fracture-matrix systems of varying vertical length consisting of sandstone blocks, and use a dual-porosity non-equilibrium model to model the discharge dynamics and the internal fracture-matrix mass exchange. The results show strong deviations from the experimental observations when the original parameterization and model assumptions are not modified. The domain coupling, i.e., the (activated) interface area for fracture-matrix interaction, described by the matrix-fracture volume ratio (κ) was found to be the critical parameter in order to reproduce the data. While the original model assumes a perfectly coupled fracture and matrix domain, in the experiments the discrete nature of the fracture network leads to a much stronger dominance of the rapid flow domain and hence to a reduction of κ. The newly introduced (calibrated) parameter κ* includes additional effects and processes related to the time dependent evolution and smaller dynamic size of the fracture-matrix interface. Furthermore, experiments of varying total vertical system size reveal convergence toward a unique parameter set and the existence of a representative elementary volume (REV) for the chosen setup. Though it performs less well for very small systems below REV scale, the unique parameter set describes discharge dynamics in sufficiently large systems with high accuracy.

    How to cite: Rüdiger, F., Dentz, M., Nimmo, J. R., and Kordilla, J.: Dual-domain modeling of discharge dynamics in a laboratory-scale fractured porous matrix system, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5444, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5444, 2022.

    EGU22-5759 | Presentations | HS8.2.4

    Developing a parsimonious distributed land surface-subsurface hydrological model 

    Hai Liu and Mostaquimur Rahman

    A hydrological model is a simplified representation of the water cycle. A model helps people to understand, predict, and manage water resources. The scope and complexity of the model depend on the modelling goal, availability of required inputs, and computational resources. A wide variety of different hydrologic models exist, which are from simplistic to complex.  Complex models are often computationally very expensive, hampering robust calibration, sensitivity evaluation, and uncertainty analysis. The purpose of this study was to develop a parsimonious distributed land surface-subsurface hydrological model.

    The parsimonious model we are developing is a combination of the land surface model V2Karst and a groundwater model that adopts a two-dimensional representation of groundwater flow. V2Karst is a large-scale model for simulating land surface hydrological processes. . The coupled hydrological model can make the simulation steps clearer and meet the simplifying assumptions in some specific demand situations. The model will be useful for robust model calibration, sensitivity tests, and uncertainty analysis.

    How to cite: Liu, H. and Rahman, M.: Developing a parsimonious distributed land surface-subsurface hydrological model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5759, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5759, 2022.

    EGU22-6036 | Presentations | HS8.2.4

    A Critical Research Gap Study of Sinkhole Hazard Assessments 

    Hedieh Soltanpour, Kamal Serrhini, Jose Serrano, and Gildas Noury

    Karst landscapes are perceived as sensible environments due to soluble rocks (limestone, marble, dolomite, etc.) being the predominant features. The dissolution process in karstic structures poses serious multiple hazards to the communities on which they are built. Sinkholes and ground subsidence are the main geological hazards from these areas causing damage to lives and livelihoods. Meteorological events such as heavy rainfall leading to flooding play an important aggravating factor for these areas which often can collide with the special geological situation resulting in a cascade of hazards (flooding and sinkhole collapse). Consequently, such multi-hazard-forming environments like karst regions present a need to better understand the complex interrelationship of water in the form of flooding and underground cavity collapses. Yet, till the present, our approaches to these hazardous events have been often fragmented and inadequate. Moreover, with climate change having a significant impact on Earth, a change in hydrological processes followed by increasing dissolution of limestone, which may lead to more flooding and sinkhole occurrences, can be predicted in the immediate future. Therefore, research on interrelated hazards will be imperative in order to set priorities for complex natural events. While numerous research works have made attempts to study sinkholes and their contributing factors, to date if not any, few studies have perceived and assessed flooding and sinkhole as a multi-hazard event. Since globally, a shift from single to multi-hazard assessment is being encouraged by international risk communities, the present study is to provide new insight towards flooding and sinkholes assessment emphasising multi-hazard approaches. This critical review aims at understanding the current state of sinkhole-related researches, reviewing grey- and peer-review literature. Afterwards, the studies are classified into seven research themes (Morphology, Flood impacts on karst, Monitoring and prediction, Hazard & risk assessment, Multi-hazard-mapping modelling, Mitigation measure, and Others), demonstrating the more favourite research directions and research gap in the field of sinkhole hazard assessment. The results highlight the importance of the integrated multi-hazard assessment in the areas affected by both flooding and karst hazards and show that so far sinkhole risk assessment (70 articles – 35%) followed by sinkhole morphology (63 articles – 31,5%) have been the most popular research subject within the discipline. This research aids future research to bridge the existing gap towards improving mitigation planning and helping policy and decision-makers in their inclusion of multi-hazard interactions in municipal policies and approaches.

    How to cite: Soltanpour, H., Serrhini, K., Serrano, J., and Noury, G.: A Critical Research Gap Study of Sinkhole Hazard Assessments, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6036, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6036, 2022.

    The South Franconian Alb is a well known karst area in Southern Germany. It comprises mainly of a slightly inclined plateau intersected by a few rivers and numberless dry valleys. Main rocks are limestones and dolomites of Jurassic Age.

    Numerous sinkholes occur within the area. Unfortunately, till now the data collection is fragmentary done for the whole area. Consequently, the sinkhole distribution is incomplete and very heterogenously spread. Nevertheless, to gain insights into the background of sinkhole distribution and the associated geologic, geomorphic and land use conditions the available data were compiled. Different local archives, the available geologic and topographic maps of the South Franconian Alb were searched for sinkhole informations, on the other hand digital elevation models from selected areas were detected for hollow shapes or depressions to estimate the maximum quantity of possible dolines. For all detected objects both verified sinkholes and unclassified depressions the geomorphological environment, cover deposit, host rock, rock facies, stratigraphy and land use were listed.

    First results show great discrepancies for the sinkhole distribution related to land use. More than 90% of the detected objects are located within forests although forested areas cover only 30-50% of the South Franconian Alb. Thus, most of former sinkholes were destroyed by agricultural or other activities. Furthermore, historic mining activities (stone-age chert mining, historic mining pit areas for iron mining, small local quarries) have also changed the sinkhole distribution. Due to such anthropogenic overprinting of the landscape an automatic detection of dolines from digital elevation models requires a very critical assessment.

    Geologically, sinkhole occurrences are closely related to the host rock distribution or rock facies. About 60% of sinkholes are hosted by dolomites, massive reefal or thick-bedded limestones whereas dolines within platy or thin-bedded rocks occur more rare.

     

    How to cite: Trappe, M. and Hein, M.: Relations between geomorphic and geologic framework and sinkhole distribution of the South Franconian Alb, Germany, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6384, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6384, 2022.

    EGU22-7502 | Presentations | HS8.2.4

    Integrated and process-based modeling of flow and transport in multi-compartment karst systems with thick vadose zones 

    Torsten Noffz, Jannes Kordilla, Alireza Kavousi, Thomas Reimann, Rudolf Liedl, and Martin Sauter

    The hydraulic characterization of karst systems remains a high challenge given their heterogeneous nature and large range of hydrogeological properties. In this study, a methodological approach is presented that demonstrates to what extent the temporal variation of spring signals, such as discharge rate, dissolved constituents and water temperature can be employed to characterize the karst system and to differentiate the individual contributions of the different physical compartments, as well as to derive hydraulic properties of the individual compartments by integrated inverse modelling of the spring signals.

    Each compartment – (i) surface zone, (ii) vadose zone, and (iii) phreatic zone – imposes a complex transformation of the input signals (e.g., flow rate, temperature, concentration) that are routed through the whole system. However, numerical approaches to reproduce flow and transport dynamics in karst systems often lack the physical representation of controlling processes (e.g., preferential flow dynamics in the vadose zone) and therefore struggle to provide unique solutions. Therefore, this study aims at the identification of parameter sensitivities and hence reduction of model uncertainty employing an integrated approach for the modeling of karst systems. In test scenarios artificial rain events deal as model input for the Precipitation Runoff Modeling System (PRMS) coupled to a dual-domain type vadose zone and discrete karst conduit network system embedded in a porous matrix within the phreatic zone in order to account for fast and slow flow components in each compartment. In the vadose zone diffuse flow through the porous matrix is modeled by standard bulk effective approaches (MODFLOW UZF or simple transfer functions) and rapid fluxes via preferential flow paths are represented by a source-responsive infiltration model governed by film flow dynamics. In the phreatic zone diffuse and conduit flow are represented by a discrete-continuum model (MODFLOW CFPv2). The model geometry is kept simple (i.e., one model layer and a single conduit connecting a single sinkhole with the spring) while vadose zone properties (e.g., overall thickness) and input signals are altered to focus on their impact on the flow signal and on the sensitivity of parameters.

    How to cite: Noffz, T., Kordilla, J., Kavousi, A., Reimann, T., Liedl, R., and Sauter, M.: Integrated and process-based modeling of flow and transport in multi-compartment karst systems with thick vadose zones, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7502, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7502, 2022.

    EGU22-10622 | Presentations | HS8.2.4

    Quantification of submarine groundwater discharge towards coral reefs around Curaçao, a semi-arid island in the Caribbean. 

    Titus Kruijssen, Mike Wit, Martine van der Ploeg, Boris van Breukelen, Mark Vermeij, and Victor Bense

    Recent studies show that submarine groundwater discharge (SGD) often equals or exceeds riverine inputs into marine environments. Pollution or extraction of groundwater may affect submarine groundwater discharge quality and quantity, impacting marine ecosystems. Most research focuses on relatively humid environments where large amounts of SGD can be expected and detected.

    However, SGD has been poorly studied on smaller (semi-)arid islands, where SGD is relatively hard to detect and quantify. We aim to shine a light on the hydrogeological link between terrestrial processes and coral reef health in the semi-arid Caribbean island Curaçao.

    It is hypothesized that the coral reef around the island is impacted by pollutants from tourism and agriculture. Previous hydrogeological measurements suggest the presence of groundwater fluxes towards the ocean through the karstic geology. However, quantitative data are lacking.

    Groundwater level and quality measurements were conducted at study locations in the various geological settings of the island. Soil infiltration measurements were performed to assess the infiltration capacity of different soil types across the island. Rainfall and groundwater level fluctuations were monitored and used to determine the hydrogeological response after rainfall events. Geophysical ERT surveys have been conducted on different geomorphological settings to assess the hydrogeology and detect preferential flow paths in the karstic geology.

    The field measurements will serve as input for a coupled groundwater-surface hydrology model of Curaçao in MODFLOW. The model outcomes will be used to guide field measurements in the future. These will include tracer tests, surface runoff measurements, marine Radon measurements and offshore geophysics.

    This study is part of the interdisciplinary SEALINK research project, comprising nine PhD projects at different Dutch universities and research institutes.

    How to cite: Kruijssen, T., Wit, M., van der Ploeg, M., van Breukelen, B., Vermeij, M., and Bense, V.: Quantification of submarine groundwater discharge towards coral reefs around Curaçao, a semi-arid island in the Caribbean., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10622, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10622, 2022.

    The rapid growth of agricultural and industrial sectors has led to inappropriate disposal of pesticides and effluents thereby causing massive ammonium contamination of soil and groundwater resources. Contaminant transport is governed by the adsorption mechanism, which varies as the contaminant migrates through different types of soils. It is important to determine the model that best defines the adsorption mechanism of ammonium ions and the factors influencing it to predict and mitigate their contamination. This work focuses on studying the effects of clay content present in the soil on the adsorption and eventually on the retardation of ammonium ions transport through soil media using single- and dual-porosity models. The movement of ammonium ions was analyzed for three soil types with different clay proportions, by column and batch experiments. The experimental results were verified by simulating ammonium migration by numerical modeling using HYDRUS-2D software. It was observed that the ammonium ions adsorption increases with the increase in the clay content of the soil. Therefore, greater content of clay in the soil enhances the attenuation of ammonium migration in the soil media. Further, the dual-porosity model was found to be a significant factor in analyzing ammonium migration where the presence of an immobile phase in the system contributes to the transport and sorption mechanism of ammonium ions into the porous medium.

    Keywords: Clay content, Ammonium ions, Single-porosity, Dual-porosity, Adsorption.

    How to cite: Agarwal, P. and Sharma, P. K.: Analyzing the effects of clay content on ammonium migration in soil using single- and dual-porosity models, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-255, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-255, 2022.

    Groundwater is one of the important water resources in western Taiwan and frequently used to meet water demands for irrigation, aquaculture, household, and public supply. In particular, groundwater nitrate-N pollution typically occurs in many agricultural regions owing to surface agricultural activities. Because numerous environmental factors can affect groundwater nitrate-N pollution, the delineation of extents of groundwater nitrate-N pollution is considerably critical according to auxiliary information of agricultural activities. The purpose of this study was to explore the influence of agricultural activities on estimating spatial distributions of groundwater nitrate-N by using regression kriging (RK) in the Choushui River alluvial fan, Taiwan. First, data on agricultural land use areas, such as crops, paddy fields, dry farmlands, orchards, livestock farming, and agricultural facility, were collected using geographical information system. Moreover, data on groundwater nitrate-N pollution surveyed by the Taiwan Water Resources Agency were determined according to medians of monitoring results between 2013 and 2020. Then, stepwise multiple linear regression (MLR) was used to explore the relationship between groundwater nitrate-N pollution and agricultural activities. Finally, RK was adopted to analyze the residuals between predicted nitrate-N obtained from MLR and observed nitrate-N. The study results indicated that groundwater nitrate-N pollution was positively related with orchard areas and negatively related with areas of agricultural attached facilities and livestock and poultry houses within a circle with a 1000-m radius centering a monitoring well. Moreover, RK estimates showed more spatial variability than ordinary kriging estimates for groundwater nitrate-N pollution because of orchards. To reduce groundwater nitrate-N pollution, feasible strategies of agricultural resources and environmental management are proposed based on the influence of surface agricultural activities on estimating spatial distributions of groundwater nitrate-N.

    How to cite: Jang, C.-S.: Applying the regression kriging method to explore the influence of agricultural activities on estimating spatial distributions of groundwater nitrate-N, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1036, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1036, 2022.

    EGU22-3648 | Presentations | HS8.2.7

    A 3D numerical groundwater model for sustainable groundwater management of the coastal aquifer system of the Arborea plain, Sardinia (Italy) 

    Manon Lincker, Antonio Sessini, Alberto Carletti, Pier Paolo Roggero, George Karatzas, and Gerhard Schäfer

    Coastal areas around the Mediterranean basin concentrate population, multi-sector economic activities and agricultural activities. This induces an important need in fresh water and high solicitation of coastal aquifers, which can lead to salt water intrusion. This issue, added to contaminated surface water percolating towards the aquifer, and along with climate change show the urge for innovative groundwater management, especially in coastal areas. The PRIMA Sustain-COAST European project aims at exploring innovative governance for sustainable coastal groundwater management and pollution reduction in the context of a changing climate by involving researchers, local populations, water stakeholders and policy makers.

    The Arborea plain in Sardinia (Italy) is characterized by an intense agricultural activity based on dairy cattle farming (approximately 31.000 livestock units in the district). The area, reclaimed from a lagoon in the 1920s, is intensely used for fodder crops to feed the cattle. Thus, an important drainage network has been developed to maintain the soil in suitable conditions for agriculture. Heterogeneous nitrates contamination of the aquifer system has been highlighted through soil sampling and groundwater monitoring in the Arborea plain in previous studies and the zone is classified as a Nitrates Vulnerable Zone (following Directive 91/676/CEE). The hydrogeology of the study site is characterized by two main aquifers: the upper one, unconfined, hosted in a sandy unit (SHU), separated from the second aquifer, hosted in an alluvial formation (AHU), by lagoon deposits aquitard.

    In the present study, we show the individual work steps to get from the existing 3D hydrogeological model to a 3D numerical groundwater model using the interactive finite-element simulation system Feflow 7.4. The developed partially unstructured steady-state flow model takes into account the recharge of the aquifer system by surface water, the drainage and irrigation network and the seasonal variation of water volumes drained and spread on the land. Also accounted for are water pumped by farms for technical use and livestock, groundwater flow between the different units and interactions with seawater. Results show the influence of groundwater management, especially for agricultural activities, and interaction with surface water, which is highly impacted by anthropic networks (irrigation and drainage). Ongoing research is aimed at quantifying the spatio-temporal distribution of nitrate in the SHU aquifer under transient groundwater flow conditions to compare different water management, climate change and contamination scenarios.

     

    References

    The project is funded by the General Secretariat for Research and Technology of the Ministry of Development and Investments under the PRIMA Programme. PRIMA is an Art.185 initiative supported and co-funded under Horizon 2020, the European Union’s Programme for Research and Innovation. We also acknowledge funding from the Italian Ministry of University and Research CUP no. J84D18000180005.

     

     

    How to cite: Lincker, M., Sessini, A., Carletti, A., Roggero, P. P., Karatzas, G., and Schäfer, G.: A 3D numerical groundwater model for sustainable groundwater management of the coastal aquifer system of the Arborea plain, Sardinia (Italy), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3648, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3648, 2022.

    Fluid-solid reactions play a key role in a wide range of biogeochemical processes. Transport limitations at the pore scale limit the amount of solute available for reaction, so that reaction rates measured under well-mixed conditions tend to strongly overestimate rates occurring in natural and engineered systems. Although different models have been proposed to capture this phenomenon, linking pore-scale structure, flow heterogeneity, and local reaction kinetics to upscaled effective kinetics remains a challenging problem.

    We present a new theoretical framework to upscale these dynamics based on the chemical continuous time random walk framework. The approach is based on the concept of inter-reaction times, which incur delays compared to well-mixed conditions due to the times between contacts of transported reactants with the solid phase. We consider a simple chemical reaction in order to focus on the effects of transport limitations and medium structure, namely a second-order degradation reaction between a fluid-phase reactant and a solid-phase reactant distributed uniformly over the fluid-solid interface, where only the fluid reactant is consumed. Our formulation quantifies the global kinetics of fluid-reactant mass as it undergoes advection, diffusion, and reaction. Predictions are in agreement with numerical simulations of transport in stratified channel flows and Stokes flow through a beadpack. The theory captures the decrease of effective reaction rates compared to the well-mixed prediction with increasing Damköhler number due to transport limitations.

    How to cite: Aquino, T. and Le Borgne, T.: Upscaling the impact of transport limitations in fluid-solid reactions using a chemical continuous time random walk, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4518, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4518, 2022.

    EGU22-5180 | Presentations | HS8.2.7

    Sharp transition to strongly anomalous transport in unsaturated porous media - Modelling and prediction 

    Andrés Velásquez-Parra, Tomás Aquino, Matthias Willmann, Yves Méheust, Tanguy Le Borgne, and Joaquín Jiménez-Martínez

    Transport processes in unsaturated porous media flows play a key role in a broad range of environmental and industrial systems. The simultaneous presence of liquid and gas in the pore space increases flow heterogeneity and fundamentally alters the observed flow patterns when compared to fully saturated systems. The introduction of the air phase leads to the development of highly structured water flow fields with preferential flow localized on a backbone and flow re-circulation occurring in flow dead-ends. However, it is unclear how saturation controls both flow statistics and transport dynamics. Here we use millifluidic experiments and high-resolution numerical simulations to develop a general theoretical framework that describes this flow re-organisation in the pore space and captures its impact on the statistics of pore-scale velocities. We observe, and predict theoretically, that this previously-identified flow structure of backbone and dead-ends induces both a drastic change in the scaling of the probability density function (PDF) of flow velocities compared to fully saturated conditions, and a sharp transition to strongly anomalous transport. From the theoretically derived velocity PDFs, we successfully predict the dynamics of advective transport for all saturation degrees using a continuous time random walk approach. These findings hence provide a new modelling framework linking flow heterogeneity to parameters that describe the liquid phase heterogeneity within the pore space.

    How to cite: Velásquez-Parra, A., Aquino, T., Willmann, M., Méheust, Y., Le Borgne, T., and Jiménez-Martínez, J.: Sharp transition to strongly anomalous transport in unsaturated porous media - Modelling and prediction, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5180, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5180, 2022.

    EGU22-5385 | Presentations | HS8.2.7

    Effect of hydraulic gradient on the optimal cost of in-situ groundwater bioremediation 

    Tinesh Pathania and T Iype Eldho

    In the recent times, simulation-optimization (S/O) models are used to design the optimal in-situ bioremediation system for groundwater problems with constant hydraulic gradient. In such problems, the main objective is to achieve the maximum allowable contaminant concentration within a selected remediation period at a minimum cost. At a relatively higher hydraulic gradient, the contaminant moves faster towards the monitoring wells near the aquifer boundaries, therefore, in-situ bioremediation cost increases to eliminate the contaminant within the same remediation time. Here, the effect of different hydraulic gradients on the in-situ bioremediation cost of a hypothetical case study is systematically studied. The S/O model linking meshless element-free Galerkin method (EFGM) based BIOEFGM model with the particle swarm optimization (PSO) algorithm, known as BIOEFGM-PSO, is applied to estimate the optimized in-situ bioremediation cost. In this study, the different hydraulic conditions are created by changing the head values at the downstream boundary. The different combinations of injection and extraction wells are also tested to satisfy the water quality constraints for different gradient conditions.  The results of the above S/O model showed that in-situ bioremediation cost increases with an increase in hydraulic gradient, and more wells are required for remediation within the same duration under a higher hydraulic gradient.

    How to cite: Pathania, T. and Eldho, T. I.: Effect of hydraulic gradient on the optimal cost of in-situ groundwater bioremediation, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5385, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5385, 2022.

    EGU22-5492 | Presentations | HS8.2.7

    Spatial Markov-Process Modeling of Solute Dispersion with Log-Normal Velocity Distributions 

    Olaf Arie Cirpka, Marie-Madeleine Stettler, and Marco Dentz

    Spatial Markov processes have become efficient methods to simulate solute transport in heterogeneous formations. The approach follows solute particles from one observation plane to the next, assuming that the particle velocity of an individual travel-distance increment depends on the velocity of the preceding increment. The approach can be seen as a correlated continuous-time random walk with deterministic spatial jumps, or as correlated time-domain random-walk method. The first-order Markov property allows simulating the pre-asymptotic regime with a limited set of rules. The transition of velocities from one step to the next can be formulated by a discrete transition matrix, or approximated with a parametric joint distribution. For the latter, we use the bivariate log-normal distribution. For this distribution, we show that the pdf of the normalized flux-weighted slowness (= inverse velocity) is identical with pdf of the volume-weighted normalized Eulerian velocity. For a flux-weighted injection, we derive analytical expressions of the travel-time variance and associated dispersion coefficient both for discrete travel-time increments and in the continuous limit of infinitesimally small increments over the same distance. The analytical solution reproduces the first-order solution of perturbative methods in the limit of small velocity variances at the limits of small and very large travel distances, but it provides natural extensions for large variances of the log-velocity. In the case of a volume-weighted injection, the mean log-slowness relaxes exponentially to the asymptotic mean, while the variance of log-slowness remains constant. The associated analytical expressions for injection into the volume involve integrals requiring numerical quadrature. We compare the derived expressions with particle-tracking simulations in 3-D heterogeneous media with isotropic exponential covariance function testing variances of log-conductivity up to 5. We observe that the variance of the log-velocity scales linearly with that of log-conductivity and that the integral scale of the log-velocity remains fairly constant. The parameters of the spatial-Markov-process model can be related to parameters of the log-conductivity field with minimal adjustments to first-order results while being applicable to cases of large velocity variability.

    How to cite: Cirpka, O. A., Stettler, M.-M., and Dentz, M.: Spatial Markov-Process Modeling of Solute Dispersion with Log-Normal Velocity Distributions, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5492, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5492, 2022.

    EGU22-6305 | Presentations | HS8.2.7

    Radionuclide transport through fractured chalk under abrupt variations in ionic strength 

    Sari Roded, Ofra Klein-BenDavid, Tuvia Turkeltaub, Emily L. Tran, Yehonatan Geller, Yarden Gerara, Nadya Teutsch, and Noam Weisbrod

    Radionuclide migration through saturated fractured chalk was studied in the context of predicting potential risks to groundwater in the vicinity of nuclear repositories. The aim of the present study was to examine the effect of salinity changes which might result from a sudden rainstorm leading to freshwater infiltration on the mobility of radionuclides in fractured carbonate rocks. A tracer mixture, simulating radioactive contaminants related to spent fuel (SF), including U, Sr, Ce (simulant for redox active actinides) and Re (simulant for Tc) was injected into a naturally fractured chalk rock in the laboratory. Uranine, a fluorescent dye, served as a conservative tracer. Two sets of experiments were carried out in which tracers were added to solutions of different ionic strength (IS) represented by total dissolved solid (TDS) values (Cl- and HCO3- as major anions): (1) low IS artificial rainwater (TDS of ca. 102 mg/L,); and (2) high IS artificial groundwater (TDS of ca. 104 mg/L). In both sets of experiments, the tracer mixture was introduced into a fractured chalk core, followed by the injection of tracer-free solution at the same IS. Next, the opposite (low/high IS) tracer free solution was introduced into the core to induce salinity variation. The behavior of the simulants was investigated under swift changes in background (BG) solution salinity. In all cases, Re breakthrough curves (BTCs) were unaffected by the change in BG solution and exhibit conservative behavior in comparison to that of the Uranine. Cerium was transported as intrinsic colloidal carbonate complexes, in agreement with previous studies, and remained unaffected by the abrupt change in BG solution. Uranium and Strontium BTCs were influenced by the abrupt change in IS, as their recovery significantly increased when high IS solution was injected into the core and reduced when low IS solution is introduced, regardless of the injection order. This indicates that U and Sr sorption to fractured surfaces is enhanced at low salinity, a phenomenon attributed to the replacement of Sr and U ions by Ca and Na at the adsorption sites at elevated IS conditions. The variable mobility of radionuclides found in this study should be considered in the design of natural and engineered barriers for SF disposal, especially in regions where seasonal rains or flooding may cause abrupt changes to groundwater ionic strength.

    How to cite: Roded, S., Klein-BenDavid, O., Turkeltaub, T., Tran, E. L., Geller, Y., Gerara, Y., Teutsch, N., and Weisbrod, N.: Radionuclide transport through fractured chalk under abrupt variations in ionic strength, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6305, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6305, 2022.

    EGU22-6908 | Presentations | HS8.2.7

    The invention of partitioning well pipe to observe solute transport in aquifers: Laboratory sandbox and synthetic studies 

    Bu-Sheng Lee, Jian-Dao Li, Hong-Ru Lin, and Jet-Chau Wen

    According to previous studies, the spatial distribution accuracy of hydrogeological parameters will directly affect the geological assessment and prediction of solute transport in aquifers. In order to describe the heterogeneity of aquifers, Hydraulic conductivity (K) and the specific storage coefficient (Ss) are among the essential hydrogeological parameters as the traditional sampling method consumes construction cost and time. Therefore, the purpose of this study is to design a multi-stage concentric well pipe, which can measure the water level at different depths in a single well pipe. To thoroughly evaluate the delicate characteristics of heterogeneous aquifers, a three-dimensional (3-D) sandbox model will be used to simulate the real underground environment for pumping experiments, and the distribution field of hydrogeological parameters will be estimated by hydraulic tomography (HT). Finally, simulation of the pollution flow direction at the heterogeneous underground field is constructed by VSAFT3. Our study highlights the importance of analyzing the characteristics of groundwater geology parameters by vertical and horizontal. And through the numerical simulation and the real field fitting of the sand box. It is proved that the partitioning well pipe can accurately estimate the 3-D field of hydrogeological parameters and can effectively predict solute transport. This research will significantly contribute to the future analysis of changes in regional flow fields, groundwater replenishment patterns, and control of the diffusion of underground pollution.

    How to cite: Lee, B.-S., Li, J.-D., Lin, H.-R., and Wen, J.-C.: The invention of partitioning well pipe to observe solute transport in aquifers: Laboratory sandbox and synthetic studies, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6908, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6908, 2022.

    EGU22-8299 | Presentations | HS8.2.7

    Uncertainty and Efficiency in geothermal systems in heterogeneous aquifers 

    Antonio Zarlenga, Mariaines Di Dato, Claudia D'Angelo, and Alessandro Casasso

    Shallow geothermal systems represent a unique opportunity for heating and cooling of buildings with green energy and low operational costs.

    Efficiency of  geothermal system is strictly related to the local subsurface flow field that moves water and energy; given the great spatial variability of hydrological and thermal properties in the subsurface environment a reliable assessment of the geothermal system efficiency requires a probabilistic approach that takes into account the uncertainty on the predictions. 

    Homogeneous domain and purely advective flow are typical hypotheses currently adopted in the design of geothermal systems, the aim of our research is to investigate how the variability of thermo-hydrological and engineering parameters impact the different heat transport dynamics and how they result in the GS efficiency.

    The study adopt a Lagrangian description of the heat transport based on the travel time evaluation.

    As application example we consider an open loop system made by a well doublet placed into a confined heterogeneous aquifer of constant thickness.

    The efficiency of the system is evaluated considering lumped parameters, usually adopted in the GS deign, such as the water recirculation ratio or the first breakthrough time and introducing more effective descriptors such as the total breakthrough time curve or the temperature evolution at the abstraction well.

    The analysis suggests that the first breakthrough time, the key parameter adopted in the GS design, decreases with heterogeneity, furthermore, the uncertainty associated with early arrivals increases with heterogeneity. Medium heterogeneity, on the other hand, has a very small impact on the recirculation ratio and on the long-term period, while the pumping rate and other geometrical parameters have a strong impact on its value.

    Since well screens usually cross a short depth we perform a detailed analysis on the uncertainty related to the ergodicity issue. Results of a single realization can significantly differ from its ergodic counterpart. As a practical consequence, a thermal feedback occurring in a heterogeneous medium could significantly differ from the expected theoretical one.

    How to cite: Zarlenga, A., Di Dato, M., D'Angelo, C., and Casasso, A.: Uncertainty and Efficiency in geothermal systems in heterogeneous aquifers, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8299, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8299, 2022.

    EGU22-8607 | Presentations | HS8.2.7

    Regional groundwater funneling within the hyporheic zone 

    Brian Babak Mojarrad, Anders Wörman, and Joakim Riml

    Groundwater-surface water interaction controls the exchange of contaminants, solutes and energy between aquifers and surface water resources. In particular, groundwater contamination and solute transport time is prolonged due to the impact induced by hyporheic fluxes within the streambed sediment. The retention of contaminants and solutes in streambed sediment influence the ecology and biodiversity of hyporheic zone. In this research, a numerical groundwater model was developed and supported with hydrologic and hydrogeological observations of the Krycklan catchment, Sweden, to investigate the impacts of hyporheic flows on the regional groundwater flow direction and discharge areas at the groundwater-surface water interface along stream networks. The applied method involved a multiscale modelling framework where the regional groundwater and hyporheic flows were analyzed via numerical modelling and exact solutions, respectively; and then superimposed to obtain the subsurface flow field. The regional groundwater flow was analyzed in presence and absence of the hyporheic flow and significant changes in groundwater flow trajectories and size of discharge areas were found upon adding the hyporheic flow fields. In particular, the upward groundwater flow was strongly contracted near the streambed surface due to the impact of hyporheic flow, which led to groundwater funneling and an acceleration of groundwater discharge velocities into streams. Consequently, the size of groundwater coherent discharge areas were substantially reduced leading to significantly fragmentation of groundwater discharge zones due to the impact of hyporheic fluxes.

    How to cite: Mojarrad, B. B., Wörman, A., and Riml, J.: Regional groundwater funneling within the hyporheic zone, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8607, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8607, 2022.

    EGU22-9046 | Presentations | HS8.2.7

    An integrated GIS-based pumping-injection control system developed for preventing the spread of NAPL contaminants in a groundwater system 

    Seong-Sun Lee, Inwoo Park, Suh-Ho Lee, Seong-chun Jun, and Kang-Kun Lee

    The objectives of this study are to develop an integrated GIS-based pumping-injection operation system that can hydraulically control the spread of groundwater contaminants and contaminant plumes and to suggest the optimized operation condition that can prevent the spreading of contaminant plume with a hydraulic flow control concept in a short period. Since there are no cases of simultaneously implementing the numerical modeling for groundwater flow and contaminant transport in groundwater monitoring or management systems at contaminated sites, the system developed through this project is an integrated operation system that can implement the numerical modeling of both groundwater flow and contaminant transport on the web and can suggest optimal remediation factors using Simulation-Optimization method. Among various studies associated with groundwater remediation at NAPL contaminated sites, this study performs to suggest cost-effective remediation factors using a simulation-optimization model that takes into account the hydrogeological factors of the contaminated site when performing remedial action by the pumping-injection method. The Genetic Algorithm(GA) code was used for the development of the optimal remediation design algorithm for the pumping-injection system. The developed optimization algorithm was verified through the simplified numerical model simulation considering random contaminant sources. And then this algorithm was applied to actual DNAPL contaminated site. The developed integrated operating system was able to smoothly perform the model for groundwater flow and contaminant transport on the web. In addition, the optimization model related to remedial action operation was well linked to the web operating system to derive optimal operating factors. This work was supported by Korea Environment Industry &Technology Institute (KEITI) through "Activation of remediation technologies by application of multiple tracing techniques for remediation of groundwater in fractured rocks"(Grantnumber:20210024800002/1485017890), "Hydraulic control and containment using pumping-injection system" (SEM projects 2020002470001/1485017133) by the Korea Ministry of Environment(MOE)" and Korea Environment Industry & Technology Institute(KEITI) through the Demand Responsive Water Supply Service Program (RE20191097) funded by the Korea Ministry of Environment (MOE).

     

    How to cite: Lee, S.-S., Park, I., Lee, S.-H., Jun, S., and Lee, K.-K.: An integrated GIS-based pumping-injection control system developed for preventing the spread of NAPL contaminants in a groundwater system, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9046, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9046, 2022.

    EGU22-9574 | Presentations | HS8.2.7

    Modelling Transverse Anomalous Solute Transport in Highly Heterogeneous Porous Media 

    Aronne Dell'Oca and Marco Dentz

    We study the intermittent transverse dynamics of solute transport through highly heterogeneous porous media.  Considering a Lagrangian framework focused on the equidistantly analysis of the particles motion, we identify two fundamental mechanisms that determine large scale particle motion, amely, the relaxation towards an (non-zero) average transverse particle position and the short-scale correlated behavior of the transverse particles motion. Based on these mechanisms, we derive a theory that jointly predicts anomalous transverse and longitudinal dispersion in terms of Eulerian velocity distribution, key statistics of the system heterogeneity and two additional parameters related to the particles relaxation process with a clear physical meaning.

    How to cite: Dell'Oca, A. and Dentz, M.: Modelling Transverse Anomalous Solute Transport in Highly Heterogeneous Porous Media, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9574, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9574, 2022.

    EGU22-9697 | Presentations | HS8.2.7

    Cross-borehole resistivity tomography: Can it be used to plan and monitor in situ remediation and assist risk assessment? 

    Rasmus Thalund-Hansen, Léa Levy, Anders Vest Christiansen, Thue Bording, Kirsten Rügge, Morten Dreyer, Lærke Brabæk Ildvedsen, Mads Troldborg, Maria Hag, Nina Tuxen, and Poul L. Bjerg

    Background

    Evolving In situ methods are showing results for sustainable and efficient plume remediation of groundwater contaminations. By injecting reactive components such as oxidation agents, zero valent iron, substrate and/or bacteria, a treatment zone (TZ) is established. In the TZ, the contamination degrades into harmless components by chemical and/or biological processes. Successful in situ remediation depends on contact between injectants and contamination. Yet, monitoring the spreading of the injectant is difficult by point sampling. The cross-borehole geophysical method DCIP (Direct Current, Induced Polarisation) allows for detailed spatial information on subsurface electrical resistivity and induced polarisation properties. The information can be used to assess the success of the injection and the development over time. Furthermore, the IP properties can be used to infer spatial information on hydraulic conductivity, which can be used in planning of the in situ remediation and in quantification of contaminant mass discharge (CMD) at the site. The objective of this study is to develop a cost-efficient method for detailed spatial and temporal monitoring of in situ remediation and to develop better tools to retrieve spatial subsurface information, able to assist and improve CMD based monitoring.

     

    Approach

    A TZ in a plume of chlorinated ethenes was established by injecting the micro zerovalent iron product and a bacterial culture into the groundwater. A network of 9 geophysical and 16 monitoring wells was established. Cross-borehole DCIP measurements and water samples were taken before and shortly after injection and during the following year. Soil cores were sampled for chemical analysis of iron shortly after injection, and slug tests and grain size analysis. Data from water samples, soil cores and hydraulic tests were compared to the geophysical measurements to assess correlation between water chemistry and electrical resistivity from cross-borehole DCIP. The hydraulic properties inferred from hydraulic tests and cross-borehole DCIP were compared. The hydraulic properties with uncertainties and the contamination data were used to estimate the CMD through the TZ.

     

    Results

    The changes in electrical conductivity and specific water quality parameters caused by the injection, showed a strong correlation with the geophysical model. The observed correlation enabled a coherent, detailed understanding of both spatial and temporal spreading of the injected components, resulting in a re-injection. Hydraulic tests and hydraulic properties inferred from cross borehole DCIP showed a very good correlation, and applying the hydraulic properties inferred from cross borehole DCIP reduced the uncertainty of the CMD estimate before and after injection. In conclusion, cross borehole DCIP has the potential to improve planning and monitoring of in situ groundwater remediation and to reduce uncertainty of CMD estimation and thereby strengthen CMD as a metric in risk assessment.

    How to cite: Thalund-Hansen, R., Levy, L., Christiansen, A. V., Bording, T., Rügge, K., Dreyer, M., Brabæk Ildvedsen, L., Troldborg, M., Hag, M., Tuxen, N., and Bjerg, P. L.: Cross-borehole resistivity tomography: Can it be used to plan and monitor in situ remediation and assist risk assessment?, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9697, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9697, 2022.

    EGU22-11166 | Presentations | HS8.2.7

    Advective trapping in  the flow through composite heterogeneous porous media 

    Juan J. Hidalgo, Insa Neuweiler, and Marco Dentz

    We study the mechanisms of advective trapping in composite porous media that consist of circular inclusions of distributed permeability embedded in a high conductivity matrix. Advective trapping occurs when solute enters low velocity regions in the media. Transport is analyzed in terms of breakthrough curves measured at the outlet of the system. The curve's peak behavior depends on the volume fraction occupied by the inclusions, while the tail behavior depends on the distribution of permeability values. In order to quantify the observed behaviors we derive two equivalent upscaled transport models. First, we  derive a Lagrangian trapping model using the continuous time random walk framework that is parameterized in terms of volume fraction and the distribution of conductivites in the inclusions. Second, we establish a non-local partial differential equation for the mobile solute concentration by volume averaging of the microscale transport equation. We show the equivalence between the two models as well as (first-order) multirate mass transfer models. The upscaled approach, parameterized by medium and flow properties captures all features of the observed solute breakthrough curves, and sheds new light on the modeling of advective trapping in heterogeneous media.

    How to cite: Hidalgo, J. J., Neuweiler, I., and Dentz, M.: Advective trapping in  the flow through composite heterogeneous porous media, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11166, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11166, 2022.

    An improved characterization of pore structure would provide a valuable input for flow and transport models both in the vadose zone or groundwater applications. The idea that the flow of non-Newtonian fluids (such as the aqueous xanthan gum solutions) in the saturated porous media can be utilized to reveal the effective pore size distribution has led to the development of affordable and efficient methods for both laboratory measurement or field infiltration experiments. In both the yield stress method (YSM, e.g. [1]) or, more recently, ANA method (e.g., [2]), the experimental setup ensures that the flow is one-directional, with both the volumetric flux and the hydraulic gradient being independent of the space variable.

    We address the possibility to extend this methodology to the radial flow, such as for example the flow generated in a confined aquifer around an injection well, or in a similar laboratory experiment. Analogously to the capillary bundle framework with a set of effective pore radii equi-present in every representative elementary volume, one can deal with the presence of horizontal layers of different thickness, assuming that each layer is well represented by one characteristic pore size. The extension would then aim to reveal the structure of such layers based on the injection of shear-thinning fluids.

    In contrast to the one-directional flow, both the flux and the hydraulic gradient vary with the radial coordinate. The very principle of both the YSM and ANA methods stems from the fact that the relation between the flux and the gradient for non-Newtonian fluid depends on the effective pore size. The obvious difficulty with the radial flow is that, given the injection rate, different pore sizes lead to different progression of the hydraulic head with the radial coordinate. Two distinct cases may be discussed. First, that the hydraulic head is shared by all present pore sizes. That would be the case of a homogeneous porous material with  multiple pore sizes, or the case of thin alternating layers where the gradient across the layers cannot develop. With the shear-thinning fluid, the distribution of the total volumetric flux across the pore sizes or layers would then vary with the radial variable. In the second case, the layers would be hydraulically separated, leading to a uniform distribution of the flux but a significant hydraulic gradient across the pore sizes or layers (such as in [3]).

    This research is supported by Czech Science Foundation under grant 21-27291S.

    [1] Rodríguez de Castro, A., Agnaou, M., Ahmadi-Sénichault, A., Omari, A., 2020. Numerical porosimetry: Evaluation and comparison of yield stress fluids method, mercury intrusion porosimetry and pore network modelling approaches. Computers and Chemical Engineering 133. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compchemeng.2019.106662

    [2] Hauswirth, S.C., Abou Najm, M.R., Miller, C.T., 2019. Characterization of the Pore Structure of Porous Media Using non-Newtonian Fluids. Water Resources Research 55, 7182–7195. https://doi.org/10.1029/2019WR025044

    [3] Chiapponi, L., Petrolo, D., Lenci, A., Di Federico, V., Longo, S., 2020. Dispersion induced by non-Newtonian gravity flow in a layered fracture or formation. Journal of Fluid Mechanics. https://doi.org/10.1017/jfm.2020.624

    How to cite: Lanzendörfer, M. and Mls, J.: Detecting the pore size distribution or the layered structure based on the radial seepage flow of shear-thinning fluids, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11406, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11406, 2022.

    EGU22-11849 | Presentations | HS8.2.7

    Inferring groundwater response time at regional scale by following a spectral approach 

    Mariaines Di Dato, Timo Houben, and Sabine Attinger

    Groundwater is the main component of river discharge during low-flow periods. The aquifer response to recharge typically depends on the catchment hydro-geological characteristics, such as the hydraulic conductivity, the storage coefficient and the aquifer dimensions. Moreover, such a response time is key to buffer drought propagation during dry periods. As a consequence, it is of paramount importance to evaluate how fast an aquifer will react to an external perturbation. Here, we apply a spectral approach to evaluate the aquifer response time. At the regional scale, the aquifer behaves as a low-pass filter, which modifies the input signal (e.g., the recharge) in the output signal (e.g., the baseflow) according to its properties. For instance, the groundwater response will be faster when the aquifer transmissivity is high or the storage is low. We tested our method across a wide range of German catchments using stream flow datasets. Spectral analysis across catchments of different sizes can provide insight into the spatial aggregation of groundwater response, thereby indicating the scaling rule in large heterogeneous catchments. This approach can help to evaluate the response time in humid regions, which are characterized by frequent interruptions of recession periods. Moreover, response time can serve to quantify the effect of possible external perturbations (climate, irrigation or land management changes) on aquifer resilience.

    How to cite: Di Dato, M., Houben, T., and Attinger, S.: Inferring groundwater response time at regional scale by following a spectral approach, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11849, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11849, 2022.

    EGU22-13452 | Presentations | HS8.2.7

    Analysis of Self-Potential signals due to cable bacteria over different conductivity structures 

    Akanksha Upadhyay, Line Meldgaard Madsen, Anders Vest Christiansen, and Lars Riis Damgaard

    Cable bacteria are multicellular microorganisms that are capable of long distance electron transport (LDET) along their length. This electron transport is the result of oxidation of hydrogen Sulfide (H2S) in the sulfidic sediment layer where electrons are conducted up through cable filament aided by cell-to-cell transfer in the oxic layer thus reducing oxygen by gaining electrons. Cable bacteria behave as dipoles where anaerobic zones interfere with oxic zones for example oil/tar pollution site and can generate enough natural SP fields as a function of redox mechanism that can be measured on the surface. This study focuses on the theoretical analysis of Self-Potential (SP) signals resulting due to the presence of dipole current source under different conductivity structures in the subsurface. To investigate the behavior of SP signals, four different types of forward models are synthesized by varying resistivity of subsurface layers and changing the depth of the dipole beneath the surface. The dipole has a default current density of 20 mA/m2. In the first model, a rectangular pollution patch carrying a dipole of the same shape is placed between two homogeneous layers where the top layer resistivity is swept from 10-1000 ohm-m while keeping the resistivity of bottom layer constant. In the second model, the pollution patch is placed between an inhomogeneous layer with low, intermediate, and high resistivity contrasts and a homogeneous layer. In this model, half of the patch lies in lower conducting region whereas the other part is in the high conductivity region. The third model is an extension of the second one, where the inhomogeneous layer is sandwiched between two homogeneous layers. In the last model, the pollution patch was moved beneath the surface to a depth where the SP signal cannot be observed at the surface. In this model, the depth is observed for three different pollution sources with current density values equal to 2, 20 and 200 mA/m2 respectively. The results showed that SP anomaly caused by the patch when the conductivity of upper layer is high is smaller as compared to the anomaly due to the less conducting upper layer. Next two models with inhomogeneous layer, correlate well with the first model showing high SP anomaly caused by dipole when it is present in the lower conducting region and low values when in high conducting region. Fourth model demonstrates when the depth of pollution patch is increased beneath the surface, SP signal decreases and is not observed beneath a depth of around 10 m, even when the source has current density value as high as 200 mA/m2. This study explicitly demonstrates the behavior of SP anomaly and will help in improved interpretation of SP technique where inhomogeneity will be present beneath the surface.

    How to cite: Upadhyay, A., Madsen, L. M., Christiansen, A. V., and Damgaard, L. R.: Analysis of Self-Potential signals due to cable bacteria over different conductivity structures, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13452, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13452, 2022.

    EGU22-13473 | Presentations | HS8.2.7

    Numerical Analysis of Multispecies Solute Transport through Heterogeneous Porous Media 

    Kumar Rishabh Gupta and Pramod Kumar Sharma

    A numerical approach to the decomposition method for the study of multispecies solute transport through heterogeneous porous media has been proposed. Governing equations of multispecies solute transport have been solved numerically using the implicit finite difference technique. The effect of time-dependent dispersion has been analyzed using exponential time-dependent dispersivity function and the same has been validated with the analytical solution. The study illustrates the solute movement involving sequential first-order decay reactions and the analysis has been carried out in three species nitrification chain and migration of radionuclides as four species. The numerical model is used to simulate the breakthrough curves and the analysis has been done using different decay rate constants. Also, this study has been carried out on the behavior of solute concentration using an increasing macrodispersivity function which accounts for the spatial heterogeneity of porous media. Further, spatial moment analysis has been performed on the concentration of all species and a comparison has been drawn using constant and exponential time-dependent dispersivity function using various breakthrough curves. This analysis revealed that the mean travel distance and variance are sensitive with the change in the dispersivity function and concludes that the solute and its transformed species may not have the same transport pattern.

    How to cite: Gupta, K. R. and Kumar Sharma, P.: Numerical Analysis of Multispecies Solute Transport through Heterogeneous Porous Media, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13473, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13473, 2022.

    As in the rest of the world, the issues of global climate change impact and anthropogenic pressure on fresh drinking groundwater resources are very relevant in Georgia. This is especially important for Georgia, as this country is rich in fresh groundwater resources, but at the same time there are many challenges in terms of sustainable management of this resource.

    Even before climate change trends became obvious, Georgia paid significant attention to groundwater research. Before early 1990’s, continuous hydrogeological monitoring had been carried out in order to protect groundwater resources. Detailed hydrogeological surveys have determined that Georgia’s natural fresh groundwater resources amount to 573 m3/sec and that water has the highest quality. Since then, for more than three decades, no centralized hydrogeological monitoring and groundwater cadaster have been carried out. Meanwhile, demand for fresh water has been steadily increasing, and uncontrolled drilling operations have and are being conducted for groundwater extraction. Failure to comply with environmental safety standards when selecting well construction and drilling works has a negative impact on both quantitative and qualitative characteristics of groundwater resources. Under conditions of improper operation, extraction of water from aquifers above the exploitation norm leads to their dry, impact on nearby water points (including springs), groundwater-related ecosystems, etc. Also, if one well crosses several aquifers, contamination of one of them (primarily a layer near the surface) causes the contaminants to migrate to other aquifers, which were normally considered to be naturally protected.

    To assess the above pressures and to plan appropriate recommendations, the primary activity is monitoring studies. After many years, Georgia has been taking significant efforts since 2013 to restore the national network for fresh groundwater monitoring. LEPL National Environmental Agency (NEA), at the initiative of the Geology Department and with support from the Czech Development Agency (CzDA), has installed modern hydrogeological monitoring equipment on two wells in the Alazani artesian basin. The measure has been followed by gradual connection of water points to the monitoring network, and currently the monitoring covers 66 water points – 60 wells and 6 natural springs. Each well is equipped with a monitoring station, which uses sensors and dataloggers to perform continuous automatic monitoring of main quantitative and qualitative parameters of groundwater regimes (water discharge, level, pressure, temperature, pH, conductivity, TDS). Monitoring of springs is carried out by electronic sensors and data collector ,,Levelogger”. Twice a year, the NEA conducts chemical and bacteriological analysis of water samples from the monitoring water points.

    Surveys conducted in 2013-2021 enabled the specialists of the Geology Department of the National Environment Agency to develop recommendations, which should be implemented in stages to assess the current state of groundwater resources and to use them racionally. In this regard, an informational hydrogeological report was published in 2021 - ,,Assessment of quantitative and qualitative characteristics of Fresh drinking groundwater resources of Georgia (analysis of the current situation, forecast and recommendations)”. The report was sent to all interested organizations - the scientific community and water management policy implementing agencies.

    How to cite: Gaprindashvili, G., Kitiashvili, N., and Gaprindashvili, M.: Fresh groundwater resources of Georgia - Global climate change impact, anthropogenic pressure and activities for sustainable groundwater management, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-193, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-193, 2022.

    EGU22-2725 | Presentations | HS8.2.8

    Systems thinking applied to conceptual urban groundwater model development 

    Charalampos Ntigkakis and Brian Thomas

    Urban groundwater is an often overlooked element of the wider urban water system. Complex interactions between urban groundwater and surface water may be obscured by urban infrastructure and its influence on groundwater flow. Urban groundwater models can be developed to jointly account for groundwater-surface water processes and urban infrastructure. Therefore, they can be used to simulate potential groundwater flooding, and help understand the role of groundwater in urban resilience to climate change. Attempting to capture the inherent complexity of the built environment within a model, however, may lead to increasing model uncertainty. We argue that robust urban groundwater modelling depends on a strong conceptual understanding of the groundwater system, which can lead to achieving the goal of characterising groundwater flooding.

    The aim of this study is to present a conceptual groundwater model of the Ouseburn watershed in Newcastle upon Tyne, UK. The industrial heritage of the watershed, as well as the residual effects of coal mining within the urban fabric present unique challenges in conceptual groundwater model design. These challenges are further increased by the hydrogeological properties of the watershed. To this end, we developed an urban conceptual model to identify various components that synthesise the groundwater system, as well as the interactions between them.  From our conceptual model, we aim to develop a groundwater flow model that is able to capture important system interactions, thus resulting in a robust model framework to understand groundwater flooding controls.

    How to cite: Ntigkakis, C. and Thomas, B.: Systems thinking applied to conceptual urban groundwater model development, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2725, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2725, 2022.

    EGU22-4775 | Presentations | HS8.2.8 | Highlight

    Using anthropogenic gadolinium as a tracer to reduce the risk for contamination of river bank filtration systems 

    Miguel Angel Marazuela, Robert Brünjes, Nathalie Tepe, Giovanni Formentin, Klaus Erlmeier, and Thilo Hofmann

    Drinking water systems providing water to large cities are frequently located in alluvial or fluvio-glacial aquifers because their high permeability allows high extraction rates. Under normal conditions, these systems are recharged by river bank filtration and groundwater is collected at a sufficient distance to ensure that filtration through the aquifer provides water of good quality. However, during flood events, infiltration from the river bank may increase reducing the transit time, which may result in a higher risk of contamination. Identifying the water origin and its path from the river to the water work is key to establish operational strategies that minimize or prevent contamination during flood events. In this study, we investigate the potential of using anthropogenic gadolinium, which is increasingly used as a contrast agent in magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and finally verted into rivers, as a conservative tracer to identify pathways of river bank filtration and then contribute to minimize the uncertainty of numerical models.

    The test site is located in a rural sub-alpine basin. Several horizontal drains extract water from a fluvio-glacial aquifer by gravity. Under normal conditions, good quality water is collected; during flood events, due to the sudden increase in infiltration and decrease in transit times, water quality might deteriorate, as shown by the appearance of E. coli and coliforms. The concentration of anthropogenic gadolinium was measured in the river, in observation wells, and in the extracted drinking water over several years. The results demonstrated the great potential of gadolinium to identify and delineate the infiltration plumes produced by river bank filtration, which is contributing to reduce model uncertainty and evaluate the best pumping strategy for each of the drains in order to prevent water quality degradation.

    How to cite: Marazuela, M. A., Brünjes, R., Tepe, N., Formentin, G., Erlmeier, K., and Hofmann, T.: Using anthropogenic gadolinium as a tracer to reduce the risk for contamination of river bank filtration systems, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4775, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4775, 2022.

    EGU22-5474 | Presentations | HS8.2.8

    ASSET project. Assessing SUDs Efficiency to Reduce Urban Runoff Water Contamination. 

    Laura Scheiber, Marc Teixidó, Rotman Criollo, Francesc Labad, Enric Vázquez-Suñé, and Maria Izquierdo

    Due to the current global change, there is a need looking for improved urban water management. Especially in urban areas, where most of the population is concentrated. These high dense areas require improvements on water quantity and quality, and Barcelona city is not an exception. Barcelona City Council has been studying different water alternatives to achieve the scarcity of the city since 1994. Following these new strategies, groundwater of the city is currently applied for different purposes in the city. Even more, aquifers are strategic water bodies that can be used during scarcity events for water supply ensuring an enough water quality.

    In addition, Barcelona City Council installed different green infrastructures called Sustainable Urban Drainage Systems (SUDs). These installations reduce the extreme runoff events by promoting and facilitating the recharge of the aquifers. The installation of these systems are increasing, but there is a lack of the knowledge and understanding of the quality of the water infiltrated in the aquifer and their effects on the state of the groundwater bodies of the city, which can reduce the current quality of groundwater.

    ASSET is a project funded and awarded by the Barcelona council under the call “Scientific research awards Urban in the Barcelona city”. The goal of this project is to evaluate the SUDs implemented in the city of Barcelona and provide improvements so that these systems are more efficient and fulfil the purpose of said facilities and advance toward an efficient and sustainable use of water, improving the adaptation capacity of the city to the current Climate Change and promoting the use of green infrastructures in their urban plans.

    ASSET project aims to define an approach and set of tools for an integrated urban water management that it will help in the new plans of uses and it will ensure the good state of these resources. ASSET key drivers are: (1) Improve our knowledge on the underlying mechanisms involved and controls on contaminants-water-air interactions in an urban setting, which is crucial to reduce the exposure of environmental receptors; (2) To reduce the impact of the floods due to torrential rains increasing the permeable surfaces in the cities and peak flows that eventually arrives at the network of collectors and consequently to the treatment plant or the receiver; (3) Optimize groundwater quality control by setting out a list of performance indicators; (4)        Promote the reuse of water stored during the rainy season for its use in periods of drought; (5) Provide improved quantitative, mechanistically robust modelling tools to (i)      optimize urban water management in the context of the wider environment in the short term; and (ii) enhance our ability to develop effective strategies to mitigate the potential effects that future climate change may have on urban resources; (6)          Develop a reactive transport model to model the effectiveness of the proposed materials for the retention of contaminants.

    How to cite: Scheiber, L., Teixidó, M., Criollo, R., Labad, F., Vázquez-Suñé, E., and Izquierdo, M.: ASSET project. Assessing SUDs Efficiency to Reduce Urban Runoff Water Contamination., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5474, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5474, 2022.

    EGU22-7595 | Presentations | HS8.2.8

    Occurrence and fate of pharmaceuticals in urban groundwater 

    Anna Jurado, Francesc Labad, Laura Scheiber, Rotman Criollo, Sandra Pérez, and Antoni Ginebreda

    Sustaining healthy living conditions in urban areas is a tremendous challenge in the European Union, and central to this mission is the supplying of freshwater resources. However, rapid urban growth and climate change will negatively impact water resources. Therefore, water shortage is encouraging research into potential alternative freshwater resources such as urban groundwater. Sometimes, urban groundwater is pumped to prevent damage to underground structures. This is the case of the underground parking lot of Sant Adrià del Besòs (Barcelona, NE Spain), where large amounts of urban groundwater are pumped to avoid seepage problems, which are directly poured to the sewage system.  This consideration ponders if this urban groundwater might be used as safe drinking-water because urban aquifers contain a vast array of pollutants such as pharmaceuticals.

    This work investigated the occurrence and fate of more than 100 pharmaceuticals in the shallow aquifer of the Besòs Delta River, which main contamination source is a polluted river that receives discharges from wastewater treatment plants. To this end, river and groundwater samples were collected from February to May 2021 for the analysis of pharmaceuticals using a solid-phase extraction and high pressure liquid chromatography coupled to high resolution mass spectrometric methodology (HPLC-HRMS). Preliminary results showed that, in more than 70% of the samples, several pharmaceuticals such as anticonvulsants, antihypertensives, antibiotics, and antivirals were detected. More precisely, 38 substances were detected in all river samples and 15 were ubiquitous in groundwater samples.  The range of concentrations for all the compounds was between 2 ng/L and up to 880 ng/L. Moreover, the behavior of the compounds along the bank filtration until reach the pumping site, close to the parking lot, suggested that the natural attenuation of the pharmaceuticals likely to adsorption or oxidation-reduction processes occurred, as groundwater sampling points located close to the river presented the highest concentrations for the detected substances.  This observation allows inferring that the pumped urban groundwater could be used for different purposes including drinking water but further studies are required to quantify the coupled processes that control their fate in urban aquifers.

    How to cite: Jurado, A., Labad, F., Scheiber, L., Criollo, R., Pérez, S., and Ginebreda, A.: Occurrence and fate of pharmaceuticals in urban groundwater, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7595, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7595, 2022.

    EGU22-7973 | Presentations | HS8.2.8

    Impact of urban geology on shallow groundwater 

    Ane LaBianca, Jacob Kidmose, Torben O. Sonnenborg, and Karsten Høgh Jensen

    Increasing urbanization and climate-change-related measures have resulted in a growing demand for knowledge of the subsurface beneath cities and urban water management. Yet, knowledge of urban subsurfaces is not well documented and the urban anthropogenic geology's impact on groundwater is poorly understood. This study examines the impact of urban geology on the water balance and the dynamics of shallow groundwater at city-scale.  

    An integrated surface-subsurface hydrological model was developed based on the MIKE SHE code for an urban domain in Odense, Denmark, covering an area of 10 km2. In addition to basic hydrological processes, the model included urban processes in the form of overland drainage based on the degree of paved area, perimeter drains around major buildings, subsurface drainage, leakage from the sewer system, and groundwater abstraction. Three geological models were tested as input to the hydrological model. The hydrological models were run with two different horizontal resolutions, respectively a grid size of 10x10 and 50x50 m. The three geological models varied in complexity and representation of the near-surface urban geology: (1) V0, the base model, represented the layered regional geology beneath the urban area. (2) V1, a revised version of V0, included a representation of subsurface infrastructure; road and railroad base and embankment material, basements, and utility trenches. (3) V2, a revised version of V1, in addition included data from shallow geotechnical boreholes, yielding a representation of local areas with fill material. The urban near-surface geology in V1 and V2 were represented in a voxel model with sand/clay fraction classes. All versions of the hydrological model were calibrated based on the same setup, objective functions, and a calibration dataset consisting of 53 hydraulic head time-series and stream discharge observations within the model domain.

    The results showed that the heterogeneity was smoothened when the hydrological model included a complex near-surface urban geology in a 50x50 m grid size and thus an effect of the urban geology was not reflected in the simulated head or the water balance. Meanwhile, the near-surface complexity in the V1 and V2 models led to a better model performance in terms of mean error and annual amplitude error, when the hydrological model had a 10x10 m grid size, which is closer to the scale of the heterogeneities.

    The study illustrates that the manmade urban geology, in terms of subsurface obstacles and utility trenches, impacts shallow groundwater dynamics and flow paths. Moreover, it documents that it is possible to represent heterogeneous urban geology in a city-scale model, given the data is available. The results suggest that to simulate the effect of urban geology on shallow groundwater the computational grid needs to be of a size that can resolve the main subsurface infrastructures. In conclusion, a representation of the urban near-terrain geology improves the simulation of shallow groundwater and thus provides a better basis for urban planning, water management, and transport modeling.

    How to cite: LaBianca, A., Kidmose, J., O. Sonnenborg, T., and Høgh Jensen, K.: Impact of urban geology on shallow groundwater, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7973, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7973, 2022.

    EGU22-7982 | Presentations | HS8.2.8

    Validation, systematization and support for the implementation of a hydrological and hydrogeological model of the Katari basin and minor Titicaca lake 

    Rotman Criollo, Laura Scheiber, Laura Poza, Sonia Valdivielso, Pedro Simunovic, and Enric Vázquez-Suñé

    The Katari Basin and Minor Lake of Titicaca (Bolivia) is one of the most populated and under pressure basins in the country where approximately 10% of the population lives at the national level (one million inhabitants). Urban development in the basin is rapid and is characterized by poor territorial planning and socio-productive patterns without appropriation in terms of caring for the urban, peri-urban, rural and aquatic environment, which has led, among others, to an accelerated and severe deterioration of water quality throughout the basin. It is for this reason that it is necessary to integrate the management of the productive aspects of the exploitation of its water resources with various environmental and socio-economic aspects of the area.

    This study is within the framework of the "Lake Titicaca Sanitation Program" financed by the Inter-American Development Bank (IDB). The main objective of this program is to contribute to the decontamination of the Katari River basin and MinorTiticaca Lake and generate the necessary conditions to improve the quality of life of the population in this region, which is included in the different actions for the development and implementation of the Katari Basin Master Plan. The Katari Basin Management Unit (UGCK) will be the main beneficiary, which depends directly on the Ministry of Environment and Water (MMAyA) of Bolivia.

    The implementation of a hydrological and hydrogeological model of the Basin would allow us to understand its operation; as well as quantify the general water balance of the Katari Basin and Minor Titicaca Lake. The specific objectives are: (i) Validate the conceptual hydrological model of the Katari basin and minor Titicaca lake; (ii) Update the existing spatial database for later use in the application of the hydrogeological conceptual model of the Katari basin and Minor Titicaca Lake; and (iii) Systematize the conceptual hydrogeological model of the Katari River basin for its integration with the validated surface hydrological model.

    This study has allowed us to analyze the operation model of the Katari aquifers, where all hypotheses and data obtained are justified by consistent calculations. Although the hydrogeological model is considered correct, the information gaps found during the conceptualization process, as well as the results obtained through numerical modeling have shown that it is necessary to go deeper into certain aspects (sampling points inventory, improve hydrochemical monitoring, know the geology in depth in greater detail, among others).

    This conceptual and numerical model, integrating the information available in a single platform, has made it possible to define the evaluation of risks or environmental impacts of the area and provide a frame of reference for other studies or more detailed models.

    How to cite: Criollo, R., Scheiber, L., Poza, L., Valdivielso, S., Simunovic, P., and Vázquez-Suñé, E.: Validation, systematization and support for the implementation of a hydrological and hydrogeological model of the Katari basin and minor Titicaca lake, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7982, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7982, 2022.

    EGU22-8553 | Presentations | HS8.2.8 | Highlight

    Nitrate contamination in the chalk aquifer of the Mons Basin (Belgium), characterization by hydrochemical and isotopic analyses 

    Louis Christiaens, Pascal Goderniaux, Serge Brouyère, and Philippe Orban

    The problem of nitrate contamination of groundwater is twofold. First, this pollutant degrades the quality of the water needed for human consumption and second, in excessive quantities, it disturbs the balance of ecosystems. While discrimination of the origin of this pollutant is a fundamental step in mitigation strategies, the multitude and mixing of nitrate sources generally makes this process difficult.

    The Mesozoic chalk aquifer of the Mons basin (Belgium) covers an area of over 400 km². From a hydrogeological perspective, this aquifer is largely exploited for public water production (50 million m³/year) to answer the local demand but also with significant volume transfers to Brussels city and other regions. Nevertheless, year after year, an increase in nitrate concentration has been observed in several water catchments and is increasingly threatening the sustainability of some production sites. The land-uses in the area are various including fields, pastures, urban areas and industrial sites. Therefore, this diversity creates difficulties in identifying the origin of nitrate and mitigate the pollution. Finally, historical measurements of nitrate concentration in groundwater suggest the presence of denitrification processes along specific interfaces such as confined – unconfined limits.

    The characterisation of the pollution and associated nitrate sources was carried out through multiple sampling campaigns covering the different land use zones and confined/unconfined areas. Classical hydrochemical analyses were performed to define the extent of the nitrate pollution, to locate potential denitrification zones and to highlight correlations with other major ions. In parallel, analyses of the stable isotopes of nitrate (δ15N and δ 18O) and boron (δ 11B)were carried out. These isotopic ratios differ according to the chemical processes in which they were involved and allow to differentiate different sources of nitrate, including mineral or organic fertilisers, household waste degradation in landfills and possible leakage from sewer systems in urban areas.

    The results of the sampling campaigns support some preliminary hypotheses while raising new questions. First, regarding the geographical distribution of nitrate, the agricultural areas in the south and west are the most affected. However, the highest local concentration peaks are generally found in urban areas, in urban zones of near former industrial sites. Furthermore, as expected, nitrate is generally absent from groundwater in confined areas of the aquifer. This observation is reinforced by higher iron concentrations and a lower redox potential in these zones. Regarding nitrate sources, isotope analyses reflect the influence of inorganic fertilisers in the most agricultural areas. At the same time, contamination due to sewage leakage seems to be significant in some specific large areas, also suggesting possible actions to mitigate the pollution.

    How to cite: Christiaens, L., Goderniaux, P., Brouyère, S., and Orban, P.: Nitrate contamination in the chalk aquifer of the Mons Basin (Belgium), characterization by hydrochemical and isotopic analyses, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8553, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8553, 2022.

    EGU22-9068 | Presentations | HS8.2.8

    Development of actionable salt intrusion forecasts 

    Bas Wullems and Albrecht Weerts

    We address the need for improved forecasts of saltwater intrusion in estuaries. Estuaries worldwide face problems with saltwater intrusion, which threatens the freshwater supply for drinking, agriculture and industry. The Rhine-Meuse delta is taken as a case study. This is a complex multi-branched system that is highly influenced by hydraulic management structures. Problems with saltwater intrusion occur regularly in this delta (e.g. 2003, 2005, 2006, 2011, 2013, 2018). These problems are most likely to occur when high sea levels due to storm swell coincide with low river discharge. We aim to provide water managers with better forecasts, so they can take mitigating measures in a timely fashion. Two modelling approaches will be investigated on how they can be applied to forecast salt intrusion on a timescale of days to weeks. These approaches are a machine learning model and several improvements (e.g. parameters, data assimilation, postprocessing) to the existing hydrodynamic SOBEK 1D model forecasts. In both approaches, the probabilistic nature of the input data will be processed to yield a probabilistic forecast of salt intrusion. Finally, we will test the developed models, or a combination thereof, in a scenario analysis of several water management decisions. The aim of this presentation is to exchange ideas on the various methods of (salt intrusion) forecasting, their advantages and limitations, and their application for deriving actionable forecasts.

    How to cite: Wullems, B. and Weerts, A.: Development of actionable salt intrusion forecasts, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9068, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9068, 2022.

    EGU22-9140 | Presentations | HS8.2.8

    On the influence of shallow geothermal energy on the behaviour of contaminants of emerging concern 

    Estanislao Pujades Garnes, Anna Jurado, Laura Scheiber, Marc Teixidó, Rotman Criollo, Victor Vilarrasa, and Enric Vázquez-Suñé

    Pressure over water resources is increasing rapidly as a result of climate change and growing population. In this context, urban aquifers emerge as a valuable resource of fresh-water for cities. However, the quality of urban groundwater is degraded due to the presence of contaminants of emerging concern (CECs) that reach continuously urban aquifers from different recharge sources. The effects of CECs are largely unknown, but it is expected that they pose a risk for human health, soil, plants and animals. CECs are naturally degraded in aquifers and their degradation rates depend on the physico-chemical conditions (i.e., redox conditions and water temperature) of the groundwater, which may vary as a result of anthropogenic activities. Therefore, it is needed to establish the impact of anthropogenic activities on CECs to determine their behaviour under modified and variable physico-chemical conditions and allow the safely use of urban groundwater. One of these anthropogenic activities that potentially modify the physico-chemical conditions is the use of the subsurface to obtain cooling and heating energy through low-enthalpy geothermal energy (LEGE) systems. LEGE is a renewable and carbon-free energy whose utilization is currently growing. Thus, it is expected that in a near future the density of LEGE systems will increase over most cities. Then, our objective is to determine the impact of LEGE systems on the behaviour of CECs.

    We have investigated the behaviour of CECs under the influence of LEGE by means of numerical models and considering different representative scenarios. The results show that the physico-chemical variations induced by LEGE systems modify notably the degradation rates of CECs, and thus, their concentrations on the downgradient side. Our results have significant implications for predicting the behaviour of CECs in urban aquifers and suggest the possibility of specifically design LEGE systems to improve in a passive way the quality of urban groundwater by eliminating CECs.

    How to cite: Pujades Garnes, E., Jurado, A., Scheiber, L., Teixidó, M., Criollo, R., Vilarrasa, V., and Vázquez-Suñé, E.: On the influence of shallow geothermal energy on the behaviour of contaminants of emerging concern, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9140, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9140, 2022.

    EGU22-9958 | Presentations | HS8.2.8 | Highlight

    The CASPER project: an integrated approach for pollution risk assessment in peri-urban groundwater catchment areas 

    Serge Brouyère, Laura Balzani, and Philippe Orban

    In 2020, the European Union has established a recast of the 1998 EU Directive on the quality of water intended for human consumption, hereafter called Drinking Water Directive - DWD. One of the most significant evolutions in this recast is the introduction, through articles 7 of ‘a complete risk-based approach to water safety, covering the whole supply chain from the catchment area, abstraction, treatment, storage and distribution to the point of compliance’. In practice, a 3-level risk assessment and risk management is expected: (1) at the level of the catchment area (article 8), (2) at the level of the water supply systems (article 9) and (3) at the level of the domestic distribution system (article 10). In this context, the CASPER project, funded by SPGE in the Walloon Region of Belgium, aims at developing an integrated approach for the evaluation and management of pollution risks for peri-urban groundwater catchments. The approach, which fully complies with the requirements of the DWD recast, consists of several key components. First, point and diffuse pollution sources are identified in the groundwater catchment area based on a mapping of hazardous activities combined with a specific groundwater monitoring survey aiming at identifying specific tracers of such sources of pollution. In a second step, risks associated to each of the identified source of pollution is estimated based on the measurement of pollutant mass fluxes and mass discharges downgradient these sources. Finally, a groundwater flow and transport model is developed at the scale of the groundwater catchment area, with the aim of evaluating the cumulative effect of the multiple sources on groundwater quality deterioration in the catchment and at the abstraction points. The objective here is to describe the CASPER approach and to illustrate it using ongoing investigations in a peri-urban groundwater catchment exploiting groundwater from a chalk aquifer in Western Belgium.

    How to cite: Brouyère, S., Balzani, L., and Orban, P.: The CASPER project: an integrated approach for pollution risk assessment in peri-urban groundwater catchment areas, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9958, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9958, 2022.

    EGU22-10971 | Presentations | HS8.2.8

    Delineating the coastal saline water intrusion zones using Electrical resistivity tomography (ERT) 

    Prarabdh Tiwari, Rupesh rupesh, and Shashi Prakash Sharma

    Seawater intrusion is a major worldwide environmental issue for coastal groundwater resources. Due to natural & human activities, freshwater aquifers are contaminated with saltwater. In the present study, the Electrical Resistivity survey was carried out in Mandarmani, West Bengal, India, to delineate such saltwater intruded zones. It was observed that in the nearby area, many shallow aquifers (around 30m depth) was affected mainly by the salinity problem. ERT results show the signature of saline clay based on significantly less resistivity value. The probable cause of the high salinity problem in this area is excessive use of groundwater resources, Fish farming, Salt industry & recently, a cyclonic effect was observed. 

    Keywords: Electrical Resistivity Tomography (ERT), aquifers, saline water intrusion.

     

     

     

     

     

    How to cite: Tiwari, P., rupesh, R., and Sharma, S. P.: Delineating the coastal saline water intrusion zones using Electrical resistivity tomography (ERT), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10971, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10971, 2022.

    EGU22-11248 | Presentations | HS8.2.8 | Highlight

    Protection of peri-urban groundwater catchments: a multi-tracer approach for the identification of urban pollution sources 

    Laura Balzani, Philippe Orban, and Serge Brouyère

    Groundwater catchment located in peri-urban areas may be impacted by many pollutants coming from different types of point or diffuse sources such as accidental spills, continuous hidden leaks in drainage networks, old landfills, treated/untreated wastewater and watercourses.

    In the scope of the CASPER project, a new methodological approach has been developed based on field survey and interpretation of the collected data in order to distinguish between the different sources of contamination and mixtures of pollutants. First, the groundwater catchment area corresponding to the land surface perimeter in which abstracted groundwater is recharged is determined and characterised in hydrogeological terms. The possible sources of pollution are identified. In a second step, a groundwater and surface water monitoring survey is established, and water samples are collected focusing on a combination of physicochemical parameters and set of various hydrochemical indicators. In particular, different stable isotopes are considered. The NO3- and B stable isotopes are used to distinguish between inputs linked to urban effluents, agricultural fertilisers and manure. Stable isotopes of SO42- are used to distinguish between sulphide minerals oxidation, sulphur-carbon compounds mineralisation, lixiviation and human pollution. Moreover, the occurrence of specific molecules like pharmaceutical and lifestyle products (carbamazepine, caffeine, etc.) are used as effective tracers of anthropogenic contamination. Microbiological analyses are also undertaken to identify microbial populations associated with specific sources of pollution or specific biochemical reactions occurring in soil and groundwater. The resulting hydrochemical dataset is then processed using multivariate and clustering analyses.

    In this context, the objective here is to describe the methodological approach developed for source identification and to illustrate this using a case study corresponding to a groundwater catchment is a chalk aquifer in Western Belgium.

    How to cite: Balzani, L., Orban, P., and Brouyère, S.: Protection of peri-urban groundwater catchments: a multi-tracer approach for the identification of urban pollution sources, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11248, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11248, 2022.

    EGU22-11353 | Presentations | HS8.2.8

    Hydrochemistry and presence of emerging organic pollutants in groundwater of the urban Barcelona area 

    Diego Schmidlin, Laura Scheiber, Marc Teixidó, Rotman Criollo, and Enric Vázquez-Suñé

    Groundwater is a vital resource for the development of urban areas where the problem focuses on the quantity as well on the quality, which constituted a challenge to be faced, an example of this is the case of Barcelona. Currently, Barcelona groundwater is used for irrigation of parks and gardens and street cleaning due to its poor quality as a source of drinking water, in addition, there are numerous pumping in the city to prevent flooding of underground structures (e.g. subway). Barcelona is a developed city with a high population density. Due to the socio economic, industrial activities and lifestyle of its inhabitants, as is common in urban areas, there has been a progressive deterioration on the quality of its water. Among the pollutants found in these waters, of special interest are the emerging organic contaminants (EOCs), which present a high risk to the aquatic environment and human health. The behavior, spatial distribution and processes that control them in the aquatic environment are still uncertain and most of them are unregulated.

    In this work, the use of classical hydrogeochemical techniques, GIS, univariate, bivariate and multivariate statistical analysis and geostatistical techniques allow to assess, identify and locate the main physicochemical processes that control the composition of this waters considering the inorganic and organic (EOCs) parameters and the correlations between them.

    isotopic analysis of the SO42- molecule, , corroborated the significant contribution of wastewater in the composition of these waters. The analysis of the EOCs showed that the highest concentration of these compounds is located towards the Besòs River. This fact indicate that this would be the main source and of greater magnitude of input of EOCs into the aquifer, while towards the urban area of Barcelona the abundance of EOCs would originate from sewage filtrations, where the input is of a lesser magnitude, this was corroborated with the factorial analysis of the EOCs. The areas with reducing conditions in general showed a higher concentration of these compounds, indicating that most of them would degrade more easily in oxidizing environments.

    The processes and/or contributions identified are: water-rock interaction, water mixing, redox processes, aquifer-river interaction, sewage seepage and infiltration of urban runoff. The high heterogeneity found in the physicochemical parameters and EOCs would denote the complex hydrogeological situation of the system. the abundance of EOCs found in these waters together with the isotopic analysis, would indicate that the main source of recharge for most of this samples should be anthropogenic, mostly wastewater (sewage seepage or aquifer-river interaction).

    How to cite: Schmidlin, D., Scheiber, L., Teixidó, M., Criollo, R., and Vázquez-Suñé, E.: Hydrochemistry and presence of emerging organic pollutants in groundwater of the urban Barcelona area, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11353, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11353, 2022.

    Increasing urbanisation and dependency on groundwater in the coastal regions has increased the vulnerability of the coastal aquifer to seawater intrusion. The objective is to understand the variation in vulnerability to seawater intrusion with response to change in groundwater level in the coastal region of Sankaraparani river basin, located in the southeast coast of India. The hydrogeology of the coastal region of Sankaraparani river basin is comprised of alluvium formation as upper aquifer and sandstone formation as lower aquifer which is separated by clayey formation. Nearly 33 groundwater samples were collected from the different depth in the coastal region during June 2019. The GALDIT index was used to calculate the vulnerability of the coastal aquifer to seawater intrusion using the parameters such as aquifer type, hydraulic conductivity, groundwater level, distance of pumping wells from the sea, impact of seawater intrusion and thickness of aquifer. Based on the GALDIT index, about 3 km2 of the coastal region is highly vulnerable to seawater intrusion, whereas 276 km2 of the coastal region is moderately vulnerable to seawater intrusion during June 2019. The sampling wells located at a distance of less than 500 m are highly vulnerable to seawater intrusion. The variation in vulnerability of coastal aquifer to seawater intrusion is calculated with a decrease and increase in groundwater level. Nearly, 10 km2 of the coastal region is found to be highly vulnerable to seawater intrusion if the groundwater level is decreased by 3 m, while about 350 km2 of the coastal region is moderately vulnerable. The coastal region is predicted to be low vulnerable to seawater intrusion if the groundwater level is increased by 1 m. This indicates that the increase in groundwater level by increasing the groundwater recharge will decrease the impact of seawater intrusion in the coastal aquifers.

    How to cite: Ramesh, R., Vengadesan, M., and Lakshmanan, E.: Variation in vulnerability to seawater intrusion with response to change in groundwater level in the coastal region of Sankaraparani river basin, India, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12370, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12370, 2022.

    EGU22-12636 | Presentations | HS8.2.8 | Highlight

    Occurrence and Removal of Emerging Contaminants in Urban Stormwater Runoff 

    Marc Teixidó, Laura Scheiber, Esther Cruz-Castillo, Rotman Criollo, Nicola Montemurro, Francesc Labad, Sandra Pérez, and Enric Vázquez-Suñé

    Rising populations, exacerbated urbanization, and climate change pose uncertainties on our traditional urban drinking water supplies. Stormwater harvesting schemes could replenish over-drafted groundwater resources, augmenting urban water supplies. However, urban stormwater runoff carries a myriad of dissolved contaminants (e.g., organics, metals, nutrients), which impair receiving water bodies. Moreover, some organic contaminants of urban origin —particularly persistent contaminants of emerging concern (known as CECs), like pesticides, plasticizers, flame retardants, etc.— may not be adequately removed by conventional infiltration treatments.Thus, it is important to fully understand their fate, transport, and effect in the built environment, while designing novel ‒or upgrading conventional‒ treatment systems. First, we have conducted field sampling campaigns to investigate contaminant presence, transport, and source apportionment, during storm events. Preliminary results have confirmed presence of pharmaceuticals (and their corresponding metabolites), pesticides and flame retardants in urban rainwater. Regarding potential treatments prior discharge to both surface and groundwater bodies, we have investigated several passive treatments. To enhance the treatment performance of conventional media, herein we propose sustainable, low-cost and low-energy reactive geomedia. For instance, pyrogenic carbonaceous materials (e.g., biochar) can adsorb trace organic and metal contaminants. We have conducted preliminary laboratory-scale batch experiments to investigate their removal capacities. Our results showed that biochar displayed faster sorption kinetics (<24h) and capacity compared to the other studied materials. Sand, commonly used in infiltration schemes, showed almost no reactivity, highlighting the need to study alternative materials to retain organic and inorganic contaminants from stormwater runoff. 

    How to cite: Teixidó, M., Scheiber, L., Cruz-Castillo, E., Criollo, R., Montemurro, N., Labad, F., Pérez, S., and Vázquez-Suñé, E.: Occurrence and Removal of Emerging Contaminants in Urban Stormwater Runoff, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12636, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12636, 2022.

    Current demographics have projected that Lagos will become the world’s most populated megacity by the year 2100. This rapidly increasing human population has led to rapid depletion of groundwater resources of its highly productive coastal aquifers. The recharge processes and its drivers are yet to be quantified and understood. This challenge prompt the need to estimate the past and present recharge rate and understand the recharge processes in the megacity using WetSpass-M model. Input data such as land cover, DEM, slope, water depth, soil, temperature, precipitation, evapotranspiration, windspeed representing the past three decades (1990 to 2020) were inputted into the model. The findings established the two contrasting trends with recharge rates decreasing from 761mm/yr to 563mm/yr and runoff increasing from 292mm/yr to 400mm/yr. Similar spatial patterns of land use, simulated recharge and runoff were observed in the central area of Lagos. This supports the pressures from urbanization activities in the reduction of infiltrating water expected to recharge the aquifers and increasing runoff waters with potential of creating environmental hazards. The increasing runoff amount at the places near the water bodies serves as source water for Fiver Bank Filtration takeoff of Managed Aquifer Recharge (MAR) that can be captured, treated and stored in aquifers for later use. This when used will reduce the water availability crisis reported and projected in city of Lagos. 

    How to cite: Olabode, O. and Comte, J.-C.: Conceptualization of recharge processes in the world most populous megacity in the past three decades using WetSpass-M Model: lessons and opportunities for Managed Aquifer Recharge (MAR), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12722, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12722, 2022.

    Nitrate (NO3) is the final product of the microbial nitrification process in the subsurface environment and can play a significant factor in potential contamination, causing seasonal hypoxia or eutrophication in the aquatic ecosystem. Excessive nitrogen (N) input by anthropogenic activities is well known as one of the major nitrogen sources such as dissolution of organic or synthetic (NH4+, NO3) fertilizer, leakage of the municipal and industrial landfill, and manure or septic wastewater. This study implemented dual nitrate isotopes approach to investigate the spatial distribution of nitrate contamination and its relative contribution of multiple nitrate sources in Daejeong region, Jeju island, South Korea. A total of 26 groundwater samples were collected from Sangmo, Hamo, and Dongil areas in Daejeong region and their nitrate concentrations were measured. The isotope ratios of N (δ15 NNO3) and O (δ18 ONO3) were analyzed using a denitrifier which converts the dissolved nitrate in the groundwater sample into gaseous nitrous oxide (N2O). The NO3-N concentration above the DWS (drinking water standard, 10 mg/L) was found in 11 out of 19 wells only in Sangmo, while the average NO3-N concentrations of Hamo and Dongil were 2.95 and 2.58 mg/L, respectively. More than 80% of land use in Daejeong region was reported as agricultural farming, and massive synthetic fertilizer usage was expected. However, the δ15 NNO3 ranged from 8.3‰ to 10.2‰, with an average of 9.22‰ and δ18 ONO3 ranged from 3.2 to 6.9‰ with an average of 5.58‰, which are similar values of manure and septic wastewater. Thus, further investigation on land use changes, historical fertilizer consumption and its isotopic shifting in Daejeong region need to be considered for the relative contribution of nitrate sources.

    How to cite: Kim, C., Lee, J., Kim, S., and Yang, M.: Dual isotopes evaluation of nitrate contamination and their relative contribution of multiple sources in Daejeong, Jeju island, South Korea, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1581, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1581, 2022.

    EGU22-1779 | Presentations | HS8.2.9

    The Role of Biofilm on the Fate of Emerging Organic Compounds: Numerical Modelling of Column Experiments 

    Vera Behle, Paula Rodríguez-Escales, and Xavier Sanchez-Vila

    Managed Aquifer Recharge (MAR) is a technology to deal with water stress and water scarcity worldwide. Depending on the origin and degree of prior treatment, the water inflow in MAR facilities contains measurable concentrations of Emerging Organic Compounds (EOCs). Understanding the processes that influence the fate of EOCs in the aquifer is therefore a key point for evaluating and predicting contaminant plumes and risk assessment. Such fate is clearly linked to the presence of biofilms that develop mainly in the first centimeters of the aquifer. Yet, the link between microorganisms, the development of biofilm and the fate of contaminants is not well understood. The spatial distribution into different redox states and thus the taking place of the different redox reactions, which significantly influence the degradation of pollutants as well as the sorption of these substances, is an important point. Sorption takes place in two different phases, the sediment and the biofilm. We have used the results of some conducted column experiments to create a numerical model, with which the processes taking place can be viewed in a differentiated manner and investigated further. The results show that biofilm plays an important role as a sorption phase and should therefore not be neglected when investigating and evaluating the fate of pollutants.

    How to cite: Behle, V., Rodríguez-Escales, P., and Sanchez-Vila, X.: The Role of Biofilm on the Fate of Emerging Organic Compounds: Numerical Modelling of Column Experiments, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1779, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1779, 2022.

    EGU22-2659 | Presentations | HS8.2.9

    Characterization of volcanic deposits along the slopes of Mount Meru, Northern Tanzania: insights into the potential sources and release of fluoride 

    Mary Kisaka, Ines Tomašek, George Bennett, Ceven Shemshanga, Jean-Luc Devidald, Karen Fontijn, Wilson Mahene, Kristine Walraevens, Pierre Delmelle, and Matthieu Kervyn

    A water quality problem exists in populated areas along the flanks of Mt. Meru in northern Tanzania, with excessively high fluoride (F-) concentrations exceeding the WHO drinking water standards (1.5 mg/L). Little is known about the potential sources of F-among the various rocks types forming the Meru aquifers. Nineteen samples (Debris avalanche deposits (DAD n=4), lava flows n=6, brecciated lava n=4, pumice n=2, scoria n=1, ash n=1, carbonitic n=1) representative of the materials covering the slopes of Mt. Meru were characterized for their mineralogical, chemical, and total and water-soluble F- compositions. Mt. Meru is mainly composed of alkaline volcanic rocks of basaltic to phonolitic composition. The total F- analysis indicated that F-occurs in all rock types with a mean value varying per rock type from 0.6 to 3.2 g/kg. The DAD in the east and northwest of Mt.Meru contained the highest amount of F- (mean 3.1±0.17 g/kg), whilst the lava flow samples had the lowest mean value (0.6±0.25 g/kg). Water rock-interaction experiments further revealed the highest release of F- in the analyzed DAD samples, possibly associated with their weathering status that progressively converted the primary minerals into secondary clay-bearing minerals assemblage, and favoring F- release into the interacting water. Unlike DAD, pumice and ash have a moderately high level of total F- (1.76±0.04 g/kg) yet; release a minimal amount of it through leaching. Petrographic observations showed that the analyzed volcanic rocks consist of volcanic glass and rare F--bearing accessory minerals (amphibole, titanite, biotite, and apatite), among others. Using electron microprobe analysis, the F- concentrations were found to be as high as 3- 6.5 g/kg in the glassy groundmass and up to 4 g/kg, 5 g/kg, and 45 g/kg in accessory phases of titanite, amphibole, and fluorapatite, respectively. Comparing the abundance and the composition of the glassy groundmass with the mineral phases, the former harbors most of the total F-content. The findings of leaching experiments are congruent with past water quality which show that, low F- is found in water from lava and tephra-dominated areas at higher altitudes and Mt. Meru west, respectively. This new information could guide future explorations for safer locations to place wells for water consumption. Itcould also be of interest for other East African Rift sectors and similar volcanic settings.

    Keywords: Northern Tanzania, East African Rift, Meru volcano, fluoride contamination, volcanic rocks, leaching

     

    How to cite: Kisaka, M., Tomašek, I., Bennett, G., Shemshanga, C., Devidald, J.-L., Fontijn, K., Mahene, W., Walraevens, K., Delmelle, P., and Kervyn, M.: Characterization of volcanic deposits along the slopes of Mount Meru, Northern Tanzania: insights into the potential sources and release of fluoride, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2659, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2659, 2022.

    EGU22-3693 | Presentations | HS8.2.9

    Mechanisms of in-situ remediation of soil with lead and sulfate contaminants using multiple binder strategies: experimental and numerical studies 

    Yikai Liu, Simone Molinari, Maria Chiara Dalconi, Maurizio Pietro Bellotto, Luca Valentini, Giorgio Ferrari, Roberto Pellay, Gabriella Salviulo, and Gilberto Artioli

    Solidification/stabilization (S/S) is a versatile process used in contaminated soil remediation. The development of green binders and the associated immobilization mechanisms is imperative to the remediation research due to the aggravated carbon/energy footprints of the widely employed ordinary Portland cement (OPC). In this work, a pyrite ash disposal site, where the soil has high lead and sulfates contents, was selected for lab-scale tests and the following in-situ field trials. Traditional binders (OPC and cement III/B) and alternative binders (calcium aluminate cement, mayenite-blast furnace mix, and alkaline-activated blast furnace slag) were preliminarily applied using the high-performance S/S pelletization treatment (HPSS©). Systematic mineralogical and microstructural characterization and pH-dependent leaching tests were applied to investigate the S/S effectiveness of different scenarios. Subsequently, simulations were developed to identify the minerals controlling the leaching behavior of stabilized pellets. Overall, the proposed methodology is a pertinent tool for extrapolating the contaminated soil HPSS© to realistic conditions.

    How to cite: Liu, Y., Molinari, S., Dalconi, M. C., Bellotto, M. P., Valentini, L., Ferrari, G., Pellay, R., Salviulo, G., and Artioli, G.: Mechanisms of in-situ remediation of soil with lead and sulfate contaminants using multiple binder strategies: experimental and numerical studies, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3693, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3693, 2022.

    EGU22-3831 | Presentations | HS8.2.9

    Is it possible to describe the behaviour of per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) and biodegradable precursors using the MACRO model? – Approach and preliminary results. 

    Eva Weidemann, René Lämmer, Thorsten Stahl, Bernd Göckener, Mark Bücking, Jörn Breuer, Janine Kowalczyk, Hildegard Just, Runa S. Boeddinghaus, and Matthias Gassmann

    Per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) are anthropogenic substances, which moved to the scientific focus due to their ubiquity in the environment. Several thousands of individual PFAS are known, which differ in chemical structure as well as in their chemical and physical properties. Due to the huge number of substances, the assessment of their environmental behaviour is challenging. Still, more information about these substances, which are partly already declared PBT (persistent, bioaccumulative and toxic), is needed for risk assessments and remediation.

    The overall aim of this study was to describe the environmental behaviour in soil during leaching of ten different PFAAs (perfluoroalkyl acids), a group of persistent PFAS, and two diPAPs (polyfluoroalkyl phosphate diesters) with physical equations and parameters to gain knowledge about substance-related characteristics. For this purpose, we simulated the leaching of all surveyed PFAAs and of the biodegradable precursors 6:2 diPAP and 8:2 diPAP, which can transform into PFAAs. Soil and percolation data received from two experimental studies, a laboratory soil column study and a field lysimeter study, were used to evaluate the leaching and transformation behaviour using the MACRO model. In both studies the behaviour of diPAPs were simulated, which enables a comparison between natural and unnatural conditions. Modelling results from the laboratory study, in which climate impacts are limited, were used as input for the field study with natural climatic conditions. Parameters used for calibration were substance-related such as the adsorption distribution coefficient (KD). The amount of non-recovered PFAS, which is potentially related to the formation of non-extractable residues (NERs), was described using a first-order degradation equation. The evaluation of simulations was done using the goodness-of-fit function KGE (Kling-Gupta Efficiency) and a fitting score comparing simulated and observed soil and percolation data. Optimisation was done using the caRamel evolutionary algorithm with multi-objectives within the GNU R environment and up to 15,000 runs per substance, which resulted in a pareto front. Results of parameter values were then used to describe their leaching behaviour as transformation products (PFAAs) of diPAPs in two steps: (1) optimisation of leaching and transformation of diPAPs with soil data, (2) simulation of leaching of transformation products using results of PFAA simulations. The preliminary modeling results are promising for simulating the behavior of PFAAs as well as their precursors with MACRO.

    How to cite: Weidemann, E., Lämmer, R., Stahl, T., Göckener, B., Bücking, M., Breuer, J., Kowalczyk, J., Just, H., Boeddinghaus, R. S., and Gassmann, M.: Is it possible to describe the behaviour of per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) and biodegradable precursors using the MACRO model? – Approach and preliminary results., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3831, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3831, 2022.

    EGU22-4348 | Presentations | HS8.2.9

    Effect of size reduction and calcite impurities on the adsorption of arsenic onto a ferric (hydr)oxide-calcite by-product 

    Lidia Fernandez-Rojo, Miquel Rovira, Irene Jubany, and Vicens Martí

    Ferrosorp® Plus (FSP) is a commercial adsorbent obtained from the sludges of drinking water treatment plants, composed of mainly amorphous ferric oxy(hydroxides) and calcite among others impurities. This product is indicated to remove arsenic along with phosphates in water treatments[1]. A novel application can be the in-situ remediation of arsenic polluted aquifers through injection of modified product of a smaller size, allowing higher reactivity and mobility through porous media, as already observed for phosphates[2]. To this end, the original granular product (G-FSP) was sonicated (S-FSP), reducing the size from 0.5-2 mm to 0.001-0.1 mm, and increasing the surface area from 218 m2/g to 233 m2/g, respectively. The only crystalline phase detected with x-ray diffraction (XRD) was calcite, which accounted for 8.3%, as determined by thermogravimetric analysis (TGA).  

    Batch kinetics studies of arsenite and arsenate adsorption on these two materials were evaluated at initial pH 4 and pH 9, the two extremes of pH range application according to the manufacturer. Adsorption equilibrium was reached after ~48 h and the experimental results fitted to a pseudo-second order kinetics model.

    Adsorption isotherms were determined in batch studies at the equilibrium pH (around 9.5) and fitted to a Freundlich model. It was observed that, despite the slight increase on the surface area in the sonicated by-product, the amount of arsenic adsorbed on both material sizes were similar;   the Freundlich constant for granular and sonicated FSP were, respectively, 10.0 and 12.8 mg(1‑1/n)·L(1/n)/g for As(III), and 5.1 and 5.3 mg(1-1/n)·L(1/n)/g for As(V). The adsorbed arsenic concentrations at equilibrium were simulated using the PHREEQC software and the Dzombak and Morel (1992) surface complexation model. Simulations were fitted to reproduce the experimental results and to elucidate the role of calcite and of the released bicarbonate anions on arsenic adsorption onto FSP[3].  

    These experiments provide evidence about the role of the material size and of the calcite on arsenic adsorption, which can be extended to other applications, like aquifers polluted by acid drainage. In this case, the presence of calcite is advantageous as it counteracts acidity while adsorbing arsenic. 

     

    Acknowledgements

    This work received the financial support of the Torres Quevedo (2019) grant number PTQ2019-010503.


    [1] HeGo BIOTEC GmbH, 2015, accessed 09/01/2022, <https://www.ferrosorp.de/english/produkte/ferrosorpplus/index.html>

    [2] Martí, V., Jubany, I., Ribas, D., Benito, J. A., & Ferrer, B. (2021). Improvement of Phosphate Adsorption Kinetics onto Ferric Hydroxide by Size Reduction. Water, 13(11), 1558

    [3] Appelo, C. A. J., Van der Weiden, M. J. J., Tournassat, C., & Charlet, L. (2002). Surface complexation of ferrous iron and carbonate on ferrihydrite and the mobilization of arsenic. Environmental Science & Technology36(14), 3096-3103.

    How to cite: Fernandez-Rojo, L., Rovira, M., Jubany, I., and Martí, V.: Effect of size reduction and calcite impurities on the adsorption of arsenic onto a ferric (hydr)oxide-calcite by-product, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4348, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4348, 2022.

    EGU22-7511 | Presentations | HS8.2.9

    Evaluating the fate of UV filters and transformation products during managed aquifer recharge: the role of reactive barriers, biofilms and varying redox. 

    Sonia Jou-Claus, Paula Rodríguez-Escales, Lurdes Martínez-Landa, M. Silvia Diaz-Cruz, Jesús Carrera, Adrià Sunyer-Caldú, Gerard Quintana, and Cristina Valhondo

    Ultraviolet filters (UVFs) are emerging organic contaminants that are present in personal care (sunscreens and many cosmetics) and numerous industrial products. Among UVFs, the group of benzophenone derivatives are the most used worldwide. Benzophenone-3 (PB-3, oxybenzone) is one of the most common UVF. BP-3 is considered as an endocrine disruptor with estrogenic activity, it is photo-stable, lipophilic and bioaccumulates in different organisms. The widespread use of BP-3 has led to its release into aquatic ecosystems mainly via discharge of wastewater treatment plant effluents. Common sources of water for Managed Aquifer Recharge (MAR) are affected, to some extent, by effluents of wastewater treatment plants and therefore, MAR has been proposed as a potential source of these compounds to the environment. Understanding the fate of UVFs but also of their transformation products (TPs) in MAR is relevant because some of them can be more ecotoxic than the parent compound. We evaluated the fate of selected UVFs and its TPs at different compartments (water, soil and biofilm) in two field pilot scale MAR systems; one of them operated with a permeable reactive barrier based on compost and the other with sand (without reactive barrier). We compared the temporal and spatial evolution of these UVFs before and after a slug injection of lithium acetate, as organic carbon source, in the two MAR systems. Quantification of selected UVFs and TPs showed that the two MAR systems promoted the removal of UVFs. Extended removal was enhanced by the compost reactive barrier, in which lower concentrations of all selected UVFs and TPs were measured. The fact that they were detected and quantified more often sorbed onto the biofilm and organic fraction of sediment than in the aqueous phase suggested that degradation takes place in the two solid compartments.

     

    Acknowledgements

    This work was financially supported by the Catalan Research Project RESTORA (ACA210/18/00040), by the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation through MONOPOLIOS (RTI2018-101990-B-100, MINECO/FEDER) and Project CEX2018-000794-S), as well as the EU project MARADENTRO (PCI2019-103425 and PCI2019-103603). We also thank the Consorci de la Costa Brava Girona (CCBGi) for the unlimited access to the WWTP.

    How to cite: Jou-Claus, S., Rodríguez-Escales, P., Martínez-Landa, L., Diaz-Cruz, M. S., Carrera, J., Sunyer-Caldú, A., Quintana, G., and Valhondo, C.: Evaluating the fate of UV filters and transformation products during managed aquifer recharge: the role of reactive barriers, biofilms and varying redox., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7511, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7511, 2022.

    EGU22-7832 | Presentations | HS8.2.9

    Coupling sorption and biodegradation of Emerging Organic Compounds with geochemical modeling 

    Paula Rodriguez-Escales, Arnau Canelles, and Xavier Sanchez-Vila

    Understanding the fate of Emerging Organic Compounds (EOCs) is quite complex. It depends on several direct processes (e.g. sorption or biodegradation) but also on indirect ones (e.g. reduction oxidation processes, soil-water interaction). For that, modeling is a useful tool to evaluate it. Nevertheless, most of the models in literature are quite simple. Most of them are completely disconnected from the geochemical conditions of the environmental systems and it has been widely proved that both sorption and degradation of EOCs depends on that, specially, on pH and reduction oxidation dynamics. For that, in this work we have evaluated different conceptual models of EOC’s fate in the context of Managed Aquifer Recharge. The tested models were from the simplest one (fully disconnected from the geochemistry) to the more complex one (coupling both EOC’s sorption and biodegradation to the geochemistry). The models were validated with a column experiment, which reproduced the fate five EOC’s (paracetamol, diuron, benzophenone-3, carbamazepine and sulfamethoxazole)  in an infiltration pond with a reactive barriers made up of compost (3 types of columns, 0% of compost, 10% and 50%) (Modrzyński et al., 2021). The EOC’s models were also coupled with a previous geochemical model focused in carbon and nitrogen cycle and validated with the same experiments (Canelles et al., 2021). Our results demonstrate that a better reproduction is achieved when both sorption and biodegradation are coupled with a geochemical reactive transport, specially for systems with a higher presence of organic carbon.   

    This work was financially supported by the Catalan Research Project RESTORA (ACA210/18/00040), by the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation through MONOPOLIOS (RTI2018-101990-B-100, MINECO/FEDER), as well as the EU project MARADENTRO (PCI2019-103425). 

    How to cite: Rodriguez-Escales, P., Canelles, A., and Sanchez-Vila, X.: Coupling sorption and biodegradation of Emerging Organic Compounds with geochemical modeling, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7832, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7832, 2022.

    EGU22-7877 | Presentations | HS8.2.9

    Evaluating the effect of DOC on PFAS sorption to soil and colloidal activated carbon using column tests 

    Georgios Niarchos, Anna Merle Liebenehm-Axmann, Dan Berggren Kleja, Lutz Ahrens, and Fritjof Fagerlund

    Remediation of sites contaminated with per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFASs) is a significant step towards protecting drinking water sources and limiting human exposure. PFAS production and use is increasingly being restricted worldwide with a reduction of point sources; however, legacy plumes are still posing a threat due to the persistence of these chemicals against degradation. One of the most widely applied soil remediation techniques for PFASs is stabilisation, aiming to long-term entrapment of the contaminants with the addition of fixation agents in the subsurface, which prevent their leaching from soil to groundwater. In relation to this, the aim of this study was to identify the leaching behaviour of various PFASs in a treatment scenario using colloidal activated carbon (CAC). The effect of dissolved organic carbon (DOC), one of the major groundwater constituents in Sweden, on sorption was evaluated. Silt loam soil sampled from central Sweden was used, as well as a mixture of the soil with CAC at 0.1% w/w. Spiked artificial groundwater was prepared with a mixture of 21 PFASs, at a total concentration of 1.4 μg mL-1. The sorption of PFASs to the solid phase was investigated using 15 cm long column experiments under saturated conditions, with and without DOC at 10 mg L-1. Non-reactive tracer tests with NaCl were used to evaluate hydrological parameters. The desorption behaviour after treatment was also investigated, by switching the inflow from contaminated to clean water after steady state was achieved. Analysis of the compounds was conducted using ultra performance liquid chromatography coupled with tandem mass spectrometry (UPLC-MS/MS). Preliminary results showed retardation of PFASs with the addition of CAC, primarily for long-chain PFASs, exhibiting a correlation between sorption strength capacity and perfluorocarbon chain length. Some short-chain compounds, like perfluorobutanoate (PFBA) and perfluoropentanoate (PFPeA), exhibited immediate breakthrough. Slightly higher retardation of long-chain PFASs was noticed in the presence of DOC, for both treated and reference soil, indicating a potential increase of adsorption sites. Conversely, short-chain PFASs appeared to be outcompeted by DOC and showed faster breakthrough in its presence. These results indicate that humus content can have variable effect on PFAS sorption to soil and CAC, depending on perfluorocarbon chain length. Further experiments aim to the quantification of the sorption capacity.

    How to cite: Niarchos, G., Liebenehm-Axmann, A. M., Berggren Kleja, D., Ahrens, L., and Fagerlund, F.: Evaluating the effect of DOC on PFAS sorption to soil and colloidal activated carbon using column tests, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7877, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7877, 2022.

    EGU22-8076 | Presentations | HS8.2.9

    Lessons learnt from a field trial of colloidal activated carbon injection to reduce PFAS migration from a contaminated site 

    Fritjof Fagerlund, Georgios Niarchos, Lutz Ahrens, Dan Berggren Kleja, Jonny Bergman, Anna Larsson, Gareth Leonard, Jim Forde, Matilda Schütz, and Henning Persson

    Due to their extreme persistence, often combined with high aqueous mobility, per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) are challenging to remediate and remove from the environment. Stabilisation by activated carbon is a method that can potentially stop or at least reduce the migration of PFAS and limit further spreading to the environment from contaminated hot spots. In the StopPFAS project, the use of sorbents to limit PFAS migration in groundwater has been investigated, including in a field trial of colloidal activated carbon (CAC) injection at a PFAS contaminated site in Arboga, Sweden. After CAC injection at the field site, there was an initial reduction in PFAS concentrations by approximately 72% for a sum of 11 PFAS. This indicates significant reduction, but that there were still flow paths where the PFAS transport was not intercepted by CAC. Later however, the PFAS concentrations rebounded to levels equal or higher than before CAC injection. After the rebound concentrations again declined to lower than before CAC injection. The reduction in PFAS concentrations by sorption is related to the amount of CAC that the PFAS come in contact with. A sorptive barrier application is likely to be less effective if the CAC emplacement is uncertain or does not reach all flow paths, if the contaminant transport is dominated by a few preferential flow channels or if the barrier is bypassed due to changes in flow directions. Furthermore, our laboratory experiments indicate that competition with natural organic matter (NOM) does not have a large net effect on the PFAS sorption to CAC on the site. The most reasonable explanation to the post-CAC-injection changes in downstream PFAS concentrations was deemed to be changes in the groundwater flow direction causing bypass or partial bypass of the injected CAC. It was concluded that the distribution of CAC in the subsurface and the extent to which CAC intercepts the PFAS-transporting groundwater are critical to the reduction in PFAS concentrations leaving the contaminated site. The soil characteristics including texture, heterogeneity and existence of preferential flow channels are important factors for the resulting CAC distribution. In a treatment with CAC to limit PFAS migration the goal is to catch as much as possible of the contaminant transport with the injected CAC. Our results show that complex hydrogeological conditions pose a challenge to this goal. For optimal design and placement of a sorptive CAC barrier, it is essential to have a detailed characterization and understanding of soil conditions, groundwater flow directions, including seasonal variations, and flux-zone locations on the local scale of flow through and around the CAC barrier.

    How to cite: Fagerlund, F., Niarchos, G., Ahrens, L., Berggren Kleja, D., Bergman, J., Larsson, A., Leonard, G., Forde, J., Schütz, M., and Persson, H.: Lessons learnt from a field trial of colloidal activated carbon injection to reduce PFAS migration from a contaminated site, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8076, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8076, 2022.

    EGU22-8720 | Presentations | HS8.2.9

    Role of soil biofilms in the transport processes of emerging organic contaminants: A laboratory experimental study 

    Edinsson Muñoz-Vega, Lucas Spada, Stephan Schulz, and Christoph Schüth

    Over the last two decades there has been a growing interest in the occurrence and fate of emerging organic contaminants (EOCs) in groundwater globally. Managed aquifer recharge (MAR) has been recognized as one of the possible causes of pollution, because of the use of insufficiently or partially treated waters as infiltration source.

    Biofilms are one of the most widely distributed modes of life on Earth, and they drive biogeochemical cycling processes of most elements in water, soil, sediment and subsurface environments. Biofilms are aggregates of microorganisms in which cells are frequently embedded in a self-produced matrix of extracellular polymeric substances (EPS). Biofilms partially cover the underlying material, changing the sorption behavior of the soil surface and giving a proper environment to microorganisms for the degradation of EOCs.

    To understand the role of biofilms in the transport processes of EOCs, we performed batches studies and a set of three saturated column experiments where biofilms were established. Two of the columns were filled with a soil having a high organic content (0.6% organic carbon) and the third one contained the same soil but muffled, to characterize the role of organic matter in the growth of biofilms. The feed water consisted of ten-fold diluted synthetic wastewater (SWW) without EOCs, and in the case of one of the organic columns, sodium azide was spiked to have an abiotic control. The columns were equipped with automated sensors (high resolution oxidation-reduction potential, water pressure and soil pH) to link these variables to biofilm development. Several tracer experiments were run during the duration of the experiments and analysis of major ions, organic carbon and trace elements were performed as well. After hydrogeochemical equilibrium was reached in each column, inflow SWW was spiked with a cocktail of five EOCs in environmental concentrations (µg/L), covering different hydrophobicity, speciation and biodegradability parameters: Carbamazepine, Metoprolol, BP3, Ibuprofen and Diclofenac.  Breakthrough curves of the EOCs were measured, and double porosity models were fitted to compare retardation factors and rates of degradation of each system. Post experiments analysis allowed the determination of the biofilms on each column by means of EPS extraction and quantification. Differences in the transport behavior of most of the compounds were observed between the columns, concluding that biofilms and biological structures can be an important factor in the transport of EOCs in soils.

    How to cite: Muñoz-Vega, E., Spada, L., Schulz, S., and Schüth, C.: Role of soil biofilms in the transport processes of emerging organic contaminants: A laboratory experimental study, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8720, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8720, 2022.

    EGU22-11168 | Presentations | HS8.2.9

    Removal of copper and chromnium from water by mixed matrix membranes loaded with natural inorganic fillers 

    Mustapha Chabane, Khaled Rahoui, Chikh Melkaoui, Benamar Dahmani, and Nacer Ferrah

    Waste water treatment using chemicals reagents are effective but pose serious environmental and health problems.Public demand for renewable and biodegradable products grows with awareness of environmental protection, materials of biological origin appear to offer solutions. In our present work, we have synthetized matrix membranes based on different compositions of granulated actived carbonne (GAC),kaolin,Zinc Oxide (ZnO) and Iron Oxyde (Fe2O3). The membrane samples  were characterized by different analytical methods such as FTIR spectroscopy and XRD .The matrix membranes were tested for the removal of toxic metals such as chromium from aqueous solutions  The experimental test were caried on filtration unit .After each filtration test ,the concentraton of the heavy metals were be determined by analytical method . The rejection rate ratio was calculatad refering to the values of the copper and chromium concentration on Feed and permeate .solutions .The results shows the important contribution of natural inorganic matter on the copper and chromium ions from water.

    How to cite: Chabane, M., Rahoui, K., Melkaoui, C., Dahmani, B., and Ferrah, N.: Removal of copper and chromnium from water by mixed matrix membranes loaded with natural inorganic fillers, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11168, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11168, 2022.

    EGU22-11191 | Presentations | HS8.2.9

    Investigating the behavior and catalytic activity of TiO2 nanomaterials in soil extracts 

    Karolina Solymos, Badam Ariya, Izabella Babcsányi, Andrea Farsang, and Zsolt Pap

    Titanium dioxide nanoparticles (TiO2 NPs) are increasingly used as photocatalysts, or as additives in personal care products, paints or food packaging, owing to their specific and individual properties. TiO2 NPs can enter the environment through corrosion and degradation of end-of-life products and surfaces bearing these entities. Additionally, the agricultural application of sewage sludge, presumed to be the primary sink for engineered TiO2 through the treatment of wastewater, has become a widespread fertilizing practice. The primary environmental medium receiving unwanted TiO2NPs as pollutants is the soil environment. Hence, studying the behavior and interactions of such NPs with the soil and the soil solution is a prerequisite for apprehending the ecological risk related to such emerging pollutants. The interactions of TiO2 NPs with the soil solution and solid phases -adsorption, aggregation, dissolution and sedimentation- are governed by the physicochemical characteristics of the nanoparticles (size, shape, surface properties, crystal structures) as well as the properties of the soil (pH, salt and organic matter contents).

                Our study focuses on performing laboratory experiments in soil extracts, as model soil solutions, of a neutral phaeozem, an acidic regosol and a solonetz (pH>9) with engineered TiO2 NPs: 89% anatase (20-25 nm) and 11% rutile (50 nm), pure rutile and pure anatase. The goal is twofold i) investigating the changes of the photocatalytic activity of TiO2 NPsfollowing their interactions with the different soil solutions, and ii) studying the degradation of the dissolved natural organic material in the soil solution due to the addition of TiO2 catalysts. Three different types of soils have been selected for the experiments displaying variable pH and salt contents (acidic and neutral soils with low salt contents, and alkaline soils with high salt contents) to examine the effect of the pH, ionic strength and salt concentrations in the soil extracts on the outcome of the experiments. The reacted NPs will be characterized by SEM for potential changes in the particle morphology, XRD for analyzing the changes induced in its crystal structure, and IR spectroscopy for examining the changes occurred on the surface of the NPs (adsorption of organic molecules from the soil solution, changes in hydrophylicity) and DRS (changes in their optical properties). The photocatalytic activity following NP interactions with the soil solutions will be evaluated by monitoring phenol degradation in a reactor. The impact of the TiO2 NPs on the degradation of natural organic matter will be assessed by total organic carbon measurements. Our preliminary results show that depending on the crystal structure of the applied TiO2 NP, the pH of the soil solution may significantly change and there are visible changes of the NPs' properties. These results will promote our understanding of potential environmental risks related to engineered nanoparticles released into soils and groundwater.

    How to cite: Solymos, K., Ariya, B., Babcsányi, I., Farsang, A., and Pap, Z.: Investigating the behavior and catalytic activity of TiO2 nanomaterials in soil extracts, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11191, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11191, 2022.

    Evidence of pesticides leaching due to intense rainfall events was found in two wellhead protection areas (WHPAs) located in the wine-growing areas of the Veneto piedmont area, in Italy. In this territory, the extensive agricultural activities related to the Prosecco production are developed often using pesticides-based vine protection practices. In the same area, numerous wells extract from the phreatic aquifers the drinking water needs of most of the province of Treviso, rising concern on the possibility of groundwater contamination from pesticides and risks for human health. Further experimental surveys – infiltration tests and soil samplings – were developed in the same WHPAs to study the spatial variability of the chemical-physical properties of the soil governing the pesticides leaching. The experimental data collected on areas of 2 hectares comprising both vineyards and non-agricultural areas, highlighted a larger variability of the soil properties inside the vineyards. Moreover, soil infiltration capacity, assumed in our case as the main property governing the pesticide leaching capacity, showed values up to one order of magnitude higher within the areas destined to wine-growing activities than the non-agricultural ones. This information, obtained at the local and at the field scale, were included in a geospatial analysis related to the distribution of vine-specific pesticides at the scale of the Treviso province, to obtain a vulnerability map for all the wells located in area. The geospatial analysis, developed in a geographical information system (GIS), is based on the sale data of pesticides for agricultural activities - also referred to as plant protection products (PPPs) – registered in the province in the period 2012-2019. The units of PPPs (kilograms or liters) collected at the municipal scale (the province of Treviso counts 94 municipalities) were analyzed by: i) identification of the vine-specific products based on the local guidelines for the vine-protection practices, ii) hazard classification of the vine-specific PPPs based on the CLP pictograms and statements (Classification, Labelling and Packaging Regulation, EC/1272/2008). This information, combined with the extension of the wine-growing areas from land use geographical data (Corine Land Cover 2018), allowed to outline, by assuming the use of the PPP in the municipality of sale, a map showing the hazard level of the wine-growing areas. The geospatial analysis based on the level of superimposition obtained between the extension of the wellhead protection areas and the wine-growing areas, led to a vulnerability map for wells. The map, resulting from the definition in different scenarios of the WHPAs extensions based on a geometrical criterion and the PPPs-based hazard of the vineyards, gives a clear picture of the wells that require PPPs-specific actions to minimize the risk for the quality of the water supplied for human consumption. 

    How to cite: Costa, L. and Salandin, P.: Vulnerability of wells supplying drinking water and use of pesticides in wine-growing areas: the Treviso province case study, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11391, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11391, 2022.

    EGU22-12154 | Presentations | HS8.2.9

    A Novel Cellulose Acetate Fouling-Resistant Ultrafiltration Membranes for Heavy Metal Remediation 

    Claudia Ursino, Sergio Santoro, Ibtissem Ounifi, Amor Hafiane, and Alberto Figoli

    Water contamination by traces of heavy metals is a global issue causing serious environmental and health concerns and, as a consequence, an increasing of demand for water remediation technologies. Nowadays, membranes, defined as a selective barrier that permit the separation of molecules or ions in a liquid by a combination of sieving and diffusion mechanisms, have more attention due to their several advantages. In particular, ultrafiltration (UF) is a well-established membrane technology for purification of contaminated water bodies enabling an efficient and cost-saving low-pressure filtration. However, UF membranes possesses a pore size ranging from 20 nm to 0.1 µm, ineffective in rejecting small molecules and ions, such as heavy metals. In this work, a new generation of antifouling UF membranes able to heavy metals remediation has been developed [1]. Specifically, poly (acrylic acid) (PAA) as ideal complexing agent for heavy metals, was blended with cellulose acetate (CA), polymer extensively studied in UF membranes preparation. The novel membranes were prepared via non solvent-induced phase separation (NIPS). These new membranes combine the use of carboxyl group of the PAA that allowing one to efficiently adsorb or chelate heavy metal ions with the processability/biocompatibility/hydrophilicity of the CA. The membranes were produced varying the PAA concentration from 0 to 15wt. %. The homogeneity of the blend was evaluated via differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) and Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy (FTIR). Mitigation of the fouling phenomena and the improvement of the efficiency of the CA membrane on heavy metal rejection was studied and evaluated. The experiments results revealed the important advantages of the blend, since CA/PAA membranes showed superior performance with respect to the neat CA membrane, in terms of: (i) water permeability (20% higher than the neat CA membrane); (ii) Cd rejection (83% at pH 6.5); and (iii) antifouling resistance to humic acid (HA) (R% of 99.9 and 95.3% of flux recovery ratio FRR).

     

    [1] I. Ounifi, Y. Guesmi, C. Ursino, S. Santoro, S. Mahfoudhi, A. Figoli, E. Ferjanie, A. Hafiane, Antifouling Membranes Based on Cellulose Acetate (CA) Blended with Poly(acrylic acid) for Heavy Metal Remediation, Appl. Sci. 2021, 11, 4354. https://doi.org/10.3390/app11104354

    How to cite: Ursino, C., Santoro, S., Ounifi, I., Hafiane, A., and Figoli, A.: A Novel Cellulose Acetate Fouling-Resistant Ultrafiltration Membranes for Heavy Metal Remediation, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12154, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12154, 2022.

    EGU22-12751 | Presentations | HS8.2.9

    Large-scale tank experiments simulating soil aquifer treatment – Assessing the attenuation potential of emerging organic compounds and nutrients during managed aquifer recharge 

    Marcel Horovitz, Edinsson Muñoz-Vega, Teresa Leitão, Christoph Schüth, and Stephan Schulz

    Managed aquifer recharge (MAR) via infiltration basins to replenish aquifers is an important part of the integrated water resource management (IWRM) toolbox. Soil aquifer treatment managed aquifer recharge (SAT-MAR) basins are used to improve water quality during infiltration. However, SAT-MAR can also pose the risk of contaminating the aquifer, by infiltrating treated wastewater effluent, which may still contain high concentrations of e.g., nutrients (N and P) and emerging organic compounds (EOCs), e.g., pharmaceuticals. In order to assess these potential risks and to be able to take measures, it is important to understand the SAT-MAR system. In this context, it is necessary to study the degradation and sorption capacity of natural conditions as well as modified regimes, e.g., by incorporating reactive layers. While laboratory column experiments are widely used and provide detailed process understanding under controlled conditions, transferring the results to field size and conditions remains challenging. On the other end, in-situ field experiments give great insights into real systems while they often study only one SAT-MAR site under distinct environmental settings which hinders to transfer knowledge to other sites. One way to bridge this gap between the two scales is through large tank experiments. However, there are few such large tank experiments in research on MAR that seek to combine the representativeness of in-situ experiments with the controlled characteristics of laboratory column studies.

    Therefore, we designed and conducted a large-scale tank experiment consisting of three tank replicates for the purpose of analyzing SAT infiltration basins using treated wastewater effluent under controlled conditions. The three tanks are packed with fine sand and comprise a vadose zone as well as a saturated zone. The vadose zone of two tanks incorporates a mixed layer of biochar/fine sand as reactive layer, while the third tank consists solely of fine sand and acts as reference. The tanks are equipped with various sensors (high resolution oxidation-reduction potential, water pressure, soil moisture content, electrical conductivity, water pressure, and temperature). To be able to measure the concentration of solutes along the flow path, several suction cups and small-diameter wells allow sampling in the vadose zone and saturated zone, respectively. The infiltrating water in this study is treated wastewater while the groundwater flowing continuously in the lower part of the tank consists of local groundwater. A set of six EOCs (carbamazepine, diclofenac, ibuprofen, naproxen, gemfibrozil, and triclosan) act as model substances as they cover a wide range of physicochemical parameters and degradation potentials.

    Preliminary results are presented on the influence of operational regimes and reactive barriers on the attenuation of EOCs, as well as on nutrients, dissolved organic carbon, and major ions in both the vadose zone and groundwater.

    Acknowledgement: This work is presented within the framework of the project MARSoluT (www.marsolut-itn.eu), a four-year Marie Skłodowska-Curie Actions (MSCA) Innovative Training Network (ITN) funded by the European Commission (Grant Agreement 814066).

    How to cite: Horovitz, M., Muñoz-Vega, E., Leitão, T., Schüth, C., and Schulz, S.: Large-scale tank experiments simulating soil aquifer treatment – Assessing the attenuation potential of emerging organic compounds and nutrients during managed aquifer recharge, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12751, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12751, 2022.

    EGU22-848 | Presentations | HS8.2.10 | Highlight

    Mapping groundwater salinity in the arid region of the Horn of Africa 

    Dahyann Araya*1, Joel Podgorski1, and Michael Berg1

    Salinization is one of the main threats to groundwater quality around the world, particularly in arid and semi-arid regions (IPCC, 2007). Some of the major causes of high salinity include natural geological conditions, seawater intrusion, climate change affecting patterns of precipitation and evaporation, overexploitation of groundwater and poor irrigation practices (Amer and Vengosh, 2001; Russ et al., 2020). Salinity can reduce the availability of water for humans and wildlife and can negatively impact crop productivity and promote desertification. Desert regions in Somalia, Ethiopia and Kenya have natural characteristics that favour high salinity in groundwater. 80% of the population in the region depends on groundwater (UNICEF, 2020), and 69% of groundwater sources have salinity levels above the WHO health-based drinking water guideline of 1500 µS/cm.

    Here, we use machine learning to spatially predict patterns of high salinity with a dataset of 6300 groundwater quality measurements and various environmental predictors. More than 60 predictor variables were tested and 100 iterations of the random forest were performed. Most of the salinity data were clustered, which can lead to sampling issues due to spatial autocorrelation (SAC). As traditional non-spatial validation methods ignore SAC in the data and therefore do not guarantee independence between training and testing data, we instead use spatial cross-validation to address this spatial phenomenon as well as variograms to identify the extent of autocorrelation among variables. Preliminary results indicate that fractured ancient marine deposits, recharge, precipitation, evaporation and proximity to the ocean are the main factors related to high salinity levels. The model performs well with a combined overall accuracy of ~80% and an Area Under the Curve (AUC) of 0.80. Predictive spatial maps of groundwater salinity will be presented along with an analysis of the drivers of salinity.

    Figure 1. Topographic map of the study area and salinity concentration represented by electrical conductivity (EC).

    How to cite: Araya*1, D., Podgorski1, J., and Berg1, M.: Mapping groundwater salinity in the arid region of the Horn of Africa, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-848, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-848, 2022.

    EGU22-1649 | Presentations | HS8.2.10

    Correlation between groundwater levels and meteorological indicators in the coastal karst aquifer of Salento (Southern Italy) 

    Maria Rosaria Alfio, Gabriella Balacco, and Maria Dolores Fidelibus

    In many regions of the Mediterranean basin, both climate variability and human pressure threaten groundwater quality and quantity. Uncertainties concerning future precipitation, temperature patterns, and water accessibility provide a challenge in understanding how groundwater reacts to the variability of the hydrological forces. This aspect is of fundamental interest for water resources planning and management, especially in those areas where groundwater is the main water source. The proposed research looks for correlations between meteorological drought indexes and groundwater levels (GWLs) to provide qualitative information about GWLs response to precipitation and temperatures changes. The GWLs time series refer to nine monitoring wells located in the coastal karst aquifer of Salento (Puglia, Southern Italy). The aquifer is challenging because of the highly complex geological, geomorphological, and hydrogeological structure and regional size. In such complex environment and under climate changes, a high and unrestricted exploitation for irrigation, industrial, and drinking purposes may deteriorate the qualitative and quantitative status of groundwater. Such features often prevent the recognition with sophisticated methods of the relationship between hydrological and hydrogeological time series, especially under data scarcity. Searching for these relationships, three correlation coefficients were applied at different time scales, with reference to the period between July 2007 and December 2011, between the SPI (Standardized Precipitation Index) and SPEI (Standardized Precipitation and Evapotranspiration Index) and GWLs time series. Results of the three coefficients outline a positive and statistically significant correlation between time series, generally for long time scales, highlighting the slow response of GWLs to precipitation. Despite the complexity of the aquifer, it linearly reacts to precipitation and temperature variability in the long term, acting as a low-pass filter with a notable inertial behavior in response to meteorological events. The aquifer response is different compared to dry and recharge periods. In most cases, the decreasing GWL courses agree with the dry SPI and SPEI ones, while the increasing GWL courses are less congruent during wet periods. This characteristic reveals crucial in defining correct measures of protection and safeguard of groundwater resources during periods of meteorological drought.

    Results suggest that the selected approaches are worthy of interest for those areas characterized by severe stress conditions due to long drought periods and under excessive groundwater exploitations, demonstrating the generality of their applicability also under data scarcity.

    How to cite: Alfio, M. R., Balacco, G., and Fidelibus, M. D.: Correlation between groundwater levels and meteorological indicators in the coastal karst aquifer of Salento (Southern Italy), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1649, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1649, 2022.

    EGU22-4544 | Presentations | HS8.2.10

    Temporal evolution of transition zone by EC depth profiles (Salento karst coastal aquifer, Southern Italy) 

    Alessandro Parisi, Gabriella Balacco, and Maria Dolores Fidelibus

    In coastal aquifers, many factors, including sea-level oscillations, cyclic flow, aquifer geologic structure, hydraulic properties of the aquifer, seawater density, variation in groundwater recharge, and human activities that involve groundwater exploitation influence the 3D spatial distribution of salt content of groundwater. Its changes over time under the natural and human forcing locally reflect on the width and elevation of the mixing (transition) zone, with different response times compared to applied stresses depending on the aquifer size and hydrogeological features at the monitoring sites.

    Groundwater depth profiles of EC in coastal aquifers allow identifying the features of the transition zone. Reliable information on the EC vertical distribution comes only from wells reaching saltwater beneath freshwater, with screens along with the entire aquifer thickness and crossing zones of prevalent horizontal flow with negligible vertical components.

    The study shows the temporal evolution of transition zones reconstructed from combining periodical EC depth profiles carried out over five decades in a few special deep wells. Such wells pertain to the regional net for groundwater monitoring of the Salento karst coastal aquifer (Southern Italy). The aquifer coincides with the geological basement of the Salento Peninsula, which is a carbonate formation of the Upper Cretaceous–Palaeocene. It comprises layers and banks of fractured and karstified limestone and dolomitic limestone. Gentle folds and normal and strike-slip faults dislocate the basement. Groundwater flows in phreatic conditions with max hydraulic heads around 3 m AMSL and low hydraulic gradients. It may be locally in confined conditions because of low permeability carbonate levels or when the carbonate basement top is below mean sea level. Hydraulic conductivity is highly anisotropic because of the combination of major and minor discontinuities and surface and subsurface karst features, thus conditioning the groundwater flow. Lateral seawater intrusion and saltwater up-coning cause diffuse and progressive groundwater salinization from the 1960s because of over-exploitation.

    Starting from an initial well net of deep wells set in the 1970s to monitor groundwater salinization, the number of deep wells changed over time. Some of the oldest wells are no longer operational because of obstruction, while others are more recent. As a consequence, the available EC depth profiles cover, for each well, different periods from 1974 to 2021. The evolution of EC vertical distributions allows recognizing the effects of climate variations (wet periods and droughts) that influence the hydrodynamics of the aquifer and unveiling critical transitions triggered by such extremes. Data evolution allows clarifying the system’s response to long-term exploitation in a more effective and comprehensive way than the only variations in groundwater levels. Because of the regional scale of the flow system, the high natural storage, and high groundwater residence times, this response shows lags compared to disturbances (as exploitation, recharge variability, droughts). The significant storage acts as a buffer, allowing cushioning from their adverse effects. Over time, the transition zone deforms with distinct upward expansion leading, in the most severe cases, to the disappearance of the freshwater of low salinity observed in the wells in the 1970s.

    How to cite: Parisi, A., Balacco, G., and Fidelibus, M. D.: Temporal evolution of transition zone by EC depth profiles (Salento karst coastal aquifer, Southern Italy), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4544, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4544, 2022.

    EGU22-4894 | Presentations | HS8.2.10

    Spatial-temporal dynamics of salinity profiles measured in the freshwater lens system of the Malta Mean Sea Level Aquifer (MSLA) 

    Francesco Demichele, Manuel Sapiano, Julian Mamo, Ivan Portoghese, and Schembri Michael

    The Mean Sea Level Aquifer (MSLA) of the island of Malta is a freshwater lens system sustained in a carbonate formation, floating on seawater in the bedrock. Given the specific hydrogeological and climatic conditions, the water table today reaches its maximum elevation at around 3 m amsl at the centre of the 316 Km2 island, with a maximum thickness of freshwater lens being about 90 m. Seawater intrusion occurs as an unavoidable effect of groundwater abstraction and the situation is further exacerbated during the dry summer period when water demands are higher.

    Groundwater plays a major role in meeting the water demand of the Maltese islands and in this regard, is a strategic resource which needs to be preserved in terms of quality and quantity. It is therefore critically important to have an accurate understanding of the volume of fresh groundwater stored in the aquifer and how it is changing in response to changes in recharge, withdrawal and climatic regimes, to support an effective management which ensures the sustainability of this resource.

    The status of fresh groundwater in the MSLA is assessed through vertical profiles of salinity along the water column of Deep Monitor Boreholes (DMBs) which penetrate partly or entirely through the brackish-water transition zone that separates freshwater from the underlying higher density seawater in freshwater lens systems. Salinity profiles were measured using a multiparametric probe (SEBA HYDROMETRIE KLL-Q-2 with MPS-D8 probe) lowered from the water table till the bottom of the DMBs measuring electrical conductivity (as a proxy for salinity), temperature, pressure and pH in three DMBs on a weekly basis over one year during the wet seasons.

    The monitoring of salinity profiles over time in these DMBs allowed the detection of typical patterns of fresh/sea-water interface fluctuations according to the occurrence of external driving forces like precipitation and/or local abstraction.  The profiles were correlated with aquifer characteristics such as, fractures and orientation of strata in the DMBs which were determined through high resolution images captured with an optical televiewer probe (MOUNT SOPRIS QL40-OBI-2G).

    The results show that the thickness of the transition zone varies in the DMBs according to the succession of dry and wet periods with maximum fluctuations of about 8 m. Furthermore, the interface depth results about 32 times the freshwater head inferring a deviation from the standard Ghyben-Herzberg coefficient of 40 for sharp interfaces. By analysing local geological conditions and time-series of total rainfall, groundwater abstraction, piezometric levels and salinity profiles, we identified occurrence mechanisms of three typical transition zones: (i) sharp interface, (ii) diffused interface, and (iii) step-like changes of salinity with depth. These types of interfaces, which are rather recurrent in space and time, lead us to gain a clearer understanding of the seawater intrusion dynamics triggered by variable abstraction conditions and drought periods.

    The outcomes of this study illustrate the value of DMBs in establishing an effective monitoring framework for island groundwater bodies status, since the development of the transition zone is an important factor for managing freshwater abstraction from near-coastal and island aquifer systems.

    How to cite: Demichele, F., Sapiano, M., Mamo, J., Portoghese, I., and Michael, S.: Spatial-temporal dynamics of salinity profiles measured in the freshwater lens system of the Malta Mean Sea Level Aquifer (MSLA), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4894, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4894, 2022.

    EGU22-4975 | Presentations | HS8.2.10

    Using continuous resistivity profiling (CRP) method to identify electrical resistivity variations related to FSGD areas. 

    Jose Tur-Piedra, Albert Folch, Pilar Queralt, Alex Marcuello, and Juanjo Ledo

    The characterization of fresh submarine groundwater discharge (FSGD) in coastal aquifers has been the object of study in many investigations due to the importance of water as a strategic resource for populations. However, investigating processes that occur in the part of the aquifer located under the sea entails greater difficulties. 
    The objective of this study has been to characterize FSGD in the coastal alluvial aquifer of Maresme, located 40 km north of the city of Barcelona. To study the marine part of the aquifer with good spatial resolution, the geophysical method of continuous resistivity profiling (CRP) has been chosen. Marine profiles, parallel and perpendicular to the coastline, have been done using a boat in a shallow water area to obtain electrical resistivity data of the seabed covering 3 km2. Data acquisition has been carried out in two field campaigns, one in the dry season and another in the wet season. 
    From the results obtained, it has been possible to observe different electrical resistivity values in marine sediments along the coast. These variations have also been identified between the two campaigns, being the wet season the one with the highest electrical resistivity values. This study shows that CRP is a non-invasive method that allows the detection of resistive zones of marine sediment that have been related to preferential discharge areas.

    Acknowledgments
    This work was partly funded by the Spanish Government (grant no. PID2019-110212RB-C22) and the project TerraMar (grant no. ACA210/18/00007) of the Catalan Water Agency.

    How to cite: Tur-Piedra, J., Folch, A., Queralt, P., Marcuello, A., and Ledo, J.: Using continuous resistivity profiling (CRP) method to identify electrical resistivity variations related to FSGD areas., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4975, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4975, 2022.

    EGU22-5294 | Presentations | HS8.2.10

    Spatiotemporal assessment of multi-sourced groundwater salinization in a coastal aquifer (Rhodope, Northern Greece) 

    Evangelos Tziritis, Katerina Sachsamanoglou, Vassilios Aschonitis, Paschalis Dalampakis, Charalampos Doulgeris, Andreas Panagopoulos, Vassilios Pisinaras, Vicky Kinigopoulou, and Ioannis Vrouhakis

    The coastal aquifer of the Rhodope region (NE Greece) is a complex groundwater system impacted by various processes that increase groundwater salinization (seawater intrusion, trapped saline lenses, geothermal fluid impact, irrigation return). In the context of the MEDSAL Project (www.medsal.net), a thorough study of its hydrogeochemical characteristics was performed to assess the spatiotemporal variations of groundwater salinization and identify the dynamics of the phenomenon.

    To this aim, we used a combination of tools, including multivariate statistics analysis (MVSA) and hydrogeochemical modelling, to decipher the mechanism(s) of groundwater salinization and their evolution in time and space.

    Results from Hierarchical Cluster Analysis (HCA) classified water samples into four (4) diverse groups and seven (7) subgroups that denote different hydrogeochemical and salinization phases. The different processes that control hydrogeochemistry were further assessed using R-mode factor analysis. The outcomes outlined three (3) factors that supplemented the HCA. The dominant factor is related to the cascading processes of salinization, and the secondary factors are related to anthropogenic contamination (N surplus due to agricultural activities) and the impact from the substrate (water-rock interaction).

    Hydrogeochemical modelling further supported assessments and provided an overview of the spatiotemporal variability of factors and processes affecting groundwater chemistry. A set of saturation indices of key minerals related to the dominant processes identified by the MVSA were calculated and interpolated to capture the spatiotemporal dynamics. Results facilitated the development of a more representative conceptual model about salinization and the key hydrogeochemical processes affecting water quality in the area.

    How to cite: Tziritis, E., Sachsamanoglou, K., Aschonitis, V., Dalampakis, P., Doulgeris, C., Panagopoulos, A., Pisinaras, V., Kinigopoulou, V., and Vrouhakis, I.: Spatiotemporal assessment of multi-sourced groundwater salinization in a coastal aquifer (Rhodope, Northern Greece), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5294, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5294, 2022.

    EGU22-5404 | Presentations | HS8.2.10

    Salt groundwater use for industrial purposes in compliance with the equilibrium between freshwater and saltwater 

    Vito Specchio, Alessandro Parisi, and Alberto Ferruccio Piccinni

    Studies on groundwater salinity stratification interested an area under a semi-arid climate located within an industrial zone in the Taranto Province (South-Eastern Italy). Fresh groundwater circulates in a Mesozoic carbonate coastal aquifer affected by salinization due to saltwater mixing. A clay formation along the coast prevents direct contact with present seawater. 
    The area is home to many companies of national and international importance that require water for their processes. The solution is to use locally available saltwater, considered a nonvaluable resource, because of the lack of surface water and use restrictions of good quality fresh groundwater. 
    The study covers the area of a company that uses its domain for both quarry and landfill activities. Because fresh groundwater resources are protected, the law authorizes the company to exploit only salt groundwater to humidify the pet-coke or lope piles stored in the landfills. The moistening is intended to avoid the atmospheric dispersion of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons.
    In the study area, with ground-level elevations around 50 m AMSL, the water table is above 2.5 m AMSL. A borehole had to reach a depth of 300 m to locate saltwater. Prospecting during drilling, including temperature and EC logs, allowed the reconstruction of the saline stratification. The elevation of saltwater top and the thickness and position of the transition zone make such stratification differ from that expected from the usual simplified laws describing the balance between fresh and salt waters in coastal aquifers. The recognized density stratification likely depends on the aquifer boundary conditions (included fresh groundwater exploitation rate), tectonic assets, and karst development. Further research may provide useful information on disturbances to fresh and salt water equilibrium that may result from direct pumping of salt water.  

    How to cite: Specchio, V., Parisi, A., and Piccinni, A. F.: Salt groundwater use for industrial purposes in compliance with the equilibrium between freshwater and saltwater, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5404, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5404, 2022.

    EGU22-7658 | Presentations | HS8.2.10

    Prediction of saltwater intrusion’ dynamics in coastal aquifer using modeling techniques: a case study in Northeastern Tunisia 

    Soumaya Aouiti, Fadoua Hamzaoui–Azaza, and Mounira Zammouri

    The groundwater, which present 30.1% of the global freshwater, is at risk of being contaminated by saltwater intrusion. The saltwater intrusion is the induced flow of seawater into freshwater aquifers. Saltwater intrusion can occur due to natural processes as well as over-abstraction of groundwater from coastal aquifers. Numerical modelling is a useful tool in helping hydrologists to understand and predict how saltwater intrusion occurs in coastal aquifers. These numerical models are based on the governing equations of groundwater flow and contaminant transport.

     In this paper, the extension of saltwater intrusion into the coastal aquifers, of the Bouficha region, has been investigated by modelling using SEAWAT in MODFLOW. The abstraction from the Bouficha groundwater had increased more than fourfold between 1993 and 2021. Numerical groundwater modelling is a powerful tool for evaluation, development and management of groundwater resources of this basin. A numerical groundwater model for Bouficha groundwater was developed using MODFLOW software (pm8) to simulate regional groundwater changes in the Bouficha groundwater under steady and transient state. The flow model was calibrated based on 29-years historical period.

    For controlling the quality of Bouficha groundwater, and as the Bouficha groundwater is a costal aquifer, a transport model related to salinity was developed using SEAWAT package, in MODFLOW, based on historical salinity data of 28-years. The transport model was successfully calibrated in the steady and transient state.

    The transport model was applied to examine how far the seawater transition zone will moved based on five future scenarios (pumping and climate change). The five flow scenarios were used to predict the salinity distribution in the Bouficha groundwater, using SEAWAT package, by extended the transport model until 2050.

    The scenarios results indicate the total deterioration of the Bouficha groundwater’s quality. The predicted salinity shows that the Bouficha groundwater will be in critical status.

    The sources of the Bouficha groundwater quality degradation are multiple: the seawater intrusion from the sea and from the Sebkha and a chloride input from agricultural activities (as transport boundary conditions).

    How to cite: Aouiti, S., Hamzaoui–Azaza, F., and Zammouri, M.: Prediction of saltwater intrusion’ dynamics in coastal aquifer using modeling techniques: a case study in Northeastern Tunisia, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7658, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7658, 2022.

    EGU22-8124 | Presentations | HS8.2.10 | Highlight

    Forecasting electrical conductivity of a coastal karstic aquifer with artificial intelligence methods 

    Vassilios Pisinaras, Aikaterini Nikolaidiou, Theodoros Semertzidis, Petros Daras, Gabriella Balacco, Maria Dolores Fidelibus, and Evangelos Tziritis

    Groundwater resources are inevitably considered as the primary source of high-quality water for the Mediterranean region. In critical cases, groundwater is essential to complement inadequate, uncertain, expensive, or even lacking surface-water sources. Especially in coastal areas of the Mediterranean, which show increasing development and population growth, karst aquifers represent vital freshwater sources. Karst aquifers are rather complex water systems, and therefore, though to manage, predict, and protect. Groundwater modeling has proved to be a very effective tool for groundwater management. Physically-based modeling is usually applicable to porous aquifers; numerical modeling application to karst aquifers is very challenging because of their complexity, which combines discontinuity, conduit, and porous medium domains. The need to forecast groundwater quantity and quality in karst aquifer systems is high, with groundwater salinity being very critical. Artificial Intelligence (AI) algorithms have been proved to be an effective alternative in simulating groundwater quality and quantity variables. This study aims to develop and test the performance of 6 AI algorithms to forecast groundwater electrical conductivity (EC) in the highly complex, coastal karst aquifer system of Salento (Puglia, Southern Italy). The AI algorithms applied were: 1) Multilayer Perceptron (MLP), 2) Long short-term memory (LSTM), 3) Bidirectional LSTM (BiLSTM), 4) Convolutional Neural Network (CNN), 5) Recurrent Neural Networks (RNN), and 6) Support Vector Machine (SVR). Except for SVR, which is considered a machine learning (ML) algorithm, all the other approaches are deep learning (DL) neural network architectures. Models’ development was based on 3-year groundwater EC daily data from 7 sensors. Other variables used for EC modeling were groundwater level and temperature, precipitation, and air temperature. The above variables were combined in 11 input variable experiments. In addition, various realizations of training times windows were developed under five scenarios. The total number of trained EC models was 2184. The results show AI models can efficiently provide a 30-day groundwater EC forecast for a wide range of EC values varying from slightly saline (0.7-2 mS/cm) to very saline (25-45 mS/cm). BiLSTM proved to be the most effective algorithm, while the least but still effective algorithm was SVR, thus showing the superior performance of DL algorithms compared to legacy ML approaches. Experimental results showed that increasing the number of input variables did not improve the performance of models. In contrast, including 2-time windows for training (one short-term and one long-term) increased it.

    How to cite: Pisinaras, V., Nikolaidiou, A., Semertzidis, T., Daras, P., Balacco, G., Fidelibus, M. D., and Tziritis, E.: Forecasting electrical conductivity of a coastal karstic aquifer with artificial intelligence methods, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8124, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8124, 2022.

    EGU22-9666 | Presentations | HS8.2.10

    Review of application of geostatistical techniques to groundwater salinization problems 

    Constantinos F. Panagiotou, Phaedon Kyriakidis, and Evangelos Tziritis

    Groundwater salinization is a complex and dynamic process often related to multiple causes, such as seawater intrusion, soil salinization associated with water irrigation, and geogenic factors such as evaporate dissolution. Consequently, a reliable assessment of salinization risks depends heavily on the ability of statistical methods to accurately capture the spatial variability and interrelation among salinization indicators. Geostatistical methods are often used to identify and map salinization-affected regions, investigate how salinization indicators influence groundwater mechanisms, and eventually design optimal groundwater management policies.

    In the context of the MEDSAL Project (www.medsal.net), this study reviews the recent key applications of geostatistical methods to address problems relevant to groundwater salinization. The basic principles of geostatistics are briefly described, and several studies are discussed that employ geostatistical and multivariate tools for identifying salinization sources, clarifying the relationship among salinization indicators and groundwater processes, and facilitating uncertainty propagation in physically-based models of the groundwater systems affected by salinization.

    The literature review identifies most used methods and offers several recommendations in terms of future directions and challenges on the role of geostatistics for improved mapping of the spatial and/or spatiotemporal distribution of geochemical data related to salinization. These recommendations include the integration of geostatistics and machine learning methods for improved understanding and modeling of groundwater salinization processes, as well as the application of modern geostatistical simulation algorithms, accounting for diverse information sources, for exploring parameter uncertainty in spatially distributed hydrogeochemical models.

    How to cite: Panagiotou, C. F., Kyriakidis, P., and Tziritis, E.: Review of application of geostatistical techniques to groundwater salinization problems, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9666, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9666, 2022.

    EGU22-10559 | Presentations | HS8.2.10

    Saltwater intrusion modelling for the safeguard of crop production in the Mediterranean 

    Anna Botto, Matteo Camporese, and Paolo Salandin

    In coastal aquifers seawater intrusion is a worldwide problem caused by natural processes but significantly worsened by aquifer overexploitation for irrigation and drinking water supply, land subsidence, sea level rise and climate changes, which contribute to the reduction of groundwater natural recharge.

    Seawater intrusion represents a relevant environmental issue along the coastal aquifers of the Mediterranean Sea, including the coast south of the Venice Lagoon, a peculiar ecosystem characterized by a fragile equilibrium between reclamation and irrigation activities, whereby salinization is significantly reducing the annual local crop production of about the 25% on average.

    Here, we present the test case of Ca’ Bianca, located near the city of Chioggia - Italy. A numerical flow and transport model has been set up with SEAWAT, aimed at reproducing the complex saltwater intrusion dynamics in the area. To pursue this goal, real field water table and concentration measurements are combined to aid in the calibration and validation of the model. Particular attention is devoted to the evaluation of the dynamics and uncertainty associated with seawater levels, an essential forcing of the model. Then, mitigation strategies, such as drains supplying freshwater in the first layer of soil, are simulated to test their effectiveness against the saltwater intrusion in a way that their application can be reproduced also in other sites affected by the same phenomenon.

    Results show a good match between the simulations and the data, with errors of about 10 cm for the water table, which is acceptable if we consider the scale of the project and its topographical and stratigraphical uncertainties. Even though matching observed concentrations proved to be more difficult, the model realistically reproduces the saltwater spatio-temporal behaviour. The comparison between the scenarios with and without mitigation strategies shows that, in the latter case, significant enhancement in crop production can be achieved.

    As a future development, climate change effects on the sea levels will be considered and predictive scenarios will be developed and quantitatively analysed.

    How to cite: Botto, A., Camporese, M., and Salandin, P.: Saltwater intrusion modelling for the safeguard of crop production in the Mediterranean, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10559, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10559, 2022.

    EGU22-11480 | Presentations | HS8.2.10

    Accounting for hydrological controls when clustering groundwater quality data 

    Phaedon Kyriakidis, Constantinos Panagiotou, and Evangelos Tziritis

    Groundwater salinization occurs when high concentrations of water-soluble salts are present in groundwater systems and is regarded as one of the most worldwide, severe, and complex phenomena affecting coastal aquifers. Salinization might occur, for example, from: (i) from marine sources via seawater intrusion, seawater ingression, (ii) underground or terrestrial sources (e.g., natural soils and rocks through the dissolution of soluble minerals), and (iii) salt and saline fluids from anthropogenic activities.

    The analysis of salinization-related data by multivariate statistical methods is often undertaken in the context of efficient groundwater management. For example, clustering algorithms are used to delineate hydrogeohemically distinct water classes, whereas dimensionality-reduction algorithms are being used to decipher underlying natural and anthropogenic influences responsible for these distinct water classes. However, most of these algorithms do not explicitly account for spatial information and/or constraints, which can often have a significant impact on the classification of groundwater quality samples.  In the context of the MEDSAL Project (www.medsal.net), such spatial effects are incorporated in the clustering procedure via the inclusion of pertinent hydrological attributes, namely, hydraulic head and conductivity data, along with pair-wise distances between sample locations.

    The application of the proposed spatially explicit clustering approach is illustrated using groundwater quality samples collected from the Rhodope coastal aquifer, located at north-eastern Greece. Sampling locations were grouped into four hydrogeochemically distinct water classes using k-means clustering with and without accounting explicitly for spatial information. Principal component analysis (PCA) was used to decipher underlying natural and anthropogenic influences responsible for these distinct water classes. The first four principal components (PCs) explained more than 83% of the total variance in water quality variables, from which the major component was found to be associated with salinization processes.

    How to cite: Kyriakidis, P., Panagiotou, C., and Tziritis, E.: Accounting for hydrological controls when clustering groundwater quality data, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11480, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11480, 2022.

    EGU22-11504 | Presentations | HS8.2.10

    Continuous monitoring of Eh, pH and CE of a coastal multilayer alluvial aquifer under different dynamic conditions. 

    Albert Folch, Alejandro Adan, Laura Martínez, Linda Luquot, Tybaud Goyetche, Jose Tur-Piedra, Bella Almillategui, and Jesús Carrera

    Understanding the behavior of the freshwater-seawater interface and its dynamics is a key issue to characterize seawater intrusion (SWI) as well as submarine groundwater discharge (SGD). A new experimental site intensively monitored and characterized was constructed north of Barcelona city (Spain) to gain insights in both phenomena, their interaction and all processes taking place in coastal aquifers. The site comprises 22 piezometers located between 10 and 90 m from the coastline. 16 piezometers are organized in four nests of four partially penetrating piezometers (2 m screened) at different depths ranging between 10 and 25 m.

    Previous studies indicated that the aquifer, which initially looked like a homogeneous unconfined aquifer 22 m thick, effectively behaves as a multi-aquifer and reactive system with freshwater discharging beneath saltwater at several depths. In order to improve understanding of the biogeochemical processes taking place in the aquifer and their dynamics, the 3 nests following a perpendicular line to the sea were equipped with specific sensors at all screened intervals (6, 12, 18 and 22 m depth). In each piezometer, Eh, electrical conductivity, pH, temperature and pressure was recorded at 15 minutes of temporal resolution. In this presentation we will show the initial results of several months of monitoring, which highlights different dynamics at different depths despite being a theoretically “homogeneous” alluvial aquifer.

     

    Acknowledgments

    This work was funded by the Spanish Government (grant no. PID2019-110212RB-C21 and PID2019-110212RB-C22) and the project TerraMar (grant no. ACA210/18/00007) of the Catalan Water Agency.

    How to cite: Folch, A., Adan, A., Martínez, L., Luquot, L., Goyetche, T., Tur-Piedra, J., Almillategui, B., and Carrera, J.: Continuous monitoring of Eh, pH and CE of a coastal multilayer alluvial aquifer under different dynamic conditions., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11504, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11504, 2022.

    EGU22-11565 | Presentations | HS8.2.10

    Assessing the effect of spatial autocorrelation in predicting groundwater salinity with Machine Learning 

    Panagiotis Tziachris, George Arampatzis, Vassilios Aschonitis, Katerina Sachsamanoglou, and Evangelos Tziritis

    Machine learning (ML) models that are robust, efficient and exhibiting sound generalization capabilities rely on the assumption that they are trained with data that are independent and identically distributed (i.i.d). Violating this assumption may result in overfitting these highly flexible methods to the training data and underestimating spatial prediction errors. Making models appear more reliable than they are, could lead in a bias assessment of the model’s capability to generalize the learned relationship to independent data and consequently models with overall poor prediction accuracy.

    Spatial data are special kind of data that the i.i.d. does not hold most of the times due to their spatial autocorrelation. Cross-validation is a very common resampling method both for the tuning of ML models and for the assessment of their predictive capabilities. Studies have shown that using random cross-validation methods with spatial data could produce overoptimistic results due to the violation of the i.i.d assumption. In order to mitigate this problem, spatial cross-validation is proposed alternatively that splits the data into spatially disjoint subsets, which are subsequently used for cross-validation.

    In the context of the MEDSAL Project (www.medsal.net), multiple data of different covariates were collected in order to study groundwater salinization. Machine learning was applied to predict salinity concentration based on these data. In the current presentation some of the results of the ML analysis are shown along with the effect of the spatial autocorrelation in the ML models' prediction capabilities. This was implemented by comparing the prediction results of the ML models created with random cross-validation versus spatial cross-validation resampling methods. Possible spatial autocorrelation, along with time series autocorrelation, in water data are important issues that data analysts should study and address especially when pairing with ML analysis and modeling.

    How to cite: Tziachris, P., Arampatzis, G., Aschonitis, V., Sachsamanoglou, K., and Tziritis, E.: Assessing the effect of spatial autocorrelation in predicting groundwater salinity with Machine Learning, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11565, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11565, 2022.

    EGU22-12355 | Presentations | HS8.2.10

    Groundwater salinization dynamics - an isotope approach 

    Christoph Külls and Dimitris Bassukas

    The evolution of groundwater salinization often is difficult identify, track and characterize. Additional factors such as hydro-climatic variability, pumping, pollution, and mixing with other groundwater end members in the borehole add complexity to the hydrochemical signal. Different isotope methods can provide insight into the inherent dynamics of groundwater salinization. The application of different isotope systems has been studied both theoretically using reactive transport models and in the field in different case studies. Tritium, SFand 14C, in combination with 13C as a marker of geochemical interaction, provide a straightforward access to information on the hydrodynamics of the flow system. Combined with data on salinity and on the geochemical fingerprint of salinization, these residence time tracers provide a first insight into the expected dynamics of changes. Radium isotope ratios allow an even more detailed reconstruction as the sorption of radium depends on the salinity of ambient groundwater and affects the transport behaviour. The chromatographic effect induced by salinity dependent transport behaviour can be used to date the onset of salinization. These concepts have been validated both by applying coupled groundwater flow and reactive transport models with PhreeqC and Geochemical Workbench and practically in several test sites. The transport modeling indicated that especially the combination of conservative residence time tracers and non-conservative tracers yield information on the dynamics of groundwater salinization, especially at time scales of decades to centuries and more. The verification of these concepts in case studies in Saudi-Arabia, in the Dead Sea valley and in the coastal aquifer of Samos within the PRIMA project MEDSAL confirms the viability of isotope methods in groundwater salinization studies.  

    How to cite: Külls, C. and Bassukas, D.: Groundwater salinization dynamics - an isotope approach, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12355, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12355, 2022.

    EGU22-12643 | Presentations | HS8.2.10 | Highlight

    Self Potential Monitoring of Saline Intrusion Dynamics in a Coastal Sand Aquifer 

    Adrian Butler, Thomas Rowan, Matthew Jackson, Mark McDonnell, Jesus Fernandez Aguila, Eric Benner, Raymond Flynn, Shane Donohue, and Gerard Hamill

    Greater groundwater abstraction combined with possible reductions in recharge rates are likely to be detrimental to the long-term viability of groundwater resources (Mehdizadeh, 2019). An additional issue specifically affecting coastal aquifers is saltwater intrusion (SI). The key processes governing SI have been long understood but monitoring the ingress of saline water into coastal aquifers and especially its risk to abstraction sources is still a complex and costly exercise (Graham, 2018). Here we build on evidence that self potential (SP) could be a useful tool for remotely tracking the movement of saline-freshwater interfaces associated with SI.  The work reported describes SP response, along with water level, temperature and electrical conductivity measurements from an array of piezometers under ambient and pumped conditions on a beach aquifer located on Benone Strand, on the northern tip of Northern Ireland, UK. These data are supplemented by time-dependent electrical resistance tomography (ERT) obtained from the BGS PRIME system.

    Self potential voltages arise from subsurface pressure and concentration gradients (Jackson et al., 2012). These gradients can cause ion separation, which gives rise to an electrical potential and a flow of electrons in order to maintain electrical neutrality. The potentials (typically in the millivolt range) can be detected and logged in the field using installed electrodes. There are two main types of SP; electro-kinetic potentials (VEK), due to differential flow velocities, and exclusion-diffusion potentials (VED), due to ion concentration gradients with different mobilities. SP has been shown to have a response to pumping tests in (Jackson et al., 2012), though this was limited in scope. In a longer-term study, tidal signatures in SP were recorded in a Chalk borehole less than 2 km inland from the English Channel (MacAllister, 2016). Separating out these two sources of SP can be challenging.

    Comparing SP and ERT responses coupled with groundwater level changes show tidal responses with are related to depth below surface and distance from the sea. In addition, results pumped well water levels appears to indicate that the drop in SP is not correlated with the expanding cone of depression from pumping, as the high pressure gradients that occur at the start of pumping has not induced an electrokinetic response. This is in contrast with the results obtained from (Jackson et al., 2012) at an inland site on the Cretaceous Chalk. This, therefore, points to the change in SP being induced by local movements of the saline-freshwater interface in the vicinity of the pumping wells, where a more progressive response is induced by changes in groundwater flow.

    How to cite: Butler, A., Rowan, T., Jackson, M., McDonnell, M., Aguila, J. F., Benner, E., Flynn, R., Donohue, S., and Hamill, G.: Self Potential Monitoring of Saline Intrusion Dynamics in a Coastal Sand Aquifer, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12643, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12643, 2022.

    Groundwater salinization has been a phenomenon of increasing concern in the circum-Mediterranean region. Future hydroclimatic and social changes in the area are expected to affect the dynamics of salinization, and to create further pressure on water resources. However, these dynamics are system-specific. To effectively mitigate predicted impacts, local water management needs to prioritize actions based on the temporal dynamics of the change. The conceptual modeling approach BC2C has been applied to the coastal aquifer on the island of Samos, Greece. The approach takes into account the flow dynamics, depending on physical parameters of the flow system, and connects biogeophysical changes of the land-use system to a response function of aquifer salinity. This straightforward modeling approach based on analytical functions yields a time-impact relationship of propagation and recession for given interventions. At the MEDSAL project pilot site of the Kampos plain in Samos, the BC2C model generates a response time between 15 years for the shallow aquifer and up to 150 years for the coupled deep aquifer system. This insight into the dynamics of groundwater salinization can be used as a guide and baseline for future groundwater management plans, and highlights the importance of a medium to long-term perspective. 

    How to cite: Külls, C. and Bassukas, D.: Groundwater salinization dynamics - a conceptual modeling approach to prioritize water management plans in a changing environment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12667, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12667, 2022.

    EGU22-12754 | Presentations | HS8.2.10

    Monitoring experimentally induced Saline Intrusion through vertical Self Potential profiling at costal aquifer in Northern Ireland 

    Tom Rowan, Mark Macdonnel, Jesus Aguila, Eric Benner, Adrian Bulter, Matthew Jackson, Chris Tompson, Raymond Flynn, Shane Donoue, and Gerry Hamill

    Due to greater ground-water abstraction, rising demand for water, possible reductions in recharge rates and rising sea levels, costal aquifers are under ever increasing threat of Saline Intrusion (SI) (Mehdizadeh, 2019). Though the mechanismins of SI have long been understood, the ability to monitor and warn in advance of the ingress of saline water into costal aquifers has remained costly and complex (Graham, 2018). The work reported here describes initial efforts to develop and results from, a vertically profiling Self Potential (SP) device. The device was used to monitoring the position of a well parametrized saline front in a costal aquifer, located on Benone Strand, Co. Derry,  on the northern tip of Northern Ireland, UK, as part of the SALine INtrusion in coastal Aquifers project.

    Naturally arising voltages, Self Potential (SP), are formed when pressure and concentration gradients move though the subsurface. The gradients cause ion separations, which create electrical potentials and a flow of electrons in order to maintain electrical neutrality. The SP signals (usually in the millivolt range) can be detected, relatively inexpensively (in comparison to resistivity imagining) with reference electrodes and a high impedance voltage logger. The positioning of the electrodes is key as it has only been possible, until now, to measure the voltage between two points. There are two key types of SP, in hydrology, electro-kinetic potentials (VEK), due to differential flow velocities, and exclusion-diffusion potentials (VED), due to ion concentration gradients with different mobilities. Understanding the source mechanims in these voltages is complex, but evolving. Previous work has shown that self-potential rises before a saline breakthrough into a borehole (Graham, 2018).

    A novel vertically travelling (or trolling) SP electrode was repeatedly used in a number of satellite boreholes during a pumping test; in order to look at the changes in the vertical gradient of SP. The pumping test took place over three days, during which initially fresh water was abstracted from the main pumping well. Resistivity imagine was used as a benchmark. It was shown that the vertical SP profile changed as the salt content of the pumped water increased (i.e. the saline front moved inland). This change in SP could not be explained by pressure changes – gradients of 50mV inside a single borehole were observed. The data showed SP profiles that varied widely before, during and after the pumping test, as saline water is drawn progressively towards the pumping well, offering far more data than a single stationary electrode. Demonstrating that these signals change in advance of the saltwater arriving at the pumping well, but also that this method could be used as an inexpensive way to safeguard costal aquifers in the future.

    References

    Graham, M. T. (2018). Self-Potential as a Predictor of Seawater Intrusion in Coastal. Water Resources Research.

    MacAllister, D. a. (2016). Tidal influence on self-potential measurements. Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth.

    Mehdizadeh, S. a. (2019). Abstraction, desalination and recharge method to control seawater intrusion into unconfined coastal aquifers. Global Journal of Environmental Science and Management, 5, 107-118.

     

     

    How to cite: Rowan, T., Macdonnel, M., Aguila, J., Benner, E., Bulter, A., Jackson, M., Tompson, C., Flynn, R., Donoue, S., and Hamill, G.: Monitoring experimentally induced Saline Intrusion through vertical Self Potential profiling at costal aquifer in Northern Ireland, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12754, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12754, 2022.

    EGU22-13533 | Presentations | HS8.2.10

    Monitoring of physical-chemical parameter depth profile to assess sea water intrusion phenomena in a coastal multi-layer aquifer 

    Stefania Da Pelo, Maria Chiara Porru, Fabrizia Antonio Piscedda, Maurizio Testa, Mario Lorrai, Paolo Botti, Francesca Lobina, Claudio Arras, Cristina Buttau, Alfredo Loi, Antonio Funedda, Riccardo Biddau, and Rosa Cidu

    Seawater intrusion is a global phenomenon occurring in many coastal aquifers. The excessive and uncontrolled withdrawal of groundwater and/or reduction in recharge to aquifers decrease the freshwater hydraulic head and can result in the saline front advancing inland toward abstraction boreholes. Sea-level rise due to the climate change can exacerbate these effects.  Old saline groundwater related to eustatic effects resulting from climate change during the last post-glacial period can also occur in coastal aquifers. According to the Ghyben-Herzberg principle, the depth of fresh-saline groundwater interface is mainly controlled by density and, in turn, by salinity. However, aquifer geometries and intrinsic heterogeneity of the geological medium, can affect the fresh-saline groundwater interface position and the response times to the forcing that control the salinization processes. Therefore, the knowledge of the response dynamics of the aquifer conditioning the position of the interface are essential to design countermeasures to compensate the salinization processes. Results of the monitoring of electric conductivity, temperature, pH and Eh log profile at about 30 m deep boreholes in the highly anthropized coastal plain of Muravera, in south-eastern Sardinia (Italy), are presented. Since the early fifties, in the plain area the natural hydrodynamic equilibrium between groundwater, surface-water, and seawater has been deeply modified by the construction of dams across the Flumendosa river, embankments, and the development of agriculture, tourism, and aquaculture activities along the coast. Moreover, abandoned branches of the river have been salinized by a fishpond that created a direct opening to the sea. According to a geological–depositional model based on sequential stratigraphy, the geometry of the aquifers in the Muravera coastal plain has been defined integrating stratigraphic, geophysical, geochemical, and isotopic data. A complex multilayer aquifer, mostly phreatic and locally confined, has been recognized. Results of the monitoring campaigns showed that the position of the fresh-saline groundwater interface along the plain cannot be explained by the Ghyben-Herzberg model. In the north area of the Muravera Plain, where the semi-confined condition of the aquifer occurs, the position of the interface doesn’t change significantly. Moreover, the lowering of pH as conductivity increases suggests high residence time of saline groundwater in the aquifer and interaction with marshes sediments. In the central sector of the plain, in unconfined conditions, the deepening of the interface as the piezometric head increases occurs and has been related to the higher transmissivity of the aquifer and a recharge rate coming from the Flumendosa river during extreme rainfall events. The multilayered aquifer geometry and the relationship between surface waters and groundwater have been recognized as responsible for the recharge rate of the aquifer and for the relative position of the freshwater–saltwater interface.

    How to cite: Da Pelo, S., Porru, M. C., Piscedda, F. A., Testa, M., Lorrai, M., Botti, P., Lobina, F., Arras, C., Buttau, C., Loi, A., Funedda, A., Biddau, R., and Cidu, R.: Monitoring of physical-chemical parameter depth profile to assess sea water intrusion phenomena in a coastal multi-layer aquifer, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13533, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13533, 2022.

    EGU22-2662 | Presentations | HS8.2.11

    Data-driven reconstruction of the main traits of the large-scale Po River basin subsurface system 

    Andrea Manzoni, Monica Riva, Giovanni Porta, and Alberto Guadagnini

    We discuss the definition and implementation of an integrated groundwater and surface water flow modeling framework focused on the Po River basin (Italy; with an extension of about 72.000 km2). At such a scale, it is possible to characterize global (space‐time) patterns of groundwater response in a way that is typically overshadowed when considering analyses at the scale of a single aquifer. We create a georeferenced three-dimensional platform that unifies the diverse types of data available in the basin area. The data collected merge streams of information from a variety of sources, including, e.g., climate satellite data, soil properties and land use data, and lithological/sedimentological information. In this context, we consider two key inputs of the large-scale groundwater model: i) the estimation recharge rates and ii) the reconstruction of the subsurface architecture. We then focus on the latter element and analyze the most critical steps associated with data collection, organization, and interpretation. We obtain an operational model of the domain upon relying on lithological and sedimentological information to reconstruct the spatial distribution of subsurface geomaterials which we integrated within a machine learning approach based on Artificial Neural Networks. Results are compared with available geological interpretations in the area. We discuss feedbacks between (a) the characterization of the system, as driven by domain discretization, that aims at considering a high-resolution hydrogeological reconstruction and (b) computational efficiency. Our results are discussed in the framework of future developments of the study with a view to establishing a physically-based three-dimensional characterization of large-scale groundwater flow accounting for a variety of processes taking place across multiple scales.

    How to cite: Manzoni, A., Riva, M., Porta, G., and Guadagnini, A.: Data-driven reconstruction of the main traits of the large-scale Po River basin subsurface system, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2662, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2662, 2022.

    EGU22-4809 | Presentations | HS8.2.11

    Long-term prediction of groundwater levels for climate scenarios with machine-learning tools 

    Moritz Gosses and Thomas Wöhling

    Estimating the effects of climate change on water resources is an important topic for researchers in hydrological sciences. Climate model outputs can be used as inputs for calibrated numerical groundwater models to predict the effect of different climate scenarios on groundwater levels. Unfortunately, spatially explicit numerical models are spatially constrained, data-hungry, and difficult to set-up and to calibrate. Furthermore, the involved model run-times make proper uncertainty analysis of the model predictions computationally expensive.
    Machine-learning (ML) tools have become recognized as a powerful alternative for numerical models for different applications in hydrological science, but come with their own challenges. They have been successfully used for the prediction of groundwater levels in single bores based on historical data, but their application for estimating groundwater levels for climate scenarios is still a matter of active research.
    To identify the potential of ML techniques for this application, two different ML algorithms have been applied to predict groundwater levels for several climate scenarios at a number of groundwater wells with long-term historical data time series. The two ML algorithms are (i) multi-layer perceptrons (MLP) with a closed feedback loop and (ii) long short-term memory (LSTM) networks. For each observation well, several thousand versions of these ML models with differing setups are trained to historical, monthly data time series up to 2015 and then applied for the estimation of monthly groundwater levels. These estimations are computed by using climate model outputs for different scenarios, as well as artificially generated scenarios, as drivers for the ML models to test their sensitivity and plausibility to those input data series. The high quantity of model versions for each bore are utilized to generate mean groundwater level estimates and accompanying uncertainty bands via Bayesian Model Averaging (BMA).
    Both ML techniques are able to match the historical data time series for the different bores with small uncertainty, but differ in their ability to predict long-term groundwater levels from climate change and artificial scenarios. The long-term simulations of the MLP models show believable trends and appropriate uncertainty bands, while the LSTM networks seem to underestimate the uncertainty of their future predictions.

    How to cite: Gosses, M. and Wöhling, T.: Long-term prediction of groundwater levels for climate scenarios with machine-learning tools, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4809, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4809, 2022.

    EGU22-6263 | Presentations | HS8.2.11

    A regional data driven model for simulating phreatic ground water levels in Flanders 

    Vincent Wolfs, Tim Franken, Cedric Gullentops, Johan Lermytte, and Jan Corluy

    The summers of 2017 to 2020 were characterized by exceptional dry spells throughout Europe. Climate models show that such periods of drought could occur more frequently and become even more extreme in the future. The recent periods of intense droughts lead to significant ecological, economic and even societal damages in Flanders (Belgium). During these summers, receding groundwater levels were observed throughout Flanders that reached historical low levels. To monitor low ground water levels and to support a proactive drought management, the Flemish government developed an operational ground water indicator. This indicator gives an overview of the current phreatic ground water levels combined with a prediction for the next month for a selected number of phreatic wells. To increase the spatial resolution of the indicator, we developed a novel data driven regional ground water model for phreatic aquifers.

    The ML model combines a gradient boosting decision tree model (CatBoost) with a Long Short Term Memory (LSTM) network. CatBoost is used to model the average ground water depth at each location. This value is passed to the LSTM network that predicts the temporal evolution of the groundwater at each location around its average. The training dataset for the CatBoost model contains the average groundwater depth of 5.673 wells spread across Flanders and a large set of explanatory variables related to soil texture, distance to a drainage, geology, topography, meteorology and land use. The model performance is evaluated using cross-validation which showed the model generalizes well with a mean absolute error of 69cm. The most important explanatory variables for the model are the thickness of the phreatic aquifer, the vertical distance to closest drain, the topographic index and the precipitation surplus.

    The training dataset for the LSTM model contains 408 wells that have sufficiently long and reliable observations for training. The input data to the LSTM consists of rainfall and evapotranspiration up to 10 years prior to each observation, combined with the same explanatory variables as the CatBoost model. A single regional LSTM model is trained on all 408 wells simultaneously. The resulting model is accurate with a median RMSE of 20cm for the validation data, outperforming the currently used SWAP models [1]. The ML model is however less performant in simulating the higher ground water depths during summer and shows a consistent bias towards lower ground water depths during long dry spells.

    [1] Kroes, J.G., J.C. van Dam, R.P. Bartholomeus, P. Groenendijk, M. Heinen, R.F.A. Hendriks, H.M. Mulder, I. Supit, P.E.V. van Walsum, 2017. SWAP version 4; Theory description and user manual. Wageningen, Wageningen Environmental Research, Report 2780

    How to cite: Wolfs, V., Franken, T., Gullentops, C., Lermytte, J., and Corluy, J.: A regional data driven model for simulating phreatic ground water levels in Flanders, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6263, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6263, 2022.

    EGU22-7384 | Presentations | HS8.2.11

    Improved groundwater simulations by multi-criteria calibration of a global hydrological model in the river basins of France 

    H.M. Mehedi Hasan, Kuei-Hua Hsu, Annette Eicker, Laurent Longuevergne, and Andreas Güntner

    Groundwater is the most important freshwater source considering its abundance, demand, quality, and accessibility. However, estimation of groundwater storage variations is notoriously difficult due to the lack of information on physical aquifer properties, the connectivity among other water storages, the scarcity of observations at regional scales and high uncertainty associated with the observations if available. In the current study, we tried to improve the simulations of groundwater storage variations of a global hydrological model with a simple bucket-type groundwater module – the WaterGAP Global Hydrological Model (WGHM) – in four French river basins. Sensitive model parameters were calibrated against in-situ streamflow observations and GRACE-based observations of total water storage anomalies in a multi-criterial calibration framework. A regional data set of in-situ observations of groundwater levels and deduced basin-average groundwater storage variations (see Hsu et al., this meeting) was used for validation of the calibration results. In a second setup, the in-situ groundwater observations were introduced as additional observations into the calibration framework.  We found significant improvement in the simulated groundwater dynamics in terms of their seasonal signals and amplitudes after calibration. Overestimated negative groundwater trends in a few river basins caused by overestimated human groundwater use in the original model could also be corrected by the calibration approach. In an additional calibration experiment, specific yield was introduced into WGHM as a new calibration parameter and its calibrated values were compared to those obtained from regionalizing the hydrogeological information.

    How to cite: Hasan, H. M. M., Hsu, K.-H., Eicker, A., Longuevergne, L., and Güntner, A.: Improved groundwater simulations by multi-criteria calibration of a global hydrological model in the river basins of France, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7384, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7384, 2022.

    EGU22-7734 | Presentations | HS8.2.11

    Data-driven time series modeling to support groundwater model development for the Grazer Feld Aquifer, Austria 

    Ainur Kokimova, Raoul Collenteur, and Steffen Birk

    Alluvial aquifers and springs play a vital role in the water supply of Austria as the main source of drinking water. One such example is the Grazer Feld Aquifer, located in an urban and semi-urban setting in southeast Austria. Urbanisation imposes stresses on aquifers leading to quantitative and qualitative groundwater problems. These problems are commonly addressed by numerical groundwater models. In these models, natural and anthropogenic processes need to be carefully represented. Calibration to groundwater level data disturbed by human activities will fail or produce erroneous parameter estimates if the disturbance is not adequately considered by the model. As a consequence, such model likely result in erroneous predictions and assessments. To account for relevant drivers in the system and examine groundwater level data for the calibration of a numerical groundwater model, we test the application of the time series analysis as an additional and preliminary step in a general numerical groundwater modeling framework. The results of time series models (TSM) contribute to the understanding of spatiotemporal aquifer dynamics and main driving forces as advocated by Bakker and Schaars (2019).

    The objective of this study is twofold. First, time series models were set up and calibrated for each monitoring well in the aquifer, using the stresses identified in the initial hydrogeological assessment (precipitation, evapotranspiration, and river levels). Second, we create a calibration data set that flags groundwater level observations that were caused by human temporal activities (e.g., pumping, irrigation, and/or dam construction). This is achieved by constructing TSMs and conducting a visual and spatial investigation on model results. The process differentiates good fit models from no-good fit models. Then, models, not delivering a good fit, are checked for missing driving forces by engaging local stakeholders. Once the process is characterized, the period with unexplained groundwater level change is marked. The groundwater level fluctuations of 115 out of 149 observation wells are found to be reasonably simulated by considering recharge from precipitation and, if applicable, river stages as driving forces. For 34 observation wells, however, the models perform less accurately, suggesting other factors, such as construction activities and temporary groundwater abstraction, influencing groundwater level fluctuations during the part or the entire simulation period. Estimated recharge is found to be higher in urban and semi-urban areas compared to agricultural fields. The results from this study will be used in the future development of a numerical groundwater model for the entire aquifer.

    How to cite: Kokimova, A., Collenteur, R., and Birk, S.: Data-driven time series modeling to support groundwater model development for the Grazer Feld Aquifer, Austria, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7734, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7734, 2022.

    EGU22-7893 | Presentations | HS8.2.11

    Analysis of hydrogeological behavior of coastal aquifers based on clusters of groundwater hydrograph features and environmental drivers 

    Annika Nolte, Ezra Haaf, Benedikt Heudorfer, Steffen Bender, and Jens Hartmann

    Distinguishing between natural and anthropogenic impacts on groundwater systems at regional scale is not straightforward using current data-driven and traditional numerical groundwater models. This limits their benefit for groundwater level predictions and thus future-oriented groundwater resource management. We propose an approach to leverage the large amount of information and variability in the characteristics of groundwater hydrographs and environmental factors to obtain generalized insights into the influences of natural and anthropogenic factors on specific patterns in groundwater hydrographs using data-driven regionalization of groundwater level dynamics. In our approach, we focus on coastal regions that are often under water stress due to the water demands of growing coastal populations building on a data set containing several thousand wells in Europe, North America, South Africa, and Australia.

    The approach comprises construction and comparison of multiple unsupervised machine learning cluster models based on a) groundwater level dynamics information, aggregated into groundwater hydrograph features, and b) selected environmental drivers that potentially influence natural groundwater recharge and discharge processes. Environmental descriptors were extracted at well locations from available global map products. We discuss the extent to which our selection of features can express the range of dynamics in representative groundwater hydrographs of clustered basins. Furthermore, we compare the similarity of anthropogenic factors within and between clusters in order to test our hypothesis that hydrograph patterns differ in response to natural processes but irrespective of anthropogenic influences. This would contribute to our understanding of natural processes in coastal groundwater systems.

    How to cite: Nolte, A., Haaf, E., Heudorfer, B., Bender, S., and Hartmann, J.: Analysis of hydrogeological behavior of coastal aquifers based on clusters of groundwater hydrograph features and environmental drivers, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7893, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7893, 2022.

    EGU22-7920 | Presentations | HS8.2.11

    Performance analysis of missing data imputation methods for daily groundwater hydrographs using typical gap patterns 

    Jānis Bikše, Andis Kalvāns, Inga Retike, and Marta Jemeļjanova

    Regular and gapless observations are necessary to perform a range of statistical analysis on the parameter of interest. Groundwater level (GWL) hydrographs  are often recorded at irregular frequencies and have time periods without any observations. As a result, groundwater level hydrographs have missing values. Typically groundwater hydrographs are removed from further analysis if large gaps are present, while each groundwater observation point is valuable and methods exist that can impute (fill in) the missing observations. 

    This study aims to evaluate performance of machine learning methods to prepare gapless daily groundwater level hydrographs and to assess the imputation error according to various approaches. Filled groundwater level hydrographs will further be used  to identify typical groundwater level patterns in the Baltic region.

    The performance of two machine learning imputation methods - missForest and missMDA - along with conventional approaches (linear interpolation, mean imputation) - were tested. A subset of the GWL observation data from Lithuania, Latvia and Estonia were used for the time period from 2011 to mid-2019 comprising 283 groundwater monitoring wells. Cluster analysis of the temporal distribution of actual missing values in the GWL time series provided 13 different gap patterns. Next a corresponding number of artificially generated gap distribution scenarios were defined. The performance of various gap-filing approaches were then evaluated by imputing each artificially generated gap pattern in each hydrograph. Results indicated that imputation performance varies among different clusters of missing value patterns, while generally the best performance was achieved by the missForest algorithm.

    This research is funded by the Latvian Council of Science, project “Spatial and temporal prediction of groundwater drought with mixed models for multilayer sedimentary basin under climate change”, project No. lzp-2019/1-0165.

    How to cite: Bikše, J., Kalvāns, A., Retike, I., and Jemeļjanova, M.: Performance analysis of missing data imputation methods for daily groundwater hydrographs using typical gap patterns, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7920, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7920, 2022.

    Recent years have seen several major groundwater drought instances in Europe, increasing the interest in their research and future predictions. Modeling methods can be used to explore groundwater drought risk in near and medium term future using climate projection data sets as an input. Therefore an optimal modeling approach has to be chosen according to the available data and modeling capacity of the historic series. 

    We  explore two approaches for modeling groundwater level time series: Transfer function-noise models with Impulse response functions (TFN-IRF) and machine learning (ML). In both approaches, daily meteorological variables are used as an input and models are calibrated against historical groundwater level observations. 

    TFN-IRF input parameters are daily precipitation and potential evapotranspiration. Other time series data, such as groundwater abstraction, can be added to potentially increase the fit. Machine learning models can, in addition to the aforementioned, benefit from a wider variety of site parameters, including derived parameters (e.g., meteorological indices), however at the expense of increased data collection effort. In addition, the obscure input data interpretation in ML methods can erode the trust in these models. In this study, only the most basic meteorological parameters - precipitation, temperature - and derived parameters such as potential evapotranspiration were used. 

    We draw from an extensive groundwater level monitoring database of more than one thousand monitoring wells from three Baltic countries. The study provides an insight into differences between the two modelling approaches, keeping in mind the limitations of future projection data.

    This research is funded by the Latvian Council of Science, project “Spatial and temporal prediction of groundwater drought with mixed models for multilayer sedimentary basin under climate change”, project No. lzp-2019/1-0165.

    How to cite: Jemeļjanova, M., Bikše, J., and Kalvāns, A.: Comparison of Impulse response function and Machine learning models for use in groundwater level short to medium term future projections in the Baltic states, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7999, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7999, 2022.

    Assessment of specific yield becomes crucial for an effective groundwater management in hard-rock aquifers in semi-arid regions, especially in southern India with its high dependence on groundwater for irrigation. Specific yield is an important parameter influencing water table fluctuations in groundwater and land-surface models as uncertainties associated with specific yield estimation are passed on to recharge estimation. In southern India, contemporary groundwater levels are heavily influenced by groundwater pumping and are spatially heterogeneous. Comparatively homogeneous natural groundwater levels in the upper weathered zone were observed in the earlier decades of 1970s and 1980s because of relatively lower pumping. Specific yield values estimated for the duration prior to 1990 are representative of upper bounds of specific yield values because of shallower water tables, hence we have selected the duration from 1980-1990 for this study. The existing water table fluctuation methodology by Maréchal et al. (2006) and Groundwater resource Estimation Committee (GEC, 2015) estimates specific yield based on net groundwater level decline during dry season corresponding to known or estimated groundwater draft. This methodology is not feasible for zero draft scenarios prevailing during 1980-1990. An alternate approach is required to account for discharge which was more dominant process to affect groundwater fluctuations when they are shallow. A physically based lumped model for unconfined aquifers, AMBHAS-1D is used in this study which is based on Park and Parker (2008) model. The model is applied on monthly groundwater levels at 100 sites tapping into a geologically homogeneous region of granitic gneissic aquifer in the Upper Cauvery River basin of Karnataka, India. Specific yield values are estimated for each of the 100 sites and a specific yield map for the region is prepared. Even though it is granitic gneissic rock in general, we observed a high variability in estimated specific yield of more than 10 orders of magnitude which can be associated with degree of fracturation, long-term rainfall trends, variation of water level and topographic impacts. Major area of Hassan and Mandya districts of Karnataka state have very low estimated specific yield (<=0.05%) indicating poor fracturing in those regions. Clusters of relatively high specific yield (>1%) are observed in south western part of Mysore district, Mysore city and southern part of Tumkur district depicting weathered upper zone.

    References:

    GEC (2015). Report of the Ground water resource Estimation Committee, Ministry of Water Resources, Govt. of India, New Delhi.

    Maréchal, J. C., Dewandel, B., Ahmed, S., Galeazzi, L., & Zaidi, F. K. (2006). Combined estimation of specific yield and natural recharge in a semi-arid groundwater basin with irrigated agriculture. Journal of Hydrology, 329(1–2), 281–293. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhydrol.2006.02.022

    Park, E., & Parker, J. C. (2008). A simple model for water table fluctuations in response to precipitation. Journal of Hydrology, 356(3–4), 344–349. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhydrol.2008.04.022

    How to cite: Goswami, S. and Muddu, S.: Estimation of specific yield of hard-rock aquifers in Upper Cauvery River basin region in India by application of AMBHAS-1D groundwater model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9975, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9975, 2022.

    EGU22-9995 | Presentations | HS8.2.11

    Time series analysis of synthetic time series generated with a saturated/unsaturated zone model 

    Mark Bakker, Martin Vonk, Raoul Collenteur, and Frans Schaars

    Time series analysis with response functions is a versatile approach to analyze measured head series in observation wells. In such an analysis, the response function of the groundwater does not change with time. This approach works well when the groundwater recharge is a linear function of the measured rainfall and evaporation, as was shown through the analysis of synthetic time series generated with a saturated groundwater model where the groundwater recharge is applied directly to the saturated zone. In this research, the method was evaluated for situations where the groundwater recharge cannot be approximated well as a linear function of the measured rainfall and evaporation. Synthetic time series were generated with a two-dimensional saturated/unsaturated zone model (Hydrus2D) and analyzed with response functions. Performance of the time series model was improved through inclusion of a new root zone model consisting of a single reservoir. Reservoir inflow is measured rainfall. Reservoir outflow is evaporation and groundwater recharge, where the evaporation is a function of the amount of water stored in the root zone and the recharge is a function of both the amount of water stored in the root zone and the groundwater table. The new root zone model is a promising tool for the analysis of head series in areas with thick unsaturated zones and/or high potential evaporative fluxes.

    How to cite: Bakker, M., Vonk, M., Collenteur, R., and Schaars, F.: Time series analysis of synthetic time series generated with a saturated/unsaturated zone model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9995, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9995, 2022.

    EGU22-10170 | Presentations | HS8.2.11

    Analysis of nationwide groundwater monitoring networks using lumped groundwater models: a case study of Switzerland 

    Raoul Collenteur, Christian Moeck, Mario Schirmer, and Steffen Birk

    Many countries maintain nationwide groundwater networks to monitor the status of their groundwater resources. To assess the current water availability as well as help forecast future changes, it is fundamental to understand and predict groundwater dynamics observed in the individual monitoring wells. Nationwide monitoring networks typically cover multiple aquifer systems with different degree of environmental complexity. Understanding these aquifer systems is challenging, as the development of physically-based, distributed groundwater models is time-consuming and costly. As an attractive alternative, statistical and conceptual lumped-parameter models may be applied to analyze monitoring networks. The advantage of these models over physically-based models is that the conceptual parameterization is relatively simple and computation is efficient, while typically results are robust.

    In this study, we analyze the long-term groundwater-monitoring network of Switzerland using conceptual, lumped-parameter models implemented in the Pastas software package. The 29 monitoring wells in the network are situated in unconsolidated aquifers across Switzerland, ranging from high altitude alpine aquifers to pre-alpine aquifers systems on the Swiss plateau. Given the very diverse topography in Switzerland, snowmelt processes affect some aquifers, while groundwater-surface water interactions are important in the valleys. The models are used to identify and quantify which driving forces (e.g., precipitation, river levels) control the groundwater dynamics, and how fast the groundwater systems respond to changes in these stresses. The results show that precipitation and evaporation explain large parts of the observed dynamics, while about half of the monitoring wells in the network appear to be influenced by river level fluctuations. Explicitly accounting for snow processes in the recharge generating process is found to improve the simulation of the water table dynamics for only a few wells in high-altitude aquifers. The models developed in this study lead to a better understanding of the observed groundwater dynamics across Switzerland and will be used in future studies to explore the sensitivity of the groundwater resources to climatic changes.

    How to cite: Collenteur, R., Moeck, C., Schirmer, M., and Birk, S.: Analysis of nationwide groundwater monitoring networks using lumped groundwater models: a case study of Switzerland, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10170, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10170, 2022.

    EGU22-11932 | Presentations | HS8.2.11

    Joint inversion of radiogenic Helium-4 and hydraulic head observations with a neural network surrogate: Application for the Neogene aquifer, Belgium 

    Alberto Casillas-Trasvina, Bart Rogiers, Koen Beerten, Laurent Wouters, and Kristine Walraevens

    Environmental tracers are naturally occurring widespread substances in a hydrogeological system that can be used to identify flow pathways, travel times, groundwater age, and recharge rates. However, these are not typically included during the numerical model inversion process. Recent work has broadened their use in a quantitative way by incorporating them in formal solutions of the inverse problem to estimate hydraulic properties and groundwater fluxes. This is commonly done with numerical codes that at least enable one-way coupling of the different processes, i.e., groundwater flow and solute-transport. Helium-4, carbon-14 and temperature-depth profile measurements represent a valuable source of information which can be exploited to support performance assessment studies. For the Neogene aquifer in Flanders, groundwater flow and solute transport models have been developed in the framework of safety and feasibility studies for the underlying Boom Clay Formation as potential host for geological disposal of radioactive waste. However, the simulated fluxes by these models are still subject to large uncertainties, as they are typically constrained by hydraulic heads only. While the evaluation of candidate host formations continues, the use of age tracers (e.g. 4He) as additional (unconventional) state variable for inverse conditioning is being explored. Current methodological developments to integrate such additional unconventional observations will allow i) to test our current understanding and corresponding models of the system, and ii) to potentially decrease the uncertainties associated with model outcomes by a joint inversion approach. From previous campaigns, a total of 18 4Herad observations have been collected at selected sites across the Nete catchment. Furthermore, the accumulation of 4Herad by in situ production and crustal flux is included in the inversion of the 4He-transport model, where the uncertainty of groundwater flow and transport model parameters is evaluated. Additionally, a Latin hypercube sampling (LHS) design is done with parameters drawn from prior distributions. The corresponding simulation results are used to construct a neural network surrogate model  to be used for uncertainty quantification using Bayesian inference. Here, we will present the first results and interpretations of Helium-4 as potential additional state variable for inverse conditioning, and constraining groundwater flow and solute transport models at the catchment scale.

    How to cite: Casillas-Trasvina, A., Rogiers, B., Beerten, K., Wouters, L., and Walraevens, K.: Joint inversion of radiogenic Helium-4 and hydraulic head observations with a neural network surrogate: Application for the Neogene aquifer, Belgium, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11932, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11932, 2022.

    EGU22-12580 | Presentations | HS8.2.11

    Presenting the Groundwater Time Series Modeling Challenge 

    Ezra Haaf, Raoul Collenteur, Tanja Liesch, and Mark Bakker

    Groundwater level time series are the most common source of information on the dynamics of subsurface water resources. The modeling of such time series is of crucial importance to increase our understanding of the system and make predictions on future changes. This becomes ever more important with global challenges such as climate change and human over-exploitation of groundwater resources. Different types of models can be applied to model groundwater level time series, ranging from purely statistical models (black-box), through lumped conceptual models (grey-box), to physically based models (white-box). Traditionally, physically based, distributed models are predominantly used to solve groundwater problems. In recent years, the use of grey- and black-box models has been receiving increased attention. In this poster we will present the “Groundwater Time Series Modeling Challenge”, which aims to systematically compare different methodologies to model groundwater level time series. We challenge researchers to model a predefined set of groundwater time series observed in unconsolidated aquifers worldwide, set in a variety of physiographic and climatic conditions. Participating groups are free to use the model of their choice, but are required to use the same forcing data and periods for calibration. Model performance will be centrally assessed by the organizers using non-public validation data set, which will be made public after the challenge. A more detailed description of the rules for this challenge and all groundwater and forcing data is available in a GitHub repository at https://github.com/gwmodeling/challenge. The results of the challenge will be presented at the General Assembly of the EGU in 2023 and reported in a peer-reviewed paper. With this challenge, we hope to increase the awareness in the groundwater community about all the different types of models that are available to model groundwater level time series.

    How to cite: Haaf, E., Collenteur, R., Liesch, T., and Bakker, M.: Presenting the Groundwater Time Series Modeling Challenge, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12580, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12580, 2022.

    Climate change will have a major impact on Ireland’s water resources. It will pose significant risks to water management and exacerbate existing pressures in terms of water supply, quality, flooding and drought. Early detection of these pressures in hydrological regimes is key to informing adaptation strategies and minimizing adverse environmental and societal impacts. In response to this risk, a framework was developed to enable short-term forecasting of groundwater levels, and to quantify and analyse the impact that climate change will have on Irish groundwater systems.

    A key element of the framework is the use of robust hydrological models to simulate groundwater levels. The framework was developed in Python, with a particular focus on groundwater flooding, and incorporates two modelling approaches: 1) mathematical transfer functions (combination of exponential decay, gamma distribution, and linear decay functions), and 2) a physically based lumped model (reservoir model). For both modelling approaches, precipitation data is converted to effective rainfall based on soil moisture deficit and evapotranspiration data, and the model parameters are calibrated using a Bayesian Markov Chain Monte Carlo algorithm.

    The framework was tested and implemented with synthetically generated groundwater level time series, and with a selection of 12 groundwater dependent wetlands covering a wide range of hydrological behaviours. The tested approaches have proof successful to: 1) produce viable numerical models for those systems, with Nash-Sutcliffe Efficiency (NSE) and Kling-Gupta Efficiency (KGE) values between 0.85 and 0.98 for most of the sites calibration and validation datasets, and 2) inform on how the groundwater systems operate (i.e. multiple outflows, changes in catchment area). The models are now used for forecasting groundwater levels and assessing the potential impact of climate change in ecologically important wetlands.

    The outputs of this project will improve the national ability to understand how groundwater resources respond to climatic stresses and improve the reliability of adaptation planning and predictions in the groundwater sector.

    How to cite: Campanyà i Llovet, J., McCormack, T., and Naughton, O.: A framework for modelling groundwater floods and its applications for forecasting and assessing the impact of climate change in groundwater systems: examples from Ireland, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12740, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12740, 2022.

    HS8.3 – Subsurface hydrology – Vadose zone hydrology

    The fate and transport of metallic nanoparticles (NPs) in the soil has been a major concern over the last decade due to the increasing use of NPs in many industries and their appearance in the environment. However, the study of NP fate and transport traditionally relies on intensive sample collection ana chemical analysis. In this work we use spectral induced polarization (SIP) to monitor the transport of metallic NPs in soils. In SIP, an alternating current in wide range of frequencies is injected, and the phase and amplitude difference between the injected and induced potential are measured. Our experimental setup involves flow-through columns packed with different types of soil, through which a suspension of NPs with different ionic compositions is passed. Electrical potentials are recorded at three locations along the column. The analyzed SIP measurements allow not only non-invasive, non-destructive monitoring of the NP’s progression through the soil but also deduction of the NPs’ fate and transport patterns through combination with elemental analysis. The sensitivity of SIP to the presence of the NPs is high and was found to be correlated to their progression in the soil even in low and environmentally relevant NP concentrations (<5mg/L).  Our results indicate that SIP is a promising method for monitoring of NPs in the soil and with further research may serve as an easy and efficient alternative to the standard methods that involve extensive water and soil sampling.

    How to cite: Ben Moshe, S. and Furman, A.: Monitoring nanoparticle progression and fate in the soil using spectral induced polarization, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-195, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-195, 2022.

    EGU22-643 | Presentations | HS8.3.1

    Simultaneous estimation of soil hydraulic properties and surface evaporation using inverse modeling for a large field-lysimeter 

    Deep Chandra Joshi, Andre Peters, Sascha C. Iden, Beate Zimmermann, and Wolfgang Durner

    A sound prediction of water and energy fluxes at the soil-atmosphere interface is important for many practical questions regarding e.g. irrigation and salinity management. Precise knowledge of soil hydraulic properties (SHP) is mandatory for such predictions. The SHP can be measured either in the laboratory within a wide moisture range or at the field scale, e.g. by inverse simulation techniques based on in situ matric potential and water content measurements. Depending on the installation depth of the sensors, soil texture, and boundary conditions, field-determined SHP are often limited to a quite narrow range of moisture conditions. Prediction of actual surface fluxes on basis of this limited information is highly uncertain. With well-instrumented large weighable lysimeters, systems are now available that allow to measure very precisely surface (and bottom) water fluxes under natural atmospheric conditions. In particular, they can be used to quantify the difference between potential evaporation, Ep, and observed actual evaporation, Ea. The difference (Ep-Ea) increases during the drying process when the soil hydraulic conductivity becomes limiting for the evaporation process. Thus, our hypothesis was that this information can be used to improve the identification of SHP of soils.

    Accordingly, the aim of this study was to see whether the information on (Ep-Ea), measured during a calibration period and supplemented by water content and matric potential data measured inside of a lysimeter, is sufficient to inversely estimate the SHP. Furthermore, we were interested to see if the prediction of Ea was possible and reliable also for time periods beyond the calibration period.  For a proof-of-concept study, we conducted forward simulations with Hydrus-1D where we generated synthetic data of actual surface fluxes and soil hydraulic internal state variables. The atmospheric boundary was given by natural precipitation and potential evaporation rates in a semi-arid climate. The study showed that it was possible to identify SHP by inverse modeling, and prediction of the cumulative actual evaporation after the calibration period was successful. In a second step, the methodology was applied to data of a real large bare-soil field-lysimeter. Our simulation results showed also here a good match between observed and predicted cumulative evaporation.

    How to cite: Joshi, D. C., Peters, A., Iden, S. C., Zimmermann, B., and Durner, W.: Simultaneous estimation of soil hydraulic properties and surface evaporation using inverse modeling for a large field-lysimeter, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-643, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-643, 2022.

    EGU22-644 | Presentations | HS8.3.1

    Effective Hydraulic Properties of Stony Soils: Simulation, Laboratory Experiment and Modeling 

    Mahyar Naseri, Sascha C. Iden, and Wolfgang Durner

    Stony soils are soils with a considerable volume of rock fragments (RF). They influence the soil hydraulic properties (SHP), including the water retention curve (WRC) and hydraulic conductivity curve (HCC). However, because of the challenges in the measurement and modeling of SHP in stony soils, RF are normally neglected in hydrological and land surface modeling.

    In the present study, we measured SHP of stony soils with volumetric RF contents up to 50 % (v/v) in the laboratory using the simplified evaporation method. Afterward, we applied Hydrus 2D/3D software to create virtual stony soils with impermeable RF up to 37.3 % (v/v) in three spatial dimensions, 3D. The evaporation and multistep unit gradient experiments were simulated for the virtual stony soils, and inverse modeling in 1D was applied to identify their effective SHP. The identified effective SHP by measurement and inverse modeling were used to evaluate the available scaling models of hydraulic conductivity, such as the simple scaling model based on only the volume of RF (Ravina and Magier, 1984), and the most recent model, GEM, proposed by Naseri et al. (2020).

    From the lab experiments, we successfully identified SHP of these stony soils for pressure heads from near saturation to -1000 cm. We also found that scaling the WRC of the background soil based on the volume of rock fragments gave reasonable effective SHP for low RF content, but was not appropriate for the highly stony soils. A higher reduction in conductivity was visible compared to the predicted values by the model of Ravina and Magier. Furthermore, comparison of the evaluated scaling models displayed a better performance of the GEM model especially when volume of RF in soil was low.

     

    References:

    Naseri, M., Peters, A., Durner, W. and Iden, S.C., 2020. Effective hydraulic conductivity of stony soils: General effective medium theory. Advances in Water Resources, 146, p.103765. DOI: 103765doi.org/10.1016/j.advwatres.2020.103765.

    Ravina, I. and Magier, J., 1984. Hydraulic conductivity and water retention of clay soils containing coarse fragments. Soil Science Society of America Journal, 48(4), pp.736-740. DOI: 10.2136/sssaj1984.03615995004800040008x.

    How to cite: Naseri, M., Iden, S. C., and Durner, W.: Effective Hydraulic Properties of Stony Soils: Simulation, Laboratory Experiment and Modeling, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-644, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-644, 2022.

    EGU22-3721 | Presentations | HS8.3.1

    Extrapolating field-scale near-surface soil moisture information from Cosmic Ray Neutron Sensing to greater depth 

    Daniel Rasche, Theresa Blume, and Andreas Güntner

    Cosmic-Ray Neutron Sensing (CRNS) is a modern technique for non-invasive soil moisture estimation at the field scale. It closes the scale gap between point-scale observations (e.g. soil sampling, in-situ sensors) and coarse-scale satellite-derived estimates. While CRNS has a large horizontal footprint with a radius of roughly 150 m around the instrument, the average vertical measurement depth is only about 30 cm. Thus, extrapolating the CRNS-derived soil moisture to greater soil depths such as the entire root zone can be highly beneficial for hydrological applications such as landscape water balancing or irrigation management. To this end, previous studies have used, for instance, additional in-situ sensors and time-stability approaches or calibrated exponential filters against reference measurements in deeper soil depths.

    However, additional permanent in-situ sensors and reference measurements in greater depths are not always available or feasible. Against this background, we use the physically-based soil moisture analytical relationship (SMAR) which can be used without calibration against reference measurements. We estimate the required model parameters from soil characteristics (e.g. porosity, water content at field capacity and wilting point) as well as from the CRNS soil moisture time series itself.

    As CRNS for soil moisture estimation is developing rapidly, new transfer functions from observed neutron intensities to surface soil moisture have been introduced. We investigate the influence of using both the standard transfer function and the recently introduced universal transport solution (UTS) on the depth-extrapolated soil moisture time series. These depth-extrapolated soil moisture time series are then evaluated against soil moisture reference time series from in-situ soil moisture sensors down to 450 cm depth.

    How to cite: Rasche, D., Blume, T., and Güntner, A.: Extrapolating field-scale near-surface soil moisture information from Cosmic Ray Neutron Sensing to greater depth, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3721, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3721, 2022.

    In recent years, models for the unsaturated hydraulic conductivity have emerged that separate the soil hydraulic conductivity to constituting conductivities of water held in soil pores by capillary forces and of water adsorbed in films on the surface of soil grains. Some models include an equivalent hydraulic conductivity that accounts for diffusive movement of water vapor. The bulk soil hydraulic conductivity for a particular matric potential is the sum of these constituting conductivities.

    The additivity attribute of the constituting conductivities relies on implicit assumptions regarding the configuration of the three domains: capillary water, water adsorbed in films, and the gas phase. These assumptions are not met in natural soils, and so alternatives to straight-forward addition are examined.

    This examination unfortunately shows that any type of averaging of the constituting hydraulic conductivities leads to a non-monotonic hydraulic conductivity curve if the capillary water content reaches zero at a distinct matric potential above oven dryness. In fact, a correct expression for the hydraulic conductivity based on physically sound configurations of the domains can be shown to be realistically unattainable, leaving us without many alternatives for the additive model.

    This being the case, an additive conductivity model and one alternative that is also unconditionally monotonic are introduced for a recently described parameterization of the soil water sigmoidal retention curve with a distinct air-entry value and a logarithmic dry branch terminating at a finite matric potential.

    How to cite: de Rooij, G. H.: The difficulty of finding conceptually correct yet practically feasible unsaturated hydraulic conductivity curves., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6499, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6499, 2022.

    EGU22-6775 | Presentations | HS8.3.1

    Preferential flow prediction—present and future 

    John R. Nimmo

    The generally accepted theory of unsaturated flow, encapsulated in the hundred-year-old Richardson-Richards equation (RRE), has been successful in many situations, especially for diffuse flow through homogeneous granular media with grains and pores of sand-size or smaller. Since the late twentieth century, some version of it has also been the most commonly applied predictor of preferential flow, typically in combination with the RRE in a dual-domain framework in which the parameters take different values in the two domains. Current knowledge of preferential flow processes, however, shows that this extension of its original use is inappropriate. Various alternative formulations have been developed for preferential flow, many of them based on film and wave concepts, but these also have limits on their applicability. They also can be prohibitively awkward to combine with RRE to account for the totality of flow in an unsaturated medium.

    Given the different dominant processes of diffuse and preferential flow, the widely used dual-domain framework is appropriate. The RRE is available for flow in the diffuse domain, but improved methods are needed for the other two fundamental components: flow in the preferential domain, and the exchange of water between domains.

    For the preferential domain, I suggest these concepts and guiding principles: (1) A flow-velocity parameterization that is generalized, not specifically tied to a particular geometrical form such as films. (2) Variability of volumetric flux that is independent of flow velocity, not inextricably linked to velocity as in the gravity term of the RRE. (3) Gravity is the only significant driving force. (4) The essential constancy and uniformity of gravitational force is a tremendous advantage, and with the absence of pure diffusive flow, it reduces the required variables to just two, flux and water content, as opposed to the triply-coupled water-content/matric-potential/conductivity variables in the RRE. Further consequences are that (a) the basic continuity equation is the central component of a partial differential equation operative within the preferential domain, and (b) flux boundary conditions are the only type possible for this domain. 

    Some guidelines for domain exchange are: (1) Flow can go in either direction, seepage as well as abstraction, depending on the diffuse-domain water content. (2) The exchange can be represented as a first-order diffusion process, from the domain interface to an internal position within the diffuse domain; this requires an additional parameter representing the effective lateral distance that this introduced water travels within the diffuse domain.

    A formulation based on these principles would require much development and testing, but if implemented with a minimal number of parameters, each of them having a physically meaningful interpretation, it could lead to a more versatile and acceptable way to predict preferential flow than is presently available.

    How to cite: Nimmo, J. R.: Preferential flow prediction—present and future, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6775, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6775, 2022.

    The agricultural production in coastal environments is challenging. In the low-lying farmlands along the Venice Lagoon, Italy, saltwater intrusion that naturally occurs in coastal environments is exacerbated by land subsidence, seawater encroachment along the main watercourses, peat oxidation, and peat-driven salinity. Sea level rise expected in the next decades will intensify seawater contamination, enhancing the threats for crop productions. In this context, mitigation strategies are fundamental to avoid the loss of agricultural land. To this end, a test of freshwater recharge through a ~200-m long buried drain was conducted in an experimental field located at the southern margin of the Venice Lagoon. The soil is mainly silt-loam with the presence of acidic peat and sandy drifts. The drain was installed in 2021 at 1.5 m depth along a sandy paleochannel crossing the area in southwest to northeast direction. It supplies the Morto Channel freshwater to the farmland taking advantage of the high hydraulic conductivity of the sandy soil and the 2-m elevation difference between the channel water level and the farmland surface. The drain was tested at the end of the 2021 maize growing season, from August, 2nd until September, 7th. Five monitoring stations were installed and equipped with a 2.5 m deep piezometer to monitor depth to the water table and electrical conductivity (ECw) and TEROS 12 (METER Group, Inc., Pullman, WA, USA) soil moisture, electrical conductivity (ECb), and temperature sensors installed at four depths (0.1, 0.3, 0.5, and 0.7 m). Three of those stations were placed along the paleochannel (S1, S2, S3), while S4 and S5 were placed outside about 30 m away. Moreover, six additional piezometers were placed at 5, 10, and 20 m from both sides of S2 station to monitor the lateral spread of freshwater supply. Stations S1 and S2 were also equipped with electrical resistivity tomography (ERT) lines crossing the recharging infrastructure. The ERT lines were 14.4 m long, electrode spacing was 0.3 m and the resistivity electrode array was dipole-dipole, obtaining a maximum depth of investigation equal to approx 2.5 m. Data were collected on five dates, two before (7/12 and 7/30) and three after the drain opening (8/10, 8/20, and 9/7). The freshwater supplied to the farmland caused an increase of resistivity at both S1 and S2, with higher resistivity differences between dates at S1, suggesting a certain effectiveness of the implemented recharge solution. The ECw measurements carried out in the piezometers show a highly variable response during the test, however ECw increased after drain closure at all piezometers. On the contrary, the effects on soil water content and ECb was negligible. The effectiveness of the strategy will be tested more deeply during the 2022 maize growing season by monitoring the effects of freshwater supply on plant stress and final crop yield.

    How to cite: Zancanaro, E., Ilaria, P., Pietro, T., and Francesco, M.: A strategy to mitigate soil and water salinity in a coastal farmland at the southern margin of the Venice Lagoon: preliminary results from a 2021 recharge test, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7543, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7543, 2022.

    The origins of the Richard’s equation date back more than a century but it is still the most commonly used model to describe variably saturated soil water movement. It requires the specification of the characteristic relationships between soil water content, tensiometric pressure and hydraulic conductivity, which can be subsumed as soil hydraulic models. Numerous soil hydraulic models and variants thereof have been developed to mimic the behaviour of natural soils, including hysteresis, macro-pore flow, and dynamic non-equilibrium flow. Despite the progress being made, it is often difficult to accurately simulate retention data derived from undisturbed field soils.

    This work presents a benchmark inverse modelling study for 1D soil water movement and field retention data from a wetting-drying cycle using state-of-the-art soil hydraulic models. The main aim is to test the ability of the different models to reproduce the field data. The soil hydraulic models tested are, among others, the van Genuchten-Mualem model (VGM, 1976, 1980), VGM with hysteresis (Kool and Parker, 1987), Brooks-Corey (1966), Dual porosity (Durner, 1994) and the non-equilibrium flow model by Diamantopoulus (2015).

    In our study, we used an implementation of the Richards equation with the highly efficient and numerically stable Methods-of-Line scheme. Best-fit estimates and parameter posterior distributions were derived using the Markov-Chain Monte Carlo sampling algorithm DREAM_ZS and time series of soil water content and tensiometric pressure. The field data shows clear signs of non-equilibrium flow. It originates from an intensively studied, inverted-lysimeter site with Pumice soils under grass from the central part of the North Island of New Zealand.

    Results demonstrate that none of the models was able to accurately mimic soil water content and tensiometric pressure data simultaneously at all times. Model deficiencies were identified particularly for the two wetting events, where all models underestimated soil water content while tensiometric pressure matched the data closely. We hypothesise that at least part of the discrepancies relate to an oversimplification of the hydraulic conductivity function for non-equilibrium flow.

    This study is limited to a single data set and by several assumptions that are commonly made in inverse parameter estimation studies. The better assessment and implementation of measurement error (structures) might alleviate (or mask) some of the discrepancies between model simulations and data. However, this is apparently not the solution to the problem. Dynamic non-equilibrium flow has been observed in natural soils in several well-conducted field experiments. Our results are just one example that demonstrates the need to improve soil hydraulic modelling by revisiting the physics of fundamental processes in natural soils. 

    How to cite: Wöhling, T. and Mietrach, R.: Richard’s equation revisited – the challenge to reconstruct non-equilibrium field retention data with soil hydraulic models, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7865, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7865, 2022.

    EGU22-9284 | Presentations | HS8.3.1

    The GEOframe Soil Plant Atmosphere Continuum Estimator (GEOSPACE) to investigate the vadose zone processes 

    Concetta D'Amato, Niccolò Tubini, Paolo Benettin, Andrea Rinaldo, and Riccardo Rigon

    This contribution illustrates the GEOframe Soil Plant Atmosphere Continuum Estimator (GEOSPACE). It is the ecohydrological model of the GEOframe system and it wants to simulate the soil-vegetation-atmosphere interactions to study and analyze the complex processes that occur in the Earth Critical Zone (CZ). The CZ is defined as the “heterogeneous, near surface environment in which complex interactions involving rock, soil, water, air, and living organism regulate the natural habitat and determine the availability of life-sustaining resources”.

    GEOSPACE is a coupled model in which the three major components are WHETGEO, GEO-ET and BrokerGEO. WHETGEO, Water Heat and Transport in GEOframe, (Tubini N. and Rigon R., 2021), solves the conservative form of Richardson-Richards equation using the Newton-Casulli-Zanolli algorithm (Casulli V. and Zanolli P., 2010) that guarantees the convergence at any time step, and the proper transition from unsaturated condition to saturated one. Besides it deals seamlessly the surface water ponding. WHETGEO also implements the numerical solution shown in Casulli and Zanolli (2005) to solve the advection-dispersion equation and describe the solute transport. GEO-ET, EvapoTranspiration in GEOframe, computes evapotranspiration according to three different formulations, the Priestley-Taylor model, Penman FAO model and GEOframe-Prospero model (Bottazzi, 2020), by considering Jarvis model (Macfarlane et al., 2004) and Ball-Berry-Leuning model (Lin et al., 2015) to compute environmental and water stress factors. BrokerGEO is the coupler component that allow the exchange of data between the other two components in memory and considers the root water uptake for the computation of the actual evapotranspiration. The GEOSPACE model was tested with the lysimeter of the “Spike II” experiment (Nehemy et al., 2019; Benettin et al., 2021) of the Ecole Polytechnic Federal de Lausanne. The analysis we carried out with GEOSPACE concern the flux partitioning of precipitation and irrigation water into evaporation and transpiration; the soil water and groundwater storage; the transport of water stable isotopes through the soil. In this research we present them and show how GEOSPACE can be used to test hypotheses on the links between the plant water status and its isotopic signatures.

    GEOSPACE is developed in Java using the Object-Oriented programming paradigm and it is completely open source, available on the GEOframe GitHub website. The code organization and its functionalities besides solving the hydrological issues are designed according to principle of open science to be inspectable and verified by third parties.

    How to cite: D'Amato, C., Tubini, N., Benettin, P., Rinaldo, A., and Rigon, R.: The GEOframe Soil Plant Atmosphere Continuum Estimator (GEOSPACE) to investigate the vadose zone processes, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9284, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9284, 2022.

    EGU22-10743 | Presentations | HS8.3.1

    Water Drop Penetration Time Revisited 

    Markus Berli, Rose Shillito, Shelby Inouye, George Nikolich, and Vic Etyemezian

    Water drop penetration time (WDPT), i.e. the time it takes for a water drop to be absorbed by the soil, is widely used as a measure of soil water repellency. Despite its popularity, little is known about the processes that govern WDPT and how WDPT is related to other soil hydraulic properties such as sorptivity. To shed some light on the physics of the WDPT, we measured apparent contact angles of sessile water drops on water repellent sand using a goniometer and compared apparent with effective contact angles of the same sand. Results showed that WDPT can be related to sorptivity by means of apparent and effective contact angles.

    How to cite: Berli, M., Shillito, R., Inouye, S., Nikolich, G., and Etyemezian, V.: Water Drop Penetration Time Revisited, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10743, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10743, 2022.

    EGU22-12503 | Presentations | HS8.3.1

    Insights on vadose zone hydrologeology within a carbonate setting: Preliminary results based on a new vadose zone monitoring system 

    Michael Schembri, Manuel Sapiano, Julian Mamo, Henry Debattista, and Ofer Dahan

    A new monitoring network was setup to adequatly assess the hydryogelogical condtions within the vadose zone in Malta. The installation of the monitoring equipment allows for the measurement of water content along the vadose zone from distinct points and along varying. Data on water content variation with time and depth was collected throughout the rainy season of 2021 and 2022 from two sites within this network. The lithology of both sites consists of alternate bands of carbonate sediments with varying levels of porosity. The data generated from these two sites allowed for the continuous tracking of water percolation within the vadose zone and therefore enabled the evaluation of water flow velocities. It was observed that the intensity and frequency of occurence of rain events controls the initiation and downward propagation of wetting fronts along the carbonate litholgical sequence within the vadose zone. The initiated wetting fronts exhibited significant variations in the velocity of the draininage process as a result of the varying lithological sequence. The velocity of the drainage process and the variations in water storage content within the vadose zone were utlised to calculate the rate of groundwater recharge for these two sites.

    How to cite: Schembri, M., Sapiano, M., Mamo, J., Debattista, H., and Dahan, O.: Insights on vadose zone hydrologeology within a carbonate setting: Preliminary results based on a new vadose zone monitoring system, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12503, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12503, 2022.

    A thorough understanding of preferential finger flow through the vadose zone is critical to deepen our knowledge on the processes of infiltration, runoff, erosion, plant growth, and contaminant transport. The paths formed during this fingered flow can be “remembered” by the soil matrix during future infiltration, even after periods of desaturation.

     

    It has been shown many times that the traditional porous media equation, Richards’ equation, is incapable of capturing this phenomenon [1]. However, recent studies demonstrate the process can be described by combining a non-equilibrium, relaxation version of Richards’ equation [2] with Preisach hysteresis (applied to the pressure-saturation relationship). In this work, the authors build upon their previously published one-dimensional work [3]. The first part of this study is to present a numerical scheme for the two-dimensional non-equilibrium Richards’ equation using operator splitting methods. The second part is a comparison to previously published experimental results that demonstrates the ability of the model to capture realistic fingering behaviour.

     

    [1] Nieber, J., et al. “Non-equilibrium model for gravity-driven fingering in water repellent soils: Formulation and 2D simulations.” Soil water repellency: occurrence, consequences and amelioration (2003): 245-258.

    [2] G C Sander et al 2008 J. Phys.: Conf. Ser. 138 012023

    [3] Roche, Warren & Murphy, K. & Flynn, Denis. (2021). Modelling preferential flow through unsaturated porous media with the Preisach model and an extended Richards Equation to capture hysteresis and relaxation behaviour. Journal of Physics: Conference Series. 1730. 012002. 10.1088/1742-6596/1730/1/012002.

    How to cite: Roche, W., Flynn, D., and Murphy, K.: Numerical Simulations for Preferential Finger Flow Using a Two-Dimensional Non-Equilibrium Richards’ Equation with Preisach Hysteresis, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13224, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13224, 2022.

    EGU22-681 | Presentations | HS8.3.4

    Patch- to hillslope-scale geodiversity: Implications for durability of dryland ecosystems under climatic changes 

    Ilan Stavi, Eli Argaman, Uri Basson, and Hezi Yizhaq

    Geodiversity encompasses the natural heterogeneity of geologic, topographic, and pedogenic systems. It determines biodiversity and dictates a range of ecosystem services. Specifically, since geodiversity regulates hydrological connectivity and soil properties, it affects the soil-water dynamics. This feature is particularly relevant for drylands, where primary productivity is predominantly determined by soil-water availability. We present results and insights obtained in a set of recent and ongoing studies in shrublands of the semi-arid Negev region of southern Israel, revealing that hillslope-scale geodiversity dictates the vitality of shrubs. The region has experienced consecutive droughts and a substantial precipitation decrease over the past two decades. In high-geodiversity hillslopes – defined with a thin (~ 0.1 m thickness) and stony calcic xerosol layer that lies on highly-weathered calcareous bedrocks – shrubs are abundant, with high species richness and high vitality. At the same time, in low-geodiversity hillslopes, defined with a thick soil layer (> 1 m thickness) and no stoniness, shrubs are very sparse and dominated by one species (Noaea mucronata (Forssk.) Asch. & Schweinf.), of which the majority have not survived the recent prolonged droughts. These studies show that hillslope-scale geodiversity alleviates the water stress imposed on the shrubs, improving their durability under long-term droughts and climate change.

    A complementary study that is currently being implemented along an aridity gradient (semi-arid, arid, and hyper-arid regions) in southern Israel reveals the substantial impact livestock trampling routes (also known as treading paths, livestock terracettes, cattle trails, migration tracks, cowtours, etc.) have on patch-scale geodiversity, consequently affecting geo-ecosystem functioning. Specifically, the extremely compacted routes minimize rainwater infiltration, thus increasing runoff-rainfall ratio. The generated runoff flows downslope, where it accumulates in shrubby patches. Thus, the shrubs experience higher soil-water availability, and are more resilient to drought episodes and climatic changes. The effect of the trampling routes is further amplified by accentuating the hillslopes’ characteristic ‘step-like profile’, which reduces hydrological connectivity at the hillslope scale, thus minimizes runoff leakage from the system. 

    Note: the study is funded by the Israel Science Foundation (ISF), grant number 602/21.

    How to cite: Stavi, I., Argaman, E., Basson, U., and Yizhaq, H.: Patch- to hillslope-scale geodiversity: Implications for durability of dryland ecosystems under climatic changes, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-681, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-681, 2022.

    Understanding and predicting water flow and solute transport at the subsurface are important for agronomical, hydrological, and environmental applications. Nevertheless, due to the heterogeneous nature of soils, those predictions are subject to significant uncertainties. Although stochastic approaches have been proposed to cope with soil heterogeneity, uncertainties in model predictions remain high due to data scarcity and lack of spatially continuous measurements. Geo-electrical methods have the potential to significantly reduce models' uncertainties due to their ability to provide continuous, extensive, and non-invasive information of the subsurface. At the core of these methods, the obtained subsurface's electrical conductivity can be translated to hydrological state-variables via site-specific hydro-electrical relations calibrated with lab or field data. However, due to soil's heterogeneity, the hydro-electrical relations can be scale-dependent.

    This work studied the impact of soil's heterogeneity at the sub-core level on the effective hydro-electrical relations scale dependency. For that purpose, synthetic soil samples with various geostatistical parameters were generated. Constant capillary pressure was applied, and water saturation maps were obtained using a van-Genuchten model and the Leverett J-function for retention and retention scaling. The water saturation maps were transformed to soil's electrical conductivity by adopting Archie's law with assumed "intrinsic" parameters. An electrical current was injected, and the corresponding electric potential was calculated. The soil's effective electrical conductivities at different spatial scales were estimated, and new effective hydro-electrical relations were calibrated for each measurement scale.

    This forward approach had shown that each soil structure has a unique signature on the effective hydro-electrical relations calibrated at different measurement scales. Following those observations, a novel stochastic inversion technique, based on an iterative Bayesian approach and Markov Chain Monte Carlo sampling, was used to confine the soil's geostatistical properties. The proposed inversion technique was tested on three different scenarios: two synthetic cases with a known structure, and one real data case based on CT images of a two-phase CO2 and brine injection at altering fractional flows. Results have shown that the proposed approach was capable of confining the soil's geostatistical parameters with high accuracy and a narrow distribution around the actual values that were tested, by calibrating the effective hydro-electrical properties at only three different measurements scales.

    How to cite: Moreno, Z.: Inferring soils' heterogeneous structure via hydro-electrical measurements at altering spatial scales , EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1051, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1051, 2022.

    EGU22-2490 | Presentations | HS8.3.4

    The influence of pore gas pressure and gas permeability on rainfall infiltration 

    Wenjing Tian, Herman Peiffer, and Benny Malengier

    Rainfall infiltration is a significant trigger that lead to slope failures. The change of pore gas pressure caused by rainfall infiltration plays an important role in the slope stability. The purpose of this research is to examine the important effect of the pore gas and the gas permeability in the process of rainfall infiltration. Firstly, Water-air-two phase flow analysis were adopted as to analyze the movement of water and gas in the process of rainfall infiltration. In order  to evaluate stability of slope, the pore gas pressure could be considered as a external load variable to incorporate in the thrust residual method which is a traditional method to evaluate slope stability. The result showed that safety factor decreased over the time when adding pore gas pressure into slope stability method compared to not consider the gas pressure, this is mainly because the pore gas pressure gradient was formed and the pore gas pressure is an important factor in the infiltration of slope stability. In addition, a numerical soil column model with the finite element method has been established for examining the effects of pore gas pressure and gas boundary condition on the rainfall infiltration. After giving the same initial conditions, the soil column under various gas permeable conditions is simulated then the influence of gas boundary permeability on infiltration intensity, pore gas pressure were also analyzed. The result showed that there is a highly relevant relationship between infiltration intensity and gas permeability on the boundary. The stable infiltration intensity is sensitive and it decreases quickly when the gas boundary permeability is at lower stage. As gas boundary permeability going up, this sensibility is declined gradually. The relationship between the infiltration intensity and gas boundary permeability can be regressed to be logarithmic. Furthermore, with the increase of gas boundary permeability, the pore gas pressure increases nonlinearly and the movement  of wetting front slows down.

    How to cite: Tian, W., Peiffer, H., and Malengier, B.: The influence of pore gas pressure and gas permeability on rainfall infiltration, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2490, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2490, 2022.

    EGU22-3012 | Presentations | HS8.3.4

    Effects of climate change on the nitrogen balance of a grassland ecosystem 

    Thomas Puetz, Mona Giraud, Jannis Groh, Horst Gerke, and Nicolas Brueggemann

    Grassland is one of the most abundant biomes in the world and important for a variety of ecosystem services. Global climate change is causing a significant increase in temperature and a change in the seasonal distribution of precipitation. The resulting variation in nitrogen turnover is site-specific and long-term experiments are needed to study these changes.
    The objective of this study was to investigate changing environmental variables on nitrogen cycling and water use efficiency of an extensively managed grassland site in a low mountain range. Data from the TERENO-SOILCan lysimeter network at the Rollesbroich and Selhausen sites were used. In a "time for space" approach, a total of nine lysimeters were filled at the initial Rollesbroich site and three of these lysimeters were moved to the Selhausen site. Compared to the initial site, the climate in Selhausen is warmer and drier, according to climate predictions.
    The results show that climate change may increase the risk of gaseous nitrogen emissions, but that low nitrogen inputs from an extensively used grassland result in only low nitrogen discharges via leachate. In addition, water use efficiency and nitrogen nutrition index will decrease if the crop suffers from water stress, making the grassland more sensitive to drought.

    How to cite: Puetz, T., Giraud, M., Groh, J., Gerke, H., and Brueggemann, N.: Effects of climate change on the nitrogen balance of a grassland ecosystem, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3012, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3012, 2022.

    Subsurface stormflow (SSF) is a direct subsurface response to a precipitation event, contributing to streamflow generation. SSF is thus all subsurface flow reaching the stream during an event, including near-stream saturation-excess overland flow triggered by SSF and return flow. Generally, SSF develops in vertically structured soils where the bedrock or a less permeable soil layer is overlaid by a permeable soil layer and vertically percolating water is, at least partially, deflected in a lateral downslope direction. SSF can also occur if groundwater levels rise into more permeable layers and water flows laterally to the stream. SSF is an elusive yet prevalent component of the runoff processes, often underestimated because a general understanding based on systematic studies across scales and sites is still lacking. However, only a standardized methodical procedure can allow us to advance our understanding by reveal general principles of SSF functioning and to provide protocols and best practices for its assessment, both experimentally and with respect to modeling. As part of this, identifying and characterizing the soil heterogeneity and the subsurface setting of the hydrologically relevant structures are among the major challenges on the way towards understanding SSF processes. These involve a high variability, presumably in combination with strongly organized patterns.

    With this contribution, we introduce the research project “Non-invasive identification and characterization of the subsurface structures and their control on SSF processes”, part of the Research Unit “Fast and invisible: conquering subsurface stormflow through an interdisciplinary multi-site approach”, recently funded by the German Research Foundation (DFG).

    This 4-years project addresses the current limitations in linking the experimental identification of subsurface structures to their numerical parameterization as required by numerical models working at larger scales. It builds on the integration of classical pedology for soil mapping and non-invasive geophysical imaging of the subsurface, and it will develop a workflow capable of accounting for such multi-source information, supported by emerging theoretical concepts for up-scaling the physical parameters to the larger domain. The systematic experimental setup provided by the Research Unit will give us the opportunity to test our approach at selected hillslopes in four highly instrumented catchments hence to evaluate the experimental results in a wider context. The subsurface characterization and derived parameterization will support various numerical models.

    The major goal of the project is to develop an operational framework for identifying and characterizing the soil heterogeneity and the subsurface structures locally and to extrapolate the physical parameters of the subsurface to the catchment scale, and ultimately gain insights into the subsurface controls on SSF generation processes and their threshold behavior.

    How to cite: Martini, E. and Hergarten, S.: Introducing the project “Non-invasive identification and characterization of the subsurface structures and their control on subsurface stormflow processes”, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4299, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4299, 2022.

    EGU22-4515 | Presentations | HS8.3.4

    Groundwater recharge using a subsurface irrigation system: A technical feasibility study 

    Rebecca Sultana, Ulrike Werban, and Thomas Vienken

    In view of humanity’s rising demand for water and rapidly depleting aquifers, managed aquifer recharge (MAR) is a proven approach to replenish groundwater resources. Different MAR techniques exist. Among them, surface spreading methods are widely used in Europe. In this method, surface water is spread over basins, furrows or trenches where water percolates through vadose zone to recharge the groundwater. This method is highly effective. However, it is associated with a number of challenges, e.g. high space requirements, installation along with removal expenses, high evaporation rate and, foremost, limited availability of the used land for other purposes during operation. A subsurface irrigation system can be an alternative solution to mitigate major limitations of surface spreading methods. However, its technical viability needs to be determined. In this research, infiltration characteristics of a subsurface irrigation system in the vadose zone was determined numerically, using Hydrus 2D/3D model for sandy soil. In addition, a test-size-scale one cubic meter soil tank experiment with a uranine tracer was set up to evaluate the model results. The wetting front velocity and pattern was traced using EC-5 soil moisture sensors and a fixedly positioned direct push optical image profile (OIP) probe. Experiments revealed that the subsurface irrigation system infiltrated 1.14 L/h/m in the considered sandy soil with a maximum percolation velocity of 9.84 cm/hr. The numerical and experimental outcomes are in good agreement and are now used to design a field application to practically assess the long-term performance of the subsurface irrigation system for managed aquifer recharge.

     

     

    How to cite: Sultana, R., Werban, U., and Vienken, T.: Groundwater recharge using a subsurface irrigation system: A technical feasibility study, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4515, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4515, 2022.

    EGU22-5036 | Presentations | HS8.3.4

    Development of a novel approach to assess the risk of physical clogging at managed aquifer recharge sites 

    Maria Chiara Lippera, Ulrike Werban, Rudy Rossetto, and Thomas Vienken

    Increasing aquifers' recharge and storage is of great importance in addressing challenges posed by climate change and growing water demand. Managed Aquifer Recharge (MAR) technologies may ensure water supply for agriculture and diminish impacts from groundwater overexploitation. The expansion of MAR solutions in Europe still requires the implementation of these waterworks at their maximum efficiency. Physical clogging is one of the main bottlenecks for these technologies. In spreading methods, during water recharge, eroded clays from surface runoff reach the infiltrating surface and intrude into the soil matrix, decreasing the basin infiltration capacity over time. The resulting loss in performance increases the operation and maintenance (O&M) costs and, in extreme cases, can lead to the MAR site's abandonment. Thus, it is vital to assess the risk of physical clogging during the MAR planning phase, extending the MAR scheme lifespan and minimising O&M costs. Our study aims to develop a comprehensive model for physical clogging transferable to multiple MAR sites, based on the characterisation of the sediment matrix and MAR operations. To achieve this, we built a semi-empirical 1D numerical model for physical clogging. Evolution in soil permeability via the Kozeny-Carman equation is computed in function of depth based on the input of fines into the soil matrix and the porous media characteristics. The vertical distribution of fines is derived through a general relationship from a systematic review of multiple studies in the literature. The model allows computing the evolution in infiltration rates over time for the MAR site and the depth of soil to be treated to restore infiltration efficiency. Preliminary validation at the field scale is conducted at a MAR infiltration basin in Suvereto, Italy. To spatially apply the model, zoning is performed through an electromagnetic induction (EMI) survey, defining areas with similar soil properties. Values of hydraulic conductivity near saturation and soil samples were collected to characterise the sediment matrix and fines content for the entire basin. Predictions of the expected decrease in infiltration capacity for spreading methods assists maintenance scheduling and reduce O&M costs for the specific site. The proposed model for physical clogging can serve as a tool for decision support when exploring a set of design alternatives prior to MAR construction.

    How to cite: Lippera, M. C., Werban, U., Rossetto, R., and Vienken, T.: Development of a novel approach to assess the risk of physical clogging at managed aquifer recharge sites, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5036, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5036, 2022.

    EGU22-5664 | Presentations | HS8.3.4

    Inverse modelling of herbicide transport during transient flow in vegetated weighable lysimeters 

    Anne Imig, Lea Augustin, Jannis Groh, Thomas Pütz, and Arno Rein

      

    Metolachlor, terbuthylazine, nicosulfuron and prosulfuron are among the typical crop protection products used on maize plantations. Leaching of those lead to a decrease of groundwater and surface water quality. Often measured individual pesticides and their metabolite concentrations in drinking water are exceeding the limit established by the European Council in drinking water. In our work we investigate contamination potential of these four herbicides to groundwater bodies using lysimeter studies and numerical modelling with HYDRUS-1D. The four herbicides were applied at specific times in the vegetation phase over a period of three years on two lysimeters located in Wielenbach, Germany. The studied lysimeters contain soil cores dominated by sandy gravel (Ly1) and clayey sandy silt (Ly2) and are both vegetated with maize. To identify governing transport and fate processes in the unsaturated zone of the lysimeters and determining dynamics and rates of these, different model structural approaches were compared. In a first step we have characterized soil hydraulic and transport parameters of each soil core by investigating stable water isotopes (δ18O and δ2H). For Ly2, model performance was improved by considering immobile water in a dual-porosity approach whereas for Ly1 a single-porosity approached seemed to yield satisfying results. This might be explained by a higher fraction of fine particles in Ly2 which can be available for water storage. Based on these findings reactive transport parameters were fitted also for root water and chemical plant uptake, sorption, and biodegradation.

    It was found that sorption plays a significant role in herbicide transport whereas root water uptake and chemical plant uptake is of minor influence. Metabolite formation was observed; however, biodegradation seems to show minor influence, only, which is also reflected by measured carbon isotopes (slight δ13C increase). Non-equilibrium and non-linear sorption were compared leading to no significant difference in model results. This was especially surprising for the charged herbicides prosulfuron and nicosulfuron. Measured herbicide concentration peaks in seepage water seemed to be connected in time with higher amounts of precipitation events indicating the influence of preferential flow. Such influences could be considered in a dual-permeability flow model setup which however was not available for stable water isotope modelling in HYDRUS-1D. Contrary to our expectations, the coarser soil of Ly1 did not lead to an increase in leached herbicides which might be explained by a higher organic matter content and thus higher sorption.

     

    How to cite: Imig, A., Augustin, L., Groh, J., Pütz, T., and Rein, A.: Inverse modelling of herbicide transport during transient flow in vegetated weighable lysimeters, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5664, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5664, 2022.

    EGU22-5954 | Presentations | HS8.3.4

    Modeling the long-term leaching of PFAS in heterogeneous vadose zones 

    Bo Guo and Jicai Zeng

    PFAS are emergent contaminants of which the fate and transport in the environment remain poorly understood. A growing body of site investigations have demonstrated that vadose zones serve as significant long-term sources of PFAS to contaminate groundwater. As surfactants, adsorption at air–water and solid–water interfaces in soils complicates the retention and leaching of PFAS. Recent modeling studies accounting for the PFAS-specific nonlinear and rate-limited adsorption processes predicted that the majority of long-chain PFAS remain in the shallow vadose zone decades after contamination ceases—in agreement with many field observations. However, some field investigations show that long-chain PFAS have migrated to tens to a hundred meters below ground surface in the vadose zone. These discrepancies may be attributed to model simplifications such as a homogeneous representation of the vadose zone. The other potentially critical process that has not been fully examined is how surfactant-induced flow (SIF) influences PFAS leaching in multidimensions.

    We develop a new three-dimensional model incorporating the PFAS-specific flow and transport processes to quantify the impact of SIF and subsurface heterogeneities. Our simulations and analyses conclude that 1) SIF has a minimal impact on the long-term leaching of PFAS in the vadose zone, 2) preferential flow pathways generated by subsurface heterogeneities lead to early arrival and accelerated leaching of (especially long-chain) PFAS, 3) acceleration of PFAS leaching in high water content preferential pathways or perched water above capillary barriers is amplified compared to conventional contaminants due to the destruction of air–water interfaces, and 4) subsurface heterogeneities are among the primary sources of uncertainty for predicting PFAS leaching and retention in the vadose zone. In addition to the specific findings, this talk will also discuss more generally the challenges and opportunities that arise from understanding and quantifying PFAS leaching in heterogeneous vadose zones.

    How to cite: Guo, B. and Zeng, J.: Modeling the long-term leaching of PFAS in heterogeneous vadose zones, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5954, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5954, 2022.

    EGU22-5968 | Presentations | HS8.3.4

    Linking lysimeter and field sensor data to investigate water flow in a heterogeneous setting at the SUPREHILL vadose zone observatory 

    Vedran Krevh, Jasmina Defterdarović, Luka Han, Lana Filipović, Zoran Kovač, Jannis Groh, Hailong He, and Vilim Filipović

    Direct measurements of water flow can provide valuable information that is not always attainable through sensors alone, however, combining methods is crucial for unlocking their full potential. Water flow monitoring is critical for the successful detection of pollutant fate in intensive agricultural production as a substantial amount of fertilizer and pesticide products are commonly used. Wick lysimeters are a common technique used for water flow measurements, where a quantity of drainage volume is measured over time. For mentioned purposes, passive wick lysimeters that maintain tension in soil by using an inert wicking material were employed in this study. This study presents a link between self-constructed passive wick lysimeters, volumetric water content sensors (TDR) and soil-water potential sensors used at the newly (2020) established SUPREHILL vadose zone observatory in Croatia, located on a hillslope vineyard. At the observatory, a network of lysimeters (x36) is installed throughout the hillslope and is accompanied by an extensive sensor network. The data from 2021 shows variability between lysimeters in regard to their position on the hillslope, as well as variability between its repetitions, suggesting the influence of soil heterogeneity at the observatory that possibly triggers preferential flow. Along with the data, a methodology for lysimeter installation and construction is presented.

    How to cite: Krevh, V., Defterdarović, J., Han, L., Filipović, L., Kovač, Z., Groh, J., He, H., and Filipović, V.: Linking lysimeter and field sensor data to investigate water flow in a heterogeneous setting at the SUPREHILL vadose zone observatory, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5968, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5968, 2022.

    EGU22-6417 | Presentations | HS8.3.4

    Detecting soil water distribution in subsurface irrigated tomato crops by coupling electrical resistivity imaging, 2D Hydrus modeling and proximal sensing techniques 

    Iael Raij Hoffman, Daniela Vanella, Juan Miguel Ramirez Cuesta, William Lennon, Thomas Harter, and Isaya Kisekka

    Nowadays there is an increasing need to improve the irrigation and fertilizer efficiency of processing tomatoes in California’s Central Valley, because they represent a major crop in this area. For agronomical and research purposes, agricultural soils are generally monitored and sampled before, during and after the season in order to establish water and fertilizer balances. However, sub-surface drip irrigation and fertigation techniques increase the already heterogeneous water and nutrient distribution in the soil, making representative measurements a challenge. In addition, the crop water status is a proxy that needs to be assessed for evaluating the response of the crop to water management.

    In this study, we coupled multiple methodologies, including electrical resistivity imaging, 2D Hydrus modeling and proximal sensing techniques, for detecting the soil water redistribution, and characterizing the relative crop water status, in a sub-surface drip irrigated processing tomato field. Specifically, soil electrical resistivity was measured by electrical resistivity tomography (ERT) in two transects during an irrigation event in parallel and perpendicular to the subsurface drip irrigation line. The time-lapse ERT transects were compared to matching 2D-HYDRUS hydrological models and the relative differences were explained by local heterogeneities in electrical resistivity and water content changes. Water contents, measured with neutron probe and TDR techniques, were compared to the changes in resistivity during the irrigation event and the heterogeneity in the different root-zone locations described. In addition, surface temperature measured using infrared thermal thermometer (IRT) showed correlations with the ERT soil resistivity changes.

    In this study, a combination between multi-dimensional soil modeling and minimally invasive techniques (geophysical and IRT) has provided specific information on local water distribution and its interaction with root water uptake. This analysis will be used to enrich TDR-measured water contents and 2D modeling of root zone soil water dynamics of processing tomatoes during the rest of the season when spatially distributed ERT data is not available.

    How to cite: Raij Hoffman, I., Vanella, D., Ramirez Cuesta, J. M., Lennon, W., Harter, T., and Kisekka, I.: Detecting soil water distribution in subsurface irrigated tomato crops by coupling electrical resistivity imaging, 2D Hydrus modeling and proximal sensing techniques, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6417, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6417, 2022.

    EGU22-6463 | Presentations | HS8.3.4

    Solute migration through unsaturated fractured chalk under variations in saturation degree, flow rate and aperture 

    Noam Weisbrod, Sari Roded, Ofra Klein-BenDavid, and Tuvia Turkeltaub

    Spent fuel (SF) produced in the nuclear industry, requires long term disposal solutions for 105-106 years, to allow its decay in an isolated setting as means to reduce the environmental threat of radioactive contamination. The feasibility of locating SF repository within a fractured carbonate formation as the host rock in the unsaturated zone, requires better understating of radionuclide transport patterns under these specific conditions. An innovative system was developed to simulate conditions of unsaturated flow and transport in fractured chalk. The system consists of an artificially fractured chalk core, situated in a flow cell, which lays on top of a ceramic membrane. The membrane separates it from a lower sealed cell where constant negative pressure is forced. Subsequently, a pressure gradient along the rock core is being developed. The system is placed on a scale in order to monitor the degree of saturation in the core throughout the experiment. Uranine fluorescent dye is used as a conservative tracer to investigate the impact of: (1) the initial degree of saturation; (2) fracture aperture; and (3) flow rate, on the transport and recovery of conservative contaminants. Preliminary results show that a conservative tracer migrates faster through the fracture when the matrix is initially nearly saturated (s=99%) than when the matrix is undersaturated (s=75%). These results will be used for comparison with radionuclide and radionuclide-simulants transport in current studies.

    How to cite: Weisbrod, N., Roded, S., Klein-BenDavid, O., and Turkeltaub, T.: Solute migration through unsaturated fractured chalk under variations in saturation degree, flow rate and aperture, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6463, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6463, 2022.

    Laterite terrain overlying the charnockite bedrock system exhibits greater lateral movement of water as compared to its vertical infiltration into the soil profile due to partial water block. Furthermore, the topographic conditions in such areas play a crucial role in the movement of soil water. The variation in the precipitation pattern, increasing population and urbanization has contributed in reducing the infiltration opportunity time for rainwater. The present study was carried out at Malappuram district of Kerala in India. Though, the study area receives an average annual rainfall of 3 m, yet experiences high baseline water stress during post monsoon season. The research study involves analysis of lateral flow from three different soil profile depths i.e. 0-0.4 m, 0.4-0.8 m and 0.8-1.2 m under two different water inducement techniques. Lateral flow monitoring was carried out in two different experimental set ups in two different sites under simulated rainfall conditions and line source of water application. Variation in the lateral flow was assessed using capacitance based sensors which were calibrated and installed at all the three respective soil profile depths. The study revealed that though the infiltration capacity of laterite soil is quite high but, the major portion of infiltrated water moved as lateral flow without contributing to the groundwater table. It was found that of the total water applied as simulated rainfall about, 10 % accounted as lateral flow from a soil profile depth of 1.2 m. During line source application of water, out of the total lateral flow recorded, the soil profile depths of 0-0.4 m, 0.4-0.8 m and 0.8-1.2 m contributed portions of 52.3 %, 43.78 % and 3.8 % as lateral flow. It was found from the study that the soil physical properties including bulk density, effective porosity and soil texture governed lateral flow in the study area. Thus, the research study emphasizes on enhancing preferential flow in vertical direction through deep rooted flora in the study area.  

    How to cite: Narayanan, J.: Lateral flow assessment in laterite terrain for better interventions in sustainable groundwater management, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7015, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7015, 2022.

    EGU22-7569 | Presentations | HS8.3.4

    Investigation of Different Trench Geometries for Optimized Bedding of Buried Power Cables 

    Maximilian Schmid, Hung Pham, Markus Schedel, and Ingo Sass

    For an efficient integration of renewable energies, many transmission lines of the electrical power grid have to be extended or newly built. Besides the common overhead transmission lines, an increasing proportion of these grid expansions is conducted using underground power cables.

    During the operation of buried cable systems, the mechanical and thermal properties of the cable’s surroundings need to meet certain requirements. To avoid insulation faults in the cables due to overheating, the ampacity is limited by specific conductor temperatures and the thermal energy resulting from the electric losses during transmission needs to be reliably dissipated. Thus, the actual performance of a buried power cable system depends strongly on the thermal properties of the cable bedding materials and soil.

    In practice, buried power cable lines typically require the use of cable trenches. The pre-existing soil from the cable trench is usually replaced by sand or artificial fluidized backfill materials with well-known material properties, which may differ from the properties of the surrounding soil. Thus, heterogeneous structures are created in the shallow subsurface, which affect the heat and water transport around the power cables. With an installation depth of 0.5 - 2.5 m, the cables are typically located in the vadose zone, where the thermal properties of the bedding are affected by the varying water content by up to one order of magnitude. Therefore, precise knowledge of the influence of size and geometry of the cable trench on the water distribution around the cable is crucial for an adequate assessment of the cable’s ampacity ratings.

    Within the scope of our research, the influence of cable trench geometry and size on heat and mass transfer around buried power cables were investigated with a coupled approach of laboratory experiments and numerical modeling.

    How to cite: Schmid, M., Pham, H., Schedel, M., and Sass, I.: Investigation of Different Trench Geometries for Optimized Bedding of Buried Power Cables, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7569, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7569, 2022.

    EGU22-8056 | Presentations | HS8.3.4

    Combined modeling and high-resolution monitoring approach for the assessment of nitrate-related redox processes at an agricultural site 

    Juan Carlos Richard-Cerda, Edinsson Muñoz-Vega, Kay Knöller, Christoph Schüth, and Stephan Schulz

    Biogeochemical redox processes control the chemical behavior of many major and trace elements. Nitrogen is particularly sensitive to changes in soil redox conditions and its presence also affects the cycles of other redox-sensitive species, which causes its excessive application through agricultural fertilizers to be a multi-faceted problem.

    To assess these processes, we constructed a high-resolution monitoring station at an agricultural site featuring sensors and sampling facilities for analyzing hydraulics and hydrogeochemistry in the vadose zone and shallow groundwater. Monitoring has been performed for over two years during which different types of crops such as dill, spinach, wheat, and sunflower have been grown on the site. Observed variations of the oxidation-reduction potential over time and depth confirm the transient behavior of the redox reactive zone, whose variation is consistent with the fluctuation of the groundwater level. Also, a strong decrease in NO3- concentrations could be observed. This corresponds to changes over depthin both the sulfateconcentration and δ34S-SO42- signatures, whichconfirms the presence of autotrophic denitrification using sulfur as an electron donor. Moreover, a hydraulic model coupled with a heat transport model was set up for the estimation over depth of water fluxes, water content, and temperatures. In combination with the monitored concentrations, this allows us to estimate solute fluxes.

    Preliminary results indicate an average nitrate input to groundwater of 200 kg·ha-1·a-1, which is almost completely reduced in the shallow groundwater. However, at the same time, a production of only 25 kg·ha-1·a-1 of sulfate is estimated, which indicates that not only sulfur serves as an electron donor, and thus heterotrophic denitrification must also be taking place. This can be confirmed based on increased bicarbonate concentrations in the reactive zone. Furthermore, other nitrate-triggered redox processes were detected, including selenium accumulation at the redox interface, presumably resulting from seleno-pyrite-driven denitrification and geogenic uranium roll-front mobilization.

    How to cite: Richard-Cerda, J. C., Muñoz-Vega, E., Knöller, K., Schüth, C., and Schulz, S.: Combined modeling and high-resolution monitoring approach for the assessment of nitrate-related redox processes at an agricultural site, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8056, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8056, 2022.

    EGU22-8238 | Presentations | HS8.3.4

    Hydrological partitioning of soil water in a hillslope segment using dual continuum model 

    Jaromir Dusek and Tomas Vogel

    The existence of a hydraulically interconnected macropore network in the soil profile and the activation of preferential flow through this network during major rainfall events represent a significant difficulty in quantifying the temporal origin of soil water fluxes. The hydrograph separation technique based on the transport of stable water isotopes (or other conservative tracers) in soils in conjunction with a mass balance approach is usually used to partition the runoff into pre-event and event water contributions. For hillslopes located in a temperate climate, the pre-event water is recognized to form a dominant fraction of a stormflow hydrograph. In this study, one- and two-dimensional dual continuum models were used to study the preferential flow of water and the transport of oxygen-18 isotope in a hillslope segment located in a temperate spruce forest. The dual continuum model divides the heterogeneous bulk soil into the soil matrix and the preferential flow domain, with a possible exchange of water and isotope content between the domains. The isotopic composition of the hillslope flow shows distinct signatures of the preferential flow paths and the soil matrix due to the nonequilibrium conditions between the domains. As a result, imperfect mixing of the isotope tracer within the hillslope soil is predicted, leading to isotopically different water pools in the soil matrix and preferential pathways. Despite the dominant role of preferential flow in the generation of hillslope stormflow, the pre-event water formed 52–84% of the total subsurface stormflow, as reflected in the measured isotopic composition of shallow subsurface runoff.

    How to cite: Dusek, J. and Vogel, T.: Hydrological partitioning of soil water in a hillslope segment using dual continuum model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8238, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8238, 2022.

    EGU22-10554 | Presentations | HS8.3.4

    Impact of structural heterogeneity on solute transport and mixing in unsaturated porous media: An experimental study 

    Oshri Borgman, Francesco Gomez, Tanguy Le Borgne, and Yves Méheust

    Solute transport in unsaturated porous media plays a crucial role in environmental processes affecting soils, the unsaturated zone, and aquifers lying below. These processes include nutrient and pesticide leaching in soils, contaminant migration to aquifers and degradation in the vadose zone, and nutrient exchange at the soil-river interface, to name a few. Natural porous media are characterized by structural heterogeneity in the pore sizes disorder and their spatial arrangements. The impact of pore size heterogeneity on the spreading and mixing of a solute plume, and the resulting reaction rates, are not well understood for unsaturated flow. In addition, these processes can be affected by incomplete mixing at the pore scale. Thus, direct pore-scale experimental measurements are needed to gain a comprehensive understanding of the mixing state of the system. Our goals are to 1) study the impact of structural heterogeneity on fluid phase distributions and 2) establish how the arrangement of fluid phases impacts solute spreading and mixing. We use micromodel experiments with two-dimensional porous media. The samples are created by placing an array of circular posts in a Hele-Shaw-type flow cell. We vary the heterogeneity by controlling the circular posts’ diameters disorder and correlation length of their spatial distribution. In the first stage of each experiment, we simultaneously inject liquid and air to establish an unsaturated flow pattern with a connected liquid phase cluster. Then, we introduce a conservative fluorescent solute pulse with the moving liquid phase. We track the solute concentration and gradients’ evolution by taking periodic images of the flow cell and analyzing their fluorescence intensity. In addition to unsaturated flow experiments, our system allows us to study the impact of pore size disorder and correlation on solute mixing in saturated porous media and even directly quantifying fast reaction products’ concentrations. Initial results confirm previous findings on the impact of desaturation on enhanced mixing rates for a single porous medium geometry. In addition, our use of a continuous solute pulse highlights regions that maintain a high mixing rate at the interface between mobile and stagnant liquid phase parts. Ongoing experiments explore the impact of increasing pore size disorder and correlation length on fluid phase distributions and mixing rates.

    How to cite: Borgman, O., Gomez, F., Le Borgne, T., and Méheust, Y.: Impact of structural heterogeneity on solute transport and mixing in unsaturated porous media: An experimental study, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10554, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10554, 2022.

    EGU22-712 | Presentations | HS8.3.5

    Biogels in the rhizosphere: Plant mucilage as a biofilm matrix that shapes the rhizosphere microbial habitat 

    Meisam Nazari, Samuel Bickel, Pascal Benard, Kyle Mason-Jones, Andrea Carminati, and Michaela Anna Dippold

    Mucilage is a gelatinous high-molecular-weight substance produced by almost all plants, serving numerous functions for plants and soil. To date, research has mainly focused on the hydraulic and physical functions of mucilage in the rhizosphere. Studies on the relevance of mucilage as a microbial habitat are scarce. Microbial research has largely focused on extracellular polymeric substances (EPS), gelatinous high-molecular-weight substances produced by microorganisms. In soil, EPS support the establishment of microbial assemblages by providing a moist environment, a protective barrier, and serving as carbon and nutrient sources. Our analyses show that mucilage shares the physical and chemical properties of EPS. Mucilage covers large extents of the rhizosphere and could function similarly to the biofilm matrix. Our laboratory and theoretical analyses largely confirmed similar viscosity and surface tension as important physical properties and polysaccharide, protein, neutral monosaccharide, and uronic acid composition as major chemical properties. Our study suggests that mucilage provides functions of EPS required for biofilm formation. Mucilage offers a protected habitat optimized for nutrient mobilization and provides carbon and nutrients. We suggest that the function of mucilage as a biofilm matrix and enabler of high rhizo-microbial abundance and activity has been strongly underestimated, and should be considered as an essential component of conceptual models of the rhizosphere. 

    How to cite: Nazari, M., Bickel, S., Benard, P., Mason-Jones, K., Carminati, A., and Dippold, M. A.: Biogels in the rhizosphere: Plant mucilage as a biofilm matrix that shapes the rhizosphere microbial habitat, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-712, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-712, 2022.

    EGU22-1596 | Presentations | HS8.3.5

    No effect of long-term soil warming on diffusive soil inorganic and organic nitrogen fluxes in a temperate forest soil 

    Erich Inselsbacher, Jakob Heinzle, Ye Tian, Steve Kwatcho-Kengdo, Chupei Shi, Werner Borken, Wolfgang Wanek, and Andreas Schindlbacher

    The capacity of forest plants to sequester C is closely linked to soil nitrogen (N) availability, a major control of plant growth and ecosystem functioning. An increase of soil temperature caused by climate change affects C and N cycling in forest soils, but implications for plant available N have remained largely unclear. In recent short-term laboratory incubation studies, an increase in soil temperature has not only led to a significant increase in diffusive N fluxes, but also to a concomitant shift in bioavailable N quality for plant and microbial uptake, i.e. towards a higher proportion of inorganic N forms compared to small organic N forms such as amino acids. However, long-term effects of soil warming on diffusive soil N fluxes in situ remain largely unknown. Applying the microdialysis technique, we quantified in situ diffusive fluxes of amino acids, ammonium and nitrate at the long-term soil warming experimental site Achenkirch (Tyrol, Austria). This site is one of the few climate manipulation experiments operational for more than 15 years and has already provided a wealth of novel insights into the potential effects of global warming on forest ecosystem responses. Results from four sampling campaigns (n = 1152 microdialysis samples) during the growing season showed no effect of warming on diffusive N fluxes. Diffusive ammonium fluxes increased from spring towards autumn while nitrate fluxes followed an opposite trend. Compared to other temperate and boreal forest soils, the proportion of amino acids in the total diffusive N flux in this carbonate soil was low (13 - 30%), while the proportions of ammonium (21 – 67%) and nitrate were high (19 – 58%). In conclusion, our results suggest that in situ diffusive N fluxes, as well as the proportions of different N forms, were unaffected after 15 years of soil warming.  Accordingly, warming may not be expected to increase diffusive soil N supply for root uptake in the topsoil in the long run. Diffusive N availability was mainly determined by seasonal effects and by the small-scale heterogeneity of the soil matrix.

    How to cite: Inselsbacher, E., Heinzle, J., Tian, Y., Kwatcho-Kengdo, S., Shi, C., Borken, W., Wanek, W., and Schindlbacher, A.: No effect of long-term soil warming on diffusive soil inorganic and organic nitrogen fluxes in a temperate forest soil, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1596, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1596, 2022.

    EGU22-1748 | Presentations | HS8.3.5

    Effect of adaptive rootzone development in quantitative land evaluation studies 

    Martin Mulder, Marius Heinen, and Mirjam Hack - ten Broeke

    For quantitative land evaluation studies often simulation models are used to express the differences between soil types in terms of water availability or crop productivity. In the Netherlands we developed a land evaluation system specifically for water authorities, provinces and drinking water companies. The system allows answering questions on how water management influences crop development due to too dry or too wet conditions in the unsaturated zone. This system is based on the linked simulation model SWAP (Soil-Water-Atmosphere-Plant) and WOFOST (WOrld FOod STudies). The impact of changes in climate or hydrology can then be studied in terms of effects on crop growth and farm income.

    Although SWAP and WOFOST are process based models, the rootzone development is simulated in a straightforward way: the development of the root extension is specified by the user in advance and the root length density distribution is assumed static in time. Because the circumstances within the rootzone is influenced by meteorological, hydrological and soil characteristics it is impossible to design an optimal rootzone development in advance. For a more realistic approach we implemented an adaptive rootzone distribution which will react on the hydrological conditions within the rootzone. This means that newly formed roots will be assigned to regions where there is no or the least stress, and less or no new roots to regions where water stress was experienced. As a result the drought and oxygen stress will be less dependent on the initial root distribution as specified by the user. An example for a regional study will be provided to show the relevance of adaptive rootzone development for assessing land qualities in space and time. 

    How to cite: Mulder, M., Heinen, M., and Hack - ten Broeke, M.: Effect of adaptive rootzone development in quantitative land evaluation studies, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1748, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1748, 2022.

    Soil pollution from neutral and ionizable compounds poses a significant threat to water resources management and food production. The development of numerical models to describe their reactive transport in the soil-plant domain is of paramount importance to elaborate mitigation strategies. However, most existing models simplify the description of physicochemical processes in soil and plants, mass transfer processes between soil and plants and in plants, and transformation in plants. To fill this scientific gap, we first coupled the widely used hydrological model, HYDRUS, with a multi-compartment dynamic plant uptake model, which accounts for differentiated multiple metabolization pathways in plant’s tissues. The model, which is able to simulate the reactive transport of neutral compounds, has been successfully validated against experimental data, and integrated in the Graphical User Interface of the HYDRUS software suite. To further extend its domain of applicability, we have recently adapted its theoretical framework to simulate the translocation of ionizable compounds. The new modeling framework connects a biophysical multi-organelles model to describe processes at the cell level with a semi-mechanistic soil-plant model, and accounts for dissociation processes and electrical interactions with cell biomembranes. Validation against experimental data showed encouraging results and opens new perspectives for its use for predictive and explanatory purposes.

     

    References

    Šimůnek, J., G. Brunetti, and R. Kodešová, Modeling the translocation and transformation of chemicals in the soil-plant continuum: A dynamic plant uptake module for the HYDRUS model, AGU Annual Meeting, ID 810092, New Orleans, Louisiana, December 13-17, 2021.

    How to cite: Brunetti, G., Šimůnek, J., and Kodešová, R.: Modeling the translocation and transformation of chemicals in the soil-plant continuum: a dynamic plant uptake module for the HYDRUS model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1962, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1962, 2022.

    EGU22-3466 | Presentations | HS8.3.5

    Coupled modelling of hydrological processes and grassland production in two contrasting climates 

    Nicholas Jarvis, Jannis Groh, Katharina Meurer, Elisabet Lewan, Thomas Puetz, Walter Durka, Cornelia Baessler, and Harry Vereecken

    Projections of global climate models suggest that ongoing human-induced climate change will lead to an increase in the frequency of severe droughts in many important agricultural regions of the world. Eco-hydrological models that integrate current understanding of the interacting processes governing soil water balance and plant growth may be useful tools to predict the impacts of climate change on crop production. However, the validation status of these models for making predictions under climate change is still unclear, since few suitable datasets are available for model testing. One promising approach is to test models using data obtained in “space-for-time” substitution experiments, in which samples are transferred among locations with contrasting current climates in order to mimic future climatic conditions. An important advantage of this approach is that the soil type is the same, so that differences in soil properties are not confounded with the influence of climate on water balance and crop growth. In this study, we evaluate the capability of a relatively simple eco-hydrological model to reproduce 6 years (2013-2018) of measurements of soil water contents, water balance components and grass production made in weighing lysimeters located at two sites within the TERENO-SoilCan network in Germany. Three lysimeters are located at an upland site at Rollesbroich with a cool, wet climate, while three others had been moved from Rollesbroich to a warmer and drier climate on the lower Rhine valley floodplain at Selhausen. Four of the most sensitive parameters in the model were treated as uncertain within the framework of the GLUE (Generalized Likelihood Uncertainty Estimation) methodology, while the remaining parameters in the model were set according to site measurements or data in the literature.

    The model accurately reproduced the measurements at both sites, and some significant differences in the posterior ranges of the four uncertain parameters were found. In particular, the results indicated greater stomatal conductance as well an increase in dry matter allocation below-ground and a significantly larger maximum root depth for the three lysimeters that had been moved to Selhausen. As a consequence, the apparent water use efficiency (above-ground harvest divided by evapotranspiration) was significantly smaller at Selhausen than Rollesbroich. Data on species abundance on the lysimeters provide one possible explanation for the differences in the plant traits at the two sites derived from model calibration. These observations showed that the plant community at Selhausen had changed significantly in response to the drier climate, with a significant decrease in the abundance of herbs and an increase in the proportion of grass species. The differences in root depth and leaf conductance may also be a consequence of plasticity or acclimation at the species level. Regardless of the reason, we may conclude that such adaptations introduce significant additional uncertainties into model predictions of water balance and plant growth in response to climate change.

    How to cite: Jarvis, N., Groh, J., Meurer, K., Lewan, E., Puetz, T., Durka, W., Baessler, C., and Vereecken, H.: Coupled modelling of hydrological processes and grassland production in two contrasting climates, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3466, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3466, 2022.

    The knowledge of crop evapotranspiration is crucial for several hydrological processes, including those related to the management of agricultural water sources. Among indirect methods to estimate actual evapotranspiration, ETa, the measurements of latent heat fluxes acquired with Eddy Covariance (EC) tower have been largely used. However, the malfunctioning of the commonly installed sensors can cause the loss of data, compromising the temporal continuity of the acquisitions. Machine learning (ML) algorithms can represent a powerful tool to perform gap-filling procedures and provide accurate predictions of missing data.

    The objective of the research was to assess different ML algorithms to fill daily actual evapotranspiration measurements acquired in a Mediterranean citrus orchard, by using a combination of in-situ or ERA5-Land reanalysis agro-meteorological data and two vegetation indices (VIs) retrieved by the Sentinel 2 platform.

    The experimental layout consisted of a standard weather station, an EC tower containing an open-patch gas-analyzer, a three-dimension sonic anemometer, a four-component net radiometer. Four “drill and drop” probes (Sentek Pty Ltd, Stepney, Australia) were also installed in the field. Six different algorithms of machine learning were tested, using in input, as climate variables the global solar radiation, mean air temperature and relative air humidity, as well as two VIs (NDVI e NDWI) characterized by a spatial resolution of 10 m and, finally, the average soil water content measured in the root zone (0-50 cm). The number of daily ETa measurements, acquired from March 2019 to September 2021, resulted in about 70% of the total days of the period; the missing data were caused by the malfunctioning of installed instruments, which occurred during the lockdown restrictions caused by the pandemic.

    Among the different ML algorithms, the best performance was associated with the Gaussian Process Regression (GPR) based on nonparametric kernel probabilistic function (Rasmussen, 2006) when, with the other input variables, the average soil water content was included; in this case, the values of root mean square error (RMSE) and determination coefficient (R2) associated with the cross-validation resulted equal to 0.42 mm/d and 0.85, respectively. However, suitable results were also associated with the GPR model, when assuming, as input variables, on-site meteorological data and VIs (RMSE=0.49 mm/d and R2=0.78), or when considering the ERA5-Land meteorological variables (RMSE=0.56 mm/d and R2=0.73). The joint use of agro-meteorological and remote sensing data, associated with a GPR model, can therefore provide the opportunity to fill the gaps of ETa time-series.

    How to cite: Ippolito, M., De Caro, D., and Provenzano, G.: Assessing Machine Learning algorithms to fill gaps of daily evapotranspiration measured in a citrus orchard using a combination of agro-meteorological and remote sensing data, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3533, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3533, 2022.

    EGU22-3890 | Presentations | HS8.3.5

    Responsiveness of maize to soil drying is related to a decrease in belowground hydraulic conductivity 

    Tina Köhler, Shu-Yin Tung, Franziska Steiner, Nicolas Tyborski, Andreas Wild, Asegidew Akale, Johanna Pausch, Tillmann Lüders, Sebastian Wolfrum, Carsten Müller, Alix Vidal, Wouter Vahl, Jennifer Groth, Barbara Eder, Mutez Ahmed, and Andrea Carminati

    Limited water supply is one of the largest impediments to food production worldwide in the light of climate change and increasing food demand. Stomatal regulation allows plants to promptly react to water stress and regulate water use. Although the coordination between stomatal closure and aboveground hydraulics has extensively been studied, our understanding of the impact of belowground hydraulics on stomatal regulation remains, as yet, incomplete. The overall objective of this study was to investigate the impact of belowground hydraulic conductivity as affected by differences in expressions of root and rhizosphere traits on the water use regulation of different maize genotypes.

    We have utilized a novel phenotyping facility to investigate the response of a selection of 48 maize (Zea mays L.) genotypes exhibiting different root and rhizosphere traits to soil drying. We measured the relation between leaf water potential, soil water potential, soil water content and transpiration rate, as well as root and rhizosphere traits (e.g. root length, rhizosheath mass) between genotypes. Our hypothesis is that stomatal response to soil drying is related to a loss in soil hydraulic conductivity and that key root and rhizosphere hydraulic traits affect such relation.

    We found that the genotypes differed in their responsiveness to drought and that such differences were related to belowground hydraulic traits. The critical soil water content at which plants started to decrease transpiration was related to a combination of plant- and rhizosphere traits (namely plant hydraulic conductance, maximum transpiration rate, root length and rhizosheath mass). Genotypes with a higher maximum transpiration rate and a higher plant hydraulic conductance and a smaller root system closed stomata in wetter soil conditions, meaning earlier in the drying process. This finding is explained by a soil-plant hydraulic model that assumes that stomata start to close when the soil hydraulic conductance of the soil-plant continuum starts to decline. Those findings stress the importance of belowground hydraulic properties on stomatal regulation and thereby drought responsiveness.

    How to cite: Köhler, T., Tung, S.-Y., Steiner, F., Tyborski, N., Wild, A., Akale, A., Pausch, J., Lüders, T., Wolfrum, S., Müller, C., Vidal, A., Vahl, W., Groth, J., Eder, B., Ahmed, M., and Carminati, A.: Responsiveness of maize to soil drying is related to a decrease in belowground hydraulic conductivity, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3890, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3890, 2022.

    EGU22-4020 | Presentations | HS8.3.5

    High-throughput phenotyping of 38 maize varieties for the study of rhizosphere traits affecting agronomic resilience under drought stress 

    Shu-Yin Tung, Tina Köhler, Andreas J. Wild, Franziska Steiner, Nicolas Tyborski, Johanna Pausch, Tillmann Lüders, Carsten W. Müller, Alix Vidal, Andrea Carminati, Wouter Vahl, Jennifer Groth, Barbara Eder, and Sebastian Wolfrum

    The occurrence of drought is likely to increase and intensify as a result of climate change, which poses a great challenge to agriculture. It is thus crucial to enhance agronomic resilience to secure food and feed production. Roots and root functioning as well as the interplay of roots with the surrounding soil, the rhizosphere, plays a key role in water acquisition of plants. Investigating rhizosphere traits is hence promising to shed light on future crops that better adapt to drought stress. A great strength of this study is the screening of various varieties which is facilitated by the high-throughput phenotyping method. It allows a wider coverage of traits and especially the genetic and phenetic diversities preserved in landraces.

    Maize (Zea mays L.), being one of the major cereal crops worldwide, was selected as the plant of study. A total of 38 varieties, which encompasses hybrid varieties, open pollinated varieties, and landraces, were screened in the “Moving Fields”, a greenhouse equipped with the high-throughput phenotyping facility in the Bavarian State Research Center for Agriculture. Maize plants were grown in mesocosms filled with loamy soil. Plants were exposed to two water treatments, well-watered and drought-stressed, during vegetative stem extension stage. Dynamic plant development was captured by continuous image acquisition. A visible light (RGB) camera was used to document the size and architecture of shoots and roots, while a chlorophyll fluorescence camera recorded the metabolic activity of shoots.

    Using shoot images, we compared variety-specific plant growth curves under well-watered and drought-stressed conditions to highlight the growth strategy of plants towards drought stress. The results reveal differences in growth inhibition during drought across varieties. In addition, differences in shoot and root dry weights are found between landraces and modern varieties. More analyses are in progress in search of rhizosphere traits and their influences on agronomic resilience.

    How to cite: Tung, S.-Y., Köhler, T., Wild, A. J., Steiner, F., Tyborski, N., Pausch, J., Lüders, T., Müller, C. W., Vidal, A., Carminati, A., Vahl, W., Groth, J., Eder, B., and Wolfrum, S.: High-throughput phenotyping of 38 maize varieties for the study of rhizosphere traits affecting agronomic resilience under drought stress, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4020, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4020, 2022.

    EGU22-4367 | Presentations | HS8.3.5

    Stomatal closure under drought is controlled by below-ground hydraulics 

    Mohanned Abdalla, Mutez Ahmed, Gaochao Cai, Fabian Wankmüller, Nimrod Schwartz, Or Litig, Mathieu Javaux, and Andrea Carminati

    Stomatal closure allows plants to promptly respond to water shortage. Although the coordination between stomatal regulation, leaf and xylem hydraulics has been extensively investigated, the impact of below-ground hydraulics on stomatal regulation remains unknown.

    We used a novel root pressure chamber to measure, during soil drying, the relation between transpiration rate (E) and leaf xylem water pressure (ψleaf-x) in tomato shoots grafted onto two contrasting rootstocks, a long and a short one. In parallel, we also measured the E(ψleaf-x) relation without pressurization. A soil–plant hydraulic model was used to reproduce the measurements. We hypothesize that (1) stomata close when the E(ψleaf-x) relation becomes non-linear and (2) non-linearity occurs at higher soil water contents and lower transpiration rates in short-rooted plants.

    The E(ψleaf-x) relation was linear in wet conditions and became non-linear as the soil dried. Changing below-ground traits (i.e. root system) significantly affected the E(ψleaf-x) relation during soil drying. Plants with shorter root systems required larger gradients in soil water pressure to sustain the same transpiration rate and exhibited an earlier non-linearity and stomatal closure.

    We conclude that, during soil drying, stomatal regulation is controlled by below-ground hydraulics in a predictable way. The model suggests that the loss of hydraulic conductivity occurred in soil. These results prove that stomatal regulation is intimately tied to root and soil hydraulic conductances.

    How to cite: Abdalla, M., Ahmed, M., Cai, G., Wankmüller, F., Schwartz, N., Litig, O., Javaux, M., and Carminati, A.: Stomatal closure under drought is controlled by below-ground hydraulics, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4367, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4367, 2022.

    EGU22-5105 | Presentations | HS8.3.5

    Rapeseed reaches 4 meters depth – but does it escape drought stress? 

    Camilla Rasmussen, Eva Rosenqvist, Fulai Liu, Dorte Bodin Dresbøll, Kristian Thorup-Kristensen, and Mathieu Javaux

    Deep-rooted crops, such as rapeseed have access to deep stored soil moisture unavailable to more shallow-rooted crops. However, it appears that the presence of deep roots in moist soil does not necessarily ensure full water supply and prevent drought stress during progressive soil drying. Thus, there is a need to quantify the contribution of deep roots to water uptake and investigate the role of deep roots in delaying drought stress.

    In large parts of Europe, climate change will lead to lower precipitation in the growing season and higher outside the growing season. This imbalance can be levelled out by growing summer crops on winter precipitation. However, it requires crops that a capable of utilizing previous surplus precipitation stored deep in the soil profile.

    We grew rapeseed in a large-scale semi-field setup, allowing root growth down to 4 meters depth. We monitored the development in root growth, water uptake, stomatal conductance, leaf ABA, photosynthesis, and soil water content during progressive soil drying. This allowed us to investigate the ability of rapeseed to compensate for a lack of water in the upper root zone with water uptake in the deeper root zone and to identify the onset of stress responses.

    How to cite: Rasmussen, C., Rosenqvist, E., Liu, F., Dresbøll, D. B., Thorup-Kristensen, K., and Javaux, M.: Rapeseed reaches 4 meters depth – but does it escape drought stress?, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5105, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5105, 2022.

    EGU22-5306 | Presentations | HS8.3.5

    Dynamics and reversibility of global hydropatterning in a split-root experiment 

    Samuele Ceolin, Stanislaus Schymanski, Dagmar van Dusschoten, Robert Koller, Daniel Pflugfelder, and Julian Klaus

    Plant water uptake is often a limiting factor for above-ground productivity and therefore models of soil-vegetation-atmosphere transfer strongly rely on a precise characterization of the spatial organization of root systems. However, roots display plasticity in morphology and physiology under environmental fluctuations. Plants, in fact, can adjust their root length distribution to soil moisture. The phenomenon of hydropatterning consists of preferential lateral root development in water-rich soil areas and suppression of lateral root growth in dry soil areas. The preferential root growth in wet soil areas was previously observed in large portions of root systems exposed to wet soil patches, including diverse types of roots and both pre-existing and newly grown roots. Here we refer to this phenomenon as “global hydropatterning”. However, the capacity of the root systems to adapt to fluctuating soil water availability at daily time scales, for example after a rainfall event, are less clear.

    We conducted an experiment with the aim to answer the following research questions: (a) can we detect global hydropatterning in response to a water pulse in a hydraulically isolated soil layer, (b) how fast does global hydropatterning occur and (c) does the phenomenon get interrupted in the previously wetted layer and promoted in another layer when a second pulse is applied there?

    We grew maize in 45 cm long cylindrical soil columns organized in four hydraulically isolated soil layers separated by vaseline barriers. After six days of water depletion by the plant, water pulses to reach 15% VWC were injected specifically into selected layers while the remaining layers remained unwatered.

    For quantifying dynamic responses of the root systems to the water pulses, we measured root distribution repeatedly and non-destructively every 48 hours using a Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) for four weeks. Vertical soil moisture distribution was quantified using the Soil Water Profiler (SWaP) [1].

    A preliminary analysis indicates that roots grew preferentially in layers where water pulses had been applied and that allocation to root growth changed dynamically in response to water pulses. Our non-invasive measurements suggest that the global hydropatterning appears in less than 48 hours, and that plants adjust root growth to highly dynamic soil moisture conditions.

    A more detailed analysis of root growth rates in response to water pulses in different soil layers will be presented and will provide insights into the response time of maize root systems to changing soil moisture conditions and in how far allocation of carbon to different portions of the root system is an absolute response to soil moisture or a relative response to soil moisture distribution.

     

    [1] van Dusschoten, D., Kochs, J., Kuppe, C., Sydoruk, V.A., Couvreur, V., Pflugfelder, D., Postma, J.A., 2020. Spatially resolved root water uptake determination using a precise soil water sensor. Plant Physiol. https://doi.org/10.1104/pp.20.00488

    How to cite: Ceolin, S., Schymanski, S., van Dusschoten, D., Koller, R., Pflugfelder, D., and Klaus, J.: Dynamics and reversibility of global hydropatterning in a split-root experiment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5306, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5306, 2022.

    EGU22-7304 | Presentations | HS8.3.5

    A new root water uptake sink term including root-rhizosphere hydraulic architecture 

    Daniel Leitner, Andrea Schnepf, and Jan Vanderborght

    Water and nutrient uptake are essential for plant productivity. Therefore, the development of precise functional-structural root models will enable better agricultural management in particular in resource limited environments. In such models water movement is of special importance since the rhizosphere's biochemical reactions are strongly  influenced by water content and water movement. We present a general sink term for larger scale root water uptake models that includes the root-rhizosphere hydraulic architecture.

    We derive the new aggregated sink term from a more complex model that describes the rhizosphere around each root segment in dependence of a hydraulic root system model. We use CPlantBox (Schnepf et al. 2018) to represent root architecture, and calculate water movement within the root system using the hybrid analytical solution of Meunier et al. (2017). Around each root segment we represent water movement within the rhizosphere by a 1D axisymmetric model. Such models are flexible in the way the rhizosphere is represented (Mai et al. 2019). They are able to accurately describe water depletion and redistribution, but are computationally expensive. 

    To simplify the model we use the analytical solution of the steady rate approximation following (Schröder et al. 2008) for water movement in the 1D axisymmetric models. The analytic solution depends on the matric potentials of the macroscopic soil (which is calculated in 1D, 2D or 3D) and the hydraulic root architecture model, root radial conductivity, and radius of the rhizosphere domain. We use fixed-point iteration to determine the matric potential at the soil root interface and store the solutions in a look up table for speedup.  

    Moving to larger scales it is generally not useful to keep track of all root system architectures. Therefore, we aim for a coarser approximation of the root architecture by representing it as detached parallel root segments. Parallel segment conductivities are based on standard uptake fraction (SUF) and root system conductivity (Krs) of the original topology (Couvreur et al. 2012), which was shown by Vanderborght et al. (2021) to be a close approximation of the uptake by the original root topology. This approach makes the computation of the full root hydraulic architecture model superfluous, leading to a stable and performant sink term. 

    This new sink term increases the accuracy of water uptake in a suite of larger scale models including crop modes, earth system models, and hydrological models. Using the presented approach, the sink term can be derived directly from 3D root hydraulic architecture. This avoids parameterizations based on proxy information about root system hydraulics and can acknowledge age dependent axial and radial root segment hydraulic conductances. Finally, information about rhizosphere hydraulic properties, which may differ from bulk soil hydraulic properties can be injected effectively in this sink term model.  

     

    References

    Schnepf, A., et al. (2018) Annals of botany, 121(5) 1033-1053.

    Meunier, F. et al. Applied Mathematical Modelling, 52, 648-663.

    Mai, TH., et al. Plant and Soil, 439(1), 273-292.

    Schröder, et al. (2008) Vadose Zone Journal 7(3), 1089-1098.

    Couvreur, V.,  et al. (2012) Hydrology and Earth System Sciences, 16(8), 2957-2971.

    Vanderborght, J.,  et al. (2021) Hydrology and Earth System Sciences, 25(9), 4835-4860.

    How to cite: Leitner, D., Schnepf, A., and Vanderborght, J.: A new root water uptake sink term including root-rhizosphere hydraulic architecture, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7304, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7304, 2022.

    EGU22-7349 | Presentations | HS8.3.5

    Estimation of Non-Linear Water Uptake Parameter using Genetic Algorithm for Sodic Soils 

    Gaurav Goet, Ickkshaanshu Sonkar, and Kotnoor Hari Prasad

    In the plant water soil system, water plays a vital part in controlling the plant's growth. The plant fulfils its water demand from the soil water through root uptake. The pattern of water uptake by the plant through roots depends on the root geometry and the root density, which varies non-linearly with the depth. To quantify this non-linearity, it is essential to precisely determine the parameter accounting for this non-linearity in the water uptake. Moreover, it has also been observed in the literature that sodicity alters the root growth and thence the density. The current study is about identifying non-linear root water uptake parameter utilizing the Genetic Algorithm (GA) technique in Sodic soils. Different models have been proposed to predict root water uptake by the plants. The non-Linear nature of root water uptake has been confirmed from previous studies and observations. The non-linear root water uptake model named as O-R (Ojha and Rai, 1996) model combined with soil moisture flow or Richard's equation is developed to determine the pattern of root water uptake by the plants. Non-linear parameter β is incorporated in the O-R model to account for non-linearity in the uptake. In the current study, parameter β is determined through inverse modelling utilizing GA optimization procedure. For parameter optimization, the difference between model-predicted and experimentally observed percentage soil moisture depletion is minimized for soils of different salinity classes. To check the viability of the developed model, the optimization procedure is validated from hypothetically generated percentage soil moisture depletion corresponding to an assumed β value and salt concentration in the soil. This study considers the wheat crop (Triticum) to apply this model and estimate the non-linear root water uptake parameter β. The results obtained show that the linked simulation-optimization model based on GA procedure precisely determines the non-linear root water uptake parameter for the Wheat crop considered. Since Different crops follow different non-linear water uptake patterns and hence, have different values of β. Thus, an accurate estimation of β is necessary to analyze the root water uptake and plan the irrigation scheduling strategies for modern agriculture.

    How to cite: Goet, G., Sonkar, I., and Hari Prasad, K.: Estimation of Non-Linear Water Uptake Parameter using Genetic Algorithm for Sodic Soils, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7349, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7349, 2022.

    EGU22-8138 | Presentations | HS8.3.5

    Lysimeter experiments reveal effects of elevated atmospheric carbon dioxide on soil-water fluxes and biomass production of alpine grassland under drought 

    Steffen Birk, Matevž Vremec, Veronika Forstner, Markus Herndl, and Andreas Schaumberger

    Elevated atmospheric carbon dioxide (eCO2) has led to global warming and thus increased evaporative demand of the atmosphere. Yet, the vegetation response to eCO2 may counter the effect of warming by improving plant water-use efficiency (WUE). Here we use a lysimeter-based experimental approach to investigate the effect of eCO2 on the evapotranspiration (ET), soil-water availability, and aboveground biomass (AGB) production of managed alpine grassland under drought. For this purpose, we use data from six weighable high-precision lysimeters at the ClimGrass experimental site operated by the Agricultural Research and Education Centre Raumberg-Gumpenstein (Austria). While one of these lysimeters is operated under ambient conditions, mini-T-FACE systems are used for controlled manipulation of the other lysimeters. Two lysimeters are operated under constant warming of +3 K relative to the ambient surface temperature, two under constant eCO2 of +300 ppm relative to the ambient atmospheric concentration, and one with a combination of elevated temperature and eCO2.

    Considering the observations from 2018 to 2020, eCO2 is found to lower ET relative to ambient conditions. Yet, biomass production does not appear to benefit from the water savings resulting from the reduced ET, because plant growth at this humid alpine site generally is energy-limited rather than water-limited (Forstner et al., Hydrol. Earth Syst. Sci., 2021). During summer 2019, however, a distinct dry spell was observed in which actual ET was well below potential ET. This suggests a depletion of the soil-water availability, potentially limiting plant growth in this time period. Under these drought conditions, ET was temporarily higher at the lysimeters with eCO2 compared to those with ambient carbon dioxide concentrations. This corresponded to higher soil water contents and matric potentials resulting from the water savings in the pre-drought period at the lysimeters treated with carbon dioxide. As opposed to other time periods, under the drought in summer 2019 AGB and WUE were found to be higher at the lysimeters with eCO2 than at those with ambient carbon dioxide concentrations. This effect appears to be most evident at the heated plots. It can be concluded that the water savings resulting from eCO2 enabled prolonged water consumption into the drought period, thus mitigating the water limitation and benefiting plant growth. In summary, our results suggest that elevated atmospheric carbon dioxide can help mitigate water stress in alpine grassland during drought.

    How to cite: Birk, S., Vremec, M., Forstner, V., Herndl, M., and Schaumberger, A.: Lysimeter experiments reveal effects of elevated atmospheric carbon dioxide on soil-water fluxes and biomass production of alpine grassland under drought, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8138, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8138, 2022.

    EGU22-8524 | Presentations | HS8.3.5

    Quantitative comparison of root water uptake simulated by functional-structural root architecture models 

    Andrea Schnepf, Valentin Couvreur, Benjamin Delory, Claude Doussan, Mathieu Javaux, Deepanshu Khare, Axelle Koch, Timo Koch, Christian Kuppe, Daniel Leitner, Guillaume Lobet, Félicien Meunier, Johannes Postma, Ernst Schäfer, Jan Vanderborght, and Harry Vereecken

    3D models of root growth, architecture and function are becoming important tools to aid the design of agricultural management schemes and the selection of beneficial root traits. While benchmarking is common for water and solute transport models in soil, 3D root-soil interaction models have not yet been systematically analysed. Several interacting processes might induce disagreement between models: root growth, sink term definitions of root water and solute uptake and representation of the rhizosphere. Schnepf et al. (2020) proposed a framework for quantitatively comparing such models. It builds upon benchmark scenarios that test individual components, followed by benchmark scenarios for the coupled root-rhizosphere-soil system.

    Here we present the results of benchmarking different well-known models (“simulators”) with respect to water flow in soil, water flow in roots, and water flow and root water uptake in a coupled soil-root system for the case of a given prescribed root architecture as observed from an MRI experiment. The participating simulators are

    CPlantBox and DuMux (Koch et al. 2021; Mai et al. 2019), R-SWMS (Javaux et al. 2008), OpenSimRoot (Postma et al. 2017) and ArchiSimple, RootTyp and SRI (Beudez et al. 2013; Pagès et al. 2014; Pagès et al. 2004).

    In the benchmark scenarios that represent individual modules, the different simulators solved the same mathematical model but with different numerical approaches; all perform well with respect to the given analytical reference solution. For the coupled problem of root water uptake from a drying soil, the different simulators make different choices for the coupling of the different sub-problems. Thus, the results of the different simulators show a larger heterogeneity amongst each other.

    We expect that this benchmarking will result in improved models, with which we can simulate various scenarios with greater confidence, avoiding that future work is based on accidental results caused by bugs, numerical errors or conceptual misunderstandings and will set a standard for model development.

    Beudez N, Doussan C, Lefeuve-Mesgouez G, Mesgouez A (2013) Procedia Environmental Sciences 19: 37-46. doi:

    Javaux M, Schröder T, Vanderborght J, Vereecken H (2008) Vadose Zone Journal 7: 1079-1088.

    Koch T, Wu H, Schneider M (2021) Journal of Computational Physics: 110823.

    Mai TH, Schnepf A, Vereecken H, Vanderborght J (2019) Plant and Soil 439: 273-292. doi: 10.1007/s11104-018-3890-4.

    Pagès L, Bécel C, Boukcim H, Moreau D, Nguyen C, Voisin A-S (2014) Ecological Modelling 290: 76-84.

    Pagès L, Vercambre G, Drouet J-L, Lecompte F, Collet C, Le Bot J (2004) Plant and Soil 258: 103-119.

    Postma JA, Kuppe C, Owen MR, Mellor N, Griffiths M, Bennett MJ, Lynch JP, Watt M (2017) New Phytologist 215: 1274-1286.

    Schnepf A, Black CK, Couvreur V, et al. (2020) Frontiers in Plant Science 11.

    How to cite: Schnepf, A., Couvreur, V., Delory, B., Doussan, C., Javaux, M., Khare, D., Koch, A., Koch, T., Kuppe, C., Leitner, D., Lobet, G., Meunier, F., Postma, J., Schäfer, E., Vanderborght, J., and Vereecken, H.: Quantitative comparison of root water uptake simulated by functional-structural root architecture models, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8524, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8524, 2022.

    EGU22-10218 | Presentations | HS8.3.5

    Measuring and modeling water fluxes across soil-plant-atmosphere continuum in a temperate forest environment 

    Tomas Vogel, Veronika Skalova, Michal Dohnal, Jana Votrubova, and Miroslav Tesar

    This study is focused on fluxes of water and energy associated with the plant transpiration in a temperate montane forest of Central Europe. The research is based on the long-term monitoring of basic hydrological and meteorological variables at two adjacent forest sites, covered with Norway spruce and European beech. The analysis of the observed variables is combined with the numerical modeling of soil-plant hydraulics.

    Among the monitored variables, sap flow in tree xylem is measured continuously by thermal dissipation probes. Soil water pressure and soil water content are monitored by tensiometers and FDR sensors at several depths. Catchment discharge observations, reflecting the subsurface responses to major rainfall events, are used together with the soil water content data to provide the relevant information on the catchment water balance, which constrains the long-term cumulative transpiration amount.

    A one-dimensional soil water flow model, involving vertically distributed macroscopic root water uptake and whole-plant hydraulic capacitance algorithm to account for the transient xylem water storage, is used to simulate the temporal variations of water fluxes in the soil-plant-atmosphere system.

    The observed sap flow rates are compared with the simulated transpiration fluxes. A particular attention is paid to the different behavior of spruce and beech trees during periods with extreme transpiration demand (summer midday conditions). The results of the comparisons confirm the expected isohydric response of spruce in contrast to a more anisohydric behavior of beech trees.

    The comparison of the modeling results with the in-situ observations reveals a complex interplay of soil and plant hydraulic properties determining the specific responses of spruce and beech forest stands to the same weather conditions.

    The research is supported by the Czech Science Foundation Project No. 20-00788S.

    How to cite: Vogel, T., Skalova, V., Dohnal, M., Votrubova, J., and Tesar, M.: Measuring and modeling water fluxes across soil-plant-atmosphere continuum in a temperate forest environment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10218, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10218, 2022.

    EGU22-10372 | Presentations | HS8.3.5

    Root activity for water uptake: a hydraulic approach 

    Mathieu Javaux and Ali Mehmandoostkotlar

    Despite most macroscopic models for root water uptake considering root length density (RLD) to describe root water uptake (RWU) distribution, there are numerous studies demonstrating inconsistencies between soil water content profile and RLD that can be attributed to the inability of some roots to extract water. In fact, the physical relationship between RWU and the root system ignores the hydraulic characteristics of the root. To cope with this rigid assumption, the activity of a root system can be defined as the portion of the root system extracting majority of soil water. Root water uptake activity depends on the hydraulic head gradient between root-soil interface and xylem and on root segment conductance, which are terms not considered in macroscopic models. Therefore, both soil and root hydraulic properties are critical in determining RWU activity. Yet, in real root systems, active root fraction is continuously changing due to root development, root adaptation and soil moisture heterogeneity, which are not possible to be assessed considering the currently available experimental facilities. Therefore, our aim in this study is threefold: (1) establish a theoretical framework to investigate root water uptake activity; (2) Investigate with 0D hydraulic architecture model and 3D architectural soil-root water flow model to estimate the active root fraction and to find the effective parameters on active root fraction and finally (3) demonstrate and provide orders of magnitude of active root fraction for real situations. The initial results showed that RWU activity for a single segment depends on radial hydraulic conductivity distribution if xylem conductance is not limiting. The active fraction of the root for fibrous and taproot systems at different ages with their realistic root hydraulic properties was investigated under equilibrium and realistic soil water potential and compared with some existing values in literature. The simulated active root fraction and obtained ones from the previous studies rarely exceed 30% of the whole root system. The active root fraction is therefore an important factor to know and characterize to properly estimate soil resistance and stress onset.

    How to cite: Javaux, M. and Mehmandoostkotlar, A.: Root activity for water uptake: a hydraulic approach, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10372, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10372, 2022.

    EGU22-11150 | Presentations | HS8.3.5

    Towards fully automated root phenotyping in the field: from Minirhizotron image acquisition to data analysis 

    Kaining Zhou, Adam Soffer, Jhonathan E. Ephrath, Ofer Hadar, and Naftali Lazarovitch

    Root phenotyping in the field remains challenging from root imaging to data analysis since each part of this process is time-consuming and labor-intensive. Extensive efforts have been taken to explore the possibility to automate parts of this process. However, few studies have provided an integrated solution to make the whole process in a manner of low cost, automated, and customizable for different tasks.  In this study, we have worked towards this goal. A newly designed root imaging system called RootCam addresses the above-mentioned limitations. RootCam moves a small camera with fully automated operations for long-term in-situ monitoring. It captures high-resolution root images (2592 x 1944 pixels). These images are saved to a “Raspberry Pi” device which is accessible by a network cable allowing users to control the system remotely. Users can also control time intervals between runs and set image capturing either overlapped or non-overlapped. This camera was tested in a net house by imaging bell pepper roots which shows superior performance over commercial minirhizotron systems. A deep convolutional neural networks (CNN) model was developed to detect plant roots and calculate root length. This model was trained and calibrated with a dataset of ~18,000 tomato root images and has been used for calculating bell pepper root length on 832 images. The high correlation coefficient (R2 = 0.854) between the measurements from the automated and manual methods proved that our model is able to generalize well over different crop roots. However, the model underestimates root length when there are many roots in an individual image. In summary, the platform we developed to automatize minirhizotron image acquisition and analysis has the promising potential to benefit both the root research community via accelerating high throughput root phenotyping in the field for root studies and farmers via making real-time root development information available for decision making.

    How to cite: Zhou, K., Soffer, A., Ephrath, J. E., Hadar, O., and Lazarovitch, N.: Towards fully automated root phenotyping in the field: from Minirhizotron image acquisition to data analysis, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11150, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11150, 2022.

    EGU22-11346 | Presentations | HS8.3.5

    Parameterization of Stomatal Conductance in a Subarctic Deciduous Shrub 

    Astrid Vatne, Ane Victoria Vollsnes, Norbert Pirk, and Lena Merete Tallaksen

    Plants play an important role in regulating the land-atmosphere water and carbon flux through stomata control. To avoid excess water loss, the stomatal conductance is reduced during low soil water availability or high water demand from the atmosphere. Atmospheric evaporative demand is projected to increase through an increase in vapour pressure deficit (VPD) in response to global warming. Stomatal conductance models used in earth system models often rely on empirical parameters. However, since VPD and soil moisture content often are correlated, it can be difficult to disentangle the effect of each driver in studies using field data. In this study, we evaluate the effect of VPD and soil moisture on stomatal conductance independently by conducting an experiment in controlled growth conditions. In the experiment, we will subject groups of dwarf birch (Betula nana) to increasing VPD in both well-watered and drying soil conditions and measure the effect on stomatal conductance and leaf scale water and carbon gas exchange. Dwarf birch is selected as it is widespread in high latitutes and our study focuses on land-atmosphere exchange in this region. The experimental design allows us to evaluate existing parametrizations of stomatal conductance and test hypotheses on how sensitive the parameters are to drought history.  The experiment will provide important knowledge on how to improve parameterization of water and carbon exchange in high latitude ecosystems. This presentation will show the first results of the experiment. This work is a contribution to the Strategic Research Initiative ‘Land Atmosphere Interaction in Cold Environments’ (LATICE) of the University of Oslo and the EMERALD research project.  

    How to cite: Vatne, A., Vollsnes, A. V., Pirk, N., and Tallaksen, L. M.: Parameterization of Stomatal Conductance in a Subarctic Deciduous Shrub, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11346, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11346, 2022.

    Forest dieback can be both a consequence and a cause of climate change. The changing climate does not only lead to temperature increases but also changes in the precipitation regime. Extreme events have increased sharply in recent years, making drought and heat waves ubiquitous. Meanwhile, for temperate forests, drought stress is considered one of the most serious impacts of climate change. In this context, forest soils are of great importance in their hydrological functions, as well as their feedbacks with ground vegetation. In this context, biological soil crusts are key drivers of functional processes and ecosystem development, also under forest, where they have been less studied so far. Bryophyte and lichen dominated communities can importantly affect e.g. water storage and discharge as well as soil development and stabilization. Moreover, they contribute to carbon and nitrogen cycling and play an important role in biogeochemical processes. Their species composition depends on soil properties such as texture and pH, on microclimate and as poikilohydric plants, their ecophysiology is strongly dependent on water availability, differing in time and space.

    For a better understanding of ecohydrological and soil stabilizing functions of biological soil crusts within forest ecosystems, their spatial and temporal activity needs to be linked with microclimate and monitored continuously in the field. Therefore, we investigate the microclimatic conditions and activity of bryophyte-lichen-dominated biological soil crusts on sandy soils in Linde, Brandenburg and silty-clayey soils in the Schönbuch Nature Park, Baden-Württemberg, Germany. Water regimes within mosses and substrates are continuously determined with a novel biocrust wetness probe (BWP). Moreover, the interactions between mosses and soils are investigated in infiltration boxes with cultivated moss species. It could be shown so far, that moss-dominated biological soil crusts decrease infiltration and soil water availability in the dry sandy soils in Brandenburg and further comparative investigations will now be processed. We thus contribute to the study of effects of bryophyte-lichen communities on soil water retention, soil structure, with a focus on drought resistance of forest stands, as well as soil development at disturbance sites in temperate forest ecosystems.

    How to cite: Seitz, S. and Veste, M.: Bryophyte-lichens dominated biological soil crusts affect soils and ecohydrology in temperate forests in Germany, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12352, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12352, 2022.

    EGU22-12379 | Presentations | HS8.3.5

    Application of deep learning segmentation techniques in smartphone images to assess growth of fine roots of spruce seedlings manipulated by air humidity and soil nitrogen source 

    Marili Sell, Abraham George Smith, Iuliia Burdun, Gristin Rohula-Okunev, Priit Kupper, and Ivika Ostonen

    A new insight in root growth dynamics is presented in this study, where pictures of root growth were taken with personal mobile phones and analysed by the machine learning based program RootPainter (Smith et al. 2020). Todays’ smartphones provide high-quality photos and user-friendly free software enables rapid processing of these images. We aimed to explore 1) how accurate the results are of the deep learning segmentation models created for assessing root growth, 2) how the changes in relative air humidity and dominating soil nitrogen source and their interactions influence root growth.
    Picea abies trees were grown separately in transparent boxes in growth chambers in moderate or elevated air humidity and on nitrate or ammonium soil source. The pictures of roots were made from each side of boxes every week, together six sessions. The pictures were analysed with RootPainter twice, one where total root projection area was measured, second with only young white roots.
    The total root growth was highest in trees growing in moderate air humidity and on ammonium source, lowest in elevated air humidity grown on nitrate source, 9.4 ± 1.9 and 3.9 ± 0.6 cm2, respectively. The young root projection area was highest in the beginning of experiment, and was affected by the soil nitrogen source. The amount of lignified roots increased over time and was affected by the air humidity treatment. The F measure was 0.88, when we compared a subset of automatically measured pictures to manually annotated pictures. We will further discuss about the magnitude of the errors 1) where the program identified “root as soil” and “soil as root”, and 2) where the root projection area of young roots was greater than the total root projection area. We did not discover treatment-specific bias in our error measurements. We conclude that the combination of smartphone images and RootPainter gives accurate and reliable results and is easy to use in plant growth manipulation experiments in the future.

    Smith AG, Han E, Petersen J, Olsen NAF, Giese C, Athmann M, Dresbøll DB, Thorup-Kristensen K. 2020. RootPainter: Deep learning segmentation of biological images with corrective annotation. bioRxiv, doi:10.1101/2020.04.16.044461

    How to cite: Sell, M., Smith, A. G., Burdun, I., Rohula-Okunev, G., Kupper, P., and Ostonen, I.: Application of deep learning segmentation techniques in smartphone images to assess growth of fine roots of spruce seedlings manipulated by air humidity and soil nitrogen source, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12379, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12379, 2022.

    EGU22-12582 | Presentations | HS8.3.5

    Rooting out soil structure 

    Paul Hallett, Md Dhin Islam, Licida Giuliani, Kenneth Loades, and Adam Price

    Soil has a spatially heterogeneous mix of weaker and stronger elements, and larger and smaller pores.  When studying physical constraints to root growth, however, most studies use sieved, repacked soil to create a more homogeneous environment that is far from conditions observed in field soils.  Sieved, repacked soil gives the advantage of careful manipulation of physical properties, such as density or penetration resistance, and also removes differences in carbon and microbial properties that could affect structurally different soils sampled from tillage or compaction field experiments.  To overcome unrealistic homogeneity of repacked soils, but remove soil structure treatment impacts on other soil properties that could confound interpretation, we have explored root growth in laboratory cores carefully packed to provide different soil structures. 

    In one set of experiments, sieved soil was compacted then broken apart to form aggregates.  Treatments were formed by packing either the sieved soil (unstructured) or much denser aggregates (structured) to a range of bulk densities, producing a 50% increase in macroporosity at 1.55 g/cm3 density and more variable penetration resistances for structured soils.  Plant growth of barley, peas and Arabidopsis, including shoot and root properties, was affected less by bulk density in structured than unstructured soils.  For instance, root length of barley and peas decreased less between 1.25 g/cm3 and 1.55 g/cm3 for structured compared to unstructured soils, as roots could exploit macropores. 

    Another experiment explored how the shape of macropores in the plough pan affected deep rooting of rice.  Round holes simulating biopores and straight pores simulating cracks were inserted through a simulated plough pan, packed to the Proctor Density of 1.53 g cm-3 and penetration resistance of 2.80 MPa at – 20 kPa water potential.  Not only did macropores improve root growth in the plough pan and through to the subsoil, but the shape of the macropore had a large impact.  Cracks compared to biopores produced 55% more root length density in the plough pan, but 26% less root length density in the subsoil. Many other root properties in the plough pan and subsoil were affected by macropore shape.

    With increased use of shallow or zero tillage, and constraints from diminishing water for irrigation and the stresses of climate change, the capacity of roots to take advantage of the heterogenous structure of field soil to grow deep and wide is extremely important.  Laboratory approaches with controlled soil structure will help to unravel the underlying processes by providing careful control, which can supplement understanding obtained from structured field soils.

    How to cite: Hallett, P., Islam, M. D., Giuliani, L., Loades, K., and Price, A.: Rooting out soil structure, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12582, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12582, 2022.

    EGU22-12979 | Presentations | HS8.3.5

    The Co-Effect of Root Exudates and Incubation Time on Solute Transport in the Rhizosphere 

    Amit Paporisch, Harel Bavli, Rachel J Strickman, Rebecca B Neumann, and Nimrod Schwartz

    Root exudates alter the rhizosphere’s physical properties, but the impact these changes have on solute transport is largely unknown. Additionally, root exudates enhance the microbial activity in soil, which may further change the rhizosphere’s physical properties, including solute transport. In this study, we tested the effects of chia mucilage and wheat root exudates on the transport of iodide in saturated soil. Solute breakthrough experiments, conducted in loamy sand soil or coarser textured quartz sand, revealed that increasing the exudate concentration in soil resulted in non-equilibrium solute transport. This behavior was demonstrated by an initial solute breakthrough after fewer pore volumes and the arrival of the peak solute concentration after greater pore volumes in soil mixed with exudates compared to soil without exudates. These patterns were more pronounced for the coarser textured quartz sand than for the loamy sand soil and in soil mixed with mucilage than in soil mixed wheat root exudates. Parameter fits to these breakthrough curves with a mobile-immobile transport model indicated the fraction of immobile water increased as the concentration of exudates increased. For example, in quartz sand, the estimated immobile fraction increased from 0 without exudates to 0.75 at a mucilage concentration of 0.2%. Saturated breakthrough experiments were also conducted in a loamy sand soil mixed with mucilage and incubated at 25 ºC for different time periods of up to 28 days. In this set of experiments, mucilage at a concentration of 0.2% in the soil had no effect on the iodide breakthrough curve prior to soil incubation, while 0.4% mucilage concentration altered the transport pattern (as described above), and its breakthrough curve pattern remained stable for the entire incubation period. However, after a 7-day incubation period, the breakthrough curve of soil with 0.2% mucilage concentration was also altered, again showing earlier breakthrough and later arrival of the peak iodide concentration compared to the breakthrough curve before incubation. This breakthrough pattern persisted for the remainder of the incubation period. The results of this study indicate that root exudates alter the rhizosphere’s transport properties and that enhanced microbial activity following root exudation may further affect solute transport. We hypothesize that this is due to exudates creating low-conducting flow paths that result in a physical non-equilibrium solute transport. Additionally, we hypothesize that enhanced microbial activity following root exudation results in secretion of extracellular polymeric substances and generation of biofilm that further affect the flow paths in soil, thus potentially altering solute transport in the rhizosphere with time.   

    How to cite: Paporisch, A., Bavli, H., Strickman, R. J., Neumann, R. B., and Schwartz, N.: The Co-Effect of Root Exudates and Incubation Time on Solute Transport in the Rhizosphere, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12979, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12979, 2022.

    HS9 – Erosion, sedimentation & river processes

    EGU22-213 | Presentations | HS9.1

    Quantifying heavy metal concentrations throughout drainage basins from river sediment mixing 

    Jonas Eschenfelder, Alex Lipp, and Gareth Roberts

    The concentration of elements in river sediments play a fundamental role in determining the ‘health’ of rivers. They also contain important information about provenance and geomorphic processes (e.g. mixing). For instance, concentrated heavy metals, such as lead, copper and chromium, can identify foci of polluting industry and stressed ecosystems.  Attempts to monitor pollution in river sediments and to generate geological baselines are thwarted by the lack of available measurements of sediment geochemistry in higher-order, downstream, river channels. We address that issue by developing forward and inverse methodologies to predict the composition of river sediments throughout drainage basins from small inventories of geochemical measurements (tens of samples). A case study, centered on the River Clyde near Glasgow, Scotland, shows that conservative downstream mixing generates robust and continuous estimates of element concentrations in river sediments. Predicted geochemistry and independent observations match well for elements that have diverse concentrations in source regions (e.g. magnesium). Anthropogenic enrichment of heavy metals along large rivers, compared to geologic baselines generated by mixing ‘clean’ source regions, correspond to the Glasgow city area and old mining regions. Continuous predictions of river chemistry are used to identify river reaches where heavy metal concentrations exceed toxic threshold levels. 

    How to cite: Eschenfelder, J., Lipp, A., and Roberts, G.: Quantifying heavy metal concentrations throughout drainage basins from river sediment mixing, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-213, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-213, 2022.

    There is a growing interest to understand the sources of sediments in river channels as basis for potential mitigation aiming to reduce soil erosion and sediment delivery in larger catchments. Within the last decades, sediment fingerprinting has been established as a powerful tool to unravel the sources of sediments in larger catchments. However, most sediment fingerprinting techniques are based on time-consuming and costly chemical analysis of sediment samples from river channels and sub- catchments. Recent studies have shown the potential of diffuse reflectance infrared Fourier transform spectroscopy (DRIFTS) as a rapid, cost-effective, and nondestructive tracers for sediment fingerprinting. The aim of this study is to analyses the sensitivity of DRIFTS based sediment fingerprinting against particle size of sediment tracers and to determine the potential of using multi-size approaches.  We used mid-infrared spectroscopy (MIRS; 4000-600 cm-1) to analyze four size fractions (125-250, 63-125, 63-38, and <38 µm) of 54 sediment samples collected at three different sub-basins spatial sediment sources and 26 target sediment samples collected at the outlet of the main basin of the Andajrood drainage river basin in Iran.  The spectral resolution was averaged over 32 cm-1 intervals to reduce the continues wavelength data to a defined number of spectral bands (n = 104) that is practicable and realistic for a statistical analysis of differences. A one-way ANOVA was used to evaluate the presence of significant contrasts between the content of individual MIRS spectra in the different size fractions. The results showed that MIRS spectra were present and distributed across all size fractions. The results of one-way ANOVA indicated that in sub-basin both, MIRS spectra form spatial sediment sources and target sediment samples, were significantly affected by the particle size fractions. Thus, this confirmed that it was appropriate to identify the dominant particle size fraction in the sediment samples and to confirm that MIRS spectra were present across that fraction rather than a sub-fraction.

    How to cite: Nosrati, K. and Fiener, P.: Particle size fraction effects on MIR-DRIFTS: Improving the quantification of sub-basin spatial sediment provenance fingerprinting, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-818, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-818, 2022.

    EGU22-858 | Presentations | HS9.1

    Improving the design and implementation of sediment fingerprinting studies: Summary and outcomes of the TRACING 2021 Scientific School 

    Olivier Evrard, Pedro Batista, Jaume Company, Aymeric Dabrin, Anthony Foucher, Amaury Frankl, Julián García-Comendador, Arnaud Huguet, Niels Lake, Ivan Lizaga, Núria Martínez‑Carreras, Oldrich Navratil, Cécile Pignol, and Virginie Sellier

    Sediment fingerprinting or tracing is a technique that allows to quantify source contributions of sediment. A Thematic School was organised in October 2021 to discuss potential options to improve the design and implementation of sediment fingerprinting procedures. The suggestions put forward by the School participants were organised around six complementary topics. First, we suggest a better use of geomorphological information to improve study design. Researchers are invited to scrutinize all the knowledge available on the catchment of interest, and to obtain multiple lines of evidence regarding sediment source contributions. Second, we think that scientific knowledge could be improved with local knowledge and we propose a scale of participation describing different levels of involvement of locals in research. Third, we recommend the use of state-of-the-art sediment tracing protocols to conduct sampling, deal with particle size, examine data before modelling and accounting for the hydro-meteorological context under investigation. Fourth, we promote best practices in modelling, including the importance of running multiple models, selecting appropriate tracers, and reporting on model errors and uncertainty. Fifth, we suggest best practices to share tracing data and samples, which will increase the visibility of the fingerprinting technique in geoscience. Sixth, we suggest that a better organisation of datasets would allow to formulate hypotheses and improve our knowledge about erosion processes in a more unified way. In conclusion, sediment fingerprinting, which is interdisciplinary in nature, should play a major role to meet the current and future challenges associated with global change.

    How to cite: Evrard, O., Batista, P., Company, J., Dabrin, A., Foucher, A., Frankl, A., García-Comendador, J., Huguet, A., Lake, N., Lizaga, I., Martínez‑Carreras, N., Navratil, O., Pignol, C., and Sellier, V.: Improving the design and implementation of sediment fingerprinting studies: Summary and outcomes of the TRACING 2021 Scientific School, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-858, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-858, 2022.

    EGU22-1223 | Presentations | HS9.1

    An integrated sediment export quantification approach for the sustainable management of agroecosystems 

    Ivan Lizaga, William Blake, Samuel Bodé, Olivier Evrard, Borja Latorre, Ana Navas, Kristof Van Oost, and Pascal Boeckx

    Soil erosion and the subsequent transport of sediment and pollutants are critical challenges for guaranteeing food security and water quality. Controlling sediment and particle-bound substance export requires the implementation of improved ecological restoration schemes, especially in areas experiencing drastic increases in erosion rates. To this end, we propose the design of an ensemble technique that combines the use of sediment fingerprinting together with radionuclide dating and remote sensing data to fill these critical knowledge gaps.

    This project will focus on testing and developing powerful specific land use tracers, such as Compound Specific Stable Isotopes (CSSI) and environmental DNA (eDNA), to improve the land cover discrimination of sediment provenance through the collection and dating of sediment cores in sink areas. This research will be conducted in two contrasting catchments with different land use histories allowing to test the effectiveness of this novel approach: i) the Ésera catchment that flows into the Barasona reservoir (Spain), representative of areas experiencing sediment export decrease due to land abandonment and the subsequent natural revegetation, and ii) the Kihira catchment, Lake Kivu (DR Congo), representative of intensively cultivated areas undergoing an unsustainable and increasing sediment export and nutrient loss. By combining the investigation of these two contrasted catchments and by applying state-of-the-art methods, it will be possible to evaluate the main driving factors of the past and present erosion rates and predict the effects of human management and climate change.

    In this first stage of the project, representative sediment samples from different land cover sources will be collected in the Ésera catchment (1.535km2) until its mouth into the Barasona reservoir. Several bulk cores and surface sediments collected in 1995 will be characterised and compared with samples collected in 2013 at the Barasona reservoir. An extra sampling campaign is planned for 2022 to examine the changes that occurred in recent years.  Records of known flood events and reservoir management data will be combined with 137Cs chronology to ascribe the sedimentary record to specific years. Besides, a set of remote sensing and aerial photographs will be analysed to reconstruct the land use variation during the last six decades.

    To track the land use apportionment variation during the last decades, geochemistry and radioisotopic activity will be analysed in both source and sediment samples and examined as possible tracers for fingerprinting modelling. The fingerprinting technique will be implemented following state-of-the-art methodologies such as the Consensus and Consistency tracer selection methods.

    Thus, by combining the use of remote sensing, novel fingerprinting techniques and radiometric dating, we aim to provide a novel and powerful tool to understand the driving factors of sediment sources (e.g., deforestation, agricultural intensification and abandonment) and associated pollutants, and their variations in space and time in the last decades.

    How to cite: Lizaga, I., Blake, W., Bodé, S., Evrard, O., Latorre, B., Navas, A., Van Oost, K., and Boeckx, P.: An integrated sediment export quantification approach for the sustainable management of agroecosystems, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1223, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1223, 2022.

    EGU22-2161 | Presentations | HS9.1 | Highlight

    The relevance of environmental DNA as a targeted sediment fingerprinting method sensitive to vegetation 

    Amaury Frankl, Olivier Evrard, Fabien Levard, Brice Dupin, Bjorn Tytgat, Erik Cammeraat, Elie Verleyen, and Alexia Stokes

    Environmental DNA (eDNA) has recently been considered as a marker that could be used for fingerprinting sediments. Identify sediment sources originating from zones covered with specific plant communities would enhance the sediment fingerprinting method significantly and enable the detailed identification of soil erosion hotspots relative to land use and cover. Here, we explore the relevance of environmental DNA (eDNA) that originates from plant litter and fixes onto fine soil particles as a targeted sediment fingerprinting method. Although research on plant eDNA signatures in soils and sediments is limited, initial results are promising and indicate that eDNA could yield more accurate results than other sediment fingerprints that are sensitive to vegetation. Plant eDNA signatures tend to produce a highly localized signal of sediment sources, mainly reflecting the current vegetation cover of soils. As eDNA is rapidly adsorbed onto fine mineral soil particles such as clay, it is protected against rapid degradation in fluvial environments. Supported by the increasing availability and quality of vegetation maps and eDNA reference libraries, we argue that sediment source fingerprinting using eDNA from plant litter will evolve into a valuable method to identify hotspots of soil erosion and allow stakeholders to prioritize areas where ecological restoration is necessary. We tested our assumptions from a case study in a high mountain environment (catchment of approximately 600 km² in the Central Pyrenees, France) which was recently affected by a severe hydro-climatic event and for which ecological restoration is pertinent.

    Keywords:

    Pyrenees, river catchments, sedDNA, sediment source fingerprinting, vegetation

    How to cite: Frankl, A., Evrard, O., Levard, F., Dupin, B., Tytgat, B., Cammeraat, E., Verleyen, E., and Stokes, A.: The relevance of environmental DNA as a targeted sediment fingerprinting method sensitive to vegetation, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2161, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2161, 2022.

    EGU22-3395 | Presentations | HS9.1

    Assessing the source and delivery of organic carbon at a catchment scale using a combined sediment fingerprinting and carbon loss modelling approach 

    Catherine Wiltshire, Toby Waine, Robert Grabowski, Miriam Glendell, Barry Thornton, Steve Addy, and Jeroen Meersmans

    Quantifying land use sources and understanding the dynamics of organic carbon (OC) in river catchments is essential to reduce both on-site and off-site impacts of soil OC erosion. The lake area of Loch Davan, located in Aberdeenshire, Scotland, has been significantly reduced over the last century due to sediment inputs and, in this study, we aimed to identify the primary source(s) and delivery of OC to the loch’s main feeder stream, Logie Burn and its major tributaries.

    The relative contribution of different land use sources to organic matter load in waterways can be assessed using sediment fingerprinting (SF) with plant-specific biomarkers such as n-alkanes. However, application of the land use sources based on SF in catchment management is hindered by the following issues: i) broad land use classifications cannot provide accurate OC origins if the same land use exists in multiple locations within a catchment; each with its own susceptibility to erosion and connectivity to the streams, and ii) eroded soil is not the only source of plant-specific biomarkers such as n-alkanes and direct input of leaves or litter to waterways could mask the input from eroded soils.

    This inter-disciplinary study aimed to improve upon the SF method by firstly constructing a “Carbon Loss Model” (CLM) to estimate areas of a catchment most likely to provide OC to waterways. We then compared the land use sources of OC estimated using the CLM and SF to improve our insights into both the origin and fate of eroded OC. Secondly, we considered whether soil specific tracers (neutral lipids) of soil microbial or fungal origin, combined with plant specific n-alkanes, could help to reduce the error in SF when discriminating land cover classes, facilitating a more accurate estimation of OC origins by adding a more soil - rather than vegetation - specific fingerprint.

    Results show that addition of short-chain neutral lipid fatty acid biomarkers to plant specific n-alkane tracers led to a significant decrease in error when distinguishing between arable, pasture, forest and moorland land uses (error reduction 1.8-9%). Comparison of the land use sources of OC estimated using the CLM and SF identified that areas of estimated high carbon loss were not always the regions contributing most sediment to the streams and that non-erosion processes within the riparian corridor are likely contributing OC to the waterways. This research highlights that to better understand the origin of sediments and OC across the terrestrial-aquatic continuum we must understand both sides of that continuum (the susceptibility of terrestrial OC to erosion and delivery, and the characteristics of OC within the waterways) as well as the role(s) of the riparian area that links the two.

    How to cite: Wiltshire, C., Waine, T., Grabowski, R., Glendell, M., Thornton, B., Addy, S., and Meersmans, J.: Assessing the source and delivery of organic carbon at a catchment scale using a combined sediment fingerprinting and carbon loss modelling approach, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3395, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3395, 2022.

    Lake sediments can be used as great environmental archives, especially when they are varved due to anoxic conditions at the lake bottom. Such an annual resolution of these archives can give unique insights in past environmental and climate settings and changes. Here, we try to track back changes in the erosion dynamics and associated land-use and potentially climate changes at the catchment scale from seasonal to centennial scales at Lake Baldegg, Switzerland.

    Land-use changes and agricultural practices become nowadays a key factor of sediment dynamics by modifying the soils erosive risk and the catchment sediment connectivity. And while soil erosion is one of the biggest threats to soil fertility as well as to ecological health of freshwater systems, restoration and management plans of water bodies can only be efficient if the sediment sources and their respective contributions, i.e. the proportion attributable to different land uses and agricultural practices, are identified.

    For this we used a compound-specific stable isotope approach (δ13C of long-chain fatty acids (LC-FA)) combined with connectivity modelling to a 130-years old varved lake sediment core from a eutrophic Swiss lake. We were able to discriminate grassland, arable and forest soils using the LC-FAs C26:0 and C28:0. Between 1940 to 1960 forest soils were the main source of the terrestrial sediment origin (80-100%). After 1960 a clear change in sediment origin happened. The contribution of arable and grassland soils to lake sediments were increasing. However quantitative attribution and differentiation between grassland and arable land were difficult due to the linear distribution of the tracers between the sources.

    For sediments older than 1940 the isotopic signal could no longer be explained by today’s terrestrial sources. We hypothesized additional sources of the assumed terrestrial long-chain fatty acids like (1) historical peatlands and/or former reed grass areas and (2) in-situ LC-FA production by algae.

    Since the last presentation at EGU2019 we went back to Lake Baldegg to expand our potential source sample set to explain deviation of source signals from sediments. After consultation of historic maps and reports, we located sites where peatlands and reed grass existed before the 1940s and where reed gras is still growing. There we took plant as well as soil samples and peat/lake sediment cores from a historical pond, which was connected to the lake and where reed grass grows today.

    To investigate the potential in-situ production of LC-FAs by algae or other microorganisms in the water column, we did four sampling-trips on the lake between April 2021 and September 2021 to get algae and water samples from different depths and integrating over depth. These samples were filtered over glas fibre filters, extracted and analysed for FAs. In some samples we found LC-FAs in different concentrations. Especially for the algae samples this was surprising. Depending on their isotopic signature we can now differentiate between terrestrial or aquatic production.

    The proof of significant aquatic contribution of LC-FAs to lacustrine sediments in Swiss lakes would be an important finding also regarding the common use of assumed terrestrial biomarkers in lake sediments for climate reconstruction.

    How to cite: Birkholz, A., Albiez, S., Gilli, A., and Alewell, C.: Aquatic microorganisms or reed grass as potential disturbing factors in varved sediment records when tracing terrestrial input. An example from a eutrophic Swiss lake., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3785, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3785, 2022.

    EGU22-4088 | Presentations | HS9.1

    Reconstruction of land degradation associated with recent agricultural expansion in Uruguay (1982-2019) based on sediment cores analyses 

    Anthony Foucher, Marcos Tassano, Guillermo Chalar, Mirel Cabrera, Joan Gonzalez, Irène Lefèvre, and Olivier Evrard

    Recent agriculture expansion and land cover conversion (post-1985) induced major deleterious environmental effects in South-America in general and in Uruguay in particular, affecting locally the sustainability of soil and water resources. Whilst the environmental consequences of agriculture’s development were largely studied (e.g. monitoring, modeling) in Europe or North America, much less attention was devoted to the intensity of land degradation in South-America and more specifically, on the Pampa Biome. In this study, sediment cores collected in two reservoirs installed along the Rio Negro river (catchments of 23.000 and 39.000 km²) and draining agricultural catchments were used for reconstructing the evolution of sediment dynamics and source contributions in this region during the last several decades. Various chemical and physical analyses were performed for characterizing this accumulated sediment (e.g. fallout radionuclides, organic matter properties (TOC, δ15N, δ13C, C:N), X-ray fluorescence). Results indicate the significant acceleration of sediment accumulation rates (e.g. by 67% on average in the Rincon del Bonete dam between 2003 and 2019) associated with major phases of agricultural expansion (e.g. expansion of soybean and afforestation). Sediment properties show an increase of native vegetation source contributions associated with the conversion of native grassland into cropland. Understanding the causes of past and present acceleration of sediment delivery are of prime importance in order to protect the soil and water resources with the design of adapted management schemes at the catchment scale.

    How to cite: Foucher, A., Tassano, M., Chalar, G., Cabrera, M., Gonzalez, J., Lefèvre, I., and Evrard, O.: Reconstruction of land degradation associated with recent agricultural expansion in Uruguay (1982-2019) based on sediment cores analyses, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4088, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4088, 2022.

    EGU22-4207 | Presentations | HS9.1

    Using differences in particle size distributions to fingerprint suspended sediment sources 

    Niels Lake, Núria Martínez-Carreras, Peter Shaw, and Adrian Collins

    Particle size is an important consideration for applications of sediment source fingerprinting. Here, most attention has focused on understanding the relationships between tracer property concentrations (e.g., geochemical, radionuclides and mineral magnetic properties) and particle size, since the fingerprinting approach is founded on the assumption that the properties of source material and target sediment samples are directly comparable. Beyond the careful consideration of particle size controls on tracers, there remains scope to investigate the use of particle size distributions as a tracer, building upon the limited amount of work reported to date. Accordingly, we hypothesize that particle size distributions can be informative of sediment provenance in areas where individual sources exhibit distinct particle size characteristics. To test this hypothesis, laboratory experiments were performed using artificial mixtures consisting of soil samples sieved to the same and different size fractions (<32 µm, 32-63 µm, 63-125 µm). Individual soil samples (i.e., sources) and mixtures were tested in a 40L large experimental water tank, in which a submersible particle size analyser was used to measure particle size distribution. Using the mixtures consisting of soil source samples sieved to different size fractions resulted in un-mixing modelling contributions being close to the known source inputs. Subsequently, a field experiment was conducted with samples collected using a confluence-based sediment fingerprinting approach during several storm runoff events and at low flows. Here, particle size differences between samples collected in an upstream and tributary sampling point (measured using a laboratory-based particle size analyser) were used to estimate suspended sediment contributions from these two spatial units to a downstream target sediment sampling point. The findings from the field experiments show derived estimates were good when discharge and suspended sediment concentrations were high, but less accurate during smaller runoff events and at baseflow.

    How to cite: Lake, N., Martínez-Carreras, N., Shaw, P., and Collins, A.: Using differences in particle size distributions to fingerprint suspended sediment sources, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4207, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4207, 2022.

    EGU22-6057 | Presentations | HS9.1

    Evaluating sediment source contributions in a river catchment impacted by glacial melt and land use change, the Rio Santa, Peru 

    Jessica Kitch, Caroline Clason, Sally Rangecroft, Sergio Morera, Shirley Contreras, and Will Blake

    The water-food-energy security nexus faces significant challenges from both climate change and growing populations, particularly in glacier-fed mountainous catchments. Sediment generation is driven by both natural and anthropogenic factors, exacerbating the pressures on the nexus; with increased erosion contributing to sedimentation of river systems that in turn endangers crucial river functions, such as drinking water availability, crop irrigation and hydroelectricity. Identifying sediment sources is of great importance to enable better understanding of sediment dynamics and thus, inform our management of water resources. Here we focus on the glaciated Rio Santa catchment in the Peruvian Andes, an important river for agriculture, energy, and domestic water supply.  

    Using sediment fingerprinting tools, this study assesses the glacial contribution to in-channel sediment along the Rio Santa, whilst investigating the contribution of anthropogenic factors such as land cover change in the Cordillera Blanca. A distributed approach along the two major sub catchments of the study catchment was taken to investigate natural and anthropogenic contributions to sediment generation for this Andean system. The Rio Santa catchment study focused on the contributions to sediment from the cordilleras, whilst the smaller Ranrahirca sub catchment study focused on land cover contributions to sediment. The distributed approach permitted quantification of source dynamics throughout the catchment and sub-catchment. To develop geochemical fingerprints, all source and mixture samples were analysed using Wavelength Dispersive X-ray Fluorescence (WD XRF). The MixSIAR mixing model was used to apportion sediment sources for both catchment scales. Our results indicate that the non-glacial zone (Cordillera Negra Mountains) was the greater contributor to sediment in the upper Rio Santa, possibly due to mining activities and lithological factors, whilst further downstream the glaciated zone (Cordillera Blanca) became the larger contributor. Sediment monitoring in remote mountainous catchments such as the Rio Santa is not without challenges. Sediment fingerprinting evidence has the potential to fill knowledge gaps and inform local resource management policy.

    How to cite: Kitch, J., Clason, C., Rangecroft, S., Morera, S., Contreras, S., and Blake, W.: Evaluating sediment source contributions in a river catchment impacted by glacial melt and land use change, the Rio Santa, Peru, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6057, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6057, 2022.

    EGU22-9912 | Presentations | HS9.1

    Geochemical “testimonies” of fine sediments’ origins in a lithologically complex and coal mining disturbed Romanian river basin 

    Gabriela Adina Moroșanu, Eugen Traistă, Liliana Zaharia, and Philippe Belleudy

    Fine sediments supplied by rivers retain the imprint of the lithological and geochemical characteristics of their zones of origin and sometimes intermediate storage, as well as of the influence of human activities. Advancing the management of watersheds could thus be achieved by taking into account natural and anthropogenic sediment sources, representing the other “half” of the material carried by rivers. In European watersheds, a less common approach to comply with the EU Water Directive is to track sediment sources and pathways within a watershed using the mineralogical and geochemical features of alluvial sediments.  Difficulties arise when quantifying sediment budgets at any spatial or temporal scale especially for watersheds exhibiting complex sediment origins and transfer pathways.

    Our study tackles the issues of different fine sediments sources, little-known residence times and the "competition" between natural processes and anthropogenic forcings responsible for sediment suspension delivery, transport, and accumulation. We seek to identify, through a geochemical approach, the relative sources of fine sediment in the Jiu River basin (10,080 km2), a major tributary of the Danube River, located in SW Romania. The study area stands out for its complex morphology and lithology (with in-river sediment footprints attributed to crystalline, limestone, and detrital facies) and its ongoing coal mining. Jiu River is an important alluvial supplier to the Danube River, especially during floods.

    The research aims to identify the sub-catchments supplying the most sediments, by analyzing coaly matter from the watershed’s two coal basins, as well as the fine sediment’s heavy minerals and lanthanides content. To meet this objective, alluvial samples were gathered from potential upstream source areas and from an alluvial riverbank deposit, on Jiu river’s lower sector. The coal species (lignite and bituminous coal) and their ratio in the upstream and downstream sediment samples were determined through apparent density differentiation, using solutions of heavy liquids, and by quantifying the volatile matter and ash content. Lanthanum elements and heavy metals samples were analyzed using Rigaku Supermini X-ray Fluorescence Spectrography. Based on their abundance in upstream and downstream samples, the main geochemical indicators (Zr/Si, Ti/Fe, Cu/Fe, Cu/S, Ca/Mg, Na/K, Lanthanides/P ratios), as well as the two coal species, were further correlated with the underlying lithology and hydrological features of the source sub-basins.

    The analysis of the upstream-downstream geochemical relationship was carried out at two spatial scales, to assess the potential upstream alluvial sources in 6 main sub-catchments, and to relate the geochemical composition of the upstream (source areas) samples with that from the downstream alluvial deposit. For the upper sediment layers making up the riverbank alluvial deposit, the information provided by the geochemical indicators was provided, where data was available, with hydrological information on the flood events having generated their accumulation.

    As key geochemical indicators for the main areas of sediment production, coal content, heavy metals and lanthanides could improve the control and planning of watershed management and conservation. The results may also provide a holistic understanding of the upstream to downstream coal pollution transfer in watersheds still affected by coal mining.

    How to cite: Moroșanu, G. A., Traistă, E., Zaharia, L., and Belleudy, P.: Geochemical “testimonies” of fine sediments’ origins in a lithologically complex and coal mining disturbed Romanian river basin, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9912, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9912, 2022.

    EGU22-10576 | Presentations | HS9.1

    Exploring novel Compound Specific Stable Isotopes (CSSIs) tracers with conventional fingerprinting properties for sediment source apportionment in an arable lowland catchment in Central Germany 

    Ghulam Abbas, Seifeddine Jomaa, Patrick Fink, Arlena Brosinsky, Karolina Malgorzata Nowak, Steffen Kümmel, and Michael Rode

    Soil erosion and associated sediment transport can cause severe water quality and ecosystems health deterioration. The fingerprinting approach has widely been applied for sediment source apportionment using a variety of sediment tracers. This study evaluates the applicability of the Compound Specific Stable Isotope (CSSI) fingerprinting technique of fatty acids to identify crop-specific soil loss and the importance of upland erosion compared to river bank erosion. We tested this new technique with fallout radionuclides, geochemical and spectral tracers in a small agricultural loess soil catchment (Geesgraben, 75 km²) within the lowland Bode river catchment in Central Germany. The CSSI tracer was combined with a linear multivariate mixing model to discriminate soil loss from areas with specific crop types (e.g., C3 vegetation/wheat and C4 vegetation/maize) and identify the share of river bank sediment source on total sediment loss. We compared the CSSI technique with fallout radionuclides, geochemical and spectral fingerprinting properties for tracing subsurface sediment sources. We found that the CSSI fingerprinting technique of fatty acids allowed to decipher surface sediments from wheat and maize fields. The CSSI δ¹³C-fatty acids were also used to disentangle arable and river bank sediment sources. The crop-specific soil loss from wheat and maize was 40% and 11%, respectively. Relative sediment contribution from river banks was up to 49%. The outcomes using the CSSI tracer were consistent and similar to those using fallout radionuclides, geochemical and spectral fingerprinting properties for arable land and river bank sediment sources, which indicated a mean sediment source contribution of 46% from river bank and 54% from surface sources, respectively. Our results showed that the stable isotope composition of fatty acids could discriminate C3 and C4 vegetation sources, and such information is of prime importance for decision making. Furthermore, the relatively high proportion of sediment losses from river banks has clear implications for management measures to reduce sediment losses in these agricultural loess areas. 

    Keywords: sediment fingerprinting, CSSI, fatty acids, C3 and C4 vegetation sources, sediment sources.

    How to cite: Abbas, G., Jomaa, S., Fink, P., Brosinsky, A., Nowak, K. M., Kümmel, S., and Rode, M.: Exploring novel Compound Specific Stable Isotopes (CSSIs) tracers with conventional fingerprinting properties for sediment source apportionment in an arable lowland catchment in Central Germany, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10576, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10576, 2022.

    EGU22-10742 | Presentations | HS9.1

    Estimation of fine sediment transport processes by forest management using Pb-210ex, Cs-137 and Cs-134 

    Yuichi Onda, Motosuke Kinoshita, Hiroaki Kato, Takashi Gomi, and Chen-Wei Chiu

    While thinning practices are essential for forest maintenance and management, it has been suggested that the amount of sediment discharge from forests to rivers increases with the practices.  In Karasawayama, Tochigi Prefecture, Japan, different types of thinning were carried out in 2011-12, and continuous observation of water and sediment runoff before and after thinning has been carried out. So far, through connectivity analysis, Lopez-Vincente (2017) estimated that work roads can be a major runoff pathway for sediment produced by thinning practices. On the other hand, radionuclides are known to be effective in estimating the source of sediment production. In this catchment, 8kBq/m2 of Cs-137 and Cs-134 were newly deposited due to the Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Power Plant accident during the observation period. Therefore, the purpose of this study was to estimate the source of fine sediment production from the slope scale to the watershed scale before and after thinning, utilizing Cs-134 of Fukushima origin and changing the end-members of the source sediment production in each year for more detailed source estimation. In addition, by using Pb-210ex, Cs-137, and Cs-134 at the same time, we can distinguish the production sources more clearly. In the field, SS samplers and turbidimeters were installed in the river to observe the amount and concentration of sediment, and soil erosion plots were set up in the forest and along the work road to collect sediment and measure the radioisotope concentration with Ge semiconductor detectors.

    As a result of the analysis, the amount of sediment in the watershed where row thinning was conducted increased rapidly in the year of thinning and one year later. On the other hand, in the watershed where point thinning was conducted, there was no significant increase in sediment discharge. In the production source estimation, we were able to clearly distinguish between work roads and river banks by using Cs-134/Cs-137 as the horizontal axis and Cs-134/Pb-210ex as the vertical axis. The tracer analysis showed that the contribution of sediment production from the working road increased during the thinning period in the row-thinning catchment, but no such trend was observed in the point-thinning catchment.

    How to cite: Onda, Y., Kinoshita, M., Kato, H., Gomi, T., and Chiu, C.-W.: Estimation of fine sediment transport processes by forest management using Pb-210ex, Cs-137 and Cs-134, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10742, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10742, 2022.

    EGU22-11814 | Presentations | HS9.1

    The use of UAV for event-based evaluation of soil redistribution on cultivated hillslopes 

    Vladimir Belyaev, Anna Semochkina, Vladimir Van, and Nikolay Lugovoy

    Over the last two decades, unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) have become widely used in geomorphological investigations at local spatial scales for different purposes. Here we present several examples of the UAV survey application for evaluation of soil redistribution volumes on cultivated hillslopes over a timescale of single to several runoff events. Several cultivated fields with prominent soil erosion and deposition features have been discovered during reconnaissance car trips through several regions of Central European Russia carried out in April-May 2021. The observed features included rill and ephemeral gully networks as well as several types of deposition features such as sheets and fans located within the field, along the field lower boundary and on the adjacent dry valley bottom. Detailed airborne surveys of the detected erosion and deposition zones were carried out using the DJI Phantom 4 Pro quadcopter-type drone with ground control points surveyed by Leica GS 1200 differential GNSS system. Simultaneous control hand measurements of volume of representative sets of erosion and deposition features were carried out within the same areas. Photogrammetric processing of the UAV survey data using the Agisoft Metashape software package allowed producing DEMs and orthorectified images of the surveyed areas with spatial resolution within ±2 cm. Following that, manual and semi-automatic detection of erosion and deposition features were employed and their available parameters (length, width, depth, areas of selected cross-sections, approximate volume for rills and ephemeral gullies; perimeter, area and shape for deposition features) have been measured in the Global Mapper software package. To obtain deposition volumes, the above parameters were combined with hand measurements of the deposited layer thickness. Zones of predominant sediment entrainment, transit, within-slope redeposition, export from the field and deposition in adjacent dry valleys were determined and local sediment budget parameters estimated. Comparison of the results obtained with the spring 2021 meteorological records allowed us to make conclusions on the relative contribution of snowmelt and rainfall-generated runoff into the observed soil and sediment redistribution.

    The study is supported by the Russian Science Foundation (Project No. 19-77-10061).

    How to cite: Belyaev, V., Semochkina, A., Van, V., and Lugovoy, N.: The use of UAV for event-based evaluation of soil redistribution on cultivated hillslopes, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11814, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11814, 2022.

    EGU22-12555 | Presentations | HS9.1

    Dissolved and particulate nutrient yields in terraced and non-terraced zero order catchments under no-tillage 

    Alice Dambroz, Douglas Utzig, Jean Minella, Ana Londero, Fabio Schneider, Claudia Barros, Davi Koefender, and Olivier Evrard

    No-tillage is an extensively used soil conservation practice in crop fields. Yet, no-tillage is prone to runoff generation, which may lead to downstream concentrated forms of erosion, floods, solute transfer and eutrophication of water bodies. However, infiltration terraces on hillslopes can reduce runoff and erosion. We analyzed nutrient losses, in both dissolved and particulate forms, on terraced and non-terraced agricultural hillslopes under no-tillage in Southern Brazil. Precipitation, runoff, sediment yield and chemical elements’ concentrations were monitored in paired catchments, including a 2.35 ha terraced catchment (TC) and a 2.43 non-terraced catchment (NTC), during rainfall events that occurred from 2017 to 2018. Runoff and suspended sediment samples were manually collected in H-flumes at the outlet of each hillslope, where automatic water level readings were recorded at 5-minute intervals by a limnigraph to estimate runoff discharge. P, K, Ca, Mg, Cu, Zn and N concentrations were analyzed in runoff-water samples and P, K, Ca e Mg in the suspended sediment samples to obtain dissolved and particulate concentrations, respectively, and total nutrient losses. Maximum N concentration in TC’s runoff samples (8.70 mg L-1) were higher than in the NTC (7.41 mg L-1). Ca concentrations were higher in the NTC (average 3.9 mg L-1). Low and similar Mg, Cu, Zn mean concentrations were observed in the catchments. Mean P concentrations were ~0.11 mg L-1 in both catchments but reached higher concentrations in the NTC. Mean (~3 mg L-1) and maximum (8.74 mg L-1) K concentrations were observed the TC. In sediment samples, Ca, Mg, P and K concentrations were higher in the NTC. To compare total dissolved nutrients losses, we chose 13 rainfall-runoff events and 10 events for particulate nutrient losses. Total rainfall for the 13 events was 1020 mm, leading to 110 and 222 mm of runoff in TC and NTC, respectively. Besides higher runoff volume, NTC shows higher losses of all analyzed nutrients in runoff. P losses were of 105 and 352 g ha-1 in TC and NTC, respectively, while K losses were of 2293 and 4604 g ha-1, showing a similar trend. The average increase in Cu losses for NTC was 21 times higher than for TC. Total sediment yield in TC, for the 10 events, was 12 kg ha-1, and 39 kg ha-1 in the NTC. Higher particulate nutrient loss was observed in the NTC outflow. An almost nine-fold increase in particulate P losses was observed in NTC, besides a four-fold increase in Ca, a seven-fold increase in Mg and two-fold K losses. Although higher nutrient concentrations in water were observed in the TC for some samples, overall losses and concentrations were greater in the NTC. This indicates that nutrient flux from agricultural hillslopes is controlled by runoff and that terraces can decrease flow and material connectivity over hillslopes. As soil and water conservation practices are needed to ensure agriculture’s sustainability and to avoid deleterious environmental impacts, measures for runoff mitigation, such as terraces, were shown to effectively control nutrient – and, potentially, other solutes – transfer to water bodies.

    How to cite: Dambroz, A., Utzig, D., Minella, J., Londero, A., Schneider, F., Barros, C., Koefender, D., and Evrard, O.: Dissolved and particulate nutrient yields in terraced and non-terraced zero order catchments under no-tillage, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12555, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12555, 2022.

    EGU22-1700 | Presentations | HS9.2

    Nearfield flocculation processes along a negatively buoyant river intrusion in a large lake (Lake Geneva) 

    Violaine Piton, Ulrich Lemmin, François Bourrin, Htet Kyi Wynn, Valentin Kindschi, and Andrew Barry

    In estuaries and marine environments, primary particles are frequently transported as large flocs. This study provides, for the first time, evidence of in situ flocculation in Lake Geneva, a glacier-fed freshwater lake on the Swiss/French border. Measurements were focused in the nearfield of the Rhône River plume as it flows as an interflow into the stratified lake (i.e., during summer). Direct observations of flocculated particles in the whole water column with a digital holographic camera (LISST-HOLO 30-2000 μm), permitted estimation of the variability of sediment floc properties (size, nature and shape) with depth. Combined with full-depth in situ laser particle sizing (LISST-100X), the measurements revealed that very fine silts (4-8 μm) are dominant in the Rhône River interflow (flowing at thermocline depth), which exhibited the highest suspended sediment loads in the water column. In the hypolimnion below the interflow, where sediment loads were the lowest, microflocs (20-125 μm) and macroflocs (> 125 μm) were most frequent. The size of the largest macroflocs decreased along the interflow pathway, from 272 μm at 350 m from the mouth to 195 μm at 1700 m. In the epilimnion above the interflow, very fine silts and numerous phytoplanktonic organisms (~100-200 μm) were observed. In the hypolimnion, the average estimated fractal dimension (DF3D) of the flocs ranged between 2.35 and 2.40, highlighting the complexity in floc shape, whereas phytoplanktonic organisms in the epilimnion had DF3D values ranging between 2.45 and 2.50, suggesting less complex shapes.

     

    The transition zone between the bottom layer of the interflow and the hypolimnion (~25-30 m depth) was marked by a sudden increase in the median particle diameter, corresponding to decreasing proportions of clays and very fine silts and to increasing proportions of micro and macroflocs. High-resolution profiles of turbulence collected with a Signature1000 revealed strong turbulence fluctuations and intense shear in this transition zone, compared to the interflow core. These levels of turbulence result in fine particle collisions, and favor the formation of larger flocs (i.e., flocculation) in the transition zone.

     

    Furthermore, the influence of instantaneous turbulent kinetic energy as a factor limiting the maximum floc size below the Rhône River interflow was investigated. The observed turbulence level below the interflow corresponded to an estimated Kolmogorov microscale of less than ~320 μm at 350 m from the mouth to ~200 μm at 1700 m, values that are consistent with measurements. This results in the potential breakup of flocs larger than these estimates into smaller finer particles and microflocs, and so can explain the decrease in the macrofloc size along the interflow pathway.

    How to cite: Piton, V., Lemmin, U., Bourrin, F., Wynn, H. K., Kindschi, V., and Barry, A.: Nearfield flocculation processes along a negatively buoyant river intrusion in a large lake (Lake Geneva), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1700, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1700, 2022.

    EGU22-1755 | Presentations | HS9.2

    Particulate phase transport of pesticides is substantial for runoff and erosion in a small agricultural catchment 

    Meindert Commelin, Jantiene Baartman, Paul Zomer, Michel Riksen, and Violette Geissen

    Agriculture on sloping lands is prone to processes of overland runoff and associated soil detachment, transportation, and deposition. The transport of pesticides to off-target areas related to runoff processes and soil erosion poses a threat of pollution to the downstream environment. This study aimed to quantify transport of pesticides both dissolved in water and in the particulate phase in transported sediments. Particulate phase transport of pesticides on short temporal time scales form agricultural fields is scarcely studied, and this study provides more insight into this process. During two growing seasons (2019 and 2020) rainfall – runoff events were monitored. We selected 32 different pesticides based on interviews with the farmers on the application pattern.  Concentrations for these 32 residues were analyzed in runoff water (dissolved phase - DP) and sediment (particulate phase - PP) and in soil samples taken in the agricultural fields. In all runoff events active substances (AS) were detected. There was a clear difference between DP and PP with a mean of 2 and 13 different AS per event respectively. The mean (± uncertainty) concentrations detected were 46 ±7 µg l-1 in DP and 2900 ± 500 µg kg-1 in PP. Although the transported mass of sediment is much lower than the total water discharge (QTSS : Qw = 1 :73) the contribution of PP to total pesticide load discharged was 47%. We conclude that for agriculture on sloping lands overland transport of pesticide in the particulate phase is a substantial transport pathway, and that this process needs to be considered in future assessments for pesticide fate and environmental risk.

    How to cite: Commelin, M., Baartman, J., Zomer, P., Riksen, M., and Geissen, V.: Particulate phase transport of pesticides is substantial for runoff and erosion in a small agricultural catchment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1755, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1755, 2022.

    EGU22-2928 | Presentations | HS9.2 | Highlight

    Progress towards an international comparison of river sediment pollution: Key factors influencing metal concentrations along seven Western European Rivers (1945-2020) 

    André-Marie Dendievel, Cécile Grosbois, Sophie Ayrault, Olivier Evrard, Alexandra Coynel, Maxime Debret, Thomas Gardes, Cassandra Euzen, Laurent Schmitt, François Chabaux, Thierry Winiarski, Marcel van Der Perk, and Brice Mourier

    Since 60 years, a large amount of data has been acquired to survey river sediment quality, especially concerning regulatory trace metals such as Cd, Cr, Cu, Hg, Ni, Pb, and Zn. Large-scale syntheses are still rare and show some limits to assess the effectiveness of public regulations and the river systems' resilience. Based on a sediment contamination database comprising more than 12,000 samples, we propose a first attempt to decipher spatio-temporal trends of metal contamination along seven major rivers in Western Europe (Garonne-Lot, Loire, Meuse Rhine, Rhone, Scheldt and Seine Rivers). Facing heterogeneous sampling and analytical methods on different sediment matrices (bed and flood deposits – BFD, suspended particulate matter – SPM, dated sediment cores – DSC), this work investigates the effect of analytical protocols, spatial and temporal factors on metal concentration trends. At a large scale, an increase in metal concentrations (especially for Cd, Pb and Zn) is reported along most of the investigated rivers. It appears closely related to major urban-industrial hotspots (Paris-Rouen corridor on the Seine River, Bonn-Duisburg corridor on the Rhine River, etc.) and to the geology of each watershed, both influencing the regional sediment quality. Former mining and metallurgical districts, generally located in crystalline areas, also caused high metal concentrations on the long term (Upper Loire River, Middle Meuse River, Lot River). A global decrease of metal concentrations is observed in all river sections since the 1960s-1970s onwards, in response to European and national regulations, and to socio-economical changes affecting urban-industrial areas. The high influence of the location of the samples along the rivers and the decade of sampling is confirmed by a Factor Analysis of Mixed Data (FAMD). Secondary factors such as the influence of the sediment matrix type (BFD, SPM and DSC) and the different digestion procedures prior to elemental analysis also explained significant differences for Cr, Cd, Cu, Pb, or Zn, although this can also be locally balanced by the substratum (i.e. for alkaline rivers). This approach points out the limitations of the available data, particularly regarding the need of regional geological backgrounds and the more systematic acquisition of ancillary data such as grain-size and TOC. It also provides critical clues to intercompare metal sediment pollution in rivers at large spatial and temporal scales worldwide.

    How to cite: Dendievel, A.-M., Grosbois, C., Ayrault, S., Evrard, O., Coynel, A., Debret, M., Gardes, T., Euzen, C., Schmitt, L., Chabaux, F., Winiarski, T., van Der Perk, M., and Mourier, B.: Progress towards an international comparison of river sediment pollution: Key factors influencing metal concentrations along seven Western European Rivers (1945-2020), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2928, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2928, 2022.

    EGU22-4512 | Presentations | HS9.2 | Highlight

    Wastewater treatment plant discharged phosphorus impacts the release of arsenic from arsenic-enriched streambed sediment 

    Petra Venhauerova, Petr Drahota, Ladislav Strnad, and Šárka Matoušková

    Phosphate competition with arsenic is one of the leading causes of As release from sediments into freshwaters. An important P source to freshwaters is wastewater treatment plants (WWTP), estimated to contribute 25–45% of all P in surface waters.

    A stream surrounded by soils and sediments with naturally elevated concentrations of As (> 200 mg/kg) and continuous entry of small capacity WWTP discharge was studied. The methods used were XRD, EPMA, bulk analyses, single extractions, and batch leaching experiments. Since 2013, the WWTP effluent supplies 7–23 mg/l of PO4 into the stream and an increased concentration of As (150–180 µg/l) due to everyday usage of As‑enriched wells water in the households. This study revealed that the fractionation of As and P in sediments changed due to exposure to treated wastewater. The adsorbed As fraction decreased by 9 %, whereas the adsorbed P fraction increased by 9 % in the downstream samples. As a result, the P‑retention capacity of the sediment decreased in the downstream samples from 16 % to 10–12 %. These findings are supported by a mineralogical study, which showed that P and As distribution within the Fe (hydr)oxides differed significantly between the samples taken upstream and downstream of the effluent discharge point. The samples upstream showed higher As and lower P median concentration (1.3 wt % of As2O5 and 0.8 of P2O5 wt %, respectively), while the opposite behavior was observed downstream: As 0.7 wt % of As2O5 and P 1.6 wt % of P2O5. These findings indicate that elevated phosphate is replaced by arsenate in the Fe (hydr)oxides, and the As is mobilized into the aqueous phase. Moreover, a detailed mineralogical investigation of samples exposed to the P-enriched effluent showed newly created Fe (hydr)oxide coatings significantly enriched in P (< 18.2 wt % of P2O5), Ca (< 10.9 wt % CaO) while depleted in As (< 3.3 wt % As2O5).

    Our results showed that local sources of phosphate, such as WWTP, in areas with elevated concentrations of As can significantly impact As behavior and may be responsible for elevated concentrations of As in surface waters.

    Acknowledgments: This research was supported by the Grant Agency of Charles University (GAUK no. 790120), Czech Science Foundation (GAČR no. 22-27939S), and the Center for Geosphere Dynamics (UNCE/SCI/006).

    How to cite: Venhauerova, P., Drahota, P., Strnad, L., and Matoušková, Š.: Wastewater treatment plant discharged phosphorus impacts the release of arsenic from arsenic-enriched streambed sediment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4512, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4512, 2022.

    EGU22-6094 | Presentations | HS9.2 | Highlight

    Accumulation of Fine Sediments and Particle-bound Pollutants in a German Urbanised Stream 

    Karen L. Rojas-Gómez, Jakob Benisch, Soohyun Yang, Dietrich Borchardt, and Peter Krebs

    In urbanised areas, the surface runoff generated by heavy rainfall events mobilise particles carrying contaminants such as heavy metals and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons. Those particle-bound pollutants (PBPs) are likely to reach streams through combined sewer overflows or stormwater discharges. Hence, stormwater runoff from urban impervious surfaces affects hydrological and sedimentological conditions of urban streams. Therefore, it is necessary to assess sediment sources, pathways and storage in urbanised catchments to improve sediment management and receiving water quality.

    This study aimed at characterising the impacts of urban wet weather discharges (UWWDs) along a stream bed. Thus, the intrusion of fine sediments and the concentration of heavy metals was evaluated along a downstream urbanisation gradient. Our study area is a small catchment (Lockwitzbach, 84 km2) located in Dresden, Germany. It has a main stream length of 29 km and its land use is dominated by non-irrigated arable land (40%), pastures (21%) and urban areas (14%). The urbanised area is clustered towards downstream. In this study we focused on the last 7 km within the city of Dresden, where 9 combined sewer overflows and 19 storm water outlets are located. The urban catchment was subdivided into 9 sewersheds considering the characteristics of the urban drainage network.

    Between March and October 2021, sediment samples were collected along the stream bed in 7 points, before and after heavy rainfall events. A total of 75 sediment samples were characterised considering 9 elements concentration (i.e., Al, B, Cd, Co, Cr, Cu, Pb, Sr and Zn) of the fine sediment fraction (<63µm), total solids and volatile solids. Additionally, suspended sediment samples were taken upstream and downstream the urban area. In those two sampling points, high-resolution discharge and turbidity data were continuously monitored. Fine sediment loads were calculated in order to compute a mass balance of the urban catchment. This allowed to understand the dynamic transport mechanisms of fine sediments and relevant PBPs in the urban stream, considering complex runoff and discharge processes.

    Furthermore, identification of main sources of sediments was carried out using finger-printing analysis. K-means clustering allowed to group the stream bed sediment samples into two distinct types: 1) “relatively clean sediment” and 2) “sediment affected by UWWDs”. The urban discharges increase the element concentration in the fine sediment fraction along the first 6 km of the stream. This suggests an accumulation of contaminants towards the urban gradient. However, results showed a high attenuation capacity of the urban stream, since after receiving 27 UWWDs, the elements concentration of the sediment collected in the last 1 km is statistically similar to the fine sediment collected upstream the urban area (cluster type 1).

    Fine sediments export was calculated for each sewershed. Areas with UWWDs carrying high sediments and PBPs loads were distinguished. Likewise, potential hotspots of intrusion of fine sediments in the stream were clearly determined. Those hotspots could be potential locations to control fine sediments and PBPs. The findings will help prioritising and locating possible strategies to improve river water and sediment quality. 

    How to cite: Rojas-Gómez, K. L., Benisch, J., Yang, S., Borchardt, D., and Krebs, P.: Accumulation of Fine Sediments and Particle-bound Pollutants in a German Urbanised Stream, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6094, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6094, 2022.

    Turbulent flow is a chaotic condition filled with vortex structures in the flow. Based on past studies, turbulent bursting events are composed of outward interactions (Q1), ejections (Q2), inward interactions (Q3), and sweeps (Q4). Among these events, ejections (Q2) and sweeps (Q4) significantly contribute to time occupied, momentum flux, and sediment flux from the turbulent coherent structure analysis. In addition, turbulent coherent events were assumed to occur continuously in the past. However, it is noticed that, on average, approximately 90% of the total stress was found within merely 50% of the total sampling time. Furthermore, the earlier works supposed the occurrences of these events are the same, and the change between the two states is uncorrelated. It is found that the occurrences of bursting events are a non-Markovian random process. The flow region can be divided into two parts (the near-bed region and the upper layer) by the spatial gradient of the flow velocity. The flow condition near the bed bottom tends to be anisotropic because of the turbulent structures. As mentioned above, these characteristics (intermittency, memory, and anisotropy) were not considered in past studies. This study proposes a modified Stochastic Diffusion Particle Tracking Model, a stochastic Lagrangian model to describe sediment particle movement. The proposed model integrates these characteristics, such as length-scale and time-scale of coherent events determined from the Direct Numerical Simulation dataset (DNS dataset), to reveal more details of sediment particle motion in the turbulent flow. We obtain the sediment particle trajectory from the model and analyze the anomalous diffusion in sediment transport by calculating the variance of the particle trajectory. As far as we know, extreme flow events such as floods induced by typhoons or heavy rainfalls can be regarded as highly intermittency processes. When a detailed description of the turbulent flow can be made available, we can simulate sediment particle motion more comprehensively under these extreme flow conditions.

    How to cite: Wu, M. J. and Tsai, C. W.: Stochastic sediment transport modeling under the effects of intermittency and anisotropy of turbulent flow, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7008, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7008, 2022.

    Open-channel confluences are important junctions in fluvial and artificial networks, which regulate the mixing phenomena of substances transported by the merging flows. This paper aims at contributing to the study of how the discharge ratio of the incoming flows influences the flow patterns and mixing phenomena at a T-shaped open-channel confluence with a wider downstream channel. In this study, Large Eddy Simulations (LES) are applied to compare the flow and passive scalar transport processes at two discharge ratios. The results clearly show that in the tributary-dominant case, the shear layer and the mixing interface move to the outer bank, due to the larger lateral velocities in the Confluence Hydrodynamics Zone (CHZ). Moreover, the turbulence and the secondary flow are enhanced, leading to a higher degree of mixing, as compared to the case with a dominance of the incoming flow from the main channel.

    How to cite: Jin, T., Xavier Ramos, P., and De Mulder, T.: Effect of discharge ratio on flow and passive scalar transport in a T-shaped confluence with a wider downstream channel, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7821, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7821, 2022.

    EGU22-8781 | Presentations | HS9.2 | Highlight

    Persistent imprint of historical metallurgy in an alpine watershed evidenced from lake sediments Pb isotopes 

    Floriane Guillevic, Magali Rossi, Fabien Arnaud, Jérôme Poulenard, Cécile Quantin, and Gaël Monvoisin

    The Pb-Ag mine of Peisey-Nancroix was operated between 1734 and 1824. The associated smelters emitted Pb-rich fumes that were reported as threatening for local people all along their period of activity. Lake La Plagne is located at 2 100 m a.s.l., 7 km uphill the former mine. Considering that smelters fumes were transported uphill by prevailing winds, studying the metal contamination within Lake La Plagne sediments offers the rare opportunity to reconstruct the local atmospheric contamination, as well as the remnant catchment area contamination in a context where historical conditions of exploitation are well-constrained.

    Sediments deposited before mining and smelting only contains 30 mg/kg of Pb, whereas the sediments deposited during smelting contains up to 148 mg/kg of Pb. Recent sediments deposited after mining activity period also present an enrichment in Pb (up to 58 mg/kg). Mineralogical observations (SEM-FEG) suggest that within contamination peaks, Pb is essentially associated with infra µm-scale Mn-Fe (hyrdr-)oxides.

    Pb isotopes were measured on selected samples collected along the lake sediment core prior mining, during mining and smelting, and after mining. The Pb isotopic ratios of all lake sediments (n=12) indicate mixing between the isotopic ratios of the ore (n=39; galena : 208Pb/206Pb =2.092 ± 0.004 and 206Pb/207Pb= 1.173 ± 0.002), and those of the deepest lake sediments (n=2; 208Pb/206Pb =2.041 ± 0.002 and 206Pb/207Pb= 1.209 ± 0.0004) that are representative of the geochemical background. The sediments deposited long after mining still present a significant influence of local ore-derived Pb, suggesting remobilisation from the watershed of Pb inherited from the smelting period.

    How to cite: Guillevic, F., Rossi, M., Arnaud, F., Poulenard, J., Quantin, C., and Monvoisin, G.: Persistent imprint of historical metallurgy in an alpine watershed evidenced from lake sediments Pb isotopes, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8781, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8781, 2022.

    EGU22-9184 | Presentations | HS9.2

    Catchment scale variation of contaminants in glacial sediments from the Cordillera Blanca, Peru 

    Dylan Bodhi Beard, Caroline Clason, Sally Rangecroft, Wilmer Sánchez Rodríguez, and William Blake

    Historically, glaciers have been seen as pristine environments. However, research has shown that glaciers can accumulate and store contaminants through processes such as atmospheric deposition, mass movements, and anthropogenic activities. Numerous anthropogenically and naturally-derived contaminants have been found within glacial sediments, including fallout radionuclides, potentially toxic elements, and heavy metals. The introduction of these contaminants often come from human activities such as the use of agricultural fertilisers, carbon based industries, vehicular use, and nuclear power plants. However, these contaminants can also originate from natural sources such as erosion of metal-rich rock and forest fires. Through mechanisms of secondary release, these often legacy contaminants are remobilized, finding their way into glacial riverine systems and downstream environments. This can then pose potential threats to human and ecosystem health, as well as impacting food quality, water resources, livelihoods, and social justice.

    When assessing potential downstream risk from glacial contaminants, it is crucial to know what types of contaminants may be released in meltwaters and in what quantity. Here we identify contaminants in cryoconite – a sediment found on the surface of glaciers – in Peru’s Cordillera Blanca, from which meltwater feeds into the Rio Santa. Previous studies have shown that glaciers in similar environments (i.e. high mountain glacier catchments) have been found to contain differing types and concentrations of contaminants within cryoconite. However, until now this had not been reported for cryoconite on glaciers in Peru. This research investigates the variation in contaminant load in cryoconite from four different glaciers (Pastoruri, Shallap, Vallunaraju, and Yanapacca) within the Cordillera Blanca. Key contaminants in cryoconite from this region have been analysed using X-ray fluorescence, gamma spectrometry, and ICP-MS. These results contribute to an improved understanding of the extent to which glaciers may act as a secondary source of contaminants to the Rio Santa catchment. This is an important first step towards assessing the risk of contaminant release from glaciers in this region.

    How to cite: Beard, D. B., Clason, C., Rangecroft, S., Rodríguez, W. S., and Blake, W.: Catchment scale variation of contaminants in glacial sediments from the Cordillera Blanca, Peru, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9184, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9184, 2022.

    EGU22-9411 | Presentations | HS9.2

    Geochemical features of river flow into Lake Onego 

    Natalia Kulik, Natalia Efremenko, Natalia Belkina, Vera Strakhovenko, and Ekaterina Gatalskaya

    Lake Onego is the second largest body of water in Europe (S lake mirrors = 9720 km2, V = 295 km3, S catchment area = 53100 km2), located at the junction of two geological structures (the Fennoscandian Shield and the Russian Platform) is characterized by a complex morphology of the basin, uneven distribution of river flow and anthropogenic load.

    In 2020-2021, the peculiarities of the flow of terrigenous material into the lake, affecting the formation of heterogeneity in the composition of the mineral part of the bottom sediments, were studied. New knowledge was obtained about the seasonal variability of the geochemical composition of river waters, the spatial and temporal nature of its variability was shown. By the example of iron, manganese and total phosphorus, the seasonal distribution of the forms of migration of these elements in rivers is considered. Concentrations of dissolved and suspended forms of trace elements in river waters were obtained. The uneven distribution of river suspension particles by size and degree of rolling, as well as seasonal differences in the ratio of mineral and organic components of the suspension are shown. The study of the composition of the dispersed sedimentary matter revealed similar spectra of minerals. It was found that the material of river suspensions is represented by a biogenic X-ray amorphous mass (biodetrite of diatoms, spores and pollen of plant communities) with associations of detrital mineral particles, scaly formations of layered silicates and aluminosilicates, fouling with jelly-like clots and films of oxides and hydroxides of manganese and iron on organic skeletons.

    The study was supported by RFBR grant #19-05-50014, RSF research project #18-17-00176 and by the Federal Budget, within the State Assignments nos. 121021700116-6.

    How to cite: Kulik, N., Efremenko, N., Belkina, N., Strakhovenko, V., and Gatalskaya, E.: Geochemical features of river flow into Lake Onego, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9411, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9411, 2022.

    EGU22-10038 | Presentations | HS9.2

    Estimating suspended sediment concentration, fluxes and loads of sediment-associated chemical constituents using a submerged spectrophotometer 

    Núria Martínez-Carreras, Niels F. Lake, Dhruv Sehgal, Christophe Hissler, and Adrian L. Collins

    Sediments are known to be a vector for nutrient and contaminant transfer because many substances partition preferentially to fine-grained sediment rather than remaining in solution. Despite the need to obtain reliable information on suspended sediment chemical composition, studies and monitoring programmes are often hampered by the difficulties associated with sampling, and by analytical costs. This, in turn, restricts high frequency sampling campaigns to a limited number of events and reduces the accuracy of the estimated fluxes and yields of sediment-associated chemical constituents.

    Over the past decade, progress in environmental monitoring and analytics has increasingly facilitated the collection of hydro-chemical data at high frequency using in-situ sensors (e.g., minutes). However, sensors to estimate sediment-associated chemical constituents are limited. Here, we propose the use of submerged spectrophotometers, which measure absorbance in the UV-VIS range, to predict sediment mineralogical composition, major and trace elements and colour. Submerged spectrophotometers have already been successfully used to predict mean particle size and sediment carbon content. In this study, we assess the performance of several regression models that relate light absorbance measurements with suspended sediment properties. To this end, spectrophotometers were installed at five different sites across Luxembourg. Preliminary results show that spectrophotometers allow simultaneous assessment of various sediment constituents and/or properties at high frequency, suggesting their deployment can assist in the estimation of reliable fluxes and yields of sediment-associated substances.

    How to cite: Martínez-Carreras, N., Lake, N. F., Sehgal, D., Hissler, C., and Collins, A. L.: Estimating suspended sediment concentration, fluxes and loads of sediment-associated chemical constituents using a submerged spectrophotometer, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10038, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10038, 2022.

    The n-alkane (n-C10 to n-C35) distributions and anthropogenic markers (sterol and PAH) from the surface sediments of Rewalsar Lake, Himachal Pradesh (India) were investigated to disentangle natural and anthropogenic organic matter sources. The presence of odd numbered n-alkanes (n-C27, n-C29 and n-C31) along with TAR, CPI and ACL values provide dominance of allochthonous over autochthonous organic matter sources. Detailed examination of allochthonous sources further reflect the accumulation of pollutants (PAHs and sterols) that mark the intensified toxicity and high degradation rates of lake system. The results obtained from diagnostic PAH indices highlight that the lake is immensely influenced by miscellaneous sources i.e, pyrogenic and petrogenic. Further, the occurrence of sewage contaminants particularly coprostanol and epicoprostanol suggest high anthropogenic loading due to sewage discharges. The overall accumulation of contaminants in the lake can be attributed to anthropogenic activities involving chemical and sewage overflow, agricultural and industrial discharges, land use changes, developmental activities. The uncontrollable pollution status of the Rewalsar lake is supported by low pristane/phytane (Pr/Ph) ratio that denotes anoxia. Moreover, dominance of coarse particles (silt and sand) over clay-sized particles further confirms high human intervention in the catchment area. Therefore, the study provides comprehensive understanding on organic matter source apportionment as well as role of anthropogenic stressors in the wake of rapid urbanization around Rewalsar lake.

    How to cite: Bulbul, M. and Anoop, A.: Molecular signatures of natural organic matter and anthropogenic contaminants from high altitude fresh water lake (Rewalsar) in NW Indian Himalaya, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11329, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11329, 2022.

    EGU22-1318 | Presentations | HS9.3

    MultiPAC: A novel approach to quantify the clogging degree of a riverbed 

    Stefan Haun, Beatriz Negreiros, Maximilian Kunz, Sebastian Schwindt, Alcides Aybar Galdos, Markus Noack, and Silke Wieprecht

    Riverbed clogging, also referred to as colmation, describes the infiltration of fine sediment in gravel bed rivers. The infiltrated fine sediment leads to a reduction of the pore space and, in the worst case, to a sealing of the riverbed. As a result of severe colmation, negative effects on the environment may occur, such as a limited oxygen supply for fish eggs or for macrozoobenthos.

    The quantification of the degree of colmation and its impact on the ecological status of a river is often based on an expert assessment or only on a single parameter, such as the amount of fine sediment. However, depending on the sediment matrix of the riverbed, the packing arrangement of particles, or the organic material in the riverbed, a single parameter may not be sufficient to evaluate the degree of colmation. In addition, most expert-based assessments, such as mapping of inner and outer colmation, are on the one hand biased due to subjectiveness and on the other hand, only investigate the surface layer of the riverbed. Knowledge on possible occurring colmation layers in deeper regions of the interstitial will not be gained by using these methods.

    In this study, a novel MultiParameter Approach to assess Colmation (MultiPAC), is presented, which measures several physical parameters, and provides insights into the status of colmation conditions in the interstitial. These are:

    • measurements of the sediment composition for identifying surface and subsurface grain size distributions and for assessing fine sediment fractions,
    • measurements of porosity by using Structure-from-Motion in combination with freeze-core sampling, and
    • measurements of oxygen concentration and hydraulic conductivity by using a newly developed double-packer system, called VertiCo.

    The VertiCo (Vertical profiles of hydraulic Conductivity and dissolved Oxygen) enables measurements with a high spatial resolution over the vertical axis of the riverbed to enable the quantification of possible colmation layers or changes of the conditions in the interstitial over depth.

    With the MultiPAC it is feasible for the first time to holistically assess the influence of oxygen and hydraulic conductivity in the interstitial. By taking also into account the properties of the sediment matrix and the porosity, the degree of colmation of a riverbed can be identified. In addition, these findings may provide important information to support the classification of the ecological state of river sections.

    How to cite: Haun, S., Negreiros, B., Kunz, M., Schwindt, S., Aybar Galdos, A., Noack, M., and Wieprecht, S.: MultiPAC: A novel approach to quantify the clogging degree of a riverbed, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1318, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1318, 2022.

    EGU22-5456 | Presentations | HS9.3

    Contribution of a windthrow-affected area to the suspended sediment transport in an Alpine Mountain catchment: a focus on the snowmelt period. 

    Giacomo Pellegrini, Riccardo Rainato, Luca Mao, and Lorenzo Picco

    In many environments, climate change causes an increase in the frequency and magnitude of Large Infrequent Disturbances (LIDs). LIDs make fragile areas, as mountain basins, even more vulnerable. Among all LIDs, windthrows are one of the most relevant disturbances affecting the Alpine region. Windthrows can affect the forest cover and morphological settings at the basin scale (e.g., due to associated landslides), changing the supply of sediments to river networks and affecting the cascading processes. This work aims to measure the sediment contribution of a managed windthrow-affected area during the snowmelt (1st April - 15th June 2021) in the Rio Cordon basin (5 km2, eastern Italian Alps). The study reach crosses the area affected by windthrow and receives sediments from six sediment sources. Two multiparameter sondes measuring the turbidity and the water level were installed upstream and downstream the windthrow-affected area. Moreover, water samples and salt dilution discharge measurements were collected to obtain the rating curves and calibrate the turbidity meters in order to derive suspended sediment loads (SSL). The cumulative precipitation registered 231.2 mm during the entire 2021 snowmelt period. The total runoff recorded was 3,054,239 m3 and the total SSL at the outlet was 109 t. Two relevant events peaking at 1.13 and 1.86 m3 s-1 were recorded in the study period, and in both cases the SSL was higher at the downstream end of the reach (+4.4% and +4.0% respectively). However, clockwise hysteresis loops were identified in both sections and events. Although these preliminary results suggest that the managed windthrow-affected area can be a potential source of sediment, the greatest contribution of sediments seems to have been provided by other sediment sources, either or both located on the slopes and in the channel bed upstream the monitoring area. This study represents a suitable way of understanding the cascading processes in a mountain basin, to improve both risk-and conservation-related management strategies. Further analysis to comprehend the all-seasons basin responses are undergoing.

     

    How to cite: Pellegrini, G., Rainato, R., Mao, L., and Picco, L.: Contribution of a windthrow-affected area to the suspended sediment transport in an Alpine Mountain catchment: a focus on the snowmelt period., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5456, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5456, 2022.

    EGU22-5480 | Presentations | HS9.3

    A century of sedimentation in a reservoir in central Europe – sedimentation rate and characteristics 

    Georg Stauch, Alexander Esch, Lukas Dörwald, Verena Esser, Simone Lechthaler, Frank Lehmkuhl, Philipp Schulte, and Janek Walk

    The sediments of the artificial Urft reservoir preserve a century of environmental information due to undisturbed sedimentation conditions. The Urft reservoir is located in the Eifel Mountains in western Germany and was built between 1900 and 1905. At the time of its construction, the Urft reservoir was the largest reservoir (45.51 million m³) and drove, with 12 MW, the most powerful water storage power plant in Europe. During construction works in November 2020, the reservoir was nearly completely drained. This offered the unique possibility to analyse the sediment volume and the composition deposited during the last 115 years.

    We used high resolution maps with a scale of 1:1,000 from 1898 which were compiled to calculate the original storage volume of the reservoir. To assess the present-day surface, the entire lake area was photogrammetrically surveyed using an Unmanned Aerial Vehicle (UAV). Additionally, 10 drill cores were retrieved in 2020 to quantify the anthropogenic influence on the sediments in the form of mining-induced sediment-bound pollutants (e.g., heavy metals) and to relate this to the history of use in the catchment area. Furthermore, microplastics were studied in the sediments. To derive the sediment ages, a detailed Cs-137 chronology was created for one of the cores.

    In summer 2021, the northern Eifel Mountains were impacted by a catastrophic flooding event, resulting in massive destructions in the catchment of the Urft and strong relocation of sediments in the floodplain. To assess these geomorphologic changes in the Urft reservoir, the water level was lowered again in December 2021. Consequently, an additional digital elevation model was produced by UAV surveying. Furthermore, additional sediment cores were taken to get information on changes in the sediment composition due to the flood event. In the upper part of the reservoir, up to 30 cm of sediments were deposited in summer 2021 while channels below the water surface experienced strong modifications.

    How to cite: Stauch, G., Esch, A., Dörwald, L., Esser, V., Lechthaler, S., Lehmkuhl, F., Schulte, P., and Walk, J.: A century of sedimentation in a reservoir in central Europe – sedimentation rate and characteristics, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5480, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5480, 2022.

    EGU22-5665 | Presentations | HS9.3

    Sediment source and pathway identification using Sentinel-2 imagery and (kayak-based) lagrangian river profiles on the Vjosa river 

    Jessica Droujko, Srividya Hariharan Sudha, Gabriel Singer, and Peter Molnar

    Estimates of suspended sediment concentration (SSC) at high spatial resolution can be used to identify sediment sources, track the natural erosion gradients over entire mountain ranges, and quantify anthropogenic effects on catchment-scale sediment production, e.g. by dam construction or erosion control. Measurements of SSC at a basin outlet yields a basin-integrated picture of possible hydroclimatically-driven sources of sediment. However, a statistical analysis of one-dimensional input-output relations does not give us a full spatial perspective on sediment pathways of production and, potentially transient, storage within the catchment. These sediment pathways within catchments are difficult to identify and quantify due to the lack of affordable monitoring options that can create both spatially and temporally highly resolved datasets. Here, we propose a methodology to quantify these pathways using Sentinel-2 Level-1C imagery and in-situ measurements from a small network of sensors. The study is carried out on the Vjosa river, which represents one of the last intact large river systems in Europe. Geological diversity in the catchment and its widely unobstructed fluvial morphology over the entire river length makes it extremely interesting to monitor natural sediment dynamics. The remote sensing signal from the river’s water column, extracted from satellite imagery, contains an optical measure of turbidity. Furthermore, in-situ turbidity measurements between May 2019 and July 2020 from seven turbidity sensors located across the Vjosa provide ground-truthing. A significant multiple linear regression model between turbidity and reflectance was fitted to these data. The regression model has a low adjusted R2 value of 0.30 but a highly significant p-value (< 2.2e-16). The satellite data together with the regression model were used to generate longitudinal profiles of predicted turbidity over the catchment from August 2020 to August 2021. Validation of these predictions for two different Sentinel-2 acquisition dates was done with in-situ turbidity measurements taken from a kayak during descents of the entire river. This validation showed accurate prediction of trends on a catchment scale but poor accuracy in the prediction of pointwise turbidity quantification. The model also showed accurate estimation of trends during different climatic seasons, suggesting that our approach captures the temporal variability in suspended sediment concentrations driven by long-term hydrological processes. Gridded rainfall from E-OBS was used to identify short-term hydrological forcing such as storm-driven activation of sediment sources. In order to monitor the many physical connections between hydrology, river processes, and sediment fluxes, future work will include extension of the in-situ turbidity sensor network with new sensors developed by our group. We plan to place these low-cost sensors at the outlet of every major tributary, on the main stem both above and below a confluence with a tributary, and within morphodynamically unique reaches.

    How to cite: Droujko, J., Hariharan Sudha, S., Singer, G., and Molnar, P.: Sediment source and pathway identification using Sentinel-2 imagery and (kayak-based) lagrangian river profiles on the Vjosa river, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5665, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5665, 2022.

    EGU22-5978 | Presentations | HS9.3

    Potentiality of bedload measures using Acoustic Doppler Current  profiler technique 

    Daniele Gasparato, Lisdey Veronica Herrera Gomez, Giovanni Ravazzani, and Marco Mancini

    Bedload discharge measurement in riverine environment is crucial to monitor and understand the morphological evolution of the riverbed and its interaction with existing and new infrastructures.  Despite their relevance, bed load solid transport measures are most of time not available due to the difficulties in their acquisition.

    The paper investigates the potentiality of Acoustic Doppler Current Profiler (ADCP ) technique, well established for measuring discharge and flow velocity in a river,  for the measure of bedload discharge in a more manageable way than the traditional ones.

    A specific field campaign was organized at Boretto (Italy) cross section on the Po river where the riverbed sediment consists of uniform sand with a mean diameter of 0.4 mm. ADCP measures of bedload discharges were done at the same time as the ones acquired by traditional Helley Smith sampler.

    The ADCP data are used in two different ways to obtain the value of the bedload solid discharge. The first approach computes the bedload discharge using the literature formulas where the shear velocities are computed by the logarithmic fit of the velocity profile given by the ADCP. The second approach uses the instrument Bottom Tracking function to obtain a measure of the sediment velocity on the river bed. The sediment velocity computed with this latter method is then used to calculate the bedload discharge with a kinematic model, whose parameters of active layer thickness and concentration are estimated using the Van Rijn model.

    The comparison of traditional measures with the one based on the ADCP show comparable values of bed load discharges of the same order of magnitude.

    How to cite: Gasparato, D., Herrera Gomez, L. V., Ravazzani, G., and Mancini, M.: Potentiality of bedload measures using Acoustic Doppler Current  profiler technique, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5978, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5978, 2022.

    EGU22-6369 | Presentations | HS9.3

    Temporal resolution of echosounding measurements for assessing bedload transport rates via dune tracking 

    Mina Tabesh, Julius Reich, and Axel Winterscheid

    Assessment of bedload transport rates is of great importance for river morphology. Over the years, many efforts have been made to get a realistic estimate of the bedload transport rate in a river. Several researchers suggested that a reliable estimate of the bedload transport rate can be computed from migration of dunes based on the so-called dune tracking method. To apply this method, bed elevation profiles have to be measured using echosounding of the river bed to determine dune geometries (length (λ) and height (H)) and dune migration rate (C).
    The migration rate of dunes (C = ∆X/∆T) is calculated by cross-correlation based on dune migration distance (∆X) and time interval (∆T) between echosounded profiles of two successive measurements. Based on literature, the ∆T between successive echosoundings has to be small enough for the same dunes to be clearly detectable in both measurements. However, the parameter ∆T has not been yet quantified for different river conditions. The objective of the present study is to get an appropriate estimation of the ∆T in order for the cross-correlation to work properly and thus to get a reliable magnitude of bedload transport rate which is at the same time also a specification for the execution of the measurements.
    To provide an accurate estimate of the ∆T, both the dune migration distance (can be related to the dune geometries) and the dune migration rate need to be known. Since both parameters (∆X and C) are not available at the beginning of measurements in the field, they need to be estimated based on the existing predictors (e.g. Allen (1968), Tsuchiya & Ishizaki (1967), Van Rijn (1984), Wilbers (2004)) in the literature. The predictors’ verification has been carried out by using the dune geometries and the dune migration rate obtained based on the echosounded profiles. The analysis has been conducted by using the echosounding data of the LiLaR campaign (November 2021) from the Rhine River around the German-Dutch border between km 858-859. For the verification, the dune tracking method has been used. The applied dune tracking method is based on a combination of the software RhenoBT (Frings et al. 2012) and Bedforms ATM (Gutierrez et al. 2018), which determine the dune geometries. Besides, the dune migration rate has been calculated by the cross-correlation using an R script.
    This study shows that the dune migration distance can be related to the dune length (∆X = p.λ). The p parameter depends on echosounding measurement uncertainties and dune geometries changes as they migrate downstream. Furthermore, the migration rate would be probably predicted best with Wilbers (2004) predictor in which dune migration rate is related to dune length. While large dunes migrations show high correlation (> 0.7) for time interval of more than 20 hours, small superimposed dunes only show high correlation for time interval lower than 2 hours. Knowing the required time interval can be a helpful factor during echosounding measurements which results in finding the dunes that are most active in transporting bedload material as they migrate downstream.

    How to cite: Tabesh, M., Reich, J., and Winterscheid, A.: Temporal resolution of echosounding measurements for assessing bedload transport rates via dune tracking, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6369, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6369, 2022.

    EGU22-8903 | Presentations | HS9.3

    Qualification of the efficiency of a dam dredging by mapping the sediment plume with adcp acoustic backscatter 

    Alexandre Hauet, Hélène Scheepers, Dominique Lepa, and Bruno Capon

    EDF is the largest producer of hydroelectricity in Europe and France, with about 640 dams and an installed capacity of about 20GW. Sedimentation in dam reservoirs is a paramount issue for EDF, including impacts on electricity generation, on dam stability, on spillway discharge capabilities and operation of bottom gates, and on the sediment starvation downstream.

    This study focusses on EDF’s dam of Chambon, in the French Alps. In order to guarantee the proper operation of the Chambon dam's outlet bottom gate (the main safety device) between 45 and 55,000   m3 of fine sediments upstream of this gate have to be cleaned out and thus create a stable release zone.  The dredging was conducted by a dilution-pumping method that consists in pumping the sediment deposited in the area upstream the bottom gate, and released them upstream the power-plant intake so that they can transit through the turbines and return to the river downstream to be diluted. The outlet of the pipe dredge was stalled several meters in front of the water intake in order to entrain the fine sediment plume while allowing sand and gravel (which can create serious damage to the turbine) to settle before the intake.

    To verify the efficiency of this method, and to ensure that the fine sediments were well entrained in the power-plant intake, adcp measurements were conducted to map the acoustic backscatter intensity that reflects the sediment concentration. A TRDI RioGrande 600 kHz was used, tilted by 20° in order to point the Beam 1 to the Nadir and avoiding side-lobe perturbation close to the bottom. The acoustic backscatter from Beam 1 is used as a proxy of sediment concentration, in a qualitative approach (without estimating the sediment concentration in g/L), in order to map areas of no-, low- or high- sediment concentration.

    The measurements show that the release of sediment from the dredging nozzle is highly variable over time, and causes sediment puffs which are diffused towards the free surface and laterally downstream. The sediment plume is homogenized in the body of water, then plunges towards the power-plant intake where it is entrained. 

    How to cite: Hauet, A., Scheepers, H., Lepa, D., and Capon, B.: Qualification of the efficiency of a dam dredging by mapping the sediment plume with adcp acoustic backscatter, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8903, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8903, 2022.

    EGU22-9307 | Presentations | HS9.3

    Influence of riverine suspended sediment carbon content and particle size on turbidity 

    Dhruv Sehgal, Núria Martinez-Carreras, Christophe Hissler, Victor Bense, and Ton (A.J.F.) Hoitink

    In recent decades, optical backscatter techniques have increasingly become used to measure turbidity for the quantification of suspended sediment (SS) concentrations. One of the limitations of this method is that site-specific calibrations between SS concentration and turbidity (NTU) are needed. This is because turbidity (NTU) readings respond to factors other than SS concentrations, such as organic and mineral fractions, SS density, particle size distributions, and particle shape. Organic matter introduces irregularity in the shape of suspended particles that may aggregate to form flocs, which are not spherical, and different SS particle fractions (clay, silt, and sand) show different optical responses. Even though organic content is known to influence particle size and density and, as a result, turbidity, an explicit formulation of turbidity accounting for organic content is still missing. We conjecture that a better understanding of the relations between turbidity, SS carbon content (proxy for SS organic content under specific conditions) and particle size can help us to move from local calibrations towards ‘global’ dependencies. In this study, we investigate this by means of (i) a laboratory experiment, and (ii) in-situ high frequency SS characterization of carbon content and particle size. We collected sediments from 6 sites in Luxembourg representing different land use types and geological settings. The sampled sediments were wet sieved into 3 size classes and one part of the sieved samples were oxidized with hydrogen peroxide to investigate the effect of carbon content on turbidity and particle size. To this end, we first conducted laboratory experiments using a tailor-made setup consisting of a cylindrical tank (40-L) with an open top. A stirrer facilitated the homogeneous mixing of SS and prevented settling of heavy particles. Here, a submerged UV-VIS spectrolyser was used to estimate SS carbon content, a LISST-200X sensor to measure particle size distribution and a YSI EXO2 multi-parameter sensor to measure turbidity (NTU). Carbon content was measured in the laboratory with a CHNS Elemental analyser to calibrate the spectrometer readings, and a Mastersizer 3000 to measure particle size distribution. Laboratory results were then validated using field data from two instrumented sites in Luxembourg (Alzette River at Huncherange and Attert River at Useldange). Ongoing analysis will be discussed, and a global calibration equation between turbidity and SSC based on particle size, density and carbon content will be presented.

    How to cite: Sehgal, D., Martinez-Carreras, N., Hissler, C., Bense, V., and Hoitink, T. (A. J. F. ).: Influence of riverine suspended sediment carbon content and particle size on turbidity, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9307, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9307, 2022.

    EGU22-9319 | Presentations | HS9.3

    Investigation of the morphological and ecohydraulic evolution in the course of river restoration works in a transboundary section of the Thaya River 

    Marlene Haimann, Mario Klösch, Patrick Holzapfel, Franz Steiner, Kevin Merl, Erich Busch, Michael Krapesch, Christopher Tomaschitz, Peter Baumann, and Helmut Habersack

    Downstream of Bernhardsthal to its confluence with the Morava River, the Thaya River forms the border between Austria and the Czech Republic. Here, in the about 15 km long river section, the river was channelized in the 1970ies and 1980ies mainly by meander cut-offs and bank protection. In addition, this section is impacted by sediment retention in upstream reservoirs and by the effects of climate change, which has led to adverse morphological response of the river and a decline in habitat diversity. Since original habitats in the form of oxbows and riparian forests still exist in the immediate vicinity of the Thaya River, the potential for restoration is particularly high. This was exploited in two projects (Dyje 2020/Thaya 2020 and Thaya Wellendynamik/Dyje, rovnovážnádynamika odtokových poměrů, funded by the EU through INTERREG AT-CZ), where restoration measures such as the removal of bank protection and enhanced bank erosion by large woody debris structures, as well as the reconnection of meanders were implemented. Without monitoring of the morphodynamics before and after restoration, the effects of these efforts would remain unclear.

    In the EU-funded project SEDECO (INTERREG AT-CZ), morphological changes and the current morphodynamics of the Thaya River in this section were investigated. The analysis is mainly based on cross-sectional measurements from 1996, which were resurveyed within the project. Furthermore, the current morphodynamics, occurring after the implementation of the restoration measures, are surveyed in detail. By comparing the different data sets, the development of the river was assessed and a sediment budget was calculated applying the newly developed sediment budgeting tool BudSed. Additionally, the suspended sediment transport is measured at a monitoring station in the upstream part of this section. These data were supplemented by orthophotos to determine the evolution of the active channel. Meso- and micro-scale habitat modeling, including climate change scenarios, will be conducted to evaluate habitat enhancement resulting from the meander reconnections. Besides numerical simulations, physical modeling of morphodynamics will be performed in the new hydraulic engineering laboratory, built as part of the project, allowing the performance of large-scale tests.

    The project results show that the entire section is affected by erosion. This is most likely the result of the straightening and slope increase of the river, as well as the sediment deficit caused by the upstream reservoir. Sections without bank protection exhibited less incision and more lateral dynamics such as widening and migration of the river axis. The smaller width/depth ratio in reaches with protected banks indicates that impeded bank erosion is compensated by more bed incision. The sediment budget shows an imbalance as more sediment is transported out of the section. This imbalance will persist until the river has changed sufficiently to compensate for human impacts or new measures are taken to reduce their effect. In this respect, the recent reconnections of meanders seem promising by reducing the slope and thus sediment transport capacity. Furthermore, preliminary results of the habitat modeling indicate that the depth and width variations increased and habitat availability became larger even at low flow conditions.

    How to cite: Haimann, M., Klösch, M., Holzapfel, P., Steiner, F., Merl, K., Busch, E., Krapesch, M., Tomaschitz, C., Baumann, P., and Habersack, H.: Investigation of the morphological and ecohydraulic evolution in the course of river restoration works in a transboundary section of the Thaya River, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9319, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9319, 2022.

    EGU22-9427 | Presentations | HS9.3

    Inferences from the comparison of two non-intrusive methods for estimation of bedload transport 

    Sándor Baranya, Hojun You, Marian Muste, Dongsu Kim, Tate McAlpin, and David Abraham

    Non-intrusive technologies for the in-situ measurement of river hydro-morphological features are increasingly popular in the scientific and practice communities due to their efficient and productive data acquisition. Our research team have successfully demonstrated through laboratory experiments and field measurements that, by combining acoustic mapping with image velocimetry concepts, we can characterize the planar dynamics of the bedform migration and eventually rates of bedload transport. The technique, labeled Acoustic Mapping Velocimetry (AMV), is currently transferred to field conditions using multiple-beam echo-sounders (MBES) and Acoustic-Doppler Current Profilers (ADCP) for producing acoustic maps and tracking the bedform dynamics.

    A constant preoccupation of the research team during this transfer has been the validation of the AMV in field conditions. Such validation requires the use of identical input data and the availability of a similar capability measurement system in terms of measurement output, spatial and temporal coverage for the measurement. Fortunately, there is a similar system for estimation of bedload transport labeled Integrated Section Surface Difference Over Time (ISSDOT).  The latter method has been developed and extensively tested by a research group of US Corps of Engineers. While the data inputs (acoustic maps) and the underlying principle (i.e., dune tracking) are the same as for AMV, ISSDOT is based on purely geometrical estimation of the bedload transports rates. The present paper described a comparison between AMV and ISSDOT applied to a set of repeated maps acquired in the Mississippi River. In the absence of a third measurement alternative to be used as benchmark, the paper draws inferences from the comparisons of the two instruments.

    How to cite: Baranya, S., You, H., Muste, M., Kim, D., McAlpin, T., and Abraham, D.: Inferences from the comparison of two non-intrusive methods for estimation of bedload transport, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9427, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9427, 2022.

    EGU22-10587 | Presentations | HS9.3

    Ultrasound investigation of sediment depositions in hydropower reservoir  - case study Banje, Albania 

    Ignacio Pereyra Yraola, Slaven Conevski, Massimo Guerrero, Hanne Novik, Siri Stokseth, and Nils Ruther

    The hydropower industry is facing serious challenges handling sediment hazards. In fact, the world’s total storage capacity is continuously decreasing 1-2% per year due to the sedimentation of reservoirs. The necessity to act accordingly, implies choosing the proper sediment management strategy, as early as in the design phase, and to adapt the system on the sediment and water discharge inflows during the operation of the hydropower plant (HPP). To achieve this goal, a detailed monitoring strategy must be implemented.

    Periodic bathymetric surveys are crucial for obtaining reliable information about the sediment deposition. The Banje reservoir is located in Albania, in the Devoll river valley, which is a catchment with approximately 2000 t/ (km2 year) sediment yield. The reservoir was commissioned in 2016 and until now two bathymetric studies were conducted. The measurements were performed using a single beam echosounder with dual frequency (80/200 kHz) and the RiverPro RDI, a five-beam acoustic doppler current profiler (ADCP): one vertical beam working at 600 kHz and four 1200 kHz slanted beam. In addition, 22 sediment samples were taken from the reservoir bottom with an Ekman grab sampler.

    Both the echosounder and the ADCP are ultrasound instruments; besides the registering of water depth, they also give information about the strength of the returned acoustic signal (i.e., the backscatter). It is well known that the backscatter is highly sensitive to different roughness and river or reservoir bed composition of the reflecting material. In addition to the regular depth measurement, this study aims to correlate the density and particle size distribution of the bed sediment samples to the corrected backscatter signal. Furthermore, combining the observed changes of bed position and the investigated sediment characteristics, details about the total sediment deposition are inferred. The signal intensity from both instruments was corrected by applying an updated ultrasound equation, which yield the corrected backscatter signal. The first and the second returns (i.e., echoes) to the echosounder were used as an input data, whereas the ADCP bottom track signal strength indicator (RSSI) was included in the equation. The recorded raw data was previously processed and smoothed, carefully filtering errors and outliers.

    A good correlation was obtained between the sediment samples density and the backscatter signal from the second echo. The ADCP backscatter is reasonably correlated to the particle size distribution of the bed material, but only for reflecting flat regions. The corrected first echo showed abrupt changes which are most likely produced by roughness variability of the reflecting region.

    The combining of ADCP and single beam echosounder enabled a detailed analysis of the sediment characteristics and depositions in the reservoir. However further research is necessary to efficiently discard the false data reflected from submerged vegetation, buildings and debris. In addition, frequency dependent returns may be exploited to investigate the sediment layer consolidation.

    How to cite: Pereyra Yraola, I., Conevski, S., Guerrero, M., Novik, H., Stokseth, S., and Ruther, N.: Ultrasound investigation of sediment depositions in hydropower reservoir  - case study Banje, Albania, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10587, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10587, 2022.

    EGU22-11793 | Presentations | HS9.3

    Vertical and lateral variability of suspended sediment in cross-sections at the river Rhine 

    Aron Slabon and Thomas Hoffmann

    Monitoring suspended sediment transported in fluvial systems is of major importance regarding natural hazards, water quality, and sustainable river management. However, monitoring is challenged by the spatial and temporal variability of suspended sediment transport and thus time consuming and costly. Here we analyze the spatial variability of suspended sediment in the German waterways using data from suspended monitoring networks of the German water and shipping authority (WSV). The data consists of four stations with cross-sectional measurements (isokinetic sampling with 20-25 samples/sampling campaign and 3-4 campaigns per cross-section/year) along with three stations with frequent (daily) point measurements. As the distribution of SSC with water depth is well established through the Rouse profile, uncertainties are induced through the determination of the settling velocity and the assumption of suspended sediment being transported as primary particles.

    The lateral and vertical variability are quantified through the mean standard deviation for each vertical profile and sampling depth for each sampling campaign respectively. First, we investigate general patterns (including the vertical and lateral variability) of suspended sediment concentration (SSC) in the four different cross-sections. Second, we link the lateral and vertical variability with discharge, the magnitude of SSC, and flow velocity. Third, we estimate differences between the cross-sectional sampling and single point sampling.

    Our preliminary results indicate an increase of vertical and lateral variability with average SSC in the cross-section. This involves a strong vertical gradient at high average SSC and increased variability at the bottom compared to near-surface SSC. As the flow velocity is smaller at the bottom, we detect a decrease in variability with higher flow velocity. These general patterns are present at each cross-section. However, site specific variations are abundant; caused by site specific properties, such as local morphology, lithology, and the impact of tributaries. Mean standard deviation of laterals and verticals shows the strongest connection to SSC, rather than discharge and flow velocity. Comparing cross-sectional average SSC with surface-sampling from the middle of the river ranges from strong underestimations (> 70 %) to strong overestimations (> 100 %) for single years with an average underestimation of approx. 11 % for all three stations over the 30-year sampling period used in this study. Thereby, incorporating cross-sectional measurements reduce uncertainties induced by point-sampling. Further, site specific adaptations regarding the sample location and an optimization of the sampling process utilizing simultaneous sampling could improve cross-sectional sampling.

    How to cite: Slabon, A. and Hoffmann, T.: Vertical and lateral variability of suspended sediment in cross-sections at the river Rhine, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11793, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11793, 2022.

    EGU22-1172 | Presentations | HS9.4

    Modelling short-range interaction of clay particles to improve erodibility prediction 

    wenlong chen, Robert Grabowski, and Saurav Goel

    Introduction: Erosion has become an urgent problem to society due to the increasing intensity and frequency of disturbances, e.g. storms, wave energy and rainfall. Yet, a universal model to predict erosion thresholds for cohesive sediment is still missing. Short range interaction of clays is recognized as the source of cohesion and adhesion of cohesive sediment. The interaction of negatively charged (i.e., montmorillonite (MMT) and beidellite (BD)) and neutral clay particles (i.e., kaolinite (KL)) are traditionally simulated through DLVO theory and van der Waals interaction[1]. However, the applicability of DLVO theory at short range (i.e., at distance less than 3 nm) has been increasingly challenged in molecular dynamics simulations[2]. A suitable description of short-range clay particle interaction is crucial for the prediction of cohesive sediment erodibility. The aim of this study was to determine how clay mineralogy and water chemistry influence clay particle interactions at short range to affect inter-particle attraction and stability under imposed forces.

    Methods: Molecular dynamics models of clay minerals and water were created using LAMMPS to simulate the interactions between water, clay and dissolved salt to investigate the forces determining clay cohesion, i.e. attractive force between clay particles [3]. A 2-layer model was used in this study, which is a simplification of the multi-layer particles found in nature. A multifactorial design was used with two factors: mineralogy and salinity. For clay mineralogy, kaolinite (KL), beidellite (BD) and montmorillonite (MMT) with sodium (Na) counter ions were tested. Three types of salt were considered, i.e., KCl, NaCl and CaCl2, with concentration ranging from 1% to 4%. Clay particle interactions with bulk water containing salt solution were simulated for 5 ns. Clay swell, i.e. the increase in the interlayer distance (d the distance between the mass center of two adjacent layers) and the underlying forces were quantified. The resistance of clay particles to imposed force was also investigated. 

    Results and Discussion: First, for most negatively charged MMT and BD treatments, positively charged cations act as a bridge to hold clay layers together, which contrasts with the swelling predicted by DLVO theory. Second, Na-MMT with -0.375, -0.5, and -0.625 e/unit swelled in pure water, induced by the breakdown of cation bridges rather than osmotic swell pressure. Third, low concentrations of dissolved salt (i.e. KCl, NaCl or CaCl2) inhibit the swelling of MMT, by increasing the cation bridge strength. Fourth, non-charged KL did not swell because of strong van der Waals interaction. Finally, stable clay particles were more resistant to external pull and shear forces. These novel molecular dynamics simulations are helping to uncover the mechanisms controlling clay cohesion to support new formulations to predict the erodibility of cohesive sediment. 

    Acknowledgements: The support of the UK Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) under grant EP/T001100/1. 

    References: [1] Grabowski et al. (2011) Earth Sci Rev 105:101-120; [2] Shen and Bourg (2020) J. Colloid Interface Sci. 584:610-621 [3] Chen et al. (2022) ACS omega (accepted).

    How to cite: chen, W., Grabowski, R., and Goel, S.: Modelling short-range interaction of clay particles to improve erodibility prediction, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1172, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1172, 2022.

    EGU22-1888 | Presentations | HS9.4

    Grain-resolving simulations of submerged cohesive granular collapse 

    Rui Zhu, Zhiguo He, Kunpeng Zhao, Bernhard Vowinckel, and Eckart Meiburg

    We investigate the submerged collapse of weakly polydisperse, loosely packed cohesive granular columns, as a function of aspect ratio and cohesive force strength, via grain-resolving direct numerical simulations. The cohesive forces act to prevent the detachment of individual particles from the main body of the collapsing column, reduce its front velocity, and yield a shorter and thicker final deposit. All of these effects can be accurately captured across a broad range of parameters by piecewise power-law relationships. The cohesive forces significantly reduce the amount of available potential energy released by the particles. For shallow columns, the particle and fluid kinetic energy decreases for stronger cohesion. For tall columns, on the other hand, moderate cohesive forces increase the maximum particle kinetic energy, since they accelerate the initial free-fall of the upper column section. Only for larger cohesive forces do the peak kinetic energy of the particles decrease. Computational particle tracking indicates that the cohesive forces reduce the mixing of particles within the collapsing column, and it identifies the regions of origin of those particles that travel the farthest. The simulations demonstrate that cohesion promotes aggregation and the formation of aggregates. They furthermore provide complete information on the temporally and spatially evolving network of cohesive and direct contact force bonds. While the normal contact forces are primarily aligned in the vertical direction, the cohesive bonds adjust their preferred spatial orientation throughout the collapse. They result in a net macroscopic stress that counteracts deformation and slows the spreading of the advancing particle front.

    How to cite: Zhu, R., He, Z., Zhao, K., Vowinckel, B., and Meiburg, E.: Grain-resolving simulations of submerged cohesive granular collapse, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1888, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1888, 2022.

    Erosion is an important issue in soil science and is related to many environmental problems, such as soil erosion and sediment transport. Establishing a simulation model suitable for soil erosion prediction is of great significance not only to accurately predict the process of soil separation by runoff, but also improve the physical model of soil erosion. In this study, we develop a graphic processing unit (GPU)-based numerical model that combines two-dimensional (2D) hydrodynamic and Green-Ampt (G-A) infiltration modelling to simulate soil erosion. A Godunov-type scheme on a uniform and structured square grid is then generated to solve the relevant shallow water equations (SWEs). The highlight of this study is the use of GPU-based acceleration technology to enable numerical models to simulate slope and watershed erosion in an efficient and high-resolution manner. The results show that the hydrodynamic model performs well in simulating soil erosion process. Soil erosion is studied by conducting calculation verification at the slope and basin scales. The first case involves simulating soil erosion process of a slope surface under indoor artificial rainfall conditions from 0 to 1000 s, and there is a good agreement between the simulated values and the measured values for the runoff velocity. The second case is a river basin experiment (Coquet River Basin) that involves watershed erosion. Simulations of the erosion depth change and erosion cumulative amount of the basin during a period of 1–40 h show an elevation difference of erosion at 0.5–3.0 m, especially during the period of 20–30 h. Nine cross sections in the basin are selected for simulation and the results reveal that the depth of erosion change value ranges from –0.86 to –2.79 m and the depth of deposition change value varies from 0.38 to 1.02 m. The findings indicate that the developed GPU-based hydrogeomorphological model can reproduce soil erosion processes. These results are valuable for rainfall runoff and soil erosion predictions on rilled hillslopes and river basins.

    How to cite: yongde, K.: Two-dimensional hydrodynamic robust numerical model of soil erosion based on slopes and river basins, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2382, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2382, 2022.

    EGU22-3306 | Presentations | HS9.4 | Highlight

    Distribution and Sedimentation of Microplastics in Taihu Lake 

    qiji zhang and xin qian

    Microplastics have been reported in environmental media for decades, but gaps in our knowledge about them still remain. We investigated the third biggest freshwater lake in China – Taihu Lake – and the 30 major rivers around it. Microplastics were detected in lake water and sediment, and in river water, at abundances varying from 1.7 to 8.5 items/L, 460 to 1380 items/kg and 1.8 to 18.2 items/L, respectively. Inflow rivers were more polluted with microplastics than outflow rivers. The most common shape was fragment. Microplastic sizes of < 100 μm dominated in inflow rivers, 100–200 μm dominated in lake water and outflow rivers. The average size of microplastics in outflow rivers (200.4 μm) was larger than that in inflow rivers (166.2 μm). Microplastics of < 100 μm only accounted for 28% in the lake surface water but were as high as 70% in the sediment, indicating that smaller microplastics may more easily settle in the lake. The main components of the microplastics were identified as being polyvinyl chloride and polyethylene. There were about 1.2× 106 items/s microplastics entered Taihu Lake. Four main rivers located at northwestern lake accounted for 79% of the total inflow microplastic fluxes.

    How to cite: zhang, Q. and qian, X.: Distribution and Sedimentation of Microplastics in Taihu Lake, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3306, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3306, 2022.

    EGU22-4742 | Presentations | HS9.4

    Use of nature-based solutions for the enhancement of river habitats – transfer of practical experience to scientifically optimized solutions 

    Andreas C. T. Müller, Christin Kannen, Frank Seidel, and Mário J. Franca

    The European Water Framework Directive aims to achieve a good ecological status for all European rivers by 2027. Since the majority of rivers in Germany are in a highly altered state, large-scale restoration projects have been promoted by the federal and state governments. To plan and implement river restoration implies the integration of different interests and constraints such as flood protection, water supply, recreational use and ecology. In particular in urban environments, or otherwise spatially restricted conditions, there are serious problems to reach the ecological objectives which are set by authorities. Thus, the planning engineer is confronted with additional difficulties, especially from human-made contiguous infrastructures. Consequently, it is not possible to develop watercourses through their own dynamics. In these cases, purposefully selected instream structures can be used as alternative means to achieve morphodynamic development and improve the ecological conditions in the existing riverbed.

    Until now, many restoration measures by means of instream structures have been implemented empirically according to the experiences by river engineers and technical staff. As a consequence, the guidelines for instream structures provide suitable hydraulic conditions and focus on the technical implementation rather than indicating which type of river habitat can be restored by the selected instream structure. The used measures often showed morphodynamic changes. However, in many cases habitat quality shows only negligible improvement compared to the initial conditions. This demonstrates a lack of scientifically derived solutions that can specifically induce morphodynamic changes and thus create fish and macroinvertebrates habitats in a targeted manner.

    At KIT we investigate artificial measures to create functional habitats in pre-alpine to lowland rivers. The investigation is made in close collaboration with governmental bodies who locally specify the ecological objectives guided by the EU Water Framework Directive. An analysis of ecological needs determines the lack of several habitat types in the examined river systems. Together with the state authorities, several types of hydraulic structures such as groynes and other instream structures are then evaluated regarding their ability of habitat replacement.

    The selected designs are examined according to state-of-the-art methods of hybrid hydraulic modelling, including mobile bed experiments, complementary numerical simulations and monitoring field campaigns. Based on the hydraulic findings the habitat suitability for all relevant flow conditions is derived through aquatic habitat simulation. The promising variants are then optimized and evaluated in terms of their ecological impact as well as hydraulic requirements, e.g. flood and bank protection for all morphologically relevant discharges.

    The current research shows that nature-based solutions, inspired by practical empiricism and improved scientifically, can be used for developing instream structures that generate purposefully ecologically favourable conditions in rivers. In our presentation we will discuss that with optimization through scientific methods we expect to improve the planning reliability and ecological benefits of the use of instream structures for the enhancement of river habitats.

    How to cite: Müller, A. C. T., Kannen, C., Seidel, F., and Franca, M. J.: Use of nature-based solutions for the enhancement of river habitats – transfer of practical experience to scientifically optimized solutions, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4742, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4742, 2022.

    EGU22-6773 | Presentations | HS9.4 | Highlight

    Morphodynamics of Lowland River Networks Modeled as Simple Binary Trees 

    Gary Parker and Li Zhang

    River networks are ubiquitous in nature. The example of the Amazon River, South America, is shown below.

    Typically, channel branches farther upstream tend to be steeper than branches farther downstream. Here we explain this tendency via a simple model of lowland sand-bed stream networks. Any given downstream branch bifurcates into two branches upstream, here each assumed to have discharges equal to half of the downstream branch. . Each branch satisfies (at bankfull flow) a relation each for flow resistance, sand transport and sediment mobility Shields number. We show that if the transport rate of sand increases downstream in proportion to the water discharge, the river slope must be the same everywhere, so that the long profile following any path shows no upward concavity. When the sand load increases downstream at a lower rate than the water discharge, on the other hand, upward concavity is manifested. The bifurcations are allowed to continue upstream until a specified drainage density is reached. The inverse of drainage density scales the distance from any channel to the nearest ridge; at an appropriately low value, it is assumed that sediment can be delivered to the nearest stream solely through overland processes. We use the above conditions to determine the extent of the spatial network, and also the spatial variation of network denudation rate.

     

    How to cite: Parker, G. and Zhang, L.: Morphodynamics of Lowland River Networks Modeled as Simple Binary Trees, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6773, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6773, 2022.

    EGU22-7976 | Presentations | HS9.4

    A model for continental-scale water erosion and sediment transport and its application to the Yellow River Basin 

    Cong Jiang, Eric J. R. Parteli, and Yaping Shao

    A large-scale water erosion and sediment transport model is introduced and applied to predict continental-scale hydrological transport processes at the Yellow River Basin in China. Our model couples the Atmospheric and Hydrological Modelling System (AHMS) with the CASCade 2 Dimensional SEDiment (CASC2D-SED), by considering a scale-adaptive water erosion parameterization and eight possible flow directions of the channel routing model. Here, the AHMS-SED is applied to simulate the water erosion processes in the Yellow River Basin over 10 years with a spatial resolution of 20 km. The simulated daily sediment fluxes from four major hydrological stations along the Yellow River (namely, Tangnaihe, Lanzhou, Toudaoguai and Huayuankou) are compared with corresponding observations. There is a quantitative agreement between these observations and modelling results at all stations. Our results demonstrate the good performance of the new scale-adaptive parameterization and the integrated AHMS-SED, paving the way for the studies of water erosion and sediment transport at large scales. We also show how of our numerical simulations can be used to predict the evolution of sediment transport in the Yellow River Basin under consideration of specific climate change scenarios.

    How to cite: Jiang, C., J. R. Parteli, E., and Shao, Y.: A model for continental-scale water erosion and sediment transport and its application to the Yellow River Basin, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7976, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7976, 2022.

    EGU22-8118 | Presentations | HS9.4

    Study of unregulated flow conditions in Norwegian rivers- Strategy for improving lake outflow using HYPE model 

    Carolina Isabel Saldana Espinoza, Lennart Schönfelder, and Jochen Seidel

    Norway's authorities are delayed in implementing the European Water Framework Directive (EU-WFD). A common challenge for the implementation of EU-WFD is finding natural reference conditions in water bodies, which can be challenging for lakes that have been regulated and used for hydropower production before any physical variables were made. Hydrological modelling of unregulated lakes can be a solution.  Modelling water level fluctuations in unregulated lakes allow us to determine the ecological functioning of the lake and the water storage that could be used for different sectors such as hydropower, agriculture and others.

    Previous studies showed that lakes had a strong influence on the performance of models when using the Hydrological Predictions for the Environment (HYPE) model. This study aims to develop model strategies for improving lake dynamic modelling with natural flow conditions in terms of discharge and water stage in HYPE. We modelled seven lakes in Norway with areas more than 5 km2 and a gauging station at the output. Each lake was calibrated independently, and each model was set up from an existing one for the mainland of Norway. Stepwise calibration was implemented to create separate discharge and water stage models. Rating curves for lakes were calculated and introduced to the model for water discharge and stage calibration following the equation Q=k(w-wo)p. Where w is the observed water level, wo is the reference water level, k is the rate, and p is the exponent. The model performance was evaluated in terms of Kling–Gupta efficiency (KGE). Preliminary results showed improvement of model performance for water stage modelling when employing a pre-calibrated model with discharge time series data. Also, improved model performance in discharge was found when using rating curves for calibration

    How to cite: Saldana Espinoza, C. I., Schönfelder, L., and Seidel, J.: Study of unregulated flow conditions in Norwegian rivers- Strategy for improving lake outflow using HYPE model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8118, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8118, 2022.

    EGU22-12058 | Presentations | HS9.4

    Numerical investigation of scale influences on hydrodynamics and morphodynamics in a groyne field experiment 

    Martin Glas, Michael Tritthart, Christine Sindelar, Sebastian Pessenlehner, Matthias Buchinger, Petr Lichtneger, and Helmut Habersack

    Large physical experiments require - among others - scaling of channel geometry and sediments in order to fit to the available laboratory infrastructure. In this study, scaling effects were investigated with the help of a 3D numerical model (RSim-3D) and a coupled sediment transport model (iSed). Numerical experiments were based on the geometries of two physical scale experiments conducted at the University of Natural Resources and Life Sciences, Vienna, Austria. The large-scale experiments (1:1) were conducted in an open-air research channel with a channel width of 5 m. The small-scale experiments (1:5) were performed inside the Hydraulic Engineering Laboratory with a flume width of 1 m. The large-scale experiments (1:1) include sediments typical for the Austrian Danube River in the section East of Vienna and the small-scale experiments were conducted with a sediment size scaled by 1:5. Results from the physical scale experiments including a submerged and attracting groyne layout with varying groyne heights and water levels were used for calibration and validation of the numerical models. Numerical model results were analyzed with respect to scale influences. In contrast to the relatively small influence of scale on the determined normalized flow velocities, normalized turbulent kinetic energy was found to increase by up to 10 times within the outdoor research channel (1:1) in comparison to the smaller scale (1:5). Moreover, the scale effect was larger in the main stream than in the groyne field. Morphodynamic equilibrium was affected by the scale of the experiment, too, leading to enhanced erosions in the 1:1 scale experiment. The findings are relevant for future hydraulic engineering measures investigated by physical scale experiments and will help to avoid underestimations of hydrodynamic and morphodynamic processes induced by scale influences.

    How to cite: Glas, M., Tritthart, M., Sindelar, C., Pessenlehner, S., Buchinger, M., Lichtneger, P., and Habersack, H.: Numerical investigation of scale influences on hydrodynamics and morphodynamics in a groyne field experiment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12058, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12058, 2022.

    EGU22-12845 | Presentations | HS9.4

    Hydrogeomorphic floodplain mapping across different morphometric and climate settings 

    Antonio Annis, Ryan Morrison, and Fernando Nardi

    Among the DTM-based parsimonious floodplain delineation methods, hydrogeomorphic scaling laws, providing consistent flood flow depth estimations as a function of contributing drainage areas, are widely used. Recent advances in this field demonstrated the suitability of hydrogeomorphic floodplain delineation models from basin to continental scale across diverse climatic and morphological settings. However, the sensitivity of scaling law parameterizations and performance in semi-arid to humid and low-gradient to steep basins is still unknown. In this work we determined flow depths – contributing areas scaling law parameters with varying basin slope and average annual rainfall across eleven basins in the west-central United States. These variable scaling law parameters were used to test the performance of the GFPLAIN hydrogeomorphic floodplain delineation model in the study area adopting largely and freely available global climate and topographic datasets. Outcomes of this analysis show improved performances and effectiveness of the GFPLAIN model with varying morphometric and climatic factors suggesting room for improvement for the current continental and global hydrogeomorphic floodplain datasets.

    How to cite: Annis, A., Morrison, R., and Nardi, F.: Hydrogeomorphic floodplain mapping across different morphometric and climate settings, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12845, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12845, 2022.

    HS10 – Ecohydrology, wetlands and estuaries: aquatic and terrestrial processes and interlinkages

    EGU22-1897 | Presentations | HS10.1

    How water and carbon ecosystem services vary over land covers and extreme weather events across Germany? 

    Karim Pyarali, Lulu Zhang, Ning Liu, Ge Sun, and Abdulhakeem Al-Qubati

    To ensure sustainable development it is vital to account the stocks and flows of ecosystem services, understand the status quo of these resources and project how resilient or vulnerable they are to future climate and land cover change. In this study, we applied the U.S. Forest Service eco-hydrological model, Water Supply Stress Index (WaSSI), to estimate the monthly spatial dynamics of green & blue water resources and evaluate the ecosystem services (water supply and carbon sequestration) across sixteen German states by land covers and during extreme drought events. The simulated discharge (Q), evapotranspiration (ET) and Gross Primary Productivity (GPP) from upstream watersheds were validated against measurements from gauging stations, eddy covariance (EC) data, and remotely sensed ET and GPP estimates. Our results showed that eleven out of twelve watersheds modeled Q bias and determination coefficient (R2) are within ± 25% and above 0.60, respectively. Similarly, when we compared ET against EC data, ten out of eleven watersheds had R2 above 0.60 and seven out of eleven watersheds have Kling-Gupta efficiency above 0.6. The R2 between simulated and Moderate Resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer (MODIS) ET was around 0.48 with a gradient of 0.63. The model bias between simulated ET and precipitation minus observed discharge (P-Q observed) values for all the validated watersheds was within ± 25%. Likewise, modeled GPP was higher than MODIS GPP by 16% and a lower R2 (0.37). A comparison to Copernicus GPP (CGLS-GPP) gave a much better R2 (0.70) with an overestimation of 7%. Moreover, a land cover specific comparison between simulated GPP and EC observed GPP showed nine out of fourteen watersheds had a model bias within ± 25% and Nash-Sutcliffe efficiency above 0.4, while twelve watersheds had R2 above 0.60. Overall, the validation results demonstrate that WaSSI can capture seasonal hydrological and carbon cycles reasonably well. It is estimated that the mean annual ET across Germany is 530 ± 49.5 mm yr-1, the mean annual water yield is 259 ± 173.5 mm yr-1, and the mean annual Net Ecosystem Productivity (NEP) is 308.3 ± 78.2 g C m-2 yr-1. The annual water yield and carbon sequestration at the German national scale was around 84.86 billion m3 yr-1 and 106.03 Tg C yr-1, respectively. We found that Mecklenburg-Vorpommern (-1.91 Tg C/yr) and Thüringen (-0.57 Tg C/yr) were the only two states where anthropogenic CO2 emissions were less than NEP. Across Germany, cropland and deciduous broadleaf forest are the largest share of water supply and carbon sequestration, respectively.  We found the severe drought events of 2003 and 2018 in Germany caused significant decrease in Q (29.6% & 26.8%), GPP (8.8% & 11.7%), and NEP (18.5% & 24.7%) due to decrease in P (22.7% & 25.5%) and ET (8.7% & 11.7%). In the next step, the potential impacts of different adaptive land cover and climate change scenarios on ecosystem services will be studied.

    How to cite: Pyarali, K., Zhang, L., Liu, N., Sun, G., and Al-Qubati, A.: How water and carbon ecosystem services vary over land covers and extreme weather events across Germany?, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1897, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1897, 2022.

    EGU22-2243 | Presentations | HS10.1

    Modeling the response of plant gas exchanges to different light and PAR curves spectra 

    Matteo Camporese and Majdi Abou Najm

    Understanding how plants react to different light treatments is of increasing importance to assess the potential of modern agricultural technologies such as agrivoltaics and hydroponics, which are considered as promising methods to optimize crop productivity and water use without the need to increase land consumption. Here, we extend a well-established model of plant photosynthesis and transpiration to explicitly take into account the spectra of incident light and photosynthetically action radiation (PAR) curves (i.e., absorptance and quantum yield). The proposed model reasonably reproduces the response of various C3 plant types treated with different light spectra in controlled laboratory conditions. A sensitivity analysis to the most important abiotic forcing variables (irradiance, air temperature, humidity and CO2 concentration) suggests that the blue part of the light spectrum is the less efficient in terms of carbon assimilation and water use and could be effectively filtered out to produce solar energy. However, the plant response to different light treatments seems to be species-specific; therefore, accurate and updated PAR curves are needed to assess which crops are more suited to be grown in controlled agricultural systems.

    How to cite: Camporese, M. and Abou Najm, M.: Modeling the response of plant gas exchanges to different light and PAR curves spectra, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2243, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2243, 2022.

    EGU22-2943 | Presentations | HS10.1

    Sitting in the dark- The impact of shading on evapotranspiration in complex urban landscapes 

    Laura Tams, Eva Nora Paton, and Björn Kluge

    Evapotranspiration (ET) is a key parameter in the water exchange of atmosphere, plant and soil and was studied on many different scales. In urban environments, the estimation of evaporation is particularly difficult, as it is effected by complex patterns of shading, which varies on a very small scale as a function of street canyon layout and orientation. Moreover, shading varies not only in space but also in time due to the seasonal orientation and altitude of the sun. Therefore, for a correct ET assessment, the diurnal variations as well as the annual variations of shading must be taken into account. For this purpose, radiation is divided into direct and diffuse radiation; in case of complete shading only the diffuse radiation was used for ET estimation, reducing the direct radiation to zero. The diffuse radiation is further influenced by the amount of visible sky in a street canyon as a function of street widths, which can be derived using the sky view factor.
    To reduce the uncertainty of ET estimation in the built environment, a process-based model was developed with an hourly resolution that takes into account the particularly heterogeneous spatial variability of urban surfaces. To assess the impact of shading on ET, six different shadow scenarios as well as two typical urban soil sealing scenarios for a wide and a narrow street canyon were analysed regarding differences and similarities of radiation and resulting actual and potential ET of a street tree as well as soil water dynamics.
    The model scenarios showed that ET is highly influenced by shading. Furthermore, shadow scenarios affect actual ET (ETA) differently during the vegetation period: whereas in April the ETA is higher for fully exposed sites, this changes by June when less exposed sites periodically have higher ETA rates. This difference is directly connected to alteration of soil moisture dynamics, for a fully sun exposed site a soil moisture of 10 Vol% is already reached by June. For a shaded site the decrease to 10 Vol% takes two months longer.

    In conclusion, the results highlight that it is essential to include the effects of shading in the quantification of vertical water fluxes in urban environments. Moreover, this new model approach will help to identify water shortage periods and critical locations for street trees.

    How to cite: Tams, L., Paton, E. N., and Kluge, B.: Sitting in the dark- The impact of shading on evapotranspiration in complex urban landscapes, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2943, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2943, 2022.

    EGU22-3400 | Presentations | HS10.1

    Rainfall partitioning respond for a wet and dry year conditions 

    Katarina Zabret and Mojca Šraj

    The climate change strongly influences the hydrological cycle mainly due to redistribution of precipitation and changes in its seasonal patterns, resulting in longer dry periods and more intense heavy rainfall events. As precipitation is the main input for rainfall interception, throughfall and stemflow, we can expect the climate change to influence also these processes. In our study plot in Ljubljana, Slovenia, covering a small urban park with two separate groups of trees (Pinus nigra Arnold and Betula pendula Roth.), we have been performing throughfall, stemflow and rainfall measurements since January 2014. In that period, we have captured various rainfall events and the measurements are available for different periods. Among them we have also covered an especially wet (2014) and a dry (2015) year. According to the long term yearly rainfall amount, equal to 1355 mm, the total rainfall amount delivered during the year 2014 was much higher (1841 mm) and in the year 2015 considerably lower (1106 mm), which characterize those years as a wet and a dry one. For each year we have analysed the influence of meteorological conditions (e.g. rainfall amount, duration, intensity, air temperature, vapour pressure deficit, size and velocity of raindrops) on rainfall interception, throughfall and stemflow under each tree species using the boosted regression trees and random forest approach. Similar influences of the variables were recognized by both models. Comparison of the obtained results with previous analysis (e.g. Zabret et al., 2018, doi: 10.1016/j.jhydrol.2018.01.025; Zabret and Šraj, 2021, doi: 10.3389/ffgc.2021.663100) showed that the indicated influential variables for wet and dry year are to some extent similar to the variables, indicated as influential in leafless and leafed period. For example, the rainfall duration was recognized as one of the most influencing variables on rainfall interception during the wet year 2014, which was previously observed also for the leafless period. Additionally, rainfall intensity had significant influence on rainfall partitioning by birch tree during the dryer year 2015 as well as in the leafed period.

    How to cite: Zabret, K. and Šraj, M.: Rainfall partitioning respond for a wet and dry year conditions, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3400, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3400, 2022.

    EGU22-3585 | Presentations | HS10.1

    Water isotopes in estuarine lagoons at the German Baltic Sea coast 

    Bernhard Aichner, Timo Rittweg, Rhena Schumann, Sven Dahlke, Svend Duggen, and David Dubbert

    River estuaries are characterized by mixing processes between freshwater inflows and marine water masses, with lower/higher isotope values, respectively. Therefore, they often show linear correlation between salinity and water isotopes (δ18O and δ2H values). In this study, we evaluated spatial and seasonal isotope dynamics along three estuarine lagoon transects at the German Baltic Sea coast: a) the Schlei; b) the Darß-Zingst Bodden Chain; c) an eastern transect (Stettiner Haff - Peene Stream - Greifswalder Bodden - Rügener Boddens). The data show strong seasonality of isotope values even at locations located furthest from the river mouths. They further reveal a positive and linear salinity-isotope correlation in spring 2020, but hyperbolic and partially even reverse correlation in summers 2019 and 2020. We conclude that additional physical processes, such as evaporation from the shallow lagoons, overprint the two-phase mixing correlation during summers. Understanding of those water isotope dynamics is crucial in context of ecological studies, for example when interpreting oxygen and hydrogen isotope values in aquatic organisms that depend on ambient estuarine water.

    How to cite: Aichner, B., Rittweg, T., Schumann, R., Dahlke, S., Duggen, S., and Dubbert, D.: Water isotopes in estuarine lagoons at the German Baltic Sea coast, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3585, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3585, 2022.

    The partitioning of bulk precipitation (PR) in forest ecosystems and its chemical composition depends on both meteorological factors, such as precipitation amount and intensity, evaporation rate, and wind speed, and stand structural factors, such as stand density, canopy structure, bark texture, and spatiotemporal distribution and density of foliage. We analysed fluxes of water and element contained therein of a mature European beech (Fagus sylvatica L.) forest stand on sandy soils in northeastern Germany. We applied a radially symmetrical setup within a stem distance gradient to measure stand precipitation (SP) with its components of throughfall (TF) and stemflow (SF), as well as to measure soil moisture, the chemical composition of the soil solution, the soil chemistry, and the fine root distribution. The chemical analysis of the constituents covered the macroelements (Ca, Mg, K, Na, Al, Fe, Mn, Si, S, P), the cations and anions NH4+, NO3-, Cl-, SO42-, and a few heavy metals (Cu, Pb, Zn). With an average PR of 620 mm a-1, the partitioning resulted in 79% TF, 6% SF, and 15% canopy evaporation. TF volume increased with distance to stem during summer, but decreased during winter. Clear spatial gradients with increasing concentrations from PR, to different classes of TF as the distance from the trunk decreased, to SF were observed for nearly all elements. The contact of precipitation with leaves and the canopy structures alters the chemical composition of TF and SF by transferring elements from dry deposition or leaching of intracellular materials from the canopy and leads to the input of larger amounts of macroelements and heavy metals with the SP into the soil. Spatial patterns of canopy structures thus affect the spatial variation of TF and its constituents, which also affects the spatial distribution of roots and, at least in phases, the chemical composition of the topsoil solution.

    How to cite: Jochheim, H., Lüttschwager, D., and Riek, W.: Stem distance as an explanatory variable for the spatial distribution and chemical conditions of stand precipitation and soil solution under beech (Fagus sylvatica L.) trees, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3780, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3780, 2022.

    It is well known that vegetation shows the apparent spatial distribution characteristics in mountainous terrain at fine scales (tens of meters to kilometers). The micrometeorological data, like radiation and temperature, are intensely governed by local topography. The relationship between terrain and the distribution of vegetation, water, energy, and carbon fluxes at fine scales in terrestrial ecosystems is still unclear. This study aims at analyzing the eco-hydrological process at tens of meters scales in a typical humid hilly area, with varying altitudes, slopes, aspects, and soil textures causing the corresponding uneven micrometeorological conditions. We use the radiation and temperature data corrected by the micro-topography data to drive the eco-hydrological model (Ecosystem demography model version 2). Results showed that different regions have different micrometeorological conditions, the distribution of vegetation, water, energy, and carbon fluxes. Furthermore, the topographic heterogeneity, giving rise to the uneven soil texture and micrometeorological conditions, directly or indirectly affects the distribution of vegetation, water, energy, and carbon fluxes. The findings will improve our understanding of the eco-hydrological processes.

    How to cite: Li, Y., Zhang, K., and Bardossy, A.: Study on the coupled eco-hydrological processes impacted by fine-scale landscape heterogeneity in a typical humid hilly area, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3856, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3856, 2022.

    EGU22-4009 | Presentations | HS10.1

    Combining field survey and time series data to learn about plant water usage in a South African agroforestry system 

    Svenja Hoffmeister, Sibylle K. Hassler, Florian Kestel, Rebekka Maier, and Erwin Zehe

    Agroforestry systems (AFSs) are associated with many benefits such as augmented soil fertility or enhanced biodiversity. However, in water-limited areas the competition over water resources between trees and crops can reduce the productivity of the crop component. We want to share some of our results gained from in-depth analyses of time series (October 2019 to March 2020) and campaign (September 2019) data of soil moisture and matric potential in a South African AFS.

    Soil water content was measured in a soil profile at two locations within an AFS plot: alongside a windbreak consisting of Italian Alders (Alnus cordata) and amongst the crop i.e. within blackberry rows. Matric potential time series are only available at the windbreak soil profile. Surficial soil samples taken along transects perpendicular to the windbreak were analysed for physical properties (e.g. texture, water retention curve).

    Based on extracted water retention curves and matric potential time series, we found no evidence for plant water limitation during the measurement period (summer months) within the field site. Estimated root water uptake indicated that the trees take water from a greater range of depths, including deeper layers, than the blackberry plants. We observed divergent hydrological behaviour of the soil at the two locations during precipitation events, potentially resulting from dissimilar storage capacities and runoff formation potentials. Furthermore, the matric potential revealed hydrological information on plant water usage that was not as obvious from the soil moisture data.

    How to cite: Hoffmeister, S., Hassler, S. K., Kestel, F., Maier, R., and Zehe, E.: Combining field survey and time series data to learn about plant water usage in a South African agroforestry system, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4009, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4009, 2022.

    EGU22-4406 | Presentations | HS10.1

    Effects of tillage systems on soil water distribution, crop development, and transpiration of soybean. 

    Gunther Liebhard, Andreas Klik, Reinhard W. Neugschwandtner, and Reinhard Nolz

    Tillage practices are known to affect soil water retention, plant available water and, consequently, crop production. Therefore, adjusted and sustainable tillage practices may contribute to an efficient use of limited available water resources. Impacts of tillage can be determined by assessing soil hydraulic properties and crop characteristics. In this study, three tillage practices were investigated with respect to soil water distribution and crop development, with a specific focus on determining actual evapotranspiration (ET) and crop transpiration (T). T/ET ratios should give additional information on soil water availability and crop water use. The practices included conventional tillage, reduced tillage (no plow), and no-tillage and were investigated on a long-term rainfed field experiment with soybean (glycine max l. merr) planting. The long-term experimental field is located in Raasdorf in the agricultural region Marchfeld east of Vienna, Austria (48°14’ N, 16°35’ E; 156 m elevation a.s.l., average annual precipitation of approx. 497 mm). The field is separated in experimental plots of 960 or 1,440 m2. The measurements comprised automated monitoring of weather and soil water by means of a telemetric sensor network as well as manual monitoring of crop development. ET and its components were determined using an isotope-based water balance technique. ET rates were determined at the conventional experimental plot based on a water balance and verified with scintillometer measurements on a nearby field of 11.5 ha. In the researched vegetation period with limited water availability, the conservative tillage practices showed better water storage, water use, and crop yields compared to the conventional practice. The weekly T/ET ratios progressed according to the canopy development, which was affected by the tillage-induced soil conditions. In this context, delayed plant development – specifically at the no-till plots – led to extended green cover and productive water use during the late season, where a large part of the precipitation has fallen. The tillage-induced difference of wetness at soil surface, however, did not have a substantial effect on T/ET; even soil evaporation was similar at all plots. Furthermore, the ratios showed the beneficial effect of mulch protection regarding unproductive losses by evaporation, in particular during the initial periods of crop emergence and development. Thus, the assessment of T/ET ratios improved the insights in impacts of management practices and showed potential to promote the efficient use of the available water resources.

    How to cite: Liebhard, G., Klik, A., Neugschwandtner, R. W., and Nolz, R.: Effects of tillage systems on soil water distribution, crop development, and transpiration of soybean., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4406, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4406, 2022.

    EGU22-4616 | Presentations | HS10.1

    Using hydrochory for agricultural landscape revegetation 

    Martin Faucher and Jean-Stéphane Bailly

    Maintaining biodiversity of spontaneous species in agricultural landscapes is a major challenge regarding the bundle of ecosystem services provided by them, such as preservation of water and soil resources. It is possible to increase landscape’s resilience to climate change through their renaturalization with agroecological measures, especially maintenance practices of vegetation cover in agroecological infrastructures. 

    In the Mediterranean environment, those infrastructures such as ditches, plot borders or even inter-rows of perennial crops concentrate both biodiversity and flow of matter (water, pollutants, particles), making these landscape elements particularly susceptible to intense rainfall events that contribute to exchange of biodiversity across landscapes. Managing vegetation of these elements is a significant lever for biodiversity maintenance considering impacts of plants on flows of matters, such as water and seeds. Promoting exchanges requires knowledge of the relative importance of the main types of plant dispersal i.e. hydrochory, anemochory and zoochory that affects seed exchange between landscape elements, by making the hypothesis that the hydrochoric dispersion, i.e. by water, is particularly important in the Mediterranean environment. 

    To establish the potential of hydrochory to rehabilitate Mediterranean vineyard environments, we proposed a conceptual model of seed exchanges at landscape scale incorporating the levers available to stakeholders (vegetation maintenance in inter-rows, drainage ditches and plot borders), as well as climatic variables and the specific characteristics of each seed present. We will present the first results of seed dispersal experiments after a rainy event on a vineyard plot, as well as manipulations to determine the seed bank, allow us to make a first estimate of seed transport and the rehabilitation potential of Mediterranean vineyard environments. At the end of the experiments, the knowledge obtained will be integrated into a spatially explicit model based on the source-sink principle to simulate the dispersion of seeds by water, this model being considered as a virtual laboratory to co-construct landscape arrangements with stakeholders for maintaining biodiversity.

    How to cite: Faucher, M. and Bailly, J.-S.: Using hydrochory for agricultural landscape revegetation, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4616, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4616, 2022.

    EGU22-5630 | Presentations | HS10.1

    Wood water content influences sap flux estimations under water limited conditions in a deciduous forest in Michigan 

    Ana Maria Restrepo Acevedo, Elizabeth Agee, and Ashley Matheny

    Sap flux measurements are the most common individual-scale measurements and are used as a proxy for transpiration through the conservation of mass. While multiple heat-tracer style sensor types exist, the most broadly used are Granier-style thermal dissipation probes (TDP). Beginning in 2014, work at University of Michigan Biological Station pioneered continuously monitoring wood water content using capacitance sensors in mature trees. This unique data set has been used to demonstrate the key role of stem-stored water, or the trees’ capacitance, to buffer transpiration against water stress. Furthermore, increasing evidence has shown diurnal variations in the hydraulic capacitance of stems as a result of changes in water stress under laboratory conditions. These variations may induce inaccuracy in the nocturnal maximum temperature (Tmax) baseline of TDP and cause underestimation of sap flux measurements. Therefore, it is critical to study the dynamics between wood water content and sap flux measurements under natural conditions to establish the likely impact of these variations and their influence on estimations of transpiration.

    We pair continuous time-series measurements of wood water content with raw sap flux observations made using traditional thermal dissipation probes in a mixed forest in northern lower Michigan. We demonstrate that decreases in wood water content result in increases in the Tmax signal of the thermal dissipation probe under water stressed conditions. This behavior is in accordance to the theory of heat conductance and the specific heat capacity of solids with respect to changes in water content. Our results suggest that the diurnal dynamics of wood water content may be an important source of error in sap flux data during drought and other water limited conditions, and should potentially be considered for use as a correction factor when using thermal based sap flux measurement techniques.

    How to cite: Restrepo Acevedo, A. M., Agee, E., and Matheny, A.: Wood water content influences sap flux estimations under water limited conditions in a deciduous forest in Michigan, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5630, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5630, 2022.

    In the context of climate warming, frequent outbreaks of flash droughts are causing serious damage to ecosystems, so there is an urgent need to understand the water stress on ecosystems during flash droughts. High vapor pressure deficit (VPD) and low soil moisture (SM) are regarded as atmospheric and soil water stress on the ecosystem, but their stress mechanisms are different. Their independent influences are difficult to separate during flash droughts that develop fast with a strong land-atmospheric coupling. Therefore, to understand the response mechanism of vegetation gross primary productivity (GPP) to flash droughts, this study uses statistical analysis to decouple the effects of atmospheric and terrestrial water stress on GPP at the site scale and regional scale, respectively. At the site scale, we use the FLUXNET2015 Dataset to decouple the stress of SM and VPD on the GPP during flash droughts, and find that low SM dominants water stress for 55% of the stations, and high VPD dominants water stress for 10%. We further investigate the differences of GPP response to moisture deficit for different ecosystems during different stages of flash droughts. The results show that non-forest ecosystems respond to water stress during the onset stage of flash droughts, while more forests respond during the drought recovery stage. Specifically, for the days that are accompanied by high temperature and intense solar radiation during flash droughts , the water stress dominated by high VPD increase to 41% of the stations. For the regional scale, we use remote sensing data to decouple the effects of water stress over China. Our results show that water stress during flash droughts is dominated by soil moisture deficit over most regions of China, but VPD stress is stronger over northern China than that over southern China.

    How to cite: Xi, X. and Yuan, X.: Decoupling terrestrial and atmospheric water stress on ecosystem productivity during flash droughts, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6738, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6738, 2022.

    Climate change is posing a threat on agricultural systems, mostly because it modifies the water ressources and dynamics: erosion, floods, drought… Adaptation is therefore becoming a vital issue (Darnhofer et al., 2010). These stakes are particularly high in the Rhine Valley, for agricultural systems are both importantly exposed and vulnerable, due to a significant change in the distribution and intensity of precipitations over the seasons (Riach et al., 2019), and their strong dependancy on a limited number of products (irrigated maize for the intensive crop production and drought sensitive grape varieties like Riesling for wine growing).In order to adapt to climate change, different practices are implemented: reduced soil tillage, soil cover, agroforestry, irrigation, new varieties etc., aiming at fighting against erosion, floods, fungi and/or retaining humidity, and thus modifying the water fluxes in the agroecosystems. In this quite homogeneous geographical area shared between France, Germany and Switzerland, facing the same climatical threats, the adaptation process nevertheless results in a very heterogeneous system, independent of borders. Actually, the choices to implement these practices depend on many factors: farmers’ observations and trials, perceptions of the impacts of climate change, awareness of environmental issues, economical and technical constraints, geolegal frames, and networks, including information exchanges between farmers, communication from agricultural organizations or associations and consumers’ demands. All farmers doesn't have the same goals and are neither equal in the face of the consequences of climate change, nor have the same opportunities to adapt. Moreover, these choices sometimes highlight contradictory objectives and debates, such as in the case of irrigation and glyphosate, and some adaptation measures can have paradoxical consequences on the hydrosystems. In fact, climatic change might lead to increase the gap between two agricultural models, two ways to face to environmental stakes.For this contribution, we based on semi-structured interviews with farmers (crops and wine growing), and we propose to analyze their choices. What adaptation practices do they adopt or not? Why? With which objectives and which consequences on hydrosystems? With wich difficulties and facilitating factors?

    How to cite: Bohnert, G. and Martin, B.: In the context of climate change, how do farmers change their practices or not, why, and with what consequences on water fluxes? Insights from the Rhine Valley (France, Germany, Switzerland), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8207, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8207, 2022.

    EGU22-8691 | Presentations | HS10.1

    Spatially heterogeneous grassland wetting patterns are controlled by canopy processes and antecedent soil moisture 

    Gökben Demir, Beate Michalzik, Janett Filipzik, Johanna Metzger, and Anke Hildebrandt

    Vegetation induces spatial heterogeneity in water entering the soil as it partitions precipitation into net precipitation components. Net precipitation patterns have potential to influence spatial variation of percolation and soil water content, including hotspots of soil bypass flow. As a result, the canopy layer can be an important driver for changing soil moisture response to rainfall. In forest and shrub ecosystems the effect of canopy induced heterogeneity in water input on soil water dynamics has already been investigated, but rarely in grassland ecosystems, where the canopy is commonly characterized as homogeneous and uniform layer. However, observations in short vegetation points at a relation between canopy layer and soil moisture variability, indicating that short vegetation can also introduce heterogeneity and influence soil water dynamics. Yet, these observations are mostly confined to evapotranspiration, and no investigation has been extended for understanding the effect of spatially variable vegetation and net precipitation patterns on soil wetting patterns. Therefore, in this study, we investigated soil moisture response to rainfall in a grassland in temperate climate. Further, we explored the effect of wind speed, gross precipitation, throughfall patterns, vegetation height and antecedent soil moisture status on soil moistening after rainfall.

    The grassland site (0.045 ha) is in Thuringia, Germany as a part of Hainich CZE and it is mown 2-3 times in a year. The field observation setup composed of closely paired (within 1.5 m in distance) net precipitation and soil water content measurements at 18 locations. Next to the field measurements in 2019 (April-August), we employed linear mixed effects model to untangle the role of canopy layer on soil moistening patterns from other abiotic factors. Also, we calculated spatially average water balance to trace soil storage recharge over the growing season.

    We found that the increase in soil water storage was remarkably lower than water input regardless of foliage cover. Also, the water balance showed that topsoil (0-17.5 cm) stored less and less precipitation compared to the deeper part (17.5-37.5 cm) through the growing season despite the increasingly drier soil conditions, probably because of non-equilibrium fast flow. The mixed-effects model revealed that spatial variation of grass height is a significant driver for soil wetting patterns together with the average antecedent soil moisture status and precipitation. Soil wetting was suppressed at locations with taller grass, especially under drier antecedent soil moisture conditions. However, the effect of throughfall patterns was obscured probably due to the prevalence of preferential flow. Our results suggest that drier conditions and grassland stemflow might reinforce and expedite preferential flow. The results confirmed that spatially varied grassland canopy together with soil moisture status alters soil moisture wetting patterns and indicates a strong influence of preferential flow on soil water patterns.

    How to cite: Demir, G., Michalzik, B., Filipzik, J., Metzger, J., and Hildebrandt, A.: Spatially heterogeneous grassland wetting patterns are controlled by canopy processes and antecedent soil moisture, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8691, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8691, 2022.

    EGU22-9647 | Presentations | HS10.1

    Water use of drought-tolerant coniferous trees (Pinus brutia and Cupressus sempervirens) in a semi-arid environment 

    Hakan Djuma, Adriana Bruggeman, Marinos Eliades, Christos Zoumides, Melpomeni Siakou, and Mohsen Fasakhondi

    Observing ecohydrological processes of indigenous, drought-tolerant trees in arid and semi-arid regions is of profound importance for assessing the suitability of plant species for future climate conditions. The objective of this study is to quantify transpiration and soil moisture of pine (Pinus brutia) and cypress (Cupressus sempervirens) trees. The study site is located in Athalassa Forest Park, in Cyprus. The site has a surface area of 10 ha with an average slope of 4%. Average annual rainfall is 315 mm with a mean daily minimum temperature of 5° C during January and a mean daily maximum temperature of 37° C during August. The site was converted in 2011 from rainfed agriculture to a mixed forest by planting seedlings of different tree and shrub species.

    Six P. brutia and six C. sempervirens trees were randomly selected for sap flow monitoring with sensors (heat ratio method) attached to the tree trunks. Forty-five soil moisture sensors were installed under the canopy, the edge of canopy and areas with no tree canopy at depths of 10 cm, 30 cm and 50 cm. Data from November 2020 to December 2021 indicated that mean total transpiration per tree was higher for C. sempervirens (≅2.2 m3) than for P. brutia (≅1.3 m3). Total rainfall during these 14 months was 339 mm. Higher transpiration of cypress trees was also reflected in the soil moisture, as canopy area soil moisture contents were generally lower for cypress than for pine for the depths of 10 and 50 cm. After rain maximum soil moisture values were similar for cypress and pine at the depth of 30 cm but the reduction of soil moisture over time was quicker for cypress. 

    This research has received support from the Water JPI (Joint Call 2018) FLUXMED Project, funded through the Cyprus Research and Innovation Foundation.

    How to cite: Djuma, H., Bruggeman, A., Eliades, M., Zoumides, C., Siakou, M., and Fasakhondi, M.: Water use of drought-tolerant coniferous trees (Pinus brutia and Cupressus sempervirens) in a semi-arid environment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9647, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9647, 2022.

    EGU22-10993 | Presentations | HS10.1

    Phosphorus and Fine Particle Retention in Agricultural Headwater Streams 

    Hannah R. Field, Audrey H. Sawyer, Susan A. Welch, Ryan K. Benefiel, Devan M. Mathie, James M. Hood, Ethan D. Pawlowski, Diana L. Karwan, Rebecca M. Kreiling, Zackary I. Johnson, Brittany R. Hanrahan, and Kevin W. King

    In many poorly drained agricultural regions, humans have introduced expansive networks of subsurface tile drains and straightened headwater streams to improve drainage. These networks serve as a direct link between cropland and larger streams and rivers, but the transport and retention of nutrients like phosphorus (P) in these networks is not well understood. Here we evaluate transport and retention of dissolved P and fine particles (which sorb dissolved P) within an agricultural drainage ditch in the Maumee River Basin in northeastern Ohio, USA. We conducted three constant rate injections of conservative salt (Cl as NaCl), dissolved P (KH2PO4), and a fluorescent fine particle (Dayglo AX-11-5 Aurora Pink®) following precipitation events in the spring (May), summer (July), and autumn (December). We model the breakthrough curves using the Continuous Time Random Walk (CTRW) approach to quantify solute and particle transport behavior. Preliminary analysis of Cl breakthrough curves indicates that in-stream velocities were slightly greater in spring (0.079 m/s compared with 0.039 m/s in summer and 0.060 m/s in fall), and conservative solute retention was also greatest in spring, as indicated by residence time behavior (tail power-law slope of -1.73 compared with -1.23 in summer and -1.59 in fall). Preliminary analysis of dissolved P breakthrough curves indicates that the nutrient spiraling length was longer in the spring (4070 m) and decreased in the summer (1560 m). Vegetation stands throughout the stream were denser in the summer and autumn and likely influenced P transport through both physical and biological processes. With the increasing frequency and severity of harmful algal blooms in major waterbodies that receive P from agricultural lands, it is crucial to understand how P moves through highly modified agricultural drainage networks. Tentatively, this study indicates that aquatic vegetation drives biophysical processes in drainage ditches that dictate seasonal nutrient export to larger waterbodies.

    How to cite: Field, H. R., Sawyer, A. H., Welch, S. A., Benefiel, R. K., Mathie, D. M., Hood, J. M., Pawlowski, E. D., Karwan, D. L., Kreiling, R. M., Johnson, Z. I., Hanrahan, B. R., and King, K. W.: Phosphorus and Fine Particle Retention in Agricultural Headwater Streams, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10993, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10993, 2022.

    EGU22-11009 | Presentations | HS10.1

    Environmental water assessment at a catchment scale comparing natural and managed conditions 

    Juan Pablo Quijano Baron, Rebecca Carlier, Jose Rodriguez, Patricia Saco, Steven Sandi, Li Wen, and George Kuczera

    Environmental water is indispensable for promoting and maintaining environmental assets in managed catchments. Water in the Macquarie Catchment is managed by releases from Burrendong Dam, which has played an important role supplying water needs in the Macquarie Valley, and environmental flows to the Ramsar listed Macquarie Marshes. Management decisions tools are necessary to analyze impacts of environmental water at a catchment scale and are critical to preserve ecosystems services under future uncertainties of climate variability and change. Here we implemented WATHNET5, a Network Linear Programming (NLP) tool to analyze effects of environmental water in the Macquarie Catchment. Our semi-distributed model includes storage areas (Dam and wetlands), input flows of the main tributary rivers, irrigation and water consumption demands, routing and conveyance losses. For model setup, rules for operation of the dam were adjusted to current conditions, while tributary rivers, irrigation and water consumption demands were obtained from a hydrological model used by local authorities for the Macquarie River. The ecological outputs of environmental releases were assessed at five locations along the river and following the objectives provided in the Long-Term Water Plan determined by the Environmental Authority (EA). In each of the five locations, our model computed different flows; Base Flows (BF), Small Fresh (SF), Large Fresh (LF) and Overbank flows (OS, OM and OL for small, medium and large respectively), which are associated to different environmental objectives. The EA determined minimum thresholds for each of the flows in terms of timing, duration, frequency and interval between events as indicators of environmental objectives compliance. Our model determines if the different flows met the thresholds and computes the amount for time that the conditions are met during the simulation period. Calibration of the flows over a 30-year period were carried out and the NLP model results were compared with the observations in five gauging station along the catchment. We found that the model adequately represents the flows with Nash–Sutcliffe efficiency coefficients between 0.42 and 0.6. Simulations were carried out for 120 years to analyze the effect of environmental water releases on ecological outcomes compared to natural condition (no dam and irrigation), showing tradeoffs between the different types of flows in different parts of the catchment. Our NLP model can be used as a multi-objective optimization tool to help identify long-term management decisions that can improve system resilience and protect environmental assets under an uncertain future climate.

    How to cite: Quijano Baron, J. P., Carlier, R., Rodriguez, J., Saco, P., Sandi, S., Wen, L., and Kuczera, G.: Environmental water assessment at a catchment scale comparing natural and managed conditions, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11009, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11009, 2022.

    The most common rainfall interception models (Rutter, Gash and Liu) require the knowledge of two canopy-related parameters, the canopy storage capacity (S) and the canopy cover fraction (c). Even though canopy cover changes over time, these parameters are treated as constants in most rainfall interception studies. The aim of this study is to evaluate the performance of these three interception models with the use of time-variable S and c with meteorological and throughfall data from a semi-arid Pinus brutia forest (Cyprus). Leaf area index (LAI) were acquired from the Copernicus global land service (https://land.copernicus.eu/global/products/lai). These data were interpolated with a cubic spline function to obtain a daily time series. Daily S and c values were expressed as one-parameter linear (S) and exponential (c) functions of the daily LAI values The model results with the variable S and c were compared with the model calibration and validation results obtained with constant S and c values. The interception losses computed with the three models ranged between 18 and 20% of the total rainfall. 
    All three models showed high performance for both calibration and validation periods with Kling–Gupta Efficiency (KGE) above 0.90. However, the constant S and c models show equifinality, meaning that a range of combinations of the input parameters S and c will result in the same interception loss. The Gash model with the variable S and c resulted in higher KGE (0.968) and lower percent bias (0.8%) than the Gash model with constant S and c (0.956 KGE and 1.5% percent bias), during the calibration period. Rutter and Liu models with the variable S and c resulted in lower bias (-6 mm and -11 mm) than the models with constant S and c (17 mm and 27 mm). The models were all capable of capturing the inherently variable interception process. However, ground-based LAI data are needed to validate the satellite-based data. 
    This research has received funding from the European Union's Horizon 2020 Research and Innovation programme, under Grant Agreement 641739 (BINGO Project) and from the Research and Innovation Foundation of Cyprus, through the Water Joint Programming Initiative (FLUXMED project).

    How to cite: Eliades, M., Bruggeman, A., and Djuma, H.: Performance of three rainfall interception models with variable canopy cover fraction (c) and canopy storage capacity (S), from satellite-based leaf area index (LAI) data., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11021, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11021, 2022.

    EGU22-11568 | Presentations | HS10.1

    Chlorophyll-a estimation and evaluating the effect of land use change in a Ramsar Site of North East India 

    Bhaswatee Baishya, Gaurav Talukdar, and Arup Sarma

    Abstract

    Chlorophyll concentration could potentially measure the relative productivity and health of lakes and ecosystem. The phytoplankton activities in the water bodies are measured by determining the amount of chlorophyll concentrations, which are used as a proxy for primary production and eutrophication. In addition, satellite imageries provide spatial and temporal changes that would indicate the health of the ecosystems. In this study, we have employed the Normalized Difference Chlorophyll Index (NDCI) algorithm to estimate the Chl-a concentrations based on the bands of Landsat-8 satellite imageries in the Deepor beel a Ramsar site, in Northeast India, Assam. The advantage of NDCI is that it can be used to detect algal bloom and qualitatively infer Chl-a concentration ranges, when the ground data is not available. Two spectral bands at 530 to 590 nm (Green Band) and 640 to 670 nm (Red Band) were selected to develop the index. We also performed the land use land cover (LULC) classifications from 2015-2021 within the lake using the supervised approach. The results indicated that the settlements within the area have increased due to human habitats with decrease in the marshy land, forest and vegetation cover. The runoffs from the settlements and nearby areas resulted in algal blooms, which could potentially result in reduced water quality for survival of aquatic habitats. Therefore, seasonal variability of the Chl-a concentrations during pre-monsoon and post monsoon period was intercompared over the years. It was observed that the Chl-a concentration undergoes both spatial and temporal variation. We found the values to be significantly high during the post monsoon period compared to the pre-monsoon period. Based on the analysis, the study would be of significant importance in evaluating the nutrient loading in lakes, where the fertilizer spill or toxicity levels may be an important aspect under consideration.

    Keywords: Chlorophyll-a, Normalized Difference Chlorophyll Index, LULC

    How to cite: Baishya, B., Talukdar, G., and Sarma, A.: Chlorophyll-a estimation and evaluating the effect of land use change in a Ramsar Site of North East India, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11568, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11568, 2022.

    EGU22-12011 | Presentations | HS10.1

    Conflicting ecosystem services within coastal natural hydrosystems. The case of Louros-Arachthos-Amvrakikos, W. Greece. 

    Christos Pouliaris, Petros Kofakis, Efthymios Chrysanthopoulos, Christos Myriounis, Konstantinos Markantonis, Evgenia Koltsida, Dimitra Pappa, Dimitrios Kaliampakos, Martha Perdikaki, and Andreas Kallioras

    A major problem faced by European coastal zones is the lack of understanding for the complex cross-littoral interactions between major anthropogenic activities. This shortcoming results generally in single-sector management of coastal water resources and water-related ecosystem services instead of a multi-sector ecosystem-based management approach. The above problem becomes more pronounced when conflicts arise between all involved ecosystem services.

    The study site involves a coastal natural and artificial hydrosystem in the Region of Epirus (NW Greece) that incorporates: (a) irrigation management through a complex network of surface canals; (b) an important water transfer infrastructure; (c) upstream-located hydropower dams that utilise surface water resources; (d) two river basins (Louros and Arachthos) that are hydraulically connected with the underlying aquifer system and discharging into the sea; (e) a karstic aquifer that supports both surface water resources as well as anthropogenic demands (drinking water supply and irrigation); and (f) a sensitive marine ecosystem (Amvrakikos) as final receptor that is highly depended on upstream water quantity and quality.

    This research aims to provide an ecosystem service analysis through the identification and characterisation of all involved socio-economic and environmental processes that link land- and sea-based economic and human activities.

    How to cite: Pouliaris, C., Kofakis, P., Chrysanthopoulos, E., Myriounis, C., Markantonis, K., Koltsida, E., Pappa, D., Kaliampakos, D., Perdikaki, M., and Kallioras, A.: Conflicting ecosystem services within coastal natural hydrosystems. The case of Louros-Arachthos-Amvrakikos, W. Greece., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12011, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12011, 2022.

    EGU22-1003 | Presentations | HS10.2

    Palynological and sedimentological records since 8.5 ka BP on the southern Brittany platform (NW Europe): complex responses to sea-level, rapid climate and anthropogenic changes 

    Ophélie David, Aurélie Penaud, Muriel Vidal, Wiem Fersi, Clément Lambert, Evelyne Goubert, Maïwenn Herledan, Pierre Stéphan, Yvan Pailler, Jean-François Bourillet, and Agnes Baltzer

    New results acquired in the south-Brittany shelf (core MD08-3204 CQ: Bay of Quiberon and core VK03-58bis: south-Glénan) allow depicting Holocene paleoenvironmental changes from 8.5 ka BP to present through a multi-proxy dataset including sedimentological and palynological data.

    First, grain-size analyses and AMS-14C dates depict a common sedimentary history for both study cores. After the post-glacial sea-level (RSL) rise and related high sedimentation rates, the parallel slowdown of the RSL rise and the drop of sedimentation rates occurred between 8.3 and 5.7 ka BP. This interval leads to the establishment of a shell-condensed level, identified in the VK03-58bis core by the “Turritella layer” and interpreted as a marker for the establishment of the maximum flooding surface. Palynological data (pollen grains and dinocyst assemblages) acquired in the core MD08-3204 CQ argue for an amplification of the fluvial influence since 5.9 ka BP; the establishment of the highstand system tract (i.e. estuarine-type sedimentation on the platform) then accompanying the slowdown of the RSL rise. On the shelf, the Anthropogenic Pollen Indicators (API) amplification, is detected since 4.2 ka BP, due to the fluvial influence becoming predominant in the context of the Late Holocene.

    In addition, the comparison of fluvial palynological tracers, including API, over the last 7 kyrs, with coastal-marines sites subjected to northern vs. southern Loire catchment areas, allowed to discuss a major hydro-climatic effect on the reconstructed palynological signals. Strengthened subpolar gyre dynamics (SPG), combined with recurrent positive North Atlantic Oscillation (NAO) configurations, are well-known to favour increased winter precipitation and fluvial discharge in northern Europe, such as Brittany, and conversely during weakened SPG the winter fluvial discharge is intensified over southern Europe. Interestingly, we record, at an infra-orbital timescale, major peaks of API during periods of strengthened (/weakened) SPG dynamics in sites whose catchment areas are located north (/south) of the Loire.

    How to cite: David, O., Penaud, A., Vidal, M., Fersi, W., Lambert, C., Goubert, E., Herledan, M., Stéphan, P., Pailler, Y., Bourillet, J.-F., and Baltzer, A.: Palynological and sedimentological records since 8.5 ka BP on the southern Brittany platform (NW Europe): complex responses to sea-level, rapid climate and anthropogenic changes, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1003, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1003, 2022.

    EGU22-1084 | Presentations | HS10.2

    The discontinuous Galerkin method for coupling a 1D river model to a 2D shallow water one 

    Insaf Draoui, Jonathan Lambrechts, Vincent Legat, and Eric Deleersnijder

    Compared to deltas, lakes and estuaries, rivers generally are characterized by their natural downstream flow that can often be dealt with adequately by having recourse to 1D models. The cross-section integrated Saint-Venant equations are widely used in river modeling and engineering applications. In order to ensure the mass conservation the conservative form of the equations is preferred. In this case, the flux and source terms may be formulated in several ways. It is seen, however, that not all of them lead to stable and accurate numerical results. The choice of the convenient unknown and intermediate variables allows getting an optimal stability with fewer numerical adjustments. Furthermore, in a realistic domain, two different issues should be carefully dealt with, namely the relative paucity of geometric data points and the connection to larger water bodies ( delta, lakes ...). Regarding the data interpolation, the reference level for data definition and interpolation is generalized along the river instead of associating a local reference frame to each cross-section, allowing to obtain a smooth, stable source term. As for the connection to a 2D model, a boundary-connected coupling based on flux continuity is adopted. The aforementioned modules are implemented in the framework of a discontinuous Galerkin finite-element model, i.e., the Second-generation Louvain-la-Neuve Ice-ocean Model (SLIM, www.slim-ocean.be). Validation is performed by running the model in idealized configurations. Then, the river-lakes-delta continuum of the Mahakam River (Borneo, Indonesia) is modeled and validation is based on measured water level.

    How to cite: Draoui, I., Lambrechts, J., Legat, V., and Deleersnijder, E.: The discontinuous Galerkin method for coupling a 1D river model to a 2D shallow water one, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1084, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1084, 2022.

    EGU22-3599 | Presentations | HS10.2

    Surface water quality under the Sustainable Development Agenda – the role of improved wastewater treatment 

    Edward R. Jones, Marc F.P. Bierkens, Niko Wanders, Edwin Sutanudjaja, Ludovicus P.H van Beek, and Michelle T.H. van Vliet

    Inadequately managed wastewater is the key driver of water quality deterioration in various regions across the world, threatening both human livelihoods and ecosystem health. Furthermore, improving wastewater management practices can supplement clean water supplies and promote sustainable development. For these reasons, Sustainable Development Goal (SDG) 6.3 sets the target of halving the proportion of untreated wastewater discharged to the environment by 2030. Yet, the impact of achieving this goal on pollutant concentrations in river waters is largely unknown.

    In this work, we use a newly developed high-resolution global surface water quality model (DynQual) to estimate the state and future development of water quality variables that are of key social and environmental relevance: water temperature (Tw), salinity (indicated by total dissolved solids, TDS), organic pollution (indicated by biological oxygen demand, BOD) and pathogens (indicated by faecal coliform, FC). We first simulate river water quality for a historical time period (1980 – 2015) as in-stream concentrations  of Tw, TDS, BOD and FC at 5 arc-minute spatial resolution (~10km) globally and at the daily timestep, and validate these results against (in-situ) water quality observations from monitoring stations worldwide. In a next-step, we simulate in-stream the same water quality parameters up to 2030 under two scenarios: 1) no expansion in wastewater treatment; and 2) expansions to halve the proportion of untreated wastewater globally by 2030 (i.e., as stipulated by SDG6.3). We compare these scenarios to evaluate the relative impact of halving the proportion of untreated wastewater on global water quality.

    We find that in most world regions the irrigation and manufacturing sectors are the major drivers of anthropogenic salinity (TDS) loadings, whereas the largest organic (BOD) and pathogen (FC) pollution loadings originate from the domestic and intensive livestock sectors. Considering also the dilution capacity of the stream network, hotspots of salinity pollution are found in industrialised regions such as northeastern China and the contiguous United States, and in heavily irrigated regions such as northern India. Hotspots of organic and pathogen pollution are closely associated with locations downstream of large urban settlements, and especially those with limited wastewater treatment capacities. Increasing wastewater treatment capacities in line with SDG6.3 leads to substantial decreases in both pollutant loading exports and in-stream concentrations, substantially reducing the frequency and magnitude of water quality threshold exceedance.

    Our work is important for identifying pollutant hotspots and supplementing available observed water quality data, which is extremely sparse in some world regions (e.g. Africa). Our framework also allows for scenario modelling under future projections of climatic and social change, as demonstrated in this work with respect to SDG6.3.

    How to cite: Jones, E. R., Bierkens, M. F. P., Wanders, N., Sutanudjaja, E., van Beek, L. P. H., and van Vliet, M. T. H.: Surface water quality under the Sustainable Development Agenda – the role of improved wastewater treatment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3599, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3599, 2022.

    EGU22-4459 | Presentations | HS10.2

    Climate change driven flood modelling predictions within Southern Thailand 

    Raymond Ward, Jerome Curoy, David Martin, Elena Puch, Jose Tenedor, Yi Wang, Netsanet Almirew, Jimy Dudhia, John Barlow, Cherith Moses, and Kanchana Nakhapakorn

    Globally, flooding is one of the most commonly occurring natural disasters and their frequency of occurrence and intensity is predicted to increase as a result of climate change and associated influences on rainfall intensity, duration and timing. The impact of floods can be exacerbated by associated damage to transport infrastructure, which can impede disaster relief activities, often where needed most. Thailand, and especially Southern Thailand suffers greatly every year and sometimes multiple times a year from flooding causing dramatic human and economic losses. In 2020 for example, after six days of heavy rains, 351 villages were affected by flooding representing a total of 16,709 households and almost 50,000 people.

    Flood risk assessments are increasingly considered vital for societies across the world and as a result, flood modelling has considerably improved in recent decades with new formulations, the acquisition of extremely accurate geodesic data and powerful computers able to handle data processing.

    This study used a bespoke software Flowroute for the flood risk assessment and flood modelling. This modelling software uses meteorological data and detailed GIS data to produce flood maps with return periods of 20, 50 and 100 years within the six largest catchments of the Krabi and Nakhon Si Thammarat provinces in Southern Thailand. Flood forecast models were run using downscaled regional (3km resolution) predictions under the AR6 RCP6.0 scenario, based on 20 year, 50 year and 100 year return period events.

    Results showed a 16-17% increase in flooded area by 2100 compared with 2020 for the 100 year return period events in the Krabi province and a 22-38% increase in flooded area for the 100 year return period events in Nakhon Si Thammarat over the same time period.

    The greatest impacts are likely to occur in the middle and lower parts of the catchments. These areas are flatter with a low angled slope in comparison to the higher parts of the catchments running into the valleys of the mountain chains. The sudden topographical changes between the upper part of the catchments and their lower parts means that during heavy rainfall, large amounts of water are very quickly drained towards a main stream that is not able to cope with it, hence water spreading over the river banks and settling more easily on those flat coastal plains. These areas are generally densely populated, used for industrial purposes and farming representing valuable assets for the economy of both provinces and the country. . Anthropic activities such as dam/weir construction or channel realignment are common in these areas and those changes exacerbate the stress on the river system created by the natural setting of these areas.

    Based on the information provided by these models, authorities and managers can undertake flood mitigation measures by adapting, improving or creating new flood defences within the catchments. A variety of methodologies have been used in the UK from re-establishing the natural flow of the rivers and streams to developing retention basins along the streams.

    How to cite: Ward, R., Curoy, J., Martin, D., Puch, E., Tenedor, J., Wang, Y., Almirew, N., Dudhia, J., Barlow, J., Moses, C., and Nakhapakorn, K.: Climate change driven flood modelling predictions within Southern Thailand, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4459, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4459, 2022.

    EGU22-4873 | Presentations | HS10.2

    Where do tidal channels begin? Insights from the Venice Lagoon 

    Francesca Uguagliati, Davide Tognin, Alice Puppin, Massimiliano Ghinassi, and Andrea D'Alpaos

    Together with salt marshes and tidal flats, tidal channels are one of the fundamental components of tidal environments, because they crucially control the morphodynamic evolution of tidal landscapes. Despite tidal channels play a fundamental role in the hydrodynamics and morphodynamics of tidal environments, the mechanisms that govern their initiation, development, and evolution have received less attention compared to their fluvial counterparts. To address issues of conservation of tidal systems, exposed as they are to the effects of climate changes and increasing human interference, it is therefore of critical importance to improve current understanding of the origins and evolution of tidal channels, of their morphological characteristics, and of the sedimentary structures emerging from their evolution. The present work addresses this important issue, focusing on the study of the erosional and depositional patterns that can be observed in tidal channels cutting through different salt marshes of the Venice Lagoon, from north to south. In particular, we analyzed whether tidal channels are first initiated over tidal-flat surfaces and then inherited by salt marshes, or tidal channels are capable to incise the vegetated salt-marsh surfaces overwhelming the erosion resistance to channel incision provided by vegetation. This study was carried out by combining sedimentological, paleontological, and geomorphic analyses for a total of 30 meanders belonging to small tidal marsh creeks. For the sedimentological analyses, a total of 191 cores were recovered along axial transects of the 30 study bends with normally 6 cores per transect. These analyses allowed us to distinguish four main types of deposits: salt-marsh, point-bar, channel-lag and tidal-flat deposits. Their correlation emphasized the position and the size of the point bars within the different examined transects. Based on the position of the point bar and its brink trajectory within each transect we determined whether the erosive processes that led to channel primary formation occurred over a salt marsh or over a tidal-flat surface. The analyses showed that in most cases the considered channels are originated through the incision of a salt marsh. Lastly, the geomorphic analyses suggested that the analyzed saltmarsh creeks are strongly incised.

    How to cite: Uguagliati, F., Tognin, D., Puppin, A., Ghinassi, M., and D'Alpaos, A.: Where do tidal channels begin? Insights from the Venice Lagoon, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4873, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4873, 2022.

    EGU22-6445 | Presentations | HS10.2

    A Satellite-based analysis of Tiber River inland-marine water connectivity 

    Rossella Belloni, Jaime Pitarch, Claudia Adduce, Angelica Tarpanelli, and Federico Falcini

    Connectivity describes the efficiency of material transfer between the components of a system. The definition of these components varies among different disciplines and in relation to the material under consideration.

    River systems are complex and dynamic environments where multiple and highly inter-correlated processes occur at various spatial and temporal scales. Because of this reason, in-situ traditional techniques for inland waters monitoring are often inadequate to the full understanding of river processes, making the evaluation of river system and inland-marine water connectivity a challenging task.

    In this study, we use high-resolution multispectral satellite data acquired by the Sentinel-2 Earth observation mission of the EU Copernicus Programme to investigate the connectivity of the lower Tiber River basin (Italy) from a sedimentological and biogeochemical point of view. To this end, Level-1C satellite imagery, collected on the study area for the period 2017-2020, were processed through the ACOLITE software to perform image atmospheric correction and to obtain water turbidity (WT) and chlorophyll-a (Chl) concentration values on multiple regions of interest along the river course up to the river mouth and the adjacent coastal area. WT and Chl are indeed key parameters for both sediment transport and water quality monitoring of inland and coastal waters. River connectivity was then evaluated by analyzing the spatio-temporal variability of seasonal climatologies of the satellite-derived parameters.

    The analysis showed a significant dependence of suspended sediment transport and chlorophyll concentration on hydrological conditions; however, complex dynamics arises. From a sedimentological point of view, as expected, connectivity seems to be positively correlated with the magnitude of the hydrological events, with the highest and lowest degrees of connectivity of WT during the highest and lowest discharge events respectively (winter and summer). From a biogeochemical point of view, there seems to be an optimum window during moderate hydrological conditions (spring) that, on one hand, allow for sediment resuspension and, therefore, nutrients transport along the river course, but on the other, prevent to reach critical resuspension values that would reduce and/or hinder Chl concentration along the river course.

    How to cite: Belloni, R., Pitarch, J., Adduce, C., Tarpanelli, A., and Falcini, F.: A Satellite-based analysis of Tiber River inland-marine water connectivity, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6445, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6445, 2022.

    EGU22-7103 | Presentations | HS10.2 | Highlight

    Living-Lab Rhine – A new approach to transboundary research along the free-flowing Rhine 

    Martin Struck, Nils Huber, Gudrun Hillebrand, Pauline Onjira, Axel Winterscheid, Jos Brils, Ralph Schielen, Jan-Willem Mol, Christina Bode, Anna van den Hoek, and Fabiola Siering

    The Rhine as Europe’s most important waterway is navigable for about 800 km. Over centuries, it has experienced numerous human interventions along this length, from barrage construction in the upper part, through river straightening and regulation, and implementation of flood defence measures along most of its course, to land reclamation in its delta, to name just a few. The large number of changes brought along major environmental issues, namely an overall tendency to insufficient sediment amounts, widespread loss of habitats and biodiversity, and the sensitivity to flooding. Nowadays, the Rhine is an intensively managed river with important industries along its banks and a highly cultivated and densely populated catchment and delta. It is therefore a fundamental challenge to reach an agreement between its role as a waterway, the manifold of other human uses and environmental demands, to improve its ecological condition.

    From its last barrage at Iffezheim, the Rhine is free-flowing and crosses the border between Germany and the Netherlands after about 530 km, where it soon connects with the Meuse to form the Rhine-Meuse delta. In this setting, Dutch and German partners take a new approach to address urgent issues on a transboundary level. As part of the pan-European research infrastructure DANUBIUS-RI, two natural laboratories, called the Middle Rhine Supersite (GER) and the Rhine-Meuse Delta Supersite (NL), are being set up to facilitate interdisciplinary research on questions regarding system understanding and ecological improvement of the river to foster the identification of possible solutions. DANUBIUS-RI, the “International Centre for Advanced Studies on River-Sea Systems”, is being developed with the goal to support interdisciplinary and integrated research on river-sea systems. It aims to enable, support and bring together research addressing the conflicts between societal demands, environmental change and environmental protection along the continuum from freshwaters to marine waters, by providing easy access to a wide range of fundamental and comparable data from a diverse set of European river-sea systems. It will also facilitate physical access to these systems through multiple supersites.

    A first pilot project at the Rhine, supported by INTERREG regional funding of the Euregio Rhine-Waal, involves partners of both the Dutch and the German supersite and focuses on the comparison of sediment measurement and data processing methods in both countries. The goal of this ‘Living-Lab Rhine’ (LILAR) project is to enable a better transboundary use and comparison of the data to eventually improve the overall understanding of the Rhine sediment regime and to strengthen the transboundary efforts regarding sediment measurements and potentially even river management between Germany and the Netherlands.

    How to cite: Struck, M., Huber, N., Hillebrand, G., Onjira, P., Winterscheid, A., Brils, J., Schielen, R., Mol, J.-W., Bode, C., van den Hoek, A., and Siering, F.: Living-Lab Rhine – A new approach to transboundary research along the free-flowing Rhine, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7103, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7103, 2022.

    EGU22-7940 | Presentations | HS10.2

    Influence of recent droughts on carbon cycling in the Elbe estuary 

    Louise Rewrie, Yoana Voynova, Holger Brix, Gregor Ollesch, and Burkard Baschek

    Climate projections show high temperature extremes, meteorological droughts and heavy precipitation events are set to increase across Europe (Barros et al., 2014), where the decadel average has already increaed, with temperature in 2002-2011 already 1.3°C±0.1°C above the 1850-1899 mean (Barros et al., 2014). The observed seasonal precipitation pattern presents drier summers and wetter winters across Europe, also mirrored in river flow changes. Across small river catchments in Europe from 1962 to 2004, winter period showed positive trends whereas summers were characterized by negative trends in river flow (Stahl et al., 2010). Such changes can alter the residence time of an estuary. Estuaries are biogeochemical hotspots, and critical zones for carbon cycling, and changes in the hydrological balance, still largely not well characterized, may influence processes within the water column. 

    The present study will assess the potential impacts of droughts on the carbonate system in the Elbe estuary. One of the largest in central Europe, the Elbe River catchment spreads over approximately 150,000 km2 in four countries. Between 2014 and 2018, regions of Northern Germany have been under drought conditions during certain months (UFZ, 2018), reducing discharge in the Elbe River. From 2014, annual Elbe river discharge has been relatively low, where 2018 exhibited the lowest annual mean river discharge of 441 m3 s-1 since 1992. Model projections show the annual river discharge for the Elbe river is likely to remain low at 410 m2 s-1 in 2046-2055 compared to >550 m2 s-1 in 1960-1990 (Krysanova et al., 2005).

    Analysis of the long-term FGG Elbe (Flussgebietsgemeinschaft Elbe) records of dissolved inorganic carbon (DIC) in the mid to lower Elbe estuary show that over spring and summer months DIC values have increased with time (1997-2018). In this period, DIC increased from the freshwater to the mesohaline region, followed by a decrease to the polyhaline zone. This is opposing to previous DIC patterns in the early 1980s, where DIC decreased towards the mid-estuary after which increased to the outer estuary. An increase in DIC in the mid-estuarine region coincided with increased turbidity and extended residence time, and during the productive months with higher organic matter from upstream regions.  This could suggest that more time for heterotrophic activity and availability of labile organic matter, acts to enrich DIC within the water column in the turbid regions, thus changing carbon cycling within the estuary. Further analysis will focus on the changes in river discharge and inorganic carbon during the past two decades, thus inclusive of low discharge and drought conditions.

    How to cite: Rewrie, L., Voynova, Y., Brix, H., Ollesch, G., and Baschek, B.: Influence of recent droughts on carbon cycling in the Elbe estuary, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7940, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7940, 2022.

    EGU22-8632 | Presentations | HS10.2

    Enrichment of trace metals from acid sulphate soils in sediments of the Kvarken Archipelago, eastern Gulf of Bothnia, Baltic Sea 

    Joonas Virtasalo, Peter Österholm, Aarno Kotilainen, and Mats Åström

    Rivers draining the acid sulphate soils of western Finland are known to deliver large amounts of trace metals (e.g. Al, Cd, Co, Cu, La, Mn, Ni and Zn) with detrimental environmental consequences to the recipient estuaries in the eastern Gulf of Bothnia, northern Baltic Sea. However, the distribution of these metals in the coastal sea area, and the relevant metal transport mechanisms have been less studied.

    This study investigates the spatial and temporal distribution of metals in sediments at 9 sites in the Kvarken Archipelago, which is the recipient of Laihianjoki and Sulvanjoki rivers that are among the most acid sulphate soil impacted rivers in Europe. Metal contents increase in the studied cores during the 1960s and 1970s due to the intensive artificial drainage of the acid sulphate soil landscape. The metal deposition has remained at high levels since the 1980s and the metal enrichment in seafloor sediments is currently visible at least 25 km seaward from the river mouths. Comparison to sediment quality guidelines shows that the metal contents are very likely to cause detrimental effects on marine biota more than 12 km out from the river mouths. The dynamic sedimentary environment of the shallow archipelago makes these sediments potential future sources of metals to the ecosystem. Finally, the strong association of metals and nutrients in the same sediment grain size class of 2–6 µm suggests that the transformation of dissolved organic matter and metals to metal-organic aggregates at the river mouths is the key mechanism of seaward trace metal transport, in addition to co-precipitation with Mn-oxyhydroxides identified in previous studies. These findings are important for the estimation of environmental risks and the management of biologically-sensitive coastal sea ecosystems.

    This study resulted from the SmartSea project, funded by the Strategic Research Council at the Academy of Finland (grant number 292 985). M.E.Å. additionally acknowledges the Swedish Research Council Formas (grant number 2018-00760). The study has utilized research infrastructure facilities provided by FINMARI (Finnish Marine Research Infrastructure network).

    Original publication: Virtasalo, J. J., Österholm, P., Kotilainen, A. T., and Åström, M. E.: Enrichment of trace metals from acid sulfate soils in sediments of the Kvarken Archipelago, eastern Gulf of Bothnia, Baltic Sea. Biogeosciences, 17, 6097–6113, https://doi.org/10.5194/bg-17-6097-2020, 2020.

    How to cite: Virtasalo, J., Österholm, P., Kotilainen, A., and Åström, M.: Enrichment of trace metals from acid sulphate soils in sediments of the Kvarken Archipelago, eastern Gulf of Bothnia, Baltic Sea, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8632, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8632, 2022.

    EGU22-10612 | Presentations | HS10.2

    Modelling of sediment transport pattern in the estuary of the Piave River 

    Antonia Menzione and Marco Mancini

    Over the last decades numerous models for sediment transport prediction have been proposed with application to fluvial transport or littoral transport. However, the morpho-dynamic interactions that occur at the river mouth are still largely unexplored given different concurring phenomena, deriving from both river hydraulics and marine hydrodynamics. Knowing the magnitude of these phenomena is important to analyse and predict sediment discharge and deposition, erosion and potential effects on biological processes. The paper investigates the possibility to assess the behaviour of suspended sediment pattern at river mouth using numerical models and satellite images, providing a platform for the prediction of the effect of climate change in estuarine morpho-dynamic.

    For this purpose, the hydrodynamic model (TELEMAC-2D) and the sediment transport model (SISYPHE) are coupled and their simulated suspended sediment maps are compared with the satellite Sentinel 2 images of SSC (suspended solid concentration) supporting the advection diffusion model coefficients calibration. 

    TELEMAC-2D, a module of TELEMAC, solves the Saint-Venant equations and allows to evaluate the depth of the water, the depth-averaged tidal currents and the velocity components. Based on the outputs of the hydrodynamic simulation, the SISYPHE module simulates the transport of the fine sediments by calculating the erosion / sedimentation fluxes, concentration in the water column and layer thickness of deposited fine sediments using the Krone and Partheniades formulation, as well as the bedload flux calculated as a function of the friction and the bed shear stress.The estimate of suspended solids from remote sensing data is performed based on the relationship between SSC and spectral reflectance.

    The case study in consideration is the estuary of the River Piave (3000 sq km), which flows from the eastern Italian Alps to the North Adriatic Sea. The impacts and influence of the different drivers (fluvial current, tidal currents, etc.) on the concentration, dispersion pattern and deposition of sediment are discussed.

    How to cite: Menzione, A. and Mancini, M.: Modelling of sediment transport pattern in the estuary of the Piave River, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10612, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10612, 2022.

    EGU22-10786 | Presentations | HS10.2

    The warmer the better?: the relationship between ecosystem metabolism and temperature, possible implications under climate change – a meta-analysis 

    Hugo Enrique Reyes Aldana, Daniel Graber, Markus Weitere, Matthew Cohen, and Ute Risse-Buhl

    River and stream metabolism have been proposed as an important tool to determine ecological status, as it encompasses most of the environmental interactions. However, some of the factors influencing it have not been studied with enough depth, which is essential to define its utility as a monitoring and diagnostic tool, especially under the variable conditions of the current global changes. One of these understudied factors is temperature, which may become problematic considering the increasing temperatures and heatwaves occasioned by climate change. For instance, increasing temperatures due to climate change or extreme events may favor the proliferation of algal species resistant to high-temperature variability occasioning blooms and altering ecosystem metabolism. Thus, there is a need to understand how temperature affects ecosystem metabolism and its components, to be able to propose better and more integrative measures to counteract negative changes and make predictions of possible scenarios. This work presents a meta-analysis of the current information that is available on the response of ecosystem metabolism to temperature and highlights some of its implications and perspectives. With this information, scientists, managers, and stakeholders might be able to have a wider perspective and propose more adequate measurements in terms of ecosystem metabolism and ecological status.

    How to cite: Reyes Aldana, H. E., Graber, D., Weitere, M., Cohen, M., and Risse-Buhl, U.: The warmer the better?: the relationship between ecosystem metabolism and temperature, possible implications under climate change – a meta-analysis, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10786, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10786, 2022.

    EGU22-11383 | Presentations | HS10.2

    Biodiversity mediates human-environment interactions in deltas 

    Martin O. Reader, Maarten B. Eppinga, Hugo J. de Boer, Owen Petchey, Alexander Damm, and Maria J. Santos

    River and sea ecosystem services contribute to the rapid and intensive development of delta social-ecological systems. This development, alongside other global change drivers, threatens the biodiversity of these deltas and in turn the ecosystem services that this biodiversity supports. However, biodiversity can itself mediate anthropogenic impacts by increasing ecosystem resilience. Linkages between biodiversity and ecosystem services are increasingly established, but we lack understanding of whether the mediating effects of biodiversity are global and ubiquitous, and whether they mediate global change drivers in deltas.

    Here, we examine the potential for biodiversity to mediate the relationships between five anthropogenic indicators and global change drivers (population, infrastructure, land use change, climate change in temperature and precipitation) and 19 ecosystem properties and services. We assess these relationships across a global dataset of 235 large deltas. We find that in 89% of cases, greater biodiversity (species richness and the intactness of biodiversity) is connected to a weakened or reversed association between anthropogenic drivers and ecosystem services. Such weaker or reversed associations were found across different ecosystem services (e.g. food production, carbon sequestration, soil regulation), most commonly with climate change and population.

    We then investigated the contribution of biodiversity and abiotic and anthropogenic drivers to delta ecosystem service supply. Ecosystem service supply was most strongly and consistently associated with abiotic drivers (mostly climatic), but biodiversity and anthropogenic drivers were also important to individual services (productivity and crop-related services respectively). Deltas showed fewer than expected associations between biotic, abiotic and anthropogenic indicators and ecosystem services, yet weakened or reversed associations were more frequent than in other social-ecological systems. Our results empirically show how biodiversity can both act as a resource and mediate social-ecological relationships, but that both of these roles could be compromised as deltas become more modified.

    How to cite: Reader, M. O., Eppinga, M. B., de Boer, H. J., Petchey, O., Damm, A., and Santos, M. J.: Biodiversity mediates human-environment interactions in deltas, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11383, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11383, 2022.

    EGU22-12581 | Presentations | HS10.2

    Regime shifts in river deltas 

    Roeland C. van de Vijsel, Marten Scheffer, and A.J.F. (Ton) Hoitink

    River deltas harbor invaluable ecosystems as well as many of the world’s largest cities and are hotspots for economic activity. This necessitates accurate prediction of the response of delta biogeomorphology to future scenarios of changes in sea level, wave climate, river discharge dynamics and anthropogenic forcing. Valuable insights have come from long-term model predictions performed with high-complexity simulation models. Such models often predict a gradual adjustment of biogeomorphic equilibrium to changing forcing conditions. On the other hand, a growing number of studies, based on strongly idealized models, indicate the presence of tipping points where delta systems may undergo irreversible regime shifts to an alternative stable state. Examples include estuarine (hyper)turbidity, delta channel instability and ecosystem emergence or collapse. However, field observations to support either the predicted absence or presence of irreversible regime shifts in river deltas remain scarce.

    Our study reviews the existing research on reversible (single equilibrium) and irreversible (multiple equilibria) transitions in delta biogeomorphology. We propose how to bridge the apparent gap between high-complexity models, which accurately capture reversible morphodynamic adjustment to small changes in forcing but are unpractical to probe wide parameter ranges for the presence of irreversible regime shifts, and idealized models, which have contrasting characteristics. We discuss (the lack of) existing field data to support morphodynamic model predictions and specify which field measurements would be needed to provide more conclusive evidence. Specific attention is given to early warning indicators for regime shifts, such as spatial patterning and critical slowing down, and which of these signals could be picked up in delta systems. Finally, we illustrate how the design of human interventions, such as channel dredging, beach nourishments and ecosystem restoration, requires fundamental knowledge of a delta’s natural resilience, as lower resilience implies higher susceptibility to irreversible regime shifts.

    How to cite: van de Vijsel, R. C., Scheffer, M., and Hoitink, A. J. F. (.: Regime shifts in river deltas, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12581, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12581, 2022.

    High levels of Faecal Indicator Organisms (FIOs), such as E Coli and Enterococci, at bathing water sites are linked to disease and public health threats. Hydro-environmental models for coastal areas are important for understanding the transport and fate of FIOs, evaluating effectiveness of environmental management strategies on coastal water quality as well as predicting FIO concentrations in bathing water sites. An important aspect in hydro-environmental models is simulating bacteria decay. Bacteria such as FIOs are generally assumed to undergo a first order degradation, C(t)=C0exp(-kt),  where C(t) is bacteria concentration at time t; C0 is initial concentration; k is bacteria decay rate. The bacteria decay rate depends on factors such as temperature, solar irradiation, and suspended solid concentration. A number of bacteria decay models, with various level of complexity, have been developed and applied in different waterbodies such as coastal areas, estuaries, and rivers; there is no consensus regarding to the best model for any given scenario. Generic bacteria decay models have been also attempted but they did not outperform site-specific models. This research evaluates the performance of several bacteria decay models in a data rich test site, namely Swansea Bay, located in South-west of UK. More than 7000 FIO samples were taken at key sources and receptors and analysed over two bathing seasons in two years. Environmental data for stream flows, tide levels, meteorology and water quality are also available. These data are important for hydro-environmental model development, calibration, and validation. This research also provides insights to the key drivers of FIOs at the bathing water sites along Swansea Bay. Hydro-environmental models for the Bay were developed with TELEMAC-2D and -3D hydrodynamic solvers, developed by the Research and Development department of Electricité de France (EDF). TELEMAC-2D solves the two-dimensional Shallow Water Equations (SWE) and TELEMAC-3D solves the three-dimensional Navier Stokes Equations (NSE). The two solvers employ the finite element method on unstructured triangular meshes. The solvers have been used in hydro-environmental studies in coastal areas, lakes, and rivers. Two main decay models were considered in this study; the Stapleton model which considers irradiation and suspended solid effects and the Mancini model which considers irradiation, salinity and temperature effects. King (2019) studied the performance of these bacteria decay models at the case study site and suggested that further improvements might be achieved by combining the two models. In this research, the performance of (i) the Stapleton model, (ii) the Mancini model and (iii) a combination of Stapleton and Mancini model were evaluated against measured FIO concentrations.  It was found that one of the key limitations of the hydro-environmental models is that the hydrodynamics of the wet-dry interface in the swash zone may not be represented accurately. Modelling wet-dry interface remains a numerical challenge; there are different modelling approaches, representing different trade-offs between computational efficiency, numerically stability and scientific accuracy. To compensate for this limitation, sensitivity of FIO concentrations to sampling locations was also evaluated. Reference: (i) King JA (2019). https://orca.cardiff.ac.uk/125923/; (ii) Mancini JL (1978). https://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/25040179.pdf; (iii) Stapleton CM et al. (2007). https://orca.cardiff.ac.uk/40376/

    How to cite: Lam, M.-Y. and Ahmadian, R.: Studying transport and decay models for Faecal Indicator Organisms (FIOs) in nearshore coastal waters, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12738, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12738, 2022.

    EGU22-12938 | Presentations | HS10.2

    Using historic records of compound flood events to identify site-specific thresholds for flooding in UK estuaries 

    Peter Robins, Charlotte Lyddon, Matt Lewis, Andrew Barkwith, Greg Vasilopoulos, and Tom Coulthard

    Estuarine flooding is driven by extreme sea-levels and river discharge, either occurring independently or at the same time, or in close succession to exacerbate the hazard, known as compound events. There is a need to identify site-specific thresholds for flooding in estuaries, which represent the magnitude of key drivers over which flooding occurs. Site-specific thresholds for flooding can be used to support forecasts and warnings, emergency response and long-term management plans. This research uses historic records of flooding in estuaries around the UK combined with 40 years of historical 15-minute frequency sea-level and river discharge data to establish the magnitude and relative timing of the drivers of flooding in 11 estuaries. The results identify estuaries which are more likely to experience flooding due to extreme compound events, e.g. Conwy, N-Wales, or independent extreme events e.g. Humber, E-England. The key limitation of using historic records of flooding is that not all flooding events have been documented, and there are gaps in the record. Therefore, this research also identified the top 50 extreme sea-level and river discharge events in the historic gauge measurements at each estuary, and cross-checked these against online sources (news reports and academic literature), to establish if these events also led to flooding. A more comprehensive historic record of flooding allows more accurate thresholds for flooding to set in each estuary. Future work will utilise numerical modelling tools in 4 estuaries to simulate flooding under different sea-level and river discharge conditions to further isolate accurate thresholds.

    How to cite: Robins, P., Lyddon, C., Lewis, M., Barkwith, A., Vasilopoulos, G., and Coulthard, T.: Using historic records of compound flood events to identify site-specific thresholds for flooding in UK estuaries, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12938, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12938, 2022.

    EGU22-13281 | Presentations | HS10.2

    The importance of 'invisible' dissolved organic carbon along the land-ocean aquatic continuum 

    Stacey L. Felgate and the Authors

    Land-ocean dissolved organic carbon (DOC) fluxes are a significant and changing component of the global carbon cycle. The current paradigm assumes that these fluxes are dominated by chromophoric or ‘coloured’ material (cDOC). DOC is often characterised and quantified using optical tools which specifically target this fraction. However, multiple studies point towards a potentially sizeable non-coloured or optically ‘invisible’ DOC (iDOC) pool which is not covered by such characterisations. Only a handful of studies have directly investigated iDOC, and so its source, composition, behaviour, and geographic prevalence remain poorly understood.

    Here we show that iDOC accounts for 21 % (0.23 Tg C yr-1) of annual riverine export in Great Britain (GB), with spatial variation in catchment-scale mean annual export depending upon forest cover and mean dairy cattle density. Using > 2,900 samples from across a range of geo-climatic settings across five continents we find a similar result: iDOC accounts for 26 % of the measured DOC flux in freshwaters. Our results indicate that iDOC is more prevalent in systems with a high degree of anthropogenic influence and/or a high residence time. 

    We also show that estuarine DOC behaviour is driven by the contributions of cDOC and iDOC, at least within GB estuaries: cDOC almost universally exhibits conservative transport, whilst apparent non-conservative bulk DOC transport is typically caused by fluctuations in the iDOC fraction.

    We conclude that iDOC is a globally significant fraction of the land-ocean carbon flux, the broad scale importance of which has been largely overlooked. This has fundamental implications for (1) our understanding of aquatic biogeochemistry and (2) the use and interpretation of optical parameters as they relate to DOC characterisation and quantification.

    This work was primarily funded by the National Environment Research Council (NERC) through the SPITFIRE Doctoral Training Programme (grant number NE/L002531/1) and the Land Ocean Carbon Transfer Programme (LOCATE; grant number NE/N018087/1). 

    How to cite: Felgate, S. L. and the Authors: The importance of 'invisible' dissolved organic carbon along the land-ocean aquatic continuum, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13281, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13281, 2022.

    EGU22-13455 | Presentations | HS10.2

    Comparison of tidal asymmetry descriptors – a sensitivity study based on one-year monitoring data of the Ems estuary 

    Anna Wünsche, Marius Becker, Jens Jürges, Jessica Kelln, and Christian Winter

    Estuarine management requires fundamental system understanding on drivers and effects of flow and transport dynamics. Among other system descriptors, tidal asymmetry is a fundamental prop-erty, used in many ways, e.g. to define the dominant direction of sediment transport in estuaries. There are several different parametrizations of tidal asymmetry, and the number of methods of their derivation has increased in recent years. We present an attempt to discuss comparability of descriptors for tidal asymmetry. We computed descriptors from one-year measured monitoring data of the Ems estuary. Using conformal mapping we scaled each of these for comparison. A sen-sitivity analysis shows the pronounced influence of freshwater discharge on descriptors derived from velocity data and, on the other hand, the influence of wind on quantities based on duration of tidal phases. The impact of spring neap variability changes over the estuary. Our results show that observations of short periods (e.g. two tides) are not robust compared to the average of a spring neap cycle. Finally, we conclude that the classification of the estuary in terms of flood or ebb dominant sediment transport is critically dependent on location and period of the input data. Further, we discuss how to interpret hydrodynamic parameters derived from point measure-ments. The actual characterization of an estuary requires more comprehensive data, such as var-iability over cross sections, data of suspended sediment concentration and a consideration of the entire density-driven circulation.

    How to cite: Wünsche, A., Becker, M., Jürges, J., Kelln, J., and Winter, C.: Comparison of tidal asymmetry descriptors – a sensitivity study based on one-year monitoring data of the Ems estuary, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13455, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13455, 2022.

    EGU22-1188 | Presentations | HS10.3

    Quantifying evapotranspiration budgets of winter rye using a automated gantry crane – effects of soil type, erosion and management and testing gap filling procedures 

    Maren Dubbert, Adrian Dahlmann, Michael Sommert, Jürgen Augustin, and Mathias Hoffmann

    In light of ongoing global climate change and related increases in extreme hydrological events, it is becoming increasingly important to have a comprehensive knowledge of the ecosystem water cycle to assess ecosystem stability and in agricultural system to ensure sustainable management and food security. Evapotranspiration (ET) plays a crucial role returning up to 90 % of ingoing precipitation back to the atmosphere. In agriculture, further knowledge about plant transpiration (T) and evaporation (E) of different soils could lead to more efficient water use in the future, which will become necessary for agricultural practice in many regions due to climate change related increase in drought events. Here, we wanted to implore impacts of soil types (representing a ful soil erosion gradient) on ecosystem water budgets (ET) and agronomic water use efficiencies (WUEagro).

    We conducted a plot experiment with winter rye (September 17, 2020 to June 30, 2021) at the "CarboZALF-D” experimental field which is located in the hilly and dry ground moraine landscape of the Uckermark region in NE Germany. Along an experimental plot (110 m x 16 m) a modern automated gantry crane was built and used for the first time to continuously determine evapotranspiration with two automated chambers. A major advantage of this system is the opportunity to assess management and soil type effects (compared to eddy covariance setups), without corroborating measurement frequency (compared to manual chamber setups).

    Three soil types representing the full soil erosion gradient of the hummocky ground moraine landscape (extremely eroded: Calcaric Regosol, strongly eroded: Nudiargic Luvisol, non-eroded: Calcic Luvisol) within each soil type were investigated (randomized block design, 3 replicates per treatment). In addition, we used five different gap-filling methods and compared them in light of their potential to aquire precise water budgets over the entire growth period as well as reproduce short water flux dynamics realistically. The best performance was achieved with methods based on mean-diurnal-variation (MDV) and support vector machine (SVM), including a validation step SVM yielded best predictions of measured ET. Subsequently, we simulated half-hourly ET fluxes and calculated balances of evapotranspiration for the cropping period.

    The results show that there are significant differences in evapotranspiration and yield between soil types, resulting in different water use efficiencies (WUEagro). The Calcaric Regosol (extremely eroded) shows a maximum of around 10% lower evapotranspiration and a maximum of around 35% lower water use efficiency (WUEagro) compared non-eroded soils.  The key period contributing to 50-65 % of overall ET of the entire growth period was from late April until harvest, however differences in the overall ET budget between soil types and manipulation resulted predominantly from small long-term differences between the treatments over the entire growth period.

    How to cite: Dubbert, M., Dahlmann, A., Sommert, M., Augustin, J., and Hoffmann, M.: Quantifying evapotranspiration budgets of winter rye using a automated gantry crane – effects of soil type, erosion and management and testing gap filling procedures, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1188, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1188, 2022.

    EGU22-2748 | Presentations | HS10.3

    Comparison of nighttime with daytime evapotranspiration responses to environmental controls across temporal scales along a climate gradient 

    Qiong Han, Tiejun Wang, Lichun Wang, Keith Smettem, Mai Mai, and Xi Chen

    Understanding daytime (ETD) and nighttime (ETN) evapotranspiration is critical for accurately evaluating terrestrial water and carbon cycles. However, unlike ETD, the factors influencing ETN remain poorly understood. Here, long-term ETD and ETN data from five FLUXNET sites along a climate gradient in Northern Australia were analyzed to compare their responses to environmental drivers at different temporal scales. Across the sites, mean annual ETN/ETD ranged between 5.1% and 11.7%, which was mainly determined by ETD variations. Both vegetation and climatic conditions were closely related to mean annual ETD, while the primary controls on mean annual ETN were air temperature and net radiation (Rn). At site levels, monthly ETD and ETN showed better correlations with meteorological and vegetation variables than annual ETD and ETN, and the coupling of ETD and ETN was also stronger at monthly timescales, particularly under drier climatic conditions. At daily timescales, leaf area index and soil water content (SWC) controlled ETD with SWC being more important at drier sites; whereas, SWC was the dominant factor controlling ETN. At half-hourly timescales, the boosted regression tree method quantitively showed that ETD and ETN were controlled by Rn and SWC, respectively. Overall, the results showed that ETN was less responsive to environmental variables, illustrating that ETD and ETN responded differently to diverse climate regimes and ecosystems at varying temporal scales.

    How to cite: Han, Q., Wang, T., Wang, L., Smettem, K., Mai, M., and Chen, X.: Comparison of nighttime with daytime evapotranspiration responses to environmental controls across temporal scales along a climate gradient, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2748, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2748, 2022.

    As a way to estimate evapotranspiration (ET), Heat Field Deformation (HFD) is a widely used method to measure sap flow of trees based on empirical relationships between heat transfer within tree stems and the sap flow rates. As an alternative, the Linear Heat Balance (LHB) method implements the same instrumental configuration as HFD but calculates the sap flow rates using analytical equations that are derived from fundamental conduction-convection heat transfer equations. In this study, we systematically compared the sap flow calculated using the two methods from four Norway spruce trees. We aimed to evaluate the discrepancies between the sap flow estimates from the two methods and determine the underlying causes. Diurnal and day-to-day patterns were consistent between the sap flow estimates from the two methods. However, the magnitudes of the estimated sap flow were different, where LHB resulted in much lower estimates in three trees and slightly higher estimates in one tree compared to HFD. We also observed larger discrepancies in negative (downward) than in positive (upward) sap flow, where the LHB resulted in lower reversed flow than HFD. Consequently, the seasonal budget estimated by LHB can be as low as ~20% of that estimated by HFD. The discrepancies can be mainly attributed to the low wood thermal conductivities for the studied trees that lead to substantial underestimations using the LHB method. In addition, the sap flow estimates were very sensitive to the value changes of the empirical parameters in the calculations and, thus, using a proper case-specific value is recommended, especially for the LHB method. Overall, we suggest that, despite the strong theoretical support, the correctness of LHB outputs depends largely on the tree individuals and should be carefully evaluated. 

    How to cite: Zhao, J., Lange, H., Meissner, H., and Bright, R.: Heat Field Deformation (HFD) vs Linear Heat Balance (LHB):  A critical comparison of two sap flow methods based on the same instrumentation, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4370, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4370, 2022.

    EGU22-4472 | Presentations | HS10.3

    Machine-learned actual Evapotranspiration for an Irrigated Pecan Orchard in Northwest Mexico 

    Robin Stoffer, Julio César Rodríguez, Chiel van Heerwaarden, and Oscar Hartogensis

    Agriculture in semi-arid regions like Northwest Mexico, is typically characterized by heavily irrigated fields surrounded by a desert environment. The strong contrast in surface conditions increases the non-linear and non-local character of the evapotranspiration dynamics at the irrigated fields, in particular through the oasis effect: strong local evaporative cooling, associated with evapotranspiration enhanced by advection of warm and dry air from the surroundings. To estimate evapotranspiration for individual fields, the agricultural practice relies on traditional empirical models (e.g. Makkink, Priestley-Taylor, FAO-Penman-Monteith) that only make use of standard weather station data. The aforementioned empirical models typically rely on arbitrary, manual tuning (e.g. adjusted constants or the application of a locally determined crop factor) to work reliably.

    The goal of this study is to explore whether a physics-informed machine learning approach can be used to improve the estimated evapotranspiration for irrigated fields located in a desert environment, without arbitrary tuning after training and only using regionally available data as input. To this end we will focus on a typical irrigated pecan orchard in Northwest Mexico. At this orchard we have obtained a rich multi-year dataset that encompasses eddy-covariance measurements, irrigation data, soil moisture measurements, and meteorological station data (e.g. air temperature, specific humidity, wind speed and direction) at a half-hourly time scale. In addition, we obtained complementary vegetation indices at the scale of the pecan orchard (~100m-1km) from operationally available remote sensing products.

    Using this dataset, we first identify and visualize the main non-linear physical processes (including amongst others the oasis effect) that drive the actual evapotranspiration at the irrigated pecan orchard, both on seasonal and daily time scales. Subsequently, we explore to what extent the effect of the previously identified non-linear processes on the actual evapotranspiration, can be captured with two different machine learning techniques (i.e. gradient boosting decision trees and multi-layer perceptrons) that only receive input variables from a regional meteorological station network and the aforementioned remote sensing products. We trained and tested the machine learning techniques on the evapotranspiration flux measured by an eddy-covariance station located at the orchard, where the estimates provided by the physics-inspired FAO-PM method were used as a starting point for the machine learning models. We find that the machine learning techniques primarily show promise in improving the representation of the seasonal dynamics.

    How to cite: Stoffer, R., Rodríguez, J. C., van Heerwaarden, C., and Hartogensis, O.: Machine-learned actual Evapotranspiration for an Irrigated Pecan Orchard in Northwest Mexico, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4472, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4472, 2022.

    EGU22-5021 | Presentations | HS10.3

    Multi-scale temporal analysis of actual evaporation on a saline lake in the Atacama Desert 

    Felipe Lobos Roco, Oscar Hartogensis, Francisco Suarez, Ariadna Huerta Viso, Imme Benedict, Alberto de la Fuente, and Jordi Vila-Guereau de Arellano

    Evaporation is a key component of the water cycle in the endorheic basins of the Chilean Altiplano. In this study, sub-diurnal to climatological temporal changes of evaporation in a high-altitude saline lake ecosystem in the Atacama Desert are analysed. We analyse the evaporation trends over 70 years (1950-2020) at a high-spatial resolution. The method is based on the downscaling of 30-km hourly resolution ERA5 reanalysis data to 0.1-km spatial resolution data using artificial neural networks. This downscaled data is used in the Penman open water evaporation equation, modified to compensate for the energy balance non-closure and the ice cover formation on the lake during the night. Our evaporation estimates show a consistent agreement with eddy-covariance measurements and reveal that evaporation is controlled by different drivers depending on the time scale. At the sub-diurnal scale, mechanical turbulence is the primary driver. At the seasonal scale, more than 70% of the evaporation variability is explained by the radiative contribution term. At interannual scales, evaporation increased by 2.1 mm per year during the entire study period according to global temperature increases. Last, we find that yearly evaporation depends on the El Niño Southern Oscillation (ENSO), where warm and cool ENSO phases are associated with higher evaporation rates and precipitation rates, respectively. Our results show that warm ENSO phases increase evaporation rates by 15%, whereas cold phases decrease by 2%. This investigation contributes with reliable long-term evaporation estimates over a typical saline lake of an arid region and a replicable methodology for climate change assessment and sustainable water management. 

    How to cite: Lobos Roco, F., Hartogensis, O., Suarez, F., Huerta Viso, A., Benedict, I., de la Fuente, A., and Vila-Guereau de Arellano, J.: Multi-scale temporal analysis of actual evaporation on a saline lake in the Atacama Desert, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5021, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5021, 2022.

    EGU22-5178 | Presentations | HS10.3

    Assessing, scaling and comparing sap flow, eddy covariance and lysimeter measurements in the BRIDGET toolbox 

    Sibylle K. Hassler, Peter Dietrich, Ralf Kiese, Mirko Mälicke, Matthias Mauder, Jörg Meyer, Corinna Rebmann, Marcus Strobl, and Erwin Zehe

    Estimates of evapotranspiration (ET) which can be derived from in-situ measurements are often difficult to compare because they originate from different research disciplines, were collected at different scales using a range of methods, and they entail method-specific uncertainties.

    The BRIDGET toolbox – developed within the Digital Earth project – aims to support the harmonisation and scaling of diverse in-situ ET measurements by providing tools for storage, merging and visualisation of multi-scale and multi-sensor ET data. This requires an appropriate metadata description for the various measurements as well as an assessment of method-specific uncertainties.

    BRIDGET is implemented both as a standalone Python package and as part of the existing virtual research environment V-FOR-WaTer. It is organised as a toolbox consisting of several sub-sections which deal with the different in-situ measurement methods, their typical scaling approaches and most relevant analysis functions. A corresponding uncertainty framework is developed separately as a Python package and as a tool in V-FOR-WaTer. Our first focus for BRIDGET is upscaling tree-level sap flow measurements and comparing them to respective transpiration estimates from eddy covariance and lysimeters.

    How to cite: Hassler, S. K., Dietrich, P., Kiese, R., Mälicke, M., Mauder, M., Meyer, J., Rebmann, C., Strobl, M., and Zehe, E.: Assessing, scaling and comparing sap flow, eddy covariance and lysimeter measurements in the BRIDGET toolbox, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5178, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5178, 2022.

    EGU22-5302 | Presentations | HS10.3

    TransP - a novel sensor for continuous in-situ measurement of transpiration and conductivity at the leaf level 

    Bálint Jákli, Michael Goisser, Jinchen Liu, and Manuela Baumgarten

    Accurate parametrization and validation of SVAT- or evapotranspiration-models requires robust estimates of transpiration and conductivity on the level of individual leaves. Such estimates are commonly made from measurements with mobile gas exchange systems, which allow precise measurements of leaf transpiration. However, this method has some decisive practical (expensive and labor intensive, both constraining feasible number of replicates) as well as methodological limitations (destruction of the leaf boundary layer). In order to validate the FO3REST model – which estimates the phytotoxic ozone uptake of forest stands – a sensor was required that continuously measures leaf transpiration and conductivity with a high number of replicates. Within the valORTree project, which was carried out from 2019-2021 in the climate chambers of the TUMmesa ecotron facility (Jákli et al. 2021), a novel, low-cost leaf sensor ("TransP") was developed that enables continuous in-situ determination of transpiration and conductivity for the important forest tree species beech (Fagus sylvatica L.) and Norway spruce (Picea abies (L.) H. Karst.) over the entire growing season. The sensor records different temperatures in the leaf/needle environment and was calibrated against the gravimetrically determined transpiration rate (r2 = 0.74 for beech; r2 = 0.84 for spruce). Measurement inaccuracies can be compensated for by using many of the inexpensive sensors in parallel. The sensor output was validated against measurements using Li-6400 and Li-6800 gas exchange systems (Licor, USA). Differences in the outputs of the two methods could be explained by the fact that the Licor systems measures transpiration based on stomatal conductance, whereas TransP includes the in-situ boundary layer resistance. So far, the sensor has been applied under low-wind conditions in indoor applications and is currently further developed for application in the field.

    However, we clearly show that measuring transpiration of beech leaves and spruce needles with the TransP sensor provides robust data. Since TransP operation is minimally invasive and the leaf boundary layer is preserved during measurements, it is assumed that the sensor provides a realistic representation of the in-situ transpiration of individual leaves/needles. In addition, the high temporal resolution of the measurements provides the ability to accurately integrate transpiration over the entire period of the measurement.

     

    Reference

    Jákli, B., Meier, R., Gelhardt, U., Bliss, M., Grünhage, L., & Baumgarten, M. (2021). Regionalized dynamic climate series for ecological climate impact research in modern controlled environment facilities. Ecology and evolution11(23), 17364-17380.

    How to cite: Jákli, B., Goisser, M., Liu, J., and Baumgarten, M.: TransP - a novel sensor for continuous in-situ measurement of transpiration and conductivity at the leaf level, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5302, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5302, 2022.

    EGU22-5529 | Presentations | HS10.3

    Lab lysimeter disaggregated ET data for the validation of a two-source model 

    Nicola Paciolla, Chiara Corbari, and Marco Mancini

    One of the main issues with obtaining accurate Evapotranspiration (ET) measurements for heterogeneous crops is managing the partition between the contribution of bare soil / cover crop and that of the main crop. Mostly, ET estimates are obtained as an aggregate of the two components, as direct measurements of distinct Evaporation (E) and Transpiration (T) are possible only with high-accuracy and time-costly field lysimeters. Hydrological modelling can provide these kinds of estimates, with the dichotomy between single-source (one energy balance equation for the whole pixel) and two-source (one balance equation each for the vegetated and the non-vegetated pixel fraction) models approaching the problem from different perspectives. In this work, a laboratory lysimeter was employed to obtain disaggregated fluxes from a global ET value and use them to validate the partitioned estimates from a two-source version (FEST-2-EWB) of the single-source FEST-EWB distributed hydrological model, which was also included in the validation as a reference. The lysimeter was sown with grass distributed in three rows, alternated with similar rows of bare soil, with irrigation being provided to the former and not to the latter. Thermal imagery from proximal sensing observations was used to calibrate the models. Two boxes were placed on the lysimeter, one completely vegetated and the other left bare. These boxes were periodically weighted separately from the lysimeter, obtaining accurate measurements of their ET, that were then scaled back to the correspondent areas in the main lysimeter. The model runs, provided similar calibration performances, showed similar global ET values, close to those measured over the lysimeter, but diverged when looking ad transpiration alone. The two-source model offered estimates much closer to those derived from the lysimeter than the single-source model.

    How to cite: Paciolla, N., Corbari, C., and Mancini, M.: Lab lysimeter disaggregated ET data for the validation of a two-source model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5529, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5529, 2022.

    EGU22-5917 | Presentations | HS10.3

    Identification of the main meteorological factors for the trend of reference evapotranspiration in Sicily, Italy 

    Tagele Mossie Aschale, Antonino Cancelliere, David Peres, and Guido Sciuto

    Climate change has potential impacts on the hydrological cycle components, especially those strongly related to temperature, such as evapotranspiration. Assessing trends of the reference evapotranspiration (ETo) and of the related climatic factors is essential for improving water resource management especially with reference to watershed  hydrology and agricultural uses. In this research, we aim to analyze the trend of ETo and of its influencing climatic factors.  More specifically, we examine the sensitivity of ETo for different climatic factors and the contribution of climatic factors for the trend of ETo in the study area.  The study considered decadal observations of climatic data from meteorological stations in Sicily, and reference evapotranspiration was estimated through the FAO Penman-Monteith method.  The Mann-Kendall test, with verification of the Trend-free prewhitening (TFPW) method, has been applied for the trend and sensitivity analyses. The Sen’s slope has also been used to examine the magnitude of the trend. Results, relative to a pilot gauging station in Piazza Armerina, indicate that the ETo has decreasing trend only in November with a decrease of 0.790 mm per year. The solar radiation (November and Autumn) and rainfall (Autumn) showed decreasing trends. While other climatic factors (minimum temperature, maximum temperature, mean temperature, wind speed and relative humidity) showed increasing trend both monthly and seasonally in the study area. Furthermore, the sensitive analysis shows that ETo is mostly sensitive to relative humidity and least sensitive to wind speed in the study area. Similarly relative humidity contributes the most to the trend of ETo (44.59% decreasing contribution), while wind speed has the least contribution (0.9% increasing contribution) in the study area.  These results can find application for irrigation scheduling and water related development project in the study area.

    How to cite: Aschale, T. M., Cancelliere, A., Peres, D., and Sciuto, G.: Identification of the main meteorological factors for the trend of reference evapotranspiration in Sicily, Italy, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5917, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5917, 2022.

    Evapotranspiration (ET) from wetlands is often considered to occur at a potential rate. However, depending on the structural and physiological traits of the dominating plant species, actual ET can deviate substantially from potential ET. Here we present a case study from a restored wetland in north-western Germany which is dominated by moor grass (Molinia caerulea). ET was measured over three years by means of the Bowen Ratio method, leaf transpiration and leaf resistance of moor grass were measured with a porometer, and both green and total leaf area index were measured optically and manually.

    Whilst actual and potential ET were practically similar during the period from late summer to the end of winter, they differed significantly from the beginning of spring to early summer and on hot summer days. Two likely reasons for this marked seasonality could be identified. (1) Molinia leaves responded very sensitively to the vapour pressure deficit of the air, independent of the unlimited water supply to its roots. (2) A thick mat of dead leaves covered the surface in spring before and while the new leaves emerged and acted as an efficient protection cover against evaporation.

    The SVAT model ‘AMBAV’ was developed by the German Meteorological Service and is operationally used in agrometeorological applications. Based on the Bowen Ratio and in-situ plant physiological data, it was newly parameterised for the investigated type of wetland. If run with weather data from a nearby station, AMBAV could verify the observed seasonal pattern of actual ET from the moor grass dominated wetland. The results demonstrate that the present vegetation reduces wetland ET and thus contributes to the maintenance of a high water table in the restored wetland.

    How to cite: Herbst, M., Matuschek, D., and Falge, E.: Assessing the influence of the vegetation on the evapotranspiration from a wetland – a case study from northwest Germany based on in-situ measurements at different scales, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7002, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7002, 2022.

    EGU22-7287 | Presentations | HS10.3

    Partitioning of evapotranspiration based on flux variance similarity theory for an urban forest land 

    Han Li, Jinhui Jeanne Huang, Han Chen, Ziqi Zhou, and Yizhao Wei

    Partitioning of evapotranspiration(ET) into its components (ET; the sum of vegetation transpiration [T] and soil evaporation [E])from urban forest land is important for guiding precise irrigation decisions in urban areas and assessing the impact of urbanization on the urban hydrological cycle. So far, the variability of T/ET in natural ecosystems has been extensively discussed, few studies have examined under urban. In this study, high frequency (10 Hz) time series eddy covariance observations collected from January 2020 to December 2021 in an urban forest land located in Tianjin, China. We observed changes in water vapor and carbon dioxide fluxes and the flux variance similarity (FVS) theory based on five water use efficiency(WUE) algorithms was applied to partition ET into E and T. We also combined with oxygen and hydrogen isotopes to verifies the partition results. The results indicated that the partitioning was partially consistent with the isotope-based approach. The growing season average T/ET ranges from 0.68 to 0.96, which can be described well as a function of leaf area index (LAI). Finally, we further discussed the characteristics, uncertainties and applicability of five WUE algorithms in urban forest land.

    How to cite: Li, H., Huang, J. J., Chen, H., Zhou, Z., and Wei, Y.: Partitioning of evapotranspiration based on flux variance similarity theory for an urban forest land, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7287, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7287, 2022.

    EGU22-7367 | Presentations | HS10.3

    A critical evaluation of simple, flexible, and scalable models of daily transpiration in forested biomes 

    Ryan M. Bright, Diego G. Miralles, Rafael Poyatos, and Stephanie Eisner

    Transpiration (T) makes up the bulk of total evaporation over vegetated land yet remains challenging to predict at landscape-to-global scale.  Model improvements often occur at the expense of model parsimony and an increased dependence on input data that is difficult to acquire at large scale.  T models intended for these scales should ideally be easily scalable using routine meteorological and/or remote sensing data as input.  

    Here, we critically evaluate several “big leaf”-type models ranging in their complexity to simulate daily T in a variety of forest biomes.  All these models use input data streams furnished by readily available global reanalysis or satellite-based remote sensing products.   We develop and evaluate a novel moisture stress method based on the Antecedent Precipitation Index (API) serving as proxy for soil moisture supply, motivated by the challenge of acquiring reliable soil moisture and other soil physical property data at large spatial and temporal scales.

    We rely on independent estimates of T derived from co-located sap flow and eddy-covariance measurement systems.  The triple collocation technique is employed to quantify error metrics when treating modeled T as a third, independent measurement.

    Preliminary results suggests that models that explicitly account for the aerodynamic coupling between canopy surfaces and the atmosphere generally perform better than those that do not, and that the API-based approach to modeling constraints related to soil moisture stress appears as a valid alternative when soil moisture information is unavailable.  

    How to cite: Bright, R. M., Miralles, D. G., Poyatos, R., and Eisner, S.: A critical evaluation of simple, flexible, and scalable models of daily transpiration in forested biomes, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7367, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7367, 2022.

    EGU22-7672 | Presentations | HS10.3

    Evapotranspiration in urban stormwater planter boxes: A study of eight lysimeters under temperate climate 

    Ahmeda Assann Ouédraogo, Emmanuel Berthier, and Marie-Christine Gromaire

    Sustainable urban drainage systems aim to promote the infiltration and the evapotranspiration (ET) processes rather than the runoff. In this study, the ET in 1 m3 pilot stormwater planters were studied from eight lysimeters monitored for three years in a dense urban environment in Paris (France). In each lysimeter, a piezometer, four weighing cells and a tipping bucket are used to measure respectively the water level in the internal water storage (IWS), the mass change of the whole lysimeter and the underdrain flow. Meteorological data, precipitation and water level are also collected respectively from the weather station, the rain gauge and the pan evaporimeter installed next to the lysimeters.

    Daily ET was calculated for each lysimeter based on a mass balance approach. The uncertainties related to the daily ET estimates were assessed at ± 0.42 to 0.58 mm depending to the lysimeter and according to the uncertainty propagation law. Results showed that for these lysimeters, with an impluvium equal to 4 times the vegetated surface, ET is the major term in water budget (57 to 90% of the cumulated water inputs) with maximum daily values reaching 8 mm/d. In addition, the observations showed that the major determinants of ET are the existence or not of an internal water storage (IWS) and the atmospheric factors (global radiation, air temperature and in a minor extent air humidity). The type of vegetation is a secondary determinant, with little difference between the herbaceous and the shrub configurations, maximum ET for spontaneous vegetation and minimal values when the vegetation was regularly removed. Shading of lysimeters by surroundings buildings is also an important factor and leads to lower values. Finally, ET with an IWS is higher than reference values tested (evaporimeter, FAO-56, and local Météo-France equations), except for regional Météo-France formula which overestimates ET of lysimeters and especially in summer. For future studies, it is expected to include some aspects in the experiments for explicitly addressing shading effects and vegetation evolution.

    How to cite: Ouédraogo, A. A., Berthier, E., and Gromaire, M.-C.: Evapotranspiration in urban stormwater planter boxes: A study of eight lysimeters under temperate climate, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7672, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7672, 2022.

    EGU22-8231 | Presentations | HS10.3

    Disentangling the main sources of evapotranspiration in a vineyard 

    Flavio Bastos Campos, Leonardo Montagnani, Fadwa Benyahia, Torben Oliver Callesen, Carina Veronica González, Massimo Tagliavini, and Damiano Zanotelli

    Evapotranspiration (ET) is a complex phenomenon that responds to soil water availability, plant development, weather variations and climate change in many magnitudes, from leaf to ecosystem scale. Disentangling the different sources contributing to the total ET at the ecosystem level could contribute to a better understanding of the single process and the overall ET dynamics.

    To tackle this goal, we established an Eddy Covariance station in a vineyard in Caldaro, South Tyrol, Italy, where cv. Chardonnay and cv. Sauvignon blanc are cultivated. The vineyard soil is covered by grasses and drip irrigation is available. We attempted to partition the total evapotranspiration (ETec) data obtained into the vines transpiration (Tv), the vines’ canopy evaporation (Ev) and the understory evapotranspiration (ETu), the latter comprising the soil evaporation and the transpiration of the ground-level vegetation. By this Ecophysiological Partitioning Approach (EPA) the ecosystem ETEPA is the sum of Tv, Ev and ETu.

    Tv was estimated upscaling the sap flow rate measured via Sap Flow sensors (SFM1, ICT International,  Armidale, NSW, Australia; 3 sensors, 1 sensor per plant). ETu was assessed with 3 transparent soil-ground-flux-chambers and a multiplexer (Li-8100 Licor Biosciences, Lincoln, NE, USA) in 6 campaigns of 72 hours each, with the chambers being moved to a new position every 24 hours to cover time and spatial variability. Ev was assessed by means of three leaf wetness sensors placed within grapevine canopy. All the measurements were set at 30-minutes intervals, to match the frequency of ETec.

    Preliminary results of this ongoing project, which forsees two years of field measurements, showed that ETec amounted to 545 mm during the growing season 2021, with values ranging from 0.33 to 4.83 mm d-1. ETec correlated well with net radiation and with ETu. All sap flow sensors showed a similar trend across the season, consistent with ETec, but differed among each other in terms of flow quantities, likely due to wood specificities of each sampled grapevine which will require specific on-site calibrations.

    Ev component, rarely considered in ET partitioning studies, was strongly dependent on precipitation pattern and we hypothesize it can offer a gain of more than 5% in explaining the ET dynamics in the experimental vineyard, wether compared to removing wet canopy moments from the dataset.  

    Once the calibration of the soil-ground-flux-chambers system and the installed sap-flow sensor be improved, in-situ measurements of components of ETEPA will contribute to a computational partitioning approach which improves the comprehension of the dynamics of the ecosystem ET sources under climate change.

    How to cite: Bastos Campos, F., Montagnani, L., Benyahia, F., Oliver Callesen, T., González, C. V., Tagliavini, M., and Zanotelli, D.: Disentangling the main sources of evapotranspiration in a vineyard, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8231, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8231, 2022.

    EGU22-10201 | Presentations | HS10.3

    Experimental and Numerical Investigation of Flux Partitioning Methods for Water Vapor and Carbon Dioxide 

    Elie Bou-Zeid, Einara Zahn, Khaled Ghannam, Marcelo Chamecki, Gabriel Katul, Christoph Thomas, and William Kustas

    The partitioning of ecosystem evapotranspiration and carbon dioxide fluxes into their plant and ground components is a critical research priority to better understand the water cycle and ecosystem function. Despite advances in different measurement techniques and partitioning models in the last decades, much is still unknown regarding the importance of different components of H2O and CO2 fluxes in ecosystems. In this work, we compare three partitioning methods that are based on analysis of conventional high frequency eddy-covariance (EC) data: the flux variance similarity method, the modified relaxed eddy accumulation methods, and the conditional eddy covariance method. First, we test these methods using fields experimental data, comparing them to other reference measurements for the components fluxes (gas chambers and leaf levels measurements). Subsequently, we develop a novel approach for simulating these fluxes in large eddy simulations and apply it to further probe the performance, assumptions, and relative skill of the three methods. The findings allow us to recommend partitioning best practices for their implementation, and to develop methods for the joint analyses of the various approaches.

    How to cite: Bou-Zeid, E., Zahn, E., Ghannam, K., Chamecki, M., Katul, G., Thomas, C., and Kustas, W.: Experimental and Numerical Investigation of Flux Partitioning Methods for Water Vapor and Carbon Dioxide, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10201, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10201, 2022.

    Peru and Chile occupy second place in South America in area devoted to olive cultivation. Although small by Mediterranean standards, the 21,000 ha in each country represent a significant recent expansion of olive cultivation, 500 years after its introduction from Europe. The main climatic characteristic of olive cultivation in Peru is the coastal desert environment with moderate temperatures (12-28 oC), almost nil precipitation and high atmospheric water content in the winter season. There is still insufficient information about olive physiology and water management under these climatic conditions. This report is part of a long-term study of water and carbon fluxes in a drip-irrigated olive grove in sandy soil, located in the Pisco province in Peru (13°45'03.25" S, 76°09'36.77" W at 74 m elevation). Due to the absence of precipitation during the main growing season, plants depend on the local aquifer and drip irrigation for growth and yields. We installed an eddy covariance system in September of 2019 in a 9 m tower over a 5 m canopy height. The canopy covered 60% of the surface, the rest being sandy soil with very limited grass cover. The flux footprint of the system covered 3 ha for 80% of the information gathered. Peak average hourly water flux from the grove to the atmosphere in the summer season took place at 1 pm, with values of 1.8 m3 ha-1 h-1.  Average daily fluxes ranged from 5 m3 ha-1 day-1 in August (winter) to 20 m3 ha-1 day-1 in February (summer). EddyPro-calculated ET values are essentially similar and represent 41% of ETo as calculated by the Penman-Monteith equation and 58.6% using a crop coefficient correction. Drip irrigation was set at 63 m3 ha-1 day-1 during the growing season (October through April) and reduced to half that amount in the winter. Optimization of water usage in relation to productivity has been pursued by monitoring photosynthetic efficiency and transpiration with an Li 6800 system in sun and shade leaves of the canopy along with use of Ekomatik digital dendrometer monitoring as a proxy for sap flow.

    How to cite: Cosio, E., Salinas, N., Tito, R., Nina, A., and Cruz, R.: Evapotranspiration and photosynthetic parameters determined by eddy covariance and infrared photosynthesis analyzers in a drip-irrigated olive grove on western coastal South America, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10648, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10648, 2022.

    EGU22-11785 | Presentations | HS10.3

    Emipirical estimates of evapotranspiration from eddy covariance: challenges and opportunities 

    Jacob A. Nelson, Sophia Walther, Fabian Gans, Basil Kraft, Ulrich Weber, Weijie Zhang, and Martin Jung

    Global freshwater is becoming an increasingly valuable resource, both due to increased human use as well as due to ecological importance in a changing climate. Understanding the hydrological cycles which govern water availability requires broad scale estimates of terrestrial evaporation, or evapotranspiration, which incorporate the complex signals of plant water use via transpiration. In this regard, evapotranspiration estimated from eddy covariance has proven a valuable resource in understanding ecosystem scale water fluxes at sites around the world, and recent advances in methods for directly estimating transpiration from eddy covariance data provide the opportunity to understand the influence plants have on water cycles. However, linking these ecosystem scale estimates to global scale processes requires a model to act as an intermediary, such as the empirical models used in the FLUXCOM products which train machine learning models on eddy covariance data linked with remote sensing data.

    Here we look at the next generation of global terrestrial water flux estimates from FLUXCOM, including both the total evapotranspiration and the individual components of transpiration and abiotic evaporation. We benchmark these new estimates against previous FLUXCOM products, as well as compare to the state-of-the-art evapotranspiration estimates from process based models and remote sensing products. The high spatial and temporal scale allows for a close look at how the transpiration to evapotranspiration ratio varies both in space and time. We also outline estimate uncertainties from potential measurement biases to feature selection, and discuss the next steps for high quality empirical water flux estimates.

    How to cite: Nelson, J. A., Walther, S., Gans, F., Kraft, B., Weber, U., Zhang, W., and Jung, M.: Emipirical estimates of evapotranspiration from eddy covariance: challenges and opportunities, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11785, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11785, 2022.

    EGU22-12488 | Presentations | HS10.3

    Determining transpiration rates from beech and spruce trees with measurements of sapflow, leaf water potential and stomatal conductance 

    Stefano Martinetti, Marius Floriancic, Peter Molnar, and Simone Fatichi

    Beech and spruce trees are dominant species in prealpine forests. Thus, plant-specific physiological traits of beech and spruce are key to determine evapotranspiration fluxes from these forests. During dry periods trees adapt to the decreased soil water availability, however these adaptation strategies are not yet well determined by observation data. Adaptations to water limitations are different between species and if not accounted for, may lead to an overestimation of evapotranspiration fluxes. These unknowns add additional uncertainty to the simulation of transpiration patterns with ecohydrological models under water limited conditions. Here we present a comparison of field methods to measure (directly and indirectly) the transpiration process for the purpose of supporting mechanistic ecohydrological modelling. At our mixed beech and spruce forest field site at Waldlabor Zurich we equipped multiple trees with sapflow sensors (hourly measurements) and frequently measured stomatal conductance and leaf water potential (weekly to twice a week) during the 2021 growing season. Along with these plant-physiological measurements, we recorded timeseries of meteorological variables and soil water content and matric potential in different depths (10, 20, 40 and 80cm).

    Sapflow measurements suggest that transpiration rates are tightly linked to the magnitude of solar radiation and vapor pressure deficit. Summer transpiration rates were higher in beech trees compared to spruce trees. Most of the early summer of the 2021 growing season was relatively wet, but the months August and September had considerably lower precipitation than the long-term average. This period with low precipitation during August and September led to decreasing soil water content and matric potential, which caused leaf water potentials to decrease accordingly. On the contrary, stomatal conductance remained relatively constant for beech and even increased for spruce, suggesting that under the encountered conditions, stomatal control is not depending directly on leaf water potential. Sapflow rates gradually decreased as the growing season proceeded, but it remains unclear to what degree this decrease was due to phenology, meteorological conditions and/or limited water availability. We compared our measurements to the simulations of an existing mechanistic ecohydrological model (Tethys-Chloris) to test the performance on the observed diurnal dynamics. The comparisons between observed and simulated transpiration rates showed that uncertainties are larger when water availability is limited in the dry periods of August and September.

    Our work provides insight into the processes at the soil-plant-atmosphere continuum by the combination of highly resolved measurements and an established mechanistic ecohydrological model. Results highlight how well different measurements of transpiration proxies agree with each other, how suitable they are to assess the actual transpiration rates, and which conditions have larger simulation uncertainties in ecohydrological models and thus need to be better constrained by field observations.

    How to cite: Martinetti, S., Floriancic, M., Molnar, P., and Fatichi, S.: Determining transpiration rates from beech and spruce trees with measurements of sapflow, leaf water potential and stomatal conductance, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12488, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12488, 2022.

    EGU22-339 | Presentations | HS10.5

    Urban Moisture (Re)cycling: quantifying canopy effects using in-situ water stable isotope monitoring 

    Ann-Marie Ring, Dörthe Tetzlaff, Birgit Kleinschmit, and Chris Soulsby

    Urban green spaces are valuable infrastructure in the urban environment because they facilitate natural stormwater management through rainwater retention, decelerated runoff and enhanced evapotranspiration which can also mitigate heat stress. Investigating the complex interactions of water flux partitioning of incoming precipitation into “green” (i.e. evaporation and transpiration) and “blue” (surface runoff and groundwater recharge) water fluxes through urban vegetation is crucial to understand what types of landcover might best balance water re-distribution for a particular geographical setting and provide a cooling effect whilst not compromising groundwater recharge.

    Stable water isotopes are very useful tools to investigate these complex processes. So far, studies investigating high-resolution ecohydrological process dynamics at the urban soil-plant-atmosphere interface, e.g. canopy evaporation, with stable isotopes are rare. Here, we conducted novel field experiments using direct in-situ monitoring of the isotope composition of evaporated atmospheric moisture at different heights above the soil surface, plant xylem and soil water in different types of urban greenspaces in Berlin, Germany. Results show a more homogenous spatio-temporal distribution of water vapour signals within the elevation profile of urban trees compared to grasslands, reflecting continuous interplay of interception evaporation, transpiration and soil evaporation. Additionally, grasslands showed a lower impact on the isotopic composition of atmospheric water vapor, mainly reflecting higher evaporative losses close to the ground surface. Complex patterns of precipitation fractionation under contrasting urban vegetation canopies were also revealed. Topsoil moisture rates strongly depended on the soil type and less on the above vegetation type.

    The collected data on the redistribution of urban water in different types of green spaces is very helpful for the development of isotope aided ecohydrological models. This knowledge can further support valuable decision-making for sustainable urban development across scales.

    How to cite: Ring, A.-M., Tetzlaff, D., Kleinschmit, B., and Soulsby, C.: Urban Moisture (Re)cycling: quantifying canopy effects using in-situ water stable isotope monitoring, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-339, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-339, 2022.

    EGU22-374 | Presentations | HS10.5

    Stable water isotopes reveal the effects of land use on ecohydrological partitioning in a drought-sensitive mixed land-use catchment 

    Jessica Landgraf, Dörthe Tetzlaff, Maren Dubbert, and Chris Soulsby

    Ecohydrological fluxes in the critical zone are characterised by complex interactions between soils, plants, and the atmosphere. Vegetation and land use therefore play a crucial role in forming the interface between the soil and atmosphere, and spatial variation in land management within a catchment can have a dominant influence on water partitioning. Consequently, in drought sensitive environments there is a need for careful assessment of the water use of different land use types, likely resilience to future climate change and implications for groundwater recharge and runoff.

    We monitored isotopes in precipitation, soil water and groundwater over the growing season of 2021 (March – October) under 8 plots with contrasting land cover in the drought-sensitive Demnitzer Millcreek Catchment (DMC) in NE Germany. These encompassed traditional arable crops, cropping schemes with water conservation measures (e.g. syntropic crops and agroforestry), grasslands and contrasting forests. The isotope monitoring was complemented with a flux tower, forest sap flow monitoring, pasture lysimetry and soil moisture measurements to provide hydroclimatic and ecohydrological context.

    The growing season of 2021 being relatively wet compared to the drought years of 2018-20. Nevertheless, ET was high and soil moisture declined from May onward with only a large (60mm) event in June substantially replenishing the soil water storage before more general re-wetting in autumn. Soil moisture availability was generally highest under grassland and syntropic crops and lowest under forests. In general, precipitation isotopic composition varied during the summer, and was largely tracked by soil water isotopes, though at all sites variations were increasingly damped and lagged with depth. Soil water isotopes generally plotted close to the local meteoric water line, with limited effects of soil evaporation showing differences in interception and transpiration mainly explained the differences in soil moisture between sites. Estimates of soil water ages showed that the upper soils of arable sites had the greatest variability in isotopic composition and most rapid turnover of water, whilst soil water under trees had more limited isotopic variability, was much older and showed low levels of groundwater recharge.

    Our study illustrated the advantage of monitoring the spatial variability of natural stable water isotope abundance in soil-vegetation systems to understand heterogeneity in water partitioning. Further, conservation measures like syntropic agriculture were tentatively shown to be a useful adaptation against dryer climatic conditions as this site was able to retain the highest proportion of precipitation in the soil for crop growth. However, monitoring over multiple growing seasons with contrasting hydroclimatic conditions is needed for a fuller assessment.

    How to cite: Landgraf, J., Tetzlaff, D., Dubbert, M., and Soulsby, C.: Stable water isotopes reveal the effects of land use on ecohydrological partitioning in a drought-sensitive mixed land-use catchment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-374, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-374, 2022.

    EGU22-1127 | Presentations | HS10.5

    Investigating root water uptake dynamics of a grassland species under varying hydro-climatic conditions with non-destructive isotopic monitoring 

    Paulina Alejandra Deseano Diaz, Dagmar van Dusschoten, Angelika Kübert, Nicolas Brüggemann, Mathieu Javaux, Steffen Merz, Jan Vanderborght, Harry Vereecken, Maren Dubbert, and Youri Rothfuss

    Traditional destructive plant and soil water isotopic monitoring has provided important insights into root water uptake changes in drought and evapotranspiration partitioning across scales. Recently, non-destructive isotopic monitoring coupled with laser-based spectroscopy allow a better understanding of these and other questions with a higher spatial and temporal resolution. We investigated the changes in root water uptake profiles and eco-physiological characteristics (e.g. stomatal conductance, leaf water potential) of the grassland species Centaurea jacea under varying environmental conditions (i.e. atmospheric demand, soil water availability) with a labeling experiment in fully-controlled laboratory conditions. We measured non-destructively the isotopic composition of soil water and of plant transpiration. With these measurements, daily root water uptake profiles were obtained using a multi-source mixing model embedded in a Bayesian statistical framework. We analyzed the daily changes of these profiles together with changes in environmental conditions and plant physiology-related variables to discover potential adaptation strategies of C. jacea to water scarcity. Even in a dry soil (~ 10% soil water content), the studied grassland species was able to sustain high transpiration rates. This was accompanied by a very negative leaf water potential (~-3 MPa). Root water uptake profiles in both dry and wet conditions were very similar: root water uptake was highest in the soil layer 0-15 cm (up to 87%) and second highest (up to 40%) in the soil layer 45-60 cm. Before soil water content dropped below 12%, transpiration rate was mainly controlled by vapor pressure deficit. After this, a reduction of canopy conductance restricted gas leaf exchange. Instantaneous water use efficiency dropped when the soil was very dry, but intrinsic water use efficiency was maintained. Our comprehensive data set of plant-related and environmental variables allowed us to investigate at a 1-cm and daily scales the plant’s response to varying hydro-climatic conditions.

    How to cite: Deseano Diaz, P. A., van Dusschoten, D., Kübert, A., Brüggemann, N., Javaux, M., Merz, S., Vanderborght, J., Vereecken, H., Dubbert, M., and Rothfuss, Y.: Investigating root water uptake dynamics of a grassland species under varying hydro-climatic conditions with non-destructive isotopic monitoring, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1127, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1127, 2022.

    EGU22-1182 | Presentations | HS10.5 | Highlight

    What stable water isotopes may tell us about belowground processes 

    Katrin Meusburger, Fabian Bernhard, and Arthur Gessler

    Processes in the rooting zone and root water uptake decisively affect ecosystem resilience to stressors such as drought or deposition of air pollutants. However, the rooting zone is literally a black box. Water stable isotopes may shed light on some parts of this black box and tell us about water residence times, mixing of different water pools, plant water sources, preferential flow, soil evaporation, and many more. While this flexibility to use stable water isotopes is advantageous, it also entails many degrees of freedom. The additional collinearity of the hydrogen and oxygen isotopes leads to a largely underdetermined problem to solve. Bayesian mixing models help quantify the resulting uncertainty and add some constraints to the system by prior knowledge. Particularly in the case of disentangling plant water sources, additional data such as soil water content, matric potential or sap flow are needed since i) the isotope gradient smoothes with soil depth and ii) isotope-derived relative changes in root water uptake cannot be translated to absolute ones. Framing this ancillary data in a physically based water balance model may refine our predictions and help to trace water and related nutrient fluxes through the belowground. This contribution will summarize some of the experience gained during an in-situ monitoring study conducted in the drought summer of 2018 and a one-year sampling campaign at ten long-term ecosystem monitoring sites across Switzerland.

    How to cite: Meusburger, K., Bernhard, F., and Gessler, A.: What stable water isotopes may tell us about belowground processes, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1182, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1182, 2022.

    EGU22-2594 | Presentations | HS10.5

    On uncertainties in the plant source water isotopic composition extracted with cryogenic vacuum distillation 

    Haoyu Diao, Philipp Schuler, Gregory Goldsmith, Matthias Saurer, and Marco Lehmann

    Recent studies challenge the use of plant water from cryogenic vacuum distillation (CVD) extraction in accurately representing the hydrogen and oxygen isotopic composition (δ2H and δ18O) of plant source water. This is hypothesized to be because the δ2H in extracted water depends on tissue relative water content (RWC), which might be explained by the exchange of H-atoms between water and organic material. Secondary hypotheses focus on extraction artefacts related to evaporation and sublimation, but clear evidence is lacking. Here, we hypothesized that the observed δ2H and δ18O offsets (Δ2H and Δ18O) are influenced by (i) an H-exchange effect, (ii) tissue water amount or RWC and (iii) evaporation and sublimation enrichments.
    The hypotheses were systematically tested by three corresponding experiments. Firstly, we added a range of strongly depleted reference water (δ2H: ca. -460‰; δ18O: ca. -170‰; 50–1200 μl) to organic materials (with and without exchangeable H) of constant weight (200 mg), followed by a 24 h incubation. In addition, the same range of pure reference water and tap water without any material were used as controls. Secondly, we incubated dry stem segments (Larix decidua) of different sizes in excess of reference water for 24 hours, then they were took out for extracting known water contents from samples with known RWC. Accordingly, fresh twig segments from the same species were prepared for extracting water with natural abundance. Thirdly, a range of different amounts of reference water (50–1200 μl) was added directly into the water collection tubes of the CVD extraction system. In addition, 2 ml glass vials containing the same range of reference water amounts were incubated in a climate chamber at 25 °C and 50 % relative humidity with lids open for 2 hours. All the samples, except the water in the glass vials, were extracted using a standard CVD extraction method for 2 hours. 
    We found that both Δ2H and Δ18O values were not related to changes in RWC. In contrast, we observed an inversely proportional relationships with water amount, i.e., the lower the water amount, the higher the Δ2H and Δ18O. For Δ2H, the pattern was more pronounced for materials with exchangeable H, which reached 150‰ at the lowest water amount and decreased to -20‰ with increasing water amounts when the depleted reference water was used. However, the pattern was much less pronounced for the samples with natural isotopic abundance, indicating that the magnitude of the pattern is probably dependent on isotope ratios of plant water and water vapour in the laboratory. The evaporation and sublimation tests both showed that the pattern was partly caused by an increasing isotopic enrichment with decreasing water amount.
    In conclusion, we identified a significant artefact of CVD when water is present in small amounts, particularly when δ2H and δ18O of the water was below natural isotope abundances. We therefore recommend extracting > 600 μl of water. Moreover, we provide first evidence of a significant H-exchange effect, suggesting that using hydrogen isotopes for estimating plant source water will remain challenging in future.

    How to cite: Diao, H., Schuler, P., Goldsmith, G., Saurer, M., and Lehmann, M.: On uncertainties in the plant source water isotopic composition extracted with cryogenic vacuum distillation, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2594, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2594, 2022.

    EGU22-3448 | Presentations | HS10.5

    Do hillslope position and rootstock matter in root water uptake by grapevines? A case study in a Tuscany vineyard, Italy 

    Daniele Penna, Paolo Benettin, Andrea Dani, Francesca Sofia Manca di Villahermosa, Matteo Verdone, Giulia Pastacaldi, Carlo Andreotti, and Massimo Tagliavini

    Understanding water availability and sources for crop transpiration is essential for sustainable management of water resources in agriculture, especially under changing climatic conditions. Identifying the origin of water accessed by crops is particularly critical in typical rain-fed agroecosystems, such as vineyards in Mediterranean regions where viticulture is one of the mainstays of the local economy.

    As far as we know, no study so far has attempted to analyse root water uptake dynamics on hilly vineyards where the hillslope topography plays a role on water redistribution and availability for grapevine uptake. For this reason, we instrumented two plots within a vineyard in the famous Chianti wine region in Tuscany, Italy. The vineyard is cultivated with 11-year-old grapevines either on 1103 Paulsen or 420A rootstocks, which are typically characterized by a deeper and shallower rooting system, respectively. We aimed to test the hypothesis that i) grapevines located at the hillslope bottom took up water from shallower soil layers compared to grapevines located at the hillslope top due to lateral downslope redistribution of infiltrated rainwater; and that ii) grapevines with rootstock 1103 Paulsen took up water from deeper soil layers compared to the grapevines with rootstock 420A.

    We monitored precipitation and temperature as well as soil moisture at 30 and 60 cm depth at two hillslope locations (top and bottom, 140 and 115 m asl, respectively) from April to October 2021. We collected samples for isotopic analysis from rainfall, soil at 30 and 60 cm, shoots and leaves from two adjacent grapevines for each rootstock at the two hillslope locations. Additional water samples were taken through the application of sealed plastic bags around some top branches and collection of water that had transpired and condensed on the bag walls. Water from soil samples, leaves and shoots was extracted though cryogenic vacuum distillation. The isotopic composition was determined through laser spectroscopy or, for organically-contaminated samples, mass spectrometry.

    Preliminary results show that soil moisture was higher at the hillslope bottom than at the top, and higher at 60 than 30 cm depth. The isotopic composition of soil water was statistically different at the two depths with more enriched values in the shallower layer, as expected in Mediterranean climates; however, no statistical difference was observed between soil water at the two hillslope locations. The isotopic composition of plant water between the two locations was statistically different for bag (transpired) water and leaf water (although the latter was highly fractionated), but not for shoot water, allowing us only to partially accept hypothesis i). However, the isotopic composition of bag, leaf, and shoot water was always similar for 1103 Paulsen and 420A grafted plants, suggesting that grapevines with different rootstock took up soil water from the same depth in the study vineyard, and leading us to reject hypothesis ii).

    These results contribute to better understand water uptake sources in economically-valuable agroecosystems such as vineyards.

    How to cite: Penna, D., Benettin, P., Dani, A., Manca di Villahermosa, F. S., Verdone, M., Pastacaldi, G., Andreotti, C., and Tagliavini, M.: Do hillslope position and rootstock matter in root water uptake by grapevines? A case study in a Tuscany vineyard, Italy, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3448, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3448, 2022.

    EGU22-4249 | Presentations | HS10.5

    New approaches to sap extraction from trees and comparison with conventional methods: new avenues for H and O stable isotopes ecohydrology 

    Alessandro Montemagno, Christophe Hissler, Victor Bense, Adriaan J. Teuling, and Laurent Pfister

    Since the `60s, stable isotopes of hydrogen and oxygen have proven to be excellent tracers for water flows in different systems. Nowadays, such tracers still represent a formidable resource for eco-hydrologists who study water spatio-temporal dynamics and transit time distributions in the Critical Zone (CZ). Unfortunately, many issues remain unsolved, especially when looking at the regolith-trees continuum in which a complex mixture of isotopic fractionation processes may occur (evaporation, transpiration, adsorption on soil clays and oxides, microorganism's activity, mixing of water of different ages). Moreover, the lack of standard protocols for sampling and analysis represents a limitation when determining which water source(s) trees uptake. Indeed, by using sap cryogenically extracted from tree cores (recognized as the standard protocol), several studies have indicated discrepancies between the isotopic signatures of xylem sap extracted from plants and the potential water source(s).

    In this context, we propose to look at the water which flowing in the xylem vessels, by directly sampling sap from tree roots and branches. It is our hypothesis that root water would represent a more reliable fraction to identify the source(s) of water that trees absorbed from the different regolith compartments. Additionally, we also aim to observe how O and H isotopic composition of sap is evolving from the roots to the leaves. Inside this pathway, the absorbed water would be impacted by various processes, such as evaporation from the bark and mixing with other water pools (e.g. storage water), which would lead to a change in the isotopic composition of the sap which will be observed in the one extracted from the branches.

    To reach our objectives, we sampled water from diverse CZ compartments at three European beech (Fagus sylvatica L.) stands in the Weierbach Experimental Catchment (Hissler et al. 2021). These stands are located along a catena from the highest elevation (plateau) to the stream (riparian zone). Rainfall, throughfall, soil solutions at 20, 40 and 60 cm depth, groundwater and streamwater were collected. For beech sap sampling, we developed and applied an in-situ extraction using suction under vacuum. This method allowed us to collect sap from roots, stems and branches, separately. At the same time, tree cores from the trunks were collected and stored at -20 °C before cryogenically extracting their water content under vacuum.

    When reported in a δ2H vs. δ18O diagram, our results clearly illustrate that beech sap samples extracted with this techniques plot in a different area than the water extracted using cryogenic extraction. The root sap samples fall on the Local Meteoric Water Line (LMWL) in the same field as specific water sources (soil solutions, groundwater, streamwater). Moreover, the sap samples collected from branches are also located on the LMWL but presented a significant enrichment in 18O and 2H in comparison to the root sap samples. These new results allow us to calculate more accurately the contribution of the regolith water pools to the tree uptake and to discuss the origin of the fractionation that happened for both O and H isotopes in the tree water pathway.

    How to cite: Montemagno, A., Hissler, C., Bense, V., Teuling, A. J., and Pfister, L.: New approaches to sap extraction from trees and comparison with conventional methods: new avenues for H and O stable isotopes ecohydrology, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4249, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4249, 2022.

    EGU22-5313 | Presentations | HS10.5

    Contrasting tree water use strategies along hillslopes in forested catchments in Luxembourg and Italy 

    Ginevra Fabiani, Julian Klaus, Remy Schoppach, and Daniele Penna

    Topography plays a major role in mediating subsurface water redistribution and ultimately water availability for tree transpiration. Trees located in valley bottoms commonly benefit from greater accessibility to groundwater and wetter soil from lateral redistribution of water compared to trees growing upslopes. However, water availability and movement in the subsurface may differ according to subsurface properties (permeability, soil texture, geology) and climatic regimes. The spatially and seasonally variable water accessibility along a hillslope affects species composition, stand structure, and biomass productivity resulting in areas which will be more likely impacted by potential water shortages. So far, the understanding of how hydrological processes occurring at the hillslope scale affect tree water use is still limited, rising the need of measurements at hillslope-level to allow deeper comprehension of forest dynamic and survival.

    Here, we set up a comparative study on a gentle and very steep forested hillslope located in the Weierbach catchment (Luxembourg) and the Re della Pietra catchment (Italy), respectively. We aimed at testing if different climatic and hydrological conditions, i.e., meteorological forcing, groundwater depth, soil moisture, and water redistribution affect water use patterns of beech trees (Fagus sylvatica L.) along hillslopes.

    We monitored soil moisture, groundwater level, sap velocity, and hydro-meteorological variables and determined the isotopic composition of precipitation, soil water, groundwater, and xylem water to estimate tree water sources. The combination of these measurements allows us to link the transpiration response of trees to water availability along the two different hillslopes.We carried out biweekly field campaigns during the growing season 2019 and 2020 in Weierbach catchment and throughout 2021 in Re della Pietra catchment to sample xylem water, soil water at different depths, groundwater, stream water, and precipitation.

    Trees in the Weierbach catchment rely on water stored in the unsaturated zone regardless of the hillslope position and the hydrologic conditions of the season. On the contrary, preliminary results from Re della Pietra suggest position-specific water use strategy. Trees located at the footslope experienced longer vegetative period compared to plants located at the midslope and hilltop locations due do larger soil moisture content recorded at the footslope. Additionally, xylem water of footslope trees displayed lighter isotopic composition compared to other trees, suggesting the use of a less fractionated water sources.

    We argue that contrary to the Weierbach catchment where subsurface hillslope structure promotes vertical water flux over lateral redistribution in the vadose zone, the steep hillslope on the Re della Pietra catchment experiences shallow lateral downslope water redistribution which results in substantial differences in vadose zone water supply between hillslope positions.

    How to cite: Fabiani, G., Klaus, J., Schoppach, R., and Penna, D.: Contrasting tree water use strategies along hillslopes in forested catchments in Luxembourg and Italy, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5313, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5313, 2022.

    EGU22-5437 | Presentations | HS10.5

    Investigating the effects of bryophytes on carbon cycling in a temperate forest ecosystem from stable isotope composition 

    Corinna Gall, Alexander Maurer, Julia Dartsch, Delia Maas, Martin Nebel, Harald Neidhardt, Yvonne Oelmann, Thomas Scholten, and Steffen Seitz

    Nonvascular plants such as bryophytes are often overlooked; however, they are important players at the soil-atmosphere interface and affecting water exchange, nutrient fluxes or carbon storage. Bryophytes also act as soil stabilizers in a variety of ecosystems and thus contribute significantly to the mitigation of soil erosion. Nevertheless, these stabilizing effects are not completely understood, with two distinctions: Firstly, bryophytes form a physical protective barrier that prevents direct drop impact on soil. Secondly, they fix carbon and thus contribute to soil carbon storage, which in turn enhances soil aggregation. Both factors result in a reduction of soil erosion, although it is unclear to what extent. As bryophytes showed a high impact on carbon assimilation and soil carbon storage in boreal environments, gaining an understanding of these effects in a temperate forest can be a key factor in assessing the overall state of that ecosystem.

    In this study, we used the stable carbon isotope ratio (δ13C) analysis as an approach to evaluate the effect of bryophytes on soil organic carbon (SOC). Furthermore, we investigated the influence of SOC on aggregate size. Soil substrates and bryophyte species were sampled in temperate forests in southern Germany with different kinds of parent material. Five sites were located in Schönbuch Nature Park next to Tübingen and one site in the Black Forest close to Freiburg. Each study site consisted of three treatments: bryophyte-covered patches, bare undisturbed soil and partial disturbed soil from forest management. In this context, it was hypothesized that there is a significant contribution of bryophytes to SOC, which is reflected by a change in isotopic signatures and aggregate sizes. Consequently, bryophyte-covered soils are assumed to exhibit higher SOC contents, form larger soil aggregates and for this reason be more resistant to soil erosion, and the contribution of bryophytes to SOC can be estimated based on the differences in the δ13C of bryophytes compared to C3 plants.

    Preliminary results of two study sites revealed a distinct positive correlation between SOC and aggregate size, whereby a contribution of bryophytes to SOC could not yet be established based on δ13C values. This could be due to the different ecological structure of the two studied sites, the similarity of carbon isotope signatures of C3 plants and bryophytes, the alteration of isotope signature as a result of decomposition, and the combination of all these factors. Laboratory and data analysis of the four remaining sites is currently ongoing, so further results will be presented at EGU 2022.

    How to cite: Gall, C., Maurer, A., Dartsch, J., Maas, D., Nebel, M., Neidhardt, H., Oelmann, Y., Scholten, T., and Seitz, S.: Investigating the effects of bryophytes on carbon cycling in a temperate forest ecosystem from stable isotope composition, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5437, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5437, 2022.

    EGU22-6602 | Presentations | HS10.5 | Highlight

    The WATSON COST Action: Water isotopes in the critical zone from groundwater recharge to plant transpiration 

    Adrià Barbeta, Miriam Coenders-Gerrits, Josie Geris, Tamara Jakovljević, Pilar Llorens, Hannu Marttila, Kazakis Nerantzis, Natalie Orlowski, Emel Zeray Öztürk, Daniele Penna, Andrea L. Popp, Youri Rothfuss, Francesca Scandellari, Michael Stockinger, Christine Stumpp, Ilja van Meerveld, Jana von Freyberg, Polona Vreča, and Petra Žvab Rožič

    The WATSON COST Action (CA19120; https://watson-cost.eu/) started in September 2020. It aims to integrate and synthesize current interdisciplinary scientific knowledge on the use of the stable isotopes of water to understand the mixing and partitioning of water in the Earth’s Critical Zone. The network is organized into working groups that focus on a major scientific challenge: 1) groundwater recharge and soil water mixing processes; 2) vegetation water uptake and transpiration; and 3) catchment-scale residence time and travel times. A fourth working group organizes the network and dissemination activities.

    WATSON aims at better connecting academia and stakeholders from industry, non-profit organizations, and government agencies. WATSON fosters the exchange of information and expertise among scientists and stakeholders, builds capacity in the use of the latest isotope approaches and translates scientific cutting-edge knowledge into tangible outputs and recommendations on how to use stable water isotopes to effectively address water management needs. 

    Our poster describes the WATSON network, as well as its activities. These include the preparation of an open-access database of water isotope-based studies in the Critical Zone, the development of protocols for water sampling and stable isotope analysis, the organization of virtual and in-person meetings, seminars, training schools, and the exchange of students, researchers, and technicians via short term scientific missions.

    How to cite: Barbeta, A., Coenders-Gerrits, M., Geris, J., Jakovljević, T., Llorens, P., Marttila, H., Nerantzis, K., Orlowski, N., Öztürk, E. Z., Penna, D., Popp, A. L., Rothfuss, Y., Scandellari, F., Stockinger, M., Stumpp, C., van Meerveld, I., von Freyberg, J., Vreča, P., and Žvab Rožič, P.: The WATSON COST Action: Water isotopes in the critical zone from groundwater recharge to plant transpiration, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6602, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6602, 2022.

    EGU22-8620 | Presentations | HS10.5

    In situ monitoring of tree water uptake depths, storage and transport reveals different strategies during drought and recovery 

    Kathrin Kühnhammer, Joost van Haren, Angelika Kübert, Maren Dubbert, Nemiah Ladd, Laura Meredith, Christiane Werner, and Matthias Beyer

    Due to ongoing and likely intensifying climate change impacts, ecosystem water availability is altered across the globe. Humid tropical forests, which evolved under conditions of abundant water, might be particularly vulnerable to water stress. One important factor in a tree's resilience to a less reliable water supply from precipitation is a root system that reaches deep into the ground. However, accessing deep soil regions as well as observing active deep root water uptake is challenging. Consequently, the occurrence, functioning and importance of deep roots are not well understood.

    The Biosphere 2 Tropical Rainforest in Arizona, USA offers a unique possibility to further investigate this knowledge gap as environmental conditions can be controlled and soil can be accessed from below. Within the interdisciplinary B2 WALD project, we imposed a two-month drought on the enclosed ecosystem. To identify deep water uptake, water labeled with 2H isotopes was supplied through a drainage system in 2-3 m soil depth before the drought ended. To investigate tree reactions to the manipulations in water supply, we closely monitored atmospheric conditions, soil water content and isotopic composition as well as tree sap flow, stem water content and the isotopic composition of tree xylem and transpired water. Only few data sets exist, combining water stable isotope information with different hydrometric measurements within the same experiment. Additionally, we used novel in situ approaches to monitor the isotopic composition in soils, tree xylem and transpiration in high temporal resolution.

    Combining all measurements in 10 tree individuals of 5 different species, we found contrasting reactions to the added deep water. Except of two understory trees, all canopy trees had access to it, suggesting that deep roots could be a common feature also in tropical tree species. Trees did not use deep water in the same way. We observed differences in the speed and timing of the reaction as well as in within-tree water dynamics. While some individuals first refilled their stem water storage, others used the deep water source to preserve their sap flow and transpiration stream. This not only impacted the time course of tree water isotopes but knowledge of those different behaviors is pivotal in better understanding and predicting tree performance, survival and ecosystem water cycling. In summary, our data illustrates the need for an extensive network combining different measurements to correctly interpret tree water isotope dynamics, tree water use strategies and to further uncover the functioning of deep roots and assess their importance for ecosystem resilience in a changing climate.

    How to cite: Kühnhammer, K., van Haren, J., Kübert, A., Dubbert, M., Ladd, N., Meredith, L., Werner, C., and Beyer, M.: In situ monitoring of tree water uptake depths, storage and transport reveals different strategies during drought and recovery, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8620, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8620, 2022.

    EGU22-8800 | Presentations | HS10.5

    Practical measurements of water stable isotopes in tree stems and soils using conservative water vapor storage 

    Ruth Magh, Benjamin Gralher, Barbara Herbstritt, Angelika Kübert, Hyungwoo Lim, Tomas Lundmark, and John Marshall

    The interest of inferring plant water uptake depths/patterns and water movements through the soil matrix grew tremendously in recent years and, studies have shown the use of in-situ measurement systems based on laser absorption spectroscopy making e.g. plant or soil water stable isotope datasets available on-site and in real-time. However useful, in-situ systems are limited to sites with power supply and require constant care.

    We tested, first in the lab and then in the field, a method for equilibrating, collecting, storing, and finally analysing water vapour for its isotopic composition. We used a vapour storage vial system (VSVS) that relies on in-situ sampling, using a pump and a flow meter powered through a small battery into crimp neck vials with a double coated lid, and measuring the samples in a laboratory. We tested the utility of the sampling method and the reliability of the VSVS to faithfully store the isotopic composition of its content by sampling a range of water vapour of known isotopic compositions (from -95 to 1700‰ for δ2H) and measuring the isotopic signature after the storage period. Samples for the field trial were taken in a tracer pulse chase experiment in a boreal forest in Northern Sweden.

    We were able to prove the utility of the sampling method within defined uncertainties (0.6 to 4.4‰ for δ2H and 0.6 to 0.8‰ for δ18O) for natural abundance. For in 2H-enriched samples the range was adapted to higher uncertainty. We detected a small change in the isotopic composition of the sample after a longer storage period, which was consistently greater for oxygen but correctable by linear models.

    Our method has the potential to combine the best of two worlds: sampling in-situ in high spatial or temporal resolution while measuring in the laboratory, could solve problems with location biases and give the community a tool that is not only cost-efficient but also easy to use while all components are commercially available.  

    How to cite: Magh, R., Gralher, B., Herbstritt, B., Kübert, A., Lim, H., Lundmark, T., and Marshall, J.: Practical measurements of water stable isotopes in tree stems and soils using conservative water vapor storage, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8800, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8800, 2022.

    EGU22-9558 | Presentations | HS10.5

    Non-invasive isotope-based hydrodynamic imaging in plant roots at cellular resolution 

    Valentin Couvreur, Flavius C Pascut, Daniela Dietrich, Nicky Leftley, Guilhem Reyt, Yann Boursiac, Monica Calvo-Polanco, Ilda Casimiro, Christophe Maurel, David E Salt, Xavier Draye, Darren M Wells, Malcolm J Bennett, and Kevin F Webb

    A key impediment to studying water-related mechanisms in plants is the inability to noninvasively image water fluxes in cells at high temporal and spatial resolution. Here, we report that Raman microspectroscopy, complemented by hydrodynamic modelling, can achieve this goal - monitoring deuterated water fluxes within living root tissues at cell- and sub-second-scale resolutions. Raman imaging of water-transporting xylem vessels in Arabidopsis thaliana mutant roots reveals faster xylem water transport in endodermal diffusion barrier mutants. Furthermore, transverse line scans across the root suggest water transported via the root xylem does not re-enter outer root tissues nor the surrounding soil when en-route to shoot tissues if endodermal diffusion barriers are intact, thereby separating ‘two water worlds’ inside roots.

    How to cite: Couvreur, V., Pascut, F. C., Dietrich, D., Leftley, N., Reyt, G., Boursiac, Y., Calvo-Polanco, M., Casimiro, I., Maurel, C., Salt, D. E., Draye, X., Wells, D. M., Bennett, M. J., and Webb, K. F.: Non-invasive isotope-based hydrodynamic imaging in plant roots at cellular resolution, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9558, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9558, 2022.

    EGU22-9870 | Presentations | HS10.5

    Assessing root water uptake transit time by simulating isotope transport in Hydrus-1D 

    Diego Todini and the PRIN WATZON

    Stable isotopes (2H and 18O) are common natural tracers for the investigation of water transport in the soil-plant-atmosphere continuum. Isotopic data can be coupled with soil water content data to inversely estimate soil hydraulic and transport parameters. The calibration of a hydrological model by inverse modelling is a prerequisite to determine the temporal origin of xylem water taken by roots.

    In this study, we used isotopic data to calibrate Hydrus-1D via inverse modelling to simulate one-dimensional water flow and isotope transport in a controlled soil-plant-atmosphere system. We propose the following protocol i) to estimate root water uptake transit time of irrigation water, and ii) to assess the sensitivity of the transit time distribution to the variation in the water available for root uptake.

    The dataset was obtained from an isotope-tracing experiment carried out between May and July 2018 on an olive tree placed in a pot inside a glasshouse. Meteorological variables and sap flow were monitored at 5-minute intervals, whereas shallow soil moisture (0-6 cm depth) was measured manually with an impedance probe at the daily timescale. The olive tree was irrigated with water of known isotopic composition. The pot surface was covered by a plastic sheet to avoid evaporation. Soil at different depths, twigs, wood cores and root samples were collected weekly for isotopic analyses. Water from soil and the xylem tissues was extracted by cryogenic vacuum distillation. Based on the results of a previous study carried out on the same dataset, we considered that no isotopic fractionation occurred during the water uptake and the transport within the olive tree.

    We used soil water content and δ18O data at different soil depths to optimize flow (soil hydraulic and root water uptake parameters) and transport (longitudinal dispersivity) parameters. Numerical simulations of isotope transport were validated with sap flow data (compared to actual transpiration) and δ18O in xylem water. Given that the timing of irrigation water for plant transpiration is fundamental for assessing the vulnerability of olive trees to drought, we will be proposing various scenarios based on different irrigation events to mimic drought periods. Based on these scenarios, we will be evaluating the sensitivity of the root water uptake transit time to the different water availability in the soil profile. Afterwards, the same protocol will be exploited to determine the root water uptake transit time for different tree species under various environmental conditions.

    Keywords: stable isotopes, HYDRUS-1D, root water uptake, transit time, soil water.

    How to cite: Todini, D. and the PRIN WATZON: Assessing root water uptake transit time by simulating isotope transport in Hydrus-1D, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9870, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9870, 2022.

    EGU22-9888 | Presentations | HS10.5

    Impact of elevated CO2, temperature, and drought on summer ecohydrological moisture cycling and water transit times in montane grassland 

    Jesse Radolinski, Herbert Wachter, Steffen Birk, Nicolas Brüggemann, Markus Herndl, Ansgar Kahmen, Angelika Kübert, Andreas Schaumberger, Christine Stumpp, Matevz Vremec, Christiane Werner, and Michael Bahn

    Rapid alteration of Earth’s climate amplifies concerns over the future quantity and quality of freshwater resources. Earth’s warming atmosphere is known to store and transport more water vapor at higher velocities than historic climatic conditions, augmenting the magnitude and frequency of extreme weather events like intense rainfall and droughts. Warming can accelerate evapotranspiration by elevating vapor pressure gradients, whereas atmospheric CO2 enrichmentcan suppress transpiration as plants preferentially close their stomata. Despite the potential hydrological implications, no study to date has comprehensively explored how these global change factors, when combined, impact the transit of moisture through the soil-plant-atmosphere continuum. In a montane grassland we tracked an extensive deuterium-labelled rainfall event following a severe experimental drought period under current versus simulated future (+300 ppm CO2 and +3°C warming) conditions. We monitored stable isotopes of water in soil and evapotranspiration vapor, to partition signatures of evaporation, transpiration, drainage and soil pore water and quantify transit times through each ecohydrological compartment. Preliminary results suggest that under future conditions (+300 ppm CO2 and 3°C) drought can drastically increase the retention time of water in the rootzone, which intermittently forces plants to return older water to the atmosphere. We intend to use these findings to directly quantify the water age preference of evaporative and drainage fluxes under a range of climate scenarios.

    How to cite: Radolinski, J., Wachter, H., Birk, S., Brüggemann, N., Herndl, M., Kahmen, A., Kübert, A., Schaumberger, A., Stumpp, C., Vremec, M., Werner, C., and Bahn, M.: Impact of elevated CO2, temperature, and drought on summer ecohydrological moisture cycling and water transit times in montane grassland, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9888, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9888, 2022.

    EGU22-10019 | Presentations | HS10.5

    Comparing plant water extraction methods for isotopic analyses: the Scholander pressure chamber vs. the cryogenic vacuum distillation 

    Giulia Zuecco, Anam Amin, Jay Frentress, Michael Engel, Chiara Marchina, Tommaso Anfodillo, Marco Borga, Vinicio Carraro, Francesca Scandellari, Massimo Tagliavini, Damiano Zanotelli, Francesco Comiti, and Daniele Penna

    Recent studies applying stable isotopes of hydrogen and oxygen showed that different methods for extracting water from plant tissues can return different isotopic composition. One of the most used methods to extract plant water is the cryogenic vacuum distillation (CVD), which tends to extract total plant water. Conversely, the Scholander pressure chamber (SPC), which is commonly used by tree physiologists to measure water potential in plant tissues, likely accesses only the mobile plant water (i.e., xylem and inter-cellular water). However, only few studies reported the application of SPC to extract plant water for isotopic analyses, and therefore, an inter-method comparison between SPC and CVD is needed.

    In this study, we analyzed the variability in the isotopic signature of plant water extracted by SPC and CVD. Furthermore, we considered the potential variability in the isotopic composition of the plant water extracted from various tissues by CVD (i.e., leaves, twig without bark, twig with bark, twig close to the trunk of the tree, and wood core), and from different tree species (i.e., alder, apple, chestnut and beech) located in three different study areas in northern Italy.

    Results indicate that plant waters extracted by SPC and CVD were significantly different, likely due to the extraction of different plant water domains. The difference in the isotopic composition obtained by the two extraction methods was smaller in the beech samples compared to alder, apple and chestnut samples. The signature of alder, apple and chestnut plant water extracted by SPC was more enriched in heavy isotopes than the samples obtained by CVD (except for the leaf water obtained by CVD, which also had a marked evaporative signature). We conclude that plant water extraction by SPC does not represent an alternative for CVD, as SPC likely extracts mostly the mobile plant water, whereas CVD tends to retrieve all water stored in the sampled tissues. However, studies aiming to quantify the relative contribution of the water sources to transpiration should rely more on the isotopic composition of xylem water transpiring during the sampling day (theoretically sampled by SPC), than the isotopic composition of total plant water (sampled by CVD), which also contains a fraction of water that could be stored in plant tissues for a long time.

     

     

    Keywords: stable isotopes of hydrogen and oxygen; cryogenic vacuum distillation; Scholander pressure chamber; plant water; xylem water.

    How to cite: Zuecco, G., Amin, A., Frentress, J., Engel, M., Marchina, C., Anfodillo, T., Borga, M., Carraro, V., Scandellari, F., Tagliavini, M., Zanotelli, D., Comiti, F., and Penna, D.: Comparing plant water extraction methods for isotopic analyses: the Scholander pressure chamber vs. the cryogenic vacuum distillation, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10019, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10019, 2022.

    EGU22-10699 | Presentations | HS10.5

    Quantifying and partitioning evapotranspiration using Bayesian inversion of an isotope-enabled soil water balance model 

    Gabriel Bowen, Paige Austin, Scott Allen, William Anderegg, Stephen Good, David Noone, and Christopher Still

    Isotope ratios of soil water and atmospheric water vapor have been used to estimate soil evaporation fluxes and to partition evapotranspiration at local (plot, stand) scales, but the application of these methods has been limited by 1) challenges associated with data acquisition, and 2) the complexity of and lack of consensus about appropriate data interpretation methods. New initiatives that have expanded access to data, such as the U.S. National Ecological Observatory Network (NEON), are beginning to address the first of these limitations. In order to make progress toward the second, we link a model of soil water and water isotope balance, based on the widely used Noah land surface model, to a range of core NEON measurements and ancillary field-collected data using a Bayesian hierarchical framework. This model framework allows self-consistent treatment of the water and isotope cycles, including representation of uncertainties and differing assumptions, and simultaneous optimization of all model parameters conditioned on all data using Markov-Chain Monte Carlo sampling. We test the framework by applying it to estimate evapotranspiration partitioning at a dryland NEON site in central Utah and show that the posterior estimates give reasonable and useful constraints on flux rates and provide constraints on model parameters that could inform our understanding of soil properties and isotopic systematics in the system. This flexible framework for interpretation of water isotope data in evapotranspiration studies is amenable to application across ecosystems and at sites with different levels of data availability in support of cross-site syntheses and validation/testing of earth system models.

    How to cite: Bowen, G., Austin, P., Allen, S., Anderegg, W., Good, S., Noone, D., and Still, C.: Quantifying and partitioning evapotranspiration using Bayesian inversion of an isotope-enabled soil water balance model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10699, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10699, 2022.

    EGU22-11593 | Presentations | HS10.5

    Deriving xylem water isotopic compositions from in situ transpiration measurements: opportunity for plant source water identification? 

    Angelika Kübert, Maren Dubbert, Kathrin Kuehnhammer, Matthias Beyer, Joost van Haren, Laura K. Meredith, S. Nemiah Ladd, and Christiane Werner

    The isotopic signature of xylem water (δX) is of great interest for plant source water studies. δX is usually derived by destructive sampling and subsequent cryogenic vacuum extraction (CVE). However, numerous studies have criticized this approach due its methodological constraints and analytical artifacts. New in situ methods to derive δX have been proposed in recent years. Yet, they are still in the development- and test phase, and their application highly intrusive. Gas exchange chamber techniques, on the other hand, have been well established for decades and allow the isotopic signature of transpired water (δT) to be monitored in high temporal resolution. As δT values approach δx values when transpiration is at isotopic steady state, measurements of δT may provide a relatively non-intrusive method to derive δX values.  

    While conducting a large-scale long-term drought experiment of 90 days in a model rainforest ecosystem (Biosphere 2, WALD project), we monitored dynamics in δT values in two tropical plant species, one understory and one canopy species. Severe drought was ended with a deep water pulse strongly enriched in 2H. By connecting flow-through leaf chambers to a water isotope analyzer, we measured δT in a 2-h resolution and observed its response to increasing drought, deep labelling and subsequent recovery. Parallel to continuous measurements of δT, branch samples were collected at 5 time points throughout the experiment to determine δX values from CVE.

    We found that δT values provide a good proxy for δX values when using the daily averages of δT values, weighted by the transpiration flux; derived δX values matched well with isotopic compositions of soil water. In situ-δ18OX agreed well with values from CVE. CVE-δ2HX values, however, were strongly enriched in 2H in comparison to in situ derived values, which is probably linked to the isotopic effects of CVE on δ2H as recently found in several studies. Moreover, by adding a 2H deep water pulse, δT allowed us to distinguish clearly between deep and shallow soil water use as well as show uptake velocities of newly added water. Monitoring  δT using gas exchange chambers provides a good proxy for δX values to address research questions concerning plant-available water sources and their usage, and at the same time give additional information on the plant water status. 

    How to cite: Kübert, A., Dubbert, M., Kuehnhammer, K., Beyer, M., van Haren, J., Meredith, L. K., Ladd, S. N., and Werner, C.: Deriving xylem water isotopic compositions from in situ transpiration measurements: opportunity for plant source water identification?, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11593, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11593, 2022.

    EGU22-11815 | Presentations | HS10.5

    The role of dew and radiation fog inputs in the local water cycling of a temperate grassland during dry spells in central Europe 

    Yafei Li, Franziska Aemisegger, Andreas Riedl, Nina Buchmann, and Werner Eugster

    During dry spells, non-rainfall water (hereafter NRW) mostly formed from dew and fog potentially plays an increasingly important role in temperate grassland ecosystems with ongoing global warming. Dew and radiation fog occur in combination during clear and calm nights, and both use ambient water vapor as a source. Research on the combined mechanisms involved in NRW inputs to ecosystems is rare, and distillation of water vapor from the soil as a NRW input pathway for dew formation has hardly been studied. Furthermore, eddy covariance (EC) measurements are associated with large uncertainties on clear, calm nights when dew and radiation fog occur. The aim of this paper is thus to use stable isotopes as tracers to investigate the different NRW input pathways into a temperate Swiss grassland at Chamau during dry spells in summer 2018. Stable isotopes provide additional information on the pathways from water vapor to liquid water (dew and fog) that cannot be measured otherwise. We measured the isotopic composition (δ18O, δ2H, and d = δ2H − 8⋅δ18O) of ambient water vapor, NRW droplets on leaf surfaces, and soil moisture and combined them with EC and meteorological observations during one dew-only and two combined dew and radiation fog events. The ambient water vapor d was found to be strongly linked with local surface relative humidity (r = −0.94), highlighting the dominant role of local moisture as a source for ambient water vapor in the synoptic context of the studied dry spells. Detailed observations of the temporal evolution of the ambient water vapor and foliage NRW isotopic signals suggest two different NRW input pathways: (1) the downward pathway through the condensation of ambient water vapor and (2) the upward pathway through the distillation of water vapor from soil onto foliage. We employed a simple two-end-member mixing model using δ18O and δ2H to quantify the NRW inputs from these two different sources. With this approach, we found that distillation contributed 9–42% to the total foliage NRW, which compares well with estimates derived from a near-surface vertical temperature gradient method proposed by Monteith in 1957. The dew and radiation fog potentially produced 0.17–0.54 mm d-1 NRW gain on foliage, thereby constituting a non-negligible water flux to the canopy, as compared to the evapotranspiration of 2.7 mm d-1. Our results thus underline the importance of NRW inputs to temperate grasslands during dry spells and reveal the complexity of the local water cycle in such conditions, including different pathways of dew and radiation fog water inputs.

    How to cite: Li, Y., Aemisegger, F., Riedl, A., Buchmann, N., and Eugster, W.: The role of dew and radiation fog inputs in the local water cycling of a temperate grassland during dry spells in central Europe, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11815, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11815, 2022.

    EGU22-12306 | Presentations | HS10.5

    Isotopic signals across the forest water cycle 

    Marius G. Floriancic, Scott T. Allen, and James W. Kirchner

    Forests greatly impact the water cycle by redistributing water between the atmosphere and the subsurface, via processes including interception, infiltration, and transpiration. In order to understand which water is redistributed among different ultimate fates, and thereby better understand the role of vegetation in that process, we use stable isotopes to quantify transport processes across the different compartments of the forest water cycle. At our Waldlabor hillslope laboratory (Zurich, Switzerland) we have frequently measured and sampled water fluxes across the forest water cycle since April 2020. Specifically, we measure the isotopic composition in precipitation, throughfall, stemflow, bulk and mobile soil waters in depths of 10, 20, 40 and 80cm as well as in deep mobile water (from boreholes in the unsaturated zone up to 7m depth), groundwater and surface discharge at the outlet of the catchment. We also assess soil water uptake by beech and spruce trees from destructive sampling of twig xylem every three weeks.

    The isotopic composition in precipitation was similar to what we found in throughfall and stemflow, so canopy interception processes did not substantially alter the isotopic signal. The seasonal variation in precipitation isotope composition was strongly dampened with depth in subsurface storages (through the soil layers, deep mobile water, and groundwater to streamflow). The assessment of the new water fractions in soil waters of different depths and the deeper soil drip water showed that the fractions of new precipitation in each layer decreased with depth. Although precipitation is almost equally distributed throughout the year, we found that soil new water fractions were generally smaller in summer compared than in winter. Water in spruce and beech xylem has a similar isotope signal throughout the year, potentially suggesting use of deep sources that contain a relatively stable mixture of summer and winter water. Together, these data provide opportunities for new perspectives on how subsurface flows and vegetation interact.

    How to cite: Floriancic, M. G., Allen, S. T., and Kirchner, J. W.: Isotopic signals across the forest water cycle, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12306, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12306, 2022.

    EGU22-1707 | Presentations | HS10.7

    Local climate impacts from ongoing restoration of a peatland 

    Fred Worrall, Nicholas Howden, Timothy Burt, and Miguel Rico-Ramirez

    We hypothesize that peatlands represent a cool humid island in their landscape context and that this effect could be recreated by successful peatland restoration. This study used 20 years of Earth observation data for land surface temperature (day- and night- time LST), albedo (near infra-red white sky albedo) and vegetation indices (EVI) measured for 42 one km2 grid squares across two peatlands and their surrounding arable fields. The peatlands have undergone restoration (re-vegetation and raising of water tables) since 2004. The results show that over the restored peatlands:

    • Daytime temperatures over the peatlands cooled relative to the surrounding arable land by up to 1.1 K (°C), but there was no significant change in night-time temperatures.
    • Over the peatlands the average amplitude of the diurnal temperature cycle decreased by up to 2.4 K (°C) over the period of the restoration.
    • Comparison of vegetation indices and albedo shows the cooling effect of increasing albedo was smaller than warming effect of changes in aerodynamic resistance brought about by development of shrubby vegetation.

    The presence of an overall cooling effect, despite a warming effect due to vegetation development, meant that a rising water table led to a lowering of the Bowen ratio. Peatlands revegetated to, or dominated by, moss carpets rather than shrubby vegetation will maximise the potential cooling effect, whereas shrub development across peatlands without a rise in water table will lead to warming.

    How to cite: Worrall, F., Howden, N., Burt, T., and Rico-Ramirez, M.: Local climate impacts from ongoing restoration of a peatland, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1707, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1707, 2022.

    EGU22-1731 | Presentations | HS10.7

    Delineating the distribution of mineral and peat soils in the northern boreal regions – Transition from discrete classification to continuous maps 

    Anneli M. Ågren, Eliza Hasselquist, Johan Stendahl, Mats B. Nilsson, and Siddhartho S. Paul

    To meet the sustainable development goals and enable protection of peatlands, there is a strong need to plan and align land-use management with the needs of the environment. The most critical tool to succeed in sustainable spatial planning is accurate and detailed maps. Here we present a novel approach to map mineral and peat soils based on a high-resolution digital soil moisture map. This soil moisture map was produced by combining LIDAR-derived terrain indices and machine learning to model soil moisture at 2 m spatial resolution across the Swedish landscape with high accuracy (Kappa = 0.69, MCC = 0.68). We used field data from about 20,000 sites across Sweden to train an extreme gradient boosting model to predict soil moisture. The predictor features included a suite of terrain indices generated from national LIDAR digital elevation model and other ancillary environmental features, including surficial geology, climate, land use information, allowing for adjustment of soil moisture maps to regional/local conditions. As soil moisture is an important control on peat formation, we investigated if this map can be used to improve the mapping of peatlands. In this study, we included a total of 5 479 soil pit data for organic layer thickness from the Swedish Forest Soil Inventory. Peat was defined as organic layer thickness > 50 cm. The data was split into a calibration dataset and a validation dataset using a randomized 50% split. An empirical relationship between the thickness of the organic layer and the continuous SLU soil moisture map (R2 = 0.66, p < 0.001) was used to generate both a categorical map (of mineral soil and peat) and continuous map (of organic layer thickness) to demonstrate how these two mapping approaches can be useful for different management objectives. The peat coverage on the new categorical map, the quaternary deposits map and topographical map was 17.3%, 14.1% and 13.5%, respectively. Map quality measures from the evaluation dataset showed that the newly developed peat map had higher recall and MCC (80.4, 0.73) than quaternary deposits map (68.5, 0.65) and topographical map (49.8, 0.61). The continuous map of the organic layer ranged 6-95 cm with an RMSE of 4 cm.

     

    Using Sweden as a test case, this study provides a guide to improved mapping of mineral and peat soils from Lidar data in other boreal forest regions for effective ecosystem management. The map of organic soils was developed to support the need for land use management optimization by incorporating landscape sensitivity and hydrological connectivity into a framework that promotes the protection of soil and water quality. The organic soil map can be used to address fundamental considerations, such as;

    • guiding the restoration of drained wetlands;
    • designing riparian protection zones to optimize the protection of water quality and biodiversity as the new map also include riparian peats.

    How to cite: Ågren, A. M., Hasselquist, E., Stendahl, J., Nilsson, M. B., and Paul, S. S.: Delineating the distribution of mineral and peat soils in the northern boreal regions – Transition from discrete classification to continuous maps, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1731, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1731, 2022.

    EGU22-2242 | Presentations | HS10.7

    Modelling water fluxes in a soil profile of a degraded peatland site 

    Mariel Davies, Ottfried Dietrich, and Christoph Merz

    Reducing greenhouse gas emissions from degraded, agriculturally used peatlands is a vital contribution to meeting the German climate protection targets by 2050. It requires an understanding their closely coupled hydraulic and geochemical processes, which is the basis of sustainable land and water management on these sites. Hydraulic modelling of the fluxes in a soil profile was done to characterise the hydraulic state of a degraded peatland site with spatially and temporally high resolution. The basis of the model were measurements from groundwater lysimeters in a site with three horizons in Spreewald wetland, Germany. The model was implemented in the one-dimensional hydraulic modelling software Hydrus-1D. The first step was the determination of initial soil hydraulic properties using soil physical properties and the ROSETTA tool based on pedotransfer functions, which is integrated in Hydrus-1D. Two model variants were set up that differed in their lower boundary condition – either the measured pressure head (representing groundwater level) or the measured flux at the lower boundary of the lysimeter. The modelled volumetric water contents, pressure heads and groundwater table (variant 1) or fluxes at lower boundary (variant 2) were validated with the measured lysimeter data. In a second step, the soil hydraulic parameters were inversely optimised based on measured time series data, for both variants. To further improve the model results, dual porosity type flow was implemented in the upper two horizons. The different steps were able to continuously improve the model. The choice of lower boundary condition had an effect on the quality of the model results: The use of groundwater table as lower boundary condition improved the modelled volumetric water contents and pressure heads, but yielded deviating fluxes at the lower boundary in comparison to the measurements. The application of flux as a lower boundary condition produced deviations in the modelled groundwater table, the water contents and the pressure heads, especially after heavy rainfall events. The integration of preferential flow (dual porosity) into the model improved the vadose zone pressure head and water content results significantly.

    How to cite: Davies, M., Dietrich, O., and Merz, C.: Modelling water fluxes in a soil profile of a degraded peatland site, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2242, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2242, 2022.

    EGU22-2646 | Presentations | HS10.7

    High-resolution water table depth modelling of Danish peatlands for upscaling emission of greenhouse gases 

    Julian Koch, Steen Gyldenkærne, Mogens Humlekrog Greve, Lars Elsgaard, and Simon Stisen

    Water table depth (WTD) modulates greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions from drained peatland soils and rewetting peatlands has been identified as a cost-effective mitigation measure to reduce emissions from the agricultural sector. However, detailed knowledge of the spatial variability of WTD is needed to guide the planning of rewetting measures as well as to upscale GHG emissions from peatlands for national inventories. In this study we developed a high-resolution (10 m) map of long-term mean summertime WTD for Danish peatlands (~9,000 km2) using a gradient boosting decision tree algorithm. The machine learning (ML) model was trained against more than 10,000 WTD observations as well as water levels in over 10,000 groundwater connected lakes and rivers. The WTD observations were transformed to better account for the non-linear relationship between WTD and GHG emissions and the limited WTD range (such as 0 – 50 below ground) in which GHG emissions are most sensitive. Over 20 high-resolution explanatory variables, many of which are satellite based, provided diverse information on topography, groundwater, moisture conditions, land-use and geology to the model. Cross validation was applied to evaluate the accuracy of the trained ML model with special focus on the shallow WTD (mean error= -8cm and mean absolute error = 18 cm). The horizontal and vertical distance to the nearest waterbody as well as organic content of the soil and land surface temperature were among the most important explanatory variables of the trained ML model. The WTD map was subsequently applied as input to two recently developed WTD-dependent GHG emission models to upscale GHG emissions from Danish peatlands. For this purpose, the mean summertime WTD map had to be corrected to represent mean annual conditions. Lastly, simple rewetting scenarios, i.e. decrease in WTD, were applied to elucidate the potentials of rewetting as mitigation measure.         

    How to cite: Koch, J., Gyldenkærne, S., Greve, M. H., Elsgaard, L., and Stisen, S.: High-resolution water table depth modelling of Danish peatlands for upscaling emission of greenhouse gases, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2646, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2646, 2022.

    EGU22-5177 | Presentations | HS10.7

    How tree management affects water levels and peat properties in a groundwater fed peatland 

    Elaine Halliday, Joanna Clark, Anne Verhoef, David Macdonald, and Debbie Wilkinson

    Groundwater-fed peatlands are a rare and vital ecosystem providing rich biodiversity, carbon storage and regulation of the hydrological cycle. Management of these species and carbon stores are essential for maintaining a healthy ecosystem. In parallel to this, groundwater aquifers are a common source of relatively clean drinking water, under pressure from population growth and climate change. Groundwater abstraction can lead to a reduction in groundwater levels within associated wetlands, affecting their condition, for example by facilitating tree encroachment. Therefore, sustainable water supply needs to balance water demand against other unintentional environmental impacts on the ecosystems. Greywell Fen is located in Southern England, situated above a chalk aquifer that is used to provide drinking water to the area. The fen has been designated a site of special scientific interest (SSSI) in recognition of its important flora. However, the critical vegetation species have been declining in recent decades in favour of extensive tree growth throughout the site. New management of the area has included the reintroduction of grazing and large areas of tree clearance. Our research concerns the impacts of groundwater abstraction and woodland management on the health of the fen. Extensive water level monitoring connected to different areas of tree growth and clearance is being used to determine if tree management is having an effect on water levels within the fen. In addition, peat cores have been sampled in the different areas to determine if tree management and/or water level changes are impacting peat properties, as an indication of drying and decline in fen health. Peat properties studied include pH, water content, C:N, and organic matter decomposition. The latter was performed using FTIR spectroscopy.  The results of this in-depth monitoring are presented here.

    How to cite: Halliday, E., Clark, J., Verhoef, A., Macdonald, D., and Wilkinson, D.: How tree management affects water levels and peat properties in a groundwater fed peatland, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5177, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5177, 2022.

    EGU22-5195 | Presentations | HS10.7 | Highlight

    Optimising natural flood management benefits from peatland restoration 

    Martin Evans, Tim Allott, David Brown, Donald Edokpa, Salim Goudarzi, Joseph Holden, Tim Howson, Adam Johnston, Martin Kay, David Milledge, Joe Rees, Emma Shuttleworth, and Tom Spencer

    Across the world restoration of degraded peatlands involves manipulation of peatland hydrology. Often this includes blocking of drainage and changing of land cover types. These landscape scale interventions in the peatland system have the potential to significantly modify runoff from peatland systems and so to be incorporated into schemes of natural flood management. In this paper we report on results from the 4 year PROTECT project which aims to optimise peatland restoration to support NFM benefits in the degraded peatlands of upland Britain. Field experiments based on a BACI analysis of over 20 peatland microcatchments along with hydrological and hydraulic modelling approaches have underpinned a series of key findings including: reductions in peak discharge and longer lag times for runoff from re-vegetated peatlands particularly associated with sphagnum growth; Reductions in peak discharge associated with optimised peat dams which allow partial drawdown between storm events; continued delivery of NFM benefit from restoration at timescales in excess of 10 years; and identification of a key role for dam permeability in optimising NFM benefits from drainage line blocking.

    Taken together these data support the potential role of peatland restoration in NFM schemes and suggest that with careful optimisation synergies between the needs of peatland restoration and flood protection in headwater communities can be realised.

    How to cite: Evans, M., Allott, T., Brown, D., Edokpa, D., Goudarzi, S., Holden, J., Howson, T., Johnston, A., Kay, M., Milledge, D., Rees, J., Shuttleworth, E., and Spencer, T.: Optimising natural flood management benefits from peatland restoration, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5195, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5195, 2022.

    EGU22-5810 | Presentations | HS10.7

    Arctic vegetation cover seen as a porous media : Numerical assessment of hydraulic and thermal properties of Sphagnum moss, lichen and peat from Western Siberia. 

    Simon Cazaurang, Manuel Marcoux, Oleg S. Pokrovsky, Sergey V. Loiko, Artem G. Lim, Stéphane Audry, Liudmila S. Shirokova, and Laurent Orgogozo

    Sphagnum moss, lichen and peat are widely present in arctic regions, covering millions of km² in permafrost-dominated regions. This multi-component low vegetation strata plays a key role in surfaces fluxes in these areas, as they are the most widespread interface between the atmosphere and the geosphere. Therefore, characterizing their transfer properties such as hydraulic and thermal conductivities is crucial for climate change impacts forecasting in arctic regions. In this work, 12 samples were collected in a discontinuous permafrost arctic area (Khanymey Research Station, Russian Federation) and dried to ensure their conservation. Collected samples have been digitally reconstructed by X-ray scanning. After having assessed morphological and hydraulic properties using numerical analysis of the obtained 3D digital tomographies (Cazaurang et al, submitted), we aim here at developing and using both experimental and numerical methodologies to characterize thermal properties of these samples of Sphagnum, lichen and peat.

    This new study consist in comparisons of numerically and experimentally estimated thermal properties for contributing to the existing knowledge on Sphagnum, lichen and peat transfer properties. Experiments consist of a steady-state thermal conductivity estimation using a hot plate source on real arctic vegetation cover samples. For this purpose, samples are placed in a confined thermal atmosphere and a constant heat flux is applied at sample base. Thermal conductivity is then retrieved with the resolution of Fourier’s heat conduction law. Similarly, numerical computations are conducted on the same digital reconstructions than those used for hydraulic properties determination. Simulations consist of a numerical reproduction of previously described experiments, allowing to strengthen the analysis of the experimental data. Additionally, the definition of representative elementary volumes of the studied samples is also undertaken using the numerical results.

    Compiling these assessments of transfer properties will represent essential information to simulate the dynamics of the permafrost underneath the arctic bryophytic layers with a devoted catchment-scale permafrost models. For instance in the framework of the HiPerBorea project (hiperborea.omp.eu), this approach will be used to forecast the impacts of climate warming on boreal permafrost-dominated catchments.

    How to cite: Cazaurang, S., Marcoux, M., Pokrovsky, O. S., Loiko, S. V., Lim, A. G., Audry, S., Shirokova, L. S., and Orgogozo, L.: Arctic vegetation cover seen as a porous media : Numerical assessment of hydraulic and thermal properties of Sphagnum moss, lichen and peat from Western Siberia., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5810, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5810, 2022.

    EGU22-6090 | Presentations | HS10.7

    Hydrological processes in undisturbed northern peatlands: Relative impact on water conservation and streamflow 

    Jelmer Nijp, Reinert Huseby Karslen, Mats Nilsson, and Kevin Bishop

    The hydrology of peatlands is a crucial control on peatland ecosystem functions, including greenhouse gas emission, biogeochemistry, biodiversity and energy balance partitioning. Undisturbed peatlands contain numerous hydrological feedbacks that stabilize the internal water balance, hence ecosystem functioning. Besides affecting the peatland water balance internally, peatlands are renowned for their capacity to regulate streamflow. Nevertheless, the impact of peatlands on flow regulation remains inconclusive. Some studies suggest that peatlands reduce floods, whereas others conclude that there is no impact or even increased risk of flooding. Such contrasting results can largely be explained by the wide range of peatland ecosystem characteristics, or differences in local geohydrology, climate, and landscape configuration that control hydrological response. No two catchment are the same, making it difficult to discern whether observed differences between catchments originate from peatland hydrological processes or catchment dissimilarities. This seriously hampers understanding the effect of peatlands on streamflow in general and also the setting of priorities in peatland restoration projects.

    In this research we take a modelling approach to quantify the relative impact of hydrological self-regulating processes in undisturbed northern peatlands on the internal peatland water balance and streamflow. By doing so, the confounding effects of local hydroclimatological settings can be excluded. Specifically, we set up a modular model to quantify the relative impact of (1) reduced lateral groundwater losses at deeper groundwater levels and (2) elastic storativity owing to the high compressibility of peat and (3) reduced evapotranspirative water losses at deeper groundwater levels. Landscape position was accounted for by adding or subtracting an extra efflux of water.

    Our results indicate that hydrological self-regulation in natural peatlands is an important means to maintain the functionality of peatland vegetation in the face of changing hydroclimatological conditions. Part of the stored water is used for evapotranspiration. A significant part, however, is slowly released as discharge, resulting in maintaining downstream streamflow.

    This study provides insight on the relative importance of hydrological processes and properties in northern peatlands in affecting internal peatland hydrology and downstream water availability. This information can be used for effective and targeted hydrological restoration of peatlands. With this research we contribute to a more solid scientific basis for the impact of peatlands on streamflow. Moreover, this work highlights the importance of undisturbed peatland processes for catchment behaviour. 

    How to cite: Nijp, J., Huseby Karslen, R., Nilsson, M., and Bishop, K.: Hydrological processes in undisturbed northern peatlands: Relative impact on water conservation and streamflow, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6090, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6090, 2022.

    EGU22-6665 | Presentations | HS10.7

    A machine-learning model to predict uncertainty in permafrost thaw-induced land cover transition 

    Shaghayegh Akbarpour Safsari and James Craig

    This study addresses the effects  of  future  climate-induced permafrost thaw  on  the distribution of land cover in the discontinuous permafrost zones of Northwest Territories (NWT) of Canada. The rapid transition from  a landscape dominated by peat plateaus to one dominated by connected wetlands (fens) and isolated wetlands (bogs) is intricately connected to permafrost thaw. To be able to predict and estimate the potential long-term evolution of these three dominant land covers, we developed a machine learning-based time series land cover change model (TSLCM). The TSLCM is trained on a set of spatio-temporal variables as driving factors of change including: the estimated summertime land surface temperature anomaly (LST), the distance to land cover interfaces, time intervals between observations, time-accumulated land surface temperature, and classified land cover maps from 1970-2008. The TSLCM is used to capture  spatial patterns of change, replicate historical land cover change, and generate reasonable estimates of future land cover evolution over time. The output of TSLCM model is the spatial distribution of fen, bogs, and peat plateaus consistent with a default 50\%\ threshold applied on the predicted probability maps. 
    We here use the TSLCM to simulate land cover change under multiple plausible futures scenarios by using the most recent set of climate model projections. The simulation of the TSLCM under different scenarios helps us to:

        1: visualize the spatial pattern of change
        2: calculate the pace of evolution over time and compare results between climate scenarios
        3:  explore the sensitivity of the model to driving factors of change

     
    In addition to examining uncertainty due to climate uncertainty, a probabilistic approach is used to sample the threshold value to generate a range of land cover realizations. 

    How to cite: Akbarpour Safsari, S. and Craig, J.: A machine-learning model to predict uncertainty in permafrost thaw-induced land cover transition, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6665, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6665, 2022.

    EGU22-6791 | Presentations | HS10.7

    Using a Hydrological Model to Understand the Hydrological Processes in a Mosaic Tropical Peatland Landscape of Pulau Padang, Indonesia 

    Adibtya Asyhari, Sofyan Kurnianto, Yogi Suardiwerianto, Muhammad Fikky Hidayat, Mhd. Iman Faisal Harahap, Chris Evans, Susan Page, Fahmuddin Agus, Dwi Astiani, Supiandi Sabiham, Symon Mezbahuddin, Murugesan Balamurugan, Chandra Prasad Ghimire, and Chandra Shekhar Deshmukh

    Tropical peatlands play an important role in addressing the climate and nature functions. In these ecosystems, hydrology strongly controls their geomorphology, ecology, and carbon cycle. More frequent and severe droughts driven by climate extremes (e.g. El Niño Southern Oscillation and the Indian Ocean Dipole events) may alter their local hydrology. In addition, growing dependencies on tropical peatlands due to population growth and economic development has resulted in land-cover change. Alteration in the hydrological processes under changing climate and land-cover may have crucial implications on tropical peatlands, but such impacts remain poorly understood.

    In this context, we used a coupled MIKE SHE and MIKE Hydro River model to represent the hydrological processes within Pulau Padang (~1,100 km2), a peat-dominated island in the eastern coast of Sumatra, Indonesia. The island is a mosaic landscape of peat swamp forest, smallholder area, and industrial plantation. We collected a comprehensive vegetation and peat properties data from field measurements, supported by high-resolution digital terrain model derived from airborne LiDAR, for the model setup. We calibrated and validated the model against observed groundwater level and stream flow data distributed across the island. Finally, we also evaluated the impacts of land-cover change trajectory in the island by comparing the water balance components (i.e. evapotranspiration, runoff, and storage change) for different hydroclimatic extremes (i.e. El Niño and La Nina) under its current condition (baseline year of 2016) to that of its past (25-year look back period) and future (50-year trajectory) conditions.

    This research should contribute to advance the understanding of the landscape scale hydrological processes in tropical peatlands under land-cover change trajectory, which are important to provide scientific basis for stakeholders involved in guiding responsible peatland management practices. This presentation will discuss the modeling approach and preliminary results.

    How to cite: Asyhari, A., Kurnianto, S., Suardiwerianto, Y., Hidayat, M. F., Harahap, Mhd. I. F., Evans, C., Page, S., Agus, F., Astiani, D., Sabiham, S., Mezbahuddin, S., Balamurugan, M., Ghimire, C. P., and Deshmukh, C. S.: Using a Hydrological Model to Understand the Hydrological Processes in a Mosaic Tropical Peatland Landscape of Pulau Padang, Indonesia, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6791, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6791, 2022.

    EGU22-7430 | Presentations | HS10.7

    River water input from upstream areas into the Cuvette Centrale peatland complex detected via SMOS data assimilation 

    Sebastian Apers, Gabriëlle De Lannoy, Alexander R. Cobb, Greta C. Dargie, Rolf H. Reichle, and Michel Bechtold

    The 16.5 million ha Cuvette Centrale peatland complex in the Congo Basin was described for the first time in 2017. However, a proper understanding of the entire hydrological functioning of this peatland complex is a challenge and large-scale land surface models (LSMs) are unlikely to accurately represent the circulation of water in this area. One of the major issues of large-scale LSMs is the quantification of the spatially- and temporally-variable lateral water input from rivers into peatlands.

    In this research, we applied our recently developed tropical peatland-specific module PEATCLSMTrop,Nat in a land surface modeling and assimilation scheme that uses L-band brightness temperature (Tb) data from the Soil Moisture and Ocean Salinity (SMOS) satellite mission. Despite the dense vegetation cover in tropical peatlands, preliminary results showed that the data assimilation improved the water level estimates at 4 evaluation sites over model-only simulations, with mean correlation coefficients of 0.46 for the model-only and 0.63 for the data assimilation estimates, and mean anomaly correlation coefficients of 0.02 for the model-only and 0.26 for the data assimilation estimates. To gain insight into the large-scale hydrology of the Cuvette Centrale peatland complex, we analyzed data assimilation diagnostics and found temporally autocorrelated positive and negative total water storage (tws) increments (=tws correction introduced via data assimilation) over periods of up to four months over the Cuvette Centrale peatlands. This is indicative of a temporarily suboptimal assimilation system, due to a shortcoming in the LSM. Since PEATCLSMTrop,Nat does not simulate lateral water input and the positive autocorrelated periods of tws increments coincide with anomalies in river stages measured upstream, it suggests that lateral water input (=flooding) from upstream mineral areas into the peatlands of the Cuvette Centrale is an important but unmodelled process in its hydrology. This means that land use change and a climate change-induced precipitation reduction in upstream mineral areas will influence the local hydrology of the Cuvette Centrale peatland complex, making it even more vulnerable to external disturbances.

    How to cite: Apers, S., De Lannoy, G., Cobb, A. R., Dargie, G. C., Reichle, R. H., and Bechtold, M.: River water input from upstream areas into the Cuvette Centrale peatland complex detected via SMOS data assimilation, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7430, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7430, 2022.

    EGU22-10042 | Presentations | HS10.7 | Highlight

    A ten-year trajectory of hydrological recovery in a restored blanket peatland 

    Emma Shuttleworth, Tim Allott, Donald Edokpa, Martin Evans, Salim Goudarzi, Tim Howson, Adam Johnston, Martin Kay, David Milledge, Michael Pilkington, Joe Lake Rees, Jonny Ritson, and Tom Spencer

    The UK supports 15% of the world’s blanket peat cover but much of this vital resource is significantly degraded. Damaged peatlands lose their hydrological integrity, depressing water tables and exacerbating downstream flooding as water is quickly evacuated from hillslopes across bare peat surfaces and through erosional gullies. The restoration of damaged peatlands is a major conservation concern, and landscape-scale restoration by revegetation and damming of gullies is extensive in areas of upland Britain. There is increasing evidence that the restoration techniques can raise water tables and significantly slow the flow of water in addition to providing other ecosystem service benefits. More recently, focus has shifted from stabilising eroding surfaces to reintroducing Sphagnum moss as part of multi-benefit restoration initiatives, but to date there is limited empirical data to evidence its impacts.

    This paper reports the results of long-term post-restoration monitoring on the Kinder Plateau in the southern Pennines, UK. Two sites were revegetated using lime-seed-fertiliser-mulch in 2011 and one of these sites was also gully blocked in 2012 and had a further phase of restoration in the form of intensive Sphagnum planting in 2015. A third unrestored control site was also monitored. We present post-intervention trajectories spanning 10 years showing the long-term recovery of vegetation, water tables, runoff generation, water quality, and sediment production.

    The trajectories of recovery for different functions differ in form and rate. At both treatment sites, vegetation cover and diversity increased rapidly then expansion slowed as full cover was approached. Sediment production was quickly reduced to levels comparable to intact peatlands within two years and bare peat cover became negligible after ~7 years. Key runoff metrics (e.g. peak discharge and lag time) showed similar immediate step changes as a result of increased surface roughness from the rapid vegetation expansion, followed by more gradual improvements as species richness developed through time.  The addition of gully blocking enhanced the short-term impacts of re-vegetation, amplifying the step change, but on longer timescales there were no additional benefits relative to the revegetation only site. Water tables recovered gradually at a constant rate and there is no sign of this slowing after 10 years. Water quality (DOC and colour) was highly variable throughout the study period and the long-term impact of restoration is inconclusive. The introduction of Sphagnum provided additional hydrological benefits, most notably through further increases in lag times and attenuation of runoff. There is also preliminary evidence that the Sphagnum provides resilience to surface drying.

    This study provides the first evidence that the reintroduction of Sphagnum in degraded headwater peatlands can provide additional natural flood management (NFM) benefits compared to standard restoration techniques aimed at stabilising eroding surfaces. We also show that water table recovery does not counteract the benefits of flow attenuation. We emphasise the critical importance of control in assessing the impact of restoration interventions and the need for investment in longer-term (>10 year) monitoring to better understand the hydrological recovery of restored peatlands.

    How to cite: Shuttleworth, E., Allott, T., Edokpa, D., Evans, M., Goudarzi, S., Howson, T., Johnston, A., Kay, M., Milledge, D., Pilkington, M., Rees, J. L., Ritson, J., and Spencer, T.: A ten-year trajectory of hydrological recovery in a restored blanket peatland, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10042, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10042, 2022.

    EGU22-10081 | Presentations | HS10.7

    Controls on storm runoff behavior in a gullied blanket peatland 

    Donald Edokpa, David Milledge, Tim Allott, Joseph Holden, Emma Shuttleworth, Martin Kay, Adam Johnston, Gail Millin-Chalabi, Matt Scott-Campbell, David Chandler, Jamie Freestone, and Martin Evans

    Many upland headwaters of the UK drain areas of blanket peat, much of which has been degraded through atmospheric deposition of pollutants, vegetation change, peat extraction, artificial drainage and erosion. These areas are increasingly the focus of interventions to restore some of the multiple-benefits lost through degradation. Understanding their runoff generation processes underpins analysis of their wider benefits including their potential to mitigate downstream flooding.

    Using a series of multivariate analysis techniques we examine controls on storm runoff in ten blanket peat catchments of 0.2-3.9 hectares all within 5 km of one another. We find that: 1) rainfall intensity is the dominant hydro-meteorological driver for both magnitude and timing of peak discharge for all ten catchments, with antecedent rainfall only relevant in small storms; 2) most of the inter-catchment variability in discharge predictability from rainfall can be explained by catchment characteristics, particularly catchment area; 3) runoff responses, particularly in small storms, are sensitive to scale even in an apparently homogenous and saturation-excess overland flow dominated peatland landscape; 4) peak discharge in large storms is strongly controlled by attenuation processes associated with the travel time distribution, and thus drainage network geometry; 5) peak discharge in smaller storms underlines the importance of hydrological connectivity at scales <1 hectare, perhaps due to depression storage driven (dis)connectivity.

    Together these results suggest a switching in rainfall-runoff behavior within these catchments where peak discharge is controlled by: catchment storage, connectivity and antecedent conditions in small storms; but runoff attenuation, travel time and thus and network structure and scale in larger storms. In the context of Natural Flood Management, our findings suggest that enhancing depression storage by creating distributed shallow peatland pools in addition to existing restoration methods could raise the threshold storm size below which catchment storage, antecedent conditions and connectivity remain important. However, changes in surface roughness and other measures that target runoff velocities are likely to be more effective in the largest (and thus most flood relevant) storms.

    How to cite: Edokpa, D., Milledge, D., Allott, T., Holden, J., Shuttleworth, E., Kay, M., Johnston, A., Millin-Chalabi, G., Scott-Campbell, M., Chandler, D., Freestone, J., and Evans, M.: Controls on storm runoff behavior in a gullied blanket peatland, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10081, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10081, 2022.

    EGU22-10763 | Presentations | HS10.7 | Highlight

    Predicting climate change impacts to peatland soil moisture in Southeast Asia 

    Nathan Dadap, Alexander Cobb, Alison Hoyt, Charles Harvey, Andrew Feldman, Eun-Soon Im, and Alexandra Konings

    Soil moisture is a key hydrologic variable that determines peat flammability and predicts burned area. In recent decades, there has been a rise in deadly peat fires across Southeast Asia, indicating the presence of dry conditions. This has largely been attributed to the extensive deforestation, drainage, and conversion to agricultural use that has occurred in the region. Climate also plays a role in mediating soil moisture, and the most severe fire years have previously only occurred when there are droughts during strong El Niño years. Thus, climate change threatens drier peat soil moisture conditions which would increase peat fire risk. Here, we assess these potential impacts by modeling soil moisture responses to predicted climate change. To overcome the lack of regional-scale data for hydrologic variables and peat properties necessary to parametrize a physical model, we used for a statistical modeling approach. Specifically, we used an artificial neural network to relate remotely sensed observations of soil moisture (SMAP) to climate reanalysis forcings (ERA5) and other datasets that characterize peatland degradation such as tree cover and canal density. After training the neural network on data from 2015-2020, we then compared moisture regimes under recent and future climate from state-of-the-science regional climate model projections (CORDEX-CORE) under RCP 8.5. Our findings suggest that reduced precipitation and increased evaporative demand, as predicted by the regional climate models, may cause significantly drier soil moisture regimes in the future. Future mean dry season soil moisture is found to be similar to that during 2015 and 2019 El Niño years, suggesting higher baseline fire risk. We further explore geographic differences in soil moisture responses, as mediated by differences in climate sensitivity between land use types.

    How to cite: Dadap, N., Cobb, A., Hoyt, A., Harvey, C., Feldman, A., Im, E.-S., and Konings, A.: Predicting climate change impacts to peatland soil moisture in Southeast Asia, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10763, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10763, 2022.

    EGU22-10949 | Presentations | HS10.7 | Highlight

    Vulnerability of peatland complexes in the Hudson Plains, Canada to permafrost-thaw-driven hydrological change 

    Mikhail Mack, William Quinton, James McLaughlin, and Christopher Hopkinson

    Thawing discontinuous permafrost in subarctic peatland-dominated landscapes is increasingly recognized as an indicator of a warming climate and potentially shifting these landscapes from atmospheric carbon store to source. Furthermore, in certain discontinuous permafrost landscapes (e.g., northwest Canada) the thaw of permafrost peatlands leads to a reorganization of near-surface flow paths as permafrost-free peatlands expand, connect, merge, and drain. Collectively, these permafrost-thaw-driven landcover and hydrological changes have increased runoff and altered biogeochemical cycles threatening natural resources and critical infrastructure in Indigenous peoples’ traditional territories along with aquatic and terrestrial wildlife habitat. Owing to the region’s remote position and vast scale, comparatively less is known about the landcover and hydrological impacts of permafrost thaw in the Hudson Plains, the world’s third largest peatland region (370,000 km2) and southern most extent continental permafrost. For this study, we assign specific hydrological functions to individual peatland types based on their form, to then infer hydrological flux and storage processes within and between peatlands un a circuitry analog, at the scale of the peatland complexes and peatland complex regions. We analyze several remotely sensed data, including high-resolution lidar, historical air photographs, and recent panchromatic and multispectral satellite imagery along a latitudinal transect to evaluate peatland form, complex, and regional patterns. We then summarise these results and interpretation to present an initial vulnerability map of peatland complexes in the Hudson Plains to permafrost-thaw-driven hydrological change.  

    How to cite: Mack, M., Quinton, W., McLaughlin, J., and Hopkinson, C.: Vulnerability of peatland complexes in the Hudson Plains, Canada to permafrost-thaw-driven hydrological change, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10949, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10949, 2022.

    EGU22-11220 | Presentations | HS10.7

    Hydrological impacts of contrasting gully blocking techniques for peat restoration and natural flood management in a degraded blanket peatland 

    Tim Allott, Donald Edokpa, Thea Cummings, Martin Evans, Emma Shuttleworth, David Milledge, Martin Kay, Adam Johnson, Tim Howson, Joe Rees, and Tom Spencer

    Erosion gullies are a common feature of degraded blanket peatlands and in recent years gully blocking has been increasingly employed as a restoration approach. The stated aims of gully blocking are typically to stabilise eroding gullies and to rewet the adjacent peatland by raising water tables, but in recent years the potential benefits of gully blocking for natural flood management (NFM) have also been recognised. However, data on the hydrological effects of gully blocking and for different gully blocking techniques are sparse.

    We report on a before-after-control-intervention (BACI) experiment of gully blocking in peatland micro-catchments (hectare scale) in the Peak District National Park, UK. Three different gully blocking interventions were made in March 2020: impermeable peat dams, permeable cobble dams, and peat dams with a restricted diameter bypass pipe. The first two interventions represent standard restoration techniques, whereas the piped peat dams are specifically designed to be optimal for natural flood management benefit. The micro-catchments were monitored for one year before and two years after gully blocking for: rainfall, discharge, depth to water table proximate to the gullies (within 2m) and depth to water table distal from the gullies (>10m away). Storm hydrograph data (peak discharges and lag times) were extracted for >120 storms from the rainfall-runoff data. All intervention data were analysed relative to data from a control micro-catchment.

    After blocking for all interventions there were significant declines in median depth to water table proximate to the gullies, with the magnitude of the rewetting benefit in the following order: peat dams > piped peat dams > cobble dams. There were no significant changes in depth to water table at the distal locations. Peat dams led to a slight increase in storm peak flows but no change in hydrograph lag times. Stone dams led to no change in peak flows but increases in lag times. Piped peat dams resulted in the greatest changes to storm hydrographs, with substantial declines in peak flows and increases in lag times once the pipe diameter had been optimised to the discharge regime.

    Peat dams maximise the rewetting benefits of gully blocking but appear to have limited NFM potential, whereas once optimised, piped peat dams provide maximum NFM benefit and greater water table recovery than stone dams.  These findings are important for restoration practitioners when making decisions on which gully blocking techniques to employ to balance the co-benefits of peatland restoration.

    How to cite: Allott, T., Edokpa, D., Cummings, T., Evans, M., Shuttleworth, E., Milledge, D., Kay, M., Johnson, A., Howson, T., Rees, J., and Spencer, T.: Hydrological impacts of contrasting gully blocking techniques for peat restoration and natural flood management in a degraded blanket peatland, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11220, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11220, 2022.

    EGU22-11300 | Presentations | HS10.7

    Water table depth dynamics derived from optical remote sensing data in northern peatlands 

    Iuliia Burdun, Michel Bechtold, Viacheslav Komisarenko, Annalea Lohila, Elyn Humphreys, Ankur R. Desai, Mats B. Nilsson, Eeva-Stiina Tuittila, Gabrielle De Lannoy, Evelyn Uuemaa, and Miina Rautiainen

    Water table depth (WTD) is one of the key factors that affect the carbon balance in peatlands. Optical remote sensing can detect WTD indirectly through the estimation of surface moisture. In peatlands, WTD and surface moisture conditions are closely related through the strong capillary connection in the topmost peat layer. We took advantage of this strong connection and calculated the OPtical TRApezoid Model (OPTRAM) that relies on the assumption that short-wave infrared reflectance represents the surface moisture conditions. OPTRAM was calculated based on Sentinel-2 MSI and Landsat 8 OLI over selected northern peatlands in Finland, Sweden, Canada, the USA, and Estonia. This is the first study in which the advantages and shortcomings of OPTRAM estimation from Sentinel-2 MSI and Landsat 8 OLI data were discussed. We calculated OPTRAM in two ways: (i) using a manual parametrisation and (ii) utilising a recently developed automatic parameterisation in Google Earth Engine. Further, we analysed the impact of these two parameterisations on OPTRAM performance in various peatlands. Our findings provide an important insight into the global applicability of OPTRAM for monitoring moisture conditions in northern peatlands.

    How to cite: Burdun, I., Bechtold, M., Komisarenko, V., Lohila, A., Humphreys, E., Desai, A. R., Nilsson, M. B., Tuittila, E.-S., De Lannoy, G., Uuemaa, E., and Rautiainen, M.: Water table depth dynamics derived from optical remote sensing data in northern peatlands, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11300, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11300, 2022.

    EGU22-314 | Presentations | HS10.8

    Estimating Head Induced by Moving Bedforms Using Dye Tracer Tests and Modeling 

    Yoni Teitelbaum, Tomer Shimony, Edwin Saavedra Cifuentes, Aaron Packman, Shai Arnon, and Scott Hansen

    Under moving bedform conditions, the shape of the sediment-water interface (SWI) is known to evolve over time. However, existing mathematical models of bedform-induced hyporheic exchange flux (HEF) assume a fixed bedform shape in determining the pressure boundary condition at the SWI. This simplifying assumption is adopted because there is no established method for prescribing head along an arbitrary, changing sediment-water interface (SWI). This gap has prevented most flow modeling efforts from accounting for the dynamics of bedform sizes and shapes, and it is currently not well understood how such dynamics are expected to affect transport and biogeochemical processes in streams. Previously, measurements of head along the SWI have been taken under stationary bed conditions using pressure sensors installed within bedforms, but installing sensors to take the same measurements under moving-bedform conditions is impractical. We propose a method to quantify the dynamics of hydraulic head at the SWI using timelapse photos of dye tracer tests, without installing any sensors in the flume. For every photo, an initial guess of head along the SWI is generated using established methods from the literature. Flow paths in the bed are calculated using the steady-state groundwater flow equation and Darcy’s Law. The predicted evolution of the dye plumes in the photo is compared against the dye plumes from the subsequent photo. This comparison is used as the objective criterion in an optimization procedure, which is run until the estimate of head at the SWI converges. Preliminary results show agreement with experimental observations from dye penetration tests. In providing a new way to estimate head under moving-bed conditions, this work is an important advance in realistic modeling of bedform-induced HEF and its effect on flow, transport, and biogeochemical processes in streams.

    How to cite: Teitelbaum, Y., Shimony, T., Saavedra Cifuentes, E., Packman, A., Arnon, S., and Hansen, S.: Estimating Head Induced by Moving Bedforms Using Dye Tracer Tests and Modeling, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-314, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-314, 2022.

    EGU22-401 | Presentations | HS10.8

    Kaolinite deposition and clogging of moving streambeds under losing and gaining flow conditions 

    Tomer Shimony, Edwin Saavedra Cifuentes, Aaron Packman, Yoni Teitelbaum, and Shai Arnon

    Clay deposition in streambed sediment can cause partial or complete clogging of the streambed. It was shown that clogging reduces the hyporheic exchange flux (HEF) between the water column and the streambed and can negatively affect stream ecosystems. For example, by reducing the fluxes of nutrients to benthic microorganisms. It has been shown that flow from the stream towards the groundwater (losing) or in the opposite direction (gaining) also affects clay deposition patterns; however, this has only been investigated experimentally under stationary bedform conditions. Here, we investigated the dynamics of clogging during moving bedform conditions and under losing or gaining fluxes. We conducted a series of experiments in a 640 long and 29 cm wide flume packed with sand (D50 = 270 μm). The flume is equipped with a drainage system that can simulate losing or gaining conditions at prescribed flux. We conducted experiments under two different losing fluxes and two gaining fluxes (10 and 20 cm/day), while stream velocity was constant at 29 cm/day.  During the experiments, kaolinite was added as a discrete series of pulses. Each pulse was added after the kaolinite deposition stabilized (2 - 4 days). HEF and the vertical hydraulic conductivity were quantified before each kaolinite addition by salt tracer test, and the “falling-head” methods, respectively. Morphodynamic properties of the bed were measured using high-frequency acoustic doppler sensor and time-lapse photometry timeseries. The kaolinite deposition rate was measured with a turbidity sensor, while core samples were taken at the end of the experiment to analyze the vertical deposition patterns. Preliminary results showed that HEF and hydraulic conductivity in losing conditions decreased from their initial value by 95% and 37%, respectively, while in gaining conditions, HEF decreased by 72% and hydraulic conductivity by 23%. We also observed that under gaining conditions, most of the clay was deposited at the upper part of the sediment (in the moving fraction). In losing conditions, kaolinite was also found deeper in the bed and below the moving fraction of the streambed. In all cases, most of the kaolinite mass was deposited at a depth of less than five cm. The results show a significant effect of stream-groundwater interactions on HEF and on suspended particle deposition in situations where the bed is under movement. Therefore, the quantification and prediction of clay deposition patterns in streams with strong interactions with groundwater has to be included in models that predict clogging and transport processes in streams. 

    How to cite: Shimony, T., Saavedra Cifuentes, E., Packman, A., Teitelbaum, Y., and Arnon, S.: Kaolinite deposition and clogging of moving streambeds under losing and gaining flow conditions, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-401, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-401, 2022.

    The groundwater-surface water interface, which is known as hyporheic zone, is a dynamic system that plays an important role in the hydrological functioning of catchments. During flow exchange, there are many chemical attenuation processes due to the variation of physical and chemical properties including surface water flow and the morphology of the riverbed. The fluctuations may depend on the seasonality, climatic zone, as well as due to the local variations such as soil structure, geology, land use, water sources etc.

    The goal of the study was to gain a depth orientated insight into the hyporheic exchange functioning, mainly focusing on the difference between upstream and downstream conditions. We collected water samples from 4 different depths until 0.5 m below the stream bed surface of the stream Ahna in Kassel, Germany, using multi-level interstitial probes. The samples were taken at different locations in the stream during a whole year. Water samples were analyzed for stable isotopes of water (δ2H and δ18O) and some major ions. Results indicate that the variations following the depth, sampling time and the location. Isotopic signatures show the summer enrichment and the winter depletion, mirroring the seasonality of stable isotopes in rainfall. We also observed an isotopic enrichment at the downstream sites and significantly higher ion concentrations, especially for K+, Na+, Mg2+, Cl-, NO3-, than the upstream. Water extraction flow rates decreased along the depth profile due to the changes in effective porosities and the hydraulic conductivities which were controlled by the sediment structure and clogging processes.

    How to cite: Mahindawansha, A. and Gassmann, M.: Evaluation of the hydraulic exchange in the hyporheic zone: A depth-oriented analysis focusing on upstream and downstream conditions., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1199, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1199, 2022.

    EGU22-1643 | Presentations | HS10.8

    The fate of trace organic compounds and their transformation products along specific hyporheic flow paths 

    Christoph J. Reith, Malte Posselt, Stephanie Spahr, Anke Putschew, Finn Amann, Reinhard Hinkelmann, and Jörg Lewandowski

    Trace organic compounds (TrOCs) are frequently detected in surface waters such as rivers. Possible entry pathways into the environment include stormwater runoff, industrial effluents, and wastewater treatment plant (WWTP) effluents. Understanding the behavior of TrOCs and their transformation products (TPs) is important, as they represent a risk to ecosystem and human health. The hyporheic zone of a river shows high turnover rates for nutrients, dissolved organic carbon, metals, pathogens, and TrOCs. Turnover rates are dependent on both, hydrological and biogeochemical conditions. We conducted a high-frequency sampling campaign in the urban lowland River Erpe (Brandenburg, Germany) which receives treated wastewater from the WWTP Muenchehofe. The aim was to study the fate of TrOCs and respective TPs along specific hyporheic flow paths. The basic idea was to enable the sampling of water parcels along specific hyporheic flow paths by forcing the flow path with a pipe (diameter: 8 cm, length: 27 cm, maximum depth: 17 cm) onto a specific path similar to the natural one. Wood on top of the pipe should increase the hyporheic exchange flow through the pipe and mimic the effect of woody debris which is often used in river restorations. Samples from the hyporheic zone and the surface water were taken every 2 hours for 14 hours. The samples were analyzed for oxygen concentrations, redox parameters, nutrients, and TrOCs. We found a clear redox zonation along the flow paths inside the pipes and investigated its impacts on the fate of TrOCs and their TPs. The hyporheic zone proved as an important river compartment for the retention of TrOCs and their TPs.

    How to cite: Reith, C. J., Posselt, M., Spahr, S., Putschew, A., Amann, F., Hinkelmann, R., and Lewandowski, J.: The fate of trace organic compounds and their transformation products along specific hyporheic flow paths, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1643, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1643, 2022.

    EGU22-2003 | Presentations | HS10.8

    Investigating Roles of Baseflow on Water Level in Lake Urmia, Iran 

    Somayeh Moghimi Nezhad, Changhyun Jun, Roya Narimani, Jongyun Byun, Jongjin Baik, and Jinwook Lee

    Lake Urmia has experienced a decline in water level by about 40 cm per year in recent decades. Investigating the relationship between baseflow and water level in the lake is essential for better understanding of changes in water level. This study aims to estimate baseflow in the Urmia basin for analyzing the interaction between changes in baseflow and water level in the lake. The Eckhardt filter and mass balance filter (MBF) were considered for baseflow separation at nine stations in the Urmia basin with observation data from 2010 to 2018. It should be noted that each result for baseflow separation was compared in terms of catchment characteristics and climate parameters. Here, the constant filter α and BFImax (the maximum value of the baseflow index (BFI)) were estimated for the Eckhardt filter. Also, electrical conductivity (EC) was used to determine baseflow from the MBF. The relationship between groundwater, baseflow, and water level in the lake was determined by Kendall-Tau coefficients. The result shows that the value of 0.978 for α has the best performance in baseflow estimation from the Eckhardt filter and MBF. The relationship between groundwater, baseflow, and water level in the lake was statistically significant with respect to Kendall-Tau correlations (p ≤ 0.05). The BFI shows that 70% of the runoff at Lake Urmia comes from streamflow, and indicates potential risks of changes in groundwater levels.

     

    Keywords: Baseflow Separation, Water Level, Eckhardt Filter, Mass Balance Filter, Baseflow Index, Lake Urmia

    How to cite: Moghimi Nezhad, S., Jun, C., Narimani, R., Byun, J., Baik, J., and Lee, J.: Investigating Roles of Baseflow on Water Level in Lake Urmia, Iran, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2003, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2003, 2022.

    EGU22-2015 | Presentations | HS10.8

    A Novel Framework for Simulating Flow and Transport Processes during Bedforms Movement 

    Shai Arnon, Yoni Teitelbaum, Tomer Shimony, Edwin Cifuentes, Jonathan Dallmann, Colin Phillips, Aaron Packman, and Scott Hansen

    Most current models for predicting flow and transport processes in bedforms do not consider that sandy streambeds occasionally move. In addition, models that consider bedform movement have used a moving reference frame, typically corresponding to an individual moving bedform. However, the latter approach cannot simulate the accumulation of fine particles at a given location over time as a modeling outcome or any other process influenced by the passage of multiple bedforms. We present a novel simulation framework that models periodic mobile bedforms within a stationary reference frame. This approach is combined with particle tracking to successfully reproduce clay deposition observations in sand beds and the resulting development of a low-conductivity layer near the scour zone. Passage of successive bedforms is represented by varying the shape of the top boundary of the domain. Simulation results successfully reproduce experimental observations of the development of the low-conductivity layer near the scour zone. We found that increased bedform celerity and filtration both lead to a shallower depth of clay deposition and a more compact deposition layer. While increased filtration causes more clay to deposit, increased celerity reduces deposition by flattening hyporheic exchange flow paths. Adopting this novel modeling approach creates opportunities to study realistic situations such as the influence of the passage of bedforms with changing sizes and shapes on flow and transport processes in sandy streams. 

    How to cite: Arnon, S., Teitelbaum, Y., Shimony, T., Cifuentes, E., Dallmann, J., Phillips, C., Packman, A., and Hansen, S.: A Novel Framework for Simulating Flow and Transport Processes during Bedforms Movement, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2015, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2015, 2022.

    Transient storage models (TSM) are a valuable tool for investigating the distribution and transport of solutes, nutrients, and pollutants in the stream corridor. The application of TSM is fundamental for understanding the continuous exchange of water between the active stream channel and dead zones, in-stream sediments, and the adjacent groundwater. Despite the large amount of studies, TSM applications are often limited by the lack of information on parameters certainty. Among the available studies, only few addressed sensitivity of TSM parameters and found poor parameter identifiability and substantial model uncertainty, which make the current interpretation of TSM results rather challenging. This issue raises the question if and when TSM parameters are actually meaningful. Addressing identifiability of TSM parameters is pivotal, since uncertainty in parameter estimation and their interpretation limit linking specific physical processes to model parameters.

    Here, we apply a step-sampling approach that combines global identifiability analysis with dynamic identifiability analysis to evaluate model sensitivity and uncertainty in a set of tracer breakthrough experiments in a headwater stream reach. Our results demonstrate that limitations in parameter identifiability often found in several TSM studies can be related to: (i) the assumption velocity = velocitypeak; (ii) the large parameter range used for the parameters sampling; and (iii) the relatively low number of sampled parameter sets. While it is generally assumed that advection-dispersion parameters act on the solute arrival time, and that transient-storage parameters control the tail of the breakthrough curve (BTC), our study brings new insights on the role of TSM parameters in controlling the solute transport in streams. The proposed step-sampling approach allowed us to clearly reduce uncertainty of parameters in TSM highlighting the importance of TSM parameters in certain sections of the BTC, where they are usually assumed to be negligible. By targeting the identifiability range of transient-storage parameters on the tail of the BTC, the applied step-sampling approach bears significant potential for substantially increasing TSM parameters identifiability, and for advancing our understanding of hydrological processes involved in solute transport in streams.

    How to cite: Bonanno, E., Blöschl, G., and Klaus, J.: Improving the identifiability of Transient Storage Model parameters to explore process information in solutes breakthrough curve, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2030, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2030, 2022.

    In this project a water management concept for the southern Randowbruch is developed, which meets the climate protection goals according to the Climate Protection Plan 2050 of the German Ministry of Environment regarding a comprehensive moor protection in the Randowbruch. The paper forms the basis for the realization of a management concept and deals in particular with the analysis of the special characteristics of the catchment area and the possible management options with the current management system. The catchment area of the Randow has a long and highly anthropogenic influenced history of melioration. The moor, which formed during the Vistula Ice Age around 18,000 years ago in the washout channel of a glacier, has been continuously drained and made agriculturally usable throughout the past 300 years by targeted human interventions. The moor was drained by ditches installed along the original main receiving water, the Randow, and dams to control water levels for agricultural use. The draining measures reached their peak in the 60s and 70s of the 20th century and have remained unchanged since. Taking into account the intensive interaction between groundwater and surface water in this area, the analysis of this catchment with a hydrological model is only possibly by including this interaction. The primary process of this interaction is the exfiltration of groundwater into the system of ditches, as well as the infiltration of water back into the groundwater. Thus, the evaporation and in particular the water levels of areas with high levels of groundwater and the adjacent ditches represent the essential boundary conditions for the exchange of the two hydrological units. Therefore, the basis for the development of the management concept is a coupled model of ArcEGMO and FEFLOW, with FEFLOW modeling the groundwater flow and ArcEGMO simulating the hydrologic balance and the complex system of water bodies. 

    Keywords: 

    coupled modeling, ArcEGMO, FELFOW, water resource management, moor protection 

    How to cite: Tix, M.: Coupled surface and groundwater modeling for the analysis of management options in groundwater affected catchment areas, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2178, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2178, 2022.

    EGU22-4381 | Presentations | HS10.8

    Interacting Influence of Log Jams and Branching Channels on Stream-Groundwater Exchange 

    Audrey H. Sawyer`, Karl Wilhelmsen, Anna Marshall, Xiaolang Zhang, Christian Roumelis, Kamini Singha, and Ellen Wohl

    Log jams restructure the hyporheic zone, or region where stream water and groundwater mix, by storing sediment, widening the stream in backwater areas, forcing new channel branches, and altering hydraulic gradients that drive hyporheic exchange. Here, we use flume and numerical experiments to quantify the effects of interacting jam structures and channel branches on hyporheic exchange at three stream flow rates. The presence of multiple jams increased wetted streambed area (the area available for hyporheic exchange) by 9-38% and increased hyporheic fluxes across the bed by roughly an order of magnitude, leading to an order-of-magnitude decrease in the turnover length that stream water travels before interacting with the hyporheic zone. Decreased turnover lengths corresponded with greater reaction significance per km, a measure of the potential for the hyporheic zone to influence stream water chemistry. For low-flow conditions, log jams increased reaction significance per km five-fold, from 0.07 to 0.35. Jams with larger volumes led to longer hyporheic residence times and path lengths that exhibited multiple scales of exchange. Additionally, the longest flow paths connecting multiple jams occurred in the reach with multiple channel branches. These findings suggest that large gains in hydrologic connectivity can be achieved by promoting in-stream wood accumulation and the natural formation of both jams and branching channels. More studies are needed at field scales to understand relationships between jams, wetted channel area, and hyporheic fluxes under natural and more complex conditions. 

    How to cite: Sawyer`, A. H., Wilhelmsen, K., Marshall, A., Zhang, X., Roumelis, C., Singha, K., and Wohl, E.: Interacting Influence of Log Jams and Branching Channels on Stream-Groundwater Exchange, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4381, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4381, 2022.

    EGU22-4567 | Presentations | HS10.8

    A novel conceptualization to estimate unsaturated zone mass-fluxes and integrate pre-existing surface- and ground- water models 

    Veethahavya Kootanoor Sheshadrivasan, Jakub Langhammer, Holger Class, and Ulrich Lang

    A good portion of our socio-economic activity relies on groundwater - a seemingly inexhaustible supply of water. Only in the recent past has the true limited nature of groundwater resources drawn mainstream attention. Groundwater resources largely remain an invisible resource, thus posing a challenge to its management and sustainable use. Replenishment of exploited groundwater reserves is a pressing issue in ensuring water security. The primary pathway of influxes into most groundwater (GW) reserves is via infiltration of surface water (SW), often through the unsaturated zone (UZ). Studying GW fluxes calls for an integrated assessment of the fluxes between GW, UZ, and SW systems - dynamically in both spatial and temporal domains. Such an integrated approach becomes even essential to study the effects of climate change on our hydrosystems.

    Numerical modelling of GW-UZ-SW fluxes holds tremendous potential in visualising the invisible resource. However, numerical modelling of hydrosystems has largely remained fragmented between hydrology and hydrogeology, for various warranted reasons.

    Often, the cost of building and running an integrated GW-SW model outweighs its benefits. A good portion of the cost can be attributed to the need to model the UZ fluxes. Farthing and Ogden (2017) outline well, the challenges associated with modelling the UZ.

    Although there exist numerous integrated models ranging from physically based ones to conceptual models, they have not yet convinced the mostly fragmented community of hydrologists and hydrogeologists to utilize them as general-purpose modelling tools for local to regional scales. Barthel and Banzhaf (2015) review the state of integrated GW-SW modelling at such scales. Furthermore, the need to acquaint oneself with new modelling tools adds to the cost of utilizing an integrated modelling approach.

    In this study, we aim to design a conceptual model to adequately model UZ fluxes with the primary aim of integrating existing GW and SW models along with the help of an explicit coupling scheme. The conceptualization is inspired by the HBV model and utilizes distributed bucket-like storage compartments on which computations are performed at each discrete element and timestep over the model domain. The model primarily sets out to describe the fluxes entering and exiting the UZ, while also partitioning the precipitation as influxes into the three respective storage terms (GW, UZ, and SW), and drawing the evapotranspiration from the affected storage terms, employing the principle of mass-balance. While the UZ storage term is retained in the model, GW and SW levels are read from the respective models at the beginning of the coupling time-step and their subsequent changes are reported as discharges at the end of the time-step, making these storages virtual.

    The model has shown promising results in a preliminary application at a peat-bog near Lake Constance. Yet it leaves plenty of room for improvement. Findings from the previous application are planned to be used in (I) testing and validation in a controlled theoretical case, and (II) application, calibration, and validation in an experimental catchment jointly maintained by the Department of Physical Geography and Geoecology of Charles University in the Sumava Mountains.

    How to cite: Kootanoor Sheshadrivasan, V., Langhammer, J., Class, H., and Lang, U.: A novel conceptualization to estimate unsaturated zone mass-fluxes and integrate pre-existing surface- and ground- water models, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4567, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4567, 2022.

    EGU22-5521 | Presentations | HS10.8

    Labile DOC increases P removal efficiencies in the benthic zone and shifts P thresholds towards higher P concentrations 

    Nuria Perujo, Lola Neuert, Patrick Fink, Norbert Kamjunke, Nergui Sunjidmaa, Markus Weitere, and Daniel Graeber

    Biofilms in river sediments play a key role in P retention in aquatic ecosystems. Most studies in freshwater ecosystems focus mainly on the autotrophic component of biofilms but little is known about the role of heterotrophic components on P removal. It is known that DOC in some streams is of low bioavailability, hence, resulting in severe DOC and P co-limitation of heterotrophic biofilm growth which could then constrain P removal efficiency. How DOC limitation affects P removal efficiency in the benthic zone and how it modifies P thresholds (i.e. concentration from which the removal efficiency decreases) are still open questions.

    We performed an experiment in the MOBICOS (Streamside Mobile Mesocosms) in the Holtemme River (Germany) to study the role of labile DOC on P thresholds in P retention in the bed-sediment biofilm community. Our flume experiment followed a BACI design (before: no DOC addition; after: labile DOC addition at C:P molar ratios >100; control: basal P and DOC concentrations; impact: P concentrations ranging from 25 µg P/L to 420 µg P/L).

    Our results show that labile DOC increases the P removal efficiency of the system (i.e. P water mass balances in the flumes) and shifts P thresholds for P removal towards higher P concentrations meaning that at a given P concentration higher P removal efficiency is achieved if the system is supplied with labile DOC. Labile DOC activated the heterotrophic component in the flumes and benthic biofilms receiving labile DOC show higher bacterial density and higher P accumulation compared to the ones not receiving labile DOC.

    Our results demonstrate that the heterotrophic biofilm community plays a key role in in-stream phosphorus retention. As it relies on availability of labile DOC, the interaction of DOC and P dynamics need consideration in models for stream nutrient processing and retention.

    How to cite: Perujo, N., Neuert, L., Fink, P., Kamjunke, N., Sunjidmaa, N., Weitere, M., and Graeber, D.: Labile DOC increases P removal efficiencies in the benthic zone and shifts P thresholds towards higher P concentrations, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5521, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5521, 2022.

    EGU22-6273 | Presentations | HS10.8

    Quantification of groundwater inflow along Moselle River by using a multiple tracer approach (222-Rn, Tritium, and δ18O) 

    Michael Engel, Simon Mischel, Sabrina Quanz, Sven Frei, Benjamin Gilfedder, Dirk Radny, and Axel Schmidt

    Groundwater represents a major component for runoff generation of large rivers systems. Its quantification is of uttermost importance during low flow periods and in the context of changing runoff dynamics due to climate change.

    The present study focuses on the surface water-groundwater interaction using the example of the Moselle River, the second most important tributary of the Rhine. The river is classified as a federal waterway and has 12 barrages on German territory to ensure navigability all year round.

    The research approach is based on the assumption that local groundwater inflow into the Moselle is detectable by increased 222-Rn concentrations in the river and that the δ18O composition of the river water approximates that of the groundwater. Therefore, we applied a numerical model for solving the 222-Rn and Tritium mass balance and a mixing model of δ18O and electrical conductivity.

    For this purpose, water samples were taken at intermediate flow conditions (gauge Cochem: about 220 m³/s) in October 2020 along the Moselle on a stretch of 242 kilometers at high spatial resolution (every 2 km) to measure stable water isotopes and electrical conductivity. Integrated over the same spatial resolution, in-situ 222-Rn measurements were carried out. Tributaries and selected groundwater monitoring wells were sampled for the same analysis. Precipitation was collected at the station Trier of the German Meteorological Service on a monthly basis. In agreement with this measurement concept, another sampling campaign took place for selected reaches in August/September 2021 at lower discharges (Cochem gauge: about 94 m³/s).

    In autumn 2020, diffuse groundwater inflow (approx. 0.17 to 0.3 m³/s) was detected for the shell limestone of the upper Moselle reaches and locally increased groundwater inflow for the middle reaches in the transition area to the Rhenish Slate Mountains and the Detzem barrage (approx. 1.4 to 2.4 m³/s). These estimates translate into groundwater contribution of the total Moselle discharge of 0.3 and 1.2 % respectively, which is much lower than those calculated by the mixing model (about 10 and 5 %, respectively). For August/September 2021, higher groundwater inflows in these areas are expected for both methods.

    The evaluation to date indicates that 222-Rn is the most sensitive tracer to locations with increased groundwater inflow compared to tritium and stable water isotopes. While tritium results seem to strongly depend on the current flow conditions and the propagating river wave, stable isotope results are affected by the appropriate characterization of end-member hydrochemistry.

    How to cite: Engel, M., Mischel, S., Quanz, S., Frei, S., Gilfedder, B., Radny, D., and Schmidt, A.: Quantification of groundwater inflow along Moselle River by using a multiple tracer approach (222-Rn, Tritium, and δ18O), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6273, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6273, 2022.

    The protection of water resources is a challenging task and requires a detailed understanding of surface water and groundwater dynamics and interactions. Integrated groundwater and surface water models represent useful tools to assess how groundwater affects the quantity and quality of surface water, which is often a source of drinking water. It is the case for the City of Quebec, Canada, where surface water is the only source of drinking water and where water managers must assess its vulnerability to contamination and depletion. This work focuses on the Nelson River catchment (70 km2), located within the larger catchment of the main drinking water source in Quebec City. The objective is to quantify the links between groundwater and surface water with the 3D integrated hydrological model HydroGeoSphere and simulate coupled surface/subsurface water flow and contaminant transfer. The Nelson catchment model has been calibrated to reproduce observed surface discharges and water table level measurements. Coupled surface water and groundwater flow is then simulated over multiple years using daily meteorological data. Output variables such as distributed infiltration, preferential flow pathways, inter-seasonal changes of surface water volumes, unsaturated and saturated groundwater volumes, are analysed to assess the link between surface water and groundwater. Since this urban area is undergoing growing urbanisation, future scenarios of urban development are also simulated to evaluate the impact of soil sealing on surface/groundwater interactions. The understanding of surface/subsurface interactions in this particular context aims at assessing the vulnerability of the surface drinking water source.

    How to cite: Gatel, L., Tremblay, Y., and Therrien, R.: Integrated surface and subsurface hydrological modelling to support the assessment of the vulnerability of surface water supplies., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6397, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6397, 2022.

    EGU22-6480 | Presentations | HS10.8

    Influence of sediment depth and groundwater underflow on residence time distributions in dune-shaped streambeds 

    Fulvio Boano, Ahmed Monofy, and Stanley Grant

    Stream dunes have been widely recognized among the major morphological features driving water exchange between a stream and its sediments, and many modeling studies have been performed to characterize hyporheic exchange induced by this type of bedforms. Despite of these efforts, the high number of factors that affect hyporheic exchange has not been completely addressed yet, mainly because of the simplifying assumptions that are unavoidably required to reduce the complexity of the problem. For instance, the effect of the limited extent of the thickness of the sediment layer on the Residence Time Distribution (RTDs) of hyporheic exchange has not been fully explored. This incomplete knowledge is particularly relevant due to the paramount role of RTDs in controlling biogeochemical reactions in microbiologically active sediments.

    In this context, this study presents a modeling analysis of RTDs in dune-shaped streambeds of finite depth in the presence of groundwater flow. Numerical simulations of particle tracking have been performed to determine the combined influence of sediment depth and horizontal underflow on the shape of RTDs. Moreover, different analytical distributions (Exponential, Gamma, LogNormal, Fréchet) have been fitted to the numerical RTDs, and the best distribution for each range of dimensionless sediment depth and underflow velocity have been identified on the basis of Anderson-Darling tests.

    How to cite: Boano, F., Monofy, A., and Grant, S.: Influence of sediment depth and groundwater underflow on residence time distributions in dune-shaped streambeds, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6480, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6480, 2022.

    EGU22-7006 | Presentations | HS10.8

    De-clogging riverbeds with artificial flushing in a near-natural bypass channel 

    Markus Noack, Beatriz Negreiros, Maximilian Kunz, Alcides Aybar Galdos, Sebastian Schwindt, Stefan Haun, and Silke Wieprecht

    The infiltration and accumulation of fine sediments in gravel riverbeds (clogging, colmation) is a natural process, especially in rivers with heterogeneous particle size distributions. However, natural rivers are characterized by regularly occurring flood events that lead to bed alterations and hence, flushing of infiltrated fine sediments. In the case of high non-natural fine sediment inputs and/or regulated low flows, this fragile balance between clogging and de-clogging is disturbed and may finally lead to heavily clogged riverbeds with well-known ecological consequences, especially for macroinvertebrates and gravel-spawning fish.

    This study presents the application of a novel approach called MultiPAC (Multi-Parameter Approach to assess Colmation) that assesses the efficiency of an artificial flood event on de-clogging of the riverbed of a near-natural bypass channel.

    In contrast to existing methods for determining colmation, which typically use qualitative approaches (e.g., mapping) or single-parameters (e.g., fine sediment contents), MultiPAC is designed to measure four in-situ key parameters, notably the particle size distribution, the porosity, the hydraulic conductivity, and the dissolved oxygen content. In particular, the combined measurements of hydraulic conductivity and dissolved oxygen along vertical profiles of the riverbed (VertiCO – Vertical profiles of hydraulic Conductivity and dissolved Oxygen) with a spatial resolution of 3.0 cm enable insights into gravel riverbeds and provide an exact vertical localization of clogged layers.

    The sediment characteristics of the near natural bypass channel show a distinct difference before and after the artificial flood. The vertical profiles of the measured hydraulic conductivities show increasing values up to a sediment depth of approx. 10 - 15 cm, which proves the efficiency of the artificial flood regarding de-clogging. In addition, the particle size analyses of most freezecore samples show a reduction in fine sediment fractions along with increasing porosity, which confirms the effectiveness of the flood operation. However, the vertical profile measurements show a reduction in dissolved oxygen concentrations after the artificial flood, which cannot be explained by the changed sediment characteristics or differences in the water temperatures in the hyporheic zone. Most likely, an apparent and widely spread Algae layer on the riverbed significantly influenced the oxygen measurements and a before-and-after comparison is not feasible because the Algae layer was removed during the artificial flood.

    The conclusion of this study is twofold: On the one hand, it could be proven that the artificial flood was sufficient to trigger de-clogging effects. On the other hand, the application of MultiPAC showed its potential for evaluating clogging/de-clogging processes in gravel riverbeds. Especially the detection of the impact depth of de-clogging events represent highly valuable information for designing artificial floods.

    How to cite: Noack, M., Negreiros, B., Kunz, M., Aybar Galdos, A., Schwindt, S., Haun, S., and Wieprecht, S.: De-clogging riverbeds with artificial flushing in a near-natural bypass channel, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7006, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7006, 2022.

    EGU22-7277 | Presentations | HS10.8

    Significance of lacustrine groundwater discharge for the rapid eutrophication of formerly oligotrophic Lake Stechlin 

    Jörg Lewandowski, Anna Jäger, Franziska Mehler, Tobias Goldhammer, and Michael Hupfer

    Lake Stechlin was an oligotrophic lake but experienced rapid eutrophication in the last 12 years. The speed of the deterioration is surprising, especially since the lake is located in a nature reserve, its catchment is almost entirely forested, there is no agriculture and there are only two small settlements with a total of less than 1000 inhabitants. Undoubtedly, groundwater is a crucial component of the water and compound balances of Stechlin, as there are no surface inflows. However, if one considers the total amount of groundwater entering the lake and the maximum compound loads possible with it, groundwater alone cannot explain the rapid increase in P concentrations in the Stechlin. Thus, internal P cycling, i.e. the mobilization of previously imported P, is an important process in the biogeochemistry of the lake. However, even if it is true that most of the P is remobilized by internal processes, it can still originate originally from groundwater. And groundwater might be the decisive trigger of the eutrophication in recent years. We provide evidence that not only P import from groundwater is the trigger, but also changes in loads of compounds that are closely coupled to the P cycle, namely calcium, manganese, iron and sulphate. While there is some evidence of elevated concentrations in the aquifer below the two settlements, the main P import into the Stechlin probably originates from the eutrophic Lake Dagow, which drains into Lake Stechlin via the aquifer.

    How to cite: Lewandowski, J., Jäger, A., Mehler, F., Goldhammer, T., and Hupfer, M.: Significance of lacustrine groundwater discharge for the rapid eutrophication of formerly oligotrophic Lake Stechlin, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7277, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7277, 2022.

    EGU22-7445 | Presentations | HS10.8

    Integrated numerical modeling of microplastic transport in fluvial systems 

    Franz Dichgans, Jan-Pascal Boos, Sven Frei, and Jan H. Fleckenstein

    Although rivers and streams are major transport vectors of microplastics into the marine environment, little research has been conducted to understand the transport behavior of microplastic particles in fluvial systems. This work contributes to the understanding of these transport processes, specifically focusing on the interface of the surface water flow and the hyporheic zone.

    Transport of microplastic particles in fluvial systems is currently modeled mainly at larger, river- or basin-wide scales using existing hydrodynamic and sediment transport models. To investigate the transport behavior of microplastic particles along the interface between the hyporheic zone and the open water flow domain, smaller-scale models are required so that the complex processes in this region can be adequately represented and analyzed.

    To this end, a novel modeling technique will be presented based on the open source CFD toolbox OpenFOAM. It combines a new coupling approach for the hydrodynamic processes in the surface water and hyporheic zone with transport modeling of microplastics.

    The methodology considers the latest findings regarding deposition and resuspension of microplastic particles as well as the hyporheic exchange in a fully coupled model. The model is validated by accompanying flume experiments and relevant transport processes are identified from the presented scenario simulations.

    How to cite: Dichgans, F., Boos, J.-P., Frei, S., and Fleckenstein, J. H.: Integrated numerical modeling of microplastic transport in fluvial systems, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7445, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7445, 2022.

    EGU22-7538 | Presentations | HS10.8

    Quantification of groundwater recharge from an ephemeral braided river using satellite photography 

    Antoine Di Ciacca, Scott Wilson, Jasmine Kang, and Thomas Wöhling

    In the coastal plains of New Zealand, braided rivers lose a considerable amount of water to the groundwater system, and for many aquifers are the largest source of recharge. Quantifying the recharge rates/transmission losses and how they relate to river stage and flow is particularly challenging. A commonly used approach to estimating recharge rates/transmission losses is differential flow gauging, where river discharges are measured simultaneously at multiple locations along a given reach. However, differential flow gauging is labour-intensive and limited by the accuracy of river discharge measurements, particularly in braided river systems.

    We have developed an alternative method for ephemeral rivers using river stage monitoring and widely available satellite photography. The method was applied to the upstream part of the Selwyn River (Canterbury, New Zealand), which is perennial in its mountainous environment, but becomes ephemeral once it crosses its alluvial plain. The river stage near the downstream boundary of the perennial reach was monitored for the period of March 2020 to May 2021 and a stage-discharge rating curve was developed. Downstream of the monitoring station, the river becomes ephemeral with the drying front location changing over time. On a number of 146 suitable satellite photographs, taken within the stage recording period, and retrieved from the Planet application program interface, we identified the position of the drying front, and used this to determine the length of the active (wet) river channel. This enabled us to calculate the average river transmission losses by dividing the river discharge at the monitoring station by the downstream active river length. The transmission losses estimated using the satellite photography correspond well with the losses estimated using seven sets of independent differential flow gauging surveys, given the respective uncertainties of both methods. The average estimated transmission losses range from 0.2 to 1 m3/s/km. Most of the estimated losses are below 0.4 m3/s/km and correspond to baseflow periods. The highest losses occur shortly after peak flows and decrease exponentially with time after the peak.

    We hypothesize that the high losses, occurring shortly after peak flows, are due to the replenishment of the shallow braid plain aquifer associated with the river. Lower losses, occurring during baseflow periods, represent groundwater recharge to the deeper regional aquifer. Groundwater recharge to the deeper regional aquifer appears to be linearly correlated with the groundwater head in the shallow aquifer. This response is consistent with the presence of an unsaturated zone that has been identified between the shallow (riverine) and deeper (regional) aquifers. Furthermore, we have successfully trained a random forest regression model to reconstruct the transmission losses for every day of the study period. The daily transmission loss dataset can now be used to evaluate our physically-based groundwater – surface water interaction models, currently under development, as well as support water management in the Selwyn basin.

    How to cite: Di Ciacca, A., Wilson, S., Kang, J., and Wöhling, T.: Quantification of groundwater recharge from an ephemeral braided river using satellite photography, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7538, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7538, 2022.

    About 90% of rivers and streams are originating in headwater catchments. Headwater catchments are more susceptible to climate change and sensitive to drought conditions. Extreme weather events (such as extended drought periods) are affecting water availability in headwater catchments which are important source areas for downstream river networks. Climate change is predicted to affect water availability for surface water bodies and groundwater alike. Future projections indicate that increasing temperature will affect the water balance with higher evapotranspiration rates. Headwater streams are often dependent on groundwater input specifically during baseflow conditions in summer/late summer. It is therefore important to investigate the potential impact of climate change on the interaction between surface water and groundwater in headwater catchments. As part of this study, we investigated the impact of local climate change on small scale surface/groundwater interactions for a small headwater catchment (Grosse Ohe) located in the Bavarian Forest (Germany). We used a the fully integrated hydrological model HydroGeoSphere (HGS) to represent surface groundwater interactions for the catchment. Simulations include data from regional climate change models (RCM) as input to represent future scenarios up to the year 2100. Results showed that increasing temperature causes higher evapotranspiration rates which significantly affects the water availability in headwater streams. Simulations indicate that climate change is responsible for more frequent drought periods during summer where groundwater inflow into the streams declines by up to 35% compared to the past (2002 to 2018). We also evaluated local exchange fluxes between groundwater and stream for the entire catchment. Here, simulations indicate that formerly gaining stream sections in future are more frequently turn into losing sections especially during extended baseflow conditions in summer. This may have severe consequences for the ecosystem as stream sections in future are prone to lose their entire water to the subsurface.

    How to cite: Munir, M. U. and Frei, S.: Impact of local climate change on groundwater resources and surface water availability in headwater catchments, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7691, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7691, 2022.

    EGU22-8108 | Presentations | HS10.8

    Identification of the Hydrological System of Kettle Holes of Northeastern Brandenburg, Germany based on their Geochemical Characteristics 

    Majid Taie Semiromi, Jörg Steidl, Masaki Hayashi, Ilja van Meerveld, and Christoph Merz

    Small postglacial depressions, such as kettle holes in northeastern Germany, are distributed across glacially embossed areas of the world. Water bodies forming in these depressions are distinct hydrological systems. Depending on the exchange fluxes with adjoining groundwater system, kettle holes are classified as recharge, flow-through-, and discharge-dominant systems. This classification is a result of their topographical position over an undulating landscape. The upland and lowland kettle holes across the undulating landscape are expected to represent recharge- and discharge-dominant systems, respectively. Hence, those located between these two are expected to be flow-through kettle holes. Nonetheless, due to the complexity of the geological setting of undulating postglacial landscapes, this topography-based classification may be wrong. Furthermore, the hydrological system of kettle holes varies in both time and space. Dynamic boundary conditions of kettle holes, resulting from extreme weather conditions such as severe or prolonged droughts and heavy storm events, may cause a discharge-dominant kettle hole to temporarily shift to a recharge-dominant or a flow-through system.

    Many kettle holes of northeastern Brandenburg, Germany are scattered throughout croplands. As a result, fertilizers are transported via the surface runoff and/or groundwater to the kettle holes. Thus, distribution and redistribution of water and solute from each of the kettle hole types and their adjoining groundwater domain and vice versa would likely be different. As these three types of kettle holes have different roles in the context of the hydrological cycle, differentiation of them based on the aforementioned classification would be of paramount importance for their proper characterization and role within a landscape hydrological system. A better characterization will also help to reduce the uncertainty in tracing water and solutes in these hydrogeologically complex systems. An extensive monitoring network of piezometers, installed within kettle holes and around them, is probably the most accurate method to characterize their hydrological system. However, its implementation is expensive, labor-intensive, and time-consuming. Therefore, it cannot be used for the determination of a landscape scale hydrological system containing a great number of kettle holes. The evaporation-to-inflow ratio (E/I) — derived from the stable isotopes of water (H and O) — has been demonstrated to be a viable alternative. We will present a new approach to determine the hydrological system of kettle holes based on geochemistry. To that end, eight chemical species (Ca, Mg, K, Na, Br, Cl, NO3, and SO4), and four in-situ parameters (temperature, pH, electrical conductivity, and redox potential) were monitored for 36 kettle holes over a 17 months period. Based on this dataset, the geochemical characteristics of the kettle holes will be identified using an advanced multivariate statistical algorithm, i.e. Gaussian finite mixture modelling (GFMM) and these will be compared to the hydrological classification of the kettle holes based on the E/I ratios.

     

    Keywords: Kettle Holes, Geochemical Characteristics, Groundwater System, Stable Water Isotopes, Germany

    How to cite: Taie Semiromi, M., Steidl, J., Hayashi, M., van Meerveld, I., and Merz, C.: Identification of the Hydrological System of Kettle Holes of Northeastern Brandenburg, Germany based on their Geochemical Characteristics, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8108, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8108, 2022.

    EGU22-8470 | Presentations | HS10.8

    Examining the impact of instream wood additions on hyporheic exchange in a lowland agricultural catchment 

    Nicholas Lugg, Ben Howard, Nick Kettridge, Sami Ullah, Simon Dixon, and Stefan Krause

    Increasingly, Instream wood  is (re)introduced into river systems to reverse decades of catchment mismanagement and to deliver nature-based solutions to contemporary water resource challenges such as flooding and pollutant attenuation. Most Research concerned with instream wood has focused on its ability to modify morphological and ecological conditions within a reach, but less work has considered the implications for hyporheic connectivity, a primary control of many ecosystem functions. Here, we investigate the impact of wood additions in river restoration on hyporheic exchange, at both the feature-scale and reach-scale,  with the application of a before-after-control-intervention experimental design.

    Research was conducted over a 200m long reach of Wood Brook (Staffordshire, UK), a lowland river, which drains a 3.1km2 catchment dominated by mixed-arable farmland and deciduous woodland. The experimental reach included 3 treatment sites where channel-spanning wood features were installed, 2 sites with natural wood features, and 3 control sites that were appropriate for treatment but received no intervention. High-resolution-temperature-sensors (HRTS) were installed at these sites to capture the temperature in the surface water and at 3 hyporheic depths, up to 25cm, at 3-minute intervals. Furthermore, a series of smart tracer injections allowed us to estimate (metabolically active) transient storage before and after intervention, in both the treatment sub-reach which had received wood additions and the control sub-reach which had not.

    Results indicate, once background conditions are excluded from the dataset, that the mean difference between hyporheic and surface water temperatures across the treatment sites reduced by 31% over the course of the study whilst the control sites remained unchanged. Further examination determined that the daily mean temperatures observed at treatment sites were significantly different to those witnessed at the control sites. This suggests that the introduction of instream wood fostered an increase in the magnitude of hyporheic exchange. This is supported by the analysis of before-after intervention data, where a smaller deviation was observed between surface water and hyporheic temperatures across the treatment sites when compared with the control group. Preliminary analysis of smart tracer injections suggests that wood additions increase reach-scale residence times of surface water and reach-scale metabolism.

    The current research supports observations previously derived from flume and model-based studies, suggesting that the addition of instream wood alters the magnitude of localised hyporheic exchange. Enhanced hyporheic exchange can offer numerous benefits to a reach including: increased habitat diversity, improved primary production, and greater attenuation and transformation of pollutants. Therefore, research within this area offers valuable insights for water resource managers who are increasingly under pressure to improve the health of our riverine environments as stipulated by international policies such as the European Unions’ Water Framework Directive. While our research has contributed to advancing current knowledge surrounding how instream wood alters hyporheic connectivity, there remains numerous questions which need addressing prior to its widespread application to global watersheds.

    How to cite: Lugg, N., Howard, B., Kettridge, N., Ullah, S., Dixon, S., and Krause, S.: Examining the impact of instream wood additions on hyporheic exchange in a lowland agricultural catchment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8470, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8470, 2022.

    EGU22-11042 | Presentations | HS10.8

    Groundwater born Fe(II) affects concentrations of  dissolved O2 in stream water 

    Silvia Parra-Suarez, Romy Wild, Johannes Barth Barth, Benjamin S. Gilfedder, Juergen Geist Geist, Silvia Dichner, and Stefan Peifer Peiffer

    The interface between groundwater and surface water is a critical zone that influences ecohydrological and biogeochemical cycles within the surface water ecosystems. It is characterized by complex redox gradients. with groundwater-mediated inflow of reduced substances into the stream water. 
    In this study, we have experimentally simulated the inflow of Fe(II)-rich groundwater with concentratrion of up to 1000 mmol L-1  into the open stream water of a flume system in order to quantify its effect on dissolved oxygen concentration in both the stream water and the hyporheic zone. The experimental setup consisted of 24 flumes, 12 of which were used for input of groundwater augumented with Fe(II), while the another 12 were used as controls, i. e., with inflow of Fe(II)-free groundwater. In addition, the experimental set-up provided the possibility to study the effects of fine sediment (coarse reference substratum (5% fine sediment content) vs. added fine sediment (35% fine sediment content) and low discharge (reference flow conditions vs. low discharge (drought) conditions within a threefold replicated, crossed design. All flumes had permanent groundwater input during the experiment. Fortnightly sampling campaigns were performed to analyze Fe(II), Fe(III),  and DO, concentrations in the porewater (hyporheic zone) and the open water over five consecutive weeks. 
    Our results clearly indicate that Fe(II) inflow resulted in a decrease of DO concentrations both in the porewater and subsequently in the open water, with distinct effects of sediment porosity and discharge. Over the five weeks, the sustained decrease between 40 and 50% of DO concentrations was more pronounced in flumes with fine sediment than in flumes with coarse sediments. Our findings suggest that increasing the Fe(II) concentration in the hyporheic zone can affect the availability of oxygen, important in controlling biogeochemical and ecological processes, microbial activities, and aquatic life. The formation of oxygen-depleted subsurface and surface waters in freshwater ecosystems has been associated with nutrient-rich waters stimulating eutrophication and the subsequent reduction of river health. In conclusion, this study highlights the importance of considering the effects of hyporheic redox processes and Fe(II) in assessing the health of stream ecosystems.  

    How to cite: Parra-Suarez, S., Wild, R., Barth, J. B., Gilfedder, B. S., Geist, J. G., Dichner, S., and Peiffer, S. P.: Groundwater born Fe(II) affects concentrations of  dissolved O2 in stream water, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11042, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11042, 2022.

    EGU22-11464 | Presentations | HS10.8

    Baseflow recession characteristic variation with the Basin Morphology. 

    Mehvish Hameed, Munir Ahmad Nayak, and Manzoor Ahmad Ahangar

    In the absence of precipitation or any other artificial input source, base-flow, a component of streamflow, sustains natural surface water bodies like rivers and streams. Therefore understanding, identifying, and extracting baseflow from streamflow measurement is essential for many hydrological studies, e.g., estimating watershed characteristics, long-term groundwater storage trends, flow regulations or water policy, water quantity, quality, supply, habitat and informing management of regional water resources. We aim to understand the morphologic factors that are known to influence groundwater outflow, for example, slope, length of the stream, drainage density, stream order, stream frequency on the baseflow recession characteristic or storage delay constant (K) in the watershed. We study how (K) varies with the choice of different estimation methods like using streamflow recession analysis by Brutsaert, (2008) algorithm, our newly developed algorithm for baseflow analysis, and using one of the solutions of Bossinesq’s groundwater flow equation. Using the aforementioned three techniques, the influence of significant morphologic characteristics is found for 56 small watersheds within the large watershed of the Rock River basin over the study period of 1990-2021. Using factor analysis we rank morphologic parameters in terms of their relative influence on (K). The findings of our study suggest that the morphologic parameters that influence the storage delay constant are intercorrelated and play a complex role in shaping the (K) values.

    How to cite: Hameed, M., Nayak, M. A., and Ahangar, M. A.: Baseflow recession characteristic variation with the Basin Morphology., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11464, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11464, 2022.

    Groundwater inflow into the Spree River and its tributaries is an important factor for the iron precipitation problem of the Spree in the Lusatian mining district (Eastern Germany). The input of dissolved iron into the Spree is difficult to estimate mainly because of unknown groundwater inflow. As part of this study, the radio-active isotope 222-Radon (222Rn) was used as a natural tracer to localize and quantify groundwater inflow into the Spree River and one of its tributaries ( Kleine Spree). Based on two 222Rn monitoring campaigns in the catchment and by applying the 222Rn mass balance model FINIFLUX, we were able to quantify local groundwater inflow for a 20 km long river section of the Kleine Spree and a 34 km long section for the Spree River. For the first campaign in May 2018 total groundwater inflow was estimated with ~3,000 m³/d for the Kleine Spree and ~20,000 m³/d for the Spree River. For the second campaign in August 2018 estimated total groundwater inflows were significantly higher with ~7,000 m3 d−1 (Kleine Spree) and ~38,000 m3 d−1 (Spree). Preferential groundwater inflow areas were identified (with up to 70% of total inflow) along the Spreewitzer Rinne, a local high permeable aquifer consisting of excavated mining materials. Based on a stoichiometric ratio calculation and by measuring instream sulfate and dissolved iron loadings, we additionally were able to estimate iron precipitation rates for the entire catchment of the Spree in the Lusatian mining area. According to our calculations, for the entire catchment of the Spree River in the Lusatian mining district total iron precipitation rates reach values as high as 120 tons/day; large quantities of iron (oxy)-hydroxides that are retained within the catchment as iron precipitates.

    How to cite: Frei, S. and Gilfedder, B.: Quantification of local groundwater inflow into the Spree River and its relevance to the iron precipitation problem in the Lusatian mining area (Germany)., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11492, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11492, 2022.

    EGU22-11651 | Presentations | HS10.8

    Spatio-temporal variations of water sources and mixing in a riparian zone 

    Guilherme Nogueira, Christian Schmidt, Daniel Partington, Philip Brunner, and Jan Fleckenstein

    Riparian zones are known for their role in regulating water quality in stream corridors. Specifically, riparian zones can act as buffers for high-concentration nutrient inputs into the stream, which can be harmful for the aquatic ecosystem. This natural attenuation capacity is controlled by variable water and solute exchanges bringing together different reactants via the mixing of stream water (SW) and local groundwater (GW). The degree and the extent of this mixing can regulate the potential for turnover processes for certain solutes. Here, we couple a previously calibrated transient and fully-integrated 3D numerical flow model with a Hydraulic Mixing Cell (HMC) method to map the different water sources in the stream corridor of the 4th-order Selke stream and track their spatio-temporal evolution. This allows us to identify areas where waters from different sources mix enhancing the potential for turnover of groundwater-borne solutes such as nitrate. We evaluate HMC results with hydrochemical field data, and outline mixing hot-spots defined by high degrees of mixing (i.e. balanced volume fractions of the mixing endmembers in a model cell) expressed in terms of a threshold mixing degree (d=dh) within the stream corridor. Our results show that around 50% of the water in the aquifer originates from infiltrating SW. Especially around the stream (within 250m from the stream), aquifer water is almost exclusively made up of infiltrating SW with minimal amount of water from other sources being mixed in. On average, 9% of the floodplain aquifer are characterized by high degrees of mixing (d=dh), but this value can be nearly 1.5 time higher following big discharge events. Our modeling results further suggest that peak intensity of events is more significant for the increase of mixing degrees than event duration. We also found that discharge events mainly facilitate high mixing degrees at greater distances from the stream; while near the stream growing SW influxes dominate water composition in the aquifer and decreasing water transit times reduce exposure-times of water and solutes to the conditions in mixing hot-spots. With this easy-to-transfer modeling framework we seek to show the applicability of the HMC method as a complementary tool for the identification of SW-GW mixing hot-spots at the floodplain-scale, when simulating the spatio-temporal patterns of SW-GW exchange in stream corridors.

    How to cite: Nogueira, G., Schmidt, C., Partington, D., Brunner, P., and Fleckenstein, J.: Spatio-temporal variations of water sources and mixing in a riparian zone, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11651, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11651, 2022.

    EGU22-11977 | Presentations | HS10.8

    Hyporheic nitrogen removal – assessing the potential for large scale stream restoration in Sweden 

    Joakim Riml, Anders Wörman, and Ida Morén

    Biogeochemical reactions along surface water flow paths mitigate nutrient inputs from agricultural land and can have large impacts on both the local water quality and the downstream export of nutrients from agricultural areas. Thus, stream restoration, in terms of engineered structures with the aim to increase the in-stream nutrient retention, is seen as an important strategy to restore the ecosystem functioning of degraded stream systems, mitigate excess nutrient concentrations and reduce the export to downstream recipients. Here, we propose a physically based model framework to assess the large-scale removal of Nitrogen (N) by denitrifications in the hyporheic zone along stream networks. The model framework, supported by an extensive dataset of hydromorphology and reach scale investigations, was used to estimate the current N removal in all local agricultural streams in Sweden defined as having a mean discharge < 1 m3/s and an agricultural N load > 0. Moreover, the theoretical potential to increase this removal by restoration structures that enhances the hyporheic removal efficiency and prolongs the stream residence times was assessed based on the Damköhler number, defined as the ratio between the hyporheic transport time scales and the reaction times scales.

    The analyses comprised approximately 26000 stream reaches equivalent to ~75 000 km or 36% of the entire stream network in Sweden and revealed that both the N removal and the conditions limiting the hyporheic denitrification was highly dependent on the stream flow conditions. Specifically, during mean discharge conditions the aggregated results indicated that 13% of the N load to the assessed reaches was removed through hyporheic denitrification and that reaction limited conditions predominately occurred (72% of the assessed reaches). The theoretical potential of N removal, i.e. the N removal under the assumption of optimal hyporheic conditions, during mean discharge conditions was estimated to be 36% when all reaches were aggregated. Overall, the study shows that stream structures, especially if implemented over larger distances, could be a promising restoration strategy to enhance hyporheic removal and reduce terrestrial N export from agricultural areas.

    How to cite: Riml, J., Wörman, A., and Morén, I.: Hyporheic nitrogen removal – assessing the potential for large scale stream restoration in Sweden, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11977, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11977, 2022.

    EGU22-13282 | Presentations | HS10.8

    Simulating TrOCs concentrations along specific hyporheic flowpaths using an integral surface water-groundwater model 

    Finn Amann, Christoph J. Reith, Jörg Lewandowski, and Reinhard Hinkelmann

    The hyporheic zone (HZ) describes an interfacial zone of permeable sediments, located in river beds, riparian and floodplain areas, where surface water mixes with groundwater. It exerts major control over the quality of river water by impacting the exchange processes between surface water and the sediment compartment through dynamically exchanging water, temperature and compounds as well as demonstrating an intensive nutrient turnover, providing the stream with a self-purification capability. Due to these properties, engineered hyporheic zones that aim to increase the hyporheic exchange flux are of great interest in the context of river management and restoration. The spatial and temporal scales on which the hyporheic exchange processes occur are manifold: Small topographical features of the streambed like ripples or burrows of aquatic organisms have to be considered as well as larger geomorphological features like meanders. In addition to steady-state-like streams and rivers, events like rapidly moving floods have to be taken into account when investigating the HZ. Numerical models are often utilised to gain a more comprehensive understanding of the interacting processes in the HZ. In contrast to widely used two-domain concepts, which are based on coupling surface flow and groundwater flow models,  integral one-domain modelling approaches to improve the resolution of the exchange processes and better account for feedback effects have recently attracted more attention. In this contribution, such an integral surface water – groundwater model, extended by a transport model, is validated against the results of a field experiment conducted in a side channel of the urban lowland River Erpe (Brandenburg-Berlin, Germany), which receives effluent from the wasterwater treatment plant Münchehofe, containing trace organic compounds (TrOCs) like Carbamazepine. The experiment consisted of a high-frequency sampling campaign to study the fate of the TrOCs along specific hyporheic flow path. The investigated flow path was dictated by a U-shaped pipe inserted into the sediment parallel to the surface water flow direction. To increase the hyporheic exchange, wooden debris was placed on the sediment in between the pipe openings. The model is set up using porousInter, which extends the multiphase flow solver interFoam of the computational fluid dynamics software package OpenFOAM, to allow flow through porous media. Flow is simulated by solving the three-dimensional Navier-Stokes equations extended by a porosity coefficient and additional drag terms to account for porous media flow. Further, the solver is extended by a transport model for a conservative tracer, which is used to simulate the spreading of TrOCs in the surface water and porous sediment. We expect to compute tracer  residence times and flow velocities inside the pipe in accordance with the results of the experiment.

    How to cite: Amann, F., Reith, C. J., Lewandowski, J., and Hinkelmann, R.: Simulating TrOCs concentrations along specific hyporheic flowpaths using an integral surface water-groundwater model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13282, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13282, 2022.

    EGU22-13465 | Presentations | HS10.8

    Assessing Climate Impacts Against Groundwater Pumping Impacts on Stream Flow with Statistical Analysis 

    Jonas Pyschik, Thomas Harter, and Kerstin Stahl

    Declining summer streamflow is observed in Pacific Northwest catchments, impacting endangered salmon species which need sufficient flow to reach their spawning grounds. Groundwater pumping for irrigation is generally considered the cause of low summer flow. However, it is unclear, how much water is lost due to water use or climatic factors, as there often is no data on pumping-volume. In this study we assess the lost amount of streamflow during summer low flows and quantify the shares attributable to climate change and agricultural water-consumption, only using streamflow data. As a case study we focused on the Scott River catchment, California, having 7% agricultural land use. We compared summer streamflow, snow water equivalent and precipitation between historic (1940-1976), intermediate (1977-1999) and modern (2000-2020) timeframes. Snow water equivalent showed negative significant trends at lower elevations (1600-1800 m). We also observed significant negative trends in mean and minimum streamflow as well as earlier starting and longer lasting low flow season. Using a paired-basin approach we were able to detect a mean 38.5% (37.5 +/- 3 Mm³) streamflow decrease from historic to modern timeframe years, where 14.6% (14.25 +/- 1.4 Mm³) were attributable to agricultural water consumption and 23.9% (23.2 +/- 1.4 Mm³) to climate change. These results demonstrate that agriculture substantially impacts streamflow; however, the influence of climate change dominates. Therefore, stopping water use in summer to increase low flows is insufficient. A possibility to ensure enough flow for endangered salmon could be artificial aquifer recharge during high flows to top of low flow season.

    How to cite: Pyschik, J., Harter, T., and Stahl, K.: Assessing Climate Impacts Against Groundwater Pumping Impacts on Stream Flow with Statistical Analysis, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13465, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13465, 2022.

    EGU22-272 | Presentations | HS10.9 | Highlight

    Response of the Caspian Sea Shoreline to hydro-climatic Drivers Variation 

    Mahdi Akbari, Björn Klöve, Omolbanin Faramrazzadeh, and Ali Torabi Haghighi

    During the past three decades, seawater level (SWL) in the Caspian Sea has declined by about 2 m, and sea area has decreased by about 15 000 km2. This has affected coastal communities, the environment and economically important sea gulfs (e.g., Dead Kultuk). We simulated SWL using total inflow from feeder rivers and precipitation and evaporation over the sea to assess the effects of coastline change and evaluate zones vulnerable to desiccation. We determined the potential of coastal vulnerability over the past 80 years by comparing the minimum and maximum annual water body maps (for 1977 and 1995). We then determined the linear regression between SWL rise and covered potential vulnerable area (CVA), using annual Normalised Difference Water Index (NDWI) maps and SWL data from 1977 to 2018. Combining SWL-CVA regression and SWL simulation model enabled us to determine desiccated areas in different regions of the Caspian Sea due to changes in precipitation, evaporation and total inflow. The results showed that 25 000 km2 of the sea is potentially vulnerable to SWL fluctuations to be desiccated. Also, we found 70% of this vulnerable area is in Kazakhstan. Potential vulnerable area per kilometer coastline was found to be 6 km2 in Kazakhstan, 4 km2 in Russia and the whole of the Caspian Sea, 1.5 km2 in Iran, 1 km2 in Azerbaijan, and 0.5 km2 in Turkmenistan. The results also indicated that SWL in the Caspian Sea is sensitive to evaporation and that, e.g., a 37.5 mm decrease in mean annual net precipitation would lead to an 1875 km2 decrease in the sea area, while a 1 km3 decrease in mean annual inflow would lead to a 1400 km2 decrease in the sea area. Thus the developed framework enabled the spatial consequences of changes in water balance parameters on sea area to be quantified. It can assess future changes in SWL and sea area due to anthropogenic activities and climate change.

    How to cite: Akbari, M., Klöve, B., Faramrazzadeh, O., and Torabi Haghighi, A.: Response of the Caspian Sea Shoreline to hydro-climatic Drivers Variation, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-272, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-272, 2022.

    EGU22-492 | Presentations | HS10.9

    Physicochemical properties of a marine lake in the central Adriatic (Lake Rogoznica): interaction with the atmosphere, the sea and the surrounding karst 

    Iva Dominović, Marija Marguš, Sunčana Geček, Tatjana Bakran-Petricioli, Donat Petricioli, Mathieu Dutour Sikirić, and Irena Ciglenečki

    Lake Rogoznica (also known as "Dragon's Eye") is a karstic, marine lake on the Gradina peninsula located at the Adriatic coast at 43° 32' N and 15° 58' E. Most of the time the lake is stratified, with an upper oxic layer, an anoxic bottom layer, and a chemocline in between. Every few years the stratification suddenly breaks down and the entire water column becomes mixed, anoxic, and euxinic, with HS- presence throughout the water column. This leads to mass mortality of aerobic populations in the lake, which require long periods of time without mixing to recover. Rogoznica residents confirmed that the sudden overturning of layers had been occurring even before continuous research began in 1992, but also that it used to happen less frequently. In the last 30 years, five such events of complete anoxia have been recorded: in September 1997, October 2011, October 2016, October 2020, and October 2021. As the sudden mixing now occurs year after year, the lake's ecosystem does not have nearly enough time to recover. Previous work has indicated that the main trigger for the abrupt mixing is a sudden drop in surface temperature caused by an overpassing low-pressure system. Nevertheless, the process of overturning and sudden release of bottom-layer sulfides is a very delicate one, and determining other biological, physical, and chemical triggers is an important question that remains to be answered. Another key question is whether the increase in the overturn frequency is solely a part of the natural life cycle of the lake, a result of the changing climate with more extreme weather events, or a more direct consequence of human activities in the area.

    Comparison of the most recent water level measurements from June 2021 with those from 2013 indicate that the tidal signal in the lake requires a somewhat different analytical approach than the standard ocean tidal analysis procedure. Moreover, measurements at the boundaries of the lake show that the water entering the lake from the karst at high tide is not only colder but also has a lower salinity. Additionally, in this work we present new insights into the physicochemical properties of the lake's water column (σT-stratification, dissolved oxygen concentration) and the direct influence of atmospheric wet deposition on the lake's surface layer.

    How to cite: Dominović, I., Marguš, M., Geček, S., Bakran-Petricioli, T., Petricioli, D., Dutour Sikirić, M., and Ciglenečki, I.: Physicochemical properties of a marine lake in the central Adriatic (Lake Rogoznica): interaction with the atmosphere, the sea and the surrounding karst, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-492, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-492, 2022.

    EGU22-1165 | Presentations | HS10.9 | Highlight

    Relative contribution of surface water concentrations (pCO2aq) and gas transfer velocity (k) to CO2 flux variability in boreal lakes 

    David Rudberg, Jonathan Schenk, Gustav Pajala, Henrique Sawakuchi, Anna Sieczko, Jan Karlsson, Sally MacIntyre, John Melack, Ingrid Sundgren, and David Bastviken

    Lakes emit CO2 to the atmosphere at magnitudes significant for the global carbon cycle, in the form of diffusive CO2 flux (FCO2). As direct FCO2 measurements are time-consuming, FCO2 is often estimated from the air-water CO2 concentration gradient (ΔpCO2) and the gas transfer velocity (k), representing the two components considered to regulate FCO2. However, extrapolating measurements of ΔpCO2 and k to whole-year estimates require understanding of their variability in time and across different types of lakes, which is often insufficient. As a result, simple linear interpolations are typically used in extrapolations which risk producing bias as spatiotemporal variability is not included. Further insight to the variability of ΔpCO2 and k may contribute to more representative extrapolations and provide guidance for focusing sampling campaigns on capturing times of high variability. We used floating flux chambers and surface water samples to measure FCO2 and ΔpCO2, respectively, both within-weeks and over seasons during the open water period at 12 locations in each of 15 boreal lakes across a latitudinal gradient in Sweden. We combined these measurements to derive spatially resolved values of k in order to identify: i) the contributions of ΔpCO2 and k to FCO2 variability over time; and ii) if differences in the contributions of ΔpCO2 and k to FCO2 variability can be related to lake characteristics. The results presented are relevant for improved modelling of lake CO2 emissions.

    How to cite: Rudberg, D., Schenk, J., Pajala, G., Sawakuchi, H., Sieczko, A., Karlsson, J., MacIntyre, S., Melack, J., Sundgren, I., and Bastviken, D.: Relative contribution of surface water concentrations (pCO2aq) and gas transfer velocity (k) to CO2 flux variability in boreal lakes, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1165, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1165, 2022.

    EGU22-1550 | Presentations | HS10.9 | Highlight

    Absence of surface water temperature trends in the presence of atmospheric warming as evidence of increasing evaporation in fresh-water Lake Kinneret 

    Pavel Kishcha, Yury Lechinsky, Boris Starobinets, and Pinhas Alpert

    In the summer months, characterized by the absence of precipitation and by limited cloud cover, subtropical lakes are particularly sensitive to atmospheric warming which causes increasing heating of surface water. Therefore, these lakes are best suited to the investigation of this phenomenon.

    Within the Jordan Rift valley there are two lakes: the fresh-water Lake Kinneret (Sea of Galilee) (a surface area of 106 km2 and a maximal depth of 40 m) and the hypersaline Dead Sea (a surface area of 605 km2 and a maximal depth of 300 m). We investigated water surface temperature (WST) and its trends in the two lakes. This was carried out using MODIS 1 km x 1 km resolution records on board Terra and Aqua satellites together with in-situ measurements, during the period (2003 – 2019). In fresh-water Lake Kinneret, we found that, in summer when evaporation is maximal, despite the presence of increasing atmospheric warming, satellite data revealed the absence of WST trends (Kishcha et al., 2021). The absence of WST trends in the presence of increasing atmospheric warming is an indication of the influence of steadily increasing evaporation on WST. Increasing water cooling, due to steadily increasing evaporation, compensated for increasing heating of surface water by regional atmospheric warming. This resulted in the obtained statistically-insignificant WST trends. During the study period (2003 – 2019), in summer, in contrast to satellite data, in-situ measurements of near-surface water temperature (at a depth of 0.1 m) in Lake Kinneret showed an increasing trend of 0.7 oC  decade-1. This trend in near-surface water temperature reflected the presence of increasing atmospheric warming in the absence of evaporation.

    In contrast to fresh-water Lake Kinneret, in the hypersaline Dead Sea (located only 100 km apart), MODIS showed an increasing statistically-significant trend of 0.8 oC decade-1 in summer WST. This fact was obtained during the same study period (Kishcha et al., 2021). The increasing WST trend, in the presence of atmospheric warming, is evidence of the absence of increasing evaporation in the Dead Sea. This fact is supported by a constant rate of ~1 m/year of Dead Sea water level drop during the last 25-year period (1995 – 2020). The absence of increasing evaporation could be explained by surface water salinity in the Dead Sea skin layer. Increasing surface water salinity suppresses further increases in evaporation. As a result, there was no acceleration in Dead Sea water level drop in the presence of an increasing SWT trend of 0.8 oC decade-1. We consider that this is a characteristic feature of the hypersaline Dead Sea, which is not present in the fresh-water Lake Kinneret.

    Reference:

    Kishcha et al. (2021). Absence of surface water temperature trends in Lake Kinneret despite present atmospheric warming: Comparisons with Dead Sea trends. Remote Sensing, 13, 3461. https://doi.org/10.3390/rs13173461

    How to cite: Kishcha, P., Lechinsky, Y., Starobinets, B., and Alpert, P.: Absence of surface water temperature trends in the presence of atmospheric warming as evidence of increasing evaporation in fresh-water Lake Kinneret, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1550, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1550, 2022.

    The karstic, stratified marine lake (Lake Rogoznica, RL) on the eastern Adriatic coast (43°32'N, 15°58'E) is a unique environment. It oscillates between a stratified water column with euxinic conditions below the chemocline and a holomictic euxinic water column under certain physicochemical conditions (1). Given the specific physicochemical, microbiological, and biochemical properties of the water column, the lake proves to be an ideal test site to track environmental changes indicative of climate change. Climate change will further increase water column temperature and enhance deoxygenation in the epilimnion while promoting the accumulation of toxic sulphide, ammonium in the hypolimnion, and organic matter (OM) throughout the water column (2). Since the early 1990s, when exploration of the lake began, the volume of the anoxic water has increased several times. The stronger stratification has led to an enrichment of dissolved organic matter (DOC) in the euxinic hypolimnion due to the anoxic conditions, while the concentration of DOC in the oxic epilimnion (0-8 m depth) decreases. At the same time, the concentration of the most reactive DOC fraction (surface active substances- SAS) (3) increases in the upper layer, while a decreasing trend in SAS is observed below 8 m depth. In addition, there is evidence of accumulation of particulate organic matter (POC) in the water column and an increase in the fraction of POC in total organic carbon (TOC).

    In RL, vertical mixing events occur in early fall that can end with holomictic conditions that affect lake biogeochemistry (4), including organic matter properties and dynamics. Over the past 30 years, these events are becoming more frequent and intense. Each holomictic event is associated with a subsequent high production of POC and a change in composition DOC. On a long-term scale (1992-2021), this study presents a unique time series of organic matter content (DOC, POC, SAS) showing a noticeable change in its quantity and quality within the RL water column as an indication of the pronounced eutrophication escalated by global change.

     

    This work was result of research activities within the MARRES project, IP-2018-01-1717.

     

    [1] I. Ciglenečki, Z. Ljubešić, I. Janeković, M. Batistić, in R.D. Gulati, E.S. Zadereev, A.G. Degermendzhi (eds) “Ecology of meromictic lakes”. Springer 2017, Cham, p 125−154.

    [2] M. Čanković, J. Žučko, I. Dupčić Radić, I. Janeković, I. Petrić, I. Ciglenečki, G. Collins,  Syst. Appl. Microbiol. 42 (2019) 126016.

    [3] I. Ciglenečki, I. Vilibić, J. Dautović, V. Vojvodić, B. Ćosović, P. Zemunik, N. Dunić, H. Mihajlović, Sci. Total Environ. 730 (2020) 139104.

    [4] M. Čanković, J. Žučko, I. Petrić, M. Marguš, I. Ciglenečki, Aquat. Microb. Ecol. 84 (2020) 141-154.

    How to cite: Simonović, N., Marguš, M., and Ciglenečki, I.: Long-term monitoring of organic matter in an eutrophic marine lake that fluctuates between stratified and holomictic euxinic conditions, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2191, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2191, 2022.

    EGU22-2787 | Presentations | HS10.9

    Representing seasonal water in ECMWF ECLand system 

    Margarita Choulga, Souhail Boussetta, Gianpaolo Balsamo, and Joe McNorton

    In 2015 lake parametrization was introduced at European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasts (ECMWF) to take into account the impact of lake on the boundary layer and near surface atmosphere. All inland water bodies (lakes, reservoirs, rivers, coastal waters) have constant size distribution and are simulated by the Fresh-water Lake model FLake.

    To introduce water seasonality and reduce errors caused by the constant water distribution, time-varying water maps based on Global Surface Water Explorer (GSWE) data are being introduced in the ECMWF ECLand system. Techniques used to adapt GSWE to create monthly water fraction maps for the use of global NWP modelling and first evaluation results will be presented.

    How to cite: Choulga, M., Boussetta, S., Balsamo, G., and McNorton, J.: Representing seasonal water in ECMWF ECLand system, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2787, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2787, 2022.

    EGU22-2858 | Presentations | HS10.9

    Chrysophyte cysts reflect seasonal meteorological and limnological conditions: Evidence from sediment trap study in northeast Poland 

    Agnieszka Szczerba, Sergi Pla-Rabes, Maurycy Żarczyński, and Wojciech Tylmann

    Chrysophyte cysts are considered as good environmental indicators because of short generation times, seasonal replacement, and their high sensitivity to changes in physicochemical conditions. In our study, we explored the relationship between chrysophyte cysts and changes in meteorological conditions in two lakes located in northern Poland (Łazduny and Rzęśniki). We compared samples collected in sediment traps, results of on-site monitoring of limnological and hydrochemical variables, and meteorological data. Multiple statistical analyses showed that meteorological conditions indirectly influence cyst seasonality, through changes in the mixing regimes that determine nutrient and light availability in lakes. Even though the taxonomic structure and interannual variability of chrysophyte cysts are dependent on multiple variables, air temperature proved to be the most important meteorological variable influencing cyst assemblages. Multi-level pattern analysis showed that specific cyst types were indicative of different periods of lake physical structure, thus suggesting the potential of chrysophyte cysts in paleoclimatic studies.

    How to cite: Szczerba, A., Pla-Rabes, S., Żarczyński, M., and Tylmann, W.: Chrysophyte cysts reflect seasonal meteorological and limnological conditions: Evidence from sediment trap study in northeast Poland, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2858, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2858, 2022.

    EGU22-4917 | Presentations | HS10.9 | Highlight

    Controls on oxygen depletion under lake ice 

    Marie-Elodie Perga, Camille Minaudo, Hugo Ulloa, Tomy Doda, Pascal Perolo, Nicolas Escoffier, Florent Arthaud, Biel Obrador, and Damien Bouffard

    Even low productive, high-altitude lakes experience deep water hypoxia under ice-cover. While the changing ice phenology is expected to ripple on the magnitude of under-ice hypoxia, the lack of a mechanistic framework linking the physical impact of ice loss to biogeochemical properties has led to seemingly contradictory conclusions.  

    Biogeochemical and physical processes constrain the Dissolved Oxygen (DO) dynamic at the sediment-water interface under lake ice. On the one hand, the biogeochemical hypothesis envisions a primary control of DO decay under the ice by sediment oxygen uptake, which arises from benthic microbial respiration and the release of reduced compounds. On the other hand, the physical hypothesis assumes a greater DO decay when sediment heat release reinforces the inverse stratification; the stronger is the sediment heat release, the more the bottom layer, from which oxygen is consumed, gets isolated from potential diffusive resupply from the upper layers. The outcome of a shorter ice-cover on the under-ice DO dynamics depends on the dominance of either biogeochemical or physical processes.

    Based on in-situ observations of DO and temperature, we assessed the relative share of biogeochemical and physical processes on decay under the ice of 14 high-altitude lakes in the French Alps. We found highly variable DO decay rates across the different lakes and years, with exponential coefficients ranging from 1.10-3 to 6.10-2 d-1.  The under-ice DO decay rates increased, within years and lakes, with sediment heat release, while biogeochemical factors played only a marginal role. We tested through a reaction-diffusion model on an archetypal, testbed lake the individual effects of biogeochemical versus physical processes on DO decay. We confirmed that the sediment heat flux at ice-on is a major driver of DO decay under the ice, explaining one mechanism by which shallower or more transparent lakes experience greater DO decay under the ice.

    How to cite: Perga, M.-E., Minaudo, C., Ulloa, H., Doda, T., Perolo, P., Escoffier, N., Arthaud, F., Obrador, B., and Bouffard, D.: Controls on oxygen depletion under lake ice, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4917, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4917, 2022.

    EGU22-5429 | Presentations | HS10.9 | Highlight

    Solutions for existing and future challenges in water governance 

    Faluku Nakulopa, Dietrich Borchardt, Rafael Marcé, Karsten Rinke, and Ilona Bärlund

    Global surface water bodies suffer multitude of human induced pressures that lead to the deterioration of water status through conditions of anoxia, eutrophication, pollution, depletion, among others, which compound water scarcity. Climatic and socio-economic changes will most likely exacerbate the water crises. However, effective water governance strategies can be deployed to mitigate water crisis and guarantee sustainable water use and ecosystem health.  Such strategies can be developed and implemented using a holistic modelling approach.  In this study, we aim at developing – through re-analysis and modelling – an adaptive water governance framework that can be utilized to ensure sustainable water-use and ecosystem health. The study will be piloted at the Möhne reservoir in the North Rhine-Westphalia state, Germany – representing a multi-decadal time machine for hydroclimatic changes, socioeconomic dynamics and water governance by the Ruhrverband. The study will address five key questions; i) How did the drivers and pressures of the reservoir water status change over time? ii) How did the water governance structures change/respond over time? iii) How did the water quality and quantity change over time? iv) What are the likely future drivers, pressures and governance structures/responses? v) Are there strategies to compare with or transfer to/from other systems?

    In order to reconstruct the drivers, pressures, status and impacts of the Möhne reservoir waters, with the respective management and policy responses over time, we start by re-analyzing the multi-decadal trajectory of a few representative variables. In this poster we highlight this using air temperature and precipitation, reservoir water level and population changes in the catchment.

    How to cite: Nakulopa, F., Borchardt, D., Marcé, R., Rinke, K., and Bärlund, I.: Solutions for existing and future challenges in water governance, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5429, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5429, 2022.

    EGU22-5713 | Presentations | HS10.9 | Highlight

    Global lake evaporation responses to climate change 

    Sofia La Fuente, Iestyn Woolway, and Eleanor Jennings

    Global lake evaporation is a critical and continuous process that plays an important role in the earth’s water cycle. Accurate quantification of lake evaporation dynamics is crucial to understanding lake energy budgets, land-atmosphere interactions, as well as water availability. However, despite its importance, relatively few studies have investigated the impacts of climate change on global lake evaporation. In this study, we present global lake evaporation projections from 1901-2099 using an ensemble of lake-climate projections from the Inter-Sectoral Impact Model Intercomparison Project (ISIMIP). Our results show that global lake evaporation will increase by the end of the 21st century with the largest changes occurring in tropical regions. Furthermore, our analysis suggests that lake evaporation extremes (90th percentile) are projected to occur more frequently, with greater changes detected at low latitudes. We anticipate lake evaporation increases to have severe impacts on the water budget, and therefore, on the availability of surface freshwater this century. 

    How to cite: La Fuente, S., Woolway, I., and Jennings, E.: Global lake evaporation responses to climate change, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5713, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5713, 2022.

    EGU22-5844 | Presentations | HS10.9

    Evidence and possible causes of velocity pulsing in a turbidity current in Lake Geneva 

    Stan Thorez, Koen Blanckaert, Ulrich Lemmin, and David Andrew Barry

    Negatively buoyant riverine inflows plunge when entering lakes or reservoirs and form gravity-driven currents near the bed. When a high sediment load causes the density excess, such currents are called turbidity currents. They can supply momentum, heat, oxygen, sediments, nutrients and contaminants to deep lake basins and are the main cause of reservoir storage capacity loss. Even with steady inflow, turbidity currents have been observed to exhibit regularly pulsing velocity patterns, which are likely to enhance mixing between the inflowing and the ambient waters. Previously, literature linked this pulsing to several mechanisms, including interfacial waves such as Kelvin-Helmholtz instabilities and Rayleigh-Taylor instabilities related to surface lobes along the plunge line. However, to our knowledge, field measurements of the latter have not been reported.

    In the present study, field measurements of the plunging inflow of the negatively buoyant Rhône River into Lake Geneva (Switzerland/France) were carried out. Vessel-mounted ADCP measurements of the longitudinal flow field of the plunging flow and the subsequent turbidity current were combined with remote time-lapse imagery capturing related surface patterns.

    The ADCP measurements confirm that the inflowing river water plunges and forms a turbidity current. At the turbidity current-ambient water interface, regularly spaced “bulges” in the velocity pattern suggest pulsing. Simultaneously taken remote time-lapse images show that at the surface, the inflowing sediment-rich water forms a distinct plume with a triangular shape leading away from the river mouth in the downstream direction towards a sharp tip. At the edge and in the immediate surroundings of this plume, a variety of intermittent lobes and vortical structures whose periodicity might be related to that of the velocity pulsing in the turbidity current, is observed.

    How to cite: Thorez, S., Blanckaert, K., Lemmin, U., and Barry, D. A.: Evidence and possible causes of velocity pulsing in a turbidity current in Lake Geneva, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5844, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5844, 2022.

    EGU22-7815 | Presentations | HS10.9 | Highlight

    How do recreational swimmers affect lake-atmosphere and lake-sediment transport? 

    Georgiy Kirillin, Liu Liu, Asiya Murakaeva, Hauke Dämpfling, and Hans-Peter Grossart
    Natural waters in urban and suburban areas experience growing stresses from active water use and recreational activities, such as leisure boating, fishing, and swimming. Among other factors, leisure swimmers are considered to have a minor effect on the large-scale dynamics of water bodies. Certain physical processes are however very sensitive to disturbances of boundary layers - a thin diffusive layer at the lake surface and the upper layer of sediment. During hot summers, a high concentration of swimmers in small lakes and ponds may disrupt the boundary layers, intensifying the vertical heat and mass exchange and producing localized outbursts of methane into the atmosphere and(or) release of the dissolved nutrients from sediment to the water column. We performed a series of experiments in the suburban area of Berlin, Germany to estimate the potential swimmer effects on the vertical heat and mass transport. Monitoring of physical and water quality parameters in small (~2 km2) Lake Mellensee revealed a consistent  increase of turbidity and decrease of transparency in the vicinity of the beach actively visited by weekend swimmers from Berlin and surroundings. The measured concentrations of the dissolved methane and the methane fluxes at the lake surface, while indicating potential increase due to localized swimming activities, were heterogeneous and depended strongly on variations in sediment composition and on wind conditions. To quantify the effects on the lake-atmosphere fluxes, we performed estimations of the surface temperature disturbance by swimmers in a large mesocosm facility using UAV-based multispectral and infrared cameras. A manifold increase of the surface heat flux derived from the root-mean-square temperature fluctuations results from the diffusive layer disruption and implies a proportional increase of the dissolved gas release.

    How to cite: Kirillin, G., Liu, L., Murakaeva, A., Dämpfling, H., and Grossart, H.-P.: How do recreational swimmers affect lake-atmosphere and lake-sediment transport?, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7815, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7815, 2022.

    The summertime evaporation over a large shallow lake located in the Schirmacher oasis, Dronning Maud Land, Antarctica. Lake Zub/Priyadarshini is the second largest lake in the oasis,  its maximum depth is  6 m. The lake is among the warmest lakes, and it is free of ice during almost two summer months. The summertime evaporation over the water table of the lake was estimated after the eddy covariance (EC) method, the bulk aerodynamic method and Dalton type empirical equations. We used special meteorological and hydrological measurements collected during the field experiment carried out in 2018 in addition to the standard observations at the nearest meteorological site. 

    The EC method was considered as the most accurate given a reference for other estimates of evaporation over the lake water surface. We estimated the evaporation over the ice free lake surface as 114 mm in the period from 1 January to 7 February 2018 (38 days) after the direct EC method. The average daily evaporation is estimated to be 3.0 mm day-1 in January 2018. The largest changes in the daily evaporation were driven by the synoptic-scale atmospheric processes rather than local katabatic winds. 

    The bulk aerodynamic method suggests the average daily evaporation to be 2.0 mm day-1 , and it is over 30 % less than the EC method. This method is much better in producing the day-to-day variations in evaporation compared to the Dalton type semi-empirical equations, which underestimated the evaporation over the lake open water table for over 40–72 %. We also suggested a linear empirical relationship to evaluate the summertime evaporation of Lake Zub/Priyadarshini from the observations at the nearest meteorological site and surface water temperature. After this method, the evaporation over the period of the experiment is 120 mm, and it is only 5 % larger than the result according to the EC method. We also estimated the daily evaporation from the ERA5 reanalysis, which suggested the average daily evaporation during austral summer (December – February) 2017–2018 to be 0.6 mm day-1. It is only one fifth of the evaporation estimated with the direct EC method. 

    The poster shows the results which were obtained together with Timo Vihma and Tuomas Naakka (Finnish Meteorological Institute, Helsinki, Finland), Miguel Potes (Institute Earth Science, Evora, Portugal), Pankaj Ramji Dhote and Praveen Kumar Thakur (Indian Institute of Remote Sensing, Dehradun, India). The study was funded by the Academy of Finland (contract number 304345) and the COST Snow Action ES1404. The measurement campaigns were supported by the Finnish Antarctic Research Program, the Russian Antarctic Expedition, and the Indian Antarctic expedition.

    How to cite: Shevnina, E.: Summertime evaporation over glacial lakes in the Schirmacher oasis, East Antarctica., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8305, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8305, 2022.

    EGU22-8356 | Presentations | HS10.9

    Statistics of sea-effect snowfall in Finland based on ERA5 and FMIClimGrid 

    Taru Olsson, Anna Luomaranta, Kirsti Jylhä, and Henri Nyman

    Convective sea-effect snowfall (snow band) can develop in the Baltic Sea when cold air masses are advected from the mainland over a relatively warm open sea. Snow bands may last for several days over the Baltic Sea and, depending on the wind direction, move towards the Finnish coast. To investigate the spatial and temporal characteristics of snow bands in Finland and statistics of conditions favoring their formation, we used a set of detection criteria together with ERA5 reanalysis at a spatial grid spacing of 0.25° (~31 km) for a 48-year time period (1973–2020). Daily changes in snow depth over land areas were studied from FMIClimGrid gridded observational data. Only snow band cases when snow fell over the Finnish mainland was considered. Based on the ERA5 and FMIClimGrid data, we found on average 16 snow band days (SBD) per year. On average, the accumulated snow depths during SBD were moderate, daily mean varied between 2 cm/day to 5 cm/day in the studied regions along the coast of Finland. The largest daily mean snow accumulation (3.5–5 cm) during SBD was observed over the southern coast, but the largest daily snow depth increase (67 cm in January 2016) in the gridded data set was detected in the western coast of Finland. Neither the annual number of snow band days nor the daily snow accumulation revealed statistically significant changes due to large variations between years. The months of November and December showed the highest frequency of SBD. However, the seasonal cycle of SBD seemed to be shifting one month forward as the decrease in the number of SBD during December as well as the increase during January and February were statistically significant in Finland. The long-term changes in sea surface temperature (SST) and air temperature at atmospheric level of 850 hPa (T850) were in line with the changes in occurrence of SBDs. SST increased in all months during 1973–2020 in northern Baltic Sea. In December, when the decrease in snow band days was largest, also the T850 increased indicating less cold air masses occurring in Finland. So, even with increased SST the temperature difference favoring snow band formation might not reach the minimum threshold (13 °C) to produce snow bands due to too warm air temperatures. On the contrary, during January and February the increased SST together with no changes in T850 could favor the formation of snow bands.

    How to cite: Olsson, T., Luomaranta, A., Jylhä, K., and Nyman, H.: Statistics of sea-effect snowfall in Finland based on ERA5 and FMIClimGrid, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8356, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8356, 2022.

    EGU22-8439 | Presentations | HS10.9

    Three-dimensional simulation of biochemical processes in inland waters 

    Daria Gladskikh, Evgeny Mortikov, and Victor Stepanenko

    Within the framework of this study, a three-dimensional numerical model of biochemical processes was developed, which complements the model of thermohydrodynamics of the lake. The proposed model includes equations to describe the transport, diffusion, and reactions of dissolved gases. To compare the calculations with the measurement data, the bottom topography and atmospheric forcing were taken into account. For the flux of short-wave radiation, the parameterization of the extinction coefficient was implemented. To assess the contribution of density stratification and velocity shear to the processes of small-scale turbulence in lakes, a modification of the standard two-parameter k-epsilon closure was proposed. The basis of the parameterization is the model that reproduces mutual transformation of the kinetic and potential energy of turbulent pulsations.

    The work was supported by the RFBR (20-05-00776), by Moscow Center of Fundamental and Applied Mathematics (agreement with the Ministry of Science and Higher Education 075-15-2019-1621), and by grant of the RF President’s Grant for Young Scientists (MD-1850.2020.5)

    How to cite: Gladskikh, D., Mortikov, E., and Stepanenko, V.: Three-dimensional simulation of biochemical processes in inland waters, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8439, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8439, 2022.

    EGU22-9026 | Presentations | HS10.9

    Inland lake temperature initialization via cycling with atmospheric data assimilation 

    Stan Benjamin, Tatiana Smirnova, Eric James, Eric Anderson, Ayumi Fujisaki-Manome, and John Kelley

    Application of lake models coupled within earth-system prediction models, especially for short-term predictions from days to weeks, requires accurate initialization of lake temperatures.   Here, we describe a lake initialization method by cycling within an hourly updated weather prediction model to constrain lake temperature evolution.   We compare these simulated lake temperature values with other estimates from satellite and in situ and interpolated-SST data sets for a multi-month period in 2021.   The lake cycling initialization, now applied to two operational US NOAA weather models, was found to decrease errors in lake temperature from as much as 5-10K (using interpolated-SST data) to about 1-2 K (comparing with available in situ and satellite observations. 

    How to cite: Benjamin, S., Smirnova, T., James, E., Anderson, E., Fujisaki-Manome, A., and Kelley, J.: Inland lake temperature initialization via cycling with atmospheric data assimilation, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9026, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9026, 2022.

    EGU22-9182 | Presentations | HS10.9

    The radiatively-driven turbulent convection in ice-covered lake: numerical and observational study 

    Sergei Smirnov, Alexander Smirnovsky, Sergey Bogdanov, Roman Zdorovennov, Nikolay Palshin, Tatiana Efremova, Arkady Terzhevik, and Galina Zdorovennova

    The features of turbulent heat and mass transfer in a stratified fluid exposed by periodical inhomogeneous volumetric heating are of great practical and fundamental interest. Such phenomena take place in geophysical flows, for example, in ice-covered boreal lakes in spring, where the mechanisms and efficiency of mixing of water masses has a great effect on chemical and biological processes in lakes [1, 2]. Detailed numerical modeling of such flows coupled with experimental observations makes it possible to reveal some important aspects of the structure and parameters of under-ice turbulence, the nature and properties of its anisotropy, difference in the spectra of vertical and horizontal pulsations, and features of energy transfer. This work presents preliminary results of both experimental and numerical investigations of the radiatively-driven free turbulent under-ice convection. The aim of this work is to study the initial stages of the formation and development of a convective mixed layer as well as comparison with obtained experimental data. Numerical simulation is based on the results presented in [3], where the LES study of the development of the convective mixed layer under constant radiation heating was considered. In this study, the radiation heat flux at the ice-water interface is a periodic function evaluated by approximation of the experimental data presented at [4]. These data were obtained during investigations of the under-ice convection in the lake Vendyurskoe at springtime of 2020. The computations were carried out using the in-house finite-volume «unstructured» code SINF/Flag-S developed at Peter the Great St. Petersburg Polytechnic University. We show that the results on the rates of temperature increase and deepening of the convective mixed layer are in good agreement with our experimental data.

    The study is supported by the Russian Science Foundation under grants no. 21-17-00262 “Mixing in boreal lakes: mechanisms and its efficiency”.

    REFERENCES

    1. Bouffard, D., Wüest, A., 2019. Convection in Lakes. Ann. Rev. of Fluid Mechanics 51: 189-215.

    2. Bouffard, D., Zdorovennova, G., Bogdanov, S. et al, 2019. Under-ice convection dynamics in a boreal lake. Inland Waters 9: 142-161.

    3. Mironov, D., Terzhevik, A., Kirillin, G., et al, 2002. Radiatively driven convection in ice-covered lakes: Observations, scaling, and a mixed layer model. J. Geophys. Res. 107: 1-16.

    4. Bogdanov, S.R., Zdorovennov, R.E., Palshin N.I. et al, 2021. Deriving of turbulent stresses in a convectively mixed layer in a shallow lake under ice by coupling two ADCPS. Fundamental and Applied Hydrophysics 14: 17-28.

    How to cite: Smirnov, S., Smirnovsky, A., Bogdanov, S., Zdorovennov, R., Palshin, N., Efremova, T., Terzhevik, A., and Zdorovennova, G.: The radiatively-driven turbulent convection in ice-covered lake: numerical and observational study, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9182, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9182, 2022.

    EGU22-10100 | Presentations | HS10.9

    Sediment resuspension and transport from near-shore zones towards the deep interior of Lake Geneva caused by winter cascading 

    François Mettra, Rafael Sebastian Reiss, Ulrich Lemmin, and David Andrew Barry

    Coastal regions accumulate particulate matter, including pollutants, that are brought into the lake from surrounding watersheds. In order to assess dispersion of these substances into the lake interior, it is important to understand the near-shore hydrodynamics and resuspension processes. In winter, cascading of near-shore cold water, caused by differential cooling, induces relatively intense density currents down the sloping bottom lake boundary. Previous field measurements in Lake Geneva have shown signs of resuspension in this cascading flow, which transports near-shore water towards the deep lake interior. However, the importance of sediment resuspension and transport could not be determined because hydrodynamic studies of those cross-shore flows were lacking the necessary resolution. With the recent advances in instrument capabilities, we were able to collect detailed field data in the near-shore bottom boundary layer in Lake Geneva. Using a unique high spatial and temporal resolution dataset, we present results on the hydrodynamics of winter cascading and their implications for sediment resuspension and transport.


    Acoustic Doppler Current Profilers (ADCPs) and vertical thermistor lines were deployed during winter on the northern shore of Lake Geneva on the shallow shelf and along the sloping lakebed. In addition, CTD (Conductivity-Temperature-Depth) profiles were taken during periods of strong cooling in order to obtain a broader view of the temperature field along a cross-shore transect. After a cold, calm night, strong differential cooling develops between the shallow shelf and the open lake, initiating the flow of cold dense water from the shelf as pulses down the sloping lakebed. Analysis shows that the maximum in the velocity profile is relatively close to the bed, as expected for a density current. During large and intense pulses, the flow is thick enough to reveal details of the velocity profiles close to the boundary. As expected for a boundary flow, the measured profiles are logarithmic. From the profile shape, the bottom shear stress can be estimated by applying the law of the wall, thus assessing the potential of sediment resuspension with the classic incipient motion approach from Shields.


    We find that within the cascading flow, favorable conditions for resuspension are intermittent which is supported by ADCP backscattering. At 30-m depth, sediment transport towards the lake interior is more likely to occur during cascading flow events than under other flow conditions during winter, including those linked to strong wind events. Indeed, during the measurement period (mid-December to March), highest near-bottom cross-shore currents with bottom shear stresses exceeding the threshold of motion were recorded during cascading flows. They are also more frequent than cross-shore currents induced by wind-driven events. Results of this study suggest that winter cascading is very efficient in renewing near-shore waters and that during weakly-stratified periods, near-shore sediment could be transported into the deep interior by strong cascading events.

    How to cite: Mettra, F., Reiss, R. S., Lemmin, U., and Barry, D. A.: Sediment resuspension and transport from near-shore zones towards the deep interior of Lake Geneva caused by winter cascading, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10100, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10100, 2022.

    EGU22-10108 | Presentations | HS10.9 | Highlight

    The influence of drought and salinity on Greenhouse Gas emissions in “Fuente de Piedra” endorheic lagoon 

    Ihab Alfadhel, Isabel Reche, Enrique P. Sánchez-Cañete, Ignacio Peralta, Sergio David Aguirre-García, Jesús Abril-Gago, Andrew S. Kowalski, Francisco Domingo, and Penélope Serrano-Ortiz

    Wetlands represent 15% of global organic carbon storage and act as natural “blue carbon”, playing a significant role in the global carbon sink. However, due to climate change and anthropogenic activities (such as desiccation), they can become an important atmospheric CO2 source.  In many arid areas, lagoons may constitute the greatest part of the natural waters in temperate latitudes. They are usually very shallow or even temporary since evaporation exceeds precipitation. The most common lagoons are saline lakes in endorheic basins, which are strongly dependent on the hydrological budget. “Fuente de Piedra” lake (hereafter FdP) is a shallow and saline endorheic lagoon located in the province of Málaga, in the south of Spain. It is an important nature reserve because of its population of nesting flamingos in the Western Mediterranean, and is also the largest lagoon in Andalusia and is part of Ramsar since 1999. Based on previous studies, we hypothesize that FdP will be a net sink of CO2 but probably a yearly source of CH4 and N2O. However, its magnitude is still to be determined. Regarding the effect of drought, due to the contradictory results found in the literature, it is difficult to predict how GHG balances will behave during periods of drought and flooding. Therefore, the main objective of this study is to quantify CO2, CH4 and N2O fluxes in FdP and their seasonal variability. In this regard, the Picarro G2508 spectrometer, is being used every 15 days in four locations over a transect (dry sediments, wet sediments, shore and lagoon) to measure CO2/CH4/N2O fluxes since March 2021. At the same time, the eddy covariance technique is being used since August 2021 to quantify CO2, CH4 and H2O exchanges at the ecosystem level. Positive values of fluxes denote a net release to the atmosphere, while negative values indicate a net uptake. Preliminary results of Picarro measurements show that, during the drought period there is a significant effect of salinity for CO2 emissions with maximum value 0.3 µmol m-2 s-1 when sediments are covered by salt and 2.8 µmol m-2 s-1 when salt was removed. Regarding measurements of the transect, during the flooding period CO2 and CH4 fluxes ranged respectively from -3 µmol (CO2) m-2 s-1 and 0.008 µmol (CH4) m-2 s-1 in the lake to 1.7 µmol (CO2) m-2 s-1 and zero (CH4) µmol m-2 s-1 in the dry sediments. On the other hand, no N2O emissions where detected. Regarding the eddy covariance measurements at the ecosystem level, CO2 and CH4 flux values ranged from 10 µmol (CO2) m-2 s-1 and 0.01µmol (CH4) m-2 s-1 to zero µmol (CO2) m-2 s-1 to -0.05 (µmol CH4 m-2 s-1) during drought period (no measurements for the flooding period were taken yet). As a preliminary conclusion FdP seems to act as a source of CO2 during the drought period, while for CH4, FdP seems to act as a slight sink. However, more measurements are needed in order to provide stronger conclusions about the drought and the flooding period.

    How to cite: Alfadhel, I., Reche, I., Sánchez-Cañete, E. P., Peralta, I., David Aguirre-García, S., Abril-Gago, J., Kowalski, A. S., Domingo, F., and Serrano-Ortiz, P.: The influence of drought and salinity on Greenhouse Gas emissions in “Fuente de Piedra” endorheic lagoon, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10108, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10108, 2022.

    EGU22-10778 | Presentations | HS10.9

    Validation of a 1-D lake model for modeling evaporation from an elongated and deep boreal reservoir 

    Habiba Kallel, Murray Mackay, Antoine Thiboult, Daniel Nadeau, and François Anctil

    Freshwater reservoirs modify the regional climate through mass, energy, and momentum exchanges with the atmosphere. Recent studies have shown that hydropower reservoirs tend to evaporate more than the land they have flooded, hence reducing water availability for other uses, at a level that should with local climate conditions, however. Knowing that evaporation is a key component of the water balance and that very few studies have focused on evaporation from northern reservoirs, which are ice covered several months per year, there is a real need for models that can provide reliable estimates of this water vapor flux. This project focuses on the modeling of evaporation from an 85-km2 hydropower reservoir located in the boreal biome of eastern Canada (50.7°N, 63.2°W), with a mean depth of 60 m and an elongated shape. To support this modeling effort, two flux towers (one on the shore and one on a raft) and a vertical chain of thermistors were deployed. Exchanges between the water surface and the atmosphere are simulated with the Canadian Small Lake Model (CSLM), a 1-D physical-based surface scheme designed to be coupled with a numerical weather prediction model. The model also simulates the thermal regime of the water body, including ice formation. Considering the irregular shape of the reservoir as well as its depth, a new model parameterization was adopted that improved simulations (albedo parameterization, leakage parameter, mixed layer maximum depth...). Turbulent fluxes were successfully predicted during the open water period. Comparison between observed and modeled time series showed a good agreement specifically for sensible heat fluxes.  Deviations mostly occur before freeze-up (October to November) and around ice off (April to May) with a tendency of overestimating latent heat fluxes when its observed magnitude is small (ice period). Thermal mixing as well as mixed layer deepening were well estimated. Thermal mixing, as well as mixed layer deepening, were well estimated. Near-surface water temperature confirmed the ability of the CSLM to simulate the near-surface seasonal cycle. However, in early fall, an overestimation of the water temperature induced an overestimation of the heat fluxes leading to early depletion of the energy storage that led to an early modeled freeze-up.

    How to cite: Kallel, H., Mackay, M., Thiboult, A., Nadeau, D., and Anctil, F.: Validation of a 1-D lake model for modeling evaporation from an elongated and deep boreal reservoir, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10778, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10778, 2022.

    EGU22-11157 | Presentations | HS10.9

    Remote sensing-based monitoring of the water surfaces in the Neusiedler See – Seewinkel National Park 

    Henri Schauer, Stefan Schlaffer, Emanuel Büechi, and Wouter Dorigo

    Topic:

    Wetlands provide important ecosystem services,  e.g. for biodiversity and water resources. The salt pans in the Neusiedler See – Seewinkel National Park are a unique ecosystem for animal and plant species especially adapted to the extreme conditions prevailing in and around the salt pans. The conservation of the salt pans is largely based on the interplay with the water balance of the area and the influence of physical as well as anthropogenic factors. The large number of lakes, which are often only filled with water for a short time due to their shallow depth, makes monitoring by means of installed gauges more difficult. Remote sensing, on the other hand,  is an important source of consistent  information in space and time. In the FEMOWinkel project, which is funded within the framework of the Austrian StartClim 2021 program, long time series of multispectral satellite data are exploited for monitoring and data-driven modeling of water extent in the salt pans.

    The water bodies are delineated based on image time series of the Landsat satellites, which have been providing data almost continuously since the 1980s. Cloud gaps will partly be filled with radar-based information provided by European Copernicus – Programme. The derived time series of water body extent and number are validated by comparison with aerial photographs and – where available – water levels. The salt pans are characterized with respect to their seasonal variability and their reaction to longer-term changes in water availability by comparison with ancillary data, e.g., surface and groundwater levels, climate data and other remote sensing products, such as soil moisture and vegetation indices. In the third step, a data-driven modeling of the lake extent is carried out using machine learning methods. We will also address the question of whether it is possible to predict the effects of dry or wet winters and springs on water body extent in the following summer using these methods.

    Preliminary results of the time series analysis show a pronounced dynamic in the extent of the water bodies over the course of the study time. Periods, e.g., from 1990 to 1993 and 2001 to 2007, in which some of the lakes fell dry, alternated with wetter periods, e.g., from 1994 to 1999, in which the salt pans remained at least partially filled even in summer. These differences correlate with drought indicators such as the Standardised Precipitation-Evapotranspiration Index (SPEI). The remote sensing-based approach will make it possible to transfer the applied methods to other similar ecosystems located in steppe regions.

    How to cite: Schauer, H., Schlaffer, S., Büechi, E., and Dorigo, W.: Remote sensing-based monitoring of the water surfaces in the Neusiedler See – Seewinkel National Park, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11157, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11157, 2022.

    EGU22-11727 | Presentations | HS10.9 | Highlight

    Circulation, stratification and salt dispersion in a former estuary after reintroduction of seawater inflow to improve fish migration 

    Wouter Kranenburg, Meinard Tiessen, Meinte Blaas, and Nathalie van Veen

    The Haringvliet is a former estuary in the Rhine-Meuse Delta. Since 1970, seaward outflow is regulated with floodgates, while seawater is kept out. To improve fish migration and the ecological quality of the Rhine-Meuse system, limited seawater inflow during flood has been reintroduced again in 2018. The incoming salt water progresses through the former tidal channels, arrives in deep pits and is partially flushed out again by the outflow, especially during high river discharge. However, the remaining salt water can gradually spread through the system due to wind-induced mixing and circulations, especially when the gates are closed also for outflow during low river discharge. As this can threaten fresh water intakes, inflow, flushing and dispersion of salt need to be well understood and carefully managed.

    In this study we analyse velocity measurements from ADCPs at two former tidal channels in the Haringvliet, together with salinity time series and profiles at multiple locations. The salinity profiles show that the system tends to be strongly stratified. Using the ADCP backscatter, we estimated the time development of the interface level to relate this to the local velocity, floodgate discharge and wind. For peak discharges and low wind speed, the velocities show a clear relation with the discharge and the interface can lower abruptly. However, for lower discharges and higher wind speed, the relations are less clear, and the profiles are highly affected by the wind. In case of wind but closed sluices, flow against the wind was found for wind in the systems longitudinal direction. We explain this from the large area of (former) shoals, leading to flow with the wind in shallow parts and against the wind in deep parts due to a local imbalance between stress divergence and pressure gradient. This turns out to be an important driver of landward salt transport, as increased salt concentrations were found at landward locations for seaward wind. Next to that, indications were found of exchange between former tidal channels and transport over sills due to wind driven tilting of the salinity interface.

    Enhanced understanding of the salt transport dynamics in this former estuary after reintroduction of limited seawater inflow is an essential element to manage this system, protect the fresh water availability and keep the confidence of critical stakeholders, which is essential for the success of this ecosystem improvement program.

    How to cite: Kranenburg, W., Tiessen, M., Blaas, M., and van Veen, N.: Circulation, stratification and salt dispersion in a former estuary after reintroduction of seawater inflow to improve fish migration, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11727, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11727, 2022.

    EGU22-12027 | Presentations | HS10.9

    The effect of natural surfactants on air-water momentum exchange under light wind conditions in Lake Geneva 

    Mehrshad Foroughan, Ulrich Lemmin, and David Andrew Barry

    Randomly distributed patches of smooth or rough/rippled surfaces are readily observed on most water bodies. Smooth surface patches are called natural slicks and typically form under low wind conditions (< 6 m s-1) when biogenic surfactants in the surface microlayer accumulate above a certain threshold. They may have spatial scales from tens of meters to kilometers. Slicks suppress the formation of wind-induced Gravity-Capillary Waves (GCW), leading to altered surface reflectance of light and microwaves and can also affect near-surface turbulent motions. Therefore, it is of interest to determine the effect slicks can have on the air-water exchange of momentum, heat, and gas, which can influence the biogeochemical dynamics in the near-surface layer of lakes and oceans.

    We investigated the spatiotemporal variability in momentum flux caused by slicks in Lake Geneva during several field campaigns using eddy covariance instrument setups mounted on an autonomous catamaran. The measurements were combined with aerial and shore-based imagery (both RGB and thermal). In addition, surface microlayer sampling was conducted from an accompanying boat to determine whether visually-identified smooth patches were associated with higher enrichments of fluorescent dissolved organic matter, a proxy for natural surfactants. Wavelet analysis was used to explore short-time (~1 min) averaged air-water exchange variations related to the transition from smooth slicks to rough surface areas that cannot be captured by the conventional eddy covariance analysis method.

    Our results suggest that under light wind conditions and in the absence of short GCW on the surface of slicks, wind stress cannot be effectively transferred to the water, leading to reduced momentum exchange inside slicks compared to the surrounding non-slick areas. This results in lateral gradients in vertical mixing that can affect air-water exchange processes and contribute to spatial variability in surface temperature and near-surface heat content.

     

    How to cite: Foroughan, M., Lemmin, U., and Barry, D. A.: The effect of natural surfactants on air-water momentum exchange under light wind conditions in Lake Geneva, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12027, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12027, 2022.

    EGU22-12536 | Presentations | HS10.9

    Deepwater dynamics and spatial heterogeneity observed in the deep hypolimnion of a large lake (Lake Geneva) 

    Rafael S. Reiss, Ulrich Lemmin, and D. Andrew Barry

    In many deep lakes, global warming is weakening wintertime convective cooling, thus reducing the occurrence of complete vertical overturning. At the same time, our understanding of the deepwater dynamics in deep lakes remains elusive, mainly because spatiotemporally resolved in situ measurements are lacking. We address this knowledge gap by exploring the dynamics in the deep hypolimnion of Lake Geneva (max. depth 309 m) by means of extensive field observations.

    Due to its great depth and the mild central European climate, Lake Geneva remains weakly stratified during most years, with complete convective overturning only occurring during severely cold winters. Recent studies show that three-dimensional (3D) transport processes, such as cold-water density currents, coastal upwelling, and wind-driven interbasin exchange significantly impact the dynamics in Lake Geneva’s deep hypolimnion, contributing to its ventilation.

    From February to July 2021, five moorings equipped with Acoustic Doppler Current Profiles (ADCPs), current meters, thermistors and Dissolved Oxygen (DO) loggers were deployed at different locations and depths across the ~300-m deep central plateau (~12 km × 6 km) of Lake Geneva. One mooring remained in place until December 2021.

    The nearly year-long measurements show frequent, large temperature peaks of ~0.03-0.15°C that last ~1-10 d at ~300-m depth, indicating significant isotherm tilting and downward transport of warmer waters, corresponding to vertical excursions of ~30-80 m. During those events, near-bottom DO levels temporarily increase by ~1-2 mg l-1. Furthermore, the different mooring sites reveal large spatial heterogeneity across the 300-m deep plateau, both in the magnitude and temporal variability of the observed peaks.

    From February to December 2021, a mean warming of ~0.07°C was observed at 300-m depth. Over longer periods, a “saw-tooth” pattern was previously found in deep lakes, which consists of continuous warming over several years, interrupted by sudden cooling during particularly cold winters (not the case during our campaign). In contrast, mean DO levels at 300-m depth first increase during spring, stagnate in early summer, and then gradually decrease until late fall/early winter.

    Rotary spectra of the current velocities in the deepest layers show a broad peak in the clockwise-rotating component close to, but below the local inertial period (~16.5 h), in agreement with recent findings of dominant clockwise-rotating inertial currents in Lake Geneva’s deep hypolimnion. However, rotary wavelet analysis further reveals that the broad peak in the clockwise spectra is composed of several distinct frequency bands, concentrating mainly at ~16 h and ~12-14 h. The latter is close to the internal Poincaré wave period, as reported in the literature, indicating that both inertial currents and near-inertial internal waves are important.

    Altogether, these preliminary results demonstrate that Lake Geneva’s deep hypolimnion is surprisingly energetic and characterized by a strong spatial heterogeneity that can only be explained by large-scale 3D flow features, challenging the classic one-dimensional concept of deepwater renewal in large, deep lakes. In the next step, a validated 3D hydrodynamic model will be used to further investigate the observed temperature/DO peaks and trends, the ever-present oscillating currents, as well as determine the origin of these processes.

    How to cite: Reiss, R. S., Lemmin, U., and Barry, D. A.: Deepwater dynamics and spatial heterogeneity observed in the deep hypolimnion of a large lake (Lake Geneva), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12536, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12536, 2022.

    EGU22-13350 | Presentations | HS10.9

    The effects of re-oxygenation of central Baltic Sea sediment; a laboratory study 

    Sina Shahabi-Ghahfarokhi, Mahboubeh Rahmati-Abkenar, Leonie Jaeger, Sarah Josefson, Anna Apler, Henric Djerf, Changxun Yu, Mats Åström, and Marcelo Ketzer

    The eutrophication of the deep central Baltic Sea, Baltic Proper, has caused deoxygenation severe consequences for benthic life. To overcome such limitations and spreads of anoxic basins, proposed techniques such as re-oxygenation of anoxic bottom waters are proposed. However, in the case of the Baltic Proper, the effects of oxygenation in the short term are unknown. Therefore, this research focuses on understanding the geochemistry changes in bottom waters' and sediments during the transition from anoxic/hypoxic to oxic conditions. Six sediment cores were retrieved from the northern and southern Baltic Proper (triplicate cores for each location), where bottom waters have dissolved O2 concentrations of ≈0 mg/L. The bottom waters were exchanged with oxygenated Baltic Sea surface waters for 96 hours. The pH, electroconductivity (EC), and metal concentrations in the exchanged water were measured over time in 12 and 24 hours intervals in the experiment cores. The results indicate that the pH of both sites didn't show any significant change in the exchanged bottom waters during the experiment. However, the EC of the bottom waters on average reduced from 15 to 9 µs/m in both sites. In terms of soluble metals/metalloids, As, Ba, Co, Mn, Mo, Rb, Sr, and U were detected in higher concentrations than unoxygenated bottom water from southern Baltic Proper. Manganese and Sr showed the highest released concentrations in both sites in terms of concentration. This study indicates that undesired release of metals from sediment to the water column may occur during re-oxygenation of Baltic Sea bottom waters. The next stage of this research will focus on the metal transfer from the surface sediments to the bottom waters over the 4-day experiments. This will be done via a sequential chemical analysis scheme, in which surface sediment samples from the experiment will be compared to reference cores collected at the same time as the experimental cores were collected.

    How to cite: Shahabi-Ghahfarokhi, S., Rahmati-Abkenar, M., Jaeger, L., Josefson, S., Apler, A., Djerf, H., Yu, C., Åström, M., and Ketzer, M.: The effects of re-oxygenation of central Baltic Sea sediment; a laboratory study, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13350, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13350, 2022.

    HS11 – Short Courses of specific interest to Hydrological Sciences

    HS12 – Inter- and transdisciplinary sessions (ITS) related to Hydrological Sciences

    EGU22-2024 | Presentations | ITS3.1/SSS1.2 | Highlight

    Understanding natural hazards in a changing landscape: A citizen science approach in Kigezi highlands, southwestern Uganda 

    Violet Kanyiginya, Ronald Twongyirwe, Grace Kagoro, David Mubiru, Matthieu Kervyn, and Olivier Dewitte

    The Kigezi highlands, southwestern Uganda, is a mountainous tropical region with a high population density, intense rainfall, alternating wet and dry seasons and high weathering rates. As a result, the region is regularly affected by multiple natural hazards such as landslides, floods, heavy storms, and earthquakes. In addition, deforestation and land use changes are assumed to have an influence on the patterns of natural hazards and their impacts in the region. Landscape characteristics and dynamics controlling the occurrence and the spatio-temporal distribution of natural hazards in the region remain poorly understood. In this study, citizen science has been employed to document and understand the spatial and temporal occurrence of natural hazards that affect the Kigezi highlands in relation to the multi-decadal landscape change of the region. We present the methodological research framework involving three categories of participatory citizen scientists. First, a network of 15 geo-observers (i.e., citizens of local communities distributed across representative landscapes of the study area) was established in December 2019. The geo-observers were trained at using smartphones to collect information (processes and impacts) on eight different natural hazards occurring across their parishes. In a second phase, eight river watchers were selected at watershed level to monitor the stream flow characteristics. These watchers record stream water levels once daily and make flood observations. In both categories, validation and quality checks are done on the collected data for further analysis. Combining with high resolution rainfall monitoring using rain gauges installed in the watersheds, the data are expected to characterize catchment response to flash floods. Lastly, to reconstruct the historical landscape change and natural hazards occurrences in the region, 96 elderly citizens (>70 years of age) were engaged through interviews and focus group discussions to give an account of the evolution of their landscape over the past 60 years. We constructed a historical timeline for the region to complement the participatory mapping and in-depth interviews with the elderly citizens. During the first 24 months of the project, 240 natural hazard events with accurate timing information have been reported by the geo-observers. Conversion from natural tree species to exotic species, increased cultivation of hillslopes, road construction and abandonment of terraces and fallowing practices have accelerated natural hazards especially flash floods and landslides in the region. Complementing with the region’s historical photos of 1954 and satellite images, major landscape dynamics have been detected. The ongoing data collection involving detailed ground-based observations with citizens shows a promising trend in the generation of new knowledge about natural hazards in the region.

    How to cite: Kanyiginya, V., Twongyirwe, R., Kagoro, G., Mubiru, D., Kervyn, M., and Dewitte, O.: Understanding natural hazards in a changing landscape: A citizen science approach in Kigezi highlands, southwestern Uganda, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2024, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2024, 2022.

    EGU22-2929 | Presentations | ITS3.1/SSS1.2

    Possible Contributions of Citizen Science in the Development of the Next Generation of City Climate Services 

    Peter Dietrich, Uta Ködel, Sophia Schütze, Felix Schmidt, Fabian Schütze, Aletta Bonn, Thora Herrmann, and Claudia Schütze

    Human life in cities is already affected by climate change. The effects will become even more pronounced in the coming years and decades. Next-generation of city climate services is necessary for adapting infrastructures and the management of services of cities to climate change. These services are based on advanced weather forecast models and the access to diverse data. It is essential to keep in mind that each citizen is a unique individual with their own peculiarities, preferences, and behaviors. The base for our approach is the individual specific exposure, which considers that people perceive the same conditions differently in terms of their well-being. Individual specific exposure can be defined as the sum of all environmental conditions that affect humans during a given period of time, in a specific location, and in a specific context. Thereby, measurable abiotic parameters such as temperature, humidity, wind speed, pollution and noise are used to characterize the environmental conditions. Additional information regarding green spaces, trees, parks, kinds of streets and buildings, as well as available infrastructures are included in the context. The recording and forecasting of environmental parameters while taking into account the context, as well as the presentation of this information in easy-to-understand and easy-to-use maps, are critical for influencing human behavior and implementing appropriate climate change adaptation measures.

    We will adopt this approach within the frame of the recently started, EU-funded CityCLIM project. We aim to develop and implement approaches which will explore the potential of citizen science in terms of current and historical data collecting, data quality assessment and evaluation of data products.  In addition, our approach will also provide strategies for individual climate data use, and the derivation and evaluation of climate change adaptation actions in cities.

    In a first step we need to define and to characterize the different potential stakeholder groups involved in citizen science data collection. Citizen science offers approaches that consider citizens as both  organized target groups (e.g., engaged companies, schools) and individual persons (e.g. hobby scientists). An important point to be investigated is the motivation of citizen science stakehoder groups to sustainably collect data and make it available to science and reward them accordingly. For that purpose, strategic tools, such as value proposition canvas analysis, will be applied to taylor the science-to-business and the science-to-customer communications and offers in terms of the individual needs.

    How to cite: Dietrich, P., Ködel, U., Schütze, S., Schmidt, F., Schütze, F., Bonn, A., Herrmann, T., and Schütze, C.: Possible Contributions of Citizen Science in the Development of the Next Generation of City Climate Services, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2929, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2929, 2022.

    EGU22-4168 | Presentations | ITS3.1/SSS1.2

    Extending Rapid Image Classification with the Picture Pile Platform for Citizen Science 

    Tobias Sturn, Linda See, Steffen Fritz, Santosh Karanam, and Ian McCallum

    Picture Pile is a flexible web-based and mobile application for ingesting imagery from satellites, orthophotos, unmanned aerial vehicles and/or geotagged photographs for rapid classification by volunteers. Since 2014, there have been 16 different crowdsourcing campaigns run with Picture Pile, which has involved more than 4000 volunteers who have classified around 11.5 million images. Picture Pile is based on a simple mechanic in which users view an image and then answer a question, e.g., do you see oil palm, with a simple yes, no or maybe answer by swiping the image to the right, left or downwards, respectively. More recently, Picture Pile has been modified to classify data into categories (e.g., crop types) as well as continuous variables (e.g., degree of wealth) so that additional types of data can be collected.

    The Picture Pile campaigns have covered a range of domains from classification of deforestation to building damage to different types of land cover, with crop type identification as the latest ongoing campaign through the Earth Challenge network. Hence, Picture Pile can be used for many different types of applications that need image classifications, e.g., as reference data for training remote sensing algorithms, validation of remotely sensed products or training data of computer vision algorithms. Picture Pile also has potential for monitoring some of the indicators of the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). The Picture Pile Platform is the next generation of the Picture Pile application, which will allow any user to create their own ‘piles’ of imagery and run their own campaigns using the system. In addition to providing an overview of Picture Pile, including some examples of relevance to SDG monitoring, this presentation will provide an overview of the current status of the Picture Pile Platform along with the data sharing model, the machine learning component and the vision for how the platform will function operationally to aid environmental monitoring.

    How to cite: Sturn, T., See, L., Fritz, S., Karanam, S., and McCallum, I.: Extending Rapid Image Classification with the Picture Pile Platform for Citizen Science, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4168, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4168, 2022.

    EGU22-5094 | Presentations | ITS3.1/SSS1.2

    Life in undies – Preliminary results of a citizen science data collection targeting soil health assessement in Hungary 

    Mátyás Árvai, Péter László, Tünde Takáts, Zsófia Adrienn Kovács, Kata Takács, János Mészaros, and László Pásztor

    Last year, the Institute for Soil Sciences, Centre for Agricultural Research launched Hungary's first citizen science project with the aim to obtain information on the biological activity of soils using a simple estimation procedure. With the help of social media, the reactions on the call for applications were received from nearly 2000 locations. 

    In the Hungarian version of the international Soil your Undies programme, standardized cotton underwear was posted to the participants with a step-by-step tutorial, who buried their underwear for about 60 days, from mid of May until July in 2021, at a depth of about 20-25 cm. After the excavation, the participants took one digital image of the underwear and recorded the geographical coordinates, which were  uploaded to a GoogleForms interface together with several basic information related to the location and the user (type of cultivation, demographic data etc.).

    By analysing digital photos of the excavated undies made by volunteers, we obtained information on the level to which cotton material had decomposed in certain areas and under different types of cultivation. Around 40% of the participants buried the underwear in garden, 21% in grassland, 15% in orchard, 12% in arable land, 5% in vineyard and 4% in forest (for 3% no landuse data was provided).

    The images were first processed using Fococlipping and Photoroom softwares for background removing and then percentage of cotton material remaining was estimated based on the pixels by using R Studio ‘raster package’.

    The countrywide collected biological activity data from nearly 1200 sites were statistically evaluated by spatially aggregating the data both for physiographical and administrative units. The results have been published on various platforms (Facebook, Instagram, specific web site etc.), and a feedback is also given directly to the volunteers.

    According to the experiments the first citizen science programme proved to be successful. 

     

    Acknowledgment: Our research was supported by the Hungarian National Research, Development and Innovation Office (NKFIH; K-131820)

    Keywords: citizen science; soil life; soil health; biological activity; soil properties

    How to cite: Árvai, M., László, P., Takáts, T., Kovács, Z. A., Takács, K., Mészaros, J., and Pásztor, L.: Life in undies – Preliminary results of a citizen science data collection targeting soil health assessement in Hungary, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5094, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5094, 2022.

    EGU22-5147 | Presentations | ITS3.1/SSS1.2

    Distributed databases for citizen science 

    Julien Malard-Adam, Joel Harms, and Wietske Medema

    Citizen science is often heavily dependent on software tools that allow members of the general population to collect, view and submit environmental data to a common database. While several such software platforms exist, these often require expert knowledge to set up and maintain, and server and data hosting costs can become quite costly in the long term, especially if a project is successful in attracting many users and data submissions. In the context of time-limited project funding, these limitations can pose serious obstacles to the long-term sustainability of citizen science projects as well as their ownership by the community.

    One the other hand, distributed database systems (such as Qri and Constellation) dispense with the need for a centralised server and instead rely on the devices (smartphone or computer) of the users themselves to store and transmit community-generated data. This new approach leads to the counterintuitive result that distributed systems, contrarily to centralised ones, become more robust and offer better availability and response times as the size of the user pool grows. In addition, since data is stored by users’ own devices, distributed systems offer interesting potential for strengthening communities’ ownership over their own environmental data (data sovereignty). This presentation will discuss the potential of distributed database systems to address the current technological limitations of centralised systems for open data and citizen science-led data collection efforts and will give examples of use cases with currently available distributed database software platforms.

    How to cite: Malard-Adam, J., Harms, J., and Medema, W.: Distributed databases for citizen science, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5147, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5147, 2022.

    EGU22-5571 | Presentations | ITS3.1/SSS1.2

    RESECAN: citizen-driven seismology on an active volcano (Cumbre Vieja, La Palma Island, Canaries) 

    Rubén García-Hernández, José Barrancos, Luca D'Auria, Vidal Domínguez, Arturo Montalvo, and Nemesio Pérez

    During the last decades, countless seismic sensors have been deployed throughout the planet by different countries and institutions. In recent years, it has been possible to manufacture low-cost MEMS accelerometers thanks to nanotechnology and large-scale development. These devices can be easily configured and accurately synchronized by GPS. Customizable microcontrollers like Arduino or RaspBerryPI can be used to develop low-cost seismic stations capable of local data storage and real-time data transfer. Such stations have a sufficient signal quality to be used for complementing conventional seismic networks.

    In recent years Instituto Volcanológico de Canarias (INVOLCAN) has developed a proprietary low-cost seismic station to implement the Canary Islands School Seismic Network (Red Sísmica Escolar Canaria - RESECAN) with multiple objectives:

    • supporting the teaching of geosciences.
    • promoting the scientific vocation.
    • strengthening the resilience of the local communities by improving awareness toward volcanism and the associated hazards.
    • Densifying the existing seismic networks.

    On Sept. 19th 2021, a volcanic eruption started on the Cumbre Vieja volcano in La Palma. The eruption was proceeded and accompanied by thousands of earthquakes, many of them felt with intensities up to V MCS. Exploiting the attention drawn by the eruption, INVOLCAN started the deployment of low-cost seismic stations in La Palma in educational centres. In this preliminary phase, we selected five educational centres on the island.

    The project's objective is to create and distribute low-cost stations in various educational institutions in La Palma and later on the whole Canary Islands Archipelago, supplementing them with educational material on the topics of seismology and volcanology. Each school will be able to access the data of its station, as well as those collected by other centres, being able to locate some of the recorded earthquakes. The data recorded by RESECAN will also be integrated into the broadband seismic network operated by INVOLCAN (Red Sísmica Canaria, C7). RESECAN will be an instrument of scientific utility capable of contributing effectively to the volcano monitoring of the Canary Islands, reinforcing its resilience with respect to future volcanic emergencies.

    How to cite: García-Hernández, R., Barrancos, J., D'Auria, L., Domínguez, V., Montalvo, A., and Pérez, N.: RESECAN: citizen-driven seismology on an active volcano (Cumbre Vieja, La Palma Island, Canaries), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5571, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5571, 2022.

    EGU22-6970 | Presentations | ITS3.1/SSS1.2

    Analysis of individual learning outcomes of students and teachers in the citizen science project TeaTime4Schools 

    Anna Wawra, Martin Scheuch, Bernhard Stürmer, and Taru Sanden

    Only a few of the increasing number of citizen science projects set out to determine the projects impact on diverse learning outcomes of citizen scientists. However, besides pure completion of project activities and data collection, measurable benefits as individual learning outcomes (ILOs) (Phillips et al. 2014) should reward voluntary work.

    Within the citizen science project „TeaTime4Schools“, Austrian students in the range of 13 to 18 years collected data as a group activity in a teacher guided school context; tea bags were buried into soil to investigate litter decomposition. In an online questionnaire a set of selected scales of ILOs (Phillips et al. 2014, Keleman-Finan et al. 2018, Wilde et al. 2009) were applied to test those ILOs of students who participated in TeaTime4Schools. Several indicators (scales for project-related response, interest in science, interest in soil, environmental activism, and self-efficacy) were specifically tailored from these evaluation frameworks to measure four main learning outcomes: interest, motivation, behavior, self-efficacy. In total, 106 valid replies of students were analyzed. In addition, 21 teachers who participated in TeaTime4Schools, answered a separate online questionnaire that directly asked about quality and liking of methods used in the project based on suggested scales about learning tasks of University College for Agricultural and Environmental Education (2015), which were modified for the purpose of this study. Findings of our research will be presented.

    How to cite: Wawra, A., Scheuch, M., Stürmer, B., and Sanden, T.: Analysis of individual learning outcomes of students and teachers in the citizen science project TeaTime4Schools, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6970, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6970, 2022.

    EGU22-7164 | Presentations | ITS3.1/SSS1.2

    Seismic and air monitoring observatory for greater Beirut : a citizen observatory of the "urban health" of Beirut 

    Cecile Cornou, Laurent Drapeau, Youssef El Bakouny, Samer Lahoud, Alain Polikovitch, Chadi Abdallah, Charbel Abou Chakra, Charbel Afif, Ahmad Al Bitar, Stephane Cartier, Pascal Fanice, Johnny Fenianos, Bertrand Guillier, Carla Khater, and Gabriel Khoury and the SMOAG Team

    Already sensitive because of its geology (seismic-tsunamic risk) and its interface between arid and temperate ecosystems, the Mediterranean Basin is being transformed by climate change and major urban pressure on resources and spaces. Lebanon concentrates on a small territory the environmental, climatic, health, social and political crises of the Middle East: shortages and degradation of surface and groundwater quality, air pollution, landscape fragmentation, destruction of ecosystems, erosion of biodiversity, telluric risks and very few mechanisms of information, prevention and protection against these vulnerabilities. Further, Lebanon is sorely lacking in environmental data at sufficient temporal and spatial scales to cover the range of key phenomena and to allow the integration of environmental issues for the country's development. This absence was sadly illustrated during the August 4th, 2020, explosion at the port of Beirut, which hindered the effective management of induced threats to protect the inhabitants. In this degraded context combined with a systemic crisis situation in Lebanon, frugal  innovation is more than an option, it is a necessity. Initiated in 2021 within the framework of the O-LIFE lebanese-french research consortium (www.o-life.org), the « Seismic and air monitoring observatory  for greater Beirut » (SMOAG) project aims at setting up a citizen observatory of the urban health of Beirut by deploying innovative, connected, low-cost, energy-efficient and robust environmental and seismological instruments. Through co-constructed web services and mobile applications with various stakeholders (citizens, NGOs, decision makers and scientists), the SMOAG citizen observatory will contribute to the information and mobilization of Lebanese citizens and managers by sharing the monitoring of key indicators associated with air quality, heat islands and building stability, essential issues for a sustainable Beirut.

    The first phase of the project was dedicated to the development of a low-cost environmental sensor enabling pollution and urban weather measurements (particle matters, SO2, CO, O3, N02, solar radiation, wind speed, temperature, humidity, rainfall) and to the development of all the software infrastructure, from data acquisition to the synoptic indicators accessible via web and mobile application, while following the standards of the Sensor Web Enablement and Sensor Observation System of the OGC and to the FAIR principles (Easy to find, Accessible, Interoperable, Reusable). A website and Android/IOS applications for the restitution of data and indicators and a dashboard allowing real time access to data have been developed. Environmental and low-cost seismological stations (Raspberry Shake) have been already deployed in Beirut, most of them hosted by Lebanese citizens. These instrumental and open data access efforts were completed by participatory workshops with various stakeholders  to improve the ergonomy of the web and application interfaces and to define roadmap for the implantation of future stations, consistently with  most vulnerable populations identified by NGOs and the current knowledge on the air pollution and heat islands in Beirut.

    How to cite: Cornou, C., Drapeau, L., El Bakouny, Y., Lahoud, S., Polikovitch, A., Abdallah, C., Abou Chakra, C., Afif, C., Al Bitar, A., Cartier, S., Fanice, P., Fenianos, J., Guillier, B., Khater, C., and Khoury, G. and the SMOAG Team: Seismic and air monitoring observatory for greater Beirut : a citizen observatory of the "urban health" of Beirut, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7164, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7164, 2022.

    EGU22-7323 | Presentations | ITS3.1/SSS1.2

    Citizen science for better water quality management in the Brantas catchment, Indonesia? Preliminary results 

    Reza Pramana, Schuyler Houser, Daru Rini, and Maurits Ertsen

    Water quality in the rivers and tributaries of the Brantas catchment (about 12.000 km2) is deteriorating due to various reasons, including rapid economic development, insufficient domestic water treatment and waste management, and industrial pollution. Various water quality parameters are at least measured on monthly basis by agencies involved in water resource development and management. However, measurements consistently demonstrate exceedance of the local water quality standards. Recent claims presented by the local Environmental Protection Agency indicate that the water quality is much more affected by the domestic sources compared to the others. In an attempt to examine this, we proposed a citizen science campaign by involving people from seven communities living close to the river, a network organisation that works on water quality monitoring, three government agencies, and students from a local university. Beginning in 2022, we kicked off our campaign by measuring with test strips for nitrate, nitrite, and phosphate on weekly basis at twelve different locations from upstream to downstream of the catchment. In the effort to provide education on water stewardship and empower citizens to participate in water quality management, preliminary results – the test strips, strategies, and challenges - will be shown.

    How to cite: Pramana, R., Houser, S., Rini, D., and Ertsen, M.: Citizen science for better water quality management in the Brantas catchment, Indonesia? Preliminary results, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7323, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7323, 2022.

    EGU22-7916 | Presentations | ITS3.1/SSS1.2

    Citizen science - an invaluable tool for obtaining high-resolution spatial and temporal meteorological data 

    Jadranka Sepic, Jure Vranic, Ivica Aviani, Drago Milanovic, and Miro Burazer

    Available quality-checked institutional meteorological data is often not measured at locations of particular interest for observing specific small-scale and meso-scale atmospheric processes. Similarly, institutional data can be hard to obtain due to data policy restrictions. On the other hand, a lot of people are highly interested in meteorology, and they frequently deploy meteorological instruments at locations where they live. Such citizen data are often shared through public data repositories and websites with sophisticated visualization routines.  As a result, the networks of citizen meteorological stations are, in numerous areas, denser and more easily accessible than are the institutional meteorological networks.  

    Several examples of publicly available citizen meteorological networks, including school networks, are explored – and their application to published high-quality scientific papers is discussed. It is shown that for the data-based analysis of specific atmospheric processes of interest, such as mesoscale convective disturbances and mesoscale atmospheric gravity waves, the best qualitative and quantitative results are often obtained using densely populated citizen networks.  

    Finally, a “cheap and easy to do” project of constructing a meteorological station with a variable number of atmospheric sensors is presented. Suggestions on how to use such stations in educational and citizen science activities, and even in real-time warning systems, are given.  

    How to cite: Sepic, J., Vranic, J., Aviani, I., Milanovic, D., and Burazer, M.: Citizen science - an invaluable tool for obtaining high-resolution spatial and temporal meteorological data, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7916, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7916, 2022.

    Among the greatest constraints to accurately monitoring and understanding climate and climate change in many locations is limited in situ observing capacity and resolution in these places. Climate behaviours along with dependent environmental and societal processes are frequently highly localized, while observing systems in the region may be separated by hundreds of kilometers and may not adequately represent conditions between them. Similarly, generating climate equity in urban regions can be hindered by an inability to resolve urban heat islands at neighborhood scales. In both cases, higher density observations are necessary for accurate condition monitoring, research, and for the calibration and validation of remote sensing products and predictive models. Coincidentally, urban neighborhoods are heavily populated and thousands of individuals visit remote locations each day for recreational purposes. Many of these individuals are concerned about climate change and are keen to contribute to climate solutions. However, there are several challenges to creating a voluntary citizen science climate observing program that addresses these opportunities. The first is that such a program has the potential for limited uptake if participants are required to volunteer their time or incur a significant cost to participate. The second is that researchers and decision-makers may be reluctant to use the collected data owing to concern over observer bias. This paper describes the on-going development and implementation by 2DegreesC.org of a technology-driven citizen science approach in which participants are equipped with low-cost automated sensors that systematically sample and communicate scientifically valid climate observations while they focus on other activities (e.g., recreation, gardening, fitness). Observations are acquired by a cloud-based system that quality controls, anonymizes, and makes them openly available. Simultaneously, individuals of all backgrounds who share a love of the outdoors become engaged in the scientific process via data-driven communication, research, and educational interactions. Because costs and training are minimized as barriers to participation, data collection is opportunistic, and the technology can be used almost anywhere, this approach is dynamically scalable with the potential for millions of participants to collect billions of new, accurate observations that integrate with and enhance existing observational network capacity.

    How to cite: Shein, K.: Linking citizen scientists with technology to reduce climate data gaps, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10634, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10634, 2022.

    The 2019-2020 bushfire season (the Black Summer) in Australia was unprecedented in its breadth and severity as well as the disrupted resources and time dedicated to studying it.  Right after one of the most extreme fire seasons on record had hit Australia, a once-in-a-century global pandemic, COVID-19, occurred. This pandemic caused world-wide lockdowns throughout 2020 and 2021 that prevented travel and field work, thus hindering researchers from assessing damage done by the Black Summer bushfires. Early assessments show that the bushfires on Kangaroo Island, South Australia caused declines in soil nutrients and ground coverage up to 10 months post-fire, indicating higher risk of soil erosion and fire-induced land degradation at this location. In parallel to the direct impacts the Black Summer bushfires had on native vegetation and soil, the New South Wales Nature Conservation Council observed a noticeable increase in demand for fire management workshops in 2020. What was observed of fires and post-fire outcomes on soil and vegetation from the 2019-2020 bushfire season that drove so many citizens into action? In collaboration with the New South Wales Nature Conservation Council and Rural Fire Service through the Hotspots Fire Project, we will be surveying and interviewing landowners across New South Wales to collect their observations and insights regarding the Black Summer. By engaging landowners, this project aims to answer the following: within New South Wales, Australia, what impact did the 2019-2020 fire season have on a) soil health and native vegetation and b) human behaviours and perceptions of fire in the Australian landscape. The quantity of insights gained from NSW citizens will provide a broad assessment of fire impacts across multiple soil and ecosystem types, providing knowledge of the impacts of severe fires, such as those that occurred during the Black Summer, to the scientific community. Furthermore, with knowledge gained from reflections from citizens, the Hotspots Fire Project will be better able to train and support workshop participants, while expanding the coverage of workshops to improve support of landowners across the state. Data regarding fire impacts on soil, ecosystems, and communities has been collected by unknowing citizen scientists all across New South Wales, and to gain access to that data, we need only ask.

    How to cite: Ondik, M., Ooi, M., and Muñoz-Rojas, M.: Insights from landowners on Australia's Black Summer bushfires: impacts on soil and vegetation, perceptions, and behaviours, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10776, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10776, 2022.

    High air pollution concentration levels and increased urban heat island intensity, are amongst the most critical contemporary urban health concerns. This is the reason why various municipalities are starting to invest in extensive direct air quality and microclimate sensing networks. Through the study of these datasets it has become evident that the understanding of inter-urban environmental gradients is imperative to effectively introduce urban land-use strategies to improve the environmental conditions in the neighborhoods that suffer the most, and develop city-scale urban planning solutions for a better urban health.  However, given economic limitations or divergent political views, extensive direct sensing environmental networks have yet not been implemented in most cities. While the validity of citizen science environmental datasets is often questioned given that they rely on low-cost sensing technologies and fail to incorporate sensor calibration protocols, they can offer an alternative to municipal sensing networks if the necessary Quality Assurance / Quality Control (QA/QC) protocols are put in place.

    This research has focused on the development of a QA/QC protocol for the study of urban environmental data collected by the citizen science PurpleAir initiative implemented in the Bay Area and the city of Los Angeles where over 700 purple air stations have been implemented in the last years. Following the QA/QC process the PurpleAir data was studied in combination with remote sensing datasets on land surface temperature and normalized difference vegetation index, and geospatial datasets on socio-demographic and urban fabric parameters. Through a footprint-based study, and for all PurpleAir station locations, the featured variables and the buffer sizes with higher correlations have been identified to compute the inter-urban environmental gradient predictions making use of 3 supervised machine learning models: - Regression Tree Ensemble, Support Vector Machine, and a Gaussian Process Regression.

    How to cite: Llaguno-Munitxa, M., Bou-Zeid, E., Rueda, P., and Shu, X.: Citizen-science urban environmental monitoring for the development of an inter-urban environmental prediction model for the city of Los Angeles, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11765, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11765, 2022.

    EGU22-11797 | Presentations | ITS3.1/SSS1.2

    Attitudes towards a cafetiere-style filter system and paper-based analysis pad for soil nutrition surveillance in-situ: evidence from Kenya and Vietnam 

    Samantha Richardson, Philip Kamau, Katie J Parsons, Florence Halstead, Ibrahim Ndirangu, Vo Quang Minh, Van Pham Dang Tri, Hue Le, Nicole Pamme, and Jesse Gitaka

    Routine monitoring of soil chemistry is needed for effective crop management since a poor understanding of nutrient levels affects crop yields and ultimately farmers’ livelihoods.1 In low- and middle-income countries soil sampling is usually limited, due to required access to analytical services and high costs of portable sampling equipment.2 We are developing portable and low-cost sampling and analysis tools which would enable farmers to test their own land and make informed decisions around the need for fertilizers. In this study we aimed to understand attitudes of key stakeholders towards this technology and towards collecting the data gathered on public databases which could inform decisions at government level to better manage agriculture across a country.

     

    In Kenya, we surveyed 549 stakeholders from Murang’a and Kiambu counties, 77% men and 23% women. 17.2% of these respondent smallholder farmers were youthful farmers aged 18-35 years with 81.9% male and 18.1% female-headed farming enterprises. The survey covered current knowledge of soil nutrition, existing soil management practices, desire to sample soil in the future, attitudes towards our developed prototypes, motivation towards democratization of soil data, and willingness to pay for the technology. In Vietnam a smaller mixed methods online survey was distributed via national farming unions to 27 stakeholders, in particular engaging younger farmers with an interest in technology and innovation.

    Within the Kenya cohort, only 1.5% of farmers currently test for nutrients and pH. Reasons given for not testing included a lack of knowledge about soil testing (35%), distance to testing centers (34%) and high costs (16%). However, 97% of respondents were interested in soil sampling at least once a year, particularly monitoring nitrates and phosphates. Nearly all participants, 94-99% among the males/females/youths found cost of repeated analysis of soil samples costing around USD 11-12 as affordable for their business. Regarding sharing the collecting data, 88% believed this would be beneficial, for example citing that data shared with intervention agencies and agricultural officers could help them receive relevant advice.

    In Vietnam, 87% of famers did not have their soil nutrient levels tested with 62% saying they did not know how and 28% indicating prohibitive costs. Most currently relied on local knowledge and observations to improve their soil quality. 87% thought that the system we were proposing was affordable with only 6% saying they would not be interested in trialing this new technology. Regarding the soil data, respondents felt that it should be open access and available to everyone.

    Our surveys confirmed the need and perceived benefit for our proposed simple-to-operate and cost-effective workflow, which would enable farmers to test soil chemistry themselves on their own land. Farmers were also found to be motivated towards sharing their soil data to get advice from government agencies. The survey results will inform our further development of low-cost, portable analytical tools for simple on-site measurements of nutrient levels within soil.

     

    1. Dimkpa, C., et al., Sustainable Agriculture Reviews, 2017, 25, 1-43.

    2. Zingore, S., et al., Better Crops, 2015, 99 (1), 24-26.

    How to cite: Richardson, S., Kamau, P., Parsons, K. J., Halstead, F., Ndirangu, I., Minh, V. Q., Tri, V. P. D., Le, H., Pamme, N., and Gitaka, J.: Attitudes towards a cafetiere-style filter system and paper-based analysis pad for soil nutrition surveillance in-situ: evidence from Kenya and Vietnam, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11797, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11797, 2022.

    Keywords: preconcentration, heavy metal, cafetiere, citizen science, paper-based microfluidics

    Heavy-metal analysis of water samples using microfluidics paper-based analytical devices (µPAD) with colourimetric readout is of great interest due to its simplicity, affordability and potential for Citizen Science-based data collection [1]. However, this approach is limited by the relatively poor sensitivity of the colourimetric substrates, typically achieving detection within the mg L-1 range, whereas heavy-metals exist in the environment at <μg L-1 quantities   [2]. Preconcentration is commonly used when analyte concentration is below the analytical range, but this typically requires laboratory equipment and expert users [3]. Here, we are developing a simple method for pre-concentration of heavy metals, to be integrated with a µPAD workflow that would allow Citizen Scientists to carry out pre-concentration as well as readout on-site.

    The filter mesh from an off-the-shelf cafetière (350 mL) was replaced with a custom-made bead carrier basket, laser cut in PMMA sheet featuring >500 evenly spread 100 µm diameter holes. This allowed the water sample to pass through the basket and mix efficiently with the 2.6 g ion-exchange resin beads housed within (Lewatit® TP207, Ambersep® M4195, Lewatit® MonoPlus SP 112). An aqueous Ni2+ sample (0.3 mg L-1, 300 mL) was placed in the cafetiere and the basket containing ion exchange material was moved up and down for 5 min to allow Ni2+ adsorption onto the resin. Initial investigations into elution with a safe, non-toxic eluent focused on using NaCl (5 M). These were carried out by placing the elution solution into a shallow dish and into which the the resin containing carrier basket was submerging. UV/vis spectroscopy via a colourimetric reaction with nioxime was used to monitor Ni2+ absorption and elution.

    After 5 min of mixing it was found that Lewatit® TP207 and Ambersep® M4195 resins adsorbed up to 90% of the Ni2+ ions present in solution and the Lewatit® MonoPlus SP 112 adsorbed up to 60%. However, the Lewatit® MonoPlus SP 112 resin performed better for elution with NaCl. Initial studies showed up to 30% of the Ni2+ was eluted within only 1 min of mixing with 10 mL 5 M NaCl.

    Using a cafetière as pre-concentration vessel coupled with non-hazardous reagents in the pre-concentration process allows involvement of citizen scientists in more advanced environmental monitoring activities that cannot be achieved with a simple paper-based sensor alone. Future work will investigate the user-friendliness of the design by trialling the system with volunteers and will aim to further improve the trapping and elution efficiencies.

     

    References:

    • Almeida, M., et al., Talanta, 2018, 177, 176-190.
    • Lace, A., J. Cleary, Chemosens., 2021. 9, 60.
    • Alahmad, W., et al.. Biosens. Bioelectron., 2021. 194, 113574.

     

    How to cite: Sari, M., Richardson, S., Mayes, W., Lorch, M., and Pamme, N.: Method development for on-site freshwater analysis with pre-concentration of nickel via ion-exchange resins embedded in a cafetière system and paper-based analytical devices for readout, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11892, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11892, 2022.

    EGU22-12972 | Presentations | ITS3.1/SSS1.2 | Highlight

    Collection of valuable polar data and increase in nature awareness among travellers by using Expedition Cruise Ships as platforms of opportunity 

    Verena Meraldi, Tudor Morgan, Amanda Lynnes, and Ylva Grams

    Hurtigruten Expeditions, a member of the International Association of Antarctica Tour Operators (IAATO) and the Association of Arctic Expedition Cruise Operators (AECO) has been visiting the fragile polar environments for two decades, witnessing the effects of climate change. Tourism and the number of ships in the polar regions has grown significantly. As a stakeholder aware of the need for long-term protection of these regions, we promote safe and environmentally responsible operations, invest in the understanding and conservation of the areas we visit, and focus on the enrichment of our guests.

    For the last couple of years, we have supported the scientific community by transporting researchers and their equipment to and from their study areas in polar regions and we have established collaborations with numerous scientific institutions. In parallel we developed our science program with the goal of educating our guests about the natural environments they are in, as well as to further support the scientific community by providing our ships as platforms of opportunity for spatial and temporal data collection. Participation in Citizen Science programs that complement our lecture program provides an additional education opportunity for guests to better understand the challenges the visited environment faces while contributing to filling scientific knowledge gaps in remote areas and providing data for evidence-based decision making.

    We aim to continue working alongside the scientific community and developing partnerships. We believe that scientific research and monitoring in the Arctic and Antarctic can hugely benefit from the reoccurring presence of our vessels in these areas, as shown by the many projects we have supported so far. In addition, our partnership with the Polar Citizen Science Collective, a charity that facilitates interaction between scientists running Citizen Science projects and expedition tour operators, will allow the development of programs on an industry level, rather than just an operator level, increasing the availability and choice of platforms of opportunity for the scientific community.

    How to cite: Meraldi, V., Morgan, T., Lynnes, A., and Grams, Y.: Collection of valuable polar data and increase in nature awareness among travellers by using Expedition Cruise Ships as platforms of opportunity, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12972, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12972, 2022.

    EGU22-13115 | Presentations | ITS3.1/SSS1.2

    Participatory rainfall monitoring: strengthening hydrometeorological risk management and community resilience in Peru 

    Miguel Arestegui, Miluska Ordoñez, Abel Cisneros, Giorgio Madueño, Cinthia Almeida, Vannia Aliaga, Nelson Quispe, Carlos Millán, Waldo Lavado, Samuel Huaman, and Jeremy Phillips

    Heavy rainfall, floods and debris flow on the Rimac river watershed are recurring events that impact Peruvian people in vulnerable situations.There are few historical records, in terms of hydrometeorological variables, with sufficient temporal and spatial accuracy. As a result, Early Warning Systems (EWS) efficiency, dealing with these hazards, is critically limited.

    In order to tackle this challenge, among other objectives, the Participatory Monitoring Network (Red de Monitoreo Participativo or Red MoP, in spanish) was formed: an alternative monitoring system supported by voluntary community collaboration of local population under a citizen science approach. This network collects and communicates data captured with standardized manual rain gauges (< 3USD). So far, it covers districts in the east metropolitan area of the capital city of Lima, on dense peri-urban areas, districts on the upper Rimac watershed on rural towns, and expanding to other upper watersheds as well.

    Initially led by Practical Action as part of the Zurich Flood Resilience Alliance, it is now also supported by SENAMHI (National Meteorological and Hydrological Service) and INICTEL-UNI (National Telecommunications Research and Training Institute), as an activity of the National EWS Network (RNAT).

    For the 2019-2022 rainfall seasons, the network has been gathering data and information from around 80 volunteers located throughout the Rimac and Chillon river watersheds (community members, local governments officers, among others): precipitation, other meteorological variables, and information regarding the occurrence of events such as floods and debris flow (locally known as huaycos). SENAMHI has provided a focalized 24h forecast for the area covered by the volunteers, experimentally combines official stations data with the network’s for spatial analysis of rainfall, and, with researchers from the University of Bristol, analyses potential uses of events gathered through this network. In order to facilitate and automatize certain processes, INICTEL-UNI developed a web-platform and a mobile application that is being piloted.

    We present an analysis of events and trends gathered through this initiative (such as a debris flow occurred in 2019). Specifically, hotspots and potential uses of this sort of refined spatialized rainfall information in the dry & tropical Andes. As well, we present a qualitative analysis of volunteers’ expectations and perceptions. Finally, we also present a meteorological explanation of selected events, supporting the importance of measuring localized precipitation during the occurrence of extreme events in similar complex, physical and social contexts.

    How to cite: Arestegui, M., Ordoñez, M., Cisneros, A., Madueño, G., Almeida, C., Aliaga, V., Quispe, N., Millán, C., Lavado, W., Huaman, S., and Phillips, J.: Participatory rainfall monitoring: strengthening hydrometeorological risk management and community resilience in Peru, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13115, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13115, 2022.

    The ITU/WMO/UNEP Focus Group on AI for Natural Disaster Management (FG-AI4NDM) explores the potential of AI to support the monitoring and detection, forecasting, and communication of natural disasters. Building on the presentation at EGU2021, we will show how detailed analysis of real-life use cases by an interdisciplinary, multistakeholder, and international community of experts is leading to the development of three technical reports (dedicated to best practices in data collection and handling, AI-based algorithms, and AI-based communications technologies, respectively), a roadmap of ongoing pre-standardization and standardization activities in this domain, a glossary of relevant terms and definitions, and educational materials to support capacity building. It is hoped that these deliverables will form the foundation of internationally recognized standards.

    How to cite: Kuglitsch, M.: Nature can be disruptive, so can technology: ITU/WMO/UNEP Focus Group on AI for Natural Disaster Management, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8, 2022.

    EGU22-79 | Presentations | ITS2.5/NH10.8

    Assessing the impact of sea-level rise on future compound flooding hazards in the Kapuas River delta 

    Joko Sampurno, Valentin Vallaeys, Randy Ardianto, and Emmanuel Hanert

    Compound flooding hazard in estuarine delta is increasing due to mean sea-level rise (SLR) as the impact of climate change. Decision-makers need future hazard analysis to mitigate the event and design adaptation strategies. However, to date, no future hazard analysis has been made for the Kapuas River delta, a low-lying area on the west coast of the island of Borneo, Indonesia. Therefore, this study aims to assess future compound flooding hazards under SLR over the delta, particularly in Pontianak (the densest urban area over the region). Here we consider three SLR scenarios due to climate change, i.e., low emission scenario (RCP2.6), medium emission scenario (RCP4.5), and high emission scenario (RCP8.5). We implement a machine-learning technique, i.e., the multiple linear regression (MLR) algorithm, to model the river water level dynamics within the city. We then predict future extreme river water levels due to interactions of river discharges, rainfalls, winds, and tides. Furthermore, we create flood maps with a likelihood of areas to be flooded in 100 years return period (1% annual exceedance probability) due to the expected sea-level rise. We find that the extreme 1% return water level for the study area in 2100 is increased from about 2.80 m (current flood frequency state) to 3.03 m (under the RCP2.6), to 3.13 m (under the RCP4.5), and 3.38 m (under the RCP8.5).

    How to cite: Sampurno, J., Vallaeys, V., Ardianto, R., and Hanert, E.: Assessing the impact of sea-level rise on future compound flooding hazards in the Kapuas River delta, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-79, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-79, 2022.

    According to UNDRR2021, there are 389 reported disasters in 2020. Disasters claim the lives of 15,080 people, 98.4 million people are affected globally, and US171.3 billion dollars are spent on economic damage. International agreements such as the Sendai framework for disaster risk reduction encourage the use of social media to strengthen disaster risk communication. With the advent of new technologies, social media has emerged out to be an important source of information in disaster management, and there is an increase in social media activity whilst disasters. Social media is the fourth most used platform for accessing emergency information. People seek to contact family, friends and search for food, water, transportation, and shelter. During cataclysmic events, the critical information posted on social media is immersed in irrelevant information. To assist and streamline emergency situations, staunch methodologies are required for extracting relevant information. The research study explores new-fangled deep learning methods for automatically identifying the relevancy of disaster-related social media messages. The contributions of this study are three-fold. Firstly, we present a hybrid deep learning-based framework to ameliorate the classification of disaster-related social media messages. The data is gathered from the Twitter platform, using the Search Application Programming Interface. The messages that contain information regarding the need, availability of vital resources like food, water, electricity, etc., and provide situational information are categorized into relevant messages. The rest of the messages are categorized into irrelevant messages. To demonstrate the applicability and effectiveness of the proposed approach, it is applied to the thunderstorm and cyclone Fani dataset. Both the disasters happened in India in 2019. Secondly, the performance of the proposed approach is compared with baseline methods, i.e., convolutional neural network, long short-term memory network, bidirectional long short-term memory network. The results of the proposed approach outperform the baseline methods. The performance of the proposed approach is evaluated using multiple metrics. The considered evaluation metrics are accuracy, precision, recall, f-score, area under receiver operating curve, area under precision-recall curve. The accurate and inaccurate classifications are shown on both the datasets. Thirdly, to incorporate our evaluated models into a working application, we extend an existing application DisDSS, which has been granted copyright invention award by Government of India. We call the newly extended system DisDSS 2.0, which integrates our framework to address the disaster relevancy identification issue. The output from the research study is helpful for disaster managers to make effective decisions on time. It bridges the gap between the decision-makers and citizens during disasters through the lens of deep learning.

    How to cite: Singla, A., Agrawal, R., and Garg, A.: DisDSS 2.0: A Multi-Hazard Web-based Disaster Management System to Identify Disaster-Relevancy of a Social Media Message for Decision-Making Using Deep Learning Techniques, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-266, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-266, 2022.

    Background and objective: The fields of urban resilience to flooding and data science are on a collision course giving rise to the emerging field of smart resilience. The objective of this study is to propose and demonstrate a smart flood resilience framework that leverages various heterogeneous community-scale big data and infrastructure sensor data to enhance predictive risk monitoring and situational awareness.

    Smart flood resilience framework: The smart flood resilience framework focuses on four core capabilities that could be augmented through the use of heterogeneous community-scale big data and analytics techniques: (1) predictive flood risk mapping: prediction capability of imminent flood risks (such as overflow of channels) to inform communities and emergency management agencies to take preparation and response actions; (2) automated rapid impact assessment: the ability to automatically and quickly evaluate the extent of flood impacts (i.e., physical, social, and economic impacts) to enable crisis responders and public officials to allocate relief and rescue resources on time; (3) predictive infrastructure failure prediction and monitoring: the ability to anticipate imminent failures in infrastructure systems as a flood event unfolds; and (4) smart situational awareness capabilities: the capability to derive proactive insights regarding the evolution of flood impacts (e.g., disrupted access to critical facilities and spatio-temporal patterns of recovery) on the communities.

    Case study: We demonstrate the components of these core capabilities in the smart flood resilience framework in the context of the 2017 Hurricane Harvey in Harris. First, with Bayesian network modeling and deep learning methods, we reveal the use of flood sensor data for the prediction of floodwater overflow in channel networks and inundation of co-located road networks. Second, we discuss the use of social media data and machine learning techniques for assessing the impacts of floods on communities and sensing emotion signals to examine societal impacts. Third, we illustrate the use of high-resolution traffic data in network-theoretic models for now-casting of flood propagation on road networks and the disrupted access to critical facilities such as hospitals. Fourth, we leverage location-based and credit card transaction data in advanced spatial data analytics to proactively evaluate the recovery of communities and the impacts of floods on businesses.

    Significances: This study shows that the significance of different core capabilities of the smart flood resilience framework in helping emergency managers, city planners, public officials, responders, and volunteers to better cope with the impacts of catastrophic flooding events.

    How to cite: Mostafavi, A. and Yuan, F.: Smart Flood Resilience: Harnessing Community-Scale Big Data for Predictive Flood Risk Monitoring, Rapid Impact Assessment, and Situational Awareness, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-781, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-781, 2022.

    Overview:

    Operations Risk Insight (ORI) with Watson is an IBM AI application on the cloud.  ORI analyzes thousands of news sources and alert services daily.  There are too many data sources, warnings, watches and advisories for an individual to understand.  For example, during a week in 2021 with record wildfires, hurricanes and COVID hotspots across the US, thousands of impacting risk events hit key points of interest to IBM globally and were analyzed in real time.  

    Which events impacted IBM’s business, and which didn’t? ORI has saved IBM millions of dollars annually for the past 5 years.  Our non-profit disaster relief partners have used ORI to respond more effectively to the needs of the vulnerable groups impacted by disasters.  Find out how disaster response leaders identify severe risks using Watson, the Hybrid Cloud, Big Data, Machine Learning and AI.

    Presentation Objectives:

    The objectives of this session are:

    • Educate the audience on a pragmatic and relevant IBM internal use case for an AI on the Cloud application, using many Watson and The Weather Company API's, plus machine learning running on IBM's cloud.
    • Obtain feedback and suggestions from the audience on how to expand and improve the machine learning and data analysis for this application to expanded the value for natural disaster response leaders. .
    • Inspire others to create their own grass roots cognitive project and learn more about AI and cloud technologies.
    • Discuss how this relates to the Call for Code and is used by Disaster Relief Agencies for free to assist the most vulnerable in society.

    References Links:  

    • ORI has been featured in two Cloud Pak for Data (CP4D) workbooks:  CP4D Watson Studio Tutorial on Risk Analysis: https://dataplatform.cloud.ibm.com/analytics/notebooks/v2/f2ee8dbf-e6af-4b00-90ca-8f7fee77c377/view and the Flood Risk Project: https://dataplatform.dev.cloud.ibm.com/exchange/public/entry/view/def444923c771f3f20285820dc072eac  Each demonstrate the application and methods for Machine Learning to be applied to AI for Natural Disaster Management (NDM). 
    • IBM use case for non-profit partners: https://newsroom.ibm.com/ORI-nonprofits-disaster
    • NC Tech article: https://www.ednc.org/nonprofits-and-artificial-intelligence-join-forces-for-covid-19-relief/
    • Supply Chain Management Review (SCMR) interview: https://www.scmr.com/article/nextgen_supply_chain_interview_tom_ward
    • Supply Chain navigator article: http://scnavigator.avnet.com/article/january-2017/the-missing-link/

    How to cite: Ward, T. and Kanwar, R.: IBM Operations Risk Insights with Watson:  a multi-hazard risk, AI for Natural Disaster Management use case, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1230, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1230, 2022.

    EGU22-1510 | Presentations | ITS2.5/NH10.8

    From virtual environment to real observations: short-term hydrological forecasts with an Artificial Neural Network model. 

    Renaud Jougla, Manon Ahlouche, Morgan Buire, and Robert Leconte

    Machine learning model approaches for hydrological forecasts are nowadays common in research. Artificial Neural Network (ANN) is one of the most popular due to its good performance on watersheds with different hydrologic regimes and over several timescales. A short-term (1 to 7 days ahead) forecast model was explored to predict streamflow. This study focused on the summer season defined from May to October. Cross-validation was done over a period of 16 years, each time keeping a single year as a validation set.

    The ANN model was parameterized with a single hidden layer of 6 neurons. It was developed in a virtual environment based on datasets generated by the physically based distributed hydrological model Hydrotel (Fortin et al., 2012). In a preliminary analysis, several combinations of inputs were assessed, the best combining precipitation and temperature with surface soil moisture and antecedent streamflow. Different spatial discretizations were compared. A semi-distributed discretization was selected to facilitate transferring the ANN model from a virtual environment to real observations such as remote sensing soil moisture products or ground station time series.

    Four watersheds were under study: the Au Saumon and Magog watersheds located in south Québec (Canada); the Androscoggin watershed in Maine (USA); and the Susquehanna watershed located in New-York and Pennsylvania (USA). All but the Susquehanna watershed are mainly forested, while the latter has a 57% forest cover. To evaluate whether a model with a data-driven structure can mimic a deterministic model, ANN and Hydrotel simulated flows were compared. Results confirm that the ANN model can reproduce streamflow output from Hydrotel with confidence.

    Soil moisture observation stations were deployed in the Au Saumon and Magog watersheds during the summers 2018 to 2021. Meteorological data were extracted from the ERA5-Land reanalysis dataset. As the period of availability of observed data is short, the ANN model was trained in a virtual environment. Two validations were done: one in the virtual environment and one using real soil moisture observations and flows. The number and locations of the soil moisture probes slightly differed during each of the four summers. Therefore, four models were trained depending on the number of probes and their location. Results highlight that location of the soil moisture probes has a large influence on the ANN streamflow outputs and identifies more representative sub-regions of the watershed.

    The use of remote sensing data as inputs of the ANN model is promising. Soil moisture datasets from SMOS and SMAP missions are available for the four watersheds under study, although downscaling approaches should be applied to bring the spatial resolution of those products at the watershed scale. One other future lead could be the development of a semi-distributed ANN model in virtual environment based on a restricted selection of hydrological units based on physiographic characteristics. The future L-band NiSAR product could be relevant for this purpose, having a finer spatial resolution compared to SMAP and SMOS and a better penetration of the signal in forested areas than C-band SAR satellites such as Sentinel-1 and the Radarsat Constellation Mission.

    How to cite: Jougla, R., Ahlouche, M., Buire, M., and Leconte, R.: From virtual environment to real observations: short-term hydrological forecasts with an Artificial Neural Network model., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1510, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1510, 2022.

    Tropical Cyclones (TCs) are deadly but rare events that cause considerable loss of life and property damage every year. Traditional TC forecasting and tracking methods focus on numerical forecasting models, synoptic forecasting and statistical methods. However, in recent years there have been several studies investigating applications of Deep Learning (DL) methods for weather forecasting with encouraging results.

    We aim to test the efficacy of several DL methods for TC nowcasting, particularly focusing on Generative Adversarial Neural Networks (GANs) and Recurrent Neural Networks (RNNs). The strengths of these network types align well with the given problem: GANs are particularly apt to learn the form of a dataset, such as the typical shape and intensity of a TC, and RNNs are useful for learning timeseries data, enabling a prediction to be made based on the past several timesteps.

    The goal is to produce a DL based pipeline to predict the future state of a developing cyclone with accuracy that measures up to current methods.  We demonstrate our approach based on learning from high-resolution numerical simulations of TCs from the Indian and Pacific oceans and discuss the challenges and advantages of applying these DL approaches to large high-resolution numerical weather data.

    How to cite: Steptoe, H. and Xirouchaki, T.: Deep Learning for Tropical Cyclone Nowcasting: Experiments with Generative Adversarial and Recurrent Neural Networks, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1650, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1650, 2022.

    EGU22-1662 | Presentations | ITS2.5/NH10.8

    Exploring the challenges of Digital Twins for weather & climate through an Atmospheric Dispersion modelling prototype 

    Stephen Haddad, Peter Killick, Aaron Hopkinson, Tomasz Trzeciak, Mark Burgoyne, and Susan Leadbetter

    Digital Twins present a new user-centric paradigm for developing and using weather & climate simulations that is currently being widely embraced, for example through large projects such as Destination Earth led by ECMWF.  In this project we have taken a smaller scale approach in understanding the opportunities and challenges in translating the Digital Twin concept from the original domain of manufacturing and the built environment to modelling of the earth’s atmosphere.

    We describe our approach to creating a Digital Twin based on the Met Office’s Atmospheric Dispersion simulation package called NAME. We will discuss the advantages of doing this, such as the ability of nonexpert users to more easily produce scientifically valid simulations of dispersion events, such as industrial fires, and easily obtain results to feed into downstream analysis, for example of health impacts. We will describe the requirements of each of the key components of a digital twin and potential implementation approaches.

    We will describe how a Digital Twin framework enables multiple models to be joined together to model complex systems as required for atmospheric concentrations around chemical spills or fires modelled by NAME. Overall, we outline a potential project blueprint for future work to improve usability and scientific throughput of existing modelling systems by creating a Digital Twins from core current modelling code and data gathering systems.

    How to cite: Haddad, S., Killick, P., Hopkinson, A., Trzeciak, T., Burgoyne, M., and Leadbetter, S.: Exploring the challenges of Digital Twins for weather & climate through an Atmospheric Dispersion modelling prototype, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1662, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1662, 2022.

    Massive groundwater pumping for agricultural and industrial activities results in significant land subsidence in the arid world. In an acute water crisis, monitoring land subsidence and its key drivers is essential to assist groundwater depletion mitigation strategy. Physical models for aquifer simulation related to land deformation are computationally expensive. The interferometric synthetic aperture radar (InSAR) technique provides precise deformation mapping yet is affected by tropospheric and ionospheric errors. This study explores the capabilities of the deep learning approach coupled with satellite-derived variables in modeling subsidence, spatially and temporally, from 2016 to 2020 and predicting subsidence in the near future by using a recurrent neural network (RNN) in the Shabestar basin, Iran. The basin is part of the Urmia Lake River Basin, embracing 6.4 million people, yet has been primarily desiccated due to the over-usage of water resources in the basin. The deep learning model incorporates InSAR-derived land subsidence and its satellite-based key drivers such as actual evapotranspiration, Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI), land surface temperature, precipitation to yield the importance of critical drivers to inform groundwater governance. The land deformation in the area varied between -93.2 mm/year to 16 mm/year on average in 2016-2020. Our findings reveal that precipitation, evapotranspiration, and vegetation coverage primarily affected land subsidence; furthermore, the subsidence rate is predicted to increase rapidly. The phenomenon has the same trend with the variation of the Urmia Lake level. This study demonstrates the potential of artificial intelligence incorporating satellite-based ancillary data in land subsidence monitoring and prediction and contributes to future groundwater management.

    How to cite: Zhang, Y. and Hashemi, H.: InSAR-Deep learning approach for simulation and prediction of land subsidence in arid regions, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2011, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2011, 2022.

    EGU22-2879 | Presentations | ITS2.5/NH10.8

    Automatically detecting avalanches with machine learning in optical SPOT6/7 satellite imagery 

    Elisabeth D. Hafner, Patrick Barton, Rodrigo Caye Daudt, Jan Dirk Wegner, Konrad Schindler, and Yves Bühler

    Safety related applications like avalanche warning or risk management depend on timely information about avalanche occurrence. Knowledge on the locations and sizes of avalanches releasing is crucial for the responsible decision-makers. Such information is still collected today in a non-systematic way by observes in the field, for example from ski resort patrols or community avalanche services. Consequently, the existing avalanche mapping is, in particular in situations with high avalanche danger, strongly biased towards accessible terrain in proximity to (winter sport) infrastructure.

    Recently, remote sensing has been shown to be capable of partly filling this gap, providing spatially continuous information on avalanche occurrences over large regions. In previous work we applied optical SPOT 6/7 satellite imagery to manually map two avalanche periods over a large part of the swiss Alps (2018: 12’500 and 2019: 9’500 km2). Subsequently, we investigated the reliability of this mapping and proved its suitability by identifying almost ¾ of all occurred avalanches (larger size 1) from SPOT 6/7 imagery. Therefore, optical SPOT data is an excellent source for continuous avalanche mapping, currently restricted by the time intensive manual mapping. To speed up this process we now propose a fully convolutional neural network (CNN) called AvaNet. AvaNet is based on a Deeplabv3+ architecture adapted to specifically learn how avalanches look like by explicitly including height information from a digital terrain model (DTM) for example. Relying on the manually mapped 24’737 avalanches for training, validation and testing, AvaNet achieves an F1 score of 62.5% when thresholding the probabilities from the network predictions at 0.5. In this study we present the results from our network in more detail, including different model variations and results of predictions on data from a third avalanche period we did not train on.

    The ability to automate the mapping and therefor quickly identify avalanches from satellite imagery is an important step forward in regularly acquiring spatially continuous avalanche occurrence data. This enables the provision of essential information for the complementation of avalanche databases, making Alpine regions safer.

    How to cite: Hafner, E. D., Barton, P., Caye Daudt, R., Wegner, J. D., Schindler, K., and Bühler, Y.: Automatically detecting avalanches with machine learning in optical SPOT6/7 satellite imagery, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2879, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2879, 2022.

    EGU22-3212 | Presentations | ITS2.5/NH10.8

    Predicting Landslide Susceptibility in Cross River State of Nigeria using Machine Learning 

    Joel Efiong, Devalsam Eni, Josiah Obiefuna, and Sylvia Etu

    Landslides have continued to wreck its havoc in many parts of the globe; comprehensive studies of landslide susceptibilities of many of these areas are either lacking or inadequate. Hence, this study was aimed at predicting landslide susceptibility in Cross River State of Nigeria, using machine learning. Precisely, the frequency ratio (FR) model was adopted in this study. In adopting this approach, a landslide inventory map was developed using 72 landslide locations identified during fieldwork combined with other relevant data sources. Using appropriate geostatistical analyst tools within a geographical information environment, the landslide locations were randomly divided into two parts in the ratio of 7:3 for the training and validation processes respectively. A total of 12 landslide causing factors, such as; elevation, slope, aspect, profile curvature, plan curvature, topographic position index, topographic wetness index, stream power index, land use/land cover, geology, distance to waterbody and distance to major roads, were selected and used in the spatial relationship analysis of the factors influencing landslide occurrences in the study area. FR model was then developed using the training sample of the landslide to investigate landslide susceptibility in Cross River State which was subsequently validated. It was found out that the distribution of landslides in Cross River State of Nigeria was largely controlled by a combined effect of geo-environmental factors such as elevation of 250 – 500m, slope gradient of >35o, slopes facing the southwest direction, decreasing degree of both positive and negative curvatures, increasing values of topographic position index, fragile sands, sparse vegetation, especially in settlement and bare surfaces areas, distance to waterbody and major road of < 500m. About 46% of the mapped area was found to be at landslide susceptibility risk zones, ranging from moderate – very high levels. The susceptibility model was validated with 90.90% accuracy. This study has shown a comprehensive investigation of landslide susceptibility in Cross River State which will be useful in land use planning and mitigation measures against landslide induced vulnerability in the study area including extrapolation of the findings to proffer solutions to other areas with similar environmental conditions. This is a novel use of a machine learning technique in hazard susceptibility mapping.

     

    Keywords: Landslide; Landslide Susceptibility mapping; Cross River State, Nigeria; Frequency ratio, Machine learning

    How to cite: Efiong, J., Eni, D., Obiefuna, J., and Etu, S.: Predicting Landslide Susceptibility in Cross River State of Nigeria using Machine Learning, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3212, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3212, 2022.

    EGU22-3283 | Presentations | ITS2.5/NH10.8

    Assessment of Flood-Damaged Cropland Trends Under Future Climate Scenarios Using Convolutional Neural Network 

    Rehenuma Lazin, Xinyi Shen, and Emmanouil Anagnostou

    Every year flood causes severe damages in the cropland area leading to global food insecurity. As climate change continues, floods are predicted to be more frequent in the future. To cope with the future climate impacts, mitigate damages, and ensure food security, it is now imperative to study the future flood damage trends in the cropland area. In this study, we use a convolutional neural network (CNN) to estimate the damages (in acre) in the corn and soybean lands across the mid-western USA with projections from climate models. Here, we extend the application of the CNN model developed by Lazin et. al, (2021) that shows ~25% mean relative error for county-level flood-damaged crop loss estimation. The meteorological variables are derived from the reference gridMet datasets as predictors to train the model from 2008-2020. We then use downscaled climate projections from Multivariate Adaptive Constructed Analogs (MACA) dataset in the trained CNN model to assess future flood damage patterns in the cropland in the early (2011-2040), mid (2041-2070), and late (2071-2100) century, relative to the baseline historical period (1981-2010). Results derived from this study will help understand the crop loss trends due to floods under climate change scenarios and plan necessary arrangements to mitigate damages in the future.

     

    Reference:

    [1] Lazin, R., Shen, X., & Anagnostou, E. (2021). Estimation of flood-damaged cropland area using a convolutional neural network. Environmental Research Letters16(5), 054011.

    How to cite: Lazin, R., Shen, X., and Anagnostou, E.: Assessment of Flood-Damaged Cropland Trends Under Future Climate Scenarios Using Convolutional Neural Network, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3283, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3283, 2022.

    EGU22-3422 | Presentations | ITS2.5/NH10.8

    Weather history encoding for machine learning-based snow avalanche detection 

    Thomas Gölles, Kathrin Lisa Kapper, Stefan Muckenhuber, and Andreas Trügler

    Since its start in 2014, the Copernicus Sentinel-1 programme has provided free of charge, weather independent, and high-resolution satellite Earth observations and has set major scientific advances in the detection of snow avalanches from satellite imagery in motion. Recently, operational avalanche detection from Sentinel-1 synthetic Aperture radar (SAR) images were successfully introduced for some test regions in Norway. However, current state of the art avalanche detection algorithms based on machine learning do not include weather history. We propose a novel way to encode weather data and include it into an automatic avalanche detection pipeline for the Austrian Alps. The approach consists of four steps. At first the raw data in netCDF format is downloaded, which consists of several meteorological parameters over several time steps. In the second step the weather data is downscaled onto the pixel locations of the SAR image. Then the data is aggregated over time, which produces a two-dimensional grid of one value per SAR pixel at the time when the SAR data was recorded. This aggregation function can range from simple averages to full snowpack models. In the final step, the grid is then converted to an image with greyscale values corresponding to the aggregated values. The resulting image is then ready to be fed into the machine learning pipeline. We will include this encoded weather history data to increase the avalanche detection performance, and investigate contributing factors with model interpretability tools and explainable artificial intelligence.

    How to cite: Gölles, T., Kapper, K. L., Muckenhuber, S., and Trügler, A.: Weather history encoding for machine learning-based snow avalanche detection, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3422, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3422, 2022.

    EGU22-4250 | Presentations | ITS2.5/NH10.8

    Landslide Susceptibility Modeling of an Escarpment in Southern Brazil using Artificial Neural Networks as a Baseline for Modeling Triggering Rainfall 

    Luísa Vieira Lucchese, Guilherme Garcia de Oliveira, Alexander Brenning, and Olavo Correa Pedrollo

    Landslide Susceptibility Mapping (LSM) and rainfall thresholds are well-documented tools used to model the occurrence of rainfall-induced landslides. In the case of locations where only rainfall can be considered a main landslide trigger, both methodologies apply essentially to the same locations, and a model that encompasses both would be an important step towards a better understanding and prediction of landslide-triggering rainfall events. In this research, we employ spatially cross-validated, hyperparameter tuned Artificial Neural Networks (ANNs) to predict the susceptibility to landslides of an area in southern Brazil. In a next step, we plan to add the triggering rainfall to this Artificial Intelligence model, which will concurrently model the susceptibility and the triggering rainfall event for a given area. The ANN is of type Multi-Layer Perceptron with three layers. The number of neurons in the hidden layer was tuned separately for each cross-validation fold, using a method described in previous work. The study area is the escarpment in the limits of the municipalities of Presidente Getúlio, Rio do Sul, and Ibirama, in southern Brazil. For this area, 82 landslides scars related to the event of December 17th, 2020, were mapped. The metrics for each fold are presented and the final susceptibility map for the area is shown and analyzed. The evaluation metrics attained are satisfactory and the resulting susceptibility map highlights the escarpment areas as most susceptible to landslides. The ANN-based susceptibility mapping in the area is considered successful and seen as a baseline for identifying rainfall thresholds in susceptible areas, which will be accomplished with a combined susceptibility and rainfall model in our future work.

    How to cite: Vieira Lucchese, L., Garcia de Oliveira, G., Brenning, A., and Correa Pedrollo, O.: Landslide Susceptibility Modeling of an Escarpment in Southern Brazil using Artificial Neural Networks as a Baseline for Modeling Triggering Rainfall, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4250, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4250, 2022.

    EGU22-4266 | Presentations | ITS2.5/NH10.8

    Camera Rain Gauge Based on Artificial Intelligence 

    Raffaele Albano, Nicla Notarangelo, Kohin Hirano, and Aurelia Sole

    Flood risk monitoring, alert and adaptation in urban areas require near-real-time fine-scale precipitation observations that are challenging to obtain from currently available measurement networks due to their costs and installation difficulties. In this sense, newly available data sources and computational techniques offer enormous potential, in particular, the exploiting of not-specific, widespread, and accessible devices.

    This study proposes an unprecedented system for rainfall monitoring based on artificial intelligence, using deep learning for computer vision, applied to cameras images. As opposed to literature, the method is not device-specific and exploits general-purpose cameras (e.g., smartphones, surveillance cameras, dashboard cameras, etc.), in particular, low-cost device, without requiring parameter setting, timeline shots, or videos. Rainfall is measured directly from single photographs through Deep Learning models based on transfer learning with Convolutional Neural Networks. A binary classification algorithm is developed to detect the presence of rain. Moreover, a multi-class classification algorithm is used to estimate a quasi-instantaneous rainfall intensity range. Open data, dash-cams in Japan coupled with high precision multi-parameter radar XRAIN, and experiments in the NIED Large Scale Rainfall Simulator combined to form heterogeneous and verisimilar datasets for training, validation, and test. Finally, a case study over the Matera urban area (Italy) was used to illustrate the potential and limitations of rainfall monitoring using camera-based detectors.

    The prototype was deployed in a real-world operational environment using a pre-existent 5G surveillance camera. The results of the binary classifier showed great robustness and portability: the accuracy and F1-score value were 85.28% and 85.13%, 0.86 and 0.85 for test and deployment, respectively, whereas the literature algorithms suffer from drastic accuracy drops changing the image source (e.g. from 91.92% to 18.82%). The 6-way classifier results reached test average accuracy and macro-averaged F1 values of 77.71% and 0.73, presenting the best performances with no-rain and heavy rainfall, which represents critical condition for flood risk. Thus, the results of the tests and the use-case demonstrate the model’s ability to detect a significant meteorological state for early warning systems. The classification can be performed on single pictures taken in disparate lighting conditions by common acquisition devices, i.e. by static or moving cameras without adjusted parameters. This system does not suit scenes that are also misleading for human visual perception. The proposed method features readiness level, cost-effectiveness, and limited operational requirements that allow an easy and quick implementation by exploiting pre-existent devices with a parsimonious use of economic and computational resources.

    Altogether, this study corroborates the potential of non-traditional and opportunistic sensing networks for the development of hydrometeorological monitoring systems in urban areas, where traditional measurement methods encounter limitations, and in data-scarce contexts, e.g. where remote-sensed rainfall information is unavailable or has broad resolution respect with the scale of the proposed study. Future research will involve incremental learning algorithms and further data collection via experiments and crowdsourcing, to improve accuracy and at the same time promote public resilience from a smart city perspective.

    How to cite: Albano, R., Notarangelo, N., Hirano, K., and Sole, A.: Camera Rain Gauge Based on Artificial Intelligence, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4266, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4266, 2022.

    EGU22-4730 | Presentations | ITS2.5/NH10.8

    floodGAN – A deep learning-based model for rapid urban flood forecasting 

    Julian Hofmann and Holger Schüttrumpf

    Recent urban flood events revealed how severe and fast the impacts of heavy rainfall can be. Pluvial floods pose an increasing risk to communities worldwide due to ongoing urbanization and changes in climate patterns. Still, pluvial flood warnings are limited to meteorological forecasts or water level monitoring which are insufficient to warn people against the local and terrain-specific flood risks. Therefore, rapid flood models are essential to implement effective and robust early warning systems to mitigate the risk of pluvial flooding. Although hydrodynamic (HD) models are state-of-the-art for simulation pluvial flood hazards, the required computation times are too long for real-time applications.

    In order to overcome the computation time bottleneck of HD models, the deep learning model floodGAN has been developed. FloodGAN combines two adversarial Convolutional Neural Networks (CNN) that are trained on high-resolution rainfall-flood data generated from rainfall generators and HD models. FloodGAN translates the flood forecasting problem into an image-to-image translation task whereby the model learns the non-linear spatial relationships of rainfall and hydraulic data. Thus, it directly translates spatially distributed rainfall forecasts into detailed hazard maps within seconds. Next to the inundation depth, the model can predict the velocities and time periods of hydraulic peaks of an upcoming rainfall event. Due to its image-translation approach, the floodGAN model can be applied for large areas and can be run on standard computer systems, fulfilling the tasks of fast and practical flood warning systems.

    To evaluate the accuracy and generalization capabilities of the floodGAN model, numerous performance tests were performed using synthetic rainfall events as well as a past heavy rainfall event of 2018. Therefore, the city of Aachen was used as a case study. Performance tests demonstrated a speedup factor of 106 compared to HD models while maintaining high model quality and accuracy and good generalization capabilities for highly variable rainfall events. Improvements can be obtained by integrating recurrent neural network architectures and training with temporal rainfall series to forecast the dynamics of the flooding processes.

    How to cite: Hofmann, J. and Schüttrumpf, H.: floodGAN – A deep learning-based model for rapid urban flood forecasting, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4730, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4730, 2022.

    EGU22-4900 | Presentations | ITS2.5/NH10.8

    A modular and scalable workflow for data-driven modelling of shallow landslide susceptibility 

    Ann-Kathrin Edrich, Anil Yildiz, Ribana Roscher, and Julia Kowalski

    The spatial impact of a single shallow landslide is small compared to a deep-seated, impactful failure and hence its damage potential localized and limited. Yet, their higher frequency of occurrence and spatio-temporal correlation in response to external triggering events such as strong precipitation, nevertheless result in dramatic risks for population, infrastructure and environment. It is therefore essential to continuously investigate and analyze the spatial hazard that shallow landslides pose. Its visualisation through regularly-updated, dynamic hazard maps can be used by decision and policy makers. Even though a number of data-driven approaches for shallow landslide hazard mapping exist, a generic workflow has not yet been described. Therefore, we introduce a scalable and modular machine learning-based workflow for shallow landslide hazard prediction in this study. The scientific test case for the development of the workflow investigates the rainfall-triggered shallow landslide hazard in Switzerland. A benchmark dataset was compiled based on a historic landslide database as presence data, as well as a pseudo-random choice of absence locations, to train the data-driven model. Features included in this dataset comprise at the current stage 14 parameters from topography, soil type, land cover and hydrology. This work also focuses on the investigation of a suitable approach to choose absence locations and the influence of this choice on the predicted hazard as their influence is not comprehensively studied. We aim at enabling time-dependent and dynamic hazard mapping by incorporating time-dependent precipitation data into the training dataset with static features. Inclusion of temporal trigger factors, i.e. rainfall, enables a regularly-updated landslide hazard map based on the precipitation forecast. Our approach includes the investigation of a suitable precipitation metric for the occurrence of shallow landslides at the absence locations based on the statistical evaluation of the precipitation behavior at the presence locations. In this presentation, we will describe the modular workflow as well as the benchmark dataset and show preliminary results including above mentioned approaches to handle absence locations and time-dependent data.

    How to cite: Edrich, A.-K., Yildiz, A., Roscher, R., and Kowalski, J.: A modular and scalable workflow for data-driven modelling of shallow landslide susceptibility, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4900, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4900, 2022.

    EGU22-6568 | Presentations | ITS2.5/NH10.8

    Harnessing Machine Learning and Deep Learning applications for climate change risk assessment: a survey 

    Davide Mauro Ferrario, Elisa Furlan, Silvia Torresan, Margherita Maraschini, and Andrea Critto

    In the last years there has been a growing interest around Machine Learning (ML) in climate risk/ multi-risk assessment, steered mainly by the growing amount of data available and the reduction of associated computational costs. Extracting information from spatio-temporal data is critically important for problems such as extreme events forecasting and assessing risks and impacts from multiple hazards. Typical challenges in which AI and ML are now being applied require understanding the dynamics of complex systems, which involve many features with non-linear relations and feedback loops, analysing the effects of phenomena happening at different time scales, such as slow-onset events (sea level rise) and short-term episodic events (storm surges, floods) and estimating uncertainties of long-term predictions and scenarios. 
    While in the last years there were many successful applications of AI/ML, such as Random Forest or Long-Short Term Memory (LSTM) in floods and storm surges risk assessment, there are still open questions and challenges that need to be addressed. In fact, there is a lack of data for extreme events and Deep Learning (DL) algorithms often need huge amounts of information to disentangle the relationships among hazard, exposure and vulnerability factors contributing to the occurrence of risks. Moreover, the spatio-temporal resolution can be highly irregular and need to be reconstructed to produce accurate and efficient models. For example, using data from meteorological ground stations can offer accurate datasets with fine temporal resolution, but with an irregular distribution in the spatial dimension; on the other hand, leveraging on satellite images can give access to more spatially refined data, but often lacking the temporal dimension (fewer events available to due atmospheric disturbances). 
    Several techniques have been applied, ranging from classical multi-step forecasting, state-space and Hidden Markov models to DL techniques, such as Artificial Neural Networks (ANN), Convolutional Neural Networks (CNN) and Recurrent Neural Networks (RNN). ANN and Deep Generative Models (DGM) have been used to reconstruct spatio-temporal grids and modelling continuous time-series, CNN to exploit spatial relations, Graph Neural Networks (GNN) to extract multi-scale localized spatial feature and RNN and LSTM for multi-scale time series prediction.  
    To bridge these gaps, an in-depth state-of-the-art review of the mathematical and computer science innovations in ML/DL techniques that could be applied to climate /multi-risk assessment was undertaken. The review focuses on three possible ML/DL applications: analysis of spatio-temporal dynamics of risk factors, with particular attention on applications for irregular spatio-temporal grids; multivariate analysis for multi-hazard interactions and multiple risk assessment endpoints; analysis of future scenarios under climate change. We will present the main outcomes of the scientometric and systematic review of publications across the 2000- 2021 timeframe, which allowed us to: i) summarize keywords and word co-occurrence networks, ii) highlight linkages, working relations and co-citation clusters, iii) compare ML and DL approaches with classical statistical techniques and iv) explore applications at the forefront of the risk assessment community.

    How to cite: Ferrario, D. M., Furlan, E., Torresan, S., Maraschini, M., and Critto, A.: Harnessing Machine Learning and Deep Learning applications for climate change risk assessment: a survey, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6568, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6568, 2022.

    EGU22-6576 | Presentations | ITS2.5/NH10.8

    Swept Away: Flooding and landslides in Mexican poverty nodes 

    Silvia García, Raul Aquino, and Walter Mata

    Natural disasters should be examined within a risk-perspective framework where both natural threat and vulnerability are considered as intricate components of an extremely complex equation. The trend toward more frequent floods and landslides in Mexico in recent decades is not only the result of more intense rainfall, but also a consequence of increased vulnerability. As a multifactorial element, vulnerability is a low-frequency modulating factor of the risk dynamics to intense rainfall. It can be described in terms of physical, social, and economical factors. For instance, deforested or urbanized areas are the physical and social factors that lead to the deterioration of watersheds and an increased vulnerability to intense rains. Increased watershed vulnerability due to land-cover changes is the primary factor leading to more floods, particularly over pacific Mexico. ln some parts of the country, such as Colima, the increased frequency of intense rainfall (i.e., natural hazard) associated with high-intensity tropical cyclones and hurricanes is the leading cause of more frequent floods.

     

    In this research an intelligent rain management-system is presented. The object is built to forecast and to simulate the components of risk, to stablish communication between rescue/aid teams and to help in preparedness activities (training). Detection, monitoring, analysis and forecasting of the hazards and scenarios that promote floods and landslides, is the main task. The developed methodology is based on a database that permits to relate heavy rainfall measurements with changes in land cover and use, terrain slope, basin compactness and communities’ resilience as key vulnerability factors. A neural procedure is used for the spatial definition of exposition and susceptibility (intrinsic and extrinsic parameters) and Machine Learning techniques are applied to find the If-Then relationships. The capability of the intelligent model for Colima, Mexico was tested by comparing the observed and modeled frequency of landslides and floods for ten years period. It was found that over most of the Mexican territory, more frequent floods are the result of a rapid deforestation process and that landslides and their impact on communities are directly related to the unauthorized growth of populations in high geo-risk areas (due to forced migration because of violence or extreme poverty) and the development of civil infrastructure (mainly roads) with a high impact on the natural environment. Consequently, the intelligent rain-management system offers the possibility to redesign and to plan the land use and the spatial distribution of poorest communities.

    How to cite: García, S., Aquino, R., and Mata, W.: Swept Away: Flooding and landslides in Mexican poverty nodes, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6576, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6576, 2022.

    EGU22-6690 | Presentations | ITS2.5/NH10.8

    A machine learning-based ensemble model for estimation of seawater quality parameters in coastal area 

    Xiaotong Zhu, Jinhui Jeanne Huang, Hongwei Guo, Shang Tian, and Zijie Zhang

    The precise estimation of seawater quality parameters is crucial for decision-makers to manage coastal water resources. Although various machine learning (ML)-based algorithms have been developed for seawater quality retrieval using remote sensing technology, the performance of these models in the application of specific regions remains significant uncertainty due to the different properties of coastal waters. Moreover, the prediction results of these ML models are unexplainable. To address these problems, an ML-based ensemble model was developed in this study. The model was applied to estimate chlorophyll-a (Chla), turbidity, and dissolved oxygen (DO) based on Sentinel-2 satellite imagery in Shenzhen Bay, China. The optimal input features for each seawater quality parameter were selected from the nine simulation scenarios which generated from eight spectral bands and six spectral indices. A local explanation method called SHapley Additive exPlanations (SHAP) was introduced to quantify the contributions of various features to the predictions of the seawater quality parameters. The results suggested that the ensemble model with feature selection enhanced the performance for three types of seawater quality parameters estimations (The errors were 1.7%, 1.5%, and 0.02% for Chla, turbidity, and DO, respectively). Furthermore, the reliability of the model performance was further verified for mapping the spatial distributions of water quality parameters during the model validation period. The spatial-temporal patterns of seawater quality parameters revealed that the distributions of seawater quality were mainly influenced by estuary input. Correlation analysis demonstrated that air temperature (Temp) and average air pressure (AAP) exhibited the closest relationship with Chla. The DO was most relevant with Temp, and turbidity was not sensitive to Temp, average wind speed (AWS), and AAP. This study enhanced the prediction capability of seawater quality parameters and provided a scientific coastal waters management approach for decision-makers.

    How to cite: Zhu, X., Huang, J. J., Guo, H., Tian, S., and Zhang, Z.: A machine learning-based ensemble model for estimation of seawater quality parameters in coastal area, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6690, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6690, 2022.

    EGU22-6758 | Presentations | ITS2.5/NH10.8

    AI-enhanced Integrated Alert System for effective Disaster Management 

    Pankaj Kumar Dalela, Saurabh Basu, Sandeep Sharma, Anugandula Naveen Kumar, Suvam Suvabrata Behera, and Rajkumar Upadhyay

    Effective communication systems supported by Information and Communication Technologies (ICTs) are integral and important components for ensuring comprehensive disaster management. Continuous warning monitoring, prediction, dissemination, and response coordination along with public engagement by utilizing the capabilities of emerging technologies including Artificial Intelligence (AI) can assist in building resilience and ensuring Disaster Risk Reduction. Thus, for effective disaster management, an Integrated Alert System is proposed which encapsulates all concerned disaster management authorities, alert forecasting and disseminating agencies under a single umbrella for alerting the targeted public through various communication channels. Enhancing the capabilities of the system through AI, its integral part includes the data-driven citizen-centric Decision Support System which can help disaster managers by performing complete impact assessment of disaster events through configuration of decision models developed by learning inter-relationships of different parameters. The system needs to be capable of identification of possible communication means to address community outreach, prediction of scope of alert, providing influence of alert message on targeted vulnerable population, performing crowdsourced data analysis, evaluating disaster impact through threat maps and dashboards, and thereby, providing complete analysis of the disaster event in all phases of disaster management. The system aims to address challenges including limited communication channels utilization and audience reach, language differences, and lack of ground information in decision making posed by current systems by utilizing the latest state of art technologies.

    How to cite: Dalela, P. K., Basu, S., Sharma, S., Kumar, A. N., Behera, S. S., and Upadhyay, R.: AI-enhanced Integrated Alert System for effective Disaster Management, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6758, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6758, 2022.

    Main purpose of current research article is to present latest findings on automatic methods of manipulating social network data for developing seismic intensity maps. As case study the author selected the 2020 Samos earthquake event (Mw= 7, 30 October 2020, Greece). That earthquake event had significant consequences to the urban environment along with 2 deaths and 19 injuries. Initially an automatic approach, presented recently in the international literature was applied producing thus seismic intensity maps from tweets. Furthermore, some initial findings regarding the use of machine learning in various parts of the automatic methodology were presented along with potential of using photos posted in social networks. The data used were several thousands tweets and instagram posts.The results, provide vital findings in enriching data sources, data types, and effective rapid processing.

    How to cite: Arapostathis, S. G.: The Samos earthquake event (Mw = 7, 30 October 2020, Greece) as case study for applying machine learning on texts and photos scraped from social networks for developing seismic intensity maps., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7129, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7129, 2022.

    EGU22-7308 | Presentations | ITS2.5/NH10.8

    Building an InSAR-based database to support geohazard risk management by exploiting large ground deformation datasets 

    Marta Béjar-Pizarro, Pablo Ezquerro, Carolina Guardiola-Albert, Héctor Aguilera Alonso, Margarita Patricia Sanabria Pabón, Oriol Monserrat, Anna Barra, Cristina Reyes-Carmona, Rosa Maria Mateos, Juan Carlos García López Davalillo, Juan López Vinielles, Guadalupe Bru, Roberto Sarro, Jorge Pedro Galve, Roberto Tomás, Virginia Rodríguez Gómez, Joaquín Mulas de la Peña, and Gerardo Herrera

    The detection of areas of the Earth’s surface experiencing active deformation processes and the identification of the responsible phenomena (e.g. landslides activated after rainy events, subsidence due to groundwater extraction in agricultural areas, consolidation settlements, instabilities in active or abandoned mines) is critical for geohazard risk management and ultimately to mitigate the unwanted effects on the affected populations and the environment.

    This will now be possible at European level thanks to the Copernicus European Ground Motion Service (EGMS), which will provide ground displacement measurements derived from time series analyses of Sentinel-1 data, using Interferometric Synthetic Aperture Radar (InSAR). The EGMS, which will be available to users in the first quarter of 2022 and will be updated annually, will be especially useful to identify displacements associated to landslides, subsidence and deformation of infrastructure.  To fully exploit the capabilities of this large InSAR datasets, it is fundamental to develop automatic analysis tools, such as machine learning algorithms, which require an InSAR-derived deformation database to train and improve them.  

    Here we present the preliminary InSAR-derived deformation database developed in the framework of the SARAI project, which incorporates the previous InSAR results of the IGME-InSARlab and CTTC teams in Spain. The database contains classified points of measurement with the associated InSAR deformation and a set of environmental variables potentially correlated with the deformation phenomena, such as geology/lithology, land-surface slope, land cover, meteorological data, population density, and inventories such as the mining registry, the groundwater database, and the IGME’s land movements database (MOVES). We discuss the main strategies used to identify and classify pixels and areas that are moving, the covariables used and some ideas to improve the database in the future. This work has been developed in the framework of project PID2020-116540RB-C22 funded by MCIN/ AEI /10.13039/501100011033 and e-Shape project, with funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation program under grant agreement 820852.

    How to cite: Béjar-Pizarro, M., Ezquerro, P., Guardiola-Albert, C., Aguilera Alonso, H., Sanabria Pabón, M. P., Monserrat, O., Barra, A., Reyes-Carmona, C., Mateos, R. M., García López Davalillo, J. C., López Vinielles, J., Bru, G., Sarro, R., Galve, J. P., Tomás, R., Rodríguez Gómez, V., Mulas de la Peña, J., and Herrera, G.: Building an InSAR-based database to support geohazard risk management by exploiting large ground deformation datasets, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7308, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7308, 2022.

    EGU22-7313 | Presentations | ITS2.5/NH10.8

    The potential of automated snow avalanche detection from SAR images for the Austrian Alpine region using a learning-based approach 

    Kathrin Lisa Kapper, Stefan Muckenhuber, Thomas Goelles, Andreas Trügler, Muhamed Kuric, Jakob Abermann, Jakob Grahn, Eirik Malnes, and Wolfgang Schöner

    Each year, snow avalanches cause many casualties and tremendous damage to infrastructure. Prevention and mitigation mechanisms for avalanches are established for specific regions only. However, the full extent of the overall avalanche activity is usually barely known as avalanches occur in remote areas making in-situ observations scarce. To overcome these challenges, an automated avalanche detection approach using the Copernicus Sentinel-1 synthetic aperture radar (SAR) data has recently been introduced for some test regions in Norway. This automated detection approach from SAR images is faster and gives more comprehensive results than field-based detection provided by avalanche experts. The Sentinel-1 programme has provided - and continues to provide - free of charge, weather-independent, and high-resolution satellite Earth observations since its start in 2014. Recent advances in avalanche detection use deep learning algorithms to improve the detection rates. Consequently, the performance potential and the availability of reliable training data make learning-based approaches an appealing option for avalanche detection.  

             In the framework of the exploratory project SnowAV_AT, we intend to build the basis for a state-of-the-art automated avalanche detection system for the Austrian Alps, including a "best practice" data processing pipeline and a learning-based approach applied to Sentinel-1 SAR images. As a first step towards this goal, we have compiled several labelled training datasets of previously detected avalanches that can be used for learning. Concretely, these datasets contain 19000 avalanches that occurred during a large event in Switzerland in January 2018, around 6000 avalanches that occurred in Switzerland in January 2019, and around 800 avalanches that occurred in Greenland in April 2016. The avalanche detection performance of our learning-based approach will be quantitatively evaluated against held-out test sets. Furthermore, we will provide qualitative evaluations using SAR images of the Austrian Alps to gauge how well our approach generalizes to unseen data that is potentially differently distributed than the training data. In addition, selected ground truth data from Switzerland, Greenland and Austria will allow us to validate the accuracy of the detection approach. As a particular novelty of our work, we will try to leverage high-resolution weather data and combine it with SAR images to improve the detection performance. Moreover, we will assess the possibilities of learning-based approaches in the context of the arguably more challenging avalanche forecasting problem.

    How to cite: Kapper, K. L., Muckenhuber, S., Goelles, T., Trügler, A., Kuric, M., Abermann, J., Grahn, J., Malnes, E., and Schöner, W.: The potential of automated snow avalanche detection from SAR images for the Austrian Alpine region using a learning-based approach, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7313, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7313, 2022.

    Flood events cause substantial damage to infrastructure and disrupt livelihoods. There is a need for the development of an innovative, open-access and real-time disaster map pipeline which is automatically initiated at the time of a flood event to highlight flooded regions, potential damage and vulnerable communities. This can help in directing resources appropriately during and after a disaster to reduce disaster risk. To implement this pipeline, we explored the integration of three heterogeneous data sources which include remote sensing data, social sensing data and geospatial sensing data to guide disaster relief and response. Remote sensing through satellite imagery is an effective method to identify flooded areas where we utilized existing deep learning models to develop a pipeline to process both optical and radar imagery. Whilst this can offer situational awareness right after a disaster, satellite-based flood extent maps lack important contextual information about the severity of structural damage or urgent needs of affected population. This is where the potential of social sensing through microblogging sites comes into play as it provides insights directly from eyewitnesses and affected people in real-time. Whilst social sensing data is advantageous, these streams are usually extremely noisy where there is a need to build disaster relevant taxonomies for both text and images. To develop a disaster taxonomy for social media texts, we conducted literature review to better understand stakeholder information needs. The final taxonomy consisted of 30 categories organized among three high-level classes. This built taxonomy was then used to label a large number of tweet texts (~ 10,000) to train machine learning classifiers so that only relevant social media texts are visualized on the disaster map. Moreover, a disaster object taxonomy for social media images was developed in collaboration with a certified emergency manager and trained volunteers from Montgomery County, MD Community Emergency Response Team. In total, 106 object categories were identified and organized as a hierarchical  taxonomy with  three high-level classes and 10 sub-classes. This built taxonomy will be used to label a large set of disaster images for object detection so that machine learning classifiers can be trained to effectively detect disaster relevant objects in social media imagery. The wide perspective provided by the satellite view combined with the ground-level perspective from locally collected textual and visual information helped us in identifying three types of signals: (i) confirmatory signals from both sources, which puts greater confidence that a specific region is flooded, (ii) complementary signals that provide different contextual information including needs and requests, disaster impact or damage reports and situational information, and (iii) novel signals when both data sources do not overlap and provide unique information. We plan to fuse the third component, geospatial sensing, to perform flood vulnerability analysis to allow easy identification of areas/zones that are most vulnerable to flooding. Thus, the fusion of remote sensing, social sensing and geospatial sensing for rapid flood mapping can be a powerful tool for crisis responders.

    How to cite: Ofli, F., Akhtar, Z., Sadiq, R., and Imran, M.: Triangulation of remote sensing, social sensing, and geospatial sensing for flood mapping, damage estimation, and vulnerability assessment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7561, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7561, 2022.

    EGU22-7711 | Presentations | ITS2.5/NH10.8

    Global sensitivity analyses to characterize the risk of earth fissures in subsiding basins 

    Yueting Li, Claudia Zoccarato, Noemi Friedman, András Benczúr, and Pietro Teatini

    Earth fissure associated with groundwater pumping is a severe geohazard jeopardizing several subsiding basins generally in arid countries (e.g., Mexico, Arizona, Iran, China, Pakistan). Up to 15 km long, 1–2 m wide, 15–20 m deep, and more than 2 m vertically dislocated fissures have been reported. A common geological condition favoring the occurrence of earth fissures is the presence of shallow bedrock ridge buried by compacting sedimentary deposits. This study aims to improve the understanding of this mechanism by evaluating the effects of various factors on the risk of fissure formation and development. Several parameters playing a role in the fissure occurrence have been considered, such as the shape of the bedrock ridge, the aquifer thickness, the pressure depletion in the aquifer system, and its compressibility. A realistic case is developed where the characteristics of fissure like displacements and stresses are quantified with aid of a numerical approach based on finite elements for the continuum and interface elements for the discretization of the fissures. Modelling results show that the presence of bedrock ridge causes tension accumulation around its tip and results in fissure opening from land surface downward after long term piezometry depletion. Different global sensitivity analysis methods are applied to measure the importance of each single factor (or group of them) on the quantity of interest, i.e., the fissure opening. A conventional variance-based method is first presented with Sobol indices computed from Monte Carlo simulations, although its accuracy is only guaranteed with a high number of forward simulations. As alternatives, generalized polynomial chaos expansion and gradient boosting tree are introduced to approximate the forward model and implement the corresponding sensitivity assessment at a significantly reduced computational cost. All the measures provide similar results that highlight the importance of bedrock ridge in earth fissuring. Generally, the steeper bedrock ridge the higher the risk of significant fissure opening. Pore pressure depletion is secondarily key factor which is essential for fissure formation.

    How to cite: Li, Y., Zoccarato, C., Friedman, N., Benczúr, A., and Teatini, P.: Global sensitivity analyses to characterize the risk of earth fissures in subsiding basins, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7711, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7711, 2022.

    Induced subsidence and seismicity caused by the production of hydrocarbons in the Groningen gas field (the Netherlands) is a widely known issue facing this naturally aseismic region (Smith et al., 2019). Extraction reduces pore-fluid pressure leading to accumulation of small elastic and inelastic strains and an increase in effective vertical stress driving compaction of reservoir sandstones.

    Recent studies (Pijnenburg et al., 2019a, b and Verberne et al., 2021) identify grain-scale deformation of intergranular and grain-coating clays as largely responsible for accommodating (permanent) inelastic deformation at small strains relevant to production (≤1.0%). However, their distribution, microstructure, abundance, and contribution to inelastic deformation remains unconstrained, presenting challenges when evaluating grain-scale deformation mechanisms within a natural system. Traditional methods of mineral identification are costly, labor-intensive, and time-consuming. Digital imaging coupled with machine-learning-driven segmentation is necessary to accelerate the identification of clay microstructures and distributions within reservoir sandstones for later large-scale analysis and geomechanical modeling.

    We performed digital imaging on thin-sections taken from core recovered from the highly-depleted Zeerijp ZRP-3a well located at the most seismogenic part of the field. The core was kindly made available by the field operator, NAM. Optical digital images were acquired using the Zeiss AxioScan optical light microscope at 10x magnification with a resolution of 0.44µm and compared to backscattered electron (BSE) digital images from the Zeiss EVO 15 Scanning Electron Microscope (SEM) at varying magnifications with resolutions ranging from 0.09µm - 2.24 µm. Digital images were processed in ilastik, an interactive machine-learning-based toolkit for image segmentation that uses a Random Forest classifier to separate clays from a digital image (Berg et al., 2019).

    Comparisons between segmented optical and BSE digital images indicate that image resolution is the main limiting factor for successful mineral identification and image segmentation, especially for clay minerals. Lower resolution digital images obtained using optical light microscopy may be sufficient to segment larger intergranular/pore-filling clays, but higher resolution BSE images are necessary to segment smaller micron to submicron-sized grain-coating clays. Comparing the same segmented optical image (~11.5% clay) versus BSE image (~16.3% clay) reveals an error of ~30%, illustrating the potential of underestimating the clay content necessary for geomechanical modeling.

    Our analysis shows that coupled automated electron microscopy with machine-learning-driven image segmentation has the potential to provide statistically relevant and robust information to further constrain the role of clay films on the compaction behavior of reservoir rocks.

     

    References:

    Berg, S. et al., Nat Methods 16, 1226–1232 (2019).

    (NAM) Nederlandse Aardolie Maatschappij BV (2015).

    Pijnenburg, R. P. J. et al., Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth, 124 (2019a).

    Pijnenburg, R. P. J. et al., Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth, 124, 5254–5282. (2019b)

    Smith, J. D. et al., Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth, 124, 6165–6178. (2019)

    Verberne, B. A. et al., Geology, 49 (5): 483–487. (2020)

    How to cite: Vogel, H., Amiri, H., Plümper, O., Hangx, S., and Drury, M.: Applications of digital imaging coupled with machine-learning for aiding the identification, analysis, and quantification of intergranular and grain-coating clays within reservoirs rocks., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7915, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7915, 2022.

    EGU22-9406 | Presentations | ITS2.5/NH10.8

    Building exposure datasets using street-level imagery and deep learning object detection models 

    Luigi Cesarini, Rui Figueiredo, Xavier Romão, and Mario Martina

    The built environment is constantly under the threat of natural hazards, and climate change will only exacerbate such perils. The assessment of natural hazard risk requires exposure models representing the characteristics of the assets at risk, which are crucial to subsequently estimate damage and impacts of a given hazard to such assets. Studies addressing exposure assessment are expanding, in particular due to technological progress. In fact, several works are introducing data collected from volunteered geographic information (VGI), user-generated content, and remote sensing data. Although these methods generate large amounts of data, they typically require a time-consuming extraction of the necessary information. Deep learning models are particularly well suited to perform this labour-intensive task due to their ability to handle massive amount of data.

    In this context, this work proposes a methodology that connects VGI obtained from OpenStreetMap (OSM), street-level imagery from Google Street View (GSV) and deep learning object detection models to create an exposure dataset of electrical transmission towers, an asset particularly vulnerable to strong winds among other perils (i.e., ice loads and earthquakes). The main objective of the study is to establish and demonstrate a complete pipeline that first obtains the locations of transmission towers from the power grid layer of OSM’s world infrastructure, and subsequently assigns relevant features of each tower based on the classification returned from an object detection model over street-level imagery of the tower, obtained from GSV.

    The study area for the initial application of the methodology is the Porto district (Portugal), which has an area of around 1360 km2 and 5789 transmission towers. The area was found to be representative given its diverse land use, containing both densely populated settlements and rural areas, and the different types of towers that can be found. A single-stage detector (YOLOv5) and a two-stage detector (Detectron2) were trained and used to perform identification and classification of towers. The first task was used to test the ability of a model to recognize whether a tower is present in an image, while the second task assigned a category to each tower based on a taxonomy derived from a compilation of the most used type of towers. Preliminary results on the test partition of the dataset are promising. For the identification task, YOLOv5 returned a mean average precision (mAP) of 87% for an intersection over union (IoU) of 50%, while Detectron2 reached a mAP of 91% for the same IoU. In the classification problem, the performances were also satisfactory, particularly when the models were trained on a sufficient number of images per class. 

    Additional analyses of the results can provide insights on the types of areas for which the methodology is more reliable. For example, in remote areas, the long distance of a tower to the street might prevent the object to be identified in the image. Nevertheless, the proposed methodology can in principle be used to generate exposure models of transmission towers at large spatial scales in areas for which the necessary datasets are available.

     

    How to cite: Cesarini, L., Figueiredo, R., Romão, X., and Martina, M.: Building exposure datasets using street-level imagery and deep learning object detection models, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9406, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9406, 2022.

    EGU22-10276 | Presentations | ITS2.5/NH10.8

    Weather and climate in the AI-supported early warning system DAKI-FWS 

    Elena Xoplaki, Andrea Toreti, Florian Ellsäßer, Muralidhar Adakudlu, Eva Hartmann, Niklas Luther, Johannes Damster, Kim Giebenhain, Andrej Ceglar, and Jackie Ma

    The project DAKI-FWS (BMWi joint-project “Data and AI-supported early warning system to stabilise the German economy”; German: “Daten- und KI-gestütztes Frühwarnsystem zur Stabilisierung der deutschen Wirtschaft”) develops an early warning system (EWS) to strengthen economic resilience in Germany. The EWS enables better characterization of the development and course of pandemics or hazardous climate extreme events and can thus protect and support lives, jobs, land and infrastructures.

    The weather and climate modules of the DAKI-FWS use state-of-the-art seasonal forecasts for Germany and apply innovative AI-approaches to prepare very high spatial resolution simulations. These are used for the climate-related practical applications of the project, such as pandemics or subtropical/tropical diseases, and contribute to the estimation of the outbreak and evolution of health crises. Further, the weather modules of the EWS objectively identify weather and climate extremes, such as heat waves, storms and droughts, as well as compound extremes from a large pool of key data sets. The innovative project work is complemented by the development and AI-enhancement of the European Flood Awareness System model, LISFLOOD, and forecasting system for Germany at very high spatial resolution. The model combined with the high-end output of the seasonal forecast prepares high-resolution, accurate flood risk assessment. The final output of the EWS and hazard maps not only support adaptation, but they also increase preparedness providing a time horizon of several months ahead, thus increasing the resilience of economic sectors to impacts of the ongoing anthropogenic climate change. The weather and climate modules of the EWS provide economic, political, and administrative decision-makers and the general public with evidence on the probability of occurrence, intensity and spatial and temporal extent of extreme events as well as with critical information during a disaster.

    How to cite: Xoplaki, E., Toreti, A., Ellsäßer, F., Adakudlu, M., Hartmann, E., Luther, N., Damster, J., Giebenhain, K., Ceglar, A., and Ma, J.: Weather and climate in the AI-supported early warning system DAKI-FWS, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10276, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10276, 2022.

    Landslide inventories are essential for landslide susceptibility mapping, hazard modelling, and further risk mitigation management. For decades, experts and organisations worldwide have preferred manual visual interpretation of satellite and aerial images. However, there are various problems associated with manual inventories, such as manual extraction of landslide borders and their representation with polygons, which is a subjective process.  Manual delineation is affected by the applied methodology, the preferences of the experts and interpreters, and how much time and effort are invested in the inventory generating process. In recent years, a vast amount of research related to semi-automated and automatic mapping of landslide inventories has been carried out to overcome these issues. The automatic generation of landslide inventories using Artificial Intelligence (AI) techniques is still in its early phase as currently there is no published research that can create a ground truth representation of landslide situation after a landslide triggering event. The evaluation metrics in recent literature show a range of 50-80% of F1-score in terms of landslide boundary delineation using AI-based models. However, very few studies claim to have achieved more than 80% F1 score with the exception of those employing the testing of their model evaluation in the same study area. Therefore, there is still a research gap between the generation of AI-based landslide inventories and their usability for landslide hazard and risk studies. In this study, we explore several inventories developed by AI and manual delineation and test their usability for assessing landslide hazard.

    How to cite: Meena, S. R., Floris, M., and Catani, F.: Can landslide inventories developed by artificial intelligence substitute manually delineated inventories for landslide hazard and risk studies?, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11422, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11422, 2022.

    EGU22-11787 | Presentations | ITS2.5/NH10.8

    Explainable deep learning for wildfire danger estimation 

    Michele Ronco, Ioannis Prapas, Spyros Kondylatos, Ioannis Papoutsis, Gustau Camps-Valls, Miguel-Ángel Fernández-Torres, Maria Piles Guillem, and Nuno Carvalhais

    Deep learning models have been remarkably successful in a number of different fields, yet their application to disaster management is obstructed by the lack of transparency and trust which characterises artificial neural networks. This is particularly relevant in the field of Earth sciences where fitting is only a tiny part of the problem, and process understanding becomes more relevant [1,2]. In this regard, plenty of eXplainable Artificial Intelligence (XAI) algorithms have been proposed in the literature over the past few years [3]. We suggest that combining saliency maps with interpretable approximations, such as LIME, is useful to extract complementary insights and reach robust explanations. We address the problem of wildfire forecasting for which interpreting the model's predictions is of crucial importance to put into action effective mitigation strategies. Daily risk maps have been obtained by training a convolutional LSTM with ten years of data of spatio-temporal features, including weather variables, remote sensing indices and static layers for land characteristics [4]. We show how the usage of XAI allows us to interpret the predicted fire danger, thereby shortening the gap between black-box approaches and disaster management.

     

    [1] Deep learning for the Earth Sciences: A comprehensive approach to remote sensing, climate science and geosciences

    Gustau Camps-Valls, Devis Tuia, Xiao Xiang Zhu, Markus Reichstein (Editors)

    Wiley \& Sons 2021

    [2] Deep learning and process understanding for data-driven Earth System Science

    Reichstein, M. and Camps-Valls, G. and Stevens, B. and Denzler, J. and Carvalhais, N. and Jung, M. and Prabhat

    Nature 566 :195-204, 2019

    [3] Explainable AI: Interpreting, Explaining and Visualizing Deep Learning

     Wojciech Samek, Grégoire Montavon, Andrea Vedaldi, Lars Kai Hansen, Klaus-Robert Müller (Editors)

    LNCS, volume 11700, Springer 

    [4] Deep Learning Methods for Daily Wildfire Danger Forecasting

    Ioannis Prapas, Spyros Kondylatos, Ioannis Papoutsis, Gustau Camps-Valls, Michele Ronco, Miguel-Ángel Fernández-Torres, Maria Piles Guillem, Nuno Carvalhais

    arXiv: 2111.02736


     

    How to cite: Ronco, M., Prapas, I., Kondylatos, S., Papoutsis, I., Camps-Valls, G., Fernández-Torres, M.-Á., Piles Guillem, M., and Carvalhais, N.: Explainable deep learning for wildfire danger estimation, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11787, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11787, 2022.

    EGU22-11872 | Presentations | ITS2.5/NH10.8

    Recent Advances in Deep Learning for Spatio-Temporal Drought Monitoring, Forecasting and Model Understanding 

    María González-Calabuig, Jordi Cortés-Andrés, Miguel-Ángel Fernández-Torres, and Gustau Camps-Valls

    Droughts constitute one of the costliest natural hazards and have seriously destructive effects on the ecological environment, agricultural production and socio-economic conditions. Their elusive and subjective definition, due to the complex physical, chemical and biological processes of the Earth system they involve, makes their management an arduous challenge to researchers, as well as decision and policy makers. We present here our most recent advances in machine learning models in three complementary lines of research about droughts: monitoring, forecasting and understanding. While monitoring or detection is about gaining the time series of drought maps and discovering underlying patterns and correlations, forecasting or prediction is to anticipate future droughts. Last but not least, understanding or explaining models by means of expert-comprehensible representations is equally important as accurately addressing these tasks, especially for their deployment in real scenarios. Thanks to the emergence and success of deep learning, all of these tasks can be tackled by the design of spatio-temporal data-driven approaches built on the basis of climate variables (soil moisture, precipitation, temperature, vegetation health, etc.) and/or satellite imagery. The possibilities are endless, from the design of convolutional architectures and attention mechanisms to the use of generative models such as Normalizing Flows (NFs) or Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs), trained both in a supervised and unsupervised manner, among others. Different application examples in Europe from 2003 onwards are provided, with the aim of reflecting on the possibilities of the strategies proposed, and also of foreseeing alternatives and future lines of development. For that purpose, we make use of several mesoscale (1 km) spatial and 8 days temporal resolution variables included in the Earth System Data Cube (ESDC) [Mahecha et al., 2020] for drought detection, while high resolution (20 m, 5 days) Sentinel-2 data cubes, extracted from the extreme summer track in EarthNet2021 [Requena-Mesa et al., 2021], are considered for forecasting.

     

    References

    Mahecha, M. D., Gans, F., Brandt, G., Christiansen, R., Cornell, S. E., Fomferra, N., ... & Reichstein, M. (2020). Earth system data cubes unravel global multivariate dynamics. Earth System Dynamics, 11(1), 201-234.

    Requena-Mesa, C., Benson, V., Reichstein, M., Runge, J., & Denzler, J. (2021). EarthNet2021: A large-scale dataset and challenge for Earth surface forecasting as a guided video prediction task. In Proceedings of the IEEE/CVF Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition (pp. 1132-1142).

    How to cite: González-Calabuig, M., Cortés-Andrés, J., Fernández-Torres, M.-Á., and Camps-Valls, G.: Recent Advances in Deep Learning for Spatio-Temporal Drought Monitoring, Forecasting and Model Understanding, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11872, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11872, 2022.

    EGU22-12432 | Presentations | ITS2.5/NH10.8

    Building wildfire intelligence at the edge: bridging the gap from development to deployment 

    Maria João Sousa, Alexandra Moutinho, and Miguel Almeida

    The increased frequency, intensity, and severity of wildfire events in several regions across the world has highlighted several disaster response infrastructure hindrances that call for enhanced intelligence gathering pipelines. In this context, the interest in the use of unmanned aerial vehicles for surveillance and active fire monitoring has been growing in recent years. However, several roadblocks challenge the implementation of these solutions due to their high autonomy requirements and energy-constrained nature. For these reasons, the artificial intelligence development focus on large models hampers the development of models suitable for deployment onboard these platforms. In that sense, while artificial intelligence approaches can be an enabling technology that can effectively scale real-time monitoring services and optimize emergency response resources, the design of these systems imposes: (i) data requirements, (ii) computing constraints and (iii) communications limitations. Here, we propose a decentralized approach, reflecting upon these three vectors.

    Data-driven artificial intelligence is central to both handle multimodal sensor data in real-time and to annotate large amounts of data collected, which are necessary to build robust safety-critical monitoring systems. Nevertheless, these two objectives have distinct implications computation-wise, because the first must happen on-board, whereas the second can leverage higher processing capabilities off-board. While autonomy of robotic platforms drives mission performance, being a key reason for the need for edge computing of onboard sensor data, the communications design is essential to mission endurance as relaying large amounts of data in real-time is unfeasible energy-wise. 

    For these reasons, real-time processing and data annotation must be tackled in a complimentary manner, instead of the general practice of only targeting overall accuracy improvement. To build wildfire intelligence at the edge, we propose developments on two tracks of solutions: (i) data annotation and (ii) on the edge deployment. The need for considerable effort in these two avenues stems from both having very distinct development requirements and performance evaluation metrics. On the one hand, improving data annotation capacity is essential to build high quality databases that can provide better sources for machine learning. On the other hand, for on the edge deployment the development architectures need to compromise on robustness and architectural parsimony in order to be efficient for edge processing. Whereas the first objective is driven foremost by accuracy, the second goal must emphasize timeliness.

    Acknowledgments
    This work was supported by FCT – Fundação para a Ciência e a Tecnologia, I.P., through IDMEC, under project Eye in the Sky, PCIF/SSI/0103/2018, and through IDMEC, under LAETA, project UIDB/50022/2020. M. J. Sousa acknowledges the support from FCT, through the Ph.D. Scholarship SFRH/BD/145559/2019, co-funded by the European Social Fund (ESF).

    How to cite: Sousa, M. J., Moutinho, A., and Almeida, M.: Building wildfire intelligence at the edge: bridging the gap from development to deployment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12432, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12432, 2022.

    EGU22-1425 | Presentations | ITS4.2/ERE1.11

    Optimal design of nature-based solutions in highway runoff management based on resilience to climate and pollution load changes 

    Mehrdad Ghorbani Mooselu, Helge Liltved, Mohammad Reza Alizadeh, and Sondre Meland

    Sedimentation ponds (SPs) are nature-based solutions (NBSs) for sustainable stormwater management. SPs control the quantity and quality of runoff and promote biodiversity. Hence, the optimal design of SPs is crucial for ecosystems resilience in urban and natural environments. This study aims to optimize the design of roadside SPs in terms of location and surface area, considering the resilience to stressors such as climate changes and pollution load variations. Accordingly, the highway runoff in a new 22 km highway (E18 Arendal-Tvedestrand) in southern Norway was simulated by the storm water management model (SWMM). The quantity and quality (BOD and TSS values) of highway runoff in all probable scenarios of existing uncertainties were estimated for potential outfall points using the repeated execution model of SWMM coded in MATLAB®. The scenarios were defined based on applying best management practices (BMPs), including grass swale and infiltration trench in different sections of the road that work before SPs, climatic (rainfall quantity estimated by the LARS-WG model), and modeling uncertainties (buildup and washoff coefficients). The generated dataset was then applied to assess the resilience of sedimentation ponds in potential outfalls to climate change and pollution load shocks. The resiliency was quantified for three metrics, including the quantity and quality of receiving runoff to sedimentation ponds and biodiversity in ponds over 25 years (2020-2045). The biodiversity index was defined based on Shannon's Entropy computed from field observation in 12 highway sedimentation ponds across Norway. Using this procedure, it was determined that the proper arrangement of BMPs along the road and the optimal design of ponds enhance the resilience of SPs by 40% over time. This study makes important contributions to stormwater management, the resilient design of NBS, and achieving UN SDG6 (Clean water and sanitation).

    How to cite: Ghorbani Mooselu, M., Liltved, H., Alizadeh, M. R., and Meland, S.: Optimal design of nature-based solutions in highway runoff management based on resilience to climate and pollution load changes, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1425, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1425, 2022.

    EGU22-1677 | Presentations | ITS4.2/ERE1.11

    Effects of land use change for solar park development in the UK on ecosystem services 

    Fabio Carvalho, Hannah Montag, Stuart Sharp, Piran White, Tom Clarkson, and Alona Armstrong

    In the rush to decarbonise energy supplies to meet internationally agreed greenhouse gas emissions targets, solar parks (SPs) have proliferated around the world, with uncertain implications for the provision of ecosystem services (ES). SPs necessitate significant land use change due to low energy densities that could significantly affect the local environment. In the UK, SPs are commonly built on intensive arable land and managed as grasslands. This offers both risks and opportunities for ecosystem health, yet evidence of ecosystem consequences is scarce. Therefore, there is an urgent need to understand how ES assessments can be incorporated into land use decision making to promote SP development that simultaneously addresses the climate and biodiversity crises. We aim to provide some of the first scientific evidence to help answer this question by determining the effects of land use change for SPs in the UK on the provision of ecosystem services (e.g., biomass production, soil carbon storage) of hosting ecosystems. Through a Knowledge Transfer Partnership project between Lancaster University and Clarkson & Woods Ecological Consultants, 35 SPs in England and Wales were surveyed in summer 2021. Soil and vegetation data were collected from 420 sample plots (900 cm2) under different types of land use: underneath solar panels, between rows of solar arrays, and control sites (e.g., pastureland, areas set-aside for conservation). Total plant cover was significantly lower underneath solar panels and between solar arrays than on land set-aside for conservation, while land around the margins of SPs showed higher aboveground biomass of monocotyledons and forbs than on land underneath solar panels. Some measures of soil fertility (e.g., nitrogen) and soil organic matter, fractioned into particulate and mineral-associated organic matter, also varied significantly between these different land uses. These results have implications for land management within SPs and will enable optimisation of SP design and management to ensure the long-term delivery of ecosystem services within this fast-growing land use.

    How to cite: Carvalho, F., Montag, H., Sharp, S., White, P., Clarkson, T., and Armstrong, A.: Effects of land use change for solar park development in the UK on ecosystem services, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1677, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1677, 2022.

    EGU22-2049 | Presentations | ITS4.2/ERE1.11

    What locals want: (mapping) citizen preferences and priorities for an alpine river landscape 

    Chiara Scaini, Ana Stritih, Constance Brouillet, and Anna Scaini

    Sustainable river management frameworks are based on the connection between citizens and nature. So far, though, the relationship between rivers and local populations has played a marginal role in river management. We present a blueprint questionnaire to characterize the perception of cultural ecosystem services and flood risk by locals, and how preferences change across the river landscape. We investigate how locals value the river and whether their preferences are affected by characteristics such as place of residence, age, frequency of visits and relation to the river. The approach is tested on the Tagliamento river, the last major free-flowing river in the Alps, which is characterized by debates on flood protection, flood management and ecological conservation. The questionnaire was filled in by more than 4000 respondents, demonstrating huge interest and willingness to contribute with their opinion on this topic. A participatory map of favorite places shows that most of the river is valued/appreciated by locals, with a high preference for the landscape of the braided middle course. River conservation is the main priority for most respondents across different stakeholder groups, highlighting the need for nature-based solutions in flood-risk management and demonstrating the mismatch between management choices and citizens´ values and priorities. Land-use planning is identified as a factor that can increase flood risk. The results highlight the necessity to tackle conservation, risk management and land-use planning together in order to develop risk-oriented river management strategies. More generally, this work points out that any river intervention should be pondered carefully accounting for its environmental impact also in terms of loss of cultural ecosystem services.

    How to cite: Scaini, C., Stritih, A., Brouillet, C., and Scaini, A.: What locals want: (mapping) citizen preferences and priorities for an alpine river landscape, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2049, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2049, 2022.

    Check dam plays a crucial role in controlling soil erosion on the Loess Plateau and reducing sediment loads in the Yellow River. Moreover, sediment deposition in check dams also provides valuable information for understanding of soil erosion on the Loess Plateau. Study on the influence of rainfall patterns on sediment yield in small catchments scale is significant for the reasonable arrangement of soil and water conservation measures, particularly for complex environments such as the wind-water erosion crisscross region. This study estimated sediment yield trapped by the check dam in Laoyeman catchment based on deposited flood couplets formed in erosion rainfall events during the period 1978-2010. All erosive rainfall were divided into three rainfall patterns according to the precipitation, rainfall duration and rainfall erosivity, and the correspondence analysis between sediment yield and rainfall pattern was analyzed. Results showed that there were 1.1´105 t sediment deposited in the dam filed during the trapping history of the check dam as a whole. It has three obvious change stages, which had sediment yield of 4.53´104 t during 1978-1988, 4.48´104 t during 1988-1997, and 1.68´104 t during 1997-2010, respectively. The stage 1989-1997 had the fastest annual deposition rate of 4.98×103 t·year-1, 20.9% and 286% faster than stage 1978-1988 and stage 1998-2010. For similar rainfall pattern in these three stages, sediment yield and the characteristic of flood couplet change were closely related to both rainfall erosivity and land use types. This was also approved by the significant decrease of sediment yield on condition of similar rainfall pattern in a decade before and after the implementation of Grain for Green project indicated that this project made a great contribution to the control of soil erosion on the Loess Plateau. The impact of rainfall pattern on sediment yield indicated that the largest sediment yield is initiated under short duration and high intensity rainfall events, while the sediment in the reservoir area is mainly deposited under the rainfall pattern of moderate precipitation, erosivity and duration. That is the reason for the wettest year (1995) had relatively low sediment deposition, while the year (1982) had strong rainfall erosivity had the maximum annual sediment yield (1.68´104 t).

    How to cite: Yin, M. and Zhang, J.: Influence of rainfall patterns on sediment yield in flood couplets of a check dam on the Chinese Loess Plateau, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3322, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3322, 2022.

    EGU22-3770 | Presentations | ITS4.2/ERE1.11

    The approach ‘think global, act local’ neglects the particular ecological value of ecosystems 

    Guido J.M. Verstraeten and Willem W. Verstraeten

    A sustainable society is considered as an organic system, called an ecosystem, wherein all possible connected parameters are contributing to the conservation and evolution of the ecosystem containing life and landscape against stress from outside. Any ecosystem contains species of mutually interacting organisms all contributing to a dynamic equilibrium. An ecosystem is characterized by a population carrying capacity.

    Humans are the only species on earth without a specific ecosystem. They live everywhere. The evolution did not adapt the homo sapiens to some ecosystem, on the contrary humans transformed all ecosystems to their own environment. Nature transforms into environment when humans are managing an ecosystem and transform it to their environment by attributing to nature the concept of natural capital as first instrumental step to economic growth, considering pollution as collateral damage.

    Inspired by Enlightenment Anthropology (Shallow Ecology and Naess´ Deep Ecology) the UN encourages humanity to transform the consumption of raw matter, energy and food into a more sustainable cleaner way and even to start transition of energy resources and human diet in order to dampen the effects of global warming. Economic policy supports technological procedures avoiding waste of raw material and stimulating sustainable production processes and sustainable recuperation of raw material inside the produced items. The energy transition and preferable industrial production method, however, is globally imposed top-down without examining the consequences for local life of humans, non-humans (e.g. wind turbines near human settlement, bird mortality, destruction of the ecosystems of the seafloor) and the landscape (e.g. solar energy systems on hillside, water dams). Moreover, the global view favors large scale in policy as well as in means of production. However, this global transition organization of the global environment establish the new order characterized by its global and universal action and is not in balance with local ecosystems characterized by diversity of life and human management (so called perverted adaptation). Nature is reduced to things and just rewarded in terms of natural capital to sustain a Global Urban Middleclass consumptive society.

    Therefore, we adopt Aldo Leopold ‘Land ethics’ (1949) and apply it to the shear coast of Southwestern Finland. We summarize his ideas in three hot headlines: (i) The land ethic changes the role of Homo sapiens from conqueror of the land-community to plain member and citizen; (ii) We abuse land because we regard it as a commodity belonging to us. When we see land as a community to which we belong to, we may begin to use it with love and respect; (iii) Anything is right when it tends to preserve the integrity, stability, and beauty of the biotic community. It is wrong when it tends otherwise. Participation to the ecosystem based on autonomous technology, i.e. not controlled, is focused on global energy transition to save the Universal Urban Middleclass Life. On the contrary, the concept of Land Ethics makes room for eco-development based on care for humans, culture, environment and nature in interaction with all ecosystems. In a nutshell: act local, interact global.

    How to cite: Verstraeten, G. J. M. and Verstraeten, W. W.: The approach ‘think global, act local’ neglects the particular ecological value of ecosystems, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3770, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3770, 2022.

    EGU22-3784 | Presentations | ITS4.2/ERE1.11

    Assessing the interconnections between the characteristics, perception, and valuation of Nature-Based Solutions: A case study from Aarhus, Denmark 

    Martina Viti, Roland Löwe, Hjalte J.D. Sørup, Ursula S. Mcknight, and Karsten Arnbjerg-Nielsen

    When assessing strategies for implementation of Nature-Based Solutions (NBS) it is fundamental to quantify all benefits for securing better, informed decision making. Particularly relevant is the quantification of their multiple co-benefits for communities and the environment. One of the most widespread techniques to quantify these values is to use contingent valuation (CV) methods, such as the Willingness-To-Pay (WTP) approach. Within the CV method, questionnaires are the main tool used to elicit the value attributed to a specific good by the respondents. However, many studies focus on site-specific economic valuation, whereby transferability to other locations is jeopardized. We therefore created a survey to explore how the valuation of an NBS is shaped by its relationship with the users (e.g. frequency and length of visits), and how these responses are linked to both the respondents and the sites’ characteristics (e.g. socio-economic status, size of the NBS, etc.).

    We applied this method to a case study comprised of two distinct areas located in Aarhus, Denmark, asking users to explore their perception of the two NBS sites with different features. Both NBS sites have as overarching goals to (i) prevent flooding from cloudburst or water bodies, (ii) improve the biodiversity in the area, and (iii) benefit the local population, e.g. by providing more recreational areas. Despite these common goals, the two sites differ by a number of characteristics, i.e. size, location, and time passed since construction. One NBS involves a large artificial lake in a peri-urban setting, while the other is a small urban park. Respondents were allowed the option of either expressing a value for only one, or for both of the sites. 

    We analyzed both responses that stated a WTP and protest votes, that is, responses that rejected the valuation scenario altogether. We found that older citizens are more likely to protest, as well as those not visiting the sites. For the respondents who accepted to state a WTP, their bids significantly increased when the improvement of nature and biodiversity was mentioned in the valuation scenario. Comparing the value given to the two different sites, the characteristics of the NBS seem to play a role in the respondents’ perception and use of the sites, which in turn enhances valuation. In our case study, people’s perception of the site and their relationship with it appear to have a stronger link with the WTP than their socio-economic characteristics. Specifically, frequency and length of visits, and interest in a good quality of nature were mostly related to a positive WTP.

    The inclusion of people-NBS relational variables in benefit quantifications appears to be an essential tool to realize a more realistic economic valuation, as well as correctly design NBS in order to achieve the desired impacts. Understanding the underlying synergies between the multiple co-benefits of NBS, their features and the users’ perception is decisive for maximizing these strategies’ potential and avoiding missing opportunities.

    How to cite: Viti, M., Löwe, R., Sørup, H. J. D., Mcknight, U. S., and Arnbjerg-Nielsen, K.: Assessing the interconnections between the characteristics, perception, and valuation of Nature-Based Solutions: A case study from Aarhus, Denmark, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3784, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3784, 2022.

    EGU22-4971 | Presentations | ITS4.2/ERE1.11

    Integrating remote sensing and social media data advances assessment of cultural ecosystem services 

    Oleksandr Karasov, Stien Heremans, Mart Külvik, Artem Domnich, Iuliia Burdun, Ain Kull, Aveliina Helm, and Evelyn Uuemaa

    Over the past decade, we witnessed a rapid growth in the use of social media data when assessing  cultural ecosystem services (CESs), like modelling the supply-demand relationships. Researchers increasingly use user-generated content (predominantly geotagged pictures and texts from Flickr, Twitter, VK.com) as a spatially explicit proxy of CES demand. However, for modelling CES supply most of such studies relied on simplistic geospatial data, such as land cover and digital elevation models. As a result, our understanding of the favourable environmental conditions underlying good landscape experience remains weak and overly generic.

    Our study aims to detect the spatial disparities between population density and CES supply in Estonia in order to prioritise them for further in-depth CES assessment and green and blue infrastructure improvements. We relied on Flickr and VK.com photographs to detect the usage of three CESs: passive landscape watching, active outdoor recreation, and wildlife watching (biota observations at organism and community levels) with automated image content recognition via Clarifai API and subsequent topic modelling. Then, we used Landsat-8 cloudless mosaic, digital elevation and digital surface models, as well as land cover model to derive 526 environmental variables (textural, spectral indices and other indicators of landscape physiognomy) via the Google Earth Engine platform. We conducted an ensemble environmental niche modelling to analyse the relative strength and directions of relationships between these predictors and the observed occurrence of CES demand. Based on multicollinearity and relative importance analysis, we selected 21 relevant and non-collinear indicators of CES supply. With these indicators as inputs, we then trained five models, popular in environmental niche modelling: Boosted Regression Trees, Generalized Linear Model, Multivariate Adaptive Regression Spline, Maxent, and Random Forest. Random Forest performed better than the other models for all three CES types, with the average 10-fold cross-validation area under curve > 0.9 for landscape watching, >0.87 for outdoor recreation, and >0.85 for wildlife watching. Our modelling allowed us to estimate the share of the Estonian population residing in the spatial clusters of systematically high and low environmental suitability for three considered CESs. The share of the population residing in the clusters of low environmental suitability for landscape watching, outdoor recreation, and wildlife watching is 5.5%, 3.1%, and 7.3%, respectively. These results indicate that dozens of thousands of people in Estonia (population is >1.3 million) likely have fewer opportunities for everyday usage of considered CESs. However, these results are biased as there was not enough evidence in social media for CES use in some of these areas.

    Although our results should be treated with caution, because social media data are likely to contain a considerable sampling bias, we have demonstrated the added value of remote sensing data for CES supply estimation. Given nearly global and continuously updated satellite imagery archives, remote sensing opens new perspectives for monitoring the loss and gains in landscape suitability for CES across temporal and spatial scales. As such, we can better account for the intangible underlying geospatial features that can influence  economic and environmental decision-making.

    How to cite: Karasov, O., Heremans, S., Külvik, M., Domnich, A., Burdun, I., Kull, A., Helm, A., and Uuemaa, E.: Integrating remote sensing and social media data advances assessment of cultural ecosystem services, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4971, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4971, 2022.

    EGU22-6317 | Presentations | ITS4.2/ERE1.11

    Effect of soil management practices on soil carbon dynamics under maize cultivation 

    Michael Asante, Jesse Naab, Kwame Agyei Frimpong, Kalifa Traore, Juergen Augustin, and Mathias Hoffmann

    An increasing world population and change in consumer preferences necessitate the need to increase food production to meet the demand of a changing world. Intensified agriculture and an accelerated climate crisis with increasing weather extremes threaten the resource base needed to improve crop production. Maize yield obtained by farmers in the guinea savannah zone of Ghana is generally low due to low soil fertility status resulting from continuous cropping coupled with low use of external inputs. Integrated Soil Fertility Management (ISFM) practices have proven to sustainably increase maize yield. However, majority of the farmers practicing ISFM till their land conventionally, potentially resulting in substantial greenhouse gases (GHG) emissions that contribute to global climate change. However, there is dearth of information on GHG emissions regarding crop production systems in sub-Saharan Africa in general and Ghana in particular. Hence, within a field trial we seek to investigate the impact of different tillage practices and ISFM applied to sustain maize yield, on net CO2 or ecosystem exchange (NEE) and net carbon (C) balance (NECB). The field trial was established at the Council for Scientific and Industrial Research-Savanna Agricultural Research Institute in Northern region of Ghana. A split plot design was used with the main plot treatments being conventional tillage and reduced tillage and the subplot treatments being factorial combination of organic and inorganic fertilizers at three levels each. To determine NEE and thereon based estimates of NECB, an innovative, customized, low-cost manual, dynamic closed chamber system was used. The system consists of transparent (V: 0.37 m3, A: 0.196 m2; for NEE measurements) and opaque chambers (for ecosystem respiration (Reco) measurements) of the same size. Diurnal regimes of Reco and NEE fluxes were measured twice a month by repeatedly deploying chambers for 5 to 10min on the 3 repetitive measurement plots (PVC frames inserted 5 cm deep into the soil as collars) per treatment. CO2 concentration increase and decrease over chamber deployment time was detected by portable, inexpensive Arduino based CO2 logging systems, consisting of a battery powered microcontroller (Arduino Uno) and data logging unit (3 sec frequency) connected to an NDIR-CO2 sensor (SCD30; ± 30 ppm accuracy), air temperature and humidity (DHT-22) as well as air pressure sensor (BMP280). Measured CO2 fluxes were subsequently gap-filled to obtain seasonal NEE. C import and export were further on added to NEE to determine the NECB for each treatment. In parallel to CO2 exchange measurement campaigns, agronomic and crop growth indices such as the normalized difference vegetation index (NDVI) were performed biweekly at all plots. Here we present NEE and NECB balances for the first crop growth period.

    Keywords: Tillage, Integrated soil fertility management, CO2 emission, Zea mays, net ecosystem carbon balance (NECB)

    How to cite: Asante, M., Naab, J., Agyei Frimpong, K., Traore, K., Augustin, J., and Hoffmann, M.: Effect of soil management practices on soil carbon dynamics under maize cultivation, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6317, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6317, 2022.

    EGU22-7121 | Presentations | ITS4.2/ERE1.11

    Application of the International Guidelines on Natural and Nature Based Features for Flood Risk Management and the way forward 

    Ralph Schielen, Chris Spray, Chris Haring, Jo Guy, and Lydia Burgess-Gamble

    In 2021, the International Guidelines on Natural and Nature Based Features for Flood Risk Management  were published, as a result of a joint project between the Rijkswaterstaat (Netherlands), the Environment Agency (England) and the Army Corps of Engineers (USA). These Guidelines give direction in the application of Nature Based Solutions (NBS) for coastal and fluvial systems. In this contribution we will focus on the fluvial part of the guidelines. We will briefly discuss the process that lead to the origin of the Guidelines and discuss the intended use. It is important to realize that the location within a catchment, and the scale of a catchment determine the specifications of the most optimal NBS. Considering the classical ‘source-pathway-receptor’ approach, in the source of a catchment, NBS aim to hold back the water in the headwaters of larger catchments, enhancing management of water and sediment. In the pathways-receptor (floodplains),  NBS are more focussed on increasing the discharge capacity of the main stem. In smaller catchments, also temporarily storage of water in the floodplains occurs, if flooding of such a temporary nature can be accommodated. Rather than a detailed instruction guide, the Guidelines are intended to give best practices and list important points of attention when applying NBS. Furthermore, they act as inspiration through the many case studies that are listed.

    We will also connect the Guidelines to other initiatives on the application of NBS, for example the impact that NBS might have on reaching the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals. This requires a proper assessment framework which has been developed in adjacent projects and which values the added co-benefits that NBS have, compared to grey or grey-green alternatives. These benefits are also addressed in the Guidelines. Finally, we will share some thoughts on upscaling and mainstreaming NBS and the actions that are needed to accomplish that.

    How to cite: Schielen, R., Spray, C., Haring, C., Guy, J., and Burgess-Gamble, L.: Application of the International Guidelines on Natural and Nature Based Features for Flood Risk Management and the way forward, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7121, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7121, 2022.

    PHUSICOS platform aims at gathering nature-based solutions (NBS) relevant to reduce hydro-geological risks in mountain landscapes. The platform can be accessed directly through a web portal. It is based on an Open Source CMS website, including a filter to store documents and a map server to bring ergonomic and powerful access.

    To design the platform, an in-depth review of 11 existing platforms has been performed.  Furthermore, a list of metadata has been proposed to structure the information. These metadata have provided the baseline for database. The PHUSICOS platform currently references 176 NBS cases and 83 documents of interest (review articles, assessment papers…). It is continuously enriched through the contribution of NBS community.

    For that, a questionnaire based on relevant data, necessary for the definition and identification of the NBS (metadata, to be used for searching the NBSs within the platform) has been defined to enter new entries. A preliminary analysis of the cases has been realized. To characterize and analyse the current 152 solutions, we have worked on the following four categories: The nature of impacted ecosystems, The hazard(s) concerned, The other challenges treated by the NBS, The type of exposed assets.

    The platform also proposes a qualitative assessment of the NBSs collected according to 15 criteria related with five ambits: disaster risk reduction, technical and economical feasibility, environment, society, and local economy. The criteria level is sufficiently general to be analysed for the entire PHUSICOS platform NBSs whatever the type of work, the realized approaches, the problematic or the spatial or temporal scale.

    The structure of the platform and a first analysis of the qualitative NBS assessment are presented in this work.

    How to cite: Bernardie, S., Baills, A., and Garçin, M.: PHUSICOS platform, dedicated to Nature-Based Solutions for Risk Reduction and Environmental Issues in Hilly and Mountainous Lands : presentation and qualitative NBS assessment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7664, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7664, 2022.

    An adequate strategy for water quality improvement in developing countries must consider the economic scarcity of water, the external factors that affect its quality, and the participation of multisectoral stakeholders in water management decisions. In addition, stronger links to nature can be established through methods inspired from nature to clean the water, such as artificial floating islands (AFI). Restoration of aquatic ecosystems with AFIs occurs as water passes beneath the floating mat and the roots of macrophytes take up metals and nutrients. In this context, we utilized Fuzzy Cognitive Maps (FCMs) to identify the principal concepts that affect water quality from different perspectives: political, economic, social, technological, environmental, and legal (PESTEL). We also theoretically explore the use of AFIs combined with different policies, to find the strategy that best adapts the local water situation.

    By applying the principles of FCMs, different sources of knowledge can predict the effects of policy, and problems can be identified using the centrality index of the underlying graph theory. Thus, a two-step approach was implemented for our analysis: First, from 40 literature-based PESTEL concepts related to water quality deterioration, local experts in water management were invited to identify the most influential concepts and to include additional ones regarding the local water situation and policies to support the improvement of water quality. Second, workshops were organized, inviting members of communities to discuss the degree of cause-effect influence of the identified concepts, and also to include a water management policy, considering AFIs as one solution.

    Three Ecuadorian communities distributed to cover representative ecosystems from the Pacific coast, Andean mountains, and Amazon floodplain were selected for this research, i.e. the community of Mogollón dominated by mangroves land cover, Chilla chico by páramos, and Awayaku by rainforest. According to the FCMs, 21 PESTEL concepts affect water quality in the páramos community and most of them are related to politics (23%) and the environment (23%). Community workshop at the same community identify that the major problem is related to natural water pollutants. For the mangrove community, 23 concepts were identified mainly driven (47%) by environmental concepts, whereas the communities see the major water quality issue in view of human exposure to environmental pollutants. In the case of the rainforest community, 19 concepts were recognized with 40% related to economics, whereas the communities identify the principal concern being the violation of environmental legislation. Regarding the potential implementation of AFIs, the páramos community concludes that AFIs should be implemented and coupled with environmental education programs. Additionally, water-related governmental institutions should be involved during realization. The mangrove community shows interest in AFIs, when combined with payment for ecosystem services. Finally, the rainforest community do not consider AFIs as a primary solution. Instead they propose the creation of a committee to denounce violations of water quality laws and to improve the educational level of community members. In conclusion, the FCM is a powerful tool to bring together the knowledge of multisectoral stakeholders and to analyse suitable strategies for the local improvement of water quality.

    How to cite: Fonseca, K., Correa, A., and Breuer, L.: Using the fuzzy cognitive map approach to promote nature-based solutions as a strategy to improve water quality in Ecuadorian communities, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8395, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8395, 2022.

    EGU22-8884 | Presentations | ITS4.2/ERE1.11

    Effects of the Nature-Based Solutions on the ecosystem services; an evaluation of the Piave River catchment (Italy) in a 2050 scenario 

    Francesco Di Grazia, Luisa Galgani, Bruna Gumiero, Elena Troiani, and Steven A. Loiselle

    Sustainable river management should consider potential impacts on ecosystem services in decision-making with respect to mitigating future climate impacts. In this respect, there is a clear need to better understand how nature-based solutions (NBS) can benefit specific ecosystem services, in particular within the complex spatial and temporal dynamics that characterize most river catchments. To capture these changes, ecosystem models require spatially explicit data that are often difficult to obtain for model development and validation. Citizen science allows for the participation of trained citizen volunteers in research or regulatory activities, resulting in increased data collection and increased participation of the general public in resource management.

    In the present study, we examined the temporal and spatial drivers in nutrient and sediment delivery, carbon storage and sequestration and water yield in a major Italian river catchment and under different NBS scenarios. Information on climate, land use, soil and river conditions, as well as future climate scenarios, were used to explore future (2050) benefits of NBS on local and catchment scales, followed the national and European directives related to water quality (Directive 2000/60/EC) and habitat (Directive 92/43/EEC). We estimate the benefits of individual and combined NBS approaches related to river restoration and catchment reforestation.

    How to cite: Di Grazia, F., Galgani, L., Gumiero, B., Troiani, E., and Loiselle, S. A.: Effects of the Nature-Based Solutions on the ecosystem services; an evaluation of the Piave River catchment (Italy) in a 2050 scenario, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8884, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8884, 2022.

    EGU22-9397 | Presentations | ITS4.2/ERE1.11

    Analysis of survival probability on multiple species using metapopulation model 

    Eun sub Kim, Yong won Mo, Ji yeon Kim, and Dong kun Lee

    The ecological concept of the meta population helps evaluate the effectiveness of conservation areas (Soule et al., 1988), and is used as a useful tool for evaluating responses between individuals to artificial stressors such as urbanization, habitat destruction, and fragmentation (Kawecki. 2004). In particular meta population model can help increase the accuracy of population estimation across various spatial scales and explain several interactions populations (Walther et al., 2002; Faborg, 2014). Previous studies have demonstrated that habitat destruction and fragmentation caused by urbanization can affect the viability of species in habitats due to reduced fertility and mobility, but papers on the selection of conservation areas can increase the viability of multi species according to the changing surroundings are insufficient. Therefore, this study analyzed the possibility of multi species surviving in the habitat using a meta population model for conservation area scenarios and analyzed the effect of habitat pattern changes on each population from various perspectives.

    In order to analyze the survival probability of multi species in habitats by conservation area scenario, (1) setting the 15 virtual habitat spaces within 160ha, (2) Big & Small conservation scenarios considering habitat area, connection, and connection, (3) collecting and estimation of migration rate, home range, dispersal distance for biological species for analyzing the possibility of extinction by population. Finally, the change in the population of each population during period t was analyzed using the meta population model.

    Overall, when the Big Conservation area was applied, the probability of extinction of all species was low, followed by the Big+Connectivity scenario. In addition, the probability of survival was similarly derived in the Small scenario and the Connectivity scenario. However, the preferred conservation scenarios for each classification population group were different depending on the conservation scenario. In particular, birds had a high probability of extinction in the small scenario, while small mammals had a low probability of extinction. Through this study, the effect on the change in the number of multi species according to the conservation area scenario was analyzed, which is expected to be used to evaluate the validity and effectiveness of setting up a conservation area in the future.

    How to cite: Kim, E. S., Mo, Y. W., Kim, J. Y., and Lee, D. K.: Analysis of survival probability on multiple species using metapopulation model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9397, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9397, 2022.

    EGU22-9474 | Presentations | ITS4.2/ERE1.11

    Co-evaluating and -designing a Sustainable Agriculture Matrix for Austria in an international context 

    Christian Folberth, Franz Sinabell, Thomas Schinko, and Susanne Hanger-Kopp

    Agricultural ecosystems provide essential services mainly through food, feed, fiber and consequently income but they also contribute cultural, supporting and regulating services. In turn, farming can adversely affect ecosystem services, especially those from natural ecosystems, if farming practices are unsustainable.

    Recently, a Sustainable Agriculture Matrix (SAM; https://doi.org/10.1016/j.oneear.2021.08.015) of indicators across environmental, economic, and social dimensions has been developed by an international research team to coherently quantify the sustainability of countries’ farming systems globally. The focus was on indicators that can be tracked over time and relate to performance to facilitate analyzes of synergies and trade-offs. At present, this indicator system is being co-evaluated with stakeholders in ten countries within an international consortium including Austria, to elicit stakeholders’ appraisal of the framework’s applicability in their specific geographical and socioeconomic context and eventually co-design a revised matrix based on stakeholders’ requirements.

    A first workshop has shown that most indicators from the environmental dimension are useful for stakeholders in the Austrian context, but some need further refinements. Biodiversity, for example, is only considered via land cover change whereas threats to (agro-)biodiversity in Austria and the EU foremost occur in-situ. The economic dimension is ranking second in its usefulness for Austrian stakeholders with few indicators such as food loss being of little relevance. The indicators presently included in the social dimension are least relevant as they cover aspects such as land rights, undernourishment, and rural poverty, which do not pose major issues in Austria and more broadly the EU.

    General concerns of stakeholders are the directionality of indicator ratings and their scope which is in part considered too narrow. E.g., high government expenditure for agriculture is considered positive in the matrix regardless of its purpose and may cause dependencies. Human nutrition is only included via undernourishment and soil nutrient status solely as surplus, whereas in both cases also the other extreme may be adverse. Accordingly, a bell-shaped indicator and rating would be favored in such cases. A general requirement was expressed for an additional context dimension. Governance arrangements and the overall socioeconomic situation are so far deliberately not included due to the focus on performance in the existing SAM. Yet, indicators describing such framework conditions can be essential to interpret synergies and trade-offs and the effectiveness of policy measures aiming at achieving SDGs. Beyond the evaluation of existing indicators, the stakeholder process yielded comprehensive suggestions for additional indicators, covering biodiversity, research and education, self-sufficiency, as well as various aspects of resilience and stability. Overall, the co-evaluation with stakeholders highlights that only few globally defined indicators are readily applicable in a regional context where consideration of local conditions and specifics is vital.

    The proposed revisions are now being matched with available data across geographic scales to revise the matrix and perform further analyses on trade-offs and synergies. This will also include further context information to facilitate the evaluation of policies, ultimately allowing for improved policy-making to attain agricultural sustainability. Results will be further co-evaluated iteratively with stakeholders to eventually produce a globally applicable indicator system.

    How to cite: Folberth, C., Sinabell, F., Schinko, T., and Hanger-Kopp, S.: Co-evaluating and -designing a Sustainable Agriculture Matrix for Austria in an international context, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9474, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9474, 2022.

    EGU22-9476 | Presentations | ITS4.2/ERE1.11

    Detection of Habitat Heterogeneity Changes Using Laser Scanning Data Targeting Birds 

    Ji Yeon Kim, Dong Kun Lee, and Eun Sub Kim

    Research dealing with three-dimensional structural data of forests or vegetation is increasing. LiDAR-based research to detect biodiversity (LaRue et al. 2019) is growing, through using structural data such as analyzing heterogeneity, distribution, and height in forest structures (Matsuo et al. 2021) or identifying rugosity (Gough et al. 2020). For example, the technology to detect canopy structures is linked with the GEDI technology, leading to structural diversity mapping on a wide scale and further to β-diversity. (Schneider et al. 2020) Meanwhile, most connectivity studies so far have been conducted on two-dimensional surfaces, and resistance value-based studies on species data, topography and vegetation structure, and habitat quality have been performed. In this study, we try to detect changes in the space distribution pattern of species due to anthropogenic intervention through lidar-based 3D structural data. Through structural heterogeneity, the connectivity at the landscape level is analyzed, and for this purpose, it can be compared with the traditional diversity evaluation method through a verification process based on species data. By detecting the impact on species in advance in the impact assessment stage, this study intends to present a methodology that can function as a forestry and conservation decision-making support tool in combination with ICT-based monitoring technology.

    How to cite: Kim, J. Y., Lee, D. K., and Kim, E. S.: Detection of Habitat Heterogeneity Changes Using Laser Scanning Data Targeting Birds, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9476, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9476, 2022.

    EGU22-9542 | Presentations | ITS4.2/ERE1.11

    Eliciting public preferences for wildfire management policies in Crete, Greece 

    Haleema Misal, Ioannis Kountouris, Apostolos Voulgarakis, and Anastasios Rovithakis

    Fire regimes form an integral part of terrestrial biomes in the Mediterranean region as they provide essential disturbances which change the structure and function of plants that favour Mediterranean type climates. Fire is inextricably linked to such ecosystems and cannot be excluded from them. However, the intensification of human activities in Greece, coupled with increasingly unpredictable wildfires has created huge imbalances and jeopardised the ecological integrity of ecosystems. Expansions into the wildland urban interface, rural abandonment, and the focus on fire suppression are increasing the vulnerability and flammability of the Greek environment. The duality of fire is delicate, both at local and national level, catastrophic wildfires singe deeply on landscapes and economies, social burns can take just as long to heal. In Greece, this is further exacerbated by the burgeoning socio-economic and political complexities that have catalysed the current ineffective and unsustainable fire management strategies. Damages from wildfires affect ecosystem services which can lead to a reduction in human wellbeing. Understanding the interactions between ecosystems and humans through environmental valuation is key to implementing effective policy. This study uses economic valuation methods in the form of a choice experiment to elicit public preference for a wildfire management policy in Crete. A survey was deployed around the island, with respondents asked about their preferences between different management strategies. The policies outlined in the survey are made up of the following attributes: risk of fire, agricultural production, landscape quality and post-wildfire damage mitigation. Results from this study indicate a positive preference by the public for a new proposed policy. The findings from this study can be used for decision making in Crete and other similar southern European environments by providing metrics for appropriate wildfire management.

    How to cite: Misal, H., Kountouris, I., Voulgarakis, A., and Rovithakis, A.: Eliciting public preferences for wildfire management policies in Crete, Greece, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9542, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9542, 2022.

    The concept of ecosystem services (ES), as a set of components of the natural capital that provide products and services directed to humans, was born around the middle of the last century, reaching a more systematic definition in the early 2000s with the Millennium Ecosystem Assessment (MA, 2005). This issue is implicitly linked to popular research topics, such as climate change,  population well-being, fight against hunger in the world and has undergone a significant increasing interest from scientific research since the SDGs subscription, defined in the 2030 Agenda.

    With the thrust of the investigation into this new branch, various tools have been created aimed at dealing with ecosystem services, not only from a qualitative point of view but in quantitative terms. The present work aims to analyze the applicability of a specific SE quantification software for vegetation, based both on the use of meteorological data and on the acquisition of field data and capable of returning outputs relating to the main components: environment (air quality), soil (use and cover) and water (quality and quantity of water runoff, with a focus on vegetation hydrology). The combination of this eco-hydrological model with a monetary ES evaluation is also interesting: although the economic model considered is particularly simple and therefore characterized by a non-negligible standard error, it is important to underline the direct and spontaneous association between SE and monetary quantification considered by the software, unlike how at the end of the last century the economic value of nature was still neglected.

    Finally, the main results of a ES quantification project in an Italian urban context will be discussed, underlining  the environmental improvement to the surroundings and the social benefits for the population.

    How to cite: Busca, F. and Revelli, R.: Ecosystem services, monetary value and social sphere: a specific-vegetation software suite on a urban-scale project, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11996, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11996, 2022.

    EGU22-12354 | Presentations | ITS4.2/ERE1.11

    Social capital in stressed social-ecological systems: understanding social learning in agricultural communities in China to aid environmental policy and practice 

    Ying Zheng, Larissa A. Naylor, Weikai Wang, Alasdair Stanton, David Oliver, Neil Munro, Nai Rui Chng, Susan Waldron, and Tao Peng

    Social learning is increasingly used to address environmental challenges including sustainable farming. How sustainable agricultural knowledge is co-produced, shared and used between farmers, scientists and government is important for building capacity and trust for sustainability in stressed socio-ecological communities worldwide. However, such understanding is largely lacking in developing economies. This research presents the findings from analysis of smallholder farmers’ social learning in three agricultural regions in China. Combining an existing social capital framework with questionnaires (Q) and interviews (I) with farmers (Q n=632; I n=30) and officials (Q n=77, I n=64), we demonstrate how farmers access and share farming knowledge through bonding, bridging and linking networks. In two regions, family bonding was the dominant learning pathway while linking networks to access ‘formal knowledge’ from government (or scientists) were limited. However, in the third region, government played a more important role in farmers’ knowledge sharing and acquisition processes. In all regions, learning from researchers was largely absent. Key suggestions about ways to enhance use of multiple forms of knowledge are provided. First, this study highlights the need for a more locally and socially embedded approach to facilitate enhanced farmers’ knowledge exchange and learning, to then build trust and capacity to help better address pressing local environmental challenges. Second, we show how social dynamics research can usefully inform knowledge exchange plans for collaborative, international development science, so that it can be best suited to local contexts, to optimise research impacts, capacity building and avoiding of mismatches. 

    How to cite: Zheng, Y., Naylor, L. A., Wang, W., Stanton, A., Oliver, D., Munro, N., Chng, N. R., Waldron, S., and Peng, T.: Social capital in stressed social-ecological systems: understanding social learning in agricultural communities in China to aid environmental policy and practice, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12354, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12354, 2022.

    HS13 – Further sessions of interest to Hydrological Sciences

    EGU22-234 | Presentations | CL4.1

    Modulation of Dry and Wet Period Temperatures in India 

    Anagha Prabhakar and Subhasis Mitra

    Temperature-based events such as heatwaves and compound dry hot extremes impact the socio-economic sectors of a nation. In this study, the differential rates of temperature intensification across different seasons and regions in India coupled with dry/ wet climatologies are studied. The analysis is done for both historical observations and future CMIP6 simulations. Further, the temperature intensification rates were linked to established atmospheric feedback mechanisms. Results show that observed temperature intensification rates are positive/negative during dry/wet climatology relative to average climatology. Analysis of feedback mechanisms showed that cooling temperature trends are associated with a decrease in atmospheric aridity (vapor pressure deficit) and an increase in relative humidity. While in southern India, temperature trends are similar for all three climatologies (average, dry, and wet), albeit with different rates of intensification, in northern India, the temperature intensification shows notable contrasting trends during dry and wet climatologies. The highly irrigated Indo-Gangetic Plain region in northern India is found to experience significant cooling temperature trends during dry climatology and these trends are much more prominent during the agricultural Rabi season. Climate change analysis using CMIP6 simulations indicates further exacerbation of temperatures across all regions in the Indian subcontinent and foresees an increased probability of compound extremes in the future.

    How to cite: Prabhakar, A. and Mitra, S.: Modulation of Dry and Wet Period Temperatures in India, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-234, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-234, 2022.

    Measurements of global solar and net radiation fluxes were made above a grass-covered surface at DACCIWA site in a tropical location, Ile-Ife, southwest Nigeria for a period of three years (2017 - 2019). The radiation data sets were obtained from a four-component net radiometer (model NR01). Observations were made for cases of clear sky and cloudy conditions during the measurement period. The results showed considerable fluctuations of both radiation fluxes occurring during the period of measurements at the location. For clear sky conditions, the magnitudes of global and net radiation fluxes were higher than those observed for cloudy conditions due to attenuation by clouds and aerosols. For the period of observation, the highest radiation flux values occurred in 2018 while the lowest were observed in 2017. The daily surface albedo (α) values ranged from 0.16 to 0.22 at the site. Empirical relationships obtained for global solar and net radiation are  RN = 0.754 RG – 17.4 Wm-2 and  RN = 0.657 RG – 32.7 Wm-2 for wet and dry seasons respectively. Based on the empirical relationships, daily net and global solar radiation can be obtained when measurements like these are not available. Linear relationships between RN  and RG indicate that for all days (cloudy and clear sky conditions), average RN  is about 65 % of RG , and about 50 % of  RG for clear sky conditions at the location

    How to cite: Ajao, A., Abiye, O., and Agboola, A.: Analysis of global and net radiation fluxes in relation to surface albedo at DACCIWA site in Ile-Ife, southwest Nigeria, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1283, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1283, 2022.

    EGU22-1292 | Presentations | CL4.1

    Quantifying land-surface albedo feedback using Dansgaard-Oeschger events 

    Mengmeng Liu, Iain Colin Prentice, and Sandy P. Harrison

    Land-surface shortwave albedo is an important quantity in the energy budget of the Earth. Remotely sensed snow cover, maximum tree height and maximum fractional absorbed photosynthetically active radiation (fAPAR) explain 87% of the variation in present-day annual mean land surface albedo (weighted by the seasonal cycle of shortwave radiation) in a generalized linear model. We can therefore apply this model during Dansgaard-Oeschger (D-O) warming events during the last glacial period. We have already used these repeated, rapid (50–200 year), near-global climate-change events to provide new quantifications of Earth system feedbacks involving atmospheric CO2, CH4 and N2O. We now reconstruct maximum tree height and maximum fAPAR based on a new global compilation of pollen data covering the relevant time interval, combined with snow cover changes during simulated D-O events, in order to reconstruct global changes in radiative forcing due to changes in vegetation and snow cover – and thereby quantify the global land-surface albedo feedback.

    How to cite: Liu, M., Prentice, I. C., and Harrison, S. P.: Quantifying land-surface albedo feedback using Dansgaard-Oeschger events, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1292, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1292, 2022.

    EGU22-1526 | Presentations | CL4.1

    Interactions between land cover change and temperature-humidity variability on a global scale 

    Anna Luisa Hemshorn de Sánchez, Bjorn Stevens, Paolo D’Odorico, and Nima Shokri

    The change of land cover affects regional and global climate through the surface energy budget and the water cycle, which determine the interactions between the terrestrial biosphere and the atmosphere. Land cover change not only affects the climate but is also influenced by it. The projected climate change and the occurrence of extreme climate events will profoundly affect the land cover, crop production, as well as water and food security. Yet, the complex interactions between land cover changes and climate variability are not fully understood. Previous studies have shown that land cover change influences the mean and extreme values of climate variables such as temperature. However, most research focused on specific types of land cover change such as deforestation or urbanisation and looked at only one climate variable (e.g., temperature). A comprehensive multivariate analysis relating multiple land cover changes and climate variables at the global scale is still missing. Here, we take an observation-based approach that analyses the complex interactions between different types of land cover change and the joint effect of temperature and humidity variability at the global scale. We analyse almost three decades of remotely sensed land cover and climate data to investigate the complex coupling between the patterns of different types of land cover change and the variability of temperature and relative humidity across the globe. Our analysis identifies hotspots of change on a global scale and correlations which will help to devise necessary action plans for sustainable land management and climate change mitigation measures crucial to the achievement of the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals.

    How to cite: Hemshorn de Sánchez, A. L., Stevens, B., D’Odorico, P., and Shokri, N.: Interactions between land cover change and temperature-humidity variability on a global scale, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1526, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1526, 2022.

    Managed alterations to ecosystems designed to increase carbon sequestration or reduce greenhouse gas emissions – so-called “natural” or “nature-based” climate solutions like reforestation and cover cropping - have growing public and private support. Despite this enthusiasm, the realizable benefits of these strategies, and unintended consequences to be avoided, are not well understood. In particular, land cover and management changes designed to affect carbon cycles will also impact water and energy cycles in ways that may or may not be climatically beneficial, but we lack systematic frameworks for assessing and valuing these “biophysical impacts.” Moreover, most of the existing observation-driven work on the topic has been limited to impacts on surface temperature; we still know relatively little about when and where modifications to surface temperature extend to the near-surface air temperature, which is arguably the more relevant target for climate adaptation. In this talk, I will describe a new approach for leveraging flux tower observations to understand the duality of surface and air temperature responses to land cover change. Then, using Eastern US reforestation as a case study, I will apply the approach together with analysis of remote sensing and meteorological data to demonstrate that over annual time scales, reforestation substantially lowers both surface and air temperature, due to canopy structural effects that enhance both sensible heat flux and latent heat flux. However, during heat waves when cooling benefits are most needed, divergent responses of sensible and latent heat fluxes between forested and non-forested ecosystems may reduce the local climate adaptation potential of reforestation.

    How to cite: Novick, K.: The local climate adaptation potential of reforestation, and how it changes during heat waves, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2056, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2056, 2022.

    EGU22-2915 | Presentations | CL4.1

    Nowcasting Tracks of Severe Convective Storms in West Africa from Observations of Land Surface State 

    Christopher M. Taylor, Cornelia Klein, Cheikh Dione, Douglas J. Parker, John Marsham, Cheikh Abdoulahat Diop, Jennifer Fletcher, Abdoul Aziz Saidou Chaibou, Dignon Bertin Nafissa, Valiyaveetil Shamsudheen Semeena, Steven Cole, and Seonaid Anderson

    In tropical convective climates, where numerical weather prediction of rainfall has high uncertainty, nowcasting provides essential alerts of extreme events several hours ahead. In principle, short-term prediction of intense convective storms could benefit from knowledge of the slowly-evolving land surface state in regions where soil moisture controls surface fluxes. Here we explore how near-real time (NRT) satellite observations of the land surface and convective clouds can be combined to aid early warning of severe weather in the Sahel on time scales of up to 12 hours. Using Land Surface Temperature (LST) as a proxy for soil moisture deficit, we characterise the state of the surface energy balance in NRT. We identify the most convectively-active parts of Mesoscale Convective Systems (MCSs) from spatial filtering of cloud-top temperature imagery.

    We find that predictive skill provided by LST data is maximised early in the rainy season, when soils are drier and vegetation less developed. Land-based skill in predicting intense convection extends well beyond the afternoon, with strong positive correlations between daytime LST and MCS activity persisting as far as the following morning in more arid conditions. For the Science for Weather Information and Forecasting Techniques (SWIFT) Forecasting Testbed event during September 2021, we developed a simple technique to translate LST data into NRT maps quantifying the likelihood of convection based solely on land state. We used these maps in combination with convective features to nowcast the tracks of existing MCSs, and predict likely new initiation locations. This is the first time to our knowledge that nowcasting tools based principally on land observations have been developed. The strong sensitivity of Sahelian MCSs to soil moisture, in combination with MCS life times of typically 6-18 hours, opens up the opportunity for nowcasting of hazardous weather well beyond what is possible from atmospheric observations alone, and could be applied elsewhere in the semi-arid tropics.

    How to cite: Taylor, C. M., Klein, C., Dione, C., Parker, D. J., Marsham, J., Abdoulahat Diop, C., Fletcher, J., Saidou Chaibou, A. A., Nafissa, D. B., Semeena, V. S., Cole, S., and Anderson, S.: Nowcasting Tracks of Severe Convective Storms in West Africa from Observations of Land Surface State, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2915, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2915, 2022.

    EGU22-4349 | Presentations | CL4.1

    Assessing the variability of soil temperatures in Land Surface Models using outputs from the Soil Parameter Model Intercomparison Project (SP-MIP) 

    Anne Verhoef, Yijian Zeng, Matthias Cuntz, Lukas Gudmundsson, Stephan Thober, Patrick C. McGuire, Hannah Bergner, Aaron Boone, Agnès Ducharne, Rich Ellis, Hyungjun Kim, Sujan Koirala, Dave Lawrence, Keith Oleson, Sean Swenson, Salma Tafasca, Philipp de Vrese, Sonia Seneviratne, Dani Or, and Harry Vereecken

    Results: Soil temperature is a crucial variable in Land Surface Models (LSMs) because it affects the fractions of frozen and unfrozen water content in the soil. For example, getting the coupling between below-ground heat- and water transfer correct in LSMs is very important in permafrost regions because these are particularly sensitive to climate change. Poor predictions of the energy- and water balance in these regions will lead to large uncertainties in predicted carbon fluxes, and related land-atmosphere feedbacks. Also, simulated near-surface soil temperatures can be used to diagnose and explain model differences in skin temperatures and soil heat fluxes, both of which are pivotal in the prediction of the surface energy balance.

    Soil temperature is generally under-researched as part of LSM intercomparisons. Here we present an analysis of the spatial distribution (including the vertical distribution along the soil profile) and seasonal evolution of soil temperature simulated by eight LSMs as part of the Soil Parameter Model Intercomparison Project (SP-MIP). We found large inter-model differences in key metrics of the annual soil temperature wave, including the amplitude, phase shift and damping depth, which were partly attributed to diversity in hydraulic as well as thermal soil properties. Soil layer discretisation also played a role.

    Methods: Via manipulation of model soil hydraulic properties, and the soil texture inputs required to calculate these properties, controlled multi-model experiments have been conducted as part of SP-MIP, this MIP was originally proposed at the GEWEX-SoilWat workshop held in Leipzig (June 2016).

    The model experiments closely followed the LS3MIP protocol (van den Hurk et al. 2016). Eight land models (CLM5, ISBA, JSBACH, JULES, MATSIRO, MATSIRO-GW, NOAH-MP and ORCHIDEE) were run globally on 0.5° with GSWP3 forcing, from 1980-2010, for vertically homogeneous soil columns. There were 4 model experiments, leading to 7 model runs: Experiment 1. Global soil hydraulic parameter maps provided by SP-MIP; Experiment 2. Soil-hydraulic parameters derived from common soil textural properties, provided by SP-MIP, using model-specific pedotransfer functions (PTFs); Experiment 3. Reference run with all models applying their default soil hydraulic settings (including their own soil maps to derive the parameters); Experiment 4: four runs using spatially uniform soil hydraulic parameters for the whole globe (loamy sand, loam, clay and silt) provided by SP-MIP.

    Differences between the model experiments will allow the assessment of the inter-model variability that is introduced by the different stages of preparing model parameters. Soil parameters for Experiments 1 and soil textures for Experiment 2 at 0.5° resolution were prepared from dominant soil classes of the 0-5 cm layer of SoilGrids (Hengl et al. 2014) at 5 km resolution. Brooks and Corey hydraulic parameters come from Table 2 of Clapp and Hornberger (1978), Mualem-Van Genuchten hydraulic parameters are ROSETTA class average hydraulic parameters (Schaap et al. 2001), and soil textures are from Table 2 of Cosby et al. (1984). Experiments 4 a-d use the USDA soil classes, using the same PTFs for Brooks and Corey and Mualem-van Genuchten parameters as in Experiment 1.

    How to cite: Verhoef, A., Zeng, Y., Cuntz, M., Gudmundsson, L., Thober, S., McGuire, P. C., Bergner, H., Boone, A., Ducharne, A., Ellis, R., Kim, H., Koirala, S., Lawrence, D., Oleson, K., Swenson, S., Tafasca, S., de Vrese, P., Seneviratne, S., Or, D., and Vereecken, H.: Assessing the variability of soil temperatures in Land Surface Models using outputs from the Soil Parameter Model Intercomparison Project (SP-MIP), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4349, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4349, 2022.

    Natural processes within the Earth system have been shown to organise themselves to achieve a state of thermodynamic optimality. Here we test these physical principles for convective flux exchange within the surface – atmosphere system.  We propose an idealised modelling framework where the convective exchange is conceptualised as the outcome of a heat engine operated between the hotter Earth’s surface and the cooler atmosphere. We use the first and second law of thermodynamics in conjunction with the surface energy balance which give rise to thermodynamic constraints on turbulent flux exchange. This new constraint is associated with the maximum power that can be generated within the heat engine to sustain convective motion. We use daily radiative forcing from NASA-CERES dataset as the input to our approach and estimated the surface energy partitioning on land into turbulent fluxes and emitted longwave radiation. The former is closely related to convective exchange within the atmosphere driving the hydrologic cycling while the latter directly relates to the surface temperature of the Earth.  We compare our estimates of surface temperatures, latent and sensible heat fluxes with observation based datasets and found a very good agreement over land at a global scale. Our findings show that physical principles of thermodynamics alone can explain the surface energy partitioning to a large extent. We further show an application of this approach in removing the cloud radiative effects (CRE) from surface temperatures. We used clear-sky fluxes from the NASA-CERES dataset as a forcing to our thermodynamically constrained energy balance model and estimated "clear-sky" temperatures. These temperatures removes the effect of radiative cooling by clouds on surface temperatures and can be used as useful variable to infer the hydrological sensitivity from observations. Our work implies that thermodynamically constrained idealised models can be used to identify the dominant physical controls on climate system to better understand land-atmosphere interactions and climate sensitivities.

    How to cite: Ghausi, S. and Kleidon, A.: How much of the surface energy partitioning can be explained by controls imposed by thermodynamics?, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4528, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4528, 2022.

    EGU22-5646 | Presentations | CL4.1

    Drivers of the spatiotemporal variability in the thermal balance of forests during heatwaves and normal conditions. 

    Adrià Barbeta, Diego G. Miralles, Leire Mendiola, Teresa E. Gimeno, Santiago Sabaté, Albert Pou, and Jofre Carnicer

    Different land covers present contrasting changes in energy budgets as a response to heatwaves and droughts and thus the land feedback is expected to vary over the landscape. To date, the study of the biotic determinants of land-atmosphere feedbacks during heatwaves has been restricted to the consideration of different plant functional types. We used improved vegetation structural measurements at organizational levels lower than plant functional types (inter– and intra–specific) to estimate the impact of forests on the surface thermal balance.

    We combined space-borne measurements of the temperature of plants (ECOSTRESS) and the land surface (MODIS) with ground-based meteorological data to estimate the thermal balance of the surface (∆T) at a resolution of 70x70m in 615 forest plots, dominated by 28 different species. In each plot, forest structural variables were determined through LiDAR. We then analysed the spatiotemporal drivers of ∆T by quantifying the contribution of topographical, landscape, meteorological and forest structural variables on ∆T both during normal conditions and heatwave episodes.

    Canopy temperatures fluctuated according to changes in air temperature and were on average 1˚C warmer than the air. During heatwaves, canopies were relatively cooler than the air, compared to normal conditions in all but Mediterranean coniferous forests. The thermal response of canopies to heatwaves strongly varied as a function of environmental variables. Forests in rainy areas and in steep slopes presented the lowest ∆T, whereas forests in arid areas and flat terrain had the highest ∆T. Interestingly, there was a strong effect of forest structure, since forests with larger biomass kept a cooler thermal balance (lower ∆T). Indeed, the total effect of forest structural variables on ∆T was of equal magnitude as that of topography or meteorological conditions.

    The thermal balance of the surface (∆T) was not only different among the main forest types, but also, it strongly varied within forests dominated by the same species. Because ∆T is an important component of the surface energy budget, our results on its dependence on forest structure imply that forest management could be employed to modify the surface energy budget to promote negative (mitigating) feedbacks of forests during heatwave episodes. Further efforts concentrate on estimating changes in aerodynamic conductance between forests and their surroundings, and their potential influence on the land–atmosphere coupling and the feedback of forests on local temperatures.

    How to cite: Barbeta, A., Miralles, D. G., Mendiola, L., Gimeno, T. E., Sabaté, S., Pou, A., and Carnicer, J.: Drivers of the spatiotemporal variability in the thermal balance of forests during heatwaves and normal conditions., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5646, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5646, 2022.

    EGU22-5787 | Presentations | CL4.1 | Highlight

    Shift towards ecosystem water limitation exacerbates hot temperature extremes 

    Jasper Denissen, Adriaan J. Teuling, Gianpaolo Balsamo, and Rene Orth

    Hot temperature extremes have severe implications for human health, crop yields and tree mortality. Whereas they are mostly introduced by atmospheric circulation patterns, the intensity of hot temperature extremes is modulated by ecosystem functioning; when soil moisture is abundant, evaporation of water through transpiration and evaporation from surfaces is high, which causes relevant evaporative cooling. This cooling is greatly reduced under drought stress, because ecosystems adapt to water-limited conditions by saving water e.g. through stomatal regulation which leads to decreased terrestrial evaporation. This in turn leaves more energy to potentially exacerbate hot temperature extremes. 

    While it has been shown that ecosystem water limitation is projected to increase in the future, the respective implications on hot temperature extremes are unclear. In this study, we capture the ecosystem's water limitation through the so-called Ecosystem Limitation Index (ELI, Denissen et al. 2020). To mitigate the confounding influence of changes in mean temperatures, which possibly originate from heat advection and circulation, we focus on the differences between mean and hot temperature extremes. Based on global climate projections from the sixth Coupled Model Intercomparison Project (CMIP6) from 1980 - 2100, we find regions with significant correlations between future evolution of temperature differences and ELI, with hot spots in North and South America. We furthermore test the role of the initial ELI for these correlations and find weak effects in Earth System Models included in the CMIP6 ensemble, but higher relevance in reanalysis data from the ECMWF Reanalysis 5th generation (ERA5) from 1980 - 2020, where the highest correlations are found in initially water-limited regions. These findings show that in large areas across the globe, temperature extremes increase much faster than mean temperatures alongside ecosystem drying. Therefore, considering ecosystem drying is relevant for assessing the intensity of projected temperature extremes and their corresponding impacts. This way, improving the representation of vegetation dynamics in state-of-the-art models is necessary to more accurately estimate evaporative cooling and consequently hot temperature extremes.

    ---

    Denissen, J. M., Teuling, A. J., Reichstein, M., & Orth, R. (2020). Critical soil moisture derived from satellite observations over Europe. Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres, 125(6), e2019JD031672.

    How to cite: Denissen, J., Teuling, A. J., Balsamo, G., and Orth, R.: Shift towards ecosystem water limitation exacerbates hot temperature extremes, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5787, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5787, 2022.

    EGU22-6467 | Presentations | CL4.1

    Daytime-only-mean data can enhance our understanding of land-atmosphere coupling 

    Zun Yin, Kirsten Findell, Paul Dirmeyer, Elena Shevliakova, Sergey Malyshev, Khaled Ghannam, Nina Raoult, and Zhihong Tan

    The major concern of land-atmosphere interactions (L-A) is the evolutionary process between the land surface and the planet boundary layer during the daytime, however many relevant studies had to use entire-day-mean daily time series to perform investigation due to lack of sub-daily data. Yet it is unclear whether the inclusion of nighttime data would alter the results or obscure the L-A interactive processes. To address this question, we generated daytime-only-mean (D) and entire-day-mean (E) daily data based on the ERA5 (5th ECMWF reanalysis) hourly product, and evaluated the strength of L-A coupling through a two-legged metrics, which assessed the coupling strength by the causality as well as the impact magnitude through two segments (land-fluxes and fluxes-atmosphere). The results demonstrated significant differences between the D- and E-based diagnoses as large as 67% (median 20.7%), which strongly depended on the season and the region. More importantly, for the first time, two special L-A coupling mechanisms were revealed. One was the advection-dominant L-A mechanism in tropical hyper-arid regions. The other was the soil moisture and sensible heat flux coupling mechanism during the cooling process over the nighttime. Both processes may play important roles during the night, andweaken the signal of L-A coupling if E was applied. To improve our knowledge of L-A interactions, we call attention to the urgent need for more high frequency data for relevant diagnoses. Meanwhile, we propose two approaches to resolve the dilemma of huge storage for high frequency data: (1) integration of L-A metrics in Earth System Model outputs, and (2) production of daily datasets based on different averaging algorithms.

    How to cite: Yin, Z., Findell, K., Dirmeyer, P., Shevliakova, E., Malyshev, S., Ghannam, K., Raoult, N., and Tan, Z.: Daytime-only-mean data can enhance our understanding of land-atmosphere coupling, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6467, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6467, 2022.

    EGU22-6753 | Presentations | CL4.1

    Upwind droughts enhance heat waves in Eastern China 

    Shiyu Zhou and Xing Yuan

    Heat wave is one of the most severe natural disasters in the mid-latitude regions. Due to climate change and urbanization, heat waves have been intensified in the past, and are projected to be more severe in the future. Droughts and heat waves usually occur simultaneously, which are referred to as compound extreme events. Antecedent or simultaneous droughts enhance heat waves through local land-atmosphere interaction, but a few case studies show that upwind droughts can have a significant impact on heat waves through sensible heat advection. In order to systematically study the impact of upwind droughts on heat waves, this study uses a Lagrangian integrated trajectory model driven by reanalysis data to analyze the heat wave events in northern part of Eastern China from 1979 to 2019. We find that half of the heat waves are enhanced by upwind droughts. For the related heat waves, the upwind droughts contributed to 67.9% of the heat anomalies. The impact of flash drought on heat waves in Eastern China is also being explored, with particular interest to extract heat wave signals from antecedent flash drought to provide early warning for extreme heat waves over downwind areas.

    How to cite: Zhou, S. and Yuan, X.: Upwind droughts enhance heat waves in Eastern China, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6753, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6753, 2022.

    EGU22-6904 | Presentations | CL4.1

    Evapotranspiration frequently increases during droughts 

    Meng Zhao, Geruo Aa, Yanlan Liu, and Alexandra Konings

    During droughts, low water availabilities limit soil evaporation and induce stomatal closure to prevent transpiration, leading to reductions in evapotranspiration (ET). At the same time, drought-associated meteorological conditions such as high temperature elevate atmospheric evaporative demand, acting to increase ET. However, the overall effect of drought on the sign of ET anomalies remains unknown, as are the determinants of this response. Positive anomalies during drought (ET+), in particular, are of concern because they quickly deplete water resources, may cause flash droughts, and exacerbate ecosystem stress. Because remotely sensed ET datasets implicitly assume a stomatal response to drought, they cannot provide direct observational constraints of the prevalence of ET+. Eddy covariance tower records are often too short and sparse to adequately sample drought conditions. To avoid these shortcomings, we used a water balance approach to derive a new estimate of ET+ occurrence during droughts by combining total terrestrial water storage (TWS) observations from the Gravity Recovery and Climate Experiment (GRACE) and GRACE Follow-On (GRACE-FO) with Global Precipitation Climatology Project precipitation data. The robustness of this approach is demonstrated across 104 hydrological basins. With this new water balance-based estimate, we showed that ET+ during droughts are globally widespread. On average, ET+ occurs in ~45% of drought periods, and it is more likely to occur during milder droughts (with relatively lower P reductions and ample available TWS). CMIP6 Earth system models (ESMs) underestimate the observed ET+ probability by nearly half. This underestimation is particularly large in relatively dry locations with an aridity index (P/PET) below ~1.5 and can be attributed in part to an overly strong ET response to decreases in soil moisture in these regions. Furthermore, ESM’s lack of accounting for variability in plant water stress response traits within plant functional types exacerbates their underestimation of ET+. This demonstrates for the first time that local adaptation of plant water stress response traits reduces the impact of droughts on ET. These process representations should be improved to reduce model uncertainties in predicting drought impacts on the energy-water-carbon nexus.

    How to cite: Zhao, M., Aa, G., Liu, Y., and Konings, A.: Evapotranspiration frequently increases during droughts, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6904, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6904, 2022.

    EGU22-7812 | Presentations | CL4.1

    Impact of trends in historical surface roughness over Europe on extra-tropical windstorms in CMIP6 

    Mareike Schuster, Thomas Raddatz, and Uwe Ulbrich

    Extratropical windstorms are amongst the highest rated perils for the European continent. Extreme wind speeds of these synoptic scale systems occur primarily in the winter season and often cause damage to buildings, forests and infrastructure, and thus can have large socio-economic impacts.

    In our studies of extratropical windstorms in the CMIP6 model ensemble, we found remarkable trends of opposite sign in the wind speed during the historical period. More specifically, we found a continuous increase in the surface wind speed in the early historical period between 1850 and 1920, and an even stronger decrease thereafter until the present.

    In a case study with one of the models (MPI-ESM) we found that the trends in the wind speed relate to a trend of opposite sign in the roughness length, thus the wind speed increases in eras with a decrease in the surface roughness (and tree fraction) and vice versa.  While this relationship is expected and physically reasonable, it appears that the interaction of surface parameters with the atmosphere was different in CMIP5 climate models, as there is no comparable reaction of surface wind speeds to the trends in surface parameters (e.g. tree fraction).

    Since the historical era serves as the reference for any derived climate change signal, these trends might affect the amplitude of the changes in a future climate and the derived conclusions. Also, state of the art climate change signals regarding storminess might need to be reconsidered with this newly represented land-atmosphere interaction in the models.

    We further explore this phenomenon by eliminating the influence of the roughness on the wind speed and investigate the effect that this correction has on the appearance of climate change signals of extratropical windstorms.

    How to cite: Schuster, M., Raddatz, T., and Ulbrich, U.: Impact of trends in historical surface roughness over Europe on extra-tropical windstorms in CMIP6, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7812, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7812, 2022.

    EGU22-8163 | Presentations | CL4.1

    Modeling the surface-atmosphere coupling in the Moroccan semi-arid plains in the context of climate change 

    Khadija Arjdal, Fatima Driouech, Étienne Vignon, Frédérique Chéruy, Adriana Sima, Philippe Drobinski, Abdelghani Chehbouni, and Salah Er-Raki

    Morocco as many semi-arid Mediterranean and north African countries is facing strong pressure on water resources exacerbated by climate change. Assessing the representation and variability of the Moroccan climate by using the climate models is of major importance to strengthen the reliability of future scenarios and anticipate the water cycle evolutions.

    The aim of this study is to evaluate and improve the representation of the surface-atmosphere coupling, and the boundary-layer dynamics over the Haouz plain by the IPSL-CM Earth System Model. The Haouz plain is one of the most important agricultural and touristic regions of Morocco. It is located in the Tensift watershed and limited with the Atlas mountains, and it has been equipped with a network of meteorological stations. We set a simulation configuration up with a model grid refined over the Haouz plain and with a nudging towards atmospheric reanalysis outside the plain, making it possible to concomitantly compare the model outputs with in-situ data. 

    A first evaluation of the control simulation reveals an overall good agreement between the observed daily mean temperature and the simulated one despite some cold biases. Simulated near-surface relative humidity is generally low-biased (up to 20%) while precipitation is overestimated (up to 50% of observed daily precipitation). Those biases are further deciphered through a careful evaluation of the different terms of the surface energy and water budgets. Complementary analyses conditioned to the direction of the large scale flow also investigate how model’s performances over the plain depend on the representation of the orographic flow over the Atlas. This evaluation work is a preliminary and an important step to identify which and how LMDZ parameterizations have to be improved for semi-arid African regions. 

    How to cite: Arjdal, K., Driouech, F., Vignon, É., Chéruy, F., Sima, A., Drobinski, P., Chehbouni, A., and Er-Raki, S.: Modeling the surface-atmosphere coupling in the Moroccan semi-arid plains in the context of climate change, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8163, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8163, 2022.

    EGU22-8601 | Presentations | CL4.1 | Highlight

    Present and future land surface and wet bulb temperatures in the Arabian Peninsula 

    Sarah Safieddine, Simon Whitburn, Lieven Clarisse, and Cathy Clerbaux

    The Arabian Peninsula exhibits extreme hot summers and has one of the world's largest population growth. We use satellite observations and reanalysis as well as climate model projections to analyze morning and evening land surface temperatures (LST), to refer to processes at the surface, and wet bulb temperatures (WBT) to measure human heat stress. We focus on three regions: The Persian Gulf and Gulf of Oman, the inland capital of Saudi Arabia, Riyadh and the irrigated agricultural region in Al-Jouf, Saudi Arabia. This study shows that the time of the day is important when studying LST and WBT, with current and future WBT higher in the early summer evenings. It also shows that the effect of humidity brought from waterbodies or through irrigation can significantly increase heat stress.

    Over the coasts of the Peninsula, humidity decreases LST but increases heat stress via WBT values higher than 25°C in the evening. Riyadh, located in the heart of the Peninsula has lower WBT of 15°C to 17.5°C and LST reaching 42.5°C. Irrigation in the Al-Jouf province decreases LST by up to 10° with respect to its surroundings, while it increases WBT by up to 2.5°. Climate projections over the Arabian Peninsula suggest that global efforts will determine the survivability in this region. Even under the sustainability scenario, the projected increase in LST and WBT reaches +10° and +5°C respectively in the Persian Gulf and Riyadh by 2100 posing significant risk on human survivability in the Peninsula.

    How to cite: Safieddine, S., Whitburn, S., Clarisse, L., and Clerbaux, C.: Present and future land surface and wet bulb temperatures in the Arabian Peninsula, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8601, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8601, 2022.

    EGU22-9810 | Presentations | CL4.1

    Land surface controls on drought termination in Belgium 

    Douwe De Vestele, Irina Yu. Petrova, and Diego G. Miralles

    Droughts are impactful climate extremes with proven dramatic consequences on economy, ecosystems and society. Numerous research has been devoted to exploring land surface controls on meteorological drought onset and evolution. However, the importance of land conditions may be equally important for drought termination, yet the latter remains much less understood. Drought demise is often abrupt, can lead to extreme rainfall and floods, and is generally hard to capture using traditional monthly drought metrics. A better predictability of the end of a drought can not only help better anticipate the duration of droughts, but also significantly improve risk assessment and water resource management during dry extremes.

    In this study, we explore the existence of a positive or negative feedback between the decreasing soil moisture and the probability of drought termination. As test cases, multiple droughts in Belgium during the period of 1981–2015 are selected. As a first step, we compose a data set of past droughts based on precipitation and soil moisture from ECMWF reanalysis data and identify the drought termination days. Next, multiple simulations of the drought termination days are executed with the CLASS4GL mixed-layer model framework, in which the influence of changing soil moisture conditions is evaluated. Finally, the sensitivity of drought demise to soil moisture is assessed based on multiple soil moisture–atmosphere coupling metrics and revealed sensitivity relationships. The obtained results highlight the importance of realistic representation of land–atmosphere feedbacks and soil moisture for drought evolution and termination, and could be used to inform drought prediction efforts or pave the way for effective geoengineering solutions designed to mitigate the increasing risk of dry climate extremes in the future.

    How to cite: De Vestele, D., Yu. Petrova, I., and G. Miralles, D.: Land surface controls on drought termination in Belgium, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9810, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9810, 2022.

    EGU22-11121 | Presentations | CL4.1

    Assessment of Extreme Precipitation Indices over India by CMIP6 Models 

    Debi Prasad Bhuyan, Popat Salunke, and Saroj Kanta Mishra

    To simulate the extreme precipitation events through GCMs has become a challenge due to discrepancies in spatio-temporal resolution, physics, and parameterization schemes of the models along with deficiencies in the observed datasets. In this study, the performance of 27 CMIP6 models and their Multi model mean (MMM) in simulating extreme precipitation indices has been compared to the observed precipitation datasets (APHRODITE and IMD) over India during JJAS for 1975-2014. Meanwhile, the MMM shows a close agreement in simulating the indices derived from APHRODITE with PCC >0.6 for all indices with higher skill score (0.54), lower NRMSE than IMD. However, the MMM over- (under)-estimate the number of consecutive wet days (total precipitation) with a median relative error of 64% and 160% (5% and 20%) respectively, as compared to APHRODITE and IMD. Which inferred that similar biases still persist in the newly released CMIP6 GCMs with inter-observation dissimilarity in reproducing the indices. In general, the MMM is unable to replicate the very heavy precipitation (R20mm), with negative median relative errors. However, for all three aforementioned precipitation indices the extent of over- and under-estimation is less while comparing against the APHRODITE than IMD. For consecutive dry days (CDD), the MMM over- (under)-estimate over the North west (northern tip and peninsular as well as lee side of Western Ghat) parts of India, where the biases relative to APHRODITE (IMD) is large (less). The MMM simulates precipitation indices well, instead of using individual model. Whereas, the variation of NRMSE values of individual models are less with the exception of CDD and CWD, where the disagreement between the models with observation is large with larger interquartile model range. Comparing the relative errors between the different homogenous regions of India, all the regions are marginally performing good in simulating the different indices except the NW region, which is appended with larger relative error. It was worth noting that the models having higher spatial resolutions simulate the indices realistically with high (low) PCC (NRMSE), whereas the reversal is not valid for the worst performing models.

     

    Key Words: Extreme Precipitation, CMIP6, MMM, IMD, APHRODITE

    How to cite: Bhuyan, D. P., Salunke, P., and Mishra, S. K.: Assessment of Extreme Precipitation Indices over India by CMIP6 Models, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11121, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11121, 2022.

    This study examined boreal summer soil moisture using long-term satellite observations to study the bimodal probability distribution function (bimodality) of the surface soil moisture for the land-atmosphere coupling hotspot region, i.e., United States, Sahel and India. Although boreal summer soil moisture bimodality has been detected globally, it has not yet been established how surface soil moisture bimodality is caused. In this comparative multiregional study of surface soil moisture, the object was to classify India, Sahel, and Unites States regions into inter-annual or intra-seasonal soil moisture variation-based soil moisture bimodality. It was found that soil moisture bimodality detection is sensitive to the number of observations and the selected time period window. For northern India, intra-seasonal soil moisture variation dominates for soil moisture bimodality, while in the case of the United States, intra-annual soil moisture variation is dominant. 

    How to cite: Dengri, A. and Yamada, T.: Soil moisture bimodality over Land–Atmosphere hotspot regions at intraseasonal and interannual timescale., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12122, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12122, 2022.

    Gando Bawal (Mad Tree) as it is called by the people of Kutch, Gujarat is the non-native species originally known as Prosopis juliflora which was introduced in this semi-arid region in the year 1960 for rehabilitation of sodic lands and to prevent the encroachment of Rann desert onto the Banni grassland. Studies by Pasha et al. 2014 have suggested that there was an increase of 42.9% of area under Prosopis cover in Kutch during 1977 to 2011. Due to its invasive nature it has spread over large areas and invaded the pastoral grasslands of Banni region of Kutch, Gujarat. There is an increase in frequency of droughts and the people of Banni are blaming Prosopis juliflora as the culprit. Prosopis juliflora has depleted the ground water sources by accessing it through its long roots. To evaluate this and to assess the rate of groundwater depletion in this region here we used terrestrial water storage-change observations from NASA's Gravity Recovery and Climate Experiment satellites (GRACE) and simulated soil-water variations from a data-integrating hydrological model to show that groundwater is being depleted. The data set was prepared by collecting the measured precipitation, remote sensing evaporation and ground water table from the period of 2002 to 2017. During this period, the other terrestrial water storage components i.e. soil moisture, surface waters and biomass did not contribute significantly to the observed decline in total water levels. The study provided valuable information in understanding the net groundwater depletion rate by the tree species. Although our observational record is brief, the available evidence suggests that the consumption of groundwater by the tree species Prosopis juliflora is the cause why the region is going through shortages of potable water, leading to extensive socio economic stresses.

    How to cite: Tundia, K., Rao, A., and Shastri, Y.: Satellite based Assessment of Groundwater Depletion by the Invasive Tree Species- Prosopis juliflora in a Semi-Arid Region of Gujarat, India , EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12254, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12254, 2022.

    EGU22-1376 | Presentations | CL4.3

    A global investigation of CMIP6 simulated extreme precipitation beyond biases in means 

    Hebatallah Abdelmoaty, Simon Michael Papalexiou, Chandra Rupa Rajulapati, and Amir AghaKouchak

    Climate models are the available tools to assess risks of extreme precipitation events due to climate change. Models simulating historical climate successfully are often reliable to simulate future climate. Here, we assess the performance of CMIP6 models in reproducing the observed annual maxima of daily precipitation (AMP) beyond the commonly used methods. This assessment takes three scales: (1) univariate comparison based on L-moments and relative difference measures; (2) bivariate comparison using Kernel densities of mean and L-variation, and of L-skewness and L-kurtosis, and (3) comparison of the entire distribution function using the Generalized Extreme Value () distribution coupled with a novel application of the Anderson-Darling Goodness-of-fit test. The results depict that 70% of simulations have mean and variation of AMP with a percentage difference within 10 from the observations. Also, the statistical shape properties, defining the frequency and magnitude of AMP, of simulations match well with observations. However, biases are observed in the mean and variation bivariate properties. Several models perform well with the HadGEM3-GC31-MM model performing well in all three scales when compared to the ground-based Global Precipitation Climatology (GPCC) data. Finally, the study highlights biases of CMIP6 models in simulating extreme precipitation in the Arctic, Tropics, arid and semi-arid regions.

    How to cite: Abdelmoaty, H., Papalexiou, S. M., Rajulapati, C. R., and AghaKouchak, A.: A global investigation of CMIP6 simulated extreme precipitation beyond biases in means, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1376, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1376, 2022.

    EGU22-2451 | Presentations | CL4.3

    A storyline view of the projected role of remote drivers on summer air stagnation in Europe and the United States 

    José M. Garrido-Pérez, Carlos Ordóñez, David Barriopedro, Ricardo García-Herrera, Jordan L. Schnell, and Daniel Ethan Horton

    Air pollutants accumulate in the near-surface atmosphere when atmospheric scavenging, horizontal dispersion, and vertical escape are reduced. This is often termed "air stagnation". Recent studies have investigated the influence that climate change could exert on the frequency of stagnation in different regions of the globe throughout the 21st century. Although they provide a probabilistic view based on multi-model means, there are still large discrepancies among climate model projections. Storylines of atmospheric circulation change, or physically self-consistent narratives of plausible future events, have recently been proposed as a non-probabilistic means to represent uncertainties in climate change projections. This work applies the storyline approach to 21st century projections of summer air stagnation over Europe and the United States. For that purpose, we use a CMIP6 ensemble to generate stagnation storylines based on the forced response of three remote drivers of the Northern Hemisphere mid-latitude atmospheric circulation: North Atlantic warming, North Pacific warming, and tropical versus Arctic warming.

    Under a high radiative forcing scenario (SSP5-8.5), strong tropical warming relative to Arctic warming is associated with a strengthening and poleward shift of the upper westerlies, which in turn would lead to decreases in stagnation over the northern regions of North America and Europe, as well as increases in some southern regions, as compared to the multi-model mean. On the other hand, North Pacific warming tends to increase the frequency of stagnation over some regions of the U.S. by enhancing the frequency of stagnant winds, while reduced North Atlantic warming does the same over Europe by promoting the frequency of dry days.

    Given the response of stagnation to these remote drivers, their evolution in future projections will substantially determine the magnitude of the stagnation increases. Our results show differences of up to 2%/K (~2 stagnant days in summer per degree of global warming) among the storylines for some regions. We will discuss the combination of remote driver responses leading to the highest uncertainties in future air stagnation separately for Europe and the U.S.

    How to cite: Garrido-Pérez, J. M., Ordóñez, C., Barriopedro, D., García-Herrera, R., Schnell, J. L., and Horton, D. E.: A storyline view of the projected role of remote drivers on summer air stagnation in Europe and the United States, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2451, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2451, 2022.

    EGU22-2669 | Presentations | CL4.3

    The influence of the North Atlantic on vegetation greening patterns in the northern high latitudes 

    Alexander J. Winkler and Leonard F. Borchert

    Rising CO2 concentrations due to anthropogenic carbon emissions and the resulting warming raise expectations of an increase in biospheric activity in temperature-limited ecosystems. Early satellite observations since the 1980s confirm this expectation, revealing so-called "greening" trends of the high northern vegetation. However, since the early 2000s, these observational records show these greening trends have stagnated in high-latitude Eurasia (HLE), with many regions even reversing to browning trends. We propose here that decadal variations of the North Atlantic ocean could have contributed to these HLE browning trends. 

    Our analysis shows that roughly 80% of HLE area has become drier in the last two decades compared to the previous decades. It is mainly in these drying regions that the vegetation exhibits browning trends. Satellite observations of vegetation and the ERA5 reanalysis show HLE browning to be concomitant with a stagnation of North Atlantic sea surface temperature (SST). North Atlantic SST was previously shown to potentially influence remote climate by modulating a circumglobal atmospheric Rossby wave train. Indeed, we find a precipitation decrease over Eurasia to potentially originate from this North Atlantic teleconnection, linking SST stagnation to the observed browning trend.

    Next, we turn to fully-coupled Earth system models to assess the plausibility of the proposed cause-and-effect chain. We employ a pattern matching algorithm to select realizations with similar-to-observed North Atlantic SST variations from three large ensembles (MPI-GE, IPSL-LE, and CanESM5). These ensembles enable a clean separation of the unforced signal (internal variability) from the forced vegetation response (CO2 forcing). Our results show that realizations that closely resemble the observed North Atlantic spatio-temporal SST pattern also simulate the respective wave-train and associated precipitation patterns over Eurasia that cause HLE vegetation to change. Thus, the models confirm that unforced decadal variations of HLE vegetation can be modulated by North Atlantic SST via changes in precipitation patterns. In addition, model simulations suggest that the relative decrease in vegetation greenness is accompanied by a reduction in land carbon uptake, such that changes in North Atlantic SST ultimately affect the global carbon balance.

    This study therefore demonstrates that the recently observed trend in HLE browning may well be due to an unforced signal originating from the North Atlantic. This implies that even decades-long trends in biospheric variables can emerge from natural climate variability and thus could be incorrectly attributed to an external forcing. This has major implications for the understanding of biospheric dynamics, including carbon uptake and release processes.

    How to cite: Winkler, A. J. and Borchert, L. F.: The influence of the North Atlantic on vegetation greening patterns in the northern high latitudes, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2669, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2669, 2022.

    EGU22-4292 | Presentations | CL4.3 | Highlight

    Quantifying and understanding very rare climate extremes using ensemble boosting 

    Claudia Gessner, Erich M. Fischer, Urs Beyerle, and Reto Knutti

    In recent years, unprecedented temperature and precipitation extremes have been observed across the world. With further global warming, climate models project extreme events to get even more intense and likely break observational records by large margins. It is challenging to estimate how extreme climate events could get and to quantify the contribution of physical drivers in the future or even in the present climate? To address these questions, we introduce the ensemble boosting method, a model-based method that generates large samples of re-initialized extreme events in climate simulations. In doing so, the method provides physically consistent storylines of climate extremes that can be used to analyse the driving factors and estimate the very high return levels for the event type beyond observational records. We apply ensemble boosting to heat waves in the millennial pre-industrial control run, made with CESM1 and to heavy precipitation in the large ensemble near future simulations, carried out with CESM2. We find that individual members of the boosted ensembles can substantially exceed the most extreme heat and precipitation events over Europe and North America in the respective climatology. Furthermore, we show that estimated upper bounds of heat correspond to the statistical estimates by the generalized extreme value (GEV) distribution and regression models. Therefore, the framework of ensemble boosting might ultimately contribute to adaption and the stress testing of ecosystems or socioeconomic systems, increasing the resilience to extreme climate stressors.

    How to cite: Gessner, C., Fischer, E. M., Beyerle, U., and Knutti, R.: Quantifying and understanding very rare climate extremes using ensemble boosting, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4292, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4292, 2022.

    EGU22-4619 | Presentations | CL4.3

    Reconstructing zonal precipitation from sparse historical observations using climate model information and statistical learning 

    Marius Egli, Sebastian Sippel, Angeline Pendergrass, Iris de Vries, and Reto Knutti

    Changes in precipitation due to climate change are having and will continue to have substantial societal impact. Although physical process understanding allows insights into some of the model-projected changes, we face many challenges when turning to observations in order to detect these changes, such as large internal variability and limited observational coverage both in time and space.

    Here, we aim to address these challenges with a tool from statistical learning, by implementing a regularized linear model to (1) reconstruct historical seasonal full (land+ocean) zonal mean precipitation starting in 1950 and (2) detect anthropogenically forced changes in zonal mean precipitation. The linear model is trained using a climate model large-ensemble archive with its coverage reduced to match gridded station observations on land only. Once trained, the linear model can reconstruct the full zonal mean precipitation from the partial coverage given by observations. The reconstructions (1) are compared against independent satellite observations and other sources of historical precipitation reconstructions. Our approach is successful at recovering a large part of the variability in zonal precipitation. In the Northern hemisphere extra-tropics, with relatively high station coverage, the reconstructions achieve an agreement of R=0.8 (Pearson correlation) or higher with independent satellite precipitation. But correlation values decrease considerably in the Southern hemisphere and parts of the tropics. Next, we estimate trends in the forced response (2) in seasonal zonal-mean precipitation, many of which lie outside the likely range in a preindustrial climate. The detected trends are, in line with the projection of climate models forced with historical greenhouse gas and aerosol emissions but are sensitive to the underlying observational data set.

    Our results show that for large scale metrics such as seasonal zonal mean precipitation our reconstruction method can facilitate new insights for the detection and attribution of changes in the hydrological cycle. 

    How to cite: Egli, M., Sippel, S., Pendergrass, A., de Vries, I., and Knutti, R.: Reconstructing zonal precipitation from sparse historical observations using climate model information and statistical learning, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4619, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4619, 2022.

    EGU22-5090 | Presentations | CL4.3

    Detecting the spatio-temporal propagation of heat waves in a regional single-model large ensemble 

    Andrea Böhnisch, Elizaveta Felsche, and Ralf Ludwig

    Heat waves are among the most hazardous climate extremes in Europe, commonly affecting large regions for a considerable amount of time. Especially in the recent past heat waves account for substantial economic, social and ecologic impacts and loss. Projections suggest that their number, duration and intensity increase under changing climate conditions, stressing the importance of quantifying their characteristics. Yet, apart from the analysis of single historical events, little research is dedicated to the general propagation of heat waves in space and time. 

    Heat waves are rare in their occurrence and limited observational data provide little means for robust analyses and the understanding of dynamical spatio-temporal patterns. Therefore, we seek to increase the number of analyzable events by using a single-model initial condition large ensemble of a regional climate model (Canadian Regional Climate Model Version 5, CRCM5-LE). This provides 50 model members of comparable climate statistics to robustly assess various spatial patterns and pathways of European heat waves in a data set of high spatial resolution. 

    Using the CRCM5-LE allows us to explore a novel data-driven approach to infer cause-and-effect relationships, in this case the spatio-temporal propagation of spatially distributed phenomena. Our aim is to investigate specifically the transitions and inter-dependencies among heat wave core regions in Europe to better understand their evolution during the recent past.

    We define heat waves as a minimum of three consecutive hot days with temperatures above the 95th JJA (1981-2010) percentile. If a reasonable fraction of the domain land area exhibits a hot day, this time step is used for clustering in order to derive core regions. Each core region is represented by a spatially aggregated time series of the cluster footprint. The approach further includes the derivation of directed links between these core regions using causal discovery and the analysis of associated atmospheric conditions.

    Results indicate that directed links among core regions of heat wave occurrence over Europe reproduce parts of observed movements. This helps to group and characterize heat waves according to, e.g. seasonality. Examples of these heat wave cluster transitions show an associated shift of high pressure patterns, suggesting that the approach allows capturing the spatial dislocation of heat wave centers. 

    How to cite: Böhnisch, A., Felsche, E., and Ludwig, R.: Detecting the spatio-temporal propagation of heat waves in a regional single-model large ensemble, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5090, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5090, 2022.

    EGU22-5131 | Presentations | CL4.3

    Future changes in circulation types in the SMHI Large Ensemble 

    Klaus Wyser, Felicitas Hansen, Danijel Belusic, and Torben Koenigk

    Recently SMHI has completed and published 50-member ensembles for each of the Tier-1 and Tier-2 future scenarios of ScenarioMIP, using the EC-Earth3 model (SMHI-LENS, Wyser et al. 2021). Monthly and daily output from these simulations are freely available on the ESGF and can serve as a base for assessing the uncertainty of climate projections in a single model, changes in the likelihood, magnitude and duration of extremes, changes in the probability for passing tipping points, or changes in the frequency of occurrence of compound events. To our knowledge SMHI-LENS is the only single-model large ensemble that includes all ScenarioMIP scenarios.

    As an application of SMHI-LENS we present results from an evaluation of changes in large-scale circulation types (CTs) over the Scandinavian domain between the present climate and two future periods in the different scenarios. For the classification in 10 CTs we are using the Simulated Annealing and Diversified Randomization (SANDRA) method applied to daily sea level pressure fields where the spatial means have been removed (Hansen and Belusic 2021). Most of the 10 CTs occur predominantly in a specific season and can hence be referred to as summer or winter CTs. We find that the frequency of the CTs does not change significantly towards the middle of the 21st century, but that most significant CT frequency changes happen towards the end of the century during summer. The magnitude of the frequency changes is found to be proportional to the warming in the different scenarios. Our results further suggest that the distinction between summer and winter season in terms of CTs becomes more pronounced in the future climate.

    Each CT has its specific effect on other variables such as temperature and precipitation, meaning that a specific CT can, for example, be associated with lower-than-normal temperatures or less-than-normal precipitation. In our study, we also investigate how this effect changes in the different future scenarios. For both temperature and precipitation, the spatial extent of the effect change is considerably larger at the end of the century compared to the change at the mid-century, but the average magnitude of the change is similar in both periods. For temperature, the effect change is strongest in the winter half-year for almost all of the 10 CTs.

    Ref: Hansen, F. and D. Belušić. "Tailoring circulation type classification outcomes." International Journal of Climatology (2021).

    How to cite: Wyser, K., Hansen, F., Belusic, D., and Koenigk, T.: Future changes in circulation types in the SMHI Large Ensemble, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5131, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5131, 2022.

    EGU22-7280 | Presentations | CL4.3

    Planning for a Large Ensemble based on the HadGEM3 climate model 

    Reinhard Schiemann, Rosalyn Hatcher, Bryan Lawrence, Grenville Lister, and Len Shaffrey

    Large ensembles of climate-scale model simulations are key tools for assessing climate risks, separating internal variability from external forcing, and interpreting the observational record. Several modelling centres have produced such ensembles over the past years. Here we present early plans for the development of a new Large Ensemble based on the HadGEM3 (Hadley Centre Global Environment Model version 3) climate model. The initial plan envisages a 40-member ensemble spanning 150 years of historical/scenario climate (1950-2100) at a resolution of N216 (about 60 km) in the atmosphere and ¼° in the ocean.

    This initiative is part of the recently started UK NERC multi-centre project CANARI (Climate change in the Arctic-North Atlantic Region and Impacts on the UK). CANARI aims to advance understanding of the impacts on the UK arising from climate variability and change in the Arctic-North Atlantic region, with a focus on extreme weather and the potential for rapid, disruptive change. While we aim for the new Large Ensemble to become a resource for a wide range of applications, it will support addressing the CANARI science questions in particular. These questions are concerned with, for example, the (i) projected Arctic change and potential lower-latitude influences through atmospheric or oceanic pathways, (ii) the projected change in the large-scale (North Atlantic) ocean/atmosphere circulation, its drivers, and interaction with weather systems, and (iii) projected impacts on the UK arising from extreme weather (windstorms and flooding, blocking, heatwaves and droughts).

    This poster invites discussion with the community on all aspects of the design of the new Large Ensemble, and particularly seeks input regarding

    • the choice/number of experiments to follow (from CMIP6 Scenario MIP),
    • the initialisation strategy, and the degree to which slow (10 years and longer) variability, particularly in the ocean, should be sampled, and
    • the desired output.

    How to cite: Schiemann, R., Hatcher, R., Lawrence, B., Lister, G., and Shaffrey, L.: Planning for a Large Ensemble based on the HadGEM3 climate model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7280, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7280, 2022.

    The frequency of precipitation extremes is set to change in response to a warming climate. Thereby, the change in precipitation extreme event occurrence is influenced by both a shift in the mean and a change in variability. How large the individual contributions from either of them (mean or variability) to the change in precipitation extremes are, is largely unknown. This is however relevant for a better understanding of how and why climate extremes change. The mechanisms behind a change in either the mean or the variability can thereby be very different.

    For this study, two sets of forcing experiments from the regional CRCM5 initial-condition large ensemble are used. A set of 50 members with historical and RCP8.5 forcing as well as a 35-member (700 year) ensemble of pre-industrial natural forcing. The concept of the probability risk ratio is used to partition the change in extreme event occurrence into contributions from a change in mean climate or a change in variability.

    The results show that the contributions from a change in variability are in parts equally important to changes in the mean, and can even exceed them. The level of contributions shows high spatial variation which underlines the importance of regional processes for changes in extremes. Further, the results reveal a smaller influence of the level of warming and level of extremeness on the individual contributions then the seasonality or temporal aggregation (3h, 24h, 72h). These results highlight the need for a better understanding of changes in climate variability to better understand the mechanisms behind changes in climate extremes.

    How to cite: Wood, R. R.: Role of mean and variability change for changes in European seasonal extreme precipitation events, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7697, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7697, 2022.

    EGU22-7861 | Presentations | CL4.3

    Identifying patterns of spatial variability within the EuroCORDEX ensemble 

    Clair Barnes, Richard Chandler, Chris Brierley, and Raquel Alegre

    Ensembles of regional climate projections provide information about the range of possible scenarios of future climate change at the local scale, with more detail and better representation of fine-scale processes than can be provided by lower-resolution global circulation models (GCMs). The CORDEX ensembles are multi-model ensembles, with each member obtained by using a GCM to drive a higher-resolution regional climate model (RCM). Due to resource limitations however, users of regional climate information typically do not want to use an entire ensemble and must select a sample of its members for their purposes. To preserve as much information as possible, such a sample should be chosen to be representative of the variation within the ensemble.

    Analysis of variance (ANOVA) has often been used to characterise ensemble variation by apportioning the total variation to differences between the GCMs or between the RCMs (Yip et al., 2011; Déqué et al., 2012), and to produce maps of the geographical regions where variance between the runs is ascribed to one or other model component (Christensen and Kjellström, 2020). However, traditional ANOVA methods require a balanced ensemble in which all possible GCM-RCM pairs are available. The analysis of unbalanced ensembles therefore typically proceeds either by discarding surplus runs or imputing missing ones, or by using computationally intensive Bayesian methods to account for the lack of balance.

    We here propose two enhancements to the existing techniques for analysis of ensemble variation. The first is a modification of the standard ANOVA approach, based on the underlying statistical model, that can be applied directly to unbalanced ensembles: the modification is computationally cheap and hence suitable for routine application, and provides ranges of variation that are potentially attributable to the different sources.

    The second enhancement adds further detail to the partitioning of variation, using an eigenanalysis that characterises the principal spatial modes of variation within an ensemble. As well as identifying the dominant spatial patterns of variation associated with the GCMs and RCMs, the analysis characterises the contribution from each model, for example by identifying models with different treatments of orography, rain shadows, or urban heat island effects. As well as informing the selection of subsets of ensemble members, this enhancement offers the possibility of emulating missing ensemble members where the GCM-RCM matrix is only partially filled. The method is applied to the EuroCORDEX ensemble with a focus on the UK.

     

    References

    Christensen, O. and Kjellström, E. (2020). Partitioning uncertainty components of mean climate and climate change in a large ensemble of European regional climate model projections. Climate Dynamics, 54:4293–4308.
    Déqué, M., Somot, S., Sanchez-Gomez, E. et al. (2012). The spread amongst ENSEMBLES regional scenarios: regional climate models, driving general circulation models and interannual variability. Climate Dynamics, 38:951–964 (2012).
    Yip, S., Ferro, C. A. T., Stephenson, D. B., and Hawkins, E. (2011). A simple, coherent framework for partitioning uncertainty in climate predictions. Journal of Climate, 24(17):4634–4643.

    How to cite: Barnes, C., Chandler, R., Brierley, C., and Alegre, R.: Identifying patterns of spatial variability within the EuroCORDEX ensemble, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7861, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7861, 2022.

    EGU22-8735 | Presentations | CL4.3 | Highlight

    Processes leading to extreme seasons – research at the weather-climate interface based on reanalyses and large ensemble climate simulations 

    Heini Wernli, Urs Beyerle, Maxi Boettcher, Erich Fischer, Emmanouil Flaounas, Christoph Frei, Katharina Hartmuth, Mauro Hermann, Reto Knutti, Flavio Lehner, Lukas Papritz, Matthias Röthlisberger, Michael Sprenger, and Philipp Zschenderlein

    Research on extreme weather typically investigated the physical and dynamical processes involved in the formation of specific meteorological events that occur on time scales of hours to a several days (e.g., heavy precipitation events, windstorms, heat waves). Such events can be extremely hazardous, but for certain socioeconomic sectors the seasonal aggregation of weather is particularly harmful. These sectors include, for instance, agriculture, forestry, energy, and reinsurance. This presentation introduces the concept of “extreme seasons” as an important and not yet thoroughly investigated research field at the interface of weather and climate science. Extreme seasons are defined as seasons during which a particular meteorological or impact-related parameter (or a combination thereof) strongly deviates from climatology. An important conclusion of the presentation will be that large ensemble climate simulations (here using an extended CESM1-LENS data set with 6-hourly output of 3D fields), with about 1000 simulated years per climate period, are an essential resource enabling novel quantitative insight into the processes leading to and characteristics of extreme seasons. The presentation provides examples for the identification of extreme seasons and emphasizes the importance of studying their substructure, including the occurrence of specific weather systems. A first approach to systematically study extreme seasons is to consider the top 10 seasons (for a given metric) in the large ensemble at every grid point, e.g., the 10 wettest winters or hottest summers, or the 10 summers with the largest vapour pressure deficit (as an example for a more impact-related metric). Alternatively, one can look at anomalies in a multi-dimensional parameter phase space, identifying extreme seasons that result from a highly unusual combination of, e.g., surface temperature, precipitation, and surface energy balance. Or, using a pragmatic method based on fitting a statistical model to seasonal mean values at each grid point, spatially coherent extreme season objects can be identified that exceed a local return period threshold of, e.g., 40 years. The same statistical approach can be applied to ERA5 reanalyses to compare characteristics of extreme season objects (e.g., their size and intensity) in climate models with observation-based data. With this approach we can meaningfully estimate how often, e.g., an observed extreme winter like the cold North American 2013/14 winter is expected anywhere in midlatitude regions. The last part of the presentation addresses the substructure and weather system characteristics of extreme seasons. Illustrative results are shown that address the questions: (i) Where are extremely hot summers the result of the warmest days being anomalously hot vs. the coldest days being anomalously mild? (ii) Where are wettest seasons the result of more frequent wet days vs. more intense precipitation on wet days? and (iii) How does the frequency of weather systems and their precipitation efficiency change during the wettest seasons? The answers to these questions reveal interesting and large regional differences.

    How to cite: Wernli, H., Beyerle, U., Boettcher, M., Fischer, E., Flaounas, E., Frei, C., Hartmuth, K., Hermann, M., Knutti, R., Lehner, F., Papritz, L., Röthlisberger, M., Sprenger, M., and Zschenderlein, P.: Processes leading to extreme seasons – research at the weather-climate interface based on reanalyses and large ensemble climate simulations, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8735, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8735, 2022.

    EGU22-10314 | Presentations | CL4.3

    A novel approach to large-ensemble modelling: the time-slice Large Ensemble 

    Laura Muntjewerf, Richard Bintanja, Thomas Reerink, and Karin Van der Wiel

    Large-ensemble modelling has become an increasingly popular approach to study the climatic response to external forcing. The idea of a large ensemble is to generate different realizations of a forced climate to explicitly reproduce the systems internal variability. With these large datasets it is not only possible to quantify and statistically test changes in the mean climate, but also changes in climate variability and subsequent changes in extremes. Typically, the approach to generate a large ensemble set is to force the model with a transient forcing and start the different simulations from slightly different initial conditions. However, this is expensive due to the high computational demand of full-complexity GCMs or ESMs.

    Here we propose a large-ensemble design that generates a multitude of years to describe the climate states of interest, while being more economical regarding computational resources: a time-slice Large Ensemble. The core of the concept is to generate multiple time slices rather than long transient simulations. The time slices represent the present-day climate and a future warmer climate. These are segments of, for example, 10-years; too short to show significant climate change. Using stochastic physics, we add a randomizing component to the simulations. This allows us to branch multiple simulations from one set of initial conditions.

    We present the advantages and limitations of this design and we quantify the underlying assumptions. Further, we demonstrate examples of analyses from earlier work for which this type of large ensemble is well (or better) suited, in particular for studying future extreme events and finding analogues of observed extreme events. Finally, we present ongoing work on the generation and analysis of a new time-slice large-ensemble dataset with EC-Earth v3. The experimental set-up is to branch off from 16 full historical and SSP2-4.5 simulations to represent the present-day climate and a future +2K climate.

    How to cite: Muntjewerf, L., Bintanja, R., Reerink, T., and Van der Wiel, K.: A novel approach to large-ensemble modelling: the time-slice Large Ensemble, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10314, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10314, 2022.

    EGU22-10421 | Presentations | CL4.3

    Classification of atmospheric circulation types over Europe in a CMIP6 Large Ensemble using Deep Learning 

    Magdalena Mittermeier, Maximilian Weigert, Helmut Küchenhoff, and Ralf Ludwig

    The 29 circulation types by Hess & Brezowsky, called “Großwetterlagen”, are one of the most established classification schemes of the large-scale atmospheric circulation patterns influencing Europe. They are widely used in order to assess linkages between atmospheric forcing and surface conditions e.g. extreme events like floods or heat waves. Because of the connection between driving circulation type and extreme event, it is of high interest to understand future changes in the occurrence of circulation types in the context of climate change. Even though the “Großwetterlagen” have been commonly used in conjunction with historic data, only very few studies examine future trends in the frequency distribution of these circulation types using climate models. Among the potential limitations for the application of “Großwetterlagen” to climate models are the lack of an open-source classification method and the high range of internal variability. Due to the dynamic nature of the large-scale atmospheric circulation in the mid-latitudes, it is highly relevant to consider the range of internal variability when studying future changes in circulation patterns and to separate the climate change signal from noise.

    We have therefore developed an open-source, automated method for the classification of the “Großwetterlagen” using deep learning and we apply this method to the SMHI-LENS, an initial-condition single-model large ensemble of the CMIP6 generation with 50 members on a daily resolution. A convolutional neural network has been trained to classify the circulation patterns using the atmospheric variables sea level pressure and geopotential height at 500 hPa at 5° resolution. The convolutional neural network is trained for this supervised classification task with a long-term historic record of the “Großwetterlagen”, which covers the 20th century. It is derived from a subjective catalog of the German Weather Service with daily class affiliations and atmospheric variables from ECMWFs’ reanalysis dataset of the 20th century, ERA-20C.

    We present the challenges of the deep learning based classification of subjectively defined circulation types and quantify the uncertainty range intrinsic to deep neural networks using deep ensembles. We furthermore demonstrate the benefits of this automated classification of “Großwetterlagen” with respect to the application to large datasets of climate model ensembles. Our results show the ensemble-averaged future trends in the occurrence of “Großwetterlagen” and the range of internal variability, including the signal-to-noise ratio, for the CMIP6 SMHI-LENS under the SSP37.0 scenario.

    How to cite: Mittermeier, M., Weigert, M., Küchenhoff, H., and Ludwig, R.: Classification of atmospheric circulation types over Europe in a CMIP6 Large Ensemble using Deep Learning, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10421, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10421, 2022.

    EGU22-10844 | Presentations | CL4.3

    A potential driver of Eurasian winter cooling in CESM large ensemble 

    Ye-Jun Jun, Seok-Woo Son, and Hera Kim

    Despite the ongoing global warming, Eurasian winter surface air temperature (SAT) has been decreasing in recent decades. This study investigates the nature of Eurasian winter cooling and its reproductivity in the Community Earth System Model Large Ensemble simulation (CESM-LE). It is found that Eurasian winter cooling and the related atmospheric circulation change are not captured by the model ensemble mean. When 40 ensemble members are divided into two groups, ensembles with Eurasian cooling tend to show a positive sea surface temperature (SST) trend over the western Pacific warm pool, whereas the other group has the opposite SST trend. The causal relationship between tropical SST warming and Eurasian winter cooling is further tested by conducting a series of linear baroclinic model experiments. These experiments reveal that the warm pool warming and the resultant convection can effectively excite the Rossby wave train that resembles atmospheric circulation change shown in the Eurasian cooling ensembles. Specifically, a cyclonic circulation forms over the Aleutian region through the teleconnection and it is followed by an anticyclonic circulation over Siberia resulting from mass redistribution. This result indicates that Eurasian winter cooling in CESM-LE is possibly determined by the internal variability of tropical SST. It also suggests that the recent Eurasian winter cooling has been likely influenced by tropical climate variability.

    How to cite: Jun, Y.-J., Son, S.-W., and Kim, H.: A potential driver of Eurasian winter cooling in CESM large ensemble, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10844, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10844, 2022.

    EGU22-11097 | Presentations | CL4.3

    Can interannual to decadal variability help increase the accuracy of climate sensitivity estimates? 

    Ghyslaine Boschat, Scott Power, and Robert Colman

    Climate sensitivity refers to the amount of global surface warming that will occur in response to a doubling of atmospheric CO2 concentrations when compared to pre-industrial levels. Understanding climate sensitivity and reducing uncertainty in the estimation of climate sensitivity are therefore critical to reducing spread in projected climate change under given scenarios. The aim of this study is to estimate real-world Equilibrium Climate Sensitivity (ECS) by exploiting relationships found between observable parameters and the magnitude of climate change. We develop an emergent constraint based on surface temperature variability, which we test using preindustrial control and historical simulations from CMIP5 and CMIP6 models. We estimate the relationship between model-to-model differences (M2MDs) in ECS and M2MDs in global, tropical and tropical Pacific temperature variability, using the various measures of variability on interannual through to multidecadal timescales. We find higher correlations between MDMDs in ECS and M2MDs in the standard deviation of temperature variability in the tropics, which peaks at the decadal timescale, with larger spread in CMIP6 models. These results are then optimally combined to constrain observed temperature decadal variability and provide a distribution of real-world ECS. 

    How to cite: Boschat, G., Power, S., and Colman, R.: Can interannual to decadal variability help increase the accuracy of climate sensitivity estimates?, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11097, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11097, 2022.

    The impact of volcanic forcing on tropical precipitation is investigated in a new set of sensitivity experiments within the Max Planck Institute Grand Ensemble framework. Five ensembles are created, each containing 100 realizations for an idealized “Pinatubo-like” equatorial volcanic eruption with emissions covering a range of 2.5 - 40 Tg sulfur (S). The ensembles provide an excellent database to disentangle the influence of volcanic forcing on monsoons and tropical hydroclimate over the wide spectrum of the climate's internal variability. Monsoons are generally weaker for two years after volcanic eruptions and their weakening is a function of emissions. However, only a stronger than Pinatubo-like eruption (> 10 Tg S) leads to significant and substantial monsoon changes, and some regions (such as North and South Africa, South America and South Asia) are much more sensitive to this kind of forcing than the others. The decreased monsoon precipitation is strongly tied to the weakening of the regional tropical overturning. The reduced atmospheric net energy input at the ITCZ due to the volcanic eruption and, under negligible changes in the gross moist stability, requires a slowdown of the circulation as a consequence of less moist static energy exported away from the ascent.

    How to cite: D'Agostino, R. and Timmreck, C.: Sensitivity of regional monsoons to idealised equatorial volcanic eruption of different sulfur emission strengths, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11547, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11547, 2022.

    EGU22-11935 | Presentations | CL4.3

    Global glacier evolution over the last millennium and the influence of climate forcings on the mass balance 

    Anouk Vlug, Ben Marzeion, Matthias Prange, and Fabien Maussion

    Mass loss of glaciers and ice caps has been one of the major contributors to sea-level rise over the past century. Glaciers respond slowly to a changing climate. Therefore, glacier evolution over the past century is partly a result of prior changes in the climate, resulting both from internal variability in the climate system and changes in external forcings. Here we present a simulation of global glacier evolution over the period 850-2000 CE and assess the influence that different climate forcings have on the glacier mass balance. The glacier evolution simulation thus serves as a base for the mass balance attribution experiment.

    The Open Global Glacier Model (OGGM) was used to simulate glacier geometry and mass balance evolution of land-terminating glaciers. The dynamic simulations were forced with the full length of the Last Millennium Reanalysis (LMR), a climate timeseries covering the period 0-2000 CE, using the first part for spin-up only. The initialization of the glacier states in 850 CE was done with a calibration procedure, making use of glaciers with a relatively short memory for initializing those with a longer one.

    To assess the influence of different climate forcings (volcanic, greenhouse gases (GHG), orbital, land cover and land use, solar and anthropogenic ozone and aerosols) on glacier mass balance, simulations of the Community Earth System Model Last Millennium Ensemble (CESM-LME) are being used. The CESM-LME fully forced, single forced and 850 CE control simulations are used to force OGGM in climatic mass balance simulations. In those simulations the glacier geometries are prescribed with those from the LMR forced dynamic simulation, in order to avoid biases in the attribution caused by deviating glacier evolutions under the different forcings.

    Results show that the changes in the GHG forcing have little influence on the SMB from 850 to ~1850 CE. After that the influence becomes increasingly more negative. All other forcings that have been assessed here have positive contribution to glacier mass balance over the last millennium. Although the influence of land use and land cover change has not received a lot of attention before in this context, it has a substantial influence on global glacier mass in our simulations. However, the influence of the forcings differs strongly between regions.

    How to cite: Vlug, A., Marzeion, B., Prange, M., and Maussion, F.: Global glacier evolution over the last millennium and the influence of climate forcings on the mass balance, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11935, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11935, 2022.

    EGU22-12305 | Presentations | CL4.3

    ModE-Sim - A new medium-size AGCM ensemble to analyze climate variability in the modern era 

    Ralf Hand, Eric Samakinwa, Laura Hövel, Veronika Valler, and Stefan Brönnimann

    We introduce a 36 to 40-member ensemble of simulations with the atmospheric general circulation model ECHAM6 that is designed to form the basis for a 3-dimensional climate reconstruction dataset in the PALAEO-RA project. It covers the years 1420 to 2009, the period for which combining natural proxies such as tree rings and archives of society such as documentary data allows to perform global climate reconstructions. However, the information provided by these historical sources is usually sparse in temporal and spatial resolution. Our simulations provide the necessary background for data assimilation and thus complement the historical information by adding physical constraints implemented in the model formulation. Our experimental setup is designed to determine the range of internal climate variability under prescribed forcings. It is oriented on the PMIP4 setup with slight modifications, using realistic ocean boundary conditions (SST and sea ice cover) and radiative forcings while also accounting for uncertainties in these.

    Our presentation will give an overview of our experimental setup and show the results of the first applications. We present an evaluation of the ensemble, including measures on how well the ensemble can sample the internal variability of some variables of interest. Beyond this, we hope to stimulate a discussion on possible further applications.

    How to cite: Hand, R., Samakinwa, E., Hövel, L., Valler, V., and Brönnimann, S.: ModE-Sim - A new medium-size AGCM ensemble to analyze climate variability in the modern era, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12305, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12305, 2022.

    EGU22-12502 | Presentations | CL4.3

    The Impacts of SST-Nudging on Performance of Community Earth System Model (CESM) in Representing the Euro-Mediterranean Climate 

    Emir Toker, Mehmet Ilicak, Gokhan Danabasoglu, and Omer Lutfi Sen

    The Mediterranean Basin, including the Mediterranean Sea and the surrounding countries, is referred to as a hotspot in terms of climate change, primarily because of a basin-wide drying trend projected for its future. The Mediterranean Sea plays an important role in the climate of the basin through air-sea interactions, and it is, therefore, important to understand how it is coupled with global as well as regional atmosphere. Coarse resolution fully coupled Earth System Models (ESM) show inaccurate results in terms of sea surface temperature (SST) and precipitation over the Mediterranean Sea and Europe. Better representation of the Mediterranean Sea SST (MedSST) by ESMs is a critical issue for the Euro-Mediterranean climate.

    In this study, we conduct three simulations using the fully-coupled Community Earth System Model (CESM): i) a historical control simulation integrated for the 1850-2014 period subject to anthropogenic forcings; ii) a Mediterranean Pacemaker-I (MedP-I) experiment where MedSST is nudged to the monthly Extended Reconstructed SST (ERSST) starting from 1880; and iii) a Mediterranean Pacemaker-II (MedP-II) experiment where the MedSST is nudged to the Optimum Interpolation SST (OISST)  starting from 1980. In both pacemaker experiments, in comparison with the control simulation, nudging of the MedSST affects the poleward energy flux transported by the atmospheric latent and dry heat, and changes the total meridional energy flux by more than ±0.1 PW over lower latitudes. Similarly, net radiation flux at the surface is changed by about ±2 W/m2 over the Mediterranean Basin. The fidelity of the nudging method was investigated by comparing solutions from MedP-I and MedP-II with respective fields from the control simulation and those from observations, i.e., World Ocean Atlas, Hadley Centre Sea Ice and SST, Climate Prediction Center, and European Observations for the 1981 - 2010 period. The control simulation shows higher surface temperatures than observations and overestimates the total precipitation over Euro-Mediterranean and Turkey. In contrast, both MedP-I and MedP-II show improvements in reproducing total precipitation over the Euro-Mediterranean region, Turkey, and at the entrance of the Gibraltar Strait. While MedP-I has improvements over the northeast Europe and the southern Mediterranean Basin regarding the surface temperatures, MedP-II has some improvements over Turkey and at the coastal areas of the Mediterranean Sea. MedP-II has more improvements for the SST and sea surface salinity (SSS) values over the Mediterranean Sea and the Black Sea compared to MedP-I. Additionally, MedP-II has a better representation of the North Atlantic SSS bias compared to the control simulation, while both MedP-I and MedP-II have some SST improvements for different areas over the North Atlantic. Core climate indices defined by the European Climate Assessment and Dataset project are calculated using simulated daily parameters and results are compared with the Global Land Data Assimilation System dataset. Accordingly, MedP-II is found to have improvements over more areas, especially for the indices calculated by using daily precipitation. Overall, we conclude that Mediterranean Sea Pacemaker simulations improve our understanding of how the Mediterranean Sea impacts the surface temperature and precipitation over the Euro-Mediterranean.

    How to cite: Toker, E., Ilicak, M., Danabasoglu, G., and Sen, O. L.: The Impacts of SST-Nudging on Performance of Community Earth System Model (CESM) in Representing the Euro-Mediterranean Climate, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12502, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12502, 2022.

    EGU22-13097 | Presentations | CL4.3 | Highlight

    Exploring the impact of climate change for biological climate variables using observations and multi-model initial condition large ensembles 

    Jared Bowden, Laura Suarez-Gutierrez, Adam J. Terando, Madeleine Rubenstein, Shawn Carter, Sarah Weiskopf, and Hai Thanh Nguyen

    Species are expected to shift their distributions to higher latitudes, greater elevations, and deeper depths in response to climate change, reflecting an underlying hypothesis that species will move to cooler locations.  However, there is significant variability in observed species range shifts and differences in exposure to climate change may explain some of the variability amongst species.  But this requires identifying regions that have experienced detectable changes in those aspects of the climate system that species are sensitive to. 

    To better understand species exposure to climate change, we estimate the time of emergence of climate change for 19 biologically relevant climate variables using observations and initial condition large ensembles from five different climate models.   The time of emergence (ToE) is calculated using Signal/Noise (S/N) thresholds.  The S/N threshold applied in this study is >=2, but this threshold can be easily modified to represent species that are more or less sensitive to climate change.  Preliminary findings from the initial condition large ensembles indicates the strongest emergence for the temperature metrics within the tropical oceanic regions in the absence of upwelling. The earliest emergence over the oceans is found within the western warm pool of the Pacific.  Notable places that haven’t emerged for the temperature metrics include both the North Atlantic and Pacific.  The ToE of a climate change signal for the temperature metrics over land is spatially complex, which may partially explain the complex observed range shifts for terrestrial species.  For instance, multiple initial condition large ensembles indicate a signal has emerge in the most recent decades only for the western and northeastern parts United States.

    How to cite: Bowden, J., Suarez-Gutierrez, L., Terando, A. J., Rubenstein, M., Carter, S., Weiskopf, S., and Nguyen, H. T.: Exploring the impact of climate change for biological climate variables using observations and multi-model initial condition large ensembles, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13097, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13097, 2022.

    EGU22-504 | Presentations | CL3.2.8

    Analogues of a historical extreme-impact event and their implication for climate change risk assessment 

    Henrique Moreno Dumont Goulart, Karin van der Wiel, Christian Folberth, Juraj Balkovic, and Bart van den Hurk

    Meteorological conditions can affect crop development and yield in multiple and non-linear ways. Many studies have investigated the influence of climate change on crops by simulating crop responses to the most likely mean climatic projections in the future. However, this approach can potentially overlook changes in extreme-impact events, highly relevant for society, due to their low probability of occurrence and to potential different behaviour with respect to the mean conditions. One way of focusing on extreme-impact events is through the use of physical climate storylines. Storylines enable the construction of self-sustained and physically-plausible chain of events that recreate historical events from source to impact. In addition, storylines allow the exploration of future analogues of the historical events under different circumstances to account for externalities, such as climate change. In this experiment, we use physical climate storylines to reconstruct a historical extreme-impact event and to explore potential analogues of the same event under climate change influence. We develop two types of analogues, event-analogues and impact-analogues, and compare how the future manifestation of the historical event depends on the analogue definition. We use soybean production in the US as an example, with the year of 2012 being the historical extreme event. Based on a random forest model, we link the historical event to meteorological variables to identify the conditions associated with the failure event. To quantify the frequency of occurrence of the different analogues under climate change, we apply the trained random forest model to large ensembles of climate projections from the EC-Earth global climate model. We find that the 2012 failure event is linked to low precipitation levels, and high temperature and diurnal temperature range (DTR) levels during July and August. The analogues of the historical event greatly diverge: while event-analogues of the 2012 season are rare and not expected to increase, impact-analogues show a significant increase in occurrence frequency under global warming, but for different combinations of the meteorological drivers than experienced in 2012. The results highlight the importance of considering the impact perspective when investigating future extreme crop yields.

    How to cite: Moreno Dumont Goulart, H., van der Wiel, K., Folberth, C., Balkovic, J., and van den Hurk, B.: Analogues of a historical extreme-impact event and their implication for climate change risk assessment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-504, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-504, 2022.

    EGU22-704 | Presentations | CL3.2.8 | Highlight

    Current and future risks of unprecedented UK droughts 

    Wilson Chan, Theodore Shepherd, Katie Facer-Childs, Geoff Darch, Nigel Arnell, and Karin van der Wiel

    The UK has experienced recurring periods of hydrological droughts in the past and their frequency and severity are predicted to increase with climate change. However, quantifying the risks of extreme droughts is challenging given the short observational record, the multivariate nature of droughts and large internal variability of the climate system. We use EC-Earth time-slice large ensembles, which consist of 2000 years of data each for present day, 2°C and 3°C conditions, to drive the GR6J hydrological model at UK river catchments to obtain a large set of plausible droughts. Applying the UNSEEN (UNprecedented Simulation of Extreme Events using ENsembles) approach show an increasing chance of unprecedented dry summers with future warming and highlight the chance of an unprecedented drought with characteristics exceeding that of past severe droughts.

    This study also aims to bridge the probabilistic UNSEEN approach with “bottom-up” storyline approaches. Physical climate storylines of preconditioned compound drought events are created by searching within the large ensemble for events resembling specific conditions that have led to past severe droughts and are relevant for water resources planning. This includes conditions such as 1) dry autumns followed by dry winters, 2) consecutive dry winters (both of which are relevant for slow-responding catchments), and 3) dry springs followed by dry summers (relevant for fast-responding catchments). The storylines can be used to understand the conditions leading to unprecedented droughts and the impacts of future droughts triggered by the same conditions. Unprecedented drought sequences and synthetic experiments conditioned on these storylines can be used to stress-test hydrological systems and inform decision-making.

    How to cite: Chan, W., Shepherd, T., Facer-Childs, K., Darch, G., Arnell, N., and van der Wiel, K.: Current and future risks of unprecedented UK droughts, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-704, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-704, 2022.

    EGU22-796 | Presentations | CL3.2.8 | Highlight

    Have there been previous heat extremes greater than the June 2021 western North America event? 

    Vikki Thompson, Alan Kennedy-Asser, Eunice Lo, Emily Vosper, Dann Mitchell, and Oliver Andrews

    In June 2021 western North America experienced a record-breaking heatwave, outside the distribution of previously observed temperatures. Our research asks whether other regions across the world have experienced so far outside their natural variability - and have there been greater heat extremes.  

    In our novel assessment of heat extremes we characterise the relative intensity of an event as the number of standard deviations from the mean, finding the western North America heatwave is remarkable, outside four single deviations. Throughout the globe, where we have reliable data, only 5 other heatwaves were found to be more extreme since 1960. We can also identify regions which, by chance, have not had a recent extreme heatwave, and may be less prepared for future events. 

    Using extreme value analysis the western North America heat extreme has been shown to be outside the previous distribution of extremes for the region. We can test if this is unique, or if previous events show similar. 

    By assessing the numbers of regions globally exceeding various thresholds, in terms of standard deviation from the mean, we can show that extremes appear to increase in line with changes to the mean-state of the distribution of the climate, and projected increase in extremes aligns with projected warming.   

    How to cite: Thompson, V., Kennedy-Asser, A., Lo, E., Vosper, E., Mitchell, D., and Andrews, O.: Have there been previous heat extremes greater than the June 2021 western North America event?, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-796, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-796, 2022.

    EGU22-1676 | Presentations | CL3.2.8

    xWEI – A novel cross-scale index for extreme precipitation events 

    Paul Voit and Maik Heistermann

    How can the extremity of an rainfall event be quantified? Extreme rainfall events are rarely homogeneous regarding rainfall intensities and the spatio-temporal distribution of rainfall can cause flooding on different scales. While small, mountainous catchments can react to short but high-intensity precipitation with flash floods, the same event can also trigger pluvial or fluvial floods on a spatially bigger scale with lower intensity precipitation, leading to compound flood events. Consequently, these cross-scale characteristics of extreme rainfall events are an important factor that should be considered regarding hydrological response or disaster management.

    To quantify the extremity of rainfall events while considering the spatial and temporal distribution of rainfall, we introduce a new index, xWEI, based on the Weather Extremity Index (WEI). By using precipitation radar data with a high spatial and temporal resolution, we analyzed and evaluated extreme rainfall events in Germany and were able to show essential differences in the performance of the classical approach (WEI) and xWEI. 

    This novel cross-scale index, in combination with modern high-resolution precipitation radar data, enables a better identification of extreme events and their characteristics and helps to link them to their impacts.

    How to cite: Voit, P. and Heistermann, M.: xWEI – A novel cross-scale index for extreme precipitation events, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1676, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1676, 2022.

    EGU22-2172 | Presentations | CL3.2.8 | Highlight

    Flood responses to increases in rainfall extremes vary depending on event severity 

    Manuela Irene Brunner, Daniel Swain, Raul Wood, Florian Willkofer, James Done, Eric Gilleland, and Ralf Ludwig

    There is clear evidence that precipitation extremes will increase in a warming climate. However, the hydrologic response to this increase in heavy precipitation is more uncertain - and there is little historical evidence for systematic increases in flood magnitude despite observed increases in precipitation extremes. These dual realities yield a paradox with considerable practical relevance: will the divergence between extreme precipitation increases and flood severity persist, or are land-surface processes at work?  Here, we investigate how flood magnitudes in hydrological Bavaria change in response to warming using a single model initial condition large climate ensemble coupled to a hydrological model (hydro-SMILE). We find that there exists a severity threshold above which precipitation increases clearly yield increased flood magnitudes, and below which flood magnitude is modulated by land surface processes. Our findings highlight the importance of large ensembles and help reconcile climatological and hydrological perspectives on changing flood risk in a warming climate.

    How to cite: Brunner, M. I., Swain, D., Wood, R., Willkofer, F., Done, J., Gilleland, E., and Ludwig, R.: Flood responses to increases in rainfall extremes vary depending on event severity, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2172, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2172, 2022.

    EGU22-2228 | Presentations | CL3.2.8

    Developing low-likelihood climate storylines for extreme precipitation using ensemble boosting 

    Claudia Gessner, Erich M. Fischer, Urs Beyerle, and Reto Knutti

    Heavy precipitation events as the one in western Germany and the Benelux countries in July 2021 destroy the local infrastructure and numerous fatalities. Due to the lack of long homogenous climate data and methodological framework, it is uncertain how intense precipitation extremes could get. We address these questions by developing storylines of the rarest precipitation events. We here generate large samples of reinitialized heavy rainfall events starting from the most extreme events in an initial condition large ensemble for the near future, carried out with CESM2. In an approach referred to as ensemble boosting, we first reinitialize the most extreme 3-day precipitation events to estimate how anomalous they could get. We find that the most extreme precipitation events can be substantially exceeded in the boosted ensembles for different regions across the world. Second, we evaluate whether the model can reproduce analogues of the precipitation event in July 2021 and re-initialize these events to analyze how this event type could have evolved and whether it could have become even more intense. In doing so, the ensemble boosting method provides storylines of heavy rainfall development beyond the observational record, which can be used to generate worst-case scenarios and stress test the socioeconomic system.

    How to cite: Gessner, C., Fischer, E. M., Beyerle, U., and Knutti, R.: Developing low-likelihood climate storylines for extreme precipitation using ensemble boosting, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2228, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2228, 2022.

    EGU22-5606 | Presentations | CL3.2.8

    Ruffling feathers: An appraisal of tail flood losses using grey swan scenarios in London, UK 

    Antonia MacDonald and Philip Oldham

    There are several tools for assessing potential future insurance flood losses in the UK, including catastrophe models which seek to generate an annualised view of flood risk losses. These catastrophe models include plausible high impact and low frequency flood events in their stochastic event sets. The addition of events which are generally considered implausible, or grey swan scenarios, is useful to increase understanding of how re/insurers will perform should our understanding of what is plausible be incorrect.

    The Thames Barrier has high levels of redundancy by design and it is generally considered implausible that the barrier would completely fail to operate. We propose three increasingly extreme scenarios for flooding in London as a consequence of the Thames Barrier and other defences across London failing. In all scenarios we assume a 1 in 250-year water level from coastal flooding, well within the standard of protection offered by defences through the city.

    The following defence failure scenarios are then modelled using a coupled 1D-2D model: 1) the Thames Barrier is open but the river defences remain intact with only overtopping occurring; 2) the Thames Barrier is open and defences are breached upstream of the barrier; and 3) a worst case scenario composite of several flood event scenarios, where for upstream reaches of the barrier, breach and overtopping occur with the barrier open and for downstream reaches, breach and overtopping occur with the barrier closed.

    JBA’s catastrophe model for the UK probabilistically models loss from river, surface water and coastal flooding. The model comprises 2D hydraulic modelled hazard maps at 5 metre resolution, a stochastic event set of 106,424 events generated from extreme value statistical analysis, and detailed vulnerability data derived from the Multi-Coloured Manual. The catastrophe model includes an occurrence exceedance probability curve for insurable residential properties, providing the wider context for estimating the loss return period of the scenario events. We present the modelled losses and the estimated loss return periods for the grey swan scenarios and make available the model for re/insurers for stress testing. The loss return periods for the three scenarios are: 1/50, 1/358, and 1/8813.

    How to cite: MacDonald, A. and Oldham, P.: Ruffling feathers: An appraisal of tail flood losses using grey swan scenarios in London, UK, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5606, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5606, 2022.

    EGU22-5900 | Presentations | CL3.2.8

    Understanding extreme events with multi-thousand member high-resolution global atmospheric simulations 

    Peter Watson, Sarah Sparrow, William Ingram, Simon Wilson, Giuseppe Zappa, Emanuele Bevacqua, Nicholas Leach, David Sexton, Richard Jones, Marie Drouard, Daniel Mitchell, David Wallom, Tim Woollings, and Myles Allen

    Multi-thousand member climate model simulations are highly valuable for showing characteristics of extreme weather events in historical and future climates. However, until now, studies using such a physically-based approach have been limited to using models with a resolution much coarser than the most modern systems. We have developed a global atmospheric model with ~60km resolution that can be run in the climateprediction.net distributed computing system to produce such large datasets. This resolution is finer than that of many current global climate models and sufficient for good simulation of extratropical synoptic features such as storms. It also allows many extratropical extreme weather events to be simulated without requiring regional downscaling. We will show that this model's simulation of extratropical winter weather is competitive with that in other state-of-the-art models. We will also present the first results generated by this system. One application has been the production of ~2000 member simulations based on sea surface temperatures in severe future winters produced in the UK Climate Projections 2018 dataset, generating large numbers of examples of plausible extreme wet and warm UK seasons. Another is showing the increasing spatial extent of precipitation extremes in the Northern Hemisphere extratropics. 

    How to cite: Watson, P., Sparrow, S., Ingram, W., Wilson, S., Zappa, G., Bevacqua, E., Leach, N., Sexton, D., Jones, R., Drouard, M., Mitchell, D., Wallom, D., Woollings, T., and Allen, M.: Understanding extreme events with multi-thousand member high-resolution global atmospheric simulations, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5900, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5900, 2022.

    EGU22-5949 | Presentations | CL3.2.8

    Towards forecast-based attribution of isolated extreme events: perturbed initial condition simulations of the Pacific Northwest heatwave 

    Nicholas J. Leach, Chris Roberts, Tim Palmer, Myles R. Allen, and Antje Weisheimer

    Here we explore the use of “counterfactual” weather forecasts, using perturbed initial condition runs of a state-of-the-art high-resolution coupled ocean-atmosphere-sea-ice ensemble NWP system, for the attribution of extreme weather events to anthropogenic climate change. We use the “record-shattering” heatwave experienced by Western North America during summer 2021 as a case study - though our forecast-based approach is applicable to other events.

    Since we cannot make direct observations of a world without human influence on climate, all approaches to extreme event attribution involve some kind of modelling, either statistical or numerical. Both approaches struggle with the most extreme weather events, which are poorly represented in both observational records and the climate models normally used for attribution studies. Recognising the compromises involved, researchers have traditionally relied on comparing results from several different approaches to assess the robustness of conclusions. We argue that a better approach would be to use initialised numerical models that have demonstrated their ability to simulate the event in question through a successful forecast.

    This work represents a continuation of a previous EGU talk and published study (https://meetingorganizer.copernicus.org/EGU21/EGU21-5731.html & https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2112087118), in which we used demonstrably successful weather forecasts to estimate the direct impact of increased CO2 concentrations (one component, but not the entirety, of human influence) on the 2019 European winter heatwave. 

    In the previous and current work we use the operational ECMWF ensemble prediction system. This state-of-the-art weather forecast system is run at a much higher resolution (Tco639 / 18km) than most climate model simulations - important as even small reductions in resolution often change the representation of extreme events in numerical models. Using a reliable forecast ensemble allows us to quantify the associated uncertainties in our attribution analyses.

    We have built on this work with the aim of providing a more complete estimate of the human influence on an isolated extreme event. In addition to the reduction of CO2 concentrations back to pre-industrial levels, we now also remove an estimate of the human influence on 3D ocean temperatures since the pre-industrial period from the initial state of the forecast model. These changes allow the model to provide a “counterfactual” picture of what an extreme event might have looked like if it had occurred before human influence on the climate.

    Using this perturbed initial condition approach, we produce counterfactual forecasts of the Pacific Northwest heatwave at the end of June 2021. This event broke records throughout Western North America, including a new Canadian high temperature record of 49.6°C, shattering the previous record by almost 5°C. The heatwave was driven by a combination of meteorological factors, including an omega block and water vapour transport at the synoptic scale, and high solar irradiation and subsidence at the meso-scale (research into the drivers is ongoing). Crucially, the event was well-predicted by weather forecast models over a week in advance.

    We estimate the human contribution to this exceptional heatwave by comparing our counterfactual forecasts to the operational forecasts that successfully predicted the event.

    How to cite: Leach, N. J., Roberts, C., Palmer, T., Allen, M. R., and Weisheimer, A.: Towards forecast-based attribution of isolated extreme events: perturbed initial condition simulations of the Pacific Northwest heatwave, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5949, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5949, 2022.

    EGU22-9259 | Presentations | CL3.2.8

    The challenges of assessing low-likelihood temperature extremes with empirical data of past events 

    Joel Zeder, Sebastian Sippel, and Erich Fischer

    Primer: The recent Pacific Northwest heatwave in June 2021 is widely considered a prime example of a record shattering low-likelihood extreme event, exceeding previous annual temperature maxima by large margins. The event intensity was generally perceived to be far beyond what was to be expected from historical data. It has been argued that the event would have been deemed essentially impossible, i.e. having an infinite return period, if estimated based on the historical record, even when taking the warming trend into account. This raises the question whether the non-stationary extreme value modelling approach, a widely used probabilistic framework applied to assess the likelihood of such extremes, yields systematically biased estimates determining the tail characteristics of the distribution.

    Research objective: We here aim at understanding why the intensity of the event exceeds the upper bound of the estimated distribution when only using data up to the year before the event. We quantify the contribution of a multitude of factors for a generalized extreme value distribution GEV with a non-stationary parametrization to be too conservative in the characterisation of tail events, especially in the context of heatwaves. We analyse how physical properties of heat extremes materialise in statistical effects contributing to potential biases in the GEV parameter estimation, as well as some inherent deficiencies of the GEV in its application to heat extremes with limited sample size due to asymptotic properties.

    Data & Methods: In order to test the respective hypotheses, we analyse climate model output of single model initial condition large ensembles (SMILEs), primarily an ensemble of 84 transient historical and RCP8.5 simulations performed with the Community Earth System Model CESM1.2. The results are further verified using additional CMIP6 models and ERA5 reanalysis.

    Preliminary results and outlook: We find that non-stationary return period estimates tend to be systematically biased high when estimated on the historical records up to a year before a record-shattering event, which is a standard practice in applications of this framework. We here disentangle the reason responsible for potential biases in the estiamtes. We find that even in case of stationary extremes, the asymptotic nature of the GEV distribution applied to finite data favours an underestimation of the shape parameter, which has substantial effects on the characterisation of the tail, inducing biases in estimates of widely used tail measures (exceedance probabilities, return periods), and derivatives thereof (risk ratios, fraction of attributable risk). The conditional effects of non-stationary components like global warming on heatwave intensity are potentially further underestimated due to internal variability and noise in the covariates. In the light of these shortcomings, we provide evidence for an improvement of the GEV framework by learning from climate model output about the effect of further process variables (high pressure patterns and soil moisture deficiencies).

    How to cite: Zeder, J., Sippel, S., and Fischer, E.: The challenges of assessing low-likelihood temperature extremes with empirical data of past events, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9259, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9259, 2022.

    EGU22-10405 | Presentations | CL3.2.8 | Highlight

    2021 North American Heat Wave Fueled by Climate-Change-Driven Nonlinear Interactions 

    Samuel Bartusek, Kai Kornhuber, and Mingfang Ting

    Extreme heat conditions in the Pacific Northwest US and Southwestern Canada in summer 2021 were of unprecedented severity. Constituting a 5-sigma anomaly, the heatwave affected millions, likely led to thousands of excess deaths, and promoted wildfires that decreased air quality throughout the continent. Even as global warming causes an increase in the severity and frequency of heatwaves both locally and globally, this event’s magnitude went beyond what many would have considered plausible under current climate conditions. It is thus important to attribute such an exceptional event to specific physical drivers and assess its relation to climate change, to improve projection and prediction of future extreme heat events. A particularly pressing question is whether any changing variability of atmospheric dynamics or land-atmosphere interaction is implicated in amplifying current and future heat extremes. Using ERA5 reanalysis, we find that slow- and fast-moving components of the atmospheric circulation interacted to trigger extreme geopotential height anomalies during this event. We additionally identify anomalously low soil moisture levels as a critical event driver: we find that land-atmosphere feedbacks drove nonlinear amplification of its temperature anomaly by 40% (contributing 3K of the 10K peak regional-mean anomaly), catalyzed by multidecadal temperature and soil moisture trends. This is supported by a model experiment demonstrating that soil moisture interaction may increase the likelihood of the observed monthly-scale regional temperature anomaly by O(10)x. We estimate that over the four recent decades of gradual warming, the event’s temperature anomaly has become 10–100 times more likely, transforming from a ~10,000-year to a 100–1,000-year occurrence. Its likelihood continues to increase, roughly exponentially, and it is projected to recur ~20-yearly by 2060 based on continued warming at a constant rate. Our results therefore suggest an important role of atmospheric dynamics and nonlinear land-atmosphere interactions in driving this exceptional heat extreme, promoted by a long-term warming trend due to anthropogenic climate change that will continue to increase the likelihood of such extremes under continued emissions.

    How to cite: Bartusek, S., Kornhuber, K., and Ting, M.: 2021 North American Heat Wave Fueled by Climate-Change-Driven Nonlinear Interactions, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10405, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10405, 2022.

    EGU22-11726 | Presentations | CL3.2.8

    Towards a more comprehensive assessment of the intensity of European Heat Waves 1979-2019 

    Florian N. Becker, Andreas H. Fink, Peter Bissolli, and Joaquim G. Pinto

    Heat waves are among the most dangerous natural hazards worldwide. Central Europe has been affected by record-breaking heat waves in recent decades, especially in 2003, 2018 and 2019. Four frequently used indices are chosen in this study to diagnose heat waves in Europe based on both station data and ERA5 reanalysis: the Heat Wave Magnitude Index daily (HWMId), the Excess Heat Factor (EHF), the Wet Bulb Globe Temperature (WBGT) and the Universal Thermal Climate Index (UTCI). To improve the quantification of the events and comparability of the four indices, a normalisation is applied and the three metrics intensity, duration, spatial extent were combined by a cumulative intensity measure. The large-scale characteristics of the 1979 to 2019 European heat waves are analysed from a Lagrangian perspective, by daily tracking of contiguous heat wave areas. The events were ranked and visualized with bubble plots. The role of different meteorological input parameters like temperature, radiation, humidity and wind speed is explored to understand their contribution to the extremeness of heat waves and the variance in time series of the heat wave indices.

    As expected, temperature explains the largest variance in all indices, but humidity is nearly as important in WBGT and wind speed plays a substantial role in UTCI. While the 2010 Russian heat wave is by far the most extreme event in duration and intensity in all indices, the 2018 heat wave was comparable in size for EHF, WBGT and UTCI. Interestingly, the well-known 2003 central European heat wave was only the fifth and tenth strongest in cumulative intensity in WBGT and UTCI, respectively. The June and July 2019 heat waves were very intense, but short-lived, thus not belonging to the top heat waves in Europe when duration and areal extent are taken into account. Overall, the proposed normalised indices and the multi-metric assessment of large-scale heat waves allow for a more robust description of their extremeness and will be helpful to assess heat waves worldwide and in CMIP6 climate projections.

    Applying the normalization to the four indices and deriving the large-scale metrics of intensity, spatial extent and duration, as proposed in the present study, will facilitate trend studies using different sources of observations and models. As the combination of duration and intensity over large areas are responsible for the most severe health and economic impacts, interdisciplinary research (e.g. links to health effects) is recommended starting to better quantify the impacts of heat waves in a warming climate.

    How to cite: Becker, F. N., Fink, A. H., Bissolli, P., and Pinto, J. G.: Towards a more comprehensive assessment of the intensity of European Heat Waves 1979-2019, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11726, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11726, 2022.

    EGU22-12579 | Presentations | CL3.2.8

    Heatwaves under different future climate scenarios and impacts on children 

    James Mollard, Sian F. Henley, and Massimo Bollasina

    Periods of prolonged extreme warm temperatures, or heatwaves, have been shown to have significant impacts on human health, in particular affecting the young and old disproportionately. Observations over the past century show that the severity, frequency and duration of these heatwaves are increasing as global temperatures rise, and model simulations suggest there will be further increases in these characteristics in the future. 

    We use a range of CMIP6 ScenarioMIP future simulations to show how heatwave characteristics change both globally and regionally. We show how these changes differ depending on the Shared Socio-economic Pathway (SSP) taken, highlighting the sensitivity of heatwaves to both global and regional warming in each scenario. The work also explores the non-linear trend between warming and heatwave characteristics, and how they vary in different future scenarios. The results suggest that the pathway followed has significant influence on heatwave attributes, and that attempting to limit changes by a set measure cannot be done by simply restricting the level of future warming to an agreed, designated temperature, such as the “1.5C above pre-industrial” figure often used in policy.  

    Finally, we present how this work is been utilised in the production of the Children’s Climate Risk Index (CCRI), which provides the first comprehensive view of children’s exposure and vulnerability to the impacts of climate change. We also aim to highlight how indices like this are being used to help prepare resources for future issues related to climate events.  

    How to cite: Mollard, J., Henley, S. F., and Bollasina, M.: Heatwaves under different future climate scenarios and impacts on children, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12579, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12579, 2022.

    EGU22-753 | Presentations | CR2.9

    3D sequential data assimilation in Elmer/Ice with Stokes 

    Samuel Cook and Fabien Gillet-Chaulet

    Providing suitable initial states is a long-standing problem in numerical modelling of glaciers and ice sheets, as well as in other areas of the geosciences, due to the frequent lack of observations. This is particularly acute in glaciology, where important parameters such as the underlying bed may be only very sparsely observed or even completely unobserved. Glaciological models also often require lengthy relaxation periods to dissipate incompatibilities between input datasets gathered over different timeframes, which may lead to the modelled initial state diverging significantly from the real state of the glacier, with consequent effects on the accuracy of the simulation. Sequential data assimilation using an ensemble offers one possibility for resolving both these issues: by running the model over a period for which various observational datasets are available and loading observations into the model at the time they were gathered, the model state can be brought into good agreement with the real glacier state at the end of the observational window. The mean values of the ensemble for unknown parameters, such as the bed, then also represent best guesses for the true parameter values. This assimilated model state can then be used to initialise prognostic runs without introducing model artefacts or a distorted picture of the actual glacier.

    In this study, we present a framework for conducting sequential data assimilation and retrieving the bed of a glacier in a 3D setting of the open-source, finite-element glacier flow model, Elmer/Ice, and solving the Stokes equations rather than using the shallow shelf approximation. Assimilation is undertaken using the open-source PDAF library developed at the Alfred Wegener Institute. We demonstrate that the set-up allows us to accurately retrieve the bed of a synthetic glacier and present our plans to extend it to a real-world example.

    How to cite: Cook, S. and Gillet-Chaulet, F.: 3D sequential data assimilation in Elmer/Ice with Stokes, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-753, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-753, 2022.

    EGU22-896 | Presentations | CR2.9

    Uncertainty quantification for melt rate parameters in ice shelves using simulation-based inference 

    Guy Moss, Vjeran Višnjević, Cornelius Schröder, Jakob Macke, and Reinhard Drews

    Mass loss from the Antarctic ice sheet is dominated by the integrity of the ice shelves that buttress it. The evolution and stability of ice shelves is dependent on a variety of parameters that cannot be directly observed, such as basal melt and ice rheology. Constraining these parameters is of great importance in making predictions of the future changes in ice shelves that have a quantifiable uncertainty. This inference task is difficult in practice as the number of unknown parameters is large, observations are often sparse, and the computational cost of ice flow models is high.

    We aim to develop a framework for inferring joint distributions of mass balance and rheological parameters of ice shelves from observations such as ice geometry, surface velocities, and radar isochrones. Here, we begin by inferring a posterior distribution over basal melt parameters in along-flow sections of synthetic and real world ice shelves (Roi Baudouin). We use the technique of simulation-based inference (SBI), a machine learning framework for performing Bayesian inference when the likelihood function is intractable. The inference procedure relies on the availability of a simulator to model the dynamics of the ice shelves. For this we use the Shallow Shelf Approximation (SSA) implemented in the Python library Icepack.  First, we show that by combining these two tools we can recover the underlying parameters of synthetic 2D data with meaningful uncertainty estimates. In a second step, we apply our method to real observations and get estimates for the basal melt rates which are coherent with the data when running the forward model over a centennial timescale.



    How to cite: Moss, G., Višnjević, V., Schröder, C., Macke, J., and Drews, R.: Uncertainty quantification for melt rate parameters in ice shelves using simulation-based inference, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-896, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-896, 2022.

    EGU22-2061 | Presentations | CR2.9

    Assimilation of CryoSat-2 radar Freeboard data in a global ocean-sea ice modelling system. 

    Aliette Chenal, Charles-Emmanuel Testut, Florent Garnier, Parent Laurent, and Garric Gilles

    Sea ice is a key element in our climate system, and it is very sensitive to the current observed climate change. Sea ice volume is a sensitive indicator of the health of Arctic although very challenging to estimate precisely since it is a combination of sea ice area and sea ice thickness. Arctic sea ice volume has decreased by as much as 75% at the end of the summer season if compared with the conditions 40 years ago. The ongoing decline of Arctic sea ice exposes the ocean to anomalous surface heat and freshwater fluxes that can have potential implication for the Arctic region and beyond, for the general oceanic circulation itself.

    For more than a decade, Mercator Ocean International develops and produces Global Ocean Reanalysis with a 1/4° resolution system. Based on the NEMO modelling platform, observations are assimilated by a reduced-order Kalman filter. In-situ CORA database, altimetric data, sea surface temperature, and sea ice concentration are jointly assimilated to constrain the ocean and sea ice model.

    In previous reanalysis, long-term sea ice volume drift has been observed in the Arctic. To obtain a better constraint on the sea ice thickness, Cryosat-2 radar Freeboard data are assimilated jointly with the sea ice concentration in a multidata/multivariate sea ice analysis. The coupled ocean and ice assimilation system runs on a 7-day cycle, using IAU (Incremental Analysis Update) and a 4D increment. The “white ocean” is modelled with the multi-categories LIM3.6 sea ice numerical model. The aim of this study is to initiate the development of the future operational multi-variate and multi-data sea ice analysis system with freeboard radar assimilation.

    After describing this global sea ice reanalysis system, we present results on the abilities of this configuration to reproduce sea ice extent and volume interannual variability in both hemispheres. Comparisons between experiments with and without assimilation show that the joint assimilation of CryoSat-2 radar freeboard and sea ice concentration reduces most of model biases of sea ice thickness, e.g., in the north of the Canadian Arctic Archipelago and in the Beaufort Sea in the Arctic. Moreover, radar freeboard assimilation does not hinder the good results in simulating sea ice extent previously obtained with the assimilation of only sea ice concentration. Validation with non-assimilated satellite data and in-situ data supports these findings. Lastly, snow depth significantly influences the Freeboard measurement: this study also reveals the importance of including snow information on freeboard retrieval and on the ice volume assimilation methodology.

    These experiments take place in a context of increasing interest in polar regions and prepare the launch of Copernicus Sentinel expansion satellite missions.

    How to cite: Chenal, A., Testut, C.-E., Garnier, F., Laurent, P., and Gilles, G.: Assimilation of CryoSat-2 radar Freeboard data in a global ocean-sea ice modelling system., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2061, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2061, 2022.

    EGU22-2535 | Presentations | CR2.9

    Quantifying Holocene Accumulation Rates from Ice-Core Dated Internal Layers from Ice-Penetrating Radar Data over the West Antarctic Ice Sheet 

    Julien Bodart, Robert Bingham, Duncan Young, Donald Blankenship, and David Vaughan

    Modelling the past and future evolution of the West Antarctic Ice Sheet (WAIS) to climate and ocean forcing is challenged by the availability and quality of observed palaeo boundary conditions. Aside from point-based geochronological measurements, the only available proxy to query past ice-sheet processes on large spatial scales is Internal Reflecting Horizons (IRHs) as sounded by ice-penetrating radar. When isochronal, IRHs can be used to determine palaeo-accumulation rates and patterns, as previously demonstrated using shallow, centennially dated layers. Whilst similar efforts using deeper IRHs have previously been conducted over the East Antarctic Plateau where ice-flow is slow and ice thickness has been stable through time, much less is known of millennial-scale accumulation rates over the West Antarctic plateau due to challenging ice dynamical conditions in the downstream section of the ice sheet. Using deep and spatially extensive ice-core dated IRHs over Pine Island and Thwaites glaciers and a local layer approximation model, we quantify Holocene accumulation rates over the slow-flowing parts of these sensitive catchments. The results from the one-dimensional model are also compared with modern accumulation rates from observational and modelled datasets to investigate changes in accumulation rates and patterns between the Holocene and the present. The outcome of this work is that together with present and centennial-scale accumulation rates, our results can help determine whether a trend in accumulation rates exists between the Holocene and the present and thus test to what extent these glaciers are controlled by ice dynamics rather than changes in accumulation rates.

    How to cite: Bodart, J., Bingham, R., Young, D., Blankenship, D., and Vaughan, D.: Quantifying Holocene Accumulation Rates from Ice-Core Dated Internal Layers from Ice-Penetrating Radar Data over the West Antarctic Ice Sheet, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2535, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2535, 2022.

    EGU22-3743 | Presentations | CR2.9

    Numerical modelling of ice stream fabrics: Implications for recrystallization processes and basal slip conditions 

    Daniel Richards, Sam Pegler, and Sandra Piazolo

    Accurately predicting ice crystal fabrics is key to understanding the processes and deformation in ice-sheets. Here we use SpecCAF, a continuum fabric evolution model validated against laboratory experiments, to predict the fabric evolution with an active ice stream. This is done by predicting the fabrics at the East Greenland Ice core Project (EGRIP) site. We do this using satellite data and inferred particle paths, combined with the shallow ice approximation (with basal slip) to infer a leading order approximation for the deformation through the ice sheet. We find that SpecCAF is able to predict the patterns observed at EGRIP - a girdle/horizontal maxima fabric perpendicular to the flow direction. By reducing the rate of rotational recrystallization in the model we are also able to predict the fabric strength at EGRIP. This suggests the effect of rotational recrystallization on the fabric may be primarily strain-rate/stress dependent. These results show SpecCAF can be applied to real-world conditions and provide insights into the deformation and basal-conditions of the ice sheet. As the model only considers deformation and recrystallization through dislocation creep, the results imply that - for the ice stream modelled - no other process is significantly influencing both the produced ice fabric and the deformation. We find that the model gives best results for full slip at the base of the ice sheet, implying that the level of sliding at the base of the ice sheet in the North Greenland Ice stream may be very high. The methodology used here can be extended to other ice core locations in Greenland and Antarctica.

    How to cite: Richards, D., Pegler, S., and Piazolo, S.: Numerical modelling of ice stream fabrics: Implications for recrystallization processes and basal slip conditions, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3743, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3743, 2022.

    EGU22-4027 | Presentations | CR2.9

    Basal Properties of the Filchner-Ronne Sector of Antarctica from Inverse Modeling and Comparison with Ice-Penetrating Radar Data 

    Michael Wolovick, Lea-Sophie Höyns, Thomas Kleiner, Niklas Nickel, Veit Helm, and Angelika Humbert

    Lubrication by subglacial water or saturated subglacial sediments is crucial to controlling the movement of fast-flowing outlet glaciers and ice streams.  However, the subglacial environment is difficult to observe directly.  Here, we combine inverse modeling with ice-penetrating radar observations to characterize the ice sheet bed in the Filchner-Ronne sector of Antarctica, with a specific focus on the Recovery Glacier catchment.  First, we use the Ice Sheet System Model (ISSM; Larour et al., 2012) to assimilate satellite observations of ice sheet surface velocity (Mouginot et al., 2019) in order to solve for basal drag and ice rheology across the Filchner-Ronne sector of Antarctica.  Next, we compare these results with ice-penetrating radar observations sensitive to the presence of ponded water at the ice sheet base (Humbert et al., 2018; Langley et al., 2011), along with remotely sensed observations of active lakes (Smith et al., 2009) and putative large subglacial lakes inferred from the ice sheet surface slope (Bell et al., 2007).  We find that the main fast-flowing region of Recovery Glacier is mostly low-drag, with the exception of localized sticky spots and bands.  The boundary between rugged subglacial highlands and a deep subglacial basin near the onset of the ice stream is associated with a sharp reduction in basal drag, although surface velocity changes smoothly rather than abruptly across this transition.  An upstream shear margin, visible in satellite radar images of the ice surface, is associated with low basal drag.  The putative large lakes have low drag but are not strongly distinguished from their surroundings, and radar evidence for ponded subglacial water within them is weak.  The active lakes identified from satellite altimetry are similarly situated in areas of low basal drag, but have limited radar evidence for ponded subglacial water.  An L-curve analysis indicates that our inverse model results are robust against changes in regularization, yet the radar-identified lake candidates do not have a clear relationship with low-drag areas in the fast-flowing ice stream.  We conclude that the deep-bedded regions of Recovery Glacier are underlain by saturated subglacial sediments, but classic ponded subglacial lakes are much more rare.  Isolated sticky spots and bands within the ice stream are either due to protrusions of bedrock out of the sediments or to localized areas of frozen and/or compacted sediments.

    How to cite: Wolovick, M., Höyns, L.-S., Kleiner, T., Nickel, N., Helm, V., and Humbert, A.: Basal Properties of the Filchner-Ronne Sector of Antarctica from Inverse Modeling and Comparison with Ice-Penetrating Radar Data, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4027, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4027, 2022.

    EGU22-5113 | Presentations | CR2.9

    Estimating large scale dynamic mountain glacier states with numerical modelling and data assimilation 

    Patrick Schmitt, Fabien Maussion, and Philipp Gregor

    Ongoing global glacier retreat leads to sea-level rise and changes in regional freshwater availability. For an adequate adaptation to these changes, knowledge about the ice volume and the current dynamic state of glaciers is crucial. At regional to global scales, sparse observations made the dynamic state of glaciers very difficult to assess. Thanks to recent advances in global geodetic mass-balance and velocity assessments, new ways to initialize numerical models and ice thickness estimation emerge. In this contribution, we present the COst Minimization Bed INvErsion model (COMBINE), which aims to be a cheap, flexible global data assimilation and inversion method. COMBINE uses an existing numerical model of glacier evolution (the Open Global Glacier Model, OGGM) rewritten in the machine learning framework PyTorch. This makes the model fully differentiable and allows to iteratively minimize a cost function penalizing mismatch to observations. Thanks to the flexible nature of automatic differentiation, various observational sources distributed in time can be considered (e.g. surface elevation and area changes, ice velocities). No assumption about the dynamic glacier state is needed, releasing the equilibrium assumption often required for large scale ice volume computations. In this contribution, we will demonstrate the capabilities of COMBINE in several idealized and real-world applications, and discuss its added value and upcoming challenges for operational application.

    How to cite: Schmitt, P., Maussion, F., and Gregor, P.: Estimating large scale dynamic mountain glacier states with numerical modelling and data assimilation, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5113, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5113, 2022.

    EGU22-5425 | Presentations | CR2.9

    Modeling the Greenland englacial stratigraphy 

    Andreas Born, Alexander Robinson, and Alexios Theofilopoulos

    Radar reflections from the interior of the Greenland ice sheet contain a comprehensive archive of past accumulation rates, ice dynamics, and basal melting. Combining these data with dynamic ice sheet models may greatly aid model calibration, improve past and future sea level estimates, and enable insights into past ice sheet dynamics that neither models nor data could achieve alone.

    In this study, we present the first three-dimensional ice sheet model that explicitly simulates the Greenland englacial stratigraphy. Individual layers of accumulation are represented on a grid whose vertical axis is time so that they do not exchange mass with each other as the flow of ice deforms them. This isochronal advection scheme does not influence the ice dynamics and only requires modest input data from a host thermomechanical ice sheet model.

    Using an ensemble of simulations, we show that direct comparison with the dated radiostratigraphy data yields notably more accurate results than calibrating simulations based on total ice thickness. We show that the isochronal scheme produces a more reliable simulation of the englacial age profile than Eulerian age tracers. Lastly, we outline how the isochronal model can be linearized as a foundation for inverse modeling and data assimilation.

    How to cite: Born, A., Robinson, A., and Theofilopoulos, A.: Modeling the Greenland englacial stratigraphy, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5425, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5425, 2022.

    EGU22-8605 | Presentations | CR2.9

    Coupling modelling and satellite observations to constrain subglacial melt rates and hydrology 

    Martin Wearing, Daniel Goldberg, Christine Dow, Anna Hogg, and Noel Gourmelen

    Meltwater forms at the base of the Antarctic Ice Sheet due to geothermal heat flux (GHF) and basal frictional dissipation. Despite the relatively small volume, this meltwater has a profound effect on ice-sheet stability, controlling the dynamics of the ice sheet and the interaction of the ice sheet with the ocean. However, observations of subglacial melting and hydrology in Antarctica are limited. Here we use numerical modelling to assess subglacial melt rates and hydrology beneath the Antarctic Ice Sheet. Our case study, focused on the Amery Ice Shelf catchment, shows that total subglacial melting in the catchment is 6.5 Gt yr-1, over 50% larger than previous estimates. Uncertainty in estimates of GHF leads to a variation in total melt of ±7%. The meltwater provides an extra 8% flux of freshwater to the ocean in addition to contributions from iceberg calving and melting of the ice shelf. GHF and basal dissipation contribute equally to the total melt rate, but basal dissipation is an order of magnitude larger beneath ice streams. Remote-sensing observations, from CryoSat-2, indicating active subglacial lakes and ice-shelf basal melting constrain subglacial hydrology modelling. We observe a network of subglacial channels that link subglacial lakes and trigger isolated areas of sub-ice-shelf melting close to the grounding line. Building upon this Amery case study, we expand our analysis to quantify subglacial melt rates and hydrology beneath the entire Antarctic Ice Sheet.

    How to cite: Wearing, M., Goldberg, D., Dow, C., Hogg, A., and Gourmelen, N.: Coupling modelling and satellite observations to constrain subglacial melt rates and hydrology, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8605, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8605, 2022.

    EGU22-8938 | Presentations | CR2.9

    Constraining Soil Freezing Models using Observed Soil Freezing Characteristic Curves 

    Élise Devoie, Stephan Gruber, and Jeffrey McKenzie

    Objective: Estimate Soil Freezing Characteristic Curves (SFCCs) and uncertainty bounds based on a compilation of existing measured SFCCs.

    Key Findings

    • Uncertainty in measured SFCCs is estimated based on measurement technique, water content, and soil disturbance
    • An open-source tool for estimating and constraining SFCCs is developed for use in parameterizing freeze/thaw models

    Abstract

    Cold-regions landscapes are undergoing rapid change due to a warming climate. This change is impacting many elements of the landscape and is often controlled by soil freeze/thaw processes. Soil freeze/thaw is governed by the Soil Freezing Characteristic Curve (SFCC) that relates the soil temperature to its unfrozen water content. This relation is needed in all physically based numerical models including soil freeze/thaw processes. A repository of all collected SFCC data and an R package for accessing and processing this data was presented in "A Repository of 100+ Years of Measured Soil Freezing Characteristic Curves".

    This rich SFCC dataset is synthesized with a focus on potential sources of error due to the combination of measurement technique, data interpretation, and physical freeze-thaw process in a specific soil. Particular attention is given to combining sources of error and working with datasets given incomplete and missing metadata. A tool is developed to extract an SFCC for a soil with specified properties alongside its uncertainty bounds. This tool is intended for use in freeze/thaw models to improve freeze/thaw estimates, and better represent the ice and liquid water content of freezing soils. As phase change accounts for a vast majority of the energy budget in freezing soils, accurately representing the process is essential for realistic predictions. In addition, SFCC type curves are provided for the common sand, silt, clay, and organic soil textures when additional data is unavailable to define the SFCC more precisely.

    How to cite: Devoie, É., Gruber, S., and McKenzie, J.: Constraining Soil Freezing Models using Observed Soil Freezing Characteristic Curves, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8938, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8938, 2022.

    EGU22-9143 | Presentations | CR2.9

    Assessing the continuity of englacial layers across the Lambert Glacier catchment. 

    Rebecca Sanderson, Neil Ross, Louise Callard, Kate Winter, Felipe Napoleoni, Robert Bingham, and Tom Jordan

    The analysis of englacial layers using ice penetrating radar enables the characterisation and reconstruction of current and past ice sheet flow. To date, little research has been undertaken on the ice flow and englacial stratigraphy of the upper catchment of the Lambert Glacier. The Lambert Glacier catchment is one of the largest in East Antarctica, discharging ~16% of East Antarctica’s ice. Quantitative analysis of the continuity of englacial stratigraphy and ice flow has the potential to provide insight into the present-day and past flow regimes of the upper catchment of Lambert Glacier. Radar data from the British Antarctic Survey Antarctica’s Gamburtsev Province Project North (AGAP-N) aerogeophysical survey was analysed using the Internal Layer Continuity Index (ILCI). This approach identified, and characterised, a range of englacial structures and stratigraphy, including buckled layers in areas of increased ice velocity (>20ma-1) and continuous layering across subglacial highlands with low ice velocity adjacent to the central Lambert Glacier trunk. Overall, the analysis is consistent with the present-day ice-flow velocity field and long-term stability of ice flow across the Lambert catchment. However, disrupted layer geometry at the onset of the Lambert Glacier suggests a past shift in the position of the onset of ice flow. These results have implications for the future evolution of this major ice flow catchment, and East Antarctica, under a changing climate. The ILCI method represents a valuable tool for rapidly characterising englacial stratigraphy, and the study demonstrates the transferability of the method across Antarctica. The use of quantitative tools such as ILCI for the analysis of large radar datasets will be critical for projects such as AntArchitecture (https://www.scar.org/science/antarchitecture/home/) which aims to investigate the long-term stability of the Antarctic ice sheets directly from the internal architecture of the ice sheet.

    How to cite: Sanderson, R., Ross, N., Callard, L., Winter, K., Napoleoni, F., Bingham, R., and Jordan, T.: Assessing the continuity of englacial layers across the Lambert Glacier catchment., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9143, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9143, 2022.

    EGU22-9262 | Presentations | CR2.9

    Assimilating Cyrosat2 freeboard into a coupled ice-ocean model  

    Imke Sievers, Lars Stenseng, and Till Rasmussen
    This presentation introduces a method to assimilate freeboard from radar satellite observations.
    Many studies have shown that the skill and memory of sea ice models using sea ice thickness as initial condition improve compered to model runs only initializing sea ice concentration. The only Arctic wide sea ice thickness data which could be used for initialization is coming from satellite observations. Since sea ice can’t directly be measured from space freeboard data is used to derive sea ice thickness. Freeboard is converted under assumption of hydrostatic equilibrium to sea ice thickness. For this conversion snow thickness is needed. Due to a lack of Arctic wide snow cover observations most products use a snow climatology or a modification of one. This has proofed to introduce errors. To avoid the errors introduced by this method the presented work aims to assimilate freeboard directly. This presentation will introduce the method and show first results. The assimilation period overlaps with ICESat2 mission. We present a comparison between the presented freeboard assimilation and ICESat2 sea ice thickness products of a first winter season.

    How to cite: Sievers, I., Stenseng, L., and Rasmussen, T.: Assimilating Cyrosat2 freeboard into a coupled ice-ocean model , EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9262, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9262, 2022.

    EGU22-9886 | Presentations | CR2.9

    Automated Tracking of Glacial Lake Outburst Floods in Norway 

    Jogscha Abderhalden and Irina Rogozhina

    No continuously updated glacier and glacial lake inventories exist for Norway. Previous inventories have been developed for the time periods of 1947-1985, 1988-1997 and 1999-2006 for glaciers and 1988-1997, 1999-2006, 2014 and 2018 for glacial lakes, by manual digitization, and semi-automated mapping. However, these methods are both time consuming and do not allow for an analysis of glacial lake behaviour on shorter timescales or on a seasonal basis. Therefore, one aim of this study is to present consistent inventories for glaciers and glacial lakes in Norway using semi-automated mapping and machine learning techniques applied on satellite imagery of different spatial and temporal resolution (Landsat 30m, 16 days, and Sentinel 10m, 5 days). An automated method that allows frequent monitoring of glacier variables can provide essential knowledge for the understanding of glacial lake dynamics in a changing climate.

    In addition to glacial lake inventories, smaller ice caps with active glacial lakes are investigated more closely, aiming at following the development of glacial lakes throughout seasons. Here we are also analyzing the suitability of PlanetScope imagery compared to the Sentinel and Landsat imagery to detect the known glacial lake outburst flood events and identify currently unrecognized hazard-prone glacial lakes. Since the field-based investigations of glacial lake changes (especially of the ice-dammed lakes) are sparse in Norway, developing methods for remote-sensed, automated monitoring of glacial lake changes and glacial lake outburst floods is essential in order to develop early warning systems, detect potentially hazardous lakes and prevent human losses and damages to infrastructure and local businesses.

    How to cite: Abderhalden, J. and Rogozhina, I.: Automated Tracking of Glacial Lake Outburst Floods in Norway, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9886, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9886, 2022.

    EGU22-10509 | Presentations | CR2.9

    A probabilistic analysis of permafrost temperature trends with ensemble modeling of heat transfer 

    Brian Groenke, Moritz Langer, Guillermo Gallego, and Julia Boike

    Over the past few decades, polar research teams around the world have deployed long-term measurement sites to monitor changes in permafrost environments. Many of these sites include borehole sensor arrays which provide measurements of ground temperature as deep as 50 meters or more below the surface. Recent studies have attempted to leverage these borehole data from the Global Terrestrial Network of Permafrost to quantify changes in permafrost temperatures at a global scale. However, temperature measurements provide an incomplete picture of the Earth's subsurface thermal regime. It is well known that regions with warmer permafrost, i.e. where mean annual ground temperatures are close to zero, often show little to no long-term change in ground temperature due to the latent heat effect. Thus, regions where the least warming is observed  may also be the most vulnerable to rapid permafrost thaw. Since direct measurements of soil moisture in the permafrost layer are not widely available, thermal modeling of the subsurface plays a crucial role in understanding how permafrost responds to changes in the local energy balance. In this work, we explore a new probabilistic method to link observed annual temperatures in boreholes to permafrost thaw via Bayesian parameter estimation and Monte Carlo simulation with a transient heat model. We apply our approach to several sites across the Arctic and demonstrate the impact of local landscape variability on the relationship between long term changes in temperature and latent heat.

    How to cite: Groenke, B., Langer, M., Gallego, G., and Boike, J.: A probabilistic analysis of permafrost temperature trends with ensemble modeling of heat transfer, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10509, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10509, 2022.

    EGU22-11310 | Presentations | CR2.9

    Layer geometry as a constraint on the physics of sliding onset 

    Elisa Mantelli, Marnie Bryant, Helene Seroussi, Ludovic Raess, Davide Castelletti, Dustin Schroeder, Jenny Suckale, and Martin Siegert

    Transitions from basal no slip to basal sliding are a common feature of ice sheets, yet one that has remained difficult to observe. In this study we leverage recent advances in the processing of radar sounding data to study these transitions through their signature in englacial layers. Englacial layers encode information about strain and velocity, and the relation between their geometry and the onset of basal sliding has been demonstrated in ice flow models (the so-called "Weertman effect"). Here we leverage this relation to test the long-standing hypothesis that sliding onset takes the form of an abrupt no slip/sliding transition. By comparing the modeled signature of an abrupt sliding onset in englacial layer slopes against slope observations from the onset region of a West Antarctic ice stream (Institute Ice Stream), we conclude that observed layer geometry does not support an abrupt no slip/sliding transition. Our findings instead suggest a much smoother sliding onset, as would be consistent with temperature-dependent friction between ice and bed. Direct measurements of basal temperature at the catchment scale would allow us to confirm this hypothesis.

    How to cite: Mantelli, E., Bryant, M., Seroussi, H., Raess, L., Castelletti, D., Schroeder, D., Suckale, J., and Siegert, M.: Layer geometry as a constraint on the physics of sliding onset, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11310, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11310, 2022.

    EGU22-13501 | Presentations | CR2.9

    Investigating basal thaw as a driver of mass loss from the Antarctic ice sheet 

    Eliza Dawson, Dustin Schroeder, Winni Chu, Elisa Mantelli, and Hélène Seroussi

    Contemporary mass loss from the Antarctic ice sheet primarily originates from the discharge of
    marine-terminating glaciers and ice streams. The rate of mass loss is influenced by warming ocean
    and atmospheric conditions, which lead to subsequent thinning or disintegration of ice shelves and
    increased outflow of upstream grounded ice. It is currently unclear how the basal thermal state of
    grounded ice could evolve in the future - for example as a result of accelerated ice flow or changes
    in the ice sheet geometry - but a change in the basal thermal state could impact rates of mass loss
    from Antarctica. Here, we use a combination of numerical simulations and ice-penetrating radar
    analysis to investigate the influence of basal thawing on 100yr simulations of the Antarctic ice
    sheet’s evolution. Using the Ice-sheet and Sea-level System Model, we find that thawing patches
    of frozen bed near the ice sheet margin could drive mass loss extending into the continental
    interior, with the highest rates of loss coming from the George V - Adélie - Wilkes Land coast and
    the Enderby - Kemp Land regions of East Antarctica. This suggests that the thawing of localized
    frozen bed patches is sufficient to cause these East Antarctic regions to transition to an unstable
    mass loss regime. We constrain model estimates of the basal thermal state using ice-penetrating
    radar surveys and analyze radar characteristics including bed reflectivity and attenuation. In
    combination, our work identifies critical regions of Antarctica where the ice-bed interface could
    be close to thawing and where basal thaw could most impact mass loss.

    How to cite: Dawson, E., Schroeder, D., Chu, W., Mantelli, E., and Seroussi, H.: Investigating basal thaw as a driver of mass loss from the Antarctic ice sheet, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13501, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13501, 2022.

    EGU22-1905 | Presentations | BG3.28

    The switching of a mid-European temperate mire from carbon sink to source in extreme climate conditions 

    Krzysztof Fortuniak, Włodzimierz Pawlak, and Mariusz Siedlecki

    Reversing the natural feedbacks that limit the rise in temperature is one of the major threats of climate change. One such mechanism is the exchange of carbon gases between the ecosystem and the atmosphere in wetlands. Wetlands cover only about 3% of the Earth's surface, but in natural conditions act as a CO2 sink and store a significant amount of carbon in the soil. The organic carbon accumulated in the Northern peatland is estimated as one-third of the world’s pool of organic carbon, equivalent to more than half the amount of carbon in the atmosphere. Climate extremes such as droughts and hot spell, can reduce or even invers this role. The water table drawdown and higher temperatures lead to enhanced peat oxidation and releasing a large portion of peat carbon as CO2. It can switch a peatland from sink to source of carbon. However, some studies suggest that other mechanisms may compensate or even turn away this effect in real peatland ecosystems. Consequently, it is vitally important to empirically verify whether the paradigm of peatland transition from carbon sink to source in hot and dry conditions is valid for natural ecosystems. Despite the growing number of observations, it is hard to find datasets clearly showing such effect in the sense that they were collected in an undisturbed environment, represent for the whole ecosystem scale, and span full annual totals.

    In this study we provide a strong empirical confirmation of switching of the mid-European temperate mire from carbon sink to source under extremely dry and hot climate conditions. The analysis is based on eight-year eddy-covariance measurements at site (53°35′30.8′′ N, 22°53′32.4′′ E, 109 m a.s.l.) located in a one of the largest coherent lowland wetlands in Central Europe – the Biebrza National Park (north-eastern Poland). In the analyzed measurement period (2013-2020) the studied ecosystem was affected by severe droughts in 2015 and 2018-2020. In wet years the peatland was a significant sink of CO2 (down to −990 gCO2∙m−2∙yr−1) whereas in dry years we observed a substantial release of CO2(up to +1020 gCO2∙m−2∙yr−1). At the same time, a CH4 emission dropped from 29 gCH4∙m−2∙yr−1 in the wettest year to about 1−4 gCH4∙m−2∙yr−1 in dry years, which does not compensate for the amount of carbon released in the form of CO2(even taking into account higher global warming potential of CH4). At the same time, relatively small differences in the water vapor flux (evapotranspiration) between wet and dry years were observed. It demonstrates that the scenario of positive feedback between wetland carbon release and climate change could be realistic and supports the need of natural wetland preservation or rewetting.

     

    Acknowledgements: Funding for this research was provided by the National Science Centre, Poland under project UMO-2020/37/B/ST10/01219 and University of Lodz under project 4/IDUB/DOS/2021. The authors thank the authorities of the Biebrza National Park for allowing the continuous measurements in the area of the Park.

    How to cite: Fortuniak, K., Pawlak, W., and Siedlecki, M.: The switching of a mid-European temperate mire from carbon sink to source in extreme climate conditions, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1905, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1905, 2022.

    Climate anomalies significantly shape forests around the World. Intensive climate changes (global warming and drought) that have occurred since 20th century have caused more extreme climate events and boosted forest mortality. Different drought resistance in the Quercus sp. was observed among species and tree populations up to the genotype level. Species-specific responses to drought further complicate the understanding of the drought-induced changes in forests. We selected 20 radial growth and six stable carbon isotope ratio (δ13C) chronologies of Quercus cerris and Q. robur from Serbia. Since both δ13C and radial growth chronologies are influenced by surrounding stressors, including nonlinear climate trends, a more flexible approach to their modeling was required, and we, therefore, chose a generalized additive mixed model (GAMM) for data processing. A total of 20 climate and environmental variables were included in models to better understand their relationship and climate predictions/reconstruction.

    In the GAMM, a better fit was obtained for δ13C and more xeric Q. cerris (adj. R2 0.646) than for radial growth and Q. robur GAMMs performances. The potential for predicting radial growth and δ13C based on 20 different climate and environmental variables was tested with GAMM. Chronologies were split into two subsets for GAMM calibration and validation. GAMM predictions were calibrated using the first 25 years (1961-1985), while the second subset (1986-2010) was used for model validation. Both oak species showed higher similarity between measured and predicted δ13C, opposite of radial growth. A xeric oak species (Q. cerris) showed higher sensitivity to climatic and environmental factors, reflected in better GAMM prediction potential.

    Species-specific differences in radial growth and δ13C were observed. The results presented in this study suggest that xeric oak species such as Q. cerris are more sensitive to environmental factors in both δ13C and radial growth. According to the GAMM results, the more climate-sensitive Q. cerris showed better relationships with the analyzed factors than Q. robur. It was concluded that δ13C responds more strongly and quickly to climatic anomalies than TRW and that the analyzed climatic and environmental factors can be a reliable indicator of cambial productivity and stress periods of both oak species.

     

    Keywords: Dendrochronology, Dendrochemistry, Stable carbon isotope, Tree ring, Quercus, Drought, GAMM.

     

    Acknowledgments: This research was supported by the Science Fund of the Republic of Serbia, PROMIS, #6066697, TreeVita. TL acknowledge the financial support from the Slovenian Research Agency - research core funding No. P4-0107 Program research group “Forest Biology, Ecology and Technology” and research grant J4-8216 “Mortality of lowland oak forests - consequence of lowering underground water or climate change?”

    Note: This contribution is a summary of a study by Kostić S, Levanič T, Orlović S, Matović B, Stojanović DB. Xeric Turkey oak (Quercus cerris L.) is a more reliable climate indicator than hydric pedunculate oak (Q. robur L.) in the same stand conditions: Stable carbon isotope ratio (δ13C) and radial growth approaches (In press)

    How to cite: Kostić, S., Levanič, T., and Stojanović, D.: Tree-ring stable carbon isotope ratio (δ13C) and growth chronologies of more xeric Turkey oak (Quercus cerris L.) is reliable climate proxy than hydric pedunculate oak (Q. robur L.) species., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2144, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2144, 2022.

    EGU22-2283 | Presentations | BG3.28

    Scatterometer soil moisture data for the conceptual rainfall-runoff model 

    Martin Kubáň, Adam Brziak, and Viera Rattayová

    The different approaches for the improvement of the calibration processes of the conceptual hydrological models are annually introduced. In our paper, we focus on the improvement of runoff and soil moisture simulation, by the assimilation of the scatterometer soil moisture to the calibration process of the HBV type rainfall-runoff model. The model was single-calibrated for runoff and multi-calibrated for the combination of the runoff and the combination of the soil moisture data for the root and surface soil zone. We validated the model in the two-period and compare the simulation results between the single and multi-objective approaches. The improvement of the soil moisture simulation was detected in almost 80% of the catchments, in the case of the runoff simulation we detect the improvement in almost 30% of the catchments, mainly in the catchments with a lower mean elevation, narrower terrain, and higher agricultural land percentage.

    How to cite: Kubáň, M., Brziak, A., and Rattayová, V.: Scatterometer soil moisture data for the conceptual rainfall-runoff model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2283, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2283, 2022.

    EGU22-2295 | Presentations | BG3.28

    Two-dimensional analysis of the irrigation needs in Danubian Lowland in Slovakia 

    Milan Cisty and Barbora Povazanova

    A water shortage implies various adverse effects on agriculture and various other risks associated with the scale and duration of the rainfall deficit. Water scarcity and droughts directly impact the inhabitants and different economic sectors of a region that directly depend on water, such as agriculture, industry, energy, tourism, or transport.

    Quantifying the expected probability characteristics of droughts assists in the planning and managing of water resources. The present work's authors described analyses from the perspective of irrigation system management and have performed a joint analysis of the severity and duration of the most important potential annual irrigation periods by a bivariate copula methodology. Basic climatic variables (temperature and precipitation) were used to determine the two derived variables that characterize dry and hot periods requiring irrigation in this work. Such a period is defined by its duration and the rainfall deficit with respect to the normal period (1960—1990). The hot and dry periods that lasted the longest for each year were identified. The duration was derived from the number of consecutive days with temperatures above 25°C. The hot period identified was extended by precipitation-free days before and after it. This variable is herein referred to as the maximum annual length of the potential irrigation period. The maximum yearly length of the potential irrigation periods and the corresponding rainfall deficit were inputs for a two-dimensional probability analysis by a copula methodology. The study was carried out on an agricultural area in Slovakia with a warm and relatively dry climate - the area of the Danubian Lowland around the municipality of Hurbanovo.

    The results of this work indicate that in the context of the case study, the need for irrigation occurs very often. For example, every second year, a period can be expected in which temperatures above 25 °C occur. A dry period usually lasts one month with a moisture deficit of about 30 mm. Precipitation of 80 mm in such a period (which would be needed to maintain this limit) occurs with a probability in the upper quartile, i.e., it is scarce. Even more significant periods of drought can be expected, for example, with a five or 10-year return period. These phenomena result in considerable damage to agriculture yields, which, as is often declared in the domestic water management community, are more significant than the investment needed for the reliable maintenance or reconstruction of irrigation systems.

    How to cite: Cisty, M. and Povazanova, B.: Two-dimensional analysis of the irrigation needs in Danubian Lowland in Slovakia, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2295, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2295, 2022.

    EGU22-2306 | Presentations | BG3.28

    The role of intense rainfall events on the land degradation processes in the Slovak and Polish catchments  

    Zuzana Sabová, Matúš Tomaščík, Zuzana Németová, Silvia Kohnová, Adam Krajewski, and Kazimierz Banasik

    Land degradation caused by anthropogenic activities (deforestation, overgrazing, unsuitable land-use and management practices) negatively influence the well-being of people and also accelerates soil erosion processes. The main evidence for a link between soil degradation and water erosion can be seen in the following elements: increasing rainfall intensity, permafrost thawing, biomass production, tillage, cultivation overgrazing, deforestation/ vegetation clearing, vegetation burning, poorly designed roads and paths to a global extent. Therefore, it is significant to investigate degradation processes in order to point out the possible adverse effects of unsuitable management practices of the landscape in the scale of past and future periods. A future prediction of the development of any processes requires long-term investigation and analysis of the phenomenon predetermined to assess future behaviour. On the contrary, analysis of past processes shows us precipitation patterns and reveals their effect on the generation of degradation processes. The study describes the role of rainfall events on a generation of erosion processes, especially soil water erosion in the catchments located in Poland (Zagożdżonka) and Slovakia (Svacenicky Jarok). A common characteristic of these catchments is the susceptibility to degradation processes, the predominance of arable land and the dominant agricultural use of catchments. In the case of Zagożdżonka catchment (Poland) the modelling period covers the years 1963-2020 with the real measured rainfall events. On the contrary, in the case of Svacenický jarok the future development of degradation processes was analyzed based on the future prediction of rainfall events covering the period 2020-2100 and generated by CLM model (Climate Land Model). In both cases, the simulations were performed using the physically-based EROSION-3D model and three scenarios were created in order to model different land cover, land use, soil types and crops on agricultural land. The first scenario reflects current catchment conditions, the second reflects the best conditions (more forests, fewer pastures and unprotected land) and the third involves worst-case conditions (no protective measures or changes of inappropriate management practices). The results provide insight into the development of degradation processes, illustrate how changes in rainfall patterns affect soil degradation processes in the past and future and take into account different scenarios of management practices together with an analysis of the impact of rainfall events on these processes.

    How to cite: Sabová, Z., Tomaščík, M., Németová, Z., Kohnová, S., Krajewski, A., and Banasik, K.: The role of intense rainfall events on the land degradation processes in the Slovak and Polish catchments , EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2306, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2306, 2022.

    EGU22-2406 | Presentations | BG3.28

    Periodic and total carbon footprint values of large-scale agricultural cultivation 

    András Polgár, Karolina Horváth, Tamara Temesi, Pál Balázs, Sándor Faragó, and Veronika Elekne Fodor

    Maintaining environmental balance and reducing the damages caused by climate change anomalies are the basic pillars of sustainable agricultural competitiveness. Applying agricultural sector life cycle assessment (LCA) to achieve both internal (comparative) and external (efficiency enhancing) benefits is a priority.

    The investigated area (Lajta-Project) is located in Kisalföld plain, specifically in the southern part of Mosoni-sík (plain). 

    The main cultivated plant species in this agricultural land (2678-2768 ha) are cereals, maize, hemp and canola. There are, on average, 10-15 crops present during a single cultivation cycle. The area is divided into 56 parcels measuring between 20 and 105 ha. The investigation covers the two decade period between 1991 and 2011. We analysed the cultivation data of 5 crops: canola, winter barley, winter wheat, green maize and maize.

    We applied the following methods and models in our life cycle impact assessment: CML2001 (January 2016) method, carbon footprint analysis according to the standard ISO 14067, GaBi impact assessment model for land use and GaBi model for water. In order to represent the overall environmental impact, we used the method of CML2001, Experts IKP (Central Europe).

    Significant impact categories resulted from the average cultivated plant values calculated on 1 ha (territorial approach) were: abiotic depletion pot. (ADP fossil), global warming (GWP 100 years) and marine aquatic ecotoxicity pot. (MAETP inf). 

    We compared the yearly time series values on 1 ha and the average yearly values of cultivated plants. According to the resulted ratio, we could define the year of above-average level emission and the year of lower level environmental impact. This provides opportunity to draw further conclusions in the time series assessments of the resulting changes in the local flora and fauna.

    We also summarized the indicator results of appropriate impact categories according to CML2001 method in the studied area by crops which resulted in the territorial environmental footprints of crops for the total time period, namely the ’super footprint’ values. The calculated carbon footprint value specific to the area was 307,000 kg CO2-equiv. according to ’super footprint’ approach. The calculated values are clear to interpret by comparison with the similar data or average values of other areas or time periods.

    The obtained results help to better assess environmental impacts, climate risks, and climate change as they pertain to arable crop production technologies, which advances the selection of appropriate technologies that have been adjusted to environmental sensitivities.

    Acknowledgement: Our research was supported by the „Lajta-Project”.

    How to cite: Polgár, A., Horváth, K., Temesi, T., Balázs, P., Faragó, S., and Elekne Fodor, V.: Periodic and total carbon footprint values of large-scale agricultural cultivation, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2406, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2406, 2022.

    EGU22-2409 | Presentations | BG3.28

    An HBV-model based approach for studying the effects of projected climate change on water resources in Slovakia 

    Roman Výleta, Patrik Sleziak, Kamila Hlavčová, Michaela Danáčová, Milica Aleksić, Ján Szolgay, and Silvia Kohnová

    Climate change challenges policymakers and river basin authorities to find sustainable management solutions and optimal strategies to avoid undesirable impacts on water resources and the environment. Our study aimed to evaluate the possible impacts of future climate change on water resources in Slovakia. Eight pilot river basins spread throughout the whole territory of Slovakia were selected in this study. To draw more general conclusions, basins were delineated into two different groups, i.e. basins with a mean elevation < 435 m a.s.l. (four basins) and basins with a mean elevation > 435 m a.s.l. (four basins). An HBV bucket-type hydrological model (the TUW model) was used to provide runoff projections. For the model parametrization, we used a cross-calibration strategy based on selecting the most suitable decade in the observation period. The model was calibrated and validated over four periods (1981–1990, 1991–2000, 2001–2010, and 2011–2019) with rainfall, air temperature and potential evapotranspiration as inputs. Then, the parameters that best reflect the current climate (mainly in terms of the mean daily air temperatures) were used to simulate runoff over the baseline (1981–2010) and three future time horizons (2011–2040, 2041–2070, and 2071–2100). For the future runoff projections, the model was driven by the precipitation and air temperatures projected by the KNMI and MPI regional climate models under the A1B (moderate) emission scenario. The model performance during the calibration and validation was assessed using four metrics (the objective function, the logarithmic Nash–Sutcliffe efficiency, the Nash–Sutcliffe efficiency, and the volume error). All model performance metrics and visual inspection of hydrographs indicated that the simulated runoff has a good agreement with the observed values.

    Our results indicate that the change in climate variables is expected to be more or less the same for both groups of the river basins. Precipitation shows an increasing pattern during spring, autumn, and winter periods. The regional climate model data suggest that the long-term mean monthly air temperatures will rise with the future time horizons. Compared to the baseline (1981–2010), winter runoff (December–February) is projected to increase, with a maximum increase in the period 2071–2100. In the summer season (June–August), the runoff will react in reverse. The values of maximum annual daily runoff are more prominent in lower elevations (i.e., basins < 435 m a.s.l.) than at higher elevations (i.e., basins > 435 m a.s.l.). Our analysis could help develop optimal strategies for water resources management and flood control in the studied basins.

     

    Acknowledgments

    This work was supported by the Slovak Research and Development Agency under Contract No. APVV-18-0347, No. APVV-19-0340, No. APVV-20-0374 and the VEGA Grant Agency No. 1/0632/19 and No. 2/0065/19. The financial support by the Stefan Schwarz grant of the Slovak Academy of Sciences is also gratefully acknowledged.

    How to cite: Výleta, R., Sleziak, P., Hlavčová, K., Danáčová, M., Aleksić, M., Szolgay, J., and Kohnová, S.: An HBV-model based approach for studying the effects of projected climate change on water resources in Slovakia, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2409, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2409, 2022.

    EGU22-2583 | Presentations | BG3.28

    Changes in the actual catchment evapotranspiration in the Western Carpathians in Slovakia 

    Jan Szolgay, Anita Keszeliova, Kamila Hlavcova, Zoltan Gribovszki, Peter Kalicz, and Miroslav Kandera

    Actual catchment evapotranspiration, which includes all forms of evaporation and transpiration through plants, plays an important role in the water, energy, and carbon cycles. This contribution aims to explore trends in the actual catchment evapotranspiration based on the analysis of the components of the long-term hydrological balance of selected river basins in the Western Carpathians and detect changes attributable to changing landuse and climate conditions. We have used high-quality gridded data sets of precipitation and air temperatures from the CarpathClim project for the water balance. Temporal changes in the catchments’ average air temperature, precipitation, runoff, and their differences (considered as an index of the actual evapotranspiration) have been estimated for 49 years of data and compared between two non-overlapping sub-periods (25 and 24 years). Given that both inputs into the equation of the long-term hydrological balance contain uncertainties, we also used proxy evapotranspiration data modelled according to the Budyko-Tomlain method for comparison. Changes in land use were evaluated from the CORINE project. This allowed us to consider the impact of the rising air temperature and, in part, the local physiographic factors, on the changes in runoff and actual catchment evapotranspiration as the main drivers of changes in the hydrological balance. In particular, the increase in air temperature was found to be statistically significant across the transect. The main conclusion related to water resources management is that the hydrological balance has changed towards an increase in actual catchment evapotranspiration and a decrease in runoff. An increase in the catchment precipitation was present in the trends but was not statistically significant. The Budyko-Tomlain actual evapotranspiration proxy series confirmed the tendencies in the actual catchment evapotranspiration with significant trends. However, local factors of runoff generation, especially catchment storage, can exhibit an influence at higher elevations (approx. above 800 m a.s.l.), thereby partially disguising the expected general tendencies at a given altitude. These factors can both lessen or intensify the changes in runoff and actual catchment evapotranspiration in catchments at similar altitudes. On the other hand, in lower elevations where runoff generation is less intensive, the influence of the climatic factors is decisive. The research was supported by the Slovak Research and Development Agency under Contract Nos. APVV-18-0347 and APVV-20-0374, and the VEGA Agency Grant No. 1/0632/19. The support is gratefully acknowledged.

    How to cite: Szolgay, J., Keszeliova, A., Hlavcova, K., Gribovszki, Z., Kalicz, P., and Kandera, M.: Changes in the actual catchment evapotranspiration in the Western Carpathians in Slovakia, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2583, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2583, 2022.

    EGU22-2677 | Presentations | BG3.28

    Monitoring and assessing the developing dynamics of the gully erosion using different mapping techniques 

    Milica Aleksić, Michaela Danáčová, Roman Výleta, Anna Liová, Matúš Tomaščík, and Kamila Hlavčová

    The appearance of the water erosion can be found not only in the small mountainous catchments but also in the agricultural hillslopes. Therefore, there is a growing necessity of monitoring and analyzing the potential changes of the features representing water erosion in space and through time. When it comes to monitoring irregular shapes of grooves and gully in the landscape, various modern surveying techniques could be used. The choice of a suitable method and equipment for terrain monitoring depends on the size of the area, its use, the purpose of the research, sufficient accuracy of measurements, weather conditions, and possibly other factors. The field measurements performed in the period 2014 – 2021 will be presented in this abstract. Field measurements were performed in the Myjava hillslope on the selected erosion gully, where throughout the year 2011, seven small wooden check dams were built. The dams had a stabilization purpose. As a part of monitoring, we focused on the dynamics of changes and development of the gully using various modern monitoring and surveying techniques, such as Global Navigation Satellite Systems (GNSS), Terrestrial Laser Scanning  (TLS), and Unmanned Areal Vehicle (UAV). The process of clogging and deepening of the erosive element was evaluated in the selected profiles.

    Moreover, the possibility of implementing further protective measures on minimizing the erosion process was also evaluated. Simulations with the physical erosion model SMODERP were also used in the evaluation. The results showed that the length of the erosion gully increased during the monitoring period. However, the gully is sufficiently stable. Clogging appeared in the locations where the stabilizing elements occurred in both the bottom and transverse profiles.

    How to cite: Aleksić, M., Danáčová, M., Výleta, R., Liová, A., Tomaščík, M., and Hlavčová, K.: Monitoring and assessing the developing dynamics of the gully erosion using different mapping techniques, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2677, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2677, 2022.

    EGU22-3560 | Presentations | BG3.28

    Comparison of measured and satellite-derived ASCAT surface soil moisture data in a small mountain catchment 

    Patrik Sleziak, Michal Danko, Martin Jančo, Ladislav Holko, and Juraj Parajka

    Soil moisture plays an important role in the transformation of precipitation into flow and affects the severity of droughts, floods and other hydrological processes such as transpiration and evaporation. Estimation of spatio-temporal dynamics of soil moisture is therefore crucial for all water sectors. The main objective of this study is to compare satellite-derived ASCAT soil moisture data and field soil moisture measurements in an experimental, well-documented catchment (the Jalovecký Creek catchment, Western Tatra mountains, Slovakia). For the comparison, we used data from the period of 2012 – 2019. Measured data are represented by point measurements at two localities: (a) Červenec – open area (1500 m a.s.l., measurements at a depth of 5 cm) and (b) Červenec – forest (1420 m a.s.l., measurements at a depth of 10 cm). The new, experimental version of the ASCAT product provides data with higher spatial and temporal resolutions and improved soil moisture mapping under vegetation. Satellite-derived soil moisture data represented by the Soil Water Index are determined by an exponential filter with characteristic time delays (T in days). T value represents the reduction of the infiltration of the soil moisture dynamics, and therefore, it must be carefully chosen. The suitability of the satellite data in terms of different T values (i.e., T = 1, 2, 5, 10) is assessed by the visual inspection (measurements vs satellite) and correlation coefficient. The agreement between observed ASCAT data and the field soil moisture measurements will be further evaluated using observations of snow accumulation and melt, precipitation, air temperature and global radiation. The study will discuss the factors controlling this agreement.

     

    Acknowledgments

    This work was supported by the Slovak Research and Development Agency under Contract No. APVV-19-0340 and the VEGA Grant Agency No. 2/0065/19. The financial support by the Stefan Schwarz grant of the Slovak Academy of Sciences is also gratefully acknowledged.

    How to cite: Sleziak, P., Danko, M., Jančo, M., Holko, L., and Parajka, J.: Comparison of measured and satellite-derived ASCAT surface soil moisture data in a small mountain catchment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3560, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3560, 2022.

    EGU22-3717 | Presentations | BG3.28

    Detection of changes in the mean monthly and yearly discharges in Slovakia 

    Katarina Jeneiova, Zuzana Danacova, Lotta Blaskovicova, Marija Mihaela Labat, and Jana Poorova

    Due to climate change, the detection of changes in the long-term hydrological time series is an important topic in water management for timely set up of possible mitigation measures. In this contribution, the mean monthly and yearly discharges in Slovakia were analysed on the data from 43 selected water-gauging stations with hydrological regime minimally affected by human activities. The trend detection analysis of the mean monthly and yearly discharges in period 1961-2020 was concluded by Mann – Kendall trend test at significance level p = 0.05. The results of the trend analysis of the mean yearly discharges point out at the occurrence of statistically significant decreasing trend mainly in the western part of Slovakia. The trend analysis of the mean monthly discharges detected significant decreasing trend in the months of April, May, June, July and August. These results indicate possible changes in the mean monthly and yearly discharges in Slovakia and may be helpful in planning and policy making to mitigate the possible climate change impacts in Slovakia.

    Acknowledgement: This work was supported by the Slovak Research and Development Agency under the Contract no. APVV-20-0374.

    How to cite: Jeneiova, K., Danacova, Z., Blaskovicova, L., Labat, M. M., and Poorova, J.: Detection of changes in the mean monthly and yearly discharges in Slovakia, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3717, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3717, 2022.

    EGU22-3820 | Presentations | BG3.28

    Comparison of methods for assessing drought risk in beech ecosystem in central Slovakia 

    Zuzana Oravcová and Jaroslav Vido

    Drought, as a consequence of climate change, impacts beech ecosystems on their lower altitudinal limit of occurrence in Slovakia. During the growing season, precipitation deficit and its uneven distribution and rising evapotranspiration demands of ecosystems are significant. In this paper, we evaluate drought risk in the beech ecosystem in Kremnica Mountains (Central Slovakia) firstly from a climatological point of view (Climatic Index of Irrigation, CII) and secondly based on water availability in the soil (Relative Extractable Water, REW), while in the latter case we used drought severity classification for drought episodes. The study aimed to describe drought evolution during vegetation seasons 2017 and 2018 and compare its evaluation methods. Results revealed that CII is sufficient to determinate drought onset in the ecosystem. On the other hand, REW is suitable for accurately describing drought evolution in particular soil horizons and severity of drought determination. Furthermore, since CII is based on climatological data, positive values immediately after precipitation recovery might be inaccurate since soil profile require a certain volume of water over a more extended period for full saturation. Therefore, REW is more precise and suitable for drought evaluation because it considers the amount of water in the soil, closely related to plants' water balance.

    How to cite: Oravcová, Z. and Vido, J.: Comparison of methods for assessing drought risk in beech ecosystem in central Slovakia, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3820, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3820, 2022.

    EGU22-3938 | Presentations | BG3.28

    Possible approach to setting lower discharge limits for the characterization of hydrological drought 

    Lotta Blaskovicova, Jana Poorova, Zuzana Danacova, and Katarina Jeneiova

    The monitoring of hydrological drought is an important part of surface water monitoring and assessment provided by the Slovak Hydrometeorological Institute. The methodology of the on-line evaluation of the mean monthly discharges in selected water-gauging stations (WS) is actually based on selected quantiles of the mean long-term monthly discharges (Qma,1961-2000). However it turns out that in the lowest category (≤ 20% Qma) the occurrence of mean monthly and daily discharges lower than this limit significantly varies among the stations in different regions of Slovakia and/or different regime types and sizes of the rivers. Therefore, in this article, we have focused on the evaluation of the extent of the occurrence of mean monthly and daily discharges bellow selected limits in the reference period 1961-2000 as well as in the period 2001-2020. The results confirmed that the lowest limit 20%Qma (as a limit for extreme hydrological drought) is too low for large part of evaluated WS or at least for part of the months of the year. The extent of months and days bellow selected limits significantly differ also in the period 2001-2020 comparing with the reference period.

    How to cite: Blaskovicova, L., Poorova, J., Danacova, Z., and Jeneiova, K.: Possible approach to setting lower discharge limits for the characterization of hydrological drought, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3938, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3938, 2022.

    EGU22-4821 | Presentations | BG3.28

    Groundwater uptake dynamics of a lowland oak forest in the Great Hungarian Plain 

    Csaba László Kiss, Zoltán Gribovszki, Zsolt Pinke, Tamás Ács, Zsolt Kozma, and Péter Kalicz

    The groundwater uptake of forest stands often generates disputes, especially in today’s drying climate. Forestry in Hungary does not take into account groundwater as a surplus water resource under 2 meters, while other sources show forest groundwater uptake in case of much deeper water table. White method is the most appropriate way to quantify water consumption. It is based on the transpiration-caused diurnal fluctuation of groundwater.

    Once in the Great Hungarian Plain, hardwood forests stood along the River Tisza. These riparian ecosystems were supplied significantly by river floods, directly or indirectly. These forests mostly disappeared because of land use changes and water regulation works. One of the relics is the Ohat Forest, a salt steppic oak forest on the edge of the Hungarian Puszta (Hortobágy). Historical maps prove that this area was continuously forested, even before the water regulations.

    Because of its dryness, the 2020/21 hydrological year is especially suitable for water uptake analysis. Its yearly rainfall sum was 469.8 mm, compared to the long-term average (more than 500 mm). A groundwater well was settled in the forest on 28th of May 2021, and on 22nd of June 2021 a vented pressure transducer was installed to monitor the water table. Logged time series show diurnal groundwater fluctuation, by which we can estimate the environment-dependent groundwater uptake of the oak forest.

    This research was supported by the NRDI Fund FK 20 Grant Project no. 134547 and TKP2021-NKTA-43 project at University of Sopron.

    How to cite: Kiss, C. L., Gribovszki, Z., Pinke, Z., Ács, T., Kozma, Z., and Kalicz, P.: Groundwater uptake dynamics of a lowland oak forest in the Great Hungarian Plain, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4821, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4821, 2022.

    EGU22-5276 | Presentations | BG3.28

    The investigation of soil carbon sequestration and storage in forest sites on different climates in South Zala (Hungary) 

    Péter Végh, András Bidló, and Adrienn Horváth

    Due to global climate change, carbon-absorbing forests and soils will come to the fore to achieve carbon neutrality as soon as possible. Continuously increasing emissions upset the equilibrium of the atmosphere and manifest themselves in climate change or weather extremes as processes shift. Our research aimed to assess the organic carbon content stored in forest ecosystems under different climatic and forestry conditions. We focused on soil analysis because the volume of soil carbon is closely equal to the amount of carbon stored in the above-ground biomass. In the recent period, we have sampled about 12 designated forest stands to determine the amount of organic carbon stored in the soil of each forest stand. Soil samples were collected by drilling to a depth of 100 cm and 110 cm, respectively. Simultaneously with the soil sampling, the living tree stock of each stand near the sampling point was also assessed. Based on the studies carried out so far in the 12 designated forest stands, the areas can be classified into soil classes Cambisols and Luvisols (WRB 2020). The pH of the soil is mostly acidic (average = 5.2) and the texture can be determined as loam. The soil organic matter (SOM) of 0-40 cm of topsoils is 1.3%, which means ~10 t carbon content by hectares. There is still enough precipitation in the area for vegetation without disturbance; therefore, the carbon balance in the area is currently stable despite stocks are already declining due to the decline of litter amount.

    How to cite: Végh, P., Bidló, A., and Horváth, A.: The investigation of soil carbon sequestration and storage in forest sites on different climates in South Zala (Hungary), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5276, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5276, 2022.

    EGU22-5298 | Presentations | BG3.28 | Highlight

    Methane fluxes in relation with redox potential of soil on temperate mire in NE Poland (dry conditions case study) 

    Włodzimierz Pawlak, Krzysztof Fortuniak, and Mariusz Siedlecki

    Wetlands occupy a special place in the mosaic of landscapes around the globe, which, as a moist areas covered with vegetation, intensively release methane. Long-term research on vertical methane exchange between wetlands and the atmosphere has shown that the intensity of this process is a function of the climatic conditions at the observation site and the physico-chemical properties of the soil, such as moisture, temperature, pH and oxidation-reduction potential (redox) which reflects the ability of the soil to develop oxidizing or reducing conditions and thus indicates whether soil conditions are currently aerobic or anaerobic, necessary for the development of methanogenesis. Wetlands with a permanently high level of soil moisture content, located in mid-latitudes, are characterized by a clear annual variation in the vertical flux of methane to the atmosphere with clear relation to soil temperature. In recent years, permanently lowered or strongly fluctuating groundwater levels lead to continuous or episodic drying of the soil, which causes a continuous or temporary reduction in the intensity of methanogenesis. Thus, in dry years, the variability of methane fluxes is disturbed and the annual methane emissions is several times lower than in wet years.

    In the years 2013-2018, continuous measurements of methane flux (FCH4) were carried out in the marshes of the Biebrza National Park (NE Poland). The results, similar to those from other stations in middle latitudes, showed a clear annual variability of FCH4 in wet years (2013 and 2014) with minimum values in winter and intense methane release to the atmosphere from April to September (up to +0.35 gCH4·m-2·day-1). In dry years (2017 and 2018) in turn, the annual variability was clearly disturbed due to lower groundwater levels.

    The aim of the study is to perform a comparative analysis of the variability of FCH4 under typical and reduced soil moisture conditions, as well as an analysis of the temporal variability of the redox potential measured at five depths as a parameter supporting the analysis of the variability of methane fluxes in dry years. The variability of FCH4, disturbed in comparison to the wet years, was analyzed based on the variability of the redox potential in the soil, with particular emphasis on the relationship between the intensity of methanogenesis and the depth at which favorable conditions for methanogenesis appear. In such years, only the occurrence of intense but short-term methanogenesis was observed in April-May (up to + 0.1 gCH4·m-2·day-1), then a rapid decrease in the FCH4 value with the groundwater level falling to values close to those of winter and an irregular appearance of elevated FCH4 values in the period from June to November.

     

    Acknowledgements: Funding for this research was provided by the National Science Centre, Poland under project UMO-2020/37/B/ST10/01219 and University of Lodz under project 4/IDUB/DOS/2021. The authors thank the authorities of the Biebrza National Park for allowing the continuous measurements in the area of the Park.

    How to cite: Pawlak, W., Fortuniak, K., and Siedlecki, M.: Methane fluxes in relation with redox potential of soil on temperate mire in NE Poland (dry conditions case study), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5298, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5298, 2022.

    EGU22-6790 | Presentations | BG3.28

    Effects of changing precipitation pattern on stream water chemistry at a forested catchment in the Russian Far East 

    Ekaterina S. Zhigacheva, Hiroyuki Sase, Tsuyoshi Ohizumi, Makoto Nakata, and Sergey A. Gromov

    Acidification of the environment is still an important problem in the Russian Far East. Since the number of studies related to acidification is limited, the monitoring at the Primorskaya, one of the EANET sites, is of interest. The Primorskaya site has a set of continuous monitoring data on air, precipitation, and stream water (SW). The site is located within the watershed of the Komarovka River.

    While emissions of major acidifying agents have started decreasing in the Russia Far East and neighboring countries (e.g., China, Korean Peninsula, and Japan), the SW pH has been decreasing continuously alongside increases in concentrations of sulfate and nitrate for the observation period at the Komarovka River. Deposition trends also do not follow the major emission tendencies completely. To understand the mechanism of SW acidification, we tried to estimate the influences of meteorological variability and atmospheric-deposition seasonality on the SW discharge of the Komarovka River. The monitoring data for the period 2005 - 2020 is presented in the study.

    Two major climatic seasons can be distinguished at the Komarovka river catchment: the cold season (from October to March) with low precipitation, and the warm season (from April to September) when the major amount of precipitation falls. Although concentrations of major acidifying agents, such as sulfate and nitrate, in precipitation are usually higher in the cold season, the deposition fluxes are higher in the warm season due to the difference in precipitation amounts. While the annual precipitation amount did not show a clear trend, the contribution of precipitation during the warm season was tended to be increased since the early 2010s. Accordingly, the deposition fluxes of sulfate and nitrate were tended to be increasing in the warm season. Similarly, the recent SW fluxes of sulfate and nitrate have become higher in the warm season. It is suggested that the change in precipitation pattern influenced atmospheric deposition and SW fluxes, resulting in SW acidification (Zhigacheva et al. submitted).

    Besides the fluxes, SW concentrations in each sampling month showed specific trends, although the SW samples were taken only five times per year according to the hydrological regime: low water in February and November, snow melting period in April, summer low water in June, and high flow in September. Moving weighted mean concentrations of nitrate show an increasing trend at every hydrological phase except for September. Sulfate and calcium concentrations are more stable. We will discuss the effects of hydrological and biological processes on the seasonality and trends of SW chemistry.

    How to cite: Zhigacheva, E. S., Sase, H., Ohizumi, T., Nakata, M., and Gromov, S. A.: Effects of changing precipitation pattern on stream water chemistry at a forested catchment in the Russian Far East, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6790, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6790, 2022.

    EGU22-6810 | Presentations | BG3.28 | Highlight

    Diverse responses of semi-arid grasslands to severe droughts in Inner Mongolia, China 

    Xiran Li and Olivia Hajek

    Covering almost one-third of the land, grasslands play an important role in providing ecosystem functions and services such as carbon cycling. Further, grasslands are considered to be one of the ecosystems most sensitive to drought. As the frequency and intensity of droughts increase globally with climate change, it is urgent to quantify the characteristics and mechanisms of grassland responses to drought events.    
    In this study, we studied the response of grassland growth to drought events in the semi-arid grasslands of Inner Mongolia, China. This semi-arid grassland is characteristic of many grasslands globally, such as in the entire Eurasian steppe belt. By utilizing remote sensing data (MOD13A1), gridded climate data interpolated from weather station observations (CRU TS4.03), and drought index calculated from the CRU datasets (SPEI03 from SPEI database) at 500m*500m spatial resolution, we found that the semi-arid grasslands in our study area experienced severe droughts in the summers (June, July, and August) of 2007 (SPEI03min = -1.94) and 2017 (SPEI03min = -2.37). Surprisingly, in 2017, the grasslands appeared to be almost unaffected by the extreme drought (EVIano = 0.004), while in 2007, productivity was reduced during drought (EVIano = -0.026). 
    To explore why the semi-arid grasslands responded differently to these two summer drought events, partial correlation analysis was done by considering the influence of temperature, precipitation, and SPEI03 on EVI in summer during 2001-2018. The results showed that grasslands are generally significantly correlated to SPEI03 (39.73% pixels with p<0.1) rather than to temperature (13.27% pixels with p<0.1) or to precipitation (11.39% pixels with p<0.1).  However, when we compare the spatial distributions of EVI, temperature, precipitation, and SPEI in summer in 2007 and 2017, a different pattern emerges. Temperature patterns were similar between summer in 2007 and 2017, but precipitation patterns were different, resulting in different SPEI patterns. In regions which showed a significant, positive correlation with precipitation, there was heavier rainfall (100mm/month<precipitation<140mm/month) in 2017 than in 2007 (precipitation<100mm/month). The heavy rains offset the negative effect of heatwave, and enhanced grass productivity in areas with moderate temperature in summer in 2017. These results demonstrate the importance of monthly to seasonal precipitation patterns and provide a reference for management in response to extreme drought events in semi-arid grassland ecosystems.

    How to cite: Li, X. and Hajek, O.: Diverse responses of semi-arid grasslands to severe droughts in Inner Mongolia, China, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6810, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6810, 2022.

    The paper aims to investigate the nature of problems related to the implementation of polders as nature based solutions (NBS) for flood risk management in two European river basins – the Tisza and the Warta rivers. The research focuses on economic and institutional challenges related to the implementation of polders and on consequences for existing or potential ecosystems of the polder areas. An important aspect of the research focuses also on investigating the course of social innovations that led to the institutional preconditions needed for enhanced implementation of future investments for multi-purpose NBS for flood risk reduction in river basins located in the Central Europe.

    Due to the observed climate change in recent years, in both the Tisza and the Warta river basins, attempts have been made to regulate legal background for water management, in particular for flood risk reduction. As both regions are characterized by an increasing flood risk and significant flood damage related to the former flood events, it is necessary to investigate the possibility of the implementation of effective solutions for flood risk reduction that would be cost effective and at the same time contribute to the preservation of the environment according to the dual expectation of the Flood and Water Framework Directives.

    In both regions one of the analyzed and planned for implementation measures were polders that can contribute to significant flood risk reduction in local and regional scale. However, despite significant socio-economical and geographical similarities of both regions, the undertaken actions aimed at implementation of polders brought different (at parts even the opposite) outcomes. While actions undertaken in the Tisza river basin led to establishment of fully operational polders, polders in Poland are still in the plans. However, establishing new infrastructure in Hungary did not solve all problems related to flood risk management.

    The following issues related to establishing polders as Nature-Based Solutions will be analyzed:

    (i) Costs of establishing polders;

    (ii) Formal and legal condition;

    (iii) The role of interests and social conflicts;

    (iv) Environmental impact.

    According to the above, despite comprehensive plans prepared on the basis of the EU Water Framework Directive and Floods Directive, the investments in the Tisza and the Warta river basins brought unexpected outcomes (such us social conflicts, ambiguity of formal and legal conditions or negative environmental impact) that affect the effectiveness of NBS.

    Identification and description of the obstacles in the decision-making process related to the flood risk mitigation and characterization of ongoing social transformations in the Tisza and the Warta river cases provide insights for future investments in other Central European countries that face similar societal, environmental and economic challenges.

    How to cite: Warachowska, W., Ungvári, G., and Kis, A.: Institutional, economic and ecological challenges of nature-based solutions implementation for flood risk management in two Central-European river basins., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6836, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6836, 2022.

    EGU22-6838 | Presentations | BG3.28

    Climatic and anthropogenic drivers of river intermittence in Poland 

    Agnieszka Rutkowska, Marzena Osuch, Mirosław Żelazny, Kazimierz Banasik, and Mariusz Klimek

    Studies on river intermittence are pivotal in water management because water scarcity impacts, apart from the catchment itself, also neighbouring catchments and water reservoirs.

    River intermittence was noticed recently in Poland in small and mid-sized catchments. The objective of the study was to answer questions about whether drying showed an increasing tendency, what might be the drivers of the tendency, and how could anthropogenic activity affect the catchment reaction to drought conditions. The total number of zero-flow days and the maximum length of zero-flow events were analysed at the annual and seasonal scale in terms of metrics of intermittence, temporal trend, association with climatic conditions, and the link with anthropogenic pressure. The Standardised Precipitation Evapotranspiration Index (SPEI) was used in identifying the association between intermittence and the climatic drivers such as precipitation and temperature. Statistical methods, namely the circular statistics, the Spearman correlation coefficient, the Mann-Kendall test for monotonic trend, and the Cucconi and the Lepage tests for step trend were applied in the study.

    An increasing trend in the total number of zero-flow days and the maximum length of zero-flow events, as well as the negative correlation with the SPEI was detected in two catchments with natural flow regime. The increasing evapotranspiration was identified there as the possible driver of intermittence because the SPEI often showed a decreasing trend in summer months. In the catchment under strong anthropogenic pressure, the zero-flow occurrence resulted from climatological reasons as well as from the operation of the open-cast brown coal mines. The anthropogenic activity enhanced the reaction of the catchment to drought conditions. Some inhomogeneities in discharges were also detected downstream from the location of the dry river bed because of water transfers from the mine. The catchment response to drought conditions was reflected in the pattern of intermittence for natural catchments and for the catchment under strong anthropogenic pressure.

    The pattern of intermittence in the form of circular diagram can serve as an indicator of the degree of anthropogenic influence on runoff conditions.

    How to cite: Rutkowska, A., Osuch, M., Żelazny, M., Banasik, K., and Klimek, M.: Climatic and anthropogenic drivers of river intermittence in Poland, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6838, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6838, 2022.

    EGU22-7000 | Presentations | BG3.28

    Interception and groundwater dynamics of an alder forest and a neighbouring wet meadow 

    Blanka Holik, Csenge Nevezi, Kamila Hlavčová, Péter Kalicz, and Zoltán Gribovszki

    Riparian vegetation forms have strong dependence on hydrological factors. Forests and meadows in valley locations are strictly protected in many cases. Knowledge of the changes in their water balance in context of climate change is critical in terms of their survival.

    We studied the hydrology of a riparian alder forest and a neighbouring wet meadow at the outlet of the Hidegvíz valley experimental catchment (eastern foothills of the Alps). Interception loss (significant element of forest water balance) and groundwater uptake importance were analyzed. LAI and forest structural parameters were measured for calculating interception and remote sensing information were also used. We settled groundwater wells for groundwater level dynamics analysis. Meteorological parameters that we used for this analysis were measured in an open-air plot next to the examined ecosystems.

    Remote sensing data is useful for determination of LAI and so vegetation storage capacity dynamically in an interception model. Field interception measurement is important for exact model calibration. Measurements of groundwater levels with high frequency give us the possibility to determine groundwater dynamics and to estimate vegetation water uptake. On the basis of the results, interception loss and groundwater uptake of alder forest are significantly higher, so riparian forests have greater water demand for their survival in the changing climate.

    Acknowledgement: Research was supported by TKP2021-NKTA-43 project. Project no. TKP2021-NKTA-43 has been implemented with the support provided by the Ministry of Innovation and Technology of Hungary from the National Research, Development and Innovation Fund, financed under the TKP2021-NKTA funding scheme.”

    How to cite: Holik, B., Nevezi, C., Hlavčová, K., Kalicz, P., and Gribovszki, Z.: Interception and groundwater dynamics of an alder forest and a neighbouring wet meadow, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7000, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7000, 2022.

    EGU22-7017 | Presentations | BG3.28 | Highlight

    Possible solution of global environmental problems: adaptive landscape management 

    Pál Balázs, Adrienn Horváth, Imre Berki, Mátyás Szépligeti, and Éva Konkoly-Gyuró

    Traditional, small scale land use based on landscape potential is mostly less harmful to the ecosystem compared to present high production-oriented practices. However, low-intensity techniques are generally under-represented in the present land management system or even forgotten. We reveal these ancient management methods and practices in a western Transdanubian forest-dominated landscape of the Carpathian basin (Őrség) through interviews with local elderly people, literature review, historical map-based long term land use change detection and landscape character assessment. We evaluate the results from the point of view of the question: how these solutions could be helpful for the fight against biodiversity loss or even climate change.

    Acknowledgement: Project no. 141576 has been implemented with the support provided by the Ministry of Innovation and Technology of Hungary from the National Research, Development and Innovation Fund, financed under the MEC_R_21 funding scheme.

    How to cite: Balázs, P., Horváth, A., Berki, I., Szépligeti, M., and Konkoly-Gyuró, É.: Possible solution of global environmental problems: adaptive landscape management, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7017, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7017, 2022.

    EGU22-7101 | Presentations | BG3.28

    Factors influencing hydrology of a riparian woody pasture in western Hungary 

    Előd Szőke, Péter Csáki, Péter Kalicz, Péter Kutschi, and Zoltán Gribovszki

    Climate change induced droughts are a major threat to riparian ecosystems.  Water scarcity can degrade such types of ecosystems but with reasonable water supply these valuable wetland ecosystems can be preserved or those that have deteriorated can be restored.

    In the frame of this research we evaluated the hydrological reconstruction works of the Doroszló meadows habitat. Groundwater monitoring wells were installed at 4 selected locations in the area. Water table values and surface soil moisture were monitored  in parallel. Hydrological parameters  were recorded manually on a weekly basis. Data for the period from April 2019 to October 2021 were processed using  statistical methods such as “treatment-control space-time deviations” and “double mass curve”. 

    As a result we found that water supply interventions had a detectable effect on the groundwater level and soil mositure of the area, but some modifying factors had also influenced the hydrology of micro locations. Therefore taking into account local effects is very important in case of the evaluation of a water supply project.

    Acknowledgement: Research was supported by TKP2021-NKTA-43 project. Project no. TKP2021-NKTA-43 has been implemented with the support provided by the Ministry of Innovation and Technology of Hungary from the National Research, Development and Innovation Fund, financed under the TKP2021-NKTA funding scheme.”

    How to cite: Szőke, E., Csáki, P., Kalicz, P., Kutschi, P., and Gribovszki, Z.: Factors influencing hydrology of a riparian woody pasture in western Hungary, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7101, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7101, 2022.

    EGU22-8034 | Presentations | BG3.28 | Highlight

    The role of environmental extremes on urbanized areas of Western Hungary 

    Adrienn Horváth, Pál Balázs, Bernadett Bolodár-Varga, Péter Csáki, Zoltán Gribovszki, Péter Kalicz, Máté Katona, Renáta Szita, Péter Végh, Dániel Winkler, and András Bidló

    The impacts of climate change don’t appear only on natural areas but urbanized areas are also well affected. The unpredictable and extreme weather events

    such as the alternation of drought periods and heavy, stormy precipitation events was typical in the last decades. Three settlements were investigated to detect how the extreme weather events influenced the water, sediment, and soil conditions on anthropogenic affected areas. The studied areas are mostly surrounded by mountains and forestlands and crossed by a river or creek; therefore, close-to-nature ideas, climate strategies, and sustainable urban management are needed to prepare against changing conditions. A heavy storm may increase the leaching of contaminants into soil and watercourses. To support the adaptation, city-wide investigations began in the last decade to make further suggestions for future direction based on measurements and experience. Altogether 672 soil samples and 30 sediment samples were analyzed to give a basis for climate strategy and settlement development concept in the future.

    Project no. 141623 has been implemented with the support provided by the Ministry of Innovation and Technology of Hungary from the National Research, Development and Innovation Fund, financed under the MEC_R_21 funding scheme.

    How to cite: Horváth, A., Balázs, P., Bolodár-Varga, B., Csáki, P., Gribovszki, Z., Kalicz, P., Katona, M., Szita, R., Végh, P., Winkler, D., and Bidló, A.: The role of environmental extremes on urbanized areas of Western Hungary, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8034, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8034, 2022.

    EGU22-934 | Presentations | NH10.2

    Compound Hot-Dry Events in Urban India: Variability and Drivers 

    Poulomi Ganguli

    The precipitation deficit-temperature feedback can severely impact multiple sectors, such as reduction in crop yield to critical infrastructure failures, especially in low latitude areas (< 30°N). Typically, a heatwave event coincides with a significant decline in surface wind speed due to atmospheric blocking and is often compounded by persistent precipitation-deficit leading to meteorological droughts. Anomalous warm-and-dry air, which comes in torrents, results in an abrupt increase in air temperature that strengthens the local land-atmosphere feedback via soil desiccation. Based on daily meteorological observations covering the 1970-2018 period, first, I show a spatial coherence in the timing of unprecedented hot-dry events over major urban and peri-urban locations of the Indian sub-continent (8°4'N and 37°6'N). Surface wind data confirms a significant decline in low wind speed over most of the locations, especially over the eastern coastal plains of the country. Further, the compound occurrence of extreme temperature and low wind speed act as a preconditioning driver for sequential short (or long)-duration precipitation deficits across most of the sites. A copula-based joint distribution framework incorporating the compounding effect of high temperature, low wind speed, and precipitation deficit reveals a T-year severe hot-dry event tends to become more frequent. Finally, I show a median 6-fold amplifications in compound hot-dry frequency than that of the expected annual number of 50-year temperature extreme. The inferred amplifications are more pronounced in low-lying urban-coastal areas than in the interior locations, where decadal changes in (significant) increase in extreme temperature at several locations are contrasted by a concurrent decrease in surface wind speed.  

    How to cite: Ganguli, P.: Compound Hot-Dry Events in Urban India: Variability and Drivers, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-934, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-934, 2022.

    EGU22-1055 | Presentations | NH10.2

    Sub-seasonal temporal clustering of extreme precipitation: Spatio-temporal distribution, physical drivers and impacts 

    Alexandre Tuel, Bettina Schaefli, Jakob Zscheischler, and Olivia Romppainen-Martius

    The successive occurrence of extreme precipitation events on sub-seasonal (weekly to monthly) timescales can lead to large precipitation accumulations and severe impacts for humans and ecosystems. We take here a global perspective to explore the spatio-temporal distribution of sub-seasonal temporal clustering of extreme precipitation (TCEP) and the physical mechanisms that are responsible for it. We first discuss the seasonal distribution of TCEP and its statistical significance, assessed with Ripley’s K function. Though TCEP is mainly confined to the tropical oceans, it is also significant regionally in the Northern Hemisphere extra-tropics, especially along the eastern margins of ocean basins. We then examine thanks to Generalized Linear Models how large-scale modes of variability and regional dynamics affect the occurrence of temporal clustering across the world. In the tropics, ENSO, the Indian Ocean Dipole and the MJO all modulate TCEP frequency, while the effect of the North Atlantic Oscillation and Pacific North American pattern dominate in the Northern Hemisphere. We conclude with an impacts-focused discussion of how TCEP affects river discharge across Europe. TCEP leads to a higher and more prolonged discharge response, especially in pluvial-dominated catchments, and thus to higher flooding risk.

    How to cite: Tuel, A., Schaefli, B., Zscheischler, J., and Romppainen-Martius, O.: Sub-seasonal temporal clustering of extreme precipitation: Spatio-temporal distribution, physical drivers and impacts, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1055, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1055, 2022.

    EGU22-1222 | Presentations | NH10.2

    Compound flooding due to interaction of waves and river discharge at Breede Estuary, South Africa 

    Sunna Kupfer, Sara Santamaria-Aguilar, Lara van Niekerk, Melanie Lück-Vogel, and Athanasios T. Vafeidis

    Recent studies on compound flooding have considered the interaction of storm surge and fluvial or pluvial flood drivers, whereas the contribution of waves to compound flooding has so far been neglected. In this study, we assess compound flooding from waves, tides and river discharge at Breede Estuary, South Africa, using a hydrodynamic model. We estimate the contribution of extreme waves to compound flooding by analysing the driver interactions and by quantifying changes in flood characteristics. We further consider the effect of waves on flood timing and compare results of compound flood scenarios to scenarios in which single drivers are omitted. We find that flood characteristics are more sensitive to river discharge than to waves, particularly when the latter only coincide with high spring tides. When interacting with river discharge, however, the contribution of waves is high, causing larger flood extents and higher water depths. With more extreme waves, flooding can begin up to 12 hours earlier. Our findings provide insights on the magnitude and timing of compound flooding in an open South African estuary and demonstrate the need to account for the effects of waves during compound flooding in future flood impact assessments of similar coastal settings with similar wave climates.

    How to cite: Kupfer, S., Santamaria-Aguilar, S., van Niekerk, L., Lück-Vogel, M., and Vafeidis, A. T.: Compound flooding due to interaction of waves and river discharge at Breede Estuary, South Africa, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1222, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1222, 2022.

    EGU22-1469 | Presentations | NH10.2

    Compound high temperature and low net primary production extremes in the ocean over the satellite period 

    Natacha Legrix, Jakob Zscheischler, Charlotte Laufkötter, Keith Rodgers, Cecile Rousseaux, Ryohei Yamaguchi, and Thomas Frölicher

    Extreme events, such as marine heatwaves (MHWs), severely impact marine ecosystems. Of particular concern are compound events, i.e. situations when conditions are extreme for multiple ecosystem stressors, such as temperature and net primary productivity (NPP). In 2013-2015 for example, an extensive MHW, known as the Blob, cooccurred with low NPP and severely impacted marine life in the northeast Pacific, with cascading impacts on fisheries. Yet, little is known about the distribution and drivers of compound MHW and low NPP extreme events. We use satellite-based sea surface temperature and NPP estimates to provide a first assessment of these compound events. We reveal hotspots of compound MHW and low NPP events in the equatorial Pacific, along the boundaries of the subtropical gyres, and in the northern Indian Ocean. In these regions, compound events that typically last one week occur three to seven times more often than expected under the assumption of independence between MHWs and low NPP events. At the seasonal timescale, most compound events occur in summer in both hemispheres. At the interannual time-scale, their frequency is strongly modulated by large-scale modes of climate variability such as the El Niño-Southern Oscillation, whose positive phase is associated with increased compound event occurrence in the eastern equatorial Pacific by a factor of up to four. Using large ensemble simulations of two Earth system models, we then investigate the exact physical and biological drivers of these compound events. We find that both models suggest that MHWs in the low latitudes are often associated with low surface ocean nutrient concentrations due to enhance stratification and/or reduced upwelling, which limits the growth of phytoplankton resulting in extremely low NPP. However, the models show large disparities in simulated compound events and its drivers in the high latitudes. This identifies an important need for improved process understanding for high latitude compound MHW and low NPP events.

    How to cite: Legrix, N., Zscheischler, J., Laufkötter, C., Rodgers, K., Rousseaux, C., Yamaguchi, R., and Frölicher, T.: Compound high temperature and low net primary production extremes in the ocean over the satellite period, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1469, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1469, 2022.

    EGU22-2325 | Presentations | NH10.2

    Guidelines for studying diverse types of compound weather and climate events 

    Emanuele Bevacqua, Carlo De Michele, Colin Manning, Anaïs Couasnon, Andreia F. S. Ribeiro, Alexandre M. Ramos, Edoardo Vignotto, Ana Bastos, Suzana Blesić, Fabrizio Durante, John Hillier, Sérgio C. Oliveira, Joaquim G. Pinto, Elisa Ragno, Pauline Rivoire, Kate Saunders, Karin van der Wiel, Wenyan Wu, Tianyi Zhang, and Jakob Zscheischler

    Compound weather and climate events are combinations of climate drivers and/or hazards that contribute to societal or environmental risk. Studying compound events often requires a multidisciplinary approach combining domain knowledge of the underlying processes with, for example, statistical methods and climate model outputs. Recently, to aid the development of research on compound events, four compound event types were introduced, namely (a) preconditioned, (b) multivariate, (c) temporally compounding, and (d) spatially compounding events. However, guidelines on how to study these types of events are still lacking. Here, we consider four case studies, each associated with a specific event type and a research question, to illustrate how the key elements of compound events (e.g., analytical tools and relevant physical effects) can be identified. These case studies show that (a) impacts on crops from hot and dry summers can be exacerbated by preconditioning effects of dry and bright springs. (b) Assessing compound coastal flooding in Perth (Australia) requires considering the dynamics of a non-stationary multivariate process. For instance, future mean sea-level rise will lead to the emergence of concurrent coastal and fluvial extremes, enhancing compound flooding risk. (c) In Portugal, deep-landslides are often caused by temporal clusters of moderate precipitation events. Finally, (d) crop yield failures in France and Germany are strongly correlated, threatening European food security through spatially compounding effects. These analyses allow for identifying general recommendations for studying compound events. Overall, our insights can serve as a blueprint for compound event analysis across disciplines and sectors.

    How to cite: Bevacqua, E., De Michele, C., Manning, C., Couasnon, A., Ribeiro, A. F. S., Ramos, A. M., Vignotto, E., Bastos, A., Blesić, S., Durante, F., Hillier, J., Oliveira, S. C., Pinto, J. G., Ragno, E., Rivoire, P., Saunders, K., van der Wiel, K., Wu, W., Zhang, T., and Zscheischler, J.: Guidelines for studying diverse types of compound weather and climate events, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2325, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2325, 2022.

    The analysis of climate change impacts involves the utilisation of climate model output. Quite often, quantities of interest are compound events rather than “raw variables” such as temperature. Questions such as "what is the probability that temperature will exceed a high threshold for five consecutive days and how will this change in the future?" are quite common. Statistical (probabilistic) modelling of climate model output can be used to answer such questions by stochastically simulating the raw variables and then quantifying the compound events as a “by-product”. This is particularly useful since any compound event can be investigated using the same approach – since the raw variables are the ones being modelled.

    Such approaches however do not always scale well with big data sets and are often too complicated to even interpret appropriately. Here we present a way of analysing such data, using the (well-established) idea of a ‘moving window’ in conjunction with penalised smoothing splines and Generalised Additive Models (GAMs). The probabilistic nature of the resulting predictions provides a way of extrapolating beyond the range of the original data to robustly quantify the likelihood of rare events and their future changes. The approach is implemented in the Bayesian framework which results in full quantification of the associated uncertainty in using this method, e.g. increased uncertainty for extreme events way outside the range of the original data.

    The method is both scalable and paralleliseable and we present it in quantifying changes in regional climate model output. Due to the simplicity of the components that make up the approach, it can be argued that it is highly interpretable as well as robust to the choice of variables – we demonstrate this using temperature as well as humidity and precipitation, variables which are known to have very different statistical behaviour. We also demonstrate how the approach can be extended to capture the behaviour of more that one variable and use it to quantify the changes in compound hazard events such as the frequency of “warm-dry” days.

    How to cite: Economou, T. and Garry, F.: Probabilistic modelling and simulation of big spatio-temporal climate data for quantifying future changes of compound events, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3392, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3392, 2022.

    Many climate-related disasters often result from a combination of several climate drivers, also referred to as "compound events''. By interacting with each other, these hazards can lead to huge environmental and societal impacts, at a scale potentially far greater than any of these climate drivers could have caused separately. Marginal and dependence properties of climate drivers, as well as their changes over time, are key statistical properties influencing the probabilities of compound events. A better understanding of how the statistical properties of variables leading to compound events evolve and contribute to the change of their occurences is a crucial step towards risk assessments. Here, based on copula theory, we develop a new methodology to quantify the contribution of marginal and dependence properties to the overall probability of compound events. For illustration purposes, the methodology is applied to analyse changes of probability for compound precipitation and wind extremes, and their potential time of emergence, in a 13-member multi-model ensemble (CMIP6) over the region of Brittany (France). Results show that compound precipitation and wind extremes probabilities from CMIP6 ensembles mostly increase for the end of the 21st century. Yet, the contribution of marginal and dependence properties to these changes of probabilities can be very different from one model to another, reflecting a large uncertainty in climate modelling. These results highlight the importance of both marginal and dependence properties changes for future risk assessments due to compound events, and the need to understand the differences' sources of statistical properties between climate models.  

    How to cite: François, B. and Vrac, M.: Emergence of compound events: quantifying the importance of marginal and dependence properties changes, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3843, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3843, 2022.

    EGU22-3877 | Presentations | NH10.2

    Compound drought and heatwave identification: daily-scale independent extreme events based on 120-year observations 

    Baoying Shan, Bernard De Baets, and Niko Verhoest

    Under the challenge of climate change, the extremes, especially for extreme temperature, are observed at an increasing pace and are expected to be more severe in the future. It is critical to study heatwaves concurrently with droughts because of the intensification of negative impacts, such as exacerbating water shortage, crop failure and GPP reduction, wildfire and tree mortality, etc. This research focuses on compound events of droughts and heatwaves and presents a framework for the identification of drought or heatwave events and their compounds.

    While most studies only look at the summer season, we also consider compound drought and heatwave events in the winter season, as these are also important in view of their significant influence on wildfires, insect outbreaks, seed germination, etc.

    We introduce the notion of "relative heatwave" as being an extreme event compared with the average of the previous 30-year temperatures for that period. Drought and heatwave events are then identified based on SPI (standardized precipitation index) and SHI (standardized heatwave index). To overcome limitations arising from the scale inconsistency (monthly drought with daily heatwave) and coarse resolution (monthly or weekly drought), we apply the daily SPI and daily SHI, bringing a more accurate measure of the start and end dates, and severity. We also propose an objective, convenient and robust method to identify the statistically extreme and independent drought and heatwave events. Thresholds for removing small-scale events and merging proximate events are found by assuming the severity of the events to follow a generalized extreme value distribution and their arrivals to follow a Poisson process. Finally, we introduce four possible ways of identifying compound events (union, conditioned on drought, conditioned on heatwave, and intersection).

    To demonstrate our methodology, we made use of 120 years of daily precipitation and daily average temperature observed at the Belgian meteorological institute in Uccle, near Brussels.

    How to cite: Shan, B., De Baets, B., and Verhoest, N.: Compound drought and heatwave identification: daily-scale independent extreme events based on 120-year observations, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3877, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3877, 2022.

    EGU22-4371 | Presentations | NH10.2

    Enhanced impacts of compound precipitation and wind extremes on residential buildings 

    Jens Grieger and Uwe Ulbrich

    While it is known that severe winter wind storms are related with strong impacts, this study investigates the enhanced impact of compound precipitation and wind extremes. Therefore, we analyse the co-occurrence of extreme wind and precipitation using ERA5 reanalysis data for the European winter season. Co-occurring events are defined by simultaneous threshold exceedance of daily wind speed and precipitation in same or neighbouring areas.

    For the quantification of impacts, we are using daily insurance records of damages for residential buildings over Germany provided by the German Insurance Association (GDV). Using the definition of co-occurring extremes, those damage records can be grouped into compound and non-compound events. Analysing insurance loss data between 1997-2016 allows comparisons of the distribution of both groups. There are much more events in the non-compound group. On the other hand, the distribution of the compound group is shifted towards higher damages with an increased median of a factor of ten.

    How to cite: Grieger, J. and Ulbrich, U.: Enhanced impacts of compound precipitation and wind extremes on residential buildings, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4371, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4371, 2022.

    EGU22-4388 | Presentations | NH10.2

    Linking statistical, hydrodynamic and machine learning models for assessment of compound floods 

    Agnieszka Indiana Olbert, Stephen Nash, Joanne Comer, and Michael Hartnett

    Many large population centres are located along estuaries where freshwater flows merge with tidally-driven sea water. In these intertidal zones the river water levels are directly affected by the upstream flow and the downstream coastal conditions. Naturally, such coastal zones can be vulnerable to flood events both from a single driver or several drivers acting in a combination. The compound coastal floods levels may generate extreme impacts even if hazards from individual drivers in isolation would be unlikely. Moreover, the complexity of compound flooding is exacerbated by the presence of interactions (e.g. tide and surge) or dependencies between drivers (e.g. river discharge and surge). To fully understand the multi-driver flood dynamics, the multiple drivers and their impacts need to be assessed in an integrated manner.

    In this study the statistical and hydrodynamic models are linked to determine probabilities of multiple-driver flood events and associated risks. Cork City on the south coast of Ireland, frequently subject to complex coastal-fluvial flooding is used as a study case.  The research shows that in Cork Harbour and estuary, the tide-surge interactions have a damping effect on the total water level while dependencies between the surge residual and river flow amplify the risk of flooding. The study also shows that for the most accurate assessment of flood hazard, these phenomena need to be accounted for in the joint probability analysis. From a range of uni- and multivariate scenarios, the multivariate joint exceedance probability AND scenario that includes dependence between multiple drivers represents the most realistic representation of flood probabilities. The outputs from the statistical analysis were used to force the hydrodynamic model of Cork City floodplains. The MNS_Flood model was found to be a robust tool for mapping coastal flood hazards in tidally active river channels. Ultimately, the model results were used to build a machine-learning-based flood forecasting tool. A range of machine learning algorithms were tested to explore relationships between the flood drivers and the resulting spatially variable inundation patterns.

    The information derived from the integrated statistical, hydrodynamic and machine learning tools can provide a significant support for short-term early-warning applications as well as for the long-term flood management.

    How to cite: Olbert, A. I., Nash, S., Comer, J., and Hartnett, M.: Linking statistical, hydrodynamic and machine learning models for assessment of compound floods, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4388, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4388, 2022.

    EGU22-4727 | Presentations | NH10.2

    Quantifying the relationship between flood and wind damage over North-West Europe, in a present and future climate 

    Hannah Bloomfield, Paul Bates, Len Shaffrey, John Hillier, Rachel James, and Francesca Pianosi

    Strong winds and extremes in precipitation are capable of producing devastating socio-economic impacts across Europe. Although it is well known that individually these drivers cause billions of Euros of damage, their combined impacts are less well understood. Previous work has typically either focused on daily or seasonal timescales, demonstrating that compound wind and precipitation events are commonly associated with passing cyclones or particularly wet and windy years respectively. This study systematically investigates the relationships between national wind and flood damage metrics at all timescales ranging from daily to seasonal during the winter season. This work is completed using high resolution meteorological reanalysis and river flow datasets to explore the historical period (1980-present). As well as this, data from the UKCP18 climate projections at 2.2km and 12km resolution is used to understand historical sampling uncertainty, and the possible impacts of future climate change.

    The correlation between national aggregate wind gusts and precipitation peaks at ~10 days; whereas, the correlation between national aggregate wind gusts and river flows peaks at ~3 weeks. When using more impact focussed metrics of compound wind and flood events, such as storm severity and flooding indices, the strongest correlations are seen at seasonal timescales. Results show the historical correlation between wind and flood damage becomes weaker as the definition of the metrics become more impact focussed, and this is true across all timescales from daily to seasonal. This change in relationship is of key importance to the insurance industry who require actionable information based on both the meteorological hazards and on the exposure of their portfolios. The work is designed to support climate analytics for financial institutions, as part of the UK Centre for Greening Finance and Investments (UKCGFI). Results incorporating the impacts of climate change on compound wind and flood events will also be discussed.

    How to cite: Bloomfield, H., Bates, P., Shaffrey, L., Hillier, J., James, R., and Pianosi, F.: Quantifying the relationship between flood and wind damage over North-West Europe, in a present and future climate, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4727, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4727, 2022.

    EGU22-4916 | Presentations | NH10.2

    Global Assessment of Compound Risk of High Temperature and Low Streamflow 

    Rihui An, Pan Liu, and Xiaogang He

    In river flowing areas, the co-occurrence of high temperature and low streamflow may cause compound hydrologic hot-dry events (CHHDEs). When thermal and hydrological extremes interact, the impact can be worse than when they occur individually. Evidence shows that CHHDEs have severe socio-economic effects, such as increasing pollutant concentration, endangering aquatic species, and reducing power generation. Despite the importance, large-scale risk quantification of CHHDEs remains rarely studied due to the lack of enough simulated data at the global scale.

    Therefore, the objectives of this study are threefold: (1) developing the first global hydrologic hot-dry event dataset from 1901 to 2014 (containing four attributes: duration, intensity, severity, and magnitude) based on a state-of-the-art physically-based Tightly Coupled framework for Hydrology of Open water Interactions in River–lake network (TCHOIR) model, which dynamically simulates thermal and hydrological regimes; (2) developing a robust statistical framework to conduct attribution analysis to identify drivers of compound risk (distinguishing high temperature-driven, low streamflow-driven, and dependence-driven); (3) quantifying the impact of river order and hydrologic belt on compound risk to pinpoint CHHDEs hotspots.

    CHHDEs have multi-sectoral impacts, including water availability, food security, and energy production. The compound risk analysis provides crucial insights to maintain regional resilience and guide adaptation strategies.

    How to cite: An, R., Liu, P., and He, X.: Global Assessment of Compound Risk of High Temperature and Low Streamflow, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4916, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4916, 2022.

    EGU22-5346 | Presentations | NH10.2

    Dependence of lightning occurrence in Europe on large-scale flow patterns 

    Homa Ghasemifard, Pieter Groenemeijer, Francesco Battaglioli, and Tomas Pucik

    There is ample evidence that the occurrence of deep convection changes as a result of global warming and that, across Europe, increases in convective instability as measured by CAPE are an important driver in many regions. This study is a first step in disentangling the role that climate change induced changes in flow pattern occurrence plays on the evolution of the frequency of thunderstorms. Here we evaluate the association between large-scale flow patterns with the (temporal and spatial) distribution of lightning in Europe as detected by the Met Office Arrival Time Difference Network (ATDnet). The seasonal cycle shows that the largest number of lightning days occurs in the summer from May to August, the period we, therefore, focus on. The large-scale flow pattern is expressed using the daily mean 500 hPa geopotential extracted from ERA5 reanalysis data. A hierarchical clustering algorithm (Ward's method) is applied to the daily mean geopotential heights in the selected four-month period between 2007 and 2019. The algorithm produces 9 patterns (Fig. 1), with cluster 1 being the most frequent, occurring around 20% of the time and pattern 3 being the least frequent, occurring around 4% of the time. The distributions of lightning associated with the clusters show that lightning often occurs in synoptically quiescent conditions or even underneath a ridge. Furthermore, lightning occurrence over western Europe seems to be more dependent on the synoptic situation, where it is strongly associated with clusters that have a southerly flow at 500 hPa, compared to lightning over the Alpine range or south-eastern Europe.

     

    Fig. 1: Large-scale flow patterns are shown in nine clusters, geopotential heights of ERA5 at 500 hPa are plotted in the foreground with 50hPa intervals, and the mean number of lightning strikes per day is shown as filled contours.

    How to cite: Ghasemifard, H., Groenemeijer, P., Battaglioli, F., and Pucik, T.: Dependence of lightning occurrence in Europe on large-scale flow patterns, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5346, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5346, 2022.

    EGU22-5455 | Presentations | NH10.2

    Strong increase of probability of Northwestern European multi-year droughts in a warmer climate 

    Karin van der Wiel, Thomas Batelaan, and Niko Wanders

    Three consecutive dry summers in western Europe (2018-2019-2020) had widespread negative impacts on society and ecosystems, and started societal debate on (changing) drought vulnerability and needs to revise adaptation measures. To facilitate that discussion, we investigate multi-year droughts in the Rhine basin, with a focus on event probability in the present climate and in future warmer climates. Additionally, we studied the temporally compounding physical processes leading to multi-year drought events. A combination of multiple reanalysis datasets and multi-model large ensemble climate model simulations was used to robustly analyse the statistics and physical processes of these rare events. In these data, we identify two types of multi-year drought events (consecutive meteorological summer droughts and long-duration hydrological droughts), and show that these occur on average about twice in a 30 year period in the present climate, though natural variability is large (zero to five events in a single 30 year period). Projected decreases in summer precipitation and increases in atmospheric evaporative demand, lead to a doubling of event probability in a world 1 °C warmer than present and an increase in the average length of events. Consecutive meteorological summer droughts are forced by two, seemingly independent, summers of lower than normal precipitation and higher than normal evaporative demand. The soil moisture response to this temporally compound meteorological forcing has a clear multi-year imprint, resulting in a relatively larger reduction of soil moisture content in the second summer and potentially more severe drought impacts. Long-duration hydrological droughts start with a severe summer drought followed by lingering meteorologically dry conditions. This limits and slows down the recovery of soil moisture content to normal levels, leading to long-lasting drought conditions. This initial exploration provides avenues for further investigation of multi-year drought hazard and vulnerability in the region, which is advised given the projected trends and vulnerability of society and ecosystems.

    How to cite: van der Wiel, K., Batelaan, T., and Wanders, N.: Strong increase of probability of Northwestern European multi-year droughts in a warmer climate, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5455, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5455, 2022.

    EGU22-5659 | Presentations | NH10.2 | Highlight

    Temporal compound events: Are they represented in catastrophe models? 

    Stephanie Hodsman

    Temporal compound events are defined in recent literature as successive events which impact the same geographical region. These kinds of events have the ability to cause catastrophic impacts. If we treat them as single events in a catastrophe model, the overall event magnitude, impact, and subsequent losses would be underestimated. The United Kingdom is vulnerable to temporally-compounding events due to low-pressure systems from the north Atlantic Ocean: the storms Desmond, Eva, Frank that occurred in December 2015 and Ciara, Dennis, Jorge that occurred in February 2020 are some recent, notable temporally compounding events that caused large economic losses.

     

    For insurers and reinsurers to appropriately manage their exposure, it is imperative the tools they use truthfully reflect the risk of an insured asset being inundated several times due to temporal compound events. It has been recognised in previous research that catastrophe models are limited in their ability to handle connected, multi-hazard events. In addition, the risk of loss from temporal compound events should be demonstrated accordingly as the loss from a second event may not be as severe as the initial impact. Therefore, the definition of an event within a catastrophe model’s event set is extremely important. This provided the motivation to review temporal compound event representation in JBA Risk Management’s stochastic event set.

     

    We manipulated various versions of stochastic event sets for known historical temporal compound events, and we explored how these different event sets alter the losses from catastrophe models. This research allowed us to interpret the impact various modelling strategies would have on (re)insurance companies should similar events occur in the future and provided further questions on how is best to model natural catastrophes.

     

    How to cite: Hodsman, S.: Temporal compound events: Are they represented in catastrophe models?, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5659, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5659, 2022.

    EGU22-5662 | Presentations | NH10.2

    Hotspots of Changes in Exposure to Multivariate Extremes at Different Global Warming Levels 

    Fulden Batibeniz, Mathias Hauser, and Sonia Isabelle Seneviratne

    It is now certain that human-induced climate change is increasing the frequency, intensity, and spatial extent of climate and weather extremes globally. While a number of studies investigated these characteristics of individual extremes, an IPCC risk framework-like holistic approach introducing the potential impacts of the changes in concurrent and multivariate extremes is more informative. By using CMIP6 climate projections, historical and future population estimates we assess the influence of human and climate change on four concurrent extreme events (heatwave–drought, warm nights–high relative humidity, extreme 1-day precipitation–wind, drought–warm days-low relative humidity) in the preindustrial period (1850-1900) and at four global warming levels (GWLs from +1 °C to +3 °C). Our results show that concurrent occurrences of the investigated extremes become 1.2 to 8 times more frequent for the 3ºC GWL. The most dramatic increase is identified for compound heatwave–drought events, with an eight-fold increase in subtropical countries, a seven-fold increase in northern middle and high latitude countries, and a five-fold increase in tropical countries, respectively. Additionally, the number of events per capita showing the contribution of climate change alone exhibits a dramatic increase in compound heatwave–drought and warm days–low relative humidity-drought events over the Mediterranean countries, Europe, China, Australia, Russia, the United States, and the Northern part of South America, emphasizing the potential risk increase in the case of lack of concerted effort to cut greenhouse gas emissions.

    How to cite: Batibeniz, F., Hauser, M., and Seneviratne, S. I.: Hotspots of Changes in Exposure to Multivariate Extremes at Different Global Warming Levels, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5662, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5662, 2022.

    EGU22-6089 | Presentations | NH10.2

    Sea Level Rise Impact on Compound Coastal-river Flood Risk in Klaipeda city (Baltic coast, Lithuania) 

    Erika Čepienė, Lina Dailidytė, Edvinas Stonevičius, and Inga Dailidienė

    Due to climate change, extreme floods are projected to increase in the 21st century in Europe. As a result, flood risk and flood related losses might increase. It is therefore essential to simulate potential floods not only relying on the historical but also include future projecting data. Such simulations can give necessary information for development of flood protection measures and spatial planning. This paper analyzes the risk of compound flooding in the Dane River under different river discharge and Klaipeda Strait water level probabilities. Additionally, we examined how water level rise of 1 meter in the Klaipeda Strait could impacts Dane River floods in Klaipeda City. Flood extent was estimated with Hydrologic Engineering Center's River Analysis System (HEC-RAS) and visualized with ArcGIS Pro. Research results show that the rise of the water level in the Klaipeda Strait has a greater impact on the Central part of Klaipeda City, while the maximum discharge rates of the river—on the Northern upstream part of the analyzed river section. Sea level rise of 1 m could lead to the increase of area affected by Dane floods up to three times. Floods can cause significant damage to the infrastructure of Klaipeda Port City, urbanized territories in the City Center and residential areas in the Northern part of the City. Our results confirm that, in the long run, sea level rise will significantly impact the urban areas of the Klaipeda City situated to Baltic Sea coast.

    How to cite: Čepienė, E., Dailidytė, L., Stonevičius, E., and Dailidienė, I.: Sea Level Rise Impact on Compound Coastal-river Flood Risk in Klaipeda city (Baltic coast, Lithuania), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6089, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6089, 2022.

    EGU22-6351 | Presentations | NH10.2

    Compounding Wet and Cold-Extremes driven by an increasing Pan-Atlantic wave-4-pattern 

    Kai Kornhuber and Gabriele Messori

    Wintertime extremes such as cold spells and heavy precipitation events can have severe societal impacts, disrupting critical infrastructures, traffc and affecting human well-being. Here, we relate the occurrence of local and concurrent cold and wet wintertime extremes in North America and Western Europe to a recurrent, quasi-hemispheric wave-4 Rossby wave pattern in the Jetstream. We identify this pattern as a fundamental mode of Northern Hemisphere (NH) winter circulation exhibiting phase-locking behavior as the associated atmospheric circulation and surface anomalies re-occur over the same locations when the pattern's wave amplitude is high. The wave pattern is strongest over the pan-Atlantic region, and is associated with an increased probability of extreme cold or wet events by up to 300 % in certain areas of North America and Western Europe. We identify a significant increase in frequency over the past four decades (1979- 2021), which we hypothesise may derive from increased convective activity in the tropical Pacific, from where the pattern originates, while a weakened meridional temperature gradient linked to Arctic warming appears to have no direct effect on its occurrence. The identified pattern and its remote forcing might provide pathways for early prediction of local and concurrent cold or wet wintertime extremes in North America and Western Europe.

    How to cite: Kornhuber, K. and Messori, G.: Compounding Wet and Cold-Extremes driven by an increasing Pan-Atlantic wave-4-pattern, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6351, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6351, 2022.

    EGU22-7281 | Presentations | NH10.2

    Changes in likelihood and intensity of spatially co-occurring hot, dry and wet extremes 

    Bianca Biess, Lukas Gudmundsson, and Sonia I. Seneviratne

    The recent 2021 spring-to-summer season was characterized by co-occurrent hot, dry and extremely wet extremes around the globe, raising questions regarding changing likelihoods of such extreme years in a changing climate. To address this question, we assess the likelihood of spatially compounding hot, dry and wet extremes under historic and present climate as well as under different future warming levels. The occurrence-probability of spatially compounding events and area affected in future climates under scenarios at 1.5°C, 2°C and higher levels of global warming is determined using Earth System model simulations from the 6th Phase of the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project (CMIP6). As climate change impacts are particularly severe when spatially compounding events occur in multiple regions with high exposure of people or crops, this study focuses on densely inhabited regions and important agricultural areas. 

    How to cite: Biess, B., Gudmundsson, L., and Seneviratne, S. I.: Changes in likelihood and intensity of spatially co-occurring hot, dry and wet extremes, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7281, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7281, 2022.

    EGU22-7289 | Presentations | NH10.2

    Advancing compound modelling of tropical cyclone wind, surge and rain impacts – now and in a changing climate 

    Simona Meiler, Ali Sarhadi, Kerry Emanuel, and David N. Bresch

    Intense precipitation from tropical cyclones (TCs), typically accompanied by wind-driven storm surges and highly destructive winds, constitutes a significant threat for compound flooding and wind-driven impacts in many coastal regions worldwide. However, most present TC risk assessment methods only consider wind as the driving hazard and thus underestimate impacts emerging from compounding TC sub-hazards. Further, it is crucial to understand how this risk will shift and intensify in a warming climate. We thus present a coupled, physics-based modeling approach for the coastal area of Metropolitan Manila (PHL) to explicitly represent TC rainfall-induced freshwater flood, TC wind-driven storm surges, and direct impacts from TC wind for present and future climate. We use a large set of synthetic TCs generated from historical climate data (1985-2014) and from the late 21st century (2071-2100) SSP585 warming scenario to simulate TC wind fields and rainfall intensity data. Our modelling chain includes a hydrodynamical component to convert TC precipitation to freshwater flood and model wind-driven storm surges. We evaluate the compound socio-economic impacts from the TC sub-hazards using a state-of-the-art, open-source probabilistic damage model (CLIMADA). Ultimately, our advances in TC impact modelling can be applied in vulnerable coastal regions worldwide, enabling better-informed adaptation decisions and mitigation strategies.

    How to cite: Meiler, S., Sarhadi, A., Emanuel, K., and Bresch, D. N.: Advancing compound modelling of tropical cyclone wind, surge and rain impacts – now and in a changing climate, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7289, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7289, 2022.

    EGU22-7426 | Presentations | NH10.2

    Investigating compound flooding in Como 

    Fabiola Banfi and Carlo De Michele

    Compound events are extreme events whose impact is enhanced by the synergy, in time and/or space, of multiple variables. An example of this typology of events is provided by compound flooding. In this case, the resulting flooded area is increased by several factors, combining together; for example, the contemporaneous occurrence of high sea level and heavy precipitation (multivariate event), the presence of high soil saturation prior to rainfall events (preconditioned event), a precipitation event affecting several basins (spatially compounding event), or a succession of precipitation events (temporally compounding event). In this respect, we have adopted a compound analysis to study a series of floods that affected the town of Como (Northern Italy). Indeed, the town experiences recurrent damages due to the flooding of the nearby lake. In particular, we collected and analyzed 53 flood events, covering the period 1981-2020, in order to gain a better and more in-depth understanding of the phenomenon. This may eventually have important implications for the prediction and risk reduction of compound flooding.

    How to cite: Banfi, F. and De Michele, C.: Investigating compound flooding in Como, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7426, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7426, 2022.

    EGU22-7724 | Presentations | NH10.2

    Integrating responsiveness in the identification and characterization of compound heavy rainfall and wave storms events 

    Jose A. Jiménez, Jose Costa, Maribel Ortego, and Maria del Carmen Llasat

    From a risk management perspective, the relevance of compound events lies in the fact that they can significantly increase the intensity and/or the spatial and temporal extension of the impact (and damage) due to the synergic and/or cumulative action of different hazards. This compounding effect may overwhelm the capability of emergency-response services since these have to tackle an “unusual” high-damaging situation, they have to respond to a large number of emergency situations throughout the region at the same time, and/or they have to maintain the level of response during a relatively long period. Due to this, from this perspective, it would be important to incorporate the emergency/recovery services responsiveness to identify these events, as well as to evaluate their probability of occurrence. In this work we investigate this by parameterising this response as a time window between individual extreme events (rainfall and waves) to define the presence of a compound event. This time window depends on the intrinsic capacity of response of the available services, but also on the magnitude of contributing events as well as their spatial scale. In this work we analyse the variation of the probability of occurrence of compound heavy rainfall and wave storms events along the Catalan coast (NW Mediterranean) as a function of the responsiveness.

    This work was supported by the Spanish Agency of Research in the framework of the C3RiskMed (PID2020-113638RB-C21/ AEI /  10.13039/501100011033)

    How to cite: Jiménez, J. A., Costa, J., Ortego, M., and Llasat, M. C.: Integrating responsiveness in the identification and characterization of compound heavy rainfall and wave storms events, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7724, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7724, 2022.

    EGU22-7784 | Presentations | NH10.2 | Arne Richter Award for Outstanding ECS Lecture

    The emergence of compound event analysis as a new research frontier 

    Jakob Zscheischler

    Over recent years, research on compound weather and climate event has emerged as a new research frontier at the interface of climate science, climate impact research, engineering and statistics. Compound weather and climate events refer to the combination of multiple drivers and/or hazards that contribute to environmental or societal risk. Compound event analysis combines traditional research on climate extremes with impact-focused bottom-up assessments, thereby providing new insights on present-day and future climate risk. In this talk, I will illustrate my own trajectory into compound event analysis and highlight current and future challenges in this novel and exciting field of research. 

    How to cite: Zscheischler, J.: The emergence of compound event analysis as a new research frontier, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7784, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7784, 2022.

    EGU22-8014 | Presentations | NH10.2

    Interactions between compound extreme events and technological change over rice yield in China as an opportunity to adapt. 

    Sonia Quiroga, Cristina Suárez, Haoran Wang, and Virginia Hernanz

    Global climate change and more frequent and severe compound events poses a threat to agricultural productivity in China with important impacts on human development, and social stability. China has 18% about 25% of the world's grain production--accounting rice up to 34% of it.  Much of the existing research has focused on the important average effects of climate warming on rice yields showing. However, there is evidence about nonlinear interactions when compound events being present (ie. frost and heavy rainfall). As some of the major natural disasters in China at present, the overall spatial extent of drought and floods in China are expected to change significantly in the future, with more extreme events resulting. This paper analyzes total factor productivity growth in China's rice production to compute technological progress as an adaptative factor for total factor productivity growth response to compound extreme events. Labor inputs, education, fertilizer application and energy use are considered as control factors, jointly with socio-economic factors the the adoption of agricultural technology by growers. The Levinsohn-Petrin consistent semi-parametric estimation method was used to empirically analyze input-output panel data on rice yields in 30 Chinese provinces from 1990 to 2019 and to simulate the level of rice yield at the end of the 21st century under different RCPs scenarios. The model has stronger prediction ability for the central-eastern and southern production areas of China and reveals that rice yields may show opportunities of increase under average conditions for some climate scenarios, but it shows a bigger risk and vulnerability to compound extreme events.

     

    How to cite: Quiroga, S., Suárez, C., Wang, H., and Hernanz, V.: Interactions between compound extreme events and technological change over rice yield in China as an opportunity to adapt., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8014, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8014, 2022.

    EGU22-9715 | Presentations | NH10.2

    Differences between lowlands and highlands in terms of compound wind-precipitation events 

    Miloslav Müller, Marek Kašpar, and Milada Křížová

    Extreme precipitation events are associated with cyclones, atmospheric fronts or convective storms which produce high winds as well. This fact increases the probability of compound wind-precipitation events. Such events can cause even more damage than single precipitation and wind events because, for example, soil moisture makes trees less stable. The joint effect is even more significant in case of solid precipitation due to snow accumulations on trees. However, as the orographic precipitation enhancement increases mainly cold-season precipitation totals in highlands, the altitude makes the difference in the seasonal distribution of precipitation in Czechia. Thus, the local lowlands and highlands also partly differ in terms of the frequency of compound wind-precipitation events. We present this fact on data series of maximum daily wind gusts, daily precipitation totals and inter-diurnal increases in show depth from the period 1961 – 2020 at selected Czech weather stations, located in various altitudes. Extreme events are defined by the method of percentiles; frequencies of compound events are evaluated in comparison to the stochastic frequencies.

    How to cite: Müller, M., Kašpar, M., and Křížová, M.: Differences between lowlands and highlands in terms of compound wind-precipitation events, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9715, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9715, 2022.

    The Mediterranean region has been identified as a hotspot of climate change characterized by a large tree mortality. Especially holm (Quercus ilex L.) and cork oak trees (Quercus suber L.) in high-value and nature-based agroforestry systems (in Spain known as dehesa) have multiple positive effects, e.g., on the microclimate, carbon storage, erosion prevention, increase of soil water content and soil nutrient concentration. Many studies dealing with the oak decline (also called seca) reported the infestation by root pathogens, in particular the soil-born pathogen Phytophthora cinnamomi, as the main driver. However, rapidly, the focus shifted to the interaction of the pathogen and single abiotic conditions like drought.

    We assume that compound events (co-occurring warm spells and soil drought) have a larger correlation with vegetation indices than single climatic drivers. We analyse time series of two vegetation indices, namely the Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) and the kernel Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (kNDVI) as an indicator for greenness and vitality. In particular, we focus on the trend of both indices over about two decades (2003-2021) in eight different plots in our study area, on a dehesa in Huelva province, Andalusia. Subsequently, we correlate them with the decomposed signal of compound events.

    Based on precipitation and temperature data, we calculated two drought indices, namely the standardized precipitation index (SPI) and the standardized precipitation evapotranspiration index (SPEI). We then used these indices together with temperature to calculate so-called compound events, a co-occurrence of extreme values in multiple environmental drivers. To assess the status of the vegetation, we calculated the NDVI and its newly proposed kernel variant kNDVI from MODIS (MYD13Q1) and Landsat (4-5, 7,8) data in eight different plots in our study area. The kNDVI is a non-linear generalization of the NDVI and showed good behaviour in the Mediterranean and correlates stronger with the gross primary productivity (GPP) than the original NDVI. To extract physically meaningful information, we decomposed the time series signals with the Complete Ensemble Empirical Mode Decomposition with Adaptive Noise (CEEMDAN) method by Torres et al. (2011) into seasonality, trend, and a remainder part. CEEMDAN is suitable for non-linear and non-stationary time series. To analyse the relationships between vegetation indices and possible climatic drivers, we subsequently calculate lagged cross-correlations (i.e., correlation between different time series) between the Intrinsic Mode Functions (IMFs) of the signal expressing the trend and different seasonalities.

    We extracted different positive and significant (p < 0.01) NDVI trend signals from the MODIS time series. The seasonal component corresponded to the expected annual cycle. Based on these first results, we will correlate the NDVI and kNDVI trend signals with the calculated compound events to observe their role in the oak tree mortality.

    How to cite: Reddig, F., Bareth, G., and Bogner, C.: Effect of compound events on oak tree vitality in a climate change hotspot: analysis of time series in a traditional Spanish dehesa, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9852, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9852, 2022.

    EGU22-10342 | Presentations | NH10.2

    Climate extremes in Mediterranean metropolitan cities and atmospheric variability 

    Iliana Polychroni, Maria Hatzaki, Panagiotis T. Nastos, John Kouroutzoglou, and Helena A. Flocas

    The Mediterranean region is an area of increasing interest due to its unique climate. Nowadays, climate change has already evident consequences, such as the rise of extreme weather events, which significantly affect peoples’ life in the highly populated urban areas of the Mediterranean. Thus, in this study, ten metropolitan cities from the wider Mediterranean region with different climatic characteristics have been selected to study the frequency and the multidecadal trends of extreme events, as well as their possible connection with the large scale and synoptic scale atmospheric variability.

    Four combined extreme indices have been evaluated on annual and seasonal basis for the period 1950-2018 using the high-resolution E-OBS gridded daily mean temperature and precipitation datasets (0.1° x 0.1°; v.19e) from the European Climate Assessment & Dataset (ECA&D, Klein Tank et al. 2002, www.ecad.eu). These combined extreme indices refer to the joint modes of temperature and precipitation extremes, concerning the co-occurrence of Cold/Dry days (CD), Cold/Wet days (CW), Warm/Dry days (WD), Warm/Wet days (WW), which can reflect extreme conditions better than temperature or precipitation statistics considered separately (Beniston, 2009; 2011). The links of the extreme events with the atmospheric variability are investigated based on large-scale teleconnection indices and spatiotemporal distribution of cyclonic activity. Toward this, the comprehensive climatology of Mediterranean cyclones assembled was used by applying a cyclone tracking algorithm (Murray and Simmonds, 1991; Flocas et al., 2011) with respect to the ECMWF ERA5 Interim mean sea level pressure fields since 1950.

    The findings of the analysis showed distinct temporal and spatial variations of the combined extremes occurrences in the cities across the Mediterranean, which can be attributed to the effects of its complex topography, as well as to the non-uniform influence of the atmospheric variability. Specifically, the CD and WD indices have higher annual occurrences than the CW and WW, which indicates that the wider Mediterranean region experiences more dry days, either cold or warm, than wet days. The urban areas most affected by cold/dry events are located on the western Africa, while almost all urban areas around the Mediterranean coast are impacted by higher number of warm/dry events, with increasing trends.

    References: Beniston M., 2009, Geophys. Res. Lett., 36, L07707; Beniston M., and Coauthors, 2011, Int. J. Climatol., 31, 1257-1263; Murray and Simmonds, 1991 Aust Met Mag 39 155 166; Flocas et al., 2010, J Climate, 23(19), 5243-5257

    How to cite: Polychroni, I., Hatzaki, M., Nastos, P. T., Kouroutzoglou, J., and Flocas, H. A.: Climate extremes in Mediterranean metropolitan cities and atmospheric variability, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10342, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10342, 2022.

    EGU22-10344 | Presentations | NH10.2

    Role of climatic oscillations in causing spatially and temporally compound droughts and heatwaves 

    Waqar ulhassan and Munir Ahmad Nayak

    Compound drought and heatwaves (CDHWs) often cause severe ecological and socioeconomic damages; however, these impacts amplify when such temporally compound events occur concurrently in distant regions. Although spatially concurrent univariate extremes (e.g., droughts) have been explored globally and usually linked to large-scale climatic oscillations, such as El-Niño Southern Oscillation (ENSO) and global warming, spatial co-occurrence of CDHWs remains understudied. Here, we present a novel methodology to identify regions that have higher-than-expected chances of experiencing CDHWs concurrently. Using daily precipitation and temperature data from Climate Prediction Centre (CPC) and ERA5, we find robust spatially concurrent CDHWs in multiple regions that are thousands of kilometres apart, revealing teleconnections in CDHWs. Composite anomalies of geopotential heights and sea surface temperatures reveal El-Niño as the major cause of teleconnections in CDHWs in tropical and sub-tropical regions. Height anomalies during extra-tropical teleconnections reveal quasi-stationary Rossby waves that often produce persistent atmospheric blockings over climacteric locations in vicinity of compound regions. The insights gained here offer new avenues in studying spatially and temporally concurrent hydrologic extremes.

    How to cite: ulhassan, W. and Nayak, M. A.: Role of climatic oscillations in causing spatially and temporally compound droughts and heatwaves, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10344, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10344, 2022.

    EGU22-11062 | Presentations | NH10.2

    The precautionary principles of the potential risks of compound events in Danish municipalities 

    Luise-Ch. Modrakowski, Jian Su, and Anne Bach Nielsen

    The risk of compound events is defined as probable weather and climate events where many factors and dangers combine to cause catastrophic socio-economic repercussions. Compound events affecting vulnerable societies are thus a major security risk. Compound events are rarely documented, making preparedness difficult. This study examines how climate risk management is perceived and practiced in flood-prone Danish municipalities (i.e., Odense, Hvidovre, and Vejle). These practices reveal how different understandings of compound events influence risk perceptions and, thus, policy decisions. We discovered through expert interviews and policy documents that specific Danish municipalities recognize compound events as a condition or situation and develop precautionary principles. Depending on their location, they see compound events as either a vague tendency (Odense), a trend to be monitored (Hvidovre), or a partial reality (Vejle). They see flood drivers and their combinations as serious physical hazards to which they adapt. By focusing on local governance systems, it revealed the need to critically assess the mismatch between responsibility and capability, as well as the ongoing fragmentation of services related to climate concerns in Danish municipalities. The findings show that one discipline cannot address the complicated challenge of compound events. The report recommends expanding scientific techniques and increasing local focus in compound event research to stimulate creative thinking, better planning, and enhanced risk management.

    How to cite: Modrakowski, L.-Ch., Su, J., and Nielsen, A. B.: The precautionary principles of the potential risks of compound events in Danish municipalities, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11062, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11062, 2022.

    Compound hazards refer to two or more different natural hazards occurring over the same time period and spatial area. Compound hazards can operate on different spatial and temporal scales than their component single hazards. This work proposes a definition of compound hazards in space and time and presents a methodology for the Spatiotemporal Identification of Compound Hazards (SI–CH). The approach is applied to the analysis of compound precipitation and wind extremes in Great Britain, from which we create a database. Hourly precipitation and wind gust values for 1979–2019 are extracted from climate reanalysis (ERA5) within a region including Great Britain and the British channel. Extreme values (above the 99% quantile) of precipitation and wind gust are clustered with the Density-Based Spatial Clustering of Applications with Noise (DBSCAN) algorithm, creating clusters for precipitation and wind gusts. Compound hazard clusters that correspond to the spatial overlap of single hazard clusters during the aggregated duration of the two hazards are then identified. Our ERA5 Hazard Clusters Database consists of 18,086 precipitation clusters, 6190 wind clusters, and 4555 compound hazard clusters. The methodology’s ability to identify extreme precipitation and wind events is assessed with a catalogue of 157 significant events (96 extreme precipitation and 61 extreme wind events) in Great Britain over the period 1979–2019. We find a good agreement between the SI–CH outputs and the catalogue with an overall hit rate (ratio between the number of joint events and the total number of events) of 93.7%. The spatial variation of hazard intensity within wind, precipitation and compound hazard clusters are then visualised and analysed. The study finds that the SI–CH approach can accurately identify single and compound hazard events and represent spatial and temporal properties of these events. We find that compound wind and precipitation extremes, despite occurring on smaller scales than single extremes, can occur on large scales in Great Britain with a decreasing spatial scale when the combined intensity of the hazards increases. 

    How to cite: Tilloy, A., Malamud, B., and Joly-Laugel, A.: A Methodology for the Spatiotemporal Identification of Compound Hazards: Wind and Precipitation Extremes in Great Britain (1979–2019), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11194, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11194, 2022.

    EGU22-11534 | Presentations | NH10.2

    Compound events in Germany: drivers and case studies 

    Florian Ellsäßer and Elena Xoplaki and the The climXtreme research network on climate change and extreme events

    The 2018 compound of hot and dry conditions in Central Europe are unprecedented in magnitude, duration and spatial extent since measurements started in 1881. During spring and summer, these compounding of extreme conditions caused a series of severe impacts on several sectors including agriculture, forestry, transport, energy and water supply. At the beginning of the same year, windstorm Friederike concurrent with heavy snowfall caused severe damages in Ireland, Great Britain, northern France, Belgium, the Netherlands, Germany, Czech Republic and Poland. Friederike reached wind gusts of the order of 100 – 150 km/h, up to 173 km/h at Sněžka in Czech Republic and 203 km/h at Brocken in Germany.

    Along the trajectory from large to the local scale, the drivers and dynamics of these events are analyzed and the impacts of the compound events are provided. Exemplary for 2018, the impacts of the compound events comprise traffic disruption, power outages, property damage by e.g., falling trees, and fatalities after the windstorm. Unprecedented winter wheat yield reductions were observed as well after the hot and dry spring and summer growing season. The impact of the drought and heat wave compound further facilitated the outbreak of bark beetle in 2018 and the following years, as a cumulative hazard and increased the probability of a dry surface water anomaly to an unexpected 68 %.

    Taking advantage of the transdisciplinary research and gathered expertise in the frame of the coordinated German ClimXtreme project network (www.climxtreme.net), we analyze and characterize these 2018 events that link with severe impacts in Germany and neighboring countries in Central Europe. We focus on two key storylines with respect to the selected case studies of compound wind & rain and drought & heat. We provide a detailed overview of the data, methods and approaches used, the scales and aspects involved as well as the events’ drivers/dynamics and their multi-sectorial impacts. We finally demonstrate the importance of considering the various facets of the compound nature of extremes and respond to timely research questions that the ClimXtreme research network addresses, such as: attribution of changing compound events to climate change, understanding the variability of clustered storms, understanding the role of decadal variations on compound heat metrics, understanding and predicting the effects of climate change on landslides, analysis of past and future changes in the frequencies of compound events.

    How to cite: Ellsäßer, F. and Xoplaki, E. and the The climXtreme research network on climate change and extreme events: Compound events in Germany: drivers and case studies, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11534, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11534, 2022.

    EGU22-359 | Presentations | NH1.4

    Is climate change to blame for rising climatic disasters mortality in Nepal? 

    Dipesh Chapagain, Luna Bharati, and Christian Borgemeister

    Human mortality and economic losses due to climatic disasters have been rising globally. Several studies argue that this upward trend is due to rapid growth in the population and wealth exposed to disasters. Others argue that rising extreme weather events due to anthropogenic climate change are responsible for the increase. Hence, the causes of the increase in disaster impacts remain elusive. Disaster impacts are higher in low-income countries, but existing studies are mostly from developed countries or at the cross-country level. This study will assess the attribution of rising climatic disaster mortality to indicators of climatic hazards, exposure, and vulnerability at the subnational scale in a low-income country, using Nepal as a case study. 
    This empirical study at the scale of 753 local administrative units of Nepal will follow a regression-based approach that will overcome the limitations of the commonly used loss normalization approach in studying the attribution of disaster-induced loss and damage.

    In Nepal, landslides and floods account for more than two-thirds of the total climatic disaster mortality. Hence, we will use the past 30 years (1991-2020) landslides and floods mortality data from DesInventar and Nepal's Disaster Risk Reduction portal as the dependent variable. As explanatory variables to represent climatic hazards, we will estimate and use mean and extreme precipitation indices from observational data by the Department of Hydrology and Meteorology Nepal. We will use the local unit’s population as a proxy of disaster exposure. Socio-economic and environmental indicators such as annual per capita income, percentage of people with access to mobile phones and internet, land cover distribution, and slope will be used as indicators of vulnerability. Exposure and vulnerability indicators data will be accessed from Nepal’s Central Bureau of Statistics and other sources. This study is expected to identify indicators of climatic hazards, exposure, and vulnerability that could explain the spatial and temporal variability of climatic disaster mortality in Nepal. Similarly, it will provide new insights on the role of climate change on rising climatic disaster mortality from the low-income countries’ context.

    How to cite: Chapagain, D., Bharati, L., and Borgemeister, C.: Is climate change to blame for rising climatic disasters mortality in Nepal?, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-359, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-359, 2022.

    EGU22-1314 | Presentations | NH1.4

    Amplification of annual and diurnal cycles of alpine lightning over the past four decades 

    Thorsten Simon, Georg J. Mayr, Deborah Morgenstern, Nikolaus Umlauf, and Achim Zeileis

    Motivation: The response of lightning to a changing climate is not fully understood. Historic trends of proxies known for fostering convective environments suggest an increase of lightning over large parts of Europe. Since lightning results from the interaction of processes on many scales, as many of these processes as possible must be considered for a comprehensive answer.

    Objectives: Our aim is a probabilistic reconstruction of summer lightning over the European Eastern Alps down to its seasonally varying diurnal cycle. This necessitates consideration of many processes which becomes feasible by combining a statistical learning approach with several recent scientific achievements: Decade-long seamless lightning measurements by the Austrian Lightning Detection & Information System (ALDIS) and hourly reanalyses of atmospheric conditions including cloud micro-physics within the fifth generation ECMWF atmospheric reanalysis (ERA5).

    Methods: These two data sets have been linked by the statistical learning approach called generalized additive model (GAM). GAMs are capable to identify nonlinear relationships between the target variable (lightning yes/no) and explanatory variables (ERA5). The most important explanatory variables have been selected objectively using a combination of stability selection and gradient boosting. This objective selection has reduced the pool of 85 potential ERA5 variables to the 9 most important ones. This reduced set still represents a large variety of processes including favorable environments for thunderstorms, charge separation and trigger mechanisms. The performance of the resulting GAM has been tested using cross-validation over the period of 2010-2019. 

    Results: With the resulting GAM lightning for the Eastern Alps and their surroundings has been reconstructed over a period of four decades (1979-2019). The most intense changes occurred over the high Alps where lightning activity doubled in the past decade compared to the 1980s. There, the lightning season reaches a higher maximum and starts one month earlier. Diurnally, the peak is up to 50% stronger with more lightning strikes in the afternoon and evening hours. Signals along the southern and northern alpine rim are similar but weaker whereas the flatlands north of the Alps have no significant trend.

    How to cite: Simon, T., Mayr, G. J., Morgenstern, D., Umlauf, N., and Zeileis, A.: Amplification of annual and diurnal cycles of alpine lightning over the past four decades, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1314, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1314, 2022.

    EGU22-1758 | Presentations | NH1.4

    The role of cyclones and PV cutoffs for the occurrence of unusually long wet spells in Europe 

    Matthias Röthlisberger, Barbara Scherrer, Andries Jan de Vries, and Raphael Portmann

    The synoptic dynamics leading to the longest wet spells in Europe are so far poorly investigated, despite these events’ potentially large societal impacts. In this study we examine the role of cyclones and PV cutoffs for unusually long wet spells in Europe, defined as the 20 longest uninterrupted periods with at least 5 mm daily accumulated precipitation at each ERA-Interim grid point in Europe (this set of spells is hereafter referred to as S20). The S20 occur predominantly in summer over the eastern continent, in winter over the North Atlantic, in winter or fall over the Atlantic, and in fall over the Mediterranean and European inland seas. Four case studies reveal archetypal synoptic storylines for long wet spells: (a) A seven-day wet spell near Moscow, Russia, is associated with a single slow-moving cutoff-cyclone couple; (b) a 15-day wet spell in Norway features a total of nine rapidly passing extratropical cyclones and illustrates serial cyclone clustering as a second storyline; (c) a 12-day wet spell in Tuscany, Italy, is associated with a single but very large cutoff-complex, which is replenished multiple times by a sequence of recurrent anticyclonic wave breaking events over the North Atlantic and western Europe; and (d) a 17-day wet spell in the Balkans features intermittent periods of diurnal convective precipitation in an environment of weak synoptic forcing and recurrent passages of upper-level troughs and PV cutoffs and thus also highlights the role of diurnal convection for long wet spells over land. A systematic analysis of cyclone and cutoff occurrences during the S20 reveals considerable spatial variability in their respective role for the S20. For instance, cyclones and cutoffs are present anywhere between 10% and 90%, and 20% and 70% of the S20 time steps, respectively, depending on the geographical region. However, overall both cyclones and cutoffs, appear in larger number and at a higher rate during the S20 compared to climatology. Furthermore, in the Mediterranean, the PV cutoffs and cyclones are significantly slower moving and/or longer-lived during the S20 compared to climatology. Our study thus documents for the first time the palette of synoptic storylines accompanying unusually long wet spells across Europe, which is a prerequisite for developing an understanding of how these events might change in a warming climate and for evaluating the ability of climate models to realistically simulate the synoptic processes relevant to these events.

    How to cite: Röthlisberger, M., Scherrer, B., de Vries, A. J., and Portmann, R.: The role of cyclones and PV cutoffs for the occurrence of unusually long wet spells in Europe, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1758, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1758, 2022.

    EGU22-1843 | Presentations | NH1.4

    The impact of compound drought and heatwave events on the unprecedented 2020 fire season in the Pantanal, Brazil 

    Renata Libonati, João L Geirinhas, Patrícia S Silva, Ana Russo, Julia A Rodrigues, Liz B C Belem, Joana Nogueira, Fabio O Roque, Carlos C DaCamara, Ana M B Nunes, Jose A Marengo, and Ricardo M Trigo

    The year of 2020 was characterised by an unprecedented fire season in Pantanal, the largest continuous tropical wetland, located in south-western Brazil. This event was the largest ever recorded over, at least, the last two decades, reaching an amount of 3.9 million ha and affecting 17 million vertebrates1,2. Recent evidence points out that this event resulted from a complex interplay between human, landscape, and meteorological factors3,4. Indeed, much of the Pantanal has been affected by severe dry conditions since 2019, with 2020’s drought being the most extreme and widespread ever recorded in the last 70 years5,6. The drought condition was maintained at record levels during most of the year of 2021, following the climate change scenarios expected for this region7. Prior to this comprehensive assessment, the 2020’s fire season has been analyzed at the univariate level of a single climate event, not considering the co-occurrence of extreme and persistent temperatures with soil dryness conditions. Here, we show that the influence of land–atmosphere feedbacks contributed decisively to the simultaneous occurrence of dry and hot spells, exacerbating fire risk. These hot spells, with maximum temperatures 6 ºC above-average were associated with the prevalence of the ideal synoptic conditions for strong atmospheric heating, large evaporation rates and precipitation deficits4. We stress that more than half of the burned area during the fire season occurred during compound drought-heatwave conditions. The synergistic effect between fuel availability and weather-hydrological conditions was particularly acute in the vulnerable northern forested areas. These findings are relevant for integrated fire management in the Pantanal as well as within a broader context, as the driving mechanisms apply across other ecosystems, implying further efforts for monitoring and predicting such extreme events.

     

    References

    [1] Garcia, L.C, et al.. Record-breaking wildfires in the world’s largest continuous tropical wetland: Integrative fire management is urgently needed for both biodiversity and humans. J. Environ. Manage. 2021, 293, 112870.

    [2] Tomas, W. M., et al. Counting the dead: 17 million vertebrates directly killed by the 2020’s wildfires in the Pantanal wetland, Brazil. Sci. Rep. accepted.

    [3] Libonati, R.; et al. Rescue Brazil’s burning Pantanal wetlands. Nature. 2020, 588, 217–219.

    [4] Libonati, R., et al. Assessing the role of compound drought and heatwave events on unprecedented 2020 wildfires in the Pantanal. Environmental Research Letters. 2022, 17, 1.

    [5] Thielen, D., et al. The Pantanal under Siege—On the Origin, Dynamics and Forecast of the Megadrought Severely Affecting the Largest Wetland in the World. Water. 2021, 13(21), 3034.

    [6] Marengo, J.A., et al. Extreme Drought in the Brazilian Pantanal in 2019–2020: Characterization, Causes, and Impacts. Front. Water. 2021, 0, 13.

    [7] Gomes, G.D.; et al.. Projections of subcontinental changes in seasonal precipitation over the two major river basins in South America under an extreme climate scenario. Clim. Dyn. 2021, 1-23.

     

    This work was supported by Project Rede Pantanal from the Ministry of Science, Technology and Innovations of Brazil (FINEP grant 01.20.0201.00). R.L. was supported by CNPq [grant 305159/2018–6] and FAPERJ [grant E26/202.714/2019]

    How to cite: Libonati, R., Geirinhas, J. L., Silva, P. S., Russo, A., Rodrigues, J. A., Belem, L. B. C., Nogueira, J., Roque, F. O., DaCamara, C. C., Nunes, A. M. B., Marengo, J. A., and Trigo, R. M.: The impact of compound drought and heatwave events on the unprecedented 2020 fire season in the Pantanal, Brazil, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1843, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1843, 2022.

    EGU22-2312 | Presentations | NH1.4

    Erosion of arable land during the July 2021 flood event in Erftstadt-Blessem, Germany: understanding groundwater sapping 

    Joel Mohren, Matthias Ritter, Steven A. Binnie, and Tibor J. Dunai

    Although fluvial erosion is predominantly governed by surface driven fluvial incision, more exotic erosional processes can significantly contribute to the fluvial shaping of landscapes. To this group belongs sapping caused by concentrated groundwater discharge, which can form a very distinct type of topography (characterised e.g. by the development of theatre-shaped channel heads). Fluvial erosion through sapping occurs where groundwater encounters a rapid change in elevation (i.e. across scarps, cliffs), and it is highly modulated by the physical properties of the solid. Groundwater sapping is, for example, promoted by inhomogeneities of permeability and/or lithological composition of the subsurface, which is often prevalent in sedimentary deposits and along contact boundaries between different lithological units. Consequently, topography shaped by groundwater sapping can be found in many places on Earth and even on Mars, and the formation of these landscapes can integrate over thousands to millions of years. However, in some regions, such as coastal areas, groundwater sapping has been reported to be associated with severe soil loss and high erosion rates on the order of tens of metres per day.

    A similar magnitude of soil loss could be observed close to the village of Erftstadt-Blessem, Germany, as caused by severe flooding, peaking the 15th of July 2021. Here, intense rain events caused the formation of local drainage networks towards a gravel pit located to the north of the village. As a consequence, adjacent arable land was subject to intense backward incision, thereby eroding the underlying Quaternary sediments. The erosion formed drainage networks that appear to resemble characteristic groundwater sapping. This fluvial topography was largely preserved after the flooding, thus providing the opportunity to decipher the processes involved in the formation of these features. We use Structure-from-Motion Multi-View Stereo (SfM-MVS) photogrammetry to reconstruct the drainage geometry based on drone imagery (provided by the Kreisverbindungskommando Köln, M. Wiese; additional SfM-MVS photogrammetry data provided by ESRI Deutschland GmbH, T. Gersthofer) and photographs taken in the field using a handheld camera. The data is subsequently used to characterise the drainage networks and to compare the topography to other groundwater sapping landscapes on Earth and on Mars. Additionally, we intend to perform grain size analyses of the different sediment layers and to quantify fallout 239+240Pu in selected samples to asses the physical properties of the substratum and to trace the fate of the radionuclides during the flood event. Our aim is that our data will contribute to a better understanding of how groundwater sapping processes operate over time and to assess the importance of individual factors (e.g. substrate properties, vegetation cover and -type) on the severity of erosion. The outcome could thus not only be important for modelling terrestrial and extra-terrestrial processes but has also practical applications to the loss of arable land and the effects of outburst flooding.

    How to cite: Mohren, J., Ritter, M., Binnie, S. A., and Dunai, T. J.: Erosion of arable land during the July 2021 flood event in Erftstadt-Blessem, Germany: understanding groundwater sapping, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2312, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2312, 2022.

    EGU22-2532 | Presentations | NH1.4

    Using Vertical Integrated Liquid Density from a Weather Radar Network to Nowcast Severe Events 

    Laura Esbrí, Tomeu Rigo, M. Carmen Llasat, and Antonio Parodi

    This contribution has the main goal of identifying, characterizing, tracking and nowcasting severe thunderstorms using the Density of the Vertical Integrated Liquid (DVIL). The DVIL can synthesize all the volumetric information of a column of the weather radar in a 2D plane. This is, it estimates the quantity of precipitable liquid water in the column but, besides, it reduces the dependency on the height of the column. This point becomes crucial to give an appropriate weight of potential danger to thunderstorms that occurred out of the typical convective season. . This is particularly useful to improve the decision-making and early warning in critical environments and infrastructures, like airports and air traffic management (ATM). The usage of DVIL has multiple advantages, for instance, reducing the computational time consumed on the analysis of large areas. Also, to obtain a good and simple description of the potentially dangerous thunderstorms, and to have an easily integrating into other systems for ATM decision making. The main disadvantage is a less precise characterization of the atmospheric objects than with the whole radar volumetric data. Nevertheless, the differences are scarce and do not produce any significant inconvenience in the procedure. The algorithm first identifies those areas exceeding a DVIL threshold, which is established for thunderstorms with a certain probability of producing severe weather. The characterization module turns out simpler than in other methodologies because of the data type (2D instead of 3D reflectivity fields), but it can be combined with other data types if needed. The tracking and nowcasting procedure obtain the past trajectory of the thunderstorm and then use it to weather forecast from 5 to the next 60 minutes, with 5 minutes steps. Different convective episodes that have affected the proximity of Italian and Spanish airports have been analysed to evaluate the following points: (1) the performance of the correct identification of potentially dangerous thunderstorms, (2) the capability of tracking the path and characterizing the life cycle of those storms, and (3) the ability of the nowcasting to correctly forecast the time and the most dangerous area.

    This project has received funding from the SESAR Joint Undertaking under grant agreement No 892362, SINOPTICA-H2020 (Satellite-borne and IN-situ Observations to Predict the Initiation of Convection for Air traffic management) project.

    How to cite: Esbrí, L., Rigo, T., Llasat, M. C., and Parodi, A.: Using Vertical Integrated Liquid Density from a Weather Radar Network to Nowcast Severe Events, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2532, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2532, 2022.

    EGU22-3090 | Presentations | NH1.4

    Flood analysis using HEC-RAS: The case study of Majalaya, Indonesia under the CMIP6 projection 

    Faizal Immaddudin Wira Rohmat, Ioanna Stamataki, Zulfaqar Sa'adi, and Djelia Fitriani

    Flooding is a natural disaster with extremely wide-reaching impacts and is a recurring problem in Indonesia. Whilst possible impacts of climate change are expected to aggravate flood risk in already flood-vulnerable areas, many countries struggle to achieve the United Nations’ (UN) 2030 Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) to achieve a better and more sustainable future for all. Using the case study of Majalaya, Indonesia, the authors investigated the impact of climate change and climate variability on urban flood risk through science-based spatio-temporal flood simulations. Based on the ensemble of 17 General Circulation Models (GCMs) CMIP6, the near-future (2021 to 2050) flood projection under Shared Socioeconomic Pathways (SSPs) 2.6 (low forcing), 4.5 (medium forcing) and 8.5 (high end forcing) common to historical (1981 to 2014) was simulated. The area’s future risk of flooding was then investigated and adaptation measures were suggested for reducing and mitigating worsening flood conditions. A numerical model was developed in HEC-RAS that represented the city of Majalaya and the results were combined with the ensemble of climate projections to enable the assessment of the effects of flooding due to the combined effect of climate change and urbanisation. The model was calibrated using historical stream gauge records and past extreme flood inundation boundaries. Using the model’s output metrics (e.g. flood depth, velocity) and local demographic data, the project aims then to use a vulnerability assessment framework to quantify the impact of climate change on flood risk. The modelling results will allow for spatio-temporal mapping of the flood-prone areas in Majalaya, which will help reduce risk and vulnerability for disadvantaged populations. The development of flood vulnerability maps and future flood risk projections will assist the government in developing land-use and flood prevention management policies. This research area, drawing from the combination of flood modelling and the use of climate projections, allows for an assessment of future flood risk scenarios of the city of Majalaya and paves new avenues towards future research.

    How to cite: Rohmat, F. I. W., Stamataki, I., Sa'adi, Z., and Fitriani, D.: Flood analysis using HEC-RAS: The case study of Majalaya, Indonesia under the CMIP6 projection, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3090, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3090, 2022.

    EGU22-4102 | Presentations | NH1.4

    Modelling hail probability over Italy using a machine learning approach 

    Riccardo Hénin, Veronica Torralba, Antonio Cantelli, Enrico Scoccimarro, Stefano Materia, and Silvio Gualdi

    Hail is a meteorological phenomenon with adverse impacts affecting multiple socio-economic sectors such as agriculture, renewable energy and insurance (e.g. Púčik et al., 2019; Martius et al., 2018; Macdonald et al., 2016). The mitigation of the hail-related risk in particularly sensitive regions such as Italy has fostered hail research, aiming at a deeper understanding of the favorable environmental conditions for hail formation and the improvement of hail forecasting skills (Mohr and Kunz, 2013). Nevertheless, one of the major limitations for the study of long-term hail variability is the inherent difficulty in measuring all the hail occurrences and the consequent scarce temporal and spatial coverage of hail observations (Mohr et al., 2015). Therefore, in this study, the Probability Density Functions (PDFs) of several large-scale meteorological variables and convective indices from the ERA5 reanalysis are considered instead, with the aim of describing a conditioned hail probability, following the statistical method by Prein and Holland (2018). Then, the best set of variables to be used as predictors in the hail model are selected with a machine learning approach, based on a genetic algorithm. The model output is an estimation of the hail probability over Italy in the 1979-2020 period, on a 30x30 km grid. The model is validated over the Friuli-Venezia-Giulia region through an independent dataset based on hail pads. The estimated hail probability has been used to characterize the seasonality, long-term variability and trends of the hail frequency and to investigate the potential large-scale drivers of hailstorms over Italy. 

     

    REFERENCES:

    Púčik, T., Castellano, C., Groenemeijer, P., Kühne, T., Rädler, A. T., Antonescu, B., & Faust, E. (2019). Large hail incidence and its economic and societal impacts across Europe. Monthly Weather Review, 147(11), 3901-3916. doi: 10.1175/MWR-D-19-0204.1.

    Martius, O., Hering, A., Kunz, M., Manzato, A., Mohr, S., Nisi, L., & Trefalt, S. (2018). Challenges and recent advances in hail research. Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society, 99(3), ES51-ES54. doi: 10.1175/BAMS-D-17-0207.1.

    Macdonald, H., Infield, D., Nash, D. H., & Stack, M. M. (2016). Mapping hail meteorological observations for prediction of erosion in wind turbines. Wind Energy, 19(4), 777-784. doi: 10.1002/we.1854.

    Mohr, S., Kunz, M., & Geyer, B. (2015). Hail potential in Europe based on a regional climate model hindcast. Geophysical Research Letters, 42(24), 10-904. doi:10.1002/2015GL067118.

    Prein, A. F., & Holland, G. J. (2018). Global estimates of damaging hail hazard. Weather and Climate Extremes, 22, 10-23. doi: 10.1016/j.wace.2018.10.004.

     

    How to cite: Hénin, R., Torralba, V., Cantelli, A., Scoccimarro, E., Materia, S., and Gualdi, S.: Modelling hail probability over Italy using a machine learning approach, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4102, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4102, 2022.

    Extreme, large-scale precipitation events can lead to extreme river floodings which are one of the most dangerous weather events for society when occurring in highly populated areas. However, the largest impacts are caused by very rare events with return periods on the order of 100 years. To do a quantitative and robust analysis of daily 100-year precipitation events, observational time series are typically too short. Therefore, an approach is applied here in which operational ensemble prediction data from the ECMWF are used to generate a large pool of simulated, but realistic daily precipitation events (corresponding to 1200 years of data) from which several 100-year events can be analysed. For five different major Central European river catchments, composite analyses show that 100-year precipitation events in all catchments are typically associated with an upper-level trough moving into Central Europe 24h to 48h before the occurrence of the events. During the 24h before the events, details in the progression of the trough and the location of the associated surface cyclone determine in which catchment extreme precipitation occurs. A comparison to composite analyses of less extreme precipitation events shows that dynamical mechanisms such as an amplified mid-tropospheric trough/cut off are more important for an intensification of precipitation events in the Danube and Oder catchments while in the Elbe, Rhine and Weser/Ems catchments thermodynamical mechanisms such as a larger moisture flux are more important. The question how a warmer climate will affect the dynamical processes of such extreme precipitation events will be investigated in a follow-up study.

    How to cite: Ruff, F. and Pfahl, S.: Dynamical analysis of large-scale 100-year precipitation events over Central European river catchments and their differences to less extreme events, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4205, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4205, 2022.

    EGU22-4353 | Presentations | NH1.4

    How does the rise of atmospheric water demand affect flash drought development in Spain? 

    Iván Noguera, Fernando Domínguez-Castro, and Sergio M. Vicente-Serrano

    Flash droughts are distinguished by a rapid development and intensification, which increase the potential drought impacts on natural and socio-economic systems. In recent years, a great effort has been made to identify and quantify this type of events in different regions of the world using different metrics. We developed a methodology to analyze the flash droughts based on SPEI at short-time scale (1-month) and high-frequency data (weekly). Thus, we characterized the occurrence of flash drought in Spain over the period 1961-2018 and showed that flash drought is a frequent phenomenon (40% of all droughts were characterized by rapid development), which exhibit a great spatiotemporal variability. The northern regions, where a higher frequency of flash droughts was found, showed negative trends in the frequency of flash droughts, while the central and southern regions subject to fewer flash drought events showed generally positive trends. Usually, the flash drought is associated with severe precipitation deficits and/or anomalous increases in atmospheric evaporative demand (AED), but while the role of precipitation seems obvious and essential, the role played by AED in triggering or reinforcing flash drought episodes is much more complex and exhibits important spatial and temporal contrasts. In Spain, the effect of AED is mainly restricted to water-limited regions and the warm season, but its role is minimal in energy-limited regions and in cold periods in which precipitation deficits are the main cause of flash drought development. However, the contribution of the AED on the development of flash droughts has increased notably over the last six decades, thus becoming a decisive driver in explaining the occurrence of the latest flash droughts in some regions of Spain. These findings have strong implications for proper understanding of the recent spatiotemporal behavior of flash droughts in Spain and illustrate how this type of event can be related to global warming processes.

    How to cite: Noguera, I., Domínguez-Castro, F., and Vicente-Serrano, S. M.: How does the rise of atmospheric water demand affect flash drought development in Spain?, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4353, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4353, 2022.

    EGU22-4588 | Presentations | NH1.4

    A Causality-guided Approach for Predicting Future Changes in Extreme Rainfall over China Using Known Large-scale Modes 

    Kelvin S. Ng, Gregor C. Leckebusch, and Kevin Hodges

    Over the past few decades, while several advancements in improving the performance of global climate models (GCMs), such as predicting mean climate,  have been made, predicting extreme rainfall events related to Mei-yu fronts (MYFs) and tropical cyclones (TCs) remains an open challenge. This is partially due the coarse spatial resolution of the GCMs that restricts their ability to represent extreme events and the associated processes on relevant spatial scales. This poses a problem for stakeholders as a failure to take appropriate precautionary action before the occurrence of extreme events can have disastrous consequences. Although the spatial resolutions of typical GCMs are too coarse to simulate extreme precipitation accurately, they are more likely to be able to simulate large-scale climate modes (LSCMs) better. Given that the activities of MYFs and TCs are linked to LSCMs, we can make use of these causal connections between LSCMs and extreme rainfall associated with MYFs/TCs to construct useful prediction models. This can then be applied to the outputs of climate GCM simulations to increase our capability in predicting extreme rainfall in the future.

    In this presentation, we demonstrate a novel technique based on causality-guided statistical models (CGSMs) to assess the projected future changes of extreme rainfall associated with MYFs and TCs over China using the CMIP6 historical and SSP585 scenario simulations for four selected models. First, we show that CGSMs, which are constructed using historical observations and reanalysis, have good performance in modelling historical observations. Then we compare extreme rainfall related to MYFs/TCs from the CMIP6 historical direct output of the selected models with the CGSMs predictions. Our results show that the climatological patterns of CMIP6 direct historical outputs are different to the observed climatological patterns. Yet, CGSMs driven by CMIP6 LSCMs can produce similar patterns as the observed climatology. For the projected change under the SSP585 scenario, projections based on CGSMs provide a more coherent picture than CMIP6 direct model outputs. This shows the potential of causality-guided approach in coarse resolution climate model outputs. The implication and potential use of this approach is also discussed.

    How to cite: Ng, K. S., Leckebusch, G. C., and Hodges, K.: A Causality-guided Approach for Predicting Future Changes in Extreme Rainfall over China Using Known Large-scale Modes, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4588, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4588, 2022.

    EGU22-5114 | Presentations | NH1.4 | Highlight

    Sediment pollution and morphodynamics of an extreme event: Examples from the July 2021 flood event from the Inde River catchment in North Rhine-Westphalia 

    Frank Lehmkuhl, Verena Esser, Philipp Schulte, Alexandra Weber, Stefanie Wolf, and Holger Schüttrumpf

    Extreme precipitation and discharge between July 13th and 16th 2021 caused serious flooding with bank erosion, including damages to infrastructure and buildings nearby the Eifel mountain region. Especially the small town of Stolberg and Eschweiler in the Inde River catchment were heavily affected. On-site investigation along the Inde River and its tributary, the Vichtbach creek, after the flood event show that mainly coarse sediments were remobilized and accumulated in the upper and middle reaches. The water masses mobilized not only sediments including gravel but also large objects like broken down trees and cars. In contrast, silty sediments were deposited in the lower reaches.

    The Stolberg region is a former mining area with related industries resulting in contaminated soils and tailings close to the floodplains (Esser et al. 2020). Therefore, our investigations also focus on pollution by sediment-bound heavy metals and their distribution in the floodplains before and after this event. Flood sediment samples were taken immediately after the extreme flood event. Based on the results of flood-related pollution monitoring, conducted between 2016 and 2019 (Esser, 2020), the impact of the extreme event in July can be evaluated. During the July flood event, an exceptional amount of pollutants was remobilized. In addition to an increase in pollutants on the modern floodplain, wider areas of older and higher floodplains (Altauen) were also affected.

    Esser, V. (2020): Untersuchungen zur fluvialen Morphodynamik und zur rezenten Schadstoffausbreitung in Flusssystemen - Beispiele aus der Grenzregion Belgien, Niederlande und Deutschland. PhD-Thesis, RWTH Aachen University.

    Esser, V., Buchty-Lemke, M., Schulte, P., Podzun, L.S., Lehmkuhl, F. (2020): Signatures of recent pollution profiles in comparable Central European rivers - Examples from the International River Basin District Meuse. Catena 193: 104646. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.catena.2020.104646

    How to cite: Lehmkuhl, F., Esser, V., Schulte, P., Weber, A., Wolf, S., and Schüttrumpf, H.: Sediment pollution and morphodynamics of an extreme event: Examples from the July 2021 flood event from the Inde River catchment in North Rhine-Westphalia, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5114, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5114, 2022.

    EGU22-5815 | Presentations | NH1.4

    Parameter exploration for hydrological hazard interactions in a data-scarce catchment. 

    Pablo López, Liz Holcombe, Katerina Michaelides, and Jeremy Phillips

    Extreme rainfall events are increasing the frequency of hydrological hazards such as landslides, debris flow, and erosion processes. Understanding the coupling of these hazards is still a challenging task, current methodologies often take a single hazard approach without integrating the mechanisms that describe the influence of one hazard on another under the same rainfall event. Physically-based distributed models have overcome these limitations incorporating the coupling of hillslope-hydrological processes that influence the interactions of hydrological hazards at the catchment scale. Nonetheless, within these models, the physical characteristics of the catchment domain are subject to a large spatial variability increasing the uncertainty in the parameters that influence the interaction of these hazards, hindering their representation in data-scarce catchments. The aim of this study is to elaborate an experimental design to parameterize a physically-distributed model to identify the parameters that have an acceptable influence in representing and describing hydrological hazard interactions under a data-scarce environment.

    The study area is set in the Soufriere catchment in Saint Lucia, which recorded multiple landslides and debris flows with impacts on catchment erosion triggered by Hurricane Tomas in October 2010. The OpenLISEM model was used to estimate the parameters that influenced the triggering of hydrological hazards that occurred during Hurricane Tomas. The parameter estimation was performed through a Global Sensitivity Analysis (GSA) All-At-a-Time (ATT) to assess simultaneously under 144 simulations the estimation of hydrological and geotechnical parameters. The parameters subject to Sensitivity Analysis were saturated moisture content, saturated hydraulic conductivity, soil cohesion, and internal friction angle. The results were verified through the Sorensen-Dice coefficient. The coefficient was calculated through a spatial overlapping method between landslide simulated areas and landslide inventory areas corresponding to the Hurricane Tomas triggered landslides obtained from the British Geological Survey (2014). The results indicated that the representation of landslides, debris flows, and erosion processes on the OpenLISEM model highly depend on the quality of the input data. The latter was confirmed by the Sorensen-Dice coefficient indicated low spatial overlap values between the simulations performed. Nevertheless, the response of the OpenLISEM model to an acceptable landslide representation similar to the landslides triggered by Hurricane Tomas was influenced in the first place by the soil cohesion and internal friction angle and in the second place by the saturated moisture content and saturated hydraulic conductivity. The identification of these parameters introduces an improvement to provide an acceptable representation of hydrological hazards interactions given the data available in a data-scarce environment.

    How to cite: López, P., Holcombe, L., Michaelides, K., and Phillips, J.: Parameter exploration for hydrological hazard interactions in a data-scarce catchment., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5815, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5815, 2022.

    The evaluation of the resilience of flood protection systems requires the assessment of the impact of climate change scenarios on future flood regimes. Due to the high computational effort and to the scarcity of hourly climate modelling chains, expected changes in future floods are often simulated by hydrological models on a daily basis, even for basins with short response times, where hourly simulations would be needed.

    In this work, the expected occurrence and magnitude of future flood events is modelled through the coupling of bias-corrected local climate scenarios at hourly time scale and continuous rainfall-runoff modelling, in reference to the Panaro river (one of the OpenAir Laboratories in the OPERANDUM H2020 project), a tributary of the Po River in the Apennines.

    The investigation exploits hourly precipitation and daily max/min temperature (used for interpolation at hourly scale) timeseries for a subset of climate modelling chains included in the EURO-CORDEX initiative through the dynamical downscaling of Global Climate Models under the RCP 8.5 concentration scenario. The comparison with observed spatial fields obtained from weather stations and from gridded E-OBS products allows to assess the biases affecting the climate raw data.

    The Scaled Distribution Mapping (SDM) bias correction procedure (Switanek et al. 2017), that preserves raw climate model projected changes in the bias-corrected series, is then applied to adjust the raw model output towards observations.

    A semi-distributed, continuously simulating rainfall-runoff model is parameterised on the basis of the observed meteorological and streamflow time-series, especially focusing on the reproduction of past flood events. The model is then run to reproduce the continuous hourly streamflow time-series in the Panaro river over past and future decades, providing in input i) observed meteorological forcing based on ground stations, ii) raw and bias-corrected climate scenarios over the control period, iii) bias-corrected climate scenarios for the future decades. Finally, the flood events are extracted from the continuous streamflow simulations and the changes in the flood signals expected over the future decades are analysed, in terms of both peaks and volumes.

     

    References

    Switanek, M. B., Troch, P. A., Castro, C. L., Leuprecht, A., Chang, H.-I., Mukherjee, R., and Demaria, E. M. C.: Scaled distribution mapping: a bias correction method that preserves raw climate model projected changes, Hydrol. Earth Syst. Sci., 21, 2649–2666, https://doi.org/10.5194/hess-21-2649-2017, 2017.

    How to cite: Toth, E., Neri, M., Reder, A., and Rianna, G.: Future occurrence and magnitude of flood events in the Panaro River (Northern Italy): coupling bias-corrected hourly climate scenarios and semi-distributed rainfall-runoff modelling, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6503, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6503, 2022.

    EGU22-6925 | Presentations | NH1.4

    Cytotoxicity as a proxy for particle-associated and dissolved organic contaminant loads in rivers during floods 

    Clarissa Glaser, Michelle Engelhardt, Beate Escher, Andrea Gärtner, Martin Krauss, Maria König, Rita Schlichting, Christiane Zarfl, and Stephanie Spahr

    Storm events lead to a mobilization of dissolved and particle-associated organic pollutants that pose a risk to river ecosystems. Target screening can hardly capture the broad range of compounds present in stormwater and receiving streams. Thus, an additional monitoring proxy that describes the overall chemical load in stormwater is needed. Each chemical in a mixture contributes, albeit with different potency, to cytotoxicity measured by reduction of cell viability after 24h in four human cell lines. Thus, the aim of this study was to investigate the applicability of cytotoxicity as a proxy for the organic contaminant load of rivers during storm events. Field investigations took place in the Ammer River (annual average discharge 0.87 m³ s-1) close to Tübingen, Germany, during intense precipitation events in June 2021. The sampling site was located at the outlet of the gauged catchment (134 km²), thus, integrating inflowing water from all upstream tributaries and sewer overflows. During storm events, high-resolution temporal monitoring of discharge, suspended particles, particle characteristics, as well as dissolved and particle-associated organic contaminants was conducted using both chemical analyses and cell-based in vitro bioassays. The cytotoxicity in the water phase (expressed as toxic units, TU), was similar among the cell lines. The TU flux followed the course of the hydrograph with highest values at the maximum or slightly after the discharge peak. This finding suggests that the chemical load is controlled by the transported volume of water despite the fact that different contaminant sources are likely to contribute to the water flux and pollutant load in the river at different time points of the hydrograph. For the particle-associated cytotoxicity, the TU flux also followed the course of the events suggesting that the particle-associated cytotoxicity in the river is, similar to the water cytotoxicity, controlled by the particle load in the river. This highlights that the cytotoxicity is a suitable proxy to detect mixtures of organic compounds and, thus, assess the chemical load in rivers during storm events.

    How to cite: Glaser, C., Engelhardt, M., Escher, B., Gärtner, A., Krauss, M., König, M., Schlichting, R., Zarfl, C., and Spahr, S.: Cytotoxicity as a proxy for particle-associated and dissolved organic contaminant loads in rivers during floods, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6925, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6925, 2022.

    EGU22-7030 | Presentations | NH1.4

    Madden–Julian Oscillation related to the prolonged heavy rainfall in East Asia in 2020 

    Byung-Kwon Moon, Jieun Wie, and Jinhee Kang

    In East Asia, unusually long-term and heavy rainfall in 2020 resulted in concentrated socio-economic damage and flooding. In this study, the characteristics of the Madden–Julian Oscillation (MJO) related to the prediction of heavy rainfall in East Asia were analyzed using the sub-seasonal to seasonal (S2S) prediction model. In 2020, unusually high precipitation fell in East Asia, compared to an average year, for an extended time. Precipitation was concentrated from the end of June to the middle of August; therefore, the analysis was carried out with an initial model date of July 2, 2020, while the lead-time was selected 1–31 day (July 3 to August 1). The model underestimated cumulative precipitation compared to observations, with KMA and UKMO having the lowest errors and ECMWF and CMA having the largest errors. The 850-hPa position altitude and wind field anomaly was analyzed and averaged over the prediction period. The results revealed that models with large errors showed different locations for the western and northern boundaries of the high pressure in the western North Pacific region, relative to observations, or else underestimated the size of the high-pressure zone. Based on the MJO prediction phases for July in the S2S models, models with good precipitation prediction performance in East Asia mainly showed phases 1–3 that were similar to observations and their amplitudes were also large. In contrast, models with poor prediction performance exhibited fewer instances of phases 1–3 on strong days or their amplitudes were small. This suggests that if an S2S model predicts the characteristics of the MJO accurately, similar to observations, it could improve predictions of summer precipitation in East Asia.

    This work was funded by the Korea Meteorological Administration Research and Development Program under Grant KMI2020-01212.

    How to cite: Moon, B.-K., Wie, J., and Kang, J.: Madden–Julian Oscillation related to the prolonged heavy rainfall in East Asia in 2020, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7030, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7030, 2022.

    Heavy precipitation is a major natural hazard that can have severe impacts.  In response to global warming, the character of heavy precipitation is expected to change. Projections of the future hydrologic cycle, especially of heavy precipitation, are uncertain. Especially at the regional scale, different data sources, such as different ensembles of global and regional climate models (GCMs and RCMs), provide sometimes conflicting conclusions. Therefore, it is even more important to investigate where differences between ensembles lie and to which processes they can be attributed.

    A precipitation scaling (introduced by Paul O’Gorman) is used to disentangle thermodynamic and dynamic contributions in extreme precipitation. In this work, we compare the results of CMIP5 and CMIP6 and focus on climate change signals between the periods 1971-2000 and 2071-2100 over Europe. The thermodynamic component provides homogeneous signals across Europe with a rise in extreme precipitation of about 7 %/K. In contrast, the dynamic component shows no spatial homogeneous results where the dynamic contribution can even modify the thermodynamic signal. The spread between the models within one ensemble is much larger. However, based on initial analyses, the spread in the CMIP6 models appears to have become smaller compared to CMIP5. This means, understanding the dynamic changes is the key to understanding the differences between the ensembles.

    As a next step, to analyze the discrepancy between CMIP5 and CMIP6 in terms of atmospheric circulation changes, we look into three atmospheric drivers: tropical and polar amplification of global warming and changes in stratospheric vortex strength.  

    How to cite: Ritzhaupt, N. and Maraun, D.: Differences in the regional pattern of projected future changes in extreme precipitation over Europe are driven by the dynamic contribution, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7209, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7209, 2022.

    EGU22-7214 | Presentations | NH1.4

    Forecasting Large Hail Using Logistic Models and the ECMWF Ensemble Prediction System 

    Francesco Battaglioli, Pieter Groenemeijer, and Ivan Tsonesvky

    An additive logistic regression model for large hail was developed based on convective parameters from ERA5 reanalysis, severe weather reports from the European Severe Weather Database (ESWD), and lightning observations from the Met Office Arrival Time Difference network (ATDnet). This model was shown to accurately reproduce the spatial distribution and the seasonal cycle of observed hail events in Europe. A spatial map of the modelled mean distribution for hail > 2 cm will be presented.

    To explore the value of this approach to medium-range forecasting, a similar statistical model was developed using four predictor parameters available from the ECMWF Ensemble Prediction System (EPS) reforecasts: Mixed Layer CAPE, Deep Layer Shear, Mixed Layer Mixing Ratio and the Wet Bulb Zero Height. Probabilistic large hail predictions were created for all available 11-member ensemble forecasts (2008 to 2019), for lead times from 12 to 228 hours.

    First, we evaluated the model’s predictive skill depending on the forecast lead time using the Area Under the ROC Curve (AUC) as a validation score. For forecasts up to two to three days, the model highlights a very high predictive skill (AUC > 0.95). Furthermore, the model retains a high predictive skill even for extended forecasts (AUC = 0.85 at 180 hours lead time) showing that it can identify regions with hail potential well in advance. Second, we compared the forecast spatial probabilities at various lead times with observed hail occurrence focusing on a few recent hail outbreaks. Finally, our four-dimensional model was compared with logistic models based on composite parameters such as the Significant Hail Parameter (SHP) and the product of CAPE and Deep Layer Shear (CAPESHEAR). The four-dimensional model outperformed these composite-based ones at lead times up to four days. The high AUC scores show that this model could improve short-medium range hail forecasts. Preliminary application of this approach to other convective hazards such as convective wind gusts will be presented as well.

    How to cite: Battaglioli, F., Groenemeijer, P., and Tsonesvky, I.: Forecasting Large Hail Using Logistic Models and the ECMWF Ensemble Prediction System, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7214, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7214, 2022.

    EGU22-7449 | Presentations | NH1.4

    Safeguarding heritage sites from hydrometeorological extremes: the Santa Croce district in Florence 

    Paolo Tamagnone, Enrica Caporali, and Alessandro Sidoti

    Humankind is currently living in an era governed by continuous climate warm-up and unstoppable urbanization, in which the ongoing climate change is leading to an exacerbation of hydrometeorological events. With an intensification of magnitude and frequency of extreme rainfall events, engineers and scientists are striving to develop methodologies and strategies to effectively defend people and assets from pluvial flooding. Pluvial floods produced by local, intense, and fast rainstorms cause the surcharge of urban drainage systems inducing the inundation of streets and buildings before the runoff reaches the receptor watercourse. Pluvial flood damage has been defined as an ‘invisible hazard’ but it increasingly weighs on the budget of direct flood losses, raising the costs incurred by flood damages. Besides the tangible losses, the costs may be even higher when the intangible share is considered, such as the potential loss of heritage held in ancient towns. For this reason, the inestimable cultural and artistic heritage preserved in historical buildings require a high-level of protection against hazards induced by natural calamities. The present study investigates extreme rainfall-related impacts and hazards threatening the cultural heritage situated in the most vulnerable areas of the Santa Croce district (Florence, Italy). The district hosts some of the most important buildings of the city: the National Central Library of Florence and the Opera di Santa Croce. The geographical location of this monumental complex makes the cultural heritage guarded inside of it dangerously exposed to multiple sources of flood hazard. Firstly, river flooding due to the proximity to the Arno River (this area has been already harshly damaged by the catastrophic flood in 1966). Secondly, flooding by sewage since that the internal drainage network is linked with one of the main sewer conduits of the city. Then, surface runoff flowing down from the headwater. Considering this framework, the pluvial flood hazard assessment is performed using a 1D/2D dual drainage model specifically implemented to simulate all hydraulic phenomena occurring both on the surface and through the sewer network. The analysis comprehends a series of scenarios designed to simulate the impact of hydrometeorological extremes on the study area and each possible concatenation of consequences or failures. The hydraulic model incorporates different layers of information: the high-resolution digital surface model of the area and buildings, the public sewer network, and the internal rainfall collection system of the district. Geometrical features and technical specifications of the sewer network have been retrieved from detailed field surveys and research in historical archives. Model’s outcomes allow identifying the critical nodes within the drainage network, delineating the most vulnerable areas, and prioritizing the rescue efforts in case of severe cloudbursts. Results may help site managers to improve the efficiency of their hazard management and emergency plans. Furthermore, the study intends to propose suitable technical solutions for safeguarding the cultural heritage where designing intrusive engineering works hardly fits within the historical urban context.

    How to cite: Tamagnone, P., Caporali, E., and Sidoti, A.: Safeguarding heritage sites from hydrometeorological extremes: the Santa Croce district in Florence, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7449, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7449, 2022.

    EGU22-8550 | Presentations | NH1.4

    Toxic European Summer Flood – Dispersion of organic pollutants along the Vicht and Inde rivers, Germany 

    Piero Bellanova, Jan Schwarzbauer, and Klaus Reicherter

    The 2021 European floods (July 13th–16th, 2021) marked Germany’s deadliest (>180 fatalities) and most costly (>€ 30 billion) natural disaster of the 21st century. In North Rhine-Westphalia (Germany) the floods have caused drastic scenes of destruction along small mountainous river systems, such as the Vicht and Inde rivers. Alongside this destruction stands the release of organic pollutants and the remobilization of sediment-associated old burdens in the former mining area of Stolberg. In a preliminary study 10 samples along the floodplains and urban areas of Vicht and the successive Inde rivers have been collected directly after the flood to determine the pollution concentration, dispersion and potential sources. With this information an assessment of the short-term and long-term environmental risks can be evaluated.

    First results show acute enrichment of organic pollutants, such as polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs – petrogenic pollutants), polychlorinated biphenlys (PCBs – old burdens/plasticizers) and linear alkylbenzenes (LABs – sewage). The sewage indicators show their highest release and accumulation in samples taken in the urban areas, and subsequently dilute along the natural floodplain segments. This repeats for at least for Stolberg and Eschweiler, which were flooded by the Vicht and Inde, respectively. Old burdens, such as represented by PCBs, related to historical and present heavy industry in the vicinity to the rivers. The flood caused the remobilization of respective old burdens from contaminated plains and urban sources. Petrogenic markers, especially those of PAHs, have been measured in concentrations of mg/kg, vastly exceeding all environmental guidelines and restrictions. These can also be linked to the flooding of industrial and urban sites (e.g., household oil heating tanks, vehicles).

    The wide range of observed pollution and fast dispersion of sediment-associated pollutants can be linked to the highly dynamic nature of this flood. In addition, the multitude of historical (mining, heavy industry) and present sources (e.g., fuels, oil, factory effluents, wastewater), sediment-associated pollutants have been remobilized or acutely released with the flood. This unprecedented 2021 European floods may allow insights into the relationships and interactions between hydrodynamics, sedimentology and pollution during such events.

    How to cite: Bellanova, P., Schwarzbauer, J., and Reicherter, K.: Toxic European Summer Flood – Dispersion of organic pollutants along the Vicht and Inde rivers, Germany, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8550, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8550, 2022.

    EGU22-8566 | Presentations | NH1.4

    Storm-type specific scaling of sub-daily precipitation with temperature over the North Atlantic and Europe 

    Jennifer Catto, Phil Sansom, and David Stephenson

    Sub-daily precipitation extremes are expected to increase in intensity in a warming climate, at a rate higher than that expected from the Clausius Clapeyron scaling. Depending on the region, these precipitation extremes can be caused by different weather system types, such as extratropical or tropical cyclones, fronts, and thunderstorms. In this study we use a storm typology, based on the objective identification of cyclone, fronts and thunderstorms, to add insight to the scaling relationship between temperature and extreme precipitation.

    We use 6-hourly information on the type of weather system present at each grid box over the North Atlantic and European region from ERA5 (1981-2000) during boreal winter (DJF). The mean hourly 2-m dew-point temperature over the 6 hours closest to the weather system type, and the maximum of the hourly precipitation over the same period are then used to estimate the scaling of the precipitation extremes with temperature for each storm type. Preliminary results using quantile regression we find significantly larger scaling for weather systems including thunderstorms (greater than CC scaling) than for those that do not. We also find that for the most common weather systems over Northern Europe (front only and cyclone and front together), the scaling of extreme precipitation with temperature is below CC scaling. The future impacts of the extreme precipitation events will depend on the future changes in the frequency of different weather system types as well as the temperature scaling.

    How to cite: Catto, J., Sansom, P., and Stephenson, D.: Storm-type specific scaling of sub-daily precipitation with temperature over the North Atlantic and Europe, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8566, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8566, 2022.

    EGU22-9357 | Presentations | NH1.4

    Characterization and nowcasting of severe weather events over Milano Malpensa 

    Aikaterini Anesiadou, Sandy Chkeir, and Riccardo Biondi

    Extreme weather events in Europe have increased in frequency and intensity in the last decades, especially in some areas like Alpes and Balkans, and is expected to increase even more in the upcoming years due to the climate change. Monitoring and forecasting the severe weather events locally developed and in a short time range is very challenging but also very important for aviation safety. Several studies have been made for studying the pre-convective environment, however there are still gaps in the knowledge of the dynamical processes of regional and short duration deep convective systems.

    This study is implemented within the SESAR ALARM project and focuses on the analysis of the pre-convective and convective environment in support to the air traffic management and air traffic control. The work focuses in the detection, analysis and nowcasting of severe weather events in a selected hotspot: the area of Milano Malpensa airport in Italy. We have used the data from 28 weather stations, 8 GNSS stations, radar and lightning detectors, in the period 2010-2020 to train a nowcasting algorithm and to characterize the pre-convective environment.

    Our first results for different locations in the area of interest, show on average that the root mean square error of the rainfall prediction lie in the range 0.1029-0.2838 mm and 0.2720-0.7815 m/s for the wind speed prediction. Our algorithm shows the best rain predictive performance in the next 10 minutes higher than 90%, and higher than 80% in the next 30 minutes. Moreover, the pre-convective environment analysis shows that all the cases with wind field divergence never show an increasing trend of GNSS Zenith Total Delay before the event.

    How to cite: Anesiadou, A., Chkeir, S., and Biondi, R.: Characterization and nowcasting of severe weather events over Milano Malpensa, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9357, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9357, 2022.

    EGU22-9520 | Presentations | NH1.4

    The seismic footprint of the devastating July 2021 Ahr Valley flood, Germany 

    Michael Dietze, Rainer Bell, Thomas Hoffmann, and Lothar Schrott

    Valley confined floods are a major hazard. In contrast to large river floods with day long warning time, they can evolve within minutes to hours, exhibit higher flow velocities and drive large amounts of debris into populated places. While many Alpine communities have developed mitigation, early warning and rapid response schemes for this natural hazard type, these measures are virtually unknown in Central European upland regions. Beyond flood protection, lacking measurement infrastructure also prevents retrospective collection of event anatomy data, which would be key to understand the evolution of an event and, hence to improve our response to future hazards.

    The 14–15 July 2021 flood that hit the Ahr valley in the Eifel mountains, west Germany, was a drastic example of the potential of such valley confined floods. A wall of water flushed through the deeply incised valley, flooding more than 15 towns and affecting 42,000 people, resulting in the highest number of casualties in Germany since 1962. All gauges along the main channel were destroyed while the flood hydrograph was still on the rising limb and grid power loss interrupted collection and transmission of data from other potential sensors.

    Here, we use data from a single seismic station near the town of Ahrweiler, originally deployed for earthquake seismology. Despite grid power cutoff around 23:19 CEST, the station recorded the arrival of the fast rising limb of the flood. We show how even an incomplete record of a single station not set up for flood early warning can be used to infer crucial and timely information about the flood: propagation velocity, water level and debris transport rate. We argue that installing a network of a few distributed low cost seismic sensors could have improved flood early warning and near real time provision of kinetic flood data. More importantly, such a network would be the key for improved response actions for future floods, deemed more likely in Central Europe under the currently changing climate conditions.

    How to cite: Dietze, M., Bell, R., Hoffmann, T., and Schrott, L.: The seismic footprint of the devastating July 2021 Ahr Valley flood, Germany, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9520, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9520, 2022.

    EGU22-9831 | Presentations | NH1.4

    A comprehensive study of the extreme heat and drought of the 2018 European summer 

    Efi Rousi, Andreas Fink, and Laura Suarez-Gutierrez and the ClimXtreme project

    The summer of 2018 was an extraordinary extreme season in Europe bringing simultaneous, widespread and coherent extremes of heat and drought in large parts of the continent with extensive impacts on agriculture, forests, water supply, and large financial losses. Joining different areas of expertise available within the German ClimXtreme project (https://www.climxtreme.net/index.php/en/), we present a comprehensive analysis of the 2018 extreme European summer in terms of heat and drought.

    First, we define the events using different traditional, as well as, novel metrics. Then, we present a comprehensive dynamical analysis of the background atmospheric state, in order to better understand the events by bringing together different approaches. First results indicate that the summer of 2018 was characterized by persistent NAO+ conditions, which favored the occurrence and persistence of a Eurasian double jet stream structure. Both of those features contribute to the occurrence of heat extremes in western and central Europe. Additionally, positive blocking frequency anomalies were present over Scandinavia, which favored the intense heatwave in the region. An analysis of Rossby wave activity during the 2018 summer shows an eastward propagation of Rossby wave packets from the Pacific towards the Atlantic and the European continent already at the end of June and before the initiation of the heatwave over Scandinavia. When the peak over the Iberia occurs, there is no pronounced Rossby wave activity, which highlights the different mechanisms involved, i.e., subtropical ridges and Saharan air intrusions.

    Low-frequency precursors, such as SSTs and soil moisture in spring, and their role in shaping those extreme events are also analyzed. A conspicuous tripolar SST anomaly pattern over the N. Atlantic, consisting of a cold blob south of Greenland and Iceland, was prominent starting in early spring. At the same time, a severe soil moisture depletion over Germany between April and July reflects the persistently warm and dry conditions in spring 2018 that caused anomalously dry soils in summer.

    Last but not least, a tailored attribution study is presented, comparing the 2018 central European heatwave with similar events in the MPI Grande Ensemble and in CMIP6 models. To provide tailored information for this study, the event was defined as the maximum daily temperature in Germany averaged over different lengths of periods of consecutive days to account for the prolonged heat that characterized the summer of 2018. According to the MPI-GE almost every summer will be more extreme than 2018 under a 2˚C warmer world.

    As heat and drought conditions are likely to become more frequent and intense under anthropogenic climate change, we argue that the scientific community can benefit from such comprehensive and transdisciplinary studies.

    How to cite: Rousi, E., Fink, A., and Suarez-Gutierrez, L. and the ClimXtreme project: A comprehensive study of the extreme heat and drought of the 2018 European summer, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9831, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9831, 2022.

    EGU22-9985 | Presentations | NH1.4

    Flood sedimentological records off the south Portuguese coasts 

    Pedro Costa and the RV Meteor M-152 scientific team

    In the present climate change scenario, the perception regarding the frequency and magnitude of flood events is changing. Nevertheless, to establish return periods and flooding patterns it is important to expand the time-window of observation beyond the historical period. To achieve this purpose, it is crucial to use the sedimentological record of alluvial plains and river banks. However, anthropogenic activities have disrupted the sedimentary dynamics thus interfering with the geomorphological settings and their stratigraphy’s. An alternative setting is the shallow nearshore, below storm wave base, where potentially stratigraphy is better preserved.

    After a campaign on board RV Meteor, a group of sediment cores were collected offshore the south Portuguese coast. These cores cover the Holocene Epoch and consist essentially on alternations of silty bioclastic layers with some sandy units rich in quartz and bioclasts. The vertical variation of several sedimentological proxies allowed the differentiation of disruptive events, mostly related with extreme marine inundations or possibly linked with abrupt fluvial discharges.

    Here we present some preliminary results based on grain-size and compositional analysis (XRD) and attempt to establish a chronology of those events. The preliminary data interpretation seems to suggest an increase in the flood record over the last 1000 years. However, this observation needs further support from other locations in the area and also requires a better understanding of post-depositional processes that affect the record of thin muddy layers on the nearshore stratigraphy.

     

    This work was supported by projects OnOff - PTDC/CTAGEO/28941/2017 – financed by FCT. and FCT/UIDB/50019/2020 - IDL, also funded by FCT.

    How to cite: Costa, P. and the RV Meteor M-152 scientific team: Flood sedimentological records off the south Portuguese coasts, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9985, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9985, 2022.

    EGU22-10975 | Presentations | NH1.4

    Observational and numerical study of a giant hailstorm in Attica, Greece, on October 4, 2019 

    Georgios Papavasileiou, Vasiliki Kotroni, Konstantinos Lagouvardos, and Theodore M. Giannaros

    On October 4, 2019, giant hailstones of 11 cm were reported in northern parts of Attica in southern Greece. During the same day, multiple large hail reports of hailstones larger than 3 cm as well as 5 tornadoes were reported in the European Severe Weather Database along the track of a long lived supercell thunderstorm that formed over northeastern Peloponnese and moved northeastwards to Attica and Euboea. In this study, we investigate the synoptic and mesoscale weather conditions that led to this rare event by using upper-air measurements from the Athens International Airport, satellite retrievals from METEOSAT, and reanalysis data from ERA5. 

    Furthermore, the predictability of this rare event is studied through high-resolution simulations performed with BOLAM, MOLOCH and WRF-ARW models, which are used operationally by the METEO unit at the National Observatory of Athens. The models were able to reproduce the mesoscale environment associated with these severe weather events, showing a highly unstable environment in Saronic gulf with more than 3000 J kg-1 MLCAPE overlapped by more than 25 m s-1 0–6 km Bulk Shear. However, the models were not able to fairly reproduce the triggering, track and timing of the supercell formation highlighting the great uncertainties associated with the initiation of deep moist convection over areas with complex terrain. Here, we attempt to constrain these uncertainties by applying a diagnostic tool for predicting hail size using an ensemble of high resolution simulations and we discuss its operational usage. 

    How to cite: Papavasileiou, G., Kotroni, V., Lagouvardos, K., and Giannaros, T. M.: Observational and numerical study of a giant hailstorm in Attica, Greece, on October 4, 2019, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10975, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10975, 2022.

    EGU22-11093 | Presentations | NH1.4

    Quantifying the hydrological responses of future climate changes on a large scale river basin in India 

    Shaini Naha, Miguel Angel Rico Ramirez, and Rafael Rosolem

    The serious hydrological consequences of climate change faced by developing countries like India show regional variability. Understanding these regional hydrologic impacts has a crucial role in the management of water resources. Mahanadi river basin (MRB) is a major large-scale river basin in India that is predicted to face severe floods under future climate change scenarios. Commonly, climate change impacts are simulated for a specific decade, specific scenario, or specific climate model in the future. We, however, employed an arguably more objective, approach that would identify the impacts of all possible combinations of specific change within the possible mean annual temperature and precipitation 2-dimensional scenario space (derived from thirteen CMIP6 models) on the hydrological responses. CMIP6 is the recent generation of climate models, released to overcome the drawbacks of the previous generation CMIP5 models such as under/overestimating the monsoon characteristics over the Indian subcontinent. Our methodological approach also involves using an ensemble of VIC models, representing the overall model uncertainty due to parameter value choices, in conjunction with these climate projections, instead of using a single calibrated model to predict the hydrological responses. The climate projections show an overall change in mean annual precipitation and mean annual average temperature that ranges from -5 to +105% and 0-7◦C respectively. This has resulted in significant changes in both mean annual flows and peak flows of up to 2849 and 29,776 m3s-1 respectively. Uncertainties associated with the model parameters, of up to 1211 m3s-1 are observed in the predicted peak flow magnitudes, which is considerably higher than in predicted annual flow magnitudes. Our findings indicate that precipitation mainly controls the future predicted flows in the basin. This study has provided a set of results on the likely future behavior of the MRB mean annual and peak flows under the CMIP6 climate projections. Future projections of hydrologic variables, along with the associated model parameter uncertainties can help with better hydrologic impact assessment and developing adaptation strategies for MRB in India.

    Keywords: Climate change, CMIP6, VIC, Mahanadi river basin, flows

    How to cite: Naha, S., Rico Ramirez, M. A., and Rosolem, R.: Quantifying the hydrological responses of future climate changes on a large scale river basin in India, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11093, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11093, 2022.

    EGU22-11221 | Presentations | NH1.4

    Moisture origin of the extreme precipitation event in Western Europe in July 2021 

    Imme Benedict, Florian Polak, Thomas Vermeulen, and Chris Weijenborg

    From the 12th to the 15th of July 2021, Western Europe was confronted with an abnormal amount of precipitation leading to extreme floods and enormous damage in western Germany, Belgium, Luxembourg and the Netherlands. Locally, almost thrice as much as the monthly precipitation amount was observed, up to 175 mm in two days. The large-scale weather pattern in Western Europe was characterised by an intense and stationary upper-level cut-off low.

    In this study the atmospheric conditions resulting in this extreme precipitation are investigated, with a focus on understanding the enhanced moisture supply leading to the extreme precipitation amounts. Previous to the event, the Baltic area experienced a significant heatwave, and it was hypothesized that due to high evaporation rates more humid air over this region would be transported towards western Europe to result in these enormous amounts of rain.

    We analysed the moisture origin of the extreme precipitation with the Lagrangian trajectory diagnostic LAGRANTO applied to both re-analysis data (ERA5) and simulations with the non-hydrostatic weather research and forecasting model (WRF). Both models represent the case rather well. In addition, the impact on precipitation by adapting the sea surface temperature (SST) of both the Baltic and the Mediterranean Sea was studied using WRF. This analysis showed that SST changes in the Mediterranean had the largest impact on precipitation in western Europe. Furthermore, first results indicate that the Mediterranean Sea, which had a positive SST anomaly of 2˚C, was the main moisture source preceding the precipitation event, contrasting our initial hypothesis.

    How to cite: Benedict, I., Polak, F., Vermeulen, T., and Weijenborg, C.: Moisture origin of the extreme precipitation event in Western Europe in July 2021, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11221, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11221, 2022.

    EGU22-11732 | Presentations | NH1.4

    Factors leading to the formation of tornadoes: statistical links emerging from a large dataset 

    Piero Lionello, Roberto Ingrosso, M.Marcello Miglietta, and Gianfausto Salvadori

    The dynamics of tornadoes include large vorticity in the lower troposphere and an intense updraft, whose combination may result in their formation. In this study we investigate the possibility of using a statistical relation for their description. In fact, the nonlinearity, complexity and fine scale of these processes presently prevents their simulation in the atmospheric circulation models currently used for weather forecasts and climate projections. Here we use a large dataset of tornadoes observed in the USA and Europe and the data of ERA5 (ECMWF ReAnalysis 5) to establish a statistical link between the occurrence of tornadoes and factors whose values can be extracted from atmospheric circulation models. The values of CAPE (convective available potential energy), WS (wind shear in the lower troposphere), SRH (storm relative helicity) and LCL (lifting condensation level) of the high resolution (about 30km) ERA5 data have been considered. The analysis shows all these variables are significantly linked to the formation of tornadoes with WS and CAPE being the most relevant ones. The analysis is an extension of a former study (Ingrosso et al., 2020, 10.3390/atmos11030301) based on a dataset of tornadoes events much larger than previously, on higher resolution atmospheric data, and more prognostic variables. The results provide a new expression for the probability of occurrence of tornadoes that can be used for forecasting their likelihood with potential applications to their predictions and future changes of their frequency.

    How to cite: Lionello, P., Ingrosso, R., Miglietta, M. M., and Salvadori, G.: Factors leading to the formation of tornadoes: statistical links emerging from a large dataset, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11732, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11732, 2022.

    EGU22-11944 | Presentations | NH1.4

    Weather circulation patterns associated with extreme precipitation events in Italy 

    Wazita Scott, Marco Gaetani, and Giorgia Fosser

    In the last years, many countries in Europe have been experiencing an increased frequency of extreme precipitation leading to natural disasters like floods and landslides. In Italy, the majority of the country’s natural disasters have been related to extreme precipitation. Floods and landslides have led to the country experiencing great loss in its social and economic structure. Early warning systems are important to stakeholders such as Disaster Risk Managers to make informed decisions in relation to a forecasted disaster.

    Extreme precipitation is often associated with specific circulation patterns. Precursor information about atmospheric circulation patterns can therefore act as an indicator of an oncoming extreme precipitation event. The objective of this work is to identify the weather circulation patterns associated with extreme precipitation events over Italy.

    E-OBS precipitation datasets were used to identify the most intense extreme precipitation events for each season for the period 1990-2020 across Italy. Mean sea level pressure and 500 hPa geopotential height from the ERA5 dataset were used to identify circulation anomalies associated with the extreme events. The analysis is performed by clustering extreme precipitation events into three homogeneous climatic zones in Italy defined following the Köppen-Geiger classification.

    Results show that extreme precipitation events are always associated with an intense low pressure system located within the Euro-Mediterranean region. Depending on the location of precipitation extremes across different climatic zones, low pressure location changes, also modifying the atmospheric circulation and the associated moisture transport. Namely, for precipitation extremes occurring in the Italian peninsula, the low pressure is located in central-western Europe, while for extremes in Sardinia and Sicily, low pressure is in the Mediterranean. 

    How to cite: Scott, W., Gaetani, M., and Fosser, G.: Weather circulation patterns associated with extreme precipitation events in Italy, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11944, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11944, 2022.

    EGU22-12077 | Presentations | NH1.4

    Weather Extremes in the Euro Atlantic Region: Assessment and Impacts 

    Margarida L. R. Liberato and Alexandre M. Ramos

    Despite being major sources of hazards and having impacts on local and national populations, environment and economies, processes involved in extremes’ intensification and generation of disastrous impacts, such as extreme and widespread dry and wet events or flash flooding, are not fully understood yet. Therefore, the goal of WEx-Atlantic project is to perform research, to improve knowledge on weather extremes in the North Atlantic European sector and to communicate it to society. Considered extremes are strong winds and heavy hydrometeorological (HM – dry and wet) events associated with extratropical cyclones (EC), frontal systems and atmospheric rivers (AR).

    WEx-Atlantic contributes to improve our understanding on the assessment of weather systems and the underlying physical mechanisms, variability and expected changes under global warming, as well as meteorological, environmental (e.g. forest) and socioeconomic (e.g. renewable wind energy and power grid) impacts on Portugal including the Macaronesia Islands.

    WEx-Atlantic applies state-of-the-art techniques to detect and track weather systems, including AR, mid-latitude systems and weather types to reanalysis datasets as well as to GCMs. Here a review of WEx-Atlantic research and new contribution is presented.

     

    This work was supported by project “Weather Extremes in the Euro Atlantic Region: Assessment and Impacts—WEx-Atlantic” (PTDC/CTA-MET/29233/2017; LISBOA-01-0145-FEDER-029233, NORTE-01-0145-FEDER-029233) funded by Fundação para a Ciência e a Tecnologia, Portugal (FCT). Alexandre. M. Ramos was supported by the FCT Scientific Employment Stimulus 2017 (CEECIND/00027/2017).

     

    Algarra I, et al. Significant increase of global anomalous moisture uptake feeding landfalling Atmospheric Rivers. Nat Commun 11, 5082 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-020-18876-w

    Gonçalves A, et al. Wind Energy Assessment during High-Impact Winter Storms in Southwestern Europe. Atmosphere. 2021; 12(4):509. https://doi.org/10.3390/atmos12040509

    Hénin R, et al. A ranking of concurrent precipitation and wind events for the Iberian Peninsula. Int J Climatol.; 41(2), 1421-1437 (2021) https://doi.org/10.1002/joc.6829

    Hénin R, et al. Assigning precipitation to mid-latitudes fronts on sub-daily scales in the North Atlantic and European sector: Climatology and trends. Int J Climatol.; 39(1), 317–330, (2019) https://doi.org/10.1002/joc.5808

    Liberato MLR, et al. Rankings of extreme and widespread dry and wet events in the Iberian Peninsula between 1901 and 2016. Earth Syst. Dynam., 12, 197–210 (2021) https://doi.org/10.5194/esd-12-197-2021

    Nieto R, et al. Contribution of the main moisture sources to precipitation during extreme peak precipitation months, Adv. Water Res., 131, (2019), 103385 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.advwatres.2019.103385

    Ramos AM, et al. Impacts of Atmospheric Rivers in Extreme Precipitation on the European Macaronesian Islands. Atmosphere 2018, 9, 325, (2018) https://doi.org/10.3390/atmos9080325

    Reale M, et al. A Global Climatology of Explosive Cyclones using a Multi-Tracking Approach, Tellus A, 71:1, 1-19, (2019) https://doi.org/10.1080/16000870.2019.1611340

    Ribeiro SL, et al. Development of a catalogue of damage in Portuguese forest associated with extreme extratropical cyclones. Science of The Total Environment, 151948, 2021 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2021.151948

    Sorí R, et al. Hydrometeorological droughts in the Miño–Limia–Sil hydrographic demarcation (northwestern Iberian Peninsula): the role of atmospheric drivers, Nat. Hazards Earth Syst. Sci., 20, 1805–1832, (2020) https://doi.org/10.5194/nhess-20-1805-2020

    Stojanovic M, et al. Consecutive Extratropical Cyclones Daniel, Elsa and Fabien, and Their Impact on the Hydrological Cycle of Mainland Portugal. Water. (2021); 13(11):1476. https://doi.org/10.3390/w13111476

    Vázquez M, et al. Atmospheric Moisture Sources Associated with Extreme Precipitation During the Peak Precipitation Month. Weather and Climate Extremes, 30, 100289 (2020) https://doi.org/10.1016/j.wace.2020.100289

    How to cite: Liberato, M. L. R. and Ramos, A. M.: Weather Extremes in the Euro Atlantic Region: Assessment and Impacts, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12077, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12077, 2022.

    EGU22-12481 | Presentations | NH1.4

    Chennai’s urban river systems – environmental changes, anthropogenic pollution and flood-induced remobilization 

    Luisa Bellanova, Piero Bellanova, Jan Schwarzbauer, Frank Lehmkuhl, Philipp Schulte, and Klaus Reicherter

    With a projected increase in frequency and magnitude of extreme weather events, the fast-growing coastal population centers of the Asian Global South experience a higher susceptibility to flood-related pollution. This is fueled by rapid land-use changes, urbanization, a multitude of emission sources, as well as anthropogenic- and flood-induced remobilization and relocation of pollutants. To yield a more comprehensive understanding of riverine and coastal floods in conjunction with these rapid urban and land-use changes, their impact on the environment and the health risks posed to local communities, sedimentary archives need to be studied.

    Meandering through densely populated urban areas, Chennai’s rivers (Cooum and Adyar) and coastal systems have been affected by monsoon-induced floods (e.g., 2015 South Indian floods) and the 2004 Indian Ocean tsunami. Simultaneously, Chennai experienced an explosive population growth over the past 30 years, with the coinciding changes in land-use, urbanization, anthropogenic alterations to aquatic systems (e.g., damming, dredging), and (unregulated) environmental pollution. Especially the missing regulations, as well as growing volumes of sewage and physical waste have an enormous toll on the aquatic systems, but also pose threats by remobilization during floods.

    To investigate potential flood-induced strata and chemostratigraphic changes over time, a total of nine sediment profiles along the Adyar and Cooum rivers are subject to GC-MS analyses of organic pollutants in correlation to stratigraphic changes in the obtained sediment profiles.

    First results indicate that organic pollutants, such as petrogenic compounds (hopanes, PAHs), urban wastewater compounds (LABs, DEHA, methyl-triclosane), technical compounds (Mesamoll®, DPE, NBFA) and pesticides (e.g., DDX) allow for the identification of past flooding events and their characterization in terms of release and distribution of pollution. These proxies are used to assess (chemo-)stratigraphical alterations preserved in these sedimentary archives. However, sedimentary archives in fast-growing, urbanized environments are influenced by physical anthropogenic alterations leading to superimpositions or a hiatus in the sedimentary archives, thus hampering with the (chemo-)stratigraphic reconstruction of past flooding events and environmental changes.

    How to cite: Bellanova, L., Bellanova, P., Schwarzbauer, J., Lehmkuhl, F., Schulte, P., and Reicherter, K.: Chennai’s urban river systems – environmental changes, anthropogenic pollution and flood-induced remobilization, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12481, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12481, 2022.

    Due to extreme precipitation and runoff, severe flooding occurred in Germany in the summer of 2021 (July 13th–16th). In the catchment area of the Rur river, especially along its tributaries Inde and Wurm, but also along the Rur itself, this flood caused severe destruction and impacts on modern and older floodplains and anthropogenic utilized areas. This led to the acute and unusual input of harmful organic pollutants, as well as the remobilization and relocation of old burdens.

    Particularly floodplains are of central importance during such flood events as their natural functions include water, sediment, and nutrient retention, as well as the self-purification of water bodies. The focus of this investigation was therefore on the importance and relevance of natural floodplains during and after the 2021 summer flood. For this purpose, 16 different floodplains distributed throughout the Rur’s course were sampled immediately after the flood. The objectives were to determine pollutant concentrations, distribution, and accumulation, as well as the identification of potential pollution sources. In this context, the results of previous floodplain sampling and regular monitoring of the river’s sediments are also considered.

    Preliminary results indicate elevated concentrations of several organic pollutant groups, including PAHs (polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons), PCBs (polychlorinated biphenyls), and LABs (linear alkylbenzenes). These substances are indicators of petrogenic pollution, historical (old burdens) and current heavy industry in the catchment area, and, of wastewater and urban pollution, respectively.

    By considering these indicators and identifying emission sources (e.g., wastewater treatment plants, destructed infrastructure and industry along the main river and its tributaries) and accumulation areas that are relevant for remobilization, statements can be obtained about the high dynamics of the flood event. Furthermore, the importance of natural floodplains for the accumulation and remobilization of organic pollutants, but also the self-purification of water bodies is thus investigated and emphasized. This is of great importance for the holistic assessment of the fate and behaviour of organic pollutants as well as for the estimation of short- and long-term environmental risks and hazards related to (extreme) flood events.

    How to cite: Schwanen, C., Bellanova, P., and Schwarzbauer, J.: The 2021 Flood Disaster in Germany – Distribution, remobilization and accumulation of organic pollutants along the natural floodplains of the Rur river, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12558, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12558, 2022.

    EGU22-12589 | Presentations | NH1.4

    Analysis of GNSS sensed slant wet delay during the severe weather events in central Europe 

    Addisu Hunegnaw, Hüseyin Duman, Gunnar Elgered, Jan Dousa, and Norman Teferle

    Over the last few decades, anthropogenic greenhouse gas emissions have increased the frequency of climatological anomalies such as temperature, precipitation, and evapotranspiration. It is noticed that the frequency and severity of the intense precipitation signify a greater susceptibility to flash flooding. Flash flooding continues to be a major threat to European cities, with devastating mortality and considerable damage to urban infrastructure. As a result, accurate forecasting of future extreme precipitation events is critical for natural hazard mitigation. A network of ground-based GNSS receivers enables the measurement of integrated water vapour along slant pathways providing three-dimensional water vapour distributions. This study aims to demonstrate how GNSS sensing of the troposphere can be used to monitor the rapid and extreme weather events that occurred in central Europe in June 2013 and resulted in flash floods and property damage. We recovered one-way slant wet delay (SWD) by adding GNSS post-fit phase residuals, representing the troposphere's higher-order inhomogeneity. Nonetheless, noise in the GNSS phase observable caused by site-specific multipath can significantly affect the SWD from individual satellites. To overcome the problem, we employ a suitable averaging strategy for stacking post-fit phase residuals obtained from the PPP processing strategy to generate site-specific multipath corrections maps (MPS). The spatial stacking is carried out in congruent cells with an optimal resolution in elevation and azimuth at the local horizon but with decreasing azimuth resolution as the elevation angle increases. This permits an approximately equal number of observations allocated to each cell. The spatio-temporal fluctuations in the SWD as measured by GNSS closely mirrored the moisture field associated with severe weather events in central Europe, i.e., a brief rise prior to the main rain events, followed by a rapid decline once the storms passed. Furthermore, we validated the one-way SWD between ground-based water-vapour radiometry (WVR) and GNSS-derived SWD for different elevation angles.

     

    How to cite: Hunegnaw, A., Duman, H., Elgered, G., Dousa, J., and Teferle, N.: Analysis of GNSS sensed slant wet delay during the severe weather events in central Europe, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12589, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12589, 2022.

    Climate change has a significant role in increasing extreme precipitation, including the intensity, frequency, and magnitude of events due to increases in atmospheric moisture and climate variability. This means that future increases in floods due to climate change must be considered in the construction of flood defenses, as well as the planning of new infrastructure and hydraulic structures. Previous approaches for stress testing the design of flood defenses have relied on the scenario neutral approach and the use of harmonic functions to represent changes in the seasonality and mean of precipitation. Such approaches may inadequately account for changes in extreme precipitation, especially in runoff dominated catchments. Here, we adapt the scenario neutral approach by integrating a discrete wavelet transform (DWT) to develop the flood response surface. Such an approach allows evaluation of flood sensitivity to high and low frequency components of precipitation. Using 39 catchments in Ireland, we examine the sensitivity of flooding (QT20) to changes in low and high frequency precipitation and air temperature. A sensitivity domain of 525 extreme precipitation scenarios is applied by combining 21 low frequency and 25 high frequency sets of precipitation and air temperature changes, with short duration frequency incorporated in each harmonic wavelet function. Clustering and discriminant analysis are used to create a typology of catchment sensitivity based on generated response surfaces, the mean of annual maximum precipitation, and the mean of annual maximum flows. Results allow characterization of catchment sensitivity in gauged and ungauged locations and the integration of a wider spectrum of precipitation changes when assessing sensitivity allowances for climate change.  

     

    How to cite: Meresa, H. and Murphy, C.: Evaluating flood sensitivity to changes in high and low frequency precipitation using a discrete wavelet transform, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13038, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13038, 2022.

    EGU22-89 | Presentations | NH10.1

    Mapping single hazards and multi-hazard interrelationships in Global South urban areas: A case study in Kathmandu, Nepal. 

    Harriet Thompson, Bruce D. Malamud, Joel C. Gill, and Robert Šakić Trogrlić

    Achieving a holistic approach to disaster risk reduction in urban areas remains challenging. This requires understanding the breadth of single hazards and multi-hazard interrelationships across various spatial and temporal scales that might impact a given urban area. Here we describe an approach to systematically map the single hazards and multi-hazard interrelationships that have a potential to impact Kathmandu, Nepal, one of the focus cities of the UK Global Challenges Research Fund (GCRF) Tomorrow’s Cities research hub. Using an existing classification of 21 natural hazard types (across six hazard groups: geophysical, hydrological, atmospheric, biological, space), we first searched for evidence of each of these occurring in or affecting Kathmandu. We used systematic mapping to find and select evidence, applying a simple Boolean search with keywords and reviewing publications across all years available on online databases before selecting evidence from 2010 onwards where available. The spatial boundary around Kathmandu was not specified, rather we chose evidence based on recorded or potential impacts in the city. When searches returned many results (i.e., over 100), we skimmed titles and abstracts for spatial and temporal occurrence to select up to 5 sources. We examined and integrated evidence from diverse sources, including academic literature, grey literature, traditional media (e.g., English language Nepali newspapers), global and national disaster databases and social media. This evidence was then used to assess potential multi-hazard interrelationships that may occur in Kathmandu. Using this blended evidence, we found 21 single hazard types that might impact Kathmandu. We found case study evidence for 11 interrelationship types that have had previous impact in Kathmandu with many more that are theoretically possible. The results illustrate the complexity of the hazard landscape, with many single hazards and multi-hazard interrelationships potentially impacting Kathmandu. This knowledge can inform the development of dynamic risk scenarios, to use in planning and civil protection, thus strengthening multi-hazard approaches to disaster risk reduction in Kathmandu.

    How to cite: Thompson, H., Malamud, B. D., Gill, J. C., and Šakić Trogrlić, R.: Mapping single hazards and multi-hazard interrelationships in Global South urban areas: A case study in Kathmandu, Nepal., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-89, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-89, 2022.

    This work aims to improve existing Early Warning Systems (EWSs) assessment tools in appraising multi-hazard risk including natural hazards and infectious diseases epidemics or pandemics. The improved EWS assessment tool is applied in four Eastern Partnership countries through the development of a questionnaire, in the framework of the EU-funded PPRDEAST3 project. The analysis of the results of the questionnaire allowed identifying a series of lessons learned to be factored into a revision of the EWSs towards a permanent state of multi-hazard risk.

    Because of the spread of the COVID-19, every country has been encountering challenges in several sectors. In addition to socioeconomic impacts, the declined capacities, especially in the health sector, led to changes in priorities for allocation of the resources in the short term and alteration of the development pathways of governments in the long term.

    Furthermore, the long-lasting nature of the pandemic has increased the possibility of the concurrence of other natural hazards during the spread time of the virus. In this multi-hazard risk condition, civil protection organizations have to consider extra countermeasures for response to prevent the outbreak of the disease, including restrictions in sheltering and evacuation procedures.  

    In the proposed approach, a conceptual model for multi-hazard EWSs, including natural hazards and infectious diseases, based on literature review and experts’ opinion, has been developed and used to derive a new set of indicators useful to understand current EWSs pandemics and multi-hazard risk capabilities.

    The final assessment tool is obtained by integrating the new indicators with the previous ones already present in the EWS assessment tool developed by CIMA Foundation. The tool consists of five groups of indicators, four (already present) assessing the traditional EWS pillars, (i) disaster risk knowledge, (ii) detection, monitoring, analysis, and forecasting of the hazard and possible consequences, (iii) warning dissemination and communication, (iv) preparedness and response capabilities, and the last one added to assess (v) pandemics (specifically COVID19) and multi-hazard capabilities. Each group is divided into three to five sub-indicators.

    Partner countries were asked to score each on a 0-5 scale in the way that 0 corresponds to "no steps have been made regarding that indicator", and 5 means "they fully meet the requirements relating to that indicator."

    The results have been discussed and validated using extra open-source information to evaluate the accuracy of the assessment tool and the compatibility of the given scores with the real situation in partner countries. From this comparison, some biases in the responses have been observed. Therefore, to further improve the assessment tool, it is suggested to firstly, determine the criteria for each point that may give by the responders and secondly, ask for the evidence for each response.

    Finally, the result of this research emphasized the necessity of the integration of infectious disease and natural hazard EWSs, the inclusion of the Health Ministry in the decision-making processes of the civil protection, and the coordination between slow onset and rapid onset hazard EWSs.

    How to cite: mohammadi, S., Miozzo, D., Boni, G., and De Angeli, S.: Assessing multi-hazard risk assessment capabilities of Early Warning Systems considering potential interactions among pandemics and natural hazards, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-100, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-100, 2022.

    EGU22-192 | Presentations | NH10.1

    A dataset for multi-risk analysis in the Philippines 

    Marleen de Ruiter, Giovanni Votano, and Anaïs Couasnon

    The occurence and impacts of disasters are increasing in many parts of the world. The increased complexity of disaster risk due to climate change, expected population growth and the increasing interconnectedness of disaster impacts across communities and economic sectors demonstrates the need to improve our ability to understand and model the impacts of consecutive disasters. These consecutive disasters can be described as disasters whose impacts overlap temporally and spatially while recovery from an earlier disaster is still underway. Several challenges affect our ability to account for the impacts of consecutive disasters and multi-hazard interactions, including extensive data requirements and a common focus on single-hazard risk.  

     

    Incorporating spatiotemporal dynamics of hazard, exposure and vulnerability is key to understanding drivers of risks and their interactions. In this study, we focus on the Philippines and generate an extensive dataset of multi-hazard events based on observed time series of disasters. We illustrate the potential applications of our dataset with an analysis of the inter-arrival time between hazard events and their impacts. The Philippines is located along the ‘Ring of fire’ and is one of the world’s most at risk countries of natural hazards includingearthquakes, tropical cyclones, landslides, and flooding. The study is carried out for the time period 1980-2019 and at two spatial scales: national and provincial. This dataset is further analysed to document the socio-economic impacts of consecutive disasters as well as the interdependencies and dynamics between multi-hazard events. This spatially and temporally consistent dataset can be used as input for future risk modelling effort to integrate the dynamics and impacts of consecutive disasters.

    How to cite: de Ruiter, M., Votano, G., and Couasnon, A.: A dataset for multi-risk analysis in the Philippines, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-192, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-192, 2022.

    EGU22-214 | Presentations | NH10.1

    Conceptualizing an adaptation pathway model for multi-hazard, multi-stakeholder systems 

    Julius Schlumberger, Marleen de Ruiter, Marjolijn Haasnoot, and Jeroen Aerts

    While current adaptation planning approaches commonly focus on single hazards and individual sectors, a paradigm shift in decision-making is required to account for the increasingly interconnected world. Decision making support tools are needed to enable fair distribution of support and (increasingly) limited resources (i.e. space, financial means). No such integrated tools exist yet that account for dependencies, conflicts, and co-benefits between various stakeholders as well as the knowledge regarding dependencies and co-existence of various hazards and their joint impacts. This work provides a first conceptual framework of a decision-support tool in the context of adaptation planning in a multi-hazard, multi-stakeholder setting.

    Decision-making processes for adaptation planning need to follow dynamically robust plans instead of a static optimal strategy to account for the deeply uncertain future. In fact, a myriad of uncertain or even unknown factors (i.e. climate change, socio-economic developments, technology advancement) might lead to very different future developments. Dynamic Adaptation Policy Pathways (DAPP) is a widely used systematic and practical approach for decision-making over time and strategic planning under uncertain conditions to design dynamic, adaptive plans covering short-term no-regret actions, long-term options, and adaptation signals to take actions.

    A systematic literature review was undertaken to analyze adaptation planning concepts across various (multi-)sectors and (multi-)hazard contexts. This literature review was used to identify underlying paradigms and relevant concepts in the field of scenario analysis, pathway modelling, and multi-objective decision-making useful for advancing the existing DAPP approach. Using a simple, synthetic multi-hazard, multi-sector case study, the tailored adaptation planning framework was tested for its robustness.

    As a result, an advanced DAPP framework was developed. It accounts for several different physical processes playing a role in natural hazard impacts on human systems (i.e., different hazard types). Moreover, it accounts for spatial and temporal dependence of (different) hazards influencing coping capacities and the triggering space to take adaptation actions (compound, consecutive, aggregating impacts). Furthermore, the framework acknowledges 1) the diversity of stakeholders in an exposed system in terms of their vulnerability, objectives, coping capacities and contesting interests (e.g., limited resources or space), and 2) the diversity of driving actors of adaptation action within a system and the connectedness of decisions and implications on the system development. The framework uses information about the system and its boundaries, along with information about the available adaptation actions, information about the decision making process / motivation to take adaptation action, information about possible conflicts / dependencies within the decision space (with regards to objectives, adaptation actions, and other system elements) and implicit assumptions used to define the system (of systems). Using this framework, adaptation pathways – meaning sequence of adaptation actions – can be created and evaluated with regards to their robustness and performance in comparison to long-term visions.

    How to cite: Schlumberger, J., de Ruiter, M., Haasnoot, M., and Aerts, J.: Conceptualizing an adaptation pathway model for multi-hazard, multi-stakeholder systems, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-214, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-214, 2022.

    EGU22-332 | Presentations | NH10.1

    A Global Multi-hazard Perspective on Joint Probabilities of Historic Hazards 

    Judith Claassen, James Daniell, Elco E. Koks, Timothy Tiggeloven, Marleen C. de Ruiter, and Philip J Ward

    While the last decade saw substantial scientific advances in studies aimed at improving our understanding of natural hazard risk, research and policy commonly address risk from a single-hazard, single-sector perspective. Thus, not considering the spatial and temporal interconnections of these events. Single-hazards risk analyses are often inaccurate and incomplete when multi-hazard disasters occur, as the interaction between them may lead to a different impact than summing the impacts of single events. Therefore, the MYRIAD-EU project aim is to catalyse the paradigm shift required to move towards a multi-risk, multi-sector, systemic approach to risk assessment and management. In order to achieve this, the overall aim is that policy-makers, decision-makers, and practitioners will be able to develop forward-looking disaster risk management pathways that assess trade-offs and synergies across sectors, hazards, and scales. A key first step to achieving this aim is to create a greater understanding of realistic multi-hazard event sets that better examines statistical dependencies between hazard types. To do so, single hazards datasets for meteorological, geological, hydrological and biological events are explored using stochastic modelling and multivariate statistical methods, and create a dataset of potential coinciding hazard events at a global scale. By exploring these multi-hazard interconnections, we achieve a deeper understanding of the different types of multi-hazards events and their temporal and spatial interconnections. Furthermore, this dataset maps indirect, interregional, and cross-sectoral risk throughout the world. Moreover, the multi-hazards event sets will enable to simulate future conditions under climate change by incorporating the Representative Concentration Pathways (RCPs) as well as Socio-economic change using Shared Socioeconomic Pathways (SSPs).   

    How to cite: Claassen, J., Daniell, J., Koks, E. E., Tiggeloven, T., de Ruiter, M. C., and Ward, P. J.: A Global Multi-hazard Perspective on Joint Probabilities of Historic Hazards, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-332, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-332, 2022.

    EGU22-547 | Presentations | NH10.1

    Multi-hazard risk assessment of critical infrastructure at the global scale 

    Sadhana Nirandjan, Elco Koks, Hans de Moel, Jasper Verschuur, Oliver Wing, Jeroen Aerts, and Philip Ward

    Critical infrastructures (CI) play an essential role in the day-to-day functioning of societies and economies. They refer to the array of physical assets required for the operation of the complex infrastructure network, which include energy grids, waste systems, and transportation networks. At the same time, impacts of natural hazards highlight the importance of improving our understanding on the natural hazard risk to these infrastructures. CI have evolved in large interconnected networks, whereby disruption of one asset may quickly propagate into widespread consequences – even outside an exposed area. The disruption of the services provided by CI have large potential to seriously hamper the daily activities of societies and economies that depend on them, as well as the recovery in the aftermath of an disruptive event.

    To date, however, scientific literature on the potential global asset damages to CI induced by multi-hazards remain limited. Modelling assessments that combine information on hazard intensities and extents, exposure of infrastructure and the vulnerability of these exposed assets are crucial to improve our understanding of infrastructure that are directly at risk to multi-hazards. In this study, we provide first global estimates of multi-hazard risk to CI systems under current climate conditions. To this end, we assess: (1) the global exposure of CI to coastal and fluvial flooding, cyclones, earthquakes and landslides; and (2) quantify the potential asset damages as a consequence of these multi-hazards.

    We represent the infrastructure network by seven overarching CI systems: energy, transportation, telecommunication, water, waste, education and health. A total of 42 infrastructure types (e.g. hospitals, power towers, wastewater treatment plants) are selected from OpenStreetMap (OSM) and categorized under these overarching CI systems. The high-detailed spatial data for infrastructure is combined with hazard data to derive the exposure of infrastructure to the various hazards. Moreover, we develop a vulnerability database for critical infrastructure based on the current body of literature to translate the exposure into asset damages.   

    It is urgently needed to build robust and resilient infrastructure, so that they are able to cope with current and future natural hazards. Therefore, risk information should systematically be included for infrastructure planning, and the protection of the most vulnerable and critical assets needs to be improved. Limiting the direct impact of natural hazards on exposed assets will result in economic and social benefits that go beyond direct infrastructure damage.

    How to cite: Nirandjan, S., Koks, E., de Moel, H., Verschuur, J., Wing, O., Aerts, J., and Ward, P.: Multi-hazard risk assessment of critical infrastructure at the global scale, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-547, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-547, 2022.

    EGU22-956 | Presentations | NH10.1

    Cascading Effects of Extreme Geohazards on Tenerife (Canary Islands) 

    Marta López-Saavedra, Joan Martí, Jose Luis Rubio, and Karim Kelfoun

    Extreme geohazards (volcanic eruptions, earthquakes, landslides and tsunamis) have the potential to inflict cascading effects whose associated risks are difficult to predict and prepare for. Thus, these events are generally not taken into account in hazard assessment. Anticipating the occurrence of such extreme events is thus key if our life-styles are to remain safe and sustainable. Volcanic islands are often the source of complex successions of disastrous events, as is evident from any examination, for instance, of the geological record of regions such as Hawaii, the Canary Islands, Reunion and Indonesia. The island of Tenerife in the Canary Archipelago is an excellent example of where cascading extreme hazards have occurred several times in the past and could occur again in the future. A cascading sequence involving a caldera-forming eruption, high-magnitude seismicity, mega-landslides and tsunamis occurred at least twice during the construction of this island. In order to understand the possible consequences of such processes if they were to reoccur, we simulated the extent and potential impact of a multiple, extreme geohazard episode similar to the last recorded one that took place on the island of Tenerife around 180 ka. If this event were to occur today, the PDCs resulting from the collapse of the eruptive column would devastate nearly the entire island. The caldera collapse would generate high-magnitude seismicity that would severely affect the central part of the island, corresponding to the caldera of Las Cañadas and its walls, the Icod Valley, the NE and NW rifts, and Bandas del Sur in the southeast. Seismic shocks could trigger a mega-landslide in the current Icod valley that would mobilise a thickness of about 500 m. The impact of this mass against the ocean would generate a first tsunami wave up to 200 m high that would sweep the coasts of the north of Tenerife in less than 10 minutes. This is probably the most catastrophic scenario for this region, and it sets a maximum limit to the range of situations that may occur in Tenerife in order to design a better risk management in this island without exceeding with minor events or falling short in case of events of greater impact. The implications of such a disastrous succession of events are analysed at local, regional and global scales, and the results obtained are discussed within the framework of disaster risk-reduction policies.

    How to cite: López-Saavedra, M., Martí, J., Rubio, J. L., and Kelfoun, K.: Cascading Effects of Extreme Geohazards on Tenerife (Canary Islands), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-956, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-956, 2022.

    EGU22-1818 | Presentations | NH10.1

    How drought affects flood risk: positive / negative effects and feedbacks in different cases 

    Anne Van Loon, Marlies Barendrecht, Ruben Weesie, Heidi Mendoza, Alessia Matanó, Johanna Koehler, Melanie Rohse, Marleen de Ruiter, Maurizio Mazzoleni, Philip Ward, Jeroen Aerts, Giuliano di Baldassarre, and Rosie Day

    Droughts are long-lasting and have a range of cascading impacts on society. These impacts and their responses can influence the further development of the drought itself, but also continue into the period after the drought ended. Especially if society is hit by a next hydrological extreme event, heavy rainfall resulting in flooding, the effects of this may be increased or decreased by the preceding drought and its impacts and responses. We here present a review and a global assessment of cases of these events, based on scientific literature, NGO and governmental reports, and newspaper articles, to study the diversity of how drought affects flood risk. We find that the balance between the positive and negative effects of extreme rainfall after a long dry period is mostly dependent on the underlying vulnerability and the effect of specific responses, and is different for different countries, and for different sectors and groups in society. Based on our initial analysis of the collection of case studies, we see some emerging patterns. For example, in Europe, the USA and Australia, the highly managed water system with hard infrastructure and early-warning systems makes that in most cases the rainfall after drought are managed and adverse effects mitigated, but also lock-ins exist that can make feedbacks of either inaction or maladaptation result in increased economic losses. In Africa and Latin-America, with a fragile governance system, less hard infrastructure, and a more exposed population, extreme rainfall after drought brings relief and replenishment of water resources, but also increased impacts, conflict and displacement. Here, we hypothesise that impacts are unequally distributed in society, because of issues of power, access to land and water resources, inadequate soft infrastructures, etc. We will test this hypothesis with an in-depth qualitative study of local stakeholder knowledge of these human-water processes in selected case studies. The typology of drought-to-flood events that we developed can serve as a starting point for further research on the complexity of these cascading events.

    How to cite: Van Loon, A., Barendrecht, M., Weesie, R., Mendoza, H., Matanó, A., Koehler, J., Rohse, M., de Ruiter, M., Mazzoleni, M., Ward, P., Aerts, J., di Baldassarre, G., and Day, R.: How drought affects flood risk: positive / negative effects and feedbacks in different cases, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1818, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1818, 2022.

    EGU22-3005 | Presentations | NH10.1

    Assessing risk managers' perceptions of risk mitigation strategies under a climate change and energy transition context. 

    Jonathan Mille, Dr Danielle Charlton, Dr Stephen Edwards, and Prof Muki Haklay

    Climate change and the energy transition are long-term challenges that could occur in a chaotic and uncertain way. The potential and varied impacts of these phenomena on existing human systems is leading to a rethinking of the ability of organisations to adapt life-sustaining services and business supply chains. However, the different scenarios surrounding these two phenomena are not always well understood by the public, by those who manage critical infrastructure, businesses, key institutions and organisations and sometimes even by risk managers. In order to assess whether current risk management strategies are able to cope with these two phenomena, it is important to understand the knowledge and perceptions of risk managers of the impacts of climate change and energy transition. 

     

    This research investigates the perception of climate change and energy transition by risk managers in order to (i) assess their understanding of the impact of the energy transition and climate change on current lifeline services and business supply chains, (ii) evaluate the needs of risk managers to integrate these phenomena into risk management strategies. Results of ongoing semi-structured interviews and questionnaires will be shared. Overall, the aim of this research is to improve cross-sectoral risk management strategies by integrating a systemic approach into risk management methodology and risk reduction strategies. 

     

    The research has been conducted in Chile, which is a country critical  to the global energy transition. Chile  is the world's primary producer of copper (30%) and ranks second in global lithium production (20%), two minerals coveted by different economic sectors and necessary for the global energy transition. In addition the region is exposed to numerous natural hazards, including climate related phenomena and associated extreme weather and temperature events. The integration of risk management strategies that incorporate both climate change and a change in energy supply is crucial in order to avoid significant disruptions and cascading effects in the supply chains of these increasingly sought-after minerals. 

    How to cite: Mille, J., Charlton, D. D., Edwards, D. S., and Haklay, P. M.: Assessing risk managers' perceptions of risk mitigation strategies under a climate change and energy transition context., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3005, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3005, 2022.

    EGU22-4118 | Presentations | NH10.1

    Multi-risk analysis, mitigation and resilience in historical cities 

    Chiara Arrighi, Marco Tanganelli, Vieri Cardinali, Maria Teresa Cristofaro, Mario De Stefano, and Fabio Castelli

    The need for a shift from single to multi-risk analysis is widely recognized in international agreements, however the different multidisciplinary aspects, hazard metrics, data requirements and resolutions make quantitative multi-hazard and multi-vulnerability assessment rarely practiced. This work aims at describing a multi-risk assessment including present and mitigation scenarios and multi-risk resilience for historical art cities where the ability to recovery from a disaster passes through cultural heritage and related economic activities. Earthquakes and floods are considered to introduce a multi-risk workflow for buildings based on common metrics for exposure, vulnerability, and risk and a dynamic resilience model to simulate the post-event recovery. The method is applied to the historical city center of Florence (Italy), which is exposed to low-probability events and renowned for its unique cultural heritage. The application of the method suggests that the estimation of direct physical damages for earthquakes and floods requires a different characterization of vulnerability parameters. The resilience to earthquakes and floods shows significantly different recovery times that are linked to the severity of losses. The results of the application to the historical city center Florence show interesting differences in the spatial distribution of multi-risk, mostly depending on the evolution of the constructive typologies form the Middle-Ages to the XX century but also on the anthropic alteration of terrain morphology.  Further research would be needed to finding synergies in multi-risk mitigation and to better understand resilience to cascade risks.

    Arrighi, C., Tanganelli, M., Cristofaro M.T., Cardinali, V., Marra, A.M., Castelli, F., De Stefano M.: Multi risk assessment in a historical city, Natural hazards, doi.org/10.1007/s11069-021-05125-6

    How to cite: Arrighi, C., Tanganelli, M., Cardinali, V., Cristofaro, M. T., De Stefano, M., and Castelli, F.: Multi-risk analysis, mitigation and resilience in historical cities, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4118, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4118, 2022.

    EGU22-4467 | Presentations | NH10.1 | Highlight

    Multiple hazards and public risk perceptions under COVID-19 

    Giuliano Di Baldassarre, Elena Raffetti, and Elena Mondino

    The salience of global crises, such as COVID-19 and climate change, have plausibly influenced how people characterize and assess multiple hazards. In this study, we examine and compare how global crises and local disasters influence public perceptions of multiple hazards in Italy and Sweden by integrating the results of nationwide surveys with information about the occurrence of hazardous events. These included more than 4,000 participants and were conducted in three different phases of the COVID-19 pandemic (August 2020, November 2020 and August 2021), corresponding to various levels of infection rates. In line with the cognitive process known as the availability heuristic, we found that people are more worried about risks related to experienced events. In both countries, individuals assess the risk associated with a given hazard based on how easily it comes to their mind. Moreover, notwithstanding the ongoing pandemic, people in both Italy and Sweden are highly concerned about climate change, and they rank it as the most likely threat. Lastly, we found that public perceptions of multiple hazards are deeply intertwined. These outcomes do no only increase our knowledge on the way in which global crises and hazardous events shape public risk perception across different contexts, but also have the potential to inform communication strategies aiming to reduce disaster risk while supporting climate change adaptation.

    How to cite: Di Baldassarre, G., Raffetti, E., and Mondino, E.: Multiple hazards and public risk perceptions under COVID-19, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4467, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4467, 2022.

    Children spend around five days a week in school for almost the entire year. Thus, it is sensible to best prepare them for coping with the potential occurrence of hazardous events while they are in school. The present research aims to explore the perceived importance and feasibility of implementing school-based disaster preparedness (SBDP) by the means of a case study of Ljungby municipality, Kronoberg county, Sweden. Through the means of semi-structured interviews, questionnaires and secondary data, the research unravelled how the respondents, in the form of both students and school staff perceive SBDP, and whether they see it as a potentially useful tool for their schools. In addition, the paper focused on understanding how this type of disaster preparedness can contribute to the municipality’s resilience. We concluded that the respondents understand the importance of SBDP and consider that the administrations at school and municipality level should focus more on ensuring that crisis plans are available, as well as on short- and long-term strategic preparedness. In addition, a shift in focus from training only staff to including students as valuable resources and considering their levels of preparedness was noticed by the interviewees, as well as the need to increase the awareness regarding the available SBDP items in each school. The existent crisis plans might need additional consideration in order to ensure their adaptability to schools’ needs, capacities, lessons learnt and locations. Further studies are needed in regard to whether students-aimed SBDP can be used for creating a sustainable SBDP culture within communities, municipalities and later on, entire countries.

    How to cite: Covaciu, A.: School-based disaster preparedness: a route to societal resilience? The case study of Ljungby municipality, Sweden, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4673, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4673, 2022.

    EGU22-5875 | Presentations | NH10.1

    CLOUDS: A toolbox for decision support and climate risk 

    Carla Sciarra, Massimo Dragan, Francesco Laio, Roberto Mezzalama, Luca Ridolfi, and Cristian Villata

    The world is currently witnessing a rapid exacerbation of the effects of climate change on anthropic and environmental systems. Through the latest Assessment Report 6, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (and so the EU with the Climate Change Adaptation strategy) has launched an urgent call to action to implement mitigation and adaptation strategies, to improve the resilience of these systems. Climate models are complex, requiring multi-disciplinary knowledge about climatology, physics, hydrology, hydraulics, mathematics and statistics, among others, to be conceived and implemented. Complexity is not limited to the model preparation and functioning, but it extends to the interpretation of the outputs by the users. Models’ assumptions and the uncertainties related to the outcomes pose an issue of accessibility and usability in the short period, with consequences on the decision-makers' (corporations, and governments) ability to correctly address the issues at hand.
    Several requirements to conduct climate risk assessment have been and are being developed by governmental and non-governmental organizations, particularly for infrastructure projects, and this is creating a demand for new services besides the traditional engineering and scientific services. Golder Associates is a global consulting firm providing services to governments and corporations, with a particular emphasis on the energy and infrastructure sectors. Golder has seen an increase in demand for Climate Risk Assessment services, requiring up-to-date climate data and projections to determine the current and future exposure, hazard, and vulnerability to climate change of its clients’ assets and activities. The firm stands as an example of the challenges in translating the results and uncertainties of climate models and data into adaptation and mitigation strategies, often leading to an increase in uncertainties in major capital investments.
    To address this issue, we are developing a decision-support toolbox named CLOUDS (CLimate OUtputs for Decision Support) to help identify and calculate a set of key performance indicators and variables. The aim of CLOUDS is to provide a more straightforward representation of the complexity of the climate models’ outputs, still maintaining the accuracy of the estimates of climate-change effects but addressing the needs of decision-makers. CLOUDS consist of methodologies and routines, derived from the available suite of global circulation models, a set of indicators useful to decision-makers in preparing climate risk assessment analysis of existing assets and future infrastructure projects. The indicators are chosen considering their ability to define the exposure, hazards, and vulnerability to climate change in various contexts, and their connection with the output of the models. The advantage of creating such a toolbox in cooperation and collaboration with a consultancy firm stands in the opportunity to test and adapt the toolbox on a wide range of projects in different business sectors, geographic conditions, and sizes. Therefore, this allows us to study the effectiveness of CLOUDS and by comparing its performances in terms of time and cost with projects using other decision-making tools. Finally, CLOUDS fosters the transfer of knowledge between the academic, the governmental, and the business communities, required to face the consequences of climate change. 

    How to cite: Sciarra, C., Dragan, M., Laio, F., Mezzalama, R., Ridolfi, L., and Villata, C.: CLOUDS: A toolbox for decision support and climate risk, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5875, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5875, 2022.

    EGU22-6010 | Presentations | NH10.1

    Risk workflow for CAScading and COmpounding hazards in COastal urban areas: The CASCO Project 

    Cecilia I. Nievas, Laurens M. Bouwer, Morelia Urlaub, Alexey Androsov, Andrey Babeyko, Christian Berndt, Fabrice Cotton, Juan Camilo Gómez Zapata, Jens Karstens, Heidrun Kopp, Danijel Schorlemmer, and Hui Tang

    Extreme climatic and geophysical events pose a threat to societies and have the capacity to cause significant damage and losses whenever they occur, both in their immediate aftermath and in the medium- to long-term. Their consequences can be amplified even further when more than one event affects the same geographical areas within a short time. Be it cascading hazards, in which one event triggers the next, or simply hazards that happen to occur simultaneously (“compounding” hazards), estimation of their cumulative consequences is challenging because the action of one event affects the exposure and vulnerability to the next one. While the efforts from the research community to develop multi-hazard perspectives have increased considerably in recent years, multiple remaining challenges require strongly-coordinated efforts across different disciplines and areas of expertise to tackle them with the most appropriate tools.

    With a multidisciplinary team of scientists from four different Helmholtz research centres in Germany, we have started working on the CASCO project (2022-2024), in which we will develop an integrated risk workflow for CAScading and COmpounding hazards in COastal urban areas by focusing on a series of events occurring around Mount Etna (Italy). The case-scenario starts with a strong earthquake that triggers a submarine collapse at the eastern flank of Mount Etna, an area already known to be unstable, and both the earthquake and the landslide trigger a tsunami that hits the coasts of Sicily and Calabria. Almost concomitantly, a heatwave or heavy rainfall happens to affect the same regions, further stressing the population that had been affected by the combined effects of the earthquake and tsunami.

    The project will be directed towards the modelling of the cascading earthquake, landslide and tsunami events, the compounding heatwave and rainfall, as well as their immediate impacts in terms of cumulative damage and casualties. Moreover, the medium- to long-term response in urban dynamics and the effect of these extreme events on the economic development of the affected populations will be explored.

    By focusing on a tangible scenario, CASCO will not only tackle the challenges associated with bringing together the whole risk chain (which will be valid beyond our case-study) but also produce outcomes that help increase awareness of such extreme events and the need for societies to develop suitable strategies to strengthen their resilience and improve their disaster response.

    How to cite: Nievas, C. I., Bouwer, L. M., Urlaub, M., Androsov, A., Babeyko, A., Berndt, C., Cotton, F., Gómez Zapata, J. C., Karstens, J., Kopp, H., Schorlemmer, D., and Tang, H.: Risk workflow for CAScading and COmpounding hazards in COastal urban areas: The CASCO Project, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6010, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6010, 2022.

    EGU22-6230 | Presentations | NH10.1

    A Systems Dependency Framework for Individual, Multi- and Systemic Risks 

    Stefan Hochreiner-Stigler and Robert Sakic Trogrlic

    ABSTRACT: New approaches for the assessment and management of individual, multi- and systemic risks are needed. In this work, we present a framework for the assessment and management of these risks based on the system dependency perspective. We suggest that dependencies may act as one guiding principle not only for assessing such risks but also for evaluating risk management options. The two most extreme cases within the suggested systems dependency perspective are the independence and full dependency state, representing the two ends of the risk continuum. Such a perspective enables an integration of risk management strategies within a coherent framework across geographical and governance scales (i.e., from local to global). Furthermore, individual and multi-hazard risks can be tackled simultaneously as well as independently through the assumption of different strengths of connectedness during a disaster event. The real-world challenges of risk bearers (e.g., households, businesses, governments, supranational institutions) to account for such interdependencies are discussed within the context of optimal complexity.

     

    Keywords: Individual Risk, Multi-Risk, Compound Risk, Systemic Risk, Dependencies, Optimal Complexity.

    How to cite: Hochreiner-Stigler, S. and Sakic Trogrlic, R.: A Systems Dependency Framework for Individual, Multi- and Systemic Risks, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6230, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6230, 2022.

    EGU22-6551 | Presentations | NH10.1

    Increasing compound concurrent hot day and night extremes in five big cities of Switzerland 

    Saeid Ashraf Vaghefi, Veruska Muccione, Raphael Neukom, Christian Huggel, and Nadine Salzmann

    The interaction of multiple hazards across various spatial and temporal scales typically causes compound climate and weather extreme events. Compound concurrent hot day and night extremes that combine daytime and nighttime heat are of greater concern for health than individual hot days or hot nights. Continuous day and nighttime heatwaves can exacerbate human discomfort and therefore increase the risks of heat-related morbidity and mortality. However, little is known about the evolution of such events in the observed and projected climate. Four compound event types, namely (a) preconditioned, (b) multivariate, (c) temporally compounding, and (d) spatially compounding events were introduced in the literature that facilitates the selection of the proper approaches in the study of compound extreme events. The impact of a single or the combination of multiple types could shape more severe extreme events. In our study, we considered the temporally compounding and multivariate types and used climate observations (1981-2020) and high-resolution bias-corrected climate model scenarios of Switzerland (CH2018). Our analyses show that the average frequency and intensity of compound consecutive hot days and nights increase in five big cities of Switzerland until 2100 under RCP4.5. We projected 1.83 ± 0.07 (days decade−1) for Basel, 1.57 ± 0.1 (days decade−1) for Bern, 2.34 ± 0.13 (days decade−1) for Geneva, 2.55 ± 0.17 (days decade−1) for Lugano, and 1.93 ± 0.12 (days decade−1) for Zürich. Moreover, we found an increase in the intensity of summertime (April-October) compound hot extremes days and night in Basel (0.28 ± 0.03 °C decade−1), Bern (0.23 ± 0.02°C decade−1), Geneva (0.37 ± 0.04 °C decade−1), Lugano (0.4 ±0.07°C decade−1), and Zürich (0.44 ± 0.05°C decade−1).

    How to cite: Ashraf Vaghefi, S., Muccione, V., Neukom, R., Huggel, C., and Salzmann, N.: Increasing compound concurrent hot day and night extremes in five big cities of Switzerland, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6551, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6551, 2022.

    EGU22-6931 | Presentations | NH10.1

    The impacts of an extreme event: inventory, susceptibility, and exposure to landslides and debris-rich floods following Cyclone Idai in two mountainous districts of Zimbabwe 

    Antoine Dille, Olivier Dewitte, Jente Broeckx, Koen Verbist, Andile Sindiso Dube, Jean Poesen, and Matthias Vanmaercke

    Extreme rainfalls associated with tropical cyclones can have devastating impacts along the cyclone path. In mountainous regions, these rainfalls may trigger up to thousands of landslides, themselves feeding destructive debris-rich floods impacting downstream valleys sometimes over tens or hundreds of kilometres. Such compound events were observed in the mountains of eastern Zimbabwe alongside Cyclone Idai in March 2019. Hitting an area of high population vulnerability and exposure, this event had very-high human and geomorphologic impacts in the region. In the framework of the UNESCO project BE-RESILIENT Zimbabwe (funded by World Bank and managed by UNOPS), we analysed the consequences of the landslides associated with this event in the Chimanimani and Chipinge districts of eastern Zimbabwe (~8000 km²). Aiming at a rapid evaluation in a data-scarce region, we built on existing tools and open access satellite remote sensing and GIS data to obtain an exhaustive inventory of the spatial extent of the impacted area, and ultimately an assessment of the population exposure in the region. We mapped over 14 000 (mostly shallow) landslides associated with this single event. Alongside a high population vulnerability, the extreme impacts of the landslides were associated with the very large mobility – up to kilometre-long runout/deposition areas are found – of the landslides. To account for this, we distinguish three types of processes (zones) in our inventory, susceptibility, and exposure analyses: landslide source/depletion, landslide runout and debris-rich floods. This discrimination is key for apprehending the hazard imposed by landslides in the study area, and finally for properly evaluating the population exposure to this hazard. While this work aims primarily at guiding land use planning, mitigation, restoration, and prevention in the Chimanimani and Chipinge districts of eastern Zimbabwe, it also offers a case for the use of simple yet powerful approaches to assess the impacts of an extreme event and the exploitation of the astonishing amount of quality open access data now available for every corner of the globe.   

    How to cite: Dille, A., Dewitte, O., Broeckx, J., Verbist, K., Sindiso Dube, A., Poesen, J., and Vanmaercke, M.: The impacts of an extreme event: inventory, susceptibility, and exposure to landslides and debris-rich floods following Cyclone Idai in two mountainous districts of Zimbabwe, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6931, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6931, 2022.

    EGU22-8460 | Presentations | NH10.1

    Climate X: an interdisciplinary approach to projecting multiple climate-related risks and impacts 

    Claire Burke, James Brennan, Hamish Mitchell, Laura Ramsamy, Markela Zeneli, and Kamil Kluza

    With ever increasing risks and impacts from climate change, there is an urgent need for adaptation information which is relevant and useful to policy makers, businesses and the general public. At Climate X we use an interdisciplinary, impacts-motivated approach to adaptation; combining multiple climate and hazard models to give a holistic view of risk, and engaging end-users at every stage. Our first version product can project the risks and impacts of climate change-related pluvial and fluvial flooding, extreme heat, landslides, subsidence, and sea level rise, all at street level UK-wide. We quantify these risks and the financial costs they could incur under low (RCP 2.6) and high (RCP 8.5) emissions scenarios out to 2080. We deliver risk and impact assessments via an easy-to-use interface, along with relevant and decision-able risk summaries. Aligning robust science at scale with user requirements and expectations is not without its challenges. I will outline our approach to multi-hazard climate risk modelling, and discuss some of the successes and challenges we have had in developing a tool which is aligned with the needs of stakeholders, businesses and other end users.

    How to cite: Burke, C., Brennan, J., Mitchell, H., Ramsamy, L., Zeneli, M., and Kluza, K.: Climate X: an interdisciplinary approach to projecting multiple climate-related risks and impacts, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8460, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8460, 2022.

    EGU22-8911 | Presentations | NH10.1

    Learning from the Covid-19 pandemic to advance multi-hazard risk management: a critical analysis of the Italian Red Cross emergency management data 

    Stefano Terzi, Silvia de Angeli, Davide Miozzo, Lorenzo Stefano Massucchielli, Fabio Carturan, Joerg Szarzynski, and Giorgio Boni

    The long-lasting Covid-19 pandemic emergency that the world has been experiencing for more than two years is dramatically challenging all national emergency management systems. For the first time in recent history, our society has been dealing with a global slow-onset disaster, whose emergency phase is lasting for such an extended period, with varying levels of intensity, even with well-defined cycles. Furthermore, the pandemic has interacted with other disasters that occurred during the last years all over the world (e.g., the earthquake in Croatia, the tropical cyclone Harold, or the devastating floods in Western Europe including Germany, Belgium, and the Netherlands) underlining the compound and cascading nature of disasters. The complex conditions of Covid-19 (and of slow-onsets in general) and their temporal and spatial overlaps with other natural and man-made hazards have highlighted the limitations of the traditional Disaster Risk Management Cycle (DRMC) to deal with complex multi-hazard risk events.

    Our research aims to identify and provide evidence of the main limitations of the current DRMC paradigm when dealing with slow-onset risk events considering the potential interactions with other hazards which lead to the creation of complex multi-hazard risk conditions.

    Existing weaknesses of the current DRMC are investigated starting from the lessons learned during the Covid-19 pandemic. Specifically, we have considered and analysed data provided by the Italian Red Cross on the management of past and ongoing emergencies including the Covid-19 pandemic. We identified those critical risk management conditions and negative feedback loops triggered or exacerbated by slow-onset risks and multi-hazard risk events. In particular, our results indicate: (i) an initial phase shift between the actual pandemic emergency conditions (i.e. intensive care units occupancy) and the Italian Red Cross emergency response (i.e. number of emergency operators), showing the need for an adaptation phase when dealing with long-onset hazard risks such as pandemics; (ii) a reduction of the coping capacity (for all the hazards) due to the number of resources deployed to manage the Covid-19 emergency; (iii) a reduction of preparedness activities (including, e.g. training or exercises), due to the continuous emergency phase imposed by Covid-19, which will result in an overall weakening of the risk management system.

    The analysis has thus highlighted the need for a revised Disaster Risk Management framework, in which prevention, response, and recovery/rehabilitation operate simultaneously rather than sequentially in complex multi-hazard risk scenarios.

    Finally, our study provides insights and lessons learned from the management of the current pandemic seen through the lens of a multi-hazard risk perspective that can be transferred to other slow-onset hazards such as droughts. These results call for improvements of risk management plans within the current national/regional civil protection mechanisms as well as international humanitarian assistance, emphasizing the ultimate need for regional coordination and collaboration.

    How to cite: Terzi, S., de Angeli, S., Miozzo, D., Massucchielli, L. S., Carturan, F., Szarzynski, J., and Boni, G.: Learning from the Covid-19 pandemic to advance multi-hazard risk management: a critical analysis of the Italian Red Cross emergency management data, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8911, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8911, 2022.

    EGU22-9686 | Presentations | NH10.1

    A State-of-the-Art Approach to Modeling Future Multi-Hazard Risk, supporting People-Centred Decision Making 

    Gemma Cremen and the Tomorrow's Cities Early Career Risk Working Group

    Numerous approaches to multi-hazard risk modelling and quantification have already been proposed in the literature and/or are well established in practice. However, most of these procedures are designed to focus on risk in the context of current static exposure and vulnerability and are therefore limited in their ability to support decisions related to the future, as yet partially unbuilt, urban landscape. This work outlines an end-to-end risk modelling framework that explicitly addresses this specific challenge, forming the computational engine of the innovative Tomorrow’s Cities decision support environment. The framework is designed to consider the multi-hazard risks of tomorrow’s urban environment, using a simulation-based approach to rigorously capture the uncertainties inherent in future projections of exposure as well as physical and social vulnerability. The framework also advances the state-of-practice in future disaster risk modelling by additionally: (1) providing a harmonised methodology for integrating physical and social impacts of disasters that facilitates flexible characterisation of risk metrics beyond physical damage/asset losses; and (2) incorporating a participatory, people-centred approach to risk-informed decision making. It can be used to support decision making on policies related to future urban planning and design, accounting for various stakeholder perspectives on risk. The framework is showcased using the physical and social environment of Tomorrowville, an expanding synthetic city that has been specifically designed to capture distinct dynamic features of developing cities as part of the Tomorrow’s Cities project. 

    How to cite: Cremen, G. and the Tomorrow's Cities Early Career Risk Working Group: A State-of-the-Art Approach to Modeling Future Multi-Hazard Risk, supporting People-Centred Decision Making, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9686, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9686, 2022.

    EGU22-9704 | Presentations | NH10.1

    Characterising the dynamic physical vulnerability of Tomorrow’s Cities to multiple natural hazards 

    Roberto Gentile, Vibek Manandhar, Gemma Cremen, Luke Jenkins, Emin Mentese, Ramesh Guragain, Carmine Galasso, and John McCloskey

    During their expansion, cities are increasingly exposed to various risks from different natural hazards. Moreover, different drivers of these risks may evolve over time due to several endogenous and exogenous factors. In the context of proactive risk-informed, people-centred, and pro-poor urban planning and design, capturing the above dynamic effects is crucial. This study focuses on modelling the time-dependent physical fragility and vulnerability (i.e., the likelihood of damage and losses as a function of a hazard intensity measure) of building stocks. Given a set of relevant hazards for a case-study region, this research combines existing methodologies and datasets to 1) match the relevant building classes (i.e., construction types) in the case-study database with existing fragility and/or vulnerability models; 2) use state-of-the-art numerical and/or empirical methods to develop fragility/vulnerability models not already available, supplementing existing models; 3) identify and account for the factors affecting the time dependency of the above fragility/vulnerability models (e.g. ageing of buildings, the interaction of different hazards); 4) create a Geographic Information System (GIS) vulnerability database for integration within a broader risk model. The proposed approach offers a reasonable trade-off between the refinement of the considered time-dependent vulnerability assessment and the expected computational complexity of a building portfolio multi-hazard risk model. The proposed approach is demonstrated for the realistic urban prototype “Tomorrowville”, considering earthquakes, floods, and debris flows as case-study hazards.

    How to cite: Gentile, R., Manandhar, V., Cremen, G., Jenkins, L., Mentese, E., Guragain, R., Galasso, C., and McCloskey, J.: Characterising the dynamic physical vulnerability of Tomorrow’s Cities to multiple natural hazards, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9704, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9704, 2022.

    EGU22-9946 | Presentations | NH10.1

    Mapping future exposure to multiple hazards in Tomorrow’s Cities: the Khokana, Kathmandu, Nepal case study 

    Aditi Dhakal, Suresh Chaudhary, Ramesh Guragain, Vibek Manandhar, Roberto Gentile, Gemma Cremen, Carmine Galasso, and John McCloskey

    Exposure to multiple hazards can create many risks, including some related to human life and physical infrastructure. Therefore, it is important to develop approaches for characterising and controlling future urban development in a risk-informed manner. Towards this aim, this study develops a future risk-sensitive exposure-mapping methodology using the Khokana area of Kathmandu (Nepal) as a case study. Characterisation of future exposure is carried out on the basis of literature reviews, a thorough review of three future urban development options prepared by the Kathmandu Valley Development Authority (KVDA), discussions with experts, and data obtained from recent detailed building and road assessment surveys of the existing urban system. This characterisation is then used, along with future multi-hazard intensity predictions, to create a risk-informed masterplan layout of buildings and infrastructure that appropriately balances the demands of an expanding population. The developed methodology forms the backbone of the urbanisation component within the Tomorrow’s Cities Decision Support Environment, and can be generally applied to risk-sensitive urban planning in any context.

    How to cite: Dhakal, A., Chaudhary, S., Guragain, R., Manandhar, V., Gentile, R., Cremen, G., Galasso, C., and McCloskey, J.: Mapping future exposure to multiple hazards in Tomorrow’s Cities: the Khokana, Kathmandu, Nepal case study, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9946, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9946, 2022.

    EGU22-10137 | Presentations | NH10.1

    Physics based simulations of multiple hazards for risk sensitive land use planning 

    Luke Jenkins, Maggie Creed, Karim Tarbali, Manoranjan Muthusamy, Robert Sakic Trogrlic, Jeremy Phillips, Hugh Sinclair, Carmine Galasso, and John McCloskey

    Rapid urban expansion in many parts of the world is increasing exposure to natural hazards, which are often exacerbated by climate change. We present the results of physics-based simulations for various flooding, earthquake, and debris-flow scenarios located in a region considered for future urban expansion. The effect of climate change, in terms of increasing rainfall intensity, is incorporated into some of the hazard scenarios. We show that a future urban area can be affected by: (1) multiple hazards at different locations; (2) multiple hazards at a particular location. We demonstrate that this information can be used to shape decision making around future social and built environment developments towards risk-informed future urban planning. In summary, this research demonstrates the importance of considering multiple hazards when designing disaster-resilient urban landscapes of tomorrow. 

    How to cite: Jenkins, L., Creed, M., Tarbali, K., Muthusamy, M., Trogrlic, R. S., Phillips, J., Sinclair, H., Galasso, C., and McCloskey, J.: Physics based simulations of multiple hazards for risk sensitive land use planning, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10137, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10137, 2022.

    EGU22-10244 | Presentations | NH10.1

    Unleashing the power of the interdisciplinary in disaster risk reduction: reflections from an early career researcher group developing a risk-informed decision support environment for Tomorrow’s Cities 

    Maria Evangelina Filippi, Robert Sakic Trogrlic, Gemma Cremen, Alejandro Barcena, Emin Mentese, Roberto Gentile, Maggie Creed, Luke Jenkins, Manoranjan Muthusamy, Karim Tarbali, Aditi Dhakal, Vibek Manandhar, Miksen Rai, Sangita Adhikari, Mehmet Kalaycioglu, Bosibori Barake, Dilli Prasad Poudel, Carmine Galasso, and John McCloskey

    The concept of disaster risk is multidisciplinary by nature. Responding to disasters and increasingly preventing new and reducing existing disaster risk has become the backbone of various disciplines. Yet, moving from various disciplinary perspectives to integrated approaches remains a fundamental challenge. This talk reflects on the experience of a group of early-career researchers, including physical scientists, engineers and social scientists from different organisations and countries, who came together to lead the refinement, operationalisation and testing of a risk-informed decision support environment (DSE) for Tomorrow’s Cities. Drawing on the notion of “boundary objects” and reflexive elicitation, members of the group explored enabling and hindering factors to interdisciplinary research across four case studies that unfolded between July-December 2021, namely: operationalisation process of the DSE; development of a testbed as a demonstration case for the implementation of the DSE; consolidation of frequently asked questions about the DSE; and elaboration of a multi-media communication tool for outreach to various audiences. The study argues that enablers of interdisciplinarity can be synthesised across a range of factors, including exogenous, governing, learning and attitudinal, and that diversity of boundary objects as convening spaces for disciplinary interaction can propel integration. It is further suggested that a similar rationale can be applied when moving towards co-producing knowledge with non-academic actors in a transdisciplinary manner. Strengthening the interdisciplinary capacities of early career researchers across disciplines and geographies is a fundamental step and promising pathway towards transformation.

    How to cite: Filippi, M. E., Sakic Trogrlic, R., Cremen, G., Barcena, A., Mentese, E., Gentile, R., Creed, M., Jenkins, L., Muthusamy, M., Tarbali, K., Dhakal, A., Manandhar, V., Rai, M., Adhikari, S., Kalaycioglu, M., Barake, B., Poudel, D. P., Galasso, C., and McCloskey, J.: Unleashing the power of the interdisciplinary in disaster risk reduction: reflections from an early career researcher group developing a risk-informed decision support environment for Tomorrow’s Cities, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10244, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10244, 2022.

    EGU22-10895 | Presentations | NH10.1

    Stakeholder Perceptions of Multi-hazards and Implications for Urban Disaster Risk Reduction in Istanbul 

    Emin Yahya Menteşe, Robert Šakić Trogrlić, Ekbal Hussein, Harriet Thompson, Emine Öner, Aslıhan Yolcu, and Bruce D. Malamud

    Istanbul is a large urban area exposed to many natural hazards, including earthquakes, landslides, tsunami, flooding, and drought. In addition to the potential risk from these single hazards, their interrelationships can  amplify overall risk, potentially overwhelming the capacity of governments, communities, and systems limits. Here, in order to investigate how multi hazards and their interrelationships are understood and considered in the decision making process in Istanbul, we have conducted two workshops and three interviews with 22 expert practitioners with a wide range of natural hazard relevant roles in Istanbul institutions.

    We focused our activities on: (i) Identifying multi-hazard interrelationships relevant for Istanbul of tomorrow and creating multi-hazard interrelationship scenarios. (ii) Understanding the usefulness of multi-hazard thinking in the context of different stakeholders, and (iii) Exploring barriers and opportunities for the integration of multi-hazard thinking into operational practice. We find in the Istanbul urban context that (i) single hazards are calculated, examined, and incorporated within urban development and planning process at a significant level, (ii) the participants’ perception of multi-hazard is mostly focused on cascading single hazards where one triggers another, excluding increasing probability and compound hazard interrelationships, (iii) that although multi-hazard approaches are taken into account at some levels in Istanbul, the main focus is still mainly on single hazards, (iv) there is a lack of interaction amongst many  hazard related institutions that are often single-hazard focused, thus hindering disaster risk reduction in a holistic and integrated way.

    Among the multi hazard types, earthquakes induced hazards such as landslides, tsunami and floods are highlighted by the participants often. It is notable that climate change related scenarios such as heavy rainfalls and heatwaves are also mentioned during conversations. Our results show that multi-hazard scenarios have the potential to improve DRR in Istanbul as there are some studies that already address the multi hazard perspective to a certain extent and knowledge on potential multi hazards is significant among experts. However, changes in policies, legislative environment, and  governance arrangements are needed, as well as further physical characterisation of interrelationships. 

    How to cite: Menteşe, E. Y., Trogrlić, R. Š., Hussein, E., Thompson, H., Öner, E., Yolcu, A., and Malamud, B. D.: Stakeholder Perceptions of Multi-hazards and Implications for Urban Disaster Risk Reduction in Istanbul, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10895, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10895, 2022.

    EGU22-11909 | Presentations | NH10.1

    An integrated assessment of multi-hazard events in Sweden 

    Johanna Mård, Örjan Bodin, and Daniel Nohrstedt

    Sweden is prone to various natural hazards, including wildfires, storms, floods, cloud bursts and landslides, which have caused considerable economic losses in the past. Natural hazard risk is also expected to increase in several regions in Sweden due to climate change. However, considerable knowledge gaps remain on how to effectively mitigate societal effects of multiple natural hazard events. Current risk assessments often focus on single hazards within distinct administrative boundaries whereas multi-hazard or compound events, which often transcend these boundaries, are rarely accounted for. This poses a problem – particularly in vulnerable geographical areas where the risk for compound events with significant societal impacts are high. Here we present a new project that will address this knowledge gap, with the aims to identify underlying factors of multi-hazard events in Sweden, and to investigate capacities among public and private actors to mitigate these impacts via effective collaboration. The first outcome is an integrated natural hazards assessment that reveals how climate-related natural hazard events have evolved over time and space in Sweden since the 1970s, and what areas have been most exposed to multi-hazard events. These results provide knowledge on the spatiotemporal distribution of natural hazard events, including compound events, which is critical when analysing their underlying drivers.

    How to cite: Mård, J., Bodin, Ö., and Nohrstedt, D.: An integrated assessment of multi-hazard events in Sweden, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11909, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11909, 2022.

    EGU22-12031 | Presentations | NH10.1

    Theoretical framework for environmental risk assessment due to Natech event 

    Riccardo Giusti, Marcello Arosio, and Mario Martina

    Natural hazards pose a significant threat to industrial areas and their surrounding environment, in particular considering that extreme natural events are expected to occur more frequently and exposure will increase due to urbanization growth. A NATECH event is defined as a NAtural hazard triggering TECHnological disasters which could affect people, the environment, other facilities and systems. NATECH research began less than thirty years ago and in the last decade these complex phenomena have been investigated by academia and industry. However, NATECH knowledge and methodology have some gaps that must be filled for better risk prevention and management. In fact, it is mainly focused on technological vulnerability or assessing its occurrence probability, yet possible consequences are only partial investigated. The aim of this study is to develop a theoretical framework to assess the environmental impact on soil and groundwater due to NATECH events triggered by flood. This is accomplished by harmonizing existing algorithms and methods for the natural and technological risk component with the new developed environmental soil and groundwater risk component into a coherent modelling chain. The proposed framework utilizes data from natural driven forces (e.g. flood height and velocity) and their probabilities of occurrence. These driven forces are applied to storage tanks through an existing vulnerability model. In order to evaluate resistance pressures, the model requires tank geometries and hypothetical filling level distribution. In addition, a simplified environmental risk model is applied at site scale depending on the stored product (e.g. gasoline, petroleum, etc.) in order to evaluate an affected area and its potential degree of contamination of soil and groundwater.  The proposed framework is applied to a realistic case study and results and critical points would be discussed. We believe that the general theoretical framework could be adapted to any natural triggering phenomena (e.g. earthquakes, lighting, etc.), in order to assess environmental impacts due to NATECH events.

    How to cite: Giusti, R., Arosio, M., and Martina, M.: Theoretical framework for environmental risk assessment due to Natech event, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12031, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12031, 2022.

    EGU22-12300 | Presentations | NH10.1

    A Novel Decision Support Environment for Risk Informed Urban Planning in Tomorrow’s Cities 

    John McCloskey, Mark Pelling, Gemma Cremen, Carmine Galasso, Ramesh Guragain, and Vera Bukachi

    This talk introduces the United Kingdom Research and Innovation (UKRI) Global Challenge Research Fund (GCRF) Urban Disaster Risk Hub, the “Tomorrow’s Cities” project. Working internationally, the ultimate goal of the Hub is to reduce disaster risk for the poor and most marginalised in tomorrow’s cities by facilitating a transition from reactive crisis management to proactive risk-informed, people-centred, and pro-poor urban planning and design. Against a backdrop of ever-increasing human populations, urbanisation, social inequality, and climate change, this ambition is critically time-sensitive.

    This talk specifically discusses the development of a state-of-practice decision support environment (DSE) that advances beyond the limits of current conventional risk models by placing knowledge co-production at the heart of risk-informed decision-making. Through a democratisation of the concept of risk, we explore understandings of risk that recognise the life experiences of the poor and most marginalised social groups. The DSE explicitly incorporates these diverse understandings to enable the iterative assessment of different policies, urban plans, and interventions in terms of their disaster-related impacts on future economic, environmental, and social objectives cooperatively agreed with relevant stakeholders. These assessments are underpinned by interdisciplinary open-source tools and processes that include: state-of-the-art physics-based multi-hazard and physical vulnerability models, innovative methods for harmonising physical and social sciences, and rigorous capacity-strengthening and knowledge exchange strategies.

    How to cite: McCloskey, J., Pelling, M., Cremen, G., Galasso, C., Guragain, R., and Bukachi, V.: A Novel Decision Support Environment for Risk Informed Urban Planning in Tomorrow’s Cities, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12300, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12300, 2022.

    EGU22-12597 | Presentations | NH10.1

    Good practices in disaster risk and crisis management for civil protection purposes: an integrated multi-hazard risk approach 

    Andrea Prota, Mauro Dolce, Claudia Morsut, Domingos Xavier Viegas, Miguel Almeida, Chiara Casarotti, Daniela Di Bucci, Francesca Giuliani, Maria Polese, and Nicola Rebora

    The last years have demonstrated the complex interplay and impacts that hazards can have on people’s lives, livelihoods and health, especially when multiple adverse events occur at the same time. The Sendai Framework for Disaster Risk Reduction 2015–2030 provides a solid foundation for disaster risk management (DRM) by specifically calling for multi-hazard and solution-driven research to address gaps, obstacles and interdependencies of disaster risks. However, most of the practices in DRM still adopt a single-hazard approach, which may not be sufficient for addressing the social, economic, educational, and environmental challenges of multi-hazard risk scenarios. Besides, questions remain about whether disaster risk is actually treated in a science-policy context, as demanded in the Sendai Framework, thus operating in the overlapping space of scientific research, political decision-making and public action. The large number of actors involved in, and affected by, multi-risk disasters make it harder to transfer knowledge into risk management decisions and set a two-way process for communicating such decisions and for collecting feedback from stakeholders. To face these challenges, the project ROADMAP (European observatory on disaster risk and crisis management best practices) aims to establish a European “Doctrine on disaster risk and crisis management”, funded on the cooperation among the scientific community and the DRM authorities. The project is developed by diverse specialized institutions from Italy (The Consortium Italian Centre for Risk Reduction “CI3R” and the Italian Civil Protection Department “ICPD”), Portugal (Association for the Development of Industrial Aerodynamics “ADAI”) and Norway (University of Stavanger). To achieve its goal, the project is identifying good practices in multi-hazard risk scenarios, by singling out the experiences in EU Member States and beyond the EU borders. Emphasis is given to the cumulative hazards that countries have had to face over the past two years, characterized by the spread of a global health emergency induced by the COVID-19 pandemic. Good practices are selected accounting for their capacity to produce results in the diverse DRM phases, as they stand out in terms of effectiveness, reach, feasibility, sustainability, and transferability. Such practices are not intended as static instruments, but rather as a guidance to be adapted if the needs of the users change and/or conditions in the application field evolve. This contribution will present the preliminary results of the research project and discuss how to create an efficient multi-hazard disaster management, focusing on a solution explorer platform collecting the good practices. When analysed closely it becomes apparent that there is a need for reinforcing actions dealing with multi-hazard disasters and for documenting successful stories and lessons learned within a bottom-up approach. By and large, it is envisaged that ROADMAP will contribute to increase access to information on DRM and disaster risk reduction (DRR) by systematically collecting, reviewing and analysing past and ongoing experiences and making them readily available and usable to communities and practitioners. The provision of good-practice guidance about a broad range of structural and non-structural risk management measures enables sharing information on how to overcome the obstacles and increasing the understanding of DRM solutions.

    How to cite: Prota, A., Dolce, M., Morsut, C., Viegas, D. X., Almeida, M., Casarotti, C., Di Bucci, D., Giuliani, F., Polese, M., and Rebora, N.: Good practices in disaster risk and crisis management for civil protection purposes: an integrated multi-hazard risk approach, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12597, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12597, 2022.

    EGU22-12794 | Presentations | NH10.1

    Mapping community exposure to extreme heat and flood hazards in the Carolinas 

    Antonia Sebastian and Kathie Dello

    Recent extreme weather events have drawn attention to how multiple climate disasters can combine to create negative social and economic consequences across sectors. Perhaps the most concerning of these multi-hazard scenarios, is the combination of heat stress, characterized as high temperature and humidity, and severe flooding, which can result in devastating socioeconomic and health consequences for communities. For example, heat stress may precede a flood event, amplifying its impact (e.g., British Columbia (2021)) and leading to increased fatalities and injuries from the event; on the other hand, infrastructure outages caused by severe flooding may increase the vulnerability of individuals to heat stress following the event, as is often the case after tropical cyclones (e.g., Hurricanes Ike (2008) and Maria (2017)). Managing future climate risks will require a better understanding of the frequency of occurrence of compound heat and flood stress and the space and time scales over which they interact. As a case study, this research develops a framework for measuring community exposure to flood and heat extremes applied to North Carolina, USA. Leveraging parcel-scale records of insured flood damage, we generate a spatially- and temporally-explicit database of historical flood extents since 1970, and couple it to a reanalysis of extreme heat events measured in terms of Wetbulb index. We then identify spatial and temporal clusters of extreme heat and flood events in North Carolina. This work will enable improved vulnerability and climate risk assessment and enable community to identify more resilient pathways to climate adaptation. The work is part of a larger Carolinas Collaborative on Climate, Health and Equity (C3HE) project which focuses on the cooccurrence of extremes and aims to measure the socioeconomic and health outcomes in partnership with Carolina communities.

    How to cite: Sebastian, A. and Dello, K.: Mapping community exposure to extreme heat and flood hazards in the Carolinas, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12794, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12794, 2022.

    EGU22-12811 | Presentations | NH10.1

    Multi-hazard, cross-border storm risk assessment in the Alps. First insights from the TRANS-ALP project 

    Kathrin Renner, Piero Campalani, Alice Crespi, Roberta Dainese, Katharina Enigl, Klaus Haslinger, Massimiliano Pittore, Matthias Plörer, Stefan Steger, Fabrizio Tagliavini, Michaela Teich, and Marc Zebisch

    Extreme hydrometeorological events such as late autumn and winter storms are being increasingly observed in southern Europe and particularly in the Alps, where they threaten environmental and socio-economic systems. An example is the 2018 Vaia (also known as Adrian) storm (Oct 28-Nov 04), which strongly affected Italy, Austria, France and Switzerland. Over the past decades several damaging storms strongly impacted (i.e., caused adverse consequences on assets, people, infrastructure or the environment) mostly those countries on the northern side of the Alps (e.g., Vivian 1990, Lothar 1999, Gudrun 2005, Kyrill 2007). The Vaia storm however affected the southern side, downing more than 8 million cubic meters of forests and causing extensive damage due to a combination of multiple compounded hazards including heavy rain, flooding and landslides, and strong winds. The event caused 12 fatalities and an economic loss exceeding 3 billion Euro. This storm has been considered exceptional yet could foreshadow multi-hazard phenomena whose frequency and intensity are likely to be influenced by climate change. In such conditions, currently available risk assessment and prevention tools may prove inadequate, particularly on a cross-border level and in vulnerable mountainous regions. Therefore, there is a need to provide decision makers and stakeholders with improved and harmonised tools and standardised frameworks to conduct efficient (climate) risk assessments for cross-border areas. Current and future impacts need to be systematically investigated to adopt prevention and disaster risk reduction measures for the mitigation of inherent risks. In its first year the TRANS-ALP project analysed the occurrence of severe weather events that can be classified as extreme and their specific features in the cross-border area between Austria and Italy (Trentino-Alto Adige/South Tyrol and Veneto). Furthermore, a systematic review of the mechanisms in place to collect impact, damage and loss data has been conducted to allow for a better conceptualisation of the different risk pathways that come into play in case of intense storms. Our findings indicate a noticeable increase of extreme weather conditions that can lead to adverse consequences, also from a systemic perspective, and a complex interplay of damaging factors and chained impacts that can extend for years after the occurrence of the generating events. The findings also highlight the importance of a comprehensive multi-hazard and transdisciplinary approach to storm risk assessment within a framework harmonising Disaster Risk Reduction (DRR) and Climate Change Adaptation (CCA) instances. In this contribution the first results and insights of the project will be presented and discussed.

    The described research activities have been carried out within the framework of the DG-ECHO project TRANS-ALP funded by the European Union (Grant Agreement 101004843).

    How to cite: Renner, K., Campalani, P., Crespi, A., Dainese, R., Enigl, K., Haslinger, K., Pittore, M., Plörer, M., Steger, S., Tagliavini, F., Teich, M., and Zebisch, M.: Multi-hazard, cross-border storm risk assessment in the Alps. First insights from the TRANS-ALP project, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12811, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12811, 2022.

    EGU22-179 | Presentations | NH9.1

    Enabling dynamic modelling of global coastal flooding by defining storm tide hydrographs 

    Job Dullaart, Sanne Muis, Hans de Moel, Dirk Eilander, Philip Ward, and Jeroen Aerts

    Coastal flooding is driven by strong winds and low pressures in tropical and extratropical cyclones that generate a storm surge, and high tides. The combination of storm surge and the astronomical tide is defined as the storm tide. Currently over 600 million people live in coastal areas below 10 m elevation worldwide which is projected to increase to more than 1 billion people by 2050 under all Shared Economic Pathways. Towards the end of the 21st century these growing coastal populations will be increasingly at risk of flooding due to SLR. To gain understanding into the threat imposed by coastal flooding and identify areas that are especially at risk, now and in the future, it is crucial to accurately model coastal inundation and assess the coastal flood hazard.

    There are three main types of inundation models with complexity levels ranging from simple, to semi-advanced to advanced. Models capable of simulating inundation at the global scale follow a simple static approach. These models, often referred to as bathtub models, delineate the inundation zone by raising maximum water levels, that correspond to a return period, on a coastal DEM and select all areas that are below the specified water level height. The main limitations of this type of model is that they implicitly assume an infinite flood duration and do not capture relevant physical processes. Regional comparisons have shown that dynamic inundation models are much more accurate than static models in terms of flood extent and depth, and they can provide information on the flood duration.

    In this study we develop a global dataset of storm tide hydrographs. These hydrographs represent the typical shape of an extreme sea level event at a certain location along the global coastline and can be used as boundary conditions for dynamic inundation models. This way we can move away from static to more advanced dynamic inundation models. To assess how different assumptions used for generating hydrographs influence the inundation extent and depth we perform a sensitivity analysis for several coastal regions.

    How to cite: Dullaart, J., Muis, S., de Moel, H., Eilander, D., Ward, P., and Aerts, J.: Enabling dynamic modelling of global coastal flooding by defining storm tide hydrographs, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-179, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-179, 2022.

    EGU22-450 | Presentations | NH9.1

    Conceptual Flood Inundation Modelling: Computationally Efficient Methods for Large Data-scarce River Basins 

    S L Kesav Unnithan, Basudev Biswal, Christoph Rüdiger, and Amit Kumar Dubey

    India is one of the world's most flood-prone countries, with 113 million people exposed to floods. Large-scale hydrological models integrated with complicated Navier–Stokes based hydraulic, and inundation models traditionally address flood preparedness, control, and mitigation. In addition to being highly data-intensive at the fine spatial and temporal resolution, this approach has a considerable computational cost that limits real-time applications. We employ the parameter-free Dynamic Budyko (DB) hydrological model to map observed precipitation with gridded runoff to overcome data scarcity. We propose a time-efficient Slope-corrected, Calibration-free, Iterative Flood Routing and Inundation Model (SCI-FRIM) framework that can be used with any hydrological model to generate a probability map of inundation. To model the catastrophic flood extents that the state of Kerala in India experienced during August 2018, we use gridded 0.25 deg × 0.25 deg IMD precipitation data. We use a parameter-free iterative approach to update flood velocity by assuming that river velocity does not fluctuate geographically across a particular river network at a given time instant. We pre-compute the iterative velocity and model the relationship between flood velocity-discharge and discharge-inundation height for each reach by combining the globally available SRTM/ASTER DEMs with empirically obtained river-reach geometry data (JPL). We compute the reach slope from the absolute vertical error-prone DEM by segmenting the river network into a series of independent channels and extracting the relationship between the channel pixel's elevation and the pixel's distance to the pour point. We use the Height Above Nearest Drainage (HAND) to map the probabilistic spatial extent corresponding to an ensemble of derived reach inundation heights. We then compare the proposed model with observed flood data points provided by the Kerala State Disaster Management Authority (KSDMA). The model captures up to 52% of 370,000 flood data points in a single run for the peak flood day within 15 minutes on a desktop computer. With reliable estimates of empirical bankfull discharge, the proposed model can achieve higher accuracy in lesser time.

    How to cite: Unnithan, S. L. K., Biswal, B., Rüdiger, C., and Dubey, A. K.: Conceptual Flood Inundation Modelling: Computationally Efficient Methods for Large Data-scarce River Basins, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-450, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-450, 2022.

    EGU22-2338 | Presentations | NH9.1

    Lower magnitude volcanic eruptions as Global Catastrophic Risks 

    Lara Mani, Asaf Tzachor, and Paul Cole

    Large-magnitude volcanic eruptions have long been considered to pose a threat to the continued flourishing of humanity. The dominant narrative focuses on the nuclear-winter climatic scenarios that may develop as a result of a large-magnitude eruption (magnitudes 7+ on the Volcanic Explosivity Index (VEI)) propelling large quantities of ash and gas into our upper atmosphere and devastating global crop production. However, the probability of such an event remains rare, and this narrative fails to fully consider the vulnerability component of the risk equation. We propose that volcanic eruptions of even moderate magnitudes (VEI 3-6) could constitute a global catastrophic risk (events that might inflict damage to human welfare on a global scale) where the impacts of the eruption are amplified through cascading critical system failures.

    Increased globalisation in our modern world has resulted in our overreliance on global critical system – networks and supply chains vital to the support and continued development of our societies (e.g. submarine cables, global shipping routes, transport and trade networks). We observe that many of these critical infrastructures and networks converge in regions where they could be exposed to moderate-scale volcanic eruptions (VEI 3-6). These regions of intersection, or pinch points, present localities where we have prioritised efficiency over resilience, and manufactured a new GCR landscape, presenting a scenario for global risk propagation. We present seven global pinch points, including the Strait of Malacca and the Mediterranean, which represent localities where disruption to any of these systems can result in a cascade of global disruptions. This is exemplified by the 2010 Eyjafjallajökull VEI 4 eruption which resulted in the closure of European airspace and cascaded to cause global disruption to just-in-time supply chains and transportation networks.

    We suggest that volcanic risk assessments should incorporate interdisciplinary systems thinking in order to increase our resilience to volcanic GCRs.

    How to cite: Mani, L., Tzachor, A., and Cole, P.: Lower magnitude volcanic eruptions as Global Catastrophic Risks, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2338, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2338, 2022.

    EGU22-2871 | Presentations | NH9.1

    Current and Future Flood Risk from Tropical Cyclones in Puerto Rico Under 1.5°C and 2°C Climate Change 

    Leanne Archer, Jeffrey Neal, Paul Bates, Emily Vosper, Jeison Sosa, and Dann Mitchell

    Small Island Developing States are some of the most at risk places to flooding caused by tropical cyclone rainfall. However, there is a mismatch between existing flood risk assessment in small islands, and the increasing severity of projected tropical cyclone rainfall under current and future climate change. This research aims to address this gap by presenting the first application of an event-based rainfall-driven hydrodynamic model in a small island, for the Caribbean island of Puerto Rico. Applying an event set of 59,000 synthetic hurricane rainfall events, we represent hurricane rainfall spatially (~10km) and temporally (2-hourly), estimating flood hazard and population exposure at the island scale (9,100km2) at 20m model resolution using hydrodynamic model LISFLOOD-FP. Using this event-based approach, we aim to understand: i) what are the current estimates of population exposure to flooding from hurricane rainfall in Puerto Rico; and ii) how do these risk estimates change under 1.5°C and 2°C climate scenarios. We find that current population exposure to flooding from hurricane rainfall in Puerto Rico is high (8-9.80% of the population every 5 years), with an increase in population exposure of 1.60-15.20% and 0.70-22.30% under 1.5°C and 2°C climate change. This has critical implications for adaptation to more extreme flood risk in Puerto Rico, as well as underlining the important implications of the 1.5°C Paris Agreement target for small islands – a finding that is likely to be applicable to other small islands affected by tropical cyclones.

     

    How to cite: Archer, L., Neal, J., Bates, P., Vosper, E., Sosa, J., and Mitchell, D.: Current and Future Flood Risk from Tropical Cyclones in Puerto Rico Under 1.5°C and 2°C Climate Change, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2871, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2871, 2022.

    EGU22-2895 | Presentations | NH9.1

    GIS automation of large-scale flood vulnerability analysis for drainage basins, based on a single Digital Elevation Model 

    Andrei Enea, Marina Iosub, and Cristian Constantin Stoleriu

    In the context of climate change, probability of risk phenomena occurrence is more frequent and with greater intensity. This is especially valid for floods which cause significantly more damage and casualties, as flood-inducing conditions are met more often. The risk is emphasized by the fact that countless human settlements are located on the floodplain of river courses of different sizes and flow rates. The current study aims to detail an automatic GIS model that can easily compare drainage sub-basins of similar order, according to Horton-Strahler hierarchical classification, at large scale, for a given basin, based on morphometric parameters. This implies the use of a digital elevation model (DEM) as the only input layer, and setting a few parameters, in order to extract several quantifiable hydrological indicators, relevant to flood analysis. Some of the most relevant ones from the list are the elongation ratio, circularity ratio, relief ratio, roughness number, drainage density etc. All the functions have been integrated into a GIS tool, that would automatically aid in the fast creation of a final vector layer, that discerns between drainage basins with higher and lower degrees of relative vulnerability. This layer contains an attribute table with all the relevant parameters, as well as the result of the formula that assigns flood vulnerability values to each drainage basin, making possible the quantitative comparison between all the drainage sub-basins. The resulting table analysis is conducted in the background, based on the calculation of normalized values for each parameter, which are encompassed into a final vulnerability score. The model is easily applicable to most types of raster elevation layers, as long as they are in a projected coordinate system, regardless of pixel size. Furthermore, several functions were added to the model to mitigate potential errors that can occur in isolated cases, where the topography is particularly difficult to interpret by some native GIS tools. Therefore, this model is an easy to apply tool, that automatically identifies more vulnerable sub-basins, from a large drainage basin, over extended areas, with limited user-input, facilitating decision making in flood management, while providing quantifiable flood vulnerability results, in a very short period of time, without requiring extensive knowledge from the user.

    How to cite: Enea, A., Iosub, M., and Stoleriu, C. C.: GIS automation of large-scale flood vulnerability analysis for drainage basins, based on a single Digital Elevation Model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2895, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2895, 2022.

    EGU22-3122 | Presentations | NH9.1

    Linking the relative importance of input uncertainties of a flood risk model with basin characteristics. 

    Georgios Sarailidis, Francesca Pianosi, Thorsten Wagener, Rob Lamb, Kirsty Styles, and Stephen Hutchings

    Floods are extreme natural hazards often with disastrous impacts on the economy and society. Flood risk assessments are required to better manage risk associated with floods. Nowadays, numerous flood risk models are available at various scales, from catchment to regional or even global scale. They involve a complex modelling chain that estimates risk as the product of probability of occurrence of an event (hazard) with its footprint (exposure) and the consequences over society and economy (vulnerability). Each component of this chain contains uncertainties, that propagate and contribute to the uncertainty in the model outputs. Much effort has been made to quantify such output uncertainty and attribute it to the various uncertainty sources in the modelling chain. However, the key drivers of uncertainty in flood risk estimates are still unclear because previous studies have reached conflicting conclusions.  Two things could possibly explain these ambiguous outcomes. First, these studies were implemented with different models and with different data, as well as different assumptions for the uncertainty and sensitivity analysis. Second, the studies were conducted at catchment and/or city scale with limited variability of physical and socio-economic characteristics within a study region, but with potentially large differences across study regions. In this project, we study the question of uncertainty quantification and attribution at much larger scale, namely the heterogeneous region of the Rhine River basin. In this way, we can identify spatial patterns of dominant input uncertainties and link them to characteristics, e.g. physical, socio-economic, in the different sub-basins. To this end, we use an industry flood risk model (catastrophe model) provided by JBA Risk Management which is capable of simulating flood risk across such a large region. Our ultimate goal is to provide evidence of how the importance of uncertainties varies across places with different climatic, hydrologic and socio-economic characteristics.

    How to cite: Sarailidis, G., Pianosi, F., Wagener, T., Lamb, R., Styles, K., and Hutchings, S.: Linking the relative importance of input uncertainties of a flood risk model with basin characteristics., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3122, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3122, 2022.

    EGU22-4950 | Presentations | NH9.1

    Investigating the effect of spatial correlation on loss estimation in catastrophe models – a case study for Italy 

    Svetlana Stripajova, Erika Schiappapietra, Peter Pazak, John Douglas, and Goran Trendafiloski

    Catastrophe models are very important tool to provide proper assessment and financial management of earthquake-related emergencies, which still create the largest protection gap across all other perils. Earthquake catastrophe models contain three main components: earthquake hazard, vulnerability and exposure. Simulating spatially-distributed ground-motion fields within either deterministic or probabilistic seismic hazard assessments poses a major challenge when site-related financial protection products are required. Several authors have demonstrated that the spatial correlation of earthquake ground-motion is period-, regionally- and scenario-dependent, so that the implementation of a unique correlation model may represent an oversimplification.

    In this framework, we have established a joint research project between the University of Strathclyde and Impact Forecasting, Aon’s catastrophe model development centre of excellence, in order to advance the understanding of spatial correlations within the catastrophe modelling process. We developed correlation models for northern, central and southern Italian regions using both ad hoc and existing ground-motion models calibrated on different databases. Thereafter, we performed both deterministic scenario and event-based probabilistic hazard and risk assessments for Italy using the 2020 European Seismic Hazard and Risk Models. We employed the OpenQuake-engine for our calculations, which is an open-source tool suitable for accounting for the spatial correlation of earthquake ground-motion residuals. The results demonstrate the importance of considering not only the ground-motion spatial correlation, but also its associated uncertainty in risk analyses. Our findings have implications for (re)insurance companies evaluating the risk to high-value civil engineering infrastructures.

    How to cite: Stripajova, S., Schiappapietra, E., Pazak, P., Douglas, J., and Trendafiloski, G.: Investigating the effect of spatial correlation on loss estimation in catastrophe models – a case study for Italy, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4950, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4950, 2022.

    EGU22-5395 | Presentations | NH9.1

    UK flood risk under a changing climate 

    James Savage, Ollie Wing, Niall Quinn, Jeison Sosa, Andrew Smith, and Chris Sampson

    This study presents a 30 m model of UK flood hazard that considers fluvial, pluvial and coastal sources of flooding. Each of the three sources of flooding are simulated through a hydrodynamic model utilising a number of methodologies and datasets developed in this study, including a new hydrography dataset for Great Britain, a blended Digital Terrain Model (DTM) consisting of LiDAR and open source terrain datasets and a new discharge model for Great Britain. Alongside these, the study incorporates leading datasets including sub-daily river, rainfall, tidal and sea level datasets alongside national flood defence datasets. A defence detection algorithm is also applied to identify flow control structures from high resolution LiDAR terrain data. Results from the hazard model are validated against national scale flood maps at both a building and footprint scale. Future rainfall estimates are then taken from the UK Climate Projections 18 (UKCP18) to directly estimate changes in rainfall for a number of future time horizons and climate scenarios. Hydrological models are then simulated to calculate changes in river discharge which are then used to perturb boundary conditions in the hydrodynamic model. Future estimates of sea level change are used to perturb the coastal boundary conditions. Combined, these future estimates allow us to directly model changes in UK flood risk for fluvial, pluvial and coastal flooding. We use these findings to identify parts of the UK that are expected to see the greatest changes in flood risk resulting from these future projections. 

    How to cite: Savage, J., Wing, O., Quinn, N., Sosa, J., Smith, A., and Sampson, C.: UK flood risk under a changing climate, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5395, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5395, 2022.

    EGU22-5608 | Presentations | NH9.1

    A global-scale vulnerability assessment of human displacement for floods and tropical cyclones 

    Benedikt Mester, Katja Frieler, and Jacob Schewe

    Floods and tropical cyclones displaced more than 275 million people between 2008 and 2020, with the two hazards together being responsible for 86% of all displacements. It is important to understand the socio-economic drivers of displacement vulnerability to quantify future changes in risk, for instance, due to climate change, economic development, or social inequities. Here, we investigate globally and event-by-event the displacement vulnerability due to flooding and tropical cyclones (TCs), using remote sensing-derived hazard data. We create a database of displacement events associated with spatially explicit flood or TC hazard, by matching displacement data from the Internal Displacement Monitoring Center (IDMC) spatially and temporally with satellite imagery from the recently published Global Flood Database and a collection of tropical cyclone data. The resulting hazard footprints are overlaid with gridded population data to derive the number of affected people for each event, which is compared with estimated displacement to determine the event-specific vulnerability. Between and within continental regions, displacement vulnerability varies by several orders of magnitude. We generally find a negative trend between displacement vulnerability and increasing (socio-)economic prosperity indicators, such as GDP per capita or the Human Development Index (HDI). Indicator binning reveals further insights, for instance, a higher proportion of urbanization or female population tends to indicate a lower susceptibility towards TC impacts. We analyze the uncertainty associated with different population datasets and methods to compute the number of affected people. Our analysis provides new insights into patterns and potential drivers of displacement vulnerability across space and between socio-economic groups. To our knowledge, the usage of the extensive set of observational satellite imagery is an unprecedented approach for global flood vulnerability analysis, posing remote sensing as a suitable alternative for global models for future studies. 

    How to cite: Mester, B., Frieler, K., and Schewe, J.: A global-scale vulnerability assessment of human displacement for floods and tropical cyclones, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5608, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5608, 2022.

    EGU22-5679 | Presentations | NH9.1

    Flood damage model bias caused by aggregation 

    Seth Bryant, Heidi Kreibich, and Bruno Merz

    Reducing flood risk through improved disaster planning and risk management requires accurate and reliable estimates of flood damages.  Damage models commonly provide such information through calculating the impacts or costs of flooding to exposed assets, such as buildings within a community. At large scales, computational constraints or data coarseness leads to the common practice of aggregating asset data using a single statistic (e.g., the mean) prior to applying non-linear damage models. While this simplification has been shown to bias model results in other fields, like ecology, the influence of object aggregation on flood damage models has so far not been investigated. This study quantifies such errors in 12 published damage function sets and three levels of aggregation using simulated water depths. Preliminary findings show bias as high as 20% (of the damage estimate), with most damage functions having a positive bias for shallower depths (< 1 m) and a negative bias for larger depths (> 1 m). In other words, compared to an analogous model with object-specific asset data, aggregated models overestimate damages at shallow depths and underestimate damages at large depths. These findings identify a potentially significant source of error in large-scale flood damage assessments introduced, not by data quality or model transfer, but by modelling approach. With this information, risk modellers can make more informed decisions about when, where, and to what extent aggregation is appropriate. 

    How to cite: Bryant, S., Kreibich, H., and Merz, B.: Flood damage model bias caused by aggregation, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5679, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5679, 2022.

    EGU22-7130 | Presentations | NH9.1

    A global analysis of economic inequality and flood losses 

    Sara Lindersson, Elena Raffetti, Luigia Brandimarte, Johanna Mård, Maria Rusca, and Giuliano Di Baldassarre

    Economic inequality is today increasing in many contexts. Its consequences are multifaceted and relate to questions of justice, welfare, human well-being and health. Economic inequality also affects (directly or indirectly) society’s vulnerability to flood disasters. Research has previously shown that the ex-ante economic distribution within a country may affect the disaster outcomes. For instance, unequal societies also tend to exhibit spatial marginalization. If these marginalized areas are burdened with neglected infrastructure they also have a lower ability to divert flood water.

    Our work highlights the role that economic inequality plays in explaining human flood losses, worldwide. We perform a statistical analysis using data for over a hundred countries and illustrate the importance of considering income distribution when building flood resilient societies. We also show how our results vary between different levels of economic development and discuss implications of our results on disaster research and risk reduction. 

    How to cite: Lindersson, S., Raffetti, E., Brandimarte, L., Mård, J., Rusca, M., and Di Baldassarre, G.: A global analysis of economic inequality and flood losses, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7130, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7130, 2022.

    EGU22-7321 | Presentations | NH9.1

    The Responsibilities of and Interactions between Tsunami Early Warning and Response Agencies in New Zealand 

    Carina Fearnley, Rachel Hunt, Simon Day, and Mark Maslin

    This research examines the responsibilities of and the interactions between the various research institutes, national agencies, regional groups, and local councils involved in monitoring, disseminating, and responding to official tsunami warnings in New Zealand. Specifically, the underlying issues within the separated structure of tsunami early warning and response in New Zealand is examined as to whether this enhances or restricts risk assessment.

    In many countries, the same agency is responsible for both monitoring tsunami hazards and issuing tsunami warnings. However, in New Zealand, this process is split. GNS Science is the research institute responsible for monitoring tsunami hazards in New Zealand, if tsunami generation is confirmed GNS Science provides risk information to the nation’s official tsunami warning agency. The National Emergency Management Agency (NEMA) is the national agency responsible for issuing tsunami warnings in New Zealand. NEMA communicates national tsunami warnings to regional response groups as well as the public and media. The Civil Defence Emergency Management (CDEM) Groups are then responsible for coordinating regional tsunami evacuations, with New Zealand being split into 16 regional CDEM Groups. Within these regional groups, district and city councils can also tailor the evacuation information to communities at a local level.

    Online social research methods were used to explore tsunami risk assessments in New Zealand. 106 documents and archives were collected and 57 semi-structured interviews conducted with tsunami researchers, warning specialists, and emergency managers. The majority of the interviewees were from New Zealand, with some participants also being recruited from Australia, the Pacific Islands, the UK, and the USA. This allowed for national, regional, and local responses in New Zealand to be compared to those in different countries to explore how warning systems operate in practice.

    Key findings indicate that New Zealand having separate monitoring and warning agencies leads to the potential for error when passing information between organisations and delays can also be caused in disseminating official warnings. The warnings are communicated on a national scale, whilst the responses carried out vary between regions, having separate warning and evacuation agencies means there is a need for consistent messages and coordinated responses. GNS Science is capable of operating 24 hours per day, whereas NEMA and the CDEM Groups do not currently have this capacity. Again, this can cause delays in issuing and responding to official warnings. Variations in funding on a regional level also effect the number of staff and amount of resources in particular CDEM Groups.

    These issues are underpinned by the ways in which knowledge is exchanged within the warning system and the lack of integration between national, regional, and local agencies. Tsunami researchers and warning specialists on a national level, and emergency managers on regional and local levels, must work together to effectively disseminate and respond to official tsunami warnings. This research concludes that the separated structure of tsunami early warning and response in New Zealand involves underlying issues which must be addressed in order to improve risk assessment.

    How to cite: Fearnley, C., Hunt, R., Day, S., and Maslin, M.: The Responsibilities of and Interactions between Tsunami Early Warning and Response Agencies in New Zealand, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7321, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7321, 2022.

    Costal reclaimed farmlands are commonly threatened by saltwater intrusion and peat-driven salinity, resulting in low and unstable agricultural productions. Climatic variables have a great effect on soil moisture and salinity influencing crop production during the various growing seasons. For this reason, monitoring soil water and salinity dynamics in the root zone during the crop growing season is fundamental to conceive mitigation strategies (e.g., precision irrigation techniques). To this end, a monitoring network was installed in an agricultural field located at the southern margin of the Venice Lagoon. Three soil-stations were placed along the main sandy paleochannel crossing the farmland southwest to northeast (stations S1, S2, and S3), while stations S4 and S5 were placed in two silty-loamy areas with high peat content. Each station was equipped with three T4e tensiometers (UMS GmbH, Munchen, Germany) at 0.3, 0.5, and 0.7 m, four Teros 12 sensors (METER Group, Inc., Pullman, WA, USA) measuring volumetric water content, temperature, and electrical conductivity (ECb) at 0.1, 0.3, 0.5, and 0.7 m. In addition, a 2 m deep piezometer was installed to monitor groundwater electrical conductivity (ECw) and depth to the water table. Soil samples were collected on each monitoring location and analyzed for texture, bulk density (BD), soil organic carbon (SOC), electrical conductivity (EC 1:5), pH, and cation exchange capacity (CEC). Moreover, a weather station was installed in the experimental field to accurately monitor the local meteorological conditions during the 2019 and 2020 growing seasons. The soil monitoring dataset shows that ECb increases with depth at all locations. Moreover, rainfall events higher than 10 mm/day caused an increase in the ECb at all layers and stations. The monitoring stations inside the paleochannel showed lower ECb if compared to station S4 and S5, probably due to the highest hydraulic conductivity and, consequently, the highest leaching capacity. S5 was characterized by the highest peat content and showed the highest salinity in both soil and groundwater. In general, soil ECb and groundwater ECw showed similar behavior in 2019 and 2020, except for S4 and S5 that were saltier in 2019. These preliminary analyses demonstrated a strong influence of rainfall events on salinity behavior and highlights how climatic variables, soil heterogeneity, and saltwater intrusion at depth play an important role in the complex salinity dynamics within the root zone.

    How to cite: Teatini, P., Ester, Z., and Francesco, M.: Assessing the effects of climatic variables on soil and groundwater salinity in a low-lying agricultural field near the Venice Lagoon, Italy, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7756, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7756, 2022.

    EGU22-7874 | Presentations | NH9.1

    Geography of World’s Water Risks 

    Olli Varis, Matti Kummu, and Maija Taka

    Water risks are perennially identified among the planet’s most stunning and influential factors of insecurity and underdevelopment by institutions such as the United Nations and The World Economic Forum. Scholarly water risk literature, however, suffers from many inconsistencies and the alignment of basic water risk concepts with key policy protocols such as those of the United Nations Post-2015 Agenda is not mature. Therefore, macro-level understanding of world’s water risks is subjected to inconsistencies. We analyze a set of water risks with a global-scale interest, namely the 13 water risks of the Aqueduct data product. First, their statistical structure is analyzed, grouping them into clusters. Second, a new classification of water risks is produced and used in a global mapping analysis of how the water risks manifest across the latitudes, including their relation to climatic zones, population density and socioeconomic development. This is done by adopting the Sendai framework’s hazard-exposure-vulnerability risk concept. The results reveal the importance of distinguishing clearly between water hazards and water risks and specifying (usually situation-specific) relevant components of exposure and vulnerability that link those. Aqueduct, for instance, uses the word risk in many instances that are factually hazards, and a similar unambiguity is present very widely in water literature. The most remarkable geographic pattern that we detected is the strong dependency of water hazards on latitudes; those related to variability being fiercest along the tropics, and those to infrastructure centering around the equator. Many chronic hazards are most pronounced in crowded latitudes, whereas those related to hydrological extremes have similarities with the patterns of variability related hazards. Besides detecting these global hotspots, our study underlines the importance of clarifying and systematizing the use of concepts of water risks, water scarcity, water security and others, and harmonizing their use to policy protocols such as those of the United Nations. Due to the underlying importance of water risks, their interrelations, and unveiled geographic patterns, this is essential in improving the scientific and policy-related understanding, and the consequent reduction, of the planet’s water risks.

    How to cite: Varis, O., Kummu, M., and Taka, M.: Geography of World’s Water Risks, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7874, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7874, 2022.

    EGU22-8609 | Presentations | NH9.1

    Global Open Source Tools to Support Landslide Hazard and Impact Assessments 

    Dalia Kirschbaum, Thomas Stanley, Robert Emberson, Pukar Amatya, Sana Khan, and Elijah Orland

    Harnessing the power of remotely sensed data for landslide hazard assessment is critical for enabling regional and global applications. Open-source tools can expand the reach and utility of these assessments to motivate new studies and support the community. This work presents a suite of open-source tools designed to characterize the potential occurrence, impacts and locations for rainfall-triggered landslides across the globe.  

    The Landslide Hazard Assessment for Situational Awareness (LHASA) model provides a suite of capabilities that consider landslide hazard leveraging primarily satellite and model products. LHASA Version 2 uses a machine learning model to bring in dynamic variables as well as additional static variables to better represent landslide hazard globally. Global rainfall forecasts are also being incorporated to provide a 1-3 day forecast of potential landslide activity, which ultimately will provide increased awareness for large storm systems that may cause landslide impacts in already susceptible areas. Finally, a new component of the LHASA model will account for the impact of recent burned areas to indicate areas where the cascading impacts of debris flows may be present. In addition to estimates of landslide hazard, this suite of tools incorporates dynamic estimates of exposure including population, roads and infrastructure to highlight the potential impacts of rainfall-triggered landslides. The ultimate goal of LHASA Version 2.0 is to approximate the relative probabilities of landslide hazard and exposure across different space and time scales to inform hazard assessment retrospectively over the past 20 years, in near real-time, and in the future. 

    A complementary component of the suite of landslide tools is an open-source algorithm to map landslide locations. We have developed a Python-based landslide mapping framework known as the Semi-Automatic Landslide Detection (SALaD) system that uses Object-based Image Analysis and machine learning. For production of event-based inventories, SALaD was modified to include a change detection module (SALaD-CD). This system can be used with both commercial high resolution optical data as well as publicly available data including Landsat and Sentinel to rapidly provide distribution of landslide locations based on limited training. Building event-based inventories is both fundamental to training the LHASA model regionally and globally as well as to support the disaster management community. In total, this suite of tools and capabilities provide a foundation to improve and support situational awareness of landslide hazards and their impacts at local to global scales and at days to decades. Information on all these capabilities is available at: https://landslides.nasa.gov 

    How to cite: Kirschbaum, D., Stanley, T., Emberson, R., Amatya, P., Khan, S., and Orland, E.: Global Open Source Tools to Support Landslide Hazard and Impact Assessments, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8609, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8609, 2022.

    EGU22-8673 | Presentations | NH9.1

    Many-hazard Risk Assessment with the CLIMADA Data API 

    Zélie Stalhandske, Emanuel Schmid, Carmen B. Steinmann, Chahan Kropf, and David N. Bresch

    As the climate and the risks of extreme weather to society change, access to tools for researchers and decision makers to assess the possible evolution of impacts should be facilitated. The open-source modelling platform CLIMADA (CLIMate ADAptation) allows to investigate the present and future statistical risk of natural hazards to human and economic systems, from the local to the global scale. One of the latest additions to the platform is an Application Programming Interface (API) providing access to exposure and hazard data to perform risk assessments on a consistent 4km grid. Hazard sets for tropical cyclones, droughts, heat-waves, wildfires, river floods, and crop-yield are, or will imminently be available at a worldwide scale on the API. In addition, region-specific hazards such as European winter storms are available. As for the exposures at risk, both population count and assets can be considered based on the data produced trough the CLIMADA LitPop module.

    Owing to the availability of globally consistent hazard and exposures datasets through the CLIMADA API, it is now possible to compute and combine the impacts from several hazards. In this first study making use of the API, we calculate global probabilistic economic impacts for tropical cyclones, river floods and reduced crop yields for historical data, as well as for future time steps based on the RCP2.6 and RCP8.5 climate scenarios. From these hazard sets, we compute probabilistic annual impact sets for each hazard. In the case that impacts are provided on an event-base and not on a yearly basis, the probabilistic annual impact sets are created by randomly sampling the number of events per year following a Poisson distribution. From the impact sets per hazard, we finally quantify the total combined cost in a same year and grid cell in order to investigate temporal and spatial correlations of the different hazards.

    How to cite: Stalhandske, Z., Schmid, E., Steinmann, C. B., Kropf, C., and Bresch, D. N.: Many-hazard Risk Assessment with the CLIMADA Data API, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8673, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8673, 2022.

    EGU22-8854 | Presentations | NH9.1

    Downscaling global wildfire model output to a relevant scale for probabilistic wildfire risk assessment of economic impacts 

    Carmen B. Steinmann, Samuel Lüthi, Samuel Gübeli, Benoît P. Guillod, and David N. Bresch

    Accurately estimating wildfire risk is essential for many use cases, such as prioritizing adaptation resources or offering insurance coverage for these devastating events. In collaboration with the Zurich-based InsurTech company CelsiusPro we present a globally consistent, open-source wildfire hazard, based on state-of-the-art fire models and providing high-resolution, probabilistic fire seasons suitable for risk analysis and insurance coverage pricing.

    For the probabilistic part, we build upon the existing wildfire hazard model available on the open-source climate risk modelling platform CLIMADA (CLIMate ADAptation). This model creates stochastic wildfire events at 1 km resolution using a random walk generator that assigns a grid-point specific fire ignition and propagation probability based on Fire Information for Resource Management System (FIRMS) satellite data and physical constraints such as population density and land cover. However, this model does not account for key physical drivers, such as wind.

    On the other hand, data from state-of-the-art fire models are available through the Fire Model Intercomparison Project (FireMIP), which coordinates the evaluation and comparison of these models. While most available models account for the complexity of fire ignition and propagation including relevant physical drivers, their resolution (ranging from 0.5° to 2.8°) is too coarse for the assessment of economic impacts as needed for insurance coverage pricing. In addition, most models are not fully probabilistic, but provide their outputs for present and future climate conditions.

    In this work, we combine the annual fraction of burnt area provided as FireMIP output with CLIMADA’s stochastic model, resulting in a probabilistic, high-resolution wildfire hazard model that is based on state-of-the-art fire modelling. This allows us to compute a globally consistent economic risk of wildfires to physical assets by combining the newly developed hazard with an exposure and vulnerability.

    How to cite: Steinmann, C. B., Lüthi, S., Gübeli, S., Guillod, B. P., and Bresch, D. N.: Downscaling global wildfire model output to a relevant scale for probabilistic wildfire risk assessment of economic impacts, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8854, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8854, 2022.

    EGU22-9310 | Presentations | NH9.1

    Can hydrological models be used to characterize spatial dependency in global stochastic flood modelling? 

    Gaia Olcese, Paul Bates, Jeffrey Neal, Christopher Sampson, Oliver Wing, and Niall Quinn

    Flood models typically produce flood maps with constant return periods in space, without considering the spatial structure of flood events. At a large scale, this can lead to a misestimation of flood risk and losses caused by extreme events. A stochastic approach to global flood modelling allows the simulation of sets of flood events with realistic spatial structure that can overcome this problem, but until recently this has been limited by the availability of gauge data. Previous research shows that simulated discharge data from global hydrological models can be used to develop a stochastic flood model of the United States (Wing et al., 2020) and suggests that the same approach can potentially be used to build large scale stochastic flood models elsewhere but this has not so far been tested.   

    This research therefore focuses on using discharge hindcasts from global hydrological models to drive stochastic flood models in different areas of the world. By comparing the outputs of these simulations to a gauge-based approach, we analyse how a model-based approach can simulate spatial dependency in large scale flood modelling outside of well-gauged territories such as the US. Based on data availability we selected different areas in Australia, Southern Africa, Southeast Asia, South America and Europe for the analysis.

    The results of this research show that the performance of a model-based approach in the different continents is promising and in most areas the errors are comparable to the results obtained in the United States by Wing et al. (2020). In the United States, with this magnitude of errors, the loss distribution obtained using the model-based approach is near identical to the one produced by the gauge-based method. This suggests that this method could be used in other regions to characterize losses. Using a network of synthetic gauges with data from global hydrological models would allow the development of a stochastic flood model with detailed spatial dependency, generating realistic event sets in data-scarce regions and loss exceedance curves where exposure and vulnerability data are available.

    References

    Wing, O. E. J., Quinn, N., Bates, P. D., Neal, J. C., Smith, A. M., Sampson, C. C., Coxon, G., Yamazaki, D., Sutanudjaja, E. H., & Alfieri, L. (2020). Toward Global Stochastic River Flood Modeling. Water Resources Research, 56(8). https://doi.org/10.1029/2020wr027692

    How to cite: Olcese, G., Bates, P., Neal, J., Sampson, C., Wing, O., and Quinn, N.: Can hydrological models be used to characterize spatial dependency in global stochastic flood modelling?, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9310, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9310, 2022.

    EGU22-9323 | Presentations | NH9.1

    MYRIAD-EU: towards Disaster Risk Management pathways in multi-risk assessment 

    Philip Ward and the MYRIAD-EU team

    Whilst the last decades have seen a clear shift in emphasis from managing natural hazards to managing risk, the majority of natural hazard risk research still focuses on single hazards. Internationally, there are calls for more attention for multi-hazards and multi-risks. Within the EU-funded project MYRIAD-EU, we argue for an approach that addresses multi-hazard, multi-risk management through the lens of sustainability challenges that cut across sectors, regions, and hazards. In this approach, the starting point is a specific sustainability challenge, rather than an individual hazard or sector, and trade-offs and synergies are examined across sectors, regions, and hazards. We argue for in-depth case studies in which various approaches for multi-hazard and multi-risk management are co-developed and tested in practice. In this contribution, we present this project, whose goal is to enable stakeholders to develop forward-looking disaster risk management pathways that assess trade-offs and synergies of various strategies across sectors, hazards, and scales.

    How to cite: Ward, P. and the MYRIAD-EU team: MYRIAD-EU: towards Disaster Risk Management pathways in multi-risk assessment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9323, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9323, 2022.

    EGU22-9586 | Presentations | NH9.1

    Testing global geomorphological model as site proxy to predict ground-shaking amplification 

    Karina Loviknes and Fabrice Cotton

    Estimating site amplification of earthquake ground shaking at new sites and sites without any direct geotechnical measurements of site parameters remains a large challenge in seismic hazard assessment. Currently, the standard procedure is to use site proxies inferred from topographic slope from digital elevation models (DEMs). In this study, we test a geomorphological model for inferred regolith, soil and sediment depth by Pelletier et al. (2016). This model was originally developed as input for hydrology and ecosystem models and is based on several global values in addition to the topographic slope, including geological maps and water table data.

    To test the suitability of the geomorphological model for ground-shaking prediction we derive the empirical site amplification for sites in Japan, Italy and California using different regional and global seismological datasets. We use the observed shaking amplification to test the correlation between the observed ground-shaking site amplification and the inferred site proxies and test the performance of site amplification models based on geomorphological proxies. We find that the geomorphological model works equally well or slightly better than the traditional inferred proxies. We therefore argue that this model is a promising alternative proxy that can be used for predicting site amplification on new sites and regions for which no geotechnical information exists (i.e. on a global level). This result has important implications for the development of the new generation of ground-shaking models used for shake maps and seismic hazard models.

    How to cite: Loviknes, K. and Cotton, F.: Testing global geomorphological model as site proxy to predict ground-shaking amplification, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9586, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9586, 2022.

    EGU22-9606 | Presentations | NH9.1

    FuturePop - Global Gridded Population Projections at 90m resolution 

    Laurence Hawker, Paul Bates, and Jeffrey Neal

    Population projections for alternative socio-economic scenarios are crucial to understand climate change impacts. Current global gridded population projections are only available at coarse resolutions (~1km) that are inconsistent with the latest hazard models. Thus, climate change impact studies often utilise sub-optimum datasets by using coarse resolution gridded population predictions or present day population, and therefore may not adequately represent future population. To fill this gap, we use the latest datasets that align with the policy relevant Shared Socioeconomic Pathway (SSP) Scenarios and CMIP6 projections to create the first gridded population at ~90m resolution globally. We call this new dataset FuturePop. Projections are made at decadal intervals and extend to 2100 for each of the 5 SSP scenarios. Our method uses country level population and % urban projections from the SSP Database, redistributing population based on delineation of rural and urban areas. We add sophistication to our method by considering associated information such as travel time, and also include predictions of urban expansion. Comparison to existing global and regional datasets show FuturePop has considerable skill in predicting plausible population changes and redistribution. Lastly, we demonstrate the importance of using FuturePop for future flood risk compared to existing gridded population projections. Hazard footprints typically have horizontal length scales of tens to thousands of meters, thus it is crucial to depict populations at these scales to accurately estimate future flood exposure.

    How to cite: Hawker, L., Bates, P., and Neal, J.: FuturePop - Global Gridded Population Projections at 90m resolution, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9606, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9606, 2022.

    EGU22-10178 | Presentations | NH9.1

    The development of a European flood catastrophe model 

    Oliver Wing, Hessel Winsemius, Remi Meynadier, Hugo Rakotoarimanga, Mark Hegnauer, Hélène Boisgontier, Anna Weisman, Andy Smith, and Chris Sampson

    To understand continental scale flood risks, including spatial and temporal coherence and cascading events, is of particular importance to the insurance industry. For this industry, an “event” entails a certain regulatory duration, and encompasses the spatial scale of the portfolio of the insurer. This requires a large catalogue of statistically well-sampled, climatologically realistic possible events, much longer than any historical record can provide. We hypothesize that events that might have occurred in the recent past, but did not occur, may be generated from shorter duration historical samples, by temporal resampling, and spatial reshuffling.

    In this contribution, we present a model framework – developed by a consortium of Fathom, Deltares, and AXA – that can efficiently compute very large event sets, using synthetically sampled weather (up to many thousands of years) that simulates continuous daily weather and sub-daily (for small-scale pluvial flooding) weather statistics, a gridded hydrological model forced by the synthetic weather that produces long-term hydrological statistics, and a subcatchment-scale fluvial and pluvial flood model archive, produced from large amounts of simulations with the Fathom flood model engine. The framework is setup such that components within the framework can be easily improved or replaced by new components, e.g. providing updated historical baselines for weather generation, enhanced weather generation, enhanced flood maps, or improved hydrological relationships. We present our first simulations using a k-nearest-neighbour weather resampling, using Self-Organizing-Maps, 10,000 years of simulated weather and hydrology, and sampled flood statistics. In forthcoming work, we will improve weather generation mechanism by relaxing the spatial locations of weather systems, and implement climate change.

    How to cite: Wing, O., Winsemius, H., Meynadier, R., Rakotoarimanga, H., Hegnauer, M., Boisgontier, H., Weisman, A., Smith, A., and Sampson, C.: The development of a European flood catastrophe model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10178, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10178, 2022.

    EGU22-11682 | Presentations | NH9.1

    Evaluating the next generation of global flood models in the Central Highlands of Vietnam 

    Jeffrey Neal, Laurence Hawker, James Savage, Tom Kirkpatrick, Yanos Zylberberg, and Pham Khanh Nam

    Global flood models have undergone rapid development over the past decade. However, with each new generation of model it is essential to systematically evaluate simulation performance for a range of tests and against multiple sources of data. It is also important to take stock, document lessons learnt and contribute to the formation of better practice and modelling standards in the field. Here we illustrate some of the progress being made in global flood modelling by evaluating the latest 30 m resolution implementation of the LISFLOOD-FP/Fathom global flood model over the Central Highlands of Vietnam, and benchmark it against several previous incarnations of the model.

    Two independent data sources are used to evaluate the model. The first of these maps recent flood extents using remotely sensed data from the Sentinal-1 missions and compares them to global flood model outputs of commensurate return periods. The second data set identifies land parcels (properties and agricultural fields) that flooded during the same events from a household survey, where uniquely all household land parcels in four villages were sampled. The independence of the date sets also allowed for cross-validation of the observations.

    Substantial simulation enhancements are associated with the transition from SRTM and MERIT DEM’s at 90 m resolution to FABDEM, a version of Copernicus DEM at 30 m with forests and buildings removed. In addition to improvements derived from the DEM, more accurate river location, river width and discharge estimates combined with the inversion of river bathymetry via gradually varied rather than uniform flow theory also have an impact on performance.

    How to cite: Neal, J., Hawker, L., Savage, J., Kirkpatrick, T., Zylberberg, Y., and Nam, P. K.: Evaluating the next generation of global flood models in the Central Highlands of Vietnam, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11682, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11682, 2022.

    EGU22-12982 | Presentations | NH9.1

    Multi-hazard open access software package review with the potential for conducting sectoral risk assessments on a European or local scale 

    James Daniell, Andreas Schaefer, Marleen de Ruiter, Evelyne Foerster, Philip Ward, Johannes Brand, Bijan Khazai, Trevor Girard, and Friedemann Wenzel

    As part of the NARSIS (New Approach to Reactor Safety ImprovementS, www.narsis.eu) project, and the MYRIAD-EU (Multi-hazard and sYstemic framework for enhancing Risk-Informed mAnagement and Decision-making in the EU, www.myriadproject.eu) project, a compendium of existing open access software packages for risk modelling of natural hazards, as well as a review of multi-hazard projects has been undertaken with a clear focus on assessments in Europe.

    There have been over 200 open access software packages produced for the evaluation of singular natural hazards, combinations of natural hazards and multi-hazard identified either propagating through to risk, or calculating extensive hazard metrics. By far, the most have been built for floods, and earthquakes, however a number have been designed for multi-hazard (RiskSCAPE, HAZUS and variants, CLIMADA, NARSIS-MHE, InaSAFE to name a few).

    In around 120 of them, they have moved through to risk assessment, with the calculation of risk metrics. Many of these have been designed for scenario analysis, but there are also many which employ probabilistic methods or stochastic models to evaluate risk. In this work, the classification of the open access software packages follows that of previous studies (Daniell et al., 2014), but with a focus on the use for multi-hazard assessment rather than singular hazards.

    Moving through to multi-risk, a number include different interconnected systems for assets (OOFIMS for instance from the EU SYNER-G project). Although there are very few that deal with consecutive or coinciding hazards, a number can be adapted to do this, and some even have the ability to be used for cascading hazard analysis.

    By understanding the state-of-the-art in existing software packages as of 2022, a multi-hazard framework can be produced for various economic sectors such as ecosystems and forestry, energy, finance, food and agriculture, infrastructure and transport, as well as tourism, to solve some of the missing links when looking at the impacts of consecutive, coinciding or cascading hazards. In addition, relevant software packages have been found to conduct assessments on the European scale, but also on the local scale for more detailed analyses.

    How to cite: Daniell, J., Schaefer, A., de Ruiter, M., Foerster, E., Ward, P., Brand, J., Khazai, B., Girard, T., and Wenzel, F.: Multi-hazard open access software package review with the potential for conducting sectoral risk assessments on a European or local scale, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12982, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12982, 2022.

    Flash floods are among the most destructive natural disasters causing extremely adverse impacts on the lives and livelihoods of people across the world. These events occur due to weather-dependent phenomena like cloudbursts or extreme rainfall characterized by a very short lead time for warning. In recent years, the Indian Himalayan state of Uttarakhand has been experiencing frequent flash flood disasters resulting in massive damage and losses in terms of life and property. To mitigate the damaging effects of these phenomena, there is a need to identify and spatially represent the surfaces/areas prone to excessive runoff due to flash floods. However, the dynamic nature of flash flooding, the complexity of the terrain, and altitude-dependent climatic sensitivity make predicting flooding sites in the region very difficult. Geospatial technology, advanced statistical techniques in conjunction with remotely sensed datasets can be potentially employed to identify the possible areas, which are susceptible to flash flooding. Mandakini River Basin (MRB) is among one of the most flash floods prone basins in Uttarakhand. In this study, Frequency Ratio (FR) and Index of Entropy (IOE) methods have been integrated to make a hybrid statistical model to calculate flash flood potential index (FFPI). Subsequently, assessment and identification of the flash flood susceptible zones were carried out for MRB. In this study, an inventory of locations where flash flood events had occurred in the past was prepared. 70% of these locations were utilized in the training sample and the remaining 30% in the testing (validation) sample. Furthermore, 15 flash flood conditioning factors were utilized for training and testing the model. The results of the model revealed that the areas with high and very high susceptibility account for approximately 9.7% and 17.4%, respectively of the entire study area. The performance assessment of the model was examined by Receiver Operating Characteristic (ROC) curve method for both training and validation event locations. The area under the curve (AUC) values obtained for the success and prediction rates were 0.871 and 0.847, respectively. The final output susceptibility map generated after the analysis depicts the study area in five (very low, low, medium, high, and very high) flash flood susceptibility zones.  As a contribution to devise appropriate basin management plans and mitigate the damage in the highly susceptible areas to flash floods, the present research results may be an important input to disaster governance.

    Keywords: Flash flood susceptibility; Flash flood potential index; Frequency Ratio; Index of Entropy; Indian Himalayas

    How to cite: Singh, G. and Pandey, A.: Identification of flash flood susceptible zones in a highly complex topography and altitude dependent climatically sensitive Himalayan River Basin, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-153, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-153, 2022.

    EGU22-438 | Presentations | NH9.8 | Highlight

    Projection of future pluvial flood events over Himalayan river basin under CMIP6 climate data 

    Antony Joh Moothedan, Pankaj R. Dhote, Praveen K. Thakur, and Ankit Agarwal

    A hydrological model conceptualizing a certain rainfall event of a watershed is capable of reflecting the hydrological situation and assessing its response not only for historical but also projected climate data in future. This works presents a futuristic flood discharge estimation using the established event based HEC-HMS model corresponding to the meteorological forcing from shared socioeconomic pathways (SSPs) of Coupled Model Intercomparison Project-6 (CMIP6). The hydrological model was setup for flood-prone Himalayan Beas river basin, India. The calibration and validation of the model was carried out for the rainfall induced flooding events of monsoon 2005 and 2010, respectively. The coefficient of determination (R2) and Nash–Sutcliffe efficiency (NSE) were achieved to be 0.82 and 0.79 for calibration and, 0.84 and 0.80 for validation at Bhuntar station, respectively. An improved carbon simulated CMIP6 rainfall data holding of ACCESS-ESM1.5, after bias correction and downscaling, was used to simulate the flood hydrographs in the Beas basin till 2100. The peak discharges of each decade from 2021 to 2100 was estimated and analysed, for the SSP245 and SSP585 scenarios. For the climate projection scenario SSP245, the peak flood event was estimated to be in July 2068 with peak discharge of 4446.7 m3/s while a SSP585 scenario observed extreme flood event in July 2057 having a peak discharge of 4817.2 m3/s. The estimated discharge magnitudes from SSP245 and SSP585 schemes are comparable to the 562 years and 706 years return period discharges of the basin, respectively. The study also revealed that the frequency of flooding events are maximum in the endmost decade of 2091-2100, with an increasing trend towards the later decades.

    Keywords: Flood, Hydrological Model, CMIP6, HEC-HMS, Himalayas, Beas river, Climate data

    How to cite: Moothedan, A. J., Dhote, P. R., Thakur, P. K., and Agarwal, A.: Projection of future pluvial flood events over Himalayan river basin under CMIP6 climate data, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-438, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-438, 2022.

    EGU22-595 | Presentations | NH9.8

    Flood risk assessment framework for Himalayan river basin 

    Pankaj R. Dhote, Antony Joh Moothedan, Praveen K. Thakur, and Ankit Agarwal

    Increasing rate of flash-floods in Himalayan river basin causes immediate damage to human lives, daily living and infrastructure. The present work proposed flood risk assessment framework by blending the hydrodynamic modelling outputs and risk evaluation concepts. The different notions of risk as in hazard, vulnerability and exposure were evaluated over flood-prone Beas river with focus at Bhuntar, Kullu and Manali. The hydrodynamic model (MIKE 11) was established for 56 km river stretch right from Manali to Bhuntar. The flood depth and flow velocity outputs from the calibrated and validated hydrodynamic model were used for the estimation of flood hazard rating. Vulnerability maps were generated using depth-damage curves prepared by Joint Research Centre, EU, for each exposure of agriculture, settlement and roads. The 100 year return period flood risk maps were prepared and analysed for all the three towns. Key interviews and community focus group discussions were held further to strengthen, compare and verify the achieved outcomes. For a 100 year return period flood risk assessment, a total of 0.054 km2, 0.226 km2 and 0.334 km2 area was flooded and extreme flood risk zones were identified with 4.7%, 6.8%, and 10.9% area of the total inundated area at the settlement regions of towns of Manali, Kullu and Bhuntar, respectively. The area on right bank of the river was inundated severely and got classified into extreme flood risk zones. The major settlements at all the towns under consideration are at the right bank due to relatively flat, low lying terrain leading to the dire risk. The outcome of the work can assist disaster managers and local administrations for flood disaster planning in advance, thus reducing human and economic loss.  Further, flood risk map could serve as catastrophic product to define flood insurance rate for various exposures in floodplain.

    Keywords: Flood Risk Assessment, MIKE11, Hazard, Vulnerability, Hydrodynamic Modelling

    How to cite: Dhote, P. R., Moothedan, A. J., Thakur, P. K., and Agarwal, A.: Flood risk assessment framework for Himalayan river basin, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-595, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-595, 2022.

    Landslide is a disaster which is affecting countries with high-relief topography and large-amount precipitation. A typical example is Bhutan. Major roads are sometimes blocked by landslides caused by monsoon-derived intensive precipitation events. To understand where landslide is prone to occur in Bhutan, we need geographical assessments focused on both of spatial distribution of past landslide mass movements and that of precipitation. In this study, landslide features were delineated from high-resolution satellite imagery and Digital Surface Model (DSM) collected by the Advanced Land Observing Satellite (ALOS) operated by the Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency (JAXA). We define three domains located in different river basins as our study site. They are located in the Mangde river tributary, the Wang river tributary, and the Drangme river tributary. Multiple geographical parameters were calculated from ALOS-derived DSM data; i.e. elevation, slope angle, distance from the river, curvature, topographic wetness index (TWI), stream power index (SPI), and sedimentary transport index (STI). Frequency ratio (FR) was calculated by the number of pixels in each class of parameter to evaluate the geographic conditions that are known to be associated with landslides.

    The results show that the FR was greater in places with (1) lower elevation, (2) closer distance from the river relative to the entire watershed, and that landslides are more likely to occur under these conditions in all three study areas. The larger FR at lower elevations is presumably due to other factors, such as weathering, which are affected by elevation. The finding that the FR was larger in the area closer to the river is explained by a hypothesis that erosion of the lower part of the slope reduces the stability of the slope and makes landslides more likely to occur. In addition, representative values of geographical parameters in the study areas were compared with each other. The Drangme river tributary area with the smallest elevation and distance from the river has the largest percentage of landslide features. They indicate the same trend as (1) and (2). Thus, elevation and distance from river are important parameters to know landslide prone area in these districts.

    How to cite: Tada, K. and Nagai, H.: Relationship between spatial distribution of landslides in Bhutan and geographical parameters, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1857, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1857, 2022.

    EGU22-3029 | Presentations | NH9.8 | Highlight

    Understanding multiscale drivers of natural hazards, cascading failures, and risk management strategies within a multisector system 

    Rocky Talchabhadel, Sanjib Sharma, and Saurav Kumar

    Deleterious impacts of rapid unplanned anthropogenic disturbances have been compounded by climate change globally. This phenomenon is particularly prominent in the high mountain regions that have suffered a string of cascading hazard-related disasters (CHDs). Recent catastrophic events (e.g., 2013 Uttarakhand Flood, 2021 Chamoli Landslide, and 2021 Melamchi Debris/Flood) have highlighted the need to better understand the complex interactions among human, natural, and engineered systems to inform the design of disaster management strategies. It is crucial to rethink disaster management as a multisystem-connected problem. In such a deeply interconnected system, it is essential to build a systematic framework to reveal linkages and identify spatially and temporally varying risk probabilities. We develop data-driven models that integrate existing hydroclimatic models (e.g., glacial lake outburst flood, landslide, and flood) and data (e.g., NASA Earth Observations) with non-traditional data streams (e.g., Citizen Science and expert knowledge) to investigate connections that lead to CHDs.

    Our modeling framework synergistically integrates models and data from different systems using a Bayesian network. The framework will serve as an operational system-of-systems model for the high mountain region that can formalize how Citizen Science and expert knowledge may be utilized with existing models for managing CHDs. Here the experts refer to everyone involved in decision-making, including academic researchers, public agency researchers, policymakers, and managers on the ground. We propose that a cyberinfrastructure should be developed that integrates all data streams and model resources necessary to understand the spatially and temporally varying risks. The cyberinfrastructure will facilitate ‘what-if’ type analysis to understand system dynamics and sensitivity to perturbations that may be used to design mitigation strategies.

     

    Case Study

    Specifically, we choose Nepal Himalaya where natural hazards and cascading failure are a major concern. The region is characterized by extreme elevation gradient, young and fragile geology, extreme seasonal and spatial variation in rainfall, and diverse human impacts. One hazard often triggers another hazard in the region, leading to cascading disaster. Also, a seemingly non-hazardous series of average events can trigger a chain of events over a long or short time-scale with disastrous consequences. Knowledge and understanding of these connections are essential for planning mitigation measures and improving hazards predictions in the region.

    How to cite: Talchabhadel, R., Sharma, S., and Kumar, S.: Understanding multiscale drivers of natural hazards, cascading failures, and risk management strategies within a multisector system, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3029, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3029, 2022.

    Heavy rainfall events in mountainous areas can trigger thousands of destructive landslides, which pose a risk to people and infrastructure and significantly affect the landscape. Inventories of these landslides are used to assess their impact on the landscape and in hazard mitigation strategies and modelling. Optical and multi-spectral satellite imagery can be used to generate rainfall-triggered landslide inventories over wide areas, but cloud cover associated with the rainfall event can obscure this imagery. This delay means that for long rainfall events, such as the monsoon or successive typhoons, landslide timing is often poorly constrained. This lack of information on landslide timing limits both hazard mitigation strategies and our ability to model the physical landslide triggering processes.

    Synthetic aperture radar (SAR) data represent an alternative source of information on landslides and can be acquired in all weather conditions. The removal of vegetation and movement of material caused by a landslide alters the radar scattering properties of the Earth’s surface. Landslides therefore have a signal in SAR imagery and the Sentinel-1 satellite constellation acquires SAR images every 12 days on two tracks globally, offering an opportunity to greatly improve the temporal resolution of individual landslides within an inventory whose trigger is poorly constrained in time, typical in regions with long periods of cloud cover. Here we present methods of using Sentinel-1 SAR amplitude time series to constrain landslide timing. Our approach combines three methods based on the change within the mapped landslide in (i) median amplitude versus the background,  (ii) amplitude spatial variability and  (iii) surface geometry. When applied to triggered landslides of known timing in Japan, Nepal and Zimbabwe, we achieved an overall accuracy of 80% when combining ascending and descending SAR tracks.

    Further we apply our methods to inventories of monsoon-triggered landslides in Nepal (from 2015, 2016 and 2017) to decipher the relationship between landsliding and  local hydrometeorological conditions. Specifically, we first analysed the spatial and temporal clustering of timed landslides. Then we calibrated satellite-based rainfall with rainfall and/or river discharge gauges to understand the rainfall intensity over various timescales preceding the landslide occurrence retrieved by our method. We conclude with implications for empirical and physical modelling of monsoon-induced landsliding.

    How to cite: Burrows, K., Marc, O., and Remy, D.: Dating individual rainfall-triggered landslides with Sentinel-1 SAR time series: Application to the Nepal monsoon, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3928, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3928, 2022.

    The river morphologies and the associated landscape experience considerable changes in response to landslides and floods. The young and tectonically active Himalayan region is more prone to such natural hazards. The impacts of climate change and anthropogenic activities have further increased the frequency and intensity of such natural disasters in this already active region. These disasters cause vast losses of life, property, infrastructure and disturb the ecological balance. This study explores the geomorphological changes occurring in the downstream river reaches of the Alaknanda River using the Google Earth Engine (GEE) cloud-based computing tool. We extract the active river channel width using Landsat multispectral images. The initial results show considerable changes in width over the years (1990-2021) and the changes start from the knickpoint continuing towards downstream. The changes in the river’s bank line indicate the bank erosion and relocation of sediments along the river, likely supplied by erosion processes at upstream reaches. Here, we try to identify the critical point where the deposition process first starts to highlight the most vulnerable zone geomorphologically. We further check whether there has been an increase in sediment deposition in recent years due to likely increased erosion related to deforestation on higher reaches of the Alakananda catchment. We try to achieve this goal by correlating the river landform changes and land cover changes along riparian areas of the river temporally. Our overall objective is to develop a framework to correlate changes or processes in upstream reaches to depositions or erosions along the downstream sections of a high-energy river.

     

    Keywords: Landscape evolution, natural hazards, erosion, deposition, River-line

    How to cite: Malakar, B., Ozturk, U., and Sen, S.: The link between downstream river planform changes and upstream changes or processes in high energy mountain rivers, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4284, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4284, 2022.

    EGU22-4333 | Presentations | NH9.8

    Multi-Hazard Risk Assessment of Schools in Lower Himalayas: Haridwar District, Uttarakhand, India 

    Shivani Chouhan, Aishwarya Narang, and Mahua Mukherjee

    The Indian Himalayan Region possesses a unique place among the world's mountain ecosystems. Being a geographic young region and tectonically active, it is subject to multiple hazards and has seen a significant loss of life and property each year. Historically, the Himalayas have been subject to various disasters (earthquakes, landslides, floods, etc.), resulting in devastating socio-economic effects on the country's population, further straining an already stressed economy.

    Haridwar, the most populous city in Uttarakhand, attracts tourists from all over the world. It is a state in northern India with young mountains and is affected by multiple disasters every year. Many national and international organizations are doing disaster risk reduction research, studies, and initiatives in the Himalayas.

    Educational institutions, such as schools, act as lifeline structures in the case of a crisis. As a result, it's critical to protect these structures for those who rely on the school as a disaster shelter and help center. Schools and hospitals, which are considered lifeline structures, play a critical role in the aftermath of disasters. The essential elements to recognize are coping capability, multi-hazard vulnerability, and their risk should be readily available for better planning and decision-making.

    In Haridwar District, multi-hazard risk assessment assessments were undertaken at 50 schools (with 285 building blocks) with the same goal. The hazard assessment is divided into two types: building-level surveys that include Rapid Visual Screening (RVS), Non-Structural Risk Assessment (NSRA), and Fire Safety Audit, and campus-level surveys that include vulnerability analysis for earthquakes, floods, industrial hazards, landslides, and wind. The Rapid Visual Screening will highlight potential weaknesses in a building's wall, roof, site condition, block geometry, foundation, seismic band availability, and other components.

    This research aims to find hazard vulnerabilities and overlooked behavioral patterns in the region that raise the multi-hazard risk of the schools and the community. The analysis findings should be utilized to prioritize hazard preparedness, retrofitting, prospective building activities, and decision-making to decrease risk and prepare the school for possible catastrophes.

    Multiple surveys are employed in this study to identify deficiencies/gaps in building methods and development patterns in existing Haridwar district schools, and solutions for risk assessment and retrofitting are proposed based on the findings. The research findings can be utilized to prioritize disaster preparedness, retrofitting, future building practices, and decision-making to lower risk and better prepare the school for future calamities.

    How to cite: Chouhan, S., Narang, A., and Mukherjee, M.: Multi-Hazard Risk Assessment of Schools in Lower Himalayas: Haridwar District, Uttarakhand, India, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4333, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4333, 2022.

    EGU22-5512 | Presentations | NH9.8

    Projection of flood seasonality Changes in the Himalayan Region River due to global warming, taking the Garhwal Himalayas river basin as an example 

    Prachi Singhal, Narendra Kumar Goel, Ankit Agarwal, Axel Bronstert, and Klaus Vormoor

    The impact of a warming climate on snow- and rain-dominated river basins such as the Garhwal Himalayas basin constitutes both a major research challenge and the potential of a severe socio-economic risk. The particular combination at the Garhwal, of hydrometeorological and hydrographic conditions entails merging and superposing two presently distinct seasonal phenomena: snowmelt induced spring floods and rainfall generated summer floods. This study focuses on the projection of seasonality changes in floods in a Garhwal Himalayas basin under global warming. The research in this context is rather uncertain in the proposed study area of the Himalayas, mainly due to the scarcity and unavailability of long-term and high-resolution meteorological data in that region. But after setting up Automatic Weather Stations and Gauge and Discharge sites in the Garhwal region in 2016, the observed data of the past five years lay the basis for understanding the different flood generating regimes. We have analysed the IMD historical maximum monthly rainfall (1901-2020) and maximum temperature (1951-2020) over the study region and found evidence of shifting of maximum rainfall peak backward up to the month of June and maximum temperature peak shifting forward to June (earlier triggering snowmelt induced peak then); if warmer climate scenarios are experienced in future. We also compared the different precipitation datasets available with respect to the observed data at daily, monthly, quarterly and yearly time scales. Those data are crucial for any analysis of possible changes in seasonal hydro-meteorological conditions. We found that the IMD precipitation dataset matches best the observations and the projected climate ensemble of chosen dataset (NEX-GDDP) required significant correction with respect to observed data to counter underestimation. Therefore, we have used quantile-based mapping to adjust the biased projected climate dataset of NEX-GDDP. Also, the corrected projected precipitation of time window 2071-2099 of RCP 4.5 and 8.5 scenarios is found to be magnitude wise higher than that of the corrected historical time window 1971-2000. This clearly indicates the possible occurrences of changes in floods, though we are well aware about the high uncertainties of projected future precipitation conditions. Thus, our analysis poses the potential of bridging the gaps of understanding different flood generating regimes and their future possibilities for better preparedness against natural hazards in the Himalayan region.

    How to cite: Singhal, P., Goel, N. K., Agarwal, A., Bronstert, A., and Vormoor, K.: Projection of flood seasonality Changes in the Himalayan Region River due to global warming, taking the Garhwal Himalayas river basin as an example, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5512, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5512, 2022.

    EGU22-6457 | Presentations | NH9.8

    Natural hazards evolution in a context of climate evolution and infrastructure development: the Kali Gandaki valley case, West-Central Nepal. 

    Monique Fort, Narayan Gurung, Rainer Bell, Christoff Andermann, Kirsten Cook, Odin Marc, and Katy Burrows

    Highest geomorphic activity in central Nepal is mostly driven by monsoon rainfall, yet the recent development of infrastructure has increased this activity and the risks for the locals and travelers. Our aim is to illustrate recent cascading hazards and their interactions with, and impacts on, socio-economic development along an important road corridor. We focus on the middle Kali Gandaki valley reach, within the High Himalayan Crystalline Series HHC where the river deeply incised and the topography is characterized by steep hillslopes and high relief.  This 20-25 km long reach experiences strong monsoon rainfall enhanced by orographic effects, with rainfall rates >2000 mm/a. In the last years between 2018 to 2021 the monsoon season was very strong and experienced several strong and long lasting rainstorm events with amplified catastrophic events such as debris flows, landsliding and river activities. On the basis of repeated field surveys, satellite images (Pléiades, Sentinel and Planet) analysis, Global Precipitation Measurement (GPM) data, UAV, river flow seismic noise records, we observed that once destabilized, hillslopes and steep, small tributary catchments evolved very rapidly during the years, all the more since road constructions for the upgrading to a 2-lane road contributed to destabilization of the hillslopes. This rapid disequilibrium has several consequences. (1) First it reworked old colluvium deposits, including old landslide material, old glacial and/or fluvial alluvium and related lacustrine deposits, hence revealing a former, complex paleo-topography of this deep valley (as observed north of Ghasa, along the Kahiku khola and Kali Gandaki). (2) Second, in providing looser material, it has accelerated the cascading system and transfer of sediments into the main Kali Gandaki River, as shown in the Rupse site, famous for its waterfall, and that was destroyed by a debris flood (July 20, 2020) generated by intense rainfall that triggered landslides in the upper catchment, with impacts at the junction with Kali Gandaki (destruction of road, bridge, settlements). Similarly, the Thaplyang site, active since 2014, was repeatedly affected by strong rainfall since 2018, with progressive erosion of an old landslide material – the active area increased from 9100 m² (March 2018) to 9600 m² (Oct. 2018) and 32300 m² (Nov 2021) – hence threatening small settlements upstream. (3) Third, the repeated disasters (river bank collapses and settlements destruction; traffic obstruction) affect the tourism economy and development along this major link between south China and north India. Further work, including SAR analyses, is ongoing to better quantify the overall sediment exported volumes and the impacts of this changing geomorphology on future infrastructure development and settlements.    

    How to cite: Fort, M., Gurung, N., Bell, R., Andermann, C., Cook, K., Marc, O., and Burrows, K.: Natural hazards evolution in a context of climate evolution and infrastructure development: the Kali Gandaki valley case, West-Central Nepal., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6457, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6457, 2022.

    EGU22-7804 | Presentations | NH9.8 | Highlight

    Numerical weather prediction model outputs define intensity-duration thresholds of extreme-precipitation-induced sediment disasters 

    Srikrishnan Siva Subramanian, Piyush Srivastava, and Sumit Sen

    Rainfall intensity-duration (ID) thresholds are helpful to estimate the likelihood of natural hazards during extreme precipitation events. Sub-daily time-series of weather data is necessary to define precise ID thresholds of sediment disasters. The Himalayas, vulnerable to extreme precipitation events, experience large-scale sediment disasters, i.e., landslides, debris flows, and flash floods. Present early warning systems currently in operation encounter difficulties forecasting sub-daily time-series of weather due to instrumental and operational challenges. Here, we present a new framework to analyse and predict extreme rainfall-induced landslides using a weather research and forecasting model (WRF) followed by a spatially distributed numerical model. The operational framework starts with the WRF model running at 1.8 km × 1.8 km resolution. Then, the spatiotemporal numerical model for landslide forecasting at the same resolution uses the WRF model outputs. We calibrate the models using Uttarakhand, India's 2013 heavy rainfall-induced landslide events. We perform parametric numerical simulations to identify critical ID thresholds of landslides under different precipitation intensities, i.e., moderate rain, rather heavy, heavy rain, very heavy rain, and extremely heavy rain according to the India Meteorological Department (IMD) glossary. Our analysis opens avenues for integrating the WRF model with rainfall ID threshold-based territorial early warning of landslides. 

    How to cite: Siva Subramanian, S., Srivastava, P., and Sen, S.: Numerical weather prediction model outputs define intensity-duration thresholds of extreme-precipitation-induced sediment disasters, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7804, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7804, 2022.

    EGU22-8461 | Presentations | NH9.8

    Landslide Susceptibility & Risk Mapping for the Northwest Himalayan State of Uttarakhand 

    Arnab Sengupta and Sankar Kumar Nath

    Landslide is the most significant natural hazard that causes socio-economic devastation in mountainous terrains around the world. In India, lands of mountains especially the Himalayas are vulnerable to landslide due to the high intensity of seismic shaking, prolonged rainfall and complex lithological setting. In the present study, Landslide Susceptibility Zonation (LSZ) has been carried out using Random Forest technique on Geographical Information System by combining different landslide causative factors i.e. slope angle, slope aspect, drainage density, distance to drainage, elevation, shape of slope, distance to lineament, lineament density, surface geology, soil, geomorphology, landform, rainfall, epicenter proximity, Normalize Differences Vegetation Index, Landuse/Landcover, road density and distance to road are integrated to model Landslide Susceptibility Index, thus classifying the terrain in terms of  ‘None’, ‘Low’, ‘Moderate’, ‘High’, ‘Very High’ and ‘Severe’. It is observed that around 45% of the terrain falls under the ‘High’ to ‘Severe’ landslide susceptibility zones. Receiver Operating Characteristics (ROC) places an 85% confidence level that predicts a strong correlation between LSZ and landslide inventory dataset of the region. Thus, this study suggests that a comprehensive approach for slope failure mapping can be used to develop appropriate mitigational strategies for landslide disaster management in the socio-economic context.

    Keywords: Landslide Susceptibility Zonation; Northwest Himalaya.

    How to cite: Sengupta, A. and Nath, S. K.: Landslide Susceptibility & Risk Mapping for the Northwest Himalayan State of Uttarakhand, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8461, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8461, 2022.

    EGU22-8654 | Presentations | NH9.8 | Highlight

    Quantifying emerging patterns of greening and browning in the Himalayan region 

    Kanwal Nayan Singh, Thomas Nocke, Roopam Shukla, Pawan Kumar Joshi, Ankit Agarwal, and Jürgen Kurths

    Himalayan region is a critical part of the globe. In recent years,  vegetation cover in this region is undergoing considerable changes attributed ongoing to climatic and anthropogenic factors. The present study aims to capture the interannual vegetation changes over 19 years and explore how topographic and climatic variables contribute to the observed changes. Satellite-derived Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) dataset (2001–2019) was used to examine the spatio-temporal patterns of vegetation in Uttarakhand state in the Indian western Himalayas. Further analysis explored variation across elevation, temperature, precipitation, and vegetation types. Most parts of the Uttarakhand region experienced increasing NDVI trends, particularly in the Needleleaved Evergreen and Broadleaved Deciduous forest types; however, negative trends were observed in shrublands.

    How to cite: Singh, K. N., Nocke, T., Shukla, R., Joshi, P. K., Agarwal, A., and Kurths, J.: Quantifying emerging patterns of greening and browning in the Himalayan region, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8654, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8654, 2022.

    EGU22-9009 | Presentations | NH9.8

    Forecasting the evolution and growth of glacial lakes 

    Aniruddha Saha, Manoj Jain, and Wolfgang Schwanghart

    The glaciers in the Himalayas are rapidly retreating. With the increasing loss of glacial mass, there is an increase in the number of glacial lakes and thereby, the potential threat of GLOF (Glacial Lake Outburst Flood) events. We aim to forecast the evolution and growth of proglacial lakes over Gangotri Glacier (Uttarakhand, India). Proglacial lakes are formed by damming action of a moraine, resulting due to retreat of melting glaciers. As the glacier melts and loses its mass, the glacier bed gets exposed, and any possible over-deepening, if available in “thereby exposed bed-topography”, shall act as a bedrock dam, to hold the meltwater, forming a moraine-dammed lake. As the glacier melts, more and more of such bedrock dams shall get exposed. The lakes shall not evolve to the full of its size at once, but slowly and gradually, as it loses the glacier mass above it. The present research aims to identify the potential sites for such glacial lake formation and forecast the growth of each of these lakes over time. This is done in two-fold steps. Firstly, identifying the potential sites of formation of glacial lakes, by preparing the glacier bed topography using the GlabTop2_IITB model. This model has a self-calibration feature, that could calibrate even in the absence of field measurements. Secondly, a glacier evolution model is operated using a simple parameterisation approach, i.e., an empirical glacier specific function is used for updating the glacier surface using the climate model datasets. The updated glacier surface data helps us forecast the evolution and growth of glacial lakes. The spatial distribution of ice thickness for Gangotri was found to be within a range of 19m to 343m for the year 2014, having a glacier volume of 13.49 km3. Fifty potential sites for glacial lake formation were identified using the bedrock topography modelling, having a total storage capacity of 37.04m3. Our results shall help determine the possibility of further expansion of the glacial lakes present and their maximum storage capacities. Having an idea of the formation and growth of lakes in future can help us forecast the: hazard potential of a lake, its flood peak, and the downstream effect of its dam break events as it evolves over time.  

    How to cite: Saha, A., Jain, M., and Schwanghart, W.: Forecasting the evolution and growth of glacial lakes, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9009, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9009, 2022.

    EGU22-10956 | Presentations | NH9.8

    Site Characterization and Assessment of Probabilistic Seismic Hazard in Northeast India Region 

    Anand Srivastava, Sankar Kumar Nath, and Jyothula Madan

    Northeast India region presenting the most complex neotectonic assemblage is one of the world’s deadliest seismic territory being struck time and again by devastating earthquakes like the 1897 Shillong earthquake of Mw 8.1, 1934 Bihar-Nepal earthquake of Mw 8.1, 1950 Assam earthquake of Mw 8.7, and 1988 Burma-India border earthquake of Mw 7.2 being triggered from the Shillong, Eastern Himalaya, Mishmi tectonic block and Eastern Boundary zones. Ground motion of an impending earthquake in the Northeast India region is amplified due to trapping up of incident energy in the overburden soft sediments/soils thus necessitating site classification and its characterization to understand Seismic Hazard potential of the region. Shear wave velocity (Vs30) is estimated from empirical relation obtained through nonlinear regression analysis of geology, geomorphology, slope and landform in conforming to NEHRP and UBC nomenclature which together with measured (Vs30)  and liquefaction susceptibility assessment  classifies the region into Site Class A, B, C1, C2, C3, C4, D1, D2, D3, D4, E and F. 1-D nonlinear/equivalent linear site response analysis performed using DEEPSOIL package estimates spectral  site amplification of  4.28 in E/F), 3.64 in D4, 2.95 in D3), 2.91 in D2, 2.80 in D1, 2.71 in C4, 2.29 in C3, 2.16 in C2, 1.98 in C1 and 1.53 in B at corresponding predominant frequencies of 0.76Hz (in E/F), 1.05Hz (in D4), 1.1Hz (in D3), 2.21Hz (in D2), 2.95Hz (in D1), 3.0Hz (in C4), 3.37Hz (in C3), 3.45Hz (in C2), 5.41Hz (in C1) and 4.42Hz (in B) along with the absolute site amplification factor 2.1  in E/F, 1.93 in D4, 1.9 in D3, 1.85 in D2, 1.81 in D1, 1.78 in C4, 1.71 in C3, 1.68 in C2, 1.6 in C1 and 1.56 in B respectively. Surface Consistent Probabilistic Seismic Hazard Assessment of this region for 10% probability of exceedance in 50 years with a return period of 475 years considered both polygonal and tectonic seismogenic sources, wherein the entire region predicted Peak Ground Acceleration (PGA) variation within 0.34-1.88g placing Dispur in the ‘Severe’ hazard regime (PGA:1.5-1.88g) while  Kohima, Shillong, Itanagar and Imphal are in the ‘Moderate’ to ‘High’ hazard (PGA:0.73-1.12g), but Agartala, Aizawal and Gangtok in the ‘Low’ hazard (PGA:0.34-0.73g) domain correlating well with the isoseismal distributions of the great historical earthquakes impeded in this region. The assessment is expected to be useful for updating the urban development plan, developing design principles for future earthquake-resistant structures.

    Keywords: Northeast India; Shear Wave Velocity; Site Class; Peak Ground Acceleration; Site Characterization.

    How to cite: Srivastava, A., Nath, S. K., and Madan, J.: Site Characterization and Assessment of Probabilistic Seismic Hazard in Northeast India Region, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10956, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10956, 2022.

    EGU22-11104 | Presentations | NH9.8 | Highlight

    Liquefaction Potential Assessment of Northeast India Region: Its earthquake and deterministic scenario 

    Jyothula Madan, Sankar Kumar Nath, and Anand Srivastava

    Northeast India is the most seismically active region being located in Seismic Zone-V and experienced liquefaction phenomenon triggered by large earthquakes with maximum MM Intensity of X. The 1950 Assam earthquake of Mw 8.7, 1897 Shillong earthquake of Mw 8.1, 1869 Cachar earthquake of Mw 7.4 and 1988 India-Burma border earthquake of Mw 7.2 reportedly induced scattered liquefaction phenomenon with the surface exposure of sand boils, ground subsidence and lateral spreading in the Northeast India region. Having a shallow groundwater condition in major populated areas of the region located on the alluvium-rich Bramhaputra river system with deltaic plains, lacustrine swamp and marsh geomorphological conditions, Northeast India region presents a strong case for systematic liquefaction potential modelling using modern multivariate techniques. In the present investigation, we delivered synthesised bedrock ground motion for the aforementioned earthquakes using finite fault stochastic simulation followed by 1-D non-linear/equivalent linear site response analysis using DEEPSOIL module for Site Amplification and Peak Ground Acceleration assessment at the surface. Factor of Safety (FOS), Liquefaction Potential Index (LPI), Probability of Liquefaction (PL), and Liquefaction Risk Index (IR) are estimated to make a more subtle understanding of the severity of liquefaction under the impact of earthquake loading and also to predict deterministic liquefaction scenario in the event of a surface-consistent probabilistic seismic hazard condition at 10% probability of exceedance in 50 years with a return period of 475 years. From the results, it is observed that, ‘Severe’ (LPI>15)  liquefaction susceptible zone exists around the cities of Guwahati and Digboi in Assam, while Silchar and Jorhat are lying in ‘High’ (5<LPI≤15) liquefaction potential zone. Imphal, Agartala, and Itanagar are the other major cities that fall under the ‘moderate’ liquefaction potential (0<LPI≤5) zone. The entire Northeast India region has been classified into ‘Severe’, ‘High’, ‘Moderate’ and ‘Non-liquefiable’ zones based on LPI distribution while the Liquefaction Risk map classified the terrain into ‘Low (IR≤20)', ‘High (20<IR≤30)’ and ‘Extremely High (IR>30)’  Risk zones. The results of this investigation are very useful to identify liquefaction susceptible areas, as well as for future development and planning of cities against liquefaction failure.

     Keywords: Northeast India, Liquefaction, Factor of Safety, Liquefaction Potential Index, Liquefaction Risk Index, Landslide Susceptibility.

    How to cite: Madan, J., Nath, S. K., and Srivastava, A.: Liquefaction Potential Assessment of Northeast India Region: Its earthquake and deterministic scenario, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11104, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11104, 2022.

    EGU22-11477 | Presentations | NH9.8 | Highlight

    Numerical Calculations & Scenario Reconstruction of the 7th Feb'21, Chamoli Event-In Terms of Velocity-Energy and Sediment-Water Amount Changes 

    Shobhana Lakhera, Michel Jaboyedoff, Marc-Henri Derron, and Ajanta Goswami

    Rock falls, rock slides and rock avalanches occurring in glaciated environments and permafrost regions are characterized by their sudden and complex character, high magnitude-mobility and cascading secondary hazards. The flow mobility is enhanced by the presence of ice and snow by up to 25% to 30%, with respect to rock avalanches of comparable magnitude evolving in non-glacial settings. Their dynamics are controlled by interaction between the detached rock and the icy component during all phases of motion, from initiation to the final deposition (Sosio et al., 2015).  The 7th Feb'21 catastrophe in the Upper part of the Chamoli district of Uttarakhand, India was one such event that impacted the catchments of Ronti Gad, Rishiganga and Dhauliganga valleys by a high magnitude debris flow, triggered by a massive rock-ice slide of 25-27 million cubic meters (ICIMOD, 2021; Pandey et al., 2021; Thaiyan et al., 2021; Shugar et al., 2021). The initial rockslide entrained glacier ice and continued as a rock-ice avalanche which fluidized along the path, evolving into a massive debris flow, traversing 21-22 km downstream in around 16 to 18 minutes (ICIMOD, 2021; Pandey et al., 2021; Thaiyan et al., 2021; Shugar et al., 2021). It destroyed two hydroelectric projects (HEP) enroute, and killed more than 100 workers at the Tapovan HEP. This also led to the formation of the lake at the confluence of Ronti Gad and Rishiganga and a small lake was also observed at the confluence of Rishiganga and Dhauliganga, which was instantaneously breached. This event accentuated the fragility of the Indian Himalayas and its complex periglacial terrain.

    In the present work, we try to numerically and conceptually reconstruct the cascade from the initial rockslide to 21 km downstream, till the Tapovan HEP. We segmented the flow path into four major sections based on: i) gradient changes; ii) observed flow physical parameters; iii) channel characteristics; iv) erosion-deposition and entrainment. For each of the four sections, we present the section wise peak velocity and energy calculations based on the fundamental Voellmy-Perla equations and present the result as profile graphs to better understand the velocity-energy changes along the longitudinal profile of the flow path. Next, we estimate the section wise sediment-rock to water amount at the end of each section, using pre-post DEM profile-differencing, satellite images and field data, based on certain logical assumptions. Thus, proposing the plausible stepwise processes and sediment-water interaction as occurred on the morning of 7th Feb'21. The results, hence obtained were found to be in-line with the available literature and were able to logically justify the so-far-known event parameters. Future work is intended on better validation of the obtained results by using flow models. Thus, aiming to better comprehend and understand such events in the complex Himalayan terrain and being able to predict and mitigate them in the future.

    Keywords: Rockslides, rock falls, rock avalanches, debris flows, hydroelectric projects, Indian Himalayas, Glacier, Climate change

    How to cite: Lakhera, S., Jaboyedoff, M., Derron, M.-H., and Goswami, A.: Numerical Calculations & Scenario Reconstruction of the 7th Feb'21, Chamoli Event-In Terms of Velocity-Energy and Sediment-Water Amount Changes, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11477, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11477, 2022.

    The Himalayan region is a seismically active belt of arc length 2400 km extends spatially from Indus river valley (western region) to Brahmaputra river valley (eastern region) India. The Central Himalayan region, along with its neighboring area is known to be the part of the `Alpine-Himalayan global seismic belt', a seismically active area of the world. In the past (1897, 1905, 1934, and 1950) four great earthquakes have triggered in this region with a magnitude higher than M =8.0. The 2015 (M = 7.8) Gorkha Nepal earthquakes call attention to the need for a more accurate understanding of seismic characteristics in the Central Himalayan region. In the present study, analysis of spatial variation of seismic activity in the Central Himalayas covering the Indian state of Himachal Pradesh, Uttarakhand and Western part of Nepal is done by analyzing the variation of seismic parameters and fractal dimension (Dc) using the updated and homogeneous earthquake catalogue of the study area. Considering the earthquake distribution and tectonic features, the central Himalayas is divided into 12 seismic source zones. For the comparison of the seismicity between each seismic source zone, seismic parameters such as seismic activity rate (λ), maximum possible earthquake magnitude (Mmax), and `b-value' are calculated. The b value varies from 0.7 to 1.05 in the study area and clustering of seismic event is prominent in western part of Nepal The seismotectonic stress variations in Central Himalayas are indicated by the estimated values of b and Dc. The calculated seismic parameters can be used directly for seismic hazard analysis of the study area.

    Keywords: Seismicity; Himalayas; Fractal Dimension; Frequency Magnitude Distribution

    How to cite: Kumar, S. and Sengupta, A.: Analyzing The Seismic Behavior of Central Himalayan Region Using Frequency Magnitude Distribution and Fractal Dimension, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12715, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12715, 2022.

    EGU22-135 | Presentations | NH9.2

    Characterizing social vulnerability for climate impact assessment at global scale 

    Lena Reimann, Elco Koks, Hans de Moel, and Jeroen Aerts

    Every year, extreme events caused by climate-related hazards result in severe impacts globally. These impacts are expected to increase in the future due to both climate change and population growth in exposed locations. However, impacts are not only driven by exposure to extreme events, but also by the population’s vulnerability to these hazards, determined by individual characteristics such as age, gender, and income. Thus far, global-scale climate risk assessments account for social vulnerability to a limited degree. To address this gap, we produce spatially explicit global datasets of variables that can be used for characterizing social vulnerability. We further combine these data into a globally consistent and spatially explicit Social Vulnerability Index (SoVI), which will be made publicly available along with the input variables. To explore the value of the SoVI in characterizing social vulnerability, we validate it with the observed impacts (e.g., fatalities, damages) of past extreme events. To do so, we overlay the spatial vulnerability characteristics with recently published flood maps of observed flooding events across the globe, also testing how each vulnerability variable performs individually in explaining the observed impacts. Our analysis helps to develop a more in-depth understanding of the characteristics that drive social vulnerability globally, along with their spatial distribution. Therefore, our results can support decision-making in developing strategies that reduce social vulnerability to climate-related hazards, for instance related to spatial planning, socioeconomic development, and adaptation.

    How to cite: Reimann, L., Koks, E., de Moel, H., and Aerts, J.: Characterizing social vulnerability for climate impact assessment at global scale, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-135, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-135, 2022.

    EGU22-1073 | Presentations | NH9.2

    Scenarios of social-environmental extremes 

    Gabriele Messori, Maria Rusca, and Giuliano Di Baldassarre

    In a rapidly changing world, what is today an unprecedented environmental extreme event may soon become the norm. Such unprecedented events, and the related disasters, will likely have highly unequal socio-economic impacts. We investigate the relation between genesis of unprecedented events, accumulation and distribution of risk, and recovery trajectories across different societal groups, thus conceptualising the events as social-environmental extremes. We specifically propose an analytical approach to unravel the complexity of future extremes and multiscalar societal responses-from households to national governments and from immediate impacts to longer term recovery. This combines the physical characteristics of the extremes with examinations of how culture, politics, power and policy visions shape societal responses to unprecedented events. As end result, we build scenarios of how different societal groups may be affected by, and recover from, plausible future unprecedented extreme events. This new approach, at the nexus between social and natural sciences, has the concrete advantage of providing an impact-focused vision of future social-environmental risks, beyond what is achievable within conventional disciplinary boundaries. In this presentation I will illustrate an application to a future extreme flooding event in Houston. However, the approach is flexible and applicable to a wide range of extreme events.

     

    How to cite: Messori, G., Rusca, M., and Di Baldassarre, G.: Scenarios of social-environmental extremes, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1073, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1073, 2022.

    EGU22-2691 | Presentations | NH9.2

    Public perceptions of flood and drought risk: Gender differences in Italy and Sweden 

    Elena Mondino, Elena Raffetti, and Giuliano Di Baldassarre

    Hydrological extremes still cause severe damage worldwide. Understanding people’s perceptions of drought and flood risk, and their changes over time, can help researchers, practitioners, and policymakers assist communities at risk. In particular, identifying and highlighting gender differences in the perception of hydrological risk is fundamental to promote fair disaster risk reduction policies which take such differences into account. To this end, we collected national survey data three times over a year on risk perception, knowledge, and preparedness in regard to floods and droughts in Italy and Sweden. Preliminary results show that: i) the perceptions of drought and flood risk are heavily intertwined; and ii) women show a higher fluctuation in perception over time compared to men, especially when it comes to floods. These results and their implications show how important it is to integrate gender into the management of floods and drought and into risk communication, as well as to promote policies that simultaneously address flood and drought risk.

    How to cite: Mondino, E., Raffetti, E., and Di Baldassarre, G.: Public perceptions of flood and drought risk: Gender differences in Italy and Sweden, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2691, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2691, 2022.

    EGU22-5347 | Presentations | NH9.2

    Typologies of community risk to climate change: fostering climate adaption networks 

    Nils Riach and Rüdiger Glaser

    Adapting to the effects of climate change will increasingly become a task of municipal planning and implementation in the coming years. This ranges from the consideration of increasing heat days to the retention of heavy rainfall. Climate related hazards, together with their dynamic interplay of exposure and vulnerability pose considerable adverse consequences for municipalities and need to be addressed through risk management plans. While this is understood in research and is increasingly being implemented in cities, it is found that particularly small and medium-sized municipalities often lack (1) the necessary evidence base for planning, (2) adequate capacities to engage in adaptation, and (3) practical analytical tools and informal planning instruments for adapting to the unavoidable consequences of climate change. Identifying communities that are similarly impacted and thus show comparable adaption needs can help local stakeholders in forming climate adaption networks. Here they can pool resources, develop solutions and exchange knowledge on the highly contextual challenges of climate change adaptation.

    We derive cluster based typologies of communities in the German state of Baden-Württemberg, which show assimilable characteristics in climatic hazards, exposure and vulnerability.   While cluster analysis is often used to differentiate patterns of climate change, few assessments have included societal variables. We therefore couple a ten-member regional climate model ensemble (RCP8.5, 1971-2000, 2021-2050, 2071-2100) with socio-economic data in so-called bivariate climate impact maps. This allows for statewide community specific conclusions on climate related risks. Statistical cluster analysis enables grouping of communities based on similar risks and adaption needs. Our approach provides a data driven basis for so-called climate adaption networks, which may foster the implementation of communal adaption efforts.

    How to cite: Riach, N. and Glaser, R.: Typologies of community risk to climate change: fostering climate adaption networks, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5347, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5347, 2022.

    EGU22-5537 | Presentations | NH9.2

    Gender and social inclusion in disaster risk reduction and management: Key learning and effective practices 

    Alison Sneddon, Mirianna Budimir, Sarah Brown, and Issy Nelder

    Resilience to natural hazards varies widely within and between populations. People living in the same area affected by the same hazard event will experience it differently depending on their specific vulnerabilities and capacities. The social inequalities which drive differential resilience vary based on the norms of a given context, but result in resources being harder for some people to reach and use than others.

    These inequalities are often invisible in traditional data, and therefore the needs of the most vulnerable are not addressed in disaster risk reduction and management policy and practice. The impacts of disasters therefore reinforce and worsen existing inequalities as already vulnerable people are left further and further behind.

    This presentation will focus on new learning about the relationship between gender and social vulnerabilities and resilience to natural hazard-related disasters in a range of contexts with three key aims:

    • To share key learning about differential disaster resilience and requirements of early warning and disaster risk management implementation
    • To explore key tools which have been piloted, tested, and developed to improve knowledge and understanding of resilience
    • To discuss effective and practical ways to apply these tools going forward in research, policy, and practice.

    The presentation will draw on experiences and findings from projects conducted in the Philippines, Bangladesh, Malawi, Nepal, and Dominica to research gender and social inclusion in relation to early warning systems, disaster preparedness and response, and disaster risk financing.

    The session will examine the drivers of social inequalities and their impacts relating to risk knowledge, monitoring and warning, communication and dissemination, and response capability, sharing examples of the different needs, considerations, and priorities relating to early warning and disaster risk management within communities.

    We’ll then explore approaches to data layering and our Missing Voices methodology as key tools to identify and understand factors, including intersectional factors, influencing social and economic resilience to natural hazards.

    How to cite: Sneddon, A., Budimir, M., Brown, S., and Nelder, I.: Gender and social inclusion in disaster risk reduction and management: Key learning and effective practices, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5537, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5537, 2022.

    EGU22-6022 | Presentations | NH9.2

    Forensic disaster analysis of the 2021 summer floods in Western Germany, Belgium and the Netherlands – Findings from the PERC study 

    Viktor Rözer, Jonathan Ulrich, Michael Szönyi, Francisco Ianni, Finn Laurien, Teresa Deubelli, Karen MacClune, and Rachel Norton

    Severe flooding in Western Germany, Belgium and the Netherlands in July 2021, particularly along the rivers Erft, Ahr and Meuse rivers has led to more than 240 causalities and an estimated damage of 29,2 billion EUR in Germany alone. The high human and economic costs of the event brought systemic problems in the flood risk management system to light and raised questions about the limits of disaster risk management and climate change adaptation. Using a forensic disaster analysis approach, the Post Event Review Capability (PERC), we systematically analyse the strengths and weaknesses of the flood risk management systems in the affected regions, the emergency response and recovery to draw lessons for future disaster risk management and climate change adaptation strategies. For that, PERC synthesizes existing information about the event from the hydro-meteorological characteristics of the physical impact and combines it with qualitative interviews with first responders, flood risk managers and other directly affected stakeholders. We will present key findings from the PERC study on the 2021 floods including the main drivers behind the high casualties and potential shortcomings in the emergency response and recovery as well as recommendations and opportunities for improvement.

    How to cite: Rözer, V., Ulrich, J., Szönyi, M., Ianni, F., Laurien, F., Deubelli, T., MacClune, K., and Norton, R.: Forensic disaster analysis of the 2021 summer floods in Western Germany, Belgium and the Netherlands – Findings from the PERC study, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6022, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6022, 2022.

    Denmark is one of the most vulnerable countries in Europe with respect to increasing risk of sea surges. A two hundred year paradigm of land reclamation close to the sea must therefore be revisited with the intent of retaining flexibility and avoiding lock-ins while recognizing the unintended consequences of new adaptation strategies. Potential solutions continue to face considerable structural, spatial, temporal and definitional challenges requiring collaboration between communities, local actors and scientists. In the “Cities and rising sea levels” project scientists from different research disciplines including (landscape) architecture, regional and local planning, and hydrology collaborate with local actors in order to tackle these challenges. The aim is to establish a common terminology and identify common scenarios, strategies, and indicators of successful and less successful urban developments in coastal areas over space and time.

     

    One of the objectives in the project is to establish a coherent, spatially explicit framework for assessing strategies for sustainable urban development (SUD) of coastal communities to facilitate mediation and decision-making for stakeholders involved in adaptation and urban planning processes. As a starting point, our study identified a total of >2200 indicators across 50 references on SUD and respective additional >1600 indicators across 28 references on coastal adaptation. By means of systemic reviews and analyses, the study builds upon previous reviews on indicators and expands beyond by laying a clear focus on sustainable adaptation in coastal areas.

     

    Extracted indicators sets of SUD and coastal adaptation are compared and similarities as well as differences are pointed out and analysed. Interestingly none of the identified indicators of SUD include a direct representation of climate risks or determinants of risk i.e. vulnerability and exposure, neither as conceptual variables driving risk, nor the assessment of adaptive capacity. At the same time, indicators of coastal adaptation disregard liveability and human wellbeing as crucial aspects of urban planning, in contrast to SUD indicators where they represent guiding principles. This illustrates a clear gap between adaptation practices and other professions involved in urban planning processes.

     

    In order to uncover sustainable pathways to adapt, adaptation must be an integral part of sustainable development. The study aims at understanding differences in performance assessments and to suggest steps forward to better integrate SUD and coastal adaptation. Here, the study will proceed by operationalizing a combined and integrated indicator framework in the form of spatio-temporal assessments. The first results of these assessments will be presented and synergies and tradeoffs between a risk lens and SUD will be highlighted.

    How to cite: Eggert, A., Arnbjerg-Nielsen, K., and Löwe, R.: Comparative Analysis of Indicators for Sustainable Urban Development and Coastal Adaptation - Uncovering Barriers and Potentials of Integrated Assessments, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6341, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6341, 2022.

    EGU22-6600 | Presentations | NH9.2

    Psychosocial response to risk mitigation measures in Iceland 

    Stephanie Matti, Helga Ögmundardottír, Guðfinna Aðalgeirsdóttir, and Uta Reichardt

    Land use planning has been espoused as a key measure to decrease the risk of climate change-relatd disasters including landslides, however there is a dearth of research on how it affects the psychosocial wellbeing of affected people. This ethnographic study examines the risk management of the Svínafellsheiði fracture in south-east Iceland, where 60 to 100 million cubic metres of debris is predicted to fall onto the glacier below, and cause flooding from or a tsunami in the proglacial lake. A no-build zone was put in place between 2018 and 2020 to prevent a further increase in the number of people exposed to the hazard. Our results indicate that the no-build zone had both direct and indirect adverse effects on the psychosocial wellbeing of those affected. It caused frustration about a perceived inability to make changes to home and businesses, people feeling that their future was in limbo or on hold, and people questioning their future in the area. These direct psychosocial effects also had the knock-on effect of causing people to talk more about the risk, thereby undermining a key coping mechanism. 

     

    How to cite: Matti, S., Ögmundardottír, H., Aðalgeirsdóttir, G., and Reichardt, U.: Psychosocial response to risk mitigation measures in Iceland, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6600, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6600, 2022.

    EGU22-10272 | Presentations | NH9.2

    Structuring citizens’ risk perception and knowledge of flooding events for planning purposes: The case study of Brindisi, Italy 

    Stefania Santoro, Vincenzo Totaro, Ruggiero Lovreglio, Domenico Camarda, Vito Iacobellis, and Umberto Fratino

    The effects of flooding on urban environment and social vulnerability are challenging issues in flood risk management and long-term planning. Flood risk is among the main causes of social crisis, as it can drastically affect the socioeconomic status of a community and an increase in flood events can significantly inhibit the political system of land and emergency management, social security, human welfare, and the economy.

    In recent decades, several studies have illustrated how the probability of occurrence of a flood event can be modified by human-dependent factors, such as, among others, climate and land-use changes. 

    For this reason, flood risk management policies are evolving to redirect the actions of policymakers from purely physical defensive measures toward integrated management and planning strategies, placing greater emphasis on the complexity of the interaction between social and physical processes.

    The complexity of physical processes lies in the wide variety of underlying phenomena that produce different types of flooding, while that of social processes can be reconducted to their characterization, given by human-related factors such as risk perception, emotions, bonds, context, and behaviors. Structuring the complexity of these two systems could support flood risk to define the elements/classes of citizens that make a social system vulnerable.

    Based on these premises, the present work aims in modelling the relationship between flood risk and community, starting from an analysis of social perception and knowledge of protective measures, and exploiting a methodology based on an online survey used to collect data, and on Mann-Whitney and Kruskal-Wallis tests used for their analysis.

    The methodology was experimentally applied to the city of Brindisi (Puglia region, Southern Italy), which is potentially subject to floods of different nature, as fluvial, coastal and pluvial floods and dam overflows.

    The results suggest that perceptions of flood risk depend on intrinsic components of individuals, primarily related to dimensions of perception such as trust in public strategies and risk communication. Slightly higher perception emerged for those living in risk areas, but the results of the remainder show that there is a non-negligible perception even where there is apparently no source of risk. This is reflected in the varying nature of the flooding that has affected the city. The presence of disabled persons in the household does not act in any way neither in the perception nor in the knowledge of the measures; the previous experience seems to have little weight in reference to the perception and almost null on the knowledge of the measures. This element is probably linked to the temporal distance from the last event that caused serious damage to the community. Knowledge of protective measures appears to be uniformly low for each category of citizens and territorial area, in particular for adolescents, a recurring category also on other investigated dimensions.

    This work represents the first step for the development of a multi-agent model, as developed by the science of intelligent systems, able to analyze more deeply the relationships between natural and social systems and to bring out elements to support flood risk management.

    How to cite: Santoro, S., Totaro, V., Lovreglio, R., Camarda, D., Iacobellis, V., and Fratino, U.: Structuring citizens’ risk perception and knowledge of flooding events for planning purposes: The case study of Brindisi, Italy, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10272, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10272, 2022.

    EGU22-11200 | Presentations | NH9.2

    Inspecting the link between climate and human displacement with Explainable AI and Causal inference 

    José María Tárraga Habas, Michele Ronco, Maria Teresa Miranda, Eva Sevillano Marco, Qiang Wang, María Piles, Jordi Muñoz, and Gustau Camps-Valls

    On average, more than 21 million forced human displacements were reported as result of weather-related events between 2008 and 2020 worldwide. This is a major concern due to the increment trend in intensity and frequency of weather hazards. Breaking down the figures, the impact is more severe in low-middle income countries, where most of the natural hazards take place and adaptation strategies are lacking. Implementing efficient and operational policy responses requires a quantitative analysis of the nexus between climate-induced displacement. So far the study of this phenomenon has been often limited to qualitative assessments or to correlation measures from regression linear models, not accounting for the inherent complexity of the problem. The multicausal nature of human mobility and data availability present significant research challenges. We apply two methodological approaches that use machine-learning to close these gaps, namely addressing both rapid-onset (e.g. floods) and slow-onset (e.g. droughts) disaster types. The former uses the Internal Displacement Monitoring Centre (IDMC) global database of displacements triggered by floods and storms at disaster level, socioeconomic (RWI Meta Data4Good, Global Human Modification Layer, Education Expenditure), and Earth-Observation variables: meteorological (CHIRPS, ERA5) and environmental (NASA ASTER SRTM DEM, MODIS NDVI vegetation index). Explainable AI techniques enable to open the black box of random forest models and were applied at the global scale: Shapley values are used to investigate the contributions of the main drivers thereby quantitatively addressing the climate-displacement nexus. Results are consistent with the hazard, exposure and vulnerability concept discussed in literature and findings reveal that socioeconomic factors greatly mediate displacement magnitudes. The slow-onset study is being explored at the local scale at district level, currently focused on the effects of droughts on displaced populations in Somalia using UNCHR PRMN displacement dataset, remote sensing variables (CHIRPS, MODIS LST), conflict (ACLED) and market prices time-series (FSNAU, WFP VAM Unit). Beyond correlations analysis, causation alongside time-lag effects for the drivers of drought-induced displacement are assessed using the PCMCI algorithm. Results in specific districts indicate that decreases in vegetation in conjunction with cattle price drops are driving drought displacement, revealing these factors are in need for targeted intervention. Albeit the same method applied to other districts in Somalia returns no causal link among considered variables, taking these findings into account, we are able to propose district-wise recommendations on how to improve the quality of the data: eg. field data collection guidelines, what other data input is required, and where sampling efforts should be directed. 

    How to cite: Tárraga Habas, J. M., Ronco, M., Miranda, M. T., Sevillano Marco, E., Wang, Q., Piles, M., Muñoz, J., and Camps-Valls, G.: Inspecting the link between climate and human displacement with Explainable AI and Causal inference, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11200, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11200, 2022.

    EGU22-11251 | Presentations | NH9.2

    The use of impact chains and Bayesian Network Analysis to assess flood risk dynamics in the Lower Mono River Basin, Benin 

    Mario Wetzel, Lorina Schudel, Adrian Almoradie, Kossi Komi, Julien Adounkpe, Yvonne Walz, and Michael Hagenlocher

    River floods are a common and often devastating environmental hazard causing severe damages, loss of lives and livelihoods, notably for the most vulnerable. Understanding the root causes, drivers, patterns and dynamics of flood risks and associated uncertainties is important to inform adequate risk management. Yet, a lack of understanding the highly dynamic processes, interactions, uncertainties, and the inclusion of participatory methods and transdisciplinary approaches in risk assessments remains a limiting factor. In many flood-prone regions of the world, data scarcity poses another serious challenge for risk assessments. Addressing the above, we developed an impact chain via desk study and expert consultation to reveal key drivers of flood risk for agricultural livelihoods in the Lower Mono River Basin of Benin and their interlinkages – a region that is both highly prone to flooding and can be considered data-scarce. Particularly, the dynamic formation of vulnerability and its interplay with hazard and exposure components is highlighted.

    Based on a simplified version of the impact chain which was validated in a participatory manner during a virtual expert workshop, an alpha-level Bayesian Network was created to further explore these interactions. The model was applied to an exemplary what-if scenario for the study area in Benin. Based on the above, this study critically evaluates the benefits and limitations of integrating the two methodological approaches to better understand and simulate risk dynamics in data scarce environments. The study finds that impact chains are a useful approach to conceptualize interactions of risk drivers. Particularly in combination with a Bayesian Network approach the method enables an improved understanding of how different risk drivers interact within the system and allows for dynamic assessments of what-if scenarios, for example, to inform resilience building strategies.

    How to cite: Wetzel, M., Schudel, L., Almoradie, A., Komi, K., Adounkpe, J., Walz, Y., and Hagenlocher, M.: The use of impact chains and Bayesian Network Analysis to assess flood risk dynamics in the Lower Mono River Basin, Benin, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11251, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11251, 2022.

    EGU22-12884 | Presentations | NH9.2

    What can we learn from previous generations? Álftaver’s experience of the 1918 Katla eruption 

    Guðrún Gísladóttir, Deanne Bird, and Emmanuel Pagneux

    Residents in Álftaver, south Iceland, are very familiar with the 1918 Katla volcanic eruption, which caused rapid and catastrophic glacial outburst flooding of the area. Descriptions of the 1918 events, passed down by older generations, have become an important part of the collective memory. Based on oral and written history, this paper provides a vivid account, including detailed maps, of what people experienced and felt during the 1918 Katla eruption. It also considers how these experiences influence current-day perceptions and the impact this may have on behavior in relation to emergency response strategies. Until now, much of this history has only been accessible in Icelandic text and through oral stories. The aim of this paper is to unlock these stories for an international audience in an effort to advance understanding of volcanic eruptions and their impacts and, inform future emergency planning. Importantly, these descriptions tell us about the nature of the glacial outburst flood, with a ‘pre-flood’ devoid of ice and travelling at a much faster rate than the ice-laden main flood. As a future eruption of Katla may impact Álftaver, emergency response plans for glacial outburst floods were developed, and in March 2006 preliminary plans were tested in a full-scale evacuation exercise involving residents and emergency response groups. But Álftaver residents questioned the plans and were reluctant to follow evacuation orders during the exercise, as they felt their knowledge and the experience of their relatives during the 1918 Katla eruption, had not been taken into consideration. Residents were concerned that flood hazards, as well as tephra and lightning, were not appropriately accounted for by officials. In response to residents’ concerns, officials developed an alternative evacuation plan (Plan B) that builds on some of the experience and knowledge of Álftaver residents. However, residents were not involved in the development of ‘Plan B’ and they are not aware of what it constitutes or when it is to be implemented. This paper argues that more needs to be done to promote inclusive dialogue and the co-production of knowledge to ensure emergency response strategies adequately reflect and accommodate local knowledge, perspectives and planned behavior.

    How to cite: Gísladóttir, G., Bird, D., and Pagneux, E.: What can we learn from previous generations? Álftaver’s experience of the 1918 Katla eruption, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12884, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12884, 2022.

    EGU22-13432 | Presentations | NH9.2

    Revisiting risk in a multi-hazard setting: the case of Cyclone Amphan occurring within the COVID-19 pandemic in the Indian Sundarbans 

    Sumana Banerjee, Himanshu Shekhar, Davide Cotti, Edward Sparkes, Saskia Werners, and Michael Hagenlocher

    Amidst a period of complete lockdown due  to COVID-19, the severe cyclonic storm Amphan made landfall in the Indian Sundarbans on 20 May 2020. The occurrence of a cyclone during  the pandemic warranted investigation of interconnected risks and impacts in this climate hotspot and eco-critical region. Based on a desk study, field observations, key informant interviews and expert consultations, this research focussed on better understanding direct and cascading risks and the associated impacts from the concurrence of the two hazards occurring simultaneously. Our analysis reveals that although the region has not experienced a high number of COVID-cases between March and August 2020, the presence of underlying vulnerabilities exposed the population to cascading effects caused by the pandemic-induced lockdown along with the compounding effect of the Cyclone Amphan. In the Indian Sundarbans, COVID-19 acted as an exogenous shock, but its interplay with interconnected vulnerabilities resulted in the emergence of disruptions of a systemic nature. This was particularly the case in the economic domain, with cascading impacts observed across the welfare, education, and employment sectors.  Cyclone Amphan, led to additional cascading impacts on these sectors, and affected other sectors such as health and infrastructure as well as biodiversity. Interventions such as introduction of new social protection schemes and community participation in cyclone preparedness measures have helped the system from facing a total collapse. However, some interventions that were implemented to mitigate impacts of these two concurring hazards somewhat counteracted one another. For example, while stringent COVID-19 interventions stressed on safety norms (including social distancing and stay at home orders), the hazard response protocol for Cyclone Amphan directed communities to evacuate their homes and move to communal shelters which were being used as quarantine units for returning migrant workers till before the cyclone. This caused concerns among the evacuated population, thus undermining the efficacy of the response effort. This case study underpins the need for moving from hazard-by-hazard approaches of understanding and managing risks towards integrated approaches that consider interconnected vulnerabilities, risks and impacts based on a systems perspective. Further, it also provides lessons for risk management in a multi-hazard and multi-risk setting besides sharing recommendations for better risk management in the Indian Sundarbans.

    How to cite: Banerjee, S., Shekhar, H., Cotti, D., Sparkes, E., Werners, S., and Hagenlocher, M.: Revisiting risk in a multi-hazard setting: the case of Cyclone Amphan occurring within the COVID-19 pandemic in the Indian Sundarbans, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13432, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13432, 2022.

    EGU22-2641 | Presentations | NH1.6

    Investigating the relationships among vegetation characters, saturated hydraulic conductivity and surface morphology at catchment scale by integrating new field data and morphometric analysis 

    Lorenzo Marzini, Enrico D'Addario, Michele Pio Papasidero, Michele Amaddii, Leonardo Disperati, and Francesco Chianucci

    Shallow landslides susceptibility assessment by physically based methods relies on the parametrization of both hydraulic and geotechnical properties of soils, which in turn depend on the conditions of root structures and vegetation cover. Vegetation roots contribute to the shear strength of soils, but their quantitative contribution is currently uncertain. Saturated hydraulic conductivity (Ks) is also relevant for slope stability as it influences infiltration rates and runoff. While the literature clearly shows the dependence of Ks on soil texture, there is a general understatement of the role of root structures on this parameter. Moreover, the distribution patterns of vegetation follow relations with surface morphologies which are not fully understood and therefore, are worthy of further investigations. For these reasons, this work focuses on the quantitative assessment of the influence of vegetation on shear strength for shallow landsliding and the investigation of the relationships between vegetation characters, saturated hydraulic conductivity and topographic parameters. Study areas affected by shallow landslides are chosen in the Garfagnana and Alpi Apuane regions (Northern Apennines, Italy), as well as in the Mt. Amiata volcano area (Southern Tuscany, Italy), where field measurements of below-ground vegetation (Root Area Ratio - RAR), above-ground vegetation (Leaf Area Index - LAI and vegetation load) and Ks are acquired inside, in the neighbour and far from shallow landslide sites. To this aim, a multi-temporal landslide inventory is already available for the study area. Below-ground data are collected in trench profiles, while above-ground data are acquired by using a digital relascope as well as implementing vegetation cover photography methods. Measurements of Ks are carried out by means of both constant and falling head approaches. The morphometric analysis is performed by using some morphometric variables (eg. slope and hillslope curvatures) derived from a digital elevation model with cell size of 10 m. Morphometric clustering of these variables allows us to extract a set of land units where the distribution of vegetation characters and Ks are assessed. First results show that: a) root reinforcement to soil in terms of root-related cohesion plays a relevant role within the soil depths involved in shallow landslides; b) the weight of above-ground vegetation plays a “mild” negative role on slope stability; c) Ks is correlated with both RAR and soil depth, suggesting possible criteria for the straightforward parametrization of input parameters.

    How to cite: Marzini, L., D'Addario, E., Papasidero, M. P., Amaddii, M., Disperati, L., and Chianucci, F.: Investigating the relationships among vegetation characters, saturated hydraulic conductivity and surface morphology at catchment scale by integrating new field data and morphometric analysis, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2641, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2641, 2022.

    EGU22-2953 | Presentations | NH1.6 | Highlight

    Changes in pasture productivity may affect potential soil erosion under climate change. The case study of Mera watershed. 

    Daniele Bocchiola, Francesca Casale, and Leonardo Stucchi

    The Mera River watershed in the Rhaetian Alps, between Italy and Switzerland, is subject to distributed erosion, and soil degradation, affecting slope stability, and sediment transport in the river. In the future under climate change, erosion is projected to increase especially in winter, as due to larger rainfall share, and smaller snow accumulation. It is therefore necessary to develop best practices for the maintenance of slopes, such as terracing, to reduce erosion and soil loss in the area. We present the results of the recent GE.RI.KO Mera Interreg, and IPCC MOUPA projects.

    We first calibrate a hydrological model Poli-Hydro in the study area during 2010-2019, against discharge data, and snow cover area from satellite. Then a Dynamic-RUSLE (D-RUSLE) model is used to simulate spatially distributed soil erosion. The model considers snow melt/accumulation, and the year round dynamics of vegetation. Potential soil erosion is validated against sediment transport data taken in a sample station in the Mera River.

    The dynamics of snow cover is simulated using Poli-Hydro, while the C-factor of land cover is corrected using NDVI (Normalized Difference Vegetation Index) from satellite images, accounting for variable vegetation stages, and larger leaf cover (LAI) in summer. The C-factor is further corrected for pasture areas, using productivity data as calculated using the Poli-Pasture model, mimicking pasture growth and biomass productivity. We considered two index species for high/low altitudes, and inter-specific competition.

    We then project future scenarios of climate change, and impacts thereby. Six GCMs and four SSPs of the IPCC AR6 are used, to develop 24 climate change scenarios for precipitation and temperature. We also consider changes in CO2 concentration, and temperature increase, upon land cover, through variation of timberline and growing season. Based upon our results, conservative practices may be devised, to help improvement of pasture productivity, and reduce soil erosion.

    How to cite: Bocchiola, D., Casale, F., and Stucchi, L.: Changes in pasture productivity may affect potential soil erosion under climate change. The case study of Mera watershed., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2953, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2953, 2022.

    EGU22-4236 | Presentations | NH1.6 | Highlight

    Biopolymer soil stabilization as protection from slope erosion and shallow sliding 

    Josif Josifovski and Aleksandra Nikolovska Atanasovska

    Climate change has a significant impact on slope stability through atmospheric perturbations, water infiltration and soil erosion, which is often accompanied by local or shallow sliding of the slopes. Usually, the erosion is not seen as a stability-treating occurrence, but with time it can develop to a reduction of the shear soil strength and raise in the pore water pressure that can disturb the slope stability.

    In order to overcome these problems, it is necessary to introduce techniques for surface stabilization of soil slopes that increase erosion resistance and reduce surface water infiltration. Moreover, they have to be environmentally friendly, thus recommendations refer to the application of natural polymer compounds that do not pollute the environment, and at the same time represent an effective and economical measure for slope stabilization. Very often, as an additional measure in the application of these biopolymer solutions on the surfaces of the slopes, at the same time, the application of seeds from low and medium vegetation is performed. In the first months, the biopolymers form a bond between the solid soil particles, which increases the erosion resistance and reduces the ability to infiltrate and absorb surface water. In parallel, the biopolymer helps and accelerates the growth of vegetation to ensure long-term erosion and slope stability.

    The aim of the presented study was to investigate the effects of the xanthan gum as a compound and to develop an original biopolymer solution which will be later tested. The testing methodology was organized in two phases: laboratory tests on natural and biopolymer treated soil in the first phase, and experimental testing of biopolymer treated slope in the second phase.

    In the first phase, the classification and strength parameters of treated and untreated soil were determined through standard laboratory tests. The tests were performed on specimens with various percentages of the xanthan gum additive, moreover, specimens were tested on days 1, 7, and 14 to examine the curing effects. From the results, it was observed that Xanthan gum has significantly increased the strength of the soil, up to 50% after the 14 days of curing time.

    In the second phase, the erosion of treated and untreated soil was experimentally tested on the 1:1.5 slope during a rainfall of 10 liters per hour which was simulated for 180 minutes. The obtained results were better than expected showing a significant erosion resistance on the treated slope. During the 180 minutes of rainfall on the treated slope, there was no eroded soil registered. The Xanthan gum binder with a content of 1.0% filling the pores was able to limit the water infiltration into the soil, which improves interparticle cohesion and shows increased erosion resistance. In contrast, the amount of eroded soil on the untreated slope with an area of 1.0m2 was about 1900gr or soil erosion of 9.5%.

    Finally, from the study can be concluded that the proposed biopolymer is a natural-based solution for erosion control which has major potential because they represent efficient, economic and environmentally sustainable engineering solutions.

    How to cite: Josifovski, J. and Nikolovska Atanasovska, A.: Biopolymer soil stabilization as protection from slope erosion and shallow sliding, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4236, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4236, 2022.

    EGU22-4499 | Presentations | NH1.6 | Highlight

    Systematic comparison of definitions and aims between Soil and Water Bioengineering (SWB) and Nature-Based Solutions (NBS) 

    Federico Preti, Vittoria Capobianco, and Paola Sangalli

    Soil and Water Bioengineering (SWB) is a discipline established in the second half of XX century, finding its roots in ancient practices, which implies the use of vegetation and natural materials for natural hazards mitigation and ecosystem restoration. Nature-based solutions (NBS) is a recent collective term for solutions supported and/or inspired by nature to address climate-related challenges.

    Although NBS cover a wide range of approaches based or inspired by natural processes and have many objectives in common with SWB, almost no attempts have been done so far to find overlaps and differences, which is needed especially when definitions are linked to legislations and funding mechanisms.

    We present the results of a systematic comparison of NBS definitions, and other terminologies that fall under the NBS concept, with the definition of SWB. First, we identified applications that are related to the NBS umbrella concept, with their relative definitions, with a special focus on flood risk mitigation, ecosystem restoration, landslide and erosion mitigation. The applications analysed include: Watershed Management or hydraulic-forestry arrangements (WM), Nature-based Solutions (NBS), Green/blue Infrastructure (GI), Urban Forestry (UF), Ecological Engineering (EE), as well as Ecosystem-based Disaster Risk Reduction (Eco-DRR).

    Secondly, a comparison matrix was proposed and developed. The matrix was developed by comparing the main aspects of SWB practice with the aims of the other NBS-related applications.

    The structure of the matrix was the following:

    • each row represents each of the 3 main aspects of SWB practices: namely "main aims", "fields of application" and "other objectives";
    • the matrix columns designate all the other NBS-related terminologies, named above.

    The three main aspects of the SWB discipline cover the following:

    • main aims: the four main objectives of SWB; namely: technical, ecological, landscape and socio-economic objectives.
    • fields of application: main domains of applications and fields of interventions;
    • other objectives: the multi-purpose functions exerted by SWB.

    Excerpts from relevant peer-review and grey literature on NBS were included in the matrix to cross-check the 3 main aspects of the SWB practice. We observed that SWB approaches have at least 2 "aims" in common with all the terms, particularly that all 3 main aspects are covered by the NBS definitions. In terms of "fields of application", the highest number of similarities are found between SWB and EE, and, to a smaller extent, WM, GBI and Eco-DRR.

    In this work we conclude that SWB discipline can be recognized as a concept falling under the NBS unifying concept to prioritise nature to integrate climate change adaptation, mitigation and disaster reduction efforts. SWB overlaps and, in some cases, compliments many NBS-related terminologies. Thus, SWB can and should be recognized as having always been an NBS.

    How to cite: Preti, F., Capobianco, V., and Sangalli, P.: Systematic comparison of definitions and aims between Soil and Water Bioengineering (SWB) and Nature-Based Solutions (NBS), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4499, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4499, 2022.

    EGU22-4768 | Presentations | NH1.6 | Highlight

    The implementation and effectiveness of vegetative barriers to regulate fluxes of runoff and sediment in open agricultural landscapes (Flanders, Belgium) 

    Alexia Stokes, Maarten De Boever, Jonas Bodyn, Saskia Buysens, Liesbet Rosseel, Sarah Deprez, Charles Bielders, Aurore Degré, and Amaury Frankl

    Abstract:

    Vegetative barriers are narrow strips of plants or plant residues that are increasingly being used as measures to reduce the connectivity of catchments in terms of water and sediment fluxes (Frankl et al., 2021a). They can mostly be found at plot edges where they do not hinder farming activities too much. Their principal function is to reduce sediment export from cropland and thus mitigate negative off-site effects of erosion (e.g. muddy floods, pollution of rivers). Being implemented in concentrated flow zones where ephemeral gullying is recurrent, they also prevent their development (Frankl et al., 2018). Although vegetative barriers are increasingly being implemented in open agricultural areas, little information is available on the effectiveness of vegetation barriers at buffering the flows of water and sediment. Here, we focus on vegetative barriers that are widely implemented in Flanders (Belgium) and which are made of straw bales, wood chips or bales of coconut fibre. Based on three simulated runoff experiments performed in the field, we calculated the hydraulic roughness and sediment deposition ratio. Our experiments show that the barriers made of coconut-fibre bales performed markedly better than those of straw bales or wood chips (Frankl et al., 2021b). However, as vegetative barriers have to be renewed every few years because of the decomposition of organic material, barriers made of locally available materials are more sustainable as a nature-based solution to erosion. We conclude that the vegetative barriers are an effective way of mitigating the negative effects of soil erosion. While barriers made of coconut-fibre bales are superior in their regulation of flows of runoff and sediment, barriers made of locally sourced materials are more sustainable.

     

    Keywords: agriculture, erosion control, hydrological connectivity, runoff, sediment

     

    References:

    Frankl, et al. (2021a) Gully prevention and control: Techniques, failures and effectiveness. Earth Surf. Process. Landforms: 46: 220– 238. https://doi.org/10.1002/esp.5033.

    Frankl, A., et al. (2021b). Report on the effectiveness of vegetative barriers to regulate simulated fluxes of runoff and sediment in open agricultural landscapes (Flanders, Belgium). Land Degrad. Dev. 32: 4445– 4449. https://doi.org/10.1002/ldr.4048

    Frankl, A. et al. (2018). The success of recent land management efforts to reduce soil erosion in northern France. Geomorphology 303: 84–93. doi:10.1016/j.geomorph.2017.11.018

     

    How to cite: Stokes, A., De Boever, M., Bodyn, J., Buysens, S., Rosseel, L., Deprez, S., Bielders, C., Degré, A., and Frankl, A.: The implementation and effectiveness of vegetative barriers to regulate fluxes of runoff and sediment in open agricultural landscapes (Flanders, Belgium), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4768, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4768, 2022.

    EGU22-7386 | Presentations | NH1.6

    Developing Novel Geophysical Tools to Investigate Urban Vegetated Soil Moisture Dynamics 

    Narryn Thaman, Ross Stirling, and Jonathan E. Chambers

    Vegetation is an important tool for managing urban surface water and shallow geotechnical assets. However, root water uptake driven changes in slope hydrology (soil water content, matric suction, and hydraulic conductivity) are poorly understood in heterogeneous soils and under extreme climatic conditions. Slope stability is affected by intrinsic factors, including geometry, soil properties, groundwater and vegetation driven matric suction. Field evidence indicates that engineered slopes are susceptible to hydrometeorological slope instability mechanisms and that these pose a potential failure hazard to asset operation and public safety. The UK hosts 15,800 km of railway network and 7100 km of strategic road network, accounting for 49,000 slopes. This is a significant portfolio of slopes that must be managed and maintained at considerable expense.

    To better understand the influence of vegetation on soil water dynamics in geotechnical infrastructure, Electrical Resistivity Tomography (ERT) is being used. ERT is a non-invasive tool for measuring and imaging subsurface soil moisture dynamics volumetrically. ERT can be used to quantitatively establish how the presence of roots influences transient soil moisture content and suction to assess the effectiveness of vegetation in managing slope hydrology and excess surface water issues in the built environment. This research aims to use 4-D ERT to determine the impact of vegetation on the hydrological behaviour of a high plasticity clay derived sub-soil used in the construction of infrastructure slopes in the southern half of the UK. Laboratory-scale experiments are underway at the UK National Green Infrastructure Facility, Newcastle, using a controlled environment chamber. A suite of soil columns is planted with vegetation, False Oat Grass (Arrhenatherum elatius) and Common Bent (Agrostis capillaris) and feature a 3D ERT electrode array and point sensors for measurement of volumetric water content, matric suction, and electrical conductivity throughout the profile. Through frequent imaging of soil-water-plant interactions and correlation with destructive root architecture imaging, this research aims to highlight how these relationships change over time and respond to extreme weather conditions (drought/inundation) to better predict, manage, and mitigate the occurrence of slope failure. Furthermore, the work aims to improve understanding of vegetation-driven soil moisture movement in the near-surface to better assess seasonal and longer-term slope stability to inform asset management strategies.

    How to cite: Thaman, N., Stirling, R., and Chambers, J. E.: Developing Novel Geophysical Tools to Investigate Urban Vegetated Soil Moisture Dynamics, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7386, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7386, 2022.

    EGU22-7965 | Presentations | NH1.6

    Modelling the effects of NBS adoption in mitigating soil losses of a land reclamation area in the Massaciuccoli lake catchment (Central Italy) 

    Antonio Pignalosa, Nicola Silvestri, Francesco Pugliese, Carlo Gerundo, Alfonso Corniello, Nicola Del Seppia, Massimo Lucchesi, Nicola Coscini, and Francesco De Paola

    Many types of Nature-Based Solutions (NBSs) have been applied worldwide to mitigate impacts of hydro-meteorological hazards produced by anthropic activities such as grazing and agriculture. Among them, vegetated buffer strips (VBSs) and winter cover crops (WCCs) are suitable solutions for reducing runoff and soil erosion rates from cultivated fields. However, their mitigating effects depends largely on local conditions such as morphology and soil nature.

    This study investigated these aspects by modelling the NBS effects on soil and water dynamics in two test sites located within the Massaciuccoli agricultural plain (Vecchiano, Pisa, Central Italy) and characterised by different soil types (peaty and silty soils). The SWAT+ model has been chosen to simulate hydraulic and hydrological phenomena using high-resolution data such as digital terrain models (DTMs) from close-range photogrammetry, detailed land cover mapping, actual crop rotations, and detailed calendars of agronomic operations. We considered two types of NBSs: i) 3 m wide VBSs planted along both sides of field ditches, covering about 10% of the agricultural land, and ii) WCCs sowed after harvesting summer cash crops. Both NBSs exert their action on 30% of the experimental area. The mitigating effect was tested by comparing simulation results from NBS and control (conventional agriculture) scenarios under ongoing climatic conditions and future climate changes.

    Results indicated that VBSs and WCCs showed different capabilities to reduce runoff and sediment losses, and the adoption of both can enhance the mitigation effect significantly. NBSs resulted effective also in completely flat areas since slight topographic irregularities can cause local preferential flows resulting in high runoff rate and sediment losses. Furthermore, it is demonstrated how the soil variability in texture and organic matter content can affect the amount of runoff and sediment loss on a local scale. Consequently, the mitigating effects of NBS can be closely driven by the soil nature and heterogeneity. This influence is even more significant under extreme climatic conditions such as higher temperatures and more aggressive rainfall events. In these cases, NBSs can play an essential role in mitigating runoff and soil erosion phenomena on fine-textured mineral soils. In contrast, they lose much of their effectiveness on peat soils.

    How to cite: Pignalosa, A., Silvestri, N., Pugliese, F., Gerundo, C., Corniello, A., Del Seppia, N., Lucchesi, M., Coscini, N., and De Paola, F.: Modelling the effects of NBS adoption in mitigating soil losses of a land reclamation area in the Massaciuccoli lake catchment (Central Italy), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7965, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7965, 2022.

    EGU22-8523 | Presentations | NH1.6

    Stress path effects on the shearing behaviour of root-reinforced soils 

    Anthony Leung and Ali Akbar Karimzadeh

    Plant roots increase soil shear strength. The increase primarily depends on the relative direction of the root orientation and the principal strains/stresses of the rooted soils. Most of the published work focused on the direct-shear behaviour of rooted soil, of which both the magnitude and direction of the principal stresses could not be controlled nor measured. Indeed, in the scenario of slopes, the stress path experienced by direct-shear soil samples and the associated shear strength parameters (e.g. cohesion and friction angle) derived are only relevant to the soil elements that are sheared in the direction parallel to the slope. The shearing behaviour of rooted soil following other stress paths, such as triaxial compression (near slope crest) and triaxial extension (near slope toe), have rarely been investigated. In this study, we conduct a comprehensive laboratory test campaign to study the effects of stress paths on the shearing behaviour including stress-strain (hardening and softening) on coarse-grained soils reinforced by the roots of vetiver grass (Chrysopogon zizanioides). Root-reinforced soil samples prepared to different root volume ratios (RVR; defined as the ratio of total root volume to total specimen volume) were subjected to undrained triaxial compression and extension stress paths at different confining stresses. We will present key experimental evidence to demonstrate how the different stress paths and RVRs affect the stress–strain behaviour of the soil. We will also present the effects of stress path on cohesion and friction angle and discuss the strength anisotropy of the rooted soils. The new test results will shed light on the selection of plants of desirable root architecture at different slope locations (i.e. crest, mid-slope, toe) to maximise the root reinforcement effects to shallow soils.

    How to cite: Leung, A. and Karimzadeh, A. A.: Stress path effects on the shearing behaviour of root-reinforced soils, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8523, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8523, 2022.

    EGU22-9004 | Presentations | NH1.6

    Do Vegetation Root Systems Affect Landslide Mobility? A Flume Experiment 

    Rozaqqa Noviandi, Takashi Gomi, Roy C. Sidle, Rasis P. Ritonga, and Yuko Hasunuma

    Landslides are common natural hazards that greatly impact lives and property worldwide. The magnitude of landslide impacts depends strongly on how far landslide sediments travel, widely known as landslide mobility. Numerous studies showed that landslide mobility is complex, but largely affected by initial water content during landslide initiation. Here, water acts as a medium that carries the collapsed landslide mass downslope. Vegetation root systems may alter the initial water content by modifying the flow path within the soil. The mechanical reinforcement of root systems may also limit the spatial propagation of the landslide mass. Thus, vegetation root systems may exert significant effects on landslide mobility. Nevertheless, effects of root systems on landslide mobility have rarely been discussed in landslide studies. The objective of this study is to evaluate the effect of rooting systems on landslide mobility.

    A flume constructed at a 1:70 scale was used to evaluate the effect of root systems on landslide mobility. The flume consisted of two segments representing landslide initiation (120 cm long, 35° inclination) and deposition (150 cm long, 35° inclination). All segments were 80 cm wide, 15 cm high, and constructed with 1-cm thick acrylic material. Sand (density=1.4 g/cm3, D50=0.23 mm) was placed in the initiation segment to a depth of 10 cm. For conditions with vegetation (V), we grew pea (Pisum sativum L.) bean sprouts in the sand to simulate the root system. Sprouts were grown at 3 cm intervals for two weeks to simulate the root system on 2200 stem/ha of Japanese cedar forest. To initiate landslides, 90 mm/h of rainfall was applied via nozzles installed at 2 m above the flume. Timing of landslide initiation was then measured. Water content was also measured by TDR sensors installed at 3 and 7 cm depths below the soil surface. The L/H ratio was estimated based on total travel distance and total descent height of the landslide mass.

    Vegetated conditions (V; n=3) were more stable than non-vegetated conditions (NV; n=3). Indeed, landslides initiated at 889-959 s (SD=41 s) on V, while on NV was 510-519 s (SD=5 s). Mean volumetric water content during landslide initiation was 0.2-0.22 (SD=0.01) on V, while on NV was 0.16-0.2 (SD=0.02). Because V had higher water content than NV, V was 1.2-1.4 times more mobile than NV. The L/H was 2.2-2.4 (SD=0.09) on V, while on NV it was 1.7-1.8 (SD=0.06). In general, vegetation root systems maintain slope stability by adding more cohesion to soils. Due to this reinforcement, greater gravitational forces and pore water pressure are needed to destabilize the slope. This consequently elevates the threshold of water content for landslide initiation. Since water content greatly influences mobility, wetter conditions enhance the mobility of the collapsed landslide mass. Our findings concur with previous studies that root reinforcement can mitigate slope instability. However, we highlight that such reinforcement can also enhance the mobility, which may elevate the potential impacts of landslides. We further investigate the effect of various stem densities on landslide mobility.

    How to cite: Noviandi, R., Gomi, T., Sidle, R. C., Ritonga, R. P., and Hasunuma, Y.: Do Vegetation Root Systems Affect Landslide Mobility? A Flume Experiment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9004, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9004, 2022.

    EGU22-9254 | Presentations | NH1.6

    Roots mechanical effects on hydraulic riverbanks erosion and on shallow landslides: tools for the protection forest management along channels 

    Marceline Vuaridel, Massimiliano Schwarz, Virginia Ruiz-Villanueva, Paolo Perona, and Denis Cohen

    Bern University of Applied Sciences, School of Agricultural, Forest and Food Sciences, COSCI, Hydraulic Platform LCH, Institute of Civil Engineering, EPFL-ENAC, Lausanne, CH and University of Lausanne, Institute of Earth Surface Dynamics (marceline.vuaridel@unil.ch)

    Floods and intense surface runoff are recurring hazards known for triggering erosion processes at the channel and the catchment slope scales, respectively. Whilst the firsts determine the removal of streambank material, also referred to as hydraulic streambank erosion (e.g., Ruiz-Villanueva et al., 2014), the seconds are typically responsible for destabilizing shallow landslides. Both processes are exacerbated by extreme precipitation events, and can cause important damages to forests, agriculture, civil structures, and settlements through the loss of land masses. Moreover, streambank erosion and shallow landslides can be responsible for the recruitment of large wood (LW), whose transport during floods may strongly impacts on downstream infrastructures of urbanized areas (e.g Ruiz-Villanueva et al., 2014).

    Via augmented mechanical stabilization, plant roots may significantly decrease the susceptibility of riverbanks to hydraulic erosion as well as shallow landslides. Under certain conditions, plant roots can be considered an alternative protection against such processes with respect to other civil engineering measures (Stokes et al., 2014). However, root reinforcement effectiveness depends on many factors such as roots density, soil properties, and soil thickness (Cohen and Schwarz, 2017), which implies that some vegetated areas have a more significant effect than others. Most available models ignore the contribution of plant roots with acceptable spatial resolution.

    In this work, we present BankforNET and SlideforNET, two physically-based modelling tools, which have been developed to take the different stabilizing effects of soil reinforcement mechanism by plant roots into account. This is important for proper modeling of bank erosion and landslides processes during extreme events, and to optimize forest protection strategies. BankforNET is a one-dimensional, probabilistic model which simulates expected hydraulic streambank erosion by considering channel morphology, bank sediment material, vegetation roots, and a certain discharge scenario. The SlideforNET is a probabilistic model based on the 3D analysis of slope stability and takes the lateral and basal root reinforcement into account. Ultimately, it gives an estimation of the degree of protection of a forest against landslides.

    These tools are currently being tested in a catchment of 29 km2 in NW Switzerland for the priorisation of protective forests against risks related to LW transport during floods. Based on the model results, the possible silvicultural measures are defined considering quantitative criteria such as the risk mitigation effect of the forest stands, or their risk increment due to LW recruitment and transport. This study is an example of how quantitative tools can be use by decision makers to priories the role of protection forest in a catchment and to support the definition of silvicultural measure to mitigate the risks due to LW transport.

    How to cite: Vuaridel, M., Schwarz, M., Ruiz-Villanueva, V., Perona, P., and Cohen, D.: Roots mechanical effects on hydraulic riverbanks erosion and on shallow landslides: tools for the protection forest management along channels, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9254, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9254, 2022.

    The Swedish Civil Contingencies Agency, the Swedish Geotechnical Institute, the Swedish Road Administration and the Swedish University of Agriculture have together been involved a project named “Vegetation as a mean for slope stabilisation”. The aim of the project was to introduce soil-bioengineering methods in Sweden through demonstration projects and to obtain experiences regarding the function and effect of plants on slope stability within Swedish conditions.

    In three selected areas, the plant- and soil conditions were studied, with tests commencing in the spring of 2004 and in the beginning of 2005, respectively. The project ended in 2007 in a report containing recommendations, based on the experiences from the project, for the continued use of soil bioengineering methods.

    In the test site Bispgården, a new road was built in 2004 through a gully area. The soil consists of highly erodible silt and sand material. Hedge- and brushlayers with grass seeding were selected to protect the soil from erosion in one slope. Equipment for measurements of pore pressure and precipitation were installed in the summer of 2004. Studies of the plant conditions were conducted several times during the first two years of the project.

    In the test site Bydalen, a reconstruction of a country road was conducted in 2005, as the road was plagued with annually recurring erosion along it’s existing silty-till slopes. These slopes were to be restabilised during reconstruction. All together nine existing slopes were stabilised in early 2005 by different soil bioengineering methods proposed by the project group. The group analysed the function of the plants together with automated recordings of precipitation.

    In the test site Näsåker, steep slopes of a country road were repaired in 2005-2008, due to continuing erosion and landslides in the silty soil slopes along the existing road. The slopes were stabilised with soil bioengineering and soil nailing.

    Different soil bioengineering methods have been used in some new production sites, following this demonstration project. The methods may also be implemented in future projects.

    The results from the demonstration in project sites, will be described in this presentation.

    How to cite: Ånäs, M.: Vegetation as a remedial measure against erosion and shallow landslides in steep soil slopes, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9829, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9829, 2022.

    EGU22-11679 | Presentations | NH1.6

    Influence of the temporal dynamic of root reinforcement on the disposition of shallow landslides 

    Massimiliano Schwarz, Denis Cohen, Filippo Giadrossich, Dominik May, Christine Moos, and Luuk Dorren

    Root reinforcement is a variable factor that influences the disposition of shallow landslides over different time scales. Natural or anthropogenic forest disturbances, such as forest fires or clear cuts, may modify considerably the vegetation cover on a short time scale, with major consequences on several ecosystem services, including the mitigation of risks due to shallow landslides. After catastrophic forest disturbances, it is of primary importance for decision makers to assess how risks will change in order to evaluate the most appropriate protection measures. Therefore, the quantification of the effect of the temporal dynamic of root reinforcement is of fundamental importance to estimate the occurrence probability of shallow landslides.

    Data on root distribution and pullout tests for spruce (Picea abies) and beech (Fagus silvatyca) trees are used to upscale the basal and lateral root reinforcement at the stand scale (Schwarz et al., 2012). The decay of root reinforcement is calculated based on data collected in a burnt (Vergani et al., 2017) and a clear-cut area (Vergani et al., 2016). The recovery of root reinforcement after disturbances is estimated considering the growing conditions of the stands (Flepp et al., 2021). The quantification of the dynamic of the forest stands and the derived root reinforcement at stand scale is based on the analysis of four Swiss National Forest Inventory (NFI 1-4). The estimated time-dependent variation of root reinforcement is implemented in the SlideforNET model (ecorisq.org) to calculate the occurrence probability of shallow landslide after disturbances.

    The results show that the recovery of root reinforcement after disturbance is effective to reduce the hazards of shallow landslide only for a narrow range of disposition factors. Given a defined rainfall statistic, slope inclination is the factor that most influence the effectiveness of root reinforcement recovery, within a range of inclination variations of 4-8°. Further relevant factors are soil thickness and runoff contributing area.

    The extended version of SlideforNET quantifies how effective is the recovery of root reinforcement in stabilizing shallow landslides after stand replacing forest disturbances. This information is fundamental to evaluate if additional temporal or permanent technical measures are needed to keep an acceptable level of risk after forest disturbances.

    How to cite: Schwarz, M., Cohen, D., Giadrossich, F., May, D., Moos, C., and Dorren, L.: Influence of the temporal dynamic of root reinforcement on the disposition of shallow landslides, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11679, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11679, 2022.

    EGU22-12425 | Presentations | NH1.6

    Observations of root growth in stratified soils at the microscopic scale: Insights from micro-computed tomography 

    Sadegh Nadimi, Nina Kemp, Vasileios Angelidakis, and Saimir Luli

    Enhancing the overall resilience of vegetated slopes against shallow mass movement can be achieved by better understanding soil-root interaction.  To predict the behaviour of vegetated slopes during design, parameters representing the root system structure, such as root distribution, length, orientation and diameter, should be considered in slope stability models. Microscale quantifications of how root growth influences soil characteristics, able to inform computational models, are scarce in the literature, especially for stratified soils. This study quantifies the relationship between soil physical characteristics and root growth, emphasising particularly on (1) how roots influence the physical architecture of the surrounding soil structure and (2) how soil structure influences root growth. A systematic experimental study is carried out using high-resolution X-ray micro-computed tomography (µCT) to observe the root behaviour in layered soil. In total, 2 samples are scanned over 15 days of growth, enabling the acquisition of 10 sets of images. A machine learning algorithm for image segmentation is trained to act at 3 different training percentages, resulting in the processing of 30 sets of images, with the outcomes prompting a discussion on the size of the training data set. An automated in-house image processing algorithm is developed to provide values of void ratio and root volume ratio for Regions of Interest at varying distance from the root. This work investigates the effect of stratigraphy on root growth, along with the effect of image-segmentation parameters on soil constitutive properties.

    How to cite: Nadimi, S., Kemp, N., Angelidakis, V., and Luli, S.: Observations of root growth in stratified soils at the microscopic scale: Insights from micro-computed tomography, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12425, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12425, 2022.

    EGU22-12479 | Presentations | NH1.6

    Large-scale triaxial tests of vegetated soil at low confining stresses 

    Alessandro Fraccica, Enrique Romero, and Thierry Fourcaud

    The focus of geotechnical researchers and practitioners has recently been on the impact of vegetation on the mechanical behaviour of the soil as nature-based techniques against erosion and landslides. Although numerous laboratory studies have already been produced on this subject, there seems to be a lack of discussion on the significance of the results in relation to the representative elementary volume (REV) used. An excessive or scarce root/soil ratio can result in over- or underestimation of the strength of the soil specimen tested, respectively. In addition, a root/soil ratio very different from that which the plants have in-situ would risk making the laboratory results difficult to upscale to the slope or catchment level. To this end, the aim of this study is to present triaxial compression tests of large vegetated soil specimens (h = 400 mm Φ = 200 mm).

    Silty sand was used and statically compacted at a dry density ρd = 1.60 Mg/m3 and at a water content w = 15%. Samples were then thoroughly poured with water up to a high degree of saturation (Sr ≈ 0.95). Eight of them were seeded with Cynodon dactilon, maintaining fixed seeding spacing and density. Samples were irrigated for eight months to induce sprouting and root growth: during this period, matric suction was monitored. The same procedure was followed to prepare ten fallow specimens.

    Prior to testing, samples were sealed and left in the darkness in a temperature/relative humidity-controlled room for 24 hours, to equalise the desired value of initial suction. An isotropic consolidation stress between 10 and 50 kPa was imposed prior to shearing at a vertical displacement rate of 0.016 mm/min. Matric suction was measured by a tensiometer and the water content was checked at the beginning and at the end of each test. Finally, soil samples were washed to retrieve the entire root architecture, to assess root volume and tensile strength. The resulting values of the root volume ratio of Cynodon dactilon were in good agreement with those observed in-situ in literature studies.

    Generally, the higher the initial soil matric suction, the higher the strength observed in the tests, with vegetated soil systematically showing greater strength than the bare one at similar hydro-mechanical states. In fact, at low values of suction, additional resistance in vegetated soil was observed once reaching large shear deformations, whereas, in drier soils, root reinforcement was activated at smaller strains. Indeed, soil hydraulic state affected the root failure mechanism. In nearly saturated soil, the roots subjected to shearing/tension are free to stretch and slip whereas in slightly saturated soil they are firmly bonded within the matrix and so they experience a more immediate breakage.  

    Despite the root reinforcement, the vegetated samples exhibited larger volume deformations upon shearing, due to the changes generated by root growth on soil fabric (fissures).

    A shear strength criterion for partially saturated soils was used to interpret successfully the results, considering suction, degree of saturation, and soil microstructure. Roots predominantly increased the apparent cohesion of the soil, with minor changes on the friction angle.

    How to cite: Fraccica, A., Romero, E., and Fourcaud, T.: Large-scale triaxial tests of vegetated soil at low confining stresses, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12479, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12479, 2022.

    EGU22-12708 | Presentations | NH1.6

    Shear strength of unsaturated soils artificially vegetated in a field test site 

    Sabatino Cuomo, Mariagiovanna Moscariello, and Vito Foresta

    The effect of a long-root grass on the shear strength response of a partially saturated pyroclastic soil was investigated through a field and laboratory experimental program. Field measurements of soil water content, suction, temperature, and laboratory tests aimed to estimate the shear strength of differently rooted soils were performed. The experimental investigation was carried out on a test site located in Nocera Inferiore, (Campania region, Italy), a few kilometers far from sites of past catastrophic flow-like landslides. The experimental program was carried out on three species of Perennial graminae grass species, characterized by fine and fasciculate long roots.  

    In the field, soil temperature, pH, humidity, and suction were monitored from seeding. The trends were compared with those of air temperature and humidity. Moreover, soil suction and water content trends were related to daily rainfall.

    Undisturbed pyroclastic soil specimens containing roots of perennial graminae grass species were collected after 5 months from seeding and tested at natural water content in standard and suction controlled direct shear equipment. The specimens exhibited different Root Volume ratio (RV) and suction. The shear envelopes were extrapolated using Bishop formulation of effective stress, which allows to consistently consider the partially saturated condition of the soils. The experimental results outlined that the shear strength envelope of vegetated specimens moves upwards in the τ-σ’ space, but also rotates counterclockwise. In general, the cohesion intercept increases, while the effective frictional angle reduces. Moreover, the RV influence on the magnitude of friction angle and cohesion has been assessed. Densely vegetated soils undergo larger modifications of the shear strength envelop than poorly vegetate specimens.   

    The authors would like to acknowledge Prati Armati S.r.l. that provided the grass species used for the tests.

    How to cite: Cuomo, S., Moscariello, M., and Foresta, V.: Shear strength of unsaturated soils artificially vegetated in a field test site, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12708, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12708, 2022.

    EGU22-12986 | Presentations | NH1.6

    Revealing the liquefaction mechanism and anisotropy behaviour of root-reinforced soils: an energy-based approach 

    Ali Akbar Karimzadeh and Anthony Kwan Leung

    Revealing the liquefaction mechanism and anisotropy behaviour of root-reinforced soils: an energy-based approach

     

    Ali Akbar Karimzadeh, Anthony Kwan Leung

    Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Hong Kong University of Science and Technology, Kowloon, Hong Kong SAR

     

    Abstract:

    Recent physical modelling work has demonstrated that plant roots provide seismic resistance to geotechnical infrastructure such as slopes and pipelines against liquefaction. Indeed, there is evidence from published triaxial data that the presence of roots increased the liquefaction resistance of soil and changed the liquefaction failure mode from limited flow failure to cyclic mobility, depending on the amount of cyclic stress ratio applied and the available root volume. However, effects of root orientation on soil anisotropy and energy dissipation during the process of liquefaction, have not been adequately addressed in the literature. In this presentation, we will present a new energy-based framework and its application to reinterpret a set of published triaxial data concerning on the undrained strain-controlled cyclic behaviour of root-reinforced soils. Based on the framework, the changes in the amount of dissipated energy required to reach the liquefaction criteria (i.e. 5% double-amplitude axial strain) of the soil due to the presence of roots of different volume ratio will be determined. We will use this energy term and the strain values at the compressive and extensive sides of a cyclic loading at the liquefaction state to explore how root orientations would affect the soil anisotropy. A new correlation between normalised cumulative dissipated energy (∑ΔW/σc, where σc is the effective confining pressure) and the cyclic resistance ratio at the cycle number of 15 (CRR15) will be established. We will also present the correlation between the ∑ΔW/σc with the normalised cumulative strain energy (∑4W/σc) which is representative to the the demand energy of an earthquake event. Finally, we will discuss any effects of the recycling and recovering of strain energy upon cyclic loading, and their importance in the energy interpretation to root-reinforced soils.

    Keywords: Energy-based approach, Root-reinforced soil, Anisotropy, Liquefaction, Triaxial cyclic tests

    How to cite: Karimzadeh, A. A. and Leung, A. K.: Revealing the liquefaction mechanism and anisotropy behaviour of root-reinforced soils: an energy-based approach, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12986, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12986, 2022.

    EGU22-13252 | Presentations | NH1.6

    Effect of vegetation roots on soil hydraulic and mechanical characteristics under rainfall 

    Xu-Guang Gao, Ji-Peng Wang, Yi-Ran Tan, Jiong Zhang, and Bertrand François

    Rainfall infiltration is the main inducing factor for the instability of unsaturated soil slopes, and root water uptake and reinforcement play an important role in preventing shallow landslide. In order to explore the influence of vegetation root on the soil hydraulic and mechanical properties under rainfall, a self-designed soil permeability coefficient measuring device considering the effects of vegetation was used to study the soil water characteristic curve (SWCC) and permeability coefficient of Festuca Arundinacea, Ophiopogon Japonicus, Ligustrum Vicaryi and bare soil under two different rainfall conditions (3.0mm/h and 5.0mm/h) were studied. Then, the direct shear tests of root-soil composite with different water contents and root contents were carried out. Finally, the slope stability under different rainfall and vegetation was simulated by GeoStudio. Results show that: root water uptake can effectively reduce soil water content and increase soil suction, and its influence range is about 2-3 times the length of the root system. Root water uptake can also significantly improve the soil water retention capacity. The air entry value of vegetation soil is larger than that of bare soil, and the permeability coefficient of vegetation soil is about one order of magnitude lower than that of bare soil. Among the three different types of vegetation, the effect of Festuca Arundinacea and Ophiopogon Japonicus on soil water content and suction is more significant than Ligustrum Vicaryi. Root reinforcement mainly increases the soil shear strength by improving the cohesion of the root-soil composite, but has little effect on the internal friction angle. The cohesion of the root-soil composite is affected by soil water content, root content and root distribution, which increases with the increase of root content, and decreases with the increase of water content. When the roots are vertically distributed, the cohesion of the root-soil composite is greater than when the roots are placed horizontally and inclined. Vegetation can effectively improve the stability of the shallow slope under various rainfall conditions, but has little effect on the stability of a deep slope. The safety factor of all three types of vegetated slopes is higher than that of bare soil slopes.

    How to cite: Gao, X.-G., Wang, J.-P., Tan, Y.-R., Zhang, J., and François, B.: Effect of vegetation roots on soil hydraulic and mechanical characteristics under rainfall, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13252, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13252, 2022.

    EGU22-13261 | Presentations | NH1.6

    Quantifying the effect on shallow landslide activity of actual and potential poplar and pine stands in New Zealand hill country. 

    Feiko van Zadelhoff, Massimiliano Schwarz, Denis Cohen, and Chris Philips

    In New Zealand shallow landslides are a prominent contributor to soil erosion in unvegetated slopes (hill country) and to water quality degradation. Selective well-planned re-vegetation of steep slopes can reduce shallow landslide hazard with comparatively low economic consequences.

    The main non-native planted tree species that contribute to slope stability are Poplar species (Populus sp.) and Pine (Pinus radiata). We will present field data quantifying the root distribution and root strength of poplar and pine trees from New Zealand. 4 poplar trees with a medium Diameter at Breast Height (DBH) of 0.48 m are included. Circular trenches have been dug at fixed distances from stem and the roots counted and their diameter measured systematically. 64 root pull-out tests over varying soil depth and root diameter provide calibration for lateral root reinforcement (Gehring et al., 2019; equation 3). The combination of root counts and root reinforcement calibration enables the parametrization of root reinforcement on a single tree scale. The Pinus radiata calibration is the adopted from Giandrossich et al., 2020 which applied a similar methodology.

    Using the slope stability model SlideforMap, we assess and compare (re)vegetation scenarios and their effect on slope stability. In addition to a detailed inclusion of vegetation, SlideforMap takes local soil and hydrology into account in the parametrization. Scenarios without poplar/radiata stands, dispersed trees and plantations are run and compared under varying precipitation conditions.

    We believe this approach enables regional decision makers to optimize tree planting to significantly reduce slope instability at minimal economic costs.

    Literature:

    Gehring, E., Conedera, M., Maringer, J., Giadrossich, F., Guastini, E., & Schwarz, M. (2019). Shallow landslide disposition in burnt European beech (Fagus sylvatica L.) forests. Scientific Reports, 9(1), 1–11. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-019-45073-7

    Giadrossich, F., Schwarz, M., Marden, M., Marrosu, R., & Phillips, C. (2020). Minimum representative root distribution sampling for calculating slope stability in pinus radiata d.Don plantations in New Zealand. New Zealand Journal of Forestry Science, 50, 1–12. https://doi.org/10.33494/nzjfs502020x68x

    How to cite: van Zadelhoff, F., Schwarz, M., Cohen, D., and Philips, C.: Quantifying the effect on shallow landslide activity of actual and potential poplar and pine stands in New Zealand hill country., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13261, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13261, 2022.

    EGU22-13300 | Presentations | NH1.6

    New modelling tools for quantification of mechanical reinforcement of soil by plant roots 

    Gerrit Meijer, Jonathan Knappett, Glyn Bengough, David Muir Wood, and Teng Liang

    Plant roots can help to stabilise riverbanks and slopes by providing additional mechanical reinforcement through tensioning of root material. This problem has typically been studied at the ultimate limit state, focussing on quantifying the peak root-reinforced soil strength. Existing models however rarely account for the gradual mobilisation of root-reinforcement associated with increasing soil displacements. Understanding these deformations is important when deformation tolerances are low, for example when constructing infrastructure embankments, or when deformations may serve as an early warning signal for slope failure.

    Several new models to quantify mechanical reinforcement were developed, with varying levels of complexity. At the most basic level, fibre bundle model theory was combined with early pioneering work by Wu and Waldron to form a new fibre bundle approach that remains simple to use yet respects the physics of soil and root deformation. A second and more comprehensive analytical model was developed that can calculate reinforcements as a function of increasing soil shear displacement. This model includes key parameters such as the elasto-plastic biomechanical root behaviour, three-dimensional root orientations, root slippage and changes in the geometry of the localised shear zone in the soil. A third model comprises a full set of constitutive stress-strain relationships for rooted soil that can be used in numerical finite-element simulations. In this framework, the rooted soil is treated as a single, composite material in which the soil and root phase can each be assigned their own unique material behaviour. The composite approach simplifies model parameterisation by using independently measurable root and soil parameters, and is also powerful enough to investigate the complicated interaction between stresses and deformations in the soil skeleton and in the roots.

    These models all provided good predictions of experimentally measured root reinforcements in direct shear tests. They will be useful tools both for the engineering industry, in terms of rapid quantification of root reinforcement, as well as for directing future research into the drivers of mechanical root-reinforcement.

    How to cite: Meijer, G., Knappett, J., Bengough, G., Muir Wood, D., and Liang, T.: New modelling tools for quantification of mechanical reinforcement of soil by plant roots, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13300, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13300, 2022.

    EGU22-13319 | Presentations | NH1.6

    Evaluating the Efficiency of a Nature-Based Solution on Flood Risk Reduction under climate change scenarios 

    Sisay Debele, Paul Bowyer, Jeetendra Sahani, Silvia Maria Alfieri, Massimo Menenti, Thomas Zieher, and Prashant Kumar

    Climate change is increasing the probability of extreme precipitation in many regions, which will lead to an increased risk of major flooding events. Recent years have seen an interest in the use of so-called nature-based solutions (NbS) to help respond and reduce the risk posed by such extreme events. This paper provides an analysis of the use of NbS to help reduce flood risk at the open-air laboratory Germany (OAL-Germany), which is part of the EU Horizon 2020 project OPERANDUM. OAL-Germany is located in the Biosphere Reserve Lower Saxony Elbe Valley. Following major flooding events which occurred in OAL-Germany in 2002 and 2013, a cooperative flood management NbS was implemented over the period 2014-2015 and has been in place since then. The NbS consisted of cutting back woody vegetation in certain locations along the riverbank which impeded overbanking during flood events, and the use of various grazing animals to try and prevent the regrowth of such woody vegetation. The objective of this study is to evaluate the efficiency of NBS against flood risk under present-day climate change scenarios and assess future flood inundations and velocities in OAL-Germany. The daily precipitation data obtained from the EURO-CORDEX project dataset for 1971–2000 and 2051–2080 represented historical and future simulations, respectively. The hydrologic model HEC-HMS was integrated with the hydraulic model HEC-RAS to simulate discharge, flood velocity, and water depth/inundations of past and future events. For HEC-RAS model boundary conditions, daily flow data with long-term quality-controlled data, obtained from the Global Runoff Data Centre were used. The model was simulated for two scenarios: (1) pre-NBS implementation, considering the landcover of mixed forest; and (2) post-NBS implementation using pastureland, which is the current NBS/landcover in place. The results of the simulation show that the pastureland released the floodwater from the main river system faster than the previous landcover. Overall, the floodwater velocity of pastureland increased by 21%, while flood depth showed a decrease of 2% compared with mixed forest. Therefore, if the modelled NBS had actually been in place in 2012, then it is reasonable to expect that they would have contributed to a reduction in flood risk further downstream from the modelled NBS areas, in the June 2013 flood event. This study can help to improve NBS uptake and upscaling, which is critical to improve NBS planning, implementation, and effectiveness assessment.

     

    Keywords: Nature-based solutions; HEC-RAS Model; Flood depth; Flood Velocity; Roughness coefficients; Climate Change

     

    Acknowledgments

    This work has been carried out under the framework of OPERANDUM (OPEn-air laboRAtories for Nature baseD solUtions to Manage hydro-meteo risks) project, which is funded by the European Union's Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under the Grant Agreement No: 776848.

    How to cite: Debele, S., Bowyer, P., Sahani, J., Alfieri, S. M., Menenti, M., Zieher, T., and Kumar, P.: Evaluating the Efficiency of a Nature-Based Solution on Flood Risk Reduction under climate change scenarios, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13319, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13319, 2022.

    EGU22-13331 | Presentations | NH1.6

    Impact of wetting-drying cycles on the hydro-mechanical behaviour of vegetated soil 

    Floriana Anselmucci, Hongyang Cheng, Yijian Zeng, Xinyan Fan, and Vanessa Magnanimo

    Climate change strongly affects the hydro-mechanical properties of soil. Due to drought and heavy rains
    the soil is subjected to severe hydro-mechanical loads, that, in turn, alter the microstructure of the soil.
    The most affected area is the so-called vadose zone, the layer of soil situated between the ground surface and
    the water table. Here the presence of vegetation has a strong impact, related to the elongation/expansion
    of the root architecture and the hydro-mechanical interactions with soil. Additionally, the presence of plant
    roots facilitate the evapotranspiration process from deeper soil layers.
    The research presents an experimental investigation, aimed to reproduce the typical hydro-mechanical
    conditions as found in the vadose zone in controlled laboratory conditions. Drying-wetting cycles are induced
    in soils samples, where maize plants are free to sprout and develop as well as in reference non-vegetated
    samples. The water content and distribution within the soil matrix are studied through 4D (3D+time)
    in-vivo x-ray computed tomography and effects on the soil-root microstructure are quantified with 3D
    image analysis. Those are correlated with above ground measurements such as fluorescence (through a
    spectroradiometer) that, in turn, provides leaf water potential, and the stomatal conductance that controls
    the evapotranspiration.

    How to cite: Anselmucci, F., Cheng, H., Zeng, Y., Fan, X., and Magnanimo, V.: Impact of wetting-drying cycles on the hydro-mechanical behaviour of vegetated soil, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13331, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13331, 2022.

    EGU22-13423 | Presentations | NH1.6

    Nature-based solutions for mitigating erosion and shallow landslides in LaRiMiT toolbox: use of expert scoring for evaluation of NBS measures 

    Vittoria Capobianco, Bjørn Kalsnes, James Strout, and Anders Solheim

    LaRiMiT (Landslide Risk Mitigation Toolbox) is a web-based database and user portal for identifying and selecting mitigation measures for a specific landslide case, assisted by an embedded expert scoring system. The webtool, developed within KLIMA2050, contains more than 80 structural landslide mitigation measures, including active (aimed at reducing the likelihood of a landslide) and passive (aimed at reducing the consequences) measures. For each mitigation measure a description, examples of application and design methods are provided, as well as references from literature. An Analytic Hierarchy Process resident in the toolbox provides a ranked list of suitable mitigation measures for a specific case. The quantitative scores reflect the input relevance weights and option scores. Recently, the database has been expanded to include also Nature-based solutions (NBS). NBS applied to landslide hazard mitigation are mostly known as soil and water bio-engineering (SWB) and the main SWB techniques have been categorized and added to the database. For these measures, the period of installation, the materials involved, advantages, and disadvantages are also provided. The database containing all the mitigation measures has open access to all users at https://www.larimit.com/. 

    A survey was sent to a group of experts in landslide management and SWB selected worldwide, with a focus on Europe, asking them to assign scores to each mitigation measure in the toolbox. The survey was made using Microsoft Forms. Each measure was linked to a dedicated response page through a hyperlink, and the experts could submit a response for the mitigation measures they felt more comfortable with giving scores. For each mitigation measure selected, the experts were asked to assess the measure by scoring 33 parameters, based on existing landslide classifications with regards to the type of movement, material type, rate of movement of the landslide (among others), as well as feasibility, economic suitability, and environmental suitability. A total of 153 experts, among landlide mitigation managers and experts of SWB practices, were asked to fill the survey. An innovative methodology for utilising experts' scoring directly within the decision support tool, was proposed and used to calculate the final scores for each parameter of the landslide mitigation measures. It consisted in 5 phases, namely Data analysis, Data filtering, data weighing, Data comparison, and Score selection.

    A total of 38 out of the 153 invited experts (corresponding to just over 25%) contributed scores for at least one mitigation measure. In total, 296 responses were received of which 172 were for traditional mitigation measures, 111 for NBS, and 13 for hybrid solutions (combination of NBS and traditional engineering solutions). The results from this first pooling are discussed and analyzed, and the scores of 56 measures were updated on the basis of the pooling answers. All the NBS measures received between 3 and 9 responses, confirming that the NBS listed in the database were well known to most of the SWB experts who participated to the survey. 

    The survey is still open and we encourage landslide mitigation experts that are willing to provide their contribution, to reach out the survey managers at vittoria.capobianco@ngi.no.

    How to cite: Capobianco, V., Kalsnes, B., Strout, J., and Solheim, A.: Nature-based solutions for mitigating erosion and shallow landslides in LaRiMiT toolbox: use of expert scoring for evaluation of NBS measures, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13423, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13423, 2022.

    EGU22-678 | Presentations | NH3.1 | Highlight

    Unraveling debris-flow erosion: experimentally assessing the effects of debris-flow composition on erosion 

    Tjalling de Haas, Lonneke Roelofs, and Pauline Colucci

    Understanding erosion and entrainment of material by debris flows is essential for modelling debris-flow volume growth and prediction of hazard potential. Recent advances have highlighted two driving forces behind debris flow erosion; impact and shear forces. How erosion and these forces depend on debris-flow composition and interact remains unclear. We experimentally investigated the effects of debris-flow composition and volume on erosion processes in a small-scale flume with a loosely packed bed. We quantified the effects of gravel, clay and solid fraction in the debris flow on bed erosion. Erosion increased linearly with gravel fraction and volume, and decreased with increasing solid fraction. Erosion was maximal around a volumetric clay fraction of 0.075 (fraction of the total solid volume). Under varying gravel fractions and flow volumes erosion was positively related to both impact and shear forces, while these forces themselves correlate. Results further show that the internal dynamics driving the debris flows, quantified by Bagnold and Savage numbers, correlate to erosional processes and quantity. Impact forces became increasingly important for bed erosion with increasing grain size. The experiments with varying clay and solid fractions showed that the abundance and viscosity of the interstitial fluid affect debris-flow dynamics, erosional mechanisms and erosion magnitude. High viscosity of the interstitial fluid inhibits the mobility of the debris flow, the movement of the individual grains, the transfer of momentum to the bed by impacts, and therefore inhibits erosion. High solid content possibly decreases the pore pressures in the debris flow and the transport capacity, inhibiting erosion, despite high shear stresses and impact forces. Our results show that bed erosion quantities and mechanisms may vary between debris flows with contrasting composition, and stress that entrainment models and volume-growth predictions may be substantially improved by including compositional effects.

    How to cite: de Haas, T., Roelofs, L., and Colucci, P.: Unraveling debris-flow erosion: experimentally assessing the effects of debris-flow composition on erosion, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-678, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-678, 2022.

    EGU22-1154 | Presentations | NH3.1 | Highlight

    Investigation of debris-flow impact forces on bridge superstructures – laboratory experiments on the influence of bridge profiles 

    Caroline Friedl, Christian Scheidl, Susanna Wernhart, and Dirk Proske

    Mountainous areas tend to have a high density of bridges due to their topography and mobility requirements. Furthermore, such areas are often characterized by frequent debris-flow activity, which in turn can endanger the structural integrity of bridges. The influence of debris flows on bridge piers has already been analyzed in the past, but mechanisms and consequences of debris-flow impact on bridge superstructures remain unclear.

    We hypothesize that in addition to horizontal forces, frictional shear-forces and uplift forces may play a considerable role in bridge failure caused by debris-flow impacts. We also conjecture that the type of the bridge superstructure, specifically the bridge profile has an influence on the occurring forces.

    In order to obtain a deeper understanding of impact forces on bridge superstructures, we aim to measure and quantify the forces exerted on different bridge profiles during debris-flow impact based on small scale experiments. We will investigate debris-flow impact on five different bridge profiles in the course of the project “Debris-flow impact forces on bridge superstructures (DEFSUP)”, funded by the Austrian Science Fund (FWF).

    The laboratory setup consists of a 4 m long semi-circular channel with a diameter of 0.3 m and an inclination of 20°. The cement miniature bridge in the scale of 1:30 is mounted on a metal frame and is installed at the end of the flume. The debris-flow material corresponds to a granular debris flow, the mass is fixed at 50 kg for each experiment. The flume itself has been optimized in preliminary studies and ensures high reproducibility of stationary debris flows with predictably sufficient flow-heights for the impact on the miniature bridge. Each profile is subjected to at least three impacts. The impact forces on the bridge profile are measured with 3-axis-force sensors at both abutments of the bridge. Thereby it is possible to determine horizontal impact forces as well as uplift and shear forces. Additionally, flow heights, pore water pressure and normal stresses are gauged.

    The results of the study are intended to contribute to recommendations for the structural design of bridges in vulnerable areas. This aims not only to protect human lives and to increase the safety of structures, but also to provide financial relief in the future, since there is evidence that the areas prone to debris-flow events are likely to increase as a consequence of climate change.

    How to cite: Friedl, C., Scheidl, C., Wernhart, S., and Proske, D.: Investigation of debris-flow impact forces on bridge superstructures – laboratory experiments on the influence of bridge profiles, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1154, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1154, 2022.

    EGU22-1860 | Presentations | NH3.1

    Assessment of debris flows activity in response to earthquake using an index of sediment connectivity 

    Yanji Li, Kaiheng Hu, Xiaojun Guo, and Xudong Hu

    Large earthquakes trigger landslides and collapses, which not only increase the loose solid materials, but also change the topography in the catchments. The debris flow activities in response to earthquake are widespread concerned, but most of the researches focus on the material conditions and the flow properties. In this research, we investigated the temporal variations of debris flow activities in a typical catchment in the Wenchuan Earthquake area, by considering the index of sediment connectivity (IC), which reflects the efficiency of sediment delivery in the catchment. The IC values in different tributaries and different period were calculated to indicate the spatial distribution and temporal variation. The results show that the high IC values distributed in the tributaries on the right hand of the mainstream in the catchment. The IC values decreased significantly after the earthquake, indicating the sediment transfer ability decreased continuously. Meanwhile, the debris flow history and loose solid material amounts were investigated via field surveys. The debris flows activities show a close consistency with the variations of debris flow source amounts and the IC values in the catchment. This research presents a new method of assessment the characteristics of sediment transfer of debris flows affected by the earthquake, and also provides a new insight to assess the debris flow actives for its close relationship with distribution of loose solid materials and sediment connectivity. 

    How to cite: Li, Y., Hu, K., Guo, X., and Hu, X.: Assessment of debris flows activity in response to earthquake using an index of sediment connectivity, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1860, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1860, 2022.

    EGU22-2174 | Presentations | NH3.1

    Particle size segregation in debris flows: insights from simulations of immersed sheared granular flows 

    Kahlil Fredrick Cui, Gongdan Zhou, and Lu Jing

    During the course of a debris flow’s motion, large particles, such as rocks and boulders, rise to the free-surface while the finer sand and silt-sized particles settle to the base. This inverse-grading process influences the development of coarse-grained heads and levees in debris flows that consequently enhance the flow mobility. Size segregation is well-studied in dry granular flows wherein it is found to be highly efficient and results in sharply separated layers of differently sized particles. Segregation diminishes in the presence of pore fluids (i.e. water or muddy slurry) and in some cases is no longer evident, although the mechanisms behind this inhibitive effect is poorly understood. In order to accurately capture size segregation in debris flows, and its impacts on the flow dynamics, it is important to understand how different types of pore fluids influence the segregation process. In this research, we systematically investigate the effects of various interstitial fluids, characterized by their density and viscosity, on the rate of particle size segregation through coupled granular-fluid simulations. Debris flows are simulated as sheared granular mixtures composed of spheres having two distinct particle sizes, immersed in ambient fluids. Solid and fluid interactions are modelled through drag and buoyant forces. Fluid effects are also evaluated across different shear rates, confining pressures, mean diameters, and gravity. It is found that the segregation slows down as the fluid viscosity is increased, but is unaffected by it below certain threshold values. In the low viscosity limit, segregation is affected only by the relative density between the particles and the fluid, and by flow inertial conditions. Analysis of stresses acting on a segregating particles reveals that the decrease of segregation rates with the viscosity is due to the increase of fluid drag forces which effectively weaken the contact stress gradients and velocity fluctuations responsible for driving the large particles upward. An empirical scaling formula is developed which accounts for the effects of fluid viscosity and the relative density on size segregation immersed in different fluids.

    How to cite: Cui, K. F., Zhou, G., and Jing, L.: Particle size segregation in debris flows: insights from simulations of immersed sheared granular flows, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2174, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2174, 2022.

    EGU22-2195 | Presentations | NH3.1

    New constrains on infrasound source mechanisms within debris-flows 

    Giacomo Belli, Emanuele Marchetti, Duccio Gheri, Fabian Walter, and Brian W. McArdell

    Debris flows are episodic gravitational currents, consisting of mixtures of water and debris in varying proportions occurring in steep mountain catchments, with volumes commonly exceeding thousands of m3. Given their unpredictability and their capability to transport large boulders, debris flows rank among the most dangerous natural hazards in mountain environments.

    The use of infrasound arrays and the combined use of collocated seismic and infrasound sensors have turned out to be efficient systems for reliable detection of debris flows in near real-time, highlighting the strong potential of infrasound for studying and monitoring debris-flows.

    Despite these advances, open questions remain about the possibility to infer debris-flow source characteristics and event magnitude from recorded infrasonic signals. This requires theoretical and/or empirical source models describing elastic energy radiation in the atmosphere, in the form of infrasound, and relating it to fluid dynamic processes within a debris flow. Infrasound radiated by debris-flows is thought to be generated by standing waves that develop at the free surface of the flow, but details of the involved dynamic processes are not fully understood.

    Here, we present the analysis of infrasonic signals from >20 debris flows and torrential floods recorded with a small aperture array at the Illgraben catchment (Switzerland, Canton Valais) between 2017 and 2021. The comparison between infrasonic signal features (maximum amplitude and peak frequency) and measured flow parameters (front velocity, maximum depth and discharge) showed that the infrasound radiation by debris flows linearly correlates with flow discharge and that the infrasonic peak frequency inversely scales with flow parameters, thus decreasing when flow velocity, depth or discharge increase. In addition, array analysis of infrasonic signals revealed that the infrasound by debris-flows at Illgraben appears to be dominated by clusters of coherent infrasonic detections generated near check dams located along the Illgraben channel.

    These pieces of evidence suggest that debris flow infrasound is generated by turbulence-induced waves and oscillations developing at the free-surface of the flow, whose dimensions scale with the magnitude of the flow. As expected from fluid dynamics, these surface oscillations are primarily generated where the flow encounters significant channel irregularities, such as topographic steps, which consequently act as preferential sources of infrasound. To test the validity of our interpretation of infrasound source mechanisms within debris-flows we also compare infrasonic recordings of a water free overfall over a weir with video recordings of the flow, to investigate how infrasound correlates with the dynamic of the surface of the flow.

    How to cite: Belli, G., Marchetti, E., Gheri, D., Walter, F., and McArdell, B. W.: New constrains on infrasound source mechanisms within debris-flows, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2195, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2195, 2022.

    EGU22-2482 | Presentations | NH3.1 | Highlight

    Stability analysis of check dam impacted by intermittent surge 

    Daochuan Liu, Bo Xiang, Jiang Shao, Yunyong He, and Miao Liang

    Viscose debris flows always move in the manner of intermittent surges and show obvious fluctuation. In the traditional design of debris flow control engineering, the impact of single surge has on the check dams was the only factor to be taken into consideration. Whereas stability variation law of the check dams under the impact of intermittent surges was always neglected. On the basis of debris flow observation material from the Jiangjia Gully (JJG), we initially analysis the fluctuating and decaying characteristics of intermittent surges. Results indicate that intermittent surges exhibit obvious decaying characteristics and finally decay in a power-law form, showing a strong no-linear behavior. Next, based on loading combination and stability analysis of check dams, we deduced the expression of the stability coefficient when intermittent surges impact on the check dams in empty and half reservoir conditions. Meanwhile, stability variation law of the check dams in the different conditions were compared. Results indicated that when intermittent surges impact on check dams, anti-sliding stability coefficient (Kc) and anti-overturning stability coefficient (Ky) decrease with the increase of surges, and the former 3th~5th surges experienced the largest decaying rate. On the other hand, the deeper deposits in the reservoir corresponds to the smaller stability coefficient under the impact of the same intermittent surges. Finally, the relationship between flow depth and stability coefficients is in the form of an envelope curve, inferring that the variation of flow depth restraint the stability coefficient of check dams.

    How to cite: Liu, D., Xiang, B., Shao, J., He, Y., and Liang, M.: Stability analysis of check dam impacted by intermittent surge, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2482, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2482, 2022.

    EGU22-3302 | Presentations | NH3.1

    Temporal characteristics of debris flow surges 

    Jun Zhang, Yong Li, Xiaojun Guo, Taiqiang Yang, Daochuan Liu, and Bin Yu

    Abstract: Debris flow is one of the most destructive geomorphological events in mountainous watersheds, which usually appears in form of successive surge waves as observed all over the world. In particular, debris flows in the Jiangjia Gully (JJG) in southwest China have displayed a great variety of surge phenomena; each debris flow event contains tens or hundreds of separate surges originating from different sources. Therefore, the surge sequence of an event must encode the information of debris flow developing. The UAV (unmanned aerial vehicle) photos provide an overview of debris-flow sources, showing the different potential of debris flow; and surge sequences present various patterns responding to the rainfall events. Then the variety of rainfalls and material sources determine the diversity of surge sequence. Using time series analysis to the surge discharge sequences, we calculate the Hurst exponent, the autocorrelation function, and the power spectrum exponent, and find that all the sequences commonly share the property of long-term memory and these parameters are correlated in exponential form, with values depending on rainfall patterns. Moreover, all events show a gross trend of discharge decay, despite the local rainfall process, which implies the intrinsic nature of the surge sequence as a systematic behavior of watershed. It is expected that these findings are heuristic for establishing mechanisms of debris flow initiation and evolution in a watershed.

    How to cite: Zhang, J., Li, Y., Guo, X., Yang, T., Liu, D., and Yu, B.: Temporal characteristics of debris flow surges, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3302, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3302, 2022.

    Slope failures are important material supplies for debris flows, and field observations have indicated that failures are random and discontinuous. However, few studies focus on the nature of failures in succession. This study reports groups of field experiments of soil failures under artificial rainfall on slopes in two debris flow valleys, the Jiangjia Gully (JJG) in Yunnan Province, and the Niujuan Gully (NJG) in Sichuan Province, in southwest China (Fig.1).

    Fig.1 Experimental sites of the study (upper, NJG; lower, JJG)

    It is found that failures occur separately and intermittently on slopes; a slope process is composed of a failure sequence (Fig.2), which presents similar properties under different rainfalls and slope conditions: 1) the sequence is primarily random, with weak autocorrelation and small correlation to time progress and less dependence on rainfall; 2) the time interval between failures satisfies the exponential distribution, and the average interval decreasing with rainfall intensity, implying the frequency increases with rainfall intensity; 3) the magnitude of failure fluctuates up to three orders, from several to hundreds of volume unit (10-3m3); and the distribution follows the power law, with total amount increasing with rainfall intensity.

    Fig 2 Failure sequences under different rainfall intensities on the experimental slopes

    We propose that these properties are ascribed to the spatial heterogeneity of soil, which can be described by two parameters, m and Dc, of the grain size distribution (GSD). The point-to-point variation of (m, Dc) leads to dramatic changes in the distribution of strength, infiltration, and pore water pressure generation, and finally results in the variety of failures across the slope.

    Correspondingly, the discontinuous failures translate into separate debris flow surges in the tributaries, thereby providing a scenario for surge formation in the mainstream flow of the valley. It is suggested that surges in the mainstream channel result from cascading development of tributary surges, and that the spatiotemporal characteristics observed in mainstream surges are rooted in the sources of slope failures.

     

     

     

     

     

    How to cite: Li, Y.: Spatiotemporal characteristics of discontinuous slope failures, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3386, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3386, 2022.

    EGU22-3410 | Presentations | NH3.1

    The nonsynchronous processes in debris flow developing 

    Yingjie Yao, Yong Li, and Jun Zhang

    Debris flow is a mixture of water and granular materials of wide-ranged grain size, which carries huge quantity of sediment. Generally, the flow is implicitly assumed a fluid of water plus solid, ignoring the when and how the mixing is going on. However, as far as the forming processes are concerned, the solid phase (granular sediments) do not always move in step with the flush water. In most cases, material supplies are scattering and discontinuous from the source areas and streambed sediment does not initiates as whole but separately in certain time intervals, while water flow is continuous from upper to downstream channels. The separation of sediment and water in debris flow developing is vividly encoded in the successive surges as ubiquitously observed in the world, especially in the Jiangjia Gully (JJG) in southwest China. Fig.1 shows the time series of water and the carried sediment of two events, indicating the out-of-synch between water and sediment.

    Using the data of debris flows in JJG, we attempt to disclose the sediment-water separation effects on the developed surge properties, which is expected to be heuristic for understanding the forming and developing mechanisms of debris flows from sources to the mainstream. Specifically, we consider the following issues as exhibited by the surge sequences.

    1) The temporal variability of water and sediment flow series, including the fluctuation, autocorrelation, power spectrum, Hurst exponent;

    2) The statistical features of the two series, especially the probability distribution of the quantity (discharge or total volume) and the physical implication of the distribution parameters;

    It is found that both the water and sediment bear high autocorrelation and Hurst index, while the sediment sources are randomly supplied. Furthermore, the series satisfies a unified distribution in form of P(x) = Kx-μexp(x/xc), with x being the discharge and volume of sediment and water.   The parameters μ and xc vary with the events (e.g., Fig.2 for the distribution of magnitude).

    These findings are expected to shine a light on how the non-synch processes of water and sediment influence the developing of debris flow and the peak discharge, and this also poses a question in dynamics, which should incorporate the random and discontinuous sediment entrance in the evolution of flow.

    Fig.1   Water and sediment flow discharge series of debris flow surges (E990716 and E990816)

    Fig.2   Probability distribution of water and sediment quantity

     

    How to cite: Yao, Y., Li, Y., and Zhang, J.: The nonsynchronous processes in debris flow developing, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3410, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3410, 2022.

    EGU22-3994 | Presentations | NH3.1

    The role of fines in the dynamics of just-saturated, inertial column collapses 

    William Webb and Barbara Turnbull

    Debris flows are subaerial, gravity-driven mass movements of water, soil and rocks.  High fluid volume fractions and the presence of a wide particle-size distribution lead to highly heterogeneous flow states, and the mechanisms giving rise to this phenomenology open to debate. For tractable modelling, assumptions around the interaction between grains and fluid must be made, but it is not clear whether those assumptions are reasonable across the wide range of length-scales observed. For example, recent studies have shown that the inclusion of a significant proportion of fine granular material within the flow’s composition limits the dissipation of excess pore pressures. Here we explore the possibility that these crucial pore pressure processes are governed at length scales that might otherwise seem insignificant to the macroscopic flow behaviour. Hence, we aim to provide insight on the underlying mechanisms controlling pore pressure through a scaling analysis describing the idealised scenario of sub-aerial axisymmetric column collapses of just-saturated fluid-grain mixtures. Glass beads provide the prototype for inertial particles within the debris flow, and Newtonian fluids carrying varying mass concentrations of fine kaolin clay particles provide the microscopic processes that can control the pore spaces. A geotechnical centrifuge permits elevated gravitational acceleration that when varied alongside particle size, fluid viscosity and mass concentration of fines, allows a wide parameter space to be explored. Pore pressure measurements from these collapses indicate two competing mechanisms, stemming from drainage related pore pressure dissipation and inertial collision related pore pressure generation. An empirical description of these processes is proposed based on our experimental data. This expression is then implemented to describe the fluid-particle coupling within a multiphase Saint-Venant inspired central-upwind scheme in an attempt to simulate the experimental observations.

    How to cite: Webb, W. and Turnbull, B.: The role of fines in the dynamics of just-saturated, inertial column collapses, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3994, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3994, 2022.

    Volcanic debris avalanches occur when volcanic edifices collapse and flow as landslides. They are preserved in the geological record as volcanic debris avalanche deposits (VDADs). Analysis of these deposits can provide insight into the flow characteristics of the avalanche and its possible triggers.

    Here we provide preliminary textural data on the shear zone layer at the base of a small-volume VDAD on Ascension Island, South Atlantic. The deposit has a volume of ~4 x 106 m3, covers 2 km2 and originated from the partial collapse of the northern flank of the 300ka Green Mountain scoria cone, which sits at 550 metres above sea level. The avalanche flowed 2 km down a ~10° slope, before stopping at in a small basin against a lava dome at 190 m above sea level.

    Over most of its length the VDAD overlies an in-situ Green Mountain scoria fall deposit that was dispersed north during the eruption. The base of the deposit is marked by a fine-grained, ~2 cm-thick shear zone with slickensides. The shear zone is distinguishable in hand specimen from the rest of the deposit by being finer grained and indurated. The bulk of the VDAD is composed of semi-coherent, metre scale blocks of scoria with a poorly sorted volcaniclastic matrix composed of a hetereolithic clast population including randomly orientated clasts of basaltic scoria, pumice and lavas. The toe of the deposit is fractured and flame structures are abundant.

    Preliminary Back-scattered Scanning Electron Microscope imaging of the shear zone reveal that porosity and pore interconnectivity decrease markedly towards the centre of the shear zone, and clasts become finer-grained, better sorted and more rounded. Experiments will be conducted on samples of Green Mountain Scoria using Rotary Shear Equipment to place constraints on slip rates and shear parameters. Ultimately, we hope to understand potential triggers of the failure and explore the hazards and potential for similar events on the island in the future.

     

    How to cite: James, H.: Volcanic Debris Avalanche and accompanying shear zone slip surface formed by a perched scoria cone collapse on Ascension Island, South Atlantic, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4185, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4185, 2022.

    EGU22-4346 | Presentations | NH3.1

    Modelling Solid-Fluid Phase Separation and Dewatering in Debris Flows 

    Guillaume Meyrat

    The runout behaviour of debris flows is strongly governed by their solid-fluid composition.  In mitigation projects it is often necessary to predict when the solid phase deposits and if there exists the possibility of fluid washes.  The solid-fluid composition in the runout zone often controls the size and type of mitigation measures, as well as how land is zoned around a specific torrent.  This problem is extremely difficult to solve in general terrain because of the difficulty to establish initial conditions for both sediment and fluid, the inability to accurately account for torrent geometry and erosion, or the complexity of the muddy-granular flow rheology.  Here we present a dilatant, two-phase debris flow model that predicts the deposition of the solid phase with eventual dewatering.  Theoretically, the model exhibits a specific solid-fluid composition ratio for a debris flow in steady-state conditions.  In the runout zone, when the flow decelerates, the shear-work is no longer capable of sustaining this steady-state, leading to the deposition of solid material with decoupling of the fluid phase.  We apply the model to simulate several debris flow events where the stopping/dewatering behaviour of flow was captured using high-resolution drone scans.   Finally, we show that the wide range of empirical friction coefficients used in single phase debris flow models can be constrained by application of two-phase models, with varying solid-fluid compositions. 

    How to cite: Meyrat, G.: Modelling Solid-Fluid Phase Separation and Dewatering in Debris Flows, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4346, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4346, 2022.

    EGU22-4597 | Presentations | NH3.1

    The Experiment Study on Debris Flow Formation Process Based on REE 

    Jianqi Zhuang

    Designing the experiment on debris flow formation process at artificial rainfall at the conditions of the loose material unusually rich for studying the debris flow formation process. The main results showed: (1) the fine particles moving first for the initiation of debris flow, and then mixed with the large particle and runoff increased sharply, along with channel block-outburst phenomenon; the debris flow phenomena gradually disappeared with the fine particles migration off and the channel rough serious. (2) the slop failure and moving at the rainstorm, the failure material deposited in channel and formed the dams which effect the erosion and deposits of the channel with moving down to downstream. (3) the erosion sediment was main from middle and lower channel, then from the upstream and slope; the debris flow fan materials was main from the downstream channel, then from the upstream and slope. (4) the pore-water pressure and water content, which not only effected by rainfall, but also effected by fine particles content and soil structure, changed obviously and varied in different time and different sites with fluctuation. (5) the fine particles played an important role in the process of debris flow initiation and it’s accumulation and displacement effected the evolution of the basin topography and the formation of debris flow. In the debris flow forecast, the fine particles of soil content should be considered duo to its critical water content and pore-water pressure quite different in different content of fine particles of debris flow initiation.

    How to cite: Zhuang, J.: The Experiment Study on Debris Flow Formation Process Based on REE, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4597, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4597, 2022.

    Numerical modelling is the physically-based method for in-depth analyzing the process from landslide to debris flow. Particle flow analysis method (PFC) has the advantage of dealing with such processes, like debris flow formation, propagation, and deposition. Hence, our study to analyze the dynamic characteristics of a landslide-generated debris-flow, taking the Shaziba landslide-debris-flow as example, which occurred in Enshi City on June 8, 2020, under complex landslide material composition, Combined the field survey, unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) aerial photography, and laboratory direct shear tests, the velocity, displacement and the characteristics of the landslide-generated debris-flow were simulated. The results indicated that the initial stage of the landslide starts with an overall motion acceleration with a time around 733 s. The maximum velocity of the landslide body is 17.5 m/s, and the maximum displacement is 1500 m with a total volume of 9.31×105 m3. The simulation results are closer to the actual landslide volume (1.0×106 m3) and the form of the dam in Qingjiang. The study reveals the mechanism of dam formation, which could be served as useful information for natural hazards management to prevent the river from being blocked by landslides or debris flows.

    How to cite: Hu, X. and Ding, M.: Modeling the propagation and run-out from gravel-silty clay landslide to debris flow in Shaziba, southwest Hubei Province, China, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4675, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4675, 2022.

    EGU22-5246 | Presentations | NH3.1

    Controls on the deposition of extremely large post-earthquake debris flows in Wenchuan 

    Erin Harvey, Tristram Hales, Daniel Hobley, Alexander Horton, Jie Liu, and Xuanmei Fan

    Debris flows are the dominant process delivering sediment from hillslopes into channels following the 2008 Wenchuan earthquake. Post-earthquake debris flows continue to pose a significant hazard to the recovering local communities. In 2019, a period of intense rainfall triggered several extremely large debris flows. The flows bulked to volumes in excess of 100 000 m3,  much larger than their initiation volumes, and transited catchments to be deposited in the Min Jiang river. The scale of these flows highlights our limited understanding of why and where large debris flows deposit. Previous studies have shown that topography (notably bed slope and channel width), flow composition (grain size), and flow characteristics (velocity and depth) can all control debris flow runout. Yet, there is limited understanding of how these interrelate. For example, whether abrupt changes in topography, such as increased channel width, lead to the deposition of certain grain size fractions and subsequently encourage further deposition. Alternatively, whether changes in bed slope affect flow velocity and this results in the entrainment of specific grain size fractions by the flow. An understanding of these relationships will help to better constrain where and how post-earthquake debris flows are more likely to deposit.

    In this study, we determine how debris flow characteristics (velocity and depth) and the grain size distribution (GSD) deposited by the debris flow evolve with changes in topography and distance from the initial debris flow source. To achieve this, we simulated two post-earthquake debris flow events in the Liusha and Luoquan catchments, China, using the 2D dynamic debris flow model, Massflow. GSDs were collected by sampling and sieving pits located equidistantly along the centre of each 2019 debris flow deposit. Bed topography data was recorded both in the field and using a 30 m resolution DEM. We compared changes in the flow characteristics and GSDs deposited for each debris flow with the data for bed topography to explore how controls on debris flow runout interrelate. Preliminary findings for the Luoquan debris flow suggest a relationship between negative changes in curvature and the deposition of fine-grained material. This work will help to better understand controls on debris flow runout, subsequently aiding future studies of post-earthquake debris flow hazard prediction.

    How to cite: Harvey, E., Hales, T., Hobley, D., Horton, A., Liu, J., and Fan, X.: Controls on the deposition of extremely large post-earthquake debris flows in Wenchuan, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5246, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5246, 2022.

    Landslides, such as debris flows and avalanches, are common natural hazards worldwide. They pose an ongoing threat to life and property. Landslide run-out models that have been developed over the past decades are powerful tools to assess landslide risks and design mitigation strategies. Due to the simplification of real-world landslide processes, the models often contain parameters that rely on calibration of past landslide events where field data are available. Deterministic calibration methods like traditional trial-and-error calibration suffer from the non-uniqueness issue and cannot account for uncertainties associated with field data. Probabilistic calibration methods like Bayesian inference avoid the two issues. However, their usage is hindered by high computational costs due to the long run time of a single run-out model evaluation and the large number of required model evaluations. 

    To address the research gap, this work proposes an efficient probabilistic calibration method for parameter estimation of landslide run-out models. The new method couples landslide run-out modeling, Bayesian inference, Gaussian process emulation, and active learning. We implement it in a Python-based environment. Its feasibility and efficiency are tested based on an extensive synthetic case study. Owing to Gaussian process emulation and active learning, our new method overcomes the computational bottleneck by reducing the number of required model evaluations from thousands to a few hundreds. It is therefore expected to advance the state-of-the-art in parameter estimation of landslide run-out models. In addition, the impact of different types of field data on calibration results is studied using the proposed method. 

    How to cite: Zhao, H. and Kowalski, J.: Efficient probabilistic parameter calibration of landslide run-out models via Bayesian active learning, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5338, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5338, 2022.

    EGU22-5590 | Presentations | NH3.1 | Highlight

    Antecedent rainfall could be a critical prerequisite for debris-flow triggering on steep slopes of arid regions 

    Shalev Siman-Tov and Francesco Marra

    Debris flows are fluidized, unconsolidated sediments that gravitationally flow downslope, and constitute one of the most impactful natural hazards in mountainous regions, with casualties and damage to infrastructures. They are typically triggered by heavy rain or sudden ice melt in mountainous and volcanic areas. In arid regions, where vegetation is sparse and not stabilizing, debris flows are occasionally observed when torrential rain showers hit the steep slopes. This is the case of our study area: the arid slopes of the Eastern Judean Desert, on the western margins of the Dead Sea. In this region, the mean annual precipitation does not exceed 100 mm yr-1. Currently, debris flows in this area are not considered an important hazard, because they are very rare and they mostly endanger infrastructures of natural reserves and main roads. However, previous studies reported a significant increase in their frequency during a late Holocene dry period, raising the question of whether their future occurrence could be affected by climate change. In this study, we focus on the critical rainfall conditions for debris flow triggering in these arid areas, which were not fully addressed by previous studies due to the small number of reported events. We combine high-resolution digital terrain models, to systematically identify small-size debris flows, with high-resolution weather radar data, to represent rainfall conditions corresponding to the debris flow locations. We identify over 40 debris flows by comparing digital elevation models available for the period 2013-2019. The deposits are relatively small (a few tens of meters) and are usually observed along the steepest slopes of the escarpment, at the outlet of small ephemeral streams. We divide the debris flows into four groups based on their spatial and temporal distribution. Using radar data and witness information, we identify three storms as the most likely triggering events for these groups, and we isolate the convective cells that led to the triggering. In all cases, debris flows were triggered by an intense convective cell (lasting 30 min to 1 hour) which was preceded by significant rainfall amounts (8-12 mm) delivered over relatively long times during the storm. Comparing triggering and non-triggering storms, we observe that rain intensity alone is insufficient to explain the phenomena: we discuss the possibility that antecedent conditions could represent a critical factor for the triggering of debris flows in steep slopes of arid environments.

    How to cite: Siman-Tov, S. and Marra, F.: Antecedent rainfall could be a critical prerequisite for debris-flow triggering on steep slopes of arid regions, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5590, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5590, 2022.

    EGU22-6045 | Presentations | NH3.1

    Integrated numerical modeling of a large debris flow in the Meilong catchment, China 

    Hui-Cong An, Chao-Jun Ouyang, and Fu-Lei Wang

    On June 17, 2020, a large debris flow occurred in the Meilong catchment following a short-duration, high-intensity rainstorm. The debris flow was initiated by two shallow landsides upstream of the catchment and had a volume of approximately 7.7×105 m3. It blocked the river and then induced flooding, which caused a great loss to the local residents. Through a combination of field observation, image interpretation and laboratory experiments, the initiation mechanism, erosion depth along the main channel and deposition area of this debris flow were comprehensively analyzed. A sequentially integrated numerical model considering the vegetation interception, infiltration and runoff process was developed. Considering the spatial variations in the climatic, hydrological and geotechnical parameters, the whole process of debris flow initiation, motion, entrainment and deposition were simulated. The computational outcomes matched well with the field observation results. A combination of the proposed integrated model and spatially varying parameters can be used to effectively describe the debris flow characteristics in the initiation and propagation stages and provide significant insights into physical processes involved in such hazards.

    How to cite: An, H.-C., Ouyang, C.-J., and Wang, F.-L.: Integrated numerical modeling of a large debris flow in the Meilong catchment, China, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6045, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6045, 2022.

    EGU22-6701 | Presentations | NH3.1

    Characteristics of Different Acoustic Emission Sources of Particles in Shearing Process 

    Ziming Liu, Yao Jiang, and Xingsheng Lu

    Debris flows and landslides are composed of granular materials with different grain sizes, shapes and mineral compositions. These geological hazards are complex evolutionary processes of granular structure from stable state to unstable destabilizing deformation, followed by large deformation flow. From the view of particle matter mechanics, the occurrence of these hazards is the process of the development of the particle assemblage comprising the geological body from a blocked state to a rheological state under the constraints of external boundaries. During the deformation process, the mutual collision, friction, fragmentation and structural changes between the particles will release strain energy and disperse it in the form of elastic waves, which is called acoustic emission (AE). Consequently, the characteristics of the acoustic emission signal generated during the deformation of granular materials and the changes of its parameters can be used to reflect the stability state inside the granular structure. We thus utilized three AE sensors to capture the elastic waves and investigated the relationships between characteristics of AE and mechanical behavior of granular deformation during direct shear tests with different normal stress, shear speed and grain sizes. Our results suggested that during the granular shearing process there was a strong correlation between stick-slip events and the distribution of AE characteristics. Some AE features - energy and Root Mean Square (RMS)- showed significant spatial clustering which can represent the different processes of stick-slip event. In particular, some low RMS and medium-high energy AEs represent internal local failure. And, the AE rate and B-value show a regular increase and decrease during the state of granular structure from stabilization to failure. All of them are valuable information for the prediction or early warning of geological hazards.

    How to cite: Liu, Z., Jiang, Y., and Lu, X.: Characteristics of Different Acoustic Emission Sources of Particles in Shearing Process, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6701, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6701, 2022.

    The shallow landslide-generated debris flow on hillside catchments plays a critical role in the change of landscape features caused by natural hazards. When these debris flows occur in dams or reservoirs, they reduce the efficiency of facilities, and when they occur in residential areas, they cause many casualties and property damage. To minimize such damages, some methods can be performed through 1) installation of the warning system and 2) construction of check dam. However, in the case of rainfall-induced debris flow, preparation through a warning system is challenging because debris flows very rapidly. Therefore, to reduce the damage caused by debris flow events, the check dam needs to be installed, and for an efficient installment, a study on numerical modeling needs to figure out. Therefore, in this study, the Deb2D numerical model was used to analyze the mitigation effect through the check dam. This model is a two-dimensional debris flow simulation software based on quadtree-grid. The debris flow was simulated by Voellmy rheology, and the erosion, entrainment, and deposition processes that must be considered for the analysis of debris flow were simulated through the algorithm suggested in our recent study. The Raemian apartment and Galram-ri debris flow events were analyzed which occurred at Mt. Umyeon in 2011 and Gangwon-do in the Republic of Korea. In addition, a check dam was hypothetical by changing the distance from the collapse zone. The efficient location can be suggested through the simulation results.

    Keywords: Debris flow; Numerical model; Check dam; Mitigation effect

    Acknowledgments

    This subject is supported by the Korea Ministry of Environment as “The SS projects; 2019002830001”

    How to cite: Lee, S., An, H., and Kim, M.: Analysis of debris flow according to the location of the check dam: suggesting the optimal location by numerical simulation, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6729, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6729, 2022.

    EGU22-6743 | Presentations | NH3.1 | Highlight

    Effects of vegetation root on hydro-mechanical properties of debris flow source 

    Mingyue Qin, Jian Guo, Yao Jiang, and Guotao Zhang

        In recent years, shallow landslides and debris flow usually have occurred successively in areas with good vegetation coverage, causing casualties and economic losses. After the occurrence of shallow landslides, the failure mass accumulated in the channel, providing the material source for debris flow. And the quantity of the failure mass determines the scale of debris flow. Therefore, it is an important basis for debris flow disaster management in vegetated mountainous areas to deeply understand the influence of vegetation on the hydro-mechanical properties of debris flow sources. This study takes the shallow landslides that occurred in Mengdong village, China in 2018 as the objects, analysis the changes in soil hydro-mechanical properties influenced by tree roots through field investigation and laboratory tests, and discusses the failure mechanism of the shallow landslides. The field investigation results indicate that the vertical root distribution can be expressed as an exponentially decayed polynomial model, that is, with the increase of depth, the distribution of tree roots increased first and then decreased. Furthermore, the maximum root area density is 0.266 mm2/cm2 at 20-40cm depth, and 80% of the roots are distributed in the soil above the slip surface. Laboratory test results show that the root-soil density above the slip surface was lower which was 1.04 g cm-3, and the maximum porosity of the root-soil is 61.23%. In addition, the saturated permeability of the root-soil above the slip surface is 10-17 times that of the soil below. The shear strength of the root-soil above the slip surface is lower than that below it under saturated conditions. The difference in root distribution and the resulting changes in the hydro-mechanical properties of soil may increase the risk of slope failure and the probability of debris flow after heavy rainfall. This research could be used as a reference for debris flow source analysis and hazard management.

    Keywords: Root-soil system; Landslide-induced debris flow; Geohazard chain; Hydro-mechanical properties

    How to cite: Qin, M., Guo, J., Jiang, Y., and Zhang, G.: Effects of vegetation root on hydro-mechanical properties of debris flow source, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6743, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6743, 2022.

    EGU22-6857 | Presentations | NH3.1

    Topographic analysis of debris flow gullies affected by tectonic activities on the edge of Qinghai-Tibet Plateau 

    Xinyue Liang, Yonggang Ge, Mengzhen Xu, and Liqun Lyu

    The collision between the Indian and the Eurasian Plates make crustal deformation and develop many faults of the Qinghai-Tibet Plateau. Debris flows affected by tectonic activities occur frequently and are various types on the edge of plateau. It is essential to scientifically categorize the debris flow gullies on active fault to understand their mechanisms, prevent and mitigate debris flow disasters. The tectonic landforms are the foundation for debris flows occurrence. Topographical measurements and statistical analyses of seven basins on the edge of the Qinghai-Tibet Plateau were carried out (Yarlung Zangbo River, Nu River, Indus River, Gaizi River, Bailong River, Xiaojiang River and Daheba River), in which typical debris flow gullies were concentrated. The results showed that debris flows were mainly distributed in the most active tectonic uplift zone of seven basins. The debris flow gullies were classified into three types by means of nonmetric multidimensional scaling. Type I was formed by rainstorms in exposed bedrock areas, Type II was formed by glaciers in exposed bedrock areas, and Type III was formed by rainstorms in depositional basins. Based on entropy method and fuzzy mathematics, the susceptibility of debris flow on seven watersheds was analyzed. Type I had good sediment connectivity due to rainstorms and main-river incision, and was easy to form small and middle-scale debris flow. Type II was easy to form high-frequency, middle and large-scale debris flows caused by abundant moraine deposit and good sediment transport under the glacier erosion. Type III was prone to form high-frequency and small-scale debris flows triggered by rainfall and loose depositional materials.

    How to cite: Liang, X., Ge, Y., Xu, M., and Lyu, L.: Topographic analysis of debris flow gullies affected by tectonic activities on the edge of Qinghai-Tibet Plateau, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6857, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6857, 2022.

    EGU22-6876 | Presentations | NH3.1

    Characteristics and Risk Assessment of Debris Flow Disasters along the Northern Sichuan-Tibet Highway 

    Yuqing Sun, Yonggang Ge, Xingzhang Chen, and Xiaojun Guo

    The Sichuan-Tibet Highway spans the Qinghai-Tibet Plateau and the Sichuan Basin. Due to its special geological and geographical environment of steep, cold, high earthquake intensity and high ground stress, it is one of the most typical areas characterized by most serious natural disasters in China. In particular, frequently occurred debris flow disasters seriously affect the distribution of highway lines, the stability of subgrade slopes, road traffic safety, etc. In order to better serve the early warning, forecasting and disaster prevention and mitigation works in disaster-prone areas, it is necessary to carry out risk assessment. Comparatively, the southern traffic line of Sichuan-Tibet Highway was more convenient with more relating researches. At present, little attention has been paid to the northern line of Sichuan-Tibet Highway. However, the northern line passed through Dege, Sichuan and Changdu, Tibet, which is of great value to the traffic and life of the local Han and Tibetan people. At the same time, the northern line passed through Ganzi-Luhuo earthquake zone, and a large section of the line was distributed in parallel along Xianshuihe fault zone, so the risk of debris flow disaster cannot be avoided, and the research significance of the northern line of Sichuan-Tibet Highway was evident. Therefore, in this paper, focus on the debris flow along the northern Sichuan-Tibet highway, combined with field investigation and GIS technology, the characteristics and pregnant environment of debris flow along the highway were analyzed, and the risk assessment of debris flow was carried out by the method of evidence weight. Based on the idea of "discretization", highway vulnerability assessment was carried out for highway structures and moving disaster-bearing bodies. Based on above researches, the debris flow risk zoning along the northern line of Sichuan-Tibet highway was completed. The results shown that: (1) There were 235 debris flows along the northern line of Sichuan-Tibet Highway, of which 136 were hidden danger spots and 101 were disaster spots, which are distributed in Daofu-Luhuo, Dege-Jiangda and Qamdo Karuo. (2) The hazards of debris flow on the northern line of Sichuan-Tibet Highway mainly include blocking culverts, impacting bridges and burying roads. Among the existing 136 hidden danger points of debris flows, 44% of which directly affect culverts, 39% of which were bridges, and 17% were hidden danger points or damaging roadbed/roads. (3) The risk zone of debris flow in the northern Sichuan-Tibet highway indicated that the middle and high-risk road sections taking part of 63.30%, more than half of which were mainly distributed in Jiangda County, dege county and Luhuo-daofu county, which were basically in consistent with the distribution of major debris flow disaster points in the study area and verified the reliability of the evaluation results in this paper. The risk zoning map obtained from this research provided references for risk avoidance, disaster prevention and mitigation of debris flow along the northern Sichuan-Tibet highway.

    How to cite: Sun, Y., Ge, Y., Chen, X., and Guo, X.: Characteristics and Risk Assessment of Debris Flow Disasters along the Northern Sichuan-Tibet Highway, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6876, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6876, 2022.

    EGU22-7428 | Presentations | NH3.1

    The initiation of runoff-generated debris flow in steep carbonate catchments 

    Oliver Francis and Hui Tang

    Debris flows are a common hazard in Alpine headwater catchments during intense convective rainstorms. These debris flows are commonly triggered by runoff entraining previously deposited sediment within the catchment. A debris flow will be initiated if rainfall exceeds the given rainfall intensity threshold. We usually define the rainfall intensity threshold as a function of storm duration (rainfall intensity-duration threshold). Above this empirically recorded threshold, the resulting surface runoff can mobilise sediment from the hillslopes and within the channel network. Thresholds are usually defined empirically for a given geographic region via monitoring of debris flow occurrence and the triggering rainfall intensity. However, direct field observations and rainfall data are sparse and noisy, and it is impossible to define rainfall thresholds when historical data are unavailable. An alternative methodology to derive rainfall ID thresholds is to use simplified physics-based model simulations. In this case, a greater understanding of the controlling factors for debris-flow activities could enable better threshold estimation in unmonitored catchments.

    Here we present the initial simulation results of three different monitored catchments in the Dolomite mountains of Northeast Italy. These catchments are dominated by steep dolomite bedrock walls, which can provide large volumes of surface runoff to the catchment during rainfall. To simulate the response to rainfall in these catchments, we use the SWEHR (Shallow Water Equation & Harsine Rose) debris flow model, which we calibrate using a combination of field data and a correlation maximising framework. By focusing on the runoff response to rainfall in the catchments, we identified several key factors in the calibration of the model. The timing and magnitude of the runoff is controlled by the hydrological characteristics of the bedrock, the roughness of the catchment, the availability of sediment in the catchment, and the characteristics of the rainfall. By running multiple rainfall simulations for the catchments, we show how these factors impact rainfall ID thresholds

    How to cite: Francis, O. and Tang, H.: The initiation of runoff-generated debris flow in steep carbonate catchments, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7428, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7428, 2022.

    EGU22-7533 | Presentations | NH3.1 | Highlight

    In-channel landslide deposits and future debris flows 

    Tommaso Baggio, Francesco Bettella, and Vincenzo D'Agostino

    Debris flows/floods are natural hazards occurring in steep mountain catchments. Debris material mainly derives from processes of channel/channel head, bed erosion, bank destabilization or shallow landslides. More rarely landslide deposits within the channel could be sources of debris. Some studies pointed out the potential increment in debris flow magnitude because the flow may increase its volume and peak discharge after the impacts against an in-channel deposit. The objective of this investigation is to estimate the potential consequences of a debris flow impacting a landslide deposit located in the channel bed.

    The project has been developed analysing the rio Rudan catchment (Belluno province, North-eastern Italy), characterized by a frequent occurrence of debris flows in the last decades. In the rio Rudan a wide shallow landslide, highly connected to the transport channel reach,   occurred on the 15th December 2020 and deposited the majority of the volume within the channel. The landslide was capable to generate only a low magnitude debris flow (of the order of 10’000 m3). Most of the released material (40’000 m3) remained in the channel close to the slope failure zone. In order to analyse the effects of following different types of debris-flows encountering the deposit, different scenarios have been simulated considering the landslide deposit as an entrainable layer. We created five triangular shaped input debris flow hydrographs characterized by different peak discharge (20, 40, 60, 80 and 100 m3 s-1) and a flow hydrograph representing a debris flood (peak of 20 m3s-1). Simulations have been performed using the r.avaflow model (version 2.4) for which we employed the two-phase routing model together with the empirical erosion model.

    Results of the simulations showed that the magnitude of possible future debris flow events was reduced due to the presence of the landslide deposit. In particular, the peak discharges of the simulated output debris flow hydrograph was reduced of 60-70% compared to the input hydrograph. Even if the coefficient of erosion was set to high values, the quantity of entrained material was low and, surprisingly, most of the solid component of the simulated debris flows deposited in the upper part of the landslide deposit due to the decrease in slope. Most of the erosion process occurred in the lower part of the deposit for the increase in slope. Conversely, in the numerical simulation of the longer-duration debris flood event (or even characterized by multiple peak discharge), the landslide deposit has proved to furnish a constant input of debris material, magnifying the total volume of the event but not the peak discharge. Looking at the results of the simulated case study, we can conclude that the big landslide deposit within the Rudan channel could have a mitigation effect in reducing the peak discharge of future debris flow events considering those debris flows with an important (return periods of 20-30 years) but not extreme magnitude. This highlights the importance of a dedicated modelling in companion cases to avoid excessive costs for interventions and to correctly assess residual risks in case of non-interventions.

    How to cite: Baggio, T., Bettella, F., and D'Agostino, V.: In-channel landslide deposits and future debris flows, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7533, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7533, 2022.

    In the last decade, major debris flows events in remote areas of the semi-arid central Andes of Chile have led to critical water supply shortages for large populated areas such as Santiago de Chile. There is therefore a crucial need for modelling debris-flow sediment connectivity to stream channels to identify both vulnerable stream channel sections and sediment source locations to focus mitigation efforts to ensure the reliability of drinking water supplies. In this research, we couple a statistical learning model of debris flow source areas with a process-based random-walk runout simulation to estimate the probability of source areas connecting to stream channel networks in a large catchment area of the upper Maipo river basin using a 12.5 m resolution digital elevation model. The runout model parameters are regionally optimised and validated using a spatial cross-validation approach.   Additionally, we perform network analysis to model the cumulative impact of potential debris flow sediment delivery to the stream channel network. The proposed methods are also designed for flexibility to adapt for assessing potential debris flow impacts and source areas corresponding to other critical features such as roads and buildings. Overall, the resulting predictive models of  runout sources and impacted areas provide not only valuable insights for characterising the potential impacts of debris-flows on stream channel networks, but also provides a model framework that can be potentially linked to weather forecast data for establishing early-warning systems of debris-flow related water supply shortages and quality issues in remote areas. 

    How to cite: Goetz, J., Buchhart, M., and Brenning, A.: Modelling debris-flow source-area connectivity and impacted stream channels in the semi-arid central Andes of Chile using random walks and network analysis, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7596, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7596, 2022.

    The impact of mountain disasters on human society continues to increase under the background of climate change and social economy development, especially for the developing countries or regions with relatively backward social and economic development level and fragile natural ecological environment. China is one of the countries suffered most serious mountain disasters in the world. In particular, after Wenchuan earthquake in 2008, the frequency and scale of secondary mountain disasters caused by heavy rainfall and the earthquake increased significantly, which seriously threatens the life and property safety and post-disaster reconstruction in earthquake-hit areas. Therefore, some events with mass deaths and injuries occurred. For example, on July 10, 2013, the massive landslide in Sanxi Village, Zhongxing Town, Dujiangyan City, Sichuan Province caused 166 deaths or missing. On June 24, 2017, the high mountain collapse in Xinmu Village, Dixi Town, Maoxian County, Sichuan Province buried 62 farm houses, caused 10 deaths, 73 missing and 3 injures. What’s more, mountain disasters also caused mass deaths and injuries in some areas less affected by Wenchuan earthquake. On June 28, 2012, the large debris flow occurred in Aizi Gully, Ningnan County, Sichuan Province, China was the annually most serious debris flow in construction site in China, resulting in 40 deaths or missing. On June 28, 2020, debris flow caused 17 deaths or missing in Caogu Township, Mianning County, Liangshan Prefecture, China. Lots of disaster cases show that disaster awareness and emergency capacity are the base of scientific emergency avoidance,which  is one of the important ways to reduce the casualties of mountain disasters in high-risk areas. Through the analysis of disaster cases, the experience and lessons of mountain disasters in western China were summarized and the measures to avoid mass deaths and injuries in the process of mountain disaster emergency avoidance were explored. So this research aims to  provide a scientific basis for the reduction of casualties in mountain disasters in similar areas.

    How to cite: Chen, R., Tan, R., and Zhang, J.: How to avoid mass deaths in the emergency avoidance process of mountain disasters: Lessons from the mountainous areas of western China, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7878, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7878, 2022.

    We present a method to obtain a parameter (b) that allows to analytically reproduce the shape of the increase in amplitude at high frequencies in time of the SON (Signal Onset) section of the spectrogram of seismic signals generated by gravitational mass movements (snow avalanches, lahars and debris flows) descending a slope and approaching a seismic sensor. This increasing shape is a consequence of the appearance of energy at high frequencies as the gravitational mass approaches the seismic sensor. The developed method to obtain the parameter (b) allows to analytically reproduce the increasing shape of the SON section. Since this shape is related to the speed of the avalanche and the characteristics of the terrain, the parameter allows us to "classify" the mass movement with only one sensor. This methodology includes a link between the propagation properties of seismic waves and the results of the application of an image processing using the Hough transform.

    Depending on the type of event, differences are obtained in the order of magnitude of the values of b. The mean value of b for lahars is around 0.003 s-1, that for debris flows is an order of magnitude greater (0.017 s-1) and an order of magnitude less than that for avalanches (0.12 s-1). Furthermore, differences in b are observed within each type of event. This fact allows us to create a template with different values of parameter b to help in the classification within each type of mass movement by only superimpose graphically the corresponding spectrogram with the appropriate template when they are at the same scale.

    Once the value of b has been determined, the characteristics of the mass movement should be set according to the judgment of experts. This must be done for each site and for each type of gravitational mass movement. The application to one lahar and one debris flow is presented as an example.

    How to cite: Suriñach, E. and Flores Márquez, E. L.: A Template To Obtain Information On Gravitational Mass Movements From The Spectrograms Of The Seismic Signals Generated, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8600, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8600, 2022.

    EGU22-9131 | Presentations | NH3.1

    Towards a simple predictive erosive debris-flow model calibrated with contrasting environmental settings 

    Verena Stammberger, Andreas Dietrich, and Michael Krautblatter

    Debris flows are fast, hazardous and massively erosive mass movements that can cause severe danger to infrastructure and have been responsible for a significant number of casualties in the last decades. The European and German Alps face an increasing frequency and magnitude of hazardous debris-flows due to more frequent rainstorms in a warming climate. While the erodibility of the channel bed is a major contributor to the magnitude of debris-flows and the effective erosion often represents more than 80% of the final volume (Dietrich and Krautblatter, 2019) which, it is not or not sufficiently implemented in present debris-flow models.

    Here, we present a concept of a simple predictive erosive debris-flow model calibrated with two erosive debris-flow events in the German Alps in June 2015. Both torrent channels were recorded with terrestrial laser scans and compared with an airborne laser scan performed in 2007. The detected geomorphic change was subdivided by same-length segments and correlated with modelled flow velocities at the cross-sections between the segments. The flow velocity at the cross sections was calculated by individual RAMMS Debris Flow simulations for every segment, each including the cumulated erosion volume of the sections upstream as well as the initial volume estimated from a rainfall-runoff calculation. As a result, we obtain a linear relationship between flow velocity and mean erosion depth, which can be used in a predictive debris-flow model to iteratively calculate the entrainment in every channel segment.

    By analysing further geological and topographical debris-flow settings, we aim to create an inventory of different catchment characteristics and calibrate the model to various dimensions and properties. This would enable enhanced magnitude predictions of anticipated erosive debris-flows in comparable catchments by a fully forward-modelling approach.

    Reference:

    Dietrich, A. and Krautblatter M. (2019): Deciphering controls for debris-flow erosion derived from a LiDAR-recorded extreme event and a calibrated numerical model (Roßbichelbach, Germany). Earth Surface Processes and Landforms 44: 1346-1361, doi: https://doi.org/10.1002/esp.4578.

    How to cite: Stammberger, V., Dietrich, A., and Krautblatter, M.: Towards a simple predictive erosive debris-flow model calibrated with contrasting environmental settings, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9131, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9131, 2022.

    EGU22-9738 | Presentations | NH3.1

    Assessing the solid-liquid discharge and rheological behavior of debris flow. A numerical model of a case study. 

    Veronica Zoratti, Silvia Bosa, Elisa Arnone, and Marco Petti

    The Friuli Venezia Giulia (FVG) region, located in the northeast of Italy, is characterised by frequent heavy precipitations that recurrently trigger debris flow phenomena. On August 2003, an intense rainfall concentrated in the north-eastern Julian Alps of FVG produced several floods and debris flow events, widespread on the entire basin of the Fella river watershed, with great economic damage and some casualties.

    In the light of this, forecasting tools for the debris-flow analysis are useful with a view to a territorial planning. The general aim of our research is to develop a hydro-morphodynamical framework to study debris flow phenomena, which includes the hydrological modelling of the rainfall triggering event, the estimate of the solid-liquid discharge of the debris-flow and the hydraulic modelling of its propagation.

    While previous works have accomplished the hydrological analysis, in the present study we focus on the evaluation of the solid-liquid discharge and the simulation of its propagation down the slope till its stop. Specifically, we considered a sub-basin of the Fella river watershed, the Uque at Ugovizza, and, in particular, a sub-area of the basin from which the debris flow that swept the village of Ugovizza in 2003 came off. The resulting liquid discharge obtained from the previous hydrological analysis was the input data to derive the solid-liquid discharge of the debris flow, which was assessed by using a formulation proposed in literature.

    In order to study the propagation of the debris flow, we first identified a rheology model suitable to represent this kind of events. This was then implemented into an in-house numerical model, which integrates the bidimensional shallow water equations by means of finite volume techniques. Furthermore, an appropriate runout criterion was also assessed, so that the final stages of the phenomenon can be represented.

    The first results of the application of the developed hydro-morphodynamic framework to this case study are presented and discussed.

    How to cite: Zoratti, V., Bosa, S., Arnone, E., and Petti, M.: Assessing the solid-liquid discharge and rheological behavior of debris flow. A numerical model of a case study., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9738, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9738, 2022.

    EGU22-10670 | Presentations | NH3.1

    A hybrid modelling approach to debris flow modelling combining physical and numerical simulations 

    Bendik Hansen, Elena Pummer, Fjóla Sigtryggsdóttir, Julia Kowalski, and Hu Zhao

    Debris flows pose a significant threat to human life and infrastructure due to the extreme forces they bring into play. In order to prevent and mitigate the effect of such events, a fundamental understanding of processes related to debris flows is required. To this end, we used a hybrid modelling approach combining physical and numerical modelling to simulate debris flows

    The physical model that served as the basis for the numerical one was a seesaw-like plexiglass flume with a hinge in the middle and sediment reservoirs at the two extreme ends. The hinge enabled the movement of the debris flow back and forth between the reservoirs when the flume was tipped, thus providing reproducible initial (sediment composition) and boundary (slope, roughness) conditions for each run. The physical model was 0.3 m wide and 4 m long, in addition to 0.5 m at each end (lengthwise) working as sediment reservoirs.  Velocity and flow height data were recorded at four points along the flume.

    We used the mass flow modelling software r.avaflow to reproduce the physical model runs with varying slopes (20, 25, and 30 degrees) and solid contents (40, 50, and 60 %). The model included simulations with both multiphase flow (unique processes for solids and fluids) and a Voellmy-type mixture model (mass represented as one homogenous block). The present study shows the preliminary findings of the research, but the long-term goal is to utilize a hybrid modelling approach to combine the advantages of real data from physical modelling with the increased potential for data extraction and number of model runs that we get from numerical modelling to perform detailed sensitivity and uncertainty analyses with probabilistic simulations in future work.

    How to cite: Hansen, B., Pummer, E., Sigtryggsdóttir, F., Kowalski, J., and Zhao, H.: A hybrid modelling approach to debris flow modelling combining physical and numerical simulations, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10670, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10670, 2022.

    EGU22-10812 | Presentations | NH3.1 | Highlight

    Sediment production and transport processes in an arctic watershed undergoing climate change  

    Marisa Palucis, Jill Marshall, and Justin Strauss

    Arctic landscapes are among the most vulnerable on Earth to climate change, largely due to the degradation and thawing of permafrost. In steeper bedrock-dominated terrains, slope instability from warming permafrost leads to larger and more frequent rockfall and frost cracking events, which in turn increases the production and delivery of sediment to hillslopes and channel networks by debris flow and fluvial processes. However, there is a fundamental lack of data on past and current rates of sediment production and transport in Arctic watersheds. Without an understanding of these phenomena, it is impossible to predict the transient responses, rates, and directions of periglacial processes in response to future climate change. To begin to address this knowledge gap, we conducted a field-based study of the Black Mountain catchment in the Aklavik Range (Northwest Territories, Canada). This site was chosen due to its position within a zone of continuous permafrost and the presence of an alluvial fan at the base of the catchment, providing a closed system.

    In the summer of 2019, after a summer storm event, we observed several debris flows that initiated from ice-filled gullies, as well as fluvial sediment transport from snowmelt. We documented flow and sediment transport conditions on the fan, yielding modern-day fluvial transport rates of 0.2–2 m3/hr for water runoff rates of 0.01–0.2 mm/hr. However, less-frequent mass flow events can rapidly deposit large amounts of sediment. For example, we estimate that a mass flow event that occurred in 2016 delivered ~1.5*105 m3 of sediment to the fan—equivalent to ~8–85 years of continuous fluvial sediment transport. Based on our surficial and sedimentological mapping, the fan has likely been forming under a periglacial climate over the last ~13,000 years from a combination of mass flow and fluvial processes. Most of the fan (~67%) was deposited fluvially, but the upper, steeper portion of the fan was deposited by coarse granular debris flows. We hypothesize that accelerated warming has increased sediment supply due to frost cracking, leading to aggradation, increased debris flow activity, and upper fan steepening.

    How to cite: Palucis, M., Marshall, J., and Strauss, J.: Sediment production and transport processes in an arctic watershed undergoing climate change , EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10812, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10812, 2022.

    EGU22-11039 | Presentations | NH3.1

    Three-dimensional numerical simulation of granular flow with a GPU-accelerated SPH model 

    Can Huang, Qingquan Liu, and Xiaoliang Wang

    A smoothed particle hydrodynamics (SPH) has obtained wildly application to granular flow and soil failure problems in last two decades. The computational efficiency is limited by the number of particles, which makes it difficult for SPH to be applied to large-scale examples. In this study, we develop a three-dimensional SPH model based on Drucker–Prager closure with a non-associated plastic flow rule, which is accelerated by employing the GPU technology. A typical three-dimensional granular slope case is simulated with 44 million particles for 88.5 hours. GPU acceleration technology significantly improves the computing efficiency almost 200 times than single-core CPU for large scale geotechnical problems with more than 10 million SPH particles. Multiple shear bands are observed in this simulation, which reveal the failure mechanism of granular flow.

    How to cite: Huang, C., Liu, Q., and Wang, X.: Three-dimensional numerical simulation of granular flow with a GPU-accelerated SPH model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11039, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11039, 2022.

    EGU22-11100 | Presentations | NH3.1

    Experimental measurement of kinematic behavior of particle collisions in ambient liquid 

    Jiajun Jiao, Yiyang Zhou, Yi An, and Qing-quan Liu

    The collisions of a particle against other particles or walls in the ambient fluid are one of the key processes in debris flow. Understanding the kinematics of this process, especially the role of particle rotation, is of great significance. We conducted a series of experiments studying the kinematics of a free-falling sphere colliding with a flat wall in the ambient fluids. Seven water-glycerol mixtures of different viscosities and densities are used. The kinematic behavior of the sphere is measured using both MEMS and optical techniques. The relationships between the coefficient of restitution (CR), contact time, and the Stokes number (St) are obtained. We found that when the St is greater than the upper critical value (448), the coefficient of restitution is stable at around 0.63. With the decrease of St, the CR drops rapidly before it approaches 0 when St is less than the lower critical value. The rotation process leads to wider distribution of CR. These results implicit the particle-particle collision might be significantly different when the viscosity of the liquid phase in debris flow varies and the particle scale kinematics of the particle phase is not trivial.

    How to cite: Jiao, J., Zhou, Y., An, Y., and Liu, Q.: Experimental measurement of kinematic behavior of particle collisions in ambient liquid, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11100, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11100, 2022.

    EGU22-11123 | Presentations | NH3.1

    Deflection effect in the interaction between granular flow and semi-ellipsoid obstacle array 

    Wangxin Yu, Su Yang, Xiaoliang Wang, and Qing-quan Liu

    Granular flow impacting structures is an important problem in the research of providing scientific basis for disaster prediction and mitigation, so it is of great significance to deepen the understanding of the interaction law. We studied the spread and deposit behaviors of fast granular flow impacting an array of semi-ellipsoid obstacles with different parameters such as the height, distribution density and deflection angle. It is found that the flow and deposit state of granular matter are controlled by the obstacle array through both dissipation and deflection effect. We quantified the deposit behavior by two dimensionless indices, one pre-existing index called runout efficiency, and a new proposed index termed as deflection efficiency. This work would provide help in designing protective obstacle arrays by exploring the relationship between regulation effect and parameters of the obstacle array.

    How to cite: Yu, W., Yang, S., Wang, X., and Liu, Q.: Deflection effect in the interaction between granular flow and semi-ellipsoid obstacle array, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11123, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11123, 2022.

    EGU22-11688 | Presentations | NH3.1

    Numerical modelling of the potential for landslide-induced tsunamis, Mount Gamalama, Indonesia 

    Saaduddin Saaduddin, Jurgen Neuberg, Mark Thomas, and Jon Hill

    Mount Gamalama is a stratovolcano forming Ternate Island in Indonesia. Collapse of the volcanoes flank has the potential to generate large tsunamis, potentially mega-tsunamis. This active volcanic island has a history of tsunami generation in 1608, 1840, and 1871. However, the generation mechanism of these tsunamis is unknown. Numerical simulation was used to understand the level of instability of the volcano flanks and the travel time and velocity of of the potential landslides and ensuing tsunamis on nearby coastlines. We also determined the factors that affect the size of the tsunami generated. An open-source finite-element code, Fluidity, was used to simulate the tsunami generation and propagation. A three-material model is considered: a viscous subaerial slide material, water, and air to capture the complex physics and interaction of the landslide and water. The results show that the subaerial mass failure takes around 2 to 6 minutes to enter the sea and can generate an initial wave of heights ranging from 35 m to 110 m. A volcanic flank collapse on Mount Gamalama would therefore have serious implications for the coastal population in neighbouring islands and submarine infrastructures like underwater cables.

    How to cite: Saaduddin, S., Neuberg, J., Thomas, M., and Hill, J.: Numerical modelling of the potential for landslide-induced tsunamis, Mount Gamalama, Indonesia, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11688, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11688, 2022.

    EGU22-12035 | Presentations | NH3.1

    Modeling the run-out behavior of the July 23rd, 2015 Cancia debris-flow event using two numerical models 

    Zhitian Qiao, Wei Shen, Matteo Berti, and Tonglu Li

    Numerical models have become a useful tool for predicting the potential risk caused by debris flows. Although a variety of numerical models have been proposed for the runout simulation of debris flows, the differences and performances of these models are unknown. To this end, in this paper, two typical depth-averaged models have been selected to analyze the debris-flow event that occurred in the Cancia basin on July 23rd, 2015. The simulations with and without entrainment are conducted to analyze the influence of entrainment on the runout behavior of the debris flow. The simulated results are compared and discussed in detail. In the scenario without entrainment, a part of the debris mass deviates from the main path during propagation, while the debris mass propagates along the channel if entrainment is considered. This conclusion illustrates that entrainment cannot be ignored in this case. Additionally, the comparison between measured and simulated results shows that both models perform generally well in the terms of simulating the erosion-deposition distribution, but the DAN3D model will present a greater lateral spreading and a thinner depositional thickness than Shen’s model.

    How to cite: Qiao, Z., Shen, W., Berti, M., and Li, T.: Modeling the run-out behavior of the July 23rd, 2015 Cancia debris-flow event using two numerical models, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12035, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12035, 2022.

    EGU22-12299 | Presentations | NH3.1

    Modelling debris flows to enhance disaster risk management in the Zhouqu region, Gansu China 

    Kristine Jarsve, Xilin Xia, Tom Dijkstra, Qiuhua Liang, Xingmin Meng, Yi Zhang, and Alessandro Novellini

    The Zhouqu area of the Bailong River Basin (Z-BRB), Gansu Province, China is an area covering some 400 km2 and is characterised by a dynamic natural environment where lives, livelihoods and critical infrastructures are at risk from flooding and various mass movements in rock and soil. The Z-BRB area is characterized by a neo-tectonically active environment with high topographic relief and elevations ranging from 1200 m to more than 4000 m. Mass movements include large earthflows (several are more than 3 km in length), rock falls and debris flows, and these play a prominent role in shaping this landscape. The area is developing rapidly, going through major expansions of urban communities and infrastructure networks. To achieve long-term sustainable development, it is urgently needed to identify the spatial and temporal patterns of multiple, and often interacting geohazards. Dynamic terrains, such as in the Z-BRB area, evolve over time. The current state of the landscape is adjusting to a range of influences that can be thought of as a nested hierarchy of processes acting over different scales, both in time and space. To gain an improved insight into this state of the landscape it is important to unpack this hierarchy, identify interactions between processes and identify their magnitudes and rates of change. By combining geomorphological mapping and numerical modelling of landslides and tying it together with an understanding of the different timelines of the various processes our goal is to develop a risk management framework for the Z-BRB area. Currently the research is focused on modelling of debris flows using the numerical model HiPIMS, which couples shallow water and sediment transport equations. HiPIMS has been calibrated against a physical experiment and the 2010 Zhouqu disaster. This enhances our confidence that the model can be applied in similar catchments elsewhere in the Z-BRB. The aim of the modelling is to identify catchments at risk of debris flows, investigate how climate change, i.e.  higher precipitation and more extreme rainfall events, will affect the catchments, and how mitigation measures such as check dams will cope with an increase in magnitude and frequency of debris flows/mobility of earthflows.

    How to cite: Jarsve, K., Xia, X., Dijkstra, T., Liang, Q., Meng, X., Zhang, Y., and Novellini, A.: Modelling debris flows to enhance disaster risk management in the Zhouqu region, Gansu China, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12299, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12299, 2022.

    Recently deglaciated terrain is highly active and subject to enhanced geomorphological change. The tropical glaciers on Cotopaxi volcano (5897 masl) in Ecuador are rapidly declining and have lost more than 50% of their surface area within the last five decades, and climate models predict a future rise of the Equilibrium Line Altitude of at least 200 m within the next 50 years (Vuille et al., 2018). The retreat of the presumably polythermal glaciers exposes unconsolidated, previously frozen pyroclastic material and moraine deposits on the steep volcano flanks. In recent years, secondary lahars unrelated to obvious trigger mechanisms occurred at Cotopaxi. As these lahars originated in proglacial areas, we aim to explore a potential connection between glacier retreat and lahar formation.

    Here, we provide first insights into scarcely investigated subsurface conditions in periglacial areas of tropical glaciers. In order to gain knowledge on the presence of permafrost and ground ice, which can act as an aquiclude and potential detachment plane, we installed temperature loggers at 5-10 cm depth and performed electrical resistivity and seismic refraction surveys in the glacier forefields between 5000 and 5300 masl. The 1.5-year temperature record shows positive mean annual ground temperatures at all six logger sites. However, the temperature-calibrated electrical resistivity tomogram indicates partly frozen ground at depths of 10-20 m, where high electrical resistivities correspond to calibrated rock temperatures of -1.3 °C. We apply a 1-D thermal model to reproduce temperature changes at the surface with depth due to the retreat of cold-based glaciers. It allows to estimate the effect of the pyroclastic cover with high ice contents, which dampens thermal changes by uptake of latent heat during thawing, and can contribute to maintain ice bodies or relict permafrost lenses for years after deglaciation. In this study, we explore the relevance of degrading permafrost and ice lenses for preconditioning periglacial secondary lahars on rapidly deglaciating tropical volcanoes.

    Vuille, M., Carey, M., Huggel, C., Buytaert, W., Rabatel, A., Jacobsen, D., Soruco, A., Villacis, M., Yarleque, C. and Timm, O. E. 2018. Rapid decline of snow and ice in the tropical Andes–Impacts, uncertainties and challenges ahead. Earth-Science Reviews, 176, 195-213.

    How to cite: Frimberger, T. and Krautblatter, M.: Investigating subsurface conditions favouring the formation of secondary lahars in the glacier forefields of Cotopaxi volcano, Ecuador, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12737, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12737, 2022.

    Gode Bola1,4, Raphael M. Tshimanga1, Jeff Neal2,  Laurence Hawker2, Mark A. Trigg3, Lukanda Mwamba4 , Paul Bates2

    1 Congo Basin Water Resources Research Center (CRREBaC) & Department of Natural Resources Management, University of Kinshasa, DR Congo

    2School of Geographical Sciences, University of Bristol, United Kingdom

    3School of Civil Engineering, University of Leeds, United Kingdom

    4General Commission of Atomic Energy, Regional Center for Nuclear Study, Kinshasa, DR Congo

    Flood disasters have always been reported in the Congo Basin with significant damages to human lives, food production systems and infrastructure. Losses incurred by these damages are huge and represent a major challenge for economic expansion in developing nations. In the Congo River Basin, where the availability of in-situ data is a significant challenge, new approaches are needed to investigate flood risks and enable effective management strategies. This study uses recently developed global flood prediction data in order to produce flood risk maps for the Congo River Basin, where flood information currently does not exist. Flood hazard maps that estimate fluvial flooding at a grid cell resolution of 3 arc-seconds (~ 90 m), gridded population density data of 1 arc-second (~ 30 m) spatial resolution, and a spatial layer of infrastructure dataset are used to address flood risk at the scale of the Congo Basin. The global flood data provide different return periods of exposure to flooding in the Congo Basin and identifies flood extents. The risk analysis results are presented in terms of the percentage of population and infrastructure at flood risk for six return periods (5, 10, 20, 50, 75 and 100 years). Of the 525 administrative territories, 374 are exposed to fluvial floods, and 38 (10 %) of them are categorised as risk hotspots. Analysis shows that the most exposed territories represent 1% of total exposure which is estimated at 2.65% of the basin’s population. This study demonstrates the first and potentially most important stage in developing flood responses by determining the flood hazards areas and the population/infrastructures that would be exposed. The flood risk maps produced in this study provide information necessary to support policy decisions of flood disasters prevention, including prioritisation of interventions to reduce flood risk in the CRB.

    Keywords: Flood hazard, Risk assessment, Return period, Congo River Basin

     

    How to cite: Gode, B. B.: Multi return periods flood hazards and risks assessment in the Congo River Basin, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-248, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-248, 2022.

    EGU22-389 | Presentations | NH1.2

    Hydraulic zoom: a hydrological/hydrodynamic downscaling framework from regional to local scale 

    Gabriel Narváez and Rodrigo Paiva

    Flooding is the most damaging natural hazard in terms of economic and population affected. Hydrological-hydraulic models are essential tools for evaluating the risks associated with flooding since they provide a physically based approach. In this work, we propose a novel approach that takes advantage of the coverage advantages of large-scale modeling and the accurate representation of local modeling, where high-resolution data are available. A dynamic downscaling framework, so-called hydraulic zoom, has been created by coupling the local relevant discharge estimation of the large-scale models with the detailed local representation of the reach-scale models. The large-scale hydrological model (MGB) is employed for estimating the inflow, rainfall excesses, infiltration, and evaporation from open water in order to use as input into an area in which the flow is solved through the full shallow waters formulation. The HEC-RAS 2D 6.1 is applied for solving the 2D dynamic equations. Besides, HEC-RAS enables forcing rainfall excess distributed inside the 2D area by the rain-on-grid approach while also allowing incorporate evaporation and infiltration. 

    The hydraulic zoom is applied in the Itajai-Açu river basin of 15000 km2 in Southern Brazil in the Santa Catarina State. The 2D area is about 833.6 km2, considering  95 km of the main river until the outlet into the sea. The 2D area modeled is highly prone to floods, recording flood events with more than 53 deaths and more than 1 million affected people only between 1983 and 2011.

    Estimations from MGB and from HEC-RAS 2D (fed with the MGB outputs) are compared against observed water surface level (WSE), WSE anomalies, and flood extent. The results reveal that streamflows estimated by a regional hydrological model can be incorporated into a local model improving in mean the estimations in about 41% (0.8 m) for WSE, 29% (0.35m) for WSE anomalies, and 10% of the Fit metric for flood extent. This hydraulic zoom framework reveals greate potential of producing high-resolution flood hazard maps allowing also representing pluvial floods, with regional distribution but local resolution. 

    How to cite: Narváez, G. and Paiva, R.: Hydraulic zoom: a hydrological/hydrodynamic downscaling framework from regional to local scale, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-389, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-389, 2022.

    EGU22-687 | Presentations | NH1.2

    QGIS-based Autonomous Process and Arc River Data Repository for Efficient Flood Inundation and Hazard Mapping 

    Kyungdong Kim, Hojun You, Dongsu Kim, and Yeonghwa Gwon

    Abstract

    Flood inundation and hazard maps have played various crucial roles in terms of municipal hazard planning, timely flood control countermeasure operation, economic levee design, and developing flood forecasting or nowcasting systems. Given that the riparian areas prone to flood conventionally imposed special cares to justify applications of recently available flood inundation or hazard assessment numerical models on top of digital elevation models of dense spatial resolution such as LiDAR irrespective of their high costs. However, laborious and time & cost-consuming processes were required to proficiently produce inundation and hazard maps, which includes preparation of geometric and hydrologic data as input for the targeted numerical model, executing the model and post-processing, and inundation and subsequent hazard mapping. For example in Korea, field surveyed geometric dataset are provided in CAD format and should have to be manually converted into cross-sectional information compatible with HEC-RAS as a numerical model, where such dataset are not managed in centralized and standardized database. Then, flood inundation and hazard maps are generated one by one based on flood stage heights simulated from the HEC-RAS, where additional tools such as HEC-GeoRAS or manual drawing against DEM are usually applied. In order to efficiently and cost-effectively provide a series of flood inundation and hazard maps automatically with minimum practitioner involvement, this study demonstrates a set of open-source based tools that automated flood and hazard mapping processes as follows: a) parse CAD files containing geometric surveys like cross-sections and store them into server-based Arc River database approachable through website; b) retrieve geometric information using RiverML from Arc River and implicitly make them compatible with HEC-RAS input format; c) execute the HEC-RAS with some designated boundary conditions and various flood discharge; d) parse HEC-RAS output in binary format and draw flood inundation and hazard map on a given DEM through a developed add-on in QGIS using Python. We found that the proposed entire autonomous processes substantially enhanced efficiency and accuracy for flood mapping. The spatial accuracy of flood inundation and hazard map after applying above processes were validated throughout comparison with an inundation trace map acquired from typhoon Nari, 2007, in Hancheon basin located in Jeju Island, Korea, where a series of inundation and hazard maps were comprehensively investigated to track the burst of flood in the extreme flood events.

     

    Acknowledgment

    This work was supported by the US Geological Survey Cooperative Grant Agreement #G19AC00257 and by the Korea Agency for Infrastructure Technology Advancement (KAIA) grant funded by the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport (21AWMP- B121092-06).

    How to cite: Kim, K., You, H., Kim, D., and Gwon, Y.: QGIS-based Autonomous Process and Arc River Data Repository for Efficient Flood Inundation and Hazard Mapping, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-687, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-687, 2022.

    EGU22-1137 | Presentations | NH1.2

    Investigation of Air-Bubble Screen on Reducing Scour in River Facility 

    Kuo-Wei Liao and Zhen-Zhi Wang

    This study proposes an innovative idea to reduce scour in river structures via air-bubble screens, which does not provoke a significant impact on the ecological environment. Check dam is one of the most popular river facilities and is selected as the research target of this study. The scouring problem on the downstream side of check dam may damage its own safety and therefore, preventing the check dam from souring has been a challenge task for years. To lessen the safety impact from scouring, the existing methods often rely on using reinforced concrete structures that often, does not solve the problem but induces a series of scouring problem. Further, reinforced concrete structure may damage the river ecological environment during and after the construction. On the other hand, air-bubble screen may provide an alternative solution in solving the scouring problem without interrupting the environment. A scaled-check dam model using flume channel at Hydrotech Research Institute in NTU is conducted, and then the FLOW-3D is used to carry out numerical simulation to evaluate the effectiveness of the air-bubble screen in reducing the depth and range (or volume) of the scours. Results shown that air-bubble screen is able to effectively reduce the check dam scours. Based on results from experiments and simulations, the design principles for air-bubble screen are provided as a reference for future practice. 

    How to cite: Liao, K.-W. and Wang, Z.-Z.: Investigation of Air-Bubble Screen on Reducing Scour in River Facility, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1137, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1137, 2022.

    EGU22-1424 | Presentations | NH1.2

    Operational hydraulic flood impact forecasting with RIM2D for improved disaster management 

    Heiko Apel, Sergiy Vorogushyn, and Bruno Merz

    The disastrous flood of July 2021 in Germany has shown that forecasts of river discharge or water levels at selected gauges do not provide sufficient information for timely and location specific warning of the population and targeted disaster management actions. The gauge forecasts as well as the available flood hazard maps were insufficient to assess the flood severity in downstream areas. In order to provide more actionable flood forecasts, the hydraulic model RIM2D was developed and setup for the Ahr river. It solves the inertial formulation of the shallow water equations on a regular grid, and is highly parallelized on Graphical Processor Units (GPUs). Moreover, the modelling concept is parsimonious and allows for fast model setup. We show that hydraulic simulations driven by the available hydrological gauge forecasts would have been feasible with short simulation duration. It would be possible to provide spatially explicit forecasts of inundation depths and flow velocities with sufficient lead time. Moreover, we also show that impact forecasts indicating human instability in water and building failure hazard can be additionally provided in operational mode. We argue that using these hydraulic and impact forecasts would have had a substantial impact on the flood alertness of the population and responsible authorities, enabling a better early warning and disaster management. This could eventually save lives during future extreme flash floods.

    How to cite: Apel, H., Vorogushyn, S., and Merz, B.: Operational hydraulic flood impact forecasting with RIM2D for improved disaster management, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1424, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1424, 2022.

    With the acceleration of urbanization, urban pluvial flooding seriously threatens urban sustainable development and human life. It is widely accepted that various landscape elements contribute to the magnitude of urban pluvial flooding. Considerable efforts investigated the universal mechanism of urban pluvial flooding by regarding the whole study area as spatial homogeneous while ignoring its local specific mechanism. The spatially heterogeneous effects of landscape elements on urban pluvial flooding remain poorly understood. Additionally, it is still unclear how the interactive effects of landscape elements affect urban pluvial flooding. In most practical situations, urban pluvial flooding is affected by multiple factors, rather than by a single factor alone. These shortcomings make it impossible to formulate urban pluvial flooding mitigation measures based on the relative contribution of various landscape elements on urban pluvial flooding. To shed some light on this topic, an innovative method that integrated the all subsect regression model, cubist regression tree, and geographical detector model is presented to spatially explicit the heterogeneous forces driving urban pluvial flooding variation and identify the pluvial flooding dominant driving forces with different local conditions. By comparing with two other commonly used regression methods (global regression model, spatial lag model), the proposed method can fully quantify this spatial non-stationarity mechanism and spatially explicit the local driving forces. Urban pluvial flooding dominant driving factors and their contribution vary with the local site conditions. Even for the same dominant factor, its contribution to pluvial flooding varies considerably in different watersheds. Based on this, local authorities can develop site-specific urban pluvial flooding mitigation strategies according to the dominant factors in different areas. The results of this study extend our scientific understanding of the site-specific mechanism of urban pluvial flooding, providing useful information for formulating more targeted and effective urban pluvial flooding mitigation strategies with different local conditions, rather than a “one-size-fits-all” policy.

    How to cite: Zhang, Q., Wu, Z., Guo, G., and Tarolli, P.: How to develop site-specific urban pluvial flooding mitigation strategies? A new approach to investigating the spatial heterogeneous driving forces of urban pluvial flooding, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1573, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1573, 2022.

    EGU22-2344 | Presentations | NH1.2

    Deep learning approaches to study floods through river cameras 

    Remy Vandaele, Sarah L Dance, and Varun Ojha

    The monitoring of river water-levels is essential to study floods and mitigate their risks. However, it is difficult to obtain accurate measurements of river water-levels: indeed, the river gauges commonly used to measure these levels can be overwhelmed during flood events, and their number is declining globally [1,2]. This means that the monitoring and study of floods relying on gauge station measurements can only be based on sparse and possibly inaccurate river water-level data distributed unevenly along the rivers, sometimes several kilometres away from the location of interest.

    We investigate if deep learning can be used to monitor river water-levels in a more flexible and efficient way. More specifically, we apply two deep learning approaches on river cameras, which are CCTV cameras commonly used to monitor the surroundings of rivers and could be easily installed at new locations. The first approach [3,4] relies on transfer learning to train water segmentation networks able to find the water pixels within the camera images and use the number of water pixels within (regions of) the images to monitor the relative evolution of the river water-level. The second approach is based on the creation of a large dataset of 32,715 images annotated with distant gauge water-level data in order to accurately train networks able to produce river water-level indexes independent from the field of view of the cameras. 

    We show that both approaches can be used as sources of river water-level data. The first approach is able to produce river water-level indexes highly correlated with ground truth river water-levels (Pearson correlation coefficient >0.94). While the second approach is less accurate (Pearson correlation coefficients between 0.8 and 0.94), it is able to produce calibrated indexes independent from the field of view of the camera. 

     

    [1] Mishra, A. K., and Coulibaly, P. (2009), Developments in hydrometric network design: A review, Rev. Geophys., 47, RG2001, doi:10.1029/2007RG000243.

    [2] Global Runoff Data Center (2016).  Global runoff data base, temporal distribution of available discharge data.  https://www.bafg.de/SharedDocs/Bilder/Bilder_GRDC/grdcStations_tornadoChart.jpg. Last visited:2021-04-26.

    [3] Vandaele, R., Dance, S. L., & Ojha, V. (2020, September). Automated water segmentation and river level detection on camera images using transfer learning. In DAGM German Conference on Pattern Recognition (pp. 232-245). Springer, Cham.

    [4] Vandaele, R., Dance, S. L., & Ojha, V. (2021). Deep learning for automated river-level monitoring through river camera images: an approach based on water segmentation and transfer learning. Hydrology and Earth System Sciences, 25(8), 4435-4453.

    How to cite: Vandaele, R., Dance, S. L., and Ojha, V.: Deep learning approaches to study floods through river cameras, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2344, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2344, 2022.

    EGU22-2418 | Presentations | NH1.2

    Flood risk mapping using multi-criteria analysis (TOPSIS) model through geospatial techniques- A case study of the Navsari city, Gujarat, India 

    Azazkhan Ibrahimkhan Pathan, Dr. Prasit Girish Agnihotri, Dr. Saif Said, Dr. Dhruvesh Patel, Dr. Cristina Prieto, Usman Mohsini, Nilesh Patidar, Dr.Pankaj Gandhi, Khushboo Jariwala, Bojan Đurin, Mohammad Yasin Azimi, Juma Rasuli, Kalyan Dummu, Saran Raaj, Arbaaz A. Shaikh, and Muqadar Salihi

    Flood is one of the most devastating natural disasters that cause enormous socioeconomic and environmental destruction. The severity of flood losses has evoked emphasis on more comprehensive and vigorous flood modeling techniques for alleviating flood damages. Flood vulnerability in Navsari is intensifying due to urbanization, industrialization, and population growth. Although there has been a significant increase in research on flood assessment at a local scale in Navsari, there remains a lack of tools developed which utilize the risk map of the city. In response to this prerequisite, in this study we have employed a GIS-based Technique for Order of Preference by Similarity to Ideal Solution (TOPSIS) multi-criteria analysis model to develop a flood risk map for Navsari city in Gujarat, India, to determine the vulnerable areas that are more susceptible to flooding. To estimate the extent of flood hazard, vulnerability, and risk intensities in terms of area covered, the city was divided into ten zones (i.e. NC1 to NC10) and classified into five classes: very high, high, moderate, low, and very low. A total of seven hazard forming spatial layers (i.e. slope, elevation, soil, rainfall, flow accumulation, distance to a river, and drainage density) and seven vulnerability forming spatial layers (i.e. female population, population density, land use, household, distance to hospital, road network density, and literacy rate) were appraised for evaluating the risk of flooding. The generated flood risk map has been compared with the extent of flood calculated based on field data collected from thirty-six random places. The outcome of the model unveiled the capability of the TOPSIS model since it capitulate low RMSE value varied between 0.95 to 0.43 and high R square value ranged from 0.78 to 0.95. The zones indicated under ‘high’ and ‘very high’ categories (i.e. NC8, NC6, NC4, NC1, NC7, and NC10) demand abrupt flood control action to alleviate the severity of flood risk and subsequent damages. The approach implemented in the study can be applied to any flood-sensitive region around the globe to accurately evaluate the risk of flood. Lastly, flood risk mapping using TOPSIS based geospatial techniques divulge the novel and efficacious approach, especially for data-sparse regions.

    How to cite: Pathan, A. I., Agnihotri, Dr. P. G., Said, Dr. S., Patel, Dr. D., Prieto, Dr. C., Mohsini, U., Patidar, N., Gandhi, Dr. P., Jariwala, K., Đurin, B., Azimi, M. Y., Rasuli, J., Dummu, K., Raaj, S., Shaikh, A. A., and Salihi, M.: Flood risk mapping using multi-criteria analysis (TOPSIS) model through geospatial techniques- A case study of the Navsari city, Gujarat, India, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2418, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2418, 2022.

    EGU22-2622 | Presentations | NH1.2

    A complete meteo-hydrological chain to support early warning systems from weather scenarios to flooded areas: the Apollo medicane use case 

    Martina Lagasio, Giacomo Fagugli, Luca Ferraris, Elisabetta Fiori, Simone Gabellani, Rocco Masi, Vincenzo Mazzarella, Massimo Milelli, Andrea Parodi, Flavio Pignone, Silvia Puca, Luca Pulvirenti, Francesco Silvestro, Giuseppe Squicciarino, and Antonio Parodi

    An intense Mediterranean hurricane (medicane Apollo) hit many countries during the last week of October 2021. Up to 7 people died because of the floods caused by the cyclone in Tunisia, Algeria, Malta and Italy. Apollo persisted over the same Mediterranean area from 24 October to 1 November 2021 producing flash-flood and flood episodes with very intense rainfall events, especially over eastern Sicily and Calabria on 25-26 October 2021. CIMA Foundation operated in real-time with a complete forecasting chain to predict both the Apollo medicane weather evolution and its hydrological and hydraulic impacts. The work provides support to the Italian Civil Protection Department early warning activities and in the framework of the H2020 LEXIS and E-SHAPE projects. The complete meteo-hydrological forecasting chain is composed by the cloud-resolving WRF model assimilating radar data and in situ weather stations (WRF-3DVAR), the fully distributed hydrological model Continuum, the automatic system for water detection (AUTOWADE), and the hydraulic model TELEMAC-2D. This work presents the forecasting performances of each model involved in the CIMA meteo-hydrological chain, with focus on both very short-range temporal scales (up to 6 hours ahead) and short-range forecasts (up to 48 hours ahead). The WRF-3DVAR model results showed very good predictive capability of the most intense rainfall events in terms of timing and location over Catania and Siracusa provinces in Sicily. Thus, enabling also very accurate discharge peaks and timing predictions for the creeks hydrological network peculiar of eastern Sicily. Starting from the WRF-3DVAR model predictions, the daily AUTOWADE tool run using Sentnel-1 (S1) data, was anticipated with respect to the scheduled timing to quickly produce a flood map (S1 acquisition performed on 25 October 2021 at 05UTC, flood map produced on the same day at 13UTC). Furthermore, an ad hoc tasking of the COSMO-SkyMed satellite constellation was performed, again based on the on the WRF-3DVAR predictions, to overcome the S1 data latency on eastern Sicily during the period 26-30 October 2021. Finally, the resulting automated operational mapping of floods and inland waters was integrated with the subsequent execution of the hydraulic model TELEMAC. Due to the probable frequency increase of such extreme events (in light of the ongoing climate change), the application of a complete meteo-hydrological chain presented in this work can pave the way for future applications in early warning activities in the Mediterranean areas.

    How to cite: Lagasio, M., Fagugli, G., Ferraris, L., Fiori, E., Gabellani, S., Masi, R., Mazzarella, V., Milelli, M., Parodi, A., Pignone, F., Puca, S., Pulvirenti, L., Silvestro, F., Squicciarino, G., and Parodi, A.: A complete meteo-hydrological chain to support early warning systems from weather scenarios to flooded areas: the Apollo medicane use case, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2622, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2622, 2022.

    EGU22-2696 | Presentations | NH1.2

    Introducing ProMaIDes: A State-of-the Science Flood Risk Management Tool 

    Daniel Bachmann, Roman Schotten, and Shahin Khosh Bin Ghomash

    Floods are natural hazards with severe socio-economic and environmental impacts on affected areas and societies every year. A chain of different processes being involved in a flooding - characterized by precipitation, topography, land use etc. - complicates the understanding of the dynamics of a flood. However, the prediction of probabilities, flood hazards, flooding extents, dike failure, consequences and understanding the ongoing processes during a flood event are important issues in flood risk management. Computational modelling is a key method in supporting flood risk management and tackling the mentioned challenges.

    While several computer-based models for assisting flood risk management exist, typically they concentrate on only one component of the flood risk analysis chain such as rainfall generation, hydrological/hydraulic modelling or damage analysis. They do not merge the other components on one platform which may result in encapsulated conclusions. In recent years the availability of higher detailed data, larger study domains, more computational power and more innovative models paved the way for more effective solutions.

    In this work we present ProMaIDes (Protection Measures against Inundation Decision support), an open-source, free software package for risk-based evaluation of flood risk mitigation measures1. The software package consists of numerous relevant modules for a flood risk analysis in riverine and coastal regions: the HYD-module for a hydrodynamic analysis, the DAM-module for an analysis of consequences (including economical damage, consequences to people and the disruption of critical infrastructure services), the FPL-module for the reliability analysis of dikes and dunes as well as a combining RISK-module and the decision support MADM-module. To support a user-friendly model setup, visualization of input and data results, a connection with the free QGIS-system is established by QGIS-plugins and a PostgreSQL-database as data-management system. A detailed online documentation featuring theory, application and programming is available2. A community of users is currently set-up.

    In order to give a better understanding and to demonstrate the capabilities of ProMaIDes, the tool itself, but also the modules combined with case studies are shortly presented.

     

    1 https://promaides.h2.de

    2 https://promaides.myjetbrains.com/youtrack/articles/PMID-A-7/General

    How to cite: Bachmann, D., Schotten, R., and Khosh Bin Ghomash, S.: Introducing ProMaIDes: A State-of-the Science Flood Risk Management Tool, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2696, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2696, 2022.

    Slope instability of river dikes during floods is often driven by the evolution of groundwater pressures. Despite the temporal nature of high river water levels, pressure heads during floods are often assumed to reflect steady-state seepage conditions, leading to conservative estimates of dike slope safety. Here, we investigate the influence of transient groundwater conditions that result from variable flood wave shapes on probabilistic safety estimates of slope stability. We have sampled a large number of flood waves, aiming to maximize the variability in the flood wave shapes, and used them in a modeling chain consisting of a hydrological model (MODFLOW) and a probabilistic dike slope safety assessment (FORM). We compared the resulting time-dependent probabilistic dike safety for inner (landward) slope and outer (riverward) slope stability with the current flood safety assessment in the Netherlands. This comparison showed that current methods based on steady-state and analytical solutions seem to underestimate dike safety. Other methods, based on a design discharge wave, are more consistent with the multi-flood wave dike reliability, but their error increases at extreme water levels. In line with the temporal component of variable flood water levels, the failure probability also has a strong temporal component. Our results indicate that the highest failure probability always occurs after the river water level peak, with a delay of up to 15 days for both inner slope and outer slope stability. In addition, the uncertainty in the shape of the flood wave can be as important as the uncertainty in the geomechanical material properties for explaining the variation in dike failure probabilities. Therefore, this research strongly suggests that transient-groundwater conditions as a function of variable flood wave shapes should be incorporated in dike safety assessment. As a first step, we recommend further research on the occurrence probability of the most influential waveform characteristics, being the total flood wave volume (for the inner slope) and the total water level decrease after the peak (for the outer slope).

    How to cite: van Woerkom, T., van der Krogt, M., and Bierkens, M.: On the incorporation of transient groundwater conditions resulting from variable flood wave shapes in probabilistic slope stability assessments of dikes, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3099, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3099, 2022.

    EGU22-3374 | Presentations | NH1.2

    Real-time Flood Forecasting Using Numerical Weather Prediction System Through NICAM-LETKF Data Assimilation in the Prek Thnot River, Cambodia 

    Sophal Try, Takahiro Sayama, Ty Sok, Sophea Rum Phy, and Chantha Oeurng

    Flood is widely recognized as the most common and frequent natural phenomenon which currently threatens huge damage worldwide. The Prek Thnot River (PTR) in Cambodia is one of the flood-prone areas where severe floods occur every year and cause damage to residents downstream. This study aims to evaluate the forecasting performance of flooding in the PTR using near real-time datasets from satellite observation (i.e., GSMaP and GPM) and forecasted rainfall from NICAM-LETKF numerical weather prediction (so called GSMaPxNEXRA) dataset. GSMaPxNEXRA data is produced by Global Cloud Resolving Model with Data Assimilation. This study used a fully distributed rainfall-runoff-inundation (RRI) model for river discharge and water level simulations. The RRI model was calibrated and validated with gauged observed rainfall during flood events in 2000, 2001, 2007, 2010, and 2020 with satisfactory and acceptable results. The most recent flood event in 2020 was considered to evaluate real-time flood forecasting. The near real-time simulation indicated the results discharge and water level with statistical indicators KGE = 0.80 and 0.07 and r2 = 0.83 and 0.87 for GPM and KGE = 0.48 and -0.12 and r2 = 0.54 and 0.67 for GSMaP. The GPM rainfall product outperforms GSMaP rainfall in the PTR. Flood forecast from the GSMaPxNEXRA showed an accuracy with KGE = 0.79 and r2 = 0.89 (1-day forecast) to KGE = 0.66 and r2 = 0.76 (5-day forecast). On the other hand, the performance of 1-day to 5-day forecast indicated with coefficient of extrapolation (CE) and coefficient of persistence (CP) between CE = -2.62 and CP = -2.65 for 1-day forecast to CE = 0.71 and CP = -0.06 for 5-day forecast. To conclude, real-time flood forecasting in the PTR was successfully assessed and evaluated in this study; however, the accuracy of flood prediction should be further improved in the future by considering data assimilation and machine learning.

    How to cite: Try, S., Sayama, T., Sok, T., Phy, S. R., and Oeurng, C.: Real-time Flood Forecasting Using Numerical Weather Prediction System Through NICAM-LETKF Data Assimilation in the Prek Thnot River, Cambodia, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3374, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3374, 2022.

    EGU22-4201 | Presentations | NH1.2

    Rainfall threshold curves and machine learning approaches for pluvial flood forecasting based on local news reports in Croatia 

    Nino Krvavica, Bojana Horvat, Ivana Marinović, and Ante Šiljeg

    This study presents a forecasting model for pluvial flooding in the city of Zadar, Croatia, where a huge mesoscale convective system recently caused massive pluvial flooding and widespread property damage. Flood forecasting approaches based on hydrologic-hydraulic models require a large set of accurate data to provide reliable simulations. They also require many simulations, which can be computationally expensive and time consuming. Therefore, we are investigating the possibility of using a data-driven approach based on local news reports of pluvial flooding combined with a local high-resolution rain gauge. To this end, we considered two different computational approaches. The first - a conventional one - is based on rainfall threshold curves that define the critical rainfall depth for different time periods above which flooding is likely to occur. The second approach is based on machine learning and a classification problem - predicting whether accumulated rainfall depths over different time periods will lead to pluvial flooding. For the second approach, we considered 10 different methods that belong to five categories of machine learning typically used for classification problems. They are logistic regression, support vector machine, discriminant analysis, decision trees, and nearest neighbours. After a careful analysis, we defined rainfall threshold curves for Zadar that can be used for an early warning system and flood forecasting. We show that some machine learning models can provide slightly more accurate predictions than the threshold curve, with quadratic discriminant analysis being the most successful method for this purpose. Overall, this study shows that flood forecasting based on news reports in the city of Zadar can be a reliable approach. The analysis conducted in this study has laid the foundation for the implementation of an early warning system and pluvial flood forecasting in the Croatian coastal area.

    How to cite: Krvavica, N., Horvat, B., Marinović, I., and Šiljeg, A.: Rainfall threshold curves and machine learning approaches for pluvial flood forecasting based on local news reports in Croatia, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4201, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4201, 2022.

    EGU22-4210 | Presentations | NH1.2

    An Integrated Approach of AHP-GIS Based Dam Site Suitability Mapping - A Noval Approach for Flood Alleviating Measures 

    Saran Raaj, Azazkhan Pathan, Usman Mohseni, Nilesh Patidar, Khushboo jariwala, Nitin Kachhawa, Dr. P.G Agnihotri, Dr. Dhruvesh Patel, Dr. Cristina Prieto, Dr. Pankaj Gandhi, and Dr. Bojan Đurin

    Surat is a district that has seen numerous floods and high rainfall over the last two decades. The solution to the problem, and the primary aim of this study, is to construct a storage facility, such as a dam, as part of flood prevention measures. The concept of multi-criteria decision making (MCDM) is now widely employed for everyday real-life challenges. Recent advancements and diverse approaches in geographic information systems (GIS) and remote sensing, along with the MCDM technique, will enable us to make an informed decision about where to build a dam site location model (DSLM). The Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) is the most frequently utilised MCDM technique for resolving water-related issues. To produce DSLM, ten thematic layers were considered: precipitation, stream order, geomorphology, geology, LULC, soil, distance to road, elevation, slope, and major fault fracture. Precipitation and stream order were the two most important elements affecting the DSLM. The weights of the thematic map layers were determined using the analytical hierarchy process (AHP) technique. These thematic maps and weights are used to perform overlay analysis, resulting in a suitability map with five classes ranging from high to low suitability. Three main sites have been selected as the best candidates for the construction of a new dam. By implementing this low-cost strategy, we may be able to reduce the amount of effort required in the traditional method of dam site selection while increasing decision-makers' accuracy. Approximately 14% of the Surat district is classified as a very high adaptability area, while 27.2 percent is classified as a high suitability area. This method can be applied all over the world to locate possible dam sites, which can be helpful for flood mitigation measures. In addition to that, the presented approach unveiled the scientific method for flood mitigation measures, which are in immediate demand all over the globe, especially in data-scarce regions.

    How to cite: Raaj, S., Pathan, A., Mohseni, U., Patidar, N., jariwala, K., Kachhawa, N., Agnihotri, Dr. P. G., Patel, Dr. D., Prieto, Dr. C., Gandhi, Dr. P., and Đurin, Dr. B.: An Integrated Approach of AHP-GIS Based Dam Site Suitability Mapping - A Noval Approach for Flood Alleviating Measures, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4210, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4210, 2022.

    EGU22-4345 | Presentations | NH1.2

    Towards Urban Flood Susceptibility Mapping Using Data-Driven Models 

    Omar Seleem, Georgy Ayzel, Arthur Costa Tomaz de Souza, Axel Bronstert, and Maik Heistermann

    Both frequency and severity of urban pluvial floods have been increasing due to rapid urbanization and climate change. Hydrological and two dimensional (2D) hydrodynamic models are still too computationally demanding to be used for real-time applications for large urban areas (i.e. flood management scale). As an alternative, data-driven models could be used for flood susceptibility mapping. This study evaluated and compared the performance of image-based models represented by a convolutional neural network (CNN) and point-based models represented by an artificial neural network (ANN), a random forest (RF) and a support vector machine (SVM) with regard to the spatial resolution of the input data. We also examined model transferability. Eleven variables representing topography, anthropogenic aspects and precipitation were selected to predict flood susceptibility mapping. The results showed that: (1) all models were skilful with a minimum area under the curve AUC = 0.87. (2) The RF models outperformed the other models for all spatial resolutions. (3) The CNN models were superior in terms of transferability. (4) Aspect and elevation were the most important factors for flood susceptibility mapping for image-based and point-based models respectively.

    How to cite: Seleem, O., Ayzel, G., Costa Tomaz de Souza, A., Bronstert, A., and Heistermann, M.: Towards Urban Flood Susceptibility Mapping Using Data-Driven Models, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4345, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4345, 2022.

    EGU22-4771 | Presentations | NH1.2

    Application of frequency ratio modelling technique for predictive flooded area susceptibility mapping using remote sensing and GIS 

    Khushboo Jariwala, Prasit Agnihotri, Dhruvesh Patel, Azaz Pathan, Usman Mohseni, and Nilesh Patidar

    Coastal areas are directly vulnerable to natural disasters like floods, which causes massive damages to natural resources and human resources. Dam induces floods can be devastating for surrounding low lying areas. Bharuch is a district with substantial industrial growth, and intended human activities were causing an imbalance in natural resources for planning and fulfilling other demands. Floods can be devastating concerning the Bharuch district's social, economic, and environmental perspectives. The proper analysis becomes very important to reduce the impact and find mitigation measuring techniques. I did flood susceptibility mapping using the frequency ratio model for the six sub-districts of the area. The susceptibility of a flood was analysed using the frequency ratio model by considering nine different independent variables (land use/land cover, elevation, slope, topographic wetness index, surface runoff, lithology, distance from the main river, soil texture, river network) through weighted-based bivariate probability values. In total, 151 historical floods were reported. I took locations for this study, from which I used 72 locations for susceptibility mapping. I combined the independent variables and historic flood locations to prepare a frequency ratio database for flood susceptibility mapping. The developed frequency ratio was varied from 0 to 13.2 and reclassified into five flood vulnerability zones, namely, very low (less than 0.99), low (0.99-2.04), moderate (2.04-5.58), high (5.58-13.2) and very high susceptibility (more than 13.2). The flood susceptibility analysis will be a valuable and efficient tool for local government administrators, researchers, and planners to devise flood mitigation plans.

    Keywords: Flood Susceptibility · Flood · Frequency Ratio · Vulnerability · Bharuch

    How to cite: Jariwala, K., Agnihotri, P., Patel, D., Pathan, A., Mohseni, U., and Patidar, N.: Application of frequency ratio modelling technique for predictive flooded area susceptibility mapping using remote sensing and GIS, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4771, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4771, 2022.

    Flood is one of the most devastating natural disasters. The damages of flood usually vary with the consideration of different factors (depth, duration, velocity, materials of infrastructures) of flooding. Therefore, flood damage estimation is a complex process. Most of previous studies considered only flood depth in developing flood damage functions for residential houses. However, the consideration of other flood parameters such as flood duration and flood velocity are also crucial to estimate flood damage more reliably. Therefore, this study aimed to consider various flood parameters such as flood depth, flood duration, and flood velocity in development of flood damage functions for residential houses.  In this study, the Teesta River Basin in Bangladesh was chosen as the study area. A detailed household questionnaire survey was conducted in flood-affected areas of Lalmonirhat and Rangpur districts (administrative unit of Bangladesh) to collect data of 2017 and 2019 flood events.  Most of the houses in the surveyed flood-affected areas are composed of mud base and side wall of corrugated iron sheets (called “MC type”). For each house, the questionnaire aimed to identify the flood information (flood depth, flood duration, the qualitative representation of flood velocity), household structure information (area, plinth height, ceiling height), structural damage mechanism and the required amount of material with labor work to repair the damage after each flood event. Using the survey data, we have developed depth-damage functions for MC type of house by considering different flood velocity and flood duration combinations. The newly developed depth-damage functions can generalize thresholds of flood depth, flood velocity and flood duration that are responsible for specific type of structural damages (mud removal from the base, mud removal from the base together with side wall instability, full structure instability) of MC type house. Finally, a grid-based approach through the integration of new depth-damage functions with hydrologic-hydraulic model (RRI) and Nays2DFlood Solver (iRIC software) simulation results has been developed to estimate the total flood damage for MC type houses in flood-affected areas of the Teesta River Basin. This comprehensive method can be easily used to derive the depth-damage functions and estimation of total damage for other types of houses if enough surveyed data can be obtained from the field.

    Keywords: Flood damage estimation, Depth-damage function, MC type house, Hydrologic-hydraulic model

    How to cite: Haque, S., Ikeuchi, K., Shrestha, B. B., and Minamide, M.: Generalizing flood damage mechanism processes of MC Type houses by developing comprehensive flood damage estimation method for Teesta River Basin, Bangladesh, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5110, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5110, 2022.

    EGU22-6322 | Presentations | NH1.2

    Development of a loosely coupled geomatic-hydrological modeling approach for flood inundation mapping in small watersheds 

    Zainab El Batti, Etienne Foulon, Camila Gordon, and Alain Rousseau

    In Québec, Canada, extraordinary spring conditions in 2017 and 2019 have provided major incentives for the provincial government to commission the updating of current flood inundation maps. Indeed, some of these maps, dating back as far as the 1980’s, do not adequately reflect actual flood risks. Classical hydrodynamic models, such as HEC-RAS (1D, mixed, or full 2D), are generally used to perform the mapping, but they do require significant expertise, hydrometric data, and high-resolution bathymetric surveys. Given the need for updating flood inundation maps and reducing the associated financial costs (data collection and human resources), there is an emerging demand for simplified conceptual methods. In recent years, several models have been developed to fulfill this need, including the geomatic Height Above the Nearest Drainage (HAND) method which solely relies on a the digital elevation model (DEM).

    This project aims at expanding upon earlier work carried out with HAND which was designed to compute the required water height to flood any DEM pixel of a watershed. The information provided by HAND along with the application of the Manning equation allow for the construction of a synthetic rating curve for any homogeneous river reach. This methodological approach has been used to come up with first-instance flood inundation mapping of large rivers in conterminous United States with a matching rate reaching 90% when compared to the use of HEC-RAS. However, to our knowledge, this has not been assessed for small rivers, and our goal here is to validate this simplified conceptual approach using two small watersheds (less than 200 km²) in Quebec.

    The results of this study show that the ensuing synthetic rating curves for small rivers are consistent with river hydraulics (Froude numbers meeting the subcritical flow requirement behind the use of Manning equation) and in-situ derived rating curves of six hydrometric stations. The results also demonstrate the relevance of this approach when comparing the use of HAND with HEC-RAS 2D for the hydrographic networks of the two watersheds given flows simulated by a semi-distributed hydrological model (i.e., HYDROTEL). For this demonstration, the forcing data include the precipitation and temperature time series of the Canadian precipitation analysis system. Preliminary results indicate good performances (hitting rate above 60%) for the pilot river watersheds which are located in a data-sparse region.

    While the preliminary results illustrate the potential to produce first-instance flood inundation mapping solely based on a DEM and simulated streamflows, future work will contribute to the advancement of our understanding of flood risks in poorly-gauged watersheds. HAND-derived inundation mapping will be further analyzed and compared to HEC-RAS-2D applications (i.e., the diffusion-wave equations), although the presence of complex urban infrastructures such as culverts, pipes, or bridges may represent a major challenge for the proposed approach. We believe a modeling continuum based on hydrological modeling and HAND-derived flood inundation mapping will inform and strengthen land management planning and contribute to the elaboration of public safety protocols.

    How to cite: El Batti, Z., Foulon, E., Gordon, C., and Rousseau, A.: Development of a loosely coupled geomatic-hydrological modeling approach for flood inundation mapping in small watersheds, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6322, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6322, 2022.

    Floods, the most frequent and severe of natural disasters worldwide, inflict significant social, environmental and fiscal impacts, including: loss of human life, damage to natural habitats and damage to infrastructure. Flood risk mapping can be used to mitigate these impacts as it provides a holistic approach to identifying flood prone areas by simultaneously considering socioeconomic and environmental indicators. This research compares the performance of two multi-criteria decision making methods, and one Machine Learning (ML) method in the development of flood risk mapping. This approach was first developed and validated for the Don River watershed in the Greater Toronto Area and subsequently extended to several other watersheds across Southern Ontario. Remote sensing data such as Digital Elevation Models and landuse and lancover datasets were used to develop the environmental flood hazard extent, and combined together with socioeconomic indicators, flood risk maps were developed using subjective and objective weighting schemes in a GIS analysis. The subjective maps were produced using the Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP), the objective maps were produced using the Shannon Entropy method and the ML maps were produced using Artificial Neural Networks. The accuracy of these maps was compared against the floodplain map of the Don River. For a range of flood risk severity, where 1 was very low risk and 5 was very high risk, the AHP maps were superior in identifying areas where flood risk severity was 4 or greater. Conversely, the Entropy maps were superior in identifying areas where flood hazard risk was 5, however the difference in accuracy for both scenarios was marginal between the two methods. The accuracy of the ML maps showed marginal superior performance under both scenarios in comparison to the multi-criteria maps. Additionally, the uncertainty in the combination of flood risk indicators was quantified through a sensitivity analysis focusing on the discretization of the number of classes in each indicator dataset. The outcome of this research provides an accurate and simplified alternative to using hydrological and hydraulic models, especially when insufficient data limits the use of hydrological and hydraulic models. Future research should focus on an optimisation approach to the discretization of classes in indicator datasets.

    How to cite: Khalid, R. and Khan, U. T.: A comparison of multi-criteria and machine learning weighting for flood risk assessment in the Southern Ontario, Canada, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6574, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6574, 2022.

    EGU22-6636 | Presentations | NH1.2

    Flood flow modelling coupled with ML-based land cover detection from UAV and satellite river imagery 

    Takuya Sato, Shuji Iwami, and Hitoshi Miyamoto

    This research examined a new method for coupling flood flow modelling with the machine learning (ML)-based land cover detection from the Unmanned Aerial Vehicle (UAV) and satellite river imagery. We examined a 2 km river channel section with a gravel bed in the Kurobe River, Japan. The method used Random Forests (RF) for riverine land cover detection with the satellite images' RGBs and Near InfraRed (NIRs). In the process, the UAV images were used effectively to train the RF in several small portions of the river channel where the types of riverine land cover were precise. Using these UAV images with the corresponding feature values (i.e., RGBs and NIRs) of the satellite images made it possible to create the training data with high accuracy for land cover detection. The results indicated that combining the high- and low-resolution images in the RF could effectively detect waters, gravel/sand, trees, and grasses from the satellite images with a certain degree of accuracy. Its F-measure, consisting of precision and recall rates, had high enough with 0.8. Then, the ML-based land covers were coupled with a flood flow model. In the coupling, the results of the detected riverine land covers were converted into the roughness coefficients of the two-dimensional flood flow analysis. The flood flow simulation could reproduce the velocity field and water surface profile of flood flows with high accuracy. These results strongly suggest the effectiveness of coupling the current flood flow modelling with the ML-based land cover detection for grasping the most vulnerable portions in river flood management.

    How to cite: Sato, T., Iwami, S., and Miyamoto, H.: Flood flow modelling coupled with ML-based land cover detection from UAV and satellite river imagery, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6636, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6636, 2022.

    EGU22-7247 | Presentations | NH1.2

    Flood early warning can significantly mitigate monetary damage 

    Heidi Kreibich, Paul Hudson, and Bruno Merz

    Flood warning systems have a long track record of protecting human lives, but monetary damage continue to increase. Knowledge about the effectiveness of early flood warnings in reducing monetary damage is sparse, especially at the individual level. To gain more knowledge in this area, we analyse a dataset that is unique in terms of detailed information on warning reception and monetary damage at the property level. The dataset contains 4,468 damage cases from six flood events in Germany. We show quantitatively that early flood warnings are only effective in reducing monetary damage if people know what to do when they receive the warning (with at least one hour's notice). The average reduction in contents damage is 4 percentage points, which corresponds to a reduction of EUR 3,800 for the average warning recipient. This is substantial compared to the mean contents damage ratio of 21% and an absolute contents damage of 17,000 EUR. For the building damage ratio, the average reduction is 2 percentage points, which corresponds to a damage reduction of EUR 10,000. This is a remarkable reduction compared to the mean building damage ratio of 11% and a mean absolute building damage of 48,000 EUR. We also show that particularly long-term preparedness is related to people knowing what to do when they receive a warning. Risk communication, training and (financial) support for private preparedness are thus effective in mitigating flood damage in two ways: through precautionary measures and more effective emergency measures.

    How to cite: Kreibich, H., Hudson, P., and Merz, B.: Flood early warning can significantly mitigate monetary damage, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7247, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7247, 2022.

    EGU22-8450 | Presentations | NH1.2

    Improving resilience through a surface water flooding decision support system 

    Heather Forbes, John Bevington, Andy Evans, Andrew Gubbin, Kay Shelton, Richard Smith, and Elizabeth Wood

    Flood Foresight is JBA’s strategic flood monitoring and forecasting system, providing flood inundation and depth estimates across the UK and Ireland at 30m resolution up to 10-days ahead of fluvial flood events. It consists of Flood Monitoring (based on observed discharges from river gauge telemetry) and Flood Forecasting (based on simulated discharge from a rainfall-runoff model) modules.

    Recently, Flood Foresight has been expanded to provide asset alerting around heavy rainfall and surface water (pluvial) flooding, demonstrated in a proof-of-concept system on behalf of Network Rail during a Small Business Research Initiative project funded by Department for Transport and delivered by InnovateUK.

    The surface water flood forecasting system is now running in real time using high resolution ensemble rainfall forecasts from Met Eireann (IREPS).  This system represents a major advance in the availability of information indicating the risk to rail infrastructure across Great Britain.  Taking advantage of ensemble rainfall forecasts, it is possible to give an indication of where rain might happen and the severity of that rain (in comparison to historical rainfall amounts), and also to provide an indication of the confidence in that forecast.  This concept is crucial to the handling of intense rainfall events, due to their inherent lack of predictability.  The presentation of mapped likelihood information for both rainfall and surface water flooding forecasts provides users with spatial context for the asset alerts.  It allows them to see the extent and uncertainty in the location of the intense rainfall event. 

    The system has been developed to run autonomously using rainfall forecasts as they are provided by Met Eireann, via FTP.  Therefore the resulting asset alert information is always available, and always presents the most up-to-date information.  This gives asset managers the ability to access the information at a time that is convenient to them, but also the system can provide alerts when assets are identified as at risk as the information becomes available. 

    The forecast data is available beyond 36 hours into the future, providing sufficient lead time for asset managers to coordinate responses and mobilise staff and equipment, if needed.  The temporal resolution of the forecast information is high at short lead times (i.e.  hourly for the first 6 hours), decreasing as lead time increases (after 24 hours the information is 6 hourly, further reducing to 12 hourly when longer lead time forecasts are available).  This decreasing temporal resolution with longer lead times allows for increased uncertainty in the timing of events further in the future to be obscured to the user, reducing confusion if the timing changes with subsequent forecasts. 

    The proof-of-concept system focuses on the rail industry, however it is extensible to other sectors where population, assets or infrastructure are vulnerable to surface water flooding. Flood impact data and associated alerts can be customised based on a client’s asset portfolio and their incident management needs.

    The presentation will explore heavy rainfall events evaluated during the proof-of-concept demonstrations, describing the information the Flood Foresight system could have provided ahead of, and during the event.

    How to cite: Forbes, H., Bevington, J., Evans, A., Gubbin, A., Shelton, K., Smith, R., and Wood, E.: Improving resilience through a surface water flooding decision support system, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8450, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8450, 2022.

    EGU22-8823 | Presentations | NH1.2

    Improved flood predictions by combining satellite observations, topographic information and rainfall spatial data using deep learning 

    Rocco Palmitessa, Oliver Gyldenberg Hjermitslev, Heidi Egeberg Johansen, Karsten Arnbjerg-Nielsen, Peter Bauer‐Gottwein, Peter Steen Mikkelsen, and Roland Löwe

    Flood warning systems are needed to plan mitigation measures and inform response strategies. The extent and dynamics of floods are typically predicted using physics-based hydrological models, which are computationally expensive and data assimilation is difficult. Deep-learning models can overcome these limitations, enabling fast predictions informed by multiple sources of data. Studies show this can be achieved while retaining or improving the level of detail and accuracy previously attainable. We, therefore, propose a deep-learning flood forecasting tool that combines multiple sources of readily available data to quickly generate flood extent maps, which can inform warnings.

    We train a neural network with U-NET architecture consisting of encoder and decoder convolutional modules. In the encoder module, features are extracted from the input and the data is downsampled to reduce complexity. Subsequently, the data is upsampled back to the original dimension in the decoder module and each 10 by 10 m pixel of the output image represents a flood prediction. The input to the neural network includes radar rainfall observations, LIDAR topographic scans, soil type and land use maps, groundwater depth simulations and previous inundation maps. All inputs are individually normalized and pre-processed. The rainfall observations are temporally aggregated to various intervals, hydrological features are highlighted in the topographic scans, and soil types and uses are grouped into categories.

    The model is trained and evaluated against a set of maps of surface water extent derived from Synthetic Aperture Radar (SAR) satellite observations. The predictions are scored against the target images by computing the critical success index (CSI), which measures the percentage of correct predictions among the total predicted of observed flooded areas. Permanent water bodies and areas where flooding is not captured by the satellite images (e.g. in forests) are masked out during both training and evaluation. The model is trained on a set of flooding events that occurred between 2018 and 2020 within the Jammerbugt Municipality in northern Denmark, which extends for about 850 km2. The model is validated on spatially independent data and tested on temporally independent events from the same study area.

    The proposed model yielded up to ~60% CSI with the test dataset, which is comparable to existing flood screening approaches. The test data included both fluvial and pluvial flooding as well as observed surface water in coastal areas. Large flooded areas were correctly predicted, while false negatives were frequently obtained for smaller areas. The overall performance of the proposed method is expected to improve by further tuning the model hyperparameters and by treating separately flood processes with different dynamics (e.g. pluvial vs. fluvial vs. coastal). These tradeoffs are compensated by the minimal computational time required to generate predictions once the model has been trained. Also, it is expected that the model can easily be transferred to other locations since it relies on local topographic information. The additional advantage of using a deep-learning approach is the ability to easily integrate alternative and additional data sources, which enables, for example, longer-term flood warnings driven by rainfall forecasts instead of observations.

    How to cite: Palmitessa, R., Hjermitslev, O. G., Johansen, H. E., Arnbjerg-Nielsen, K., Bauer‐Gottwein, P., Mikkelsen, P. S., and Löwe, R.: Improved flood predictions by combining satellite observations, topographic information and rainfall spatial data using deep learning, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8823, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8823, 2022.

    EGU22-9037 | Presentations | NH1.2

    Improvement of Disaster Management Approaches in Japan Using Paddy Field 

    Debanjali Saha, Kazuo Oki, Koshi Yoshida, and Hideaki Kamiya

    Japan has a history of major natural disasters, mostly due to its geographical characteristics and topographic features. Major typhoons and floods cause severe damages to lives, properties and important infrastructure, which may increase in future due to climate change. Therefore, sustainable and cost-effective disaster management strategies are of timely requirement, and paddy fields in the river flood plain areas of Japan can be effectively utilized in this regard. After the paddy harvest season, most paddy fields remain unused for a few months and during this time it can work as storage reservoir with minor interventions. During intense rainfall, water can be stored within the paddy field bunds if the drainage outlets are kept closed for some time. Thus, contribution of rainwater to the river can be lessened, resulting river discharge reduction to some extent and protecting important areas from flood damages. The potential of paddy fields in Japan as storage reservoir is not well represented in any research that involves hydrological modelling. This study is performed to assess the impact of using paddy fields for river discharge and inundation reduction, through hydrological model simulation. Two major river basins in Japan, Abukuma river in Fukushima prefecture and Chikuma river in Nagano prefecture are selected as study areas. Paddy field covers 15-20% of watershed areas of these rivers and most of these fields are very close to the main river stream, which indicates their fair potential to store rainwater and contribute to discharge reduction. A global hydrological and water resources model named ‘H08’ is used in this study to simulate river discharge for two scenarios, where one is the control scenario with no storage of water within the paddy field and another is storing rainwater within the exiting or extended paddy bunds. Simulations are performed for 2018 and 2019 to compare the normal flood year and extreme event (a super typhoon occurred in Japan in 2019). Observed and simulated discharge is compared for model calibration and results show better correlation in the upstream section of the rivers. More adjustment of model parameters is still necessary for better calibration. Simulation results show that for 2018, Abukuma river experienced 21-25% decrease in river discharge when water is stored within the conventional 25cm paddy bund. The reduction increased up to 35% when the paddy bunds are assumed to be extended up to 50cm in height. Similar results are observed for Chikuma river basin. For 2019, discharge shows 10-15% decrease for 25cm paddy bunds and around 20% reduction for proposed 50cm bund. With this discharge reduction potential, if paddy field bunds can be extended up to 50cm with a working public-private partnership, where farmers are aware of the advantages of utilizing unused paddy fields as such an effective means of flood management, then this strategy can be considered a sustainable and cost-effective way of disaster management, where the existing land-cover will act as a natural means of storage reservoir. Moreover, this sustainable strategy can be adopted in other countries having similar geographical features as Japan.

    How to cite: Saha, D., Oki, K., Yoshida, K., and Kamiya, H.: Improvement of Disaster Management Approaches in Japan Using Paddy Field, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9037, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9037, 2022.

    EGU22-10674 | Presentations | NH1.2

    Towards development of a seamless probabilistic flood inundation map for extreme flood events across Australian catchments 

    Katayoon Bahramian, Wendy Sharples, Christoph Rudiger, S L Kesav Unnithan, Basudev Biswal, Elisabetta Carrara, and Zaved Khan

    Floods in Australia are among the most costly and deadly natural disasters causing significant material damage, injury, and death. Effective emergency management to reduce the devastating consequences of flooding depends on the accuracy and reliability of forecasts. Effective infrastructure planning for flood mitigation depends on the accuracy and reliability of future projections. Flood inundation mapping is a tool widely used for flood mitigation purposes by providing information on flood event characteristics such as occurrence, magnitude, timing, and spatial extent. However, information derived from flood inundation maps is subject to uncertainties in each step of a complex modelling chain, including uncertainties in hydro-meteorological and observational datasets, digital elevation models and representation of rivers, as well as over-simplification of hydrological and hydraulic processes. Therefore, relying on a purely deterministic representation of flood characteristics may lead to poor decision making. Probabilistic flood maps are capable of accounting for uncertainty by estimating the probability of a certain area being flooded, which is a recommended approach for risk-based decision making. In addition, providing probabilistic flood map information encompassing past, present, and future, will improve Australia’s resilience to flood events and target infrastructure spending. Generation of seamless probabilistic flood maps in an operational setting, particularly at a continental scale, needs to be supported with an integrated and consistent set of hydro-meteorological datasets across timescales and catchments.  

    The aim of this study is to develop a seamless probabilistic flood inundation mapping framework for near-future to far future floods across flood-prone Australian catchments. We take advantage of products from the Australian Water Outlook (AWO: awo.bom.gov.au), a water service that provides nationally consistent water information since 1911 until the present as well as long-term projections out to 2100. In this framework, large rainfall events are detected based on ensemble forecasts or projections from AWO using a threshold analysis. After detection of a potential flood, an event-based hydrological model (URBS) is initialised to generate an ensemble of river reach hydrographs in a Monte Carlo framework where the parameterisation of the catchment wetness is informed by historical flood events for the catchment. This enables uncertainty from ensemble rainfall and catchment losses to be quantified and incorporated within the hydrograph generation step. Lastly, we combine remotely sensed data with topographic and river network information to map the flood extent, using the height above nearest drainage (HAND) method. This framework will be tested for two major flood events in February 2020 and March 2021 at Hawkesbury Nepean Valley catchment located in New South Wales, Australia, which, due to significantly different antecedent conditions, had dissimilar flood characteristics, thereby demonstrating the suitability of the framework.

    How to cite: Bahramian, K., Sharples, W., Rudiger, C., Unnithan, S. L. K., Biswal, B., Carrara, E., and Khan, Z.: Towards development of a seamless probabilistic flood inundation map for extreme flood events across Australian catchments, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10674, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10674, 2022.

    EGU22-10803 | Presentations | NH1.2

    Sensitivity analysis of network structure in missing streamflow data complementation using Bidirectional Short-Term Memory network 

    Takeyoshi Nagasato, Kei Ishida, Daiju Sakaguchi, Motoki Amagasaki, and Masato Kiyama

    Streamflow data based on the observation may be partially missing due to flood or malfunction of the measuring equipment. Here, it is important to complement the missing flow rate with high accuracy for water resource management and flood risk management. Various statistical approaches such as linear regression and multiple regression models have been proposed as methods for complementing missing flow rates. Among the statistical methods, deep learning has been rapidly evolved with the improvement of computational equipment. Then, deep learning methods have achieved remarkable success in various fields. It may indicate that there is a possibility that the missing flow rate can be complemented with high accuracy by using the deep learning method. Therefore, this study implemented deep learning for missing streamflow complementation. In addition, because the network structure of deep learning may have a great influence on estimation accuracy, this study conducted a sensitivity analysis of the network structure. Among the deep learning methods, Bidirectional LSTM (Bi-LSTM) was implemented in this study. Bi-LSTM is a kind of LSTM that can learn long-term dependence of time series data. Bi-LSTM learns data in both forward and backward directions, compared to Unidirectional LSTM which learns data forward directions. As for the input data, both hourly streamflow and precipitation data were used. For model learning and evaluation, missing streamflow data were artificially generated. The results show that Bi-LSTM can complement the flow rate with high accuracy. It also showed the importance of optimizing the network structure.

    How to cite: Nagasato, T., Ishida, K., Sakaguchi, D., Amagasaki, M., and Kiyama, M.: Sensitivity analysis of network structure in missing streamflow data complementation using Bidirectional Short-Term Memory network, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10803, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10803, 2022.

    EGU22-10827 | Presentations | NH1.2

    A Numerically-integrated Approach for Residential Flood Loss Estimation at the Community Level 

    Rubayet Bin Mostafiz, Ayat Al Assi, Carol Friedland, Robert Rohli, and Md Adilur Rahim

    Evaluating average annual loss (AAL) is an essential component of assessing and minimizing future flood risk. A robust method for quantifying flood AAL is needed to provide valuable information for stakeholder decision-making. Several recent studies suggest that the numerical integration method can provide meaningful AAL estimates since this technique includes the full loss‐exceedance probability of flood. While past research focuses on applying the numerical integration method on a single, one-family residential house, calculations across space are necessary for assessing community vulnerability. This research develops a computational framework in MATLAB for integrating across the full loss-exceedance probability curve through space to evaluate flood AAL for multiple single-family homes, including loss to the structure, content, and time spent in refurbishing it (i.e., use), over a case-study census block in Jefferson Parish, Louisiana, USA. To further inform flood mitigation planning, the AAL is also calculated for one, two, three, and four feet of freeboard and separately for each owner-occupant type of residence (i.e., homeowner, landlord, and tenant). Although previous studies provided essential information related to the structure and content loss for one type for ownership-occupant type (homeowner), the wider scope of this study allows for consideration of the use loss and the remaining ownership-occupant types. Results show that individual building AAL varies within a community because of its building attributes. Besides, results highlight the difference of AALs by owner-occupant type, with homeowners generally bearing the highest total AAL and tenants incurring the lowest total AALs. A simple elevation of only one foot can decrease the AAL by as much as 90 percent. A sensitivity analysis underscores the importance of using the exact values of the base flood elevation (BFE) compared to rounding to the nearest integer and excluding damage lower than first flood height (FFH) in the depth-damage functions (DDFs). Expanding the application of the numerical integration method to a broad-scale study area may enhance validity and accuracy as compensating errors are likely to make bulk estimates more reasonable, which might augment its utility at the community level. In general, such techniques improve resilience to flood, the costliest natural hazard, by assisting in better understanding of risk with and without mitigation efforts. 

     

    How to cite: Mostafiz, R. B., Assi, A. A., Friedland, C., Rohli, R., and Rahim, M. A.: A Numerically-integrated Approach for Residential Flood Loss Estimation at the Community Level, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10827, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10827, 2022.

    EGU22-10891 | Presentations | NH1.2

    Improvement of river flow estimation accuracy using ensemble learning stacking 

    Daiju Sakaguchi, Kei Ishida, Takeyoshi Nagasato, Motoki Amagasaki, and Masato Kiyama

    In recent years, disasters are more frequent and enormous due to global warming. In the field of hydrology, high-precision rainfall-runoff modeling is required. Recently, deep learning has been applied to rainfall-runoff modeling and shows high accuracy. It is also expected that the accuracy will be improved by using ensemble learning for deep learning. This study tried to improve the accuracy of river flow estimation by performing ensemble learning for deep learning. Stacking was used as the ensemble learning method. For deep learning, LSTM, CNN, and MLP was used and compared. XGBoost was used as the learning device used for ensemble learning. The target area was the Tedori River basin in Ishikawa Prefecture, Japan. In deep learning, the input data were daily average precipitation and temperature. In deep learning and ensemble learning, the target data was the daily average river flow. RMSE was used as the evaluation index. As a result, the accuracy was the highest after ensemble learning when using LSTM. It shows that the selection of the learning device is important for ensemble learning.

    How to cite: Sakaguchi, D., Ishida, K., Nagasato, T., Amagasaki, M., and Kiyama, M.: Improvement of river flow estimation accuracy using ensemble learning stacking, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10891, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10891, 2022.

    In recent years, climate change intensifies heavy rainfall, resulting in annual flood damage. Population is increasing worldwide, and urbanization is expected to continue expanding. Under these circumstances, once an inundation occurs, the damage is expected to be more extensive than ever before. Therefore, in this study, we are analyzing the effects of DEM resolution and land use data, which are the calculation conditions for inundation calculations in flood forecasting, on inundation characteristics such as inundation magnitude and duration during large-scale inundation.

     In this paper, the target watershed was the Tone River in Japan, where major floods have occurred in the past, and the analysis was conducted in the plain area. DEM data and land use data are important factors in determining inundation characteristics; The higher the resolution of the DEM data, the better it can represent the microtopography, which in turn affects the inundation flow. Also, land use data determines the roughness coefficient, which affects the velocity of floodwaters, and the infiltration capacity and initial loss into the ground. In this paper, The DEM data were analyzed with resolutions of 5m, 25m, 50, 100m, and 250m. The land use data for the years 1978, 1987, 1997, 2006 and 2016 were used to analyze the inundation characteristics due to increasing urbanization.

    The results of inundation analysis with different resolutions of DEM data show that the resolution has no significant effect on the inundation rate. However, as for the inundation area, the larger the mesh size, the larger the inundation area, which is expected to be caused by the homogenization of DEM data. It was also found that as urbanization progresses, the inundation area spreads faster. In addition, the urbanization process affects the diminishing period of inundation rather than the expansion process, because it loses the function of infiltration capacity, and the inundation depth is less likely to decrease.

    How to cite: Koyama, N. and Yamada, T.: Analysis of inundation characteristics under various computational conditions for large-scale flood forecasting, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10930, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10930, 2022.

    EGU22-10940 | Presentations | NH1.2

    An Improved Micro Scale Average Annual Flood Loss Implementation Approach  

    Md Adilur Rahim, Ehab S Gnan, Carol J Friedland, Rubayet Bin Mostafiz, and Robert V Rohli

    Average annual loss (AAL) is used as the basis for the evaluation of risk mitigation measures.  However, the current AAL implementations in flood risk assessment have several shortcomings. For instance, results generated using Riemann trapezoids for the available return periods of a site are typically gross approximations, especially when damage changes rapidly with depth. Monte Carlo simulations offer improvements in precision but at the expense of being computationally intensive. The log-linear method that extrapolates losses to higher return periods and performs piece-wise Riemann sum with these limited return periods can fail to capture the non-linear flood behavior. This paper presents an improved implementation that quantifies AAL at the micro-scale level including the full range of loss‐exceedance probabilities. To demonstrate the methodology, the financial benefit of increasing the lowest floor elevation for a one-story single-family residence is assessed. Several depth-damage functions (DDFs) are selected and compared to examine the variability in AAL results related to the DDF choice. Results demonstrate the need for an AAL estimate that includes the full loss‐exceedance probabilities. Results also highlight the need to assess flood risk at the micro-scale level for a more localized and accurate assessment, whereupon the estimate can be expanded to broader-scale risk estimations with a higher degree of accuracy. The more realistic AAL estimates results could encourage homeowners and communities to take action and support government decision-makers by investing in flood mitigation and considering building code changes.

    How to cite: Rahim, M. A., Gnan, E. S., Friedland, C. J., Mostafiz, R. B., and Rohli, R. V.: An Improved Micro Scale Average Annual Flood Loss Implementation Approach , EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10940, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10940, 2022.

    EGU22-12430 | Presentations | NH1.2

    Modelling the natural flood management in medium scale lowland catchments in Thames Basin (UK) 

    Heou Maleki Badjana, Anne Verhoef, Hannah Cloke, Stefan Julich, Patrick McGuire, Carla Camargos, and Joanna Clark

    Natural flood management (NFM) is widely promoted and adopted as an effective way of managing flood risks. However, there remain many unknowns especially on its effectiveness at medium and large scales. This study has first analysed the consistency of a modelling framework that integrates the Soil and Water Assessment Tool (SWAT) model for simulating the land based NFM in two medium scale lowland catchments within the Thames River basin (UK). Afterwards, it has assessed the effectiveness of NFM in these catchments using broadscale hypothetical scenarios. The results show that it is possible to model land-based NFM in medium scale catchments but this is highly dependent on the one hand on catchment landscape characteristics and on the other hand on the availability and quality of necessary input datasets, model choice, configuration, parametrisation and calibration and uncertainty analysis techniques. Furthermore, the NFM effects vary across the catchments and landscapes characteristics. Afforestation seems to provide less effect on large flood events in terms of reducing the peak flows compared to small events. The implementation of crop rotation scenarios, depending on the crop choice and tillage practice may lead to the increase of the peak flows. Overall, this study showed that NFM modelling in medium catchments is not straightforward and prior to any task, an extensive analysis needs to be carried out to understand the datasets, the model, and processes configuration as well as different calibration and uncertainties analysis techniques. Moreover, the choice of woodland planting only as NFM measure will require an extensive work within the catchment to produce an effect which suggests that to better minimise the flood risk, the combination with other measures that can reduce the amount of flow reaching the river channel or delay the timing of the peak flow (eg. leaky barriers) would be necessary.

    How to cite: Badjana, H. M., Verhoef, A., Cloke, H., Julich, S., McGuire, P., Camargos, C., and Clark, J.: Modelling the natural flood management in medium scale lowland catchments in Thames Basin (UK), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12430, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12430, 2022.

    EGU22-574 | Presentations | CR2.1

    Development of a permittivity sensor for melting probes to explore terrestrial and extraterrestrial cryospheres 

    Fabian Becker, Pia Friend, and Klaus Helbing

    We will present the design of a permittivity sensor that can be attached to a melting probe and measure the respective ice properties during the melting process, yielding in a comprehensive permittivity profile. Melting probes were already successfully applied in terrestrial cryospheres, such as alpine glaciers and Antarctica. Further applications to cross the ice shield on Dome C in Antarctica or even on icy moons in the outer solar system, such as Europa, are already planned e.g. within the TRIPLE project line funded by the German aerospace center. A sensor measuring the permittivity of the surrounding ice in situ during melting could provide valuable data about the ice properties. The respective density of the ice is correlated with the permittivity, or volcanic ash layers can be identified through permittivity measurements. Another usage of the data could be to correct distance measurements from radar travel times within the ice.

    The sensor is designed to operate in the frequency range of 0.1 - 1.5 GHz and works in the range of the near field, which is defined to be within one wavelength, corresponding to the frequency. The concept of this sensor is based on an open coaxial probe, which is connected to the medium of interest. The measurement principle and calibration techniques, as well as first lab measurement results of ice and other materials will be presented. A comprehensive data set on effects of porosity, salinity and impurities of lab-manufactured ice samples on the permittivity will also be given. These data will help to interpret the taken permittivity profiles of glaciers on further missions.

    We will also show how the device can be integrated into a melting probe, such as the TRIPLE melting probe. One major challenge is to ensure good contact to the ice during measurement. The diameter of a melting hole often results to be several cm larger in diameter than the melting probe itself. A mechanism that extends the sensors of the melting probe and press it onto the ice for measurements is being developed. 

    How to cite: Becker, F., Friend, P., and Helbing, K.: Development of a permittivity sensor for melting probes to explore terrestrial and extraterrestrial cryospheres, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-574, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-574, 2022.

    EGU22-612 | Presentations | CR2.1 | Highlight

    Using offsets in airborne radar sounding and laser altimetry to characterize near-surface firn properties over the Greenland ice sheet 

    Anja Rutishauser, Andreas P. Ahlstrøm, Robert S. Fausto, Nanna B. Karlsson, Baptiste Vandecrux, Kirk M. Scanlan, Ghislain Picard, and Signe B. Andersen

    In recent decades, the Greenland Ice Sheet (GrIS) has experienced a significant increase in surface melting and meltwater runoff, which is now the main contributor to GrIS mass loss. In areas covered by firn, meltwater percolation and refreezing processes can significantly buffer meltwater runoff to the ocean. However, this process leads to the formation of ice layers and an overall firn densification, which is predicted to limit the firns’ meltwater storage capacity in the future. Additionally, the high spatial and temporal variability of ice layer formation and subsequent firn densification can cause large uncertainties in altimetry-derived mass balance estimates. Thus, understanding the spatial and vertical extent of ice layers in the firn is important to estimate the GrIS contribution to sea-level rise.

    Due to limited direct observations of firn properties, modeling future meltwater runoff and processes over the rapidly changing GrIS firn facies remains challenging. Here, we present a prospective new technique that leverages concurrent airborne radar sounding and laser altimetry measurements to characterize near-surface firn over spatially extensive areas. We hypothesize that due to their different depth sensitivities, the presence of ice layers in the firn yields an offset between radar sounding- and laser-derived surface elevations (differential altimetry). We compare existing airborne radar and laser measurements to in-situ firn observations and use one-dimensional radar sounding simulations to investigate 1) the sensitivity of the differential altimetry technique to different firn facies, and 2) the techniques’ capability to estimate firn density and firn ice content. Preliminary results over the western GrIS show good correlations between differential altimetry signatures and areas of firn affected by percolation and refreezing processes.

    Through this technique, we explore the potential to leverage a wealth of radar sounding measurements conducted at low frequencies (< 200 MHz), that typically do not resolve the firn structure, to derive near-surface firn properties. Finally, we apply the differential altimetry technique to data collected as part of NASA’s Operation IceBridge between 2009-2019 to derive spatio-temporal changes in the GrIS firn in response to climatic conditions, in particular the formation of ice layers and changes in firn ice content. Our results can help reduce uncertainties in satellite-derived mass balance measurements and improve firn models, which both contribute to reducing uncertainties in current and projected GrIS contributions to global sea-level rise.

    How to cite: Rutishauser, A., Ahlstrøm, A. P., Fausto, R. S., Karlsson, N. B., Vandecrux, B., Scanlan, K. M., Picard, G., and Andersen, S. B.: Using offsets in airborne radar sounding and laser altimetry to characterize near-surface firn properties over the Greenland ice sheet, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-612, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-612, 2022.

    EGU22-942 | Presentations | CR2.1

    Towards assembling the internal ice stratigraphy in coastal regions of Dronning Maud Land, East Antarctica 

    Reinhard Drews, Inka Koch, Falk Oraschewski, Mohammadreza Ershadi, Leah Sophie Muhle, Heiko Spiegel, Vjeran Visnjevic, Guy Moss, Jakob Macke, Steven Franke, Daniela Jansen, Daniel Steinhage, and Olaf Eisen

    The internal ice stratigraphy as imaged by radar is an integrated archive of the atmospheric- oceanographic, and ice-dynamic history that the ice sheet has experienced. It provides an observational constraint for ice flow modeling that has been used for instance to predict age-depth relationships at prospective ice-coring sites in Antarctica’s interior. The stratigraphy is typically more disturbed and more difficult to image in coastal regions due to faster ice flow. Yet, knowledge of ice stratigraphy across ice shelf grounding lines and further seawards is important to help constrain ocean-induced melting and associated stability.

    Here, we present preliminary results of synthesizing information from radar stratigraphic characteristics from airborne and ground-based radar surveys that have been collected for specific projects starting from the 1990s onwards focusing on ice marginal zones of Antarctica. The key data is based on airborne surveys from the German Alfred Wegener Institute’s polar aircrafts equipped with a 150 MHz radar. In the meantime this system has been replaced by an ultra-wide band 150-520 MHz radar. The older data will provide a baseline with extensive coverage that can be used for model calibration and change detection over time. We aim to provide metrics of the radio stratigraphy (e.g. shape and slope of internal reflection horizons) as well as classified prevalent stratigraphy types that can be used to calibrate machine learning approaches such as simulation based inference. The data obtained will be integrated in coordination efforts within the SCAR AntArchitecture Action Group.

    How to cite: Drews, R., Koch, I., Oraschewski, F., Ershadi, M., Muhle, L. S., Spiegel, H., Visnjevic, V., Moss, G., Macke, J., Franke, S., Jansen, D., Steinhage, D., and Eisen, O.: Towards assembling the internal ice stratigraphy in coastal regions of Dronning Maud Land, East Antarctica, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-942, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-942, 2022.

    EGU22-1002 | Presentations | CR2.1

    Application of cosmic ray snow gauges to monitor the snow water equivalent on alpine glaciers 

    Rebecca Gugerli, Darin Desilets, and Nadine Salzmann

    Temporally continuous measurements of the snow water equivalent (SWE) are a key variable in many hydrological, meteorological and glaciological studies and are of particular importance in high mountain regions. Obtaining temporally continuous, accurate and reliable SWE observations in these harsh environments, however, remains a challenge. Recently, promising results have been achieved by using a neutronic cosmic ray snow gauge (n-CRSG). The n-CRSG device is deployed below the seasonal snowpack and counts fast neutrons from the secondary cascades of cosmic rays, which are efficiently moderated and absorbed by the hydrogen atoms contained in the snowpack. Based on the exponential relationship between neutrons and hydrogen atoms, we can infer SWE from the neutron count rate. We have installed and evaluated a n-CRSG on the Swiss Glacier de la Plaine Morte. Our validation with 22 manual measurements over five winter seasons (2016/17-2020/21) showed an average underestimation of -2% ±10% (one standard deviation).
    In the present study, we explore the use of muons instead of neutrons to infer SWE. To this end, we deployed two muonic cosmic ray snow gauges (µ-CRSG), one below and one above the seasonal snowpack, for the winter season 2020/21 on the same glacier site in Switzerland. The difference in count rates between the top and bottom device can be related to the SWE of the snowpack. We derive a first-cut conversion function based on manual SWE observations by means of snow pits and snow cores. To evaluate the measurements by the µ-CRSG, we also compare them to SWE estimates by the n-CRSG. Over the winter season 2020/21, almost up to 2000 mm w.e. were observed. Overall, the µ-CRSG agrees well with the n-CRSG on the evolution of the snowpack at a high temporal resolution and thus demonstrates its great potential. Also, the inferred SWE measurements lie within the uncertainty of manual observations. Furthermore, the µ-CRSG has several advantages over the n-CRSG; It is cheaper, lighter and promises a higher measurement precision due to the improved counting statistics of the muon count rates. We conclude that the µ-CRSG has even greater potential than the n-CRSG to monitor SWE in remote high mountain environments.

    How to cite: Gugerli, R., Desilets, D., and Salzmann, N.: Application of cosmic ray snow gauges to monitor the snow water equivalent on alpine glaciers, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1002, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1002, 2022.

    EGU22-1021 | Presentations | CR2.1

    Best practices for collecting polarimetric data with ApRES for constraining ice-fabric orientation and its spatial variability 

    Olaf Eisen, Reza Ershadi, Reinhard Drews, Sophie Berger, Da Gong, Yazhou Li, Carlos Martin, and Ole Zeising

    In recent years radar polarimetry has re-surfaced as an ideal tool to determine ice-fabric patterns and linked mechanical ice anisotropy. The leap forward was facilitated by coherent data processing often collected by phase-sensitive Radio-Echo-Sounding (pRES) systems at fixed locations. The polarimetric response can either be synthesized from a set of quad-polarimetric measurements or obtained by manually rotating the antennas. Specifics of the data collection in the field varied between the different surveys, and no set of best practices has yet emerged.  Here we present a systematic study that includes more than fifty different combinations of how polarimetric data can be acquired, including:

    • different distances between the transmitter and receiver (2, 4 and 8 m)
    • different combinations in polarization orientation (22.5 deg)
    • a comparison between discrete full azimuthal data collected every 22.5 degrees and synthesized data collected in a quad-pole setup
    • the effect of 180-degree polarization orientation on repeat measurements, e.g., basal melt rate and polarimetric analysis, e.g., coherence phase
    • definition of Horizontal (H) and Vertical (V) orientation is pRES antenna setup and its impact on synthesizing and analyzing data
    • 90-degree fabric orientation ambiguity in polarimetric data

    This study aims to provide best practices, considering that observation time in the field is limited. Ideally, this will lead to a unified setup and nomenclature, facilitating better compatibility from data collected by different groups on ice sheets, shelves, and glaciers.

    How to cite: Eisen, O., Ershadi, R., Drews, R., Berger, S., Gong, D., Li, Y., Martin, C., and Zeising, O.: Best practices for collecting polarimetric data with ApRES for constraining ice-fabric orientation and its spatial variability, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1021, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1021, 2022.

    EGU22-1852 | Presentations | CR2.1

    Changes in the internal structure of polythermal glaciers over the last decade: the case study of Fridtjofbreen and Erdmanbreen from 2010 to 2021, Svalbard 

    Aleksandr Borisik, Aleksandr Novikov, Ivan Lavrentiev, and Andrey Glazovsky

    Glaciers on Svalbard have been shrinking in recent decades in response to current climate change. Most of them have decreased in size, area and surface elevation with stable negative or even accelerated changes in mass balance. Many of them are of the polythermal type, and as they shrink, their thermal regime might also change significantly depending on climate and local parameters, such as distribution of ice facies, firn thickness, and other factors affecting hydrology and glacier movement. In this study, we used data from repeated GPR surveys in 2010/12 and 2020/21 to identify likely changes in the thermal regime of the two polythermal glaciers Fridtjovbreen and Erdmanbreen in the western part of the Nordenskiöldland. These changes we have identified by comparison of changes in the depth of the internal reflection horizon (IRH) which corresponds to the cold-temperate transition surface (CTS) in polythermal glaciers.

    Comparison of radio-echo sounding (RES) data obtained along the same transverse and longitudinal transects shows that in the last decade the most prominent CTS changes have occurred in the upper western basin of the Fridtjovbreen, where the mean total ice thickness decreased with rate −0.76 m a-1 (from 151 to 144 m in 9 years), meanwhile the thickness of the temperate ice core decreased with rate −2.52 m a-1 (from 115 to 92 m). As a result, with a general reduction in the thickness of the glacier, its upper cold layer increased from 36 to 52 m. These changes we attribute to the reduction of the firn area in this basin, which resulted in less thermal insulation and water retention and internal refreezing, and, therefore, in the fast cold front penetration into the glacier body with rates more than 3 times higher than the glacier thinning.

    How to cite: Borisik, A., Novikov, A., Lavrentiev, I., and Glazovsky, A.: Changes in the internal structure of polythermal glaciers over the last decade: the case study of Fridtjofbreen and Erdmanbreen from 2010 to 2021, Svalbard, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1852, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1852, 2022.

    EGU22-3030 | Presentations | CR2.1

    Arctic Sea-Ice Permittivity Derived from GNSS Reflectometry Data of the MOSAiC Expedition 

    Maximilian Semmling, Jens Wickert, Frederik Kreß, Mainul Hoque, Dmitry Divine, Sebastian Gerland, and Gunnar Spreen

    Sea ice is a crucial parameter of the Earth’s climate system. Its high albedo compared to water and its insulating effect between ocean and atmosphere influences the oceans’ radiation budget significantly. The importance of monitoring sea-ice properties arises from the high variability of sea ice induced by seasonal change and global warming. GNSS reflectometry can contribute to global monitoring of sea ice with high potential to extend the spatio-temporal coverage of today’s observation techniques. Properties like ice salinity, temperature, thickness and snow cover can affect the signal reflection. The MOSAiC expedition (Multidisciplinary drifting Observatory for the Study of Arctic Climate) gave us the opportunity to conduct reflectometry measurements under different sea-ice conditions in the central Arctic. A dedicated setup was mounted, in close cooperation with the Alfred-Wegener-Institute (AWI), on the German research icebreaker Polarstern that drifted for one year with the Arctic sea ice.

    We present results from data recorded between autumn 2019 and spring 2020. The ship drifted in this period from the Siberian Sector of the Arctic (October 2019), over the central Arctic (November 2019 until May 2020) towards Fram Strait and Svalbard (reached in June 2020). Profiles of sea-ice reflectivity over elevation angle (range: 1° to 45°) are derived with daily resolution considering reflection data recorded at left-handed (LH) and right-handed (RH) circular polarization. Respective predictions of reflectivity are based on reflection models of bulk sea ice or a sea-ice slab. The latter allows to include the effect of signal penetration down to the underlying water. Results of comparison between LH profiles and bulk model confirm a reflectivity decrease (about 10 dB) when surrounding open water areas is reduced (by freezing) and the ship drifts in compact sea ice.

    Further results comprise estimates of sea-ice permittivity from mid-elevation range reflectivity (10° to 30°). The median of estimated permittivity 2.4 (period of compact sea ice) lies in the expected range of reported old ice type (mostly second-year ice). The retrieved reflectivity in the low-elevation range (1° to 10°) give strong indication of signal penetration into the dominating second-year ice with influence of sea ice temperature and thickness. We conclude that sea-ice characterization in future can profit form GNSS reflectometry observations. The on-going study is currently extended to the further evolution of Arctic sea ice during winter and spring period of the MOSAiC expedition.

    How to cite: Semmling, M., Wickert, J., Kreß, F., Hoque, M., Divine, D., Gerland, S., and Spreen, G.: Arctic Sea-Ice Permittivity Derived from GNSS Reflectometry Data of the MOSAiC Expedition, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3030, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3030, 2022.

    EGU22-3073 | Presentations | CR2.1 | Highlight

    Drone-based GPR system for 4D glacier data acquisition 

    Bastien Ruols, Ludovic Baron, and James Irving

    Thanks to the excellent propagation characteristics of radar waves in ice, ground-penetrating radar (GPR) has been one of the key geophysical methods used in the field of glaciology over the last 50 years. Alpine glacier GPR surveys are typically performed either directly on the glacier surface (e.g., on foot, skis, or with snowmobiles), or by helicopter several tens of meters above the surface. Helicopter-based surveys allow the coverage of large areas safely and efficiently, but this comes at the expense of reduced resolution of glacier internal structures, particularly in the context of 3D surveys. On the other hand, ice-based acquisitions offer high-resolution opportunities, but are very time-consuming, often risky, and can be physically exhausting to perform. Recent advances in the development of drone technologies open new data acquisition possibilities for glacier GPR data, combining the advantages of both ice and air-based methods.

    We have developed a drone-based GPR system that allows for safe and efficient high-resolution 3D and 4D data acquisition on alpine glaciers. Our custom-built GPR instrument uses real-time sampling to record traces of length 2800 ns, which corresponds to a depth of over 200 m in glacier ice. Each trace is stacked over 5000 times and acquired using a sampling frequency of 320 MHz, the latter of which is just enough to avoid aliasing with our single lightweight 70-MHz-center-frequency antenna. Traces are recorded at a rate of 14 Hz, meaning that a drone speed of at least 4 m/s can be considered while maintaining a sufficiently high trace density for high-resolution studies. This is at least four times faster than a conventional survey on foot. The total weight of our GPR system plus single transmit/receive antenna is around 2 kg. The drone used in our work has a maximum payload capacity of about 6 kg and is equipped with a radar-based ground sensor which enables us to follow the glacier surface topography during the flights. An independent differential GPS allows us to locate each recorded GPR trace with decimeter precision.

    We performed initial testing of the above-described system in August 2021 on the Otemma glacier and successfully acquired around 70-line kilometers of 3D GPR data, over an 8-day period, covering a large portion of the glacier. In September 2021, we undertook additional fieldwork on the Tsanfleuron and Sex-Rouge glaciers and recorded 30-line kilometers of 3D GPR data in less than 3 days. We could then determine and model with high-precision the ice-thickness distribution over the Tsanfleuron pass. These first field results show the concrete benefit of drone-based GPR glacier surveys and motivate further development towards 3D and 4D studies.

    How to cite: Ruols, B., Baron, L., and Irving, J.: Drone-based GPR system for 4D glacier data acquisition, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3073, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3073, 2022.

    EGU22-3192 | Presentations | CR2.1

    Strong Ocean Influence on Seasonal Changes in Shallow Shear-Modulus Structure in Alaska 

    Toshiro Tanimoto and Jiong Wang

    We have developed a method to determine shear-modulus (rigidity) structure for the upper 20-50m of the Earth. The method is based on the analysis of co-located pressure and seismic instruments. We applied this method to about 200 (co-located) stations in Alaska and examined seasonal variation in shallow shear-modulus structure at each site; in this report we quantify this seasonal change by taking the ratio (R) of the highest shear-modulus to the lowest throughout a year and use it as a characteristic feature for each station.

    R is smaller than 2 at many stations but there are some stations in and near the Arctic zone that have R larger than 10. Such a large seasonal change implies that there occurs massive melting of shallow permafrost and a significant development of the active layer every summer. As a side product, because of such a huge reduction in near-surface shear-modulus, horizontal amplitudes in seismic noise become 30 times larger in summer than amplitudes in winter.

    These seasonal changes may not be surprising because thawing of ice is common every summer in the permafrost region. But regions with large R show a systematic geographic pattern on a large-scale map; large-R stations are typically found near the coast (ocean) and tend to decrease toward the interior of the continent (Alaska and NW Canada). Large R stations are found in the NW Territories in Canada, the North Slope region northern side of the Brooks Range, near the Seaward Peninsula (west), and the Yukon-Kuskokwim Delta (west). These locations suggest a strong influence by the nearby ocean on the climate at each station. Proximity to the ocean (coast) seems to be an important factor in evaluating periglacial hazards.

    There are a few exceptions in the northernmost coastal stations as they show small R despite the fact that they are at the coast. But the ICEsat-2 (satellite) data show that sea ice seems to remain thick near the peninsula (near Barrow, Alaska) much longer than other coastal areas in this study; temperature is colder because of thicker sea ice and the amount of melting at these exception sites remains low. This would strengthen the hypothesis that near-coastal ocean has strong influence on the climate of continental interior.

    How to cite: Tanimoto, T. and Wang, J.: Strong Ocean Influence on Seasonal Changes in Shallow Shear-Modulus Structure in Alaska, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3192, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3192, 2022.

    EGU22-3205 | Presentations | CR2.1 | Highlight

    Estimation of snow SWE using passive RFID tags as radar reflectors 

    Mathieu Le Breton, Éric Larose, Laurent Baillet, Alec van Herwijnen, and Yves Lejeune

    Estimation of snow SWE using passive RFID tags as radar reflectors

    Mathieu Le Breton(1,2), Éric Larose(1), Laurent Baillet(1), Alec van Herwijnen(3), Yves Lejeune(4)

    (1) Univ. Grenoble Alpes, CNRS, ISTerre, Grenoble, France
    (2)
    Géolithe Innov, Géolithe, Crolles, France
    (3)
    WSL Institute for Snow and Avalanche Research SLF, Davos, Switzerland
    (4)
    CEN-CNRM, Météo-France, CNRS, Saint Martin d’Heres, France

     

    Passive radio-frequency identification (RFID) tags are used massively to remotely identify industrial goods, and their capabilities offer new ways to monitor the earth’s surface already applied to coarse sediments, landslides, rock fissures and soils (Le Breton et al., 2910, 2020, 2021b). We introduce a method to estimate the variations in snow water equivalent (SWE) of a snowpack using an 865–868 MHz (RFID) system based on commercial off-the-shelf devices. The system consists of a vertical profile of low-cost passive tags installed before the first snowfall, on a structure that is minimally disruptive to the snowpack. The tags are interrogated continuously and remotely by a fixed reader located above the snow. The key measured value is the increase of phase delay, induced by the new layers of fresh snow which slow down the propagation of the waves. The method is tested both in a controlled laboratory environment, and outdoors on the Col de Porte observation site, in order to cross-check the results with a well-documented reference dataset (Lejeune et al., 2019). The experiments demonstrate that SWE can be estimated by this non-contact and non-destructive RFID technique. However, multipath interferences in the snowpack can generate errors up to 40 mm of SWE. This error is mitigated by using multiple tags and antennas placed at different locations, allowing the RFID measurements to remain within +/-10% of the cumulated precipitations (outdoor) and snow weighting (laboratory). In complement, the system can also estimate whether the snow is wet or dry, using temperature sensors embedded in the tags combined with the received signal strength. Using this approach with a mobile reader could allow the non-destructive monitoring of snow properties with a large number of low-cost, passive sensing tags.

     

    Publications related to the project:

    Le Breton, M., Baillet, L., Larose, E., Rey, E., Benech, P., Jongmans, D., Guyoton, F., Jaboyedoff, M., 2019. Passive radio-frequency identification ranging, a dense and weather-robust technique for landslide displacement monitoring. Eng. Geol. 250, 1–10. http://doi.org/10.1016/j.enggeo.2018.12.027

    Le Breton, M., Grunbaum, N., Baillet, L., Larose, É., 2021a. Monitoring rock displacement threshold with 1-bit sensing passive RFID tag (No. EGU21-15305). Presented at the EGU21, Copernicus Meetings. http://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu21-15305

    Le Breton, M., Liébault, F., Baillet, L., Charléty, A., Larose, É., Tedjini, S., 2021b. Dense and long-term monitoring of Earth surface processes with passive RFID -- a review. Submitted. Preprint at: https://arxiv.org/abs/2112.11965v1

    Lejeune, Y., Dumont, M., Panel, J.-M., Lafaysse, M., Lapalus, P., Le Gac, E., Lesaffre, B., Morin, S., 2019. 57 years (1960–2017) of snow and meteorological observations from a mid-altitude mountain site (Col de Porte, France, 1325 m of altitude). Earth Syst. Sci. Data 11, 71–88. http://doi.org/10.5194/essd-11-71-2019

    How to cite: Le Breton, M., Larose, É., Baillet, L., van Herwijnen, A., and Lejeune, Y.: Estimation of snow SWE using passive RFID tags as radar reflectors, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3205, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3205, 2022.

    EGU22-3248 | Presentations | CR2.1

    Annual development of subalpine grassland observed with UAV: how NDVI evolution is controlled by snow melting 

    Jesús Revuelto, Javier Sobrino, Daniel Gómez, Guillermo Rodriguez-López, Esteban Alonso-González, Francisco Rojas-Heredia, Eñaut Izagirre, Raquel Montorio-Lloveria, Fernando Pérez-Cabello, and Juan Ignacio López-Moreno

    In the Pyrenees, as in other mid latitude mountain ranges, sub alpine areas have a long lasting snow cover that affect different mountain processes, including river discharge timing, soil erosion, primary production or animal and plant phenology. This work presents and analyzes a complete snow depth and Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) spatial distribution dataset, generated by Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAV) over two years. This study aims to increase the knowledge and understanding of the relationship of the duration and timing of snowmelt and vegetation cover and its annual cycle.

    The dataset was obtained in Izas Experimental Catchment, a 55 ha study area located in Central Spanish Pyrenees ranging between 2000 to 2300 m a.s.l., which is mostly covered by grasslands. A total of 18 UAV snow depth and 14 NDVI observations were obtained by a fixed wing UAV equipped with RGB and multispectral cameras during 2020 and 2021. The melt out date for the different areas of the catchment has been obtained from the snow depth distribution dataset, which in turn has been used to analyze the NDVI evolution. The NDVI values for each UAV flight have been correlated with the snow depth distribution observed in previous dates and with different topographic variables as elevation, solar radiation, curvature (through the Topographic Position Index) or slope.

    The maximum seasonal NDVI happens throughout the study area simultaneously in the entire study area; however those zones with the latest snow disappearance do not reach NDVI values as high as those observed in areas with earlier snow disappearance. Oppositely areas with the soonest snow melting (in late February) have lower maximum NDVI values that those observed in areas with snow melting occurring later (around May).  NDVI correlations have shown that the snow depth distribution observed about one month prior to each NDVI acquisition has a very important control on pasture phenology. This correlation is particularly evident on the free-snow areas during first melting weeks, with a lower influence in those areas where snow melts at the end of the snow season. This field study exemplifies how intensive UAV acquisitions allow understanding snow processes over extended areas with an unprecedented spatial resolution.

    How to cite: Revuelto, J., Sobrino, J., Gómez, D., Rodriguez-López, G., Alonso-González, E., Rojas-Heredia, F., Izagirre, E., Montorio-Lloveria, R., Pérez-Cabello, F., and López-Moreno, J. I.: Annual development of subalpine grassland observed with UAV: how NDVI evolution is controlled by snow melting, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3248, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3248, 2022.

    EGU22-4179 | Presentations | CR2.1

    Hansbreen’s calving-driven ice loss derived from seismic data supported by millimetre-wave radar scans and neural networks 

    Wojciech Gajek, William Harcourt, and Dannielle Pearce

    Calving of tidewater glaciers is a key driver of glacier mass loss as well as a significant contribution towards sea level rise. However, this dynamic process is still challenging to quantify. In addition, there are very few direct measurements of calving activity in Svalbard at daily to sub-daily resolution due to the requirement of continuous human labour at the calving front for field studies. Seismic instruments in the vicinity of glaciers offer the potential to circumvent this issue since they record ground motion signals, including those generated by calving events, with an unprecedented sub-second resolution. Such data sets are not affected by site conditions like poor visibility or darkness and, in the case of permanent regional seismological stations, already offer long-term datasets. Despite this, a knowledge gap remains which prevents making a direct link between precise calving volumes and seismic records. This study presents our effort made towards obtaining an estimate of volumetric ice loss from integrating seismic records with 3D millimetre-wave radar measurements of a tidewater glacier calving front. In the summer of 2021, an 8-day long time series of integrated measurements was acquired at the calving front of Hansbreen, South Spitsbergen. It included remote sensing observations from a millimetre-wave radar (AVTIS2), Terrestrial Laser Scanner and time-lapse cameras correlated with a seismic dataset from two local arrays deployed at direct vicinity of calving front and a closeby regional permanent seismological station in Hornsund. Integrating these datasets brings an opportunity to correlate visual observations of calving including volumetric ice loss derived from radar scans with seismic signatures registered at nearby seismic arrays. We explore various parameters that characterize observed calving events and develop a model linking chosen parameters with ice loss using machine learning techniques. Local arrays were installed for a limited time and the calibrated parameters are expected to change spatially. Therefore, we further transfer our approach and integrate decade long records from nearby permanent seismological station. Limiting data to a single station record reduces both the accuracy of estimated ice volume and spatial resolution. However, it enables us to apply detection algorithm trained using observed calvings to decade long records and, consequently, to revisit a decade long history of Hansbreen's calving.

    How to cite: Gajek, W., Harcourt, W., and Pearce, D.: Hansbreen’s calving-driven ice loss derived from seismic data supported by millimetre-wave radar scans and neural networks, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4179, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4179, 2022.

    EGU22-4573 | Presentations | CR2.1

    Single-frequency GNSS-IR for estimating snowpack height with consumer grade receivers and antennas 

    Giulia Graldi, Simone Rover, and Alfonso Vitti

    Ground and space based GNSS-IR (Interferometric Reflectometry) has been used in the last 20 years for characterizing the Earth Surface, together with other remote sensing techniques. Among the physical quantities which can be monitored using these techniques, the characterization of the snow cover is of particular interest since it is an important source of freshwater. The increase of the global temperature due to anthropogenic climate changes is threatening the seasonal recharging, and for this reason monitoring the snow cover is crucial. Ground based GNSS-IR can be used for obtaining information on the height of the snowpack, with a precision of 0.04 m by using geodetic-grade GNSS instruments (such those involved in Continuously Operating Reference Stations - CORS). In the present study, the sensitivity of the retrieval of the snowpack height from data acquired with low cost non-geodetic grade instruments with the GNSS-IR technique is evaluated. The analysis is applied to a flat alpine area in the Lavarone plateau in the Province of Trento, Italy (1400 m above sea level), where GNSS field campaigns were carried out in 2018, 2019 for short time periods (90, 120 minutes) due to constraints of the study area. Single-frequency GPS observations were collected with u-blox M8T GNSS receivers and patch u-blox and Tallysman antennas. Leica antenna and receiver were also used for collecting GPS data in double frequency, in order to acquire reference data with geodetic grade instruments. Given the characteristics of the area, it is possible to consider that GPS signals reflect with specular reflection, and thus modelling the Signal to Noise Ratio (SNR) as a function of the distance between the reflecting snow surface above solid ground and the antenna. Multipath frequency associated with snowpack height is retrieved by applying the Lomb Scargle Periodogram on SNR data. The results show that, by applying GNSS-IR technique to data acquired with low-cost receivers and antennas, it is possible to retrieve the height of the snow pack with a standard deviation of about 0.05 m. This demonstrates the feasibility of GNSS-IR also with non-geodetic grade instruments.

    How to cite: Graldi, G., Rover, S., and Vitti, A.: Single-frequency GNSS-IR for estimating snowpack height with consumer grade receivers and antennas, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4573, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4573, 2022.

    Ice thickness is a key parameter for predictive ice sheet modeling, geological interpretation of the underlying bed rock, and site selection for deep ice sheet and bed rock sampling.  However, the uncertainties typically reported are in terms of crossover statistics, and ice thickness uncertainties are generally not formally integrated into ice sheet models.  Here we examine what crossover statistics reveal and conceal for the actual uncertainty in reported ice thickness, examine the impact of system and geometric parameters on uncertainties, and place these parameters in the context of the observed subglacial roughness.  We provide a predictive model for uncertainties as a function of ice thickness, sensor height, and subglacial roughness parameters, evaluate it from the perspective of ground based, airborne and orbital sounding and make recommendations for parameters that should be reported in ice thickness data products.

    How to cite: Young, D., Kempf, S., and Ng, G.: Beyond crossovers: Predicting ice thickness uncertainties in ice penetrating radar data from geometric controls, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5506, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5506, 2022.

    EGU22-5865 | Presentations | CR2.1

    Diffraction imaging of alpine glacier GPR data 

    Johanna Klahold, Benjamin Schwarz, Alexander Bauer, and James Irving

    Over the past decades, ground-penetrating radar (GPR) has become a fundamental tool in glaciological studies thanks to its tremendous capacity to provide high-resolution images in snow and ice. 3D acquisitions in particular can give detailed information on the internal structure, properties, and dynamics of glaciers. For imaging and highlighting important englacial and subglacial features such as meltwater tunnels and voids, an analysis of the spatial distribution of diffractions in the data holds great potential. However, the diffracted wavefield typically has low amplitude and is often masked by more prominent arrivals. Diffraction separation and imaging procedures have already become topics of significant interest in the field of exploration seismology, and may potentially open new possibilities for the analysis of glacier GPR data.

    Here, we explore the potential of recent advances in diffraction imaging for the analysis of alpine glacier GPR data. To this end, we consider a 3D data set acquired on the Haut Glacier d’Arolla (Valais, Switzerland) using a 70-MHz single-antenna real-time-sampling GPR system. The approach we use coherently approximates the dominant reflected wavefield and subtracts it from the data. The remaining diffracted wavefield is then enhanced using local coherent stacking. We find that this methodology is highly effective at isolating diffractions in glacier GPR data and provides clean images of the diffracting structures. Current work includes investigation of the correlation between these structures and the englacial and subglacial hydrological network.

    How to cite: Klahold, J., Schwarz, B., Bauer, A., and Irving, J.: Diffraction imaging of alpine glacier GPR data, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5865, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5865, 2022.

    The radar detection of bedrock interface and internal ice layers is a widely used technique for observing interiors and bottoms of ice sheets, which is also an important indicator of inferring the evolution of glaciers and explaining subglacial topographies. The conventional methods, such as the filtering denoise, are limited by the low contrast in ice radar image with noise and interferes and thus the automatic method in tracing and extracting layers' features is trapped. The manual and semiautomatic methods are widely applied but with large time-consuming especially for the large-scale radar image with continuous bedrock and internal layers. To extract and identify the bedrock interface and internal ice layers automatically, we propose EisNet, a fusion system consisting of three sub neural networks. Because of the limitations of conventional manual methods, it is relatively rare that the high-precision extraction of layer features, which can be applied as labels in training. To obtain sufficient radar images with high-quality training labels, we also propose a novel synthetic method to simulate the not only visual texture of the bedrock interface and internal layers but also the artifact noise and interference to match the feature in field data. EisNet is first verified on synthetic data and shows capacity on the extraction of multi types of layer targets. Second, the application on observational radar images reveals EisNet’s generalized performance from synthetic data to the CHINARE data. EisNet is also applied to extract bedrock interfaces from the radar film from the Antarctic. EisNet is now open open-accessing. We hope that EisNet could be applied in more ice radar images from other regions and different forms to promote glacial research.

    How to cite: Dong, S., Tang, X., and Fu, L.: Using EisNet to Extract Bedrock and Internal layers from Digital and Analog Radiostratigraphy in Ice Sheets, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6377, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6377, 2022.

    EGU22-6414 | Presentations | CR2.1

    Ice layer detection, distribution, and thickness in the near-surface firn on Devon Ice Cap: a new dual-frequency radar characterization approach 

    Kristian Chan, Cyril Grima, Anja Rutishauser, Duncan A. Young, Riley Culberg, and Donald D. Blankenship

    Atmospheric warming has led to increased surface melting on glaciers in the Arctic. This meltwater can percolate into firn and refreeze to form ice layers. Depending on their thickness, low-permeability ice layers can act as barriers that inhibit subsequent vertical meltwater infiltration in deeper firn pore space and favor lateral meltwater runoff. Thus, characterizing ice layers in firn is key for understanding the near-surface hydrological conditions that could promote surface meltwater runoff and its contribution to sea level rise.

    Airborne ice-penetrating radar (IPR) is a powerful tool for imaging subsurface structure, but only recently have these systems been applied to direct observations of the bulk properties of the near-surface. To evaluate the bulk permeability of the near-surface firn system of Devon Ice Cap (DIC), Canadian Arctic, we use the Radar Statistical Reconnaissance (RSR) technique, originally developed for accumulation studies in West Antarctica. This method utilizes both the coherent and incoherent components of the total surface return, which are predominately sensitive to near-surface permittivity/structure within the system’s vertical range resolution and surface roughness, respectively. Here, we apply RSR to IPR data collected over DIC with the High-Capability Airborne Radar Sounder 2 (HiCARS) system (60 MHz center-frequency, 15 MHz bandwidth), operated by the University of Texas Institute for Geophysics (UTIG). Guided by ground-based ice-penetrating radar data and firn core density measurements, we show that the near-surface heterogeneous firn structure, featuring ice layers, mainly affects the observed coherent component.

    We further compare the coherent component of HiCARS with that derived from IPR data collected with the University of Kansas Multichannel Coherent Radar Depth Sounder (MCoRDS) 3 system (195 MHz center-frequency; 30 MHz bandwidth), to evaluate the utility of dual-frequency IPR for characterizing near-surface ice layers. We expect that each radar system is sensitive to a different scale of near-surface bulk properties (i.e., depth and thickness of ice layers of different vertical extents), governed by each radar systems’ center frequency and bandwidth-limited range resolution. We leverage these differences in range resolution to derive ice layer thickness constraints in the DIC firn zone containing meter-thick ice layers, which are consistent with ground-based observations. Our results suggest this dual-frequency approach does indeed show that ice layers are vertically resolvable, spatially extensive, and mostly impermeable to surface meltwater. Thus, we hypothesize that lateral flow over high elevation meter-thick ice layers may contribute to the total surface runoff routed through supraglacial rivers down-glacier in the ablation zone.

    How to cite: Chan, K., Grima, C., Rutishauser, A., Young, D. A., Culberg, R., and Blankenship, D. D.: Ice layer detection, distribution, and thickness in the near-surface firn on Devon Ice Cap: a new dual-frequency radar characterization approach, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6414, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6414, 2022.

    Electrical resistivity tomography (ERT) is a geophysical method that produces an estimate of subsurface resistivity distribution, which can be used to infer the presence and extent of frozen ground. Repeated ERT surveys indicate how subsurface temperature and ground ice conditions are changing over time, which is particularly important for evaluating the changes and risks associated with climate change. However, there is no existing framework for sharing ERT data and datasets are rarely published, making it difficult to find and use historical data to assess subsurface changes. To facilitate data sharing, we are developing a Canadian database for ERT surveys of permafrost.

    A key component of this project is the development of an automated ERT data processing workflow to prepare datasets. Establishing best practices for data processing ensures that ERT results are optimized and standardized, which is essential so that changes in subsurface conditions can be reasonably interpreted. We also present our web-based data visualization tool that allows for targeted searching of surveys and plotting of selected results. By storing ERT data in a standardized and accessible way, our goal is to facilitate interpretations of permafrost change on a range of spatial and temporal scales and guide future research in permafrost science.

    How to cite: Herring, T. and Lewkowicz, A.: Creating a database of electrical resistivity tomography surveys of permafrost in Canada and establishing best practices for data processing and sharing, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6575, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6575, 2022.

    EGU22-7154 | Presentations | CR2.1

    In-situ measurements of sediment temperature under shallow water bodies in Arctic environments 

    Frederieke Miesner, William Cable, Julia Boike, and Pier Paul Overduin

    The thermal regime under lakes, ponds, and shallow near shore zones in permafrost zones in the Arctic is predominantly determined by the temperature of the overlying water body throughout the year.   Where the temperatures of the water are warmer than the air, unfrozen zones within the permafrost, called taliks, can form below the water bodies.

    However, the presence of bottom-fast ice can decrease the mean annual bed temperature in shallow water bodies and significantly slow down the thawing or even refreeze the lake or sea bed in winter. Small changes in water level have the potential to drastically alter the sub-bed thermal regime between permafrost-thawing and permafrost-forming. The temperature regime of lake sediments is a determining factor in the microbial activity that makes their taliks hot spots of methane gas emission. Measurements of the sediment temperature below shallow water bodies are scarce, and single temperature-chains in boreholes are not sufficient to map spatial variability.

    We present a new device to measure in-situ temperature-depth profiles in saturated soils or sediments, adapting the functionality of classic Bullard-type heat flow probes to the special requirements of the Arctic. The measurement setup consists of 30 equally spaced (5cm) digital temperature sensors housed in a 1.5 m stainless steel lance. The lance is portable and can be pushed into the sediment by hand either from a wading position, a small boat or through a hole in the ice during the winter. Measurements are taken continuously and 15 minutes in the sediment are sufficient to acquire in-situ temperatures within the accuracy of the sensors (0.01K after calibration at 0°C). The spacing of the sensors yield a detailed temperature-depth-profile of the near-surface sediments, where small-scale changes in the bottom water changes dominate the temperature field of the sediment. The short time needed for a single measurement allows for fine-meshed surveys of the sediment in areas of interest, such as the transition zone from bottom-fast to free water.

     

    Test campaigns in the Canadian Arctic and on Svalbard have proven  the device to be robust in a range of environments. We present data acquired during winter and summer, covering non-permafrost, thermokarst lake and offshore measurements.

    How to cite: Miesner, F., Cable, W., Boike, J., and Overduin, P. P.: In-situ measurements of sediment temperature under shallow water bodies in Arctic environments, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7154, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7154, 2022.

    EGU22-7409 | Presentations | CR2.1

    S-wave velocity profile of an Antarctic ice stream firn layer with ambient seismic recording using Distributed Acoustic Sensing 

    Wen Zhou, Antony Butcher, J. Michael Kendall, Sofia-Katerina Kufner, and Alex Brisbourne

    Measurements of the seismic properties of Antarctic ice streams are critical for constraining glacier dynamics and future sea-level rise contributions. In 2020, passive seismic data were acquired at the Rutford Ice Stream, West Antarctica, with the aim of imaging the near-surface firn layer. A DAS (distributed acoustic sensing) interrogator and 1 km of optic fibre were supplemented by 3-component geophones. Taking advantage of transient seismic energy from a petrol generator and seismicity near the ice stream shear margin (10s of km away from the DAS array), which dominated the ambient seismic noise field,  we retrieve Rayleigh wave signals from 3 to 50 Hz. The extracted dispersion curve for a linear fibre array shows excellent agreement with an active seismic surface wave survey (Multichannel Analysis of Surface Waves) but with lower frequency content. We invert the dispersion curves for a 1D S-wave velocity profile through the firn layer, which shows good agreement with the previously acquired seismic refraction survey. Using a triangular-array geometry we repeat the procedure and find no evidence of seismic anisotropy at our study site. Our study presents challenges and solutions for processing noisy but densely sampled DAS data, for noise interferometry and imaging. 

    How to cite: Zhou, W., Butcher, A., Kendall, J. M., Kufner, S.-K., and Brisbourne, A.: S-wave velocity profile of an Antarctic ice stream firn layer with ambient seismic recording using Distributed Acoustic Sensing, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7409, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7409, 2022.

    EGU22-7447 | Presentations | CR2.1

    Investigation of the induced polarization effect in transient electromagnetic soundings to characterize rock glaciers 

    Lukas Aigner, Nathalie Roser, Clemens Moser, Theresa Maierhofer, Umberto Morra Di Cella, Christian Hauck, and Adrián Flores Orozco

    Geophysical characterization of rock glaciers commonly relies on electrical resistivity tomography (ERT) and seismic refraction tomography (SRT). Yet, large blocks make the installation of geophones and electrodes time consuming, while bad contacts lead to reduced signal-to-noise ratios in both methods. Additionally, ERT and SRT campaigns require rather heavy equipment and need long profiles to reach large depths of investigation. Transient electromagnetic (TEM) measurements offer diverse advantages, as they do not require a galvanic contact with the ground, and can be conducted with light instruments for simplified field procedures. We propose the application of TEM measurements with a single-loop configuration for the collection of extensive data sets in alpine environments. We hypothesize that TEM measurements provide the same information as SRT and ERT, yet field procedures of the TEM method are much more efficient permitting to cover larger areas in reduced time. In particular, we present investigations conducted on the Gran Sometta rock glacier (above Cervinia, Aosta Valley, Italian Alps). The study area consists of a large active rock glacier complex composed of two main lobes with varying ice content. Our surveys aimed at: (i) estimating the depth to the bedrock below the rock glacier, (ii) identifying the degree of weathering in the underlying bedrock, and (iii) evaluating spatial variations of ice content of the rock glacier. We collected TEM data with a TEM-FAST 48 system using 4 A current and a 50 m by 50 m single loop configuration. The experimental setup fits in a single backpack and our 3-person team covered an area of approximately 75’000 m² in 2.5 days, despite the difficult terrain. We measured 28 soundings distributed over the entire site and repeated two sounding locations with a larger 75 m square loop. Complementary spectral induced polarization (SIP) data were measured using 64 electrodes with a separation of 2.5 m between electrodes along two perpendicular profiles to validate our TEM results. We used separated transmitter and receiver instruments as well as cables to reduce EM coupling effects in our SIP data. TEM data reveal sign reversals, which are caused by the induced polarization effect due to the ice content in the rock glacier. We model the TEM response with the open-source algorithm empymod assuming a layered media. We observe that including a layer with a frequency-dependent polarization results in the signal reversals, while the geometry of such a layer also influences the TEM response. Furthermore, we observe that resistivity variations in the layer below the polarizable one can also be detected by the TEM data. Hence, our results demonstrate the applicability of TEM measurements to determine the geometry of the ice-rich layer in an active rock glacier, possible variations in ice content at the study area as well as the electrical properties of the underlying bedrock.

    How to cite: Aigner, L., Roser, N., Moser, C., Maierhofer, T., Morra Di Cella, U., Hauck, C., and Flores Orozco, A.: Investigation of the induced polarization effect in transient electromagnetic soundings to characterize rock glaciers, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7447, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7447, 2022.

    EGU22-7552 | Presentations | CR2.1

    Assessment of ESA CryoSat-2 radar altimetry data using GNSSdata at three sites on the Greenland Ice Sheet 

    Karina Hansen, Kristine M. Larson, Michael J. Willis, William Colgan, Veit Helm, and Shfaqat Abbas Khan

    Ten-year records of ice surface elevation changes derived from three GNSS stations placed on the interior of the Greenland ice sheet are used to assess the ability of CryoSat-2 radar altimetry to capture surface elevation changes during 2010-2021. We use GNSS interferometric reflectometry (GNSS-IR) to derive time series of continuous daily surface elevations. The footprint of GNSS-IR is about 1000 m2 and the accuracy is ±2cm, making it an excellent tool to validate ice surface height from satellite altimetry. We compare GNSS-IR derived ice surface elevations with CryoSat-2 derived surface elevations and find Cryosat-2 performs best at the GNSS site furthest north (GLS3) with a maximum difference of 12cm. The other GNSS sites have a higher residual range because of poorer data availability and local surface variations. The number of Cryosat-2 data points are roughly doubled from GLS1 and GLS2 to GLS3. GLS3 Is located in a very flat area of the ice sheet only moving 55m during 2011-2020. In contrast GLS1 moved 292m in the same period, clearly indicating a steeper slope to the ice sheet at this location, which we have difficulty correcting for because digital elevation models are associated with high uncertainty on the interior of the ice sheet. The strength of this assessment method lies in the continuous daily time series of surface elevation change derived from GNSS, as they clearly capture extreme short-term changes, which otherwise might have been perceived as errors in the radar altimetry measurements.

    How to cite: Hansen, K., Larson, K. M., Willis, M. J., Colgan, W., Helm, V., and Khan, S. A.: Assessment of ESA CryoSat-2 radar altimetry data using GNSSdata at three sites on the Greenland Ice Sheet, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7552, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7552, 2022.

    EGU22-7725 | Presentations | CR2.1

    Illuminating the deeper radio-stratigraphy of an alpine glacier using SAR processing 

    Falk Oraschewski, Inka Koch, Mohammadreza Ershadi, Jonathan Hawkins, and Reinhard Drews

    The internal stratigraphy of alpine glaciers entails information about its past dynamics and accumulation rates. It further can be used for intercalibrating the age-depth scales of ice cores. The internal ice stratigraphy is often imaged using radar, but similar to polar ice sheets the deeper stratigraphy is often difficult to resolve with classical pulsed radar systems. For polar ice sheets, the introduction of phase coherent radars has illuminated this former echo-free zone (EFZ) and now patterns of folded, buckled and disrupted ice stratigraphy are clearly visible. Unfortunately, the new airborne and ground-based radar systems applied in polar regions are typically too heavy to be deployed in an alpine environment.

    Here, we transfer the lightweight autonomous phase-sensitive radio-echo sounder (ApRES) to an alpine glacier targeting its echo-free zone (Colle Gnifetti, Italy/Switzerland). The ApRES is a coherent frequency modulated continuous wave radar with an integration time of 1 s per trace which we deployed in combination with a GNSS used in real time kinematic (RTK) mode. The latter allows repositioning of the antennas with sub-wavelength accuracy (approximately 5 cm) required to exploit the coherent signal. Like this, the radio-stratigraphy of the former EFZ at this site could be imaged using a matched filtering SAR method. The resulting radargrams cover former ice core sites (e.g., Ice Memory and KCC) and can be used to harmonize conflicting age-depth scales. This dataset will be analysed further in conjunction with ice-fabric measurements from ice cores to reveal how the anisotropic ice rheology imprints on the flow field of glaciers.

    How to cite: Oraschewski, F., Koch, I., Ershadi, M., Hawkins, J., and Drews, R.: Illuminating the deeper radio-stratigraphy of an alpine glacier using SAR processing, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7725, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7725, 2022.

    EGU22-8245 | Presentations | CR2.1

    A passive seismic approach including fiber-optic sensing for permafrost monitoring on Mt. Zugspitze (Germany) 

    Fabian Lindner, Krystyna Smolinski, Jonas Igel, Daniel Bowden, Andreas Fichtner, and Joachim Wassermann

    As observed elsewhere on a global scale, permafrost at Mt. Zugspitze (German/Austrian Alps) is warming in response to climate change. To monitor permafrost warming and thawing, which affect the rock slope stability and thus the hazard potential, borehole temperature logging and electrical resistivity tomography (ERT) have been employed at Mt. Zugspitze for more than a decade. Furthermore, a recent study shows that the ambient seismic noise recordings of a single seismometer at the same site can be utilized to track permafrost changes over the past 15 years. This passive seismic approach is non-invasive, labour- and cost-effective and provides high temporal resolution. Together with recent advances in instrumentation allowing the measurement of seismic vibrations on a meter scale along a fiber-optic cable (known as distributed acoustic sensing), passive seismology provides unprecedented spatio-temporal resolution for monitoring applications.

     

    Starting in July 2021, we extended the single-station deployment on Mt. Zugspitze with three small seismic arrays (six stations each, aperture ~25 m) along the permafrost-affected ridge. The stations are partly installed in a tunnel beneath the surface, which intersects a permafrost body, thus allowing in-situ observations of the frozen rock. We equipped the tunnel facilities with a fiber-optic cable, which we will interrogate on a regular basis, about once per quarter year, to resolve seasonal permafrost dynamics. A first 10-day data set of this monitoring element with seismic channel spacing of 2 m along a cable exceeding 1 km in length is already available and shows that artificial avalanche triggering explosions were successfully recorded. We present data and first results dedicated to permafrost monitoring along the fiber-optic cable and between pairs of seismic stations through cross-correlation of ambient seismic noise. In addition, the seismic arrays are designed to derive rotational ground motions, which we expect to be more sensitive to local subsurface/permafrost changes compared to the classical translational motion measurements. The experiment aims to explore the permafrost monitoring capabilities of passive seismology compared to more classical and established methods as ERT.

    How to cite: Lindner, F., Smolinski, K., Igel, J., Bowden, D., Fichtner, A., and Wassermann, J.: A passive seismic approach including fiber-optic sensing for permafrost monitoring on Mt. Zugspitze (Germany), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8245, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8245, 2022.

    EGU22-8555 | Presentations | CR2.1

    Using different seismic approaches to detect submarine permafrost and gas hydrates on the continental Beaufort shelf of the Canadian Arctic 

    Henrik Grob, Michael Riedel, Mathieu J. Duchesne, Sebastian Krastel, Jefferson Bustamante Restrepo, Gabriel Fabien-Ouellet, Dirk Kläschen, Jonas Preine, Young Keun Jin, and Jong Kuk Hong

    In the Canadian Arctic, permafrost and permafrost-associated gas hydrates formed extensively during the last 1 Ma. After the last glaciation, a marine transgression followed and former terrestrially exposed shelf areas became submerged. Subaerial mean annual temperatures of -20°C or even less changed to present submarine bottom water temperatures near -1°C. The relict submarine permafrost and gas hydrates present in the Beaufort Sea still react to this ongoing thermal change which results in their continued degradation. Thawing permafrost and destabilisation of permafrost-associated gas hydrates may release previously trapped greenhouse gases and can lead to even further gas hydrate dissociation. Moreover, thawing permafrost poses a geohazard in form of landslides and ground collapses. Yet, both the extent of the submarine permafrost and the permafrost-associated gas hydrates are still not well known. Here, we present three different approaches using marine 2D multichannel seismic data to improve the current knowledge of the distribution of offshore permafrost and gas hydrates occurrences in the southern Canadian Beaufort Sea. The acoustic properties of permafrost are determined by the content of ice and unfrozen pore fluids. Changing permafrost conditions affect the elasticity of the medium making seismic methods appropriate for permafrost detection. First, we identify direct and indirect seismic reflection indicators from permafrost and gas hydrates by the presence of cross-cutting, polarity-reversed, and upward-bend reflections as well as velocity pull-ups and shallow pronounced high-amplitude reflections. Second, using diving-wave tomography provides insights into the near-surface permafrost structure by imaging the velocity structure in greater detail than achievable by standard velocity analyses.  And third, diffractions separated from the reflected wavefield yield insights into the sub-wavelength architecture of the permafrost realm on the southern Canadian Beaufort Shelf that may add information about weak phase-boundaries and small-scale heterogeneities. All methods are applied to seismic lines crossing the outer continental margin, where a maximum thermal effect of the transgression is expected, and thus a maximum lateral variation in permafrost and permafrost-associated gas hydrate phase boundaries is expected to be present. 

    How to cite: Grob, H., Riedel, M., Duchesne, M. J., Krastel, S., Bustamante Restrepo, J., Fabien-Ouellet, G., Kläschen, D., Preine, J., Jin, Y. K., and Hong, J. K.: Using different seismic approaches to detect submarine permafrost and gas hydrates on the continental Beaufort shelf of the Canadian Arctic, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8555, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8555, 2022.

    EGU22-8588 | Presentations | CR2.1

    3D Spectral Induced Polarization survey to evaluate a thawing permafrost endangered hut in the Italian Alps 

    Clemens Moser, Theresa Maierhofer, Elisabetta Drigo, Umberto Morra Di Cella, Christian Hauck, and Adrian Flores Orozco

    Due to generally rising air temperatures in the European Alps in context of climate change, large areas of mountain permafrost are thawing, and subsurface pore ice is melting. Consequently, the cohesion of rock masses decreases which can constitute a threat for infrastructure like mountain huts in alpine areas. One directly affected building is the Guide Val d'Ayas al Lambronecca, a hut on a rock ledge in the Italian Alps at 3400 m above sea level. During the last decade the ground directly underneath the hut sank of about 2 m, probably due to the melting of pore ice in the subsurface below the hut. In this study, we investigate the subsurface properties beneath the hut using a 3D geophysical survey. In particular, we deploy the spectral induced polarization (SIP) method, which has emerged as a promising tool to discriminate between ice-rich and ice-poor regions in the subsurface. Our investigation is built on the hypothesis that ice can be identified in electrical images due to its high electrical resistivity and polarization (i.e., capacitive) properties at frequencies above 10 Hz. In our survey, we conducted 2D SIP measurements in summer 2020 (between 0.5 and 225 Hz) along three profiles near the hut, while real 3D SIP measurements (in the range between 1 and 240 Hz) were conducted in summer 2021. For the 3D measurements, we deployed two parallel lines, one on the southern and one on the northern rock wall of the summit where the hut is located. To improve the data quality, we used coaxial cables for the 2D measurements in 2020, while data collected in 2021 were based on the actual separation of the transmitter and receiver (i.e., instrument and cables) to reduce the contamination of the data due to parasitic electromagnetic fields. Processing of the data was based on the statistical analysis of normal and reciprocal misfits. Inversion of the data was performed in 3D using ResIPy which uses complex calculus to simultaneously resolve for the conductive and capacitive properties. Our imaging results evidence a core of ice-filled pores corresponding to high resistivity values (>10 kΩm) directly underneath the hut, this structure is overlain by lower values (<1 kΩm) in near-surface areas representing the active layer. Images of the polarization effect confirm an anomaly due to high values at frequencies above 10 Hz in the center of the rock ledge. Our study demonstrates that 3D SIP measurements can be used to differentiate between ice-rich and ice-poor areas in high mountain permafrost sites with complex topography. Moreover, 3D SIP approaches enable a detection of electrical anomalies in all three dimensions and not only along one certain direction in the case of 2D profiles. This information can be used to assess the impact of permafrost degradation on infrastructure stability in mountain regions and to support restoration actions.

    How to cite: Moser, C., Maierhofer, T., Drigo, E., Morra Di Cella, U., Hauck, C., and Flores Orozco, A.: 3D Spectral Induced Polarization survey to evaluate a thawing permafrost endangered hut in the Italian Alps, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8588, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8588, 2022.

    EGU22-10159 | Presentations | CR2.1

    Year-round high-resolution geoelectrical monitoring to improve the understanding of deglaciated soil evolution in the High Arctic 

    Mihai O. Cimpoiasu, Harry Harrison, Philip Meldrum, Paul Wilkinson, Jonathan Chambers, James Bradley, Pacifica Sommers, Steven K. Schmidt, Trevor Irons, Dane Liljestrand, Carlos Oroza, and Oliver Kuras

    High Arctic regions are experiencing an accelerated rise in temperatures, about three times more than the global average. As a result, the glacier coverage over these landscapes is reducing, uncovering soils which start their development by sustaining emergent microbial communities. These new systems will have a significant impact on the global carbon budget, thus monitoring and understanding their evolution becomes a necessity.

    Geoelectrical methods have emerged as a fast, cost-effective and minimally invasive way of imaging soil moisture dynamics in the shallow subsurface. BGS PRIME technology is designed to facilitate low-power remote geoelectrical tomography by using an array of sensor electrodes. We are using such technology to monitor the year-round variability of soil electrical resistivity in 4D on a glacier forefield in the vicinity of Ny-Alesund, Svalbard. Until now, such assessment of soil properties was confined to the summer period due to harsh Arctic winter conditions making site access very difficult.

    Two PRIME systems were deployed during the summer of 2021 on Midtre Lovénbreen glacier forefield, which exhibits a soil chronosequence extending from the youngest soils near the glacier snout up to soils of approximately 120 years old. The two geophysical systems are monitoring electrical resistivity within the top 2m of soil of approximately 5 and 60 years of age respectively, recording soil moisture and freeze-thaw dynamics within the active layer above the permafrost.

    We present early results, a timeseries of 3D soil electrical resistivity models, that captured several precipitation events during the summer and the progression of the freezing front when soil temperatures dropped below 0 °C in October 2021. These results reveal differences in the hydrodynamic activity between the 5- and 60-year-old sites determined by soil properties and their location on the glacier forefield. In addition, soil cores were sampled from the vicinity of the PRIME systems. These were subsequently subjected to laboratory tests to describe the changes in electrical resistivity as a function of moisture content and during successive freeze-thaw cycles. Furthermore, we are working towards an integrated analysis and a more comprehensive model of soil evolution at our sites by combining geoelectrical measurements with point measurements of environmental parameters and microbiological activity.

    How to cite: Cimpoiasu, M. O., Harrison, H., Meldrum, P., Wilkinson, P., Chambers, J., Bradley, J., Sommers, P., Schmidt, S. K., Irons, T., Liljestrand, D., Oroza, C., and Kuras, O.: Year-round high-resolution geoelectrical monitoring to improve the understanding of deglaciated soil evolution in the High Arctic, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10159, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10159, 2022.

    EGU22-10195 | Presentations | CR2.1

    Investigation of ice with geophysical measurements during the transit of cryobots 

    Marc S. Boxberg, Anna Simson, Qian Chen, and Julia Kowalski

    Several icy moons of our Solar System like Jupiter’s moon Europa have a global ocean of liquid water below their icy crust. These ocean worlds are possible targets for space missions that aim to assess their potential for habitability or even to search for life. Cryobots (or ice melting probes) are suitable tools to reach the subglacial oceans for in-situ investigations. The necessary ice shell transit provides an excellent opportunity to investigate structure and composition of the ice itself by means of geophysical and other in-situ measurements. This will allow us to better understand the evolution of icy moons and their role in our solar system.

    We present current ideas as well as first results from terrestrial analogue studies. Acoustic data obtained during a field test on Langenferner Glacier, Italy was used to conduct a travel time tomography, which yields insight into heterogeneities in the local acoustic wave propagation speed through the ice. The acoustic sensor set-up was originally designed for localization of the melting probe rather than an investigation of the ice structure. However, we can still show that such opportunity data can be used to obtain a wave velocity distribution which can be further interpreted with respect to ice properties like porosity.

    While we already investigated the acoustic data, we evaluate the potential of other measurements. For example, Radar measurements in combination with the acoustics can be used to identify the ice-water boundary and, in addition, cracks and inclusions in the ice. Conductivity measurements provide information on the salinity. At ice-water interface regions, the salinity is in thermochemical equilibrium with the temperature and porosity of the ice. We present our concept for on-board electrical conductivity measurements and analyze its potential, for example, to constrain ice properties and to predict ice-water interfaces based on existing terrestrial field data and process models. Furthermore, some of the cryobot’s housekeeping data might be of interest for investigating the ambiance, too. For example, the temperature and the density of the ice affect the melting velocity of the cryobot, which constitutes an inverse problem to get further information on the ice.

    How to cite: Boxberg, M. S., Simson, A., Chen, Q., and Kowalski, J.: Investigation of ice with geophysical measurements during the transit of cryobots, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10195, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10195, 2022.

    EGU22-10565 | Presentations | CR2.1

    Initiation of an international database of geoelectrical surveys on permafrost to promote data sharing, survey repetition and standardized data reprocessing 

    Coline Mollaret, Christin Hilbich, Teddi Herring, Mohammad Farzamian, Johannes Buckel, Baptiste Dafflon, Daniel Draebing, Hannelore Fossaert, Rebecca Gugerli, Christian Hauck, Julius Kunz, Antoni Lewkowicz, Jonas K. Limbrock, Theresa Maierhofer, Florence Magnin, Cécile Pellet, Sebastian Pfaehler, Riccardo Scandroglio, and Sebastian Uhlemann and the IDGSP IPA Action Group

    Geoelectrical methods are widely used for permafrost investigations by research groups, government agencies and industry. Electrical Resistivity Tomography (ERT) surveys are typically performed only once to detect the presence or absence of permafrost. Exchange of data and expertise among users is limited and usually occurs bilaterally. Neither complete information about the existence of geophysical surveys on permafrost nor the data itself is available on a global scale. Given the potential gain for identifying permafrost evidence and their spatio-temporal changes, there is a strong need for coordinated efforts regarding data, metadata, guidelines, and expertise exchange. Repetition of ERT surveys is rare, even though it could provide a quantitative spatio-temporal measure of permafrost evolution, helping to quantify the effects of climate change at local (where the ERT survey takes place) and global scales (due to the inventory).

    Our International Permafrost Association (IPA) action group (2021-2023) has the main objective of bringing together the international community interested in geoelectrical measurements on permafrost and laying the foundations for an operational International Database of Geoelectrical Surveys on Permafrost (IDGSP). Our contribution presents a new international database of electrical resistivity datasets on permafrost. The core members of our action group represent more than 10 research groups, who have already contributed their own metadata (currently > 200 profiles covering 15 countries). These metadata will be fully publicly accessible in the near future whereas access to the resistivity data may be either public or restricted. Thanks to this open-access policy, we aim at increasing the level of transparency, encouraging further data providers and fostering survey repetitions by new users.

    The database is set up on a virtual machine hosted by the University of Fribourg. The advanced open-source relational database system PostgreSQL is used to program the database. Homogenization and standardization of a large number of data and metadata are among the greatest challenges, yet are essential to a structured relational database. In this contribution, we present the structure of the database, statistics of the metadata uploaded, as well as first results of repetitions from legacy geoelectrical measurements on permafrost. Guidelines and strategies are developed to handle repetition challenges such as changing survey configuration, changing geometry or inaccurate/missing metadata. First steps toward transparent and reproducible automated filtering and inversion of a great number of datasets will also be presented. By archiving geoelectrical data on permafrost, the ambition of this project is the reanalysis of the full database and its climatic interpretation.

    How to cite: Mollaret, C., Hilbich, C., Herring, T., Farzamian, M., Buckel, J., Dafflon, B., Draebing, D., Fossaert, H., Gugerli, R., Hauck, C., Kunz, J., Lewkowicz, A., Limbrock, J. K., Maierhofer, T., Magnin, F., Pellet, C., Pfaehler, S., Scandroglio, R., and Uhlemann, S. and the IDGSP IPA Action Group: Initiation of an international database of geoelectrical surveys on permafrost to promote data sharing, survey repetition and standardized data reprocessing, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10565, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10565, 2022.

    EGU22-10835 | Presentations | CR2.1

    Combined measurement of snow depth and sea ice thickness by helicopter EM bird in McMurdo Sound, Antarctica 

    Wolfgang Rack, Adrian Tan, Christian Haas, Usama Farooq, Aston Taylor, Adriel Kind, Kelvin Barnsdale, and Greg Leonard

    Snow on sea ice is a controlling factor for ocean-atmosphere heat flux and thus ice thickness growth, and surface albedo. Active and passive microwave remote sensing is the most promising way to estimate snow depths over large sea ice areas although improved validation is understood as a missing information to support further progress. However, severe limitations in the representative measurement of snow depth over sea ice persist, which exacerbates sea ice mass balance assessments as well as the indirect estimation of consolidated ice thickness from remotely sensed freeboard.

    We have designed and flown a snow radar in combination with an electromagnetic induction device for sea ice thickness. The goal was the simultaneous measurement of both the consolidated sea ice thickness and the snow depth on top as a tool to derive snow and ice statistics for satellite validation. The snow radar was integrated into an EM-bird and flown about 15 m above the surface by suspending the instrument from a helicopter. The combination of the applied technologies hasn’t been deployed in this configuration before. The helicopter flight speed was around 70 knots, resulting in a snow measurement about every four meters. The EM instrument can detect ice thickness at 0.1m accuracy, whereas the snow radar is designed to measure snow depth at 0.05m accuracy.

    Our field area was the land-fast sea ice and adjacent ice shelf in McMurdo Sound (Antarctica) in November 2021. During this time we found a relatively shallow but variable snow cover (up to about 0.3m) above sea ice of about 2m thickness. Deeper snow was only measured at the transition from the sea ice to the ice shelf, and on the ice shelf itself, where the maximum radar penetration in snow in ideal conditions is estimated to be around 2-3 meters.

    We present first results of snow cover statistics in comparison to ground validation and observed snow characteristics, and we compare these results to airphotos and optical satellite imagery. We show that the measurement set-up meets the requirements for level ice and rough fast ice with patchy but dry snow cover. The system still needs to be tested over pack ice with potentially more complex snow morphology.

    How to cite: Rack, W., Tan, A., Haas, C., Farooq, U., Taylor, A., Kind, A., Barnsdale, K., and Leonard, G.: Combined measurement of snow depth and sea ice thickness by helicopter EM bird in McMurdo Sound, Antarctica, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10835, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10835, 2022.

    Ground surface movements and snow cover during freeze/thaw cycles of permafrost are important variables for studying climate change. GPS-IR has emerged as an effective technique to estimate the relative elevation changes of ground surface such as the thaw subsidence of frozen ground and snow depth variations. In permafrost areas, the freezing process of the ground is always accompanied by the snow accumulations, making it hard for GPS-IR to separate these two distinct signals from the estimated elevation changes. In this study, using the Signal to Noise Ratio (SNR) collected by a permafrost GPS site SG27 (Northern Alaska) in 2018, we proposed a physical model-based method to simultaneously estimate the daily snow depths and freezing-ground uplifts with GPS-IR. First, we applied GPS-IR to the SNR data to obtain the daily elevation changes of the ground surface from September 1 in 2018 to August 31 in 2019. The elevation change measurements indicate the onset of snow season on October 18 in 2018 and the end of snow-cover on June 15 in 2019. Second, we used the thermal index Accumulated Degree Days of Freezing (ADDF) calculated from the temperature records to determine the onset of the permafrost freezing season as of September 17 in 2018. Third, we fitted the Stefan function to the estimated elevation changes (i.e. freezing-ground uplifts) from September 17 to October 18 in 2018. The Stefan model agrees with the freezing uplifts with an R2 of 0.65. Forth, we extended the fitted model to the time when the ground was completely frozen (November 1) to estimate daily freezing-ground uplifts up to 1.75 cm under the snowpack. Last, we extracted the snow depths from the estimated elevation changes by subtracting the corresponding freezing-ground uplifts. Our study is the first attempt to simultaneously estimate the daily freezing-ground uplifts and snow depths over the permafrost area with GPS-IR, providing the measurements to understand the coupling effects of the permafrost and snow cover.

    How to cite: Hu, Y. and Wang, J.: Simultaneous estimation of snow depth and freezing-ground uplift by GPS Interferometric Reflectometry over a permafrost area, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10858, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10858, 2022.

    EGU22-12006 | Presentations | CR2.1

    Characterising ice sheet properties using Rayleigh wave ellipticity 

    Glenn Jones, Ana Ferreira, Bernd Kulessa, Martin Schimmel, Andrea Berbellini, and Andrea Morelli

    The physical properties of the ice column are fundamental to the deformation and flow of glaciers and ice sheets. With a warming climate, surface meltwater is ever increasingly being routed and distributed throughout the ice column changing the mechanical and hence thermal properties of the ice and leading to accelerated ice flow and ice mass loss. Since the early 1990s, ice mass loss from the Greenland Ice Sheet (GrIS) has contributed ~10% of the mean global sea level rise. Seismic waves have routinely been used to study the physical characteristics of glaciers and ice sheets due to their sensitivity to both mechanical and thermal properties of ice. Traditionally, reflection seismic surveys have been chosen as the primary seismic approach but this survey method can suffer from difficult logistics in polar regions. Recent advancements in ambient noise methods and the permanent installation of a seismic network in Greenland now permit the long term study of the ice properties of the GrIS.

    Rayleigh wave ellipticity measurements (the horizontal-to-vertical ratio of Rayleigh wave particle motions) are particularly sensitive to the subsurface structure beneath a seismic station. Using the polarisation properties of seismic noise, we extract Rayleigh wave ellipticity measurements from the Earth’s ambient noise for on-ice stations deployed in Greenland from 2012-- 2018. For wave periods sensitive to the ice sheet (T ≤ 3.5 s), we observe significant deviation between ellipticity measurements extracted from noise and synthetic fundamental mode calculations using a single ice column. Using a forward modelling approach we show: (1) a slow seismic shear-wave velocity at the near surface, (2) seismic attenuation, quantified as the quality factor Q, is sensitive to the temperature, water content and density of the ice and (3) the excitation of Rayleigh wave overtones plays a leading role in perturbing the ellipticity. Our results highlight how the inclusion of Q and overtone information can fill important gaps in our knowledge of ice sheet temperature, density and water content, which are important for predictions of the future evolution of the GrIS.

    How to cite: Jones, G., Ferreira, A., Kulessa, B., Schimmel, M., Berbellini, A., and Morelli, A.: Characterising ice sheet properties using Rayleigh wave ellipticity, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12006, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12006, 2022.

    EGU22-12082 | Presentations | CR2.1

    Snow measurement campaign for snowpack model and satellite retrieval validation in Italian Central Apennines within SMIVIA project 

    Edoardo Raparelli, Paolo Tuccella, Annalina Lombardi, Gianluca Palermo, Nancy Alvan Romero, Mario Papa, Errico Picciotti, Saverio Di Fabio, Elena Pettinelli, Elisabetta Mattei, Sebastian Lauro, Barbara Cosciotti, Chiara Petroselli, David Cappelletti, Massimo Pecci, and Frank SIlvio Marzano

    The Apennine mountain range is the backbone of the Italian peninsula, crossing it from North-West to South-East for approximately 1200 km. The main peaks are found in Central Apennines, especially in the Gran Sasso d’Italia massif, which hosts the highest Apennines peak, named Corno Grande, with its 2912 m a.s.l. During the winter season, Central Apennines are typically covered with snow, with thickness that can vary between a few centimeters to several meters. Despite the historical presence of snow in these territories, the Apennine snowpack is poorly studied and weather data coming from automatic measurement stations and manual snow measurements hardly coexist. Thus, within the SMIVIA (Snow-mantle Modeling, Inversion and Validation using multi-frequency multi-mission InSAR in Central Apennines) project, we identified the measurement sites of Pietrattina, at 1459 m a.s.l, and Campo Felice, at 1545 m a.s.l., both located in Central Apennines. There we collected automatic measurements using ad hoc installed automatic weather-snow stations (AWSS) and where we performed systematic manual measurements of the snowpack properties, from November 2020 till April 2021. The AWSS measures every 5 minutes air temperature, relative humidity, wind speed, wind direction, incoming short-wave radiation, reflected short-wave radiation, soil surface temperature, snow surface temperature and snow height. The manual part of the campaign included the digging of 10 and 8 snow pits at Pietrattina and Campo Felice sites, respectively, to measure vertical profiles of snow density, temperature, grain shape, grain size and fractional content of light absorbing impurities. Manual snow measurements provide important information on the state of the snowpack, and give the opportunity to reconstruct the history of the snowpack. Their proximity to automatic weather stations let us evaluate the impact of the very local atmospheric conditions on the snowpack evolution. These measurements were performed within the SMIVIA project to: i) evaluate the ability of the snow cover model SNOWPACK to reproduce the observed snow cover properties; ii) verify the possibility to infer snow height and snow water equivalent from the data retrieved with Earth observation satellites; iii) investigate whether the use of a combination of snow numerical models and remote sensing data may provide better results compared to using each of the aforementioned approach, separately. Nevertheless, the data collected during the SMIVIA campaign at the measurement sites of Pietrattina and Campo Felice during season 2020-2021 can also provide precious information for other fields of study, like hydrology, biology and chemistry.

    How to cite: Raparelli, E., Tuccella, P., Lombardi, A., Palermo, G., Alvan Romero, N., Papa, M., Picciotti, E., Di Fabio, S., Pettinelli, E., Mattei, E., Lauro, S., Cosciotti, B., Petroselli, C., Cappelletti, D., Pecci, M., and Marzano, F. S.: Snow measurement campaign for snowpack model and satellite retrieval validation in Italian Central Apennines within SMIVIA project, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12082, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12082, 2022.

    EGU22-12233 | Presentations | CR2.1 | Highlight

    Monitoring lake ice with seismic and acoustic sensors 

    Cedric Schmelzbach, Daniel May, Christoph Wetter, Simon Stähler, and John Clinton

    Seismic monitoring of the thickness and elastic parameters of floating ice on lakes and the sea is of interest in understanding the climate change impact on Alpine and Arctic environments, assessing ice safety for recreational and engineering purposes, studying ice shelves as well as exploring possibilities for the future exploration of the icy crusts of ocean worlds in our solar system. Seismic data can provide an alternative to remote-sensing and ground-based radar measurements for estimation of ice thickness in cases where radar techniques fail. Because of the difficult access to Alpine and Arctic environments as well as seismic sensor coupling issues in ice environments, it is of interest to optimize the use of seismic instruments in terms of sensor type, sensor numbers and layouts.

    With the motivation to monitor over time the seismic activity of the lake ice and the ice properties, we conducted a series of seismic experiments on frozen lake St. Moritz in the Swiss Alps during two consecutive winters. Arrangements of sensors ranging in numbers from 96 geophones in mini-arrays to installations of 8, 2 and 1 conventional seismic sensors were used to measure the seismic wavefield generated by ice quakes (cryoseisms), artificial sources like hammer strokes, and ambient vibrations. These data provide an impressive and rich insights into the growth of the ice and variations of seismic activity with time. Even recordings with only a single station enable the determination of ice parameters and location of ice seismicity. Furthermore, we are exploring the value of recording air-coupled waves with microphones as alternative contact-free measurements related to seismic wave propagation in the ice, possibly even with sensors placed on the lake shore.

    How to cite: Schmelzbach, C., May, D., Wetter, C., Stähler, S., and Clinton, J.: Monitoring lake ice with seismic and acoustic sensors, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12233, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12233, 2022.

    EGU22-12490 | Presentations | CR2.1

    Exploring the potential of cosmic muon scattering to measure the snow water equivalent 

    Aitor Orio, Esteban Alonso, Pablo Martínez, Carlos Díez, and Pablo Gómez

    The seasonal snowpack influences the hydrology, ecology and economy of the areas where it is present. However, the real time monitoring of the seasonal snowpack is a still well known scientific challenge. In this study, we have explored the potential of muon scattering radiography (MSR) to infer the snow water equivalent (SWE) of the snowpack. We have used the energy and mass balance model Snowpack to realistically simulate the time evolution and microstructure of the snowpack. The ERA5-Land reanalysis was used as forcing of Snowpack, in a location close to the Monte Perdido massif (Central, Pyrenees) at an elevation of 2041m above sea level. The simulations cover the hydrologic year 2015/2016, approximately reaching up to 700mm of peak SWE. Then, we have coupled the Snowpack numerical simulations with the Geant4 model to simulate the propagation of the muons through the snow layers and to collect the deviation of the muon trajectories. We have measured these deviations with a virtual muon detector based in multiwire proportional chambers, replicating a real detection system designed by us. The obtained distributions of muon deviations have exhibited a strong correlation with the simulated SWE, showing a coefficient of determination of 0.99. This model presents a root-mean-square error (RMSE) of 23.9mm in the SWE estimation. In order to validate the simulation analysis results, we have replicated the numerical experiments under controlled conditions, measuring three artificial snow samples ranging from 0 to 200 mm of SWE in our laboratory. We have measured the samples with an experimental setup composed of the real muon detector whose hardware was virtually replicated for the numerical experiments. Then, we have applied the model derived from the numerical simulations to the muon deviations measured in our laboratory. We have calibrated the real measurements and we have obtained a RMSE of 38.4mm in the SWE estimation. These results show that MSR is a promising non-destructive technique that can be used for the deployment of accurate SWE monitoring networks and can eventually provide information from the internal layered structure of the snowpack.

    How to cite: Orio, A., Alonso, E., Martínez, P., Díez, C., and Gómez, P.: Exploring the potential of cosmic muon scattering to measure the snow water equivalent, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12490, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12490, 2022.

    EGU22-1350 | Presentations | SSS6.3 | Highlight

    New approach to water content measurements in soil core using microwave probing 

    Pierre Sabouroux, Floriane Sparma, and Agnieszka Szypłowska

    Abstract – A new approach for water content determination in an in situ soil at depths ranging from the soil surface down to a few meters in soil profile is under development. The concept of this method is based on a core drill that will be equipped with a multi-probe sensor working at  radio and  microwave frequencies. The objective of the presented research focuses on the study of the multi-probe sensor that was carried out on sandy soils and clay.

    This solution is based on reflection and transmission measurements using several probes arranged on the circumference of a metal tube. The use of various probes allows us on one hand to detect thresholds of the water in soil and on the other hand to diagnose the homogeneity of the material under test. This sensor is incorporated in a test bench composed of a VNA and a Switch Matrix that allows the VNA to connect with the 6 probes of the sensor. The measurements are the reflection of each probe and the transmission between two identified probes in a band of frequencies between 100MHz and 12GHz.

    The first series of measurements with the multiprobe sensor was carried out on sand containing 0 to 20% water with increments of 5%. From the reflection coefficient values of each probe and the transmissions between two respective probes, we were able to verify the variation related to the increase of the water content in the sand. This determination of the water content is made from the modulus of the reflection coefficient and the different cases of transmissions between two probes.

    In conclusion, a new concept of a multi-probe sensor, for the determination of a soil moisture profile in the relatively loose and homogeneous sandy and clayey soil has been developed and tested. Thus, we were able to evaluate thresholds of water content in the sand of around 5% with this sensor. In order to continue the study of the sensor, we now plan to test more complex soils, but especially to extrapolate this multi-probe sensor to a system using a core drill to increase the depth of testing. This is a solution to characterize soils without sampling them. Especially, it is hoped that with the developed sensor a soil profile can be measured down to several meters in depth.

    Acknowledgment : This work has been supported by the Polish National Agency for Academic Exchange under Grant No. PPI/APM/2018/1/00048/U/001.

    How to cite: Sabouroux, P., Sparma, F., and Szypłowska, A.: New approach to water content measurements in soil core using microwave probing, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1350, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1350, 2022.

    EGU22-1385 | Presentations | SSS6.3

    BEST-WR for the hydraulic characterization of hydrophilic and water-repellent soils 

    Simone Di Prima, Ryan D. Stewart, Majdi R. Abou Najm, Ludmila Ribeiro Roder, Filippo Giadrossich, Rafael Angulo-Jaramillo, Deniz Yilmaz, Pier Paolo Roggero, Mario Pirastru, and Laurent Lassabatere

    Water-repellent soils usually experience water flow impedance during the early stage of a wetting process followed by progressive increase of infiltration rate. Current infiltration models are not formulated to describe this peculiar process. Similarly, simplified methods of soil hydraulic characterization (e.g., BEST) are not equipped to handle water-repellent soils. Here, we present an adaptation of the BEST method, named BEST-WR, for the hydraulic characterization of soils at any stage of water-repellency. We modified the Haverkamp explicit transient infiltration model, included in BEST for modeling infiltration data, by embedding a scaling factor describing the rate of attenuation of infiltration rate due to water repellency. The new model was validated using analytically generated data, involving soils with different texture and a dataset that included data from 60 single-ring infiltration tests. The scaling factor was used as a new index to assess soil water repellency in a Mediterranean wooded grassland, where the scattered evergreen oak trees induced more noticeable water repellency under the canopies as compared to the open spaces. The new index produced results in line with those obtained using the water drop penetration time test, which is one of the most widely test applied for quantifying soil water repellency persistence. Finally, we used BEST-WR to determine the hydraulic characteristic curves under both hydrophilic and hydrophobic conditions.

    How to cite: Di Prima, S., Stewart, R. D., Abou Najm, M. R., Ribeiro Roder, L., Giadrossich, F., Angulo-Jaramillo, R., Yilmaz, D., Roggero, P. P., Pirastru, M., and Lassabatere, L.: BEST-WR for the hydraulic characterization of hydrophilic and water-repellent soils, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1385, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1385, 2022.

    EGU22-1450 | Presentations | SSS6.3

    Soil water retention curves determined in the laboratory and in the field 

    Urša Pečan, Marina Pintar, and Damijana Kastelec

    Soil water retention curves (SWRCs) provide information on the energy status of soil water and its availability to plants and are therefore important for irrigation management. SWRCs have traditionally been determined in the laboratory. With the development of new equipment that allows continuous measurement of soil water content and matric potential, it is possible to generate SWRCs in the field. The objective of our study was to determine SWRCs from continuous measurements in the field using dielectric methods and to see how SWRCs change over time. We compared them to SWRCs determined in the laboratory on undisturbed soil samples using the evaporation method (HYPROP®, METERgroup, Munich, Germany). Both the SWRCs determined in the field and in the laboratory were based on drying data only. Our results show significant differences between the SWRCs determined in the laboratory and in the field. For a given value of the matric potential, SWRCs in the laboratory often reach higher water contents, which can be attributed to the difference in soil wetting in the laboratory and in the field. The SWRCs constructed in the field also exhibit temporal variations. Therefore, we can conclude that the use of a single laboratory-constructed SWRC is not sufficient to describe the relationship between soil water content and matric potential.

    How to cite: Pečan, U., Pintar, M., and Kastelec, D.: Soil water retention curves determined in the laboratory and in the field, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1450, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1450, 2022.

    EGU22-2086 | Presentations | SSS6.3

    Confronting the water potential information gap 

    Kimberly Novick, Darren Ficklin, Dennis Baldocchi, Kenneth Davis, Teamrat Ghezzehei, Alexandra Konings, Natasha MacBean, Nina Raoult, Russell Scott, Yuning Shi, Benjamin Sulman, and Jeffrey Wood

    Water potential directly controls the function of leaves, roots and microbes, and water potential gradients drive water flows throughout the soil-plant-atmosphere continuum. Notwithstanding its clear relevance for many ecosystem processes, soil water potential is rarely measured in-situ, and plant water potential observations are generally discrete, sparse, and not yet aggregated into accessible databases. These gaps limit our conceptual understanding of biophysical responses to moisture stress and inject large uncertainty into hydrologic and land surface models. Here, we outline the conceptual and predictive gains that could be made with more continuous and discoverable observations of water potential in soils and plants. We discuss improvements to sensor technologies that facilitate in situ characterization of water potential, as well as strategies for building new networks that aggregate water potential data across sites. We end by highlighting novel opportunities for linking more representative site-level observations of water potential to remotely-sensed proxies. Together, these considerations offer a roadmap for clearer links between ecohydrological processes and the water potential gradients that have the ‘potential’ to substantially reduce conceptual and modeling uncertainties.

    How to cite: Novick, K., Ficklin, D., Baldocchi, D., Davis, K., Ghezzehei, T., Konings, A., MacBean, N., Raoult, N., Scott, R., Shi, Y., Sulman, B., and Wood, J.: Confronting the water potential information gap, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2086, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2086, 2022.

    EGU22-5290 | Presentations | SSS6.3

    A meta-analysis of near-saturate hydraulic conductivities using the newly compiled Open Tension-disk Infiltrometer Meta-database OTIM 

    John Koestel, Guillaume Blanchy, Lukas Albrecht, Gilberto Bragato, and Nicholas Jarvis

    Saturated and near-saturated hydraulic conductivities K (mm/h) are important soil properties that determine the partitioning of precipitation into surface runoff and infiltration and indicate soil susceptibility to preferential flow as well as soil aeration properties. Measurements of saturated and near-saturated soil hydraulic conductivities are time consuming and not practical for larger scales where they are mostly needed. The research community has therefore put effort in deriving pedotransfer functions to predict K using proxy variables. The precision of such pedotransfer functions has been very modest, however. As a result, recent studies have focused on assembling and analyzing bigger databases, aiming to find better predictors for the saturated and near-saturated soil hydraulic conductivities. A prominent example is the meta-database on tension-disk infiltrometer data compiled by Jarvis et al. (2013. Influence of soil, land use and climatic factors on the hydraulic conductivity of soil. Hydrology and Earth System Sciences 17(12), 5185-5195), who found that climate variables were better correlated with K than soil properties. OTIM (Open Tension-disk Infiltrometer Meta-database) builds on this database, adding 577 new data entries collated from 48 additional peer-reviewed scientific publications. OTIM contains more detailed information on local climate as well as land use and management than its predecessor. In this study, we present OTIM together with a meta-analysis on topsoil K from supply tensions ranging between 0 and 10 cm. Evaluating Spearman coefficients, we found that near-saturated K correlated best with the mean diurnal temperature range (0.54), the aridity index (-0.47) and the precipitation in the driest quarter of the year (-0.44). It may be speculated that larger diurnal temperature ranges stimulate the vertical movement of soil fauna while dry climates may lead to well-developed networks of shrinkage cracks. Notably, the correlations vanished for all considered climate variables at and close to saturation. At saturation, bulk density exhibited the highest correlation (-0.36). Furthermore, we found that arable land uses were related to strong decreases in saturated, but only moderate reductions in near-saturated K. This is well explained by effects of tillage and trafficking. Tillage disconnects macropores, diminishes the presence of macrofauna and thus leads to smaller saturated K; but for some weeks after seedbed preparation, it also improves near-saturated K by creating a well-connected inter-aggregate pore-network in the topsoil. Trafficking, in contrast, leads to soil compaction and higher bulk-densities. We found that soil compaction strongly reduced K for all investigated tensions. In line with the above explanations, we observed that no-till agriculture was associated with decreased K compared to conventional and reduced tillage for all considered tensions. Moreover, infiltration measurements conducted soon after seedbed preparation led to larger K, also for all investigated tensions. Our study demonstrates the importance of land use, soil management and time of measurement relative to tillage for predicting saturated and near-saturated K. Besides, we found confirmation that climate variables have a large impact on near-saturated K. The underlying mechanisms are however not clear and should be investigated in future studies.   

    How to cite: Koestel, J., Blanchy, G., Albrecht, L., Bragato, G., and Jarvis, N.: A meta-analysis of near-saturate hydraulic conductivities using the newly compiled Open Tension-disk Infiltrometer Meta-database OTIM, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5290, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5290, 2022.

    EGU22-6128 | Presentations | SSS6.3 | Highlight

    Water status monitoring in almond and walnut orchards using random forest and remote sensing 

    Isaya Kisekka and Srinivasa Peddinti

    Water status in almond and walnut orchards is critical in optimizing irrigation management practices since it affects productivity, nut quality, and composition. Water status is frequently determined by the midday stem water potential (SWP) of almond and walnut orchards. Using SWP, allows for determination of the water status of almond and walnut trees, as well as to compare stress between days. SWP measurements are collected on a tree-by-tree basis and do not provide information on spatial variability or the comparison of different time periods because the recorded value is affected by both soil water content and the weather conditions on the day of the measurement, which makes comparisons between different time periods impracticable unless SWP readings are normalized by a baseline (non -water stressed tree under similar environmental conditions). The utilization of a very high-resolution manned and unmanned aerial vehicles equipped with multispectral cameras is being used to record the variability of different spectral features from the plant to the field-scale.

    With this research, we aimed to construct a data-driven model based on the Random Forest (RF) ensemble technique to predict SWP spatial variability in drip and sprinkler irrigated almond and walnut orchards in the Central Valley of California, USA. For the training of the RF model, SWP data from three crop seasons from 2019 to 2021 were used along with Landsat-derived evaporation fraction, normalized vegetation index, soil water content from neutron probe, meteorological parameters, and soil properties as covariates. The results demonstrate that the trained model was capable of predicting the SWP at higher spatial resolutions when aerial imagery data were used in conjunction with the trained model. The R2 values for training and validation for almond and walnut orchards were 0.92 and 0.84, respectively. Using the results of the comparison between the pressure chamber measurements and the RF model predictions, we were able to estimate SWP with root mean square errors (RMSE) of 2 and 1.2 bars, mean absolute errors (MAE) of 1.2 and 0.96 bars, and mean bias of 0.62 and 0.48 bars in almond and walnut orchards, respectively. These results demonstrate the capabilities of a machine learning-based RF algorithm for predicting the SWP at higher spatial resolutions by using satellite, aerial imagery, and other meteorological variables as covariates. Spatial maps of SWP can be used by growers to optimize precision irrigation management in orchards characterized by water induced spatial variability.

    How to cite: Kisekka, I. and Peddinti, S.: Water status monitoring in almond and walnut orchards using random forest and remote sensing, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6128, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6128, 2022.

    EGU22-6648 | Presentations | SSS6.3

    Assimilation of ERT data to improve Feddes parameters in a hydrological model during a root water uptake experiment 

    Benjamin Mary, Anna Botto, Veronika Iván, Luca Peruzzo, Chunwei Chou, Yuxin Wu, Giorgio Cassiani, and Matteo Camporese

    Mitigating plant water stress while reducing irrigation is one of the biggest challenges that sustainable agricultural practices aim to tackle. The rhizosphere is the main unknown component controlling the water distribution in the soil, but non-destructive observations of root physiology are often lacking due to methodological limitations.  

    Numerous studies relate the use of electrical resistivity tomography (ERT) or stem-based methods to measure soil water content changes associated with root water uptake (RWU) in the rhizosphere area. Nevertheless, geoelectrical data are correlated with many rhizosphere parameters and their interpretation needs to be supported by physics-based models of root hydrology.

    Here, we use a Data Assimilation (DA) framework to combine geoelectrical data with a hydrological model (Mary et al. 2021). DA offers the possibility to estimate model parameters governing RWU, such as in the well-known Feddes approach while introducing data observations to update them. 

    In a synthetic experiment mimicking a top-down infiltration in a rhizotron containing a wine plant (Vitis Vinifera), we simulated different scenarios of ERT data assimilation with the CATHY surface-subsurface hydrological model. The rooting depth associated with the Feddes parameters are perturbed to generate the ensemble states. At each observation time, model states and root depth parameters are updated using the Ensemble Kalman Filter (ENKF). 

    Expected results aim to demonstrate (i) what is the best ENKF scheme to integrate ERT measurements with the hydrological model and (ii) how much the uncertainties on the Feddes parameters can be reduced with the assimilation of ERT data. In a future work, the best approach identified will be applied to real soil and plant observation datasets.

    Mary, B., Peruzzo, L., Iván, V., Facca, E., Manoli, G., Putti, M., et al. (2021). Combining Models of Root-Zone Hydrology and Geoelectrical Measurements: Recent Advances and Future Prospects. Front. Water 3, 767910. doi:10.3389/frwa.2021.767910.

    How to cite: Mary, B., Botto, A., Iván, V., Peruzzo, L., Chou, C., Wu, Y., Cassiani, G., and Camporese, M.: Assimilation of ERT data to improve Feddes parameters in a hydrological model during a root water uptake experiment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6648, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6648, 2022.

    EGU22-7678 | Presentations | SSS6.3

    Effect of different tree species on soil moisture and temperature. Early-stage view of continuous forest soil regime monitoring. 

    Marta Kuželková, Lukáš Jačka, Martin Kovář, and Václav Hradilek

    Due to the spatial heterogeneity, root presence and other specific properties, measurement of forest soil hydraulic properties is difficult. Forests are generally hydrologically important systems that can mitigate negative climate change impact, and specifically, forest soil represents crucial water reservoir. A common forest management strategy is to plant monocultural stands of trees. Due to the differences in trees characteristics, e.g., root system, litter and leaf area, the development of soil undergoes specific changes according to the planted species. The main aim of this study is to investigate the connection between the tree species and hydro-physical properties of forest soil with focus on long term soil moisture and temperature regime monitoring. This research brings an early-stage view to data obtained from May 2021 up to nowadays.

    A set of 55 TDT (time domain transmission) soil moisture and temperature sensors were installed into three nearby locations. In each of those a monoculture stand of beech (Fagus sylvatica), spruce (Picea Abies), and larch (Larix Decidua) are planted. Half of the sensors are used for measuring the mineral soil moisture in depth of -15 to -29 cm below soil surface and point temperature of -23, -15, +5 cm relative to the surface, the rest is used for measuring the topsoil moisture from the surface to the depth of -14 cm and point temperatures in levels of -8, 0 and +15 cm.

    Results shows distinct differences in soil moisture among tested tree species. After longer period without precipitation (period of soil-water loss), the highest differences in volumetric water content (VWC) were observed. After one-month period without rain in early summer, mean values of VWC for topsoil were 35% for beach, 28% for larch, and 21% for spruce. Overall, the beech stands showed the highest ability to maintain soil water after periods of soil water loss and therefore, potentially exhibited the strongest resistance towards soil drought. By contrast, spruce tends to lose water relatively fast which can be problematic especially in events of long-term drought. For the surface temperature during vegetation season, the highest values were observed in larch stands followed by spruce and the lowest in beach. These findings probably corresponding to different solar radiation permeability of tree canopies. The observed effects of tree species on soil moisture and temperature should be considered for hydrological modelling, future forest planning, and water management improvement of forest soil.

    How to cite: Kuželková, M., Jačka, L., Kovář, M., and Hradilek, V.: Effect of different tree species on soil moisture and temperature. Early-stage view of continuous forest soil regime monitoring., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7678, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7678, 2022.

    EGU22-8297 | Presentations | SSS6.3

    Land-use change impacts on soil water balance in Santa Cruz Island, Galapagos 

    Ilia Alomia, Rose Paque, Armando Molina, Yessenia Montes, Jean Dixon, and Veerle Vanacker

    In the Galapagos archipelago, about 96% of the land area has been declared a Protected National Park in 1959. Of the four inhabited islands, Santa Cruz is the most populated, with 15,393 inhabitants in 2010. The non-protected area in Santa Cruz corresponds to the south-central part of the island and the bay area around Puerto Ayora. Over the period 1961-2018, the agricultural land expanded from 6% to 67% of the non-protected land area. In a field-based study around the settlement of Santa Rosa, we monitored hydrometeorological and soil physical and hydrological properties over the period July 2019-December 2021. Six sites were monitored including two replicates per land cover type: (i) native Miconia forest, (ii) agricultural land, and (iii) abandoned farmland with invasive species. The spatiotemporal distribution of rainfall and air temperature over the sites is recorded via one weather station, four rain gauges, air temperature and relative humidity sensors; and the atmospheric input and rainfall were sampled at biweekly basis. After pedological characterization of the six profiles, soil and rock samples were taken per horizon for analysis of elemental chemistry, mineralogy, texture, C/N ratio, and organic matter content. Upslope of the soil profiles, TDR probes measured volumetric soil moisture content, soil electrical conductivity and temperature; and soil water samples were taken using suction lysimeters. 

     

    Over the monitoring period, the highest rainfall amounts were measured in January (226 to 265 mm), and the lowest in May (20 to 25 mm). Most of the year, the relative air humidity is close to 100% with values dropping to 60% in March. The lowest air temperatures (15 °C) are measured in August, and the highest (29 °C) in March and April. Solar radiation strongly fluctuates from 80 W/m2 during the rainiest month to 220 W/m2 in March. Deeply weathered soils are developed on basaltic parent material and have a depth up to 50 cm. Soils are loose and lack macro-structure. The dry bulk density varies as a function of land cover, with the highest bulk densities of 0.9 g.cm-³ in abandoned farmlands, intermediate values of 0.7 g.cm-³ in agricultural land and lowest values of 0.5 g.cm-³ in forests. Although the air temperature is similar amongst all six sites, there are clear differences in the soil temperature between agricultural and abandoned farmland, and forest sites. Our data show that soil moisture is systematically higher in the two forest sites compared to the agricultural and abandoned sites.  

     

    As such, the field data provide evidence of the impact of forest clearing on soil physical properties and soil-water balance.

     

    Keywords

    Soil weathering, soil water balance, Galapagos, basaltic soils, Agricultural expansion

     

    How to cite: Alomia, I., Paque, R., Molina, A., Montes, Y., Dixon, J., and Vanacker, V.: Land-use change impacts on soil water balance in Santa Cruz Island, Galapagos, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8297, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8297, 2022.

    EGU22-8703 | Presentations | SSS6.3

    Testing effects of deviations from theory for beerkan infiltration experiments 

    Massimo Iovino, Vincenzo Bagarello, Michal Dohnal, and Jianbin Lai

    The beerkan infiltration experiment is carried out by inserting the ring a short depth into the soil and establishing a positive head of water on the infiltration surface for at least a part of the run. Nevertheless, the data are analyzed by assuming a fully unconfined infiltration process (ring insertion depth, d = 0) and a null ponded depth of water (H = 0). The influence of ring insertion and ponded water on an infiltration process of 2 hours sampled every minute was tested in this numerical investigation. Five soils varying from sand to silt loam, three ring radii (5 - 15 cm) and the beerkan specific range of values for both d and H, that is between 0 and 1 cm were considered. The differences between the theoretical (d = H = 0) and the practical (d = H = 1 cm) setups varied from -10.4% and +8.6% for the mean infiltration rate and from -10.2% to +8.3% for the final cumulative infiltration. These differences were small and they decreased by considering a soil dependent ring radius. In particular, nearly negligible differences were detected using a small ring in coarse-textured soils and a large ring in fine-textured soils. In the coarser soils, inserting the ring and establishing a ponded depth of water did not alter appreciably the estimated coefficients of the two-parameter infiltration model with the Cumulative Linearization method since these coefficients differed between the theoretical and practical setups by no more than 9.2%; while in fine soils, linearization could not be possible regardless of the considered setup or it was the use of d = H = 1 cm instead of d = H = 0 that impeded a convincing linearization of the data. In conclusion, the satisfactory correspondence, in many circumstances, between the theoretical and the practical beerkan infiltration experiment reinforced the interest for this simple experiment as a practical means to collect infiltration data in the field. Other numerical tests should be carried out to reach more general conclusions, also considering heterogeneous soil conditions. The numerical results should represent the first step of a wider investigation that also includes laboratory and field experiments.

    How to cite: Iovino, M., Bagarello, V., Dohnal, M., and Lai, J.: Testing effects of deviations from theory for beerkan infiltration experiments, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8703, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8703, 2022.

    In precision irrigation, a wise approach for decision making would consider not only a response to the current observations by sensors or other means. It should also consider forecasting the near future and prospecting hypothetical scenarios for water requirements and potential yield. These would require simulations which, in turn, demand for site specific characterization of the Soil-Plant-Atmosphere scenario. While crop parameters can be retrieved relatively easy from remote sensing, the availability of precise soil data would be limiting the accuracy of the simulations. Such limitations could be alleviated by in-situ calibration of the soil-crop models where the simulated soil water budget is contrasted with observed series of crop’s vigor and water state. This contribution describes an example where the soil waterholding capacity was estimated from inverse modelling during the seasons of 2020 and 2021 in a vineyard near Lleida, Spain.

    How to cite: Casadesus, J. and Bellvert, J.: In situ calibration of soil-plant-atmosphere simulations, for precision irrigation practice, using timeseries of crop’s vigor and water state, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8928, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8928, 2022.

    EGU22-9216 | Presentations | SSS6.3

    Water dynamics in an infiltration trench in an urban centre in Brazil 

    Artur Paiva Coutinho, Paulo Henrique Lopes Bezerra, Laurent Lassabatere, Severino Martins dos Santos Neto, Tassia dos Anjos Tenório Melo, Antonio Celso Dantas Antonino, Rafael Angulo-Jaramillo, and Suzana Maria Gico Lima Montenegro

    Infiltration trenches are compensatory techniques that have been settled up for decades. These aim to store the stormwater previously collected and infiltrate water into its banks. The objectives of the proposed study consist of modeling the water dynamics in an infiltration trench in order to evaluate its hydraulic performance. The studied trench is installed in the city of Recife (Pernambuco-Brazil, Brazil). We analyzed the response time of the infiltration system, the percentage of the infiltrated volume, and the dynamics of water storage processes for an extensive series of several rainfall events. We used the PULS method to model the events and quantify the contributions of each compartment to the water budget (infiltration, evaporation, etc.). Both observations and modeling demonstrated that the infiltration trench had a positive effect, with high performance, allowing the infiltrating of a large part of the drained volume. The infiltration trench achieved its objective of decreasing the volume drained on the surface. In this research, we also question the changes in the soil characteristics with time (in particular clogging of the banks) and the potential occurrence of preferential flow.

    How to cite: Coutinho, A. P., Lopes Bezerra, P. H., Lassabatere, L., Neto, S. M. D. S., Melo, T. D. A. T., Antonino, A. C. D., Angulo-Jaramillo, R., and Montenegro, S. M. G. L.: Water dynamics in an infiltration trench in an urban centre in Brazil, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9216, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9216, 2022.

    EGU22-9499 | Presentations | SSS6.3

    Comparing the performances of Pedotransfer Functions with Hydrus 1D Inverse Parameters Estimation in a deep cultivated sahelian soil 

    Djim M L Diongue, Frederic C Do, Christine Stumpp, Didier Orange, Christophe Jourdan, Sidy Sow, Serigne Faye, and Olivier Roupsard

    Knowledge about soil water balance and ecosystem water partitioning is crucial for managing soils in semi-arid areas like the Sahel, but hydraulic parameters are hardly available to run either parsimonious or detailed process models. This study aims at bridging this parameterization gap in a typical deep (> 2m) loamy sand soil from the groundnut basin in Senegal[1]. Five approaches of soil hydraulic parameterization with a range of different complexity were compared: (1) the lookup table of Carsel and Parrish (1988) that use only the soil texture class known as “Class PTFs”, (2) Rosetta PTFs from only topsoil characterization, (3) Rosetta PTFs with a detailed multilayer soil characterization, and inverse estimation from soil moisture using Hydrus-1D, considering the soil column either as (4) a single soil material and (5) with three-layered soil material. We compared the predicted (i) soil water content (SWC) with high-frequency measurements from 15 cm down to 200 cm deep and (ii) actual evapotranspiration (ET) with Eddy Covariance (EC) data during four consecutive growing seasons under a rotation of pearl millet and peanut crops. The simplest methods (1 & 2) resulted in a significant bias of the predicted SWC, with, however, some predictive ability of Method 2 to simulate the general trends of Swc, especially under peanut crops. Method 3 behaved reasonably with average RMSE for SWC, varying between 0.029 and 0.023 cm-3 cm-3. Method 4 further improved the predictions with RMSE ranging from 0.013 to 0.020 cm-3 cm-3. The best agreement was found under peanut using Method 5 (RMSE ≤ 0.013 cm3 cm-3). Methods 3, 4 or 5 behaved satisfactorily for predicting ET whatever the crop, e.g. Method 4 (RMSE= 0.05 cm day-1, NSE= 0.9 and R²= 0.93) for pearl millet.

    We showed that inverse modelling should be preferred over using PTFs when studying water fluxes and evapotranspiration in cultivated Sahelian soils.


    [1] Faidherbia-Flux (FLUXNET: SN-Nkr): https://lped.info/wikiObsSN/?Faidherbia-Flux

    How to cite: Diongue, D. M. L., Do, F. C., Stumpp, C., Orange, D., Jourdan, C., Sow, S., Faye, S., and Roupsard, O.: Comparing the performances of Pedotransfer Functions with Hydrus 1D Inverse Parameters Estimation in a deep cultivated sahelian soil, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9499, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9499, 2022.

    EGU22-9931 | Presentations | SSS6.3

    Characterizing soil-plant interactions under heterogeneous micro-irrigated citrus orchards 

    Daniela Vanella, Giuseppe Longo-Minnolo, Juan Miguel Ramírez-Cuesta, Domenico Longo, Alessandro D'Emilio, and Simona Consoli

    The increased water demand from the irrigated agriculture sector calls for the introduction of more efficient water saving strategies in order to maintain sustainable crop production. This need is particularly urgent in Mediterranean climate areas, already deeply affected by water scarcity and soil depletion issues. In this context, the use of advanced near surface geophysics monitoring techniques can help to characterize the temporal and spatial soil physics dynamics and the related soil moisture processes active at the root-zone level aiming at optimizing the irrigation management.

    In this study, the electrical resistivity imaging (ERI) technique was applied for characterizing the mass exchange mechanisms acting within the soil-plant system of heterogeneous micro-irrigated orchards. In particular, repeated ERI surveys were carried out in a citrus orchard (Citrus sinensis (L.) Osbeck), located in Eastern Sicily, southern Italy, characterized by the presence of crop heterogeneity features within the same plant framework, both in terms of variety and age (i.e. 3-year old Tarocco Ippolito and 8 year-old Tarocco Nucellare Scirè, respectively).

    The time-lapse ERI monitoring has permitted to identify specific wetting fronts and root water uptake (RWU) patterns effective in the soil / root system during dynamic condition (i.e. an irrigation cycle), mostly affected by the complex nonlinear interactions (i.e., soil evaporation, RWU and soil water redistribution) operating under crop heterogeneous conditions. Moreover, the use of soil moisture sensors installed in situ has permitted to identify a clear relationship between the changes in the soil water content observed in the field and the soil electrical resistivity (ER) characteristics with reference to the different types of analysed tree crops (with overall R2 value of 0.63). Specifically, it has been observed that the soil evaporative process, represented by an increasing of ER values, was greater in the younger citrus trees due to their lower vegetation groundcover and roots development. While, the greater soil moisture changes (resulting in greater ER decreasing patterns) occurred for the mature tree crops, characterized by higher root biomass, because its initial soil water condition was lower in comparison to the young tree crops.

    How to cite: Vanella, D., Longo-Minnolo, G., Ramírez-Cuesta, J. M., Longo, D., D'Emilio, A., and Consoli, S.: Characterizing soil-plant interactions under heterogeneous micro-irrigated citrus orchards, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9931, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9931, 2022.

    EGU22-10912 | Presentations | SSS6.3

    A critical review of conceptual and empirical approaches to characterize infiltration 

    Majdi Abou Najm, Christelle Basset, Rafael Angulo-Jaramillo, Vincenzo Bagarello, Simone Di Prima, Massimo Iovino, Laurent Lassabatere, and Ryan Stewart

    Over the past two centuries, studying the infiltration process has received significant efforts resulting in numerous infiltration models being developed. These models depended on specific soil properties, and were influenced by initial and boundary conditions. They were also classified into two major categories: empirical and conceptual models, although the boundaries between those two categories can be debated for several models. The empirical models solved the infiltration problem by curve-fitting measured data into algebraic equations. In contrast, the conceptual approaches built on earlier concepts, mainly derived from the fundamental flow models, and then formulated analytical solutions applied to the infiltration problem. In this review, we create an inclusive survey covering the diverse spectrum of published infiltration modeling to understand the philosophy and evolution of those empirical and conceptual models across the years. After providing a full historical retrospective of infiltration models, we explored the model parameters and their evolution with time. We also reviewed the different methods applied to estimate the basic and common infiltration parameters, as well as the challenges that arise by such methods.

    How to cite: Abou Najm, M., Basset, C., Angulo-Jaramillo, R., Bagarello, V., Di Prima, S., Iovino, M., Lassabatere, L., and Stewart, R.: A critical review of conceptual and empirical approaches to characterize infiltration, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10912, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10912, 2022.

    Proper parameterisation and conceptualisation of the commonplace process of infiltration into the soil is still a topic of debate. Measuring soil water distribution in a spatio-temporally continuous manner can advance our understanding of infiltration in non-uniform flow networks and the soil matrix. At the same time, we find different measurement techniques bound to different concepts and scales, which make a general interpretation and quantification of the data still a challenging task.

    We present results from several irrigation experiments at the plot and hillslope scale, in which we combined hydrological, geophysical and remote sensing techniques. On this basis, we will point out how different techniques have advantages and pitfalls for their interpretation. E.g. despite the different scales, we found hydraulic conductivity measured in soil cores in good coherence with plot scale experiments, while in-situ measurements with a constant head permeameter deviated substantially. Another example are multispectral data of the changing surface conditions during irrigation which cannot discern different subsurface infiltration patterns, once the surface becomes sufficiently wet.

    Since any parameterisation links back to the conceptual and numerical models, we have developed an alternative concept to simulate soil water infiltration and redistribution based on a Langangian approach using film flow in representative macropores and a 2D random walk for the soil matrix. Simulations highlight the inherently combined effect of antecedent state and connected preferential flow networks on the respective generation of non-uniform infiltration patterns.




    How to cite: Jackisch, C. and Allroggen, N.: Initial non-uniform soil water redistribution as inherent hydrological process – from field experiments to model insights, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12777, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12777, 2022.

    EGU22-1148 | Presentations | SSS11.4

    Experimental Study on the Efficiency of a Hydrosuction System for Desilting Sediment from a Farm Pond 

    Tung-Yang Lai, Yu-Chao Hsu, Ji-Shang Wang, Yu-Wen Su, Guei-Lin Fu, and Cheng-Yi Hung

    Sedimentation has been a crucial problem in the management of storage in farm ponds, which cuts down the capability of ponds in aspects of irrigation, flood detention, and water retention. The Hydrosuction sediment removal system features low energy consumption and reduction of structural modifications to the existing shaft, which is an economically feasible method to remove siltation in storage areas. However, the effect of desilting might be limited due to the position of inflow orifice of siphon-type pipe which controls the scope of desilting affected area. This study aims to enhance the desilting effect of a fixed siphon system through connected a designed drainage tube.

    The experiments were conducted in a cubic tank with a volume of 1.0 m3. Inside the tank, a vertical square shaft with the height of 80cm connected to an outlet channel was placed, and the siphon-type pipe was arranged from the inner of the tank to the outlet channel along with the shaft with a 3.0 cm inner diameter. The tests were performed in two kinds of inflow conditions in three water heights (60, 70, 80 cm), one is constant head inflow condition for continuous inflow provided, the other is falling head inflow condition with limited inflow supply. The initially deposited depths of sediment varied from 30 or 40cm. The designed 24cm long tube which has three added upward orifices with two types of diameters (1.0, 2.0 cm) could be connected to the inflow orifice of the siphon pipe to compare the desilting effect with the original arrangement in the above flow conditions.

    The experimental results revealed that the effect of desilting was promoted by the connection of the designed tube to the siphon system. Besides, the efficiency of desilting was affected by the sizes of discharge orifices on the designed tube in different inflow conditions. In the constant head inflow condition, the arrangement of the connected 2cm discharge orifice tube performed better results due to the larger amount of outflow induced by the larger orifice. On the contrary, the arrangement of the connected 1cm discharge orifice tube had better desilting effect in falling head inflow condition induced by the longer time of disturbance between flow and sediment in smaller discharge. The results indicate that the capability and efficiency of sediment removal in the siphon system might be promoted by connecting an extended drainage tube with an appropriate size of upward discharge orifices.

    How to cite: Lai, T.-Y., Hsu, Y.-C., Wang, J.-S., Su, Y.-W., Fu, G.-L., and Hung, C.-Y.: Experimental Study on the Efficiency of a Hydrosuction System for Desilting Sediment from a Farm Pond, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1148, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1148, 2022.

    EGU22-1841 | Presentations | SSS11.4

    Making the Schmidt Hammer Great Again! 

    Benjamin Huxol, Gunnar Pruß, Anne Voigtländer, Michael Dietze, and Jens M Turowski

    Have you ever applied the Schmidt hammer method and wondered what the R‑value represents? What SI unit it would have and which material properties it actually assesses? The Schmidt rebound hammer is a device initially intended to test the curing state and strength of concrete. Since then, the concept has been transferred to determine the strength, weathering, and sometime even surface exposure age of rocks in geomorphology. The advantage of the Schmidt hammer that it is non-destructive, easy to handle, light, and readily applicable in the field. However, the method is only based on correlation, without physical explanation of the measured value being provided, and using a seemingly arbitrary resolution of the scale without reference. Here we present our approach to put the Schmidt hammer and especially the physics behind the R‑value on solid ground. Using a dataset of material properties and R‑Values, we find that the Schmidt hammer best represents the elasticity of the material. The elasticity and, along with it, the elastic modulus, can be independently and complementarily assessed with other geophysical methods. Both metrics are known to vary with i) moisture level, ii) stress state, and iii) temperature. Consequently, we conducted controlled experiments to constrain the influence of these conditions on R‑values. A major disadvantage of the Schmidt hammer, the resolution of the scale, remains and needs further calibration.

    How to cite: Huxol, B., Pruß, G., Voigtländer, A., Dietze, M., and Turowski, J. M.: Making the Schmidt Hammer Great Again!, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1841, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1841, 2022.

    EGU22-2558 | Presentations | SSS11.4

    Machine Learning for low-field NMR to improve pore fluid characterization 

    Tina Katika and Panagiotis Michalis

    The level and type of saturation of the petroleum reservoirs is an essential parameter in reserve estimation because it determines the effective volume of the hydrocarbon that is being stored. At the same time, rock wettability influences the displacement of oil by water from oil-producing reservoirs, especially during water-flooding processes. Low-field Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) spectrometry evaluates the pore size distribution and has proved a powerful tool in determining the type of saturation and assessing the solid-fluid affinity (Katika et al., 2017).

    However, assessing the pore-fluid distribution of rocks with complex mineral composition at laboratory conditions, such as chalk and argillaceous sandstones, that are commonly found in the North Sea oil reservoirs, often requires further investigation. NMR data are combined with a visual inspection or with traditional techniques, such as MICP, to evaluate the microtexture of rocks (Katika et al., 2018, Faÿ-Gomord et al., 2016). Considering that laboratory low-field NMR can be used as a guide to interpreting logging data, improving the evaluation of lab measurements has a profound influence on the field.

    Deep Learning (DL), as an artificial intelligence technique utilizing neural networks, has the potential to transform low-field NMR into a more efficient and powerful tool in reservoir characterization.

    The various peaks in NMR T2 relaxation spectra differ in rocks with multiple types and levels of saturation, rock-fluid affinity, or pore size distribution. In the present study, we aim to improve the interpretation of the T2 spectra and automate peak picking. Using laboratory data for reservoir rocks from the literature (Katika et al., 2017), a Deep Neural Network (DNN) was trained to optimize the internal network parameters and successfully evaluate the type of peaks existing in T2 spectra. The successful evaluation is confirmed with visual inspection and correlated with geophysical data derived from the same literature.

    References

    Katika, K., Saidian, M., Prasad, M. and Fabricius, I.L., 2017. Low-Field NMR Spectrometry of Chalk and Argillaceous Sandstones: Rock-Fluid Affinity Assessed from T1/T2 Ratio. Petrophysics-The SPWLA Journal of Formation Evaluation and Reservoir Description, 58(02), pp.126-140. SPWLA-2017-v58n2a4

    Faÿ-Gomord, O., Soete, J., Katika, K., Galaup, S., Caline, B., Descamps, F., Lasseur, E., Fabricius, I.L., Saïag, J., Swennen, R. and Vandycke, S., 2016. New insight into the microtexture of chalks from NMR analysis. Marine and Petroleum Geology, 75, pp.252-271. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marpetgeo.2016.04.019

    Katika, K., Alam, M.M., Alexeev, A., Chakravarty, K.H., Fosbøl, P.L., Revil, A., Stenby, E., Xiarchos, I., Yousefi, A. and Fabricius, I.L., 2018. Elasticity and electrical resistivity of chalk and greensand during water flooding with selective ions. Journal of Petroleum Science and Engineering, 161, pp.204-218. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.petrol.2017.11.045

    How to cite: Katika, T. and Michalis, P.: Machine Learning for low-field NMR to improve pore fluid characterization, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2558, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2558, 2022.

    EGU22-2582 | Presentations | SSS11.4

    Soil erosion assessment via temporal and spatial high-resolution time-lapse Structure from Motion on rainfall simulation plots 

    Lea Epple, Anne Bienert, Oliver Grothum, and Anette Eltner

    High-resolution information on the processes and rates of soil erosion, transport, and deposition, offer important knowledge for soil erosion modelling, and the protection and sustainable management of soil. It helps improve the cross-scale understanding on aspects as aggregate breakdown, rill erosion, swelling and shrinking effects, and rill-network evolution. As a non-invasive, high-resolution, and cost as well as time-efficient method, Structure from Motion (SfM) presents a valuable tool to calculate soil loss, depict soil surface change detection, and offer high-resolution information on soil and soil erosion processes. Even though SfM shows in general higher erosion rates, due to the influence of non-erosive processes, the technique is altogether in good agreement with the sampling data at the outlet. We monitor soil erosion on multiple erosional plots and with spatial and temporal high-resolution photogrammetry to assess its feasibility over time.

    For this purpose, we conduct 12 rainfall simulations on a three times one metre plot, on different sides, with different vegetation cover, tillage, and initial soil conditions. Seven to ten synchronized time-lapse cameras are set up around the plot, taking pictures every 10-60 seconds. The data thus obtained allow change detection assessment via digital elevation models of difference at least once per minute. The elevation change by SfM is validated via bulk density measurements, and sampling at the plot’s outlet assessing runoff, and sediment concentration at minute intervals. During an overflow experiment, we measure flow velocity via video using particle tracer and manually via colour tracer, gaining spatial and temporal distribution information on the flow velocity. Using low-cost sensors, we furthermore monitor the progress of the soil moisture and temperature during the whole rainfall simulation.

    We present sampled and photogrammetric results based on a dozen rainfall simulations at the micro-scale with a very high temporal and spatial resolution. This gives an insight into spatial distribution and development of soil erosion processes on a sub-minute resolution. We compare these data to gain knowledge on the feasibility of temporal and spatial high-resolution SfM soil erosion assessment and their usability for the validation and calibration of process-based soil erosion models.

    How to cite: Epple, L., Bienert, A., Grothum, O., and Eltner, A.: Soil erosion assessment via temporal and spatial high-resolution time-lapse Structure from Motion on rainfall simulation plots, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2582, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2582, 2022.

    EGU22-3891 | Presentations | SSS11.4

    Impact of grain size distribution and wind velocity on the armoring layer of aeolian megaripples 

    lior saban, Itzhak Katra, and Hezi Yizhaq

    Aeolian megaripples are a landscape formation widespread on Earth and Mars that develop in sand surfaces with a bimodal grain size distribution of coarse and fine grains. Megaripples are relatively high with a greater wavelength compared with normal sand ripples. Previous works provided quantitative information on the morphological characteristics, development, flattening mechanisms, longevity, and transverse instability of megaripples. It has been hypothesized that the sorting process of the initial bimodal size distribution is a key factor in megaripple formation. In this study, we experimentally explored the impact of the grain size distribution on the crest characteristics under different wind velocities in a boundary-layer wind tunnel. The controlled experiments allowed measurements of sand fluxes, particle size distributions, and ripple morphology by a laser module. The results reveal links between the rate of growth of the incipient megaripples, ripple height, and the armoring layer thickness and composition to wind velocity. The ripples grow higher as the wind velocity increases, and the armoring layer is thicker up to a certain wind velocity when erosion of the crest starts. In addition, the correlation between the armoring layer's nonlinear thickening rate and the ripples growth rate seems to indicate a fundamental connection between ripples height and the formation of the armoring layer, which is crucial for megaripples formation.

    How to cite: saban, L., Katra, I., and Yizhaq, H.: Impact of grain size distribution and wind velocity on the armoring layer of aeolian megaripples, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3891, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3891, 2022.

    EGU22-4865 | Presentations | SSS11.4

    Effect of coarse gravel and cobble size particles’ shape on their dynamic image analysis results 

    Tamara Kuzmanić and Matjaž Mikoš

    The Dynamic Image Analysis (DIA), standardised in ISO 13322-2:2006 and ISO 9276-6:2008 standards, introduces a simple and fast analysis of diverse particle shape and size parameters, compared to a manual method or static image analysis, respectively. While the DIA method is time conserving, as it is a quasi-3D method, it is susceptible to greater variations in results compared to a real-3D, time consuming static image analysis. A variation analysis of the DIA results as a function of the analysed particles’ shape was the focus of our study. The particle shape plays a role in various processes, including wearing off (mechanical abrasion) during sediment transport or due to in-situ abrasion of larger sediment particles in fluvial environments.

    More than 40 particles were randomly selected for the DIA analysis. Analysed particles included quarried, angular rock particles and rounded fluvial sediment particles. The selected particles had a geometric mean diameter in the range between 15 mm and 70 mm (coarse gravel to cobble size). The mass of particles was between 10 and 400 g. All particles were divided into four shape groups (bladed, prolate, equant, and oblate) according to Zingg’s shape classification. Axes' lengths used for shape classification were manually measured using a caliper. All particles were also individually analysed in a dynamic image analyser (quasi-3D image analyser) Microtrac Camsizer XL, using the accompanying software, PartAn 3D. The software evaluates 33 size and shape parameters of analysed particles, including dimensional (e.g. length, width, thickness, surface area, etc.) and dimensionless (e.g. ellipticity, sphericity, convexity, etc.) parameters. Three DIA repetitions of each particle were applied to estimate the mean values and variation (coefficients of variation, CV) in its results.

    Furthermore, the effect of particles’ size, mass, and Zingg’s shape on the variability of the DIA results was investigated. Particles’ size, as well as particles’ angularity, showed no obvious effect on the variation in the DIA results. Quarried, angular particles had CV of 3.54% on average for all parameter results, while rounded, fluvial particles had CV of 3.68% for all parameter results. On the other hand, Zingg’s shape class showed an effect on the variation of both, dimensional and dimensionless DIA resulting parameters. Bladed particles displayed the greatest variations of all the resulting parameter values, with an average CV of 6.85%, and the greatest scatter of parameters’ CVs. When analysing such particles, it would be beneficial to conduct more than three repetitions for more accurate results. Since the DIA analysis is a fast method, this is not a problem in order to get a robust estimation of coarse particle shape. Additionally, observing the parameters themselves, “concavity” and “angularity” had the highest CVs, namely 13.35% and 10.24%, as well as the greatest scatter of the CVs. Parameters “convexity”, “solidity”, and “sphericity” had the lowest CVs, namely 0.12%, 0.26%, and 0.96%, respectively, as well as the lowest scatter of the CVs.

    How to cite: Kuzmanić, T. and Mikoš, M.: Effect of coarse gravel and cobble size particles’ shape on their dynamic image analysis results, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4865, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4865, 2022.

    EGU22-4928 | Presentations | SSS11.4

    Testing of soil aggregate stability by means of laser diffractometer Mastersizer 3000 

    Jan-František Kubát, Michal Vrána, David Zumr, and Petr Kavka

    Good stability of soil aggregates is an essential characteristic that positively affects soil health, increases agronomic productivity, decreases susceptibility to soil erosion and can improve carbon sequestration. The most common laboratory procedure for determining soil aggregate stability is a water resistance index (WRI) which is based on a wet sieving method. Within this contribution we introduce a newly developed method which utilizes laser diffraction for estimating the water resistance index of soil aggregates (WRILD). Recently, this newly introduced method has been tested and compared with the Kemper & Rosenau equation. This new method was developed with an emphasis on comparability to the standard sieving procedure performed with the Eijkelkamp wet sieving apparatus. The water stability of the aggregates was tested across five different soil types (haplioc Luvisol, Chernozem, Regosol, Fluvisol, Cambisol). The pH of each sample was measured and according to this value, either hexametaphosphate or sodium hydroxide was used to disrupt the stable aggregates along with ultrasound. The resulting WRILD is determined based on a fraction of undisturbed aggregates recorded for each fictitious sieve size. Initial results show promising agreement between the standard sieving and laser diffractometer methods. The advantage of the latter is a much faster processing time of a large number of samples and their replicates. This new method has a lower variability of results. However, further measurements are needed to validate the method.

    This study has been supported by the Grant Agency of the Czech Technical University in Prague, grant No. SGS20/156/OHK1/3T/11 and EC H2020 Project 101000224 (TuDi).

    How to cite: Kubát, J.-F., Vrána, M., Zumr, D., and Kavka, P.: Testing of soil aggregate stability by means of laser diffractometer Mastersizer 3000, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4928, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4928, 2022.

    EGU22-4947 | Presentations | SSS11.4

    Rainfall Simulators – how plot scale affects results 

    Martin Neumann, Petr Kavka, Romana Kubínová, Adam Tejkl, Michal Vrána, Jan-František Kubát, and Tomáš Laburda

    Rainfall simulators (RS) are commonly used tools for soil erosion research under natural conditions. This research was focused on the plot scale effect in the formation of surface runoff and soil loss. Two surface conditions were tested - grass and bare soil. All experiments were performed in field conditions on undisturbed soil samples located on the experimental site Řisuty, where CTU has been performing experiments with rainfall simulators for many years. Three experiments were performed to investigate the formation of surface runoff depending on area size, surface type and precipitation intensity. These experiments were performed on a surface with grass cover and also on a plot of ​​cultivated bare soil. For the bare soil experiment, the area was prepared just prior to the experiment itself. The grass plots were left to develop naturally for 2 years after sowing. A large rainfall simulator with a maximal experimental area of 16 m2 (8 m length 2 m wide) was used for this experiment. Four plots with lengths of 1, 2, 4 and 8 m (with widths of 1 m) were placed under the RS. Soil moisture sensors were placed on the plot at various depths to monitor the evolution of soil moisture over time. For the plot with the grass cover, a rainfall with variable intensity over 75 minutes was used (rainfall intensities 40, 60, 90 mm/h). Two follow-up experiments were conducted on the plot with bare soil. Rainfall intensities were a constant 60 mm/h for 30 minutes after surface runoff starts. The second experiment started 15 minutes after the conclusion of the first one. This same methodology has been used in other, past, experiments with RS so our results are directly comparable to those previously conducted experiments. All results were recalculated to 1m2 and 1 minute intervals for comparison in addition to the cumulative values for each experiment.

    Results from the plots with grassland showed significant differences between plots of different lengths. Experimental plots with bare soil provided higher variability in results on the plots in their natural moisture (dry condition), than those of the fully saturated samples. Results showed that the length of the plot is more important for soil loss than for surface runoff processes. The heterogeneity of the infiltration soil properties would play significant role on the experiment results.

    This study has been supported by Grant Agency of the Czech Technical University in Prague, grant No. SGS20/156/OHK1/3T/11 and the Project QK1910029.

    How to cite: Neumann, M., Kavka, P., Kubínová, R., Tejkl, A., Vrána, M., Kubát, J.-F., and Laburda, T.: Rainfall Simulators – how plot scale affects results, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4947, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4947, 2022.

    EGU22-5032 | Presentations | SSS11.4

    Experimental laboratory setup for identification and quantification of transported soil particles in subsurface flows 

    Laura Kögler, Thomas Iserloh, Alina Helmer, Andreas Ruby, Miriam Marzen, Manuel Seeger, and Johannes B. Ries

    There is a knowledge gap concerning the identification and quantification of transported soil particles in subsurface flows. If these soil particles reach relevant amounts, protective measures against soil erosion applied on the surface may be partially ineffective, and the soil may degrade further and unnoticed. In consequence, there is a need to develop a method to determine this subsurface particle transport in situ. A laboratory flume experiment was developed to examine the processes of fine soil material transport as well as the development of sediment traps for in situ measurements. Since, steep-slope vineyard soils are especially prone to subsurface flows they were subject of first investigations: The shallow steep-slope vineyard soils of the Mosel wine region are mainly developed from Devonian argillaceous schists and Pleistocene terrace sediments. Among the main physical characteristics are a very high rock fragment content and a loose surface layer over a strongly compacted layer caused by the combined action of tillage and weathering. This structure is presumably prone to subsurface flows within the upper horizon, especially in periods of very high soil moisture. The results of this laboratory experiment clearly confirm the presence of subsurface particle transport and the applicability of a sediment trap prototype consisting of a relatively simple and low-cost drain structure. 

    How to cite: Kögler, L., Iserloh, T., Helmer, A., Ruby, A., Marzen, M., Seeger, M., and Ries, J. B.: Experimental laboratory setup for identification and quantification of transported soil particles in subsurface flows, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5032, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5032, 2022.

    EGU22-6569 | Presentations | SSS11.4

    Development of a multimodal approach to monitoring of coastal waters 

    Morena Galešić Divić, Vladimir Divić, Marija Kvesić, Mak Kišević, and Roko Andričević

    The levels of monitoring quality and quantity for environmental factors present continuous challenges for engineers, scientists, and related decision-making bodies. This is particularly highlighted in complex ecosystems such as coastal areas and estuaries with the pronounced intersection of numerous natural gradients. On the other hand, constant technological advances of different measurement equipment, including the remotely operated vehicles and their modular design, are introducing vast opportunities for gathering various data. Furthermore, readily available open-source solutions for hardware and software domains present additional potential in developing the framework for multipurpose monitoring. We are developing a multimodal approach to monitoring coastal zones, particularly in estuarine waters, which comprises using commercially available measurement equipment (multisensory probes) and, more importantly, building task-oriented drifters with relevant sensors. Furthermore, we are implementing the usage of remotely operated vehicles, both areal and underwater, which present a suite of measurement devices for data amplification (metadata), collection, and verification, especially when coupled with satellite data. Moreover, the use of drones has additional value in reducing the disturbance of natural conditions and improving the safety of researchers. So far, the monitored data include conductivity, temperature, pressure, wave heights, water velocity, dissolved oxygen, chlorophyll, colored dissolved organic matter, turbidity, hyperspectral properties, and further research including thermal camera and LIDAR technology. Different measurement approaches also contain several issues such as temporal and spatial scale comparability and interoperability, while drone use implicates some concerns about privacy, noise, and the general social attitude. These issues are currently being investigated, generating some challenges for future progress. Through current multiple research projects, we are testing the presented multimodal approach on the case study of the river Jadro estuary near the city of Split (Croatia), aiming to develop a field laboratory with the potential to be replicated in any similar hydrological monitoring.

    How to cite: Galešić Divić, M., Divić, V., Kvesić, M., Kišević, M., and Andričević, R.: Development of a multimodal approach to monitoring of coastal waters, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6569, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6569, 2022.

    EGU22-6585 | Presentations | SSS11.4

    New opportunity of RS - variable rainfall simulator for plots variable plots area 

    Petr Kavka, Martin Neumann, Tomas Laburda, Jan Devátý, and Tomas Dostal

    Rainfall simulators are devices commonly used to study soil erosion in field and laboratory conditions. There is still an effort to develop equipment that will: not require a large number of workers, be easy to manipulate, have simple control systems, and automatically record data and parameters.

    This paper shows a new variable rainfall simulator with many possibilities, it consists of four independent sections that can be joined into larger simulator. Each section can simulate rain on a 2x4m area. The rain is generated by swinging and pulse mechanisms. Soil sensors and rain gauges are integrated into the control unit.

    The whole device is placed on a trailer that is moveable by car. On the trailer, there is also a 1m3 water reservoir, control unit based on WAGO control unit with electric switchboard, water pump, hydraulic system and valves. The device could be controlled by any laptop or smartphone with a wifi connection.

    Each section (4 total) consists of a boom with 3 nozzles connected to a stepper motor for swinging. Each nozzle has a valve to interrupt the water supply to the nozzle. These sections can be connected linearly to increase the length of the rainfall area (to maximum 16 meters), or they can be used parallelly, thereby performing multiple replications at one time on multiple areas side by side. All these sections are computer-controlled and are independent of each other. Each section contains sensors for measuring soil moisture and tipping bucket rain gauges for continuous monitoring of actual soil properties and control of the rainfall. Remote control also allows for variable rainfall scenarios. The device allows the use of both pulsed and swinging rainfall formation or their combination and thus a large variability in the choice of nozzles according to the purpose of the experiment. Water is pumped by the gas water pump throughout the redistributions and pressure reducing valve, which can manage the required stable pressure. It also contains a datalogger so all measurements and parameters are collected in one device.

    This study has been supported by the Grant Agency of the Czech Technical University in Prague, grant No. SGS20/156/OHK1/3T/11 and the Project QK1910029.

    How to cite: Kavka, P., Neumann, M., Laburda, T., Devátý, J., and Dostal, T.: New opportunity of RS - variable rainfall simulator for plots variable plots area, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6585, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6585, 2022.

    EGU22-6627 | Presentations | SSS11.4

    An experimental study on effects of grain size distribution on debris flow deposition characteristics 

    Hiroaki Izumiyama, Takao Yamakoshi, Yuya Takahashi, Yuki Nishiguchi, and Ryosuke Okuyama

    Precise prediction of travel distance of debris flow is required to design countermeasure strategy against natural disaster. A lot of numerical simulation tools have been developed using a selected shear stress which has been modeled to express the characteristics of debris flow and a modeled entrainment ratio. However, the calculation results for past events often show underestimated travel distance. One of the possible causes of the fact may be that the effect of grain size distribution on the entrainment ratio. This is because most models have been modeled assuming debris flow is constituted by a single size particle. An entrainment ratio model involving the effect of particle size distribution may improve the calculation reproductivity. From an engineering point of view, it is desirable that the effect can be taken into account as simply as possible. In this study, we conducted an experiment to know the extent to which the entrainment ratio is affected by the grain size distribution. The experiments were undertaken in a rectangular flume the channel slope of which can be adjusted at two points in longitudinal direction. Two-size mixtures of spherical glass beads or gravels were set as debris flow material. For each mixture, travel distance of debris flow and fractions of each size of debris flow material deposited near the channel slope change point were measured using high-speed camera.

    How to cite: Izumiyama, H., Yamakoshi, T., Takahashi, Y., Nishiguchi, Y., and Okuyama, R.: An experimental study on effects of grain size distribution on debris flow deposition characteristics, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6627, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6627, 2022.

    EGU22-6737 | Presentations | SSS11.4

    Laboratory rainfall simulation for surface runoff generation on tephra-covered slopes with different fine particle content 

    Marino Hiraoka, Naoki Imamori, Takeshi Shimizu, and Koji Ishida

    After pyroclastic materials are deposited in a watershed following a volcanic eruption, the risk of debris flow initiation may increase during subsequent rainfall events. Clarifying the rainfall-runoff process on tephra-covered slopes is essential to understand the mechanism of debris flow initiation after an eruption. Because the quality and quantity of pyroclastic materials vary from volcano to volcano, and from eruption to eruption of the same volcano, each rainfall-runoff process is expected to differ accordingly. Laboratory rainfall simulation is useful to highlight parameters (rainfall and sample conditions) that may affect the surface runoff process on slopes during and after a volcanic eruption. In this study, a laboratory experiment was conducted using a calibrated rainfall simulator to investigate how the occurrence of surface runoff during the first rainfall after an eruption depends on the fine particle content. Pyroclastic material was volcanic ash collected on Mount Sakurajima, Japan and the fine particle content Fc was adjusted using artificial silt: Sample A (Fc = 20%, control) and Sample B (Fc = 30%, adjusted). The experimental plots (1723.4 cm2 of the projection area) were prepared by filling each sample with a 5 cm thickness at a constant pressure on highly permeable silica sand, and placed at an inclination of 10°. The initial moisture condition of both samples was assumed to be dry (≈ 5% of water content ratio). The rainfall simulation was performed for 3 hours on each sample at an intensity of 30 mm h-1. Runoff water including sediment from the experimental plot during the simulation was captured at the lower end of the plot and the weight was recorded. Two soil moisture sensors were buried 2.5 cm below the surface of each sample to measure the change in volumetric water content (VWC) over time. Runoff water including sediment occurred and increased with time on Sample B though hardly occurred on Sample A. In both samples, the VWC increased with time and eventually approached a constant value. However, the maximum value of the VWC, and the time to reach the maximum value, were different; lower and slower in Sample B. The saturated hydraulic conductivity of Sample B was one order of magnitude lower than that of Sample A. These comparative results suggested that surface runoff may be greater during the first rainfall after an eruption because the infiltration is lower when the fine particle content, that is particle size distribution, in pyroclastic materials is high.

    How to cite: Hiraoka, M., Imamori, N., Shimizu, T., and Ishida, K.: Laboratory rainfall simulation for surface runoff generation on tephra-covered slopes with different fine particle content, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6737, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6737, 2022.

    EGU22-6912 | Presentations | SSS11.4

    Flow Resistance Due to Rigid and Flexible Vegetation: A Review 

    Laxman V Rathod, Prafulkumar V Timbadiya, and Bandita Barman

    Riverbank and floodplain vegetation substantially affects the fluvial processes and play a key role in river hydraulics and river management. Presence of vegetation influences the water levels, flow velocity profiles and resistance to flow. Therefore, better understanding of behavior of flow over vegetation is required in design of vegetative channels, construction of stage-discharge curves, determining horizontal flow structure around hydraulic structures, and to develop numerical models. A detailed review of flow resistance due to rigid and flexible vegetation has been done under both emergent and submerged conditions. Based on the flow conditions and vegetation features, the investigators made a transition between rigid, flexible, emergent, and submerged vegetation. The variation of the flow field in the vegetative open channel follows a two-layer approach, it is almost constant inside the vegetation layer and logarithmic one above the vegetation layer. Firstly, several theoretical approaches for determining the resistance due to rigid vegetation in emergent and submerged condition are discussed. For simplicity many investigators have considered a rigid cylinder without side branches and foliage, the vegetation having constant height, stem diameter, and uniform flow condition was considered as rigid. The resistance due to vegetation also depends on the uniform and staggered pattern arrangements, the latter has more impact on flow in comparison to the former. The analysis for flexible vegetation is complex due to the complex nature of vegetation, and it is difficult to take the heterogenous nature of field vegetation into the account. The resistance due to flexible vegetation is a function of the height of vegetation, vegetation density, foliage, plant form alignment of vegetation, submergence ratio, and type of vegetation. The flexible vegetation also assumes different configurations depending on the hydrodynamics of flow and bending stiffness. Furthermore, more recent approaches for describing the resistance due to flexible vegetation are presented.

    Keywords: Rigid vegetation, Flexible vegetation, Resistance to flow, Rivers, Floodplains, Flow field

    How to cite: Rathod, L. V., Timbadiya, P. V., and Barman, B.: Flow Resistance Due to Rigid and Flexible Vegetation: A Review, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6912, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6912, 2022.

    EGU22-7001 | Presentations | SSS11.4

    Review on Morphology and Turbulence Characteristics in Meandering Rivers 

    Yatirajulu Gurugubelli, Prafulkumar V Timbadiya, and Bandita Barman

    Meandering rivers are one of the most complex earth-surface systems and have a significant impact on riverine ecosystem mechanics. Because of the fascinating intricacy of meander morphodynamics, scholars from various disciplines, from fluid mechanics, fluvial hydraulics, and geomorphology, have been fascinated by meandering rivers. In spite of many years of research still, many processes regarding meandering rivers are not answered. Recent decades of research are reviewed herein in this paper. Scholars and experts have studied about flow features and processes such as a distorted profile of longitudinal velocity, secondary flow, inner and outer banks flow separation, etc., and sedimentological processes such as point bars, bend scour, lateral bed slope, etc. Many of them studied time-mean flow, Reynolds stresses, turbulence intensities (TI), turbulent kinetic energy, quadrant analysis, and turbulence scales, etc. under the effect of meandering bends. Many laboratory experiments are carried out to understand the individual processes under different conditions. Due to the rapid enhancement of soft computational techniques, these experimental data sets can be validated. Some future recommendations are also suggested in the field, laboratory, and numerical modelling.

    Keywords: Meandering rivers, secondary flow, Reynolds stresses, turbulent kinetic energy, turbulence scales

    How to cite: Gurugubelli, Y., Timbadiya, P. V., and Barman, B.: Review on Morphology and Turbulence Characteristics in Meandering Rivers, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7001, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7001, 2022.

    EGU22-7850 | Presentations | SSS11.4

    Identification of erosion rills via machine learning 

    Adam Tejkl and Petr Kavka

    Water erosion is the physical wearing of the earth’s surface. Erosion removes surface soil material (topsoil), reduces levels of soil organic matter, and contributes to the breakdown of soil structure.

    The large amount of time required for manual identification of the rills is an obstacle in effective erosion research. Nevertheless, a significant number of rills have already been manually marked for various studies. It is therefore possible to use these already obtained data to train an algorithm, which will then automatically identify the grooves. The experiment is carried out using a rain simulator. The first part of the precipitation lasts 30 minutes, followed by a 15-minute break and another 30-minute precipitation. Photos for SfM method of creation detailed DMT are taken in three states a) before the simulation, b) between the simulations and c) after the experiment. On the finished DMT rills are manually digitalized in ArcGIS Pro, and their cover polygons are thus created.

    Nhu et al. 2020 in his work dealt with the evaluation of the capabilities of the Keras deep learning model and their optimization algorithms. Keras is a deep learning API written in Python, running on top of the machine learning platform TensorFlow.

    The image is converted to a matrix using the Raster to Array tool. The corresponding square is selected from each band and a mosaic is then created from these squares. The length of the square edge is chosen. The resulting mosaic consists of individual squares of the image spectrum bands placed side by side to form a rectangular image.

    The Kaggle Cat Dog model was used as the basis for creating the model. This is a model designed to sort color images into two groups. This model was modified by inserting mosaics into the model instead of images. The training dataset is loaded into the model and divided into calibration and validation parts for the purpose of model calibration. This distribution was chosen to be 20%. The image size was specified as 100x200 pixels, with pixel of size 0,1 cm.

    The individual mosaics not used for model training are then classified by this trained model. Loading mosaics for classification is controlled by a CSV file, which contains the name of the mosaic, the position of the mosaic in the image and whether it is intended for training or not. The probability value with which the mosaic is classified as erosive or not is then added to this CSV file. Training mosaics are omitted and assigned a no_data value.

    The CSV file of the classified image is loaded back into the GIS environment using a Python script. The script loads the CSV file and creates an according classified raster.

    The research is funded by the Technological Agency of the Czech Republic (research project SS01020366) and an internal student CTU grant (SGS20/156/OHK1/3T/11).

    How to cite: Tejkl, A. and Kavka, P.: Identification of erosion rills via machine learning, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7850, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7850, 2022.

    Soil erosion has environmental and socioeconomic significances. Most of the loess soils throughout the world are subjected to increased land uses such, which increased soil destruction and dust emission to the atmosphere. There is a distinguish interest in applications for dust control and soil stabilization. This study examines empirically the use of a metakaolin-based geopolymer for dust control and soil stabilization in a semi-arid loess soil that is subjected to land uses and erosional processes. The application of the geopolymer for dust control in comparison with common products (brine, bitumen, PVA) resulted with no soil erosion and dust emission by wind tunnel simulations. As a soil stabilizer, the geopolymer tested in this study provides remarkably good results in the tensile test. The most successful composition of the geopolymer, which is activation solution of sodium silicate and sodium hydroxide (NaOH) together with an addition of 30% metakaolin, obtained soil strength of 23900N after 28 days. The attempt to replace NaOH with lime (CaO) in the activation solution was far inferior to the original composition.

    How to cite: Katra, I.: A clay-based geopolymer in loess stabilization to water and wind soil erosion, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8329, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8329, 2022.

    EGU22-9688 | Presentations | SSS11.4

    Experimental wind erosion study in argan woodlands, badlands and wadis in the Souss-Massa Basin, Morocco 

    Miriam Marzen, Mario Kirchhoff, Irene Marzolff, Ali Aït Hssaine, and Johannes B. Ries

    The Souss-Massa basin features unique and centuries old human–environment interactions in a vulnerable arid ecosystem. A high pressure caused by intense agriculture combined with increasing water scarcity causes degradation of soils and vegetation cover. The test sites are located on alluvial fans from the flanking High Atlas Mountains in the north and the northern talus of the Anti Atlas in the south. Wind-tunnel tests were applied to investigate susceptibility to wind erosion from sparse argan forest, badland and wadi surfaces. The results show diverse potential for emission of coarser and finer mineral dust with highest values found on freshly tilled surfaces in the extensively managed argan forest and sandy wadi surfaces. For one tested wadi section, very erodible areas were found in close vicinity to areas with much lower sediment yield. The wind-erosion dynamics are thus closely related to fluvial processes previously influencing surface characteristics as well as previous sorting processes by wind impact. The strongly crusted surfaces attributed to badland environments are least susceptible to wind erosion, with the exception of higher emissions measured on the wadi rim.

    The data give insight into possible wind-erosion patterns under non-extreme wind regime and are a valuable basis for investigation of interactions between fluvial and aeolian processes in wadi structures.

    How to cite: Marzen, M., Kirchhoff, M., Marzolff, I., Aït Hssaine, A., and Ries, J. B.: Experimental wind erosion study in argan woodlands, badlands and wadis in the Souss-Massa Basin, Morocco, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9688, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9688, 2022.

    The phenomenon of multiphase splash can be a mechanism for transporting various types of pollution (e.g. petroleum substances), which makes it especially interesting in the context of environmental protection.

    In this paper, the water splash phenomenon caused by the impact of a petrol drop on the water surface was simulated using the multiphaseInterFoam solver, i.e. a part of the OpenFOAM computational fluid dynamics software implementing the finite volume method (FVM) for space discretization. The simulations were experimentally validated based on splash images obtained with the use of a high-speed camera (2800 fps). Several variants of simulations with a varying drop size (in 0.10-mm steps) or drop velocity (in 0.025-m/s steps) were conducted.

    Our experiments showed the importance of even a slight underestimation/overestimation of the properties of a falling drop on the simulation of the size and dynamics of splash in an immiscible liquid system. On the other hand, correct simulation made it possible to analyse aspects of the phenomenon that were difficult or even impossible to achieve experimentally due to the limitations of the image analysis method. This concerned the determination of the cavity width, the moment of cavity disappearance, the moment of jet formation (still below the water level), and the height of the jet. In addition, based on the validated simulation of splash in immiscible liquids, the scale of the spread of petroleum contamination as a result of the impact of a single droplet was determined.

    The study was partly funded by the National Science Centre (Poland), based on decision no. 2017/26/D/ST10/01026.

    How to cite: Sochan, A., Lamorski, K., and Bieganowski, A.: Effect of underestimation/overestimation of falling drop parameters on the result of splash simulation in an immiscible liquid system, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12186, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12186, 2022.

    EGU22-495 | Presentations | BG4.3

    Stream solutes respond differently within and across flow conditions: a comparison of baseflow and higher flow events 

    Katherine Pérez Rivera, Stephen Plont, Morgan Wood, Felicity DeToll, Barbara Niederlehner, Kristen Bretz, Carla López Lloreda, and Erin Hotchkiss

    Streams are dynamic ecosystems susceptible to frequent and long-term physical and chemical changes. Characterizing how solute concentrations change with hydrology is key to understanding solute sources, fate, and transport. Here we tested how solute concentrations respond to changes in flow in a stream draining a mixed land use catchment in Blacksburg, Virginia, USA. To do this, we measured how various solutes (i.e., DOC, DIN, Cl-, Na+, Mg+2, Ca+2, SO4-2, K+) changed within and across one baseflow period of 24 hours and three high flow events during summer 2021. Solutes concentration relationship with flow dynamics can result in different responses: (1) enrichment (increase in concentration), (2) dilution (decrease in concentration), or (3) chemostasis (no change in concentration). We found that, overall, solutes responded to changes in flow and the patterns observed for each flow event were variable, resulting in both dilution and enrichment. Discharge (Q) ranged from 0.04 - 3.37 m3/s during our 8-week sampling period. Dissolved organic carbon (DOC) and dissolved inorganic nitrogen (DIN) concentrations ranged from 2 - 5.7 and 0.23 - 0.94 mg/L, respectively. While DOC exhibited enrichment with increasing Q, DIN, Cl-, Na+, Mg+2, Ca+2, SO4-2, and K+ were mainly diluted during higher flows. However, during baseflow conditions the relationship between Q and solute concentrations was more pronounced (R2 >0.30), particularly for DIN and SO4-2 (dilution), and Cl- and Na+ (enrichment). During higher flows, we did not see a general dilution or enrichment pattern for all solutes but there were solute-specific behaviors which were similar among sampling periods. The differences in Q-solute dynamics among the 4 sampling events supports the enhancement of hydrological connectivity and landscape influence during changes in flow and how it can contribute to changes in solute concentration. Additionally, Q-solute patterns observed highlight the importance of time and sampling frequency to develop a well characterization of solute dynamics during changes in flow. Ongoing work is focused on understanding the directionality and timing of responses to further inform changes in solute concentrations during different flow events. Analyses of solute-specific behavior, timing of peak concentrations, and directionality will broaden our understanding of solute chemical dynamics and the different factors that contribute to the variable responses that have been found.

    How to cite: Pérez Rivera, K., Plont, S., Wood, M., DeToll, F., Niederlehner, B., Bretz, K., López Lloreda, C., and Hotchkiss, E.: Stream solutes respond differently within and across flow conditions: a comparison of baseflow and higher flow events, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-495, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-495, 2022.

    EGU22-1085 | Presentations | BG4.3

    Origin, accumulation and fate of dissolved organic matter in an extreme hypersaline shallow lake. 

    Andrea Butturini, Peter Herzsprung, Oliver Lechtenfeld, Paloma Alcorno, Robert Benaiges-Fernandez, Merce Berlanga, Judit Boadella, Zeus Freixinos Campillo, Rosa Gomez, Maria del Mar Sanchez-Montoya, Jordi Urmeneta, and Anna Romaní

    Hyper-Saline Endorheic Aquatic Systems (H-SEAS) are shallow lakes in arid and semiarid climatic zones that undergo to extreme oscillation in salinities and large drought episodes. Although their geochemical uniqueness and microbiome are deeply studied, very little is known about availability, transformation and fate of dissolved organic matter (DOM) in water column, interstitial waters and in salts that precipitate under driest conditions. To advance in this direction, a small hypersaline shallow lake from Monegros desert (Zaragoza, NE, Spain) has been studied during a complete hydrological wet-drough-rewetting transition. DOM analysis includes: i) a dissolved organic carbon (DOC) mass balance;  ii) optical spectroscopy (absorbance and fluorescence) characterization and; iii) molecular description by negative electrospray ionization Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry (FT-ICR-MS).

    The studied system stored large amount of DOC and the mass balance revealed that under highest salinity conditions, salt-saturated waters (i.e. brines, salinity >30%) accumulated a disproportionate quantity of DOC indicating a significant net in-situ DOM production. Simultaneously, during the hydrological transition from wet to drought, the DOM pool changed drastically its qualitative properties: thus, aromatic and humified moieties were rapidly replaced by fresher, relatively small size and microbial derived moieties with large C/N ratio. Further FT-ICR-MS highlight the accumulation of small-size, saturated and, highly oxidized molecules (O/C molar ratio >0.5) with a remarkable increase of relative contribution of sugar-like molecules and decrease of aliphatic and carboxyl-rich alicyclic like molecules. Overall, there results highlight that H-SEAS are extremely active in accumulating and processing DOM and, the observed patterns pointed to a notable release of organic solutes from decaying microplankton probably triggered by the osmotic stress under extremely high salinities.

     

    How to cite: Butturini, A., Herzsprung, P., Lechtenfeld, O., Alcorno, P., Benaiges-Fernandez, R., Berlanga, M., Boadella, J., Freixinos Campillo, Z., Gomez, R., Sanchez-Montoya, M. M., Urmeneta, J., and Romaní, A.: Origin, accumulation and fate of dissolved organic matter in an extreme hypersaline shallow lake., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1085, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1085, 2022.

    EGU22-2051 | Presentations | BG4.3

    High Arctic freshwaters as emitters of greenhouse gases 

    Nicolas Valiente, Andrea L. Popp, Peter Dörsch, Laurent Fontaine, Dag O. Hessen, Sigrid Trier Kjær, Anja Sundal, and Alexander Eiler

    Climate change is causing temperatures in the Arctic to rise faster than in any other region of the world. This rapid warming leads, among other effects, to the massive loss of ice masses, development of thermokarst features when permafrost thaws, intensification of the hydrological cycle, and increasing loads of nutrients and organic carbon to surface waters. Freshwaters are highly sensitive to these changes, which affect microbial community composition and diversity. Therefore, these ecosystems are good sentinels to study processes in primary ecological succession related to ecosystem processes such as productivity and greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. With this study, we aim to contribute to a deeper understanding of the linkages between biogeochemistry and hydrology in High Arctic freshwaters. To this end, we sampled various water sources (e.g., lakes and streams) in two High Arctic catchments (Bayelva and Lovénbreen, in Svalbard in July 2021) for the analysis of GHGs (CH4, CO2, N2O), noble gases (radon-222, argon-40), major ions, stable water isotopes (δD and δ18O) and nutrients (organic C, organic -P and organic -N). We used Ar-corrected gas saturation of each GHG as a proxy of net metabolic changes, while tracers such as stable water isotopes help to disentangle water source contributions. Our first results show that lakes and streams were oversaturated in CO2 as well as N2O but slightly undersaturated in O2, suggesting higher respiration activity than primary production. Our data also indicate a  strong oversaturation in CH4 in lakes, but not in streams. Moreover, we used microbial mineralization of organic matter as a proxy for GHG production. We found similar concentrations of total organic C and N in both lakes and streams and significantly higher concentrations of total P in streams than in lakes. This work furthers our knowledge of the current state of High Arctic freshwaters and helps to predict future effects of climate change impacts on GHG evasion.

    How to cite: Valiente, N., Popp, A. L., Dörsch, P., Fontaine, L., Hessen, D. O., Kjær, S. T., Sundal, A., and Eiler, A.: High Arctic freshwaters as emitters of greenhouse gases, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2051, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2051, 2022.

    EGU22-2148 | Presentations | BG4.3

    Long-term changes in dissolved inorganic carbon (DIC) across boreal streams caused by altered hydrology 

    Marcus Wallin, Lukas Rehn, Hjalmar Laudon, and Ryan Sponseller

    A major challenge for predicting future landscape carbon (C) balances is to understand how environmental changes affect the transfer of C from soils to surface waters. Here we evaluated 14 years (2006-2019) of data on stream dissolved inorganic carbon (DIC) concentrations and export rates for 14 nested boreal catchments that are subject to climatic changes, and compared long-term patterns in DIC with patterns in dissolved organic carbon (DOC). Few streams displayed significant concentration or export trends at annual time scales. However, a clear majority of streams showed decreasing DIC concentrations during spring flood, and about half showing declines during summer. Although annual runoff has generally not changed during the studied period, intra-annual redistribution in runoff explained much of the seasonal changes in stream DIC concentration. We observed negative DIC-discharge relationships in most streams, suggesting supply limitation of DIC with increasing discharge. This was in contrast to DOC, which mostly showed a chemostatic behaviour. The distinct trend patterns observed for DIC and DOC underpin intra-annual changes in the total C pool (DIC/DOC ratio) in most streams and reflect differences in how these C forms are produced and stored, are mobilized by hydrological events, and are responding to long-term environmental changes. Collectively, our results indicate that future changes in hydro-meteorological conditions will affect the transfer of DIC from soils to water, and that these changes contrast to those of DOC. Such information is critical for future projections on how total C transfer from boreal system will respond on a changing climate.

    How to cite: Wallin, M., Rehn, L., Laudon, H., and Sponseller, R.: Long-term changes in dissolved inorganic carbon (DIC) across boreal streams caused by altered hydrology, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2148, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2148, 2022.

    EGU22-2334 | Presentations | BG4.3

    Dissolved organic matter quality variations in drinking water reservoirs and their catchment waters – Scientific knowledge and research gaps 

    Peter Herzsprung, Wolf von Tümpling, Norbert Kamjunke, and Oliver J. Lechtenfeld

    Dissolved organic matter (DOM) is ubiquitous in aquatic systems. Discharge of DOM to reservoirs via shallow ground and surface waters from the catchment poses major problems for drinking water production. Knowledge had been generated about mobilization and discharge of DOM in catchments based on the bulk parameter dissolved organic carbon (DOC) (1-3) or on bulk optical parameters describing its quality (4). The decomposition of DOC in catchments and reservoir waters was reported using DOC, bulk optical and carbon isotope analysis (5, 6).

    For drinking water treatment, removal of humic substances by coagulation / flocculation and the formation of disinfection byproducts are the most pressing challenges. The treatment success depends strongly on the chemical quality of DOM, which probably consists of thousands or even millions of different molecules. The identification of the isomeric structure of each molecule is still far from any instrumental analytical realization. From the analytical point of view the highest resolution of DOM can be achieved by Fourier Transform-Ion Cyclotron Resonance Mass Spectroscopy (FTICR-MS). This analytical tool generates elemental compositions of thousands of DOM components which are water extractable (solid phase extractable DOM, SPE-DOM) and which are ionizable (electrospray ionization, ESI).

    Using FTICR-MS, knowledge has been generated about the formation potential of disinfection byproducts and its composition (7) and about the flocculation behavior as function of the raw water DOM quality (8).

    Only few knowledge exists about DOM quality variations in the reservoirs and their catchments based on sum formulas from FTICR-MS analysis (8 - 11). Also little is known about transformations of drinking water treatment relevant sub fractions within the complex DOM in catchments and reservoir waters.

    As a first result of FTICR-MS measurements we observed that few components (sum formulas) showed high abundance differences as function of depth during reservoir stratification. Some poly-phenol-like components (relevant for flocculation) declined in the epilimnion of a drinking water reservoir potentially due to photo degradation. Some of the (more aliphatic) photo products, which were enriched in the epilimnion, are suspected to be disinfection byproduct precursors. This knowledge can be used to investigate the adaptation of the raw water subtraction depth in the reservoir.

     

    1) Blaurock K et al., Hydrol. Earth Sys. Sci. Disc. (2021), https://doi.org/10.5194/hess

    2) Werner BJ et al., Biogeosci. (2019), 16, 4497-4516

    3) Musolff A et al., J. Hydrol. (2018), 566, 205-215

    4) Da Silva MP et al., Biogeosci. (2020), 17, 5355-5364

    5) Kamjunke N et al., Sci. Tot. Environ. (2016), 548-549, 51-59

    6) Morling K et al., Sci. Tot. Environ. (2017), 577, 329-339

    7) Phungsai P et al., Environ. Sci. Technol. (2018), 52, 3392-3401

    8) Raeke J et al., Wat. Res. (2017), 113, 149-159

    9) Da Silva MP et al., J. Geophys. Res. Biogeosci. (2021), 126, e2021JG006425

    10) Herzsprung P et al., Environ. Sci. Technol. (2020), 54, 13556-13565

    11) Wilske C et al., Water MDPI (2021), 13, 1703

    How to cite: Herzsprung, P., von Tümpling, W., Kamjunke, N., and Lechtenfeld, O. J.: Dissolved organic matter quality variations in drinking water reservoirs and their catchment waters – Scientific knowledge and research gaps, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2334, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2334, 2022.

    EGU22-5422 | Presentations | BG4.3

    Spatial variance in river bed methane cycling – measurement and interpretation of geochemical profiles linked with quantitative PCR and 16S rRNA sequencing 

    Tamara Michaelis, William Orsi, Anja Wunderlich, Thomas Baumann, and Florian Einsiedl

    Rivers and streams are often supersaturated in methane (CH4) and emit significant amounts of this potent greenhouse gas to the atmosphere. Methane is produced by methanogenic archaea in anaerobic sediments where energetically more favorable redox processes are substrate-limited. Diffusing up towards the sediment surface, methane can be oxidized in the hyporheic zone (HZ) aerobically with oxygen or anaerobically with nitrate, nitrite, sulfate or iron and manganese oxides as electron acceptors. Yet, knowledge about net carbon emissions from streams is restricted, because high spatial heterogeneities in production and consumption zones make bottom-up global estimations particularly challenging.

    In this study we want to increase process understanding of riverine methane cycling, in particular production and oxidation in hyporheic stream sediments. Several studies have investigated predictors for potential methane production and oxidation in river sediments using incubation experiments. We chose a different approach by measuring high-resolution depth-dependent geochemical profiles at five different locations across a stream bed. An in-situ equilibrium dialysis sampler (peeper) was used to obtain pore-water samples with a 1 cm depth-resolution for the measurement of dissolved oxygen, relevant anion and cation concentrations as well as methane concentrations and stable carbon isotopes (δ13C) of methane. In the methanogenic zone stable carbon isotopes may provide information about the most relevant methane production pathway, while an isotopic enrichment in δ13C-CH4 towards the sediment surface linked with decreasing methane concentrations may indicate microbial degradation. Production and oxidation rates were estimated using inverse numerical modeling of measured concentration gradients. Additionally, the concentration of 16S rRNA genes (a measure of bacteria biomass) was quantified from one of the locations using quantitative PCR, which revealed an increase in microbial biomass at the nitrate-methane transition zone.  Sequencing of the 16S rRNA genes shows clear shifts in microorganisms driving the streambed methane cycle at and below the nitrate-methane transition zone.

    The measured δ13C-CH4 values between -75 ‰ and -70 ‰ indicate that hydrogenotrophic methanogenesis is the dominant production pathway. However, we found that methane fluxes into the surface water were low. Mainly responsible for a strong decrease in methane concentrations towards the sediment surface were most likely diffusive processes. Decreasing methane concentrations linked with a significant enrichment in δ13C towards heavier isotopes was only observed at one of the sampling locations. The isotopic shift together with modeling results and microbiological analyses may reveal microbially driven aerobic and anaerobic methane oxidation in the HZ, but in most locations methane is only oxidized at low rates where the environment is already methane depleted by diffusion. Limiting for both aerobic and anaerobic methane oxidation was supposedly the low methane concentration in zones with available electron acceptors.

    How to cite: Michaelis, T., Orsi, W., Wunderlich, A., Baumann, T., and Einsiedl, F.: Spatial variance in river bed methane cycling – measurement and interpretation of geochemical profiles linked with quantitative PCR and 16S rRNA sequencing, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5422, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5422, 2022.

    EGU22-5476 | Presentations | BG4.3

    The impact of reservoir on downstream water quality and pCO2: a case study in Seine Basin, France 

    Xingcheng Yan, Vincent Thieu, and Josette Garnier

    The impact of reservoirs on downstream water quality has received widespread attention, but most current studies are based on short-term data only, and less attention has been paid to the impact of reservoirs on downstream carbon dioxide (CO2) concentrations. In the present study, we assessed the nutrient budgets (DIN: dissolved inorganic nitrogen, PO43-: orthophosphate, DSi: dissolved silica) of the reservoirs (Marne, Aube, Seine, and Pannecière reservoirs) in the Seine Basin using long-term dataset (1998-2018), and we also evaluated the reservoir effect on downstream partial pressure of carbon dioxide (pCO2) based on field measurements during 2019-2020. The mean annual retention rates accounted for 16%-53%, 26%-48%, and 22%-40%of the inputs of DIN, PO43-, and DSi in the four reservoirs during the period 1998 to 2018, respectively, showing that the four reservoirs play important roles in nutrient retentions. We further identified that three reservoirs (Marne, Aube, and Seine reservoirs) significantly changed downstream water quality during the emptying period, increasing the concentrations of dissolved organic carbon (DOC) and biodegradable DOC, while lowering the concentrations of DIN, DSi, PO43-, and total alkalinity. Interestingly, we found that the three reservoirs notably decreased downstream pCO2(24%-37%) and enhanced the gas transfer coefficient of CO2 (21%) in downstream rivers compared to the upstream ones, during the emptying period, which highlights the necessity to consider the potential impact of reservoirs on downstream riverine not only for water quality variables, but also for CO2 emissions. Finally, the findings of this study highlight the importance of the combination of biogeochemical and hydrological characteristics to understand the biogeochemical functioning of reservoirs to downstream rivers.

    How to cite: Yan, X., Thieu, V., and Garnier, J.: The impact of reservoir on downstream water quality and pCO2: a case study in Seine Basin, France, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5476, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5476, 2022.

    EGU22-5655 | Presentations | BG4.3

    Spatial and temporal changes of dissolved and particular organic carbon in Iceland glaciers and glacier-fed streams 

    Peter Chifflard, Martin Reiss, Lukas Ditzel, Kyle S. Boodoo, and Christina Fasching

    Glaciers are unique ecosystems with the potential to affect the aquatic carbon cycle, accumulating and releasing organic carbon (OC). OC stored in glaciers may be released as dissolved and particulate OC (DOC and POC), primarily via meltwater at the glacier’s surface into glacier-fed streams. Current global projections indicate an export of 78 Tg POC by 2050, representing more than double the DOC export (32.4 Tg DOC) predicted for the same period. However, POC data for glacier runoff is very limited and existing predictions are primarily based on an integrated approach, using single ice sampling points and mass balances to calculate an average annual export of glacier derived DOC. But this mass balance approach does not account for potential seasonal changes in OC, and may therefore not accurately reflect glacial OC export rates. Additionally, Icelandic glaciers are not included in global predictions of OC export, which is surprising as the largest nonpolar ice cap of Europe (Vatnajökull) is located in Iceland.

    Therefore, we analyzed the concentration of DOC and POC, as well as its optical properties (absorbance and fluorescence) in glaciers and glacier-fed streams of Iceland. Sampling points covered ice samples from several glaciers of the Icelandic ice caps Vatnajökull, Langjökull, Hofsjökull, Myrdalsjökull, and Snaefellsjökull (110 ice samples) and water samples of the corresponding glacier-fed rivers (300 water samples) at the glacier termini. The majority of these sampling points were sampled seasonally (winter, spring, summer, autumn) and two times per day to cover temporal changes.

    First results show, that DOC and POC concentrations in glacier-fed streams were found to range from 0.03 mg l-1 to 20.1 mg l-1, and from 0.1 mg l-1 to 33.0 mg l-1, respectively, whereas DOC and POC concentrations in glacier ice were found to range from 0.09 mg l-1 to 2.24 mg l-1, and from 0.3 mg l-1 to 39.4 mg l-1, respectively. Based on optical properties, we found that DOM is more proteinaceous and of recent origin (fresher) in summer and autumn. In contrast, DOM is more refractory with a higher contribution of a humic-like component in winter and spring. Based on the concentrations in glacier-fed streams we estimate an annual release of 0.032 Tg C yr-1 (DOC) and 0.128 Tg C yr-1 (POC) from Icelandic glaciers, assuming a mean glacier runoff of 1,500 m³ s-1 from the glaciers, and using the mean concentration of DOC and POC from our seasonal sampling points directly at the glacier terminus. If the annual release of DOC is weighted by the glaciated area of Iceland (11,060 km²), the calculated value is 0.0029 Gg C yr-1 km-², clearly exceeding the area-weighted estimations of the Greenland Ice Sheet and the European Alps (0.0002 Gg C yr-1 km-² each).

    Here for the first time, we analyzed the concentration of DOC and POC as well as its optical properties in proglacial streams of Iceland, location of Europe’s largest nonpolar ice cap, and thus established a comprehensive basis for improved prediction of global export of OC from glaciers.

    How to cite: Chifflard, P., Reiss, M., Ditzel, L., Boodoo, K. S., and Fasching, C.: Spatial and temporal changes of dissolved and particular organic carbon in Iceland glaciers and glacier-fed streams, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5655, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5655, 2022.

    Preserving the health of estuarine ecosystems has been an increasing challenge in the recent past with the spreading of areas affected by deep-water hypoxic conditions. Hence, it is of critical importance to identify the causes of such perturbation, triggered by changing ocean circulation and increasing inputs of organic matter (OM), which results in serious threats to living species. Estuaries are large deposition centers for organic matter (OM) where stable carbon isotope ratios of either bulk OM or specific organic compounds provide detailed information about carbon cycling and the tracing of OM sources and transformations along the terrestrial-marine continuum. In particular, the ∂13C values of biomarkers that are specific to heterotrophic bacteria (branched iso- and anteiso-C15:0 fatty acids) can be used to assess the type of OM that they preferentially degrade as the ∂13C values of marine organic carbon (OC) are more enriched in 13C than those of terrestrial OC. However, very little is known on the dynamics between the seasonally varying relative inputs of terrestrial vs. marine OM and the ∂13C values of these bacteria-specific fatty acids. In this study, we will use a kinetic batch incubation approach in which natural sediments from the St. Lawrence Estuary and Gulf, amended with fresh terrestrial or marine OM characterized by a very different 13C/12C ratio (difference of between 10 and 14 ‰ depending on the sampling station), will be incubated for varying amounts of time. Quenching of the incubations followed by the extraction, quantification and isotopic characterization of the bacterial fatty acids will allow determining the rate and temporal extent of change of their compound-specific ∂13C values. Bulk elemental (OC and total nitrogen) and isotopic (∂13C and ∂15N) mass balances will be precisely monitored throughout the experiment. Acquisition of this knowledge, combined with results from other studies carried out in our lab, will provide a better understanding of the relative importance of terrestrial and marine OM processing in the onset of hypoxia and will be exploited as a guide for remedial efforts aiming to improve the health of such an important ecosystem.

    How to cite: Mirzaei, Y. and Gelinas, Y.: Exploring the Bacterial Preference for Terrestrial or Marine Organic Matter in Estuarine Sediments Using Compound Specific Stable Carbon Isotope Ratios: A Degradation Kinetics Study, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5896, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5896, 2022.

    As the largest semi-enclosed estuarine system in the world, the St. Lawrence Estuary and Gulf is an ecosystem rich in natural resources and very important in terms of biodiversity, as well as economic, transportation and recreational activities. Since the beginning of the industrialization of the St. Lawrence Valley, this aquatic system has been threatened by human activities resulting in increased industrial and agricultural pollution, eutrophication (nutrient enrichment), biodiversity loss, and landscape deterioration, culminating in the depletion of dissolved oxygen in its bottom waters (hypoxia). Deep water hypoxia conditions have been steadily worsening in the past 80 years, reaching dissolved O2concentrations has low as 35 µM in the fall of 2021. Hypoxia in this system is fueled by changes in oceanic circulation in the North Atlantic as well as by an increase in the water column flux of organic matter (OM) either discharged by the St. Lawrence River and other tributaries (terrestrial OM), or produced in the surface waters from discharged and upwelled nutrients (marine OM). The consumption of the more labile OM components of this sedimenting OM by aerobic heterotrophic bacteria results in sustained pressure on dissolved O2 concentrations and the accumulation of the more recalcitrant fraction of this OM. As cold temperate estuarine systems such as the St. Lawrence are characterized by large seasonal variations in riverine discharge rates and in situ primary production, mineralization of the more recalcitrant sedimentary OM components should be strongly modulated by the priming effect resulting from sudden influxes of fresh and more labile OM. In this study, we will attempt to quantify the priming effect in this system using elemental (organic carbon and total nitrogen) and isotopic (∂13C and ∂15N) mass balances, as well as compound specific stable carbon isotope analysis of the bacterial fatty acids iso- and anteiso-C15:0. We will use a batch incubation approach in which natural sediments from the St. Lawrence Estuary and Gulf will be amended with fresh terrestrial or marine OM characterized by a very different 13C/12C ratio (difference of between 10 and 14 depending on the sampling station). Quenching of the incubations followed by the extraction, quantification and isotopic characterization of the bacterial fatty acids will allow determining the effect of labile OM on the mineralization of recalcitrant OM in this system. Acquisition of this knowledge, combined with results from other studies carried out in our lab, will provide a better understanding of the relative importance of terrestrial and marine OM processing in the onset of hypoxia and will be exploited as a guide for remedial efforts aiming to improve the health of such an important ecosystem.

    How to cite: Radu, M.-E. and Gelinas, Y.: The Priming Effect in Sediments of a Cold Temperate Estuarine System: An Assessment Using Compound Specific Stable Carbon Isotope Ratios Measurements on Bacterial Fatty Acids, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6033, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6033, 2022.

    EGU22-7365 | Presentations | BG4.3

    Transformations of C, N, P in lotic-lentic transition 

    Petr Porcal and Tanja Shabarova

    The transformation of organic matter in lentic and lotic conditions are dominated by different processes. The special attention deserves the transition from riverine to lacustrine conditions. In our experiment we incubated the stream and pond water inside of mesocosms in the small forest ponds for 28 days. That time was previously observed as sufficient for the reestablishing of chemical and biological processes after severe rain events in the same pond. We aimed to evaluate the dynamics in organic matter, nitrogen, and phosphorus concentrations, fractioning between particulate and dissolved forms, as well as the development of microbial community. Additionally, we tested the influence of presence and absence of solar radiation in one experiment and the effect of different transparency of surrounding environment. The observed changes in C, N, and P fluxes were simulated by the first order kinetics model. The slowest processes were observed in dark mesocosms with the highest initial color and organic carbon content, while the light exposed and less colorful mesocosms revealed fastest rates.

    How to cite: Porcal, P. and Shabarova, T.: Transformations of C, N, P in lotic-lentic transition, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7365, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7365, 2022.

    EGU22-7419 | Presentations | BG4.3

    Sediment phosphorus stock shows a shift at the river – floodplain interface, accompanied by high vegetation biodiversity 

    Matthias Pucher, Elisabeth Bondar-Kunze, and Thomas Hein

    Floodplains can contribute enormously to nutrient reduction in streams. The phosphorus cycle at the aquatic–terrestrial interface is driven by hydrology and vegetation. Our aim was to assess conditions relevant to the phosphorus cycle prior to a floodplain restoration. The phosphorus cycle was studied by means of measuring several phosphorus fractions and adsorption/desorption experiments using floodplain soil and river sediment. The study area was located at the Mulde River near Dessau, Germany, and covered different inundation patterns, vegetation and reaches with or without embankment. A shoreline ecotone was identified by means of high vegetation biodiversity with a distinct plant community. In the ecotone, the P cycle was influenced by accumulation of relatively high bioavailable P in the soil (equilibrium phosphate concentration, EPC0) and reduction of the soluble reactive phosphorus (SRP) concentration in the pore water. Both suggested a high productivity of the vegetation. The ecotone also acted as a delineation between the stream sediments with low organic matter and inorganic P and the floodplain soil with high organic matter and inorganic P. Additionally, the study demonstrated a lower SRP concentration and EPC0 in the parts of the floodplain without bank fortification.

    Since floodplains were considered ecotones before, we identified another ecotone at another scale, i.e. between floodplain and river. The ecotone does not only show the area with a favourable ratio of disturbance and resource availability but also acts as a location for biogeochemical exchange processes between rivers and floodplains. The identified shoreline ecotone offered a habitat for a specifically diverse vegetation, which itself influenced the P cycle by high biological turnover. As a highly biogeochemically active part of the floodplain, the shoreline ecotone could help in mitigating high nutrient loads in anthropogenically impacted water sheds and provide a habitat for diverse vegetation.

    How to cite: Pucher, M., Bondar-Kunze, E., and Hein, T.: Sediment phosphorus stock shows a shift at the river – floodplain interface, accompanied by high vegetation biodiversity, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7419, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7419, 2022.

    EGU22-7444 | Presentations | BG4.3

    Drivers of spatial and temporal variability of dissolved organic matter across the terrestrial−aquatic continuum 

    Stephan Krüger, Klaus Kaiser, Stefan Julich, Ingo Müller, and Karsten Kalbitz

    Dissolved organic matter (DOM) is an important component in carbon and nutrient cycles in terrestrial and aquatic ecosystems. For three decades, concentrations of dissolved organic carbon (DOC) have been increasing in European and North American surface water bodies. The increase has been mainly attributed to export of DOC from terrestrial ecosystems. Depending on the hydrological regime in a catchment (stormflow vs. baseflow conditions), the flow pathways through different soil horizons are varying and in result, the drivers determining the amount and chemical composition DOM vary as well. By studying soil water and surface water at the catchment scale, we aim at identifying the main sources and environmental conditions driving the ongoing trend of increasing DOM in aquatic ecosystems.

    To understand the spatial and temporal variations of the export of DOM from soils to surface waters the catchment of the drinking water reservoir Sosa in the Ore Mountains (Germany) is instrumented and monitored along the terrestrial−aquatic continuum for 1 ½ years. We installed plate lysimeters and suction cups to collect soil water at three soil depths, including topsoil organic and subsoil mineral horizons at four different sites (peatland, degraded peatland, cambisol and podzol) representing the potential terrestrial DOM sources within the catchment. In addition, two tributaries of the reservoir were equipped with fluorescence-based probes to continuously monitor DOC. Water samples were taken fortnightly and event-based during heavy rain and snowmelt. All soil and stream water samples were analyzed for DOC, dissolved organic nitrogen (DON), as well as inorganic cations and anions. To identify possible DOM sources, the DOM composition of all samples was additionally analyzed by fluorescence spectroscopy (Excitation-Emission-Matrices – EEMs).

    We found the different soils contributed differently to the aquatic DOM, depending on seasons and hydrological conditions. The highest DOC concentrations in the organic layer and upper mineral horizon of the podzol did not correspond with high average DOC concentrations in the stream. However, the stream affected by the peatland had much higher DOC concentrations. All organic topsoil horizons had low DOC concentrations in winter and high concentrations in summer, but only streams fed by peat soils followed this pattern. During stormflow events (snowmelt and strong rainfall), both monitored streams showed DOC concentrations 5 to 6 times higher than the average, illustrating the large potential of all soils (i.e. peatlands, cambisols, podzols) for DOM export. The DOC:DON ratios clearly reflect the differences in DOM composition of the different soils, with high proportions of plant-derived DOM in soil water and the corresponding streams. In conclusion, our research indicates that organic soils, such as peatlands, contribute most to stream DOM under baseflow conditions, while under high-flow conditions, as during snowmelt or rainstorms, mineral soils become additional strong DOM sources. Ongoing analyses of the DOM composition will provide further insights into specific DOM sources and the related spatial and temporal variations of DOM export from soils to surface waters.

    How to cite: Krüger, S., Kaiser, K., Julich, S., Müller, I., and Kalbitz, K.: Drivers of spatial and temporal variability of dissolved organic matter across the terrestrial−aquatic continuum, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7444, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7444, 2022.

    EGU22-7981 | Presentations | BG4.3

    Sulphide stimulates nitrate reduction in benthic diatoms from a microbial mat 

    Elisa Merz, Gregory J. Dick, Dirk de Beer, Gaute Lavik, Hannah K. Marchant, and Judith M. Klatt

    Diatoms are among the few eukaryotes known to store nitrate (NO3) and to use it for dissimilatory nitrate/nitrite reduction to ammonium (DNRA) to generate enegry in the absence of light and O2. We used stable isotope incubations and in situ microsensor measurements over complete light cycles to study the diel activity transitions of the NO3-storing benthic diatom Craticula cuspidata in the submerged Middle Island Sinkhole, Lake Huron (USA). We found that this diatom links NO3 respiration to diel migration into deep (~4 cm) sulfidic sediments below the microbial mat. This pattern was accompanied by pronounced diel changes in the depth of sulphide consumption. During the day sulphide was consumed by anoxygenic photosynthesis and aerobic sulphide oxidation in the uppermost few mm. Surprisingly, the consumption zone moved downward in the evening and was deepest in the sediment at night. Thus, the sulphide consumption zone strikingly overlapped with the depth of DNRA-performing diatom residence. Using an enrichment of Craticula cuspidata, we found that the nitrate respiration via DNRA was ~10-fold higher in the presence of sulphide. Overall, our data therefore indicate that C. cuspidata and/or their microbiome link NO3 reduction to sulphide oxidation.

    How to cite: Merz, E., Dick, G. J., de Beer, D., Lavik, G., Marchant, H. K., and Klatt, J. M.: Sulphide stimulates nitrate reduction in benthic diatoms from a microbial mat, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7981, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7981, 2022.

    EGU22-7985 | Presentations | BG4.3

    Improving lignin quantification and characterization in seawater using spectral liquid chromatography and PARAFAC2 

    Anders Dalhoff Bruhn, Urban Wünsch, Christopher Lee Osburn, and Colin Andrew Stedmon

    Lignin, a macromolecule found in all vascular plants, can be used as a biomarker for terrestrial dissolved organic matter in the ocean. Measuring lignin in the ocean can help us quantify the supply to and fate of terrestrial carbon in the ocean. Lignin analyses in aquatic samples quantify phenolic products after cupric oxidation using gas or liquid chromatography, with detection either by mass spectrometry or UV-Vis spectroscopy. Mass spectrometry yields low detection limits and high specificity, but requires specialized and expensive instrumentation. In contrast, liquid chromatography coupled with UV-Vis spectroscopy is more readily available and cheaper to operate, but traditionally suffers from lower specificity due to overlapping signals of the bulk organic matter background.

    This study demonstrates a new approach of UV-Vis spectroscopic detection coupled to high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) that circumvents common issues and improves the detection limit by a factor of 10. This improvement is accomplished by using the second derivative of the chromatogram and applying a modified parallel factor analysis (PARAFAC2). PARAFAC2 tolerates subtle remaining chromatogram shifts in retention time between samples and successfully separates spectra of co-eluting signals. The isolation of spectra based on this machine learning approach improves both lignin phenol identification and the accuracy of their quantification. The approach developed automates the analysis of chromatograms and considerably reduces the water volumes required, improving the applicability of HPLC-UV-Vis for lignin characterization, which may increase the feasibility for widespread use.

    How to cite: Bruhn, A. D., Wünsch, U., Osburn, C. L., and Stedmon, C. A.: Improving lignin quantification and characterization in seawater using spectral liquid chromatography and PARAFAC2, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7985, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7985, 2022.

    EGU22-9071 | Presentations | BG4.3

    The influence of river morphology on nitrogen retention at river network scale in the agricultural Bode River, Germany 

    Michael Rode, Xiangqian Zhou, Seifeddine Jomaa, and Xiaoqiang Yang

    European Water Framework Directive (WFD) reported that river morphological alteration and diffuse pollution are two dominant pressures of European water bodies at the catchment scale. To achieve good status targeted by WFD, river restoration has received increasing attention. However, less is known about the spatial and temporal effects of stream morphologic characteristics (i.e., meandering, stream order) on instream nitrate retention at the river network scale. The objective of this study is to explore the relationship between in-stream nitrate retention and stream geomorphologic characteristics (sinuosity, width and order) and to assess the effect of natural river conditions on in-stream nitrate retention. Therefore, we implemented a grid-based nitrate catchment model (mHM-Nitrate, Yang et al. 2018) in the Bode catchment (3200 km2) in central Germany, which offers comprehensive long-term and high-frequency data at several water quality gauge stations for model calibration and validation. We evaluated two alternative empirical approaches to quantify in-stream denitrification (based on denitrification velocity and denitrification rate constant, respectively) and conducted scenario analysis on more natural morphological stream conditions by increasing the river sinuosity according to its relationship with stream power.  Results showed that the model well captured the dynamics of daily discharge and nitrate concentration, with Nash-Sutcliffe Efficiency ≥ 0.87 for discharge and Kling-Gupta Efficiency ≥ 0.59 for nitrate concentration from 2015-2018. In-stream retention (including assimilatory uptake and denitrification) by the whole river network accounted for 3.5% and 35.9% of total nitrate loadings in winter and summer, respectively. The summer in-stream denitrification rate was two times higher in the lowland arable area than in the mountain forest area (225.1 and 68.8 mg N m-2 d-1, respectively). Similarly, summer in-stream assimilatory uptake was five times higher in the lowland arable area than the mountain forest area (167.9 and 27.2 mg N m-2 d-1, respectively). The model scenario representing more natural river network conditions by restoring the river sinuosity can lead to an additional nitrate loading reduction of 20% in 6th order stream network in summer. Our results show that the renaturation of streams can increase nitrate retention in flowing water, with efficiency increasing significantly with decreasing runoff. However, a significant reduction in the nitrate concentration remains limited to the growing season, especially in summer.

    Yang, X., Jomaa, S., Zink, M., Fleckenstein, J. H., Borchardt, D., Rode, M. (2018): A New Fully Distributed Model of Nitrate Transport and Removal at Catchment Scale. Water Resources Research, 54 (8) 5856.

    How to cite: Rode, M., Zhou, X., Jomaa, S., and Yang, X.: The influence of river morphology on nitrogen retention at river network scale in the agricultural Bode River, Germany, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9071, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9071, 2022.

    EGU22-9256 | Presentations | BG4.3

    Carbon dioxide dynamics in a boreal forest ditch affected by clear-cut forestry 

    Alberto Zannella, Karin Eklöf, Hjalmar Laudon, Eliza Maher Hasselquist, and Marcus Wallin

    Boreal water courses are large emitters of carbon dioxide (CO2) to the atmosphere. In Sweden, a high share of these water courses are man-made ditches, created to improve drainage and increase forest productivity. Previous studies from boreal regions have mainly suggested that terrestrial sources sustain the CO2 in these ditches and with variability in hydrology as the main temporal control. However, few studies have quantified ditch CO2 dynamics in harvested catchments. An altered hydrology, increased nutrient export and light availability upon forest harvest are all factors that potentially can change the main source control. Thus, there is a strong need to better understand how clear-cut forestry affects the ditch CO2 dynamics in boreal regions.

    Here, high-frequency (30 min) CO2 concentration dynamics together with other hydro-chemical variables were studied in a forest ditch draining a fully harvested catchment in the Trollberget Experimental Area, northern Sweden. Data were collected during the snow-free season from May to October. Ditch CO2 concentrations displayed a clear seasonal pattern with higher CO2 during summer than in spring and autumn. Concentrations were ranging from 0.41 to 3.99 mg C L-1 (median: 1.69 mg C L-1, corresponding to partial pressures (pCO2) of 2553 μatm, IQR = 1.08 mg C L-1). Strong diel cycles in CO2 were developed during early summer, with daily amplitudes in the CO2 reaching up to 2.1 mg C L-1. These daily cycles in CO2 were likely driven by aquatic primary production consuming CO2 during daytime. In addition, individual high-flow events in response to rainfall had a major influence on the ditch CO2 dynamics with generally a diluting effect, but the strength in the CO2-discharge relationship varied among seasons and between events. It was evident from the study that growing season CO2 dynamics in forest ditches affected by clear-cut forestry are high and controlled by a combination of hydrological and biological factors. These high dynamics and the associated controls need to be considered when scaling ditch CO2 emissions across boreal landscapes affected by clear-cut forestry.

    How to cite: Zannella, A., Eklöf, K., Laudon, H., Maher Hasselquist, E., and Wallin, M.: Carbon dioxide dynamics in a boreal forest ditch affected by clear-cut forestry, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9256, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9256, 2022.

    EGU22-9273 | Presentations | BG4.3

    Disentangling in-stream nitrate uptake pathways based on two-station high-frequency monitoring in high-order streams 

    Xiaolin Zhang, Xiaoqiang Yang, Bobby Hensley, Andreas Lorke, and Michael Rode

    Stream and river systems are an important compartment of nitrogen (N) transport and retention from terrestrial landscape to marine ecosystems. In-stream nitrate uptake in rivers involves complex assimilatory and dissimilatory pathways, which often exhibit spatiotemporal variability due to stream hydraulic, biotic (e.g., phytoplankton and periphyton) and abiotic (e.g., temperature and light availability) variations. Two-station based multi-parameter high-frequency monitoring allows quantitative disentangling of multi-path nitrate uptake dynamics at the reach scale. However, such monitoring and analysis are still limited to few small river types (e.g., headwaters and spring-fed rivers) and have not been well explored in higher order streams with varying hydro-morphological and biogeochemical conditions. Here, we conducted the two-station high-frequency monitoring in five high-order stream reaches in central Germany (i.e., two in the 4th order Weiße Elster River and three in the 6th order Bode River). Two-station 15-min time series of nitrate-N and dissolved oxygen were used to calculate the N mass balance and whole-stream metabolism, respectively. The mass-balance based net nitrate uptake rates (UNET) differed between reaches with contrasting morphology (e.g., 13.8±3.85 mg N h-1 in the more natural Weiße Elster compared to 2.05±0.83 mg N h-1 in the modified reach of Bode), as well as between different periods in the same reach (e.g., higher in post-wet period than in dry period). The measured GPP and the related autotrophic nitrate assimilation (UA) were determined by seasonal-varying radiation and riparian-canopy shading conditions. Heterotrophic N uptake (UD), including denitrification and heterotrophic assimilation, was further disentangled as the difference between UNET and UA. This rarely reported uptake pathway showed relatively higher values than UA, especially during late spring periods; moreover, it exhibited obvious diel signals that are significantly negatively correlated with DO. We further summarized difficulties and cautious considerations in conducting such two-station monitoring campaign at larger reach scales. In conclusion, benefiting from the less labor-consuming and high-frequency sensor monitoring, the two-station methods for N mass balance and stream metabolism can be applied at larger reach scales, and can well disentangle the multiple N uptake pathways that often exhibit high spatiotemporal heterogeneity.

    How to cite: Zhang, X., Yang, X., Hensley, B., Lorke, A., and Rode, M.: Disentangling in-stream nitrate uptake pathways based on two-station high-frequency monitoring in high-order streams, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9273, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9273, 2022.

    EGU22-9455 | Presentations | BG4.3

    Coastal Blue Carbon Storage, Sources and Accumulation in Gautami-Godavari (Coringa) Mangrove sediments 

    Karuna rao, Tim jennerjahn, Ramanathan al, and Raju nj

    The mangrove ecosystem is an important natural sink of carbon owing to its potential to accumulate and store large amounts of organic carbon, in particular in its anaerobic sediments. To better understand the role of and quantify this carbon sink, the present study measured organic carbon stocks, carbon accumulation rates, and organic matter sources in the sediments of the Gautami-Godavari (Coringa) mangrove ecosystem, Andhra Pradesh, India. The carbon and nitrogen stable isotopic composition and elemental ratios of total organic carbon (TOC) to total nitrogen (TN) have been used to detect the sedimentary organic matter sources in the Coringa mangrove complex. 210Pb isotopes have been used to determine the sedimentation rates and carbon accumulation rates. The value of ∂13C ranges from -17.8‰ and -26.1‰ with an average value of -23.3‰ and TOC/TN ranges from 9-27 with an average value of 15. The spatial variation of all sedimentary parameters i.e., TOC, TN, ∂13C, and ∂15N is found to be significant at various sites. Both Sedimentary Carbon Stock and Carbon Accumulation Rates also have significant spatial variation among different sites and their values are maximum in an area where mangroves are directly affected by aquaculture effluents. The lowest carbon stock has been observed in an area where mangroves are degraded. The scatter plot between δ13C and TOC/TN ratio reveals that most of the sedimentary organic matter originated from non-mangrove sources like algae, phytobenthos, and suspended particulate matter.

    How to cite: rao, K., jennerjahn, T., al, R., and nj, R.: Coastal Blue Carbon Storage, Sources and Accumulation in Gautami-Godavari (Coringa) Mangrove sediments, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9455, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9455, 2022.

    EGU22-9757 | Presentations | BG4.3

    Solid-phase extraction of aquatic organic matter: loading-dependent chemical fractionation and self-assembly 

    Xianyu Kong, Thomas Jendrossek, Kai-Uwe Ludwichowski, Ute Marx, and Boris Koch

    Dissolved organic matter (DOM) is an important component in marine and freshwater environments and plays a fundamental role in global biogeochemical cycles. In the past, optical and molecular-level analytical techniques evolved and improved our mechanistic understanding about DOM fluxes. For most molecular chemical techniques, sample desalting and enrichment is a prerequisite. Solid-phase extraction (SPE) has been widely applied for concentrating and desalting DOM. The major aim of this study was to constrain the influence of sorbent loading on the composition of DOM extracts. Here we show that increased loading resulted in reduced extraction efficiencies of dissolved organic carbon (DOC), fluorescence and absorbance, and polar organic substances. Loading-dependent optical and chemical fractionation induced by altered adsorption characteristics of the sorbent surface (PPL) and increased multilayer adsorption (DOM self-assembly) can fundamentally affect biogeochemical interpretations, such as the source of organic matter. Online fluorescence monitoring of the permeate flow allowed to empirically model the extraction process, and to assess the degree of variability introduced by changing the sorbent loading in the extraction procedure. Our study emphasizes that it is crucial for sample comparison to keep the relative DOC loading (DOCload [wt%]) on the sorbent always similar to avoid chemical fractionation.

    How to cite: Kong, X., Jendrossek, T., Ludwichowski, K.-U., Marx, U., and Koch, B.: Solid-phase extraction of aquatic organic matter: loading-dependent chemical fractionation and self-assembly, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9757, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9757, 2022.

    EGU22-9904 | Presentations | BG4.3

    Linking the carbon and sulfur cycles in a historically brackish diked peatland: Stable Isotopes and FT-ICR-MS 

    Mary Zeller, Cátia von Ahn, Anna-Kathrina Jenner, Erwin Racasa, Amy McKenna, Manon Janssen, and Michael Böttcher

    Here we report on the porewater dissolved organic matter dynamics and underlying benthic biogeochemical processes in a historically brackish, diked, peatland located along the Baltic Sea in northeastern Germany.  The regeneration process of the “Heiligensee and Hütelmoor” includes a return of freshwater inputs as well as increased connection to the sea.  For porewater observations, two stationary multiport (about 0.5 m intervals) lances are located in the coastal sediments coastward of the sand-dune dyke, reaching down to ~5 meters through permeable sediments and peat layers.  Frequent sampling of these porewater lances indicates substantial influences by fresh submarine ground water discharge in the middle depths.  Therefore, we studied the impact by mixing of these groundwater (as, for example, a source of Fe, DOM, DIC, P, Ca) with saltwater (a source of SO4 to fuel sulfate reduction) and the role of organic matter in the drowned peat layers.  We were particularly interested in the sulfurization of DOM, as biogenic sulfide can react both with Fe and DOM/POM.  Samples for a suite of analyses were taken in November 2020.  Characterizations included dissolved organic matter (21T FT-ICR-MS, National High Magnetic Field Laboratory), major and trace elements (ICP-OES), nutrient and sulfide concentration, as well as stable isotopes of sulfate, DIC, and water. Results are compared to nearby groundwater wells (a coastal sandy aquifer, a coastal peat layer, and an inland well), the brackish Baltic Sea and  the Hütelmoor surface waters, as well as the river Warnow.  Thus, we characterize the endmembers as well as the mixing zones in order to understand their influence on the chemical alterations of dissolved organic matter in this dynamic region.

    How to cite: Zeller, M., von Ahn, C., Jenner, A.-K., Racasa, E., McKenna, A., Janssen, M., and Böttcher, M.: Linking the carbon and sulfur cycles in a historically brackish diked peatland: Stable Isotopes and FT-ICR-MS, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9904, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9904, 2022.

    EGU22-11857 | Presentations | BG4.3

    The role of stream heterogeneity in gas emissions from headwater streams. 

    Gianluca Botter, Anna Carozzani, Paolo Peruzzo, and Nicola Durighetto

    Headwater streams represent a key component of the global carbon cycle, as they are hotspots for the evasion of carbon dioxide from surface waters. Gas emissions from rivers and streams are modulated by the gas transfer velocity at the water-air interface, k, which is physically related to the energy dissipated by the flow field, ε. Here we study how local relations between gas transfer rate and energy dissipation can be spatially averaged in presence of heterogeneous flow fields, e.g. as induced by changes in the local slope. Furthermore, we develop mathematical tools for the quantification of the fraction of gas emission that is related to localized energy losses (e.g. sudden drops and step-pool formations). The study complements numerical simulations and direct measures of stream CO2 outgassing in an Italian headwater catchment. Our theoretical results indicate that reach-scale relations between k and ε in general differ from the corresponding local scaling laws. In particular, we show that high energy heterogeneous streams are characterized by a gas transfer velocity significantly higher than that of an equivalent homogeneous stream. The empirical data suggest that the outgassing is highly heterogeneous along a river network, with the outgassing generated by localized gas emissions in correspondence of hydraulic discontinuities that might be a dominant contribution to the total gas evasion in many settings. These results offer a clue for the interpretation of empirical data about stream outgassing in heterogeneous reaches and complex river networks.

    How to cite: Botter, G., Carozzani, A., Peruzzo, P., and Durighetto, N.: The role of stream heterogeneity in gas emissions from headwater streams., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11857, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11857, 2022.

    EGU22-11986 | Presentations | BG4.3

    Organic carbon fluxes in intermittent springs 

    Annika Feld, Christina Fasching, Martin Reiss, and Peter Chifflard

    Springs link the terrestrial and the aquatic ecosystem and connect groundwater and surface water. They are distinguished primarily by their type and discharge, whereby the latter can influence the biogeochemistry. Perennial springs, characterized by continuous spring discharge, show stable conditions and relatively low organic carbon contents. Although previous studies have investigated the sources of dissolved organic carbon (DOC) in streams considering mainly the riparian zone, the hyporheic zone and the hillslopes, our current understanding of springs as sources of organic carbon (OC) is still limited. Thus, our study focuses on intermittent springs, which are particularly vulnerable to climate change induced decreased groundwater levels. Additionally, changing groundwater levels may further increase the frequency of springs with an interrupted discharge during dry periods. Intermittent springs with a temporarily loss of the connectivity to the groundwater, impacting the quantity and quality of received OC and consequently the in-stream respiration, may lead to changed OC quantity and quality transported to downstream ecosystems.

    The aim of this investigation is to quantify the export fluxes of OC and to analyze their origin and composition in intermittent springs. For this purpose, 40 springs at four study sites in different low mountain range regions in Germany (Sauerland, Ore Mountains, Hesse Mountains and Black Forest) with different geology and vegetation types will be instrumented with hydrological on-site-measurements for discharge and electrical conductivity. Continuous quarterly biogeochemical sampling campaigns will be carried out and event-based sampling with an autosampler during 4 rainfall events at one spring per site is intended. Additionally, analyses of groundwater, soil water and precipitation samples as well as fDOM and CO2 measurements are implemented. Stable water isotopes (δ2H, δ18O) and nutrient concentrations (PO4, NO3, NH4) will also be determined to enable flux modelling. In this project the combination of continuous measurements and frequent sampling campaigns will be used to gather long-term data with high temporal resolution. Thus, the seasonal dynamics and spatio-temporal variability of OC export fluxes as well as event-based changes in OC and nutrient status and further the influence of spring OC on the following headwater streams will be studied in the next three years. First results show that there are great spatial variabilities in DOC concentration between the 40 intermittent springs in the four study catchments. This underscores that intermittent springs differ substantially from perennial springs in their export behavior.

    How to cite: Feld, A., Fasching, C., Reiss, M., and Chifflard, P.: Organic carbon fluxes in intermittent springs, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11986, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11986, 2022.

    EGU22-12853 | Presentations | BG4.3

    Metabolic synchrony in stream networks 

    Jacob Diamond

    Synchrony of dissolved oxygen (DO) signals among river network elements reflects the dynamic balance between shared regional drivers, signal propagation, and local hydraulic, energetic, and metabolic heterogeneity. We used high frequency DO measurements at 42 sites across five watersheds catchments to evaluate DO signal synchrony among reaches in response to dynamic variation in light availability and discharge. We hypothesized that homogeneity of light availability and longitudinal hydrologic connectivity between sites would enhance synchrony in DO signals. We observed strong support that increasing spatial homogeneity of light inputs, both in magnitude and diel variation, greatly increase diel DO signal synchrony both within and across stream networks during early spring and fall. We further observed the central role of longitudinal connectivity in controlling within network synchrony. Specifically, shared regional drivers (light, temperature) increase the synchrony in DO signals when flow connectivity was high, whereas fine-scale patch behavior and low synchrony, especially in smaller streams, occurred when connectivity declines. A model including light synchrony and longitudinal connectivity explained 65% of variation in dynamic DO synchrony. We provide a framework for evaluating DO signal synchrony at confluences with implications for broadly understanding solute where network flow elements mix. DO synchrony and network and confluence scales provides an empirical demonstration of the dynamic balance between regional drivers and local patch dynamics modulated by the flow-varying length scales of signal integration.

    How to cite: Diamond, J.: Metabolic synchrony in stream networks, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12853, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12853, 2022.

    EGU22-13525 | Presentations | BG4.3

    Metabolic potential of the microbial community along a depth gradient in Lake Kinneret sediments 

    Almog Gafni, Orit Sivan, Maxim Rubin Blum, and Werner Eckert

    Despite the crucial role of lake sediments in global biogeochemical cycling as a source of the greenhouse gas methane, our understanding the intrinsic microbial communities and their role in geochemical cycles in this environment is limited. Here, we used metagenomics and geochemical analyses to assess the microbial methane, iron, sulfur, and nitrogen cycling in depth profiles of sedimental samples from lake Kinneret, a warm monomictic subtropical lake. In these sediments microbes catalyze anaerobic methane oxidation and iron reduction beneath the sulfate reduction and the main methanogenic zones. High quality metagenome-assembled genomes revealed a broad potential for respiratory sulfur and nitrogen metabolism. Wood-Ljungdahl pathway used by acetogens and methanogens was found to be highly common given the widespread occurrence of the genes encoding the key enzyme carbon-monoxide dehydrogenase. Acetate, alcohol, and hydrogen are the prominent substrates for the fermentative metabolism. Methane metabolism was found in Methanotrichales Methanomicrobiales, Methanomethyliales, ANME-1 and Methanomassiliicoccales, and the bacterial Methylomirabilales. Iron reduction genes such as porins, MtrABC and outer membrane cytochromes were observed in Thermodesulfovibrionales, Geobacterales, Burkholderiales and Myxococcales. Our results indicated flexible metabolic capabilities of core microbial community, which could adapt to changing redox conditions.

    How to cite: Gafni, A., Sivan, O., Blum, M. R., and Eckert, W.: Metabolic potential of the microbial community along a depth gradient in Lake Kinneret sediments, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13525, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13525, 2022.

    Maintaining riverine habitat connectivity for important ecological processes like fish reproduction is essential for conserving endangered migratory species in regulated river. The unique reproductive behavior of migratory fish, which has a potential effect on habitat connectivity assessment, is the key for the success of population restoration in a changing climate conditions. However, existing analytic connectivity models mostly focus on broad-scale terrestrial studies tested with landscape features and large-scale riverine hydrological cases, they are not able to describe aquatic micro-habitat connectivity and cannot incorporate effects of multiple pathways linking spawning function areas with altered hydrological conditions. Here, we developed an ecological functional connectivity model that overcame these obstacles by borrowing from electrical circuit theory and highlighting functional attributes of habitat patches. It was the first time for circuit theory to apply in water ecosystem environment for habitat protection and population rebuilding. In this model, a function path tree restricted to patch connectivity constraints was first proposed for micro-habitat connectivity index. The model greatly improves aquatic habitat suitability predictions because it incorporates patch function attributes to account for habitat status and simultaneously integrates all possible pathways connecting spawning function areas for a more reliable connectivity assessment. When applied to data from Chinese sturgeon (a well-known endangered anadromous fish) in the Yangtze River, our model outperformed conventional aquatic habitat models, revealing that the low functional connectivity in spawning function areas, especially between dispersal area and incubation area, was a limiting factor for Chinese sturgeon reproduction. Results also demonstrated that contributions of global warming on increasing stream temperature intensified spawning habitat fragmentation, which would further hampered fish breeding activities. The proposed model is transferrable to fish species with different life histories, and holds much promise in habitat restoration, river management and conservation planning to reduce future ecological impacts of climate change.

    How to cite: deng, Q. and zhang, X.: Maintaining functional connectivity is essential for reducing negative effects of climate change on endangered species, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-315, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-315, 2022.

    A river corridor includes the active channel(s), floodplain, and underlying hyporheic zone. Geomorphic heterogeneity refers to the spatial distribution of geomorphic units within the river corridor. Heterogeneity can be conceptualized at different spatial scales, from bedforms such as pools and riffles in the active channel, to the distribution of subsurface paleochannels across the entire floodplain. Essentially, geomorphic heterogeneity describes the extent to which the river corridor is spatially non-uniform in the three dimensions of vertical, lateral, and longitudinal. Heterogeneity results from erosion and deposition caused by temporal and spatial variations in both inputs and boundary resistance, as well as modifications created by biota such as riparian vegetation or beavers (Castor spp.). In many river corridors, these variations and biotic influences reduce longitudinal connectivity but enhance lateral and vertical connectivity within the river corridor. Resilience is the ability to absorb disturbances without diminishing or changing river corridor function. Resilience can be conceptualized as occurring along a continuum dependent on time and space scales, especially when applied to a system such as a river corridor that includes individual components with different levels of resilience. Changing climate will affect averages and extremes such as floods and wildfires. I use case studies from mountain streams in Colorado, USA to illustrate how a geomorphically heterogeneous river corridor is more resilient to extremes of high and low flow and large inputs of either sediment or solutes. Geomorphic heterogeneity promotes resilience because the spatial non-uniformity of the river corridor provides more opportunities for transient storage over diverse timespans, which attenuates downstream fluxes, and diffuses the energy inputs resulting from a disturbance.

    How to cite: Wohl, E.: Geomorphic Heterogeneity in River Corridors as a Source of Resilience to Changing Climate, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1552, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1552, 2022.

    EGU22-3566 | Presentations | GM5.2

    Releasing the banks: initial morphological responses after removal of groynes and installation of a longitudinal dam 

    Coleen Carranza, Nard Onderwater, Annegret Larsen, Jasper Candel, Victor Bense, Ton Hoitink, Jakob Wallinga, and Martine van der Ploeg

    Longitudinal dams (LD) are novel engineering structures built parallel to the river channel that support sustainable river management. The recent replacement of groynes by longitudinal dams in low-land rivers such as the Waal has been successful in restoring the ecological river functions while simultaneously achieving its navigation, recreation, and flood-protection functions. However, the impact of the LD on the riverbanks is still unknown despite recent investigations on the flow dynamics in the side channel behind it. We fill this knowledge gap by investigating initial bank responses and quantifying changes in sediment dynamics over five years since the completion of the LD in the Waal at Wamel. We rely on available annual high-resolution LiDAR-derived DTMs, orthophotos, and in situ measurements to estimate erosion and deposition rates and their changes over the study period. A two-stage initial response is revealed with the largest bank erosion (~140 x 103 m3/yr) and deposition (~20 x 103 m3/yr) confined in the first year after installation, as the banks adjust to a new hydrogeomorphic equilibrium. This is followed by successively lower rates of surface-level changes (<70 x $103 m3/yr eroded and <10 x 103 m3/yr deposited) as a response to the hydrogeomorphic dynamics in the new system. The overbank deposits from recent floods have a similar distribution with those prior to LD construction based on the DTMs. However, higher volumes of sandy deposits are found post- compared to pre-LD construction for floods of similar magnitude and duration. This increase is caused by the additional contribution of the bank sediments that have been made available through the removal of groynes. Although eroding banks may be a threat to infrastructure and navigability, they have a positive effect on restoring ecological diversity and floodplain connectivity.

    How to cite: Carranza, C., Onderwater, N., Larsen, A., Candel, J., Bense, V., Hoitink, T., Wallinga, J., and van der Ploeg, M.: Releasing the banks: initial morphological responses after removal of groynes and installation of a longitudinal dam, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3566, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3566, 2022.

    EGU22-3974 | Presentations | GM5.2 | Highlight

    Machine learning and RFID-based large wood tracking in rivers 

    Janbert Aarnink, Virginia Ruiz-Villanueva, and Marceline Vuaridel

    Large wood (10cm diameter & 1m long) gets recruited into a mountain river system from surrounding forested areas. Instream large wood positively influences the diversity of the river system, creating habitats for terrestrial and aquatic species. However, the corresponding risk to the presence of instream large wood is a more controversial topic in river management. On the one hand, large wood increases the riverbed roughness, partly dissipating energy during a flood. On the other hand, its transport during floods might cause damage to infrastructure. Direct observations or monitoring stations are scarce and knowledge on how and when wood is transported remains far from complete.

    In order to quantify a river’s instream wood transport regime, we are developing a video-based wood tracking system that counts the number of pieces that pass a certain point and estimates their sizes. We use a DeepSORT algorithm that uses machine learning to identify individual pieces of instream wood and draws a bounding box around every piece. Subsequently, it uses a Kalman filter to estimate the piece’s trajectory. To prevent counting the same pieces multiple times, the projected trajectory is compared to the detections in the subsequent frame. The system is designed so that it can be applied to different datasets and will be available to the increasing wood monitoring efforts around the world. For a more detailed look into the large wood regime at one of our main study sites (Vallon de Nant, Switzerland), and to calibrate our video-based wood tracking system, we have installed RFID tags into all pieces of large wood (approximately 1000 pieces) over a stretch of 3 km. A stationary RFID antenna registers the tagged pieces that pass by, of which the size and origin are known.

    First results show that the custom trained DeepSORT algorithm can not only identify pieces of instream wood, but also largely follow the pieces in subsequent frames. The approach seems to outperform current computer vision solutions. In our ongoing research, we aim to make the system more robust and expand the observation network to other rivers. With an expanding dataset, containing (manually) labelled training samples from different locations, and the low-cost measurement set-up, the system promises to aid successfully to an intercomparison of river systems in the context of the wood management debate.

    This work is supported by the SNSF Eccellenza project PCEFP2-186963 and the University of Lausanne.

    How to cite: Aarnink, J., Ruiz-Villanueva, V., and Vuaridel, M.: Machine learning and RFID-based large wood tracking in rivers, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3974, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3974, 2022.

    EGU22-4251 | Presentations | GM5.2 | Highlight

    Impact of a volcanic eruption on the wood fluctuation along a Chilean river basin: the Calbuco study case 

    Andrés Iroumé, Karla Sanchez, Lorenzo Martini, Giacomo Pellegrini, and Lorenzo Picco

    Large wood (LW), both as individual pieces and in accumulations (WJ), plays an important role in the morphology, hydrology, and ecology of rivers. However, LW dynamics in rivers affected by volcanic eruptions has been little studied. This study aims to investigate the changes of LW volumes along a segment of the Blanco-Este River (southern Chile) affected by the 2015 Calbuco volcanic eruption. The following research questions were addressed: a) what are the drivers that explain the spatial and temporal variability of the amount of LW along the river active channel? b) what is the level of connection between the potential source areas of wood and the channel? c) is it possible to infer a relationship between recruitment sources and floods, with fluctuations in the amount of wood along the channel? The study was conducted in two reaches, the upstream one more proximal to the volcano (hereinafter R1) and the downstream more distal from the volcano (R2). LW and WJ volume were calculated using the structure from motion (SfM) technique for several sampling campaigns performed between 2017 and 2020 using a drone. Data from a fluviometric station near the Blanco-Este River and time lapse camera records were used to interpret the dynamics of wood during floods. Finally, the stability of WJs was used to indirectly evaluate the mobility of LW in the study reaches. Results show that the amount of LW (n°/ha), WJ (n°/ha) and total wood volume (m3/ha) are considerably higher in R2 than in R1. In both reaches, the main recruitment source of LW to the channel is associated with erosions of the forested margins, but for R2 a tributary and erosions of old laharic deposits are also recruitment sources. LW volume in R1 did not vary much between campaigns (1.9-5.1 m3/ha) which would indicate that this reach is in an equilibrium condition of LW loading. Since the wood volume in R2 showed important variations between sampling campaigns (9.1-73.9 m3/ha), this reach does not seem to have reached this equilibrium condition yet. Results showed that there is no clear relationship between the wood fluctuations and the flood intensities (volume increases and decreases indistinctly associated to low or high peak flows), a fact confirmed from the time lapse cameras. However, wood supply appears, as might be expected, somehow controlled by floods, as well as wood transport. But, apparently, the floods competent to move logs are of lower magnitude than those generating bank erosions and subsequent wood recruitment. From the analyses of the drone images, it was observed that the stability of the WJs was very low in the Blanco-Este, which indicates a high LW mobility. A connection between the areas that supply LW to the river channel appears to occur during major flood events with sufficient competence to erode forested streambanks. The latter calls for the need to incorporate the analysis of longitudinal wood connectivity in channel studies. This study is part of the FONDECYT 1200079 project.

    How to cite: Iroumé, A., Sanchez, K., Martini, L., Pellegrini, G., and Picco, L.: Impact of a volcanic eruption on the wood fluctuation along a Chilean river basin: the Calbuco study case, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4251, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4251, 2022.

    EGU22-5060 | Presentations | GM5.2

    An experimental study on the displacement of large wood in river channels 

    Diego Panici and Georgina Bennett

    Large wood is an essential component of river systems, often considered as the third leg of riverine fluxes (together with water and sediment). Large wood can provide beneficial effects to river restoration and natural flood management (NFM) measures. At the same time, large wood can obstruct bridge openings and increase risk of failure to structures and risk of flooding to adjacent areas. The transport of large wood in rivers crucially affects all the above processes, but to date the importance of factors affecting displacement of large wood in rivers is still poorly understood. Past theories postulated that flow secondary cells may drive large wood trajectories, but have never been confirmed. In this work, we experimentally tested at the flume scale the hydrodynamic factors influencing the displacement of large wood at the river surface. Results showed that past theories were inconclusive, whereas large wood elements tend to follow well-defined trajectories mostly driven by localised changes of the flow velocity. Furthermore, large wood elements are very sensitive to changes in their trajectories at the onset of motion, although are much less prone to change once motion has fully developed. The results from this work will pave the way for better-defined motion models of floating large wood, and will be used to test and calibrate smart sensors for field-based applications.

    How to cite: Panici, D. and Bennett, G.: An experimental study on the displacement of large wood in river channels, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5060, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5060, 2022.

    EGU22-5495 | Presentations | GM5.2

    Flow redistribution and backwater rise due to brush accumulation upstream of logjams with a lower gap 

    Elizabeth Follett, Isabella Schalko, and Heidi Nepf

    Engineered logjams with a gap at the bed are used in engineering practice to provide natural flood management and ecological benefits while preserving river connectivity at base flow. In addition, logjams with a gap at the bed form naturally in small streams with river width less than log length. The accumulation of wood pieces acts as a porous obstruction, and the distribution of flow through and beneath a jam with a lower gap satisfies a two-box, momentum-based model constrained by drag generated in the jam, momentum loss in flow through the lower gap, and net pressure force. Accumulation of brush and fine material upstream of logjams occurs naturally as small wood pieces and leaves are transported to the river channel. However, the impact of accumulated upstream material on logjam-generated increase in backwater rise presents a potential concern for long term maintenance of engineered logjam projects. We present recent results demonstrating that initial accumulation of wood pieces upstream of a jam with a lower gap has little impact on backwater rise, but backwater rise increased during a simulated flood cycle as wood pieces blocked the lower gap. The effect of varying brush size and shape and impact on flow redistribution between the jam and gap is examined.

    How to cite: Follett, E., Schalko, I., and Nepf, H.: Flow redistribution and backwater rise due to brush accumulation upstream of logjams with a lower gap, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5495, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5495, 2022.

    Title: Catchment-scale geomorphological modelling of leaky dams using CAESAR-Lisflood

     

    Joshua Wolstenholme              j.wolstenholme-2018@hull.ac.uk          1

    David Milan      d.milan@hull.ac.uk      1

    Christopher Skinner    chris.skinner@environment-agency.gov.uk 2

    Daniel Parsons              d.parsons@hull.ac.uk               1

     

    Affiliations:

    • University of Hull, Energy and Environment Institute, United Kingdom of Great Britain – England, Scotland, Wales (j.wolstenholme-2018@hull.ac.uk)
    • Environment Agency, Flood Hydrology Improvements, United Kingdom of Great Britain – England, Scotland, Wales

     

    The introduction of large wood to fluvial systems is becoming increasingly popular as a method of natural flood management commonly referred to as leaky dams. These are often installed as semi-permanent features through live felling and anchoring in-situ. Currently, most natural flood management modelling is hydrological and focuses on flood risk without accounting for geomorphology of these ‘fixed’ features. We argue that the long-term effectiveness of NFM interventions require and understanding of the nested hydrogeomorphological processes at work within river catchments, particularly those related to bed scour, sediment transport and deposition, and the associated feedbacks following implementation of leaky dams. Leaky dams that are designed to attenuate the hydrograph and ‘slow-the-flow’, may cause sediment storage as well as scour, potentially impeding the effectiveness of a leaky dam to reduce flood risk after a single storm event. Using the new ‘Working with Natural Processes’ toolbox developed for CAESAR-Lisflood, the influence of different storm scenarios on a series of leaky dams in a hypothetical catchment based on a site in North Yorkshire is assessed. The effectiveness of the model at representing the influence of the dams on hydrogeomorphology is also assessed.

    How to cite: Wolstenholme, J.: Catchment-scale geomorphological modelling of leaky dams using CAESAR-Lisflood, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5730, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5730, 2022.

    EGU22-6134 | Presentations | GM5.2

    A High Resolution Topography (HRT) based stochastic model for  multi-year river adjustment post restoration 

    Georgios Maniatis, Richard Williams, and Trevor Hoey

    Recent developments in generating High Resolution Topography (HRT), such as UAV photogrammetry, LiDAR and dGPS, have been extensively used in fluvial settings. Most data generation methods are based on commercial sensing and pre-processing tools that are tested by geoscientists in a trial-and-error manner for clarifying: a) their accuracy; and b) their applicability in field settings that are generally outside the range of their factory calibration. For many applications, this involves the concurrent deployment and the cross comparison of more than one sensing techniques. Despite the above, HRT techniques reduce surveying time and costs significantly. The frequency of surveying has increased to a point where it is now common to monitor the development and survival of in-stream bed forms with high resolution Digital Elevation Models (DEMs) on a monthly to annual basis.

    In parallel, river scientists have developed dedicated GIS workflows for: a) parameterising the errors during DEM differentiation, thus producing better constrained DEMs of Difference (DoDs); and b) delineating automatically (or semi-automatically) DEMs for the coherent identification of Geomorphic Units (GUs), a term used to distinguish in-stream bed forms and morphological features within the 3 Tier Classification of Wheaton et al., (2015, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.geomorph.2015.07.010).

    Here, we use the outputs from the GUT (Geomorphic Unit Tool, Riverscapes consortium) GU delineation as a proxy to predict the change of in-stream geomorphic variability. More specifically, we present a Markov-Chain (MC) model with a state incorporating all the observed GUs and transition matrices built using observed GU changes. The models are then left to converge to a set of probabilities that demonstrates what would happen to the stream if subjected to the observed hydrological forcing for a period that exceeds the surveying plan. To validate the model, we apply it for three successive post-restoration surveys (between 2012-2017) of a 700 m long reach of the Allt Lorgy restoration scheme (Scotland). The first two surveys are used to parametrise the MC transition matrix and the initial states and the third to test the predictions. The results show that the observed GU probabilities are within the predicted uncertainty ranges when the MC chain is modified and a proxy for sediment input is introduced as an additive term.

    The MC model is intended to describe post-restoration morphological evolution, and subsequently to provide a tool for predicting morphological change and the end state, assuming constant hydrological forcing.

    How to cite: Maniatis, G., Williams, R., and Hoey, T.: A High Resolution Topography (HRT) based stochastic model for  multi-year river adjustment post restoration, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6134, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6134, 2022.

    EGU22-6472 | Presentations | GM5.2 | Highlight

    Modeling the effects of low flow on wood transport in the Piave River 

    Elisabetta Persi, Gabriella Petaccia, Stefano Sibilla, Lorenzo Picco, and Alessia Tonon

    In low flow conditions, wood transport is limited but still important. In addition, low flows are significant to stress a numerical model of Large Wood (LW) transport and to assess its capacity in simulating LW displacement or non-displacement.  The solver ORSA2D_WT was employed and tested to improve the knowledge related to these thresholds (moving vs not moving). The software couples the solution of the 2D Shallow Water Equations to a dynamic Discrete Element Model that computes the hydrodynamic forces to calculate LW transport. To assess whether ORSA2D_WT can cope with the infrequent mobilization of LW in low flow conditions, it is applied to a reach of the Piave River (North-East Italy), where the wood budget was already investigated. Field data about LW position, mobilization, shape, size and orientation, flow conditions and morphological changes were collected.

    The critical aspects that affect the model performance and that deserve an in-depth analysis are the wood-riverbed interaction and the log shape representation in the model. ORSA2D_WT works in fixed-bed conditions, computing a 2D force balance to determine wood entrainment. It considers only cylindrical forms or jams composed by cylindrical elements, whose relevant hydrodynamic parameters are the longitudinal cross-section and the hydrodynamic coefficients, that depend also on the log orientation to the flow.

    Regarding wood-riverbed interaction, bed friction plays a significant role compared to the forces that trigger wood motion. This is especially true in low flow conditions when floatation is less important than rolling/sliding. The local erosion that occurs nearby wood pieces likely influences wood mobilization, as well as the presence of roots and/or branches.

    To assess if the model schematizations are sufficiently accurate for low flow conditions and to overcome the model limitations, the friction and hydrodynamic coefficients are suitably corrected. In particular, the influence of the local water level on the friction coefficient is investigated, and the hydrodynamic coefficients are modified to include different LW shapes. The modified model is calibrated with the data available for one sub-reach and then applied to a different sub-reach, to assess its performance.

    How to cite: Persi, E., Petaccia, G., Sibilla, S., Picco, L., and Tonon, A.: Modeling the effects of low flow on wood transport in the Piave River, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6472, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6472, 2022.

    EGU22-7443 | Presentations | GM5.2

    Trait-based numerical modelling of feedbacks between river morphodynamics and riparian vegetation for sustainable river management in a changing climate 

    Virginia Garófano-Gómez, Florent Arrignon, Franck Vautier, Eric Tabacchi, Elisabeth Allain, Anne Bonis, Sébastien Delmotte, Eduardo González, Frédéric Julien, Luc Lambs, Francisco Martínez-Capel, Anne-Marie Planty-Tabacchi, Erwan Roussel, Johannes Steiger, Jean-Pierre Toumazet, Irène Till-Bottraud, Olivier Voldoire, Romain Walcker, and Dov Corenblit

    River ecosystems are spatiotemporally and intimately tied to physicochemical and biological processes, driven by strong feedbacks between riparian vegetation dynamics and hydrogeomorphic processes and fluvial landforms. Climatic and hydrogeomorphic constraints to vegetation determine a naturally shifting habitat mosaic dynamism, fostering high habitat heterogeneity and biodiversity, and providing multiple ecosystem services to society. However, most European river systems have lost their inherent highly dynamic character after major human-induced impacts, such as river channelisation and altered flow and sediment regimes. In March 2019, the United Nations designated the period of 2021–2030 as the "Decade on Ecosystem Restoration", and river ecosystems will be a significant target. Consequently, river restoration practitioners will need robust decision-making tools to guide their deliberations and subsequent management actions. Recommendations are to avoid merely reproducing river features and instead restoring geomorphic, hydrological, and ecological processes, but river science has not fully understood yet how processes develop and interact following restoration interventions. Integrative modelling of feedback mechanisms between riparian vegetation dynamics and hydrogeomorphic processes is critical for making predictions that enable river managers to optimise the use of the natural self-regulation potential of riparian corridors whilst maximising human benefits. Today’s existing models, however, do not fully reflect the interactions between river hydraulics and vegetation succession. In particular, the role of vegetation needs to be included through its impact in modulating river landforms and their evolutionary trajectories. Here, we present the conceptual and methodological framework, preliminary results, and the perspectives of the NUMRIP project, funded by the French National Research Agency. Along the project, a numerical (cellular automata) model of fluvial landscape dynamics will be developed, integrating physical, biological, and human components. The project focuses on riparian vegetation, from individual plants to communities. It explicitly considers vegetation as a dynamic component of the system, both responding to and affecting hydrogeomorphic processes and fluvial landforms. Accordingly, NUMRIP builds upon the conceptual fluvial biogeomorphological succession model and recent advances in remote sensing techniques of plant-geomorphology interactions. The NUMRIP project will explicitly associate plant functional traits (e.g., physiological, morphological, and biomechanical characteristics) to hydrogeomorphic processes and fluvial landforms, using plant functional trait approaches, remote sensing- and numerical modelling techniques. The lower course of the Allier River (France) is used as a case study. It is one of the last remaining free meandering river segments in Europe, and thus, constitutes an opportunity to investigate riparian succession processes of a dynamic, temperate river system. Despite its natural character, it is also experimenting an increase of stability (i.e., a reduction in channel migration and progression/retrogression of vegetation patches), because of a concomitant decrease of high and moderate magnitude floods due to current global climate change. The model could be used as a research tool in river science as well as a decision support system for river managers. It will be able to predict potential future evolutionary trajectories of fluvial corridors, adjusting for example to a changing hydrological regime or river restoration works.

    How to cite: Garófano-Gómez, V., Arrignon, F., Vautier, F., Tabacchi, E., Allain, E., Bonis, A., Delmotte, S., González, E., Julien, F., Lambs, L., Martínez-Capel, F., Planty-Tabacchi, A.-M., Roussel, E., Steiger, J., Toumazet, J.-P., Till-Bottraud, I., Voldoire, O., Walcker, R., and Corenblit, D.: Trait-based numerical modelling of feedbacks between river morphodynamics and riparian vegetation for sustainable river management in a changing climate, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7443, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7443, 2022.

    EGU22-7845 | Presentations | GM5.2

    Assessing the effects of gravel augmentation on thermal processes in gravel-bed rivers 

    Baptiste Marteau, Kristell Michel, and Hervé Piégay

    Gravel augmentation has become common practice to mitigate the effects of decline in upstream sediment supply in gravel-bed rivers. However, functional aspects of river systems such as thermal functions are often left out of rehabilitation monitoring programmes. Despite temperature being a fundamental parameter determining the general health of rivers, a limited number of studies have tested whether gravel augmentation can aid restoring thermal functions. Using airborne thermal infrared (TIR) imagery, this paper explores potential feedbacks through the monitoring of gravel augmentation on 3 rivers in France. To overcome the lack of pre-rehabilitation data, we used hydromorphological indicators within a trajectory-based Before-After-Control-Impact (BACI) framework to assess the success of rehabilitation on thermal functions. This design, combining long-term geomorphic evolution with TIR-based CI strategy, indicated that restoring forms was not sufficient to restore thermal functions. Nonetheless, hydromorphological indices mesures on historical aerial photographs can be used to estimate long-term evolution of groundwater-surface water interactions. We emphasise the benefits of trajectory-based BACI assessment to identify current conditions, understand the past evolution (trajectory) of the system to define the framework within which rehabilitation can objectively be assessed.

    How to cite: Marteau, B., Michel, K., and Piégay, H.: Assessing the effects of gravel augmentation on thermal processes in gravel-bed rivers, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7845, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7845, 2022.

    New field data are reported for overbank sedimentation generated by the extreme flood event of summer 2021 along the Maas River, an intensively managed lowland river in the Netherlands. Flood duration was short (3-4 days) but flood magnitude was extreme, the highest stage and discharge (3,2650 m^3/s) recorded in more than 100 years.

    Flood sediments were sampled at 108 sites from the NL-BE border to the delta (195-km distance) over a range of depositional environments, including artificial flood basins created for the Room for the River flood management program. Flood deposits were sampled in August and September using conventional field sampling procedures, which included identifying recent sediment deposited atop buried soil and organic layers using field texture and density, and differences in soil color (recorded). The modal Munsell soil color value for flood deposits and the darker underlying soil were brown (2.5 Y 3/2) and light olive brown (2.5 Y 5/3), respectively. Sedimentation thickness (mm) of each of the 108 reported values is an average of three individual thickness measurements obtained within a ~0.5 m radius at each field site. Minimum flood water height was measured by identifying silt and trash lines in vegetation and fencing at multiple locations and ranged from 3.5-m to 0.3-m above low and high floodplain surfaces, respectively. Particle size of 84 flood sediment samples was determined by hydrometer analysis and wet sieving.

    Average flood deposit thickness was 21 mm, and varied significantly according to geomorphic setting: low floodplains (28 mm), high floodplains (6 mm), channel banks (31 mm), inset banks (11 mm), and flood basins (42 mm). Maximum sedimentation was associated with discreet sand sheets (295 mm). Floodplain stripping (erosion) at some low floodplain sites included reworking and deposition of large clasts (gravel, cobble). Pronounced lateral decreases in sedimentation thickness persists despite flood water height, and rapidly declines beyond about ~30 m from the channel bank. Lateral changes in particle size, however, are less abrupt, and along some reaches very fine sand was deposited to the distal margins of the embanked floodplain. Some laterally distant sites > ~200 m from the channel bank underwent high amounts of sedimentation (38 mm, 25 mm, 43 mm) with pronounced vertical fining (very fine sand to silt) of flood deposits associated with slackwater sedimentation within basins engineered for the Room for the River flood management program. In contrast to many prior sedimentation studies a pattern of downstream fining (along same geomorphic surface) does not exist, likely due to high stream power and reworking of older channel bed deposits.

    The overall thickness of the 2021 flood deposits are considerably less than reported for large flood events in 1993 and 1995. This may be due to the shorter duration of the 2021 flood event, as well as the persistent decline in Maas River sediment loads since about the early 1950s, as well as differences in sampling strategy. Study results are further contextualized by considering corresponding event-based discharge – suspended sediment dynamics as well as sediment province.

    How to cite: Hudson, P.: Sedimentation from an extreme event along an intensively managed fluvial system: Summer 2021 flooding along the Maas River, Netherlands, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8326, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8326, 2022.

    EGU22-8699 | Presentations | GM5.2

    Hydrodynamic Response to Partially Spanning Logjams 

    Isabella Schalko, Elizabeth Follett, and Heidi Nepf

    Wood is a key part of a river ecosystem and affects both flow conditions and channel morphology. Wood accumulations or logjams may generate important habitat by increasing the upstream water surface elevation (backwater rise) and creating a downstream region with reduced flow velocity. Depending on the logjam size and the flow conditions, the resulting backwater rise can also provoke a flood hazard. Therefore, the prediction of backwater rise due to logjams is required to inform river restoration as well as flood hazard assessment efforts. Backwater rise due to channel spanning logjams can be described based on analytical and empirical models. However, logjams can exhibit various shapes, including partially spanning logjams. The hydrodynamic response to logjams that partially span the channel lateral extent has not been studied so far. Therefore, a series of flume experiments was conducted at the Laboratory of Hydraulics, Hydrology and Glaciology (VAW) at ETH Zurich to study how the flow depth and flow velocity are altered by partially spanning logjams with a lateral gap. The objectives were to determine how the jam relative width (jam width to channel width) influenced flow heterogeneity, described by flow velocity and turbulent kinetic energy, and to predict the backwater rise. Initial results demonstrated that logjams with a relative width Brel ≥ 0.5 created two distinct zones of velocity and increased flow heterogeneity. In addition, backwater rise increased with increasing relative logjam width. As a next step, the existing analytical model for channel spanning logjams will be adapted to describe backwater rise due to partially spanning logjams.

    How to cite: Schalko, I., Follett, E., and Nepf, H.: Hydrodynamic Response to Partially Spanning Logjams, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8699, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8699, 2022.

    EGU22-9081 | Presentations | GM5.2

    Adjustment of channel morphology and complexity following restoration of timber-floated rivers 

    Lina E. Polvi and Richard J. Mason

    River restoration is essential to reverse biodiversity decline and improve river resilience to climate change. In northern Sweden, virtually all rivers were historically timber-floated and thus channelized with all complexity elements (e.g., boulders, islands, side channels) removed. In these rivers restoration design is determined in the field by a team leader directing an excavator driver. This efficient methods allows restoration of 100s of river kilometers annually; however, there is little to no monitoring of restoration outcomes. Thus, the influence of restoration on channel morphology and habitat complexity is unknown. Furthermore, response of semi-alluvial rivers constrained by glacial legacy sediment (e.g., boulders) to restoration is poorly understood and expected to differ from their alluvial counterparts. In this study, we followed up eight reaches in the Lögde River catchment (~64° N, DA: ~1600 km2) restored as part of the EU LIFE project ReBorN. Reaches were equally divided above and below the former-highest coastline (FHC), demarcating different glacial histories and surficial geologies (semi-alluvial vs. alluvial channels). To evaluate the influence of river size on channel response to restoration, half of the reaches were located on tributaries and half of the reaches were on the mainstem of the Lögde River. We surveyed all reaches with a total station or RTK-GPS prior to restoration and 1-year and 3-years post-restoration. Hydromorphologic characteristics and complexity metrics were calculated and compared among years to determine changes during and post-restoration.

    As expected due to the nature of the restoration methods, channel size increased, with significant increases in channel width and planform area. Although channel complexity showed increasing trends, few were significant except three metrics describing the longitudinal profile (α= 0.10); one complexity metric showed a significant decrease (thalweg planform sinuosity). In the 3-year period following restoration, channel width, planform area, and depth decreased. Complexity metrics either showed no change or a similar trend of decreasing, with significant decreases in three metrics (width SD, thalweg concavity, and thalweg R2). There were no significant differences between reaches above and below the FHC or between the mainstem and tributaries.

    Overall, these reaches were over-dimensioned during restoration and post-restoration adjustment shows slight narrowing. Inset bankfull channels started forming with vegetation establishing below the designed bankfull channel. An over-dimensioned channel reduces overbank flooding and thus lateral channel-floodplain connectivity, negating a restoration design aim. The decreased post-restoration complexity indicates a smoothening of the longitudinal profile and planform bankfull profile through sediment settling and preferred areas of erosion/deposition, rather than the artificial complexity created by the excavator. Although eight reaches were too few to reveal many significant changes, many post-restoration studies make conclusions based on a single reach, thus the trends shown here indicate similar processes acting across several reaches. Similarly, three years is a short time period to evaluate post-restoration channel adjustment, particularly in semi-alluvial boulder-bed rivers. Ideally, river restoration should be followed up for at least a decade, allowing the river to experience high flows and potentially varied winter ice conditions.

    How to cite: Polvi, L. E. and Mason, R. J.: Adjustment of channel morphology and complexity following restoration of timber-floated rivers, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9081, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9081, 2022.

    EGU22-9135 | Presentations | GM5.2

    Morphological response to climatic and anthropic pressures of the Vjosa river, a reference system for river management and restoration 

    Marta Crivellaro, Livia Serrao, Walter Bertoldi, Simone Bizzi, Alfonso Vitti, and Guido Zolezzi

    Besides their environmental values, near-natural rivers offer the opportunity to observe and investigate riverine processes as they would occur under limited anthropic pressures, representing fundamental references for river management and restoration. Even so, few large near-natural rivers can still be found in Europe and worldwide, and their knowledge is often scarce due to a lack of hydromorphological monitoring and baseline studies. Among them, the Vjosa/Aoos River (GR, AL) has been recently recognized as a key large fluvial corridor and a significant model ecosystem. We investigate the catchment-scale recent morphological trajectories of the Vjosa river and its tributaries, coupling the reconstruction of channel adjustments over the past 50 years from remote sensing images with the analysis of possible drivers of change at the catchment and reach scale. We considered eight reaches in the main course of the Vjosa river as well as in some major tributaries (Sarandaporo, Drinos, Shushica) with different morphologies and confinement degrees. Our results underline the sensitivity of the Vjosa system to both hydrological alterations and human pressures. Specifically, it is possible to observe a response  of the system passing from an intense period of high magnitude, frequency, and duration of flood events in the 1960s to a drier period in the following decades. To study the morphological response, three time periods are considered: 1968-1985, 1985-2000 and 2005-2020. In the first examined decades, river trajectories highlight the narrowing of the active channel as a primary response to the hydrological change in the majority of selected reaches, with a 20-50% active width reduction with respect to 1968. In the following time periods, the narrowing rate decreases at the catchment scale, while in the last phase the effect of human pressures in some reaches can be observed. Indeed, from the late 1980s, human pressures at different spatial and temporal scales can be identified, locally altering the natural trajectory of the affected reaches. Such pressures include sediment mining and extensive bank protection of the lowland reaches, together with flow regime alteration occurring in one headwater sub-catchment.  However, our analysis reveals primarily a high sensitivity of the Vjosa system to recent climatic variations, suggesting the importance of accounting for future projected changes in rainfall regime in shaping morphological trajectories. The baseline knowledge on the morphological sensitivity and recovery time developed in this work provides an important reference for the management of highly dynamic river corridors in temperate and Mediterranean climates.

    How to cite: Crivellaro, M., Serrao, L., Bertoldi, W., Bizzi, S., Vitti, A., and Zolezzi, G.: Morphological response to climatic and anthropic pressures of the Vjosa river, a reference system for river management and restoration, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9135, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9135, 2022.

    In the UK Leaky wooden dams (LWD) have become an increasingly popular method of Natural Flood Management (NFM) and river restoration. LWD are in and/or across channel structures made from woody material designed to mimic naturally occurring woody debris that is often found in riverine environments. LWDs aim to reduce flooding downstream by holding back water and promoting flow onto the floodplain, increasing connection with the floodplain and infiltration by diverting water onto the floodplain. A key difference between woody debris and LWD are that LWD are usually secured and unable to move and adjust within the river and LWD are sometimes placed in areas where woody debris would not naturally occur. With the large scale and quick implementation of LWD there is a lack of critique or investigation into the geomorphic impacts of LWD. Instead, researchers and practitioners have been using what is known about the geomorphic impacts of natural woody debris to explain and predict the geomorphic impacts of LWD – even though it has been established that they are fundamentally different. This project investigates the geomorphic impacts of different styles and configurations of LWD through the use of analog physical models, surface velocimetry and structure from motion photogrammetry. Using these techniques this research aims to identify any patterns in flow and sediment dynamics both up and downstream of LWDs and to further our understanding of the specific geomorphic impacts of different LWD structures. Identifying the specific geomorphic impacts of LWD is important to be able to understand if they are having a detrimental impact to the river systems where they have been installed in the UK and to be able to inform best practice for the future.

    How to cite: Carter, C., Coulthard, T., Thomas, R., and McLelland, S.: Understanding the geomorphic impacts of Leaky Wooden Dams (LWDs) through utilising analog physical models, structure from motion photogrammetry and surface velocimetry., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10199, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10199, 2022.

    EGU22-10651 * | Presentations | GM5.2 | Highlight

    Using backpack mobile laser scanning system for mapping large wood in a forested headwater stream of southwest Japan 

    Kenta Koyanagi, Taku Yamada, and Koji Ishida

    Understanding the dynamic of instream large wood (LW) is essential for reducing hydrogeomorphic hazards in populated mountainous catchments. Quantifying the spatiotemporal distribution of LW is generally the most demanding process for investigating LW dynamics in rivers. Over the last two decades, multiple airborne sensors have been applied for mapping LW in relatively large alluvial rivers. However, those existing approaches are not necessarily suitable for remotely sensing LW in forested headwater streams, mainly due to canopy obstruction, weak illumination, and operational difficulty. Therefore, we tested the applicability of a 5-kilogram commercial backpack mobile laser scanning system for detecting and quantifying LW in a forested headwater stream of southwest Japan. Extremely dense point clouds (~15000 pts/m2) were continuously scanned within 150-meter reach of the 2nd-order stream (slope: 0.045) by a 6-minute walk following rainfall-triggered debris flows. Dimension and volume of LW measured from point clouds were compared to associated field and UAV photogrammetry-based mapping data. Based on a surface shape detection algorithm and subsequent manual filtering of falsely detected objects (e.g., riparian trees), 25 cylinders corresponding to 34.9 m3 total volume were delineated from point clouds. While the UAV photogrammetry-based approach was able to quantify only 2.4% of total LW volume, 75.1% of LW volume was successfully reconstructed by backpack mobile laser scanning. The visibility of the UAV photogrammetry-based approach was substantially limited by the dense riparian vegetation of our study reach. However, underestimation of wood piece length and overestimation of wood piece diameter consistently occurred for both remote sensing approaches. Therefore, further efforts would be made to evaluate the sensitivity of individual parameters used in point cloud processing for LW detection and quantification. Considering the mobility of sensors and data availability of near-surface objects, our case study indicates that backpack mobile laser scanning potentially provides a powerful alternative for more continuous, efficient, and frequent LW mapping, particularly in forested headwater streams.

    How to cite: Koyanagi, K., Yamada, T., and Ishida, K.: Using backpack mobile laser scanning system for mapping large wood in a forested headwater stream of southwest Japan, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10651, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10651, 2022.

    EGU22-11359 | Presentations | GM5.2

    The geomorphic response of river alternate bars to climate change 

    Marco Redolfi, Mattia Carlin, and Marco Tubino

    Understanding the possible geomorphic trajectory of rivers on the scale of decades is crucial for a successful design of river restoration interventions, especially in the contest of a changing climate. In this contribution we focus on river alternate bars, large bedforms that appear as a repeating sequence of diagonal depositional fronts and scour holes. Downstream-migrating alternate bars can spontaneously form due to a well-known process of riverbed instability and are frequently found in channelized river reaches. We considered two study reaches of the Alpine Rhine River in Switzerland, characterized by similar hydrological and sedimentological characteristics, but different channel width. Expected hydrological changes until 2100, depending on the Representative Concentration Pathways for greenhouse gases, were evaluated by considering the recents projections from the Hydro-CH2018 project. The bar evolution was reproduced through the novel mathematical model developed by Carlin et al. (2021), which allows for simulating the temporal variability of the reach-averaged bar height in the long-term. Model’s results clearly show that the expected response of the river bed strongly depends on channel conditions with respect to the relevant morphodynamics threshold for bar formation. The first reach, which is sufficiently wide to allow for a full development of migrating alternate bars, turns out to be weakly sensitive to the projected hydrological alterations. Conversely the second, narrower reach, which is currently close to the threshold conditions, is expected to experience a remarkable alteration in bar dynamics. Specifically, the average bar height is expected to significantly increase, while its variability during flood events will probably drastically reduce. Ultimately, this work reveals a noteworthy example of a more general property of near-threshold geomorphic systems, which are potentially fragile and highly susceptible to changes of their hydrological and ecological conditions, in contrast to systems that being far from threshold conditions are more likely to maintain their physical characteristics in the long term.

    How to cite: Redolfi, M., Carlin, M., and Tubino, M.: The geomorphic response of river alternate bars to climate change, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11359, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11359, 2022.

    EGU22-11911 | Presentations | GM5.2

    Hydrodynamics in the near-wake of cylindrical obstacles in a turbulent open channel flow 

    Théo Fernandez, Ingo Schnauder, Olivier Eiff, and Koen Blanckaert

    The research concerns the hydrodynamic processes around obstacles of cylindrical shape installed across an open channel flow at a subcritical Reynolds number of ReD = 1 x 104 (based on the cylinder diameter), and the forces exerted by the turbulent flow on these obstacles. Based on field measurements performed on the Plizska River, Poland, this study is mainly on cylinders representing large wood trunks that traverse a river. 

    The first aim of the study is to reproduce the flow pattern around an inclined single tree trunk of quasi constant diameter and without branches measured in the field and to enable a more detailed analysis of the underlying turbulent flow processes. These field measurements have shown that horizontal near bank recirculation zones, scour below the trunk and plunge scour overtopping it occurred.

    The second aim is to compare the mean flow and vortex shedding around inclined and horizontal cylinders across the flow. The effects of inclined and horizontal cylinders on the flow field are very different: the former create a higher variability in flow processes.  These configurations differ in gap width below the cylinder and in approach velocity, as the inclined cylinder is located at different elevations in the bottom boundary layer. Both parameters affect the vortex shedding frequency and the wake structure. 

    Results show that a transversally inclined cylinder generates more complex flow patterns and creates a high heterogeneity in the flow as well as the depth. The analysis of the dimensionless shedding frequency also suggests the suppression of vortex shedding near both banks when the gap ratio is small. However, vortex shedding characteristics in the central part of the cross-section are similar for the horizontal and inclined cylinders, i.e. the changing gap ratio below the inclined cylinder does not affect significantly the vortex shedding. In the central part of the cross-section, the wake flow is governed by the interaction of the nearly symmetrical shear layers generated above and below the cylinder. Near the banks, the shear layer near the bed or water surface is suppressed, which could explain the suppression of the vortex shedding.

    How to cite: Fernandez, T., Schnauder, I., Eiff, O., and Blanckaert, K.: Hydrodynamics in the near-wake of cylindrical obstacles in a turbulent open channel flow, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11911, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11911, 2022.

    In-stream large wood (LW) can have significant effects on channel hydraulics and thus water and sediment connectivity. The relationship between LW structures and their hydraulic function is generally quantified through drag force. Drag analyses, however, are often not straightforward, especially in complex debris jam settings where LW accumulations often consist of wood pieces of variable sizes. Here, we introduce simple LW (dis-)connectivity and sediment storage potential indices, especially developed for river management assessments. The LW (dis-)connectivity index (IDLW) is calculated based on visually estimated, field-derived parameters such as the degree of channel blockage. The LW sediment storage potential index (ISLW) is based on a classification scheme differentiating between different types of LW accumulation. Both indices were calculated and tested in two medium-sized mixed-load streams in Austria, further assessing fine sediment retention volumes behind LW structures. In both systems a variety of different types of LW accumulation with different degrees of blockage and storage potential have been detected. The larger system (river length = 5.7 km) had IDLW and ISLW values of 0,75 and 0,027, the smaller system (river length = 1.3 km) of 1,76 and 0,057. In the larger system in total 88.7 m³ fine sediment have been found to be retained by LW, while 4.7 m³ have been accumulated behind LW structures in the smaller river system. The application of the newly developed indices has shown to be a straightforward and valuable method to assess the effects of LW on water and sediment (dis-)connectivity, especially in a river management context.

    How to cite: Pöppl, R., Fergg, H., and Perez, J.: Large wood (LW) and sediment (dis-)connectivity in river systems: Introducing the newly developed LW (dis-)connectivity and sediment storage potential indices and their application in river management contexts., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12394, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12394, 2022.

    EGU22-12515 | Presentations | GM5.2

    Exploring the effect of instream boulders on large wood transport combining numerical modelling and field experiments 

    Jérémy Marchesseau, Ana Lucía, Francesco Comiti, Emmanuel Mignot, and Virginia Ruiz-Villanueva

    Large and relatively immobile sediment particles (i.e., boulders, usually defined with a diameter greater than 256 mm) are naturally delivered to rivers from hillslopes, transported by extreme floods, or produced by processes such as bed armouring. Boulder placement is also used as an artifical method for stabilizing channel beds and banks in river restoration projects. Natural or reintroduced boulders are important elements with a significant influence on channel hydraulics, erosion and deposition dynamics, and morphology. Still, little is known about their effect on large wood transported as floats along the river.

    A field experiment was performed to track the mobility of cylindrical wood elements artificially placed in a reach of the Rienz River upstream from the city of Brunico, in South Tyrol (Northern Italy) and transported along a few kilometres over a period of three years. The Rienz River is a single thread sinuous gravel-bed river, characterized by the presence of several large boulders. Combining available field observations and 2D numerical modelling (coupling a 2D flow and a Lagrangian calculation of wood elements), this work aims to test the effect of boulders on both the river ecohydraulics and large wood transport. First, a detailed topography was obtained combining an available digital elevation model (2 m resolution) with topographical surveys. Second, the numerical model (i.e., Iber-Wood) has been calibrated with flow depths observations and the wood travel distances recorded during one high flow event were used for validation of the Lagrangian calculation. Finally, different scenarios with different boulder rearrangements are currently run to explore the effects of boulders size and location distribution on both wood transport and river ecohydraulics. This contribution will show preliminary results and discuss how boulder-rich channels differ from boulder-free channels in terms of large wood transport and deposition.

    How to cite: Marchesseau, J., Lucía, A., Comiti, F., Mignot, E., and Ruiz-Villanueva, V.: Exploring the effect of instream boulders on large wood transport combining numerical modelling and field experiments, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12515, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12515, 2022.

    Dam removals are currently experiencing a hype as a measure to restore water bodies to a more natural and thus more resilient state. Following the implementation of major projects in North America and some EU countries in particular, an inventory regarding planned and implemented projects has been carried out in Austria for the first time. A total of 53 cross barriers are known to have been removed to date. The characteristics and also problems in the definition of these projects will be presented.

    The second part will deal with the challenges in the practical implementation of such measures. Case studies on the Maltsch and the Aschach show which resistances of the local population, hydraulic considerations and practical implementation risks are to be expected.

    Finally, the significance of such measures will be evaluated in the overall consideration of river restoration measures and solutions in terms of climate change adaptation.

    How to cite: Höfler, S., Pilz, I., and Gumpinger, C.: Dam Removal in Austria – Current status, lessons learned from implementation, and potential contribution of the measure in climate change adaptation, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13254, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13254, 2022.

    EGU22-13365 | Presentations | GM5.2

    Restoring urban river habitats. Lessons learned for monitoring, appraisal and management from the River Wandle, South London, UK. 

    Giuditta Trinci, Geraldene Wharton, and Nicola Bartoletti

    In recent decades, the number of urban river restoration projects has grown considerably, with schemes designed to daylight rivers and reconnect them to their floodplains and deliver a range of environmental, social and economic benefits including building flood resilience in a changing climate. However, the limited pre and post-project appraisal continues to have implications for evaluating the success of projects and improving future schemes. In this presentation we share an example of a river restoration project aimed to tackle the urban river syndrome, loss of aquatic biodiversity and habitat degradation and present the results from several post-project appraisals carried out between 2013 and 2018 that examined different aspects of the river habitat. The lessons learned from combining the findings of several studies not only informs on-going management of the Wandle but the approach can help guide the appraisal of urban rivers more widely. In particular, we show the potential of Citizen Science surveys as for identifying early warning signs of deteriorating river condition and as a foundation for long term affordable monitoring of river restoration schemes.

    How to cite: Trinci, G., Wharton, G., and Bartoletti, N.: Restoring urban river habitats. Lessons learned for monitoring, appraisal and management from the River Wandle, South London, UK., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13365, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13365, 2022.

    EGU22-13483 | Presentations | GM5.2

    Influence of Wood Density on Backwater Rise due to Large Wood Accumulations 

    Rebeca Mallqui, Juan Cabrera, and Arnold Lazóriga

    The backwater caused by the accumulation of wood and large logs in rivers surrounded by tropical forests is determined by the characteristics of the floating material and the approaching flow. Density, as a characteristic of wood logs, determines their buoyancy and depends on the tree species, age, state of decomposition and water content, reaching values between 250 kg/m3 and over 900 kg/m3. Despite this apparent relationship, flood hazard studies in rivers with log transport usually do not consider the influence of density.

    In the present study, the effect of wood density on the increase in backwater and the shape of the accumulation is evaluated by means of laboratory-scale simulation with pieces of artificial logs for different Froude numbers and approach flow heights. The pieces were manufactured on 3D printers to obtain certain density ranges (400 ±30, 600 ±30, 800 ±30 and 950 ±30 kg/m3), reduce the possible variation in the moisture content of the wood and facilitate its reuse. Backwater formation was forced by installing vertical steel rack in a control section installed downstream of the test channel. The results of the evaluation show a marked tendency in the increase of the backwater height with the increase of the density of the wood for each approach flow condition evaluated. Regarding the shape of the accumulations, the presence of a carpet form was observed only for the tests with subcritical approach flows, for the tests with supercritical flow, wedge or box shapes were observed for low densities and higher densities, respectively. Likewise, it was observed that the length of the carpet form decreases as the Froude number of the approach flow increases. On the other hand, it was observed that the percentage of retention of pieces of logs in the grid decreases when the density of the logs increases under subcritical flow conditions. The findings of the present investigation demonstrated the interaction between the density of the wood and the different forms of accumulations of logs and the relationship of the density of the wood with the increase in backwater.

    How to cite: Mallqui, R., Cabrera, J., and Lazóriga, A.: Influence of Wood Density on Backwater Rise due to Large Wood Accumulations, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13483, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13483, 2022.

    EGU22-769 | Presentations | GM10.2 | Highlight

    Sediment supply affects uncertainties and memory in alpine geomorphic systems 

    Jacob Hirschberg, Brian W. McArdell, Georgina L. Bennett, and Peter Molnar

    Geomorphic systems are affected by climate forcing and sediment supply. Due to non-linear relationships of forcings and sediment mobilization, it is debated whether environmental signals are preserved in such systems, or if they are rather dampened or shredded in the sediment output. Tracing the cause and effect in such systems is commonly impossible to do from observations alone. Therefore, numerical models are interesting to study geomorphic system behavior. We use a modeling chain consisting of the SedCas sediment cascade model (Bennett et al., 2014; Hirschberg et al., 2021) and the AWE-GEN stochastic weather generator (Fatichi et al., 2011), which has been calibrated for a debris-flow catchment in the Swiss Alps, the Illgraben, and used for climate change impact assessment (Hirschberg et al., 2021). Here we use this modeling setup to study the long-term behavior of such a system under consideration of different mean erosion rates and sediment production mechanisms. This numerical experiment is unique because we conducted simulations at high temporal resolution (hourly) while also spanning geological time scales (10k years).

    We show that the analysis of short sediment records is characterized by high uncertainties and that especially supply-limited systems are at risk to have underestimated mean sediment. This is in concert with field observations on short- and long-term erosion rates from other basins, and can be attributed to transient hillslope sediment supply to the channel. Furthermore, we demonstrate how large hillslope landslides, or the absence of sediment supply, introduce long-term memory effects which can be quantified in the sediment yield. This long-term memory increases uncertainty and reduces interannual variability in annual sediment yields. Interestingly, details of the actual timing of sediment supply events are shredded and have no discernible impact on sediment yields at the outlet. The study highlights the need of characterizing variability in erosional events with regard to their stochastic nature. Furthermore, these results will corroborate the analysis of erosion rates, support decision making and decrease the risk of misinterpretation both in natural hazard and climate change impact assessment, especially if they are based on short records.

     

    REFERENCES

    Bennett, G. L., P. Molnar, B. W. McArdell, and P. Burlando (2014), A probabilistic sediment cascade model of sediment transfer in the Illgraben, Water Resour. Res., 50, 1225– 1244, doi:10.1002/2013WR013806.

    Fatichi, S., Ivanov, V. Y., & Caporali, E. (2011). Simulation of future climate scenarios with a weather generator. Advances in Water Resources, 34(4), 448-467.

    Hirschberg, J., Fatichi, S., Bennett, G. L., McArdell, B. W., Peleg, N., Lane, S. N., et al. (2021). Climate change impacts on sediment yield and debris- flow activity in an Alpine catchment. Journal of Geophysical Research: Earth Surface, 126, e2020JF005739. https:// doi.org/10.1029/2020JF005739

    How to cite: Hirschberg, J., McArdell, B. W., Bennett, G. L., and Molnar, P.: Sediment supply affects uncertainties and memory in alpine geomorphic systems, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-769, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-769, 2022.

    High-elevation mountainous regions are experiencing an increase in the frequency of mass-wasting processes related to climate-change. Understanding the interplay between the climatic triggers (temperature and precipitation, in particular) and their effects on the dynamics of surface processes is crucial for developing reliable predictive models and for quantifying vulnerability and risk associated with these hazards.

    In this work, we exploit a consolidated statistical-based approach in which triggering conditions are identified as climatic anomalies (i.e., non-exceedance probability below/above the 10th/90th percentile) in temperature and precipitation values at multiple temporal scales occurred in the lead-up of the events triggering. Specifically, we integrate the traditionally used in-situ information from daily weather stations with: (a) high-resolution (0.1°, 30-min) precipitation estimates from the Integrated Multi-Satellite Retrievals from GPM (IMERG) and (b) daily gridded temperature observations from ENSEMBLES OBServation (E-OBS). We investigate the use of these freely available gridded climatological datasets as an integration/surrogate for in-situ measurements.

    Our analysis is based on a database of 358 geomorphic hazards occurred across the Italian Alps in the period 2000-2015, including landslides, rockfalls and debris flows. Preliminary results indicate that IMERG could significantly improve precipitation information by providing estimates directly on the initiation zones, which is particularly relevant in case of hazards triggered by small-scale convective storms. This advantage is evident and in particular for the case of debris flows: IMERG allows to detect precipitation in numerous cases (~60%) for which in-situ data showed no precipitation; in ~19% of these, climatic anomalies (exceedance of the 90th percentile) are detected.

    Further results on the role of sub-daily precipitation processes, particularly relevant for hazards triggered by convective rainfall, such as debris and mud flows, and on the use of temperature data from E-OBS, as being evaluated and will be presented.

    How to cite: Paranunzio, R. and Marra, F.: Climate anomalies and geomorphic hazards in high-mountain regions in the Alps: new perspectives from the integrated use of observations and satellite-based products, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1717, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1717, 2022.

    EGU22-1854 | Presentations | GM10.2

    A warming-induced rainfall heterogeneity accelerates landscape evolution 

    Nadav Peleg, Jorge Alberto Ramirez, Francesco Marra, Chris Skinner, Simone Fatichi, and Peter Molnar

    The hydro-morphological response of a catchment is highly dependent on rainfall properties, including rainfall intensity, storm duration and frequency, and the timing of those events. Furthermore, rainfall spatial variability impacts streamflow, erosion, and sediment transport, and is explored primarily in the context of heavy rainfall triggering floods and rapid morphological changes on hillslopes and in channels. In order to examine the potential effects of warming on hydro-morphological responses, we first examined how changes in air temperature are affecting the spatial structure of rainfall. We observed that heterogeneity increases as temperatures rise. Then, we investigated the sensitivity of fast hydro-morphological responses to increasing temperatures and rainfall heterogeneity scenarios by simulating an extreme rainfall event that occurred in August 2005 in the Kleine Emme stream in Switzerland. The results show that rainfall heterogeneity has a greater impact on erosion processes than simply intensifying high rainfall intensities. We also looked at how changes in rainfall patterns affect landscape evolution over hundreds of years at the catchment scale. Multiple realizations of hourly rainfall fields, each with a different spatial distribution but identical in all other respects, were simulated using a stochastic weather generator, and the impact of the storm heterogeneity on catchment morphology was assessed using a landscape evolution model (CAESAR-Lisflood). We found that erosion and deposition rates increased and net erosion and deposition areas changed (increased and decreased, respectively) when the rain became less uniform in space. Increasing temperatures and rainfall heterogeneity resulted in longer, deeper, and more branched gullies. The results of these studies indicate that heterogeneity in rainfall spatial patterns accelerates landscape development even when rainfall volumes and temporal structures are identical.

    How to cite: Peleg, N., Ramirez, J. A., Marra, F., Skinner, C., Fatichi, S., and Molnar, P.: A warming-induced rainfall heterogeneity accelerates landscape evolution, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1854, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1854, 2022.

    EGU22-4061 | Presentations | GM10.2

    The signature of extreme rainstorms properties on cliff morphology in arid areas 

    Yuval Shmilovitz, Francesco Marra, Yehouda Enzel, Efrat Morin, Moshe Armon, Ari Matmon, Amit Mushkin, Yoav Levi, Pavel Khain, and Itai Haviv

    Climatic impact on landscape morphology was previously demonstrated under pronounced gradients in average climatic properties such as mean annual precipitation or temperature. However, in arid areas, where both meteorological observations and rainfall measurements are scarce and the latter is meager, short-term and highly variable in space and time, the determination of meaningful “average climatic” conditions and their variability is challenging. Although it is generally acknowledged that surface processes in arid landscapes should be effected by short-duration rainfall intensities and their extremes, the topographic sensitivity to storm-scale properties were rarely quantified. Here, we attempted to bridge this gap by documenting systematic precipitation variations along a 40 km arid escarpment (Ramon crater) in the central Negev desert (Israel) and their associated topographic signature.

    We used 0.5 m pixel-1 LiDAR-derived topographic data coupled with field measurements to characterize the morphology of cliffs and slopes along the entire Ramon crater. Sub-hourly rainfall intensities were characterized using an 8-year record of high-resolution, convection-permitting, numerical weather model prediction (NWP). Frequency analyses of rainfall intensity and its spatial variation were conducted using a novel statistical method and used to determine runoff and sediment transport along sub-cliff slopes, through grid-based hydrological simulations of synthetic rainstorms with different frequencies.

    Our results indicate that due to a pronounced decreasing gradient in the number of rain storms per year, the mean annual rainfall decreases from ~100 mm in the southwest (SW) cliff segment to ~40 mm in the northeast (NE) segment. However, in the drier NE cliff segment, extreme rainfall intensities such as the ones occurring during a storm with a 100-year return period are higher. Topographic cliff gradients and the percentage of exposed bedrock over the cliffs increase toward the drier NE cliff section. Sub-cliff slopes in the NE are systematically straighter, shorter, and associated with a smaller clast sizes relative to the wetter (SW) part of the escarpment. Hydrological simulations reveal that under extreme storms, sediment is mobilized by sheetwash on the NE slopes but is less mobile on the wetter SW slopes. In addition, incised gullies and disconnected talus-flatirons are more frequent in the NE and correlate with the higher erosion efficiency of extreme rainstorms in this zone. Our results indicate that significant morphologic differences can be imprinted in arid landforms due to spatial gradients in the properties of extreme rainstorms.  

    How to cite: Shmilovitz, Y., Marra, F., Enzel, Y., Morin, E., Armon, M., Matmon, A., Mushkin, A., Levi, Y., Khain, P., and Haviv, I.: The signature of extreme rainstorms properties on cliff morphology in arid areas, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4061, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4061, 2022.

    EGU22-5929 | Presentations | GM10.2 | Highlight

    CRHyME (Climatic Rainfall Hydrogeological Model Experiment): a versatile geo-hydrological model for climatic scenario and extreme event simulation at basin scale 

    Andrea Abbate, Laura Longoni, Monica Papini, Leonardo Mancusi, and Antonella Frigerio

    In this abstract is described the new model concept called CRHyME (Climatic Rainfall Hydrogeological Model Experiment). This model represents an extended version of the classical spatially distributed rainfall-runoff models. The main novelties are related to:

    • the possibility to have a direct integration with climatic scenario outputs, such as rainfall and temperature field data from NETCDF file format,
    • the physical description of some geo-hydrological hazards strongly related to rainfalls such as shallow landslide, debris flow, watershed erosion and solid transport,
    • the possibility to interact with other hydraulic/landslide models applied through the BMI (Basic Model Interface) approach at finer scale.

    The CRHyME model is intended as a part of a hydrological modelling chain. The aim is to try to interpret the effect of future climate evolution on the local territory, giving a physical-based instrument to fill the gap between broader climatic scale and watershed scale. CRHyME model has been written in PYTHON language, using the PCRaster libraries. It has been inspired by the PCR-GLOWB2 model that was implemented at a global scale to study climate change effects on water resource availability. In this sense, the CRHyME model has been completely rewritten to work at a higher spatial resolution to let the assessment of geo-hydrological hazards using the available worldwide databases about morphology, land coverage, soil composition and hydrogeological properties.

    The versatility of the CRHyME model permits to set also different timesteps of simulations, reproducing for example extreme rainfall events described with sub-hourly data. It is possible to set the model to reproduce watershed behaviour under critical rainfall using the information stored in local IDF (Intensity-Duration-Frequency) curves making CRHyME also suitable for the risks now-casting at the Civil Protection level.

    CRHyME model is currently under development. Remarkable results have been obtained for the study case of the Valtellina catchment in the Alpine region (northern Lombardy, Italy) and three Apennine’s catchments (Emilia region, Italy). After calibration and validation for past occurred events, CRHyME was applied considering three different climatic models from the EUROCORDEX program. According to IPCC Fifth Assessment Report (AR5) indications, the reference period 1986-2005 and the future scenario 2006-2075 under RCP 8.5 were simulated. Several variables were investigated such as maximum daily precipitation, the mean temperature, the maximum daily water discharges, the annual sediment yield, the maximum daily number of triggered shallow landslide and debris flow movements. Statistical test on mean and variance was applied to data series to highlight possible future tendencies in comparison to the reference period. The results have shown a general intensity increase of the geo-hydrological cycle, especially across the Alpine region. Similar results were also assessed from the analysis of the outliers of the sample distributions. This evidence represents a confirmation of the studies carried out by IPCC scientists in respect to the latest updated report in the IPCC Sixth Assessment Report (AR6).

    How to cite: Abbate, A., Longoni, L., Papini, M., Mancusi, L., and Frigerio, A.: CRHyME (Climatic Rainfall Hydrogeological Model Experiment): a versatile geo-hydrological model for climatic scenario and extreme event simulation at basin scale, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5929, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5929, 2022.

    EGU22-279 | Presentations | GM2.7

    Assessment of sensor pre-calibration to mitigate systematic errors in SfM photogrammetric surveys 

    Johannes Antenor Senn, Jon Mills, Claire L. Walsh, Stephen Addy, and Maria-Valasia Peppa

    Remotely piloted airborne system (RPAS) based structure-from-motion (SfM) photogrammetry is a recognised tool in geomorphological applications. However, time constraints, methodological requirements and ignorance can easily compromise photogrammetric rigour in geomorphological fieldwork. Light RPAS mounted sensors often provide inherent low geometric stability and are thus typically calibrated on-the-job in a self-calibrating bundle adjustment. Solving interior (lens geometry) and exterior (position and orientation) camera parameters requires variation of sensor-object distance, view angles and surface geometry.

    Deficient camera calibration can cause systematic errors resulting in final digital elevation model (DEM) deformation. The application of multi-sensor systems, common in geomorphological research, poses additional challenges. For example, the low contrast in thermal imagery of vegetated surfaces constrains image matching algorithms.

    We present a pre-calibration workflow to separate sensor calibration and data acquisition that is optimized for geomorphological field studies. The approach is time-efficient (rapid simultaneous image acquisition), repeatable (permanent object), at survey scale to maintain focal distance, and on-site to avoid shocks during transport.

    The presented workflow uses a stone building as a suitable 3D calibration structure (alternatively boulder or bridge) providing structural detail in visible (DJI Phantom 4 Pro) and thermal imagery (Workswell WIRIS Pro). The dataset consists of feature coordinates extracted from terrestrial laser scanner (TLS) scans (3D reference data) and imagery (2D calibration data). We process the data in the specialized software, vision measurement system (VMS) as benchmark and the widely applied commercial SfM photogrammetric software, Agisoft MetaShape (AM) as convenient alternative. Subsequently, we transfer the camera parameters to the application in an SfM photogrammetric dataset of a river environment to assess the performance of self- and pre-calibration using different image network configurations. The resulting DEMs are validated against GNSS reference points and by DEMs of difference. 

    We achieved calibration accuracies below one-third (optical) and one-quarter (thermal) of a pixel. In line with the literature, our results show that self-calibration yields the smallest errors and DEM deformations using multi-scale and oblique datasets. Pre-calibration in contrast, yielded the lowest overall errors and performed best in the single-scale nadir scenario. VMS consistently performed better than AM, possibly because AM's software “black-box” is less customisable and does not allow purely marker-based calibration. Furthermore, we present findings regarding sensor stability based on a repeat survey.

    We find that pre-calibration can improve photogrammetric accuracies in surveys restricted to unfavourable designs e.g. nadir-only (water refraction, sensor mount). It can facilitate the application of thermal sensors on surfaces less suited to self-calibration. Most importantly, multi-scale survey designs could potentially become redundant, thus shortening flight time or increasing possible areal coverage.

    How to cite: Senn, J. A., Mills, J., Walsh, C. L., Addy, S., and Peppa, M.-V.: Assessment of sensor pre-calibration to mitigate systematic errors in SfM photogrammetric surveys, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-279, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-279, 2022.

    EGU22-344 | Presentations | GM2.7

    A sensitivity analysis of Rillstats for soil erosion estimates from UAV derived digital surface models. 

    Josie Lynch, Derek McDougall, and Ian Maddock
    Fertile topsoil is being eroded ten times faster than it is created which can result in lowered crop yields, increased river pollution, and heightened flood risk (WWF 2018). Traditional methods of soil erosion monitoring are labour-intensive and provide low resolution, sparse point data not representative of overall erosion rates (Báčová et al., 2019). However, technological advances using Uncrewed Aerial Vehicles (UAVs) obtain high-resolution, near-contactless data capture with complete surface coverage (Hugenholtz et al., 2015).  
     

    Typically, analysing UAV-Structure-from-Motion (SfM) derived soil erosion data requires a survey prior to the erosion event with repeat monitoring for change over time to be quantified. However, in recent years the ability of soil erosion estimations without the pre-erosion data has emerged. Rillstats, which is specifically designed to quantify volume loss in rills/gullies, has been developed by Báčová et al., (2019) using the algorithm and Python implementation in ArcGIS to perform automatic calculations of rills. Although this technique has been developed, it is not yet tested. 

    This research evaluates the sensitivity of Rillstats to estimate soil erosion volumes from Digital Surface Models (DSM) obtained using a DJI Phantom 4 RTK UAV. The aims of the research were to test i) the influence of UAV-SfM surveys with varying flight settings and environmental conditions and ii) the effect of the size and shape of the boundary polygon. Results will be presented that analyse the sensitivity of estimations of soil erosion to changes in DSM resolution, image angle, lighting conditions, soil colour and texture to develop recommendations for a best practice to optimize results. 

    How to cite: Lynch, J., McDougall, D., and Maddock, I.: A sensitivity analysis of Rillstats for soil erosion estimates from UAV derived digital surface models., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-344, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-344, 2022.

    EGU22-2513 | Presentations | GM2.7

    Evaluation of UAV-borne photogrammetry and UAV-borne laser scanning for 3D topographic change analysis of an active rock glacier 

    Vivien Zahs, Lukas Winiwarter, Katharina Anders, Magnus Bremer, Martin Rutzinger, Markéta Potůčková, and Bernhard Höfle

    Recent advances in repeated data acquisition by UAV-borne photogrammetry and laser scanning for geoscientific monitoring extend the possibilities for analysing surface dynamics in 3D at high spatial (centimeter point spacing) and temporal (up to daily) resolution. These techniques overcome common challenges of ground-based sensing (occlusion, heterogeneous measurement distribution, limited spatial coverage) and provide a valuable additional data source for topographic change analysis between successive epochs.

    We investigate point clouds derived from UAV-borne photogrammetry and laser scanning as input for change analysis. We apply and compare two state-of-the-art methods for pairwise 3D topographic change quantification. Our study site is the active rock glacier Äußeres Hochebenkar in the Eastern Austrian Alps (46° 50’ N, 11° 01’ E). Whereas point clouds derived from terrestrial laser scanning (TLS) have become a common data source for this application, point clouds derived from UAV-borne sensing techniques have emerged only in recent years and their potential for methods of 3D and 4D (3D + time) change analysis is yet to be exploited.

    We perform change analysis using (1) the Multi Scale Model to Model Cloud Comparison (M3C2) algorithm [1] and (2) the correspondence-driven plane-based M3C2 [2]. Both methods have shown to provide valuable surface change information on rock glaciers when applied to successive terrestrial laser scanning point clouds of different time spans (ranging from 2 weeks to several years). The considerable value of both methods also lies in their ability to quantify the uncertainty additionally to the associated change. This allows to distinguish between significant change (quantified magnitude of change > uncertainty) and non-significant or no change (magnitude of change ≤ uncertainty) and hence enables confident analysis and geographic interpretation of change.

    We will extend the application of the two methods by using point clouds derived using (1) photogrammetric techniques on UAV-based images and (2) UAV-borne laser scanning. We investigate the influence of variations in measurement distribution and density, completeness of spatial coverage and ranging uncertainty by comparing UAV-based point clouds to TLS data of the same epoch. Using TLS-TLS-based change analysis as reference, we examine the performance of the two methods with respect to their capability of quantifying surface change based on point clouds originating from different sensing techniques.

    Results of this assessment can support the theoretical and practical design of future measurement set-ups. Comparing results of both methods further aids the selection of a suitable method (or combination) for change analysis in order to meet requirements e.g., regarding uncertainty of measured change or spatial coverage of the analysis. To ease usability of a broad suite of state-of-the-art methods of 3D/4D change analysis, we are implementing an open source Python library for geographic change analysis in 4D point cloud data (py4dgeo, www.uni-heidelberg.de/3dgeo-opensource). Finally, our presented study provides insights how methods for 3D and 4D change analysis should be adapted or developed in order to exploit the full potential of available close-range sensing techniques.

    [1] https://doi.org/ 10.1016/j.isprsjprs.2013.04.009

    [2] https://doi.org/10.1016/j.isprsjprs.2021.11.018

    How to cite: Zahs, V., Winiwarter, L., Anders, K., Bremer, M., Rutzinger, M., Potůčková, M., and Höfle, B.: Evaluation of UAV-borne photogrammetry and UAV-borne laser scanning for 3D topographic change analysis of an active rock glacier, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2513, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2513, 2022.

    The main type of research material is multi-season aerial photography of the oil mining karst river basin was carried out by unmanned aerial vehicle.

    Visual photo delineation revealed the consequences of mechanical transformations, some hydrocarbon inputs (bitumization) and salts (technogenic salinization) were also identified. The last processes were verified using materials from direct geochemical surveys (chemical analyses of soils, surface waters and sets of ordinary photo of sample plots).

    It has been established that mechanical transformations, as a rule, is detected by the color and shape of objects. Less often, it is necessary to additionally analyze indirect photo delineation signs: shape of the shadow, configuration of the borders, traces of heavy vehicle tracks. Photo delineation signs of technogenic salinization are turbidity of water and the acquisition of a bluish-whitish color; the change of the color of the water body to green-yellow; white ground salt spots. The bituminization process is sufficiently reliably identified only in the presence of open oil spills on the surface of soil or water. Despite the difficulty of photo delineation, the use of orthophotos allows to identify 13 new sites (26 in total in the studied area) of the processes of bitumization and technogenic salinization, which had not been noted during previous large-scale field survey.

    The use of orthophotos to detect the processes of bitumization and technogenic salinization is effective, especially in combination with direct field studies. Conditions for using aerial photography to identify the consequences of oil mining technogenesis: pixel resolution should be equals or more precise than 20 cm / pixel (more desirable – equals or more precise than 10 cm / pixel), snowless shooting season, lack or low level of cloud cover, relatively low forest cover percent. The spatial distribution of the identified areas of all types of technogenesis indicates a close relationship with the location of oil mining facilities.

    A promising direction for the development of the research is associated with the use of multispectral imaging, the improvement of attend field surveys, as well as the expansion of the experience of aerial photography of oil fields located in other natural conditions.

    The reported study was funded by Russian Foundation for Basic Research (RFBR) and Perm Territory, project number 20-45-596018.

    How to cite: Sannikov, P., Khotyanovskaya, Y., and Buzmakov, S.: Applicability of aerial photography for identifying of oil mining technogenesis: mechanical transformations, bitumization, technogenic salinization, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2643, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2643, 2022.

    EGU22-3163 | Presentations | GM2.7

    Comparison of 3D surfaces from historical aerial images and UAV acquisitions to understand glacier dynamics: The Aneto glacier changes in 40 years 

    Ixeia Vidaller, Jesús Revuelto, Eñaut Izagirre, Jorge García, Francisco Rojas-Heredia, and Juan Ignacio López-Moreno

    Pyrenean glaciers have shown a marked area and thickness decrease in the last century, especially in the last decades, and currently are highly threatened by climate change. Out of the 39 glaciers existing in the Pyrenees in 1984, 23 very small glaciers remain in this mountain range, from which only four have more than 10 ha. Probably, the most emblematic glacier of these four is Aneto glacier as it is located in the North-East face of the highest summit in the Pyrenees, the Aneto peak (3404 m a.s.l.). This work presents the Aneto glacier surface reconstruction from aerial images obtained in 1981, and its comparison with the glacier surface obtained in 2021 with Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAV) images.

    The 1981 and 2021 images have been processed with Structure from Motion (SfM) algorithms to reconstruct the Digital Surface Model (DSM) of the glacier and nearby terrain. Taking advantage of the accurate geolocation of the UAV images in 2021 (GPS with RTK/PPK surveying), the DSM obtained has a precise representation of the glacier surface. Oppositely the aerial images of 1981 lack precise geolocation and thus require a post-processing analysis. The aerial images of the '80s have been firstly geolocated with Ground Control Points (GCPs) of known coordinates within the study area (summits, crests, and rock blocks with unaltered position). After this initial geolocation, the DSM of 1981 was generated with SfM algorithms. Nevertheless, this DSM still lacks a geolocation accuracy. To allow a comparison between the 1981 and the 2021 DSMs, the glacier surface in 1981 was registered to the 2021 surface with an Iterative Close Point (ICP) routine in the surrounding area of the glacier. The technique described in this work may be applicable to other historical aerial images, which may allow studying glacier evolutions all over the world for dates without field observations.

    The surface comparison generated with images that have a temporal difference of 40 years has shown the dramatic area and thickness loss of this glacier, with areas decreasing more than 68 m, and an average thickness reduction of 31.5 m. In this period, the glacier has reduced its extent by about a 60%. There is a recent acceleration in the rate of shrinkage if we compare these data with the obtained for the period 2011-2021, in which area loss reaches 15% and thickness reduction almost reaches 10 m. During the 1981-2021 period the shrinkage rate is 0.78 m thickness/year and 1.5% area/year, meanwhile, during the 2011-2021 period the shrinkage rate is 0.99 m thickness/year and 2.7% area/year.

    How to cite: Vidaller, I., Revuelto, J., Izagirre, E., García, J., Rojas-Heredia, F., and López-Moreno, J. I.: Comparison of 3D surfaces from historical aerial images and UAV acquisitions to understand glacier dynamics: The Aneto glacier changes in 40 years, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3163, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3163, 2022.

    EGU22-3516 | Presentations | GM2.7

    Uncertainty of grain sizes from close-range UAV imagery in gravel bars 

    David Mair, Ariel Henrique Do Prado, Philippos Garefalakis, Alessandro Lechmann, and Fritz Schlunegger

    Data on grain sizes of pebbles in gravel-bed rivers are a well-known proxy for sedimentation and transport conditions, and thus a key quantity for the understanding of a river system. Therefore, methods have been developed to quantify the size of gravels in rivers already decades ago. These methods involve time-intensive fieldwork and bear the risk of introducing sampling biases. More recently, low-cost UAV (unmanned aerial vehicle) platforms have been employed for the collection of referenced images along rivers with the aim to determine the size of grains. To this end, several methods to extract pebble size data from such UAV imagery have been proposed. Yet, despite the availability of information on the precision and accuracy of UAV surveys, a systematic analysis of the uncertainty that is introduced into the resulting grain size distribution is still missing.

    Here we present the results of three close-range UAV surveys conducted along Swiss gravel-bed rivers with a consumer-grade UAV. We use these surveys to assess the dependency of grain size measurements and associated uncertainties from photogrammetric models, in turn generated from segmented UAV imagery. In particular, we assess the effect of (i) different image acquisition formats, (ii) specific survey designs, and (iii) the orthoimage format used for grain size estimates. To do so, we use uncertainty quantities from the photogrammetric model and the statistical uncertainty of the collected grain size data, calculated through a combined bootstrapping and Monte Carlo (MC) modelling approach.

    First, our preliminary results suggest some influence of the image acquisition format on the photogrammetric model quality. However, different choices for UAV surveys, e.g., the inclusion of oblique camera angles, referencing strategy and survey geometry, and environmental factors, e.g., light conditions or the occurrence of vegetation and water, exert a much larger control on the model quality. Second, MC modelling of full grain size distributions with propagated UAV uncertainties shows that measured size uncertainty is at the first order controlled by counting statistics, the selected orthoimage format, and limitations of the grain size determination itself, i.e., the segmentation in images. Therefore, our results highlight that grain size data are consistent and mostly insensitive to photogrammetric model quality when the data is extracted from single, undistorted orthoimages. This is not the case for grain size data, which are extracted from orthophoto mosaics. Third, upon looking at the results in detail, they reveal that environmental factors and specific survey strategies, which contribute to the decrease of the photogrammetric model quality, also decrease the detection of grains during image segmentation. Thereby, survey conditions that result in a lower quality of the photogrammetric model also lead to a higher uncertainty in grain size data.

    Generally, these results indicate that even relative imprecise and not accurate UAV imagery can yield acceptable grain size data for some applications, under the conditions of correct photogrammetric alignment and a suitable image format. Furthermore, the use of a MC modelling strategy can be employed to estimate the grain size uncertainty for any image-based method in which individual grains are measured.

    How to cite: Mair, D., Do Prado, A. H., Garefalakis, P., Lechmann, A., and Schlunegger, F.: Uncertainty of grain sizes from close-range UAV imagery in gravel bars, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3516, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3516, 2022.

    Near-continuous time series of 3D point clouds capture local landscape dynamics at a large range of spatial and temporal scales. These data can be acquired by permanent terrestrial laser scanning (TLS) or time lapse photogrammetry, and are being used to monitor surface changes in a variety of natural scenes, including snow cover dynamics, rockfalls, soil erosion, or sand transport on beaches.

    Automatic methods are required to analyze such data with thousands of point cloud epochs (acquired, e.g., hourly over several months), each representing the scene with several million 3D points. Usually, no a-priori knowledge about the timing, duration, magnitude, and spatial extent of all spatially and temporally variable change occurrences is available. Further, changes are difficult to delineate individually if they occur with spatial overlap, as for example coinciding accumulation processes. To enable fully automatic extraction of individual surface changes, we have developed the concept of 4D objects-by-change (4D-OBCs). 4D-OBCs are defined by similar change histories within the area and timespan of single surface changes. This concept makes use of the full temporal information contained in 3D time series to automatically detect the timing and duration of changes. Via spatiotemporal segmentation, individual objects are spatially delineated by considering the entire timespan of a detected change regarding a metric of time series similarity (cf. Anders et al. 2021 [1]), instead of detecting changes between pairs of epochs as with established methods.

    For hourly TLS point clouds, the extraction of 4D-OBCs improved the fully automatic detection and spatial delineation of accumulation and erosion forms in beach monitoring. For a use case of snow cover monitoring, our method allowed quantifying individual change volumes more accurately by considering the timespan of changes, which occur with variable durations in the hourly 3D time series, rather than only instantaneously from one epoch to the next. The result of our time series-based method is information-rich compared to results of bitemporal change analysis, as each 4D-OBC contains the full 4D (3D + time) data of the original 3D time series with determined spatial and temporal extent.

    The objective of this contribution is to present how interpretable information can be derived from resulting 4D-OBCs. This will provide new layers that are supporting subsequent geoscientific analysis of observed surface dynamics. We apply Kalman filtering (following Winiwarter et al. 2021 [2]) to model the temporal evolution of individually extracted 4D-OBCs. This allows us to extract change rates and accelerations for each point in time, and to subsequently derive further features describing the temporal properties of individual changes. We present first results of this methodological combination and newly obtained information layers which can reveal spatial and temporal patterns of change activity. For example, deriving the timing of highest change rates may be used to examine links to external environmental drivers of observed processes. Our research therefore contributes to extending the information that can be extracted about surface dynamics in natural scenes from near-continuous time series of 3D point clouds.

    References:

    [1] https://doi.org/10.1016/j.isprsjprs.2021.01.015

    [2] https://doi.org/10.5194/esurf-2021-103

    How to cite: Anders, K., Winiwarter, L., and Höfle, B.: Automatic Extraction and Characterization of Natural Surface Changes from Near-Continuous 3D Time Series using 4D Objects-By-Change and Kalman Filtering, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4225, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4225, 2022.

    EGU22-4522 | Presentations | GM2.7

    Morphological evolution of volcanic crater through eruptions and instabilities: The case of Ol Doinyo Lengaï since the 2007-08 eruption 

    Pierre-Yves Tournigand, Benoît Smets, Kate Laxton, Antoine Dille, Michael Dalton-Smith, Gian Schachenmann, Christelle Wauthier, and Matthieu Kervyn

    Ol Doinyo Lengaï (OL) in north Tanzania is the only active volcano in the world emitting natrocarbonatite lavas. This stratovolcano (2962 m a.s.l) is mostly characterized by effusive lava emissions since 1983. However, on the 4th of September 2007, explosive events marked the beginning of a new eruptive style that lasted until April 2008. This new phase involved short-lived explosive eruptions that generated volcanic ash plumes as high as 15 km during its paroxysmal stage. This explosive activity resulted in the formation of a 300 m wide and 130 m deep crater in place of the growing lava platform that had filled the crater since 1983. Since then the effusive activity at OL resumed within the crater and has been partially filling it over the last 14 years. Due to the remote location of the volcano there is a lack of monitoring of its activity and, hence, its eruptive and morphological evolution over the last years is not well constrained (e.g., emission rates, number of vents, unstable areas). This absence of monitoring, preventing the detection of features, such as instabilities of the summit cone, could have hazard implications for the tourists regularly visiting the summit area.

    In this study, we quantify the evolution of OL crater area over the last 14 years by reconstructing its topography at regular time interval. We collated several sources of optical images including Unoccupied Aircraft Systems (UAS) images, videos and ground-based pictures that have been collected over the period 2008-2021 by scientists and tourists. Those data have been sorted by year and quality in order to reconstruct the most accurate topographical models using Agisoft Metashape Pro, a software for Structure from Motion (SfM) photogrammetry, and CloudCompare a 3D point cloud processing software. This enables estimating the emitted volume of lava, the emission rate and the remaining crater volume available before crater overflow. It also allows identifying punctual events, such as hornito formation or destruction, and partial crater collapses. Our results indicate that the main lava emission area has repeatedly moved over the years within the crater floor and that OL’s effusion rate has been increasing over the last few years, with more than two times higher lava emission in the period 2019-2021 compared to 2017-2019. Assuming a similar lava effusion rate in the coming years, the crater could again be filled within the next decade leading to new lava overflows. There is thus a need for periodic assessment of the situation at OL. New cost- and time-effective photogrammetry techniques, including UAS and SfM processing, offer a solution to improve the monitoring of such remote volcanoes.

    How to cite: Tournigand, P.-Y., Smets, B., Laxton, K., Dille, A., Dalton-Smith, M., Schachenmann, G., Wauthier, C., and Kervyn, M.: Morphological evolution of volcanic crater through eruptions and instabilities: The case of Ol Doinyo Lengaï since the 2007-08 eruption, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4522, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4522, 2022.

    EGU22-4763 | Presentations | GM2.7

    Using high-resolution topography to solve “periglacial puzzles”: A semi-automated approach to monitor solifluction movement 

    Marije Harkema, Jana Eichel, Wiebe Nijland, Steven de Jong, Daniel Draebing, and Teja Kattenborn

    Solifluction is the slow downslope movement of soil mass due to freeze-thaw processes. It is widespread on hillslopes in Polar and Alpine regions and contributes substantially to sediment transport. As solifluction lobe movement is in the order of millimeters to centimeters per year, it is tricky to measure with a high spatial and temporal resolution and accuracy. We developed a semi-automated approach to monitor movement of three solifluction lobes with different degrees of vegetation cover along an elevational gradient between 2,170 and 2,567 m in Turtmann Valley, Swiss Alps. Subsequently, we compared movement rates and patterns with environmental factors.

    • For solifluction movement monitoring, we applied a combination of the Phantom 4 Pro Plus and Phantom 4 RTK (Real Time Kinematic) drones, image co-alignment and COSI-CORR (Co-registration of Optically Sensed Images and Correlation) to track movement on orthophotos between 2017 and 2021. This drone data acquisition and co-alignment procedure enable a simple, time-saving field setup without Ground Control Points (GCPs).
    • Our high co-registration accuracy enabled us to detect solifluction movement if it exceeds 5 mm with sparse vegetation cover. Dense vegetation cover limited feature tracking but detected movement rates and patterns still matched previous measurements using classical total station measurements at the lowest, mostly vegetated lobe.
    • In contrast to traditional solifluction monitoring approaches using point measurements, our monitoring approach provides spatially continuous movement estimates across the complete extend of the lobe. Lobe movement rates were highest at the highest elevations between 2,560 and 2,567 m (up to 14.0 cm/yr for single years) and lowest at intermediate elevations between 2,417 and 2,427 m (up to 2.9 cm/yr for single years). We found intermediate movement rates at lowest elevations between 2,170 and 2,185 m (up to 4.9 cm/yr for single years). In general, movement had the highest rates at the solifluction lobes center and the lowest rates at the front of solifluction lobes.
    • We linked observed movement patters to environmental factors possibly controlling solifluction movement, such as geomorphic properties, vegetation species and coverage, soil properties determined from electrical resistivity tomography (ERT), and soil temperature data. The least movement at the lobe front is characterized by coarse material and plant species stabilizing the risers or plant species growing here due to the stable risers. Most movement at the lobe center is characterized by fine material and no vegetation or plant species promoting movement. The soil temperature data further suggests that snow cover reduced freezing rates at solifluction lobes and potentially decreased solifluction movement at the lobe between 2,417 and 2,427 m.

    This study is the first to demonstrate the use of drone-based images and a semi-automated method to reach high spatiotemporal resolutions to detect subtle movements of solifluction lobes at timescales of years at sub-centimeter resolution. This provides new insights into solifluction movement and into drivers of and factors controlling solifluction movement and lobe development. Therefore, our semi-automated approach may have a great potential to uncover the fundamental processes to understand solifluction movement.

    How to cite: Harkema, M., Eichel, J., Nijland, W., de Jong, S., Draebing, D., and Kattenborn, T.: Using high-resolution topography to solve “periglacial puzzles”: A semi-automated approach to monitor solifluction movement, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4763, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4763, 2022.

    EGU22-6894 | Presentations | GM2.7

    Rapid formation of a bedrock canyon following gravel mining in the Marecchia River, Northern Apennines. 

    Manel Llena, Tommaso Simonelli, and Francesco Brardinoni

    River canyons are characteristic features of transient fluvial systems responding to perturbations in base level and/or sediment supply. Investigating the dynamics of canyon formation and development is challenging due to the typically long time scales and the possible experimental confounding involved. In this context, the lower portion of the Marecchia River, with a history of gravel mining on alluvial deposits resting on highly erodible (i.e., claystones and poorly consolidated sands) bedrock, offers the opportunity to set up a natural experiment and investigate the onset of canyon incision and its subsequent stages of development across five decades (1955-1993). To these ends, we evaluate decadal geomorphic changes of 10-km valley segment of the Marecchia River between Ponte Verucchio and Rimini (Northern Italy) through analysis of Digital Elevation Models derived from the application of Structure from Motion to archival aerial imagery (i.e., 1955, 1969, 1976, 1985, 1993) and from a reference-LiDAR survey (i.e. 2009), in conjunction with analysis of planimetric changes in active channel width and lateral confinement.

    During the 1955-2009 period, fluvial incision led to the formation of a 6-km canyon, with average vertical incision of about 15 m (in places exceeding 25 m) and a corresponding annual knickpoint migration rate of about 100 m/yr. In volumetric terms, canyon formation and evolution has involved 6.1 106 m3 (95%) of degradation and 0.29 106 m3 of aggradation (5%), with a corresponding net volume loss of 5.8 106 m3. As a result of canyon development, the active channel has narrowed by about 80%, and channel pattern has drastically changed from braided unconfined to single-thread tightly confined one. These processes were especially important during the 1955-1993 period. Since 1993 to the present, main channel is characterized by a general stability of the active channel width with evidences of a slight recovery through mass wasting processes within it. Local disturbance associated with ongoing canyon development have propagated and are still propagating upstream, posing immediate threat to infrastructures.

    How to cite: Llena, M., Simonelli, T., and Brardinoni, F.: Rapid formation of a bedrock canyon following gravel mining in the Marecchia River, Northern Apennines., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6894, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6894, 2022.

    EGU22-7374 * | Presentations | GM2.7 | Highlight

    Expanding glacier time series of Antarctica and Greenland using Soviet Era KFA-1000 satellite images 

    Flora Huiban, Mads Dømgaard, Luc Girod, Romain Millan, Amaury Dehecq, Jeremie Mouginot, Anders Schomacker, Eric Rignot, and Anders Bjørk

    Long-term records of glaciers are more than ever crucial to understand their response to climate change. High-quality photogrammetric products, Digital Elevation Models (DEMs) and orthophotographs from early satellites are essential, as they offer a unique high-resolution view on the historical glacial dynamics. However, obtaining and producing high-resolution datasets from historical imagery can be a challenge.

    In our study, we are extending available satellite images time series using images from Soviet Era KFA-1000 satellite cameras. Each KFA-1000 has a 1000 mm objective, holding 1800 frames in its magazine. Each frame is typically 18x18 cm or 30 × 30 cm, with an 80 km swath width, providing panchromatic images. They supplement the very sparse data period between aerial images and high-resolution modern satellites, giving us high-resolution insight of Antarctica and Greenland dating from 1974 to 1994. Since these images have been largely underused, they have the potential to improve our knowledge of glaciers and open new scientific perspectives. They could help us improve models in studies regarding, for instance the frontal position, the flow-velocity (by doing feature tracking), the surface elevation or the grounding line of the glaciers, etc. With a spatial resolution up to 2 m and images recorded in stereo geometry, they offer a valuable complement to other historical satellite archives such as the declassified American KH imagery. Here, we use structure-from-motion (SfM) to reconstruct former glacier surfaces and flow of main outlet glaciers in both Antarctica and Greenland. We compare and assess the quality of the results by comparing the produced DEMs with recent high-resolution imagery from Worldview’s ArcticDEM. We combine the historical DEMs with recent satellite imagery of the ice elevation and reconstruct the comprehensive history of volume change over southeast and northeast Greenland glaciers since the 90s. Mostly lost from sight for 50 years, we are now resurrecting these highly valuable records and will make them freely available to science and the public.

     

    How to cite: Huiban, F., Dømgaard, M., Girod, L., Millan, R., Dehecq, A., Mouginot, J., Schomacker, A., Rignot, E., and Bjørk, A.: Expanding glacier time series of Antarctica and Greenland using Soviet Era KFA-1000 satellite images, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7374, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7374, 2022.

    EGU22-7686 | Presentations | GM2.7

    Comparison of deep learning methods for colorizing historical aerial imagery 

    Shimon Tanaka, Hitoshi Miyamoto, Ryusei Ishii, and Patrice Carbonneau

    Historical aerial imagery dating back to the mid-twentieth century offers high potential to distinguish anthropogenic impacts from natural causes of environmental change and reanalyze the long-term surface evolution from local to regional scales. However, the older portion of the imagery is often acquired in panchromatic grayscale thus making image classification a very challenging task.  This research aims to compare deep learning image colorisation methods, namely, , the Neural Style Transfer (NST) and the Cycle Generative Adversarial Network (CycleGAN), for colorizing archival images of Japanese river basins for land cover analysis. Historical monochrome images were examined with `4096 x 4096` pixels of three river basins, i.e., the Kurobe, Tenryu, and Chikugo Rivers. In the NST method, we used the transfer learning model with optimal hyperparameters that had already been fine-tuned for the river basin colorization of the archival river images (Ishii et al., 2021). As for the CycleGAN method, we trained the CycleGAN with 8000 image tiles of `256 x256` pixels to obtain the optimal hyperparameters for the river basin colorization. The image tiles used in training consisted of 10 land-use types, including paddy fields, agricultural lands, forests, wastelands, cities and villages, transportation land, rivers, lakes, coastal areas, and so forth. The training result of the CycleGAN reached an optimal model in which the root mean square error (RMSE) of colorization was 18.3 in 8-bit RGB color resolution with optimal hyperparameters of the dropout ratio (0.4), cycle consistency loss (10), and identity mapping loss (0.5). Colorization comparison of the two-deep learning methods gave us the following three findings. (i) CycleGAN requires much less training effort than the NST because the CycleGAN used an unsupervised learning algorithm. CycleGAN used 8000 images without labelling for training while the NST used 60k with labelling in transfer learning. (ii) The colorization quality of the two methods was basically the same in the evaluation stage; RMSEs in CycleGAN were 15.4 for Kurobe, 13.7 for Tenryu and 18.7 for Chikugo, while RMSE in NST were 9.9 for Kurobe, 15.8 for Tenryu, and 14.2 for Chikugo, respectively. (iii) The CycleGAN indicated much higher performance on the colorization of dull surfaces without any textual features, such as the river course in Tenryu River, than the NST. In future research work, colorized imagery by both the NST and CycleGAN will be further used for land cover classification with AI technology to investigate its role in image recognition. [Reference]: Ishii, R. et al.(2021) Colorization of archival aerial imagery using deep learning, EGU General Assembly 2021, EGU21-11925, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu21-11925.

    How to cite: Tanaka, S., Miyamoto, H., Ishii, R., and Carbonneau, P.: Comparison of deep learning methods for colorizing historical aerial imagery, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7686, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7686, 2022.

    EGU22-7967 | Presentations | GM2.7

    Time-lapse stereo-cameras and photogrammetry for continuous 3D monitoring of an alpine glacier 

    Francesco Ioli, Alberto Bianchi, Alberto Cina, Carlo De Michele, and Livio Pinto

    Photogrammetry and Structure-from-Motion have become widely assessed tools for geomorphological 3D reconstruction, and especially for monitoring remote and hardly accessible alpine environments. UAV-based photogrammetry enables large mountain areas to be modelled with high accuracy and limited costs. However, they still require a human intervention on-site. The use of fixed time-lapse cameras for retrieving qualitative and quantitative information on glacier flows have recently increased, as they can provide images with high temporal frequency (e.g., daily) for long-time spans, and they require minimum maintenance. However, in many cases, only one camera is employed, preventing the use of photogrammetry to compute georeferenced 3D models. This work presents a low-cost stereoscopic system composed of two time-lapse cameras for continuously and quantitatively monitoring the north-west tongue of the Belvedere Glacier (Italian Alps), by using a photogrammetric approach. Each monitoring station includes a DSLR camera, an Arduino microcontroller for camera triggering, and a Raspberry Pi Zero with a SIM card to send images to a remote server through GSM network. The instrumentation is enclosed in waterproof cases and mounted on tripods, anchored on big and stable rocks along the glacier moraines. The acquisition of a defined number of images and the timing can be arbitrary scheduled, e.g., 2 images per day acquired by each camera, around noon. A set of ground control points is materialized on stable rocks along the moraines and measured with topographic-grade GNSS receivers at the first epoch to orient stereo-pairs of images. From daily stereo-pairs, 3D models are computed with the commercial Structure from Motion software package Agisoft Metashape, and they can be used to detect morphological changes in the glacier tongue, as well as to compute daily glacier velocities. The work is currently focused on improving the orientation of stereo-pairs: the use of computer vision algorithms is under study to automatize the process and increase the robustness of consecutive orientation of stereo-images, e.g., by including images coming from different epochs in the same bundle block adjustment and dividing them afterwards for dense 3D reconstruction. Change detection can be then computed from 3D point clouds by using M3C2 algorithms. Although the stereoscopic system is already installed on the Belvedere Glacier and it is properly taking daily images of the glacier tongue, the processing workflow of stereo-pairs needs to be tuned and automatized to enable high-accurate continuous 3D photogrammetric monitoring of an alpine glacier, computing short-term and infra-seasonal ice volume variations and velocities, as well as detecting icefalls.

    How to cite: Ioli, F., Bianchi, A., Cina, A., De Michele, C., and Pinto, L.: Time-lapse stereo-cameras and photogrammetry for continuous 3D monitoring of an alpine glacier, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7967, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7967, 2022.

    EGU22-8738 | Presentations | GM2.7 | Highlight

    Review on the processing and application of historical aerial and satellite spy images in geosciences 

    Camillo Ressl, Amaury Dehecq, Thomas Dewez, Melanie Elias, Anette Eltner, Luc Girod, Robert McNabb, and Livia Piermattei

    Historical aerial photographs captured since the early 1900s and spy satellite photographs from the 1960s onwards have long been used for military, civil, and research purposes in natural sciences. These historical photographs have the unequalled potential for documenting and quantifying past environmental changes caused by anthropogenic and natural factors.

    The increasing availability of historical photographs as digitized/scanned images, together with the advances in digital photogrammetry, have heightened the interest in these data in the scientific community for reconstructing long-term surface evolution from local to regional scale.

    However, despite the available volume of historical images, their full potential is not yet widely exploited. Currently, there is a lack of knowledge of the types of information that can be derived, their availability over the globe, and their applications in geoscience. There are no standardized photogrammetric workflows to automatically generate 3D (three-dimensional) products, in the form of point clouds and digital elevation models from stereo images (i.e. images capturing the same scenery from at least two positions), as well as 2D products like orthophotos. Furthermore, influences on the quality and the accuracy of the products are not fully understood as they vary according to the image quality (e.g. photograph damage or scanning properties), the availability of calibration information (e.g. focal length or fiducial marks), and data acquisition (e.g. flying height or image overlap).

    We reviewed many articles published in peer reviewed journals from 2010 to 2021 that explore the potential of historical images, covering both photogrammetric reconstruction techniques (methodological papers) and the interpretation of 2D and 3D changes in the past (application papers) in different geoscience disciplines such as geomorphology, cryosphere, volcanology, bio-geosciences, geology and archaeology. We present an overview of these published studies and a summary of available image archives. In addition, we compare the main methods used to process historical aerial and satellite images, highlighting new approaches. Finally, we provide our advice on image processing and accuracy assessment.

    How to cite: Ressl, C., Dehecq, A., Dewez, T., Elias, M., Eltner, A., Girod, L., McNabb, R., and Piermattei, L.: Review on the processing and application of historical aerial and satellite spy images in geosciences, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8738, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8738, 2022.

    EGU22-9799 | Presentations | GM2.7

    Coastal erosion dynamics of high-Arctic rock walls: insights from historical to recent orthoimages and DEMs 

    Juditha Aga, Livia Piermattei, Luc Girod, and Sebastian Westermann

    The thermal regime of permafrost, as well as the retreat of sea ice, influence coastal erosion in Arctic environments. Warming permafrost temperatures might lead to enhanced instabilities, while shorter periods of sea ice expose coastal cliffs to waves and tides for longer periods. Although most studies focus on erosion rates in ice-rich permafrost, coastal cliffs and their permafrost thermal regime are still poorly understood.

    In this study, we investigate the long-term evolution of the coastline along Brøgger Peninsula (~30 km2), Svalbard. Based on high-resolution aerial orthophotos and, when available, digital elevation model (DEMs) we automatically derive the coastline from 1936 (Geyman et al., 2021), 1970, 1990, 2011 and 2021. Therefore, we quantified coastal erosion rates along the coastal cliffs over the last 85 years. Due to their high spatial resolution and accuracy, the two DEMs from 1970 and 2021 are used to calculate the erosion volumes within this time. Elevation data and coastline mapping from 2021 is validated with dGPS measurements from August 2021 along three transects of the coastline. In addition, we measured surface temperature of the coastal bedrock from September 2020 to August 2021.

    Our preliminary results show erosion rates along the coastal cliffs of Brøgger Peninsula. Uncertainties remain due to mapping issues, which include resolution of aerial images and DEMs, and shadow effects. Overall, historical aerial images combined with recent data provide insight into coastal evolution in an Arctic environment where permafrost temperatures are close to the thaw threshold and might become prone to failure in future.

     

    Geyman, E., van Pelt, W., Maloof, A., Aas, H. F., & Kohler, J. (2021). 1936/1938 DEM of Svalbard [Data set]. Norwegian Polar Institute. https://doi.org/10.21334/npolar.2021.f6afca5c

    How to cite: Aga, J., Piermattei, L., Girod, L., and Westermann, S.: Coastal erosion dynamics of high-Arctic rock walls: insights from historical to recent orthoimages and DEMs, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9799, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9799, 2022.

    EGU22-10060 | Presentations | GM2.7

    Automated mapping of Soil Surface Components (SSCs) in highly heterogeneous environments with Unoccupied Aerial Systems (UAS) and Deep Learning: working towards an optimised workflow 

    Eva Arnau-Rosalén, Ramón Pons-Crespo, Ángel Marqués-Mateu, Jorge López-Carratalá, Antonis Korkofigkas, Konstantinos Karantzalos, Adolfo Calvo-Cases, and Elias Symeonakis

    Pattern recognition remains a complex endeavour for ‘structure/function’ approaches to ecosystem functioning. It is particularly challenging in dryland environments where spatial heterogeneity is the inherent functional trait related with overland flow redistribution processes. Within this context, the concept of Soil Surface Components (SSCs) emerged, representing Very-High-Resolution (VHR) hydrogeomorphic response units. SSCs are abstraction entities where spatial patterns of the soil surface and erosional functional processes are linked, according to a large pool of experimental evidence.  

    Τhis abstraction complexity, particularly in the abiotic domain, has  so far mandated the use of on-screen visual photointerpretation for the mapping of SSCs, thus limiting the extent of the study cases and their potential for providing answers to the ongoing research discourse. Although significant advances have been achieved with regards to the VHR mapping of vegetation traits with either shallow or deep machine learning algorithms, mapping the full range of SSCs requires bridging the existing gap related with the abiotic domain.

    The current confluence of technical advances in: (i) Unoccupied Aerial Systems (UAS), for VHR image acquisition and high geometric accuracy; (2) photogrammetric image processing (e.g. Structure from Motion, SfM), for accurately adding the third dimension, and (3) Deep Learning (DL) architectures that consider the spatial context (i.e. Convolutional Neural Networks, CNN), offers an unprecedented opportunity for achieving the pattern recognition quality required for the automated mapping of SSCs.

    We decompose this complex issue with a stepwise approach in an attempt to optimise protocols across all stages of the entire process. For the initial step of image acquisition, we focus on the design of optimal UAS flight parameters, particularly with regards to flight height and image resolution, as this relates to the scale of the analysis: a critical issue for hillslope and catchment scale surveys. At the core of the methodological framework, we then approach the challenge of mapping the patchy mosaic of SSCs as a hierarchical image segmentation problem, decomposed into classification (i.e. discrete) and regression (i.e. continuous fields) tasks, required for dealing with the biotic (e.g. vegetation) and abiotic (e.g. fractional cover of rock fragments) domains, respectively.

    Our pilot study area is a hillslope transect near Benidorm, a representative case in semi-arid environment of SE Spain. In this area, the mapping of SSCs was previously undertaken via visual image interpretation. We obtain satisfactory results that allow for the differentiation of plant physiognomies (i.e. annual herbaceous, shrubs, perennial tussock grass and trees). Regarding the abiotic SSCs, in addition to the identification of rock outcrops, we are also able to quantify the fractional cover of rock fragments (RF): an improvement to the visual photointerpretation of only three intervals of RF coverage. A number of challenges remain, such as the position of RF and the transferability of our methodological framework to sites with different lithological and climatological properties.

    How to cite: Arnau-Rosalén, E., Pons-Crespo, R., Marqués-Mateu, Á., López-Carratalá, J., Korkofigkas, A., Karantzalos, K., Calvo-Cases, A., and Symeonakis, E.: Automated mapping of Soil Surface Components (SSCs) in highly heterogeneous environments with Unoccupied Aerial Systems (UAS) and Deep Learning: working towards an optimised workflow, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10060, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10060, 2022.

    EGU22-10190 | Presentations | GM2.7 | Highlight

    Historical Structure From Motion (HSfM): An automated historical aerial photography processing pipeline revealing non-linear and heterogeneous glacier change across Western North America 

    Friedrich Knuth, David Shean, Chistopher McNeil, Eli Schwat, and Shashank Bhushan

    Mountain glaciers are responding in concert to a warming global climate over the past century. However, on interannual to decadal time scales, glaciers show temporally non-linear dynamics and spatially heterogeneous response, as a function of regional climate forcing and local geometry. Deriving long-term geodetic glacier change measurements from historical aerial photography can inform efforts to understand and project future response. 

    We present interannual to decadal glacier and geomorphic change measurements at multiple sites across Western North America from the 1950s until present. Glacierized study sites differ in terms of glacial geometry and climatology, from continental mountains (e.g., Glacier National Park) to maritime stratovolcanoes (e.g., Mt. Rainier). Quantitative measurements of glacier and land surface change are obtained from Digital Elevation Models (DEMs) generated using the Historical Structure from Motion (HSfM) package. We use scanned historical images from the USGS North American Glacier Aerial Photography (NAGAP) archive and other aerial photography campaigns from the USGS EROS Aerial Photo Single Frames archive. 

    The automated HSfM processing pipeline can derive high-resolution (0.5-2.0 m) DEMs and orthomosaics from scanned historical aerial photographs, without manual ground control point selection. We apply a multi-temporal bundle adjustment process using all images for a given site to refine both extrinsic and intrinsic camera model parameters, prior to generating DEMs for each acquisition date. All historical DEMs are co-registered to modern reference DEMs from airborne lidar, commercial satellite stereo or global elevation basemaps. The co-registration routine uses a multi-stage Iterative Closest Point (ICP) approach to achieve high relative alignment accuracy amongst the historical DEMs, regardless of reference DEM source. 

    We examine the impact of regional climate forcing on glacier elevation change and dynamics using downscaled climate reanalysis products. By augmenting the record of quantitative glacier elevation change measurements and examining the relationship between climate forcing and heterogeneous glacier response patterns, we aim to improve our understanding of regional glacier mass change across multiple temporal scales, as well as inform management decisions impacting downstream water resources, ecosystem preservation, and geohazard risks.

    How to cite: Knuth, F., Shean, D., McNeil, C., Schwat, E., and Bhushan, S.: Historical Structure From Motion (HSfM): An automated historical aerial photography processing pipeline revealing non-linear and heterogeneous glacier change across Western North America, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10190, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10190, 2022.

    EGU22-10513 | Presentations | GM2.7

    Using UAS-based LiDAR data to quantify oyster reef structural characteristics for temporal monitoring 

    Michael C. Espriella, Vincent Lecours, H. Andrew Lassiter, and Benjamin Wilkinson

    Given the global decline in oyster reef coverage, conservation and restoration efforts are increasingly needed to maintain the ecosystem services these biogenic features offer. However, monitoring and restoration are constrained by a lack of continuous quantitative metrics to effectively assess reef health. Traditional sampling methods typically provide a limited perspective of reef status, as sampling areas are just a fraction of the total reef area. In this study, an unoccupied aircraft system collected LiDAR data over oyster reefs in Cedar Key, FL, USA to develop digital surface models (DSMs) of their 3D structure. Ground sampling was also conducted in randomly placed quadrats to enumerate the live and dead oysters within each plot. Over 20 topographic complexity metrics were derived from the DSM, allowing relationships between various geomorphometric measures and reef health to be quantified. These data informed generalized additive models that explained up to 80% of the deviation of live to dead oyster ratios in the quadrats. While topographic complexity has been associated with reef health in the past, this process quantifies the relationships and indicates what metrics can be relied on to efficiently monitor intertidal oyster reefs using DSMs. The models can also inform restoration efforts on which surface characteristics are best to replicate when building restored reefs.  

    How to cite: Espriella, M. C., Lecours, V., Lassiter, H. A., and Wilkinson, B.: Using UAS-based LiDAR data to quantify oyster reef structural characteristics for temporal monitoring, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10513, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10513, 2022.

    EGU22-10597 | Presentations | GM2.7

    Semantic segmentation of historical images in Antarctica with neural networks 

    Felix Dahle, Roderik Lindenbergh, Julian Tanke, and Bert Wouters

    The USGS digitized many historical photos of Antarctica which could provide useful insights into this region from before the satellite era. However, these images are merely scanned and do not contain semantic information, which makes it difficult to use or search this archive (for example to filter for cloudless images). Even though there are countless semantic segmentation methods, they are not working properly with these images. The images are only grayscale, have often a poor image quality (low contrast or newton’s rings) and do not have very distinct classes, for example snow/clouds (both white pixels) or rocks/water (both black pixels). Furthermore, especially for this archive, these images are not only top-down but can also be oblique.

    We are training a machine-learning based network to apply semantic segmentation on these images even under these challenging conditions. The pixels of each image will be labelled into one of the six different classes: ice, snow, water, rocks, sky and clouds. No training data was available for these images, so that we needed to create it ourselves. The amount of training data is therefore limited due to the extensive amount of time required for labelling. With this training data, a U-Net was trained, which is a fully convolutional network that can work especially with fewer training images and still give precise results.

    In its current state, this model is trained with 67 images, split in 80% training and 20% validation images. After around 6000 epochs (approx. 30h of training) the model converges and training is stopped. The model is evaluated on 8 randomly selected images that were not used during training or validation. These images contain all different classes and are challenging to segment due to quality flaws and similar looking classes. The model is able to segment the images with an accuracy of around 75%. Whereas some classes, like snow, sky, rocks and water can be recognized consistently, the classes ice and clouds are often confused with snow. However, the general semantic structure of the images can be recognized.

    In order to improve the semantic segmentation, more training imagery is required to increase the variability of each class and prepare the model for more challenging scenes. This new training data will include both labelled images from the TMA archive and from other historical archives in order to increase the variability of classes even more. It should be checked if the quality of the model can be further improved by including metadata of the images as additional data sources.

    How to cite: Dahle, F., Lindenbergh, R., Tanke, J., and Wouters, B.: Semantic segmentation of historical images in Antarctica with neural networks, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10597, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10597, 2022.

    EGU22-10943 | Presentations | GM2.7

    High-resolution topography project on the rock walls of the Mont-Blanc massif to reconstruct volume change 

    Daniel Uhlmann, Michel Jaboyedoff, Marc-Henri Derron, Ludovic Ravanel, Joelle Vicari, Charlotte Wolff, Li Fei, Tiggi Choanji, and Carlota Gutierrez

    Before modern remote sensing techniques, quantifying rock wall retreat due to rockfall events in the high alpine environment was limited to low-frequency post-event measurements for high-magnitude events. LiDAR and SFM now provide precise and accurate 3D models for computing 3D volume changes over time. Otherwise, mid- and low-sized events can remain unobserved due to the remoteness of the rockwalls and the lack of remnant evidence due to the rapid sequestration of ice in surrounding valley and cirque glaciers. To extend rockfall event measurement an initial measurement (t0) is necessary. The Mont-Blanc Massif (MBM, European Alps) High Resolution Topography Project is currently completing high-precision 3D models in the MBM using ground-based and aerial LiDAR, and drone-based structure-from-motion (SFM). In 2021, we began acquisition with initial measurements of 11 major sectors of the massif, representing about 80 km2 of rock and ice slopes, between 1700m - 4810m in elevation. By choosing a study area with robust existent photographic and film archives, such as the MBM, it is possible to extend 3D models back in time for comparison with current datasets. Despite existent high-quality image archives, SFM processing is more challenging and error-prone than from contemporary images due to a lack of metadata, such as camera and lens type, precise dates of images, and the general degradation of the original material.  Despite these limitations, the use of historical-image-based SFM in combination with modern LiDAR data can allow the reconstruction of significant slopes of the MBM over several decades in order to i) obtain estimates of erosion rates, ii) to document rockfall events, and iii) to quantify the extent change and volume loss of hanging glaciers and ice aprons. We thus explore geomorphic processes in the high mountain environment in context of warming climate, as well as the limits of input data (image sets) in terms of practical output resolution.

    How to cite: Uhlmann, D., Jaboyedoff, M., Derron, M.-H., Ravanel, L., Vicari, J., Wolff, C., Fei, L., Choanji, T., and Gutierrez, C.: High-resolution topography project on the rock walls of the Mont-Blanc massif to reconstruct volume change, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10943, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10943, 2022.

    EGU22-11081 | Presentations | GM2.7

    Extraction of geomorphological entities from unstructured point clouds – a three-dimensional level-set-based approach 

    Reuma Arav, Florian Poeppl, and Norbert Pfeifer

    The use of 3D point clouds has become ubiquitous in studying geomorphology. The richness of the acquired data, together with the high availability of 3D sensing technologies, enables a fast and detailed characterisation of the terrain and the entities therein. However, the key for a comprehensive study of landforms relies on detecting geomorphological features in the data. These entities are of complex forms that do not conform to closed parametric shapes. Furthermore, they appear in varying dimensions and orientations, and they are often seamlessly embedded within the topography. The large volume of the data, uneven point distribution and occluded regions present even a greater challenge for autonomous extraction. Therefore, common approaches are still rooted in utilising standard GIS tools on rasterised scans, which are sensitive to noise and interpolation methods. Schemes that investigate morphological phenomena directly from the point cloud use heuristic and localised methods that target specific landforms and cannot be generalised. Lately, machine-learning-based approaches have been introduced for the task. However, these require large training datasets, which are often unavailable in natural environments.

    This work introduces a new methodology to extract 3D geomorphological entities from unstructured point clouds. Based on the level-set model, our approach does not require training datasets or labelling, requires little prior information about existing objects, and wants minor adjustments between different types of scenes. By developing the level-set function within the point cloud realm, it requires no triangulated mesh or rasterisation. As a driving force, we utilise visual saliency to focus on pertinent regions. As the estimation is performed pointwise, the proposed model is completely point-based, driven by the geometric characteristics of the surface. The result is three-dimensional entities extracted by their original points, as they were scanned in the field. We demonstrate the flexibility of the proposed model on two fundamentally different datasets. In the first scene, we extract gullies and sinkholes in an alluvial fan and are scanned by an airborne laser scanner. The second features pockets, niches and rocks in a terrestrially scanned cave. We show that the proposed method enables the simultaneous detection of various geomorphological entities, regardless of the acquisition technique. This is facilitated without prior knowledge of the scene and with no specific landform in mind. The proposed study promotes flexibility of form and provides new ways to quantitatively describe the morphological phenomena and characterise their shape, opening new avenues for further investigation.

    How to cite: Arav, R., Poeppl, F., and Pfeifer, N.: Extraction of geomorphological entities from unstructured point clouds – a three-dimensional level-set-based approach, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11081, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11081, 2022.

    EGU22-12200 | Presentations | GM2.7

    Terrain Change Detection with ICESat-2: A Case Study of Central Mountain Range in Taiwan 

    Pin-Chieh Pan and Kuo-Hsin Tseng

    Ice, Cloud, and land Elevation Satellite 2 (ICESat-2), part of NASA's Earth Observing System, is a satellite mission for measuring ice sheet elevation as well as land topography. ICESat-2 is equipped with the Advanced Topographic Laser Altimeter System (ATLAS), a spaceborne lidar that provides topography measurements of land surfaces around the globe. This study intends to utilize ICESat-2 ATL03 elevation data to identify the outdated part in Taiwan’s Digital Elevation Model (DEM). Because the update of DEM takes time and is relatively expensive to renew by airborne LiDAR, a screen of elevation change is crucial for planning the flight route. ICESat-2 has not only a dense point cloud of elevation but also a short revisit time for data collection. That is, ICESat-2 may have a chance to provide a reference for the current condition of terrain formation.

    In this study, we aim to verify the 20-meter DEM from the Ministry of the Interior, Taiwan, by ICESat-2 elevation data. The goal is to find out the patches that have experienced significant changes in elevation due primarily to landslides. We select a typical landslide hillside in southern Taiwan as an example, and compare the DEM with ICESat-2 ATL03 photon-based heights before and after the occurrence of landslide events. In our preliminary results, the comparison of DEM and ICESat-2 ATL03 heights has a high degree of conformity inaccuracy (within meter level), indicating ICESat-2’s ability for DEM renewal.

    How to cite: Pan, P.-C. and Tseng, K.-H.: Terrain Change Detection with ICESat-2: A Case Study of Central Mountain Range in Taiwan, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12200, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12200, 2022.

    EGU22-348 | Presentations | GM4.1 | Highlight

    Review on deep-seated landslides in the Carpathians under climate variability/change and their implication in hazard assessment 

    Mirela Vasile, Flavius Sîrbu, Răzvan Popescu, Dana Micu, and Mihai Micu

    In mountain regions, landslides are enhancing the short- to long-term slope denudation and sediment delivery, conditioning the general landscape evolution; meanwhile, their regional typological patterns should be properly incorporated into single- to multi-hazard evaluations for a proper mitigation of consequences and risk management strategies development.  The Carpathians are an elongate and twisted young mountainous chain of Europe, which is continuing the Alpine orogenetic system towards the internal, Central and Eastern parts of the continent, covering parts of Austria, Czech Republic, Slovakia, Poland, Ukraine, Romania and Serbia. Their heterogeneous morphological and litho-structural forming conditions, the regional climatic traits and the extremely complex and complicated political and socio-economical development stages resulted in a landslide-prone environment, as outlined through numerous scientific works. Nevertheless, there is little synthesis information which can allow a clear evaluation of the entire mountain chain, highlighting the importance of such a study in the present-day context of climate variability and change analysis. As part of the broad landslide typological spectrum, the deep-seated landslides are important paleo-environmental witnesses which may offer substantial information within the risk management and resilience construction context under the modern challenges of climate change impact evaluation. The complexity (many times site-specific) of deep-seated landslides susceptibility and hazard evaluation is enhanced by the (very) high magnitude of such processes, marking with a substantial share the evolution of the coupled slope and channel morphodynamic systems, an interface usually prone to the development of human activities, thus driving the fundamental understanding of their morphogenesis towards highly applied exposure analysis, vulnerability evaluations and risk mitigation concerns. In order to obtain a full extent evaluation of the implication of deep-seated landslides in hazard assessment, a consistent literature review was performed. Several key-issues in understanding the complexity of hazard evaluation, from inventory to susceptibility and frequency/magnitude or triggering thresholds and their return periods were studied: predisposition traits (structure, lithology, terrain/elevation models), preparing conditions (neotectonics, seismicity, human influence, climate variability), triggering factors (precipitation and climate change, earthquakes, anthropic activities), landslide inventories (graphic representations and spatio-temporal coverage), susceptibility modelling (in terms of methods, purpose, units, validation methods, existence of sensitivity analysis), triggering thresholds (scale, typologically-adapted or not, theoretical/validated, recurrences, EWS or  forecast systems) and hazard evaluation (scale, typologically-adapted or not, theoretical/validated, expressed in terms of  susceptibility, relative hazard or hazard). The purpose of this paper is to harmonize for the first time at the entire mountain chain’s continental scale the information concerning the role of deep-seated landslides inside the complex hazard assessment framework. A special attention is directed towards climate variability/change related implications, since the Carpathians, through their more internal, continental position, are representing a key environment for the assessment of continental climate change adaptation strategies.

    How to cite: Vasile, M., Sîrbu, F., Popescu, R., Micu, D., and Micu, M.: Review on deep-seated landslides in the Carpathians under climate variability/change and their implication in hazard assessment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-348, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-348, 2022.

    EGU22-1038 | Presentations | GM4.1 | Highlight

    Basin-scale sediment transport and sediment concentration-discharge relationship modeling in a permafrost-dominated basin 

    Ting Zhang, Dongfeng Li, Albert J. Kettner, and XiXi Lu

    Permafrost degradation by ongoing climate warming has expanded the erodible thermokarst landscapes, enhanced the thermal erosion, and altered the sediment transport processes in cryosphere basins. Thermal-activated sediment sources and enhanced sediment export due to developed hillslope-channel connectivity can increase the annual sediment flux and accelerate the sediment response to hydroclimatic disturbances, thus complicating suspended sediment concentration (SSC) and discharge (Q) relationships and forming various hysteretic patterns. Yet, the commonly used sediment rating curve (SSC=a×Qb with a and b as static fitting parameters) is unable to capture the SSC-Q hysteretic patterns and most single-event-scale hysteresis models mainly emphasize the pluvially enhanced sediment transport (e.g. rainstorms), but overlook the thermally-erosional processes.

    To rebuild dynamic SSC-Q relationships and hysteresis in sediment transport in cryosphere basins, we propose a Sediment-Availability-Transport (SAT) model by extending traditional rating curves to incorporate the time-varying sediment availability regulated by thermal-fluvial processes and long-term storage exhaustion. In the SAT-model, increased thermal erosion is represented by basin temperature; enhanced fluvial erosion is represented by runoff increase; sediment transport capacity is represented by total runoff. Specifically, thawing permafrost as temperature rising can enhance sediment generation by forming active layer detachment, retrogressive thaw slump, and thermal erosion gully from hillslopes, and fluvio-thermal erosion along the riverbank, associated with a time-lag in the sediment response due to the time for temperature accumulation to melt cryosphere and long-travel distance from thermal-activated sediment sources to the basin outlet. A surge in basin water supply during intense rainfall and excessive melting with a certain time-lag can increase sediment availability and fluvial erosion by flushing the erodible slope and scouring the river channel. Moreover, sediment storage is assumed to be continuously depleted throughout a hydrological year and leads to sediment exhaustion.

    With the support of multi-decadal daily SSC and Q in-situ observations (1985-2017), the SAT-model can be parameterized and validated in the permafrost-dominated Tuotuohe basin on Tibetan Plateau. In Tuotuohe, thermal erosion processes are found to be best captured by an eight-day average temperature, associated with an exponential amplification of SSC. Fluvial erosion is best captured by a two-day runoff increase and shows a linear amplification of SSC. Moreover, the warming-wetting climate over the past decades has expanded the thermokarst landscapes and boosted the slope-channel connectivity by thermal gullies, which leads to the significant inter/intra-annual variation in SSC-Q relationships and reduces the performance of the sediment rating curve. Yet, the SAT-model can robustly reproduce the long-term evolution, seasonality, and various event-scale hysteresis of SSC, including clockwise, counter-clockwise, figure-eight, counter-figure-eight, and more complex hysteresis loops. Overall, the SAT-model can explain over 75% of long-term SSC variance, outperforming the sediment rating curve approach by 20%, with stable performance under an abrupt hydroclimate change.

    Part of the results is also published in Water Resources Research: Zhang et al., 2021. Constraining dynamic sediment-discharge relationships in cold environments: The sediment-availability-transport (SAT) model.;. Li et al., 2021. Air temperature regulates erodible landscape, water, and sediment fluxes in the permafrost dominated catchment on the Tibetan Plateau.

    How to cite: Zhang, T., Li, D., J. Kettner, A., and Lu, X.: Basin-scale sediment transport and sediment concentration-discharge relationship modeling in a permafrost-dominated basin, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1038, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1038, 2022.

    Denudation, including both chemical and mechanical processes, is controlled by a range of environmental drivers and is in most environments and landscapes worldwide significantly affected by anthropogenic activities. In the boreal mountain environment of central Norway the regulated lake Selbusjøen, situated at ca. 160 m a.s.l. with an area of 58 km2 and connecting the upstream main mountain river Nea and the downstream main river Nidelva, forms a significant sink for sediments being transferred from its drainage basin area of in total 2876 km2.  The significant sediment trapping efficiency of lake Selbusjøen is causing a sediment deficit and locally increased fluvial erosion and down-cutting in the downstream river Nidelva which drains into the Trondheim fjord.

    This ongoing GFL research on contemporary denudation rates in undisturbed and anthropogenically modified surface areas of the boreal mountain basin of lake Selbusjøen builds on year-round process geomorphological field work including high-resolution monitoring of runoff, solute and sediment fluxes in selected catchments or drainage areas draining into Selbusjøen. The selected catchment or drainage area systems are characterized by high shares of surface areas with a nearly closed and continuous vegetation cover mostly composed of boreal forests and bogs, and represent a range of different catchment sizes, catchment morphometries, orientations/aspects, and sediment sources and sediment availabilities. Different types and intensities of direct anthropogenic impacts like, e.g., agriculture, forestry, and modifications of natural stream channels (e.g., dams, steps, bank protection) and channel discharge for water power purposes are found in the different selected catchments.

    Runoff is occurring year-round and the natural runoff regime is clearly nival. Most fluvial transport is occurring during peak-runoff events generated by snowmelt, rainfall events or combinations of snowmelt and rainfall.  Altogether, chemical denudation is moderate but dominates clearly over mechanical fluvial denudation. While chemical denudation is not significantly affected by anthropogenic impacts, mechanical fluvial denudation shows significantly higher rates in surface areas that are modified by anthropogenic activities like agriculture and forestry. At the same time, anthropogenic stream channel and channel discharge modifications are leading to reduced fluvial bedload transport rates into lake Selbusjøen.

    Ongoing and accelerated climate change with the related changes of the current wind, temperature and precipitation regimes are expected to increase fluvial denudation and sediment transport rates into lake Selbusjøen, particularly in surface areas that have been modified by anthropogenic activities.

    How to cite: Beylich, A. A. and Laute, K.: Contemporary denudation rates in undisturbed and anthropogenically modified surface areas of the boreal mountain basin of a regulated lake system in central Norway, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1766, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1766, 2022.

    EGU22-1991 | Presentations | GM4.1

    Understanding sedimentary provenance and sub-surface lithostratigraphy of Central Gangetic Basin 

    Oindrila Bose, Abhijit Mukherjee, Probal Sengupta, Ashok Shaw, Prerona Das, Mrinal Kanti Layek, and Martin Smith

    River Ganges, being one of the largest trans-boundary river, flows along the northern part of the Indian subcontinent contributes sediment to, one of the largest alluvial basin in the world, the Indo-Gangetic basin. The basin is composed of sediments sourced from the Himalayas and also from peninsular India. This river has experienced rapid and multiple migrations through its geological history and varied fluvial geomorphic processes, tectonic controls and complex climatic interplay have led to the deposition of different lithofacies within this Central Ganges basin (CGB). A provenance study has been started in the CGB in order to understand its geological evolution and reconstruct the regional paleo-environment through subsurface lithostratigraphy. Initial X-ray diffraction data of borehole sediments in CGB shows dominant presence of quartz, feldspar, mica and heavy minerals in varying proportions at different depths. Substantial amounts of kaolinite, smectite, illite and montmorilonite are found in descending proportions within the upper clay layers, where abundance of kaolinite is significantly higher over the other minerals. The upper layers till ~30m comprises of clay having particle size of 2.42μm- 3.12μm, below which are mostly silt and sand layers ranging from 16.4 μm -1.63mm, with fine intercalations of gravel and clay layers in-between.The upper layers are dominated by muscovite indicating a Himalayan origin of the sediments, which shows a sharp decline in abundance below 100 m bgl. Moreover, presence of only zircon as heavy mineral is noted within 100m bgl. In contrast, beyond 100m bgl, the sediments are represented by very low mica content, abundance of pyroxene, and heavy minerals like zircon, rutile, illmanite, and sphene possibly signifying contribution from cratonic areas. Significant quantities of recrystallized and highly altered quartz-feldspathic mass showing clear evidence of strain, are also observed. The disposition of sediments from multiple provenances confirms significant contribution of sediment load from southern tributaries of the Ganges river system which eventually diminishes with time due to temporal and spatial migration of the river.

    How to cite: Bose, O., Mukherjee, A., Sengupta, P., Shaw, A., Das, P., Layek, M. K., and Smith, M.: Understanding sedimentary provenance and sub-surface lithostratigraphy of Central Gangetic Basin, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1991, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1991, 2022.

    EGU22-2245 | Presentations | GM4.1

    P mobilization by an extreme rainfall event and its spatial variability in an agroforestry South-Pyrenean catchment 

    Maria Concepción Ramos, Ivan Lizaga, Leticia Gaspar, and Ana Navas

    High intensity rainfall events produce not only significant soil losses but also nutrient losses which act as important sources of water pollution. In particular, those erosion processes contribute significantly to phosphorous (P) losses and its transportation along the catchments. The high-intensity events that occurred during the last decade and the projected increase under climate change scenarios, suggest the need for a more in-depth analysis of the associated effect of rainfall on the mobilization and export of P from a catchment. Nevertheless, the P losses are influenced not only by rainfall characteristics but also by land use and by soil properties. The agricultural lands have been pointed out as the main contributor to P losses, but other landscape elements should be taken into account. In addition, the form in which P is linked to soil particles also conditions the processes. The aim of this research was to evaluate the effects of an extraordinary event on P mobilization in areas under different land use in an agroforestry catchment of the South Pyrenean region (Aragón, Spain), as well as the variability in the processes along the channel beds in three nested subcatchments. P concentrations in soils under different land use and the sediments in the channels were assessed before and after an extreme event in three nested sub-catchments and related to other soil properties. The results showed that in the study catchment, P was mostly linked to the mineral fraction (mainly to silicates), while the binding between P and OM was only observed in the soils under forest land use. The high intensity rainfall event produced a significant change in the particle size distribution with the loss of fine material (clay and silt) and OM leading to an enrichment of the sediments in P. It was also confirmed that, in addition to the agricultural lands, which had the highest P concentration and were more prone to suffer erosion and contribute to P release, the channel banks and the own beds of the channels should be considered as contributors to P exportation. The higher P concentration in the channel beds after the extreme events leads to higher P levels exposed to be eroded. The variability of P concentration along the nested channels was in agreement with the increase of magnitude of the erosion processes along the streams.

    How to cite: Ramos, M. C., Lizaga, I., Gaspar, L., and Navas, A.: P mobilization by an extreme rainfall event and its spatial variability in an agroforestry South-Pyrenean catchment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2245, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2245, 2022.

    During the second half of 20th century, in the central part of the Călimani Mountains (Eastern Carpathians, Romania), the mining activities for sulfur-rich ore extraction and processing resulted in significant morphological changes. Hydrogeomorphic processes, i.e., debris flows originating in the spoil heap area produced in the last decades an increasing volume of sediments transferred along the stream channels. In this mining area, very limited information exist about the frequency and spatial extent of debris flow activity. To bridge the gap between the increasing need of information regarding debris flow patterns and the data provided by the costly field monitoring methods, dendrogeomorphic methods allow to document the spatial extent and temporal frequency of debris-flow activity in forested areas. Dendrogeomorphic approach rely on the identification of growth anomalies recorded by the annual rings of trees disturbed by debris flows. This method proven to be a viable tool for reconstruction of past natural debris flows occurring mountainous areas, but recently few dendrogeomorphic studies have focused also on reconstructing anthropogenically-induced debris flows. The main aim of this study is to apply dendrogeomorphic methods to reconstruct debris flow chronology in mining area of Cǎlimani Mts. Trees living along debris-flow channels below the spoil heaps, which exhibited clear external signs of disturbances (stem wounding) caused by the mechanical impact of past debris-flows were sampled. The growth anomalies, e.g., scars identified within the annual rings of the disturbed trees served to date the occurrence of debris-flows events with a seasonal resolution. In the study area, tree-ring analyses allowed the reconstruction of the past debris-flow events, spanning the period 1970–2021. Reconstructed debris flow frequencies and return periods indicate an increase of debris flow activity over the last two decades. Further studies will attempt to link the seasonality of reconstructed events and the analysis of meteorological patterns characterizing debris flow triggering rainfall events in the study area.

    How to cite: Pop, O., Rusu, A., and Horvath, C.: Seasonality of debris-flow events in the mining area of Călimani Mountains (Eastern Carpathians, Romania) inferred from tree rings, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3575, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3575, 2022.

    EGU22-3861 | Presentations | GM4.1

    Fingerprinting approach to trace sedimentary and contaminant sources in a canalized section of the Scheldt river (Northern France) for watershed management 

    Dylan Laurence, Christine Franke, Claire Alary, Marion Delplanque, and Laurent De Windt

    Watershed management is an important issue throughout Europe. A key point is that business activities that prosper through fluvial transport require optimal conditions of navigation, leading to a double problematic. On one hand, urbanization, industrial, and agricultural activities have evolved to intensifying inflow to water ways (run off and effluents). Input of particulate matter to river networks has hampered functionality of water gates and fluvial circulation. On the other hand, due to human activities (industry, wastewater treatment plants, domestic and agricultural drains), particulate matter may become a contamination vector in the fluvial realm and thus may degrade sediment and water quality.

    The territorial direction of the Voies Navigables de France (VNF) of the Nord-Pas-de-Calais is responsible of the maintenance of all water ways in the Northern France region. Regular dredging campaigns are necessary to maintain optimal navigation conditions, which produces ~100.000 m3 of sediment waste each year. VNF has the ambition to both prevent particle and contaminant inputs into the water ways and valorize the dredged sediments. However, this is not feasible without a detailed knowledge of the contribution of particulate matter sources, which requires a source-to-sink approach for both sediments and contaminants.

     

    The present study aims to spatialize and quantify the contribution of particulate matter sources and their role on the sediment contamination using a sediment fingerprint approach (e.g. Haddadchi et al., 2013). The focus is on the canalized Denain-Trith reach of the Scheldt River which presents an important sediment accrual (about 18.000 m3/year) contaminated by heavy metals (Zn, Pb, Cd) and organic compounds.

    Geochemical and mineralogical analyses were performed on about 200 riverbed sediments and 30 topsoil samples by powder X-ray diffraction, X-ray fluorescence, ICP-MS, and chemo-analytical methods adapted to organic compounds (RRLC-MS/MS, HPLC-MS). This set of analyses is used as tracers of the different particulate sources. Effluent samples are also analyzed to evaluate the contribution of anthropogenic inputs. Preliminary results have already demonstrated the spatial distribution of metal contamination in the reach, which can be related to spot sources, and led to a first estimation of their respective contributions. Geostatistical analyses (such as kriging) will be further used to assess the impact of contaminant sediment accrual on the sediment source quantification (Alary and Demougeot-Renard, 2010).

    Alary, C., Demougeot-Renard, H., 2010. Factorial Kriging Analysis As a Tool for Explaining the Complex Spatial Distribution of Metals in Sediments. Environ. Sci. Technol. 44, 593–599. https://doi.org/10.1021/es9022305

    Haddadchi, A., Ryder, D.S., Evrard, O., Olley, J., 2013. Sediment fingerprinting in fluvial systems: review of tracers, sediment sources and mixing models. International Journal of Sediment Research 28, 560–578. https://doi.org/10.1016/S1001-6279(14)60013-5

    How to cite: Laurence, D., Franke, C., Alary, C., Delplanque, M., and De Windt, L.: Fingerprinting approach to trace sedimentary and contaminant sources in a canalized section of the Scheldt river (Northern France) for watershed management, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-3861, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-3861, 2022.

    EGU22-4280 | Presentations | GM4.1 | Highlight

    Landslides in the Tovel Valley: shaping the landscape and ruling the people 

    Sandro Rossato, Silvana Martin, Susan Ivy-Ochs, Alfio Viganò, Paolo Campedel, and Manuel Rigo

    Landslides are very efficient in shaping mountain landscapes, modifying the drainage pattern of the valleys, forcing people to adapt, react or counter them. In particular, valleys in the southern side of the Alps are narrow, with very steep slopes, and often have been inhabited since prehistoric times.

    The Tovel Valley is located in the Adamello Brenta Nature Park in the northern Brenta Dolomites, near a lake (Tovel lake) that is famous for its, at times, red colour. This valley can be found in the central-eastern Southern Alps, along the western margin of the Adriatic indenter. Here, tectonic forces started to act in the Late Cretaceous, during the initial phases of the Alpine orogenic history, and are still active today. Moreover, the Trentino Region is one of the most seismically active sectors of Northern Italy, with significant historical and instrumental earthquakes typically clustered in very good agreement with tectonic structures. N-S oriented vertical strike-slip faults determined the shape of the Tovel Valley, favouring the occurrence of prominent source detachment scarps on the eastern valley side. The Tovel lake, whose origin is still debated if due to glacial processes or landslide events, records a sudden rise in its level, testified by the drowning of a submerged forest dated by dendrochronology at 1597 AD. This event is interpreted as due to a minor rockfall, which blocked the outflow channel on the north-eastern lakeside. This event had direct consequences on people living in the area, that were forced to find timber elsewhere, but also older, and larger, rock avalanches likely affected people living in the valley.

    Whilst Tovel lake has been studied for a long time, the blocky deposits of the Tovel Valley gathered much less attention. By means of field mapping, remote sensing and cosmogenic 36Cl exposure dating, we reconstruct the age and the evolution of the blocky deposits that occupy large areas of the valley bottom, with implications directly connected to the formation and evolution of the Tovel lake. Landslide deposits cover an area of ~5 km2 and are composed of seven bodies distributed at different elevations, ranging from ~1900 to ~900 m a.s.l. Their total volume is estimated at 200–280 Mm3 of debris made of Dolomia Principale and Calcare di Zu Formations. Detachment areas are mainly located along the eastern valley side, with six out of seven events that can be classified as rock avalanches.

    How to cite: Rossato, S., Martin, S., Ivy-Ochs, S., Viganò, A., Campedel, P., and Rigo, M.: Landslides in the Tovel Valley: shaping the landscape and ruling the people, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4280, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4280, 2022.

    EGU22-4510 * | Presentations | GM4.1 | Highlight

    Enormous erosion in mining areas during the 2021 July flood in western Germany: Examples from the Inde and Erft River 

    Frank Lehmkuhl, Georg Stauch, Philipp Schulte, Stefanie Wolf, and Catrina Brüll

    Extreme precipitation and resulting extraordinary discharge on July 15th 2021 caused serious flooding and erosion in the northern foreland of the Eifel Mountains, western Germany. We provide two examples of strong backward erosion and sedimentation events from two open cast mining areas in North Rhine-Westphalia (NRW). The first one from the catchment of the Inde River close to Lamersdorf and the lignite open cast mining Inden; the second one from the catchment area of the Erft River near the village of Blessem and the local gravel mining. On-site fieldwork was supported by surveys of unoccupied aerial systems (UAS). Subsequent structure-from-motion (SfM) analyses were compared with the 1 m digital elevation model of the state NRW to estimate size and volume of the erosion and to provide the basis for a geomorphological mapping approach.

    At the Inde River between 1998 and 2005 a new river course was created due to the eastward extension of the lignite mining Inden. The 4 km long course of the Inde River was abandoned and today the river relocation, “new Inde River”, passes the mining area in a ~12 km long river bend to the west. At the junction of the new and old river course a flood protection dam was constructed to avoid the flooding of the lignite mining. After heavy rainfall on July 15th bankfull discharge of the Inde River resulted in a spill over at the junction and the reoccupation of parts of the old river channel. As the lignite mining is more than 200 m below the surface, rapid erosion of the old channel and fast backward erosion creates a 540 m long gorge which was about 5 m deep. More than 500.000 m³ of material were eroded and subsequently accumulated in the lignite mining area.

    At the Erft River flooding of a 60 m deep gravel pit occurred and backward erosion quickly reaches the nearby settlement Blessem resulting in the destruction and damage of several houses. In Blessem, first the settling basin of the gravel pit was flooded on July 15th 2021, resulting in backward erosion of the flood protection dams and finally in a large canyon. An area of more than 7 ha eroded until a depth of 8 m to max. 14m and more than 530,000 m³ sediment were transported into the nearby gravel pit. The new erosion level of the Erft River was about 3 m below its previous base. The original 60 m deep gravel pit was filled with water and about 30 meters of sediments. The digital elevation model and the aerial images indicate three morphdynamic phases of this flood event, with different direction of backward erosion and sediment transport.

    Both areas show semi-circle like structures caused by the backward erosion at the headwalls. Immediately deposited material in the headwalls during the event slowed down the erosion processes. Both examples show the high risk and strong geomorphological processes in flooded open-cast mining areas with large base-level changes on short distances.

    How to cite: Lehmkuhl, F., Stauch, G., Schulte, P., Wolf, S., and Brüll, C.: Enormous erosion in mining areas during the 2021 July flood in western Germany: Examples from the Inde and Erft River, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4510, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4510, 2022.

    This paper outlines a recording schema for features, events, processes and data identified by decimal latitude-longitude locations. Such geolocation is preferable to using only names or geomorphic features because points, areas and lines can be uniquely identified, represented on a GIS (or Google Earth) and (ideally) searched for in any literature (geomorphic, hydrological, tectonic, ecological etc). It is thus useful for location and integrating ‘critical zone’ studies and to develop knowledge management systems. Such systems would include geolocated data points in tables, diagrams or as maps. Downslope transects, on hillslopes most notably, can be identified by geolocated points appended to a bearing. This bearing will generally be downslope to provide a pathline that can be associated with data points corresponding to e.g. downhill movement, fluxes, material properties, dated surfaces as well as locations that may correspond to geomorphic features. Transects may link not just surface features or ‘processes’ but represent a flowline in continuum mechanics. Data points can be referenced according to either/or/both Eulerian and Lagrangian schemes as appropriate. The schema also suggests sharing data and interoperability for measurement methods and data that will be especially useful for modelling purposes.

    How to cite: Whalley, W. B.: Towards better long-term integration of earth science data from landscape scale to detail studies, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4630, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4630, 2022.

    EGU22-5075 | Presentations | GM4.1 | Highlight

    Initial soil formation in an artificial river valley - Interplay of anthropogenic landscape shaping and fluvial dynamics 

    Philipp Schulte, Hendrik Hamacher, Frank Lehmkuhl, and Verena Esser

     Recultivation is a strategy for restoring near-natural landscape systems in anthropogenically influenced environments. Especially in post-mining landscapes after open pit mining, recultivation gives opportunities and potential for near-natural landscape modeling. In order to evaluate the success of the applied measures, biological monitoring approaches with a focus on biodiversity are often carried out. However, the loss of natural soils, which are the result of long-term formation, is an irreversible damage to the pedosphere. The natural soil functions must be completely re-established and it is difficult to examine its success. In our study we therefore investigated initial soil formation in an morphodynamically active artificial river valley, modeled and constructed with a recultivation substrate called “Forstkies”. The study area is located in the catchment of the Inde River (North Rhine-Westphalia, Western Germany), which is part of the international River Basin District Meuse. Due to the progress of the open pit lignite mining, a 5 km long river course had to be relocated. With the aim of creating a near-natural landscape and an appropriate development corridor for the river, a ~ 12 km long river relocation was designed. The artificial river section "Neue Inde" is still geomorphologically naïve and characterized by temporary, highly energetic morphodynamic processes resulting in strong erosion processes in the river bed and the surrounding area. To characterize the morphodynamics and to detect initial soil formation processes, we analyzed a transect of seven soil profiles. The transect includes floodplains and slope areas further away from the river. Allochthonous flood sediments can be differentiated from the underlying artificial Forstkies sediments by inherited contamination of the heavy metals Pb, Zn and Cu. By means of common soil parameters (grain size, CaCO3, total organic carbon, pH value and sediment colors) and geochemical weathering indices, first initial post-sedimentary alterations can be detected. The quality of the soils is absolutely appropriate to the state of development. The results obtained can be helpful for the planning of future renaturation in post-mining landscapes.  

    How to cite: Schulte, P., Hamacher, H., Lehmkuhl, F., and Esser, V.: Initial soil formation in an artificial river valley - Interplay of anthropogenic landscape shaping and fluvial dynamics, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5075, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5075, 2022.

    EGU22-5240 | Presentations | GM4.1

    Impact of an extreme storm on the 10Be signal in a mountainous catchment 

    Apolline Mariotti, Pierre-Henri Blard, Julien Charreau, Carole Petit, and Team Aster

    The impact of discrete extreme meteorological events on the long-term evolution of landscapes and sedimentary budget is poorly understood. We need quantitative estimates of the geomorphic change occurring during such events, of the sediment fluxes produced by landslides, flashfloods, and sediment remobilization. The frequency of such events at the geological and historical time scale and how they can be driven by climate change is also a major concern, especially for risk management. 10Be concentrations measured in river sediments produced during extreme events may provide a powerful tool to quantitatively study the geomorphic impact of the event.

     

    On October 2-3 2020, the Var catchment in the French Alps was struck by an extreme rainfall episode connected to the "Alex" storm (> 500 mm / 24h). This event resulted in flash floods in the Vésubie and Var valleys, mobilizing large volume of sediments and resulting in a 10 km long sedimentary plume at the Var outlet in the Mediterranean Sea. Fortunately, the Var catchment had been extensively studied before this event: 10Be had been measured in sediments to derive sub-catchment denudation rates and interannual variability of the 10Be signal (Mariotti et al., 2019). Moreover, paleo denudation rates over the last 75 ka for the whole catchment had also been measured using two sediments cores drilled in the Mediterranean Sea (Mariotti et al., 2021), providing a high-resolution record of past sedimentary dynamics. This extreme rainfall event of October 2020 and our previous 10Be dataset offer the unique opportunity to assess the sensibility of a sedimentary system and its capacity to relay extreme events in a source-to-sink system. This is also a great opportunity to characterize the 10Be geochemical signature of such events. This step is important to interpret paleo-10Be signals in sedimentary archives, with the aim to better assess the frequency of extreme events at the geological time scale.

     

    In order to characterize the response of the Var system to the Alex event, we compare 10Be concentrations in samples taken in 2016, 2017 and 2018 with 10Be concentrations in samples taken at the same locations after the 2020 storm at +7 days, +21 days, +4 months and +7 months. We use also use samples taken within each sub-catchments to constrain the evolution of the 10Be signal over time. This dataset permits to define the background of the 10Be concentrations and compare these concentrations to the ones measured after the storm. The 10Be concentrations measured at the outlet of the Var catchment at +7 days and +21 days are similar to those measured before the storm. However, the sample taken +4 months later shows a 20% decrease in 10Be concentration from pre-storm values. The Vésubie sub-basin is the only one to exhibit a 10Be decrease at +21 days. Hence, the delayed depletion observed at the outlet probably reflects the transfer of a 10Be-depleted sediment-wave from the Vésubie valley, where most of the landslides and terraces reworking happened during the storm.

    How to cite: Mariotti, A., Blard, P.-H., Charreau, J., Petit, C., and Aster, T.: Impact of an extreme storm on the 10Be signal in a mountainous catchment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5240, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5240, 2022.

    EGU22-5981 | Presentations | GM4.1

    Applicability of Smart-SED, a new sediment erosion and transport model, to Alpine scenarios 

    Monica Corti, Federico Gatti, Andrea Abbate, Monica Papini, and Laura Longoni

    In recent times, the study of effective methods to deal with hydrological hazard in urban areas became more urgent in relation to the climate changes in act.

    The development of tools able to predict the effects of extreme rainfall events is of great importance particularly for cities located at the downstream of mountain catchments, where exposure to floods and to the hazard related to sediment transport is relevant. Soil erosion and transport models are helpful instruments for the identification of hazardous areas and for risk management.

    In this work, results gained applying an efficient simulation tool, developed by Politecnico di Milano research group and named Smart-SED, to different real case studies are presented.

    The advantages of this new model over other tools already available in literature are the few input parameters required, the automatic identification of the drainage zones, the adaptive time step implied for the computations and the capability of dealing with multi-event simulations.

    The proposed model was calibrated on a catchment locatedin the Southern Alps, in Northern Italy, and successfully validated, considering rainfall events of 2020 together with sediment and water discharge data collected in control points on the field. The calibrated model was then applied to another catchment in the proximity to evaluate flood risk in case of extreme rainfall events, such as catastrophic storms recently occurred in Northern Italy and climate change scenarios.

    How to cite: Corti, M., Gatti, F., Abbate, A., Papini, M., and Longoni, L.: Applicability of Smart-SED, a new sediment erosion and transport model, to Alpine scenarios, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5981, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5981, 2022.

    EGU22-6098 | Presentations | GM4.1

    Decadal sedimentary yield and provenance in the Gioveretto, San Valentino and Vernago reservoirs, western South Tyrol, Italy 

    Francesco Brardinoni, Manel Llena, Volkmar Mair, and Giovanni Vezzoli

    In mountain drainage basins, constraining source-to-sink sediment fluxes over decadal time scales is critical for evaluating hillslope and fluvial response to ongoing climate change and holds practical implications for sediment management. To this end, we combine geomorphic change detection (GCD) (Wheaton et al., 2010) and sediment provenance analysis in the reservoirs of Gioveretto (1850 m a.s.l.), Vernago (1665 m a.s.l.) and San Valentino (1499 m a.s.l.), western South Tyrol, Italy. The reservoirs are located in the Austroalpine domain and the main outcropping lithologies consist of metamorphic rocks (e.g., metapelites and gneisses).

    Through GCD analysis conducted on recently acquired lake-bottom DTMs (i.e., SfM-UAV and multibeam surveys) and pre-dam (i.e., contour-based) counterparts, we have mapped the spatial distribution of erosion and deposition, and have assessed the relevant sediment yields over the last six decades. The three systems, which drain areas of 69 km2 (Vernago), 77 km2 (Gioveretto) and 163 km2 (San Valentino), exhibit varying degree of glacier extent, and have experienced a different history of lake-bottom anthropogenic disturbance. Preliminary, conservative GCD results constrain net aggradation volumes that correspond to sediment yields of 35*103 m3/yr at Gioveretto (1954-2019), and 68*103 m3/yr at San Valentino (1959-2020). In this context, the much lower figure of 6.5*103 m3/yr (1962-2021) at Vernago refers to a small portion (20%) of the lake bottom, which was spared from sediment removal during maintenance work occurred in 2001-2002.

    To quantify the contribution of each tributary stream to the sediment yield in each reservoir, quantitative provenance analysis was carried out on 18 sand/silt samples collected from fluvial bars of major tributaries and on the 3 reservoirs. The similarity between petrographic composition of river sediments supplied by different combinations of diverse end-member sources (e.g., parent lithologies) and the observed detrital mode of the sediments in the reservoirs was quantified using a statistical distance. Next, the relative contribution to the total sediment load from each of these tributaries was calculated by forward mixing modelling (Garzanti et al., 2012). Sediments in the study streams are dominated by quartz, feldspars, and metamorphic lithic grains. Heavy minerals include hornblende, garnet, and epidote. Results of the provenance analysis indicate that in Lakes San Valentino, Gioveretto and Vernago, the dominant contributions derive respectively from Rio Carlino (Mt. Palla Bianca – Weißkugel; 3738 m a.s.l.), Rio Plima (Mt. Cevedale – Zufallspitze; 3769 m a.s.l) and Tisentalbach (Mt. Similaun 3607 m a.s.l). This contribution is part of the SedInOut project (2019-2022), funded through the V-A Italia-Österreich Interreg Programme (European Regional Development Fund). Modern bathymetric data, processed by Cartorender Srl, are kindly made available by Alperia Srl.

     

    References

    Garzanti E., Resentini A., Vezzoli G., Andò S., Malusà M., and Padoan M. 2012. Forward compositional modelling of Alpine orogenic sediments. Sedimentary Geology, 280, 149-164.

    Wheaton J.M., Brasington J., Darby S.E., Sear D.A. 2010. Accounting for uncertainty in DEMs from repeat topographic surveys: improved sediment budgets. Earth Surface Processes and Landforms, 35, 136-156.

    How to cite: Brardinoni, F., Llena, M., Mair, V., and Vezzoli, G.: Decadal sedimentary yield and provenance in the Gioveretto, San Valentino and Vernago reservoirs, western South Tyrol, Italy, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6098, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6098, 2022.

    Tailings are a by-product of the processing of minerals at mine sites and are usually fine grained, contain water and processing chemical residues and are usually very erodible. Tailings are commonly stored in ‘tailings dams’ and these dams are a feature of many mine sites. These dams are in a geomorphic disequilibrium and have similar risk to that of water storage dams with geotechnical, seismic, hydrological (rainfall) and erosional induced failure concerns. These dams also pose a risk of release of polluted water and the accompanying chemicals and fines.  At the majority of mine sites tailings dams will be permanent geomorphological features which do not geomorphologically integrate with the surrounding landscape. A dam has a design life and it has been suggested that closure designs be considered for a 1000 year design life with other sites considered for 10 000 year scenarios. New methods are therefore needed for assessing long-term behaviour of anthropogenic structures such as tailings dams. Computer based Landscape Evolution Models (LEMs) are a new tool to assess tailings dam design.  These models provide information on type of erosion and erosion location as well as erosion rates. Models such as CAESAR-Lisflood can also provide information on water quality and stream sediment loads and models the transport of all size fractions. The model can therefore provide guidance on long-term behaviour, which allow designs to be tested and improved accordingly. The work uses CAESAR-Lisflood to examines a series of hypothetical tailings dams subject to a range of different possible rainfall scenarios. The findings demonstrate that without maintenance the dam wall will be breached at a time exceeding the dam life design for average conditions but may breach within decades for an extreme (yet possible) event. For both cases water quality will be reduced for centuries post breach and may never reach background (pre breach) levels representing a permanent change in water quality. The modelling here provides a method for the assessment of not just tailings dams but other anthropogenic structures and their geomorphological behaviour. The work here also raises questions about landscape stewardship for such altered systems.

    How to cite: Hancock, G. and Coulthard, T.: Anthroprogenic landscapes: assessing the geomorphological stability of tailings dams using a Landscape Evolution Model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6548, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6548, 2022.

    EGU22-6550 | Presentations | GM4.1

    How landslide debris grainsize controls sediment transport and dynamics 

    Jun Xie and Tom Coulthard

    The grain size of sediment delivered to a river by hillslope processes is crucial for fluvial erosion, sediment transport and associated geomorphic changes. Grain size distribution (GSD) is increasingly recognized an important factor for the impact of landslides on sediment pulses and long-term erosion rates. Therefore a better understanding of grain size control on landslide generated sediment transport and dynamics is crucial and imperative for post-seismic fluvial process and landscape evolution. In this study, we modelled the recovery of the Hongxi river catchment affected by landslides triggered from the Wenchuan Earthquake under different GSD scenarios. Using the CAESAR-Lisflood (CL) model we simulated three different GSD scenarios (Original, Coarser, Finer) by altering original sediment GSD data set observed from a post-earthquake basin. In particular we analysed the fate of landslide-generated sediment using a new sediment tracing function embedded in CAESAR-Lisflood. This enabled us to evaluate the role of landslide GSD variation on the spatial-temporal heterogeneity of sediment transport and landform changes. Our results show that the GSD variations of landslide material exerts an evident impact on both sediment yield and spatial distribution of sediment transport with Finer scenarios showing an overall higher sediment yield. The content of fine sediment display a predominant control when the daily sediment yield is less than 5*10 m³ at the basin outlet. The impact of GSD on sediment transport process varies from landslide to landslide based on their characteristics. These findings highlight the importance of grain size distribution of landslide material and thus shed some light to determine the complete role of landslides on basin sediment dynamics.

    How to cite: Xie, J. and Coulthard, T.: How landslide debris grainsize controls sediment transport and dynamics, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6550, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6550, 2022.

    EGU22-8173 | Presentations | GM4.1

    Reconstructing five decades of suspended sediment yields at two high alpine gauges in the Ötztal, Austria, using quantile regression forests 

    Lena Katharina Schmidt, Till Francke, Peter Grosse, Christoph Mayer, and Axel Bronstert

    Suspended sediment export from partly glaciated high alpine catchments is not only relevant for ecosystems, but also for infrastructure and flood hazard alterations in downstream areas. In order to estimate future changes, it is important to assess long-term developments in past sediment yields. However, existing records of suspended sediment export are mostly too short to investigate these long-term changes. For example, for the two gauges “Vent Rofenache” and “Vernagtferner” in the high alpine and partly glaciated Upper Ötztal in Tyrol, Austria, only 15 and four years of turbidity measurements exist, respectively, precluding robust explorations of longer-term developments.

    To compensate for this lack of measurement data, we use a Quantile Regression Forest approach, a non-parametrical, multivariate tool based on regression trees. It allows for reconstructing continuous sedigraphs based on short-term or point-like sediment concentration data and continuous predictor variables such as discharge (Q), precipitation (P) and air temperature (T).

    At gauge “Vernagtferner”, turbidity-based sediment concentration data were available only for the years 2000, 2001, 2019 and 2020. To test the ability of our model to reconstruct past sediment concentrations, we trained our model using the 2019 and 2020 data and validated against the 2000 and 2001 measurements, which showed good agreement (Nash-Sutcliffe Efficiency of 0.73). At gauge “Vent Rofenache”, the hydrographic service of Tyrol, Austria, has recorded turbidity-based sediment concentration data since 2006. Our model showed to be well able to reconstruct sediment yields based on by these data (out-of-bag Nash-Sutcliffe efficiency of 0.66).

    This validation enabled us to confidently use the long-term availability of the predictor variables (Q, P, T) to reconstruct sediment yields at gauge “Vernagtferner” since 1974 and at gauge “Vent Rofenache” since 1967.

    The resulting dataset allows us to

    • Analyze annual sediment yields with respect to trends and change points for time series of 47 and 54 years, respectively,
    • Examine changes in the predictor variables,
    • and connect developments in sediment yields to mass balances of the large glaciers within the catchment.

    Current results point at an almost step-like increase in annual sediment yields at the beginning of the 1980s at both gauges. This coincides with a marked increase in discharge volumes that in turn correlate with a basic change in glacier mass balances.

    How to cite: Schmidt, L. K., Francke, T., Grosse, P., Mayer, C., and Bronstert, A.: Reconstructing five decades of suspended sediment yields at two high alpine gauges in the Ötztal, Austria, using quantile regression forests, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8173, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8173, 2022.

    EGU22-8589 | Presentations | GM4.1

    Quantifying long-term sediment dynamics of a proglacial river in an alpine catchment 

    Livia Piermattei, Tobias Heckmann, Moritz Altmann, Sarah Betz-Nutz, Fabian Fleischer, Florian Haas, Norbert Pfeifer, Camillo Ressl, Jakob Rom, and Michael Becht

    Alpine rivers have experienced considerable changes in channel morphology over the last century. The main problem of current studies is the lack of information over a longer period. In order to reliably assess the magnitude of the channel change processes and/or their frequencies due to recent climate change, the investigation period needs to be extended to the last century, ideally back to the end of the Little Ice Age. In addition, a high temporal resolution is required to account for the history of changes in channel morphology and for better detection and interpretation of related processes.

    The increasing availability of digitized historical aerial images, together with advances in digital photogrammetry, provides the basis for reconstructing and assessing the long-term evolution of the surface, both in terms of mapping of historic planimetric position and generation of historical digital elevation models (DEMs). We use photogrammetric analysis of recent and historical images, together with LiDAR and drone-based photogrammetric DEMs, to quantify channel changes and the net sediment balance of a main alpine river in a glaciated catchment (Kaunertal, Austria) over nineteen periods from 1953 to 2019. Based on DEMs of difference, we estimate the spatio-temporal patterns of erosion and deposition. We show that geomorphic changes are mainly driven by deglaciation, i.e. glacier retreat, and sediment delivery from recently deglaciated steep lateral moraines, and from extreme runoff events. Overall, this work contributes to better understanding the main factors influencing river changes and the links between channel changes and climatic factors.

    How to cite: Piermattei, L., Heckmann, T., Altmann, M., Betz-Nutz, S., Fleischer, F., Haas, F., Pfeifer, N., Ressl, C., Rom, J., and Becht, M.: Quantifying long-term sediment dynamics of a proglacial river in an alpine catchment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8589, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8589, 2022.

    EGU22-8702 | Presentations | GM4.1

    Hydrological drivers of bedload transport in an Alpine watershed 

    Gilles Antoniazza, Tobias Nicollier, Stefan Boss, François Mettra, Alexandre Badoux, Bettina Schaefli, Dieter Rickenmann, and Stuart Lane

    Understanding and predicting bedload transport is an important element of watershed management. Yet, predictions of bedload remain uncertain by up to several order(s) of magnitude. In this paper, we use a five-year continuous time-series of streamflow and bedload transport monitoring in a 13.4 km2 snow-dominated Alpine watershed in the Western Swiss Alps to investigate the hydrological drivers of bedload transport. Following a calibration of the bedload sensors, and a quantification of the hydraulic forcing of streamflow upon bedload, a hydrological analysis is performed to identify daily flow hydrographs influenced by different hydrological drivers: rainfall, snow-melt, and mixed rain and snow-melt events. We then quantify their respective contribution to bedload transport. Results emphasize the importance of mixed rainfall and snow-melt events, for both annual bedload volumes (77% in average) and peaks in bedload transport rate. Results further show that a non-negligible amount of bedload transport may occur during late summer and autumn storms, once the snow-melt contribution and baseflow have significantly decreased (9% of the annual volume in average). Although rainfall-driven changes in flow hydrographs are responsible for a large majority of the annual bedload volumes (86% in average), the identified melt-only events also represent a substantial contribution (14 % in average). Through a better understanding of the bedload magnitude-frequency under different hydrological conditions, the results of this study may help to improve current predictions of bedload transport, and we further discuss how bedload could evolve under a changing climate through its effects on Alpine watershed hydrology.

    How to cite: Antoniazza, G., Nicollier, T., Boss, S., Mettra, F., Badoux, A., Schaefli, B., Rickenmann, D., and Lane, S.: Hydrological drivers of bedload transport in an Alpine watershed, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8702, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8702, 2022.

    EGU22-8920 | Presentations | GM4.1

    Chronology and sedimentary characteristics of rock avalanches from Meseta Belgrano to Lago Pueyrredón Valley, Patagonia 

    Veronika Kapustová, Tomáš Pánek, Michal Břežný, Elisabeth Schönfeldt, Diego Winocur, and Rachel Smedley

    On the northern slopes of Meseta Belgrano (MB), eastern foothills of Patagonian Andes in Argentina, complex of multiple overlapping rock avalanches and landslides can be found. Interpretation of remote-sensing data, field mapping, together with OSL dating of lacustrine sediments revealed that slope collapses evolved during last oscillations of the Patagonian Ice Sheet and after its retreat. The longest rock avalanche with ~11 km runout originated most likely before the last glacial advance following the LGM because it involves moraine deposits in part of the scarp area. We suppose, that the distal part of the rock avalanche body was subaqueous due to presence of a proglacial lake in Lago Pueyrredón Valley after LGM. The hummocky character of the distal body and its lithological composition coming from MB bedrock was preserved, but the deposit is discontinuous with straight east-west glacial lineations on the surface. We think this is result of erosion by the ice sheet approaching from East during post-LGM glacial fluctuations. Next pronounced landslide activity took place after ~17 ka BP, when at least three rock avalanches overlaid lacustrine sediments in a dropping proglacial lake. One of them, superimposing the above described older rock avalanche, evolved from the collapsed moraine deposit and created ~5 km long lobe with subaqueous radial distal part. In the proximal parts of the rock avalanches east from this form, bellow the slopes of MB, distinct large ridge-like forms are visible in topography. They are similar to moraine ridges preserved on the MB slopes in higher altitudes. They can be interpreted as lower-lying moraines, but this requires another pronounced ice-sheet oscillation after its final retreat, which was not documented in Patagonian Ice Sheet chronostratigraphy. Thus, we interpret them as Toreva blocks. Documentation and granulometric analysis of natural outcrops in rock avalanche bodies show that typical features, i.e. blocky, jigsaw and fragmented facies are present throughout the depth along whole travel distances of rock avalanches. Fragmented facies with jigsaw-fractured blocks and preserved original lithology sequence are most frequent. Sedimentary facies are very similar in all of the studied rock avalanches, which collapsed from bedrock MB slopes, regardless of their age or size.

    How to cite: Kapustová, V., Pánek, T., Břežný, M., Schönfeldt, E., Winocur, D., and Smedley, R.: Chronology and sedimentary characteristics of rock avalanches from Meseta Belgrano to Lago Pueyrredón Valley, Patagonia, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8920, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8920, 2022.

    EGU22-9191 | Presentations | GM4.1

    A framework for assessing sediment volumes mobilized by debris flows: the case study of the Liera catchment (Dolomites) 

    Giorgia Macchi, Stefano Crema, Gabriella Boretto, Giovanni Monegato, Lorenzo Marchi, Luciano Arziliero, Barbara De Fanti, and Marco Cavalli

    Extreme meteorological events can trigger widespread environmental damages, particularly in mountain areas where landslides and debris flows express their full destructive potential. An intense storm, named Vaia, occurred from 27th to 30th October 2018 over Northeastern Italy, triggering mass wasting processes, generating slope instabilities, causing widespread windthrows, and damaging anthropic structures. The Liera catchment (37.7 km2) in the Dolomites (Northeastern Italy), was severely affected by the Vaia storm and 34 sub-basins featured debris flows. Mapping sediment source areas and quantifying sediment volumes mobilized by debris flows in extraordinary events greatly contributes to reliable and accurate hazard assessment. The objectives of the present study are to create and compare pre- and post-event sediment source inventories and to quantify debris flows mobilized volumes. To this end, a combination of field surveys, orthophotos interpretation, rainfall analysis, and high-resolution multi-temporal LiDAR data processing was carried out in the Liera catchment test area. The main outcomes of this study encompass (i) reliable and detailed pre- and post-event sediment sources inventories from which it was possible to identify new source areas generated by the Vaia storm, (ii) the quantitative estimation of mobilized material from each sub-basin through DEM of Difference (DoD) and (iii) the assessment of the debris yield rate (i.e. the volume eroded for unit channel length) of each homogeneous channel reach. Sediment sources identified and mapped in 2015 in the Liera catchment were 1,346, ranging in area from 10 to 347,000 m2, with a total area of about 1,890,000 m2. The 2019 post-event inventory shows 815 more sediment sources, 550,000 m2 more than the 2015 inventory. Results indicate that the total amount of sediment mobilized from the sub-basins was about 307,000±63,500 m3, and the total net volume balance exiting the basins was -64,000±14,500 m3. The latter value encompasses the volume entered the Liera stream and the material that has been removed during and after the emergency operations. Despite the great impact of the event, only a limited amount of the total material mobilized reached the Liera torrent. We propose the approach devised and tested in the Liera catchment as an effective way to recognize the sources and assess the volumes of sediment mobilized by debris flows at the event and catchment scales, making an effective use of data commonly available in alpine catchments.  

    KEY WORDS: DEM of Difference (DoD); debris flow; geomorphometry, LiDAR; sediment delivery; natural hazard.

    How to cite: Macchi, G., Crema, S., Boretto, G., Monegato, G., Marchi, L., Arziliero, L., De Fanti, B., and Cavalli, M.: A framework for assessing sediment volumes mobilized by debris flows: the case study of the Liera catchment (Dolomites), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9191, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9191, 2022.

    Among the greatest stressors on global riverine sediment transport are the 48,000+ existing large dams and the ~3,700 dams that are planned or under construction. They directly obstruct sediment flowing to the ocean, alter downstream flow regimes, modify sediment carrying capacities, trigger hazardous bank erosion and riverbed incision, and influence river water quality. Understanding the role of dams in sediment retention is crucial for quantifying the anthropogenic influences on global fluvial systems. Representation of sediment trapping by dams is currently a major source of bias in continental- and global-scale hydro-geomorphic modeling frameworks. This study focuses on developing a new reservoir trapping efficiency (Te) parameter to account for the impacts of sediment trapping behind dams in hydrological modeling efforts. This will be done by harnessing a novel remote sensing data product, developed using Machine Learning within Google Earth Engine (GEE) to generate high-resolution and spatially continuous maps of sediment concentration across the CONUS. Sediment trapping is calculated for 400+ dams across the CONUS using pre-reservoir and post-dam sediment fluxes, and various explanatory variables including attributes of dams, topography, land use and land cover characteristics, soil parameters, and fluvial properties, are evaluated to estimate their contribution for predicting sediment trapping. This study provides a robust framework for isolating and quantifying the influence of anthropogenic factors on fluvial fluxes by informing more realistic trapping of sediment at dam locations.

    How to cite: Moragoda, N., Cohen, S., and Gardner, J.: Development of a New Reservoir Trapping Efficiency Parameter for Large Scale Sediment Modeling using Remote Sensing of Fluvial Sediment, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10636, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10636, 2022.

    EGU22-10839 | Presentations | GM4.1

    Increasing sediment connectivity and decreasing water availability: the anthropogenic impacts of exotic tree plantations on a Mediterranean catchment in central Chile 

    Violeta Tolorza, Mauricio Zambrano-Bigiarini, Christian Mohr, Benjamin Sotomayor, Dagoberto Poblete-Caballero, and Mauricio Galleguillos

    The Coastal Range in the Mediterranean segment of the Chilean active margin is a soil mantled landscape of gentle hillslopes, able to store fresh water and potentially to support biodiverse native forests. In this landscape, anthropogenic intervention has been increasing soil erosion for ∼200 yr, with the last ∼45 yr experiencing intensive management on exotic tree plantations. Such intense forest management practices come along with rotational cycles as short as 9-25 yrs, depending on the tree species, dense forest road networks, and promoting wildfire susceptibility. 

    Here we compare decadal-scale catchment erosion rates from suspended sediment loads with 104-years-scale catchment erosion rate estimated from detritic 10Be in a ∼400 km2 catchment. We relate these rates to land cover dynamics, sediment connectivity modified by forestry roads, and  hydro-meteorologic trends, because the catchment has been widely disturbed by forest management practices, wildfires, and  earthquakes, while an unprecedented drought started on 2010. 

    Both, short- and long-term erosion show comparably low rates (0.018 ± 0.005 mm/yr and 0.024 ± 0.004 mm/yr). Recent human-made disturbances include logging operations every season and the building, the maintaining and the heavy machinery traffic on forestry road. Forestry roads often intersect streams, thus forming bypasses to route sediments between hillslopes and valleys. That is, increasing structural sediment connectivity. In addition, one Mw 8.8 earthquake and two widespread wildfires disturbed this catchment in 2010, 2015 and 2017, respectively. Mann-Kendall tests applied to decadal records of rainfall and streamflow resulted in decreasing trends. The suspended sediments fluxes of July also decreases in the same period, yet other subsets of that specific series were ruled out by autocorrelation or by completeness tests. 

    The low 104-years erosion rate agrees with a landscape dominated by slow soil creep. The low 10-years-scale erosion rate, however, conflicts with the observed disturbances and the increase in structural sediment connectivity.

    The latter results suggest that, either the suspended sediment fluxes are underestimated, or the decennial sediment detachment and transport may be affected by the negative trends on rainfall and streamflows. Sediment mobilization depends mostly on specific thresholds of rainfall intensity on hillslopes and on water discharge in the streams, while the unprecedented drought starting in 2010 together with high water demands of fast-growing tree plantations mean a reduction in water availability. Ultimately, our findings indicate that human-made disturbances and hydrometeorologic trends may result in contrasting effects for the recent mobilization of sediments. However, both are negative for the resilience of ecosystems and then, for humans.

    How to cite: Tolorza, V., Zambrano-Bigiarini, M., Mohr, C., Sotomayor, B., Poblete-Caballero, D., and Galleguillos, M.: Increasing sediment connectivity and decreasing water availability: the anthropogenic impacts of exotic tree plantations on a Mediterranean catchment in central Chile, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10839, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10839, 2022.

    EGU22-10893 | Presentations | GM4.1

    A new photo-sieving approach: quick and effective semi-automated method for gran size counting for gravel beds, and application to a Chilean Patagonia river 

    Amantu Jullian, Franco Fortini, Paulo Quezada, Alejandro Dussaillant, Cristian Gonzales, and Pedro Chavez

    Many rivers in Chilean Patagonia are difficult to access, experience high flow variability and frequent sudden floods, which make traditional grain size distribution sampling and analysis extremely challenging. There are several diverse methods and software that attempt to determine grain size using analysis of photographs. Manual methods, although of high precision, are extremely labour and time intensive as they process particle by particle by hand. On the other hand, automated methods although fast, still produce low precision in particle identification and size determination, This motivated us on developing a field and desktop method that is fast, precise and requires light equipment. It includes good natural light management with a light and inexpensive kit, considering a good representative selection of the study site. Preliminary to the automated method, the photographic sample is calibrated regarding tones, colours and brightness, with the aim of generating high contrast between clasts and therefore an easier recognition by the software ImageJ. We tested the method with 50 photographs analysed with manual and other (semi)automated methods, characterizing the surface depoosits of río Simpson between the towns of El Blanco and Coyhaique, in Chilean Patagonia. We identified and mapped sediment patches using an UAV. Results show that our method has a lower error and processing time. Ongoing challenges include the underestimation in size and number of some clasts, and overestimation of sand, with respect to the manual method, but it still outperforms other (semi)automatic methods.

    How to cite: Jullian, A., Fortini, F., Quezada, P., Dussaillant, A., Gonzales, C., and Chavez, P.: A new photo-sieving approach: quick and effective semi-automated method for gran size counting for gravel beds, and application to a Chilean Patagonia river, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10893, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10893, 2022.

    EGU22-11706 | Presentations | GM4.1

    Global variations in SSC-Q relationships and the controlling catchment characteristics 

    Renee van Dongen, Thomas Hoffmann, and Stephan Dietrich

    Rivers transport large amounts of fine mineral and organic matter in suspension from their sources to the ocean. Suspended solids, which also bind contaminants and nutrients, therefore, affect river morphodynamics, water quality and ecosystem functioning. A detailed understanding of suspended solid dynamics is urgently needed to improve suspended sediment monitoring and management around the world.

    Sediment rating curves (SSC=aQb) describe the relation between suspended solid concentrations (SSC) and river discharge (Q) and are frequently used to study suspended sediment dynamics at specific location in a river. In this formula, a and b are regression coefficients that depend on river basin characteristics. The a-parameter is an indicator of the erosion severity and the b-parameter reflects the erosion reactivity with respect to changing discharge. To date, a few studies have compared the rating parameters (a and b) to catchment characteristics, however, these studies only focused on specific regions on earth. A global study is required to better understand suspended sediment dynamics along a wide range of catchments characteristics.

    In this study, we compiled available SSC and Q data from 176 rivers that are located in various regions around the world. The majority of the SSC and Q data have been collected from the GEMStat and the Global Runoff Data Centre (GRCD) databases, but we also included data from the USGS and SO-HYBAM datasets. The compiled dataset ranges from small basins (~50 km2) to large basins (~190,000 km2), with medium-sized river basins (~1000-10,000 km2) being most dominant. Furthermore, the dataset contains basins that are located in various climate regions, ranging from semi-arid to humid climate, and includes both upland and lowland rivers. We only included river monitoring stations with >50 overlapping SSC and Q data points (i.e., SSC and Q data measured on the same day). We parameterized the rating curve between the SSC and Q data and compared the a- and b-parameters to topographic, lithologic, climatic and land cover-related catchment characteristics using simple and multiple linear regressions.

    The first results reveal that the b-exponent and, thus, the suspended solids variability, shows a fairly good relationship with catchment steepness and basin size. The data suggests that climatic and land use parameters play an insignificant role, however, when combining all parameters in a multiple linear model, climate seems to have a secondary effect on top of topographic parameters. The erosion severity (a-parameter) is most strongly controlled by climatic and land cover parameters. The results of this study can be used to infer for suspended sediment dynamics in ungauged catchments, which is relevant for implementing sediment monitoring and management in these regions on earth.

    How to cite: van Dongen, R., Hoffmann, T., and Dietrich, S.: Global variations in SSC-Q relationships and the controlling catchment characteristics, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11706, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11706, 2022.

    EGU22-12005 | Presentations | GM4.1

    Trends in suspended sediment fluxes and sediment budgets across the river Rhine basin (1990-present) 

    Tatjana Edler, Marcel Van der Perk, and Hans Middelkoop

    Suspended sediment transport is a vital process in healthy river systems as it provides a source of nutrients in the soils of riverbanks and floodplains that eventually forms the principal building material of downstream river deltas. Deltas require sufficient sediment supply from the upstream river basin to sustain area and elevation on the long-term. Recent decades, the delivery of suspended sediment to many deltas in the world has decreased, which, together with sediment extraction through dredging, resulted in negative sediment budgets of these deltas. To design strategies to attenuate or reverse the decreased sediment delivery, a quantitative understanding of the sources, fluxes, and budget of suspended sediment in river basins is essesntial.

    The aim of this study is to quantify the contribution of different tributaries to the suspended sediment budget in the Rhine river basin between 1995 and 2015. For this, we used fortnightly to monthly measurements of suspended sediment concentrations and daily discharge measurements at 34 stations along the main branch of the Rhine river and its four major tributaries Aare, Neckar, Main, Mosel. Annual suspended sediment loads were estimated by means of the sediment rating curve method, which allowed establishing the annual sediment budgets for 28 river sections.

    For the first time we were able to show the relative contribution of different tributaries to the overall decreasing suspended sediment load of the upper Rhine river (between 1995 and 2015). A decline of 70% percent in suspended sediment at Lobith between 1950 and 2016 and an observed consistent decline further upstream suggests an overall decline of sediment delivered to the lower lying delta. The causes must be sought in basin wide changes such as land-use, land management, hydrology, or climate. This is a trend that is observed in many river basins in recent decades.

     

     

    How to cite: Edler, T., Van der Perk, M., and Middelkoop, H.: Trends in suspended sediment fluxes and sediment budgets across the river Rhine basin (1990-present), EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12005, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12005, 2022.

    EGU22-12285 | Presentations | GM4.1

    New luminescence chronological tools for dating and tracing sediment movement 

    Ed Rhodes, Andrew Ivester, James Dolan, Judith Gauriau, Russ Van Dissen, and Tim Little

    As part of a large research project reconstructing fault slip rates, palaeoseismiology and landscape evolution in New Zealand, we have developed a range of new chronological tools with applications to sediment. These closely related methods are based on Infra-Red Stimulated Luminescence (IRSL) signals of alkali feldspar, and allow us to determine aspects of transport and burial at the scale of individual grains over time periods ranging from 1 to 300,000 years. In particular, we have introduced and tested a method referred to as 3ET-IRSL (Three Elevated Temperature IRSL), and we are also applying a MET-IRSL (Multiple Elevated Temperature IRSL) approach comprising measurement sequences that include five IRSL measurements at different temperatures. These techniques can be used in different ways to filter complex single grain IRSL apparent age distributions that arise from processes including short duration reworking associated with incomplete trapped charge removal during transport. These methods were primarily designed to improve chronological control for sediment dating in contexts where conventional approaches encounter significant challenges owing to the geomorphic setting including high volume, rapid deposition. However, these approaches can provide significant insight into the dynamics of sediment transport routes and rates at the individual grain scale. We will demonstrate the performance of these methods at key test sites, and assess the implications of our findings in New Zealand (NZ), coupling observations of relict fluvial terrace formation with landscape response to the Mw 7.8 Kaikoura earthquake of 2016. At one of our NZ sites, fluvial system response to this event is the opposite of that expected from the literature in terms of sediment deposition and erosion; the degree to which this represents a transient response is assessed. We highlight the amazing potential of these new tools for improving our understanding of source-to-sink sediment transport dynamics.

    How to cite: Rhodes, E., Ivester, A., Dolan, J., Gauriau, J., Van Dissen, R., and Little, T.: New luminescence chronological tools for dating and tracing sediment movement, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12285, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12285, 2022.

    EGU22-12674 | Presentations | GM4.1

    Sources and transformation of dissolved inorganic carbon in a Himalayan river system 

    Siddhartha Sarkar, Rayees Ahmed Shah, and Sanjeev Kumar

    Inland waters play a vital role in the global carbon cycling. Mountainous rivers act as active pipelines for the transportation of sediments and elements from the mountains through the plains to be ultimately processed and buried along the coasts. During this transit, various in situ biogeochemical processes govern the alterations of the suspended and dissolved matter (and associated organic and inorganic components) and in the process exchange major GHGs (CH4, CO2 and N2O) with the atmosphere. Due to changing climate and the associated shifts in the flow regime of the world rivers, it is essential to revisit the mechanisms by which carbon is being transported along the river continuum and further constrain the effects of regional climate and lithology on the rates of transport and processing. The rivers originating from the Tibetan plateau and the Himalayan region play a dominant role in continental weathering, and represent some of the highest rates among the large river systems across the globe.

                In the present study, an attempt has been made to estimate the concentrations and fluxes of dissolved inorganic carbon (DIC) in the Jhelum River (a tributary of the Indus River) along with its major tributaries (Sindh, Liddar, Vishav, and Rambiara) situated in the Kashmir valley of the western Himalaya. The Jhelum River drains a distinct terrain of recent alluvium to a thick loess deposit, which is assumed to have a significant contribution to the inorganic carbon loading into the river. Furthermore, the flow velocity of the river and turbidity varies along its continuum resulting in a strong coupling of respiration and primary production. We used the miller-tans plots (a graphical mixing model) to identify the sources of inorganic carbon in different reaches along the continuum. Preliminary results from ~ 50 sites and three major seasons in the valley indicate DIC source with isotopically enriched signature (d13CDIC ~ – 2.1 to –3.7 ‰) in the Sind and Lidder catchments whereas a depleted source in the mainstem of the river (d13CDIC ~ –7.1 ‰).

    How to cite: Sarkar, S., Shah, R. A., and Kumar, S.: Sources and transformation of dissolved inorganic carbon in a Himalayan river system, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12674, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12674, 2022.

    The Yellow Riversource zone is located in the northeast of the Qinghai-Tibet Plateau. The landform of this zone is diverse,leading to various river network patterns. To explore the planform geometries and controlling factors of the river networks in this zone, 83 representative sub-basins are selected for the study. Based on the definitions and descriptions of different river network types, these sub-basins can be divided into four types, namely, dendritic, pinnate, rectangular, and symmetrical pinnate patterns. Using river network parameters, the classification trees are established to automatically classify river networks. The results show that the aspect ratio, drainage density and maximum frequency of flow directions play important roles in classification. Aspect ratios of basins characterize basin shapes, andthe more elongated the basin is, the smaller the aspect ratio is. Thus, aspect ratios of pinnate and symmetrical pinnate patterns are lower than that of dendriticand rectangular patterns. The mean aspect ratios of dendritic, pinnate, rectangular and symmetrical pinnate patterns were 0.56, 0.29, 0.62, and 0.26, respectively. Drainage density reflects the relative spacing of drainage lines in a network. The tributaries of the pinnatepattern are long and concentrated, and the drainage density of this pattern is the largest, with an average of 1.92 km/km2.  Though the tributaries of the symmetrical pinnate pattern arealso concentrated, most of the tributaries are short, and the drainage density is smaller than that of the pinnate pattern, with an average of 1.54 km/km2. Mean drainage densities of dendritic and rectangular patternsareabout 1.24 km/km2and 1.22 km/km2. The maximum frequency describes flow direction distributions of river networks. The greater the value is, the rivers within the basin tend to flow in the same direction.The flow directionsof tributaries inthe dendritic pattern are free, and the mean maximum frequency is small, which is 2.48. For the rectangular pattern with lots of right-angle bends, the mean maximum frequency is 2.40. There is a dominant direction in the pinnate pattern. The mean value of the maximum frequency of this pattern is the largest, which is 8.11. Tributaries of the symmetric pinnate pattern are distributed symmetrically along the main trunk, and the mean maximum frequency is 3.36. To explore the controlling factors, correlation analysis is made between these river network parameters and topography (i.e. basin slope and relief) and climate (i.e.precipitation, temperature, and aridity). Compared with topography, climate is more strongly correlated with these river network parameters. In the Yellow River source zone, the pinnate pattern is mainly distributed in arid areas with little precipitation. Dendritic and symmetric pinnate patterns, the basin slopes of which are relatively larger, are more likely to occur in humid areas with more precipitation. The rectangular pattern is concentrated in the Ruoergai basin, where the slope and relief are low and the climate is relatively humid. 

    How to cite: Li, M. and Wu, B.: Planform geometries and controlling factors of river networks in the Yellow River source zone, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13217, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13217, 2022.

    EGU22-13442 | Presentations | GM4.1

    How do both valley head initiation and headwater catchment extent change with relief? 

    Hui Chen and Jongmin Byun

    Headwater catchments, each of which consists of hillslopes, valley heads, and colluvial channels, make up a major portion of a drainage basin, supplying sediment, water, and nutrients downstream. In a headwater catchment, valley heads where hillslope diffusive transport transits to fluvial transport play an important role in channel initiation. Headwater catchments where mass movements are dominated are sensitive to human activities. Human activities in headwater catchments, such as logging and crop cultivation, change the rate of hillslope erosion, thereby increasing sediment inputs and leading to channel form change and stream habitat destruction. In recent years, such human activities have increased significantly in headwater catchments. As such, delineations of the extent of headwater catchment and valley head initiation become increasingly important for watershed protection and management. Previous studies have shown that the area of the headwater catchment ranges from 104 to 106 m2, but little is known about what factors affect its range. The evolution of headwater catchment topography is mainly determined by surface processes such as landslides and runoff. The rates of these processes vary depending on the hillslope gradient closely related to topographic relief. To understand the impacts of relief on the valley head initiation and the extent of headwater catchment, we analyzed the slope-area relations of the Seo River drainage in South Korea. Firstly, we found that the upslope area at the valley head shows a weak positive correlation with relief. This finding seems to be associated with hillslope material input to fill valley heads. Steep hillslopes in a high relief region could induce more hillslope material supply, consequently filling valley heads. Such abundant flux into valley heads probably enhances the hillslope length and makes valley head initiation downstream. Secondly, the upslope area of the headwater catchment, which is set by the downstream limit of the colluvial channel increased exponentially with relief. This exponential correlation would be related to the length of debris flow-dominated channel. In high relief regions where the channel slope is steeper, debris flows scour for a further distance, resulting longer colluvial channels. These results reveal the importance of relief as controls on valley head initiation and headwater catchment extent.

    How to cite: Chen, H. and Byun, J.: How do both valley head initiation and headwater catchment extent change with relief?, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13442, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13442, 2022.

    EGU22-91 | Presentations | NP4.1

    The role of teleconnections in complex climate network 

    Ruby Saha

    A complex network provides a robust framework to statistically investigate the topology of local and long-range connections, i.e., teleconnections in climate dynamics. The Climate network is constructed from meteorological data set using the linear Pearson correlation coefficient to measure similarity between two regions. Long-range teleconnections connect remote geographical sites and are crucial for climate networks. In this study, we discuss that during El Ni\~no Southern Oscillation onset, the teleconnections pattern changes according to the episode's strength. The long-range teleconnections are significant and responsible for the episodes' extremum ONI attained gradually after onset. We quantify the betweenness centrality measurement and note that the teleconnection distribution pattern and the betweenness measurements fit well.

    How to cite: Saha, R.: The role of teleconnections in complex climate network, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-91, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-91, 2022.

    EGU22-1831 | Presentations | NP4.1

    Quantifying space-weather events using dynamical network analysis of Pc waves with global ground based magnetometers. 

    Shahbaz Chaudhry, Sandra Chapman, Jesper Gjerloev, Ciaran Beggan, and Alan Thompson

    Geomagnetic storms can impact technological systems, on the ground and in space, including damage to satellites and power blackouts. Their impact on ground systems such as power grids depends upon the spatio-temporal extent and time-evolution of the ground magnetic perturbation driven by the storm.

    Pc waves are Alfven wave resonances of closed magnetospheric field lines and are ubiquitous in the inner magnetosphere. They have been extensively studied, in particular since  Pc wave power tracks the onset and evolution of geomagnetic storms.  We study the spatial and temporal evolution of Pc waves with a network analysis of the 100+ ground-based magnetometer stations collated by the SuperMAG collaboration with a single time-base and calibration. 

    Network-based analysis of 1 min cadence SuperMAG magnetometer data has been applied to the dynamics of substorm current systems (Dods et al. JGR 2015, Orr et al. GRL 2019) and the magnetospheric response to IMF turnings (Dods et al. JGR 2017). It has the potential to capture the full spatio-temporal response with a few time-dependent network parameters. Now, with the availability of 1 sec data across the entire SuperMAG network we are able for the first time to apply network analysis globally to resolve both the spatial and temporal correlation patterns of the ground signature of Pc wave activity as a geomagnetic storm evolves. We focus on Pc2 (5-10s period) and Pc3 (10-45s period) wave bands. We obtain the time-varying global Pc wave dynamical network over individual space weather events.

    To construct the networks we sample each magnetometer time series with a moving window in the time domain (20 times Pc period range) and then band-pass filter each magnetometer station time-series to obtain Pc2 and Pc3 waveforms. We then compute the cross correlation (TLXC) between all stations for each Pc band. Modelling is used to determine a threshold of significant TLXC above which a pair of stations are connected in the network. The TLXC as a function of lag is tested against a criterion for sinusoidal waveforms and then used to calculate the phase difference. The connections with a TLXC peak at non zero lag form a directed network which characterizes propagation or information flow. The connections at TLXC lag peak close to zero form am undirected network which characterizes a response which is globally instantaneously coherent.

    We apply this network analysis to isolated geomagnetic storms. We find that the network connectivity does not simply track Pc wave power, it therefore contains additional information. Geographically short range connections are prevalent at all times, the storm onset marks a transition to a network which has both enhancement of geographically short-range connections, and the growth of geographically long range, global scale, connections extending spatially over a region exceeding 9h MLT. These global scale connections, indicating globally coherent Pc wave response are prevalent throughout the storm with considerable (within a few time windows) variation. The stations are not uniformly distributed spatially. Therefore, we distinguish between long range connections to avoid introducing spatial correlation. 

    How to cite: Chaudhry, S., Chapman, S., Gjerloev, J., Beggan, C., and Thompson, A.: Quantifying space-weather events using dynamical network analysis of Pc waves with global ground based magnetometers., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1831, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1831, 2022.

    EGU22-2014 | Presentations | NP4.1

    OBS noise reduction using music information retrieval algorithms 

    Zahra Zali, Theresa Rein, Frank Krüger, Matthias Ohrnberger, and Frank Scherbaum

    Since the ocean covers 71% of the Earth’s surface, records from ocean bottom seismometers (OBS) are essential for investigating the whole Earth’s structure. However, data from ocean bottom recordings are commonly difficult to analyze due to the high noise level especially on the horizontal components. In addition, signals of seismological interest such as earthquake recordings at teleseismic distances, are masked by the oceanic noises. Therefore, noise reduction of OBS data is an important task required for the analysis of OBS records. Different approaches have been suggested in previous studies to remove noise from vertical components successfully, however, noise reduction on records of horizontal components remained problematic. Here we introduce a method, which is based on harmonic-percussive separation (HPS) algorithms used in Zali et al., (2021) that is able to separate long-lasting narrowband signals from broadband transients in the OBS records. In the context of OBS noise reduction using HPS algorithms, percussive components correspond to earthquake signals and harmonic components correspond to noise signals. OBS noises with narrowband horizontal structures in the short time Fourier transform (STFT) are readily distinguishable from transient, short-duration seismic events with vertical exhibitions in the STFT spectrogram. Through HPS algorithms we try to separate horizontal structures from vertical structures in the STFT spectrograms. Using this method we can reduce OBS noises from both vertical and horizontal components, retrieve clearer broadband earthquake waveforms and increase the earthquake signal to noise ratio. The applicability of the method is checked through tests on synthetic and real data.

    How to cite: Zali, Z., Rein, T., Krüger, F., Ohrnberger, M., and Scherbaum, F.: OBS noise reduction using music information retrieval algorithms, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2014, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2014, 2022.

    EGU22-2097 | Presentations | NP4.1 | Highlight

    Medium- to long-term forecast of sea surface temperature using EEMD-STEOF-LSTM hybrid model 

    Rixu Hao, Yuxin Zhao, Xiong Deng, Di Zhou, Dequan Yang, and Xin Jiang

    Sea surface temperature (SST) is a vitally important variable of the global ocean, which can profoundly affect the climate and marine ecosystems. The field of forecasting oceanic variables has traditionally relied on numerical models, which effectively consider the discretization of the dynamical and physical oceanic equations. However, numerical models suffer from many limitations such as short timeliness, complex physical processes, and excessive calculation. Furthermore, existing machine learning has been proved to be able to capture spatial and temporal information independently without these limitations, but the previous research on multi-scale feature extraction and evolutionary forecast under spatiotemporal integration is still inadequate. To fill this gap, a multi-scale spatiotemporal forecast model is developed combining ensemble empirical mode decomposition (EEMD) and spatiotemporal empirical orthogonal function (STEOF) with long short-term memory (LSTM), which is referred to as EEMD-STEOF-LSTM. Specifically, the EEMD is applied for adaptive multi-scale analysis; the STEOF is adopted to decompose the spatiotemporal processes of different scales into terms of a sum of products of spatiotemporal basis functions along with corresponding coefficients, which captures the evolution of spatial and temporal processes simultaneously; and the LSTM is employed to achieve medium- to long-term forecast of STEOF-derived spatiotemporal coefficients. A case study of the daily average of SST in the South China Sea shows that the proposed hybrid EEMD-STEOF-LSTM model consistently outperforms the optimal climatic normal (OCN), STEOF, and STEOF-LSTM, which can accurately forecast the characteristics of oceanic eddies. Statistical analysis of the case study demonstrates that this model has great potential for practical applications in medium- to long-term forecast of oceanic variables.

    How to cite: Hao, R., Zhao, Y., Deng, X., Zhou, D., Yang, D., and Jiang, X.: Medium- to long-term forecast of sea surface temperature using EEMD-STEOF-LSTM hybrid model, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2097, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2097, 2022.

    In this presentation, we introduce the IMFogram method ( pronounced like "infogram" ), which is a new, fast, local, and reliable time-frequency representation (TFR) method for nonstationary signals. This technique is based on the Intrinsic Mode Functions (IMFs) decomposition produced by a decomposition method, like the Empirical Mode Decomposition-based techniques, Iterative Filtering-based algorithms, or any equivalent method developed so far. We present the mathematical properties of the IMFogram, and show the proof that this method is a generalization of the Spectrogram. We conclude the presentation with some applications, as well as a comparison of its performance with other existing TFR techniques.

    How to cite: Cicone, A.: The IMFogram: a new time-frequency representation algorithm for nonstationary signals, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2560, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2560, 2022.

    EGU22-2922 | Presentations | NP4.1

    Constraining the uncertainty in CO2 seasonal cycle metrics by residual bootstrapping. 

    Theertha Kariyathan, Wouter Peters, Julia Marshall, Ana Bastos, and Markus Reichstein

    The analysis of long, high-quality time series of atmospheric greenhouse gas measurements helps to quantify their seasonal to interannual variations and impact on global climate. These discrete measurement records contain, however, gaps and at times noisy data, influenced by local fluxes or synoptic scale events, hence appropriate filtering and curve-fitting techniques are often used to smooth and gap-fill the atmospheric time series. Previous studies have shown that there is an inherent uncertainty associated with curve-fitting processes which introduces biases based on the choice of mathematical method used for data processing and can lead to scientific misinterpretation of the signal. Further the uncertainties in curve-fitting can be propagated onto the metrics estimated from the fitted curve that could significantly influence the quantification of the metrics and their interpretations. In this context we present a novel-methodology for constraining the uncertainty arising from fitting a smooth curve to the CO2 dry air mole fraction time-series, and propagate this uncertainty onto commonly used metrics to study the seasonal cycle of CO2. We generate an ensemble of fifitted curves from the data using residual bootstrap sampling with loess-fitted residuals, that is representative of the inherent uncertainty in applying the curve-fitting method to the discrete data. The spread of the selected CO2 seasonal cycle metrics across bootstrap time-series provides an estimate of the inherent uncertainty in curve fitting to the discrete data. Further we show that the approach can be extended to other curve-fitting methods by generating multiple bootstrap samples by resampling residuals obtained from processing the data using the widely used CCGCRV filtering method by the atmospheric greenhouse gas measurement community.

    How to cite: Kariyathan, T., Peters, W., Marshall, J., Bastos, A., and Reichstein, M.: Constraining the uncertainty in CO2 seasonal cycle metrics by residual bootstrapping., EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2922, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2922, 2022.

    EGU22-4795 | Presentations | NP4.1

    Robust Causal Inference for Irregularly Sampled Time Series: Applications in Climate and Paleoclimate Data Analysis 

    Aditi Kathpalia, Pouya Manshour, and Milan Paluš

    To predict and determine the major drivers of climate has become even more important now as climate change poses a big challenge to humankind and our planet earth. Different studies employ either correlation, causality methods or modelling approaches to study the interaction between climate and climate forcing variables (anthropogenic or natural). This includes the study of interaction between global surface temperatures and CO2; rainfall in different locations and El Niño–Southern Oscillation (ENSO) phenomena. The results produced by different studies have been found to be different and debatable, presenting an ambiguous situation. In this work, we develop and apply a novel robust causality estimation technique for time-series data (to estimate causal influence between given observables), that can help to resolve the ambiguity. The discrepancy in existing results arises due to challenges with the acquired data and limitations of the causal inference/ modelling approaches. Our novel approach combines the use of a recently proposed causality method, Compression-Complexity Causality (CCC) [1], and Ordinal/ Permutation pattern-based coding [2]. CCC estimates have been shown to be robust for bivariate systems with low temporal resolution, missing samples, long-term memory and finite length data [1]. The use of ordinal patterns helps to extend bivariate CCC to the multivariate case by capturing the multidimensional dynamics of the given variables’ systems in the symbolic temporal sequence of a single variable. This methodology is tested on dynamical systems data which are short in length and have been corrupted with missing samples or subsampled to different levels. The superior performance of ‘Permutation CCC’ on such data relative to other causality estimation methods, strengthens our trust in the method. We apply the method to study the interaction between CO2-temperature recordings on three different time scales, CH4-temperature on the paleoclimate scale, ENSO-South Asian monsoon on monthly and yearly time scales, North Atlantic Oscillation-surface temperature on daily and monthly time scales. These datasets are either short in length, have been sampled irregularly, have missing samples or have a combination of the above factors. Our results are interesting, which validate some existing studies while contradicting others. In addition, the development of the novel permutation-CCC approach opens the possibility of its application for making useful inferences on other challenging climate datasets.


    This study is supported by the Czech Science Foundation, Project No.~GA19-16066S and by the Czech Academy of Sciences, Praemium Academiae awarded to M. Paluš.


    References:
    [1] Kathpalia, A., & Nagaraj, N. (2019). Data-based intervention approach for Complexity-Causality measure. PeerJ Computer Science, 5, e196.
    [2] Bandt, C., & Pompe, B. (2002). Permutation entropy: a natural complexity measure for time series. Physical review letters, 88(17), 174102.

    How to cite: Kathpalia, A., Manshour, P., and Paluš, M.: Robust Causal Inference for Irregularly Sampled Time Series: Applications in Climate and Paleoclimate Data Analysis, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-4795, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-4795, 2022.

    Rainfall time series prediction is crucial for geoscientific system monitoring, but it is challenging and complex due to the extreme variability of rainfall. In order to improve prediction accuracy, a hybrid deep learning model (VMD-RNN) was proposed. In this study, variational mode decomposition (VMD) is first applied to decompose the original rainfall time series into several sub-sequences according to the frequency domain. Following that, different recurrent neural network (RNN) models are utilized to predict individual sub-sequences and the final prediction is reconstructed by summing the prediction results of sub-sequences. These RNN models are long short-term memory (LSTM), gated recurrent unit (GRU), bidirectional LSTM (BiLSTM) and bidirectional GRU (BiGRU), which are optimal for sequence prediction. The root mean square error (RMSE) of the predicted performance is then used to select the ideal RNN model for each sub-sequences. In addition to RMSE, the framework of universal multifractal (UM) is also introduced to evaluate prediction performances, which enables to characterize the extreme variability of predicted rainfall time series. The study employed two rainfall datasets from 2001 to 2020 in Paris, with daily and hourly resolutions. The results show that, when compared to directly predicting the original time series, the proposed hybrid VMD-RNN model improves prediction of high or extreme values for the daily dataset, but does not significantly enhance the prediction of zero or low values. Additionally, the VMD-RNN model also outperforms existing deep learning models without decomposition on the hourly dataset when evaluated with the help of RMSE, while universal multifractal analyses point out limitations. 

    How to cite: Zhou, H., Schertzer, D., and Tchiguirinskaia, I.: Combining variational mode decomposition and recurrent neural network to predict rainfall time series and evaluating prediction performance by universal multifractals, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6014, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6014, 2022.

    EGU22-6281 | Presentations | NP4.1

    Application of information theoretical measures for improved machine learning modelling of the outer radiation belt 

    Constantinos Papadimitriou, Georgios Balasis, Ioannis A. Daglis, and Simon Wing

    In the past ten years Artificial Neural Networks (ANN) and other machine learning methods have been used in a wide range of models and predictive systems, to capture and even predict the onset and evolution of various types of phenomena. These applications typically require large datasets, composed of many variables and parameters, the number of which can often make the analysis cumbersome and prohibitively time consuming, especially when the interplay of all these parameters is taken into consideration. Thankfully, Information-Theoretical measures can be used to not only reduce the dimensionality of the input space of such a system, but also improve its efficiency. In this work, we present such a case, where differential electron fluxes from the Magnetic Electron Ion Spectrometer (MagEIS) on board the Van Allen Probes satellites are modelled by a simple ANN, using solar wind parameters and geomagnetic activity indices as inputs, and illustrate how the proper use of Information Theory measures can improve the efficiency of the model by minimizing the number of input parameters and shifting them with respect to time, to their proper time-lagged versions.

    How to cite: Papadimitriou, C., Balasis, G., Daglis, I. A., and Wing, S.: Application of information theoretical measures for improved machine learning modelling of the outer radiation belt, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-6281, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-6281, 2022.

    EGU22-7256 | Presentations | NP4.1

    Identifying patterns of teleconnections, a curvature-based network analysis 

    Jakob Schlör, Felix M. Strnad, Christian Fröhlich, and Bedartha Goswami

    Representing spatio-temporal climate variables as complex networks allows uncovering nontrivial structure in the data. Although various tools for detecting communities in climate networks have been used to group nodes (spatial locations) with similar climatic conditions, we are often interested in identifying important links between communities. Of particular interest are methods to detect teleconnections, i.e. links over large spatial distances mitigated by atmospheric processes.

    We propose to use a recently developed network measure based on Ricci-curvature to visualize teleconnections in climate networks. Ricci-curvature allows to distinguish between- and within-community links in networks. Applied to networks constructed from surface temperature anomalies we show that Ricci-curvature separates spatial scales. We use Ricci-curvature to study differences in global teleconnection patterns of different types of El Niño events, namely the Eastern Pacific (EP) and Central Pacific (CP) types. Our method reveals a global picture of teleconnection patterns, showing confinement of teleconnections to the tropics under EP conditions but showing teleconnections to the tropics, Northern and Southern Hemisphere under CP conditions. The obtained teleconnections corroborate previously reported impacts of EP and CP.
    Our results suggest that Ricci-curvature is a promising visual-analytics-tool to study the topology of climate systems with potential applications across observational and model data.

    How to cite: Schlör, J., Strnad, F. M., Fröhlich, C., and Goswami, B.: Identifying patterns of teleconnections, a curvature-based network analysis, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7256, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7256, 2022.

    EGU22-8399 | Presentations | NP4.1

    Using neural networks to detect coastal hydrodynamic phenomena in high-resolution tide gauge data 

    Felix Soltau, Sebastian Niehüser, and Jürgen Jensen

    Tide gauges are exposed to various kinds of influences that are able to affect water level measurements significantly and lead to time series containing different phenomena and artefacts. These influences can be natural or anthropogenic, while both lead to actual changes of the water level. Opposed to that, technical malfunction of measuring devices as another kind of influence causes non-physical water level data. Both actual and non-physical data need to be detected and classified consistently, and possibly corrected to enable the supply of adequate water level information. However, there is no automatically working detection algorithm yet. Only obvious or frequent technical malfunctions like gaps can be detected automatically but have to be corrected manually by trained staff. Consequently, there is no consistently defined data pre-processing before, for example, statistical analyses are performed or water level information for navigation is passed on.

    In the research project DePArT*, we focus on detecting natural phenomena like standing waves, meteotsunamis, or inland flood events as well as anthropogenic artefacts like operating storm surge barriers and sluices in water level time series containing data every minute. Therefore, we train artificial neural networks (ANNs) using water level sequences of phenomena and artefacts as well as redundant data to recognize them in other data sets. We use convolutional neural networks (CNNs) as they already have been successfully conducted in, for example, object detection or speech and language processing (Gu et al., 2018). However, CNNs need to be trained with high numbers of sample sequences. Hence, as a next step the idea is to synthesize rarely observed phenomena and artefacts to gain enough training data. The trained CNNs can then be used to detect unnoticed phenomena and artefacts in past and recent time series. Depending on sequence characteristics and the results of synthesizing, we will possibly be able to detect certain events as they occur and therefore provide pre-checked water level information in real time.

    In a later stage of this study, we will implement the developed algorithms in an operational test mode while cooperating closely with the officials to benefit from the mutual feedback. In this way, the study contributes to a future consistent pre-processing and helps to increase the quality of water level data. Moreover, the results are able to reduce uncertainties from the measuring process and improve further calculations based on these data.

    * DePArT (Detektion von küstenhydrologischen Phänomenen und Artefakten in minütlichen Tidepegeldaten; engl. Detection of coastal hydrological phenomena and artefacts in minute-by-minute tide gauge data) is a research project, funded by the German Federal Ministry of Education and Research (BMBF) through the project management of Projektträger Jülich PTJ under the grant number 03KIS133.

    Gu, Wang, Kuen, Ma, Shahroudy, Shuai, Liu, Wang, Wang, Cai, Chen (2018): Recent advances in convolutional neural networks. In: Pattern Recognition, Vol. 77, Pages 354–377. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.patcog.2017.10.013

    How to cite: Soltau, F., Niehüser, S., and Jensen, J.: Using neural networks to detect coastal hydrodynamic phenomena in high-resolution tide gauge data, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8399, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8399, 2022.

    EGU22-8899 | Presentations | NP4.1

    Body wave extraction by using sparsity-promoting time-frequency filtering 

    Bahare Imanibadrbani, Hamzeh Mohammadigheymasi, Ahmad Sadidkhouy, Rui Fernandes, Ali Gholami, and Martin Schimmel

    Different phases of seismic waves generated by earthquakes carry considerable information about the subsurface structures as they propagate within the earth. Depending on the scope and objective of an investigation, various types of seismic phases are studied. Studying surface waves image shallow and large-scale subsurface features, while body waves provide high-resolution images at higher depths, which is otherwise impossible to be resolved by surface waves. The most challenging aspect of studying body waves is extracting low-amplitude P and S phases predominantly masked by high amplitude and low attenuation surface waves overlapping in time and frequency. Although body waves generally contain higher frequencies than surface waves, the overlapping frequency spectrum of body and surface waves limits the application of elementary signal processing methods such as conventional filtering. Advanced signal processing tools are required to work around this problem. Recently the Sparsity-Promoting Time-Frequency Filtering (SP-TFF) method was developed as a signal processing tool for discriminating between different phases of seismic waves based on their high-resolution polarization information in the Time-Frequency (TF)-domain (Mohammadigheymasi et al., 2022). The SP-TFF extracts different phases of seismic waves by incorporating this information and utilizing a combination of amplitude, directivity, and rectilinearity filters. This study implements SP-TFF by properly defining a filter combination set for specific extraction of body waves masked by high-amplitude surface waves. Synthetic and real data examinations for the source mechanism of the  Mw=7.5 earthquake that occurred in November 2021 in Northern Peru and recorded by 58 stations of the United States National Seismic Network (USNSN) is conducted. The results show the remarkable performance of SP-TFF extracting P and SV phases on the vertical and radial components and SH phase on the transverse component masked by high amplitude Rayleigh and Love waves, respectively. A range of S/N levels is tested, indicating the algorithm’s robustness at different noise levels. This research contributes to the FCT-funded SHAZAM (Ref. PTDC/CTA-GEO/31475/2017) and IDL (Ref. FCT/UIDB/50019/2020) projects. It also uses computational resources provided by C4G (Collaboratory for Geosciences) (Ref. PINFRA/22151/2016).

    REFERENCE
    Mohammadigheymasi, H., P. Crocker, M. Fathi, E. Almeida, G. Silveira, A. Gholami, and M. Schimmel, 2022, Sparsity-promoting approach to polarization analysis of seismic signals in the time-frequency domain: IEEE Transactions on Geoscience and Remote Sensing, 1–1.

    How to cite: Imanibadrbani, B., Mohammadigheymasi, H., Sadidkhouy, A., Fernandes, R., Gholami, A., and Schimmel, M.: Body wave extraction by using sparsity-promoting time-frequency filtering, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8899, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8899, 2022.

    EGU22-9626 | Presentations | NP4.1

    A Recurrence Flow based Approach to Attractor Reconstruction 

    Tobias Braun, K. Hauke Kraemer, and Norbert Marwan

    In the study of nonlinear observational time series, reconstructing the system’s state space represents the basis for many widely-used analyses. From the perspective of dynamical system’s theory, Taken’s theorem states that under benign conditions, the reconstructed state space preserves the most fundamental properties of the real, unknown system’s attractor. Through many applications, time delay embedding (TDE) has established itself as the most popular approach for state space reconstruction1. However, standard TDE cannot account for multiscale properties of the system and many of the more sophisticated approaches either require heuristic choice for a high number of parameters, fail when the signals are corrupted by noise or obstruct analysis due to their very high complexity.

    We present a novel semi-automated, recurrence based method for the problem of attractor reconstruction. The proposed method is based on recurrence plots (RPs), a computationally simple yet effective 2D-representation of a univariate time series. In a recent study, the quantification of RPs has been extended by transferring the well-known box-counting algorithm to recurrence analysis2. We build on this novel formalism by introducing another box-counting measure that was originally put forward by B. Mandelbrot, namely succolarity3. Succolarity quantifies how well a fluid can permeate a binary texture4. We employ this measure by flooding a RP with a (fictional) fluid along its diagonals and computing succolarity as a measure of diagonal flow through the RP. Since a non-optimal choice of embedding parameters impedes the formation of diagonal lines in the RP and generally results in spurious patterns that block the fluid, the attractor reconstruction problem can be formulated as a maximization of diagonal recurrence flow.

    The proposed state space reconstruction algorithm allows for non-uniform embedding delays to account for multiscale dynamics. It is conceptually and computationally simple and (nearly) parameter-free. Even in presence of moderate to high noise intensity, reliable results are obtained. We compare the method’s performance to existing techniques and showcase its effectiveness in applications to paradigmatic examples and nonlinear geoscientific time series.

     

    References:

    1 Packard, N. H., Crutchfield, J. P., Farmer, J. D., & Shaw, R. S. (1980). Geometry from a time series. Physical review letters, 45(9), 712.

    2 Braun, T., Unni, V. R., Sujith, R. I., Kurths, J., & Marwan, N. (2021). Detection of dynamical regime transitions with lacunarity as a multiscale recurrence quantification measure. Nonlinear Dynamics, 1-19.

    3 Mandelbrot, B. B. (1982). The fractal geometry of nature (Vol. 1). New York: WH freeman.

    4 de Melo, R. H., & Conci, A. (2013). How succolarity could be used as another fractal measure in image analysis. Telecommunication Systems, 52(3), 1643-1655.

    How to cite: Braun, T., Kraemer, K. H., and Marwan, N.: A Recurrence Flow based Approach to Attractor Reconstruction, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-9626, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-9626, 2022.

    EGU22-11064 | Presentations | NP4.1

    The Objective Deformation Component of a Velocity Field 

    Bálint Kaszás, Tiemo Pedergnana, and George Haller

    According to a fundamental axiom of continuum mechanics, material response should be objective, i.e., indifferent to the observer. In the context of geophysical fluid dynamics, fluid-transporting vortices must satisfy this axiom and hence different observers should come to the same conclusion about the location and size of these vortices. As a consequence, only objectively defined extraction methods can provide reliable results for material vortices.

    As velocity fields are inherently non-objective, they render most Eulerian flow-feature detection non-objective. To resolve this issue,  we discuss a general decomposition of a velocity field into an objective deformation component and a rigid-body component. We obtain this decomposition as a solution of a physically motivated extremum problem for the closest rigid-body velocity of a general velocity field.

    This extremum problem turns out to have a unique,  physically interpretable,  closed-form solution. Subtracting this solution from the velocity field then gives an objective deformation velocity field that is also physically observable. As a consequence, all common Eulerian feature detection schemes, as well as the momentum, energy, vorticity, enstrophy, and helicity of the flow, become objective when computed from the deformation velocity component. We illustrate the use of this deformation velocity field on several velocity data sets.

    How to cite: Kaszás, B., Pedergnana, T., and Haller, G.: The Objective Deformation Component of a Velocity Field, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11064, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11064, 2022.

    EGU22-11118 | Presentations | NP4.1

    Explainable community detection of extreme rainfall events using the tangles algorithmic framework 

    Merle Kammer, Felix Strnad, and Bedartha Goswami

    Climate networks have helped to uncover complex structures in climatic observables from large time series data sets. For instance, climate networks were used to reduce rainfall data to relevant patterns that can be linked to geophysical processes. However, the identification of regions that show similar behavior with respect to the timing and spatial distribution of extreme rainfall events (EREs) remains challenging. 
    To address this, we apply a recently developed algorithmic framework based on tangles [1] to discover community structures in the spatial distribution of EREs and to obtain inherently interpretable communities as an output. First, we construct a climate network using time-delayed event synchronization and create a collection of cuts (bipartitions) from the EREs data. By using these cuts, the tangles algorithmic framework allows us to both exploit the climate network structure and incorporate prior knowledge from the data. Applying tangles enables us to create a hierarchical tree representation of communities including the likelihood that spatial locations belong to a community. Each tree layer can be associated to an underlying cut, thus making the division of different communities transparent. 
    Applied to global precipitation data, we show that tangles is a promising tool to quantify community structures and to reveal underlying geophysical processes leading to these structures.

     

    [1] S. Klepper, C. Elbracht, D. Fioravanti,  J. Kneip, L. Rendsburg, M. Teegen, and U. von Luxburg. Clustering with Tangles: Algorithmic Framework and Theoretical Guarantees. CoRR, abs/2006.14444v2, 2021. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/2006.14444v2.

    How to cite: Kammer, M., Strnad, F., and Goswami, B.: Explainable community detection of extreme rainfall events using the tangles algorithmic framework, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11118, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11118, 2022.

    EGU22-11667 | Presentations | NP4.1

    Spurious Behaviour in Networks from Spatio-temporal Data 

    Moritz Haas, Bedartha Goswami, and Ulrike von Luxburg

    Network-based analyses of dynamical systems have become increasingly popular in climate science. Instead of focussing on the chaotic systems aspect, we come from a statistical perspective and highlight the often ignored fact that the calculated correlation values are only empirical estimates. We find that already the uncertainty stemming from the estimation procedure has major impact on network characteristics. Using isotropic random fields on the sphere, we observe spurious behaviour in commonly constructed networks from finite samples. When the data has locally coherent correlation structure, even spurious link-bundle teleconnections have to be expected. We reevaluate the outcome and robustness of existing studies based on their design choices and null hypotheses.

    How to cite: Haas, M., Goswami, B., and von Luxburg, U.: Spurious Behaviour in Networks from Spatio-temporal Data, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11667, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11667, 2022.

    EGU22-12351 | Presentations | NP4.1

    VAE4OBS: Denoising ocean bottom seismograms using variational autoencoders 

    Maria Tsekhmistrenko, Ana Ferreira, Kasra Hosseini, and Thomas Kitching

    Data from ocean-bottom seismometers (OBS) are inherently more challenging than their land counterpart because of their noisy environment. Primary and secondary microseismic noises corrupt the recorded time series. Additionally, anthropogenic (e.g., ships) and animal noise (e.g., Whales) contribute to a complex noise that can make it challenging to use traditional filtering methods (e.g., broadband or Gabor filters) to clean and extract information from these seismograms. 

    OBS deployments are laborious, expensive, and time-consuming. The data of these deployments are crucial in investigating and covering the "blind spots" where there is a lack of station coverage. It, therefore, becomes vital to remove the noise and retrieve earthquake signals recorded on these seismograms.

    We propose analysing and processing such unique and challenging data with Machine Learning (ML), particularly Deep Learning (DL) techniques, where conventional methods fail. We present a variational autoencoder (VAE) architecture to denoise seismic waveforms with the aim to extract more information than previously possible. We argue that, compared to other fields, seismology is well-posed to use ML and DL techniques thanks to massive datasets recorded by seismograms. 

    In the first step, we use synthetic seismograms (generated with Instaseis) and white noise to train a deep neural network. We vary the signal-to-noise ratio during training. Such synthetic datasets have two advantages. First, we know the signal and noise (as we have injected the noise ourselves). Second, we can generate large training and validation datasets, one of the prerequisites for high-quality DL models.

    Next, we increased the complexity of input data by adding real noise sampled from land and OBS to the synthetic seismograms. Finally, we apply the trained model to real OBS data recorded during the RHUM-RUM experiment.

    We present the workflow, the neural network architecture, our training strategy, and the usefulness of our trained models compared to traditional methods.

    How to cite: Tsekhmistrenko, M., Ferreira, A., Hosseini, K., and Kitching, T.: VAE4OBS: Denoising ocean bottom seismograms using variational autoencoders, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-12351, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-12351, 2022.

    EGU22-13053 | Presentations | NP4.1

    Causal Diagnostics for Observations - Experiments with the L63 system 

    Nachiketa Chakraborty and Javier Amezcua

    Study of cause and effect relationships – causality - is central to identifying mechanisms that cause the phenomena we observe. And in non-linear, dynamical systems, we wish to understand these mechanisms unfolding over time. In areas within physical sciences like geosciences, astrophysics, etc. there are numerous competing causes that drive the system in complicated ways that are hard to disentangle. Hence, it is important to demonstrate how causal attribution works with relatively simpler systems where we have a physical intuition. Furthermore, in earth and atmospheric sciences or meteorology, we have a plethora of observations that are used in both understanding the underlying science beneath the phenomena as well as forecasting. However in order to do this, optimally combining the models (theoretical/numerical) with the observations through data assimilation is a challenging, computationally intensive task. Therefore, understanding the impact of observations and the required cadence is very useful. Here, we present experiments in causal inference and attribution with the Lorenz 63 system – a system studied for a long time. We first test the causal relations between the variables characterising the model. And then we simulate observations using perturbed versions of the model to test the impact of the cadence of observations of each combination of the 3 variables.

    How to cite: Chakraborty, N. and Amezcua, J.: Causal Diagnostics for Observations - Experiments with the L63 system, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13053, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13053, 2022.

    An accurate understanding of dynamical similarities and dissimilarities in geomagnetic variability between quiet and disturbed periods has the potential to vastly improve Space Weather diagnosis. During the last years, several approaches rooted in dynamical system theory have demonstrated their great potentials for characterizing the instantaneous level of complexity in geomagnetic activity and solar wind variations, and for revealing indications of intermittent large-scale coupling and generalized synchronization phenomena in the Earth’s electromagnetic environment. In this work, we focus on two complementary approaches based on the concept of recurrences in phase space, both of which quantify subtle geometric properties of the phase space trajectory instead of taking an explicit temporal variability perspective. We first quantify the local (instantaneous) and global fractal dimensions and associated local stability properties of a suite of low (SYM-H, ASY-H) and high latitude (AE, AL, AU) geomagnetic indices and discuss similarities and dissimilarities of the obtained patterns for one year of observations during a solar activity maximum. Subsequently, we proceed with studying bivariate extensions of both approaches, and demonstrate their capability of tracing different levels of interdependency between low and high latitude geomagnetic variability during periods of magnetospheric quiescence and along with perturbations associated with geomagnetic storms and magnetospheric substorms, respectively. Ultimately, we investigate the effect of time scale on the level of dynamical organization of fluctuations by studying iterative reconstructions of the index values based on intrinsic mode functions obtained from univariate and multivariate versions of empirical mode decomposition. Our results open new perspectives on the nonlinear dynamics and (likely intermittent) mutual entanglement of different parts of the geospace electromagnetic environment, including the equatorial and westward auroral electrojets, in dependence of the overall state of the geospace system affected by temporary variations of the solar wind forcing. In addition, they contribute to a better understanding of the potentials and limitations of two contemporary approaches of nonlinear time series analysis in the field of space physics.

    How to cite: Donner, R., Alberti, T., and Faranda, D.: Instantaneous fractal dimensions and stability properties of geomagnetic indices based on recurrence networks and extreme value theory, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13342, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13342, 2022.

    EGU22-869 | Presentations | NP5.1 | Highlight

    Machine learning for postprocessing ensemble forecasts of wind gusts with a focus on European winter storms 

    Benedikt Schulz and Sebastian Lerch

    Postprocessing ensemble weather predictions to correct systematic errors has become a standard practice in research and operations. However, only few recent studies have focused on ensemble postprocessing of wind gust forecasts, despite its importance for severe weather warnings, e.g. in European winter storms. First, we provide a comprehensive review and systematic comparison of several statistical and machine learning methods for probabilistic wind gust forecasting via ensemble postprocessing, then we assess the performance of selected methods within winter storms. The methods can be divided in three groups: State of the art postprocessing techniques from statistics (ensemble model output statistics (EMOS), member-by-member postprocessing, isotonic distributional regression), established machine learning methods (gradient-boosting extended EMOS, quantile regression forests) and neural network-based approaches (distributional regression network, Bernstein quantile network, histogram estimation network). The different approaches are systematically compared using six years of data from a high-resolution, convection-permitting ensemble prediction system run operationally at the German weather service, and hourly observations at 175 surface weather stations in Germany. While all postprocessing methods yield calibrated forecasts and are able to correct the systematic errors of the raw ensemble predictions, incorporating information from additional meteorological predictor variables beyond wind gusts as well as estimating locally adaptive neural networks leads to significant improvements in forecast skill. Assessing the performance of EMOS and neural network-based postprocessing for selected winter storms, we find that the networks better adapt to the extreme conditions than the statistical benchmark and thus yield a superior predictive performance. However, results suggest that the performance can still be further improved, e.g. via regime-dependent postprocessing.

    How to cite: Schulz, B. and Lerch, S.: Machine learning for postprocessing ensemble forecasts of wind gusts with a focus on European winter storms, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-869, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-869, 2022.

    EGU22-921 | Presentations | NP5.1

    Generative machine learning methods for multivariate ensemble post-processing 

    Jieyu Chen, Sebastian Lerch, and Tim Janke

    Statistical post-processing of ensemble forecasts has become a common practice in research to correct biases and errors in calibration. While many of the developments have been focused on univariate methods that calibrate the marginal distributions, practical applications often require accurate modeling of spatial, temporal, and inter-variable dependencies. Copula-based multivariate post-processing methods, such as ensemble copula coupling, have been proposed to address this issue and proceed by reordering univariately post-processed ensembles with copula functions to retain the dependence structure. We propose a novel multivariate post-processing method based on generative machine learning where post-processed multivariate ensemble forecasts are generated from random noise, conditional on the inputs of raw ensemble forecasts. Moving beyond the two-step strategy of separately modeling marginal distributions and multivariate dependence structure, the generative modelling approach allows for directly obtaining multivariate probabilistic forecasts as output. The flexibility of the generative model also enables us to incorporate additional predictors straightforwardly and to generate an arbitrary number of post-processed ensemble members. In a case study on the surface temperature and wind speed forecasts from the European Centre of Medium-Range Weather Forecasts at weather stations in Germany, our generative model that incorporates additional weather predictors substantially improves upon the multivariate spatial forecasts from copula-based approaches. And the model shows competitive performance even with state-of-the-art neural network-based post-processing models applied for the marginal distributions.

    How to cite: Chen, J., Lerch, S., and Janke, T.: Generative machine learning methods for multivariate ensemble post-processing, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-921, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-921, 2022.

    EGU22-1201 | Presentations | NP5.1

    Physics-constrained postprocessing of surface temperature and humidity 

    Francesco Zanetta and Daniele Nerini

    Traditional post-processing methods aim at minimizing forecast error. This often leads to predictions that violate physical principles and disregard dependencies between variables. However, for various impact-based applications such as hydrological forecasting or heat indices, it is important to provide forecasts that not only have high univariate accuracy, but also are physically consistent, in the sense of respecting physical principles and variable dependencies. Achieving physical consistency remains an open problem in the post-processing of weather forecasts, while this question has recently gained a lot of attention in the wider deep learning community and climate field. Recent contributions show that physical consistency may be pursued by applying different forms of constraints to deep learning models. The most widely used approaches are to incorporate physics via regularization, by defining physics-based losses in addition to common metrics such as mean absolute error, or to define custom-designed model architectures, such that the physical constraints are strictly enforced. Including constraints also has the potential to help the training procedure by restraining the hypothesis space of the model and improving generalization capabilities.

    This work investigates the application of the aforementioned approaches for the postprocessing of a set of variables related to surface temperature and humidity, specifically temperature, dew point, surface pressure, relative humidity and water vapor mixing ratio. As baseline, we use an unconstrained fully connected neural network. We consider the simple case of postprocessing at a single location, and we show how it is possible to incorporate domain knowledge, specifically thermodynamic relationships, via analytic constraints, to obtain physically consistent postprocessed prediction. We compare different approaches and show that we can enforce physical consistency without degrading performance, or even improving it. Furthermore, we discuss additional advantages and disadvantages of these approaches in the context of post-processing, besides error reduction.

    How to cite: Zanetta, F. and Nerini, D.: Physics-constrained postprocessing of surface temperature and humidity, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-1201, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-1201, 2022.

    EGU22-2176 | Presentations | NP5.1

    Probabilistic power ramp forecasts using multivariate Gaussian regression 

    Thomas Muschinski, Moritz N. Lang, Georg J. Mayr, Jakob W. Messner, Thorsten Simon, and Achim Zeileis

    Efficient wind farm operation requires reliable probabilistic forecasts of power ramps. These are sudden fluctuations in power production which, if unanticipated, can lead to significant imbalances in the electrical grid.  The power produced by a turbine strongly depends on the wind speed at hub-height, making it is useful to base these forecasts on calibrated wind speed scenarios generated by statistically postprocessing numerical weather predictions (NWPs). Since the probability of a ramp event depends jointly on the wind speed distributions forecasted at multiple future times, postprocessing methods must not only calibrate the marginal forecasts for each lead time, but also estimate temporal dependencies among their errors.

    We use new multivariate Gaussian regression (MGR) models to postprocess all next-day hourly 100m wind speeds near offshore wind farms in one step. The postprocessed forecast is a multivariate Gaussian distribution with mean vector μ — containing the 24 forecasted hourly mean wind speeds — and Σ — the 24 × 24 covariance matrix containing uncertainties of the individual forecasts as well as their temporal error correlations.  Joint distributions are estimated conditionally by flexibly linking the components of μ and parameters specifying Σ to predictors derived from an ECMWF ensemble using generalized additive models for each distributional parameter.

    The joint distribution — predicted uniquely for each ECMWF initialization — can simulate postprocessed wind speed ensembles with any number of members. Subsequently, the forecasted ensembles are transformed into power space using an idealized turbine power curve and probabilities computed for different ramp events. Ramp forecasts from MGR outperform those obtained using reference methods which postprocess wind speed forecasts in two-steps: (i) first calibrating the marginal distributions with nonhomogeneous Gaussian regression before (ii) constructing temporal error dependencies using either the order statistics of the NWP ensemble (ensemble copula coupling, ECC) or those of raw observations (Schaake Shuffle).

    How to cite: Muschinski, T., Lang, M. N., Mayr, G. J., Messner, J. W., Simon, T., and Zeileis, A.: Probabilistic power ramp forecasts using multivariate Gaussian regression, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2176, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2176, 2022.

    EGU22-2311 | Presentations | NP5.1

    Gaussian mixture models for clustering and calibration of ensemble weather forecasts 

    Gabriel Jouan, Anne Cuzol, Valérie Monbet, and Goulven Monnier

    Nowadays, most weather forecasting centers produce ensemble forecasts.  Ensemble forecasts provide information about probability distribution of the weather variables. They give a more complete description of the atmosphere than a unique run of the meteorological model. However, they may suffer from bias and under/over dispersion errors that need to be corrected. These distribution errors may depend on weather regimes. In this paper, we propose various extensions of the Gaussian mixture model and its associated inference tools for ensemble data sets.  The proposed models are then used to identify clusters which correspond to different types of distribution errors. Finally, a standard calibration method known as Non homogeneous Gaussian Regression (NGR)  is applied cluster by cluster in order to correct ensemble forecast distributions. It is shown that the proposed methodology is effective, interpretable and easy to use.  The clustering algorithms are illustrated on simulated and real data. The calibration method is applied to real data of temperature and wind medium range forecast for 3 stations in France. 

    How to cite: Jouan, G., Cuzol, A., Monbet, V., and Monnier, G.: Gaussian mixture models for clustering and calibration of ensemble weather forecasts, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-2311, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2311, 2022.

    EGU22-5609 | Presentations | NP5.1

    Postprocessing of gridded precipitation forecasts using conditional generative adversarial networks and quantile regression 

    Stephan Hemri, Jonas Bhend, Christoph Spirig, Daniele Nerini, Lionel Moret, Reinhard Furrer, and Mark A. Liniger

    Probabilistic predictions of precipitation call for rather sophisticated postprocessing approaches due to its low predictability, high spatio-temporal variability and highly positive skewness. Moreover, the large number of zeros makes the generation of physically realistic postprocessed forecast scenarios using standard approaches like ensemble copula coupling (ECC) rather difficult. In addition to classical statistical approaches, recently, machine learning based methods gained increasing popularity in the field of postprocessing of probabilistic weather forecasts.

    In this study, we compare conditional generative adversarial network (cGAN) based postprocessing of daily precipitation with a quantile regression based approach. In principle, an appropriately trained cGAN model should be able to generate postprocessed forecast scenarios that improve forecast skill and cannot be distinguished from observed data in terms of spatial structure. While we use ECC to generate physically realistic forecast scenarios from quantile regression, cGAN does not need any additional ECC steps. For training and verification, we use COSMO-E ensemble forecasts with a grid resolution of about 2 km over Switzerland and the corresponding CombiPrecip observations, which are a gridded blend of radar and gauge observations. Preliminary results suggest that it is possible to generate realistic looking forecast scenarios using cGAN, but up to now, we have not been able to increase forecast skill. On the other hand, quantile regression seems to increase forecast skill at the expense of relying on an additional ECC step to generate forecast scenarios.

    How to cite: Hemri, S., Bhend, J., Spirig, C., Nerini, D., Moret, L., Furrer, R., and Liniger, M. A.: Postprocessing of gridded precipitation forecasts using conditional generative adversarial networks and quantile regression, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5609, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5609, 2022.

    EGU22-5797 | Presentations | NP5.1

    News about the EUMETNET statistical postprocessing benchmark 

    Jonathan Demaeyer

    New postprocessing methods are sometimes introduced without proper comparison to other available techniques, and therefore the institutions responsible for the operational implementation of weather forecasts may struggle deciding the best choice for their particular usecase. With the goal of helping the weather community to make such decisions, the benchmark of different postprocessing methods on predefined datasets is an important topic and is a key deliverable of the current EUMETNET postprocessing module. This benchmark is also a collaborative effort from several meteorological institutions, members of EUMETNET, and academia to define common pratices and shape standards.

     

    In this presentation, we will highlight the different aspects of the benchmark: (1) its current status and organization and (2) its objectives for the next 2 years. We will also detail the challenges ahead for this exercise, and the foreseen datasets and infrastructures needed to tackle them.

    How to cite: Demaeyer, J.: News about the EUMETNET statistical postprocessing benchmark, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-5797, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-5797, 2022.

    EGU22-7407 | Presentations | NP5.1

    Temperature prediction with expert agregation 

    Léo Pfitzner, Olivier Mestre, Olivier Wintenberger, and Eric Adjakossa

    A lot of Numerical Weather Prediction (NWP) models and their associated Model Output Statistics (MOS) are available. Expert aggregation has a bunch of advantages to deal with all these models, like being online, adaptive to model changes and having theoretical guarantees. With a new expert aggregation algorithm - FSBOA - a combination of BOA (Wintenberger 2017) and FS (Herbster and Warmuth 1998), and the use of a sliding window, we improved the temperature prediction on average without loosing too much reactivity of the expert weights. We also tested several aggregation strategies in order to improve the prediction of  extrem temperature events like cold and heat waves. To do so, we added some biased experts of the Météo-France 35-member ensemble forecast (PEARP) to the set of models. We also tried out the SMH (Mourtada et al. 2017) algorithm which fits the sleeping experts framework.

    How to cite: Pfitzner, L., Mestre, O., Wintenberger, O., and Adjakossa, E.: Temperature prediction with expert agregation, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-7407, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-7407, 2022.

    EGU22-8200 | Presentations | NP5.1

    climpred: weather and climate forecast verification in python 

    Aaron Spring

    Predicting subseasonal to seasonal weather and climate yields numerous benefits for economic and environmental decision-making.
    Forecasters verify the forecast quality of models by initializing large sets of retrospective forecasts to predict past variations and phenomena in hindcast studies.

    Quantifying prediction skill for multi-dimensional geospatial model output is computationally expensive and a difficult coding challenge. The large datasets require parallel and out-of-memory computing to be analyzed efficiently. Further, aligning the many forecast initializations with differing observational products is a straight-forward, but exhausting and error-prone exercise for researchers.

    To simplify and standardize forecast verification across scales from hourly weather to decadal climate forecasts, we built climpred: a python package for computationally efficient and methodologically consistent verification of ensemble prediction models. We rely on the python software ecosystem developed by the open pangeo geoscience community. We leverage NetCDF metadata using xarray and out-of-core computation parallelized with dask to scale analyses from a laptop to supercomputer.

    With climpred, researchers can assess forecast quality from a large set of metrics (including cprs, rps, rank_histogram, reliability, contingency, bias, rmse, acc, ...) in just a few lines of code:

    hind = xr.open_dataset('initialized.nc')
    obs = xr.open_dataset('observations.nc')
    he = climpred.HindcastEnsemble(hind).add_observations(obs)
    # he = he.remove_bias(how='basic_quantile',
    #                                       train_test_split='unfair', 
    #                                       alignment='same_verif')
    he.verify(metric='rmse',
                    comparison='e2o',
                    alignment='same_verif',
                    dim='init',
                    reference=['persistence', 'climatology'])

    This simplified and standardized process frees up resources to tackle the large process-based unknowns in predictability research. Here, we perform a live and interactive multi-model comparison removing bias with different methodologies from NMME project hindcasts and compare against persistence and climatology reference forecasts.

    Documentation: https://climpred.readthedocs.io

    Repository: https://github.com/pangeo-data/climpred

    Reference paper: Brady, Riley X. and Aaron Spring (Mar. 2021). “Climpred: Verification of Weather and Climate Forecasts”. en. Journal of Open Source Software 6.59, p. 2781. https://joss.theoj.org/papers/10.21105/joss.02781

    How to cite: Spring, A.: climpred: weather and climate forecast verification in python, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8200, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8200, 2022.

    EGU22-8424 | Presentations | NP5.1

    Offline models for statistical post-processing of surface weather variables 

    Zied Ben Bouallegue, Fenwick Cooper, and Matthew Chantry

    Statistical post-processing based on machine learning (ML) methods aims to capture systematic forecasts errors, relying on information from various predictors. We explore the exclusive use of “offline” predictors for the bias correction and uncertainty estimation of 2m temperature and 10 m wind speed forecasts. Offline predictors are defined as predictors available before the start of the forecast-of-the-day. Offline predictors encompass model characteristics such as the model orography and the model vegetation cover as well as spatio-temporal markers such as the day of the year, the time of the day and the latitude. The resulting offline models are particularly simple to implement as no time-critical operations are involved. The benefits of offline models and performance compared with more complex approaches will be discussed. 

    How to cite: Ben Bouallegue, Z., Cooper, F., and Chantry, M.: Offline models for statistical post-processing of surface weather variables, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8424, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8424, 2022.

    EGU22-8706 | Presentations | NP5.1

    IMPROVER : A probabilistic, multi-model post-processing system for meteorological forecasts 

    Stephen Moseley, Fiona Rust, Gavin Evans, Ben Ayliffe, Katharine Hurst, Kathryn Howard, Bruce Wright, and Simon Jackson

    The UK Met Office is developing an open-source probability-based post-processing system called IMPROVER to exploit convection permitting, hourly cycling ensemble forecasts. The system is tasked with blending these forecasts with both deterministic nowcast data, and coarser resolution global ensemble model data, to produce seamless probabilistic forecasts from the very short to medium range.

    A majority of the post-processing within IMPROVER is performed on gridded forecasts, with site-specific forecasts extracted as a final step, helping to ensure consistency. IMPROVER delivers a wide range of probabilistic products to both operational meteorologists and as input to automated forecast production. and this presentation will detail some of the work that has been undertaken in the past year to prepare, with a focus on the use of statistical post-processing.

    Statistical post-processing plays two complimentary roles within IMPROVER; ensuring forecasts better reflect reality, and in so doing, bringing different models into better alignment, which improves the seamlessness of model transitions. For a selection of diagnostics, the gridded forecasts from different source models are calibrated independently using ensemble model output statistics (EMOS). Results of experiments looking at the calibration of gridded forecasts will be discussed briefly.

    More recently calibration of site forecasts has been introduced as a final step for temperature and wind speed forecasts. Results of experiments using EMOS to perform calibration in a variety of different ways will be presented, including justifications and trade-offs made in choosing a final approach.

    • This will include some discussion of the remaking of weather symbol products as period, rather than instantaneous, forecasts and the implications for their verification.

    How to cite: Moseley, S., Rust, F., Evans, G., Ayliffe, B., Hurst, K., Howard, K., Wright, B., and Jackson, S.: IMPROVER : A probabilistic, multi-model post-processing system for meteorological forecasts, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-8706, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-8706, 2022.

    EGU22-10869 | Presentations | NP5.1

    Causality in long-term predictions, past-value problems and a stochastic-deterministic hybrid 

    Lenin Del Rio Amador and Shaun Lovejoy

    Over time scales between 10 days and 10-20 years – the macroweather regime – atmospheric fields, including the temperature, respect statistical scale symmetries, such as power-law correlations, that imply the existence of a huge memory in the system that can be exploited for long-term forecasts. The Stochastic Seasonal to Interannual Prediction System (StocSIPS) is a stochastic model that exploits these symmetries to perform long-term forecasts. It models the temperature as the high-frequency limit of the fractional energy balance equation (fractional Gaussian noise) which governs radiative equilibrium processes when the relevant equilibrium relaxation processes are power law, rather than exponential.

    The multivariate version of the model (m-StocSIPS), exploits the space-time statistics of the temperature field to produce realistic global simulations, including realistic teleconnection networks and El Niño events and indices. One of the implications of this model is the lack of Granger-causality: the optimal predictor at gridpoint i is obtained from the past of the timeseries i and cannot be improved using past temperatures from any other location j. This allows to treat predictions for long-memory processes as “past value” problems rather than the conventional initial value approach that uses the current state of the atmosphere to produce ensemble forecasts.

    To improve the stochastic predictions, a zero-lag independent (non-stochastic) predictor is needed. Here we use the Canadian Seasonal to Interannual prediction System (CanSIPS), as a deterministic co-predictor. CanSIPS is a long-term multi-model ensemble (MME) system using two climate models developed by the Canadian Centre for Climate Modelling and Analysis (CCCma). The optimal linear combination of CanSIPS and StocSIPS (CanStoc) was based on minimizing the square error of the final predictor in the common hindcast period 1981-2010 using different out-of-sample validations. Global time series and regional maps at 2.5ºx2.5º resolution show that the skill of CanStoc is better than that of each individual model for most of the regions when non-overlapping training and verification periods are used.

    How to cite: Del Rio Amador, L. and Lovejoy, S.: Causality in long-term predictions, past-value problems and a stochastic-deterministic hybrid, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-10869, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-10869, 2022.

    EGU22-11689 | Presentations | NP5.1

    Graphical Model Assessment of Probabilistic Forecasts 

    Moritz N. Lang, Reto Stauffer, and Achim Zeileis

    As a consequence of the growing importance of probabilistic predictions in various application fields due to a necessary functional risk management and strategy, there is an increasing demand for appropriate probabilistic model evaluation. Besides proper scoring rules, which can evaluate not only the expectation but the entire predictive distribution, graphical assessment methods are particularly advantageous to diagnose possible model misspecifications.

    Probabilistic forecasts are often based on distributional regression models, whereby the computation of predictive distributions, probabilities, and quantiles is generally dependent on the software (package) being used. Therefore, routines to graphically evaluate probabilistic models are not always available and if so then only for specific types of models and distributions provided by the corresponding package. An easy to use unified infrastructure to graphical assess and compare different probabilistic model types does not yet exist. Trying to fill that gap, we present a common conceptual framework accompanied by a flexible and object-oriented software implementation in the R package topmodels (https://topmodels.R-Forge.R-project.org/).  

    The package includes visualizations for PIT (probability integral transform) histograms, Q-Q (quantile-quantile) plots of (randomized) quantile residuals, rootograms, reliability diagrams, and worm plots. All displays can be rendered in base R as well as in ggplot2 and provide different options for, e.g., computing confidence intervals, scaling or setting graphical parameters. Using examples of post-processing precipitation ensemble forecasts, we further discuss how all theses types of graphics can be compared to each other and which types of displays are particularly useful for bringing out which types of model deficiencies.

    How to cite: Lang, M. N., Stauffer, R., and Zeileis, A.: Graphical Model Assessment of Probabilistic Forecasts, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-11689, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-11689, 2022.

    EGU22-13118 | Presentations | NP5.1

    Calibration of wind speed ensemble forecasts for power generation 

    Sándor Baran and Ágnes Baran

    In 2020, 36.6 % of the total electricity demand of the world was covered by renewable sources, whereas in the EU (UK included) this share reached 49.3 %. A substantial part of green energy is produced by wind farms, where accurate short range power predictions are required for successful integration of wind energy into the electrical grid. Accurate predictions of the produced electricity require accurate forecasts of the corresponding weather quantity, where the state-of-the-art method is the probabilistic approach based on ensemble forecasts. However, ensemble forecasts are often uncalibrated and might also be biased, thus require some form of post-processing to improve their predictive performance.

    To calibrate (hub height) wind speed ensemble forecasts we propose a novel flexible machine learning approach, which results either in a truncated normal or a log-normal predictive distribution (Baran and Baran, 2021). In a case study based on 100m wind speed forecasts of the operational AROME-EPS of the Hungarian Meteorological Service, the forecast skill of this method is compared with the predictive performance of three different ensemble model output statistics approaches and the raw ensemble predictions. We show that compared with the raw ensemble, post-processing always improves the calibration of probabilistic and accuracy of point forecasts, and from the five competing methods the novel machine learning based approaches result in the best overall performance. 

    Reference

    Baran, S., Baran, Á., Calibration of wind speed ensemble forecasts for power generation. Idöjárás 125 (2021), 609-624.

    How to cite: Baran, S. and Baran, Á.: Calibration of wind speed ensemble forecasts for power generation, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13118, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13118, 2022.

    EGU22-13125 | Presentations | NP5.1

    Restoration of temporal dependence in post-processed ensemble forecasts 

    Mária Lakatos and Sándor Baran

    An influential step in weather forecasting was the introduction of ensemble forecasts in operational use due to their capability to account for the uncertainties in the future state of the atmosphere. However, ensemble weather forecasts are often underdispersive and might also contain bias, which calls for some form of post-processing. A popular approach to calibration is the ensemble model output statistics (EMOS) resulting in a full predictive distribution for a given weather variable. However, this form of univariate post-processing may ignore the prevailing spatial and/or temporal correlation structures among different dimensions. Since many applications call for spatially and/or temporally coherent forecasts, multivariate post-processing aims to capture these possibly lost dependencies.

    Our main objective is the comparison of different nonparametric multivariate approaches to modeling temporal dependence of ensemble weather forecasts with different forecast horizons. We investigate two-step methods, where after univariate post-processing, the EMOS predictive distributions corresponding to different forecast horizons are combined to a multivariate calibrated prediction using an (empirical) copula (Lerch et al, 2020). Based on global ensemble predictions of the European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasts from January 2002 to March 2014 we investigate the forecast skill of different versions of Ensemble Copula Coupling and Schaake Shuffle. In general, compared with the raw and independently calibrated forecasts, multivariate post-processing substantially improves the forecast skill; however, there is no unique winner, the best-performing approach strongly depends on the weather variable at hand. 

    Reference

    Lerch, S., Baran, S., Möller, A., Groß, J., Schefzik, R., Hemri, S., Graeter, M., Simulation-based comparison of multivariate ensemble post-processing methods. Nonlinear Process. Geophys. 27 (2020), 349-371.

     

    How to cite: Lakatos, M. and Baran, S.: Restoration of temporal dependence in post-processed ensemble forecasts, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13125, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13125, 2022.

    EGU22-13205 | Presentations | NP5.1

    Support Vector Machine Quantile Regression based ensemble postprocessing 

    David Jobst, Annette Möller, and Jürgen Groß

    Current practice in predicting future weather is the use of numerical weather prediction (NWP) models to produce ensemble forecasts. Despite of enormous improvements over the last few decades, they still tend to exhibit bias and dispersion errors and consequently lack calibration. Therefore, these forecasts need to be statistically postprocessed.

    Support vector machines are often used for classification and regression tasks in a wide range of applications, as e.g. energy, ecology, hydrology and economics. In this study, ensemble forecasts of 2m surface temperature are post-processed using a quantile regression approach based on support vector machines (SVMQR). This approach will be compared to the benchmark postprocessing methods ensemble model output statistics (EMOS), boosted EMOS and quantile regression forests (QRF). Instead of only regarding temperature variables as predictors, other weather variables including time dependence are taken into account as independent variables. The considered dataset consists of observations and forecasts for five years which cover Germany including three different forecast horizons. Despite of a shorter training period for SVMQR in contrast to e.g. boosted EMOS or QRF, SVMQR yields more calibrated quantile ensemble forecasts than the other approaches. Additionally, a comparable performance in terms of CRPS to the benchmark methods and a great improvement in comparison to the raw ensemble forecasts could be detected.

    How to cite: Jobst, D., Möller, A., and Groß, J.: Support Vector Machine Quantile Regression based ensemble postprocessing, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13205, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13205, 2022.

    EGU22-13388 | Presentations | NP5.1

    Spatially adaptive Bayesian estimation for Probabilistic Temperature Forecasts 

    Annette Möller, Thordis Thorarinsdottir, Alex Lenkoski, and Tilmann Gneiting

    To account for forecast uncertainty in numerical weather prediction (NWP) models it has become common practice to employ ensemble prediction systems generating probabilistic forecast ensembles by multiple runs of the NWP model, each time with variations in the details of the numerical model and/or initial and boundary conditions. However, forecast ensembles typically exhibit biases and dispersion errors as they are not able to fully represent uncertainty in NWP models. Therefore, statistical postprocessing models are employed to correct ensembles for biases and dispersion errors in conjunction with recently observed forecast errors.

    For incorporating dependencies in space, this work proposes a spatially adaptive extension of the state-of-the-art Ensemble Model Output Statistics (EMOS) model. The new approach, named Markovian EMOS (MEMOS), introduces a Markovian dependence structure on the model parameters by employing Gaussian Markov random fields. For fitting the MEMOS model in a Bayesian fashion the recently developed Integrated Nested Laplace Approximation (INLA) approach is utilized, allowing for fast and accurate approximation of the posterior distributions of the parameters. To obtain physically coherent forecasts the basic MEMOS model is provided with an additional spatial dependence structure induced by the Ensemble Copula Coupling (ECC) approach, which makes explicit use of the rank order structure of the raw ensemble.

    The method is applied to temperature forecasts of the European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasts (ECMWF) over Europe, where it exhibits comparable or improved performance over univariate EMOS variants.

    How to cite: Möller, A., Thorarinsdottir, T., Lenkoski, A., and Gneiting, T.: Spatially adaptive Bayesian estimation for Probabilistic Temperature Forecasts, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13388, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13388, 2022.

    EGU22-13413 | Presentations | NP5.1

    Multivariate post-processing of temporal dependencies with autoregressive and LSTM neural networks 

    Daniel Tolomei, Sjoerd Dirksen, Kirien Whan, and Maurice Schmeits

    We consider the problem of post-processing forecasts for multiple lead times simultaneously. In particular, we focus on post-processing wind speed forecasts for consecutive lead times (0 - 48h ahead) from the deterministic HARMONIE-AROME NWP model. Given the strong temporal dependency between forecasts at consecutive lead times, it is essential to model the problem as a multivariate statistical post-processing problem in order to take this temporal correlation into account.

    A standard procedure in multivariate statistical post-processing is to produce multiple probabilistic forecasts independently for each lead time and introduce the dependency between them at a later stage using an empirical copula. For our specific problem, a successful example of this approach is to use EMOS to fit truncated normal marginal distributions at each lead time and then model the joint distribution by drawing samples from these distributions and reconstructing the temporal dependencies using the Schaake Shuffle.

    Our aim is to explore alternative methods that can model and exploit temporal dependencies more explicitly with the goal of improving forecast performance and moving away from sample based distribution modelling. We develop two new methods that produce multivariate truncated normal probabilistic forecasts for all lead times simultaneously, by combining elements from time series analysis and artificial neural networks.

    In our first method, we exploit the autoregressive dependencies in the residuals of the NWP wind speed forecasts to deduce an explicit multivariate model. By using a neural network to determine the parameters of this model, we arrive at our first method, which we coin ARMOSnet.

    In our second method, we apply Long Short-Term Memory networks, which rank among the state-of-the-art tools for the forecasting of time series. We adapt the LSTM architecture to output a multivariate density that models the temporal dependencies between the consecutive lead times.

    We compare our two methods to EMOS combined with the Schaake Shuffle for post-processing wind speed forecasts from the HARMONIE-AROME NWP model. Our new methods both outperform the EMOS-Schaake Shuffle approach in terms of the logarithmic, energy, and variogram scores. Among the two new methods, ARMOSnet exhibits the best performance.

     

    How to cite: Tolomei, D., Dirksen, S., Whan, K., and Schmeits, M.: Multivariate post-processing of temporal dependencies with autoregressive and LSTM neural networks, EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022, EGU22-13413, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-13413, 2022.

    CC BY 4.0